Ithaca Journal · 8 August 2002
CP-2002-144
Pullout agreement falls through
Palestinians say Israelis changed terms of deal

Transcribed from the clipping
RAMALLAH, West Bank — The Palestinians and Israel agreed Wednesday on a plan for a gradual Israeli withdrawal from areas of the West Bank and Gaza Strip but the deal appeared to flounder later in the day when Palestinian officials said Israel had changed the terms.
Israeli Defense Minister Binyamin Ben-Eliezer laid out a proposal last week under which Israeli troops would gradually begin withdrawing from Palestinian-ruled parts of Gaza and the West Bank town of Bethlehem, in exchange for Palestinian guarantees that no attacks would be launched from these areas.
The Palestinian Cabinet accepted the proposal on Wednesday and Palestinian security officials and members of Israel’s Shin Bet security services met later in the day to map out the details. However, Palestinian officials emerged from the meeting and accused Israel of changing its offer. They declared the session a failure.
Calls placed to Israeli officials early today (Wednesday night EDT) were not immediately returned. Regardless, the Cabinet approval had been provisional pending the outcome of the meeting, and obstacles were still likely even if it were finalized.
Earlier, top officials of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat’s Fatah movement denounced the Cabinet decision, saying it had been taken without their consultation and amounted to a betrayal of the Palestinian struggle for the past 22 months of fighting.
In Washington, meanwhile, a senior Palestinian delegation arrived for talks with Secretary of State Colin Powell and other U.S. officials. The delegation’s head, Saeb Erekat, bristled at a blunt critique of the Palestinian leadership by Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld a day before.
Rumsfeld said the Palestinian Authority was entangled with terror and that he doubted Israel could turn over territory to it because of its poor track record.
Rumsfeld also referred to the West Bank as “so-called occupied territory,” signaling he does not share the Bush administration’s view of Israel’s presence on the land, captured by Israel in the 1967 war.
After the meeting between Palestinian and Israeli security officials, Arafat aide Nabil Abu Rdeneh said Israel had imposed new conditions on the Palestinians in the talks that were “impossible to accept or even to implement.”
He wouldn’t elaborate except to say that Israel hadn’t mentioned withdrawing from Bethlehem in the talks, just Gaza, and he declared the meeting a failure.
How this transcription was made
Read from the scan Maria supplied on 17 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. No masthead, no folio line and no date appear anywhere on this clipping. So the label date 2002-08-08 cannot be confirmed from the page. Internal evidence fits it and fixes the day of publication precisely: the deal was struck “Wednesday”, and the paper prints “Calls placed to Israeli officials early today (Wednesday night EDT) were not immediately returned” — a line that only makes sense in a Thursday paper. 7 August 2002 was a Wednesday, so Thursday 8 August 2002 is the expected fit. No masthead on this clipping at all, so I cannot check the page against pub “Ithaca Journal”. Flagging the spelling question anyway because it is the kind that moves a count: the archive has it WITHOUT a leading “The”, while the deck caption reads “The Ithaca Journal Aug 8 2002”. The page settles neither. HEADLINE vs DEK — my reading, with the evidence, because this one is arguable. “Pullout agreement falls through” is a banner set in heavy condensed sans across the FULL width of the package, above both the photograph and the text. “Palestinians say Israelis changed terms of deal” is set in a lighter serif, two lines, confined to the text columns and sitting directly on top of the byline. I took the banner as the headline and the serif line as the deck because the serif line occupies the deck’s position (over the byline, over the text measure only) and is subordinate in weight. If the archive would rather carry the serif line as the headline, the two are recorded here and the swap is clean. Column order: the photograph fills the left half; two text columns run down the right. Established from sense — column 1 ends “...the Palestinian struggle for the” and column 2 opens “past 22 months of fighting.”. NO QUOTES RECORDED. The two quotations on the page are both sentence fragments, not whole sentences, so under the standing rule neither can go into quotes[]: Rumsfeld referring to the West Bank as “so-called occupied territory”, and Nabil Abu Rdeneh saying Israel had imposed conditions “impossible to accept or even to implement”. Both are transcribed in place in the excerpt. A small mug-shot portrait of Yasser Arafat is inset in the first text column, labelled in bold simply “Arafat”. That is a photo label, not a caption, and it is not in photo_caption. The photo_caption field holds the italic caption under the main picture; its credit line, set separately above the caption, reads “The Associated Press”. The byline is set on two lines, “By HADEEL WAHDAN” over an italic “The Associated Press”. The paper set “throw stones towards an Israeli army Jeep” (British “towards”, capital J on Jeep) and “Few Palestinian demonstrators were injured”. Transcribed as printed. Nothing on this page touches Los Angeles, Southern California or any university or campus body. (Ithaca is Cornell’s town, but the page does not mention Cornell or any campus.).
Cite this clipping
"Pullout agreement falls through," Ithaca Journal, 8 August 2002. Covering Palestine archive, CP-2002-144. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-2002-144
More from Ithaca Journal
- Why the United Nations is tackling racismIthaca Journal · 15 August 2001
- Palestinian prisoners launch hunger strikeIthaca Journal · 16 August 2004
More from the 2000s
- Don’t forget it’s an Israeli occupationThe Daily Press · 1 January 2002
- Soothing Israel’s FearsThe New York Times · 7 January 2002
- Israel, in Reprisal for Killings, Razes Gaza Refugee HomesThe New York Times · 11 January 2002
- Refugees and Reparations in the MideastThe New York Times · 13 January 2002
- Israeli missiles strike naval baseThe Greenville News · 13 January 2002
- Friendship of Palestinian, architect defies oddsThe Bismarck Tribune · 17 January 2002
- All 527 clippings from the 2000s →
Last updated 17 November 2026
This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.
The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.
Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-2002-144.
Everything printed in 2002 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset