← Covering Palestine

The 2000s, in full text

Every clipping in this archive printed between 2000 and 2009: 527 of them, oldest first, as plain text that can be read, searched and quoted without running any code. Each entry links to its own record, where the scan is.

· Pittsburgh Post-Gazette · Pittsburgh

Are refugee camps still temporary?

DHEISHEH, West Bank — It's been 50 years since they first put up tents on this plot of ground called Dheisheh refugee camp, on the doorstep of Bethlehem. What was then a tent camp of Palestinian peasants fleeing Israeli armed forces, is now a densely packed, bustling city-like neighborhood of more than 10,000 people living in multiple-story houses.

Some of those houses sport satellite dishes on the roof, and home personal computers are common. Educated, liberal, free spirited, and politically active, the people of Dheisheh have come a long way. A large proportion of the young are university graduates, and Dheisheh is known for its large representation of successful professionals.

Yet these 50 years on, the people will still tell you all this is only temporary. Someday, they say, they will return to their homeland villages.

When the general Palestinian population may be reconciled to the political reality that Israel will not agree to a deluge of 2 to 4 million Palestinian refugees returning to lands now inside Israel proper, the refugees themselves are not. The refugee problem remains one of the most intractable issues to be dealt with in the final status talks.

Correction: The caption read 21 February 2000. The masthead reads "PITTSBURGH POST-GAZETTE, SUNDAY, FEBRUARY 27, 2000"; the 27th was a Sunday and the 21st was a Monday.

CP-2000-049 →

· Lexington Herald-Leader · Lexington

Some Palestinians fed up with Arafat

JERUSALEM — In the hilly Arab village of Sur Bahir, just south of Jerusalem, self-appointed rebel Zuhair Hamdaan declares that townspeople will resist if members of Yasser Arafat’s security forces question villagers without his okay.

Palestinian agents have shown such “disrespect” to Sur Bahir residents in past encounters, says Hamdaan, 47, that “if they come to interrogate or arrest anyone they should be aware they will be arrested by us.”

Hamdaan’s challenge to Arafat’s rule is one of many signs these days that Palestinians are fed up with a 6-year-old government that has brought them rampant corruption and police-state tactics, but neither prosperity nor independence.

Given the current stalemate between Arafat and Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak, there is growing danger that simmering grass-roots dissent among Palestinians could erode Arafat’s ability to negotiate a peace accord with Israel. Sur Bahir, home to 15,000 people, is not yet inside the Palestinian self-rule areas.

But like much of the West Bank and Gaza, the village is disillusioned by the Arafat government’s record. Hamdaan says he represents many East Jerusalem Arabs who fear being handed over like “sheep” from Israeli to Palestinian rule. “It would be like killing our kids, who are used to democracy,” he says.

Since his triumphant arrival in the Gaza Strip in 1994 from exile in Tunis, Arafat has managed to buy the support of many elected officials and local leaders with mysterious multimillion-dollar slush funds that provide new cars and villas to those who tow his Fatah line.

Independent voices who speak out are arrested or otherwise intimidated by one of 10 Palestinian security services that consume 36 percent of the governing Palestinian Authority’s budget. Just last week the PA closed a Hebron television station for 24 hours on grounds it was too sympathetic to striking teachers.

And Khaled Amayreh, editor of the new weekly Hebron Times, was summoned by security agents and told his publication would be “burned” if he failed to support PA government policies.

CP-2000-035 →

· Lansing State Journal · Lansing

Building, like West Bank peace, still under construction

CP-2000-036 →

· Laredo Morning Times · Laredo

No progress in peace mission

CP-2000-037 →

· Staten Island Advance · Staten Island

Symbols, semantics key to Jerusalem peace

• 2 sides explore an 'expandand-share' plan for the city By SARI BASHI ASSOCIATED PRESS ABU DIS, West Bank - Hidden in a well-guarded construction site on Jerusalem's outskirts, workers drill the finishing touches on a four-story stone auditorium some say will one day be the Palestinian parliament.

But the gleaming hall is in Abu Dis, a West Bank suburb, and not in Jerusalem, claimed by Israelis and Palestinians as a capital. Abu Dis may become part of the city in the future. Despite public pledges by both sides never to compromise on Jerusalem, negotiators have considered redrawing the city's borders in hopes of finding a solution to the stickiest issue on the table.

In the meantime, though, Abu Dis has emerged as more of an obstacle than a solution. Peace treaty talks have collapsed - and a U.S. envoy failed to revive them in a weeklong shuttle that ended yesterday - in part because of a dispute over the status of Abu Dis and Jerusalem's two other Palestinian suburbs.

The Palestinians complain that Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak has reneged on a promise to give them control of the suburbs in an upcoming troop withdrawal. Barak says he made no such commitment.

"The Palestinians feel that every time they negotiate an agreement with the Israelis, the Israelis renegotiate it." said Edward Abington, a former U.S. diplomat in Jerusalem and now a Washington-based lobbyist for the Palestinian Authority. While Jerusalem is the most difficult issue on the table, Israeli Justice Minister Yossi Beilin says it may also be one of the easiest.

Five years ago, Beilin and Mahmoud Abbas, a deputy of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, drafted a plan to expand Jerusalem's borders to include Abu Dis and create two capitals in the west and east, with areas of shared control in the middle. It was never adopted, but Israeli negotiators say they have again raised the expand-and-share idea with their Palestinian partners.

Abu Dis, a neighborhood of about 13,000 Palestinians, straddles the Jerusalem boundary, with 10 percent in the city and the rest in the West Bank, under administrative control of the Palestinian Authority. The Jordanians included Abu Dis in a 1965 plan for greater Jerusalem that was never adopted because Israel seized the eastern part of the city in the 1967 Middle East war.

It was also part of a U.N.-designated international zone for Jerusalem, proposed in 1947 but never implemented. In the 33 years since Israel captured east Jerusalem, Abu Dis has grown from a sleepy agricultural village to a bustling commercial hub. The four-story building under construction there is officially designated an economic studies center.

However, officials privately admit it is the future Palestinian parliament. A rare look inside by an Associated Press reporter revealed an amphitheater-like hall resplendent with skylight roof, about 500 seats in a semicircle overlooking a speaker's stand and stone stairs snaking up the sides.

The site is just yards from Jerusalem's boundary and two miles from the Al Aqsa Mosque, Islam's third holiest site. But suggesting Abu Dis could - or couldn't - become a capital raises hackles on both sides.

Palestinian Parliament Speaker Ahmed Qureia, whose home is in Abu Dis, said the neighborhood is a "village of Jerusalem," but cannot be an acceptable substitute for east Jerusalem proper.

Jerusalem Mayor Ehud Olmert, who opposes granting the Palestinians a foothold in the city, warned the Palestinians would use Abu Dis "for continuous sabotage activities" aimed at eventually winning control of east Jerusalem.

The chief Israeli negotiator, Oded Eran, said that in light of such opposition, Barak did not want to hand over Abu Dis and the other suburbs now, but only as part of a full peace package. "Right now, to raise it is not smart politically," Eran said. Jerusalem's current borders make little historic or demographic sense.

They were drawn after Israel captured east Jerusalem from Jordan in 1967 and then added 28 square miles to the municipal area, annexing West Bank land. The considerations were purely strategic. "The principle was to annex maximum territory with minimum (Arab) population," said Yisrael Kimchi, a researcher at the Jerusalem Institute who helped draw the boundaries.

The new border largely ignored the natural demography, cutting Palestinian villages in half. It left Israel with a large Palestinian minority in the city, now 200,000 compared to 430,000 Jews. Moussa Abu Hilal, an Abu Dis storekeeper, said that whatever the outcome of peace talks, the gerrymandered borders of his neighborhood will not remain as they are.

"These lines?" he said. "No. There will be negotiations."

CP-2000-038 →

· The Bulletin · Bend · page 1

The poetry of Arab pain: Are Israeli students ready?

Susan Sachs, N.Y. Times News Service, Ramallah

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Mahmoud Darwish, the poet whose lyrical writings have long been a touchstone of Palestinian national passions, was banned from Israel and the occupied territories for nearly 30 years.

Now he finds himself watching — still from afar, but with considerable bemusement — as his poetry becomes a weapon in the hands of right-wing Israeli politicians who would like to bring down the government. “The Arabs are always accused of being a nation of poetry,” Darwish said Monday in his sunny office in a Ramallah arts center.

“But it’s Israel that now is putting poetry in the eye of the storm.” The storm began brewing late last week, when Yossi Sarid, the iconoclastic education minister, announced that Darwish’s poetry would be included in a new multicultural literature curriculum for Israeli high school students.

The outcry from hard-liners in the opposition was not long in coming. Darwish is “anti-Zionist and an Israel-hater who calls for the destruction of the Zionist entity,” complained one member of the right-wing Likud Party. His poetry, said a member of the even more conservative National Union Party, is racist.

To impose it on Israeli students, said a member of the National Religious Party, is “a Bolshevik decision.” Prime Minister Ehud Barak said Israel was not yet ready for Darwish’s poetry to be taught… “We cannot continue to grant legitimacy to the delegitimizing that is done to us,” declared Yuval Steinitz, a Likud member of parliament. For Darwish, the dispute is like the rumbling of a distant thunderstorm.

It is ominous, but there is nothing he can do about it. His poetry may have infiltrated Israel, but he cannot. Although he was born in a village in the Galilee region in what is now Israel, and was educated in Israeli schools and studied Zionist poetry, he was barred from re-entering the country after he left in 1970.

He has lived in Cairo, Beirut and Paris, and served until 1993 as a member of the executive committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization. Long after other PLO figures were permitted to return home, the Israeli prohibition on Darwish remained.

The ban was lifted only four years ago and then only to allow Darwish to live in the parts of the West Bank and Gaza Strip under Palestinian control. The poet who once wrote that his homeland was a suitcase moved to the Palestinian city of Ramallah on the West Bank, about a 20-minute drive and a world away from Jerusalem.

Except for one trip for a funeral, he was not allowed even to visit his aging mother in the Galilee. But three months ago, to his surprise, he received a six-month pass to enter Israel — a goodwill gesture toward the Palestinian leadership, he believes, from Barak. The pass expires in May.

Darwish fears that the uproar over the teaching of his poetry in Israeli high school classes could jeopardize a renewal. “I feel embarrassed, really, by all this,” he said. “The accusation is that I hate Jews. It’s not comfortable that they show me as a devil and an enemy of Israel. I am not a lover of Israel, of course. I have no reason to be.

But I don’t hate Jews.”

“Palestinian poet: Mahmoud Darwish, 58, the poet whose lyrical writings have long been a touchstone of Palestinian passions, was banned from Israel and the occupied territories for nearly 30 years.” · Rina Castelnuovo / N.Y. Times News Service. A map beside it marks the zone of Israeli control and Ramallah.

The same week as the St. Petersburg report and a different news agency, with more of him in it. One sentence holds the whole case: his poetry may have infiltrated Israel, but he cannot. Except for a single trip to a funeral he was not permitted to visit his mother in the Galilee — and among the poems of his that the obituaries in this archive list as having been set to music and become anthems is the one called ‘I yearn for my mother’s bread.’ The two facts are printed in different American newspapers eight years apart and neither mentions the other.

CP-2000-012 →

· The Oregonian · Portland · page 1

Israelis argue over teaching Palestinian’s verse

The education minister is assailed for suggesting Mahmoud Darwish’s poems as optional reading

Susan Sachs, New York Times News Service, Ramallah

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Mahmoud Darwish, the poet whose lyrical writings have long been a touchstone of Palestinian national passions, was banned from Israel and the occupied territories for nearly 30 years… “The Arabs are always accused of being a nation of poetry,” Darwish said Monday in an interview in his sunny office in a Ramallah arts center.

“But it’s Israel that now is putting poetry in the eye of the storm.”… Prime Minister Ehud Barak weighed in, saying that Israel was not yet ready for Darwish’s poetry to be taught in the schools… The ban was lifted only four years ago and then only to allow Darwish to live in the parts of the West Bank and Gaza Strip under Palestinian control.

The poet, who once wrote that his homeland is a suitcase, lives in Ramallah on the West Bank. “I feel embarrassed, really, by all this,” he said. “The accusation is that I hate Jews. It’s not comfortable that they show me as a devil and an enemy of Israel. I am not a lover of Israel, of course. I have no reason to be. But I don’t hate Jews.”

Darwish, 58, has written poems that range from dreamy reflections on love to bitter longing for the Palestine that was lost when Israel was created in 1948. “I became addicted to exile,” he said. “My language is exile.

The metaphor for Palestine is stronger than the Palestine of reality.” One poem in particular, published in 1987, has rankled many Israelis. Called “Those Who Pass Between Fleeting Words,” it is a tirade against unnamed interlopers in what Darwish calls “our land.” “It is time for you to be gone,” the poem reads.

“Live wherever you like, but do not live among us. It is time for you to be gone. Die wherever you like, but do not die among us. For we have work to do in our land.” Darwish has said that he did not mean, as some Israeli critics charged, that he wanted to evict the Jews from Israel.

The poem, he said, was a call for Israel to leave the Palestinian territories it captured in the 1967 Middle East War.

“DARWISH — Former PLO member”

The third printing of this row in the archive and the third headline, and the only one that prints both the poem and his answer to it. That makes the poem’s whole American life visible: quoted in a wire story in April 1988 as a demand for all of Israel; here in March 2000 with his own explanation that it meant leaving the territories taken in 1967; and again in 2008, in six obituaries, where Yitzhak Shamir is reported reading it aloud in the Knesset and a specialist says it was misunderstood and mistranslated. The correction was in American newspapers eight years before the obituaries repeated the charge.

CP-2000-013 →

· The News Virginian · Waynesboro · page 1

An uproar over introduction of poet into curriculum

Israeli schools to offer works as optional reading

Samar Assad, Associated Press Writer, Ramallah

RAMALLAH, West Bank — It has little to do with poetry, and a lot with politics. A decision by the Israeli education minister to introduce five works by the Palestinian national poet, Mahmoud Darwish, as optional reading in Israeli schools has incensed hawkish and religious lawmakers, who threatened Monday to try to bring down Prime Minister Ehud Barak’s government over the verses.

Barak, apparently fearing another defeat in parliament after his coalition crumbled last week in a key vote on peace with Syria, said time “is not ripe” to teach Darwish, who as a PLO member was banned from entering Israel for 26 years. The emotional dispute over a few lines of poetry illustrates how hard it still is for Israelis and Palestinians to put aside resentments accumulated in a century of conflict.… Introducing Darwish into the curriculum is part of reforms begun by dovish Israeli Education Minister Yossi Sarid. “It is very important to know one another.

Ignorance is not the best recipe for good neighborliness,” Sarid said. The opposition Likud party accused Sarid of “legitimizing the negation of Zionism” and submitted a motion of no confidence in the government.

The religious Shas faction, a member of Barak’s coalition, hinted it might join Likud in next week’s vote on the motion, which would embarrass, but not topple the prime minister. Darwish said Monday the uproar shows how fearful many Israelis are of challenging long-held negative stereotypes about Palestinians.

“The first step of real peace is to know the other side, its culture and creativity,” Darwish said in an interview. Those who object to teaching his poetry in Israeli schools “cannot digest that the other side has culture, creativity and intellect,” Darwish said. “They consider this to be a dangerous recognition of the other side.”

“Mahmoud Darwish, the Palestinian national poet, speaks to The Associated Press in his office in the West Bank town of Ramallah on Monday.” · AP Photo

The fourth printing of this row held here, from a third news service, and the one that carries the sentence the rest of this section is circling. Objecting to his poems in a classroom, Darwish says, means being unable to digest that the other side has culture, creativity and intellect — and treating that recognition as dangerous. The number of poems at issue, given only in this version, is five, offered as optional reading.

CP-2000-014 →

· Tampa Bay Times · St. Petersburg · page 1

Poet’s work inflames cultural divide

Flore de Preneuf, Times Correspondent, Ramallah

RAMALLAH, West Bank — In his tweed jacket and tortoise-shell glasses, Mahmoud Darwish doesn’t look very threatening. Sitting in his immaculate office sipping coffee recently, the acclaimed 58-year-old Palestinian poet talked about his search for new metaphors and his latest collection of love poems.

Yet Darwish is in the middle of a political storm that threatens Israel’s government. The dispute erupted last week when Israel’s education minister, Yossi Sarid, decided to add works by Darwish to Israel’s high school curriculum.

What began as an attempt to better reflect the multicultural reality here quickly became a political liability for Prime Minister Ehud Barak.… In the Knesset, Israel’s parliament, Darwish has been the subject of heated debates this week. Right-wing politicians have pored over his prolific body of work looking for ammunition.

Quoting a line from a 1987 poem in which Darwish says “it is time for you to be gone,” some have accused the poet of wanting to evict Jews from Israel. The uproar caught Darwish by surprise. He took no part in the decision to alter Israel’s curriculum and has watched the uproar unfold from the sidelines. “I don’t like scandals,” he said.

“I’m well-enough known in my field and I don’t want to be an obstacle to Israeli unity.” “The storm makes me believe Barak is right,” Darwish said with a wink. “Israel is not ready to listen to the culture of others. Israelis do not recognize Palestinians as cultural producers.

They accept us as obstacles, as part of the landscape but nothing beyond that.”… According to Israeli historian Tom Segev, the controversy is “a combination of coalition politics and a battle in an ongoing cultural war that is raging in this country”… Sarid has refused to back down for the sake of the coalition.

Fanning the flames of the religious party’s anger, Sarid told the Knesset that he had drafted the new literature curriculum on a Saturday — a desecration of the Sabbath. On a deeper level, the controversy is a struggle over Israel’s identity.

“Geographically Israelis are living in the Middle East, but culturally they don’t want to be here,” said Darwish, who was born in the Arab village of Barweh, now part of Israel, but was forced to live in exile for more than 20 years because he was a PLO member. Sarid was careful not to choose overly political poems as an introduction to Arabic poetry.

But the attempt to open Israelis to Palestinian culture has been perceived as an affront to Zionism. In the 1960s and 1970s especially, Darwish’s poetry focused on the themes of dispossession, exile and resistance to Israeli occupation. “Nothing of our ancestors remains in us, but we want / the country of our morning coffee,” he wrote in one poem.

“I am the son / of simple words / I am the martyr of the map,” another reads. “Return to me my hands / Return to me / my identity.” Darwish said Israelis should not fear his poetry.

Noting that as a high school student in Israel he was forced to read the works of Haim Bialik, the poetic voice of Zionism, Darwish said Bialik “did not change me into a Zionist. He did not even get me to like his poems.”

“Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish is surprised at the debate over teaching his poetry in Israeli schools. ‘I don’t like scandals,’ he says. ‘I’m well-enough known in my field and I don’t want to be an obstacle to Israeli unity.’” · Associated Press

The line that the 2008 obituaries reduce to one sentence, reported here while it was happening, with the poet interviewed in his own office. He had nothing to do with the decision and watched it from the sidelines. Asked about it, he says Israelis do not recognize Palestinians as cultural producers and accept them as obstacles, as part of the landscape and nothing beyond that — which is this section’s subject, stated by him, in a Florida newspaper, eight years before he died. He also points out that being made to read the poet of Zionism at school did not turn him into a Zionist, and did not even get him to like the poems.

CP-2000-011 →

· Indianapolis Star · Indianapolis, IN

Children fulfilling pope’s dreams

■ At Jerusalem YMCA, Arab, Christian and Jewish youngsters are learning to get along.

By Judith Cebula, STAFF WRITER

JERUSALEM — Pope John Paul II isn’t going to the Jerusalem International YMCA today, his last day in Israel.

Instead, the Holy Father will make a final historic blitz across this city of three faiths — for prayer at the Western Wall, the most sacred place for Jews; a tour of Al Aqsa Mosque on the Temple Mount, the third most holy Muslim site; and Mass at the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, where Jesus was crucified, died and was buried.

If the 79-year-old man, so full of pleas for peace, walked into the Jerusalem Y, he would see the fulfillment of his prayers in Jewish, Muslim and Christian children learning to love one another as they learn together how to tie their shoes. For 20 years, Arab and Israeli Jewish boys and girls have been coming to this unique preschool.

Together they draw pictures of trees and birds, build houses from Lego blocks and run around in circles on the playground for the simple joy of it. “Children are the innocents,” said Daphna Bassewitch Ginzberg, the preschool’s director. “They are too young to have stereotypes or prejudices.

They are still naive enough to become friends easily.” … Children at the YMCA know nothing of this pain. They are 3- and 4- and 5-year-olds from working-class families and wealthy families. Most spend their days in mixed classrooms — half of the students are Jewish, the other half Arab. Most of the Arab children are Muslim. Just 2 percent are Christian.

The demographics reflect Jerusalem itself. Like street signs, every bulletin board, art project and parent newsletter is bilingual — Hebrew and Arabic. Each classroom has two teachers: One is Jewish and speaks Hebrew; the other is Arab and speaks Arabic.

Even the children’s names and birth dates, written on colorful construction paper butterflies and doves decorating the classroom walls, contain both the fanciful Arabic and Hebrew scripts — Yael and Mohammed; Ahmad and Tali.

A good clipping for the terminology question even though it never uses “Israeli Arab”. It shows the categorisation problem in its raw form: in a 1,500-word article about a preschool in which half the children are Arab, the Arab children are never given a nationality while the Jewish children are, the sorting categories change three times, and no Arab parent, teacher or child speaks.

CP-2000-069 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Says It Will Restore Seized Land to Arab Village

Joel Greenberg

Forty-four years after the killings, land taken from Kafr Qasim is to be returned. The verb in the headline is says.

CP-2000-057 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco

Israel Promises to Return Land to Arab Village

San Francisco’s version of the same day. Says becomes promises.

CP-2000-058 →

· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha

Land Day Marches Are Violent

Palestinians Stone Israeli Troops, Who Fire Pellets at Crowd

The Associated Press

Palestinians staged marches Thursday in Israel, the West Bank and Gaza Strip — and in some cases clashed with Israeli troops — to protest the confiscation of Arab-owned land and Jewish settlement expansion.

Land Day at twenty-four, in Omaha. The subhead gives both actions and both actors, which is unusual enough in this archive to note.

CP-2000-056 →

· The Jamestown Sun · page 6

Holy Land understanding unheralded

Among differing religious faiths in area where 'God chose to pitch his tent'

MAALE ADUMIM, West Bank (AP) — During his Middle East pilgrimage, Pope John Paul II called for more dialogue among religious faiths in the land where "God chose to pitch his tent." Under a goat-hair tent on a recent afternoon, a Muslim and Jew were having just such a talk. The two men sat on either side of a fire, next to cross-legged children on mats.

Behind them on a hill, row upon row of stone houses in Maale Adumim, the West Bank's largest Jewish settlement, dwarfed their encampment of tents and tin shacks. Hamad Abu Daoud, in a red-and-white keffiyeh, is a leader of the Jahalin, a Bedouin community. His guest, Jeremy Milgrom, in a blue workshirt, is a rabbi.

They exchange small talk about family in Arabic, punctuated by the long silences of men who have spent time together. They discuss the 25 volunteers Milgrom oversees who tutor the Bedouin in English.

And they address the pressing news: orders from Israeli's military government in the West Bank that the Jahalin leave this land for a settlement near a garbage dump where it will be difficult to herd their sheep. There is no talk of God; there are no references to the Torah or Koran. No talk of interreligious understanding.

But to Milgrom the experience is distinctly religious. "He opens his home to me," says the rabbi.

"The root of a religious atmosphere is a spirit which is shared." While the pope's impassioned call for harmony among the faiths has received international attention, the ongoing work of interreligious understanding in Israel and the Palestinian Authority is more often unheralded and hidden.

It's less about one-time dialogues between leaders, like Thursday's troubled encounter between the pope, Israel's chief rabbi and a Muslim cleric, than about sustained relationships between more private people in a society that says such bonds shouldn't exist.

The one clipping in the batch outside the 1967-69 window, and the only one in which Palestinians speak at length in their own voices — three of them, two named with occupations and one with her age. It also contains, in two sentences, the whole 1948 expulsion told through one house in Ramle: 'Israeli soldiers had driven the Al-Khayri family from the property in 1948 during an expulsion of Palestinians from the area' — the paper's own voice, unhedged, the word 'expulsion' unqualified. That is the Dalia Landau / Bashir Al-Khayri story later told in Sandy Tolan's 'The Lemon Tree'; the detail of the blind father asking to touch the lemon tree he planted, caressing it and crying, is here in a 2000 AP wire story on page 6 of a North Dakota daily. Worth showing Maria for that alone. Note also the Jahalin thread: the lede scene is a Bedouin community being ordered off its land to a site next to a garbage dump, reported in passing as 'the pressing news' while the story's subject is interfaith dialogue.

CP-2000-070 →

· The New York Times · New York · page A6

In West Bank, Water Is as Touchy as Land

Parched Villagers Uneasy as Talks Go On

By WILLIAM A. ORME Jr.

KARMEL, West Bank, July 12 — Rafat, a skinny 9-year-old too shy to supply a surname, heads every summer morning to the only swimming hole in this hardscrabble stretch of the Hebron hills. It is a stark stone cistern, about a 100 feet long and 50 feet across, built long ago to store the rains that fall only in winter.

Descending a rickety ladder, Rafat and his pals plunge happily into stagnant water barely three feet deep, its surreal surface an unbroken carpet of brilliant green algae. “These are our children,” said Khalil Yunis, mayor of the nearby town of Yatta, shaking his head at the sight of the small boys diving under the undulating scum.

“And this is their water.” Rafat’s algae-choked swimming pool is the centerpiece of the village water system. The other daily water source for Karmel’s 3,500 residents is a tiny spring-fed brook wending its way through a herd of goats into a newly covered concrete cistern.

The villagers carry pails past a hand-lettered sign in English and Arabic extolling this modest public works project, “implemented by Yatta municipality” and financed by the United States Agency for International Development. “God bless America,” Mr. Yunis said with a wry smile. Mr.

Yunis tried to help Karmel further by linking the village to Yatta’s municipal water system, but the summer supply in Yatta is so low that water now flows through the three-inch pipe here just two or three days a month, the mayor said. Like most of the West Bank, Yatta gets its water from Israel’s state water company.

Dispute over water resources has been a fact of life here since the land was occupied by Israel 33 years ago.

The stone cistern that is the centerpiece of Karmel’s water system is filled only three feet deep with stagnant, algae-covered water. But lacking any better swimming hole in the vicinity, young boys jump in. “These are our children,” said the mayor of a nearby town. “And this is their water.”

Date check: The masthead line reads in full: “A6 L+ THE NEW YORK TIMES INTERNATIONAL SATURDAY, JULY 15, 2000”. This matches both pub and date exactly. The story dateline is “KARMEL, West Bank, July 12”.

CP-2000-062 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

ARAB WRITER ADMITS STONE-THROWING

Edward Said, the Palestinian writer and Columbia University professor, has admitted he threw stones at Israel’s border fence — but he said it was a harmless act of joy. Mr. Said was photographed this month among the daily throng of Lebanese who celebrate Israel’s May withdrawal by stoning the fence. Israel has called on Lebanese authorities to properly police the area.

In a July 6 statement faxed Wednesday to The Associated Press in Jerusalem, Mr. Said wrote, “Much is now made of an incident that is basically trivial, as if that could ever outweigh the work I have done over 35 years on behalf of justice and peace.”

CP-2000-071 →

· Indianapolis Star · Indianapolis · page 1

Arafat rejected $30 billion for refugee relocation, aide says

By Ibrahim Barzak, The Associated Press, Gaza City

“GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat rejected an American plan to set up a $30 billion international fund to resettle refugees, a top Palestinian official said Thursday. Salim Zanoun, chairman of the PLO Central Council, said the offer came during last month’s summit at the Camp David presidential retreat outside Washington.

He said it was part of American pressure on Arafat to compromise on the refugee issue. The Palestinians are demanding that millions of refugees be allowed to return to their former homes in what is now Israel. Rejecting the offer, Arafat ‘told the Americans that the issue of refugees is non-negotiable,’ Zanoun said.

In Washington, State Department spokesman Richard Boucher declined to comment. Israel is willing to allow a few thousand Palestinian refugees to be reunited with their families in Israel. The others would settle in a Palestinian state or in countries where they now live. Palestinians fled during the 1948 war that followed Israel’s creation.

They were confined to refugee camps in Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon, where many still live with their descendants. Some of the camps came under Israeli control in 1967, when Israel captured the West Bank and Gaza Strip.”

“Yasser Arafat won’t negotiate on refugees.”

Attributed to an aide. The headline is the refusal; what was being refused — resettlement in a Palestinian state or in the countries where the refugees now live — is further down the column.

CP-2000-001 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Israel is a stone's throw from Arab violence

MICHAEL GOODWIN

Make no mistake: The barbarians are at the gate. The Fatma Gate, that is. The gate is the main border point between northern Israel and Lebanon, and I was there recently on a working vacation. The vacation part of the trip was thrilling: Israel is a fascinating country, full of wondrous achievements and baffling contradictions. The working part of the trip was sobering.

My visit to the Israeli watchtower on the Lebanese border, a bunker in the sky, brought home clearly the extent to which violence against Israel is not just an Arab strategy. It is *the* Arab strategy. Whether it's a stone in Lebanon or a terrorist bomb in Jerusalem, or just the threat of one, the tune is consistent. Violence seems the only card the Arabs play.

It's a point Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat underscored before his visit to New York, where he is to meet today with President Clinton. Any hopes that Arafat was bringing an olive branch were dashed by his fiery speech to Arab leaders Sunday that included explicit warnings of violence if there is no deal.

The miniature version of that sickening strategy is on daily display at the Fatma Gate, despite Israel's pulling all its troops out of Lebanon three months ago. Its 18-year occupation of a buffer zone was costly and unpopular, and Prime Minister Ehud Barak ordered an overnight withdrawal.

Hezbollah, the main terrorist group in Lebanon, failed to inflict a single casualty during the retreat, and its frustration is showing on the border. Donning the required army flak jackets, my wife and I had no sooner entered the bunker's main observation room when our Israeli Army host announced, “Be careful, now it begins.”

Looking past the machine gun mounted in the slit window toward the concrete barricades that mark the actual border, we saw on the Lebanese side 30 yards away three armed men in civilian clothes. But the man to watch was standing near those three. Wearing a light blue T-shirt and a black baseball cap, he was at that moment hurling a large stone in our direction.

It shattered harmlessly against the steel-and-cement tower, but the clanging sound was jarring. Ditto for the 10 or so other stones the man threw before taking a seat next to the Hezbollah men and picking up a walkie-talkie. The stone-throwing void was quickly filled. Other men appeared and threw.

The clanging when the stones hit the tower makes you feel you are inside a bell jar during a mad scientist's experiment. Then, most pathetically of all, a man appeared beyond the barricades with three children. Each took turns picking up stones to throw. “The weekends are the worst,” said our host, an army spokesman named Itamar.

“Hundreds of people come like tourists to throw stones.” Edward Said, the Columbia University Palestinian professor, was recently a stone-throwing visitor. Another soldier, one of six in the 10-by-12-foot space, pointed to a small pile of stones on the Lebanese side and said the pile would grow by the weekend so that tourists would have plenty of ammunition.

The Israeli soldiers accept this routine abuse as part of their famously required service to their country. The oldest in the room was 25; most were 20 or 21. Behind macho disdain for the rock throwers, several seemed nervous about the situation. They are human tripwires with no communication with the other side. “Shooting is how we talk here now,” said Itamar.

His point was driven home to us two days later, when soldiers shot two Lebanese who tried to scale the border fence. Violence, sadly, is not limited to stones. Later in my trip, I met in the West Bank town of Ramallah with Nabil Amr, Arafat's minister of parliamentary affairs.

Noting that Barak had offered to return 90% of the West Bank that Israel seized in the 1967 war, Amr said, “Nobody before could imagine an Israeli offering to return 90%.” Lest that sound like praise, he quickly added: “So he can give 95%.” And if he doesn't?

To that, Amr repeated a version of what was a mantra in the 75-minute interview: *There are these groups that we cannot control.* The message was clear: Don't blame the Palestinians if terrorists return to their deadly business. Blame only the Israelis for refusing to surrender themselves and their country. These are not the sentiments of peacemakers.

To paraphrase the late Yitzhak Rabin, Israel is a great country. It just happens to be in a really bad neighborhood.

Bassam Shaka, visiting Palestinian official, hurling stone at Fatma Gate last month.

CP-2000-072 →

· The Columbian · Vancouver

Contested holy sites

CONTESTED HOLY SITES · Arafat’s refusal of plan dims peace hopes · Palestinian leader and Barak say they’re still committed to reaching an accord

By Barry Schweid, Associated Press writer

UNITED NATIONS — Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat has rejected a proposal by President Clinton for control of Muslim and Jewish holy sites in East Jerusalem, but Clinton refused to abandon his effort to bring about a Mideast peace accord. Although Arafat’s action dimmed already fading hopes for an agreement, Clinton directed his senior mediator, Dennis B.

Ross, to keep talking to Israeli and Palestinian negotiators. Arafat and Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak are still committed to concluding a settlement, and “they understand the time is short,” Clinton said.

“Revered ground: Nuns climb the stairs to the site of the crucifixion of Jesus at Calvary in the Church of the Holy Sepulcher in the Christian quarter of East Jerusalem’s Old City on Thursday. Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak and Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat both said, after meeting with President Clinton at the U.N.

Millennium Summit in New York, that they could not yield any further ground, especially in Jerusalem, the holy city claimed by Israelis and Palestinians as a capital.” Jacqueline Larma / The Associated Press.

Three weeks before the second intifada. The headline puts the failure on one man’s refusal; the line under it says both leaders are still committed, which is the same fact arranged the other way. The caption is the neat version of the whole problem: a city claimed by Israelis and Palestinians as a capital, with both claims given the same verb and neither given a history. The photograph is of nuns on a staircase.

CP-2000-002 →

· The Courier News · Bridgewater

Arafat at the United Nations

Clinton proposal rejected by Arafat

By Barry Schweid, The Associated Press

UNITED NATIONS — Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat has rejected a proposal by President Clinton for control of Muslim and Jewish holy sites in East Jerusalem, but Clinton refused to abandon his effort to bring about a Mideast peace accord. Although Arafat’s action dimmed already fading hopes for an agreement, Clinton directed his senior mediator, Dennis B.

Ross, to keep talking to Israeli and Palestinian negotiators. Arafat and Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak are still committed to concluding a settlement and “they understand the time is short,” Clinton said. Arafat has reserved the right to proclaim Palestinian statehood without Israel’s blessing on Sept.

13, though he has hinted the PLO’s top policy-making body, which will make the final decision, is likely to delay such a proclamation until later this year… Even if Arafat accepted the proposal, east Jerusalem’s future would still be undecided.

At the Camp David summit in July, Barak offered the Palestinians local control of some neighborhoods and suburbs, but Arafat rejected the overture, insisting on sovereignty over the entire part of the city Israel won from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast war.

“Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, left, shakes hands with President of Yemen during their meeting at the United Nations Millennium Summit.” Associated Press photo.

The same Barry Schweid dispatch the Columbian ran the same day (CP-2000-002), under a different headline and a different photograph. Here it is a transaction — Clinton proposal rejected by Arafat — and the picture is Arafat shaking hands at a summit. There it was Arafat’s refusal of plan dims peace hopes, over a photograph of nuns climbing a staircase in the Old City. Neither headline carries the second half of the first sentence, which is that Clinton refused to give up. The last paragraph is the one worth reading twice: it says Barak offered local control of some neighborhoods and suburbs of a city Israel won from Jordan, which is a lot of the argument in one sentence.

CP-2000-003 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel’s Next Palestinian Problem

Deborah Sontag

“As the Israelis wrestle with an external peace, the nation’s Arab population tests the identity of the Jewish state.”

A magazine cover on Palestinian citizens of Israel, a fifth of the country, framed in the headline as Israel’s next problem. The people are the subject of the article and the predicate of the title.

CP-2000-050 →

· Hawaii Tribune Herald · Hilo

Worst violence in four years erupts in Gaza

12-year-old boy killed in Palestinian-Israeli cross fire

Associated Press

NETZARIM, Gaza Strip — Caught in Israeli-Palestinian crossfire, a father and son clung together behind a metal barrel, barely visible in the smoke as shots flew overhead. “The child, the child!” the father yelled, helplessly waving his arm in the air.

The boy screamed in panic as shots hit a wall just inches over their heads as Israeli troops traded shots with several gunman and scores of rock-throwing Palestinians. Seconds later, 12-year-old Mohammed Rami Aldura was fatally shot in the stomach. He loosened his grip on his father and slumped over.

Seriously wounded, the father, Jamal, shook with convulsions, rolled his eyes skyward and lost consciousness. He was hospitalized in Gaza, family members said Saturday. An ambulance driver was killed trying to rescue them, and a Palestinian police officer also died in the clash.

The three killed in Netzarim were among 12 Palestinians who died Saturday in the bloodiest clashes on the West Bank and Gaza Strip since 1996. More than 500 Palestinians were injured, the Palestinian health minister said.

The trigger for the violence was a visit by Israel’s hard-line opposition leader, Ariel Sharon, last week to a bitterly contested Jerusalem shrine sacred to Muslims and Jews. Sharon said he toured the compound to show Israel was in control there. On Friday, six Palestinians were killed and close to 200 wounded in clashes in the walled compound.

“The battle over Jerusalem has begun,” said Bassem Naim, a Palestinian activist, as thousands of protesters chanting the Muslim battle cry “Allahu Akbar,” or God is Great, marched toward an Israeli army position. Further dimming prospects for an Israeli-Palestinian peace treaty, the two sides traded angry accusations Saturday.

These photos show Jamal Aldura and his 12-year-old son, Rami, take shelter as they’re caught in crossfire between Israeli troops and Palestinian gunmen in Netzarim Jewish settlement in southern Gaza. At left, Aldura looks toward the cameraman as he shouts for help; center, he tries to wave off the gunmen; at right, both are shot, the boy fatally.

CP-2000-022 →

· Daily News · New York

12 Arabs slain, 523 hurt

Bloody Mideast riots worst since 1996

JERUSALEM — Israeli troops battling gunmen and thousands of rock-throwing Palestinians opened fire on the rioters yesterday, killing 12 Palestinians and wounding 523 in the bloodiest confrontations in the West Bank and Gaza Strip since 1996.

Among those killed in the second day of deadly clashes was a 12-year-old boy who was caught in the crossfire and screamed in panic as shots hit a wall just inches above his head. The trigger for the violence was a dispute over a bitterly contested Jerusalem shrine sacred to Muslims and Jews.

Six Palestinians were killed and nearly 200 were injured in clashes at the compound Friday. “The battle over Jerusalem has begun,” Bassem Naim, a Palestinian activist, said as thousands of protesters chanting the Muslim battle cry “Allahu akbar” [God is great] marched toward an Israeli army position.

Further dimming prospects for an Israeli-Palestinian peace treaty, the two sides traded angry accusations Saturday. Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak spoke to Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat by phone late yesterday. “The prime minister warned Arafat that he [Barak] will not let violence a become tool in the negotiations,” Barak’s office said in a statement.

But Palestinian officials said that emotions were running high among Palestinians, and that the heavy-handed response of Israeli troops made matters worse. Secretary of State Albright, in Iceland yesterday during a trip to Europe, said she had spoken to leading parties on both sides in an effort to ease tensions.

“We are very concerned about the violence,” Albright said. “It is clearly counterproductive in the peace process. There is danger of a cycle of violence developing. “The talks are at a very delicate stage, and it is important that the violence stops.”

UNDER FIRE A Palestinian man and his 12-year-old son are caught in crossfire as they huddle near concrete block yesterday. The boy was killed and the father badly wounded.

CP-2000-023 →

· The Ledger · page A13

Child Perishes In Cross-Fire

By Najib Abu Jobein, The Associated Press

NETZARIM, Gaza Strip — Caught in Israeli-Palestinian cross-fire, a father and son clung together behind a metal barrel, barely visible in the smoke, as shots flew overhead. “The child, the child!” the father yelled, helplessly waving his arm in the air. The boy screamed in panic as shots hit a wall just inches above their heads.

Seconds later, 12-year-old Mohammed Aldura was fatally struck in the abdomen. He loosened his grip on his father and slumped over. Seriously wounded, the father, Jamal, shook with convulsions, rolled his eyes skyward and lost consciousness. He was hospitalized in Gaza and was expected to recover, family members said Saturday.

Khaled Bazyan, 16, left home Saturday morning to join a rock-throwing protest against Israeli soldiers. His mother, Alia, feared the worst. She sent her younger son Mohammed to bring him back, but the teen-ager wouldn’t listen.

The boy, who dropped out of high school last week to take a job at a car wash, was killed when Israeli soldiers crouching behind jeeps traded fire with masked Palestinian gunmen in an olive grove south of Nablus. His mother kissed Khaled goodbye when his body was brought to her home, lying on a stretcher and wrapped in a Palestinian flag, before burial.

“Last night he was playing soccer in the room with his brother and I warned him not to break the furniture. He wouldn’t stop and was happy,” she said, dressed in black and breaking into tears.

In these television images Saturday, Jamal Aldura, top left photo, signals his position while protecting his 12-year-old son Rami, as they shelter behind a barrel from cross-fire in Gaza City. In top right photo, Aldura shouts toward the cameraman.

In bottom left photo, dust rises from the cross-fire and moments later, bottom right photo, Rami slumps to the ground fatally hit, and his father, gravely wounded, loses consciousness.

CP-2000-026 →

· St. Louis Post-Dispatch · St. Louis

Rioting, gunfire in Gaza, West Bank leave 12 dead

Palestinians burned effigies of Sharon in a Lebanese refugee camp, and 5,000 Egyptian students rallied at their campuses to protest the shootings. A thousand protesters carrying Palestinian flags marched through Ein el-Hilweh, Lebanon’s largest refugee camp, shouting: “We live for Palestine! We die for Palestine!”

About 40 Palestinian guerrillas armed with AK-47 assault rifles trampled the Israeli flag. In Lebanon’s 13 refugee camps, where most of the nation’s 400,000 Palestinian refugees live, residents observed a general strike and day of mourning for the victims. Shops and schools were closed.

Arab League Secretary-General Esmat Abdel-Meguid said the 22 ambassadors to the league would meet in emergency session in Cairo, Egypt, to discuss violence in the Palestinian areas. “We strongly condemn the Likud leader, Ariel Sharon, whose provocative actions led to this bloodshed,” Abdel-Meguid told The Associated Press.

In Beirut, Lebanese Prime Minister Salim Hoss called on world nations to “work for an immediate halt to the Israeli aggression against Arab Jerusalem.” In Amman, the Jordanian Council of Unions called Sharon a criminal. Efforts are under way to “hold a popular trial for the terrorist Sharon,” council spokesman Saleh Armouti said.

But Jordanian Foreign Minister Abdul-Ilah Khatib has said the “practical response to such provocative acts” as Sharon’s visit would be to secure an Israeli-Palestinian peace agreement that “guarantees our Palestinian brothers their rights and declares their independent state with Jerusalem as its capital.”

On Friday, six Palestinians were killed and almost 200 wounded in clashes in the walled compound. “The battle over Jerusalem has begun,” said Bassem Naim, a Palestinian activist, as thousands of protesters chanting the Muslim battle cry “Allahu Akbar,” or God is great, marched toward an Israeli army position.

On Saturday, Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak told Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat by phone that Barak “will not let violence be a tool in the negotiations,” Barak’s office said in a statement. Israel’s army chief, Lt. Gen.

Shaul Mofaz, said the Palestinian Authority did nothing to stop the violence and that Palestinian police officers in some cases even participated in the clashes. Palestinian peace negotiator Nabil Shaath called the deadly confrontations at the Jerusalem shrine a “premeditated massacre” by Israeli security forces, aimed at proving that Israel is sovereign there.

During the unrest, Palestinian youths hurled rocks. Others stuffed gasoline-soaked rags into bottles and threw them at Israeli soldiers who fired rubber-coated steel pellets and live rounds from behind walls and jeeps. The Palestinian Authority, providing a list of names and ages, said 12 Palestinians were killed and four were brain dead as a result of army fire.

The Palestinian health minister, Riad Zanoun, said 523 Palestinians were injured. The Israeli army said 11 soldiers were injured. In two spots — an army outpost outside the Jewish settlement of Netzarim in Gaza and south of the West Bank town of Nablus — several Palestinians, some masked, exchanged fire with Israeli soldiers.

“The Israelis must understand that Palestinians can also shoot and kill,” said a gunman armed with an M-16 assault rifle. He would not give his name. In Netzarim, the 12-year-old boy who was killed was identified as Mohammed Aldura. He was caught in the cross-fire with his father, Jamal.

At one point, before the child was fatally hit, the father raised his head above the metal barrel that served as their cover and shook his finger, as if to admonish those firing at him. Besides the boy, two other Palestinians died in that clash, including an ambulance driver who tried to rescue the child and a Palestinian policeman.

Israeli troops fired anti-tank missiles during the firefight, the army said. The deadliest confrontation erupted in Nablus, where six Palestinians, including two policemen and a 16-year-old boy, were killed in a protracted firefight. Sharon denies that his visit triggered the violence, and he blamed the unrest on the Palestinian Authority.

Palestinian youths evacuate a wounded man Saturday during a clash with Israeli soldiers near the Jewish settlement of Netzarim in the Gaza Strip. A 12-year-old boy was among those killed Saturday in Netzarim.

CP-2000-031 →

· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota

TV captures young boy's death

BUREIJ REFUGEE CAMP, Gaza Strip — Caught in a hail of bullets, he died in his father’s arms - and in the viewfinder of a TV camera. The scene was viewed all over the world.

Twelve-year-old Mohammed al-Durrah — shot as his desperate father tried to shield him after they blundered into the middle of a fierce Israeli-Palestinian clash outside a small Jewish settlement — was mourned Sunday in the teeming refugee camp where he spent his short life.

It was not entirely clear who fired the fatal shots, though Palestinians blamed the Israelis. “I was always afraid something like this would happen to him,” said Mohammed’s 30-year-old mother, Amal, sitting at the family’s home, which was filled with friends and relatives who spilled over into the mourning tent outside.

“To those who did it, I say: I wish you may burn.” Amid a welter of brutal scenes from street battles that have swept the West Bank and Gaza Strip since Thursday, the boy’s death was a singularly horrific one.

TV footage shot by French television during Saturday’s pitched battle outside the heavily guarded Gaza settlement of Netzarim showed Mohammed clinging to his father, Jamal, and screaming in terror as a sustained burst of gunfire raked a concrete wall behind them. As the two huddled behind a tiny abutment, the father vainly stretched a protective arm in front of his son.

Most stations that aired the footage cut away before the stricken boy could be seen slumping over, loosing his grip on the father, who himself twitched convulsively as he was struck by round after round. On Sunday, Jamal al-Durrah, a 37-year-old laborer, remained in a Gaza hospital recovering from bullet wounds.

In this TV image, Jamal Aldura shouts toward the camera as he protects his son, Rami, on Saturday.

CP-2000-018 →

· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota

Funerals for Palestinians feed rage

ing, “Our babies’ blood is as red as your babies.” For the first time, Palestinian rioting itself spread beyond the West Bank and Gaza into Arab towns such as Nazareth inside Israel’s borders. The size and intensity of the internal riots stunned Israeli police.

Nine Palestinians were reported killed Sunday, bringing the Arab death toll to 28 since Friday, when Israeli troops stormed the area of Al Aksa Mosque in the contested center of Jerusalem’s Old City after Palestinians began stoning Jewish worshippers at the Western Wall.

That action followed angry scenes on Thursday set off by the visit of the right-wing politician, Ariel Sharon, to the steps of the ancient shrines in the Old City. The riots claimed their first Israeli victim Sunday, a border police officer wounded in a gun battle that began when Palestinians surrounded Joseph’s Tomb, a holy Jewish site, in Palestinian-controlled Nablus.

With the deadlocked peace negotiations as their backdrop, the Israelis blamed the Palestinians for failing to control their streets while the Palestinians, using such words as “murder” and “massacre,” accused the Israelis of excessive force.

A senior Israeli official said that the Israelis believed that the Palestinians wanted to exact vengeance — “a few Israeli soldiers dead to make it even” — before they cracked down on protesters.

In uncharacteristically harsh language, Foreign Minister Shlomo Ben Ami, accused the Palestinians of orchestrating the clashes “from above, in the hopes that a certain degree of violence would serve a short-term political purpose.” But he said that unleashing violence deliberately is like “trying to ride a tiger.”

With black smoke billowing from burning tires and trash cans, funeral processions snaked through the rocky hills of the West Bank and along the sands of the Gaza Strip. Marching grimly to mourning verses from the Koran, Palestinian soldiers carried aloft the bodies of young men draped in Palestinian flags as fresh bodies collected in the morgues.

An Israeli police officer aims his gun towards Israeli Arab protestors in the northern city of Nazareth Sunday. Palestinians and Israeli troops waged running gunbattles. It was a vicious, but familiar, cycle, in which the sorrow roused by burials turned into angry confrontations.

CP-2000-019 →

· The Arizona Republic · Phoenix

Boy slain in crossfire is hailed as martyr

Palestinian mom sees death on TV

BUREIJ REFUGEE CAMP, Gaza Strip — Like viewers around the world, Amal Aldura watched her terrified son die on television as his father tried to shield him from Israeli gunfire. “I went crazy.

I was screaming and crying,” the 34-year-old mother of seven said Sunday, as dozens of mourners filled the bare concrete house where her boy Mohammed Jamal Aldura was born 12 years ago. Now, as her husband lies critically wounded in a nearby hospital, Amal is sedated.

Outside, Mohammed’s face is already emblazoned on posters calling him the “Martyr of al-Aqsa.” The morning paper published a sequence of photos showing him crouched behind a cement block Saturday and then cut down by a hail of bullets.

Mohammed’s mother and his brother and cousins remember him as an active, outgoing boy who liked to play soccer, go for a ride with his dad or run errands for older relatives who worked in the neighborhood. The Israeli army said Mohammed and his father Jamal were among the protesters who assaulted their outpost outside a Jewish settlement in Gaza.

In Mohammed’s death, it was not entirely clear who fired the fatal shots, though Palestinians blamed the Israelis.

Amal said Mohammed had gone with his father to shop for a used car in Gaza City on Saturday morning, because his parents didn’t want him to get swept up with other children who might be inclined to watch or join in the riots that began in Gaza on Friday.

Family members said that when father and son were coming home, without a new car, their taxi was stopped at an Israeli roadblock at Netzarim junction. The shooting started just as the two headed hand-in-hand across the intersection to get a taxi on the other side. For 40 minutes, they were trapped by the gunfire.

After the boy was hit, his father yelled, “My son is dying, my son is dying,” but no one could get to them. The Israeli army has opened an investigation into Mohammed’s death, which a spokesmen called a “horrible tragedy.” Mohammed’s mother said she takes comfort that her child is in paradise because he died a martyr’s death.

But she does not believe her son’s death will change anything. “We’re used to this. Once in a while people die. But everything goes on as usual,” she said. The Associated Press contributed to this article.

CP-2000-025 →

· Kalamazoo Gazette

Fighting in Jerusalem intensifies

JERUSALEM — Israelis and Palestinians waged fierce gun battles throughout the West Bank and Gaza Strip today, ignoring appeals from around the world to cease fire. Those in the midst of the violence spoke in panicked tones of war, and clashes intensified in Israeli Arab villages, with reports of five killed.

In Gaza, at an army outpost near the isolated settlement of Netzarim, Palestinians scaled an abandoned tower and removed an Israeli flag. Palestinian snipers fired inside the compound. The Israelis responded with anti-tank missiles and helicopter gunships, killing two Palestinians and injuring 35, according to hospital officials.

The missiles tore chunks off buildings and torched a car. The violence also continued to spread in Israeli Arab villages. Police reported that five Israeli Arabs died in clashes today, bringing the total to six since Arab Israelis began their solidarity protests on Sunday.

Riots even reached towns otherwise known for successful Jewish-Arab coexistence, such as the old coastal town of Acre. Rioters trashed Jewish-owned businesses in Nazareth, the town of Jesus’ boyhood.

The street battles, sparked by a visit last week by Ariel Sharon, the leader of the hard-line opposition Likud party, to the Jerusalem shrine revered by Muslims and Jews, had taken the lives of 35 Palestinians and eight Israelis by today. More than 1,000 Palestinians were injured, by Palestinian count.

Today’s death toll was 10: in addition to the five Israeli Arabs, four protesters died in the Gaza Strip, and one was killed in the West Bank. Fire fights also raged in a West Bank town and a besieged Jewish settlement, and the violence increasingly disrupted the lives of ordinary Israelis and Palestinians.

An Israeli undercover police officer grabs a Palestinian youth participating in stone-throwing clashes with Israeli troops during a riot-control operation in the Shuafat refugee camp in east Jerusalem Sunday.

CP-2000-027 →

· Newsday · Melville · page A7

Shattering Image

Family mourns boy, 12, killed in the crossfire

By Matthew McAllester, Middle East Correspondent

Bureij Refugee Camp, Gaza Strip — Mohammed al-Durra’s mother will have to clean out the pink birdcage now and feed her son’s five pet finches. “I’ll raise them for him,” said Amal al-Durra yesterday afternoon, as she sat in a white plastic chair in her living room surrounded by dozens of female members of her family, some crying, all somber.

“His math teacher gave them to him. He loved them so much.” The birdcage that hangs from the ceiling is just one visual reminder of her second-oldest son. Another will forever be the television images broadcast around the world on Saturday of the 12-year-old’s last moments sheltering with his father from a torrent of gunfire.

Mohammed died in a crossfire between Israeli soldiers and Palestinian police at the nearby Netzarim junction in Gaza as he accompanied his father back from a trip to the local used-car market.

As the boy sheltered next to his father, Jamal, behind a concrete pipe leading to Gaza’s sewer system, a French television cameraman filmed his death and his father’s wounding. It was a shocking image that had no apparent impact on the ongoing violence between Israel and the Palestinians.

His mother’s religion tells her that the footage was the filming of a Palestinian martyr in the making. Her political acumen tells her that it was the chronicle of a pointless death, just another numbing moment in the decades-long struggle between the Palestinians and the Israelis.

“Nothing new will come of this,” she said, unnervingly calm under medication prescribed by her doctor. “We will still have our martyrs. Things will continue . . . There will never be a peace agreement. We’re used to this. Every once in a while people die and it continues.”

As she mourned her son yesterday, another Palestinian mother lost her 12-year-old boy in Gaza. And another lost her 10-year-old in Nablus. At Netzarim, where Mohammed died the day before, a teenage boy ran at the Israeli army base, threw a stone at the same time as a rifle shot sounded, and then crumpled in the street, motionless until an ambulance arrived to scoop him up.

The fighting continued past sundown. Like most of the victims of the clashes, those boys and Mohammed will soon be forgotten by all but their family and friends.

In this image from video taken Saturday, Jamal al-Durra shouts toward the camera as he tries to shield son Mohammed from gunfire. Moments later, al-Durra was wounded, and the 12-year-old son was killed. Below, al-Durra recovers in a Shifa hospital in Gaza.

A full page carrying two stories: Bloody Sunday, as Arab Israelis join Palestinians in confrontations, above; and the family piece below.

CP-2000-028 →

· Lincoln Journal Star · Lincoln

Fighting fire with firepower

Israel criticized for using deadly force to quash riots

By Laura King, The Associated Press

NETZARIM JUNCTION, Gaza Strip — This violent crossroads, scene of some of the bloodiest battles in six days of Israeli-Palestinian clashes, is ground zero in a growing debate: How much force is too much force? Israeli military doctrine is simple: When soldiers’ lives are threatened, deadly force is justified.

But in places like Netzarim, where teen-age Palestinian stone-throwers are being felled by live bullets and machine-gun fire from helicopter gunships, the unequal matchup has Israelis on the defensive.

Israel argues that the presence of Palestinian gunmen among the demonstrators — even if they are only a tiny minority in the crowd — leaves its soldiers with no choice but to use live ammunition. “Wherever we are fired upon, we will fire back,” Ephraim Sneh, the deputy defense minister, told Israel radio Tuesday.

Since the unrest began last week, more than 50 people have died. Two of the dead were Israeli soldiers and one was a Jewish Israeli civilian. Most of the rest were Palestinians. “It’s not a war. We’re not shooting at them; they’re shooting at us and we’re dying,” said senior Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat.

At Netzarim Junction, a highway crossroads in the scrubby flatlands of the central Gaza Strip, a lone army outpost guards the access road to a Jewish settlement by the same name. Like many other settlements in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, Netzarim is loathed by Palestinians living in nearby towns and refugee camps as a symbol of oppression and occupation.

The Israeli soldiers at Netzarim Junction, many of them teen-age conscripts, are far outnumbered by mobs of rioters who have besieged their isolated post each day.

Given their state of hair-trigger jumpiness, it sometimes is only a matter of moments before a lower-level confrontation — stone-throwing repelled by rubber bullets and tear gas — turns into a full-scale battle with live ammunition.

On Tuesday at the junction, a chaotic scene erupted when a rioter on a warehouse rooftop adjacent to the army outpost was struck by a missile. Onlookers said the man — identified as 28-year-old Fahmi Abu Amounah — was throwing stones. But the army said he was probably shooting toward the soldiers.

Friends who jumped to his aid saw that his brains had literally been blown out, sending them into a frenzy of shock, rage and grief. “Allahu Akhbar (God is great)!” they screamed. One of the group seized a handful of bloody brain matter and waved it wildly in his bare hands.

Palestinian police tried to block the group from charging the Israeli outpost, but they snatched up rocks and furiously stoned the police, quickly breaking through their lines. As firing broke out, some shots appeared to come from a building on the Palestinian side, pocked with bullet holes. Smoke billowed from piles of burning tires in the street.

Israeli helicopters circled overhead, as dozens of youths ran through the street, one waving a Palestinian flag. A veiled Palestinian woman stumbled as she tried to get out of the line of fire. At least 41 people were hurt and two other men killed in the daylong battle, according to hospital officials.

The army acknowledged the use of live fire and said helicopter gunships fired rockets. Hospital emergency room director Moawia Hassan said a gaping wound like Abu Amounah’s, which blasted away a huge chunk of bone, would likely have come from a high-caliber weapon, but he could not say what type.

Netzarim Junction has been the scene of some of the most wrenching events in nearly a week of fighting. On Saturday, a 12-year-old Palestinian boy was shot dead and his father seriously wounded as the two huddled, terrified, trying to find shelter from a hail of bullets.

The army acknowledged Tuesday its soldiers had apparently fired the fatal shots and expressed sorrow over the incident — but blamed Palestinians anew for “cynical use” of children in the confrontation with Israeli troops. On Monday, nearly three dozen Palestinians were hurt by a single anti-tank missile, one of several fired at Netzarim.

Word of Tuesday’s gruesome fatal shooting spread swiftly to the ranks of the young stone-throwers massing for a new wave of attacks against the Israeli outpost. “We’re a little terrified,” said Yasser Abu Assi, 19. He and his friends were regrouping, having scattered when a helicopter gunship flew overhead.

“We have stones, and they have that,” he said, gesturing toward the helicopter. “They are using much more force. But it’s our land, and if I die, my death is a good one.”

Palestinian protesters stay low to avoid rubber bullets fired by Israeli soldiers outside the West Bank town of Ramallah Tuesday. · Palestinian protesters carry away one of their wounded during a clash with Israeli security forces outside Ramallah Tuesday. · A Palestinian woman brandishes an assault rifle during a funeral procession Tuesday in Nablus.

The paper gives a nineteen-year-old the top of the page. Above the photograph, above the headline, in italic across the full width, it prints what Yasser Abu Assi said and puts his name under it: ‘It’s our land, and if I die, my death is a good one’. That placement is rare in this archive. A Palestinian sentence is almost never the largest type on a page. Three Palestinians are named in the copy, which is also unusual: Abu Assi, Fahmi Abu Amounah, who was 28 and whose death the story describes, and Moawia Hassan, the hospital emergency room director asked what weapon makes a wound like that. The twelve-year-old shot at this same junction the previous Saturday is in the story but not named. He was Muhammad al-Durrah.

CP-2000-015 →

· The Spokesman-Review · Spokane · page A2

Mideast clashes pit guns against stones

Israelis say threat of gunmen forces use of live ammunition

By Laura King, Associated Press

NETZARIM JUNCTION, Gaza Strip — This violent crossroads, scene of some of the bloodiest battles in six days of Israeli-Palestinian clashes, is ground zero in a growing debate: How much force is too much force? Israeli military doctrine is simple: When soldiers’ lives are threatened, deadly force is justified.

But in places such as Netzarim, where teenage Palestinian stone-throwers are being felled by live bullets and machine-gun fire from helicopter gunships, the unequal matchup has Israelis on the defensive.

Israel argues that the presence of Palestinian gunmen among the demonstrators — even if they are only a tiny minority in the crowd — leaves its soldiers with no choice but to use live ammunition. “Wherever we are fired upon, we will fire back,” Ephraim Sneh, the deputy defense minister, told Israel radio on Tuesday.

Since the unrest began last week, 56 people have died. Two of the dead were Israeli soldiers and one was a Jewish Israeli civilian; 43 were Palestinians and the other 10 were Israeli Arabs. “It’s not a war. We’re not shooting at them; they’re shooting at us and we’re dying,” senior Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat said.

At Netzarim Junction, a highway crossroads in the scrubby flatlands of the central Gaza Strip, a lone army outpost guards the access road to a Jewish settlement by the same name. Like many other settlements in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, Netzarim is loathed by Palestinians living in nearby towns and refugee camps as a symbol of oppression and occupation.

The Israeli soldiers at Netzarim Junction, many of them teenage conscripts, are far outnumbered by mobs of rioters who have besieged their isolated post each day.

Given their state of hair-trigger jumpiness, it sometimes is only a matter of moments before a lower-level confrontation — stone-throwing repelled by rubber bullets and tear gas — turns into a full-scale battle with live ammunition.

On Tuesday at the junction, a chaotic scene erupted when a rioter on a warehouse rooftop adjacent to the army outpost was struck by a missile. Onlookers said the man — identified as 28-year-old Fahmi Abu Amounah — was throwing stones. But the army said he was probably shooting toward the soldiers.

Friends who jumped to his aid saw that his brains had literally been blown out, sending them into a frenzy of shock, rage and grief. “Allahu Akhbar (God is great)!” they screamed. One of the group seized a handful of bloody brain matter and waved it wildly in his hands.

Palestinian police tried to block the group from charging the Israeli outpost, but they snatched up rocks and furiously stoned the police, quickly breaking through their lines. As firing broke out, some shots appeared to come from a building on the Palestinian side, pocked with bullet holes. Smoke billowed from piles of burning tires in the street.

Israeli helicopters circled overhead, as dozens of youths ran through the street, one waving a Palestinian flag. A veiled Palestinian woman stumbled as she tried to get out of the line of fire. Demonstrators rushed to carry the wounded to arriving ambulances. One drove off so fast that a roll of surgical tape unwound out its open back doors.

At least 41 people were hurt and two other men killed in the daylong battle, hospital officials said. The army acknowledged the use of live fire and said helicopter gunships fired rockets. Hospital emergency room director Moawia Hassan said a gaping wound like Abu Amounah’s, which blasted away a huge chunk of bone, likely came from a high-caliber weapon.

More than 2,000 people packed the narrow concrete alleys of Nusseirat for Abu Amounah’s funeral, held only an hour after he was killed. Netzarim Junction has been the scene of some of the most wrenching events in nearly a week of fighting.

On Saturday, a 12-year-old Palestinian boy was shot dead and his father seriously wounded as the two huddled, terrified, trying to find shelter from a hail of bullets.

The army acknowledged Tuesday its soldiers had apparently fired the fatal shots and expressed sorrow over the incident — but blamed Palestinians anew for “cynical use” of children in the confrontation with Israeli troops.

Speaking specifically of that incident, but referring generally to problems faced by soldiers at outposts under siege, a top Israeli commander said the troops’ field of vision was often limited. At the bunker-like outpost at Netzarim, for instance, soldiers are aiming through small slits, said Gen. Giora Eiland.

On Monday, nearly three dozen Palestinians were hurt by a single anti-tank missile, one of several fired at Netzarim. Word of Tuesday’s gruesome fatal shooting spread swiftly to the ranks of the young stone-throwers massing for a new wave of attacks against the Israeli outpost. “We’re a little terrified,” said Yasser Abu Assi, 19.

He and his friends were regrouping, having scattered when a helicopter gunship flew overhead. “We have stones, and they have that,” he said, gesturing toward the helicopter. “They are using much more force. But it’s our land, and if I die, my death is a good one.”

Palestinian youth engage Israeli forces from behind a makeshift barricade on the outskirts of the West Bank town of Ramallah on Tuesday. A tentative cease-fire between Israel and the Palestinians lasted barely a day.

The same Laura King dispatch the Lincoln Journal Star ran that morning, and the two papers did different things to it. The headlines take opposite sides of the question the copy raises. Lincoln: Fighting fire with firepower, with a line saying Israel is criticized for using deadly force. Spokane: Mideast clashes pit guns against stones, with a line giving Israel’s explanation for using it. The bigger difference is a number. Spokane keeps the breakdown of the dead: 56 killed, of whom 43 were Palestinians and 10 were Israeli Arabs. Lincoln prints the same sentence with the count taken out, as more than 50 people have died… Most of the rest were Palestinians. Spokane also keeps two paragraphs Lincoln drops: the ambulance with the surgical tape unwinding out of its open doors, and the two thousand people who packed the alleys of Nusseirat for Abu Amounah’s funeral an hour after he was killed.

CP-2000-016 →

· St. Petersburg Times · St. Petersburg · page 14A

Mideast violence

By Laura King, Associated Press

“…Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat. At Netzarim Junction, a highway crossroad in the scrubby flatlands of the central Gaza Strip, a lone army outpost guards the access road to a Jewish settlement by the same name.

Like many other settlements in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, Netzarim is loathed by Palestinians living in nearby towns and refugee camps as a symbol of oppression and occupation. The Israeli soldiers at Netzarim Junction, many of them teenage conscripts, are far outnumbered by mobs of rioters who have besieged their isolated post each day.

Given their state of hair-trigger jumpiness, it sometimes is only a matter of moments before a lower-level confrontation — stone-throwing repelled by rubber bullets and tear gas — turns into a full-scale battle with live ammunition.

On Tuesday at the junction, a chaotic scene erupted when a rioter on a warehouse rooftop adjacent to the army outpost was struck by a missile. Onlookers said the man — identified as 28-year-old Fahmi Abu Amounah — was throwing stones. But the army said he was probably shooting toward the soldiers.

Friends who jumped to his aid saw that his brains had literally been blown out, sending them into a frenzy of shock, rage and grief. ‘Allahu Akhbar (God is great)!’ they screamed. Palestinian police tried to block the group from charging the Israeli outpost, but they snatched up rocks and furiously stoned the police, quickly breaking through their lines.

As firing broke out, some shots appeared to come from a building on the Palestinian side, pocked with bullet holes. Smoke billowed from piles of burning tires in the street. Israeli helicopters circled overhead, as dozens of youths ran through the street, one waving a Palestinian flag. A veiled Palestinian woman stumbled as she tried to get out of the line of fire.

Demonstrators rushed to carry wounded to arriving ambulances. One drove off so fast that a roll of surgical tape unwound out its open back doors. At least 41 people were hurt and two other men killed in the daylong battle, according to hospital officials. The army acknowledged the use of live fire and said helicopter gunships fired rockets.

Hospital emergency room director Moawia Hassan said a gaping wound like Abu Amounah’s, which blasted away a huge chunk of bone, would likely have come from a high-caliber weapon, but he could not say what type. More than 2,000 people packed the narrow concrete alleys of Nusseirat for Abu Amounah’s funeral, held only an hour after he was killed.

‘My brother, my only brother,’ wept his 20-year-old sister, Falestine. Netzarim Junction has been the scene of some of the most wrenching events in nearly a week of fighting. On Saturday, a 12-year-old Palestinian boy was shot dead and his father seriously wounded as the two huddled, terrified, trying to find shelter from a hail of bullets.

The army acknowledged Tuesday its soldiers had apparently fired the fatal shots and expressed sorrow over the incident — but blamed Palestinians anew for ‘cynical use’ of children in the confrontation with Israeli troops.

Speaking specifically of that incident, but referring generally to problems faced by soldiers manning outposts under siege, a top Israeli commander said the troops’ field of vision was often limited. At the bunker-like outpost at Netzarim, for instance, soldiers are aiming through small slits, said Gen. Giora Eiland.

On Monday, nearly three dozen Palestinians were hurt by a single anti-tank missile, one of several fired at Netzarim. Word of Tuesday’s gruesome fatal shooting spread swiftly to the ranks of the young stone-throwers massing for a new wave of attacks against the Israeli outpost. ‘We’re a little terrified,’ said Yasser Abu Assi, 19.

He and his friends were regrouping, having scattered when a helicopter gunship flew overhead. ‘We have stones, and they have that,’ he said, gesturing toward it. ‘They are using much more force. But it’s our land, and if I die, my death is a good one.’”

Palestinians duck for cover on the outskirts of Ramallah as Israeli troops fire rubber-coated bullets. What was billed as a third cease-fire attempt in six days of violence unraveled by Tuesday afternoon.

The third printing of Laura King’s dispatch that Wednesday, and the only one of the three that keeps the sister. All three papers carry the death of Fahmi Abu Amounah. Lincoln stops there. Spokane adds the funeral, two thousand people in the alleys of Nusseirat an hour after he was killed. This paper adds the next sentence, and it is the one that turns a casualty back into a family: ‘My brother, my only brother,’ wept his 20-year-old sister, Falestine. Her name is the name of the country. It survived in one American newspaper out of the three, on a jump page, at the end of a paragraph about a funeral.

CP-2000-017 →

· The Mercury

Will boy dying on TV change anything?

It is hard to look at the photographs of 12-year-old Mohammed al-Durrah dying in his father’s arms on a Gaza street, but once you do, it is much harder to forget them. Imagine that the French television crew had not been there.

The death of a child would perhaps have provoked a shrug of the shoulders and a sentiment along the lines of: “It’s a shame, but that sort of thing happens all the time over there.” But in an instant, these pictures demolish that cotton emotional buffer.

The viewer sees the terror in Mohammed’s eyes and imagines the eyes of his or her own children in a reflexive act of empathy.

It is too early to say whether Mohammed’s death will provoke any more determined Western intervention, but there is a long history of powerful images searing themselves onto the global consciousness and, arguably, diverting the course of history.

When an American photographer called Eddie Adams filmed the 1968 execution of a Vietcong suspect by a South Vietnamese police general, the image reinforced a growing unease in the United States about the nation’s intervention on behalf of a corrupt and dictatorial regime.

Adams later discovered that the executed man had knifed a South Vietnamese family and apologized to the general, Nguyen Ngoc Loan. But whatever the details of the case, the picture illustrated a deeper truth which many Americans had been reluctant to face — the thuggishness of their allies.

The same was true of perhaps the most famous photograph to emerge from the Vietnam war — the picture of a nine-year-old Vietnamese girl, Phn Thi Kim Phuc, running towards the camera, screaming in pain from napalm burns on her back.

The attack had been a case of “friendly fire” — a South Vietnamese pilot had mistaken a group of fleeing villagers for communist troops — but that was not the issue. The picture, taken by AP photographer Nick Ut, conveyed like no other picture what the war was doing to children.

CP-2000-021 →

· Green Bay Press Gazette

Gaza crossroads at center of debate on force

NETZARIM JUNCTION, Gaza Strip — This violent crossroads, scene of some of the bloodiest battles in six days of Israeli-Palestinian clashes, is ground zero in a growing debate: How much force is too much force? Israeli military doctrine is simple: When soldiers’ lives are threatened, deadly force is justified.

But in places like Netzarim, where teen-age Palestinian stone-throwers are being felled by live bullets and machine-gun fire from helicopter gunships, the unequal matchup has Israelis on the defensive.

Israel argues that the presence of Palestinian gunmen among the demonstrators — even if they are only a tiny minority in the crowd — leaves its soldiers with no choice but to use live ammunition. “Wherever we are fired upon, we will fire back,” Ephraim Sneh, the deputy defense minister, told Israel radio on Tuesday.

Since the unrest began last week, 56 people have died. Two of the dead were Israeli soldiers and one was a Jewish Israeli civilian, but 43 were Palestinians and the other 10 were Israeli Arabs. “It’s not a war. We’re not shooting at them; they’re shooting at us and we’re dying,” said senior Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat.

At Netzarim Junction, a highway crossroad in the scrubby flatlands of the central Gaza Strip, a lone army outpost guards the access road to a Jewish settlement by the same name.

Symbol of oppression Like many other settlements in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, Netzarim is loathed by Palestinians living in nearby towns and refugee camps as a symbol of oppression and occupation. The Israeli soldiers at Netzarim Junction, many of them teen-age conscripts, are far outnumbered by mobs of rioters who have besieged their isolated post each day.

Given their state of hair-trigger jumpiness, it sometimes is only a matter of moments before a lower-level confrontation — stone-throwing repelled by rubber bullets and tear gas — turns into a full-scale battle with live ammunition.

On Tuesday at the junction, a chaotic scene erupted when a rioter on a warehouse rooftop adjacent to the army outpost was struck by a missile. Onlookers said the man — identified as 28-year-old Fahmi Abu Amounah — was throwing stones. But the army said he was probably shooting toward the soldiers.

Friends who jumped to his aid saw that his brains had literally been blown out, sending the friends into a frenzy of shock, rage and grief. Palestinian police tried to block the group from charging the Israeli outpost, but they snatched up rocks and furiously stoned the police, quickly breaking through their lines.

As firing broke out, some shots appeared to come from a bullet-pocked building on the Palestinian side. Smoke billowed from piles of burning tires in the street. Israeli helicopters circled overhead, as dozens of youths ran through the street, one waving a Palestinian flag. A veiled Palestinian woman stumbled as she tried to get out of the line of fire.

Demonstrators rushed to carry wounded to arriving ambulances. One drove off so fast that a roll of surgical tape unwound out its open back doors. Shooting of 12-year-old boy Netzarim Junction has been the scene of some of the most wrenching events in almost a week of fighting.

On Saturday, a 12-year-old Palestinian boy was shot dead and his father seriously wounded as the two huddled, terrified, trying to find shelter from a hail of bullets. The army acknowledged Tuesday its soldiers apparently had fired the fatal shots but blamed Palestinians anew for “cynical use” of children in the confrontation with Israeli troops.

The boy’s death, caught on camera, shocked viewers around the world. Israel’s Deputy Chief of Staff Maj. Gen. Moshe Yaalon expressed “deep sorrow” and said a sniper apparently had mistaken the child for a gunman.

Speaking specifically of that incident, but referring generally to problems faced by soldiers manning outposts under siege, a top Israeli commander said the troops’ field of vision was often limited. At the bunkerlike outpost at Netzarim for instance, soldiers are aiming through small slits, said Gen. Giora Eiland.

CP-2000-029 →

· The Sun · Baltimore

Bloody crossroads at center of debate

NETZARIM JUNCTION, Gaza Strip (AP) — This violent crossroads, scene of some of the bloodiest battles in six days of Israeli-Palestinian clashes, is ground zero in a growing debate: How much force is too much force? Israeli military doctrine is simple: When soldiers’ lives are threatened, deadly force is justified.

But in places like Netzarim, where teen-age Palestinian stone-throwers are being felled by live bullets and machine-gun fire from helicopter gunships, the unequal matchup has Israelis on the defensive.

Israel argues that the presence of Palestinian gunmen among the demonstrators — even if they are only a tiny minority in the crowd — leaves its soldiers with no choice but to use live ammunition. “Wherever we are fired upon, we will fire back,” Ephraim Sneh, the deputy defense minister, told Israel radio on Tuesday.

Since the unrest began last week, 56 people have died. Two of the dead were Israeli soldiers and one was a Jewish Israeli civilian, but 43 were Palestinians and the other 10 were Israeli Arabs. “It’s not a war. We’re not shooting at them; they’re shooting at us and we’re dying,” counters senior Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat.

At Netzarim Junction, a highway crossroad in the scrubby flatlands of the central Gaza Strip, a lone army outpost guards the access road to a Jewish settlement by the same name. Like many other settlements in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, Netzarim is loathed by Palestinians living in nearby towns and refugee camps as a symbol of oppression and occupation.

The Israeli soldiers at Netzarim Junction, many of them teen-age conscripts, are far outnumbered by mobs of rioters who have besieged their isolated post each day.

Given their state of hair-trigger jumpiness, it sometimes is only a matter of moments before a lower-level confrontation — stone-throwing repelled by rubber bullets and tear gas — turns into a full-scale battle with live ammunition.

CP-2000-032 →

· The Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe

Netzarim becomes a symbol of brute force

Israelis accused of hair-triggered violence at this lonely and now bloodied outpost

NETZARIM JUNCTION, Gaza Strip — This violent crossroads, scene of some of the bloodiest battles in six days of Israeli-Palestinian clashes, is ground zero in a growing debate: How much force is too much force? Israeli military doctrine is simple: When soldiers’ lives are threatened, deadly force is justified.

But in places such as Netzarim, where teen-age Palestinian stone-throwers are being felled by live bullets and machine-gun fire from helicopter gunships, the unequal matchup has Israelis on the defensive.

Israel argues that the presence of Palestinian gunmen among the demonstrators — even if they are only a tiny minority in the crowd — leaves its soldiers with no choice but to use live ammunition. “Wherever we are fired upon, we will fire back,” Ephraim Sneh, the deputy defense minister, told Israel radio on Tuesday.

Since the unrest began last week, 56 people have died. Two of the dead were Israeli soldiers and one was a Jewish Israeli civilian, but 43 were Palestinians and the other 10 were Israeli Arabs. “It’s not a war. We’re not shooting at them; they’re shooting at us, and we’re dying.” counters senior Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat.

At Netzarim Junction, a highway crossroad in the scrubby flatlands of the central Gaza Strip, a lone army outpost guards the access road to a Jewish settlement by the same name. Like many other settlements in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, Netzarim is loathed by Palestinians living in nearby towns and refugee camps as a symbol of oppression and occupation.

The Israeli soldiers at Netzarim Junction are far outnumbered by mobs of rioters who have besieged their isolated post each day. Given their state of hair-trigger jumpiness, it sometimes is only a matter of moments before a lower-level confrontation — stone-throwing repelled by rubber bullets and tear gas — turns into a full-scale battle with live ammunition.

An unidentified Palestinian sits in front of the Netzarim Junction, where some of the worst Palestinians-Israeli violence has occurred.

CP-2000-033 →

· St. Petersburg Times · St. Petersburg

Sides look to U.S. to help end killing

Knight Ridder Newspapers

“As battles between Arab youths and Israeli forces raged Tuesday for the sixth day, hope turned to Washington and the international community to do what leaders here seem unable to do: stop the shooting…

Our working hypothesis is that the climax of the violence is still ahead of us, said Moshe Yaalon, the deputy chief of staff of the Israeli army. Tuesday’s worst scenes were again from Netzarim Junction in Gaza, a few yards from where the shooting death of a boy shocked the world.”

A second, separate article on a page this archive already held. Netzarim Junction is where Muhammad al-Durrah was killed four days before this was filed, and the paper places the day’s worst scenes a few yards from it. Moshe Yaalon, who appears again in this archive four years later in a Chicago Tribune essay about the wall, is quoted saying the climax of the violence is still ahead. Found on 5 October 2026 when the full page was read.

CP-2000-055 →

· The Palm Beach Post · West Palm Beach

Nothing random about hatred

The killing of Mohammed Jamal Aldura at age 12 on a Gaza road last weekend cannot be dismissed as a random accident or a senseless tragedy.

A chain of avoidable events created the scene in Gaza that has shocked television viewers and newspaper readers around the world: Horror registers on the face of Mohammed’s father as he instinctively but futilely crooks his arm to shield the boy from the bullets flying around them.

He seems to scold the unseen gunmen as a television cameraman caught in the same fusillade films father and son. Incomprehension and dread contort the boy’s features. Then Mohammed is shot to death and his father is severely wounded as Israelis and Palestinians fire wildly at each other. (Israeli commanders conceded Tuesday that their bullets probably hit the boy.)

Photos do not lie, it is said. But frequently they tell partial truths. They tear moments out of time and separate them from what has come before and what will follow. They can misrepresent as well as represent.

This time, however, the news photographs from this spasm of Middle East violence capture the underlying, terrifying essence of what the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has become. If insanity has a face, it can surely be glimpsed in that terrible footage from Gaza. All wars are cruel, some are senseless and a few qualify as insane.

Insane wars feed on hatred instead of personal calculation or national advantage. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is rapidly slipping into that latter category, just as peace seemed within reach. Hatred has at least momentarily overtaken the hope that Prime Minister Ehud Barak sought to nurture with his visionary peace offers to the Palestinians at Camp David this summer. Mr.

Barak reaffirmed and amplified proposed Israeli concessions on Jerusalem in a lengthy interview with The Jerusalem Post conducted on Sept. 28 and published in full on Sept. 30. His proposal for the Palestinians to regain most of East Jerusalem and to call it al-Quds, the capital of a Palestinian state, was intended to restart the stalled peace negotiations.

But it was completely overshadowed by a brazen ploy by Ariel Sharon on Sept. 28. The other enduring image of this crisis will be Mr. Sharon strutting for political effect that day on the paved pavilion of the Temple Mount, site of Islamic and Jewish holy shrines. Fearful of a challenge to his leadership of the Likud coalition, Mr.

Sharon made a spectacle of walking on territory most Israeli politicians and citizens avoid for reasons of religion or prudence. Mr. Sharon claims he did not set out to provoke Palestinian violence. But it is clear that he did nothing to avoid becoming a pretext for the predictable upheaval that followed. Mr.

Sharon offers the equivalent of a manslaughter plea: He admits that he played into the hands of Yasser Arafat and his lieutenants — who have in fact orchestrated much of the violence for their own political effect. Mr. Sharon styles himself a fool rather than a knave. The political space that Mr.

Barak hoped to create for himself and for peace is being squeezed out of existence by such extremism. It is not Mr. Barak’s offers of peace and cooperation with the Palestinians that created this wave of violence, as apologists for Likud will claim. It is the inability of Messrs Sharon, Arafat and others to respond to those offers with the humanity shown by Mr. Barak.

Peace threatens them. The picture you have not seen is one of Mr. Arafat going on Palestinian TV to appeal for calm. He has let the fires stoked by his Fatah youth organization burn without interference. If Mr. Sharon or Mr. Arafat had acted differently at the outset of the crisis, the odds are that Mohammed Jamal Aldura would still be alive.

That is probably true for most of the more than 50 others, mostly Palestinians, who have died as well. In that sense these deaths are not random or senseless. They have meaning. They are the cost of political acts that appeal to hatred as a tool of political gain. Mr. Arafat seeks the world’s sympathy and diplomatic advantage from these deaths. Mr.

Sharon thinks his macho swagger will bring him votes. But the force of hatred, stirred by such slaughter, quickly overtakes calculations like these. Senseless behavior then edges into the insanity of revenge at all costs. Israelis and Palestinians must find a way out, by finding a way apart, to avoid that outcome. Jim Hoagland is a columnist for The Washington Post.

His e-mail address is hoaglandj@washpost.com

In this image from video, Jamal Aldura shouts toward the camera operator as he tries to shield his son near the Netzarim Jewish settlement in southern Gaza City. Moments later, the boy was hit. He died. The father was wounded.

CP-2000-030 →

· The Daily Telegram

Picture power: Images that made history

It is hard to look at the photographs of 12-year-old Mohammed al-Durrah dying in his father’s arms on a Gaza street, but once you do it is much harder to forget them. Imagine that the French television crew had not been there.

The death of a child would perhaps have provoked a shrug of the shoulders and a sentiment along the lines of: “It’s a shame, but that sort of thing happens all the time over there.” But in an instant, these pictures demolish that cotton emotional buffer.

The viewer sees the terror in Mohammed’s eyes and imagines the eyes of his or her own children in a reflexive act of empathy.

It is too early to say whether Mohammed’s death will provoke any more determined Western intervention, but there is a long history of powerful images searing themselves onto the global consciousness and, arguably, diverting the course of history.

When an American photographer called Eddie Adams filmed the 1968 execution of a Vietcong suspect by a South Vietnamese police general, the image reinforced a growing unease in the United States about the nation’s intervention on behalf of a corrupt and dictatorial regime.

Adams later discovered that the executed man had knifed a South Vietnamese family and apologized to the general, Nguyen Ngoc Loan. But whatever the details of the case, the picture illustrated a deeper truth which many Americans had been reluctant to face — the thuggishness of their allies.

The same was true of perhaps the most famous photograph to emerge from the Vietnam war — the picture of a nine-year-old Vietnamese girl, Phn Thi Kim Phuc, running towards the camera, screaming in pain from napalm burns on her back.

The attack had been a case of “friendly fire” — a South Vietnamese pilot had mistaken a group of fleeing villagers for communist troops — but that was not the issue. The picture, taken by AP photographer, Nick Ut, conveyed like no other picture what the war was doing to children.

These sudden outbreaks of angst over individual, well-photographed tragedies often evokes cynicism — what about the hundreds or thousands of others who have died? It is unfair, but it is natural. Human beings are wired in such a way that the tragedy of a single individual stirs a more emotional response than the deaths of hundreds.

A lot of people in Britain remember the death of Ferida Osmanovic, a Bosnian woman who hanged herself after the fall of Srebrenica in July, 1995. Not so many recall how many boys and men from the Muslim enclave were murdered by Bosnian Serb forces in the aftermath — it was roughly 7,000.

Likewise all that most people remember of the Tiananmen Square massacre was the television picture of a single man standing alone in front of a tank, blocking its advance. The picture shocked the world, but these days the world is trading with China again, and human rights issues are on the back-burner. Images are powerful but short-lived.

If the sight of Mohammed dying before our eyes does not change anything in the next days or weeks, it probably never will.

CP-2000-020 →

· The Spokesman-Review · Spokane

‘Caught in cross-fire’ takes on new meaning

Reporters accused of using phrase to hide truth when Palestinians are killed by Israelis

BEIRUT — When I read the word “cross-fire,” I reach for my pen. In the Middle East, it almost always means that the Israelis have killed an innocent person.

When the Israelis fired shells into the U.N. compound at Qana in southern Lebanon in 1996, Time magazine printed a photograph of a dead baby with a caption saying it had been killed in “cross-fire.” This was untrue. The baby had been killed in the Israeli bombardment, along with 105 other civilians.

The shelling began after Hezbollah guerrillas opened fire on an Israeli army unit that was laying booby-trap mines inside the U.N. zone. So when 12-year-old Mohammed al-Durah was killed in Gaza on Friday and I read on the Associated Press wire that the child was “caught in the cross-fire,” I knew at once who had killed him.

Sure enough, reporters investigating the killing said the boy was shot by Israeli troops. So was his father — who survived — and so was the ambulance driver who was killed trying to rescue the boy.

Yet BBC World Service Television was still saying Sunday morning that Mohammed al-Durah was “caught in the cross-fire of a battle that has left hundreds wounded and killed many others.” I knew what this meant. True, the Israeli soldiers who killed the boy may not have known whom they hit. They were apparently firing through a wall.

But why the reluctance on the part of journalists to tell the truth? Why was it that in its report from Jerusalem on Saturday, the AP only mentioned — in paragraph 17, for heaven’s sake — that Israeli troops, on the word of their own officer, fired antitank missiles during the confrontation? What was the Israeli army doing using missiles against rioters?

By Sunday afternoon, the story had been transformed into a “blame” conflict. The Israelis blamed the Palestinian authority for organizing riots. BBC World Service Radio ran a tape of an Israeli official stating that rioters were “shooting (sic) Molotov cocktails and stones” which “kill people.”

A listener might have been forgiven for thinking that 22 Israelis had been killed — rather than 22 Palestinians — in the previous 72 hours. The BBC then ran a tape of Nabil Shaath, the Palestinian spokesman, saying that the Israelis, not the Palestinians, had been shooting. Truth is a hard bullet to bite.

Palestinian police officers had also opened fire on the Israelis. Ironically, the Arab press in Beirut had no hesitation in saying this. The press in Lebanon showed photographs of Palestinian police officers firing Kalashnikov rifles at Israeli troops.

But, given the fact that they did not kill Israelis — one of them was hit while firing — was it not worth mentioning that the Palestinians were the victims, not the Israelis?

When BBC Television got around on Sunday to mentioning Ariel Sharon’s flagrantly provocative visit to the Haram as-Sharif/Temple Mount on Thursday, they called him an “Israeli leader” when — for Palestinians — he was the man who bore indirect responsibility (according to Israel’s own enquiry) for the massacre of up to 2,000 Palestinian civilians in the Sabra and Chatila refugee camps in Beirut 18 years ago.

What lies behind this — apart from the sheep-like inability of many journalists to call a spade a spade — is the continuing belief that Palestinians are, by nature, violent and riotous.

The United States called for an end to the “violence” — this statement courtesy of Secretary of State Madeleine Albright — without making any reference to Sharon’s grotesque visit to the mosque grounds of East Jerusalem.

Palestinian youths pull a bucket of rocks to the barricades in Hebron on Thursday as clashes with Israeli forces flared up after the funeral of a 19-year-old Palestinian killed Wednesday.

CP-2000-024 →

· The Jamestown Sun · Bridgewater

New violence sweeps West Bank and Gaza Strip

Police storm holy site

JERUSALEM — Israeli police commandos stormed a Jerusalem shrine Friday, ripping down a fluttering Palestinian flag, and nine Palestinians were killed in gunbattles with Israeli troops throughout the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.

The day started with both sides endeavoring to enforce a U.S.-brokered truce, but its quick collapse underscored how far apart the two sides are. A combative Prime Minister Ehud Barak spoke, for the first time, in terms of war.

“With the same determination we had in leaving no stone unturned to find a way toward peace, with the same determination ... we will fight and defend our soldiers and our citizens, even if it is against the whole world,” he told Israeli television.

Barak has resisted international pressure to allow a U.N. commission to investigate the latest outbreak of violence, which has taken 77 lives and left more than 1,900 hurt in nine days of fighting. Aside from the nine slain Friday, a tenth Palestinian died of wounds suffered earlier.

While the fighting raged Friday, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat spent the day away from the region, traveling first to Tunisia and then on to Spain. Near Tunis, about 10,000 people joined Arafat and Tunisian President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali at a rally in support of Palestinians.

In the Gaza Strip, Palestinian gunmen kept up attacks on another flashpoint, the isolated Netzarim settlement, and for the first time besieged other Jewish settlements, drawing heavy Israeli responses. In the West Bank, settlements near the Palestinian controlled town of Ramallah reported coming under heavy fire from the city.

Palestinian demonstrators run for cover from heavy shooting during clashes with the Israeli Army at the Netzarim Junction in the southern Gaza Strip Friday. Israeli troops battled thousands of Palestinian rock-throwers and several dozen gunmen Friday in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, killing at least four rioters on what Palestinians had declared their “day of rage.”

Filed as The Courier News; the page prints The Jamestown Sun. Folio line running beneath the "World" section head at the top of the page, read at 10x. Left end: "16 Saturday, October 7, 2000". Right end, in bold serif: "The Jamestown Sun".

CP-2000-039 →

· The Courier News · Bridgewater

Truce fails, violence engulfs West Bank, Gaza

JERUSALEM — Israeli police commandos stormed a Jerusalem shrine Friday, ripping down a fluttering Palestinian flag, and nine Palestinians were killed in gunbattles with Israeli troops throughout the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.

The day started with both sides endeavoring to enforce a U.S.-brokered truce, but its quick collapse underscored how far apart the two sides are. A combative Prime Minister Ehud Barak spoke, for the first time, in terms of war.

“With the same determination we had in leaving no stone unturned to find a way toward peace, with the same determination ... we will fight and defend our soldiers and our citizens, even if it is against the whole world,” he told Israeli television.

Barak has resisted international pressure to allow a U.N. commission to investigate the latest outbreak of violence, which has taken 77 lives and left more than 1,900 hurt in nine days of fighting. Aside from the nine slain Friday, a tenth Palestinian died of wounds suffered earlier.

While the fighting raged Friday, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat spent the day away from the region, traveling first to Tunisia and then on to Spain. Near Tunis, about 10,000 people joined Arafat and Tunisian President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali at a rally in support of Palestinians.

In the Gaza Strip, Palestinian gunmen kept up attacks on another flashpoint, the isolated Netzarim settlement, and for the first time besieged other Jewish settlements, drawing heavy Israeli responses.

A masked Palestinian brandishes his knife Friday during a Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine rally in Nablus.

Filed as The Jamestown Sun; the page prints The Courier News. Folio line across the top of the page, read at 12x. Left end: "A-4 SATURDAY, OCTOBER 7, 2000"; centre: "WORLD"; right end: "COURIER NEWS".

CP-2000-040 →

· The News Tribune · Tacoma

Truce fails, fighting rages on

MIDEAST: 9 Palestinians killed in battles with Israeli troops; shrine stormed

JERUSALEM – Israeli police commandos stormed a contested Jerusalem shrine Friday, ripping down a fluttering Palestinian flag, and nine Palestinians were killed in gun battles with Israeli troops throughout the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.

The day started with both sides endeavoring to enforce a U.S.-brokered truce, but its quick collapse underscored how far apart the two sides are. A combative Prime Minister Ehud Barak spoke, for the first time, in terms of war.

“With the same determination we had in leaving no stone unturned to find a way toward peace, with the same determination ... we will fight and defend our soldiers and our citizens, even if it is against the whole world,” he told Channel 2 television.

Barak has resisted international pressure to allow a U.N. commission to investigate the latest outbreak of violence, which has taken 77 lives and left more than 1,900 hurt in nine days of fighting. Aside from the nine slain Friday, a 10th Palestinian died of wounds suffered earlier.

While the fighting raged Friday, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat spent the day away from the region, traveling first to Tunisia and then on to Spain. Near Tunis, about 10,000 people joined Arafat and Tunisian President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali at a rally in support of Palestinians.

Early today, Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak ordered what he said was a temporary evacuation of soldiers in the military outpost of Joseph’s Tomb, the first time Israel has relinquished territory as a direct result of Palestinian violence.

A young Palestinian stone thrower ducks for cover during a shootout Friday between Palestinian gunmen and Israeli soldiers on the outskirts of the West Bank village of Salim, near Nablus. At least 77 people, mostly Palestinians, have been killed in nine days of fighting.

CP-2000-041 →

· Times Tribune

Violence rips Mideast

Nine Palestinians killed; Barak talks of war

JERUSALEM — Israeli police commandos stormed a contested Jerusalem shrine Friday, ripping down a fluttering Palestinian flag, and nine Palestinians were killed in gunbattles with Israeli troops throughout the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.

The day started with both sides endeavoring to enforce a U.S.-brokered truce, but its quick collapse underscored how far apart the two sides are. A combative Prime Minister Ehud Barak spoke, for the first time, in terms of war.

“With the same determination we had in leaving no stone unturned to find a way toward peace, with the same determination ... we will fight and defend our soldiers and our citizens, even if it is against the whole world,” he told Channel Two television.

Barak has resisted international pressure to allow a U.N. commission to investigate the latest outbreak of violence, which has taken 77 lives and left more than 1,900 hurt in nine days of fighting. Aside from the nine slain Friday, a tenth Palestinian died of wounds suffered earlier.

While the fighting raged Friday, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat spent the day away from the region, traveling first to Tunisia and then on to Spain. Near Tunis, about 10,000 people joined Arafat and Tunisian President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali at a rally in support of Palestinians.

In the Gaza Strip, Palestinian gunmen kept up attacks on another flashpoint, the isolated Netzarim settlement, and for the first time besieged other Jewish settlements, drawing heavy Israeli responses. In the West Bank, settlements near the Palestinian controlled town of Ramallah reported coming under heavy fire from the city.

In Nablus, gunmen attacked the Israeli-controlled Joseph’s Tomb outpost and drew heavy fire.

A wounded Palestinian demonstrator is lowered from his position on the walls of Jerusalem’s Old City inside the Al-Aqsa mosque compound Friday.

CP-2000-042 →

· The Macon Telegraph · Macon

Day of Rage, Plea for Peace

Jerusalem — The Israeli soldiers who guard Joseph’s Tomb retreated today after a week of heavy gunfire and an organized “Day of Rage” at an embattled holy site. In the “Day of Rage,” 10 more Palestinians were killed in fighting across East Jerusalem, the West Bank and Gaza.

Israeli riot troops stormed the holy site in the Old City and tore down the Palestinian flag. In the United States, pro-Palestinian demonstrations were held Friday in New York City, Washington and Miami. In Syracuse, hundreds of members of the Islamic Society of Central New York marched Friday afternoon to call for an end to the violence and to pray for peace.

MEMBERS of the Islamic Association of Central New York stage a rally for peace Friday in the Syracuse University area. · A YOUNG PALESTINIAN uses a sling to hurl a rock at a burning Israeli police station Friday as clashes continued in Jerusalem’s Holy City.

CP-2000-043 →

· The Post-Standard · Syracuse

'Day of rage' brings new round of bloodshed to Jerusalem's holiest site

JERUSALEM — An organized “day of rage” brought a new round of bloodshed to Jerusalem’s holiest shrine and the Palestinian territories Friday, as cooperation between Israeli and Palestinian security forces failed and Israel responded with force to widespread rioting and stone-throwing.

Ten Palestinians were killed, more than 100 wounded and at least 24 Israeli police officers hurt on a ninth day of deadly clashes in which Israel temporarily ceded control of the Temple Mount, or the Noble Sanctuary, to Palestinian authorities, only to have police storm it later when rioting got out of control.

As protesters temporarily hoisted the Palestinian flag on the Al Aqsa mosque compound, Israeli officials feared that the disturbances would encourage the Hamas movement and other Islamic radicals who had incited them.

Two days after a U.S.-sponsored summit in Paris failed to defuse the crisis, an attempt by Israel to display less firepower and pull its police off the mount also failed when riots erupted immediately after midday prayers and worshippers ran wild over the mount, some using their prayer rugs to gather rocks. “Get back! Get back!

I beg you!” screamed Abu Jamal, 69, a respected elder trying to prevent Palestinian youths from throwing stones off the mount at Israeli police. “Don’t give them a chance to kill you here, or this will go on until Judgment Day!” “This is a holy place, and we have to defend it!

It has to be a holy war until we liberate Palestine!” shouted back Abu Ahmed, a cook from Ramallah armed with a rock in his hand.

Palestinians try to help an injured man Friday who was shot by Israeli fire in front of Rachel’s Tomb in the West Bank town of Bethlehem.

CP-2000-044 →

· The Kansas City Star · Kansas City

Blood flows on 'day of rage'

10 Palestinians die in new clashes with Israeli forces

JERUSALEM — An organized “day of rage” brought a new round of bloodshed to Jerusalem’s holiest shrine and the Palestinian territories Friday. Cooperation between Israeli and Palestinian security forces failed, and Israel responded with force to widespread rioting and stone-throwing.

Ten Palestinians were killed, more than 100 persons were wounded and at least 24 Israeli police officers were hurt on a ninth day of clashes in which Israel temporarily ceded control of the Temple Mount, or the Noble Sanctuary, to Palestinian authorities, only to have police storm it later when rioting erupted.

As protesters temporarily hoisted the Palestinian flag on the Al Aqsa mosque compound, Israeli officials feared that the disturbances would encourage the militant Hamas movement and other Islamic radicals who had incited them.

Two days after a U.S.-sponsored summit in Paris failed to defuse the crisis, an attempt by Israel to display less firepower and pull its police off the mount also failed when riots erupted immediately after midday prayers and worshippers ran wild over the mount, some using their prayer rugs to gather rocks. “Get back! Get back!

I beg you!” screamed Abu Jamal, an elder trying to prevent Palestinian youths from throwing stones off the mount at Israeli police. “Don’t give them a chance to kill you here, or this will go on until Judgment Day.” Abu Ahmed, a cook from Ramallah, armed with a rock in his hand, responded: “This is a holy place, and we have to defend it.

It has to be a holy war until we liberate Palestine.” Across the Palestinian territories, the pattern of violence was much the same and was widespread. Four of the Palestinians who lost their lives were killed in the Gaza Strip, which has been a hotbed of Arab militancy.

Israeli troops and Palestinians clashed again Friday in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. When shooting broke out at the Netzarim Junction in the southern Gaza Strip, Palestinians ran for cover.

CP-2000-045 →

· The New York Times · New York

Times Square Marchers Protest Killing of Palestinians

“‘From the inside, I feel very bad, the kid who got shot, I feel awful,’ said Diana Awawdeh, 10. ‘I felt someone was shooting part of my heart.’”

Amy Waldman, with several thousand people south of Times Square in the evening rush. The kid who got shot is Muhammad al-Durrah, 12, whose photocopied image they are holding on posters. Diana Awawdeh is ten years old and from Sunset Park, and hers is the most precise sentence any Palestinian child says anywhere in this archive.

CP-2000-061 →

· estimated · Florida Today · Melbourne · page 1

Sept. 30: Clashes erupt in West Bank and Gaza Strip

Fourteen Palestinians killed by Israeli fire, including 12-year-old Mohammed Aldura, whose death is captured by a television cameraman and broadcast around the world.

Correction: {'note': 'uncaptioned; from a 2000 second-intifada chronology'}

CP-2000-004 →

· Florida Today · Melbourne · page 1

A PALESTINIAN MOTHER flees with her children after a rocket fired from an Israeli helicopter at the port of Gaza City on Thursday

“A PALESTINIAN MOTHER flees with her children after a rocket fired from an Israeli helicopter at the port of Gaza City on Thursday. The Israeli Army hit several Palestinian targets in retaliation for the killings of two Israeli soldiers by a group of Palestinians.” AP photos.

CP-2000-005 →

· The New York Times · New York

Police Block Thousands of Muslims From Attending Prayer Services in Old City’s Mosques

William A. Orme Jr.

“A huge Israeli security cordon prevented thousands of Palestinians from attending Friday Prayer services at the ancient mosques inside the Old City today.”

Two weeks into the second intifada, worship itself is the thing being blocked. About 3,000 got in, roughly a fifth of a normal Friday congregation.

CP-2000-051 →

· Chicago Tribune

Death of an Arab painter colors fabric of enmity in Mideast

Israelis call it a car accident. Palestinians say he was tortured. Either way, it spurred the mob that lynched 2 Israeli reservists.

By Hugh Dellios / TRIBUNE FOREIGN CORRESPONDENT

UM SAFA, West Bank—Discovered next to his overturned car, Issam Juddah died a ghastly death last week. At least that much is agreed upon. Yet a bitter quarrel over just how the Palestinian painter died speaks volumes about the presumptions of evil and the chasms of mistrust that brought the Israelis and Palestinians to the brink of what looked like all-out war last week.

The Palestinians claim Juddah was the victim of torture by Jewish settlers, an outrage that was fresh in the minds of the mob that lynched two reserve Israeli soldiers in Ramallah on Thursday, leading to Israel’s retaliation with rockets from helicopter gunships. The Israelis insist Juddah was the victim of a common car crash, something they had nothing to do with.

Last Tuesday, Juddah’s family found his body near his West Bank home and took him to Ramallah Hospital, where doctors found that his skull was fractured, his right eye damaged, several bones were broken and patches of skin were burned severely, doctors said.

Noting that Juddah’s clothes were undamaged and that his car was neither bloody nor burned, the doctors concluded that Juddah had been tortured to death and the accident staged. The news spread like wildfire through the West Bank, helping to incite more violence between Israeli troops and Palestinian rioters.

“This is the most criminal event I have seen in my life,” said Dr. Hosni Atari, the hospital director, showing photographs of Juddah’s wounds. “He was stripped and tortured. For us, there is no doubt about it.”

Palestinians pray in a Ramallah mosque during the funeral of Issam Juddah last week. After the funeral, hundreds of Palestinians stoned Israeli positions in this West Bank town for several hours. Reuters photo by Osama Silwadi

CP-2000-063 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles

Images Are the Ammo in War for World Sympathy

CP-2000-034 →

· Ann Arbor News · Ann Arbor · page 1

Gore-Lieberman will likely support genocide in Palestine

Bill A. Cobb, Brighton

“Gore-Lieberman will likely support genocide in Palestine. I have not heard one word, whether from citizens or editorials, about Joseph Lieberman’s position on the Palestine occupation issue.

After seeing the photo sequence of the 13-year-old boy shot to death in his father’s arms, it makes me think that the U.S. foreign aid program (both money and diplomatic support) is responsible for this insanity.

I wonder where Lieberman’s loyalty is on this issue: balanced for the security of Israel versus the sovereignty of Palestine, or imbalanced in a position towards eminent domain boldly taken by Israel. I can’t help but feel that those supporting Al Gore also wind up supporting the dismantling and genocide of Palestinian civilization (and perhaps others).

I’ve noticed a strong U.S. English accent in practically all interviews of Israeli settlers in Palestine, making me believe Americans are directly responsible for the problems there now.

If Bloomfield Hills residents drove out your way, looked around and decided to take over your backyard, on the grounds that their grandfathers wrote a book about it, would you sit back and allow it to happen, would you have a little Internet chat-room discussion about it to get consensus among participants, or would you resist up to the point of blowing them to kingdom come?

I think the first two options have been tried and failed. I have fear that round three is in the works. Where do Gore and Lieberman stand? Why aren’t more Democrats speaking out on this issue? I think I know the answer.”

An election-season letter in a Michigan paper, three weeks after the death of Muhammad al-Durrah, which it refers to only as “the photo sequence of the 13-year-old boy shot to death in his father’s arms.” It runs between a letter about Nader and one about executions in Texas.

CP-2000-006 →

· The State Journal-Register · Springfield · page 1

Israel has no ‘partners for peace’

George Will

JERUSALEM — Since 1948, when Israel was founded on one-sixth of 1 percent of the land carelessly called “the Arab world,” the conflict has been not about what land Israel should occupy but whether it should occupy any land.

The conflict has been constantly violent but now, in today’s world climate of appeasement, the Palestinians’ violence is self-legitimizing: The assumption always is that they must have been provoked. Today, and as usual, the problem is not that Israel is being provocative, but that Israel’s being is provocative.

And now the potentially lethal asymmetry in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is this: Israel’s government desperately wants to end the conflict, the Palestinian Authority fiercely wants to win it.

The phrase in a headline in October 2000, in quotation marks.

CP-2000-007 →

· The Jonesboro Sun · Jonesboro

Barak pushes coalition as the army warns of confrontations

Use of tanks by the Israelis marks escalation in the conflict

By GREG MYRE / Associated Press

Four weeks into the second intifada. The deck notes the tanks; the headline is about a coalition.

CP-2000-059 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Troops Shoot 4 Palestinians Dead in New Violence

John Kifner

“In Ramallah, ambulances screamed in constant rotation as hundreds of Palestinians gathered on a hill to watch squads of young men hurl rocks at Israeli jeeps.”

Kifner writes the rotation of the ambulances rather than the count of the dead, and the count is in the headline anyway. Four.

CP-2000-052 →

· Odessa American · Odessa

Israel closes Gaza, deports 4

JERUSALEM — Israeli security forces yesterday ordered four Palestinians deported from the Gaza Strip, and cabinet ministers called for tougher measures against terrorism following Friday’s killing of three Israelis at a factory near Tel Aviv.

The army closed the entire Gaza Strip and carried out intensive searches for two Palestinian brothers suspected in the killings. The suspects belong to the outlawed Islamic fundamentalist movement Hamas. An army spokesman said more than 500 Palestinians have been arrested since Friday, but Palestinian lawyers said close to 1,000 Gaza Palestinians were arrested.

By either count, it was the largest round-up since the Palestinian uprising began three years ago. Authorities said all of those arrested were members of Hamas. Palestinians claimed the arrests were made in retaliation for the killings, not in order to apprehend the suspects.

CP-2000-048 →

· The Lima News · Lima · page 1

Five Palestinians killed in gunfire

Karin Laub, The Associated Press

JERUSALEM — Israeli combat helicopters battered a West Bank village Wednesday to rescue wounded Israeli soldiers trapped by Palestinian fire, and five Palestinians were killed in a battle in the Gaza Strip. The clashes did not scuttle plans for the highest level meeting since fighting began 35 days ago.

“A Palestinian child takes cover next to a police officer behind a wall as Israeli helicopters open fire with machine guns during clashes in the West Bank on Wednesday.” Associated Press.

Karin Laub filed from Jabalia in 1987. Thirteen years later the byline is hers again; her name is on clippings here through 2017.

CP-2000-008 →

· The New York Times · New York

Doctors Back Many Palestinian Accusations, but Not All

William A. Orme Jr.

“An independent investigation into the past month’s violence echoed many Palestinian accusations against Israel.”

Physicians for Human Rights finds a pattern of the Israeli Army using live bullets to wound and disperse unarmed rioters, a practice prohibited by army guidelines. The headline leads with the part the investigators rejected.

CP-2000-053 →

· Anderson Independent Mail · Anderson, SC

Violence continues while Arafat leaves

By Joel Greenberg, N.Y. Times News Service

JERUSALEM — Palestinian gunmen killed an Israeli customs agent and Israeli troops shot dead three Palestinian teenagers in the Gaza Strip on Wednesday on the eve of a meeting in Washington between President Bill Clinton and Yasser Arafat, the Palestinian leader. Mr. Arafat left Wednesday for Washington, where he is scheduled to meet Mr.

Clinton on today to discuss ways to revive peace efforts, which have been devastated by more than five weeks of street clashes and gun battles that have left more than 180 people dead, most of them Palestinians. As Mr. Arafat headed for Washington, Prime Minister Ehud Barak of Israel sent a letter to world leaders criticizing what he called Mr.

Arafat's resort to violence and urging a negotiated agreement on a Palestinian state. "The only road to be taken is the one leading to an honorable, agreed-upon, negotiated birth of a Palestinian state," Mr. Barak wrote in the letter released by his office. The violence has persisted despite a truce agreed upon last week and an earlier cease-fire accord reached last month. Mr.

Barak, who is scheduled to meet Mr. Clinton on Sunday, said that the killing of the customs agent near the Rafah border crossing between the Gaza Strip and Egypt "put in doubt" Mr. Arafat's intentions of observing the truce.

Clipped two-column article, no masthead, no folio, no printed date; date is label-only. There is no deck. PRINTER'S ERROR PRESERVED: 'scheduled to meet Mr. Clinton on today' — the Naples Daily News version of the same wire copy reads 'on Thursday', so a sub here has replaced 'Thursday' with 'today' and left the 'on' standing. Transcribed as printed. This paper keeps the New York Times house style of 'Mr. Arafat' and 'Mr. Barak' throughout; the Naples Daily News on the same day strips every honorific. WIRE-COPY DIVERGENCE: the Anderson text STOPS at Faris Odeh. The Naples Daily News printed three further named Palestinian dead — Muhammad Abu Ghali, 16, Raed Daoud, 14, and two unnamed young men — and the Barak state-commission inquiry into 13 Arabs killed. This clipping is a cut-down of the same dispatch. Faris Odeh, named here at 14, is the same boy Hugh Dellios lists by name in the op-ed on slides 67 and 68.

CP-2000-065 →

· Naples Daily News · Naples, FL

Arafat leaves for Washington; West Bank violence continues

By JOEL GREENBERG, N.Y. Times News Service

JERUSALEM — Palestinian gunmen killed an Israeli customs agent and Israeli troops shot dead three Palestinian teenagers in the Gaza Strip Wednesday on the eve of a meeting in Washington between President Clinton and Yasser Arafat, the Palestinian leader.

Arafat left Wednesday for Washington, where he is scheduled to meet Clinton on Thursday to discuss ways to revive peace efforts, which have been devastated by more than five weeks of street clashes and gun battles that have left more than 180 people dead, most of them Palestinians.

As Arafat headed for Washington, Prime Minister Ehud Barak of Israel sent a letter to world leaders criticizing what he called Arafat's resort to violence and urging a negotiated agreement on a Palestinian state.

"The only road to be taken is the one leading to an honorable, agreed-upon, negotiated birth of a Palestinian state," Barak wrote in the letter released by his office. The violence has persisted despite a truce agreed upon last week and an earlier cease-fire accord reached last month.

Full page scan, clipped at the left and right edges where neighbouring columns bleed in. No masthead, no folio, no printed date; date is label-only. 'EMOTIONAL DEMONSTRATION' set in caps above the photograph is a PHOTO-PACKAGE KICKER, not a deck; the article's headline is the two-line 'Arafat leaves for Washington; West Bank violence continues'. There is no deck. WIRE-COPY DIVERGENCE, and this is the one worth showing Maria: the Anderson Independent Mail ran the same Joel Greenberg dispatch on the same day and stopped after Faris Odeh. The Naples Daily News runs three more paragraphs and names two more Palestinian children, Muhammad Abu Ghali, 16, and Raed Daoud, 14, plus two unnamed young men who died of earlier wounds, plus the state commission inquiry into 'the deaths of 13 Arabs killed in unrest in Israeli-Arab communities last month'. Naples also strips every 'Mr.' honorific that Anderson keeps, and prints 'meet Clinton on Thursday' where Anderson prints the garbled 'meet Mr. Clinton on today'. Two photographs. Caption one: 'Palestinian mourners burn a U.S. flag during the funeral procession of 24-year-old Said abu Khatia in Rafah, southern Gaza Strip, on Wednesday. Abu Khatia was shot and killed by Israeli soldiers during clashes on Tuesday.' (Associated Press (2)). Caption two: 'The shadow of a Palestinian demonstrator is cast upon a wall as he throws a stone during clashes with Israeli soldiers in the West Bank city of Hebron on Wednesday.' The lower-case 'abu' in 'Said abu Khatia' is the paper's own and is kept as printed. Columns two and three were read at page magnification except for the Abu Ghali / Daoud paragraphs, which were transcribed from a magnified crop.

CP-2000-066 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore, Maryland · page 2A

Victims of the conflict

■ Middle East: Instead of the peace that leaders hoped for, the Middle East is again the setting for violence. In the past seven weeks, more than 200 Palestinians, Israelis and Israeli Arabs have died in clashes – by gunshots, bombs, hangings, stabbings and stones. Almost every day, the list of victims grows. Whatever their cause, or the circumstances of their deaths, they deserve at least to be named, and remembered as part of a conflict seemingly without end.

David Biri, 19, Israeli, Sept. 27. ■ Bilal Afanih, 26, Palestinian, Sept. 29. ■ Haitham Iskafi, 45, Palestinian, Sept. 29. ■ Nizar Shwaiki, 18, Palestinian, Sept. 29. ■ Usama Jada, 23, Palestinian, Sept. 29. ■ Yihya Faraj, 17, Palestinian, Sept. 29. ■ Yossi Tabaja, 37, Israeli, Sept. 29. ■ Mahmoud Anbara, 20, Palestinian, Sept. 30. ■ Nizar Aida, 16, Palestinian, Sept.

30. ■ Zakariya El Kilani, 22, Palestinian, Sept. 30. ■ Amjad Daragmi, 22, Palestinian, Sept. 30. ■ Mahir Abeed, 22, Palestinian, Sept. 30. ■ Mohammad El Utla, 25, Palestinian, Sept. 30. ■ Mohammad El Dura, 12, Palestinian, Sept. 30. ■ Basam El Balbisi, 45, Palestinian, Sept. 30. ■ Mohammad Qalaq, 23, Palestinian, Sept. 30. ■ Khalid Bazian, 14, Palestinian, Sept.

30. ■ Iyad Khashashi, 18, Palestinian, Sept. 30. ■ Madhat Yosef, 19, Israeli, Oct. 1. ■ Mohammad Jabareen, 24, Israeli Arab, Oct. 1. ■ Mohammad Dawood, 14, Palestinian, Oct. 1. ■ Salah El Faqih, 25, Palestinian, Oct. 1. ■ Sami El Taramsi, 20, Palestinian, Oct. 1. ■ Imad El Anati, 29, Palestinian, Oct. 1. ■ Husam Bakheet, 18, Palestinian, Oct.

1. ■ Samer Tabanja, 12, Palestinian, Oct. 1. ■ Jihad El Aloul, 22, Palestinian, Oct. 1. ■ Mustafa Ramadan, 26, Palestinian, Oct. 1. ■ Sara Hasan, 15, Palestinian, Oct. 1. [the list continues in the same form to Mohammed al-Ijla, 13, Palestinian, Nov. 14; the complete sequence is transcribed in named_individuals]

Maria's note on this clipping: she is right that it does the thing almost nothing else in the archive does. The page gives the whole seven weeks as a single run-on roll of 210 names set in body type across the full measure, each with age, nationality and date of death, broken only by square bullets, with the headline and standfirst dropped into a well in the middle. The layout is the argument: there is no hierarchy, no photograph of a victim, no story about any one of them, and nothing to say whether a person was shot at a checkpoint or lynched in a police station. The standfirst makes that explicit — “Whatever their cause, or the circumstances of their deaths, they deserve at least to be named”. On whether the paper gave Palestinian and Israeli dead the same detail: formally yes, the same four fields for everyone, and the first name on the page is an Israeli soldier. Where the symmetry breaks it breaks against the Israeli entries, which supply the only three missing ages. Against that, the two pull quotes give the page a 1993 Oslo frame — Rabin on the left, Arafat on the right, both dated Sept. 13, 1993 — which reads the seven weeks as the failure of a peace two leaders promised rather than as anything with a cause. 183 of the 210 dead are Palestinian and the youngest is nine; the page does not remark on either. For the name page: the youngest entries are Mohammad Abu Asi, 9 (Oct. 4), and Mohammad El Dura, 12, and Samer Tabanja, 12 (both Oct. 1); Fares Odeh, 14 (Nov. 8) is also here.

CP-2000-068 →

· Enterprise Record · Chico · page 1

Amounah Al Deges, the mother of 12-year-old Mohammed Al Deges, weeps over her dead son at the Jabalia refugee camp in northern Gaza city

“Amounah Al Deges, the mother of 12-year-old Mohammed Al Deges, weeps over her dead son at the Jabalia refugee camp in northern Gaza city. Al Deges was shot and killed Saturday during clashes with Israeli soldiers.” Associated Press

A photograph and its caption, and the caption names both of them: the boy who was killed and his mother.

CP-2000-009 →

· The New York Times

10 Die as Violence Surges on Palestinian ‘Day of Rage’

By JOEL GREENBERG

JERUSALEM, Dec. 8 — Ten people were killed today in the West Bank and East Jerusalem in one of the deadliest days of violence since the outbreak of the current Palestinian uprising more than two months ago. The violence surged as Palestinians marked the 13th anniversary of the first uprising in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Israeli security forces killed seven Palestinians, and Palestinian gunmen shot dead three Israelis, casting a pall over diplomatic efforts to stop the bloodshed and renew peace negotiations between the two sides. An international panel headed by former Senator George J. Mitchell was expected to arrive here within days to investigate the unrest.

More than 300 people, most of them Palestinians, have died in 10 weeks of street clashes, gunbattles, shootings and bombings that have punctuated a Palestinian uprising for independence that has aimed mostly at Israeli soldiers and settlers in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

The mainstream Palestinian movement Fatah and Islamic groups had called for a “day of rage” today to mark the start of the first Palestinian uprising, which began in 1987 and ended after the 1993 Oslo peace accord.

The flare-up today also coincided with the second Friday of the Muslim fasting month of Ramadan, when Palestinians gathered for mosque prayers and many were turned away as they tried to reach Jerusalem for services at Al Aksa Mosque, one of Islam’s holiest shrines. The day began with a drive-by shooting at Jewish settlers south of Hebron.

Palestinian gunmen in a passing car sprayed gunfire at a van carrying teachers to the settlement of Qiryat Arba, killing one of them and the driver.

Naama Didovsky, 6, stood by the covered body of her mother, Rina Didovsky, killed in a drive-by shooting in the West Bank yesterday. Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times

CP-2000-064 →

· Albuquerque Journal · Albuquerque

Israeli Soldiers Are Killing Children

In an attempt to quell the current Palestinian popular uprising, the Al-Aqsa Intifada, Israel’s propaganda machine has sought the pinnacle of ruthless dehumanization of the Palestinian people. Israel blames Palestinian mothers for the deaths of their young children at the hand of its military.

The premise behind this twisted logic is that Palestinian parents chauffeur their children to the riot areas and place them as targets be shot at and killed by Israeli soldiers. Why? Israel’s macabre answer is: to embarrass the Jewish state and for monetary gain.

But Israel gives no explanation of why its army, celebrated for its “purity” of purpose, lends itself to this nefarious Palestinian scheme by killing children. Israel explicitly suggests that the Palestinian mothers, in effect the entire Palestinian nation, are subhumans no better than animals.

In fact, I have not heard of an animal that would willingly hand its offspring to the lion. This is beyond political pathology or arrogance of power. It is the core of the official Israel racist tenet that denies Palestinian humanity to make it easier to blame the victim.

This presumably makes it less of an effort for Israeli Jews and their supporters to suppress their colossal feelings of guilt. Israel claims that the Palestinian National Authority pays parents $300 per injured child and $1,200 per death.

This deliberate degradation of the Palestinians is equivalent to a Nazi alleging that the Zionist movement perpetrated the killing of Jews in Europe so that Jewish leaders and Holocaust survivors would receive financial compensation.

CP-2000-046 →

· The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, UT

Palestinian Schoolboy Foretold Martyrdom

Teen is revered by Palestinians for fatal attack on Israeli tank; meanwhile, his parents mourn

BY LEE HOCKSTADER, THE WASHINGTON POST

GAZA CITY — The poster boy for Palestinian defiance stood about 5 feet 4 inches in his socks. He might have weighed 100 pounds if he had eaten recently and well, which he rarely did.

He was good at soccer, naughty at school, and before he died — after he was shot in the neck by Israeli troops and left to bleed to death on the battlefield — he told his friends he was intent on becoming a martyr for the Palestinian cause. Faris Odeh got his wish, and then some.

Killed last month, a few weeks shy of his 15th birthday, Faris has been immortalized posthumously by a remarkable photograph. It captured him — short, scrawny and wearing a baggy sweater — rearing back to sling a stone at an Israeli tank perhaps 15 yards away. Now Faris is a Palestinian legend, his valor celebrated in graffiti and wall art. Political parties pay him homage.

Television extols his example. His photograph adorns calendars and posters and has been painted, larger than life, on the walls of refugee camps in the Gaza Strip and on the sides of West Bank office buildings. But at home in Gaza City, where Faris lived with his parents and eight siblings, the hullabaloo strikes a sour chord. His mother, for one, isn't sure she buys it.

Masthead line reads 'The Salt Lake Tribune WORLD Tuesday, December 12, 2000'; 12 Dec 2000 was a Tuesday, so the date is verified. 'WORLD' is part of the folio line, not a deck. The deck is the single line under the headline. WORTH SHOWING MARIA: the dek says the boy is 'revered by Palestinians for fatal attack on Israeli tank'. The attack was not fatal to anyone but Faris Odeh; he threw a stone and was shot in the neck. The paper's own body text says so in its first sentence. The headline and dek assign the fatality to the boy's act, and the mother's quotes in column two refuse exactly that reading. This is the only clipping in the batch where a Palestinian parent speaks at length. The paper spells the boy 'Faris Odeh' and gives his age as a few weeks short of 15; the Columbia Missourian letter on slide 71 calls him 'Fares Odeh, a 13-year-old'; the Los Angeles Times on the same slide calls him '15-year-old Fares Odeh'; the Joel Greenberg dispatch on slide 69 calls him a '14-year-old'. Four American papers, four different renderings of one boy. Columns three and four were read at page magnification only; columns one and two were transcribed from magnified crops. The right-hand quarter of the clipping is advertisements ('I Lost 43 lbs. Using Hypnosis!' and 'DIVORCE $150'), which are not part of the article.

CP-2000-067 →

· Southern Illinoisan · Carbondale · page 1

Israel kills Palestinian in renewed hostilities

Associated Press, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli soldiers gunned down a Palestinian activist Tuesday, witnesses said, the fourth West Bank leader killed in a little over a month — all considered political assassinations by the Palestinians. The Israeli military refused to comment on the killing of Yousef Abu Swayeh, nor would it confirm that the 27-year-old was even on its wanted list.

But Deputy Defense Minister Ephraim Sneh told Israel radio earlier in the day that the only way to stop Palestinian attacks on Israelis is to “strike at those who are leading the shooting cells and their deputies.”

The killing in the West Bank town of Bethlehem came as Prime Minister Ehud Barak, beginning his re-election campaign, said he hoped conditions would soon be right for resuming peace negotiations with the Palestinians.

First, he said, violence must be substantially reduced… The violence, which has left more than 310 people dead, and Barak’s response to it, are at the center of the campaign… An activist in the Fatah movement of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, Abu Swayeh was gunned down in front of his home in a village near Bethlehem, witnesses said, demanding anonymity.

They said Israeli soldiers fired at him from a road under Israeli control and hit him with 17 bullets. At least three other regional Palestinian leaders have been killed since the current unrest began. Israel took responsibility for two of the killings. On Nov.

9, not far from where Abu Swayeh died, Israeli helicopters fired at a car carrying the local Fatah commander, Hussein Abayat, killing him and two women bystanders.

In Cairo, Egypt, the chairman of an international inquiry committee appointed by President Clinton said the group will not limit itself to reading reports and will gather evidence on the ground to determine the causes of the violence between Israel and the Palestinians.

“We’ll receive information from the widest possible range of sources and we will make the appropriate judgment at the appropriate time on what is necessary,” said former U.S. Sen. George Mitchell.

The witnesses are quoted anonymously and the paper says why they asked for it. The two women killed beside Hussein Abayat are counted but not named.

CP-2000-010 →

· Albuquerque Tribune · page C4

Some Israeli faithful offended by ‘ignorance’ of Mideast, ‘fascist Sharon’

Holger Jensen

For the past two months, the Denver Rocky Mountain News and other papers that run my column have received a heavy flow of mail criticizing my views on the Palestinian uprising and Israel's response to it. By way of balance, I would direct them to the words of Robert Fisk, a respected colleague who has devoted 30 years to covering the Middle East.

This is what he wrote for Britain's Independent newspaper: “The degree of abuse now being directed at anyone — academic, analyst, reporter — who dares to criticize Israel, or dares to tell the truth about the Palestinian uprising, is reaching McCarthyite proportions. “Take Edward Said, the brilliant Palestinian academic who is a professor at Columbia University.

The Zionist Organization of America now demands on an almost daily basis his dismissal from Columbia — solely because he points out, with clinical ferocity and painful accuracy, the historical tragedy of Palestinian dispossession, the brutality of Israel's continued occupation and the bankruptcy of the Oslo ‘peace’ agreement.

“Columbia University has issued an unprecedented public defense of Said and the fundamental values of a great university, saying to give way to the Jewish lobby's demand would be ‘a threat to us all and to academic freedom.’” Too true.

Noam Chomsky — himself Jewish — is one of the most profound philosophers of our age, but his scathing reviews of the Israeli occupation and America's blind, unquestioning support for Israel now earn him ever more ruthless abuse.

“In the United States,” he wrote recently, “a whole population is kept in ignorance of the facts because the economic and military programs (of Israel) rely crucially on U.S. support, which is domestically unpopular and would be far more so if its purposes were known.”

Ignorance of the Middle East is now so firmly adhered to in the United States that only a few tiny newspapers report anything other than Israel's point of view. You won't find Chomsky in The New York Times.

It was put very well by Charl[illegible] Reese in a recent issue of the Orlando Sentinel when he wrote that “Palestinians won't get their independence until Americans get theirs.” “But the attempt to force the media to obey Israel's rules is now international.

We must say that Israel is under siege by Palestinians (rather than occupying Palestinian land), that Palestinians are responsible for the violence (even though Palestinians are the principal victims), that Arafat turned down a good deal at Camp David (though he was offered just over 60 percent of his land, not 94 percent), and that Palestinians indulge in child sacrifice (rather than question why the Israeli troops have shot so many Palestinian children).”

I would also direct my critics to this open letter from Jewish artist Selma Waldman in Seattle: “We are Jewish activists here in Seattle who agree with the United Nations indictment of Israel, that Ehud Barak's government has committed war crimes in this time of The Second Intifada, when the Palestinian people are in a life-and-death struggle for their independence.

“Because we are Jews, we suggest that if a State did not want to see atrocity against captured soldiers, it should never have sent its sharpshooters to murder children, nor its tanks, helicopters, mortars and automatic weapons to kill stone-throwers, nor its massed security to protect a bloated old fascist like Sharon in his arrogant act.

“We support the shared sovereignty of Jerusalem, and the Israeli Gush Shalom demands to end all demolitions of Palestinian homes, all Jewish settlements on Palestinian lands, and all occupation of the territories that are rightfully Palestine.

We further demand that the Israeli government put an end to settler vigilantism and terror raids against the Palestinian-Israeli people in their villages in Israel. “To make a more appropriate use of Barak's farcical expression, we would suggest that now, if ever, is the time for the U.S. to declare a ‘time out’ for all U.S. aid to Israel.

As for the Israeli government, it is out of time to end its grotesque military mobilization against the Palestinian people, a final aggression which we protest as a murderous disgrace to Jewish history.”

Israel's Ha'aretz newspaper reported last week that a growing number of Israeli soldiers are beginning to wonder if they are indeed guilty of overkill against the Palestinians. American supporters of Israel would do well to ask the questions that Israelis are asking of themselves.

Mug shot of the columnist in column 1, captioned “Holger Jensen” in two lines.

CP-2000-073 →

· Times Record · Fort Smith

Thousands march in funeral procession for slain Palestinians

RAFAH, Gaza Strip — An Israeli motorist was killed in a drive-by shooting Thursday in the West Bank… In the West Bank, Ahmed Awad, 41, was killed by Israeli gunfire in a clash near the town of Tulkarem.

Ahmed Awad, 41, is named. The headline counts the rest as slain Palestinians, and the first sentence is about someone else's death.

CP-2000-060 →

· Midland Reporter Telegram · Midland

Fate of Palestinian refugees a key sticking point to peace deal

Laura King

DHEISHEH REFUGEE CAMP, West Bank — Some have heavy old iron keys to homes destroyed long ago. Some have crumbling yellow land deeds. Some have faded sepia photographs. And all have memories — their own, or those handed down to them like a family keepsake.

Now, the nearly 4 million Palestinian refugees — whose families fled or were driven from their homes during Israel’s 1948 war of independence and subsequent fighting — may prove the single biggest obstacle to a U.S.-proposed peace accord being weighed by leaders on both sides.

Alarmed and angry over word that Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat could agree to give up the “right of return” — ending their decades-old dream of returning to homes inside Israel — many refugees say they would fight rather than accept such terms.

In the Dheisheh refugee camp on the edge of the West Bank town of Bethlehem, a garbage-strewn shantytown where 11,000 refugees are crammed into half a square mile of concrete-block hovels, there is talk of a “refugee intefadeh” — an uprising — if Arafat concedes what many Palestinians consider a sacred tenet of their national struggle.

Since President Clinton outlined the main points of a proposed treaty to Israeli and Palestinian delegations in Washington last week, news reports and sources on both sides have indicated the proposed accord calls on Palestinians to effectively trade away the “right of return” in order to win a coveted prize: sovereignty over the Al Aqsa mosque compound in Jerusalem’s walled Old City, Islam’s third-holiest shrine.

But many refugees say no one — not even Arafat — has the authority to relinquish what they consider their birthright. “The right of return is holy to us,” says graffiti splashed across gray walls in Dheisheh’s hillside alleyways.

The explosive question of the refugees’ fate stretches well beyond the boundaries of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, where a three-month outbreak of fighting has killed nearly 350 people, the vast majority Palestinians. Hundreds of thousands live in refugee camps in neighboring Lebanon, Syria and Jordan, where their presence is tolerated but largely unwelcome.

Fairouz Hamash, 15, looks at a flower arrangement in the living room of her family’s home in the Dheisheh refugee camp on the edge of the West Bank town of Bethlehem Tuesday. The fate of nearly 4 million Palestinian refugees is a key sticking point to a Mideast peace accord.

CP-2000-047 →

· The New York Times · New York

The Price of Peace Will Be Paid in Dreams

John Kifner

“They treasure keys to homes in the Galilee, where they once lived. Old, tattered land deeds with the tax stamps of the British mandate are passed down the generations with equal reverence.”

Written as the Clinton talks collapsed, under the standing head Out of Place. The keys and the mandate-era deeds appear as objects of reverence; the headline calls the right they document a dream to be paid for.

CP-2000-054 →

· The Grand Rapids Press · Grand Rapids

Palestinian refugees cling to ‘right of return’

The Palestinians — angry that their leader could give up their right to return to Israel — say they will fight against such terms.

Laura King

DHEISHEH REFUGEE CAMP, West Bank — Some have heavy old iron keys to homes destroyed long ago. Some have crumbling yellow land deeds. Some have faded sepia photographs. And all have memories — their own, or those handed down to them like a family keepsake.

Now, the nearly 4 million Palestinian refugees — whose families fled or were driven from their homes during Israel’s 1948 war of independence and subsequent fighting — may prove the single biggest obstacle to a U.S.-proposed peace accord being weighed by leaders on both sides.

Alarmed and angry over suggestions that Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat could agree to give up the “right of return” — ending their decades-old dream of returning to homes inside Israel — many refugees say they would fight rather than accept such terms.

In the Dheisheh refugee camp on the edge of the West Bank town of Bethlehem, a garbage-strewn shantytown where 11,000 refugees are crammed into half a square mile of concrete-block hovels, there is talk of a “refugee intefadeh” — an uprising — if Arafat concedes what many Palestinians consider a sacred tenet of their national struggle.

Since President Clinton outlined the main points of a proposed treaty to Israeli and Palestinian delegations in Washington last week, news reports and sources on both sides have indicated the proposed accord calls on Palestinians to effectively trade away the “right of return” to win a coveted prize: sovereignty over the Al Aqsa mosque compound in Jerusalem’s walled Old City, Islam’s third-holiest shrine.

Palestinian boys aim toy guns as they play in the Dheisheh refugee camp, a garbage-strewn shantytown where 11,000 Palestinian refugees are crammed into half a square mile on the edge of the West Bank town of Bethlehem.

CP-2001-023 →

· The Atlanta Journal-Constitution · Atlanta · page 1

Palestinians don’t want to give up ‘right of return’

Saeed Ahmed, sahmed@ajc.com

“Saber Ayoub was 23, newly married and about to take over the family farm when his family was forced out of the village of Safad in northern Palestine by advancing Israeli troops. He thought the family would return in a week or two. Fifty-three years later, Ayoub is still waiting.

Now a frail 76, the Palestinian exile, who settled in Atlanta in 1989 after decades in refugee camps in Lebanon, still speaks longingly of his family home — where the vineyards produced the sweetest grapes and wildflowers cast the hills in a brilliant yellow.

His desire to return has never wavered, even as the 150 acres of land that once constituted his farm has given way to Jewish settlements. ‘I have moved from place to place, stateless, all my life, and all I ask for is a graveyard in the land that I call home,’ says Ayoub, the tears welling in his eyes, ‘but even that has become a political issue.’

And so it goes for the nearly 4 million Palestinian refugees, whose families fled or were driven from their homes during Israel’s 1948 war of independence and subsequent fighting. Hundreds settled in metro Atlanta, but the exact number is difficult to come by. Most had to assume the citizenship of another country as Palestine is not officially recognized as a nation.

Some carry rusty keys to homes destroyed long ago, others yellowed land deeds or faded photographs. As Israeli and Palestinian diplomats try to hammer out a peace deal, the fate of these refugees is proving to be one of the biggest obstacles.

To such displaced Palestinians, sovereignty over the disputed Jerusalem shrine the Muslims call Haram Al-Sharif means nothing if they have to trade away their ‘right of return.’ ‘That’s like spitting in our faces,’ says Ayoub’s son Nabil.

‘The Israeli position on the refugee situation has been that “the old will die and the young will forget,” but the names of our towns and where we belong has been fed to us with the milk of our mothers nursed us with.’

While Palestinians say their right to return is well-grounded in international law — they cite the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Fourth Geneva Convention and United Nations Resolution 194, which mandates that refugees wishing to return to their homes be permitted to do so — Israel has resisted.

To Israelis, opening the door to all Palestinian refugees would not only place an unbearable economic strain on their country but would result in what Israel calls ‘demographic suicide.’

Israelis fear an influx of Palestinians would dilute the Jewish character of Israel and, with the country’s population already 20 percent Arab, reignite the 5 million Jews to minority status.

‘The very nature of the state of Israel is in jeopardy if all Palestinian refugees are given an unlimited ability to live in Israel,’ says Kenneth Stein, professor of Middle Eastern history at Emory University.

But Hussein Ibish, communications director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, says the refugees have a fundamental right that ought to be granted. ‘The rights of refugees is one that is upheld so vociferously by the international community that we even went to war with Yugoslavia, a sovereign state,’ says Ibish.

‘We didn’t buy into Serbia’s ethno-national ambition, but somehow in this instance, we find this argument compelling.’ The Palestinian refugee crisis has had as many phases as Israel has had wars. About 700,000 Palestinians fled in 1948, and more waves of refugees followed the 1967 and 1973 Arab-Israeli conflicts.

Among those living in the worst conditions are the 370,000 refugees marooned in Lebanon, where Ayoub lived for 41 years before moving to the United States… Following the assassination of Lebanese President Bashir Gemayel, members of the South Lebanon Army — vowing to avenge his death — slaughtered 7,000 civilians in a 36-hour rampage in Shatila and a second camp, Sabra.

The Ayoub family escaped unharmed, and soon after, Ayoub’s eldest son, Nabil, made his way to America, graduated from college and landed a job as a software engineer. The father followed in 1989. Now sitting in a friend’s house in south Cobb, Ayoub swaps stories with other refugee families. His son Nabil is now 33 and has never set foot in his hometown.

Unlike his father, his emphasis is on the ‘right’ more than on an actual ‘return’ to Palestine. He doesn’t want to live under Israeli sovereignty now that he has made a life for himself in another land, he says. But still, he insists, he ought to be given that option.

‘Until that dream is reached, I will pass on to my child the dream my father has willed to me,’ says the younger Ayoub.”

“Saber Ayoub (left), who settled in Atlanta in 1989, visits with the family of another Palestinian refugee, Hany El-Nazzer (second from right). El-Nazzer, who came to the United States in 1977, lives in Austell with his U.S.-born wife, Pat, holding Amin, 3, and their son Ismail, 9.” Andy Sharp / Staff

A father and son in Atlanta disagreeing about what the right of return means: the father wants a graveyard in Safad, the son wants the right without the return. Both are named, and so is a second refugee family photographed with them. The Israeli objection is quoted at equal length.

CP-2001-001 →

· Hartford Courant · Hartford · page 1

Palestinians Deserve Rights, Including Right To Return

Mazin Qumsiyeh

“Recent calls for the Palestinians to abandon their right to go home should not be acceptable to anyone with elemental knowledge of legality and morality.

The British ‘mandate’ to fulfill Lord Balfour’s promise of a Jewish homeland in populated Palestine (which had a minority Jewish presence of 7 percent at the time) was implemented by force without consulting the wishes of the Palestinian inhabitants.

Jewish land ownership at the eve of the British-inspired, American-pushed declaration of dividing Palestine into a ‘Jewish state’ (55 percent of the land) and an ‘Arab state’ (45 percent) in 1947 was less than 8 percent of all privately held lands. From that time forward, Zionists have methodically altered the character of the land and the people.

As a result of sometimes ingenious and other times brutal ways of ethnic cleansing, over 95 percent of Palestinian families (Muslim and Christian) have lost lands or homes to Zionists. This is not a Palestinian story but a fact attested to by Israeli historians themselves and in the published words and documents of Israeli leaders.

Israel/Palestine now has about 4.5 million Jews and 3.7 million Christians and Muslims. Of the 8 million Palestinians in the world, more than 5 million are refugees or ‘displaced persons.’

A quarter of Israel’s 1.2 million ‘Gentile’ citizens are considered by the Israeli legal system as ‘present absentees’ and their land is confiscated.

Lands and homes vacated by Christian and Muslim refugees and ‘absentees’ are considered state property and turned over to the Jewish agency that administers the land and leases it only to Jews. Palestinians are treated much worse than blacks were in South Africa under apartheid.

Incomplete success of ethnic cleansing led Israeli governments to attempt to isolate Palestinians in bantustans (homelands) and to ensure that refugees never return (3,000 were killed trying to ‘infiltrate’ back before fences were put up).

The 30-year-old Israeli-American solution to the Palestinian ‘problem’ was reinvented at Oslo and re-presented lately by Prime Minister Ehud Barak and President Clinton as final deals to Palestinians.

Modeled after apartheid in South Africa, it envisions no return of refugees and disjointed segments of a demilitarized ‘Palestine,’ without control of natural resources or borders surrounded by the Israeli army and settlements. But even if Arafat agrees to this sham ‘peace,’ it cannot last.

Palestinian refugees know their return is an inalienable, individual and collective right supported by international law and morality. Research has also shown return to be feasible and not a threat to other. On the contrary, no lasting peace can occur without it; annulling it would set a precedent in international law.

Israel also needs to evolve from a Jewish state to a state of its citizens. It is only logical to expect that the current Palestinian citizens of Israel (and secular Israelis in general) are not thrilled to stand in awe at a national anthem that talks about Jewish yearning for a homeland.

They are not keen about a state that has no constitution to protect Gentiles but rather has specific laws to discriminate against them and insure Jewish-only settlements continue to flourish while Arab towns and villages are destroyed or strangled.

They are not content with an Israeli law of return giving automatic citizenship to any Jew in the world who desires it while denying return to people born and raised there for generations simply for being Gentile (many of them relatives of those Palestinians remaining and who have not seen each other in 52 years).

Why does the U.S. government give more money to Israel than it gives to any state in the union? And why do we fund the Israeli military oppression of Palestinian Muslims and Christians?… They still prefer to talk about everything from geopolitics to religion but not address basic human rights and true coexistence in equality.

It is time for U.S. citizens to demand a change.”

A Palestinian academic given the op-ed page. The paper identifies him: director of cytogenetics services at the Yale University School of Medicine, and chairman of the media committee of the Palestine Right to Return Coalition.

CP-2001-002 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinians who are Israeli citizens weigh the election

“‘As Palestinians who are Israeli citizens, we are already so unequal and so much on the margins. We can’t sit out this election like we all really want to do.’”

Souhel Karram, in Nazareth, to Deborah Sontag. He names himself: a Palestinian who is an Israeli citizen. The paper’s own vocabulary took another twenty years to arrive where this sentence already is.

CP-2001-034 →

· The Herald Sun · Durham

Polls predict landslide for hard-liner Ariel Sharon in Israeli election

The election the next three clippings are datelined from Kafr Qasim about.

CP-2001-030 →

· Daily Dispatch

Arabs willing to lose this election to win Israeli rights

Dina Kraft

KAFR KASSEM, Israel — Two days before Israel’s election, boycott is the buzzword among Arabs across Israel… “I won’t vote, and neither will 95 percent of the village,” said Ali Sarsur, 38, a roofer donating his time for the construction of a mosque… In 1956, Israeli riot police enforcing a curfew — Israeli Arabs then lived under military rule — killed 49 villagers for violating the restrictions.

Forty-five years on, the village is a dateline. Named here: Ali Sarsur, a roofer; Jafar Farah of the Mussawa Center; Yazbak, a professor of Palestinian history at Haifa University. One sentence does the history, and it still says the villagers were killed for violating the restrictions.

CP-2001-031 →

· South Idaho Press

Israeli Arabs see boycott of election as punishment for Ehud Barak

The Associated Press

“‘It is a clear message to Barak and Sharon that the Arabs have an independent political position,’ said Arab lawmaker Taleb as-Sana. ‘We want to deliver an electric shock to the political system.’… In Israel’s May 1999 election, 77 percent of Arab voters turned out. Of those casting ballots, 95 percent supported Barak.”

Idaho, datelined Kafr Kassem. The figures are the argument: 95 per cent for Barak in 1999, a boycott in 2001.

CP-2001-032 →

· News Press

Israeli Arabs plan boycott of election to punish Barak

The third printing of the same dispatch, in a third state.

CP-2001-033 →

· The Boston Globe · page A20

Feared road offers clues to Israel vote

more pointedly at Prime Minister Ehud Barak, who has been unable to stop it, either by diplomacy or by force. If the public opinion polls are correct, the Labor Party’s Barak is about to face a stunning defeat to opposition Likud Party leader Ariel Sharon, who in Friday’s polls led by 18 percentage points.

Campaign signs plastered along Route 443 last week overwhelmingly favored Sharon, the 72-year-old former general and defense minister.

Loathed by the Israeli left and the Palestinian public for leading the bloody 1982 invasion of Lebanon and engineering the expansion of Jewish settlements in the West Bank, the legendary hawk has concocted a campaign slogan his critics find almost surreal: “Only Sharon Can Bring Peace.” In a campaign where both candidates speak of peace, the mood is of war.

At roughly two-mile intervals along Route 443, three Israeli tanks stood perched on rocky cliffs, their guns trained on Palestinian villages. Armored personnel carriers crawled up winding hills with soldiers training machine guns on passing cars. New military checkpoints dotted the road.

At the entrance to the road, coming from Tel Aviv, is the sprawling town of Modi’in, a bedroom community of 40,000. It was built in the early 1990s hard along the border of the West Bank, a confident expression of an Israel poised to make peace with its Palestinian neighbors.

Now the heavy military presence and the huge concrete blocks and piles of dirt that block Palestinian villages from using the road seem to make that confidence a distant memory. Route 443 is often called the Modi’in Road. For the first six weeks after the intifadah, or Palestinian uprising, began on Sept. 28, Israelis continued to use the route.

But the conflict came closer to home in December, when the shooting started.

An Israeli motorist says the drive-by shootings have not stopped him from taking Route 443 from Modi’in to Jerusalem. These days, many Modi’in residents opt for an alternate route. GLOBE PHOTO/HEIDI LEVINE

CP-2001-044 →

· Seattle Post-Intelligencer · page A5

Fear detours peace on Israel’s deadly Route 443

Voters angry with Barak are poised to elect hawk Sharon

BY CHARLES M. SENNOTT / The Boston Globe

MODI’IN, Israel — In the long shadows of Friday afternoon, when Israelis are usually rushing home or picking up groceries for the weekend, Route 443 between Tel Aviv and Jerusalem was dead quiet. This stretch of road is the shortest distance between Israel’s two major cities, the thinking commuter’s alternative to the often-jammed eight-lane Highway 1.

Using Route 443, which winds in and out of the Israeli-occupied West Bank, can save you a half-hour on your commute, but these days it can also get you killed. In recent weeks, two Israelis have been shot dead and seven wounded in drive-by shootings by Palestinians.

And as Israelis prepare to vote today for prime minister, this road, and the fact that Israelis are now afraid to drive it, runs straight to the core issue of this election: fear.

After four months of a spiraling Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the collapsing dialogue over a final peace agreement, Israelis interviewed along this road express a sense of vulnerability, a fear for their very survival that they say this country has not known since the war that marked the founding of the Jewish state in 1948.

This grim reality has made voters angry, not simply at the Palestinian leadership, which they believe has directed the violence, but more pointedly at Prime Minister Ehud Barak, who has been unable to stop it, either by diplomacy or by force.

If the public opinion polls are correct, the Labor Party’s Barak is about to face a stunning defeat to opposition Likud Party leader Ariel Sharon, who in Friday’s polls led by 18 percentage points. Campaign signs along Route 443 last week overwhelmingly favored Sharon, the 72-year-old former general and defense minister.

Loathed by the Israeli left and the Palestinian public for leading the bloody 1982 invasion of Lebanon and engineering the expansion of Jewish settlements in the West Bank, the legendary hawk has concocted a campaign slogan his critics find almost surreal: “Only Sharon Can Bring Peace.” Both candidates speak of peace, but the mood is of war.

CP-2001-045 →

· The News Journal · Wilmington · page A2

Bush team plans different Mideast tack

Associated Press, Washington

“Even familiar terminology is being cast aside. In a move approved by Secretary of State Colin Powell, the phrase ‘peace process’ is being jettisoned in favor of specific references. ‘There is no official term to describe our efforts to achieve Middle East peace,’ a State Department memorandum says.”

A State Department memorandum about what not to call something, reported as news. The photograph beside it is captioned: Secretary of State Colin Powell approved a move to jettison the phrase ‘peace process.’ The main story on the page is Karin Laub’s Sharon vows to keep Jerusalem — her third appearance in this collection, after Jabalia in 1987 and the naming story of 2013.

CP-2001-015 →

· The New York Times · New York

Bitter, Stark Souvenirs: Sneakers and Slingshots

By DEBORAH SONTAG

RAMALLAH, West Bank, Feb. 19 — In one translucent plastic box, there is a single sock, recovered by the widow of 25-year-old Bial Affaneh after he was shot dead by Israeli forces outside the Aksa Mosque in Jerusalem last September. It is tied up like a gift, with twine for a ribbon. In another box, another totem: pint-sized Fares Odeh’s rough-hewn slingshot.

It flung its last rock at an Israeli tank on Nov. 8, when the 15-year-old boy took a bullet in the neck. The Sakakini Cultural Center here has been converted into a spare, somber shrine to the first 100 Palestinians killed in the uprising that began in late September.

Each life is summed up by one or two objects, selected by the family and wrapped into a tidy bundle, boxed and mounted beneath a photograph of the deceased. The curator is a French-Palestinian artist, Samir Salameh. “I didn’t want to entomb the martyrs,” Mr. Salameh said in French, looking more Rive Gauche than West Bank. “The clear boxes are like windows into their souls.

The objects are banal but they are made precious by those who died. They are wrapped because the people gave their lives like a present to their country.” Encased on the gallery’s stone walls are book bags, soccer balls, boxing gloves, Gameboys, prayer shawls, teacups, wedding pictures and water pipes.

Seventeen-year-old Sami Balawneh is represented by his Israeli security clearance card, expiration date: May 19, 2001. He was killed last October. Israeli critics would say that the exhibit, “100 Martyrs — 100 Lives,” glorifies death and encourages the cult of the shaheed, or martyr.

But Adila Laidi, the cultural center’s director, said that she feared death was so routine that the dead were becoming “dismissable statistics.” Ms. Laidi said that she intentionally focused on the lives of those who were killed rather than on their deaths. In fact, she said, she declined to include the photograph of one young man because it was taken during his autopsy.

“Can you imagine that the only picture ever taken of this poor boy showed the entrance wound for the bullet that killed him?” she asked. […] Samir Maslamani of Jerusalem lent the exhibit a safari-style vest that his 15-year-old son, Madje, used to wear.

“If you ask me to close my eyes and describe him, he is wearing that vest and eating maybe chocolates or a biscuit,” Mr. Maslamani said in a telephone interview. “It’s not a painful thought. I feel proud. This was Madje’s destiny, and I couldn’t intervene.” Another youth, Nizar Eideh, is memorialized by an empty bird cage.

On the morning before Nizar was killed, he released his bird so that it could fly back to its mother, his family said. Then, ignoring his mother’s pleading, he headed toward the site of clashes with Israeli troops in Ramallah. “God will protect me,” he said. Putting last-minute touches on the exhibit, Mr.

Salameh worked to arrange the cage just so, and to position the boy’s picture beside it in an evocative manner. Inside this restored Palestinian villa, the cage was a long way from the boy’s refugee camp home — just as the elegantly mounted exhibit was far from the messy clashes that took the lives being memorialized.

Yazan Halayqa, a 14-year-old from Bethlehem who was killed on Nov. 2, used to ride that bike everywhere. “It was his best friend,” said his father, Muhammad Halayqa. Mr.

Halayqa, who owns several quarries and lives in a grand house, said that his son’s presence in the exhibit demonstrates that it is not only poor youths with nothing to lose who are willing to put their lives on the line. “What can I say?” he said. “It’s like I lost a part of my liver with this boy.

But everybody’s saying that only the sons of poor people die, and it’s good for them to know that also those of rich people do. The intifada is for all Palestinians.”

[upper photograph] A Palestinian woman looks at a shoe that belonged to Mohammed al-Durra, 12, killed next to his father in Gaza.

Next to it is a backpack belonging to another 12-year-old lost in the uprising that began last September. [credit: Photographs by Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times] —— [lower photograph] A slingshot and sunglasses, above left, belonging to 15-year-old Samer Eweiss, who was killed on Oct. 20.

Ramallah now has a place Palestinians can visit to honor the dead of the uprising known as the Aksa intifada.

CP-2001-041 →

· The St. Augustine Record · St. Augustine

Palestinian women suffer under occupation

By PHYLLIS BENNIS, Knight Ridder

Malake Kafishe lives in Hebron's Old City, and she was seven months' pregnant last November when the Israeli military attacked. “There was shooting, and then I heard the helicopter gunships coming in and my heart just stopped,” she said. She began to bleed and then collapsed on the doorstep. Her family telephoned for an ambulance.

Because of a curfew imposed on the 40,000 Palestinians in Hebron's Old City, it took an hour for an ambulance to arrive. In place of paramedics, two Israeli soldiers insisted on examining Kafishe. Before the ambulance could get her to a hospital, it had to pass four checkpoints.

At each roadblock, soldiers swung open the vehicle doors and peered at the ashen-faced woman inside. By the time she reached the hospital, a journey that normally takes five minutes, an hour and a half hours had elapsed. The baby was dead. “The doctor told me, ‘If you had got here 20 minutes earlier, you could have saved the baby,’” Kafishe said.

Israel's continued siege of Palestinian territories is taking a particular toll on women. Because the Israeli military controls the roads in both Gaza and the West Bank, mothers often cannot take their children to school, doctors cannot reach their clinics in the smaller towns.

And pregnant women and the sick, however desperate, often cannot pass the checkpoints to reach a hospital. Palestinian women have also suffered because of the plunging standard of living.

According to the United Nations, unemployment jumped to 38 percent from 12 percent following last fall's siege, and the World Bank reports that one out of every three Palestinians is living in poverty.

Because Palestinian territories have been closed off from Israel for the last five months, the Palestinian economy is losing about $11 million daily, according to the United Nations.

Miftah, an independent organization founded by Palestinian spokeswoman Hanan Ashrawi, reports the closures forced more than 100,000 families into abject poverty, making them survive on less than $2 per day. The U.N. World Food Program recently renewed its emergency appeal for $4 million to feed Palestinian refugees now facing unprecedented starvation.

By February, the number in need of food had soared to 250,000. Most of them, according to the United Nations, are families of workers kept from their jobs in Israel, and widows and their children. It is Palestinian women who figure out how to cope with closures of cities and towns, the blocking of roads and the economic siege.

And as is the case in any community under such economic pressures, social and household tensions rise, and families and the women who sustain them face unbearable strains: how to feed their families when even flour and cooking oil run low, how to care for traumatized children, how to look after the not-really-fearless young men confronting the soldiers.

It's the women who must hold their families together. Palestinian women remain vocal in demanding an end to Israeli occupation. They see a viable Palestinian state as necessary to ensure their rights as women. Some Israeli women recognize the same reality.

Bat Shalom (the Daughters of Peace) recently reasserted that “our principles — a real peace, one based on a just resolution of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict and equal rights for all the citizens of Israel — are strong and resilient. And, maybe because we are women, no one can convince us that violence is the only road that leads to peace and security.”

An article in the Israeli newspaper Ha'aretz last November clarified the point. It quoted a young Palestinian woman in Ramallah, on the West Bank, who said, “There is one subject that makes the issue of the establishment of a Palestinian state more important for women: You need a sovereign framework to fight for human rights in general, and for women's rights in particular.”

Ending Israel's occupation of Palestinian lands would be a good start. Phyllis Bennis is a fellow at the Institute for Policy Studies in Washington. She can be reached at pmproj(AT)progressive.org, or by writing to Progressive Media Project, 409 East Main St., Madison, Wis. 53703.

The tagline at the foot identifies the writer as a fellow at the Institute for Policy Studies in Washington, distributed by Progressive Media Project.

CP-2001-019 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Leaders’ Cordiality Doesn’t Halt Gaza Clashes

By WILLIAM A. ORME Jr.

JERUSALEM, March 9 — Prime Minister Ariel Sharon has told Yasir Arafat that he hopes they can establish “personal contact” after violence diminishes in the region. But prospects for a meeting any time soon appeared distant today as street clashes and gun battles flared anew throughout Gaza and the West Bank.

The fighting was heaviest on the outskirts of Ramallah, where stone-throwing rioters protested the Israeli Army’s digging of a deep trench intended to cut contact between the city and neighboring Bir Zeit.

Armed clashes in Gaza claimed at least one life, and Israeli police near Hebron took into custody several Jewish settlers suspected in the shooting of a local Palestinian man. Prime Minister Sharon expressed his hope for renewed dialogue with the Palestinians in a letter sent to Mr. Arafat on Thursday, his office reported today.

The letter was a reply to a note of congratulations sent by the Palestinian leader after Mr. Sharon was sworn in Wednesday night. “I hope that we will find a way to conduct personal contacts in the near future,” Mr.

Sharon wrote, “in order to put an end to the cycle of bloodshed, hatred and incitement, and to renew security and economic cooperation on the way towards achieving true peace.” But in an implicit reply to Palestinian demands that negotiations resume from the point where they were suspended in Camp David, Md., and Taba, Egypt, Mr.

Sharon said peace could be achieved only through “direct talks and negotiations on the basis of written and signed agreements and obligations.” Mr. Sharon has said his government will not be bound by any negotiating proposals put on the table by the previous administration of Ehud Barak. Mr.

Sharon and his close aides have said that direct dialogue with the Palestinian leadership will not resume until rioting and armed clashes subside for a sustained period. But Shimon Peres, Mr. Sharon’s foreign minister, has expressed his desire to meet with Mr. Arafat as soon as possible, with few preconditions. The climate for diplomacy did not seem propitious today.

Dozens of Palestinians were wounded in the confrontation outside Ramallah, several seriously, according to the Palestinian Red Crescent Society. And the new army-dug trench severed the one direct road between Ramallah and Bir Zeit, home to the area’s leading university. The university may be forced to suspend classes in coming weeks, Palestinian officials said.

An Israeli army cordon in the area prevented most Palestinians from traveling in or out of Bir Zeit and surrounding towns today, Palestinians said.

Bishop Michel Sabbah, the Latin patriarch and ranking Roman Catholic prelate in the region, was turned back at an Israeli checkpoint as he tried to enter the village of Ein Arik to say Mass there tonight, officials at the patriarchate said in a statement.

Farther north in the West Bank, thousands of supporters of the militant Hamas faction rallied to support the group’s promised campaign of suicide bombings against Israeli civilians in Israeli territory. The Hamas marchers converged on a refugee camp outside Tulkaram that was the home of Ahmed Aliyan, who set off a bomb that killed him and three Israelis on Sunday in Netanya.

In Gaza, the Israeli Army shot and killed a 16-year-old youth in clashes near the Karni border crossing, the army radio reported. The Israeli Army had a scare as Binyamin Ben-Eliezer, Israel’s newly appointed defense minister, was touring army headquarters in Gaza today.

His bodyguards pulled him to the ground as a Palestinian gunman opened fire nearby in what was initially reported to be an assassination attempt. The defense minister took office under Mr. Sharon on Wednesday.

“After looking into the matter, it appears the shot that was heard during the defense minister’s visit to the Gaza brigade headquarters was aimed at a nearby base and had no connection with his visit in the area,” the Israeli army said in a statement later. “Hostile terrorist activity, including gunfire, is common in this sector.”

Binyamin Ben-Eliezer, Israel’s newly appointed defense minister, with guards yesterday at army headquarters in the Jewish settlement of Gush Katif in the Gaza Strip, as street clashes and gun battles continued. (credited “Agence France-Presse”)

CP-2001-059 →

· The New York Times · page B9, continued on B11

A Stone’s Throw Is a Freudian Slip

By DINITIA SMITH

The Freud Society of Vienna has canceled a lecture by Edward Said, the Palestinian-American professor, after members saw a photograph of him poised to hurl a stone at an Israeli guardhouse last July at the Lebanese border, said Johann August Schulein, the society’s president. Mr.

Said was invited last August to give the speech, on Freud’s fascination with the ancient civilizations of Egypt, Palestine and Greece, on May 6, the anniversary of Freud’s birth. But on Feb. 5 Mr. Schulein wrote to Mr.

Said, a strong champion of Palestinian causes, and canceled the invitation because of “the political development in the Middle East and the consequences expected.” In a telephone interview from Vienna, Mr. Schulein said, “A lot of members of our society told us they can’t accept that we have invited an engaged Palestinian who also throws stones against Israeli soldiers.” Mr.

Said’s action drew some sharp criticism last summer. Mr. Said said he was having a stone-throwing contest with his son and called it a “symbolic gesture of joy” at the end of Israel’s occupation of Lebanon. “It was a pebble,” Mr. Said said this week. “There was nobody there. The guardhouse was at least half a mile away.” He called the cancellation of his speech outrageous.

“Freud was hounded out of Vienna because he was a Jew,” he said. “Now I am hounded out because I’m a Palestinian.” Mr. Said is a professor of English and comparative literature at Columbia University. Its provost and dean of faculties, Jonathan R. Cole, has defended Mr. Said’s right to free speech.

Several prominent psychoanalysts have written to the society protesting the cancellation, calling it “contrary to the spirit of psychoanalytic understanding and dialogue.” They include Jonathan Lear, an American; André Green and Julia Kristeva in Paris; and Adam Phillips in England. Learning of the cancellation by the Vienna group, the Freud Museum in London has invited Mr.

Said to deliver his talk there, and he said he plans to do so. Mr. Schulein said that a majority of the society’s 18 board members, who include psychoanalysts and representatives from finance and politics, voted to withdraw the invitation, but he would not give the exact vote.

He said the society acted out of concern for the anxieties of Austria’s few remaining Jews in a climate of pro-Nazi and anti-immigration statements by Jorg Haider, the former leader of the extreme-right Freedom Party in Austria’s ruling coalition. “Anti-Semitism hasn’t stopped with World War II and the Nazis,” Mr. Schulein said.

“It has become more dangerous since the Haider party coalition has grown to a mighty force in Austrian politics.” “Lots of Jews fear a situation when xenophobia and anti-Semitism will grow, and will come to a situation where they fear they have to leave the country again,” he said. Before World War II there were some 190,000 Jews in Vienna; only 5,000 to 10,000 are there now.

“The majority decided to cancel the Freud lecture to avoid an internal clash,” Mr. Schulein said. He said he had argued against the decision, adding, “I deeply regret that this has been done to Professor Said.” ... Mr. Said said that the withdrawal of the invitation particularly angered him in light of his lecture topic.

Freud, he said, was a “Eurocentric who tried nevertheless without being reductive, to talk about experience outside of Europe.” In his writings, said Mr. Said, Freud “was talking about a composite culture that didn’t exclude races and civilizations.”

Prof. Edward Said, a stalwart of the Palestinian cause, in his office at Columbia. [credit: Ruby Washington/The New York Times] || The photo that led to an outcry: Prof. Edward Said in Lebanon throwing a stone at Israeli border soldiers. [credit: Agence France-Presse]

CP-2001-060 →

· The New York Times

Palestinians Delicately Begin Debate on Circle of Violence

By DEBORAH SONTAG

AL BIREH, West Bank, March 8 — Muhammad Darraj, a 40-year-old construction worker with weathered hands and dirt-caked boots, moved his family into a new apartment with a commanding view of a Jewish settlement several weeks ago. His reasons were pedestrian but loomed large in his life: he wanted to own, not rent.

Now the new apartment is a house of mourning for his 9-year-old son, Odai, who became an accidental “martyr” for the Palestinian cause after an errant Israeli bullet pierced his bedroom window and then his heart while he was playing with a plastic truck last weekend. An apolitical worker, Mr.

Darraj still looks stunned that his family has been swept into the current of the conflict, and that government officials and gun-toting militants are parading through his living room with plaques and wreaths. Mr.

Darraj said he felt a surge of hatred toward the Israelis, whose troops were responding to gunfire in an area where Palestinian militants use a half-constructed building to shoot toward the settlement of Psagot. But his teen-age daughter, Jamileh, blames the gunmen, too, and strove to express that sentiment until her father shushed her anxiously.

Other Palestinian voices, though, those of clerics, academics, residents of hard-hit areas and even government officials, are starting to be heard. It is hardly an uprising against the uprising, but it is the beginning of an internal Palestinian debate about the violent nature of the intifada for the first time since late last September.

Some Palestinians are speaking out only against the militants’ use of residential neighborhoods as a base, especially after a wave of bystander deaths in Al Bireh, outside Ramallah, during the last few weeks. The sheik at the central mosque here, for instance, condemned the gunmen as “either collaborators or ignorant” in his sermon on March 2.

But the broader question of the intifada’s direction is being broached, too. Some Palestinians are gingerly asking if their leaders have a strategy that justifies the devastating loss of life, property, mobility and income — gingerly out of concern that their questioning be mistaken for disloyalty to the nationalist cause.

CP-2001-050 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · page A4

Despite arrests, Israel lifts bans

Three Palestinians were accused of a bomb-attack plan, while restrictions were eased in the West Bank and Gaza.

By Mark Lavie / ASSOCIATED PRESS

JERUSALEM — Three members of Yasir Arafat’s Fatah group accused of planning a bomb attack in Jerusalem have been arrested, Israel announced yesterday, even as Israeli soldiers lifted some roadblocks in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, allowing Palestinians more freedom of movement.

The three Fatah members intended to set off a large bomb near an Israeli military headquarters, according to a statement from the Israeli Prime Minister’s Office. They belong to a group headed by the Ramallah commander of Force 17, a special unit in Arafat’s security detail.

Members of the group were responsible for at least 25 gunfire attacks, killing eight Israelis and wounding about 20, the statement said. Meanwhile in Washington, U.S. Secretary of State Colin L.

Powell outlined the Bush administration’s policy to Congress, saying there was no way to settle the Arab-Israeli conflict unless the cycle of violence that has gripped the area for six months was stopped.

“Only when we start going back down that escalator of violence can we start to see the opportunity for getting negotiations started again,” Powell told the House Budget Committee in asking for $23.9 billion for international spending in the fiscal year beginning Oct. 1.

Israel has repeatedly alleged that Arafat’s Palestinian Authority is involved in violence against Israelis. Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, who took office last week, has said he will not resume peace negotiations until the Palestinians stop their attacks.

Palestinian schoolgirls enjoy a day at the beach along the coast of Gaza City after Israel began easing travel restrictions. Also yesterday, Palestinian fishermen returned to work for the first time in weeks. LAURENT REBOURS / Associated Press

CP-2001-046 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles, CA

A Personal Portrait of an Uprising

Snapshots, slingshots and other mementos at a West Bank exhibit tell the stories of 100 people killed in the territories by Israelis.

By DAVAN MAHARAJ, TIMES STAFF WRITER

RAMALLAH, West Bank—Some visitors to the Khalil Sakakini Cultural Center here come to see the tan hiking boots once worn by Mohammed Durra, the slain 12-year-old whose picture—showing him cowering beside his father—has become one of the most incendiary images of the 5½-month-old intifada.

Others admire the roughly carved slingshot that 15-year-old Fares Odeh used to fling stones at Israeli tanks—until he took a fatal bullet in the neck. Or the unfinished piece of embroidery that Rahma Hindi, 54, was working on before she was killed by an Israeli missile.

The footwear, slingshot and stitchery are part of an unusual exhibit of photographs and treasured items belonging to the first 100 people killed by Israelis in the ongoing Palestinian uprising against rule by the Jewish state in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

The idea for the memorial exhibit was hatched in October when Palestinians were being killed in clashes almost every day, their identities unknown to the vast majority of their compatriots. Since the uprising broke out at the end of September, about 425 people have been killed, 80% of them Palestinians.

Organizers say the exhibit, funded by the Ford Foundation, is intended to help visitors see the dead as individuals, not mere statistics.

Clipped page, no masthead, no folio, no printed date; date is label-only. 'THE MIDDLE EAST' in the reversed black bar at the top is a SECTION FLAG, not a deck; the deck is the square-bulleted paragraph in column one, 'Snapshots, slingshots and other mementos at a West Bank exhibit tell the stories of 100 people killed in the territories by Israelis.' Note the deck's construction: 'killed in the territories by Israelis' — agency stated plainly, which is rare in this batch. WORTH SHOWING MARIA: this is the densest clipping in Batch D for named Palestinians — nine people named, four of them dead, with ages, objects and a mother. The Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish is reported to keep an office on the second floor of the building. The paper also records the Israeli criticism of the exhibit and gives the Palestinian organiser the reply. The spelling 'Fares Odeh' matches the Columbia Missourian letter on the same slide but the age, 15, does not match its 13, and neither matches the 14 of the Joel Greenberg dispatch on slide 69. Photo caption: 'Curator Samir Salameh places an item on display in Ramallah.' (Associated Press). Column two and most of column three were read at page magnification; column one, the Laidi quotes and the closing paragraphs were transcribed from magnified crops. The printed text sets em dashes closed up without spaces, as transcribed.

CP-2001-053 →

· The New York Times

Palestinians Embarrassed By Closing Of TV Office

By DEBORAH SONTAG

RAMALLAH, West Bank, March 22 — A senior Palestinian official clicked his finger at his nostrils. “We are not just shooting ourselves in the foot,” he said. “We are shooting ourselves in the nose.”

The official was referring to the Palestinian Authority's decision to shut down the West Bank and Gaza bureaus of al Jazeera satellite television station for what were seen by some as insults to Yasir Arafat's dignity.

Al Jazeera is a highly popular pan-Arab station based in Qatar with an avid following in the West Bank and Gaza, where many Palestinians disdain their own news media as unobjective or propagandistic.

“Our office is now under Palestinian closure,” said [illegible] [illegible], al Jazeera's correspondent in the Palestinian territories, referring tongue-in-cheek to the Israeli sealing of Palestinian areas. The stated reason for the closing? Al Jazeera, in its promotional advertisements for a special series on Lebanon, has been playing and replaying some old film from Beirut.

In the film clip, an opponent of Yasir Arafat is holding a poster of Mr. Arafat that is draped by a shoe. The shoe is dangling in the face of the Palestinian leader. “In our culture, showing someone your shoe is an insult,” a Palestinian journalist said. “You never want to sit with your shoe in someone's face.”

The Palestinian officials felt that al Jazeera would not have shown any other Arab leader with a shoe in his face. The Palestinian reaction was not exactly a governmental decision, the official in Ramallah said. Rather, the official said, a senior aide to the Palestinian leader took it upon himself to rush zealously to the defense of Mr. Arafat by shutting down the station.

The official pressed his temples and cringed. “Please don't ask me about this,” he said. Al Jazeera's Lebanon series, which includes an in-depth look at the events surrounding the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982, was impeccably timed for broadcast when Prime Minister Ariel Sharon took office. Mr.

Sharon was the mastermind of the Israeli invasion, and an Israeli inquiry commission found him indirectly responsible for the Sabra and Shatila massacre of Palestinian refugees by Lebanese Christian allies of Israel. But Mr. Sharon's history is entwined with Mr. Arafat's, and the series has also been shining a spotlight on Mr. Arafat's past. And it is Mr.

Arafat, or at least his senior aide, who has ended up peeved. Some believe that the shoe is only part of what offended him, and that he did not like the way he was portrayed in the documentary series, either. Al Jazeera has been beaming images of the Palestinian uprising throughout the Arab world. Its coverage has served to unify the Arabs behind the Palestinian struggle.

Still, the station has needled Palestinian officials as it has Arab officials everywhere because it is not beholden to any government and does not allow itself to be censored. At a recent training course for Palestinian journalists, Marwan Kanafani, a spokesman for Mr. Arafat, lamented the lack of professionalism in the Palestinian news media.

He blamed Palestinian officials for manipulating the news media, and the Palestinian government for the fact that 80 percent of Palestinians get their news from non-Palestinian sources — al Jazeera and “even enemy news sources,” that is, the Arabic-language Israeli news programs.

“Any action which prevents anyone from, or punishes anyone for, speaking out, is more dangerous than the speech itself, regardless of its nature,” Mr. Kanafani said. “A state that cannot tolerate differing opinions, cannot convince the world of its steadfastness on other more dangerous issues.”

Mr. [U/O]man, the Jazeera correspondent, said that the station was asked on Monday to stop playing the commercial because it insulted Mr. Arafat. He said that before al Jazeera officials had a chance to discuss the request, armed security officers visited the bureau and gave them two hours.

On Tuesday and today, Palestinian guards were posted out front to make sure that no transmissions took place. In a telephone interview broadcast on al Jazeera, Hanan Ashrawi, a prominent Palestinian official, said that she regretted the closing of the offices.

“I am trying with many colleagues and others not only to reopen the office but to make sure this doesn't happen again,” she said. Today, al Jazeera moved its operation, at least temporarily, to West Jerusalem so that it could keep broadcasting.

“We have to stop working in Ramallah and Gaza, so we will start working in Israel,” said Wael Abu [illegible], the bureau chief, whose father happens to be Mr. Arafat's human rights adviser.

CP-2001-062 →

· New Haven Register · page A11

Protesters stone Israeli 'tank' in Manhattan

Associated Press

NEW YORK — Demonstrators staged a mock stoning of a cardboard Israeli tank in midtown Manhattan Saturday, as hundreds of Palestinian supporters marched downtown from the Israeli Mission. A huge red banner reading “Free Palestine” led the 28-block march from the Israeli Mission near the United Nations to Union Square.

“We're trying to show that Palestinians are not heard in the media,” said Laura Wiltshire, a 19-year-old college student who was one of two demonstrators hoisting the cardboard tank on her body. Some marchers had labels plastered to their backs that read “Free Palestine,” and others were draped in Palestinian flags.

One protester carried a sign that read “Long live the Intifada.” The tank, made from green cardboard, was flanked by a figure of Uncle Sam walking on stilts. As the two protesters held up the tank, they danced to Arab music coming from a platform where speakers addressed the crowd.

George Habash, former leader of the Palestinian extremist faction, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, was among the speakers. “Allow me to express my eternal gratitude as I salute our people,” he said. “Allow me to bow before our beloved martyrs,” he added, referring to Palestinians who have died in the struggle with Israel.

Edward Said, a Palestinian scholar who addressed the group, said the conflict in the Middle East is not merely between two states. “It's a battle between an imperial colonial occupier — a state armed to the teeth by the United States — and an unarmed defenseless population,” Said told the crowd.

Qusaye Ibn Ibrahim, 19, holds a Palestinian flag during a pro-Palestinian march in New York on Saturday.

CP-2001-061 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israelis Destroy Homes in Gaza Refugee Camps

Joel Greenberg

“The demolition in the refugee camp in Rafah, described by an army spokesman as engineering work, was the latest example of an increasingly common tactic.”

Engineering work. The archive keeps this one for the phrase, and for the detail that the State Department rebuked it the same day.

CP-2001-025 →

· Anchorage Daily News · Anchorage · page 1

Israeli bulldozers strike deep into Gaza

Elizabeth Dalziel, The Associated Press

“Palestinian police and civilians go through the rubble left behind Friday after Israeli bulldozers withdrew from Deir El Balah in the southern Gaza Strip.” Elizabeth Dalziel, The Associated Press.

The photograph and its headline run above the fold; the story itself is not part of this clipping.

CP-2001-003 →

· The Turlock Journal · Turlock

3 Palestinians killed in West Bank protest

Seven words. Three dead, a place, and a protest. Nobody kills them: they are killed in the protest, as though the protest were the thing that did it. This is the sentence shape the archive finds in 1989 and again in 2022.

CP-2001-004 →

· The New York Times

Land and the Intifada

By Yasir Abed Rabbo

RAMALLAH, West Bank — With great precision, an international fact finding committee has identified the principal hindrance to calming the crisis and resuming the Israeli-Palestinian peace talks.

In its report, completed at the end of April, the committee, headed by former United States Senator George Mitchell, declared: “A cessation of Palestinian-Israeli violence will be particularly hard to sustain unless the government of Israel freezes all settlement construction activity.” The implications of this statement are clear.

The intifada, if it is to end, must first be seen for what it is: Palestinian resistance to Israeli military occupation, exemplified by Israel’s continuing confiscation of Palestinian territory and destruction of Palestinian property in order to build and expand illegal settlements.

For Palestinians, the primary goal is the return of our land and the establishment of a viable, contiguous state on a portion of historic Palestine. Continuing Israeli settlement not only makes this goal impossible to attain, it also has caused us to doubt whether the Israeli government really wants peace.

Israel is continuing to colonize the territory from which it is ostensibly negotiating a withdrawal — since the Oslo accords were signed in 1994, the number of Israeli settlers on Palestinian land has increased by nearly 70 percent. As a result, every new brick laid in Israeli settlements is transformed into a stone of Palestinian defiance.

CP-2001-047 →

· The New York Times

Israelis Tell of Army Mistake In Killings of 5 Palestinians

By DEBORAH SONTAG

JERUSALEM, May 17 — An internal Israeli Army investigation has determined that the killing of five Palestinian security men earlier this week was a deadly mistake, Yossi Sarid, the Israeli opposition leader, said today. Mr. Sarid urged the army chief of staff, Lt. Gen.

Shaul Mofaz, to publish the investigation’s findings soon, publicly own up to the error and punish those responsible. He said, “Mofaz is the one to bring such matters to justice, even if it means paying an uncomfortable price.”

Israeli officials said that an intelligence mistake led to the killing of the wrong five Palestinians in an ambush on Monday of a checkpoint in Beituniya in the West Bank. It was a case of “mistaken identity,” said Raanan Gissen, spokesman for Prime Minister Ariel Sharon.

Israeli troops meant to attack members of a different Palestinian security unit, Force 17, whom they held responsible for shootings from that area on an Israeli bypass road, said Uzi Landau, the security minister. But they did not realize that there had been a changing of the guard at the Palestinian checkpoint, Mr. Landau said, speaking during a visit to New York.

So, in the middle of the night, the Israeli troops shot dead five Palestinians who were not implicated in any attacks on Israel. Palestinian officials said that the Israeli premise that the Beituniya guard post was a launching pad for attacks on Israeli cars was false.

Hazem Abu Shamla, captain of the security forces in the area, said there had never been “a single bullet” fired from the post — a tin shack.

CP-2001-048 →

· The New York Times · New York

A Conflict’s Bedrock Is Laid Bare

“Israelis ventured into the West Bank town of Ramallah for its nightlife. They spent Saturdays loading their roof racks with furniture from a West Bank market where Palestinian merchants posted signs in Hebrew and Russian.”

Shipler describes what the boundary was like when it was briefly permeable, which is the only way to show what was lost. The sub-head is Clashing Rights of Return.

CP-2001-026 →

· Fresno Bee · Fresno, CA

Two large obstacles

Settlements, violence aggravate Arab-Israeli stalemate.

After six months of sporadic violence in which 479 Palestinians and 87 Israelis have died, there are faint signs of movement toward serious new efforts to end the bloody stalemate between the two peoples.

But unless there is movement on two key points — ending violence and freezing construction of Jewish settlements in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip — that movement could grind to a halt. An international commission headed by former U.S. Sen.

George Mitchell, formed by mutual agreement to investigate the cause of the Palestinian uprising against the Israeli occupation, has made several recommendations. Key among them is that Israel freeze expansion of 140 settlements where some 200,000 Israeli settlers constitute a permanent source of Palestinian resentment.

While the Israeli government has said it generally accepts the findings of the Mitchell panel (as the Palestinian Authority has done without qualification), it flatly rejects the call to stop expanding settlements. Indeed, Israel’s housing ministry has just approved permits for 713 housing units in two settlements in order to accommodate what it calls “natural growth.”

Yet Palestinians, and Israeli human rights activists, protest that there are hundreds of vacancies in existing settlements. Into this impasse the Bush administration, abandoning a hands-off approach pending steps by the principals to end the violence and resume negotiations, has sent a new special envoy.

But while envoy William Burns is now actively engaged, progress seems unlikely unless both sides take steps to create conditions for renewed talks. On the Palestinian side, that means strenuous efforts by Arafat to rein in militants.

On the Israeli side, it means a pledge to freeze settlement expansion, a step consistent with an offer by the previous Israeli government to end expansion and to dismantle, as part of a final agreement, settlements not immediately adjacent to Israel.

Arafat rejected that offer during U.S.-mediated talks at Camp David last summer, and since then a new, hard-line Israeli government headed by Ariel Sharon, an architect of the settlement policy, has been elected. Sharon has refused to make any concessions, putting all the onus on Arafat, a position supported by a solid majority of Israelis.

But while Israeli anger over renewed Palestinian attacks is justified, Sharon’s harsh military crackdown has only deepened the divide and worsened prospects for new peace talks.

Beyond initial steps to create a less hostile climate, there’s a serious long-standing gap that only Arafat can narrow — between Palestinian leaders’ professed desire to peacefully coexist with Israel and the hateful propaganda, purveyed in Arabic to the population at large and in the schools, that belies that claim.

Any sign that the Palestinian leadership is willing to abandon that duplicitous strategy might reassure Israelis that their neighbors are not still bent on destroying Israel. By the same token, a more forthright Israeli commitment to stop building settlements might yield the same result among Arabs.

Fully legible. No reference to Arab citizens of Israel. Its value is as a clean, countable instance of a paper using “Palestinian” throughout its argument and “Arab” at the two points where it is summarising — the subhead and the closing sentence.

CP-2001-058 →

· The New York Times · New York, NY

Arafat Calls for Cease-Fire, Deploring Tel Aviv Attack

In Response, Israel Urges ‘Deeds,’ but Aide Says Military Will Hold Off Reprisal

By DEBORAH SONTAG

JERUSALEM, June 2 — For the first time since the latest Israeli-Palestinian violence began eight months ago, Yasir Arafat made a public call this afternoon for an immediate and unconditional cease-fire and also condemned the suicide bombing that killed 18 young Israelis outside a Tel Aviv nightclub on Friday night. The Israeli security cabinet responded by urging Mr.

Arafat to follow up his words with “deeds,” such as rearresting immediately the Islamic militants who were released from Palestinian prison last fall and who have undertaken a systematic terrorist campaign that reached a new peak on Friday night with the deadliest attack on Israel in five years The cabinet also issued what the Palestinians heard as a veiled threat of bombardment: “Israel will act to protect the lives of its citizens and will take every necessary step toward this end.”

But a senior Israeli military official, noting that Mr. Arafat’s public statement had the potential to be very significant, said that Israel would hold off on a direct military reprisal against Palestinian Authority targets to give the Palestinian leader time to follow through.

“Maybe this is some kind of turning point that grew unfortunately out of yesterday’s tragedy,” the official said. “The real question, however, is what are the practical measures that Arafat is going to take, and what will be the intensity of the international pressure to do so.” … continue to hold its fire. Speaking in Arabic on television in Ramallah, Mr.

Arafat was submitting to international demands that he finally agree to make a public call for a cease-fire. He read a statement drafted during a heated meeting with Joschka Fischer, the German foreign minister, who had been in Tel Aviv at the time of the blast, and with Terje Rod-Larsen, the United Nations envoy. Glasses on the tip of his nose, Mr.

Arafat told the cameras, “We have exerted and will now exert the utmost efforts to stop the bloodshed of our people and of the Israeli people, and to do all that is needed to achieve an immediate and unconditional, real and effective cease-fire.”

Backed by the American government, the Israelis had been pressing for a statement for months, and especially since Prime Minister Ariel Sharon asked such a call 10 days ago and began a self-imposed policy of military restraint.

Nabil Shaath, a senior Palestinian minister, said international efforts helped “crystallize our ideas” and that the enormity of the bombing also played a role. “It would have been difficult for such a declaration to come from Arafat if it had been 17 Palestinians who were killed,” Mr. Shaath said, not knowing an 18th had died.

“There is a feeling among Palestinians that this was really a tragedy for the Israelis. Remember, though, that it’s not only what we say and do that matters. If the Israelis use firepower now, that will destroy everything.” As Mr.

Arafat spoke, the Israeli security cabinet was huddled in the Defense Ministry in an extraordinary Sabbath session to plan Israel’s response, and hundreds of irate Israelis were gathered outside to demand all-out war. After Mr.

Arafat read his statement in Ramallah, Palestinian journalists fled the Palestinian leader’s compound, fearful that an Israeli reprisal was imminent. The Palestinian Authority ordered all its employees to leave their offices and citizens to stay inside their homes.

Since midnight, diplomats have been pressing Israel to exercise restraint in its military response, fearing that the conflict is on the brink of escalation. In Washington, Secretary of State Colin L. Powell canceled a trip he was to make to Costa Rica on Sunday to watch developments in the Middle East.

So far, Israel is tightening already tight restrictions to prevent all Palestinians, including workers with permits, from entering Israel. And the military may “try again to fight specifically” against individual Islamic militants, the senior military official said. The army has done so previously by using undercover units to abduct or kill them.

This morning, at the beach-front site of the Tel Aviv explosion, the street still bore the stain of dried rivers of blood. It was littered with bone fragments and bits of scalp with hair attached. The acrid smell of burned flesh fouled the air. Street cleaners arrived shortly before noon to try to erase the signs of what had happened. Police helicopters hovered overhead.

A yellow sign in Russian identified the club, which catered to teenagers, as the Dolphi Disco. The club took its name from the former aquarium, the Dolphinarium, that used to occupy the site. The wall held an incongruously cheery mural of fish frolicking in the sea. A small sign promised “ladies” free entrance.

Indeed, 12 victims were teenage girls or young women, including two sisters. The other 6 were young men. All but one were new immigrants from the former Soviet Union. They ranged in age from 14 to 32. Many of them attended the same state high school. Less than a mile from the site, at the morgue, Russian families streamed in and out all morning to identify the dead.

Mothers were collapsing, one after the other, onto the ground outside the building, and paramedics were tending to them. The club sits in southern Tel Aviv near the mixed city of Jaffa.

In the morning, the police cordoned off a nearby mosque where about 30 Muslims were praying because a sizable flag-waving crowd, some of whom were yelling “Death to Arabs!” and “Muhammad is dead!” had gathered outside. By late afternoon, the crowd had grown into an angry mob [one line illegible — see note] the mosque.

In Jaffa, after Jews set fire to a restaurant owned by Israeli Arabs, Arab residents began throwing stones as the police tried to keep the situation from turning into a riot. Many among the scores of people who stood behind the police barriers outside the Dolphi Disco were silent and mournful. Shirley Biton, 47, wept and tried to describe her feelings.

“It is like some divine decree, or curse, has fallen on us,” she said. Avi Elbaz, 58, from the city of Rishon Letzion, said he had forgone his usual Saturday folk dancing to visit the spot. “I came to identify with these boys and girls, these little souls who last night were here and now they’re gone.”

The crowd and their anger built [one line illegible — see note] [surname illegible], a 26-year-old travel agent, held up a sign that said, “Enough passivity. We want war.” “The people should feel the country is doing something,” she said. “Our blood is being spilled and nothing is happening.

I have an 11-month-old baby and I feel I can’t leave my house. I’m willing to spend a month in a shelter so that this problem can be solved once and for all.” Israelis tend to be defiant in the face of terrorism, refusing to be penned into their homes out of fear of attacks on public places. And there is a streak of fatalism at work.

When my time comes, people say, it comes. That, at least, is the public posture. In reality, though, and especially after a bombing of the magnitude of Friday’s, Israeli parents do not want to put their children in harm’s way. And so, even if they move about freely themselves, they encircle the children with restrictions.

No buses, because they are frequent targets. No shopping malls. No visits to relatives in towns that are typically struck, like Netanya. And now no nightclubs. Limor Livnat, the right-wing education minister, said that Israelis “should not cancel all their plans and lock themselves up in their homes.”

But she acknowledged that she suffered intense concern on Friday night until she located her teenage son, who likes to go to the Pacha Club adjacent to the Dolphi Disco. “On a personal level, I calmed down, but on a national one I haven’t,” she said. Israeli officials said that they believed that Mr.

Sharon had changed the momentum of the conflict by initiating the policy of military restraint and causing international pressure on Mr. Arafat to build toward today’s announcement. The senior Israeli military official said Israel was now waiting for Mr. Arafat to give strict no-fire orders and lock up militants.

“The job that Arafat is playing is similar to the zookeeper who opens all the cages of the lions and tigers,” he said, using a comparison that many Palestinians would find objectionable. “He is not personally going to be the predator. The tigers select and attack their prey. But everyone knows who makes it possible for them to do so.”

The right-hand column of the clipping carries the head of a separate, unrelated story (“Sexual Attacks In City Schools Are Up Sharply”, by Edward Wyatt), excluded. Jump line reads “Continued on Page 4”. No “Israeli Arab” vocabulary at all — this is a West Bank/Gaza conflict story and sits outside Maria’s cluster; useful only as a baseline.

CP-2001-054 →

· The New York Times · New York

Police Killings of Israeli Arabs Being Questioned by Inquiry

“A formal inquiry this month into the police killing of 13 people in violent protests by Israeli Arabs in October has raised questions about several of the shootings… Umran Asieh, a cousin, testified that he had seen the chase and a gun pointed at the teenager’s head.”

The Or Commission, into the thirteen killed in October 2000. The testimony is from relatives because thirteen of the people who could have given it are dead. No officer was prosecuted.

CP-2001-035 →

· Fort Worth Star-Telegram · Fort Worth · page 1

In deepest incursion yet, Israeli forces raze Palestinian homes, police station

Jamie Tarabay, AP

DEIR EL BALAH, Gaza Strip — Israeli bulldozers flattened a police station and five homes Friday in the deepest foray into Palestinian territory since field commanders last week were given a free hand to carry out such retaliatory raids.

In Jerusalem, a pipe bomb exploded in a flowerbed on the promenade leading to the Jaffa Gate of the walled Old City, and two Polish tourists were slightly injured, police said… In the past seven days, there have been more than two dozen Israeli incursions into the West Bank and Gaza Strip in which Israeli troops razed 60 homes and hundreds of acres of farmland, Palestinian police said.

Four Palestinians have been killed and dozens wounded in the raids. Palestinians accused Israel of systematically slicing away at the Palestinian areas. “We might now be witnessing the gradual undoing of the peace process,” said Palestinian commentator Ghassan Khatib.

Israeli Defense Minister Binyamin Ben-Eliezer said he had no intention of retaking land handed to the Palestinians in interim peace accords. He said the incursions are short-term and aimed at achieving security goals. The army would not say how many raids it has carried out.

“Palestinians who had been going through the rubble of destroyed homes duck for cover as Israeli soldiers fire in their direction, at Deir El-Balah in the southern Gaza Strip, Friday.

Israeli tanks and a bulldozer made their deepest penetration into Palestinian-controlled territory yet, demolishing a Palestinian police outpost and five houses after a grenade attack on an Israeli military post early Friday.” AP.

Correction: {'note': 'Resolved. The microfilm caption gave 1988-07-21. The clipping names Binyamin Ben-Eliezer as Defense Minister and refers to land handed to the Palestinians in interim peace accords, neither of which was true in 1988. Dated here to 2001-07-21.'}

CP-2001-005 →

· The Times

Young Jewish, Palestinian musicians strive for harmony against backdrop of violence

By The Associated Press

CHICAGO — The orchestra played behind guarded doors. Photographs of the entire group, some of its members there without their government's permission, were strictly prohibited. So were bags and even umbrellas.

With violence escalating in the Middle East, security was tight as a group of young Palestinian and Jewish musicians came to the United States for a public concert, the end of three weeks aimed at building understanding through music. “The first day we played together, you wouldn't believe it.

It was like fragments that are messed up everywhere,” said Claude Chalhoub, a violinist from Beirut, who was the 73-member orchestra's concertmaster.

The tension came from political differences, but also just from trying to unite a diverse group of young musicians — ages 15 to 26, and from nations such as Israel, Lebanon, Jordan and Egypt — many of whom had never played together.

“Now it's just a great piece,” Chalhoub said before the orchestra performed Beethoven's “Eroica” symphony in front of a nearly packed house at Chicago's Orchestra Hall on Tuesday, the night before a funeral for eight Palestinians killed in an Israeli helicopter raid.

The workshop was the third organized by Daniel Barenboim, music director of the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, but the first in the United States. The others were held in Germany. Barenboim, who is Jewish, already has a reputation for trying to use music to heal — and to stir and challenge.

Just days before the young musicians arrived in Chicago, he angered some Jews by leading a German orchestra in a piece by Richard Wagner, Adolf Hitler's favorite composer, at Israel's most prestigious arts festival. No one should be forced to listen to the music, Barenboim said, but “these associations were not created by Wagner, they were created by Hitler.”

Barenboim hopes the annual West-Eastern Divan Workshop — named for German writer Goethe's imaginary dialogue with 14th century Persian poet Hafiz — will evolve into a year-round institute. He said this year's gathering was particularly poignant, given the increase in bloodshed in the Middle East.

The tension was particularly raw during discussions scheduled in the evenings and led by professors from the University of Chicago and Columbia University, he said. “You feel the pain that these kids feel and then you think, ‘My God, it's better not to talk about it,’” Barenboim said. “And then the next day, it is as if the music washes that all away.”

Planning the latest workshop had its share of tension. Without explanation, Egyptian officials canceled a plan to send 23 students from a conservatory in Cairo, though organizers believe it was a comment on recent Israeli attacks on Palestinians. Israel says the attacks are retaliation for Palestinian aggression.

The situation is so tense that some musicians attended the workshop in secret. Orchestra officials asked that they not be photographed or named for fear they would face jail time once they returned home.

The violence, which has left hundreds of Palestinians and Israelis dead since fighting erupted last September, is disheartening to Saleem Abboud-Ashkar, a Palestinian Israeli who attended the workshop. “Sometimes I think I am optimistic only because there is no other option,” the 24-year-old pianist said. “Optimism becomes only a way of survival.”

Abboud-Ashkar led off Tuesday night's concert, performing Mozart's “Concerto for Three Pianos” with Shai Wosner, a 25-year-old Jewish pianist from Israel, and Barenboim. Abboud-Ashkar and Wosner played side-by-side pianos. Rather than politics — or symbolism — the pianists said the moment was about Mozart's composition.

“How can you say one sound belongs to one and the other sound belongs to the other?” he asked. “It's about music from, in this case, 18th century Europe — not an Israeli and a Palestinian.” Audience members, however, took home more than memories of the music.

“It gives hope for the future that people can see beyond a gun,” said Jacie Hachem, a 28-year-old Chicagoan and native of Lebanon who attended the concert. “It helps us see that there are other ways to solve problems.”

Palestinian Israeli pianist Saleem Abboud-Ashkar, left, and Israeli pianist Shai Wosner gather their thoughts backstage at Chicago's Orchestra Hall prior to their performance of Mozart's Concerto for Three Pianos in F Major Tuesday with the West-Eastern Divan Worskshop Orchestra.

Abboud-Ashkar and Wosner joined 71 other young Jewish and Palestinian musicians in Chicago for the three-week intensive workshop, even as violence in many of their homelands was escalating.

The paper's own spelling of Worskshop in the caption is kept.

CP-2001-020 →

· The Register-Guard · Eugene

Palestinian news agency appeals for halt to attacks

JERUSALEM — The official Palestinian news agency called for an end to armed attacks against Israel in a statement published Friday, an unprecedented appeal for restraint in the 10 months of Mideast violence.

The Wafa news agency, which is controlled by Yasser Arafat’s Palestinian Authority and reflects official Palestinian positions, said Palestinians could achieve their goals “only by political means” and “not (by attacks) inside Israel, and not using firearms.”

The Wafa editorial was the strongest statement to date calling for Palestinians to refrain from attacking Israel. While the editorial was presumed to have the approval of the Palestinian leadership, the statement was not issued in Arafat’s name.

It was not clear whether radical Palestinian groups would heed the statement, and hours after the editorial was published, violence broke out. Palestinians fired mortar rounds at a Jewish settlement in the Gaza Strip, slightly injuring a 6-year-old boy, the Israeli army said.

Palestinians have fired hundreds of mortar rounds at Jewish settlements and army posts in Gaza and at Israeli villages just outside the territory. In Tel Aviv, a Palestinian woman tried to carry a bomb into the central bus station, police said, but security guards challenged her and she dropped the bag with the bomb.

Police arrested the woman, cleared the area and defused the device. Also, Palestinian gunmen shot and killed a Palestinian suspected of collaborating with Israel in Bethlehem. Abdullah Abu Alhawa, 56, who was gunned down in a public square, was the fourth suspected collaborator killed by Palestinians this week.

Palestinian children hold real grenades and wear mock explosives during an anti-Israeli demonstration

CP-2001-024 →

· The New York Times · page 20

A Scholarship And a Crisis

Palestinian students look to build a new society and ties with the United States. They may be Bill Clinton’s Middle East legacy.

BY PETER LAGERQUIST

RAMALLAH, West Bank THE Palestinian uprising that erupted last fall put an abrupt end to Bill Clinton’s efforts to secure a foreign policy legacy — a lasting peace in the Middle East. Almost one year later, scores of Israelis and hundreds of Palestinians have been killed, with thousands wounded. … “I was participating in the first intifada.

For one year and a half I was wanted by the Israelis, living on the run. Sometimes I slept under buildings or trees. During the interrogation they tortured me — beatings, they hung me from a pole. I don’t like to speak about it, because it is very private, and it is the past.

But I remember in particular the ‘zinzana,’ a room the size of a box, so small you can’t lie down, where they put me for a week. “The prison was both good and bad, however. We ran a good education program, which helped me when I went to university.

Some of the books came from the Red Cross, others the prisoners smuggled in without the knowledge of the army. Some materials the prisoners themselves wrote. I read art, economics, psychology, sociology.

Raed Awashreh, 31, was arrested by the Israeli Army during the first Palestinian uprising, from 1987 to 1993, and released after three years in military detention camps.

After the establishment of the Palestinian Authority, he joined a high school refresher course for former detainees, which allowed him to enroll in 1995 in Bir Zeit, the premier Palestinian university, located just outside Ramallah. With a major in business administration and minor in journalism, he went on to work as a journalist and researcher. Mr.

Awashreh, who would like to teach, will study public administration this fall at the Monterey Institute of International Studies in California, where he is taking a class this summer in English as a second language.

CP-2001-051 →

· The Herald Sun

Uprising undermines Arab-Jew experiment

Potential enemies live together in Israel's Neve Shalom, but tensions from the conflict seep in

By JASON KEYSER, Associated Press

NEVE SHALOM, Israel — A nearly 30-year experiment by Arabs and Jews in living side by side in this hilltop village is being tested by the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians. Neve Shalom, also known by its Arabic name, Wahat al-Salam, means “Oasis of Peace.”

That's something becoming difficult to find in Israel as the divide between Jew and Arab grows wider due to the uprising in the Palestinian territories. It's a sobering turn for the 40 Arab and Jewish families who came to live on the hilltop of small eucalyptus trees in an idealistic demonstration of coexistence.

AP staff feature. Vocabulary: 'Arabs and Jews', 'Arab and Jewish families', with 'Palestinians' and 'the Palestinian territories' reserved for outside the Green Line. One ordinary person named and quoted at length: Ahmad Hijazi, 34. His complaint - that Hebrew dominates and the Education Ministry curriculum emphasises Jewish history - is the 2001 version of the Arabic-language grievance the 2018 group will report as law.

CP-2001-057 →

· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis · page 1

The United Nations: Back to Orwellianism

From the Desk Of

By Robert A. Cohn, Editor-in-Chief/Publisher

“Once again, after a few years of relatively balanced treatment of the State of Israel and other Jewish concerns, the anti-Israel, anti-Jewish and pro-Arab/Islamic majority at the United Nations has returned to its familiar Orwellianism… the infamous libel that ‘Zionism is racism’ has reared its ugly head in statements by the so-called ‘moderate’ leaders of Iran, who have urged its readoption at the upcoming United Nations World Conference on Racism.… The resolution remained on the official U.N. books until it was rescinded in 1991 at the urging of then President George H.W.

Bush, who said the resolution ‘mocks the principles upon which the U.N. was founded.’… Chaim Herzog came to the lectern to publicly rip to shreds a copy of the resolution which ranks alongside the Protocols of the Elders of Zion and the anti-Jewish blood libels of history as among the most vicious anti-Semitic actions of all time.… The infamous ‘Zionism is Racism’ resolution belongs on the ash-heap and in the dustbin of history.”

The page this runs on is an argument with itself. The column is illustrated by a cartoon of the cover of Orwell’s 1984 in which the Party slogans read WAR IS PEACE, FREEDOM IS SLAVERY, IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH and ZIONISM IS RACISM. Directly beneath it the paper prints a letter from Hedy Epstein, who grew up in Nazi Germany, objecting to the paper’s own repeated hook-nosed caricatures of Yasser Arafat and comparing them to Der Stuermer. The editor answers in two lines: your point is well-taken, we will attempt to be more respectful in our future cartoons.

CP-2001-009 →

· Ithaca Journal · Ithaca · page 1

Why the United Nations is tackling racism

By Sheryl McCarthy and Adrian Peracchio, Newsday

“The delegates haven’t even arrived in Durban, and already a huge slugfest is in progress over what subjects should or should not be discussed. The Europeans are demanding that there be no discussion of the compensation against gypsies… The Indians insist on avoiding talk about the caste system… Portugal, Spain, France and Great Britain want to derail any talk about reparations for colonial oppression… And the United States government is threatening to boycott the conference unless it receives assurances that there’ll be no talk about reparations for slavery or revived efforts to equate Zionism with racism.… ‘Zionism as racism is ridiculous, but the government delegation should show up and register its opposition, rather than pout and stay at home’… [And, against:] ‘it took several days of incessant bickering during the drafting of the agenda in Geneva to decide whether ‘Holocaust’ should be capitalized in reference to the Nazi extermination of Jews.

But that’s probably tied into the most blatantly discriminatory of the agenda items, the one that equates Zionism with racism. That hateful canard, which keeps resurfacing at the United Nations whenever the Israeli-Palestinian conflict grows more bitter, is in direct contradiction of another agenda item that condemns anti-Semitism directed at Jews.

Go figure.’”

Two syndicated columnists set against each other on the same page a fortnight before Durban opens, one arguing the United States should attend and object, the other that the conference is doomed by the length of its own agenda. Both take it as given that the formula is the thing that will wreck it.

CP-2001-010 →

· Star Tribune · Minneapolis · page A5

Body count climbs in day of heated Mideast violence

A Palestinian man and his children were among those killed when their home was shelled; the Israeli army denied responsibility.

New York Times

JERUSALEM — On a day of intense violence in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, a Palestinian man and his two small children were killed Sunday night when their house was shelled in Rafah, along Gaza’s border with Egypt. How they died was in sharp dispute early today.

Palestinian security officials in Rafah said that the Israeli army had aimed two missiles at the house of Samir Abu Zaid, a member of a group called the Popular Resistance Committees. Abu Zaid, 32, was killed, along with his son, Salman, 7, and his daughter, Alaa, 3. The Israeli army denied responsibility.

It said that Palestinians in Rafah had fired mortar rounds at an Israeli position but missed, hitting the Abu Zaid house instead. The deaths added to a body count that had climbed earlier Sunday, overshadowing a new flicker of hope for resumed talks on an Israeli-Palestinian truce.

The day was studded with violence, including clashes in Rafah in which a 14-year-old Palestinian boy, Muhammad Abu Arrar, was killed by Israeli soldiers. In Nablus, in the West Bank, Israeli forces shot and killed a man said to have belonged to the Fatah faction of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat. There was also renewed fighting in the West Bank city of Hebron.

And Palestinians fired mortar rounds at Israeli settlements in southern Gaza, prompting the army to respond with missiles that damaged a Palestinian security post near Khan Yunis. Also killed Sunday was an unarmed Palestinian man who was shot by Israeli soldiers as he tried to walk around an army checkpoint near Nablus.

Relatives said the man, Muin Abu Lawi, 38, was returning to his village with school supplies that he had bought for his children. An army spokeswoman said the incident was being investigated. Israel has said that a number of bombing attacks have been launched from Nablus, and it has tightened its security cordon around the town.

Previously, only the main paved roads were blocked, but in recent days soldiers have also cut off dirt paths leading in and out of Nablus and other West Bank cities. Through it all, officials on both sides talked hesitantly about the possibility of sitting down to figure out how to make a cease-fire work.

Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres said he was in contact with Palestinian officials for that purpose. Palestinian leaders had a mixed response to his overtures. “What Mr. Peres is saying is just a trick, another game to cover the policy of assassinations and attacks against the Palestinian people,” said Yasser Abed Rabbo, the Palestinian information minister.

However, another Palestinian minister, Nabil Shaath, said he saw no problem in talking. Foreign diplomats have been encouraging such a dialogue, he added. In theory, a truce is in place, arranged in mid-June by George Tenet, the CIA director. But it has never taken root, and the Israelis and Palestinians are, if anything, further apart than they were two months ago.

Relatives carried the body of 14-year-old Palestinian Muhammad Abu Arrar, who was killed by Israeli troops in Rafah.

Five Palestinians are named in this dispatch and four of their ages are given, the youngest three years old. The headline over all of it is an arithmetic. The line beneath the headline puts a man and his children and the army’s denial into one sentence, and six days later the paper would print a reader’s complaint that even that was too definite.

CP-2001-016 →

· The Register-Guard · Eugene · page 10A

Palestinian father, children killed

By The New York Times

JERUSALEM — On a day of intense violence in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, a Palestinian man and his two small children were killed on Sunday night when their house was shelled in Rafah, along Gaza’s border with Egypt. It was not possible early today to reconcile the differing versions.

Either way, the deaths added to a body count that had climbed earlier Sunday, overshadowing a new flicker of hope for resumed talks on an Israeli-Palestinian truce. The army said in a statement that Palestinians in Rafah had fired at an Israeli position but missed their target, hitting the Abu Zaid house instead.

Also killed on Sunday was an unarmed Palestinian man shot by Israeli soldiers as he tried to walk around an army checkpoint near Nablus. There was also renewed fighting in the West Bank city of Hebron. And Palestinians fired mortar rounds at Israeli settlements in southern Gaza.

The same New York Times dispatch, the same Monday, on page 10A in Eugene, Oregon. Three words of headline and the people in it are a father and his children. Minneapolis ran the arithmetic. Nothing in the copy made the difference; the difference was made at the paper.

CP-2001-017 →

· Star Tribune · Minneapolis

Headline downplays dispute over how 3 Palestinians died

If you ran the newspaper

Lou Gelfand

The caller, an advocate for Israel, said the second deck of a Monday headline was incomplete and, as a result, inaccurate. It said: “A Palestinian man and his children were among those killed when their home was shelled; the Israeli army denied responsibility.” The headline accurately echoed the opening paragraph of the New York Times News Service article.

But the basis of the complaint emerged from the next three paragraphs: “How they died was in sharp dispute early today. “Palestinian security officials in Rafah said that the Israeli army had aimed two missiles at the house” of Samir Abu Zaid, a member of the Popular Resistance Committee and he was killed, along with his son, 7, and daughter, 3.”

“The Israeli army denied responsibility. It said that Palestinians in Rafah had fired mortar rounds at an Israeli position but missed, hitting the Abu Zaid house instead.” The caller said that since how they died was in dispute, the headline should have begun: “Palestinians say...”

Comment: The headline needed to underscore the dispute over who was responsible for the shelling.

A newspaper auditing its own headline about three dead Palestinians, in print, under a standing head that asks the reader to imagine running the paper. What the reader’s representative accepts is that the headline was not doubtful enough. Nobody in the column raises the main headline over the same story, which was Body count climbs in day of heated Mideast violence. The next item in the column is about a photograph of a two-year-old holding a latex balloon.

CP-2001-018 →

· The New York Times

A Perilous Road in Israel Becomes a Death Trap Again

By CLYDE HABERMAN

MODIIN, Israel, Aug. 26 — Route 443 makes it an easy drive here from Jerusalem, 15 miles to the east. But for Israelis, the question is whether they will make it at all. Too many of them have not. The Modiin road, as Route 443 is sometimes called, winds through brown hills of jutting rock.

It is mostly smooth and dependable, and it takes maybe 15 minutes to get from Jerusalem’s northern outskirts to this growing town grazing the southwestern lip of the West Bank. It can be a pleasant shortcut for anyone heading to Tel Aviv, along the Mediterranean coast. For Israelis, it has become a death road. A stretch of Route 443 slices through the West Bank.

In the Israeli-Palestinian conflict of the last 11 months, it has become a fine target for Palestinian gunmen, who can lie in ambush, wait for an Israeli car, fire away and dissolve into nearby villages. At least half a dozen Israelis have been killed on this road, a number that grew late Saturday night when Palestinians shot at a car carrying five members of the same family.

Two died right away, a husband and wife, Yaniv and Sharon Ben-Shalom. Mrs. Ben-Shalom’s brother, Doron Sviri, shot in the head, died today as the young couple were being buried. Their two little girls, Shahar and Efrat, ages 6 months and 18 months, were slightly wounded. The deaths contributed to one of the grislier weekends in this unending crisis.

It also saw three Israeli soldiers killed on Saturday during a daring raid by two Palestinians on an army base near a bloc of settlements in the Gaza Strip. The two attackers were themselves killed.

Overnight, in retaliation, Israeli F-16 planes and tanks demolished police headquarters in four Palestinian towns, actions that were largely casualty-free, aimed as they were at evacuated buildings, but that led nonetheless to the death of a Palestinian security officer in Gaza. The staccato of violence continued through today.

An unidentified Israeli man from the coastal town of Netanya was shot to death on a little-traveled road north of Tulkarm in the West Bank. The same group that said it had fired on the Ben-Shalom family, the Aksa Martyrs Brigade, took responsibility for today’s attack as well.

Officer Gil Oz was buried yesterday in Tel Aviv. He was one of six Israelis killed in a weekend of violence.

CP-2001-049 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinians Reclaim Their Town After Israelis Withdraw

By CLYDE HABERMAN

Clyde Haberman, 31 August 2001, eleven days before the attacks that reframed all American coverage of the region.

CP-2001-038 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Separate and Unequal on the West Bank

By Amira Hass

RAMALLAH, West Bank From my living room window in Ramallah, a Palestinian city, I see the lights of the Israeli settlement Pesagot on the opposite mountain. Across the eastern road of my neighborhood, there is an Israeli military base, protecting another settlement, Beit El.

Had I wanted, as an Israeli Jew, born in West Jerusalem, I could have moved at any moment to any of these settlements. My Palestinian next-door neighbors in Ramallah, whose grandparents were born in what is now Israel, could not even think of moving to, say, Tel Aviv.

There is no way to understand the current Palestinian uprising without examining the moral, economic and social reality that Israeli settlement policy has created in the last 34 years.

Since the 1967 war, Israeli governments — both Labor and Likud — have built settlements all over the occupied West Bank and the small Gaza Strip, in the midst of Arab-Palestinian communities that are centuries old. About 390,000 settlers now live in the West Bank (including East Jerusalem) and in Gaza.

The construction and development of these outposts have essentially allowed Israel to create the infrastructure of one state, stretching from the Mediterranean to the Jordan River.

Israel’s governments have determined the overall character of these lands and the fate of their people while the three million Palestinians who live there and have paid taxes to Israel’s Treasury could not vote for these governments. Yet Israeli Jews in the settlements have the right to vote.

A network of large, well-maintained roads now connects Israeli outposts — even the smallest and most remote ones — to Israel proper. While Israelis can at any time move to the West Bank or Gaza, Palestinians are not allowed to live legally in an Israeli city or settlement, even if this settlement is built upon their family land.

From the river to the sea, within the contours of what is now de facto one state governed by Israel, live some 4 million Palestinians. These people are classified in three different categories: One million of them are Israeli citizens, who live within Israel’s 1967 borders and who have the right to vote.

Some 200,000 Palestinians are residents of East Jerusalem, which was annexed to Israel’s West Jerusalem in 1967.

Date check: No masthead, page folio or printed date line appears on this clipping — it is trimmed to the article itself, which begins at the headline. Nothing on the clipping confirms or contradicts 2001-09-02, and nothing on it names the newspaper either; the only internal dateline is the standing place line “RAMALLAH, West Bank”, which carries no date.

CP-2001-040 →

· Arizona Daily Sun · page 1

Rights forum equates Zionism with racism

By Chris Tomlinson, Associated Press, Durban

“The forum’s document brands ‘Israel as a racist apartheid state’ and calls for an end to the ‘ongoing, Israeli systematic perpetration of racist crimes, including war crimes, acts of genocide and ethnic cleansing.’… Shimon Peres said the gathering ‘is an outburst of hate and of anti-Semitism.’

‘It appears like a camp that has neither understanding nor tolerance nor a message for the future.’ Shawqi Issa, spokesman for the Arab caucus at the forum, thought the document was ‘a very good one.’ ‘It’s just facts. The Israeli government is a racist government . . . and the Israeli government is an apartheid government.

These are facts, and we can prove it,’ he said. Mary Robinson… said she regretted the language equating Zionism with racism.

Palestinians have the right to protest what they believe to be their victimization, but ‘it is not appropriate that text emerged that revictimizes and is hurtful in itself,’ said Robinson. ‘Israel has committed serious crimes against the Palestinian people, but it is simply not accurate to use the word genocide and wrong to equate Zionism with racism,’ said Reed Brody, the New York-based group’s advocacy director… Black U.S. lawmakers attending the conference expressed disappointment Sunday that criticism of Israel has overshadowed efforts to raise the question of reparations to Africa and African-Americans for slavery and colonialism.”

The jump page of the same dispatch, carrying everything the front page did not have room for: the Palestinian who says it is a statement of fact, the human rights director who says it is inaccurate, the UN commissioner who regrets it, and the American congressional delegation watching a conference about slavery reparations get taken over.

CP-2001-011 →

· The Tribune · page 1

Rights forum equates Zionism with racism

Occupation of Palestine decried as colonialism

By Chris Tomlinson, Associated Press, Durban

DURBAN, South Africa — Pro-Palestinian groups scored a victory Sunday when a human rights forum coinciding with the World Conference Against Racism equated Zionism with racism and called for international sanctions against Israel. But Jewish, Christian and international human rights groups rejected the forum’s final resolution, which was presented to U.N.

High Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson to be included in a final declaration by the U.N. conference… Israel’s occupation of Palestinian territories was also decried as colonialism, a potent political label in much of the world.

The forum brought together 166 non-governmental rights groups from around the world… The forum also recommended that the United Nations reinstate a resolution equating Zionism with racism, the establishment of a U.N. committee to prosecute Israeli war crimes and the complete isolation of Israel as an apartheid state.

Israeli Foreign Minister Mordechai Yedid speaks at a news conference at the World Conference Against Racism in Durban, South Africa, on Sunday.

Ten years after the repeal, a parallel forum of 166 organizations votes to put the resolution back. The caption calls Mordechai Yedid Israel’s foreign minister; he was the head of its delegation.

CP-2001-012 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Arab’s Suicide Bomb Points to Enemy Within

8 Dead, Scores Hurt; A Nation Horrified

By JAMES BENNET

James Bennet, from Nahariya. The clause is the reason the attack is reported as a turn rather than another bombing — and note the form the Times reaches for when the sentence has to be exact: not Israeli Arab, but Arab citizen of Israel.

CP-2001-036 →

· Palm Beach Jewish Star Times · the rail carries only the edition code “PB” and the web address; no city is printed · page 11

Israeli statement made at World Conference

…freedom in their land, was intrinsically bound up with the belief that not just one people but rather all peoples must be free. It was this conviction that Theodor Herzl, the founder of the Zionist movement, expressed in his book Altneuland, as early as 1902. He wrote: “There is still one problem of racial misfortune unsolved.

The depths of that problem only a Jew can comprehend. I refer to the problem of the Blacks. Just call to mind all those terrible episodes of the slave trade, of human beings who merely because they were black were stolen like cattle,taken prisoners, captured and sold.

Their children grew up in strange lands,the objects of contempt and hostility because their complexions were different. I am not ashamed to say, though I may expose myself to ridicule for saying so, that once I have witnessed the redemption of Israel, my people, I wish to assist the redemption of the Black people.”

As Herzl understood, remembrance of slavery is integral to the Jewish experience. A Jew cannot be truly free if he or she does not have compassion for those who are enslaved. Madame Chairperson, If slavery is one form of racist atrocity, anti-Semitism is another. And by anti-Semitism, let us be clear, we mean the hatred of Jews.

The word “anti-Semitism” was deliberately coined in 1879 by Wilhelm Marr, an anti-Jewish racist in Germany, to replace the term “judenhass” or Jew-hatred,which had gone out of favor. It has always and only been used to describe hatred and discrimination directed at Jews.

Attempts to eradicate the plain meaning of the word are not only anti-Semitic, indeed they are anti-semantic.

This clipping is the one in Batch E whose publication I would not ingest without Maria or Eva ruling on it. Everything else about it is readable and transcribed.

CP-2001-055 →

· The Spokesman-Review · page A12

Palestinians take to streets by thousands

Three killed, many wounded in clashes with Israeli troops

By Jamie Tarabay

JERUSALEM — Tens of thousands of Palestinians marched in the West Bank and Gaza Strip on Saturday in support of their uprising against Israel. Three Palestinians were killed and dozens wounded in confrontations with Israeli troops. The renewed fighting raised doubts about prospects for a truce sought by the United States.

Each side accused the other of breaking promises made this past week in cease-fire talks, including a meeting of senior security commanders Friday. The Palestinians said Israel hadn’t started pulling back troops as promised and had used excessive force. Israel said the Palestinians hadn’t made a serious effort to stop violent protests.

More security talks were scheduled for today, but both sides said expectations were low. Israel TV said Israel’s Cabinet would decide today whether to permit Foreign Minister Shimon Peres to meet with Palestinian negotiators later in the day to continue truce talks. The United States wants an end to the fighting, which began a second year Saturday.

Washington sees the conflict as an impediment to its effort to win Arab and Muslim support for possible military action against Islamic extremists suspected in the Sept. 11 terror attacks.

It was not clear whether the latest violence would cool after the Palestinians’ commemorations of their uprising’s anniversary, or whether Saturday’s protests signaled strong popular opposition to a truce. In the past, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat has been reluctant to go against the public mood in Palestinian areas.

But in the past two weeks he has gone out of his way to be seen as supportive of U.S. policy. There have been signs of open dissent among Palestinians. On Friday, about 150 protesters opposed to a cease-fire threw stones and firebombs at an empty Palestinian police station in Gaza’s Rafah refugee camp, a persistent trouble spot.

In some areas, Palestinian policemen tried to contain protests, though in other cases they did not interfere. Saturday morning, hundreds of young Palestinians, many still carrying school bags, threw stones at three Israeli army posts in the Gaza Strip.

The army said the rioters also hurled firebombs, but an Associated Press reporter who witnessed clashes at the Netzarim Junction and the Erez Industrial Park did not see firebombs. Israeli troops fired tear gas and bullets at the stone-throwers, killing a 14- and 17-year-old, said Moawiya Hassanein, director of Shifa Hospital in Gaza City.

Sixty-nine Palestinians, ages 13 to 20, were wounded, including 10 in critical condition, Hassanein said.

A wounded Palestinian boy is carried to an ambulance during clashes with Israeli forces near the Jewish settlement of Netzarim, southern Gaza Strip on Saturday.

CP-2001-063 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinians Attack Israeli Settlement

Gunmen Kill 2 and Wound 15 in Hard Blow to Shaky Cease-Fire

James Bennet

“Two Palestinian gunmen attacked this Israeli settlement at the northern edge of the Gaza Strip on Tuesday night, killing a young couple and wounding 15 others.”

Kept because the archive is not a brief. Alei Sinai, three weeks after 11 September, with the settlement named and the dead counted.

CP-2001-027 →

· Albuquerque Tribune · Albuquerque, N.M. · page A10

Arab citizens of Israel show signs of increasing alienation

THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

UMM EL-FAHM, Israel — Arab Israeli Hassan Asleh was the guest of honor at a rally by Islamic fundamentalists, a Palestinian flag draped around his neck as a crowd of 50,000 chanted it would fight Israel in defense of Muslim holy places. Asleh once would have stayed away from such a scene; he was a firm believer in Arab-Jewish reconciliation.

But a year ago, 13 Arab Israelis, including Asleh's peace activist son, were shot dead by Israeli police trying to quell protests in Arab towns. At the time, demonstrators were pouring into the streets in an outburst of solidarity with the Palestinian uprising in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Arab Israelis await with anticipation the report of a commission investigating the police killings of last October, including the death of 17-year-old Asel Asleh who his family maintains was shot by police at close range. Hassin Asleh, 52, said he hopes for a measure of justice, but his son's death has hardened the grocer, a former champion of Arab-Jewish coexistence.

At a Sept. 14 rally by the Islamic Movement, Asleh sat in the front row, with a picture of his son leaning against his leg. Asleh said that no matter what the outcome of the investigation into the killings, his fate will always be tied to Israel. “This is our country,” Asleh said. “We don't have any place else to go.”

AP staff copy, unbylined. Vocabulary: 'Arab citizens of Israel' in the headline, 'Arab Israeli(s)' throughout the body, 'Palestinians' reserved for the West Bank and Gaza - except in Jaber's quote, where a citizen of Israel calls Palestinians his nation. Two ordinary people named, father and son.

CP-2001-056 →

· Columbia Missourian · Columbia, MO

Comparison with Israel is misguided

From EDWARD R. MOAD, Columbia

Unfortunately, our recovery, as Americans, from the horrific attacks on Sept. 11 has been marred by a small but vocal chorus of "see, I told you so" from Israel and its supporters in our country. Their premise is that the attack on the Twin Towers is "just like what Israelis have to live with every day." We are supposed to have something in common with them. They are wrong.

The magnitude of the Sept. 11 attacks was incomparable to Palestinians' acts of resistance against the illegal Israeli occupation. Also, the Sept. 11 attack was unprovoked. The Israelis, by contrast, have killed more than 600 Palestinians (nearly five times the number of Israelis killed) in just the last year in order to preserve their occupation.

One-quarter of these have been children, like Fares Odeh, a 13-year-old boy who was hunted down and shot through the throat for throwing rocks at Israeli tanks. Americans don't do that.

But the most important difference of all between America and Israel is that in America, great efforts have been made to protect innocent Muslim and Arab-Americans from misguided retaliations, harrassment and blame by association.

But if America were like Israel, our government would be demolishing whole neighborhoods of Arab homes and businesses as a form of "collective punishment" and arming and abetting vigilante groups to inflict violence against them. No. America is nothing like Israel. Thank God.

A READER LETTER, not staff or wire copy. The credit line 'From EDWARD R. MOAD, Columbia' is the letters-page form; it is recorded in byline because the form requires a byline field, but this is not a journalist. No masthead, no folio, no printed date; date is label-only. There is no deck. THIS IS THE SHARPEST LANGUAGE IN THE WHOLE BATCH and it does not come from a reporter. It is the only item in Batch D that uses 'illegal Israeli occupation', 'collective punishment', 'acts of resistance', and the only one that frames house demolition as something a government does to a people rather than a security measure. Everything comparably direct elsewhere in the batch is inside quotation marks attributed to someone else; here the paper printed it as the writer's own argument. SPELLING AS PRINTED: 'harrassment' with a double r is the paper's error and is kept. The letter prints 'Fares Odeh, a 13-year-old'; the Salt Lake Tribune on slide 70 calls the same boy 'Faris Odeh' and a few weeks short of 15, and the Los Angeles Times on this same slide calls him '15-year-old Fares Odeh'. Flag for Eva: the age and the spelling cannot both be right across these records, and this archive should not quietly harmonise them.

CP-2001-052 →

· The Journal Times · page 3A

Car blast kills 3 Palestinians; 3 more killed in West Bank battles

BY KARIN LAUB

JERUSALEM — A top Palestinian militia leader and two of his fighters were killed Thursday in the West Bank by an explosion that their colleagues blamed on Israel. The blast came only hours after Prime Minister Ariel Sharon threatened retaliation for the assassination of an Israeli Cabinet minister.

Elsewhere in the West Bank, Israeli tanks seized outlying neighborhoods of two Palestinian towns. The incursions triggered gun battles, and doctors said three Palestinians were killed, including a 12-year-old girl hit by Israeli fire at her school. After nightfall, Palestinians opened fire on a car in the West Bank between Jerusalem and Jericho.

An Israeli who was critically wounded died at the scene, rescue workers said. Two others were wounded. The burst of violence threatened Washington’s efforts to retain Arab and Muslim support for U.S. military action against Islamic militants suspected of having masterminded the Sept. 11 terror attacks on New York and Washington.

The United States is courting moderate Arab states and fears Israel-Palestinian violence could interfere. After Wednesday’s killing of Israeli Tourism Minister Rehavam Zeevi, Israel demanded that Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat arrest and hand over the assassins and outlaw militant groups.

Israel’s police minister, Uzi Landau, said Israeli investigators knew the names of the killers. Israeli media linked an Israel police sweep in a West Bank suburb of Jerusalem to the Zeevi killing. Zeevi, a retired general, advocated the expulsion of Palestinians from the West Bank and Gaza.

Israel hinted it would launch an all-out attack on the Palestinian Authority if its demands were not met. In Washington, the State Department urged Israel to exercise restraint in response to the shooting death of Zeevi. Otherwise, deputy spokesman Philip Reeker said, Israel would be letting terrorists derail recent steps toward peace with the Palestinians.

But Reeker offered no support to Israel’s insistence it has a right to try Palestinian suspects in Zeevi’s death. Jurisdiction in the case is for Israel and Arafat’s Palestinian authorities to work out, he said.

Palestinian security forces on Thursday arrested 11 members of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, the PLO faction that claimed responsibility for killing Zeevi, officials said. It was not clear whether any of those in custody, eight in the Gaza Strip and three in the West Bank town of Ramallah, had direct links to the killers.

Several of those detained were leaders of the PFLP’s political wing, the security officials said. Palestinian officials said they would try to find and punish the killers, but would not hand them to Israel. “We do not receive our orders or directions from Sharon and his government,” said Palestinian Information Minister Yasser Abed Rabbo.

A Palestinian woman argues with Israeli soldiers atop an armored vehicle Thursday as she tries to persuade them to let her enter the West Bank town of Jenin.

CP-2001-064 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Raid in Bethlehem Leaves 3 Dead

“Israel invaded Bethlehem yesterday for the first time in the current conflict. Palestinians with guns and slingshots responded.”

Israeli Raid in Bethlehem Leaves 3 Dead

Thirty-one words and a page reference. Slingshots, in a sentence about an invasion, in the front-page summary box.

CP-2001-028 →

· The Jonesboro Sun · Jonesboro

Israelis tighten grip on Palestinian towns

“Israeli tanks moved deeper into the West Bank on Sunday, tightening their grip on Bethlehem and five other towns in the widest operation against the Palestinians in years. Four Palestinians — among them a 16-year-old — were killed Sunday.”

Mark Lavie for the AP, in Jonesboro, Arkansas, six weeks after 11 September. The photograph is of an Israeli soldier on an armoured personnel carrier beside a road sign reading Kfar Sava in Hebrew and Arabic, and the caption names the town being surrounded: Qalqilya — the same town four American papers called Jordan in 1956. The archive dated this clipping 27 October; the masthead says Monday, 22 October 2001, and that was a Monday.

CP-2001-037 →

· The New York Times · New York · page A14

Israelis Storm Village in the West Bank

Attack Comes After Bush Urged Withdrawal; at Least 5 Are Killed

By JAMES BENNET

HALAMISH JUNCTION, West Bank, Oct. 24 — Hours after President Bush appealed for an Israeli withdrawal from Palestinian territory, Israeli troops stormed into another West Bank village early this morning, killing at least 5 Palestinians and arresting 11 more, including two men the Israelis said helped kill a cabinet minister last week.

Palestinian leaders accused the Israeli government of inventing a link to the minister’s killing to cover up what they called a “massacre” of not 5 but at least 10 people in the village. Israeli troops did not permit journalists, Palestinian ambulances, or the Red Cross into the village today, saying the military operation was still under way. There were no Israeli casualties.

The raid on the Palestinian town, Beit Rima, brought to seven the number of villages and cities in which Israeli troops have captured positions in an operation begun a week ago, after the killing of the tourism minister, Rehavam Zeevi, Israel’s senior right-wing leader. “We were terrified,” said Abdul Salam Rimawi, a resident of the village, by telephone from his home tonight.

“It was a horrible situation, where you hear bullets coming from all directions.” Mr. Rimawi, a journalist, said he and his brother, Jamal, covered their children with their bodies. After pounding on the door of his house, soldiers with blackened faces took away Jamal at gunpoint, Mr. Rimawi said.

He said that his brother was a nurse in Jerusalem and that he was baffled by his arrest. Mr. Rimawi said that late tonight tanks were still rumbling through the village, and helicopters were circling overhead.

Israeli troops marched back to their base yesterday after a raid on the West Bank village of Beit Rima. The Israelis said 5 Arabs were killed; Palestinians put the number at 10 or more. [credit: Agence France-Presse]

CP-2001-042 →

· The New York Times · New York

Restraint Used in Bethlehem, Israeli Major Says

By JAMES BENNET

BETHLEHEM, West Bank, Oct. 24 — With the Paradise Hotel burning a few blocks away and gunfire resounding around the Israeli position there, Maj. Kobi Katz unfolded a large black-and-white aerial photograph of Bethlehem on the concrete floor of an army outpost here this morning.

He jabbed a finger at buildings circled in red — the schools, churches, mosques and monasteries of this storied city, which is now a war zone. “Honestly, I’m the father of a child,” Major Katz said. “The orders are very clear. We don’t shoot at these positions.”

During a visit to the outpost — a small Palestinian apartment building whose top floor has been hung with camouflage netting, reinforced with sandbags and armed with three machine guns and a box of grenades — two or three bullets smacked into the outer walls. The bullets, the soldiers said, were fired from a nearby mosque.

Gesturing at an Israeli sniper who was lying on sandbags as he gazed through a rifle scope toward the mosque, Major Katz said, “The snipers here can see the barrel of the gun, day and night, but we don’t shoot.”

Which raised a question — one of many by Israeli critics from both the right and the left — about the goals of the incursions into at least seven Palestinian cities and villages since the killing of an Israeli minister on Oct. 17. If the Israelis were not firing back at such gunmen, what was the point of conducting the operation in the first place?

“It’s very problematic,” Major Katz said wearily. “Without going into details, it’s very difficult, because we’re very limited.” As the deputy battalion commander, Major Katz is the No. 2 man in the operation here.

The Israeli Army brought four foreign journalists, one of them an American, to see an outpost here, apparently in an effort to counter impressions that it was recklessly endangering Palestinian civilians.

[upper photograph] Palestinian gunmen drank tea during a break in shooting toward Israeli positions yesterday in the West Bank town of Bethlehem.

Israeli troops and the Palestinians have engaged in gun battles in the town for six days. [credit: Associated Press] —— [lower photograph] The Paradise Hotel on the outskirts of Bethlehem was set on fire yesterday during fierce fighting between Israelis and Palestinians. [credit: Reuters]

CP-2001-043 →

· Madison Daily Leader · Madison · page 1

Mahmoud Darwish

The Associated Press, New York

NEW YORK (AP) — Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish and Columbia University professor Edward Said, an outspoken advocate for the Palestinian cause, have won awards from the Lannan Foundation. Darwish, who writes in Arabic, will receive the foundation’s $350,000 award for cultural freedom.

Said, a prominent literary scholar and a former adviser to Yasser Arafat, will receive the foundation’s $200,000 literary award for lifetime achievement. The foundation, based in Santa Fe, N.M., announced the awards Thursday through David Lerner, a spokesman in New York. The award to Said is the first by the foundation for a work of nonfiction.

The lifetime achievement award, which honors writers who have made significant contributions to English-language literature, is the largest monetary prize for literary achievement in the world after the Nobel Prize, which comes with a $900,000 award. Patrick Lannan, who heads the family-run foundation, said Darwish and Said were chosen long before the Sept.

11 terrorist attacks. The Lannan Foundation describes itself as dedicated to cultural freedom, diversity and creativity. In a telephone interview, Lannan described Darwish as “arguably, the most prominent contemporary poet writing in Arabic in the world. We felt his poetry was important and deserved wider translation into English.

We wanted to call attention to his social conscience.” Said, an English professor, was honored because “he founded a theory for literary criticism and literary evaluation and there’s not a university professor in the Western world who doesn’t know his work,” Lannan said. Said, who is an American citizen, sparked a controversy last year when he threw a rock toward an Israeli guardhouse on the Lebanese border.

Columbia University did not censure him, saying that the stone was directed at no one, no law was broken and that his actions were protected by principles of academic freedom.

Six weeks after 11 September 2001, an American foundation gives its largest prizes to a Palestinian poet and a Palestinian professor, and the man who runs it tells a reporter they were chosen long before the attacks. Nobody asked him about a connection; the sentence is there because the connection is assumed. The archive also holds this poet’s photograph illustrating a review of this professor’s book fifteen years earlier.

CP-2001-008 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia · page 1

Sales of first Palestinian beer go flat

This Mideast brew of hope was popular before the renewed violence.

Michael Matza, Inquirer Staff Writer, Taybeh

TAYBEH, West Bank — They said Nadim Khoury was crazy, back in 1994, when he staked his future on a microbrewery in an Arab land where devout Muslims don’t drink and alcohol advertising is prohibited.

Clearly off his rocker, they said, amid suicide bombers and restricted borders, when he sank $1.5 million into a West Bank plant whose success hinged on the prospect of peace in the Middle East. But Khoury, 41, general director of the Taybeh Brewing Co., made history with the first Palestinian beer.

His was a business built on hope, and when peace seemed more than a mirage, business was good. But a year of violence has soured both hope and prosperity here… And as thousands of expatriate Palestinians began streaming back to help with the birth to a nation, Khoury was a bright example that not every Palestinian was a penniless refugee living a desultory, angry life.

“We got our approval from the Israeli [Civil Administration] before they pulled out. Yasir Arafat gave us his blessing. When we had peace, we had lots of business,” Khoury recalled last week inside his dank, 10,000-square-foot brew house, amid the gurgle of gleaming stainless-steel tanks and a picture of himself with Palestinian leader Arafat.

Taybeh is a preservative-free brew of Belgian malt and Bavarian hops mixed with local springwater.

Khoury named it for his village of 1,200 Christian Arabs in the ancient, terraced Samaritan hills between Ramallah and Jericho, and the handcrafted ale grew to such success that even upscale shops and bars in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv were starting to stock it. Taybeh, which in Arabic means nice and delicious, was consumed in the secular cafes of Ramallah and sold under the counter in some shops during Ramadan, the Muslim holiday month.

It was a staple on the menu at the legendary American Colony Hotel in Arab East Jerusalem, a frequently requested choice at the casino in Palestinian-controlled Jericho, and an off-hours favorite of the Marines assigned to guard the U.S. Consulate. (The refrigerator in the soldiers’ house wears a jaunty Taybeh bumper sticker.

“If you’ve had it — smile,” reads the sticker, replete with grinning happy face.) A small but growing number of peace-camp Israelis smiled on Taybeh. A West Bank rabbi even pronounced it kosher. Now, more than a year of intifadah violence has drained its success to the dregs. “Business isn’t bad, it’s terrible.

And it’s getting worse every day,” Khoury said. “Making business in this country is like a nightmare.”

From a once-high capacity of 5,000 barrels a year, the brewery is down to 1,000… Where Khoury once supplied 63 hotels in Jerusalem, he now supplies only three… To keep one of his Tel Aviv restaurant clients happy, Khoury said he’s had to mask the Taybeh label by wrapping layers of white tape around the kegs.

The restaurant sells Taybeh on tap but identifies it only as the “house brand” to avoid angering Israelis who don’t want to drink a Palestinian beer. “It hurts me to do it, because I’m really proud of my beer,” said Khoury.

“But what am I supposed to do?” Khoury attended Hellenic College in the Boston area, where he worked in a liquor store and dabbled in homemade brews during the beer boom of the ’80s and ’90s.

From Massachusetts he headed to the University of California at Davis, where he got a brew-master’s degree… Yet Khoury remains optimistic… “If peace doesn’t take place in this region, the whole world will be on fire. We haven’t seen peace yet,” he said. “But we have seen pieces of peace.

We just have to be patient and keep on hoping.”

A man taping over his own label so that the people drinking it will not know who made it. Photo credit: Evelyn Hockstein / For The Inquirer.

CP-2001-007 →

· Corpus Christi Caller Times · Corpus Christi · page 1

Former Palestinian hijacker reflects on life

Leila Khaled, the ‘deadly beauty,’ says bin Laden does not represent her people’s cause

By Jonathan Curiel, San Francisco Chronicle, Amman

AMMAN, Jordan — Palestinian girls would carry her photograph and dream of being a revolutionary. Men would swoon at her looks, amazed that a woman so striking could use rifles and grenades.

In the Arab world 30 years ago, Leila Khaled was treated like a celebrity for hijacking jetliners, a practice that led to a slew of sensational labels, including “deadly beauty.” These days, Khaled is a 57-year-old mother of two who leads a relatively quiet life in Amman… “I feel sorry for the innocent people who were killed (on Sept.

11),” says Khaled. “They were not involved. By comparison, when we hijacked planes, it was very well known that we wanted to keep (the passengers and crews) safe. We declared that.” “Bin Laden,” she says, “has no contacts with any Palestinian group… The Palestinian issue is important to Arabs and Muslims. That’s why he used it.

But, practically speaking, he hasn’t done anything for the Palestinians.”… A year later, Khaled, after having plastic surgery to disguise her looks, boarded an El Al flight from Amsterdam to New York… Khaled concedes that Israel has a right to exist within certain borders.

But she insists that a state of Palestine must have East Jerusalem as its capital… The mother of boys 19 and 16, and the wife of a physiotherapist, Khaled says she doesn’t worry about her safety.

Leila Khaled is a 57-year-old mother of two living in Jordan. Thirty years ago, she was a celebrity terrorist who hijacked her first plane in 1969 for the Palestinian cause.

Thirty-one years after eight American papers ran one photographer’s account of a day with her under eight headlines about how she looked, a paper writes the phrase down: a slew of sensational labels, including deadly beauty. Four paragraphs later, in a subordinate clause, it records that before the second hijacking she had surgery to change her face.

CP-2001-014 →

· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota · page 1

Peres: Declaration of Palestinian state could start talks

The Associated Press

“In new violence, Israeli soldiers in the Gaza Strip killed a mentally disabled Palestinian man and critically wounded a 13-year-old boy, Palestinian security officials said… In the Gaza Strip, Israeli soldiers shot and killed a mentally disabled and deaf Palestinian man walking a few hundred yards from an Israeli watchtower east of the Khan Yunis refugee camp, Palestinian security officials and relatives said.

The army said soldiers fired only after the man ignored their warnings in Arabic and Hebrew not to come any closer. Soldiers also fired warning shots, the army said.… Near the Jewish settlement of Neve Dekalim, a 13-year-old Palestinian boy was critically wounded when he was shot in the head by Israeli troops, Palestinian witnesses and doctors said.

The boy was watching a soccer game at the time, the witnesses said. The army said the youth appeared to soldiers to be at least 16 and was carrying a large bag as he tampered with a security fence… Soldiers warned him and then shot toward his lower body, the army said… ‘Maybe the best thing to re-open negotiations is the declaration of a Palestinian state.

Maybe,’ Peres said. ‘I want to check it. I don’t reject it immediately.’”

He was deaf. The army’s account of why he was shot is that he did not respond to spoken warnings in two languages. The paper prints both sentences, one after the other, and draws no line between them. He is not named. Two paragraphs on, a boy shot in the head is answered by an army statement that soldiers fired toward his lower body. All of it runs above a furniture advertisement, fifty to seventy per cent off, just in time for the holidays.

CP-2001-013 →

· Huntsville Times · Huntsville

Ignored by Bush, Arafat greeted warmly at U.N.

PLO leader honored by secretary general, cheered by delegates

UNITED NATIONS — Shunned by President Bush and under attack for not doing enough to combat terrorism, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat found a warm audience at the United Nations on Sunday and the ear of the secretary-general.

Arafat was escorted to the podium at the General Assembly’s annual debate, an honor reserved for presidents and prime ministers, and many delegates — although not the Israelis — broke out in applause even before he began his speech. Even Bush was not met with the same enthusiasm when he addressed the 189-nation assembly.

While many world leaders who addressed this year’s Assembly debate focused heavily on the terrorist attacks on the United States, Arafat devoted his time to the current Mideast crisis and accused Israel of “state-sponsored terrorism.”

Despite being unable to secure a meeting with Bush, Arafat praised the president for his recognition Saturday of a future Palestinian state next to Israel.

“We will exert every possible effort to achieve these objectives and will continue to exert our efforts to provide the best conditions for this endeavor,” Arafat said, calling for the resumption of peace negotiations as soon as possible. The Middle East has dominated the agenda here for nearly a decade.

However, while world leaders focused on terrorism and Afghanistan this year, many — including Bush — made a point of mentioning the crisis in their speeches.

China’s foreign minister, Tang Jiaxuan, said in his address Sunday that the unabated violence “not only poses a grave threat to the Middle East peace process and regional stability, but also exerts an increasingly negative impact on world peace.”

PLO leader Yasser Arafat addresses the U.N. General Assembly Sunday.

CP-2001-021 →

· The Grand Rapids Press · Grand Rapids · page A12

Bush ‘Palestine’ reference noted

In a significant shift, the president and Secretary of State Colin Powell both mention the likely name of a future Palestinian state.

Anne E. Kornblut, The Boston Globe

NEW YORK — As President Bush paid tribute at the World Trade Center site on the two-month anniversary of its destruction, administration officials held intense closed-door meetings on the Middle East on Sunday and said Bush purposely used the name “Palestine” for the first time to spur peace talks.

Bush returned to Washington on Sunday night without meeting Palestinian chairman Yasser Arafat at the United Nations, a snub that offended some Arab allies and dampened White House efforts to breathe life into the international coalition against terrorism.

But Secretary of State Colin Powell did see Arafat, and reported Sunday night that he saw a “new urgency” in the Palestinian leader about reaching a resolution. In a significant shift in State Department protocol, Powell also said it is now “appropriate” to call a future Palestinian state by its likely name, Palestine.

During another critical session, Powell discussed nuclear weapons reductions and missile defense with Russian Foreign Minister Igor Ivanov, laying the groundwork for a potential arms agreement when Bush and Russian President Vladimir Putin meet in Washington and Texas starting Tuesday.

Putin has expressed increasing confidence the United States and Russia can resolve differences about the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty, which Bush would abrogate to test and build a U.S. missile shield. Both leaders have suggested they would cut their nuclear arsenals by as much as two-thirds, a desirable move for Russia, which can barely afford to maintain its stock.

After a day of back-to-back meetings with top officials from nearly a dozen key countries — including Israel, Syria, Saudi Arabia, and Russia as well as the Palestinians — Powell offered a cautiously optimistic assessment about his progress, especially in the Middle East.

“Both sides realize we cannot continue as we have in recent months,” Powell told reporters.

Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, left, greets Secretary of State Colin Powell on Sunday in New York.

CP-2001-022 →

· Connecticut Post · page A7

Bush uses 'Palestine' deliberately

NATION/WORLD MONDAY, NOVEMBER 12, 2001 A7 Bush uses 'Palestine' deliberately Powell says using name marks Rights groups say Israel tortures prisoners new U.S. policy of coexistence JERUSALEM - Israeli authorities violations are being investigated. It torture Palestinian detainees also says that security forces By Ron Kampeas Mr.

Powell said. regularly despite a 1999 Supreme sometimes need to extract The Associated Press No Democrat, either.

Court ban on the practice, three information quickly from suspects President Clinton carefully local and international human rights who may have knowledge of an WASHINGTON - "Palestine" parsed his historic speech in 1998 groups said in a report Sunday. • impending attack. entered the U.S. government lexi- to Palestinian legislators: "For The document cited affidavits con with President Bush's speech the first time in the history of the from detainees, including a An Israeli government report on to the United Nations.

Palestinian movement, the Pales- 16-year-old who said he was the issue and the response by the Secretary of State Colin Powell tinian people and their elected soaked in freezing water, made to human rights groups will be said Sunday that it reflected the representatives now have a carry a heavy wooden beam while submitted to an 11-day meeting of administration's vision of two chance to determine their own manacled and then beaten. the U.N.

Committee Against Torture states, Israel and Palestine, side destiny on their own land." Israel said the ban on torture is in Geneva, to begin today. by side.

Until now, the State Depart- still in effect and that alleged The Associated Press Until now, U.S. officials have ment has used "Palestine" only to referred to the possibility of a describe the British-controlled "Palestinian state," but have nev- territory that existed before Isra- er called it "Palestine." el's establishment in 1948. Israel Mr. Powell said Mr.

Bush's use assumed some of the territory; of "Palestine" in his speech Satur- the other parts were controlled by day was deliberate. "If one is moving forward with apared by Israel in the 19re a vision of two states side by Mideast war. side," Mr.

Powell said on NBC's Although Israel has accepted Meet the Press, "it's appropriate the existence of a Palestinian ... to call those two states what state as an outcome of peace they will be, Israel and Palestine." talks, calling it "Palestine" has Mr. Bush told the U.N. General been a sensitive issue.

It has Assembly that the United States raised concerns that it would im- is "working toward the day when two states - Israel and Palestine - Palestine- aly the pre-94a eresury, trut live peacefully together within se- ing Israel. cure and recegnized borders as Palestinian leader Yasser Ara- called for by the Security Council fat, who met with Mr. Powell resolutions.

Sunday in New York, sax Mr. "No Republican president has Bush's use of "Palestine" was ever made (such) a statement," "very importent," and significant that it came before the world body. "We thank him from the bottom of our heart." Mr. Bush wants to bolster Arab and Muslim support for the U.S.- led war against suspected terrorists and their protectors in Af- ghanistan.

His statement was warmly welcomed by Arab delegates for referring to "recognized" borders, and for suggesting that Security Council resolutions implied statehood Before the Sept. 11 attacks, the administration's approach to the yeariong Israeli-Palestinian violence was notable for its lack of involvement. Mr.

Bush said be thought the Clinton administration had been too involved in there- gion, disappointing some Arabs who had hoped Mr. Bush would balance what they perceived as Clinton's pro-Israel tilt. The shift since Sept.

11 has unnerved Israelis, and Israel Prime Minister Ariel Sharon last month wondered whether the United States was sacrificing Israel's security interests to building a coalition against terror. Administration officials stressed they were still keeping a tough tine with Mr. Arafat. Condoleezza Rice, Mr. Bush's national security adviser, said Mr.

Bush still would not meet with Mr. Arafat, although both were in New York over the weekend. Ms. Rice said the administration was frustrated with Mr. Arafat's failure to arrest terronsts.

CP-2001-039 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Denies Groups’ Charge That It Is Torturing Detainees

Elizabeth Olson

“Appearing before a United Nations committee, Israel defended itself today against accusations by Amnesty International… Elizabeth Hodgkin, a representative of Amnesty International, said the organization’s investigation found increased incidences of torture.”

Two years after the Supreme Court ruling and the structure is unchanged: a charge, a denial, and the denial in the headline. Twenty-four years after the first one in this archive.

CP-2001-029 →

· Daily Dispatch · page 1

Opinion cartoon: Arafat, Hamas and Sharon

OPINION · Friday, December 7, 2001 · Arafat has never been a ‘partner in peace’

Jonah Goldberg, Tribune Media Services. Cartoon by Mike Shelton, The Orange County Register.

“Say you’re having an argument with your neighbor. He thinks your fence extends a couple feet onto his property. You agree in principle to talk about moving the fence. But you insist that before you both sit down to hash things out, he’s got to stop kneeing you in the groin… Now, doesn’t that sound reasonable?

That, in effect, was Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s so-called ‘hard line position’… The 1993 Oslo peace accords identified Arafat, ludicrously, as a ‘partner in a peace.’… So Israel gave Arafat control of 98 percent of the Palestinian population and authority over Gaza, the West Bank and other strategically critical areas… The Israelis are systematically destroying the symbols of Arafat’s authority: his beloved helicopters, his airport, his police stations.

The message: what Israel grants a partner in peace, it can take from an enemy in war.”

Editorial cartoon, three panels. A figure in a keffiyeh and a figure in a suit with a Star of David on the lapel face each other, pointing. In the second panel the suited figure reaches across. In the third the keffiyeh is lettered HAMAS and the word

SMACK! runs across the panel. Signed Mike Shelton, The Orange County Register.

The phrase this archive follows for thirty years, in an opinion headline, with the quotation marks placed around partner in peace to mark it as someone else’s idea. What the column argues, in its own closing line, is that the relationship was always conditional: “what Israel grants a partner in peace, it can take from an enemy in war.” The opening analogy makes the land a fence dispute between neighbors and the occupation a knee to the groin, in that order. Above it, a cartoon whose third panel replaces the man with the word HAMAS.

CP-2001-006 →

· The Daily Press · Newport News · page 1

Don’t forget it’s an Israeli occupation

Ali Abed, Yorktown

“It was quite easy for the Israel lobby and our misguided media to mislead the American public into believing that the Palestinians were the victimizers rather than the victims in the recent spate of violence. Where was the media the week before the attacks in Jerusalem and Haifa?

Why didn’t the media show the body parts of the Palestinian children who were blown to pieces by an Israeli shell in Gaza?… The media needs to constantly remind its readers and viewers that the Israeli occupation is the root cause of the violence that takes place in Palestine.

Is it not odd that the word ‘occupation’ seems to be vanishing from the vernacular of reporters, editors, columnists and anchormen?”

A reader in Yorktown, Virginia, making a point about American newspapers in an American newspaper.

CP-2002-022 →

· The New York Times · New York

Soothing Israel’s Fears

David K. Shipler

Humiliation, humiliation — but all they have learned is their right to exist.

Op-Ed diagram: humiliation leading to violence and back to humiliation, or to non-violence and peace.

An op-ed printed around a diagram: humiliation leads to violence, which leads back to humiliation; humiliation leads to non-violence, which leads to peace. A flowchart in the Times in 2002 proposing that Palestinians choose the second arrow.

CP-2002-053 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel, in Reprisal for Killings, Razes Gaza Refugee Homes

Joel Greenberg

“Residents searched for their belongings in the Rafah refugee camp yesterday. Palestinians said the Israeli Army had bulldozed dozens of homes.”

Residents searched for their belongings in the Rafah refugee camp yesterday. Palestinians said the Israeli Army had bulldozed dozens of homes.

Reprisal in the headline, in the paper’s own voice rather than the army’s. Dozens of houses in Rafah, a five-acre sea of rubble.

CP-2002-054 →

· The New York Times · New York

Refugees and Reparations in the Mideast

Yoel Esteron

“If we recognize such a right, the number of actual returnees would not be so great as to overwhelm the Jewish nature of this state.”

An Israeli editor argues for recognizing the right of return, on the ground that recognizing it would cost little. The argument is rare enough in the American press to keep; the arithmetic it rests on is the thing to notice.

CP-2002-055 →

· The Greenville News

Israeli missiles strike naval base

Government rejects Palestinian claim that accused arms smugglers detained

By Ibrahim Barzak / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Israel fired missiles at a Gaza City naval base Saturday in a fourth day of reprisals for a Palestinian weapons smuggling operation, and disputed a Palestinian claim that two suspects in the affair have been detained. One of the men supposedly in detention is not even in the Palestinian areas, Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s office said.

The Palestinians said Israel’s daily attacks, including the razing of homes and the demolition of the runway of Gaza International Airport, were inflaming an already tense situation. “This is not the way to bring the peace process back on track,” said Ahmed Qureia, the speaker of the Palestinian parliament.

In Saturday’s attack on Gaza City’s harbor, Israeli navy boats fired missiles at a Palestinian naval base, destroying a small patrol boat and setting fuel tanks ablaze. Divers also blew a large hole into the Jandala, a vessel that had occasionally been used by Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat.

The Israeli military said the base was targeted because Palestinian naval police officers were involved in the smuggling and a Wednesday attack that left four soldiers dead. Israel last week intercepted a boat carrying 50 tons of weapons from Iran which the Palestinian captain said were destined for the Gaza Strip.

Israel has said Arafat and his Palestinian Authority were behind the shipment of arms, which included rockets, explosives and anti-tank missiles forbidden under Israeli-Palestinian accords. Palestinians have come under intense Israeli and U.S. pressure to produce explanations and punish anyone involved, but have denied any ties to the shipment.

“We don’t know where the ship was going. We don’t know whether it was private enterprise, arms smuggling, arms dealing, whatever,” said Palestinian legislator Hanan Ashrawi.

Crippled ship: Palestinian fishermen work to clean their nets Saturday as a vessel at a Palestinian naval base in Gaza City lies crippled in the background after it was hit by missiles fired by Israeli navy boats earlier in the day.

The Israeli military said the base was targeted, destroying two vessels and exploding a fuel tank, in reprisal for a Palestinian weapons smuggling operation. LEFTERIS PITARAKIS / The Associated Press

CP-2002-094 →

· The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck · page 1

Friendship of Palestinian, architect defies odds

Jamie Tarabay, Associated Press Writer, Beit Jala

BEIT JALA, West Bank — It was a friendship that defied Mideast odds — between a Brooklyn-born architect who came to Israel in the 1960s, led by Zionist convictions, and a Palestinian hotel owner in the West Bank whose brother was a hijacker killed by Israel in the 1976 Entebbe rescue operation.

But Avi Boaz and Jamal al-Arja remained close through decades of Israeli-Palestinian conflict, sharing meals, vacationing together and attending the weddings of each others’ children — until the 71-year-old Boaz was killed Tuesday by Palestinian militants. “If we were born as a family, we couldn’t have loved each other more,” the 65-year-old al-Arja said Wednesday, his eyes red-rimmed from crying. Only a day earlier, the two men had shared lunch at al-Arja’s Everest hotel and restaurant on a hill in the Palestinian town of Beit Jala — as they had for most days in the past 33 years.

Sometime after the meal, Boaz, who was building a home in the nearby Jewish West Bank settlement of Har Gilo, drove off with al-Arja’s son Bashir to shop for building supplies and furniture. During the trip, the two encountered a Palestinian police checkpoint.

Four armed Palestinian civilians stopped Boaz’s silver Rover convertible, dragged Bashir out of the car and took off with Boaz. The police did not intervene, and the journey ended at a soccer field in nearby Beit Sahour, where the gunmen pumped 20 bullets into the windshield of the Rover, killing Boaz.

Boaz had unknowingly got caught up in one of the many unexpected twists of the conflict — a day earlier, a local militia leader elsewhere in the West Bank had been killed by a bomb widely attributed to Israel, and Palestinian gunmen clamored for revenge.

The Al Aqsa Brigades, to which the militia leader belonged, announced in a belief Tuesday that it killed Boaz in a revenge attack. Boaz’ son-in-law, Evyatar Cohen, said Boaz never cared about politics. “For him, there weren’t any borders. He would just go (to the West Bank) and come back.

He was always sure that because he was an American citizen, he was safe in every place,” he said… Two years ago, Boaz and his U.S.-born wife Eve, who died this month of cancer, went on a 15-day trip to Egypt with Jamal al-Arja and his wife, Nawal. There were also trips to Jordan and picnics in the West Bank hills.

When Boaz’ daughter got married two years ago, the al-Arja clan filled an entire table in the reception hall. Boaz was a regular at Beit Jala weddings, often driving the newlyweds to church in his Rover… However, Cohen and her husband said they would never set foot in the West Bank again.

“If they (the Palestinians) killed him, then it can happen for normal relations between us. We need to separate and that’s it,” said Evyatar Cohen. Makram al-Arja, 30, said he believed peace would come one day. “How much longer can they (Israelis and Palestinians) shoot at each other?” he wondered.

Jamal al-Arja’s brother was among the hostages Israeli commandos rescued at Entebbe in 1976; Avi Boaz’s brother was a hijacker killed in the same operation. The two men ate lunch together most days for the next thirty-three years. The parenthesis in Makram al-Arja’s question is the paper’s own.

CP-2002-023 →

· estimated · Austin American Statesman · Austin

To fight growth of Arabs, Israel entices migrants

Experts say Jews will become minority in area sometime this decade

By ROBERT W. GEE / American-Statesman Staff

RA’ANANA, Israel — Esther Leibovich is unambiguous about her allegiances. “I was born Argentine; I am Argentine; I always will be Argentine,” she said. But she is also Jewish, and that’s what matters to Israel. Leibovich, 41, moved to this tranquil suburb of Tel Aviv three weeks ago with her husband, Jorge, and three children.

They were aboard the first of three planeloads of Argentine Jews to immigrate to Israel since Argentina’s economic collapse in late December.

These newcomers, many of whom were unemployed and struggling to make ends meet in Argentina, are receiving so many government benefits in Israel — subsidized housing, free job training and a generous package of grants and loans — that they are making money, for about six months, just by living on Israeli soil.

In a high-stakes battle of demographics, Israel is trying harder to entice Jews from abroad to immigrate to their biblical homeland. Argentina’s Jewish community of 200,000 — who are mostly middle class but increasingly jobless — represents the latest hope for migration to Israel.

The Israeli government this month also added South Africa and France to the list of countries whose Jews can take advantage of a new, expanded basket of incentives to move to Israel. Demographers predict that sometime this decade Jews will become the minority in Israel and the disputed territories.

There are at least 4.2 million Arabs living in Israel, the West Bank and Gaza Strip, compared with roughly 5 million Jews. For years, Palestinian leaders have encouraged large families in an effort to outnumber Israelis. In the 1980s, Yasser Arafat personally urged Palestinian women to give birth for the cause. Jews make up 80 percent of the Israeli population.

The other 20 percent, mostly Arab Muslims, average a birth rate of 4.5 children per mother, compared with 2.5 children for Jewish mothers. The result by 2050 will be an Israel with a Jewish majority of two-thirds that is ever-shrinking.

Even the extraordinarily large families of ultra-orthodox Jews, about 20 percent of the Israeli Jewish population, are not expected to mitigate the demographic shift. “Time is running out, and I can see within Israel an explosion. Yes, I am very afraid,” said Arnon Soffer, a professor of geopolitics at the University of Haifa.

The Leiboviches are new Israeli residents from Argentina, living in an apartment in an immigrant center in Ra’anana. From left are Jacqueline, father Jorge, Hernan, mother Esther and Mariela.

Date check: The running head carries no date. It reads “Austin American-Statesman” at the left with the paper’s logo, and the section flag “WORLD” at the right. The paper name matches pub; the date 2002-01-22 could not be checked because no date or page folio is printed on the clipping.

CP-2002-081 →

· Austin American Statesman · Austin · page A3

Israeli troops take West Bank town

First seizure of town since 1994 is a new blow to isolated Arafat

By JAMIE TARABAY / Associated Press

TULKAREM, West Bank — Israeli troops searched homes and traded fire with Palestinians as the military took over an entire Palestinian town Monday, a first in 16 months of fighting and another blow to beleaguered Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat.

Stepping up the pressure, Israel also sent several tanks into a neighborhood in Nablus, the West Bank’s largest city, early today. In the first incursion, dozens of tanks rumbled through the streets of Tulkarem, emptied by a military curfew. Troops firing tank-mounted machine guns fought with Palestinian militiamen and rounded up suspected militants.

The exchanges of gunfire went on through the night. Three Palestinians were killed and 23 wounded in clashes in Tulkarem and in the West Bank town of Ramallah. Israel said the seizure was in response to lethal attacks on Israelis and said it was doing the job Arafat failed to do — rounding up militants.

In the second incursion, Israeli tanks drove within one-third of a mile of Nablus’ city center before dawn today. Residents heard sporadic gunfire, but apparently there was no heavy Palestinian resistance. A Palestinian security official said he was informed by Israeli counterparts that the Nablus raid was limited in scope, unlike the Tulkarem operation.

There was no immediate comment by the Israeli military. However, Israeli government officials have said that other Palestinian towns might be targeted. The Palestinians accused Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon of trying to bring down Arafat and destroy all prospects for a resumption of peace talks.

A defiant Arafat said the Palestinians would resist the Israeli incursion, saying Israel “crossed all the red lines” by taking over Tulkarem. “Our people will never keep silence about all of these Israeli attacks,” he told visitors at his headquarters in the West Bank town of Ramallah, which has been surrounded by Israeli tanks since Friday.

In a rare reference to his own mortality, Arafat also suggested he might not be around to see the establishment of a Palestinian state. “I swear to God I will see the Palestinian state, as a martyr or while still alive,” Arafat said.

Date check: The folio line across the top reads “F Tuesday, January 22, 2002 A3”. The date matches the slide label exactly, and Jan. 22, 2002 was indeed a Tuesday. The folio does not print the newspaper’s name.

CP-2002-082 →

· South Bend Tribune

'Separate but equal' Israeli education leaves Arab children at disadvantage

Neve Gordon

BEER-SHEVA, ISRAEL — One would have thought that following the civil rights movement in the United States and the liberation movement in South Africa, people would recognize that the idea of “Separate but equal” is nothing more than a devious fabrication employed to mask, perpetuate and sustain iniquitous social hierarchies.

And yet, despite the victorious struggles of these great historical movements, in Israel the conception that an education system can indeed be segregated but equal is ubiquitous. The facts, however, point to a different reality: Nearly one-quarter of Israel's 1.6 million school children are educated in a totally separate government-run school system.

Often overcrowded and understaffed, poorly built, badly maintained, or simply unavailable, schools for Palestinian citizens of Israel offer fewer educational opportunities to their children than the Jewish schools do. The degree and scope of discrimination is indeed alarming.

In “Second Class: Discrimination Against Palestinian Arab Children in Israel's Schools,” a 187-page report recently published by Human Rights Watch, one reads that Arab children attend classes that are 20 percent larger, with some children having to travel long distances to reach the nearest school.

Arab schools have fewer teachers and their teachers have, on average, fewer qualifications and receive lower salaries than Jewish teachers.

Op-ed by Neve Gordon, who 'teaches human rights in the department of politics and government at Ben-Gurion University' (italic bio set beside his mugshot). This is the earliest item in the batch to use the term 'Palestinian citizens of Israel' in body text, and it does so twice - the same phrase the 2018 op-eds will use. The comparison to Jim Crow and to apartheid South Africa is made in the first sentence, in 2002.

CP-2002-125 →

· The Buffalo News · Buffalo · page F-5

Palestinian, Israeli women team up for peace

By RANIA AWWAD, Special to The News

The term “intifada” comes from an Arabic word signifying a “shaking up” or “shaking off.” And true enough, the Palestinian intifada has lived up to this meaning in several ways, involving both the attempt to shake off the Israeli occupation as well as the shaking up of the societies affected by that occupation.

Perhaps more than anything else, one particular feature of the intifada that vividly dramatizes the extent to which societies have been shaken up by this struggle has been the unprecedented mobilization and widespread participation of women — Palestinian and Israeli alike — in promoting a peaceful and just resolution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Palestinian women have used nonviolent resistance as a political tool since the beginning of the last century. During the British Mandate period in the early 1920s, they organized petitions to the British government and held mass demonstrations against British policy in Palestine. In the late 1920s, they convened the first Palestinian Arab Women's Congress in Jerusalem.

After the 1967 Arab-Israeli war, when nearly 1 million Palestinians were driven from their homes with the creation of the state of Israel, Palestinian women led the way in organizing the kinds of services and support networks that would be needed to keep this new refugee population alive.

More recently, with the outbreak of the first intifada in 1987, Palestinian women became acutely aware of their precarious and conflicted position under the occupation.

On the one hand, they were forced to assume new economic responsibilities for providing for their families, sometime even as sole providers in the absence of male relatives who had been imprisoned, deported, maimed or killed.

On the other hand, in addition to their newly acquired responsibilities, they were also expected to fulfill their traditional responsibilities as wives and mothers — preservers and transmitters of the culture and identity of the Palestinian people.

Today, with the second intifada of 2000 raging in full force, Palestinian women continue to assume important roles in leading peaceful demonstrations and setting up popular relief committees.

In some of the larger cities, for instance, women's groups have created after-school programs for Palestinian youth to keep them from being drawn into street fights with armed Israeli soldiers or settlers, and to teach them how to express and demonstrate their legitimate frustrations through creative and nonviolent means.

The Palestinian intifada also has promoted the political involvement of Jewish-Israeli women against the occupation, a significant number of whom have organized and taken a strong stand against their government's treatment of the Palestinians.

Many have taken to the streets because they fear the corrosive effect that half a century of occupying another people will have on Israeli society in the future. Others are worried about the emotional price their own sons and daughters might have to pay for participating in the violent suppression of the Palestinian uprising.

(Conscientious objectors, or Israelis who refuse to serve their mandatory military duty in the occupied Palestinian territories, face harsh prison sentences).

But these women can draw hope from the near-legendary success of an Israeli women's peace group that relentlessly campaigned for years against the occupation of southern Lebanon and slowly eroded Israeli popular support for staying there.

In addition to invigorating the Palestinian women's nonviolent resistance movement and triggering the emergence of a distinct women's peace movement in Israel, the intifada has also created numerous opportunities for encounters and joint ventures between women on both sides.

Together they have succeeded in removing Israeli army blockades and filling in trenches — practices routinely undertaken by the Israeli army to inhibit Palestinian freedom of movement.

In other actions, these women have pushed nonviolent resistance one step further by placing their own lives in danger, such as by lying down in front of army bulldozers or chaining themselves to olive trees in efforts to prevent the destruction of Palestinian homes and property.

While there is good reason to be inspired by the ability of Jewish-Israeli and Palestinian women to reach out to each other across the battle lines, the alliances between them are, however, still fragile and face constant challenges.

The challenges originate both from a volatile and unpredictable political context and the disparities in power and privilege between the two sides. Furthermore, women working for a nonviolent end to the world's most violent conflict sadly enjoy little support — and sometimes even open hostility — from those in power.

This is precisely why it is so critical for us to help bolster these movements. It is especially important to help more Palestinian and Israeli women take their rightful places at the peace table. Last year, through a project funded by the Dutch government, Palestinian and Israeli women began to formulate their own criteria for establishing and sustaining peace in the region.

Such monumental proceedings must not be marginalized as irrelevant side projects, as they have been to date, but should be integrated into the larger, ongoing peace process. Women must be given a greater opportunity to formally participate in not only rebuilding their societies after decades of bitter conflict, but also in negotiating the peace terms.

Palestinian women mourn during a funeral procession on the Gaza Strip. Women have been quietly working for a nonviolent end to the Mideast conflict.

Signed guest column in the FINAL edition. The tagline reads: RANIA AWWAD is a Palestinian-American, a Ph.D. candidate at George Washington University and the Washington, D.C., regional director of Palestine Media Watch. Photograph credited Associated Press.

CP-2002-035 →

· The Atlanta Constitution · Atlanta, GA

Middle East: Long list of short lives

By HUGH DELLIOS

Diya Tmeizi. Koby Mandell. Faris Odeh. Shalhevet Pass. Burhan Himuni. Yehuda Shoham. Mohammed al Dura. The list goes on. They are children as young as 2 months, both Israeli and Palestinian, whom the world got to know in the past 15 months because they died.

As we all watched in horror, their parents grieved after they were shot down by soldiers or snipers, stoned through the windshield of a car, found bludgeoned in a cave, torn apart by a helicopter missile. Already more than 200 names long, the list of dead children and devastated parents will be longer in a year.

And quite likely the world will still be asking: How can fathers and mothers let this go on? The dawn of 2002 brought no end in sight to a conflict in which the protective love of parenthood is no match for the forces that put Mideast children at risk every day.

While the Bush administration vainly tries to coax a cease-fire from lulls, vicious terror attacks on coming-of-age bat mitzvah parties and the bulldozing of Gaza homes where hundreds of children live give no hint that the Israelis and Palestinians are preparing peace and safety for the next generation.

Clipped article, no masthead, no folio, no printed date; date is label-only. There is no deck. The pull quote in column two, 'Each side pushes on with attacks that inevitably kill children', is a pull quote taken from the body, not a deck. WIRE-COPY DIVERGENCE AND DATE CONFLICT: this is the same Hugh Dellios column that the Wilmington Morning Star / Star News ran on slide 67 under a different headline, 'Arabs, Israelis killing children'. Maria dates this one 28 Jan 2002 and the Star News one 30 Jan 2002, two days apart, which is ordinary for a syndicated column; neither clipping carries a printed date, so neither date can be checked against the page. The two texts are not identical. Atlanta prints 'in the past 15 months' where the Star News prints 'in the last 15 months'; 'will be longer in a year' for 'will be longer in a year's time'; 'More than a year ago, the Palestinian intifada' for 'A year ago, the Palestinian intifada'; 'near Tekoa' for 'in the desert near Tekoa'; an em dash before 'before Jewish vigilantes' where the Star News sets an en dash. Atlanta also CUTS a phrase: where the Star News asks 'For the sake of their children, how can fathers and mothers let this go on?' Atlanta prints only 'How can fathers and mothers let this go on?'. Atlanta runs several of the Star News's separate paragraphs together. Columns two, three and four were read at page magnification; column one was transcribed from magnified crops. Tagline at the foot: 'Hugh Dellios just completed three years as the Chicago Tribune's Middle East correspondent.'

CP-2002-121 →

· Staten Island Advance · Staten Island, NY

Grim first: Woman bomber kills Jerusalem man

■ 81-year-old Israeli killed, at least dozen wounded

By GREG MYRE, ASSOCIATED PRESS

JERUSALEM — A Palestinian woman launched a bomb attack yesterday on a busy Jerusalem street, killing herself and an 81-year-old Israeli man and wounding at least a dozen people. She was believed to be the first female suicide bomber since fighting began 16 months ago.

Israeli police were hesitant to call her a suicide bomber, saying it wasn’t clear if the woman intended to kill herself or if the bomb exploded prematurely as she walked along Jaffa Street, the main commercial strip in west Jerusalem.

Today, meanwhile, a Palestinian was shot dead in the Ramat-Gan suburb of Tel Aviv after running down and injuring an Israeli policeman,officials said. Three civilians were hospitalized from shock, ambulance officials said. Israeli officials believe the same man earlier ran a car through an army roadblock outside the West Bank city of Qalqilya, moderately injuring a soldier.

In Lebanon, the Al-Manar television station run by the militant Hezbollah movement said the Jerusalem bomber was Shinaz Amuri, a female student at Al-Najah University in the West Bank town of Nablus.

Israel accused Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat of “encouraging terrorism” and said it was prepared to respond to the bombing — the third major attack in an Israeli city in a week. The blast next to a shoe shop blew out shop windows, set a store on fire and left victims sprawled on the pavement amid shards of glass, pieces of fruit, shoes and storefront mannequins.

“It sounded like half the street exploded,” said Hama Gidon, a clothing store worker who was slightly injured. “All the mannequins went flying and I did too. People were falling, glass was flying everywhere.” More than 100 people were treated on the spot or taken to hospitals, though most suffered only from shock.

Three people were seriously hurt and nine had moderate injuries, officials said.

Standard AP wire news. The word “Palestinian” is used throughout, uniformly, as an adjective of nationality and of threat; there is no competing ethnonym on the page.

CP-2002-131 →

· estimated · The Patriot Ledger · Quincy

Terror triumphs over peace

The rash of suicide bombings in Israel’s cities has all but killed any hope of a resuscitated peace process. Who would the Israelis talk to? It is unclear what has motivated Palestinian militants to step up the number of these murderous attacks. One thing is certain: If they continue, Israel could become off-limits to Palestinians, period.

If that should happen, the Palestinians could congratulate themselves for turning the clock back to 1967, when they were driven from Jerusalem and the West Bank was placed under Israeli occupation. Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat has been isolated politically as well as geographically. Israeli tanks now surround his compound, and the airport in Gaza City is in shambles.

The illogic that propels Palestinian fanatics is mindboggling to outside observers. To mount repeated attacks against civilians on Israel’s streets while the world is riveted as never before on the horror of religious terrorism is indeed suicidal. There is no support for these murders, except among other fanatics.

Nor are there many expressions of support for Arafat from leaders in the Middle East or anywhere else. Arafat cannot control the killers but he could have condemned them when this round of violence began months ago. He chose not to do so, thus relegating himself to the sidelines.

The shipment of 50 tons of sophisticated weapons en route to Palestinian terrorists that Israel intercepted a few weeks ago was the last straw. Though the shipment cannot be linked directly to Arafat, his Fatah group was said to be involved.

It is nearly impossible to imagine an Israeli leader willing in the future to have enough confidence in Arafat as a leader to sit with him at a negotiating table.

Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping; it is trimmed to the editorial itself. The only standing matter is the section head “OUR OPINION” above a rule. Nothing on the clipping names the newspaper or gives a date, so 2002-01-30 could not be checked.

CP-2002-087 →

· Star News · Wilmington, NC · page 11A

Arabs, Israelis killing children

HUGH DELLIOS

Diya Tmeizi. Koby Mandell. Faris Odeh. Shalhevet Pass. Burhan Himuni. Yehuda Shoham. Mohammed al Dura. The list goes on. They are children as young as 2 months, both Israeli and Palestinian, whom the world got to know in the last 15 months because they died.

As we all watched in horror, their parents grieved after they were shot down by soldiers or snipers, stoned through the windshield of a car, found bludgeoned in a cave, torn apart by a helicopter missile. Already more than 200 names long, the list of dead children and devastated parents will be longer in a year's time.

And quite likely the world will still be asking: For the sake of their children, how can fathers and mothers let this go on? The dawn of 2002 brought no end in sight to a conflict in which the protective love of parenthood is no match for the forces that put Mideast children at risk every day.

While the Bush administration vainly tries to coax a cease-fire from lulls, vicious terror attacks on coming-of-age bat mitzvah parties and the bulldozing of Gaza homes where hundreds of children live give no hint that the Israelis and Palestinians are preparing peace and safety for the next generation.

MASTHEAD DISAGREES WITH PUB: the folio at the top of this clipping reads 'WILMINGTON MORNING STAR | 11A'. Maria's pub label is 'Star News'. Do not change pub; the two are the same Wilmington, NC paper at different points in its naming, but the masthead on THIS page says WILMINGTON MORNING STAR, and if 'Star News' is a new spelling in the archive it would ingest as a second newspaper. Flagging for Eva. The folio's top edge is clipped, so the page number reads as '11A' with the tops of the figures cut; treat the page as probable rather than certain. LABEL ORDER: Maria's label lists slide 67 as 'USA Today Dec 5 2005' then 'Star News Jan 30 2002', but s067_1 is the Star News/Morning Star item and s067_2 is the USA Today item. The images are in the reverse order from the label. No printed date appears on the clipping, so the date itself is label-only; the text's internal reference, 'The dawn of 2002 brought no end in sight' and 'the last 15 months' from September 2000, is consistent with late January 2002. 'OPINIONS & IDEAS' is a SECTION FLAG, not a deck; the standing author name 'HUGH DELLIOS' above the headline is the byline. The headline is the article's own. The pull quote in column two, 'The protective love of parenthood is no match for the forces that put Mideast children at risk every day', is a pull quote taken from the body, not a deck. Tagline at the foot: 'Hugh Dellios just completed three years as the Chicago Tribune's Middle East correspondent.' This is the only op-ed in the batch and it is written on an explicit both-sides frame — 'Arabs, Israelis killing children', 'both Israeli and Palestinian', 'neither side's leadership appears eager to quell'. Within that frame it nonetheless prints 'booby-trap bombs that Israeli soldiers plant on a street leading to a Gaza school' and 'the bulldozing of Gaza homes where hundreds of children live', and it names four Palestinian children with their ages and the circumstances of their deaths. It also prints 'Many Palestinians claim not to know this' about Israeli teenagers killed by suicide bombs — an assertion about a whole people, offered without a source. The whole of column two and the upper half of column three were read at page magnification only; columns one and three were transcribed from magnified crops.

CP-2002-120 →

· The New York Times

Israelis Declare Arab Woman Was in Fact a Suicide Bomber

By JAMES BENNET

TEL AVIV, Feb. 8 — An Israeli government investigation has concluded that a Palestinian woman who died when she detonated a huge explosion in downtown Jerusalem on Jan. 28 was in fact a suicide bomber, a senior Israeli military official said here today.

In the aftermath of the explosion, in the busy shopping district of Jaffa Road, it was not clear if the woman had intended to plant the bomb and escape or to blow herself up. The blast also killed an 81-year-old Israeli man and wounded many other bystanders.

But the senior military official said there was no question that the Palestinian, Wafa Idris, 28, was the first female suicide bomber to strike inside Israel. “She was a suicide bomber,” he said. “We know this now.” Ms.

Idris, a resident of the Amari refugee camp just north of Jerusalem, was a volunteer medic with the Palestine Red Crescent Society and an activist with Yasir Arafat’s Fatah faction. The Fatah-linked group that claimed responsibility for the attack, the Aksa Martyrs Brigades, described her as a “martyr,” implying that she had intended to die.

But her friends, members of her family and the Israeli police said they were not so sure. Ms. Idris left no note and no “martyr video” other suicide bombers have done. A spokesman for the Israeli police had no immediate comment on the disclosure that Ms. Idris was a suicide bomber. Ms.

Idris was identified by a shoe saleswoman, Rivka Reuven, as having examined merchandise in her store moments before stepping outside to detonate the bomb. Ms. Reuven said the bomber was holding a green nylon bag, slug over one shoulder and cradled with one hand. “Her look was not from this earth,” Ms. Reuven said.

“She was like a zombie. like she was drugged.”

Wafa Idris blew herself up on a crowded street in Jerusalem.

CP-2002-096 →

· The New York Times

Israeli Woman Stabbed to Death in a Wave of Violence

By JAMES BENNET

JERUSALEM, Feb. 9 — Capping a violent week in which militants jailed by the Palestinian Authority at Israeli request were released, a group of Arab youths in the Forest of Peace here repeatedly stabbed a 24-year-old Israeli woman, the police said.

The woman, who died at a hospital soon afterward, was taking a walk in the park, which is set between Jewish and Arab areas of the city. Masked Palestinians were spotted running away and the police said they caught four of them. One collapsed and died at the scene, though the police said that he had not been shot or wounded and that an autopsy would be performed.

In the Jabaliya refugee camp in the Gaza Strip, thousands of supporters of the Islamic group Hamas gathered for a rally in which performers acted out a rocket attack on a Jewish settlement. “We are ready to explode!” the crowd chanted. Dr.

Abdel Aziz Rantisi, a pediatrician who is a top political leader of Hamas, addressed the crowd, in his first public appearance since he agreed with the Palestinian Authority to submit to house arrest in December. That deal, together with a limited cease-fire declared by Hamas, appears to have collapsed in the recent exchange of attack and counterattack.

In a reference to suicide attacks, Dr. Rantisi declared to the crowd, “I say it clearly, that Hamas will continue the martyrdom operations.” “Let’s not care if they say that we are terrorist organizations,” he said. “Your choice is your gun.”

As the violence has flared recently, Yasir Arafat has repeatedly called for a cease-fire, and the Palestinian leadership did so again today. But Dr. Rantisi told the crowd, “Whoever wants to stop the intifada wants to tear us apart.” “I swear that one day all Israelis will run away from your land,” he told a throng of Palestinians.

More than 10,000 Hamas supporters rallied at the Jabaliya refugee camp in the Gaza Strip yesterday. Speakers vowed to continue suicide attacks.

CP-2002-097 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Killed as His Commandos Demolish West Bank House

James Bennet

“The leader of an elite Israeli commando unit was killed today by a falling wall as his troops demolished a Palestinian militant’s home in the West Bank.”

A house demolition reported through the death of the man demolishing it. The Palestinian family whose house it was does not appear in the headline or the first six paragraphs.

CP-2002-056 →

· The New York Times · New York

Life and Death in the Mideast

“Palestinian militants gave young boys weapons lessons yesterday in the Gaza Strip. On the West Bank, a Palestinian girl, 15, was killed as she ran toward Israeli soldiers with a knife, and an Israeli and a Palestinian gave birth after being shot.”

Life and Death in the Mideast

Four events balanced in one summary box under the head Life and Death in the Mideast. The two women who gave birth after being shot are given one clause between them.

CP-2002-057 →

· The New York Times · New York

Portrait of an Angry Young Arab Woman

Joel Greenberg

BEIT WAZAN, West Bank, Feb. 28 — Frustrated by the refusal of Hamas to enlist her in a suicide mission…

Beit Wazan, and a woman turned down by Hamas. The headline calls her angry and young and Arab before it calls her anything else.

CP-2002-072 →

· Statesman Journal

Gaza plant typical of Enron's risky business

The project is 90 percent complete but still in jeopardy.

Enron Corp.’s foray into the Middle East three years ago was typically brazen and risky. The Houston-based global energy company wanted to build a 136-megawatt power plant in the Gaza Strip and help the Palestinian Authority provide a stable and reliable source of electricity for 136,000 households for the next decade.

That alone might have given pause to investors worried about political instability, but the project hit a further snag when U.S. officials learned that a key investor in the plant had links to the Saudi Binladin Group, the Saudi Arabian construction company founded by the father of the international terrorist, Osama bin Laden.

The story behind the Gaza power plant reflects Enron’s remarkable ability to overcome political, diplomatic and financial hurdles. It also shows the consequences of the company’s willingness to push foreign projects that looked good on paper but carried extraordinary risk.

Plant sits incomplete A year and a half after it was supposed to begin operation, construction of the $140 million power plant just south of Gaza City is stalled, yet another of Enron’s numerous international gambles that have run out of luck.

Construction was virtually halted in late 2000 when violence flared, after conservative Israeli leader Ariel Sharon visited the Temple Mount in Jerusalem’s Old City. Some work has since resumed, but there is no target date for the plant to open.

It is unclear what role the international projects played in the company’s decision to hide debts in off-the-books transactions, a strategy that forced the company to declare billions of dollars in losses and seek bankruptcy protection in December.

CP-2002-036 →

· LNP Lancaster Online

Rumors of peace

In a war-torn land, even a small move toward resolution by Saudi Arabia has raised hopes for that elusive Mideast settlement.

JERUSALEM — Israelis and Palestinians are locked in their deadliest battle in decades. No political initiative has graced the horizon for months. Nearly everyone — Arab and Jew — is exhausted.

Into such bleak circumstances floats a proposal by Saudi Arabia that is gaining astonishing momentum — even though it is vaguely worded, starkly simple and not particularly creative. Headlines in newspapers from Jerusalem to Cairo and beyond trumpet it. The European Union envoy detours to Jidda to hear more, and President Bush bestows his praise.

The formula, which emerged as nothing more than a trial balloon in a New York newspaper, offers Israel recognition and normal economic, cultural and political relations with the entire Arab world in exchange for the Jewish state’s withdrawal from all land it captured and occupied in the 1967 Middle East War, including the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Instead of details, it presents a quid pro quo of broad sweep, and is difficult for any party to dismiss out of hand. The proposal would seem to have little chance to prosper, however.

As eager as Israelis are to enjoy diplomatic normality with their Arab neighbors, Prime Minister Ariel Sharon has adamantly refused to cede more than a portion of the West Bank and Gaza Strip to the Palestinians.

Yet the proposal has captured the imagination of many people in the region, in part because of the rare involvement of powerful Saudi Arabia and in part because they are so desperate for any initiative that might staunch the flow of blood in the Holy Land.

“The public wants to grab at straws,” said Galia Golan, an Israeli political scientist and veteran peace activist. EFFORTS TO END 17 months of violence that has claimed more than 1,100 lives have failed repeatedly. Throughout the escalating bloodshed, the U.S. government has abdicated its mediator role and remained largely on the sidelines.

But the Saudi plan, a senior State Department official said, is “important and interesting.” The promise of diplomatic recognition for Israel and the signal to Palestinian Authority President Yasser Arafat that peaceful negotiations are still possible are encouraging incentives, the official said, but cautioned: “This is not a settlement.

It has to be reached through negotiations, after a rebuilding of trust, which has to come after an end to the violence. So we’re still where we were before; we just have a better idea of what’s down the road.”

Hussein Jarboo, a 4-year-old Palestinian boy, wields an AK-47 assault rifle during an anti-Israel and anti-U.S. rally Monday in Rafah, in the Gaza Strip: Saudi Arabia has offered new hope for peace in the Mideast.

CP-2002-037 →

· The Sentinel · Carlisle

Palestinian suicide bomber kills at least 9 others

CP-2002-038 →

· The Sunday Oregonian · Portland

Palestinian suicide bomber kills at least 9 in Jerusalem

CP-2002-039 →

· The New York Times

Israeli Raids Kill 17 Palestinians; In Tel Aviv, 3 Die in a Shooting

By SERGE SCHMEMANN

JERUSALEM, Tuesday, March 5 — Still burying its dead from the weekend’s bloodshed, Israel unleashed its anger at Palestinians throughout their territories on Monday.

Helicopters fired shells that landed near Yasir Arafat’s headquarters in Ramallah, and an Israeli tank shell ripped into a pickup truck there, killing a woman and her children before the eyes of passing schoolchildren.

Then early today a lone gunman armed with an M-16 assault rifle fired into a popular Tel Aviv night spot, killing three Israelis and wounding 30 before he himself was shot, the police said. [After the assault on the night club, Israeli troops raided the Palestinian controlled sector of Hebron in the West Bank and a Palestinian ruled town to the south, Dura, killing one Palestinian and wounding 10 others in exchanges of fire, Reuters reported, citing Palestinian security and hospital officials.] The Aksa Martyrs Brigade, a militant Palestinian group, claimed responsibility for the attack on the night spot, the Seafood Market Club, in a telephone call to reporters in Ramallah, identifying the gunman as Ibrahimi Muhammad Hassouni.

The police said he also threw two grenades and pulled out a knife to try to stab victims after he ran out of ammunition. It was not clear who killed the gunman. In all, at least 17 Palestinians were killed on Monday, after a weekend in which 22 Israelis were killed. Many of the dead from both sides were children and civilians.

From the two sides came ever louder vows of vengeance and violence, and there was no sign of any effort to break the vicious circle. “If the Palestinians are not being beaten, there will be no negotiations,” Prime Minister Ariel Sharon told reporters at Parliament. “The aim is to increase the number of losses on the other side.

Only after they’ve been battered will we be able to conduct talks.” Addressing a special session of Parliament, he said: “We are in a bitter war against a cruel and bloodthirsty enemy. We are fighting for our home, and we will prevail.”

A wounded woman was moved from a Tel Aviv night spot today after a Palestinian gunman killed three Israelis and wounded 30 others there.

CP-2002-098 →

· The Jonesboro Sun · Jonesboro

Seven Palestinians died in fighting in Gaza

“Seven of the Palestinians died in fighting in Gaza Wednesday… ‘I don’t think declaring war on Palestinians will work,’ Powell said in Washington.”

Operation Defensive Shield, with Arafat confined in Ramallah. An American secretary of state is the voice of restraint in the middle of the casualty count.

CP-2002-078 →

· USA Today · McLean

Palestinian gunmen use Manger Square for cover

Israelis round up, question residents of refugee camp

DHEISHEH REFUGEE CAMP, West Bank — An extraordinary scene unfolded Monday in the town where the Bible says Jesus was born 2,000 years ago. Israeli troops, protected by tanks and armored cars, interrogated more than 600 Palestinian men and youths in the Dheisheh refugee camp near Bethlehem.

But the suspected terrorists they were hunting had set up an armed camp less than a mile away under the protection of uniformed Palestinian Authority police.

Dozens of Palestinian gunmen from the three main militant Palestinian groups — Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade, Hamas and Islamic Jihad — smoked cigarettes, drank coffee or wandered around Manger Square outside the ancient Church of the Nativity, which marks the traditional birthplace of Jesus.

The men said they felt safe among the shuttered souvenir shops because Israel would not dare to launch an attack so close to the ancient shrine. Many of the men are wanted by Israel, which accuses them of masterminding and carrying out a long string of terror attacks, including suicide bombings over the past 10 days.

Abu Nasser, the leader of the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade in Bethlehem, lounged near the newly built Peace Center opposite the church. He held a heavy machine gun and had an ammunition belt loaded with large-caliber bullets slung over his shoulder. “We are here because this is an uneven battle,” Nasser said.

“The Israeli soldiers have tanks and Apache helicopters, while we have only rifles. We will defend our homeland. We are here to prevent them from entering central Bethlehem.” From Manger Square, Nasser could see the refugee camp less than a mile away, where Israeli armored vehicles maneuvered through the streets. The Israeli incursion began at 8 a.m. Monday.

After surrounding the poorly built concrete houses that provide cramped living space for some 10,000 Palestinians, Israeli soldiers driving through the camp used loudspeakers to ask all men 15 to 45 to gather at a stone-cutting factory on the edge of the camp. All the men in the camp appeared to comply. Residents told the soldiers the gunmen had fled long ago.

“We are all civilians,” Kamal Khmais, 25, said as soldiers tied his hands.

Interrogated: A soldier directs blindfolded and handcuffed Palestinians as the Israeli army rounds up males in Dheisheh refugee camp Monday. On edge: An Israeli soldier looks out of a smashed window during a house-to-house search. Photos by Magnus Johansson, Reuters

CP-2002-052 →

· Tampa Bay Times · St. Petersburg · page 12

Israeli siege explodes hopes in Ramallah

Explodes, in a headline about a siege, and the thing exploded is hopes. The word for the actual explosions of that month does not appear. The siege is named as Israeli, which many of these headlines do not do.

CP-2002-001 →

· Birmingham Post Herald · Birmingham, AL

Tanks roll into West Bank

Street fighting is intense in the Gaza Strip

By HADEEL WAHDAN, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Israeli tanks moved deeper into two West Bank towns today, just ahead of the arrival of a U.S. mediator, and troops killed four Palestinian gunmen in intense street fighting. In the Gaza Strip, three Israelis were killed when an explosion went off near a tank. In biblical Bethlehem, Palestinian militiamen shot dead two suspected informers for Israel.

The attackers then tried to hang the body of one victim from a building on Manger Square, overlooking the Church of the Nativity, but were stopped by Palestinian policemen. The militiamen left the scene, firing their weapons into the air. In Ramallah, Palestinian witnesses initially said some Israeli forces were pulling out early today.

However, by daybreak it became clear that troops remained in the city, and a regional army commander, Col. Yair Golan, said tanks had changed positions for tactical reasons, but that the Ramallah operation was not over. Palestinian security officials said four Palestinian gunmen were killed in fighting with Israeli troops early today.

Israeli tanks also drove deeper into Bethlehem, with some taking about positions about 250 yards from Manger Square.

Clipped page top with a section flag 'MIDEAST' above the headline; no masthead and no printed date anywhere on the clipping, so the date is label-only. The section flag is not a deck; the deck is the two-line drop head 'Street fighting is intense in the Gaza Strip'. Golan is 'Col. Yair Golan' here — a lower rank than the 'Brig. Gen.' of the 2005 clippings, which fits the three-year gap. The byline is a Palestinian AP reporter, Hadeel Wahdan. The sentence 'with some taking about positions about 250 yards from Manger Square' reproduces a printer's error in the original ('taking about positions about'); it is kept as printed. Photo caption: 'A Palestinian gunman walks past the body of an alleged collaborator with Israel in this image taken from TV in the West Bank town of Bethlehem. Palestinian militiamen killed two alleged collaborators today and attempted to hang one body from a rooftop of a building on Manger Square, overlooking the Church of the Nativity.' (AP)

CP-2002-117 →

· Staten Island Advance · Staten Island, NY

Israel digs into positions in West Bank towns

In the Gaza Strip, 3 Israelis are killed when an explosion goes off near a tank

By HADEEL WAHDAN, ASSOCIATED PRESS

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Israeli tanks moved deeper into two West Bank towns today, just ahead of the arrival of a U.S. mediator, and troops killed four Palestinian gunmen in intense street fighting. In the Gaza Strip, three Israelis were killed when an explosion went off near a tank. In biblical Bethlehem, Palestinian militiamen shot dead two suspected informers for Israel.

The attackers then tried to hang the body of one victim from a building on Manger Square, overlooking the Church of the Nativity, but were stopped by Palestinian policemen. The militiamen left the scene, firing their weapons into the air. In Ramallah, Palestinian witnesses initially said some Israeli forces were pulling out early today.

However, by daybreak it became clear that troops remained in the city, and a regional army commander, Col. Yair Golan, said tanks had changed positions for tactical reasons, but that the Ramallah operation was not over. Palestinian security officials said four Palestinian gunmen were killed in fighting with Israeli troops early today.

Israeli tanks also drove deeper into Bethlehem, with some taking about positions about 250 yards from Manger Square. In the Gaza Strip, three Israelis were killed and two others were wounded when Palestinians set off a roadside bomb next to a tank, the army said.

Israel Radio said the tank was escorting a convoy of civilian vehicles in southern Gaza when a powerful bomb was detonated, apparently by remote control. One person was killed outright by the blast and two others burned alive in a vehicle, radio reports said.

Clipped page with photograph, headline, dek and four columns; no masthead, no folio, no printed date, so date is label-only. The in-page advertisement reads 'Today Thru Wed. March 20th!', which is consistent with a mid-March date but proves nothing by itself; it is an advertisement, not a dateline. IMPORTANT WIRE-COPY FINDING: this is the same Hadeel Wahdan AP dispatch as the Birmingham Post-Herald clipping on slide 63, same day, but the two papers did not print the same words. The Post-Herald ends the Ciriello paragraph at 'a French photographer was hit by shrapnel from a small bomb.' The Advance prints 'a French photographer working nearby was hit by shrapnel from a small bomb apparently planted by Palestinian fighters.' The Advance also carries three further paragraphs the Post-Herald did not run, including the Foreign Press Association statement criticising army fire at reporters and the search of the AP's own Ramallah office by about 20 Israeli troops. The printer's error 'with some taking about positions about 250 yards' appears in both papers and is kept as printed. The paper also prints 'Arafat aid Nabil Abu Rdeneh' for 'aide'; kept as printed in the paper, not carried into this excerpt. Photo caption: 'An Israeli army tank patrols the empty streets in the West Bank Town of Ramallah.' (ASSOCIATED PRESS) — note the paper's capital 'Town'.

CP-2002-118 →

· The New York Times · New York

For Children, Peace Seems Easy if They Get to Connect

“A Palestinian boy named Faraj tells a documentary filmmaker about his desire to avenge a friend who threw stones at an Israeli soldier and was killed. But when the filmmaker arranges to have Faraj meet Israeli twins, he prepares for the rendezvous as if it’s a date. Before they arrive, he spritzes himself with cologne.”

A review of Promises, the Academy Award nominated documentary. Faraj with the cologne is the detail that survives the film, and the headline’s easy is doing something the children in the film never claim.

CP-2002-058 →

· Post Star · Glens Falls, NY

Hazards of covering combat growing

By LAURA KING, Associated Press

JERUSALEM ♦ On one side are Israeli soldiers, on the other are Palestinian gunmen — and caught in the middle are journalists trying to cover an increasingly chaotic conflict raging in the streets of the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

The death of an Italian photographer in the West Bank town of Ramallah on Wednesday — the first foreign journalist to be killed in 17 months of fighting — points up the growing hazards faced by those reporting on the latest spasm of bloodletting in the Middle East.

This week, Israel launched its biggest military operation in a generation, using troops, tanks, Apache assault helicopters and F-16 warplanes in what it described as a decisive push against Palestinian militants and weapons-makers.

For the most part, the recent fighting has taken place at breathtakingly close range, in crowded Palestinian towns and refugee camps throughout the West Bank and Gaza. And on both sides, many combatants are young, jittery and quick at the trigger. A top Israeli military commander said Thursday that journalists needed to weigh the risks for themselves.

"It's an unhealthy neighborhood, and journalists ... need to be careful and not move in places that are too dangerous," said Col. Yair Golan, a brigade commander. The danger, of course, is not limited to journalists. This has been the bloodiest month since the conflict erupted in September 2000.

So far in March, more than 170 Palestinians and at least 62 Israelis, including combatants and civilians on both sides, have died.

Clipped page top: headline, byline, photograph and four columns. No masthead, no folio, no printed date, so date is label-only. There is no deck; the headline stands alone. The paper uses a diamond ♦ rather than a dash after the dateline, a Post-Star house style. Casualty figures as printed: 'more than 170 Palestinians and at least 62 Israelis' for March alone. The paper spells the photographer 'Ciriello' throughout. Photo caption: 'A crewman of an Israeli armored personnel carrier looks for targets for his Gatling gun on Thursday in Ramallah.' (ASSOCIATED PRESS). The excerpt is transcribed from magnified crops of column one; the Ricucci and World Association of Newspapers material in columns three and four was read at full-page magnification only and should be re-checked before any of it is quoted on the site.

CP-2002-119 →

· The New York Times

As Tanks Leave City, Ramallah Is Defiant

By JOEL BRINKLEY

RAMALLAH, West Bank, March 15 — The Israeli Army pulled out of here early this morning, leaving behind numerous cars flattened by tanks, homes shattered by searches and residents loudly proclaiming victory. Most of the militants the Israelis were seeking, however, had run away to hide.

The military incursion into this teeming West Bank city began Tuesday morning and lasted until this morning. With the tanks gone, several thousand young men turned out early today to bury some of the fighters killed by Israeli troops in the last 72 hours.

They carried the bodies from a mosque to the cemetery, shouting and firing weapons into the air with a spirit of victory and defiance. Much of the Israeli Army’s attention here was directed at Al Amari refugee camp, home to about 10,000 people. Residents walked the street this afternoon, eager to share stories of how they were treated.

Nabil Inabi, 45, said soldiers broke through a window Tuesday night and herded his family into the kitchen. They expelled him, his wife and 10 children from their home. For three nights they slept on the floor of his small food store downstairs while soldiers, he said, used his home as a snipers’ nest.

When he and his family returned home this morning, they found the place in shambles. A sofa and a television had been thrown out the front door and down the steps, clothes had been pulled from closets and ripped and mattresses had been slashed. On the street-side wall of Mr.

Inabi’s house, as on many homes here, was pasted a poster commemorating the camp’s latest hero, Wafa Idris, a 28-year-old woman from Al Amari who blew herself up Jan. 28 on a busy Jerusalem shopping street, killing herself and an 81-year-old man and wounding 113 others. Down the street, three 16-year-old boys sauntered past, home for the first time in three days.

“Definitely they would have arrested us,” said one, who would give only his first name, Ahmed. “But we left. Everybody left. So they failed in their mission.” The curb beside him had been chewed away by a passing tank.

Asked about this operation and others like it in Tulkarm, Balata, Bethlehem and other West Bank locations in recent days, Shaul Mofaz, the Israeli Army chief of staff, said: “From the army’s standpoint, it has been proven that when the Israel Defense Force is on the offensive, it does its job well.

The enemy either surrendered or ran away before the army arrived.” Ahmed said, “We learned lessons from Tulkarm and Balata,” two refugee camps similarly invaded in the last month. “All the armed people here left before the soldiers came. They didn’t fight. So we won, and they failed.”

This afternoon armed Palestinian gunmen strutted the streets, assault rifles slung over their shoulders. Thaer, 20, who also declined to give his surname, carried a rifle, wore the uniform of the Palestinian security force and said he lived in Al Amari. But he said had been stationed elsewhere the last three days.

He did not return home at night, he said, “because I couldn’t.” Ramallah is a large city; about 200,000 people live here. And in three days’ time the Israelis could not accomplish a great deal. The home of Hamdi Flaifer, 35, was in ruins after an Israeli search.

Windows were broken, furniture was smashed, sofa cushions slashed, closets and cabinets were emptied onto the floor. Just outside his front door, Israelis had spray- painted a Star of David and a number, indicating to other Israelis that his house had been searched. Mr.

Flaifer, who was active in the first intifada more than a decade ago, said, “The last time they arrested me, in 1993, I spent a year in jail.”

Residents of Al Amari refugee camp on their way to a funeral for residents killed during a three-day Israeli military incursion.

CP-2002-099 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Anger and Isolation Roil Israeli Arabs

By JOEL BRINKLEY

UMM AL FAHM, Israel, March 24 — Ibrahim Siam has been a citizen of Israel for all of his 42 years. He has built a successful building contracting business here, and he lives in a spacious, comfortable home. But after a Palestinian suicide bomber from the West Bank killed six people last week aboard a bus just outside town, Mr.

Siam seethed with a rage that used to be uncharacteristic. “This is the answer for what the Jews of Israel are doing,” he said through clenched teeth. “They are the ones who ought to be blamed.”

The mayor of Umm al Fahm, Ahmad Eghbaria, settling into his office moments after a City Council meeting, said he had “mixed feelings” about the bombing. After all, “there were some Arabs on that bus.” For decades, when Israelis spoke of the Palestinian problem they were referring to the Arabs who live in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

But now the 1.4 million Palestinians who live inside Israel as full citizens of the state are growing increasingly angry, and some have become violent. The Israeli government is reacting with alarm; as security officials describe the situation, it is like a pot of water that has just reached boiling, the lid just beginning to rattle.

With attention, they say, the problem might be calmed. Instead, the two sides seem to be growing further apart.

Ibrahim Siam, an Israeli Arab, at the grave of his son Ibrahim, who was killed by Israeli police officers in 2000.

Date check: No masthead or running head is present on this clipping — it is trimmed to the article and its photographs. The story dateline reads “UMM AL FAHM, Israel, March 24”, which is consistent with publication the following day, March 25, 2002. The photo credit reads “Photographs by Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times”, which confirms the paper.

CP-2002-083 →

· The New York Times

Suicide Bomber, 18, Kills 2 Israelis and Herself

By SERGE SCHMEMANN

JERUSALEM, March 29 — An 18-year-old Palestinian suicide bomber blew herself up at a Jerusalem supermarket today, killing herself and two others and wounding at least 30 people.

The bombing was the latest in a string of terror attacks that prompted the Israeli government to proclaim Yasir Arafat an enemy and to send tanks into Ramallah to batter his compound and isolate him in his office. It also reflected the new use of women as suicide bombers, a role until recently limited to men.

The bomber was identified as Ayat al-Akhras, a high school student from the Dheisheh refugee camp in Bethlehem who went to school in the morning before heading for Jerusalem. In a recorded message, she identified herself as a member of the Aksa Martyrs Brigades, a militant group associated with Mr.

Arafat’s Fatah movement, and assailed Arab leaders for “watching while Palestinian women” were fighting to end Israeli occupation. The attack occurred at the entrance to a supermarket in the blue-collar neighborhood of Kiryat Yovel in southeastern Jerusalem, far from the tourist and social centers of the city, and so an unusual target.

The police said the young woman had approached the store but was stopped by a security guard; she then set off her explosives. A man and a woman were killed. The police said the guard’s vigilance prevented a greater toll, as did the fact that part of her charge failed to detonate. Israeli stores are normally full Friday morning in anticipation of the Sabbath.

The bombing came during a series of fierce hailstorms, adding a striking backdrop to the scene of the broken storefront and the armies of investigators and rescue workers. The bombings have come so frequently that they have become almost ritualized. It was the fourth suicide bombing in the two weeks since the arrival of the American mediator, Gen. Anthony C. Zinni.

The largest of the attacks, a bombing Wednesday evening in a seafront hotel in Netanya, in central Israel, left 22 dead. Sivan Peretz, 20, a cashier in the supermarket, said she had been spared because she was working today at the deli section near the back of the store. “There was a tremendous explosion at the entrance to the store,” she recalled.

“I saw black smoke billowing in the air, as food from the shelves flew all over the ground. People began screaming, ‘Let me out, let me out,’ and the emergency doors were opened at the back of the store.”

Workers cleaned up the wreckage at a Jerusalem supermarket yesterday after a suicide bombing that killed 2 bystanders and wounded 30. —— The suicide bomber, Ayat al-Akhras, 18, in a family photograph. She left a tape faulting Arab leaders for watching as women fought in resistance.

CP-2002-100 →

· The Advocate-Messenger · Danville

Israeli troops round up Palestinians

Subject, verb, object, all five words assigned. Round up is what the papers chose for it, which is a phrase used of cattle and of suspects, and it carries the scale without giving a number.

CP-2002-002 →

· The Anniston Star · Anniston

Palestinian news agency criticized U.S. envoy; warned Arab leaders of being overthrown

From Page 1A West Bank. An Israeli officer and the two Palestinians were killed. President Bush said Saturday that he respects Israel’s right to defend itself and demanded that Arafat do more to stem violence. “I can understand why the Israeli government takes the actions they take. Their country is under attack,” Bush said.

He said Arafat “can do a lot more” to prevent terrorist attacks. “He’s got a lot of people that listen to him still,” Bush said. “He’s got to make it absolutely clear that the Palestinian Authority does not support these terrorist activities.” The Palestinian news agency responded harshly on Sunday, criticizing U.S.

Mideast envoy Anthony Zinni and warning Arab leaders they could be overthrown for failing to back the Palestinians. Wafa, said Arafat “shocked the invader” by refusing to surrender, and complained that the United States and Arab leaders were harming the Palestinian cause.

In a statement signed by the political editor of the agency but giving no name, Wafa said the United States “is godfathering Israel.” The agency also charged that Arab leaders were preventing their people from demonstrating against the United States and Israel. “When nations get fed up by their leaders, they will find the way to remove them,” Wafa said.

Despite the harsh U.S. words for the Palestinians, Washington supported a U.N. Security Council resolution passed early Saturday that called on Israel to withdraw from Palestinian cities, including Ramallah. European nations criticized Israel, calling on it to implement the resolution, while angry protests broke out in several Arab nations.

CP-2002-044 →

· The Beaufort Gazette · Beaufort

Palestinian news agency slams U.S. envoy, Arab leaders

JERUSALEM — With Yasser Arafat under Israeli siege in his West Bank office today, the Palestinian news agency harshly criticized the U.S. Mideast envoy and warned that Arab leaders could be overthrown if they fail to back the Palestinians.

After a series of bloody Palestinian attacks, Israel sent its army into Ramallah on Friday, and tanks crashed into Arafat’s headquarters compound, trapping him in part of his office building in a policy described by the Israelis as “isolation.”

The Palestinian news agency, Wafa, said Arafat “shocked the invader” by refusing to surrender, and complained that the United States and Arab leaders were harming the Palestinian cause.

A statement, signed by the Wafa political editor but giving no name, charged that U.S. envoy Anthony Zinni “has betrayed his mission and became a rubber stamp to Israeli dictations.” Zinni has been trying to negotiate a truce to end 18 months of Palestinian-Israeli violence.

His mission hit a snag after he offered bridging proposals to overcome differences over how to implement a truce plan negotiated last June by CIA director George Tenet. The Israelis said they reluctantly accepted Zinni’s proposals, but the Palestinians requested some changes.

The United States “is godfathering Israel,” the statement said, hoping that “Arafat would collapse and agree to change the Tenet understandings to suit the Israeli desires.” The official Palestinian news agency also charged that Arab leaders were preventing their people from demonstrating against the United States and Israel.

“When nations get fed up by their leaders, they will find the way to remove them,” Wafa wrote. The statement noted that at a summit in Beirut three days ago, Arab leaders offered to make peace with Israel, and said that they must now react to the “hasty Israeli response” to their offer.

CP-2002-045 →

· The New York Times · New York

Grimly, Palestinians Stay Tuned to News

Neil MacFarquhar

“They restored the indoor graveyard here last year. Hundreds of dead, stacked sometimes 10 to a grave, lie under newly poured raw concrete floors in what used to be a mosque.”

Shatila, twenty years after the massacre, watching Jenin on television. MacFarquhar writes the floor before he writes the broadcast, and the floor is the whole history of the camp in one sentence.

CP-2002-059 →

· The New York Times · New York

Daughter Concealed Angry Soul Of a Martyr

“She left that morning at the normal hour, 7 a.m., for the half-hour walk to her high school in a neighboring village.”

Muhammad Akhras, center, with neighbors and relatives, mourned his daughter.

Ayat al-Akhras, 18, of Dheisheh camp, and her father Muhammad, a construction foreman, who thought he knew her. Filed under the standing head The Terrorist. The archive keeps it as written, label and all.

CP-2002-060 →

· Concord Monitor · Concord · page 1

Israel broadens Palestinian offensive

Once the 'Bride of Palestine,' Ramallah a wreck

Daniel Williams, The Washington Post

“RAMALLAH, West Bank – Israeli tanks and troops broadened their offensive into Palestinian areas yesterday with a thrust into the West Bank town of Qalqilya while Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat remained surrounded by a cordon of heavy armor at his headquarters in Ramallah.

Tanks and troop carriers were also reported massing near Bethlehem, and alarmed residents began to stock up on bread and other foods. In Ramallah, roundups of young Palestinian men intensified. Dozens were led away from homes and office buildings shackled by white plastic handcuffs… Life has come to a standstill in Ramallah. Sporadic shooting echoed throughout the day.

Garbage is piling up. Cars smashed by roving tanks lie in twisted heaps. A few burned buildings line major roadways. The curbsides and garden walls have been smashed and utility poles knocked over. Only ambulances, reporters and cats roam the streets. Once known as the Bride of Palestine, Ramallah is a wreck. Soldiers also tried to invade Ramallah Hospital, the city’s biggest.

Hospital workers, led by deputy health minister Munzer Sharif, stood between two tanks that had entered a parking lot outside the emergency room.”

“An Israeli soldier orders two Palestinian men to carry the body of a dead Palestinian inside a house in central Ramallah yesterday. Israeli soldiers rounded up suspected gunmen for detention. Circumstances of the man’s death are unknown.” AP.

The sentence giving Israel’s reason runs off the bottom of the clipping: “Israel said it began the operation in response to a suicide…”

CP-2002-003 →

· The New York Times · New York · page A1

ISRAELIS BROADEN WEST BANK RAIDS AS ARABS PROTEST

No Sign of Any Peace Talk Efforts — Palestinians Strike Again

By JOHN KIFNER with JAMES BENNET

RAMALLAH, West Bank, Tuesday, April 2 — Israeli soldiers and tanks poured into the West Bank on Monday as Palestinians continued attacks and as angry demonstrations spread across the Arab world against Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s all-out campaign against the Palestinians.

Early this morning, the Israeli Army attacked the headquarters of Jibril Rajoub, the powerful Palestinian security chief in the West Bank, who had been a crucial ally of the United States after the 1993 Oslo peace talks, and jailed scores of Islamic militants. The building was set on fire.

In the West Bank, the army moved in force on Monday night into Bethlehem and into Tulkarm to the north with scores of tanks, armored personnel carriers and armored bulldozers backed by infantry. Troops in Qalqilya reinforced their positions and began house to house searches.

Armored vehicles had already been stationed in Beit Jala, the nearby, largely Christian hilltop village within range of the Jewish district of Gilo. But for all of Israel’s military might, Palestinians struck again Monday, as they have in the past few days in Netanya, Tel Aviv, Haifa and Jerusalem.

A sniper, firing from Bethlehem, killed an Israeli in Har Homa, a housing development built on land Israel conquered in 1967. A bomber — the sixth in as many days — blew up his car near a junction that divides East and West Jerusalem, killing the policeman who stopped him for a check. During the day, at least 15 Israeli soldiers were wounded in fighting.

In all, it was another tense, ugly day that left diplomats in despair. There was no sign of Gen. Anthony C. Zinni, who had been dispatched as the American intermediary. As the mood hardened, 11 Arabs, most of them pulled from jail cells and accused of “collaborating” with Israel, were brutally killed by Palestinians in three separate incidents on the West Bank.

The Israeli Army said tonight that it had rounded up more than 700 people in Ramallah since Friday. The streets here, where Yasir Arafat, the Palestinian leader, was besieged in two rooms of his wrecked headquarters for a fourth day, are eerily empty. Iron gates shutter every shop. Residents are running out of food and water.

Protests against Israeli military action spread across the Arab world yesterday, including, left, Cairo; top, Beirut, Lebanon; and Amman, Jordan.

Date check: The full masthead folio is legible: “VOL. CLI .. No. 52,076” / “Copyright © 2002 The New York Times” / “NEW YORK, TUESDAY, APRIL 2, 2002” / “$1 beyond the greater New York metropolitan area.” / “75 CENTS”. Both the paper and the date match the slide label exactly, and April 2, 2002 was a Tuesday. The story’s own dateline also reads “RAMALLAH, West Bank, Tuesday, April 2”.

CP-2002-084 →

· The New York Times · New York

Sharon Would Let Arafat Leave, but Only for Exile

“Israeli armored vehicles pushed for the first time into Manger Square, which Palestinian gunmen have treated as a haven.”

Printed under the standing head Mideast Turmoil: Rejecting Exile, Burying the Dead. The debate the paper stages is about where Arafat would do the most good, or harm, and to whom.

CP-2002-061 →

· The New York Times

Threatened, Couple Flee Apartment In Brooklyn

By SUSAN SAULNY

Death threats have prompted a Brooklyn couple to leave their home amid anger over reports that one of their sons, a humanitarian worker in the Middle East, shared breakfast with Yasir Arafat after being trapped in the Palestinian leader’s besieged compound over the weekend, the couple’s family said.

Noah Shapiro, a Manhattan lawyer, said that his parents, Stuart and Doreen Shapiro, who are both public school teachers, fled their home in Sheepshead Bay on Sunday to stay with friends out of state. He added that he did not feel safe in New York anymore, even as the police presence around his apartment has increased.

“I don’t even think we can measure the emotional toll,” he said. “People in New York have interpreted my brother’s actions to say that he is a terrorist, a traitor, an aide to Arafat. And none of this is based on fact.” In news interviews over the weekend, Adam Shapiro, the humanitarian worker, said he became trapped for a night in Mr.

Arafat’s compound after persuading Israeli military authorities to let ambulances in to treat the injured. He said Mr. Arafat offered him breakfast as a sign of thanks. The death threats against Mr. Shapiro’s parents began after he left the compound on Saturday. The threats to the Shapiros came via e-mail and telephone messages.

Fliers went up around Brooklyn urging people to dial a number where a message denounced Adam Shapiro as a traitor to America and the Jews, compared him to John Walker Lindh and urged his parents to condemn him. The recording even left a purported home address. A Web site also listed personal information about the Shapiro family and urged action against them, Noah Shapiro said.

According to Noah Shapiro, most of the messages wish “a fiery death” to the entire family. “Some of the messages say, ‘We hope,’ and others say, ‘This will happen to you and we will make it happen to you.’” He said the family was turning over all messages to the police, who are monitoring the family’s phone lines.

A spokeswoman for the Police Department refused to comment, citing security issues for the family, but Abraham H. Foxman, the national director of the Anti-Defamation League, confirmed calling law enforcement officials on the family’s behalf. “This is sinister and serious,” Mr. Foxman said.

“We find it reprehensible to target anybody based on what they believe and what they stand for, whether or not we believe in their actions.” In a telephone interview from his home in Ramallah, Adam Shapiro expressed a sense of disbelief about what is happening to his family. “It’s not that I don’t understand people’s anger,” he said.

“But I do think it’s based on hatred and not on a balanced and fair understanding of the situation.”

Doreen and Stuart Shapiro, shown yesterday after they left Brooklyn, received death threats because of their son’s actions in Ramallah.

CP-2002-101 →

· The New York Times

Gazans Await Israeli Attack Despite Lack Of a Buildup

By JOEL BRINKLEY

GAZA, April 2 — Sammy Abu Samhadanah commands a militia here allied with Yasir Arafat, and in his apartment this afternoon he was meeting with nine of his fighters, apportioning weapons and plotting strategy. If Israel attacks the Gaza Strip as it has the West Bank, “we are going to fight; we are ready,” Mr. Abu Samhadanah asserted.

His fighters left, automatic rifles slung over their shoulders, determined looks on their faces. Across the Gaza Strip today, everyone was preparing in his own way for the predicted invasion. But there was no hint of an Israeli military buildup, as there has been around the West Bank cities that have been attacked.

In Jerusalem on Sunday evening, a senior security official said Israel was not as concerned about the Gaza Strip because nearly all of the recent suicide attacks inside Israel had been carried out by Palestinians from the West Bank. That official and the Israeli defense minister have said the government has made no decision about whether to enter Gaza.

The most likely explanation for the lack of urgency, as the security official said, is that around Gaza “there is a fence.” Attackers cannot easily get out and enter Israel. The Erez border crossing, the only entry into Israel, was very quiet today. Gazans are not permitted out. “It’s like a jail here,” a Palestinian border guard said.

“We can’t get out.” What is more, late last week Israeli troops set up military roadblocks that divided the strip into three sections — southern, central and northern. No one goes back and forth between the sections except Israeli settlers, and that has seriously disrupted the workings of the various militia groups. Mr.

Abu Samhadanah, the militia leader, said that “it’s not impossible” for his fighters to get out of Gaza to attack Israel, “but it’s very hard.” Still, he was readying himself. He says he is a wanted man — he has spent time in Israeli jails already, and he expects Israeli soldiers to be looking for him if they do come.

“I am preparing a small bomb,” he said. “If they come for me, I will take some of them with me.” A short time later one of his lieutenants poked his head inside the door to tell him how work on the bomb was going. “We’re making it now,” he said. “If Israel comes they will pay,” Mr. Abu Samhadanah said.

“We know how to deal with them now.” At the central market here in Gaza City, people were buying food in a near panic. One ran up to a streetside store and, eyes wide, shouted: “Is there flour? Is there flour?” No, the merchant responded. It was sold out.

“Yesterday I sold 300 bags of flour, the day before 500,” said Ahmer Al-lakta, who owns one market shop. That is 10 times what he normally sells. “Everybody is scared of war, an Israeli attack on us,” he said. “I think they will be here in five minutes.” Abu Hazeim, 48, a buyer, said, “Everybody in town is worried.”

“I have 13 people at home, and I have to feed them,” he said. “They have closed the road from the south, and that is where the flour comes from. We don’t want to be like they are in Ramallah,” where Israeli forces have enforced a lockdown for four days now. “They can’t buy milk or food. They are trapped in their homes.”

The Israelis, he said, “care only about the land, not the people.” “They don’t want peace,” he said. “They don’t want us.” That was one of the more moderate opinions offered here today. On the other side of town, a dozen members of the Palestinian police, officers and men, were loitering in and around the soccer stadium.

Everyone in Gaza City knows that the police have been camping out at the stadium since Israeli planes destroyed their headquarters earlier this year. But Abu al-Raed, 30, who commands an eight-man squad, insisted as he stood by the stadium entrance that “we are on the street.” “We live on the street,” he said. “We are not here.”

Apparently he was concerned that the concentration of policemen might present an inviting target. “We don’t have anything to do with the place,” he asserted as the others looked on. Still, like everyone here, he was defiant. “If they hit the stadium we will fight back,” he said. “We are Palestinians, and we will shoot back.”

CP-2002-102 →

· The New York Times

Arabs’ Grief in Bethlehem, Bombers’ Gloating in Gaza

By JAMES BENNET and By JOEL BRINKLEY

Bleeding to Death By JAMES BENNET BETHLEHEM, West Bank, April 3 — They did not know much about the Palestinian, just his name, and that he came from a refugee camp, and that they simply could not stop his bleeding. They found him on the stony street on Tuesday morning, shortly after the Israeli ground forces invaded.

He had a big hole in his right side, it seemed from shrapnel, and so they helped him into their two-room home and made him as comfortable as they could on blankets piled on the hard kitchen floor. As the crimson stain crept over his pale blue shirt, they called for an ambulance. They called again and again.

There was a hospital just a few blocks away, but no ambulance could pass through the gunfire or get by the Israeli armored vehicles that were choking the narrow lanes of Bethlehem’s old city. “They told us to give him water and soup,” said Fathia Musa Attiyeh, sobbing as she remembered how helpless she was.

“This morning he said, ‘I’m dying.’” He held out for a few more hours, until about three o’clock this afternoon. By five, his body was stiffening. As a child stared, Issam Issis, who had also cared for the stranger, sat beside the body, gently stroking the black hair and crying softly. The man had been unarmed, Mr. Issis said.

His name was Abdel Khader Abu Ahmed, and he came from a refugee camp in Jordan. Outside, a wailing woman shouted into the air, cursing the Israelis, the Arabs, everybody. An ambulance that finally reached the neighborhood could not take the body.

Two wounded people were already riding atop Hamas Spirits Soar By JOEL BRINKLEY GAZA, April 3 — The leaders of Hamas, the militant Islamic movement responsible for the most deadly suicide attacks in Israel in the last week, are pleased and satisfied just now.

“Our spirit is high, our mood is good,” said Ismail Abu Shanab, one of the organization’s leaders. If Israel attacks Gaza, as it has areas of the West Bank, he and the other leaders would likely be principal targets. For now, they live and operate here openly.

By their estimation, the organization’s two recent attacks — the one at a Seder on Passover night in a Netanya hotel that killed 25 people, and the other in a Haifa cafe that killed 15 — were the most successful they have ever made. That is true partly, Mr.

Shanab said, because Hamas is now using weapons-grade explosives instead of home made bombs manufactured using fertilizer, a fact the Israelis have confirmed. “Forty were killed and 200 injured — in just two operations,” another of the leaders, Mahmoud al-Zahar, said with a smile.

What’s more, Hamas believes that the Palestinian Authority has given up on negotiating with Israel, negotiations that Hamas virulently opposed. That has led to a budding alliance between Hamas and Fatah, the organization headed by Yasir Arafat, the Palestinian leader, despite years of bitter and sometimes violent feuding. Mr.

Arafat “is Palestinian and I am Palestinian,” said Sheik Ahmed Yassin, the spiritual leader of Hamas. “We have the same problem now. Israel is our enemy.”

CP-2002-103 →

· Courier Post · Camden

Killing children

Muslims marching for Arafat might want to rethink the “Stop Killing Our Children” slogan. According to the media, Palestinian mothers are winning fortunes from Arafat and acclaim in the community for strapping bombs on their children and shoving them out the door to detonate in Israeli streets.

Meanwhile in the United States, Stephanie Fitzgerald, the mother awaiting trial for taking the life of her tot, might be regretting having grown up in Pennsauken instead of Palestine. If the accusations are true, she could have earned as much as $25,000 in Palestine and a pat on the back from friends and family members, who stand to share the largess, for killing her child.

If convicted, she can expect jail time with no marching, chanting throng of protesters to shield her from the ignominy of being labeled “child killer.”

CP-2002-047 →

· The New York Times

Life Under Siege

By Allegra Pacheco

BETHLEHEM, West Bank Last Thursday night Jihad Abu Ajour, a young woman living down the road from me, gave birth to her first child in her home in Dheisheh refugee camp in Bethlehem. The Israeli Army was refusing to allow ambulances to approach the camp. Ms. Abu Ajour’s baby was not breathing properly.

Hours later an ambulance finally came to take the baby to the hospital, where he died soon after. Later, under the night curfew and the threat of snipers, the two grandfathers and the father sneaked out of the camp to the nearby cemetery to bury the baby.

In its quest to stop suicide bombings in Israel, the Israeli Army invaded Bethlehem last week and has placed the entire civilian population under siege. The people here are running short of water, food and milk for the young. Those lucky enough to have stored food before the invasion now sit in crowded rooms far away from windows exposed to gunfire.

Those without food wait in desperation for the Red Cross to reach them with supplies. Armored personnel carriers and soldiers patrol the streets, and shots are fired in all directions. A safe corner in the house today can be a deathbed tomorrow. On Monday, the Israeli Army lifted the curfew for a few hours, but that didn’t help much.

The main market and neighborhood stores were almost empty. Because the city has been totally sealed off, no new food has replenished the market shelves. Still, it was good to go outside briefly, after nearly a week when no one dared to step outside for fear of being shot by an Israeli sniper. The sick, though, stay sick in their homes.

The sound of gun and tank fire still echoes around the hills while Israeli soldiers move from neighborhood to neighborhood entering homes, detaining the men and leaving the women, elderly and children abandoned. Hundreds of male residents of Bethlehem have been taken away in the last few days.

They, along with more than 1,000 other Palestinian men, are being held in detention in an Israeli Army base outside Ramallah. Last week, B’Tselem and other Israeli human rights organizations appealed to Israel’s Supreme Court to cancel the military order prohibiting lawyers from visiting the detainees for 18 days after the arrests.

On Sunday the court rejected the petition and upheld the incommunicado detention. The laws of war, as codified in the Fourth Geneva Convention, severely restrict armies from involving civilian populations in military actions. The dignity of each and every person much be respected at all times; the wounded and sick must be cared for.

Yet each additional day of this invasion increases the attack on the civilian population. As an Israeli human rights lawyer representing Palestinians in the West Bank, I am witnessing another stage of the human rights violations that the Israeli occupation has caused.

CP-2002-104 →

· Los Angeles Times

Mideast Tensions at UCLA

By MILTON CARRERO GALARZA

More than 200 pro-Israeli and pro-Palestinian demonstrators engaged in a yelling match outside UCLA’s Kerckhoff Hall on Thursday in yet another campus confrontation arising from the Middle East conflict. While each side struggled to drown out the other, the arguments did not lead to violence.

Students have been protesting at college campuses around the country as hostilities have intensified on the West Bank. Earlier this week, hundreds of pro-Israeli and pro-Palestinian students held simultaneous demonstrations at UC Berkeley. Seventy-nine students were cited after pro-Palestinian protesters occupied Wheeler Hall.

UCLA’s pro-Palestinian demonstration, organized by the Peace and Justice Committee, was originally scheduled for Tuesday, but the student group postponed it to Thursday to avoid interfering with a Holocaust remembrance ceremony.

Thursday’s pro-Palestinian rally lasted nearly two hours and featured several speakers who denounced what they described as atrocities in refugee camps by the U.S.-sponsored Israeli military. In response, Jewish activists carried signs denouncing Palestinian suicide bombings that have killed Israeli civilians.

Iroshi Perera, a sophomore studying neuroscience, stood in the middle of the pro-Israeli and pro-Palestinian groups and tried to listen to the colliding viewpoints. “I’m confused,” she said. “I don’t know what to believe. It’s completely opposite views. They both seem adamant that they are right.”

“I don’t think it accomplished anything because nobody wants to hear each other,” said Neda Sargordan, a junior majoring in political science. But she too was ultimately drawn into a debate with a pro-Israeli demonstrator—one that grew so heated that a university administrator stepped in to mediate.

CP-2002-142 →

· The New York Times · New York

Thousands March in Germany To Oppose Israeli Incursions

Desmond Butler

“Thousands of demonstrators marched in German cities today to protest Israeli incursions into the West Bank. We went to the mosques and asked that radical militant groups stay away.”

Anna Lemberg, 21, a student at the Free University, speaks for the organizers. Solidarity marches in Germany in 2002, with the organizers policing their own demonstration in advance — a dynamic the archive sees again twenty years later.

CP-2002-062 →

· The New York Times · New York

Scene of Devastation, Horror and Minutiae At Jenin Refugee Camp

“Two bodies were seen here today, both found on the second stories of bullet-riddled and scorched houses, both charred beyond recognition. One was a male, just over five feet tall. Part of a sneaker remained on the right foot. The left foot and hand were cinders.”

The minutiae of the headline are a sneaker and a hand. Jenin, four days after the army entered, with the paper still unable to say how many civilians were killed.

CP-2002-063 →

· The New York Times · New York

Arafat Condemns Terror; Powell Meeting On

My father, my brother, my son — I have no one! wailed a woman.

Nahla Abid, left, and Fatmeh Ahmed in a cave under a house in the Jenin refugee camp, where they told of hiding for days from the Israeli Army.

Nahla Abid and Fatmeh Ahmed photographed in a cave under a house in Jenin camp, where they hid for days from the Israeli Army. Bennet writes that people rushed up to strangers to tell their stories, and that they waited for the patrols to pass so they would not be heard wailing.

CP-2002-064 →

· The New York Times

With Powell Coming, Israel Eases Grip in Ramallah

By JOEL BRINKLEY

RAMALLAH, West Bank, April 13 — The commander of Israeli forces in central Ramallah said today that he is trying to relax the siege on Yasir Arafat’s compound here, “at least for the time being.” During a quick tour of the site with a military escort this afternoon, the atmosphere appeared calm, although an armored cordon remained.

“It has been so sensitive and tense that we have stepped back a little bit,” said Col. Uzi Moskowitz, who commands Israeli forces in the most important parts of this city. “There was just too much friction, and shooting.” … Palestinians say the Israelis are ransacking their houses. Colonel Moskowitz is unapologetic.

“This is a city of war,” he declared. “This is a city of occupation, by us.” He described some of the recent suicide bombings — 132 Israelis have been killed in these attacks since March 1 — and said, “Enough is enough; that is our feeling.”

Israeli soldiers patrolled yesterday in the center of Ramallah, where the Palestinian leader, Yasir Arafat, remained besieged in his headquarters.

CP-2002-115 →

· The New York Times · page A10

Inside a Siege, Signs of Life and Loss

By TODD S. PURDUM

RAMALLAH, West Bank, April 14 — The one they call “old man” walks the halls of what is left of his once-proud compound here. In the wee hours, Yasir Arafat’s followers can hear him prowling past the makeshift quarters where they have been confined by Israeli tanks and snipers for 17 days now, sharing mattresses on the floor.

“Sometimes he comes down and looks around, and checks the rooms,” said Mohamed Masharqa, 42, a journalist who works for a Palestinian daily newspaper, Al Ayam, and has been living in the compound. “He talks to his guys: ‘How are you? Don’t worry. Take care of yourselves. Stay away from the windows,’ he says.

‘It’s not safe.’ We sleep in shifts. I hear his voice sometimes in the morning.” The Israeli siege has left Mr. Arafat and a few dozen aides, sympathizers and international peace protesters virtually isolated in a few rooms, often without electricity, water or working plumbing. Secretary of State Colin L.

Powell’s visit to the compound in a heavily armed and armored motorcade this morning gave outsiders a rare look inside, and it was fairly grim. “I am down to the last analgesics,” said Dr.

Zedi Abu Shawish, a surgeon and deputy director of hospitals for the West Bank who said he has been caring for a half dozen wounded Palestinian fighters inside with dwindling supplies left by the Red Cross, performing an amputation below the knee on one man with just local anesthetic. “I need first of all the water.

It’s the most important here for us, because if I have more diarrhea here, it will be messy.” As Israeli tanks pulled just far enough away to let Secretary Powell’s convoy pass, the 14 American journalists traveling with him got only the briefest glimpse inside the compound today, and a sanitized glimpse at that, people staying in the compound said.

CP-2002-105 →

· The New York Times · New York, NY

For Palestinian Refugees, Dream of Return Endures

By NEIL MacFARQUHAR

BAQAA REFUGEE CAMP, Jordan, April 13 — Any boy wandering lost in the warren of streets and alleyways that form this camp will inevitably tell a concerned adult that he comes from someplace he has almost surely never been. “Jerusalem” he will say, or “Nablus,” or he will name some hamlet that once stood on land in what is now Israel.

The adult will know precisely how to get the child home. The refugees who fled the Israeli-Arab wars of 1948 or 1967 and ended up here named the quarters of the camp after the towns and villages they left behind, making the street map into a quilt of longing.

Their existence as refugees was supposed to be temporary, yet 54 years after the creation of Israel, millions of Palestinian refugees exist in suspended animation. Ever since that initial exodus in 1948, they have not been able to return home or assimilate. Feeling rejected everywhere, they keep their eyes firmly fixed on the horizon behind them.

The expectation that they will return ebbs and flows with the tide of violence across the Jordan River. But time is also reshaping that expectation. … “The reason for this fantastic attachment to Palestine is partly because the Arabs encouraged it,” said Kamel Abu Jaber, a retired Jordanian foreign minister and a peace negotiator.

“To say, let’s settle them, let’s absorb them, was considered treason and still is.” Predictions of old that the children of the 1948 refugees would forget about Palestine proved premature; indeed their great-grandchildren are now learning to spout the tortured list of historical, religious, legal and cultural reasons that they should be allowed back.

Masthead-verified date — the only clipping in the batch with a printed folio line carrying the full date. Terminologically this is a “Palestinian refugees” story, not an “Israeli Arab” one; its one use of “Israeli-Arab” names the 1948 and 1967 wars, which is a different sense of the compound entirely and should not be counted toward Maria’s pattern.

CP-2002-122 →

· The Blade · Toledo

Palestine an invention of Arab propaganda

Mona Charen

WASHINGTON — Several members of the Nobel Committee have expressed regrets about the Peace Prize that was jointly awarded to Yasser Arafat and Shimon Peres in 1994.

This is certainly understandable — one of the recipients has consistently failed to live up to the promises made in Oslo, lied repeatedly about that failure, imported arms and explosives against the explicit wording of the Oslo agreement, sent teenagers to blow themselves up amid civilians, and actively fomented a wider war.

But the person the Nobel committee regrets honoring is not Mr. Arafat — it is Mr. Peres! Europe is shaming itself. Across the continent, crowds fill the streets demonstrating against Israel. Synagogues are burning all over France. Old anti-Semitic imagery and language is resurfacing.

The Italian newspaper La Stampa ran a cartoon featuring an Israeli tank pointing its muzzle at the crib of baby Jesus with the tag line, “Don’t tell me they want to kill me again.” On April 10, the European Parliament voted to impose trade sanctions on Israel. Some of this is simple Jew hatred. Some is a sinister response to guilt.

Since the Holocaust happened on European soil, how cleansing to believe that the Jews are now the guilty parties, which is why the Nazi analogy crops up with nauseating regularity vis a vis the Israelis, probably more often than it is invoked against anyone else (except perhaps for America in Vietnam).

This is monstrous, and in an ideal world, Secretary of State Colin Powell and President Bush would be saying so. Instead, they, too, are undermining the Israelis, demanding that Israel permit terror to succeed — thus utterly clouding America’s clear stand against terror.

But some of this anti-Israel sentiment represents a victory for Arab propaganda and lies about the origin of the conflict — lies that have been swallowed whole by large segments of the press and public even in the United States. A one-stop shopping book puts these myths to rest. Joan Peters set out to write a sympathetic history of the Palestinian “struggle.”

Her research soon persuaded her that nearly everything she thought she knew about the Arab-Jewish conflict in the Middle East was wrong. Her meticulously researched book, From Time Immemorial, was published in 1984 but is still in print. The Arabs have successfully blurred the true history of what happened when Israel was formed in 1948.

Six hundred thousand Jewish refugees from Arab nations fled to Israel — many in fear for their lives, most after having their property expropriated. They were assimilated by Israel. About the same number of Arab refugees fled what is now Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza.

They were not assimilated by the Arab nations, with whom they shared a common religion, ethnicity, history, and language, but were instead herded into refugee camps, the better to “return” to their homes after Israel was obliterated by Arab armies. Further, these Arab refugees had no ancient tie to the land of “Palestine.”

When Mark Twain visited the Holy Land in 1867, he found to his dismay that the land was barren. “Stirring scenes ... occur in the valley (Jezreel) no more. There is not a solitary village throughout its whole extent — not for 30 miles in either direction. There are two or three small clusters of Bedouin tents, but not a single permanent habitation.

One may ride 10 miles hereabouts and not see 10 human beings.” But when large numbers of Jews began to resettle the land in the 1880s and made it more prosperous, large numbers of Arab migrants began to arrive. The whole idea of a Palestinian nation and a Palestinian people is an invention of Arab propaganda. Mr. Arafat is himself an Egyptian.

The only people to have lived continuously on the land “from time immemorial” are Jews. It is not and never was “Palestinian land.” Mona Charen’s column is distributed by Creators Syndicate.

Eighty-three years after Binghamton, the argument has stopped describing Palestinian speech as propaganda and started describing Palestinians as propaganda. The column’s evidence for an empty country is a traveler’s impression of one valley in 1867. This archive answers that from its own shelves: nine years before the 1919 article, and twenty-six years after Mark Twain, an Ohio paper was printing a report on the orange groves that surrounded the port of Jaffa, 1,780 acres of them, watered by hand from wells a hundred feet deep.

CP-2002-029 →

· The New York Times

Only Label for American in Ramallah Is ‘Human Being’

By JOEL GREENBERG

JERUSALEM, April 17 — After more than two weeks under curfew in Ramallah, Adam Shapiro and his fiancée came here this week for a brief respite and some organizational work before returning to the battered West Bank city that is still occupied by Israeli troops.

At an East Jerusalem hotel, the couple was fielding calls on three cellphones from fellow activists in West Bank cities that have been invaded by the Israelis. Later, they helped arrange shipments of food and medical supplies to Palestinians confined to their homes. Mr.

Shapiro, an American Jew from Brooklyn living in Ramallah, gained attention when he entered Yasir Arafat’s compound with an ambulance shortly after Israel tanks broke through its walls last month.

His account of events inside the besieged offices of the Palestinian leader were widely reported, earning him harsh criticism from right-wing Jewish groups who labeled him a traitor. His parents moved out of their home in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, after receiving death threats, and the police still keep an eye on their house.

Arriving for an interview in a bandana, earrings and a stubbly beard, Mr. Shapiro, 30, seemed unfazed by the criticism, and intent on pursuing his work in Ramallah with his fiancée, Huwaida Arraf, a Palestinian-American from Detroit. They plan to marry in Detroit next month, passing through New York on the way.

Police officers will be at the airport to deter possible violence, Mr. Shapiro said. “I’m not as scared of a sniper outside my house in Ramallah as I am of some crazy in New York City,” he added, half-jokingly. Since leaving Mr. Arafat’s compound, Mr. Shapiro and Ms.

Arraf have been busy challenging the Israeli curfew, defying Israeli snipers by walking the streets and delivering food and medicine.

Adam Shapiro, raised Jewish in America, and his fiancée, Huwaida Arraf, a Palestinian-American, oppose Israeli actions in the West Bank.

CP-2002-106 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Forces Pull Back From Jenin, But Blockade Still Remains

James Bennet

“Israel withdrew its forces to the outskirts of the fetid ruins here.”

The pullback and the blockade in the same headline, which is the shape of most withdrawals in this archive.

CP-2002-065 →

· Quad City Times · Davenport · page 1

Demonstration

Muslim Community of Q.C., Davenport

“DEMONSTRATION. Come join us to protest the genocide in Palestine and to end the Israeli Occupation. Date: Saturday, April 20. Time: 12:00-1:00 p.m. Location: Intersection of Kimberly and Brady in Davenport. Contact: 359-8123. Sponsored by: Muslim Community of Q.C.”

Paid space, not reporting. A local Muslim community buying a box in an Iowa daily in 2002 to use the word, with a street corner and a phone number under it.

CP-2002-004 →

· The Journal News · White Plains · page 1

Increased criticism of Israel justified

Mideast crisis

Letters

Under “Increased criticism of Israel justified”: “Robert Klein (April 13 ‘In Reply’) is ‘troubled’ by Khalil Amiri’s reasoned presentation (April 6 ‘Community View’) of the Palestinian cause. More troubling to him should be the erosion of good will toward Israel that has long existed in America.”

Under “Israel must defend its population”: “It was the Arabs who rejected this plan and every other plan since. Israel’s territorial expansion since 1948 has come at a great price due to the invasion or threats of invasion by its Arab neighbors.”

Under “Zionist propaganda dehumanizes Arabs”: “I was shocked that The Journal News published Ann Ganeles’ hate-filled April 13 letter. She personally attacked Maher Al-Jamal, a fellow Westchester resident, who simply expressed his wish to educate his children on their ancestral language and customs by sending them to live in his native Jordan.”

Four letters on one page, running in both directions: Richard Cross of Tarrytown, Nancy Rabin Neff of New Rochelle, Lynn R. Lowin of Scarsdale and Anabela DeAlmeida of Yonkers. They are arguing with each other and with two pieces the paper had already run, one of them a Community View by Khalil Amiri.

CP-2002-005 →

· The Miami Herald · Miami · page 1

Tales of bloodshed emerge from Jenin

MOURNING: A young Palestinian prays for a loved one at the Jenin refugee camp hospital, where corpses were being delivered. Mike Nelson / AP.

The photograph is the item: rows of body bags on the ground, one person kneeling among them with their face in their hands. The headline runs underneath it.

CP-2002-006 →

· Corvallis Gazette-Times · Corvallis · page 1

U.S., Israel both failing in war against terrorism

Donald J. Martel, Corvallis

“Ariel Sharon of Israel and George W. Bush of the United States of America, are demonstrating to the world that killing is not putting an end to terrorism.

Israel has a trained army, Palestine does not; Israel has 3,900 tanks, Palestine has none; Israel has artillery, Palestinian children throw stones; Israel has an air force, Palestine does not; Israel has bulldozers, Palestine does not; Israel is supported by the United States of America, Palestine is not. Sharon claims that he is conducting a war against terrorism.

Bush claims that he is conducting a war against terrorism. Sharon and Bush, after spending many billions of dollars, have shown no positive results. Both Bush and Sharon are killing people, creating more terrorists and propagating more hatred. Our Congress permits these men of little intellect to lead us down a pathway to possible chaos.

Civilization, as we know it, could be destroyed by unending warfare but these fearless leaders continue their misguided policies that are akin to genocide in Palestine and indistinguishable from terrorism elsewhere.”

A reader’s letter built as a list of asymmetries, one clause each.

CP-2002-007 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore

"What happened in Jenin camp has caused enormous suffering of innocent Palestinian civilians."

A pull quote set across a column in the Baltimore Sun nine days after the fighting in Jenin ended. What happened is the subject of the sentence — a thing that happened, with no one making it happen — and what it caused is suffering. The people it happened to are given two qualifiers before they are given a noun.

CP-2002-008 →

· The Journal News · White Plains · page 1

Thousands at D.C. rally denounce Israeli, U.S. policies

Kristoffer A. Garin, The Journal News

“…wearing a ‘Free Palestine’ baseball cap struggled with a sign nearly as big as he was. On his wavering placard was a gruesome photo of a bloody Palestinian infant and the words, ‘Our tax dollars at work.’ Marchers also voiced their opposition to global economic policies, racial profiling and nuclear weapons. Police reported no arrests.

Near the main rally, a small group supporting America’s war on terror staged a counterprotest. In front, a handwritten sign had an arrow pointing to the pro-Palestinian demonstration with the message: ‘Cowards and traitors rally.’ But Alaby called the suicide bombings desperate acts of people who believe the world could not care less about their fate.

‘Those who support the Palestinian struggle generally don’t support suicide bombing,’ she said. ‘But to speak of terrorism in this issue, you have to start with Israeli terrorism.’ The marchers came from all over the country, including at least 200 from Westchester County.

Early in the morning, rest stops along the highways between New York and Washington filled with busloads of expectant marchers. Red- or black-checkered scarves, known as kaffiyehs, were worn by many either as an expression of cultural pride or solidarity with the Palestinians. As the protesters chanted in front of her, Tami Anaya could not muster such hate.

Still tired from an eight-hour bus trip from Buffalo, the former Marine Corps lance corporal and Seattle native sat on the edge of the protest. Just over seven months after losing her brother on Flight 93, which crashed Sept. 11 in Pennsylvania, the 38-year-old painter and photographer cried much of the morning thinking about him.

Although she has reason for revenge, Anaya said she wants peace because too many people have suffered. ‘What happened to my brother woke me up, and I’m not comfortable being passively patriotic,’ she said. ‘I just can’t support terrorizing another human being.’”

“Protesters march in Washington, D.C., yesterday, carrying a stretcher with a child to signify violence against children in the Israeli-occupied territories.” Robert A. Sabo / The Journal News. A placard in the crowd reads “STOP US FUNDING OF GENOCIDE.”

A jump page; the story begins on 1A, which is not on this clipping. A sister of a Flight 93 passenger is quoted at the end, at the edge of the march.

CP-2002-009 →

· Daily Herald

Protest capital of the U.S.

Mideast issue rises above other topics

The Washington Post; and, alongside, the Los Angeles Times

“Protest capital of the U.S. · Mideast issue rises above other topics WASHINGTON — Tens of thousands converged on downtown Washington Saturday to demonstrate for a variety of causes, but it was the numbers and passion of busloads of Arab Americans and their supporters that dominated the streets.

Eager to make their presence felt and their voices heard in the nation’s capital as never before, Arab and Muslim families marched and chanted for an end to U.S. military aid to Israel, overwhelming the messages of those with causes in a peaceful day of downtown rallies and marches. Young men wore the Palestinian flag around their necks like a cape.

Arabic was heard nearly as often as English, and cardboard signs held by women and children denounced Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon and President Bush.

Protesters rallying against corporate wrongs and the global economy found themselves tweaking Vietnam War-era chants to the Palestinian cause, shouting, ‘One, two, three, four: We don’t want no Mideast war!’

‘The message here is we must support the Palestinian people against a military occupation and an apartheid state,’ said Randa Jamal, a graduate student at New York’s Columbia University who joined thousands at a pro-Palestinian rally near the White House.

She said her cousins were killed in Ramallah, and her 16-year-old sister has been unable to attend school because of the Israeli occupation. ‘What they are going through,’ she said, ‘is crimes against humanity.’

Palestinian rights was the theme of two of four permitted marches that merged on Pennsylvania Avenue in a loud and colorful procession to the Capitol. The host of other issues — anti-corporate globalization, antiwar and anti-U.S. policies in several areas — were boiled down to an essence visible on banners, placards and T-shirts.

Banners read: ‘Drop debt, not bombs’ and ‘Peace treaty in Korea now.’ Bumper stickers on T-shirts declared: ‘No blank check for endless war’ and ‘We are all Palestinian.’

It was possible to stand on the Washington Monument grounds and hear simultaneous speeches from three rallies nearby, antiwar demonstrators, counter-demonstrators and pro-Palestinian activists, in a mind-boggling surround-sound mix.

Israel pulling out of West Bank cities

Israeli officials say they will cooperate with a U.N. probe of the army’s attack on Jenin. JERUSALEM — Israel began pulling forces out of the West Bank cities of Nablus and Ramallah Saturday night, and officials said they will cooperate with a United Nations probe into the army’s devastating attack on the Jenin refugee camp.

The Israeli moves, however, did not include ending the siege of Palestinian Authority President Yasser Arafat’s compound in Ramallah. They came as President Bush was meeting at Camp David with members of his national security team, including Secretary of State Colin Powell, to discuss what peace efforts the U.S. might make next.

Powell, who on Wednesday ended a 10-day overseas trip focused on the Mideast conflict, failed either to persuade Israel to immediately withdraw from all Palestinian-controlled areas or to induce Arafat to declare a cease-fire. U.S. Middle East envoy William Burns toured the wrecked Jenin camp Saturday as refugees and aid workers continued to search for bodies in the rubble.

He declared it the site of ‘terrible human tragedy.’ But Israeli officials said they are confident the United Nations will determine that no massacre of civilians took place during the eight-day military offensive, as Palestinians have charged.

Hospital officials in Jenin reported Saturday that 42 bodies had been pulled from the remains of homes and other buildings bulldozed during the furious Israeli assault. Twenty-three Israeli soldiers also were killed during the fighting in the camp, which Israel said it conquered because nearly two dozen suicide bombers came from its warren of homes.

Rescue efforts continued to be hampered by the presence of explosives left behind during the battle. A Palestinian medic who had volunteered his services suffered severe injuries to a foot Saturday when he stepped on what local doctors said was a mine. It was unclear whether the device was left behind by Israeli or Palestinian fighters.

The Israeli army reported that a suspected Palestinian suicide bomber exploded at a checkpoint on the western side of the West Bank town of Kalkilya on Saturday afternoon, after soldiers there called on him to halt as he walked through. There was no immediate claim of responsibility by any group.

And in Gaza, a lone Palestinian gunman opened fire at the Erez checkpoint between Israel and Gaza, killing a border policeman before he was shot dead by an Israeli tank, both the army and Palestinian sources reported. The Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigade militia, an offshoot of Arafat’s mainstream Fatah faction, claimed responsibility for the attack.”

“A dizzying variety of signs denouncing Israel’s military action in the West Bank nearly becomes a blur as tens of thousands of protesters march on Washington, D.C., on Saturday. Palestinian solidarity protesters weren’t alone as people converged on the Capitol to protest a range of issues, including U.S. policy in the Mideast and corporate greed.”

Associated Press.

Two dispatches set side by side on one page. On the left a march in Washington, where the person the Washington Post chooses to quote is a named Palestinian graduate student — Randa Jamal — who says her cousins were killed in Ramallah and her 16-year-old sister cannot get to school. On the right, Jenin: 42 bodies pulled from bulldozed buildings, 23 Israeli soldiers killed, and Israeli officials saying they are confident the United Nations will find that no massacre took place. The two headlines never touch each other.

CP-2002-028 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco · page 1

Ex-ambassador calls Arafat obstructionist

Clinton envoy fuels criticism in Congress

Edward Epstein, Chronicle Washington Bureau

“WASHINGTON — A former top U.S. Mideast negotiator’s statement that Yasser Arafat scuttled attempts to reach an accord under former President Bill Clinton fueled criticism of the Palestinian leader yesterday and set the stage for a congressional vote as soon as today that would tag Arafat as an obstacle to peace.

Former Ambassador Dennis Ross’ remarks, vigorously disputed by Palestinian representatives, buttressed the view of many in Congress and the Bush administration who believe Arafat ruined ambitious peace initiatives by Clinton and then-Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak in the final days of Clinton’s presidency.

The peace talks’ failure, in turn, led to the anger that fueled Palestinian suicide bombings and Israel’s recent West Bank military action, Arafat’s critics say… According to Ross, Arafat rejected a deal in January 2001 that would have given the Palestinians 97 percent of the disputed West Bank, all of the Gaza Strip, a capital in East Jerusalem, a $30 billion international fund to pay for resettling Palestinians in their own state and an international force in the Jordan Valley.

Ross, who spent thousands of hours in talks with Palestinian and Israeli negotiators, said on Fox News that he now believes Arafat was never interested in an agreement, although his aides in the Palestinian Authority were. ‘Arafat’s whole life has been governed by struggle and a cause. ...

For him to end the conflict is to end himself,’ Ross said in an interview on Fox News… Palestinian negotiators, however, say Ross’ version of events is wrong. Hassan Abdel Rahman, the Palestinian representative in Washington since 1994, said those who said that the Palestinians had caused the current crisis were mistaken.

‘Some in this town say, “Well, the Palestinians deserve it. They brought it onto themselves, because they were offered a very generous deal in Camp David, and they rejected it.” And this lie has been repeated so often in this town to the point where it has become a fact or appears to be a fact,’ he said at a forum sponsored by the U.S.

Institute for Peace. Rahman contended that no formal offer had ever been made, and that Israel’s positions on resettling refugees, the future of Jerusalem, security arrangements for the West Bank and its insistence on controlling West Bank airspace were all unacceptable.

Rahman said Arafat had told Clinton not to force the sides into the Camp David summit because they weren’t ready.

‘We offered Israel a compromise with the hope that they will behave as neighbors with us, that they will respect our humanity and our dignity, not to perpetually control us and deprive us of every right that every one of you take for granted,’ Rahman said.

Ross’ remarks sparked Feinstein to take to the Senate floor, where she read large pieces of his interview to colleagues, and said his comments were the most thorough account she had yet seen of Clinton’s lame-duck peace efforts. ‘When push came to shove, Yasser Arafat said no,’ said Feinstein. Last week, she and Sen.

Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., introduced a bill that would designate Arafat’s group as a terrorist organization and enact sanctions against it. ‘I think Yasser Arafat is totally responsible for the problems in the Middle East,’ said Sen. Harry Reid, D-Nev.”

“Former U.S. Ambassador Dennis Ross said Yasser Arafat rejected a peace deal last year.”

The generous-offer claim and the Palestinian answer to it in one column, and the Palestinian representative names the mechanism he objects to: that a thing repeated often enough in Washington becomes a fact.

CP-2002-010 →

· USA Today · McLean, VA (national edition) · page 9A

Palestinians see cruelty, pettiness in damage

Israel says troops razed only what they had to

By Paul Wiseman, USA TODAY

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Mohammed al-Assmar is still trying to figure out how his ’78 Fiat fit into Israel’s plans to crush Palestinian terrorism on the West Bank. The little yellow car was destroyed during Israel’s military assault on this West Bank city, the unofficial Palestinian capital. Israeli troops hauled the crumpled Fiat into the street to use as a barricade.

Now Assmar, 47, a Palestinian civil servant, can’t ferry his three kids to school. “I don’t think my car was a terrorist,” he says. Such bewilderment and anger are common here as Palestinians survey losses from Israel’s 25-day incursion.

In addition to destroying civilian property and claiming an unknown number of lives, Israeli troops demolished, damaged or seized much of what Yasser Arafat’s Palestinian Authority needs to function as a government — from water mains to computer servers to student transcripts.

The World Bank today will estimate damage to Palestinian areas of the West Bank at $200 million to $300 million, USA TODAY has learned. The estimate is to be presented at a meeting of aid donors in Oslo, Norway. It tallies damage from March 1, when Israel began ratcheting up retaliation against suspected terrorists.

Hardest hit has been the city of Nablus, where tanks, troops, bulldozers and aerial assaults have caused up to $100 million in damage. Jenin and Ramallah each are believe to have sustained more than $50 million in damage.

Israelis say the wreckage was unavoidable because the foundations of Arafat’s fledgling Palestinian state are indistinguishable from the terrorist infrastructure Israel set out to destroy. “We tried to differentiate between the terrorists within the (Palestinian Authority) and the PA itself, but sometimes they are interconnected,” says Col.

Miri Eisin, an intelligence officer with the Israel Defense Forces. Israelis say the raids on Palestinian government offices turned up a bonanza of secret documents tying Arafat to terrorism and helped lead them to the men behind a wave of attacks on Israel.

The Israeli military says it has captured or killed 32 of the 50 highest-ranking Palestinian militants — including top figures in radical Hamas and Islamic Jihad — since the incursion began March 29. Israel’s top capture is Marwan Barghouti, West Bank chief of Arafat’s Fatah faction.

Zero uses of “Arab”. By April 2002 USA TODAY’s register for the West Bank is “Palestinian” without exception, and the people in the story are named, aged and quoted. Worth putting beside the 1997 Boston Globe clipping to show what the vocabulary looks like when the subject is Palestinians under occupation rather than Palestinians who hold Israeli citizenship.

CP-2002-123 →

· The New York Times

In Grim Cortege, 9 Arabs Carry Dead From Church

By C.J. CHIVERS

BETHLEHEM, West Bank, April 25 — Nine Palestinian youths were evacuated today from the Church of the Nativity, ending their involvement in the siege by forming a bizarre funereal processional out of the church and into a gantlet of leveled Israeli guns. The youths carried two coffins holding the bodies of Palestinians who had been killed earlier in the siege.

The procession, which began at the entrance to the compound built on the site where Jesus is believed to have been born, could hardly have been stranger: a slow-moving column of weary Muslim teenagers, led by robed Christian monks, carrying bodies in front of Israeli tanks and paratroopers.

… “I saw how they treat my people and what they think of my people when they let that happen to our bodies,” said Shefah Saman, a Red Crescent volunteer, who later in the day asked visitors to look inside the coffins and examine the badly decomposed remains at the Beit Jala Hospital.

Israel took a milder view, saying the evacuation was a promising sign and meant that the two sides might soon be able to end the siege peacefully. The dead men were identified as Khalid Abu Suihan, 24, a member of the Palestinian Authority’s national security force, and Husan Nusman, 27, a civilian. Both were from the Gaza Strip. Israel has said the dead were gunmen.

But Dr. Peter Qumri, director of the hospital, said that one had been shot in the head while fighting a fire inside the compound, and that a sniper’s bullet had struck the other in the shoulder and burrowed into his chest when he bent over in the compound garden to pick lettuce. “He was hungry,” Dr. Qumri said. Neither version could be independently verified.

Arab youths and two priests removed a coffin from the Church of the Nativity. Israelis opened the coffins to check for explosives.

CP-2002-113 →

· The New York Times

Israel Refuses to Recognize Greek Orthodox Patriarch

By SERGE SCHMEMANN

JERUSALEM, April 25 — The Israeli government has once again refused to recognize the new Greek Orthodox patriarch of Jerusalem, the custodian of most of the Christian religious sites in the region. The patriarch, Irineos, was elected by the bishops of the Jerusalem patriarchate in August and enthroned on Sept.

15 as the leader of the oldest and largest church in the Holy Land. Since then, however, the Israeli government has refused to grant him formal recognition, a decision the cabinet restated on Sunday. … Jordan and the Palestinian Authority, whose lands are part of the Jerusalem patriarchate, endorsed Patriarch Irineos, but Israel refused.

In an interview with The Jerusalem Post in November, Patriarch Irineos declared, “I am not pro-Palestinian, nor pro-Israeli, nor pro-anything. I am only pro-God.”

Patriarch Irineos leads the Holy Land’s oldest and largest church.

CP-2002-114 →

· The New York Times · page A11

Arafat Court Said to Convict 4 Israel Seeks

By SERGE SCHMEMANN

JERUSALEM, April 25 — The Israeli-Palestinian confrontation shifted increasingly to the political and public relations fronts today as Palestinians besieged with Yasir Arafat announced that they had tried and convicted four assassins of an Israeli government minister.

Israel has declared the surrender of those and other wanted men as a central condition for ending the military siege of Mr. Arafat’s headquarters in Ramallah, where the trial was held with the men present.

The Palestinian Authority said a “military field court” under Ribhi Arafat, a military judge not related to the Palestinian leader, had given the four men sentences ranging from one to 18 years. A statement said Mr. Arafat had ratified the sentences.

A Palestinian military court meeting in Yasir Arafat’s offices yesterday. It sentenced four Palestinians in the killing of Israel’s tourism minister. / Palestinians walked in the devastation of the Jenin refugee camp yesterday.

At the United Nations, Israelis are trying to restrict a fact-finding mission centering on Jenin that is scheduled to arrive in Israel on Saturday.

CP-2002-116 →

· Press & Sun-Bulletin · Binghamton · page 1

Protesters stand up for Palestinians

Binghamton demonstrators criticize actions by Israelis

Scott Rockefeller, Correspondent

BINGHAMTON — About 60 demonstrators gathered Friday in front of the Broome County Courthouse to protest the treatment of Palestinians in Israel. The demonstrators carried a wide array of signs, some reading “No Justice, No Peace,” “Stop Genocide in Palestine” and “Sharon Must Stop His Nazism.”

Farouq Al-Khalidi of Binghamton said it was their responsibility to speak out against the terror being directed at Palestinians. “We would feel terribly guilty if we didn’t exercise our rights as citizens and express our views,” Al-Khalidi said. He said there is a lack of support for the Palestinians because of ignorance.

“If most Americans knew the real story, they would probably be more sympathetic,” Al-Khalidi said. The demonstration, organized by the Islamic Organization of the Southern Tier, included a march from the courthouse to the Federal Building. Among the protesters were local religious leaders and students.

Union-Endicott High School student Mohammed Ansari had one reason for demonstrating…

“These are not the faces of Terrorism . . . but of Massacre,” reads a sign held by Moinuddin Ansari of Binghamton, who attended Friday’s Pro-Palestinian Peace Protest with his 3-year-old son Ammaar, not pictured, in front of the Broome County Courthouse.”

Suzie O’Rourke / Press & Sun-Bulletin · “About 60 people gathered Friday in front of the Broome County Courthouse to show their support for peace in the Middle East. As demonstrators later walked from the courthouse to the Federal Building, they chanted phrases like ‘End the occupation!’ ‘No Justice.

No Peace.’ and ‘Stop the Genocide in Palestine.’ The demonstrations were peaceful.”

Sixty people outside a courthouse in upstate New York. The photographed sign is a board of pasted-on newspaper pictures with a hand-lettered line across it. The story continues on 4B, which is not on this clipping.

CP-2002-011 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

ARABS IN DISGUISE KILL FOUR SETTLERS IN THE WEST BANK

GIRL, 5, AMONG THE SLAIN | Raid May Increase Pressure for New Army Action, as Bush Seeks Israeli Pullback

By JAMES BENNET

ADORA, West Bank, April 27 — Three Palestinian gunmen dressed like Israeli soldiers cut through the fence surrounding this small Jewish settlement today and attacked the residents while they were relaxing on a Sabbath morning, killing four, including a 5-year-old girl, the Israeli Army said.

Seven people were wounded, one of them critically, as the gunmen went house to house, also firing at armed settlers who tried to defend their homes but apparently mistook the attackers for soldiers. As Israeli forces rushed to the scene, the men escaped back through their hole in the fence and vanished into the deep valleys surrounding Adora’s isolated hilltop.

Soldiers later found and killed one of them, the army said. It was the deadliest assault on a settlement since Israel began its sweep in the West Bank on March 29, and another blow to the fragile diplomacy seeking to contain the violence in the Middle East.

The attack was almost certain to prompt the Israeli government to consider dispatching more ground forces to this area, just as President Bush has stepped up his call for a full Israeli withdrawal from Palestinian-controlled territory. Mr.

Bush is himself under pressure, from the government of Saudi Arabia, which warned him this week that he must temper his support for Israeli measures against Palestinians or risk undermining American credibility in the Arab world. Israeli government officials said the attack proved the need for the military measures in the West Bank.

Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping — it is a single trimmed column that begins at the headline and ends at “Continued on Page 14”. The story dateline reads “ADORA, West Bank, April 27”, consistent with publication on April 28, 2002. Nothing on the clipping names the newspaper.

CP-2002-085 →

· The New York Times

Israel Says Palestinians Link Arafat to Terrorism

which by treaty has limited power to govern Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. For his part, Mr.

Arafat, though pale and seemingly frail, appeared among his people this morning with his broad smile and characteristic ambiguity intact, speaking of a commitment to peace and lashing out at the Israeli government over its military offensive into Palestinian-controlled territory in the West Bank.

Israeli forces raided the West Bank cities of Tulkarm and Hebron today, the army said, arresting several Palestinian men. [Early Friday, the Israeli Army entered Nablus, destroying a three-story building and killing a Palestinian policeman, The Associated Press reported.

The Israeli military did not comment.] The Bush administration has called for a halt to such raids, but Israel says they are necessary for its defense. Palestinians say the raids are intended to blur and ultimately to erase negotiated boundaries. On a tour of Ramallah, Mr.

Arafat stopped in a hospital parking lot to pray over an improvised grave for Palestinians who died during the Israeli offensive here, and he viewed damage to the city. “Unbelievable, what has happened,” he said. The Israeli statement tonight came as Mr. Sharon was preparing to go to Washington for a meeting early next week with President Bush.

A senior political adviser said that Mr. Sharon planned to present “specific and detailed proposals” that “could include short-term territorial concessions,” provided that Palestinian violence completely halted. Mr.

Sharon has indicated that he is willing to consider steps to provide the Palestinians with “territorial contiguity,” that is, paths to move among the islands of territory now under their control without crossing Israeli-controlled land and army checkpoints. Mr. Sharon also plans to discuss with President Bush a possible regional summit meeting, the adviser said.

Well-wishers mobbed Yasir Arafat yesterday after he left his compound for the first time since the Israeli siege there began more than a month ago.

CP-2002-107 →

· The New York Times

A Death and a Breach by Activists as Bethlehem Siege Persists

By C. J. CHIVERS

BETHLEHEM, West Bank, May 2 — On a day of more fatal gunfire, and a scramble by foreign peace activists carrying food into the Church of the Nativity, Palestinian negotiators offered a compromise to end the monthlong standoff between Israeli soldiers and Palestinian gunmen inside.

The proposal by the Palestinians, modeled after an American-brokered agreement that freed Yasir Arafat, the Palestinian leader, from house arrest in Ramallah, would end the siege here by transferring men wanted by Israel as terrorists from inside the church to a Palestinian jail guarded by foreign wardens.

“In principle, this is something we could accept here at the church,” said Hanna Nasser, the mayor of Bethlehem and a member of the Palestinian negotiating team. “We say that a third party should step in now and handle this situation.” Although six men accused of terrorism were transferred from Mr.

Arafat’s compound on Wednesday in a similar arrangement, ending the siege there, no formal negotiations were held between the two sides today on the impasse in Bethlehem, and Israel sent mixed signals through the news media on the Palestinian suggestion.

One military official, who is working closely with Israel’s negotiating team, said the proposal probably offered a way toward an eventual solution. “We cannot ignore what happened in Ramallah, and this option is now in discussion,” he said.

But a high-ranking defense official said it was unlikely the proposal would be accepted because Israel classifies about 25 men inside the church as the most dangerous of terrorists — who must be either tried in Israel or exiled upon their exit. “Why should we compromise on an issue where we are really 100 percent correct?” the official said.

“These are really murderers.” There was no public sign of active United States diplomacy on the Bethlehem siege, and Western and Israeli officials in Jerusalem said the Ramallah siege had been a higher priority for Washington because it involved Mr. Arafat.

The Palestinian proposal came as Israel faced the added complication of having 11 foreigners — 10 activists and a photographer — inside the compound.

A group of 23 activists appeared in Bethlehem’s narrow stone alleys about 5:50 p.m. today, then picked their way through the barbed wire barricade about 200 yards from the church and walked quickly across Manger Square. Several had food in their backpacks: rice, flour, lentils, canned goods, salt, cigarettes and sugar.

The Palestinians inside say they have been living on boiled grass for two weeks.

A group of peace activists made a dash yesterday to the Church of the Nativity where 10 of the 23 got inside. Israeli soldiers detained the other 13.

CP-2002-108 →

· St. Louis Post-Dispatch · St. Louis, Mo.

Group sees possible war crimes but no massacre

Israel rejects allegations from Human Rights Watch regarding Jenin battle

THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

JERUSALEM — U.S.-based Human Rights Watch says Israeli troops who battled their way through a Palestinian refugee camp in the West Bank town of Jenin last month may have committed war crimes, but there was no evidence to support Palestinian claims of a massacre.

In a report to be published today, the organization said three of its investigators spent a week gathering testimony in the Jenin camp and documented the deaths of 52 Palestinians, of which it said 22 were civilians. Human Rights Watch is the largest human rights group in the United States.

“Many of the civilians were killed willfully or unlawfully,” a summary of the 48-page report said. “The abuses we documented in Jenin are extremely serious, and in some cases appear to be war crimes.” Israeli military spokesman Lt. Col.

Olivier Rafowicz dismissed the report's findings, charging that Palestinian fighters used their own people as shields in a refugee camp from which 28 suicide bombers were sent into Israel.

AP staff copy. People of Palestine are called 'Palestinians', 'Palestinian fighters', 'Palestinian refugee camp'; the paper also prints, near the end, that 'Palestinian Cabinet Minister Saeb Erekat told CNN that 500 Palestinians had been killed in the fighting, although he later told The Associated Press that he could not document the figure.' Photo caption reads: 'Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon (right) presents flowers to a government official (not pictured) at a Cabinet meeting Wednesday. At left is Foreign Minister Shimon Peres. Israel held firm in objecting to a U.N. mission to Jenin.' No ordinary person named.

CP-2002-129 →

· The Free Lance-Star · Fredericksburg · page 1

Arafat is ‘partner for peace’ all right — as in ‘rest in peace, Israel’

Michael Kelly, Washington Post Writers Group, Boston

BOSTON — On June 6, 1967, the second day of the Six Day War, Israeli Foreign Minister Abba Eban laid before the United Nations Security Council Israel’s case for pre-emptively striking in a war sought and forced by the Arab nations.

As the historian Michael Oren describes in his first-rate new account of the conflict, “Six Days of War: June 1967 and the Making of the Modern Middle East,” Eban looked at each ambassador before him and said: “Look around this table and imagine a foreign power forcibly closing New York or Montreal, Boston or Marseilles, Toulon or Copenhagen, Rio or Tokyo or Bombay Harbor.

How would your government react? What would you do?

How long would you wait?”… Officially, at least, the United States still believes this; and so, before Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon arrived in Washington, various senior Bush administration officials were taking to the newspapers and the Sunday public-affairs talk shows to pressure Sharon to, as Secretary of State Colin Powell delicately put it, “recognize who the Palestinian people look to as their leader,” no matter “how disappointed we’ve been with him over time.”

Yes, we have been a little disappointed, haven’t we?

You give a fellow a perfectly good peace process, not to mention the Nobel Peace Prize; award him much of the land he demands and a $90 million monthly budget; let him build an armed force on Israeli territory; and, finally (as America’s former top negotiator, Dennis Ross, recently revealed in a remarkable Fox News interview), get both the president of the United States and the prime minister of Israel to promise him all of Gaza and nearly all of the West Bank as an independent and joined Palestinian state, with a right of Palestinian return to that state, plus a multibillion-dollar reparations fund — and, what does he do?

He goes to war against you… The New York Times buried its coverage of the report on A10 and sniffed that the evidence did “not appear to show definitively that the Palestinian leader ordered terror attacks.”… Imagine that the government of the United States believed, on evidence, that a certain Islamic leader was responsible for directing a campaign of murder against Americans.

To ask Abba Eban’s question, what would we do? Actually, the answer doesn’t require much imagination, does it? We would mount an army against that leader and all his followers, and we would bomb them and shoot them and chase them and arrest them and ship them to Guantanamo Bay.

If we had the leader in question trapped in a room, we would not let him out and set him up again as a partner for peace.

A syndicated column written five months after Guantanamo opened, arguing from the American precedent. It quotes the New York Times and the Washington Post against themselves for how they played the Israeli documents.

CP-2002-012 →

· Kingsport Times-News

Israel calls up reservists; Palestinians brace for attacks

Associated Press

EDITOR'S NOTE — This story was submitted to the Israeli military censor, who ordered significant deletions. Associated Press JERUSALEM — Tanks were poised outside Gaza and Israel called up military reservists Thursday ahead of an expected retaliatory attack for Palestinian suicide bombings, even as a deal was reached to end the standoff at Bethlehem's Church of the Nativity.

Palestinians arrested 16 members of Hamas, the Islamic militant group that claimed it carried out a deadly suicide attack earlier this week, a first sign that Yasser Arafat was taking action against terror groups. Tanks were parked off Gaza, the home base of the Hamas militant group, and Israeli forces around the strip were being beefed up Thursday night.

But Hamas leaders in Gaza — a sliver of Mediterranean coastline two-thirds of which is under Palestinian autonomy — said they were going about life as usual. Hamas founder Sheik Ahmed Yassin went ahead with the afternoon wedding reception for one of his seven daughters, his son Mohammed said.

A Yassin deputy, university lecturer Mahmoud Zahar, said he was staying at home to prepare exams and a Hamas spokesman, Abdel Aziz Rantisi, said his schedule was filled with TV interviews. Mohammed Dahlan, Yasser Arafat's security chief in Gaza, said the Palestinians were expecting an attack.

“Everyone is prepared and our people know how to confront the occupation,” said Dahlan, who has been in the West Bank town of Ramallah for months. “We said this before, and we mean it now — if the occupation forces carry out an aggression, we will face this aggression.”

The Israeli Cabinet Thursday approved unspecified reprisals in response to Tuesday's bombing in a pool hall in a Tel Aviv suburb. Fifteen Israelis were killed in the attack, the deadliest since Israel launched its West Bank military offensive March 29 in response to a wave of suicide bombings.

The reserve call-up was smaller than the one that preceded that earlier operation, during which troops occupied six of the eight main Palestinian towns in the West Bank for periods of up to several weeks and fought running battles with Palestinian gunmen.

Foreign Minister Shimon Peres hinted Israel might have a more limited operation in mind, “striking at centers from which the suicide attackers come, or the houses from which they come, or the nests from which the organization of suicide bombers comes.” Military sources said the operation will be centered on Gaza, but may not be restricted to the strip.

The objective is to hit at Hamas leaders and end the sense of immunity the militants in Gaza have enjoyed, senior official sources said. Military commentators also said they expected the Gaza operation to be more limited than the West Bank offensive. Fighting in densely populated Gaza would be much more complicated and could expose troops to greater risks.

Eurc ean Union envoy Miguel Moratinos condemned the suicide attack, but said the EU was “very concerned” it could lead to increasing violence and new military action. The EU was working with the United States, Russia and the United Nations to try to prevent that, he said. Palestinian Cabinet minister Saeb Erekat criticized the expected operation.

“Such an attack will lead to disastrous consequences for the Palestinian people there,” he said. “This will be adding fuel to the fire.” In a televised address Wednesday, Arafat said he had ordered his security forces to arrest Palestinian terror groups.

Palestinian Information Minister Yasser Abed Rabbo said Thursday the Palestinian Authority “has already taken some measures to control the security situation.” In Gaza City, Hamas officials reported that 16 of their members were arrested Thursday by Palestinian police. None of the senior members of the group were among those taken into custody, however.

In the past, Palestinian police have temporarily detained Hamas leaders, then released them soon after. In some cases, it appeared the Palestinians took the moves largely to protect the Hamas leaders. Israel has accused the Palestinian Authority of only trying to give the appearance of a crackdown on militants.

President Bush's spokesman reacted cautiously, saying the key test will be whether those arrested remain in custody. “We're looking into the reports of the arrests,” White House spokesman Ari Fleischer said.

Israeli soldiers and a row of Merkava tanks are seen near the Gaza Strip Thursday. The Israeli military has begun calling up reservists and tanks moved toward Gaza after Israel's Cabinet approved retaliation for Palestinian suicide bombings. — Associated Press

CP-2002-138 →

· The Fayetteville Observer · page 13A

Israel expected to retaliate

By Ravi Nessman / The Associated Press

EDITOR'S NOTE — This story was submitted to the Israeli military censor, who ordered significant deletions. JERUSALEM — Tanks were poised outside Gaza and Israel called up military reservists Thursday ahead of an expected retaliatory attack for Palestinian suicide bombings, even as a deal was reached to end the standoff at Bethlehem's Church of the Nativity.

Palestinians arrested 16 members of Hamas, the Islamic militant group that claimed it carried out a deadly suicide attack earlier this week, a first sign that Yasser Arafat was taking action against terror groups. Tanks were parked off Gaza, the home base of the Hamas militant group, and Israeli forces around the strip were being beefed up Thursday night.

But Hamas leaders in Gaza — a sliver of Mediterranean coastline, two-thirds of which is under Palestinian autonomy — said they were going about life as usual. Hamas founder Sheik Ahmed Yassin went ahead with the afternoon wedding reception for one of his seven daughters, his son Mohammed said.

A Yassin deputy, university lecturer Mahmoud Zahar, said he was staying at home to prepare exams, and a Hamas spokesman, Abdel Aziz Rantisi, said his schedule was filled with TV interviews. Ready to fight back Mohammed Dahlan, Yasser Arafat's security chief in Gaza, said the Palestinians were expecting an attack.

“Everyone is prepared, and our people know how to confront the occupation,” said Dahlan, who has been in the West Bank town of Ramallah for months. “We said this before, and we mean it now — if the occupation forces carry out an aggression, we will face this aggression.”

The Israeli Cabinet on Thursday approved unspecified reprisals in response to Tuesday's bombing in a pool hall in a Tel Aviv suburb. Fifteen Israelis were killed in the attack, the deadliest since Israel launched its West Bank military offensive March 29 in response to a wave of bombings.

The reserve call-up was smaller than the one that preceded that operation, during which troops occupied six of the eight main Palestinian towns in the West Bank for periods of up to several weeks and fought battles with Palestinian gunmen. Limited operation?

Foreign Minister Shimon Peres hinted Israel might launch a more limited operation this time, “striking at centers from which the suicide attackers come, or the houses from which they come, or the nests from which the organization of suicide bombers comes.” Military sources said the operation will be centered on Gaza but may not be restricted to the strip.

The objective is to hit at Hamas leaders and end the sense of immunity the militants in Gaza have enjoyed, senior official sources said. Military commentators also said they expected the Gaza operation to be more limited than the West Bank offensive. Fighting in densely populated Gaza would be much more complicated and could expose troops to greater risks.

European Union envoy Miguel Moratinos condemned the suicide attack but said the EU is “very concerned” it could lead to increasing violence and a new military action. Palestinian Cabinet minister Saeb Erekat criticized the expected operation. “Such an attack will lead to disastrous consequences for the Palestinian people there,” he said. “This will be adding fuel to the fire.”

Family members of Ratzon Sharuck mourn during his funeral in Tel Aviv. Sharuck was killed during a suicide attack on Tuesday that killed at least 15 people and injured at least 60 in the coastal city of Rishon Letzion. — AP photo

CP-2002-139 →

· (newspaper unidentified) · page A1, continued on A10 (“PLEASE SEE ISRAEL, PAGE A10” / “CONTINUED FROM A1”)

Gaza Braces For Israeli Revenge

Meanwhile, a deal is reached to end the standoff at Bethlehem’s Church of the Nativity.

By RAVI NESSMAN

JERUSALEM — Tanks were poised outside Gaza and Israel called up military reservists Thursday ahead of an expected retaliatory attack for Palestinian suicide bombings, even as a deal was reached to end the standoff at Bethlehem’s Church of the Nativity.

Palestinians arrested 16 members of Hamas, the Islamic militant group that claimed it carried out a deadly suicide attack earlier this week, a first sign that Yasser Arafat was taking action against terror groups. Tanks were parked off Gaza, the home base of the Hamas militant group, and Israeli forces around the strip were being beefed up Thursday night.

But Hamas leaders in Gaza — a sliver of Mediterranean coastline two-thirds of which is under Palestinian autonomy — said they were going about life as usual. Hamas founder Sheik Ahmed Yassin went ahead with the afternoon wedding reception for one of his seven daughters, his son Mohammed said.

Mohammed Dahlan, Yasser Arafat’s security chief in Gaza, said the Palestinians were expecting an attack. Early today, Bethlehem police chief Alaa Hosni said 13 suspected militants would leave the church starting at daybreak, part of a deal to end the 5½-week standoff at the Church of the Nativity — Jesus’ traditional birthplace.

Cyprus’ foreign minister and Palestinian sources said the militants would be taken first to Cyprus and later be divided among several countries. Under the deal, Italy and Spain would take some of the alleged militants, while Austria, Greece, Luxembourg and Ireland might take the rest, said an Italian Foreign Ministry official.

The official, who spoke in Rome on condition of anonymity, said the move was a “humanitarian decision” — meaning the 13 would likely not be kept in prison. Also Thursday, the Israeli Cabinet approved unspecified reprisals in response to Tuesday’s bombing in a Tel Aviv suburb.

Fifteen Israelis were killed, the deadliest since Israel launched its West Bank military offensive March 29 in response to a wave of suicide bombings.

The reserve call-up was smaller than the one that preceded that operation, during which troops occupied six of the eight main Palestinian towns in the West Bank for periods of up to several weeks and fought running battles with Palestinian gunmen.

Foreign Minister Shimon Peres hinted Israel might have a more limited operation in mind this time, “striking at centers from which the suicide attackers come, or the houses from which they come, or the nests from which the organization of suicide bombers comes.” Military sources said the operation will be centered on Gaza, but may not be restricted to the strip.

The objective is to hit at Hamas leaders and end the sense of immunity the militants in Gaza have enjoyed, senior official sources said. Military commentators also said they expected the Gaza operation to be more limited than the West Bank offensive. Fighting in densely populated Gaza would be much more complicated and could expose troops to greater risks.

European Union envoy Miguel Moratinos condemned the suicide attack, but said the EU was “very concerned” it could lead to increasing violence and a new military action. The EU was working with the United States, Russia and the United Nations to try to prevent that, he said. Palestinian Cabinet minister Saeb Erekat criticized the expected operation.

“Such an attack will lead to disastrous consequences for the Palestinian people there,” he said. “This will be adding fuel to the fire.” In a televised address Wednesday, Arafat said he had ordered his security forces to arrest Palestinian terror groups.

Palestinian Information Minister Yasser Abed Rabbo said Thursday the Palestinian Authority “has already taken some measures to control the security situation.” In Gaza City, Hamas officials reported that 16 of their members were arrested Thursday by Palestinian police. None of the senior members of the group were among those taken into custody, however.

CP-2002-140 →

· Norwich Bulletin · page 1

Gaza braces for Israeli attack

By RAVI NESSMAN

JERUSALEM — Tanks were poised outside Gaza and Israel called up military reservists Thursday ahead of an expected retaliatory attack for Palestinian suicide bombings, even as a deal was reached to end the standoff at Bethlehem’s Church of the Nativity.

Palestinians arrested 16 members of Hamas, the Islamic militant group that claimed it carried out a deadly suicide attack earlier this week, a first sign that Yasser Arafat was taking action against terror groups. Tanks were parked off Gaza, home base of Hamas, and Israeli forces around the strip were being beefed up Thursday.

But Hamas leaders in Gaza — a sliver of Mediterranean coastline two-thirds of which is under Palestinian autonomy — said they were going about life as usual. Hamas founder Sheik Ahmed Yassin went ahead with the afternoon wedding reception for one of his seven daughters, his son Mohammed said.

A Yassin deputy, university lecturer Mahmoud Zahar, said he was staying at home to prepare exams and a Hamas spokesman, Abdel Aziz Rantisi, said his schedule was filled with television interviews. Mohammed Dahlan, Yasser Arafat’s security chief in Gaza, said the Palestinians were expecting an attack.

“Everyone is prepared and our people know how to confront the occupation,” said Dahlan, who has been in the West Bank town of Ramallah for months. “We said this before, and we mean it now — if the occupation forces carry out an aggression, we will face this aggression.”

Nativity deal Late in the day, an Israeli official said a deal had been reached whereby 13 suspected militants inside Bethlehem’s Church of the Nativity would be divided among several countries. The Cypriot foreign minister and Palestinian sources said the militants would be taken first to Cyprus and later elsewhere.

Under the deal to end the 38-day standoff at the traditional birthplace of Jesus, Italy and Spain would take some of the militants, while the remainder would be spread among at least four other countries, the Israeli official said. Others inside the church would be allowed to go free.

Also Thursday, the Israeli Cabinet approved unspecified reprisals in response to Tuesday’s bombing in a pool hall in a Tel Aviv suburb.

CP-2002-141 →

· Palladium-Item · page A11

Gaza residents brace for reprisals

Postponed operation: Palestinians prepare for Israeli military strikes

Editor’s note: This story was reviewed by the Israeli military censor as required by the Israeli government, and deletions were made. GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip (AP) — Gaza Strip residents hoarded food and thronged bakeries Friday, while Palestinian gunmen patrolled streets and blocked camp entrances with mounds of rubble ahead of an anticipated Israeli military strike.

Even as Israeli tanks massed on the borders of Gaza, Israeli TV's Channel 2 reported that Defense Minister Binyamin Ben-Eliezer had decided to postpone the operation because of leaks about the army's plans to strike Gaza in retaliation for a suicide bombing that killed 15 Israelis this week. Ben-Eliezer's adviser, Yarden Vatikai, would not confirm or deny the report.

Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, replying to a question about a possible incursion into Gaza, accused Israel of committing crimes against Palestinians. “Our people are steadfast and will continue with all their power to defend our holy cities, Christian and Muslim places,” he said at his West Bank headquarters.

In biblical Bethlehem, meanwhile, the 39-day standoff between Israeli troops and Palestinian gunmen at the Church of the Nativity ended Friday, with 13 suspected militants flown into European exile and 26 released into the Gaza Strip.

Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres said the aim of any military operation in Gaza would be “to reach points where we have had centers of terror in a very careful and measured way.”

In the West Bank town of Tulkarem, meanwhile, Israeli troops demolished a four-story building belonging to the family of a Hamas suicide bomber, Abdel Bassat Odeh, who blew himself up on March 27 in a hotel in the Israeli coastal town of Netanya.

Twenty-nine Israelis died in the attack that targeted diners assembled for the Passover Seder, the ritual meal that ushers in the weeklong Jewish holiday. The attack triggered Israel's West Bank offensive two days later. Israeli troops imposed a curfew on the neighborhood where Odeh lived and blew up his family's home, making 21 people homeless.

A three-story building next door was badly damaged and 50 residents had to leave it, Palestinian officials said.

CP-2002-136 →

· The Forum · page 1

Evidence is clear: Zionism is racism

Your Opinion

Ron Schmidt, letter to the editor

“Anytime someone questions the actions of the state of Israel, one is likely to be called anti-Semitic. In other words, a ‘bigot.’ Black and white.

For us or against us.… Why are so many Americans so adamantly justifying whatever Israel did in Jenin while Israel is so adamantly denying that whatever it did was unjustified?… The purpose of Jewish settlements in the West Bank is to colonize in order to create the Greater Israel. In so many ways it is reminiscent of the American West.

Settlers would move on to Native American lands. In reprisal for this theft, the indigenous people would attack and often kill the settlers and their families. As Sitting Bull said, ‘The need to own land is like a sickness with the White Man.’ Zionism is racism.

As ‘God’s Chosen People,’ the chosen ones are special with a predetermined destiny. We may say: ‘a manifest destiny.’”

A reader in Tolna, North Dakota, opens with the complaint the rest of this section traces and then reaches for the nearest local comparison he has. It runs between a letter about a county sheriff’s missing evidence and a letter about the war on terrorism that quotes Martin Luther King Jr.

CP-2002-025 →

· Houston Chronicle · Houston

Palestinian official asks for aid, empathy

Dalal Salamah, a member of the Palestinian Legislative Council, was in Houston on Friday to issue a plea for aid as well as understanding for fellow Palestinians. “There is a need to talk about our situation,” Salamah said in an interview.

“Through the media, people are able to see the attacks and the damage, but the daily life — how people manage their daily lives. I want to paint a real picture of how they manage to live,” Salamah said. Salamah used her trip to call attention to changes in her homeland since the Israeli occupation began in March.

While she said she once traveled to Jerusalem via Jordan, this time she was forced to go through the mountains, and to walk for several miles carrying her bags. As she spoke Friday, the Israeli army was surrounding the Palestinian city of Ramallah with barbed wire, blocking what was a way to leave and enter Ramallah without passing checkpoints.

The move, according to international aid officials, is the first step in an Israeli plan to encircle all eight major cities of the West Bank, and their outlying villages, including Salamah’s home, Nablus. “There is no semblance of normal life in the camps and villages now,” said Salamah.

“In Palestinian West Bank and Gaza, each city and refugee camp is separated from the others. Sixteen cities, totally separated from one another,” Salamah said. “Some people who tried walking (from one village to another) to get milk and bread for their kids died,” she said.

“They are suffering because they have finished their water, their own wells are empty.”

CP-2002-049 →

· The New York Times

He Was Arab and Israeli And Now a Victim, Too

By JOEL GREENBERG

BARTAA, Israel, June 19 — Ayman Kabaha, an Israeli Arab student killed by a Palestinian suicide bomber in Jerusalem on Tuesday, was buried here today on a rocky hillside, mourned by relatives on both sides of this Arab village that lies half in Israel and half in the West Bank. Mr.

Kabaha’s death at the hands of a fellow Arab underlined the predicament of the people living here. A million Israeli Arabs are caught in a conflict between their country and their people. “We’re between the hammer and the anvil,” said Abed Mahameed, an Israeli Arab friend of Mr. Kabaha.

“We want the Palestinians to be free of occupation, but suicide bombing is a savage form of resistance, and we can be its victims along with the Jews. We’re in a tremendous dilemma.” Mr. Kabaha, 25, was one of 19 Israelis killed in Tuesday’s suicide bombing as he rode a bus to a teacher training college where he was studying special education.

He was among the Israeli Arab students renting rooms in Beit Safafa, an Arab village in southern Jerusalem where the bomber got on the bus. For people in Bartaa, a community of 7,000, Mr. Kabaha’s death in an attack by a Palestinian student-turned-bomber, exposed a painful tangle of conflicting loyalties. As the villagers — all members of Mr.

Kabaha’s clan — gathered for his funeral today, there were outbursts of grief but also ambivalent responses to the circumstances of his death. Weeping for his close friend, Amir Arshid, said that Mr. Kabaha advocated peace and befriended Jews as well as Arabs. “The two governments must do everything to reach peace and stop this,” Mr.

Arshid said, sobbing. “It doesn’t distinguish between Jews and Arabs. The death and pain are the same.”

CP-2002-111 →

· The Times · page A1, continued on A6

Prominent Palestinians decry suicide bombings

By JAMIE TARABAY

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — More than 50 Palestinians took out a full-page newspaper ad yesterday condemning suicide bombings, a move that sparked debate at a time when most Palestinians support the attacks as an effective way to hit Israel.

The ad in Al Quds, a leading Palestinian daily, appeared yesterday morning — a day after a suicide bombing killed 19 people on a Jerusalem bus, and hours before another suicide attack killed seven more people at a bus stop in the evening.

In the ad, the Palestinians urged the militant groups behind deadly assaults on Israeli civilians to “stop sending our young people to carry out such attacks.” “We see no results in such attacks, but a deepening of the hatred between both peoples and a deepening of the gap between us,” the ad said.

The signatories included Hanan Ashrawi, a leading Palestinian spokeswoman and a legislator, and the Palestinians' senior Jerusalem official, Sari Nusseibeh, along with other prominent figures regarded as moderates. The ad urged other Palestinians to join them in their opposition to the bombings.

Among the others who signed the statement were noted Gaza human rights activist and psychiatrist Iyad Serraj, newspaper editor Hana Siniora, prominent economist Mohammed Ishtaya, Yasser Arafat's security adviser Mamdouh Nofal and Abdel Khader Husseini, son of the late Faisal Husseini, who was Nusseibeh's predecessor as top Palestinian official in Jerusalem.

“We felt we had to chart a course, not just break the silence,” Ashrawi said. “We wanted to create a momentum to get people to think with their minds and to reason, instead of always reacting emotionally and out of revenge and pain and trauma.”

With the latest attacks, Palestinians have carried out 71 suicide bombings in the past 21 months of Mideast fighting, killing about 250 people on the Israeli side.

The attacks outrage Israelis, and the government has responded with military strikes and incursions into Palestinian territory, aimed at suspected militants as well as buildings belonging to the Palestinian Authority government and security forces.

Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon says Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat is ultimately responsible for failing to stop the attacks. Palestinians have held virtually no public debate on the issue. Polls regularly show strong support for the suicide bombings, though it has come down a bit in recent months, following the strong Israeli military response.

A poll released last week by a Palestinian think tank showed support for suicide bombings dropped from 74 percent in December to 68 percent recently. The survey, which had a margin of error of 3 percentage points, was roughly in line with other polls.

Ghassan Khatib, who headed the think tank and was recently named Labor Minister, said the modest decline in support for bombings was due to three reasons: international criticism of the Palestinians, the damage done to the Palestinian image by the bombings, and the consequences for the Palestinians, including Israel's military responses.

He said the newspaper ad was the strongest public expression to date opposing the bombings.

An Israeli man is helped from the scene of a suicide bomb attack in Jerusalem yesterday, the second attack in two days. The bomber killed six people at a busy intersection.

CP-2002-132 →

· The Grand Island Independent · page 4-A

Bomber kills six in Jerusalem

Israel to reoccupy Palestinian areas

By Susan Sevareid, The Associated Press

EDITOR'S NOTE — This story was submitted to Israeli military censors as required by the government, and deletions were made. JERUSALEM — A suicide bomber sprang from a car, slipped past a pair of policemen and blew himself up at a busy Jerusalem intersection Wednesday, killing at least six other people in the second deadly attack in the city in two days.

Responding, Israeli forces early Thursday entered a suburb of the West Bank town of Ramallah. Palestinian witnesses said tanks circled a house in Beitunia, where soldiers apparently planned to make arrests. The Israeli military had no immediate comment. Soldiers also occupied Qalqiliya, placing the West Bank town under curfew.

Two Israeli soldiers were killed and three others wounded when they entered a house of a suspected militant, and shooting broke out, the military said. Shortly after the suicide attack, Israeli helicopters fired rockets at metal workshops in the Gaza Strip used to manufacture weapons. Thirteen Palestinians were hurt, two seriously, Palestinian doctors said.

A group tied to Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat’s Fatah faction, the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, claimed responsibility for the suicide bombing, according to Al Manner television station run out of Lebanon by the militant Islamic group Hezbollah.

Israel said early Wednesday that it would seize and hold parts of Palestinian territory in retaliation for terror attacks, and troops moved into three West Bank towns. In Washington, President Bush decided to hold off revealing his plan for a future Palestinian state.

Administration officials said an announcement at this sensitive time would be unlikely to have a positive effect. Aides said the announcement may be delayed until next week. Arafat was expected to call for a halt to attacks against Israeli civilians in a speech on Thursday.

An advance copy of the speech set for Palestinian TV, obtained by The Associated Press, urges and end to the attacks, because “these operations have given the Israeli government the excuse to reoccupy our land, killing hundreds of our innocent people and destroying all that we have built in the last eight years.”

In one of his strongest condemnations ever, Pope John Paul II decried Tuesday’s attack, saying “those who plot and plan such barbarous attacks will have to answer before God.” On Wednesday, the bomber emerged from a red Audi and dashed toward a concrete bus stop shelter, which is also used as a hitchhiking post.

The intersection has been targeted by assailants in the past and was heavily guarded. But the attacker made it past a pair of border policemen. “The police chased him to try to stop him, and when he got to the (bus stop), he blew up a large device,” said Jerusalem Police Chief Mickey Levy. One policeman chasing the bomber was badly hurt, Levy said.

More than 35 people were wounded, many of them seriously. [One paragraph here describes the physical aftermath of the blast and the recovery of human remains by religious volunteers; it is summarized rather than transcribed.] An overturned baby carriage was covered with black plastic by rescue workers.

Government spokesman Danny Seaman said a baby wasn’t among the dead, but one had been rushed to a hospital. Israeli troops, meanwhile, fortified their positions in the northern West Bank, suggesting plans for an extended stay. The move came after the government announced it was prepared to reoccupy Palestinian areas in response to attacks.

Tuesday’s bombing on a Jerusalem bus killed 19 people, the worst in Jerusalem in six years. Hamas claimed responsibility for Tuesday’s blast in a leaflet saying it was prepared for a prolonged offensive against Israel that it called “the war of the buses.” Hamas, based in Gaza, boasted it had dozens of suicide bombers waiting to strike.

The Palestinian leadership condemned the attack Wednesday, but Israel again held Arafat responsible. Palestinian Cabinet secretary Ahmed Abdul Rahman condemned Wednesday’s attack, as the Palestinian Authority routinely does with such bombings. But he said Israel’s occupation of Palestinian land was the underlying cause of the violence.

“We all denounce any operation against civilians — if they are Palestinians or Israelis — but the Israeli government should ask itself about what they are doing today ... and their decision to reoccupy our cities,” he said.

In a sign of the army’s longer-term intentions, seven mobile homes were brought in on flatbed trucks and set up Wednesday in a forest just outside the West Bank’s Jenin refugee camp.

Israeli bomb disposal experts work at the scene of a suicide bombing in Jerusalem, Wednesday. A suicide bomber emerged from a car and detonated explosives at a bus stop on Wednesday evening. [credit: The Associated Press] || Medics evacuate a wounded Israeli woman from the site of a suicide bombing in northern Jerusalem, Wednesday. [credit: The Associated Press]

CP-2002-133 →

· The Grand Island Independent

Prominent Palestinians condemn bombings

Palestinians have carried out 71 suicide bombings in the past 21 months

By Jamie Tarabay, The Associated Press

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — More than 50 Palestinians took out a full-page newspaper ad Wednesday condemning suicide bombings, a move that sparked debate at a time when most Palestinians support the attacks as an effective way to hit Israel.

The ad in Al Quds, a leading Palestinian daily, appeared Wednesday morning — a day after a suicide bombing killed 19 people on a Jerusalem bus, and hours before another suicide attack killed seven more people at a bus stop in the evening.

In the ad, the Palestinians urged the militant groups behind deadly assaults on Israeli civilians to “stop sending our young people to carry out such attacks.” “We see no results in such attacks, but a deepening of the hatred between both peoples and a deepening of the gap between us,” the ad said.

The signatories included Hanan Ashrawi, a leading Palestinian spokeswoman and a legislator, and the Palestinians’ senior Jerusalem official, Sari Nusseibeh, along with other prominent figures regarded as moderates. The ad urged other Palestinians to join them in their opposition to the bombings.

Among the others who signed the statement were noted Gaza human rights activist and psychiatrist Iyad Serraj, newspaper editor Hana Siniora, prominent economist Mohammed Ishtaya, Yasser Arafat’s security adviser Mamdouh Nofal and Abdel Khader Husseini, son of the late Faisal Husseini, who was Nusseibeh’s predecessor as top Palestinian official in Jerusalem.

“We felt we had to chart a course, not just break the silence,” Ashrawi said. “We wanted to create a momentum to get people to think with their minds and to reason, instead of always reacting emotionally and out of revenge and pain and trauma.”

With the latest attacks, Palestinians have carried out 71 suicide bombings in the past 21 months of Mideast fighting, killing about 250 people on the Israeli side.

CP-2002-134 →

· The Grand Island Independent · page 4-A

Israeli helicopters strike Gaza Strip hours after suicide bombing

By Jamie Tarabay, The Associated Press

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Israeli helicopters fired on several targets in Gaza Strip late Wednesday, including a metal workshop in the south, Palestinian security officials said. There was no immediate word on casualties.

The Israeli army refused to comment on the strikes, which began about three hours after a Palestinian suicide bomber detonated himself at a bus stop in Jerusalem, killing seven others in the second such attack in the city in two days.

The helicopters struck a metal workshop in Khan Yunis as well as points in Jebaliya refugee camp just north of Gaza City and the Gaza City neighborhood of Zeitun, the security officials said on condition of anonymity. Israel has often said that places like metal workshops are used to manufacture bombs and other weapons used by Palestinian militants in attacks on Israelis.

On Wednesday night, ambulances streamed into the crowded streets of Jebaliya camp, the largest refugee camp in the Palestinian territories, where at least one building was damaged. It wasn’t immediately clear what was in the building, but smoke could be seen coming out of a caved-in roof.

Israel TV reported that most of the strikes were in the Khan Yunis area of the southern Gaza Strip. Early Wednesday, Israel announced a major policy shift in response to a suicide bombing Tuesday on a Jerusalem bus that killed 19 Israelis. The new approach was to reoccupy Palestinian areas gradually and stay put until terrorism stops.

CP-2002-135 →

· The Jamestown Sun · page 1

Suicide bomber kills seven others in Jerusalem

Editor's note: This story was submitted to Israeli military censors as required by the government, and deletions were made. JERUSALEM (AP) — A suicide bomber sprang from a car, slipped past a pair of policemen and blew himself up at a busy Jerusalem intersection Wednesday, killing at least seven other people in the second deadly attack in the city in two days.

Responding, Israeli forces forces moved into Bethlehem and the nearby Dheisheh refugee camp early Thursday and declared a curfew, the military said in a statement. Troops also moved into Beitunia, a suburb of Ramallah, and searched for suspects. Soldiers also occupied Qalqiliya, placing the West Bank town under curfew.

Two Israeli soldiers were killed and three others wounded when they entered a house of a suspected militant, and shooting broke out, the military said. Shortly after the suicide attack, Israeli helicopters fired rockets at metal workshops in the Gaza Strip used to manufacture weapons. Thirteen Palestinians were hurt, two seriously, Palestinian doctors said.

A group tied to Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat's Fatah faction, the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, claimed responsibility for the suicide bombing, according to Al Manner television station run out of Lebanon by the militant Islamic group Hezbollah.

Israel said early Wednesday that it would seize and hold parts of Palestinian territory in retaliation for terror attacks, and troops moved into three West Bank towns. Arafat was expected to call for a halt to attacks against Israeli civilians in a speech on Thursday.

An advance copy of the speech set for Palestinian TV, obtained by The Associated Press, urges an end to the attacks, because “these operations have given the Israeli government the excuse to reoccupy our land, killing hundreds of our innocent people and destroying all that we have built in the last eight years.”

The difficulty of stopping attacks was underscored early Thursday, when an armed Palestinian tried to break into a high school in the Jewish settlement of Kiryat Arba, next to Hebron. Soldiers shot and killed the attacker, the military said.

In one of his strongest condemnations ever, Pope John Paul II decried Tuesday's attack, saying “those who plot and plan such barbarous attacks will have to answer before God.” More than 50 prominent Palestinians signed a full-page newspaper ad in al Quds news urging groups behind deadly assaults on Israeli civilians to “stop sending our young people to carry out such attacks.”

On Wednesday, the bomber emerged from a red Audi and dashed toward a concrete bus stop shelter, which is also used as a hitchhiking post. The intersection has been targeted by assailants in the past and was heavily guarded. “The police chased him to try to stop him, and when he got to the (bus stop), he blew up a large device,” said Jerusalem Police Chief Mickey Levy.

One policeman chasing the bomber was badly hurt, Levy said. More than 35 people were wounded, many of them seriously. Israeli troops, meanwhile, fortified their positions in the northern West Bank, suggesting plans for an extended stay. The move came after the government announced it was prepared to reoccupy Palestinian areas in response to attacks.

Tuesday's bombing on a Jerusalem bus killed 19 people, the worst in Jerusalem in six years.

A man is helped to leave from the scene shortly after a suicide bomb attack in a northern Jerusalem neighborhood Wednesday. A suicide bomber sprang from a car, slipped past a pair of policemen and blew himself up at a busy Jerusalem intersection, killing at least seven other people in the second deadly attack in the city in two days.

CP-2002-137 →

· The New York Times · New York

MIDEAST TURMOIL: Harried West Bankers, the Arafat View, the Sidelined Conference

A photograph of a crowd of women under a standing head that files them as turmoil.

CP-2002-073 →

· The New York Times

The Most Wanted Palestinian

Qeis Adwan started as a stone-throwing child in the first intifada and ended up as Israel’s public enemy No. 1.

By Elizabeth Rubin

At age 7, Qeis Adwan (far right) was still playing little-boy games with guns. By the time he was 12 or 13, having experienced the first intifada, in 1987, he had become dedicated to Hamas. | At 17, Qeis was a top high-school student, memorizing long Koran passages and taking the Hamas motto to heart. | At 23, thanks to the … terrorist mastermind.

CP-2002-095 →

· Southwest Daily News · Sulphur · page 1

Peace in the Middle East still proving to be very elusive

Morton Kondracke, syndicated columnist

President Bush’s Mideast speech last week was visionary and direct — a reality bath for the Palestinian people — but it is unlikely to lead to peace, unfortunately. The message to the Palestinians was simple and truthful: Without political reform and an end to terrorism, they will never have a state.

But with reform, the United States will work to get them one.

But early indications are that even ardent Palestinian reformers heard only the ultimatum in Bush’s remarks — “elect new leaders,” i.e. not Yasser Arafat — and not the opportunity… Participants included proven Palestinian reformers Khalil Shikaki and Ziad Abu Amr, who confirmed that significant elements of their society yearn for dependable government and the rule of law.

“We want to be a democracy,” said Shikaki, a scholar and pollster. “We don’t want to be a corrupt, mismanaged entity — just another Arab country.”

In May, Shikaki’s Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research found that 83 percent of the population believe that the Palestinian Authority is corrupt and 91 percent support fundamental reform.

Many of the specific reforms called for by Bush also had wide support among Palestinians — unification of security services, 81 percent; dismissal of corrupt ministers, 95 percent; adoption of a constitution, 92 percent; establishment of a democracy, 89 percent.

On the other hand, both Shikaki and Abu Amr criticized Bush’s speech and said it would hurt the cause of reform, not help it. Shikaki said Bush’s “attempt to oust Yasser Arafat is an attempt to make the Palestinian people swallow a deal with Israel that they will never accept. Reform will be set back.”

Shikaki predicted that Bush’s implicit call for Arafat’s ouster would boost the Palestinian leader’s approval ratings by only 10 percent from its lowly 35 percent.

Yet, he said, if Arafat runs for re-election, he’ll win — both because he’s seen as “the symbol of Palestinian aspirations” and out of fear that “if he’s removed, there’d be chaos.” Abu Amr, chairman of the political committee of the Palestinian Legislative Council, scathingly declared, “Bush told us who not to elect.

Maybe next he’ll tell us whom we should elect.”

Abu Amr interpreted Bush’s speech as being primarily driven by domestic politics — a desire “not to upset the Israel lobby and the conservatives” — and said Bush “is not offering the Palestinians anything but [Israeli Prime Minister Ariel] Sharon’s view of a long interim period of negotiations.”

He predicted that the Bush proposal would “create more despair and radicalism” among Palestinians, not impetus for reform… A late May poll by the Jerusalem Media & Communication Centre showed that 68 percent of Palestinians support suicide bombings in Israel.

Shikaki’s poll found that support at 52 percent and found that 86 percent oppose the arrest of those planning bombings.

Illustrating a deep inner conflict among Palestinians, 70 percent in Shikaki’s poll said they favor “reconciliation” with Israel in a peace agreement, yet the Jerusalem Centre survey showed that 51 percent want Israel eliminated… In 2000, Arafat rejected a peace proposal by Clinton that would have given Palestinians a state comprising 97 percent of the land occupied by Israel since 1967, plus shared sovereignty over Jerusalem.

Arafat triggered terrorism to get more. So as not to reward violence, Bush is offering a lot less — a “provisional state” whose borders will have to be determined in negotiations with Israel. Arafat rejected the best offer Palestinians are ever likely to get. The danger now is that Palestinians will reject Bush’s offer — and end up with nothing.

A pull quote is set in reverse across the top of the column: “Arafat rejected the best offer Palestinians are ever likely to get. The danger now is that Palestinians will reject Bush’s offer - and end up with nothing.”

Two Palestinians quoted at length in an American column arguing against their leader: a pollster and a legislator, both named, both critical of the Palestinian Authority and of Bush. The polling figures point in opposite directions and the column prints both sets.

CP-2002-013 →

· The New York Times · New York

Plan to Keep Israeli Arabs Off Some Land Is Backed

“A cabinet vote endorsing a bill that would bar Israeli Arabs from buying homes in Jewish communities built on state land… The court decision was handed down in a case involving an Israeli Arab, Adel Kaadan, who was turned down when he applied to buy land to build a home in the Jewish village of Katzir in Galilee.”

Adel Ka’adan applied to build a house and spent seven years in court to be allowed to. He won in 2000. This is the cabinet voting to undo it.

CP-2002-074 →

· The New York Times · New York

A History of the Mideast In the Humble Chickpea

A common food like falafel can unite or divide.

By JODI KANTOR

THE last time you bit into a falafel sandwich you were probably thinking about nothing more than the warm spice and crunch of the chickpea fritters and the way they played against the soft bread, crisp vegetables and nutty tahini sauce. Unless you’re Palestinian, in which case you may have had weightier culinary issues on your mind.

Many Palestinians believe that Israelis have stolen falafel, a traditional Arab food, and passed it off as what postcards at tourist kiosks all over Israel call “Israel’s National Snack.”

“We always sort of look at each other and roll our eyeballs when we pass a restaurant that says ‘Israeli falafel,’” said Rashid Khalidi, a Palestinian-American and a professor of Middle Eastern history at the University of Chicago. Some do more than roll eyeballs.

Aziz Shihab, a Palestinian-American and the author of the cookbook “A Taste of Palestine,” once picked an argument with the owners of an Israeli restaurant in Dallas that served falafel. “This is my mother’s food,” he said. “This is my grandfather’s food. What do you mean you’re serving it as your food?”

It’s nice to think that sharing a cherished food brings enemies together, easing tension and misunderstanding. But the world’s rawest conflicts can include disagreements over common foodstuffs. Irish Catholics and Protestants have lightly bickered over whiskey. Turks and Greeks have feuded over coffee.

And Jews and Arabs argue about falafel in a way that reflects the wider conflict, touching on debates over territory and history. “Food always migrates according to immigration and commerce,” said Yael Raviv, an Israeli student at New York University who wrote her Ph.D. thesis on Israeli nationalism and cuisine.

“But because of the political situation, falafel has taken on enormous significance.”

CP-2002-088 →

· The News-Times · Danbury

Israel lifts Bethlehem curfew for a few hours a day at most

Associated Press

BETHLEHEM, West Bank (AP) — Mounir Sansuor lay dead more than three days after a fatal heart attack before his family was able to bury him Wednesday when Israel finally gave permission to break the Bethlehem curfew that was last lifted on the day Sansuor died.

Fifty people were allowed to attend the funeral, walking through the deserted, shuttered streets of Bethlehem to the Church of the Nativity, which would otherwise have been overflowing with mourners for the 39-year-old Sansuor. “It is sadder than a regular funeral, because his friends and beloved can’t attend this man’s funeral,” said the Rev.

Amjad Sabara, the Roman Catholic priest who led the funeral Mass. Israeli troops occupied Bethlehem, as well as six other major West Bank towns and cities, after Palestinian attacks killed 31 Israelis between June 18-20.

The Palestinians have demanded the Israelis leave, but Israeli officials say they’ll stay as long as it takes to end attacks — enforcing curfews and hunting down suspected militants. The army has lifted the curfews in most towns for a few hours every day or so to let residents stock up on food, visit family members and take care of business.

But in Bethlehem, the curfew was last lifted for all residents for four hours on Sunday and before that on Thursday. “They are denying the citizens from going to their churches and mosques during this incursion,” Mayor Hanna Nasser said from the home he is unable to leave because of the curfew. “This is very dangerous.”

He appealed to world governments to pressure Israel to leave the town, saying Bethlehem residents were growing increasingly frustrated at being cooped up in their homes with Israeli tanks rumbling outside. “The citizens are depressed.

The citizens are frustrated, and I don’t think that this tolerance which has been shown until now will continue for good,” Nasser said. Ranaan Gissin, spokesman for Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, said the Bethlehem curfews were necessary because Israeli field commanders had received “continuous alerts” about planned attacks on nearby Jerusalem.

“The orders the commanders on the ground receive is, any place we can ease the curfew and allow to open up, we open up,” Gissin said. “Now, if the authorities in Bethlehem will take real action to prevent suicide bombers, we will consider lifting the curfew altogether.” For Sansuor’s family, the curfew came at a particularly difficult time.

It took them four days to get permission from the army to allow them to bring his body to the Church of the Nativity for the funeral. During that time, they managed to obtain a casket and flowers, despite the restrictions.

On Wednesday, they walked slowly and silently through the streets behind the casket and joined in singing hymns, as his body was taken to a cemetery near the Nativity compound. “Thank God we managed to bury him, because this person died four days ago,” Sabara said.

A Palestinian man walking down Nativity Street is stopped and questioned by an Israeli army armored personnel carrier crew as they enforce a curfew in the West Bank town of Bethlehem Wednesday. · Palestinian bride Jala Abu Ajamia, 16, prepares to marry her 27-year-old cousin during the Israeli military curfew on Sunday.

Because of the curfew, more that half the guests could not attend, and those who did attend were not fed because Palestinian shops were closed or out of stock. (AP)

One page, two sacraments, and a curfew across both. Mounir Sansuor, 39, died of a heart attack and lay unburied for more than three days while his family sought permission to carry him to the Church of the Nativity. Fifty people were allowed to the funeral of a man whose church would otherwise have been overflowing. The priest who said the Mass: it is sadder than a regular funeral, because his friends and beloved can’t attend. Beside that story is a photograph of Jala Abu Ajamia, 16, in her veil, marrying her 27-year-old cousin the same week. More than half her guests could not come, and the ones who did were not fed, because the shops were shut or empty. Bethlehem’s mayor gave his quotes from a house he was not permitted to leave, and what he objected to was religious: they are denying the citizens from going to their churches and mosques. The Palestinians in this story are Christians, and the wedding and the funeral are the two things the curfew reached.

CP-2002-030 →

· Kentucky New Era · Hopkinsville

Palestinian photographer killed in northern West Bank

By MOHAMMED DARAGHMEH, Associated Press Writer

NABLUS, West Bank (AP) — Palestinian free-lance photographer Imad Abu Zahra died of a gunshot wound today in the northern West Bank, and a fellow photographer said the shot came from a machine gun on an Israeli tank.

Israel's military said the tank gunner was responding to rifle fire from Palestinians who were also lobbing firebombs and rocks when the tank was disabled after hitting an electricity pole in the town of Jenin on Thursday. The military spokesman said it was not clear if army fire hit anyone, and said it was possible that Palestinian shooting killed the photographer.

Said Dahlah, a colleague working with Abu Zahra on Thursday, said the tank fired randomly as it moved up a street around midday, and people ran, barricading themselves in shops and homes.

Dahlah, a photographer for the Palestinian news agency Wafa, said that he and Abu Zahra were the only people left on the street and were shot at as they photographed the tank ramming into the electricity pole. A military curfew had been lifted at the time of the shooting, the army said.

Israel took control of Jenin and six other Palestinian cities and towns after back-to-back suicide bombings in Jerusalem killed 26 Israelis last month. Dahlah, who said he was wearing body armor with a fluorescent colored sign that read “Press” in English, was hit in the leg by shrapnel. He ran as the tank fired. Abu Zahra was not wearing a protective vest.

Shot in the leg, he fell to the ground. “When I looked back I saw him bleeding,” Dahlah said. “I came back to try to drag him away but the tank fired again. Then I left him and he crawled to a nearby alley. I saw a lot of blood on the ground.”

Dahlah said that people returned to the streets to find the two photographers injured, and only then did they attack the tank with rocks. He didn't know if any shots were fired from the angry crowd, because he left quickly for the hospital with his wounded colleague. A doctor at Jenin Hospital, Ashraf Tzubah, said a bullet severed Abu Zahra's femoral artery.

His heart stopped twice, and doctors were unable to restart it the second time, Tzubah said. The photographer, who was not married, died early today. Abu Zahra, 35, was a free-lance photographer and worked with foreign journalists, helping to arrange interviews, transportation and translations.

He had his own news agency called Al-Nahil and started a weekly newspaper, called “Jenin,” in 1996. The Palestinian Authority closed the newspaper and detained Abu Zahra for a week because the paper was critical of the Palestinian leadership.

The Associated Press account. It gives Imad Abu Zahra's age as 35 and says he was not wearing a protective vest. The Washington Post account, printed the next day in Spokane, gives his age as 34 and says both injured men were wearing blue bulletproof vests identifying them as journalists. This account alone carries his detention by the Palestinian Authority.

CP-2002-032 →

· The Spokesman-Review · Spokane

Palestinian photographer shot by Israeli troops dies

Witnesses say armored carrier fired on rescuers of two victims

Washington Post

JERUSALEM — A Palestinian news photographer who was shot by Israeli troops in an armored personnel carrier died from his wounds Friday, and two Palestinians, including a 13-year-old boy, were killed during a clash in the Gaza Strip, according to Palestinian security officials and other sources. The freelance photographer, Imad Abu Zahra, 34, was shot in the leg about 2 p.m.

Thursday while covering a story in the northern West Bank town of Jenin, according to colleagues with him at the time. They said Zahra was part of a small group of photographers taking pictures of a disabled Israeli armored personnel carrier when they were fired upon from the vehicle without warning.

Zahra and another photographer, Said Dahle, 25, who works for the Palestinian news agency WAFA, were both shot in the legs. Zahra, who was engaged to be married, lapsed into a coma and died Friday from loss of blood, hospital officials said.

Witnesses said neither of the injured men, who were wearing blue bulletproof vests that identified them as journalists, could be evacuated to a hospital because the Israeli vehicle kept firing at anyone who tried to rescue them. “They opened fire for no reason,” said Ali Samudi, a photographer for the Reuters news agency who said he witnessed the incident.

According to Reporters Without Borders, an international press organization, more than 40 journalists have been wounded by Israeli weapons fire since the start of the current Palestinian uprising in September 2000.

Naim Toubassi, head of the Palestinian Journalists Syndicate, said that in the past 21 months, his group has chronicled “167 cases in which journalists were targeted, assaulted, beaten and their cameras were smashed and destroyed” by Israeli forces. Three journalists were killed and 65 were wounded, he said.

In addition, according to Reporters Without Borders, 15 foreign or Palestinian media offices have been occupied by the Israeli army and at least 30 journalists have been arrested in the past 15 weeks. Six — all Palestinians — are still being detained, most without being charged.

“It is intolerable that two journalists have been killed in the last five months by the Israeli army, even more so when Israeli soldiers refused to allow an ambulance to get to the latest victim,” said Robert Menard, secretary general of Reporters Without Borders, in a statement. “The Israeli army is acting with complete impunity. This is also intolerable.”

An Israeli military spokeswoman said the army had no knowledge of any casualties in the Jenin incident, which she said occurred when the armored personnel carrier crashed into an electric pole, which collapsed on top of the vehicle and prevented it from moving. She said that as the crew waited for assistance, a crowd gathered and began throwing rocks and gasoline bombs.

Eventually, the armored vehicle came under sniper fire, she said, “and they fired back.” “There was accurate fire at the soldiers, and they returned fire only toward the people who were shooting at them,” she said, adding that the incident is under investigation.

In the Gaza Strip, Muain Adaini, 13, and a Palestinian police officer, Khaled Khattab, 25, were killed during an exchange of gunfire early Friday in the town of Deir al-Balah, Palestinian sources said.

An Israeli army spokeswoman said heavy gun battles broke out when army forces entered the central Gaza Strip town to arrest a man wanted by Israeli security and met armed resistance. She said she was not aware of any deaths or injuries, but army radio said the target of the raid was apprehended and five Palestinians were injured by Israeli fire.

With Israeli soldiers and Palestinian pedestrians seen in the reflection, a Palestinian boy looks out a car window while waiting to pass through an Israeli army checkpoint on the outskirts of Jerusalem. (Associated Press)

The Washington Post account of the same death the Associated Press reported the day before. This headline names who fired. It gives Abu Zahra's age as 34, spells his colleague Said Dahle and gives his age as 25, and states that both injured men were wearing blue bulletproof vests identifying them as journalists, which the Associated Press account contradicts.

CP-2002-033 →

· Florence Morning News

Israeli, Palestinian doctors at forefront of treating trauma cases

Celean Jacobson

JERUSALEM — When doctors saw the X-ray of an Israeli rushed to Hadassah Hospital after a suicide bus bombing, it looked normal. Still, they hooked him up to a respirator and inserted chest tubes, waiting for the signs of injury to catch up with their handiwork.

Three hours later, another X-ray of the patient showed severe internal bleeding in one lung, but the respirator and tubes already were in place to prevent a fatal buildup of air and blood.

Such is the nature of blast injuries, and the recovery of the patient, whom the hospital would not identify, became one more example of trauma care expertise gained by Israeli doctors — and those on the Palestinian side — through an unwelcome amount of recent experience.

For 21 months, Israeli and Palestinian doctors have been immersed in trauma cases: At least 564 people have been killed on the Israeli side and 1,743 on the Palestinian side. Thousands more have been wounded.

Palestinian physicians, no matter their specialty, are trained to remove bullets but have developed a different sort of expertise: saving lives in run-down hospitals under siege, often without electricity and short on supplies.

Experience has put Israeli doctors in the forefront of treating blast injuries — caused by shock waves passing through the body after an explosion, leaving no external damage but massive internal ruptures — and deep wounds, said Avi Rivkind, chief of surgery and trauma at Hadassah Hospital.

“No one has this combination,” said Rivkind, who said his teams have tried innovations such as using a new hemophilia drug to help stop bleeding during surgery.

Palestinian doctors at the hospital in the West Bank town of Beit Jalla tend to a man wounded during heavy gunfights between Palestinian militants and Israeli forces in this Oct. 21, 2001 file photo.

CP-2002-048 →

· Iowa City Press-Citizen · Iowa City

Mideast violence pushes doctors beyond limits

JERUSALEM — When doctors saw the X-ray of an Israeli rushed to Hadassah Hospital after a suicide bus bombing, it looked normal. Still, they hooked him up to a respirator and inserted chest tubes, waiting for the signs of injury to catch up with their handiwork.

Three hours later, another X-ray of the patient showed severe internal bleeding in one lung, but the respirator and tubes already were in place to prevent a fatal buildup of air and blood.

Such is the nature of blast injuries, and the recovery of the patient, whom the hospital would not identify, became one more example of trauma care expertise gained by Israeli doctors — and those on the Palestinian side — through an unwelcome amount of recent experience.

For 21 months, Israeli and Palestinian doctors have been immersed in trauma cases: At least 564 people have been killed on the Israeli side and 1,743 on the Palestinian side. Thousands more have been wounded.

Palestinian physicians, no matter their specialty, are trained to remove bullets but have developed a different sort of expertise: saving lives in rundown hospitals under siege, often without electricity and short on supplies.

Experience has put Israeli doctors in the forefront of treating blast injuries — caused by shock waves passing through the body after an explosion, leaving no external damage but massive internal ruptures — and deep wounds, said Avi Rivkind, chief of surgery and trauma at Hadassah Hospital.

“No one has this combination,” said Rivkind, who said his teams have tried innovations such as using a new hemophilia drug to help stop bleeding during surgery. They also have devised techniques to anticipate and prevent future complications, such as with the patient suffering the contused lung.

Palestinian doctors at the hospital in the West Bank town of Beit Jalla tend to a man Oct. 21 wounded during heavy gunfights between Palestinian militants and Israeli forces.

CP-2002-050 →

· The Journal Times · Racine

Intefadeh pushes Israeli, Palestinian doctors, paramedics beyond limits

JERUSALEM — When doctors saw the X-ray of an Israeli rushed to Hadassah Hospital after a suicide bus bombing, it looked normal. Still, they hooked him up to a respirator and inserted chest tubes, waiting for the signs of injury to catch up with their handiwork.

Three hours later, another X-ray of the patient showed severe internal bleeding in one lung, but the respirator and tubes already were in place to prevent a fatal buildup of air and blood.

Such is the nature of blast injuries, and the recovery of the patient, whom the hospital would not identify, became one more example of trauma care expertise gained by Israeli doctors — and those on the Palestinian side — through an unwelcome amount of recent experience.

For 21 months, Israeli and Palestinian doctors have been immersed in trauma cases: At least 564 people have been killed on the Israeli side and 1,743 on the Palestinian side. Thousands more have been wounded.

Palestinian physicians, no matter their specialty, are trained to remove bullets but have developed a different sort of expertise: saving lives in rundown hospitals under siege, often without electricity and short on supplies.

Experience has put Israeli doctors in the forefront of treating blast injuries — caused by shock waves passing through the body after an explosion, leaving no external damage but massive internal ruptures — and deep wounds, said Avi Rivkind, chief of surgery and trauma at Hadassah Hospital.

“No one has this combination,” said Rivkind, who said his teams have tried innovations such as using a new hemophilia drug to help stop bleeding during surgery. They also have devised techniques to anticipate and prevent future complications, such as with the patient suffering the contused lung.

Abdominal procedures that textbooks recommend be done only once are repeated to check for intestinal perforations. “There is enormous regard for Israeli doctors,” said Professor James Ryan, head of conflict medicine and trauma at the Leonard Cheshire Center at University College, London.

“Unquestionably, they are the world authority and it is not surprising.”

Israeli police and medical staff work near the body of an Israeli soldier killed June 5 at the site of a deadly car bomb at Megiddo Junction in northern Israel. For 21 months, Israeli and Palestinian doctors have been immersed in trauma cases.

CP-2002-051 →

· The New York Times · New York

In Palestinian Children, Signs of Increasing Malnutrition

James Bennet

“A study under way for the United States Agency for International Development is finding that malnutrition is rising. This is going to be disastrous for Israel, the official said.”

An American aid study finds Palestinian children going hungry, and the Israeli official quoted calls the finding, rather than the hunger, the disaster. The sentence is printed without remark.

CP-2002-066 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinian Children

“This absolves Palestinians for the consequences of continuous acts of war begun two years ago by their militias against Israel’s civilian population.”

A reader answers the malnutrition article five days later. Signed from Truro, Massachusetts on 29 July and printed on the 31st. The archive holds both the report and the rebuttal, filed four records apart, which is how the argument actually ran.

CP-2002-067 →

· The New York Times

Drama as a DMZ in Israel

Arab and Jewish Actors Share the Stage as Partners in Provocative Works

By SAMUEL G. FREEDMAN

JAFFA, Israel — One Friday night in October 2000, several bloody weeks into the Palestinian uprising called the Aksa intifada, the Arab-Hebrew Theater here presented an open-mike night.

It went by the title “In Jaffa, We Talk,” and it was meant to reinforce in wrenching times the theater’s commitment to partnership between the Jewish and Arab citizens of Israel. At one point Igal Ezraty, the theater’s artistic director, began to read aloud the names of the intifada’s fatalities, and he asked the audience to stand in mourning.

But when he mentioned several Israeli soldiers who were killed, some Arab spectators shouted back that they could not commemorate “our oppressors, our murderers.” And when Mr. Ezraty listed the dead Palestinians and Israeli Arabs, some Jews pointedly took their seats. “This is the first time I ever felt such tension in the air,” Mr.

Ezraty recalled in a recent interview here, still shaking his head at the memory. “It is the first time I wondered if we can be together or not.” That episode, and its impact on Mr. Ezraty, attests to the unique burden of Israel’s several Jewish-Arab theater troupes.

Founded in less volatile times as living examples of how a Jewish majority and Arab minority could coexist in Israel, they now operate in a climate of fear, hatred, suspicion and terrorism.

The intifada, much more than its predecessor in the late 1980’s, has traumatized Arab-Jewish relations not just across the border separating sovereign Israel from the occupied territories but also within Israel itself. To the theaters’ participants, this makes their work all the more imperative.

“We are not a mirror of life in Israel,” said Haled Abu Ali, an Israeli Arab who is a featured actor in the Acco Theater Center, which is in Acre, a city in northern Israel. “We are the dream of life in Israel. The dream is that someday everyone will be able to live like this, Arab and Jew together.”

Barely three years ago such a pluralistic vision formed part of mainstream political discourse in Israel. The performing arts in particular proved receptive. Ehud Barak was elected prime minister in

Smadar Ya’aron, an actress with the Acco Theater Center of Acre, Israel, in “The Wedding Night,” which reinterprets an Arab folk tale. —— “Longing,” by the Arab-Hebrew Theater.

CP-2002-109 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Hamas Says It Regrets American Toll in Attack, But Hails Bombing as Success

By JOHN KIFNER

GAZA, Aug. 1 — The chief Hamas spokesman expressed regret today for the deaths of Americans in the bombing of a cafeteria at Hebrew University in Jerusalem on Wednesday, but he hailed the attack as a success for his group and predicted a continuation of the seemingly endless cycle of Israeli-Palestinian violence.

In an interview in his home here — where the streets emptied out early tonight in fear of Israeli retaliation — the spokesman, Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi, was asked about the fact that five of the seven people killed in the bombing were American.

He said almost offhandedly, “We are so sorry for that, because, you know that the fighters will not check the identity card of those in the field. “We are so sorry for every innocent killed in that operation,” he said. “We are not targeting Americans. The bomb was clearly against occupation.

We want to say clearly our conflict is with occupation, not America or any other state.” After flicking off a cartoon program his son had been watching on television, Dr. Rantisi, a pediatrician, added: “I think it will be a long conflict. If they will not withdraw, we are going on with our struggle.

We can’t settle for occupation, it’s the worst kind of slavery.” Dr.

Rantisi, along with a spokesman for Hamas’s military wing, described the attack as retaliation for Israel’s July 23 bombing of a densely populated residential area in Gaza City, which killed the Hamas military commander, Sheik Salah Shehada, and 14 other people, 9 of them children.

A statement by the military wing, the Qassam Brigades — named for a Muslim who led resistance against the British between the World Wars — mentioned revenge for the sheik’s killing and asserted that the assassination of any leader, political or military, would be met with “killing a hundred Zionists.”

As for Americans, the Hamas statement condemned the “criminal Bush who supports the Zionist enemy.” Dr. Rantisi, somewhat more mildly, said Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s decision to kill the sheik had “opened the gate widely in front of the fighters to attack any place.”

“From the Israeli side,” he said, “they said there would be more and more attacks, they were threatening acute attacks. And again, the military wings, not only Hamas, but all the Palestinian factions, even Fatah, will respond with our attacks. We have been aggressed on and victimized. The Palestinians have no choice but to defend themselves.”

There was an eerie parallel between Dr. Rantisi’s reaction to the American deaths and the response of Maj. Gen. Dan Harel, the Israeli Army’s chief of intelligence, to the Gaza City bombing that killed Sheik Shehada and the others.

General Harel had said, “Unfortunately, along with him died several civilians, apparently innocent, and we are very sorry for it.” The warring sides echoed each other again in comparing the American deaths in the Hamas attack to the deaths of civilians in a recent American attack on Afghanistan. In his interview today, Dr.

Rantisi invoked that incident, saying, “A couple of weeks ago, you killed tens of Afghans in a wedding party.” And on Wednesday at the bomb-shattered Hebrew University campus, the Israeli interior security minister, Uzi Landau, said, “The Americans do it in Afghanistan.”

Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping — it is trimmed to the article. The only standing matter is the kicker “THE BOMBERS” above the headline. The story dateline reads “GAZA, Aug. 1”, consistent with publication on Aug. 2, 2002. Nothing on the clipping names the newspaper.

CP-2002-086 →

· The New York Times

A Blow to Security, and to Tolerance

By JOEL GREENBERG

JERUSALEM, Aug. 1 — To the students and professors who spend their days there, the fortresslike campus of Hebrew University on Mount Scopus seemed to offer protection from the furious conflict battering this city. That sense of security lay in ruins today, a day after the bombing of a campus cafeteria in which seven people were killed and dozens wounded.

The attack challenged efforts to maintain a diverse academic community in an environment rife with bloodshed and hate. … Some Arab students said they had already felt reverberations from the bombing. Mahmoud Ektelat, 25, an accounting student from Nazareth, said some of his Jewish dormitory neighbors had urged the expulsion of Arabs from Israel.

Sumaya Aghbaria, 22, of Umm al-Fahm, a mathematics major, said she sensed that people were eyeing her suspiciously as she walked through the campus today in traditional Muslim dress. A security guard at one entrance demanded that she unload every book from her bag and unbind a sheaf of papers for inspection, she said.

… Janan Tuma, 20, an Israeli Arab law student who said she had many Jewish friends on campus, asserted that now was the time to make those relationships count. “This is when we need each other,” she said. “The bomb didn’t distinguish between Jews and Arabs, and the idea behind it was to divide us.

What’s important about these events is the response. If we know how to respond, things will work out.”

After the fatal attack, foreign students were debating leaving Israel yesterday. Lissa Young, of Boston, said: “It could easily have been me.”

CP-2002-112 →

· Sand Springs Leader · Sand Springs, Okla.

Thoroughly Modern Deborah

JOHN MARK YOUNG, Oklahoma Columnist

Looks are deceiving. The elderly woman didn't look the part. She looked like everybody's grandmother and was in fact somebody's grandmother. But that's not why all eyes in the cavernous room were focused on her now. She had been born in the same year that the United States had fought the Spanish American War.

Had she stayed in the country of her birth we might have considered her an enemy at the height of the Cold War. But when she was only eight years old in 1906 her family moved from the Ukraine, one of the “republics” in the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (U.S.S.R.), to Milwaukee, Wisconsin. They were refugees seeking to escape the persecution of Jews by the Czar's forces.

A small-town Oklahoma column written entirely from the Israeli side. People of Palestine appear only as 'the Arabs', 'Arab children', 'Arab terrorists', 'the seemingly perpetual Palestinian refugee problem'; no Palestinian is named or quoted. Useful as the counter-case in the 2001-02 group: the same months in which the Daily Illini printed a Jenin woman's testimony, this paper printed Golda Meir's forgiveness line without comment.

CP-2002-128 →

· Detroit Free Press

Malnutrition plagues many Palestinian kids

FREE PRESS NEWS SERVICES

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — One in five Palestinian children under age 5 is malnourished, preliminary findings of a study showed Monday. The survey, funded by humanitarian organization CARE International and the U.S. Agency for International Development, drew an urgent appeal by the Palestinian health minister for more international aid. The U.S.

Embassy said the U.S. government would “increase food and emergency health and nutrition assistance to the affected population.” Asked about the findings, Israeli Health Minister Shlomo Benizri said: “They are suffering from malnutrition but at least they are still alive.”

Benizri made the statement to Israel’s Channel One television a day after 13 Israelis were killed in Palestinian attacks. “They brought economic hardship on themselves. They are holding a rifle and shooting at us, and when we come to strike them, they say, “ ‘Wait, I’m holding a child in my arms.’

” The results were released by two Palestinian institutions — Al Quds University and the Global Management Consulting Group, with technical assistance from Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore. CARE said food shortages were “primarily due to border closures that seal the Gaza Strip off from Egypt, Israel and the West Bank.”

The group also said food shortages in the West Bank were “caused by a combination of road closures, checkpoints, curfews and military conflict.” Israeli officials say blockades and curfews are necessary to stop suicide bombers.

CP-2002-143 →

· Ithaca Journal

Pullout agreement falls through

Palestinians say Israelis changed terms of deal

By HADEEL WAHDAN

RAMALLAH, West Bank — The Palestinians and Israel agreed Wednesday on a plan for a gradual Israeli withdrawal from areas of the West Bank and Gaza Strip but the deal appeared to flounder later in the day when Palestinian officials said Israel had changed the terms.

Israeli Defense Minister Binyamin Ben-Eliezer laid out a proposal last week under which Israeli troops would gradually begin withdrawing from Palestinian-ruled parts of Gaza and the West Bank town of Bethlehem, in exchange for Palestinian guarantees that no attacks would be launched from these areas.

The Palestinian Cabinet accepted the proposal on Wednesday and Palestinian security officials and members of Israel’s Shin Bet security services met later in the day to map out the details. However, Palestinian officials emerged from the meeting and accused Israel of changing its offer. They declared the session a failure.

Calls placed to Israeli officials early today (Wednesday night EDT) were not immediately returned. Regardless, the Cabinet approval had been provisional pending the outcome of the meeting, and obstacles were still likely even if it were finalized.

Earlier, top officials of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat’s Fatah movement denounced the Cabinet decision, saying it had been taken without their consultation and amounted to a betrayal of the Palestinian struggle for the past 22 months of fighting.

In Washington, meanwhile, a senior Palestinian delegation arrived for talks with Secretary of State Colin Powell and other U.S. officials. The delegation’s head, Saeb Erekat, bristled at a blunt critique of the Palestinian leadership by Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld a day before.

Rumsfeld said the Palestinian Authority was entangled with terror and that he doubted Israel could turn over territory to it because of its poor track record.

Rumsfeld also referred to the West Bank as “so-called occupied territory,” signaling he does not share the Bush administration’s view of Israel’s presence on the land, captured by Israel in the 1967 war.

After the meeting between Palestinian and Israeli security officials, Arafat aide Nabil Abu Rdeneh said Israel had imposed new conditions on the Palestinians in the talks that were “impossible to accept or even to implement.”

He wouldn’t elaborate except to say that Israel hadn’t mentioned withdrawing from Bethlehem in the talks, just Gaza, and he declared the meeting a failure.

Palestinian youths throw stones towards an Israeli army Jeep during minor clashes that took place Wednesday in the West Bank town of Ramallah. Few Palestinian demonstrators were injured in the clashes as the Israeli army maintains control of the besieged town.

CP-2002-144 →

· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis

We will never go hungry

BALATA REFUGEE CAMP, West Bank — With unemployment in the territories at an all-time high, few families can afford to buy a pound of grapes for 35 cents, not to speak of meat.

Gil Sedan, filing from Balata. The detail that carries it is the price of grapes.

CP-2002-077 →

· Times Record · Fort Smith

Survivors battling fear, grief, flashbacks

“Samir Abu Shaloof dives under the stairs whenever a plane flies overhead. An airstrike destroyed his house… Anna Krakovich, a teacher, is so repelled by the smell…”

Nicole Winfield, in the Sunday Insight section in Fort Smith. A Palestinian boy and an Israeli teacher, their trauma set side by side in the same feature — which is rarer in this archive than it sounds.

CP-2002-079 →

· Kitsap Sun · Bremerton, WA · page B1, continued B2

Court bans Army’s use of ‘human shields’

■ A Palestinian teenager was killed after being forced to knock on a suspicious door.

By Mark Magnier, Los Angeles Times

JERUSALEM — Israel’s Supreme Court issued a temporary injunction Sunday barring the army from using unwilling Palestinian civilians to knock on suspicious doors, enter buildings it believes might be booby-trapped and pick up dubious packages. The ruling came in response to a filing earlier in the day by a coalition of seven human-rights groups.

Charges that the army has been using “human shields” hit the headlines last week when a 19-year-old Palestinian, Nidal abu Muhsein from the West Bank village of Tubas, was handed a bulletproof vest and sent by the army to knock on the door of a nearby house. Wanted Hamas leader Nasser Jerar was holed up inside.

Muhsein — who had no police record and was never under suspicion — knocked, the door opened, and the teenager fell dead in a hail of bullets. It’s a matter of debate who started the shooting. The Israeli military then bulldozed the house and killed Jerar, who was wanted on suspicion of planning several attacks against Israelis, as Muhsein’s body lay amid the rubble.

The high court will decide at an as-yet unscheduled hearing what limits, if any, should be placed on the army’s growing use of Palestinian civilians to serve against their will as deterrents, advance scouts and early warning systems.

The seven human-rights petitioners, led by the Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel, or Adalah, say such tactics are illegal under both the Geneva Convention and Israeli law.

The army, which terms its use of civilians a “neighbor practice,” argues that the policy provides a necessary and effective deterrent under extreme circumstances, and one that saves both Palestinian and Israeli lives. Muhsein’s family sees the matter differently. “We’ve lost our eldest son.

We are in so much pain,” said Abdul Raouf abu Muhsein, Nidal’s father, who says their child was chosen at random because of his sturdy physique. “I can hardly bear to go into my own house anymore. I still see him here, even though he’s gone.”

Zero “Israeli Arab” vocabulary despite Adalah being the lead petitioner. The story is about Palestinians in the West Bank and uses “Palestinian” throughout; the word “Arab” appears on the page exactly once, inside the name of an Israeli legal NGO.

CP-2002-130 →

· The Atlanta Constitution · Atlanta · page 1

Racists court anti-Israel groups

Pro-Palestinians vow to shun supremacists

Dan Chapman, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

“Neo-Nazis and white supremacists from Georgia to Europe are stepping up efforts to forge ties with Arab groups and governments who share their hatred of Israel. Some homeowners in Atlanta and North Georgia recently found leaflets in their mailboxes from the white supremacist New Order.

The fliers had a picture of the World Trade Center towers burning and the words: ‘Want to stop terrorism? Tell your government to stop subsidizing Israeli genocide against Palestine.’

Pro-Palestinian groups in Atlanta have been approached this year by the National Alliance, another supremacist group, as well as other anti-Israeli groups claiming to support a Palestinian homeland… ‘It’s something we have to live with and start dealing with,’ said Adam Levenstein, who is Jewish and a member of Atlanta Palestine Solidarity.

‘We want nothing to do with these people.’ Samir Moukaddam, Southern regional director for the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, recalls at least three episodes within the last year in which anti-Jewish groups tried to co-opt his committee’s anti-Israel message.

‘They sometimes approach us stealthily or show up and say, “We’ve been following the news and we are supporters and I can’t believe what the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians,”’ Moukaddam said. ‘At some point, they start saying, “Jews are this and Jews are that.”’”

“Asmahan Hooper participates in a pro-Palestinian rally Monday organized by Atlanta Palestine Solidarity at the Israeli Consulate in Midtown. Some white supremacists seek to ride the anti-Israeli cause.” Bita Honarvar, staff.

The hardest clipping in the archive to place, and it is here because it names the mechanism: a white supremacist group using the word genocide about Palestine on a leaflet, and Palestinian and Jewish organizers in Atlanta both refusing them.

CP-2002-014 →

· The New York Times · New York

7 More Israeli Arabs Jailed; Tied to Palestinian Bombing

“Interior Minister Eli Yishai has called for stripping Israeli Arab suspects of their citizenship, depriving them of legal advantages enjoyed by citizens. Politicians have also called for the demolition of their houses.”

Serge Schmemann. The proposal is to remove citizenship from suspects — people not yet tried — and the phrase for what citizenship gives them is legal advantages. House demolition, the clause notes, is already policy elsewhere.

CP-2002-075 →

· The New York Times

‘Moonlight’ and Mendelssohn in the West Bank

By SERGE SCHMEMANN

RAMALLAH, West Bank, Sept. 10 — The old Steinway grand had seen better days, but when Daniel Barenboim drew the first nostalgic notes of Beethoven’s “Moonlight” Sonata from it today, 200 neatly uniformed Palestinian students froze in delight.

Music, and especially music of this caliber from a live Israeli master, is not something that has often graced young lives more wrapped up in the daily misery of curfews, roadblocks, dangers and hatreds. Mr. Barenboim, the famed conductor and pianist, seemed forgiving of the hoarse old instrument and the many television cameras with him on the stage.

The music was a message, which he spelled out after an ecstatic ovation from the pupils. “Each one of us has a responsibility to do what is right, and not to wait for others to do it,” he said. “My way is music.

What I can do is play music, play music for you, and maybe this way, in a very small way for these few moments, we are able to build down the hatred that is so much in the region.” His words sounded incontrovertible. But Mr.

Barenboim’s music has stirred some sharp debate in Israel, most memorably when he led a German orchestra in a piece by Wagner, Hitler’s favorite composer, at an Israeli arts festival in July 2001. Many in the audience walked out, and Mr. Barenboim was accused of everything from insensitivity to “cultural rape.” Mr.

Barenboim, who was born in Argentina, raised in Israel, and now divides most of his time between Berlin and Chicago, has also been vocal in his criticism of Israel’s military crackdown on the Palestinians, often posting his views on his Web site, daniel-barenboim.com. In March, while Israeli troops were cracking down on Palestinian towns, Mr.

Barenboim announced that he would give a concert in Ramallah, the Palestinian headquarters in the West Bank. The Israeli Army barred him from going, saying it could not guarantee his security, and the concert was canceled. Three weeks ago, on his last visit to Israel, Mr. Barenboim, 59, gave a concert at Bir Zeit University, a Palestinian university near Ramallah.

This time, there was little advance notice, and Mr. Barenboim simply ignored whatever restrictions were in force. He declined to discuss how he got in, but a German diplomatic car was waiting for him outside. After a few weeks of relative quiet, the visit seemed not to generate the same resistance that arose in March.

There was no immediate comment from Israel, and the event was given scant notice on Israeli television news. But for the students who came to the Friends School, a respected private school, it was a day to remember. Mr. Barenboim performed only the one sonata, and then invited the Palestinians to play for him. Three girls rose to the challenge.

Sileen Khoury, 15, gamely worked her way through a Chopin waltz, followed by 15-year-old Nadia Arouri with Mendelssohn’s barcarole, and Zeina Amr, 14, who was so nervous she forgot the name of her piece. Mr. Barenboim told them all they were great, and urged them to keep studying.

“It was very nice of him, because he took all the trouble to come here through checkpoints and everything,” said Ms. Amr. Ms. Khoury, who said she wanted to continue with music, added that she was “a bit nervous, but with Mr. Barenboim beside me I felt safe.” “Actually it was an honor for us, she said.

“The Israelis try to stop us from learning, working, but they can never stop us from playing music.” She said she had been studying piano for six years, but her seventh year at the conservatory was delayed because curfews had prevented her from taking her exams.

The pianist and conductor Daniel Barenboim played yesterday for Palestinian students in Ramallah. A recital planned for March was canceled after the Israeli Army said it could not guarantee Mr. Barenboim’s security.

CP-2002-110 →

· Danville Register & Bee

Lebanese model Nathalie Fadlallah wears a Palestinian keffiyeh while displaying a dress de

Lebanese model Nathalie Fadlallah wears a Palestinian keffiyeh while displaying a dress designed by Saudi Yahya al-Bushairy during a fashion show recently in Beirut. The dress design shows mock blood stains, an Israeli tank and a Palestinian boy who was killed at the outbreak of the Palestinian intefadeh.

CP-2002-089 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli-Arab Hero Is Praised, but Not Embraced

“Rami Mahamid, with his mother beside him, was honored by the Israeli police yesterday for his bravery… Other Israeli Arabs, after all, had helped Palestinian terrorists. But Rami foiled one.”

James Bennet, from Afula. A teenager spots a bomber at a bus stop and is given a commendation, and the story is about how far the commendation does not go. The headline tells you before the first paragraph does: praised, but not embraced.

CP-2002-076 →

· The New York Times · New York

More Young Victims Falling On Front Lines in the Mideast

Joel Greenberg

“Children are often on the front line as soldiers use live ammunition to enforce curfews and break up violent street protests, sometimes with deadly results.”

Balata camp, with the boys running and the soldiers firing, twelve years after the 1990 report in this archive found the same pattern and the same ammunition.

CP-2002-068 →

· Press of Atlantic City · Atlantic City

Israeli tanks enter Gaza; missile kills 10

Israeli military sources say the move into Gaza is a limited operation and not a large-scale invasion.

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Ten Palestinians were killed and dozens wounded today during an Israeli incursion into the southern Gaza city of Khan Younis, officials and doctors said, most when an Israeli helicopter fired a missile that exploded in a crowd. The Israeli military had no immediate comment on the missile explosion.

Israeli military sources, speaking on condition of anonymity, said the operation in Khan Younis was limited and not a large-scale invasion. It came a few hours after Palestinians fired a mortar shell at a Jewish settlement in another part of the Gaza Strip, the military said. The Israeli missile strike came at the end of the four-hour incursion.

It wasn’t clear what the target was. Residents said people came out into the streets around 4:30 a.m. when they heard the tanks pulling out, but two Israeli helicopters remained overhead, and one of them fired the missile. Doctors said 10 people were killed in the raid, including eight in the missile attack. They said at least 65 people were wounded by the missile blast.

Abed Ouda, 29, said he was parking his car when the missile struck. “I heard a huge explosion,” he said, “and people were wounded and bleeding on the ground in front of my car.” Dr. Mohammed Abu Dalal of Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis appealed for more doctors and supplies to help treat the large numbers of casualties.

After midnight, about 40 Israeli tanks, backed by helicopters, had entered Khan Younis and shelled houses on the main street, witnesses said. Israeli armored columns have frequently moved into Palestinian-controlled areas in recent weeks, destroying workshops where Israel says weapons are made and arresting terror suspects.

On Sunday, two Palestinian men were shot dead in the northern West Bank, one in a gunbattle with Israeli troops, the other allegedly shot by a Jewish settler in an olive grove. Palestinians accused Jewish settlers of killing Hani Yousef, 22, as he was harvesting olives near his village, Aqraba.

Another Palestinian farmer was shot and wounded by the settlers, who came from the nearby settlement of Itamar, according to the Palestinian mayor, Ghaled Mayadme. Israeli police spokesman Gil Kleiman said the farmer’s death was being investigated, but no arrests had been made. The farmer had been shot in the back, he said.

In the Jenin Refugee Camp, also in the northern West Bank, Israeli troops killed Samer Jalamneh, a 22-year-old member of the radical Islamic Jihad movement, after he opened fire at them with an assault rifle, witnesses and the military said.

Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, speaking from the remnants of his Ramallah compound, accused the Israeli army of covering up settlers’ actions.

CP-2002-040 →

· Columbia Daily Tribune · Columbia

Israeli raid in Gaza kills 13 Palestinians

KHAN YOUNIS, Gaza Strip (AP) — Israeli troops raiding this town with tanks and helicopters killed 13 Palestinians early today, including 10 who died when a missile slammed into a large crowd. Palestinian officials said all the dead were civilians, while the Israeli army said most were armed men killed in battle.

About 110 Palestinians were wounded in the four-hour raid, including 25 who were in critical condition, doctors said. Most suffered shrapnel wounds in the head, chest and abdomen. The dead ranged in age from 14 to 52. Israeli troops fired machine guns and assault rifles at a Khan Younis hospital where most of the wounded were taken, killing one man and injuring three people.

The military said the shots were fired in response to mortar fire, and witnesses said they heard two explosions before the shooting began. Palestinians denounced the Israeli strike, the deadliest since July, as a massacre and called for international protection. The Islamic militant group Hamas threatened revenge.

Israeli officials said Palestinian militants were responsible for the casualties because they took cover among civilians. The military said Khan Younis is a Hamas stronghold and that during the raid troops arrested a wanted man carrying an explosive device.

However, there was no indication of a particular target, as in previous strikes against wanted militants that also claimed civilian casualties. The Israeli military said the missile was aimed at a group of armed men who were attacking soldiers with guns and grenades. The missile was fired toward the end of the raid.

Wissam Abdeen, 29, said that as troops withdrew, residents emerged from their homes to inspect the damage and check on the fate of friends and relatives. “We heard the sound of helicopters,” said Abdeen, who was hit by shrapnel in his arm. “Two minutes later, I heard the sound of something coming from the air, and I saw the flames.

Then a big explosion lifted me and blew me 10 yards away.”

Palestinians pray today during a mass funeral in the southern Gaza Strip beside the bodies of those killed after an Israeli raid today in Khan Younis. Thirteen Palestinians were killed and about 110 were injured, including 10 who died when a missile exploded in a crowd.

CP-2002-041 →

· The Journal Times · Racine

10 Palestinians killed as Israelis attack Gaza

Witnesses say dozens hurt by missile fired into crowd

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip – Ten Palestinians were killed and 115 wounded early today during an Israeli raid into the southern Gaza city of Khan Younis, officials and doctors said, most when an Israeli helicopter fired a missile that exploded in a crowd. The missile strike came at the end of the four-hour incursion. It was unclear what the target was.

Residents said people came into the streets at about 4:30 a.m. when they heard Israeli tanks pulling out, but two military helicopters remained overhead, and one of them fired the missile.

In a statement, the Israeli military said the soldiers operating in the Amal neighborhood of Khan Younis, “known to be a stronghold for Hamas,” exchanged fire with armed Palestinians. The statement did not mention the missile explosion.

Of the 10 people killed in the raid, eight died in the missile attack, doctors said, adding that at least 65 people were wounded by the missile blast. Abed Ouda, 29, said he was parking his car when the missile struck. “I heard a huge explosion, and people were wounded and bleeding on the ground in front of my car,” he said. Dr.

Mohammed Abu Dalal of Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis appealed for more doctors and supplies to help treat the large numbers of injured. The Israeli military had no immediate comment on the missile explosion. Israeli military sources, speaking on condition of anonymity, said the operation in Khan Younis was limited and not a large-scale invasion.

It came a few hours after Palestinians fired a mortar shell at a Jewish settlement in another part of the Gaza Strip, the military said. About 40 Israeli tanks, backed by helicopters, had entered Khan Younis after midnight and shelled houses on the main street, witnesses said. At least 10 people were wounded, two of whom died in the hospital, doctors said.

CP-2002-042 →

· The Journal Times · Racine · page 3A

10 Palestinians killed as Israeli tanks enter southern Gaza city

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Ten Palestinians were killed and dozens wounded today during an Israeli incursion into the southern Gaza city of Khan Younis, officials and doctors said, most when an Israeli helicopter fired a missile that exploded in a crowd. The Israeli military had no immediate comment on the missile explosion.

Israeli military sources, speaking on condition of anonymity, said the operation in Khan Younis was limited and not a large-scale invasion. It came a few hours after Palestinians fired a mortar shell at a Jewish settlement in another part of the Gaza Strip, the military said. The Israeli missile strike came at the end of the four-hour incursion.

It wasn’t clear what the target was. Residents said people came out into the streets around 4:30 a.m. (10:30 p.m. CDT Sunday) when they heard the tanks pulling out, but two Israeli helicopters remained overhead, and one of them fired the missile. Doctors said 10 people were killed in the raid, including eight in the missile attack.

They said at least 65 people were wounded by the missile blast. Abed Ouda, 29, said he was parking his car when the missile struck. “I heard a huge explosion,” he said, “and people were wounded and bleeding on the ground in front of my car.” Dr.

Mohammed Abu Dalal of Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis appealed for more doctors and supplies to help treat the large numbers of casualties. After midnight, about 40 Israeli tanks, backed by helicopters, had entered the Khan Younis and shelled houses on the main street, witnesses said.

Israeli armored columns have frequently moved into Palestinian-controlled areas in recent weeks, destroying workshops where Israel says weapons are made and arresting terror suspects. On Sunday, two Palestinian men were shot dead in the northern West Bank, one in a gunbattle with Israeli troops, the other allegedly shot by a Jewish settler in an olive grove.

Palestinians accused Jewish settlers of killing Hani Yousef, 22, as he was harvesting olives near his village, Aqraba. Another Palestinian farmer was shot and wounded by the settlers, who came from the nearby settlement of Itamar, according to the Palestinian mayor, Ghaled Mayadme.

Israeli police spokesman Gil Kleiman said the farmer’s death was being investigated, but no arrests had been made. The farmer had been shot in the back, he said.

In the Jenin Refugee Camp, also in the northern West Bank, Israeli troops killed Samer Jalamneh, a 22-year-old member of the radical Islamic Jihad movement, after he opened fire at them with an assault rifle, witnesses and the military said.

Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, speaking from the remnants of his Ramallah compound, accused the Israeli army of covering up settlers’ actions.

“The army is protecting their daily crimes against Palestinian residents in their homes and against Palestinian farmers,” Arafat said after a meeting with Jakob Kellenberger, president of the International Committee of Red Cross, who is touring Israel and Palestinian areas this week.

Also, the Palestine Legislative Council gave Arafat another four weeks to appoint a new Cabinet, following the resignation of his previous Cabinet last month, Palestinian parliament speaker Ahmed Qureia said.

Arafat asked the legislature for an extension on his original two-week deadline to name a new Cabinet after Israeli troops besieged his Ramallah compound, destroying several buildings Palestinian reform plans were put on hold during the siege.

In Jerusalem, four Arab residents of the city’s traditionally Arab eastern sector, accused of helping bombers carry out three attacks that killed 35 people and wounded almost 200, went on trial amid a flood of insults from relatives of the Israeli victims. Relatives shouted obscenities and insults at the accused.

“You should all be strung up on a crane,” said Gila Arazi, aunt of Danit Dagan, who was killed with her fiancee, when a suicide bomber blew himself up at the Cafe Moment in Jerusalem on March 9.

In addition to that attack, which killed 11, the group is accused of helping to arrange a suicide bombing that killed 15 at a pool hall in Rishon Letzion, near Tel Aviv, and planting a bomb at a cafeteria in Jerusalem’s Hebrew University that killed five Americans and four Israelis.

Inside the courtroom, the four accused and their families were protected by riot police, who stood in a row facing the angry relatives of the victims. The accused, Wael Qassem, Wissam Abassi, Ala Abassi and Muhammed Oudeh, sat handcuffed to prison guards. The prisoners’ legs were also shackled.

CP-2002-043 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Raid in Gaza Kills 9 And Hurts 50, Witnesses Say

“Israeli tanks backed by helicopters raided a neighborhood in the Gaza Strip town of Khan Yunis overnight, killing 9 Palestinians and wounding more than 50 others… Residents said the helicopters fired missiles at a car, and a woman and a child were among the dead.”

Joel Greenberg, filed Monday morning. Three other American papers in this archive carried the same Khan Yunis raid that day and all three said ten; the Times said nine, counting from Palestinian medical officials at the scene while the wire counted later. Down the page, settlers fire on olive pickers at Akraba and kill Hani Yusuf, 24, with a shot to the stomach. October 7, 2002.

CP-2002-080 →

· The New York Times · New York

Death and Revenge: Palestinian vs. Palestinian

James Bennet

“Yousef Akel was killed by other Palestinians a year ago. When his death was avenged on Monday, his mother, Aysha, and his niece, Islam, 7, felt they could finally grieve in the family’s house in Gaza.”

Three Palestinians named in one photograph caption, including a seven-year-old. The killing is Palestinian and so is the revenge, and the paper gives the family more space than most clippings here give the dead.

CP-2002-071 →

· Courier-Journal · Louisville

Palestinian boxer overcame the serious fighting

Associated Press

“Boxer Monir Abukeshek has little in the way of equipment or sparring partners at his home in a Palestinian refugee camp in the West Bank. ‘Just the bag and my brothers,’ the 27-year-old light-heavyweight said.

But today he will fight in the semifinals of the Asian Games, where he is guaranteed a medal — making him the Palestinians’ first medalist in the games. He said his training has been interrupted by fighting between Israeli troops and Palestinians at home, which he left five weeks before his first child was born to prepare for the Asian Games.

Abukeshek — who has seen only photographs of his son, Yazen, since he was born Aug. 18 — said he hopes to win gold. ‘If I win the medal, I will put it around my son’s neck,’ he said.”

Monir Abukeshek, 27, trains in a refugee camp with just the bag and my brothers, and is about to become the first Palestinian to win a medal at the Asian Games. He left home five weeks before his first child was born. He has seen his son Yazen only in photographs. What he intends to do with the medal is the last line: ‘If I win the medal, I will put it around my son’s neck.’

CP-2002-031 →

· The New Mexican · Santa Fe · page D-3

Palestinian boxer will honor his people with medal

The Associated Press

BUSAN, South Korea — Boxer Monir Abukeshek has little in the way of equipment or sparring partners at his home in a Palestinian refugee camp in the West Bank. “Just the bag and my brothers,” the 27-year-old light-heavyweight says.

On Friday, Abukeshek will fight in the semifinals of the Asian Games, where he is guaranteed a medal — making him the Palestinians' first games medalist. The losers of the semifinals are each awarded bronze medals, while the winners go on to contest the gold and silver.

Abukeshek said his training has been interrupted this year by fighting between Israeli troops and Palestinians at home, which he left five weeks before his first child was born to prepare for the Asian Games. “I am hoping very much for the gold medal,” Abukeshek said Thursday after a light workout in his room at the athletes' village in Busan.

“I will present this medal for my people.” But not before he presents it to his son, Yazen, who he has seen only in photographs since Yazen was born Aug. 18. “If I win the medal, I will put it around my son's neck,” Abukeshek said. Palestinian athletes are competing in 16 events at the Asian Games, which has drawn 44 countries from Japan to the Middle East.

Palestinians have competed in three of the past four Asian Games, which are held every four years. They gained International Olympic Committee recognition in 1993 after the Israeli-Palestinian peace accords. Palestinians competed at their first Olympic Games in Atlanta in 1996.

Palestinian officials say Israeli military incursions into Palestinian territory have killed athletes and destroyed sporting facilities. At a May meeting of National Olympic Committee chiefs in Malaysia, Zaher Akram, the Palestinian delegation's assistant secretary general, claimed the number of athletes killed was 134.

Abukeshek, an agricultural studies graduate, lives with his wife and child in Askar refugee camp near Nablus, the scene of many bloody clashes since Israel launched a crackdown in Palestinian territories earlier this year. His five brothers and three sisters also live in the camp.

In April, Israeli tanks and armored personnel carriers surrounded Askar as part of operations in response to suicide bombing attacks in Israel. Dozens of people were killed in the clashes. Askar camp is known as a center for armed militants from Fatah, the movement headed by Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat.

Abukeshek said that on April 15, four of his friends were killed in one day of fighting. He stopped training for three weeks. “The intefadeh (uprising) has affected my training and preparation too much, because of the closures and the soldiers attacks on the streets in Palestine,” he said.

Abukeshek said that on his way to training camps in Jordan and Tunisia he was held up for two weeks in Jericho while Israeli officials approved travel papers. “I hope the occupation will end,” he said. “Our people desire freedom so that we can live our lives like other people.”

Monir Abukeshek. Stopped training for three weeks after four friends were killed in Middle East violence.

The same day's Associated Press copy as the Courier-Journal printing, at greater length and under a different headline.

CP-2002-034 →

· San Francisco Chronicle

Settlers' attacks disrupt harvest in West Bank

Palestinian farmers say olive trees have been destroyed

By Danielle Haas / CHRONICLE FOREIGN SERVICE

TUWANI, West Bank — A series of attacks by Jewish settlers has disrupted Palestinian farmers' olive harvest in the West Bank and added a new level of tension to the standoff in the region. Most of the settlers involved are squatters on hilltops that are adjacent to Palestinian agricultural lands.

They are accused by Palestinians and Israeli human rights groups of cutting down and burning olive trees, stealing the crop and provoking violent incidents. One death has occurred so far. On Oct.

6, Hani Minyeh, a 22-year-old grocery store clerk in the village of Aqraba, was killed when settlers from the Jewish community of Itamar, near Nablus, fired on a group of olive pickers. Police seized six weapons, arrested one settler and questioned six others, but all were later released and no charges were filed.

Police spokesman Gil Kleiman said ballistic checks were being run on the bullet that killed Minyeh and added that the case was being taken “very seriously.” “It's very difficult to do (proper) policing in a war zone,” he complained.

An incident nearly as troubling took place on Sunday, when masked settlers believed to be living in the outpost known as Adi'ad disrupted an olive harvest and began shooting in the air and later at the legs of the Palestinian pickers.

The settlers then set fire to seven cars belonging to residents of the Palestinian village of Turmous-Aya, on the road connecting Ramallah and Nablus. Around 200 villagers ran out to the olive groves and brawled with the settlers until police arrived and fired into the air to disperse the two sides. Several settlers were arrested.

Palestinian men protected by Israeli soldiers prepare to harvest olives near Yanun in the West Bank. (BRENNAN LINSLEY / Associated Press) | Moussa Jabril Rabbi takes a break in his olive grove. (DANIELLE HAAS / Special to The Chronicle)

CP-2002-090 →

· Hartford Courant

A Hazardous Harvest For Palestinians

Jewish Settlers Wage An Economically Devastating War Against Olive Pickers

By JOHN WARD ANDERSON / WASHINGTON POST

MAZRAA SHARQIYA, West Bank — Members of the Azzam family gathered in their 3-acre olive grove Tuesday for a usually routine ritual that in recent weeks has become increasingly hazardous: the annual olive harvest.

As 16 family members, from toddlers to grandparents, shook the branches and raked through the silvery green leaves with their fingers to plunk the small, green olives onto tarps spread like blankets below the trees, they said they were on guard against Jewish settlers who this year are waging a violent and economically devastating war against Palestinian olive pickers.

Next to the family plot, hundreds of olive trees were set afire two weeks ago by residents of nearby Jewish settlements, family members said. Down the road, about 100 other trees were sawed to the ground.

Ten miles north, in the town of Aqraba, settlers three weeks ago shot and killed a 24-year-old Palestinian man who was picking olives on his land, according to Palestinian witnesses.

Since the harvest season began in early October, Palestinian communities across the West Bank have reported almost daily attacks by settlers against harvesters collecting the bright green, rock-hard olives that are a staple of the Palestinian diet and economy.

On several occasions, Palestinians complained that after driving them from their groves, the settlers collected the olives for themselves.

“They are trying to uproot us from our lands, and without our land, we will have no attachment to Palestine,” said Lufti Azzam, 54, as he sat with his family in the shade of an olive tree eating bread and chicken with spicy peppers. “But we are not going to be as simple-minded as our parents and grandparents. We are not going to leave our land like they did.

We are not going to Jordan and Syria. We are going to resist them and harvest our olives.”

TWO-MONTH-OLD PALESTINIAN GIRL Noha Odah yawns, oblivious as most of her immediate family works nearby on Thursday to harvest olives from a stand of trees they own near the West Bank town of Aqraba. Palestinians have complained that Jewish settlers have cut and burned trees and beat villagers.

Settlers say their fight is primarily pre-emptive and defensive against Palestinians who might use olive harvesting as a ruse to sneak up to Jewish settlements and attack them. (ASSOCIATED PRESS)

CP-2002-091 →

· Austin American Statesman

Olive groves now another West Bank battleground

By John Ward Anderson / THE WASHINGTON POST

MAZRAA SHARQIYA, West Bank — Members of the Azzam family gathered in their 3-acre olive grove last week for a usually routine ritual that has become increasingly hazardous: the annual olive harvest.

As 16 family members, from toddlers to grandparents, shook the branches and raked through the silvery green leaves with their fingers to plunk the small, green olives onto tarps spread like blankets below the trees, they said they were on guard against Jewish settlers who this year are waging a violent and economically devastating war against Palestinian olive pickers.

Next to the family plot, hundreds of olive trees were set afire two weeks ago by residents of nearby Jewish settlements, family members said. Down the road, about 100 other trees were sawed to the ground.

Ten miles north, in the town of Aqraba, settlers three weeks ago shot and killed a 24-year-old Palestinian man who was picking olives on his land, according to Palestinian witnesses.

Since the harvest season began in early October, Palestinian communities across the West Bank have reported almost daily attacks by settlers against harvesters collecting the olives that are a staple of the Palestinian diet and economy. On several occasions, Palestinians complained that after driving them from their groves, the settlers took the olives.

“They are trying to uproot us from our lands, and without our land, we will have no attachment to Palestine,” said Lufti Azzam, 54, as he sat with his family in the shade of an olive tree eating bread and chicken. “But we are not going to be as simple-minded as our parents and grandparents,” he said.

“We are not going to leave our land like they did. We are not going to Jordan and Syria. We are going to resist them and harvest our olives.”

CP-2002-092 →

· The Arizona Republic · Phoenix · page 1

Palestinian artists protest

Say U.S. values are upside down

The Associated Press, Ramallah

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Palestinian artists built a mock Statue of Liberty atop the rubble in Yasser Arafat’s ruined headquarters Thursday to protest U.S. support of Israel. Israeli forces have repeatedly besieged the Palestinian leader’s Ramallah compound, most recently last month in a response to a Palestinian suicide bombing.

Israeli tanks and bulldozers destroyed most of the buildings in the city-block-size compound. Sculptors Nabil Anani and Abdel Hadi Yaish created the 6-foot-high, corrugated cardboard model on the wreckage of a building.

Anani said the message was that the United States violates its own values of freedom by backing Israel. “Therefore we have turned the torch upside down, to say that American values are also upside down,” Anani said, adding that “the destruction around the statue in Arafat’s compound” is proof of Israel’s misdeeds.

Israel charges that Arafat has done nothing to stop militants from attacking Israel, but Palestinians counter that Israel has decimated Palestinian security forces during its many military raids, leaving them powerless to act. The United States in recent months has shunned Arafat and called for his replacement and has been supportive of Israel’s right to defend itself.

Borrowing the most familiar object in American civic iconography and turning it upside down. The Messenger ran the same dispatch as “Palestinians mock Statue of Liberty,” which is a different claim about what they were doing. Photo credit: Nasser Nasser / Associated Press.

CP-2002-024 →

· St. Cloud Times · St. Cloud · page 1

Israel's siege scars West Bank

Palestinians say occupation excessive; Israelis say it derails suicide attacks

The headline names the siege as Israel’s and the verb it gives it is scars, which is what a wound does afterwards. Underneath, the two sides are set out in one line each. The Palestinian line is an opinion about a degree — the occupation is excessive, which concedes the thing and argues about the amount. The Israeli line is a function.

CP-2002-015 →

· Argus Leader · Sioux Falls · page 1

'We've had no water for 10 days'

OCCUPATION OF A WEST BANK CITY. Israeli says military curfew is necessary to prevent suicide bombings

Jamie Tarabay, Associated Press, Jenin, West Bank

“JENIN, West Bank – Israel’s renewed occupation of Jenin – now in its third week – has left its mark everywhere: tanks have knocked down electricity poles and palm trees lining streets, and a military curfew confines tens of thousands of residents to their homes. Israel says it has no choice but to keep what it calls the ‘capital of terror’ in a chokehold.

A disproportionately large number of suicide bombers have come from Jenin and its adjacent refugee camp by the same name. ‘The minute you open the road, you get two, three, four bombers a day,’ said Raanan Gissin, an adviser to Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon. The Palestinians say the Israeli measures are excessive and counterproductive.

‘The presence of the army in Jenin will not stop operations inside Israel. If they leave and hand it back to us, the operations (attacks) would cease,’ said the Jenin governor, Haider Arshaid, pausing while an armored vehicle rumbled by his home.”

“Palestinian children violate a curfew by playing in front of their home last week near a heap of uncollected garbage in the West Bank city of Jenin. There has been a virtually constant Israeli army presence in Jenin since a Palestinian suicide attack against Israelis in June prompted a crackdown.” Brennan Linsley, AP.

Both officials named and quoted in consecutive paragraphs, the Israeli adviser and the Palestinian governor of the city under curfew.

CP-2002-016 →

· St. Louis Jewish Light

Israeli school breaks stereotypes

JESSICA STEINBERG

JERUSALEM (JTA) – A 6-year-old student runs into Ala Hatib's office at the Jerusalem Bilingual School to tell the principal that he hurt his back, with half the sentence in Hebrew, half in Arabic. Hatib chuckles at the bilingual jumble. “I see it every day, every minute, every hour,” says Hatib, who joined the school as co-principal this summer.

But what still surprises him is how quickly he has become attached to the school and its ideals. After a Jew and an Arab founded the nonprofit organization in 1997, the organization established its first school in the Galilee in 1998 and the Jerusalem school a year later.

Bilingual skills form a major component of the school curriculum – all subjects are taught in both Arabic and Hebrew by Arab and Jewish co-teachers – but what most attracts parents is the educational opportunities of a multicultural school in a city that is holy to several religions.

“We want our son to grow up without stigmas, without stereotypes,” said Rema Jebara, a Muslim whoseson is in the second grade. “For us, it was important for him to go to a liberal school where he can say what he wants to say and accept others who are different from him. I want the school to help sculpt his personality.”

JTA wire feature. The article's own sharpest line is further down the page and is not in the excerpt: 'Israeli flags fly outside the school... However, as an Israeli school supervised by the Education Ministry, Palestinian flags are not allowed.' Two ordinary people named, one of them a Palestinian parent speaking for herself.

CP-2002-127 →

· The Capital Times · Madison

Palestinian doctor tells of Israeli abuses

Mamdouh Al-Aker says the worst thing about his 40-day imprisonment by the Israeli government wasn’t that he was in solitary confinement in a one-by-two-meter cell. It was that the clothes they gave him smelled like urine.

Al-Aker, a Palestinian doctor and activist from the West Bank city of Ramallah who was imprisoned in 1991, says he never saw papers saying what he was being charged with and was never brought to trial. Some Israeli officials initially accused him of associating with terrorists, but they later lifted that claim.

“When you have a country in the situation where such a lot of terrorism is going on, you have to be very, very cautious. And sometimes the people who are not directly concerned are the victims of that,” Zalman Shoval, former Israeli ambassador to the United States, said later that year regarding the case.

After his imprisonment, Al-Aker joined the Palestinian delegation to the 1991 Madrid Peace Conference. He has since become an outspoken critic of both the Palestinian National Authority and Israel’s policies in the West Bank. Al-Aker is one of almost a dozen Palestinian and Israeli activists speaking in Madison this month.

His talk Wednesday night at UW-Madison, attended by slightly over two dozen people, was sponsored by Alternative Palestinian Agenda and various university departments, including the Middle East Studies Program and the Haven Center for the Study of Social Structure and Social Change.

“Is it possible to separate the two communities and establish a Palestinian state that lives in peace side by side with Israel? There’s a big question mark now,” said Al-Aker. “It’s becoming every day more and more unachievable.” But, he insisted, “60 to 70 percent of both people want a peaceful resolution.”

Big obstacles to peace include suicide bombings by Palestinians and the Israeli military’s tightening of control on West Bank towns and villages, including curfews, assassinations, home demolitions and infrastructure damage, Al-Aker said. “From my point of view, suicide bombing is unacceptable,” he said.

Militant groups have no standing to accuse Israel of violating international conventions prohibiting warfare against civilians, because suicide bombings violate those same conventions, he said.

CP-2002-046 →

· Newsday

Bitter Harvest in West Bank

Violence curbs olive farming

By Joshua Mitnick / SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT

Yanoun, West Bank — The annual olive harvest season used to be a bucolic time for Palestinian farmers such as Khader and Adnan Abu Haniyeh. After knocking piles of the purplish-brown fruit from their branches, the brothers would brew a pot of tea and smoke cigarettes amid their grove of dusty green trees, orange earth and dried thistle.

This fall, that rhythm has been broken. The brothers' groves shade rocky slopes within sight of the Jewish settlement of Itamar. For two weeks last month, the men stayed out of the groves, fearing a confrontation with gunmen from the settlement. In recent days, to avoid losing their crop, the brothers have gone to harvest.

But now it's Ramadan, the Muslim month of fasting, and as they abstain from food and drink during daylight hours, the men have been able to work only slowly. “When you breathe you feel thirsty,” said Adnan Abu Haniyeh, 30. “By the afternoon all of us feel weak and hungry.”

The olive harvest has brought tension for decades, ever since settlers arrived in the West Bank. But this year's olive grove violence has been the worst, leaving a Palestinian farmer dead and scores injured after clashes with settler vigilante squads. The violence has flared partly because a bountiful harvest drew more pickers into the groves.

Palestinian families, their businesses and jobs lost to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, have been desperate to harvest their olives. The settlers have been quicker to attack than they used to be because of recent incidents in which Palestinian militants have crept into Itamar and other settlements to kill residents in their homes.

Settlers have formed vigilante squads to prevent Palestinians from approaching anywhere within sight of the settlements.

Khader Abu Haniyeh takes a break from picking olives in his family's orchard outside Yanoun, in the West Bank, earlier this month. (Photo by Joshua Mitnick)

CP-2002-093 →

· Fresno Bee · Fresno · page 1

Seven killed in Israeli tank assault

White House document blames Palestinians for failing to curtail militants' violence.

Ahmed Rabah, a doctor at the Al-Aqsa hospital in nearby the nearby village of Deir el Balah. He said the toll could rise. Rabah did not identify the casualties.

A day earlier, an Israeli helicopters fired a missile into a Gaza City building, killing a… Palestinian Cabinet Minister S… called it “unfair and unacceptable”… The Palestinians blame Israe… crackdown for fueling the violence.

The scan is a narrow crop and the right-hand column is cut. Two printing errors are kept as set: in nearby the nearby village and an Israeli helicopters.

CP-2002-017 →

· Standard Speaker · Hazleton

Israeli army incursion into Gaza refugee camp leaves 10 dead

Israeli army is in the first two words, which the Ventura County Star the same day left out (CP-2002-019). What it gives up for that is the verb: an incursion that leaves ten dead has the deaths as something found afterwards, like litter. Put the two headlines side by side and a reader can have the actor or the act, not both.

CP-2002-018 →

· Ventura County Star · Ventura

Incursion into Gaza camp kills 10

Two papers carried this on 7 December 2002 and between them they hold all the pieces, but neither holds them at once. Here the verb is strong — an incursion kills ten — and no army is in the sentence. In the Standard Speaker the army is named and the verb goes soft: the incursion leaves ten dead (CP-2002-018).

CP-2002-019 →

· The New York Times · New York

10 Palestinians Are Killed in Israeli Hunt for a Militant

Michael Wines

“All the young men here left their houses, she said. Some had guns.”

Palestinians waded in the debris of a home destroyed yesterday morning by Israelis. The militant who had been sought by the Israelis eluded them.

Bureij camp. The dead include Merwan Tahrawi, 15, his relative Osama Hassan Tahrawi, 27, a guard at a United Nations preparatory school, and Ahlam Riziq Alwawi, 31, a teacher struck by shrapnel inside her own house. Siham Tahwari, 44, is the mother quoted. Ten people, and the man the army came for got away.

CP-2002-069 →

· (newspaper unidentified) · page 1

Israeli soldiers kill disabled Palestinian

By Steve Weizman, Associated Press, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM — Israeli troops shot and killed a mentally disabled Palestinian yesterday and arrested an alleged gunman accused of killing a 10-month-old Israeli girl last year in the West Bank city of Hebron… In yesterday’s violence, Israeli troops shot and killed a 28-year-old mentally disabled Palestinian, Basel al-Koa, at a military checkpoint near the West Bank town of Tulkarem.

The army said soldiers opened fire when the man refused an order to halt and started running… Planning Minister Nabil Shaath said attacks on all Israeli civilians must stop, including those on Jewish settlers in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. “Stopping targeting Israeli civilians is a step that needs to be implemented,” Shaath said.

The Palestinian Authority has condemned attacks on civilians in Israel but has said settlers and soldiers remain legitimate targets.

The same Associated Press dispatch as the Star-Ledger, and the headline is the finding. Three papers here carried it. Two wrote Disabled Palestinian is shot dead and Mentally disabled Palestinian killed, both of which leave out who fired. This one writes it down. The masthead is not in the scan, so the paper is recorded as unidentified rather than guessed at.

CP-2002-026 →

· The Star-Ledger · Newark · page 1

Disabled Palestinian is shot dead

Another Arafat aide joins the call to end attacks on Israeli civilians

By Steve Weizman, Associated Press, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM — Israeli troops shot and killed a mentally disabled Palestinian yesterday and arrested an alleged gunman accused of killing a 10-month-old Israeli girl last year in Hebron… In yesterday’s violence, Israeli troops shot and killed a 28-year-old mentally disabled Palestinian, Basel al-Koa, at a military checkpoint near Tulkarem.

The army said soldiers opened fire when the man refused an order to halt and started running. Near the city of Nablus, a 25-year-old woman was shot dead by troops and her husband and her mother were wounded as they drove along a dark road in defiance of a dusk-to-dawn curfew, Palestinian security sources said.

The army had no immediate comment.… Jewish settler leaders called for the death penalty for the alleged gunman.

“The murder of this baby, which shocked the entire nation, requires more severe punishment than the usual prison sentences,” the settler leaders said in a statement… Israel’s Supreme Court yesterday temporarily put on hold government plans to tear down 15 Palestinian homes in Hebron to make way for a wider road connecting a Jewish settlement to shrines in the city center.

An Israeli soldier welds a fence restricting movement of Palestinians at the Hawara checkpoint near Nablus.

Basel al-Koa is named, and so is the Israeli baby whose killer was arrested the same day. The woman shot dead near Nablus that night is not. The story runs as one column across the top of page eight; the rest of the page is a one-day sale on bras and sleepwear.

CP-2002-027 →

· The Daily Illini · Champaign, Ill.

History, examples prove Israeli military guilty of atrocities against Palestine

David Green, Champaign resident

Paul Weichsel (12/2) writes that it is “self-evident,” that there is a “culture of violence and death in Palestinian society.” By discounting the context of a willfully humiliating 35-year occupation that has destroyed the fabric of Palestinian society, Weichsel lives in a world of self-evident denial, in which his only alternative is to blame Israel's victims.

I would encourage readers to visit the web site electronicintifada.net in order to learn about the occupation, and how to decode the Israeli/American propaganda that denies its historical origins and current realities.

For a minor example, Fatihiya Suliman, aged 70, gave this account of events on April 6, 2002, relating to the destruction of the Jenin refugee camp, and recorded by B'tselem: “When the bulldozer approached our house, we asked the soldiers to let us get Jamal out (Jamal, 38, is deaf and paraplegic). Other women, a male neighbor who spoke Hebrew, and I continued to beg them.

At first, they told us that the commanding officer was sleeping. Then a soldier agreed that we could get him out. But, he said, only the woman was allowed to take him out. We went into the house, but the operator of the bulldozer wouldn't wait even one minute so that we could take Jamal out of the house.

The soldiers who said we could go into the house called out to the soldier who was operating the bulldozer to stop for a moment, but he refused. We rushed in while the bulldozer was already eating away at the house. Amal, my daughter, some women neighbors, and I found Jamal in the house under the rubble. The house began to collapse, and we ran for our lives.

The house was completely destroyed with Jamal underneath.”

The sharpest language in the 2001-02 group sits in this reader letter, not in any staff or wire copy: 'atrocities against Palestine' in the headline, 'Israel's victims', 'a willfully humiliating 35-year occupation'. The letter closes by noting that operators of D-9 bulldozers 'subsequently received citations for "performing under fire with dedication and tenacity"' and calls that a '"self-evident" culture of violence and death,' indeed - turning the phrase from the letter he is answering back on its author.

CP-2002-126 →

· Marshfield News-Herald · Marshfield · page 1

7 Palestinians killed by Israeli army gunfire

Hadeel Wahdan, The Associated Press, Ramallah

“RAMALLAH, West Bank — Israeli troops chasing militants in the West Bank surrounded homes, a hospital and a downtown square Thursday, killing five armed Palestinians and two bystanders, while soldiers reoccupied Bethlehem after withdrawing over Christmas.

The military activity reflected Israel’s strategy of seizing the initiative in its conflict with the Palestinians instead of reacting to Palestinian attacks… Israel’s latest occupation of Bethlehem came after a Palestinian suicide bomber from the town blew himself up on a bus in Jerusalem on Nov. 21, killing 11 passengers.

Israel says it has warnings of other militants planning attacks originating in Bethlehem… Later, after soldiers imposed a curfew, hundreds of Palestinians protested and threw rocks at soldiers, who opened fire, killing an 18-year-old and wounding 20 other people, Palestinians said. The military said Palestinians threw rocks and fire-bombs at soldiers.”

A named agent in the headline, the strategy in the second paragraph, and the Israeli account of why, all in one dispatch.

CP-2002-020 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Raids Kill at Least 8 Palestinians

Dexter Filkins

“Friends grieved over a Palestinian killed yesterday in Ramallah. At least eight Palestinians were killed in incidents in the West Bank and Gaza.”

Friends grieved over a Palestinian killed yesterday in Ramallah. At least eight Palestinians were killed in incidents in the West Bank and Gaza.

The last clipping of 2002 in this deck. Eight dead, reported in the same grammar as the first one: a number, a place, a day.

CP-2002-070 →

· The Star-Ledger · Newark · page 1

Israel bans film about battle at refugee camp

Eight months after Jenin, a state banning a film about it, printed as news in New Jersey. The word the headline uses for what the film is about is battle — which is one of the two available words, and the one the ban presumably preferred.

CP-2002-021 →

· The New York Times

In Nablus, Strife Dims Dreams and Daily Life

By James Bennet

NABLUS, West Bank, Dec. 27 — For Munir Abu Kishek, a boxer, the intifada has meant the end of his hopes of representing Palestinians in the Olympic Games, and the start of a new career selling vegetables from a cart. For Nablus itself, the uprising has meant the slow death of a commercial center that, Palestinians say, once set the standard for this society.

The Israeli Army, which has reoccupied Nablus since June, says that it is here to stop terrorism, and that its measures here have saved Israeli lives.

Staff-written feature datelined Nablus. People of Palestine are called 'Palestinians'. One ordinary person is named in the lede: Munir Abu Kishek, a boxer turned vegetable seller.

CP-2002-124 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco · page 1

Unfortunately, It Was Paradise

By Mahmoud Darwish · University of California; 210 pages; $39.95, $16.95 paperback

Jonathan Curiel

“If there is one writer who best reflects the hopes and frustrations of the Palestinian people, it is Mahmoud Darwish.

For 40 years, the poet has chronicled the Palestinians’ experience with Israel, the Palestinians’ exile from historic lands and the Palestinians’ yearning to return to a kind of normalcy. Yet it would be a mistake to see Darwish as only a ‘protest poet,’ as a new collection of his work makes clear. ‘Unfortunately, It Was Paradise’ covers the full range of Darwish’s career. There are poems about love, such as ‘Lesson From the Kama Sutra.’

(‘Speak to her as a flute would to a frightened violin string, as if you knew what tomorrow would bring’). And poems with references to New York, Paris and other Western cities, like ‘As Fate Would Have It.’ (‘He didn’t look at his watch, nor was he tempted by the trees standing tall under our tenth-floor room in Manhattan.

He was wrapped in memories.’). The poems are a window into Darwish’s own diaspora.

Born in a village in what is now Israel’s Galilee, Darwish fled with his family to Lebanon during the war that followed Israel’s creation. When Darwish returned to Israel a year later, the government legally considered him a ‘present-absent alien’ — an identity he considers in his poem ‘The Owl’s Night,’ which talks about ‘a present not embraced by the past.’ In his 20s, after being jailed by Israeli authorities, Darwish lived much of his life in Lebanon, France, Tunisia and the Soviet Union.

For the past seven years, he has divided his time between Amman, in Jordan, and Ramallah in the West Bank. Many of the poems in ‘Unfortunately, It Was Paradise’ deal with freedom, separation and exile, and about strangers meeting and feeling connected. There are dreams and sadness in these beautiful poems.

The full depth of a man and a people are evident. Poet and professor Carolyn Forche and Munir Akash, an Arab American editor, led the team that translated Darwish’s work into English. This book’s publication is a major event — especially for those who can’t read Arabic and have only heard of Darwish’s reputation.

Now they can discover what the Arab world has known for decades: Darwish is a literary giant whose voice is passionate and universal.”

The book jacket of “Unfortunately, It Was Paradise: Selected Poems,” translated and edited by Munir Akash and Carolyn Forché with Sinan Antoon and Amira El-Zein.

An American reviewer saying, in 2003, the thing this section is about: that it would be a mistake to read him as only a protest poet, and here are the love poems to prove it. The jailing appears in one clause and the poems get the rest of the column. The phrase the Israeli state used for him when he came home, present-absent alien, is printed beside the line of his it produced: a present not embraced by the past.

CP-2003-010 →

· Columbia Missourian · Columbia, MO

62 Palestinian shops destroyed

By MOHAMMED DARAGHMEH, Associated Press

NABLUS, West Bank — Israeli forces staged the biggest demolition in the West Bank in years on Tuesday, destroying 62 shops in a Palestinian village. Also Tuesday, Israel’s Supreme Court relaxed a ban on soldiers using Palestinians as “human shields” or ordering Palestinians to knock on doors of Islamic militants’ houses.

In Gaza, Palestinians fired rockets at two Jewish settlements, damaging buildings but causing no casualties, settlers and the military said. In the village of Nazlat Issa, next to the West Bank border with Israel, seven bulldozers, guarded by 300 soldiers, destroyed shops and market stalls.

Dozens of protesters threw stones at troops, who fired tear gas and rubber-coated steel pellets. Israel says the shops were built illegally. The mayor of the village accused Israel of waging war on the Palestinian economy. The market is a main source of income for the 2,500 residents, said the mayor, Ziad Salem.

Meanwhile, there have been numerous Palestinian complaints about Israeli practices that endanger them. While the military denies using Palestinians as human shields, journalists have documented the practice. The court on Tuesday amended a ruling to say soldiers could use Palestinians, if the Palestinians agree.

Marwan Dalal, a lawyer for the human rights group Adalah, condemned the decision. “International law prohibits the use of civilians by an occupying power,” he said. Israeli police also blew up a car carrying a large amount of explosives in the Israeli Arab city of Um el-Fahm, near the line with the West Bank. Three people escaped from the car.

Meanwhile, an Egyptian effort to bring rival Palestinian factions together in Cairo on Wednesday to negotiate a yearlong end to attacks on Israeli civilians appeared to run aground. Hamas and Islamic Jihad, responsible for dozens of suicide bomb attacks in Israel, said Tuesday that they would not attend the talks.

Officials from Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat’s Fatah movement said they were awaiting further information.

Short, clean, fully legible. For the terminology job its value is precisely the thing that makes it a weak match for Maria’s note: it shows “Israeli Arab” surviving in 2003 as a geographic adjective for a town inside the Green Line, in an article whose people are all “Palestinians”.

CP-2003-032 →

· estimated · The Charlotte Observer · Charlotte · page 1

Israeli forces kill two Palestinians

RAID NETS FUGITIVE - Sharon speaks with Bush about meeting to discuss peace plan

Jason Keyser, The Associated Press, Jerusalem

“JERUSALEM – Israeli undercover troops killed two Palestinians, including a fugitive Islamic militant, in a gun battle at a West Bank firehouse yesterday. Also yesterday, Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon was reported to be trying to arrange a meeting with U.S. President George W. Bush.

Sharon, re-elected this week to another term, spoke with Bush by phone about meeting in Washington to discuss a U.S. peace plan that aims to create a Palestinian state by 2005, a senior official in Sharon’s office said on condition of anonymity.”

“Ismail Hamed, 7, lies in a hospital bed in Jabalia after being injured by, Palestinian security forces said, tank shells fired by Israeli tanks yesterday. Israeli tanks are reported to have fired three tank shells, injuring seven Palestinians under the age of 17, two of them seriously.

According to witnesses and hospital officials, they children had been playing soccer in an open area between Jabalia and Beit Hanoun. An Israeli military source said the shells had been fired at a group of Palestinians who tried to launch rockets from the same area.” Andrea Comas, Reuters.

The caption carries the Palestinian account, the hospital account and the Israeli military account in four sentences. “they children” is the paper’s.

CP-2003-009 →

· The Gazette

A Palestinian boy holds a bomb used by Israeli soldiers as he stands in the rubble of his family home Monday in Jabalia in Gaza

Abid Katib, Getty Images

“A Palestinian boy holds a bomb used by Israeli soldiers as he stands in the rubble of his family home Monday in Jabalia in Gaza.” Abid Katib – Getty Images photo.

A boy in a keffiyeh holding the casing of a bomb, standing in what is left of his house. The caption says who used the bomb, which is more than most of them do. It does not say who he is. Jabalia again — the camp that had one army base inside its boundaries in 1987 (CP-1987-005).

CP-2003-001 →

· The Free Lance-Star · Fredericksburg · page 1

Some Israelis contemplate low-grade ‘genocide’ for Palestinians

Comment

Robert Jensen, Austin, Texas

AUSTIN, Texas — One way to cover up a crime is to find a benign term that hides the violence and cruelty of the act. Such is the case with “transfer,” an idea increasingly being put forward in Israel as a solution to conflict with the Palestinians.

Transfer conjures up images of a worker reassigned to a new office, or a slip allowing a rider to change buses for free. But transfer of the Palestinians would be nothing less than ethnic cleansing. The main public proponents of this have been on the far right of Israeli politics, such as the Moledet Party, which refuses to recognize Palestinian rights.

But in a poll earlier this year, 46 percent of Israelis supported transfer of Palestinians out of the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, while 31 percent favored transferring Israeli Arabs out of the country.

As Israeli author Tanya Reinhart argues in her new book “Israel/Palestine: How to End the War of 1948,” there has long been planning for “the second half of 1948” by some Israeli politicians, including Prime Minister Ariel Sharon.

The phrase refers to the 750,000 Palestinians who fled or were driven from their homes during the 1948 war, which ended with Israel controlling 78 percent of Palestine that existed under the British Mandate (compared with 56 percent under the U.N. partition plan in 1947). Now some Israelis ponder whether can they take 100 percent.

A military campaign to achieve that had been unthinkable, but many now believe that under the cover of a U.S. war against Iraq, Israeli soldiers would be free to finish the job.

I say “finish,” because a slow ethnic cleansing is already under way, primarily through the systematic destruction of the Palestinian economy; when people cannot make a living, many will leave. A study for the U.S.

Agency for International Development released in August showed that one-fifth of Palestinian children were malnourished, due to dramatically lowered Palestinian incomes and disruptions of food distribution because of the tightened Israeli occupation. Life for Palestinians means constant harassment at checkpoints.

Olive trees, central to agriculture there, are bulldozed by Israeli troops who claim they provide cover for snipers. Palestinian homes are demolished, supposedly because Palestinians built on their land without appropriate permits, which Israel will not give them.

This fall the residents of the Palestinian village Yanun chose to leave rather than continue to endure the property destruction and assaults from Israeli settlers from nearby Itamar.

As Effi Eitam of the right-wing National Religious Party has put it, if Palestinians find “the situation so hard and so dangerous that they prefer to move to some other part of the world,” well, he will shed no tears. The plan appears to be working.

According to the Jerusalem Post, by August last year about 80,000 Palestinians had left the West Bank and Gaza, a 50 percent increase over last year. If this ethnic cleansing — either the slow version or expulsion by Israeli soldiers — is successful, another term may come into play: genocide.

The crime of genocide is generally associated with mass killing, but international law defines genocide as acts intended “to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial, or religious group.”

One of the five types of acts is “deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part.” Creating conditions “so hard and dangerous” that they drive people off their land is a way to eliminate the Palestinian people.

Not all the Palestinians need be killed; once completely dispersed in other countries, they will cease to be a recognizable group that could press a claim to that land. Is the world ready to accept that kind of genocide as a solution to the conflict?

No doubt the world is not; for years there has been a consensus on a diplomatic settlement that calls on Israel to withdraw from illegally occupied territory in return for peace. The key is whether the United States will allow it.

For years the United States — which supplies Israel with diplomatic support, military assistance, and at least $3 billion a year in economic aid — has backed Israeli power and called it a “peace process.” Unless we demand that our government press for peace rooted in justice, this process will be the end of the Palestinian people.

A cartoon runs with the column: a figure on a ladder painting over the word PEACE with the letters PLO. Signed Barkalov.

An American journalism professor arguing the case for the word in 2003, and doing it by quoting the legal definition clause by clause. He is identified at the foot as teaching at the University of Texas at Austin.

CP-2003-002 →

· The Plain Dealer · Cleveland

United States must demand justice for Palestinians

CP-2003-015 →

· Index-Journal · Greenwood

Two Palestinian farmers killed by Israeli fire

JERUSALEM — Israeli tank fire killed two Palestinian farmers in the Gaza Strip on Monday, and soldiers arrested a leader of Yasser Arafat’s Fatah group on the West Bank. Meanwhile, an opinion poll indicated that Palestinians are increasingly feeling the economic pinch of their 28-month-old conflict with Israel.

In the village of Abassan in the Gaza Strip, Israeli tanks fired shells and machine guns in an open area, killing two men, ages 60 and 29, and wounding four others with shrapnel and gunshots, Palestinian security officials said. The Israeli military said the shots were fired about 60 yards from a restricted border fence.

CP-2003-016 →

· The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City · page 1

Violence Continues as Sharon Tries to Form Government

Gunmen shot dead after killing Israeli officer and soldier

By James Bennet, The New York Times, Jerusalem

“In the Gaza Strip, Israeli forces, apparently firing from helicopters, killed two 21-year-old male nurses at a hospital for rehabilitating the disabled, Palestinian officials said.

The shooting, which the Israeli army said it was investigating, occurred shortly before midnight Wednesday.… The army said it was still investigating the death Wednesday of a 65-year-old woman, Kamla Said, who was crushed when Israeli forces demolished the family home of her stepson. She apparently did not hear the Israelis’ warnings to evacuate, her family said.

The army said that its soldiers followed the proper procedure.… Near the Israeli-Arab town of Umm el-Fahm shortly after noon Thursday, officers of the border police stopped a man who was walking with a group of Palestinians and who aroused their suspicions… the police ordered the man to lift his shirt to demonstrate he was not wearing a bomb… Another officer then shot and killed the man, who was identified only as Arab.”

Fifteen months after a deaf man was shot near a watchtower because, the army said, he ignored spoken warnings, a woman of sixty-five is crushed in a demolition because, her family says, she did not hear them. In both cases the warning is the defense. He was never named. She is: Kamla Said. The same page reports two nurses killed at a rehabilitation hospital, and a man shot at Umm el-Fahm who is identified only as Arab.

CP-2003-011 →

· estimated · Austin American Statesman · Austin

Sharon sets own pace for peace talks

Despite U.S. call for quick action, prime minister says his first priority is economy

By Margaret Coker / INTERNATIONAL STAFF

JERUSALEM — Introducing his new government, Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon set tough conditions Thursday for peace talks with Palestinians, even as President Bush urged him to work quickly toward Palestinian independence.

In a strongly worded speech delivered to the Israeli parliament, Sharon appeared to put his government at loggerheads with the U.S.-backed plan — outlined by Bush in a speech Wednesday night — to establish a Palestinian state by 2005. While Sharon conveyed a hope for peace, he didn’t offer details about how to achieve it.

“The people of Israel strive for peace, and I am convinced that, in exchange for true peace, there is readiness for painful concessions,” he said. But Sharon said that deep reforms in the Palestinian leadership would be required before he considers negotiations.

Furthermore, he said renewing peace talks would require special Cabinet approval, a difficult hurdle since two parties in his four-party coalition, the National Religious Party and National Union, oppose Palestinian independence. Some National Union leaders have even advocated exiling the 3 million Palestinians to Egypt and annexing the West Bank and Gaza Strip to Israel.

Sharon also said Palestinians must drop their longtime demand for the “right of return” to parts of Israel from which they were displaced during the 1948 Mideast war. He also said that Jerusalem must remain an undivided city under Jewish control. Palestinians want their capital in east Jerusalem.

Newly appointed Israeli Foreign Minister Silvan Shalom, left, and newly appointed Finance Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, center, attend a parliament session with Prime Minister Ariel Sharon on Thursday in Jerusalem.

Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping — the trim begins just below a rule at the top of the page and nothing names the paper. The story says the speech was delivered “Thursday”, consistent with a Friday paper; Feb. 28, 2003 was a Friday. That is the only internal support for the date.

CP-2003-022 →

· Argus Leader · Sioux Falls · page 1

Sioux Falls Muslims take their views to the streets

Iraq war prompts protests, prayer

John-John Williams IV, Argus Leader

“About 50 people walked up and down Sixth Street Friday afternoon, carrying signs and protesting the U.S. invasion of Iraq. The group gathered in front of the Islamic Center of Sioux Falls to let the community know they oppose the war.

‘We condemned the killing of innocent people on September 11 (2001), now we condemn the killing of innocent people in Iraq,’ said Mohamed Sahrif, director of the Islamic Center. Among messages on protesters’ signs: ‘Sharon Is the Terrorist,’ ‘Genocide in Palestine,’ ‘Work for Peace,’ ‘S.D.

Values Justice,’ and ‘Stop the War.’ Mustapha Dibba said the U.S. invasion disheartened him. ‘This is the worse experience in my life,’ said Dibba. ‘We must not forget our history. We were all guided here because of suppression.’ Azeem Muhammad called the war unjust. ‘It needs to come to a stop,’ Muhammad said.

‘If he (Saddam) had any weapons of mass destruction, it was because the Americans sold it to him.’ John Koch, a spokesman for the Islamic Center, said most people expected the bombing. Many think both President Bush and Saddam…”

“Members of the Islamic Center of Sioux Falls protest the war against Iraq after midday prayers Friday. John Koch, a spokesman for the Islamic Center, said most members wish President Bush and Saddam Hussein could have found a peaceful solution.” Lloyd B. Cunningham / Argus Leader. A placard in the photograph reads “GENOCIDE IN PALESTINE.”

The word on a hand-lettered sign in South Dakota, carried at a protest about Iraq. The paper lists it among the messages without comment. The story continues on 3B, which is not on this clipping.

CP-2003-003 →

· The Brainerd Dispatch · Brainerd · page 1

Hundreds of Palestinian minors in Israeli custody

Jason Keyser, The Associated Press, Jerusalem

“JERUSALEM — About 300 Palestinian minors have been rounded up in Israeli army sweeps over the past year and are being held in crowded lockups, some without charges, lawyers and human rights monitors say.

The army acknowledges it has locked up teens, but treats those over 16 as adults, despite international conventions defining minors warranting special treatment as those under 18. Israel says militant groups often recruit teens, pointing to a 16-year-old suicide bomber, Issa Bdair from Bethlehem, who killed two Israelis in a blast in Tel Aviv last year.

Several other bombers have been minors. Roundups of Palestinians have intensified in the past year, and the International Committee of the Red Cross says a total of 7,600 Palestinians are currently in custody.

Red Cross officials say they have visited 260 minors in Israeli lockups… A 14-year-old, Ali Rahman, said he was jailed for eight days after throwing a stone at an army jeep that drove past his home in the Aida refugee camp in Bethlehem. Ali said he slept on a floor with a blanket, sharing a cell with 15 other boys at the West Bank’s Etzion military detention center.

Israeli human rights lawyer Tamar Peleg represents several Palestinian teens, including Mohammed Najar from Bethlehem who was first arrested when he was 15… Najar is being held in so-called administrative detention, a practice held over from British Mandate rule that allows the army to jail Palestinians without trial or charges… Israel is in violation of the U.N.

Convention on the Rights of the Child, which defines minors as younger than 18, said Jessica Montell, director of B’tselem. The treaty, which Israel signed and ratified, says the arrest and imprisonment of children should be a last resort and for the shortest appropriate time, and they should not be jailed with adults.”

Both arguments inside one dispatch, including the Israeli one, named and dated. Two of the children are named and their ages given, and so is the Israeli lawyer acting for them.

CP-2003-004 →

· Vicksburg Post · Vicksburg · page 1

Palestine never was a 'verdant resort'

Diana West, The Washington Times

“In 1857, the British consul in Palestine, James Finn, told his government that Palestine ‘is in a considerable degree empty of inhabitants and therefore its greatest need is that of a body of population.’ Ten years later, Mark Twain visited the Holy Land, recording his impressions in ‘The Innocents Abroad.’

Jericho was ‘a moldering ruin,’ he wrote. About the Galilee, he noted ‘a desolation … that not even imagination can grace with the pomp of life and action.’ Which is pretty desolate. As for the land around Jerusalem, ‘The further we went … the more rocky and bare, repulsive and dreary the landscape became,’ Twain wrote.

‘There was hardly a tree or shrub anywhere. Even the olive and cactus, those fast friends of a worthless soil, had almost deserted the country.’

Things hadn’t changed much by 1881, when British cartographer Arthur Penrhyn Stanley observed, ‘In Judea it is hardly an exaggeration to say that for miles and miles there is no appearance of life or habitation.’

To be sure, there were at this time Arabs (and Jews) living in Palestine, but 1881 hardly marks the shimmering high point of civilization Yasser Arafat would describe to the United Nations in 1974 when he conjured visions of ‘a verdant land, inhabited mainly by an Arab people in the course of building its life and dynamically enriching its indigenous culture.’

Why it is that the world came to accept the mendacious vision of a terror-kingpin over a wealth of historical impressions recorded by writers, scientists and officials is a tantalizing question… Somehow, the weight of the world’s collective understanding of history flipped: Myth turned to fact, and the facts were forgotten… I just know I never came across such vivid eyewitness accounts of 19th-century Palestine as those above until I read them (and others) in the 2000 edition of Benjamin Netanyahu’s excellent Middle East primer ‘A Durable Peace: Israel and Its Place Among the Nations.’… What is different now, I fear, is that the world sees Palestinian terrorism, including suicide terrorism, in a new light.”

A syndicated column making the empty-land argument in 2003, and saying where it read the sources: a book by Benjamin Netanyahu. The Arafat sentence it is written against is quoted here as the column quotes it.

CP-2003-005 →

· York Sunday News · York, PA

Israel: Disband Hamas

THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

JERUSALEM — Israel’s foreign minister said yesterday that no progress can be made on a U.S.-backed peace plan unless the Palestinian Authority decides to dismantle the violent Hamas group. The comments came as Palestinians continued efforts to instead win a Hamas pledge to stop attacks. On the West Bank, Israeli troops shot and killed a Hamas militant.

European, U.S. and U.N. mediators were scheduled to meet today to discuss ways of salvaging the road map plan. President Bush could dispatch National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice — whom he has called his “personal representative” to the Mideast peace process — to the region as early as next week, administration officials said.

The visit would be the latest in a series of high-level U.S. efforts to bolster the road map, which Bush launched at a June 4 Mideast summit. The plan, a blueprint for ending 33 months of violence and establishing a Palestinian state by 2005, has been hobbled by deadly bombings and missile strikes.

Clean, fully legible clipping; the whole item is transcribed. Useful mainly as a 2003 baseline showing what the wire register looks like when no Arab citizen of Israel is in the story: “Palestinian” appears only as an institution or a future state.

CP-2003-030 →

· The Herald Journal

Main road open in Gaza Strip

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip (AP) — Israeli and Palestinian commanders shook hands Monday, bulldozers dismantled checkpoints and Palestinian traffic flowed freely in the Gaza Strip — the most significant sign of disengagement after 33 months of bloody fighting. But one man was killed in a Palestinian shooting.

In line with a U.S.-backed peace plan, Israel pulled troops out of northern Gaza late Sunday, and agreed to withdraw from the West Bank town of Bethlehem on Wednesday.

In another reflection of the bid to end 33 months of fighting, Prime ministers Ariel Sharon of Israel and Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian Authority were to meet in Jerusalem on Tuesday, Palestinian sources said. Several Palestinian militant groups announced a suspension of attacks against Israelis on Sunday.

But the first full day of truce was marred by the killing of a Romanian truck driver on an Israeli construction crew. But there was also a first glimmer of optimism as Israeli troops pulled out of Beit Hanoun, which had seen most of its farmland razed by Israeli bulldozers.

“You were late,” Mohammed Shabat, 65, pointing to the destruction, told Palestinian policemen who took over the Israeli positions. “But, God willing, we will bring this town back to the old days.”

“This is a very important and serious step by the Israeli side toward the implementation of the road map,” said Palestinian Information Minister Nabil Amr.

An Israeli police officer is seen through a bullet riddled front windshield of a truck in which a Romanian worker was shot while working on a bypass road next to the West Bank village of Yabed east of Tulkarem on Monday.

CP-2003-026 →

· The Greenville News

Israel offers Bethlehem to Palestinians

Both sides optimistic about truce despite shooting in West Bank

By Alexandra Zavis, The Associated Press

JERUSALEM — Israel agreed to return the West Bank town of Bethlehem to Palestinian control after its pullback Monday from the Gaza Strip, crucial steps that advance a U.S.-backed “road map” to Palestinian statehood and raise hopes that 33 months of violence may be nearing an end.

The two sides’ prime ministers also set a meeting to plan their next moves, as bulldozers tore down Israeli checkpoints and traffic flowed freely in Gaza for the first time in months. Palestinian police took control of the Gaza town of Beit Hanoun on the heels of the departing Israeli troops.

The developments followed declarations of a temporary halt to attacks by three main Palestinian groups, but there were still trouble spots. The first full day of the truce was marred by a Palestinian shooting that killed a Bulgarian construction worker on an Israeli road project near the West Bank town of Yabed.

Renegade members of the Al Aqsa Martyrs’ Brigades, loosely linked to Yasser Arafat’s Fatah movement, claimed responsibility. However, Palestinian Information Minister Nabil Amr said it was not clear Fatah was involved. “It was an individual attack that should not affect the truce declaration,” he said.

Despite the violence, Israeli and Palestinian officials remained upbeat about prospects for further advances under the “road map” peace plan launched by President Bush at a June 4 summit. The plan leads through three stages to a Palestinian state in 2005.

Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon declined to criticize his Palestinian counterpart, Mahmoud Abbas, after the shootings, noting that security responsibility was handed over to the Palestinian Authority in the northern Gaza town of Beit Hanoun only on Monday morning.

In the West Bank: An Israeli police officer is seen through a bullet-riddled front windshield of a truck in which a Bulgarian worker was shot while working on a bypass road next to the West Bank village of Yabed on Monday.

CP-2003-027 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco

Teens take steps toward expression

“In our performances, we have a message, and this message includes our dreams and our hopes,” says Nadi, 18. “We want the world to know that Palestinian children — besides throwing stones — can dance.”

Every member of Ibdaa (which, in Arabic, means “to create something out of nothing”) knows too well the intifada and the violent tit-for-tat that has claimed thousands of Palestinian and Israeli lives. The Martyrs Cemetery in Dheisheh is full of their friends who grew up in the camp and died within its confines.

Jehad al-Shamarkheh speaks for others when he says he wants one day to leave the camp for good — preferably for his ancestral home, which existed before 1948 in what is now Israeli land.

For now, al-Shamarkheh concentrates on helping to coach the Ibdaa troupe, which mixes traditional Palestinian dances called debkeh with modern choreography and recorded music of the oud, shabbabah (Palestinian flute) and other instruments. The music features exquisite singing and instrumentation.

“This is our third generation of dancers,” says Shamarkheh, 21, a former Ibdaa dancer who is on the current tour as a youth leader. Ibdaa’s one-month U.S. tour, which is sponsored by Berkeley’s Middle East Children’s Alliance, began July 3 in Los Angeles and ends Aug. 6 in New York.

Some of the members are seeing the United States for the first time. Others, like Sanabel al-Fararja, participated in Ibdaa’s 1999 American tour.

Last year, al-Fararja and Kayan al-Saify made headlines when they visited the United States to attend the Academy Awards (as guests of the documentarians who made “Promises,” a film about Palestinian and Israeli children) and had to stay after Israel sealed off Dheisheh and their parents advised them not to return.

The dance troupe Ibdaa, including Nidaa Farraj, top, and Ahmed Alghrouz, waving a Palestinian flag, rehearses for Bay Area shows. Photos by Paul Chinn / The Chronicle

CP-2003-021 →

· estimated · Pittsburgh Post-Gazette · Pittsburgh

Israel blocks Palestinian spouses’ residency

By James Bennet / The New York Times

JERUSALEM — The Israeli parliament yesterday voted to block Palestinians who marry Israelis from becoming Israeli citizens or residents, erecting a new legal barrier as Israel finished the first section of a new physical barrier against West Bank Palestinians. Supporters of the legislation called it a necessary bulwark against infiltration by terrorists.

“We are in a state of war — not with the English, or the Americans, or the Dutch, or the Slovaks — we are at war with our neighbors, the Palestinians,” Gideon Sa’ar, of the dominant Likud Party, told the parliament in debate before the vote. “It’s a tragic reality.”

Proponents also called the law a way to preserve Israel’s Jewish majority. Foes called the law a racist measure that threatened to divide thousands of families or force them out of Israel. Roughly 1.2 million of Israel’s 6.7 million citizens are Arabs, and they are far more likely than Israeli Jews to marry Palestinians.

“It cannot be that, because of the actions of one or 10 or 20, that a population of 1 million will be punished,” said Ahmad Tibi, an Israeli-Arab member of parliament. He called the law “blacker than black.” The vote was 53-25, with one abstention.

Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping — it is a single trimmed column beginning at the headline. The lead says the parliament voted “yesterday”; the Knesset vote was taken Thursday, July 31, 2003, which is consistent with a Friday, Aug. 1 paper. Nothing on the clipping names the newspaper.

CP-2003-023 →

· The Ledger · page A7

Marriage Law Blocking Israeli Citizenship Moves Ahead

By JAMES BENNET / The New York Times

JERUSALEM — The Israeli parliament voted Thursday to block Palestinians who marry Israelis from becoming Israeli citizens or residents, erecting a new legal barrier as Israel finished the first section of a new physical barrier against West Bank Palestinians. Supporters of the legislation called it a necessary bulwark against infiltration by terrorists.

“We are in a state of war — not with the English, or the Americans, or the Dutch, or the Slovaks — we are at war with our neighbors, the Palestinians,” Gideon Sa’ar, of the dominant Likud Party, told the parliament in debate before the vote. “It’s a tragic reality.”

Proponents also called the law a way to preserve Israel’s Jewish majority. Opponents of the law called it a racist measure that threatened to divide thousands of families or force them out of Israel. Roughly 1.2 million of Israel’s 6.7 million citizens are Arabs, and they are far more likely than Israeli Jews to marry Palestinians.

“It cannot be that because of the actions of one, or 10, or 20, that a population of one million will be punished,” said Ahmad Tibi, an Israeli-Arab member of parliament. He called the law “blacker than black.”

After occupying the West Bank and Gaza Strip in the Six-Day War of 1967, Israel began permitting Israelis who married residents of the territories to apply for their spouses in Israel under a program of family unification. Last year, the Israeli government froze any such requests.

Thursday’s parliamentary action, which effectively puts the government’s freeze into law, will lapse after a year if it is not renewed. Yuval Steinitz, a parliamentary leader from Likud, accused the governing Palestinian Authority of encouraging Palestinians to marry Israeli Arabs and move into Israel.

“It’s not a humanitarian case — or not only humanitarian — but a deliberate strategy by the Palestinian Authority to change the demographic balance in Israel in order to destroy us,” he said in a telephone interview.

He said that if, as envisioned by a new peace plan, a Palestinian state is to be created in the West Bank and Gaza, then “Palestinians should be unified there.” Orna Kohn, a staff attorney for Adalah, a legal organization for Arab minority rights in Israel, said her group would petition the courts to overturn the law as violating basic rights.

She noted that it did not apply to non-Palestinian foreign spouses of Israelis, and she said that it was also aimed at Israel’s Arab citizens. “You have an Israeli citizen who is an Arab, and you won’t allow him to live with his spouse?” she said. “If this is not racism then perhaps we need to have a new definition.”

Tensions have been growing between Israel’s Jewish and Arab populations during the course of the conflict with the Palestinians, which began in September 2000. On Thursday, Israeli education authorities shut down an Israeli-Arab day care center in northern Israel that they said was extolling “suicide acts of Palestinians.”

The government did not disclose precise figures of how many Palestinians had become Israeli citizens or residents, or had submitted applications to do so. Israeli officials said that 49 Israelis had been killed in some 20 attacks that to some extent involved Palestinians who had entered Israel through family unification. The vote was 53-25, with one abstention.

Date check: The running head reads in full: “THE LEDGER • WWW.THELEDGER.COM • FRIDAY, AUGUST 1, 2003” with the folio “A7” at the right. Paper and date both match the slide label exactly, and Aug. 1, 2003 was a Friday.

CP-2003-024 →

· estimated · The Ledger

West Bank Security Wall Fuels More Palestinian Anger Against Israel

By LARA SUKHTIAN / The Associated Press

QALQILIYA, West Bank — Khaled Amer’s family tilled their vegetable fields and guava groves for three generations — until Israel cut their land in half with a security barrier it’s building in the West Bank.

Amer’s story is no rarity in Qalqiliya: the town is walled off on three sides by a combination of concrete walls, fences, razor-wire and trenches that residents say is strangling their livelihood and feeding anger at Israel.

“If they want a security wall, why don’t they build it on their land?” asks Amer, gazing through the fence at fields he hasn’t been able to tend for five months. “This is the land that I live off, this is the land that feeds me, and now they’ve come and taken it away.”

The obstructions around Qalqiliya are part of a 370-mile-long barrier Israel is building near the dividing line with the West Bank, arguing it is needed to keep out Palestinian militants who have killed hundreds of Israelis in three years of violence.

But, in some areas, the barrier plunges deep into the West Bank to encompass larger Israeli settlements, effectively gobbling up Palestinian areas, splitting towns from their hinterlands and blocking Palestinians from jobs in Israel or other parts of the West Bank.

Perhaps no town along the route of the barrier better illustrates the reasons for Palestinian anger over the project — and the Israeli rationale for it — than Qalqiliya.

Activists from the International Solidarity Movement and Palestinians spray graffiti during a demonstration against the wall erected by Israel in the West Bank town of Qalqiliya on Thursday.

Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping — the trim starts immediately above the headline. The caption dates the demonstration to “Thursday”, consistent with a Friday paper; Aug. 1, 2003 was a Friday. Nothing on the clipping names the newspaper.

CP-2003-025 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago, IL

Wall adds security, builds enmity

Some sleeping easier, others see land grab at work

By Uli Schmetzer, Special to the Tribune

UM AL-FAHM, Israel — The day soldiers put down the stakes for the new Israeli security barrier on the hill behind his house, Ahmed Yussef Jabarin realized he was about to be zoned out of Israel and into the West Bank. Jabarin, 67, a farmer, is one of Israel’s 1.3 million Arab citizens. Like most Israeli Arabs, he grumbles about being treated like a second-class Israeli.

But he had no intention of joining his fellow Palestinians on their side of the controversial new divide, a wall and fence already snaking 90 miles down the northern part of the West Bank. The barrier has drawn fierce criticism because much of it is to be built inside the West Bank, creating a new de facto border that carves away Palestinian territory.

In Jabarin’s case, however, the opposite was proposed. Planners were willing to give up Israeli territory to locate the fence on the hill, providing a better vantage point. “Listen, I’m an Israeli,” he said. “Why should they kick me out? Because I’m an Arab they tried to make me into a Palestinian. It would have killed me. There is no work, no money over there.”

So he protested. His cousin Rafiq Jabarin, a lawyer, took up the case. The municipality of Um Al-Fahm, a town of 37,000 Israeli Arabs on the Green Line dividing Israel and the West Bank, joined in the protest, enraged by the prospect of losing 3 million square feet of land to the Palestinian side if the fence had run its planned course.

The Tribune also prints, in its own voice, “Palestinians dub the new West Bank barrier the ‘Wall of Shame’ or the ‘Apartheid Wall.’ Israelis call it a ‘security fence.’” — an explicit, symmetrical statement that the two sides have different names for the same object, printed on a page whose own people-naming is anything but symmetrical.

CP-2003-033 →

· Austin American Statesman · Austin

Israel releases 334 Palestinian prisoners to joyous homecoming

By Craig Nelson, INTERNATIONAL STAFF

BETHLEHEM, West Bank — Israel freed more than 330 Palestinian prisoners Wednesday, a move it called a goodwill gesture to advance the U.S.-backed peace plan. Palestinian officials reacted to the release with scorn, calling it inadequate. The mood in this biblical town was hardly dismissive, however.

After about 40 Palestinian prisoners were let off an Israeli bus at a nearby checkpoint and their handcuffs were removed, they were showered with an exuberant welcome home by more than a thousand friends, family and supporters as they strode along Pope John Paul II Street.

Some of the freed prisoners were thrust aloft and carried on the shoulders of supporters, while others were mobbed by well-wishers eager to hug and kiss them. Scores of children, many no more than 6, served as triumphal escorts, waving the green and black flags of Islamic militant groups Hamas and Islamic Jihad and sporting headbands to match.

Wednesday's prisoner release came a day after Palestinian Prime Minister Mahmoud Abbas, angered partly by the small number of inmates that Israel announced it would let go, cancelled a summit with Israeli leader Ariel Sharon that had been scheduled to coincide with the releases.

Israel had hoped that the releases would be, as Sharon adviser Arnon Perlman put it Wednesday, “a trust-building move” that would “help promote the (peace) process.” But Yasser Abed Rabbo, a senior member of the Palestinian Authority Cabinet, called the releases “worthless and meaningless” and a “theatrical step to appease Washington.”

A spokesman for Palestinian Authority President Yasser Arafat said, “Israel should free all the prisoners,” a sentiment also expressed by most of the prisoners released Wednesday.

Israel has rejected demands for a mass release of the more than 5,300 Palestinian prisoners it says it still holds, saying that as long as militant groups are not dismantled, it cannot risk swelling their ranks. Sharon has spurned demands from members of his right-wing coalition government to release no suspected militants at all.

The 3-month-old “road map” peace plan, which calls for an end to violence and the establishment of a Palestinian state by 2005, does not specifically mention prisoner releases. But the three main Palestinian militant organizations have made the continuation of a cease-fire they agreed to June 29 conditional on Israel freeing jailed Palestinians.

None of the 334 prisoners released Wednesday was accused of direct participation in attacks on Israelis. More than 180 had been convicted by Israeli courts of crimes ranging from stone-throwing to membership in “terrorist organizations,” and at least 150 others had been detained without trial on unspecified “security grounds.”

Although Israeli authorities said none of those prisoners has “blood on their hands,” the assurances did not ease the concerns of Malka Deri, a 40-year-old Israeli who received burns over more than 90 percent of her body when she was riding on a Jerusalem bus that was blown up by a suicide bomber in November 2002.

“I'm very worried they will be even more motivated to violence after their release. They may want to take revenge,” said Deri, who watched TV news coverage of the release. The expressions of joy she saw on the faces of freed Palestinian prisoners gnawed at her: “It is painful to see the prisoners meet their families and raise their hands in a victory sign.

They look happy as though they have won. I survived a suicide bombing, but other neighbors of mine did not, and it is very painful for their families.”

Hamdi Sha'at hugs his sister Sanaa outside his home at the Khan Younis refugee camp in the southern Gaza Strip on Wednesday. Sha'at was one of more than 300 Palestinian prisoners released as part of what Israel called a goodwill gesture in support of the U.S.-backed peace plan.

Photograph credited Khalil Hamra, Associated Press. The byline foot gives cnelson@coxnews.com.

CP-2003-014 →

· The Patriot Ledger · Quincy

American policy leaves Palestinians no hope

Bill Maxwell

If the Jews are God’s chosen people, then the Palestinians are God’s cursed people. I cannot think of a single, substantive, long-lived good thing that has happened for the Palestinians during my lifetime (I was born in 1945). All people – even Palestinians – need a victory at least one time in their existence.

At some point, all people need to be affirmed in their positive aspirations. All people need real hope, at least temporarily. People cannot withstand perpetual abuse without suffering irreparable damage to their individual and collective psyches. For sure, the Palestinian diaspora has suffered in ways that we may never know.

And nothing good will ever happen for these people until the United States develops the political vision and the moral backbone to lead the way.

The state of Israel apparently has little if any genuine interest in empowering Palestinians with the tools to become self-reliant neighbors – neighbors who have legitimate claims to much of the land that Israelis now call their home. What has been going on in the embattled region is the classic game of blaming the victim.

From the beginning, with the creation of the nation of Israel, Palestinians have been the victims of Israel’s determination to keep them virtually powerless. Since 1948, successive U.S. administrations, citing Israel’s need for security, have given the Jewish state carte blanche to implement undemocratic policies that dehumanize Palestinians.

American would not tolerate such policies anywhere else in the world. The most troubling result of this dynamic – America’s unblinking alliance with Israel – is the birth and maturation of Palestinian organizations that use terror as their means of protest.

The sooner the United States begins to earnestly listen to the Palestinian side, the sooner real progress will occur.

CP-2003-020 →

· The York Dispatch · York · page 1

Thumbs down

“Thumbs down: To the Bureau of Immigration Control and Enforcement (formerly the INS) for deporting Munir Lami with no notice to his family members. The 54-year-old Palestinian, who is blind and suffers from diabetes, was a detainee at the York County Prison.

But recently he called his family and said he’d been asked to sign release papers and was a free man. Before his family could come from Philadelphia to pick him up, he’d been placed on a deportation plane to the Middle East. They argue that it’s not fair to ask a blind man to sign legal papers without his lawyer present.

Granted, Lami was slated for deportation because he’d broken the law and had served time for ‘conspiracy’ pertaining to ‘welfare checks and food stamps,’ according to family members. But that doesn’t justify dumping a blind, diabetic, stateless Palestinian someplace where he has no support — at least not without first notifying his family.”

Six sentences on an editorial page in Pennsylvania. A blind man is asked to sign his own release without a lawyer and put on a plane before his family can drive from Philadelphia. The paper cannot name where he was sent, because he has no country to be sent to.

CP-2003-013 →

· The Herald Mail · page 1

Palestinian Authority freezes funds of Islamic charities

Associated Press, Gaza City

“Palestinian authorities said Thursday they froze the bank accounts of nine Islamic charities to investigate whether the organizations funnel money to militants — the Palestinians’ most striking action yet in a U.S.-sought clampdown on armed groups… The Palestinian Monetary Authority issued the order to shut down 39 accounts of the nine charities on Sunday.

The move became known Thursday, when hundreds of Palestinians relying on welfare payments from charities tried to pick up their monthly checks at banks in Gaza City.

The banks said the accounts were blocked and turned them away.… The airstrike in the southern Gaza town of Khan Younis killed Hamdi Kalakh, 23, as he was driving a donkey cart along a residential street… Dore Gold, an Israeli government spokesman, praised the move.

‘There have been charities that Israel has long suspected of being front organizations for Hamas,’ he said.”

Disabled Palestinian citizens hold signs during a rally organized by Islamic charity associations in the southern Gaza Strip town of Rafah Thursday to protest the freezing of bank accounts.

The story is the freeze. The photograph is who it landed on: men in wheelchairs at the front of a march in Rafah, carrying signs written in English. One of them reads LET US LIVE WITH DIGNITY. It is the first time in this thread that disabled Palestinians appear doing something rather than having something done to them.

CP-2003-012 →

· Daily Herald · page 1

Israeli occupation generates lots of violence of its own

An Arab perspective

Ray Hanania

“Occupation, land confiscation, indiscriminate arrests, and police and military violence all add up to the same kind of terrorism often associated with Arab extremism. Ironically, ‘occupation terrorism’ results in more civilian deaths than the more horrific suicide bombings that get the majority of the American media’s attention.

Since the current intifada three years ago, Israelis have killed 2,216 Palestinians, including 12 Israeli Arabs, nine foreign citizens and 389 victims under the age of 18. During the same period, Palestinians killed 768 Israelis, including 190 settlers, 346 in Israel, seven foreign citizens and 72 minors.

Nearly three times as many Palestinians are killed by the Israeli occupation than Israelis are killed by retaliation attacks and suicide bombings. Which is the more violent?… The Israelis love to talk about the trees they plant in Israel, but they never talk about the trees owned by Palestinians that they uproot.”

A standing column in a suburban Chicago daily, labeled An Arab perspective, with the columnist’s photograph beside it.

CP-2003-008 →

· The Times · page 1

Palestinians camp out in compound, saying they will act as ‘human shields’

Mohammed Daragmeh, The Associated Press

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Two dozen Palestinians at Yasser Arafat’s headquarters settled down for a third straight night Saturday, pledging to serve as human shields if Israel tries to forcibly expel the Palestinian leader.

The men put up two tents next to Arafat’s bullet-pocked, sandbagged office in what remains of his headquarters compound, largely destroyed in previous Israeli raids. “We are here because we decided to be human shields to protect our leader,” said Mohammed Diek, a 22-year-old university student. “We don’t have any weapons.

We just have our bodies.”… When 28-year-old construction worker Morad Hashash heard of the Israeli decision to banish Arafat, he rushed to the compound… “When I heard there would be a human shield I decided to be one of them,” Hashash said.

For the third consecutive night, thousands of Palestinian men, women and children marched into the compound in a demonstration of support for Arafat, who emerged and kissed children. “I wanted to see him for the first time,” said 77-year-old Fatima Kosba. “I wanted to talk to him, to sing for him, to do everything I can for him.

He is our national symbol.”

The earliest human-shields clipping here, and the shields are volunteers who say so by name. Three are named on one page; the record had held one and a half.

CP-2003-006 →

· The Plain Dealer · Cleveland, OH · page L2

Palestinian arrivals hold onto heritage

This gives Greater Cleveland one of the largest Palestinian communities in America. It is largely a first-generation immigrant community, often working-class couples struggling to send their kids to college. The community does not yet enjoy the resources to package its culture in museums or festivals for others to see.

Yet Palestinians display abundant culture going about their daily lives. Freshly butchered lambs hang from meat hooks above the shop floor at Al-Manar Market, and the butcher needs only reach up and pull down a carcass to begin his work at a whirring saw.

On a recent morning, store owner Mahmoud Zayid stood nearby and read aloud in Arabic notes he had scribbled on a piece of yellow notebook paper. A customer had called with specific instructions for cutting her meat. Zayid, his bushy black mustache twitching, watched as his butcher sliced lamb steaks thick as bricks.

He does a brisk business selling imported foods from the Middle East, wood-fired breads and lamb dinners to-go. But he’s most proud of the meats he butchers in accordance with Islamic halal standards, which are similar to kosher guidelines. A native of Jerusalem, Zayid moved his family from Chicago to Cleveland 10 years ago after visiting the city.

He said he liked Cleveland’s proximity to the countryside. Two years ago, he fulfilled his dream of opening a grocery store with a butcher shop. He buys lambs and goats directly from farms, he said, follows them to the slaughterhouse and cuts meats on demand. Customers have rewarded him with increasing business.

“I like Cleveland,” said Zayid, who lives with his wife and six children on the city’s West Side. “It’s quiet. I’m making it.” Palestinian families live scattered throughout western Cuyahoga County, in suburbs including Westlake, North Olmsted and especially Lakewood. But the largest concentration lives within walking distance of Al-Manar Market.

Up and down Lorain Avenue, between West Boulevard and West 130th Street, signs in Arabic news in Arabic. Palestinian women, like other Muslim women, are more likely to gather in each other’s homes. “We can’t have a coffee and go laugh loud in front of men, or take our scarf off,” said Nahida Farunia, who started an Arab American women’s club in Lakewood.

She was often lonely after moving to Cleveland 17 years ago. Not anymore. “You have a lot of Palestinian people from everywhere,” she said. Three Palestinian-owned supermarkets stand near West 117th Street and Lorain Avenue, and customers often greet one another with “al salam elikom,” peace be to you.

Photo credit: “PHOTOGRAPHS BY EUSTACIO HUMPHREY | THE PLAIN DEALER”. Caption 1: “In the Palestinian village of Beit Hanina, a woman elder marks the palm of a bride-to-be with the initials of her future husband, using a red dye from the henna plant. Amnah Abed, of Westlake, chose to continue that tradition at her recent Henna party at the Beit Hanina Social Club in Cleveland.” Caption 2: “Palestinian-Americans, most connected to the West Bank village of Beit Hanina, paraded Amnah Abed, left, and Yazeed Najjar into a traditional Henna the night before their wedding.” Caption 3: “Traditional sweet pastries and other foods were served at the Henna party.” This is the clipping to put beside the Los Angeles Times and Washington Post pair: same people, different continent, and the vocabulary stops wobbling the moment they are not being counted against Israelis.

CP-2003-031 →

· Des Moines Register · Des Moines · page 1

Editorial didn't help Israel/Palestine

Frank Cordaro, Des Moines Catholic Worker

“How irresponsible the opening words are in the Sept. 16 editorial, ‘Arafat Must Go’: ‘Let us be honest about Yasser Arafat. He is not a man of peace … He must go.’ Half a truth can be as dishonest as any lie. Your words reflect the moral bankruptcy of U.S. foreign policy in the Middle East. Sure, Arafat is no prince of peace.

Neither is Ariel Sharon every bit the war criminal Arafat is claimed to be. The Register espouses the same hypocrisy the U.S. government practices in its blind support of the criminal, lethal actions of the state of Israel against the people of Palestine.

Outside of Palestine and Israel, U.S. hypocrisy is the single major reason for the continued blood bath and killing going on in these ancient and Holy Lands… There are people in Palestine and Israel who truly want peace and are willing to work toward that goal. Editorials like the Register’s ‘Arafat Must Go,’ do not help them get closer to their goals.”

A reader answering the paper’s own editorial of 16 September, and citing a second piece in the same issue, “Carter: U.S. Must Push Harder.”

CP-2003-007 →

· York News Times

Sharon aide: Gaza plan seeks to 'freeze' Palestinian statehood

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — A top aide to Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon stirred a hornet’s nest yesterday when he was quoted as saying the purpose of Israel’s proposed withdrawal from the Gaza Strip and parts of the West Bank was to “freeze” Palestinian statehood indefinitely, as if suspended in “formaldehyde.”

“The significance of the disengagement plan is the freezing of the peace process,” Dov Weisglass, senior diplomatic adviser to Sharon, said in unusually candid remarks published by the Israeli daily Haaretz as excerpts from an interview that will appear in the paper tomorrow.

“When you freeze that process, you prevent the establishment of a Palestinian state, and you prevent a discussion on the refugees, the borders and Jerusalem,” Weisglass reportedly said. “Effectively, this whole package called the Palestinian state, with all that it entails, has been removed indefinitely from our agenda.”

Israeli Labor Party leader Shimon Peres immediately pounced on the statements. “You cannot stop the world from turning,” he told Israeli Army Radio. “Whoever aims for a half peace will get a half war.”

Palestinian cabinet minister Saeb Erekat said Weisglass unmasked the “true intentions” behind Sharon’s plan, which Erekat has described as the dumping of Gaza to consolidate Israel’s hold on the West Bank.

Palestinian leaders are deeply skeptical of Sharon’s unilateral-disengagement plan, saying that by Israel’s sinking its roots deeper into the West Bank it destroys the possibility of a contiguous Palestinian state by confining 2.5 million West Bank Palestinians to “bantustans” separated by Jewish settlements.

Israeli soldiers on foot and in an armored vehicle move from the Palestinian town of Beit Hanoun in the northern Gaza Strip toward an army staging area near the Jewish settlement of Nissanit.

CP-2003-017 →

· The Star-Ledger · Newark

Israelis shoot 2 Palestinians in Gaza

Bomb hurts soldier in W. Bank, 2nd dies in gunfire on border

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Israeli troops yesterday fired at Palestinians trying to bypass a checkpoint, critically wounding one man and injuring a 14-year-old boy. Israel said its troops fired warning shots and only shot toward the group after the pedestrians ignored orders to halt.

In the West Bank, a bomb exploded after nightfall under an Israeli army vehicle traveling near the Jewish settlement of Kochav Hashahar, wounding a soldier who was a passenger, rescue and army officials said. And gunfire erupted across the Israel-Lebanese border yesterday, killing one Israeli soldier.

An Israeli military official, speaking on condition of anonymity, blamed the attack on Hezbollah, the anti-Israeli militant guerrilla group active in south Lebanon. But Hezbollah said it was not involved. Hours later, a four-year-old Lebanese boy was killed and his brother wounded in an explosion in a village near the border with Israel.

Israel’s army said at least three mortar shells were shot early today from Lebanon toward northeastern Israel. Lebanese officials said they didn’t know if today’s explosion in the village of Houla was caused by a rocket or an anti-aircraft shell fired toward Israel that fell short.

Meanwhile, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat prepared to swear in a small eight-member Cabinet today, with Ahmed Qureia as prime minister, after declaring a state of emergency in the Palestinian areas. Arafat’s decree came a day after an Islamic Jihad suicide bomber killed 19 Israelis in a restaurant in the port city of Haifa.

The Palestinians wounded in the Gaza Strip had been trying to cross a road closed by the military a daily earlier, as part of new restrictions imposed in response to the Haifa bombing. The road links the southern Gaza towns of Rafah and Khan Younis, and was blocked by a checkpoint.

A 42-year-old man was in critical condition with a head wound, and 14-year-old boy was shot in the leg, hospital officials said. On Sunday, a 26-year-old man was killed and three others were wounded while trying to bypass the same checkpoint.

Also yesterday, Israeli tanks and bulldozers entered the Rafah refugee camp in southern Gaza and demolished four Palestinian homes, Palestinian security officials and local residents said.

Israeli army officials said they had no report of house demolitions in the area but that Palestinians fired anti-tank missiles, mortar shells and live ammunition toward Israeli forces in the area. One Israeli soldier was slightly injured, the army spokesman said.

A Palestinian man carries his son as he climbs a sand barricade at a junction on the main beach road south of Gaza City yesterday. The Israeli army blocked the road Sunday, preventing north-south vehicle travel.

CP-2003-018 →

· The Forum

FBI reportedly funneled money to Hamas

WASHINGTON – While President Clinton was trying to broker an elusive peace between Israelis and Palestinians, the FBI was secretly funneling money to suspected Hamas figures to see if the militant group would use it for terrorist attacks, according to interviews and court documents.

The counterterrorism operation in 1998 and 1999 was run out of the FBI’s Phoenix office in cooperation with Israeli intelligence and was approved by Attorney General Janet Reno, FBI officials told The Associated Press.

Several thousand dollars in U.S. money was sent to suspected terror supporters during the operation as the FBI tried to track the flow of cash through terror organizations, the FBI said in a rare acknowledgment of an undercover sting that never resulted in prosecutions.

“This was done in conjunction with permission from the attorney general for an ongoing operation, and Israeli authorities were aware of it,” the bureau said. One of the FBI’s key operatives, who has had a falling out with the bureau, provided an account of the operation at a friend’s closed immigration court proceeding.

AP obtained and reviewed the court documents.

CP-2003-019 →

· The Times and Democrat · Orangeburg, SC

Put Arafat on trial

NAT HENTOFF

Israel should not remove or kill Yasser Arafat. Assassinating him will make this lifelong revolutionary a martyr for the ages, and not only among Palestinians. But he should be put on trial, in Jerusalem, for direct involvement in serial acts of terrorism against civilians. This trial should be entirely public – unlike state trials in Cuba and China.

Facilities should be provided for the world press, including neutral, professional translators that are neither from Israel, nor the Palestinian Authority nor Arab countries.

Intense worldwide attention will certainly be paid to these proceedings, considering the identity of the defendant and the issues to be raised in the trial – historical and contemporary – that will concern a number of nations, as well as Israel and the Palestinian Authority.

Arafat’s defense will surely include extensive charges against the state of Israel, including that state’s alleged acts of terrorism against the Palestinian people.

Both sides, then, before a world audience will finally, in direct confrontation in an open courtroom, be able to present their quintessential arguments for self-preservation – as nations and as peoples. … I cannot pretend to be neutral about Arafat.

For years, I wrote strongly in favor of an independent Palestinian state, and even received recognition from an Arab-American organization for fairness in my reporting. But the horror of suicide bombings – vigorously approved by Arafat in speeches in Arabic to Palestinians – has deeply changed the moral equation of this conflict.

Avraham Burg, former speaker of Israel’s Knesset (its unicameral parliament) and a persistent critic of Ariel Sharon’s policies, said in a recent “Letter to my Palestinian friends” about suicide bombings: “It is a weapon of monsters, not freedom fighters. And until you spit it and its facilitators from your midst, you will have no partner on my side.”

If Arafat does go to trial, I hope with all my heart that suicide bombings everywhere will be, at last, definitively condemned as indeed a monstrous violation of human rights – and will then be glaringly defined as such in international law.

Maria’s note on this slide asks whether a pattern or carousel on Israeli Arabs is possible. This clipping contributes nothing to that: it is a syndicated opinion column about Arafat, with no reference to Arab citizens of Israel at all. Recorded as a negative case.

CP-2003-029 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles, CA · page A9

Bethlehem Under Blockade as Israel Hunts for Gunman

One of two soldiers slain at a checkpoint was on the phone with his mother when killed. Al Aqsa group reportedly claims responsibility.

By LAURA KING / Times Staff Writer

JERUSALEM — Israeli troops blockaded the biblical West Bank town of Bethlehem on Tuesday after a Palestinian gunman carrying an assault rifle that was wrapped in a prayer rug cut down two Israeli soldiers manning a checkpoint on its outskirts.

The shooting, on the edge of the Palestinian village of El Khader, rekindled debate in Israeli military circles about the dangers faced by Israeli troops who patrol remote West Bank villages or stand guard at ambush-prone roadblocks.

Israeli authorities said the slain soldiers were a 23-year-old sergeant major and a 20-year-old staff sergeant. [...] "Before, we allowed traffic inside the city and outside it, we allowed merchants to leave the city and tourists to enter it, we allowed civilians to leave," said Col. Gadi Eisenkot, the army's West Bank commander.

"But in view of this incident ... the life of the residents will become harder than it was before this morning," he said.

Folio line reads "THE WORLD | LOS ANGELES TIMES | WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 19, 2003 A9" — masthead agrees with Maria's label, and Nov 19 1903 would not be a Wednesday, so the year is sound. The page also carries a Macy's advertisement across the lower right, excluded here. Named individuals in the story (the two soldiers) are serving military, not ordinary civilians, and are unnamed in the text.

CP-2003-028 →

· The Daily Progress · Charlottesville

Palestinian athlete is forced to be resourceful

Teenager trains in a frigid, makeshift pool for Olympics

Associated Press

JERUSALEM — Teeth chattering and lips blue from the cold, 17-year-old Palestinian Raad Aweisat took a deep breath and dived back into the chilly three-lane swimming pool for a few more laps.

Huge nylon sheets surround the pool on all sides, creating a makeshift natatorium and keeping in the minimal heat, but the room has no ventilation, and the smell of chlorine soaked the hall. “It’s not perfect, but it’s made an Olympian of my son,” said Aweisat’s mother, Amaal. Aweisat is training for the Aug.

13-29 Athens Olympics, where he plans to compete in the 100-meter butterfly. He will be the first Palestinian swimmer to represent his people at the Olympics. Palestinians gained International Olympic Committee recognition in 1993 after the Israeli-Palestinian peace accords. A Palestinian team competed at their first Olympics in Atlanta in 1996.

The thought of representing Palestine in the Olympics is enough motivation for Aweisat to dive into cold water in the middle of winter. Winning a medal, however, is another matter. The qualifying speed for the Olympic 100-meter butterfly event is 58 seconds.

Aweisat, with limited financial resources, a primitive swimming pool and only three hours of training a day, finished the 100 in 58.95 seconds during the Palestinian national swimming competition. Nevertheless, Aweisat will be at the Olympics, said Ibrahim Tawil, head of the Palestinian Swimming Federation.

The world record for the 100-meter butterfly is 50.98 seconds, held by Ian Crocker. Palestine, not yet a state, its people locked in a bloody conflict with the Israelis, has sent only a few athletes to the Olympics. Aweisat’s father introduced him to swimming at age 4. Two years later, Aweisat was not just a swimmer but training to become a competitor.

By age 10, he was winning all the local Palestinian competitions, collecting dozens of medals and trophies that adorn the family’s living room. At 14, Aweisat was traveling throughout the Middle East, and then to Europe and Asia, to compete in international competitions.

He trains in a village on the outskirts of Jerusalem in a pool that was built in less than a week in a joint effort of residents, family, and friends, Tawil said. They asked that the location of the pool be kept a secret, because it has no building permit from the Israelis, who control this area.

With a corrugated tin roof and no temperature control, the swimming conditions are hardly optimal, Tawil said. “In the summer, it gets way too hot, and in the winter, it’s freezing in here,” said Tawil, wearing a wool hat and a thick winter coat while Aweisat did laps in chilly water. Aweisat used to practice at the YMCA on the Jewish side of Jerusalem.

But after violence broke out more than three years ago, the YMCA told Aweisat to either join the Israeli Swimming Federation, or find somewhere else to swim, according to his father. So the Aweisats and the Palestinian Swimming Federation extended a 17-meter village pool, located in the back yard of several connected homes, to a 25-meter pool, more proper for Olympic training.

Raad Aweisat, 17, training to be the first Palestinian swimmer at an Olympics, in a 25-meter pool in the back yard of several connected houses outside Jerusalem. It was built in under a week by residents, family and friends, and they asked the reporter not to say where it is, because it has no building permit from the Israelis who control the area. Corrugated tin roof, no ventilation, no temperature control. His coach gives laps in a wool hat and a winter coat. He used to swim at the YMCA on the Jewish side of Jerusalem. After the violence began, the YMCA told him to join the Israeli Swimming Federation or swim somewhere else. The pool with no permit is what somewhere else turned out to mean. His mother Amaal supplies the line the headline is a euphemism for: It’s not perfect, but it’s made an Olympian of my son.

CP-2004-010 →

· The Times

Swimmer braves weather for dream

Aweisat to be first Palestinian swimmer to compete in Olympics

By Lara Sukhtian, Associated Press

JERUSALEM – Teeth chattering and lips blue from the cold, 17-year-old Palestinian Raad Aweisat took a deep breath and dived back into the chilly three-lane swimming pool for a few more laps.

Huge nylon sheets surround the pool on all sides, creating a makeshift natatorium and keeping in the minimal heat, but the room has no ventilation, and the smell of chlorine soaked the hall. “It’s not perfect, but it’s made an Olympian of my son,” said Aweisat’s mother, Amaal. Aweisat is training for the Aug.

13-29 Athens Olympics, where he plans to compete in the 100-meter butterfly. He will be the first Palestinian swimmer to represent his people at the Olympics. Palestinians gained International Olympic Committee recognition in 1993 after the Israeli-Palestinian peace accords. A Palestinian team competed at the Olympics in Atlanta in 1996 for the first time.

The thought of representing Palestine in the Olympics is enough motivation for Aweisat to dive into cold water in the middle of winter. Winning a medal, however, is another matter. “I have no illusions,” said Aweisat. “But I have hope. And besides, this is only one step along the ladder to success.”

The qualifying speed for the Olympic 100-meter butterfly event is 58 seconds. Aweisat, with limited financial resources, a primitive swimming pool and only three hours of training a day, finished the 100 in 58.95 seconds during the Palestinian national swimming competition in August.

Nevertheless, Aweisat will be at the Olympics, said Ibrahim Tawil, head of the Palestinian Swimming Federation. The world record for the 100-meter butterfly is 50.98 seconds, held by Ian Crocker of Portland, Maine. Palestine, not yet a state, its people locked in a bloody conflict with the Israelis, has sent only a few athletes to the Olympics.

One of four American printings of Lara Sukhtian’s Associated Press dispatch on Raad Aweisat held here, all from 10 January 2004, under four different headlines. This one puts the weather in the headline and leaves the permit, the secrecy and the YMCA out of it.

CP-2004-012 →

· News Herald · Morganton

Against all odds

Palestinian swimmer trains in frigid, makeshift pool for Olympics

By Lara Sukhtian, Associated Press

Palestinian swimmer Raad Aweisat trains in a swimming pool in east Jerusalem on Thursday. Massive nylon sheets surround the pool from all sides keeping in the heat, but the room has no ventilation and the smell of chlorine soaks the steam-filled pool hall. (Associated Press)

One of four American printings of Lara Sukhtian’s Associated Press dispatch on Raad Aweisat held here, all from 10 January 2004, under four different headlines. Filed under a standing sports label reading Olympics: Frigid training. The headline is the one cliche the story itself never uses.

CP-2004-013 →

· Los Angeles Times

Two-State Solution Sells Palestinians Short

By GEORGE BISHARAT

SAN FRANCISCO — It is a tragic irony that, more than 55 years ago, one desperate people seeking sanctuary from murderous racism decimated another — and continue to oppress its scattered survivors to this day. In 1948, about 700,000 Palestinians were expelled from their homeland, their land and possessions taken by the new Jewish state of Israel.

This included the Jerusalem home of my grandparents, Hanna and Mathilde Bisharat, which was expropriated through a process tantamount to state-sanctioned theft. Today, many assume that to achieve Middle East peace, we Palestinians must surrender our right to return to our homes and homeland.

Millions of Palestinians — with memories and photographs of our stolen properties, keys to our front doors, and an abiding sense of injustice — are expected to swallow our losses in order to facilitate a “two-state solution.” But it's not that simple.

Although Israel has claimed that Palestinians willingly abandoned Palestine after being urged to leave in radio broadcasts by Arab leaders, a review of broadcast transcripts by Irish diplomat Erskine Childers in 1961 revealed that Palestinians were exhorted by Arab leaders to stay, not leave their homes.

In fact, Yigal Allon, commander of Palmach, the elite Zionist troops, and later Israeli foreign minister, launched a whispering campaign to terrorize Palestinians into flight. Nor were we simply unintended victims of a war launched by the Arab states against Israel.

As far back as the late 19th century, leaders of Political Zionism (the movement to create a Jewish state in Palestine) advocated “transfer” of the Palestinians, by force if necessary.

IN JERUSALEM: The author's grandparents pose with other family members in front of their house in Jerusalem about 1929. (Photographs by GEORGE BISHARAT For The Times) | FAMILY PORTRAIT: The Bisharats gather together for a proud moment in 1941.

CP-2004-044 →

· Oakland Tribune · page 10

In 1948, Israel did what it had to do to survive

Benny MORRIS

ON July 12, 1948, Israeli soldiers battling the Arab Legion and local irregulars in the towns of Lydda and Ramle, just south of Tel Aviv, were ordered to empty the two towns of Arab residents. Over two days, between 50,000 and 60,000 inhabitants were driven from their homes. Many were forced to walk eastward to the Arab Legion lines; others were carried in trucks or buses.

Clogging the roads, tens of thousands of refugees marched, shedding their possessions along the way. The expulsions, conducted under orders from then-Lt. Col. Yitzhak Rabin, were an element of the partial ethnic cleansing that rid Israel of the majority of its Arab inhabitants at the very moment of its birth.

Earlier, in the 1930s and 1940s, a near consensus had emerged among Zionist leaders on the necessity of “transfer.”

They believed that it was critical to buy out or drive out the Arab inhabitants from the areas destined for Jewish statehood, both to make way for Jewish immigrants and to remove the Arabs who opposed, often violently, the establishment of such a state.

The idea of transfer never crystallized into a formal Zionist policy — there was no master plan and, of course, not all Palestinians who became refugees in 1948 were expelled like the Arabs of Lydda and Ramle. Indeed, most fled because they feared the ravages of war or because they were advised to do so by their leaders.

But one way or another, transfer was accomplished; 700,000 Palestinians left the country, and the refugee problem that has haunted Israel ever since was born.

CP-2004-045 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago

The wall is about hate, not security

Marda Dunsky

“A precedent in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict will be set in the Netherlands on Monday.

The International Court of Justice will convene in The Hague, and its 15 judges will open the case captioned ‘Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory’… At issue is the barrier — a combination of walls, fences, barbed wire and trenches expected to stretch for more than 400 miles — that Israel is building in the West Bank, with about one-fourth of the route completed… The UN has documented that the barrier, if completed as originally planned, would disrupt the lives of 600,000 of the 2.3 million Palestinians living in the West Bank…

It has converted Palestinian towns and villages into prisons. Since September 2000, approximately 2,600 Palestinians have been killed, according to an Associated Press tally, with an estimated three-quarters of them civilians. The Israeli military reports just over 900 Israelis killed, with 70 percent of them civilians; just under half died in suicide bombings.”

Written for the Sunday the International Court of Justice opened hearings at The Hague, and the only account of that case in this archive. It carries the counts both ways, sourced: an Associated Press tally of about 2,600 Palestinians killed since September 2000, three-quarters of them civilians, against just over 900 Israelis, 70 per cent civilians. The record previously held 443 characters of a page carrying nearly six thousand; the essay was transcribed on 5 October 2026, and the second essay on the same page is now its own record.

CP-2004-007 →

· Casper Star-Tribune · Casper · page A6

For Israelis a lifesaver; for Palestinians a curse

Dividing barriers protect one society and damage the other

By Ravi Nessman, Associated Press writer

ALONG THE ISRAEL-WEST BANK FRONTIER — For the Israelis of Kfar Saba, the high concrete wall dividing them from the West Bank is a salvation: It has halted the suicide bombings that cloaked their town in fear. For the Palestinians of Qalqiliya, less than a mile away, it is a noose suffocating their once vibrant town.

Meir Toledano, a 52-year-old from Kfar Saba, nods approvingly at the barrier: “I live in peace now.” Mohammed Hanini, 40, glares at it from the other side: “If I could pull it out with my teeth, I would.”

Starting Monday, the International Court of Justice in the Netherlands will hear arguments on the legality of the barrier and decide whether to wade into the dispute. The U.N. General Assembly decided in December to ask the court for an advisory opinion after Israel ignored a resolution demanding the barrier be taken down.

Israel has challenged the judges’ authority in the case, saying it is a political matter, and will not attend the hearings. It says that the barrier has greatly slowed suicide bombings and that the planned 450-mile route will be completed.

The United States and the European Union, while critical of the barrier’s route, said the court’s intervention would be inappropriate and could undermine peace efforts. The Palestinians call it “the wall,” the Israelis call it the “anti-terrorism fence.”

Most of it is a sandwich of fences, ditches, razor wire and high-tech sensors, but in Qalqiliya it is a two-story-high wall to stop snipers from terrorizing traffic on a highway on the Israeli side. An Israeli girl was killed in a shooting in June 2003 and a month later Palestinians fired at a car but no one was hurt.

It doesn’t just cut off Qalqiliya from Israel; it encircles it to protect a nearby Jewish farming community inside Israel and a road used by West Bank settlers, the army said. The Palestinians say Israel is building illegally on occupied land and using the barrier to grab areas they claim for a state.

The 125 miles already built run mostly close to the “Green Line,” the pre-1967 Mideast war boundary, but in parts dips as much as 4 miles into the West Bank. Unbuilt sections could jut 14 miles, or more than one-third of the way across the West Bank.

It’s “a human catastrophe,” Palestinian Cabinet minister Saeb Erekat says — a juggernaut that keeps farmers from their fields, patients from their doctors and children from their schools.

Israel has lately acknowledged planning errors that unnecessarily disrupted Palestinian life and says it may move parts of the barrier closer to the Green Line to minimize hardship for Palestinians. These second thoughts may be a sign of Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s continued ambivalence. The barrier wasn’t his idea but his moderate predecessors’.

Sharon initially opposed it because it would mean abandoning Jewish settlements on the West Bank side and would be seen as acknowledgment that Israel plans to give up the whole West Bank one day. However, as suicide bombers kept attacking and a frightened public cried out for a solution, Sharon relented. Construction began in August 2002.

Costing roughly $3 million a mile, it is one of the largest public works projects ever undertaken by the Israeli government. Its ripples spread far beyond. The appeal to the General Assembly and world court was supported by neighboring Jordan, which feared it would have to deal with a new wave of Palestinian refugees squeezed out by the fence.

Israel insists it is not drawing a political border, and says the barrier can be taken down or moved if a peace deal is reached. Kfar Saba, a town of 85,000 about 10 miles northeast of Tel Aviv, was once intertwined with Qalqiliya, population 43,000, in a relationship that transcended the conflict.

Palestinians from Qalqiliya went to Kfar Saba for work and to buy little luxuries. Israelis from Kfar Saba went to Qalqiliya to dine, buy produce and get their cars fixed. Many in both towns talk of their friends across the divide. “We lived together without any problem,” said Bilal Mansour, 41, who owns a car repair shop in Qalqiliya.

But that relationship soured when violence erupted in 2000. Five suicide bombers set out from Qalqiliya and killed 28 Israelis. Kfar Saba was the target of four bombings. It became lifeless. Many stopped riding buses, shopping at the mall and eating in restaurants.

Since the northern section of the barrier was completed in July, there have been no bombings and Kfar Saba has come back to life. The streets are filled with children on bicycles and parents pushing baby strollers. “You can see the difference in the faces of the people. There’s more joy,” said Dedi Rahv, 52, an electrician.

A sharp drop in Israeli deaths since the start of construction has been attributed largely to the barrier, though analysts also cite other factors, including sporadic truce talks, the weakening of militant groups and better intelligence. Though would-be bombers can still get into Israel through unbarricaded areas, the longer journey gives more time to catch them, said Col.

Dany Tirza, the army’s operations chief for the barrier. In recent months, the army says, troops have cornered several militants with explosive vests trying to find their way around the barrier. Palestinians see nothing but oppression in the construction, and have focused all their efforts on derailing it.

“It has become a symbol of occupation and apartheid, and for the sake of both people and for the future it must be removed,” said Mustafa Barghouti, a Palestinian human rights activist. Human rights groups say 7,000 acres of Palestinian land have been expropriated for the barrier, and about 100,000 trees uprooted.

Unless the route is changed, the barrier will affect nearly one-third of West Bank Palestinians, according to the United Nations: 274,000 Palestinians trapped in tiny enclaves and 400,000 more blocked from their fields, jobs, schools and hospitals.

The barrier has about 40 gates to ease disruptions, but opening times are irregular and permits to cross are hard to get, Barghouti and international human rights workers say. Communities along other parts of the barrier are also suffering, particularly Arab suburbs of Jerusalem that have been cut off from the city. Qalqiliya now feels like a ghost town.

More than 40 percent of stores and other businesses have closed, streets have emptied, unemployment has soared to 65 percent, and more than 80 percent of families are receiving international food aid, local officials say. Farmers have trouble getting to their fields beyond the barrier, let alone delivering produce to West Bank markets.

They can no longer sell to Israelis at all. Bilal Mansour used to bring in about 2,500 shekels ($550) a day fixing Israeli-owned cars with his brother. Now he takes a midday snooze on the grassy median of a four-lane road that once carried a constant flow of traffic between the town and Israel. It now dead-ends at the wall.

Mansour’s nearby garage, with bays for 10 cars, sits empty. The car wash brushes are so dry and sunbaked after two years of idleness that they crumble to dust in his hand. He makes between $11 and $55 a day on the few days when there is work. His family of six has stopped eating meat regularly, and he shaves only once a week to save on razors.

“If I could, I would sell and get out of here,” he said. Mansour blames Sharon and Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat for failing to reach an agreement, and the suicide bombers “who have ruined everything.” The military admits its haste in erecting the barrier led to some poor decisions that hit Qalqiliya especially hard.

While the wall will stay, the checkpoint controlling traffic into and out of Qalqiliya has been unmanned for weeks and will soon be dismantled completely, Tirza said. A tunnel is being built to help people move in and out of town, he said. Sections elsewhere will be moved to reduce by about two-thirds the 11,000 people trapped between it and the boundary with Israel.

“An aerial view of an 8-meter-tall cement wall (more than 8 yards tall), part of the barrier Israel is building to separate the outskirts of Jerusalem, left, from the West Bank, is seen in the Palestinian village of Abu Dis last week.” Lefteris Pitarakis/AP.

Set beside the headline, in its own panel: “The Palestinians call it ‘the wall,’ the Israelis call it the ‘anti-terrorism fence.’”

Wyoming’s first appearance in this archive, and the page does the thing this archive mostly records papers not doing: it puts the two names for the same object in a panel of its own, side by side, and attributes each. The headline gives both readings in one line. Four people are named and quoted, two Israeli and two Palestinian, and the Palestinian mechanic gets the longest passage — his empty garage, the car wash brushes that crumble in his hand, shaving once a week to save on razors.

CP-2004-008 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago

A tangible sign of conquest

Gary Fields

“In a 1923 polemic, Ze’ev Jabotinsky, pioneer of revisionist Zionism, insisted upon the use of force to break Arab resistance to Jewish settlement of Palestine, an imperative he cast in metaphorical terms as ‘The Iron Wall.’

Rising upon the Palestinian landscape in a cloak of concrete and concertina wire, the wall erected by Jabotinsky’s modern-day political progeny in Israel admits to a conflict over territory and rights of citizenship, communicating a stark asymmetry of power… a collective psychology of conquest articulated most succinctly by one of its leading proponents, Moshe Yaalon, the Israeli army chief of staff.”

The second of two essays printed side by side in the Chicago Tribune on the Sunday before The Hague hearings, and the one that goes back furthest: it traces the barrier to Jabotinsky’s 1923 essay and names the metaphor he used, the Iron Wall. It shares a page with Marda Dunsky’s essay on the court case, and was found there on 5 October 2026 when the whole page was read rather than the one article that had been clipped from it.

CP-2004-042 →

· Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Who created the Palestinian refugees?

The latest salvo from Israeli historian Benny Morris, says Ethan Bronner, puts more blame on both sides

Ethan Bronner

Of all the issues separating Israelis and Palestinians, nothing is more contentious than the Palestinian “right of return.” Palestinian refugees say they must be permitted to go back to the lands they lost during the 1947-48 war inside what is today Israel.

Even pragmatic Arabs who do not expect that Israel will ever permit large numbers of refugees to return believe that many Palestinians were pushed out of their homes through intimidation and force in a planned expulsion, and they believe that the right of return must be acknowledged, if not actually put into practice.

Israelis counter that the real aim of the right of return is to suffocate their state by flooding it with hostile Arabs — a sort of Trojan horse. Moreover, they argue, there is no historic sin that requires expiation because there was no Zionist plan to expel the Palestinians.

They say that Zionist leaders urged the Palestinians to stay put, but that Arab leaders instructed them to leave so Arab armies would have a clear field. In the Middle East, history is never a purely academic exercise.

Evidence that Israelis drove out villagers at the point of a gun or that Palestinian leaders urged villagers to abandon their homes becomes not simply an interesting fact from the past but also a weapon in an ongoing struggle. One reminder of that is the current controversy over the Israeli historian Benny Morris.

There are few more prominent figures in the debate over the origin of the refugees than Morris, who in 1988 published “The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem,” a book that helped force Israelis to accept the idea that Palestinian expulsions did indeed occur. Now Morris is back with a new book that is a heavily revised and updated version of the 1988 account.

CP-2004-046 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore, MD · page 6A

Survivors try to make sense of attack

Bombing of Jerusalem bus stuns witnesses, wounded

By PETER HERMANN / SUN FOREIGN STAFF

JERUSALEM — Five months ago, Alice Eizenkot had just dropped off her two teen-age daughters at dance class on Emek Rafaim Street when a Palestinian suicide bomber blew up a cafe about 100 yards from where she was standing. Eight people died.

Yesterday, Eizenkot had left her daughters at their school and was in her car, at the other end of the same street, when a bus behind her blew up at a stoplight. She stopped her car in the middle of the road but didn't look back. "I knew it was an explosion, and I knew it was the bus," she said, trembling in a bed at Hadassah Hospital on Mount Scopus an hour after the attack.

"I didn't want to see anything. My children called, and they didn't believe that I had survived." [...] Abed Issa, a 42-year-old laborer from East Jerusalem, was on his way to a bank to cash a check so he could buy food for his wife and five children. He was pushing his way toward the center of the bus when the bomb exploded.

"There was so much blood we had to wipe it from our eyes," Issa said at the hospital as he dabbed a gash above his left eye with a piece of gauze. Issa, who works as a gardener and cleans floors at a medical clinic on Emek Rafaim, shrugged off the politics behind the blast. "What does it matter, Arab or Jew?" he said. "You just don't do things like this.

We are all from the same place, from the same God. My only war is providing bread for my children."

Folio reads "Page 6A : Monday, Feb. 23, 2004 : The Sun" — the date agrees with Maria's label. Photo caption: "Volunteers retrieve a body from the scene of a Palestinian suicide bombing on a packed bus in west Jerusalem. The bomber killed eight people, and at least 60 others were injured." Credit: AVI OHAYON : AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE. The paper's spelling "teen-age" and "Yedioth Ahronoth" are left as printed. This clipping is worth keeping on its own merits rather than as an Eisenkot record: it gives a wounded Palestinian labourer from East Jerusalem a named, quoted presence in a US daily's account of an Israeli bus bombing, and puts his words in display type.

CP-2004-050 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco

Sharon nears point of no return in dealings with Palestinians

JERUSALEM — In words and deeds, Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon is letting it be known that he has all but given up on a dialogue with the Palestinians, and that the time has come for Israel to impose its own solution to the Middle East conflict.

Nearly six months after Prime Minister Ahmed Qureia took office, Sharon’s aides say the Palestinians are still stalling on setting a date for the two men to meet — and last week Sharon let his frustration boil over as never before.

He lashed out at Qureia’s laconic response to last Sunday’s suicide bombing in Jerusalem that killed eight people, including two teenage schoolboys, and injured 50 more.

The attack occurred as the World Court in The Hague, Netherlands, was about to deliberate on a Palestinian-led petition claiming that Israel’s security barrier in the West Bank is a breach of international law. In remarks to the Yediot Ahronoth newspaper, Sharon blasted Qureia’s administration as “a government of murder and lies.

With this government it will not be possible to reach any agreement.” Sharon condemned the proceedings in The Hague as a “campaign of hypocrisy,” an “international circus” and “an attempt to deny Israel the basic right to self-defense,” adding, “We won’t capitulate.”

He also said that Qureia’s expression of regret over the suicide attack only pertained to the timing of the act, since it “could harm them in The Hague.” The Palestinian prime minister responded with angry words of his own, calling Sharon’s remarks “totally unacceptable.” “We do not have murderers,” said Qureia.

“We have a cause.”

CP-2004-019 →

· Kingsport Times-News

Israeli airstrike kills three Palestinians in Gaza Strip

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — An Israeli helicopter fired missiles at a car in the Gaza Strip on Saturday, killing three people — including an Islamic Jihad militant — and wounding 15 others, doctors said. One of the dead was identified by his family as Islamic Jihad militant Ayman Dahdouh. The body of another victim could not immediately be identified.

The two missiles targeted a small gray Subaru traveling on a road linking Gaza City with the Jebaliya refugee camp. A thunderous explosion was heard along with the chops of helicopter blades. Ambulances raced to the scene as a warplane flew overhead, firing flares.

The car was pulverized, and Palestinian security officials strained to keep order around the scene as surging crowds jumped on the wreckage and called for revenge. The airstrike was carried out in a densely populated residential area, and three children were among the wounded, said doctors at Gaza’s Shifa Hospital.

One girl was in critical condition and another boy was seen bleeding from his head. One of the wounded told The Associated Press from the hospital that a helicopter fired at least two missiles at the vehicle. Hundreds of people gathered at the hospital to check on the conditions and identities of the casualties. Some gunmen at the morgue were crying.

An Israeli military spokesman said he was checking the report of the airstrike. Israel has frequently sent helicopter gunships and warplanes to kill Palestinian militants in targeted missile strikes during more than three years of fighting. The last such strike was Feb.

7, when an attack helicopter fired a missile that shattered a car, killing an Islamic Jihad leader in the vehicle and a 12-year-old boy on his way to school.

CP-2004-020 →

· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota · page 14A

Palestinian runner trains for Olympics

The Associated Press

Palestinian runner Sanaa Abu Bkheet runs at her makeshift training ground in Deir El Balah, central Gaza Strip, on Wednesday. Abu Bkheet has qualified for the 800-meters at the Athens Olympics against great odds: She owns only one pair of running shoes, no access to a track and used to get pelted with rocks during her training runs. (Associated Press / Kevin Frayer)

An earlier printing of the same dispatch, three weeks before the Indiana Gazette’s, and it gives her the top of the page in her own words rather than a headline about odds: ‘It’s not easy to be a runner in Gaza, especially for a female. It’s strange because of our traditions. It’s hard to see a girl running in the streets.’ set in large type above the photograph, with her name under it.

CP-2004-015 →

· The Star Press · Muncie

14 Palestinians killed in raid

Israeli officials said they wanted to put militants on defensive.

BUREIJ REFUGEE CAMP, Gaza Strip — Israeli troops carried out their deadliest raid in Gaza in 17 months on Sunday, part of a surge of bloodshed ahead of a possible Israeli withdrawal from the coastal strip. Fourteen Palestinians were killed and 81 wounded in more than six hours of fighting on the edge of the Bureij refugee camp.

The battle pitted Palestinians armed with assault rifles, antitank missiles and grenade launchers against Israeli troops firing from helicopters, tanks and rooftop sniper positions. Children chased tanks, throwing stones. Among the dead were three boys, ages 8, 12 and 15.

The Israeli military said the purpose of the raid was to put Palestinian militants on the defensive and prevent them from carrying out attacks on Israelis. However, residents of Bureij said soldiers did not try to make arrests or search for arms caches.

The Palestinian Authority denounced the raid as “state terrorism,” and urged the international community to intervene. Palestinians said Israeli soldiers were trying to draw out militants in what appeared to be a new tactic.

Armed groups routinely exhort their members over mosque loudspeakers to confront approaching Israeli troops, despite vastly inferior weapons and considerable risk. Sunday was no exception. After the battle, a militant leader took the highly unusual step of appealing to his forces not to fall into the trap again.

“The Palestinian people are now uniting in the trenches of resistance,” said Islamic Jihad leader Mohammed al-Hindi, “but we also call on the sons of the resistance not to be dragged into battles forced upon us by the [Israeli] occupation.”

Sunday’s fighting was part of a recent rise in violence that has been attributed to Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s proposal to withdraw from most, if not all, of Gaza and parts of the West Bank if there is no progress toward peace in coming months.

Each side seems to be positioning itself to claim a withdrawal as a victory — Israel by pounding the militants hard before a pullout, and the armed groups by stepping up attacks to create the impression they are chasing the Israelis out.

A PALESTINIAN WOMAN stands in front of an Israeli army bulldozer, working on a section of the separation barrier Israel is building to separate the West Bank from Israel near the village of Beit Dukou, northwest of Jerusalem on Sunday.

Dozens of demonstrators clashed with troops as they tried to stop work on the barrier that Israel says is needed to prevent suicide bombers from entering Israel. Palestinians and human rights organizations say it is a land grab that in some areas dips as much as four miles into the West Bank.

CP-2004-037 →

· Midland Daily News

14 Palestinians die as Israelis raid camp

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip (AP) — Hamas threatened revenge today after 14 Palestinians were killed in the deadliest Israeli raid in Gaza in 17 months — part of an upsurge in bloodshed linked to a proposed Israeli withdrawal from the coastal strip. Killed were 11 militants and three boys between the ages of 8 and 15. Eighty-one people were wounded.

The fighting near the Bureij refugee camp Sunday pitted hundreds of Palestinians with assault rifles, anti-tank missiles and grenade launchers against Israeli snipers and troops firing from helicopters and tanks. In new fighting today, a 16-year-old Palestinian was killed by army fire.

The spike of violence in Gaza — two recent Israeli air strikes and a complex attack on an Israeli army post by militants — has come weeks after Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon said he would withdraw from most of the strip if peace efforts remain stuck.

Each side now seems to be positioning itself to claim a withdrawal as a victory — Israel by pounding the militants hard before a pullout, and the armed groups by stepping up attacks to create the impression they are chasing the Israelis out.

CP-2004-053 →

· The Times-Mail · page A6

Mideast leaders plan to meet next week

JERUSALEM — The Israeli and Palestinian prime ministers have tentatively agreed to hold a summit next week, their first meeting since the Palestinian leader took office in October, Israeli and Palestinian officials said today. The delayed summit is tentatively scheduled for Tuesday, a Palestinian official said on condition of anonymity.

But Hassan Abu Libdeh, an adviser to Palestinian Prime Minister Ahmed Qureia, said the date is not definite and will depend on the outcome of a preparatory meeting Sunday between the leaders’ aides. “We are discussing various issues and if we agree on these issues then there will be no obstacles to a meeting,” Abu Libdeh said.

Raanan Gissin, a Sharon adviser, said “there are discussions about possibly holding a meeting on this date, but it cannot be confirmed.” Israeli media reported the main topic at the summit would be Sharon’s plan to unilaterally withdraw from the Gaza Strip, a proposal that could include the removal of most Jewish settlements in the coastal area.

CP-2004-054 →

· The Day · New London · page 1

Middle East blood politics

“Israel’s assassination of Sheik Ahmed Yassin was a spectacular setback to the peace process in the Middle East… The Jerusalem Post referred to Sheik Yassin as Israel’s Osama bin Laden in its justification of the move… While much of the world probably would exult in the death of Mr. bin Laden, the military assassination of an elderly and disabled cleric held in wide esteem has had the opposite effect.

What fragile chance there was of reaching a peace settlement was badly shattered.… President George W. Bush needs to use all his clout to quiet the furor, bring the two sides back to the negotiating table and assure that Israel doesn’t have any further surprises in store. The trouble with this is that President Bush, like Mr.

Sharon, is an unabashed unilateralist… But acts like the murder of Sheik Yassin only provide legitimacy to the organization and further the violence. That is not the road to peace.”

An editorial page reaches for his disability as a measure of how badly the killing will play. Yassin’s quadriplegia is not the subject of the sentence; it is the reason the paper expects the assassination to backfire. The standfirst above the column calls him an elderly, disabled Palestinian leader before it calls him anything else.

CP-2004-004 →

· USA Today

Hamas pledges to keep fighting, as does Israel

By Arieh O'Sullivan, Special for USA TODAY

TEL AVIV, Israel — The Hamas terrorist group chose a hard-liner Tuesday to replace its assassinated spiritual leader, and Israeli security officials said they had reached a turning point in their war against Palestinian guerrillas.

The assassination early Monday of Sheik Ahmed Yassin was the most dramatic move to date by Israel, which has embarked on a campaign to crush the leadership of groups such as Hamas in Gaza ahead of a unilateral Israeli withdrawal from the territory.

President Bush, in his first remarks on Monday's killing of Yassin, a quadriplegic cleric whose group has carried out dozens of suicide bombings, defended what he called Israel's right to defend itself against terror. "And as she does so, I hope she keeps consequences in mind as to how to make sure we stay on the path to peace," he said.

Palestinians reacted to Yassin's death with vows to unleash an unprecedented wave of terror. "We will fight them everywhere. We will hit them everywhere. We will chase them everywhere," said Abdel Aziz Rantisi, 54, a pediatrician who was elected Hamas' new leader in a secret election in Gaza on Tuesday.

Rantisi has urged accelerated attacks on Israel and said there is no room for compromise. Hamas suggested Monday that it might attack U.S. targets. [...] "Motivation is high, but it all comes down to capability," said Brig. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot, commander of Israeli forces in the West Bank.

Speaking at a conference in Tel Aviv on combating terror, Eisenkot said his forces arrest an average of 30 suspected terrorists every night. He also said a security barrier being built to separate Israel and the West Bank is preventing terrorist infiltrations into Israel.

According to Israeli army statistics, security forces thwarted 400 suicide bombings last year; 18 were successful. The number of Israeli casualties was 40% lower than in 2002, Eisenkot said.

Section flag above the headline reads "World" — not a dek. Photo caption: "Thousands protest: Israeli Arabs in Nazareth denounce the assassination of Hamas founder Sheik Ahmed Yassin, who used a wheelchair." (credit: By Uriel Sinai, Getty Images). A boxed sidebar photo at right carries the pull quote "We will fight them": Abdel Aziz Rantisi makes his way through a crowd in Gaza after being elected leader of Hamas. (credit: By Kevin Frayer, AP). Story ends "Contributing: Wire reports". Eisenkot is a brigadier general here, West Bank commander.

CP-2004-047 →

· Indiana Gazette · Indiana

Against all odds

Female Palestinian runner training for summer Olympics

By Ibrahim Barzak, Associated Press Writer

DEIR EL BALAH, Gaza Strip — Sanaa Abu Bkheet has qualified for the 800-meter run at the Athens Olympics against great odds: she owns only one pair of running shoes, has no access to a track and used to get pelted with rocks during her training in the streets of her hometown. The 19-year-old is one of two Palestinians who will compete at the Aug. 13-29 games in Greece.

The other athlete is 17-year-old Raad Aweisat, a swimmer from Jerusalem who has qualified for the 100-meter butterfly. Abu Bkheet is something of an oddity in the impoverished, conservative Gaza Strip.

The sight of the tall, thin woman running through the streets of this ramshackle town in her green track suit used to cause a minor uproar, and children at times would throw rocks at her as she zipped past. “It’s not easy to be a runner in Gaza, especially for a female,” she said. “It’s strange because of our traditions.

It’s hard to see a girl running in the streets.” But she’s since won the support of her neighbors, joyful that one of their own will carry the Palestinian flag before the world at the Olympics. Now, admiring children crowd around her.

And after she came in first among the women runners in a local track meet on Friday, a Palestine TV news crew rushed for an interview. Palestinians gained International Olympic Committee recognition in 1993 after the signing of Israeli-Palestinian interim peace accords. A Palestinian team competed at their first Olympics in Atlanta in 1996.

Abu Bkheet, a middle distance runner, will be the first female runner to represent Palestinians at the Olympics. Her best time in the 800 is 2:28.11.

She took up running at age 12, and her training amounts to this: Each morning she downs a teaspoon of olive oil — said by generations of Palestinian matriarchs to bring good health — and sets out on 90-minute training runs in a simple pair of generic, no-name running shoes.

Without a proper track, she jogs along dirt roads that nearly disappear among the shifting sand near the Mediterranean coast. Her 17-year-old sister Wesam and three other girls from her extended families come along for company. The runners often dodge Israeli army checkpoints and hear not-so-distant gunfire.

“I know it is a big responsibility to be the first Palestinian woman runner in the Olympics and to represent Palestine,” Sanaa said. “I know it’s going to be very hard to win.” She lives with four sisters and two brothers in a small house with a roof of corrugated metal sheeting.

In the living room hang medals she’s won in competitions in Gaza, Egypt, Jordan and Iran in the past three years. Her idol is Maria Mutola of Mozambique, the reigning Olympic 800 champion. On Friday in Gaza City, Abu Bkheet came in first for the women in a local track meet.

Handing her a medal and trophy, the awards announcer referred to her — hopefully and with pride — as the “Olympic champion.” Her mother kissed her. On the back of the runner’s plain red T-shirt was the word: “Palestine.”

Palestinian runner Sanaa Abu Bkheet, right, talked with her mother Amna in her house in Deir El Balah, central Gaza Strip, on March 5 prior to leaving for a local competition. · Bkheet, left, and another participant in a local race, wait in front of the Dome of the Rock in Gaza City. (AP photos)

The fullest account in this archive of a Palestinian woman’s life, and it is a sports story. Sanaa Abu Bkheet, 19, of Deir el Balah: one pair of generic running shoes, no track, a best 800 of 2:28.11. Her training is a teaspoon of olive oil each morning — said by generations of Palestinian matriarchs to bring good health — and ninety minutes on dirt roads that disappear into the sand by the sea. Her sister Wesam, 17, and three other girls run with her for company, and they dodge Israeli army checkpoints and hear not-so-distant gunfire. She is candid about the other obstacle, which is not the army: It’s not easy to be a runner in Gaza, especially for a female. It’s strange because of our traditions. Children used to throw rocks at her. Now they crowd round her. Her mother Amna is named. Her idol is Maria Mutola of Mozambique. The last line is the detail the whole piece rests on: on the back of her plain red T-shirt was the word Palestine.

CP-2004-014 →

· Park City Daily News

Hurting our Arab friends

WHEN KING Abdullah II of Jordan pointedly postponed the visit he was scheduled to have today with President Bush, it dramatized a major drawback in Bush’s siding with Israel last week to dictate key peace terms to the Palestinians.

The Bush deal with Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, endorsing the latter’s unilateral “disengagement” plan, is a severe blow to moderate Arab leaders who are important to U.S. interests in that volatile region.

The president scrapped decades of American policy when he publicly accepted the permanence of large Jewish settlements in occupied Palestinian territory. Bush also joined in Sharon’s rejection of a “right of return” for Palestinian refugees displaced from their former homes in recurrent conflict over the creation of Israel.

The refugees, Bush said, would have to reside within a new Palestinian state. These issues were supposed to be subject to bargaining in future Palestinian-Israeli negotiations, in line with Bush’s “road map” to a two-state solution.

Abdullah is not the only friendly Arab leader dismayed by Bush’s abandonment of his “honest broker” role to court pro-Israel votes in his re-election campaign.

President Hosni Mubarak of Egypt, whose country was the first to sign a peace treaty with Israel, now says there is “unprecedented hatred” of America in the Arab world, because of both the war in Iraq and Bush’s embrace of Sharon’s policy on Palestine. The Bush-Sharon deal is generally deplored by those promoting democratic reform in the Arab nations.

We had thought the president was a champion of such reform, among his announced goals in Iraq. But he undermines the democratic cause with unfairness to the Palestinians.

The clipping carries no date line or masthead. The editorial is about the Bush–Sharon agreement of April 2004 and King Abdullah II postponing the Washington visit he was “scheduled to have today”, which he did on 21 April 2004. It was filed here as July 2023, two decades out. The month is established by the events; the day is not on the page and is not guessed.

CP-2023-087 →

· The Times Leader · Wilkes-Barre · page 1

Refugee camp in Gaza hit

Citing security reasons, Israel tightens its grip on Rafah. Three die in missile attack, say Palestinians.

The headline is four words and a past participle with nothing attached: a camp hit. The summary underneath names Israel, gives its reason first — citing security reasons — and then hands the three dead to the Palestinians to claim: say Palestinians. The tightening is reported; the dying is attributed.

CP-2004-001 →

· Santa Barbara News-Press · Santa Barbara

Gazans lose a rare pleasure: the zoo

Armored forces reportedly razed cages, structures

By Craig Nelson, Cox News Service

RAFAH, Gaza Strip — The families crammed into this narrow sliver of land don’t have much by way of entertainment. There are no movie theaters, thanks to censuring Islamic fundamentalists. Shopping malls are a fantasy. A summer afternoon at the beach must usually suffice.

In all, though, there are precious few diversions for a population of 1.3 million mostly poor and mostly young people. So when Israeli forces destroyed a tiny, dilapidated zoo in Rafah this week, it was a notable loss.

On Friday, as residents tore through piles of rubble and twisted metal fences looking for any creatures still alive, the zoo’s owner, Mohammed Ahmed Joma, asked why. “The last thing I expected is that they would destroy my zoo. This is just a family place, one of the few here in Gaza that people can enjoy,” Mr. Joma said.

Nearby, the remains of an Egyptian goose, a brightly-colored male pheasant, two Guinea hens and a turtle were piled on a mound of dirt. A lamb lay dying under a stairwell, near a raccoon with a six-inch gash across its abdomen. A terrified kangaroo huddled among a turkey, a peacock and at least four horned sheep in the basement of Mr.

Joma’s house, where he put them for safekeeping. And somewhere in this dusty frontier town, there were other animals on the loose, including a python, another kangaroo and two ostriches. Israel initially denied that its forces had demolished the zoo.

Almost nothing in this archive is about what people do on a day off. This is: a family place, one of the few, in a town of 1.3 million with no cinema and one beach. The inventory in the fourth paragraph is the whole piece — a goose, a pheasant, two guinea hens, a turtle, a lamb dying under a stairwell, a raccoon cut open, and a kangaroo hiding in a man’s basement with a turkey and a peacock and four sheep because he carried them there himself.

CP-2004-009 →

· Waco Tribune-Herald · Waco · page 1

U.N. wants Israel to avow nukes

Sharon refuses to alter his nation’s policy for security reasons

Here for the last four words. For security reasons is a phrase this archive follows across sixty years of American papers, attached to demolitions, closures, permits, deportations and curfews. This is the same phrase doing the same work at the level of a nuclear arsenal, printed without comment in a Texas daily.

CP-2004-002 →

· USA Today · Atlanta, GA

Pressured, Arafat shuffles security leaders

Appointment of cousin triggered violence

From wire reports

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat backed down in the face of a major challenge to his authority on Monday as he tried to defuse a crisis over corruption in his government. Responding to widespread public anger in Gaza over his appointment of a cousin as head of security there, Arafat reinstated a security chief whom he had removed from power days earlier.

The reinstated commander, Abdel Razak Majaide, will outrank Moussa Arafat, the cousin whose appointment Saturday fueled a weekend of violence in which militants attacked government offices to demand anti-corruption reforms.

Small headshot of Arafat at right with the caption word "Challenged:" and the line "Yasser Arafat works Monday at his compound in Ramallah, West Bank." Credit: By Abbas Momani, AFP. The story is unbylined wire copy under the slug "From wire reports".

CP-2004-048 →

· USA Today

To Israelis, good fence is good sense

Nation willing to defy international demands to gain sense of security

By Arieh O'Sullivan / Special For USA TODAY

JERUSALEM — Israelis are shrugging off world criticism and domestic court rulings that say the security barrier they are building to separate Israel from Palestinian territory is illegal.

The four-month lull since the last major Palestinian suicide attack has created a sense among Israelis that their tactics — building the barrier along with targeted assassinations and arrests of militants — are working.

Since the first 120 miles of the controversial 430-mile barrier was declared operational last August, three suicide bombers have reached targets in Israel from the northern West Bank, where most attacks had been launched. This year, no suicide bomber has slipped through the electronically monitored barrier. The seven suicide bombings in Israel in 2004 originated elsewhere.

Until Israel built the barrier, an average of about two suicide bombers would slip into Israel from the northern West Bank every month. From September 2000, when the Palestinian uprising began, until August 2003, when construction began on the fence, 293 people were killed in suicide attacks.

Israeli officials say the barrier — a series of fences, walls and barbed wire — has been the key to their security.

This notion is hardening Israel’s rejection of Palestinian and international demands that the barrier be taken down because it creates hardship by cutting into Palestinian territory, at times cutting Palestinians off from their land and families. Palestinians also say it creates a de facto border between Israel and a future Palestinian state.

But the barrier is popular among many Israelis. According to a survey last October by Tel Aviv University’s Tami Steinmetz Center for Peace Research, 82% favored a barrier.

In Bat Hefer, 22 miles northeast of Tel Aviv, town manager Chen Hokima shrugged off this month’s ruling by the International Court of Justice in The Hague, Netherlands, that declared the barrier illegal because it violates international law. “We don’t care what the court says. This barrier was a matter of life or death for us,” Hokima said.

He credits the 17-foot-high concrete wall here with stemming an exodus of fearful Israelis that had threatened to turn this bedroom community of 6,000 people into a ghost town. “Instead of hundreds of terrorist attacks, since the wall has been built we have had zero.”

He pointed past a row of bougainvillea-covered villas to the gray concrete wall at the end of the street: “That is why.” Palestinians call the barrier an “Apartheid Wall” because it separates them from their families and fields and cuts thousands of people off from schools, shops, jobs and hospitals.

They also say that in some places, it annexes some of the region’s most fertile land. In its July 9 decision, the International Court of Justice said Israel should tear down the barrier, compensate Palestinians harmed by the structure and return property confiscated for its construction.

It also urged the United Nations General Assembly and Security Council to consider “what further action is required to bring to an end to the illegal situation.” The U.N. Security Council was expected to consider a Palestinian-sponsored resolution this week urging Israel to abide by the world court’s decision.

Only the Security Council can order the barrier to be torn down or impose sanctions. But the United States, Israel’s closest ally, would likely veto the resolution.

Responding to the world court ruling, Ziyad Nakhaleh, a leader of the militant Palestinian group Islamic Jihad, said the decision came at the right time “to demonstrate the injustice inflicted upon the Palestinian people and the hostility of the Zionist entity.” Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon criticized the decision.

Pointing to a bomb detonated remotely on July 11 in Tel Aviv that killed a female soldier and injured 34, Sharon said the attack was carried out “under the patronage” of the court. Israel’s Supreme Court ruled last month that a 20-mile section of the barrier should be moved because it was causing hardship for Palestinians.

Israeli officials are considering a new route but vow to continue construction. No Israelis have died in a suicide attack in Israel since a border policeman was killed April 17. The barrier isn’t the only reason for the dramatic decline in attacks. Israel’s security forces have sought out potential terrorists. Brig. Gen.

Gadi Eizenkot, commander of Israeli forces in the West Bank, said “close to 60” suicide bombers have been captured during army raids in Palestinian cities. The Israelis also have confiscated dozens of bomb belts, which Eizenkot said proved Palestinians are still motivated to stage attacks.

Each night, Israeli troops and police stage about a dozen arrest sweeps in Palestinian territory. Eizenkot said about 2,000 Palestinian militants have been rounded up this year. Security experts say the arrests, coupled with the policy of targeted assassinations of militants, have crippled Palestinian terrorist groups such as Hamas.

The Israeli security forces have carried out 148 targeted assassinations in the past 45 months of conflict with the Palestinians, according to B’Tselem, an Israeli human rights group.

Shmuel Bar, an expert on Hamas at the Institute for Policy and Strategy in Herzliya, Israel, said the group’s leadership was devastated by the assassination of its spiritual leader, Sheik Ahmed Yassin, in March and its political leader, Abdel Aziz Rantisi, in April. Hamas appointed a new leader but has not revealed his identity.

“Their rotating leadership is expending all their energy hiding. They are afraid of Israel hitting them, which makes any sort of sophisticated planning difficult,” Bar said. But many Israelis believe the barrier deserves the most credit for making them safer.

In Bat Hefer, Israeli dairy farmer Doron Feller, 36, says it has brought him a sense of security and stability. “Now, not even a mouse can get through the wall,” Feller said. Contributing: Wire reports

Photo caption: "Going up: A Palestinian walks through concrete slabs that Israel has stockpiled on the outskirts of Jerusalem for its security barrier." Credit: By David Silverman, Getty Images. The page also carries a map ("West Bank barrier", source: PLO Negotiations Affairs Department, by Adrienne Lewis, USA TODAY) and a bar chart ("Suicide bombings in Israel", source: Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs, by Tiffany Sakato and Karl Gelles, USA TODAY) — both are graphics on the same story, not separate clippings. Also quoted: Ziyad Nakhaleh, a leader of the militant Palestinian group Islamic Jihad, who called the barrier an "Apartheid Wall" and said it separates families and annexes the region's most fertile land; and Shmuel Bar of the Institute for Policy and Strategy in Herzliya.

CP-2004-049 →

· The Columbian · Vancouver

Athens and Adversity

Some athletes travel bumpy road the Games

By Niko Price, Associated Press

“A swimmer who sat idle for months because U.S. soldiers took over the pool where he trained. A judo competitor who practices in a small room because she can’t go out in public without a veil. A runner who jogs on the sand because the streets are too dangerous. The road to Athens is tough for any athlete, but for some it is lined with land mines.

For those representing war-torn countries, training can mean risking bombs and bullets to reach the stadium, and making do without the barest essentials of equipment and coaching. But many say the adversity they face has strengthened their resolve to push themselves. Some even dare to dream of a medal.

‘All people who live a hard life can do good things,’ said Palestinian swimmer Raad Aweisat, 17. ‘People who have everything just go to sleep. You must make yourself by yourself.’ Many athletes have followed that philosophy.

Friba Razayee, 18, describes herself as ‘the only girl in all of Afghanistan who loves boxing,’ but since she didn’t have a coach she tried her hand at judo.

One year later, she is an Olympian… Swimmer Mohammed Abbas, 26, had a different problem with his training regimen: He had to spend a month cowering in his house while bombs rained down on Baghdad; and when the war ended, U.S. troops commandeered the pool where he trains for soldiers’ R&R in the hot Iraqi summer.

Gaza Strip residents horrified by the sight of Sanaa Abu Bkeet running down the street in shorts threw stones at her, and Israeli security measures made it impossible for her to get to a proper track, so she trained barefoot on a sand path.

The 19-year-old came to Athens to run in the 800-meter event, but said she has spent most of her time getting used to running in spikes — and on asphalt. ‘I know of other athletes who trained for four years for the Olympics. I trained only one month,’ she said. ‘It was so difficult to run on the sand. It is very soft and your feet can sink down.

It is difficult to change from sand to the track.’ Nonetheless, the athletes say adversity breeds strength… Aweisat, the Palestinian swimmer, trained in a backyard pool that was unheated and covered with a tin roof to prevent the Israelis from spotting it. ‘If you want to know why I’m doing this, it’s because I love my country,’ he said.

‘I know I won’t medal — I just need to participate well.’ But that doesn’t stop him from dreaming about the future — specifically, the 2008 Olympic Games in Beijing. ‘In China, I’ll take the gold medal,’ he said. ‘I promise you.’”

Palestinian Raad Aweisat practices in a pool covered by a tin roof so it won’t be spotted by Israelis. (Thannassis Stavrakis / The Associated Press)

The only Palestinian sportswoman in this archive appears here. Sanaa Abu Bkeet, 19, ran the 800 meters at Athens on one month’s training, and the story gives both reasons she had no track. Gaza residents horrified by the sight of her running in shorts threw stones at her; Israeli security measures made a proper track unreachable. So she trained barefoot on sand, and then had to learn to run on asphalt in spikes. The photograph caption states outright what the earlier report about Aweisat’s pool only implied: it is covered by a tin roof so it won’t be spotted by Israelis. He supplies the line the page is built around, set in large type beside his photograph: ‘All people who live a hard life can do good things. People who have everything just go to sleep. You must make yourself by yourself.’ And then a promise about Beijing four years later: In China, I’ll take the gold medal. I promise you.

CP-2004-011 →

· Ithaca Journal · Ithaca

Palestinian prisoners launch hunger strike

By MARK LAVIE, The Associated Press

JERUSALEM — Palestinian prisoners launched a hunger strike Sunday, in what was shaping up to be the biggest showdown between thousands of inmates and the Israeli authorities since the outbreak of Mideast fighting in 2000. The prisoners want more family visits and phone access, but an Israeli Cabinet minister said he'd rather let them starve.

Prison officials imposed more sanctions. In violence in Gaza, meanwhile, Israeli helicopters fired four missiles north of Gaza City near the border with Israel early today (Sunday night EDT), witnesses said. Israeli military sources, speaking on condition of anonymity, said soldiers spotted militants setting up a rocket launcher, and the helicopters targeted them, hitting one.

Ambulances arrived at the scene but hesitated to enter because of Israeli gunfire, witnesses said. Meanwhile, the most prominent Palestinian prisoner is working on a smooth transition in the Gaza Strip after Israel's planned withdrawal next year.

Marwan Barghouti, a leader of Yasser Arafat's Fatah movement, has presented an 18-point plan for Gaza to Hamas and Islamic Jihad, and the leaders of the two militant groups responded “positively, in principle,” according to a source close to Barghouti. A copy of the plan was obtained by The Associated Press.

Barghouti proposed that after the Israeli withdrawal, militant groups be given a role in running Gaza, but insisted that they halt attacks on Israel from that territory — though not from the West Bank. Militants would stop parading armed in public, and within three months of the withdrawal would have to sell their weapons to the security forces.

Gunmen could join the security forces, but would have to cut their ties with the militant groups. Since Israel announced its pullout plan earlier this year, concerns have been raised about a power vacuum and a possible takeover by Islamic militants.

Under Barghouti's plan, Arafat's Palestinian Authority would be the sovereign in Gaza, but a “monitoring committee” with representatives from all groups would have considerable say.

A Palestinian youth wears symbolic handcuffs during a protest demanding the release of Palestinian prisoners being held in Israeli jails, in the village of Beit Hanoun, in the northern Gaza Strip.

About 1,600 Palestinian prisoners began a hunger strike Sunday to protest conditions in Israeli jails, but Israel's Public Security Minister has said they can “starve to death” before he agrees to ease their restrictions. / A Palestinian prisoner is seen behind bars as he is brought into the Hadarian prison, north of Tel Aviv, while another Palestinian prisoner flashes a V sign from a cell in the same prison.

Photographs credited The Associated Press.

CP-2004-018 →

· The Herald Sun · Durham

Palestinian singer loses contest

Libyan becomes new ‘Superstar’ on Lebanese TV

By Lara Sukhtian, Associated Press

SALFIT, West Bank — Palestinians hoping for a morale boost after four years of bloody conflict with Israel were disappointed Sunday, when their contestant in a much-watched contest for the Arab world’s best singer lost to a Libyan.

Ammar Hassan, 27, from the town of Salfit in the West Bank, stood stunned and silent when it was announced that Libyan singer Eyman Al-Atar outpolled Hassan by a wide margin. Gracious in defeat, Hassan and the winner took the stage together, holding each other’s national flags in a sign of unity.

Back home, however, some in Salfit called the vote unfair because of its unstructured nature: Under the contest rules, people could cast multiple ballots by cellular phone text messages and over the Internet.

Bitterly disappointed, Mahmoud Yassin, 20, lashed out at fellow Arabs who did not vote for the Palestinian singer… At a community center, a happy furor erupted when Ahmed Fulpan, 16, discovered a shortcut that would allow quick, easy multiple voting for Hassan over the Internet.

“There is more than one way to fight for your country,” he said, observing the young computer whiz. Despite the sad ending, the song contest provided a welcome three-month diversion.

Salfit is across the road from Ariel, the second-largest Israeli settlement in the West Bank with 18,000 residents, and clashes between Palestinians and Israelis are common, leading to curfews and arrests.

A singing competition covered as national news, because it was. Ammar Hassan, 27, of Salfit, lost the Arab world’s Superstar final to a Libyan, and stood stunned and silent; the two then took the stage holding each other’s flags. The piece is at its best on the voting. A sixteen-year-old named Ahmed Fulpan found a way to cast multiple ballots online, to a happy furor at the community center, and somebody watching him says the line the story is worth keeping for: ‘There is more than one way to fight for your country.’ The last paragraph places Salfit across the road from Ariel, the second-largest Israeli settlement in the West Bank, and notes the curfews and arrests. The three-month contest is described as a welcome diversion.

CP-2004-016 →

· Daily News · New York

Palestinian singer strikes a chord

The Associated Press

SALFIT, West Bank — Palestinians hoping for a morale boost were disappointed yesterday when their contestant in a much-watched competition for the Arab world's best singer lost to a Libyan.

Ammar Hassan, 27, from the town of Salfit in the West Bank, became the darling of the Palestinian people as he made his way through the stages of the 13-week “Superstar 2” contest on the Lebanese TV channel al-Mustaqbal — a show similar to the popular “American Idol” program in this country.

About 5,000 people crowded into the park in the center of Salfit to watch the TV broadcast from Beirut by satellite. They stood stunned and silent when it was announced that Libyan singer Eyman Al-Atar outpolled Hassan by a wide margin.

As with practically everything in Palestinian society, the singing contest became a symbolic element in the campaign for an independent state and against Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, territories the Palestinians claim. Bitterly disappointed, Mahmoud Yassin, 20, lashed out at fellow Arabs who did not vote for the Palestinian singer.

“They sold Jerusalem,” he said, referring to a perceived lack of Arab support for the Palestinian cause.

Supporters of Palestinian singer Ammar Hassan gather to watch the performer in “Superstar 2.”

The same day's Associated Press copy as the Herald Sun printing, under a different headline.

CP-2004-017 →

· Austin American Statesman · Austin · page 1

PORTRAITS: Palestinian painter has critics

Many Israelis say artist’s estimated 170 works glorify death, incite more violence

Margaret Coker, International Staff

“Many Israelis say Hasni’s pictures glorify death and incite more violence. To the bespectacled father of six, however, this criticism misses the point. He says his estimated 170 martyr portraits reflect his society’s desire to project strength amid despair.

‘This is our genre, the genre of our time,’ said Hasni, waving a paint-spotted arm toward the canvases of slain young men stacked in his makeshift garage studio. ‘Some cultures have movies, some have museums. Day after day, we have more martyrs.’… In this grim social scene, Hasni plays a crucial role.

His two-story concrete home wedged down the narrow, congested back alleys of the Beach Refugee Camp in northwestern Gaza City is where relatives and friends come with photographs of loved ones, seeking to glorify them in death beyond what they were in life… That commissions cost an average six-month salary — from $100 to $200 depending on the size — is seldom a concern.

‘It’s proper that my brother be remembered, not only by my mother and the shabab (his neighborhood gang), but by the whole city,’ said Ahmad Shaghnabi, whose 19-year-old brother, Akram, died in January when his gun accidentally discharged while he was cleaning it.

Shaghnabi’s family paid $140 for his portrait… ‘It saddens me that they don’t want the painting to reflect the people they were. But I’m obligated to fulfill their wishes,’ Hasni said.

‘If they say camouflage clothes and guns and bravery, then that’s what I paint.’ The industrial paint that Hasni uses because it is cheaper than better oil colors makes the skin of his subjects appear as waxy as a grocery store apple and leaves their eyes flat and glassy, giving them an odd magnetism… Israelis criticize the portraits as another way Palestinian culture glorifies violence.

An Israeli army officer once called artists such as Hasni ‘worse than jackals’ for making money from death. Hasni, however, denies such charges… ‘A people who lives without any right to travel or possibility of finding a well-paying job doesn’t need artistic inspiration to feel hate,’ Hasni said.

‘My work is not centered around making money. I’m establishing a social chronicle. People (want) to remember their fallen.’ While the criticism doesn’t irk him, his backlog of commissions does. Steady demand for his work means more Gazans have died.

When the killings hit too close to home — at least 10 of his paintings have been of former students or of neighborhood children — he anguishes. ‘When I paint I need to have a calm space,’ Hasni said. ‘When a face that I recognize as a child I once nurtured looms down at me in a death mask, that space is shattered.’”

An arts story whose headline is about his critics and whose second line leads with what Israelis say. The painter is identified in the pull quote as Fayez al-Hasni and in the body as Hasni. Photo credit: Margaret Coker / International Staff.

CP-2004-003 →

· Victoria Advocate · Victoria

Israeli attacks kill seven Palestinians, including militant in Gaza airstrike

Mark Lavie

JERUSALEM – Israelis killed seven Palestinians in attacks Monday, including a Gaza airstrike that killed one militant and wounded a militia commander, who vowed revenge from his hospital bed. The Gaza attack came as each side pummels the other in the run-up to Israel’s planned pullout from the crowded seaside territory next year.

An Israeli helicopter fired a missile at a car east of the city of Khan Younis, killing Ali al-Shaer, a member of the Popular Resistance Committees, an umbrella of dissidents from several militant groups. The Israeli military said the target was the other occupant of the car – Mohammed Abu Nasira, southern Gaza commander of the group.

“The (Israeli) crimes will not pass without punishment,” Abu Nasira told The Associated Press by telephone from the hospital, where he was being treated for serious burns. “I will continue my mission to terrorize the enemy (Israel), and we will win the battle.”

Hundreds of people gathered around the white vehicle after the missile blast burned the passenger compartment, twisting the chassis but leaving the front half intact. The Popular Resistance group was behind explosions that destroyed two Israeli tanks and is thought by some to have been involved in a similar blast that destroyed a vehicle in a U.S.

Embassy convoy a year ago, killing three security guards. Two other people were wounded in the airstrike, one of dozens Israel has directed at Palestinian militants in four years of violence. Israel calls them self-defense strikes against potential terrorists, but Palestinians and human rights groups denounce them as summary executions.

Israel plans to pull its 8,200 settlers out of Gaza late next year, and Palestinian militants want to show that they are driving the Israelis out by force. Israel is determined to keep hitting the militants to deter them from attacking after the withdrawal.

At nightfall, Palestinian gunmen kidnapped a producer for the TV network CNN at gunpoint, the network’s correspondent, Ben Wedeman said. In a CNN broadcast from Gaza, Wedeman said the gunmen stopped a CNN van and extracted Riad Ali.

CP-2004-040 →

· Lansing State Journal · Lansing

26 Palestinians, 3 Israelis die in battles

Army clashes with militants deep inside largest refugee camp

Ibrahim Barzak

JEBALIYA REFUGEE CAMP, Gaza Strip — Israeli troops struck deep inside the largest Palestinian refugee camp Thursday, battling masked gunmen in an unprecedented campaign to stop deadly rocket fire on Israeli towns. Twenty-six Palestinians were killed and 131 wounded, the bloodiest single-day toll in fighting in 30 months.

Three Israelis — two soldiers and an Israeli woman jogger — were killed in two Palestinian shooting attacks in northern Gaza. Prime Minister Ariel Sharon approved a large-scale military operation in the northern Gaza Strip after meeting with advisers late Thursday, an Israeli official said.

The plan was a response to the killing of two Israeli children, ages 2 and 4, by a Hamas rocket attack on an Israeli border town Wednesday. However, Sharon stopped short of ordering a call-up of reserves. The plan, which has the backing of Defense Minister Shaul Mofaz, was expected to be given final approval by the security Cabinet later Thursday.

Troops would focus on the Jebaliya refugee camp and the nearby town of Beit Hanoun. The army’s push Thursday into the center of Jebaliya — a first in four years of fighting — signaled a change in military tactics.

Camp ruins: A Palestinian youth pulls a burning tire next to a United Nations school where Israeli troops, not seen, took positions Thursday in the Jabaliya refugee camp adjacent to Gaza City. Twenty-six Palestinians and three Israelis, including a woman jogging in a Jewish settlement, were killed in northern Gaza on Thursday.

CP-2004-041 →

· Hispanos Unidos

Israel invade Franja de Gaza y ataca blancos civiles

FRANJA DE GAZA — El primer ministro Ariel Sharon declaró el domingo que Israel ampliará su ofensiva en Gaza, manteniendo a soldados en el área por tiempo indefinido para impedir que los palestinos disparen cohetes contra poblaciones del estado judío.

Sharon manifestó que estaba decidido a frenar los ataques con misiles a poblaciones que se encuentran dentro del territorio israelí y contra asentamientos judíos en la Franja de Gaza. Otros funcionarios israelíes dijeron que el operativo no establecerá una presencia permanente de Israel en Gaza.

Seis palestinos murieron el domingo en medio de los persistentes acontecimientos violentos en el norte de la franja. Tras convocar a una reunión de emergencia para analizar la crisis, legisladores palestinos emitieron el domingo una declaración sugiriendo que los milicianos deberían dejar de lanzar misiles contra Israel.

“El Consejo Legislativo Palestino, si bien declara el derecho de nuestro pueblo de resistir la desagradable ocupación de Israel, pide a todas las facciones que coloquen a esta resistencia dentro de un marco estratégico que sea consistente con los máximos intereses palestinos,” expresaron los legisladores en el comunicado.

Israel emplazó a unos 2.000 soldados en el norte de la Franja de Gaza después de un ataque palestino con un cohete que mató el miércoles a dos niños en la ciudad de Sderot. Desde entonces, han muerto 57 palestinos y otros tres israelíes.

En el campamento de refugiados Jebaliya, escenario de los combates más sangrientos de los últimos cuatro años, los soldados y tanques retrocedieron unos pocos metros durante la noche, dejando una estela de destrucción pues las máquinas excavadoras habían destruido numerosas casas, huertas y calles.

“Es necesario terminar por completo con el lanzamiento de cohetes contra Sderot y otras poblaciones que limitan con la Franja de Gaza. La actual situación no puede continuar,” declaró Sharon a Radio Israel.

La ciudad de Gaza se observa en el fondo, mientras que tanques israelíes maniobran para tomar posición en Beit Lahiy, al norte de la Franja de Gaza el Lunes por la mañana. Siendo la mayor escalada en 4 años.

CP-2004-021 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia

Two Palestinians wounded by army fire in Gaza Strip

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip (AP) — Israeli troops fired at Palestinians trying to bypass a checkpoint Monday, critically wounding one man and injuring a 14-year-old boy, a day after a similar incident in the same location killed one Palestinian, witnesses and hospital officials said.

The Israeli military said troops fired warning shots and then shot toward the group, after the pedestrians ignored orders to halt. Meanwhile, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat prepared to swear in a small eight-member Cabinet on Tuesday, with Ahmed Qureia as prime minister, after declaring a state of emergency in the Palestinian areas.

Arafat’s decree came a day after an Islamic Jihad suicide bomber killed 19 Israelis in a restaurant in the port city of Haifa. The Palestinians wounded in the Gaza Strip had been trying to cross a road closed by the military a daily earlier, as part of new restrictions imposed in response to the Haifa bombing.

The road links the southern Gaza towns of Rafah and Khan Younis, and was blocked by a checkpoint. A 42-year-old man was in critical condition with a head wound, and 14-year-old boy was shot in the leg, hospital officials said. On Sunday, a 26-year-old man was killed and three others were wounded while trying to bypass the same checkpoint.

Also Monday, Israeli tanks and bulldozers entered the Rafah refugee camp in southern Gaza and demolished four Palestinian homes, Palestinian security officials and local residents said.

Israeli army officials said they had no report of house demolitions in the area but that Palestinians fired anti-tank missiles, mortar shells and live ammunition toward Israeli forces in the area. One Israeli soldier was slightly injured, the army spokesman said.

The Islamic militant group Hamas said it fired 16 mortar shells at Israeli settlements in the Gaza Strip overnight, in retaliation for an Israeli air strike on a suspected Islamic Jihad training camp in Syria. Israel had launched the strike in reprisal for the Haifa bombing. Hamas also said it would also carry out more attacks in Israel.

“Any aggression against an Arab or Islamic country is an aggression against the Palestinian people and, God willing, our response to this aggression will be decisive,” read a statement on a Hamas web site. “We call on our fighters ... to respond quickly, and in the heart of the Zionist entity, to this serious escalation.”

CP-2004-022 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles

Israel Is Allegedly Intent on Freezing Peace Process

Sharon aide tells paper officials hope to stall talks with Palestinians after a Gaza pullout. He later says remarks were taken out of context.

JERUSALEM — One of Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s closest aides suggested in remarks published Wednesday that the Israeli government hopes to put Palestinian aspirations for statehood on hold indefinitely after withdrawing troops and Jewish settlers from the Gaza Strip next year.

The comments by Dov Weisglass, Sharon’s main liaison with the Bush administration, seemed to contradict Israel’s official position supporting the U.S.-backed peace plan. The initiative, known as the “road map,” is a step-by-step plan for Israeli-Palestinian negotiations that would lead to the creation of a Palestinian state.

Weisglass, who until recently served as Sharon’s chief of staff, told the daily newspaper Haaretz that a primary goal of the prime minister’s plan to unilaterally withdraw from the Gaza Strip by the end of 2005 “is the freezing of the peace process.”

“It supplies the formaldehyde necessary so there is no political process with the Palestinians,” the newspaper quoted him as saying. “When you freeze the process, you prevent the establishment of a Palestinian state.” The remarks appeared to catch U.S. diplomats by surprise.

After the interview was published, Sharon’s office issued a terse statement reaffirming Israel’s commitment to the peace plan, which a U.S. Embassy spokesman said reflected the American understanding of Israel’s position. The official did not comment directly on what Weisglass had said.

Weisglass told Israel Radio that the excerpts published by Haaretz, which will run the full interview Friday, had truncated his remarks. The former chief of staff insisted that he had meant only that a return to negotiations was currently impossible because of “a Palestinian administration that has no control and no ability to prevent terror.”

FROM A DISTANCE: An Israeli boy watches as Israeli tanks head toward Jabaliya refugee camp in the northern Gaza Strip, where military operations are in their second week. More than 80 Palestinians have died in the raids aimed at stopping militant rocket attacks.

CP-2004-023 →

· Star News

Palestinians and Arafat: History, and what’s next?

George Edmonson

The land traditionally known as Palestine has been an unsettled international issue since the end of World War I, when the Ottoman Empire collapsed. In 1947, the United Nations proposed dividing the land into Arab and Jewish countries, with Jerusalem under international administration. Israel was established in 1948.

After wars with surrounding Arab forces, the West Bank was put under Jordanian control, while Egypt controlled the Gaza Strip. Since the 1967 war, Israel has occupied those lands.

In 1994, after the Oslo peace accords were signed between Israel and the Palestinians, the Palestinian National Authority was established to administer much of that land, and Yasser Arafat was chosen as its president. Mr. Arafat’s grave illness raises many questions about the future of the Palestinians, the chances for peace and the situation throughout the Middle East.

Here’s a look at key issues: Q: WHO WILL SUCCEED MR. ARAFAT AS LEADER OF THE PALESTINIANS? A: No one knows. Mr. Arafat did little to encourage succession. Palestinian Authority laws call for Mr. Arafat to be succeeded by the speaker of the legislature, but virtually no one expects that to transpire.

Neither of the two highest-ranking Palestinian officials – Ahmed Qureia, the prime minister, and Mahmoud Abbas, also known as Abu Mazen, the Palestinian Liberation Organization’s No. 2 and former prime minister – is seen by many as a likely successor.

The former Gaza security chief, Mohammed Dahlan, is preferred by some in the West but has a small following among Palestinians. Militant factions also could seek to expand their role after Mr. Arafat’s death. Some analysts fear a bloody Palestinian civil war in a power struggle to replace Mr. Arafat.

Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat is pictured Oct. 29 aboard a French hospital plane en route from Amman, Jordan, to Paris, France, where he would seek medical treatment. Mr. Arafat was rushed to intensive care Thursday at the French military hospital after his condition had seriously deteriorated, Palestinian officials said. ASSOCIATED PRESS FILE

CP-2004-036 →

· The Free Lance-Star · Fredericksburg

Who gets to see Arafat? Very few

Officials may be in showdown with ailing Palestinian leader’s wife

Lara Sukhtian

CLAMART, France—Palestinian leaders rushed to Paris on yesterday to check on the critically ill Yasser Arafat, but hospital officials said visiting rights were restricted—setting the stage for a dramatic showdown between the delegation and Arafat’s wife.

Early yesterday, Suha Arafat accused the leadership—including top lieutenants Ahmed Qureia and Mahmoud Abbas—of coming to the French capital with the sole intention of usurping her husband’s role as head of the Palestinian Authority.

“I tell you they are trying to bury Abu Ammar alive,” she shouted, using Arafat’s nom de guerre, in a furious telephone call with Al-Jazeera television from the 75-year-old Arafat’s bedside in a hospital southwest of Paris. Tayeb Abdel Rahim, a senior Arafat aide, called a news conference in the West Bank to dispute the claims.

“What came from Mrs. Arafat doesn’t represent our people,” he said, accusing her of wanting “to be the lone decision maker.” And Palestinian Cabinet minister Salah Taamri said, “We are Yasser Arafat’s family. We knew Yasser Arafat even before Mrs. Suha Arafat was born.

We care for Yasser Arafat and no one has the right to deny the truth from the Palestinian people.” The Palestinian leadership abruptly called off the Paris trip, then reversed its decision. Qureia, the Palestinian prime minister, and Abbas, a former prime minister and the current PLO deputy chairman, landed in France late yesterday on a private jet.

The prospect of their being barred from Arafat’s hospital bedside was bound to inflame an increasingly tense power struggle. Suha Arafat seems to have aligned herself with hard-liners who apparently seek to take over the Palestinian leadership in a post-Arafat era, though some Palestinian officials said her motives are more financial.

She is widely believed to have control of vast funds collected by the PLO.

A child wearing Palstinian headgear stands next to the makeshift shrine for the ailing Yasser Arafat yesterday in front of the Percy Military Teaching Hospital in Clamart outside Paris.

CP-2004-026 →

· Portland Press Herald · Portland

Arafat’s other legacy: Money

Some Palestinians want an accounting, but Arafat’s finances are cloudy – and a fortune may be gone.

JERUSALEM — In his four decades as Palestinian leader, Yasser Arafat has run a murky financial empire that includes far-flung PLO investments in airlines, banana plantations and high-tech companies, and money hidden in bank accounts across the globe.

Jaweed al-Ghussein, a former PLO finance minister, told The Associated Press it was worth $3 billion to $5 billion when he quit in 1996. No one will say how much it’s worth now – some estimates say as little as a few million.

But as 75-year-old Arafat fights for life in a hospital near Paris, Palestinians fear that what’s left will disappear or be pocketed by Arafat cronies. “It’s the money of the Palestinian people,” said Palestinian legislator Hassan Khreishe, adding that he would urge a parliamentary investigation. That could prove difficult.

Arafat has long resisted proper accounting for the funds, which include Arab payments to the PLO in the 1970s and 1980s, and Western aid to his self-rule government, the Palestinian Authority, after interim peace deals with Israel in the 1990s. Arafat lived frugally, but needed large sums to maintain loyalties.

He would register investments and bank accounts in the names of loyalists, both to buy their support and protect the holdings from scrutiny and seizure, said al-Ghussein.

A Palestinian boy walks by posters of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat in a street in Gaza City recently. While Arafat remains in a coma in France, questions are being raised about his financial worth. One Palestinian legislator is urging a parliamentary investigation into Arafat’s poorly-documented finances.

CP-2004-031 →

· Muskegon Chronicle · Muskegon

Arafat through the years

Key dates in Yasser Arafat’s life

Jan. 1, 1965 – Formed Fatah guerrilla movement, later core group of PLO* Feb. 4, 1969 – Took over PLO Sept. 5, 1972 – PLO faction seized Israeli athletes at Munich Olympics Nov. 13, 1974 – Addressed U.N. General Assembly June 6, 1982 – Israel invaded Lebanon to crush PLO, forcing Arafat to flee Beirut, Lebanon Oct.

1, 1985 – Escaped death in Israeli air raid on PLO headquarters in Tunis, Tunisia Dec. 12, 1988 – Accepted Israel’s right to exist, renounced terrorism November 1991 – Married 28-year-old secretary, Suha Tawil, in Tunis; daughter born in Paris 1995 Sept. 13, 1993 – Israel and PLO signed accord on Palestinian autonomy in Washington, D.C.

July 1, 1994 – Set foot on Palestinian soil for the first time in 26 years Dec. 10 – Won Nobel Peace Prize, along with Israeli Prime Minister YitzhakRabin and Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres July 11, 2000 – Met with Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak and President Clinton, but summit fails Sept. 28 – Palestinian uprising begins Dec.

3, 2001 – Confined to Ramallah in West Bank after suicide bombings take place March 29, 2002 – After wave of suicide bombings, Israel reoccupied many Palestinian areas, destroying much of Arafat’s compound April 29, 2003 – Palestinian parliament confirmed Arafat’s deputy, Mahmoud Abbas, as first Palestinian prime minister June 4 – Israeli leader Ariel Sharon and President Bush launched “road map” peace plan with Abbas, refusing to deal with Arafat Oct.

29, 2004 – Arafat flown to Paris hospital gravely ill Nov. 10 – Died in hospital * Palestinian Liberation Organization

CP-2004-028 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia

Word from France sets off a wave of reactions

Bush called Arafat’s death “a significant moment in Palestinian history.” Palestinian flags at his compound were at half-staff.

Lara Sukhtian and Jamie Tarabay

CLAMART, France — Palestinian leader Yasir Arafat died in intensive care at early today, a French military hospital spokesman confirmed. “Mr. Yasir Arafat, president of the Palestinian Authority, has died at the Percy Military Training Hospital in Clamart on Nov. 11, 2004, at 3:30,” the hospital spokesman, Gen.

Christian Estripeau, told reporters in a brief statement. Estripeau then told reporters that Arafat’s body would be leaving the hospital but that — because of French privacy laws — there would no details on the cause of death or anything else. Arafat, 75, was flown to Paris on Oct. 29 for treatment of an undisclosed illness.

He fell into a coma a week later and was put on a life-support machine. His health steadily deteriorated and he suffered some brain damage due to a hemorrhage. Only his heart and lungs were still functioning, Palestinian officials said yesterday. No diagnosis has been made public.

Confirming Arafat’s death, French President Jacques Chirac said: “With him disappears a man of courage and conviction who for 40 years embodied the Palestinians’ struggle for recognition of their national rights.”

Chirac urged the international community to persevere with efforts to ensure that an international peace plan known as the road map is put into effect in the Middle East. President Bush issued a statement this morning saying: “The death of Yasir Arafat is a significant moment in Palestinian history. We express our condolences to the Palestinian people.

For the Palestinian people, we hope that the future will bring peace and the fulfillment of their aspirations for an independent, democratic Palestine that is at peace with its neighbors.

During the period of transition that is ahead, we urge all in the region and throughout the world to join in helping make progress toward these goals and toward the ultimate goal of peace.”

Israeli Justice Minister Yosef Lapid said: “It is one of the tragedies of the world that he didn’t understand that the terror that began here would spread to the entire world.”

CP-2004-029 →

· The Plain Dealer · Cleveland

Father of Palestinian nationalism is dead

The diminutive, fatigue-clad Arafat was the ultimate survivor and architect of legendary escapes. He used cunning, money and force to manipulate his subordinates and recover from sometimes-disastrous decisions. Numerous Israeli moves against him usually resulted in a backlash of Arab support for Arafat from a people desperate to shake off occupation and enjoy human rights.

His checkered keffiyeh head scarf came to symbolize revolution in coffee shops and street protests around the world. But in the reality of his last fitful years, Arafat was diminished and resented in the eyes of the world and even many of his own people.

The violent uprising against Israel that began in September 2000 prompted a harsh Israeli military response that devastated the Palestinians. Arafat’s administration, which he ran down to the finest details, squelched dissent and encouraged corruption. “The real feeling is more nostalgic than anything else.

Arafat reminds the Palestinians of the good times when the Palestinian resistance was at its peak,” said political analyst Labib Kamhawi, a Palestinian in Jordan. “The most important legacy for him in the last few years is the failure to have Palestinian democracy. He killed that really, established a police state and dictatorship like any other Arab regime.”

Nearly a half-century ago, Arafat shaped a Palestinian movement independent of the rest of the Arab leadership, which often had professed to represent Palestinians’ interests only to let them down. Arafat said Palestinians were ready to fight their own battles and chart their own course to statehood.

He used both the guerrilla tactics and terrorism of his Palestine Liberation Organization and his wile and charisma to press for a homeland for the Palestinian people, the largest group of refugees in the world. Arafat’s mystique grew in a career of ups and downs. He lived through numerous assassination attempts and an airplane crash landing in the Libyan desert.

He lost a short but bloody war against King Hussein of Jordan in 1970 and dressed as a woman to escape the Israeli siege in Lebanon in the 1980s.

CP-2004-030 →

· The Atlanta Constitution · Atlanta

Arafat’s death draws mixed reactions locally

Dan Chapman and Moni Basu

As in much of the world, Yasser Arafat’s death Thursday rekindled strongly divergent feelings among Atlantans — sadness, remorse, bitterness and disgust for the keffiyeh-draped leader who epitomized the plight of the Palestinians.

For former President Jimmy Carter, Arafat’s life was a testament to the struggle for human rights and statehood for a long-oppressed people. “He was the father of the modern Palestinian nationalist movement,” Carter said Thursday. “A powerful human symbol and forceful advocate, Palestinians united behind him.” Former U.N.

Ambassador Andrew Young, however, described Arafat’s death as the end of an era of lost opportunity. “Unfortunately, Yasser Arafat doesn’t leave much of a legacy, except for a legacy of frustration and violence,” said Young, who is also a former mayor of Atlanta.

“When he was trying to be a statesman, in the early days, he got very good support at the U.N. But when he turned violent, [the Palestine Liberation Organization] dug themselves a hole they couldn’t get out of. Arafat didn’t demonstrate almost any leadership or courage.” If anything, Arafat was a survivor, a fighter, a pillar of the Palestinian cause.

“He brought the Palestinian story to the United Nations and the world and made it an international issue more than any other person,” said the Rev. Fahed Abu-Akel, a Presbyterian minister in Atlanta who grew up in Israel. “I never dreamed in my lifetime that he would make peace with Israel.”

Abu-Akel, past moderator of the Presbyterian Church (USA), recalled a 2002 visit with Arafat at his compound in Ramallah that was nearly destroyed by the Israeli military. The reverend presented the Palestinian Authority chairman with a cross.

Arafat, seated at his kitchen table, unbuttoned his shirt to show another cross resting upon his chest given by French President Jacques Chirac. The Palestinian leader’s death, said Georgia Tech student Aysha Abdullatif, translates into even greater uncertainty for the troubled region.

“Now that Yasser Arafat is gone, the Palestinian people are without a country and without a leader,” said Abdullatif, whose ancestral home is the West Bank town of Azoun.

“If you’re an Israeli living in Haifa and one of your kids dies in Gaza during the intifada [Palestinian uprising], Arafat was the greatest disaster that ever befell you,” said Kenneth Stein, a professor of Middle Eastern studies at Emory University who met Arafat twice in 1993.

“But for a Palestinian living in a refugee camp in Beirut, Arafat was a leader who stayed true to his cause. ... History indicates that Arafat was unwilling to make critical compromises because he held fiercely onto his ideology.” Stein served as executive director of the Carter Center in Atlanta from 1983 to 1986.

His former boss remained one of Arafat’s staunchest supporters.

Former President Jimmy Carter (left) met with Yasser Arafat in Gaza City on Jan. 21, 1996. The Palestinian leader then met Carter in his hometown of Plains the following year.

CP-2004-024 →

· The Morning Call · Allentown

Arafat mourners look to future with uncertainty

Palestinians now face world without their most visible symbol.

Ken Ellingwood and Tracy Wilkinson

RAMALLAH, West Bank | Penned inside a half-demolished compound for the last 2½ years of his life, Yasser Arafat in death was suddenly everywhere. Within hours of the news that Arafat had died in a Paris hospital, grieving Palestinians on Thursday plastered posters of his grizzled face on seemingly every corner of this city.

Many people simply clutched an oversized image of Arafat in their hands, as if afraid to let him go. Sorrow and trepidation hung over the West Bank and Gaza Strip as Palestinians were left to ponder a world without Arafat as their leader for the first time in nearly 40 years.

Over and over, residents referred to Arafat as their father — the enduring leader of their struggle for a state — and the absence seemed to leave many disoriented and nervous. Hundreds of Palestinians who flocked to the gates of Arafat’s heavily shelled compound to share their grief. “He’s the symbol of the Palestinian struggle,” said one.

Around Ramallah and Gaza City, youths burned piles of tires in the street, sending up thick fingers of black smoke. Schools, shops and offices were shuttered in official mourning, and mosques blared Quranic verses for hours.

In front of the mosque in the Shati camp, militants from the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigade, in black masks and with AK-47s slung across their backs, used black spray paint to scrawl their message on a wall: “We swear we will follow your footsteps!” In Ramallah’s Manara Square, masked Al Aqsa militants marched, chanted and fired rifles into the air.

They tossed out leaflets announcing they had changed the group’s name to Martyr Yasser Arafat Brigade. Palestinians wrestled with mixed emotions, aware that a new era was upon them.

In addition to expressions of gratitude toward Arafat for carrying their cause to the world’s stage, there was a sense, too, that his passing might at last bring some of the changes for which they have longed.

Two messages seemed to compete throughout the day: the need to hew to Arafat’s unflinching approach toward Israel and the possibility for peace and an independent Palestinian state.

A MASKED MEMBER of Yasser Arafat’s Fatah movement passes a pile of tires set afire to mark the death of the Palestinian leader during a mourning demonstration in Gaza City, Gaza Strip.

CP-2004-027 →

· The Post-Standard · Syracuse

Tears amid Flames

In France, where Arafat died before dawn Thursday after 13 nights in a Paris military hospital, eight pallbearers carried his flag-draped coffin past an honor guard Thursday evening as a military band played the French and Palestinian national anthems and a Chopin funeral march.

Arafat’s widow, Suha, stifled sobs as the coffin was transferred from a French military helicopter to the official French airplane heading to Egypt. Though it had been expected for several days as he fell into a coma, Arafat’s death stunned Palestinians and left them wondering who could possibly replace their leader of the last four decades.

New government begins Arafat had not anointed a successor, but within hours the Palestine Liberation Organization elected former Prime Minister Mahmoud Abbas to replace him as its new chief, virtually ensuring he takes over as Palestinian leader, at least for now.

The Palestinian legislature also swore in Speaker Rauhi Fattouh as caretaker president of the Palestinian Authority, the self-ruling power in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, though that position will likely have far less power than when Arafat held it.

Fattouh is to serve for 60 days until elections can be held, though the law may be amended to allow parliament to choose the new president. Thousands of Palestinians flooded the streets, many weeping and clutching Arafat’s photo. Even members of the Hamas and Islamic Jihad militant groups, often critical of Arafat, mourned his death.

A SOLDIER FROM Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat’s 17th Force Presidential Guard weeps outside his former headquarters Thursday in Gaza City, after hearing of Arafat’s death in Paris.

CP-2004-032 →

· Poughkeepsie Journal · Poughkeepsie

Arafat: Leader will be buried in West Bank site

Associated Press

the Palestinian leader in a modest ceremony this morning, before Arafat’s body is flown to Ramallah for a burial service.

In France, where Arafat died before dawn Thursday after 13 nights in a Paris military hospital, eight pallbearers carried his flag-draped coffin past an honor guard Thursday evening as a military band played the French and Palestinian national anthems and a Chopin funeral march.

Arafat’s widow, Suha, stifled sobs as the coffin was transferred from a French military helicopter to the official French airplane heading to Egypt. Though it had been expected for several days as he fell into a coma, Arafat’s death stunned Palestinians and left them wondering who could possibly replace their leader of the last four decades.

Arafat had not anointed a successor, but within hours the Palestine Liberation Organization elected former Prime Minister Mahmoud Abbas to replace him as its new chief, virtually ensuring he takes over as Palestinian leader, at least for now.

The Palestinian legislature also swore in Speaker Rauhi Fattouh as caretaker president of the Palestinian Authority, the self-ruling power in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, though that position will likely have far less power than when Arafat held it.

Fattouh is to serve for 60 days until elections can be held, though the law may be amended to allow parliament to choose the new president. Thousands of Palestinians flooded the streets, many weeping and clutching Arafat’s photo. Even members of the Hamas and Islamic Jihad militant groups, often critical of Arafat, mourned his death.

Safra Hassan gave birth to twin boys in Gaza a few hours after Arafat died and said she was naming them Yasser and Arafat. “I’m so proud that the name of Yasser Arafat will be in my house every day, just as the name of Yasser Arafat will be in every Palestinian house forever,” she said.

Black smoke from burning tires rose across the Gaza Strip and gunmen fired symbolic volleys into the air. At Arafat’s battered Ramallah compound where he will be buried, flags flew at half staff. The radio played somber music, church bells in the partly Christian city rang out, and Quranic verses were played for hours over mosque loudspeakers.

Suha Arafat weeps Thursday during a French military honor guard ceremony for her deceased husband, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, at Villacoublay airbase southwest of Paris.

CP-2004-033 →

· San Antonio Express News · San Antonio

Significant events in the life of Yasser Arafat

1929–2004 Aug. 4, 1929 Born in Cairo, Egypt, fifth child of Palestinian merchant Abdel Raouf al-Qudwa al-Husseini. 1933 Mother Zahwa dies. Arafat and infant brother Fathi sent to Jerusalem to live with uncle. 1949 Moves back to Cairo; forms Palestinian Students’ League.

August 1956 Attends international student congress in Prague, Czechoslovakia, secures membership for Palestine. For first time, wears Palestinian headdress, or keffiyeh, that becomes his trademark. Jan. 1, 1965 Forms Fatah guerrilla movement; two days later attempts first attack on Israel, abortive bombing of water canal in Galilee.

March 21, 1968 Israeli army attack on PLO base at Karameh, Jordan, inflicts heavy losses, but seen as victory for Arafat and his group; thousands join PLO. Feb. 4, 1969 Arafat takes over PLO chairmanship, transforms it into dynamic force that makes Palestinian cause known worldwide. Nov. 13, 1974 Arafat addresses U.N. General Assembly.

June 6, 1982 Israel invades Lebanon to crush PLO, forcing Arafat and loyalists to flee Beirut. Oct. 1, 1985 Arafat narrowly escapes death in Israeli air raid on PLO headquarters in Tunis, Tunisia. April 16, 1988 Khalil al-Wazir, Arafat’s military commander, also known as Abu Jihad, assassinated in Tunis; Israel blamed. Dec.

12, 1988 Arafat accepts Israel’s right to exist, renounces terrorism. Aug. 2, 1990 Iraq invades Kuwait; Arafat supports Saddam Hussein, resulting in PLO’s isolation. November 1991 Arafat secretly marries 28-year-old secretary, Suha Tawil, in Tunis. Their daughter Zahwa born July 24, 1995, in Paris.

April 7, 1992 Arafat rescued after plane crash-lands in Libyan desert during sandstorm, killing two pilots and engineer and leaving Arafat bruised and shaken. Sept. 13, 1993 Israel and PLO sign accord on Palestinian autonomy in Oslo, Norway, giving Arafat control of most of Gaza Strip and 27 percent of West Bank.

Arafat shakes hands with Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin on White House lawn. July 1, 1994 Returning from exile, a triumphant Arafat sets foot on Palestinian soil for the first time in 26 years. Dec. 10, 1994 Arafat wins Nobel Peace Prize, along with Rabin and Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres. Nov.

4, 1995 Ultranationalist Jew assassinates Rabin at peace rally in Tel Aviv, Israel. Nov. 9, 1995 Arafat makes first visit to Israel in secret trip to offer condolences to Rabin’s widow.

CP-2004-034 →

· South Bend Tribune

Arafat leaves chaos behind

Palestinian leaders left to grapple with competing warlords.

GAZA CITY — Police chiefs are kidnapped and ambushed. Armed gangs fight one another in the streets. Rioters torch government buildings. Prisoners are killed in custody. Long before the late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat fell gravely ill last month, his ability to govern was steadily crumbling.

The Gaza Strip and parts of the West Bank had descended into a kind of chaos, ruled haphazardly by competing warlords, rival factions and tribal clans engulfed in power struggles and turf battles and eclipsing the official Palestinian Authority.

Most institutions of state have all but collapsed in Gaza, in part from Israeli military incursions during the 4-year-old Palestinian uprising, and in part from Palestinian political paralysis. In the last two years, schools and hospitals have continued to operate, for example, but there has been a near-total breakdown in public security.

“The government has no role in maintaining law and order,” said Ziad abu Amr, a Palestinian legislator from Gaza City and frequent critic of Arafat and the Palestinian Authority he led. “The people are relying on customs and tradition and the principle of mutual deterrence: If I attack somebody, I should expect retaliation.”

Most Palestinians in Gaza do not rely on the 14 or more government security services functioning here; in fact, agents from these services are often the ones committing violent acts in the course of turf battles. Instead, clans have been forming militias and arming members as a means of self-defense, said residents who were interviewed recently.

The resurgence of tribal justice is another sign of the deterioration of the Palestinian Authority. Although its use is common in the Middle East, the Palestinian nation-in-waiting was supposed to rely on its government-run court system. Turmoil at the rank-and-file level isn’t surprising given the turmoil above.

Commanders of the various security agencies are locked in a bloody competition that has gained steam since the summer — fueled by Arafat’s political limitations and failing health. “Arafat never committed himself to the building of institutions or to the rule of law,” said Eyad Sarraj, a prominent Gazan psychiatrist.

“He created all these sultans of power, always under his umbrella, with him as the ultimate arbitrator. He tried to keep everyone loyal ... and the result today is you have this anarchy.”

A young girl watches a Palestinian woman weep at Yasser Arafat’s compound after news of his death broke Thursday in Ramallah, West Bank.

CP-2004-035 →

· Staten Island Advance · Staten Island

Legions of followers swarm Arafat’s coffin

faces, as is common in Palestinian funerals during times of crisis. However, the gunmen calmly submitted to inspection by plainclothes security personnel who ensured there were no bullets in the chambers. The cooperation between militants and policemen was a likely reflection of Palestinians’ desire for consensus in the wake of Arafat’s death.

HUNDREDS ON ROOFTOPS In Gaza City, hundreds of people gathered on rooftops, streets and apartment balconies in hopes of catching a glimpse of the helicopter. Barred from attending the burial, tens of thousands of Gaza residents held rallies and symbolic funerals across the strip.

The 75-year-old Arafat, who led the Palestinians for four decades, died yesterday at a Paris hospital from an undisclosed illness that had plunged him into a weeklong coma. He had spent his final three years confined to his Ramallah headquarters, known as the Muqata, never leaving out of fear the Israelis wouldn’t allow him back in.

Today, teenage boys climbed onto the walls of the compound chanting “Whoever poisoned Arafat, we will drink his blood.” Others cried out, “Allahu akbar,” Arabic for “God is great,” and “We want to see Abu Ammar.” Top Arafat aide Tayeb Abdel Rahim emerged from the compound and asked the crowd to stop chanting.

“The whole world is watching us now on television and we have to reflect our real picture,” he said. In Jerusalem, hundreds of Palestinian youths scuffled with Israeli police outside the al-Aqsa mosque — the third holiest site in Islam — after police barred them from prayers amid fear of riots and unrest during Arafat’s funeral.

POLICE ON ALERT Israeli police, ordered to stay on the sidelines of the burial, were on their highest state of alert and canceled all leaves, worried that the prayers for the last Friday of the holy month of Ramadan, together with mourning for Arafat, would get out of control.

Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince Abdullah, center foreground, in traditional Arab garb, and Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, wearing sunglasses, are among Arab leaders paying their respects to Palestinian President Yasser Arafat during a funeral service in Cairo.

CP-2004-038 →

· USA Today · McLean

Palestinian moderates hope to step in

Winning over Hamas is just one obstacle

As the reality of a Middle East without Yasser Arafat sinks in, some analysts say the first major challenge will be choosing a new Palestinian leadership through elections, a process that will require the assistance of Israel and the United States. Under an informal constitution adopted by the Palestinian Authority, elections for a new president are to be held in 60 days.

Arafat held a unique position in Palestinian politics as president of the authority, chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), an umbrella organization representing Palestinians inside and outside the West Bank and Gaza, and leader of Fatah, the largest faction within the PLO. In the aftermath of his death, the jobs have been assigned to three men.

The speaker of the Palestinian parliament, Rauhi Fattouh, on Thursday became provisional president. Former prime minister Mahmoud Abbas is the new chairman of the PLO. And Farouk Kaddoumi, a veteran Palestinian politician who lives in Tunisia, is the new leader of Fatah.

End of era: Members of Yasser Arafat’s security detail react to the news of his death Thursday outside the Palestinian leader’s compound in the West Bank city of Ramallah. Arafat’s funeral will be today in Cairo.

CP-2004-039 →

· The Forum

Arafat buried in chaotic farewell

Palestinians swarm their leader’s coffin

Ravi Nessman

RAMALLAH, West Bank – Yasser Arafat was buried Friday in the place where he spent his last years as a virtual prisoner, seen off in a huge and chaotic outpouring of grief for the man who embodied the Palestinian people’s dream of statehood.

Police firing in the air failed to restore order as the tens of thousands of mourners rushed toward the coffin, struggling to be close to their leader – hailed as a Nobel Peace laureate and branded a terrorist – for one final time.

“President Arafat would have wanted it this way, with exhilaration, feelings of loyalty, pain, sadness and love all at once,” Palestinian legislator Hanan Ashrawi said. “The people reclaimed him. They wanted to say goodbye without distance.”

The frenzied burial took place at Arafat’s headquarters in the West Bank city of Ramallah, where Israel had kept him under siege for nearly three years. It came just hours after an orderly funeral ceremony in Cairo, where the only outburst of emotion was the quiet weeping of Arafat’s 9-year-old daughter, Zahwa, standing beside her veiled mother, Suha.

Where that service gave foreign dignitaries an opportunity to bid a formal farewell to the 75-year-old Palestinian leader, his burial in Ramallah allowed the Palestinian masses, who adored Arafat even as the United States and Israel tried to marginalize him, to say goodbye.

“Everyone wanted to carry the coffin, to touch it, to say goodbye to the president,” said Ahmed Tirawi, 22, a West Bank villager.

Arafat’s death Thursday at a French military hospital shocked many Palestinians, who had never considered life without the man who led them for nearly four decades and transformed their struggle from a refugee problem into an international crisis. Arafat promised Palestinians a state of their own, but died without delivering.

Palestinian Cabinet minister Saeb Erekat, who accompanied Arafat’s coffin on the helicopter flight from Egypt to the West Bank, said he kept talking along the way, as if Arafat were still alive. “I told him, ‘My heart is broken. Your life has ended, but the occupation has not.’”

Palestinian police struggle with the crowd to load Yasser Arafat’s coffin onto the top of a vehicle Friday in Ramallah. People chanted, “With our blood and our soul we will redeem you Yasser Arafat!”

CP-2004-025 →

· Concord Monitor · Concord

Palestinians eager for democracy

“Freed from Yasser Arafat’s one-man rule, Palestinians say they are eager and able to build the first real democracy in the Arab world.”

Three weeks after Arafat's death. Freed from does a great deal of work in a sentence about people living under occupation.

CP-2004-043 →

· Richmond Times-Dispatch · Richmond, VA

Israeli offensive kills 6 in Gaza

Palestinian militants die in raid spurred by rocket, mortar blasts

©New York Times News Service

JERUSALEM — At least six Palestinians were killed and 24 were wounded yesterday in an Israeli army raid near Khan Younis in the Gaza Strip. The raid was designed to end days of mortar and rocket attacks from the town on Israeli troops and nearby settlements. Four of the dead were militants linked to Fatah and two were civilians, local medics and the Israeli army said.

Five more Palestinians died and others were trapped when a tunnel they were digging collapsed because of heavy rain near the Egyptian crossing point of Rafah, in southern Gaza. Palestinians use these tunnels from Egypt to smuggle contraband, including weapons, ammunition, explosives and anti-tank rockets for use against Israeli forces.

Last Sunday, Hamas and Fatah militants set off a ton and a half of explosives in an 800-yard tunnel dug under a fortified Israeli army post and then fired at rescuers, killing five Israelis and wounding eight. There was a second explosion an hour later. Hamas said it had taken four months to dig the tunnel.

The Israeli army says it has discovered nearly 100 tunnels from Egypt to Gaza and regularly criticizes Egypt for not doing enough to stop the digging. The army also says the tunnels are the main reason that it has destroyed hundreds of homes near the Rafah crossing point, to create a buffer zone.

In Khan Younis yesterday, hundreds of Palestinians sought refuge from the fighting. Israeli bulldozers demolished several homes that the army said served as cover for those firing rockets and mortars. A local army commander, Lt. Col. Ofer Winter, told Israel radio that the army would stay in Khan Younis “for as long as it takes to secure quiet in the Israeli communities.”

Short NYT News Service wire piece. The only voice in it is Winter’s; the six Palestinians killed and 24 wounded are counted but not named, and the hundreds who ‘sought refuge from the fighting’ are not spoken to. Worth holding against the slide-44/45/46 Winter clippings as a 2004 baseline: a decade before Rafah 2014 the same officer is already being quoted in an American paper promising to stay until there is ‘quiet in the Israeli communities’ while bulldozers work.

CP-2004-052 →

· Hartford Courant · Hartford, CT

8 Killed In Palestinian Refugee Camp

Hundreds are forced to flee their homes as Israel responds to recent attacks against a Jewish settlement.

Los Angeles Times

JERUSALEM — Backed by combat helicopters, Israeli troops and tanks pushed their way into a Palestinian refugee camp in the southern Gaza Strip on Friday, killing at least eight Palestinians and wounding scores of others, hospital officials said.

Continuing unrest in Gaza has been causing political headaches for Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon as he seeks to pursue his plan to uproot the Jewish settlements of the seaside strip next year.

Sharon lost his parliamentary majority during infighting over the Gaza withdrawal and has been seeking to shore up his conservative government by allying with the left-leaning Labor Party. Israeli news reports said Friday night that an agreement had been reached granting Labor eight Cabinet positions, including deputy prime minister for party leader Shimon Peres.

Sharon’s political foes say violence in Gaza underscores the need for Israeli forces to maintain a tight grip on the territory to prevent it from becoming a staging ground for attacks against Israel. Supporters of the withdrawal plan insist that the Mediterranean enclave is a quagmire from which Israelis should extricate themselves as soon as possible.

The Khan Younis camp, a sprawling enclave of alleyways and concrete-slab buildings only yards from the Jewish settlement of Neve Dekalim, has in recent days been used by Palestinian militants as the launching site for mortar attacks against Jewish settlers. A young Thai woman working at one settlement was killed in such a barrage this week.

“More than 50 mortar shells were fired at Jewish communities in the last week,” Col. Ofer Winter, an Israeli army commander in Gaza, told Israel Radio. “This is unacceptable. So long as our residents have no peace, neither shall theirs.”

As the Israeli troops moved into the camp, hundreds of panicked Palestinian civilians fled their homes in darkness and freezing temperatures, according to Palestinian officials. “They shelled our neighborhoods and broke the windows, and then they called us by loudspeaker to leave our homes,” said 34-year-old Palestinian mother Lubna Asfour.

“We didn’t have a chance to take anything with us.”

The sharpest Winter sentence in the whole batch and the sharpest Palestinian sentence in the whole batch sit in the same two columns of a wire story. Nothing about the Hannibal Directive. Note the structure: the headline counts the dead without naming the killer (‘8 Killed In Palestinian Refugee Camp’) while the deck frames the operation as a response (‘as Israel responds to recent attacks against a Jewish settlement’).

CP-2004-051 →

· Wisconsin State Journal · Madison · page 1

Pressured not to run, Palestinian women did well at polls

By Mohammed Ballas, Associated Press, Yabed

YABED, West Bank — Women faced pressure not to run as candidates in the Palestinian local elections.

But they did — and they won, with more than half of them defeating their male opponents in this conservative, traditional Arabic society. Palestinian women won 51 seats in Thursday’s elections, 32 of them winning their place outright without having to claim a seat reserved for women by Palestinian law. Maisoun Badarneh, a 44-year-old teacher elected as an independent candidate to the council in the town of Yabed, said she faced intense opposition from relatives and neighbors who argued it was unacceptable for a woman to hold a position requiring daily contact with the public.

“The majority of my problems were due to society’s inability to accept the idea of women participating in the municipality,” Badarneh said, adding that four other female candidates in her town dropped out before the elections due to family pressure. The role of women in the Palestinian struggle has seen peaks and valleys.

Leila Khaled pushed women into the forefront in 1969 when she hijacked a TWA airliner to Syria, and Hanan Ashrawi has had a long career as a Palestinian spokeswoman, legislator and human rights activist.… “We were hoping for more, but this is a beginning,” she said of the elections.

“We’re delighted and plan to have a big celebration for the women.”

In the village of Abwein, north of Ramallah, Fatima Suhweil, 59, received more votes than any of the 27 other candidates despite religious-based parties campaigning relentlessly against her. Now she will be mayor of the village… Suhweil attributed her support, from both men and women, to her record in building up and running a girls’ high school. “People knew that I would be successful regardless,” she said, adding that she wanted to use the position as a springboard to run for parliament… “Women are demanding a say,” he said.

Seventy-five years after the first Arab Women’s Congress drove through Jerusalem in seventy automobiles and the wire counted the cars, four Palestinian women are named in one dispatch, three with ages and jobs, two of them elected. The paper also draws the line this archive draws: it explains Palestinian women’s politics by starting with Leila Khaled.

CP-2004-005 →

· Wausau Daily Herald · page 1

Disabled Palestinian-American comic builds bridges with laughter

She gives others a chance to entertain while sharing diversity

By Heather Salerno, Gannett News Service

“When Maysoon Zayid takes the stage, she knows the audience probably never has seen a comic like her.

So she lays it all out right from the start. ‘I’m a Palestinian-American virgin from New Jersey with cerebral palsy.’ With that zinger, Zayid loosens up a crowd, which otherwise might not know what to expect from this wild-haired woman with an Arabic name and shaking limbs.

‘I get these things out of the way, so they know who I am,’ Zayid says.

‘And I always laugh, because I wonder when I’ll stop saying I’m a virgin.’… She’s brassy, tough and opinionated — not exactly traits most Americans associate with Muslim women… ‘Stop with the suffering,’ she playfully told her fellow Arab-American artists. ‘That’s so easy.

Stop making the suffering films and suffering plays where people are killed. Start doing something funny that make people feel good and want more of.’ That’s not to say she hasn’t seen her share of horror back in her parents’ homeland.

Zayid’s stand-up earnings pay for an art program she runs for disabled and wounded children in Palestinian refugee camps four months out of the year. The barbs in her comic routines come from personal experience: Two of her students have been shot and killed by Israeli soldiers in the past three years.… She’s called Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon a war criminal, though she notes that she was just as tough on the late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat.

Zayid is very clear on one point: She might poke fun at Israel, but never at Jews. ‘Judaism isn’t Zionism,’ she says. ‘I live and work in a society of all three Judeo-Christian religions, and I have respect for all three.’… She is vague about her exact age, putting it between 25 and 30.

‘Too old to be unmarried, too young to be dead,’ she deadpans… The only concession Zayid makes to her disability is a stool she uses during performances… ‘Yes, I’m a sit-down stand-up,’ she chuckles.… ‘I’ve been told by some great, great, great comics that I respect, ‘Baby, step away from the Palestine thing.

You’re not going to go anywhere with this. You need to be careful. People don’t like it. It’s a ball and chain,’ Zayid says. ‘But I say, no, no way. I can’t.’”

She co-founded the New York Arab-American Comedy Festival in 2003, funds an art program for children in the camps out of her own stand-up earnings, has lost two of those children to Israeli soldiers, and tells her fellow Arab-American artists to stop making suffering plays. Comics she admires have advised her to drop the Palestine material. She is also the only person in this archive to settle in three words a question the United Nations spent sixteen years voting on.

CP-2004-006 →

· Desert Sun

Abbas denounces ‘Zionist enemy’ after tank fire kills 7

JERUSALEM — Just days before the Palestinian presidential election, Israeli tank fire in the northern Gaza Strip on Tuesday killed seven Palestinian youths harvesting strawberries, witnesses said, prompting the leading candidate, Mahmoud Abbas, to deliver an unusually caustic attack on Israel, which he called “the Zionist enemy.”

Israel quickly responded, with Vice Prime Minister Ehud Olmert saying Abbas’ statements were “intolerable, unacceptable, and they cannot serve as the basis for any cooperation in the future.” The death of the Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat on Nov. 11 ushered in a brief period of reduced violence and less hostile oratory.

But the deaths on Tuesday, and the bitter recriminations that followed, felt more like the darker days of the last four years and marked a breakdown of the relatively restrained public exchanges between Abbas and Israeli leaders.

The troubles began when Palestinians fired four mortar rounds in the morning, wounding an Israeli civilian in an industrial zone on the northern edge of the Gaza Strip, the Israeli military said. One shell nearly hit a school bus carrying children in northern Gaza, the military added.

Soon afterward, an Israeli tank fired on a group of Palestinians believed to have been responsible for firing the mortars from farmland on the outskirts of Beit Lahiya, the Israeli military said.

Seven Palestinian youths working in a strawberry field, ages 11 to 17, were killed, according to relatives, witnesses and Palestinian officials at Kamal Adwan Hospital, who said an additional 11 Palestinian civilians had been wounded. Dr. Mahmoud al-Asli, the hospital’s director, said six members of the Ghaben family, including three brothers, had been killed.

The Ghaben family confirmed the information given by the hospital, The Associated Press reported. Abbas, who was campaigning in southern Gaza at the time of the exchange, said, “We are praying for the souls of the martyrs who were killed Tuesday by the shells of the Zionist enemy.”

Palestinian mourners carry five of the seven bodies of Palestinians killed by an Israeli tank’s shells in the northern Gaza Strip town of Beit Lahiya on Tuesday.

CP-2005-016 →

· Springfield News Sun

Abbas seeking cease-fire

Palestinian suicide bomber blows himself up on settler road in Gaza

Associated Press

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — In the biggest test of his brief tenure, Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas came to the Gaza Strip on Tuesday, hoping to persuade militants to halt attacks on Israel. But in a show of defiance, a Palestinian suicide bomber blew himself up on a settler road in Gaza, wounding six Israelis.

The Islamic militant group Hamas claimed responsibility for the attack — the first suicide bombing against an Israeli target since Nov. 1. Before the bombing, Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon warned his patience was running thin, telling military commanders the army must deal with rocket and mortar attacks against Israelis “at the earliest possible stage.”

Sharon aide David Baker said Tuesday’s bombing showed that “Palestinian terror is increasing.” He said Israel has been restrained, but “no country in the world would allow its citizens to be bombed on a daily basis.”

Israel has come under international pressure to hold off on any large-scale raid into Gaza to give Abbas, who took office Saturday, a chance to cobble together a cease-fire. The European Union and Jordan both urged Sharon to hold off on a raid. Abbas traveled to Gaza on Tuesday evening and planned to remain for several days to try to work out a deal with the militants.

Palestinian officials said he met late Tuesday with Islamic Jihad and then saw Hamas leaders.

CP-2005-021 →

· Indianapolis Star · Indianapolis

Forsaking the tunnel of death

Dan Carpenter

An Israeli Jew is touring the United States, Canada and Mexico with a message he believes is largely lost on those countries and his countrymen: “Palestinians are regular people just like us and they deserve the same, the same, the same.”

Without international pressure to enforce that equal status, Teddy Katz says, “Palestinians and Israelis will stay in this tunnel where we are only able to fight and kill each other.”

The 62-year-old spokesman for the Israeli peace group Gush Shalom stopped in Indianapolis last week to deliver an historical critique as well as a denunciation of the policies of Prime Minister Ariel Sharon and President Bush. He’s a figure of controversy.

Military veterans hit him with a libel suit after he wrote a paper for master’s degree studies at the University of Haifa in the late 1990s, accusing the Israeli army of massacring more than 200 residents of the Palestinian village of Tantura during the formative days of the Jewish state in 1948.

Katz retracted that assertion to settle the lawsuit but has been trying ever since to rescind the decision. He stands by his information, drawn from scores of interviews with Palestinian and Jewish witnesses. He and his supporters maintain he was overwhelmed by legal fees and by enormous political pressure from a nation in denial.

Official history agrees with Katz that Palestinians died at Tantura; but it says they were far fewer in number and were, along with Israelis, battle casualties. Even this concession hits a sore point, says Katz, who is among the “new historians” in Israel who have drawn heat for what they see as their de-romanticization of the nation’s origins.

CP-2005-013 →

· The Courier News · Bridgewater

Israeli soccer makes room for Arab heroes

The last clipping in this run, and the only cheerful one.

CP-2005-017 →

· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota

Disengagement from settlements a crucial step toward peace

Nikki Nilon, Guest Columnist

“Almost a year and a half ago, Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon announced his courageous initiative to disengage from the entire Gaza Strip and northern tier of the West Bank. This will effectively remove the Israeli civilian and military presence from these areas, allowing the Palestinian Authority to take full control and responsibility for what goes on there.

Sharon’s disengagement initiative, when first announced, was intended to be a unilateral act to protect Israel’s interests in the absence of a credible peace partner.

Now that the most serious impediment to peace, Yasser Arafat, is gone, and Mahmoud Abbas has been elected with the mandate to pursue Palestinian aspirations nonviolently, Sharon’s disengagement plan could become a catalyst toward Israeli-Palestinian reconciliation.

Sharon’s meeting with President Bush in Crawford, Texas, on Tuesday will take places as implementation of disengagement is assured in the wake of passage in the Knesset of Israel’s state budget in March. The prime minister has repeatedly imperiled his political career in order to see the disengagement initiative carried out.

For Israelis, disengagement promises to be a painful and disruptive sacrifice. Some 8,000 Jewish residents in the Gaza Strip and several hundred more in the West Bank will be relocated this summer, along with Israel’s military presence.

Undoubtedly, the families of the uprooted communities will face hardship and trauma in remaking their lives in new communities in Israel. Disengagement also stands to cost the state hundreds of millions of dollars in an already strapped economy, which got that way almost entirely due to the effects of Palestinian terrorism over the past four years.

Yet, the vision of two states for two peoples stands upon the chance to take a giant step forward with disengagement.

Israel is relinquishing exclusive control of the Gaza Strip and the northern West Bank to the Palestinian Authority, which now has the opportunity to govern responsibly and prove that it is ready to accept living permanently alongside Israel, thus ending the conflict.

The vacuum that will be created through Israel’s departure from these areas must be filled by real actions on the part of Mahmoud Abbas to reform Palestinian society and prepare it for a durable and genuine peace with Israel. Disengagement must now be met by the willingness and capability on the Palestinians’ side to fulfill their obligations.

Abbas must do more than simply coax Palestinian terrorist groups into accepting a nonbinding ‘temporary lull’ in violence.

Instead, he must act decisively to unify the Palestinian security forces and use them to dismantle these terrorist groups’ capacity to carry out attacks by collecting illegal weapons, destroying bomb-making factories and closing the tunnels used to smuggle weapons in from Egypt to Gaza. He also must work to end incitement in state media and schools.

These are the basic requirements agreed upon for the ‘road map’ to peace. Both Sharon and Bush are anxious to use disengagement as a springboard for progress on the road to peace. The president recently asked Congress for a $350 million assistance package for the Palestinians over two years to help rebuild their infrastructure and improve their economy.

The Europeans and the Arab states should be expected to increase their involvement in the economic arena as well. Egypt and Jordan have vital roles to play in helping the Palestinians to fulfill their security responsibilities and to undertake government reforms. Other Arab states should commit to normalizing relations with Israel as the environment improves.

If the Palestinians and Israel’s other Arab neighbors are ready at long last to end their conflict with Israel, disengagement will represent a start on the path toward two states living side by side in peace.”

A guest column on the Gaza disengagement, and the arithmetic of whose displacement counts. The 8,000 Israeli settlers to be moved are uprooted communities who will face hardship and trauma in remaking their lives; the word for what happens to them is sacrifice. The 1.3 million Palestinians already in Gaza appear as an entity with obligations — to reform, to dismantle, to collect weapons, to end incitement in schools. Not one of them is named or quoted. The column also assigns the cause of Israel’s economic difficulty in a single clause: an economy which got that way almost entirely due to the effects of Palestinian terrorism over the past four years. The writer is identified at the foot as chairwoman of the Sarasota-Manatee Jewish Federation’s Community Relations Council, so the page is doing what an opinion page should: printing an argument with its source attached.

CP-2005-008 →

· Detroit Free Press · Detroit · page 1

A solemn anniversary for some

Day of Israel’s creation painful for Palestinians · Refugees continue the fight for return of homeland, rights

Mohammed Daraghmeh, Associated Press, Ramallah, West Bank

“RAMALLAH, West Bank — Protesters marched through the streets and traffic halted throughout the West Bank and Gaza on Sunday as Palestinians mournfully commemorated the day Israel was created, calling it one of the darkest days in their history.

Israelis held barbecues, concerts and launched fireworks to celebrate the 57th anniversary of their independence Thursday — according to the date on the Hebrew calendar.

Palestinians see the day very differently, marking it Sunday as Al-Nakba, which is Arabic for ‘the catastrophe’… About 700,000 Palestinians lost their homes in the fighting that followed Israel’s independence in 1948.

Their demand to return to their homes with their descendants — a total of 4 million people by a United Nations estimate — represents one of the toughest issues in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In Palestinian cities and towns Sunday, traffic stopped and people stood silent at noon.

The sirens paralleled those that sound throughout Israel on Holocaust Remembrance Day and Memorial Day, but the silence was broken by shots fired in the air by gunmen… ‘The Nakba is still a black day in the history of the Palestinian people, and we’ve been suffering since that day,’ said 61-year-old Gaza resident Suleiman Arabeed.

Like many of the protesters, Arabeed is a Palestinian refugee. Hamas, the largest Palestinian militant group, released a statement referring to Israel as a ‘cancer’ and promising to continue fighting ‘until the liberation of the last inch of our land and the last refugee heads back to his home.’

In his speech, Abbas called on the host countries to ensure basic civil rights for the refugees, demanding they be granted the right to work and travel freely. Some 350,000 Palestinians live in 12 refugee camps in Lebanon and have no civil rights. In Syria, Palestinians can work and join the army. In Jordan, most have Jordanian citizenship.”

“Palestinians march Sunday in Gaza City to mark Al-Nakba — Arabic for ‘the catastrophe’ — which is how they describe Israel’s creation 57 years ago. Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas said, ‘Palestinians have a homeland, and it is called Palestine.’” Hatem Moussa, Associated Press.

And: “Meryam Amarneh, 70, who lives in the Aida refugee camp near Bethlehem in the West Bank, holds the key to her family’s former house Sunday. Amarneh and her family left their home in Rassa Abu Ammar village west of Jerusalem during fighting in 1947.” Musa Al-Shaer, Getty Images / Agence France-Presse.

The qualifier is in the banner over the page: a solemn anniversary for some.

CP-2005-001 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco

Berkeley: KPFA pair give young Palestinians a voice

The reporting and writing talents of the teenagers of Dheisheh, the Palestinian refugee camp, made a powerful impact on two East Bay radio journalists who recently spent time there to volunteer their know-how for a youth media project.

KPFA radio producers Nora Barrows-Friedman and Babak Jacinto Tondre left the camp in the occupied West Bank outside Bethlehem believing they may have glimpsed a future for the Palestinian people beyond war.

They say the journalism being practiced by kids as young as 14 in the refugee community of 12,000 people was compelling enough that it could become a peaceful force toward a resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict that has enmeshed the youngsters’ elders for more than 50 years.

With KPFA and the Berkeley Middle East Children’s Alliance, Barrows-Friedman, a Berkeley resident, and Tondre, who lives in Oakland, formed the Freedom Radio Project. Their goals: to give Palestinian youth the means to speak for themselves and to be heard outside their own communities.

“You have a new generation of Palestinians growing up who are watching satellite TV, learning different languages,” said Tondre, 36, a producer for KPFA’s Voices of the Middle East program. “They’re getting new ideas about the world. They’re breaking some of the cultural barriers. They have an open tabula rasa about what to do.”

The two East Bay residents, among other international volunteers, are helping Dheisheh youth produce and distribute radio stories through the camp’s Ibdaa Cultural Center. They’re also joining journalists and technicians from Chicago and London in supporting the camp’s new low-power FM radio station, Ibdaa Radio 194.

If licensed by the Palestinian Authority, the station will become the first broadcast media source beaming from a West Bank refugee community.

On the streets: Nora Barrows-Friedman, a KPFA radio producer, follows Rawan, 14, (with microphone) and Haneen, 16, in a field recording class in the Dheisheh refugee camp.

CP-2005-014 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco

Teens’ stories come out of own lives in refugee camp

“These kids are incredible because they’re some of the best journalists I’ve ever seen, and they live in a refugee camp,” said Danny Muller, a volunteer at the camp through Chicago’s Voices in the Wilderness. “They cut through the bull and see the world in an amazing way.”

During her visit to the camp last fall, Barrows-Friedman, the senior producer for KPFA’s Flashpoints program highlighting human-rights abuses around the world, led workshops in radio journalism skills, from developing story ideas, to interviewing, writing narration, sound layering and editing.

With Tondre providing technical help, the camp journalists completed 14 short radio segments. Barrows-Friedman’s connection to the Ibdaa center grew out of aid work she had done in the West Bank through the Middle East Children’s Alliance.

“What Nora and Babak have said is, ‘OK, it’s horrible here, but we believe young people in particular really need to have a vision for the country and what it could be, and we believe this project does just that,’” said Barbara Lubin, the founder and executive director of the alliance. “This is something that gives them real hope.

There’s more to life than just trying to fight off the effects of occupation.” Barrows-Friedman is an outspoken supporter of Palestinian rights, but she said she didn’t influence what the teens had to say. “It was totally spontaneous,” said Barrows-Friedman, 26, who plans to return to the West Bank in September.

“The stories they deal with on a daily basis are the stories that came through in their radio voices. We didn’t have to come from 10,000 miles away to tell them what they already know.” The subject matter the teens chose was overwhelmingly political.

It centered on the naqba, the Arabic term for the expulsion of 750,000 Palestinians to make way for the creation of a Jewish state in 1948. It means “catastrophe” in English.

“Every aspect of these children’s lives is political,” said Ziad Abbas, co-director of the Ibdaa center, “from the moment they are born in a refugee camp, to growing up under occupation, to not being able to go to school because of Israeli military curfews, to witnessing the death and imprisonment of friends and family members.

“It’s impossible to separate the children’s lives from politics because their very existence is a contentious political issue.”

Ansam and Rawan get a lesson on digital editing from Nora Barrows-Friedman at Ibdaa Radio 194 in the Dheisheh refugee camp.

CP-2005-015 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago, IL · page Section 1, page 4

Israelis sweep into West Bank city

Postblast raid comes as Sharon advances withdrawal plans

By Joel Greenberg, Tribune foreign correspondent

JERUSALEM — Israeli forces swept into the West Bank city of Tulkarem on Wednesday, killing a Palestinian police officer in a gunfight and arresting five suspected members of Islamic Jihad after the militant group killed four Israelis in a suicide bombing Tuesday, the army and Palestinians said.

Pressing ahead with preparations for a withdrawal next month from the Gaza Strip, Prime Minister Ariel Sharon signed an order closing Israeli settlements there to non-residents in an effort to block entry by protesters who have vowed to resist the pullout.

The reoccupation of Tulkarem came four months after it was handed back to Palestinian security control as part of steps to bolster a truce. Moves to hand over other West Bank cities were frozen after Tuesday's bombing, Israeli officials said.

A woman and two 16-year-old girls were killed in the attack outside a shopping mall in the coastal city of Netanya, and another woman died of her wounds Wednesday. More than 30 people were wounded in the bombing, carried out by an 18-year-old Palestinian from the village of Attil near Tulkarem.

Islamic Jihad claimed responsibility. 'We will not relent' "I instructed the defense establishment to step up our activity and to hit the leaders of the Islamic Jihad terror organization as much as possible," Sharon said.

Full broadsheet page scan. Folio at top left reads '4 CHICAGO TRIBUNE SECTION 1 MW'; the dateline at top right is cut off by the right edge of the scan and reads only 'THU'. Maria's label of 14 July 2005 (a Thursday) is consistent with the visible 'THU' and with the internal chronology (Netanya mall bombing 'Tuesday', raid 'Wednesday'), but the printed date itself is not readable in this scan. Golan is styled 'Brig. Gen.' here. The page also carries a separate AP story, 'Kidnappers in Gaza free 2 foreign aid workers', which is a different article and is not transcribed in this record. Two photo captions on the page: 'An Israeli soldier patrols Tulkarem in an armored personnel carrier Wednesday. The city was retaken after a suicide attack Tuesday.' (Getty Images photo by Jaafar Ashtiyeh) and 'Israeli police officers scuffle in Jerusalem Wednesday with an anti-pullout protester who pleads not to be arrested. Ariel Sharon, meanwhile, has moved to block protests in Gaza settlements.' (AP photo by Kevin Frayer). Named dead are combatants or unnamed civilians, so named_individuals is empty.

CP-2005-023 →

· The Patriot-News · Harrisburg, PA

Pullout's opponents protest Israeli settlement blockades

BY DANIELLE HAAS, Of The Associated Press

KISSUFIM JUNCTION, Gaza Strip • Israeli troops sealed off a cluster of Gaza Strip settlements marked for evacuation yesterday to stop the influx of hard-line opponents, the government's most sweeping measure yet to prepare for next month's pullout. Settlers responded defiantly, threatening to block roads throughout Israel and to step up other protests.

Also yesterday, Israeli troops reoccupied the northern West Bank town of Tulkarem in response to a suicide bombing that killed four Israeli people in the resort town of Netanya a day earlier. A firefight between Israeli soldiers and Palestinian police in Tulkarem left one police officer dead and a second critically wounded.

Soldiers arrested six people, including the father of the bomber. Palestinian officials strongly condemned the bombing. Palestinian officials, as well as most militant groups, want to maintain calm ahead of Israel's planned withdrawal from the Gaza Strip and four West Bank settlements next month.

In preparation for the pullout, Prime Minister Ariel Sharon ordered the settlements closed to all nonresidents. Residents would still be able to move in and out of the settlements freely, the army said.

Soldiers set up roadblocks at the Kissufim crossing into the Gush Katif cluster of settlements in Gaza to enforce the order, causing a traffic jam of settler cars, army trucks and police vehicles. The soldiers turned away anyone without a residence permit.

See the note on s065_1: the two images on this slide are in the reverse order from Maria's label. This is the Patriot-News item. No masthead, no folio, no printed date on the clipping, so the date is label-only; the internal chronology (Netanya bombing 'a day earlier', Tulkarem reoccupied 'yesterday') is consistent with 14 July 2005. There is no deck. The paper uses a bullet • after the dateline. Golan's Tulkarem quote here differs from the Chicago Tribune's wording on the same day — 'Palestinian Islamic Jihad' not 'Islamic Jihad', 'told Israel's Army Radio' not 'told Army Radio'. The clipping says four Israelis were killed at Netanya; the Chicago Tribune of the same date says four were killed and a fourth woman died of her wounds, giving slightly different arithmetic. Photo caption: 'A Jewish settler scuffles with soldiers yesterday as settlers and protesters block the Kissufim crossing into the Gush Katif bloc of settlements in the southern Gaza Strip.' (BAZ RATNER, The Associated Press). Columns two and three were read at page magnification only; the Sharon, Harel, Sternberg and Ben-Ruby quotes should be re-checked against a crop before any is published.

CP-2005-027 →

· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis

For Washington, the work begins after Israel's withdrawal

BY RON KAMPEAS / JTA

Ron Kampeas on the Gaza disengagement. The standing head frames the summer as Palestinian infighting.

CP-2005-018 →

· Pittsburgh Post-Gazette · Pittsburgh · page E-8

Send in the Gowns

Antiochian museum displays Palestinian wedding dresses

By Rebekah Scott, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

“No matter what the bridal boutique sales lady tells you, a ‘traditional’ wedding gown is not necessarily ruffled, slinky, lacy or even white. In the Middle East region known historically as Palestine, the bridal gown tradition reaches back 2,000 years.

Gowns are black, brown or off-white, or sometimes a brilliant combination of red, orange and hot pink, jingling with silver coins. Like a Scotsman’s tartan, a Palestinian wedding dress tells through color, cut and stitching the wearer’s native region, village and clan.

Hanan Munayyer’s collection of knockout Palestinian bridalwear is on display now in ‘Threads of Tradition: Palestinian Traditional Costumes.’ The show continues through September at the Antiochian Heritage Museum at Antiochian Village Conference and Retreat Center, an Arab-Christian gathering place on Route 711 north of Ligonier.

The Village is unofficial headquarters for a North American diocese of the Antiochian Orthodox Church, an Arab-Christian congregation with roots in what is now Turkey. The antique wedding gowns fit perfectly into the museum’s cultural agenda, said events coordinator Sally Richards, because they show an aspect of daily domestic life in a fast-vanishing culture.

‘It’s surprising to see how many of the kids recognize these clothes from old photos of family members,’ Richards said. Gowns are made of natural-brown or black linen inset or appliquéd silk, embroidered with ancient geometric designs called Bird of Paradise or Tree of Life.

Each town or tribe had its own colors, motifs and techniques; sometimes a coin-covered bridal vest was passed down from bride to bride, a way to ceremonially display the wealth of the entire clan. Up in Haifa, the wedding dresses were white, alive with brilliant red embroidered birds, flowers and vines. Bright red pantaloons peek from under the hem.

Men wove the linen in Ramallah, but the bride and her friends embroidered it for months before the wedding. One black dress from the 1930s has a thickly stitched yoke made in Bethlehem, full of expensive metallic thread — times were good there. But a dress from the 1890s reflects a less than prosperous wedding under Ottoman rule.

The cross-stitching is sparse, but this bride still managed to stand out: the silk embroidery thread is dyed lavender purple, an unusual shade for its time. Elaborately embroidered panels were sometimes cut off a worn-out dress and transplanted onto a new garment, or made over into pillow covers or wall decor.

From Asdud and Majdal come shocking pink fabrics, dyed using the seashell extract that made the area famous in Roman times. A saffeh headdress is lined with heavy silver coins; another headpiece has detachable silver bangles in cross or crescent shapes, so Christian or Muslim brides could choose the suitable symbol.

The bridalwear on display isn’t all glitter and flash. Desert-dwelling Bedouin brides wore huge black gowns with severe geometric insets on the shoulders. There were no low-cut bodices, bustles, trains or tulle. And definitely nothing strapless. Hanan Munayyer isn’t a dress designer. She and her husband are collectors of cultural artifacts.

Both were born in the 1940s in what is now Israel. They grew up in the turbulent days that saw Israel established on land it had held in biblical times. In the millenniums since, the same land was renamed and settled by a rainbow of ethnic groups and religious persuasions collectively.

Munayyer’s collection sidesteps the conflicts that often accompany discussions of the region’s recent history. Her collection stops in the 1940s, she said, just before modern Israel was created in 1948. Mention Fallujah, Ramallah or Gaza to her, and she’ll tell you which type of stitching, silk threads, vegetable dyes were used in each area a century ago.

Both the Munayyers are pharmaceutical researchers in New Jersey and avid collectors of now-vanishing antique gowns and ethnic embroideries.

Since 1987, they’ve accumulated almost 250 costumes and 750 accessories, furnishings, lamps and musical instruments — things younger generations of Palestinians, Lebanese, Syrians or Israelis might not recognize as part of their heritage.

‘Throughout the ’50s and ’60s, everyone was married in white, but now I’m seeing more brides — educated, cosmopolitan women — honoring their roots by wearing some element of traditional attire,’ Munayyer said. ‘I’ve loaned several newer dresses to brides in the U.S. or in Canada.

… And the Palestinian embroidery workshops in Lebanon still are capable of beautiful workmanship.’ Munayyer doesn’t expect a great surge in ethnic wedding attire anytime soon, she said. Headpieces were anchored in the bride’s long, braided tresses, and won’t work with a short haircut.

Heirloom-quality gowns are hard to find, labor-intensive, expensive and heavy. ‘They’re not comfortable to wear, and they’re not very slimming,’ she said. ‘By the time you put on all these layers of clothing, belt, veil, headpiece … even if you’re slim, you look like a tent. A really gorgeous tent.’”

Detail on the arm of a bridal white Ramallah dress (circa 1930s). · The exhibit ‘Threads of Tradition: Palestinian Traditional Costumes’ continues through September at the Antiochian Heritage Museum north of Ligonier. · This bridal costume from Beni Na’im (circa 1930s) has a special headdress and a coined jacket. (V.W.H.

Campbell/Post-Gazette photos)

A Palestinian wedding dress is a map. The sentence that says so is the third one: like a Scotsman’s tartan, it tells through color, cut and stitching the wearer’s native region, village and clan. The article then reads the map — white with red birds in Haifa, linen woven by the men in Ramallah and embroidered by the bride and her friends for months, metallic thread from Bethlehem in the 1930s when times were good there, sparse cross-stitching on an 1890s dress from a poorer wedding under the Ottomans, shocking pink from Asdud and Majdal dyed with the seashell extract the coast was famous for in Roman times. One headdress has detachable silver bangles in cross or crescent shapes, so a Christian or a Muslim bride could pick the symbol she wanted. The collector, Hanan Munayyer, is a pharmaceutical researcher in New Jersey who was born in what is now Israel. Her collection deliberately stops in the 1940s, just before modern Israel was created in 1948 — the villages it maps are the ones that stopped existing, and the way to exhibit them in an American museum is to end before the year they ended.

CP-2005-007 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco · page A17

Leaving Gaza: Israel's plan to shut down the settlements

The Disengagement

Prime Minister Ariel Sharon announced his plan to shut all 21 Jewish settlements in the Gaza Strip and four small settlements in the northern West Bank in 2004, after four years of Israeli-Palestinian confrontation had claimed the lives of more than 3,000 Palestinians and nearly 1,000 Israelis.

The disengagement marks the first time Israel will dismantle Jewish settlements in either the West Bank or Gaza, territories captured by Israel in the 1967 Middle East war and claimed by the Palestinians for a future state.

The disengagement plan, formulated unilaterally by Israel, is unpopular with hard-line politicians in Sharon's Likud Party, who accuse him of caving in to Palestinian violence, and with ultra-Orthodox Jews, who argue the withdrawal ignores Israel's biblical connection to the territory.

Supporters of the plan hope it will revitalize peace efforts between Israel and the Palestinian Authority. What about the Palestinians? The Palestinian Authority has promised a large security deployment for the period of the disengagement.

After it is completed, the 1.3 million Palestinian residents will be able to move freely within the Gaza Strip, but will have to pass through border checks to work in Israel or travel to the West Bank. Israel will continue to control Gaza airspace and all borders.

The Palestinian Authority is seeking Israeli permission to reopen the Gaza airport, which was closed by the Israeli military in 2000. Who's handling evacuations?

About 55,000 Israeli soldiers and police: Security forces will patrol the buffer zones between Palestinian and settler areas, and guard the border between Gaza and Israel. [From the analysis below the map:] Israel is withdrawing from the Gaza Strip, 38 years after capturing the territory in the Six-Day War.

But assuming the mission that begins this week is successful, will it renew the peace process between Israelis and Palestinians? “The Israeli-Palestinian conflict has no neutral gear. You either go forward or backward,” said Lewis Roth, assistant executive director at Americans for Peace Now, a Jewish advocacy group in Washington.

Israel for now is retaining control over Gaza's borders, airspace and water, electricity and gas infrastructure, as well as the flow of goods and people in and out of Gaza. “There is an open-air prison. (Israelis) still control everything regarding the population,” said Michael Tarazi, legal adviser to the Palestinian Authority, in a telephone interview from Tel Aviv.

A full page. An annotated satellite map of the Gaza Strip naming all 21 Jewish settlements with their founding dates and populations, above a news analysis by Chronicle staff writer Jack Epstein headed AFTER GAZA DISENGAGEMENT, THEN WHAT? SPECULATION INTENSIFIES. Map credit: Todd Trumbull / The Chronicle. Sources given as New York Times News Service, satellite image of Gaza Strip captured on June 6 by SPACE IMAGING/INTA-SPACETURK, image of surrounding area by EarthSat, Associated Press, Chronicle research.

CP-2005-010 →

· Bangor Daily News · Bangor · page 1

Settlers resist as Israel completes Gaza pullout

Associated Press

“Abbas said Israel’s unilateral withdrawal was only the first step. ‘Tomorrow they will start leaving part of the West Bank,’ Abbas told a group 400 disabled Palestinians wounded in uprisings against Israel. ‘It’s a beginning of the full withdrawal from all the settlements. We will not close our eyes.

We will not rest until they leave from all our land.’… At Sanur, the most hardline West Bank settlement earmarked for evacuation, young men were welding bars onto the open windows of an old British police structure known as ‘the fortress’… On the roof, settlers flew a hand-painted Israeli flag that was taken from a refugee boat in 1947 that was trying to break the British blockade of pre-independence Israel.

Painted on a sign under the flag: ‘The British didn’t succeed in expelling. And you?’… The 5-year-old daughter of the rabbi put a handful of sand in her purse… Some evacuated settlers set up tent cities on vacant Israeli land near Gaza’s borders, with signs at the perimeters calling them ‘refugee camps.’

Sharon has called the camps a political ploy to create sympathy.”

Jewish settlers remove a Menorah from the synagogue at the Jewish settlement of Netzarim in the Gaza Strip on Monday.

Four hundred Palestinians wounded in the uprisings, assembled as an audience for a speech. They are the population the 1996 lawsuits were filed by, nine years on, and they appear here as a room Abbas is speaking to. On the same page, evacuated settlers pitch tents and call them refugee camps, and the prime minister calls that a ploy.

CP-2005-006 →

· The Morning Call · Allentown

In long run, Gaza disengagement will hurt peace

MICHAEL J. MAKOUL

An Aug. 16 op-ed piece proclaimed Israel's “disengagement” from the Gaza Strip as “a grand gesture” and “historical opportunity” for the Palestinians. However, a careful examination of the facts and circumstances surrounding disengagement paint a much different picture. The biggest threat that the Palestinians present to Israel's security is a demographic one.

By the end of the decade, some believe that Palestinians living between the Jordan River and Mediterranean Sea will outnumber the Jews. In order to maintain a democratic and Jewish state, Israel needs definable boundaries that include the smallest number of Palestinians.

By not taking action on establishing these boundaries, Israel risks apartheid status (a la South Africa), or losing its Jewish character if Palestinians fight for equal rights and citizenship. Given these facts, the withdrawal from Gaza, where 8,500 Israelis lived among 1.3 million Palestinians, was clearly a necessary one for the future of Israel.

While the architect of disengagement, Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, has been praised as “bold and courageous,” he has likely sounded a death knell for the dream of a viable Palestinian state living side-by-side in peace with Israel.

Instead of coordinating the withdrawal from Gaza with Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, Sharon insisted that disengagement be a unilateral action, and that a return to the negotiating table will only occur after Abbas disarms Hamas and other armed militias.

By taking this unilateral action, Sharon has managed to strengthen Hamas, which is taking credit for “driving the enemy out of Gaza.” Now, it will be virtually impossible for Abbas to disarm Hamas without causing anarchy and civil war in the Palestinian street.

It appears that Sharon, who knew how this was going to play out, devised the disengagement plan as a way to kill “The Road Map” for good.

Before launching the disengagement plan, Sharon, in a quid pro quo, received a letter from President Bush that supported Israel's intent to annex large “Jewish population centers” in the West Bank (where the majority of Israel's estimated 280,000 settlers live) as part of any future peace deal with the Palestinians.

In direct violation of the Road Map, Israel has increased the build-up of settlements in the West Bank, especially around Arab East Jerusalem, where it is expected that Palestinians living in the Old City will soon be cut off completely from the West Bank.

In recent interviews, Sharon has confirmed that the status of Jerusalem is not subject to negotiation and that settlement blocs in the West Bank will forever be a part of Israel. If disengagement is played out according to Sharon's plan, the Palestinian hopes of living in a viable, contiguous state with East Jerusalem as its capital have been dashed.

With recent news footage from Gaza displaying traumatic scenes of Israeli soldiers dragging women and children from their homes and synagogues, some will say that I am being unfair to Sharon, or too pessimistic.

However, it must be pointed out that much of the resistance to the Gaza withdrawal was not actually carried out by the settlers, but by extremists who entered Gaza from Israel to protest the withdrawal and win sympathy from around the world.

It must also be pointed out that the occupation of Gaza (like the West Bank and Golan Heights) is in violation of multiple United Nations resolutions and the settlements are illegal under international law.

Further, the dismantling of settlements and withdrawal from Gaza does not officially end Israel's occupation of Gaza since Israel has not yet agreed to give up control of Gaza's border crossing, air space, and sea ports.

Without freedom of movement in and out of Gaza, there is little hope that the quality of life for Palestinians living in Gaza will be significantly improved, or that Palestinian violence towards Israel will abate. While disengagement from Gaza might be viewed as a necessary step for Israel, it is by no means a “grand gesture” toward the Palestinians.

From the Palestinian perspective, withdrawal from Gaza without freedom of movement and a larger withdrawal from the West Bank and East Jerusalem is virtually meaningless. Not only does disengagement do little to help the Palestinians in the short term, but it simultaneously hurts chances for a genuine peace in the long term.

A reader's op-ed, answering an op-ed the paper had run on 16 August. The tagline reads: Michael J. Makoul of Upper Macungie Township is a certified public accountant and a certified fraud examiner.

CP-2005-009 →

· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis

Palestinian 'Authority' A Total Oxymoron

“If one wanted to come up with a 21st century example of the definition of an ‘oxymoron,’ an expression that conjoins contradictory terms, one might suggest ‘Palestinian Authority.’”

An editorial board building its argument out of a word game about whether Palestinians can hold authority.

CP-2005-019 →

· The Capital Times · Madison

Palestinian embroidery renaissance

Al-Tatreez, the art of Palestinian embroidery, is currently enjoying a renaissance. The color combinations of the thread, and design and color of the cloth, have historically reflected the region where the embroidery was made and the status of the person owning or wearing the item.

Starting today, embroidered handicrafts, including shawls, tapestries, table runners and purses, will be displayed in gallery space at The Casbah Mediterranean Restaurant & Lounge, 119 E. Main St. The items are available for purchase, with proceeds benefiting the Madison-Rafah Women’s Fund, a venture of the Madison-Rafah Sister City Project.

A gallery opening, with Arabic dancing, music and hors d’oeuvres, runs tonight from 5-11 p.m. A donation of $10 for the Women’s Fund is suggested.

CP-2005-020 →

· The Journal News · White Plains · page 1

The making of a human bomb

‘Paradise’ paints a compelling portrait of two ordinary guys turned mass killers

Kevin Canfield, The Journal News

“Said and Khaled are best friends. Boyish young men in their 20s, they live at home with their parents and share meals with siblings and friends.

They work together at an automobile repair shop, but you get the sense that like lots of others their age they haven’t quite decided what to do with their lives. In short, they’re very much like you or someone you know.

Except for this: They’re Palestinian suicide bombers in waiting. The protagonists of the brilliant new film ‘Paradise Now,’ Said (Kais Nashef) and Khaled (Ali Suliman) are ordinary men in an extraordinary situation and their sheer averageness makes director Hany Abu-Assad’s film a compelling portrait. The carnage these men are about to set in motion, like the branch of zero-sum militancy they subscribe to, is loathsome.

But as humans they are not loathsome, and that disconnect, that raising-of-questions, is the stuff of great art.… (Hamas, the Palestinian organization responsible for many such suicide bombings is never mentioned by name, but the implication is clear.)… In one of the film’s many emotionally resonant scenes, Said silently watches his mother chop vegetables.

He wants to speak but can’t. Khaled, whose father was badly injured by Israeli soldiers, is certain he’s doing the right thing — ‘Now it’s our turn,’ he says gleefully — but Said is clearly spooked, equally afraid of dying and murdering innocents.

Later that night he will sneak out for a final, chaste visit with the woman he seems to be in love with. Her late father was also a bomber, complicating his feelings all the more… Abu-Assad knows exactly what he’s doing.

By portraying Khaled and Said as unimpeachably normal, even likable, young men, he argues that moments in history make men — that any of us, or at least many of us, would act irrationally were we raised in similar straits.

This is a terribly unsophisticated argument, one that seems to suggest a given person’s makeup is all nurture and no nature. Coexistence, of course, isn’t merely a matter of seeing one another as human. But maybe that’s a start? Rating PG-13 (mature thematic material and brief strong language). Running time 90 minutes. Bottomline A-.”

“Ali Suliman and Kais Nashef in director Hany Abu-Assad’s ‘Paradise Now.’” · Seamus Murphy / Warner Independent Pictures

An A-minus review that calls the film brilliant and then objects to the thing it does. Showing two Palestinians as unimpeachably normal is, the reviewer writes, a terribly unsophisticated argument. The scene he singles out as most affecting is a young man watching his mother chop vegetables. Nine years later this archive holds the same director in the Los Angeles Times insisting his next film is not about the conflict, and an American paper filing a Palestinian screenwriter under the label CONFLICT seven months after that.

CP-2005-003 →

· Newsday · Melville · page 1

A Mideast ‘Paradise’ apocalypse

Gene Seymour, Staff Writer

“PARADISE NOW (PG-13). Two Palestinians (Kais Nashef, Ali Suliman), friends since childhood, agree to carry out a suicide bombing in Tel Aviv. Director Hany Abu-Assad’s hyper-realist film is provocative, chilling and tense, even after it’s over. With Lubna Azabal and Amer Hlehel. 1:30 (some vulgarisms). In Arabic with English subtitles.

At select theaters… ‘Paradise Now’ walks a narrow tightrope in trying to make sense out of what many regard as senseless behavior.

Even making the film required the nerves of a high-wire artist. It was shot in the West Bank city of Nablus where director Hany Abu-Assad had to deal with both the Israeli army and Palestinian citizens. However tense the filmmaking process was, it could scarcely be any more wrenching than the story being told.

It’s about Saïd (Kais Nashef) and Khaled (Ali Suliman), who have been friends since childhood, growing up as Palestinians under Israeli occupation. They work as auto mechanics for low wages, filling the empty hours between shifts smoking a hookah and drinking tea.

Their lives seem so numbingly nonextraordinary that it’s hard for anyone, especially them, to imagine what could give such lives meaning. Maybe it’s the pretty young customer (Lubna Azabal) who’s attracted to Saïd on first sight.

But before he and she can get to know each other better, a professorial-looking man named Jamal (Amer Hlehel) offers Saïd and Khaled a chance to carry out a suicide bombing attack in Tel Aviv… The movie weaves debate over tactics, ideology, belief and existence into the airtight framework of the plot.

If Abu-Assad is a high-wire walker with the movie’s issues, he also shows a safecracker’s poise with building tension and teasing suspense. As a visceral experience, ‘Paradise Now’ chills and absorbs, wearing down one’s resistance to its subject matter. It is in no way an apologia for terrorism.

But it’s a character study that subtly nudges the viewer toward greater understanding.”

“Kais Nashef as Saïd and Hiam Abbass as Saïd’s mother in director Hany Abu-Assad’s ‘Paradise Now’”

The second American review of this film in the archive, printed the day after the first, and both reviewers feel obliged to take a position on the same thing. One calls showing Palestinians as unimpeachably normal a terribly unsophisticated argument. This one assures readers the film is in no way an apologia for terrorism. Six Palestinian actors are named between the two notices, including Hiam Abbass, who plays the mother.

CP-2005-004 →

· The Mobile Register · Mobile, AL · page 21A

Israeli missile aimed at Jihad kills 7 people

Ariel Sharon shuns Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas, signaling failed peacemaking

By KARIN LAUB, Associated Press Writer

JERUSALEM — Israel killed seven Palestinians in a missile strike Thursday against Islamic Jihad, and Prime Minister Ariel Sharon said he would not meet with the Palestinian leader until he cracks down on armed groups — a double-edged Israeli response to the latest suicide bombing.

Sharon threatened a "broad and relentless" offensive against Palestinian militants, including mass arrests and airstrikes, but security officials said Israel would stop short of a large-scale military operation.

Sharon's decision to shun Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas was the clearest signal yet that efforts to revive peacemaking after Israel's pullout from the Gaza Strip last month have run aground. Abbas has said he cannot and will not confront militants, fearing civil war, but it's unlikely progress can be made unless the two leaders meet.

The international community has been pressing for a quick Israeli-Palestinian agreement on new security arrangements for Gaza's borders, and a continued deadlock over such issues will prevent the economic recovery of impoverished Gaza. That, in turn, could hurt Abbas' chances in parliamentary elections in January.

Folio reads 'Friday, October 28, 2005 MOBILE REGISTER 21A'; 28 Oct 2005 was a Friday, matching Maria's label. Yair Golan appears late in the story: 'West Bank commander Brig. Gen. Yair Golan said Izzedine, considered as a political leader, was arrested because he had ties to Islamic Jihad's military wing' — i.e. Golan on the record justifying the arrest of a man the paper itself calls a political leader. The arrested man is named earlier as Abdel Halim Izzedine, an Islamic Jihad leader in Jenin. Photo caption: 'Two Palestinians comfort each other at the Kamal Edwan hospital in Beit Lahiya, northern Gaza Strip, on Thursday after an Israeli missile attack killed seven in the nearby Jebaliya refugee camp. The Islamic Jihad on Wednesday carried out its fourth suicide attack against Israel since Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas negotiated a truce deal with Palestinian groups in February.' (HATEM MOUSSA/Associated Press). Headline photograph credit shows a Palestinian photographer. Excerpt stops at a complete sentence partway down column one; the remaining columns cover the Jabaliya strike, Islamic Jihad's reply and the Jenin arrests.

CP-2005-025 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago, IL

Israeli soldier, Arab militant die in raids

Citing strikes, Hamas says it won't renew 'period of calm'

By Joel Greenberg, Tribune foreign correspondent

JERUSALEM — An Israeli soldier and a Palestinian militant were killed in separate army raids in the West Bank on Wednesday, and Hamas warned after the killing of one of its operatives Tuesday that it would not renew a cease-fire due to expire at the end of the year.

More than a week of violence has severely shaken the truce and dimmed hopes for a revival of peace efforts after Israel's withdrawal from the Gaza Strip in September. Israeli raids and air strikes have killed 15 Palestinians, both militants and civilians, after a Palestinian suicide bombing that killed five Israelis.

The militant Islamic Jihad group said the bombing was revenge for Israel's killing of one of its West Bank commanders. On Wednesday the first Israeli soldier was killed in action since the Gaza withdrawal. Staff Sgt. Yonatan Evron, 20, was shot during the arrest of a Hamas militant at a house in the village of Marka near Jenin in the northern West Bank, the army said. Brig.

Gen. Yair Golan, commander of Israeli forces in the West Bank, said that after the militant was taken into custody, a gunman opened fire at troops surrounding the house, killing the soldier. In another army raid near Jenin in the town of Qabatiyeh, soldiers exchanged fire with Palestinian gunmen, killing Rafat Turkman, 22, from the militant Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades.

Clipped column, not a full page. Dateline strip above the headline reads 'THURSDAY NOVEMBER 3, 2005', which matches Maria's label (3 Nov 2005 was a Thursday). The paper's own name does not appear on the clipping; attribution to the Chicago Tribune rests on the credit line 'Tribune foreign correspondent' and the sign-off 'jogreenberg@tribune.com'. Golan is 'Brig. Gen.' here, as on 14 July. Photo caption at foot: 'Israeli artillery fires into the Gaza Strip on Wednesday. Rocket fire at Israel from Gaza also has resumed, jeopardizing the truce.' (AP photo by Kevin Frayer). The two named dead, Staff Sgt. Yonatan Evron and Rafat Turkman, are a soldier and a man the paper identifies as a militant, so neither is recorded as an ordinary individual.

CP-2005-024 →

· The Boston Globe · Boston, MA

2 killed in raids in West Bank

Hamas refuses cease-fire renewal

By Joel Greenberg, CHICAGO TRIBUNE

JERUSALEM — An Israeli soldier and a Palestinian militant were killed yesterday in separate army raids in the West Bank, and Hamas warned after the killing of one of its operatives Tuesday that it would not renew a cease-fire due to expire at the end of the year.

More than a week of violence has severely shaken the truce and dimmed hopes for a revival of peace efforts after Israel's withdrawal from the Gaza Strip in September. Israeli raids and airstrikes have killed 15 Palestinians — militants as well as civilians — after a Palestinian suicide bombing that killed five Israelis.

The militant Islamic Jihad group said the bombing was revenge for Israel's killing of one of its West Bank commanders. A 20-year-old soldier fatally shot yesterday was the first Israeli serviceman killed in action since the Gaza withdrawal.

Staff Sergeant Yonatan Evron was killed during the arrest of a Hamas militant at a house in the village of Marka in the northern West Bank, the army said. Brigadier General Yair Golan, commander of Israeli forces in the West Bank, said that after the militant was taken into custody, a gunman opened fire at troops surrounding the house, killing the soldier.

In another army raid near Jenin in the town of Kabatiya, soldiers exchanged fire with Palestinian gunmen, killing Raafat Turkman, 22, of the militant Al Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades. The army said troops had shot three gunmen who fired on them.

LABEL ORDER: Maria's note for slide 76-style ordering lists slide 65 as 'The Patriot News July 14 2005' then 'The Boston Globe Nov 3 2005', but image s065_1 is the BOSTON GLOBE and s065_2 is the Patriot-News piece. The images are in the reverse order from the label. Masthead line reads 'THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 3, 2005 THE BOSTON GLOBE'; 3 Nov 2005 was a Thursday, so the date is verified. IMPORTANT WIRE-COPY FINDING: this is Joel Greenberg's Chicago Tribune dispatch, the same copy as s062_2, but the Globe re-edited it. Where the Tribune printed 'Brig. Gen. Yair Golan' the Globe prints 'Brigadier General Yair Golan'; 'Qabatiyeh' becomes 'Kabatiya'; 'Rafat Turkman' becomes 'Raafat Turkman'; 'Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades' gains an apostrophe, 'Al Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades'; 'air strikes' becomes 'airstrikes'; 'on Wednesday' becomes 'yesterday'; and the Globe recasts the soldier's death to lead with his age. Nothing in the Palestinian spokesman's quote changes. Photo caption: 'Palestinian mourners carried the body of Fawzie Abo al Qarea, a top Hamas operative, during his funeral yesterday in the refugee camp of Jabaliya in the northern Gaza Strip. He was killed Tuesday in an Israeli airstrike.' (ALI ALI/EUROPEAN PRESSPHOTO AGENCY). Most of the page is taken up by a 'SUMMER BRITE' toothpaste advertisement, which is not part of the article.

CP-2005-026 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore, MD

Israeli soldier, Palestinian militant killed

Hamas says it will not renew cease-fire at the end of the year

BY JOEL GREENBERG

JERUSALEM // An Israeli soldier and a Palestinian militant were killed in separate army raids in the West Bank yesterday, and Hamas warned after the killing of one of its operatives Tuesday that it would not renew a cease-fire due to expire at the end of the year.

More than a week of violence has severely shaken the truce and dimmed hopes for a revival of peace efforts after Israel's withdrawal from the Gaza Strip in September. Israeli raids and airstrikes have killed 15 Palestinians — militants and civilians — after a Palestinian suicide bombing Oct. 26 that killed five Israelis.

The militant Islamic Jihad group said the bombing was revenge for Israel's killing of one of its West Bank commanders. Yesterday, the first Israeli serviceman was killed in action since the Gaza withdrawal. The soldier, Staff Sgt.

Yonatan Evron, 20, was fatally shot during the arrest of a Hamas militant at a house in the village of Marka-near Jenin in the northern West Bank, the army said. Brig. Gen. Yair Golan, the commander of Israeli forces in the West Bank, said that after the militant was taken into custody, a gunman opened fire at troops surrounding the house, killing the soldier.

In another army raid near Jenin in the town of Kabatiya, soldiers exchanged fire with Palestinian gunmen, killing Raafat Turkman, 22, from the militant Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades. The army said troops had shot three gunmen who fired on them.

Clipped article, no masthead, no folio, no printed date, so the date is label-only; the internal chronology matches 3 Nov 2005 and matches the Boston Globe clipping of the same dispatch on slide 65. The large block set 'HAMAS SPOKESMAN / "IT REMAINS A ONE-SIDED CALM. ... NO ONE SHOULD DREAM ANOTHER CALM IS COMING."' is a PULL QUOTE, not a deck; the deck is the single line 'Hamas says it will not renew cease-fire at the end of the year'. The byline carries no paper credit on this clipping, although Greenberg writes for the Chicago Tribune; the article's tagline at the end of column four reads 'Joel Greenberg writes for the Chicago Tribune.' WIRE-COPY DIVERGENCE: the Sun follows the Globe on 'Kabatiya' and 'Raafat Turkman' but follows the Tribune on 'Brig. Gen.' and on 'Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades' without an apostrophe; it alone adds the date 'Oct. 26' for the suicide bombing and alone uses the double slash '//' after the dateline. PRINTER'S ERROR PRESERVED: the clipping sets 'the village of Marka-near Jenin', with a hyphen left in from a line break; transcribed as printed. Right-hand half of the clipping is taken up by an advertisement.

CP-2005-028 →

· The Franklin Journal and Farmington Chronicle

Women in Black International conference discussed Nov. 8

FARMINGTON - University of Maine at Farmington assistant professor of English and Women’s Studies, Lee Sharkey will offer a presentation on her experience at the August 2005 Women in Black International Conference in Jerusalem - a conference which drew 750 women peace activists from 44 countries to discuss issues they confront, propose strategies of resistance, and strengthen international feminist alliances.

The presentation - a narrative, through journal entries, audio recordings, photos, and poems - will be held at 7 p.m. on Tuesday, Nov. 8, on the UMF campus in Ricker Hall.

The Women in Black International Conference focused on the work Palestinian and Israeli women and their allies in other countries are doing in coalition to end the occupation of the West Bank and bring about a just settlement of the Palestinian/Israeli conflict.

Though jointly organized by women on both sides of the divide, the conference demonstrated that coalition work is rarely without points of tension.

Professor Sharkey was among the cohort of women welcomed by conference organizer Gila Svirsky in Jerusalem: “My sisters...We are part of a broad movement across the globe that rejects war, violence, economic injustice, environmental destruction, racism, homophobia, and intolerance towards each other...We are everywhere, and our cumulative work will change the world.”

During a visit to the West Bank, in which the international visitors were guests of the General Union of Palestinian Women and participated in a non-violent confrontation with the Israeli Defense Forces in the village of Bil’in, Sharkey experienced those tensions herself.

“Our Palestinian hosts’ vision of the purpose of the day,” she reflected, “turned out to be quite different from our own.”

Lieve Snellings photo. Awareness: Friday afternoon Women in Black vigil at Hagar Square, Jerusalem. The signs read “Stop the Occupation” in Arabic, Hebrew, and English.

CP-2005-012 →

· The Selma Times-Journal · Selma · page 1

‘Paradise’ examines terrorists

CHICAGO — “From the most unexpected place, comes a bold new call for peace.” That’s the rosy-eyed, punctuation-challenged poster slogan for “Paradise Now,” a suspense-filled character study of two Palestinian suicide bombers.

But that’s not how writer-director Hany Abu-Assad sees his movie. “Honestly, it’s not my interpretation,” the 44-year-old filmmaker said while in Chicago recently. “My principle is film is for others. When you make it, others have the right to find in it what they think they find in it.

It’s impossible to force your idea.”… Abu-Assad, who was born in Nazareth but has lived for many years in Amsterdam, has an open face and a laugh that operates like a comical shrug, as if to say: What can you do?… The production was squeezed between Israeli checkpoints (and missiles) on one side and rival Palestinian factions, some suspicious that the film would criticize suicide bombers, on the other.

Eventually, one of these factions kidnapped the movie’s location manager, and Abu-Assad wound up contacting Yasser Arafat to negotiate his release.

When a landmine exploded 300 feet from the set, the production finally moved to Nazareth. Looking back, Abu-Assad said he’s not sure he would make “Paradise Now” again, knowing the circumstances. “I don’t want to complain, but really I don’t sleep well anymore,” he said.

“It’s a difficult experience to live five months in such stress in order to make this film.” He’s not ambiguous about blaming the Israeli army for those conditions. “When you are controlling the borders, you are making a big jail, and the people who are making this jail are responsible for the inside chaos,” he said. Let there be no confusion: “Paradise Now” is the work of a filmmaker who, like many Palestinians, rejects the legitimacy of Israel not only from its 1967 borders but as it was conceived in 1948.

Abu-Assad contends that peace will come only when Jews and Palestinians are sharing the entire country equally. “Paradise Now” is about the Palestinian characters debating violence vs. non-violence, despair vs. positive action.

It’s a debate that, Abu-Assad said, is a constant in Palestinian life… Abu-Assad said he focused on suicide bombers “because we know nothing about them — they have no face.” You have to give them their face. You have to understand them in order to know what’s the problem.

For me the unknown, the dark, is more scary than to give light and to make something invisible visible.’

“Lubna Azabal, left, as Suha and Kais Nashef as Said in director Hany Abu-Assad’s ‘Paradise Now,’ a Warner Independent Pictures release.” Pull quote: “I don’t sleep well anymore.” — Hany Abu-Assad, Filmmaker

The headline calls the film an examination of terrorists. The director, given the length of an interview, says the opposite: that he made it because we know nothing about these men and they have no face, and that the unknown frightens him more than making something invisible visible. The clipping stays whole: it also reports that he rejects Israel’s legitimacy as conceived in 1948, and that a faction kidnapped his location manager so that he had to ask Arafat to get the man back. Nine years later the same director tells the Los Angeles Times that his next film is not about the conflict.

CP-2005-005 →

· Staten Island Advance · Staten Island · page 1

Gazans pass through first Palestinian-run border

Border open for only four hours

Ibrahim Barzak, The Associated Press, Rafah Terminal

RAFAH TERMINAL, Gaza Strip — It was a smooth debut Saturday for the first Palestinian-run border. Hundreds of travelers zipped through passport control without having to submit to Israeli security checks, savoring their new freedom after 38 years of military occupation… Under a U.S.-brokered deal, the Palestinians are in charge, with backup from European monitors.

Israel watches over closed-circuit TV, but cannot veto travelers. Jihad Zanoun, 30, a government employee, was the first to cross.

“It is the beginning of a new era that will open a new horizon for me,” said Zanoun, who was visiting relatives in Egypt. The border was open for just four hours Saturday — a day after Palestinians took control with an inauguration ceremony — to give European monitors more time to settle in, but it will eventually operate around the clock.

European officials said 1,587 people crossed on the first day. “We are extremely happy,” said Cristina Gallach, spokeswoman for European Union foreign policy chief Javier Solana. “It has gone very smoothly.”

For fenced-in Gazans, the opening of the border between Gaza and Egypt marked the most dramatic improvement in their lives since Israel withdrew from the coastal strip in September. Before the pullout, Israelis security checks at Rafah — meant to stop militants and weapons smuggling — often caused delays of hours or days.

During the last five years of fighting, Israel also imposed travel restrictions on the ages of 18-45, and most couldn’t leave.

The first man through a border his own government ran. The photograph beside him shows a Palestinian traveler shouting as she protests the four-hour opening. The Chronicle Tribune carried the same dispatch as “First Palestinian-run border opens.” Photo credit: Amr Nabil / The Associated Press.

CP-2005-002 →

· USA Today · McLean, VA · page 9A

Islamic Jihad leader lives to fight holy war

Israel targets members of militant faction

By Matthew Gutman, USA TODAY

TULKAREM REFUGEE CAMP, West Bank — Imad Abu Diab knows he is a dead man. Two assassination attempts he blames on the Israeli army have left him a patchwork of platinum rods and skin grafts. Of 40 wanted Islamic Jihad militants who lived in this refugee camp five years ago, only three have survived the fighting between Israel and the Palestinians.

Abu Diab, 28, an Islamic Jihad leader, is one of them. Israel declared open season on Islamic Jihad in the West Bank after the Iranian-backed group claimed responsibility for four suicide attacks in Israel. In a raid last week in Jenin, Israeli forces captured Iyad Abu el-Roub, a senior Islamic Jihad commander in the northern West Bank, Israel said.

On Sunday, Israeli jets retaliating for missile attacks bombed targets in Gaza, including an Islamic Jihad charity. The Israeli military said the charity disbursed payments to the families of dead terrorists. Frail and sallow-cheeked, Abu Diab barely mourns the loss of so many fighters. "There are more important things than living," he says.

Folio reads 'USA TODAY · MONDAY, DECEMBER 5, 2005 · 9A'; 5 Dec 2005 was a Monday, so date and page are verified. LABEL ORDER: see the note on s067_1 — the two images on this slide are in the reverse order from Maria's label. 'World' above the headline is a SECTION FLAG, not a deck; the deck is the stacked 'Israel targets members of militant faction' in the first column. This is the most Palestinian-voiced clipping in the batch: the reporter goes into Tulkarem refugee camp, spends an hour at a safe house, names and ages a Palestinian man, records his injuries, his daughter, his brothers in prison, and lets him speak five times. Golan appears only as the source of a troop-strength estimate and is not quoted. Two photo captions: 'Attack in Gaza: Palestinian police inspect damage to the building of an Islamic Jihad charity after a missile attack Sunday. The Israeli military said the charity disbursed payments to the families of dead terrorists.' (By Mohammed Salem, Reuters) and 'Remembering fallen comrades: Palestinian youths pray Nov. 2 in Qabatiya, West Bank, beside the graves of Islamic Jihad militants Arshad Abu Zaid and Jihad Zakarneh. The two men were killed by Israeli troops on Oct. 30.' (By Abed Omar Qusini, Reuters). The clipping is pasted over part of an unrelated page about Flight 19 and the Bermuda Triangle, which is not part of this article. Columns three and four were read at page magnification except where a crop is noted above. Casualty totals as printed, verified from a crop: the conflict 'began in September 2000 and claimed the lives of about 1,000 Israelis and more than 3,700 Palestinians'.

CP-2005-029 →

· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis, MO

UN Palestinian groups OK’d

Compiled from JTA reports

The U.N. General Assembly passed a series of resolutions widely seen as anti-Israel. The body passed its annual resolutions Thursday extending the mandates of the so-called Palestinian committees, which support the Palestinians’ agenda at the United Nations.

A four-line news brief, complete as shown — the whole item is transcribed above. No Palestinian is named or quoted; the Palestinian committees are ‘so-called’ and the resolutions are ‘widely seen as anti-Israel’ with no attribution for who sees them that way. Nothing to do with Ofer Winter despite the slide grouping.

CP-2005-022 →

· The Grand Rapids Press · Grand Rapids · page 1

Mind-set of suicide bombers covered in Globe-winning film

Not all Palestinians, Israelis appreciate effort

Ali Daraghmeh, The Associated Press, Nablus

NABLUS, West Bank — The Palestinian film “Paradise Now,” which explores the lives of a pair of suicide bombers and just won the Golden Globe for best foreign film, is getting mixed reviews in this tough West Bank city where it was filmed.

Although the film has never been screened in Nablus, many residents here have viewed several clips widely broadcast on satellite television, and some are not happy with what they have seen. Those giving the film thumbs down feel it portrays the bombers as less than heroic and godless.

“This movie doesn’t help the Palestinian cause,” said an armed Palestinian militant who would not give his name.

“People who go to carry out bombings do not hesitate so much.”… The movie generally has been praised around the world and has been shown in about 60 countries, according to director Hany Abu-Assad, an Arab born in Israel — currently living in Holland — who considers himself Palestinian. Speaking during the glitzy Golden Globes ceremony Monday, Abu-Assad said he believed the film’s success stemmed from the world’s recognition the Palestinians deserve “liberty and equality unconditionally.” The announcement at the ceremony that the award was going to Abu-Assad from Palestine ruffled some feathers in Israel and elsewhere, since Palestinians do not yet have a state.

Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman Mark Regev said it was incorrect to refer to a Palestine before a Palestinian state has been established. “There is a Palestinian Authority, but not a Palestinian state,” Regev said. Official origin notwithstanding, Abu-Assad worked closely with Israelis and Palestinians and filmed the movie on both sides of the divide.

Most of the movie was shot in Nablus, a militant stronghold and the home base of many of the suicide bombers sent to attack Israeli targets in recent years. The conflict served as a constant backdrop for the film, which showed houses demolished in Israeli army operations, the sound of airstrikes against Palestinian militants and large crowds waiting at army roadblocks.

The violence even interrupted filming — once when Israel carried out a missile strike at militants near the camera crew and once when militants briefly kidnapped a cameraman in an effort to stop the filming of a movie they believed would portray them in a negative light. Filming was moved to an Israeli Arab city to avoid further interruptions.

“Trophy time: Hany Abu-Assad, the writer and director of ‘Paradise Now,’ accepts the Golden Globe Award for foreign language film at the Golden Globe Awards on Monday in Beverly Hills, Calif.” · AP Photo

A government objecting to a word spoken at an awards ceremony. The Globes announced the winner as coming from Palestine, and Israel’s foreign ministry spokesman told reporters that was incorrect because there is a Palestinian Authority and not a Palestinian state. The piece is filed from Nablus by a Palestinian Associated Press reporter, and it also reports that Palestinians there disliked the film — for the opposite reason to the American reviewers in this archive, because it made the bombers hesitate. On the same page, a grid of critics’ picks for twenty-three current films does not list it.

CP-2006-006 →

· The Blade · Toledo

Bush: U.S. won’t deal with advocate of Israel’s destruction

WASHINGTON — Stunned by Hamas’ decisive election victory, President Bush said yesterday the United States will not deal with the militant Palestinian group as long as it seeks Israel’s destruction. “If your platform is the destruction of Israel it means you’re not a partner in peace,” the President said.

“And we’re interested in peace.” He urged Hamas to reverse course. Hamas has taken responsibility for dozens of suicide attacks on Israel over the last five years but has largely observed a cease-fire since the election of Fatah leader Mahmoud Abbas as Palestinian president last year. Mr.

Bush left open the possibility of cutting off U.S. aid to the Palestinians. That was echoed by a nonbinding Senate resolution condemning Hamas and expressing support for halting assistance to the Palestinian government, of which the United States is providing $150 million for development this year. The symbolic resolution, crafted by U.S. Sen.

John Thune (R., S.D.) says aid should be ended if the party controlling the Palestinian parliament advocates the destruction of Israel, as Hamas does. It was unclear when the Senate would vote on the proposal. Mr. Bush also called on Mr. Abbas, a U.S. ally, to remain in office despite Fatah’s defeat by Hamas in parliamentary elections. Mr.

Abbas, elected separately a year ago, said he was committed to negotiations with Israel and suggested talks would be conducted through the Palestine Liberation Organization, a possible way around a Hamas-led government.

“A political party that articulates the destruction of Israel as part of its platform is a party with which we will not deal,” he said at a White House news conference. Washington was shocked by Hamas’ landslide victory. U.S. Sen.

Lindsey Graham (R., S.C.) called it “a de-facto declaration of war by the Palestinian people against the state of Israel.” U.S. Rep. Nita Lowey (D., N.Y.) said the outcome was “very disturbing” and Hamas needed to disarm, denounce violence, and recognize Israel’s right to exist.

Fatah supporters gesture to the crowd from windows broken by stones at the Palestinian parliament building in Ramallah.

CP-2006-014 →

· The Daily Press · Newport News

Hamas victory surprises White House, Congress

President Bush says the militant Palestinian group must renounce its call for Israel’s destruction.

WASHINGTON — Stunned by Hamas’ decisive election victory, President Bush said Thursday the United States will not deal with the militant Palestinian group as long as it seeks Israel’s destruction. “If your platform is the destruction of Israel it means you’re not a partner in peace,” the president said.

“And we’re interested in peace.” He urged Hamas to reverse course. Hamas has taken responsibility for dozens of suicide attacks on Israel over the past five years but has largely observed a cease-fire since the election of Fatah leader Mahmoud Abbas as Palestinian president last year. Bush left open the possibility of cutting off U.S. aid to the Palestinians.

That was echoed by a nonbinding Senate resolution condemning Hamas and expressing support for halting assistance to the Palestinian government, of which the U.S. is providing $150 million for development this year. The symbolic resolution, crafted by Sen.

John Thune, R-S.D., says aid should be ended if the party controlling the Palestinian parliament advocates the destruction of Israel, as Hamas does. It was unclear when the Senate would vote on the proposal. Bush also called on Abbas, a U.S. ally, to remain in office despite Fatah’s defeat by Hamas in parliamentary elections.

Abbas, elected separately a year ago, said he was committed to negotiations with Israel and suggested talks would be conducted through the Palestine Liberation Organization, a possible way around a Hamas-led government.

“A political party that articulates the destruction of Israel as part of its platform is a party with which we will not deal,” Bush said at a White House news conference. But he also said, “Peace is never dead because people want peace.” Washington was shocked by Hamas’ landslide victory. Sen.

Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., called it “a de facto declaration of war by the Palestinian people against the state of Israel.” Rep. Nita Lowey, D-N.Y., said the outcome was “very disturbing” and Hamas needed to disarm, denounce violence and recognize Israel’s right to exist.

Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, R-Tenn., said the election “casts a serious shadow over the prospects for peace.” The administration scrambled for a diplomatic response.

The White House found it difficult to criticize the results — as distasteful as they were for the United States — since Bush himself has led the charge for spreading democracy and freedom across the Middle East. “When you give people the vote, you give people a chance to express themselves at the polls,” Bush said.

“And if they’re unhappy with the status quo, they’ll let you know. That’s the great thing about democracy.” It’s not the first time Bush has faced obstacles in dealing with Palestinians. He refused to meet or talk with the late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat and dealt with Abbas and others instead.

Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice held a conference call Thursday with other international sponsors of a plan to draw Israelis and Palestinians back to the peace table. She also talked with Abbas and the Israeli foreign minister, Tzipi Livni. Rice will travel to Europe for further consultations Monday.

“You cannot have one foot in politics and another in terror,” Rice told the World Economic Conference in Davos, Switzerland, via a telephone hookup from the State Department. “Our position on Hamas has therefore not changed.”

CP-2006-015 →

· The Morning Herald

Bush: U.S. won’t deal with Hamas if it threatens Israel

WASHINGTON (AP) — Stunned by Hamas’ decisive election victory, President Bush said Thursday the United States will not deal with the militant Palestinian group as long as it seeks Israel’s destruction. “If your platform is the destruction of Israel it means you’re not a partner in peace,” the president said.

“And we’re interested in peace.” He urged Hamas to reverse course. Hamas has taken responsibility for dozens of suicide attacks on Israel over the past five years but has largely observed a cease-fire since the election of Fatah leader Mahmoud Abbas as Palestinian president last year. Bush left open the possibility of cutting off U.S. aid to the Palestinians.

That was echoed by a nonbinding Senate resolution condemning Hamas and expressing support for halting assistance to the Palestinian government, of which the U.S. is providing $150 million for development this year. The symbolic resolution, crafted by Sen.

John Thune, R-S.D., says aid should be ended if the party controlling the Palestinian parliament advocates the destruction of Israel, as Hamas does. It was unclear when the Senate would vote on the proposal.

House Speaker Dennis Hastert, R-Ill., issued a similar hint, saying, “Hamas has shown that it prefers terrorism against innocent civilians to pursue its political aims, and the United States should play no role in assisting a majority terrorist parliament.”

Bush also called on Abbas, a U.S. ally, to remain in office despite Fatah’s defeat by Hamas in parliamentary elections. Abbas, elected separately a year ago, said he was committed to negotiations with Israel and suggested talks would be conducted through the Palestine Liberation Organization, a possible way around a Hamas-led government.

“A political party that articulates the destruction of Israel as part of its platform is a party with which we will not deal,” he said at a White House news conference. But he also said, “Peace is never dead because people want peace.” Washington was shocked by Hamas’ landslide victory. Sen.

Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., called it “a de-facto declaration of war by the Palestinian people against the state of Israel.” Rep. Nita Lowey, D-N.Y., said the outcome was “very disturbing” and Hamas needed to disarm, denounce violence and recognize Israel’s right to exist.

Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, R-Tenn., said the election “casts a serious shadow over the prospects for peace.”

Filed as The Herald Mail. The masthead on this scan reads The Morning Herald, A10, Friday, January 27, 2006. Both were Hagerstown papers of the Herald-Mail Company. The two other records under The Herald Mail are left there; no masthead was read on either.

CP-2006-016 →

· Lincoln Journal Star · Lincoln

Hamas’ landslide victory takes world by surprise

Leaders of Islamic militant group have no experience in government

RAMALLAH, West Bank — In a moment of deep symbolism, thousands of Hamas supporters marched to the Palestinian parliament in Ramallah on Thursday and raised the Islamic militant group’s green banner over the building. Fatah activists hoisted their own yellow flag alongside it, and a shoving match ensued.

One Fatah supporter yelled at the Hamas men, “If this means you’re not going to make peace with Israel, it means you’re not solving our problems and our lands won’t be returned!” But in the end, Hamas prevailed.

The fight underscored the tensions and uncertainty following Hamas’ landslide election victory Wednesday, a vote that stunned the world and threw into question the future of Mideast peace. The win stunned even Hamas leaders, who mounted a well-organized campaign but did not expect to govern.

Now Hamas, which has no experience in government, must decide whether to moderate its stance toward Israel. Abbas, elected last year on a platform of making peace with Israel, must decide whether to try to form a coalition government with Hamas or step down.

Fatah leaders said they would not serve under a Hamas-led government, choosing instead to be the opposition, said chief Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat. “We will be a loyal opposition and rebuild the party,” Erekat said after meeting with Abbas.

Palestinian supporters of Hamas celebrate their victory in parliamentary elections Thursday in the West Bank city of Nablus. Hamas won a huge majority in parliamentary elections as Palestinian voters rejected the longtime rule of the Fatah Party, throwing the future of Mideast peacemaking into question.

CP-2006-017 →

· The Oregonian · Portland

Hamas prepares to govern

The group must show it can shift from resistance to politics

GAZA CITY, GAZA STRIP — The political earthquake that swept Hamas to power in Wednesday’s parliamentary elections has been rumbling below the surface of Palestinian life for nearly two decades.

Founded in the crowded Gaza Strip in 1987 as an outgrowth of the Egyptian fundamentalist Muslim Brotherhood, the group, whose name means “zeal,” is an Arabic acronym for the Islamic Resistance Movement.

Its birth coincided with the start of the first Palestinian uprising against Israel, and its covenant, published a year later, called for a zealous campaign to destroy Israel. “Holy war,” the document declared, is a duty binding on all Muslims whenever “enemies usurp Islamic lands.”

Now, as Hamas faces the demands and responsibilities of governing, is it the same organization it was at birth, or will its leaders steer a more moderate course to participate in politics?

“Hamas faces the difficult task of adjusting from a resistance movement to a political party in the system,” said Ziad Abu Amr, an independent Palestinian lawmaker who ran for office with Hamas’ backing. “What is it going to do with militants who made resistance a career?

How is it going to deal with issues that matter to its voters: corruption, internal order, the peace process? It is much easier to be in the opposition and criticize mistakes,” Amr said. Hamas “has translated those mistakes into power,” he said. “Now it has to translate power into change.”

Ismail Haniyeh, a Hamas leader and top candidate for the Palestinian parliamentary elections, salutes supporters Thursday outside his house at the al-Shati refugee camp in Gaza City. Hamas won an outright majority of parliamentary seats in the elections held Wednesday and has won the right to form the next Palestinian government.

CP-2006-020 →

· The Sacramento Bee · Sacramento

Hamas: Prime minister resigns

Qureia, a member of Fatah’s discredited old guard who did not run for re-election, told reporters. He said his Fatah Party would continue to serve the Palestinian people from the opposition. The mood of resignation among Fatah leaders contrasted sharply with the jubilation of Hamas supporters, who fired guns in the air and distributed sweets in the streets of Gaza City.

In Ramallah, Fatah and Hamas loyalists clashed outside the Palestinian parliament building, where Fatah activists burned tires and hurled stones, shattering windows.

Israel’s acting prime minister, Ehud Olmert, convened his senior Cabinet ministers and security chiefs for an emergency session and declared afterward that Israel would have no dealings with a Palestinian Authority in which Hamas took part.

“We will not negotiate with a government that does not keep to its most basic commitment – fighting terror,” Olmert said in a statement. President Bush said the United States would not deal with Hamas unless the group renounced violence and recognized Israel’s right to exist.

“A political party that articulates the destruction of Israel as part of its platform is a party with which we will not deal,” Bush said at the White House. The election leaves Abbas, who will continue to serve the four-year presidential term he won in an election a year ago, in an awkward position.

He said late Thursday that his vanquished Fatah Party would consider an invitation from Hamas to form a coalition government. He said because he is still committed to peace negotiations with Israel, he would revive the role of the Palestine Liberation Organization in any future talks, possibly giving Israel a chance to bypass the Palestinian government in negotiations.

A Fatah Party supporter injured by a thrown stone peers Thursday out a shattered window of the Palestinian parliament building in Ramallah after Fatah and Hamas loyalists clashed.

CP-2006-025 →

· Sun News

Hamas’ election victory muddies Bush’s policies

WASHINGTON | The landslide victory by the militant group Hamas in this week’s Palestinian elections threatens President Bush’s quest for peace in the Middle East and underscores the perils of his aggressive push for democracy in the Muslim world.

Senior U.S. officials acknowledged that they were shocked by the election’s outcome: a group designated by the U.S. as a terrorist organization taking power in voting that virtually all observers agree was free and fair. With his twin goals of fighting terrorism and promoting democracy in direct conflict, Bush delivered a carefully nuanced response.

The president praised the election process, but stood by Washington’s refusal to deal with Hamas unless it renounces its goal of destroying Israel. “The United States does not support political parties that want to destroy our ally Israel,” Bush said at a news conference.

Yet Bush praised the power of elections and acknowledged many Palestinians’ anger over corruption under the long-ruling Fatah faction. “When you give people the vote, you give people a chance to express themselves at the polls ... and if they’re unhappy with the status quo, they’ll let you know,” he said.

Bush said he hoped that Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, a Fatah leader who opposes violence against Israel, would remain in office. Bush and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice face dilemmas in dealing with the Hamas victory. “The State Department and the president are in a tough spot here,” said Sen. Joseph Biden, D-Del., who observed the elections.

“I think the administration has had really a pretty naive view about how rapidly and how neatly democracy will be embraced” in the Middle East. “They’ve constantly underestimated the pull and tug of Islam.”

CP-2006-026 →

· Asbury Park Press

Fatah supporters rampage through Gaza City in protest

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Thousands of Fatah supporters burned cars and shot in the air across the Gaza Strip on Friday, demanding the resignation of corrupt party officials and insisting there be no coalition between their defeated party and the victorious Hamas.

The protest against the party that dominated Palestinian politics for the past 40 years came after President Mahmoud Abbas, who was elected last year to a four-year term, said he would ask the Islamic militant group to form the next government. Abbas later fired six Fatah officials.

Israel’s government, caught off guard by the Hamas parliamentary landslide, said it would have no contacts with a Palestinian government that includes Hamas. Acting Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni appealed to the international community not to legitimize a Hamas government, saying elections “are not a whitewash for terror.”

A Hamas-led government could lead to a cutoff of crucial foreign aid to the cash-strapped Palestinian Authority if the Islamic militants do not renounce violence and end their call for the destruction of Israel. Despite international pressure, Hamas leaders said Friday that they had no intention of recognizing Israel.

Hamas held a celebratory rally in the central Gaza town of Khan Younis, as supporters waved green party flags and caps and chanted slogans. Small, violent confrontations also broke out in Khan Younis. An argument between about 20 Hamas and Fatah loyalists degenerated into gunfire and rock-throwing that left three people injured, one with gunshot wounds.

Wednesday’s election exposed deep tensions within Palestinian society and was a clear rebuke to Fatah for its corruption and inability to maintain order in Palestinian towns.

On Friday, thousands of Fatah activists, furious with those leaders for the electoral loss, protested throughout Gaza and the West Bank, demanding the Fatah central committee resign and insisting the party not form a partnership with Hamas. Demonstrators burned cars and shot in the air in Gaza City.

About 1,000 angry party activists went to Abbas’ house in Gaza, and hundreds of gunmen fired rifles in the air. Abbas was in the West Bank city of Ramallah at the time. Hamas, responsible for dozens of suicide bombings on Israelis, has long called for the destruction of the Jewish state.

In recent years, some Hamas leaders grudgingly accepted the idea of a Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza, but only as a stage toward freeing the rest of Palestine — meaning Israel. Hamas is listed as a terrorist organization by the United States and the European Union.

Jacob Walles, the U.S. consul-general in Jerusalem, said the United States would not give aid to terrorist organizations, members of terrorist organizations or ministries controlled by people belonging to terrorist organizations.

Protesters are seen around several burning cars in Gaza City on Friday. Thousands of Fatah supporters, the rival party to Hamas, went on a rampage to protest corrupt leaders and Wednesday’s election results. (ASSOCIATED PRESS)

CP-2006-013 →

· Naples Daily News

Fatah activists protest

Palestinian leader Abbas says he will ask Hamas to form government

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Thousands of activists from Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas’ Fatah Party demonstrated in the West Bank and Gaza Strip on Friday, burning abandoned cars, shooting in the air and demanding corrupt leaders resign after their devastating election loss to the militant Hamas movement.

With Hamas winning a strong majority in parliamentary elections, Abbas said he will ask the Islamic group to form the next Palestinian government, but Fatah rejected a role in the new Cabinet and Israel ruled out peace talks in what could be the first steps to isolate the militant group after its election victory.

Acting Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni asked world leaders not to legitimize a government led by Hamas, saying elections are not a “whitewash” for terrorist groups.

CP-2006-018 →

· The Orlando Sentinel · Orlando

Shift in power ‘best thing’ for Jewish state, many say

Ian Fisher

TEL AVIV, Israel — Arie Schmidt stopped Saturday morning to place a pebble on the memorial to the 21 dead at the Dolphinarium disco, killed in a suicide bombing by Hamas in 2001. The dead were mostly teenagers. Schmidt, 56, sighed, then chained one careful word to the next on what it means now that Hamas is the official Palestinian power.

“I tell you,” he began, “we think it is actually the best thing that can happen to Israel. “Because now we see the real face of the Palestinians,” said Schmidt, a computer engineer from Haifa who considers himself neither on the left nor the right.

“From their vote, we can understand their theory to destroy the state of Israel is not a theory but a fact. “So,” he said, in a conclusion that was repeated again and again in interviews here, “I think it is the best chance for peace. I think Hamas can understand there is no way to destroy the state of Israel and will take a course to peace.

“Hopefully.” Among Israelis, there is no lack of shock and anger that Palestinian voters overwhelmingly chose a radical Islamic group with a deadly resume: 19 dead on the No. 32A bus in Jerusalem in 2002, 23 dead on the No. 2 bus in Jerusalem in 2003, a double bombing on buses in Beersheba in 2004, killing 16 and injuring 100.

And that is only a small, and recent, part of the list. Still, from conversations in Tel Aviv, anger was not the strongest emotion. Rather, there seemed satisfaction, not with the result itself, but with how starkly it put the issues into plain view.

In electing Hamas, many Israelis here said, Palestinians could no longer hide behind figures such as Yasser Arafat, who talked about peace but, they said, worked to undermine it until his death in November 2004.

A memorial honors the dead at the site of a suicide bombing at the Dolphinarium disco that killed 21, mostly teenagers, in June 2001 in Tel Aviv, Israel.

CP-2006-021 →

· The Plain Dealer · Cleveland

For Israelis, Hamas victory brings shock — and hope

Ian Fisher

TEL AVIV, ISRAEL — Arie Schmidt stopped Saturday morning to place a pebble on the memorial to the 21 people killed in a suicide bombing by Hamas at the Dolphinarium disco in 2001. The dead were mostly teenagers. Schmidt, 56, sighed, then chained one careful word to the next on what it means now that Hamas is the official Palestinian power.

“I tell you,” he began, “we think it is actually the best thing that can happen to Israel. “Because now we see the real face of the Palestinians,” said Schmidt, a computer engineer from Haifa who considers himself neither on the left nor the right.

“From their vote, we can understand their theory to destroy the state of Israel is not a theory but a fact. “So,” he said, “I think it is the best chance for peace. I think Hamas can understand there is no way to destroy the state of Israel and will take a course to peace.”

Among Israelis, there is no lack of shock and anger that Palestinian voters overwhelmingly chose a radical Islamic group with a deadly resumé: 21 dead at the disco here in 2001; 19 dead on a bus in Jerusalem in 2002; 23 dead on a bus in Jerusalem in 2003; a double bombing on buses in Beersheeba in 2004, killing 16 and injuring 100.

And that is only a small, and recent, part of the list. Still, from conversations in Tel Aviv, anger was not the strongest emotion. Rather, there seemed satisfaction, not with the result itself, but with how starkly it put the issues into plain view.

In electing Hamas, many Israelis here said, Palestinians no longer could hide behind figures like Yasser Arafat, who talked about peace but, they said, worked to undermine it until his death in November 2004. His Fatah faction now lies beaten, its monopoly on official power ended by the Hamas election landslide.

In contrast, Hamas stands quite clearly for the destruction of Israel. Now, Israelis said, the rest of the world can see this is the program supported by most Palestinians.

“Finally we are standing and confronting the real thing,” David Chen, 45, an Israeli government employee, said as he walked by the Dolphinarium monument, which honors, as the inscription says, the “many youngsters whose lives were cut by murderers in a bloody terror attack.” “It is the moment of truth,” he said.

A memorial stands at the site of the Dolphinarium disco in Tel Aviv, Israel, where 21 people were killed in a suicide bombing by Hamas in 2001.

CP-2006-023 →

· Roanoke Times · Roanoke

Militant Hamas vows to stick to its guns

But the world holds out hope that international pressure can make them become more moderate.

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Following their resounding election victory, the Islamic militants of Hamas met the question of whether they will change their stripes with a loud “no”: no recognition of Israel, no negotiations, no renunciation of terrorism. But the world holds out hope that international pressure can make them more moderate.

At stake is the future of Mideast peacemaking, billions of dollars in aid and the Palestinians’ relationship with Israel, the United States and Europe.

Hamas’ victory — winning 76 of 132 parliament seats in Wednesday’s election — has created a dizzying power shift in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, overturning certitudes and highlighting the failure by Palestinian leaders, Israel and the international community to ease growing desperation in the Palestinian territories.

Weekend violence between Hamas and Palestinian policemen mostly allied with long-dominant Fatah, and angry demonstrations by disgruntled gunmen fearing the loss of jobs and income after the Hamas win, have raised the specter of widespread civil strife.

The win by Hamas — which is responsible for dozens of suicide bombings on Israelis and has long called for the destruction of the Jewish state — caught everyone, including the organization itself, off-guard. Both Hamas and the international community face agonizing dilemmas.

Hamas leaders say they won’t renounce their violent ideology, but the consequences of failing to do so are likely to be catastrophic: loss of life-sustaining aid, international isolation and a profound setback to their statehood aspirations.

By all accounts, Palestinians didn’t choose Hamas because they reject peace talks with Israel but rather because they were fed up with graft in the ruling Fatah Party. Hamas candidates ran on a platform of clean government, largely de-emphasizing their militant credentials. Hamas leaders are aware of their dilemma.

Since the election, they have struggled to persuade Fatah to join them in a coalition — hoping to avoid having to deal with Israel and the West. But Fatah has so far rejected the offer.

CP-2006-024 →

· Newsday · Melville

Hamas election pleases hard-liners on both sides

James P. Pinkerton

The Hamas election in the Palestinian territories was disturbing to many. But not to all. Some were happy — extremely happy. There’s a concept in political science called “objective allies.” That is, even people who hate each other can still find common ground — by, for example, hating others even more.

In the past century’s Europe, the communists and fascists of Europe agreed on nothing, except that they both, from their respective extremes, hated the centrists. And so both Reds and Browns would be objective allies, as both sought to tear down moderate parties and governments. So it is in the Middle East.

The Hamas election spells the dead end of “the road map for peace.” Such an end to negotiations seems to be fine with Hamas, but it’s also fine with many Israelis. The “no-negotiations” hard-liners on both sides have been objective allies all along.

Uri Avnery, a longtime observer from the left end of Israeli politics, wrote last week: “If Ariel Sharon had not been in a deep coma, he would have jumped out of his bed for joy. The Hamas victory fulfills his most ardent hopes.”

The Israeli prime minister became something of a moderate in his country’s politics only because all but the hawkiest hawks concluded that many of the settlements were not viable in the era of suicide bombing. So the hawks, such as Sharon, moved to the center. But their basic disdain for the Palestinians never changed.

Avnery says that what Sharon & Co. wanted was to avoid dealing with the Palestinians: “Such negotiations would inevitably have led to a situation that would have compelled him to give up almost all of the West Bank. Sharon had no intention of doing so. He wanted to annex about half of the territory.”

And in the current climate, with Hamas ruling the roost, nobody expects the Israelis to sit down and talk with people sworn to exterminate them.

CP-2006-019 →

· San Antonio Express News · San Antonio · page 1

Emotion Pictures

Will the controversial ‘Paradise Now’ grab Oscar gleam, or will the message of human unity in ‘Joyeux Noel’ win out?

James P. Pinkerton, Newsday

“But a furor is starting to erupt around another movie, ‘Paradise Now,’ nominated as best foreign-language film. The film is obscure (director Hany Abu-Assad is not a name heard much around Hollywood), and it hasn’t made much money (barely more than $1 million), but the topic is red hot: suicide bombing in Israel.

The tagline of the movie declares, ‘From the most unexpected place comes a bold new call for peace,’ and the film is nuanced and ambiguous. Still, it’s hard to refute the argument that it humanizes Palestinian suicide bombers. A private group called The Israel Project has led the charge against ‘Paradise Now’; the project this week held a news conference in Jerusalem in which the Israeli father of a teenager killed by a suicide bomber referred to the film as ‘Hell Now.’

And the project is running an ad in Variety that asks, ‘Is it right to honor a film that puts a human face on deliberate murders of children?’ That’s a great question, although Hollywood, of course, humanizes murderers all the time.

‘Capote,’ one of the films in contention for the best picture Oscar, puts human — and to Truman Capote, at least, sexually alluring — faces on the men who killed four people in Kansas, including two teenagers, back in 1959. Still, ‘Paradise Now’ might turn out to be too edgy for the Hollywood crowd.

The Academy Awarders might not want to vote for the movie some say will encourage more suicide bombers in Israel — and maybe, too, in Iraq. Instead, there’s another foreign film that might actually cleanse some of the blood on Hollywood’s hands.

It’s ‘Joyeux Noel,’ and it’s about temporarily ending a war that never should have been fought, World War I… on Sunday Hollywood has a chance to remind us that audiences can be warmed and heartened by what unites us — not thrilled and chilled and bloodied by what divides us.”

“ABOVE: Hany Abu-Assad, director of ‘Paradise Now’ (center, with cast members Ali Suliman and Kais Nashef) has garnered criticism, but could reap an Oscar… TOP: Then again, so could the French film ‘Joyeux Noel,’ which offers a more uplifting message about the humanity brought out by war.” · Mario Anzuoni / Reuters

The organized campaign against the film, reported in a column that argues against it and then concedes the case. A group took out an advertisement in Variety asking whether it is right to honor a film that puts a human face on the murder of children. The columnist calls it a great question and answers it himself in the next sentence: Hollywood humanises murderers all the time, and Capote was up for best picture the same year for doing it to two men who killed four people in Kansas. This is the fifth American notice of this film in the archive, and between the five of them a Palestinian director is told his work is unsophisticated, is cleared of being an apologia, is objected to by a foreign ministry for the country named on his award, and is asked whether his characters may have faces at all.

CP-2006-007 →

· The Journal News · White Plains

Palestinian women argue with security officers in Ramallah

Palestinian women argue with security officers yesterday in the West Bank town of Ramallah. Top Hamas lawmakers promised yesterday that the new Palestinian government will protect women's rights.

Palestinian women argue with security officers yesterday in the West Bank town of Ramallah. Top Hamas lawmakers promised yesterday that the new Palestinian government will protect women's rights.

A standalone Associated Press photograph printed under a standing JERUSALEM label. The item carried no headline of its own; the headline field holds a description of the picture.

Correction: The item is a standalone Associated Press photograph.

CP-2006-009 →

· Los Angeles Times

Two sides on the Israeli fence

Re “Drawn into a blueprint of bias,” Opinion, March 10 UCLA’s relentless Palestinian propagandist Saree Makdisi writes articulately that Israel’s security fence wreaks havoc on Palestinian life. For sure, it’s a shame that such a wall exists and that suffering continues — on both sides of it.

The Israelis gave up Gaza unilaterally last summer and were thanked in the form of continuing rocket attacks. If they were to undo the wall, what message would that give to the same barbaric folks who perfected the art of suicide bombing?

MARTIN ZUCKER Canoga Park • Makdisi’s arguments would draw more water had they touched on the fact that the Israeli wall has demonstrably reduced the number of suicide bombings launched from the Palestinian areas affected by the barrier.

The Palestinian electorate has given ample evidence of where its heart lies, as witnessed by the election of a Hamas majority to its governing body. What part of “we call for the destruction of the state of Israel” doesn’t Makdisi understand? LOUIS H. NEVEL Los Angeles • Thank you for publishing Makdisi’s beautiful Op-Ed article.

She confronts issues of human rights, justice, injustice and censorship, particularly relating to the interrelationship of Israel, Palestine and the United States, with sensitivity, clarity, compassion, elegance and power. UCLA is lucky to have her on its faculty. JEANIE SHATERIAN Berkeley

CP-2006-038 →

· estimated · Telegram & Gazette · Worcester

Just solution in Mideast remains elusive

In January, the Israeli Knesset (congress) voted, in my opinion, to ethnically cleanse 40,000 Arab-Israeli citizens (Bedouins) living in unrecognized villages in the Negev, because Shimon Peres and others called for the Judaizing of this region which has been home to Beadoins for 1,000-plus years. How can such a policy be legal in a democracy?

Israeli citizens have few rights; however, Jewish nationals have rights others in democratic countries regard as basic human rights. In 1948, Israel created the first of its “absentee property laws,” which allowed it to seize land, property and bank accounts of Arabs absent for as little as one day (and they drove them off at gunpoint).

In 1965, the Israeli government passed the National Planning and Building Law. Arab-Israeli villages became unrecognized villages, which effectively made these communities illegal. Though the indigenous people of the region continued to live on their traditional lands, Israel rarely provided services and made it illegal for private agencies to do so.

As a consequence, residents in these villages were denied running water, electricity, sewage treatment facilities, schools and health centers. What is at the heart of the so-called Arab-Israeli conflict is found in the basic laws of Israel. I believe they imprint within the hearts and minds of Israelis the DNA of racism.

If Israel were to establish a constitutional democracy where all are truly equal, a just solution would be found for its citizens as well as for Palestine, which has existed since the time of the Persian Empire in 500 BC.

Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping — the trim begins at the headline of the letter. Nothing on it names the newspaper, so 2006-03-18 and pub “Telegram & Gazette” could not be checked. The only internal time reference is “In January, the Israeli Knesset … voted”, which is consistent with a 2006 letter but fixes nothing.

CP-2006-030 →

· The Bulletin

Israelis threaten to re-invade Gaza

Generals say rocket attacks won't be tolerated; the Palestinian premier says "we will not give in" to pressure.

THE NEW YORK TIMES

JERUSALEM — Israeli generals threatened Friday to re-invade the Gaza Strip if Palestinian rocket attacks continued, keeping up a war of words and weapons even as Jews, Muslims and Christians celebrated their holy days. "I do not rule out ground operations if requested by the southern command of Israel," the army deputy chief of staff, Maj. Gen.

Moshe Kaplinski, told the nation's biggest-selling daily, Yediot Aharonot, in one of a spate of bellicose interviews in weekend newspapers. "If the times come, we will launch them." As thousands of Palestinians rallied after Friday prayer to protest Israeli shelling and the cutoff of international aid, the new Hamas leadership, broke and shunned, was no less adamant.

"We will not give in, and attempts to isolate the government will fail," Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh told a cheering crowd at a mosque in Gaza at the Jabaliya refugee camp.

"We are prepared to eat salt and olives." Western nations have suspended tens of millions of dollars in direct aid to the Palestinian Authority, demanding that Haniyeh's government renounce violence and recognize Israel's right to exist.

Stepping up the pressure, the U.S. government on Friday said it has barred Americans from most business dealings with the Palestinian government. In the past week, 18 Palestinians have been killed in artillery shelling and in Israeli airstrikes. The latest victims were two gunmen from al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade who were killed on Thursday as they tried to get through a fence.

On Thursday and Friday, Israeli troops, with armored bulldozers, ventured inside Gaza searching for explosives, the first such incursion since their withdrawal in September.

Kaplinski maintained in his interview that the Israeli military pressure was "beginning to bear fruit." He added, however, "More should be done to stop rocket attacks." The army's chief operations officer, Maj. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot, expressed similar views in a lengthy interview in Haaretz.

"If Hamas leaders don't act to stop the rockets, they must be hit hard and pay a heavy price," Eisenkot said. "What we saw up to now was just an introduction." Asked about a possible Israeli ground incursion into Gaza, he said, "It is possible things will go in that direction." In another interview, Maj. Gen.

Yitzhak Harel, the army's chief planning officer, told the Jerusalem Post: "We are at war. We will continue escalating our actions, and it is possible that eventually we will launch a ground operation in Gaza." He added: "The main issue, however, is that the other side needs to understand that even one launched rocket is not worth it for them.

We are almost there." This report includes material from the Associated Press.

Credit line above the text reads THE NEW YORK TIMES; no individual reporter is named in this version. Same day, same wire story as s002_2 (Omaha World Herald), where the byline is John Kifner and the premier's name is spelled "Ismail Haniya". This paper spells it "Ismail Haniyeh" and "al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade"; the other spells it "Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigade". Both print the Eisenkot quotation identically.

CP-2006-034 →

· Omaha World-Herald

Israel threatens to retake Gaza if attacks persist

By John Kifner / New York Times News Service

JERUSALEM — Israeli generals threatened Friday to re-invade the Gaza Strip if Palestinian rocket attacks continued, keeping up a war of words and weapons even as Jews, Muslims and Christians celebrated their holy days. "I do not rule out ground operations if requested by the southern command of Israel," the army deputy chief of staff, Maj. Gen.

Moshe Kaplinski, told the nation's biggest selling daily, Yediot Aharonot, in one of a spate of bellicose interviews in weekend newspapers. "If the times come, we will launch them." As thousands of Palestinians rallied after Friday prayer to protest Israeli shelling and the cutoff of international aid, the new Hamas leadership, broke and shunned, was no less adamant.

"We will not give in, and attempts to isolate the government will fail," Prime Minister Ismail Haniya told a cheering crowd at a mosque in Gaza at the Jabaliya refugee camp. "We are prepared to eat salt and olives." In the past week, 18 Palestinians have been killed in tank and artillery shelling and in Israeli airstrikes.

The latest victims were two gunmen from Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigade who were killed on Thursday as they tried to get through a fence. On both Thursday and Friday, Israeli troops, with armored bulldozers, ventured several dozen yards inside Gaza searching for explosives, the first such incursion since their withdrawal in September.

Kaplinski maintained in his interview that the Israeli military pressure was "beginning to bear fruit." He added, however, "More should be done to stop rocket attacks." The army's chief operations officer, Maj. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot, expressed similar views in a lengthy interview in Haaretz.

"If Hamas leaders don't act to stop the rockets, they must be hit hard and pay a heavy price," Eisenkot said. "What we saw up to now was just an introduction."

Photo above the headline: Israeli border police and soldiers scuffling with demonstrators. Caption reads "Israeli border police and soldiers scuffle with demonstrators Friday during a protest against construction of Israel's separation barrier in the West Bank village of Bilin, near Ramallah." Credit: Nasser Shiyoukhi / The Associated Press. This cut of the wire story runs shorter than The Bulletin's and closes on the Eisenkot "just an introduction" line.

CP-2006-035 →

· The Patriot Ledger · Quincy

Gaza health crisis: Severe shortage of medical supplies cripples hospitals

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip – With a sudden shortage of everything from disposable needles and adhesive tape to vital drugs, Gaza’s once impressive public health system is running down fast under the dual pressure of aid cutoffs and the closing of the Karni crossing point with Israel. Already, says Dr.

Ibrahim al-Habbash, the general director the main Gaza hospital, Al Shifa, the hospital can no longer provide chemotherapy for many forms of cancer, has only a few days’ supply of important surgical drugs and has used up its strategic three-month cache normally kept for a health crisis.

“We’ve suffered in the past, of course, but in the last month, the problems have really increased,” Habbash said. “ . . . People are suffering, even dying because of these shortages.”

The 1,400 hospital staff members, and many of the families of the patients, are frustrated by a second month without salary, a situation suffered by every employee of the Palestinian Authority. The gaps in health care are a result of a double crisis.

One is the budget deficit in the Palestinian Authority, which has worsened significantly since Israel stopped transferring tax collections and the U.S. and the European Union cut off aid after the Hamas government took over. The other is the inability to get goods into Gaza through the main crossing point at Karni, which the Israelis close whenever there is a security alert.

A recent internal report by the World Health Organization says the crisis will worsen as the economic siege of the Palestinian Authority continues. The report forecasts a “rapid decline of the public health system toward a possible collapse.”

CP-2006-022 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia

Israeli aide, Abbas meet on peace efforts

But, the foreign minister said “time is working against those who believe in a two-state solution.”

SHARM EL-SHEIKH, Egypt — Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas met here yesterday with Israel’s foreign minister and deputy prime minister in the highest-level talks between Palestinian and Israeli officials in nearly a year.

Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni said that urgent measures were needed to resurrect stagnant Middle East peace talks if there were to be hope of Israelis and Palestinians living peacefully in their own, neighboring countries. “I think that time is working against those who believe in a two-state solution,” she said.

Deputy Prime Minister Shimon Peres told reporters that the meeting, on the sidelines of the World Economic Forum conference here, had gone well and was a “preparation and an opening, particularly on the economic side.”

The meeting came just before Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert’s first official trip to Washington, where he is expected to face political pressure not to isolate Abbas, whom U.S. officials are working to bolster in his ongoing power struggle with the Hamas-dominated Palestinian government.

Underscoring Abbas’ difficult position, Palestinian police in Gaza foiled what they said was another apparent assassination plot against a top official allied with Abbas. Police said they had discovered a 150-pound bomb planted on the road that Rashid Abu Shbak, head of the Palestinian Authority’s security services, takes from his home in south Gaza City to work.

The bomb was discovered just before Shbak left his house. A day earlier, Abbas’ intelligence chief was seriously injured by an explosion in an elevator shaft at his headquarters in Gaza. The apparent assassination attempts followed gun battles between Abbas’ Fatah organization and Hamas, raising concerns that the factional fighting could spin out of control.

Fatah’s statement called the attacks a “clear conspiracy” against the party, though members stopped short of overtly blaming Hamas.

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas (left) talks with Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni during the World Economic Forum.

CP-2006-027 →

· Houston Chronicle · Houston · page 1

Trying to atone for deadly error

Israeli government takes an unexpected step and covers medical costs of a Palestinian family whose car was bombed by mistake · A family shattered

“A FAMILY SHATTERED. Trying to atone for deadly error. Israeli government takes an unexpected step and covers medical costs of a Palestinian family whose car was bombed by mistake.”

“GRIEVING: A Palestinian man weeps at the funeral of his mother, wife and son, who were killed by an accidental Israeli airstrike in late May.” Emilio Morenatti : Associated Press

The clipping is the photograph, its caption and the headline stack; the story below was not clipped. The man in the photograph is not named, and neither are his mother, his wife or his son.

CP-2006-001 →

· Desert Dispatch

Israeli troops enter Gaza, planes attack bridges, knock out power in most of Gaza Strip

By STEVEN GUTKIN / The Associated Press

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Israeli tanks and troops entered southern Gaza and planes attacked three bridges and knocked out electricity to the coastal strip early Wednesday, stepping up the pressure on Palestinian militants holding captive a 19-year-old Israeli soldier.

The ground troops and tanks began taking up positions in two locations east of the Gaza town of Rafah under the cover of tank shells, according to witnesses and Palestinian security officials. Palestinians dug in behind walls and sand embankments, bracing for a major Israeli offensive.

The Israeli strikes came amid intensive diplomatic efforts in the Arab world and by the United Nations. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice urged Israel to “give diplomacy a chance.” Trying to defuse building tensions, negotiators from the ruling Hamas movement said Tuesday they had accepted a document implicitly recognizing Israel.

But two Syrian-based Hamas leaders denied a final deal had been reached. Israel said only freedom for the captive soldier, Cpl. Gilad Shalit, could defuse the crisis, not a political agreement. The Israeli military said in a statement that the object of the attacks on the bridges was “to impair the ability of the terrorists to transfer the kidnapped soldier.”

Knocking down the bridges cut Gaza in two, Palestinian security officials said. Early Wednesday, Israeli planes fired at least nine missiles at Gaza's only power station, cutting electricity to much of the Gaza Strip, Palestinian security officials said.

The station's three functioning turbines and a gasoline reservoir were engulfed in enormous flames that firefighters were unable to control. The attack raised the specter of a humanitarian crisis in Gaza, as water pumps in the strip are powered by electricity.

CP-2006-032 →

· Times Record · Fort Smith

Hamas-linked group won't release information about soldier

“Because Israel ignored a deadline to release Palestinian prisoners, the militants won’t release any information about the soldier.”

Gilad Shalit, the week after his capture. The exchange being refused is prisoners for information.

CP-2006-028 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore, MD (per the printed folio) · page 9A (per the printed folio)

Israeli attacks kill 6 in Gaza; truce in doubt

Palestinian premier urges U.S. to press Israel to halt offensive to stamp out rockets

BY ASHRAF KHALIL

BEIT LAHIYA, GAZA STRIP // Israeli attacks in the northern Gaza Strip yesterday left six Palestinians dead, including two children, and at least 10 wounded, casting doubt on the prospects of a cease-fire initiative being circulated among militant groups by Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas.

One shell hit a parking lot here, killing three and injuring 10, authorities said. Witnesses said a second shell in another area of Beit Lahiya struck a donkey cart, killing a 60-year-old woman and her 12-year-old grandson. The area around Beit Lahiya is a favored spot for Palestinian militants firing rockets into southern Israel.

The twin smokestacks of the power plant in the Israeli city of Ashkelon are clearly visible, separated only by bare ground that used to contain several Israeli settlements. Early yesterday, militiamen from the Aqsa Martyrs Brigade fired several rockets toward Ashkelon.

"Oh sure, they launch from all over the place around here," said Nasser Arasha, a 36 year-old unemployed Palestinian day laborer and resident of the Naba apartment complex in this Gaza border town. An Israeli army spokeswoman said more than 50 rockets had been fired into Israel from the Beit Lahiya area in the past few weeks.

"The launching of rockets has continued, so I guess you could say we decided to step things up," she said. Palestinian Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh said Washington should pressure Israel to stop its weeks-long offensive in Gaza.

"All that we ask the American administration is to take a moral stance toward the Palestinian people and the Palestinian suffering, and to bear its responsibility as a superpower," he told the Associated Press. [...] "We didn't target the apartment complex," said the Israeli army spokeswomen.

"But the cells do fire from that building." She attributed yesterday's deaths to "shells that misfired." As the familiar whump and delayed thud of nearby artillery fire continued yesterday, families from Naba loaded luggage and strollers into waiting cars, while fielding frantic phone calls from relatives.

"They're all leaving," said Arasha, who smoked a cigarette while calmly surveying the scene. He said that he was planning to stay. "I'm afraid the house will be looted if I leave it," he said. Arasha used to work as a day laborer in Israel, he said, but that stopped months ago when Gazans were barred from entering.

He blamed Israel for the violence, but had no love for the "disastrous" new Palestinian government led by Hamas. His solution to the generations-old Israeli-Palestinian standoff: "I wish the sea would take us both so the world could relax."

Story ends "Ashraf Khalil writes for the Los Angeles Times." Photo caption for this story: "Palestinians assist a wounded man into a hospital in Gaza City. Israeli attacks yesterday in the northern Gaza Strip left six Palestinians dead, including two children, and at least 10 wounded." Credit: ADEL HANA (ASSOCIATED PRESS). No Eisenkot in this story; the Eisenkot reference on this page is in the Rice story beside it.

CP-2006-036 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore, MD (per the printed folio) · page 9A, jump from 1A (jump line reads "MIDEAST [From Page 1A]")

Rice pays surprise visit to Lebanon

Paul Richter and Ken Ellingwood write for the Los Angeles Times.

[jump page; the clipping begins mid-sentence] ...wants to create conditions for a "sustainable" cease-fire. The 13-day-old conflict has claimed the lives of nearly 400 Lebanese and at least 41 Israelis. Israeli troops were encountering heavy resistance as they closed in on a Hezbollah stronghold in southern Lebanon.

At least four Israeli soldiers were killed and 15 wounded in the fighting. Meanwhile, in the Gaza Strip, Israeli shelling killed five people and wounded several others.

Israel has sent about 3,000 troops to Lebanon's border region to drive Hezbollah from a 6-mile-wide swath of arid hills and stony valleys that Hezbollah militants have been using to fire rockets at northern Israel.

Hezbollah fired more than 80 rockets yesterday at a number of Israeli communities, including Kiryat Shemona and Safed in the northern Galilee and the port of Haifa, on the Mediterranean. [...] The Israeli casualties included two soldiers killed when their tanks were hit by Hezbollah fire and two pilots who died after their helicopter was either shot down or crashed not far from the border, according to an Israeli army spokesman.

Maj. Gen. Gadi Eizenkot, head of the army's operations branch, said Israeli forces were encountering fire from a type of anti-tank missile employed by Syrian forces, which he said underscored Syria's support for Hezbollah. Meanwhile, Human Rights Watch said Israeli forces have used artillery-fired cluster munitions in populated areas of Lebanon.

The rights group's researchers said cluster munitions were used on the village of Blida on July 19, killing one person and wounding at least 12, including seven children.

THE EISENKOT RECORD ON THIS PAGE. Eizenkot appears here in July 2006, during the Lebanon war he would later be given Northern Command over, in a single sentence of technical sourcing about Syrian anti-tank missiles — immediately before the paragraph reporting Human Rights Watch's finding that Israel used cluster munitions on the village of Blida, wounding seven children. The page thus carries his name and the cluster-munitions finding in adjacent paragraphs with no connection drawn. Two photographs belong to this story: the main one captioned "Israeli soldiers evacuate a wounded comrade in southern Lebanon. Troops engaged in fierce battles with Hezbollah fighters as Israeli forces attempt to drive the Shiite militia from the area near the border." (DAVID FURST [AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE]), and a second captioned "Relatives react as they see the bodies of a Palestinian teen and his uncle as Israeli forces fired yesterday at Palestinian rocket storage depots in the Gaza Strip." (PIER PAOLO CITO [ASSOCIATED PRESS]). Also quoted: Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki ("I am afraid there will be a great push toward fundamentalism, and also a message — a negative one — to all those who want to follow the course of peace"), Lebanese Speaker Nabih Berri, and Assistant Secretary of State David Welch.

CP-2006-037 →

· Telegram & Gazette · Worcester

Palestinian dance troupe is taking steps to peace

By Bronislaus B. Kush, Telegram & Gazette Staff

WORCESTER — Walk past Atwa Jaber and Jadya Aqel on the street and you’d think they’re typical American teenagers. Their clothes look as if they’ve been purchased at The Gap and they embrace all that pop culture offers.

But the two high school juniors are a long way from home… The Al Raja Palestinian Folkloric Dance Troupe has been performing across the country over the past couple of months, as part of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America’s “Peace Not Walls” campaign. The 22 teens have performed in Chicago, San Francisco, San Antonio and Omaha, Neb.

“This will give them a chance to get a better understanding of American teens,” said the Rev. Daniel Wilfred, Immanuel’s pastor. Mr. Jaber and Ms. Aqel, who also participated in the…

Members of the Al Raja Palestinian Folkloric Dance Troupe, made up of Palestinian, Christian and Muslim students from Ramallah, perform at Trinity Lutheran Church. (T&G Staff / Steve Lanava)

Twenty-two teenagers from Ramallah touring American churches, and the caption is worth reading twice: the troupe is made up of Palestinian, Christian and Muslim students. Palestinian is set beside Christian and Muslim as though it were a third category rather than the thing all of them are. The reporter’s way into the story is that they look like everyone else: their clothes look as if they’ve been purchased at The Gap.

CP-2006-008 →

· Ann Arbor News · Ann Arbor

Palestinian families commonly have several members in jail

The Hamas movement's military wing, the Qassam Brigades, say they captured the Israeli corporal, Gilad Shalit, as a bargaining chip to win the release of at least some of those prisoners, particularly the women and children. It is a move that many Palestinians support.

“We have 10,000 prisoners in jail, and the world cares only for this one Israeli prisoner,” said Mohsin Jirjawi, an uncle of a Palestinian wounded in the current fighting, referring to Shalit during an interview in Al Shifa hospital in Gaza City, where his wounded nephew is. He said “all Palestinians” supported Hamas' proposal to trade prisoners with Israel.

“And when Israel doesn't respond, our steadfastness grows.” When it followed with its raid, Hezbollah said it was acting in solidarity with the Palestinians.

Since 1998, the Palestinian Authority has maintained a Ministry of Prisoners' and Former Prisoners' Affairs, with 300 bureaucrats to keep track of the swelling number of prisoners in Israeli jails and to give allowances and legal aid to the prisoners and their families.

Even its own minister, Wasfi Qabaha, is now in prison, arrested by Israel in the wake of the capture of Shalit. For the Palestinians, the ripples of distress from every arrest have become an oppressive wave. One Gaza family has four sons in prison and more than one family has both parents and children in jail, the Israeli Prison Authority said.

Fakhri al-Barghouti of Ramallah was sentenced to 28 years in jail and is now sharing a cell with two of his sons, who are both serving life sentences, said the Palestinian prisoner's ministry assistant deputy minister, Muhammad Tluli.

Israeli officials could not immediately confirm those details, but said the Israeli Prison Authority did approve such living arrangements for prisoners with good records of behavior. “We are willing to sacrifice ourselves for the freedom of the Palestinian prisoners,” said Abu Muhammad, a field commander for the Qassam Brigades, in a standard turn of phrase.

He said he had spent four years in prison after the first intifada, or uprising, against Israel that began in 1987. “Even if Israel destroys all of Gaza, we will fight until they are released,” he said.

One of the factors that helped the militant Palestinian Islamic movement Hamas beat the long-ruling Fatah movement in elections last January was Fatah's failure to win the release of Palestinian prisoners in large numbers.

The Fatah leader and Palestinian president, Mahmoud Abbas, did manage to secure the release of 900 prisoners in two groups in 2005, but Palestinians complained that the prisoners freed did not include long-term prisoners or fighters. Israel said it would not release any Palestinian guilty of killing Israelis.

During the current crisis, the Palestinians and their backers have kept insisting that there is an easy way for Israel to reclaim its soldiers, one that does not require the kind of brute military force now in play in Gaza and Lebanon.

“From the first day, the Arab countries have supported a prisoner exchange — it's the logical solution,” said Taher al-Nounou, the Palestinian Authority's Foreign Ministry spokesman. Israel has repeatedly said that it will not trade prisoners to free its soldiers. But Israel has traded prisoners many times.

In January 2004, it released some 430 prisoners in exchange for Elhanan Tannenbaum, an Israeli businessman kidnapped by Hezbollah four years earlier. The exchange also included the bodies of three Israeli soldiers.

In 1997, Israel freed the spiritual leader of Hamas, Sheik Ahmed Yassin — who was later killed in an Israeli missile strike — along with dozens of others in return for two Israeli intelligence agents who had been arrested in Jordan after a failed attempt to kill Hamas' current leader, Khaled Mashaal.

“Israel returned prisoners many times in the past, so why is Israel being so stubborn this time?” asked Ikrama Sabri, the mufti of Jerusalem, the highest-ranking Islamic cleric here, in a recent sermon at the Al Aksa Mosque. “Returning the prisoners will bring happiness and peace to the hearts of both the Israelis and the Palestinians.”

That kind of talk has given hope to people like Fathiya Sbieh, who believes the fighting will mean that she will see her new grandchild soon. Two months ago, Sbieh watched on TV as her daughter Samar got off a prison bus, her hands and feet shackled, and hobbled into Meir Hospital in Kafr Saba in Israel.

She watched again as Samar hobbled out five days later, this time with her hands free, holding her newborn son. Sbieh insists that her daughter's only crime was using someone else's identification card to get permission to travel to the West Bank. But as is common, there is more than one version of the story.

Orit Shteltzer, spokeswoman for the Israeli Prisons Authority, said Samar had been convicted of belonging to the Qassam Brigades and had prepared a suicide belt for a would-be bomber. The birth was widely covered in the Gaza Strip, where her family has lived since fleeing the fighting in Israel in 1948.

The prison guards who took her to the hospital insisted that she remain shackled during her Caesarean section. Sbieh still believes that her daughter's hands and feet were tied. A spokeswoman for the hospital, Hagit Sharon, said that Samar was shackled only in her room.

She said the hospital had refused the request of prison administrators to keep her shackled in the operating room. Shteltzer said the her agency made no such request. In the Palestinian Ministry of Prisoners' Affairs' pale stone-faced headquarters in Gaza City, the walls are lined with posters bearing the pictures of prominent prisoners.

One shows the face of Saeed al-Ataba, the longest-serving Palestinian prisoner in Israeli jails. He will soon enter his 30th year in prison.

Palestinians hold pictures of detainees during a demonstration outside Gaza City last month. When Hezbollah guerrillas sneaked into Israel last month to kill and capture Israeli soldiers, setting off the current crisis, their goal was to trade them for a Lebanese man held by Israel.

But the question of prisoners held by Israel — nearly all of them Palestinians — is central to the conflict and likely to figure in its resolution. It is an issue that animates Hezbollah and the Palestinians as much as anything else in their fight with Israel.

A jump page, labeled MIDEAST FROM A1. Photograph credited File: Shawn Baldwin, The New York Times.

CP-2006-010 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles

Embellishing tradition

A Craft and Folk Art Museum embroidery show displays ancient Palestinian designs — and a couple’s devotion to preserving them.

By SCARLET CHENG / Special to The Times

Hanan Karaman Munayyer fell under the spell of Palestinian embroidery in 1987, when she saw a collection of dresses and accessories brought to New York by an antiques dealer. She and her husband are of Palestinian descent, but she says, “The beauty of the embroidery on these early 20th century dresses — we saw it for the first time in that collection.”

The dealer intended to sell off the 65 dresses piecemeal. But Munayyer, along with her husband Farah Joseph Munayyer, thought the collection was too important to be split apart. Embroidery, says Hanan Munayyer, is “one of the strongest expressions of Palestinian culture, and we were interested in promoting the Palestinian cultural image in a positive way.”

So the couple took out a home equity loan and bought the entire lot. Once in possession of it, Munayyer says, “I knew there was so much we didn’t know.” Munayyer, a molecular biologist, put her research skills to use to dig into the history of their new possessions — through books (only a handful were available then), textile experts and trips back to the Middle East.

Today the couple have collected more than 400 dresses, some dating to the 19th century, along with 1,100 other objects, including jewelry, headdresses, jackets and shawls, many embellished with the unique embroidery of the region.

Highlights of the collection, including 35 dresses dating from the mid-19th century to mid-20th century, are on display at the Craft and Folk Art Museum in “Sovereign Threads: A History of Palestinian Embroidery,” curated by Munayyer, along with the Assn. for the Development of Palestinian Camps, or INAASH.

“ ‘Sovereign Threads’ is an exhibition about both art and cultural identity,” writes Maryna Hrushetska, the museum director, in the introduction to the exhibition brochure.

“As these threads of tradition are passed through generations, they weave a fabric of cultural cohesiveness that testifies to the fact that neither war, conflict nor displacement can erase national identity.” Munayyer, speaking by telephone from her home in West Caldwell, N.J., describes embroidery as “very much a woman’s art and a woman’s history.”

For Palestinian women, she says, embroidery is a tradition handed down from mother to daughter, a means of displaying skill and status, and a reminder of both ancient and near history.

COLORFUL: The Craft and Folk Art Museum exhibition is “about both art and cultural identity,” the museum’s director says. Some of the embroidery motifs have been passed down for 3,000 years. | DECORATION: Ottoman coins, coral beads and silk embroidery adorn a headdress.

CP-2006-031 →

· estimated · The Post-Standard · Syracuse

Palestinian premier renews pledge not to recognize Israel

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Hamas will not recognize Israel or give in to international pressure that has crippled the Palestinian government, Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh told tens of thousands of banner-waving supporters at a rally Friday.

Haniyeh’s fiery speech was interrupted when he fainted onstage, apparently overcome by the heat and two weeks of dawn-to-dusk fasting during the holy month of Ramadan. He resumed his speech after a few minutes.

“I tell you with all honesty, we will not recognize Israel, we will not recognize Israel, we will not recognize Israel,” Haniyeh declared to a roar of applause from the crowd. “We say we will be in every government, we will stay in the government.”

The Hamas leader ruled out a proposal by members of his own Hamas movement to form a new government of technocrats as a way of winning international support and ending a seven-month aid freeze. “There are new scenarios, such as an emergency government, a technocrat government, or early elections,” Haniyeh told the crowd in a packed soccer stadium.

“They all aim at one thing, getting Hamas out of the government.” Moderate Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, who was elected separately, has the authority to dissolve the Hamas Cabinet and replace it with an emergency government, or could call early elections.

However, Abbas aides say he’s not considering either option at the moment, fearing such moves would not have popular support. An emergency government would also require approval of the parliament, which is controlled by Hamas.

Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh, of the Islamic group Hamas, wipes his face following a speech at a Hamas rally in Gaza City, Friday.

Date corrected 2005-10-07 to 2006-10-07. No masthead, folio or date line appears anywhere on the scan. The AP story (Sarah El Deeb) describes Ismail Haniyeh as Palestinian prime minister addressing a rally 'Friday' and fainting onstage 'overcome by the heat and two weeks of dawn-to-dusk fasting during the holy month of Ramadan'; it mentions 'a seven-month aid freeze' and gunbattles between Hamas and Fatah that 'erupted ... last week'. Haniyeh took office March 2006 and the aid freeze began April 2006, so seven months later is October 2006; Ramadan 1427 began 24 September 2006, putting 'two weeks' of fasting at 6-8 October 2006; the Hamas-Fatah gunbattles were 1-2 October 2006. The display ad in the lower right carries the trafficking code 'NF03 RMW 440619 100206' (2 October 2006). The year filed, 2005, is impossible - Haniyeh was not prime minister then. No date is printed on the clipping; the date is fixed by what the article reports, at the precision the evidence supports, and is not guessed beyond it.

CP-2005-011 →

· The Bay City Times · Bay City

Israel returns fire after Gaza rocket launch

JERUSALEM – Israeli troops fired tank shells into the southern Gaza Strip on Thursday in response to a rocket launched from Gaza that landed in an open area in southern Israel, the Israeli military said. No one was hurt in the exchange but it came a day after another rocket landed in the town of Sderot, also without casualties.

Israel carried out airstrikes in response to Wednesday’s rocket attack. An Israeli air force pilot who participated in those strikes was killed in a plane crash. Israel typically responds to any rocket fire, holding Gaza’s Hamas rulers responsible for all attacks emanating from the territory.

Since a 50-day war between Israel and Gaza militants in the summer of 2014, a cease-fire has largely held. But militants in Gaza occasionally launch rockets toward Israel. Neither side appears interested in an escalation, though casualties could spark more violence.

CP-2006-011 →

· Dothan Eagle

Gaza the ultimate test for Palestinians

Sueddeutsche Zeitung, Munich, Germany, on the Palestinian leadership: Is the Gaza Strip, evacuated by Israeli settlers, the seed of an independent Palestinian state, or a starting point for a bloody conflict between its political and military factions? The latest events, which again saw Palestinians shooting at Palestinians, give no cause for optimism. . . .

People die, the government wobbles and the president stands there like a helpless clown. The reasons for the chaos are known. Militants from Hamas and Islamic Jihad are leading an armed life of their own. The rudimentary and corruption-ridden state has neither the will nor the ability to achieve peace, security and order.

As if that were not enough, Israel often enough deliberately pours fuel onto the Palestinian fire from outside. . . . So far, Gaza is not a successful model. The chances that it will become one are shrinking.

CP-2006-012 →

· estimated · The Herald News · Passaic

5. PREMIER REJECTS COMPROMISE, RENEWS PLEDGE NOT TO RECOGNIZE ISRAEL

GAZA CITY (AP) – Hamas will not be edged out of power, accept compromise or recognize Israel, Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh told tens of thousands of banner-waving supporters at a rally Friday.

Haniyeh’s fiery performance was interrupted when he fainted onstage, seemingly overcome by the combined effects of heat and two weeks of dawn-to-dusk fasting during the holy month of Ramadan. He resumed his speech after a few minutes.

The Hamas leader ruled out a proposal by members of his own Hamas movement to form a new government of technocrats as a way of winning international support and ending a seven-month aid freeze.

No compromise: Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh, of the Islamic group Hamas, waves to his supporters during a rally at a soccer stadium in Gaza City on Friday.

Date corrected 2016-10-07 to 2006-10-07. The clipping is item '5.' in a numbered world-news digest under the section label 'GAZA STRIP', with no masthead, folio or date line on the scan. The AP copy is the same report as CP-2005-011: Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh telling 'tens of thousands of banner-waving supporters at a rally Friday' that Hamas will not recognize Israel, fainting onstage 'overcome by the combined effects of heat and two weeks of dawn-to-dusk fasting during the holy month of Ramadan', and ruling out a technocrat government that might end 'a seven-month aid freeze'; the Hatem Moussa photo caption repeats 'during a rally at a soccer stadium in Gaza City on Friday'. Haniyeh was prime minister only from March 2006; the aid freeze began in April 2006, putting 'seven-month' in October 2006; Ramadan 1427 began 24 September 2006, so two weeks of fasting falls on 6-8 October 2006. The filed 2016-10-07 is ten years out - by October 2016 Haniyeh had not been prime minister for two years and Rami Hamdallah led the PA government. No date is printed on the clipping; the date is fixed by what the article reports, at the precision the evidence supports, and is not guessed beyond it.

CP-2016-012 →

· Post Bulletin · Rochester · page 1

Gaza Strip: Israeli air strikes

GAZA STRIP · ISRAELI AIR STRIKES · Palestinian women human shields

Associated Press, Beit Hanoun

BEIT HANOUN, Gaza Strip — Housewife Tahrir Shahin left her seven children sleeping at home Friday morning and did something out of the ordinary: She marched into a combat zone, along with hundreds of other Palestinian women.

The women, dressed in long robes and headscarves, were responding to appeals by the local Hamas radio station that they try to rescue Palestinian gunmen trapped in a local mosque surrounded by Israeli troops. By nightfall, two women were dead and at least 10 wounded, including Shahin, whose left leg was amputated above the knee because of a severe gunshot wound.

Shahin, 36, said she had no regrets but was saddened by the loss of a limb… In another new tactic for Gaza, troops have rounded up hundreds of men for questioning, releasing most of them but detaining dozens, the army official said.

On Friday evening, for example, soldiers ordered men between the ages of 16 and 46 in Beit Hanoun’s Al Masri neighborhood to report to the local agricultural school for questioning.

“Palestinian women, one holding a copy of the Quran, Islam’s holy book, chant anti-Israeli slogans during a rally supporting the Hamas government in Gaza City, Friday.

At least one Palestinian woman was killed, witnesses said, by Israeli army fire when hundreds of women streamed to serve as human shields for militants inside a Gaza mosque besieged by Israeli troops.” Associated Press.

The headline is three words with no verb: Palestinian women human shields. Underneath it the reporting does something the headline does not — it gives one of them a name, an age, a job, seven children and an amputated leg, and then lets her say what she thought about it. Tahrir Shahin is one of the named ordinary Palestinians in this archive. The phrase in the headline is the one this archive follows for twenty years as it changes sides: see the human shields section. Note also what the caption does with the killing — witnesses said — and what the last paragraph reports without comment: every man between 16 and 46 in one neighborhood ordered to report to a school.

CP-2006-002 →

· The Jonesboro Sun · Jonesboro

Hundreds of Palestinian women stream into a Gaza combat zone

“Hundreds of Palestinian women in robes and head scarves streamed into a Gaza combat zone Friday to help free gunmen besieged by Israeli troops at a mosque. Two women who… In all, 35 Palestinians have been killed…”

Beit Hanoun. Two of the women were shot. The figure at the end of the paragraph is thirty-five.

CP-2006-029 →

· The Spokesman-Review

Palestinians have hopes for calm olive harvest

Israeli army protecting farmers from settler attacks

BY ARON HELLER / Associated Press

AWARTA, West Bank – Standing in an olive grove, the 61-year-old Palestinian farmer smiled as red, green and black olives rained down from trees shaken by field hands. For six years West Bank farmers have had little to be happy about: Jewish settlers often attacked them during the harvest.

But spurred by a Supreme Court ruling, the Israeli army now protects the Palestinian olive groves. “This is a wonderful beginning,” said Khaled Junaidi, head of the Palestinian olive oil council. “These trees are the livelihood of our people.”

Olives are the backbone of Palestinian agriculture, and Palestinians are counting on a bumper harvest to boost their economy, which was weakened by an international aid boycott imposed after Hamas came to power.

Since the Palestinian uprising began in 2000, two West Bank olive farmers have been killed and dozens wounded in attacks blamed on settlers, who also cut down trees or steal crops. In other areas, farmers have been denied access to their land by settlers or the army. Israeli leaders have spoken out strongly against the settler violence.

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert has called on the army to act firmly against those he called hooligans. Defense Minister Amir Peretz commissioned a World Bank study on the olive harvest, and U.N. officials have said Peretz made protecting this year's harvest a priority.

The army traditionally kept its distance, but the tough talk of Israel's leaders, coupled with the Supreme Court ruling, has trickled down to the field.

Palestinians sort olives last week in the West Bank village of Awarta. For years, farmers in the West Bank have been attacked by Jewish settlers during the harvest season. (Associated Press)

CP-2006-033 →

· The Star-Ledger · Newark · page 1

Palestinian human shields thwart Israeli airstrikes on Gaza homes

Sarah El Deeb, The Associated Press, Beit Lahiya

“BEIT LAHIYA, Gaza Strip — Hundreds of Palestinians serving as human shields guarded the homes of two top militants yesterday, a new tactic that forced Israel to call off missile strikes on the buildings and re-evaluate a mainstay of its aerial campaign in Gaza.

In recent months, the Israeli air force has repeatedly struck the homes of militants after warning residents by phone to clear out. Israeli security officials said they did not know how to respond to the human shield tactic, but pressed ahead with other airstrikes yesterday.

In Gaza City, an aircraft fired a missile at a car, killing one man and wounding nine, including two Hamas militants.

Four of the wounded were children, ages 5 to 16, who suffered shrapnel injuries, hospital officials said… The standoff over the homes of the militants began late Saturday when Mohammed Baroud, local leader of the Popular Resistance Committees, was informed by the army that his house would be hit.

The three-story building is home to 17 people from Baroud’s family… Instead of fleeing, though, the two decided to stay in their homes and called in reinforcements. They were quickly joined by crowds of supporters, including dozens of armed men, who gathered on balconies, rooftops and in the streets outside.

‘Death to Israel, Death to America,’ the crowds chanted… The army said it called off the nighttime airstrikes because of the crowds. It condemned what it said was a cynical exploitation ‘by the terrorists of uninvolved people as human shields.’

Israeli military officials acknowledged they had no solution for the standoff… Baroud’s mother, Umm Wael, said shifts had been organized in preparation for a long standoff. ‘Where should we go?’ she said. ‘We will stay here or die in the house.

Let them bring it down on our heads.’… Also yesterday, Hamas militants in Gaza fired eight rockets at the Israeli town of Sderot, seriously wounding one person.”

“Palestinians acting as human shields gather around and on top of a house in the northern Gaza Strip to keep it from being struck by Israeli warplanes. Israel called off the attacks on the homes of suspected terrorist leaders.” Mahmud Hams, Agence France-Presse.

The pivot. The Associated Press calls it a new tactic, the shields are volunteers, and the Israeli army supplies the sentence in which the same words mean the opposite.

CP-2006-003 →

· The Beaumont Enterprise · Beaumont · page 1

U.S. nun, priest are human shields at Palestinian militant’s house

The Associated Press

“BEIT LAHIYA, Gaza Strip — An American priest and nun spent several hours Wednesday at a militant’s home that Israel has targeted for destruction, the first foreigners to join a weeklong standoff between Palestinian ‘human shields’ and the Israeli air force.

Father Peter Dougherty, 65, and Sister Mary Ellen Gundeck, 55, both Michigan-based peace activists, said they were sent by God to help protect the Palestinians.

The pair arrived Wednesday morning at the family home of Mohammed Baroud, a militant involved in rocket attacks on Israel… The use of human shields is a new tactic in the Palestinians’ war against Israel’s mighty military.

Since militants allied with the ruling Hamas party kidnapped an Israeli soldier in June, the air force has destroyed the homes of at least 73 militants, usually after calling owners and warning residents to evacuate. House demolitions are considered harsh punishment in crowded Gaza.

Most people live in densely populated apartment blocks with extended families, and dozens are often left homeless when one building is destroyed… ‘It is wrong for Israel to bomb people’s houses,’ Dougherty said. ‘We are here in solidarity, and to try to communicate to the world what is really going on.’

The nun and priest, dressed in shirts and pants, said they were staying for several hours at each of the targeted houses. They were warmly welcomed by Ahmed Baroud, a brother of the militant… However, the New York-based Human Rights Watch said militants calling on civilians to act as human shields was a ‘war crime.’

‘There is no excuse for calling civilians to the scene of a planned attack,’ said Sarah Leah Whitson, Middle East director. The rights group also criticized Israel’s policy of shelling houses. The Israeli military said the militants were exploiting civilians. ‘It just further demonstrates the cynical use of civilians by terrorists,’ said Israeli army Capt.

Noa Meir… Visiting U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights Louise Arbor said Tuesday the human shield tactic was a sign of Palestinian desperation. ‘There is something frankly almost pathetic in the sense of despair … civilians rallying in a defensive gesture,’ she said during a Gaza visit.”

Three days later, the human shields are an American nun and an American priest. The page carries the answers from all sides: the activists, Human Rights Watch calling the tactic a war crime, the Israeli army, and the U.N. commissioner. The paper spells her Arbor.

CP-2006-004 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago · page 1

Use of human shields complicates Israel’s approach

Middle East tactics

Joel Greenberg, Tribune foreign correspondent, Beit Lahiya, Gaza Strip

BEIT LAHIYA, Gaza Strip — On a rooftop in a crowded neighborhood here, about 30 Palestinian women sat on chairs and mattresses on a recent afternoon, serving as human shields against a possible Israeli air strike on the family home of a prominent Hamas militant. As an Israeli drone buzzed overhead, the women were defiant.

“Our technology is faith in God,” said Itaf al-Masri, 47.

The scene was an example of the kind of struggle waged here in recent months between the Israeli military and the Palestinians, a battle between a high-tech army and the simpler arms and tactics of militants and their civilian supporters… Gaza militants fired crude but deadly homemade rockets at Israel and dug tunnels under the border with Egypt to smuggle in arms.

In one standoff with Israeli troops, Palestinian women marched to a mosque where militants were holed up and enabled them to escape. The Israelis used sophisticated surveillance technology and aircraft to hunt down rocket squads and kill militant leaders, often also hitting civilians…

A united front. Flags of several Palestinian factions flew from the threatened house in Beit Lahiya last week, showing a united front against the Israelis, who had warned in a telephone call that residents should leave because the house would be hit.

“We can’t go out and fight with guns, so we are participating in the resistance this way, protecting our houses, and our children from expulsion. Where else can we go?” said Maha Rajab, 35, who lives in the targeted home.

The shielding tactic, used in at least two other houses whose residents were warned to vacate, created a new challenge for the Israeli army, which had been bombing homes of suspected militants with regularity in recent months, saying the buildings were used to store weapons.

A total of 105 homes were destroyed in the Gaza Strip since July after residents were warned to leave, according to figures compiled by the Israeli human-rights group B’Tselem. With human shields gathering at targeted houses, that tactic will have to be reconsidered in any future confrontation.

“It definitely complicates the situation, and Israel will have to overcome it,” said Boaz Ganor, an Israeli expert on counterterrorism at the Interdisciplinary Center in Herzliya. “That’s the whole story of asymmetric war: The number of troops and type of weapons is not as important as in regular warfare.”

Army weighing its strategy. Maj. Avital Leibovich, a spokeswoman for the army, acknowledged that the army was weighing its tactics. “We have to examine what we will do in the next cases,” she said. “It is a dilemma, and we are looking for a possible solution in the future. But this dilemma is created by the militants every time.

They are responsible for the life of innocent women and children if they get hurt.” The New York-based group Human Rights Watch called the Palestinian use of human shields a war crime and said the Israeli army had respected its obligations under international law by suspending an attack on one house that could have inflicted heavy civilian casualties.

But Palestinians who came to the homes said they were acting to protect their neighborhoods from further destruction. Nihad Rajab, 30, came to the house in Beit Lahiya with her two daughters, ages 4 and 1. She said that every Israeli bombing threatened people in adjacent homes and that the whole area was at risk.

“I don’t feel secure in my own house,” she said.

The women are named and asked why. Human Rights Watch calls the practice a war crime and in the same sentence says the Israeli army respected its obligations by calling off a strike. The army spokeswoman calls it a dilemma. Everything is in one column.

CP-2006-005 →

· The Birmingham News · Birmingham · page 1

No one seeks to wipe out Palestinians

Nate Salant, Hoover

“A recent letter sneaked in a mention of ‘genocide’ in Palestine and compared it to the Nazis. There is no comparison. No one seeks to wipe Palestinians off the face of the Earth the way the Nazis tried to wipe out the Jews and gypsies; that is, unless it is Hamas trying to wipe out Fatah, and vice-versa. Adolf Hitler never handed the Jews their own place to live.

Israel handed Gaza to the Palestinian Authority and is willing to give up most of the West Bank, too. No Jews or gypsies fired artillery (the 1940s equivalent of rockets) into Germany or any other part of Europe, for that matter.

If either side is Nazi-like, it is the Palestinians, whose charter still calls for wiping Israel off the face of the Earth and forbids Jews from living in any eventual Palestinian country.”

The answer, in the same letters column, with the word back inside quotation marks. Kept because the argument ran both ways on these pages and the archive is not a clipping service for one side of it.

CP-2007-001 →

· The Island Packet · Hilton Head Island

University degree can be Palestinian bride’s biggest asset

The Associated Press

ABWEEN, West Bank — The village matchmaker described the perfect Palestinian bride: tall, slim, fair-skinned — and college-educated. Times are tough, explained Nawal Sehwel, the local cupid, and a college degree means an extra salary.

With poverty spreading after six years of fighting with Israel, that’s a mantra heard across the Palestinian territories, where marriage is a balancing act between tribal traditions and urban modernity. In the West Bank town of Ramallah, young career women increasingly pick their own mates, in defiance of tradition and sometimes their parents’ wishes.

In conservative Gaza, women still are married off by their families, often to men they have never met, and would be branded immoral if they asked to have a say.

Palestinian brides are among the youngest in the Arab world — 18 on average and one-fourth 16 or younger — in part because some parents want to get daughters out of the house quickly and have one mouth less to feed. A matchmaker is sometimes called in.

When Nawal Sehwel got her start in matchmaking four decades ago, marriage was strictly a business arrangement between families. Grooms wanted wives to bear them children and work in the fields. Sehwel, 57, follows a simple rule — match people who have something in common. The matchmaker said she has brought together roughly 200 couples, and none has split.

But business has dropped off in the past years, because women are getting out and making their own choices. Almost as many female as male students attend the 20 four-year and 20 community colleges in the Palestinian territories, according to official figures. Expectations also have changed.

“The new generation would not agree to marry without love,” said the matchmaker’s daughter, Nafeza, 36. Nafeza was forced into marriage at age 15 by her father and uncles, over her mother’s objections, and says it took her 10 years to accept her fate.

Palestinian relatives of Bissan Zedan, 17, center, prepare gold jewelry as a gift for groom Mohammed Zedan, 21, right, during their engagement celebration in the West Bank. Palestinian brides are among the youngest brides in the Arab world. (The Associated Press)

Four Palestinians named in one story and not one of them is a casualty, a spokesman or an official. Nawal Sehwel, 57, a village matchmaker in Abween who has made about two hundred marriages and says none has broken. Her daughter Nafeza, 36, who was married off at fifteen by her father and uncles over her mother’s objections and says it took her ten years to accept it — and who supplies the line the story turns on: ‘The new generation would not agree to marry without love.’ And the couple in the photograph, Bissan Zedan, 17, and Mohammed Zedan, 21. The occupation is present but as economics: poverty after six years of fighting, and a degree worth an extra salary. Nearly as many women as men attend the territories’ forty colleges, which is why the matchmaker’s trade is dying.

CP-2007-008 →

· St. Louis Post-Dispatch · St. Louis

Better educated women make their own choices

Business falls off for Palestinian matchmaker

By Karin Laub, The Associated Press

ABWEEN, WEST BANK — The village matchmaker described the perfect Palestinian bride: tall, slim, fair-skinned — and college-educated. Times are tough, explained Nawal Sehwel, the local cupid, and a college degree means an extra salary.

With poverty spreading after six years of fighting with Israel, that’s a mantra heard across the Palestinian territories, where marriage is an increasingly delicate balancing act between tribal traditions and urban modernity.

In the West Bank town of Ramallah, young career women increasingly pick their own mates, in defiance of tradition and sometimes their parents’ wishes. In conservative Gaza, where veils as a show of piety are becoming more common, women are still married off by their families, often to men they have never met.

Palestinian brides are among the youngest in the Arab world — 18 on average and one-fourth of them 16 or younger — in part because some parents want to get daughters out of the house quickly and have one mouth less to feed. Yet 12 percent never marry, far more than in most other Arab countries, in part because so many young men emigrate or are in Israeli prisons.

Here, a bachelor’s mother and sisters initiate the search for a bride. Sometimes a matchmaker is called in. When Sehwel, a farmer’s wife, got her start in matchmaking four decades ago, marriage was strictly a business arrangement between families, particularly in rural areas. Grooms wanted wives to bear them children and work in the fields.

Her first client, a cousin from Kuwait, simply asked that his bride be tall, and proposed to her after one chaperoned meeting. Sehwel, 57, follows a simple rule: Match people who have something in common. She operates mostly by phone. Her reward is her neighbors’ respect, she said. She insists she gets no payment or gift.

Sehwel was married off to a neighbor’s son, no questions asked, when she was 17, and she believes her system is superior to the Western ideal of romantic love. She said that she had brought together roughly 200 couples, and that none had split. INSISTING ON LOVE.

But business has dropped off, down to six couples in the past two years, because women are increasingly getting out into the world and making their own choices. Almost as many female as male students attend colleges in the Palestinian territories, according to official figures. Expectations have also changed.

“The new generation would not agree to marry without love,” said the matchmaker’s daughter, Nafeza, 36. Nafeza was forced into marriage at age 15 by her father and uncles, over her mother’s objections. She says it took her 10 years to accept her fate. Yet even in today’s changing marriage market, some things remain the same.

Some 25 percent of the couples are cousins, according to official figures, reflecting families’ concerns about entrusting their daughters to outsiders. The bride customarily moves in with the husband’s family. And youth and beauty are still key assets.

A bride should be 22 or younger; after age 25, she may have to settle for a divorced man or a widower with children, said Sehwel. The ideal she describes is close to that of the West and drawn from its movie and TV imagery — tall, slender, fair-skinned, with blue or green eyes.

A good education can make up for a plain girl’s looks, Sehwel said, as can a foreign passport — preferably American — to escape the fighting and joblessness and settle abroad.

Relatives of Bissan Zedan (center), 17, prepare jewelry earlier this month as a gift for Mohammed Zedan (right), 21, at their engagement party in the village of Beir Nabala. (The Associated Press)

One of five American printings of Karin Laub’s dispatch held here, all from the same week, and the five headlines do not agree about who the story is about. This is the only one of the five whose headline makes the women the subject of a sentence rather than the asset in it. It is also the fullest printing, and it carries a clause the others cut: 12 percent never marry, far more than in most other Arab countries, in part because so many young men emigrate or are in Israeli prisons. The shorter printings keep the matchmaker and drop the prisons.

CP-2007-009 →

· Goldsboro News-Argus · Goldsboro

University degree can be Palestinian bride’s best asset

Marriage becomes an increasingly delicate balancing act between tribal traditions and urban modernity.

By Karin Laub, Associated Press

ABWEEN, West Bank — The village matchmaker described the perfect Palestinian bride: tall, slim, fair-skinned — and college-educated. Times are tough, explained Nawal Sehwel, the local cupid, and a college degree means an extra salary.

With poverty spreading after six years of fighting with Israel, that’s a mantra heard across the Palestinian territories, where marriage is an increasingly delicate balancing act between tribal traditions and urban modernity.

In the West Bank town of Ramallah, bastion of the educated middle class, young career women increasingly pick their own mates, in defiance of tradition and sometimes their parents’ wishes.

In conservative Gaza, where veils as a show of piety are becoming more common, women are still married off by their families, often to men they have never met, and would be branded immoral if they asked to have a say. Some of the customs, such as marriage among cousins, are found across the Arab world, while others are linked to the Palestinians’ dire straits.

Palestinian brides are among the youngest in the Arab world — 18 on average and one-fourth 16 or younger — in part because some parents want to get daughters out of the house quickly and have one mouth less to feed. Yet 12 percent never marry, far more than in most other Arab countries, in part because so many young men emigrate or are in Israeli prisons.

Here, a bachelor’s mother and sisters initiate the search. The final decision is up to the groom, and the bride is expected to go along with it, though she has the right to turn him down. A matchmaker is sometimes called in.

When Sehwel, a farmer’s wife, got her start in matchmaking four decades ago, marriage was strictly a business arrangement between families, particular in rural areas. Grooms wanted wives to bear them children and work in the fields, and didn’t have expectations of finding a soulmate.

Nawal Sehwel, 57, a local matchmaker, prepares coffee for a family member at her home in the village of Abween, near the West Bank town of Ramallah, in November 2006.

The matchmaker said she has brought together roughly 200 couples, and none has split. / Relatives of Bissan Zedan, 17, center left, prepare gold jewelry as a gift for groom Mohammed Zedan, 21, right, during their engagement celebration in January 2006 in the West Bank village of Beir Nabala, near Ramallah.

One of five American printings of Karin Laub’s dispatch held here, all from the same week, and the five headlines do not agree about who the story is about. Best asset. The bride is the thing being valued.

CP-2007-010 →

· Lansing State Journal · Lansing · page 5A

Palestinian women adding college to marital assets

Degree means extra paycheck in area mired in poverty

By Karin Laub, Associated Press

ABWEEN, West Bank — The village matchmaker described the perfect Palestinian bride: tall, slim, fair-skinned — and college-educated. Times are tough, explained Nawal Sehwel, the local cupid, and a college degree means an extra salary.

With poverty spreading after six years of fighting with Israel, that’s a mantra heard across the Palestinian territories, where marriage is an increasingly delicate balancing act between tribal traditions and urban modernity.

In the West Bank town of Ramallah, bastion of the educated middle class, young career women increasingly pick their own mates, in defiance of tradition and sometimes their parents’ wishes.

In conservative Gaza, where veils as a show of piety are becoming more common, women are still married off by their families, often to men they have never met, and would be branded immoral if they asked to have a say.

Dire straits Some of the customs, such as marriage among cousins, are found across the Arab world, while others are linked to the Palestinians’ dire straits.

Palestinian brides are among the youngest in the Arab world — 18 on average and one-fourth 16 or younger — in part because some parents want to get daughters out of the house quickly and have one mouth less to feed. Yet 12 percent never marry, far more than in most other Arab countries, in part because so many young men emigrate or are in Israeli prisons.

Here, a bachelor’s mother and sisters initiate the search. The final decision is up to the groom, and the bride is expected to go along with it, though she has the right to turn him down. A matchmaker is sometimes called in.

Socializing on campus: A young Palestinian woman speaks with a male student last month at Bir Zeit University near Ramallah. In cosmopolitan Ramallah, young career women increasingly pick their own mates, in defiance of tradition.

One of five American printings of Karin Laub’s dispatch held here, all from the same week, and the five headlines do not agree about who the story is about. Adding college to marital assets. The degree joins the list of things a wife brings.

CP-2007-011 →

· Roanoke Times · Roanoke

Palestinian brides’ assets evolve — to a degree

As poverty spreads, educated women are favored in the tradition of arranged marriages.

By Karin Laub, Associated Press

ABWEEN, West Bank — The village matchmaker described the perfect Palestinian bride: tall, slim, fair-skinned — and college-educated. Times are tough, explained Nawal Sehwel, the local cupid, and a college degree means an extra salary.

With poverty spreading after six years of fighting with Israel, that’s a mantra heard across the Palestinian territories, where marriage is an increasingly delicate balancing act between tribal traditions and urban modernity.

In the West Bank town of Ramallah, bastion of the educated middle class, young career women increasingly pick their own mates, in defiance of tradition and sometimes their parents’ wishes.

In conservative Gaza, where veils as a show of piety are becoming more common, women are still married off by their families, often to men they have never met, and would be branded immoral if they asked to have a say. Some of the customs, such as marriage among cousins, are found across the Arab world, while others are linked to the Palestinians’ dire straits.

Palestinian brides are among the youngest in the Arab world — 18 on average and one-fourth 16 or younger — in part because some parents want to get daughters out of the house quickly and have one mouth less to feed. Yet 12 percent never marry, far more than in most other Arab countries, in part because so many young men emigrate or are in Israeli prisons.

Here, a bachelor’s mother and sisters initiate the search. The final decision is up to the groom, and the bride is expected to go along with it, though she has the right to turn him down. Yet even in today’s changing marriage market, some things remain the same.

Some 25 percent of the couples are cousins, according to official figures, reflecting families’ concerns about entrusting their daughters to outsiders. The bride customarily moves in with the husband’s family. And youth and beauty are still key assets.

A bride should be 22 or younger; after age 25, she might have to settle for a divorced man or widower man with children, said Sehwel. A good education can make up for homely looks, Sehwel said, as can a foreign passport — preferably American — to escape the fighting and joblessness and settle abroad.

Education student Islam al-Haj, 23, holding her son, Mohammed, says her husband insisted she continue school after she gave birth.

One of five American printings of Karin Laub’s dispatch held here, all from the same week, and the five headlines do not agree about who the story is about. A week later than the rest, and the only one that makes a pun of it.

CP-2007-012 →

· Log Cabin Democrat · Conway

Cartoon character urging Palestinian children to fight pulled for review

“Hamas militants have suspended a TV program that featured a Mickey Mouse lookalike urging Palestinian children to fight Israel… Information Minister Mustafa Barghouti said the character…”

Conway, Arkansas. A story about Palestinian children that reached small-town America when the subject was a cartoon rodent.

CP-2007-016 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago

Hamas takeover of Gaza

Israel, Fatah had coordinated relief

By Richard Boudreaux, Tribune Newspapers

“…mercial cargo and humanitarian relief supplies. Those goods, including United Nations-administered food aid to two-thirds of Gaza’s population, passed into Gaza through border crossings under U.S.-supervised agree…”

Four days after Hamas took the Gaza Strip. The headline puts the takeover in the subject position and cripples as its verb, and the object is the aid. The fragment of the story that survives on this scan carries the fact that gives the sentence its weight and that the headline leaves out: two-thirds of the population of Gaza was living on United Nations-administered food before any of this happened.

CP-2007-003 →

· estimated · Richmond Times-Dispatch · Richmond

Border closure stops construction in Gaza

U.N. projects wait while Israel lets in only essential goods

The Associated Press

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — The United Nations yesterday suspended construction of homes, schools and an emergency sewage system in the Gaza Strip, blaming a shortage of building materials resulting from Israel’s closure.

The move, which threatens the jobs of 121,000 Palestinians, is the latest hardship facing the poverty-stricken territory buffeted by infighting, ruled by Islamic militants and tightly controlled by Israel. John Ging, director of the U.N.

Relief and Works Agency in Gaza, said many houses in refugee camps were damaged during months of clashes between Hamas and rival Fatah forces and his agency lacks repair supplies. He said school repairs and construction also have fallen behind schedule, leaving children without classrooms.

“Some $93 million worth of projects are on hold because cement and other building supplies have run out,” Ging said. In the southern town of Rafah, the concrete skeletons of dozens of partly finished houses rise from the sand, part of a refugee camp hard hit by Israeli military operations before 2005 and later Palestinian infighting.

Construction has been halted, forcing dozens of destitute families to crowd in with relatives. About 1.4 million people are jammed into Gaza, a territory 25 miles long and six miles wide with no natural resources. It is hemmed in on two sides by Israel, one side by the Egyptian Sinai desert and the last by the Mediterranean Sea.

Ging said the shortage of building materials was the result of severely limited imports through crossings between Gaza and Israel. Since Hamas defeated Fatah forces and took control of Gaza last month, Israel has shut the crossings except for humanitarian assistance, citing security threats.

Shlomo Dror, spokesman for the Israeli army unit that deals with Gaza issues, said some cement is being let in along with the emergency supplies, and other building materials would be added to the next shipment.

Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping — the trim begins at the headline. Nothing on it names the newspaper. The lead says the U.N. acted “yesterday” and the story places the Hamas takeover of Gaza “last month”, which is consistent with a July 2007 paper, but neither 2007-07-10 nor pub “Richmond Times-Dispatch” could be checked against the page.

CP-2007-017 →

· The Bay City Times · Bay City

Israel releases 250 Palestinian prisoners today

By DALIA NAMMARI, ASSOCIATED PRESS

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Israel released more than 250 Palestinian prisoners today in an attempt to bolster moderate Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas in his power struggle with Hamas. Leaning out of bus windows and hoisting Palestinian flags, the prisoners headed to Abbas' headquarters in the West Bank city of Ramallah for a festive reception.

“All the suffering, all the pain is gone,” said released prisoner Iyad Milhem, 30, as he rode on one of the buses. “But we still hope for the release of all the other prisoners.” Most of those released were from Abbas' Fatah movement.

Prominent among the freed prisoners was 61-year-old Abdel Rahim Malouh, second-in-command in a small PLO faction, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which assassinated an Israeli Cabinet minister in 2001. Israeli and Palestinian officials said they hoped the release marked a new chapter in relations following seven years of bloody fighting.

The new cooperation between Israel and the moderate Palestinian leadership was driven, in part, by the violent takeover of Gaza by Hamas last month. Today's release began shortly after daybreak when the shackled prisoners left the Ketziot prison camp in southern Israel and boarded buses with darkened windows that took them to the West Bank.

At an Israeli military checkpoint in the West Bank, the prisoners got off the buses, some kissing the ground, and boarded Palestinian buses that took them to the West Bank. Israel holds about 9,200 Palestinian prisoners, most of whom were arrested during the past seven years of Israeli-Palestinian fighting.

Almost every Palestinian family has had a member in Israeli jails at some point, and the fate of the prisoners is one of the most emotionally charged issues of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

For Palestinians, the prisoners are heroes in the struggle for statehood, and large-scale prisoner releases are seen as an effective way for Israel to back Abbas in his confrontation with the Islamic militants who took the Gaza Strip by force last month. However, Israel refuses to free inmates serving time for wounding or killing Israelis, in part for fear of a public outcry.

None of the prisoners being freed Friday was directly involved in attacks on Israelis, according to Israeli officials. Earlier this week, families of victims of Palestinian attacks tried to stop the release with a Supreme Court appeal, but the court backed the government.

Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman Mark Regev said the prisoner release is part of a package of goodwill gestures that is to give new momentum to stalled peace efforts.

“We're hopeful that the combined steps by the Israeli government and the Palestinian government can bring about a new period of cooperation and dialogue, that we have turned the corner on the negative dynamic,” Regev said. However, Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad said Israel needs to do more to improve the atmosphere. “Your policy is a policy of small change.

You do a little here, a little there,” he told the Israeli daily Yediot Ahronot in an interview published today.

Freedom: An Israeli prison gourd escorts a Palestinian prisoner on board a bus prior to leaving Ketziot prison camp in southern Israel's Negev desert today. Israel started releasing more than 250 Palestinian prisoners in an attempt to bolster moderate Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas in his power struggle with Hamas.

The same day's Associated Press copy as the Evening Sun printing, under a different headline and with a different photograph. The paper's own spelling of gourd for guard in the caption is kept.

CP-2007-014 →

· The Evening Sun

255 Palestinian prisoners released

Israel offers freedom

By DALIA NAMMARI, Associated Press Writer

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Israel released more than 250 Palestinian prisoners today in a gesture to embattled President Mahmoud Abbas, who pledged not to rest until Israel's jails were emptied of its thousands of Palestinians. The release was meant to bolster Abbas in his power struggle with the Islamic militant Hamas, which took control of Gaza by force last month.

Several thousand chanting, clapping Palestinians greeted the prisoners as their buses rolled into Abbas' headquarters in the West Bank city of Ramallah. “This is the beginning,” said Abbas, wearing a black-and-white checkered baseball cap, a symbol of Palestinian nationalism. “Efforts must continue. Our work must continue until every prisoner returns to the his home,” he said.

Israeli and officials of Abbas' government said they hoped the release marked a new chapter in relations, following seven years of bloody fighting. “All the suffering, all the pain is gone,” said released prisoner Iyad Milhem, 30, as he rode on one of the buses. “But we still hope for the release of all the other prisoners.” Most of those freed were from Abbas' Fatah movement.

Prominent among them was 61-year-old Abdel Rahim Malouh, second-in-command in a small PLO faction, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which assassinated an Israeli Cabinet minister in 2001.

Today's release began shortly after daybreak when the shackled prisoners left the Ketziot prison camp in southern Israel and boarded buses with darkened windows that took them to the West Bank. At an Israeli military checkpoint in the West Bank, the prisoners got off the buses, some kissing the ground, and boarded Palestinian buses that took them to Ramallah.

Israel had agreed to release 256 prisoners, but one was held back for further security checks, said Eli Gadizon, of the Israel Prisons' Service. All the inmates were required to sign an undertaking not to engage in anti-Israel violence. Israel holds about 9,200 Palestinian prisoners, most of whom were arrested during the past seven years of Israeli-Palestinian fighting.

Almost every Palestinian family has had a member in Israeli jails at some point, and the fate of the prisoners is one of the most emotionally charged issues of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

For Palestinians, the prisoners are heroes in the struggle for statehood, and large-scale prisoner releases are seen as an effective way for Israel to back Abbas in his confrontation with the Islamic militants. However, Israel refuses to free inmates serving time for wounding or killing Israelis, in part for fear of a public outcry.

None of the prisoners being freed today were directly involved in attacks on Israelis, according to Israeli officials.

Palestinian prisoners are seen inside their cell today before leaving Ketziot prison camp in southern Israel's Negev desert. Israel started releasing more than 250 Palestinian prisoners in an attempt to bolster moderate Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas in his power struggle with Hamas.

The same day's Associated Press copy as the Bay City Times printing, under a different headline, at a different length and with a different photograph. This printing carries the count 255 in the headline and the detail of the 256th prisoner held back.

CP-2007-015 →

· Star Herald · page 9A

Israel releases more than 250 prisoners

RAMALLAH, West Bank (AP) — Family and friends joyously hugged 255 Palestinians freed by Israel on Friday, hoisting them on shoulders for a boisterous heroes’ welcome meant to give President Mahmoud Abbas a political boost in his power struggle with Hamas.

But thousands more Palestinians remained in Israeli jails, and aides to Abbas said Israel must do more to help the moderate leader after years of failed peace efforts. The Islamic militant Hamas, which seized control of the Gaza Strip by force last month, belittled the prisoner release.

Most of those let go were members of Abbas’ largely secular Fatah movement and none belonged to Hamas. Elation reigned at Abbas’ West Bank headquarters. Thousands of whistling, cheering and clapping Palestinians greeted the freed men as their buses rolled into the walled compound in Ramallah.

Shaded from the fierce sun by a big Palestinian flag, Mohammed Abdullah scoured the buses for a glimpse of his 27-year-old son, Majdi, who served half of a 10-year sentence for anti-Israeli activities as a member of the Al Aqsa Martyrs’ Brigades, a violent Fatah offshoot.

After spotting Majdi, Abdullah and his wife, Fatima, embraced their son, showered him with candy and said they had slaughter a calf in his honor. “This is the beginning of a new stage, when we can live in two countries next to each other in peace,” Abdullah said later, after taking Majdi home.

Abdullah, a father of 11, said he was jailed by Israel as a young man and four of his sons had been locked up. Some of the prisoners suggested the era of armed attacks on Israel is over. “We want to send a message to the rest of the world that we want peace for our people,” Majdi Abdullah said.

Others said they were eager to take revenge against Hamas for the Gaza takeover. Israel holds some 9,200 Palestinians, most arrested during the past seven years of Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Almost every Palestinian family has had a member in Israeli jails at some point, making the fate of prisoners one of the most emotionally charged issues in dealing with Israel.

Released Palestinian prisoner Mohannad Jaradat is greeted by one of his sisters as he arrives to his family house at the West Bank village of Seelat Al-Haretyieh, next to Jenin, Friday.

Date check: The running head reads “Star-Herald” at the left, the section flag “World” in the centre, and at the right “SATURDAY, JULY 21, 2007 9A”. Paper, date and page all match the slide label, and July 21, 2007 was a Saturday.

CP-2007-018 →

· Gettysburg Times · Gettysburg · page 1

EU cuts electricity funding to Gaza, says Hamas ‘diverting’ revenues

Ibrahim Barzak, Associated Press Writer, Gaza City

“GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip (AP) — Electricity in Gaza on Monday became the latest battleground in the struggle between the coastal strip’s Islamic Hamas rulers and their Fatah rivals, who have accused Hamas of pocketing electricity revenues.

The losers are hundreds of thousands of Gazans, who have been plunged into darkness as European donors cut off key electricity aid. On Sunday, the European Union stopped paying for fuel to power generators that produce electricity for at least half of Gaza’s population of 1.4 million.

On Monday, it said the payments would not resume because it had received word that Hamas was ‘diverting’ electricity revenues.

‘We are ready to resume our support to the Gaza power plant within hours once we receive the appropriate assurances that all the funds will be exclusively used for the benefit of the Gaza population,’ the European Commission — the EU’s executive branch — said in a statement.

Hamas has controlled Gaza since it vanquished Fatah gunmen in fierce fighting in June. The Fatah-led government that Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas set up in the West Bank has accused Hamas of siphoning off electricity revenues.

‘Hamas is collecting all the electricity fees and never pays the costs of the electricity,’ said [a Fatah official]… ‘In the next few days, the government will announce the investigations of the former director of the company, who stole money the EU donated,’ [said] Araj, a Hamas adviser.

In recent weeks, Hamas has been going door to door in Gaza ordering residents to pay long overdue electricity bills. While Hamas denies that it controls the electricity company, Fatah insists it does — citing the director’s arrest as evidence.

Jehad Hamad, a political analyst based in Gaza, said electricity is one of many battlegrounds the two sides are using to try to gain the upper hand. The Ramallah government, Hamad added, might be worried that Hamas has uncovered proof that Fatah officials skimmed off money from the electrical company in the past.

‘Electricity is a “hot-button” issue,’ he said. The suspension of the EU fuel payments dealt a harsh blow to at least 700,000 Palestinians who live in central Gaza. Electricity had already been cut back sharply last week after Israel closed a fuel crossing into the coastal territory, citing security concerns.

Israel reopened the passage Sunday, but the plant’s Israeli fuel supplier didn’t deliver fuel to the power plant, on instructions from the European Union.”

“A Palestinian man uses candles for light as he prepares water pipes at his cafe after the electricity was cut in the area of Gaza City, Sunday. The European Union cut off vital funding to a Gaza power plant on Sunday, forcing it to shut down the last of its generators and darken tens of thousands of Palestinian homes.

The shutdown was another blow to the long-suffering residents of the Gaza Strip, where the Islamic group Hamas has been governing, largely under international isolation, since June.” AP Photo / Khalil Hamra

Written from Gaza City by a Palestinian reporter for the Associated Press. One quotation in the left column is cut by the clipping’s edge and the speaker’s name with it; nothing has been supplied for it.

CP-2007-004 →

· Press of Atlantic City · Atlantic City

Surfer seeks to conquer wave of Gaza violence

Jewish surfing guru Dorian Paskowitz, 86, hopes his donation of 12 surfboards to Palestinian surfers will promote peace in the Gaza Strip.

By ARON HELLER, Associated Press

JERUSALEM — An 86-year-old Jewish surfing guru from Hawaii is bringing good vibrations to the impoverished Gaza Strip. Dorian Paskowitz, a retired doctor who has been surfing for 75 years, donated 12 surfboards to Gaza's small surfing community Tuesday in a novel gesture to promote peace between Israelis and Palestinians.

“God will surf with the devil if the waves are good,” Paskowitz said. “When a surfer sees another surfer with a board, he can't help but say something that brings them together.” Tanned and shirtless, Paskowitz emerged grinning at the Israel-Gaza border crossing after handing over the dozen boards to Palestinian surfers waiting on the other side.

He said he was inspired after reading a story about two Gaza surfers who could not enjoy the wild waves off the coastal strip because they had only one board to share between them. “So I said to my son, ‘Come, we'll go to Israel and get them some boards,’” Paskowitz said. He described his mission as a “mitzvah,” Hebrew for a “good deed.”

During his visit, Paskowitz said he wanted to “do something spectacular, like getting all the surfers and paddling around into the waters of Gaza.” But those plans were scuttled because of security concerns.

Arthur Rashkovan, a 28-year-old surfer from Tel Aviv, said Paskowitz's project was part of a larger effort called “Surfing for Peace,” aimed at bringing Middle Eastern surfers closer together. He said eight-time world surfing champion Kelly Slater, who is of Syrian descent, is expected to arrive in Israel in October to take part in the drive.

“We want Palestinians to enjoy the surfing experience. We believe it brings people together,” Rashkovan said. “The idea is for people to forget about the violence and follow the journey to peace on the waves.” Paskowitz is venerated by Israeli surfers as the man who brought the sport to the Jewish state five decades ago. Rashkovan called him a “guru” to Israeli surfers.

Paskowitz said he first arrived in Israel in 1956 during a war between Israel and Egypt. He tried to join the Israeli military but was turned down. So he surfed off the coast of Tel Aviv instead, he recounted, and was mobbed by Israelis charmed by the strange sight of a man riding the waves standing upright on a board.

The father of nine served in the Navy during World War II, practiced family medicine for more than half a century and has published books on surfing and health. He said he has surfed for 75 years all over the world, and he ranks the waves off the Israeli and Gaza coasts as among the world's best. “I'm 86 years old.

I can't stand up very well, I have a piece of titanium in my hip. But I still love it,” he said.

Hawaiian Dorian Paskowitz carries two surfboards across the Erez crossing on Tuesday that are part of personal donation to Palestinian youths in the Gaza Strip.

CP-2007-013 →

· The Sun · Baltimore · page 1

Israel claims it foiled Palestinian plot to kill Olmert

By Josef Federman, Associated Press, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli officials on Sunday said they foiled a recent attempt by Palestinian militants to assassinate Prime Minister Ehud Olmert during a trip to the West Bank and warned the plot could hurt prospects for an upcoming U.S.-hosted Mideast peace conference… “It clouds the atmosphere of the conference,” Olmert said before leaving on a trip to France… Diskin did not say how close the militants were to carrying out the plot, and it was not clear why Olmert was allowed to proceed on his trip if there was a threat to his life.… “The interrogation did not reveal according to our security services anything that was imminently dangerous,” [Salam Fayyad] said… “This is one more attempt to put obstacles in the way to the fall conference,” said Nabil Abu Rdeneh, a spokesman for Abbas.

Disabled Palestinian artist Mohammed Shaban paints a mural on a wall depicting the face of late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat in the West Bank city of Jenin on Sunday.

He is named, he is called an artist, his work is the only picture on the page, and he is in no sentence of the story. Ten weeks later another American paper ran a second photograph of the same man and the same wall, and did the same thing. The photographer here is Mohammed Ballas, who also shot the 2004 story about Palestinian women winning council seats.

CP-2007-006 →

· The Register-Guard · Eugene · page 1

‘Al-Nakba denial’ pervades letter

Mariah Leung, Eugene

“Claire Gumbs’ Dec. 4 letter, ‘Palestine no longer exists,’ provides a flagrant example of ‘al-Nakba denial.’ No less objectionable than Holocaust denial, our human rights community should protest this ignorance.

Gumbs’ letter reflects a carefully orchestrated, 59-year campaign of al-Nakba memoricide in an attempt to legitimize an apartheid state supported by U.S. taxpayer money. Gumbs states, ‘there is no such thing as … a Palestinian.’ Please tell that to the indigenous refugees and their families of the 531 villages and 11 urban areas that were brutally ethnically cleansed in 1948.

Palestinians with U.N.-registered claims against Israel now number more than 4 million, the world’s largest refugee group, now spanning four generations. Called ‘al-Nakba’ (‘the catastrophe’), this Arabic term should be as familiar to us as the Holocaust which it soon followed.

The campaign to expel as many Arabs as possible — in any way possible — was executed against a largely defenseless population by the Jewish terrorist groups Haganah, Irgun and the Stern Gang. Israel’s Palestinian victims continue to be denied their basic human rights under the U.N.

Charter, the Geneva Conventions, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and some 90 U.N. resolutions against Israel. Peace in Israel-Palestine will elude fruition until Israel’s 1948 crimes against humanity are acknowledged and the right of return or just compensation is granted to the refugees as required under U.N.

Resolution 194 and pledged by Israel upon admission to the United Nations. For background, read Israeli historian Ilan Pappe’s book, ‘The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine.’”

A reader answering another reader by name, ten days later, in the same letters column.

CP-2007-005 →

· Leader-Telegram · page 1

Israeli premier: Peace unlikely

Associated Press, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM (AP) — Furious over the killing of two Israelis hiking in the West Bank, Israel’s prime minister said Sunday that no peace will come until Palestinians crack down on militants, a declaration that clouds a coming visit by President Bush. To clear the way for Bush to push for progress, the two sides had just agreed to paper over another spat: Israel’s plan to build 307 new apartments in a Jewish neighborhood in east Jerusalem, the section claimed by the Palestinians.… “As long as the Palestinian Authority doesn’t take the necessary steps and act with the necessary vigor against terror organizations, Israel won’t be able to carry out any change that would expose it to any jeopardy or endanger Israel’s security,” he said… “To address this issue between Palestinians and Israelis, we need the resumption of a meaningful peace process,” Erekat said.

Disabled Palestinian artist Mohammed Shaban painted a mural on a wall depicting the face of former Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein, left, next to a mural depicting late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat in the West Bank city of Jenin, Sunday.

The second time in ten weeks that this man’s painting is the photograph on an American page and this man is in none of its sentences. Both papers name him. Both call him a disabled Palestinian artist. Neither asks him anything.

CP-2007-007 →

· Columbia Daily Tribune · Columbia · page 1

Food, not bombs

Palestinians draw cultural focus to cuisine and away from combat.

Diaa Hadid, Associated Press Writer, Bethlehem

BETHLEHEM, West Bank — It’s the most talked-about conflict in the world — but the food remains a mystery.

Despite decades of attention to the Mideast, Palestinian cooking is all but unknown to a world more familiar with images of angry Palestinians with AK-47s than chefs creating delicate salads or carefully roasted stuffed pigeon. “We do have fighters,” said Fadi Kattan, organizer of the Second Palestinian Culinary Competition, a recent effort to raise the profile of the region’s cuisine.

“But we also have other things that make us Palestinian.” One reason so little is known about those other things, Palestinians say, lies with politics: Years of Israel-Palestinian fighting have ravaged the Palestinian middle class, leaving enough patrons for only a handful of high-end Palestinian restaurants.

With so many families destroyed by poverty and fighting — more than 80 percent of Gazans and almost 50 percent of West Bank residents live on less than $2 a day — the attention paid to food elsewhere in the world can seem frivolous… “We can’t wait forever,” said Abu Mahmoud, a Jerusalem taxi driver who cheered the idea of a competition.

Palestinian cooking is a regional variation on the Arabic-Mediterranean kitchen. It generously uses fresh seasonal vegetables such as cauliflower, zucchini, eggplant, tomatoes, onions, carrots, beans and potatoes. You can count on tasty spiced stews, padded with rice.

Chicken or meat tends to flavor dishes, not star in them, except for celebrations, where roasted whole goats and sheep are still served on platters of rice.

There’s also traditional Palestinian “fast food” — shared with its regional neighbors — hummus, falafel and shawarma… In conservative Palestinian culture, women mostly marry young and stay home, learning to cook from their mothers and neighbors.

There’s no need for cooks to teach them new tricks… Palestinians and Israelis both claim ownership of some foods, especially hummus. That’s prompted an online protest called “Hummus not Chummos,” a dig at the inability of some Israelis of European origin to pronounce the guttural “h” in hummus. During Kattan’s competition this year, 11 Palestinian chefs from Israel, the West Bank and Jerusalem were invited to innovate on traditional Palestinian recipes, as well as produce a freestyle dish of their choice.

Iyad Jallaf, 28, stood nervously before cool-eyed judges, presenting a slightly tweaked traditional Palestinian dish: grape leaves stuffed with rice and herbs alongside chicken filled with crushed nuts, instead of rice or barley.

Meanwhile, George Srour piled small rounds of flat bread topped with fried onions and chicken to create the classic Palestinian dish musakhan… “This is our first step,” Goric said of the 2-year-old competition, adding that it shows “Palestinian cuisine is important”… Nahed Mona, who works at the shop, says buyers mostly are Westerners looking to recreate meals enjoyed in the region… Anthropologist Ali Qleibo said despite the Palestinian notion that their food has always been the same, he said Palestinian kitchens had already seen dramatic changes during the past 80 years… “Palestinians know how to cook their own food.

They don’t need a book to tell them that,” said Mona.… Now Qleibo thinks Palestinian food should be pushed forward again and improved for modern tastes and the small Palestinian middle class who want to try new things. “Life is consuming beauty,” Qleibo said.…

BALILAH (Chickpea Salad). Start to finish: 20 minutes (10 minutes active). Servings: 4 to 6.

3 cups canned chickpeas, drained · 3 scallions, ends trimmed, thinly sliced · ½ cup chopped fresh parsley · ¼ cup lemon juice · ¼ cup extra-virgin olive oil · 1½ teaspoons salt · 1½ teaspoons cumin · ⅓ teaspoon freshly ground black pepper.

In a medium bowl, combine the chickpeas, scallions and parsley. Toss to combine. In a small bowl, whisk together the remaining ingredients, then pour over the chickpeas and toss to coat evenly. Let sit 10 minutes for the flavors to develop. Source: Christiane Dabdoub Nasser’s “Classic Palestinian Cookery,” (Saqi Books, 2001)

“Chickpeas are a staple of the Palestinian diet. In this salad, they are seasoned with a pungent but pleasing blend of cumin, olive oil and lemon juice.” · AP photo. Quick Bite box: “Maqluba, which means ‘upside down’ in Arabic, is one of the most popular family dishes in Palestine.

Essentially an eggplant and rice casserole, the dish is turned over before serving.”

A food page that states this archive’s subject in its first sentence and then answers it: the most talked-about conflict in the world, and the food remains a mystery. Seven Palestinians are named, a recipe is printed with a source, and the sidebar defines maqluba — the dish that turns up in three more American papers over the next fourteen years. Diaa Hadid, who filed this, also wrote the Associated Press obituary of Mahmoud Darwish seven months later, and Ali Qleibo is quoted in both.

CP-2008-008 →

· Centre Daily Times

Gaza falls into darkness as fuel cut off

The Associated Press

“Palestinian women in the West Bank participate in a protest against Israel on Sunday as Gaza City was plunged into darkness after Israel blocked the shipment of fuel that powers its only electrical plant.”

The photograph is of women protesting; the headline is about electricity. Israel calls the move retaliation.

CP-2008-014 →

· Great Falls Tribune · Great Falls · page 1

Breakout from Gaza

Hole in fence leads to time of freedom

Associated Press, Rafah

RAFAH, Gaza Strip (AP) — On foot, in cars and in donkey carts, tens of thousands of Gazans flooded into Egypt Wednesday through a border fence blown up by militants — puncturing a gaping hole in Israel’s airtight closure of the Gaza Strip… For ordinary Gazans, it was a day of joy and plenty. Osama Hassan, 25, said the border opening will enable him to marry his 17-year-old fiancee next week, because they were able to buy items they need to set up a household.

He bought a special mattress for his injured back and she assembled kitchen supplies.… “Freedom is good. We need no border after today,” said Mohammed Abu Ghazal, a 29-year-old out-of-work Gazan.

Children bought soft drinks and chocolate, women scooped up cheese and cleaning products, and men stocked up on cigarettes — all expensive or simply unavailable in Gaza because of Israel’s shutdown of cargo crossings… Some brought in goats and chickens. Four Palestinians in wheelchairs were pushed over the border, where ambulances picked them up for treatment in Egypt.

A Palestinian in a wheelchair is helped back home to Rafah after traveling to Egypt for a day of medical treatment. Even physically disabled Palestinians moved across the border of Gaza to Egypt through a gap in a fence Wednesday.

A hole in a fence, and what people did with it: a mattress for an injured back, kitchen supplies, goats, chickens, cigarettes, and four people pushed across in wheelchairs to meet ambulances on the other side.

CP-2008-013 →

· estimated · Chicago Tribune · Chicago

Egypt works to restore border

Policing increased ahead of talks

By Joel Greenberg / TRIBUNE CORRESPONDENT

JERUSALEM — Egypt worked diplomatically and on the ground to restore its breached border with the Gaza Strip on Sunday, tightening checkpoints and choking off supplies to curb buying by Palestinians coming across the frontier for the fifth day.

The Egyptians have invited Hamas, which controls the Gaza Strip, and the rival Fatah faction of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas for separate talks in Cairo on resolving the Gaza border crisis.

The breach of the border by Hamas militants last week has undermined an Israeli blockade of Gaza and given the Islamic group leverage in discussions of future arrangements at the Egypt-Gaza frontier.

Hamas says it wants to work out a new border-crossing arrangement with the Egyptians and Fatah, which would ease the isolation of Gaza since the Islamic group seized control there in June.

Abbas has rejected talks with Hamas, saying it must roll back its takeover of Gaza, and has proposed posting his own forces at the territory’s border crossings — an unlikely prospect without Hamas agreement. Abbas discussed the border situation with Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert on Sunday and is to meet Wednesday in Cairo with Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak.

A Hamas delegation is expected in Cairo the same day. After meeting Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad on Sunday, Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Aboul Gheit said that Egypt “will take the necessary actions and measures to control the border with Gaza soon.”

A Palestinian boy sells food to people crossing the Gaza-Egypt border Sunday as Egypt increased diplomatic and police efforts to seal a breach.

Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping — it is trimmed to the article and its photograph. The story is datelined Jerusalem with events “on Sunday”, consistent with a Monday paper; Jan. 28, 2008 was a Monday. Nothing on the clipping names the newspaper, though the credit line “TRIBUNE CORRESPONDENT” and the sign-off e-mail “jogreenberg@tribune.com” are consistent with pub “Chicago Tribune”.

CP-2008-017 →

· Daily Herald

Punishing the people in Gaza feeds extremism

An American editorial page naming collective punishment as policy and arguing against it on the grounds of what it produces.

CP-2008-015 →

· The Charlotte Observer

Gaza siege takes terrible toll

Now Israel is blocking even humanitarian supplies residents need

BY SAREE MAKDISI

Israel must lift its siege of Gaza. While it has been exhilarating to see hundreds of thousands of Gaza residents free themselves from the prison that was their lives, they have been able to obtain in Egypt a mere fraction of the supplies they need.

Emergency stocks are near zero, as Israel for two weeks blocked relief agencies from delivering needed amounts of food and medical supplies.

Now as long as the border with Egypt remains even partially open, Israel refuses to allow anything other than the bare minimum of industrial fuel to keep the territory’s solitary power plant operating and a few truckloads of humanitarian aid, down from 250 a day arriving last year. On Jan.

30, Israel’s supreme court approved these actions, with the callous view that “during wartime, the civilian population is the first and central victim of the fighting, even when efforts are made to minimize the damage.”

Economy suffocated Israel’s blockage even of humanitarian supplies is new, but for years it has otherwise largely cut off Gaza from the outside world, suffocating the economy and thus reducing the population to penury.

It has done so even though international law holds Israel – not Hamas – responsible for the welfare of the population, since it remains an occupying power, despite its partial redeployment in 2005. The World Food Programme warned last November that because of Israel’s restrictions, less than half of Gaza’s food import needs were being met.

Basics including wheat, vegetable oil, dairy products and baby milk were in short supply. Few families could afford meat. Anemia rates rocketed. “We are seeing evidence of the stunting of children,” noted the U.N. Relief and Works Agency, which supplies most of the food to the refugee population of Gaza.

Today, 80 percent of the population of Gaza’s 1.5 million people depend on food assistance for day-to-day survival. Unless Israel relents, they could starve. Utilities failing Gaza is not only out of food.

Because of Israel’s siege, the water system is faltering, the sewage system has broken down and is discharging raw waste into streets and the sea, the power supply is intermittent at best, hospitals lack heat and spare parts, and dozens of life-saving medicines are no longer available. Gaza is dying.

In the last few weeks alone, far more people have died unnecessarily – and seemingly invisibly to the world’s media – because of hospital shortages than have been hurt by the firing of homemade rockets across the border into Israel.

There is no excuse for firing those rockets, but Israel was squeezing Gaza long before the first of those primitive projectiles was cobbled together. The vast majority of Gazans are refugees – or the descendants of refugees – who were expelled from their homes when Palestine was destroyed and Israel was created in 1948.

Israel blocks return Like all Palestinian refugees, those of Gaza have a moral and legal right to return to the homeland from which they were expelled. Israel blocks their return for the same reason it expelled them in the first place. Their presence would undermine its already tenuous claim to Jewishness; that is the nature of its “demographic problem.”

Israel’s chief Ashkenazi rabbi recently proposed a solution: transferring the population of Gaza to the Egyptian desert. “They will have a nice country, and we shall have our country and we shall live in peace,” he said. That attitude is unacceptable. So is Israel’s siege.

Palestinians watch people returning from Egypt at the border crossing between Egypt and Gaza, in Rafah, southern Gaza Strip, Sunday.

CP-2008-028 →

· Modesto Bee · page B-7

Siege is taking terrible toll

By SAREE MAKDISI

Israel must lift its siege of Gaza. While it has been exhilarating to see hundreds of thousands of Gaza residents free themselves from the prison that was their lives, they have been able to obtain in Egypt a fraction of the supplies they need.

Israel refuses to allow anything other than the bare minimum of industrial fuel to keep the territory’s solitary power plant operating and a few truckloads of humanitarian aid. On Jan.

30, Israel’s Supreme Court approved these actions, with the callous view that “during wartime, the civilian population is the first and central victim of the fighting, even when efforts are made to minimize the damage.”

Israel’s blockage even of humanitarian supplies is new, but for years it has otherwise largely cut off Gaza from the outside world, suffocating the economy and thus reducing the population to penury.

It has done so even though international law holds Israel — not Hamas — responsible for the welfare of the population, since it remains an occupying power, despite its partial redeployment in 2005. The World Food Programme warned this past November that because of Israel’s restrictions, less than half of Gaza’s food import needs were being met.

Basics including wheat, vegetable oil, dairy products and baby milk were in short supply. Few families could afford meat. “We are seeing evidence of the stunting of children,” noted the U.N. Relief and Works Agency, which supplies food to the refugee population of Gaza.

Today, 80 percent of the population of Gaza’s 1.5 million people depend on food assistance. Unless Israel relents, they could starve. Gaza is not only out of food.

Because of Israel’s siege, the water system is faltering, the sewage system has broken down and is discharging raw waste into streets and the sea, the power supply is intermittent at best, hospitals lack heat and spare parts, and dozens of lifesaving medicines are no longer available.

In the last few weeks, far more people have died unnecessarily because of hospital shortages than have been hurt by the firing of homemade rockets across the border into Israel. There is no excuse for firing those rockets, but Israel was squeezing Gaza long before the first of those projectiles was cobbled together.

The vast majority of Gazans are refugees — or descendants of refugees — who were expelled when Palestine was destroyed and Israel was created in 1948. Like all Palestinian refugees, those of Gaza have a moral and legal right to return to the homeland. Israel blocks their return for the same reason it expelled them in the first place.

Their presence would undermine its claim to Jewishness; that is the nature of its “demographic problem.” Israel’s chief Ashkenazi rabbi recently proposed transferring the population of Gaza to the Egyptian desert. “They will have a nice country, and we shall have our country and we shall live in peace,” he said. That attitude is unacceptable.

So is Israel’s siege.

The wall in Rafah, at the southern end of the Gaza Strip, consists of steel and barbed wire separating Palestinians, left, from Egyptian forces.

CP-2008-029 →

· The News-Times · Danbury, CT

Peace possible if both sides make commitment

AVI SHAKED

Not so long ago, President Bush and his administration urged all parties to renew a peace initiative in my region. I believe the peace can be won — indeed, it may be near — if we marshal the willpower to make it happen. In this process, we must confront the challenges honestly.

For example, in the summer of 2006, an Israeli Defense Force patrol inside Israeli territory was attacked from Lebanon. Seven soldiers were killed, and two abducted — Eldad Regev and Ehud Goldvaser. Israel could never accept a situation in which the government of Lebanon allows a non-governmental armed body to attack it.

The fully justified response of the Israeli government to this act of violence came in the form of an attack on terror cells in southern Lebanon.

After 34 days of fighting, the United Nations offered a solution to both Israel and Lebanon: to mobilize the Lebanese armed forces in the southern region of Lebanon; and to assemble a special U.N. force that would also be positioned in the southern region of the country.

These two actions were designed to allow the government of Lebanon to reach a better level of control in its territory so acts of violence similar to the one that caused the war in the first place would not recur. In the past seven years, continuous acts of aggression have been launched from the Gaza territory toward Israel.

These acts significantly increased in volume after Israel’s withdrawal from Gaza in the summer of 2005. The results of this situation: 10 killed, 1,000 injured, and a total of 3,000 rockets fired from the Gaza Strip into Israel. No one disputed Israel’s right to retaliate in order to protect its citizens.

Actions by Israel designed to eliminate the attacks from Gaza are understood. Should Israel declare an official state of war against Gaza and invade its territory? I don’t think so — Gaza is not a sovereign state and does not have an official government controlling it.

Tagline as printed: ‘Avi Shaked of Hertzelia, Israel, is co-founder of the Geneva Initiative (www.geneva-accord.org), a joint Israeli-Palestinian effort that suggests a detailed model for a peace agreement to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. His e-mail address is aviavishaked@post.com.’ The headline is the most even-handed of the three Shaked placements — ‘both sides make commitment’ — over a text that argues entirely from Israeli interest.

CP-2008-025 →

· The Kansas City Star · Kansas City, MO

PRO-CON: Is it time to push for a peace agreement between Israelis and Palestinians?

Avi Shaked, co-founder, Geneva Initiative (YES side); Lawrence J. Haas, vice president, Committee on the Present Danger (NO side)

YES Not so long ago, President Bush and his administration urged all parties to renew a peace initiative in my region. I believe the peace can be won — indeed, it may be near — if we marshal the willpower to make it happen.

Israel’s primary interest today is to transform the Gaza Strip and the West Bank territories into one joint country, or in case this is not possible into two sovereign countries. Israel’s only concern should be which of these two entities will become sovereign as soon as possible, with clear borders and responsibility for the actions coming from its territory.

Only after this transformation is completed will the Gaza Strip and the West Bank have the same interest of stopping all acts of aggression toward Israel. It is in Israel’s best interest, as a law-abiding state with clear boundaries, to have a regulated state on the other side as well — a state that has something to lose.

Peace is near and we must not stop our efforts to advance along this important path. Avi Shaked, co-founder, Geneva Initiative NO No issue of public policy is hidden in more layers of mythology than the Arab-Israeli conflict.

Conventional wisdom has held that the path to peace runs through Jerusalem, that Arab hostility toward the Jewish state is rooted in sympathy with the Palestinian cause, and that Israeli concessions to the Palestinians will lead to not just Israeli-Palestinian peace but also to reduced tensions across the region.

A myth dies hard, especially when so many nations have grown accustomed to it. But this myth is not just wrong; it’s dangerous to U.S. national security.

President Bush’s pledge to seek an Israeli-Palestinian peace agreement by year-end is guaranteed to fail because it lacks: ■ Strong national leaders on both sides who can cut a deal. ■ Populations that trust each other enough to enforce it. ■ Neighboring states that will support it. Lawrence J. Haas, vice president, Committee on the Present Danger

A pro-con with two Israeli/American voices and no Palestinian voice on either side of the question ‘is it time to push for a peace agreement between Israelis and Palestinians?’. The accompanying AP photo shows Israeli soldiers in Gaza passing graffiti that reads ‘FREE PALESTIN… / ZIONISM IS…’; the lettering runs off the edge of the frame and is not fully legible, so it is not transcribed.

CP-2008-023 →

· Great Falls Tribune · Great Falls, MT

Yes: Palestinian state would benefit Israel, advance peace

By AVI SHAKED

HERTZELIA, Israel — Not so long ago, President Bush and his administration urged all parties to renew a peace initiative in my region. I believe the peace can be won — indeed, it may be near — if we marshal the willpower to make it happen. In this process, we must confront the challenges honestly.

For example, in the summer of 2006, an Israeli Defense Force patrol inside Israeli territory was attacked from Lebanon. Seven soldiers were killed, and two abducted — Eldad Regev and Ehud Goldvaser. Israel could never accept a situation in which the government of Lebanon allows a non-governmental armed body to attack it.

The fully justified response of the Israeli government to this act of violence came in the form of an attack on terror cells in southern Lebanon.

After 34 days of fighting, the United Nations offered a solution to both Israel and Lebanon: to mobilize the Lebanese armed forces in the southern region of Lebanon; and to assemble a special U.N. force that would also be positioned in the southern region of the country.

These two actions were designed to allow the government of Lebanon to reach a better level of control in its territory so acts of violence similar to the one that caused the war in the first place would not recur. In the past seven years, continuous acts of aggression have been launched from the Gaza territory toward Israel.

These acts significantly increased in volume after Israel’s withdrawal from Gaza in the summer of 2005. The results of this situation: 10 killed, 1,000 injured, and a total of 3,000 rockets fired from the Gaza Strip into Israel. No one disputed Israel’s right to retaliate in order to protect its citizens.

Actions by Israel designed to eliminate the attacks from Gaza are understood. Should Israel declare an official state of war against Gaza and invade its territory? I don’t think so — Gaza is not a sovereign state and does not have an official government controlling it.

The full version of the ‘YES’ half of the Kansas City Star pro-con on slide 48, run under its own headline as a standalone column. Signed off: ‘Avi Shaked is co-founder of the Geneva Initiative (www.geneva-accord.org), a joint Israeli-Palestinian effort that suggests a detailed model for a peace agreement to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Write to him at 85a Medinat Hayehudim St., Hertzelia, Israel and e-mail him at avi@avishakedpost.com.’ Three American papers in this batch (Kansas City Star, Great Falls Tribune, The News Times) ran the same Israeli author in the same week of March 2008; no Palestinian author appears opposite him in any of them.

CP-2008-024 →

· Great Falls Tribune · Great Falls, MT

No: End-of-term effort undermines U.S. anti-terror message

By LAWRENCE J. HAAS

WASHINGTON — No issue of public policy is hidden in more layers of mythology than the Arab-Israeli conflict.

For decades, conventional wisdom has held that the path to peace runs through Jerusalem, that Arab hostility toward the Jewish state is rooted in sympathy with the Palestinian cause, and that Israeli concessions to the Palestinians will lead to not just Israeli-Palestinian peace but also to reduced tensions across the region.

A myth dies hard, especially when so many nations have grown accustomed to it or, in the case of Arab states, exploit it by diverting attention from the problems within their sclerotic societies. But this myth is not just wrong; it’s dangerous to U.S. national security.

President Bush’s pledge to seek an Israeli-Palestinian peace agreement by year-end is guaranteed to fail because the effort lacks: ■ Strong national leaders on both sides who can cut a deal. ■ Populations that trust each other enough to enforce it. ■ Neighboring states that will support it.

Meanwhile, Bush’s push to surmount the insurmountable will undercut his anti-terror message and his commitment to promoting freedom and democracy as an antidote to terror. It also will distract him from the more urgent global challenges that stretch from Iraq and Iran to Russia and China.

Tagline as printed: ‘Lawrence J. Haas is vice president of the Committee on the Present Danger. Readers may write to him at the Committee on the Present Danger, 1146 19th Street NW, Suite 300, Washington, D.C. 20036.’ The cartoon is the thing worth looking at: the Palestinian figure is drawn as a racial caricature and is the only Palestinian presence on a page asking whether there should be peace with Palestinians. Neither commentator on the page is Palestinian.

CP-2008-026 →

· Wisconsin State Journal · Madison, WI

YOUR VIEWS / MIDDLE EAST PEACE

Is the time ripe for President Bush’s push for a peace agreement between the Israelis and Palestinians? Neither side really wants peace now While peace in the Middle East is a nice dream, the reality is that it will never happen.

The reasons are many — religion, greed, racial hatred and lack of leadership, to name a few — and while there are many people in the Middle East who want peace, there are more who want chaos. Both the Israeli and Palestinian governments have been accused of corruption and both lack a plan.

The antagonism between the Jewish and Palestinian people has been festering for generations with no real solution in sight. There are also factions in both the Israeli and Palestinian armies and militias that are extreme to both the left and right.

Finally, the Middle East has always been a breeding ground for zealots, fanatics, war lords and others who want to recreate the world. The best thing for the United States to do is back off and let both sides make their own destinies. — Michyle S.

Glen, Columbus Israel expands; Palestine bleeds Our lame duck president has no more chance of furthering a peace agreement between the Palestinians and the Israelis than his predecessors. Neither the Israelis nor the Palestinians want peace. Both do everything possible to derail peace talks and pursue their goals of territorial expansion.

Not unlike the American Indians, the Palestinians lost their territory and were confined to reservations (refugee camps) with no recourse but to fight for their homeland.

Though Israel has every right to defend its United Nations-sanctioned borders, no country since World War II has had a government that confined a million people in a ghetto and withheld basic necessities of life to achieve their goal of domination and territorial expansion. — Gerald F.

Miller, Lake Mills First U.S. must respect Palestinians For peace to prosper anywhere, there must be some measure of justice perceived by all. At no time over the last eight years has there been anything resembling even the pursuit of peace through justice for the Palestinians.

Following the Clinton administration’s failed attempt at a peace accord, incoming Prime Minister Ariel Sharon upped the ante with his “visit” to the Dome of the Rock, for centuries one of the holiest sites to Arabs. What followed were years of effort by President Bush, his advisers and Sharon to divide and conquer the Palestinian will.

Despite our arrogant view of what the Arab world should think, it’s important to know what they do think. First, there was the notion that the centuries-defunct Israel should be re-established; then, that a limb of the Arab body should be severed for it.

And after swallowing U.N.-dictated international law, the Arab world has witnessed 40 years of lawbreaking by Israel, with its occupation of Palestine and other U.N.-condemned aggressions, all occurring with U.S. support. The choice of Forum commentators, Avi Shaked and Lawrence Haas, is a good indication of why peace is not probable.

Directly answers the ‘where is the sharpest language’ question: it is in the reader letters, not the wire copy or the op-eds. Two of the three letters are responding to the Shaked/Haas point-counterpoint also in this batch (slides 48, 52, 53), which means this paper ran the syndicated pro-Israel pair and then printed readers objecting to that choice. Note also that the two signed letters both open with a ‘neither side wants peace’ framing and then diverge sharply in what they go on to say.

CP-2008-027 →

· Times Record News · Wichita Falls

Palestinians’ keffiyeh feels heat of Chinese imports

Karin Luab and Dalia Nammari / The Associated Press

HEBRON, West Bank — Yasser Herbawi once supplied much of the West Bank and Gaza with black-and-white checkered scarves, the proud emblem of Palestinian identity made famous by the late Yasser Arafat. But most of his looms now stand idle, his product edged out by cheap imports from the world’s newest keffiyeh capital: China.

After a decade of being flooded with Chinese goods, from scarves to toys and bags, the West Bank’s largest city is struggling to compete — yet another obstacle to economic independence for Palestinians as they strive for a state of their own.

Two-thirds of Hebron’s textile workshops have closed and 6,000 shoe factory workers have lost their jobs in the last eight years, pushing unemployment to 30.5 percent, the highest in the West Bank, according to Hebron’s chamber of commerce. Cheap imports have hit manufacturing towns across the world, but the economic decline of this city of 230,000 is particularly ironic.

Hebron long adhered to what is now China’s recipe for success: work hard and sell cheap. And Chinese goods are imported to the West Bank by traders from Hebron, the city suffering most. It’s hard to find an upside to globalization here. Old industries are being squeezed out, while Israeli restrictions on movement and land development limit the scope for new ventures.

Israel’s measures to stop suicide bombers make it much harder to get goods into Israel, and West Bank manufacturers can no longer sell to Gaza, sealed off after the violent Hamas takeover there last year.

U.S.-led efforts to broker a peace agreement between Israelis and Palestinians will be futile without a Palestinian economic recovery, but Hebron Mayor Khaled Osaily said he doesn’t see any quick fixes. “We have a disaster here,” he said.

Palestinian weaver Yasser Herbawi, 76, inspects a loom Tuesday in his workshop that produces checkered head scarves, or keffiyehs, in the West Bank town of Hebron.

CP-2008-018 →

· The Day · New London · page 1

Palestinians mourn Israel’s anniversary as the ‘Nakba’

Black-clad marchers, moments of silence mark the ‘catastrophe’

Ashram Khalil, Los Angeles Times, Jerusalem

Jerusalem — Across Israel, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, Palestinians on Thursday mourned their exodus from the land with moments of silence, black clothing and displays of defiance. The day marked the 60th anniversary of Israel’s declaration of statehood, an event that Palestinians still refer to as the Nakba: the catastrophe.

It led to a war between the new state and the surrounding Arab nations — and lives as rootless refugees for generations of Palestinians. In Ramallah, thousands of black-clad marchers marked the day by rallying in Manara Square. Throughout the West Bank protesters released 21,195 black balloons — one for each day since May 15, 1948.

A two-minute siren and a moment of silence preceded the event and Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas addressed the rally via satellite from Kuwait. “We mark this anniversary not to feel sorry for ourselves, but to remind everyone of the long and glorious struggle of this people, whose suffering and pain have not ended yet,” Abbas said.

“It is time the occupation came to an end and the mark of disgrace in human history called the Palestinian Nakba also came to an end.” Scattered clashes broke out throughout the day between Israeli soldiers and rock-throwing Palestinian youth near the Qalandia checkpoint that bisects the Jerusalem-Ramallah road. No serious injuries were reported.

In the Gaza Strip, intra-Palestinian disputes marred Nakba protests. Supporters of Hamas, the militant group that controls Gaza, fought with cadres from the rival Fatah faction during a Fatah-sponsored Nakba rally.

Thirty people were reported injured in the clashes… On Monday, students at mostly Arab East Jerusalem’s Al Quds University staged a mocked wedding between a bride named “thawra,” or revolution, and a groom named “aid,” or return.

It was meant to symbolize the demand that Palestinian refugees be allowed to return to Israel, a major sticking point in peace talks between the Israelis and Palestinians.

“Palestinians release black balloons during an activity marking Israel’s 60th anniversary Thursday in the West Bank refugee camp of Kalandia.” Muhammed Muheisen / AP

One balloon for each day since 15 May 1948. The paper prints the number: 21,195. It also prints the fighting between Hamas and Fatah that marred the day in Gaza.

CP-2008-001 →

· Wisconsin State Journal · Madison · page 1

Remembering the Nakba on Israel’s 60th anniversary

Guest column

Judith Laitman and Tsela Barr, Madison Chapter of Jewish Voice for Peace

“This month, Jews around the world are celebrating the 60th anniversary of the founding of the state of Israel. These celebrations reflect the understandable joy of Jews who view Israel as the symbol of 60 years of freedom from centuries of persecution, culminating in the Holocaust. Nevertheless, we are Jews who will not be celebrating.

While Israel provided a safe haven for many Jews, the terrible fact is that more than 700,000 Palestinians were made into refugees to make room for the future state of Israel. Sixty years later, that number has swelled to an estimated 7 million.

Many live in 58 registered refugee camps dispersed throughout the Middle East, and some 4 million Palestinians in the Occupied Territories continue to endure reprehensible collective punishment to this day. That is why the creation of the state of Israel is known as the Nakba, or the Catastrophe to Palestinians.

Any peaceful future depends on recognizing both the Palestinian and the Israeli narrative. And yet, just as the names of more than 400 pre-1948 Palestinian towns and cities have been deliberately erased from maps, the history of the Palestinian Nakba itself has been all but erased from consciousness.

Surely it is now time to acknowledge the narrative of the other, the price paid by another people for European anti-Semitism and Hitler’s genocide. Today, because much of the world has forgotten, we remember that: In April, 1948, the same month as the infamous massacre at Deir Yassin, Plan Dalet was put into operation.

It authorized the destruction of Palestinian villages and the expulsion of the indigenous population outside the borders of the state. On May 22, 1948, Jewish soldiers from the Alexandroni Brigade entered the house of Tantura residents killing between 110-230 Palestinian men.

In July 1948, 70,000 Palestinians were driven from their homes in Lydda and Ramleh in the heat of the summer with no food or water. Hundreds died. It was known as the Death March. Under the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, every person ‘has the right to leave any country, including his own, and to return to his country.’

Israel has never accepted this basic human right as a basis for peace negotiations, whether by return, compensation, or resettlement. We will not celebrate as long as Israel continues to violate international law, inflicts a monstrous collective punishment on the civilian population of Gaza, and continues to deny to Palestinians their human rights and national aspirations.

We cannot participate in celebrations that erase both the history and modern-day injustices experienced by Palestinians. We choose instead to work towards justice and self-determination for both peoples. We will celebrate when Arab and Jew live as equals in a peaceful Middle East.”

A guest column by two members of Jewish Voice for Peace in Madison, on the sixtieth anniversary. The paper ran it as a column, not a letter.

CP-2008-002 →

· The Miami Herald · Miami · page 1

Israel-Palestinian coverage is a matter of perception

Miami Herald Ombudsman

“‘The Herald is biased towards Jews,’ Nidal Hussain, a local Palestinian leader, said in an interview this week. He cited stories he did not find in The Miami Herald but read in The Christian Science Monitor, The Economist and the website for National Public Radio on the suffering of Palestinians in Gaza, the source of the rockets Ms. Fried wrote about.

‘I know you guys try very hard to be fair, but you have a long way to go.’ So, on this 60th anniversary of the founding of the state of Israel, with President Bush celebrating in Israel as I write, I decided to take a look at The Miami Herald’s Israel coverage over the last three months.

There were 77 articles in which Israel and/or the Palestinians were mentioned in the first two paragraphs. That is considerable attention to a small region of seven million people, plus an additional four million Palestinians. By comparison, there were 319 articles on Cuba and 203 on Iraq.

Further breaking down the 77 stories, I found that only three mentioned Palestinians alone. This is a very imprecise measure of what the stories were about, but it does reflect a general trend I found.

Not only did Israel get more attention, but more importantly, stories about the conflict between the two were overwhelmingly told from inside Israel, even if critical of Israeli actions. This is partly understandable: Almost all of the foreign correspondents in the area, including The Miami Herald’s shared McClatchy correspondent, Dion Nissenbaum, are based in Jerusalem.

Compared with Gaza and the West Bank, Israel has far superior safety, communications, support services, cultural affinity and functioning government. Plus, it occupies the West Bank.

Reporting on what is happening inside Israel is of importance to more South Florida readers, too… One warm front page feature, for example, recounted the anniversary celebration trip to Israel of 120 South Floridians on behalf of the Greater Miami Jewish Federation. No similar article ran on local Palestinians.

They refer to the establishment of Israel as al naqba — the catastrophe. There were no corresponding activities by local Palestinians, either, which lets The Miami Herald a little off the hook, though a reporter should have at least asked. In Palestinian territories, black balloons were released into the sky.

The constant reporting from the Israeli vantage is unfortunate. As much as the stories may include Palestinian views, the trend denies readers the opportunity to see more articles through Palestinian eyes, and thus better understand Palestinian thinking, for better or worse.

The effect is a subtle bias that isn’t intentionally or even necessarily for or against one side, but does over time give readers a greater shared understanding of Israelis than Palestinians. With understanding, there is greater chance for sympathy.

All that said, I found the articles in the news pages to be fair, with no appreciable bias for one side or the other… ‘I don’t think we have problems trying to balance the issues that arise, but it takes work,’ said Executive Editor Anders Gyllenhaal.

He noted that Palestinians locally were not particularly ‘robust’ in presenting their views, making it the paper’s responsibility to get it. Mr. Hussain and others said that since 9/11, Palestinian and other Arab groups were afraid to be too outspoken. Any thoughts of Jewish conspiracies are, of course, nonsense.

Neither McClatchy nor Knight-Ridder before it had Jewish owners, and the few news organizations that do, such as The New York Times, where I once reported, are among the most critical newspapers of the Israeli occupation.

Art Teitelbaum, former director of the Anti-Defamation League, said it best when he said the greater issue is not bias but space for news, as The Miami Herald, like so many newspapers, have had to cut back. Context and perspective get sacrificed.

‘I would say to you that all interested communities, whether Jews, Muslims, Blacks, Hispanics or subsets thereof, when they are close to a story and its facts, see imperfections that the general public does not see,’ he said.”

A newspaper counting its own coverage: 77 articles in three months, only three about Palestinians alone, against 319 on Cuba. The ombudsman names the mechanism — correspondents based in Jerusalem, stories told from inside Israel — and calls the result a subtle bias that nobody intended.

CP-2008-003 →

· The State Journal-Register

Israelis, Palestinians welcome 2nd day of truce with skepticism

By ARON HELLER / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

JERUSALEM — Israelis and Palestinians skeptically welcomed a second peaceful day of a cease-fire Friday, soaking up the sun at beaches and markets while warily predicting that their newfound quiet would be brief.

The Egyptian-mediated truce in Gaza went into effect Thursday, halting daily Palestinian rocket attacks against southern Israeli towns and communities and Israeli counter raids and airstrikes against Hamas militants in Gaza.

The six-month deal is meant to end attacks that have killed more than 400 Palestinians and seven Israelis since the Islamic Hamas seized control of the Gaza Strip a year ago, and pave the way toward wider-reaching agreements.

If it succeeds, Israel will ease its blockade on Gaza in stages and negotiations will resume on the release of an Israeli soldier held for two years by Hamas-linked forces and on opening the Rafah crossing between Gaza and Egypt. In Gaza, residents said they took to the streets freely with their children Friday for the first time in recent memory.

“This was the first night in a long time that there was relative calm, but we wonder how long will it last?” said Fadya Shaheen, 50, a mother of three. “We don’t hear the sound of strikes anymore, but the situation is still the same. ... The calm seems fragile.” Israelis on the front lines were equally skeptical.

“Today was quiet, but that doesn’t mean anything. They still have their stocks of weapons as well as not-too-nice plans for us,” said Adina Mastbaum, a mother of four in Sderot. The town of 24,000 people less than a mile from Gaza has borne the brunt of Palestinian rocket attacks in the past seven years.

Palestinian fishermen sort their catch of fish Friday in the Gaza seaport in Gaza City. Hatem Moussa/The Associated Press

CP-2008-020 →

· Plainview Daily Herald

Going through the two Israels

“Palestinian women giving birth at checkpoints because Israeli soldiers won’t let them through (four documented cases last year).”

A traveller’s account from Hebron that stops to count. The four documented cases sit in a parenthesis in the middle of a list, between a barbed-wire fence built in 2004 and the diversion of water. Twelve years after the Tucson Citizen reported one of them by name.

CP-2008-016 →

· The Star-Ledger · Newark · page 1

Mahmoud Darwish, voice of Palestine

Diaa Hadid, Associated Press, Gaza City

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Mahmoud Darwish, whose prose gave voice to the Palestinian experience of exile, occupation and infighting, died yesterday in Houston. He was 67.

The predominant Palestinian poet, whose work has been translated into more than 20 languages and won numerous international awards, died following open heart surgery at a Houston hospital… Born to a large Muslim family in historical Palestine — now modern-day Israel — he emerged as a Palestinian cultural icon eloquently describing his people’s struggle for independence while also criticizing both the Israeli occupation and the Palestinian leadership… “He felt the pulse of Palestinians in beautiful poetry.

He was a mirror of the Palestinian society,” said Ali Qleibo, a Palestinian anthropologist and lecturer in cultural studies at Al Quds University in Jerusalem. Darwish first gained prominence in the 1960s with the publication of his first poetry collection, “Bird without Wings.”

It included the poem “Identity Card” that defiantly spoke in the first person of an Arab man giving his identity number — a common practice among Palestinians when dealing with Israeli authorities and Arab governments — and vowing to return to his land.

Many of his poems have been put into music — most notably “Rita,” “Birds of Galilee” and “I yearn for my mother’s bread” — and have become anthems for at least two generations of Arabs. He wrote another 21 collections, the last, “The Impression of Butterflies,” in 2008.

Qleibo described Darwish’s poetry as “the easy impossible”… “He started out as a poet of resistance and then he became a poet of conscience,” said Palestinian lawmaker Hanan Ashrawi. “He embodied the best in Palestinians… even though he became iconic he never lost his sense of humanity.

We have lost part of our essence, the essence of the Palestinian being.”… Darwish was born in the Palestinian village of Birweh near Haifa, which was destroyed in the 1948 Mideast war that led to Israel’s independence.

He joined the Israeli Communist Party after high school and began writing poems for leftist newspapers… In 2000, Israel’s education minister, Yossi Sarid, suggested including some of Darwish’s poems in the Israeli high school curriculum. But Prime Minister Ehud Barak overruled him, saying Israel was not ready yet for his ideas in the school system.

In 1988, a Darwish poem, “Passing in Passing Words,” was read by then-Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir inside Israel’s parliament as an example of the Palestinians’ unwillingness to live alongside Jews… Adel Usta, a specialist on Darwish’s poetry, said the poem was misunderstood and mistranslated. “He created a national Palestinian identity that no other poet could achieve,” Usta said. Darwish married and divorced twice.

He does not have any children. Siham Daoud, a fellow poet and longtime friend of Darwish, said he traveled to a hospital in Houston 10 days ago for the surgery and asked not to be resuscitated if it did not succeed.

“Mahmoud Darwish, the Palestinian poet, during an interview in 2000 in his West Bank office.” · Jacqueline Larma / Associated Press

This archive holds the same paper’s front-page treatment of another dead Palestinian writer thirty-six years earlier. In July 1972 the Star-Ledger headline was “Explosion kills leader of Arab terrorist group.” Here it is “voice of Palestine.” One of them was assassinated and one of them died after heart surgery in Texas, and this collection does not claim that is the only difference between the two headlines. It simply holds both.

CP-2008-005 →

· Houston Chronicle · Houston · page 1

1941 — Mahmoud Darwish — 2008

“‘FELT THE PULSE OF PALESTINE’: Palestinian poet and journalist Mahmoud Darwish, shown on stage last July in Israel, died Saturday after open heart surgery at Memorial Hermann-Texas Medical Center.”

“‘FELT THE PULSE OF PALESTINE’: Palestinian poet and journalist Mahmoud Darwish, shown on stage last July in Israel, died Saturday after open heart surgery at Memorial Hermann-Texas Medical Center.” · Gil Cohen Magen / AFP / Getty Images

A display page rather than a story: his dates set as a rule across the top, a photograph of him with both hands raised, and a caption. He died about four miles from this newsroom, which is the only reason a Houston paper gave a Palestinian poet the full width of a page.

CP-2008-006 →

· The Dispatch · Columbus · page 1

Palestinian poet Darwish dead at 67

The Associated Press, Gaza City

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip (AP) — Mahmoud Darwish, whose prose gave voice to the Palestinian experience of exile, occupation and infighting, died on Saturday in Houston. He was 67.

The predominant Palestinian poet, whose work has been translated into more than 20 languages and won numerous international awards, died following open heart surgery at a Houston hospital, said Nabil Abu Rdeneh, a spokesman for Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas. Born to a large Muslim family in historical Palestine — now modern-day Israel — he emerged as a Palestinian cultural icon eloquently describing his people’s struggle for independence while also criticizing both the Israeli occupation and the Palestinian leadership.

He gave voice to the Palestinian dreams of statehood, crafted their declaration of independence and helped forge a Palestinian national identity.… “He felt the pulse of Palestinians in beautiful poetry.

He was a mirror of the Palestinian society,” said Ali Qleibo… Many of his poems have been put into music — most notably “Rita,” “Birds of Galilee” and “I yearn for my mother’s bread” — and have become anthems for at least two generations of Arabs… Darwish was born in the Palestinian village of Birweh near Haifa, which was destroyed in the 1948 Mideast war that led to Israel’s independence.… “He started out as a poet of resistance and then he became a poet of conscience,” said Palestinian lawmaker Hanan Ashrawi… Last year, Darwish recited a poem damning the deadly infighting between rival Palestinian groups Hamas and Fatah, describing it as “a public attempt at suicide in the streets”… “He created a national Palestinian identity that no other poet could achieve,” Usta said.

Darwish married and divorced twice. He does not have any children.

“Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish in an undated file photo. A Palestinian presidential aide said Saturday that the renowned poet has died at a hospital in Houston following complications from an open heart surgery.” · Associated Press

The fifth American printing of this obituary held here, and the fifth headline. Every one of the five calls him a poet. The archive also holds six printings of the killing of Ghassan Kanafani, a Palestinian novelist, in July 1972; one of those six headlines called him an artist. Both men belonged to Palestinian political organizations and one of them was assassinated, so the two sets are not a controlled comparison. The counts are given because they are counts.

CP-2008-010 →

· The Billings Gazette · Billings · page 1

Palestinian poet Darwish dead at 67

The Associated Press, Ramallah

RAMALLAH, West Bank — A Palestinian presidential aide says that renowned Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish has died.

Darwish died at a hospital in Houston following complications from an open heart surgery, according to Nabil Abu Rdeneh, a spokesman for Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas. Darwish is the world’s most recognized Palestinian poet and became a Palestinian cultural icon. He was a vocal critic of both the Israeli occupation and the Palestinian leadership.

His poetry is considered to have given voice to the Palestinian experience of exile, occupation and infighting. His work has been translated into more than 20 languages and he had won many international prizes.

A portrait, captioned “DARWISH”.

The seventh and shortest American printing of this death held here. Seven paragraphs, a photograph, and the word poet three times. Set against the other set in this archive, the counts now stand: ten American printings of the killing of the novelist Ghassan Kanafani in 1972, of which one headline called him an artist and nine called him a leader, a chief, a militant, a guerrilla or a terrorist; and seven printings of the death of the poet Mahmoud Darwish in 2008, of which seven called him a poet. One man was assassinated and the other died after heart surgery, and both belonged to Palestinian political organizations, so the two sets are not a controlled comparison. They are counts, and this is what they count.

CP-2008-012 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco · page 1

Mahmoud Darwish — poet, Palestinian cultural icon

Obituary

Diaa Hadid, Associated Press, Gaza City

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Mahmoud Darwish, a Palestinian cultural icon whose poetry eloquently told of his people’s experiences of exile, occupation and infighting, died Saturday in Houston.

He was 67… Born to a large Muslim family in historical Palestine — now modern-day Israel — he described his people’s struggle for independence while also criticizing both the Israeli occupation and the Palestinian leadership. He gave voice to the Palestinian dreams of statehood, crafted their declaration of independence and helped forge a Palestinian national identity.… Mr.

Darwish gained prominence in the 1960s with the publication of his first poetry collection, “Bird without Wings.”

It included the poem “Identity Card” that defiantly spoke in the first person of an Arab man giving his identity number — a common practice among Palestinians when dealing with Israeli authorities and Arab governments — and vowing to return to his land. Many of his poems have been set to music — most notably “Rita,” “Birds of Galilee” and “I yearn for my mother’s bread” — resulting in anthems for at least two generations of Arabs.… Qleibo described Mr.

Darwish’s poetry as “the easy impossible,” for Mr. Darwish’s ability to condense the Palestinian narrative into simple, evocative language… Mr.

Darwish was born in the Palestinian village of Birweh near Haifa, which was destroyed in the 1948 Mideast war that led to Israel’s independence.… In 1988, a Darwish poem, “Passing in Passing Words,” was read by then-Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir inside Israel’s parliament as an example of the Palestinians’ unwillingness to live alongside Jews.

The poem suggested that Mr. Darwish called for Jews to leave the region. Adel Usta, a specialist in Mr. Darwish’s poetry, said the poem was misunderstood and mistranslated. “He created a national Palestinian identity that no other poet could achieve,” Usta said. Mr. Darwish married and divorced twice. He does not have any children.

A portrait, with the pull quote: “Mahmoud Darwish wrote several poems that were set to music and became Arab anthems.”

The sixth American printing of this obituary held here, and the only one filed under a standing Obituary head rather than as news. That makes the two sets even: six printings of the death of Mahmoud Darwish, six headlines, every one of which calls him a poet or a cultural icon; and six printings of the killing of Ghassan Kanafani in 1972, of which one headline calls him an artist and the other five call him a leader, a chief, a militant, a guerrilla and a terrorist. One man was assassinated and one died after heart surgery, and both belonged to Palestinian political organizations, so this is a count and not an experiment.

CP-2008-011 →

· Honolulu Star-Bulletin · Honolulu · page 1

Palestinian poet told of his people’s plight

Mahmoud Darwish / 1941-2008

Diaa Hadid, Associated Press, Gaza City

“GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip >> Mahmoud Darwish, a Palestinian cultural icon whose poetry eloquently told of his people’s experiences of exile, occupation and infighting, died Saturday in Houston.

He was 67… Born to a large Muslim family in Palestine — now modern-day Israel — he described his people’s struggle for independence while also criticizing both the Israeli occupation and the Palestinian leadership. He gave voice to Palestinian dreams of statehood, crafted their declaration of independence and helped forge a Palestinian national identity. ‘He felt the pulse of Palestinians in beautiful poetry.

He was a mirror of the Palestinian society,’ said Ali Qleibo… Darwish first gained prominence in the 1960s with the publication of his first poetry collection, ‘Bird Without Wings.’

It included the poem ‘Identity Card,’ which defiantly spoke in the first person of an Arab man giving his identity number — a common practice among Palestinians when dealing with Israeli authorities and Arab governments — and vowing to return to his land… Qleibo described Darwish’s poetry as ‘the easy impossible,’ for his ability to condense the Palestinian narrative into simple, evocative language… Darwish wrote the Palestinian Declaration of Independence in 1988, read by the late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat when he unilaterally declared statehood.

The declaration was symbolic.… ‘When we think of Darwish … he is our heart and our tongue,’ said Issam Makhoul, an Arab lawmaker and veteran member of the Israeli Communist Party… In 2000, Israel’s education minister, Yossi Sarid, suggested including some of Darwish’s poems in the Israeli high school curriculum.

But Prime Minister Ehud Barak overruled him, saying Israel was not ready yet for his ideas in the school system… Siham Daoud, a fellow poet and longtime friend of Darwish, said he traveled to a hospital in Houston 10 days ago for the surgery and asked not to be resuscitated if it did not succeed.

She said Darwish had a history of heart problems and had been operated on twice. Akram Haniyeh, editor-in-chief of the Al Ayyam newspaper and a friend of Darwish, was by Darwish’s bedside in Houston. He said Darwish underwent an operation Wednesday and that there were complications.”

The fourth American printing of this obituary in the archive and the fourth headline: voice of Palestine in Newark, controversial legacy in Bangor, a full-width display page of his dates in Houston, and here, in Honolulu, told of his people’s plight. This version keeps the last hours — the friend at the bedside, the operation on Wednesday, the complications — and the instruction he left that he was not to be resuscitated.

CP-2008-009 →

· Bangor Daily News · Bangor · page 1

Poet Darwish leaves controversial legacy

Author of Palestinian Declaration of Independence dies in Houston after heart surgery

Diaa Hadid, The Associated Press, Gaza City

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Mahmoud Darwish, a Palestinian cultural icon whose poetry eloquently told of his people’s experiences of exile, occupation and infighting, died Aug. 9 in Houston. He was 67… Darwish was born in the Palestinian village of Birweh near Haifa, which was destroyed in the 1948 Mideast war that led to Israel’s independence.

He joined the Israeli Communist Party after high school and began writing poems for leftist newspapers… “When we think of Darwish … he is our heart, and our tongue,” said Issam Makhoul, an Arab lawmaker and veteran member of the Israeli Communist Party.… “He started out as a poet of resistance and then he became a poet of conscience,” said Palestinian lawmaker Hanan Ashrawi… In 2000, Israel’s education minister, Yossi Sarid, suggested including some of Darwish’s poems in the Israeli high school curriculum.

But Prime Minister Ehud Barak overruled him, saying Israel was not ready yet for his ideas in the school system. In 1988, a Darwish poem, “Passing in Passing Words,” was read by then-Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir inside Israel’s parliament as an example of the Palestinians’ unwillingness to live alongside Jews.

The poem suggested that Darwish called for Jews to leave the region.

The same Associated Press obituary the Star-Ledger ran three days earlier as “Mahmoud Darwish, voice of Palestine.” Here the headline is “controversial legacy.” This version also keeps a line the other cut: Issam Makhoul, a Palestinian member of the Israeli Knesset, saying he is our heart and our tongue.

CP-2008-007 →

· Press of Atlantic City

Olive harvest another West Bank battleground

Extremist Jewish settlers clashing with Palestinian farmers over land

By KARIN LAUB and DALIA NAMMARI / Associated Press

TURMUS AYYA, West Bank —The olive harvest was off to a bad start for Said Abu Aliya — branches torn from the Palestinian farmer's trees lay scattered on the ground, along with bright-green olives. He blamed Israeli settlers in a nearby hilltop camp while Israeli soldiers patrolled as a buffer while he and his family picked the remaining crop.

“Without their presence, we wouldn't be able to enter our lands because the settlers would attack us,” said the 47-year-old. For many Palestinians, the fall harvest of about 10 million trees used to be a joyful ritual steeped in tradition.

But the West Bank's olive groves have increasingly become a target of extremist Jewish settlers who, hilltop by hilltop, seek to expand their control over land they say they were promised by God.

Just in the first two weeks of this season, farmers say, assailants beat a 63-year-old olive picker, slashed another man's car tires, tried to chase Palestinians out of several groves and stole or damaged some of the crop. In one incident captured on video, four settlers punched and kicked a Palestinian photographer and a foreign activist in an olive grove.

Compounding the farmers' problems, more trees are harder to reach because they lie beyond Israel's growing West Bank separation barrier or close to Jewish settlements and their multiplying satellite camps. Israeli human rights activists say securing the harvest is an important test of Israel's obligation as an occupying power to protect Palestinians.

They say the military and police are doing a better job than in the past, but have failed to protect crops or bring vigilantes to justice.

Palestinians ride on a truck after harvesting olives outside the West Bank village of Turmus Ayya, near Ramallah. Olive groves have increasingly become targets of extremist Jewish settlers seeking to expand their control over land. (Associated Press photo by Bernat Armangue) | Palestinian villagers prepare olive oil in the outskirts of the West Bank village of Qabatyah.

Palestinian farmers say extremist Jewish settlers have beaten olive pickers and stolen or damaged crops. (Associated Press photo by Mohammed Ballas)

CP-2008-019 →

· American Press

Motley crew comes to aid of blockaded Gazan residents

KHUZAA, Gaza Strip (AP) — A tattooed Italian trucker, middle-aged twin sisters from San Jose, Calif., a polite Scottish couple and a solemn-faced Greek hailed a cab in Gaza City, drawing stares from passers-by unused to visitors. The party was off to southern Gaza to plant wheat with Palestinian farmers in a dangerous area near an Israeli-patrolled border.

They were among some 80 foreign volunteers who have sailed across the Mediterranean to Gaza in three trips since August, defying a closure of the Hamas-ruled territory imposed by Israel and Egypt. The blockade-runners from the Free Gaza Movement are a motley bunch.

They have included physicians, lawmakers and Yvonne Ridley, a British woman who was kidnapped by the Taliban and afterward converted to Islam. One high-profile volunteer was Lauren Booth, sister-in-law of Tony Blair, the former British prime minister who is now the international community’s Mideast peace envoy.

They bring medicines, accompany fishermen and farmers to dangerous areas, and say they want to draw attention to the hardship the blockade has inflicted on 1.4 million Gazans. “Governments in the West are asleep,” said Vittorio Arrigoni, 33, the trucker, whose black cap featured the face of Che Guevara.

Activists accompany Gaza fishermen beyond the 3-mile limit enforced by the Israeli navy. They also escort farmers to border area fields that Israel has declared off-limits because militants have launched rockets from there. Israel’s navy has not tried to stop the boats, apparently to avoid unwanted publicity.

“The entry of a few people doesn’t mean the blockade is off,” said Andy David, a Foreign Ministry official. Israel’s patience is clearly limited. On Nov. 18, a week after their wheat-planting effort, Arrigoni and two others were arrested for going to sea with Palestinian fishermen.

Activists say they are focused on the plight of ordinary Palestinians, but are aware Hamas is using their presence to legitimize its rule.

CP-2008-021 →

· The York Dispatch · York · page 1

Israel rejects calls for a truce

Tunnels: Attacks target Hamas smuggling

The Associated Press, Gaza City

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Israel rejected international pressure to suspend its air offensive against Palestinian militants, sending warplanes Wednesday to demolish smuggling tunnels that are the lifeline of Gaza’s Islamic Hamas rulers.

The diplomatic action was set in motion by the scale of destruction in Gaza since Israel unleashed its campaign Saturday, and a casualty toll that Gaza officials now put at 390 dead and some 1,600 wounded. Hamas says some 200 uniformed members of Hamas security forces have been killed, and the U.N. says at least 60 Palestinian civilians have died.

Four Israelis have been killed by rocket fire, including three civilians. The chief of Israel’s internal security services, Yuval Diskin, told Cabinet ministers Wednesday that Hamas’ ability to rule had been “badly impaired.”

Weapons development facilities have been “completely wiped out” and the network of smuggling tunnels has been badly damaged, a participant in the meeting quoted Diskin as saying. Calls for an immediate cease-fire have also come from the United States, the European Union, the United Nations and Russia.

President Bush and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice personally called leaders in the Middle East on Tuesday to press for a durable solution. Underlying the Israeli decision to keep fighting are the mightier weapons that Hamas has smuggled into Gaza through underground tunnels along the border with Egypt.

Newer weapons have dramatically expanded their range and put more than a 10th of Israel’s population in their sights. More than two dozens rockets and mortar shells were fired by midday Wednesday, including five that hit in and around the major southern Israeli city of Beersheba, 22 miles from Gaza. No serious casualties were reported.

While rejecting a truce, Israel said it would allow 2,000 tons of food and medical supplies to enter Gaza on Wednesday, in addition to 4,000 tons the military says have been allowed in since the offensive began.

Meanwhile, in Iran, hard-line student groups have appealed to the government to authorize volunteer suicide bombers to leave Iran and fight against Israel in response to the Gaza attacks.

“Pro-Palestinian demonstrators line Wilshire Boulevard in front of the Israeli Consulate in Beverly Hills, Calif., Tuesday night to protest Israel’s attacks in the Gaza Strip. Thousands of Arab-Americans and other supporters marched in a number of U.S. cities, including New York, Fort Lauderdale and Tampa in Florida, and the Detroit suburb of Dearborn.

In several cities there were also demonstrations of support for Israel.” Gus Ruelas — The Associated Press. Placards read “STOP U.S. FUNDED ISRAELI MASSACRES,” “STOP MASSACRES IN PALESTINE NOW,” “BREAK THE SIEGE FREE GAZA” and “Death and destruction in Gaza: Our taxes at work.”

Three separate counts of the Palestinian dead in one paragraph — Gaza officials’, Hamas’ and the United Nations’ — and the Israeli dead counted separately with their civilians named as a number. The caption notes there were also demonstrations of support for Israel.

CP-2008-004 →

· The Atlanta Journal-Constitution · Atlanta, GA (per the printed folio) · page A7 (per the printed folio)

McKinney relief ship hits Israeli vessel

By JULIA MALONE jmalone@ajc.com, BOB DEANS bdeans@ajc.com and JEFFRY SCOTT jscott@ajc.com

Former Georgia Congresswoman Cynthia McKinney, standing beside a damaged yacht, Tuesday accused the Israeli navy of ramming the vessel to halt the delivery of medical supplies to the embattled Gaza Strip. But Israeli authorities said the collision was accidental.

Foreign Ministry spokesman Yigal Palmor said the boat tried to outmaneuver an Israeli navy ship and crashed into it, lightly damaging both vessels. The navy then escorted the boat out into the territorial waters of Cyprus. A U.S. State Department spokesman said Tuesday that U.S. diplomats had issued no protests to Israeli authorities.

But the incident reverberated in Atlanta, McKinney's hometown. A protest was held Tuesday outside the Israeli Consulate on Spring Street by pro-Palestinian groups in the Atlanta area. Saba Khalid, a member of Emory Advocates For Justice In Palestine, said about 100 people protested against Israeli action in Gaza.

Staff copy, three bylines, all local. This is a Georgia paper covering the Free Gaza Movement's SS Dignity being rammed off Gaza during Cast Lead, and the local protest that followed — the kind of hometown-angle coverage the archive is usually short of. Photo caption: "A crowd on the dock welcomes the vessel SS Dignity from the group Free Gaza as it arrives in the port of Tyre, Lebanon." Credit: MUHAMMED ZAATARI / Associated Press. Mugshot of McKinney captioned "McKinney". Also quoted in the story: Riad Mansour, Palestinian Ambassador to the U.N.; Jonathan Peled, spokesman for the Israeli Embassy in Washington; and Paul Larudee, a co-founder of the California-based Free Gaza group. The story closes "The Associated Press contributed to this article."

CP-2008-022 →

· estimated · Argus Leader · Sioux Falls · page 1

Stop genocide in Palestine

Mohamed Sharif, Sioux Falls

“Once again, the apartheid state of Israel has launched a genocide wave against unarmed civilian Palestinians. The last existing apartheid state is murdering hundreds of children, women and men, and no one cares. This is a result of the blank check that was given Israel by the U.S. government. This genocide must be stopped before it is too late.

All civil people must stand together against this atrocity. Please contact your congressional representative and ask for an immediate stop of the killing and an immediate stop of support to Israel.”

A letter from Sioux Falls in 2009. The Argus Leader quoted a Mohamed Sahrif of the same city, director of the Islamic Center, in 2003; the two printings spell the name differently and nothing on either clipping says they are the same man.

CP-2009-001 →

· Argus Leader · Sioux Falls · page 1

Re: Stop genocide in Palestine

reprinted reader comments

“U.S. foreign policies have supported the occupation of the Palestinian West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem, so it is our duty to demand an end. We call for an unconditional, immediate cease-fire; full humanitarian access to Gaza and a lifting of Israel’s siege; and accountability for Israel’s misuse of U.S. weapons to kill Palestinian civilians.”

Posted by ISLAMIISPEACE at 8:47 p.m. Thursday. “Hmmm, let’s look at what’s happening here: 1. Hamas has fired over 180 rockets into Israel since the ‘cease-fire’ agreement lapsed several days ago. 2. Hamas continually says they want to ‘rid the Earth of the Israelis for all time.’ 3. Hamas is purposely using human shields as a way to deter retaliation attacks.

My question here is, what would the USA do if Cuba sent even one missile rocket into Miami? I think Israel’s reaction is justified, appropriate and long over due.” Posted by jeffmd at 11:05 p.m. Thursday. “They’ve been at it a long time and finding neutral ground is impossible.” Posted by realraker at 5:28 a.m. Friday.

The paper reprinting its own comment board, carrying both directions in one column, with the screen names and the timestamps as printed.

CP-2009-002 →

· Dayton Daily News · Dayton

Israeli troops and tanks slice deep into Gaza

Slice, for an army entering a place where a million and a half people live. It is a verb for cake and for surgery, and what it does here is make the ground the object and leave the people out of the sentence entirely. Eight days later a Washington paper used advance and had to say where they were advancing into: Gaza’s urban areas (CP-2009-015).

CP-2009-003 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia · page 1

Israeli ground operation cuts Gaza Strip in two

Sebastian Scheiner, Associated Press

“An Israeli tank fires at targets in the southern Gaza Strip from a position along Israel’s side of the border with Gaza. Medical officials there said more than 80 Palestinians, including 21 children, were killed and 140 injured in the ground offensive.” Sebastian Scheiner, Associated Press.

A front page given to the photograph and the headline; the story is not part of this clipping. The count is in the caption, attributed to medical officials.

CP-2009-006 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles

CASUALTIES: A Palestinian man carries a girl killed in an Israeli strike into Shifa Hospital in Gaza City; a wounded Israeli soldier arrives at a hospital in Beersheba

“CASUALTIES: A Palestinian man carries a girl killed in an Israeli strike into Shifa Hospital in Gaza City; a wounded Israeli soldier arrives at a hospital in the town of Beersheba.” Photos by KHALIL HAMRA, Associated Press, and TARA TODRAS-WHITEHILL, AP.

Two photographs side by side under one word. On the left a man carrying a dead child; on the right a soldier with a head wound, walking. The caption calls both of them casualties and gives neither a name. The girl is dead and is described by what was done to her; the soldier is wounded and arrives.

CP-2009-007 →

· Ventura County Star · Ventura · page A13

Israel killing people, hope and ambition

Nabil Alshurafa

I am writing on a day during which Israeli strikes have killed more than 460 Palestinians and wounded more than 2,750, many of whom are women and children. After many attempts, I was finally able to reach my family in Gaza.

As I speak to them, I try to calm them down and ask them to remain hopeful, but all of a sudden, my 70-year-old grandmother blurts in frustration, “Every few minutes I jump from the sound of a blast, F-16s all over the place, no electricity, food is scarce, hope? We’ve forgotten the meaning of this word; we’re living dead, trapped in hell.”

I feel their fear and pain as well. I turn on American television stations and notice that, although this may be the greatest massacre in the region since the war in 1967, very little of what’s really happening is being addressed. On the other hand, Al-Jazeera and many other news outlets are covering this matter 24/7.

The Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the American stance are, I believe, at the heart of our homeland security. I hope for long-lasting peace, not only for the safety of America, but for the safety of Israelis and Palestinians alike. The main problem that foments terrorism is not religion, it is insanity, it is hunger and it is oppression.

When we have a population that is habitually oppressed — living under continued blockades, without enough food, unreliable electricity, children unable to go to school, people unable to leave a small swath of land and feeling imprisoned — how do we expect people to act as if they are not captives? Terrorist groups feed on such individuals.

Date check: The running head reads “Tuesday, Jan. 6, 2009 FC The Star” at the left, “COMMENTARY” centred, and the folio “A13” at the right. The date matches the slide label exactly, and Jan. 6, 2009 was a Tuesday. The masthead prints the paper as “The Star”, not the full “Ventura County Star” of pub.

CP-2009-037 →

· The Courier · page 1

Civilian deaths soar in Gaza

About 300 of 670 Palestinians killed so far are civilians

“About 300 of 670 Palestinians killed so far are civilians… …has adopted tougher tactics to prevent the killing or capture of soldiers. One concern is that troops could be lured toward booby-trapped houses, said the… are civilians, according to Palestinian and U.N. figures.

Of those killed, at least 130 are children age 16 and under, says the Gaza-based Palestin… killed and 55 wounded Tuesday when Israeli mortar shells hit near a U.N. school where hundreds of civilians had sought refuge from the fighting. Israel…”

Palestinians pray over the bodies of 14 people killed near a United Nations school Tuesday during their funeral in the Jebaliya refugee camp in the northern Gaza Strip today. At least 39 people died and 55 were wounded when mortar shells hit the school. AP Photo.

The clipping is a crop of the top of the page, so three of its columns break mid-sentence. Nothing has been supplied to complete them.

CP-2009-008 →

· The Town Talk · Alexandria

Aid reaches civilians

Israel orders brief halt, then Gaza fight resumes

GAZA CITY, Gaza — Israeli airstrikes and Hamas rockets resumed after a brief pause Wednesday to allow food and fuel to reach Palestinian civilians in Gaza, where an Israeli warplane dropped leaflets urging some residents to flee because of imminent attacks.

Even as the Israeli government tentatively welcomed a cease-fire proposal from Egypt and France, its military was instructed to continue its assault on Hamas. The proposal could mark the first sign of a possible exit from 12 days of bloodshed in Gaza.

But Israel says it needs guarantees that any cease-fire will halt rocket fire and prevent Hamas from rearming, while Hamas demands that Gaza’s blockaded border crossings be opened. Israeli strikes in response to continued Hamas rocket fire on southern Israel have killed at least 688 Palestinians since Dec.

27, including around 350 civilians, among them 130 children, according to Palestinian officials. Israel says it has killed at least 130 Gaza militants since it launched its ground offensive Saturday. Ten Israelis have been killed since the fighting began, including three civilians.

On Wednesday, 29 Palestinians were killed, including at least 22 civilians and two Islamic Jihad militants, medics said. In one incident, a family of four was killed in an airstrike on their car, medics said. In the Jebaliya refugee camp, there was a mass funeral for 40 people killed Tuesday by Israeli mortar fire toward a U.N. school.

Israel said it was responding to an attack by Hamas militants who fired mortar shells from an area near the school. The bodies, wrapped in blankets, were laid out in a long row on the ground, with mourners kneeling in prayer before them.

Israel carried out 40 airstrikes Wednesday on targets including smuggling tunnels on the Gaza-Egypt border, Israel’s chief army spokesman Brig. Gen. Avi Benayahu said. An Israeli combat officer, identified as Lt. Col. Amir, said troops neutralized hundreds of explosives devices, including booby-trapped houses.

Residents said 16 houses on the border were destroyed, with Israel presumably targeting buildings shielding tunnel entrances. Hamas had about 300 smuggling tunnels in the area before the offensive, and Israel has already destroyed dozens in repeated strikes. Fida Kishta, an area resident, said she could hear sporadic shelling from F-16 planes.

“I feel like the ground is shaking when we hear the shelling. People are terrified,” Kishta said. In the evening, an Israeli warplane dropped leaflets over the Rafah refugee camp on the Gaza-Egypt border, urging residents to flee because of planned Israel strikes.

Hamas has weapons smuggling tunnels in the area, and Israel has already destroyed dozens of them in airstrikes. “Because Hamas uses your houses to hide and smuggle military weapons, the IDF will attack the area, between the Egyptian border until the beach road,” the leaflet said, according a local U.N. official.

After the leaflets were dropped, about 5,000 fled to two U.N. schools turned into temporary shelters.

A Palestinian injured in an Israeli army operation reacts as he is treated at Kamal Adwan Hospital, in Beit Lahiya, northern Gaza Strip on Wednesday.

Israel tentatively welcomed a proposal Wednesday from Egypt and France for a Gaza cease-fire and briefly halted its offensive to allow aid to reach civilians, but also gave the military a green light to press ahead with its assault on Hamas.

CP-2009-036 →

· estimated · Associated Press · page 1

Relief aid to Gaza disrupted

“Relief aid to Gaza disrupted. The U.N. and the Red Cross curtailed aid deliveries to the Gaza Strip Thursday, citing Israeli attacks on their staff and installations. The death toll in Israel’s offensive climbed higher as international diplomats worked on a proposed cease-fire deal.”

The labels on the map read: “Militants in Lebanon fired rockets into Israel Thursday, striking a house in Nahariya. Israel responded with mortar fire on open areas in southern Lebanon.” “Hundreds of families fled their homes in Rafah, according to the Palestine Red Crescent.” “The bodies of 35 people were found in the rubble of a battle zone in Gaza City.”

“Refugees fleeing to Deir el-Balah from the western shore, villages near Netzarim and the eastern border areas.” “A U.N. official said Israeli forces fired on a U.N. aid truck in northern Gaza, killing the driver.” Sources: ESRI; United Nations. The Associated Press.

A wire-service map. Both directions of fire are labeled on it, and so is the aid truck.

Correction: {'note': 'The graphic carries no date. It refers to a proposed cease-fire deal, rockets fired into Israel from Lebanon on a Thursday, and 35 bodies found in Gaza City, which places it in the first ten days of January 2009.'}

CP-2009-009 →

· The Cincinnati Enquirer · Cincinnati

257 children killed in attacks upon Gaza

The Associated Press

Six words in a single column, thirteen days in. The number is children and the number is 257. The preposition is upon, which is a formal word, and there is nobody attacking. A reader gets the count and not the army.

CP-2009-010 →

· The Cincinnati Enquirer · Cincinnati

Israel fires on UN, Red Cross trucks in Gaza

The same paper, the same day, two headlines. This one has Israel as the subject and fires on as the verb, stated flat. The other one on that page counts 257 dead children and has nobody doing it: 257 children killed in attacks upon Gaza (CP-2009-010). The thing that changes between them is who was hit. When it is the United Nations and the Red Cross, the army appears in the sentence.

CP-2009-011 →

· Messenger Inquirer · Owensboro

Israel tells Gazans to expect escalation

A state addressing a population directly, and what it tells them to expect is an escalation — a word with no object. Gazans is the noun, which makes them residents of a place rather than a people, and there is nothing in the sentence they can do with the warning.

CP-2009-012 →

· The Boston Globe · Boston

Palestinians sought food aid at a United Nations food distribution center in Shati refugee camp in Gaza City

“Palestinians sought food aid at a United Nations food distribution center in Shati refugee camp in Gaza City yesterday. Israeli forces pounded dozens of targets and edged closer to Gaza City, while southern Israel came under renewed rocket fire.” Hatem Moussa / Associated Press.

Women and children pressed against a metal grille with their hands through it. The first sentence of the caption is what the photograph shows. The second is the war, and it is balanced: Israeli forces pounded, southern Israel came under fire. Nobody in the picture is part of either clause.

CP-2009-013 →

· Times-News

Braving Israeli assault, Gaza medics face war’s carnage daily

Ibrahim Barzak and Ben Hubbard

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — The medics who brave Israel’s assault on Gaza have come under fire from tanks and faced days-long delays in getting to the scene of attacks, sometimes finding animals gnawing at corpses when they finally reach the dead and wounded.

Few are more exposed to the carnage of Israel’s two-week military offensive than Gaza’s medics, who number around 400 including volunteers. They work long hours, get little sleep and risk their lives daily. Many have lost friends and family, but the overwhelming workload leaves no time to process what they’ve seen.

Awaiting coordination with Israel often delays access to the injured, medics said. Some reported finding people stranded in their homes for days, or bodies lying in the streets uncollected. “Disgusting is not the word,” said Shawki Saleh, 24, a volunteer medic at Kamal Adwan hospital. “If it’s not a dog, it’s rats around the bodies. ...

I’ve been doing this volunteer work for two years but I never imagined I’d see this. Who knows how many people are still under the rubble. We were carrying them out screaming.” In one long workday, medic Haitham Adgheir carried five corpses, saw six more at a Gaza hospital, and his medical convoy took Israeli tank fire that showered a driver with glass.

“My mind is like a video of body parts and injured people,” said Adgheir, 33. Israel launched airstrikes across the Gaza Strip on Dec. 27 and sent in ground troops a week later in an attempt to halt years of Hamas rocket fire on southern Israel. More than 800 Palestinians have been killed, about half of them civilians, according to Palestinian medical officials.

Thirteen Israelis have also been killed.

A Palestinian Red Crescent medic carries a dead child, killed in an Israeli army operation, Thursday at Kamal Edwan hospital in Beit Lahiya, northern Gaza Strip.

CP-2009-032 →

· Pensacola News Journal · Pensacola · page 1

Israel said to use white phosphorus

Jason Keyser, Associated Press, Jerusalem

“JERUSALEM — Human Rights Watch said Sunday that Israel’s military has fired artillery shells with the incendiary agent white phosphorus into Gaza and a doctor there said the chemical was suspected in the case of 10 burn victims who had skin peeling off their faces and bodies.

Researchers in Israel from the rights group witnessed hours of artillery bombardments that sent trails of burning smoke indicating white phosphorus over the Jebaliya refugee camp in northern Gaza. But they could not confirm injuries… An AP photographer and a TV crew based in Gaza visited Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis on Sunday and recorded images of several burn patients.

One of them, Haitham Tahseen, recalled sitting outside his home with his family in the morning when something exploded above them. ‘Suddenly, I saw bombs coming with white smoke,’ said the man, whose burned face was covered with medical cream. ‘It looked very red and it had white smoke. That’s the first time I’ve seen such a thing.’

His cousin, in another hospital bed, was more severely burned, with patches of skin—”

“Palestinian Akram Abu Roka is treated for burns at Nasser Hospital in the southern Gaza Strip on Sunday. The hospital’s chief doctor said the injuries might have been caused by munitions containing white phosphorus.” Eyad Baba, Associated Press.

The headline says said to use. The photograph names the man in the bed.

CP-2009-014 →

· The Olympian · Olympia

Israeli forces advance deep into Gaza's urban areas

Urban areas is where people live, said in a way that does not say so. Still, this is the only headline in this January cluster that concedes the army is going in among them; the Dayton Daily News on 5 January had the tanks slice deep into Gaza and nothing else (CP-2009-003).

CP-2009-015 →

· The Globe

Rights group: Israel using white phosphorus in Gaza

The Associated Press

JERUSALEM (AP) — Human Rights Watch said Sunday that Israel’s military has fired artillery shells with the incendiary agent white phosphorus into Gaza and a doctor there said the chemical was suspected in the case of 10 burn victims who had skin peeling off their faces and bodies.

Researchers in Israel from the rights group witnessed hours of artillery bombardments that sent trails of burning smoke indicating white phosphorus over the Jebaliya refugee camp in northern Gaza. But they could not confirm injuries on the ground because they have been barred from entering the territory.

The chief doctor at Nasser Hospital in southern Gaza said he treated several victims there with serious burns that might have been caused by phosphorus. He said, however, that he did not have the resources or expertise to say with certainty what caused the injuries.

The substance can cause serious burns if it touches the skin and can spark fires on the ground, the rights group said in a written statement calling on Israel not to use it in crowded areas of Gaza. Military spokeswoman Maj.

Avital Leibovich refused to comment directly on whether Israel was using phosphorus, but said the army was “using its munitions in accordance with international law.” Israel used white phosphorus in its 34-day war with Hezbollah in Lebanon in 2006.

The U.S. military in Iraq used the incendiary during a November 2004 operation against insurgents in the city of Fallujah. An AP photographer and a TV crew based in Gaza visited Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis on Sunday and recorded images of several burn patients.

One of them, Haitham Tahseen, recalled sitting outside his home with his family in the morning when something exploded above them. His cousin, in another hospital bed, was more severely burned, with patches of skin peeling off his face and body, and had to be wrapped with thick white bandages.

The hospital’s chief doctor, Youssef Abu Rish, said the burns were not from contact with fire, but he couldn’t say what sort of substance caused them. He said information he collected on the Internet indicated it could have been white phosphorus.

White phosphorus is not considered a chemical weapon, and militaries are permitted under laws of warfare to use it in artillery shells, bombs and rockets to create smoke screens to hide troop movements as well as bright bursts in the air to illuminate battlefields at night. Israel is not party to a convention regulating its use.

Under customary laws of war, however, Israel would be expected to take all feasible precautions to minimize the impact of white phosphorus on civilians, Human Rights Watch said.

“What we’re saying is the use of white phosphorus in densely populated areas like a refugee camp is showing that the Israelis are not taking all feasible precautions,” said Marc Garlasco, a senior military analyst for the rights group.

Garlasco was among researchers on a ridge about a mile (1.5 kilometers) from the Gaza border who observed the shelling from a 155mm artillery unit on Friday and Saturday. Each 155mm shell contains 116 of what Garlasco described as wafers doused in phosphorus that can be spread over an area as large as a sports field, depending on the height at which it detonates.

The phosphorus ignites when it comes in contact with oxygen. Human Rights Watch has not been able to confirm whether there have been any civilian casualties from phosphorus. The group has a consultant working for it inside Gaza but he has been unable to move around due to the danger. Foreign journalists have also been barred from entering Gaza.

Garlasco said photos published Thursday in British newspaper The Times showed Israeli units handling American-manufactured white phosphorus shells with fuses on them.

The news agency dispatch, run whole and under its own headline. Two Palestinians are named in it — Haitham Tahseen, burned, and Dr. Youssef Abu Rish, who treated him — and so is the Israeli spokeswoman and the analyst who watched the shelling from a ridge. The same copy ran the same morning in Westchester as a sidebar under a shorter headline.

CP-2009-027 →

· The Journal News · White Plains · page 3B

Densely populated area targeted

Israeli forces pursue Hamas fighters deep inside Gaza City

Ibrahim Barzak and Christopher Torchia, The Associated Press; sidebar by Jason Keyser

“IN FOCUS · CONFLICT IN GAZA STRIP

Densely populated area targeted

Israeli forces pursue Hamas fighters deep inside Gaza City GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Israeli ground forces made their deepest foray yet yesterday into Gaza’s most populated area, with tanks rolling into residential neighborhoods and infantry fighting urban warfare in streets and buildings with Hamas militants, who kept up their rocketing of southern Israel.

An Israeli army spokeswoman said residential neighborhoods in Gaza are riddled with homemade bombs and booby traps, including mannequins placed at apartment entrances to simulate militants and rigged to explode if soldiers approach. The army ‘is advancing more into urban areas,’ said the spokeswoman, Maj. Avital Leibovich.

‘Since the majority of the Hamas militants are pretty much in hiding in those places, mainly urban places, then we operate in those areas.’ Late yesterday, dense plumes of smoke from explosions rose over Gaza City and heavy gunfire was heard just south of the city.

Early today, Israeli navy gunboats fired more than 25 shells at Gaza City, setting fires and shaking office buildings, including the local bureau of The Associated Press. The military said that in general, the targets are Hamas installations, but a spokesman had no immediate information about the shelling that began just after midnight.

Gaza medical officials say at least 870 Palestinians, about half of them civilians, have been killed in the conflict that began Dec. 27 with Israeli airstrikes on Hamas buildings, as well as suspected rocket launch sites and smuggling tunnels on the Egyptian border. Thirteen Israelis, including 10 soldiers, have died.

German and British envoys pressed efforts to negotiate an end to the war even though Israel and Hamas have ignored a U.N. Security Council resolution calling for an immediate and durable cease-fire…

Rights group: Israel uses white phosphorus JERUSALEM — Human Rights Watch said yesterday that Israel’s military has fired artillery shells with the incendiary agent white phosphorus into Gaza, and a doctor there said the chemical was suspected in the case of 10 burn victims who had skin peeling off their faces and bodies.

Researchers in Israel from the rights group witnessed hours of artillery bombardments that sent trails of burning smoke indicating white phosphorus over the Jebaliya refugee camp in northern Gaza. But they could not confirm injuries on the ground because they have been barred from entering the territory.

The chief doctor at Nasser Hospital in southern Gaza said he treated several victims there with serious burns that might have been caused by phosphorus.

White phosphorus is not considered a chemical weapon, and militaries are permitted under laws of warfare to use it in artillery shells, bombs and rockets to create smoke screens to hide troop movements as well as bright bursts in the air to illuminate battlefields at night. Israel is not party to a convention regulating its use.

Under customary laws of war, however, Israel would be expected to take all feasible precautions to minimize the impact of white phosphorus on civilians, Human Rights Watch said.”

“Palestinian youths inspect the rubble of a mosque and Islamic school yesterday after it was destroyed in an Israeli missile strike in Rafah, southern Gaza Strip.” Khaled Omar/The Associated Press.

The page is headed On the Wire and slugged IN FOCUS · CONFLICT IN GAZA STRIP, and the main headline makes the density of the population the thing being targeted, with nobody targeting it. The white phosphorus dispatch that another paper ran whole and under its own headline is here a single column down the right-hand side. Underneath, in the same copy, the Associated Press reports that its own Gaza bureau was shaken by naval shelling.

CP-2009-028 →

· Santa Barbara News-Press · Santa Barbara

Israeli leader warns of 'iron fist'; Hamas remains defiant

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert stood within Hamas rocket range Monday and warned Islamic militants that they face an “iron fist” unless they agree to Israeli terms for an end to war in the Gaza Strip.

Hamas showed no signs of wavering, however, with its leader, Ismail Haniyeh, saying the militants were “closer to victory.” Despite the tough words, Egypt said it was making slow progress in brokering a truce, and special Mideast envoy Tony Blair said elements were in place for a cease-fire. As Mr.

Olmert spoke in the Israeli city of Ashkelon, Israeli tanks, gunboats and warplanes hammered suspected hiding places of Hamas operatives who control the poor, densely populated territory just across the border. After nightfall, flares and explosions lit up the sky over Gaza and heavy gunfire was heard in parts of the coastal territory of 1.4 million people.

Hamas fighters battled Israeli troops on the outskirts of Gaza City and launched 15 rockets at southern Israel. Fighting picked up early Tuesday, as Israeli forces, backed by artillery and naval shelling, advanced closer to Gaza City from the south, witnesses said.

Khader Mussa, 35, a resident of the area under attack, told The Associated Press by telephone that he saw two apartment buildings on fire. He said he was huddling in the basement of his building with 25 other people, including his pregnant wife and his parents. “The gates of hell have opened,” he said. “God help us.”

Gaza’s Hamas prime minister insisted on an Israeli withdrawal from Gaza and the opening of blockaded border crossings as part of any truce. “As we are in the middle of this crisis, we tell our people we, God willing, are closer to victory. All the blood that is being shed will not go to waste,” Mr. Haniyeh said on Hamas’ Al Aqsa television.

But he said the group was also pursuing a diplomatic track to end the conflict that “will not close.” Mr. Haniyeh sat a desk in a room with a Palestinian flag and a Quran in the background. His location was unclear; Israeli airstrikes have targeted militant chiefs, and most are in hiding. The fighting began Dec.

27 and has killed more than 900 Palestinians, about half of them civilians, according to Palestinian medical officials. Thirteen Israelis, including 10 soldiers, have been killed. As diplomats struggled for traction in truce efforts, Mr.

Olmert said Israel would only end military operations if Hamas stops rocketing Israel, as it has done for years, and is unable to rearm after combat subsides. “Anything else will be met with the Israeli people’s iron fist,” Mr. Olmert said. “We will continue to strike with full strength, with full force until there is quiet and rearmament stops.”

Israeli soldiers advance toward the northern Gaza Strip. Ground troops edged closer to the Gaza Strip’s densely populated urban center on Monday. (ASSOCIATED PRESS PHOTOS)

Correction: The caption read 13 July 2009. The scan prints "Tuesday" with 13 January 2009, which was a Tuesday; 13 July 2009 was a Monday.

CP-2009-034 →

· Asbury Park Press

Next step could hinge on ‘decisive’ talks in Egypt

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Terrified residents ran for cover Tuesday in a densely populated neighborhood of Gaza City as Israeli troops backed by tanks thrust deeper into the city and sought Hamas fighters in alleyways and cellars.

On the diplomatic front, Egyptian mediators pushed Hamas to accept a truce proposal and, in a hopeful sign, Israel sent its lead negotiator to Cairo for “decisive” talks on a cease-fire. U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon also headed for the region to join diplomatic efforts.

Israeli military officials say that depending on what happens with what they described as “decisive” talks in Cairo, Israel will move closer to a cease-fire or widen its offensive. They spoke on condition of anonymity because they were discussing sensitive policy matters.

Asked if Israel’s war aims had been achieved, Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak said: “Most of them, probably not all of them.” Israeli troops now have the coastal city of 400,000 virtually surrounded as part of an offensive launched Dec. 27 to end years of Palestinian rocket attacks on its southern towns.

Palestinian medical officials reported at least 42 deaths from the conflict on Tuesday throughout Gaza. Early Wednesday an Israeli warplane fired a missile at the former Gaza city hall, used as a court building in recent years, witnesses said. The 1910 structure was destroyed and many stores in the market around it were badly damaged, they said.

The Israeli military said three soldiers were wounded, including an officer who was searching a northern Gaza house when a bomb exploded. Palestinian hospital officials say more than 940 Palestinians, half of them civilians, have been killed in the fighting. A total of 13 Israelis, 10 of them soldiers, have died.

Palestinian rocket fire has dropped significantly since the offensive was launched. Some 15 rockets and mortar shells were fired toward Israel Tuesday, causing no injuries, the army said.

Palestinians react after hearing news about dead relatives on Tuesday outside the morgue in Kamal Adwan hospital in the northern Gaza Strip town of Beit Lahiya.

CP-2009-033 →

· The Herald-Times

Embargo led to attacks

To the editor: At the direction of the Bush administration, our U.N. representative to the Security Council vetoed a proposal that would have called for an immediate cease-fire in the Gaza Strip. The purpose of this veto was to permit the Israeli government to proceed with its attempt to root out and essentially overthrow the Hamas government in Gaza.

Rockets have been fired from the Gaza Strip into Israel during the past seven months, but until the Israeli attack 10 days ago, no Israeli citizen had been killed. Firing rockets into another country is certainly an act of aggression.

But what had preceded these attacks was Israel’s decision, strongly backed by the U.S., to seal off the borders and embargo the Palestinians. Food supplies, medical supplies, electricity, oil — the necessities of life — were reduced to a mere trickle.

Hospitals and schools and businesses could not function, and children were diagnosed as suffering from malnutrition. Rescue ships bringing desperately needed supplies were turned back by the Israeli navy; Palestinian fishermen were not permitted to leave the shore; the country was being slowly strangled.

Such tactics constitute an act of aggression; it is beyond shameful that American foreign policy permits such treatment of a democratically elected government. JIM ACKERMAN Bloomington

CP-2009-038 →

· Log Cabin Democrat · Conway · page 1

Human shields: Hamas’ favorite tactic

Hamas’ favorite tactic

Alan M. Dershowitz, special to the Los Angeles Times

“A temporary cease-fire in Gaza that simply allows Hamas to obtain more lethal weapons will assure a repetition of Hamas’ win-win tactic of firing rockets at Israeli civilians while using Palestinian civilians as human shields.” The pull-quote set into the column reads: “A bad day for Hamas is a day in which its rockets fail to kill or injure any Israeli civilians.”

Two years after the Gaza clippings in which the shields volunteered, a syndicated column makes the phrase mean the opposite, and the archive holds both. The scan is 146 pixels wide across four columns, so only the line under the headline, the byline, the opening sentence and the pull-quote have been re-read against it.

CP-2009-016 →

· The News Virginian · Waynesboro

Gaza war doctor grieves 3 daughters

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — The Palestinian doctor provided Israeli TV viewers with regular updates on Gaza fighting’s human toll. But Friday’s report was different — with sobs he told how his three daughters and a niece were killed by an Israeli shell. “I want to know why my daughters were harmed,” Ezzeldeen Abu al-Aish said on Channel 10.

“This should haunt [Israeli Ehud Prime Minister] Olmert his entire life.” Throughout the 21-day war, Abu al-Aish has brought accounts of war’s tragedy to Israeli living rooms, making him for many the voice of Palestinian suffering.

During the broadcasts, Abu al-Aish also often spoke of his fears for his eight children as Israeli shells punished not only the Hamas militants they were targeting but civilians who live in the crowded enclave. His wife reportedly died recently of cancer.

When Channel 10 called him on Friday, he answered his cell phone crying that his house in the northern Gaza strip town of Jebalia had been hit by Israeli shells and his daughters killed. Eighteen members of his extended family were in the house at the time.

Gazan officials identified Abu Al-Aish’s slain daughters as 22-year-old Bisan, 15-year-old Mayer and 14-year old Aya. His niece was identified as 14-year-old Nour Abu al-Aish. At least two other daughters were injured. His tragedy prompted numerous calls of concern to the station, many from people who know him.

“We all know and love him well at Soroka, and we really hope the situation gets better,” Dr. Shaul Sofer, head of the ER at Soroka who taught Abu al-Aish. Abu al-Aish, a 55-year-old gynecologist, is a rarity among Palestinians, a Hebrew speaker who trained in two Israeli hospitals.

He is also is a known peace activist who was involved in promoting joint Israeli-Palestinian projects, and an academic who studied the affects of war on Gazan and Israeli children. He works at Gaza’s main Shifa Hospital.

Dr. Ezzeldeen Abu Al-Aish, a Palestinian doctor who trained in Israel, bursts into tears as he is escorted into Tel Hashomer hospital in Tel Aviv, Israel, late Friday after he was evacuated from the Gaza Strip.

CP-2009-031 →

· The Boston Globe · Boston · page 1

Israel accused of war crimes

White phosphorus used, group says

Israel is the subject and then held at two removes: accused, and then group says. Both are ordinary newspaper practice. The same day another paper ran the same finding with the fact in the subject position and the quotation marks moved onto the word that means it cannot be argued with.

CP-2009-021 →

· estimated · The Retort

Israel & Palestine, The Aftermath

By Bailey Martin, Of The Retort Staff

“Today, the recent conflict between Israel and Palestine seems to be at a close. Two ceasefires — one by Hamas and another by Israel — have been declared and now they are starting to be upheld. Israel and Palestine have been at conflict since decades before the establishment of Israel as a country.

The groundwork was laid for tensions between Israel and Palestine at the end of the 19th century when the Zionist movement emerged as a response to European anti-Semitism. The latest Israeli-Palestinian conflict began on December 27th, and lasted 22 days until its end on January 17th.

According to British Broadcasting Corporation News (BBC), the conflict began when sites across Gaza were assaulted by air and missile attacks sent by Israel. Prime Minister of Israel, Ehud Olmert, declared a one-sided end to military operation in the Gaza Strip on January 17th.

On that same day, a spokesman for the UN called for an investigation to determine if a war crime occurred. On January 18th, Israeli sources reported that eighteen rockets were fired into Israel within hours of the ceasefire. A week-long ceasefire was declared by Moussa Abou Marzouk, the deputy chief of Hamas. He demanded that Israeli troops leave the Gaza Strip.

January 21st marked the final withdrawal of Israeli troops from the Gaza Strip. After they withdrew, the troops were posted around Gaza. According to BBC, over 1,300 Palestinians — almost a third of them were children — were killed, and 5,500 Palestinians have been wounded in the conflict.

During the fighting, thirteen Israelis — three of which were civilians — were killed. In Gaza, 20,000 buildings have been brutally damaged and over 4,000 buildings have been ruined. The conflict has left 400,000 Palestinians in Gaza without running water, and 50,000 homeless.

In the Gaza Strip, Hamas is giving payments to Palestinians who have lost their homes or family members. They claim to be basing their payments on the extent of each individual’s loss as opposed to basing them on political affiliation. Many Palestinians view this as an attempt to purchase political support.

During the conflict, Israel used white phosphorus shells in Gaza. White phosphorus can cause death when ingested or inhaled, it also clings to skin and can burn through flesh to the bone. This can result in painful injuries or death. According to BBC, in open battleground, white phosphorus may legally be used to create smokescreens.

Israel has been accused of illegally using white phosphorus in crowded civilian areas. A spokesman for Israel’s foreign ministry says that their internal investigation has yet to uncover evidentiary support for claims of illegal white phosphorus use. Headquarters of the United Nations (UN) were struck by some white phosphorus shells during the conflict.

Allegations of Israel’s illegal use have been made by Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, and foreign journalists. The International Red Cross has seen no evidence of white phosphorus being used illegally. Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert says Israel will protect any Israeli soldiers accused of war crimes in Gaza from overseas prosecution.

UN officials want independent investigations into war crimes accusations. Now, in Egypt, attempts are being made to create a lasting ceasefire between Israel and Palestine in Gaza. During the conflict, Egypt mediated between Israel and Palestinian militants. Representatives from Hamas and Israel are expected to meet in Egypt to work on creating a bilateral long-term ceasefire.

European Union (EU) foreign ministers have met to discuss the Israeli-Palestinian conflict’s end and what should been done in the process for peace. They are urging Palestinian factions to come together as one during peace talks. In their conditions for a lasting ceasefire, Israel is demanding the end of smuggling weapons into Gaza via Egypt.

Hamas wants Israel to open Gaza’s border crossings and to end their blockade without delay. Israel’s blockade of the Gaza Strip has been strengthened since June 2007 when Hamas began controlling it. Much needed aid, construction materials, and goods have been kept by the blockade from entering Gaza.”

A student paper working through the January 2009 war on Gaza with the BBC as its source and the numbers kept in the copy: 1,300 Palestinians killed, almost a third of them children, 5,500 wounded, 13 Israelis killed, 400,000 without running water, 50,000 homeless. White phosphorus is named, explained and attributed, and the last paragraph is about the blockade.

Correction: {'note': 'Captioned 20 January 2009. The copy reports the final Israeli withdrawal of 21 January, so it was printed later than that date and the day is marked estimated.'}

CP-2009-026 →

· Daytona Beach News-Journal · Daytona Beach

Last Israeli troops leave Gaza

Shelling, smuggling test truce

JERUSALEM — Israel’s last troops left the Gaza Strip on Wednesday, although the cease-fire was frayed when its navy opened fire toward beaches in northern Gaza, and smugglers’ tunnels that were targeted in the 23-day campaign against Hamas were active again at the Egyptian border.

The Israeli military said it would investigate allegations by the United Nations and human rights groups that it wrongly used white phosphorous — an ingredient in weapons that inflicts horrific burns.

Although the use of phosphorus weapons is permitted by international law, Amnesty International has accused Israel of committing a “war crime” by using them in densely populated areas.

A Palestinian human rights group said it had completed its count of the death toll from the Israeli operation, putting the number of dead Palestinians at 1,284 — with 894 of those civilians including 280 children or teenagers. The Israeli military said 500 Palestinian militants were killed. Gaza’s militant groups said they lost 158 fighters.

Thirteen Israelis also were killed, 10 of them soldiers. As the Israeli troops departed and the focus shifted to cementing the fragile cease-fire, Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni went to Europe to rally international support for a plan to halt weapons smuggling into Gaza from Egypt.

A key goal of the offensive, aimed at punishing Hamas militants who have been lobbing rockets at Israel for the past eight years, was destroying the hundreds of tunnels along the eight-mile border used to smuggle weapons into Gaza.

Israel said it had destroyed about 60 percent of the tunnels — but already Wednesday there were signs they were back in action, adding urgency to Livni’s mission. President Barack Obama is expected to name former Senate Democratic leader George J.

Mitchell special envoy to the Mideast for incoming Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton, according to diplomatic officials.

Palestinian human rights researcher Yasser Abdel Ghafar, second from left, takes notes while talking to Rami Najar, left, in front of his family’s destroyed house in Khan Younis, southern Gaza Strip, on Wednesday. Three members of Rami’s family were killed in an Israel Army attack.

The job of counting Gaza’s dead is a painstaking endeavor carried out under chaotic and confusing conditions.

Correction: The deck caption gave a shorter name than the masthead prints. Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 163 clippings in this deck.

CP-2009-030 →

· The Forum · Fargo, ND (columnist datelined Casselton, N.D.)

Heaviest guilt falls on Israel

ROSS NELSON / Casselton, N.D.

We will wield disproportionate power against every village from which shots are fired on Israel, and cause immense damage and destruction ... This is a plan that has already been authorized. – Israeli Maj. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot, October 2008 Intentionally launching a disproportionate attack is a war crime.

(ICC Statute, Article 8 (2) (b) (iv)) – Amnesty International Israel's military leaders weren't joking. About 100 Palestinians were killed for every Israeli in the recent turkey shoot in Gaza, better than half of them civilians and many of the rest having only a tenuous connection to Hamas.

The Bush administration did everything it could to stymie any ceasefire and extend the slaughter as long as possible, much like it did in the 2006 war between Israel and Hezbollah.

This is an opinion column with a mugshot of the author, not staff news copy. The column opens with two epigraphs — Eisenkot and Amnesty International — before the first line of body text. Maria's row lists this clipping second but the images are in the reverse order: s003_1 is the Los Angeles Times and s003_2 is The Forum.

CP-2009-039 →

· Taylorville Daily Breeze-Courier · Taylorville · page 1

“A Partner for Peace”

“Israel’s Prime Minister designate Benjamin Netanyahu is seen before giving a speech at an economic conference in Jerusalem, Wednesday, March 25, 2009. Netanyahu on Wednesday promised to resume peace talks with the Palestinians after he takes office, saying his government will be a ‘partner for peace.’” (AP Photo/Bernat Armangue)

CP-2009-022 →

· Huntsville Times · Huntsville · page 1

Netanyahu: Israel ‘partner for peace’ with Palestinians

Likud leader reverses course, willing to talk

Amy Teibel, The Associated Press, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM — Incoming Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Wednesday his government would be a “partner for peace with the Palestinians,” softening his hawkish rhetoric a day after the centrist Labor Party joined his coalition in exchange for vaguely worded promises to pursue negotiations.

During his election campaign, the Likud Party leader painted himself as an opponent of peace talks. But facing the prospect of a clash with the Obama administration, Netanyahu has been tempering his line. Peace is a “common and enduring goal for all Israelis and Israeli governments, mine included,” Netanyahu told an economic conference in Jerusalem.

“This means I will negotiate with the Palestinian Authority for peace,” he added. “The Palestinians should understand that they have in our government a partner for peace, for security, for the rapid development of the Palestinian economy,” Netanyahu said.

But he remains vague on the issue of Palestinian statehood, a key component of current peace efforts. With the backing of at least 69 lawmakers, and likely more, he plans to present his government to parliament next week for its approval, he said. His spokeswoman Dina Libster said the vote likely would take place Tuesday.

Palestinians welcomed Netanyahu’s words, but said they must be matched by deeds. On Wednesday, Netanyahu said his plan to develop the Palestinian economy was not a substitute for political negotiations but “a complement to them.” A strong Palestinian economy is a “strong foundation for peace,” he said.

Netanyahu spoke hours after Labor voted to join his coalition, adding a moderate element to what had been shaping up to be a narrow, hawkish government.

The phrase the archive tracks, used the other way round: here Netanyahu is claiming to be the partner for peace.

CP-2009-023 →

· Evansville Courier & Press · Evansville · page 1

Biblical Claim

Karen Amin

“Biblical Claim. CONTRARY TO the ideas expressed in a recent letter, Israel has neither a just nor an historic claim to Palestine. Her claim is biblical and in a world in which two-thirds of its inhabitants do not recognize the Bible as divinely inspired nor as historical fact, this claim can hardly be considered legitimate.

True, there were Hebrews in Palestine from about 900 B.C. onward, but they were only one of a myriad of peoples who lived in the Fertile Crescent area. For the Jews to portray themselves as an exclusive, significant and powerful people in ancient Palestine is a gross distortion of historical fact. Jewish power and influence flowered in Europe, not in the Middle East.

Nor do the Jews have a just claim to Palestine. There is no justice in asking Arabs to pay the price for the atrocities committed by Europeans. Furthermore, to continually hold the specter of World War II before the American public is not a plea for justice, but only cheap emotional blackmail.”

A reader's letter answering another reader, printed whole.

CP-2009-024 →

· Evansville Courier & Press · Evansville · page 1

Don't fund Israeli attacks on Gaza

Sam Blankenship, Mount Vernon, Ind.

“Israel’s warring actions in Gaza are terroristic and our country should cut off all aid to it… We are horribly complicit in the deaths of more than 500 Gazan children. We have pledged $30 billion to Israel over the next 10 years. Most of the funds must be used to purchase American weapons. We recently pledged $900 million to help rebuild Gaza.

It is insanity to fund both the destruction and the rebuilding of Gaza.”

CP-2009-025 →

· The Jackson Sun · Jackson, TN

Army's ethics chief: Israel put on fair fight in Gaza

By KARIN LAUB / The Associated Press

NETANYA, Israel — In some ways, Brig. Gen. Eli Shermeister's job is one of the toughest in the Israeli army. Shermeister serves as the Israeli army's ethics watchdog, at a time when the military is under international scrutiny for its behavior during its Gaza invasion.

That puts him in the front line of a war of words that extends into the white-hot realm of "war crimes," "anti-Semitism," "atrocities" and "blood libel." But his job is made easier by the fact that most Israelis support his contention that they have nothing to be ashamed of.

"I didn't see in the Gaza operation anything that can teach us or show us that something in the moral attitude of the IDF (military) was ... changed or spoiled," Shermeister said in an interview with The Associated Press at an officers' school in Netanya, north of Tel Aviv. [...] One army officer, Maj. Gen.

Gadi Eizenkot, has spoken of the "Dahiya doctrine," named after the Beirut suburbs considered a Hezbollah stronghold where Israel destroyed dozens of buildings in 2006. "We will wield disproportionate power against every village from which shots are fired on Israel, and cause immense damage and destruction.

From our perspective, these are military bases," Eizenkot told the daily Yedioth Ahronoth in October. "This isn't a suggestion. This is a plan that has already been authorized." The army would not confirm such a doctrine exists, but acknowledged many similarities between the Lebanon and Gaza wars. In Israel, debate about the Gaza offensive came late and quickly fizzled.

Photo caption: "A Palestinian man plants a tree Tuesday during a protest demanding the right to farm land near the border with Israel, in Khan Younis, southern Gaza Strip. The protesters replanted trees in an area destroyed by Israeli forces during the recent offensive." Credit: KHALIL HAMRA/The Associated Press — a Palestinian AP photographer, and one of only two pictures in this batch in which Palestinians are doing something other than being killed or throwing something. The story also reports that last month the Maariv and Haaretz dailies quoted from a discussion at a military prep school in which unidentified Gaza war veterans described vague rules of engagement, an "anything goes" atmosphere, and two cases of fatal shootings of Palestinian civilians caught in the war zone, and that the military prosecutor's office concluded the reports of the killings had been based on hearsay. Also named: Col. Bentzi Gruber.

CP-2009-043 →

· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota

The Blue Eagles soar above their occupied lands

By Howard Schneider, The Washington Post

WADI AL-NEES, West Bank — Like any soccer match among 6-year-olds, the gang behind the village school brought as much structure to the game as a swarm of bees.

But Omar Abu Hamad, coach of the champion Wadi al-Nees Blue Eagles of the Palestinian Football Association, was already scouting his next generation of players — including the speedy sons of two of his current stars. If all goes well, he said, this village of 800 in the occupied West Bank will contribute to a Palestinian national team worthy of the world stage.

“Their talent puts them on the right track,” he said of the children. “The reputation is very important to us. We want to build our team.”

More than 15 years after the Oslo peace accords put Palestinian society on what was envisioned as a path to self-government, prospects for the creation of a Palestinian state are in limbo… But last fall, the soccer league completed a full 21-game season.

That may not seem like a profound step forward, but it is one that gave fans in 22 towns and villages a taste of normalcy, and a chance to wave a flag in a context that did not involve rock throwing or tear gas. Play had been suspended for years because of the violent Palestinian uprising, or intifada, that broke out in 2000.

But the sport appears to be on the upswing under the guidance of Jibril Rajoub… Roughly $3 million in overseas donations and some local funding paid for renovations that brought Ramallah’s al-Husseini stadium up to international standards. Last fall, the Palestinian national team played its first ever FIFA-sanctioned home match: a 1-1 draw against Jordan.

Perhaps as significant, Wadi al-Nees — for its winning effort in last season’s league play — earned a $25,000 prize that will let the Blue Eagles invest in new shoes and equipment and perhaps start developing a home pitch, or playing field. The team currently practices on the same blacktop playground where the coach scouts the 6-year-olds.

“For the first time in years we had a league from A to Zed. For the first time in the history of Palestine we had a league for women. We had a home pitch. This has never happened,” Rajoub said. “One of the problems we have is to convince the international community that we deserve independence.

Presenting the Palestinian people through sport is an important development — to convince the world that we are normal.” It has certainly become central to Wadi al-Nees, the playfully named “Valley of the Porcupines.” The village sits on a hillside south of Bethlehem, near the Israeli settlement of Efrat.

Salim Abu Hamad, the soccer team’s director, said their area had not witnessed serious clashes during the intifada. Many men in the town work as stonecutters in a nearby Palestinian-owned quarry. It is a quiet life in a village where most everyone is related, by blood or marriage, to the Abu Hamad clan. Which makes the soccer, like everything else here, a family affair.

The team is largely a gaggle of brothers and cousins, though they have imported a player or two. The team was formed in the 1980s, and at first was a doormat for one of the lower divisions in the nascent league.

As the league expanded, Wadi al-Nees eventually started bringing home prizes even as it advanced to the top division — a triumph, team members say, against the odds. Goalkeeper Mohammed Abu Hamad is hardly a giant in the net. But he scoffs at mention of his short stature and notes that in 21 games last year the Blue Eagles allowed only 10 goals.

“The secret is loving one another,” the coach said. “Other teams fight among themselves.” The Abu Hamads, coach and director, say they have the talent to stay atop the Palestinian league and, over time, help boost the national squad out of its ranking of 174, between Bangladesh and St. Lucia.

Ultimately, they said, a match against the Israeli national squad is not out of the question, but only after they have a few years to build. “Now,” said Salim Abu Hamad, “we just need a field.”

Wadi al-Nees, a Palestinian village of 800 south of Bethlehem, fields winning soccer teams. (Washington Post / Howard Schneider)

A village of 800 called the Valley of the Porcupines, a soccer team that is mostly brothers and cousins, and a coach who scouts six-year-olds on the blacktop playground where his champion side also trains, because they have no pitch. The head of the Palestinian Football Association says what the league is for: ‘Presenting the Palestinian people through sport is an important development — to convince the world that we are normal.’ He also notes, in passing, that the previous season was the first in the history of Palestine with a league for women. The national squad is ranked 174th, between Bangladesh and St. Lucia. The team’s $25,000 prize is to go on shoes, equipment and perhaps a field. The story ends on the director saying the only thing still missing: Now, we just need a field.

CP-2009-029 →

· The Jonesboro Sun · Jonesboro, AR · page B11

Army's ethics chief: Israel fair in Gaza

BY KARIN LAUB / ASSOCIATED PRESS WRITER

NETANYA, Israel (AP) — In some ways, Brig. Gen. Eli Shermeister's job is one of the toughest in the Israeli army. Shermeister serves as the Israeli army's ethics watchdog, at a time when the military is under international scrutiny for its behavior during its Gaza invasion.

That puts him in the front line of a war of words that extend into the white-hot realm of "war crimes," "anti-Semitism," "atrocities" and "blood libel." But his job is made easier by the fact that most Israelis support his contention that they have nothing to be ashamed of.

"I didn't see in the Gaza operation anything that can teach us or show us that something in the moral attitude of the IDF (military) was ... changed or spoiled," Shermeister said in an interview with The Associated Press at an officers' school in Netanya, north of Tel Aviv. The 3-week Gaza war has widened the gap between Israel's self-image and how it is perceived abroad.

The wave of international criticism, and an imminent U.N. investigation, have deepened a sense here that Israel is being treated unfairly and held to impossible standards. Critics in Israel as well However, the war that took more than 1,000 lives by both sides' count and left entire neighborhoods in rubble has a few Israeli critics, too.

They say their countrymen are too quick to brush aside tough questions arising from the military's overwhelming use of force in Gaza, including mounting hundreds of bombing raids and firing imprecise artillery shells in one of the most crowded places on Earth.

They say Israeli leaders haven't posed the right question to the public — how much force and loss of civilian life is it willing to sanction to stop the rockets that Gaza militants had been firing at Israeli communities for eight years. The offensive, launched Dec. 27, had been intended as a punishing blow to Hamas, similar to what Israel unleashed in the 2006 war in Lebanon.

The campaigns sent a message, both to Gaza's Hamas rulers and Lebanon's Hezbollah guerrillas, that rocket attacks would draw a harsh response.

Deterrence, say Israeli military experts, is the key weapon in Israel's arsenal; the military is developing a shield against short-range rockets and missiles, but it would only be deployed next year at the earliest, and will likely be expensive and only partially effective. One army officer, Maj. Gen.

Gadi Eizenkot, has spoken of the "Dahiya doctrine," named after the Beirut suburbs considered a Hezbollah stronghold where Israel destroyed dozens of buildings in 2006. "We will wield disproportionate power against every village from which shots are fired on Israel, and cause immense damage and destruction.

From our perspective, these are military bases," Eizenkot told the daily Yedioth Ahronoth in October. "This isn't a suggestion. This is a plan that has already been authorized."

Crosshead in the story reads "Critics in Israel as well". The structure of the page is worth recording in itself: a wire story headlined on the army's own ethics chief saying Israel was fair in Gaza, which then, five paragraphs later and in the same narrow column, prints the Dahiya doctrine in the general's own words with the word "disproportionate" in it. The AP does not editorialise on the contradiction; it simply sets the two next to each other. Also quoted in the story: Yedioth Ahronoth.

CP-2009-040 →

· The Jonesboro Sun · Jonesboro, AR · page B11

Palestinians set peace demands

Chief negotiator says Israel must back 2-state solution

BY DIAA HADID / ASSOCIATED PRESS WRITER

JERUSALEM (AP) — Israel must declare its support for the eventual establishment of a Palestinian state if peace talks are to resume, the chief Palestinian negotiator said Saturday.

In neighboring Jordan, senior officials from several Arab states reiterated their support for an Arab peace initiative offering recognition to Israel in exchange for an Israeli withdrawal from the territories it occupied in the 1967 Mideast War, including the Gaza Strip and the Palestinians want for a state.

However, Israel's previous centrist government did not accept the initiative, and it is even less likely to win the support of the new right-wing coalition led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

Folio reads "SUNDAY, APRIL 12, 2009 | WORLD | www.jonesborosun.com | THE JONESBORO SUN | B11". Photo caption above the headline: "King Abdullah II of Jordan (center back) meets with Arab foreign ministers and the secretary general of the Arab League at the Royal Palace in Amman, Jordan, on Saturday." Credit: Yousef Allan, Jordan Royal Palace / AP. Also named in the story: Palestinian foreign minister Riad Malki, President Mahmoud Abbas, U.S. envoy George Mitchell, and Jordanian Foreign Minister Nasser Judeh. No Eisenkot in this article.

CP-2009-041 →

· Asheville Citizen Times · Asheville, NC · page A4

Israel defends army conduct

Despite criticism, ethics chief says Gaza conflict waged fairly

By Karin Laub / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

NETANYA, Israel — In some ways, Brig. Gen. Eli Shermeister's job is one of the toughest in the Israeli army. Shermeister serves as the Israeli army's ethics watchdog at a time when the military is under international scrutiny for its behavior during its Gaza invasion.

That puts him in the front line of a war of words that extend into the white-hot realm of "war crimes," "anti-Semitism," "atrocities" and "blood libel." But his job is made easier by the fact that most Israelis support his contention that they have nothing to be ashamed of.

"I didn't see in the Gaza operation anything that can teach us or show us that something in the moral attitude of the IDF (military) was ... changed or spoiled," Shermeister said in an interview with The Associated Press at an officers' school in Netanya, north of Tel Aviv.

Image problems The three-week Gaza war has widened the gap between Israel's self-image and how it is perceived abroad. The wave of international criticism, and an imminent U.N. investigation, have deepened a sense here that Israel is being treated unfairly and held to impossible standards.

However, the war that took more than 1,000 lives by both sides' count and left entire neighborhoods in rubble has a few Israeli critics, too.

They say their countrymen are too quick to brush aside tough questions arising from the military's overwhelming use of force in Gaza, including mounting hundreds of bombing raids and firing imprecise artillery shells in one of the most crowded places on Earth. [...] 'Disproportionate power' One army officer, Maj. Gen.

Gadi Eizenkot, has spoken of the "Dahiya doctrine," named after the Beirut suburbs considered a Hezbollah stronghold where Israel destroyed dozens of buildings in 2006. "We will wield disproportionate power against every village from which shots are fired on Israel, and cause immense damage and destruction.

From our perspective, these are military bases," Eizenkot told the daily Yedioth Ahronoth in October. "This isn't a suggestion. This is a plan that has already been authorized." The army would not confirm such a doctrine exists, but acknowledged many similarities between the Lebanon and Gaza wars. In Israel, debate about the Gaza offensive came late and quickly fizzled.

Folio reads "A4 SUNDAY, APRIL 12, 2009" with the section head "WOR[LD]" — date agrees with Maria's label; the paper's own name is not in the visible folio. Crossheads: "Image problems", "'Disproportionate power'", "Finding solidarity". Photo caption: "An Israeli soldier fires tear gas towards Palestinian protesters in the village of Safa near the West Bank Jewish settlement of Bat Ayin on Wednesday. Palestinian medics said eight people were wounded in the clash with Jewish settlers in a Palestinian village near the spot of a deadly attack in the West Bank last week." Credit: NASSER SHIYOUKHI/THE ASSOCIATED PRESS. This is the same Karin Laub AP story as the Jonesboro Sun (slide 17) and The Jackson Sun (s019_2), run in three American papers within three days.

CP-2009-042 →

· Juneau Empire

Obama: 'Palestine' named

changes in U.S. foreign policy. Nevertheless, interviews from Egypt to Turkey and Iraq suggested that they believed he was distancing himself from the Bush era and prepared to engage the Islamic world with openness and trust.

“I have come here to seek a new beginning between the United States and Muslims around the world, one based upon mutual interest and mutual respect,” Obama said. “America and Islam are not exclusive, and need not be in competition. This cycle of suspicion and discord must end.”

That discord has been prevalent for generations, but intensified after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. Americans grew increasingly wary of the Islamic world. The invasion of Iraq and Bush’s declaration of a war on terrorism angered Muslims, many of whom believed Washington was using its military power to control the Middle East and its oil.

Tensions were further aggravated by al-Qaida and an increase in terrorism attacks worldwide. Obama called for a renewed drive to solve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and acknowledged the importance of reaching out to Iran, whose nuclear ambitions have been a growing, contentious concern.

He said he wanted U.S. soldiers out of Iraq, promised that America would not condone torture, and stated that even though he had ordered a troop buildup in Afghanistan, Washington had no desire for long-term military bases there.

“There is a difference between his policy and Bush’s policy,” said Mahmoud Ramahi, a Hamas member of the Palestinian Authority parliament. “But the problem is still on the ground. Would they achieve a Palestinian independent state? If he does that, that would be a relief and good for all parties.”

The clipping is a jump page and carries no date line or masthead. It reports Barack Obama’s address to the Muslim world in Cairo, delivered on 4 June 2009, quoting it at length. It was filed here as May 2014, which put it in the wrong decade. The month is established by the speech; the day is not on the page and is not guessed.

CP-2014-029 →

· Corpus Christi Caller Times · Corpus Christi · page 1

Netanyahu rejects construction freeze

By Amy Teibel, Associated Press

“Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Monday rejected President Barack Obama’s demand for a freeze on West Bank Jewish settlement construction, but his government’s move to dismantle some squatter camps set off a rampage by Jewish settlers against Palestinians… Netanyahu said Israel cannot ‘freeze life’ in settlements, according to a participant who spoke on condition of anonymity because the meeting was closed.

Netanyahu was quoted as saying that ‘there are reasonable requests and unreasonable requests.’ Settlers have vowed to retaliate with attacks on Palestinians after removal even the tiniest enclave — a tactic known as ‘price tag.’”

An elderly, disabled Palestinian man sits with his relatives.

The whole caption is eight words. No name, no place, no date, and no connection to the story, which is about settlement construction. The photograph is there to be a picture of Palestinians.

CP-2009-019 →

· Chicago Jewish Star · Chicago, IL · page 1

CITY HOSTS ANTI-ISRAEL, ANTI-JEWISH FEST

"NON-POLITICAL" EVENT HAS ANTI-ISRAEL CRAFTS, LITERATURE / 3RD ANNUAL CHICAGO ARABESQUE / JUF DECRIES ANTI-SEMITIC HANDOUT, CHICAGO HUMAN RELATIONS INACTION

By DOUGLAS WERTHEIMER, Editor

Continuing a trend first described in these pages nearly six years ago, a program hosted by the City of Chicago Commission on Human Relations (CCHR), with the explicit approval of Mayor Richard M. Daley, has again included an anti-Israel — and this year, an anti-Semitic — component.

The third annual "Chicago Arabesque" was described as "a non-religious, non-political festival that promotes public awareness, understanding, and appreciation of the rich cultural heritage of the Arab World," by Dana V. Starks, CCHR Chairman, in a June 8 letter printed in a City of Chicago promotional brochure for the event.

That description — the exact same words were used for the 2007 event — was not accurate then nor in 2009, judging by items sold at those events. In both years, they included material featuring geographic images labelled "Palestine" (in English and Arabic) which extend from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea, obliterating the State of Israel.

One such image listed, in Arabic, the names of cities in the area covered by the Palestinian flag. Those cities — Acre, Tiberias, Haifa, Tsfat, Lod and Jerusalem — are in Israel.

LABEL ORDER: Maria's label lists slide 78 as 'Wisconsin State Journal Aug 8 2009' then 'Chicago Jewish Star July 3 2009'; s078_1 is the Wisconsin State Journal column and s078_2 is the Chicago Jewish Star, so on this slide the order matches the label. Front page of the Chicago Jewish Star; the masthead itself is above the top of the scan and is not visible, so the date is label-only. Attribution to the paper is secure from its own body text, which refers to 'the JEWISH STAR' twice and to a translation done 'for the JEWISH STAR by Alexandra Dunietz'. The three stacked lines recorded in dek are the paper's own deck stack, set between rules beneath the banner headline. WORTH SHOWING MARIA: the typographic argument. This paper puts the word Palestine in quotation marks every time it appears for a place — 'an image of "Palestine"', 'a PLO-like image of "Palestine"', 'geographic images labelled "Palestine"' — while printing Israel, the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea without them. It uses 'Palestinian' without quotation marks only as an adjective for a flag and for an organisation. The clipping is the mirror image of the 1949-1959 group: there, Palestine was a neutral geographical word and Palestinians did not exist; here, Palestinians exist and the word Palestine is what is in dispute. Photo caption, transcribed from a magnified crop, three photographs across the top of the page: 'FOR SALE AT THE "NON-RELIGIOUS, NON-POLITICAL" CHICAGO ARABESQUE — At the booth run by Arabica, a Bridgeview store, at Chicago Arabesque last week, wall hangings and key chains (at left) featured an image of "Palestine" with the Palestinian flag covering the territory from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean, blotting out the State of Israel. The silhouette is identical to that used by the Palestine Liberation Organization, whose Charter calls for "purg[ing] the Zionist presence from Palestine". / A t-shirt (center) at the Palestine Solidarity Group booth featured the words "ZIONISM MAKES ME SO ANGRY!". / At another booth, wooden table top carvings featured a Palestinian flag flying over a PLO-like image of "Palestine". The Arabic text, translated for the JEWISH STAR by Alexandra Dunietz, lists the names of cities of this geographical area, including Acre, Tiberias, Haifa, Tsfat, Lod, and Jerusalem — all of which are in present-day Israel.' Credit: '— LEFT AND RIGHT IMAGES: CHICAGO JEWISH STAR PHOTOS'. A sidebar box reads 'EDITORIAL, PAGE 4: Shut down the Arab Advisory Council'. Three unrelated articles share the page — 'NO MEZUZAH LAW FOR TEXAS', 'Controversial prof gets tenure' (Joseph Massad at Columbia) and 'Kosher packer on the block' — and none is transcribed here. The story continues on page 2 and that continuation is not in the scan.

CP-2009-045 →

· Los Angeles Times

Across the great divide

They share a passion for the Middle East, where geography and the personal hold sway.

AMY WILENTZ

I am a Jew, but also part Palestinian, and pretty much part Lebanese. My great-grandmother, a Jew, was born in northern Palestine and grew up in Beirut. Her first language was Arabic, her second French. By the rules defining who can be called an Arab, she was one: a child of the Arabic tongue. My great-grandfather too.

Another Jew, he was born in Safed and grew up in Alexandria; first language, Arabic. They married in Beirut. When they arrived at Ellis Island, in 1896, they were classified as Turks. By the time I was born, no one in my family talked about this. My first hint was the word my mother used for eggplant, which sounded like “battenjam.”

Thirty years later, I discovered in a book by Palestinian intellectual Edward Said that the Arabic word for eggplant was badinjan. It was as if I had suddenly dipped the madeleine in my tea: A world opened before me. Where my ancestors came from matters, because in the Middle East — which I love completely — everything is geographical.

In “A World I Loved: The Story of an Arab Woman” (Nation Books: 208 pp., $14.95 paper), Wadad Makdisi Cortas, born in 1909, manifests a similar love, inflamed yet tempered by loss. As I read her book, I kept thinking: This is my country too. And yet for Cortas, the greatest disaster was the founding of Israel — also, supposedly, my country.

Everything’s geographical in the Middle East, and personal too: I have a personal interest in Cortas. She is the mother of my longtime acquaintance Mariam Cortas Said and the mother-in-law of Mariam’s late husband, that same Edward Said. (The central figure in my novel about Jerusalem, “Martyrs’ Crossing,” is based in part on him.)

The Makdisis and Saids form an intermarried intellectual dynasty. Edward was one of the commanding Arab thinkers of our era. His sister, Jean Said Makdisi, wrote a stunning memoir of the Lebanese civil war called “Beirut Fragments.” Her son Saree, who teaches at UCLA, wrote “Palestine Inside Out: An Everyday Occupation.”

All were or are teachers or professors — educators at heart. Cortas is an emblematic figure of this family. One of the early educated women of the Arab world, she studied in the U.S. and Paris before returning to Beirut. There, she became a teacher, and then, for 40 years, headmistress of Beirut’s Ahliah School for Girls, where she had studied and taught.

FAMILY: Author Wadad Makdisi Cortas with her children, including daughter Mariam at the piano.

CP-2009-049 →

· The Bulletin

Rare inscribed cup is unearthed near Old Jerusalem

By Thomas H. Maugh II, Los Angeles Times

U.S. archaeologists have found an extremely rare 2,000-year-old limestone cup inscribed with 10 lines of Aramaic or Hebrew script near the Zion Gate of the Old City of Jerusalem.

Such ritual cups are common, especially in areas that were inhabited by priests, but usually they are unmarked or bear only a single line of text, such as a name, said archaeologist Shimon Gibson of the University of North Carolina at Charlotte, who led the dig with James Tabor of the same school.

"To have 10 lines of text is unprecedented," Gibson said in announcing the find Wednesday. Although the script is not eroded or otherwise degraded, he said, researchers are not yet able to decipher it because the text is written in an informal cursive script and is apparently deliberately cryptic.

They know it contains the Hebrew word for God, "YHWH" or "Yahweh," indicating it was probably important to the priests. Gibson predicted it would take two months to six months to understand its meaning. The team has been digging in Gan Sobev Homot Yerushalayim National Park since June 14.

The site, overlooking the Kidron and Hinnom valleys and the Mount of Olives, had not been excavated since the 1970s, when Israeli archaeologist Magen Broshi found a monumental Arabic inscription from the 13th century A.D.

The new dig has produced building remains dating from the founding of the Temple — the center of ancient Judaism — by King Solomon in 970 B.C. through the Early Islamic Period, which ended with the destruction of the Old City by Crusaders in A.D. 1099.

Clipped two-column wire story. No masthead, no folio, no printed date and no city of publication on the scan, so the date is label-only and city_state is left empty. FLAG FOR EVA: 'The Bulletin' is a common American newspaper name and nothing on this clipping identifies which one. Confirm against any existing 'Bulletin' record before ingest. The announcement was made 'Wednesday', which for a Saturday 1 August 2009 paper would be 29 July 2009. WIRE-COPY DIVERGENCE: this is the same Thomas H. Maugh II dispatch the Sacramento Bee ran on the same date, Maria's slide 80. The Bulletin heads it 'Rare inscribed cup is unearthed near Old Jerusalem' and capitalises 'the Temple'; the Bee heads it '2,000-year-old cup unearthed in Jerusalem', sets 'the temple' lower case and uses en dashes where The Bulletin uses em dashes. This clipping ends at A.D. 1099 and the Second Temple Period paragraph; the Bee runs three further paragraphs through the murex shells, the fire pit and the Church of St. Mary. WORTH NOTING AGAINST THE 1949-1959 ARCHAEOLOGY CLIPPINGS: sixty years on, the pattern is unchanged. The dig is in Gan Sobev Homot Yerushalayim National Park, which lies in East Jerusalem, occupied since 1967; the clipping says 'National Park' and nothing else. The only Arab thing in the story is 'a monumental Arabic inscription from the 13th century A.D.', found by somebody else in the 1970s and mentioned in a subordinate clause. The Islamic period is a date range that 'ended'. No Palestinian is named, quoted or alluded to.

CP-2009-047 →

· The Sacramento Bee · Sacramento, CA

2,000-year-old cup unearthed in Jerusalem

BY THOMAS H. MAUGH II, Los Angeles Times

U.S. archaeologists have found an extremely rare 2,000-year-old limestone cup inscribed with 10 lines of Aramaic or Hebrew script near the Zion Gate of the Old City of Jerusalem.

Such ritual cups are common, especially in areas that were inhabited by priests, but usually they are unmarked or bear only a single line of text, such as a name, said archaeologist Shimon Gibson of the University of North Carolina at Charlotte, who led the dig with James Tabor of the same school.

"To have 10 lines of text is unprecedented," Gibson said in announcing the find Wednesday. Although the script is not eroded or otherwise degraded, he said, researchers are not yet able to decipher it because the text is written in an informal cursive script and is apparently deliberately cryptic.

They know it contains the Hebrew word for God, "YHWH" or "Yahweh," indicating it was probably important to the priests. Gibson predicted it would take two to six months to understand its meaning. The team has been digging in Gan Sobev Homot Yerushalayim National Park since June 14.

The site, overlooking the Kidron and Hinnom valleys and the Mount of Olives, had not been excavated since the 1970s, when Israeli archaeologist Magen Broshi found a monumental Arabic inscription from the 13th century A.D.

The new dig has produced building remains dating from the founding of the temple – the center of ancient Judaism – by King Solomon in 970 B.C. through the Early Islamic Period, which ended with the destruction of the Old City by Crusaders in A.D. 1099. From the Second Temple Period, 573 B.C. to A.D.

70, the team found a housing complex with a "mikveh," or purification pool, and a well-preserved vaulted ceiling. Inside the house were three bread ovens dating to A.D. 70, the year when Roman Emperor Titus and his troops sacked the city.

Clipped four-column wire story, no masthead, no folio, no printed date; date is label-only. 'ARCHAEOLOGY' in the reversed bar above the headline is a SECTION FLAG, not a deck; there is no deck. The right-hand third of the clipping is a 'High Blood Pressure?' clinical-trial advertisement and is not part of the article. WIRE-COPY DIVERGENCE: the same Thomas H. Maugh II dispatch as The Bulletin's on slide 79, same date, different headline and different typesetting. Where The Bulletin prints 'the founding of the Temple — the center of ancient Judaism —', the Bee prints 'the founding of the temple – the center of ancient Judaism –', lower case and with en dashes; verified from a magnified crop. The Bee also compresses 'two months to six months' to 'two to six months' and breaks the cryptic-script paragraph in two. The Bee runs the story to its end, through the murex shells, the fire pit, the Byzantine mosaic floor and the Church of St. Mary; The Bulletin's clipping stops earlier. The closing paragraphs of the Bee version were read at page magnification; the opening paragraphs and the 'temple' sentence were transcribed from magnified crops. The observation in the record for The Bulletin about Gan Sobev Homot Yerushalayim National Park and occupied East Jerusalem applies identically here.

CP-2009-048 →

· Wisconsin State Journal · Madison, WI

In Arab gloom a light shines from West Bank

THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN

RAMALLAH, West Bank — In 2002, the U.N. Development Program released its first ever Arab Human Development Report, which bluntly detailed the deficits of freedom, women's empowerment and knowledge-creation holding back the Arab world.

It was buttressed with sobering statistics: Greece alone translated five times more books every year from English to Greek than the entire Arab world translated from English to Arabic; the GDP of Spain was greater than that of all 22 Arab states combined; 65 million Arab adults were illiterate. It was a disturbing picture, bravely produced by Arab academics.

Coming out so soon after 9/11, the report felt like a diagnosis of all the misgovernance bedeviling the Arab world, creating the pools of angry, unemployed youth, who become easy prey for extremists. Well, the good news is that the U.N. Development Program and a new group of Arab scholars last week came out with a new Arab Human Development report.

The bad news: Things have gotten worse — and many Arab governments don't want to hear about it. The whole report would have left me feeling hopeless had I not come to Ramallah, the seat of Palestinian government in the West Bank, to find some good cheer. I'm serious. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is to the wider Middle East what off-Broadway is to Broadway.

It is where all good and bad ideas get tested out first. Well, the Palestinian prime minister, Salam Fayyad, a former International Monetary Fund economist, is testing out the most exciting new idea in Arab governance ever. I call it "Fayyadism."

A syndicated opinion column. No masthead, no folio, no printed date; date is label-only. There is no deck. The byline runs as a photograph of the columnist with 'THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN' reversed out of a black block beside the first paragraph — a standing column signature, not a conventional byline line. Tagline at the foot: 'Friedman writes for the New York Times.' The column's premise — that a reporter comes to Ramallah and finds 'good cheer' in Palestinian governance — sits oddly beside the same columnist's frame, which treats the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as 'off-Broadway' to the Middle East's Broadway and Palestinian rights as a distraction from institution-building. The lede, the Fayyadism paragraph and the two Fayyad quotations were transcribed from magnified crops; the remainder was read at page magnification.

CP-2009-044 →

· The Anniston Star · Anniston, AL · page OP-ED

Obama must face Mideast realities

U.S. should prepare for region's new extremism

BY FRIDA GHITIS, McClatchy Newspapers

President Barack Obama deserves credit for keeping his promise to work for peace in the Middle East from the earliest days of his administration. Unfortunately, the results so far have proven less than encouraging. In fact, some recent trends look downright ominous. On all sides American efforts have run into embarrassing setbacks.

Much global attention has focused on the spat between Washington and Jerusalem over the growth of Israeli settlements on the West Bank and Jerusalem. But Obama's efforts to pressure the other side are running into stiff resistance — and much worse. Obama planned to use his verbal gifts of persuasiveness to persuade all sides to start with small gestures of reconciliation.

All the players would then develop the mutual trust required for the push towards the ultimate prize, peace. It hasn't worked out that way. The first major setback came during a humiliating visit to Saudi Arabia by the American president. The incident received little attention, since it happened hours before Obama's headline-monopolizing speech to Muslims from Cairo.

Obama asked Saudi King Abdullah to give him a token of good will to show Israelis as he publicly pressured them to freeze settlement activity.

The Saudi's answer was a most definitive "No." Even more troubling are developments inside Fatah, the more moderate Palestinian faction, the one the world backs because it favors coexistence with Israel in contrast with Hamas, whose charter calls for Israel's destruction.

Fatah, the party that controls the Palestinian Authority, just held its first convention in two decades in Bethlehem. In advance of the gathering, Fatah officials displayed a troubling tendency toward renewed radicalism. The aim is to drum up popular support among the Palestinian public.

The folio across the top reads 'The Anniston Star' at the left and 'OP-ED' at the right; paper and page are verified from the page itself, but no date is printed on the clipping, so the date is label-only in effect and 'In Washington on July 31' is the only internal dating evidence, consistent with mid-August 2009. 'GLOBAL AFFAIRS' below the folio is a SECTION FLAG, not a deck; the deck is the single line 'U.S. should prepare for region's new extremism'. The nut graf is set in display type centred under the byline and is transcribed here as the first paragraph of the excerpt, which is how the page reads it. Tagline: 'Frida Ghitis writes about global affairs for The Miami Herald.' A wash drawing of a crane swinging a wrecking ball shaped like a peace symbol fills the lower half of the page; it carries no caption. The column's structure places every Palestinian statement inside a frame of 'radicalism', 'extremism' and 'moderation'; no ordinary Palestinian is named or quoted, and the three Palestinians who appear are all Fatah officials quoted to establish their unreliability. Columns were read at page magnification except the nut graf, the opening paragraphs and the Saud al-Faisal quotation, which were transcribed from magnified crops.

CP-2009-046 →

A year at a time: 2000 · 2001 · 2002 · 2003 · 2004 · 2005 · 2006 · 2007 · 2008 · 2009

Last updated 17 November 2026

Part of Covering Palestine, an archive of 3637 newspaper clippings about Palestinians printed in 748 papers between 1724 and 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles. Nothing here was printed after 6 October 2023.

The clippings belong to the newspapers and news agencies that printed them and are reproduced for research, criticism and commentary. Selection, transcription, counts and writing are © Maria Robles, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.

All decades · archive.json · Questions · Contribute a clipping · When was this printed? · How this was built · maria@rozumstudio.com