· The New York Times · New York
Jewish Colonization in Palestine
JEWISH COLONIZATION IN PALESTINE.—The danger is not so much from Bedouin Arabs — who, so far as I know, have never yet disturbed any of these Jewish agriculturists — as from the native authorities, and a want, not of perseverance or agricultural aptitude, but of discipline and harmony among the Jews themselves.
The colony of Summarin especially is a notable instance of an unnecessary waste of funds, all of which have been subscribed by Jews themselves, owing to mismanagement on the part of the Central Organizing Committee and a want of harmony on the part of the colonists.
Upward of 200,000f. have already been spent on this colony, which has in it every element of success, and upon which the colonists have been working indefatigably; but a far greater number of families have been sent out than the amount of land purchased could support, and the money has been spent so injudiciously that the colonists must undergo privations before they have sold their first crop, which might have been avoided; and, indeed, unless some charitable persons will come forward to purchase more land for the surplus families — and a good tract may be bought in the neighborhood — it is difficult to see how the means of subsistence are to be provided.
But this fact does not prove either the insecurity of the country, or the agricultural incapacity of the colonists.
It only proves that ignorance and organizing incapacity on the part of the committee in Europe, the opposition of the Government and officials, and the absence of any sympathizing protection and support on the part of co-religionists in the West, who might have afforded it, have formed a combination of adverse circumstances against which the colonists, in the absence of any leading, directing spirit, were unable successfully to struggle.
The experience of the colony near Safed tells a very different tale, and bids fair to afford an illustration of the fact that in spite of all the difficulties with which they have had to contend, the problem of Jewish colonization in Palestine is by no means insoluble; and that it needs only a wise and skillful direction, a firm hand, and the necessary protection against injustice and the infraction of treaty rights by the Turkish Government, to insure success.—Blackwood’s Magazine.
The word colonization in a New York Times headline in 1883, nineteen years before the paper’s 1902 plan of colonizing Palestine with Jews. The piece is a progress report on the colony at Zammarin, counting pounds spent and harmony lost.