Los Angeles Times · 27 January 2004

CP-2004-044

Two-State Solution Sells Palestinians Short

By GEORGE BISHARAT

Scan 860 × 980 pixels

Transcribed from the clipping

SAN FRANCISCO — It is a tragic irony that, more than 55 years ago, one desperate people seeking sanctuary from murderous racism decimated another — and continue to oppress its scattered survivors to this day. In 1948, about 700,000 Palestinians were expelled from their homeland, their land and possessions taken by the new Jewish state of Israel.

This included the Jerusalem home of my grandparents, Hanna and Mathilde Bisharat, which was expropriated through a process tantamount to state-sanctioned theft. Today, many assume that to achieve Middle East peace, we Palestinians must surrender our right to return to our homes and homeland.

Millions of Palestinians — with memories and photographs of our stolen properties, keys to our front doors, and an abiding sense of injustice — are expected to swallow our losses in order to facilitate a “two-state solution.” But it's not that simple.

Although Israel has claimed that Palestinians willingly abandoned Palestine after being urged to leave in radio broadcasts by Arab leaders, a review of broadcast transcripts by Irish diplomat Erskine Childers in 1961 revealed that Palestinians were exhorted by Arab leaders to stay, not leave their homes.

In fact, Yigal Allon, commander of Palmach, the elite Zionist troops, and later Israeli foreign minister, launched a whispering campaign to terrorize Palestinians into flight. Nor were we simply unintended victims of a war launched by the Arab states against Israel.

As far back as the late 19th century, leaders of Political Zionism (the movement to create a Jewish state in Palestine) advocated “transfer” of the Palestinians, by force if necessary.

Cite this clipping

More from Los Angeles Times

• Bomb Victim Had Expected DeathLos Angeles Times · 10 July 1972
• Mrs. Meir's Safety StudiedLos Angeles Times · 11 January 1973
• Show of Artists from PalestineLos Angeles Times · 24 June 1977
• Jews of the Arab World?Los Angeles Times · 2 November 1986
• Islamic Group Challenges PLO Over PalestineLos Angeles Times · 5 September 1988
• U.N.: Israel Condemned for Palestinian DeathsLos Angeles Times · 13 October 1990
• 35 more from this paper in the full text →

More from the 2000s

• Against all oddsNews Herald · 10 January 2004
• Palestinian athlete is forced to be resourcefulThe Daily Progress · 10 January 2004
• Swimmer braves weather for dreamThe Times · 10 January 2004
• In 1948, Israel did what it had to do to surviveOakland Tribune · 1 February 2004
• For Israelis a lifesaver; for Palestinians a curseCasper Star-Tribune · 22 February 2004
• A tangible sign of conquestChicago Tribune · 22 February 2004
• All 516 clippings from the 2000s →