Palestine an invention of Arab propaganda

Mona Charen

Transcribed from the clipping

WASHINGTON — Several members of the Nobel Committee have expressed regrets about the Peace Prize that was jointly awarded to Yasser Arafat and Shimon Peres in 1994.

This is certainly understandable — one of the recipients has consistently failed to live up to the promises made in Oslo, lied repeatedly about that failure, imported arms and explosives against the explicit wording of the Oslo agreement, sent teenagers to blow themselves up amid civilians, and actively fomented a wider war.

But the person the Nobel committee regrets honoring is not Mr. Arafat — it is Mr. Peres! Europe is shaming itself. Across the continent, crowds fill the streets demonstrating against Israel. Synagogues are burning all over France. Old anti-Semitic imagery and language is resurfacing.

The Italian newspaper La Stampa ran a cartoon featuring an Israeli tank pointing its muzzle at the crib of baby Jesus with the tag line, “Don’t tell me they want to kill me again.” On April 10, the European Parliament voted to impose trade sanctions on Israel. Some of this is simple Jew hatred. Some is a sinister response to guilt.

Since the Holocaust happened on European soil, how cleansing to believe that the Jews are now the guilty parties, which is why the Nazi analogy crops up with nauseating regularity vis a vis the Israelis, probably more often than it is invoked against anyone else (except perhaps for America in Vietnam).

This is monstrous, and in an ideal world, Secretary of State Colin Powell and President Bush would be saying so. Instead, they, too, are undermining the Israelis, demanding that Israel permit terror to succeed — thus utterly clouding America’s clear stand against terror.

But some of this anti-Israel sentiment represents a victory for Arab propaganda and lies about the origin of the conflict — lies that have been swallowed whole by large segments of the press and public even in the United States. A one-stop shopping book puts these myths to rest. Joan Peters set out to write a sympathetic history of the Palestinian “struggle.”

Her research soon persuaded her that nearly everything she thought she knew about the Arab-Jewish conflict in the Middle East was wrong. Her meticulously researched book, From Time Immemorial, was published in 1984 but is still in print. The Arabs have successfully blurred the true history of what happened when Israel was formed in 1948.

Six hundred thousand Jewish refugees from Arab nations fled to Israel — many in fear for their lives, most after having their property expropriated. They were assimilated by Israel. About the same number of Arab refugees fled what is now Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza.

They were not assimilated by the Arab nations, with whom they shared a common religion, ethnicity, history, and language, but were instead herded into refugee camps, the better to “return” to their homes after Israel was obliterated by Arab armies. Further, these Arab refugees had no ancient tie to the land of “Palestine.”

When Mark Twain visited the Holy Land in 1867, he found to his dismay that the land was barren. “Stirring scenes ... occur in the valley (Jezreel) no more. There is not a solitary village throughout its whole extent — not for 30 miles in either direction. There are two or three small clusters of Bedouin tents, but not a single permanent habitation.

One may ride 10 miles hereabouts and not see 10 human beings.” But when large numbers of Jews began to resettle the land in the 1880s and made it more prosperous, large numbers of Arab migrants began to arrive. The whole idea of a Palestinian nation and a Palestinian people is an invention of Arab propaganda. Mr. Arafat is himself an Egyptian.

The only people to have lived continuously on the land “from time immemorial” are Jews. It is not and never was “Palestinian land.” Mona Charen’s column is distributed by Creators Syndicate.

Context added by this archive

Eighty-three years after Binghamton, the argument has stopped describing Palestinian speech as propaganda and started describing Palestinians as propaganda. The column’s evidence for an empty country is a traveller’s impression of one valley in 1867.

This archive answers that from its own shelves: nine years before the 1919 article, and twenty-six years after Mark Twain, an Ohio paper was printing a report on the orange groves that surrounded the port of Jaffa, 1,780 acres of them, watered by hand from wells a hundred feet deep.

Cite this item

"Palestine an invention of Arab propaganda," The Blade, 17 April 2002. Covering Palestine archive, CP-2002-029. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-2002-029