← Covering Palestine

The 1990s, in full text

Every clipping in this archive printed between 1990 and 1999: 383 of them, oldest first, as plain text that can be read, searched and quoted without running any code. Each entry links to its own record, where the scan is.

· estimated · (newspaper unidentified) · page 1

Israel censoring news of Soviet immigrants

Allyn Fisher, Associated Press, Jerusalem

Israeli leaders fail to agree on U.S. plan. JERUSALEM — Israel’s four top leaders yesterday debated U.S. proposals for opening Middle East peace talks, but they failed to bridge differences blocking a response to the plan… Shamir rejected domestic and international pressure for a quick decision… In remarks bound to further strain relations with the United States, Shamir also said the government would direct Soviet Jewish immigrants to Jerusalem, including Israeli-annexed East Jerusalem.

The United States opposes such a policy. Without mentioning his name, Shamir criticized President Bush for saying there should be no new settlements in East Jerusalem, captured in the 1967 Six-Day War.

“There are no settlements in Jerusalem,” Shamir told foreign Jewish fund-raisers in a statement that an aide said was pointedly added to a prepared speech to counter Bush’s comment.

He reiterated his opposition to any proposal that deviated from Israel’s elections plan and rejected any role in peace talks for the Palestine Liberation Organization and any negotiations on Jerusalem, Israel’s declared eternal and indivisible capital… Baker has been trying to bring together Israelis and Palestinians for preliminary talks in Cairo on Israel’s plan for elections in the occupied West Bank and Gaza strip.

The elections would be a step toward limited autonomy for the territories, which Israel has occupied since 1967… Those proposals were intended to meet PLO demands to include outside Palestinians in the talks but still meet Israel’s demand to talk only to residents of the territories… In the Gaza strip yesterday, two Arab teen-agers were wounded by army gunfire during clashes, Palestinian sources said.

An army spokesman reported that one Palestinian was wounded. A curfew in the Rafah camp and town was lifted after seven days. Rafah schools remained closed by military order to prevent disturbances.

Israel censoring news of Soviet immigrants. Israeli military censors made deletions from this article. JERUSALEM — Israel said yesterday it was censoring news reports about Soviet Jewish immigrants to protect them from Arab attacks and denied trying to muzzle criticism of the immigrants’ settlement in occupied territories.

“It is not our aim to use the censor for political purposes or for any reason other than security,” Avi Pazner, media adviser to Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir, told Israel Radio. “There were a number of threats by terrorist organizations, Palestinian and otherwise, to strike at immigration, to strike at immigrants,” he said.

Israel’s military censors, in a one-line statement issued Friday, ordered local and foreign journalists to submit all stories on Soviet Jewish immigration to censorship before publication. They offered no reasons.

Pazner said Israel would bar three elements from stories — how the Soviet immigrants traveled to Israel, their numbers and the names of people dealing with the matter. “We can’t and don’t want to censor the entire subject of immigration from the Soviet Union. It would be ludicrous,” he said.

Arab states and the United States, Israel’s closest ally, have objected to the prospect of the current wave of Soviet immigrants settling in the occupied West Bank and Gaza strip.

The future of lands that were seized in the 1967 Six-Day War and are home to 1.75 million Palestinians is at the center of U.S. efforts to convene Israeli-Palestinian peace talks… “No one can check the behavior of the Palestinian citizen in the occupied territories,” Mahmoud Abbas, a member of the PLO executive committee, told London’s Asharq al-Awsat newspaper.

“Shamir (left) and Peres in Jerusalem shortly before meeting on peace plan.” Associated Press

The sidebar carries its own warning in italics: Israeli military censors made deletions from this article. On the clipping, two phrases about the occupied West Bank and Gaza are underlined by hand where the censor’s deletions fell.

Correction: {'note': 'arrived captioned Philadelphia Inquirer 1918; names Shamir, Baker and Soviet Jewish immigration, placing it in 1990'}

CP-1990-001 →

· The New York Times · New York

PALESTINIANS MARK ’76 LAND SEIZURES

Fourteen years on, the headline names the seizures as seizures.

CP-1990-024 →

· The New York Times · New York

KILLINGS OF ARABS BY ISRAELIS DROP

A headline in which Israelis are the subject and the verb is killings, which is rare enough in this archive to be worth the record on its own. The news is that there are fewer.

CP-1990-025 →

· The Daily Press · Newport News · page 1

Christians in Israel protest settlement

Jerusalem

JERUSALEM — The leaders of the Christian churches in Israel announced Monday that they would close all their shrines for a day to protest the Israeli government’s support for a new Jewish settlement in the Christian quarter of the Old City.

The announcement was made in an angry statement signed by the 10 heads of the Latin, Greek, Armenian, Coptic, Lutheran, Anglican, Ethiopian and other Christian demoninations with offices or sites in Israel. It comes one day after the government acknowledged that it had secretly donated $1.8 million in public funds so 150 Jewish settlers could lease the St. John’s Hospice.

The Palestinians in this story are Christian, and the objection is theirs. “Demoninations” is the paper’s.

CP-1990-002 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israelis Consider Reopening the Palestinians' Universities

Israelis Consider Reopening The Palestinians’ Universities — By ALAN COWELL

Nine years after the first closure in this sequence. The possessive in the headline — the Palestinians’ universities — concedes whose they are while the sentence is about whether Israel will permit them to open.

CP-1990-027 →

· The New York Times · New York

Report Charges Violence Against Arab Children

Alan Cowell

“Nearly a fifth of the children were shot dead while at home or within 10 meters of their homes. Over 50,000 people under 16 required medical treatment for their beating and other injuries in the first two years of the revolt.”

A report by the American researcher Anne Nixon for Radda Barnen, accusing Israeli soldiers of severe, indiscriminate and recurrent violence against children. The army’s answer, printed here, is that children are turned into martyrs and are engaged as foot-soldiers.

CP-1990-023 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago · page 1

A woman uses a Palestinian flag to taunt Israeli border guards Monday in Jerusalem

“A woman uses a Palestinian flag to taunt Israeli border guards Monday in Jerusalem. Israel sent soldiers to Gaza and the West Bank to quell rioting over the slayings of Palestinians.”

“A woman uses a Palestinian flag to taunt Israeli border guards Monday in Jerusalem. Israel sent soldiers to Gaza and the West Bank to quell rioting over the slayings of Palestinians.” Agence France-Presse photo

A photograph and its caption. The flag was outlawed at the time. Neither woman in the picture is named, and the slayings that caused the rioting are not explained.

CP-1990-003 →

· The Orlando Sentinel · Orlando · page 1

3 more Palestinians killed

10 tourists wounded in Jordan in anger against Israelis

3 more. The word doing the work is more, which is a paper telling its readers this is a series and they have seen it before. Three Palestinians are killed by nobody; ten tourists are wounded in the line underneath, and that line names an emotion as the cause.

CP-1990-004 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Arabs, Feeling Adrift, Talk of Rising Identity Crisis

“After a brief and violent outpouring of rage Monday at the killing of seven Palestinians in a town about 150 miles to the south, the hills and Arab villages of Galilee that form an Arab pocket in Israel seem…”

Alan Cowell from Nazareth, after the Rishon LeZion killings. The headline calls it an identity crisis, which locates the problem inside the people rather than in the arrangement they live under. The crisis described in the copy is budgets, land and planning permission.

CP-1990-026 →

· estimated · Modesto Bee

Bomb explodes in Jerusalem market

By ALFONSO CHARDY, Knight-Ridder Newspapers

JERUSALEM — A bomb exploded at lunch time Monday in the principal Jewish market in downtown Jerusalem killing one person and wounding at least nine others. Within minutes of the blast at the market in the Mahane Yehuda neighborhood, Israeli shoppers spontaneously attacked journalists covering the event and Arab workers at the scene.

One journalist, a photographer, was hospitalized, Israeli Radio said. Many Israelis dislike the press, blaming it for Israel’s battered international image. Coming eight days after an Israeli gunman killed seven Palestinians in the Tel Aviv suburb of Rishon Lezion, many Israelis automatically perceived the Mahane Yehuda blast as Arab revenge for Rishon Lezion.

But senior police officials said they had no idea who planted the bomb or for what purpose. Reuters news agency said a caller in the Syrian capital of Damascus claimed responsibility for the blast on behalf of a group called Fatah Uprising. The caller said a group operative planted a bomb on a bus and timed it to go off as the vehicle passed the market.

However, Israeli police said the bomb was concealed in a plastic bag placed inside a trash bin between a food stall and a restaurant. In Arab East Jerusalem, Palestinian political leader Faisal Husseini condemned the bomb attack. “I absolutely reject attacks against civilians,” Husseini said.

The place where the bomb exploded is an old-style market of colorful stalls selling fruit and vegetables in the heart of downtown Jewish Jerusalem. Located off Jaffa Road, the principal business thoroughfare in downtown Jerusalem, the market is the main attraction in Mahane Yehuda, a neighborhood chiefly populated by Jewish immigrants from Arab countries.

Politically conservative, Mahane Yehuda is fervently anti-Palestinian and consistently supportive of Israel’s most hard-line political figures.

Date check: No masthead and no page date line on the clipping — it is cut to the one-line headline, the byline block and four text columns, with no folio and no paper name. “Modesto Bee” appears nowhere on the scan; the only credit is “Knight-Ridder Newspapers”, the syndicate, not the paper. The story is datelined JERUSALEM with no date and reports a bomb “at lunch time Monday” coming “eight days after” the Rishon Lezion killings, which is consistent with a Tuesday paper of 29 May 1990, but the page itself does not say so.

CP-1990-028 →

· Tucson Citizen · Tucson · page 1

Cut PLO contact, Israel urges U.S.

Calls attack proof Arafat broke his word

The Associated Press, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM — Israel today urged the United States to end all contacts with the PLO after seaborne Palestinian guerrillas loyal to a top PLO official tried to attack crowded beaches and hotels on a Jewish holiday. Four guerrillas were killed and 12 captured by Israeli forces in yesterday’s Libyan-sponsored infiltration.

No Israelis were harmed in the attack, even though tens of thousands were on beaches for Shavuot, the Jewish holiday that marks the giving of the Ten Commandments. The Palestine Liberation Front, headed by Mohammed Abbas, claimed responsibility. Abbas, known as Abul Abbas, is a member of the PLO Executive Committee and loyal to PLO chief Yasser Arafat.

He planned the 1985 hijacking of the Italian cruise ship Achille Lauro. Israel radio said today the government had sent Washington details of the interrogations of the 12 captured PLO guerrillas. Israeli leaders called yesterday’s attack proof that Arafat had violated his December 1988 pledge to renounce terror.

It was Arafat’s pledge that led the United States to open a dialogue with the PLO. Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman Motti Amihai claimed today that Abbas and Arafat met in Tunis, Tunisia, five days before the attack. “We believe that Abul Abbas at that time knew for sure that this operation was going to take place,” Amihai said.

“I think there is little doubt that Arafat personally, and also probably (Libyan leader Moammar) Ghadafi, knew beforehand about this operation.” The PLO is an umbrella group for several factions. The smaller groups sometimes fight among themselves or launch independent attacks on Israel.

Foreign Minister Moshe Arens said Israel would try to persuade the United States to abandon contacts with the PLO. “If we can convince them there that the basic assumption for dialogue no longer exists, then it’s possible that the United States will decide to cease the dialogue,” he said on Israel radio.

“The only question is whether they (the Americans) will see reality as it is,” said Deputy Foreign Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. In Washington, U.S. State Department spokeswoman Margaret Tutwiler said it was too early to say whether the attack would affect the 17-month dialogue, but added that “we would view this as a very serious matter.”

She said the United States was “horrified at this terrorist attack” and was “pleased that all terrorists were apprehended or killed in action.”

A map marks “Second boat captured” off the coast and “Boat attack on Israelis” near Nizzanim, with the Gaza Strip, West Bank and Dead Sea labeled. Associated Press

The attack that ended the American dialogue with the PLO, reported the day after. The paper notes in its own voice that no Israelis were harmed.

CP-1990-005 →

· Fort Worth Star-Telegram · Fort Worth · page 1

Six-panel editorial cartoon: 'REVENGE FOR A PALESTINIAN KILLED' / 'REVENGE FOR THE REVENGE OF A PALESTINIAN KILLED' / ... each panel adding to a growing mound of bodies until the caption itself runs off the frame

Gary Markstein

A six-panel editorial cartoon. Panel one is captioned REVENGE FOR A PALESTINIAN KILLED. Each following panel adds another REVENGE FOR THE to the front of the same sentence, until the words no longer fit the frame. Beneath each caption the pile of bodies grows.

A 1990 cartoon that states this project’s thesis directly. The page itself is dated: Saturday, June 2, 1990, Fort Worth Star-Telegram, Section 1, Page 27.

CP-1990-006 →

· USA Today · McLean · page 1

‘Our enemies want our annihilation, not peace’

Inquiry: The Middle East. Printed beside it, ‘Israel must be pressured to move toward peace’

Netanyahu interviewed by Mary-Ann Bendel; Talhami interviewed by Wendy Buchert

“Benjamin Netanyahu, 40, is Israel’s deputy foreign minister and a member of the Knesset, its parliament… NETANYAHU: In the Middle East, the only kind of peace that can survive is a peace that can be defended.

So we will continue to seek a peace that will enable Israel to change the status quo with its Arab neighbors and the Palestinian Arabs living among us while being able to defend ourselves… USA TODAY: You have often stated that Arafat is locked in a ‘circle of blood.’ Why do you say that?

NETANYAHU: Arafat, himself, preaches peace in the West and practices terror in the East. If he were to genuinely disengage from terrorism and the larger goal of eradicating Israel, he probably would be a dead man. So whether by inclination or whether by intimidation, all the PLO leadership is locked into perpetual war with Israel.

If it’s going to be up to the PLO, there will never be peace. We’ve advocated all along that we should put the PLO aside and move on to more constructive paths where we can find genuine partners for political progress…

‘Israel must be pressured to move toward peace.’ Yitzhak Shamir’s newly organized government is seen as a setback to the peace process by

Ghada Talhami, vice chair of Palestine Human Rights Campaign, a national organization in Chicago. ‘This cabinet has been a great disappointment,’ she said.

‘The press has described it as the most right-wing government in the history of Israel, which includes all the religious and far-right political parties, most of which apparently want more Israeli settlements in the West Bank. And some are even advocates of a policy of eviction of Palestinians to Jordan.’

Talhami, also associate professor of politics and a specialist in Mideast politics at Lake Forest College, added: ‘That is not going to be a cabinet that’s really interested in peace.’… What the USA should be doing: ‘Putting Secretary of State James Baker’s peace plan on the table,’ she said.

‘Baker proposed this a long time ago. The Israelis haven’t moved on it. Nothing will happen at all if the USA refuses to pressure Israel in order to make it accept this kind of a peace plan.’ What would Talhami say to Benjamin Netanyahu? ‘Israel is throwing away the peace and security of future generations of Israelis.

It is condemning Israel to more years of strife with the Arab states, with the Palestinians.’”

One page, two interviews, two headlines that answer each other. The Palestinian is an academic in Chicago and the paper gives her a column of her own.

CP-1990-007 →

· Houston Chronicle · Houston · page 1

Report says Israelis interrogate Palestinian minors violently

Sergei Shargorodsky, Associated Press, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM — Israeli police and the Shin Bet security service routinely use violence while interrogating Palestinian minors, an Israeli human rights group said in a report released Monday.

The Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories, known as Betselem, also cited other abuses, such as overcrowded cells, a lack of proper medical attention and delays in investigating complaints of police brutality. Police said in response that they were investigating every complaint of brutality.

A spokeswoman acknowledged that prison conditions need to be improved. “Police treat complaints of brutality by officers with special seriousness. An investigation has been launched into every complaint submitted to police,” said Elinoar Mazoz, who deals with public complaints. Her statement was attached to the Betselem report.

National police spokesman Adi Gonen said Monday he had nothing to add. The report focused on the treatment of Palestinians ages 12 to 18 from Israeli-annexed Arab east Jerusalem and nearby villages, who were held at police headquarters in downtown Jerusalem.

All were detained during the 30-month Palestinian uprising on suspicion of stone-throwing, torching cars and anti-Israeli violence. Betselem said its report was not based on a representative survey, but that the findings indicated a “widespread phenomenon that should be viewed seriously.” The report includes affidavits from nine minors.

They were not identified by name, in keeping with Israeli law. A 12-year-old said he was placed inside a bag by interrogators. “They put the lights out, and I felt it being closed above my head. Then they began to beat me with a stick,” he said.

A 16-year-old said an interrogator “beat me with the end of a plastic ruler on the arms, the back and all parts of the body. Then he grabbed a metal bar and hit me on the head. I was handcuffed all the time.” Another 16-year-old said he was pushed against a hot-water tank and suffered burns when water spilled on his right leg.

The report also described the interrogation methods of the Shin Bet, which deals with those over 16. Betselem said the Shin Bet used a square punishment cell measuring about 4½ feet a side. It described it as a “dark, smelly and suffocating room where prisoners are often kept for days.”

Shin Bet interrogators also handcuff prisoners in distorted poses or place them in the so-called “grave,” a small underground cell in which prisoners can only crouch, it said.

The children are quoted and unnamed, and the paper says why: Israeli law. The police response is printed with them. The findings are an Israeli organization’s.

CP-1990-008 →

· Springfield News Sun

Suspending PLO contacts correct course of action

Various analysts are saying that President Bush’s decision to suspend contacts with the Palestine Liberation Organization because it did not condemn an attempted terrorist attack by some of its members may lead to a resumption of widespread terrorism.

Ironically, in attempting to express reservations about the president’s decision, they may have offered the best justification possible for it. Implicit in their statements is the notion that we must tolerate a little terrorism in order to win “moderation” by the PLO, or we’ll have to endure a lot of it.

And implicit in that notion is the simple and unfortunate truth that the Palestine Liberation Organization is, at heart, a terrorist organization. Maybe Yasser Arafat, the PLO’s ostensible leader, truly wanted to try a different course when he agreed 18 months ago to (more or less) recognize Israel’s right to exist and (more or less) renounce violence.

But the fact is it doesn’t really matter very much what Yasser Arafat wanted. As the intercepted assault on an Israeli beach by a PLO sub-group demonstrates, Mr. Arafat does not control what the organization does. On the contrary, his refusal to condemn the attack demonstrates that the organization — especially its most bloodthirsty elements — controls him.

He dares not speak out against their murderous ways because he knows he would probably lose his position as chairman, titular though it may be.

The U.S. government’s agreement was to talk to the PLO in exchange for that organization’s adoption of civilized methods of political discourse — not to accept it as a legitimate political element merely because its figurehead chairman cleaned up his own act a bit.

The PLO as a group did not do that, and Arafat is powerless to do anything about it, so Bush was correct to suspend the relationship. Actually, the fact that the president only suspended, rather than ended, the talks provides a perfect opportunity for the PLO to show the world its true colors.

It can prove that it is the upstanding, trustworthy party that it claims to be merely by taking strong action against its members who violated Mr. Arafat’s pledge. Or it can prove that it is a savage band of murderers and cowards by reverting to its old terrorist ways.

CP-1990-019 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Israeli Arab Poet Is Set Free, But Court Silences His Song

JERUSALEM, July 2 — An Israeli Arab poet charged with inciting violence through nationalistic verse was released from house arrest Sunday night pending trial The poet, 49-year-old Shafik Habib, was arrested in early June for publishing poetry the Israelis said was politically dangerous.

He was put under house arrest in his Galilee village of Deir Hanna for 12 days before being released on appeal. A court in the northern city of Akko ordered Mr. Habib not to write any poetry until his trial, which begins on July 25. Copies of his eight books of verse were confiscated by the police. Mr.

Habib said today that police investigators had mistranslated his poems from Arabic. “There is no incitement in the poems,” he said. “The authorities just didn’t understand them.” He accused the police and the state prosecutor of laying legal groundwork for curtailing freedom of expression.

The poems, written in 1988, were previously published in Arabic newspapers and had been approved by Israel’s military censor.

CP-1990-033 →

· Hickory Daily Record · page 9D

Israeli Naval Patrols See Trouble Brewing

By NICOLAS B. TATRO, Associated Press Writer

Editor's Note: This story was submitted to the Israeli military censor who ordered a deletion. OFF THE LEBANON COAST — Pointing to a map of Lebanon’s coast, the captain of the Israeli patrol boat Dvora says the possibility of a Palestinian guerrilla attack has seldom been greater.

“In the eight years I have been on these boats, I don’t remember a time when there was such certainty in the air that something was going to happen,” said Capt. Chen.

He spoke as the 69-foot craft sliced through the waters a few hundred yards off the south Lebanon coast, sweeping the coastline with radar and occasionally stabbing through the darkness with a powerful searchlight.

The tension felt by Chen and his eight-member crew is reflected throughout Israel at a time when efforts to arrange Palestinian-Israeli negotiations are at a standstill.

Palestinian guerrillas, including hard-liners who oppose PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat’s diplomatic initiative, have mounted two recent seaborne raids, using speedboats for the first time and finding a chink in Israel’s armor.

On the Jewish holiday of Shavuot on May 30, boats with heavily armed Palestinians from Abul Abbas’ Palestine Liberation Front were launched from a mother ship that had set sail from Libya. One outran Israeli defenders and reached the shore near a crowded beach resort before four Arabs were killed and seven captured.

The attack prompted the United States to suspend its political dialogue with the PLO. On June 23, Chen’s Dvora — Bee in Hebrew — ran down a speedboat heading toward the Israeli border settlement of Rosh Haniqra and killed two guerrillas armed with rocket-propelled grenades and automatic rifles.

Responsibility was claimed by a fundamentalist faction of Lebanese Sunni Moslems, traditional allies of the PLO. Ariel Merari, a terror expert at Tel Aviv University, says a successful raid could set off a chain reaction that could end in a new Middle East war.

He notes that terror raids were a contributing factor to the 1956, 1967 and 1982 wars between Israel and its Arab neighbors. “A single dramatic terror attack or series of smaller ones change the atmosphere and trigger a war,” he said.

… Chen, whose full name could not be used in keeping with military regulations, was surrounded by a bank of squawking radios linking him to other Israeli patrol craft as well as radar and other shore installations.

Gunner Prepares Weapon Aboard Dvora [credit: AP Laserphoto]

CP-1990-034 →

· LA Weekly · page 17

Westside Mideast Conflict

Mel Levine opponent David Barrett Cohen favors a Palestinian state. Otherwise, he's a mainstream Republican.

BY TOM WALDMAN

DAVID BARRETT COHEN'S CAMPAIGN this fall against U.S. Rep. Mel Levine (D-Santa Monica) is probably a first in American politics. Never before has a Jewish candidate (much less a Jewish mainstream Republican) campaigned on a platform calling for a self-governing Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza.

Cohen believes that the hard line espoused by the government of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir has created a public for his Mideast positions, and hopes that his campaign will encourage other critics of U.S. policy within and without the Jewish community.

Not surprisingly, Cohen has already been endorsed by the increasingly active Arab American Republican Club of Orange County.

The more interesting question is whether Cohen, who on most questions is a standard Reagan Republican, can win any serious support from fellow Jewish Republicans, or from the growing peace constituency within the Los Angeles Jewish community — a constituency that by virtue of its liberalism seems likely to support his opponent.

Levine is a mainstream Democratic liberal, favoring a greater role for the public sector in the American economy. First elected to the House in 1982, Levine is one of the major figures in the Westside's powerful Waxman-Berman political organization, and is considered a prime candidate for the U.S. Senate in 1992.

He is known by supporters and detractors alike as one of Israel's safest votes in the House, and speaks frequently on Mideast affairs. A member of the House subcommittee on the Mideast, Levine confers regularly with Yitzhak Shamir and others in the Knesset, and has traveled to Iraq, Jordan and Saudi Arabia.

Republican David Cohen: Negotiate with the Palestinians / Democrat Mel Levine: Negotiate with the other Arab states

CP-1990-035 →

· The New York Times

Palestinians Struggling To Rebuild Their Lives

By CHRIS HEDGES

Two years ago, Issam F. Muala was studying civil engineering at a university in his hometown of Ramallah, on the Israeli-occupied West Bank. Today, he is working in a small grocery store in Brooklyn. Suffering from a self-imposed economic boycott in the occupied territories and the recent loss of thousands of jobs in the Persian Gulf states, many young Palestinian men like Mr.

Muala are immigrating to America. By the thousands, they are arriving in places like the Bay Ridge section of Brooklyn, looking for jobs and a little breathing room after three years of struggle in the Palestinian uprising, or intifada.

Thousands of miles from the Palestinian diaspora of the Arab world, they are finding themselves equally estranged in a new Palestinian diaspora. Back home, despite broad support for their struggle against the Israelis, the Palestinians are stateless, widely scattered and often resented.

To many Arabs in America — Yemenites, Egyptians and others — the young Palestinians are traitors for abandoning the fight. Nor do the Arabs look kindly on the allegiance many Palestinians have lent President Saddam Hussein and the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait.

Tortured by Guilt Palestinians, who with many Lebanese are among the best educated and most liberal people in the Arab world, frequently resent going to work as grocery stockers. They chafe under a lack of affordable educational opportunities and the loss of their social and political prestige. And many say they feel tortured by guilt for having left.

Laila Jammal, a Palestinian community organizer in Brooklyn, estimated that in the Bay Ridge section alone the Palestinian population has grown to 40,000, from 25,000, in the last three years.

CP-1990-031 →

· estimated · Associated Press

A Palestinian cradles the body of a boy slain by Israeli police during rioting Monday at Temple Mount

“A Palestinian cradles the body of a boy slain by Israeli police during rioting Monday at Temple Mount.” The Associated Press.

A man carrying a dead child through a crowd. The caption says who killed him, which the headlines that week mostly did not, and calls the thing he was killed during rioting. Neither the man nor the boy is named. The place is given its Jewish name and not its Muslim one, in a caption about a Muslim child killed at a mosque.

Correction: {'note': 'uncaptioned; Oct 1990 al-Aqsa'}

CP-1990-009 →

· estimated · Bennington Banner · Bennington · page 1

The 80-year-old Mufti of Jerusalem, Saad Al-Din Al-Alami, is carried to a hospital by aides after he was overcome by tear gas fired by riot police

“The 80-year-old Mufti of Jerusalem, Saad Al-Din Al-Alami, is carried to a hospital by aides yesterday after he was overcome by tear gas fired by riot police. The Mufti led about 200 Moslems to the Temple Mount the day after 19 Palestinians were killed.”

Correction: {'note': 'The clipping carries the caption but no date. The caption places it the day after 19 Palestinians were killed at the Temple Mount, which dates it to October 1990.'}

CP-1990-010 →

· Kentucky New Era · Hopkinsville

GRIEVING MOTHER, Mrs. Kefiya Jihad Hamide, 32, weeps with family members at their Jerusalem home over the death of her son, among 19 Palestinians shot to death by Israeli troops

“GRIEVING MOTHER, Mrs. Kefiya Jihad Hamide, 32, (center) weeps with family members at their Jerusalem home today over the death of her son, among 19 Palestinians shot to death by Israeli troops.” Associated Press.

Three women on a bed, and the caption gives one of them a name, an age and a place. That is rare in this archive and it is the reason this record is here. Her son is among the nineteen; he is not named. The verb is shot to death and the people who did it are in the sentence. On the same day the Kentucky New Era’s own headline said the police gassed a crowd (CP-1990-012).

CP-1990-011 →

· Kentucky New Era · Hopkinsville

Israeli police gas Moslem crowd at Temple Mount

Nineteen people were shot dead on 8 October 1990. The headline the next morning is about tear gas. The verb is gas, the object is a Moslem crowd, and nobody dies in the sentence. The same edition carried a photograph of a mother weeping over her son, captioned with the nineteen and with who shot them (CP-1990-011). The facts were in the paper. They were under the picture.

CP-1990-012 →

· The Atlanta Journal · Atlanta

Israeli police close holy site, fire tear gas at Muslims

Tuesday 9 October 1990, across the top of an Atlanta page. Two things happen in it: a site is closed and tear gas is fired. Nineteen people had been shot dead the previous morning, and no part of that is in the line. The people fired at are Muslims, which is how most of these headlines named them that week — a religion rather than a nationality.

CP-1990-013 →

· The Buffalo News · Buffalo

Angry Palestinians demonstrate in Amman, Jordan to protest the killing of 19 Palestinians by Israeli police during unrest Monday in Jerusalem

“Angry Palestinians demonstrate in Amman, Jordan, today to protest the killing of 19 Palestinians by Israeli police during unrest Monday in Jerusalem.” Associated Press.

The fullest sentence of the week, and it is a caption: nineteen Palestinians, killed, by Israeli police, in Jerusalem. Everything the headlines left out is in it. The adjective the caption gives the people in the photograph is angry, and the banner over their heads is in Arabic and is not translated.

CP-1990-014 →

· Newsday · Melville

Handprints of blood from wounded Palestinians mark Temple Mount wall

“Handprints of blood from wounded Palestinians mark Temple Mount wall.” UPI / Reuter.

Four handprints on a wall. The caption is eleven words and it gets the grammar right where most of that week’s headlines did not: the blood belongs to wounded Palestinians, and it is on a wall at the place. What it still does not say is who wounded them. Three days after the shootings.

CP-1990-015 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles

U.N.: Israel Condemned for Palestinian Deaths

Five days after, and this is the first headline in the October cluster with Israel and the Palestinian dead in the same line. What makes it printable is the first word: the United Nations is the one saying it, so the paper is reporting a condemnation rather than making one. The deaths are still deaths rather than killings, and nobody in the sentence causes them.

CP-1990-016 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles

Israel Bars Palestinians From Temple Mount Prayer Services

Printed the same day as the condemnation (CP-1990-016), in the same paper. Israel is the subject, the verb is bars, the object is Palestinians, and what they are barred from is prayer. Five days after nineteen of them were shot dead at that place, the story is that they may not go back to it.

CP-1990-017 →

· The New York Times

Outside Arabs Barred From Jerusalem

By SABRA CHARTRAND, Special to The New York Times

JERUSALEM, Oct. 22 — Israeli policemen surrounded Jerusalem with roadblocks today to keep Palestinians from the West Bank and Gaza Strip out of the city and away from Israelis who might seek revenge for the slaying of three Jews on Sunday. It was believed to be the first time the whole city of Jerusalem was closed to Palestinians living outside it.

Thousands of paramilitary border policemen in green berets were sent out to deter violence and appeared in groups at every major intersection and along boundaries between mainly Jewish West Jerusalem and Arab East Jerusalem. They startled residents in quiet Jewish neighborhoods where military patrols have not been seen for years.

It was in such a neighborhood that an army woman and two Israeli men were stabbed to death in minutes early Sunday morning. The police arrested a man they said was the assailant, identified as Omar Abu Sirhan, a 19-year-old Muslim fundamentalist from the West Bank who worked as a plasterer. Today, the authorities said Mr.

Abu Sirhan, who has no criminal record, told them he planned the attack on his own last week. They said he was evidently trying to avenge the deaths of 21 Arabs at Al Aksa Mosque two weeks ago and a beating he said he received from Jews. The police said they did not believe he was affiliated with any Palestinian guerrilla group.

Last week the United Nations adopted a resolution condemning Israel for the deaths at Al Aksa, where police opened fire on Palestinians throwing stones at Jewish worshipers.

Linking the international criticism of Israel with the killings Sunday in Jerusalem, Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir said today: “There have been attacks on Jews in Jerusalem more than once, and there have been political attacks on Israel more than once, too. We stood up to them and prevailed, and this time we’ll stand up to them and overcome them as well.”

Deputy Foreign Minister Benyamin Netanyahu called other nations “double-faced and cynical” for not condemning the three Jews’ deaths in the same way.

Israeli soldiers checking the papers of Arab passengers near Bethlehem yesterday. The car was prevented from going to Jerusalem amid fears that Israelis might seek revenge for the Sunday slaying of three Jews.

CP-1990-032 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Assassin or Muslim Avenger, He’s a Hero in the West Bank

By SABRA CHARTRAND

ABADIYA, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, Oct. 23 — Villagers in this dusty little town on a jagged hilltop described their most famous son today as friendless and reclusive, a man they never expected would one day become a hero to his neighbors and a potent symbol of Arab evil to Israelis.

The man, Amer Abu Sirhan, a 19-year-old plasterer, is in a Jerusalem jail, accused of stabbing three Jews to death early Sunday morning.

The killings set off a round of attacks and counterattacks involving Jews and Arabs that quickly spread, until tonight, alarmed military officials decided to ban West Bank and Gaza Arabs from entering Israel, trying to separate warring civilians from both sides.

This recent cycle of violence originated with the shooting deaths of 21 Palestinians at Al Aksa Mosque two weeks ago. However, some Palestinians believe that Mr. Abu Sirhan can also be credited with helping to revive the Palestinian uprising and reminding Israelis of the cost of occupation.

A Quiet, Remote Place But all the uproar is mostly lost on the villagers in Abadiya, where there is no running water, no telephones or paved roads. Quiet has prevailed here, largely because the army has enforced an order preventing residents from leaving the town. The Abu Sirhans are sleeping in tents because the army sealed the house where 21 family members lived.

This was part of Israel’s punishment for Mr. Abu Sirhan’s actions, even though he and his wife lived by themselves in a detached apartment. “Everyone looks at the killings from their own point of view,” said Fayez Abu Sirhan, one of 10 children and Amer’s brother.

Pointing to clothes, furniture and appliances strewn around the dirt yard by soldiers, he said: “The results from our point of view are not very good. But people here are proud because they see in Amer a kind of courage, enthusiasm and daring that has not been seen since the beginning of the uprising.”

The village, home to a few thousand people, is at the end of a long, narrow road winding to the edge of a deep valley near Bethlehem. Steep cliffs fall away on all sides of the town. and brown, barren desert surrounds it. The village is so isolated that the army rarely comes here.

The few reminders that Abadiya exists in the 20th century come from a modern mosque loudspeaker and the dozens of Iraqi and Palestine Liberation Organization flags hanging from houses and posts. The mosque is only a few yards from the Abu Sirhan house, and his family describes him as a devout Muslim.

His brother said, “He has prayed every day since he was 7, but then everyone in this village is like that.” The family describes Mr. Abu Sirhan — his mother says his first name is Amer, not Omar as the Israelis rendered it when he was arrested — as an eighth-grade dropout who learned plastering from his father.

He was quiet, they say, had no friends and never talked to anyone about his thoughts, plans or ambitions. He just went to prayers, worked and watched TV. His routine seems to have been altered only once — last year. His brother said Mr. Abu Sirhan was detained by border policemen, accused of harassing a Jewish woman, taken to a forest and severely beaten.

“Apparently this thing stayed in his mind, and he sought revenge for it,” Fayez Abu Sirhan said. “I never saw him angry, but you know sometimes people hold things in and then explode all at once.” The family and the Israeli authorities seem to agree that Mr.

Abu Sirhan did not belong to any Arab guerrilla group and did not plan the killings Sunday much in advance.

“There was nothing different about him the night before,” said his wife, Muna, although she said she and her husband rarely talked and that they did not know each other well until about a year and a half ago when their engagement was arranged, a common custom in Abadiya. And his brother remembered “going to prayers as usual, and then Amer went to bed early.

It was very normal.” A group of young village men said, like most everyone here, that they did not know Amer Abu Sirhan well. They were nevertheless eager to portray him as a Palestinian freedom fighter. Another victim of the latest violence will probably be Mr. Abu Sirhan’s wife. If her husband is convicted and sentenced to prison, she will live with his family.

And for now, at least, they have no home. A shy and uneducated 18-year-old, Mrs. Abu Sirhan has no children. In a traditional village like Abadiya, she has no hope of making an independent life for herself. “I can’t sleep, I can’t eat,” she said today. “I didn’t expect this to happen — my husband was a very ordinary person.

But this is my fate.”

Date check: No masthead and no page date line — the clipping is cut to the two-line headline, the byline block and two full text columns, closing on a rule. The byline block reads “Special to The New York Times”, which confirms `pub`. The dateline reads “ABADIYA, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, Oct. 23”, one day before the labelled date, and the body dates itself twice over: the stabbings were “early Sunday morning” and the “shooting deaths of 21 Palestinians at Al Aksa Mosque two weeks ago” places this a fortnight after 8 October 1990. Both are consistent with `date` (1990-10-24).

CP-1990-030 →

· South Florida Sun Sentinel · Fort Lauderdale · page 1

Israeli inquiry pins blame on police, Arabs for deaths

“An elderly Palestinian hobbles past Israeli troops on his way to Friday prayers in Jerusalem.” AP photo.

The headline and the photograph are what this clipping carries; the story beneath them is not part of it.

CP-1990-018 →

· The Journal News · White Plains

Journalist wounded by gunfire in Gaza Strip

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip (AP) — A correspondent for Cable News Network was shot in the back Tuesday while covering clashes between Israelis and Palestinians in the Gaza Strip. Ben Wedeman, 41, the CNN bureau chief in Cairo, was in stable condition after a bullet entered his back and came out his side, officials at the Shifa hospital in Gaza said.

Wedeman was covering the fighting at the Karni crossing between Israel and the Gaza Strip when he was hit. According to the army, Wedemen was caught in the crossfire when Palestinians fired machine guns and anti-tank missiles at Israeli soldiers who returned fire.

“We were caught in a gun battle and its hard to say what exactly the sources of fire were,” Wedeman told reporters. There was “a large explosion near me so I decided it was time to leave, and it was in the process of getting off the ground to begin running away from the area that I got hit,” he said.

Intense fighting at the crossing left one Palestinian dead and another critically injured, hospital officials said in Gaza. Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat visited Wedeman at the hospital in Gaza. CNN reported that Wedeman was filming an Israeli bunker before he was shot.

The Israeli army spokesman said Wedeman was hit while on the Palestinian side or somewhere in between the two sides. The army statement said Israeli soldiers do not target reporters. Wedeman was conscious and talking, and his injuries were not life-threatening, Claudia Coles, a CNN spokeswoman in London, said.

Israeli army medics were awaiting Wedeman at a crossing into Israel for his transfer to an Israeli hospital after an initial check at the Gaza hospital, the army spokesman said. Wedeman joined CNN in 1994, Coles said. The Committee to Protect Journalists based in New York published a report that six journalists have been wounded by gunfire or beaten since the unrest began.

Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat speaks to Ben Wedeman, 41, CNN bureau chief in Cairo, Tuesday at the Shefa hospital in Gaza City. Wedeman was shot in the back and suffered moderate injuries while covering clashes between Israelis and Palestinians in the Gaza Strip.

CP-1990-022 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore

Palestinian doctor, kin shot on West Bank

Zionist group takes blame for attack

JERUSALEM — An Arab doctor was shot and seriously wounded on Thursday night as he was traveling in a car with his sister and her baby 10 miles south of here in the occupied West Bank, the police and the army said yesterday.

An unknown group called the Zionist Avengers called the Israeli army radio and the state television offices and claimed responsibility for the attack, the Israeli radio reported. The attack occurred a day after the early release of three of the last imprisoned members of a 25-member Jewish underground that attacked and killed Arab civilians and dignitaries in the early 1980s.

Yesterday, both the Israeli left and right condemned the shooting, and Defense Minister Moshe Arens pledged to catch the assailant and try him. Dr. Feisel Amar, 40, who was shot in the chest and legs, was listed in serious condition at Hadassah hospital, hospital officials said. Around 11:15 p.m., Dr.

Amar was returning home to Hebron along with his sister, Ibtisam, and her 1-year-old daughter, Aya. He had just taken his wife to a Bethlehem hospital, where she gave birth to a baby girl, Palestinians said. Near a junction by the Jewish settlement of Efrat, a man in an Israeli army uniform and wearing a small yarmulke opened fire at them, Palestinians said.

Aya, the daughter, was slightly wounded from a gunshot to the leg, while her mother had a small wound in her hand, hospital officials said. The police and the army immediately began widespread searches.

While condemning the attack, Elyakim Haetzni, a member of parliament from the right-wing Tehiya Party, said it was a result of the army’s inability to suppress the three-year Arab uprising in the occupied territories. The three Jewish underground members released on Wednesday served 7 years of their sentences of 20 years to life imprisonment.

A Palestinian doctor, Feisel Amar, is taken from ambulance in Jerusalem after he and two family members were attacked by vigilantes.

CP-1990-021 →

· The Kansas City Star · Kansas City

2 killed in West Bank protests

But most Palestinians obey Israeli curfew.

The New York Times JERUSALEM — Two Palestinians were killed in demonstrations Tuesday, but more than a million others in the Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip and West Bank stayed home, abiding by a curfew declared by Israeli authorities.

The curfew was invoked to prevent demonstrations on the 26th anniversary of the first military operation by Al Fatah, the main guerrilla group of the Palestine Liberation Organization. The curfew failed to stop all demonstrations. The two Palestinians were shot in the West Bank village of Rajib, near Nablus, and Qabatiya, also in the West Bank.

Demonstrations also were reported in the West Bank village of Burka, and in Khuzaa in the Gaza Strip. But the curfew, backed up by a large deployment of Israeli army troops, succeeded in preventing large-scale demonstrations called for in Fatah leaflets that urged Palestinians in the occupied territories to “scorch the land under the feet of the occupiers.”

The curfew and the fear and suspicion engendered by the three-year Palestinian uprising in the occupied territories cast a pall on New Year’s festivities in Jerusalem. Most residents of the city went home before nightfall and stayed there, fearful of the recent wave of attacks by Arabs or Jews on one another.

Most hotels were empty, and the new year arrived in a darkened, quiet, and seemingly deserted city, with only the piercing lights of police patrol cars speeding by in deserted streets giving any sign of life. On Tuesday, Israeli police announced that they had arrested a 19-year-old Israeli soldier, Sgt.

Arieh Chelouche, and charged him in the shooting of a Palestinian doctor, his sister, and her one-year-old daughter on Thursday. All three were wounded but survived. The police said Chelouche had acted in a random retaliation for the killing of his brother, an anti-terror police officer who was knifed to death about two months ago.

After the attack on the Palestinian doctor, a caller took responsiblity for the shooting in the name of a heretofore unknown orgnization called the Zionist Avengers. One of those wounded in the shooting said the assailant had an accomplice who drove a getaway car. But on Tuesday the police said Chelouche had asserted that he had acted alone.

Three Palestinians protest the arrest of a relative by Israeli riot police after a disturbance Tuesday in the Palestinian refugee camp Shu’Fat. Most Palestinians, however, heeded an Israeli curfew.

CP-1991-019 →

· Times Record News · Wichita Falls

Two top men in PLO assassinated

Two top men in the Palestine Liberation Organization have been assassinated. A third man who was supposed to be guarding the men also was killed. The two men were aides — assistants — to Yasser Arafat, the leader of the Palestinian Liberation Organization, called the PLO. The two aides were named Salah Khalaf, who was also known as Abu Iyad, and Hayel Abdel-Hamid.

They were killed by a man who had been part of a different faction of the PLO. But some people at first said that Israel was behind the assassinations, but now the PLO is blaming an Arab bodyguard ounce linked to Abu Nidal. Salah Khalaf helped Yasser Arafat found — start — a group called Fatah in 1960. Fatah was the first group in the PLO.

Palestinians are the Arab people from lands which are now part of Israel. The PLO was founded to get back the lands from Israel. Salah Khalaf was thought to be a moderate member of the PLO. A moderate (Say it, MOD-er-it) is someone who is not too much on one side or another of an issue.

He was thought to be in favor of a land for Palestinians while still letting Israel exist — live. Some members of the PLO want to destroy — ruin — Israel. The leader of this part of the PLO is Abu Nidal. Abu Nidal wanted to kill Khalaf and Arafat because they want to come to an agreement with Israel and the United States.

Salah Khalaf was not always so moderate, though. He started a group called “Black September.” There were guerrillas (Say it, Ger-ILL-uz). They were fighters who were not part of a regular army. In September 1971, the country of Jordan threw the Fatah guerrilla fighters out of the country. That is how they got the name “Black September.”

The next year, Black September took terrorism to the Olympics. In the summer of 1972, the Olympics were in Munich, Germany. Members of Black September kidnapped athletes from Israel who were at the Olympics. They ended up killing the 11 athletes. The United States said that Khalaf masterminded — thought up — the attack at the Olympics.

But Khalaf always said he was not responsible for it.

CP-1991-021 →

· La Crosse Tribune · La Crosse

Both Saddam Hussein, Israel blamed for PLO slayings

Two top men in the Palestine Liberation Organization have been assassinated. A third man who was supposed to be guarding the men also was killed. The two men were aides — assistants — to Yasser Arafat, the leader of the Palestinian Liberation Organization, called the PLO. The two aides were named Salah Khalaf, who was also known as Abu Iyad, and Hayel Abdel-Hamid.

They were killed by a man who had been part of a different faction of the PLO. But some people at first said that Israel was behind the assassinations, but now the PLO is blaming an Arab bodyguard once linked to Abu Nidal. Some newspapers in the Middle East say that Iraqi President Saddam Hussein may have ordered the killing.

Saddam was reportedly unhappy that Khalaf did not support his invasion of Kuwait. Salah Khalaf helped Yasser Arafat found — start — a group called Fatah in 1960. Fatah was the first group in the PLO. Palestinians are the Arab people from lands which are now part of Israel. The PLO was founded to get back the lands from Israel.

Salah Khalaf was thought to be a moderate member of the PLO. A moderate (MOD-er-it) is someone who is not too much on one side or another of an issue. He was thought to be in favor of a land for Palestinians while still letting Israel exist — live. Some members of the PLO want to destroy — ruin — Israel. The leader of this part of the PLO is Abu Nidal.

Abu Nidal wanted to kill Khalaf and Arafat because they want to come to an agreement with Israel and the United States. Salah Khalaf was not always so moderate, though. He started a group called “Black September.” There were guerrillas (Ger-ILL-uz). They were fighters who were not part of a regular army.

In September 1971, the country of Jordan threw the Fatah guerrilla fighters out of the country. That is how they got the name “Black September.” The next year, Black September took terrorism to the Olympics. In the summer of 1972, the Olympics were in Munich, Germany. Members of Black September kidnapped athletes from Israel who were at the Olympics.

They ended up killing the 11 athletes. The United States said that Khalaf masterminded — thought up — the attack at the Olympics. But Khalaf always said he was not responsible for it.

CP-1991-020 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Palestinians Are Buoyed By the Attacks on Israel

By SABRA CHARTRAND

JERUSALEM, Jan. 20 — “There is an Arabic proverb which says there are days of honey and days of onion,” a young Palestinian, shoulders hunched against wind and rain in the Old City, says philosophically. “For years Israel has known only honey — now it is tasting the onion.”

Along wet stone streets and past shuttered shops, Palestinians hurried today with crates of milk, huge sacks of rice and potatoes and bags crammed with flat pita bread. Like Israelis, they used the first quiet moment after Iraqi missile attacks on Friday and Saturday to stockpile for further siege.

But unlike the Jews, the Palestinians say they welcome the missiles, because they believe Israel deserves to be attacked, and because, one way or another, they think war will help create a Palestinian state.

In the occupied areas of the West Bank and Gaza Strip and in East Jerusalem, people acknowledge that the rocket attacks terrify them, but they also say the missiles have restored spirits that were dashed when United States and allied planes bombarded Baghdad on the first night of the war.

After months of unyielding support for President Saddam Hussein of Iraq, Palestinians were devastated by the apparent ease of the American assault and Iraq’s failure to resist. ‘A Joyous Moment for Us’ But morale among Palestinians soared when President Hussein kept his promise to fire Scud surface-to-surface missiles at Israel.

Many Palestinians were skeptical, suspicious that like other Arab leaders, the Iraqi’s threats against Israel and promises to help the Palestinians were just rhetoric. Then President Hussein proved, Palestinians say, that only he is willing and able to stand up to Israel, and that only he understands that the Israeli-Arab conflict is at the root of Middle East instability.

“When the first air raid siren went off, it was a very joyous moment for us,” said a 21-year-old bank teller who declined to give his name. “It was great — we clapped our hands and made victory signs with our fingers.” He added: “Look, the Israelis have been attacking us for nearly 50 years, and they attack southern Lebanon just about every day.

They deserve massive missile assaults, not just a few.” Military Curfews Lifted Walking arm-in-arm in the drizzle with a friend, another Palestinian, 18-year-old Ghada Bitar, said: “The Israelis have to know what we Palestinians feel, what the Iraqis are feeling, what it feels like living with war. Now we are hopeful that this will help liberate Palestine.”

In the West Bank and Gaza Strip this morning, military authorities temporarily lifted curfews that had been in place since the war erupted, to allow Palestinians an hour or two to shop for food. In Ramallah and Bethlehem, the army resumed the court-ordered dispersal of gas masks by taking Palestinians in buses to distribution centers and driving them back home.

But only Palestinians living in towns close to Israel are to receive the masks, because the military does not have enough for the entire Arab population. In Beit Sahur, next to Bethlehem, residents refused to accept adult-sized gas masks because the army was not issuing the gear for children at the same time.

… Outside the Old City, Pierre Salfiti is kept busy all day by crowds shopping in his market. Mulling over the missile attacks, he had another suggestion: “Israel maintains it has the right to strike back at Iraq any time it wants, maybe now, maybe in 10 years.

It could be that Saddam Hussein also reserved the right to strike back for what the Israelis did to him in 1981, when they destroyed his nuclear reactor.” He paused for a moment, and then added: “We Palestinians are like someone who is drowning — we look for anything that will save us. That may be why people see Saddam as a great savior.”

CP-1991-059 →

· The Register-Guard

Palestinians on desperate course

Leaders' support for Hussein damages political credibility

ANTHONY LEWIS

BOSTON — “It is a great day,” a Palestinian in Amman said on Friday. “It is the first time we have hit Israel with missiles.” Across the Middle East, most Palestinians support Iraq in the war. They cheer even an act as outrageous as firing missiles at civilians. They speak with the voice of desperation, of defeat, of resentment.

The Palestinians feel betrayed and abandoned by the West, especially by the United States. They lost their home, and the greatest world power has brought them no justice. The feelings are real, and we have to understand them. But what a disaster it is for Palestinians to be led by those feelings into support of Saddam Hussein.

Over many decades Palestinian nationalism has made crucial political mistakes. This may be the worst. The fault lies with the Palestinian leadership. The PLO has been ardent in backing Iraq since it gobbled up Kuwait. Yasser Arafat, addressing a Palestinian rally in Baghdad on Jan.

7, said that if the United States and its allies wanted to fight, “then I say welcome, welcome, welcome to war.” He said “Iraq and Palestine” would be “together, side by side.” When the war started, the PLO executive committee condemned “American aggression.”

The folly of that position — the folly for the Palestinian cause — is understood by many Palestinian intellectuals. A leading figure among them, Walid Khalidi, makes the case in a pamphlet just published by the Institute for Palestine Studies in Washington.

“The principles violated by Saddam in his invasion of Kuwait,” Khalidi wrote, “were the very principles from which the Palestinian cause drew its moral strength. The 'terrorist' image that Arafat was so desperate to shed was only reconfirmed by a close association with Saddam after (his) invasion of Kuwait . . .

“Even if moral considerations were not at issue — and they are — antagonizing more than half the Arab states, particularly those that have enabled the PLO to operate for the last quarter of a century, is hardly in Palestinian interests.”

CP-1991-061 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore · page 1

‘Administrative detention’: Israelis skip due process

Doug Struck, Sun staff correspondent

“JERUSALEM — He still does not know the crime that sent him to a prison camp in the desert, said Jad Isaac. He is Palestinian, and that is offense enough, he said. Dr. Isaac is a professor of biochemistry at Bethlehem University and was placed under ‘administrative detention’ by Israeli authorities in 1988.

His case is strikingly similar to that of Sari Nusseibeh, another professor and moderate supporter of the Palestine Liberation Organization, who was arrested by Israeli authorities last week, accused of spying for Iraq during the Persian Gulf war. Mr. Nusseibeh was ordered held under administrative detention. Mr.

Nusseibeh’s arrest has again drawn attention to the detention procedure that has been used by Israeli authorities to imprison 14,000 Palestinians or their supporters in the past three years, according to the military’s own count. An arrest under administrative detention requires little more than the signature of a military officer. There are no charges. There is no trial.

The person detained may appear with a lawyer before a judge,—” (See DETAIN, 9A, Col. 3)

The pull-quote set beside the story reads: “An arrest requires little more than the signature of a military officer. There are no charges. There is no trial.”

The paper puts the term in quotation marks and calls it what it is in the same line. The figure of fourteen thousand is attributed to the military’s own count.

CP-1991-001 →

· Syracuse Herald Journal · Syracuse · page 1

Books About the Arab World

Fiction

“‘Palace of Desires,’ just out in hardcover from Doubleday, is the second volume in Naguib Mahfouz’s Cairo Trilogy… ‘Season of Migration to the North’ and ‘The Wedding of Zein’ (Heinemann or Three Continents), both by the highly recommended Sudanese writer Tayeb Salih.

‘Cities of Salt’ (Vintage), a recent novel by Abdel Rahman Munif… ‘Woman at Point Zero’ (Zed Press), and two other novels, all by Egyptian feminist Nawal al Saadawi… ‘Men in the Sun’ and ‘Palestine’s Children’ (both Three Continents), both by Palestinian writer Ghassan Kanafani.

‘Wild Thorns’ (Interlink), by Sahar Khalifeh, a Palestinian woman. ‘Days of Dust’ (Three Continents), by the Lebanese novelist Halim Barakat.

‘Secret Life of Saeed the Ill-Fated Pessoptimist’ (Readers International), by the Palestinian writer Emile Habiby. ‘Opening the Gates: A Century of Arab Feminist Writing’ (Indiana University Press), an anthology mixing fiction and non-fiction, edited by Margo Badran and Miriam Cooke.”

Nineteen years after five American papers reported his killing as the death of a militant, a guerrilla chief and a terrorist leader, Ghassan Kanafani is on a books page in Syracuse as “Palestinian writer.” Emile Habiby is “the Palestinian writer.” Sahar Khalifeh, who has three clippings of her own in this archive, is “a Palestinian woman.”

CP-1991-008 →

· Newsday

Kuwait’s Palestinians Targeted

By Susan Sachs

Kuwait City — This scarred city’s liberation has unleashed a small but unusual crime wave. The bottled-up anger of seven months of Iraqi occupation is erupting in violent acts of retribution against Palestinian residents, apparently by both Kuwaiti soldiers returning from exile and civilians who rode it out at home.

In addition, gunfire has struck at least a dozen Kuwaiti soldiers manning checkpoints throughout the city. Doctors at Mubarak Hospital, which serves a largely Palestinian community, said yesterday they have treated five young Palestinian men who had been beaten or shot over the last week.

One man’s toenail had been ripped off, in grisly imitation of one of the torture methods employed by the Iraqis against Kuwaitis. Three of the victims worked at the Palestine Liberation Organization, whose leadership supported Iraqi President Saddam Hussein and is vilified by Kuwaiti officials.

A PLO spokesman at the group’s run-down offices in Kuwait City, speaking from behind a closed door, refused to comment on the attacks. But the doctors said the three men told them they had been shot by the Kuwaiti military at checkpoints or police stations.

“What we hear about is a lot of quarrels at the checkpoints,” said one doctor, a Palestinian himself, who feared retribution if his name was revealed. “Is it a green light from their people to torture the Palestinians? We had trouble during the Iraqi presence. Why should we suffer when Kuwait becomes a free country?”

The sound of gunfire still rings through the night. Most is believed to come from celebrating Kuwaitis who fire into the air, with weapons abandoned by the Iraqis.

DANGEROUS TOY. A 4-year-old child plays with a live anti-aircraft round yesterday in Kuwait City, one of thousands of rounds of live ammunition and unexploded ordnance left behind by Iraqi forces.

CP-1991-046 →

· Daily Herald

Kuwait’s Palestinians live in fear

Los Angeles Times/Washington Post News Service and Associated Press

KUWAIT CITY — At least two Palestinians have been killed with gunshots to the head and five others have been hospitalized with injuries from apparent beatings and shootings, raising new concerns about reprisals against the Palestinian community here.

One of the hospitalized men, who is believed to have been tortured, is unable to talk coherently, and another is so fearful that he has refused to leave the hospital, according to doctors and representatives of Kuwait’s substantial Palestinian community.

The reports of violence came as American oil firefighters working near clouds of black smoke and roaring oil fires were assessing what it will take to restore Kuwait’s oil facilities sabotaged by Iraqi forces last month. Some say the bill could run as high as $20 billion over 10 years.

Kuwaiti oil officials estimated on Thursday that 189 million gallons a day — double what Britain uses in a day — have been lost from Kuwait’s largest oil field since Iraqi forces blasted 400 of the field’s 500 oil wells.

All the hospitalized Palestinians said they were beaten by Kuwaiti or Saudi soldiers after being arrested in their homes or at checkpoints throughout the city, in some cases for offenses as minor as failing to have their car registration.

Medical reports, combined with evidence that Palestinians are being detained for substantial periods and sometimes roughly harassed at military checkpoints throughout the city, have raised tensions among Kuwait’s remaining 180,000 Palestinians, some of whom are accused of collaborating with Iraqi forces during the seven-month-long occupation of Kuwait.

“Is the liberation of Kuwait a green light for their people to try to torture Palestinians, to make their life more difficult?” said one resident of Kuwait city’s Jabriyah district.

In New York Wednesday, the PLO observer to the United Nations, Nasser Kidwa, wrote to the president of the Security Council charging that “violent and hostile actions” against Palestinians living in Kuwait continue at the hands of armed vigilantes and “some elements from the Kuwaiti army.”

The confrontations raise questions about the future of Kuwait’s Palestinian community, estimated at nearly 400,000 before the Iraqi occupation, which historically has held important teaching, medical and technical positions that could not be filled by Kuwaitis.

Now, many Palestinians worry that the returning Kuwaiti government, angered at the PLO leadership’s support of Iraqi President Saddam Hussein, will replace them with workers from Arab countries such as Egypt, which helped to liberate Kuwait from occupation.

CP-1991-047 →

· Huntsville Times

Violence against the Palestinians raises concern

By KIM MURPHY

KUWAIT CITY — At least two Palestinians have been killed with gunshots to the head and five others have been hospitalized with injuries from apparent beatings and shootings, raising new concerns about reprisals against the Palestinian community here.

One of the hospitalized men, who is believed to have been tortured, is unable to talk coherently, and another is so fearful that he has refused to leave the hospital, according to physicians and representatives of Kuwait’s substantial Palestinian community.

All the hospitalized Palestinians said they were beaten by Kuwaiti or Saudi soldiers after being arrested in their homes or at checkpoints throughout the city, in some cases for offenses as minor as failing to have their car registration.

Medical reports, combined with evidence that Palestinians are being detained for substantial periods and sometimes roughly harassed at military checkpoints throughout the city, have raised tensions among Kuwait’s remaining 180,000 Palestinians, some of whom are accused of collaborating with Iraqi forces during the seven-month-long occupation of Kuwait.

“Is the liberation of Kuwait a green light for their people to try to torture Palestinians, to make their life more difficult? We had difficulty during the Iraqis’ presence. Why should we suffer more?” said one resident of Kuwait city’s Jabriyah district, one of three heavily Palestinian neighborhoods in the capital.

The confrontations raise questions about the future of Kuwait’s Palestinian community, estimated at nearly 400,000 before the Iraqi occupation, which historically has held important teaching, medical and technical positions that could not be filled by Kuwaitis.

Now, many Palestinians worry that the returning Kuwaiti government, angered at the PLO leadership’s support of Iraqi President Saddam Hussein, will replace them with workers from Arab countries such as Egypt, which helped to liberate Kuwait from occupation.

Many Palestinian professionals who sent their families out of Kuwait during the occupation say they now doubt that the Kuwaiti government will grant their families visas to return, and many therefore expect to be leaving Kuwait to join their spouses.

The Kuwaiti government has said it does not intend to discriminate against Palestinians in Kuwait who did not collaborate with Iraqi forces, and has no plans systematically to replace Palestinians with Egyptians or other foreign workers.

Clearly alarmed at the reports of violence, it has ordered the army to renew instructions to its soldiers at checkpoints and insist on proper treatment of Palestinians. “We must not lose in one week what we have gained, what we have fought for in seven months,” said a senior Kuwaiti official. “But if you suffered ... it may be difficult to control.”

Kuwait’s Crown Prince Saad al Abdullah al Sabah responded Thursday to reports of police torturing Palestinians. “I would like to ... put on the record that I deny all such rumors and I would like you not to believe whatever is being rumored in such a direction,” he said.

CP-1991-048 →

· Los Angeles Times · page A10

Palestinians Tell of Abuse, Reprisals

Vengeance: Victims in hospitals say they were beaten by Kuwaiti or Saudi soldiers after being arrested. The Emir’s regime renews warnings to its military.

By KIM MURPHY

KUWAIT CITY—At least two Palestinians have been killed with gunshots to the head and five others have been hospitalized with injuries from apparent beatings and shootings, raising new concerns about reprisals against the Palestinian community here.

One of the hospitalized men, who is believed to have been tortured, is unable to talk coherently, and another is so fearful that he has refused to leave the hospital, according to physicians and representatives of Kuwait’s substantial Palestinian community.

All of the hospitalized Palestinians said they were beaten by Kuwaiti or Saudi soldiers after being arrested in their homes or at checkpoints throughout the city, in some cases for offenses as minor as failing to have their car registration.

Medical reports, combined with evidence that Palestinians are being detained for substantial periods and sometimes roughly harassed at military checkpoints throughout the city, have raised tensions among Kuwait’s remaining 180,000 Palestinians, some of whom are accused of collaborating with Iraqi forces during the seven-month-long occupation of Kuwait.

“We have a feeling that a danger is present after the liberation of Kuwait,” said one resident of Kuwait city’s Jabriyah district, one of three heavily Palestinian neighborhoods in the capital. “We are afraid. We are telling our families not to go out except for important reason.”

Said another: “Is the liberation of Kuwait a green light for their people to try to torture Palestinians, to make their life more difficult? We had difficulty during the Iraqis’ presence. Why should we suffer more?”

In New York on Wednesday, the Palestine Liberation Organization observer to the United Nations, Nasser Kidwa, wrote to the president of the Security Council charging that “violent and hostile actions” against Palestinians living in Kuwait continue at the hands of armed vigilantes and “some elements from the Kuwaiti army. . . .”

The confrontations raise questions about the future of Kuwait’s Palestinian community, estimated at nearly 400,000 before the Iraqi occupation, which historically has held important teaching, medical and technical positions that could not be filled by Kuwaitis.

Now, many Palestinians fear that the returning Kuwaiti government, angered at the PLO leadership’s support of Iraqi President Saddam Hussein, will replace them with workers from Arab countries such as Egypt, which helped to liberate Kuwait from occupation.

Many Palestinian professionals who sent their families out of Kuwait during the occupation say they now believe it is unlikely that the Kuwaiti government will grant their families visas to return, and many therefore expect to be leaving Kuwait to join their spouses.

The Kuwaiti government has said it does not intend to discriminate against Palestinians in Kuwait who did not collaborate with Iraqi forces and has no plans to systematically replace Palestinians with Egyptians or other foreign workers.

Clearly alarmed at the reports of violence, it has ordered the army to renew instructions to its soldiers at checkpoints and insist on proper treatment of Palestinians.

CP-1991-049 →

· News and Record · Greensboro · page A4

Violence against Palestinians in Kuwait raises troubling questions

L.A. Times-Washington Post News Service

KUWAIT CITY — At least two Palestinians have been killed by gunshots to the head and five others have been hospitalized with injuries from apparent beatings and shootings, raising new concerns about reprisals against Kuwait’s substantial Palestinian community.

One of the hospitalized men, who is believed to have been tortured, is unable to talk coherently, and another is so fearful that he has refused to leave the hospital, according to physicians and representatives of the Palestinian community.

All the hospitalized Palestinians said they were beaten by Kuwaiti or Saudi soldiers after being arrested in their homes or at checkpoints, in some cases for offenses as minor as failing to have their car registration. Evidence indicates that Palestinians are being detained for substantial periods and sometimes roughly harassed at military checkpoints throughout the city.

Tensions have heightened among Kuwait’s remaining 180,000 Palestinians, some of whom are accused of collaborating with Iraqi forces during the seven-month occupation of Kuwait. “Is the liberation of Kuwait a green light for their people to try to torture Palestinians, to make their life more difficult? We had difficulty during the Iraqis’ presence.

Why should we suffer more?” said one resident of Kuwait city’s Jabriyah district, one of three heavily Palestinian neighborhoods in the capital.

In New York, the Palestine Liberation Organization’s observer to the United Nations, Nasser Kidwa, wrote Wednesday to the president of the Security Council charging that “violent and hostile actions” against Palestinians living in Kuwait continue at the hands of armed vigilantes and “some elements from the Kuwaiti army.”

The confrontations raise questions about the future of Kuwait’s Palestinian community, estimated at nearly 400,000 before the Iraqi occupation. Palestinians historically have held important teaching, medical and technical positions in Kuwait.

Now many Palestinians worry that the returning Kuwaiti government, angered at the PLO leadership’s support of Iraqi President Saddam Hussein, will replace them with workers from Arab countries such as Egypt, which helped to liberate Kuwait from occupation.

Many Palestinian professionals who sent their families out of Kuwait during the occupation say they now doubt the Kuwaiti government will grant their families visas to return, and many therefore expect to be leaving Kuwait to join their spouses.

The Kuwaiti government has said it does not intend to discriminate against Palestinians in Kuwait who did not collaborate with Iraqi forces. It also said it has no plans to replace them with foreign workers. The Kuwaiti government has ordered the army to insist on proper treatment of Palestinians.

“We must not lose in one week what we have gained, what we have fought for in seven months,” a senior Kuwaiti official said.

CP-1991-050 →

· The News & Observer · Raleigh · page 1

Temple Mount inquiry continues

New evidence counters Israel’s claim that shootings were justified

Six months after the shootings. The headline is about a process continuing; the line beneath it is the news, and it is the strongest sentence about that week anywhere in this archive: new evidence counters Israel’s claim that shootings were justified. The word for what happened is still shootings, with nobody shooting, but the justification has become something a state claimed and evidence contradicts.

CP-1991-002 →

· The New York Times

Kuwaitis Urged to Halt Attacks on Palestinians

By JOHN KIFNER

KUWAIT CITY, April 2 — American military and diplomatic officials are pressing the Kuwaiti Government to prevent further attacks against Palestinians like those that occurred in the first weeks after the end of the Iraqi occupation.

A half-dozen younger members of the royal Sabah family formed what a Western diplomat called “goon squads” and carried out some of the attacks, diplomats, Kuwaitis and Palestinians say. Other attacks came at the hands of low-ranking Kuwaiti troops and armed civilians at roadblocks.

“We’re putting severe pressure on them that ‘you don’t want to look like Iraqis,’ ” said Col. Ron Smith of the 352d Civil Affairs Command, which is working with the Kuwaiti police. The command has taken over much of the day-to-day running of Kuwait and is also giving advice on the reconstruction of the country.

The pressure, say diplomats and Palestinians, appears to have made a change from the early days of liberation, when resentment of the Palestine Liberation Organization’s support for Iraq led to abductions, beatings, arbitrary jailings and at least 10 deaths, according to accounts by human rights organizations, journalists and Western diplomats.

Many Palestinians, who served as the major work force here before the war, were rounded up and expelled from the country. Nevertheless, as recently as last Wednesday night, Lieut. Col. Ed McCarty, a legal officer with the Civil Affairs Command, found the bodies of two men identified as Palestinians in a garbage dump.

There was “clear evidence of their having been tortured before they were killed,” he said. “What really upsets us is the indifference to finding the murderers,” said Colonel McCarty, a reservist who is a Nassau County judge in civilian life. “These bodies cry out for justice.”

Ambassador Edward Gnehm of the United States is known to have personally warned Crown Prince Saad al-Sabah that human-rights abuses against Palestinians and other foreign Arabs would lessen international support for Kuwait. “There is credible information there have been some abuses,” Mr. Gnehm told reporters.

“I have furnished the Government with the names of places and people. The Government has never denied that these things are going on.” The Crown Prince, a diplomat said, has warned the group of younger sheiks in the Sabah family that if their activities continued, he would “hang them from the lampposts.”

United States Army officers have several times dissuaded the Kuwaitis from conducting an armed sweep through the main Palestinian neighborhood, Hiwali, to search for weapons, believing that it would almost inevitably lead to gunfire and deaths.

The Hiwali district — called “Little Palestine,” the home of the middle-class professionals, technocrats and Government servants who once kept Kuwait functioning — is a tense, fearful place these days, surrounded by roadblocks and barricades of bulldozed earth.

As Palestinians stood in a long bread line the other day to get five round pieces of Arab bread — half the ration of Kuwaitis — a few came over to whisper to a reporter of beatings of their relatives. “They are taking the Palestinians and dumping their bodies in the desert,” a man said, looking nervously over his shoulder.

The human-rights group Middle East Watch estimates that at least 10 people were killed, possibly more, and some 2,000 abducted or imprisoned. Diplomats gave credence to the report. “Frankly, we’ve been very, very fortunate because the Kuwaiti society is so passive,” said Colonel Smith, the police adviser.

“Which is not to say that there haven’t been bodies turning up.” In many cases, the Americans’ insistence on such niceties as due process seems to be met with amused astonishment.

As Colonel Smith and Sergeant Damico made their rounds the other day, a police captain stared at them, stroking his mustache, his impassive face sometimes betraying the hint of a shrug as he listened to reports of alleged police misconduct. Frequently, he broke off to talk on the telephone.

Later, an army colonel commanding a police station grumbled to the Americans about their reports: “The Crown Prince is very angry. He will shoot my minister, who will shoot my general, who will shoot me. “All you ask about is the Palestinians. And they are the very worst people.”

From across the room, another colonel put in, “We don’t want the Palestinians or the Jordanians anymore.” “But who will change the oil in the police cars?” asked Colonel Smith, trying to make a joke out of the Kuwaitis’ total dependence on total labor. “Egyptians,” the second colonel replied, shrugging.

CP-1991-051 →

· The Atlanta Journal

For Kuwait’s many Palestinians, future looks as grim as the past

By Colin Campbell

KUWAIT CITY — It could be (since anything is possible) that the Middle East’s 4 million Palestinians are due for a run of luck. Washington’s new prestige in the region, for example, might encourage creative realism all around. But for Kuwait’s 400,000 prewar Palestinians, trouble and despair seem more likely.

They are now out of jobs, or exiles again, or both. Kuwait’s Palestinian community did much of the work Kuwaitis declined to do. They were prominent in technical, commercial and other middle-class fields. And they stood a better chance of keeping their jobs and educating their children here than in the West Bank or Gaza Strip.

But Kuwait was also a trap — even before the Iraqi invasion. Few Palestinians owned any property. Almost none were granted citizenship. If they lost their jobs, they could be deported. When their children reached adulthood, they too could get thrown out. Being born here made no difference. Many Kuwaitis, moreover, treated them like dangerous inferiors.

The Palestinians, in turn — shutting their eyes to Kuwait’s charms — resented the Kuwaitis’ wealth, privilege, safety, idleness, arrogance, provincialism and a hundred other qualities. The Iraqi invasion offered Palestinians a desperate, violent flash of hope. Saddam Hussein humiliated Kuwait and threatened to obliterate Israel.

He claimed to do all this to liberate Palestine. Yasser Arafat, like more radical PLO leaders, sided with Saddam. Most Palestinians here probably took no active role in the occupation. Some helped Kuwaiti friends and work mates. A few worked for the Kuwaiti resistance. But 400,000 is a lot of people.

“Some thousands of Palestinians here in Kuwait collaborated with the Iraqis,” said a well-informed Kuwaiti who asked not to be named. “And Saddam Hussein brought some thousands of Palestinian commandos to Kuwait, including Abul Abbas’s group and the Arab Liberation Front — a Baathist group — and Abu Nidal and George Habash.

“These people were seen in the streets. They went to many houses to search for Kuwaitis. They got some collaboration from the Palestinians who lived here, and some Palestinians who are not political stole many cars and robbed many shops. And so the Kuwaitis are angry.” Roughly 200,000 Palestinians fled Kuwait as the occupation dragged on.

Most of those who left had passports and other connections that offered them a place to go. Large numbers drove to Jordan. Yet many Palestinians were unable to leave, and their position now is extremely precarious. “Where am I supposed to go?” a distraught Palestinian professional demanded. He whipped out his passport and almost flung it at a reporter.

It was one of those Lebanese documents that identify the holder as a Palestinian refugee. “I drive around now in fear,” he said. “I sleep in fear. They are killing us, arresting us. I can’t go to Lebanon, I can’t go to Jordan, I can’t go to the United States, I can’t go anywhere. I am trapped here.

We don’t even have enough food now.” Palestinians whose stateless travel documents link them to the West Bank and Gaza Strip feel similarly trapped. Armed Kuwaitis began terrorizing Palestinians soon after liberation. The persecution has abated lately, under pressure from Washington.

Many Kuwaitis, however, hope to get tough again when the American influence recedes. No one thinks Kuwait is going to welcome back many Palestinians who left — though they include some of the best educated, most productive and presumably most law-abiding. There are no jobs for them — not now, anyway.

But, more important, the Kuwaitis don’t want to find themselves again at a demographic disadvantage. Imported Pakistani, Korean and Thai workers can be manipulated. Almost none want to live here permanently. Neither do smaller numbers of Europeans and Americans.

But Arabs aren’t so easily handled; many do want to stay, and they yearn to take part in any Arab political life that exists. The Palestinians, with no homeland to return to, are the most awkward Arab group of all.

CP-1991-052 →

· The New York Times

Fear Rises as Another Palestinian Dies in Kuwait

By JOHN KIFNER

KUWAIT CITY, April 9 — A prominent Palestinian has been shot to death here in circumstances that have raised concern among American officials that Kuwaitis, including some army and Government officials, are still abusing Palestinians. Dr.

Salim Mukhtar, a 56-year-old dentist and writer, a widely respected figure among Kuwait’s Palestinians, was slain last Thursday night, according to police records. The incident occurred near an army roadblock by the Sura district next to the main Palestinian quarter, Hawali. It is the only area of the city still regularly blocked off by army checkpoints. Dr.

Mukhtar was shot twice in the back of the head, once in the neck and once in the chest, Kuwaiti police reports compiled that night at a nearby hospital said. His body bore a grazing wound from a bullet across the stomach that also struck his companion, a woman, in the leg. The woman and other witnesses said Dr.

Mukhtar’s car was pulled over by another car, possibly a white Mercedes with a blinking blue light, and three men got out and one opened fire with a pistol, according to investigators looking into the incident. “Do you recognize me?” the gunman reportedly asked before shooting, some accounts of the incident said. If true, the odd question is striking.

The same question was said to have been posed to a prominent Kuwaiti leader of the opposition to Iraq’s occupation, Hamad al-Jauan, seconds before a gunman shot him in the chest after knocking at his door in the first days after the Iraqi forces were ousted. Mr.

Jauan was evacuated by American diplomats and military officials and is now reportedly being treated in a military hospital in the United States. At the time, many opposition members attributed the shooting to private militias loyal to some younger members of the ruling Sabah family who were described as intent on preserving the status quo.

Palestinians here, numbering perhaps 400,000 and long established, had furnished many of the engineers, teachers, other professionals, bureaucrats and shopkeepers who built Kuwait’s roads, schools, hospitals and other basic installations.

After the Iraqi occupation, some Kuwaitis took out their anger and frustration on the local Palestinians, whom they blamed for the Palestine Liberation Organization’s support for Iraq and accused of collaborating with the occupation.

Underground leaders have said that while some Palestinians worked with the Iraqis, many others helped them, providing food and other necessities. And Palestinians here were split over the official P.L.O. stand.

American officials say they put considerable backstage pressure on leaders of the Kuwaiti Government, including the Crown Prince, Saad al-Abdullah al-Sabah, after initial reports of Palestinians being beaten at roadblocks and bodies turning up in hospital morgues, vacant lots and garbage dumps.

A human rights group, Middle East Watch, says that at least 30 people were killed, a report that Western diplomats say they find credible.

United States Army officers working with the Kuwaitis say that despite their efforts, there are still cases of Kuwaiti soldiers or policemen pulling people from their homes and beating them; they say they are not sure how many Palestinians and others may be held captive, and they worry that trials for the 600 or so prisoners being charged with crimes during the occupation could turn into kangaroo courts.

“The Kuwaiti Government is well aware that we’re constantly pushing them on human rights,” an American officer said today. “We’re consistently getting the right answers, but then this stuff keeps going on.

You don’t know whether it’s incompetence and inefficiency, or that they’re just telling us what we want to hear and waiting for us to go away, or some of both.” Asked if he was worried that human rights abuses might occur once American forces left, the officer replied: “Of course. I think the potential is clearly there.

The only reassuring thing is that Kuwaitis mostly just talk.”

CP-1991-053 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York · page 44

The Land Of Oz

The novels of Amos Oz deliver an unsentimental view of Israeli life.

BY JAY PARINI

THE NEGEV IS AN UNREAL world, a landscape of whirling dunes, wind-sculptured stones and scrub trees. Jackals sleep in the nearby caves while desert hares scurry across the sand, dodging vultures. Apart from a few wandering Bedouin tribesmen on ragged camels, there is nothing human about this place. It is a vast, sprawling symbol of divine absence.

“The desert means a great deal to me,” says Amos Oz, the Israeli novelist. “I get up every morning at 5:30, and I go for a 40-minute walk out there, alone.”

Though a longtime member of Kibbutz Hulda, where he lived from the age of 14 until a few years ago, Oz and his wife, Nily, were recently forced to move to the desert city of Arad, in the northern Negev, because of his son’s asthma.

Their house — an unexceptional split-level that would raise no eyebrows in Levittown — is nestled on a quiet road that backs right up to the desert. “Leaving the kibbutz was obviously very painful for us,” Oz tells me, lighting a cigarette. “But we had no choice. My son can breathe here in the dry desert air.”

It is obvious to anyone who meets him in Arad that Oz can breathe here, too. At 51, he seems perfectly self-contained. A small, almost excessively handsome man, he wears his hair short and — in the tradition of the kibbutz movement — dresses down. Blue jeans and open collars are his preferred style.

His leathery, well-tanned face and flinty eyes suggest a life lived out-of-doors. The desert atmosphere seems appropriate for a man whom many Israelis regard as something of an old-time prophet.

Oz’s dozen novels and collections of shorter fiction — from “Where the Jackals Howl and Other Stories” (1965) to his latest, “To Know a Woman” (which has just been published by Harcourt Brace Jovanovich in an English translation by Nicholas de Lange) — offer a disturbingly frank and unsentimental view of Israeli life.

His outspoken, combative essays in the Israeli press on a wide range of sensitive topics seem calculated to win him few friends on either side of the political spectrum. His frequent lectures to American audiences on Israeli politics have enraged some of his most vocal critics.

Noam Chomsky of M.I.T., whose criticism of Israeli foreign and domestic policy has been influential on the left, accuses Oz of portraying himself as “a tragic victim” and Israel as “willing to make peace if only the Arabs were not committed to their militancy.” Oz brushes off such accusations as overly academic.

“Unlike Chomsky,” he says, “I have always believed that the P.L.O. has been one of the most extremist, fanatic and uncompromising movements of our times. Not in terms of what they have done to us, the Israelis, but in terms of what they have done and are still doing to their own people.

Nonetheless, self-determination is not granted to people as a reward for good behavior. Despite the stupid decision of the Palestinian leadership to endorse Saddam Hussein in the gulf war, the Palestinians in fact deserve and ought to get self-determination simply because the alternative to that for us is death.”

A sabra, or native Israeli, Oz grew up speaking and writing modern Hebrew, but his English — studied at school and picked up on numerous trips abroad — is crisply idiomatic, full of unusual metaphors and memorable phrases.

You sense immediately that whatever he says has been carefully thought out; as with everything else about the man, he speaks deliberately, in complete, measured sentences that hold a listener’s attention in something like an iron vise of eloquence and sincerity.

“To Know a Woman,” his most recent book, centers on a retired Mossad agent, Yoel Ravid, who at 47 has pretty much resigned himself to a life of atonement for his previous sins. “It’s a story about a spy,” Oz says, “but it’s not really a spy or espionage story.”

Amos Oz and his wife, Nily, near their home in Arad, a city in the Negev.

Date check: No masthead, but this is a magazine opening spread rather than a news page: the folio 44 is printed at the foot of the display column, and the photograph is credited “JAMES LUKOSKI FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES”, which confirms `pub`. The page prints no date. Internal evidence puts it after the Gulf war — Oz speaks of “the stupid decision of the Palestinian leadership to endorse Saddam Hussein in the gulf war” in the past tense — and gives Oz’s age as 51 and “To Know a Woman” as having “just been published” in English. All of that is consistent with `date` (1991-04-14, a Sunday, the Magazine’s day) without confirming it exactly.

CP-1991-026 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York · page 14

In Defiance of Israel

By Trudy Rubin

IN the wake of the liberation of Kuwait, many people are wondering how the outcome of the gulf war will affect the chances of resolving the Palestinian problem, including the fate of the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip. So this would seem an opportune time for an inside portrait of Gaza that illuminates the lives and thinking of its population. But in “Gaza.

A Year in the Intifada: A Personal Account From an Occupied Land,” Gloria Emerson, who movingly reported the human side of the war in Vietnam for The New York Times and who, in 1989, lived in Gaza for four and a half months, never gets much below the surface.

The tragic complexities of the place, where more than 500,000 stateless Palestinians are trapped in an underdeveloped, sandy Mediterranean strip only five miles wide by 28 miles long, are missing from her book. What Ms.

Emerson says she has set out to do is produce “a record of the life of Gazans for only one year” during the Palestinian uprising known as the intifada, which began in Gaza in 1987. She wants “to illuminate . . . why there is a revolution that will persist for years until the Palestinians have their nation.”

Staying at Marna House, a guest house with a lovely garden run by upper-class Palestinian women, where foreign journalists and voluntary agency workers cluster, she interviewed residents of the camps and various Gaza personalities, including a human-rights lawyer who was jailed, a hospital surgeon laboring under horrendous conditions who was fired after speaking out against the occupation and a white-haired, indefatigable female pillar of the community who has made a career of defying the Israeli authorities.

Ms. Emerson succeeds in conveying the pain and constant humiliations imposed by occupation, which afflict those who try to avoid trouble as well as those who court it.

Occasionally, her writing shows the passion of her celebrated Vietnam dispatches, as when she describes the despair of a father who was shot when he broke curfew to take his sick daughter to the hospital, or the distress of a woman sent to prison along with her child after her husband was deported.

And the stories of beatings and torture recounted by many of those she interviewed, who were often arrested without charges, are a useful reminder of the warped justice that any occupation breeds. But Ms.

Emerson’s strong identification with her subject matter and her anger at what she sees often produce a disconcerting self-righteousness in tone, which interferes with the story she is trying to tell. Most of her portraits lack depth, and her book doesn’t offer enough historical context, or even basic physical descriptions, to make Gaza come alive. In Ms.

Emerson’s portrayals, all Palestinians are good and almost all Israelis, mostly brutal soldiers, are bad. She never peels back any of the complex layers and divisions of Gaza society, between refugee camp and town, for example, or between secularists and fundamentalists. She does not discuss the major social and political differences between Gaza and the West Bank.

This kind of context is essential to help a reader understand the lives Gazans lead, and their hopes for the future. Rather than ferret out such telling information, Ms. Emerson tends to quote other journalists who have written on the subject.

She also makes some disconcerting errors of fact: she refers, for example, to the intifada’s leadership as “the underground cell in Jerusalem,” a pinpoint location that would surprise most Palestinians, not to mention the Israeli authorities; and she alleges, after one interview with a human-rights lawyer, that “only the problem of how to avoid the Israeli censor remained” before she could publish her material.

In fact, foreign correspondents in Israel do not necessarily have to consult the censor when writing stories like this one. Though the book is supposed to be about the uprising, it glosses over the byzantine underground politics of Gaza and never examines the multilayered attitudes of Gazans toward the Palestine Liberation Organization. And Ms.

Emerson is at a disadvantage in having done her research in 1989. The repercussions of the gulf war are already affecting the attitudes of Palestinians in Gaza and elsewhere; and the addition at the end of the book of a chronology of world events for 1990 doesn’t illuminate these changes.

A very different, and often overlooked, Palestinian community is examined in “Citizens Apart: A Portrait of the Palestinians in Israel.”

The subject is an important one because the growing radicalization of Israel’s 700,000 Arab citizens (17 percent of the population) is as significant as the uprising in the West Bank and Gaza to the future of the Jewish state.

Amina Minns, a social anthropologist, and Nadia Hijab, a journalist now working at the United Nations, offer a fascinating portrait of how the Palestinians who remained inside post-1948 Israel became more conscious of their ethnic identity, and how they have been affected by the intifada.

These Palestinians, as portrayed by the authors, are in a schizophrenic position: sympathetic to the uprising waged by West Bankers and Gazans for a Palestinian state but themselves struggling for equal rights with Israeli Jews. “No one knows the Jewish mentality the way we Palestinians in the ’48 area know it,” says Amer, a teacher from Nazareth.

Kept under military rule until 1966 by Israeli authorities, who confiscated much of their farmland and played on their tribal and clan divisions, these Palestinians have been slow in developing their own institutions and political parties.

But now, the authors say, the Palestinian citizens of Israel are “becoming more self-confident and sure-footed,” and they document their point with portraits of five “institution builders” and their families, including members of the Druse and Bedouin communities.

Israel’s Palestinian citizens are forming private institutions and voluntary groups, in Arab regions and urban ghettos that the Israeli Government has neglected, to provide services for sewage disposal, housing, schooling, health care and child care.

These Palestinians speak to the book’s authors with immense self-awareness, describing the discrimination against them in the jobs market and the threats they face of losing their homes in Jaffa and Acre or their villages in the Negev.

The story is a gripping one, because they are living side by side with Israelis and operating within Israel’s democratic system, which is often discomforted by their presence.

Many will disagree with the authors’ desperate, unrealistic conclusion: that Israel must “de-Zionize” into a “normal” state that no longer serves as a special haven for Jews. But the book provides a useful, provocative portrait of a worsening Palestinian problem internal to Israel of whose existence Americans are often unaware.

Israeli police guard the Temple Mount in Jerusalem after demonstrations in 1990, as Palestinians pray outside.

Date check: No masthead, but this page carries its own date line: at the foot of the first column it reads “14 May 12, 1991”, the folio and the issue date together. That confirms `date` (1991-05-12) exactly. `pub` is not named on the clipping; the page is a Book Review page and the date line gives no paper name, so The New York Times could not be verified from the page itself.

CP-1991-027 →

· The Orlando Sentinel · Orlando · page 1

Palestinians march, ask for fair play

Walkathon contributions targeted medical programs, kindergartens and family support networks in Israel's occupied territories.

Sharon McBreen, of the Sentinel staff

“About 150 Palestinian supporters demonstrated Saturday in downtown Orlando, hoping their call for peace here will win the same freedom of expression for their relatives in the Middle East.

In one of several walkathons nationwide, families, teen-agers and senior citizens paraded from Lake Eola, where they rallied, to the federal building on Hughey Avenue and back to the park.

They carried signs demanding a Palestinian state and called for Israel to follow United Nations resolutions to leave the West Bank and the Gaza Strip in return for recognition by the Arab countries. ‘We need a Palestinian homeland,’ shouted Mohammad Abuasba, who led the ceremonies organized by the Arab-American Community Center for the second year.

‘[Secretary of State James] Baker, Baker, go for peace. Occupation must cease.’ Walkathon contributions targeted medical programs, kindergartens and family support networks in the occupied territories. Violence has flared in the region, killing both Palestinians and Jews, since intifada, a Palestinian uprising against Israeli rule, began in December 1987.

Israel has said it needs the territories, which it seized in a 1967 war with Egypt and Syria, for border security and to resettle Jewish immigrants from other countries, including the Soviet Union and Ethiopia. Israeli leaders have been hesitant to trade land for peace.

The Persian Gulf War also ‘created a whole new set of hostilities’ in the territories, said Catherine Price, Middle East task force coordinator for the Florida Coalition for Peace and Justice, a co-sponsor of Saturday’s march. Many Palestinians used to work in Kuwait and send money to their families in the territories, Price said.

In the territories, about 1.5 million Arabs have been under curfew since the war began. ‘We as Americans should stand against aggressions,’ said Dr. Talal E. Hilal, a Bethlehem native whose relatives still live there. He compared aggres…”

“Walkathon in downtown Orlando was 1 of several in nation. Rally started and ended at Lake Eola.” Bobby Coker / Sentinel. Placards in the photograph read “STOP GENOCIDE IN THE WEST BANK AND GAZA,” “JERUSALEM IS THE CAPITAL OF PALESTINE” and “PALESTINIAN WOMEN NEED FREEDOM TOO.”

Two Palestinians named in Orlando, one of them a doctor from Bethlehem. The story continues on B-4, which is not on this clipping.

CP-1991-003 →

· estimated · Boca Raton News · Boca Raton

Israelis to release more Arab prisoners

JERUSALEM — Continuing its carrot-and-stick approach to the Palestinian uprising, Israel is expected to release several hundred Arab prisoners from the West Bank and Gaza Strip Thursday, military sources said Wednesday. In recent years, Israel routinely has released prisoners approaching parole time in advance of the Muslim Feast of Sacrifice, called Id al-Adha.

The feast begins Thursday night. Military sources would not say how many would be released.

Date check: No masthead and no page date line — the clipping is cut to a two-line headline and three short paragraphs. Neither “Boca Raton News” nor 1991-06-20 appears on the scan. The item is datelined JERUSALEM with no date and reports that military sources spoke “Wednesday” about a release expected “Thursday”, which points to a Thursday paper; 20 June 1991 was a Thursday, consistent with `date`.

CP-1991-024 →

· Staten Island Advance · Staten Island · page 1

Palestinian refugees head home

Camp Canada, Egypt has been home to thousands

William C. Mann, Associated Press, Camp Canada, Egypt

CAMP CANADA, Egypt — Sitting in the ruin of what was his home for 15 years, Mustafa Kamel el-Hawi spoke of jumbled emotions as he prepared to leave for a new world.

It’s a world three miles away, across a frontier of barbed wire, in Israeli-occupied Gaza… “I feel confused, like I still need something from Egypt, but I must make a statement for Palestine,” said el-Hawi, a 33-year-old civil engineer educated in Houston. “Everybody in the camp feels the same way.”

The forgotten families are going home from scruffy Camp Canada, named for Canadian peacekeepers who, in the 1950s, used it to watch over the area where the Sinai Peninsula meets the Gaza Strip.

The 560 families, about 6,000 people in all, were stranded in Egypt in 1982 when Israel ended 15 years of occupation in Sinai but kept control of Gaza… It was a 70-mile trip, along a border fence of steel mesh and barbed wire, across a no man’s land 135 feet wide into Israel, then back along the fence to Tel Sultan and a two-bedroom house of concrete blocks el-Hawi built.

He stripped his Camp Canada house for construction materials, so the family left a shell of roofless rooms behind. “We call it our new life,” he said. “It’s going to be difficult to begin the new life on the outside… We’ll have to make new friends.

We’ll be meeting Jews in the street.”… The afternoon before a move to Tel Sultan, singing young men on flatbed trucks moved through the dusty streets to the three houseshells where belongings are stacked or heaped on dirt floors. They work like wreckers, sweating and laughing as they manhandle mattresses and tables and carpets into the trucks. El-Hawi said the young men serve as moving crews “just for friendship.

They’re just happy to work, instead of sitting here with nothing to do.”… Tamraz, 42, sat on the floor of his concrete-block house with his youngest daughter, 4-year-old Heba. “Heba,” he asked, “do you like Egypt better, or Palestine?”

She grinned and said, “Palestine.” As Tuesdays are for moving, Mondays are for reflection. The el-Hawis chatted under a lemon tree in what used to be their interior courtyard. Neighbors dropped by to wish them well. Sitting on the sand outside her kitchen, el-Hawi’s mother began sobbing, wiping tears from wrinkled cheeks with her orange scarf.

She wept because of the intefadeh, the anti-Israel uprising now in its fourth year, during which Israeli soldiers have killed at least 830 Palestinians. She worries about Mustafa and about his four sons, aged 6 to 16 months. “She told me that if she’s with us on the outside, then she’ll know we’re all right,” el-Hawi said.

A moving day, reported as a moving day. Six Palestinians are named, including a four-year-old who is asked a question and answers it, and an eighteen-year-old sitting her final exams. The casualty figure appears once, near the end, as the reason an old woman is crying in her own courtyard. The paper’s spelling, intefadeh, is kept.

CP-1991-007 →

· The Birmingham News · page 4C

Palestinians gamble for homeland with weakened hand

By Kim Murphy

SAFWAN, Iraq — For decades, this highway through hell has been the road of hope out of Palestine. The narrow slice of blacktop, which cuts through the desert out of Basra and winds through the rich oil fields of Kuwait, was built in the 1960s by the fledgling construction company of Yasser Arafat when the Palestine Liberation Organization was being hatched.

Palestinians since have traveled the road from Amman, Jordan, to the Persian Gulf when they ran out of hope at home. But now, time has run out on the other end.

For many Palestinians, the journey ended this spring where it began, in Safwan, a ramshackle town on the Iraqi-Kuwaiti frontier — a spot on the road home from the gulf for thousands of Palestinian exiles, deportees and refugees of the gulf war.

“We haven’t food, we haven’t water, we haven’t anything,” said Gassen Mutlaq, 23, the son of a Palestinian who emigrated to Kuwait in 1968, as he and nine Palestinians stood, aimlessly, at the road’s side one recent afternoon.

Taken prisoner by the Iraqis during the war, the men later had made it back as far as Kuwait City’s outskirts before Kuwaiti authorities intercepted them. They were shipped back across the border. Now they could not return to Kuwait, feared to go on to Baghdad and were uncertain how to get home — wherever home was.

“My father, my mother, my wife, my brother in Kuwait. What do I do? After 23 years I live in Kuwait. Now, no. Why not? Because I am Palestinian,” Mutlaq said. Ibrahim Mohammed Awad, a Kuwait University student, interrupted him, adding: “Our dream is broken. There is nothing. There are no dreams after this moment.”

Palestinians compare the occupation and subsequent deportations, arrests, torture and harassment that are driving Kuwait’s 400,000 Palestinians from the gulf to the “catastrophe,” the Palestinian exodus from Israel when the Jewish state was created.

For Palestinians, Kuwait “is a paradise lost that will never be gained again,” a senior Kuwaiti official said. “Let them be relegated to the forgotten. . . . Every one of them is a ticking time bomb.” The end of the gulf war has left the Palestinians in a political and economic crisis.

Four decades after Israel was carved out of Palestine, the 3-year-old uprising, or intifada, is stagnating. The Palestinians are no closer to finding a permanent homeland than they were in 1948.

The economic losses stemming from the PLO leadership’s controversial support of Iraq during the war now exceed an estimated $12 billion, according to the group’s official estimates. Factional violence in the Israeli-occupied territories has taken a dramatic upswing, with more Palestinians being killed by other Palestinians this year than by the Israeli army.

For the Palestinians, the war is not over yet — a proposition with grim prospects for the region.

Yasser Arafat / Backed the wrong horse, and now has lost Arab support.

CP-1991-054 →

· The Anniston Star · Anniston

Israeli settlements remain obstacle to peace

Obstacle to peace, in an Alabama paper in July 1991, and what is named as the obstacle is the settlements. This is the frame American papers used for two decades: the settlements are assessed by what they do to a negotiation, not by what they do to the people whose land they are on, who do not appear in the sentence.

CP-1991-004 →

· Los Angeles Times · page A14

PLO: Radicals, Moderates on Collision Course

Among the hard-liners are Ahmed Jibril, head of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine-General Command, and Abu Nidal, head of the Fatah Revolutionary Council, both suspected terrorists. Arafat is also expected to meet with radical fundamentalist groups such as Hamas and Islamic Jihad, which have not yet formally accepted invitations to the September meeting.

Many of these groups have not renounced terrorism and still advocate a Palestine that includes all the territory of Israel. “What this means is not good, at least not good for the PLO,” said a European diplomat in Damascus.

Khaled Fahoum, head of a coalition of four Damascus-based Palestinian groups, including the PFLP-GC, said the groups notified Arafat last week that they are accepting his invitation to meet in Sana, Yemen, before the PNC convenes in Algiers on Sept. 15.

“We're not asking him to take everything back but to stop being individualistic, to stop giving concessions for nothing,” Fahoum said in an interview. “He's made too many concessions during the past six to seven years, but he didn't get anything for it. They were concessions without any price. Also, he made a big mistake by siding with Saddam Hussein.

We want him to acknowledge that, to have self-criticism.” Jibril said in an interview last week that Damascus-based Palestinian leaders will demand, as their price for rejoining the PNC, that the PLO modify its political program to insist on the right of Palestinians to return to pre-Israeli Palestine and their right to self-determination.

“Any Palestinian leader who makes a deal without making these conditions, I have stated, he will be beheaded,” said Jibril, who was born in the village of Yazour, near Jaffa on the coast south of Tel Aviv.

CP-1991-062 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco

Veil Squads Enforce Islamic Law

Paint-gun war on ‘loose’ Gaza women reflects a nationalistic fervor

Sabra Chartrand

“About 30 teenage boys were scattered… her father, husband and brothers must force her. If they fail to do so, others must intervene.”

Coercion of Palestinian women by Palestinian men, reported in the New York Times and reprinted in San Francisco. The archive keeps it for the same reason it keeps the 1993 dispatch about a clinic that will not dispense contraceptives without a husband’s consent: the pressure on these women did not come from one direction.

CP-1991-022 →

· The New York Times

Settlements, Born of War, Seen as Barrier to Peace

By DENNIS HEVESI

What began as a Passover seder in occupied territory, less than a year after the 1967 Middle East war, would soon evolve into the Jewish settlement movement. It has been a contentious issue in Israeli-American relations for years, with President Bush only the latest American leader to be incensed by the settlements and to call them an obstacle to a possible Middle East peace.

On the eve of Passover in 1968, 73 religious Jews checked into the Park Hotel in the West Bank city of Hebron and announced that their seder, the ritual meal celebrating the exodus from slavery in Egypt, symbolized the return of Jews to the biblical lands of Judea and Samaria, their term for the West Bank.

There had been Jews in the West Bank for thousands of years — even after the Diaspora. But also, for centuries, there had been Palestinian Arabs. Conflict would come. “The true struggle between Palestinian Arabs and Jews started after World War I,” said Merle Thorpe Jr., president of the Foundation for Middle East Peace in Washington.

“At that point, 10 percent of the population of Palestine was Jewish,” Mr. Thorpe said, “and between 1920 and 1947, when the partition of Palestine was proposed by the United Nations, the Jewish population increased to about 31 percent.”

After the 1967 Mideast war, in which Israel captured Sinai, the West Bank, Golan Heights and Gaza Strip, the Jewish settlement movement was born.

New housing in the occupied territories, such as in Maaleh Adumim in the West Bank, above, is reportedly earmarked for Soviet immigrants. | The expansion of settlements like Kiryat Arba is a point of contention in Mideast peace efforts.

CP-1991-055 →

· Pottsville Republican

Baker, Palestinian meet in Jordan

By Donald M. Rothberg / Associated Press

AMMAN, Jordan — Secretary of State James A. Baker III held a surprise meeting today with a Palestinian representative who came to the Jordanian capital with the approval of the Palestine Liberation Organization. Hanan Ashrawi, a professor of languages who lives in the West Bank, is one of three Palestinians who has met six times with Baker in Jerusalem and Washington.

After meeting with Ashrawi, Baker returned to Syria for a five-hour meeting with President Hafez Assad to discuss a draft letter outlining U.S. positions on issues of concern to the Syrians. Baker then departed for Washington. “We made some progress,” a State Department official said after today’s meeting with the Ashrawi.

But he also indicated the United States was unwilling to yield on any of the major demands by the Palestinians. The official said the message from the United States was, “Look, we’re prepared to try to respond to some of your concerns, but understand ... we’re not going to make any assurances inconsistent with what our policy positions are.”

The Palestinians want the United States to support their demand for an independent state, a position at odds with U.S. thinking on that issue. The United Stated does support autonomy for Palestinians living in the West Bank and Gaza, a solution that would give the Palestinians control over most activities involving their people. Mrs.

Ashrawi said she wanted to discuss three issues: self-determination for Palestinians, the status of Jerusalem, and the Israeli policy of building settlements in occupied territories. “Some of the points we required were met,” she said of the earlier talks.

“But some others need more clarification ... that’s why President (Yasser) Arafat approved the meeting.” Baker had invited the Palestinians to come to Jordan for discussions, but his invitation initially was turned down. Mrs.

Ashrawi said the decision on whether the Palestinians would attend a peace conference as part of the Jordanian delegation “will be taken by the Palestinian leadership at the Palestine National Conference.” The conference is scheduled to meet starting Monday in Algiers.

U.S. officials traveling with Baker got word after midnight Jordanian time of the decision to authorize Mrs. Ashrawi to meet with the secretary of state. Baker has often said that a key signal of Palestinian willingness to join the peace process would be the presence of Palestinians in Jordan to discuss the make-up of a joint delegation.

However, Baker spokeswoman Margaret Tutwiler said no Jordanian officials were participating in today’s meeting. The meeting came after Baker joined with Jordan’s King Hussein to send a strong signal to the Palestinians to attend the conference or risk having it go on without them.

Hussein cautioned the Palestinians that “time is short” to join the peace process and added that “this opportunity may not come again, ever.”

Palestinian representative Hanan Ashrawi held a surprise meeting today with Secretary of State James A. Baker III in Amman, Jordan. Associated Press

CP-1991-057 →

· Courier Post · Camden · page 1

Bush to U.N.: Repeal resolution equating Zionism with racism

Associated Press and Gannett News Service

“President Bush called Monday for the United Nations to stop equating Zionism to racism.

Bush, addressing the opening session of the U.N. in New York, said that its 1975 resolution equating Zionism with racism needs to be repealed because it mocks the organization’s pledge to practice tolerance and live together in peace. ‘To equate Zionism with racism is to reject Israel itself,’ Bush said in his speech to the General Assembly of representatives from 166 nations.

‘This body cannot claim to seek peace and at the same time challenge Israel’s right to exist.’ ‘By repealing this resolution unconditionally,’ he said, ‘the United Nations will enhance its credibility and serve the cause of peace.’ The United States has long deplored the resolution but Bush had postponed a campaign to repeal it out of a desire to maintain Arab support for the effort against Iraq in the Persian Gulf. John Bolton, State Department assistant secretary for international organizations, said, ‘We think we have a majority in favor of repeal.’”

The repeal is asked for in public, and the same paragraph explains why it had waited two years: the United States wanted Arab support against Iraq first. The sidebar of quotations from the speech has three headings, on free markets, on international cooperation, and on Zionism.

CP-1991-009 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

On Coveted Hill in Galilee, 17 Arab Families Dig In

By CLYDE HABERMAN

CARMIEL, Israel, Sept. 28 — The tiny Arab hamlet of Ramya does not appear on Israeli maps, and after reaching it, up a rocky dirt trail that passes for a road, there is not much to see except nearby hilltops.

Unmarked Ramya, at the southern edge of this Israeli boomtown in Galilee, is a glum cluster of tin roofs and stone walls filled by nearly 100 people of Bedouin background whose families stopped wandering decades ago. Because it is unrecognized by the Government, it has had to get by without basic services like running water, electricity and paved roads.

Still, Ramya is home to its people, and they have dug in against an insistent Israeli Government that wants them to leave the land, to make room for new immigrants from the Soviet Union and other Jews.

Their fight has put a new spin on one of the oldest disputes in this country: the Arab-Jewish struggle over land, not in the Israeli-occupied territories this time but in Israel proper. ‘Why Should I Leave?’

While more than 300,000 Soviet Jews have arrived in Israel since 1989, with thousands settling in the predominantly Arab Galilee, the Ramya dispute marks perhaps the first time in this migration that Government officials are on record as saying that the Soviet immigrants and other Jewish newcomers have priority over longtime Arab residents.

Salah Hasel Sawaid, a construction worker who was born in 1944, four years before the state of Israel came into being, says he does not understand why. “My grandfather was born here, and he died here,” Mr. Sawaid said. “Why should I leave?”

The Government has offered him and other Ramya residents compensation in the form of a sliver of land elsewhere in the region, but he argues that it is too little, too far away. So does a cousin, Yussuf Sawaid, who tends Carmiel’s public gardens. “We have nothing against the immigrants coming here, but why should we suffer because of them?” he said.

“We want to stay here, and we’ll live together with these new people.” No they won’t, says Carmiel’s Mayor, Adi Eldar. Although the Sawaids and their neighbors claim legal title to 25 acres, Mr. Eldar and national officials insist that all of Ramya’s land was expropriated in 1976, from Jews as well as Arabs.

In effect, the authorities say, the residents have been allowed to stay on at the Government’s good graces. That grace period, they add, is now over. “It’s not even a village,” Mr. Eldar said. “They were there in tents, in little shacks. It doesn’t belong to them. They’re just living there.”

Akiram Shapira, a spokesman for the Israeli Lands Authority, said that “according to the law, their settlement is not legal,” and the courts have agreed. “But even though the court gives us permission to move them out,” Mr. Shapira said, “we want to give them another place not far away.”

Mayor Eldar figures that 7,000 apartments could be built on the Ramya hilltop and surrounding territory. There is no way, he and other officials say, that 17 families can block development of that magnitude, which he insists is intended to ease pressures on his city and not just to benefit fresh arrivals from the Soviet Union.

Nonetheless, Carmiel has grown by 8,000 people in the last two years, to 30,000, and two-thirds of that expansion comes from Soviet newcomers. That the Arabs would be displaced by Jewish immigrants was made clear last spring in a Lands Authority application for a court order expelling Ramya’s residents.

“It is a matter of extreme urgency,” the agency said, “that the tenure of the tract be handed over to the authority, for the area is needed immediately by the Department of Housing in order to build apartment houses for immigrants.”

Other Evacuations Feared Critics of the Government’s settlement policy, including several hundred people who rallied here in protest this weekend, warn that there are several dozen “unrecognized” villages like Ramya in Galilee. If the evacuation of Arabs is successful here, they predict, it will spread elsewhere to make room for new Jewish settlement.

Israel’s hard-line Housing Minister, Ariel Sharon, has already said he wants to send Soviet immigrants to Galilee to help build a Jewish majority in a region where Arabs now account for more than 60 percent of the population.

“Why must Arabs pay the price for this immigration?” said Mohammed Miari, an Arab member of Parliament from the left-wing Progressive List for Peace. “It is absurd to bring in people from outside to solve their problems while creating new problems for people already living here.”

Under one court order, the wrecker’s ball for Ramya was supposed to arrive in a few days, but further legal considerations have delayed it for two months. In the meantime, Ramya’s people and the Israeli authorities are negotiating possible compromises.

One Government offer involves giving each of the 17 families one-eighth of an acre of land a few miles away — a total of roughly 2 acres in exchange for the 25 they now inhabit. But Ramya residents say that the land being offered them does not provide enough room for their families to grow.

Besides, they say, their roots are on the hilltop, near the cluster of white stones marking relatives’ graves. “We were born here,” Yussuf Sawaid said, echoing his cousin. “And we will die here.”

Arab residents of Ramya, a hamlet in Galilee whose existence Israel does not recognize, marching to protest government plans to displace them to make room for immigrants from the Soviet Union. Their sign reads, “Law of the jungle: displacing an Arab settlement for a Jewish one.

Date check: No masthead and no page date line. `pub` is confirmed twice over on the page: the byline block reads “Special to The New York Times” and the locator map is credited “The New York Times”. The date is not printed anywhere. The dateline reads “CARMIEL, Israel, Sept. 28”, four days before the labelled date of 1991-10-02, and the body refers to a protest rally “this weekend”; 28 September 1991 was a Saturday. A gap of several days between dateline and publication is normal for the paper’s datelined “Journal” features, so this does not contradict `date`, but nothing on the page confirms it either.

CP-1991-028 →

· The Miami Herald · Miami

Palestinians wounded in Gaza Strip clashes

JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli troops clashed with stone-throwing Palestinians today in the occupied Gaza Strip, wounding more than 70 with rubber bullets, according to Arab and U.N. reports. Dozens more were treated for tear gas inhalation, the Arab reports said. The injury toll was the highest in months in clashes between the army and Palestinians.

The confrontations in Gaza City and the town of Rafah came as troops tried to break up rallies in support of Arab prisoners who have been on a hunger strike in Israeli jails since Sept. 27. The army spokesman’s office confirmed the Palestinian marches and said it was checking reports of injuries.

But today is Yom Kippur, and army reports on incidents in the occupied territories are frequently delayed on Jewish holidays. Officials with the U.N. Relief and Works Agency said preliminary reports indicated 63 Arabs from the town of Rafah and the Rafah refugee camp were treated at U.N. clinics for injuries from rubber bullets and rubber-coated metal pellets.

Arab reports said an additional 30 people were treated for tear gas inhalation. In downtown Gaza City, more than 2,000 Palestinians marched in solidarity with the striking prisoners. Arab reports said troops fired rubber bullets, wounding 10, and also sprayed the area with tear gas.

The demonstrators waved flags of the outlawed Palestine Liberation Organization and carried banners and posters in support of the prison strike, witnesses said.

CP-1991-015 →

· The Miami Herald · Miami

In isolation, Gaza Palestinians put hopes on peace process

JABALIYA REFUGEE CAMP, Gaza Strip — There were no burning tires and no stone-throwing protests on this Muslim Sabbath, once a trigger time for unrest in this miserable refugee camp.

Instead, some teen-age boys and old women were strolling down a back alley, careful to dodge a nearby Israeli patrol, as they headed home to their cement shacks from family visits at the Central Prison.

“Now, because we are waiting for peace we don’t have that many confrontations with the soldiers,” explained Jamal, 15, whose father and three brothers have been jailed during the nearly 4-year-old Palestinian uprising called intifada. “The intifada still exists,” he said, “but it is frozen. We are waiting for the peace process.

We are waiting to see what happens.” Not so long ago, Jamal would have been ambushing Israeli patrols as Muslim worshipers spilled out of their mosques to confront the Israeli occupation forces with rocks and taunts. It was as ritualistic as the Friday prayers themselves.

Conciliatory mood But, thwarted by Israel’s tactics, isolated from Arab world support since the Persian Gulf War and pinning their hopes on the prospects of peace, the residents of Gaza are in a somewhat conciliatory mood. The Palestinians’ parliament-in-exile has declared qualified support for a U.S.-backed plan for peace between the Arabs and the Israelis.

And people here seem inclined to give the Palestine Liberation Organization a chance to find a way to end two decades of Israeli occupation in the West Bank and Gaza. “It will be a peace not only between us and the Jews, but also with the United States and the whole world,” said Jamal, “but if we do not get it — we will make it hell here again.”

Gaza, the birthplace of the intifada, is a 140-square-mile strip of cement-block shantytowns crammed with 800,000 Palestinians.

Correction: Catalogued from the deck caption as The Daily Iberian, 7 October 1992. The page furniture on the scan reads "6A MONDAY, OCTOBER 7, 1991 / THE MIAMI HERALD / INTERNATIONAL EDITION". A different article from CP-1991-015, which is the same issue. Re-attributed 3 October 2026.

CP-1991-016 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinians Seek U.S. Assurances on Talks

“…Palestinians seek United States assurances that the delegation will include a representative from Jerusalem and that Israel will halt new settlements in the occupied territories before the talks begin.”

Three weeks before Madrid. Hanan Ashrawi and Faisal al-Husseini are named as the negotiators who have met Baker; the delegation they would join is still Jordanian-Palestinian, because a Palestinian one was not on offer.

CP-1991-023 →

· Bennington Banner · Bennington

Members of the 'Temple Mount Faithful' march to protest the shootings in October of 17 Palestinians by Israeli police

“Members of the ‘Temple Mount Faithful’ march to protest the shootings in October of 17 Palestinians by Israeli police” The Associated Press.

A year after the killings, and the same news agency that captioned the photographs in October 1990 now puts the count at 17. Its own captions that week said 19 — twice, in two papers (CP-1990-011, CP-1990-014). Nothing in this archive explains the difference. Two people left the number somewhere between October 1990 and October 1991, and no correction appears. The caption also has the Temple Mount Faithful marching to protest the shootings, which is how the sentence is set; the archive cannot tell from this scan whether that is what the march was.

CP-1991-005 →

· Huntsville Times

Arab driver hits Israeli soldiers; two dead, 11 hurt

By MARCUS ELIASON, The Associated Press

EDITOR'S NOTE — Israeli military censors delayed this report until next of kin were notified. The censors also ordered the last name of Sgt. Gil deleted. TEL AVIV, Israel — A Palestinian drove a van into hitchhiking Israeli soldiers in Tel Aviv today, killing two and injuring 11, in an attack intended to avenge the killing of Arabs at Temple Mount last year, police said.

The attack, which Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir called an “act of terror,” came as the Bush administration tried to arrange a Mideast peace conference this month amid opposition from Israeli hard-liners.

The assault, at a busy intersection in Tel Aviv, also came at a time of heightened Arab-Israeli tension following the seizure Wednesday of six houses in an Arab neighborhood of Jerusalem by Jewish nationalists. Authorities said the driver, a 25-year-old from a militant village in the occupied West Bank, was arrested and that he acted on “nationalist grounds.”

Tel Aviv police spokeswoman Dalia Gilad confirmed radio reports that the driver confessed he wanted to avenge the Temple Mount killings. Three days ago, Palestinians marked the first anniversary of the incident on the mount, known in Arabic as the Haram es-Sharif. Israeli police opened fire on the mount on Oct.

8, 1990, to quell a disturbance, killing 17 Palestinians and wounding at least 150. The incident set off a series of revenge attacks that have taken the lives of 19 Israelis and two foreign tourists. Eight Palestinians also have been killed, some during the assaults.

A statement by Shamir said today’s “act of terror” was “further proof of the murderous character of our enemies, who do not loathe using any method to harm our sons.” The statement pledged to “take all necessary actions to protect the lives of the citizens and prevent the reign of terror.” He did not elaborate.

But Rabbi Yerachmiel Boyer, mayor of the Bnei Brak suburb of Tel Aviv, said he would push for banning Palestinians from entering the city. The dead were identified as Sgt. Aharon Kaluzne-Agmon, 36, and Master Sgt. Shmuel Michaeli, 21. Two of the injured were in critical condition, police said.

A soldier who caught the driver said: “He told me he ran a red light ... and couldn’t stop. But he was alone on the road and he had every opportunity in the world to avoid the soldiers.” Police said the driver is from the village of Qibya near Ramallah in the West Bank, captured from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast War.

The vehicle belonged to his employer, an Israeli from a farm village in central Israel, they said. An Israeli sergeant whose first name is Gil said the van ran a red light, approached at 40 mph and struck the two military police officers, a man and a woman, who had been posted at the corner to keep order among the hitchhikers.

Today’s attack could heighten opposition among Israeli hard-liners to a Mideast peace conference the United States is trying to arrange this month. Israeli hard-liners say members of the Palestine Liberation Organizatior, which they consider to be terrorist, should not be allowed to attend.

Also, Syrian President Hafez Assad reportedly has raised questions about his country’s participation in a phase of the negotiations with Israel. In Washington, Palestinian Arabs were returning to the State Department today to continue so-far inconclusive talks on the terms for Palestinian participation in the planned Middle East peace conference.

CP-1991-060 →

· Daytona Beach News-Journal · Daytona Beach

Peace talk delegates tie themselves to PLO

JERUSALEM — Brushing aside Israel’s warnings that it will not negotiate with anyone tied to the Palestine Liberation Organization, the man widely understood to be the designated chief of the Palestinian delegation to the Middle East peace talks said Monday that he and his colleagues were prepared to declare openly that they are PLO members.

“If we need to say this at any juncture, we shall not hesitate to say it if necessary,” Dr. Haider Abdel-Shafi of the Gaza Strip told the Israeli army radio. “Certainly, we are not going to refrain from affirming we are PLO supporters.”

In Cairo, the organization’s chairman, Yasser Arafat, made clear that even though his group would have to stay in the background at Israel’s insistence, it intends to exert great influence on the 14 Palestinian representatives who will go the conference in Madrid next week as part of a joint delegation with Jordan.

“Each and every person among the Palestinian people represents the PLO,” Arafat said Monday. A six-member advisory committee has been established to go to Madrid and serve as a link between the official Palestinian delegation and the PLO leadership.

According to knowledgeable Palestinians in Jerusalem, this panel includes two experienced negotiators here, Faisal al-Husseini and Hanan Ashrawi, who have often met with Secretary of State James Baker over the last half a year and who speak openly for the PLO.

The increasingly high profile that the organization has chosen to show in the last few days, if carried far enough, could push the Israeli government to a point where it feels it has no choice but to walk out of the peace talks. Thus far, that point has not been reached.

CP-1991-017 →

· Fort Worth Star-Telegram · Fort Worth

Head of Palestinian delegation not shy about PLO ties

Israel says it won’t negotiate at the peace conference with members of what it considers a terrorist organization.

JERUSALEM — The designated leader of the Palestinian delegation to the Middle East peace talks in Madrid yesterday brushed aside Israel’s warnings that it will not negotiate with anyone tied to the Palestine Liberation Organization. Dr.

Haider Abdel-Shafi of the Gaza Strip told Israeli army radio that he and his colleagues were prepared to declare openly that they are PLO members. “If we need to say this at any juncture, we shall not hesitate to say it if necessary,” Abdel-Shafi said. “Certainly, we are not going to refrain from affirming we are PLO supporters.”

In Cairo, PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat made clear that even though his group would have to stay in the background at Israel’s insistence, it intends to exert great influence on the 14 Palestinian representatives who will go the conference in Madrid on Oct. 30 as part of a joint delegation with Jordan.

“Each and every person among the Palestinian people represents the PLO,” Arafat told reporters. A six-member advisory committee has been established to go to Madrid and serve as a link between the official Palestinian delegation and the PLO leadership.

Knowledgeable Palestinians in Jerusalem said the panel includes two experienced negotiators in Jerusalem, Faisal Husseini and Hanan Ashrawi, who have often met with Secretary of State James Baker III over the last six months and who speak openly for the PLO.

The increasingly high profile that the organization has chosen to show in the last few days, if carried far enough, could push the Israeli government to a point where it feels that it has no choice but to walk out of the peace talks. Thus far, that point has not been reached.

Israeli officials chose yesterday to dismiss the latest assertiveness as posturing by a group frustrated over its lack of an official role in Madrid. “The more the PLO is deprived from being in the process, the more it will do to be perceived as being involved,” a senior Israeli official said.

“As far as Israel is concerned, there is no role for the PLO.”

CP-1991-018 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Israelis Deplore Advisory Panel Of Palestinians

By CLYDE HABERMAN

JERUSALEM, Oct. 22 — Israeli officials said today that they were “most unhappy” with a Palestinian team that will attend the Middle East peace conference next week, and they called on the United States to insist that the group’s members have nothing to do with the Palestine Liberation Organization.

The Israelis stopped well short of threatening to withdraw from the peace process unless their demand was met. Nonetheless, one senior official charged that the Palestinians “are trying to provoke us,” and he cautioned that “at some point it could become too much.”

For Israel, the issue is not the official Palestinian delegation, 14 men from the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip who were formally named today and who will go to the peace talks in Madrid in tandem with representatives from Jordan.

‘People We Can Deal With’ Israel has already got what it wants on that score, having made sure, as a price for going to Madrid, that all 14 have no overt P.L.O ties and live in the occupied territories, but not Jerusalem.

“These are people we can deal with,” said Yosef Ahimeir, a senior aide to Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir, who like other officials here was well aware of the names long before they were made public.

Date check: No masthead — the clipping is a single column cut from the top of a page, running from the three-line headline to the jump line. `pub` is confirmed by the byline block, “Special to The New York Times”. The date is not printed, but the dateline reads “JERUSALEM, Oct. 22”, the day before the labelled date, and the story says the Madrid conference is “next week” (it opened 30 October 1991). Both are consistent with `date` (1991-10-23).

CP-1991-029 →

· The Island Packet · Hilton Head Island · page 6-A

Peace talks

Who will win? Who will lose? Don’t expect a quick answer

By PATRICK MARTIN, Toronto Globe and Mail

JERUSALEM — Talking peace is a risky business. When Anwar Sadat returned to Cairo after his historic 1977 visit to Jerusalem, the newspaper Al-Ahram welcomed the Egyptian president home with a banner headline that called him “peace-warrior.” “Thirty years of war were eliminated in 30 hours,” the paper wrote enthusiastically. But it didn’t quite turn out that way.

Although Egypt and Israel signed a bilateral peace treaty, the failure of the two countries to resolve the issue of a Palestinian homeland left most Arabs angry and denied Egypt its place as leader of the Arab world for years to come. Sadat’s visit was a gamble that, in most Arab eyes, failed.

Next week, it is Palestinians who will be taking the greatest risks, as they, Israel and its Arab neighbors sit down in Madrid for a historic conference to resolve one of the world’s most enduring conflicts.

And in language reminiscent of 1977, East Jerusalem’s Al Fajr newspaper has described the Palestine Liberation Organization’s decision to attend the talks as waging a “war of peace.”

While no one this time expects 43 years of war to be eliminated in 43 hours, hopes for the conference’s success are high — particularly since President Bush and Soviet President Mikhail Gorbachev have decided to convene the meeting personally. Indeed, Washington’s extraordinary commitment is the best thing the new Middle East peace process has going for it.

It may be the only thing, and it may not be enough. Arab and Israeli participants hold differing views about what is the most important subject for negotiation. For Israel, it is a settlement with neighbouring Arab states. For the Arabs, it is deciding the question of a Palestinian homeland.

The Palestinians’ willingness to live alongside Israel — and not in place of it — helped make these peace talks possible. It remains to be seen, however, whether Israel is prepared to meet even minimum Palestinian goals.

CP-1991-031 →

· Anchorage Daily News · Anchorage · page G6

Palestinian leader fears unreasonable expectations

By ETHAN BRONNER, Boston Globe

GAZA CITY, Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip — Since he accepted the responsibility of leading the Palestinian delegation to the Middle East peace conference in Madrid next week, Dr. Haider Abdel Shafi has been something of a haunted man. He is not worried about himself, despite threats to his life.

Rather, the 72-year-old Gazan physician, a man of self-deprecating sophistication and impeccable English, said Wednesday that his concerns are with the Palestinians in the occupied territories. Desperate for a new dawn, he says, they are building up unreasonable expectations for the Oct. 30 meeting. “I am haunted by this.

People have totally unjustified hopes that through this conference they will be able to have their children out of prison. This certainly is mortifying me,” he told five foreign journalists in his spacious but modest office of the Red Crescent Society, of which he is president. “Many people are looking at this conference as the salvation that they are waiting for.”

Abdel Shafi says he did not want to go to a peace conference. For weeks, he told those who asked that if chosen he would refuse. He would say: “I am an old man. I prefer to rest. This could be a very time-consuming and tedious matter,” he said.

But after Yasser Arafat, the Palestine Liberation Organization chief, appealed personally, Abdel Shafi said, he was left with no choice. “I was told I must not shirk this responsibility,” he said. Then, with the briefest of smiles, he added: “Really, I was cornered.”

Abdel Shafi’s thick, gray-and-white eyebrows moved up toward his bald pate, his shoulders hunched slightly and he gave a look that was at once game and world-weary.

Abdel Shafi believes firmly in coexistence with Israel — as he has since 1947 — and says his speech for the Palestinian delegation at the Madrid conference will concentrate not so much on grievances as on a vision for the future. “There is no way to establish peace except based on the value of coexistence,” he said.

Abdel Shafi plans to call for a freeze of Israeli settlements and says that if that is turned down, he will appeal to the U.S. and Soviet sponsors of the conference. If Israel accedes to the requested gesture, “the intifadah will stop,” he said, using the Arabic word for the uprising of the past four years.

A Gazan by birth whose family goes back about 500 years on this seaside strip, packed since 1948 with hundreds of thousands of refugees, Abdel Shafi has had a remarkable political career. Through years of tumultuous involvement with the Palestinian cause, he has skillfully avoided being pinned down. He has remained independent while gaining respect.

In 1947, when the United Nations voted to partition Palestine into one Jewish and one Arab state, the Zionists accepted it but the Arabs rejected it. Abdel Shafi was one of the rare Palestinians who urged acceptance.

“Palestinians were caught at the time in a strong and deep sense of grievance,” he said, seeking to explain the fateful rejection of partition that he feels led to so much more suffering. “People are surprised at how much anger that produces. Judgment is thwarted by anger. We should have accepted the partition plan. I was of that opinion then.

But I understand the strong drive within oneself not to accept it.” Abdel Shafi says he has always been a reluctant politician. “I have been drawn into politics against my inclination,” he said. “I am a doctor and a doctor sees the troubles of his people. You start to be moved by the suffering of those around you.”

CP-1991-032 →

· The New York Times · New York

Getting To ‘Yes’ In Madrid

By Roger Fisher

CAMBRIDGE, Mass. — While Secretary of State James Baker’s persistence may lead Israel and the Arabs to sit down together in Madrid, there is little basis for optimism. People virtually ignore questions of process as they focus on “what really counts” — substance: “I don’t care which road I take, as long as I get there.” But the road taken determines where we end up.

Until now, the parties have treated negotiations as pure bargainings that reward intransigence. The more extreme Israel’s position (“not one inch of territory for peace”) and the more stubbornly Israel resists making any concession, the greater chance it sees of retaining the occupied territories.

Palestinians, too, are under pressure to adopt extreme positions (“no recognition of Israel”). For Israel, direct negotiations are unlikely to produce an agreement with anyone — Palestinians, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon. Since a Palestinian peace is likely to be the heart of the matter, a key question arises: how to produce a plan that can be adapted later for others?

To design an effective process we need to understand two crucial points: Today, each side reasonably says no to what the other demands, and neither is able to put forward a realistic proposal of its own. The most basic Palestinian demand is for statehood.

As Israel asks itself, “Shall we now agree to a Palestinian state” the negative consequences of saying yes are overwhelming: we antagonize many constituents; we increase the risk of losing the West Bank; we create a potential threat to our security; we reward Palestinian violence; the Palestinians will ask for more.

To Israel, the consequences of saying no look attractive: the Government retains support among its public constituencies, maximizes the chance of keeping the West Bank, minimizes the risk of a hostile Palestinian state and keeps its options open. In saying no today, Israel acts reasonably from its viewpoint. It thus insists that the Palestinians give up the idea of a state.

For Palestinians, the reasons for saying no are compelling. Hence the deadlock.

CP-1991-033 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel’s Anxiety

One Goal Seems to Be to Avoid Blame For a Failure of Madrid Conference

By CLYDE HABERMAN, Special to The New York Times

JERUSALEM, Oct. 27 — The most cynical assessment is that Israel’s primary goal at the Madrid peace talks this week is to avoid having to absorb the blame should the conference fall apart. Across the political spectrum, many Israelis suspect that that is probably the most realistic view as well .

Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir certainly suggests that potential finger-pointing against his country looms large for him. “We have to take into consideration everything,” he acknowledged when the subject arose in an interview the other day.

More than any other event in recent years, save the Iraqi Scud missiles that fell on Israelis during the Persian Gulf War, the Middle East peace process has tapped Israel’s ample reservoir of anxiety about what comes next.

Those worries are especially keen on the political right, which includes not only the Shamir Government but also, if the experts are correct, an expanding segment of the Israeli electorate. These people see Madrid as a trap, an opportunity for Arabs and a United States Administration perceived as increasingly hostile to gang up on Israel and wrest territory from it.

The argument, expressed by Cabinet ministers and Parliament members close to Mr. Shamir, is that the true goal is to force Israel back to its pre-1967 borders. That means no West Bank, no Golan Heights, no Gaza Strip, no East Jerusalem and, from this viewpoint, no secure borders and no real peace. So the doubters say it is best for the country that the talks collapse.

If they had had their druthers, they would not have taken part in the first place, and the only question for them now is how to slip out of Madrid without getting pummeled later by the United States for being obstructionists.

“I am not enthusiastic about the Madrid conference,” Uzi Landau, a right-wing lawmaker who is one of the Israeli delegates, confessed on the state-owned radio over the weekend. Yoel Marcus, a columnist for the newspaper Haaretz, wrote dourly on Friday that “on the eve of the Madrid conference the Israeli public is divided into two groups: skeptics and pessimists.”

Spanish authorities continue to make preparations for the Middle East peace talks in Madrid. Civil Guard vehicles crowded the courtyard of the Royal Palace yesterday as officials secured the site of the talks. (Associated Press)

CP-1991-034 →

· estimated · Mennonite Weekly Review

Palestinian Villagers Honored

Christian Peacemaker Teams coordinator Gene Stoltzfus introduces the Harriet Hanson award, which the Chicago-based peace and justice agency Synapses recently gave to the unrecognized Palestinian villages in Israel.

Accepting the award on behalf of the villagers during Synapses’ 10th anniversary observance was Anna Mustapha, the only Arab member of the Chicago board of education. Synapses honored the Palestinian villages for their organized non-violent effort to survive and become recognized so they can receive such basic services as water, electricity and schools.

Stoltzfus and other CPT members met many of the villagers during a CPT visit to Israel in June. Stoltzfus is scheduled to present the award in person during a Synapses-sponsored visit to Israel and Palestine this month.

Date check: No masthead or date line is visible on this clipping — the scan is cropped to the photograph and its caption only, so the 1991-10-31 date could not be confirmed against the page.

CP-1991-025 →

· The New York Times · New York · page A18

Mideast Clashes Kill One Arab And Wound 35

But Backers of P.L.O. Stage a Peace March

By CLYDE HABERMAN, Special to The New York Times

JERUSALEM, Oct. 30 — The opening of the Madrid peace conference was greeted in the Middle East today with new bloodshed and calls for an Islamic holy war against Israel, but also with a rare peace march by supporters of the Palestine Liberation Organization.

One Palestinian youth was shot to death and at least 35 others were wounded in stone-throwing clashes with the Israeli Army in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. It was an uncommonly high casualty count even for people grown numb to the incessant mayhem produced by the four-year-old Palestinian uprising against Israeli occupation.

Still more unusual were violent battles that erupted, notably in Gaza City, between rival groups of Palestinians who disagree on whether their leaders should be attending the peace talks.

And perhaps more extraordinary yet was the pro-peace march by more than 2,000 Palestinians through the dusty streets of Gaza City, where many of them openly carried knives, clubs and chains, and waved Palestinian flags. Every aspect of this event — the weapons, the flags, the march itself — is banned by the Israeli Army, and normally would invite swift arrest.

Instead, dozens of Israeli soldiers followed the marchers, all supporters of the mainstream Fatah faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization, in a clear attempt to encourage the demonstration, at least this one time. Some of the Palestinians responded by handing the soldiers olive branches, still another action that is hardly routine.

Near a central square, the Fatah marchers ran into a group from the fundamentalist Islamic Resistance Movement, or Hamas, which had called a protest general strike today that closed shops and other businesses through most of Gaza and the West Bank.

The two sides clashed in a burst of knife-slashing, stone-throwing and window-smashing at a nearby mosque that sent four Hamas supporters to the hospital with stab wounds.

During a rare march by Palestine Liberation Organization supporters who favor the peace talks, a Palestinian youth in the West Bank held an olive branch and a pistol, signifying peace and armed struggle. (Associated Press)

CP-1991-035 →

· The Buffalo News · Buffalo

Israelis, Palestinians show how to manipulate press

By TOM HUNDLEY, Chicago Tribune

MADRID, Spain — The peace conference is high theater, and the actors are playing their parts before the audience of world opinion. Shortly after the Syrian foreign minister finished his speech Wednesday — a stinging attack on Israel — Israel’s Deputy Foreign Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was ready with his lines.

Taking the stage at the conference’s press center, Netanyahu launched a counterattack that reached its dramatic climax when he dug into his breast pocket and produced a copy of the PLO covenent, a document that calls for the destruction of Israel.

Waving the paper before the TV cameras, his voice choked with emotion, he called on Israel’s enemies to “tear up the paper of hate and sign the paper of peace.” For years, Netanyahu, a marquee-handsome former paratrooper, has been one of the masters of this stage.

Known in Israel simply as Bibi, he is the darling of hard-liners both at home and in the American Jewish community. It was no surprise when Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir made him the spokesman for Israel’s delegation. But in Madrid, the Palestinians have come up with a leading lady who can hold her own.

To the chagrin of the Israelis, Hanan Ashrawi, a telegenic university professor and mother of two, has replaced Yasser Arafat as the voice and image of the Palestinian cause. In sharp contrast with Arafat, whose trademark is the peasant kaffiyah draped over his head, the three-day stubble on his chin and his ever-present revolver, Mrs.

Ashrawi comes packaged in smart business suits and sensible shoes. Her English is flawless, her demeanor cool and analytical. Unlike the aggressive and hard-edged Netanyahu, whose specialty is putting the Arabs on the defensive, Mrs. Ashrawi scores points by appearing open and reasonable.

CP-1991-036 →

· The New York Times · New York

For Palestinians, a Seat At the Table Is a Victory

By Youssef M. Ibrahim

NADRID, Oct. 31 — Just before the international peace conference on the Middle East began here on Wednesday, Sameh Kanaan, a member of the Palestinian delegation who spent more than 10 years in Israeli jails, asked a friend to take his picture in the conference hall from an angle that shows him in the same frame with the Israeli Prime Minister, Yitzhak Shamir.

“He told me, ‘Please record that I have sat face to face with him around that table as a free man, because the only time I have been with Israelis is when they were my jailers or came to arrest me,’” said the friend, Daoud Kutab, a Palestinian who came to observe what he and most Palestinians here unreservedly describe as a historic event.

Palestinians have spoken of this conference as a crowning event at the end of years of struggle to be recognized as a people.

‘The Foundation Stone’ When a phalanx of Spanish Army troops escorts their representatives out of the Victoria Hotel or into the Hall of Columns of Madrid’s Royal Palace, when Western reporters and television crews flock to record their words, and when they are photographed with Secretary of State James A.

Baker 3d, many Palestinians here agree they almost have to pinch themselves to remember where they came from. “We have come a long way from the days when Golda Meir used to say, ‘Who are the Palestinians?’” said Sami Kilani, a member of the Palestinian negotiating team, in a reference to the late Israeli Prime Minister.

“Today I feel that by being here, in Madrid, we have placed the foundation stone for the Palestinian state.” Never mind that many of the participants here do not expect anything that resembles a Palestinian state for years to come. The sentiment here is of ecstasy and triumph.

The conference, many say, is a bigger-than-life experience that has already changed them and changed the way the world looks at them. An Irrevocable Change “When I packed my luggage to come here, I knew that no matter what happens here I will not be the same man again.

None of us will,” said Saeb Erakat, a professor at Bir Zeit University in the Israeli-occupied West Bank who is a member of the Palestinian team attending the talks.

A noticeable byproduct of the conference has been the emergence of new faces and leaders among the Palestinians, including Faisal al-Husseini and Hanan Ashrawi, who spoke with reporters yesterday.

CP-1991-037 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore

Palestinian spokeswoman shines amid glare of Madrid conference

wi, a university professor of English from the West Bank, was their brightest star. Mrs. Ashrawi emerged as the Palestinians’ most polished voice and, at times, their most skillful diplomat. Some admiring Israelis liken her to two famous leaders of their own.

In her public warmth, she is compared to former Prime Minister Golda Meir, Israel’s motherly prime minister in the early 1970s. For her debating skills, she is compared to Abba Eban, who was his country’s most articulate diplomat. Members of Israel’s government have been less complimentary.

After Palestinian gunmen shot and killed two Jewish settlers last week, Defense Minister Moshe Arens blamed Mrs. Ashrawi. Citing statements by her that violence would increase during the peace talks, Mr. Arens declared the attackers “were acting on her directives.” Mrs.

Ashrawi was one of the most frequently quoted people at the Madrid conference without even being a member of an official delegation. She arrived as part of a 15-member advisory team, a group organized to get around Israel’s ground rules for the regular delegation.

Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir ruled out conducting formal talks with Palestinians from East Jerusalem or with anyone considered to have close ties to the Palestine Liberation Organization. Mrs. Ashrawi was excluded on both counts. She lives in Ramallah, a West Bank city, in a stone house not far from the local headquarters of the Israeli military government.

Her Israeli-issued identification card lists her official place of residence as East Jerusalem. In her politics, she is identified less as a moderate or a radical than as a pragmatist. She makes no secret of her loyalty to the PLO or of her belief that the organization erred by being inflexible in the past. She also says Mr.

Shamir’s government is making a mistake by not talking directly with people such as her. “We are not ashamed of the PLO,” she said before going to Madrid. “We are very proud of it. If the Israelis close their eyes to reality, it doesn’t mean the reality will disappear.”

HANAN ASHRAWI Palestinian spokeswoman

CP-1991-038 →

· The Post-Standard · Syracuse

Palestinians Boost Image at Negotiations

Many participants in the talks view the Palestinians’ new presentation as a successful public relations coup.

MADRID, Spain (AP) — Palestinian negotiators presented a realistic and moderate case at the Middle East peace conference that gave their beleaguered people more status than ever before on the international diplomatic stage.

The composition of the Palestinian delegation — and its conciliatory statements at the conference — contributed to what many participants described as a public-relations coup. “I have to tell you that I think that a lot of what the Palestinian representatives had to say at the conference was well received in many places around the world,” U.S.

Secretary of State James A. Baker III said at news conference Sunday. The Palestinian team included U.S.-educated university lecturers, political scientists, businessmen and former prisoners — in sharp contrast with the Palestinians’ terrorist image of the 1970s.

In Western dress, they sat opposite the Israelis, although part of a joint delegation with the Jordanians, at Israel’s insistence. Just before the conference opened Wednesday, members of the Palestinian delegation were granted a meeting with President Bush.

Tahseen Beshir, former Egyptian government spokesman and political analyst, said the Palestinians “have managed to give a human face to the Arab position, refuting the Israeli extremism of Shamir without being caught in the trap (Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak) Shamir put them to engage them with the past instead of facing the future. They were very successful.”

A speech by Dr. Haidar Abdul-Shafi, a physician from the occupied Gaza Strip, dropped demands for immediate statehood and said Palestinians would agree to a transitional period of self-rule. He urged Israelis to agree to live side-by-side with a Palestinian state they hope to establish in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Although a Palestinian state remains a dream, the delegates apparently managed to establish their plight as the core of the Middle East conflict.

Palestinian spokeswoman Hanan Ashrawi, in a final news briefing to reporters, thanked the media Sunday for “relaying our narrative to the rest of the world and for allowing us to speak out for ourselves, actually, for the first time in our history.” Earlier, a member of the Palestinian negotiating team made a similar remark in an interview.

“We told our story. No people in this century were as misinformed about and discriminated against as the Palestinians,” said Saeb Erekat, a Palestinian delegate.

“After all these years of trying to undermine us, trying to discredit us, trying to make us look the unwanted of the earth, we were able to face Shamir face-to-face and tell him, ‘You have failed’,” Erekat said. But Israel also allowed the Palestinians some latitude in an effort to keep the conference from collapsing.

CP-1991-014 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago · page 4

At Madrid conference, Palestinians seized the day

By Tom Hundley

MADRID—For years Israeli politicians have been dining on senior statesman Abba Eban’s famous line: “The Palestinians have never missed an opportunity to miss an opportunity.” But in Madrid last week it was the Palestinians who finally seized the opportunity, and the Israelis and Syrians who let it slip through their fingers.

While the Israeli and Syrian delegations—trading recriminations to the bitter end—quickly slipped out of town within hours of U.S. Secretary of State James A. Baker III’s departure early Monday, the Palestinians seemed to want to linger a bit, to savor their successes in Madrid.

One key decision made by the delegation was to buck Syria’s wishes and quickly agree to enter the bilateral phase with Israel.

Despite the bad blood between the Israelis and Syrians, and despite the inability of Israel or any of its Arab adversaries to reach agreement on the seemingly simple question of where to hold the next round of talks, it appears the peace process still is breathing.

Baker said the next step will be up to the participants, but it is clear the next step will have to be Baker’s—to break the deadlock on the question of venue. The Israelis want the talks to be held in the Middle East, alternating between Arab and Israeli cities. The Arabs say the talks should be held at a neutral site.

A possible compromise choice mentioned by both sides is Washington. For Palestinians, however, that debate receded to the background Monday as they tried to focus on the meaning of what they had accomplished in Madrid.

In little more than a week, the Palestinians had assembled a new political and diplomatic infrastructure from scratch, formulated a new political agenda and reincarnated themselves as the good guys on the stage of world opinion.

Nabil Shaath (left), senior adviser to PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat, and PLO spokesman Ahmad Abdul Rahman tell reporters Monday in Madrid that the PLO approves of the results of the Mideast talks.

CP-1991-039 →

· Stamford Advocate · Stamford

Israelis, Palestinians applaud peace talks

By Ruth Sinai

MADRID, Spain — They have met before, Israelis and Palestinians. But often there was a rifle, a roadblock or a detention order between them. In Spain, they met as equals. And the result was surprising. They told jokes. They talked about their families. They drank coffee and ate cake during a break.

Both invoked God’s will: the Arabs said “Inshallah,” the Israelis “Im Yirtzeh Hashem.” It wasn’t all sweetness and light. The Palestinians demanded that Israel stop building settlements in the occupied West Bank. The Israelis demanded that the Palestinians cease their violent four-year-old uprising. They couldn’t agree on a site for future talks.

But they did agree to talk again — soon. “It’s gotten off to a better start than I would have expected,” said Secretary of State James A. Baker III, the architect of the talks. The goal is to allow the 1.7 million Palestinians under Israeli rule to run their own lives — to elect leaders with genuine powers, freely administer their city halls — for an interim period.

During the third year of that period, talks would begin to negotiate the permanent fate of the territory. The arrangement, while not ideal, suits both sides for the time being.

It reflects the broad changes in the regional balance of power: the decline of the Soviet Union, which was the Arabs’ main backer, the resulting growth in U.S. influence and American willingness to twist the arm of its closest ally in the region — Israel.

Although the self-rule proposal doesn’t promise Palestinians the independent land they want, it does envisage an end the interference of the Israeli military in their daily lives and holds out the hope of a permanent solution to their 43-year problem.

Israel hopes that agreement with the Palestinians will snuff out the intefadeh, or uprising, which has been tying up large numbers of security forces and distracting resources from the country’s top priority — the absorption of hundreds of thousands of Soviet Jews.

Syrian Foreign Minister Farouk al-Sharaa waves to reporters as he is escorted to his plane by Spain’s Foreign Minister Francisco Fernandez Ordonez yesterday in Madrid, Spain.

CP-1991-040 →

· The New York Times · New York · page A17

Gaza Voting Favors Arab Moderates

By Clyde Haberman

JERUSALEM, Nov. 5 — Results from a local election in the Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip suggested today that Palestinians have begun to swing away from hard-line Islamic fundamentalists to favor relative moderates who support the Middle East peace process.

Voting on Monday for the regional Chamber of Commerce, the first election of its kind in Gaza since 1964, ended with mainstream supporters of the Palestine Liberation Organization winning a surprising 13 of the 16 seats at stake. The fundamentalist Islamic Resistance Movement, or Hamas, captured only two seats, while an independent candidate won the remaining one.

Elections have only recently begun to be held in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank after 24 years of Israeli occupation, and so they may be imperfect guides, at best, to the popular mood. Nevertheless, the results made public today were widely interpreted as a pro-peace message from the streets.

The triumphant mainstream Fatah faction of the P.L.O. firmly supported the conference that just ended in Madrid while Hamas, which had been presumed to be growing fast in Gaza, joined two Marxist P.L.O. factions in bitterly opposing Palestinian participation in the talks.

‘A Real Shock’ A Hamas leader and a losing candidate in Gaza City, Ibrahim al-Yazouri, acknowledged that the outcome was “a real shock.” Aoni Hasham, a furniture store owner in Gaza City, was one of many merchants who said he had rejected Hamas principally because “it did not offer an alternative to the peace process.”

Crowded, poor and desperate Gaza has been torn to a greater degree than the West Bank by the P.L.O. decision to endorse the Madrid conference. Hamas calls the peace process a sellout of the Palestinian dream of an independent state, while Fatah argues that it is time to become more practical and to settle for attainable goals.

In that sense, the election results “are a message from the Palestinian streets to the peace conference,” said Mohammed al-Kitwah, one of the 13 victorious Fatah candidates.

A Palestinian being searched by Israeli border police officers on patrol yesterday in Jerusalem.

CP-1991-041 →

· HUNTSVILLE NEWS · page A-5

Israeli army bans Palestinian peace demonstrations

By SERGEI SHARGORODSKY

(Editor’s note: This article was submitted to Israeli military censors, who ordered a deletion.) JERUSALEM — The Israeli army announced Tuesday that Palestinian peace demonstrations in the occupied territories will not be permitted because they could escalate into violent confrontations. “We are not allowing any demonstrations,” Chief of Staff Lt. Gen.

Ehud Barak declared on a tour of the West Bank. “Many demonstrations starting with olive branches ... quickly become very violent.” Palestinians in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and the Gaza Strip have organized dozens of peace demonstrations since the Mideast peace talks opened last week in Madrid, Spain.

Participants have sometimes clashed with Israeli troops or members of Muslim fundamentalist and radical Palestinian groups opposing the talks. In comments over army radio, Barak said commanders in the field have been instructed to use sound judgement and not necessarily employ force while dispersing nonviolent demonstrations.

On Tuesday, soldiers dispersed a demonstration by about 600 Arabs who were waving olive branches and chanting slogans in the West Bank town of Tulkarem. In theory, Palestinians would still be allowed to ask for a permit to demonstrate, but Barak said the chances of one being granted were slim.

The fundamentalist movement Hamas, or Zeal, issued another leaflet Tuesday vowing to kill Palestinian supporters of the peace talks with Israel. “We warn away those bargaining away Palestine that he who will approve the confiscation of Palestine and Jerusalem will not pass without a punishment,” the leaflets said.

The Palestinian negotiators are seeking limited autonomy as a first step toward self-rule in their talks with Israel, which captured the West Bank and Gaza, home to 1.7 million Palestinians, in the 1967 Six Day War. The Palestinian uprising that began in 1987 has claimed more than a thousands lives.

The number of Palestinians killed by Israelis in the uprising rose to 867 with the death Tuesday of Mahdi Abu Hassan, a 22-year-old Arab armed with a submachine gun who tried to fire on troops who seized him, Israeli sources said. At least 464 Palestinians have been slain by other Arabs as suspected collaborators with Israel.

CP-1991-058 →

· Houston Chronicle · Houston · page 29A

Palestinians seek to break link to violence, show peace image

By Susan Warren

JERUSALEM — After being linked with violence for decades, Palestinians are nurturing a new image based on the gentle message of the olive branch. The Madrid peace conference, where the grandfatherly Haidar Abdel Shafi stood at the podium and delivered an eloquent recital of his delegation’s national cause, was the first step in the Palestinians’ image make-over.

“In some ways, we succeeded in changing the Palestinian stereotype,” said Ziad Abu Zayad, an adviser to the Palestinian delegation at the conference. “This was an opportunity for us to show the whole world our real face and our real intentions, and to try to stand firm against the propaganda that misrepresents us.”

But leaving behind their reputations as terrorists won’t be as easy as swishing an olive branch through the air. While the Palestinians may be anxious to forge a new name for themselves in the world, Israel is equally anxious to keep the Palestinians firmly zipped into their old wolf’s clothing.

Zayad acknowledges that the Palestinians, led by the Palestine Liberation Organization, have made mistakes in the past by using violence to grab the world’s attention. “They were old mistakes that were used against us, that were used by the other side to destroy the image of the Palestinian people,” he said. “I hope that such mistakes will not be repeated.”

But even as the Palestinians at the peace conference were garnering praise for their new cooperation in the peace process, Israeli officials were accusing them of inciting violence and sponsoring terrorism. Israeli police, who remain suspicious of any Palestinian gathering that smacks of nationalist overtones, broke up several Palestinian peace demonstrations during the Oct.

30-Nov. 1 Madrid conference. Even though the rallies celebrated peace, they could have easily dissolved into violence, a police official said. Not all the Palestinians in and outside the occupied territories approve of the peace negotiations, and many have promised to use violence to stop them.

On her way to Madrid, the Palestinians’ popular spokeswoman, Hanan Ashrawi, had predicted that a rise in nationalist fervor would likely cause an escalation in the intifada, the Palestinian revolt against the Israeli occupation.

Israeli government officials used that comment to blame Ashrawi when a bus carrying Jewish settlers was sprayed with automatic gunfire on its way to Tel Aviv, killing two Israelis, two days before the Madrid conference began. “The role of spokeswoman does not conform with instigating violence,” said Yossi Olmert, director of the Israeli Government Press Office.

Ashrawi

CP-1991-042 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinian Negotiator May Face Israel Charge

By CLYDE HABERMAN

JERUSALEM, Nov. 15 — The Israeli police recommended today that Hanan Ashrawi, the main voice of the Palestinians at the recent Middle East peace talks held in Madrid, be brought to trial for supposedly having met with officials of the Palestine Liberation Organization. Mrs.

Ashrawi, who rose to international prominence at the Madrid conference, denounced the action as “vindictive and petty,” and Jordan’s Foreign Minister, Kamel Abu Jaber, asked the United States and the Soviet Union to protect her from prosecution. It was far from clear that the Israeli Attorney General would in fact pursue an indictment against Mrs.

Ashrawi, a university professor who lives in the West Bank town of Ramallah, six miles north of Jerusalem. A Justice Ministry spokesman said only that prosecutors would study the police file, a procedure that could take weeks.

Liberal and left-wing critics of the Government said, however, that the case had already threatened to give Israel a public-relations black eye at a delicate moment, as it prepares to resume peace negotiations with its immediate Arab neighbors, including a joint Jordanian-Palestinian delegation. Mrs.

Ashrawi, in an interview at her Ramallah home on Thursday night, said that she, too, doubted that the Israeli authorities would press criminal charges against her at this delicate juncture. After the police action became known today, she said in a telephone conversation that she wanted to “wait and see” what the Justice Ministry would do.

But she added, “I refuse to be intimidated, and I refuse to be silenced.” At issue is a five-year-old statute banning contacts with the P.L.O., which is viewed by Palestinians as the agent of their national aspirations but is regarded by Israel as a terrorist group committed to this country’s destruction.

Early last month, Israel’s best-known peace campaigner, Abie Nathan, received a prison sentence of a year and a half for having defied the law by meeting with the P.L.O. chairman, Yasir Arafat. Two days later, Mrs.

Ashrawi and another Palestinian leader here, Faisal al-Husseini, were called in for police questioning on charges that they had met the P.L.O. leadership in Algiers. The Palestine National Council, which is the Palestinian legislature, convened in September in Algiers, where it endorsed the peace process, as Mr. Husseini and Mrs. Ashrawi had been urging.

Delegates told journalists that the two had appeared before the council to plead their case, but they both denied the reports, saying they were in London at the time. The police said there was not enough evidence to sustain criminal charges against Mr. Husseini, but, without elaborating, they said that Mrs. Ashrawi was another matter.

The Israeli radio reported that investigators were relying on an interview with Jordan Television in which she purportedly acknowledged having met P.L.O. officials.

Hanan Ashrawi, the main voice of the Palestinians at the Middle East peace talks, doubted that Israel would press criminal charges against her. (Reuters)

CP-1991-043 →

· The Blade · Toledo · page SECTION F., PAGE 3

The gain in Spain is mainly to the Palestinians

BY GARY LAKES

NICOSIA — Members of the Palestinian delegation to the Madrid peace conference returned to the Israeli-occupied West Bank to a tumultuous welcome. Thousands of Palestinians gathered near the town of Jericho to greet the delegates as they made their way from the Allenby bridge to Jerusalem.

It is said of the Palestinians that they never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity. But all that changed in Madrid. The Palestinian moderates comprising the delegation abandoned the traditional maxmalist demand for an independent Palestinian state in favor of a gradualist approach. In so doing they clearly came out ahead.

For the first time in their history — and to the chagrin of the Israelis — the Palestinians were portrayed as an independent people with legitimate claims, not terrorists but equal partners in a long-overdue process designed to produce a peaceful settlement to a 42-year-old conflict.

For the Palestinians, the Madrid conference was a success because they decided to get on and stay on the bus that Secretary of State James Baker had warned was coming around for the last time. By the end of the three-day conference and the first bilateral meeting with an Israeli delegation, the Palestinians had succinctly put forward their argument for a national homeland.

THE RESULT of the Madrid conference gave rise to a new sense of euphoria and optimism among residents of the West Bank and Gaza Strip who have taken to holding peace marches during which they offer olive branches and flowers to occupying Israeli soldiers, rather than pelting them with rocks and firebombs.

There has even been talk among Palestinians of stopping the intifada — the uprising that began in December, 1987 — if Israel agrees to ease its repressive measures in the occupied territories.

The meeting in Madrid has also brought more political cohesion to the Palestinians in the occupied territories where opinion was beginning to splinter following the Palestine Liberation Organization’s mistaken support for Saddam Hussein during the Gulf war and ugly incidents born of the intifada, which was degenerating into Palestinian gangs murdering Palestinians accused of being Israeli informers.

Support for the talks and the PLO was vividly displayed in the outcome of a Chamber of Commerce election in Gaza Nov. 4. Supporters of Yasser Arafat, PLO chairman, won a surprise victory over the radical Islamic fundamentalist group Hamas, which was thought to have a strong following in the Gaza Strip. Hamas won only three seats in the chamber, while supporters of Mr.

Arafat’s Fatah group won 13. DURING A recent press conference in Jerusalem, Faisal al-Husseini and Hanan Ashrawi, the main architects of the Palestinian position in Madrid, said that Palestinian teams from inside the occupied territories and the diaspora were drawing up plans for the transfer of authority from the Israeli authorities. This is somewhat premature.

The Government of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir has tried to squelch the new buoyance among the Palestinians. The United States and Soviet Union, co-sponsors of the conference, awarded the Palestinians diplomatic protection, a move that displeases the Israeli Government. YOSSI AHNIMEIR, a spokesman for Mr.

Shamir, said of the Palestinian delegation’s joyous return that they have “apparently returned with exaggerated self-confidence and think they are permitted to do anything and act like the leaders of an independent state. They should get back down to earth and take a more realistic view of things.”

CP-1991-044 →

· The Herald-Times · Bloomington · page 1

‘Tired’ arguments

To the editor

Ramsay Harik

“At a time when bold new Mideast peace talks offer Palestinians the first (albeit muffled) voice that they have ever been allowed in discussions of their own bleak future, it is disappointing to find ‘Israel right or wrong’ zealots such as Martin Spechler and Hans Tischler trotting out the same old tired ‘mis-truths’ used to legitimate the silencing and oppression of the Palestinians for over 40 years.

Three of the more glaring of these demand a quick correction. Palestinians are not simply generic Arabs who can or want to be absorbed into Jordan, and Jordan has no more reason or capacity to adopt the Palestinians than France would to adopt millions of Spaniards suddenly evicted from their homeland.

Secondly, even the dullest student of logic can see that the wrongs of certain undemocratic regimes in the area do not justify what Israel has done to the Palestinians (and, for that matter, to the Lebanese)… And finally, yes, the U.S. does have a grave responsibility in dragging Israel to the negotiating table: had the U.S. insisted from the start on Israeli decency as a pre-requisite for our annual billions of aid dollars, Israel would long ago have had to behave like one nation among many rather than a nuclear-backed law unto itself.

Far too many ‘friends of Israel’ have likewise surrounded themselves with a comfortable ‘fortress of the mind’ of rationalizations and distorted history to justify Israel’s exemption from international standards of conduct.

One would hope that now, 50 years after the holocaust, they could acknowledge that while the victimization of the Jews does accord them special status in the eyes of the world, it does not bestow the right to inflict the same on others.”

A reader answering two named correspondents in the same paper, at the opening of the Madrid talks.

CP-1991-006 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel’s Coffee Spoons

Talking about openings for peace in the Middle East, Israelis like to recall Abba Eban’s tart remark about the Palestinians: They never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity. At this pregnant moment, it’s Israel that risks falling into the opportunity gap.

For 43 years, Israel has wanted nothing more than face-to-face negotiations with its several Arab neighbors — neighbors that except for Egypt would not deign even to acknowledge Israel’s existence. Courtesy of the Bush Administration, Israel now has that opportunity. Last month’s Madrid conference opened the way for negotiations, in circumstances agreeable to Israel.

Does Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir’s Government now seize on this monumental opportunity with imagination, energy and even daring? On the contrary; it measures out its grudging responses in coffee spoons. Mr. Shamir seems capable of no more than angry procedural gestures to show that he won’t be pushed around.

Israel’s friends wonder sadly whether it truly sees the opportunity for peace by coming to the table, or wishes to dither endlessly about its shape. Mr. Shamir has reason to be offended. To a list of perceived slights from the Bush Administration he can now add the way he was treated on his recent visit to Washington.

For the Administration to issue invitations to a new round of peace talks in Washington without telling him offended all Israelis. Even so, the Bush Administration’s behavior surely seems more clumsy than calculated. It could hardly expect to remain an honest broker by antagonizing the principal party to talks.

The important issue in any case is not Israeli pride but Israeli perspective. By going on now to Chapter 3 of the peace talks, Israel can act, momentously, in its own long-term interest. Chapter 1 embraced the agreement of Arabs to meet with Israel at all, in Madrid. Chapter 2 covered the meeting itself, leading to fragile expressions of willingness to continue the process.

There’s no haste in the American invitation to meet in Washington on Dec. 4; that’s almost a month after Madrid. Mr. Shamir is posturing by now insisting on Dec. 9. The U.S. has, further, offered broad ideas for how Israelis and Arabs might loosen some of the negotiation knots — a welcome progression from procedure to substance.

The recent rough spots in personal relations notwithstanding, the Administration deserves Israeli respect for the content of its policies. It’s a rare opportunity to ease the Middle East’s cruel history, the first such opening since the dazzling day in 1977 when Anwar el-Sadat held out his hand to Israel.

A bold, substantive initiative from Israel now might also win the widest attention and support, and for the same reason. Peace is worth risks.

CP-1991-045 →

· The New York Times

Another West Bank Settlement Starts

By CLYDE HABERMAN

JERUSALEM, Dec. 3 — On the eve of the scheduled resumption of Middle East peace talks, the Israeli Government took steps today toward starting a new settlement on the site where snipers killed two Jews recently in the occupied West Bank.

Soldiers from the army’s Nahal unit moved into mobile homes that Israeli settlers had put overnight at Kefar Tappuah, 25 miles north of Jerusalem. Just before the start of the first peace conference in Madrid on Oct. 30, unidentified gunmen fired on a busload of settlers at an intersection near that town, killing two adults and wounding half a dozen children.

A small group of angry settlers quickly pitched tents, and they have since occupied the site, invoking what they call a Zionist imperative to establish new communities wherever Jewish blood is shed. By moving Nahal soldiers there, the Government is now suggesting that that will become a permanent civilian settlement.

That has been the normal pattern, and even though Defense Minister Moshe Arens said the purpose of the latest action was to “guarantee security in the area,” he acknowledged that a new full-time community was likely.

The Government move came two days after another ambush attack, in which a Jewish settler, Zvi Klein, was fatally shot while driving through the town of el-Bira, six miles north of Jerusalem. Israeli radio said that settlers might try to set up yet another community not far from where Mr. Klein was shot.

For his part, Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir, who is committed to building such communities in the face of Arab demands that they stop, declared today that “these murderous acts will not deter us from founding, expanding and establishing settlements.” “We will have the upper hand,” he told the state-run radio. “The Land of Israel is ours.”

Left-of-center opposition parties denounced the army move, and warned that it could undermine the peace process, which has already been unsettled by Israel’s refusal to show up in Washington Wednesday for the scheduled restart of negotiations with Palestinians and Arab countries.

But it was not clear how much of an effect the formal start of the new community, called Rachelim, would have, even though a settlement freeze is a Palestinian priority, one that the United States endorses. As the Madrid talks ended on Nov.

4, the Israeli Government inaugurated a new settlement for Soviet immigrants on the Golan Heights, territory that Israel had annexed but that Syria wants back. That action was swiftly condemned by Secretary of State James A. Baker 3d as not helpful to the peace talks.

But in this case, there is an emotional component in that the settlement marks the spot where civilians were gunned down. That might make a difference in how Washington and the Arabs react, some Israeli commentators said.

Members of Arab delegations arriving yesterday at Dulles Airport near Washington for peace talks with Israel. From left were Hanan Ashrawi, a Palestinian spokeswoman; Haidar Abdel-Shafi, head of the Palestinian delegation; and Abdel Salam Majali, leader of the Jordanian negotiators.

CP-1991-056 →

· Houston Chronicle · Houston

Palestinians honor dead on Martyr Street

Susan Warren, Jabalia Refugee Camp, Occupied Gaza Strip

“A small metal sign nailed high on a post marks the rutted, unpaved road as the Street of the Martyr… Hatem was the first to die in the Palestinian uprising… Hatem’s family still lives in the same four rooms along the Street of the Martyr, named after the dead teen… ‘If there is peace, the olive branch will be raised for the Palestinian state.

But if there is no peace, the olive branch will be put in the pocket, and we will continue to carry the stone.’”

The same family as the Morning News clipping of December 1987, four years on, in a different paper — and it supplies what the first story could not: that Hatem Abu Sisi was the first person killed in the First Intifada, and that the street his family lives on is named for him.

CP-1991-013 →

· The New York Times · New York · page A14

Israeli View of Talks With the Arabs From a Lonely Hill on the West Bank

By Clyde Haberman

KEFAR TAPPUAH, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, Dec. 9 — What passes for the budding settlement of Rachelim is nothing more than three battered trailers and a few portable latrines, plunked down willy-nilly on a wind-raked hill two miles south of this town. Most people looking at it probably would not find much there worth fighting about.

But Rachelim (unofficial population: 15) has become the most recent battleground in the long-running struggle over the Israeli Government’s insistence on its right to build Jewish settlements on Arab lands occupied since 1967.

When Middle East peace talks get under way in Washington on Tuesday, assuming no last-minute hitch, the Palestinian delegation is likely to lose little time before denouncing Israeli settlement activity and demanding that it end immediately.

And Rachelim, not yet a full settlement but given an official start last week, could well be mentioned by name, which would suit Yael Ben-Yaakov just fine because she has no intention of leaving. Yes, world opinion may be against her, she acknowledges, and perhaps a majority in Israel as well. But she can live with that, she says.

“We get the sympathy of the world,” Mrs. Ben-Yaakov said inside one of the trailers today, “only when we are beaten, only after the Holocaust, only during the gulf war, when the TV showed the missiles falling on Tel Aviv and Ramat Gan.

Now, that’s over, and we’re the price that Bush wants to pay the Arabs for their participation in the gulf war.” “We need the land; we can’t give it up,” said Shulamit Livyatan, another settler. “I don’t believe giving up land will bring peace. The Arabs just want us out. They want us to go to Europe, go to Africa, go to America.

They have thousands of kilometers in Egypt, in Jordan, Iraq, Kuwait, Morocco. We have just this. This is our place. This is our land.”

The settlement of Rachelim, with an unofficial population of 15, is nothing more than three trailers and a few portable latrines put down on a hill. Yet, it has become the most recent battleground in the long-running struggle over the Israeli Government’s insistence on its right to settle on Arab lands. (Associated Press)

Date check: the masthead reads A14 / THE NEW YORK TIMES INTERNATIONAL / TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 1991 — matches the slide date

CP-1991-030 →

· Des Moines Register · Des Moines · page 1

U.N. General Assembly overturns 1975 Zionism-is-racism resolution

Israel scores a victory as Arabs say the 111-25 vote would hurt the peace talks

Associated Press, United Nations

“The United Nations on Monday voted 111-25 to repeal the 1975 resolution equating Zionism with racism.

Thirteen members abstained and 17 did not take part. In favor of the repeal: Albania, Antigua-Barbuda, Argentina, Australia, Austria, Bahamas, Barbados, Belarus, Belgium… India, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Jamaica, Japan, Kenya… Ukraine, U.S.S.R, United Kingdom, United States, Uruguay, Venezuela, Yugoslavia, Zaire, Zambia.

Against repeal: Afghanistan, Algeria, Bangladesh, Brunei, Cuba, Democratic People’s Republic of Korea, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, Libya, Malaysia, Mali, Mauritania, Pakistan, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, Sri Lanka, Sudan, Syria, United Arab Emirates, Vietnam, Yemen.

Abstaining: Angola, Burkina Faso, Ethiopia, Ghana, Laos, Maldives, Mauritius, Myanmar (Burma), Trinidad and Tobago, Turkey, Uganda, Tanzania, Zimbabwe.

Absent from the vote: Bahrain, Chad, China, Comoros, Djibouti, Egypt, Equitorial Guinea, Guinea, Guinea Bissau, Kuwait, Morocco, Niger, Oman, Senegal, South Africa, Tunisia, Vanuatu.… Arab moderates did not participate. That was seen as an effort not to antagonize the United States, which pressured them to support the measure.

Non-participation is considered a weaker statement than abstention.”

The only printing here that runs the whole roll call, every country in all four columns. Read it against the interviews a New York Times correspondent did in 1980 and three names change meaning. Sri Lanka introduced the original resolution and its delegate had said he never worked out what it meant; in 1991 Sri Lanka voted against repealing it. Nigeria, which had called the formula a good abstraction, voted for repeal. Tunisia, which had wanted it kept as a negotiating asset, did not vote. The page also carries a mission appeal: thirteen dollars and ninety cents will feed ten hungry people.

CP-1991-010 →

· Florence Morning News · page 1

U.N. takes back 1975 Zionism-racism resolution

The Associated Press, United Nations

“The General Assembly on Monday rescinded its 1975 resolution equating Zionism with racism by a 111-25 vote… The 25 negative votes mostly came from Arab and Islamic states, but Arab moderates, including Bahrain, Kuwait, Morocco, Oman, Tunisia and Egypt — the only Arab nation to make peace with Israel — did not participate. Voting against were Algeria, Bangladesh, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, Libya, Malaysia, Pakistan, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Syria, United Arab Emirates and Yemen… David Levy: ‘The international community has transmitted a loud and clear message that all expressions of hatred and intolerance are unacceptable to the enlightened nations’… Abdalla al-Ashtal of Yemen: ‘We hope that this will not be another sign for the Israelis to do more of the same.’”

Israeli Foreign Minister David Levy, left, embraces Israel’s United Nations ambassador Yoram Aridor after the U.N. General Assembly voted Monday to repeal its 1975 resolution equating Zionism with racism.

The same dispatch in South Carolina, with a different photograph and two extra sentences: one more line from the Israeli foreign minister and one more from the Yemeni ambassador. It shares the page with an advertisement for hashed pork barbecue with cole slaw at a dollar ten.

CP-1991-011 →

· Herald Statesman · page 1

U.N.: Zionism no longer racism

Vote repeals ’75 resolution against Israel

The Associated Press, United Nations

UNITED NATIONS — The General Assembly yesterday rescinded its 1975 resolution equating Zionism with racism by a 111-25 vote, giving a major boost to Israel’s global stature as it pursues peace talks with its Arab neighbors. It was only the second time that the assembly had overturned one of its own resolutions.

There were 13 abstentions, and 17 members of the assembly didn’t participate in the vote. All former Soviet Bloc countries and many Third World states voted yesterday to overturn the Zionism-is-racism resolution, a reflection of how the collapse of Communism has altered the Mideast equation. In 1975, only 35 nations ventured to oppose the measure.

Deputy Secretary of State Lawrence S. Eagleburger, who introduced the resolution, told the assembly, “It is more than time to consign one of the last relics of the Cold War to the dustbin of history.”

Israeli Foreign Minister David Levy called the vote “the victory of morality over injustice, truth over falsehood and courage over cowardice”… At the United Nations, Arab opponents of repeal said it would impede peace efforts, inflame extremists on both sides and justify what they said were discriminatory laws against Palestinians in Israel and the territories.

“This resolution is like saying everything is OK,” said Abdalla al-Ashtal, Yemen’s U.N. ambassador and the Arab representative on the Security Council.… Zionism is the ideology of reconstituting the Jewish nation in its biblical homeland.

Arabs said that since Zionism calls only for Jews to return to a land also claimed by Palestinians, it is exclusionary and therefore racist.

Israeli envoys celebrate yesterday at the United Nations after a resolution equating Zionism with racism is repealed. From left, Foreign Minister David Levy, Ambassador to the U.N. Yoram Aridor and Deputy Ambassador Ephraim Tari. Man standing is unidentified.

Sixteen years and a month after the vote. The photograph is of three Israeli diplomats celebrating, and the caption names all three and then says the fourth man standing with them is unidentified.

CP-1991-012 →

· Fort Worth Star-Telegram · Fort Worth · page 1

Is Zionism racism? Yes

John Taylor, letter to the editor

“Your Dec. 18 column dismissing the 1975 U.N.

‘Zionism is racism’ resolution as simply a product of the Cold War shows that, despite the Bill of Rights, there are some topics too sensitive for meaningful discussion in the Star-Telegram. It’s OK to consider whether President Bush conspired with Iran to delay the release of American hostages, to publish a comic strip suggesting that Vice President Dan Quayle used cocaine and to print photos of ‘Mapplethorpe art.’

But the charge that Israel, to which we give $4 billion a year, is founded upon the racist principle that Jews have the right to the land of Palestine, but Christian or Moslem Arabs do not, is somehow off limits. In 1948, more than 300 Arab villages were destroyed by Israel, and their inhabitants were expelled.

After the 1967 war, some villages were razed, including Emmaus, mentioned in Luke 24 as the place where Christ appeared to his disciples after the resurrection. Is Zionism a form of racism? The Star-Telegram and President Bush don’t think so, and the United Nations has changed its mind.

But if something walks like a duck, quacks like a duck and looks like a duck, it’s a duck, no matter what anyone says.”

Three weeks after the repeal, a reader in Fort Worth writes to say the vote settled nothing. The paper prints him on a page that also carries letters about the Internal Revenue Service and Japanese business books, under a standing box inviting readers to provoke thought and inquiry.

CP-1992-006 →

· The Bay City Times · Bay City · page 1

Repealed / Pending

Editorial cartoon by Steve Benson

Two panels. The left is boxed and labeled

Repealed: a figure labeled YASSER, in keffiyeh and wearing a button reading NO ISRAEL, holds a placard reading

ZIONISM IS RACISM. The right is boxed and labeled

Pending: a figure labeled YITZHAK stands at a bank of microphones holding a placard reading

ARABISM IS TERRORISM.

Drawn one month after the repeal, and the cartoonist has already worked out what comes next. The word he chose for the second panel was Pending. It runs above a syndicated column about the State Department deciding to strongly condemn rather than strongly deplore Israel, in which the Democratic front-runner, Governor Bill Clinton of Arkansas, is quoted calling the language a mistake.

CP-1992-007 →

· Iowa City Press-Citizen · Iowa City · page 1

Editorial was inaccurate

David Gutterman, M.D., letter to the editor

“Let’s get the facts straight. The Soviet Union put forth the infamous 1975 resolution equating Zionism with racism to appease Arab allies and frustrate the United States. It was not introduced, as suggested by a Press-Citizen editorial (Dec.

30), to ‘deter Israel from putting the establishment of the nation above human rights’… In 1975, 72 countries voted in favor of ‘Zionism equals racism.’ Of these, 18 permitted slavery, child slavery and debt bondage; 17 were rated worst in human rights violations in the World Human Rights Guide; and 15 restricted free practice of religion.

Israel did not.… It is precisely the freedom of the press in Israel that allows us media access to the difficult situation in the administered territories. Repeal of the 1975 resolution merely rights a wrong committed by the United Nations two decades ago and exposes a new form of anti-Semitism.”

A reader answering his paper’s editorial, six weeks after the repeal, and arriving at the sentence that the rest of this section is about: that repeal exposes a new form of anti-Semitism. He closes by quoting a line on Zionism and anti-Semitism attributed to Martin Luther King Jr. That attribution is disputed: it circulates from a letter and a secondhand dinner anecdote, and it has never been traced to a documented King text or recording. The letter is printed here as the paper printed it.

CP-1992-008 →

· The Oregonian · Portland

Arab terrorist might be sent to Algiers

Doctors report Habash too ill to be questioned

PARIS — Doctors examining George Habash late Friday decided that he was not in a state to be questioned, opening the way for the Palestinian guerrilla leader to be released and flown to Algeria, a news agency reported.

Magistrate Jean-Louis Bruguiere, France’s top anti-terrorism investigator, met with doctors who said a shock to Habash’s head had made it virtually impossible to speak with him, Agence France-Presse reported, quoting well-placed sources. The doctors said Habash had lost nearly all ability to speak.

After spending nearly four hours at Henry Dunant Hospital, the judge cut through a crowd of reporters and departed under police escort. The 65-year-old leader of the radical Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which gained notoriety with a series of hijackings and terrorist attacks in the 1970s, reportedly suffered a stroke at his home in Tunis, Tunisia, on Monday.

PLO officials, speaking on condition of anonymity, said Habash felt strong pains in his head and collapsed to the floor. The nature of the head injury was unclear. Neither the French Foreign Ministry nor the presidential Elysee Palace would confirm the report of the stroke.

A report said Habash, who had been placed under custody Thursday night, was to leave Paris for Algiers on Saturday. Algeria’s Foreign Ministry said late Friday that at the request of the Palestine Liberation Organization it had agreed to receive Habash, who travels on an Algerian passport.

President Francois Mitterrand’s government has been assailed at home and abroad for allowing Habash to enter France for medical care.

A Palestinian delegation leaves the French Consulate in Jerusalem on Friday after delivering a letter demanding that France release George Habash, leader of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.

CP-1992-014 →

· San Antonio Light · San Antonio

Palestinian terrorist leaves France

PARIS (AP) – George Habash, head of one of the most violent Palestinian terror factions, was allowed to leave France Saturday despite requests here and abroad that he be held for terrorism investigations. The Justice Ministry lifted a custody order on Habash, 65, who had been hospitalized in Paris since Wednesday after suffering an apparent stroke at his home in Tunisia.

Habash left Henry Dunant Hospital and flew from Orly airport. Several hours later, Palestine Liberation Organization officials said Chairman Yasser Arafat greeted Habash as he walked off the plane in Tunis, where he lives. He used a cane and was supported by two people.

France’s top anti-terrorism investigator had wanted to question him, and Israel had suggested it might seek Habash’s extradition for a murder probe. Neither Paris nor Washington had issued warrants for his arrest. “Habash is not the object of any warrant, neither national nor international,” the Interior Ministry said after his departure.

“There no longer exists any legal reason to hold him on the national territory.” Anti-terrorism investigator Jean-Louis Bruguiere said Thursday he wanted to question Habash about arms and explosives found in the forest of Fontainebleau outside Paris in 1986.

But doctors later told Bruguiere that Habash’s condition made it virtually impossible to speak with him, according to the Agence France-Presse news agency. The weapons were uncovered during bombings that killed 13 people, injured scores of others and terrorized the capital. Investigators linked the weapons to Habash’s guerrilla faction.

Habash leads the radical Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which gained notoriety for promoting the Palestinian cause through terrorist attacks in the 1970s – including the hijacking of an Air France airliner to Entebbe, Uganda. His group also was responsible for the machine-gun slaughter of 27 people at Israel’s Lod airport in May 1972.

HABASH FAREWELL: Palestinian guerrilla leader George Habash, at the top of the stairs, climbs into a chartered jet Saturday at Orly airport in Paris.

CP-1992-016 →

· THE HOM[E NEWS] — masthead truncated · page A14, section WORLD/NATION

Arabs kill 3 Israeli soldiers

EDITOR’S NOTE: This report was deiayed by the Israeli military censor, who made no changes. EIN IBRAHIM, Israel (AP) — In an attack likely to have political repercussions, Arab assailants raided an army camp in Israel and hacked to death three soldiers, the army said yesterday.

The attackers — armed with axes and knives — escaped with four of the soldiers’ rifles, military sources said. The attackers were Palestinians or Israeli Arabs who attacked as the victims slept in a base near the occupied West Bank, army officials said. A fourth soldier was moderately wounded.

It was the first time in the four-year Palestinian uprising that local Arabs hit a base in Israel. Army radio said the raid was audaciously planned, and others compared it to a 1987 attack by hang-glider from Lebanon that set the stage for the uprising. The attack, which came on the Jewish Sabbath, was expected to prompt a public outcry over military preparedness.

Two of those slain arrived only recently from the former Soviet Union and had been in the army a few weeks. The slayings raised questions about preparedness at the camp, 23 miles southeast of the coastal city of Haifa.

The apparent ease with which the attackers operated sent shockwaves through Israel, as reflected in a question by Israel television’s military reporter to army chief of staff, Lt. Gen. Ehud Barak.

“When a veteran soldier like you ... sees a chain of things that simply can’t be — no response, no opening of fire, communications problems ... no struggle with the terrorists, the terrorists leaving an area like this clean, unharmed — how do you react?” reporter Motti Eden asked.

“It is an extremely serious incident,” Barak said after arriving by helicopter at the camp near the Israeli Arab village of Ein Ibrahim. The killings were likely to cause political repercussions that could affect the Middle East peace talks. Army radio reported Parliament would meet this week to discuss the raid.

Military officials said the assailants stabbed and hacked the two Russian immigrants to death around midnight as they slept in their tents. A third soldier was fatally stabbed with a pitchfork when he heard the commotion and ran to help the others, they said. News of the slayings was held up by military censors for nearly 16 hours while the victims’ families were notified.

Troops descended on the area to launch a search. Flares lit the green, windswept hills around the camp, helicopters flew overhead and Bedouin trackers were called in. Police said about a dozen Israeli Arabs were rounded up for questioning.

Army radio quoted residents as saying responsibility was claimed by the Black Panthers, a local Palestine Liberation Organization militia, but radio reports said Islamic fundamentalists were suspected.

Israeli troops fan out from a helicopter during a manhunt around an army base near the occupied West Bank after Arab guerrillas armed with knives killed three soldiers early yesterday morning. (credited “The Associated Press”)

CP-1992-024 →

· The Herald Palladium

Arabs kill Israeli soldiers

EDITOR'S NOTE: This report was delayed by the Israeli military censor, who made no changes. EIN IBRAHIM, Israel (AP) — Israeli jets early Sunday attacked two Palestinian refugee camps in Lebanon, hours after Arab assailants raided an army camp in Israel and hacked to death three soldiers.

A brief statement from the Israeli military did not give a reason for the attacks on the Ein el-Hilwe and Rashadiyeh camps, but did say “the targets belonged to Fatah.” Fatah, the mainstream faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization, was accused by Israeli Defense Minister Moshe Arens of mounting the attack on the army camp.

The attackers were Palestinians or Israeli Arabs who attacked as the victims slept in a base near the occupied West Bank, army officials said. A fourth soldier was moderately wounded. It was the first time in the four-year Palestinian uprising that local Arabs hit a base in Israel.

Army radio said the raid was audaciously planned, and others compared it to a 1987 attack by hang-glider from Lebanon that set the stage for the uprising. The attack, which came on the Jewish Sabbath, was expected to prompt a public outcry over military preparedness. Two of those slain arrived only recently from the former Soviet Union and had been in the army a few weeks.

The killings were likely to cause political repercussions that could affect the Middle East peace talks. Army radio reported that Parliament would hold a special session this week to discuss the raid. The military chief of staff, Lt. Gen.

Ehud Barak, traveled to the scene by helicopter and called the incident “extremely serious.” [A paragraph here reports the manner in which the three soldiers were killed; it is summarized rather than transcribed.] An AP reporter at the camp saw a cot in one tent covered with blood, and a puddle of blood outside.

News of the slayings was held up by military censors for nearly 16 hours while the victims’ families were notified. Troops descended on the area to launch a search. Flares lit the green, windswept hills around the camp, helicopters flew overhead and Bedouin trackers were called in.

Police said about a dozen Israeli Arabs were rounded up for questioning The camp is about 23 miles southeast of the coastal city of Haifa and 2½ miles from the West Bank.

Army radio quoted residents in the nearby West Bank town of Jenin as saying a claim of responsibility was made by the Black Panthers, a local PLO militia, but radio reports said Islamic fundamentalists were suspected. Barak said it was not known if the attackers were Israeli Arabs or Palestinians from the occupied territories.

CP-1992-025 →

· Dickinson Press

3 Israeli soldiers slain in attack

Aircraft assault Palestinian refugee camps after Arab raid

EDITOR'S NOTE: This report was delayed by the Israeli military censor, who made no changes. EIN IBRAHIM, Israel (AP) — Israeli aircraft early Sunday attacked two Palestinian refugee camps in Lebanon, hours after Arab assailants raided an army camp in Israel and hacked to death three soldiers. Lebanese police said the raids killed one person and wounded nine.

A brief statement from the Israeli military did not give a reason for the attacks on the Ein el-Hilweh and Rashidiyeh camps, but did say “the targets belonged to Fatah.”

Fatah, the mainstream faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization, was accused by Israeli Defense Minister Moshe Arens of mounting the attack on the army camp, which is 23 miles southeast of the coastal city of Haifa. Ein El-Hilweh is the largest of 12 Palestinian camps in Lebanon, and has roughly 33,000 residents; Rashidiyeh has about 20,000 inhabitants.

Rashidiyeh was one of the camps where the Lebanese army last July disarmed Palestinian guerrillas. The attackers in Israel were Palestinians or Israeli Arabs who struck as the victims slept in a base near the occupied West Bank, army officials said. A fourth soldier was moderately wounded.

It was the first time in the four-year Palestinian uprising that local Arabs hit a base in Israel. Army radio said the raid was audaciously planned, and others compared it to a 1987 attack by hang-glider from Lebanon that set the stage for the uprising. The attack, which came on the Jewish Sabbath, was expected to prompt a public outcry over military preparedness.

Two of those slain arrived only recently from the former Soviet Union and had been in the army a few weeks. The apparent ease with which the attackers operated sent shockwaves through Israel, as reflected in a question by Israel television’s military reporter to army chief of staff, Lt. Gen. Ehud Barak.

“When a veteran soldier like you ... sees a chain of things that simply can’t be — no response, no opening of fire, communications problems ... no struggle with the terrorists, the terrorists leaving an area like this clean, unharmed — how do you react?” reporter Motti Eden asked Barak.

“It is an extremely serious incident,” Barak said after arriving by helicopter at the camp near the Israeli Arab village of Ein Ibrahim. The killings were likely to cause political repercussions that could affect the Middle East peace talks.

Army radio reported Parliament would meet this week to discuss the raid. [A paragraph here reports the manner in which the three soldiers were killed; it is summarized rather than transcribed.] An AP reporter at the camp saw a cot in one tent covered with blood, and a puddle of blood outside.

News of the slayings was held up by military censors for nearly 16 hours while the victims’ families were notified. Troops descended on the area to launch a search. Flares lit the green, windswept hills around the camp, helicopters flew overhead and Bedouin trackers were called in.

Police said about a dozen Israeli Arabs were rounded up for questioning in Ein Ibrahim and nearby Muawiya. Army radio quoted residents in the nearby West Bank town of Jenin as saying a claim of responsibility was made by the Black Panthers, a local PLO militia, but radio reports said Islamic fundamentalists were suspected.

SITE OF ATTACK: Israeli soldiers survey the area at an army cammp near the occupied West Bank where Arab attackers armed with knives and axes killed three soldiers Saturday morning. [credit: AP photo]

CP-1992-026 →

· Press and Sun Bulletin

Israel retaliates after Arab attack

EDITOR'S NOTE: This report was delayed by the Israeli military censor, who made no changes. EIN IBRAHIM, Israel (AP) — Israeli aircraft early today attacked two Palestinian refugee camps in Lebanon, hours after Arab assailants raided an army camp in Israel and hacked to death three soldiers. Lebanese police said the raids killed one person and wounded nine.

A brief statement from the Israeli military did not give a reason for the attacks on the Ein el-Hilweh and Rashidiyeh camps, but did say “the targets belonged to Fatah.”

Fatah, the mainstream faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization, was accused by Israeli Defense Minister Moshe Arens of mounting the attack on the army camp 23 miles southeast of the coastal city of Haifa. Ein El-Hilweh is the largest of 12 Palestinian camps in Lebanon, and has roughly 33,000 residents; Rashidiyeh has about 20,000 inhabitants.

Rashidiyeh was one of the camps where the Lebanese army last July disarmed Palestinian guerrillas. The attackers in Israel were Palestinians or Israeli Arabs who struck as the victims slept in a base near the occupied West Bank, army officials said. A fourth soldier was wounded. It was the first time in the four-year Palestinian uprising that local Arabs hit a base in Israel.

Army radio said the raid was audaciously planned, and others compared it to a 1987 attack by hang-glider from Lebanon that set the stage for the uprising. The attack, which came on the Jewish Sabbath, was expected to prompt a public outcry over military preparedness. Two of those slain arrived only recently from the former Soviet Union and had been in the army a few weeks.

The apparent ease of the operation sent shockwaves through Israel, as reflected in a question by Israel television’s military reporter to army chief of staff, Lt. Gen. Ehud Barak.

“When a veteran soldier like you . . . sees a chain of things that simply can’t be — no response, no opening of fire, communications problems . . . no struggle with the terrorists, the terrorists leaving an area like this clean, unharmed — how do you react?” reporter Motti Eden asked Barak.

“It is an extremely serious incident,” Barak said at the camp near the Israeli Arab village of Ein Ibrahim. The killings were likely to cause political repercussions that could affect the Middle East peace talks. Army radio reported Parliament would meet this week to discuss the raid.

Israeli soldiers fan out from a helicopter Saturday during a manhunt around an army base in Ein Ibrahim near the occupied West Bank after an Arab attack, the first of its kind inside Israel since the beginning of the Palestinian uprising. [credit: AP PHOTO]

CP-1992-027 →

· South Bend Tribune

One Palestinian's story shows tragic situation

ANTHONY LEWIS BOSTON — It is a small thing by the bloody standards of the Middle East: just a man cut off from his home and family, arbitrarily, without legal process. But the story does shed some light on the reality of that abstract term "occupied territory." Dr. Khalil Ibrahim Shikaki, 38, is a Palestinian political scientist who got his Ph.D. at Columbia University.

He taught at An-Najah University in Nablus, the West Bank, until Israel closed the universities in the occupied West Bank and Gaza at the end of 1987 because of the intifada. In 1989 Shikaki came to the United States. He taught for a year at the University of Wisconsin in Milwaukee, and was asked back twice to teach summer courses on international relations.

He went on to the University of South Florida as an adjunct professor. Late in 1991 Israel allowed An-Najah to reopen. Shikaki planned to return to Nablus - and to his wife and three children. He had to have an Israeli permit to re-enter the West Bank. He got it this January, and he flew to Jordan to go home. On Jan.

18 he went to the Allenby Bridge to cross into the West Bank. But Israeli military authorities turned him back, and took his re-entry permit from him. They refused to give him any reason. Colleagues at the University of South Florida asked Israeli authorities to reconsider, describing Shikaki as a scholarly and objective academic. Newspapers in Tampa wrote about the case.

At that point Israeli officials told the Tampa Tribune that there was a security reason for excluding Shikaki: His brother, Fathi, was a founder of Islamic Jihad, a terrorist organization. A Tampa Tribune columnist, Mark August, telephoned Shikaki in Amman, Jordan, to ask about it. He said he had nothing to do with his brother's politics.

"We have lived our separate ways since 1973," Shikaki said. "I am not a fundamentalist in any sense of the word. I abhor all forms of fanaticism, religious or otherwise." When I heard about the case, I telephoned an Israeli official. He said security authorities regarded Shikaki as a risk and excluded him for that reason.

"Would the United States government act any differently?" he asked. I answered: "Are you suggesting that the United States would keep a man born in America from returning home because of suspicion about a connection with his brother? It would not, and constitutionally it could not." The Israeli official said, "Of course Dr.

Shikaki is not exactly a citizen of Israel." Then, perhaps realizing the import of his statement, he dropped the point. For that is the point. Shikaki, like other Palestinians in the occupied territories, is a person without a country. Israel prides itself on being a democracy, but the nearly 2 million Palestinians it rules have no vote and no rights of citizenship.

To understand the case of Shikaki is to understand why Palestinians want to end the occupation, and why their negotiators have so bitterly criticized the form of "autonomy" proposed to them by Israel. For that plan would still leave it to Israeli authorities to decide who may leave or enter the West Bank, who may build a house, who may dig a well and so on.

The case also shows, in its understated way, why many Israelis yearn to end the occupation. For they understand that the exercise of arbitrary authority can corrupt anyone: that occupation corrupts the occupier. No doubt concern for Israel as well as concern for Shikaki led Professor Mark Tessler of the University of Wisconsin to appeal to Israel on his behalf.

Tessler is closely involved with Israel and has been there seven times in the last three years. He said Shikaki was "a fine scholar . . . objective and fair," who had helped persuade several Wisconsin students to study at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem. The case reminded me of a piece in The New York Review of Books last July by an Israeli army reservist, Ari Shavit.

He told about service as a guard in a Gaza detention camp - about the inhumanity routinely inflicted on the Palestinian prisoners. "It is not at this hour a matter of territories in exchange for peace," he concluded. "It is a matter of territories in exchange for our humanity."

CP-1992-011 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Study Finds Torture Common

By CLYDE HABERMAN

“The commission of inquiry into Shin Bet practices said ‘moderate physical pressure’…”

An Israeli study, in the headline, five years after the Landau Commission. The case it turns on is Mustafa Akawi, who died in Israeli custody in February 1992. Israel’s answer, printed here, is that investigators are strictly forbidden to use violence or even the threat of it.

CP-1992-017 →

· Courier-Journal · Louisville · page 1

4 Palestinians killed in occupied territories

“Palestinian boys displayed toy guns yesterday while playing in Gaza City in the occupied Gaza Strip, where a research group says nearly 60 percent of the 750,000 Palestinians are under age 19.” Associated Press.

The headline counts four dead. The photograph under it is of boys with toy guns, and the caption gives a population figure.

CP-1992-001 →

· Pueblo Chieftain · Pueblo

Israeli couple: Army murdered Palestinians

Associated Press

JERUSALEM (AP) — An Israeli couple accused the army Tuesday of opening fire without warning on two Palestinians who were writing slogans on a wall in the occupied West Bank.

David Elimelech and his wife Aviva, an Israeli Jewish couple, told Israel radio they saw soldiers shoot the two masked Palestinians in the back as they were spray painting slogans on a wall in Dura, 22 miles south of Jerusalem. “They didn’t even tell them to raise their hands,” said Mrs. Elimelech.

She said she and her husband saw the Monday night incident from the house of an Arab friend they were visiting.

The verb in the headline is murdered, and the archive holds very few headlines that use it for the killing of Palestinians. It is printable here because it is in the mouths of two named Israeli witnesses rather than the paper’s. They are named, and so is the detail that they were watching from the house of an Arab friend.

CP-1992-009 →

· The New York Times

To a Novelist of Nazareth, Laurels and Loud Boos

A salute from Israel brings down the wrath of many Palestinians.

By Joel Greenberg

JERUSALEM, May 6 — When Israel marks its independence day on Thursday, it will award its highest literary honor for the first time to an Israeli Arab writer, an act of cultural recognition that has set off fierce debate in Arab intellectual circles.

The dispute centers on whether the writer, Emile Habibi, a 70-year-old novelist from Nazareth and chronicler of the quandaries and conflicts of Arabs in Israel, should have agreed to accept the annual Israel Prize, given for scholarly or cultural achievement.

Winners — there are 10 this year, in several fields — are chosen by a committee of academicians appointed by the Ministry of Education and Culture, and they receive the award from Israel’s President and Education Minister. Mr.

Habibi’s writings, often fraught with bitter irony, enjoy wide popularity among Palestinians and other Arabs, and have been translated into several languages, including Hebrew.

Considered one of the Arab world’s leading writers, he was awarded the Jerusalem Medal for Culture, Literature and Arts by Yasir Arafat, chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, in a ceremony in Cairo in 1990. Better Than Bullets? Critics say Mr.

Habibi (pronounced hah-BEE-bee) will sully those Arab credentials by accepting an award from Israel’s leaders as part of their independence day celebrations. But Mr. Habibi replies that the prize is an acknowledgment of Arab cultural achievement that can promote both Arab rights in Israel and Palestinian-Israeli peace.

“This prize can be utilized to accelerate the march of peace, to bring official Israeli policy to concrete action towards peace,” he said. “A dialogue of prizes is better than a dialogue of stones and bullets.” Normally, the Israel Prize is not a matter of political controversy.

But for some Arabs, the question this year is whether accepting this gesture means giving legitimacy to Israel and its Government. Mr. Habibi seeks to reconcile both the Israeli and Arab elements of his identity: he will accept the $8,300 prize, but says he will donate the money to a Palestinian medical center in the occupied territories.

For years a sharp-tongued critic of Government policies as a Communist in Parliament and as editor of the party’s newspaper, he turned to writing novels relatively late in life, publishing his most prominent works in the 1970’s and 80’s.

In his best-known novel, “The Secret Life of Said the Pessoptimist,” he portrayed a character who embodied the contradictions of Israeli Arab life. Mr. Habibi broke in recent years with his political past, and has increasingly become a dissenter. He left the party after the unsuccessful coup in the Soviet Union last year.

During the Persian Gulf crisis, he criticized P.L.O. leaders for supporting President Saddam Hussein of Iraq. Such unorthodox positions form the backdrop for the current debate, which has raged in newspapers abroad, in Israel and in the territories.

One overseas critic is a former Habibi protégé, Mahmoud Darwish, a Palestinian poet and a senior P.L.O. official, who reportedly advised the novelist to turn the prize down. Writing in Al Quds, an East Jerusalem newspaper, Mr. Habibi complained about being criticized from afar.

“The person under the lash is not the same as the one counting the lashes from a distance,” he said. “We in Israel have found our own special path, the path of consistency and patience.”

Case of the Muzzled Poet But criticism also comes from Arab writers in Israel and the occupied territories who say a prize should not be accepted from a right-wing Government that they believe pursues tough anti-Arab policies and limits their freedom of expression.

They cite the recent case of an Israeli Arab poet, Shafik Habib, who was given a suspended prison sentence and a stiff fine for praising the Palestinian uprising in poems described by the court as incitements to violence. It was believed to be the first time that a poet in Israel had been punished for his writings. Samih Al-Kasim, a leading Israeli Arab poet, called Mr.

Habibi’s prize an empty gesture, “a political act that has no literary basis.” Muhammad Ali Taha, chairman of the Association of Arab Writers in Israel, said Mr. Habibi’s acceptance would serve “official Israeli propaganda” while Palestinian intellectuals in the territories were imprisoned.

And Lutfy Mashour, editor of the Israeli Arab newspaper A-Sinara, called the prize “a fig leaf, not a cloak of honor for the Arab population.” “Someone tramples you, discriminates against you, humiliates you, then comes with a cotton swab and dabs at your ear,” he said. ‘A Good Omen’ But Mr.

Habibi calls the Israel Prize “a first-class achievement” for Israeli Arabs, and says some Palestinian leaders have told him they agree. “It is indirect recognition of the Arabs in Israel as a nation, not just as communities,” he said. “This is recognition of a national culture.

It will help the Arab population in its struggle to strike roots in the land and gain equal rights.” Naim Arraydi, a writer and Habibi supporter, said the critics reveal a “mindset in the Arab sector, which still, subconsciously, does not recognize the existence of the state of Israel.”

“There is a belief that by accepting the prize, Emile Habibi is granting Israel legitimacy because of his status,” Mr. Arraydi said. “But this is precisely what is needed now, because finally it is dawning on Arab consciousness that Israel is a fact, and Israel is beginnning to understand that there is a Palestinian people whose problem must be solved.”

“The award,” he said, “is a good omen.”

The Israeli Arab writer Emile Habibi says his acceptance of Israel’s highest literary award is an acknowledgment of Arab cultural achievement that can promote Arab rights in Israel and Palestinian-Israeli peace. Critics say his acceptance would give legitimacy to Israel.

CP-1992-022 →

· The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City · page 1

Dispossessed Palestinians Gain Attention For Their Demands to Be Emancipated

Harry E. Fuller Jr.

“A dusty street in Palestinian refugee camp, Jabalia. Some 42,000 Palestinians live in Jabalia, which is three square kilometers in size. It and other refugee camps in the Gaza Strip, on the Mediterranean Sea, are operated by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency.” Harry E. Fuller Jr.

The headline and the photograph; the story under them is not part of this clipping.

CP-1992-003 →

· The New York Times

Palestinians Critique Election, and See Basis for Hope

By JOEL GREENBERG, Special to The New York Times

BETHLEHEM, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, June 24 — On streets and in shops, in restaurants and offices throughout the occupied territories today, Palestinians chewed over the results of Israel’s election and expressed hesitant hopes that the Labor Party’s victory might bring them closer to peace.

Many watched the returns throughout the night on television, and their delight at the defeat of the rightist Likud Party was evident. But their satisfaction was tempered with a heavy measure of caution. At Al Bashir restaurant on the main road into Bethlehem, customers agreed that the victory of Yitzhak Rabin and the Labor Party was a good thing.

“Labor is more capable than the Likud of promoting the peace process,” said George Zeineh, a grocer. “The question is whether they can stop wavering and find the courage to seize this golden opportunity.”

“We haven’t forgotten that they built settlements and confiscated land when they were in power, and Rabin ordered soldiers to break the bones of Palestinians during the intifada,” Mr. Zeineh added, referring to the Palestinian uprising. “Despite that, I believe Labor can now play a positive role.”

“The main thing was to get rid of the Likud,” said Khalil Salaam, from the village of Beit Safafa. “Labor can do better.” In an East Jerusalem barbershop, a customer at first dismissed the election results. “Likud and Labor are the same,” said the customer, who declined to be identified.

But on second thought he added: “Labor is a little less difficult than Likud, and if Mr. Rabin carries out what he says about reaching an understanding with the Arabs and stopping settlements, it will be good. We have some hope.”

Ali Yaish, editor of a nationalist paper in East Jerusalem, Al Shaab, said that “we’re very careful about a real change.” But he added that he had a “sliver of hope” that there might be a step forward to Palestinian autonomy in the occupied territories.

An editorial in another Palestinian newspaper published in East Jerusalem, the pro-Jordanian An Nahar, echoed this reserve, arguing that there was no fundamental difference between Mr.

Rabin and the outgoing Prime Minister, Yitzhak Shamir, since both reject Israeli withdrawal from all of the occupied territories, a Palestinian state, and talks with the Palestine Liberation Organization. Some Palestinians recalled that Mr. Rabin, as Defense Minister, had ordered house demolitions and deportations in an attempt to put down the uprising.

But the P.L.O. and Palestinian delegates to the Mideast peace negotiations welcomed Mr. Rabin’s victory. The spokeswoman for the Palestinian delegation to the talks, Hanan Ashrawi, said in a radio interview in Jordan: “It looks like the peace process has been rescued from from the Likud’s attempts at sabotaging it.

It looks like there is a definite majority for Labor and leftist parties in order to engage on issues of substance, especially dealing with the transitional phase. Hopefully they will stop all settlement activity, and we will launch our own elections for Palestinian self-government.”

Residents of Bethlehem expressed satisfaction and caution over the Labor Party’s victory.

CP-1992-023 →

· The Day · New London

Four Palestinians die in Gaza, West Bank violence

Jerusalem (AP) — Israeli soldiers fatally shot a Palestinian activist during a gunfight in the occupied West Bank city of Jenin on Wednesday night, the army reported. Three other Palestinians were killed by fellow Arabs in separate incidents in the occupied West Bank and Gaza territories, the army said.

Mahmud Abu Hasan, 23, a leader of the Black Panthers, a militant wing of the PLO’s mainstream Fatah faction, was carrying a pistol and hand grenade when soldiers shot him, a military spokesman said. In the Khan Yunis district of Gaza, Palestinians shot and killed Fawzi Ayub Sabeg, 33, who was suspected of collaborating with Israeli authorities, according to Arab reports.

In Kufr Raay, a village near Jenin, masked men entered the home of Muraweh Al-Haradien, 54, and demanded to question his son about alleged collaboration with Israel, the army and Arab sources said. When Al-Haradien refused, the intruders fatally shot him and also killed another family member, Jamil Muhammed Said Sabah, 27.

Abu Hasan was the 941st Palestinian killed by Israeli soldiers or civilians during the 4½-year uprising against Israeli rule in the occupied territories. The deaths in Gaza and Jenin brought to 603 the number of Palestinians killed by fellow Arabs for suspected collaboration with Israel. Ninety-seven Israelis have been killed in the violence.

Also on Wednesday, Palestinian peace negotiator Dr. Zakaria Al-Agha filed a complaint against the Israeli army after soldiers locked him inside his bedroom for forty minutes.

CP-1992-013 →

· Tampa Bay Times

Israel releases about 200 Palestinians

NAHAL OZ, Israel — Palestinian families embraced in tearful reunions Monday after Israel freed 195 prisoners, including 13 who had completed their terms, as a goodwill gesture to coincide with the sixth round of Middle East peace talks in Washington.

The prisoners were freed at the Nahal Oz checkpoint, an entrance to the occupied Gaza Strip where 750,000 Palestinians live. Others were taken to the occupied West Bank. A total of 600 prisoners are to be released over the next few days, an Israeli Army spokeswoman said. About 10,000 Palestinians are in prison.

CP-1992-021 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Arab Resistance Leader Held

Special to The New York Times

JERUSALEM, Sept. 18 — The Israeli Army said today that it had arrested the underground commander of the militant Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine in the occupied territories on Sept. 1. The commander, identified as Ahmad Suleiman Katmash, 42 years old, from the town of El Bireh near Jerusalem, had been wanted since 1976, the army said.

A military spokesman said that documents found on Mr. Katmash included a forged identity card and calls for action, including “attacks on soldiers and civilians.”

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible — the scan is cropped to this single short item. The dateline reads “JERUSALEM, Sept. 18”, consistent with a Sept. 19, 1992 paper, but the date itself could not be confirmed from the page.

CP-1992-020 →

· The Advocate · Stamford

Israel allows media to visit fasting Arab inmates

Two-week hunger strike ends; better prison conditions sought

By Marcus Eliason, Associated Press

NABLUS, Occupied West Bank — Arab prisoners ended their two-week-old hunger strike yesterday after Israel took the unusual step of opening its main West Bank prison to the media, authorities said.

Hours after Israeli, Arab and foreign journalists visited the Central Prison near Nablus, the police ministry announced the inmates had called off the strike, which had fomented a new wave of Palestinian unrest.

Ministry spokesman Rafi Levy added that the deal was reached after Police Minister Moshe Shahal and prison officials agreed to investigate the inmates' demands, “with particular emphasis on the humanitarian ones,” starting Tuesday, the day after the Jewish holiday of Sukkot.

Levy stressed that the prisoners were promised better conditions as long as improvement does not harm security. All prisoners began eating again after the deal was announced, he added. Palestinian lawyers who helped negotiate the deal confirmed yesterday that the strike was over.

But Freih Abu Medein, head of the Gaza Strip Bar Association, said Palestinian inmates in three prisons refused to break the hunger strike, preferring to wait until they saw the outcome of Tuesday's investigation. Medein, who met with striking inmates in Nafah prison, said they wanted any agreement made in writing with the International Red Cross.

During the prison visit, journalists were allowed to interview fasting inmates at random, out of earshot of the wardens, and were briefed in four languages by senior prison officials. The media event reflected the government's concern that the hunger strike that began Sept.

27 was leading to increasingly bloody confrontations between troops and Palestinians, and could disrupt the U.S.-sponsored peace talks resuming later this month. Two Palestinians have been killed and more than 80 wounded by troops during weekend disturbances in the occupied territories that grew from rallies supporting the hunger strike.

A police officer also was injured by a stone thrown by rioters. Thus the government has been eager to settle the strike and prove to inmates' families that conditions are not bad enough to warrant street riots. The strike began at Central Prison, an 850-inmate lockup on a mountainside outside Nablus, and spread to other prisons.

After a two-day halt for negotiations between prisoners' representatives and Shahal, the fast resumed Thursday in the Nablus prison and seven others. Yesterday, 1,984 prisoners were on strike and another 850 on partial strike, the Prisons Authority said, adding in a statement: “The prisoners are feeling well. There have been no hospitalizations.”

During a tour of Central Prison, journalists were told the Prison Authority accepted many of the prisoners' grievances but rejected their demand for a say in where convicts are imprisoned.

Yossi Pollak, the newly appointed governor of Central Prison, said that demand amounted to “gross interference in prison administration” and was designed to deadlock negotiations and keep alive the unrest on the streets. But inmates told reporters the strike was entirely over prison conditions.

They demanded free movement among cell blocks, better food, more family visits, less crowding, better medical care and fewer searches. They said they want a say in where inmates are housed partly to make family visits easier. Prison Commissioner Gabi Amir said many of the demands would be met, including more educational opportunities and longer family visits.

Other concessions, he said, included putting ventilators in the cells and building a taller TV antenna to pick up Syrian and Jordanian broadcasts. He said crowding was a problem in jails the world over and “we have nothing to be ashamed of.” None of the inmates at Central Prison would say why he was there. “We're at war, right?

There's an intefadeh (uprising),” said Zaher Abdel Halek, 36, who lost an arm handling a grenade. Of the 850 inmates, 203 are serving life sentences.

A group of Palestinian prisoners on a hunger strike at the Jneid prison in the Israeli occupied West Bank town of Nablus, display the victory sign to photographers.

Photograph credited AP photo.

CP-1992-010 →

· The New York Times · New York

The Difference a Line Makes

“The international frontier that once separated Israel from the West Bank cut Bartaa in two, following a valley that runs through its heart.

When Israel captured the West Bank from Jordan in 1967, the villagers were reunited, but the road that links Bartaa’s two sides is a passage between contrasts… We’ve invited journalists, Parliament members and international or… should stay in Israel. They say we should be part of the Palestinian state.”

Bartaa, a village cut in half by the armistice line in 1949 and rejoined in 1967, with the two halves disagreeing about which state they want to be in. A microcosm, the paper says, of the relationship between Israeli Arabs and their Palestinian kin.

CP-1992-018 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia

Suffering keeps alive Palestinians’ dream of returning home

Israel favors humanitarian relief short of outright return, fearing the nation would lose its Jewish identity if it were flooded by millions of people hostile to its existence. It is an argument that is lost on the refugees in the camps, where decades of unending misery and deprivation have only sharpened the bitterness and the yearning.

A visit to a camp like Dheisheh shows how the apparently innocuous — like an old man’s faded documents, children’s games and a young man’s limp — are all fodder for more hatred. The refugees’ concept of the “right of return” is often very specific.

Children and grandchildren raised on golden stories of villages long since paved over say they will settle for nothing less than the very patch of land their forefathers occupied. That is land that Jews now live on.

“They should go back to where they came from,” said Soud Laham, a 30-year-old mother of 10 who lives with her husband in the first house built in Dheisheh. “Everyone had a house before, and everyone should go back to his home. If someone takes my best blouse and leaves me wearing patches, how can I be satisfied with less?”

To understand such seeming rigidity, it is necessary to understand how anger and pain are honed a little sharper every day. About 8,000 refugees live in Dheisheh. Every month, on average, 45 babies are born into poverty. The average family of seven people earns $300 a month. International aid provides the few amenities.

The sewers were built by the Italians, the physical therapy clinic by the Japanese, the vocational school by the Germans. Even the blue trash bins come from outside, bearing the initials U.N.

CP-1992-015 →

· Fort Worth Star-Telegram · Fort Worth · page 1

The intifada

Deaths: 988 Palestinians killed by Israeli soldiers or civilians, including 110 by undercover units; 678 Palestinians killed by fellow Arabs, most on suspicion of collaboration; 109 Israelis, including 21 soldiers. Deportations of Palestinians: 73. Palestinian houses: 301 sealed, 434 demolished.

Arrests and detentions: More than 80,000 Palestinians detained; 6,830 Palestinians in jail as of Nov. 1, including 223 held without charge or trial. Soldiers court-martialed: 236 cases brought; 191 convicted. The Gaza Strip, home to 800,000 Palestinians, covers 140 square miles - slightly smaller than Rockwall County, Texas' smallest.

CP-1992-004 →

· San Antonio Light · San Antonio · page 1

Lebanon thwarts Israel’s expulsion of Palestinians

Troops set up blockade and order buses to return

Associated Press, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM (AP) — Lebanese troops early today blocked a convoy of buses carrying Palestinians deported by Israel in a move to strike back at mounting violence by Muslim fundamentalists. The deportations of about 400 Palestinians, which began Thursday, drew widespread condemnation and raised fears the fragile Middle East peace process could shatter.

The Lebanese army used earthen mounds to halt the first group of six buses and ordered them to return to Israel’s self-declared “security zone” in South Lebanon about 3:15 a.m. (7:15 p.m. San Antonio time Thursday), said Lebanese security sources. The Lebanese then reinforced the blockade with tanks and armored vehicles.

It was not immediately known if the Israeli-allied forces permitted the buses back into the zone. Earlier, Israel radio reported that an additional 34 fundamentalists were taken from an Israeli detention center and flown to South Lebanon. The army refused to comment on the report. Palestinians said the moves jeopardize the future of U.S.-brokered peace talks.

But Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin said swift retaliation was needed to protect the Arab-Israeli negotiations from the rise of Muslim fundamentalist power. The United States regards deportations as illegal, and President Bush urged Israel to stop them. Israel radio said Washington told Jerusalem that it would not block a U.N. resolution today denouncing Israel.

A police source in the security zone said 22 buses, carrying 350 to 400 Palestinians, were in the area early today. Israel’s surrogate militia, the South Lebanon Army, took charge of the red-and-white buses in Zommaraya, on the edge of the zone. Sources in Lebanon saw this as a bid by Israel to avoid confrontation with Lebanon’s army.

The expulsions Thursday, the most sweeping since the early 1970s, were delayed for 15 hours by the Supreme Court, leaving the Palestinians in buses on the cold, rainy frontier, handcuffed, blindfolded and pounding windows in frustration.

Fundamentalists killed six Israeli troops this month in eight days, climaxing their actions this week by kidnapping and killing a border policeman. Initially, Israel singled out 418 people for two-year periods of exile.

Deportations complicate peace talks. WASHINGTON (AP) — President Bush, echoing warnings from outraged Arab negotiators, said Thursday that Israel’s deportations of Palestinians “risk complicating” the Middle East peace talks he helped orchestrate.

In Tunisia, the Palestine Liberation Organization said that Palestinian participation in peace talks with Israel will be suspended until the return of about 400 Palestinians deported to Lebanon… But the State Department said the United States “strongly condemns the action of deportation.”

At the United Nations, U.S. officials were attending informal consultations of the Security Council to discuss a proposed resolution ordering Israel to reverse its deportation of 383 suspected Muslim fundamentalists.

Chief Palestinian negotiator Haidar Abdel Shafi said Bush expressed anger about the deportations during his meeting with the joint Palestinian-Jordanian delegation, calling them a violation of the Geneva Conventions governing international human rights. But Israeli officials said Bush barely raised the matter with them at their 20-minute meeting.

“EXPULSIONS: An Israeli soldier, above, aboard a bus in Metulla, Israel, adjusts the blindfold of one the Palestinians being deported into Lebanon on Thursday. At right, an Israeli human rights supporter scuffles with a policeman inside the Supreme Court building in Jerusalem on Thursday.

The Palestine Liberation Organization said Thursday that Palestinian participation in peace talks with Israel will be suspended until the Palestinians are returned to Israel. European and Arab countries have called the latest deportations of Palestinians a breach of international law.” Photos by the Associated Press

Four hundred men deported into a country that would not take them, and left on the frontier in the cold. The number changes down the page: 418 singled out, about 400 deported, 383 in the draft resolution.

CP-1992-005 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Arabs protest the deportations

“Many of the 760,000 Arabs in Israel… a series of protests inside Israel that one specialist says is unprecedented.”

Chris Hedges, filing from Beit Safafa — the village cut in half by the 1949 armistice line, one side in Israel and one in Jordan, and the subject of some of the earliest coverage in this collection. Forty-three years later the Times is back in the same street, counting 760,000 people and calling the protest unprecedented.

CP-1992-019 →

· The Grand Rapids Press · Grand Rapids · page D3

Women in waiting

Palestinian women fight for national, personal liberation

By Karin Laub, Associated Press Writer

EL BIREH, Occupied West Bank — Sahar Sleim gets up at 4 a.m., sews blouses for Israeli shops for a dollar apiece, then throughout the day cooks, cleans, oversees her children's homework, sews again and collapses into bed at 9 p.m. Her husband, Walid, often gripes when he comes home from his tailor shop because Sahar has no time for him.

But she is quietly resisting his growing demands to give up her job. “I work so my children can finish university,” Sleim says from behind the sewing machine in her living room. “I want my daughters to be independent. I want them to get an education and only then to marry. I don't want them to repeat my mistakes.”

Sleim, 38, married Walid, a distant cousin, at age 19 under pressure from her father. She had hoped to study engineering by correspondence from Beirut University, but the dream died when the first of her six children was born. “If I could choose now between a husband and university, I would choose university,” Sleim says bitterly. “Sewing blouses is not enough.”

Sleim is among a growing number of younger Palestinian women who want to be more than housewives and mothers, completely subservient to fathers, brothers and husbands. The social mores in the occupied lands are no different from most of the Arab world.

But 25 years under Israeli occupation have exposed the West Bank and Gaza Strip to a Western industrialized society where contraceptives, college and careers are available to both sexes. Palestinian women's status has also been boosted, ironically, by resistance to occupation. Women have played a prominent role in the five-year uprising in the occupied territories.

But a full-scale feminist revolt seems far away. Women keep their complaints among themselves. Open dissent is severely dealt with: a daughter faces beatings, even banishment from the family, if she gets a job against her father's wishes. In rare cases, unmarried women who eloped were killed by their fathers or brothers for besmirching the family honor.

Still, some feminists see hope. They point to the negotiations with the Israelis for limited Palestinian self-rule in the territories as an opening. “Perhaps it will be the start of establishing a new society,” says Zuheira Kamal, an adviser to the Palestinian negotiating team.

But women will have to fight for any gains because the Palestinians' struggle for a state overrides all else, she adds. For example, the Palestinian team appointed Kamal to draft women's rights legislation, such as equal pay, to be considered under autonomy. But she says she got the go-ahead only after much pleading.

FREEDOM WITH LIMITS While many younger Palestinian women say they want change, they dislike what they see as the lonely and often frenetic lives of their Western sisters. “I would like Palestinian women to be free, but within the framework of Arab tradition,” says Sleim, who lives in El Bireh, a town just north of Jerusalem. “The family should stay strong.

I don't want to turn my children loose when they are 18.” Indeed, the traditional life has much to offer, especially the warmth and security of family. Household chores and child care are shared by many. After a woman gives birth, female relatives for the first weeks take care of her house and the older children.

Women can drop off their kids at a relative's without prior notice. Mothers, daughters and neighbors often cook together while sitting in a circle and chatting. The elderly are cared for at home, and old-age homes are unheard of. But the system only works because every family member obeys the rules which are enforced by men.

Fathers and older brothers decide whether girls should study and whom they should marry. Husbands determine how many children the wife will have, what she should wear, where she goes. Divorcees are stigmatized. Polygamy is still practiced, and men can get a divorce more easily than women.

“Our lives are full of the fear of men,” says Hania Aswad, a 22-year-old women's rights activist. Hanna Saed, 43, from the West Bank refugee camp of Dheishe near Bethlehem, said her father pulled her out of school at age 14 and engaged her to his friend's son, 17-year-old Ismail, to cement ties between the two families.

“I used to cry when I watched my brothers prepare their books for the new school year. If I had been allowed, I would have finished school and become a teacher,” says Saed, smoothing her traditional red-on-black embroidered robe and white head scarf in a nervous gesture.

Married at age 15, Saed moved in with her in-laws in Dheishe where she cooked and cleaned for a 13-member household. A year later, the young couple moved into its own home, a one-room shack in Dheishe furnished with a gas cooker, two beds, a table and chairs, and an outhouse and well.

Here, Saed raised three girls and three boys on Ismail's meager income as an olive wood carver. The children slept on mattresses that were stacked during the day, and took turns at the table to do their homework. Saed says she still cannot leave the house without her husband's permission. Like Sahar Sleim, Saed stakes her hopes on education.

A proud smile comes over her soft face when she describes how she kept her three daughters in school despite objections from her father-in-law. The oldest, Maha, is a lab technician, and Suzanna and Noha are in high school. MORE WOMEN ARE EDUCATED Education is one area where many of the 900,000 women in the occupied lands have made great strides.

In 1970, 65 percent had no schooling. Twenty years later, that number was down to around 30 percent. The percentage of women attending university rose from 0.5 to 6.2 in the West Bank, and from 0.5 to 4.9 in Gaza. Still, only some 30,000 Palestinian women, most of them single, work outside the home.

Most have menial jobs, cleaning for Israelis, picking fruit or working in factories. The law obliges Israeli employers to pay basic social benefits, but some dodge it by hiring unregistered workers. And the law doesn't apply in the occupied territories.

The 20,000 women working there have no medical insurance and only after 15 years on the job are they entitled to a small pension, said researchers at the Women's Studies Center near Jerusalem. A female factory worker earns an average of $170 a month, or enough to buy a food processor or 10 sacks of rice. In some areas, wages are as low as $28 a month.

MEN EARN MORE Males average $300. Pieceworkers like Sleim get just over $1 dollar to sew a blouse and 75 cents for a pair of jeans. Women with college degrees become teachers, bookkeepers and clerical workers. Only a few have made a career in business. It is the educated women who often face the toughest choice between tradition and Western ideas.

Hania Aswad and her younger sister set up house together while studying at the University of Texas in Austin. Their father retaliated by cutting off financial support and Aswad had to abandon her interior design course after two semesters because she couldn't study holding two jobs.

Aswad's parents divorced 18 years ago, and a year ago she returned from the United States to live with her mother, Mahboubeh, in the West Bank town of Ramallah. Aswad says her outspoken feminism clashes with convention. Mothers of girlfriends have blacklisted her as a bad influence and friends urge her to keep her mouth shut and find a husband.

“Some men have asked for my hand. But I've refused them because I don't want someone who is afraid of my beliefs,” she says. Sousan, 31, a West Bank teacher who moved back in with her family after divorcing, says her father initially refused to let her take driving lessons. He feared the neighbors would gossip if she spent time alone with a male instructor.

So her younger brother played chaperon, sitting in the back seat. Most women still follow the traditional path of housewife and mother. The average number of children is estimated down from nine to six since the 1960s, but Palestinian women still have one of the world's highest birth rates.

In recent years, the percentage of women using birth control rose from five to 15, said Mirray Jhniem of the Women's Resource Center, the main source of contraceptives in the occupied lands. But the center only dispenses contraceptives to women whose husbands consent, and advises that they be used only for spacing between pregnancies, not to limit the number of children.

It does not perform sterilizations. Abortions are illegal, though some doctors perform them secretly. When the Palestinian uprising began in December 1987, many women's activists were euphoric. They saw the rebellion as weakening the patriarchs' grip and pushing women forward.

In the initial mass protests, women won respect by standing alongside men and throwing stones at Israeli soldiers. Forty-seven women have been killed and 3,000 detained by the army since 1987. But many gains later disappeared, Kamal says. Long curfews and mass arrests have raised family tensions, and there have been more reports of wife-beating.

The average age of marriage for women fell from 20 to 17 during the uprising. Daughters are married off quickly because money is tight and potential husbands more scarce due to the mass arrests, Kamal says. She says women have a chance only if autonomy works without bloodshed. “And even then, we won't see this social change in this generation,” Kamal says.

“It will be for the next one.”

Cutting grass in a field near Bethlehem, these Palestinian women seem like a portrait of the past. · At work in a chocolate factory in Ramallaha, these women are among the growing number taking jobs outside the home. (AP PHOTOS)

Eleven Palestinian women are named in one story. By the same reporter who filed the February 1994 dispatch on the first women's shelter in the Arab world. The paper's spelling of Ramallaha is kept.

CP-1993-014 →

· The Jonesboro Sun · Jonesboro · page 7C

Status of Palestinian women is changing ever so slowly

By KARIN LAUB, Associated Press

EL BIREH, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Sahar Sleim gets up at 4 a.m., sews blouses for Israeli shops for a dollar apiece, then throughout the day cooks, cleans, oversees her children's homework, sews again and collapses into bed at 9 p.m. Her husband, Walid, often gripes when he comes home from his tailor shop because Sahar has no time for him.

But she is quietly resisting his growing demands to give up her job. “I work so my children can finish university,” Mrs. Sleim says from behind the sewing machine in her living room. “I want my daughters to be independent. I want them to get an education and only then to marry. I don't want them to repeat my mistakes.” Mrs.

Sleim, 38, married Walid, a distant cousin, at age 19 under pressure from her father. She had hoped to study engineering by correspondence with Beirut University, but the dream died when the first of her six children was born. “If I could choose now between a husband and university, I would choose university,” Mrs. Sleim says bitterly. “Sewing blouses is not enough.” Mrs.

Sleim is among a growing number of younger Palestinian women who want to be more than housewives and mothers, completely subservient to fathers, brothers and husbands. The social mores in the occupied lands are no different from most of the Arab world.

But 25 years under Israeli occupation have exposed the West Bank and Gaza Strip to a Western industrialized society where contraceptives, college and careers are available to both sexes. Palestinian women's status has also been boosted, ironically, by resistance to occupation. Women have played a prominent role in the five-year uprising in the occupied territories.

But a full-scale feminist revolt seems far away. Women keep their complaints among themselves. Open dissent is severely dealt with: a daughter faces beatings, even banishment from the family, if she gets a job against her father's wishes. In rare cases, unmarried women who eloped were killed by their fathers or brothers for besmirching the family honor.

Still, some feminists see hope. They point to the negotiations with the Israelis for limited Palestinian self-rule in the territories as an opening. “Perhaps it will be the start of establishing a new society,” says Zuheira Kamal, an adviser to the Palestinian negotiating team.

But women will have to fight for any gains because the Palestinians' struggle for a state overrides all else, she adds. For example, the Palestinian team appointed Kamal to draft women's rights legislation, such as equal pay, to be considered under autonomy. But she says she got the go-ahead only after much pleading.

While many younger Palestinian women say they want change, they dislike what they see as the lonely and often frenetic lives of their Western sisters. “I would like Palestinian women to be free, but within the framework of Arab tradition,” says Mrs. Sleim, who lives in El Bireh, a town just north of Jerusalem. “The family should stay strong.

I don't want to turn my children loose when they are 18.” Indeed, the traditional life has much to offer, especially the warmth and security of family. Household chores and child care are shared by many. After a woman gives birth, female relatives for the first weeks take care of her house and the older children.

Women can drop off their kids at a relative's without prior notice. Mothers, daughters and neighbors often cook together while sitting in a circle and chatting. The elderly are cared for at home, and old-age homes are unheard of. But the system only works because every family member obeys the rules, which are enforced by men.

Fathers and older brothers decide whether girls should study and whom they should marry. Husbands determine how many children the wife will have, what the wife should wear, where she should socialize. Divorcees are stigmatized. Polygamy is still practiced, though it is more rare than in the past, and men can get a divorce more easily than women.

“Our lives are full of the fear of men,” says Hania Aswad, a 22-year-old women's rights activist. Hanna Saed, 43, from the West Bank refugee camp of Dheishe near Bethlehem, said her father pulled her out of school at age 14 and engaged her to his friend's son, 17-year-old Ismail, to cement ties between the two families.

“I used to cry when I watched my brothers prepare their books for the new school year. If I had been allowed, I would have finished school and become a teacher,” says Mrs. Saed, smoothing her traditional red-on-black embroidered robe and white head scarf in a nervous gesture. Married at age 15, Mrs.

Saed moved in with her in-laws in Dheishe where she cooked and cleaned for a 13-member household. A year later, the young couple moved into its own home, a one-room shack in Dheishe furnished with a gas cooker, two beds, a table and chairs, and an outhouse and well. Here, Mrs. Saed raised three girls and three boys on Ismail's meager income as an olive wood carver.

The children slept on mattresses that were stacked during the day, and took turns at the table to do their homework. Mrs. Saed says she still cannot leave the house without her husband's permission. Like Sahar Sleim, Mrs. Saed stakes her hopes on education.

A proud smile comes over her soft face when she describes how she kept her three daughters in school despite objections from her father-in-law. The oldest, Maha, is a lab technician, and Suzanna and Noha are honor students in high school. Education is one area where many of the 900,000 women in the occupied lands have made great strides. In 1970, 65 percent had no schooling.

Twenty years later, that number was down to around 30 percent. The percentage of women attending university rose from 0.5 to 6.2 in the West Bank, and from 0.5 to 4.9 in Gaza during that period. Still, only some 30,000 Palestinian women, most of them single, work outside the home.

Most have menial jobs, cleaning for Israelis, picking fruit or working in Palestinian and Israeli factories. The law obliges Israeli employers to pay basic social benefits, but some dodge it by hiring unregistered workers. And the law doesn't apply in the occupied territories.

The 20,000 women working there have no medical insurance and only after 15 years on the job are they entitled to a small pension, said researchers at the Women's Studies Center near Jerusalem. A female factory worker earns an average of $170 a month, or enough to buy a food processor or 10 sacks of rice. In some areas, wages are as low as $28 a month. Males average $300.

Pieceworkers like Mrs. Sleim get just over $1 dollar to sew a blouse and 75 cents for a pair of jeans. Women with college degrees become teachers, bookkeepers and clerical workers. Only a few have made a career in business. It is the educated women who often face the toughest choice between tradition and Western ideas.

Most women still follow the traditional path of housewife and mother. Though no statistics are available, the average number of children is estimated down from nine to six since the 1960s, and Palestinian women still have one of the world's highest birth rates.

IN THE FIELD: Palestinian women cut grass in a field near Bethlehem in the Occupied West Bank. Palestinian women's status has been boosted, ironically, by resistance to occupation. Women have played a prominent role in the five year uprising in the occupied territories. (APN)

The same Associated Press dispatch The Grand Rapids Press ran three days earlier as a full page under the headline Women in waiting. This printing gives the women courtesy titles the other does not, and stops at the birth rate. Everything after it — the 47 women killed and 3,000 detained since 1987, the rise in wife-beating, the marriage age falling from 20 to 17, and Zuheira Kamal's closing line — is not in this version.

CP-1993-015 →

· The Journal Times · Racine · page 2A

Careful sips of freedom

Palestinian women slipping free from old tyrannies—but slowly

Stories and photos by the Associated Press

Sahar Sleim gets up at 4 a.m., sews blouses for Israeli shops for a dollar apiece, then throughout the day cooks, cleans, oversees her children's homework, sews again and collapses into bed at 9 p.m. Her husband, Walid, often gripes when he comes home from his tailor shop because Sahar has no time for him. But she is quietly resisting his growing demands to give up her job.

“I work so my children can finish university,” Sleim says from behind the sewing machine in her living room. “I want my daughters to be independent. I want them to get an education and only then to marry. I don't want them to repeat my mistakes.” Sleim, 38, married Walid, a distant cousin, at age 19 under pressure from her father.

She had hoped to study engineering by correspondence with Beirut University, but the dream died when the first of her six children was born. “If I could choose now between a husband and university, I would choose university,” Sleim says bitterly. “Sewing blouses is not enough.”

Sleim is among a growing number of younger Palestinian women who want to be more than housewives and mothers, completely subservient to fathers, brothers and husbands. The social mores in the occupied lands are no different from most of the Arab world.

But 25 years under Israeli occupation have exposed the West Bank and Gaza Strip to a Western industrialized society where contraceptives, college and careers are available to both sexes. Palestinian women's status has also been boosted, ironically, by resistance to occupation. Women have played a prominent role in the five-year uprising in the occupied territories.

But a full-scale feminist revolt seems far away. Women keep their complaints among themselves. A daughter faces beatings, even banishment from the family, if she gets a job against her father's wishes. Still, some feminists see hope. They point to the negotiations for limited Palestinian self-rule in the territories as an opening.

“Perhaps it will be the start of establishing a new society,” says Zuheira Kamal, an adviser to the Palestinian negotiating team. While many younger Palestinian women say they want change, they dislike what they see as the lonely and often frenetic lives of their Western sisters.

“I would like Palestinian women to be free, but within the framework of Arab tradition,” says Sleim, who lives in El Bireh, a town just north of Jerusalem. “The family should stay strong. I don't want to turn my children loose when they are 18.” Indeed, the traditional life has much to offer, especially the warmth and security of family.

Household chores and child care are shared by many. Women can drop off their kids at a relative's without prior notice. The elderly are cared for at home, and old-age homes are unheard of. But the rules are tough. “Our lives are full of the fear of men,” says Hania Aswad, a 22-year-old women's rights activist.

Hanna Saed, 43, from the West Bank refugee camp of Dheishe near Bethlehem, said her father pulled her out of school at age 14 and engaged her to his friend's son, 17-year-old Ismail, to cement ties between the two families. “I used to cry when I watched my brothers prepare their books for the new school year.

If I had been allowed, I would have finished school and become a teacher,” says Saed, smoothing her traditional red-on-black embroidered robe and white head scarf in a nervous gesture. Saed says she still cannot leave the house without her husband's permission. Like Sahar Sleim, Saed stakes her hopes on education.

A proud smile comes over her soft face when she describes how she kept her three daughters in school despite objections from her father-in-law. The oldest, Maha, is a lab technician, and Suzanna and Noha are honor students in high school. Education is one area where many of the 900,000 women in the occupied lands have made great strides. In 1970, 65 percent had no schooling.

Twenty years later, that number was down to around 30 percent. The percentage of women attending university rose from 0.5 to 6.2 in the West Bank, and from 0.5 to 4.9 in Gaza during that period. Still, only some 30,000 Palestinian women, most of them single, work outside the home.

Most have menial jobs, cleaning for Israelis, picking fruit or working in Palestinian and Israeli factories. Women with college degrees become teachers, bookkeepers and clerical workers. Only a few have made a career in business. It is the educated women who often face the toughest choice between tradition and Western ideas.

Hania Aswad and her younger sister set up house together while studying at the University of Texas in Austin. Their father retaliated by cutting off financial support and Aswad had to abandon her interior design course after two semesters because she couldn't study holding two jobs.

Aswad's parents divorced 18 years ago, and a year ago she returned from the United States to live with her mother, Mahboubeh, in the West Bank town of Ramallah. Aswad says her outspoken feminism clashes with convention. Mothers of girlfriends have blacklisted her as a bad influence and friends urge her to keep her mouth shut and find a husband.

“Some men have asked for my hand. But I've refused them because I don't want someone who is afraid of my beliefs,” she says. At her desk at the Women's Studies Center, she looks like any other Western college student, in jeans, T-shirt and unruly black ponytail. Even smaller issues often lead to a confrontation.

Sousan, 31, a West Bank teacher who moved back in with her family after divorcing, says her father initially refused to let her take driving lessons. He feared the neighbors would gossip if she spent time alone with a male instructor. So her younger brother played chaperon, sitting in the back seat. Most women still follow the traditional path of housewife and mother.

Though no statistics are available, the average number of children is estimated down from nine to six since the 1960s, and Palestinian women still have one of the world's highest birth rates.

In recent years, the percentage of women using birth control rose from five to 15, said Mirray Jhniem of the Women's Resource Center, the main source of contraceptives in the occupied lands. But the center only dispenses contraceptives to women whose husbands consent, and advises that they be used only for spacing between pregnancies, not to limit the number of children.

It does not perform sterilizations. Jhniem says the center's rules are stringent because it has to stay clear of Muslim fundamentalists and political activists. The PLO encourages childbirth to compete demographically with Israel. When the Palestinian uprising began in December 1987, many women's activists were euphoric.

They saw the rebellion as weakening the patriarchs' grip and pushing women forward, notably Hanan Ashrawi, spokeswoman of the Palestinian peace delegation. In the initial mass protests, women won respect by standing alongside men and throwing stones at Israeli soldiers. But many gains later disappeared, Kamal says.

Muslim fundamentalists moved in, sending modesty squads to roam the streets and ambush women with tomatoes and even acid for not covering their heads. The average age of marriage for women fell from 20 to 17 during the uprising.

Daughters are married off quickly because money is tight as a result of the revolt and potential husbands more scarce due to the mass arrests, Kamal says. She says women have a chance only if autonomy works without bloodshed. “And even then, we won't see this social change in this generation,” Kamal says. “It will be for the next one.”

Palestinian women cut grass in a field near Bethlehem. Women have played a prominent part in the uprising against Israeli rule. · A candy plant provides work for these Palestinian women. A daughter can face banishment if she takes a job against her father's wishes.

The third printing of this Associated Press dispatch in the archive, run under the standing label TOPIC A. Karin Laub is not credited here. This version alone carries the modesty squads, the acid, Hanan Ashrawi and the line about the PLO encouraging childbirth. It does not carry the 47 women killed and 3,000 detained by the army, which The Grand Rapids Press printed on 7 January.

CP-1993-016 →

· Daily Chronicle · DeKalb · page 16

Situation of Palestinian women slowly changing

By Karin Laub, Associated Press Writer

Editor's note: The situation of Palestinian women is changing, albeit ever so slowly. They still live in a male-dominated society, survive in a culture which stonily limits the role of women to home and children. But they are exposed more and more to Western culture and a rebellion that puts them in the front lines.

EL BIREH, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Sahar Sleim gets up at 4 a.m., sews blouses for Israeli shops for a dollar apiece, then throughout the day cooks, cleans, oversees her children's homework, sews again and collapses into bed at 9 p.m. Her husband, Walid, often gripes when he comes home from his tailor shop because Sahar has no time for him.

But she is quietly resisting his growing demands to give up her job. “I work so my children can finish university,” Mrs. Sleim says from behind the sewing machine in her living room. “I want my daughters to be independent. I want them to get an education and only then to marry. I don't want them to repeat my mistakes.” Mrs.

Sleim, 38, married Walid, a distant cousin, at age 19 under pressure from her father. She had hoped to study engineering by correspondence with Beirut University, but the dream died when the first of her six children was born. “If I could choose now between a husband and university, I would choose university,” Mrs. Sleim says bitterly. “Sewing blouses is not enough.” Mrs.

Sleim is among a growing number of younger Palestinian women who want to be more than housewives and mothers, completely subservient to fathers, brothers and husbands. The social mores in the occupied lands are no different from most of the Arab world.

But 25 years under Israeli occupation have exposed the West Bank and Gaza Strip to a Western industrialized society where contraceptives, college and careers are available to both sexes. Palestinian women's status has also been boosted, ironically, by resistance to occupation. Women have played a prominent role in the five-year uprising in the occupied territories.

But a full-scale feminist revolt seems far away. Women keep their complaints among themselves. Open dissent is severely dealt with: a daughter faces beatings, even banishment from the family, if she gets a job against her father's wishes. In rare cases, unmarried women who eloped were killed by their fathers or brothers for besmirching the family honor.

Still, some feminists see hope. They point to the negotiations with the Israelis for limited Palestinian self-rule in the territories as an opening. “Perhaps it will be the start of establishing a new society,” says Zuheira Kamal, an adviser to the Palestinian negotiating team.

But women will have to fight for any gains because the Palestinians' struggle for a state overrides all else, she adds. For example, the Palestinian team appointed Kamal to draft women's rights legislation, such as equal pay, to be considered under autonomy. But she says she got the go-ahead only after much pleading.

While many younger Palestinian women say they want change, they dislike what they see as the lonely and often frenetic lives of their Western sisters. “I would like Palestinian women to be free, but within the framework of Arab tradition,” says Mrs. Sleim, who lives in El Bireh, a town just north of Jerusalem. “The family should stay strong.

I don't want to turn my children loose when they are 18.” Indeed, the traditional life has much to offer, especially the warmth and security of family. Household chores and child care are shared by many. After a woman gives birth, female relatives for the first weeks take care of her house and the older children.

Women can drop off their kids at a relative's without prior notice. Mothers, daughters and neighbors often cook together while sitting in a circle and chatting. The elderly are cared for at home, and old-age homes are unheard of. But the system only works because every family member obeys the rules, which are enforced by men.

Fathers and older brothers decide whether girls should study and whom they should marry. Husbands determine how many children the wife will have, what the wife should wear, where she should socialize. Divorcees are stigmatized. Polygamy is still practiced, though it is more rare than in the past, and men can get a divorce more easily than women.

“Our lives are full of the fear of men,” says Hania Aswad, a 22-year-old women's rights activist. Hanna Saed, 43, from the West Bank refugee camp of Dheishe near Bethlehem, said her father pulled her out of school at age 14 and engaged her to his friend's son, 17-year-old Ismail, to cement ties between the two families.

“I used to cry when I watched my brothers prepare their books for the new school year. If I had been allowed, I would have finished school and become a teacher,” says Mrs. Saed, smoothing her traditional red-on-black embroidered robe and white head scarf in a nervous gesture. Married at age 15, Mrs.

Saed moved in with her in-laws in Dheishe where she cooked and cleaned for a 13-member household. A year later, the young couple moved into its own home, a one-room shack in Dheishe furnished with a gas cooker, two beds, a table and chairs, and an outhouse and well. Here, Mrs. Saed raised three girls and three boys on Ismail's meager income as an olive wood carver.

The children slept on mattresses that were stacked during the day, and menial jobs, cleaning for Israelis, picking fruit or working in Palestinian and Israeli factories. The law obliges Israeli employers to pay basic social benefits, but some dodge it by hiring unregistered workers. And the law doesn't apply in the occupied territories.

The 20,000 women working there have no medical insurance and only after 15 years on the job are they entitled to a small pension, said researchers at the Women's Studies Center near Jerusalem. A female factory worker earns an average of $170 a month, or enough to buy a food processor or 10 sacks of rice. In some areas, wages are as low as $28 a month. Males average $300.

Pieceworkers like Mrs. Sleim get just over $1 dollar to sew a blouse and 75 cents for a pair of jeans. Women with college degrees become teachers, bookkeepers and clerical workers. It is the educated women who often face the toughest choice between tradition and Western ideas.

Hania Aswad and her younger sister set up house together while studying at the University of Texas took turns at the table to do their homework. Mrs. Saed says she still cannot leave the house without her husband's permission. Like Sahar Sleim, Mrs. Saed stakes her hopes on education.

A proud smile comes over her soft face when she describes how she kept her three daughters in school despite objections from her father-in-law. The oldest, Maha, is a lab technician, and Suzanna and Noha are honor students in high school. Education is one area where many of the 900,000 women in the occupied lands have made great strides. In 1970, 65 percent had no schooling.

Twenty years later, that number was down to around 30 percent. The percentage of women attending university rose from 0.5 to 6.2 in the West Bank, and from 0.5 to 4.9 in Gaza during that period. Still, only some 30,000 Palestinian women, most of them single, work outside the home.

Most have But the center only dispenses contraceptives to women whose husbands consent, and advises that they be used only for spacing between pregnancies, not to limit the number of children. It does not perform sterilizations. Abortions are illegal, though some doctors perform them secretly. Mrs.

Jhniem says the center's rules are stringent because it has to stay clear of Muslim fundamentalists and political activists. The PLO encourages childbirth to compete demographically with Israel. When the Palestinian uprising began in December 1987, many women's activists were euphoric.

They saw the rebellion as weakening the patriarchs' grip and pushing women forward, notably Hanan Ashrawi, spokeswoman of the Palestinian peace delegation. In the initial mass protests, women won respect by standing alongside men and throwing stones at Israeli soldiers. Forty-seven women have been killed and 3,000 detained by the army since 1987.

But many gains later disappeared, Kamal says. Muslim fundamentalists moved in, sending modesty squads to roam the streets and ambush women with tomatoes and even acid for not covering their heads. Long curfews and mass arrests have raised family tensions, and there have been more reports of wife-beating.

There are no statistics, but women activists say domestic violence is widespread and tolerated. There are no shelters for battered women. The average age of marriage for women fell from 20 to 17 during the uprising. Daughters are married off quickly because money is tight as a result of the revolt and potential husbands more scarce due to the mass arrests, Kamal says.

She says women have a chance only if autonomy works without bloodshed. “And even then, we won't see this social change in this generation,” Mrs. Kamal says. “It will be for the next one.”

The fourth printing of this dispatch in the archive and the fullest. It is the only one of the four to carry the sentence about domestic violence and the absence of shelters. Thirteen months later the same reporter filed on the opening of the first shelter in the Arab world. The paper’s own typesetting scrambles two columns, so the text jumps mid-sentence in two places. It is transcribed as printed.

CP-1993-017 →

· The Daily Press · Newport News

Rabin defends plan to return Palestinians

Asserts right to future deportations

JERUSALEM Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin told Parliament on Wednesday that his agreement with the United States to bring back a quarter of the 400 Palestinians banished to Lebanon had preserved his right to deport hundreds more people in the future.

“The principle of our ability to remove for a limited time hundreds of inciters, leaders, organizers remains,” he said, replying to harsh criticism that he had surrendered to Washington this week by accepting the swift return of 100 deportees to the occupied territories.

In a vigorous defense of both the expulsions and the compromise, the Labor prime minister asserted that no government over the last two decades, most of which were dominated by the hawkish Likud Party, had been bolder than his when it came to exiling Palestinians deemed to be security threats.

“I believe this decision was a correct one, an exceptional decision that in the last 20 years no government in Israel dared take,” he said in remarks that were interrupted by heckling from both the right and left.

Israeli officials said later that the prime minister’s declaration of his right to expel still more people did not mean he actually planned to do so. To the contrary, senior officials turned their attention to putting the seven-week-old crisis behind them.

They urged Arab countries not to let the deportations get in the way of resuming the stalled Middle East peace talks. But with the deportees still camped on a snow-covered hillside in southern Lebanon, where they say they will not budge until all are taken back, the Israelis acknowledge that their troubles remain very much alive.

They express confidence that they are safe from U.N. sanctions. But they add that they nonetheless risk a new condemnation from the Security Council for violating a mid-December resolution instructing Israel to return all the exiles.

And they still must deal with the diplomatic and public-relations damage caused by daily televised images of Palestinians in tents, demanding to go home. So it could be, one official said, that the world will wearily tell the Palestinians that it is time to move on, or “it could be a fight on the Security Council front and on the CNN front.”

The peace talks are supposed to resume next week, with multilateral discussions on issues affecting the entire region, and continue with direct bilateral negotiations between Israel and delegations representing the Palestinians, Syria, Jordan and Lebanon.

But since the expulsions, Palestinian delegates have said they will not take part, and question marks surround the Arab countries. Foreign Minister Shimon Peres said Wednesday that he thought Syria was more interested in resuming the talks than in dwelling on the deportees, Islamic fundamentalists whom the Arab negotiators also regard as threats.

ARAFAT REACTION Yasser Arafat, chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, Wednesday rejected Israel’s agreement to return some Palestinian deportees and shorten the exile of others. Arafat condemned the move as an attempt to “go around” United Nations Security Council Resolution 799, which calls for the immediate return of the deportees.

Arafat accused the United Nations of applying a “double standard” in its dealings with the Arabs in Israel. “The only one who has the ability to say no to the United Nations resolutions without being afraid of any punishment or sanctions is the naughty baby,” said Arafat, “the Israelis.”

RABIN, Heckled.

CP-1993-024 →

· The Journal Star

Israeli soldiers raid wedding party

Associated Press

JERUSALEM (AP) — Undercover Israeli soldiers raided a Palestinian wedding party in an occupied West Bank village, wounding the father of the bride and arresting her brother, Arab reports said Friday.

The Israeli army said troops carried out a raid in Barta on Thursday afternoon, but would not say whether the target was a wedding reception nor whether the soldiers were in civilian dress. Arab reports said the soldiers shot and wounded the bride’s father, Yousef Kabaha, in the leg while arresting her brother Marouf, 28. Two other men were also arrested at the party.

The army confirmed that Marouf Kabaha was arrested and said he has been wanted for a year on suspicion of weapons possession and attacking alleged Arab collaborators. Kabaha’s father, along with two other party guests later detained, threw stones at soldiers. The elder Kabaha was shot and wounded after he ran away and ignored calls to halt, the army said.

A wedding reception in Barta, and the whole of what an American reader is told about it fits in eight paragraphs. Two Palestinians are named, both by their relationship to the bride: her father Yousef Kabaha, shot in the leg, and her brother Marouf, 28, arrested. The bride is not named. It is her wedding, and she is the fixed point everyone else is described from.

CP-1993-012 →

· Albany Democrat-Herald · page 1

Palestinian woman to perform at OSU

CORVALLIS — Emily Shihadeh will present a one-woman performance at Oregon State University on Sunday, March 7, that looks at her life growing up in Jerusalem and the Israeli-occupied West Bank and her subsequent move to America. The performance, “Grapes and Figs are in Season: A Palestinian Woman’s Story,” will begin at 7:30 p.m. in the Engineering Auditorium of the LaSells Stewart Center, 26th and Western in Corvallis.

It is free and open to the public. Shihadeh, a Palestinian-American, blends comedy, storytelling and songs to tell her personal story of how she “found beauty within, then opened to the beauty of the other, including her enemy.”

“Grapes and Figs” interweaves Shihadeh’s experiences with politics, history, love, violent death, the loneliness of refugees, and interpersonal relationships with family.

Four inches in an Oregon daily, announcing a Palestinian woman performing her own life in an engineering auditorium in Corvallis, free, with comedy and songs in it.

CP-1993-009 →

· The New York Times

The Other Israel

By Robin Wright

IN 1961, John Howard Griffin’s “Black Like Me” stunned and shamed white America.

The painful, even wrenching reportage about the life of black Americans, then the largest minority in the United States at 10 percent, was particularly credible — and damning — because it was written by a white who altered his skin pigmentation to journey across the nation’s deepest divide.

The injustices that echoed through its pages stirred the American conscience and helped, in a small way, to spur the 1960’s civil rights movement. David Grossman, an Israeli journalist and novelist, has written a work of equal force and importance.

In “Sleeping on a Wire: Conversations With Palestinians in Israel,” an Israeli Jew crosses another of the world’s deepest divides for encounters with Israel’s largest minority, its Arab citizens, who are almost 20 percent of the nation’s population. (These Arabs are not to be confused, as they often are, with those in the occupied territories.)

Mr. Grossman’s reportage, ably translated by Haim Watzman, is just as haunting and painful as was John Howard Griffin’s.

On his journey, the author discovers an anonymous people, now numbering almost a million men, women and children, who have lived in “suspended animation” since 1948, when they chose to stay in the new state of Israel rather than to flee.

Two are young men, one who dreamed of a career in science, the other in philosophy; they instead ended up working as unskilled laborers because their Arab schools had outdated curriculums, because state tests for advancement were saturated with questions on Jewish culture and history, because the tests were in Hebrew.

Another is a doctor who stoically observes that the state confiscated two-thirds of his village’s land and that what remained of the village had to wait 20 years longer than the adjacent Jewish settlement for electricity.

But what burns his soul is the way his two small children were turned back from a swimming pool, after being sold tickets, when the attendant heard them speak Arabic. Each chapter is a different encounter; the compilation, moving and powerful, covers the political and cultural spectrum. Mr.

Grossman is particularly chilled by his conversations in Ein Hud, one of 51 Arab villages not acknowledged or served by the state: neither the homes built nor the children born there are recognized. The residents are known as “present absentees” because they fled their towns but not their country in 1948.

The members of one Ein Hud family, for example, moved into a shepherd’s hut on their farmland; 45 years later, they are still there. Their village has been taken over, their mosque turned into a restaurant and disco, their Muslim cemetery desecrated by garbage and the burial of pets.

After Israel failed to persuade Arab “absentees” to sell the land they were no longer allowed to live on, it officially confiscated the property in 1964. The family’s father now earns $400 a month working the land he once owned; he cannot buy a new farm because laws prohibit the sale of land to non-Jews.

“For several days I looked at Israel through the eyes of the present absentees,” Mr. Grossman writes, “and I knew how much this merciful country of mine, which sends medicine and blankets to every Kurdish refugee and every earthquake survivor in Armenia, how well it also knows how to put on a stone face.”

He is reminded of a poem that ends, “How tiring it is to be evil.” Mr. Grossman also agonizes with an “honorary” Arab, a Jewish woman who considered Arabs threatening and little more than objects — until she fell in love with one. After their marriage, she had to lease their Jerusalem home, since the landlord would not rent to her Arab husband.

Her father sat shiva for her, and later refused her sister’s deathbed request for a family reconciliation. Recounting how roadblock checks and searches have become a way of life, she muses, “Isn’t it a horrible thing when you become accustomed to the absurd?” Mr. Grossman’s subjects are not exceptions.

As of 1991, he tells us, 92 percent of Arab workers were on the bottom half of the wage scale, while 60 percent of Arab children lived in poverty, compared with 10 percent of Jewish children. Of 4,000 directors on 200 boards of Government-owned companies, only one was an Arab, and of 5,100 full-time Israeli professors, only 12 were Arabs.

The 400 state prosecutors responsible for Israeli justice included not one Arab, and the Department for Muslim Affairs was headed by a Jew. “How long can a relatively large minority be assumed by the majority to be an enemy without in the end actually turning into one?” Mr. Grossman asks.

“How long can the state exist as a stable political framework if this is how it treats a sixth of its citizens?” One of Mr. Grossman’s major contributions is redefining the Israeli Arab “issue” in terms of human rights, not just security.

Although still treated and feared as archenemies, most Israeli Arabs have integrated after a half-century, he contends. The new reality is reflected not only in the fact that most Arabs spoke to Mr. Grossman in Hebrew, but also in a 1989 poll conducted by the Guttmann Institute for Applied Social Research.

It showed that 75 percent of the Arabs do not want to live outside Israel — compared to 80 percent of Jews. Despite strong feelings about the Palestinian intifada in the neighboring territories — an event foreshadowed in Mr.

Grossman’s last work of nonfiction, “The Yellow Wind” — Israel’s Arabs are struggling now mainly for their own equality within Israel. To his credit, the author does not absolve himself.

“How could I not have ever exposed myself, until now, to the tangle of emotions and anguish of the Arab who wishes to be part of the Israeli reality yet finds himself endlessly rejected, suspected, detested?” he wonders. “I did not, I knew not, I remembered not, and I thought not.”

And he admits his own anxiety about having Arabs in Israel’s cabinet and other Government offices, and in the army. But in the end, he concludes, denial is worse. “Slowly and steadily, as if slumbering, Israel is missing its chance to rescue itself from a horrible mistake,” Mr. Grossman warns.

“It is creating for itself the enemy it will run up against after its other enemies have made their peace with it.”

CP-1993-039 →

· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota

Palestinian women on the brink of change

Feminists have hope

By Karin Laub, Associated Press

They live in a male-dominated society, but Palestinian women are being exposed to Western culture, and some want more than subservience. EL BIREH, Occupied West Bank — Sahar Sleim gets up at 4 a.m., sews blouses for Israeli shops for a dollar apiece, then throughout the day cooks, cleans, oversees her children's homework, sews again and collapses into bed at 9 p.m.

Her husband, Walid, often gripes when he comes home from his tailor shop because Sahar has no time for him. But she is quietly resisting his growing demands to give up her job. “I work so my children can finish university,” Mrs. Sleim says from behind the sewing machine in her living room. “I want my daughters to be independent.

I want them to get an education and only then to marry. I don't want them to repeat my mistakes.” Mrs. Sleim, 38, married Walid, a distant cousin, at age 19 under pressure from her father. She had hoped to study engineering by correspondence with Beirut University, but the dream died when the first of her six children was born.

“If I could choose now between a husband and university, I would choose university,” Mrs. Sleim says bitterly. “Sewing blouses is not enough.” Mrs. Sleim is among a growing number of younger Palestinian women who want to be more than housewives and mothers, completely subservient to fathers, brothers and husbands.

The social mores in the occupied lands are no different from most of the Arab world. But 25 years under Israeli occupation have exposed the West Bank and Gaza Strip to a Western industrialized society where contraceptives, college and careers are available to both sexes. Palestinian women's status has also been boosted, ironically, by resistance to occupation.

Women have played a prominent role in the five-year uprising in the occupied territories. But a full-scale feminist revolt seems far away. Women keep their complaints among themselves. Open dissent is severely dealt with: a daughter faces beatings, even banishment from the family, if she gets a job against her father's wishes.

In rare cases, unmarried women who eloped were killed by their fathers or brothers for besmirching the family honor. Still, some feminists see hope. They point to the negotiations with the Israelis for limited Palestinian self-rule in the territories as an opening.

“Perhaps it will be the start of establishing a new society,” says Zuheira Kamal, an adviser to the Palestinian negotiating team. But women will have to fight for any gains because the Palestinians' struggle for a state overrides all else, she adds.

For example, the Palestinian team appointed Kamal to draft women's rights legislation, such as equal pay, to be considered under autonomy. But she says she got the go-ahead only after much pleading. While many younger Palestinian women say they want change, they dislike what they see as the lonely and often frenetic lives of their Western sisters.

“I would like Palestinian women to be free, but within the framework of Arab tradition,” says Mrs. Sleim, who lives in El Bireh, a town just north of Jerusalem. “The family should stay strong. I don't want to turn my children loose when they are 18.” Indeed, the traditional life has much to offer, especially the warmth and security of family.

Household chores and child care are shared by many. After a woman gives birth, female relatives for the first weeks take care of her house and the older children. Women can drop off their kids at a relative's without prior notice. Mothers, daughters and neighbors often cook together while sitting in a circle and chatting.

The elderly are cared for at home, and old-age homes are unheard of. But the system only works because every family member obeys the rules, which are enforced by men. Fathers and older brothers decide whether girls should study and whom they should marry. Husbands determine how many children the wife will have, what the wife should wear, where she should socialize.

Divorcees are stigmatized. Polygamy is still practiced, though it is PLEASE SEE PALESTINIANS ON 6F

Palestinian women cut grass near Bethlehem in the Occupied West Bank. (AP PHOTOS)

The fifth printing of this dispatch in the archive, and the only one to run three months after the others. It is also the only one to add a standfirst written by the paper rather than the reporter, telling the reader what the story means before the story begins. The clipping ends at PLEASE SEE PALESTINIANS ON 6F; the continuation is not in the scan.

CP-1993-018 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore

Israeli soldiers fatally shoot two children during stone-throwing protests.

Subject, verb, object, and the object is two children. Fatally shoot is as plain as these headlines get. Then the last four words supply the setting and, with it, the reason: the children were at stone-throwing protests. This archive holds the same construction in 1988 (CP-1988-022) and in 2001 (CP-2001-004).

CP-1993-002 →

· The Orlando Sentinel · Orlando · page 1

Israeli army kills 5 Arabs in Gaza, witnesses say

“JABALYA, Gaza Strip — The Israeli army shot and killed four Palestinians in the occupied Gaza Strip on Tuesday, and a fifth Arab died of wounds, Palestinian witnesses and hospitals said. Troops shot dead at least three Palestinians and wounded at least 35 in a single incident in the Gaza town of Jabalya, witnesses said.”

Everything in the headline is attributed to witnesses. The clipping is two paragraphs long.

CP-1993-003 →

· The New York Times

ISRAEL SHIFTS VIEW ON OCCUPIED LANDS

Emergency Measure to Limit Movement of Arabs May Bring Permanent Split

By JOEL GREENBERG / Special to The New York Times

JERUSALEM, May 29 — When the Israeli Government sealed off the West Bank and Gaza Strip in late March, it was responding to Palestinian attacks that had killed 15 Israelis that month. Now, what began as an emergency measure is becoming a fixture, and changing entrenched Israeli attitudes toward the occupied territories.

The closing is the longest separation of Palestinians from Israelis since the two populations began mingling after Israel captured the territories in the 1967 war. It is a significant shift from the open-door policies set in the early years of the occupation by Defense Minister Moshe Dayan.

Now, Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin has promised that the days of free Arab movement into Israel are over. To some officials, the separation has sent a clear political signal that the current Labor-led Government, unlike its Likud-led predecessor, is not wedded to the occupied territories.

“The headline is: We’re on the way out,” said Housing Minister Binyamin Ben-Eliezer, a former military governor in the West Bank. “The closing indicates the direction this Government is going, which is separation from the territories through an interim period of Palestinian self-rule.” No Big Happy Family Gad Ben-Ari, Mr.

Rabin’s spokesman, said that another lesson of the last two months was that “there is no concept of a Greater Israel in which the Palestinians will live with us like one big happy family.”

“The relatively calm public reaction to the Government’s decision shows that the illusion of coexistence with the Palestinians, one inside the other, doesn’t sell,” he said.

The ban prevents most of the 1.8 million Palestinians in the territories from entering Israel and East Jerusalem, including about 100,000 laborers who cannot reach their jobs and whose absence has been keenly felt by Israeli farmers and contractors.

CP-1993-041 →

· Houston Chronicle · Houston

Kids are in harm’s way

Bernard J. Shapiro, director, Freeman Center for Strategic Studies, Houston

“The story, ‘Palestinian child deaths on the rise’ (Chronicle, May 19), raises some issues that need more discussion. As a parent, I am greatly disturbed by the untimely death of any child. This story, however, fails to explain the cause of the problem or point to its solution.

International covenants of human rights and the rights of children specifically prohibit the induction of children under 15 years of age into the armed forces of any nation. They also prohibit the use of children under 15 in political demonstrations and activities where they are likely to suffer harm.

In contradiction to these principles, Palestinians have frequently used not only children but also women as shields in political confrontations. In Lebanon, for instance, Palestine Liberation Organization training bases were frequently located near schools, hospitals or other civilian areas. They may wish that the Israelis would refrain from attacking those bases.

Unfortunately the primary purpose is to create negative public relations for Israel when civilian casualties inevitably occur. It is in fact the ease with which they are able to blacken Israel’s reputation with the assistance of the media that promotes this policy.

The sure-fire method of preventing Palestinian child deaths is for their parents to keep them out of violent demonstrations. Soccer, basketball, football and other sports should be organized to channel the energy of these kids. Attacking Israeli soldiers is neither an appropriate nor safe activity for children.

Israeli soldiers — many of them just 18 years old — will certainly defend their lives if attacked. Without getting into the complex issues involved, I can say with authority that Palestinian parents must take responsibility for their children’s safety.

The sad thing is that the media’s rush to blame Israel for every dead child plays into the callous calculations of the PLO. As long as Palestinians continue to win sympathy on the altar of dead Palestinian children, they will continue to place them in harm’s way.

If there would occur a moral outrage in the West against the use of children in this manner, the Palestinians would gain no advantage from sacrificing their sons and daughters. The killing would stop.”

A reader arguing with his own paper’s reporting, five years after a Memphis reader did the same thing from the opposite direction. This one answers a Chronicle story about rising Palestinian child deaths and locates the cause in Palestinian parents and in the media. The human-shields construction is here in 1993, applied to children and women, and the closing sentence makes the deaths conditional on Western outrage.

CP-1993-011 →

· Grand Forks Herald · Grand Forks · page 2A

Palestinian children in deadly tug of war

In the Mideast

Karin Laub, Associated Press, Jebaliya, Occupied Gaza Strip

“232 Palestinian minors have been killed by troops in occupied lands since 1987… JEBALIYA, Occupied Gaza Strip — Ten-year-old Issat Matar was flying a homemade kite on a dusty square when a playmate threw a stone at two passing Israeli army jeeps.

Palestinian witnesses say the jeeps stopped, a soldier climbed down and fired at the fleeing boys, wounding Issat in the back of the head. Issat died Tuesday, two days later, becoming the 41st Palestinian under age 16 to be shot dead in the occupied lands since December.

The sharp increase in shooting deaths of Palestinian minors is fueling mutual distrust at a time when Israeli-Palestinian peace negotiations are at a deadlock. Each side on Wednesday accused the other of using children as a tool to heat up the atmosphere in the talks.

Deputy Defense Minister Motta Gur, defending the army actions against left-wing critics in Parliament, claimed the Palestinians were intentionally sending their children to the front lines of Palestinian protests. He bristled at suggestions that soldiers deliberately shot at children. ‘It’s a blood libel,’ Gur said.

The Israeli human rights organization Betselem said last week that, until June 8, 232 Palestinian minors have been killed by troops in occupied lands since the Palestinian uprising began in this refugee camp on Dec. 9, 1987. Betselem said troops increasingly use live ammunition, even when children are present.

It said that of 38 children killed between December and June 8, only six were shot dead in situations that posed a danger to soldiers’ lives. The army doesn’t dispute the death toll.

But an army statement said soldiers are not permitted to shoot at anyone under 15 and that most children killed were in ‘large rioting crowds, near armed terrorists . . . or in circumstances where soldiers didn’t know children were there.’… ‘I want to be like the masked men, but I’m also afraid of them,’ said 13-year-old Khalil Madhoun.

Among the adults, there is great bitterness. ‘I cannot forgive the Israelis for what they have done, even if there will be peace,’ said Issat’s aunt… On top of the closet in Issat’s room stood the octagonal skeleton of a kite that Issat was making. It was like the light blue and pink one he was flying on Sunday.”

“Eight-year-old Maha Al-Haweiti screams in pain as her mother lifts her to a hospital bed in Gaza City in the Occupied Gaza Strip Wednesday. Maha was shot by Israeli soldiers Sunday.

Forty-one Palestinian children under the age of 16 have been shot by the Israelis since December, prompting Palestinian spokeswoman Hanan Ashrawi to say ‘Israel . . . persists in human rights abuses as a means of exacting a political price.’” Associated Press

The figures are an Israeli human rights organization’s and the army does not dispute the toll. The army’s own explanation is printed beside them.

CP-1993-004 →

· Journal Tribune · Biddeford

Palestinians dance in street celebrating self-rule pact

By Karin Laub, Associated Press

JERICHO, Occupied West Bank — With their once-banned flag flying overhead, thousands of Palestinians danced arm-in-arm today celebrating the prospect of shedding a quarter-century of Israeli military rule. “Today we are celebrating our state from Jericho to Gaza,” said Jamal Safi, a local leader. “Today we are holding our heads up proudly.”

Instead of soldiers, the streets were patrolled by about 200 activists from Fida, a moderate pro-PLO party… beating of drums filled the air. Pictures of Yasser Arafat and the red, white, green and black Palestinian flags decorated the town’s main square where Palestinians marched and shouted pro-Arafat slogans.

A billboard-sized portrait of Arafat was painted on the town hall. “I just love to see all those flags going up,” said Nancy Qunbar, an 18-year-old student. “I only hope…” Monawar Salah, 60, who heads the Jericho Women’s Benevolent Society, said she stayed up until midnight to sew 50 cloth flags.

“It’s the first step toward ending the occupation and we hope all Palestinians will rally around the leadership and help them end the occupation.” The call for unity was timely…

A Palestinian man dances in a Jericho street in front of the Palestinian flag this morning. (AP Wirephoto)

The day the Oslo accords were signed, and the detail that survives is a sixty-year-old woman who sat up until midnight sewing fifty flags. Monawar Salah runs the Jericho Women’s Benevolent Society. The flag she was sewing had been banned. Two other Palestinians are named and one is a teenager: Nancy Qunbar, 18, who says she just loves seeing the flags go up.

CP-1993-013 →

· Longview Daily News · Longview

Israel, PLO sign historic peace plan

WASHINGTON (AP) — After 40 years as a wandering guerrilla leader, Yasser Arafat today entered the White House to seal a peace accord intended to end decades of hatred, wars and vengeance between Arabs and Jews.

Arafat, speaking on a South Lawn podium as Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin listened, assured the Israelis that the self-rule the Palestinians would gain under the peace pact would in no way threaten them.

“Our people do not consider that exercising the right to self-determination could violate the rights of their neighbors or infringe on their security,” he said to the 3,000 people gathered at the White House for the signing ceremony. The agreement was signed by the Palestine Liberation Organization’s No.

2 official, Mahmoud Abbas, and Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres. Arafat then initiated a handshake with Rabin. “The battle for peace is the most difficult battle of our lives,” said Arafat, wearing a khaki military-style suit and the traditional kaffiyeh, or Palestinian headdress.

“It deserves our utmost efforts, because the land of peace yearns for a just and comprehensive peace.”

A loud cheer went up on the South Lawn of the White House today when Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin and PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat sealed their new peace agreement with a handshake. It was Arafat who made the first move, reaching in front of President Clinton to extend his hand to Rabin. After a moment’s hesitation, Rabin clasped it.

It was not known beforehand whether the two longtime arch enemies would shake hands. Arafat reached out a second time for Rabin’s hand after the PLO leader concluded his speech. Again, Rabin shook the offered hand but his face showed no emotion and immediately afterward he looked away.

CP-1993-021 →

· estimated · The Daily News · Longview

Palestinians Happy But Israelis Wary

“JERICHO, Occupied West Bank (AP) — One minute, thousands strained to catch the moment on the small TV and transistor radio on a stage in Jericho’s main square. The next, they beat drums, waved flags and danced arm-in-arm as the sun disappeared behind the foothills.

The throngs packing the streets Monday clapped, cheered and sang when Israel and the PLO signed their landmark peace agreement. ‘I feel so good inside,’ said Nasser Prince, a 28-year-old money changer. ‘I hope I and my children will be able to live in a real peace. ‘Now we can be friends with the Israelites.’

The celebrations were striking not only as a display of sheer delirium by a people fighting for years for a homeland, but as a show of support for PLO chief Yasser Arafat. Israeli military patrols in Jericho had orders to stay away so Palestinians could savor the historic day. Some Palestinians gave the soldiers flowers.

PLO activists deployed its own security force to keep the festivities as orderly as possible. Hours before, a strike called by the Islamic fundamentalist foes of Arafat and the accord closed stores and kept cars from the streets in the West Bank.

In Gaza City in the morning, fundamentalists lobbed stones at about 4,000 Palestinians waving flags and chanting support for the deal. The crowd marching through the streets doubled by nightfall. Similar large marches were held elsewhere in Gaza. Israeli soldiers shot and slightly wounded 16 anti-pact demonstrators in clashes in Gaza Monday night.

At Shati refugee camp, Israeli troops wounded 10 Hamas activists hurling stones at them from the roof of a mosque, Arab reporters and hospital officials said. In Gaza City, six other Palestinians were shot after stoning patrolling soldiers.

Palestinian refugees living in neighboring Jordan and Syria tore up pictures of Arafat, burned Israeli flags, marched angrily through the streets and promised to wreck the PLO-Israeli peace. In a Beirut suburb, security forces fired on protesters, killing seven and wounding 41.

In Iran, Tehran radio said ‘Arafat has sold 98 percent (of Palestinian lands) to the Zionist regime.’ In Arab east Jerusalem, thousands of Palestinians waved their once-banned red, white, green and black Palestinian flag. Many wept, kissed each other and sang their national anthem, ‘My Country, My Country.’

Everyone agreed that the Palestinians gained a measure of freedom, but they disagreed on how much. Despite Palestinian proclamations of statehood, few Israelis have ever envisioned this. Benjamin Netanyahu, leader of Israel’s main opposition Likud bloc, called it a ‘historic blunder.’

In Tel Aviv, where many people left work early to watch the signing ceremony or brought TVs to work, Hasbiel Pick said he was the odd man out.”

The day the accord was signed, reported from Jericho, and the first person quoted is not an official. Nasser Prince, a 28-year-old money changer, is named with his age and his trade and given three sentences. The same dispatch counts 16 demonstrators shot by Israeli soldiers that night, 10 more wounded on a mosque roof at Shati and six shot in Gaza City, and it carries the opposition leader calling the agreement a historic blunder.

Correction: {'note': 'This scan arrived captioned 25 August 1961. The copy reports the signing of the Israel—PLO agreement and quotes Benjamin Netanyahu as leader of the Likud opposition, which places it in September 1993. No masthead is in the scan, so the day is taken from the dispatch’s own Monday and marked estimated.'}

CP-1993-010 →

· The New York Times

Reflections on Accord: New Hopes, Old Fears

An Athlete’s Widow Ankie Rekhess-Spitzer is the widow of Andrei Spitzer, one of 11 Israeli athletes killed at the 1972 Summer Olympics in Munich by gunmen of the Black September group in the Palestine Liberation Organization.

On Sunday, a day before the signing of the Israeli-Palestinian peace accords, she joined relatives of other victims at a memorial ceremony on the Hebrew calendar anniversary of the massacre. My response is total confusion. I have a tremendous dilemma. My mind tells me one thing and my heart tells me something else, and I can’t figure it out.

My mind tells me we really don’t have any option: Maybe this will lead to a situation where we can get rid of terrorism. But I don’t have any room in my heart for Arafat. He is a symbol of hatred and terror, and I can’t make the switch in one day. The sensible approach is that we have to have peace. We’ve buried enough dead people.

But I can’t disconnect myself from the fact that Arafat is the father of all terrorists. The image of Arafat applauding the Munich terrorists never leaves my mind. For me, this is a murderer He has blood on his hands. He destroyed 21 years of my life, and maybe we should forgive and forget, but I can’t do it.

I’ve never had a problem with the Palestinian people. I differentiate between terrorists and them. And I understand that we have to be courageous. But I’m not happy. There’s not a lot of hope in my heart, and I’m not totally convinced that this is the answer. I want to see if the words Arafat is saying now can be taken seriously.

A Palestinian Journalist Ali Jiddah, a Palestinian journalist and political activist, spent 17 years in Israeli prisons after he was convicted of planting a bomb that wounded seven Israelis in Jerusalem in 1968.

He was released in a 1985 prisoner exchange between Israel and Ahmed Jabril’s Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine-General Command. This agreement is killing me emotionally. I felt sad and very bitter. I went back to the period when I was arrested, to my experiences in prison, the suffering with my brothers.

I went back to the convoys of martyrs and their mothers. I’ve spent the best days of my life in prison, and I’m one of the people who really needs peace, for my child, who I don’t want to experience what I went through. But we are not heading toward a stable peace. It is a total subjection of the Palestinians to the Israeli and American conditions.

They are not talking about self-determination, establishing an independent state with Jerusalem as its capital, and there’s no mention of the right of return. At the same time they are denying terrorism. What does that mean? That 100,000 Palestinian martyrs since 1967 and the martyrs of the intifada are terrorists?

I didn’t spend 17 years in jail so that Arafat could say I’m a terrorist. I want peace, but real peace between equals. This is artificial, and it won’t last long.

A Palestinian Intellectual Sari Nusseibeh, a Palestinian intellectual and writer who was once jailed by the Israelis, has been a leading strategist for the Palestinians’ peace-talks team. One wants to keep one’s emotions in check. We hope this is a turning point. It opens up a lot of potential for this area and for the two people.

But it is a very fragile agreement, fraught with explosives, and one has to nurture it very tenderly to make sure that it grows — on both sides. There are millions of explosives. But the basic problem is Jerusalem. That issue has to be addressed at a later point.

We hope it will be addressed in such a way that it meets the natural aspirations of the Palestinian people for Jerusalem. And I hope the Israeli authorities will take courageous and generous steps.

On the Palestinian side, we have to act very seriously to make sure that no acts are committed that do not bring the peace effort forward and that might actualy undermine progress toward a state. Above everything else, we need to undergo a lot of education to slow people the impact of such actions as killings of Israelis.

It is not in the interest of the Palestinian people to allow such actions, also violence among the Palestinian people themselves. One cannot dismiss the possibility that at some level this sort of thing will happen. Education is a long process. But there has to be a beginning, and this is a good time to begin.

A Palestinian Journalist Daoud Kuttab This is the best possible plan. It falls short of what a lot of people want, but it’s a cornerstone for the new house not a ceiling. And those who think it may be a ceiling are mistaken if they try to close us off to just Gaza and Jericho.

The reality of what you see today, with flags and feeling proud, shows that Palestinian nationalism is not going back. An Israeli Arab Writer Emile Habibi is an Israeli Arab author and political commentator who is widely read by Palestinians and throughout the Arab world. Israel and the P.L.O. have awarded him their highest literary prizes. Future shock is here.

I feel as if the most sublime goals of my life are coming true. I have lived through the tragedy of my people in 1947. I have tried to take part in realizing the hope that my Palestinian people will overcome this tragedy and safeguard its future in its homeland.

This agreement gives me great hope that we have reached the end of the road of the tragedy of the Palestinian Arab people. So I am very happy and feel great satisfaction. Some say that we, the Palestinians in Israel, have the most to gain from this agreement. It makes it easier.

We stayed here and suffered and refused to be evicted, and we could not have endured all this were it not for the belief that this day would come. At least the fate of the Palestinians as the primary victim of this conflict will come to an end, and we will have put the black days behind us.

Ankie Rekhess-Spitzer — Widow of an Israeli athlete killed at the 1972 Summer Olympics. “My response is total confusion. My mind tells me one thing and my heart tells me something else, and I can’t figure it out.” | Ali Jiddah — A Palestinian journalist active in politics. “This agreement is killing me emotionally.

I felt sad and very bitter. I want peace, but real peace between equals.”

CP-1993-040 →

· Pottsville Republican

Pact marks true end of postwar era

Past loosened its hold in Rabin-Arafat handshake on White House lawn

BOSTON — The same phrase was repeated again and again, until it became the distillation of everyone’s wonder, the common denominator of everyone’s quiet shock: “I never thought I would see this.” Yitzhak Rabin and Yasser Arafat. The Israeli and the Palestinian did not just represent each other’s enemies but each other’s demons.

Parents in Tel Aviv and children in the Gaza Strip have lost sons, daughters, brothers, fathers at each others’ hands. Yet there the two sides were, in a ceremony of gravity and solemnity, full of biblical references and cadences.

The Israeli foreign minister Shimon Peres, signing a paper promising to recognize the “devil” as the legitimate representative of the Palestinian people. The PLO official, Mahmoud Abbas, signing a paper renouncing terrorism and acknowledging the existence of the nation they had promised to wipe off the map. There they were, all of them, shaking hands.

Shaking hands. And witnesses saying: I never thought I would see it. Students of body language may analyze the torturously slow ascent of Rabin’s hand to meet Arafat’s hand. “This signing ... is not so easy,” Rabin had said soberly and his difficulty was palpable. It was if he were lifting an enormous weight at the end of his arm.

But in that handshake, the past loosened its hold. For all the caution, for all the caveats about first steps, the Jewish New Year that begins this week may mark the true end of the postwar period. The unending Middle East crisis was, after all, as permanent a part of the postwar landscape as the Cold War that divided the world into U.S. and U.S.S.R.

But beyond that, for many Jews this period was darkened by the shadow of the Holocaust.

CP-1993-022 →

· The New York Times · page 1 (front page), jump to A17, Column 1

Dividing a Homeland

Can the Israelis and Palestinians Work Out A Way to Share Space They Fought Over?

By THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN / Special to The New York Times

WASHINGTON, Sept. 14 — And now for the hard part.

The importance of Monday's handshake between Yasir Arafat, the P.L.O. chairman, and Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin of Israel is that with one gesture it transformed the problem between them from an ideological struggle over who is the rightful owner of historic Palestine into a practical one over how to share the same living space.

Indeed, the document they signed was less about how they should live separately — that won't happen for a while — and more about how they are going to live together for an interim period of five years while Israel tests the P.L.O. as a secure and stable neighbor. Only after the P.L.O. proves it can live with Israelis might it be allowed to live entirely without them.

The reason that this sharing will prove difficult is that up to now Israel has physically controlled it all, and not simply in military terms, but also in functional ones: from education text books, to the number of oranges that a Gaza farmer can export, to taxation, tourism, and even permission to dig for archeological artifacts.

‘He Needs Space’ “For us to finally recognize Arafat from the outside is one thing,” said Meron Benvenisti, an Israeli historian. “I can say hello to him on the street. But that is not all. Now he is coming into my house. We are going to share some of the rooms. And he needs space, and that is going to be the difficulty at all levels.

Because we are not just talking about physical space. We are talking about everything. It is much more complicated than the peace treaty with Egypt. There, space was being divided. Here it is being shared.” At least for a few years. The agreement between Israel and the P.L.O. sets a timetable for the two sides to negotiate the details of their coexistence.

Their quick calendar looks like this: Within 30 days Israel and the P.L.O. begin negotiations over the details of Israel's troop withdrawal from Gaza and Jericho. Within two months those negotiations are supposed to be completed, and a Palestinian police force, made up mostly of pro-Arafat P.L.O. fighters from abroad, will be imported to keep order in Gaza and Jericho.

Quietly, Israeli and P.L.O. intelligence services will then have to begin cooperating to protect Mr. Arafat and to contain the militants who oppose the agreement.

At the same time, elsewhere in the West Bank, the Israeli military government and civil administration will transfer power to “authorized Palestinians” in five spheres: education and culture, health, social welfare, direct taxation and tourism.

Completion of Withdrawal Four months after that, Israeli troops are supposed to be fully out of Gaza and Jericho, although they will just be down the road, surrounding both places. Within 10 months of today, Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza are to hold elections for a self-governing council, the exact powers of which Israel and the P.L.O. still have to define.

Two issues will be critical: who will control water resources and who will control land-use zoning. Both are now in Israeli hands. Somehow they will have to share, because Israel draws water, for instance, from under the West Bank to irrigate fields as far away as Tel Aviv.

Talkson Final Status Also in the 10th month, by the eve of the Palestinian elections at the latest, Israeli military forces, by then already withdrawn from Gaza and Jericho, will redeploy outside populated areas in the rest of the West Bank. Israeli forces will remain responsible for protecting Israeli settlers and the roads they use, as well as the external borders.

In two years, negotiations between Israel and the P.L.O. over final status of the territories are to begin, and within five years the final status of who will control what is to be resolved. Only then will real, and total, separation be theoretically possible. Until then, the Israelis will be doing most of the giving, and Mr. Arafat will be doing most of the taking.

Consider a few examples: ¶It is very difficult in Israel to get mobile telephones because the army controls so much of the air waves for its own communications. How many channels will the Palestinians get?

In such a small space, everyone has to share. ¶Israel now tightly controls the exports of fruits and vegetables to different markets, always making sure that lower-cost Palestinian farmers are limited in what they can sell to Israel's prized markets in Europe.

Now they will have to share those markets. ¶The accord speaks about the possibility of Israel granting Palestinians a broadcasting license and television station. Again, space will have to be found on the air waves to accommodate them. Will Palestinian broadcasts be subject to Israeli military censorship? ¶The vast majority of males in the Gaza Strip work in Israel. Mr.

Arafat cannot afford for Israel to seal its border with the Arab populated areas of the Gaza Strip; otherwise, his population will not have enough work, at least in the near future. ¶Territorial boundaries remain to be determined. Jericho, for instance, is both a town and a governmental district. Jericho town is a few square blocks that can be traversed by car in five minutes.

The Jericho district is almost as big as the Gaza Strip. Which area the Palestinians will control — the town or the district — still has to be negotiated. Whatever the outcome, Israel will still need free civilian access to Jericho, which sits astride a main north-south highway and the bridges over the Jordan River.

These negotiations, and the degree of sharing between Israelis and Palestinians, are going to be influenced by several factors. The most important is money. It is no accident that Mr. Arafat's influence in the West Bank has fallen since Saudi Arabia and the other Persian Gulf states cut off his money two years ago because he supported Iraq in the gulf war.

Iran stepped into the vacuum and began giving money to the Hamas Muslim organization, which then began to dominate politics in Gaza. Money Brings Power If Mr. Arafat can begin to pour money into Gaza, Jericho and the rest of the West Bank, he can enlarge the pie that he and the Israelis will have to share and thereby get a bigger slice for himself.

The less dependent he is on Israelis for creating jobs, the more he is able to improve roads, sewers and communications in Gaza and Jericho, the more popular he is going to be; if there is no money, he will be in trouble. The second factor that will influence the negotiations is the interplay of Arab politics on the Israeli psyche.

It was a breakthrough for Prime Minister Rabin to go to Morocco on his way home from Israel, and a critically important overture by King Hassan II to receive him. For the message it sends to the Israeli public is that reconciliation with Mr. Arafat means more than just getting him as a neighbor, which doesn't exactly thrill most Israelis.

It also means opening up the Middle East to Israelis, for travel and commerce. Again it comes down to space. It is a lot easier for Israelis to share their limited home with Mr. Arafat if they feel a neighborhood that previously shunned them was now ready to embrace them. But there is a wild card in this inter-Arab game and it is called Syria.

Although President Hafez al-Assad's Ambassador in Washington attended Monday's signing ceremony, Mr. Assad cannot be happy that Mr. Arafat, his old rival, has stolen a march on him. The Clinton Administration and Mr.

Rabin's Government have only so many economic and political resources they can devote to peacemaking at one time, and it is likely that the P.L.O. is now going to take up most of them. Mr. Arafat needs space not only from Israel, but from the Arabs as well. If Mr. Assad is unhappy, he can use his surrogates in the Palestinian community to shrink Mr.

Arafat's political space, by challenging his legitimacy, forcing him to drive unrealistic bargains with Israel and even threatening his life. Neither Israeli nor American officials have an answer yet as to how they intend to keep Mr. Assad interested enough to leave Mr. Arafat alone, but not so interested that Mr.

Rabin feels pressured to withdraw on both the Syrian and Palestinian fronts at once. But if Mr. Assad is unhappy, the region will know about it. As one Syrian official put it: “How do you think President Assad felt watching Yasir Arafat received at the White House while Syria is still on the State Department terrorism list?”

Front page: “Senator Bob Dole of Kansas greeting Yasir Arafat, the chairman of Palestine Liberation Organization, during a visit to the Capitol.” — Agence France Presse. Jump page A17: “In Nablus in the occupied West Bank, a rooftop that was once an observation post for Israeli troops became a stage for Palestinian celebration.” — Associated Press.

CP-1993-043 →

· Newsday · Melville · page 33

Rabin, Arafat: Joined by Their Fear of Zealots

Leslie Susser, diplomatic correspondent of The Jerusalem Report

FOR OVER two decades, Yasser Arafat has been the man Israelis loved to hate. Former Prime Minister Menachem Begin compared him to Hitler. “No one since the Nazis has more Jewish blood on his hands,” he used to say. Deep in the Israeli national psyche, Arafat was a primal force of evil, a prince of darkness, the devil incarnate.

There were two main reasons for this: Arafat’s Palestine Liberation Organization denied Israel’s right to exist; and it employed terror to realize its destructive aims. It killed schoolchildren in Ma’alot, athletes in Munich; it blew up planes and attacked defenseless civilians. It was a faceless enemy without pity and without honor.

And, it seemed, it was an enemy with whom there could be no reconciliation. Zionism and Palestinian national aims as represented by the PLO seemed mutually exclusive. More than any other living Israeli, Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin is associated with the nation’s struggle for survival against this wall of Palestinian and Arab rejectionism.

For Israelis, he is the epitome of the Israeli-born “sabra” hero: the daring, blue-eyed young commander in the elite Palmach force during the 1948 War of Independence, the brilliant army chief of staff of the 1967 Six-Day War in which the occupied territories were captured, and the long-serving prime minister and/or minister of defense who rescued Israelis hijacked to Entebbe in 1976, and who has confronted the Palestinian uprising, the intifada, since 1987.

But for Palestinians, the iconography is reversed. Rabin is the general who said he would “break their bones,” a symbol of the Israeli military might used to crush their national aspirations. And, for them, Yasser Arafat, the revered Abu Amar, is the very embodiment of those aspirations.

For both sides, last week’s Rabin-Arafat handshake on the White House lawn was fraught with symbolic significance. Arafat gave Israel the prize that ultimately only he could confer — legitimacy and acceptance in the Arab Mideast.

And Rabin gave the Palestinians a new legitimacy and acceptance as equals on the international stage, with an implied promise of national self-determination at the end of the road. Yitzhak Rabin made no secret of the fact that for him, personally, it was not easy. In a very deep sense, he was fighting his own national mythology, his own demonization of the Palestinian enemy.

Rabin is an unlikely peacemaker. A cautious and suspicious man, a soldier, in effect, over nearly all his adult life, whether in or out of uniform, he never really wanted to talk to the Tunis-based PLO. He tried to bolster the more moderate Palestinian leadership in the occupied territories so that he wouldn’t have to.

It was only about five months ago that he finally realized that that just wasn’t going to work. By then, Rabin’s arch rival in Israeli politics, Foreign Minister Shimon Peres, was well ahead of the game.

While Rabin and the local Palestinians dithered over details, Peres and his deputy, Yossi Beilin (the man Rabin called “Peres’ poodle”), engineered accommodation with Arafat’s PLO. It took the Norwegian back channel and Peres’ remarkable flair and imagination to pull it off. Rabin could not have done it.

But then Peres could never have sold the deal to the Israeli people. That needed a man with Rabin’s impeccable military credentials. With his deep voice and his slow, deliberate delivery, Rabin is the national reassurer, the trusted father figure, the Israeli de Gaulle.

CP-1993-023 →

· La Crosse Tribune · La Crosse

Conflicts forced Israel to settle with Palestinians

On the surface, the recent Israeli-Palestinian peace accord might seem to be a huge Israeli concession. But a closer examination might show that both sides were under considerable pressure to settle.

In fact, many radicals in the Arab world are accusing the Palestine Liberation Organization’s Yasser Arafat of throwing in the towel — and giving in to an Israeli plan — at the point where Israel was most desperate. But Israel has been asking to get rid of the Gaza Strip for the past six months.

Since late last year, the increase in violence inside Israel proper from Gaza-based terror squads had grown dramatically. Gaza, 130 square miles on the Mediterranean, was given up because Israel could not hold it anymore. Jericho, on the West Bank, was the price Israel had to pay in order to get rebellious Gaza off its back.

The Palestinian uprising, the intifada, was born in Gaza on Dec. 8, 1988. It seems safe to conclude that the intifada played an important role in forcing off Israeli occupation. Col.

Shalom Harare, an intelligence officer at the Israeli Defense Forces who is responsible for security inside the occupied territories, explained the nature of the problem Israel was confronting shortly before the recent outbreak of peace. Palestinians were willing to die for the price of their guns, he said.

“There are so many (Palestinian) operatives available out there that the price of hitting at us kept dropping,” he said. “In the past few months $5,000 was buying a huge amount of firepower for the Palestinians,” Harare told me. “For $2,000 apiece they could buy four M-16s or Uzis. They were probably stolen from our own army.

Then for $300 they could buy a stolen car and the rest could buy them food and hiding for a few months.”

Signing on the Dotted Line

CP-1993-025 →

· Lexington Herald-Leader · Lexington

Palestinians protest in Gaza Strip

JERUSALEM — Hundreds of Palestinian youths stoned Israeli troops searching the Gaza Strip home of a slain Palestinian fugitive yesterday, and three were wounded when the soldiers opened fire. Also yesterday, Israeli-backed militiamen killed a guerrilla on the edge of Israeli-held territory in south Lebanon.

The Israeli army said there were clashes in Gaza City’s Tufah neighborhood, but no injuries were reported. Palestinian sources said two people were shot in the head, including a 12-year-old boy who was in serious condition.

CP-1993-026 →

· The Macon Telegraph · Macon

On the same field

Palestinians, Israelis to compete in '96 Olympics

By Charles W. Holmes, Cox News Service

JERUSALEM — Peace with the Palestinians presented Ankie Rekhess with a troubling and personal dilemma. The widow of one of 11 Israeli athletes shot dead at the 1972 Olympic Games in Munich, Rekhess recalls with difficult emotion the day her husband died at the hands of Palestinian guerrillas.

Now, she faces the likelihood that Palestinian athletes will compete alongside Israelis at the 1996 summer games in Atlanta. The International Olympic Committee has formally recognized a Palestine national team, a byproduct of the peace agreements signed last month between Israel and the PLO.

Palestinian athletes from the Israeli-occupied territories will be able for the first time to compete under their flag at the Atlanta games. In Israel, the decision has stirred deep emotions, raising prospects that some Israelis will urge their country to boycott the '96 games and worrying the Jewish state's Olympic committee.

The surviving families of the Munich tragedy decided to reluctantly accept the IOC's decision, with the stipulation that they will oppose the move if PLO leaders fail to halt violence and terror. For Rekhess, it was a question of whether to accept the Israeli-Palestinian peace and its place in the Olympics ideal, or decry the IOC decision in the memory of her late husband.

Andrei Spitzer, a fencing coach, died at 27, leaving Rekhess alone with a one-month-old daughter. “The head says one thing and the heart says another. You can't put away your emotions, but you've got to be realistic. Our government has made peace with the Palestinians and we have to accept that,” Rekhess said. Other Israelis are more determined to object.

“I don't recognize a Palestinian Olympic team because there is no Palestinian state,” said Shifra Hoffman, founder and director of Victims of Arab Terror, a group not affiliated with the athletes' families. “I'm sure that Jews will protest.”

The Israeli Olympic Committee has not taken a formal position on Palestinian participation in the Atlanta games, but its leaders are clearly concerned. The Israeli committee sent a letter last week to IOC director general Francois Carrard seeking clarification of the decision.

“We need to know exactly what this means before we respond publicly to it,” said Israeli Olympic Committee director general Uri Afek. “Officially we cannot mix politics with sports, but we have to be realistic.”

Olympic recognition is a powerful symbol of international acceptance for the Palestinians, 2 million of whom live in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, occupied by Israeli since the 1967 Middle East war. Palestinian sports officials say they want to compete in as many as 19 events, including wrestling, boxing, judo, volleyball, basketball and gymnastics.

“We should all forget the past and start a new era. We know there was bloodshed, hatred and aggression against each other. They can point to their examples of it and we have our examples, too,” said Majid Asad, a school administrator in the West Bank town of Ramallah and chairman of the Palestinian Sports Commission.

Rekhess says her group, Families of the Munich Victims, will demand that the Palestinian team participate in a memorial ceremony for the Munich victims being planned for the Atlanta games. Palestine had an Olympic committee with Jewish and Arab members from 1934 until the creation of the state of Israel in 1948.

However, because of World War II and turmoil in the Middle East, the Palestinian team never competed in an Olympic games. As a first step in international competition, a Palestinian soccer team played an exhibition match in the West Bank town of Jericho against the French national team Friday. “We accepted this game to show the world we exist,” Asad said.

“We know that our standards in sports are so low compared to the rest of the world. But we know we will have important symbolic participation in the next Olympics.”

Carries the fact that Palestine had an Olympic committee with Jewish and Arab members from 1934 until 1948, which is the same period in which this archive's 1947 tennis clipping uses the word Palestinian for three Jewish players.

CP-1993-019 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinians Rule Jericho, at Least in Soccer

Clyde Haberman

“To gather in one spot in the occupied territories and to cheer the raising of the Palestinian flag, to applaud rhythmically as the Palestinian anthem played.”

The Palestinian soccer team parading a Palestinian flag yesterday before their game in Jericho.

A football match in Jericho a month after the handshake on the lawn, and the first legal flag-raising many in the crowd had seen. The visiting side was a veterans’ team; the point was never the score.

CP-1993-027 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Eases Palestinian Travel Rules

Clyde Haberman

“Mourners crowded around the coffin of Assad Saftawi, a leading figure in the mainstream faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization, who was shot and killed Thursday by two masked gunmen.”

Mourners crowded around the coffin of Assad Saftawi, a leading figure in the mainstream faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization, who was shot and killed Thursday by two masked gunmen.

The eased travel rules are the headline; the photograph is of a PLO funeral in Gaza. Assad Saftawi, 58, killed by Palestinians two months after Oslo — the internal cost of the agreement, printed above the fold of a story about gestures.

CP-1993-028 →

· The New York Times · New York

Arafat’s Wife Tries to Coexist, With P.L.O.

Youssef M. Ibrahim

“My mother was engaged in dialogue with the Israelis 25 years ago, shortly after they invaded Jerusalem. I grew up seeing Israelis come and go in our house, so the idea of making peace is not strange to me.”

Suha Tawil, interviewed in Paris. Her mother is Raymonda Hawa Tawil, whose prison memoir the Times reviewed in 1980 — thirteen years and two clippings apart, the same family, the same archive.

CP-1993-029 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Starts Freeing Hundreds of Palestinian Prisoners

Joel Greenberg

“I’ll put a Palestinian flag on my house, Mr. Awajneh said, noting that he had served more than six months of a one-year sentence for raising the flag.”

Suleiman Awajneh steps off the prison bus in Ramallah and says the first thing he will do is the thing he was jailed for. The whole of the Oslo period is in that sentence.

CP-1993-030 →

· The New York Times

Rampage Over West Bank Death

Special to The New York Times

RAMALLAH, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, Oct. 30 (Reuters) — Angry Jewish settlers set fire to Arabs’ houses and cars tonight in the Israeli-occupied West Bank in response to the killing of a settler by Palestinian militants. They set fire to about 50 houses, a bus and at least a dozen cars in the West Bank towns of El Bireh and Ramallah, firefighters said.

Thousands of settlers also blocked roads in the area of the attack, near Ramallah. One group surrounded about 500 people at a wedding party in a restaurant between Jerusalem and El Bireh. The manager of the restaurant, Issa Shkukani, said that settlers had clashed with soldiers who tried to disperse them and that he had heard gunshots. Who fired the shots was unclear.

The militant Palestinian movement Hamas said today that it was responsible for killing the Israeli settler, Chaim Mizrahi, a resident of the Beit El settlement near Ramallah. Security officials said the army had found the body of Mr. Mizrahi, who had been abducted by masked Palestinians Fridaywhile he was buying eggs near Ramallah.

The army said it was still checking the identity of the victim. Hamas opposes the accord on Palestinian self-rule signed by Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization in Washington last month. Ron Nahman, Mayor of the settlement of Ariel, said the settlers would fight back.

“We will have to take care of ourselves because we feel abandoned by the Israeli Government,” he told Israel Radio. Police Minister Moshe Shahal said Israel would not let fundamentalist groups derail its peace talks.

“There should be no illusions about our resolve to use the full extent of the law and all our force against those who perpetrate attacks,” he told Israel’s army radio.

A Palestinian leader who has taken part in Middle East peace talks, Faisal al-Husseini, said in Jerusalem, “We are so sad about any killing, Palestinian or Israeli, and we hope that these activities will stop.”

CP-1993-042 →

· The New York Times · New York

ISRAELI AIDES WANT MORE FROM ARAFAT

They Say His Condemnation of Killing of Settler Does Not Go Far Enough

Joel Greenberg

“Israeli Cabinet ministers said today that Yasir Arafat’s condemnation on Saturday of the killing of a Jewish settler did not go far enough.”

A condemnation is issued and judged insufficient. The archive holds a long run of these: the demand is never for a statement, it is for the next statement.

CP-1993-031 →

· The Miami Herald · Miami

Jewish settler violence claims 1st Arab victim

Two things are settled in seven words: the violence is settler violence and the settlers are Jewish. What the sentence then does is give the violence the verb — it claims a victim — so that no person does anything. And 1st is a counting word: the headline is marking the start of a series it expects to continue.

CP-1993-005 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Israeli Arabs Say P.L.O. Pact Is a Path to First-Class Status

By Clyde Haberman

NAZARETH, Israel — Diab Mahroum, a pastry maker in this ancient city, could see for himself how much the world had suddenly changed when he put his baklava on display at a food fair in October in Cologne, Germany. For the first time, he said, business executives from Saudi Arabia and Kuwait felt confident enough to visit the Israel booth.

Before you could say pistachio, they had placed orders for 8,000 pounds of sweets from the factory here founded by his father, Foad. Not that everything has changed in the Middle East, where an official Arab boycott of Israel remains in effect.

The boxes of baklava, which will be shipped to the Persian Gulf by way of Cyprus, say simply in English, “Mahroum Sweets Ltd., Nazareth.” No mention of Israel. Still, says Mr. Mahroum, an Israeli Arab, even this small step would have been improbable before Sept.

13, when Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization signed their agreement on self-rule for roughly 1.8 million Palestinian Arabs in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip. “The psychological border was opened,” he said. “The Arab countries were very afraid before. This was the first exposition where we could feel them showing interest.”

Like Mr. Mahroum, many of the 800,000 Arab citizens of Israel see the agreement as a force for potentially sweeping improvements in their lives — in business, politics, Government services and cultural endeavors.

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan shows the top of a front page without the nameplate. The “INSIDE” box refers to “Part 2 of Tony Kushner’s ‘Angels in America’ opened on Broadway” and to pages A2–D17, consistent with a New York Times of late November 1993, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1993-037 →

· The New York Times · New York

Violence by Settlers on West Bank Is Forcing Showdown With Rabin

“Talal al-Bakri’s living came from selling vegetables in Hebron. His death came from traveling past this neighboring Jewish settlement.”

Haberman writes two sentences in parallel and lets the structure carry it. Cabinet ministers in the next column call settlers fanatics and terrorists, words the paper rarely applies in that direction.

CP-1993-032 →

· Wisconsin State Journal · Madison · page 1

Four Arabs die in blast; 3 slain in Gaza

TERROR: Soldier shoots a woman who stabbed him in the face; bomb victims presumed to have been building a device

Associated Press

JERUSALEM — Seven Palestinians were killed in the occupied lands, including four who died in an explosion in the West Bank, the army and Palestinian reporters said today.

In the Gaza Strip town of Rafah, an Israeli soldier shot and killed an Arab woman after she attacked him with a knife… The victims were identified as Mazouz Balouneh, 27; Faisal Balouneh, 28; Naim Balouneh, 18; and Khaled Ramadin, 25… The Rafah incident started when a woman standing in front of the military government pretended to faint, a Palestinian reporter said.

When a soldier approached to help her, she pulled a knife and stabbed him in the face. The soldier fired, killing her. The soldier suffered minor injuries, the army said.

The death brought to 850 the number of Palestinians slain by Israelis during the Palestinian uprising that erupted in December 1987… The deaths brought to 431 the number of Palestinians slain by fellow Arabs during the uprising, most on suspicion of helping Israel.

The kicker over this story is TERROR, and the story it sits over includes an Israeli soldier shooting a Palestinian woman. The four men killed in the blast are named. She is not.

CP-1993-006 →

· Wisconsin State Journal · Madison · page 1

Palestinian women hopeful self-rule will bring greater freedom for them

Karin Laub, Associated Press, Gaza City

GAZA CITY, Occupied Gaza Strip — After commanding an underground PLO cell in the Palestinian uprising, Ayshe Abu Maghaseeb is not interested in sitting at home. But she’s afraid it may come to that.

During the six-year revolt against Israeli occupation, Abu Maghaseeb stoned and firebombed soldiers, smuggled messages from PLO leaders abroad and was interrogated by Israeli agents. She says they tried to make her talk by threatening rape and public humiliation. Many other Palestinian women were on the front lines.

Fifty were killed and about 3,000 detained… “Arab men don’t believe women should be in positions of responsibility,” said Abu Maghaseeb, 30. Her face framed by a black head scarf she wears reluctantly to escape harassment by Muslim militants.

In the Algerian guerrilla war against the French in 1954-62, “Algerian women took part in all parts of the revolution,” she said. “But after achieving independence, they ended up sitting at home.

We want to make sure this experience will not be repeated in Palestine.”… There are signs Palestinian self-rule will break down at least some traditional barriers.

Hanan Ashrawi, who became known in the West as the eloquent spokeswoman of the Palestinian cause, has been named by Yasser Arafat as the Palestine Liberation Organization’s “ambassador” to Washington.

Eighty-five women have joined the new Palestinian police force… “Men have an old boys” network, but women don’t, so we are trying to beat them to it this time,’ said Zuheira Kamal, leader of the women’s federations… Only about 30,000 of the more than 900,000 women in the West Bank and Gaza work outside the home, most of them as factory hands or domestics.

Anam Tawil, a 29-year-old architect, won a contract sought by 21 established Gaza firms to design four eight-story apartment houses to be built in the Khan Yunis refugee camp… In the Shati refugee camp, just a five-minute drive from Tawil’s office, Ibtissam Badri Tahan, 33, hoped life would somehow improve under a PLO government.

Her parents took her out of school at 15 to marry Mohammed, then 24, and she has borne him eight children. She works from 4 a.m. until evening making hummus sandwiches for the family’s small stand, then does the family cooking, cleaning and laundry.

“The house is like a prison,” she said carefully, watching her husband across the table for any sign of disapproval. “I hope my girls will have a better life.”

Five Palestinian women named, with ages, jobs and arguments. The last of them says her line while watching her husband’s face.

CP-1993-007 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Reinforces Troops In Occupied Territories

“Five days before Israel is scheduled to begin pulling back its forces in the Gaza Strip and part of the West Bank, it went in the opposite direction today, significantly bolstering troop strength.”

Five days before the withdrawal, reinforcements. Printed without comment, which is the comment.

CP-1993-033 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Sees New Delays to Palestinian Self-Rule

Clyde Haberman

“No dates are sacred, he said.”

The 13 December target date for Israeli withdrawal passes with nothing changed, and Rabin is quoted in four words. The archive holds thirty years of deadlines after this one.

CP-1993-034 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago

A Palestinian, killed in a clash with Israeli soldiers Tuesday in Gaza City, lies near the wreckage of a car that contained explosives

“A Palestinian, killed in a clash with Israeli soldiers Tuesday in Gaza City, lies near the wreckage of a car that contained explosives. Authorities detonated the explosives with a remote-controlled robot.” AP photo.

A burning car fills the frame and a body lies on the road at the bottom left, small enough to miss. The caption opens with him and then spends its second sentence on the robot. He is killed in a clash — the construction that leaves nobody killing — and he is not named.

CP-1993-008 →

· The New York Times · New York

Facing the Future

Youssef M. Ibrahim

“She turned Mr. Arafat down when he offered her the chance to be the first Palestinian ambassador to Washington; she resigned, saying she will devote herself to Palestinian human rights.”

Hanan Ashrawi refuses an embassy to work on human rights, three months after the handshake. The photograph on the same page is of Palestinian women demanding the release of prisoners from Israeli jails. Self-criticism and self-rule arriving in the same section.

CP-1993-035 →

· The Daily Astorian · Astoria · page 7

Women warriors of Palestine fear being relegated to home

By KARIN LAUB, Of The Associated Press

GAZA CITY, Occupied Gaza Strip — After commanding an underground PLO cell in the Palestinian uprising, Abu Maghaseeb is not interested in sitting at home. But she's afraid it may come to that.

During the six-year revolt against Israeli occupation, Abu Maghaseeb stoned and firebombed soldiers, smuggled messages from PLO leaders abroad and was interrogated often by Israeli agents. She says they tried to make her talk by threatening rape and public humiliation. Many other Palestinian women were on the front lines. Fifty were killed and about 3,000 detained.

Now that Israeli troops are preparing to pull out of the Gaza Strip, however, they fear they will be sent back to their kitchens, excluded from power in the new government. “Arab men don't believe women should be in positions of responsibility,” said Abu Maghaseeb, 30.

Her tanned face was framed by a black head scarf she wears reluctantly to escape harassment by Muslim militants. In the Algerian guerrilla war against the French in 1954-62, “Algerian women took part in all parts of the revolution,” she said. “But after achieving independence, they ended up sitting at home.

We want to make sure this experience will not be repeated here in Palestine.”

THERE ARE SIGNS Palestinian self-rule will break down at least some traditional barriers: • Hanan Ashrawi, who became known in the West as the eloquent spokeswoman of the Palestinian cause, has been named by Yasser Arafat as the Palestine Liberation Organization's “ambassador” to Washington. • Eighty-five women have joined the new Palestinian police force, along with several thousand men, although they will handle only office work and juvenile cases. • Professional women have compiled a list of more than 1,000 colleagues as candidates for important jobs.

“Men have an old boys' network, but women don't, so we are trying to beat them to it this time,” said Zuheira Kamal, leader of the women's federations in occupied lands. Anticipated investment in the Palestinian economy, including more than $2 billion in international aid, is expected to create thousands of jobs, including many for women in manufacturing and offices.

Only about 30,000 of the more than 900,000 women in the West Bank and Gaza work outside the home, most of them as factory hands or domestics. Economic investment already has brought rewards to a few women.

Anam Tawil, a 29-year-old architect, won a contract sought by 21 established Gaza firms to design four eight-story apartment houses to be built in the Khan Yunis refugee camp with European Community aid. Ironically, her design is based on Islamic beliefs that women should be homemakers and kept out of sight of strangers.

“There are no windows facing each other, and the windows of the kitchen look out over the green area so the mothers can watch the children,” she said. As she showed visitors a cardboard model of the buildings, Tawil's 2-month-old son Ahmed began crying in his crib in the next room. Her male secretary rushed to calm the baby and later served lemon juice to the guests.

THE ROLE REVERSAL in Tawil's office was jarring in Gaza, where many women marry at 14 or 15, usually have seven or eight children and need their husband's permission to leave the house.

In the Shati refugee camp, just a five-minute drive from Tawil's office but a world away, Ibtissam Badri Tahan, 33, hoped life would somehow improve under a PLO government and that she would be able to study nursing. Her parents took her out of school at 15 to marry Mohammed, then 24, and she has borne him eight children, the youngest four months old.

She works from 4 a.m. until evening making hummus sandwiches for the family's small stand, then does the family cooking, cleaning and laundry. “The house is like a prison,” she said carefully, watching her husband across the table for any sign of disapproval. “I hope my girls will have a better life.” They agreed that their six girls should finish high school.

Kamal, the women's federation leader, is drafting legislation that would guarantee equal pay and the right of women to education. Women in factories now are paid only one-half to two-thirds as much as men doing the same job and only about 70 percent have attended school.

She said Arafat had given her no commitment, and that even if he is sincere about improving women's lot, he will face opposition from Muslim groups. “Any kind of compromise would be at the expense of the women,” she said.

The same dispatch the Wisconsin State Journal ran two weeks earlier under the headline Palestinian women hopeful self-rule will bring greater freedom for them. One headline says hopeful and the other says fear, over the same words. This printing carries the whole dispatch; it runs above a half-page Christmas sale advertisement.

CP-1993-020 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinians Must Now Master The Art of Forgetting

“A different cartography, however, occurred somewhere else, within the hearts and minds of those Palestinians who live in the diaspora and the refugee camps, most of whom did not even have a chance to watch the televised images.”

Illustrated with a hand holding a house key wrapped in barbed wire. The key is the object refugees carry; the headline tells them to master the art of forgetting it. Hold the picture and the headline in view at once and the page argues with itself.

CP-1993-036 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Israel and the P.L.O. Wrestle With the Border Control Issue

By Youssef M. Ibrahim

CAIRO, Dec. 28 — Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization struggled today to resolve their conflicting proposals for security arrangements in the Gaza Strip and Jericho, including an Israeli suggestion for joint patrols and a Palestinian suggestion for electronic surveillance by Israelis.

On the second day of the latest round of talks, Palestinian, Egyptian and Israeli officials said they were discussing what one called “several scenarios” to resolve the disagreements over who will control access to the areas once Israel pulls back its troops and who will guard the borders to Egypt and Jordan.

Israel was scheduled to begin withdrawing from Gaza and the West Bank town of Jericho on Dec. 13, but it delayed the action until it reached a broader agreement on security arrangements with the Palestinians. Israel’s main demand is that its forces continue to man the checkpoints on the border with Egypt and Jordan, on the grounds that the Sept.

13 agreement of recognition with the P.L.O. left Israel exclusively responsible for the external security of its borders. The P.L.O. leadership asserts, however, that if the Palestinians do not have at least some measure of control over the borders, they will be accused of selling out to the Israelis.

A Palestinian official said today that the P.L.O. had rejected an Israeli suggestion that Palestinian outposts be placed within sight of Israeli control points at the entry of the Allenby Bridge connecting Jordan and Israel, and at the Gaza crossing point on the Egyptian borders with Israel.

For its part, Israel has also rejected a Palestinian proposal to turn total control over to Palestinians, with arrangements for its guards to forward information electronically to Israeli officials stationed at a location nearby.

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is cropped to the article. The dateline reads “CAIRO, Dec. 28”, consistent with a Dec. 29, 1993 paper, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1993-038 →

· The Town Talk · Alexandria

Gaza life after dark

Gaza as a place where people are awake in the evening, four months after the handshake.

CP-1994-026 →

· The New York Times · New York

Building Peace in Palestinian Schools

By Joel Greenberg

JERUSALEM HASSAN Abu Ghosh, principal of the Abdullah Ibn Hussein High School for Palestinian boys in East Jerusalem, says he has little use for a study booklet on peace that he recently received from the Israeli Ministry of Education.

“We leave it here in the office — we don’t use it,” he said, picking up the collection of readings published after the signing of the peace agreement between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization. “What peace are they talking about? My son is a prisoner, half paralyzed, and still in jail. We’ve had pupils arrested.” Mr.

Abu Ghosh waved a newspaper report about a brawl at the school between opponents and supporters of the accord. His assistant, Muhammad Mudlij, said, “We can’t discuss the agreement in class, because things would get out of control.”

Politically polarized and plagued by clashes between pupils and Israeli soldiers, Palestinian schools seem hardly the place where the foundations of Arab-Jewish coexistence are going to be built.

Yet a team of Palestinian experts has been at work for half a year on the first Palestinian national school curriculum, based on principles of pluralism, tolerance and “value-free” instruction.

The 124 planners hope to put the curriculum into effect during the expected interim stage of Palestinian self-rule in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, beginning with a trial run in the next school year.

In its declared goals, the curriculum seeks to undo the legacy of decades of schooling under foreign rule — going back well before the Israeli occupation in 1967 — and the effects of years of political turmoil in the occupied territories.

During the six-year-old Palestinian uprising, or intifada, against Israel, Arab schools were closed for months by the Israeli military government on the grounds that they had become centers of violent anti-Israeli protest. When they were not shut by the Israeli authorities, they often were closed by Palestinian protest strikes.

Over the years, scores of pupils have been killed in stone-throwing clashes with the Israeli Army, and thousands arrested.

In East Jerusalem, a teacher instructs female Palestinian students in geography of the region.

CP-1994-061 →

· The Houston Post · Houston

Medicine in Gaza lags behind Israel

Palestinians push for money, modernization

GAZA, Occupied Territories — To page a doctor at Gaza’s al-Ahli Hospital, staff members must rush to a square outside their offices to ring a church bell as old as the 1917 building. Electronic pagers, only some of the trappings of modern medical care missing in the Gaza Strip, are banned by Israel for security reasons, doctors say.

“When we want to page a doctor, we ring one bell, for a cleaner, two, and for X-ray, three bells,” said Anis Abu Hashem, a staff nurse at the private al-Ahli facility.

Palestinian physicians, drained by six years of casualties from the uprising against Israel, hope the ailing health-care system will receive a desperately needed infusion of money, medicine and modernization when self-rule is born. Limited Palestinian self-rule was to have begun in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank town of Jericho on Dec.

13 but was delayed by disputes with Israel, mainly over security. Dr. Riyad Zaanoun, head of the Palestinian Health Council, said new hospitals, renovation of old ones, purchase of equipment and training of specialized doctors abroad will have priority. The hospitals are run by Israeli authorities and staffed by Palestinian doctors and nurses.

Critical cases such as cardiology and sensitive surgery are taken to hospitals in Israel. Doctors said 20 people died last year because of lack of resources or while waiting for the Israeli military administration to approve their transfer. “My father waited for two years and he died before he got permission to undergo heart surgery (in Israel),” Abu Hashem said.

Israeli Health Ministry figures show that Israel spent $700 per person for medical care in Israel last year. The expenditure in Gaza was $46 per capita.

CP-1994-021 →

· The New York Times

To Read All About It, Palestinians Scan the Walls

By CHRIS HEDGES

JABALIYA REFUGEE CAMP, Israeli-Occupied Gaza Strip — Four men, their faces covered by black hoods, darted out of an alley and positioned themselves in front of a graffiti-covered wall on Market Street. One man, wearing black latex gloves, dipped a brush into a plastic bucket filled with gray paint.

He quickly painted over the old slogans on the concrete wall as another man began writing a new message with a can of blue spray paint, glancing frequently at a small slip of white paper. A crowd of onlookers gathered to read the new announcement: “Neither the days nor the years will weaken our drive for revenge against the Jews.

Hamas announces its responsibility for the operation in Ramallah that led to the death of two settlers and the wounding of others. This operation was carried out in memory of our leader Emad Ahal, who died a month ago, and in revenge for the killing of the martyr Osama Hamid, who was killed on Dec. 22.”

Militants' Bulletin Board Because they are denied a radio station or a newspaper to call their own and are no longer barred from writing nationalist slogans, Palestinian groups like the militant Islamic organization Hamas in the Gaza Strip use the walls as a main mode of communication.

Here rumors are dispelled, strikes called and the successes or losses in the struggle against Israeli occupation announced. Many walls, already saturated with multicolored cries for vengeance or shouts of triumph, simply carry the names of those killed in the six-year uprising known by Palestinians as the intifada.

“This is like our daily newspaper,” Ihad Abu Mahmoud said as he sat in his shoe shop. “If a group wants to express a political point of view or make an announcement, it uses the walls. This is how we know what the groups are thinking and doing. We don't trust the radio or the newspapers because we know the Israelis censor them.”

Shooting the Messenger Israeli troops once arrested or shot those painting slogans. They fined owners if their walls were covered with nationalist slogans, or forced them to paint them clean. But after the September accord, calling for limited Palestinian autonomy in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank town of Jericho, the Israelis have let Gaza drown itself in graffiti.

But Palestinian factions that remain outlawed and are opposed to the accord, like Hamas, send out squads of masked young men known as the hooded ones to spray-paint their own propaganda at the risk of being shot by Israeli troops.

While Palestinians' painting slogans is no longer considered a crime, their wearing black hoods does expose them to possible apprehension by the Israeli troops, who are authorized to shoot if they encounter resistance. If hooded men refuse to heed an order by soldiers to stop, they can be fired upon. And the risk, especially to Hamas militants, is high.

“If the soldiers see us they will shoot,” said the lanky man carrying the bucket of gray paint, his black pants and sneakers speckled from his morning's work. “We will not surrender. We work as fast as we can. The more time we spend in one place, the more danger we face.”

The announcement about “revenge against the Jews,” which would later be picked up by local and international news organizations, let the world know that the armed wing of Hamas, known as the Qassam Brigades, was behind the killing of two Israeli men the day before.

Hooded Role Models The graffiti painters finished in a few minutes, then jogged down the muddy street to paint the message at the other end of the market. “This is a dangerous operation for us,” one said while glancing up and down the street. “But it is the way we communicate with the people.”

The Hamas movement has mounted a campaign in recent weeks to kill Israelis in an effort to sabotage the P.L.O.-Israeli agreement. But all of the groups compete for wall space for their political messages.

“Palestinian groups come to the market to hand out leaflets and put up posters,” said a vegetable vendor, Shihdi Abdullah, as he stood over his baskets of apples and tomatoes. “But the messages on the walls are the fastest way to get information. Everything of importance has to be written on the walls.”

There are few opportunities open to young men who live in the garbage-strewn alleys and around the fetid cesspools that dot the Jabaliya refugee camp. But joining the ranks of “the hooded ones” is high on the social scale. “No one knows who they are,” said Mohammed Salwali, a 16-year-old boy who stood with a group of friends on the muddy street just after the militants fled.

“When we see them it gives us pride. We feel we have our own army. They inspire us.” But joining the underground groups, especially the Qassam Brigades, is not easy. And it remains a dangerous and arduous occupation. “If you want to be a member of the Qassam Brigades, first you have to go to the mosque and pray and pray and pray,” Mr.

Abdullah said as he leaned over his small fruit cart. “Then the Hamas leaders come and recruit you. You have to train and dedicate your life to the struggle. I admire them, but it is not the life for me. I will command my brigade of apples and tomatoes.”

With the signing of the September accord between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization, Israeli troops no longer crack down on Palestinians' painting slogans in the occupied territories. Referring to a slip of paper, a Palestinian militant spray-painted a message in a Gaza Strip refugee camp.

It said in part, “Neither the days nor the years will weaken our drive for revenge against the Jews.”

CP-1994-069 →

· The Bay City Times · Bay City

Palestinian photographer beaten by Israeli troops

Israel

JERUSALEM (AP)

JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli troops beat a Palestinian photographer and threatened him at gunpoint Friday while he was photographing a riot in the West Bank town of Ramallah, Israel radio said. Atta Awesat, who works for the Israeli photo agency Zoom, said one soldier grabbed him by the throat and another whacked him in the head with his M-16 assault rifle.

He required 12 stitches to close the wound.

A numbered world brief. The standing label above it reads ISRAEL. What it describes happened in Ramallah, in the West Bank.

CP-1994-013 →

· Sunday Telegraph · page 1

Israelis shoot 12-year-old

“ISRAELI soldiers shot dead a 12-year-old Palestinian boy at the Jabalia camp in the Gaza Strip yesterday during a stone-throwing incident and killed a driver who violated the curfew at Balaa, in the West Bank. — AFP”

A two-sentence brief. Two people killed, neither named, and the whole item is one paragraph.

CP-1994-001 →

· The Monitor · McAllen · page 1C

Palestinian women establish shelters, rape hotlines

Unmarried females who are assaulted are villified by relatives, often killed

By KARIN LAUB, The Associated Press

JERUSALEM — At age 11, Reem was raped at knifepoint by a teen-age cousin. When her family found out five years later, they punished her for shaming them and a brother broke her right foot with a cinder block.

“My mother cursed me and told me, ‘You are dirt and people are gossiping about you,’” recalled Reem, a 16-year-old Bedouin with a cherubic face framed by a pageboy haircut. Still, Reem is lucky. Unlike many, she had a place to escape from her family's abuse and death threats: a shelter set up last fall by Arab feminists.

They say it is the first such sanctuary in the Arab world, where violence against women is often hushed up. Since September, 50 teen-agers have found temporary refuge in the five-room apartment. Its location is kept secret. Reem, not her real name, has a chronic infection in her right foot and wears orthopedic sneakers.

When police brought her to the shelter four months ago, she refused to speak. “I didn't trust anyone,” she said. “I dreamt all the time that my parents were chasing after me with a knife and I woke up screaming.” She proudly showed her drawings of flowers and a scrapbook of photos of soccer players.

Starved for affection, she idolizes her counselor Hanan and called her “my good mother” in a poem. Rima Assy, director of the center, said she has space for 10 girls, but receives 30 placement requests a week and has to refuse most of them. While the shelter is a good start, she said, there is no follow-up.

Several girls had to return home with no protection beyond pledges signed by their families in the presence of police that they would not be harmed. The shelter's founders are pioneers in a region where violence against women is often condoned and victims are discouraged from seeking help.

“It is accepted as a private matter that concerns only the family,” said Hadiya Jarrad of the Democratic Women's Association in Tunisia. “The reigning mentality is that a woman can be corrected when she is on the wrong path.”

Information is sketchy, but there is enough to suggest the depth of the problem: • In Jordan, a country of 3.9 million people, about 60 women a year die in “honor killings,” said Zuhra Sharabati, a criminal lawyer.

About 500 women a year file assault complaints against their husbands, she added, but the vast majority of cases are not reported. • In Tunisia, 85 percent of the 480 female assault victims admitted in 1992 at Rabita Hospital in Tunis were beaten by their husbands, said the Tunisian Democratic Women's Association. • In the occupied territories, nearly all of the 107 Palestinian women reported slain by fellow Arabs as alleged collaborators during the uprising against Israel were in fact victims of honor killings, the Israeli human rights group Betselem said last month.

… [THIS IS THE JUMP OF CP-1994-012, NOT CP-1997-035.] Violence Continued from page 1C Nadera Kevorkian, a sociologist at Bethlehem University in the West Bank, cited the case of a Palestinian woman who was raped by a brother-in-law, got pregnant, gave birth last May and was critically beaten by relatives while in the maternity ward. She was moved to another hospital.

Kevorkian pleaded with officials not to release the woman to her family, but was ignored. The day after her release, the woman’s body was found, hacked to pieces, in a plastic bag on the steps of the hospital, Kevorkian said. In recent months, Palestinian women’s groups have begun trying to help.

With money from donations and Israel’s Welfare Ministry, the Association of Women Against Violence set up two shelters in northern Israel. The organization of Arab feminists focuses on the 450,000 Arab women in Israel. One of the shelters helps teen-agers like Reem.

The other, for married Arab women, is a gray two-story house in an Arab village, protected by a spike fence and alarm system. It housed seven women and 18 children during a recent visit.

The Union of Palestinian Working Women’s Committees, originally associated with the Communist Party, has established a counseling center and two hotlines for the West Bank’s 500,000 women. Amal Khreishe, who runs the hotlines, said she got 11 calls on the first day of operations in January, some from women who had never dared to discuss their problem.

Among those seeking help was a university graduate who said she had been raped repeatedly by a relative and feared her secret would be discovered. “She said her mother believes the family must kill any girl who has sexual relations outside the marriage institution,” Khreishe said.

The caller said she was running out of excuses for rejecting suitors — marriage being out of the question because of her loss of virginity. As a result of the pressure, the woman said, she suffered frequent fevers and hysterial fits. Kevorkian said Arab women often blame themselves instead of their attackers because they are taught to be subservient to men.

Tide Of Resistance: Palestinian women are seen during a gathering last Sept. 1993 at Beir Zeit University on the Israeli occupied West Bank. Palestinian women in the occupied lands and in Israel are among the pioneers in the arab world in confronting violence against women.

While in most of the Middle East the problem is still hushed up, Palestinian women have established two shelters for battered women and several hotlines in recent months.

Printed under a standing section label reading VIOLENCE, and continued on page 5C. The paper's own spelling of villified and arab is kept.

CP-1994-012 →

· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha

Arabs Cling to 45-Year-Old Israeli Promise

Iqrit, Israel — There is no sign marking the turnoff to Iqrit. There is no mention of it on contemporary Israeli road maps. And there is no village. All that remains of what was once an Arab Christian village is the church, poised on a hill above cow pastures, and a tree-shrouded cemetery. The homes have long since been turned to rubble, overgrown with weeds.

Yet the village of Iqrit lives on in the memory of the Arabs who were expelled from it by the Israeli army in November 1948. The people from Iqrit and another Arab Christian village, Biram, were promised by the army that they could return in “two weeks.” But the army’s promise remains unfulfilled 45 years later.

The pledge continues to stir controversy in Israel.

Although the Jewish state has firmly rejected demands from Arab refugees for the right to return to homes from which they fled or were expelled in the 1948 war, the case of Iqrit and Biram has torn at the conscience of many Israelis, because their Christian residents did not run away, were not hostile and were given a commitment they could go back.

Deep Fears The unkept promise to the villagers of Iqrit and Biram illuminates some of the complex psychology of the long conflict between Jews and Arabs over this mountainous terrain. For Israeli Jews, the case goes to the heart of deeply held fears that Arabs will one day try to return to their lands.

If just two villages can go back, they fear, it will set a precedent for others. But from the perspective of the villagers, the case of Iqrit and Biram illustrates how Israel has failed to live up to basic promises it made to those Arabs who did not fight and flee in 1948.

They became citizens of the Jewish state, but they believe Israel has never delivered on its pledge to treat them equally with its Jewish citizens.

CP-1994-015 →

· Corpus Christi Caller Times · Corpus Christi · page A32

Palestinian women seek protection against warped moralists

Being raped is just the start; next comes blame, perhaps murder, by the family

By Karin Laub, Associated Press

JERUSALEM — At age 11, Reem was raped at knifepoint by a teen-age cousin. When her family found out five years later, they punished her for shaming them and a brother broke her right foot with a cinder block.

“My mother cursed me and told me, ‘You are dirt and people are gossiping about you,’” recalled Reem, a 16-year-old Bedouin with a cherubic face framed by a pageboy haircut. Still, Reem is lucky. Unlike many, she had a place to escape from her family's abuse and death threats: a shelter set up last fall by Arab feminists.

They say it is the first such sanctuary in the Arab world, where violence against women is often hushed up. Since September, 50 teen-agers have found temporary refuge in the five-room apartment. Its location is kept secret. Reem, not her real name, has a chronic infection in her right foot and wears orthopedic sneakers.

When police brought her to the shelter four months ago, she refused to speak. “I didn't trust anyone,” she said. “I dreamt all the time that my parents were chasing after me with a knife and I woke up screaming.” She proudly showed her drawings of flowers and a scrapbook of photos of soccer players.

Starved for affection, she idolizes her counselor, Hanan, and called her “my good mother” in a poem. Rima Assy, director of the center, said she has space for 10 girls but receives 30 placement requests a week and has to refuse most of them. While the shelter is a good start, she said, there is no follow-up.

Several girls had to return home with no protection beyond pledges signed by their families in the presence of police that they would not be harmed. The shelter's founders are pioneers in a region where violence against women is often condoned and victims are discouraged from seeking help.

“It is accepted as a private matter that concerns only the family,” said Hadiya Jarrad of the Democratic Women's Association in Tunisia. “The reigning mentality is that a woman can be corrected when she is on the wrong path.”

Information is sketchy, but there is enough to suggest the depth of the problem: ■ In Jordan, a country of 3.9 million people, about 60 women a year die in “honor killings,” said Zuhra Sharabati, a criminal lawyer.

About 500 women a year file assault complaints against their husbands, she added, but the vast majority of cases are not reported. ■ In Tunisia, 85 percent of the 480 female assault victims admitted in 1992 at Rabita Hospital in Tunis were beaten by their husbands, said the Tunisian Democratic Women's Association. ■ In the occupied territories, nearly all of the 107 Palestinian women reported slain by fellow Arabs as alleged collaborators during the uprising against Israel were in fact victims of honor killings, the Israeli human rights group Betselem said last month.

Nadera Kevorkian, a sociologist at Bethlehem University in the West Bank, cited the case of a Palestinian woman who was raped by a brother-in-law, got pregnant, gave birth last May and was critically beaten by relatives while in the maternity ward. She was moved to another hospital. Kevorkian pleaded with officials not to release the woman to her family but was ignored.

The day after her release, the woman's body was found, hacked to pieces, in a plastic bag on the steps of the hospital, Kevorkian said. In recent months, Palestinian women's groups have begun trying to help. With money from donations and Israel's Welfare Ministry, the Association of Women Against Violence set up two shelters in northern Israel.

The organization of Arab feminists focuses on the 450,000 Arab women in Israel. One of the shelters helps teen-agers like Reem. The other, for married Arab women, is a gray two-story house in an Arab village, protected by a spike fence and alarm system. It housed seven women and 18 children during a recent visit.

The Union of Palestinian Working Women's Committees, originally associated with the Communist Party, has established a counseling center and two hotlines for the West Bank's 500,000 women. Amal Khreishe, who runs the hotlines, said she got 11 calls on the first day of operations in January, some from women who had never dared to discuss their problem.

Among those seeking help was a university graduate who said she had been raped repeatedly by a relative and feared her secret would be discovered. Kevorkian said Arab women often blame themselves instead of their attackers because they are taught to be subservient to men.

Palestinian women are often sexually assaulted and then blamed and accused of bringing dishonor on their families. (ASSOCIATED PRESS)

The same dispatch The Monitor ran five days earlier under the headline Palestinian women establish shelters, rape hotlines. This printing is longer by a third, and everything it adds is Palestinian women running things: a sociologist at Bethlehem University, a counseling center and two hotlines, and the woman who answers them.

CP-1994-014 →

· The New York Times · New York

Biblical Tomb Long a Site of Arab-Jewish Conflict

Context published the morning after the massacre. The building is introduced to American readers by its biblical name.

CP-1994-027 →

· The New York Times · New York

AT LEAST 40 SLAIN IN WEST BANK AS ISRAELI FIRES INTO MOSQUE

CLINTON MOVES TO RESCUE TALKS

“At least 40 slain in West Bank as Israeli fires into mosque; Clinton moves to rescue talks.”

The front page of 26 February 1994. The archive previously held the aftermath of the Ibrahimi Mosque massacre from 2 March onward and nothing at all from the days it happened; this deck supplies fourteen clippings across four days. Note the grammar: an Israeli fires, and the second clause is about the talks.

CP-1994-028 →

· The New York Times · New York

Killer’s Path of Militancy: From Brooklyn to Israel

A History of Anti-Arab Feeling

“Born in Brooklyn, Dr. Goldstein grew up in the middle-class community of Bensonhurst, where neighbors said his family kept their distance from the… Following is the text of a letter by Dr. Baruch Goldstein that was printed in The New York Times in 1981.”

The paper traces the killer to Brooklyn and then does something unusual: it reprints a letter he had written to the New York Times thirteen years earlier, in 1981. A newspaper publishing its own earlier publication of him.

CP-1994-029 →

· The New York Times · New York

The Horror in Hebron

The paper’s own editorial, the morning after.

CP-1994-030 →

· The New York Times · New York

Disarm the West Bank Settlers

Michael Lerner

“The murder of more than 40 Palestinians at Ramadan prayer in a mosque in the West Bank town of Hebron yesterday cannot be dismissed as the action of a psychopath and nothing more…

The massacre was predictable. We in the Jewish religious peace movement are often called traitors, our lives have been threatened, our motives demeaned. Bombs have been placed near Peace Now and the New Israel Fund offices, and my magazine, Tikkun, has received bomb threats.”

Written and published within a day. Lerner argues from inside the Jewish religious peace movement and lists the threats made against it, which is the part that does not usually survive into later accounts.

CP-1994-031 →

· Des Moines Register · Des Moines

Murderer at mosque was doctor, father

Suicide attacker preached violence

“Murderer at mosque was doctor, father. Suicide attacker preached violence.”

Iowa calls him a murderer in the headline. The word choice is not uniform across the papers in this archive that morning, which is the reason for keeping all of them.

CP-1994-032 →

· Post Star

Mosque awash in blood, tears after early morning massacre

Glens Falls, New York. The only one of the fourteen that puts the inside of the room in the headline.

CP-1994-033 →

· San Antonio Express News · San Antonio

Slaughter at mosque denounced

Incident appalls S.A. leaders

“Massacre wounds peace process.”

San Antonio localises it to its own religious leaders, under a page banner reading Massacre wounds peace process.

CP-1994-034 →

· The New York Times · New York

Massacre Leaves Israelis Shamed, Sad and Scared of What’s Ahead

Clyde Haberman

TEL AVIV, Feb. 26 — Fingersnapping and brisk-paced, Tel Aviv hardly stopped today, but it skipped a few beats as it wrestled with the Hebron massacre, a brutal blow that left many Israelis depressed…

The day after, written from Tel Aviv about Israeli feeling. The dead are in the word massacre and the story is about the mood of the country the killer came from.

CP-1994-035 →

· The New York Times · New York

Never Again: An Ideology Takes Up Arms Against Peace

“Never again.”

The slogan turned on the people who use it, in a Week in Review headline two days after Hebron.

CP-1994-036 →

· The Star-Ledger · Newark

Mosque protests extend into Arab areas

One of three Star-Ledger clippings in this archive from the same Sunday. New Jersey still prints Occupied West Bank in its dateline in 1994.

CP-1994-037 →

· The Star-Ledger · Newark

Jewish radicals view killer as hero

“KIRYAT ARBA, Occupied West… there are more people willing here… Arabs out of the biblical Land of Israel…”

Reported from the settlement next to Hebron. The paper goes and asks, and prints the answer.

CP-1994-038 →

· The Star-Ledger · Newark

A voice is stilled by hate

“…is stilled by hate.”

The third of the Star-Ledger’s clippings from that Sunday.

CP-1994-039 →

· Quad City Times · Davenport

PLO blames deaths on troops

Toll hits at least 61 during the aftermath

“PLO blames deaths on troops. Toll hits at least 61 during the aftermath.”

Under a standing head reading MOSQUE MASSACRE. The sixty-one includes those killed in the protests afterward, which most of the other papers here do not count.

CP-1994-040 →

· The Miami Herald · Miami

Israeli soldiers fired in mosque, TV says

The Associated Press

“Israeli TV reported Saturday that some of the victims of the massacre in the Mosque of Abraham were killed by Israeli soldiers who rushed in after a Jewish settler opened fire on praying… the mosque was not there, and it took an army unit 20 minutes to arrive, Barak said.”

Israeli television reporting that soldiers also fired, and the chief of staff saying the unit took twenty minutes to arrive. Printed beside a column headed For settlers, a Holy War on Arabs.

CP-1994-041 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Orders Tough Measures Against Militant Settlers

Arafat Dismisses Rabin’s Moves as ‘Hollow’

By CLYDE HABERMAN

Two days on, the response is a crackdown on settlers, which is rare in this archive in either direction.

CP-1994-042 →

· North Jersey Herald and News

The Real Image

“…a Brooklyn-born physician and Jewish settler in the occupied West Bank, entered the Al-Ibrahimi Mosque — the second holiest in Palestine — and opened fire with a machine gun. As many as 50 people who were worshiping there at the time were killed…

government must be stopped until the settlers are disarmed.”

A reader named Waheed Khalid writing to a New Jersey paper, using the mosque’s Arabic name and calling Palestine by name. One of the few Arab-American voices in this archive printed within days of an event rather than months after it.

CP-1994-043 →

· Syracuse Herald Journal · Syracuse

Hundreds mourn Goldstein’s death

A coffin carried through a crowd, photographed for a Syracuse front page.

CP-1994-044 →

· Syracuse Herald Journal · Syracuse

Security was poor at site of massacre

The second Syracuse photograph from that day.

CP-1994-045 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Arafat Dismisses Rabin’s Moves as ‘Hollow’

By Clyde Haberman

HEBRON, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, Feb. 27 — Seeking to defuse Arab anger and allay international concerns over the Hebron massacre, the Israeli Government today ordered some of the toughest measures ever taken against militant Jewish settlers in the occupied territories.

The actions, which were accompanied by the creation of a commission to investigate the massacre and by the planned release this week of up to 1,000 Palestinian prisoners, affect a relatively small number of settlers for now.

At his headquarters in Tunis, Yasir Arafat, chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, quickly rejected them as “empty, hollow” gestures. [Page A8] Nonetheless, they represent a change in spirit for Israel’s leaders in that the sort of sanctions imposed collectively on Palestinians for years have now been placed on some Jews.

Settlers deemed to be dangerous are to be detained, disarmed and restricted in their movements through the territories.

Army commanders issued orders for the immediate “administrative detention” — arrest without formal charges — of five settlers presumed to be members or sympathizers of the Kach movement and its spinoff, Kahane Chai, both grounded in the anti-Arab militancy espoused by the late Rabbi Meir Kahane. It was a Kahane disciple, Dr.

Baruch Goldstein from the neighboring Qiryat Arba settlement, who killed at least 40 Palestinians in Hebron on Friday by opening fire with an automatic rifle as they knelt in prayer at a shrine held holy by both Muslims and Jews. Dr.

Goldstein, who was finally overcome and beaten to death by the worshipers, was buried today in Qiryat Arba after a funeral service in which some mourners praised him as a hero and a righteous man. His grave was said to be temporary, and there are plans to move him to the Jewish cemetery in Hebron when tensions ease.

“One million Arabs are not worth a Jewish fingernail,” Rabbi Yaacov Perrin said in a eulogy. At the service in Jerusalem, attended by 300 people, one man shouted, “We are all Goldstein,” an opinion echoed across Qiryat Arba by neighbors who said variously that they approved of his attack on the Arabs or at the least could not judge him.

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is a single narrow column cropped from the page. The dateline reads “HEBRON, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, Feb. 27”, consistent with a Feb. 28, 1994 paper, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1994-057 →

· The New York Times · New York

Sad, Angry and Fearful: Voices of Arab-Americans and American Jews

Francis X. Clines

“Essa Abed, a Palestinian social worker in Brooklyn: ‘What I’m hearing in the community is a lot of anger, frustration and feelings that the peace process won’t proceed.’… ‘Israel should not be in the occupation business,’ said Terry Ahwal of Detroit, a member of the national board of the Ameri… Arab-Americans were particularly sensitive to the news coverage of the event, contending that while Dr.

Goldstein was portrayed as a lone militant, a Muslim in a similar situation would have been more easily labeled a terrorist.”

Arab-Americans named and quoted in the New York Times: Essa Abed in Brooklyn, Terry Ahwal in Detroit. The complaint they make is about labelling — that a lone militant and a terrorist are the same man described twice — and this archive now holds both the 1946 and the 1994 ends of that argument.

CP-1994-047 →

· Indianapolis Star · Indianapolis

The mosque massacre

“It would be a double tragedy if the hateful Jewish doctor who gunned to death at least 40 Muslims at prayers last…”

An Indianapolis editorial, four days on.

CP-1994-048 →

· Springfield News Leader

Take settlers’ weapons, just as Palestinians have been disarmed

Walid Abbasi

Printed under a standing head reading THEIR VIEWS, in Missouri.

CP-1994-049 →

· Messenger Inquirer · Owensboro

Palestinians question official account

Karin Laub

“Challenging the army’s account of the mosque massacre, worshiper Maliha Jaberi said Israeli soldiers burst into a chamber… shooting and found that a soldier could fire 111 bullets in 30 seconds. ‘It was very easy to harm a lot of people,’ Yatom said.”

A named Palestinian worshiper, Maliha Jaberi, contradicting the army. The same wire reporter, Karin Laub, appears elsewhere in this archive on Palestinian women. Printed the same day as a paper in Virginia ran the army’s account under its own headline.

CP-1994-050 →

· The Daily Press · Newport News

Mosque massacre: the Israeli army’s account

“The army says Baruch Goldstein alone was responsible for… Two Israeli soldiers at Muslim entrance, overwhelmed with fleeing Palestinians, fire… Israeli guard commander, alone at his post because four soldiers have not shown up, tries to get into the prayer hall through three entrances after…”

The army’s version, diagrammed, in Newport News. Read it beside the Kentucky paper from the same morning in which Palestinians dispute it. Neither paper tells its readers the other account exists.

CP-1994-051 →

· Laredo Morning Times · Laredo

Israel agrees to international observers in territories

Ed Blanche

“Israel agreed Monday to disarm settlers in parts of the occupied territories as part of a concession package aimed at coaxing the PLO back to the peace talks… Under the measures announced Sunday, up to 30 settlers were ordered disarmed and 15 were banned from the occupied territories. Five were ordered detained without trial for three months.”

Thirty disarmed, fifteen banned, five detained without trial. The administrative detention that appears throughout this archive applied, for once, to settlers.

CP-1994-052 →

· The New York Times · New York

Among Israeli Arabs, Latent Anger Explodes

By CHRIS HEDGES

The week of the Ibrahimi Mosque massacre, and one of the few clippings here that sets the reaction of Palestinian citizens of Israel beside the reaction of American Jews and Arab-Americans on the same page.

CP-1994-053 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Among Israeli Arabs, Latent Anger Explodes

By Chris Hedges

RAHAT, Israel, Feb. 28 — On a windswept hill overlooking a patchwork of rolling farmland, 5,000 Arab men knelt as the body of Sami Abu Jama, who died Sunday in clashes with the police, was slowly lowered into the rocky soil. Black flags of mourning, green Islamic banners and Palestinian flags snapped taut in the wind.

Angry young men, many with their faces masked, chanted slogans vowing to avenge the death of Mr. Abu Jama, who was shot in a demonstration protesting the massacre of Muslim worshipers in Hebron. And militant Islamic leaders, their words amplified through a sound system, reminded the mourners that each Arab who fell was now a martyr in a holy struggle.

“There is a blood pact now between Palestinians who died in Hebron and here,” Raed Salah, the Mayor of Umm el Fahm, the second largest Arab city in Israel, told the crowd. “This pact reminds us that we are all an integral part of the wider Islamic and Arab world, and most of all that we are an integral part of the Palestinian people.”

The somber scene today, however, marked not just the death of another Arab youth, but the first time a Bedouin Arab living inside Israel had died in political violence. It underscored the deteriorating relations between Israeli Arabs and Israel.

And it was a signal that the aspirations for a Palestinian homeland, which have turned the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip into a battleground, are spreading to dozens of Arab towns and villages inside Israel. When the Israeli police used live ammunition against the crowd in Rahat on Sunday, killing Mr.

In Rahat, angry Arab youths vowed to avenge a friend’s death.

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is cropped to the article and its map. The dateline reads “RAHAT, Israel, Feb. 28”, consistent with a March 1, 1994 paper, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1994-058 →

· Newsday · Melville

Mosque Massacre Foreshadowed

Susan Sachs

Hebron, Israel-Occupied West Bank — Mohammed Abu Ghet was walking through the pre-dawn darkness to pray at the mosque last Friday when he crossed paths with a lone man he says was a Jewish settler. From a few feet away, the man shouldered an automatic rifle and fired three bullets into Abu Ghet’s chest and stomach.

The 18-year-old Palestinian quarry worker survived. Speaking from Hebron’s Aliya Hospital yesterday, he said he was shot only one hour before settler Baruch Goldstein slipped into another mosque nearby and massacred dozens of Arab worshipers as they knelt in morning prayers.

“I saw the picture of Goldstein in the newspaper,” said Abu Ghet, convalescing with three bullets fired from an automatic rifle still lodged in his body. “I don’t think it was the same man who shot me.”

In the pandemonium following the slaughter in the Ibrahimi mosque at the Cave of the Patriarchs, the attempted murder of Abu Ghet — the same morning in the same Palestinian city and apparently by one of the small coterie of Jewish settlers in the area — appears to have been overlooked.

An Israeli army spokesman said the incident was not reported to the military, but that it would be investigated in connection with the Goldstein killings.

The Abu Ghet shooting is one more indication of the dangerously tense atmosphere in Hebron in the hours before the massacre at the Cave of the Patriarchs, a site revered and fought over by both Muslims and Jews for centuries.

Late Thursday, soldiers had to break up a screaming match between Arab and Jewish worshipers at the Cave of the Patriarchs, a massive compound built over the reputed graves of biblical patriarchs and their wives.

According to several Arab Muslim witnesses, Jews were in a hall used by both religions for a special Purim service, reading the Book of Esther story about Jewish revenge on their enemies in ancient Persia. When a group of Arab men arrived for evening prayers, the witnesses said, soldiers told them they should conduct their service outside instead of disturbing the Jews.

The army has confirmed that a confrontation occurred that night when the Arabs were refused entrance to the mosque area. The Arabs said they shouted “God is Great” as the settlers responded with insults.

Jewish settlers from Kiryat Arba, the settlement adjacent to Hebron where Goldstein resided and other anti-Arab extremists live, claimed the Arabs shouted “Kill the Jews.” In any case, men from both sides said, the mood that night was full of mutual fear.

Violence continues in Hebron after last Friday’s massacre of Muslim worshipers as Palestinian youths on the ground and a rooftop hurl rocks at Israeli soliders yesterday.

CP-1994-023 →

· The New York Times · New York · page A6

In ‘Tragic Error,’ Soldiers Kill a Settler

“Israeli soldiers shot dead a Jewish settler in the occupied West Bank tonight, apparently believing him to be a Palestinian gunman, the army said. The episode — described by an army spokesman as a ‘tragic error’…”

Alan Cowell, six days after the mosque. One settler killed by Israeli soldiers, and the army’s phrase for it goes in the headline in quotation marks. Lower down the same page the count of the Palestinian dead is still being revised, and the paper notes the revision may not account for “the Palestinian practice of quickly removing bodies for burial without notifying Israeli military authorities”. One death gets a named error. Twenty-nine get an arithmetic problem.

CP-1994-054 →

· The New York Times · New York · page A1

Israel Eases Curfew in Territories; Ensuing Riots Deepen Pessimism

“Almost as soon as the Israeli army lifted curfews today in the occupied territories, rioting erupted and new deaths followed… the army began today to carry out other measures, telling 18 settlers to stay out of Arab towns and to turn in their army-issued rifles. The settlers vowed to defy what they called ‘insane orders.’”

Clyde Haberman, page one. Read the two halves against each other. The answer to a massacre of Palestinians was a curfew on Palestinians, and the news is that lifting it caused rioting. The answer for the settlers was being asked to stay out of Arab towns and hand back rifles the army had issued them. Binyamin Zeev Kahane calls that illegal and criminal.

CP-1994-055 →

· The New York Times · New York · page A8

West Bank Palestinians Wander in a No-Man’s Land Defined by Soldiers

“Yasir Abdallah al-Tarzi has not been able to go home for five days… a group of Israeli soldiers pulled up outside the Nativity Bakery in Bethlehem and told 18-year-old Iyad Elsheweiki and his two brothers they would have to shut down the ovens in their family’s bakery and go home.”

Youssef M. Ibrahim, under the standing head How It Feels to Be Occupied. The curfew counted in ordinary objects: the last bottle of tetanus injection on a pharmacy shelf, ovens shut at a bakery, a third of the nursing and medical staff of Makassed Hospital unable to reach it. Named here: Yasir Abdallah al-Tarzi, Younis Alwohoush, Iyad Elsheweiki and Dr. Rustom Nammari.

CP-1994-056 →

· The Arizona Republic · Phoenix

Deranged system to blame for murders at the Ibrahimi Mosque

The massacre at the Ibrahimi Mosque in the Occupied West Bank has reportedly resulted in at least 93 people dead and 300 wounded, according to sources in Hebron. This disaster is shocking to 1 billion Muslims who are worshiping in unison on this scared month of Ramadan, to all people who believe in the one God and to all who want to promote human decency.

This tragedy did not occur because of a deranged person, but it happened because of a deranged system, an Israeli occupation that tells one religion to dominate other people’s land.

It is not surprising that this American physician from Brooklyn was settling in Kiryat Arba, for it is the same village that produced Robert Manning, the suspected terrorist responsible for bombing the offices of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee and the assassinating Alex Odeh in 1985.

Kiryat Arba is also a haven for Jewish terrorism against innocent Palestinian civilians and worshipers.

A trend has developed in assaulting Muslim mosques: in 1968, the Al-Aqsa mosque was destroyed; in 1990, the Temple Mount Faithful attacked the Al Aqsa mosque and killed Muslim worshipers; and finally, worshipers were killed in the Ibrahimi mosque and more Palestinians are being killed on the streets as they protest the slaughter.

Prime Minister Yitzak Rabin is disregarding the enormity of this extremism by considering the massacre simply as an act of one madman. Officials spent four months to determine if John Hinckley was a madman for attempting an assassination against former President Reagan; tragically, Israeli officials want us to believe that they diagnosed Dr.

Goldstein within four minutes to determine his insanity. American citizens, who foot the bill of Israel’s aggression, should demand the facts from Israeli authorities. For the U.S.-sponsored peace process to have a chance of success, President Clinton must now deal with the issues that have been exposed in this bloody onslaught.

First, Palestinian security should be a priority for achieving a just settlement in the Occupied Territories, and not simply settlement in the Occupied Territories, and not simply Israeli security.

While Israeli settlers are armed and roam through the land defiantly, Palestinians have been suppressed and disarmed, only to be continuously brutalized by Israeli soldiers and settlers. Second, the president must clearly stand against terrorism. Substantial evidence has surfaced that this creed of Jewish terrorism from places like Kiryat Arba will continue.

Third, mosques must be protected by Muslims, so that worshipers do not have to worry about these massacres while bowing down to God in their most humble prostration. God promised the Holy Land to the seeds of Abraham (Genesis 17:18), and these seeds include Christians and Muslims, not just Jews.

Jewish fundamentalism, however, has adulterated this biblical verse to satisfy its form of religious bigotry. It is time for all Americans who want a policy that reflects decency and is not stained by the blood of martyrs to cry out for justice in the Middle East.

CP-1994-016 →

· Democrat and Chronicle · Rochester

Palestinians in terror

Mosque massacre is only latest episode; when will they be protected?

As a Palestinian born in Al Quds, or Jerusalem, I have often prayed in the Haram al Ibrahimi in Khalil, or Hebron, where the latest massacre of Palestinians took place. I underscore the word “latest” because this bloody outburst against Palestinians is by no means the first large-scale terrorist act — nor will it be the last.

The American media’s memory may be short, but I recall only too vividly the 1992 attacks by Israeli security forces that killed and injured 354 Palestinians at the Haram al Sherif mosque (Dome of the Rock) in Al Quds (Jerusalem) in 1992. Such spectacular acts of terrorism tend to mask a relentless if veiled campaign that continues to claim Palestinian lives as I write.

According to news reports, in the three days after the massacre of prostrate worshipers at the Ibrahimi mosque Feb. 25, the Israelis killed a total of 11 Palestinians. Then there was news of another five deaths. Israeli security has failed. It has not protected the Palestinian people.

Israel must allow United Nations troops to protect the Palestinians, which Israel has always refused to do. Had international troops been close by the holy places — Jewish, Christian and Muslim — these crimes might not have happened.

Palestinian man carries his son into emergency room at Jerusalem hospital Feb. 25 after mosque massacre that killed at least 39.

CP-1994-019 →

· The Patriot-News · page A6

Palestinians clash with Israeli soldiers in Hebron

By Said Ghazali, Associated Press

HEBRON, Occupied West Bank — Hundreds of Palestinians stoned a Jewish enclave in the heart of this Arab city today, clashing with soldiers when a two-week curfew imposed after the mosque massacre was lifted briefly. Soldiers protecting the Beit Hadassah compound fired tear gas and rubber bullets at Palestinians who hurled stones with slingshots.

Protesters, some shouting “settlers out,” set tires on fire and rolled them at army positions. Eight Palestinians were wounded, one seriously, and others suffered from tear gas inhalation, hospital officials said.

Beit Hadassah is one of a half-dozen settlements that the PLO has demanded be evacuated to reduce tensions and clear the way for the resumption of Israel-PLO peace talks, which were suspended after the Feb. 25 massacre. The unrest began after the army lifted the curfew for two hours to allow Palestinians to shop for food.

Noam Arnon, a spokesman for the 450 settlers in Hebron, said Palestinians used mosque loudspeakers overnight to threaten the settlers in Hebrew. “Your day will come, and we will destroy all of you,” he quoted the message as saying.

Danny Hizmi, a Beit Hadassah resident, said the army asked settlers to stay indoors while the curfew was lifted but several defied the request to show they could not be cowed. Tensions have remained high between the city's 80,000 Palestinians and 450 Jewish settlers living in six enclaves.

The Palestinians have been confined to their homes under an army-imposed curfew since the massacre, while armed Jewish settlers walked around freely. The rioting in Hebron came as an inquiry commission held its third session, taking testimony from soldiers present at the Tomb of the Patriarchs when the massacre took place.

A New York-born doctor, Baruch Goldstein, gunned down 30 Muslims as they knelt in prayer at the tomb. Chief Superintendent Meir Tayar, the border police commander in Hebron, told the panel in Jerusalem that he received orders several months ago to forbid troops from opening fire on Israeli civilians who fired at Palestinians.

Pressed by the commission head, Meir Shamgar, if such an order seemed logical to him, Tayar replied: “Not so much. I was not 100 percent comfortable with it.” He said various officers' discomfort with the order “was discussed” but he nonetheless passed the rule down to the enlisted men. Hebron's military governor, Col.

Shalom Goldstein, denied claims by Muslim clerics that Israel destroyed important evidence by rinsing blood-soaked carpets and stone floors after the massacre. “There was no attempt to whitewash anything,” Goldstein said.

CP-1994-072 →

· The New York Times

Palestinian Killed

The following article has been altered by Israeli military censorship. HEBRON, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, March 22 (AP) — Violent fighting broke out today between Palestinians and Israeli soldiers in Hebron, and Arab journalists said a Palestinian was killed by army gunfire. The Palestinian, Hunduk Zahdeh, 34 and pregnant, died instantly, the journalists said.

The Israel radio said dozens of Palestinians were wounded. The fighting began when a curfew was lifted briefly so residents could buy food. The United Nations Relief and Works Agency also said Israeli soldiers had seized two United Nations officers in a refugee camp northwest of Nablus, handcuffed them and dragged them out of the camp.

A spokesman for the agency, Sandro Tucci, said the officers were arrested after “observing an incident between Israeli soldiers and Palestinian civilians, including women and children.” Elsewhere in the West Bank, Israeli soldiers wounded five Palestinian children, including a 6-month-old girl, during confrontations with stone-throwing youths, Arab reports said.

In the Gaza Strip, Arabs stabbed two Israelis on a farm, seriously injuring one of them, the army radio said. It said that one attacker was captured.

CP-1994-067 →

· The New York Times · page A10

First Arabs to Address Hebron Hearing Say They Heard Explosions

By JOEL GREENBERG / Special to The New York Times

JERUSALEM, March 22 — Palestinian survivors of the Hebron massacre testified today before an Israeli commission of inquiry, providing the first Arab accounts at the public hearings. Muslim officials from Hebron refused to testify last week, and today at least one witness arrived with a summons from the Israeli military. Mutual distrust permeated the session.

Some of the five panel members were openly skeptical of the Palestinian accounts when they diverged from earlier statements that the same witnesses had given to investigators. For their part, the Palestinians voiced their grievances against Jewish settlers in Hebron and said they hoped the panel — four Israeli Jews and an Israeli Arab — would be impartial.

The accounts today added new and contradictory elements to the picture of the carnage on Feb. 25 at the Cave of the Patriarchs, where an Israeli settler killed at least 29 Muslims at prayer. The only previous testimony was from Israeli soldiers and settlers.

Reports of Explosions A few of the 12 Arab witnesses, all from Hebron, said they had heard gunfire coming from different directions, suggesting that more than one attacker was involved. Several said they had also heard at least one powerful explosion.

But they immediately came under close questioning by panel members who pointed to discrepancies between what the witnesses said today and what they had told investigators just after the massacre. Those statements, parts of which were read aloud today, made no mention of multiple sources of gunfire, and did not allude to possible accomplices.

But the witnesses insisted that their testimony today was correct and that there had been earlier omissions. Muhammed Musbah al-Jaabari said the attack by the settler, Dr. Baruch Goldstein, had begun with “an explosion that shook the hall,” followed by gunfire and another blast. A third explosion occurred when fire extinguishers were hit by gunfire, he said.

“We heard more than one source of shooting,” Mr. Jaabari said. “When Goldstein took out an empty clip, firing continued from another source. The shooting alternated, each time from a different direction. There was a strong echo in the hall, but clearly there was more than one source of gunfire, perhaps two or three.”

Abdel Hafiz Salman al-Jaabari, a member of the same extended family, said the attack had begun with two powerful explosions. “We thought it was an earthquake,” he said. “People got up to run away and the shooting began. The firing was coming from three locations.” Yusri Mahmud al-Jamal testified that he had heard shooting from two directions.

“The sounds of the gunfire were different,” he said. “One had a higher pitch, the other was lower.” None of the witnesses reported actually seeing an assailant other than Dr. Goldstein, although one said his son had reported seeing a second attacker. Some witnesses complained of persistent harassment at the shrine by Jewish settlers, and by Dr. Goldstein in particular.

They said settlers had poured acid on prayer rugs, stolen shoes that Muslim worshipers had taken off as a sign of respect, hurled chairs, and disrupted Muslim services. Abdel Hafiz al-Jaabari appealed for the evictions of the settlers. “There are half a million Arabs in the Hebron area,” he said.

“Either they will have to go to the Arab states, or the troublemakers will have to be moved out.”

Witnesses to a Massacre / Palestinian survivors of the Hebron massacre began testifying before an Israeli panel of inquiry, providing the first Arab accounts at the public hearings. Four witnesses waited to be called yesterday. Page A10. [credit: Associated Press]

CP-1994-068 →

· The New York Times

Massacre and Redemption

By Emile Habibi

NAZARETH, Israel — There is an old Arab saying that the Jews celebrate their feasts around gardens, the Christians inside kitchens and the Muslims around graveyards. This year, at the end of the Islamic holy month of Ramadan, the Arab residents of the West Bank town of Hebron had a tragic new reason to keep this old tradition.

The lifting of a round-the-clock curfew for a few hours on March 11 was barely enough time for the Arab residents of Hebron to visit the new graves of beloved ones, victims of the massacre at the shrine of Abraham in Hebron on Feb. 25. Since that date, the land has been cloaked with sorrow and shame.

The sorrow of the bereaved families is blended with the shame of all those who refused to anticipate the possibility of such a crime. Negotiators on all sides in the current peace talks have mainly been interested in whether the Palestinians can peacefully coexist with Israel. No one dared ask whether Israel was capable of peaceful coexistence with the Palestinians.

Yet there is no alternative but to believe that the peace process will overcome the Hebron ordeal. All but the most militant Palestinians recognize that reconciliation with Israel is the only salvation. Our determination to survive was born out of such ordeals.

The 1956 massacre by Israeli border police at Kfar Kasim, an Arab village in Israel, which claimed 49 lives, only strengthened the attachment of Israel’s Arabs to their homeland. As for our Israeli Jewish brothers and sisters, they have also shown that they are here to stay.

If it were not for this mutual recognition between Palestinians and Israelis — of the impossibility of forcing either people from their only homeland — this historic reconciliation could not be achieved.

Since the United Nations partition of 1947, most Palestinians have understood that our national conflict with Israel could not be resolved through one nation annihilating the other, as in centuries past. The fact is that my people, the Palestinian people, were always the ones who were threatened with being forced to leave.

Thus Israel’s recognition of the P.L.O., which continues to fight for Palestinian self-determination, is a great achievement, and it cannot be altered either by massacres or by extremists on either side. Yet one cannot go on pretending that nothing has changed after the Hebron massacre.

This month Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin said he did not dare even to imagine “what the reaction of the Jews would be if an Arab madman were to commit a massacre against Jewish worshipers in the shrine of Abraham.”

Sober-minded and responsible Israeli politicians cannot allow themselves the luxury of presuming that they will be able to keep every faction under control, even if they have the best and most sophisticated security. Instead, most Palestinians and Israelis have concluded that we have gone too far in the peace process to turn back, and that we must put our faith in the future.

Palestinian leaders who support the peace agreement dared to drink the bitter cup of telling their people that they must pay a very high price for achieving a secure future in their homeland, almost as high as the one the mother was prepared to pay in King Solomon’s court: she would have given up her child to save it.

We have the help of courageous and honest Israeli Jewish colleagues, exemplary in their defense of mutual recognition. Yet many Israeli leaders, especially among the politicians, refuse to tell their people that they must reach out to the Palestinians; they have nobody else to rely on in the long run.

In Arabic we have a saying: “Even if your beloved one were made of honey, do not suck it all.” There is a limit to the endurance of the Palestinians, an ancient people with a rich legacy, as with any other people. But their endurance is their pledge of their belief in the future. We, Israelis and Palestinians, are already fated to be born again as Siamese twins.

We hope the rest of the world has already understood that true solidarity with one is contingent on true solidarity with the other. There is no alternative. Palestinians and Israelis alike have a duty to stand up to our own extremists. Yet the Israeli extremists are the real threat, not only to the peace process but also to the future of Israel itself.

That much has been proved by the Hebron massacre. Israel needs to show by its actions that it can live in peace with the Arab world. After all, it was Foreign Minister Shimon Peres, in his report to the Knesset on Baruch Goldstein’s massacre at Hebron, who said: “Only God almighty knows the way out of what this damned man has done to us.

The norms of peaceful coexistence have been frustrated and we should not underestimate the dangers.” God always knows. What is new is the encouraging beginnings of recognition by Israeli leaders and the Israeli people that they can no longer hesitate to drink their own bitter cup.

CP-1994-063 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

After Hebron, a Fierce Test of Bedouin Loyalty

By Clyde Haberman

RAHAT, Israel, March 30 — In this Bedouin town on the northern lip of the Negev, not an Israeli flag was to be seen today. Palestinian flags were hoisted at an annual Arab protest event called Land Day, and so were green Islamic banners. But when a man tried to wave an Israeli flag, someone yanked it down and a scuffle broke out.

The fight over banners in a Rahat park was a sign of how the anger ignited by the Hebron massacre last month has yet to subside, not just in the occupied territories but also among the roughly 800,000 Arabs who are citizens of Israel.

“Not having an Israeli flag today is a way of accusing the Israeli Government and holding it responsible for the killings, including the killing of a person from this place,” said Talab al-Sana, a Rahat resident who is a member of Parliament. “Our destiny is to live with each other.

But coexistence between the two peoples has to be based on equality, not repression.” Post-Hebron resentment is keen among Israeli Arabs, especially in Rahat, 10 miles north of Beersheba, where a young man was shot to death by the police during protests that erupted soon after the massacre of Muslim worshipers by a Jewish settler.

Not without anecdotal evidence to make their case, the Israeli Arabs here are convinced that the authorities would not have fired so readily if the demonstrators had been Jews. They had as an example a daylong siege last week of a house in Yehud, near Tel Aviv, where a politically fiery rabbi and his followers had barricaded themselves and battled the police.

Those Jewish protesters had shot at police officers and thrown gasoline bombs, but still the authorities held their fire and negotiated a peaceful surrender. In Rahat last month, where the demonstrators’ main weapons were stones, the police used guns. Even Israel’s police chief, Rafi Peled, says officers were too quick on the trigger.

In an internal memo published today in Haaretz and affirmed as accurate by a police spokesman, Mr. Peled said that “in Rahat we shot too much.”

In the aftermath of the Hebron massacre, Israeli Arabs are torn between their citizenship and Palestinian identity. Women in Rahat, a Bedouin town in the Negev, waved a Palestinian flag yesterday during a rally. (Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times)

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is cropped to the article, photograph and map. The dateline reads “RAHAT, Israel, March 30”, consistent with a March 31, 1994 paper, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1994-059 →

· The Record · Hackensack · page 1

Political correctness stifles Palestinian artists

Neil MacFarquhar, The Associated Press, Gaza City

GAZA CITY, Occupied Gaza Strip — For Palestinian artists, it was inevitable that the first movie premiered here in recent memory would deal with Gaza under occupation. As Israeli jeeps burst across the screen, the audience backed up the soundtrack with the echoing whistles used throughout the occupied territories to warn of soldiers approaching.

Those watching “Curfew,” which premiered during the winter in the territories and Israel, wanted their art that way — a reflection of reality. But for Palestinian painters, writers, and filmmakers, realism is becoming an artistic burden.

The artists, ignored unless they pay homage to Palestinian causes, find that occupation themes stamp their work with an unremitting sameness.

They are especially eager for peace, hoping it will liberate them from the obligations of political correctness, but fear the Palestine Liberation Organization won’t let that happen. “A painting without a reference to Jerusalem, a painting without a Palestinian flag, without any symbol of the cause, would be rejected as not Palestinian art,” said painter Fayez Sirsawi.

“People want art to reflect their daily lives. Otherwise they don’t understand it.” In addition to politics, Muslim artists must deal with religious codes that declare representations of the human figure to be shameful because only God can create humans. Sometimes when the two issues seem at odds, politics wins.

Artists in Gaza tell of a religious leader connected to the fundamentalist Islamic Resistance Movement, or Hamas, who visited an exhibition of work by art students. He was especially incensed by sculpted abstract human figures. After the artist explained that the figures represented youths pelting Israeli soldiers with stones, the cleric gave it his blessing.

“The themes of the struggle have dominated our cultural life for the past 50 years or so, maybe to the point of total preoccupation, to the point of obsession,” said Eyad Sarraj, a psychologist. “It has stunted creativity and smothered freedom of expression. It has made art and culture run in circles.

There isn’t the courage to challenge the taboos.” The uprising against occupation that began in December 1987 has put especially tight reins on artists… But change may be on the way; Palestinians are beginning to find the old themes dull.

Teachers of children’s art classes say the youngsters are using more colors, that the sun is getting bigger while the Palestinian flags shrink. In “Curfew,” director Rashid Masharawi, a Gazan, depicts the deadening effect of having to stay inside day after day. Risky art, especially poetry, does have an audience.

Well-known poet Mahmoud Darwish, who resigned from the PLO executive committee to protest the autonomy agreement with Israel, wrote a long work laced with sarcasm about Palestinian leaders handing over their people’s birthright to Israel.

One Associated Press dispatch, four papers, four headlines. The Record: “Political correctness stifles Palestinian artists.” The Houston Post: “Palestinian artists hope peace will liberate them.” The Sun: “Palestinian artists bound by their own politics.” The Kalamazoo Gazette: “Palestinian artists wonder how free new state would be.” The Record and the Kalamazoo Gazette also ran different lengths of it: Kalamazoo cut the Hamas cleric, Mahmoud Darwish’s resignation and Masharawi’s name from the body. All four scans are held.

CP-1994-008 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago · page 1

A Palestinian woman interrupts an Israeli soldier aiming at stone-throwers to request safe passage in the Gaza town of Deir El Balah

“A Palestinian woman interrupts an Israeli soldier aiming at stone-throwers Monday to request safe passage in the Gaza town of Deir El Balah.” AP photo.

CP-1994-002 →

· Honolulu Star-Bulletin · Honolulu

Rev. Jackson gets caught in violence in Hebron during trip

HEBRON, West Bank — U.S. civil rights leader Jesse Jackson today led Palestinians in a chant of “keep hope alive” when he visited the West Bank town of Hebron, scene of the February mosque massacre.

The black leader, who received a dose of tear gas in downtown Hebron when his bus was caught in a battle between Palestinian stone-throwers and Israeli soldiers, urged Palestinians and Israelis to break the cycle of violence.

At least 25 Palestinians were shot and wounded by the soldiers during the clashes that erupted around the bus as Jackson was about to leave Hebron without visiting al-Ibrahimi mosque, scene of the massacre. Jackson, on a peace mission to Israel and the occupied territories, was unhurt.

Moments earlier, he stood on a parked car opposite an Israeli army checkpoint, telling a crowd of young Palestinians to back peace and assuring them their day of freedom was near. Jackson arrived in Israel yesterday at the invitation of Palestinian leaders in Hebron and Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres.

He said he came to Hebron to deliver a message of peace and justice, urging Israelis and Palestinians to abandon violence. Palestinian leaders complained about Israeli army crackdowns and urged Jackson to help reopen the mosque, closed since the massacre, and to work for the evacuation of some 400 Jewish settlers from Hebron.

Also today, Israel announced it would import foreign workers to replace Palestinians banned from the Jewish state after two recent Arab guerrilla attacks. Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin reported to his security cabinet yesterday the sealing off of the occupied territories to protect Israelis from more revenge attacks over the Hebron massacre.

The closure, which a government statement said would last at least until after Israel’s independence day on Thursday, effectively keeps 60,000 to 70,000 Palestinians away from their mainly manual labor jobs in the Jewish state.

The Rev. Jesse Jackson and his entourage sit trapped in their tour bus as Palestinian stone-throwers battle Israeli soldiers in Hebron today. The U.S. civil rights leader was on a private peace mission to the town.

CP-1994-020 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Bars Entry to Palestinians of West Bank and Gaza

By Clyde Haberman

JERUSALEM, April 8 — Israel took measures today to rid itself of Arab labor from the occupied territories by imposing an indefinite ban on Palestinian entry and by deciding to bring in thousands of foreign construction workers and farm hands.

Confining Palestinians to the West Bank and Gaza Strip is a tactic that Israel often uses to reassure its jittery population, only to relax the restrictions after a while.

But after two terrorist attacks this week that killed 8 Israelis and wounded nearly 50 others, and with Islamic radicals warning of more bloodshed to come, the Government says that this time it means business about keeping the populations apart.

“The first thing on the agenda is to improve the national sense of personal security,” said Oded Ben-Ami, a spokesman for Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin.

Once again, however, the Government said the violence would not deflect it from negotiations with the Palestine Liberation Organization on carrying out the long-delayed plan for Palestinian self-rule and a companion Israeli troop withdrawal, starting in Gaza and the West Bank town of Jericho. According to Mr. Ben-Ami, Mr.

Rabin told senior ministers who form his “security Cabinet” that Israel’s negotiators would resume talks in Cairo on Sunday “in spite of the anger and agony” over the latest attacks.

Opposition leaders have demanded a halt in the negotiations, just as they were suspended by the P.L.O. for five weeks after an Israeli settler killed at least 29 Palestinians worshipers at a Hebron mosque on Feb. 25.

But there is no appetite for such a course among Government leaders, who fear that the longer it takes to carry out the Gaza-Jericho plan, the greater the chances for an act of violence so severe that it causes the entire package to come unglued.

The Rev. Jesse Jackson, standing on a car next to Taysir Tamini, a Muslim prayer leader, urged Palestinians in Hebron to pursue peace yesterday. Later, Mr. Jackson was caught in the middle of a skirmish between stone-throwing Palestinians and the Israeli Army. (Associated Press)

Date check: The running head reads THE NEW YORK TIMES INTERNATIONAL SATURDAY, APRIL — the day of the month and the year run off the right edge of the scan and cannot be read. The dateline reads “JERUSALEM, April 8”, and April 9, 1994 was a Saturday, so the slide date is consistent with what is legible, but the printed date is only partly visible.

CP-1994-060 →

· The New York Times

Cold-Blooded Killer

(Rabbi) William G. Hamilton

To the Editor: “The tyrant dies and his rule is over; the martyr dies and his rule begins.” Soren Kierkegaard’s words have never been more applicable than in the wake of Baruch Goldstein’s antihuman, anti-Jewish act of barbarism in Hebron. Condemnation of the massacre was swift and thoroughgoing. Yet Dr.

Goldstein’s horrific deed has been magnified to the point of taking on a life all its own. Anthony Lewis suggests in “Self-Inflicted Wounds” (column, April 1) that Israelis and Israel’s supporters kid themselves if they cannot see that Dr. Goldstein’s act shows how oppressed and threatened Palestinians have been under 27 years of occupation.

How remarkable it is that a tiny band of extremist Jewish settlers now appear so widespread that they represent the greatest threat to peace as well as to the moral fabric and security of Israel. The monster of the Hebron massacre has not made a monster out of every opponent of the Gaza-Jericho First peace plan.

Baruch Goldstein’s heinous act also does not entitle Emile Habibi to fabricate history in “Massacre and Redemption” (Op-Ed, March 28) by claiming that a national conflict between Israelis and Arabs has witnessed century-old attempts to annihilate one another. Precisely who was Baruch Goldstein emulating from the annals of Jewish history?

A tragedy within the tragedy is that Baruch Goldstein was a cold-blooded killer, not a self-glorifying martyr.

CP-1994-064 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia · page 1

Joyful Gazans anticipate era of peace

“…and hope to the people of Gaza and Jericho,’ Jabali said, but he indicated changes would take time. He told reporters the initial force of 1,500 Palestinian police officers would arrive in a week with uniforms and arms. Jabali also said the nightly curfew, one of the most hated aspects of Israel’s occupation, would not be lifted immediately.

‘We are not in control yet,’ he said. Three of the police commanders traveled in Israeli military jeeps to Jericho, expected to be the government center for Palestinian self-rule. The phased transfer of authority is largely hinged on the arrival of 7,000 policemen from outside and training 2,000 locally.

Palestinians, still doubtful about the degree of control Israel will have over their lives, did not make the signing ceremony a holiday. But the effects of the signing were immediately visible in Gaza with the start of the 11 a.m. ceremony in Cairo.

At the Rafah crossing in southern Gaza, Palestinian officials and Israeli officers watched television together as they waited for the Palestinian police commanders.

An hour after the signing, the first of 600 Palestinian prisoners, including four belonging to factions opposed to the PLO-Israel accord, got off buses on the outskirts of Gaza City to the ululations of welcoming relatives.

The four, two of them members of the militant Islamic group Hamas, which has vowed to continue attacking Israelis, had to sign a statement condemning violence and terror. As part of the PLO-Israel agreement, Israel is to free 5,000 Palestinian inmates over the next three weeks — about half those held in Israeli jails.

Israel also allowed 14 Palestinian deportees and 10 dependents to enter Israel yesterday, bringing to about 150 the number allowed back since negotiations started. Most were members of PLO Chairman Yasir Arafat’s Fatah faction who are expected to take on administrative roles.

The army sealed off Jericho early in the day, and soldiers dragged dozens of Jewish settlers out of an ancient synagogue nearby, where they had gathered to protest the autonomy agreement. Organizers said soldiers took settlers from the synagogue while they were still praying and wearing prayer shawls.

Israeli officials said about 100 settlers were detained, but settlers said 400 were taken to a nearby army camp. Right-wing Israeli leaders vowed to stage demonstrations and fight to keep autonomy from being extended to other areas of the occupied territories.

On the Palestinian side, Hamas supporters oppose the self-rule plan for not meeting Palestinian demands for an independent state. ‘We are against such agreement, and we will remain so. It is a sad day for the Palestinian people,’ said Mahmoud Zahar, a Hamas leader.

Some Palestinians expressed hope that self-rule will bring security and economic well-being, but others were skeptical. ‘I doubt that Yasir Arafat will be able to provide me with a good education and good living conditions,’ said Khaled Hussein, 19, a resident of Beach Refugee Camp in Gaza. Awad Abd-Al, 55, sounded more hopeful.

‘We hope there will be peace so that I can stop worrying about my boys getting shot by the Israelis,’ he said.”

“An Israeli soldier watches celebrants in Gaza City. The PLO’s Yasir Arafat expressed hope that violence will subside as the talks bear fruit.” Associated Press / Gavin Smith

The jump page of a front-page story. Two ordinary Gazans are named and quoted at the end, one doubtful and one hopeful, and the paper gives both of them the last word.

Correction: {'note': 'Headline corrected on re-read: the record carried “Celebration”, which is not printed on this page.'}

CP-1994-003 →

· Rutland Daily Herald · Rutland · page 1

After Joy, What's Next In Middle East?

Trudy Rubin, Philadelphia Inquirer editorial board, Gaza City

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — On Wednesday, the day that Israel turned over control of the occupied Gaza Strip to the Palestinians who live there, I saw something that summed up the hopes and fears invested in this dramatic step toward peace.

The leading Israeli peace group, Peace Now, started a demonstration just outside the entrance to Gaza in support of Palestinian self-rule and mutual co-existence.

Several hundred Israelis of all ages showed up, though Gaza is a good distance from central Israel… Gaza — a tiny, impoverished dot of land crammed with 800,000 Palestinians — was a hotbed of fevered resistance to Israeli rule.

However, two leading Gaza activists from Yasir Arafat’s Fatah group circulated among the demonstrators, shaking Israeli hands and making brief remarks. Both had been recently released from Israeli prisons after serving, respectively, 21 and 24 years for organizing armed resistance to the occupation.

One, Hishm Abdul Razk, insisted to me, “I really believe there can be peace between an Israeli and a Palestinian state.”… A small group of Palestinian farmers — mostly men but with three women, two small children and a donkey — had gathered on the other side.

One of them was waving a flagpole bearing both an Israeli and a Palestinian flag… The rest of the Palestinians were waving their arms and shouting “salaam” (peace) while the women ululated… One man tied a Palestinian flag to the Israeli banner he had been carrying. A woman beside me wept, saying over and over again “It’s beautiful.”

Some Israeli teenagers started chanting “Israel-Palestine, Two countries for two peoples” and both sides waved madly at each other… Latif Dori, a well-known Israeli peace activist, shouted furiously, “Rabin and Arafat meet in Cairo and we can’t meet those people”… A Palestinian woman beside me nodded, adding, with a glance toward a raucous Israeli counter-demonstrator, “There are maniacs on both sides who can cause hurt.”… So Zucker began urging the angry Israeli crowd to move back.

But as he did, he grabbed an Israeli flag and walked deliberately toward the fence.

Cutting through the police line — with legislative immunity — and dodging the police cars, he reached the barrier and passed the flag across the barbed wire and was given a Palestinian flag in return… all around I heard Israelis saying, “We have waited for this for so many years.”… But in the meantime, as the Israelis pull out, Arafat has failed to assign Palestinians to positions of authority to keep services and security in Gaza in operation… uncertainty breeds grumbling, or jokes, about Arafat’s theatrical performance at Wednesday’s signing ceremony in Cairo and his autocratic ways.

And more serious complaints can be heard widely about the Palestinian leader’s effort to exert control over every charitable or social or educational institution in Gaza.

Many Gazans worry that international donations to build the infrastructure will disappear into private Fatah hands… Ex-prisoner Abdul Razk tells me firmly, “I don’t believe Arafat will press unfairly on local Palestinian leaders.

But any undemocratic action will cause a reaction from us.”… As I leave Gaza, an Israeli soldier checking cars entering his country asks me anxiously what I have seen in Gaza. When I tell him people are celebrating, he smiles and says, “This has to be good for both sides.”

The paper spells him Hishm Abdul Razk. It says the two released men served “respectively, 21 and 24 years” and names only one of them, so which term is his is not on the page.

CP-1994-004 →

· The New York Times

In Gaza, a ‘Shoot’ Is Not Just Film Slang

By JOEL GREENBERG

GAZA Cradling plastic replicas of rifles and dressed in mock Israeli Army fatigues, helmets and bullet-proof vests, a group of Arab actors stood in an orange grove last month and pointed their fake guns at a Palestinian boy. As one actor playing a jittery soldier went through the motions of shooting, a burst of genuine gunfire rattled in the distance.

Real Israeli soldiers were patroling nearby roads, checking cars for fugitive Palestinian militants. The scene in the orchard was from a Palestinian movie described by its makers as the first feature film made entirely in the Gaza Strip, other than documentaries.

It has been shot here over the last two months in circumstances that often blur the line between staged drama and reality. The production may be the last under such conditions. The Israeli Army has begun withdrawing under an agreement on Palestinian self-rule.

“Tale of the Three Lost Jewels” is set against the background of the Palestinian uprising in the occupied territories. A mixture of realism and allegory, it traces the odyssey of a Palestinian boy who tries to win a beautiful girl by finding lost jewels from her grandmother's necklace.

The imagery is left unexplained, but the three gems may symbolize a Palestinian's roots; the people are divided into those in Israel, those in the occupied territories and those in the Diaspora. The jewels are thought to be lost in South America, where many Palestinians immigrated after the 1948 Arab-Israeli war.

Arabs playing Israeli soldiers in “Tale of the Three Lost Jewels” check a Palestinian they “killed.” In the distance, real shots broke out. (Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times)

CP-1994-062 →

· Clarion Ledger · Jackson

Criticism of Zionism itself is not anti-Semitic

I recently tried an experiment. After reading the March 6 Clarion-Ledger Perspective section, I counted the words therein devoted to denouncing Khalid Muhammad and Louis Farrakhan for bad-mouthing white Christians and Jews. I then attempted to count the words condemning Major Barukh Goldstein for shooting praying Muslim children in the back.

The totals were, Muhammad and Farrakhan: 2,256; Goldstein: 0. One article in that Sunday section described the nation of Islam as a “fringe group with neglegible political and economic power.”

Israel, on the other hand, receives billions in U.S. aid — more than any other country — employs influential lobbyists in Washington and is apparently so confident of U.S. backing it defies U.N. resolutions with impunity.

How, then, do insulting remarks by spokesmen for a “neglegible fringe group” merit such in-depth editorial treatment in The Clarion-Ledger, but mass-murder by an American-Israeli army terrorist merits no mention whatsoever? The bullets that slaughtered my breatheren-at Al-Ilbrahimi Mosque were paid for with U.S. tax dollars!

Although American and Israeli propagandists claim the Hebron abomination was the act of a “lone gunman,” survivors stated as many as five soldiers fired on the worshipers. Also, the victims weren’t just “men and boys” as was repeatedly claimed.

Goldstein, aided (or at the very least unhindered) by his army cohorts, entered the Mosque and fired into the back rows of defenseless prostrated worshipers. In Muslim congregational prayer, women pray behind their men.

Major Goldstein — may he forever suffer Hell’s vilest torments — murdered men, women and children for the “crime” of having been born on land coveted by the Israelis. The Al-Ibrahimi massacre is by no means the first such atrocity perpetrated by Palestine’s European colonizers.

In October 1990, Israeli occupation troops murdered 18 Muslims at Al-Aqsa Mosque. More than 100 Mosques have been destroyed and many more forcibly closed since the occupation began. It seems the primary goal of the occupiers, whether in army uniform or in “settlers” garb, is to torment and murder unarmed Palestinian Muslims at every opportunity.

The Palestinians are forced to fight the depradations of the most heavily-armed population outside South Africa with sticks, knives and stones. Experience teaches that to criticize Israel is to invite Farrakhan’s fate of being branded “anti-Semite” by Israel’s vocal apologists in this country.

I, therefore, close by pointing out that being anti-Zionist doesn’t make me “anti-Semitic” — quite the contrary. I despise Nazis, and it doesn’t matter to me whether they justify their crimes by claiming to be “the Master Race” or “God’s Chosen People.”

CP-1994-018 →

· The New York Times

Rustum Bastuni, 71, Builder and Teacher

Rustum Bastuni, a retired New York architect and campaigner for Palestinian-Israeli conciliation, died on April 25 at his home on the Upper West Side. He was 71. The cause was a heart attack, his family said. Mr. Bastuni was born in Palestine near Haifa, trained at Technion, the Israel Institute of Technology, and became an assistant town planner in Haifa.

He also planned permanent housing in the Negev for Bedouin, a nomadic people, on behalf of the Israeli Government. He served as an Arab member of the Israeli Parliament from 1951 to 1955 and as an Israeli delegate to international peace congresses. He also contributed articles to various publications and had a weekly broadcast on Israeli radio.

After coming to the United States in 1969, he lectured at universities around the country on the prospects for peace in the Middle East. He was an adjunct professor of Middle East history at the State University of New York at Purchase in the 1970’s and played an active role in a number of organizations working for peace and international understanding.

CP-1994-066 →

· The News Journal

Little peace accorded settlers in Gaza

Police presence not enough to calm residents’ fears

NETZARIM, Gaza Strip — No sooner had Palestinian autonomy started in the Gaza Strip than a Jewish settler was ambushed and wounded on his way home. By Thursday, this tiny Jewish enclave resembled an armed camp. Most men in the community of 27 families were armed, and dozens of Israeli soldiers were visible.

But residents seem to believe that even a ratio of one soldier for every two settlers might not be enough to ensure their security. About 5,000 Israelis live among the 750,000 autonomous Palestinians.

For Shlomit Ziv, 24, a pregnant mother of two, the dangers to herself and her family are a necessary sacrifice for what she called “the struggle for Jews’ rights to live in the Land of Israel.” “The situation in Gaza will eventually dissolve into such chaos that the government will have no choice but to send the army to reoccupy it,” said Ziv.

“When we came here, we knew it would not be easy.” The withdrawal from Gaza was popular in Israel. The support there for settlements on the West Bank does not exist where Gaza is concerned. Nearly half of Gaza’s Palestinians live in refugee camps. Few roads are paved, the economy is in shambles and unemployment is at least 40 percent.

“I can’t explain the reason for being here rationally,” said Hanan Gutman, 28, a student in Netzarim’s seminary. “It’s a religious conviction that this place belongs to us. I’ve given up trying to explain it to secular Israelis.” Local council head Shlomo Kostiner said most settlers were surprised the Sept.

13 Israel-PLO peace accord was implemented and are trying to come to grips with the situation. Israel insisted on keeping all settlements in place during the interim phase to last five years. Talks on issues like Jerusalem, permanent borders and a Palestinian state are to be resolved by 1998.

While many Israeli officials admitted Netzarim and several other tiny Gaza Strip settlements were a security nightmare, they feared getting rid of them now would encourage demands to dismantle more established settlements. Now they are becoming a major irritant for Palestinians and a target for attacks that could undermine the peace accord.

“We told the Israelis it would be impossible to protect the settlements of Kfar Darom, Netzarim and Morag, but they didn’t listen,” said Freih Abu Medein, a leading Gaza lawyer and member of the council that is to oversee Palestinian autonomy. “We talk about security; they talk about ideology,” he said.

The security arrangements for settlers have forced Israel to retain a presence in the strip. Soldiers guard the settlements and man roadblocks on several routes linking the settlements to Israel.

At intersections between Pales Wednesday’s shooting of 34-year-old Netzarim settler Rami Sarid, only one day after Israel completed its redeployment, seemed to highlight the volatility of the arrangement. No group claimed responsibility.

CP-1994-024 →

· The New York Times

Gaza’s Palestinians Revel in Daily Joy of Freedom

By YOUSSEF M. IBRAHIM / Special to The New York Times

GAZA, May 23 — Perhaps the most dramatic measure of the Palestinians’ first week of self-rule in Gaza has been the sudden normalcy in people’s lives: barbecuing at the beach, leaving home without I.D. cards, chatting in coffee shops long past the former curfew and strolling by police stations without throwing a stone.

The 900,000 Palestinians packed into this tiny strip of Mediterranean coast, once described by a Gaza psychiatrist, Dr. Iyad Elsaraj, as “tribal, conservative, rigid, confrontational, prone to violence and wildly moody,” have, in fact, behaved in the most remarkably affable way.

Since May 18, when the Israeli Army began to withdraw, the Palestinians here have immersed themselves in joyful celebration. Calves and sheep have been slaughtered to feed the 5,000 or so Palestinian policemen who streamed into Gaza over the last 10 days to replace the Israeli police. Mounds of food and sweets make their way daily from each neighborhood to the police camps.

On the whole, Gazans and foreign visitors alike say, these first few days of autonomy for the four cities, eight refugee camps and seven villages that make up the Gaza Strip — widely viewed as a lawless urban jungle — have gone rather well. If anything, Gazans are demonstrating a kind of political maturity that many analysts did not anticipate.

Many, in fact, predicted factional fighting would break out among those who support and those who oppose the peace accord between the Palestine Liberation Organization and Israel immediately after the Israeli soldiers pulled back . It could still happen. But fewer people are willing to believe it now,

For Gazans like these young Palestinian women, peace with Israel is nothing less than a day at the beach. Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times

CP-1994-065 →

· San Antonio Express News · San Antonio · page 1

Constitution draft refers to Jerusalem as Palestine capital

The Associated Press, Jerusalem

“JERUSALEM — A constitution for the Palestinian governing council — drafted by senior PLO figures — declares Jerusalem the capital of a future state of Palestine, a move likely to further upset PLO-Israel relations.

Sources close to Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin told the newspaper Haaretz that the document was the ‘most serious violation of the Gaza-Jericho (autonomy) agreement to date.’ The PLO’s London-based legal committee faxed a copy of the 21-page draft to the Associated Press in Jerusalem on Friday.

Article 5, on the first page, unequivocally declares Jerusalem as ‘the capital of Palestine.’

It adds that ‘during the transitional period, the Palestinian authorities may set up the Government Headquarters in any other place in Palestine.’… ‘Just as the Israelis have repeatedly declared Jerusalem their own eternal capital, we have the right to declare it our own capital,’ the PLO legal committee’s chairman, Anis Qassem, said by telephone from London… Rabin is adamant about maintaining Israeli sovereignty over Arab-populated east Jerusalem, which was captured in the 1967 war, and is said to be considering banning a visit by Arafat to the city’s Islamic holy sites.”

The pull-quote on the page reads “We have the right to declare it our own capital.” — Anis Qassem, PLO legal committee chairman.

CP-1994-005 →

· Daily News · New York · page 1

Arafat’s mixed review

Backers watch and wait

By Judith Colp Rubin, Special to The News, Shati Refugee Camp

SHATI REFUGEE CAMP, Gaza Strip — Gaza resident Jamil Saadoun is a long-time supporter of Yassir Arafat who was caught up in the emotional whirl of the PLO chairman’s return to his native soil this weekend after 30 years in exile.

But the 38-year-old translator and father of three also considers himself a realist about the man who has led the political struggle for the Palestinian people… “He makes decisions by asking his companions around him and then just decides himself,” said Saadoun.

“He must make decisions more democratically.”… “He didn’t speak about what he would do in the meantime, about finding housing and jobs for people of Gaza,” said Saadoun… “He needs financial help from the Arabs, Europeans and American world,” said Mahmoud Abu Kahr, who was sitting outside his small convenience store near the camp… Nearby, pharmacist Mahmoud Taleb, standing behind a counter filled primarily with Israeli medicines, said he thought Arafat would be a better leader than the heads of such Arab nations as Libya, Jordan and Syria… “If Arafat will be good for the people, so we will love him; if not, the elections will change that,” shrugged Nazan Nabhaa, a student.… “Arafat is not a good leader, because he does not adhere to the Islamic principles,” said a member of the Islamic fundamentalist group Hamas who would identify himself only as Abu Khalid… “Hamas is too young,” argued fisherman Abu Kahr.

PLO CHAIRMAN Yasser Arafat hugs disabled Palestinian man who was one of about 20 in wheelchairs who welcomed Arafat to the Gaza self-rule area yesterday.

Twenty disabled Palestinians were assembled to welcome Arafat home, and the man he embraces in the photograph is the only person on this page who is not named. Six ordinary Gazans are: a translator, a shopkeeper, a pharmacist standing behind a counter of Israeli medicines, a student, a fisherman, and a Hamas member who would give only a first name. All six are criticizing Arafat, four days into his return.

CP-1994-010 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore · page 1

Security Reasons

Cordelia Edvardson, Jerusalem

“Jerusalem. IT WAS one of those days when what is sometimes called ‘the Israeli reality’ hit me with the full impact of its desperation. As a foreign correspondent I am among the first to be notified whenever an Israeli soldier is killed or wounded in southern Lebanon. Notification is a service of the government press office.

But I am never the very first; the first to know is always the bereaved family. So I shouldn’t have been so panicky when the routine message from the military spokesman came over the telephone: ‘RPG fired against an Israeli patrol. One soldier killed.’ No name was given. It usually isn’t to correspondents.

My son, who chose to be an Israeli citizen, is a conscript in the Army and is doing his stint in southern Lebanon. Like thousands of other parents in this country I jump every time the doorbell rings unexpectedly. What will I find when I open the door? Three people in uniform: the commander of my son’s unit, an Army doctor and a girl soldier?

I have been told that this is the procedure when parents are notified. The angels of death are three. Later that day I heard that Moshe Zar would be released on bail. Moshe Zar is one of the defendants in the Jewish terror trial. He is accused of attempted murder.

He is also known as one of the biggest land dealers on the occupied West Bank and his name has been linked not only to several cases of fraudulent land transactions, but also to many cases of harassment of West Bank Palestinians in order to force them to sell privately owned land. Please, the Palestinian Arabs his name is mentioned with fear and hate. Mr.

Zar lost an arm during one of Israel’s wars and his release on bail was motivated by ‘health reasons.’ There is a connection between the situation in southern Lebanon, with bitter irony also called the ‘North Bank,’ and the Jewish terror gang on the West Bank. An occupation is an occupation is an occupation.

Occupations breed bitterness and hatred among the occupied and violence and moral rot among the occupiers. Stones are thrown on the West Bank and rocket propelled grenades (RPGs) are fired on the North Bank. In retaliation, houses are blown up and orchards are uprooted on the West Bank and on the North Bank (though not always for the same reasons).

Israeli families whose sons are serving in southern Lebanon fear the knock on the door that heralds the message of death or injury to one of their loved ones. Palestinians on the West Bank and Shi’ites on the North Bank dread the sound in the middle of the night when a nailed boot kicks the door and the butt of a rifle simultaneously bangs on it.

Israeli soldiers are searching for ‘terrorists.’ Maybe they will take away the father, the husband, the son or brother. He will be taken for ‘interrogation’ and for a long time there will be neither trial nor sentence. Maybe he will come back, and maybe not.

In a village on the West Bank or the North Bank a hand grenade is thrown, a rifle fired, and a curfew is clamped down. Israeli soldiers patrol the empty lanes, and from behind windowpanes eyes watch them, eyes filled with fear and hatred. This is the climate that fosters and nourishes terrorism — on both sides.

This is the climate created by the mistaken belief in force instead of political compromise. The belief of the present Israeli leadership which tells the people that they have to live and act like a garrison state for the next hundred years.

The root of this dreadful situation is the government’s conviction that the Israeli Army has to stay put on the North Bank for ‘security reasons,’ and that the Jewish settlers on the West Bank, protected by the Army, should settle all over the place, both for security and ideological reasons.

‘Judea and Samaria are an inseparable part of the Land of Israel,’ as the slogan goes… Security means not only military might and force; security is also, and more so, the result of national consensus about life and death issues like war and peace. In Israel this consensus doesn’t exist any more.

Furthermore, security is contained in the moral fabric of a nation. But military occupation, however moral it tries to be, is based, ultimately, on the immoral idea that might is right.

There is no such thing as a benevolent occupation, and the brutal force and disregard of basic human rights now used to ‘pacify’ the population in the occupied territories will not stop at the Green Line, Israel’s border before 1967.

The moral cancer of the occupation has grown deep inside the body of Israeli society, and the present government doesn’t seem to know that only a healthy society can, in the long run, be secure… I firmly believe in the message of my dream.

I am convinced that the forces which are now trying to destroy the Zionist dream of justice for all and peace with Israel’s neighbors will not succeed. I know that their weapons, the blunt instrument of brutal force, will be overcome in the end by the voice of reason.

The day will come when Israel has left both the West Bank and the North Bank, and what the popular movement, Peace Now, calls ‘sane Zionism’ will be victorious over messianic fantasies, false prophets and wildly nationalistic aspirations. The Jewish people in its own independent state will live peacefully side by side with the Palestinian people in their state.

Both peoples will enjoy the security of peace, the only true security there is.”

An illustration accompanies the piece: a soldier with a rifle standing at the foot of an enormous dark house marked with a Star of David, its roof looming over him. Signed Jean-Francois Allaux.

A foreign correspondent for a Swedish newspaper, writing from Jerusalem, whose own son is an Israeli conscript in Lebanon. She uses the phrase the archive is named for in its official sense — “security reasons” — and turns it around.

CP-1994-006 →

· The Register-Guard · Eugene · page 1

Palestinian negotiator enters self-rule areas

The Associated Press, Jericho

JERICHO, West Bank — The top Palestinian architect of the autonomy accord with Israel, unhappy over its implementation, entered the self-rule areas Friday for the first time since Palestinians took them over.

Mahmoud Abbas, a frontrunner for this year’s Nobel Peace Prize, said he didn’t think he would be involved with the council dominated by Yasser Arafat that administers the autonomous Gaza Strip and West Bank town of Jericho. “I want to be a regular person with a Palestinian identity after being away for such a long time,” Abbas, also known as Abu Mazen, told reporters after crossing the Allenby Bridge from Jordan into Jericho.

He said it was his first time back in a quarter of a century. Abbas, 59, was a key negotiator at the talks in Oslo, Norway, that led to the self-rule accord he and Foreign Minister Shimon Peres of Israel signed on the White House lawn Sept. 13.

In negotiations on implementing the agreement, he became estranged from Arafat after accusing him of making too many concessions to the Israelis. He also urged the older leadership in the Palestine Liberation Organization to make way for younger men, a dig at Arafat’s refusal to delegate authority.

A man who negotiated the agreement, crossing a bridge home after twenty-five years, asking to be ordinary. The Pueblo Chieftain ran the same dispatch as “Top Palestinian negotiator returns after years.”

CP-1994-009 →

· The Lincoln Star

$12 M emergency grant to bolster foundering Palestinian police force

OSLO, Norway (AP) — Norwegian and U.N. officials agreed Thursday to send an emergency grant of $12 million to the Palestinian police, who have run out of money for salaries. Norwegian officials said the money would arrive “within weeks” to help cover costs for the more than 6,000 police from June through October.

“If one cannot finance the police, the whole security net for reconstruction will break down,” said Terje Roed Larsen, a U.N. coordinator for the Gaza Strip and the West Bank. International donors have promised $2.3 billion for Palestinian self-rule in Gaza and the West Bank town of Jericho.

But political maneuvering blocked the aid until a meeting Tuesday in Oslo between Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres and PLO leader Yasser Arafat. They agreed not to involve donor countries in politically sensitive issues, such as the future status of Jerusalem. Another meeting to release the funds was to be held in Paris soon.

But Larsen said payments to the Palestinian police in Gaza and Jericho were so acute they could not wait. Larsen and foreign ministry officials said they hope international donations will allow $7 million a month to be given to the Palestinian police from November through February.

They said such funding should also pave the way for hiring and training of an additional 3,000 police. In Gaza on Thursday, Palestinian police said Japan has sent $10 million in emergency aid and 2,000 uniforms.

The money is earmarked for building 300 homes for police officers, most of whom returned from exile in the Arab world and had to leave their families behind because of lack of housing in the new autonomous areas. The Japanese are also paying for setting up a central police computer, the police statement said.

CP-1994-071 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles

Hebron Mosque, Site of Massacre, to Reopen

West Bank: Despite Muslim protests over security measures, worshipers may enter Cave of Patriarchs today.

JERUSALEM—Israel’s Cabinet voted unanimously Sunday to reopen the Cave of the Patriarchs in Hebron today despite protests from Muslims, who say new security measures violate the site’s sanctity. Tension around the site was high Sunday after the Islamic Jihad, a militant Islamic group, called a general strike to protest the planned reopening.

The army declared downtown Hebron a closed military area. What Muslims call the Ibrahimi Mosque has been closed since a Jewish settler opened fire on Muslim worshipers there in February, killing about 30. The settler, Dr. Baruch Goldstein, was bludgeoned to death by Muslims who overpowered him as he fired.

For nine months, the army has labored to install security measures designed to keep Jewish and Muslim worshipers separated inside the shrine. Adherents of both faiths believe the tombs of their shared patriarchs—Abraham, Isaac and Jacob—as well as the tomb of Abraham’s wife, Sarah, rest inside the stone structure.

The site has been a focal point of friction between Arabs and Jews since militant Jewish settlers began moving into Hebron shortly after Israel captured the West Bank from Jordan during the 1967 Middle East War. The settlers insisted that they be allowed to pray in the structure.

Arabs say the shrine served exclusively as a mosque for more than 1,000 years and should revert to that in order to avoid further friction between the two communities. Before the February massacre, Jews and Muslims were separated only by movable partitions inside the structure. Settlers were routinely allowed to carry their weapons into the site.

Now, the partitions are permanent and signs outside the tomb warn that weapons are forbidden. Palestine Liberation Organization Chairman Yasser Arafat issued a statement Sunday saying that restructuring the building violated the Israeli-PLO peace treaty.

“We consider the Ibrahimi Mosque a holy place for Muslims, and we do not accept division or separation,” he said. “We see this separation as a provocation that will lead to increasing tension between Muslims and Jews.”

For their part, Jewish settlers complain that the army’s security measures grant too much prayer space to Muslims and not enough to Jews. Under the new plan, Jews will not be allowed to pray in Yitzhak Hall—where the massacre occurred.

Neither Arabs nor Jews will be allowed to enter the site at night, a measure that will prevent adherents of both faiths from saying their evening prayers there. The measures the army has taken “are totally against the Jews and for the Arabs,” said Noam Arnon, a spokesman for the settlers.

Arnon said that Jews are left with only a tiny part of the site to use for their prayers. “Of course, we cannot reach a solution which will satisfy everyone, but . . . I think we have reached the best possible arrangements,” Deputy Defense Minister Mordechai Gur told Israel Army radio Sunday.

In addition to surveillance cameras, the army has trained a special unit to guard the site. It has installed gates on the roads leading to the site and metal detectors at the entrances. There are separate entrances for Muslims and Jews, as well as separate drinking fountains and restrooms. Military sources said Sunday that the army is braced for disturbances today.

Initially, the army intends to limit worshipers to 300 from each faith. “It does not look like a mosque—it looks like a fortress,” Hebron Mayor Mustafa Natshe said after touring the site with the Israeli military governor Sunday. Natshe said he believes the army should first take measures to ease tensions in Hebron before reopening the mosque.

Israeli soldiers guard one entrance of Hebron mosque. Muslims say security steps violate site’s sanctity.

CP-1994-022 →

· The News Tribune · Tacoma

Israel to block diplomatic visits to PLO at Jerusalem site

JERUSALEM – Israel ordered police posted near the PLO’s Jerusalem headquarters on Sunday to prevent future diplomatic meetings there such as a weekend visit by Turkey’s Prime Minister Tansu Ciller.

The PLO viewed Ciller’s visit on Saturday as a boost to their claims to the city’s eastern sector, which they want as the capital of a future Palestinian state. Israel claims all of Jerusalem as its capital. Some Cabinet ministers called Ciller’s unannounced visit an embarrassing trick.

Israel views the headquarters, called Orient House, as part of a Palestinian attempt to erode Israeli control in east Jerusalem. The ministers were angered by a televised clash of words between Israeli and Palestinian security men at the site. The Palestinians wouldn’t let six Israeli agents guarding Ciller inside, saying it wasn’t their “territory.”

“They have no status and cannot say that this is their territory,” Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres said on Israel radio.

CP-1994-025 →

· Bradenton Herald

Israel sends medicine to Gaza for cholera

The disease is not yet widespread in the PLO-run Gaza Strip, but the Palestinian Authority has declared a medical emergency.

JERUSALEM — The growing number of cholera cases in the PLO-run Gaza Strip prompted Israel to send medical aid Thursday to help test and treat patients with the contagious disease. At least 25 cholera patients were being treated on isolation wards in Gaza hospitals, an increase from 20 cases Wednesday. Over 200 people have been tested.

“We are announcing an emergency in all health departments in the Gaza Strip,” said Dr. Riad Zanoun, health minister in the Palestinian Authority, who requested medical assistance from Israel. Despite the death of a 30-month-old child on Monday and the increase in cases, an Israeli medical official assisting Gaza doctors said the disease was not widespread.

“We are still not talking about an epidemic,” said Dr. David Levanon, chief coordinator between Israeli and Palestinian health ministries. All the cholera patients in Gaza belong to five families and come from four adjacent neighborhoods in Gaza City, he said.

Levanon, who headed health services in Gaza for five years under the Israeli military government, said the Israeli Health Ministry sent antibiotics, liquid infusion and rubber gloves, plus a laboratory kit for detecting the disease. Until now, samples were sent to Israel for testing. The disease causes diarrhea, dehydration and ultimately death if not treated quickly.

It is spread through water or food contaminated with feces. Experts tested water sources in Gaza, but so far no contamination was detected. In the meantime, Israel banned produce imports from Gaza into Israel or the West Bank, for fear of contamination. The ban has angered farmers in the poverty-stricken Gaza Strip, which is costing them about $300,000 a day.

No time limit has been set on the ban.

CP-1994-017 →

· The Herald · Miami · page 16A

Gaza settlement checkpoint has become a target

John Donnelly, Gaza City, Gaza Strip

“Said Foreign Minister Shimon Peres earlier this week: ‘Netzarim is a thorn that should be torn out’… ‘What the hell do you need it for, anyway?’ … Today, 5,000 Jews live in 19 cordoned-off settlements among Gaza’s nearly 1 million Palestinians… ‘Let a thousand mothers cry so long as your mother doesn’t.

Shoot and be blamed. Just don’t come home in a coffin.’”

The story runs as a band across the top of the page. The other four-fifths is a Black Friday jewelry sale — diamond studs at $699, thirty dollars a month, stores open at eight. Nobody did anything wrong: the news hole is what is left after the advertising, and the advertising paid for the correspondent in Gaza City. That is the economics of every clipping in this archive, visible in one glance.

CP-1994-011 →

· The New York Times

Palestinian Authority Holds Up Delivery of Newspapers in Gaza

By JOEL GREENBERG

JERUSALEM, Nov. 30 — For a third straight day, the Palestinian Authority delayed distribution in the Gaza Strip today of the two main Palestinian newspapers in an apparent punishment for their reports on Hamas, the militant Muslim group that is challenging the authority.

Copies of Al Quds and An Nahar, dailies published in East Jerusalem, were confiscated by the Palestinian police when they arrived in Gaza at dawn, and were released several hours later. Similar measures were taken on Monday and Tuesday.

The delays began after the papers published reports on a large Hamas rally in Gaza on Saturday, citing a crowd estimate by the organizers of 70,000 participants. The Palestinian police had put the number at 5,000. Some Western news organizations used a figure of 20,000. “It’s a form of censorship, basically,” said Marwan Abu Zalaf, editor in chief of Al Quds.

“They are making a kind of clampdown because they want us to abide by their statements. Where is the democracy that the Palestinian Authority advocates? The police are supposed to enhance democracy, not abuse it.” Although it normally supports the Palestinian Authority, Al Quds has attacked the restrictions in editorial columns and cartoons.

On Tuesday it published a caricature of the Gaza police chief, Brig. Gen. Ghazi Jabali, showing him in an office equipped with a censor’s stamp and scissors, sitting next to a sign that said: “The distribution of papers in Gaza is forbidden because their news doesn’t suit my mood.”

General Jabali has attributed the delays to heavy rains in Gaza, difficulties at an Israeli checkpoint and “routine procedures.” He denied there were orders to hold up the newspapers. “There is no official decision to ban or confiscate the newspapers,” he said.

But Yasir Abed Rabbo, who holds the Information and Culture portfolio in the authority, told Palestinian journalists that the delays were “a decision by the authority at the highest level,” an apparent reference to Yasir Arafat. Mr. Abed Rabbo criticized the actions, however.

“We are against any measures that violate the freedom of the press, and they must be lifted quickly,” he said. “We will not allow, with all the means at our disposal, any such possibility. Palestinian mouths should not and will not be shut by Palestinian hands.” He said the issue would be discussed at the weekly meeting of the Palestinian Authority on Saturday.

The authority drew criticism from Palestinians when it banned the distribution of An Nahar last July, asserting that its pro-Jordanian stance ran counter to Palestinian interests. The paper was allowed to reappear five weeks later after it abandoned its pro-Jordanian line and declared its loyalty to the P.L.O.

CP-1994-070 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore · page 1

Protest draws blood at Israeli settlement

Up to 18 injured; 25 are detained

From wire reports, Al-Khader, West Bank

AL-KHADER, West Bank — A protest against the expansion of a Jewish settlement turned violent yesterday. Up to 11 Palestinians, an Israeli peace activist and six Israeli soldiers were injured during exchanges of tear gas and rocks, according to the army and Palestinian medical workers.

The clash occurred on the ninth day of protests over plans by the Jewish settlement of Efrat to expand onto land claimed by the Palestinian village of Al-Khader. Police detained about 25 protesters, most of them Israeli peace activists opposed to the construction of a new Jewish neighborhood on the land, 10 miles south of Jerusalem near Bethlehem.

The construction threatens to disrupt negotiations between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization as they struggle to hammer out an agreement on an Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank. PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat called the settlement a “flagrant violation” of the 1993 peace accord.

He said Palestinians would not accept the new building in an area slated to come under their rule. “They don’t know that the Palestinian people [are] not affected by injuries and by clashes,” he told a crowd at a Gaza rally for the 30th anniversary of his Fatah organization.

Several hundred Palestinians and left-wing Israeli activists had gathered peacefully about 200 yards from the designated site of the new neighborhood after the army banned them from demonstrating at the site itself. Witnesses said demonstrators charged scores of Israeli troops guarding the site. Demonstrators also threw stones at border police troops, knocking one unconscious.

Troops pushed back the protesters, in some cases clubbing them. The youths continued to throw stones and the soldiers responded with tear gas. A curfew was imposed on Al-Khader. Ahmed Tibi, an Arafat adviser, said troops provoked the clash. “I am sorry to say maybe there were instructions to do so.

Soldiers invaded 200 meters inside the demonstration and started to hit people, and this is the reason why the situation exploded,” he said. Israel’s Supreme Court has rejected a petition by activists to reverse the army order outlawing demonstrations at the site. Palestinians claim the rocky, 150-acre plot was confiscated from them illegally.

Settlers claim they purchased it privately after a previous Israeli government earmarked the land for their use…

Knesset passes law to tighten grip on Jerusalem.

Limits Palestinian political activity. JERUSALEM — Israeli officials are starting the new year armed with a new law, one that they say will put an end to Palestinian political activity in the Holy City… The legislation, which takes effect Monday, restricts activities of the self-governing Palestinian Authority to the Gaza Strip and the West Bank town of Jericho — areas that Israel handed over to the Palestinians in May.

It bars the Palestine Liberation Organization from carrying out any activity in Jerusalem without Israeli government permission… “Passing a law like this puts pressure on the Palestinian Authority and reduces the credibility of the peace process and the Palestinian leadership,” said Ghassan Khatib, a former Palestinian negotiator who often criticizes implementation of the Israeli-Palestinian peace accord… In a statement issued after the legislation was enacted, Mr.

Husseini said the law restricting Palestinian political activity “represents a serious violation of the Palestinian-Israeli accords and international resolutions.” “Orient House confirms that its political activities will continue unabated as they always have been since 1992. The new Israeli law will not hinder nor stop any of these activities,” he said.

“Israeli soldiers tend to comrade hurt when Palestinians and Jewish peace activists stormed an army blockade at the disputed site.” Associated Press

Most of the twenty-five people detained at a protest against a settlement were Israeli peace activists. The caption names the Israeli casualty and not the eleven Palestinian ones.

CP-1994-007 →

· The New York Times

Arabs Split on Cultural Ties to Israel

Some say cultural contacts should await a definitive peace.

By Youssef M. Ibrahim

PARIS, March 6 — The Arab world’s most famous poet has been expelled from the Arab Writers’ Union for meeting with Israeli intellectuals, and the punishment has generated bitter debate among writers and artists across the Middle East.

At issue is the whole idea of cultural exchange with Israel, but underlying it is a long-simmering rebellion against pressures Arab governments exert on their cultural establishments.

On the face of it, the expulsion of the 65-year-old poet, Adonis, whose real name is Ali Ahmed Saeed, appeared absurd when it was announced in Damascus by the head of the Arab Writers’ Union, Ali Akla Ersan, on Jan. 27.

The poet, a Syrian who adopted Lebanese nationality and now lives in France, was being punished for a meeting in Grenada, Spain, two years ago, sponsored by Unesco and attended by the P.L.O. chairman, Yasir Arafat, and Israel’s Foreign Minister, Shimon Peres, among others. Several similar gatherings have been held since then between Arabs and Israelis.

Syria’s pressure on the writers’ union to expel Adonis is echoed in the actions of other Arab governments, which although they are engaged in talks with Israel, continue to seek to intimidate their intellectuals from following suit.

More important, the use of an obscure union staffed by bureaucrats to restrain major Arab literary figures has been a sore point for some time in Arab intellectual circles, whatever their position regarding contact with Israel.

“These so-called intellectual unions are the remnants of a Stalinist past,” said Hazem Sagieh, cultural page editor of the London-based Arabic daily Al Hayat.

“In this case, Adonis, the most prominent poet of the Arabic language today, is far more important than the so-called Arab Writers’ Union of Damascus, and the fact that he is for or against normalization with Israel is nothing more than a detail.”

Unlike many Arab cultural figures, Adonis has not wrapped himself in the flag of his country, but has kept himself above the fray. But in a brief conversation here, he indicated that for the first time he would address the issue in an article. “All I can say now is that these matters are a sideshow for the Arab world,” he said.

The controversy over how much exchange there should be between Arabs and Israelis has simmered since the Madrid peace conference in 1991. The conference, after the Persian Gulf war, brought Arabs and Israelis together in direct talks.

Since then more Arab intellectuals have begun to call for an end to the rupture between Arab and Jewish thinkers that begun at the turn of the century.

The action by the Arab Writers’ Union, which amounts to no more than a moral and political condemnation of Adonis, turned a halting dispute into a consuming debate during the last month that has spawned hundreds of articles and has drawn important cultural figures from Morocco to the Persian Gulf region.

They include two of Syria’s leading writers, Saadallah Wanous and Hanna Mina, who quit the union in solidarity with Adonis. The issue has even seeped into a wider domain, involving popular performers. Midhat Salem, a well-known Egyptian singer, accepted a singing engagement in Israel two months ago.

When he returned to Egypt, he was attacked by some and praised by others. Fifi Abdou, Egypt’s and the Arab world’s most famous belly-dancer, has refused to perform in Israel, and has met the same mixed reaction. Among intellectuals the debate has ranged widely.

Some speak of their fear of Israel’s “cultural domination” of a weak and fractured Arab world that needs time to heal.

Arab literary figures — including Emile Habibi, an award-winning Palestinian novelist, and Naguib Mahfouz, Egypt’s Nobel laureate — argue that there is nothing to fear from intellectual discourse with Israel and perhaps something to gain. Mr.

Mahfouz, who survived an assassination attempt by Islamic militants in October, said recently that if the Arab world, which has a foundation of 14 centuries of Arab and Islamic cultural heritage, is afraid it will lose its cultural identity by mingling with Israel, then perhaps that fate is a deserved.

Still others, like Saad el Din Wahba, the president of the Arab artists syndicate that controls the immensely influential movie and theater industry, and a Syrian feminist writer, Colette Khoury, maintain that it is too early for cultural rapprochement with Israel, which can flow freely only when the political conflict is settled.

“How long are we going to fight windmills?” said Mr. Habibi, the Palestinian who won the highest Israeli literary award two years ago. A former Communist militant, Mr. Habibi remains firmly anchored to the left, arguing in a conversation: “We need to open as many doors as possible and win over Israeli intellectuals to our views of Palestinian rights.

How are we going to do this by restraining Arab thinkers from talking to Jews while Arab Governments have done so openly for years?”

Rifaat el-Saeed, the leading figure among leftist opposition parties in Egypt, said that while the logic of the Arab Writers’ Unions decision was dismissed by virtually all Arab intellectuals as demagogic, the issue of relations of any kind with Israel remains deeply controversial among Arab intellectuals. “There are those who call for it immediately,” Mr.

Saeed said in an interview. “Others, largely the Islamists and the hard-line leftists, reject it completely. But most think cultural normalization is a last card in the hands of the Arabs that should be used only after a lasting, definitive peace has been reached with the other side. We are not there yet.”

Last year the Lebanese Government, which is heavily influenced by Syria, threatened to put Miss Lebanon of 1994 on trial. Her crime was that she appeared in a photo standing next to Miss Israel. Public ridicule of the ruling finally persuaded the Lebanese Government to relent.

Indeed, the Arab intellectual discourse is far ahead of the broader Arab public, which remains by and large apathetic to the idea of normal ties with Israel.

Lotfi al-Khouli, one of Egypt’s most prominent intellectuals and a leading columnist and writer who has vigorously championed normalization with Israel, says there has been vast resistance to it among ordinary Arabs. “Israelis think they have fulfilled all their obligations on peace by talking about peace with Arabs,” he said in a recent conversation.

“But we are finding that the ordinary Arab person only sees continuing Israeli occupation of Arab lands, continued mistreatment of Palestinians. They see this on their television every evening and on the front pages of newspapers and in searing cartoons, every morning.” Mr.

Khouli added, “I think it is high time to move in the struggle to another stage that is neither military nor absolute, but I wonder if the popular current allows that.”

The poet known as Adonis was expelled from the Arab Writers’ Union recently for meeting with Israelis.

CP-1995-018 →

· The New York Times

Gaza Arabs Dispute Origin Of Sunday's Mystery Blast

By JOEL GREENBERG

JERUSALEM, April 6 — A mysterious explosion in Gaza that killed a senior Muslim militant and several other Palestinians on Sunday has set off a contest of credibility between the Palestinian Authority and its chief rival, the Islamic group Hamas.

In a stream of public statements and leaflets this week, both sides have offered conflicting explanations of how the explosion occurred, their debate growing into a war of words to win over ordinary Gazans angered by the carnage in a crowded neighborhood. Each side has tried to use the blast to discredit the other.

The authority says that explosives accidentally went off in a Hamas hideout used to manufacture bombs, and accuses Hamas of reckless disregard for human life in setting up the bomb factory in the middle of a residential area. Hamas calls the blast an assassination carried out by Israel in collaboration with the authority.

Israel has denied any involvement, and many Gazans seem skeptical of the Hamas claims. But Hamas has mobilized thousands of its supporters to convince public opinion that this explosion was a conspiracy.

On Wednesday, it organized a mass demonstration at the scene of the blast in the poor Sheik Radwan neighborhood of Gaza, a Hamas stronghold where protesters vowed revenge and gunmen fired into the air. The Palestinian police have waged their own information campaign.

On Wednesday they arrested a Gaza journalist who published a report suggesting that the explosion may have been planned. The journalist, Taher al-Nunu of An Nahar newspaper, quoted Palestinian civil defense officials as saying the blast could have been set off by a time bomb. The Civil Defense, an arm of the Palestinian security forces, promptly denied the report.

CP-1995-017 →

· The New York Times · New York

Doctor Says Snapping of Head Killed Palestinian Held in Israel

Joel Greenberg

“Accounts by former prisoners and court testimony by Shin Bet agents indicate that Palestinians under interrogation have been violently shaken, shackled in painful positions with foul-smelling sacks on their heads and deprived of sleep.”

Abd al-Samed Hreizat, 30, of Hebron, died in Israeli custody; a pathologist’s affidavit says his head was snapped. The corroboration the Times cites is not a human rights report but the Shin Bet’s own testimony in court.

CP-1995-006 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Widely Mistreats the Detainees

The 1987 Landau Commission — in the words of the Israeli Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories (B’Tselem) — “ended up legitimating the use of torture” with its sanction of “moderate physical pressure.”

A reader answering the 1 May 1995 article on the torture death of Abd al-Samed Hreizat, which is also in this archive. The reader supplies what the news article did not: the name of the commission, the year, and an Israeli human rights organization’s judgment of what it did. The minister being corrected is Yossi Sarid.

CP-1995-008 →

· estimated · Omaha World-Herald · Omaha

Israel Votes To Seize Arab Land

LOS ANGELES TIMES

Jerusalem — Defying Arab warnings that it is endangering peace negotiations, Israel’s government on Sunday voted to go through with the confiscation of Arab-owned land in south Jerusalem to build Jewish neighborhoods. The vote was forced by left-wing Cabinet members who oppose the seizure of 131 acres.

But they were unable to halt the planned expropriation, even though four members of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin’s Labor Party abstained. But Rabin promised that there will be no further land confiscations from the city’s Palestinian residents for housing unless the Palestinian Authority agrees, Cabinet member Shulamit Aloni told reporters after the session.

“It was said openly in the government that it’s going to be the last one,” Aloni said. “The prime minister said it, and the minister of housing said it.” Aloni, the minister of communications and minister of culture, is a leader of the left-wing Meretz Party, Labor’s primary coalition partner.

The four Meretz Cabinet ministers had demanded that the government freeze or cancel its order to confiscate the land, arguing that such action would pose a serious threat to ongoing Israeli-Palestinian peace talks.

Yasser Arafat, chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, and other senior officials in the Palestinian Authority have warned that the confiscation could derail the talks. Palestinian officials on Sunday said that Rabin’s promise not to take more land does not resolve the issue.

“This is not the end of the road for us,” said Marwan Kanafani, spokesman for Arafat. “We should not accept this confiscation as a done deal with the promise of no confiscations in the future. This is a tyrannical decision that has to be canceled.”

Kanafani said that “extremists on both sides are now congratulating each other for this decision, which will lead to a crisis in the peace process.”

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible — the scan is a single column cut from the page. The story says the vote happened “on Sunday”; May 14, 1995 was a Sunday, consistent with a May 15, 1995 paper, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1995-009 →

· The Rock Island Argus · Rock Island

Settler violence in Israel is criminal

Six words, a subject and a verdict, in an Illinois paper in September 1995 — two years after Oslo. Criminal is not a hedge and it is not attributed to anybody. Two years earlier the Miami Herald had the same violence claiming a victim, with no one doing it (CP-1993-005).

CP-1995-001 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia · page A3

Palestinian women say no to release from prison

All Palestinian women in prison must be freed, they said. The 21 refused to denounce terrorism.

By Marjorie Miller, Los Angeles Times

JERUSALEM — The Israeli-Palestinian peace agreement ran into further complications yesterday when 21 Palestinian women prisoners rejected freedom in solidarity with four others who were denied release.

The women prisoners who were to have been released yesterday morning announced to Israeli authorities that they would not sign a declaration renouncing terrorism — a requirement for their liberty — unless all of the Palestinian women being held were freed.

Israeli officials responded that no one would be forced to leave jail and returned the women to their cells, at least until tomorrow, after the first day of the seven-day Jewish Sukkoth festival. The women hung the red-green-black-and-white flag of the Palestine Liberation Organization from their cells.

PLO Chairman Yasir Arafat announced that he would send a delegation to the Sharon Prison in central Israel tomorrow to try to persuade the women to leave. One Palestinian who had been jailed apart from the other women did sign the commitment to refrain from terrorist attacks and was let out.

But when Bashaher abu Laban arrived home in East Jerusalem, she said that she, too, would have stayed behind bars had she known the rest of the women were doing so. Under the interim peace accord signed in Washington on Sept.

28, all Palestinian women prisoners were to be released along with men who have completed two-thirds of their terms and prisoners who are under 18, over 50 or ill. The women were to be let out first. But last week, President Ezer Weizman announced that, despite the accord, he would not pardon two of the women who, he said, had “blood on their hands.” Israeli Gen.

Ilan Biran, chief of the army's central command, then refused to allow the release of two others also involved in the killing of Israelis. Weizman was responsible for pardoning prisoners from Jerusalem or those tried in Israeli civilian courts. Military commanders are responsible for signing the release of those who were tried in military courts.

It was unclear whether the approximately 1,100 Palestinian men who are scheduled to be released tomorrow would take a stand similar to the women's. Israeli Police Minister Moshe Shahal said that no prisoners would be released who refused to sign the vow against further violence.

PLO officials have called the government's refusal to release the four women a grave violation of the peace accord, but they have not made the women's freedom a condition for continuing implementation of the accord.

The Israeli government has closed off the Gaza Strip and the West Bank until the end of the Sukkoth holiday for fear of another attack by Islamic extremists opposed to the peace accord.

Israeli and Palestinian military officials, meanwhile, met yesterday at the Erez checkpoint into the Gaza Strip to discuss details of the Israeli troop redeployment from Palestinian cities in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and the introduction of Palestinian police in their place.

Foreign Minister Shimon Peres said early yesterday after a meeting with Arafat that Israel would pull troops and close administrative offices in four Arab villages within two weeks.

CP-1995-005 →

· The New York Times · New York

20 Jailed Arab Women Say No to Israeli Offer of Freedom

Serge Schmemann

“Imprisoned Palestinian women refused to accept a presidential pardon, charging that Israel had reneged on a pledge to free all female Palestinian prisoners.”

Twenty women decline their own release because it is not all of them. Printed as a hitch in the implementation of an agreement; it is one of the clearest acts of collective discipline in the archive.

CP-1995-007 →

· The New York Times · New York

The Rabin Assassination

Israel has had to endure more than its share of political violence over the years. But it faces a frightening new kind of experience with yesterday’s assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin.

The country’s democratically elected leader and the guiding hand of its historic peace agreement with the Palestinians was gunned down, apparently by a right-wing Jewish extremist, as he left a peace rally in Tel Aviv. In the past, Arabs have been the killers of Jews.

Now, what had been unthinkable seems to have occurred, as a Jewish Israeli citizen is accused of striking down the nation’s leader. A country that has survived so many military threats from outside must now hold course through the most severe internal political strain that can confront a democratic government.

Israel’s basic values and the strength of its people will enable it to meet this test. The continued pursuit of peace, with the Palestinians and all of Israel’s Arab neighbors, must be Mr. Rabin’s monument. Mr. Rabin was not a man to take unreasonable risks with Israeli security.

He gained renown as a tough, professional soldier, who fought in Israel’s 1948 war of independence and commanded Israel’s victorious armed forces in the 1967 war.

He chose the path of negotiation with Yasir Arafat’s Palestine Liberation Organization only after he became convinced that the P.L.O. was ready to turn its back on its terrorist past and agree to compromises that would assure the survival of the Jewish state.

The peace negotiations have met with repeated setbacks and crises in the 26 months since that first promising signing ceremony on the White House lawn. But in recent weeks Mr. Rabin had stiffened his resolve to see the process through to a successful conclusion.

Just weeks ago, following a second White House signing ceremony, Israel’s Army began pulling back from major Palestinian towns in the West Bank. The agenda for the coming months includes Palestinian elections and the start of discussions on the most difficult issues of all — including Jerusalem and Jewish settlements. Mr.

Rabin also oversaw a formal peace agreement with Jordan and first steps toward defining the terms of an eventual peace with Syria. He had a clear vision of an Israel finally at peace with its region, and, step by step, he was making it come true. He knew well enough that his program of peace was violently opposed by Palestinian and Jewish extremists.

But he had the courage and determination to press ahead whatever the risks. Fortunately, his Foreign Minister, Shimon Peres, who will now take over the reins of power, was a full partner in pioneering the peace process and deserves his nation’s confidence in continuing it. He was Mr. Rabin’s indispensable alter ego along every step of the road to peace.

While the two men differ in background and basic temperament, and for years carried on a bitter rivalry within Israel’s Labor Party, the last two years joined them in a common purpose and a common resolve to make peace the legacy of their political generation. Mr. Peres lacks Mr. Rabin’s background as a military leader, but as a former Prime Minister, Mr.

Peres is a seasoned hand in guarding Israel’s diplomatic and security interests. The United States, under both the Bush and Clinton Administrations, rightly saw Mr. Rabin as a special ally and did all it could to smooth the path of peace. Washington’s sympathetic efforts will now be needed more than ever to reassure traumatized Israelis and keep a delicate diplomacy on course.

That is the best way to honor Mr. Rabin’s memory and preserve his greatest achievement.

CP-1995-010 →

· The New York Times · New York

Suspect Says He Tried to Kill Rabin Before

Arrested Law Student Often Joined Protests Against Government

By JOEL GREENBERG

JERUSALEM, Nov. 4 — Yigal Amir, the 27-year-old law student who was arrested for the assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin tonight, was described by acquaintances as a militant critic of the Government who regularly joined protests against Mr. Rabin’s policies. He told interrogators that he had carried out the killing on his own. Under questioning by the police, Mr.

Amir said he had been planning the assassination for a long time and had intended to kill Mr. Rabin on two previous occasions but was thwarted by tight security measures. After his self-appointed mission tonight, Mr. Amir, a short, dark-haired man dressed in a blue shirt and light-colored pants, was pinned to a wall by police officers and rushed to a waiting police car.

“I have no regrets,” he was quoted as telling investigators. “I acted alone and on orders from God.” According to some accounts, Mr. Amir had links to a small militant anti-Arab group known as Eyal that is virulently opposed to the Government’s accords with the Palestine Liberation Organization. A leader of the group, Avishai Raviv, acknowledged tonight that he knew Mr. Amir.

But he denied that the assassin belonged to Eyal or that the group had anything to do with the shooting. After the shooting, Israeli reporters received beeper messages signed Ain, a Hebrew acronym for the Israeli Avenging Organization, a previously unknown group.

The group claimed responsibility for the killing, though it was not immediately known if it had any connection with Mr. Amir. The assassination was the second incident of extreme violence by right-wing Jewish militants since the 1993 signing of the Israeli-Palestinian accord.

THE SUSPECT An Israeli police officer grabbed Yigal Amir, the suspected assassin, around the neck after the shooting. (Associated Press)

CP-1995-011 →

· The New York Times · New York

Some Arabs Deplore Killing; Others Rejoice

JERUSALEM, Nov. 5 (Reuters) — The assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin of Israel on Saturday underscored the political fault lines across the Middle East. While most Arab leaders condemned his killing, radical Palestinian groups rejoiced. In neighboring Jordan, King Hussein, who signed a peace deal with Mr.

Rabin ending decades of conflict, said the Prime Minister’s death was a “great personal blow.” President Hosni Mubarak of Egypt mourned Mr. Rabin as a man who fell from “treacherous bullets at the hands of extremists who are enemies of peace.” The chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, Yasir Arafat, for years the sworn enemy of Mr.

Rabin until the Middle East peace settlement began, expressed shock and sorrow at his death. “I am very sad and shocked at this awful and terrible crime against one of the brave leaders of Israel and one of the peacemakers,” he said on Saturday at his Gaza headquarters. But P.L.O. officials said Mr.

Arafat would not attend the funeral on Monday for fear that his presence would provoke reaction from hard-liners. Syria made no official comment on the killing, but diplomats expected the Government to pursue a peace settlement with Israel. Syria has held peace talks with Mr. Rabin’s Government since 1991, although no tangible progress has been made.

Elsewhere, hard-line opponents of Mr. Rabin called his death by gunfire a fitting end. The Libyan Government news agency, Jana, described Mr. Rabin as a terrorist whose “hands were covered in the blood of the martyrs.” In Iran, President Hashemi Rafsanjani called the assassination “God’s warning to humanity.”

“We believe that whoever unsheathes the sword of tyranny will be killed by the same sword,” Mr. Rafsanjani said in a statement broadcast on the Iranian radio. In Lebanon today, a Muslim militant rally in Beirut to mourn the death of a Palestinian guerrilla leader turned into a celebration of Mr. Rabin’s slaying.

Thousands of Lebanese and Palestinian militants chanted, “Death to Israel!” The rally, attended by about 5,000 Palestinians and Lebanese, was called before Mr. Rabin’s assassination by the pro-Iranian Party of God to mourn the chief of the Islamic Holy War guerrilla group, Fathi Shiqaqi, who was gunned down in Malta 10 days ago.

The group had blamed the Israelis for the killing.

The leader of the Party of God, Sheik Hassan Nasrallah, said at the rally at a mosque: “It was God’s will that this meeting be held for two events: a painful one that hurt us and made our eyes cry, Shiqaqi’s martyrdom, and another cheerful event that made hearts happy and filled the streets until the morning, the death of the biggest of the terrorists of our time, Yitzhak Rabin.”

In the southern Lebanese city of Merj ’Uyun, the South Lebanon Army, Israel’s militia ally, declared two days of mourning in the Israeli-held border strip for Mr. Rabin. Palestinian guerrillas and refugees opposed to the P.L.O. took to the streets of the Ain Hilwe camp in southern Lebanon minutes after hearing news of Mr. Rabin’s death, chanting, “Rabin is gone!

Rabin is gone!” and dancing into this morning. The guerrillas fired machine guns and anti-tank rockets skyward.

While the assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin was condemned by Arab leaders, militant Palestinian groups rejoiced, like these guerrillas in refugee camp in the southern Lebanese port of Sidon. (Associated Press)

CP-1995-012 →

· The New York Times · New York

In the West Bank and Gaza, Mixed Feelings

By YOUSSEF M. IBRAHIM

RAMALLAH, West Bank, Nov. 5 — Palestinians in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip expressed mixed feelings today about the assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, with some remembering him as the man who cracked down on their uprising against the Israeli authorities and others saying he was a visionary who recently moved with determination to make peace with Arabs .

“The whole Middle East lost a great man,” said Issa Albucheide, a marble supplier from Bethlehem, echoing the sentiments of family members. “He was a very good man. He did something nobody else could do: He made peace with the Arabs.” But such praise was rare.

Most Palestinians willing to discuss the assassination expressed mixed feelings and said it indicated that Israel was deeply divided over the changes brought by the peace agreement. “We have felt a split in Israel — now we see how big the split is,” a 47-year-old gold merchant in Ramallah said, speaking on the condition of anonymity.

“The Israelis saw that a lot of Palestinians are coming back, that we have police,” he said. “They began to see that this is not a joke, that this was becoming more than talk, and they got scared.”

In Gaza, where Palestinian security forces have been on high alert since Saturday night, officials of the Palestine Liberation Organization, including Yasir Arafat, were cloistered for most of the day in its headquarters, contemplating the direction of peace efforts without Mr. Rabin as a partner.

“His disappearance is going to be a big problem for us,” a senior Palestinian security official said by telephone. “He was the guarantor of continuity in the this process and the only one strong enough to impose his views on a divided country.”

For a great majority of Palestinians, there was little empathy with the death of a man many had viewed as an iron-fisted ruler of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip both as Defense Minister and then Prime Minister.

CP-1995-013 →

· The Atlanta Constitution · Atlanta

‘I did this to stop the peace process. We need to be coldhearted.’ — Yigal Amir

Brothers held: Police say the suspected assassin and his brother may have been part of a right-wing conspiracy.

FROM OUR NEWS SERVICES

Tel Aviv, Israel — The man who has confessed to assassinating Yitzhak Rabin told a judge Monday he made a “coldhearted” decision to kill the prime minister to stop the peace process. Police were investigating whether Yigal Amir and his older brother were part of a right-wing conspiracy. Magistrate Dan Arbel ordered Amir, 25, held for 15 days as the investigation continued.

His 27-year-old brother, Hagai, who admitted giving Amir 20 bullets of the type used to shoot Rabin, was ordered held for seven days. Unshaven and clad in the same clothes and skullcap he wore when he fired the fatal shots Saturday night, Amir told the judge he drew his ideas from the Halacha — the Jewish legal code. “According to the Halacha, you can kill the enemy,” he said.

“My whole life, I learned Halacha. When you kill in war, it is an act that is allowed.” In an even tone, Amir described the shooting. “I tried to get as close as I could,” he said. “The police jumped on me and hit the pistol,” causing him to hit Rabin’s bodyguard, too. The guard was slightly wounded. “I did this to stop the peace process. We need to be coldhearted.”

Did you act alone, Arbel asked? “It was God,” Amir replied. During a pause in his arraignment, Amir engaged in a heated exchange with Israeli reporters, expressing his hatred of Arabs.

“It’s interesting how an entire nation did not notice that the center of the Palestinian state is an army of terrorists that we will have to fight in less than half a year or a year,” said Amir, lecturing in an aggressive tone. “Everyone is shocked about the killing of a prime minister who groveled before all the countries of the world.

He is responsible for the security of only 98 percent of the population and did not care about the other 2 percent,” Amir said, a reference to the estimated 130,000 Jewish settlers. “Such a prime minister is not a prime minister for me.” Amir mentioned the peace rally where he had stalked his target: “It was 50 percent Arab. Did anyone cover it?

Did anyone report that there were 50 percent Arabs? These Arabs who will determine the future of my state? “If you are willing to let them determine the future of your state ... you are hypocrites. What will you do when there are 2 million Arabs in the country? You will give this country to the Arabs.”

Escorted into court for arraignment Monday in Tel Aviv, Yigal Amir said he killed Yitzhak Rabin because the slain prime minister wanted to “give this country to the Arabs.” (Associated Press)

CP-1995-014 →

· The New York Times · New York

Arafat Honors a ‘Hero of Peace,’ a Friend

Yasir Arafat, the P.L.O. chairman, paid a condolence call to Leah Rabin, widow of Israel’s slain Prime Minister, last night in Tel Aviv. At center was Yossi Ginnosar, a former official of the Shin Bet security service, who arranged the meeting. It was Mr. Arafat’s first known visit to Israel. Page A8. (Associated Press)

CP-1995-015 →

· The New York Times · New York

Zeal of Rabin’s Assassin Linked To Rabbis of the Religious Right

By JOHN KIFNER

JERUSALEM, Nov. 11 — The men arrested in the killing of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin are part of a new, deeply religious Jewish underground movement whose fury was fueled by the Israeli-Palestinian peace accord, Israeli police officials and political analysts say.

A week after the assassination, the picture emerging from the police investigation is of a small band with many of its adherents coming out of religious schools, a spinoff from the Kach organization founded by Rabbi Meir Kahane that revolved around the killer, Yigal Amir, and his brother Hagai. The Amir brothers come from a religious family of Yemeni origin.

Their father is a Torah scribe, who painstakingly copies the holy words on parchment with a quill pen. The brothers learned combat skills in the Israeli Army and stole arms and explosives. But what is most shocking to many in this already stunned country is that, according to the police, the killing of the Jewish leader of the Jewish state had the blessing of a rabbi.

The Israeli police say they believe that a religious decree in effect declaring Mr. Rabin a mortal enemy of the Jewish people who must be killed, compelled Yigal Amir, an intense 25-year-old religious scholar, to sidle up to the Prime Minister at a peace rally in Tel Aviv and fire three shots from a 9-millimeter Beretta pistol.

Israeli military radio reported today that an Israeli Army solider and his father had been taken into custody in connection with the assassination. [Page 12.] Of the eight men now under arrest, five are Israeli-born religious students.

CP-1995-016 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco · page 1

Israeli Opposition Goes Back to Attacking Peace Process

Netanyahu ends post-assassination political truce

Dina Shiloh, Chronicle foreign service, Tel Aviv

Tel Aviv — Barely two weeks after Yitzhak Rabin was buried, opposition leader Benjamin Netanyahu already is firing the first shots of Israel’s 1996 election campaign. “We will win the next election,” he told several hundred top members of his Likud Party at a meeting Sunday night. “We will win because we are right.”

Yesterday, after declining to block parliamentary approval of the replacement government of Shimon Peres, Netanyahu sharply attacked Peres in the Knesset, saying that there are clear signals that without Rabin serving as a restraining force, Israel’s new prime minister “is running to make concessions” to the Arabs.

Netanyahu’s rhetoric and public statements were restrained after the assassination. During Rabin’s funeral, when the fruits of peace — the presence of Jordan’s King Hussein, Egypt’s President Hosni Mubarak and other Arab leaders — were clear to all Israelis, Netanyahu looked uncomfortable.

Yigal Amir, Rabin’s confessed killer, was the product of right-wing extremist ideology, and Netanyahu was held responsible by many on the left — including Rabin’s widow, Leah — for having done little to discourage the violence on the far right… As the Likud drew closer to the National Religious Party… and even Moledet — an extremist party that advocates “transferring” Arabs out of Israel and the West Bank — anti-government rallies became the scene of some of the worst excesses of anti-Rabin incitement.

Netanyahu was often the chief speaker, though he claims not to have been aware of some of the most inflammatory placards held up and not to have seen a coffin with “Rabin, killer of Zionism” written on it at a demonstration last year near Tel Aviv.

“Israeli opposition leader Benjamin Netanyahu (left) spoke with newly appointed Foreign Minister Ehud Barak.” By Associated Press

Seven months before Netanyahu first became prime minister. The word for what Moledet wanted is the paper’s own, in its own quotation marks: “transferring.”

CP-1995-002 →

· The Morning Call · Allentown · page 1

First Palestinian police open office in Bethlehem area

Nasser Shioukhi, Of The Associated Press, Beit Jala

BEIT JALA, West Bank — The first Palestinian police who will take control of Bethlehem from Israeli troops by Christmas raised the Palestinian flag on a hill overlooking the biblical city yesterday. About 400 people turned out to welcome the 12 officers who opened the Israel-Palestinian liaison office in this neighboring village.

They raised the red, green, black and white Palestinian flag over the office.

Residents clapped and chanted “We will sacrifice soul and blood for Palestine” when the officers marched in, carrying handguns, flags and pictures of PLO leader Yasser Arafat. “This is the sweetest moment in my life,” said Khalil Dakadeka from the nearby village of Beit Fajjar. “We have waited for this moment for many years,” said Bethlehem merchant Nader Hidweh.

As he raised the flag, Brig. Gen. Ziad Atrash, a senior police commander, announced: “Christmas will be under the auspices of the Palestinian Authority, and Arafat will attend the ceremonies.”

Thirty thousand people are expected to attend Christmas celebrations in Bethlehem’s Manger Square, the traditional birthplace of Jesus, for the first Christmas under Palestinian control.

In past years, visitors passed through Israeli metal detectors to reach Manger Square and the Church of the Nativity, and Israeli army snipers were posted on rooftops… Earlier yesterday, dozens of Palestinians tried in vain to block bulldozers clearing land for a bypass road around Hebron, 12 miles south of Bethlehem.

The road cuts through cultivated olive groves and grape vineyards in Halhoul, a Palestinian village outside of Hebron. “This is my land, and it is the only thing I have,” said Ali Akel, 45.

“I understand that this peace is a peace for land, but the Israeli government has both the peace and the land.” Soldiers pushed the protesters back and kept them from blocking the bulldozers.

Three named Palestinians in one column: a man having the sweetest moment of his life, a merchant who waited, and a man watching bulldozers take his olive groves the same morning. The archive also holds the Jamestown Sun’s printing of this dispatch.

CP-1995-003 →

· The State · Columbia · page 1

Palestinians take over Christmas in Bethlehem

The Associated Press, Bethlehem

BETHLEHEM, West Bank — Palestinian activists strung a banner proclaiming “Jesus, the First Palestinian Revolutionary” in Manger Square on Wednesday, preparing for the Christmas Eve arrival of Yasser Arafat in the city of Jesus’ birth.

The square was festooned with a two-story portrait of the PLO chairman and Palestinian flags for Bethlehem’s first Christmas celebration under Palestinian rule. Some foreign Christians said they were offended by the display linking Christ with Palestinian national symbols, and accused Arafat of hijacking Christmas for political gain ahead of Jan. 20 elections.

“The whole world is allowing Arafat to use the birthplace of the Lord of our church for propaganda,” said Jan Willem van der Hoeven, spokesman of the International Christian Embassy in Jerusalem. He says his group represents millions of evangelical Christians around the world.

But the top Roman Catholic clergyman in the Holy Land, Latin Patriarch Michel Sabbah, said a dose of politics was justified as Bethlehem celebrates an end to 28 years of Israeli occupation. “This year we will have a special Christmas,” said Sabbah, a Palestinian.

“This is the first time in history the Palestinian people are free and able to decide for themselves.” Israeli troops are to withdraw from Bethlehem, a town of 15,000 Christians and 35,000 Muslims, by early Friday… “It’s impossible to tell whose birthday it is, but no one has the guts to say it,” said van der Hoeven, the evangelical Christian.

“Arafat is not a Christian and he has an abominable record against Christians in Lebanon. He is going to misuse Bethlehem.” Van der Hoeven’s group has urged Christians to boycott the Bethlehem celebrations and instead spend Christmas at the nearby Jewish West Bank settlement of Efrat.

The group believes Israel should not return the West Bank to the Palestinians because it is part of the biblical land of Israel.

A city handed back after twenty-eight years, and the headline verb is “take over.” The Latin Patriarch gets two sentences; the spokesman who objects to him gets four and the last word.

CP-1995-004 →

· The New York Times

In Bethlehem, a Season of Joy for Palestinians

By JOEL GREENBERG

BETHLEHEM, West Bank, Dec. 21 — Church bells pealed and fireworks burst over Manger Square tonight as the last Israeli soldiers left the town of Bethlehem, handing over the traditional birthplace of Jesus to Palestinian rule after 28 years of occupation.

Palestinian officers, their rifles thrust triumphantly toward the darkening sky, were mobbed by a rapturous crowd as they rode into a police station beside the Church of the Nativity, where Christmas will be celebrated for the first time this year under Palestinian control.

Yasir Arafat, the chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, is expected in Bethlehem on Sunday to address throngs of Palestinians and to take part in a Christmas Eve Mass at the church, which is built over the site revered as the birthplace of Jesus. Mr.

Arafat had pressed Israel to withdraw from Bethlehem before Christmas so he could visit on the holy day, highlighting Palestinian control of the town at a time when it is the focus of attention of Christians worldwide. Israel agreed to move up the withdrawal date.

Security for thousands of expected tourists and even more Palestinian visitors is now in the hands of the Palestinian Authority, which is eager to prove it can run the celebrations smoothly and safely.

“In Bethlehem we will provide security for all people,” Hajj Ismail Jaber, the Palestinian police chief in the West Bank, said shortly after his forces took control of the town,

The new police force is cheered as Bethlehem prepares to celebrate its first Christmas under Palestinian rule. Associated Press

CP-1995-019 →

· The New York Times · page 2

Christmas in Bethlehem: Arafat at Midnight Mass

By SERGE SCHMEMANN

BETHLEHEM, West Bank, Monday, Dec. 25 — The night was certainly not silent and it was not always calm as Bethlehem marked its first Christmas under Palestinian control with thunderous fireworks, choirs, bagpipes, dances and laser lights.

While the revelry flowed over Manger Square, Yasir Arafat, the chairman of the Palestinian Authority, took his place in the front pew of St. Catherine’s Roman Catholic Church, part of the larger complex including the Orthodox Church of the Nativity, for the traditional Midnight Mass in his role as the new leader of Bethlehem and the Palestinians of the West Bank.

… “It’s good, it’s big, and it’s a good deal of money,” rejoiced a Palestinian man peddling haroup, a sweet non-alcoholic Arab beverage, from a large backpack decorated in flowers. “Everything is different from before. There are many more people, much more celebration.”

Amal Shukri, a Christian Palestinian from Bethlehem, came out with two children, ages 8 and 7. “I told them this is a very special Christmas,” she said. “It’s wonderful that Arafat is here. We’re very happy to have him.”

Yasir Arafat, left rear, watched with Bethlehem’s Mayor, Elias Freij, and Suha Arafat as the Latin Patriarch, Michel Sabbah, center, celebrated Midnight Mass at St. Catherine’s Roman Catholic Church.

CP-1995-021 →

· The New York Times · page A14

Palestinians Take Control Of Ramallah

By JOEL GREENBERG

RAMALLAH, West Bank, Dec. 27 — Under a final cascade of stones, Israeli troops withdrew today from Ramallah, completing a pullout from six West Bank cities and their neighboring villages in preparation for Palestinian elections next month.

“Out!,” shouted youths as a column of Israeli jeeps moved away from a police station downtown, trailed by scores of cheering Palestinians. As stones pitched by the crowd arched toward the receding vehicles, Palestinian officers entered the station, raised a flag and greeted the throng from the roof, waving their rifles.

The scene was similar to others played out this month across the West Bank, and it set the stage for Palestinian elections planned for January 20. Under an Israeli-Palestinian accord signed in September, Israeli forces have left six cities and more than 400 villages and towns in recent weeks, ending 28 years of control over much of the West Bank.

The city of Hebron remains in Israeli hands, but most of it is supposed to be handed over in March after the completion of a bypass road for Jewish settlers. Israeli soldiers will remain to protect an enclave of settlers inside the city.

Outside the prison compound in the West Bank city of Ramallah, Palestinians celebrated after the last Israeli troops pulled out yesterday. Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times

CP-1995-020 →

· San Francisco Examiner · page 1

Israel rejects blanket damages

Cabinet approves committee to hear Arabs’ claims

Examiner News Services

“Israeli leaders decided Wednesday against blanket compensation for Arabs claiming damages from Israeli army actions during the Palestinian uprising in the occupied West Bank and Gaza… Government officials said Prime Minister Shimon Peres and the ministers of justice and finance met to discuss the issue and decided legislation should be proposed in parliament giving the state blanket immunity to the claims.

But they accepted a compromise proposal by Justice Minister David Libai for the establishment of a special committee to deal with exceptional cases.… Israelis killed more than 1,000 Palestinians between the start of the uprising on Dec 9, 1987, and the end of the official government tally on Nov. 2, 1994.

In that same period, Palestinians killed more than 100 Israelis.

According to Israeli army figures, 17,987 Palestinians and 7,137 Israelis were injured… But Leah Tsemel, an Israeli lawyer who represents several Arab claimants, said travesties had been committed against Palestinians, beyond what courts would consider a legal armed response by soldiers or police to anti-Israeli violence.”

Palestinian Ali Fanoun, 20, who was paralyzed when Israeli troops opened fire on rioters six years ago and a bullet smashed his spine, is suing Israel for $1.7 million. Fanoun is one of more than 1,000 disabled Palestinians who have filed suit in the last two years.

The answer, the same morning, in a different paper: no blanket compensation, a bill offering the state blanket immunity, and a committee for exceptional cases. The body of the story calls him Palestinian Ali Fanoun. The headline printed over his photograph calls him a paralyzed Arab.

CP-1996-008 →

· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha · page 1

Disabled Palestinians Sue Israelis for Injuries

Associated Press, Jerusalem

Jerusalem (AP) — Ali Fanoun was leaving his West Bank mosque after dawn prayers when Israeli troops opened fire at Palestinian rioters. A bullet smashed his spine, leaving him paralyzed from the waist down.

Six years later, he’s suing Israel for $1.7 million. “I didn’t do anything to deserve this,” said Fanoun, a computer science student who was 14 at the time and insists he was never involved in clashes with the Israeli army. More than 1,000 Palestinians disabled during the 1987-93 uprising against Israeli rule have filed suit since Israel and the PLO signed a peace treaty two years ago… According to the newspaper Haaretz, pending claims against Israel’s government total about $180 million… But Prime Minister Shimon Peres says he won’t consider paying compensation unless the Palestinians pay damages to the hundreds of Israelis also hurt during the uprising.

“If it is mutual, I am prepared to consider compensation. If not, each side must bear its own costs.” Most Palestinians object to the idea of equal blame. “Fighting occupiers is legitimate in international law.

But the Israelis violated the international law because they did not have a legitimate right to kill or injure people,” said Mohammed Ayyoub, a Palestinian lawyer… According to Israeli army figures, a total of 1,067 Palestinians were killed by Israelis and 17,987 were injured between the start of the uprising on Dec. 9, 1987, and Nov. 2, 1994.

During the same period, 52 Israeli soldiers were killed and 5,037 injured in Palestinian attacks, while 62 Israeli civilians were killed and 2,100 injured.

GOING TO COURT: Ali Fanoun motions for his father to bring him a wheelchair at the home they share in the West Bank village of Nahaleen. He is suing Israel for $1.7 million after soldiers shot him six years ago.

Where the disabled came from, counted by the army that made them: 17,987 Palestinians injured in six years. More than a thousand of them sued, and the prime minister answered that he would pay only if the Palestinians paid for injured Israelis too. The San Francisco Examiner ran the same story the same day and carried what happened next.

CP-1996-009 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Eldad, 86, a Top Leader In Palestine Jewish Underground

JERUSALEM, Jan. 22 (Reuters) — Israel Eldad, a leader of the Jewish underground before Israel became a nation and for 50 years one of the most influential figures of the Israeli right wing, died today, his family said. He was 86. Mr.

Eldad, born in Ukraine, immigrated to Palestine when it was under the British Mandate in 1941 and, along with Yitzhak Shamir, who later became Israeli’s Prime Minister, was a leader of Lehi, also known as the Stern Gang, the most militant of the Jewish underground groups fighting for independence. After the state of Israel was founded in 1948, Mr.

Eldad taught humanities at Israeli universities and established various ultranationalist political groups. The groups advocated taking biblical Jewish land from neighboring Arab countries. “Eldad was a highly educated, extremely literate man,” Mr. Shamir wrote in a 1994 autobiography. He also wrote that Mr.

Eldad was “a believer in the Messianic aspects of the liberation of the Land and profoundly opposed to the return of any part of it to the Arabs.” Mr. Eldad bitterly opposed the effort for peace between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization that was pursued by the Government of Yitzhak Rabin, who was assassinated last November.

During Israel’s troop withdrawal from the West Bank last month under the terms of its peace deals with the P.L.O., Mr. Eldad wrote in his weekly column in the Yedioth Ahronoth newspaper: “Whoever does not feel the loss and the destruction does not understand that this is the most dangerous assassination of all — the daily cutting away of the body and the soul.”

CP-1996-025 →

· The New York Times · New York

Arrest Puts Israel Arabs Under Cloud

After the 1996 bus bombings. The headline uses Israel Arabs — the 1950 form from the Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle, surfacing once more forty-six years later. Beside it on the page, a closing-forever suit sale on 43rd Street.

CP-1996-016 →

· Index-Journal · Greenwood · page 1

Runner on first Palestinian Olympic squad

The Associated Press, Gaza City

GAZA CITY (AP) — Majed Abu Marahil sighed as he pulled his police uniform from a khaki duffel bag. His afternoon training for the Olympics was over. Now it was time to work the night shift as a guard at Yasser Arafat’s headquarters.

Abu Marahil will compete in the 10,000 meters at the Atlanta Games this summer, part of Palestine’s first Olympic team, but he can’t afford to quit his $300-a-month job. Arafat’s fledgling government has no money to spare for athletes’ stipends. The 32-year-old father of five is one, and perhaps the only, member of the team.

The Palestinians were admitted to the Olympic movement as a result of their 1993 peace agreement with Israel. Abu Marahil has little chance of winning a medal. His best time in the 10,000 is about 30 minutes, almost 3½ minutes slower than the world record of 26:43.53 by Ethiopia’s Haile Gebrselassie.

But his goal is not to win — it is to help change the negative association his people have had with the games since the massacre of Israeli athletes by Palestinian terrorists at the 1972 Munich Olympics.

Eleven Israeli athletes and coaches were killed in the attack that ended in a shootout between German commandos and the hostage-takers. “I know the world remembers us as terrorists,” Abu Marahil said, a dark blue track suit covering his lean 6-foot frame.

“I hope I can change this picture.”… Abu Marahil is on his own in preparing for the Olympics. With no doctors or dieticians to advise him, he has designed a simple plan. He runs about two hours every day, stays away from cigarettes and alcohol, eats a lot of fruit and vegetables and tries to get as much sleep as possible.

Some days, he runs from his small house in Gaza City’s Zaytoun neighborhood to work at Arafat’s seaside compound and back. The 2½-mile route takes him through potholed streets crowded with cars, donkey carts and street vendors. Most times, Abu Marahil trains at Yarmouk Stadium, the city’s only sports arena.

Built by the Egyptians in the 1960s, Yarmouk’s track has long since been pockmarked by holes and covered by the sand that is so abundant in the coastal strip… Abu Marahil has been promised a $10,000 reward and a promotion in the police force if he brings home Palestine’s first Olympic medal.

But he dismissed the money. “It is enough for me to raise the flag of Palestine,” he said.

A sports story that routes through Munich by the fifth paragraph. The reward he turned down was worth nearly three years of his wages. This paper spells him Abu Marahil; the Atlanta Constitution spells him Abu Maraheel four months later.

CP-1996-004 →

· Tucson Citizen · Tucson

Roadblocks blamed in baby’s death

A Bedouin woman denied access to a Jerusalem hospital at an Israeli checkpoint gives birth six weeks early

Scheherezade Faramarzi

“When soldiers at an Israeli checkpoint refused to let Fayza Abu Dahouk, a 22-year-old…”

Fayza Abu Dahouk, 22, of Nabi Samuel, turned back at a checkpoint on the way to a Jerusalem hospital. The baby was born six weeks early and died. The earliest checkpoint birth in this archive, and one of the few anywhere in it where the woman is named.

CP-1996-014 →

· Paris Post-Intelligencer · Paris · page 1

Palestinians erasing doubts about sincerity in ending Israeli struggle

News analysis

Karin Laub, Associated Press, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM (AP) — By formally ending their armed struggle against Israel, the Palestinians have gone a long way toward erasing doubts about Yasser Arafat’s sincerity and restarted a peace process stalled by deadly suicide bombings.

The decision to delete anti-Israel clauses from the Palestine Liberation Organization’s charter also provided a major boost for Prime Minister Shimon Peres of Israel in his quest to retain his job in May 29 elections. Right-wing Israelis had made much of the fact that the charter advocated armed struggle to establish a Palestinian state in all of what is now Israel.

But with the vote Wednesday to formally end that struggle, their objections to peacemaking lost steam. “This is a meaningful change with historic dimensions, the greatest ideological change of this century,” said Peres, who called Arafat on the telephone to congratulate him. “It seems that it is possible to trust Arafat.”

Israel is also expected to remove troops from most of Hebron — the last West Bank city it occupies — and go ahead with talks next month with the PLO on explosive issues including Palestinian refugees and the future of disputed Jerusalem. Arafat, in turn, solidified his rule when the Palestinians’ highest body voted overwhelmingly to amend the charter.

The sweeping 504-54 victory gives the Palestinian leader greater leverage in confronting the Islamic militant groups that sent out suicide bombers in an effort to wreck peace. Arafat said the decision was a victory for the nascent Palestinian democracy and for peacemaking. “This is a success for the peace process,” he told CNN.

The vote in the Palestine National Council — tantamount to a formal recognition of the state of Israel — takes the Palestinians themselves a step closer to statehood. Peres had said that if Arafat met his promise to have the charter amended, Israel would start negotiating a final peace agreement with the Palestinians on May 4.

Under their peace accord, the two sides have three years to reach agreement on the future of the West Bank, Gaza Strip and Jerusalem. The Palestinians hope the outcome of the talks will be a Palestinian state. If Peres is re-elected, that may very well be the case.

In a sign that it was softening its position, Peres’ Labor Party prepared to vote today on a new platform that would scrap a clause opposing the establishment of a Palestinian state. Arafat himself presented that simple choice to Palestine National Council delegates this week.

Yelling at hard-liners poised to vote “no,” Arafat said that if the charter was not amended, the Palestinians would miss their last real hope for independence. Peres, meanwhile, faces several difficult decisions in the weeks leading up to the elections… The Palestinians have sent a clear message that they are serious about peace.

That message may win over centrist swing voters who favor peacemaking, but don’t want to put their security at risk. In a sign of how widely the Palestinian vote was welcomed in Israel, Netanyahu, the opposition leader, called it a positive step.

Yet Netanyahu has moved steadily toward the political center as the election draws near, saying for the first time this week that he would consider meeting with Arafat.

An editorial cartoon runs above: two men under an umbrella in a downpour of blood drops, one saying “DO YOU THINK THIS BLOOD IS EVER GOING TO LET UP?” Signed Edstein ’96, Rocky Mtn. News / NEA.

The vote to amend the PLO charter, 504 to 54, reported as a news analysis. The correspondent is identified at the foot as having covered Israel and the Palestinian areas since 1987.

CP-1996-002 →

· The New York Times

Emile Habibi, 73, Chronicler Of Conflicts of Israeli Arabs

By Joel Greenberg

JERUSALEM, May 2 — Emile Habibi, an Israeli Arab writer whose depiction of the predicament of Arabs in the Jewish state made him one of the most prominent and popular authors in the Middle East, died today in a hospital in Nazareth. He was 73. The cause was cancer, his family said.

Widely read throughout the Arab world and translated into more than a dozen languages, including Hebrew, Mr. Habibi’s novels and stories explored the conflicts of a people caught between their Arab identity and their Israeli citizenship.

He was awarded Israel’s highest cultural award, the Israel Prize, in 1992, and the top Palestinian literary honor, the Jerusalem Medal, by the Palestine Liberation Organization in 1990.

His most renowned work, “The Secret Life of Said the Pessoptimist,” portrayed with ironic humor a character who embodied the contradictions of Israeli Arab life, trying to conform to Israeli society while struggling to preserve his Arab roots. In rich Arabic prose embellished with original expressions that he coined, Mr.

Habibi also wrote of the differences that emerged when Israel’s Arabs were reunited with their Palestinian brothers after Israel captured the West Bank and Gaza Strip in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war. Mr. Habibi was born in Haifa on Aug. 29, 1922, during the British Mandate in Palestine.

Like many Israeli Arabs, he stayed in the country when others fled or were forced from their homes during the Arab-Jewish fighting that followed Israel’s declaration of independence in 1948. He was a founder of the Israeli Communist Party and editor of its newspaper, serving as a parliament member for two decades.

But he broke with the party when it opposed reforms in the Soviet Union in the 1980’s, and he severed ties with it after it backed a coup in Moscow by Communist hard-liners in 1991. He turned to writing fiction in the 1970’s and 80’s, publishing three novels, a play and two collections of short stories.

But he continued to write political articles in Israeli Arab and Palestinian newspapers. While asserting his Arab identity and heritage, Mr. Habibi was also a staunch advocate of Jewish-Arab coexistence and mutual recognition between Israelis and Palestinians. His acceptance of the Israel Prize set off fierce debate in Arab intellectual circles.

Critics accused him of lending legitimacy to what they called the discriminatory and anti-Arab policies of Israel’s government, then led by the right-wing Likud party. But Mr. Habibi replied that the prize was an acknowledgement of Arab cultural achievement and could promote Israeli-Palestinian peace.

“A dialogue of prizes is better than a dialogue of stones and bullets,” he said. “It is indirect recognition of the Arabs in Israel as a nation. This is recognition of a national culture. It will help the Arab population in its struggle to strike roots in the land and win equal rights.”

Holding up the Israeli Arab experience as a model of steadfastness in the face of adversity and dispersion, Mr. Habibi asked in his will that his tombstone be inscribed: “Emile Habibi — remained in Haifa.” He is survived by his wife, Nada; a son, Salaam; two daughters, Johaina Kandalaft and Rawiya Ganadri; 10 grandchildren and two great-grandchildren.

Emile Habibi

CP-1996-027 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Suitcase No Longer His Homeland, a Poet Returns

By Joel Greenberg

RAMALLAH, West Bank, May 7 — Staying in a modest hotel room here this week, Mahmoud Darwish seemed no more than a traveler passing through town. But after 26 years in exile, the man Palestinians consider their national poet felt he was coming home. Over several days, Mr.

Darwish, a 54-year-old Israeli Arab, had returned to his native Galilee, visited the West Bank and seen Jerusalem. The poet of Palestinian dispersion who had once written, “My homeland is a suitcase,” had begun to unpack years of emotional baggage. “I went back to being a child,” he said of his trip.

“I touched the trees and the stones, and felt as if I hadn’t left. Time had stopped, and the circle was closed.” Mr. Darwish had been permitted a brief visit to Israel to take part in a film documentary about the Israeli Arab author Emile Habibi, but arrived to find that Mr. Habibi had just died. Instead of being reunited with his mentor, Mr.

Darwish eulogized him at his funeral. The Israeli authorities had lifted a years-long ban, allowing Mr. Darwish four days in Israel and an unlimited stay in the Palestinian self-rule areas of the West Bank.

He visited his family in the Galilee village of Judeida, went back to Haifa where he had once lived and edited a newspaper, and read his poetry to thousands of Palestinian listeners. Mr.

Darwish had left Israel in 1970 after he was repeatedly jailed and put under travel restrictions because of what Israel considered subversive activities in Arab nationalist groups and the Communist Party. He spent a decade in Beirut and joined the Palestine Liberation Organization, serving a few years on its executive committee.

After living in Paris for 10 years, he moved several months ago to Amman, Jordan. He has published more than two dozen books, and is admired by Palestinians for his intensely political poetry that evokes their collective history. In one poem about exile, he wrote: We travel like other people, but we return to nowhere. We have a country of words.

But his sometimes bitter verses condemning Israel, praising the stone-throwers of the Palestinian uprising and criticizing the P.L.O.’s accord with the Israelis have made them wary of letting the influential writer return to Israel.

The Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish, an Israeli Arab exiled from his Galilee village 26 years ago, was back this week, feeling still loved. (Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times)

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is cropped to the article, photograph and map. The dateline reads “RAMALLAH, West Bank, May 7”, three days before the slide date of 1996-05-10, so the date could not be confirmed and the gap is unexplained by anything on the page.

CP-1996-021 →

· Paragould Daily Press · Paragould · page 1

Family discusses bombing suspect

The Associated Press, Khan Younis

“KHAN YOUNIS, Gaza Strip (AP) — The young man left his family in February, advising his new wife to mind her studies and telling his mother he was going away to work in a plastics factory. Within weeks, a series of suicide bombings shook Israel.

On Friday, Hassan Salameh was shot and arrested by Israeli troops in the West Bank — accused by Israel of organizing three bombings this year that killed 43 people and wounded 91.

In their home in a squalid Gaza Strip refugee camp near Khan Younis, Salameh’s family members said Sunday that they had no idea about the activities of the devout, hot-tempered 25-year-old — and seemed divided on the wisdom of his ways.

Samir Salameh, 33, said he knew his brother was a member of the military wing of the Islamic militant Hamas group, but was still surprised. The family had expected Hassan to ‘settle down and put his life in order,’ he said.

Younger brother Mohammed defended Hassan’s actions as ‘a legitimate kind of self-defense’ resulting from ‘years of oppression and injustice.’ Their mother, Khadija Hourani, said she just wanted peace. ‘I don’t want bombings anywhere — here or in Israel.

I don’t want people to die,’ she said. Still, she warned that if any harm befell her son during interrogation, ‘worse things will happen — more bloodshed, revenge and killings.’ Salameh was a teenager when the Palestinian uprising against Israel broke out in December 1987. Like many boys, he threw stones at Israeli soldiers.

A year later, he was shot in the pelvis and seriously wounded. He spent the next few years in and out of Israeli jails… Salameh entered Gaza illegally in December 1994 and was promptly arrested by Arafat’s security forces and held for five months, Samir Salameh said.

‘They told him they were protecting him from the Israelis because he was wanted by them,’ he said. After his release, he enrolled in a computer course in the mornings and worked in a plastic factory at night. A devout Muslim, he spent most of his free time in mosques teaching children the Koran. Salameh left his mother, six brothers, sister and wife on Feb.

2 after breaking his daylong fast at sunset during the holy Muslim month of Ramadan. ‘He said, “Mother, I’m going away to work in a plastic factory in Gaza and may be away for a while. I don’t want you to worry about me. I may phone you,”’ Hourani said.

He told his 18-year-old bride Maryam, to whom he had been married only four months, to concentrate on her high school studies. ‘He said he was going away for work and God willing, will come back soon,’ she said… But, he said of his brother, ‘I wish he had died a martyr and was not arrested.’”

The Birmingham Post Herald ran the same dispatch the same day as “Militant’s relatives surprised by his actions,” and kept the mother’s appeal for peace word for word. What it cut was the man: the uprising, the bullet in his pelvis, the Israeli jails, the five months in Arafat’s prison, the Koran classes, the wife of four months. The short version keeps the mother and deletes the son. Both scans are held. This Samir Salameh is a third man of that name in this material and is linked to none of the others.

CP-1996-006 →

· Fort Worth Star-Telegram · Fort Worth

Israeli Arabs vote for a prime minister yesterday in Kafr Kassem

Israeli Arabs vote for a prime minister yesterday in Kafr Kassem.

An Associated Press photograph of three women at a ballot box, Arabic notices on the wall behind them, run in Texas the morning after the Israeli prime-ministerial election of 29 May 1996. The paper spells the village Kafr Kassem. The clipping carries no headline of its own; the caption is the only text on it.

CP-1996-015 →

· Los Angeles Times

Palestinians Won't Accept Reversal

Israel: The new government is obliged to continue peace moves involving Jewish settlements and a sovereign Arab state.

By DAOUD KUTTAB

JERUSALEM—When Shimon Peres took over the premiership in Israel after the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, he made a special appeal to the Syrians. Trying to convince them of his seriousness about the peace process, Peres said that he preferred to win the peace rather than win the elections.

In the months leading to the elections, however, Peres reneged on his statement when dealing with Palestinians with a brutal siege and with indiscriminate bombing of Lebanese civilians. In the end, Peres lost both the peace and the vote.

Now Israel's Prime Minister-elect Benjamin Netanyahu is singing a similar tune about his “deep” commitment to peace with the Arab world, including with Palestinians. It is possible that in the short term Netanyahu will seek to improve the situation vis-a-vis Palestinians.

But in the long term he will be unable to effectively move the peace process unless he makes dramatic and courageous changes in his current political platform. Netanyahu inherits a partially completed interim solution with Palestinians and final status talks that had a ceremonial opening last month.

He has to deal with Palestinian and Arab interlocutors that are highly mistrustful of him and his coalition partners. He also needs to convince a suspicious international community with actions that show he is committed to peace.

When Netanyahu says that he respects existing peace agreements, he needs to remember that they were signed between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization, with international approval. For Netanyahu and the newly elected government to talk to Yasser Arafat is not a negotiable matter but a matter of necessity.

CP-1996-029 →

· Tampa Bay Times · St. Petersburg

Column One

from 1A

… we will be able to play.” With a tiny entourage of 15 members, including just three athletes, the Palestinian presence in Atlanta will be largely symbolic. The two runners, Abu Mraheel and 20-year-old Ehab Salameh, are both a good three minutes behind the world record in their respective races, 10,000 and 5,000 meters.

The third athlete, boxer Rashid Al-Obeid, is training in America, and Palestinians here say it is unknown how he will fare. But it really doesn't matter. With these three athletes, Palestinians will realize a goal many had seen as impossible.

Barred for decades from joining the Olympic games, Palestinian participation is one of the many dividends of the Oslo peace agreement signed with Israel in September 1993.

Eleven days after the famous handshake on the White House lawn between the late Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin and Palestine Liberation Organization chairman Yasser Arafat, the International Olympic Committee met in Washington and accepted the Palestinian team.

“They said we were welcome because we have a land now to represent,” said Nabil Mabrook, one of the Palestinian Olympic Committee members, who has spent the past two decades attending the Olympic Games as an observer. He has been reduced to an outsider going all the way back to Montreal in 1976.

“Before, they told us we didn't have a state, we didn't have a land, so we couldn't participate,” said Mabrook. “We tried all the diplomatic (channels); we wrote letters to everybody, but they said no.”

The low point in Mabrook's battle for Palestinian acceptance came in 1983 at the International Amateur Athletics Federation games in Helsinki, when Palestinian athletes who participated in the opening ceremonies had to carry a white flag instead of the red, white, green and black colors of the Palestinian flag.

Their national flag, tarnished by the murders of 11 Israeli athletes at the Munich Games in 1972 by five members of the Black September guerrilla group, had been banned from the competition. The militant Palestinian organization carried out the killings to protest the plight of Palestinian refugees.

Instead, they shocked the world and made the word “Palestinian” synonymous with terrorism. It is a stigma Palestinians say they hope their peaceful presence in Atlanta will erase. “I want to change this view,” said the 36-year-old Abu Mraheel. “I am coming in the name of peace to play sports. I'm not coming for politics or war.”

Abu Mraheel and Salameh are both sons of refugees who fled in 1948 from towns now in Israel. Both of them grew up amid the oppressive poverty that is endemic to the Gaza Strip, enduring the worst that Gaza has to offer the residents of its squalid refugee camps.

When the intifada began in 1987, violent clashes between Palestinians and Israeli soldiers kept Abu Mraheel from running in the streets during the day, while at night, all of Gaza lived under an army-imposed curfew. He resorted to running circles around his father's orange and lemon groves in the fertile Zietun neighborhood of Gaza City.

Salameh, 11 years old when the uprising started and barely 17 when it ended, missed out on participating in the team sports that were canceled because of the low-intensity war; he spent his formative sports years confined to his house during the dusk-to-dawn curfew.

Today, both runners are preparing for the Atlanta trip by running along Gaza's Mediterranean coast or at the Yarmuk stadium. Their Olympic status has brought them enough fame that they are recognized and cheered on by local Palestinians — and trailed by international news teams — as they run by beachfront restaurants and shops.

“All the Palestinians support us because they are happy that we get to participate with the other countries in the world,” said Salameh. “It has been a Palestinian dream for a long time.” At this early stage, that support is exclusively sentimental.

The impoverished population is in no position to offer financial help, while the nascent government, dependent upon aid from international donors for everything from new schools to government employees' salaries, has yet to allocate a budget to its national Olympic team. The government will pay only for the airplane tickets for the 15 members to fly to Atlanta.

An international Olympics charity is picking up the tab for the team to stay at the Olympic Village. Everything else is run on a shoestring. The Palestinian Olympic Committee members are all volunteers, including two trainers who work both as physical fitness coaches and as medical advisers.

The training facilities stand at a bare minimum, with only running and martial arts training available in Gaza. There is no swimming pool, no gymnastics bars or rings, no basketball court, no track and field gear. But there are Palestinian swimmers, gymnasts, basketball players and high jumpers. Mirroring the Palestinian political problem, they are spread all over the globe.

Swimmers are in France, track and basketball stars are in Jordan and Egypt. Gymnasts were in Kuwait — until the Persian Gulf war dispersed them and the Palestinian Olympic Committee lost track of them.

Palestinians hope these athletes will find their way to the West Bank and Gaza, and the Palestinian diaspora community — generally better off than those at home — will step in to help them financially in preparation for the Games in Sidney, Australia, in 2000. “Every beginning is difficult,” said Abu Mraheel as he warmed up at the stadium.

“I am opening the door now so that other Palestinians can follow.” “In another four years, we can be great,” he said with a smile. “Just give us time.”

The jump page of a Column One feature; the clipping begins mid-sentence and the front-page opening is not in the scan. This paper names the team's boxer Rashid Al-Obeid and says he is training in America. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, writing about the same three-athlete team the same month, names him Rashid Judeh and says he was barred from competing. The discrepancy is logged, not resolved.

CP-1996-013 →

· estimated · LNP Lancaster Online

Palestinians losing ground to Israel

East Jerusalem’s housing shortage has forced thousands to move to the West Bank autonomy zone.

JERUSALEM (AP) — The lights go out early in Arab east Jerusalem. After sundown, storekeepers along Salah Edin Street pull down their shutters and the few restaurants close for lack of customers.

Just 15 miles from east Jerusalem’s main shopping avenue, traffic jams the commercial district in the West Bank town of Ramallah, where dozens of stores, boutiques and discos have opened in recent months.

The shift in action to Ramallah is only one of many signs that the Palestinians are losing ground in east Jerusalem, which they hope to turn into the capital of their own state.

The new right-wing Israeli government recently revoked the residency permits of hundreds of Palestinians in the city and is preparing to start building another big Jewish neighborhood in east Jerusalem. At the same time, Yasser Arafat’s Palestinian Authority has quietly shut several offices in Jerusalem, opting to avoid a showdown with Israel it feels it would only lose.

And plans to build Palestinian neighborhoods in east Jerusalem with $30 million from Saudi Arabia have been thwarted by Israel’s refusal to grant construction permits. So the Saudis have kept their aid, and east Jerusalem’s worsening housing shortage has forced thousands of Palestinians to move to the city’s suburbs in the West Bank autonomy zone.

Officials of the Palestinian Authority acknowledge that many of Jerusalem’s Arab residents no longer look to Arafat for help and instead try to move under Israel’s widening umbrella of services in a de facto recognition of Israeli sovereignty.

“We are losing our credibility in the eyes of the people in Jerusalem because they see us as being unable to do anything for them,” said Anis Al Qaq, deputy director of the Palestinian Planning Ministry. “People cannot live on national dreams. They need food, health care and education.”

Israel annexed east Jerusalem into its capital after capturing it from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast war. Today, the city has 405,000 Jewish and 160,000 Palestinian residents.

Palestinian theater and film director Jamal Ghoushe, center, speaks to a friend at the Hakawati theater in East Jerusalem. Because most Palestinians are spending their leisure time in Ramallah, Ghoushe expects the theater will close. (Associated Press)

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is cropped to the article and its photograph. The story describes “the new right-wing Israeli government” (Netanyahu took office in June 1996), consistent with the slide date of 1996-07-21, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1996-017 →

· estimated · Midland News

Israel seals off Arab town

JERUSALEM (AP) — The Israeli army sealed off the West Bank city of Ramallah on Saturday, in a showdown with Palestinians over the arrest of an Israeli Arab. Troops blockaded Ramallah, a bustling center of Palestinian commerce, because Palestinian agents seized Abd e-Salam Hirbawi late Friday night in Jerusalem, the army spokesman said.

Israel maintains that the Israel-PLO autonomy agreements forbid the Palestinian Authority to arrest Israeli citizens or to operate inside Jerusalem. The blockade cut off Ramallah from the rest of the West Bank and from Jerusalem, the army spokesman said. Only urgent medical cases could leave and only trucks carrying food or other essential supplies could enter.

Hirbawi, 50, was arrested at his Jerusalem home by Palestinian Preventative Security Service agents. The plainclothes agents were armed with pistols, his family said. The family said the reason for the arrest lies in a dispute with the Coptic Church, which claims ownership of a property that Hirbawi leases inside the Old City of Jerusalem.

The church enlisted the aid of Egypt’s government, which persuaded Palestinian Authority President Yasser Arafat to support the church. Hirbawi was abducted because he refused to hand over the property, the family said. Police spokesman Shmuel Ben-Ruby said the Palestinian Authority had been warned that Israel “took a very grave view of the abduction.”

Israel Radio reported that Israel is considering cancellation of the VIP pass of Col. Jebril Rajoub, head of the Preventative Security Service, unless Hirbawi is released. The pass enables the bearer to move freely between the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, with minimal security checks. Rajoub told the AP he knew nothing about the arrest of Hirbawi.

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is a single column cut from the page. The story says the blockade happened “on Saturday” and the seizure “late Friday night”; July 20, 1996 was a Saturday, consistent with a July 21, 1996 paper, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1996-018 →

· estimated · Press of Atlantic City · Atlantic City

Palestinians losing ground in hoped-for capital

The new Israeli government recently revoked the residency permits of Palestinians in east Jerusalem and is preparing to start building another Jewish neighborhood there.

Associated Press

JERUSALEM — The lights go out early in Arab east Jerusalem. After sundown, storekeepers along Salah Edin Street pull down their shutters and the few restaurants close for lack of customers.

Just 15 miles from east Jerusalem’s main shopping avenue, traffic jams the commercial district in the West Bank town of Ramallah, where dozens of stores, boutiques and discos have opened in recent months.

The shift in action to Ramallah is only one of many signs that the Palestinians are losing ground in east Jerusalem, which they hope to turn into the capital of their own state.

The new right-wing Israeli government recently revoked the residency permits of hundreds of Palestinians in the city and is preparing to start building another big Jewish neighborhood in east Jerusalem. At the same time, Yasser Arafat’s Palestinian Authority has quietly shut several offices in Jerusalem, opting to avoid a showdown with Israel it feels it would only lose.

And plans to build Palestinian neighborhoods in east Jerusalem with $30 million from Saudi Arabia have been thwarted by Israel’s refusal to grant construction permits. So the Saudis have kept their aid, and east Jerusalem’s worsening housing shortage has forced thousands of Palestinians to move to the city’s suburbs in the West Bank autonomy zone.

Officials of the Palestinian Authority acknowledge that many of Jerusalem’s Arab residents no longer look to Arafat for help and instead try to move under Israel’s widening umbrella of services in a de facto recognition of Israeli sovereignty.

“We are losing our credibility in the eyes of the people in Jerusalem because they see us as being unable to do anything for them,” said Anis Al Qaq, deputy director of the Palestinian Planning Ministry. “People cannot live on national dreams. They need food, health care and education.”

Israel annexed east Jerusalem into its capital after capturing it from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast war. Today, the city has 405,000 Jewish and 160,000 Palestinian residents.

Palestinian theater and film director Jamal Ghoushe, left, speaks to a friend in the cafe at the Hakawati Theater, a hub for Palestinian intellectuals in east Jerusalem. Ghoushe expects the theater to close soon. (Associated Press photo)

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is cropped to the article and its photograph. The story describes “the new right-wing Israeli government” (Netanyahu took office in June 1996), consistent with the slide date of 1996-07-21, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1996-019 →

· The Herald-Times · Bloomington

Arabs moving out of Jerusalem to West Bank

Pressure from Israeli government forcing many Palestinians to move to Ramallah

Associated Press

JERUSALEM — The lights go out early in Arab east Jerusalem. After sundown, storekeepers along Salah Edin Street pull down their shutters and the few restaurants close for lack of customers.

Just 15 miles from east Jerusalem’s main shopping avenue, traffic jams the commercial district in the West Bank town of Ramallah, where dozens of stores, boutiques and discos have opened in recent months.

The shift in action to Ramallah is only one of many signs that the Palestinians are losing ground in east Jerusalem, which they hope to turn into the capital of their own state.

The new right-wing Israeli government recently revoked the residency permits of hundreds of Palestinians in the city and is preparing to start building another big Jewish neighborhood in east Jerusalem. At the same time, Yasser Arafat’s Palestinian Authority has quietly shut several offices in Jerusalem, opting to avoid a showdown with Israel it feels it would only lose.

And plans to build Palestinian neighborhoods in east Jerusalem with $30 million from Saudi Arabia have been thwarted by Israel’s refusal to grant construction permits. So the Saudis have kept their aid, and east Jerusalem’s worsening housing shortage has forced thousands of Palestinians to move to the city’s suburbs in the West Bank autonomy zone.

Officials of the Palestinian Authority acknowledge that many of Jerusalem’s Arab residents no longer look to Arafat for help and instead try to move under Israel’s widening umbrella of services in a de facto recognition of Israeli sovereignty.

“We are losing our credibility in the eyes of the people in Jerusalem because they see us as being unable to do anything for them,” said Anis Al Qaq, deputy director of the Palestinian Planning Ministry. “People cannot live on national dreams. They need food, health care and education.”

Israel annexed east Jerusalem into its capital after capturing it from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast war. Today, the city has 405,000 Jewish and 160,000 Palestinian residents.

Palestinian theater and film director Jamal Ghoushe, center left, speaks to a friend in the cafe at the Hakawati theater in East Jerusalem Thursday. Ghoushe expects the theater to close as few patrons frequent it. AP PHOTO

Date check: the page line reads “Sunday Herald-Times, July 21, 1996” — matches the slide date, and the page-top section flag reads NATION/WORLD

CP-1996-020 →

· estimated · The Star-Ledger · Newark

Palestinians shift action to Ramallah, losing ground in east Jerusalem

By Said Ghazali, Associated Press

JERUSALEM — The lights go out early in Arab east Jerusalem. After sundown, storekeepers along Salah Edin Street pull down their shutters and the few restaurants close for lack of customers.

Just 15 miles from east Jerusalem’s main shopping avenue, traffic jams the commercial district in the West Bank town of Ramallah, where dozens of stores, boutiques and discos have opened in recent months.

The shift in action to Ramallah is only one of many signs that the Palestinians are losing ground in east Jerusalem, which they hope to turn into the capital of their own state.

The new right-wing Israeli government recently revoked the residency permits of hundreds of Palestinians in the city and is preparing to start building another big Jewish neighborhood in east Jerusalem. At the same time, Yasir Arafat’s Palestinian Authority has quietly shut several offices in Jerusalem, opting to avoid a showdown with Israel it feels it would only lose.

And plans to build Palestinian neighborhoods in east Jerusalem with $30 million from Saudi Arabia have been thwarted by Israel’s refusal to grant construction permits. So the Saudis have kept their aid, and east Jerusalem’s worsening housing shortage has forced thousands of Palestinians to move to the city’s suburbs in the West Bank autonomy zone.

Officials of the Palestinian Authority acknowledge that many of Jerusalem’s Arab residents no longer look to Arafat for help and instead try to move under Israel’s widening umbrella of services in a de facto recognition of Israeli sovereignty.

“We are losing our credibility in the eyes of the people in Jerusalem because they see us as being unable to do anything for them,” said Anis Al Qaq, deputy director of the Palestinian Planning Ministry. “People cannot live on national dreams. They need food, health care and education,” he said.

Israel annexed east Jerusalem into its capital after capturing it from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast war. Today, the city has 405,000 Jewish and 160,000 Palestinian residents.

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is cropped to the article. The story describes “the new right-wing Israeli government” (Netanyahu took office in June 1996), consistent with the slide date of 1996-07-21, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1996-023 →

· The Town Talk · Alexandria

Losing Jerusalem

Palestinians’ hope for capital in east Jerusalem is fading

JERUSALEM (AP) — The lights go out early in Arab east Jerusalem. After sundown, storekeepers along Salah Edin Street pull down their shutters and the few restaurants close for lack of customers.

Just 15 miles from east Jerusalem’s main shopping avenue, traffic jams the commercial district in the West Bank town of Ramallah, where dozens of stores, boutiques and discos have opened in recent months.

The shift in action to Ramallah is only one of many signs that the Palestinians are losing ground in east Jerusalem, which they hope to turn into the capital of their own state.

The new right-wing Israeli government recently revoked the residency permits of hundreds of Palestinians in the city and is preparing to start building another big Jewish neighborhood in east Jerusalem. At the same time, Yasser Arafat’s Palestinian Authority has quietly shut several offices in Jerusalem, opting to avoid a showdown with Israel it feels it would only lose.

And plans to build Palestinian neighborhoods in east Jerusalem with $30 million from Saudi Arabia have been thwarted by Israel’s refusal to grant construction permits. So the Saudis have kept their aid, and east Jerusalem’s worsening housing shortage has forced thousands of Palestinians to move to the city’s suburbs in the West Bank autonomy zone.

Officials of the Palestinian Authority acknowledge that many of Jerusalem’s Arab residents no longer look to Arafat for help and instead try to move under Israel’s widening umbrella of services in a de facto recognition of Israeli sovereignty.

“We are loosing our credibility in the eyes of the people in Jerusalem because they see us as being unable to do anything for them,” said Anis Al Qaq, deputy director of the Palestinian Planning Ministry. “People cannot live on national dreams. They need food, health care and education.”

Israel annexed east Jerusalem into its capital after capturing it from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast war. Today, the city has 405,000 Jewish and 160,000 Palestinian residents.

Palestinian Liberation Organization President Yasser Arafat talks to reporters last week in Gaza City. (Associated Press)

Date check: The page line reads only “The Town Talk, Alexandria-Pineville, La.” — no date and no page number are printed in the part of the page that was scanned, so the slide date 1996-07-21 could not be confirmed. A house advertisement on the same page carries the dates “JULY 23” and “AUGUST 12-14”, which is consistent with a paper of around 21 July but does not establish it.

CP-1996-024 →

· The Courier News · Bridgewater

Pair of Palestinian athletes have been running forever

Mike Lopresti, At the Olympics

ATLANTA — The scars of the two-man Olympic team from Palestine tell of the road they have traveled. How tortured it has been, and how important it is to them that they are even in Atlanta. Majid Abu Marahil will show you his right arm, where an Israeli bullet found him in 1987. Or left knee, where he has fallen running through the streets of a teeming, turbulent Gaza.

Ihab Salama can point to his left thigh from being shot during the Intifada, when he would hurl rocks at Israeli troops and then run for his life, and not a medal. “Many of my athletes have bullets in them here or there,” said Muhammar Bississo, chief of the first delegation to ever come into the Olympics under the Palestinian flag.

“And some of them have died.” Perhaps it is not surprising that Palestine’s first Olympians are runners, for they come from a place that has seen gunshots in the street and tear gas in the air. To be slow sometimes meant to die.

“The nature of the life they were living in Palestine,” Bississo said, “necessitates that everybody moves fast.” “Not only in sport,” Marahil added, “but also in sprint.” He is here to run the 10,000 meters, Salama to run the 5,000. Neither will come near a medal.

The top competitors will have stopped sweating by the time they finish. But that is hardly the point. Not when your homeland is flying its first Olympic flag. Not when you have endured the uncertain life of the Gaza refugee camps, and now hope for the fragile peace with Israel to hold in a land where there has been only misery.

And not when your people are forever linked with the darkest Olympic hour … Munich … 1972 … Israeli athletes killed … Palestinian terrorists. And so the memory will always stay. “We have already won a gold medal by being here to raise the national flag,” Marahil said.

“I hope it will be the beginning to ease of the sour images of the past.” Nor is the final place in the race important when one comes from a homeland with no true running tracks. Where one has been forced to train in simple sneakers or barefoot, running on the streets or on the beach. “What else? We have only our seashore,” Salama said.

“I owe it all to the sand.” He is 20 years old, and until recently had only been on two true running tracks in his life. Marahil is 32, once worked in an Israeli greenhouse and now is a bodyguard for Palestinian leader Yassar Arafat. Not until 16 days ago had either runner ever worn spiked running shoes. Salama’s may be too tight.

The open wound on his left toe from running in the new shoes is a symbol for the struggle Palestine is having to climb to its feet in Olympic sport. “Even it was amputated,” Marahil said, “he would run.”

Not until the final days before the Olympics, when an Israeli protest was turned down, was it certain that Palestine would march in the Opening Ceremony. When the day came, it was Marahil who carried the flag. “A child’s dream,” he said. He led the way, for the world to see. They are here to blaze a difficult trail, the two runners.

Perhaps the next Olympics will be different for Palestine. Its distance runners will have been able to train on real running tracks, in real running shoes. And they will not wear the scars from bullets.

The first Palestinian Olympic team was two men, and an American columnist in Atlanta went and asked them how they trained. Majid Abu Marahil, 32, carries an Israeli bullet scar in his right arm from 1987 and a bad left knee from falling while running through Gaza. He worked in an Israeli greenhouse and then became a bodyguard for Arafat, and he carried the flag at the opening ceremony: a child’s dream. Ihab Salama, 20, was shot in the left thigh during the intifada, throwing stones and then running — and not a medal. He had been on two running tracks in his life. Asked how he trained, he answered: ‘What else? We have only our seashore. I owe it all to the sand.’ Neither had worn spiked shoes until sixteen days before the Games, and Salama ran with an open wound on his toe because the new ones were too tight. The delegation chief, Muhammar Bississo, explains why Palestine’s first Olympians were runners: the nature of the life they were living necessitates that everybody moves fast. Marahil finishes the thought — not only in sport, but also in sprint. The column ends on the thing it has been circling: And they will not wear the scars from bullets.

CP-1996-011 →

· The Atlanta Constitution · Atlanta · page 1

Major strides

Competing in the Olympics for the first time, Palestinians hope to erase some of the negative images from the past.

Mark Sherman, Staff Writer

“Majed Abu Maraheel is not worried about medals. He could not care less about the track conditions. He has no problems with the heat. The Palestinian flagbearer in last week’s Opening Ceremony holds no illusions about his ability to compete with the world’s best 10,000-meter runners.

Maraheel’s only concern was making it to the Olympic stadium in time for his qualifying heat Friday, when he became the first Palestinian to compete in the Olympics under his own flag. ‘We already won the gold medal by being here,’ he said.… Maraheel is a member of Force 17, the security unit that guards Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat.

The group also has been identified by the CIA and State Department as being responsible for terrorist activities in the occupied territories, and one in Cyprus, since 1985. Maraheel rolls up the right sleeve of his T-shirt to reveal a 3-inch scar that he said came from an Israeli bullet.

Yet the Palestinian presence in Atlanta ‘will help heal wounds and erase some of the sour images of the past,’ he said… Added his Israeli counterpart, Efraim Zinger, ‘We hope we’ll be able to contribute something to relations in our region.’… Maraheel and Ehab Salama, a 5,000-meter runner from Gaza, are the team’s only athletes in Atlanta.

Palestinian officials said a third athlete, boxer Rashid Judeh, was barred from competing here by boxing officials who said he lacked sufficient international experience.

The size of the first Palestinian squad is due in equal parts to the virtual lack of athletic facilities in the West Bank and Gaza and to Israel’s refusal to allow Palestinians who claim Jerusalem as their address to compete in the Olympics… They put on spiked track shoes for the first time 15 days ago. ‘In Gaza, we ran either in sneakers or barefoot,’ Salama said. Describing the difference between practice facilities in Atlanta and the Gaza Strip, Maraheel said, ‘It’s like from heaven to Earth.’

Salama, wearing sandals to an interview, nursed a painful-looking sore on his left foot. But his teammate said the wound would not keep him out of the race. Said Maraheel, ‘Even if it was amputated, he would run.’”

The same runner as the Index Journal four months earlier, spelled Maraheel here and Abu Marahil there. Both spellings stand as printed. The section header reads PALESTINIAN DELEGATION and the paragraph about Force 17 and the CIA sits between the scar and the healing. Photo credit: Rich Addicks / Staff.

CP-1996-007 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles · page 1

‘When I First Got My Legs, I Had to Practice Every Day’

Making a Difference

Interviewed by Kate Seelye

“YOSHIO SETIGUCHI, pediatrician and prosthetics specialist: ‘The biggest problem for Nizar initially was adapting to this country. Here was a 10-year-old from a refugee camp.

Suddenly he was here in sunny Southern California… There is no question that Nizar is a fortunate kid, but this always raises the question of why he was selected and what about the others that didn’t get selected.’

LEILA BROOKS, businesswoman and host mother: ‘I’ll never forget what he told me a few years ago when he was 12 or 13. His family is very poor. He said the first money he makes, he’s going to buy his dad a new donkey. He didn’t want to buy a game or a computer.’

NIZAR EL-BARKY: ‘I have been coming to the States since I was 10. It’s fun going to places like Disneyland. I can’t have this kind of fun in Gaza… When I first got my legs, I had to practice walking every day in the hospital for many months… There’s a woman at the hospital with no legs and no arms, and she drives a van.

I look at her and think if she can drive, I can do anything.’ [El Barky was injured when he was 9. He said he reached for something that dropped from an Israeli helicopter that he thought was a toy. It exploded.] ‘It was pretty bad. Sometimes I say, why me, why Nizar, but it could happen to anyone.

At least I have my mind, I have my brain… I got a letter from Bill Clinton. It made me feel good. I know there’s a lot of other kids that didn’t have this chance. Many wonderful people have helped me to come here. If they hadn’t, I’d still be in a wheelchair in Palestine.’”

Nizar El-Barky after getting his new prosthetics.

Three people are given headed sections of their own: a surgeon, a host mother, and a fifteen-year-old from Gaza who lost both legs and an arm at nine. He gets the longest. He talks about Disneyland, a donkey he means to buy his father, an award he won for learning to read, a letter from a president, and a woman at the hospital who drives a van. How he was injured is printed in square brackets.

CP-1996-010 →

· The Atlanta Journal-Constitution · Atlanta

Major strides

PALESTINIAN DELEGATION — Competing in the Olympics for the first time, Palestinians hope to erase some of the negative images from the past.

By Mark Sherman, Staff Writer

“Majed Abu Maraheel is not worried about medals. He could not care less about the track conditions. He has no problems with the heat. The Palestinian flagbearer in last week’s Opening Ceremony holds no illusions about his ability to compete with the world’s best 10,000-meter runners.

Maraheel’s only concern was making it to the Olympic stadium in time for his qualifying heat Friday, when he became the first Palestinian to compete in the Olympics under his own flag. ‘We already won the gold medal by being here,’ he said.

The Olympic movement, its leaders love to say, prides itself on bringing together unfriendly neighbors — sometimes warring nations — for sporting events that are divorced from politics. It’s not always easy to do. Maraheel is a member of Force 17, the security unit that guards Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat.

The group also has been identified by the CIA and State Department as being responsible for terrorist activities in the occupied territories, and one in Cyprus, since 1985. Maraheel rolls up the right sleeve of his T-shirt to reveal a 3-inch scar that he said came from an Israeli bullet.

Yet the Palestinian presence in Atlanta ‘will help heal wounds and erase some of the sour images of the past,’ he said. That hope certainly was shared by the heads of the Israeli and Palestinian delegations, who came together spontaneously during last week’s Opening Ceremony to shake hands, exchange pins and take pictures.

It marked the first meeting of the Middle Eastern neighbors on a field of sport. ‘It was very important because governments have to listen to the wishes of the people, and sports are the best representatives of the people,’ said Muammar Bississo, the Palestinian chef de mission.

Added his Israeli counterpart, Efraim Zinger, ‘We hope we’ll be able to contribute something to relations in our region.’ Zinger said the president of Israel’s Olympic Committee has invited the Palestinians to his Tel Aviv headquarters.

The Israeli Olympic delegation pointedly disagreed with the government’s complaint about the use of the name ‘Palestine’ for the Palestinian team. Maraheel and Ehab Salama, a 5,000-meter runner from Gaza, are the team’s only athletes in Atlanta.

Palestinian officials said a third athlete, boxer Rashid Judeh, was barred from competing here by boxing officials who said he lacked sufficient international experience.

The size of the first Palestinian squad is due in equal parts to the virtual lack of athletic facilities in the West Bank and Gaza and to Israel’s refusal to allow Palestinians who claim Jerusalem as their address to compete in the Olympics. The status of Jerusalem is to be resolved in future negotiations.

But the athletes are thrilled to be here and Atlanta’s small Palestinian community is delighted to have them. At a Gwinnett restaurant last week, Atlanta businessman Amin Ghanem hosted a reception for the Palestinian delegation and talked excitedly about his reunion with a first cousin he had not seen since they were children in Gaza 50 years ago.

The cousin, Abdul-hamid Ghanem is the deputy chef de mission for the Palestinians. ‘You know, this represents something so special to us,’ Amin Ghanem said. ‘It is something that cannot be taken away.’ The runners’ expectations are on a different level from many of their competitors. They put on spiked track shoes for the first time 15 days ago.

‘In Gaza, we ran either in sneakers or barefoot,’ Salama said. Describing the difference between practice facilities in Atlanta and the Gaza Strip, Maraheel said, ‘It’s like from heaven to Earth.’ Salama, wearing sandals to an interview, nursed a painful-looking sore on his left foot.

But his teammate said the wound would not keep him out of the race. Said Maraheel, ‘Even if it was amputated, he would run.’”

OPENING CELEBRATION: Palestinian athletes perform in the parade of nations under their own flag. (Rich Addicks / Staff)

The host city’s own paper on the same two runners, and it carries three things the syndicated column does not. A third athlete existed: the boxer Rashid Judeh, barred from competing by boxing officials who said he lacked international experience. The squad was two men, the paper says, in equal parts because there were almost no athletic facilities in the West Bank and Gaza and because Israel would not let Palestinians who give Jerusalem as their address compete at all. And the Israeli Olympic delegation pointedly disagreed with its own government’s complaint about the use of the name ‘Palestine’ for the team, then shook hands with the Palestinian delegation at the opening ceremony and exchanged pins. The paper also spells the flagbearer Maraheel where the syndicated column spells him Marahil, and Salama’s first name Ehab where the column has Ihab.

CP-1996-012 →

· The Arizona Republic · Phoenix · page 1

Netanyahu’s 450 ‘security reasons’

Concern for future of settlers stalls withdrawal from Hebron

The Associated Press, Hebron

“HEBRON, West Bank — When 4-year-old Yiska Federman wanders out to play, Israeli soldiers keep watch from a sandbagged guard post on her doorstep and from a nearby rooftop… Yiska and the rest of Hebron’s 450 Jews are the ‘security reasons’ Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu cites when he balks at fulfilling Israel’s promise to withdraw from most of this West Bank town, where 94,000 Palestinians wait impatiently for self-rule… ‘They live in ghettos, and they don’t want any relations with Arabs,’ said Samira Sarabateh, a Palestinian mother of nine.

‘We don’t want any relations with them either, because they came and stole our land and our houses and attacked us… I don’t believe there’s going to be any peace with these settlers.

At the end, it’s just us or them.’… Under the existing agreements, Israel was supposed to pull its troops out of 80 percent of Hebron by last March… Soldiers would remain to protect the 52 Jewish families who live in six tiny enclaves in the city… In Hebron, normal means buses with bulletproof windows and guns tucked in the waistband of most male settlers’ pants.

It means a maze of cement blocks and strips of metal spikes put up by the army in an attempt to separate Jews and Arabs in the wake of the 1994 massacre of 29 Palestinian worshipers by a settler at the Tomb of the Patriarchs… ‘I think there should be no Palestinian weapons in Hebron at all — not one,’ said settler Orit Strook… At age 3, Yiska saw a Palestinian stab and wound a settler and another settler shoot the Palestinian dead.

‘Since then, she knows that the Arabs are our enemies,’ her mother said.”

“For young West Bank settlers, like David Federman, 2, and his sister, Sapir, 3, a soldier is a more familiar figure than an ice-cream man. The children, and their elder sister, Yiska, 4, play under the watchful eye of Israeli soldiers every day.” (Will Yurman/Associated Press)

Back in quotation marks, attached to a name, with a number on it. The settlers are given as much room on the page as the Palestinians, and the record now holds both.

CP-1996-003 →

· Los Angeles Times · page A12

Jordanian King Visits W. Bank to Back Arafat

Mideast: Trip is Hussein's first to area in nearly 30 years. He says he wanted to urge on talks with Israel.

By REBECCA TROUNSON, TIMES STAFF WRITER

JERICHO, West Bank—King Hussein offered a dramatic gesture Tuesday in support of Palestinian Authority President Yasser Arafat, as the Jordanian monarch made his first public visit to the West Bank in almost 30 years to discuss the troubled Mideast peace process.

Hussein, the first Arab leader to travel to this autonomous Palestinian area, said his landmark visit was intended to help speed the pace of Israeli-Palestinian negotiations over Israel's overdue withdrawal of its troops from the West Bank city of Hebron.

But the king, who has been critical of Israeli delays in the Hebron redeployment, said he was not trying to pressure the government of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. “The problem lies in the slow pace of implementing what has been agreed upon,” Hussein said at a news conference with Arafat.

Arafat and Hussein—whose relationship has often been stormy—addressed each other warmly Tuesday as they stood at neighboring lecterns, praising each other for their efforts for peace. They also were united in their insistence that Israel should move quickly on the issue of Hebron. “We have one position,” Arafat said, looking toward the king.

“We have a complete understanding that there should be the implementation of everything that has been agreed upon.” The king's visit came as negotiations over Hebron reached a critical stage.

Israeli and Palestinian negotiators held another round of intensive, small-group discussions in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem on Tuesday, and formal negotiations were expected to resume soon, perhaps as early as today in the Egyptian resort of Taba. But the two sides offered differing accounts of their progress. Arafat's own assessment was gloomy.

“Until this point, there is no move forward in the negotiations,” he told reporters at his headquarters in this dusty desert town. “We don't ask the impossible. We want what was signed to be implemented on the ground.”

Yasser Arafat salutes during ceremony welcoming King Hussein.

CP-1996-030 →

· The New York Times · New York

Netanyahu, Scorning Critics, Visits West Bank Settlement

By Serge Schmemann

JERUSALEM, Nov. 26 — Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu paid his first official visit to Jewish settlements in the West Bank today, adding new fuel to steadily rising tensions with the Palestinians. While the Prime Minister’s visit in itself was not unusual, since Labor Government leaders had also visited the settlements and the settlers are part of Mr.

Netanyahu’s right-wing constituency, it came after a tense confrontation around a settlement in the Gaza Strip, and against a steady drumbeat of recriminations over the deadlock in the talks over the future of the West Bank city of Hebron. Greeted by schoolchildren in the large settlement of Ariel, and by chanting religion students in nearby Eli, Mr.

Netanyahu issued a combative retort to critics of the settlements at home and abroad. “A government was elected which says it will maintain communities in Judea and Samaria, and the Prime Minister shouldn’t visit these communities?” he asked rhetorically, using the biblical terms for the West Bank.

“What, don’t you understand that there were elections in Israel? The Arab world doesn’t understand that there were elections in Israel? “And why shouldn’t settlements develop here?” he continued. “Is somebody stopping the development of the Arab communities nearby? Am I preventing that? Am I choking them?

Am I telling them don’t build houses, don’t build schools?” The statement won predictable plaudits from the settlers, who have been increasingly restive in the first months of Mr. Netanyahu’s administration as he appeared reluctant to approve a major new settlement drive and, in recent weeks, concentrated on negotiating an Israeli withdrawal from Hebron.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu paid his first official visit to Jewish settlements in the West Bank yesterday, adding to tensions with the Palestinians. In Ariel, he talked to the Israeli Army’s area commander. (Agence France-Presse)

Date check: The running head reads THE NEW YORK TIMES INTERNATIONAL WEDNESDAY, NOVE… — the rest of the date runs off the right edge of the scan. The dateline reads “JERUSALEM, Nov. 26”, and November 27, 1996 was a Wednesday, so the slide date is consistent with what is legible, but the printed date is only partly visible.

CP-1996-022 →

· Delaware Gazette · Delaware · page 1

Killings don’t deter Netanyahu

Israeli woman, son slain in drive-by shooting

Associated Press, Beit El, West Bank

BEIT EL, West Bank — Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu praised Jewish settlers today as “heroes” and promised to strengthen settlements in the West Bank after a woman and her 12-year-old son were killed in a drive-by shooting.

The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a radical Palestinian group opposed to the Israeli-Palestinian peace agreements, claimed responsibility for the shootings and linked them to Israel’s settlement policies.

Eeta Tzur, 42, and her son Efraim were killed Wednesday evening when gunmen sprayed bullets at their car near the Jewish settlement of Beit El, then sped into the Palestinian-controlled town of Ramallah. “The roots of the Jewish people are rooted in the land of Beit El,” Netanyahu, his voice shaking with emotion, said at their funeral today.

“These roots not only will not be uprooted, they will be deepened.” “Our answer to these murderers … is that we are staying here,” he said. “We are building here. We live here. You will not uproot us from here.” Netanyahu also demanded the Palestinians help catch the gunmen.

Israeli troops clamped a closure on Ramallah, barring anyone from leaving or entering… Palestinian sources said Palestinian police arrested seven PFLP activists in Ramallah today. Israel’s Army radio said 15 activists were arrested. Thousands of people attended the Tzurs’ funeral in Beit El.

Netanyahu praised them as “pioneers, heroes of our time.” He denounced the “campaign of slander” against settlers in Israel and abroad, and said: “It is time to say that there is no one better than them.” Tzur’s husband, Yoel, and four of their children were injured in the shooting.

Yoel Tzur, one of the founders of the Beit El settlement, told Israel radio the family was attacked as they returned home from visiting relatives. Tzur said he saw a car turn around and a man take out a Kalashnikov rifle and start firing. Tzur then waved down a passing Palestinian who drove him to get help.

Tzur blamed the shooting on the “stupid autonomy accord” with the Palestinians and urged Netanyahu to respond to every attack by expanding Jewish settlements.

Arafat did not respond to reporters’ questions today on the slaying, but his Palestinian Authority condemned the attack, saying it will “give the Israeli government a pretext to delay the implementation of the peace process.”

“Israeli police examine a bullet-riddled car Wednesday after gunmen shot at the vehicle carrying an Israeli family near the Beit El settlement. A woman and her 12-year-old son were killed in the shooting. A radical Palestinian group claimed responsibility for the attack.” AP

An Israeli mother and her twelve-year-old son killed, named and mourned at length. The same column records that the wounded father was driven to get help by a Palestinian who stopped for him.

CP-1996-005 →

· The New York Times

Netanyahu’s Hebron Dilemma

By Geoffrey Wheatcroft

LONDON Weeks of wrangling about whether Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel will — or should — agree to a partial withdrawal of Israeli troops from Hebron have been intensified by his decision to increase economic aid to the Jewish settlements and by the murder of a Jewish woman and her child near Ramallah, another West Bank city.

Amid all this, a fascinating statement by one of Israel’s spiritual leaders has gone virtually unnoticed. Speaking in Hebron recently, Rabbi Eliahu Bakshi-Doron, the Sephardic Chief Rabbi, said it was preferable for several hundred Jews to remain in the city, with its shades of the patriarchs.

“However,” he said, “if it is impossible to insure their security there, it is forbidden for them to remain.” He continued: “Pikuah Nefesh” — the preservation of life — “supersedes everything, including the mitzvah of settling the land.”

His surprising words were just as surprisingly endorsed by Rabbi Moshe Gafni of the ultra-Orthodox Degel Hatorah Party, who said there was no religious reason why settlers should stay in Hebron: “In an area where there is a small group of Jews, they should be evacuated for their own safety.”

Rabbi Gafni was attacked by the leader of his own party, Rabbi Avraham Ravitz, who called his colleague “irresponsible.” Rabbi Ravitz said, “Sometimes, you think something that you shouldn’t say out loud.”

This rabbinical dispute casts an unusual light on the divisions in Israel, which have become more bitter than ever since the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin. A poll in late November showed 42 percent worrying about “civil war” in Israel. Unlike many Jewish settlers, those in Hebron are almost all religious fundamentalists.

Some openly venerate the memory of Baruch Goldstein, who killed 29 worshipers in a mosque in 1994, and some don’t conceal their admiration for Rabin’s assassin. This marks a longstanding rift. Zionism was originally a secular movement, and most Israelis are not observant Jews.

Many resent the disproportionate influence religious groups exert and, in particular, the huge effort and expense that goes into guarding the fewer than 500 settlers living amid 200,000 hostile Palestinians in Hebron.

CP-1996-028 →

· The Missoulian

Settlers, Palestinians clash in Hebron as tensions rise

HEBRON, West Bank (AP) — A fight between settlers and schoolchildren escalated into a melee between hundreds of Israelis and Palestinians in Hebron on Saturday, and a U.S. mediator returned to the region to revive negotiations over the troubled city.

U.S. envoy Dennis Ross was to meet with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat late Saturday or Sunday. Peace talks are deadlocked over a long-delayed Israeli troop withdrawal from Hebron, where 500 Jewish settlers live amid 130,000 Palestinians.

On Friday, Arafat accused Ross of being biased in favor of the Israelis, and Palestinian officials said they doubted he could jump-start the talks. In Hebron, Israeli soldiers in helmets, with guns cocked, hit, kicked and punched Palestinians after fights broke out near Jewish settlements in Hebron's Old City.

Reporters saw at least one Palestinian beaten unconscious, and another bleeding from his nose and mouth. Several Palestinian youths pelted the soldiers with stones and tomatoes. Settlers clapped and cheered as the soldiers pushed the Palestinians away. The fighting broke out along the main road running beside the settlements.

Some 200 Jewish settlers, many of them armed, exchanged blows and insults with 100 Palestinian residents before Israeli troops intervened. It was unclear what sparked the confrontations.

Palestinians try to prevent an Israeli soldier arresting a youth accused of throwing stones during clashes between Jewish settlers. Palestinians and Israeli soldiers in the occupied West Bank town of Hebron Saturday. The delayed partial pullout of Israeli troops from the majority Palestinian town is opposed by militant rightwing Jewish settlers. (Associated Press)

CP-1996-026 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore · page 1

Israeli soldier shoots into a crowd in Hebron, injuring six Palestinians

“Zuhair Muhtasseh was among them. He saw an Israeli soldier in green fatigues and a black skullcap standing before an army watchtower on the edge of the market. The soldier suddenly aimed his M16 rifle at the crowd. ‘He stood there and started shooting,’ said the 32-year-old Palestinian painter. ‘He finished the first clip.

He was about to put in the second one [when Israeli soldiers] jumped him.’ Struck by the spray of 10 to 16 rounds, some Palestinians fell to the ground. Others clutched their wounds and raced for cover.

Muhtasseh heard many cry ‘Allahu Akbar’ — Arabic for ‘God is great’ — and ‘The settlers are shooting us.’… Muhtasseh, the Palestinian painter, said he wasn’t expecting bloodshed.

‘We were hoping that they would hand over Hebron today,’ he said, standing not far from a marketplace stand that bore bullet holes from the gunman’s rifle. But Said Abu Sneineh, 22, was not surprised that a religious Jewish settler would attack Palestinians.

It was another religious Jew, physician Baruch Goldstein, who, wearing an army uniform and carrying a machine gun, killed 29 Muslim worshipers at the tomb of the biblical Abraham in 1994… ‘This is not the first [incident].

This is not the last,’ said Sneineh… At a police barricade in Hebron, a young Palestinian and an Israeli soldier stood face to face. ‘This is peace?’ 15-year-old Omar Shahin asked the soldier. ‘There can be peace,’ the soldier replied. ‘There is peace in Tel Aviv,’ said the teen-ager. ‘But not here.’

‘Not yet,’ said the soldier. ‘It takes time. I have a kid your age. Maybe when you’re both older, maybe there will be peace.’”

A printed exchange in which a named Palestinian teenager and an Israeli soldier are both given their own words, and neither is characterized. The headline names the shooter, which most of the death headlines in this archive do not. The eyewitness is a painter.

CP-1997-004 →

· Daily News · New York

Arabs celebrate Hebron self-rule

News Wire Services

HEBRON, West Bank — Hundreds of Palestinian school children waving flags and posters of Yasser Arafat marched through Hebron yesterday to celebrate the start of self-rule… “It was a dream and now we are realizing some of our hopes,” said a smiling Fathi Jarradat as he watched the parade go by.

“What you see here is the foundation of a Palestinian state. I hope now my children will have a better chance than I ever did.”

The dateline is HEBRON, West Bank. Occupied has gone. Two other things happen on this page: the headline says Arabs while the story says Palestinian six times, and Jibril Rajoub is quoted on the 500 Jewish settlers living amid Hebron's 140,000 Palestinians.

CP-1997-007 →

· Concord Monitor · Concord · page A8

Palestinians celebrate in Hebron; settlers stay defiant

20% of city still in Israel’s hands

“A woman in a long white dress covered in tiny Palestinian flags danced to a traditional folk song.”

Hebron, the week of the partial redeployment, by Nasser Shiyoukhi for the Associated Press. The main headline is the celebration and the defiance; the fifth of the city Israel kept is the subheading under it.

CP-1997-014 →

· The Boston Globe · Boston, MA · page jump page from A1; page number not printed on the clipping

Israel to require students to take Arabic

New law calls for three years of language study starting in fall

ing this fall, all students will be required to study three years of Arabic. Those behind the move, which has been contemplated for some two decades and was announced to little fanfare several weeks ago, see it in larger, geopolitical terms.

“If Israeli kids have to learn Arabic, it will make them start seeing Arabs as people to live with, as their neighbors, and not just as the other side of the Arab-Israeli conflict,” said Shlomo Allon, the Education Ministry’s coordinator of Arabic studies. In some ways, it seems extraordinary that the move has taken this long.

Arabic is, along with Hebrew, one of Israel’s official languages. Street signs and television subtitles in Arabic are common and there are 900,000 Israeli Arabs, along with 4.7 million Jews. Tens of millions of Arabic speakers live in the bordering Palestinian areas, Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon. “It’s about time,” said Azmi Bishara, a member of the Palestinian parliament.

“The reality is that Israelis live in an Arab region. They’ll continue to live here, and that means they’ll continue to live with Arabs.” Yet few Israeli Jews, especially among those born here, can read or speak Arabic. When they consider foreign language study, most youngsters choose English, which has become the international language, or French, which is considered chic.

But with the Middle East peace process begun in 1991, Arabic has developed a new, if not yet robust, following. “I’m learning Arabic, in essence, for the future,” said Uri Weiss, 17, a student in a religious Jerusalem high school, his colorful skullcap pinned to closely cropped hair. “I chose to study it.

It’s not easy, but I hope there will be peace and I will be able to use it.” Yaffa Rothstein said that in 18 years as an Arabic instructor in a Jerusalem high school, she has witnessed its metamorphosis from a subject of trivial significance into one that many students deem useful. “The attitude has changed,” she observed.

“Since the peace talks began, people have begun thinking it is important.” And with the de facto end of the Arab economic boycott on trade with Israel, another incentive has appeared. “Students no longer see Arabic as a language of war; they see it as a key to business with their Arab neighbors,” said Rothstein.

In Israel’s early days, Arabic was often studied by those seeking jobs in intelligence. In recent years, it has been slowly phased in to schools for more general consumption. But it has a way to go before being widely welcomed. “You don’t need to talk with them.

You need to fight with them,” remarked Gaby Spitzer, a 14-year-old Jerusalem high school student who says he hates his Arabic class. “It’s like, because everyone hates it, you should hate it too. There’s a stigma. Whoever knows it is a nerd because no one needs to know it.”

“Many young people approach the Arabic language in the same way they approach Arab people, as terrorists and enemies,” lamented Reuven Gal, a psychologist who conducted a much-publicized survey of 2,743 Jewish students and found that 37 percent of Israeli schoolchildren say they hate Arabs.

This is the richest terminology clipping in the batch and the clearest single answer to Maria’s question. “Israeli Arabs” appears exactly once, as a population count — 900,000 of them, set against 4.7 million Jews — and then the article drops the compound entirely and says “Arabs” for the remaining seven uses, including in the sentence where it concedes they are a fifth of the country. The people counted are given one speaker, and the paper files him in the wrong legislature.

CP-1997-036 →

· The Winchester Sun · page 8

More than 200,000 at Al Aqsa Mosque for Ramadan

By Said Ghazali, Associated Press Writer

JERUSALEM (AP) — Hundreds of thousands of Muslims prayed at the Al Aqsa Mosque under heavy Israeli security Friday to mark the fourth Friday of Ramadan. Their prayer leader accused Israel of harassing Palestinians in Jerusalem. Some 3,000 Israeli police and border forces patrolled in and around the walled Old City where the mosque and other Muslim shrines are located.

Police closed downtown streets to cars and stopped many Palestinian pedestrians for identity checks. Ramadan, the Muslim month of fasting, is a time of increased religious fervor for Muslims and Israel is concerned about possible attacks by Islamic militants.

For Friday prayers during Ramadan, Israeli troops eased their long-standing restrictions barring most Palestinians from the West Bank and Gaza Strip from entering Israel. Palestinians over the age of 30 were let through army checkpoints ringing Jerusalem.

Abdallah Harb, an Islamic court judge from the West Bank town of Ramallah, said he was turned away by troops on the outskirts of Jerusalem because he is 29. Harb, dressed in a white robe and prayer cap, said he found a back road and entered the city anyway.

The Al Aqsa and Dome of the Rock mosques sit on a raised platform known to Muslims as Haram as-Sharif, or Noble Sanctuary, and to Jews as the Temple Mount. The mosques were built on the remains of the Jewish Temple destroyed by the Romans in 70 AD. More than 200,000 worshipers today knelt in neat rows, filling the mosques and courtyards of the 11-acre compound.

A police helicopter hovered above. Their prayer leader, Yousef Abu Sneineh, accused Israel’s government of intransigence. “The government doesn’t care about peace,” Abu Sneineh said in his sermon. “It is offering peace for peace and not land for peace.”

Abu Sneineh also complained of Israeli restrictions on Palestinians living in Jerusalem, a city of 405,000 Jews and 155,000 Arabs. He said hundreds of Palestinians who lived abroad temporarily had their Jerusalem residency permits revoked by the Israeli government in an attempt to reduce the number of Arabs in the city.

“They (the Israelis) have not stopped their harassment against our Muslim people,” Abu Sneineh said. He also said the Arab world, especially Persian Gulf countries, have done little to strengthen the Palestinian claim to east Jerusalem, the sector captured by Israel from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast war.

Date check: the folio line reads “8 — Saturday, February 1, 1997” at the left and “The Winchester Sun” at the right — matches both the slide date and pub

CP-1997-024 →

· South Florida Sun Sentinel · Fort Lauderdale

Israel: Women to go free

Middle East

JERUSALEM

JERUSALEM — Twenty-four Palestinian women held in Israeli jails on security offenses will be released by next week, an Israeli official said Friday. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told his Cabinet on Friday that the women would be released in line with Israeli promises made in last month's agreement on a troop withdrawal from the West Bank town of Hebron.

A world brief. The headline gives Israel the subject and the verb; the twenty-four women are what Israel does something to.

CP-1997-008 →

· Midland Reporter Telegram · Midland · page 5A

Israel releases 7 Palestinian women prisoners after year of haggling

By Ethan Bronner, The Boston Globe

RAMALLAH, West Bank — They came to hang balloons and flags and posters of Yasser Arafat and eat sweets and congratulate each other on the imminent release from an Israeli jail of a woman they consider a national symbol and hero.

“She fought occupation by the gun and we are proud of her for doing what every Palestinian girl wants to do,” said Jihad Taha, 23, as she waited to greet Abir Wehaidi, freed by Israel Tuesday after 4 1/2 years as part of a peace accord. Thirty other Palestinian women were freed along with Wehaidi.

Not 10 miles away, outside a religious school for boys in the Jewish settlement of Ofra, a very different gathering was held. Psalms were recited and angry speeches made at a small park dedicated Tuesday in memory of Zvi Klein, the settler who was Wehaidi's victim in 1991.

“They may free killers but we will not be broken,” Ora Klein, his widow, told about 100 pupils and guests. “We will continue to build and plant roots throughout the land of Israel.”

The release of the women prisoners, following Israel's withdrawal from most of the city of Hebron, marks the second move by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to fulfill pledges made by the government that preceded his, suggesting that the Middle East peace process is again gaining momentum.

But the glorification of violent struggle by some Palestinian supporters of the women and the celebration of West Bank Jewish settlement indicate how volatile the situation remains. This volatility becomes all the more striking when one realizes that Wehaidi did not kill Klein directly.

In fact, according to eyewitness testimony and the ruling of the Israeli military court, she was not at the scene. It was the armed cell she organized that carried out the drive-by shooting on a rainy December afternoon in 1991, a month after the Middle East peace conference in Madrid that launched a new era in the region.

She was sentenced to 17 years in prison; the man who pulled the trigger was put away for life. Yet Wehaidi is celebrated among Palestinians precisely for being a courageous resistence fighter, a woman of the armed struggle. Her handsome face and dark hair have graced Palestinian magazine covers, greeting cards and posters.

Drawings of her show a Kalashnikov rifle and a flag of Palestine. Arafat has often cited her as a model. As the last women to be released were taken from the prison by bus to Ramallah, Arafat waited to greet them. “No doubt this will help the relationship between the two peoples,” he said of the release.

The daughter of a wealthy, politically active Palestinian family, Wehaidi is by far the best known of the Palestinian women who were held in Israeli prison, although two others were also sentenced in connection with killings. A former engineering student at nearby Bir Zeit University, Wehaidi had been an activist for years before her arrest.

“I know she came from what is called a good family, that she acted out of ideology,” remarked Ora Klein, when asked about Wehaidi. Like the others who were freed, Wehaidi signed a pledge not to engage in violence. But this was not new for her.

A loyal member of Arafat's mainstream Fatah faction, she told the Associated Press in a prison interview last year, “Circumstances are different now. There is no need for armed struggle.”

Her crime was committed before the 1993 Palestinian-Israeli accord that brought Arafat to the Gaza Strip and handed over to the Palestinian Authority control of most of the Palestinian population centers.

Her freedom was agreed to in September 1995 under the next stage of that accord, but delayed when President Ezer Weizman refused to sign the release of those said to have “blood on their hands.” The other women prisoners refused to leave in solidarity.

After last September's battles between Israeli and Palestinian troops following the election of Netanyahu and his opening of an archeological tunnel in Jerusalem that Muslims considered a threat, Weizman met Arafat and committed to signing the releases. And after the Hebron pullback last month, Netanyahu also agreed to go ahead with freeing the women.

Wehaidi's mother, Maisoun, a senior official in the Palestinian social welfare ministry, said in an interview at her house that Abir began her activism at age 7 when she saw her father arrested and jailed for two years.

The daughter visited him in prison and soon took part in numerous demonstrations, volunteering as a young teen-ager to visit the families of killed or jailed Palestinians. “Her struggle is different now,” said Maisoun Wehaidi, the mother of six. “Now she wants to help in building her country. She is planning to work with children when she gets out.”

Asked what she would say to Ora Klein today, Maisoun Wehaidi said she would urge her “to look forward, not back, to start a new beginning for the sake of all our children. We must put an end to the harm and pain.” Ora Klein says her pain can not be ended so easily. “You don't free a killer of an innocent man,” she said in a brief interview at the park dedication ceremony.

“We know that they are planning a big celebration. We know that Arafat always points to her as a symbol of their struggle against the enemy, meaning us. I am very disappointed in Benjamin Netanyahu for doing this.” She was not alone in that feeling Tuesday.

Across Israel's right wing, there was anger and disappointment in Netanyahu, who was scheduled to leave Wednesday for a visit to Washington. Hanan Porat, a parliament member from the National Religious Party, said, Tuesday “The most shocking thing of all is that we, the people of Israel, a nation of justice and decency, are doing this and descending to their level.”

As in the Hebron redeployment, the fact that this step was taken by a government elected for its hawkishness seems to have taken the wind from the sails of those Israelis who oppose the peace process with the Palestinians. About 3,000 Palestinian men still remain behind Israeli bars, mostly for anti-Israel activism.

And the young women who gathered at the Wehaidi home Tuesday said their joy was only partial because of all those prisoners left behind. “The time for guns is not over,” said Mona Awad, 24. “There is still occupation. They still kill us.”

Still handcuffed, one of 31 Palestinian women prisoners freed by Israeli authorities waves to waiting relatives upon leaving the Israeli Tel Mond prison by bus Tuesday night. Several of the women prisoners had been involved in deadly attacks on Israel. (AP Laserphoto)

The headline says seven. The story and the photograph caption both say thirty-one. The discrepancy is logged, not resolved. This story also records what happened to the twenty-one women who refused release in October 1995.

CP-1997-009 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Frees 30 Arab Women In Long-Delayed Peace Move

Joel Greenberg

“The rest of the women refused to be freed until all of them were released.”

Israel freed 30 Palestinian women last night. Suad al-Jubeh, of East Jerusalem, 23, was greeted by her father, Muhammed.

Sixteen months after they refused, the rest are let out. Suad al-Jubeh, 23, of East Jerusalem, is met by her father Muhammed. The refusal in 1995 and the release in 1997 are the same story, and the archive now holds both ends of it.

CP-1997-010 →

· The New York Times · New York, NY

Empire State Gunman’s Note: Kill ‘Zionists’

By MATTHEW PURDY

The gunman who opened fire on the observation deck of the Empire State Building on Sunday said in a letter found on his body that he planned his attack as revenge for the treatment of Palestinians by the United States, Israel and other countries.

“The Zionists are the paw that carried out their savage aggression,” wrote Ali Abu Kamal, the 69-year-old English teacher from Gaza who shot seven people before killing himself Sunday afternoon. “My restless aspiration is to murder as many of them as possible, and I have decided to strike at their own den in New York, and at the very Empire State Building in particular.”

Law enforcement officials said they have found no evidence to support the contention of Mr. Abu Kamal’s family that he was distressed at having been swindled out of hundreds or thousands of dollars of his life’s savings, and the officials said they doubted the money ever existed. They also said they had found no indication that Mr.

Abu Kamal acted in concert with a terrorist group or any accomplices. Instead, investigators are left to search for motivation in Mr. Abu Kamal’s two-page letter, titled “Charter of Honour,” which identifies four groups of “bitter enemies” who he said “must be annihilated & exterminated” for misdeeds both political and personal.

The “enemies” include a group of students who he said attacked him in 1993 because he “didn’t agree to their command asking me to help them cheat in the final examination,” students in the Ukraine who he said beat his son and stole $250 from him and an Egyptian police officer who he said beat him for “pass- … [NOT TRANSCRIBED IN FULL — SEE needs_rescan AND note.

Only what I can read with certainty is given below.] RAMPAGE AT THE EMPIRE STATE BUILDING: Messages Behind the Violence OVERVIEW Gunman Wanted to Kill ‘Zionists,’ His Note Says Continued From Page A1 port formalities.” [The rest of the jump — three narrow columns down the right-hand edge of the page — is below the resolution this scan can carry and is NOT transcribed.

The other articles sharing the clipping, which are separate journalism and not part of CP-1997-035, are: “THE LETTER — ‘My Restless Aspiration Is to Murder’”, printing the text of the letter released by City Hall beside a photograph of the handwritten “Charter of Honour” and signed at its foot by a relative of Ali Abu Kamal; “THE WEAPON — Calls for Stricter Gun Control Laws Increase in Aftermath of Shooting”, By FRANK BRUNI; and “THE TOURISTS — Observation Deck Draws Thousands as It Reopens”, By BRUCE WEBER, with a photograph of visitors on the 86th-floor deck.]

Clean clipping. The caption of the accompanying photograph (“A VICTIM IS REMEMBERED As the 86th-floor observation deck reopened yesterday at the Empire State Building, flowers and a card honored a slain musician. Page B3.”, credit “Thomas Dallal for The New York Times”) belongs to this article but is a caption, not body text, so it is excluded from the excerpt and recorded here. Jump line reads “Continued on Page B3, Column 5”. No Israeli-Arab vocabulary.

CP-1997-035 →

· South Florida Sun Sentinel · Fort Lauderdale · page 1

Israeli troops firebombed

Thirteen soldiers hurt when truck hit

By Joel Greenberg, The New York Times, Jalazoun

JALAZOUN, West Bank — An army truck carrying Israeli soldiers plunged off an embankment, overturned and burned Wednesday near this Palestinian refugee camp after a firebomb was thrown through its windshield.

The driver and 12 soldiers were hurt in the attack… A firetruck from Ramallah was the first to arrive at the scene after it was called by Palestinians, and its crew extinguished the flames… At the neighboring Jewish settlement of Itamar, two residents were arrested after they were accused of beating a disabled Palestinian after their car was stoned.

The stone-throwers fled, leaving behind the disabled man, who complained that he was beaten, and later identified the two residents to Israeli police.… Israeli Channel 2 television reported on Wednesday that Defense Minister Yitzhak Mordechai had approved plans to build thousands of apartments in Jewish settlements in the West Bank.

Israeli soldiers investigate the hulk of an army truck that was firebombed on Wednesday near a Palestinian refugee camp.

One sentence, in the middle of a story about a burned army truck: the stone-throwers ran and left behind the one man who could not, and he is the only witness who could identify anybody. He is not named. The same page carries an Associated Press story about a joint Israeli-Palestinian Sesame Street, in which two puppets shout the names of hummus and falafel at each other.

CP-1997-005 →

· Concord Monitor · Concord

Israel accused of taking living rights from Palestinians

“Away from the bulldozers and stone-throwing, another battle for Jerusalem is under way. Palestinian and Israeli human rights groups charge that Israel is quietly and deliberately revoking…”

Residency revocation in Jerusalem, reported as a quieter battle than the one with bulldozers. The phrase in the headline is living rights.

CP-1997-015 →

· estimated · Corvallis Gazette-Times · Corvallis

Groups: Rights to Jerusalem revoked

Human rights groups say Israel is trying to tighten its grip on the city

By Hilary Appelman, The Associated Press

JERUSALEM — Away from the bulldozers and stone-throwing, another battle for Jerusalem is under way. Palestinians and Israeli human rights groups charge that Israel is quietly and deliberately revoking residency rights of Palestinians who live in Jerusalem in order to strengthen its grip on the disputed city.

The policy is not new: Palestinians who don’t become Israeli citizens and who move outside the city — even to the West Bank — can lose their residency permits, which means they cannot legally return to live in Jerusalem. Only now, the groups say, the Israeli government is enforcing the policy with new vigor.

Palestinians returning after living elsewhere have been notified that their permits have expired and they have 15 days to get out. “The idea is simple,” Yuval Ginbar of the Israeli group Betselem said Monday. “Israel will do anything to make Palestinians leave Jerusalem.”

Betselem and Hamoked, another Israeli human rights group, issued a report Monday accusing Israel of revoking the rights of hundreds, perhaps thousands, of Palestinians to live in Jerusalem during the past 18 months.

Betselem’s Yael Stein said the policy was part of the government’s goal to “decrease the number of Palestinians and increase the number of Jews living in the city.”

President Bill Clinton meets with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the Oval Office of the White House Monday. The president sought to build a bridge between Israelis and Palestinians. (RUTH FREMSON/Associated Press)

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is cropped to the article and its photograph. The story refers to a report issued “Monday” and a Clinton–Netanyahu Oval Office meeting on “Monday”; April 7, 1997 was a Monday, consistent with an April 8, 1997 paper, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1997-021 →

· South Florida Sun Sentinel · Fort Lauderdale · page 1

Israeli soldiers and Palestinian protesters clash at close range

“Israeli soldiers and Palestinian protesters clash at close range in Hebron, West Bank. The clash occurred after the funeral of a Palestinian killed Tuesday.”

“Israeli soldiers and Palestinian protesters clash at close range on Wednesday in Hebron, West Bank. The clash occurred after the funeral of a Palestinian killed Tuesday.” AP photo / Sharon Abady

A photograph and its caption; no body text on the clipping. The man whose funeral it was is not named.

CP-1997-001 →

· The New York Times · New York

In Israel, Coercing Prisoners Is Becoming Law of the Land

The Use of Force

Serge Schmemann

“He was kept sleepless in contorted and excruciating positions with a stinking bag over his head, he was threatened, he was beaten and he was subjected to violent shaking until he passed out.”

A special report, and the clearest single account of the Landau regime in the archive. It names what Israel officially calls the practice — moderate physical pressure — says that human rights groups call it torture, and states that the Israeli Supreme Court has regularly condoned it. The man it opens on is a twenty-year-old student called George, arrested at a checkpoint between Jerusalem and Bethlehem in December 1995. Filed the day the United Nations Committee Against Torture summoned Israel to an extraordinary hearing in Geneva.

CP-1997-011 →

· The New York Times · New York

Execution and Torture

A. M. Rosenthal

“Though the world refused to witness, the death warning was probably…”

A New York Times columnist on the same Geneva hearing, the day after the special report.

CP-1997-012 →

· The New York Times

Two Palestinian Suspects Held in Death of Arab Real Estate Dealer

By JOEL GREENBERG

JERUSALEM, May 15 — The Israeli police said today that they were holding a Palestinian man and woman on suspicion of involvement in the killing of an Arab real estate dealer accused of selling land to Jews.

An Israeli court here ordered them detained for questioning in the killing of the dealer, Farid Bashiti, 70, an East Jerusalem resident, whose bludgeoned and bound body was found last Friday in the Palestinian-ruled West Bank town of Ramallah.

The killing followed an announcement by the Palestinian Authority on May 5 that it would impose the death sentence on Palestinians convicted of selling land to Jews. An Israeli police spokesman identified the male suspect as Nasser al-Anani, an officer in the Ramallah police who lives in Jerusalem.

The woman was identified as Nadia Dabash, 33, a real estate agent from Jerusalem. Palestinians said Mr. Anani, 36, was a lawyer employed by the Ramallah police. Questioned by reporters as he was led into court, he denied that he had taken Mr. Bashiti to Ramallah and said he did not know who had. His lawyer said that his client was not involved in the killing.

Miss Dabash made no statement. Mr. Bashiti’s body was found hours after he met Miss Dabash at a Jerusalem hotel for what his relatives said was a business appointment. Israeli security officials said they suspected that Mr. Bashiti had been lured to Ramallah, where he was killed by Palestinian security men.

“The investigation points in the direction of involvement in one form or another of the Palestinian Authority,” said the chief of the Jerusalem police, Yair Yitzhaki. Palestinian security officials have denied any connection to the slaying, and Mr. Bashiti’s relatives said it might have been related to a personal dispute.

The killing came several days after the Palestinian Authority’s Justice Minister, Freih Abu Middein, announced that swift death sentences would be imposed on Arabs convicted of selling land to Jews.

CP-1997-033 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinian Rights Monitor Charges Torture of Prisoners

Serge Schmemann

“A large number of detainees also reported being subjected to ‘shabeh,’ a punishment reportedly commonly used by Israeli interrogators, which involves tying the prisoner for long stretches in an excruciating position.”

The only clipping in the archive that names shabeh. The monitor is Bassem Eid, and the detainees he is reporting on were held by the Palestinian Authority as well as by Israel: of the cases he studied, all began with beatings and twenty-six involved beatings with weapons or batons. His news conference coincided with a Palestinian death in Palestinian custody.

CP-1997-013 →

· The Oregonian · Portland · page 1

Murders linked to land sales reopen an ugly chapter in Israeli-Palestinian history

Trouble in Palestine

Barbara Demick, Knight-Ridder News Service, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM — Ali Jumhour kissed his wife goodbye at 9 a.m. Saturday and headed off to driving school. A few hours later, the 34-year-old waiter was found on a roadside, where he had been unceremoniously dumped with two bullet wounds through the neck.

“God only knows who killed him,” said his widow, Layla, as she sat with grieving family members at the Shofat refugee camp the next day. “If my husband was involved with some kind of illegal deals, I, as his wife, would surely have known.”

But Israeli authorities insist they’ve unraveled the mystery of Jumhour’s murder: They say he fell prey to Palestinian vigilantes who executed him for selling Arab land to Jews. Jumhour is the third suspected land dealer to be murdered in the past month… Palestinian officials adamantly deny involvement.

Nevertheless, the murders have become a cause celebre in Israel, adding fresh venom to the increasingly poisonous relationship between Israeli and Palestinian leaders… “Senior officials of the Palestinian Authority … openly encouraged these murders,” Netanyahu said later on Israel’s army radio.

“This is simply standing the peace process on its head. There cannot be a situation in which residents of Jerusalem are being murdered, and we go on as though nothing had happened.”

At the least, Israeli officials have said, the Palestinian Authority is guilty of creating a climate in which vigilantes are encouraged to summarily execute any Arab suspected of selling land to Jews… Just four days later, the body of 79-year-old Farid Bishiti, a Jerusalem real estate broker, was found bound and gagged, his head split open, near the police station in the West Bank city of Ramallah… The murders reopen a particularly ugly chapter in Jewish-Palestinian relations that dates to the 1930s.

Then, as now, a number of Arabs who sold land to Jews were deemed traitors and summarily murdered… “I can’t believe he was involved in any land sales. They wouldn’t have released him if he’d done anything wrong,” insisted Jumhour’s 27-year-old widow, Layla. “I never heard about him doing anything out of the ordinary.

He went to work. He came home. That was his whole life.”… “I have no problem accepting the death penalty for the one who sells land to the enemy,” Layla Jumhour said.

“Palestinian children join a protest Tuesday against the confiscation of Palestinian land at an Israeli settlement in the southern Gaza Strip. Land disputes are a sore point that have stalled the peace process, and three Palestinian land dealers suspected of selling land to Jews have been killed.” Adel Hana / Associated Press

The page runs four boxes beside the story — U.S. Aid, Marked for Death, Arrest Warrant, Fight Over Schools — and a second article by Karin Laub on corruption in the Palestinian Authority. The widow is quoted three times and named.

CP-1997-002 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Says Arabs Born in Jerusalem Are Aliens

By Joel Greenberg

JERUSALEM, June 11 — Rihab Essawi went to the Israeli Interior Ministry office in East Jerusalem recently to get what she thought would be a routine travel permit for a visit abroad.

Like all Palestinians from East Jerusalem, she had an Israeli identification card, which she presented along with an American passport that she got after studying a few years in the United States. “The clerk took my card and told me to wait,” Mrs. Essawi recalled.

“He came back 15 minutes later and told me: ‘Your residence here has expired because you have American citizenship. You have to leave the country.’ I asked: ‘How long do I have? I have a husband here, and a house.’ He said, ‘Fifteen days.’ ” Mrs.

Essawi, a 47-year-old educator, suddenly found herself an illegal alien in her hometown. She is one of more than 1,000 East Jerusalem Arabs and their relatives whose residency permits have been revoked in the last year and a half. The revocations have accelerated in recent months.

Palestinians and human rights groups say the policy is intended to reduce the Arab population of the city as negotiations on its final status draw near. The United States has been urging Israel to ease up on the policy, as a concession to Arab feelings that might help restart the peace talks.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu hinted recently that the policy might change, but so far the revocations have continued. Israeli officials have long insisted that they are only enforcing the law, and deny any intention of ousting Jerusalem’s 180,000 Arabs.

The revocation of 1,000 residence permits does not mean that many people have left, since many stay on as illegal aliens. But their lives are far more difficult, and they could be expelled if Israel decided to crack down. The 1,000 Arabs whose residency rights were revoked either lived several years outside Jerusalem or had accepted foreign citizenship.

The status of Jerusalem’s Arab population has become part of the struggle over the future of the city, which is perhaps the most difficult issue dividing Israelis and Palestinians. Their talks have stalled since the Israelis began work in March on a new Jewish neighborhood in East Jerusalem, which Palestinians claim as the capital of their hoped-for state.

Israel asserts that all Jerusalem will remain its undivided capital.

Palestinians waited outside the Interior Ministry in East Jerusalem one day last week, carrying papers to prove their residency rights. Arabs say the Israelis are cracking down ahead of talks on Jerusalem’s status. (Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times)

Date check: The running head reads THE NEW YORK TIMES INTERNATIONAL THURSDAY, JUNE — the day of the month and the year run off the right edge of the scan. The dateline reads “JERUSALEM, June 11”, and June 12, 1997 was a Thursday, so the slide date is consistent with what is legible, but the printed date is only partly visible.

CP-1997-022 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Strangers at Home

Joel Greenberg

While Israeli-Palestinian talks remained stalled last week, Israel’s policy of revoking the residence permits of Jerusalem Arabs added to the mistrust. More than 1,000 Arabs have lost residency since January 1996 on the grounds that they lived outside Jerusalem for several years or accepted foreign citizenship.

Ordered to leave Jerusalem within 15 days, most have remained as illegal aliens in their native city. Palestinians accuse Israel of trying to reduce their numbers, and the Palestinians’ claim to East Jerusalem, before talks on the city’s future. Israeli officials say they are only following the law.

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is cropped to this short boxed item. Its reference to talks “last week” and the format are consistent with a Sunday Week in Review summary, and June 15, 1997 was a Sunday, but the printed date could not be read.

CP-1997-023 →

· Lansing State Journal · Lansing · page 1

Arab Americans seek their roots

West Bank experience opens young eyes to the world of their ancestors

By Samar Assad, Associated Press, Ramallah

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Rose Haddad turned heads and triggered sarcastic remarks when she and her American friends got down on their knees in downtown Ramallah to plant flowers and pick up garbage.

Haddad, an 18-year-old from Saginaw, this month was making her first visit to the homeland of her parents and grandparents, along with 13 other young Palestinian Americans… Another day, sitting with new friends from Ramallah, some of the Americans suggested a visit to Jerusalem, 15 minutes away.

“I was surprised to hear the guys sitting with us say they could not go — they needed a permit from Israel,” Haddad said.

“Wow,” I thought.’… “The project is an attempt to get American-born Palestinians acquainted with their roots,” said Samir Mashni… “If they don’t feel part of the city, they will lose their whole culture.” The project is similar to the hundreds of long-established programs that bring young American Jews to Israel to volunteer and study… Palestinian officials blamed the lack of investment on Israeli restrictions — including closures of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, restricted visas and border controls… “I plan to return and work for a couple of years in Ramallah,” said Mashni, a distant relation of Samir Mashni.

“Definitely.”

Far from home: Rose Haddad (center) and her colleagues, Arab Americans volunteering in “Project Hope,” speak with a disabled Palestinian recently at the Abu Rayeh rehabilitation center in the West Bank town of Ramallah.

Three Americans are named in the caption. The Palestinian they have come to meet is not. The culture shock the story records is not the one its headline expects: an eighteen-year-old from Saginaw discovers that her new friends cannot travel fifteen minutes to Jerusalem.

CP-1997-006 →

· Concord Monitor · Concord

Angry Palestinians want their revenge

“A Palestinian boy is carried by a crowd enraged by a Jewish extremist’s anti-Muslim leaflet in the West Bank city of Nablus.”

Thirty thousand marched in Nablus. The headline gives them one motive, revenge, and the photograph underneath it is of a boy being carried.

CP-1997-016 →

· The New York Times · New York

At Palestinian Papers, Money Is as Elusive As Freedom

By JUDITH MILLER

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Just as Palestinians are struggling to establish a state of their own, an independent Palestinian press is fighting to be born. So far, neither effort has been easy.

For Arabic-language Palestinian newspapers in Jerusalem, the neighboring West Bank and the Gaza Strip, political turmoil, censorship and intimidation have combined with soaring paper and printing costs and a severe recession to make publishing an extremely risky venture.

Moreover, competition is fierce among the three leading dailies — for market share, the skimpy number of advertisers, and readers. Israel continues to censor the Jerusalem-based Arabic press, but things are not that different on the Palestinian side of the military checkpoints.

While the Palestinian Authority, Yasir Arafat’s government, does not formally censor newspapers, its corruption and heavy-handed crackdown on Islamic and secular dissent, among other things, have made it increasingly unpopular. Rather than censor, it is inclined to intimidate papers on the rare occasions they report on official abuses.

The Palestinian press law enacted in 1995 ostensibly guarantees a free press — as do most Arab states, at least in theory — and the “absolute right” of every Palestinian “to express his opinion in a free manner either orally, in writing, photography, or drawing.” But self-censorship, editors agree, is often more insidious than official control.

“You can’t have genuine freedom of the press without real democracy,” said Khaled Amayreh, an American-educated columnist who writes for non-Palestinian Arabic-language newspapers and for several English-language journals.

Marwan Abu Zalaf, publisher of Al Quds, in the offices of a West Bank press plant. The paper’s official circulation of 50,000 makes it the largest of the Palestinian dailies.

CP-1997-025 →

· The New York Times · New York · page A6

Israel Steps Up Its Security In Fear of New Bombings

By DOUGLAS JEHL

JERUSALEM, Aug. 3 — As relations between the Israeli and Palestinian leaders continued to fray, a reinforced army of security forces fanned out across Israel today in the face of new signs that Islamic militants may be planning more attacks after a suicide bombing last week.

The huge deployment, which included thousands of army troops, police officers and paramilitary forces, nearly doubled the number of heavily armed police on the streets of Jerusalem alone and added to a sense of unease that left buses mostly empty and shopping centers nearly deserted.

A threat issued in the name of Hamas, the militant group blamed by the authorities for the suicide attack that killed 13 Israelis in a crowded Jerusalem market on Wednesday, warned of further action if Palestinian prisoners were not freed by 9 tonight. The deadline expired without incident.

Israeli officials have said they do not know whether the warning, posted in in the West Bank town of Ramallah the same day as the bombing, was credible. But the chief of the Israeli police, Assaf Hefetz, said the authorities had learned of “a series of details” pointing to the possibility of renewed violence.

And in a sign of the potential for retaliatory strikes, the Israeli authorities said a Palestinian man in his 50’s or 60’s was found shot dead near the Jewish settlement of Carmel in the West Bank this evening. They said Palestinian witnesses had reported that he had been shot from a passing car.

Israel’s Channel 2 television quoted one witness as saying that the car bore the yellow license plates issued to Israelis. The dark mood today was underscored by a stern declaration from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who told his Cabinet during a daylong meeting that Israel would no longer honor its agreements with Yasir Arafat, the Palestinian leader, unless Mr.

Arafat did more to crack down on Islamic militants in territory under Palestinian control. Mr. Netanyahu and Mr. Arafat have adopted an increasingly venomous tone in recent days, accusing each other of bad faith. Today the Prime Minister suggested that the consequences of a breakdown in relations between the two sides could be drastic.

“If Arafat honors his commitments in the agreement, chiefly to fight terrorism, the agreement will survive,” Mr. Netanyahu said of the interim peace accords that Israel first concluded with the Palestinians four years ago. “If he doesn’t, we will not keep up our part of the bargain unequivocally.”

Israeli security forces braced for more bombings yesterday. Officers cleared Jerusalem’s main bus station during what turned out to be a false alarm.

CP-1997-026 →

· The New York Times

Caught in Crackdown, Arabs’ Hopes Lie in Ruins

By JOEL GREENBERG

AL ADEISA, West Bank, Aug. 5 — On a wind-scoured hill near Hebron this afternoon, Fayed Jaradat stood holding his child on the rubble of the house in which he awakened this morning.

It had taken less than four hours for two Israeli bulldozers to reduce the two-story stone structure to chunks of concrete and twisted iron rods, and now dozens of villagers, many of them boys, clambered among the debris. Men loaded a refrigerator and other household goods salvaged from the wreckage onto a pickup truck.

“Israel does not want peace in any way whatsoever,” said Mr. Jaradat, a 28-year-old stone worker and father of five. “They exploited the bombing in Jerusalem and did this without warning.” The destruction of Mr.

Jaradat’s house and two other homes in the Hebron area today were the latest in a series of a dozen demolitions of Arab homes in the West Bank and East Jerusalem since two suicide bombers killed 13 other people and wounded 170 in a Jerusalem market last Wednesday.

Israeli officials said the homes were destroyed because they were built without construction permits, but the officials acknowledge that the demolition campaign carries a political message.

“We are signaling the Palestinian Authority that they will not be able to resume normal life until they take certain measures to combat terrorism,” said a Defense Ministry official, who spoke on condition of anonymity. The demolition policy is not new.

About 90 Arab homes have been torn down this year in the West Bank on the ground that they were built illegally in areas under Israeli control. More than 500 other homes are scheduled for destruction for the same reason, although these demolition orders have occasionally been suspended and then renewed for political reasons.

Now the green light has been given for demolitions, and there have been daily scenes of Israeli bulldozers gnawing into Arab houses under the stunned gaze of their evicted occupants. For Mr. Jaradat, the rude awakening came at 8:45 this morning, when Israeli military officials and police officers arrived at his home and told him they had come to tear it down.

“My wife was rolling up the bedclothes, and some of the children were still sleeping when they came and surrounded the house,” he recalled. “I asked if they were carrying a demolition order, and they said, ‘No — go to your lawyer.’ They told us to get out in a hurry, closed us up in a neighboring house and tossed out our belongings.

I watched the demolition from nearby. I felt hopeless.”

Palestinians gathered around the rubble of the home of Fayed Jaradat in Al Adeisa, West Bank, yesterday. Israeli authorities demolished the house. Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times

CP-1997-029 →

· Concord Monitor · Concord

Palestinians feel backed into a corner

“‘We reject pressure on the Palestinian Authority,’ said Amin Maqboul, a senior Fatah leader in the West Bank… barred from traveling to jobs in Israel, and merchants and farmers…”

Said Ghazali for the Associated Press. Closure, named through what it does to the people who cannot get to work.

CP-1997-017 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago · page 1

Graffiti in the occupied territories

“Two Palestinian boys relax recently on a cart in the crowded Khan Younis refugee camp in the Gaza Strip.” Photo for the Tribune by Will Yurman.

The clipping is the photograph and its caption; the story it belonged to is not on this scan. Arabic graffiti and a Star of David are painted on the wall behind the two boys.

CP-1997-003 →

· The Daily Press

Settlers, road crew clash at site in Hebron

The Associated Press

HEBRON, West Bank — A U.S.-funded project to renovate a street for Palestinian traffic in Hebron became the focus of violent confrontation Tuesday, a week before Secretary of State Madeleine Albright arrives in the region.

Jewish settlers threw stones at Palestinian workers renovating Shuhada Street, a main downtown thoroughfare that passes by two settler enclaves in this West Bank town. They fired pellet guns, smashing the window of a bulldozer.

Renovating the road, which had been demanded by Palestinians, would “endanger our lives and allow for masses of troublemakers to come,” settler leader Noam Arnon said. Israeli police arrested the project manager, David Muirhead of Sherman, Conn., and two Palestinian employees for refusing to cooperate with them.

Muirhead accused police of failing to stop the attack. “I was arrested for holding up the police in arresting the driver,” said Muirhead, who was released on bond with the other two and ordered to appear in court today. The Israeli army closed Shuhada Street to Arab traffic after a Jewish settler killed 29 Muslim worshipers in a Hebron mosque in February 1994.

The street was partially reopened after Israel withdrew troops from most of Hebron last January. The Palestinians demanded the street be fully opened, and as part of the withdrawal agreement, the United States pledged $1 million to fix up the street, which is in the Israeli-controlled area of Hebron.

CP-1997-030 →

· USA Today

Israeli settlers attack road project in Hebron

Jewish settlers threw stones Tuesday at Palestinian workers on a U.S.-funded road project in Hebron. The American project manager and two Palestinian employees were arrested for refusing to cooperate with Israeli police.

The United States is paying $1 million to renovate Shuhada Street, a main thoroughfare that passes in front of two settler enclaves, a project that is supposed to lead to the street’s reopening to Palestinian traffic for the first time in more than three years. The settlers oppose the reopening, claiming it will put them in danger of Palestinian attacks.

Also Tuesday, several thousand Palestinians returned to jobs in Israel after Israel eased its closure of the West Bank and Gaza Strip. The travel ban was imposed after the July 30 market bombing in Jerusalem that killed 17 people. The Islamic militant group Hamas claimed responsibility.

Gaza Strip: Palestinian women prepare to show permits as they cross into Israel By Adel Hana, AP

CP-1997-031 →

· The Commercial Appeal · Memphis, TN

1906 letter tells of life in Palestine

PERRE MAGNESS

In scrapbooks, in attics, in drawers all over town are fascinating documents of family history, often ignored and unrecognized. One such family treasure has seen the light. Dr. Sidney S. Friedman found a letter that tells an unusual story, especially meaningful as Jews around the world gather today to celebrate Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year.

Friedman’s great-grandparents, Herman and Mollie Goldberger, had a clothing factory in Memphis. For a few years around the turn of the century, they lived in New York, then returned to Memphis. In 1906, they received this letter from a relative whom they had entertained in their Brooklyn home, recounting his journey to Palestine.

At the beginning of the 20th Century, thousands of Jewish immigrants came to the United States from eastern Europe, fleeing pogroms and persecution in their homelands. Adolph H. Schagrin reversed that trend. In 1906, he went with his family from the United States to settle in Palestine. Palestine — today’s Israel — has been overrun by conquerors from time immemorial.

Ammonites, Canaanites, Hebrews, Assyrians, Babylonians, Persians, Greeks, Seleucids, Romans, Arabs, Christian Crusaders, Mamelukes, Ottoman Turks all laid claim to the land at the eastern end of the Mediterranean. Most of the Jews fled during Roman times.

By the time Palestine became part of the Ottoman Empire in 1517, there were small colonies of Christians and Jews, but most of the population was Muslim. During the 1800s, organized persecution of the Jews in Russia spurred Jewish immigration to Europe and the United States.

In 1882, a group of Jewish youths calling themselves Lovers of Zion formed a movement to promote immigration to Palestine. Austrian journalist Theodore Herzl was a leader in the political Zionist movement, seeking recognition of the Jewish claim to a homeland in Palestine. Herzl organized the first World Zionist Conference in Basel, Switzerland, in 1897.

The movement gained political recognition during World War I, when Britain defeated the Turks. In 1947, after the Holocaust of World War II, the United Nations approved the partition of Palestine into Arab and Jewish states. Adolph Schagrin joined the early Zionist movement to settle in Palestine. He wrote his impressions in a Jan. 16, 1906 letter to his aunt and uncle.

A local-history column, not news. Its value for the archive is as a 1997 example of American prose about Palestine in which the indigenous population is present only as a religious census category and a line in a list of conquerors. The one-word absence — “Palestinian” never appears — is the finding.

CP-1997-037 →

· The New York Times · New York

Gaza Gives Freed Sheik Welcome Fit for a Hero

“A sea of hands stretched out toward the slight, bearded man on a wheelchair, and a cry went up from thousands of throats… his return was celebrated here as a great victory, raising the group’s popularity among an increasingly embittered population.”

Joel Greenberg at Yarmuk Stadium. Sheik Ahmed Yassin home after eight years, released in the swap after the Mossad’s failed poisoning of Khaled Meshal in Amman. The last clause is the reporting: the popularity is read as a function of the embitterment, not of the man.

CP-1997-018 →

· The New York Times · New York

On This Street, It’s All Painted Over but the Hatred

“The Shuhada Street project… was paid for and supervised by the United States Agency for International Development… the work is ending three months behind schedule and about $1 million over its budget… vandalism by Jewish settlers opposed to reopening the street to Arab traffic.”

Joel Greenberg, three and a half years after the massacre. Spanish street lights, palm trees, flower beds and new brick sidewalks on Shuhada Street, the road closed to Palestinians after the mosque, paid for by American taxpayers through USAID and vandalised by settlers who did not want it reopened to Arab traffic. The street has not reopened since.

CP-1997-019 →

· The Day · New London, CT · page A4

Israel to offer Palestinians a small pullback

By GWEN ACKERMAN, Associated Press Writer

Jerusalem — Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is preparing a proposal to revive peace talks by offering the Palestinians another pullback in the West Bank — but one much smaller than they expect, Israeli media reports said Sunday.

Earlier Sunday, Netanyahu angered the Palestinians by pledging more Jewish settlements in east Jerusalem in response to the killing of a religious student by suspected Palestinian militants.

Israel TV and Israel Radio said that in a meeting Sunday with top ministers, Netanyahu said he would offer the Palestinians autonomy in another 6 to 8 percent of the West Bank in exchange for their agreeing to enter accelerated talks on a final peace deal.

No immediate confirmation was available, but earlier Netanyahu adviser David Bar-Illan confirmed the meeting took place and said that Netanyahu’s main goal was to begin final status talks. He also said that any further pullbacks depended on a tough crackdown by Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat against Islamic militants.

The proposals were slightly more generous than what Netanyahu reportedly proposed in a meeting with Secretary of State Madeleine Albright two weeks ago. The Yediot Ahronot daily said Netanyahu proposed then to turn over 3-5 percent of the West Bank — far short of the 20 percent the Palestinians demand.

Yediot and the Maariv daily also said President Clinton is angry with Netanyahu for failing to meet American demands for a “timeout” in construction of Jewish settlements. Netanyahu has repeatedly sought Palestinian agreement to speed up talks toward a final settlement, which the Israel-PLO accords — signed by a more dovish Israeli government — say should be reached by 1999.

But the Palestinians have demurred, apparently fearing the hardline Netanyahu would never agree to their demands for statehood. They have insisted Israel first carry out a promised three-phase expansion of their autonomous area, which presently covers most of Gaza and about a quarter of the West Bank.

The earliest clipping in the batch and the earliest Liberman: in 1997 he is a staff official resigning over ‘strong-arm tactics’ in party matters, a caption line under a photograph, not a politician with a position on Palestinians. The article itself is about the pullback proposal and the Hirschberg killing. Also printed: Hirschberg ‘attended a seminary run by Ateret Cohanim, a group involved in buying up property for Jews in the Muslim quarter and other Arab neighborhoods of east Jerusalem. Almost immediately after Netanyahu’s speech, workers took measurements at an abandoned two-story house in the Muslim quarter that Ateret Cohanim said it purchased in 1992 but has lacked the money to repair until now.’ The Palestinian deaths referenced across the page are not counted or named anywhere.

CP-1997-034 →

· The Times and Democrat

Off Gaza Strip, Israel rules the waves

By Laura King, Associated Press Writer

ABOARD ISRAELI PATROL BOAT WASP 906 – The crew scrambled into helmets and flak jackets, and a moment later came the order: “Fire!” The deafening boom of a 20 mm cannon echoed over the waves. The patrol boat had barely left harbor at the Israeli port of Ashdod, but within moments, it would be off the Palestinian-ruled Gaza Strip.

And it never ventures into those troubled waters without its weapons fully armed and tested. “We have to be ready for anything,” said the skipper, Navy Lt. Itai, whose full name could not be used under Israeli military regulations. The long and bitter quarrel of Israel and the Palestinians is firmly rooted in land, but it travels readily to the high seas.

To the Israelis, the Mediterranean Sea off Gaza is awash in potential threats — seaborne terrorists, drug smugglers, arms traffickers. So Israel shadows Gaza’s 20-mile coastline with patrol boats, and painstakingly tracks hundreds of vessels from radar stations on shore.

To the Palestinians, though, the Israeli naval presence is a constant reminder that a prime symbol of statehood — territorial waters under their own control — remains a distant dream. And as often happens, Israeli security concerns exact a high price from ordinary Palestinians — in this case, fishermen.

On a recent day in Gaza City’s main fish market, the day’s catch was meager but anger was in abundant supply. More than half the market stalls were shuttered, and only a few wooden pallets of fish lay scattered on the concrete floor. “It’s a siege at sea,” said Mustafa Omar Abu Al-Khaier, a fisherman for 29 of his 39 years.

Like his father and grandfather before him, he begins his workday long before dawn, catching shrimp and squid, sea bass and sole. He built the family business into a fleet of three boats and once had 42 crewmen in his employ. Now, he says, he has just seven — and wonders how long he can keep them.

Ironically, the fishermen say, the situation has worsened dramatically during the 3√ years of Palestinian self-rule in Gaza.

An Israeli patrol boat cuts through the water off the Palestinian-ruled Gaza Strip Monday. Palestinian fishermen complain their livelihood is threatened by Israeli maritime restrictions. (AP Photo)

CP-1997-027 →

· The New York Times

In West Bank, ‘Time’ for Settlements Is Clearly Not ‘Out’

By SERGE SCHMEMANN

OFRA, West Bank, Dec. 4 — If there is any serious talk of a “time-out” in settlement construction, it sure hasn’t reached Ofra. On one hillside, 27 houses stand in various stages of completion, while bulldozers shift boulders on another hill to make room for 24 more. Outside their settlement, Ofra residents have moved mobile homes onto another hilltop.

Despite a national strike that paralyzed all such work elsewhere in Israel, private electricians were busy stringing wire to the outpost. Similar activity can be seen in many other settlements, where construction that was frozen under the former Labor Government has resumed under Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s right-wing coalition.

According to Peace Now, a left-wing Israeli organization that closely monitors settlement activity, 4,714 housing units are now under construction in 61 of the 140 West Bank settlements.

The organization also said the Government had put out tenders for the construction of 26 housing units in a small Jewish settlement in the Gaza Strip, marking the first construction there since the last Likud Government in 1992.

“Time out?” declared Yona Hoffman, the head of the 1,860-member Jewish settlement five miles northeast of Ramallah, as talk turned to Secretary of State Madeleine K. Albright’s suggestion that Israel take a pause in settlement construction to break the deadlock in peace negotiations with the Palestinians. “It would be a disaster!

Let her freeze construction in her own United States. I sure hope if she demands this, that Bibi will give a good answer.” “Bibi” — Mr. Netanyahu — is to meet Ms. Albright on Friday in Paris, where she is likely to press him for progress on the requirements Washington has laid out for resuming the peace talks.

They include a “significant and credible” further withdrawal in the West Bank and a timeout in settlement expansion.

Yona Hoffman, shown with a neighbor outside her mobile home, says a delay in settlement construction would be a disaster. In the background are the old Ofra settlement on the right and new homes on the left. Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times

CP-1997-032 →

· The Tennessean

Israel rules the waves — and Palestinians chafe

Off Gaza Strip, the Mideast warriors carry their disputes from land to sea. Palestinian fishermen appear to be the losers.

By Laura King, Associated Press

ABOARD ISRAELI PATROL BOAT WASP 906 — The crew scrambled into helmets and flak jackets, and a moment later came the order: “Fire!” The deafening boom of a 20 mm cannon echoed over the waves. The patrol boat had barely left harbor at the Israeli port of Ashdod, but within moments, it would be off the Palestinian-ruled Gaza Strip.

And it never ventures into those troubled waters without its weapons fully armed and tested. “We have to be ready for anything,” said the skipper, Navy Lt. Itai, whose full name could not be used under Israeli military regulations. The long and bitter quarrel of Israel and the Palestinians is firmly rooted in land, but it travels readily to the high seas.

To the Israelis, the Mediterranean Sea off Gaza is awash in potential threats — seaborne terrorists, drug smugglers, arms traffickers. So Israel shadows Gaza’s 20-mile coastline with patrol boats, and painstakingly tracks hundreds of vessels from radar stations on shore.

To the Palestinians, though, the Israeli naval presence is a constant reminder that a prime symbol of statehood — territorial waters under their own control — remains a distant dream. And as often happens, Israeli security concerns exact a high price from ordinary Palestinians — in this case, fishermen.

On a recent day in Gaza City’s main fish market, the day’s catch was meager but anger was in abundant supply. More than half the market stalls were shuttered, and only a few wooden pallets of fish lay scattered on the concrete floor. “It’s a siege at sea,” said Mustafa Omar Abu Al-Khaier, a fisherman for 29 of his 39 years.

Like his father and grandfather before him, he begins his workday long before dawn, catching shrimp and squid, sea bass and sole. He built the family business into a fleet of three boats and once had 42 crewmen in his employ. Now, he says, he has just seven — and wonders how long he can keep them.

Ironically, the fishermen say, the situation has worsened dramatically during the 3 1/2 years of Palestinian self-rule in Gaza. Gazing out over the sparkling blue water, fisherman Abu Al-Khaier was gloomy. “Today we have fish — only a few, but at least we have something,” he said. “Tomorrow, we may have nothing.”

An Israeli seamen fires his M-16 rifle during a practice on board a patrol boat off the Gaza Strip coast.

CP-1997-028 →

· Daily Oklahoman · Oklahoma City

Poor Arab Villages a Startling Sight in Israel

“Over 75,000 Palestinian Israeli citizens live in unrecognized villages… While the Arabs in the new state were made citizens in 1948, they lived under a Military Administration.”

Mark Frey, writing from Arab al-Na’im in the Galilee for an Oklahoma paper. It sets Israel’s declaration of independence, promising complete equality of social and political rights, against a village with no recognition. The only clipping in this archive that names the unrecognized villages as a category, and it uses the phrase Palestinian-Israelis to do it.

CP-1997-020 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles, CA · page A10

Israeli Arabs Living Inside a Jewish Neighborhood Know Fear

■ Mideast: Three women in West Jerusalem endure firebombs and insults—but also receive support.

By MARJORIE MILLER, TIMES STAFF WRITER

JERUSALEM—Each time there is a knock on their soot-blackened front door, Wafa and Sonya Khoury remove a Post-it from the peephole, peer into the hallway of their apartment building and ask the visitors to identify themselves. Satisfied the callers are not hostile, they unbolt and then unlock the door.

What may be normal precautions in another country would seem like paranoia in low-crime Israel, except for the fact that the Arab women have twice found firebombs on the doorstep of their fourth-floor apartment in predominantly Jewish West Jerusalem.

The Khoury sisters and roommate Manal Diab, another Arab Israeli from the Galilee, say they were not looking for trouble in July when they moved into the new building that borders a religious neighborhood and the dividing line between East and West Jerusalem. They just wanted a nice and reasonably priced place to live.

When the first fire was set in their stairwell in October, they went looking for safer quarters. But after the second bomb was detonated before dawn Nov. 30, in the hands of a police officer who was trying to dismantle it, they decided to stay and fight. “If we leave, they will do the same to others, and then all Arabs will have to leave,” said Sonya Khoury, 25.

“It is very dangerous, but if we don’t fight for our rights, it will be even more dangerous.” While many eyes are focused on the battle between Israelis and Palestinians in East Jerusalem, the flames outside the women’s apartment have brought to light racial and religious tensions that also exist in West Jerusalem.

Many Arab citizens of Israel, whose families remained in the country after the state was formed in 1948, say that, by and large, they feel unwelcome and unwanted by Jewish compatriots in Jerusalem. Firebombs are not the norm, but many Arab Israelis say hostility is.

They hunt for housing among reluctant landlords and, when they find something, neighbors seem unhappy to see them moving in. If they speak Arabic among themselves on buses or in restaurants, they say, they receive angry stares and sniping comments. Sometimes they are prevented from entering public places.

Despite their Israeli citizenship and fluency in Hebrew, they say they are regarded as outsiders or, worse, as a potential fifth column in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In the aftermath of Palestinian suicide bombings in Jerusalem—five in the last 2½ years that have left more than 65 people dead—they feel they must lie low.

“It is always more difficult after an explosion,” said Iyad Ighbarieh, 25, a Hebrew University student from the Arab village of Umm al Fahm in northern Israel. “Usually, we just stay home. Or we come to campus, but they look at us differently. When there is an explosion, we avoid contact with them.”

Photo credit CARLOS RAMOS / For The Times. Photo caption: “‘They don’t want us to be here because we are Arabs,’ Manal Diab says of some West Jerusalem neighbors.” Tagline at the foot: “Researcher Batsheva Sobelman of The Times’ Jerusalem Bureau contributed to this report.” Other figures printed on the page: 6,400 Arab Israelis added to West Jerusalem when Beit Safafa was absorbed after 1967; only a couple of hundred Arab Israelis living in West Jerusalem; about 150,000 Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem; a Gallup poll in Maariv and Yediot Aharonot showing 60% of Israelis would not rent an apartment to an Arab, 40% not to homosexuals, 33% not to ultra-Orthodox Jews, 25% not to Russian immigrants. Police spokesman Shmuel Ben Rubi says the bombers were “haredi extremists”; someone wrote nevelah, or carcass, on the stairwell wall. This is the clipping to show Maria first.

CP-1998-029 →

· The St. Augustine Record · St. Augustine, FL · page 6B or 8B — the leading digit will not resolve at 20x; see flags

Arab citizens of Israel despair they’ll never be accepted

The Washington Post

JERUSALEM — When Manal Diab and sisters Sonia and Wafa Khoury lived in an Arab neighborhood of East Jerusalem, men hassled them constantly for breaking tradition by having left their parents’ homes to seek education and careers. So, last summer, the three Israeli Arab women moved to Jewish West Jerusalem, rejoicing at the idea of living there quietly. There has been no quiet.

The women’s Jewish neighbors have harassed them and demanded they leave. Twice, firebombs have exploded at their entryway, leaving it a scorched, melted mess. And Israeli authorities, they say, have done little to defend them. Now, Diab wonders if there is any place in Israel for a 26-year-old Arab woman trying to build a career.

Her doubts reflect evidence that Israel’s Arab minority — about 1 million Muslims and Christians who form 17 percent of the population — continues to grow alienated. Over the past 20 years, opinion polls show, Arabs living in Israel have come to accept the existence of the Jewish state but conclude that it accords them no legitimate place in society.

In the past year, the breakdown of peace negotiations between Israel and the Palestinian leadership of the West Bank and Gaza Strip has accentuated the Israeli Arabs’ despair, according to Youssef Jabareen, an Israeli Arab civil rights lawyer.

After the Israeli-Palestinian peace process began in 1993, “we felt that Israelis’ attitudes toward us improved ... and that we had more of a chance to move toward an equal footing with Jews in this state,” said Jabareen. But since the talks stalled last spring, he said, “we have lost momentum.”

In 1948, when Jewish militia forces captured most of what had been British-ruled Palestine, more than three-quarters of the territory’s Arab residents fled as refugees. Those who stayed — most of them in villages in the north — were eventually given Israeli citizenship.

But, like blacks in America, Israel’s Arabs historically have faced chronic discrimination over education, jobs and housing, and, despite government measures designed to promote equality, they form a frustrated underclass. Their disaffection is deepened by Jewish suspicions that Israel’s Arabs form a disloyal fifth column in its confrontation with the Arab world.

Israeli Arabs work mostly in low-skilled jobs, often on construction projects, and live apart from the Jewish mainstream in tightly knit villages and neighborhoods. Many young Arabs, Diab said, “are moving to the cities to develop (their) lives, looking for opportunities,” because “there are too many limits” in Arab villages and towns.

Also on the page and not transcribed: the paragraphs on the 1948 absorption of Beit Safafa, Jerusalem Mayor Ehud Olmert’s response, and a short passage on Arabic names defaced on the trilingual street signs. Below the article, cut off at the foot of the scan, is the top of a separate item (a display head beginning “Bb ... t ... f ...” with a boxed element) which is not part of this story and is excluded.

CP-1998-030 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago

Palestinian protesters voice support for Iraqis

New York Times News Service

Printed as the United States prepared to strike Iraq. The photograph is of women under umbrellas in the rain.

CP-1998-019 →

· Tulsa World · Tulsa, OK

Netanyahu Snubs British

Israel Vows to Continue Expansion in East Jerusalem

JERUSALEM (AP) — Touching a raw nerve in Israel, Britain’s foreign secretary was greeted by taunts of “Anti-Semite!” as he visited the site of a new Jewish housing project in Jerusalem and insisted that Mideast peace hinged on a halt to Jewish settlement expansion.

A furious Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu lashed back, vowing to build “thousands of homes” on disputed land in east Jerusalem, and canceling a dinner and even a traditional handshake with the diplomat, Robin Cook.

Cook ignited deep Israeli enmity by meeting with a Palestinian official at the divisive housing project known in Hebrew as Har Homa and in Arabic as Jabal Abu Ghneim. Ignoring the driving rain, Israeli protesters jeered Cook at the 6,500-unit construction site, banging pots and pans and chanting “Anti-Semite!” and “Robin, go home!”

Netanyahu’s snub capped days of wrangling between Israel and Britain over the symbolism of Cook’s visit to east Jerusalem, the sector claimed by the Palestinians as a future capital.

“The issue of Jerusalem is a cardinal one in our eyes and it is important for us to inform any guest in Jerusalem and anyone who wants to contribute to the peace process that Israel is sovereign in Jerusalem and will remain so,” a stern-faced Netanyahu told reporters. “This government is the one that decided to go forward with the building on Har Homa.

And Har Homa will be built. There will be thousands of homes in Har Homa,” he said. British Embassy spokeswoman Sara Buchanan said Cook’s agenda had been sanctioned by the European Union — since Britain holds the EU’s rotating presidency — and called Netanyahu’s response “an overreaction.”

Clean AP page. No Israeli-Arab vocabulary: a negative case, but a useful one, because the story shows the paper is perfectly capable of giving a place two names in two languages in a single clause while giving the people only one.

CP-1998-032 →

· The New York Times · page 14

Israeli Arabs March Home, To a Place They Can’t Live In

By Serge Schmemann

SHEIK DANNUN, Israel, March 28 — Viewed from a distance through the thick haze of a sandstorm, the marchers with their upheld sheets of red and green paper seemed to merge with the flowering fields of the Galilee. As they approached, their chants became audible: “The Right of Return Is Inalienable!” “Land Day Lives On!”

And it became evident that each sheet of paper carried Arabic lettering. There were 418 sheets, a marcher said, one for each Arab village that stood among these and similar fields 50 years ago, before being leveled by the Jewish soldiers of the new State of Israel.

About the time of the march, Palestinians protesting the presence of Jewish settlers near Nablus, in the Samarian hills of the West Bank, clashed with Israeli police officers, who opened fire with rubber-coated bullets. The thousand Arabs walking out of Sheik Dannun were not West Bank Palestinians, for whom the Israeli settlers and soldiers were occupiers and interlopers.

The marchers were Israeli citizens, most fluent in Hebrew, and they marched with a permit from the police, who were mainly there to handle traffic. Yet their red, green, black and white flags were also Palestinian, although their grievance differed largely in its vintage from those of West Bank Palestinians.

The march was called to mark what the Israeli Arabs call Land Day, March 30, the anniversary of the day 22 years ago when Israeli forces opened fire on Israeli Arabs protesting the expropriation of their lands, killing six.

This year, the 50th anniversary of the founding of the State of Israel, the commemoration had a special significance: to begin events to mark Al Nakbeh, or the Disaster — the defeat and dispossession of the Palestinian Arabs in 1948. Israeli Arab leaders have called for a general strike on Monday and major commemorations on May 15.

A few miles north of Sheik Dannun, the column turned onto a dirt road that led through wheat fields into a wood, with thick hedges of cactus among the pines. This was a sure sign that an Arab village had once stood here; the cactus fenced a corral.

The ruin of a mosque, surrounded by a high fence topped with barbed wire, soon came into view, and the chants gave way to the Palestinian anthem, “Biladi, Biladi” — “My Country, My Country.”

As the speeches began, Hamad Ali, a 62-year-old construction worker from Sheik Dannun, walked to the edge of the crowd and pointed to a large tree among the weeds and hillocks. “I was born here,” he said in Hebrew. “My parents’ house stood there, by the tree. The mosque was the center. There was a bakery over here, two meat shops.

My family lived off the land — they had some cows, sheep, grew some wheat.” The village was called Gabsiyeh, and it was apparently much like the other 900 villages in which the majority of Palestinian Arabs, then estimated to number 1.2 million, lived in 1948. About 700 people lived here. Mr.

Ali interrupted his story for a minute of silent prayer called for those killed during the 1948 civil war. “We ran away and hid in caves,” he resumed. “We were afraid they’d kill us. I heard there was a young man who climbed on the mosque with a white flag to surrender, and they shot him.” True or not, there were many similar stories.

But unlike tens of thousands of other Arabs, who fled into Arab-held territories to the north and east, the villagers of Gabsiyeh returned to their homes. “The officers came back in 1951,” Mr. Ali said. “It was winter. I remember because it was the first snow I ever saw. A few Jewish officers came.

They said the army were going to hold maneuvers, and it was safer for us to leave. My poor parents believed them and obeyed. Nobody was ever allowed back. Those who came back were arrested. I was 14.” The villagers appealed to the high court, which ordered the military administration to let them return.

Instead the army leveled the village, leaving only the mosque to crumble slowly among the cactuses. Mr. Ali’s story has countless echoes among the millions of Palestinian Arabs.

Their continued existence as refugees in the West Bank, the Gaza Strip and neighboring Arab countries remains one of the major hurdles to a final peace settlement, and a troubling shadow over Israel to many of its citizens.

The people who marched today are what the Israeli novelist David Grossman called present absentees — an ironic play on the fact that the Israeli Government seized some Arab properties in the early years on the ground that their owners were absentee landlords. According to Israeli statistics, about 156,000 Palestinian Arabs were left in Israel in November 1948.

Their numbers have surpassed one million, almost a fifth of the population. They hold Israeli citizenship and elect representatives but do not serve in the army. They proportionately receive a much smaller share of state money than Jews for schooling and other services, but most are aware that their plight is better than that of other Palestinians.

“My life is good,” acknowledged Yussef Mahmoud Salem, a well-dressed man of 38, whose father had been a major landowner in Gabsiyeh. “I’m a Palestinian, and I’m a citizen of Israel. I think Israel should be a country for all its citizens.” Mr. Ali agreed. He had no complaint with being Israeli, but he wanted his land back.

“We were born here, and we want to live here,” he said. “I don’t care who’s in charge. As we say, the man married to my mother is my father.” The police arrested one of two youths who had somehow climbed onto the mosque’s dome to put up a flag.

In the West Bank, that would have triggered a wave of stones, but here, the youth was just told not to leave until his lawyer arrived. “They say this is private property,” he said sullenly. “I don’t want to get in trouble with police. But this is our mosque. How can it be private property?”

Arab Israelis protesting expropriation of their villages marched yesterday to commemorate the day 22 years ago when Israeli forces killed six.

CP-1998-025 →

· Chicago Tribune · page 1; jump on 13, Section 1

Netanyahu says Palestinians not doing their part

By Storer H. Rowley, TRIBUNE FOREIGN CORRESPONDENT

JERUSALEM—Brushing aside U.S. concerns that the Mideast peace process is in “dire straits,” Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu declared Tuesday that he is confident he will forge a peace agreement with the Palestinians, Lebanon or Syria by the end of his term in office, in the year 2000.

“I intend to do it in this term, at least one of these agreements,” Netanyahu asserted in an interview with the Tribune. His Likud-led government took office in 1996 and must call elections again by 2000.

Despite threats by right-wing members of his ruling coalition to bring down his government if he cedes too much land to the Palestinians in a peace agreement, Netanyahu said he is convinced they will not bolt the coalition and risk allowing the opposition Labor Party to return to power. “My chief concern is not with the coalition.

My chief concern is with a coalition of one: myself,” Netanyahu said. “I have to be satisfied that the Palestinians do their part and I have to be satisfied that I protect Israel's security. “I will never jeopardize my country's security. But if I'm satisfied that these two concerns are met, then the coalition concerns are not going to be in the way.”

Until now, Netanyahu has used threats of defection by right-wing coalition members to justify his tough stand in negotiations with the Palestinians. That has contributed to a yearlong deadlock in the peace process and exasperated the Clinton administration.

However, a relaxed and confident Netanyahu laid all the blame for the deadlock squarely on Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, accusing him of failing to keep his commitments to fight terrorism and those who incite it.

CP-1998-038 →

· Kalamazoo Gazette · page 1

Palestinians confront past, betrayals on path to statehood

By Laura King, The Associated Press, Gaza City, Gaza Strip

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — His memories are scraps torn from childhood’s fabric: a peacock’s jewel-toned tail feathers. Town streets abruptly giving way to the desert’s bleak beauty. And his mother’s sewing machine. Palestinian psychiatrist Eyad Sarraj was 4 when his family hastily left their home in what is now the Israeli town of Beersheba.

And the clearest image he can call up from that spring day in 1948 is the sight of his mother trying to lug her prized machine — a wondrous contraption of heavy-wrought metal — to a waiting truck. Stop, his father told her. Don’t be silly. You don’t need to bring that. We’ll be back in two weeks.

For the Sarraj family — and some three-quarters of a million other Palestinians who fled or were driven out when the British withdrew and the land was partitioned — those weeks somehow expanded into half a century.

Today, the Palestinian people — some 8 million worldwide, by United Nations count — remain scattered and stateless… Almost from the beginning, Israelis and Palestinians denied one another’s very existence as a people… And the late Israeli prime minister, Golda Meir, once said there was no such thing as a Palestinian.

Palestinians fared little better at Arab hands. After partition, neighboring states grabbed chunks of land; Jordan annexed the West Bank, and Egypt seized the Gaza Strip.

It was the kind of betrayal the Palestinians would experience again and again… If 1948 marked the original catastrophe — “al-nakba,” in Arabic — for Palestinians, its echo came in 1967, when Israel and its Arab neighbors again went to war. It was a rout.

Israel captured the West Bank and east Jerusalem from Jordan, the Gaza Strip from Egypt and the Golan Heights from Syria.

Another 300,000 Palestinians became refugees — and lost hope that the Arab world would be their savior… “It’s fine to talk about the end of occupation, but if I walk to the end of this road, I see Israeli soldiers,” said Gaza merchant Salim Kamal. “So it’s ours, this land? It doesn’t look like ours.”

“A Palestinian man hurries past Israeli soldiers aiming their rifles — equipped with rubber bullets — at Palestinians throwing stones in the West Bank Town of Hebron in March.” Eyal Warshavsky, Associated Press.

The word in Arabic, glossed, in an American daily in April 1998, in a piece that also prints Golda Meir on there being no such thing as a Palestinian and then spends a page disproving her with named people. The subheadings are “Existence denied,” “Routs and catastrophes,” “Ragtag band,” “Lost and found,” “Vast chasms” and “Sum of its grief.”

CP-1998-009 →

· Journal Tribune · Biddeford · page 1

Palestinian freed after 6 years in Israeli jail

Samar Assad, Associated Press, Ramallah, West Bank

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Israel unexpectedly released a leader of a radical Palestine Liberation Organization faction today after holding him nearly six years without charges or trial. Ahmed Qatamesh, 46, was the longest-held prisoner in so-called administrative detention and was at the center of a campaign by human rights activists trying to end the practice.

Dozens of friends and relatives showered Qatamesh with yellow flower petals as he entered his home in the West Bank town of Ramallah. Clutching a bouquet of flowers, Qatamesh hugged his wife and 8-year-old daughter.

Qatamesh, a leader of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a radical PLO faction, said he was happy to be home, but also felt “extreme anger and frustration” over the five years and eight months he spent in prison.

A second PFLP activist, Hassan [—]afafta, 35, was also released today after serving four years in administrative detention, said Qatamesh’s lawyer, Jawad Boulos. In all, about 200 Palestinians and Lebanese are currently held without charges, some imprisoned for several years. Israel says administrative detentions are an important tool in the fight against terrorism.

However, human rights groups say imprisonment without due process can never be justified. Qatamesh was never convicted of a crime, said his wife, Soha Barghouti. On Sept. 1, 1992, he was placed in administrative detention, and earlier this month, his term was extended for a 10th time for a period of six months.

David Bar-Illan, a senior adviser to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, said he did not know why Qatamesh won early release. The Israeli daily Haaretz said that while still in prison, Qatamesh granted interviews to two Israeli TV stations in which he spoke out against terrorism… Qatamesh was released early today from Damoun prison in northern Israel.

On the way home to Ramallah, he stopped at a West Bank cemetery where his mother and father are buried. Dozens of friends and relatives awaited his arrival in Ramallah. “We welcome the leader, teacher and comrade,” read a banner outside his home signed by the PFLP… Mrs.

Barghouti said that in recent months, eight of the longest-held administrative detainees had been freed, and suggested that the Israeli government was beginning to respond to the human rights campaign being waged inside Israel and abroad.

Administrative detentions were first used by the British during their rule of pre-state Palestine, and one of those held by the British at the time, former Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir, said today the practice would be phased out.

Five years and eight months without charge, and the detail the paper puts last: the practice was inherited from the British, and one of the men they had held that way was a later Israeli prime minister. The advertisement under it is for a hair salon in Biddeford. The first letter of the second man’s surname falls off the left edge of the clipping and is not supplied here.

CP-1998-001 →

· The Seattle Times · Seattle, WA · page M 10

Pressures from within, without

If concern about security has been one constant in Israel’s 50 years, change has been another. Growth has been steady and, in the 1990s, explosive. As happened after World War II, Israel again has become the destination for hundreds of thousands of Jews from other countries and societies. The economy is stratifying into richer and poorer.

The dream of a common language is harder to hold. Even the singular religious and cultural identity that has been Israel’s strength for 50 years seems shaken. Almost from the beginning, Israel has opened its arms for any Jew who wanted to come. The Jewish population doubled right after World War II, when the Holocaust survivors streamed in.

In more recent years, the country has assimilated millions of immigrants from the former Soviet Union, Morocco and Ethiopia. About 800,000 immigrants from the former Soviet Union alone have arrived since 1989; the Israelis call them “the Russians,” and they now make up one-seventh of the population.

Some 36 percent of the 13.8 million Jews worldwide now live within Israel’s borders. Many immigrants are poverty-stricken and face little hope of true assimilation. Many don’t speak Hebrew, the Israelis’ chosen language, or English, the country’s second language. Many have inadequate housing.

Ethiopian immigrants complain of being isolated in muddy trailer communities in the north. Many immigrants from the former Soviet Union are trained, skilled professionals who say there is little work for them in their true professions.

The problem of too many immigrants and too few jobs has exacerbated an economic recession that many blame on the government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

Also on the page: a dominant photograph of the Safed cemetery, caption “ALMOST A QUARTER-MILLION JEWS have been buried in this Safed cemetery since the 1300s. Highly revered rabbis are buried in sarcophagi, which are painted blue and where the faithful go to pray.”; a second photograph captioned “IT IS SAID IN SAFED that when the Messiah comes, he will walk up these steps. An old woman used to sit in the pathway with tea and cakes, awaiting his return.”; and a chronology strip along the foot running 1971–1984. None of these are the article and none are transcribed as excerpt.

CP-1998-035 →

· Houston Chronicle · Houston, TX · page 1A, continued 8A

Israel test village makes neighbors of Jews, Arabs

By DEBORAH HORAN, Special to the Chronicle

NEVE SHALOM, Israel — Ranin Boulos, a lanky, eloquent 13-year-old, breaks into a sprint when she spots Naomi Mark near a restaurant in this village. “She’s my very best friend,” Ranin explains with a wide smile. “There’s a connection between us. The last thing I think is that we’re different.”

Yet their friendship is unique here in Israel because Ranin is Arabic, Naomi is Jewish. In a country where Arabs and Jews tend to live apart and often harbor deep suspicions of one another, the girls’ friendship is a testament to the ability of the human will to overcome hatred and prejudice.

The girls are products of what their parents call an “experiment in peaceful coexistence” first envisioned by the Rev. Bruno Hussar, an Egyptian Jew who converted to Christianity and became a Dominican monk. In 1972, Hussar leased property from a nearby monastery about 30 miles southwest of Jerusalem and established the village of Neve Shalom, which means New Peace in Hebrew.

It was to be a place for Jews and Arabs to live together. Today, 15 Jewish families and 15 Arabic families dwell here in the belief that if they expose their children to the other side, they can slowly chip away at old attitudes and stereotypes. Fifteen more families have been accepted to move to the village, and 300 more are on a list waiting to get in.

“By being here we are making a statement that you can have a conflict as complicated as the Israeli-Arab conflict and still live together,” says Ranin’s dad, Daoud Boulos, a television director of Arabic children’s shows. The family moved to Neve Shalom in 1989.

An innovative effort from the start, the village also boasts the only bilingual and bicultural primary school in Israel. Beginning in kindergarten, children learn subjects in both languages from two teachers, one Jewish and one Arabic. Everyone celebrates Muslim, Jewish and Christian religious holidays. At first, the school served only the 15 children of the village.

But the idea of an integrated class has slowly caught on. Today, 100 students attend, two-thirds from surrounding towns. And next year, a Jewish village in the Galilee region plans to open a joint secular primary school.

The last clipping of the batch and one of the two or three strongest. A family of Arab citizens of Israel are at the centre of a two-part series, three of them speak at length, and the paper still cannot settle on what to call them: Arabic six times in its own voice, Arabs seven times, and Palestinian never — while reserving Palestinian for people in the West Bank and Gaza in the same columns.

CP-1998-034 →

· The New York Times · New York

Living With the Palestinian ‘Catastrophe’

By Ethan Bronner

REHOVOT, Israel — At first, Ibrahim Shikaki is lost amid the widened roads, bowling alley and Toyota garage off Menachem Begin Avenue. But having spent his first 20 years here in what was once the village of Zarnouga, he insists that even at age 70 he will gain his bearings.

At the intersection of streets honoring Israelis who fought in the 1967 and 1973 wars, he says: “Turn right. The mosque used to be that way.” It still is, up a dirt road, crumbling and fenced off, with six-foot-high weeds climbing a steel door that now bears a Star of David. The sight of the dome from which Mr.

Shikaki used to call for prayers produces tales of his imam father, the surviving mulberry tree elicits memories of his sister, and the few remaining houses from his era bring to his tongue the names of their former owners — Ahmed Nimr here, Hashem Qassab there.

The Shikakis farmed this land for generations, if not centuries, cultivating wheat and apricots, oranges and cucumbers. In May 1948, they fled the fighting that led to the establishment of Israel and were never permitted back. Their house was demolished and their land given to Jews.

Today their former village is on the outskirts of the Israeli city of Rehovot, and the clan lives as refugees in the sand-choked, litter-strewn town of Rafah at the southern edge of the Gaza Strip. The last half century has not been an easy one for Mr. Shikaki, scion of a respected village family eking out a living as a day laborer in the Jewish state.

In many ways, his story and that of his eight children — including a founder of Islamic Holy War, a professor, a businessman and unskilled workers — is that of the Palestinian people, a saga of humiliation and fury but also one of emerging accommodation and rebirth.

Israel is observing its 50th anniversary, celebrating the vibrant and democratic regional superpower established upon the ashes of Nazi genocide. But for the Palestinian Arabs, the anniversary marks the Nakba, or catastrophe.

The Arabs had rejected the 1947 United Nations plan to partition British-controlled Palestine into Jewish and Arab states, and when Israel declared its independence the next spring, five Arab countries attacked.

By the time the fighting ended, Israel had conquered far more land than had been allotted to it under the plan, and some 700,000 people — half the Palestinian Arab population at the time — had fled or were driven out.

Abdul-Aziz Shikaki, right, talked with a neighbor during a regular Friday picnic at the Shikaki farm in the Gaza Strip last week. Mr. Shikaki mixes a hard political line with a pragmatic accommodation to Israel. (James Estrin/The New York Times)

The page date line reads NEW YORK, THURSDAY, APRIL 23, 1998. The article continues on page A12, which this archive does not hold, so the text here stops at the foot of the front-page column.

CP-1998-012 →

· The Herald · Miami · page 1

Netanyahu tells Palestine: Don’t declare state

The Associated Press, Jerusalem

“JERUSALEM — Saying Israel could not accept a ‘new Iraq or Iran’ on its doorstep, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu warned Monday that Israel would retaliate if Palestinians declare a state before reaching a peace agreement. The Israeli leader, in one of his toughest statements yet on Palestinian statehood, refused to say what steps might be taken.

The most likely option would be the annexation of disputed West Bank land by Israel. ‘We cannot accept and mustn’t accept the formation of a new Iraq or Iran next to our doorstep,’ Netanyahu told the Foreign Press Association. ‘If the Palestinians react with unilateral actions, so will we.’

The statement came in reaction to a warning from Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, who told reporters in the autonomous Gaza Strip over the weekend that he would press ahead with a declaration of statehood if there was no peace settlement by May 4, 1999, the deadline set in the Oslo accords. ‘It’s our right, and we’re going to declare it,’ Arafat said.

He has made similar assertions before… ‘We hope there will be progress, but I cannot guarantee that,’ said Netanyahu, adding that Israel was trying to be ‘flexible’ but it would take an equal effort from the Palestinians. Palestinians have accused Netanyahu of foot-dragging and warned that a failure in London could lead to an explosion of violence.”

Annexation, named as the threatened answer to a declaration of statehood, in 1998 — in the reporter’s own sentence, not in a quotation. The word Jerusalem is set as a drop-in label beside the second paragraph.

CP-1998-002 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Still Not Full Citizens

Hilda B. Silverman

To the Editor: As to whether the 160,000 Palestinian Arabs who remained within the new state of Israel in 1948 were “internal refugees” (front page, April 23) or “full citizens” (letter, April 28), some facts might prove helpful. Until 1966 those who remained lived under harsh military rule.

In addition, 81,000 were designated “present absentees” and permanently denied the right to return to their homes. While they were granted citizenship, their land (750,000 acres) was confiscated by the state, along with their houses, shops, furniture and bank deposits. Today, Palestinian-Israelis represent almost 20 percent of Israel’s population.

Some still live in dozens of unrecognized villages, where they are granted identity cards but no further recognition and no services. HILDA B.

Date check: No masthead or page date line is visible; the scan is cropped to this single letter. The letter is dated at the foot “Cambridge, Mass., April 30, 1998”, which is consistent with publication on 1998-05-03, but the printed publication date could not be read.

CP-1998-021 →

· The Atlanta Constitution · Atlanta · page 1

Netanyahu: No Palestine

Tactfully, he rebuffs Mrs. Clinton’s view

Don Melvin, staff writer

“Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, ever the courtly hard-liner, mixed a gentle manner with firm words on a CNN broadcast Thursday to rebuff U.S. first lady Hillary Rodham Clinton’s call for the creation of a Palestinian state in the Middle East. ‘I have a different view,’ said Netanyahu, who did not mention President Clinton’s wife by name.

He said he would never accept what he called an ‘unbridled’ state, in which the Palestinians could field an army and form military alliances, perhaps with countries such as Iran and Iraq. ‘I am opposed to a Palestinian state,’ Netanyahu said. ‘I am not opposed to the Palestinians governing themselves.’”

CP-1998-003 →

· The Star-Ledger · Newark

White House says Mrs. Clinton’s Palestine view is simply her own

But Jewish and Arab Americans take remark about separate state as a signal of policy

WASHINGTON — The White House winced yesterday over a statement by Hillary Rodham Clinton advocating a Palestinian state, politely saying she was speaking her own mind, not making policy for her husband.

Spokesman Mike McCurry, lapsing into a convoluted style that often signals he is grappling with a prickly subject, veered between the need for politeness to his boss’s wife and the need for clarity at a crucial point in the peace effort.

“In a very real and a very human way, the abundant opportunities that would exist for (Arabs and Israelis) if they are able to bridge the gaps that they have between them and move forward in this process was something that the first lady responded to in a human way,” he said at a regular news briefing. “That’s not a surprise, given who she is.

But she would be the first to say that she was not reflecting the administration view, and our views on those subjects are well known.” The remarks about West Bank land the U.S. is pressing Israel to leave were made by Hillary Clinton over a satellite hookup from Washington to a conference in Switzerland bringing together young Arabs and Israelis.

“I think that the territory the Palestinians currently inhabit, and whatever additional territory they will obtain through the peace negotiations, should be considered and evolve into a functioning modern state,” she said in part.

That state would be “responsible for the well-being of its people and is seen on the same footing as any other state in terms of dealing responsibly with all of the issues that state governments must deal with.” Her statement was seized on by Jewish and Arab Americans as a signal from the White House, but McCurry was adamant it was not.

“That view expressed personally by the first lady is not the view of the President,” he said.

Filed as The News and Advance; the page prints The Star-Ledger. Folio line across the very top of the page, cropped at 10x in three segments: left "FRIDAY, MAY 8, 1998", centre "THE STAR-LEDGER", right "O PAGE 9" with a large "3" in the outer margin.

CP-1998-013 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco · page 1

Arab Protests Erupt in Violence

9 people die in riots over Israel’s birth

Serge Schmemann, New York Times, Jerusalem

“Palestinians yesterday marked the 50th anniversary of the creation of Israel, an event they call the ‘catastrophe,’ with two minutes of silence and several hours of violence in which nine were left dead… In the Gaza Strip, Israeli forces opened fire with live ammunition on Palestinians pressing in toward Jewish settlements, killing eight Palestinians, two of them 8-year-old boys.

Another man was killed by a rubber-coated bullet in the West Bank in Ramallah.

Exactly what led to the shooting is not clear, but the Israeli army said that it fired at rioters at three locations, and that Israeli forces were fired on at two of them… In Ramallah, Bethlehem and Hebron, Israeli forces seemed to exercise greater restraint, and there was evidence of coordination with Palestinian police to let Palestinian passions play out without inflaming them further… For every poster and slogan commemorating a village or a home lost in ‘al nakba,’ the catastrophe, there was another with a current grievance… ‘The nakba has thrown us out of homes and dispersed us around the globe.

Historians may search, but they will not find any nation subjugated to as much torture as ours.’”

“Israeli police officers with batons charged Palestinians protesting Israel’s 50th anniversary.” Associated Press. And: “Israeli police fired at stone-throwing Arabs in East Jerusalem; nine people were killed in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.” Reuters.

The headline calls it Israel’s birth. The Palestinian name appears further down, in quotation marks and glossed as “the catastrophe,” and then unquoted in Arafat’s speech.

CP-1998-004 →

· St. Cloud Times · St. Cloud · page 1

No agreement reached on West Bank pullout

Netanyahu vows he won't establish Palestine state, redivide Jerusalem

Associated Press, Washington

WASHINGTON (AP) — Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says he probably will make concessions to reach an agreement with the Palestinians over the West Bank, but not at the risk of his country’s security.

Netanyahu, taking a hard line Thursday night after his two-day talks with Secretary of State Madeleine Albright ended without a breakthrough, pledged never to agree to establish a Palestinian state or to redivide Jerusalem.

With Israeli officials saying no agreement was reached on any of the difficult issues, including how much territory Israel would relinquish on the West Bank, the Clinton administration seemed to have suffered a foreign policy setback.

“The Palestinians should have all of the powers to run their lives, but not the powers of statehood,” Netanyahu told an American Jewish Committee dinner. He said Israel had determined which areas of the West Bank that it could withdraw its troops from safely and that peace was “within our reach.”

But an agreement to reopen negotiations with the Palestinian Authority after 15 months of stalemate continued to elude the Israeli leader and Albright, although they directed aides to keep meeting in the search for an acceptable formula. “There is no agreement yet on the issues that were discussed,” said Gadi Baltiansky, the Israeli Embassy spokesman.

“But they continue to be discussed.” Albright’s spokesman, James P. Rubin, said: “We do have sufficient reason to continue serious work.” But he added: “It is hard to be optimistic.”

“Benjamin Netanyahu, Israeli prime minister”

The formula printed plainly in 1998: all the powers to run their lives, but not the powers of statehood. No Palestinian is quoted in the story.

CP-1998-005 →

· Stamford Advocate · Stamford · page 1

Palestinian march broken up in Jerusalem

“Palestinian residents of Arab East Jerusalem struggle with Israeli police officers yesterday after the officers tried to break up a Palestinian march commemorating the 50th anniversary of the Palestinian Nakba, their uprooting after Israel’s creation 50 years ago. Clashes erupted as Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza commemorated the Nakba.

Below, marchers shout at police and hold up signs reading ‘Despite the Nakba, hope remains.’” AP photos

A picture page. The caption gives the word, translates it, and quotes what the marchers had written on their signs. Most of the faces in the photograph are young women.

CP-1998-006 →

· The New York Times · New York

9 Palestinians Die in Protests Marking Israel’s Anniversary

Serge Schmemann

“Palestinians today marked the 50th anniversary of the creation of Israel, an event they call the catastrophe, with two minutes of silence and several hours of violence during which Israeli forces fired on crowds.”

Nine dead on the anniversary. The Palestinian commemoration is two minutes of silence; the paper gives the quotation marks around catastrophe, which it will keep for another twenty years.

CP-1998-018 →

· Houston Chronicle · Houston · page 1

Israelis, Palestinians clash on the 4th day of unrest over ‘al nakba’

Associated Press, Hebron, West Bank

HEBRON, West Bank (AP) — Palestinian youths threw stones and bottles Sunday at Israeli troops who responded with rubber bullets, wounding six Palestinians in a fourth day of West Bank clashes.

The latest round of violence began Thursday with mass Palestinian demonstrations to mark al nakba, or the catastrophe — which is what Palestinians consider Israel’s founding 50 years ago. Five Palestinians were killed in the clashes, the worst in nearly two years.

On Sunday, six Palestinians received medical treatment for injuries from rubber-coated metal bullets, Hebron hospital officials said. No Israeli soldiers were hurt, according to an Israeli army statement.

The violence continued as Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was scheduled to meet in Washington on Sunday with U.S. officials for talks on a delayed Israeli troop withdrawal from the West Bank.

The Clinton administration backed away from a threat to suspend its mediation of peace talks, even though Netanyahu did not accept a U.S. proposal for territorial compromise… “If you ask me, as the prime minister of Israel, to sign a peace treaty in which we somehow erode Israel’s defenses, that won’t hold,” Netanyahu said on ABC-TV’s This Week with Sam Donaldson and Cokie Roberts.

Israel has signaled it could give up 11 percent of the West Bank in addition to the 27 percent it agreed previously to relinquish, but only 3 percent of which is fully under Palestinian control… Among his themes were allegations that Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat is violating his agreements with Israel by vowing to establish a Palestinian state if he could not attain one through negotiations, and that the Palestinian police force far exceeds agreed limits… In Jericho on Sunday, about 150 new Palestinian police cadets were graduated, increasing the force to more than 30,000 — far beyond its authorized strength of 24,000.

Two portraits run side by side, captioned “Netanyahu” and “Arafat.”

The fiftieth anniversary, and the paper prints the Arabic word in italics with a translation. Five Palestinians killed; no Israeli soldiers hurt.

CP-1998-007 →

· Democrat and Chronicle · Rochester, NY

Let’s be fairer to Israel in reporting on the Middle East

JOANNE PRIVES

The American media devote an inordinate amount of coverage to the stalled peace process in the Middle East. Invariably, Israel is accused of being “obstructionist” (Speaking Out essay, June 2).

Chairman Arafat has lived up to none of the provisions of the Oslo accords, although the media rarely, if at all, call attention to PLO transgressions: ■ The PLO charter still calls for Israel’s destruction. ■ The PLO per capita has more armed “policemen” (about a 1-to-40 ratio) than any other country. ■ Some diplomats reportedly abuse their immunity by transporting arms across borders. ■ Children’s programs on PLO TV routinely glorify violence and hate vs.

Israelis. ■ Arafat’s Arabic speeches continually call for Israel’s end and the abrogation of treaties. We do read about Palestinians living in ghettoes and camps but not that Muslim rulers have intentionally interned them there since 1948 for propaganda purposes.

We read nothing about Arafat’s homes in Gaza and Jericho, his proposed domiciles in Nablus and Bethlehem or his plans for a multimillion-dollar mansion. There are 158 members of the United Nations. Libya, Iraq, Syria, Iran, Cuba and North Korea, all sponsors of terrorism, are among the 157 who can seek a seat on the Security Council.

Only Israel is ineligible to serve a term; its Arab neighbors, particularly Saudi Arabia and Iraq, refuse it membership in the regional alliance, a prerequisite for the Security Council. This isolation also excludes Israel from UNICEF, the World Court, the Commission of Human Rights and the Economic and Social Council.

Recently, 80 U.S. senators and more than 100 House members wrote President Clinton, urging his administration to cease its one-sided pressure on Israel. John Loftus and Mark Aarons in their book, The Secret War Against the Jews, assert that the “largest single obstacle to peace in the Middle East is the secret bias of Western government against the Jews.”

Peace negotiations between mature nations are not conducted under threats of violence. Differences can be resolved only in an atmosphere of compromise. Stated positions are negotiable, not grounded in concrete, a democratic principle seemingly foreign to the Arabs. Peace with Egypt is a mockery of Sadat’s and Begin’s Camp David vision.

Tourism and trade have not flourished, intellectual interchange is nonexistent. Peace with Jordan is illusory. More than 20 Arab nations surround the thin sliver of territory that is Israel. In a half dozen defensive wars, Israel has captured land and reunited Jerusalem. Now she is accused of “occupying territory.”

No other nation has been called upon to return land won in defensive wars. Territorial concessions can push Israel to the brink of national suicide. Israel’s security concerns are grounded in the reality of a sea of hostile neighbors and the potential for atomic weapons in the hands of rogue nations like Iran and Iraq. Israel has but to lose one war to cease to exist.

Who among us would trade places with an Israeli citizen and face the daily threats to life?

A photograph of Prives runs with the essay. No Israeli-Arab vocabulary whatsoever: in this writer’s map there are Israelis, Arabs who surround Israel from outside, and Palestinians kept in camps by Muslim rulers. The one-fifth of Israel’s citizens who are Arab have no place in the geography the essay describes.

CP-1998-036 →

· The New York Times · New York

West Bank Arabs Scrape By as They Lose Housing

By Joel Greenberg

KHIRBET KILKES, West Bank, June 22 — On a sunbaked hill outside Hebron, a Palestinian family lives in a tent beside the rubble of its house, which has been demolished for the third time, after Israeli authorities denied the family a building permit.

Surrounded by broken furniture, smashed household goods and other wreckage, the parents, Zuhur and Youssef al-Atrash, and their 10 children live in sweltering heat without running water or a toilet and drink water from a tanker truck that serves nearby parched Palestinian communities. Their water well was demolished along with the house.

“This is what Netanyahu has left us,” Mrs. Atrash said, waving toward a roofless floor where upholstered car seats were arranged around an Arab water pipe under the jagged remains of a wrecked ceiling. “We’re living like cave men, in a garage dump.”

In Jewish settlements that flank the roads to Hebron rows of new stone houses are sprouting on the rocky hills, and there is enough water to sprinkle gardens among the red-shingled houses. But demolitions of Arab houses in the West Bank and East Jerusalem have sharply increased in recent weeks, leaving scores of people homeless because their dwellings lacked building permits.

The policy seems to be aimed at consolidating Israel’s hold on East Jerusalem and on areas of the West Bank that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Government seeks to keep. A spokesman for the State Department, James P.

Rubin, has called the demolitions a wrong signal at a time when efforts to restart stalled peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians have reached a delicate stage. The Clinton Administration is reportedly pressing for a suspension of further demolitions as part of a deal to renew the negotiations.

One family in Khirbet Kilkes has had three houses demolished. (The New York Times)

Date check: the running head reads …E NEW YORK TIMES INTERNATIONAL TUESDAY, JUNE 23, 1998 (the first letters of “THE” are cut off at the left edge of the scan) — matches the slide date

CP-1998-022 →

· Bryan Times · Bryan, OH · page 9 (not legible on the scan; see flags)

Palestinians, Israel head to showdown over state

By NICOLAS B. TATRO, Associated Press Writer

RAMALLAH, West Bank (AP) — Over the past four years, Palestinians have slowly built up a political entity that looks very much like a state in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. There is a 30,000-member police force, a quarrelsome legislature, myriad government offices and a sparkling new international airport with everything but airplanes.

The success of self-rule can be seen in the little things, too: glassed-in bus stops in Ramallah, white-and-black street signs in Arabic and English, metal trash containers and, in some towns, telephone booths. Yasser Arafat, who has the title of president of the Palestinian Authority, is promising to make it official at midnight on May 4, 1999.

That’s when the Oslo accords negotiated between Israel and the Palestinians expire, at least according to Palestinian interpretation. “We are already a state in terms of the land, the people, an elected government and recognition.

What is left is to exercise sovereignty over the territory by that date,” said Mahdi Abdel Hadi, head of the independent Passia think tank in Jerusalem. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has hinted that if the Palestinians declare statehood on their own, he might annex large tracts in the West Bank, where the Palestinians govern only 27 percent of the land.

Wire copy. The vocabulary here is uniformly “Palestinians” and the subject is the West Bank and Gaza, not Israel’s own Arab citizens; a negative case for Maria’s cluster.

CP-1998-031 →

· The Arizona Republic · Phoenix · page 1

Palestinians remember ‘Nakba’

Show pictures life since Israel became a state

Lidia Romero, The Arizona Republic

“Palestinian crafts and traditional dresses embroidered in bright reds, pinks and oranges decorated the vast room at the Ramada Hotel-Camelback. Photographs of men, women and children dominated much of the exhibit — photos of old family portraits, of people posing in front of homes, of kneeling worshipers in temples.

One picture was of a young girl crying over the death of her father, an image that reflected the agony and pain of the Palestinians’ war against the Israelis. The exhibit, sponsored by a group of Palestinians living in the Valley, was titled ‘Nakba,’ which translates to ‘The Year of the Tragedy.’

‘(We) did this to create memory of the tragedy that happened to Palestinians in Israel,’ said Marwan Ahmad, coordinator of the event and one of an estimated 10,000 Palestinians who call the Valley home. ‘Americans know there is a problem in the Mideast, but they don’t know the details.’

Ahmad said there were two major events that reshaped Palestinian history: In 1948, Nakba, which is used to refer to the birth of Israel, and in 1967, when Israel occupied the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, where many Palestinians have lived for centuries. For 50 years, Israelis and Palestinians have been in war over land they both live on.

They both believe they have a legitimate claim to the land and use their respective religious beliefs to back their positions. The celebration earlier this year of Israel’s 50th anniversary inspired the exhibit, Ahmad said. Some Palestinians wanted to raise awareness of their culture and to shed a more sympathetic light on their struggle, he said.

‘We are a people of culture,’ Ahmad said. ‘Palestinians are normal people who want to live in peace.’ Dana Waken, a 35-year-old Phoenix resident, said she attended the exhibit because she wanted to learn more about the Palestinian culture. She said it’s unfortunate that such events fail to draw more people.

About 2,000 people attended the three-day event at the central Phoenix hotel. ‘The world is so small (and) we’re still isolationists,’ Waken said. Ahmad Aljallad, 34, a former resident of Damascus who stays aware of Palestinian issues, said he appreciated that the exhibit focused more on culture than politics.

‘It showed the history of the conflict, a picture of life of a Palestinian for the past 50 years and their future hope in Palestine,’ he said. Dorothy Sima, of Mesa, said she sees similarities between the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the Native American experience. ‘It makes me angry. They are being denied their basic human rights,’ she said.

‘If I was in their situation I would fight too.’ She said the exhibit gave her a different perspective on the Middle East issue because the media doesn’t present both sides. ‘This is something all people should see,’ Sima said.”

“Traditional items of Palestinian culture, such as these miniature nargilehs (water pipes), are part of the ‘Nakba’ exhibit sponsored by a group of Valley Palestinians.” Mark Schiefelbein / The Arizona Republic

Ten thousand Palestinians in the Phoenix valley, putting on an exhibition about 1948 for the fiftieth anniversary, and a local paper covering it as a community story.

CP-1998-008 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Water Divides Haves From Have-Nots in West Bank

By DOUGLAS JEHL

HEBRON, West Bank, Aug. 13 — In the unrelenting heat of what has been an unforgiving summer, water should spell relief. But in this city of 200,000, most taps ran dry a month ago, just as record temperatures took hold, soaring day after day to nearly 100 degrees.

That would have spelled misery anywhere, but what has made it worse on the West Bank is that Palestinians cannot help but notice that they are the only ones so parched. There is no sign of a water shortage in the Jewish settlements just outside Hebron. There and in Israel as a whole, residents still water lawns and wash their cars.

Yet most water for the Palestinians still flows through Israeli pipes, and by the time it gets to cities like Hebron these days, there is barely a trickle left. It was only 18 months ago that the Palestinians celebrated an agreement that brought Hebron under their control, making it the last of seven West Bank cities to come under Palestinian self-rule.

This summer, with cisterns empty, showers a luxury and fresh laundry a distant dream, many are learning basic lessons about the limitations of an incomplete peace.

“We don’t clean; we don’t wash our clothes; we don’t use the water for anything but drinking,” said Jibrin Kaffrawi, a 32-year-old electrician, who had embarked with his wife and seven children on a quest for water at almost any price. “But still there is not enough to go around, because it is all in the hands of the Jews.”

Israel still controls nearly all the water resources in the West Bank, including three enormous aquifers, just as it did during years of direct rule when it occupied all of the territory. Simply to dig a new well is prohibited unless a Palestinian can first negotiate a host of political and technical restrictions.

The extent to which the Palestinians will acquire water rights is supposed to be part of a final peace settlement. Until then, access to most fresh water is governed by a 1995 agreement that requires Israel to make available a fixed amount of water — slightly over one billion cubic feet a year — to meet the Palestinians’ “immediate needs.”

That arrangement leaves big gaps.

On the outskirts of Hebron a pool provided a meager source of supplemental water for Palestinians coping with rationing. The water supply, controlled by Israel, has been reduced despite an unusually hot summer.

Date check: No masthead or dateline rule is visible in the clipping — it begins at the headline. The story’s own dateline reads “HEBRON, West Bank, Aug. 13”, which is consistent with publication on Aug. 15, 1998. The photo credit reads “Rina Castelnuovo for The New York Times”, which confirms the paper.

CP-1998-023 →

· Portland Press Herald · Portland, ME · page 5A

Israel closes borders to avert threat of ‘horrific’ bombing

● The militant Islamic Hamas vowed to retaliate against Israel for the killing of two Hamas leaders.

Associated Press

JERUSALEM – Israel closed its borders with the Palestinian territories on Friday in an effort to prevent what Defense Minister Yitzhak Mordechai said were plans for an “unprecedented, horrific” attack that could set back peace talks.

The army was trying to prevent a bombing by the Islamic militant group Hamas, which could hamper Israeli-Palestinian negotiations on an Israeli troop withdrawal from the West Bank.

Although Israeli officials said the U.S.-brokered talks have brought some advances toward a deal they hope to conclude in a four-day summit in Washington in mid-October, the Palestinians remained skeptical. Hamas has vowed to carry out attacks against Israel after Israeli soldiers killed two of the group’s leaders last month.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu warned Friday that the security forces could not be totally effective in combating terror groups. “We have to know that, during this fight, we will take some blows,” Netanyahu said. “We are working against those murderers so there will be less attacks or none at all.”

Still, Israeli and Palestinian security forces have prevented bombing attempts in recent weeks by Hamas, whose attacks since 1994 have killed dozens of Israelis.

Palestinian police caught two Hamas members with 130 pounds of explosives in the Gaza Strip a week ago and uncovered a Hamas bomb factory with almost a ton of explosives in the West Bank city of Hebron, security officials said. Another Hamas member was killed earlier this week when a bomb-laden car, apparently intended for an attack on Israelis, exploded.

While Palestinian police worked to avert attacks, the peace talks were getting nowhere, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat said Friday. “No substantial progress can be cited” from his two meetings this week with Netanyahu in the United States, Arafat said, according to a speech read by Palestinian International Cooperation Minister Nabil Shaath in Ramallah.

Arafat said he was continuing with plans to declare a Palestinian state on May 4, 1999, the date the Palestinians say the interim peace accords expire.

Whole item transcribed. Terminologically uniform: by 1998 the AP wire register for West Bank and Gaza stories is “Palestinian” without exception, which makes the wobble in the feature writing elsewhere in this batch look like a feature-desk phenomenon rather than a house-style one.

CP-1998-033 →

· The New York Times

In the West Bank, Almost Zero Jubilation

‘I Don’t Want to Get My Hopes Up,’ Is General Reaction to Pact

By DEBORAH SONTAG

RAMALLAH, West Bank, Oct. 24 — Yasir Arafat has a tough crowd to please. After the interim peace accord was signed in Oslo in 1993, they took to the bustling streets here with olive branches, wrapping themselves in Palestinian flags, cheering and honking in what they believed would be a new era for Palestinians. This morning, barely 12 hours after Mr.

Arafat signed an agreement that promises the Palestinians what amounts to 40 percent of the West Bank, there were no parties here, no outbursts of pride, no euphoria. It was just traffic as usual in this busy, cosmopolitan town, daily commerce interrupted by heated conversations about hopes raised and hopes dashed.

Few wanted to admit what many said they did feel — a leap in the heart, a flash of faith — because they did not want to end up dupes of a peace effort they no longer trust. “Look, we can’t believe,” said Fatmeh Jwailes, a mother of 10, as she shopped for wall-to-wall carpeting, wearing traditional Islamic dress.

“Until I see with my own eyes that their promises are worth the ink they’re written in, I don’t want to get my hopes up.” If carried out, the agreement could transform the nature of the Palestinian entity, making it larger and more autonomous.

It would grant the Palestinians complete control over a sizable chunk of territory, much of it contiguous, and create safe-passage corridors between the West Bank and Gaza, linking the two axes of the Palestinian world here. It would create a Palestinian airport and an industrial zone in Gaza.

But to Palestinians, from the elite strata of the intellectual class to the angry ranks of the refugee camps, the “if” is a big one, and implementation is the key. The agreement signed at the White House on Friday is mostly a reiteration of actions already promised, in accords signed in Oslo in 1993 and 1995, and never undertaken.

This agreement sets a precise timetable for Israeli troop withdrawal in exchange for specific Palestinian steps to eradicate terrorism. And, unlike the Oslo agreements, it is a trilateral one, with the Americans playing guarantor, policeman and financier, using promises of financial aid to both sides.

These are distinctions, and they might make a huge difference, Palestinians say — or they could crumble. “The whole thing was like pulling teeth, so you hesitate to have confidence that there will be follow-up,” said Hanan Ashrawi, a prominent Palestinian academic and member of the legislative council.

“Only the absolutely naïve would be carried away with the spectacle of the signing.” Egypt cautiously welcomed the accord, echoing on a state level what the Palestinians were saying on the street: not only that implementation is all, but that there are thorny issues yet to be resolved.

As Foreign Minister Amr Moussa put it: “The accord is one step on the right path toward restoring Palestinian land and negotiating fundamental issues, topped by Jerusalem and the Palestinian right to self-determination. The road is still long for a comprehensive peace.”

In a village outside Ramallah, said Raafat Hamdan, 17, who works as a day laborer in Israel, he watched the White House ceremony on satellite television with his extended family. They sipped sweet, hot tea and munched on green grapes, speechless until the papers were actually signed.

Then, he said, there were some sniffles, and he himself became choked up to think that the whole world was watching what he believed was Palestinian history being made. “I am young so I like to have hope,” he said. “Maybe with everyone watching them like hawks, the Israelis will behave.

I think that if there are no suicide bomb attacks, they will, because they must be tired of the whole fight, too.” After the signing of the 1993 accord, the Palestinians, particularly those in the Gaza Strip, experienced hardships they did not anticipate.

Owing to a series of terrorist attacks, the Israelis imposed frequent border closings, denied many work permits and tightened security at checkpoints. Many Palestinians felt the lands they had been granted — mostly cities — were bubbles that they were trapped in. “Forget about the larger peace,” said Moussa Zubedi, 27, who is unemployed.

“Palestine is my homeland, and I want the right to go from one place to another without restrictions. So let them do just that, the safe-passage thing.” At a busy intersection, a crowd gathered to debate, as vendors poured shots of Turkish coffee. An older man, Khalil Abi Hawa, chastised the younger ones for not having vision.

“This is a step toward getting freedom and then independence,” he said. “Even the details are astonishing; maybe you are too young to realize. Now we will get an airport, a Palestinian airport!” He added, “We will have borders, then a state. You guys must keep your eye on the prize.”

Notwithstanding the dove and olive branch on the window of the Peace Taxi Station in the West Bank town of Ramallah, it was business as usual yesterday, the day after a new peace accord was signed in Washington.

CP-1998-028 →

· The Times (Trenton, NJ) · page A12

Palestinian teen dead as accord sparks infighting

RAMALLAH, West Bank (AP) — In a major rupture within the ranks of the Palestinian leadership, members of Yasser Arafat’s political faction fought Palestinian security forcesyesterday. A teenager died in the violence.

The fighting followed an attempt by Palestinian military intelligence to seize unlicensed weapons and inspect files belonging to Arafat’s Fatah faction. A crackdown on illegal arms was among tough new security measures Arafat agreed to at last week’s Israeli-Palestinian summit.

The clash alarmed Palestinian leaders, who fear that the pressures of putting the U.S.-brokered agreement into effect will wind up pitting Palestinian against Palestinian. Many of its provisions, such as reining in Islamic militants and halting anti-Israel incitement, are extremely unpopular and will be difficult politically for Arafat’s government to impose.

Former Cabinet minister Hanan Ashrawi, who was present when the outburst began in the West Bank town of Ramallah, called it a result of an accord that put too much emphasis on Israeli security at Palestinian expense. “This is very dangerous,” she said. “If this situation is allowed to continue, we would be facing an internal breakdown.”

The fighting broke out as Marwan Barghouti, the leader of Fatah in the West Bank, was addressing a group of about 100 supporters outside the Palestinian Authority headquarters and the offices of Gov. Mustafa Isa.

SOME OF the Fatah activists picked up stones and hurled them over a fence into the compound and at plainclothes intelligence agents who were watching the gathering from the sidelines, witnesses said. Intelligence agents hurled rocks back at the crowd. Some agents then fired from the second- and third-floor windows, with some of the gunfire directed into the crowd.

About the same time, armed Fatah members arrived on the scene, firing shots into the air. One man was injured and a Fatah activist, 16-year-old Wassim Tarifi, died of a gunshot wound to the head. After he was shot, the gunfire stopped, and leaders from both sides quickly withdrew for a meeting.

CP-1998-026 →

· The Times (Trenton, NJ) · page A12

Jewish settlers protest accord, rip Netanyahu

OFRA, West Bank (AP) — Jewish settlers demonstrated across the West Bank yesterday, vowing to scuttle a new Mideast peace deal that gives more land to Palestinians. The protests came hours before Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu returned to Israel, hoping to convince hard-liners that the deal he made with Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat was the best possible.

Arriving back in Israel to a red-carpet welcome, the Israeli leader said security concessions won from the Palestinians during the nine-day summit outside Washington would justify ceding more West Bank land. “We are returning after a long and difficult effort to bring ... security and peace to Israel,” he said.

“We achieved such a deal — we achieved the best deal ... We did something good for the state of Israel.”

At least 20 settlers — once Netanyahu’s staunchest supporters — were arrested and two police officers were hurt in yesterday’s widespread demonstrations, including one outside Israel’s international airport after Netanyahu’s arrival.

A police officer hauls away a settler who sat in the middle of a main road during a protest in the West Bank at the Jewish settlement of Orfra yesterday. Jewish settlers protesting the new peace accord staged road-blocking protests across the West Bank yesterday. AP photo

CP-1998-027 →

· Southwest Times Record · Fort Smith

Sticks and stones

“School children everywhere chant a version of this playground doggerel: ‘Sticks and stones can break my bones, but words will never hurt me.’ But in Israel the words can kill, too.”

Three years after Rabin's assassination, a column about political language and what it licenses — in Fort Smith, Arkansas.

CP-1998-020 →

· The New York Times

Palestinians Celebrate Israeli Exit

Residents climbed on the vehicles of Palestinian policemen in the West Bank town of Qabayita yesterday. They were celebrating the Palestinian control of 220 square miles of land that Israel turned over. Page A8. (Associated Press)

CP-1998-024 →

· The Manhattan Mercury

Palestinians open gateway to world

Associated Press

DAHANIEH, Gaza Strip — Taking a major step toward statehood, the Palestinians today opened Gaza International Airport, their first gateway to the world. An Egypt Air plane was the first to land on the desert tarmac in the southern Gaza Strip, arriving at 8:30 a.m. to the cheers of dozens of Palestinian dignitaries waiting on the ground.

The emotional highlight was the touchdown of the first Palestinian Airlines plane, a Fokker 50. After landing, the pilot and co-pilot raised Palestinian flags high above their heads as they descended the stairway. A crowd of thousands of Palestinians who had pushed their way onto the airfield to join the celebrations chanted “Allahu Akbar!(God is great).”

“You are a beautiful sight,” Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat later told the Palestinian crew in the VIP lounge, lavishly decorated with deep red Oriental carpets and wall mosaics. Arafat walked from the lounge to the tarmac to greet each of the seven planes that landed today.

“This is a preparation for the declaration of the Palestinian state,” Arafat said, smiling broadly and flashing a victory sign. Israel controls the airspace and has the authority to shut down the airfield at any time. It will monitor arriving passengers and cargo and can keep travelers or goods out if it considers them a danger to Israeli security.

Disputes over security arrangements delayed the airport opening for more than two years. The $75 million airport will provide a boost to the troubled Palestinian economy, permitting the export of Palestinian flowers and farm produce that has been shipped out via Israel, often with delays. The airport also will make it easier for Palestinians to travel abroad.

Until now, their only options were to get permission to enter Israel and fly out of Ben Gurion International airport near Tel Aviv or travel by land to Jordan and catch flights there.

Palestinian cheers as the first plane lands at Gaza International Airport.

CP-1998-037 →

· The Macon Telegraph · Macon · page 1

U.N. General Assembly lists anti-Semitism as form of racism

N.Y. Times News Service, United Nations

“UNITED NATIONS — For the first time in more than half a century, the U.N. General Assembly decided Wednesday to list anti-Semitism as a form of racism.

The resolution was adopted by consensus on the 50th anniversary of the international convention against genocide and a day before the United Nations celebrates the 50th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. In a resolution introduced by Indonesia on behalf of more than 100 developing nations, the Assembly also warned against new avenues for disseminating the ‘repugnant views’ of racist organizations… General Assembly resolutions do not carry the force of Security Council resolutions, but they reflect world opinion.

In the past, the Assembly had voted to equate Zionism with racism.… This year the Clinton administration lobbied hard to include a condemnation of anti-Semitism in the resolution, titled Measures to Combat Contemporary Forms of Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerance.

‘The U.N. is about tolerance and inclusion,’ said Felice Gaer, director of Jacob Blaustein Institute for the Advancement of Human Rights, at the American Jewish Committee. ‘But this is the first time that the U.N. has used the phrase ‘anti-Semitism,’ which has been fought over for years and kept out of any resolutions.’… The monitor, known as a special rapporteur, was asked to examine racist incidents ‘against blacks, Arabs and Muslims’ and ‘xenophobia, Negrophobia, anti-Semitism and related intolerance.’

Secretary General Kofi Annan… said he was aware that ‘the United Nations is regarded by many as biased against the State of Israel.’ ‘I know that Israelis are offended when other nations’ delegates leave the room as Israelis rise to speak,’ he said.”

Seven years after the repeal the same body names antisemitism as a form of racism for the first time in its history, and the wire story explains it by reminding readers what the Assembly used to say instead. Three years later the parallel forum at Durban voted to put the old formula back.

CP-1998-010 →

· The Abilene Reporter-News · Abilene

Palestinians quell violence before Clinton visit

BETHLEHEM, West Bank — Wisps of tear gas enveloped a banner welcoming President Clinton on Saturday in the West Bank, where Palestinian protesters briefly clashed with police and Israeli troops.

Seven protesters were injured before Palestinian police quelled the violence in Bethlehem hours before Clinton’s visit — a sign of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat’s determination to smooth the president’s trip. Clinton’s visit was meant to celebrate the U.S.-brokered Mideast peace agreement achieved at Wye River in October.

But the president will now try to salvage it as Israelis and Palestinians accuse each other of violating the deal. Palestinians strung a banner across the entrance to Bethlehem reading “Bill Clinton: Welcome to Palestine.” In a home above the banner, a family decorated their balcony for Christmas.

But the scene changed when masked youths chanting “Long Live Palestine!” began lobbing stones and firebombs at Israeli troops guarding the city entrance. The troops responded with rubber bullets. The Palestinians are angry because they say Israel has not met a commitment to release hundreds of Palestinians jailed for anti-Israel activities.

They say most of those released so far have been common criminals. The release of more anti-Israel prisoners “would be a real indication Israel is implementing” the peace agreement, Arafat said in Gaza after meeting with Jordanian Prime Minister Fayez Tarawmeh. The Palestinian protesters in Bethlehem said they were not opposed to the Clinton visit.

“I’m protesting by throwing stones so that my brother will be released from prison,” said 18-year-old Khaled Dakakta, slingshot in hand. “This is not timed for Clinton.”

Palestinian Christians festoon their balcony with Christmas decorations below a banner which reads, “Bill Clinton: Welcome to Palestine” in preparation for President Clinton’s upcoming visit in the West Bank town of Bethlehem Saturday. Clinton arrives this weekend for a three-day visit aimed at salvaging the Israeli-Palestinian peace process.

Paper and date corrected from Springfield News Sun, 1 July 1990. The folio on the scan reads “Abilene Reporter-News · Sunday, Dec. 13, 1998 · 30A” under the section head World & Nation, read twice at magnification by two readers working separately. The article reports the Wye River agreement of October 1998, Netanyahu as prime minister and Clinton’s visit to Bethlehem, none of which is possible in 1990. The stored headline was the lettering on a banner inside the photograph and has also been corrected.

CP-1990-020 →

· Juneau Empire

Palestinians quell violence ahead of Clinton visit

BETHLEHEM, West Bank – Wisps of tear gas enveloped a banner welcoming President Clinton on Saturday in the West Bank, where Palestinian protesters briefly clashed with police and Israeli troops.

Seven protesters were injured before Palestinian police quelled the violence in Bethlehem hours before Clinton’s visit – a sign of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat’s determination to smooth the president’s trip. Clinton’s visit was meant to celebrate the U.S.-brokered Mideast peace agreement achieved at Wye River in October.

But the president will now try to salvage it as Israelis and Palestinians accuse each other of violating the deal. Palestinians strung a banner across the entrance to Bethlehem reading “Bill Clinton: Welcome to Palestine.” In a home above the banner, a family decorated their balcony for Christmas.

But the scene changed when masked youths chanting “Long Live Palestine!” began lobbing stones and firebombs at Israeli troops guarding the city entrance. The troops responded with rubber bullets. The Palestinians are angry because they say Israel has not met a commitment to release hundreds of Palestinians jailed for anti-Israel activities.

They say most of those released so far have been common criminals. The release of more anti-Israel prisoners “would be a real indication Israel is implementing” the peace agreement, Arafat said in Gaza after meeting with Jordanian Prime Minister Fayez Tarawmeh. The Palestinian protesters in Bethlehem said they were not opposed to the Clinton visit.

“I’m protesting by throwing stones so that my brother will be released from prison,” said 18-year-old Khaled Dakakta, slingshot in hand. “This is not timed for Clinton.” The highlight of the visit will be Clinton’s attendance at a meeting of the Palestine National Council on Monday evening.

The council is to remove clauses from the Palestinian charter that call for Israel’s destruction. He is also to light a Palestinian Christmas tree in Bethlehem’s Manger Square on Monday. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said he will not go ahead with a planned withdrawal from further West Bank territory unless the clauses are removed by vote.

But Arafat said that a formal vote is not necessary. Although he likely has a majority behind him, Arafat may be backing off a vote because he could lack a two-thirds quorum at the 600-member council’s meeting.

Stone’s throw from trouble: A Palestinian youth uses a slingshot to fire a rock at Israeli troups in the West Bank town of Bethlehem Saturday. (JACQUELINE LARMA / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS) — Welcome: An Israeli soldier, watching for stone-throwing Palestinian youths, stands near a sign welcoming President Clinton to Palestine. (RUTH FREMSON / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS)

CP-1998-014 →

· Roanoke Times · Roanoke

Peace mission tests the survival skills of Clinton, Netanyahu

The leaders of both nations are facing crises of confidence in their leadership and fear the impact of the other’s actions.

JERUSALEM — President Clinton arrived in Israel just before midnight Saturday on an intricate mission to revive the peace effort, a centerpiece of his foreign policy.

On a cool, overcast night, Clinton was greeted with trumpets and an honor guard, but also with flinty remarks from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who declared that the Palestinians had not kept their commitments “and have reverted to past practices.”

In an extraordinary moment of symmetrical political peril, the arrival ceremony brought together two men who are facing crises of confidence in their leadership, each of whom has reason to fear the other’s potential impact on his own precarious position.

The House will vote late this week on Clinton’s impeachment, and just days later the Israeli parliament is scheduled to hold a vote of confidence in Netanyahu’s government. In a brief, sober address, Clinton — who is traveling with his wife, Hillary, and daughter, Chelsea — expressed understanding of Israeli concerns.

“We are determined that Israel’s just requirements for security be met,” he said. But he added that “for two peoples who are fated to share this land,” peace was “the only choice that can avert still more years of bloodshed, apprehension and sorrow.”

Netanyahu shattered his support on the right and jeopardized his hold on office by cooperating with Clinton in October and agreeing to cede more land to the Palestinians, under an accord reached at the Wye River Plantation in Maryland. Now, when failure of that agreement could make Clinton look weak, Netanyahu has every reason not to see it through.

And the president risks further erosion in his congressional support if he is seen as leaning too hard on the Israelis.

In his nine-minute remarks — three times as long as the president’s — Netanyahu warned, “Agreements not anchored in security, agreements which only serve to conceal belligerent aims, agreements brazenly flouted and violated with violence inevitably lead not to peace but to the continuation and intensification of conflict.”

With impeachment and his stewardship of foreign affairs linked in the minds of many members of Congress, Clinton is under intense pressure to perform during his three-day visit.

American and Palestinian flags hang from a building Saturday in Gaza. The flags will be hung along President Clinton’s route Monday.

CP-1998-015 →

· Roanoke Times · Roanoke

The Clintons' Palestine message

Stipulated: Hillary Rodham Clinton weighs her every public word to advance her husband’s policies and interests.

Therefore, her decision last week to declare via global satellite, “I think that it will be in the long-term interest of the Middle East for Palestine to be a state” must be taken as a calculated move by both Clintons to ratchet up the pressure on Israel.

“We have been waiting for such a signal from any American administration for a long time,” responded the leading Arab spokesperson here. Hillary’s signal was unambiguous; she used the word “state” nine times in promulgating the Clinton policy.

On cue, the presidential press secretary then dismissed the first lady’s carefully crafted statement as the uncleared mouthings of some ditzy spouse who would not again be “venturing into the Middle East peace process anytime soon.” Supposedly not official administration policy.

But the Clintons’ message was received exactly as the presidential couple intended: unless Israel obeyed the Clinton summons to a summit at which Washington would decide exactly how much territory Israel would hand over to the Palestinians, the United States would escalate its intervention.

Not only would the world’s superpower “re-examine its approach,” as Secretary of State Albright warned. The Clintons have signaled they are prepared to go further — to dictate not just the scope of interim steps, but to impose terms of the final settlement. Palestinian statehood is an issue that has up to now been reserved for the final talks.

Israel takes the position that Palestinian autonomy should suffice for self-government, and that statehood’s sovereignty would enable Yasser Arafat to make alliances with Iraq and others to threaten Israel’s security. To be realistic, statehood is in the cards.

But no responsible Israeli leader can let it be taken for granted because it is a significant card to play. That major concession to Palestinian aspirations would demonstrate Israel’s willingness to take a great risk for peace.

CP-1998-016 →

· Connecticut Post

Palestine leaders renounce call for Israel's destruction

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Stirring Palestinian passions for statehood, President Clinton stood witness Monday as hundreds of Palestinian leaders renounced a call for the destruction of Israel. Clinton urged “legitimate rights for Palestinians, real security for Israel.”

The Palestinian vote — registered with a show of hands and applause — removed a contentious issue dating back to 1964 from the crisis-shrouded Mideast peace process. Clinton, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu planned a three-way meeting early today.

At stake was the revival of the Wye River land-for-security accord, nearing collapse with Israelis and the Palestinians accusing each other of violating the deal. Netanyahu told reporters in Jerusalem that the Palestinian vote would “lead to a real peace, a lasting peace, not a minute-long peace.”

But at the same time, he told reporters, Arafat must renounce plans to declare statehood and take steps to end the violence in the region. Just as Netanyahu told Clinton on Sunday that the Palestinians were violating peace accords, Arafat told the president Monday that Israel was guilty of violations.

He called on Israel to release jailed Palestinians — “our heroes in prison.” Netanyahu has vowed not to release prisoners he regards as terrorists. Secretary of State Madeleine Albright urged Netanyahu to move ahead with West Bank troop withdrawals, although she acknowledged Israel probably will not conduct a pullback by Friday.

“We hope very much that it can be as close to the schedule as possible,” she said. Pressing both sides to reconcile, Clinton said, “I think there will be more breakdowns, frankly. But I think there will be more breakthroughs as well.”

Addressing former guerrilla fighters and other top Palestinians, Clinton said the peace process has brought rewards: elections and self-government in Gaza and the West Bank, Israeli troop redeployments, relations with Washington and a Palestinian airport.

But he also acknowledged Palestinian bitterness over Israeli restrictions on people and commerce, land confiscation and Israeli settlements. He said Israel, for its part, has justifiable concerns about Palestinian violence. Tentative plans for a three-way meeting at the Erez border crossing between Israel and Gaza were abandoned Monday night.

White House spokesman Joe Lockhart said all three leaders decided to postpone the meeting until early this morning, “because of the logistics of trying to put it together.” But an Israeli official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said Clinton had wanted Israel to give something to the Palestinians in exchange for the PNC action.

Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, second from left, holds up piece of ribbon from the inauguration of Gaza International Airport Monday as President Clinton put his piece of riboon into his pocket. At far left is Arafat's wife, Suha, and at right is first lady Hillary Rodham Clinton.

CP-1998-011 →

· The New York Times · page 36–39

The One-State Solution

Why the only answer to Middle East peace is Palestinians and Israelis living as equal citizens under one flag.

By Edward Said

“There is no example in history,” Said quotes David Ben-Gurion as saying in 1944, “of a people saying we agree to renounce our country, let another people come and settle here and outnumber us.” […] Thus we are the victims of the victims, the refugees of the refugees. […] There can be no reconciliation unless both peoples, two communities of suffering, resolve that their existence is a secular fact, and that it has to be dealt with as such.

Not separate and not equal: Since 1948, Jews and Arabs have become more, not less, enmeshed, as in Hebron, where Israeli soldiers patrol the West Bank city holy to both.

Edward Said, professor of literature at Columbia University, is the author most recently of “Peace and Its Discontents.” A former member of the Palestine National Council, he broke publicly with Yasir Arafat in 1993 over the Oslo peace accords. — the author note printed at the foot of page 38.

CP-1999-022 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

How Jews Turn Houses Into Homes on West Bank

By DEBORAH SONTAG

ELI, West Bank, March 16 — From this entrenched Jewish settlement on a bluff above the Palestinian territories, the vista is dotted for miles around with what the Israelis call “facts on the ground.” Almost every hilltop bears a scattering of mobile homes, evidence of the continuing and willful expansion of the Jewish presence in the West Bank.

The hills are truly alive with the sound of hammers, buzz saws and bulldozers as Israelis — with the help of Palestinian laborers — dig into the land. They aim to sink their roots as deeply as possible in the hope that the acres they occupy now will never be turned over to the Palestinian Authority.

“When they built the hill, we climbed on up,” said Oria Levinstein, 17, whose family moved from Eli, which is almost suburban, into a tin shack on a barren hillside nearby. “We felt like pioneers. At first it was horrible — no water, no electricity. But now we have our trailers, and it’s gorgeous. Look at this view!

At night you see all the land of Israel. What, we should let the Arabs have it?” For months Palestinian leaders have criticized the growth of Jewish settlements in the West Bank, particularly in the rocky hills between the Palestinian cities of Ramallah and Nablus.

And in the last few days, American diplomats have turned up the pressure on Israel to contain the expansion, butting heads with the Israelis in a war of words played out through the media.

New Jewish homes near Ofra, on the West Bank. Some Jews hope that larger settlements — they call them “facts on the ground” — will give them rights to more land, but both Palestinians and Americans are angry.

Date check: The running head across the top reads “THE NEW YORK TIMES INTERNATIONAL WEDNESDAY, MARC…” — the rest of the date is cropped off the right edge of the scan. March 17, 1999 was a Wednesday, and the story dateline reads “ELI, West Bank, March 16”, both consistent with the slide date.

CP-1999-018 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinians Seem Resigned to a Delay in Statehood

By DEBORAH SONTAG

GAZA, April 27 — Several miles from the seaside compound where Palestinian leaders locked themselves away today to deliberate the timing of a declaration of statehood, Motee and Ali Anan sat shrugging amid porcelain toilets in their luxury-bathroom store on the main boulevard in town.

The Anans, uncle and nephew, are not hanging on the outcome of the meeting of the 120-member Central Council of the Palestine Liberation Organization. They are barely curious; few people here seem to care. It seems clear to them that under international pressure, the Palestinian leader Yasir Arafat has already decided to delay the declaration he once promised for May 4.

“Today is only a show,” Ali Anan said, gazing at a $1,000 toilet, sink and bidet set. “It is theater, and we don’t have to wait for the curtain to come down to know how it will end.” If the meeting was theater, it seemed to be a rehearsal of a democratic process, with the Palestinian leaders reportedly engaging in fiery debate.

But despite guest appearances by such opponents as Sheik Ahmed Yassin, the Islamic fundamentalist, Mr. Arafat seemed to be guiding the council members toward a scripted conclusion: a statehood declaration must be postponed, and negotiations with the Israelis continued.

“We are going through a very delicate period in the history of our people, a period during which we cannot afford to make any mistakes,” the official Palestinian news agency WAFA quoted Mr. Arafat as saying. “We don’t need to affirm our state because we are actually exercising statehood.”

Under the terms of the Oslo peace accord, May 4 is the day when the Palestinians’ transitional government is to expire and a target date for the conclusion of final peace talks between Israelis and Palestinians.

Residents of Gaza gathered yesterday at the office of Yasir Arafat to urge him to declare statehood on May 4, as he has promised. But most Gazans seem to recognize that with peace talks stalled, the time is not right.

CP-1999-021 →

· Las Cruces Sun News · Las Cruces, NM · page B-11

Israeli Arabs face uphill battle for equal status

The Washington Post

JERUSALEM — An Israeli Arab who is neatly groomed, cleanshaven and possessed of a serious travel bug, Jabbour Jabbour wanted to be a flight attendant for El Al — undeterred by the fact that not one of the Israeli national airline’s 1,000 flight attendants is an Arab.

Jabbour, a Christian, seemed to fit the bill: 30-year-old travel agent; Israeli citizen in good standing; fluent in English, Hebrew and Arabic; exceptionally well traveled. In the early ’90s, he studied travel and tourism in Toronto. But this month, for the third time in three years, El Al turned him down.

The state-owned airline, which accepts only one in 20 flight attendant applicants, said Jabbour failed its extensive tests. That virtually none of its flight attendants or 2,400 other workers is an Arab had nothing to do with his rejection, El Al said. “We’re looking for the top people,” said El Al spokesman Nachman Klieman.

“We’re looking for the level of employee who can provide the best service, and we’ll continue to maintain this high level.” Jabbour doesn’t buy it, and neither do many of the 1 million or so Israelis — a sixth of the population — who are Arab. He is certain he passed the El Al tests and accuses the airline of screening out Arab applicants.

“They don’t want to give us any answers,” said Jabbour, who is taking his case to a labor court, alleging ethnic discrimination. “They won’t say where I failed or what’s wrong with me or what my negative side was. ... We know one thing. There is no Arab in this company, and they are continuing this racist regime and discrimination, and it’s very obvious.”

Unlike their brethren in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, the mostly Muslim Israeli Arabs are Palestinians who remained in Israel when the state was born in 1948. They are full citizens who vote in national and local elections, hold seats in parliament, attend state schools and speak Hebrew. An Israeli Arab woman, Rana Raslan, was recently named Miss Israel for 1999.

But they also constitute an underclass in a society whose standards of wealth have drawn even with some Western European countries. In Jewish-owned hotels, Arabs are usually the busboys and dishwashers. In Jewish-owned service stations, Arabs pump the gas. The poverty rate for Israeli Arabs, about 30 percent, is nearly twice that of Israelis overall.

Jabbour’s case, like similar ones before it, flashed across Israel’s news pages and talk shows this week, then faded, leaving scarcely a ripple. Most Israeli Jews seem unperturbed that huge national enterprises like the airline, electricity and telephone companies, which have thousands of employees each, hire no more than a handful of Arabs.

Civil rights lawyers are trying to pry open the doors of employment for Israeli Arabs, but they often have difficulty proving their cases. Despite the near-absence of Arab workers in many government ministries and public-sector companies, they say, it’s hard to show an official policy of discrimination.

Israeli courts have not tended to accept the lopsided employment patterns as proof of discriminatory intent. And often, Arab applicants are excluded because firms ask for proof of army service, for which Israeli Arabs are ineligible. Civil rights activists say the results speak for themselves. There is scarcely an Arab employee among El Al’s 3,400 workers, they say.

Just a few dozen of the electric company’s 14,000 employees are Arabs. In government ministries themselves, perhaps 1 percent of employees are Arabs, civil rights lawyers say. The employment pattern in the public sector helps fuel 20 percent unemployment among Israeli Arabs, more than twice the national average.

And it serves as a reminder that 51 years after its independence, Israel still hasn’t settled the question of whether it is a country of all its citizens. Some Israeli Arabs say it’s a system of apartheid masquerading as a democracy.

“We face this discrimination everywhere, especially in government corporations,” said Hassan Jabareen, an attorney who is director of Adalah, a legal center for Arab rights in Israel that models itself after the NAACP. “It’s very, very harsh, and barely can you find Arabs there.”

There are some scattered signs that Israel’s political elites may be ready to chip away at the decades-old pattern. After Jabbour’s case was publicized this week, a few politicians — Israeli liberals as well as Arab members of parliament — said they will boycott El Al until it begins hiring Arabs.

Whole article transcribed. For the pattern question this is the spine clipping of the 1999 end of the range: it shows “Israeli Arabs” functioning as the unmarked American term, the word “Palestinians” present but quarantined in a single explanatory clause, and two Palestinian citizens of Israel speaking at length and choosing “Arab” themselves.

CP-1999-024 →

· The Beaufort Gazette · Beaufort

History of Palestinian-Israeli conflict can't be ignored

By RAYMOND VONHARTEN

David Harb (Letter July 17) asked how a Palestinian “right of return” would destroy Israel. I am not sure he understands the ramifications of this concept.

“Right of return” does not only refer to Palestinians returning to a future Palestinian state, or even to areas controlled by the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank and Gaza, but pertains to Israel proper, including the Israeli cities of Jaffa and Haifa. If this notion is implemented, the destruction of Israel would be a simple matter of demographics.

In order to maintain its status as a Jewish state, its population must remain predominantly Jewish. An influx of Palestinians would alter Israel's population and national character, which would effectively bring an end to the state. Second, the Palestine National Covenant and the harsh statements attributed to Arab leaders are not relics of 1948 as Harb indicated.

The PLO and its covenant were established in 1964 (not 1948) as symbolic gesture of the Egyptian government, which at the time was under intense pressure from other Arab states for not confronting Israel and for not providing enough support for the Palestinian cause. Of the 33 articles in the Covenant, as many as 30 directly or indirectly pertain to the destruction of Israel.

As to the recent amendment of the Covenant, it cannot be substantiated that the Palestine National Council (PNC) voted “to a man” to change its provisions. Article 33 of the Covenant states that only a majority of a two-thirds of the 572-member PNC (446 members) can modify the document.

I watched on Israeli television as Palestinian delegates in Gaza symbolically raised their hands in unison to vote for some resolution, but it is not known for sure who — or how many — actually voted for the measure. Thus, an ambiguous method of voting to rescind the disputed articles was presented, so this apparent Palestinian concession remains vague at best.

Furthermore, if the covenant has been changed, what are its new terms? The publication of such document would do much to clarify the matter and reassure the Israeli public of the PLO's peaceful intentions. Third, the much touted 1988 PLO denunciation of terrorism to which Harb refers is ambiguous, if not contradictory, as well.

While it did say it would reject any form of terrorism, the PLO stated in an accompanying resolution that it still had the right to “resist foreign occupation, colonialism, and racial discrimination” and the PLO had always claimed that its attacks on Israel were legitimate military operations, even those aimed at civilians.

The reason this statement was issued by the PLO was not to reconcile peacefully with Israel, but to impress the U.S. government, with whom the PLO desired to establish more formal dialogue at that time.

Harb fails to mention however, that the U.S. government severed relations with the PLO in 1990 after Arafat refused to reprimand a PLO-member organization that carried out a terrorist attack. It should also not be forgotten that Arafat and the PLO supported Saddam Hussein after the Iraqi takeover of Kuwait.

More recently, in September 1996, Palestinian civilians and security forces clashed with the Israeli military because Israel opened one end of an archeological tunnel in Jerusalem's Old City that provided an easier exit for tourists.

Some Palestinian leaders falsely claimed that the Israelis were destroying the Dome of the Rock, Islam's third holiest site, which angered much of the Palestinian populace. Sixty-nine Palestinians and 14 Israelis were killed and more than 1,200 were wounded on both sides.

This use of incitement under false pretenses is perhaps indicative of the Palestinian leadership's inclination to use violence to further its political objectives. Fourth, in the spirit of providing factual information, I offer a clarification of Harb's reference to the 1948 Deir Yassen massacre, which, he writes, was an “Israeli military” operation. This is incorrect.

The Deir Yassen incident occurred on April 9, 1948, more than a month before the establishment of the State of Israel (May 14-15) and the formation of the Israel Defense Forces (May 26). The massacre was carried out by an extreme Jewish organization (known as the Irgun) that operated largely outside of the command structure of the principal Jewish military force, the Haganah.

Harb also writes that Palestinian women were raped during the massacre. In truth, events of that day remain largely unknown; whether rape did or did not occur is mere speculation and to make such claim appears sensationalist. I am also puzzled by Harb's statements about ethnic cleansing and the Holocaust.

It is a well-known fact that the Arab states did not engage in the systematic killing of Jews in Palestine as the Germans did in Europe, but to argue that the Arab states were not bent on driving the Jews out of region defies the fact that five Arab states did attack Israel with the intent of defeating the Israelis and destroying the Jewish state.

Harb is correct in writing that we should be working on current issues that can create a lasting peace in the region; however, the history of the conflict cannot be neglected and ignored in making decisions that have such a significant impact on both the present, and future, of the region.

A guest opinion answering a letter by David Harb printed in the same paper on 17 July 1999. Harb's letter is not in this archive and is an acquisition target. The tagline at the foot reads: Raymond VonHarten lives in Beaufort.

CP-1999-002 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore · page 11A

Release of Palestinian prisoners tangled in years of suffering, rage

Jailed men are seen as freedom fighters or common criminals

By Ann LoLordo, Sun Foreign Staff

KUBER, Occupied West Bank — To Palestinians, Fachri Barghouti is a hero, a freedom fighter who helped kill a Jewish bus driver in the war against the Israeli occupiers. Sentenced to a life prison term, he has spent 20 years in an Israeli jail. To Israelis, Barghouti and others like him are men with blood on their hands. For their crimes they should stay in prison.

But Barghouti's crime took place in 1978 when the Palestine Liberation Organization waged a terrorist campaign against Israel. Today, Israel and the Palestinians are at peace, but the release of prisoners like Barghouti was the central point of passionate disagreement in the way of a deal that would revive their peace process.

It was a thorny political problem for both Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak and Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat. “Arafat should insist on releasing the prisoners before doing anything else,” said Shadi Barghouti, who was only 8 months old when his father went to prison. Israeli victims feel passionately the opposite.

“All the time, all the time, they are renewing our pain,” said Sylvia Hatuka, whose 28-year-old son Shlomo was shot dead by a terrorist 13 years ago. “Why should they release terrorists with blood on their hands?” Once Barak releases Palestinian prisoners with “blood on their hands” he “will get what he deserves — he won't be prime minister.”

She weeps at the thought of her son and what might have been if he had not been murdered by Palestinian terrorists. “I waited for him to get married. I'm a widow, without a husband. … I don't know what to do with myself.” As many as 2,000 Palestinian security prisoners are in Israeli jails. Fachri Barghouti, 45, is one of them.

A house painter, Barghouti joined Arafat's Fatah political movement as a young man, according to his wife, Samira, and son, Shadi. He joined five other Fatah members in an April 1978 attack on a bus driver near the West Bank settlement of Halamish, about 25 miles northwest of Jerusalem.

Barghouti participated in the attack to avenge the death of his brother, who was killed in south Lebanon in 1976 during an Israeli bombing raid, according to his family.

His family's arguments about why Barghouti should be released reflect the sentiments of many Palestinians who have waited for years to be reunited with their imprisoned husbands, fathers, sons, brothers and uncles. “That was a different era,” said Shadi's mother, Samira, referring to the late 1970s when her husband was active in the Fatah movement.

“Even the Israelis have killed many of us.” “My father was arrested in the 1970s when the time was just for resistance,” said Barghouti's 22-year-old son, Shadi. “Nobody talked about peace. If my father did what he did after Oslo, we might accept that phrase — that he has blood on his hands. But why are we talking about this now?”

At the time of her husband's arrest, Samira Barghouti was pregnant with the couple's second child. The couple was living in Barghouti's home village of Kuber on the Israeli-occupied West Bank.

Then, Palestinian men joined the resistance movement, a struggle led by Yasser Arafat and others who now hold responsible positions in the peace-time government of the Palestinian Authority. When Israel made peace with the Palestinians in 1993, Arafat and other top Palestinian leaders who had led the fight returned to the West Bank and Gaza a year later.

The peace accords committed the Israelis to free Palestinian prisoners “as a confidence building measure.” The releases dragged out over the years; suspicion replaced confidence. “We are not benefiting from this peace. They are playing with our nerves.

We don't want to see only the leadership benefit,” said Barghouti's sister-in-law, Asmahan, as she sat in the three-story family home in Kuber. “We do not need peace with just the leadership.” Shadi Barghouti is an interior decorator now with plans for his own wedding. Shadi says he has known his father only as a prisoner in jail.

During his monthly visits, his father is separated from him by a wire screen. The visiting room is crowded with other families and prisoners. “I remember the one time I have hugged him,” Shadi said. It was a special occasion and prisoners were allowed to visit with their families without a barrier separating them. “I was 14 years old. I cannot describe it. He's my father.

But I never felt the feeling of a father and son. I have no memories with him,” Shadi said. “I have never lived with him.” Over the years the family has received financial help — ranging from $100 to $200 a month — from the PLO and then the Palestinian Authority. Before then, Shadi says, his uncles cared for him, his brother and mother.

As the Fateh movement put aside the struggle to follow Arafat and the path toward peace, so did Barghouti, Shadi said. Twice before, he said, it seemed as though his father would be released from jail. Of the six men who took part in the murder of the bus driver, two fled to Jordan immediately and four were imprisoned.

Of the four, only Shadi's father and cousin remain in jail, according to the son. “We are not against Israel,” said Shadi. “We are not against the peace. We just want our beloved people out.” But Sylvia Hatuka only remembers the night 13 years ago when her son Shlomo was killed. It was a Saturday evening just days before Passover. “Where are you going?”

Hatuka asked her son, a bus driver. That night Shlomo Hatuka's bus route took him through the West Bank, near the settlement of Halamish, about 25 miles northwest of Jerusalem. “They reached Beit Aryeh,” Hatuka said, referring to a nearby settlement in the area. “And they encountered three terrorists. They set a fire on the road to stop the bus.”

Because the road was narrow, Hatuka's son was forced to stop the bus. “He couldn't turn around,” the mother said. The terrorists stormed the bus, firing a machine gun through the bus door. Her son was shot in the stomach. “He was buried on the eve of Passover,” she said. This was not the incident that Barghouti was involved in.

But like him, two of the three Palestinians who killed her son are still in jail. As far as Hatuka is concerned they should never be let out. “Why should they come out … [flashing] a victory sign with their hands?” Hatuka demanded.

Waiting for release: Samira Barghouti and her sons, Hadi, 21, (sitting) and Shadi, 22, say their father and husband, Fachri Barghouti, was a guerrilla fighter at war with Israel when he helped kill a Jewish bus driver. (SHARON ABBADY : SPECIAL TO THE SUN)

Datelined KUBER, Occupied West Bank. A second photograph on the same page shows Israeli Foreign Minister David Levy after meeting Madeleine Albright about the treatment of Arab-Americans, and belongs to a different story.

CP-1999-003 →

· Press of Atlantic City · Atlantic City

Israel’s top court bans agents from torturing suspects

Twelve years after the Landau Commission permitted it, the Israeli Supreme Court restricts it. Two American papers in this archive carried the ruling on the same morning and both put it in the headline.

CP-1999-013 →

· Tri-City Herald · Kennewick

Israel Supreme Court outlaws torture of Palestinian suspects

The same ruling, in Washington state, with one word changed: bans becomes outlaws, and the suspects are identified as Palestinian.

CP-1999-014 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Of Bombs and Israeli Arabs, and Years of Loyalty

By JOEL GREENBERG

MASHHAD, Israel, Sept. 7 — There was no funeral in this village today for Nazal Krayim, an Israeli Arab who was killed on Sunday when a car he was in blew up in the port city of Haifa. His body was not brought home, but taken directly to the cemetery. There were no mosque prayers, no wreaths, no Koran verses broadcast over loudspeakers.

There was only a heavy sense of grief and shame hanging over this community of [illegible],000, in the hills of Galilee near Nazareth. Mr.

Krayim’s death, along with those of two other Israeli Arabs in a second car that exploded in the resort at Tiberias, sent shock waves through Israeli Arab communities today after the identities of the men were made public by the police.

Here and in nearby Daburiya, which was home to the other two men, people struggled to come to terms with what looked like the first suicide car-bombing attempts by Israeli Arabs — the kind of attacks carried out previously by Palestinian militants from the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Although doubts about the loyalty of the one million Arab citizens of Israel linger among Jewish Israelis, and although the Israeli Arabs sympathize with the national aspirations of their Palestinian brothers, few Israeli Arabs have been involved in anti-Jewish attacks.

So the revelation that Israeli Arabs were involved in the explosions on Sunday horrified many here, raising fears that they might all be tarred with the same brush. “This is the blackest day of my life,” said Mr. Krayim’s brother, Mohammed, a 56-year-old schoolteacher, as he sat in his house with stunned relatives.

“In my worst nightmares I never imagined such a thing. The whole family condemns this and we feel ashamed. “We are proud of our loyalty to the state, and we seek peace and coexistence. We beg forgiveness from all the people of Israel, first of all the Jews, as well as the Arabs. Islam calls for mercy, not only to human beings but to animals and the trees.

A person who carries out terrorist attacks is a heretic.” Just a few years ago, Mr. Krayim recalled, he had gathered his students to demonstrate on the streets of Mashhad against suicide bombings by Palestinian militants that had killed dozens of people in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem. “I drew 20 signs,” he said.

“We stood in the main street and cried out against the despicable suicide acts. God hates murder most of all.

In Daburiya, a mourners’ reception area for Jad Azaizeh, which would ordinarily be filled with neighbors, was left empty after he and two others were linked to car bombings Sunday, perhaps the first by Israeli Arabs.

Date check: The running head reads “THE NEW YORK TIMES INTERNATIONAL WEDNESDAY, SEPT…” — the day number and year are cropped off the right edge. Sept. 8, 1999 was a Wednesday, and the story dateline reads “MASHHAD, Israel, Sept. 7”, both consistent with the slide date.

CP-1999-019 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago · page 1

Newly freed Palestinians bittersweet

Arafat gets new deal’s land maps

Hugh Dellios, Tribune Foreign Correspondent, Bidu, West Bank

BIDU, West Bank — Behind the tears in Beyan Mansur’s eyes was barely restrained joy as she and other Palestinians on Thursday tasted the first fruits of peace in the Ehud Barak era. For the first time in eight years, the 10-year-old Palestinian girl clambered into the lap of her father, Samir, and kissed him on the cheeks.

Well-wishers streamed through the family’s home to embrace him. On the porch, women wailed and beat drums in bittersweet celebration, awaiting their turn to smother Samir in hugs as friends sent fireworks bursting over the village.

Samir Mansur was among 199 Palestinian security prisoners freed Thursday by Israel in the first step of implementing the peace treaty signed Sunday between Barak, the new Israeli prime minister, and Palestinian President Yasser Arafat. Hours later, Israel gave Arafat maps delineating another 7 percent of the occupied West Bank to be returned to the Palestinians.

While Israeli soldiers retain ultimate authority over the land and few Palestinians will benefit directly, Arafat’s police will control civilian affairs and no Jewish settlements will be allowed there… Although the Palestinians celebrated, they also expressed deep disappointment that 1,800 prisoners remain behind bars in Israel, where Israelis victimized by past terror attacks accused Barak of jeopardizing the nation’s security by freeing detainees who had murdered Palestinian collaborators… “What is going on here now symbolizes the victory of terrorism,” said Meir Indor, chairman of the Terror Victims Association, displaying wounds from two attacks by Palestinians, one when he was a soldier.

The bus then headed into the Palestinian city of Ramallah, where it was mobbed by well-wishers grabbing at the prisoners’ hands and tossing cigarettes into the open windows. At the central police station, the freed men received a heroes’ welcome.

“I think this gives us hope that the new government in Israel will go ahead and implement agreements,” said Marwan Barghouti, head of Arafat’s Fatah faction in the West Bank. “People were frustrated to see that every year we have a treaty without any change on the ground. I think this is an important day.”

“An unidentified Palestinian makes a victory sign with still-bound hands while being driven to freedom Thursday from an Israeli prison.” AP photo by Nasser Isstayeh

A ten-year-old girl who had not sat in her father’s lap for eight years, named in the first sentence of a Chicago Tribune story. The Israeli objection to the release is printed in the same column.

CP-1999-001 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Israel Relents, Letting Arab Live for Now In Jerusalem

By JOEL GREENBERG

JERUSALEM, Sept. 11 — On a visit to East Jerusalem in July, Interior Minister Natan Sharansky announced that he wanted to end an Israeli policy that in recent years had stripped hundreds of Palestinians of their right to live in the city. “The time has come to change this policy and to stop canceling the residence of inhabitants of East Jerusalem,” Mr.

Sharansky said. “We cannot talk about a united Jerusalem without proper treatment of the residents of East Jerusalem. We need to do everything to insure that residents of the east receive equal treatment to those of the west.”

Critics had long condemned the practice of stripping Palestinians of their East Jerusalem residency as a means of curbing the growth of the Arab population in this bitterly contested city. Interior Ministry figures show that nearly 5,[illegible]00 Palestinians had lost their East Jerusalem residency in this way since Israel captured the area in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war.

About half lost it during the three-year term of the rightist Government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who was defeated in national elections last May. A few days after Mr. Sharansky spoke, a test case landed in his lap.

Following standard procedure, his ministry had sent an eviction letter to another Palestinian, this time a member of a prominent Jerusalem family that has lived in the city for centuries. Dr.

Musa Budeiri, 53, a political science professor who has British citizenship and travels regularly abroad, was served notice that his residence had expired and that he was henceforth a tourist, required to leave Israel within 30 days. His British residence permit, obtained after he married a British woman, was cited as the reason for this move.

Under ministry regulations, East Jerusalem residence expires if someone has “moved the center of his life” outside the city for more than seven years, received a permanent residence permit in another country or become a foreign citizen.

Date check: No masthead or date line appears on this clipping — it is a single trimmed column beginning at the headline. The story dateline reads “JERUSALEM, Sept. 11”, consistent with publication on Sept. 12, 1999. The only other standing matter is a promotional box at the foot reading “Company News: Tuesday through Saturday, Business Day”, which is consistent with The New York Times but is not a dated masthead.

CP-1999-020 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinian Frustration

To the Editor: Re Thomas L. Friedman’s “Go Ahead, Bore Me!” (column, Sept. 22): Having just returned from a two-month visit to the West Bank, I can attest that the Palestinian silence represents not a promising acquiescence but a festering sense of hopelessness.

Palestinians feel demeaned and helpless against an Israeli occupying force whose tactics constantly remind them they are powerless to go about their daily lives. And they feel betrayed by the Palestinian leader, Yasir Arafat, who promised a just resolution to the conflict yet who seems to be delivering a brighter future only for the Palestianian Authority. DAVID J.

SILVEIRA Boston, Sept. 23, 1999

CP-1999-004 →

· The New York Times · New York

A Hard-Line Palestinian Returns to the West Bank

Arafat Trying to Turn Hawks Into Doves

JERICHO, West Bank, Sept. 30 — A leading Palestinian radical, one of the few renegades who had remained committed to armed struggle against Israel, returned home from Damascus today after 32 years in exile.

The Palestinian, Mustafa Zubari, known as Abu Ali Mustafa, also ended years of estrangement from Yasir Arafat, and entered the West Bank to a minor hero’s welcome from senior officials of the Palestinian Authority. After greeting him at the Jordanian border, the officials accompanied Mr.

Zubari to a small ceremony, complete with beeping horns and ululation, at a dusty bus depot. Speaking through a crackling loudspeaker, Mr. Zubari neither renounced violence nor embraced peace. The officials who greeted him, however, made it clear that they saw his return as a victory: the collapse of a stubborn pocket of resistance both to the peace process and to Mr. Arafat.

“We did not ask him to sign anything, but there is a consensus that everybody who returns will denounce violence,” said Tayeb Abdel Rahim, secretary general of the Palestinian Authority. “His blessed return represents an important turn and a necessary step for national unity.” Mr.

Zubari, 61, is the deputy chief of a Damascus-based radical faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization. His group, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, is best known for plane hijackings in the 1960’s and 70’s. Its leader, Dr. George Habash, a 72-year-old Marxist, is expected to retire soon and pass the reins to Mr. Zubari.

Through private meetings in Cairo and Amman, Mr. Arafat negotiated the return directly with Mr. Zubari. It is part of an aggressive campaign to bring home key rejectionist leaders and consolidate Mr. Arafat’s already formidable control over the Palestinian people at the beginning of final peace talks with the Israelis.

Mustafa Zubari, the balding man getting into the car, returned yesterday to the West Bank after 32 years in exile promoting violence against Israel.

CP-1999-005 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinian Route Through Israel Is Cleared

JERUSALEM, Tuesday, Oct. 5 (Reuters) — Yasir Arafat, the Palestinian leader, accepted an agreement with Israel today, clearing the way for opening a “safe passage” route to enable Palestinians to travel between the West Bank and Gaza Strip, a Palestinian official said.

“Arafat has approved the agreement,” said the chief Palestinian negotiator, Saeb Erekat. “The safe passage agreement will be signed on Tuesday.” Officials had said they expected it to open this week. Late on Monday, Mr.

Erekat said at a joint news conference with the Israeli Public Security Minister, Shlomo Ben Ami, that he would submit the agreement to Mr. Arafat for approval. Early today, Mr. Erekat said that Mr Arafat had given the green light.

The route, along Israeli roads, is meant to answer years of complaints that Israel prevents Palestinians in the separate self-rule areas of the West Bank and Gaza Strip from seeing friends and family. It was to have been opened on Sunday, but differences over security led to extended negotiations. Outlining the terms of the agreement, Mr.

Erekat said, “No Palestinians will be arrested on that route and the applications for the safe passage cards will be submitted to the Palestinian liaison offices, which will submit them to the Israeli liaison offices.” He said that distribution will be made by both sides, and a safe passage card will be valid for one year.

Palestinians with security problems will travel in buses.

CP-1999-006 →

· The New York Times · New York

School Official Wants to Mark Israeli Atrocity

Joel Greenberg

Forty-three years on, an Israeli education official proposes teaching it, and the New York Times calls it an atrocity in the headline — a word the paper did not use in 1956 or in 1958.

CP-1999-015 →

· Austin American Statesman · Austin

Israeli official asks schools to teach about Arab massacre

Austin’s version of the same story, two days later.

CP-1999-016 →

· The New York Times

West Bank Shooting Starts What Accords Could Not

By DEBORAH SONTAG

NABLUS, West Bank, Oct. 7 — Inside the casbah, two men hustled past the bullet-pocked refrigerator cases into the Abu Salhieh family butcher shop. The butcher raised his meat cleaver in joy. The men hauled a lamb slaughtered in celebration: after 23 days in the hospital, the butcher’s younger brother was about to be released.

Bashar Abu Salhieh, although he cannot yet walk, survived a shootout that stunned this northern Palestinian city. It began as a petty dispute, with two youths harassing women from the Abu Salhieh family during a wedding march. But it escalated into a full-fledged battle between the largest, most radical refugee camp in the West Bank and city folk in this commercial town.

“It was like Chicago,” said the butcher, Mohammed Abu Salhieh, 43. What most shook not only Nablus but the Palestinian Authority was the vast number of automatic weapons that poured into the streets. At the climax, after Mr.

Abu Salhieh was gunned down in the butcher shop, the usually tranquil town square filled with 1,000 men, many firing wantonly in a brazen exhibition of illegal arms. In a limited sense, the violent episode in Nablus accomplished what the latest peace agreement had not.

It propelled Palestinian officials into starting to hunt down thousands, if not tens of thousands, of illegal weapons whose seizure has been required by every peace accord since 1995. But the crackdown, focused on the Balata refugee camp and its thriving black market, did not go smoothly and ultimately went only so far.

After an ugly showdown with the camp’s youth that evoked scenes from the intifada, the Palestinian uprising against Israel several years ago, the Palestinian officers arrested 17 men they said were arms dealers.

They did succeed in putting out the word, which seeped through rutted streets where weapons had been worn as freely as cell phones, that the guns must be locked away; the authorities, for the meantime, mean business. Those authorities did not, however, actually confiscate many weapons. It is Israel that has traditionally seen the accumulation of weapons in the West Bank and the

Palestinians’ arms abound.

CP-1999-023 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

A Gain for Arabs in East Jerusalem

By JOEL GREENBERG

JERUSALEM, Oct. 17 — Interior Minister Natan Sharansky announced today that he had ended an Israeli policy that had stripped thousands of Palestinians from East Jerusalem of their right to live there.

Human rights groups and Palestinians have condemned the practice as a “quiet deportation” that they say was intended to curb Arab population growth in East Jerusalem, whose future is to be determined in talks between Israel and the Palestinians on a permanent peace.

“This was an impractical policy that served no purpose, and I’m very happy that today we are stopping the policy,” Mr. Sharansky said in a radio interview. “As someone who believes that Jerusalem must remain under Israeli sovereignty, we must look after the human rights of all citizens, including those who live in East Jerusalem.”

Israel says East Jerusalem, captured from Jordan in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war and later annexed, will remain part of its indivisible capital. The Palestinians claim the area as the capital of their hoped-for state. Since 1967 the Interior Ministry has stripped about 5,400 Palestinians of their residency rights in Jerusalem, according to Interior Ministry figures.

This has restricted their entry to the city and deprived them of Israeli health insurance and social security benefits. The figures show that about half of the actions were taken in the last three years, when the rightist Government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was in power.

Palestinians who had moved to West Bank suburbs of East Jerusalem in search of housing, or who had traveled abroad for studies or work and could not prove that they had been in the city for seven consecutive years, were told that their residence had been revoked and were ordered to leave.

The ministry asserted that by moving their “center of life” outside East Jerusalem, they had lost the permanent resident status granted by Israel to the city’s 200,000 Arabs. But Mr. Sharansky declared in his remarks that those days were now over.

“The Interior Ministry is beginning to carry out a new policy, under which we will not search how many years a Jerusalem resident was in Jerusalem and how many years he was absent,” he said. “Those who wish to continue to be residents of the city,” Mr.

Sharansky said, “but in the past spent a few years in Kuwait or other countries where they were working — we do not use the pretext that they were not here to cancel their residency.” Palestinian officials welcomed the policy change and urged Mr. Sharansky to restore East Jerusalem residency to Palestinians whose rights had been revoked.

Ziyad Abu Zayyad, a representative of East Jerusalem in the Palestinian legislative council, said the new Israeli policy would ease the daily hardships of his constituents. “It has humanitarian meaning,” Mr. Abu Zayyad said. “I hope this will put an end to the policy of ethnic cleansing of Jerusalem.”

Date check: DATE PROBLEM. No masthead survives — the clipping is trimmed to a rule, the headline, the byline and three full text columns, with no paper name and no page date line. The dateline reads “JERUSALEM, Oct. 17”, which fits an Oct. 18 paper, but the year on the slide label (1990) cannot be right. The story reports Natan Sharansky acting as Israel’s Interior Minister (he held that office from July 1999), describes the Netanyahu government in the past tense as having been in power “in the last three years” (Netanyahu was Prime Minister 1996-99), and quotes a representative in the Palestinian legislative council, a body that did not exist until 1996. The internal evidence points to 18 October 1999, nine years after the labelled date. `date` is left unchanged at 1990-10-18 as instructed. Date corrected 1990-10-18 to 1999-10-18. FILED YEAR WRONG BY NINE YEARS. No masthead or page date line survives; the only printed date is the dateline 'By JOEL GREENBERG / JERUSALEM, Oct. 17 - Interior Minister Natan Sharansky announced today that he had ended an Israeli policy that had stripped thousands of Palestinians from East Jerusalem of their right to live there.' Three details fix the year beyond doubt. Natan Sharansky was Israel's Interior Minister only from July 1999 to July 2000, so an October dispatch naming him in that post can only be October 1999. The story refers in the past tense to 'the last three years, when the rightist Government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was in power' - Netanyahu was Prime Minister from June 1996 to July 1999. And it quotes 'Ziyad Abu Zayyad, a representative of East Jerusalem in the Palestinian legislative council', a body first elected in January 1996. None of this can be 1990. A same-day dispatch of 17 October appears in the next morning's paper, 18 October 1999 - the filed day and month are right and only the year is wrong. No date is printed on the clipping; the date is fixed by what the article reports, at the precision the evidence supports, and is not guessed beyond it.

CP-1990-029 →

· The New York Times · New York

Mandela Visits Israel With Praise but Rifts Linger

JERUSALEM, Oct. 19 — It was a trip intended to heal old wounds, and as Nelson Mandela concluded his first visit to Israel today, he took pains to praise “my friends” — Prime Minister Ehud Barak and President Ezer Weisman — for their regional peacemaking efforts and the “warmth” of their reception.

The 81-year-old South African leader called Mr. Barak “a man of vision” for his pursuit of a settlement with Syria. And Mr. Mandela made it clear that he understands Israel’s need “for Arab recognition of its existence within secure boundaries.” Without such recognition a regional armistice would be “foolhardy,” he said.

Yet the visit was marked by continuing undercurrents of distrust between Mr. Mandela, a staunch champion of the Palestinian cause, and a country that once helped arm the apartheid Government that Mr. Mandela drove out of power. Before traveling on to Gaza for an afternoon meeting with another “good friend” — Yasir Arafat, the Palestinian leader — Mr.

Mandela reiterated his unwavering opposition to Israeli control of Gaza, the West Bank, the Golan Heights and southern Lebanon. “Talk of peace will remain hollow if Israel continues to occupy Arab territories,” he said, sitting at a conference table in Israel’s Foreign Ministry, where such sentiments are rarely heard.

“I understand completely well why Israel occupies these lands. There was a war. But if there is going to be peace, there must be complete withdrawal from all of these areas.”

And, leaving little doubt about his lingering resentment of Israel’s diplomatic and military ties to his former jailers, he tartly noted that upon his release from prison in 1990, he received invitations to visit “almost every country in the world, except Israel.”

Yasir Arafat, the Palestinian leader, helping Nelson Mandela, the former South African President, down stairs at the Gaza Airport yesterday.

CP-1999-007 →

· The New York Times · New York

Link Opens West Bank to Gaza's Job Hunters

EREZ CROSSING, Gaza Strip, Oct. 25 — Khader Juneed, 23, had never set foot outside Gaza in his life, and his family didn’t want him to, either. His parents feared he might never return, and so when he came home proudly last week with a shiny new Israeli-issued permit that would allow him to travel to the West Bank, they forbade him to use it.

Early this morning, many hours before the first “safe passage” route between the Gaza Strip and the West Bank opened, Mr. Juneed said, he acted as if he were leaving for work. He put his construction boots in one black plastic bag and his painter’s pants in another.

And then he hitched a ride to the border with Israel without saying goodbye, not even to his wife and three children. As he waited in line to be searched by Israeli soldiers, Mr. Juneed opened a green vinyl folder to show off the magnetic crossing card that he, like many other young and underemployed Gazans, sees as an exit permit from a life without a future.

“All my life I lived behind the high walls of Gaza, like a prisoner behind a fence,” he said. “Now I am grabbing at the opportunity to know the Palestinian world on the other side. To Gazans, the West Bank seems like the land of plenty.”

Twelve years after the Palestinian uprising against Israel severed the natural link between Gaza and the West Bank, the route established today reconnected the divided halves of the Palestinian world. The opening went smoothly, with relatively quick processing at the border and barely any protest from Israelis, except for six men with an angry banner along the way.

It marked another concrete step forward in the Israeli-Palestinian peace effort that was revived by Ehud Barak, who took office as Prime Minister in July.

Khader Juneed rode a bus on the “safe passage” route from the Gaza Strip to Tarqumiya on the West Bank.

CP-1999-008 →

· Newsday · Melville

Israel to Rid Schoolbooks Of Anti-Arab Stereotypes

Reuters

“Israeli Education Minister Yossi Sarid told UNESCO yesterday he would rid his nation’s schoolbooks of negative stereotypes about Arabs… Villagers who were in the fields and did not know of the curfew were shot dead by members of the Israeli Border Police as they returned to their homes.

Several Border Police officers were sentenced to long prison terms but these were commuted.”

Datelined Paris, 29 October 1999 — the anniversary. In two sentences it supplies what forty years of headlines left out: the villagers did not know about the curfew, and the sentences were commuted.

CP-1999-017 →

· The New York Times · New York

Reversing Himself, Barak Bars Palestinian

JERUSALEM, Oct. 29 (AP) — Prime Minister Ehud Barak of Israel has reversed his decision to let a Palestinian guerrilla chief return to areas of Palestinian self-rule, an Israeli official said today. On Sunday, Mr.

Barak’s office, acceding to the wishes of Yasir Arafat, the Palestinian leader, had announced that the man, Nayef Hawatmeh, head of the Damascus-based Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, could return to the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. Today, Mr. Barak “decided to suspend the permit because of statements that Mr.

Hawatmeh has made and conditions he has tried to impose,” said Mr. Barak’s media adviser, Gadi Baltiansky. Mr. Hawatmeh said this week that he favored armed struggle against Israel and insisted, for his return, on freedom of movement, immunity from arrest and access for his followers.

His group and another militant group, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, were the most vehement in the 1970’s against reconciliation with Israel.

CP-1999-009 →

· The New York Times · New York

A Link That Drives Palestinians Apart

RAMALLAH, West Bank — In jeans and T-shirts, each carrying a small gym bag, a group of young Gaza men drew taunts and stares as they wandered the streets here Friday evening in a fruitless search for work. “They told us we were ruining Ramallah,” said Adham A’jour, 22, taken aback by the hostility.

“People in the West Bank should be more understanding of our situation.” Shadi Achmed, his companion, concurred: “I felt that they hated us the way that they were looking at us. If they come to Gaza we will treat them the same way.”

The two 22-year-olds were among the first of several hundred Gazans to travel a two-lane road to the rocky uplands of the West Bank last week, an hour’s drive but still an eventful journey. Cousins embraced for the first time since Israel closed its borders to most Gazans six years ago. Young day-trippers eyed their first mountains.

And Palestinian peace negotiators hailed the belated fulfillment of a promise extracted from Israel by President Clinton a year ago. This new “safe passage” route for goods as well as people holds out the promise of unifying the West Bank and Gaza into one integrated economy, a prerequisite for building a viable Palestinian state.

But in a place like Ramallah, the bustling administrative center of the Palestinian-governed West Bank, the sudden appearance of Gazan visitors aroused undisguised trepidation. Although people here welcome the theoretical prospect of Palestinian unity, the new opening has already exposed the stark cultural and economic contrasts between the two regions.

Now the poorer, more religious and less educated Gazans will compete for jobs with the more settled and secular urbanites of the West Bank. This could mean unwelcome sacrifices for the West Bank and could trigger resentment and envy among the Gazans. Unemployment in Gaza hovers above 17 percent, double the rate in the West Bank.

And the median age in the Strip is just 14, compared to 17 in the West Bank. In southern Gaza, the poorest and most densely populated Palestinian region, per capita spending is $2.50 a day, far below the still-modest $6.00 average around Ramallah.

Palestinians in taxis have their papers checked as they cross from Gaza into Israel on the “safe passage” road to the West Bank.

CP-1999-010 →

· The New York Times · New York

While Mrs. Clinton Looks On, Palestinian Officials Criticize Israel

RAMALLAH, West Bank, Nov. 11 — In a return visit to Palestinian territory today, Hillary Rodham Clinton was acclaimed anew as a champion of Palestinian nationhood, and then listened with visible discomfort as her hosts at a health care function here excoriated Israel for its alleged toxic contamination of Palestinian air and water.

Going furthest of all was the other first lady in the room: Suha Arafat, the wife of the Palestinian Authority president, who in a rare public address contended that the Israeli military had routinely used carcinogenic crowd-control gases in Gaza and the West Bank, creating a severe public health problem.

“Our people have been subjected to the daily intensive use of poisonous gas by the Israeli forces, which have led to an increase in cancer cases among women and children,” Mrs. Arafat asserted. Her comment sparked an immediate uproar in Israel, with opposition legislators demanding a retaliatory halt to planned West Bank troop withdrawals.

Prime Minister Ehud Barak issued his own swift denunciation. “These comments have no connection to reality, and it would have been better if they would have never been said,” the prime minister’s office said. “Poisoning the public atmosphere does not help in bringing about success in these negotiations,” the statement added.

On the second day of her tour in the Middle East, Mrs. Clinton, the first lady and presumptive senatorial candidate, who has tried hard to avoid such controversy in her regional tour, was unavoidably in the middle of it all.

CP-1999-011 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel and Palestinians Start Major Talks

RAMALLAH, West Bank, Nov. 8 — Israeli and Palestinian teams sat down here today to begin negotiating a permanent settlement of their century-old conflict, staking out opposing positions but promising to work faithfully to reach an accord.

“It will be an honor to disagree with you,” Oded Eran, the head of the Israeli negotiating team and a former ambassador to Jordan, told the head of the Palestinian team, Yasser Abed Rabbo.

“But it will be a fulfillment of a life’s dream to shake hands with you at the end of the process and to say, ‘Brother and comrade, we did it.’” “It is a historical moment for all of us,” Mr.

Abed Rabbo, a minister in the Palestinian cabinet, said after the hour-and-a-half meeting, which began an intensive effort to negotiate a framework agreement on a permanent peace by mid-February. “We believe that through continuous and extensive work we will be able to meet the date,” Mr. Abed Rabbo said.

“We started with a very open and frank atmosphere, without any barriers.” In Paris, Yasir Arafat, the Palestinian leader, said he would meet Prime Minister Ehud Barak of Israel on Tuesday. Both leaders are in Paris for a meeting of the Socialist International.

The latest Israeli-Palestinian accord, reached in September at Sharm el-Sheik in Egypt, commits the two sides to try to reach the framework agreement by Feb. 13 and to conclude a permanent treaty by September. The issues to be tackled are the most intractable in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, and they were deferred in the 1993 Oslo interim accord.

They include the future of Jerusalem, Palestinian refugees displaced in the 1948 and 1967 Arab-Israeli wars, Jewish settlements in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, borders, water and security details. Mr. Eran said that because each side was well versed in the other’s positions the ambitious timetable for reaching an accord could be met.

“It’s a long road we have to cover in a very short time, but I believe that through our joint efforts we can make it,” Mr. Eran said. “After several decades of conflict and negotiations now for almost six years, all the problems between us are known. There is nothing that we will learn in another 10 years or 15 years of conflict and strife.

All the issues, all the views, all the opinions are known to each other. It is not a matter of discovery. It is a matter of negotiations.” For all the cordiality of the first session, the opening statements restated the sharply conflicting positions that the sides have long maintained.

Although clearly a starting stance by both sides, the yawning gap between them testified to the hard bargaining ahead. Mr. Abed Rabbo began with a demand for a full Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank, Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem to the boundaries before the 1967 Arab-Israeli war.

“Without return by Israel of all land acquired by war in 1967, including Jerusalem, our efforts will amount to no more than the deferral of crises,” he said. “The only formula that is acceptable is land for peace.” Palestinian “self-determination,” a code word for statehood, is another goal, Mr.

Abed Rabbo said, as well as “the right of Palestinian refugees to return and to receive compensation and restitution.” Mr. Abed Rabbo demanded an end to the construction and expansion of Jewish settlements in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, saying such activity predetermined the outcome of the talks.

“We find it inconceivable and quite contrary to the logic of negotiation to continue changing facts on the ground,” he said. In later remarks to reporters, Mr. Abed Rabbo called continued settlement building “the main obstacle to progress in our negotiations.” Mr.

Eran named security as Israel’s priority, putting it at the top of a proposed agenda for the talks. But in his remarks he took up the issue of Jerusalem first. “To all Israelis, regardless of their political views, Jerusalem is our capital, and it should continue to be so,” he said.

“Under its sovereignty, Israel has proven its sensitivity to all religions and to the sanctity of freedom of worship. We therefore maintain that it should remain united, open and under Israel’s sovereignty.” Borders have to be secure, and “the pre-1967 lines clearly do not provide for this,” Mr. Eran added. Alluding to Mr.

Barak’s plan to retain large sections of settlements under Israeli control, Mr. Eran said, “Establishing secure borders should equally leave most of the Israelis residing today in the West Bank and Gaza under Israeli sovereignty.” The solution of the refugee problem “cannot be found within the borders of Israel,” Mr. Eran said.

Speaking to reporters, he added that the solution “should be based on absorbing the refugees in their current places of residence” with an infusion of “massive economic aid.”

The Palestinian team leader, Yasser Abed Rabbo, left, and the chief Israeli negotiator, Oded Eran, as talks began yesterday on a peace accord. The two sides are trying to reach a framework agreement by Feb. 13.

Correction: The caption read 12 November 1999. The scan prints "Tuesday" with 9 November 1999, which was a Tuesday; the 12th was a Friday.

CP-1999-012 →

A year at a time: 1990 · 1991 · 1992 · 1993 · 1994 · 1995 · 1996 · 1997 · 1998 · 1999

Last updated 17 November 2026

Part of Covering Palestine, an archive of 3637 newspaper clippings about Palestinians printed in 748 papers between 1724 and 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles. Nothing here was printed after 6 October 2023.

The clippings belong to the newspapers and news agencies that printed them and are reproduced for research, criticism and commentary. Selection, transcription, counts and writing are © Maria Robles, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.

All decades · archive.json · Questions · Contribute a clipping · When was this printed? · How this was built · maria@rozumstudio.com