Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle · 26 March 1948
CP-1948-162
New U. S. Palestine Policy Attacked in Congress
Demand Recognition of De Facto Jewish State, Lifting of Arms Ban

Shown from the top. The whole column — 5.2 times taller than it is wide — is in the enlargement.
Transcribed from the clipping
Washington—(JTA) — A sharp debate broke out in both houses of Congress as a number of Senators and Representatives attacked the American reversal on Palestine partition and espousal of a plan for a U. N. trusteeship for the Mandate. The high points of the debate came when Rep.
Leo Isaacson, American Labor Party of New York, demanded that the United States recognize the de facto Jewish state in Palestine and Rep. Jacob K. Javits of New York introduced a bill to legalize the shipment of arms and munitions to Palestine despite the State Department embargo. Isaacson also urged that the Administration return to its former pro-partition stand.
In the Senate Irving M. Ives, Republican of New York, asserted that he knew that “this wholly, catch-as-catch-can, will-o’-the-wisp policy does not represent the character of the American people.” He asked why the United States should decide to abandon the plan for partition on the basis that it is “hazardous and dangerous.”
The trusteeship plan, he insisted, appears to be “just as hazardous.” Sen. Homer Capehart, Republican of Indiana, concurred in Ives’ statements. Rep. Helen Gahagan Douglas, California Democrat, said that the Administration had been “vacillating and dishonest” in handling the Palestine problem from the day the United Nations voted for partition.
Chet Holifield, Republican Congressman from California, called the U. S. reversal “the last and culminating blunder of a weak and confused leadership.” Rep. Emanuel Celler, New York, also blasted the Administration. Rep.
Vito Marcantonio, American Labor of New York, charged that the State Department’s present Palestine policy is an “integral part” of the European Recovery Program. He added that persons who supported E.R.P. and at the same time protested the latest American change regarding Palestine were “talking out of both sides of their mouths.”
Rankin Supports Reversal In support of the Administration’s trusteeship proposal was Rep. John Rankin of Mississippi, who said that the President “ought to be applauded” by members of both parties for his latest stand. The U.
N. had no more right to set up a Jewish state in Palestine than they would have to set up a “Negro state in Harlem or a Mexican state in Texas,” he said. He was joined by Rep. Ed Gossett, of Texas, who said that 90 percent of the Congress would support Truman. Rep.
Lawrence Smith, Wisconsin Republican, said the decision to partition Palestine had been a “tragic mistake” which was now being corrected. Rep. Clare Hoffman of Michigan said the American people are “getting tired of going to war for minority groups.”
How this transcription was made
Read from the scan Maria supplied on 14 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. NO MASTHEAD, NO FOLIO AND NO DATE LINE APPEAR ON THIS SCAN. It is cropped to begin at the headline, with a sliver of the neighbouring column showing at the right edge. Neither pub nor date can be checked against the page. The article’s own dateline is a place line only, “Washington—(JTA)”, with no date in it. CONFIRMED A SEPARATE STORY, not a continuation of the U. S. Zionists article. Four independent reasons: it has its own headline and its own deck set in the same display faces; its dateline is Washington while the other article’s is New York; its subject is a floor debate in both houses of Congress, not the ZOA Administrative Council meeting; and it is a self-contained story, opening at a dateline and closing at a full stop, with no jump line in or out, whereas the other article carries explicit “(Continued on Page 3)” and “(Continued from Page 1)” furniture that accounts for all of its parts. There is no textual seam that could join the two. Both stories are JTA copy and both concern the same reversal of American policy in the same week, which is presumably why they were filed together. They should still be two records. PRINTED AS SET, INCLUDING AN ERROR OF FACT: the paper calls Chet Holifield a “Republican Congressman from California”. Holifield sat as a Democrat. I have left it exactly as printed and am flagging it here rather than repairing it. ONLY ONE WHOLE-SENTENCE QUOTATION IN THE WHOLE ARTICLE. Everything else is a clipped phrase set inside the reporter’s paraphrase — “hazardous and dangerous”, “just as hazardous”, “vacillating and dishonest”, “the last and culminating blunder of a weak and confused leadership”, “integral part”, “talking out of both sides of their mouths”, “ought to be applauded”, “tragic mistake”, “getting tired of going to war for minority groups”. None of those is a sentence, so under the whole-sentence rule none is recorded, and I have not stitched any of them into one. THE LINE MARIA WILL WANT, AND WHY IT IS NOT IN quotes: Rep. John Rankin of Mississippi is reported as saying the U. N. had no more right to set up a Jewish state in Palestine than to set up a “Negro state in Harlem or a Mexican state in Texas”. The quotation marks in the paper open only at “Negro”, so the quoted span is a fragment inside a paraphrased sentence and does not qualify as a whole-sentence quote. It is the most striking thing on the page and it is in the excerpt verbatim; it simply cannot be recorded as a quote without inventing the rest of the sentence. Thin on ordinary people, and thin in the way the 1948 material usually is: thirteen individuals are named and all thirteen are officials — two senators, ten representatives and the President. No Palestinian is named anywhere in a story entirely about the future of Palestine. Palestinians appear only as the implied object of “partition”. Nobody here can honestly be marked ordinary true, so nobody is. Ed Gossett and Lawrence Smith both appear here and also in the Evening Star advertisement in this batch (image23). In that advertisement Gossett is quoted calling the partition vote one of the blackest days in American history; here he is counting votes for Truman. Same men, two papers, two registers.
Cite this clipping
"New U. S. Palestine Policy Attacked in Congress," Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle, 26 March 1948. Covering Palestine archive, CP-1948-162. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-1948-162
More from Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle
- Peace in Palestine When Balfour Party ArrivesWisconsin Jewish Chronicle · 27 March 1925
- House of Lords Hears Figures on Cultivatable Land In PalestineWisconsin Jewish Chronicle · 29 May 1925
- A. L. Saltzstein Tells Story Of Trip To PalestineWisconsin Jewish Chronicle · 26 June 1925
- 88 Jews Left Palestine in MayWisconsin Jewish Chronicle · 7 August 1925
- The Evil Eye in PalestineWisconsin Jewish Chronicle · 18 September 1925
- Palestine Arab Executive Makes Issue of Haifa Court SentenceWisconsin Jewish Chronicle · 26 February 1926
- 27 more from this paper in the full text →
More from the 1940s
- Jewish Reprisal Raids On Two Arab Villages Take Toll of 8 LivesThe News Journal · 1 January 1948
- Palestine Blasts Rip Arab OfficesThe New York Times · 5 January 1948
- Jews Blow Up Military Post Of Jaffa ArabsMorning Advocate · 5 January 1948
- Ninety Wounded In Truck Blast At HeadquartersThe Beaumont Enterprise · 5 January 1948
- Jews Dynamite HQ of Arabs’ High CommandDaily News · 5 January 1948
- 15 Arabs Die In Jaffa BlastTerre Haute Tribune · 5 January 1948
- All 339 clippings from the 1940s →
Last updated 17 November 2026
This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.
The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.
Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-1948-162.
Everything printed in 1948 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset