Every clipping in this archive printed between 1980 and 1989: 571 of them, oldest first, as plain text that can be read, searched and quoted without running any code. Each entry links to its own record, where the scan is.
· The New York Times · New York
The View From the West Bank
“The reader must decide not how strong the Palestinian case is, but how well Mr. Said presents it. Would he convince an impartial jury?”
Edward Said’s The Question of Palestine and Raymonda Hawa Tawil’s My Home, My Prison reviewed on the same page, a Palestinian scholar and a Palestinian woman writing from under occupation. The reviewer frames Said’s book as a case to be argued before a jury rather than a history to be read.
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. — Almost unnoticed late last year, the General Assembly overwhelmingly adopted a resolution proclaiming “The Inadmissability of the Policy of Hegemonism in International Relations.”… Tucked into the resolution was a far more notorious phrase.
The resolution “resolutely condemns” among other things “racism including zionism.” The uncapitalized “z” is a device to express contempt. The document was adopted by a vote of 111 to 4 (Australia, Canada, Israel and the United States dissenting), with 26 abstentions, mostly Western European democracies.
It marked the first explicit appearance of the famous Zionism-racism formula in the Assembly since 1975.
Yehuda Blum, the Israeli delegate, termed the action a monstrous perversion, an obscenity and a specimen of “the lies told in the United Nations that have turned this forum into the laughingstock of international society”… For a handful of Arab nations outraged at Israel’s treatment of Palestinian Arabs, the formula describes reality.
For most Third World countries and the Soviet bloc, which regularly vote for the device, it is politics.… William Korey, director of international policy research at B’nai B’rith, said: “The Zionism-equals-racism resolution has had the effect of promoting, sustaining and legitimizing anti-Semitism in various parts of the world… Because the U.N. is regarded in broad regions of the globe as a source of fundamental judgments about political reality, especially in Third World areas, to that extent the resolution has a profound and deleterious impact on attitudes toward Jews.” An attempt to delete the words “including zionism” from the condemnation of racism lost, 79 to 26, with 33 abstentions.
The U.N. General Assembly condemned Zionism
The formula came back in 1979 inside a resolution about hegemonism, with a lower-case z that the correspondent reads as contempt, and almost nobody noticed. The attempt to strike the two words failed by 79 to 26. This is the short version of a piece that ran at greater length in Miami two days later.
By Bernard D. Nossiter, The New York Times News Service
“On its face, the juncture of Zionism and racism makes little sense, at least according to Webster’s Third New International Dictionary… The UN formula appears to mean that Israel is a state founded on a belief of Jews that they are biologically superior to Palestinian Arabs and others.
In the world after Hitler no charge could be more morally damning.… It is clear that for most of those who regularly support the equation it does not have a biological meaning.
Indeed, they are far from clear about what they do mean. Biyagamage Jayasena Fernando, delegate of Sri Lanka, which introduced the UN resolution, said: ‘There are problems in my mind. Racism is an ethnic thing. Zionism is a political thing, political security… Our Arab brothers feel this is a form of racism.
I’m sorry to say I haven’t taken the trouble to analyze and come to a conclusion.’ So Sri Lanka can be described as a consensus supporter of the equation. B. Akporode Clark, the influential delegate from Nigeria, was just as blunt… ‘Israel is a petulant child, maximizing her relations with South Africa.
It’s done in order to spit in the face of the Africans. It’s politics. You use any means to build support for your cause.’… ‘Arab friends insist on our support for their formula,’ he explained. ‘Whether it is accurate or not, it might produce the desired results.
That’s politics, isn’t it?’… Brazil’s delegate, Sergio Correa da Costa, also betrays uneasiness over his vote… ‘It was politically inspired,’ he replied. ‘Politically it meant some alignment with the Arabs . . . .
Brazil is so vulnerable and dependent on Arab oil.’… Mahmoud Mestiri, who served as Tunisia’s delegate until recently, was almost dismissive about the equation. ‘If Zionism is the establishment of the State of Israel, then everybody is a Zionist,’ he said… ‘Many Arabs want to retain it as a negotiating asset,’ he said.
‘To rewrite it has no meaning. The only thing you can do is forget about it.’ For Mansur Rashid Kikhia of Libya the formula equating Zionism with racism is literal truth. He said: ‘It describes reality, the facts.’”
PLO, early to label Zionism racist, was allowed to enter UN debates
A New York Times correspondent went and asked the delegates who kept voting for it what they thought it meant. The delegate for the country that introduced the 1975 resolution had not worked it out. Nigeria called it a good abstraction. Brazil explained that eighty per cent of its oil came from the Arab world. Tunisia wanted it kept as a bargaining chip. Eleven years later, when the vote to repeal came, Sri Lanka voted against repeal and Tunisia did not vote at all.
“On the parched hills of Hebron, on the West Bank of the Jordan River, Kiryat Arba’s stone-hewn apartment towers rise into the clear desert air. The fortress-like quality they create is appropriate: Kiryat Arba is ringed by barbed wire. Israeli soldiers man the checkpoints and prowl the yard at night.
Established in 1969 by a band of orthodox Jews under Rabbi Moshe Levinger, Kiryat Arba, population 1,500, is the largest of 40 fortified settlements that now dot the West Bank. The settlers journeyed there after the Israeli army occupied the West Bank following the Six-Day War in 1967.
They were seeking a messianic kingdom on land that was once part of ancient Israel, land that they claim was given to them by God and to which their return is divinely ordained… In recent months, a wave of violence, triggered by opposition to the Palestinian autonomy talks, has erupted in Kiryat Arba and spread down the slope into Arab Hebron and across the entire West Bank.
Forty women and children marched from Kiryat Arba to Hebron last April and occupied a building. They threatened to take over whole areas of Hebron, claiming, correctly, that some of it had been Jewish property before 1929. That year, the English, governing under the British Mandate, evacuated the Jews in an attempt to end violence between Jewish and Arab settlers.
Last June a goon squad from Kiryat Arba was arrested for riding around Nablus in a sound truck, exhorting the Arabs to flee. A similar gang broke into an Arab house in Hebron last July and beat up the residents. Then, in September, 70 Kiryat Arba residents tried to confiscate an Arab field.
Israeli troops sent to break up the occupation were met by a barrage of flaming tires and fire bombs… Eliakim Haetzni, a lawyer and key activist of the ‘Eretz Yisrael’ movement, insists that the violent incidents are isolated aberrations, and that relations between residents of Hebron and Kiryat Arba are excellent.
‘If the Palestinian Arabs hated us,’ Haetzni asked, ‘why would they come up the hill to build our synagogues, work in our factories and tend our gardens?
The Palestinians see us as neighbors, not as a threat.’… Rabbi Meir Kahane, former head of the Jewish Defense League in the United States and now head of Israel’s Kach Party, thinks that Haetzni’s good-neighbor policy is ‘crap.’ ‘You can’t buy Arab love with indoor toilets and good health care,’ he said.
‘Israeli Arabs and West Bank Arabs identify with the PLO. Moreover, they multiply like rabbits. At their rate of growth, they will take over the Knesset (Israel’s Parliament) in 25 years. I am not prepared to sacrifice Zionism to democracy. There is only one solution: The Arabs must leave Israel.’
When asked how he would implement such a policy if he were prime minister, Kahane, who is running for a Knesset seat in May, said, ‘I’d go to the Arabs and tell them to leave. I’d promise generous compensation.
If they refused, I’d force them out.’… ‘Arabs can live on the West Bank,’ said Gush leader Levinger, ‘but they will have no political rights.’
Mamoun el Sayyed, the editor of El Fajar, an Arab-language newspaper published in East Jerusalem, summed up the Arab attitude toward Kiryat Arba: ‘Haetzni reminds me of a liberal plantation owner in the American South prior to the Civil War,’ he said. ‘Rabbi Levinger is writing his own version of the Nuremberg laws.
Kahane is inclined toward deportation and genocide. Do I think Kiryat Arba is a cancer in the heart of my homeland? Of course, and so does every Arab in Palestine.’
Despite a recent Israeli Supreme Court order to evacuate a similarly controversial West Bank settlement near Nablus that had been illegally seized from Arab landowners, the Israeli Housing Ministry plans to settle an additional 50,000 Jews in Kiryat Arba by the mid-1980s. ‘We will never leave Kiryat Arba,’ one mother said as she cradled her infant close to her.
‘Not the Israeli High Court or the Arabs will ever move us. Like the Zealots who defended Masada against the Romans, we will resist, if necessary, to the bloody end.’”
A Palestinian editor answering three settler leaders in their own paper’s words, and using “genocide” of Kahane’s program in 1980. The reporter had spent five years in the Middle East and was living in Madison, Wisconsin.
“My father, who lived there more than 50 years, can’t even find the place of our home. You can’t see anything but trees.”
Feres Abu Shawish teaches English in Nuseirat camp and describes his father looking for a house and finding a forest. Shipler opens on a barefoot twelve-year-old in Jabaliya. The dream in the headline belongs to the Palestinians; the word hostages does the rest of the work.
Israeli Censorship Strikes A Discordant, Insistent Note
By DAVID K. SHIPLER
JERUSALEM — Israeli military censors are outrageously courteous, at times infuriatingly charming. It is so difficult to hate them, as every red-blooded journalist knows he should, that occasionally, even in the hardest reporter’s coldest heart, stirrings of sympathy have been observed for those nice guys who have such an uncomfortable job.
Israel is the only open political system in the Middle East, a tiny dot of free debate at the edge of a vast sweep of dictatorships. Censorship strikes a discordant note, and the army officers in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem perusing news copy before publication or broadcast seem an odd contradiction to Israel’s national pasttime of exposing its own sins.
Yet last week the Government revoked the accreditation of Dan Raviv, a reporter for CBS radio. He had avoided the censors by flying to Rome to broadcast a report from anonymous “informed sources” that Israel had detonated a nuclear bomb — allegedly the source of that mysterious flash in the South Atlantic last September. Defense Minister Ezer Weizman denied the story. Mr.
Raviv — for failing to submit it for prior clearance — was deprived of his Government-issued press credentials, without a peep of editorial objection from normally contentious Israeli newspapers. Few Israelis seem to mind the censorship; it is such an accepted part of the landscape that many are only vaguely aware of it.
Officials justify it as essential to protect military secrets during a state of war. The peace treaty with Egypt notwithstanding, there is no peace accord with Jordan, Syria or other hostile Arab nations. A high state of military readiness is an everyday fact of life.
Military authorities, however, often blur the line between protecting the country’s security and protecting its image, and this has provoked occasional criticism.
Not until last autumn, for example, did Israelis learn that an army officer was serving a 30-month prison sentence for murdering Lebanese civilians during “Operation Litani,” a 1978 Israeli sweep into southern Lebanon. Because the military court had tried the man [Lieut. Col. Arye Sadeh] in camera, censors had banned publication of details that emerged in court.
The news leaked out in the British weekly, the Spectator; 150 university lecturers wrote to Mr. Weizman complaining that the punishment was light and the Israeli newspaper, Yediot Ahronot, reported that the wife of the officer appealed to Prime Minister Menachem Begin for clemency. Events outside the court were not barred by censorship.
Similarly, details of another atrocity during Operation Litani squeezed past censorship months after the fact and caused a furor, including calls for the resignation of Lieut. Gen. Rafael Eitan, the chief of staff. An army lieutenant, Daniel Pinto, was convicted in a closed military court of murdering Lebanese civilians and sentenced to 12 years in prison.
This was reduced to eight by an appeals court, and later to two years by General Eitan. Censors barred publication of details by the Israeli press and by resident foreign correspondents, who are also subject to censorship. But Israel being the kind of flagrantly free-wheeling society it is, nobody stayed quiet.
Uri Avneri, a leftist parliamentarian in the Sheli Party, wrote an unofficial account describing Lieutenant Pinto as having “tortured his victims cruelly for hours, in a number of different ways. At the end, he murdered them by strangulation, using his hands and a nylon cord.” He was said to have dumped their bodies downa well.
Softening a Draconian Law Under censorship, the account could not be published in Israel or be sent out of the country. But it did find its way out. When Dial Torgerson, Jerusalem correspondent of The Los Angeles Times, was vacationing in London, he received a copy from his Los Angeles office.
He had asked the Jerusalem censor if he could write the story and been told no; under no restrictions in London, he wrote it. After publication abroad, the story became open to the Israeli press which gave it big play. Censorship had lost its tenuous hold.
The legal basis of Israeli censorship, dating back to Britain’s mandate over Palestine, is “a Draconian law,” as one military official put it, which authorizes suffocating control over everything printed, filmed or broadcast.
Israelites Claim Arabs Have ‘Fared Well’ Under Jewish Rule
United Press International, Ara, Israel
“The grim-faced soldier motions each car past the roadblock with a cursory glance and an absent wave of his submachine gun. Occasionally, he orders a vehicle to pull over for inspection.
The stopped cars carry Arab passengers… ‘We’re always being stopped and checked on the roads and it’s humiliating,’ said Mahmoud Woshahy, 23, an Israeli Arab… ISRAELI ARABS see themselves as second class citizens in a state founded and governed by Jews, a people particularly aware of persecution. Yet barely a whisper of dissent rippled among the Jewish majority when one of its military leaders, Maj.
Gen. Avigdor Ben-Gal, defined the Arabs in Israel as ‘a cancer in our body only waiting for a chance to jump at our throats and strangle us.’… ‘I am an Israeli citizen but in practice I am nothing,’ Woshahy said. He is from Ara, a hilly village of ankle-twisting dirt paths 40 miles northeast of Tel Aviv.
‘In my heart I am a Palestinian.’… ‘If we needed this land, we confiscated it from the Arabs. We had to create a Jewish state in this country, and we did,’ Gur-Arye said candidly. ‘I don’t apologize for what happened 32 years ago. We didn’t start the war.’”
CHILDREN PLAY ON UNPAVED STREETS OF ISRAEL · Israeli Arabs Say Their Towns Get Little Attention
A wire survey of the Arab citizens of Israel, printed in Texas. The line that matters is not the general’s; it is the clause in front of it. The paper reports that the remark passed without objection, and then moves on to budget figures. Also on the page: a Nazareth of 45,000 with a budget of $3.6 million against a largely Jewish Acre of 35,000 with $7.3 million, and a Haifa lawyer’s count of land seizures in 470 of 570 Arab villages. The masthead carries two papers and two dates, the Tyler Courier-Times of 26 March and the Morning Telegraph of 27 March; the later date is recorded here.
MISGAV AM, Israel, April 7 — Israeli troops stormed a children’s dormitory on this kibbutz today, killing five Palestinian terrorists who had taken a group of children hostage in a bid for the release of guerrillas from Israeli prisons. A two-and-a-half-year-old boy in the dormitory was killed, possibly by the terrorists, and four other children were slightly wounded.
The kibbutz secretary, 38, was shot to death as he fought the guerrillas with his bare hands when they first entered the compound, near the border with Lebanon, after 1 o’clock this morning. An Israeli soldier was killed during a first unsuccessful rescue attempt about 2:30 A.M.; 10 soldiers and one civilian were reported wounded.
Afterward, wind blew through the shattered windows of the children’s house, whipping shredded, brightly colored curtains like torn battle flags. One side of the mattress in a crib in a corner was soaked with blood. Toys stood cracked and splintered by bullets.
Spent brass cartridges from the Soviet-made Kalashnikov rifles the terrorists carried lay scattered on the floor, among tiny shoes and toy teacups and books of fairy tales. The terrorist attack, the most serious in a year, coincided with the departure of President Anwar el-Sadat of Egypt for talks in Washington on granting self-rule to Palestinians under Israeli occupation.
The attack was regarded as likely to stiffen the resistance of Prime Minister Menachem Begin of Israel to transferring substantive power to the Palestinians. Prime Minister Begin flies to Washington next week.
TEL AVIV, April 15 — An Arab student at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem was ordered expelled from his campus dormitory today for having blown out a memorial candle on Sunday, Holocaust Memorial Day.
The student, Ihsan Sleman, 19 years old, will also be refused dormitory accommodation next year, according to a decision by the disciplinary committee of students’ hostels. The committee consists of two faculty representatives and one member of the students’ union. Mr.
Sleman, a first-year student of mathematics, was given 10 days to find alternative quarters and may also appeal. In his appearance before the committee, Mr. Sleman maintained that he had not been aware of the symbolism of the candle, declaring he had thought it was lit during the night because of a power failure. A maintenance worker in the dormitory said he had seen Mr.
Sleman blow out the candle between 5 and 6 A.M. on Sunday. The committee rejected Mr. Sleman’s, explanation, maintaining that since he had been born in Israel and spoke Hebrew, he must have been familiar with Holocaust Day.
· (newspaper unidentified) · page 1B, continued on 2B (“Please See HADDAD, 2B” / “From Page 1B”)
Militia Chief Embarrassing but Valuable Ally
By Michael Precker
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Maj. Saad Haddad’s Christian militiamen in southern Lebanon are embarrassing allies for the Israeli government. But it continues to support them because they are a deterrent to Palestinian attacks on northern Israel. U.N. peacekeeping troops are locked in a deadly confrontation with Haddad’s forces for control of three Lebanese villages.
One Irish soldier died last week after being shot in the eye, and two other Irish troops were murdered. Haddad maintains the Irish troops are sympathetic to Palestinian guerrillas and allow them to operate in the U.N. zone. The U.N. denies the charge.
The 6,000 U.N. troops moved into the volatile strategic region above Israel’s northern border two years ago to replace Israeli forces that occupied southern Lebanon to drive out Palestinian guerrillas who returned there after the Lebanese civil war. A News Analysis Though the U.N.
Security Council ordered the force to take control of all Lebanese territory south of the Litani River, the withdrawing Israelis turned over a narrow border strip to Haddad, a former Lebanese army officer who shared the Israeli aim of keeping Palestinian guerrillas out of the area and proclaimed his territory “Free Lebanon” in defiance of the Lebanese government in Beirut.
Israel provides Haddad with weapons and supplies and pays his soldiers. Hundreds of Lebanese living in his enclave work in Israel. The major appears regularly in the northern Israeli town of Metulla for news conferences arranged by Israeli liaison officers.
The close cooperation has provoked frequent denunciations from Arab states who accuse Israel of violating Lebanese sovereignty, and appeals from Western countries and the United Nations to Israel to stop Haddad from clashing with the U.N. forces.
Israeli officials admit their government is embarrassed by Haddad, but they give no indication that it might reduces its support of him. “Haddad is not an Israeli puppet,” said one official who asked that his name not be used. “He’s the head of a people in great danger as a result of terrorist intentions to take over all of south Lebanon.
It’s in our political and moral interests to save the lives of the Christians in south Lebanon.” “We cannot control Haddad. Our policy is to support him in the interests of our security in the north and to exert influence to calm down the situation.”
Informed sources said the government refrains from cutting off aid to Haddad or otherwise applying strong pressure because of its commitment to the Lebanese Christians and the belief that any alternative to Haddad would be far worse for Israel. Israel distrusts the U.N. Force, which it says is ineffec tive in stopping guerrilla infiltration.
Israel charged that the Palestinian terrorists who killed three Israelis in the border kibbutz of Misgav Am on April 7 crossed through U.N. territory unhindered on their way to Israel. After the attack, Israel sent several hundred troops to patrol in southern Lebanon for five days, demonstrating a lack of faith in both the U.N. troops and Haddad’s militia.
Israeli sources charge that some 700 guerrillas now operate within the U.N. zone and that some peacekeeping troops have become sympathetic to the Palestinian cause. Israel has caught two U.N. officers smuggling weapons to Palestinian groups inside Israel. The U. N.
Forces deny they are partial to either side and say their mission is hampered by lack of cooperation from Israel and the Christians. Spokesman Hugo Rocha said the U.N. troops have suffered as many casualties fighting Palestinians and their leftist Lebanese allies as they have against Haddad’s forces. Rocha said the U.N.
Command regularly complains to the Israeli army about Haddad’s actions but is told the Israelis are not responsible for the Lebanese militias. “What can we say? We are not playing games. We make a serious complaint and we expect a serious answer,” he said.
Israel deports 3 Palestinian West Bank leaders after ambush
Associated Press, Hebron, Israeli Occupied West Bank
“The Arab mayor of the occupied city of Nablus, Bassam Shakaa, said: ‘We are now in the struggle for the Palestinian nation.’”
Thirty-one days later the Journal Herald reported that Bassam Shakaa had lost both legs and Karim Khalaf a foot in coordinated car bombings, and in 1983 the Associated Press called those bombings the most notorious unsolved case in the territory. The archive holds the sentence and what followed it.
Thousands attend funeral for Israeli killed in attack
Associated Press
HEBRON, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Thousands of Israelis went to the occupied Arab city of Hebron Monday for the funeral of a U.S.-Israeli Vietnam War veteran killed last week in a Palestinian guerrilla ambush… “We must expel all the Arabs from here,” said extremist Rabbi Meir Kahane. “It’s either them or us,” he told Israel Radio.
The dateline reads HEBRON, Occupied West Bank. The word occupied is in the dateline, in the body twice more, and the paper calls Kahane an extremist in its own voice. Seventeen years later the same town would be datelined without it.
Arafat Defends Ambush of Israeli Settlers in Hebron as Resistance to Occupation
Anthony Lewis
“Any occupied people have a right to fight invaders, comparing the situation of the Palestinians in the territories occupied by Israel in 1967 to Americans fighting the British in the Revolutionary War, Algerians against the French and the European Resistance against the Nazis.”
Anthony Lewis in Beirut, printing Arafat’s argument in full rather than in summary. The objection recorded here is to Resolution 242, which treated Palestinians only as refugees — a legal complaint about a noun.
JERUSALEM, June 5 — The Palestinian Arab Mayor of Nablus, who lost his legs in a terrorist bombing Monday, was taken to Jordan today for medical treatment after his condition deteriorated.
The Israeli Government, which has condemned the attack on the Mayor, Bassam al-Shaka, and two other West Bank mayors, first offered to take him to any hospital in Israel and then, when he declined the offer, sent an ambulance to drive him to the border crossing at Damiya, northeast of here. A Jordanian helicopter flew him to Amman.
There were still no leads in the police investigation of the bombs, which were set to detonate when the car ignition switches were turned on. Arab protests against the bombings died down after Israeli troops broke a general strike. Emergency Surgery in Jordan Mr.
Shaka, whose legs were amputated after the blast, developed gangrene late yesterday and underwent further surgery last night in the hospital in Nablus, the town he has headed as Mayor since 1976. “He felt that he needed more careful treatment than he could get here,” explained a friend who saw Mayor Shaka this morning.
“The medicine seemed to be causing an allergy and there was more fever and infection.” His doctors said that he was also experiencing a “drastic drop in blood pressure.” According to the Israeli state radio, Mr. Shaka received emergency treatment this afternoon upon his arrival at the hospital in Amman.
PARIS — Observe The Great Deception at work. Publicly, President Carter ritually declares he opposes the creation of a Palestinian state.
But privately, Zbigniew Brzezinski’s staffers at the White House, echoed by Harold Saunders’ Arabists at the State Department, assure Arabs and Europeans that after the American elections — when the president no longer has to worry about the reaction from American supporters of Israel— “self-determination” will be insisted upon even if it means the creation of a radical state within artillery range of Tel Aviv.
Publicly, the Carter White House mildly disapproves of the French-inspired call for diplomatic dealings with Palestinian terrorists pledged to the destruction of Israel. Secretary of State Edmund S.
Muskie solemnly reaffirms our promise not to deal with the Palestine Liberation Organization until it accepts United Nations Resolution 242 and drops its goal of driving the hated Zionists into the sea.
But privately, a member of Brzezinski’s staff traveling in Bonn tells all and sundry — on background, of course — just the opposite: That the European embrace of the PLO “might even be helpful in U.S. efforts to get a settlement.” (The voice is the voice of Muskie but the hand is the hand of Brzezinski.)
Anybody who gives any credence to what the Carter administration says in public about not dealing with the PLO is deceiving himself. Every politician in Europe is certain that, if the Carter men are returned to power, Israel will be punished for its stiffneckedness and the PLO included in the imposition of a deal. The cynics are right.
The public position is a facade, to be replaced by the private position when the time is ripe.
The message is unmistakeable: Just let us get this silly business of an election behind us and we will bring back Andy Young, force the Israelis to hand over the West Bank to the PLO and invite the Soviet Union into the Mideast for a truly “comprehensive” solution — as we planned all along.
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Three Palestinians were killed in a village near Hebron today, apparently when a bomb they were working on exploded prematurely, an Israeli military spokesman said. It was the second apparent accidental bomb blast in as many days on the occupied West Bank of the Jordan River.
On Wednesday, an Arab from Nablus was killed when a bomb he was working on went off prematurely, the Israeli spokesman said. The explosions appeared to signal a possible new surge of violence in the occupied area, despite Israeli claims that the region was “absolutely quiet and normal.”
Four deaths in two days, all of them explained the same way by the same source. The word apparently is in the first sentence and apparent in the second paragraph, and the only account of what happened in either case is an Israeli military spokesman’s. Nobody is named. The last line records the same source calling the region absolutely quiet and normal.
Zionism Equated With Racism By Some Women at U.N. Conference
United Press International, Copenhagen
COPENHAGEN, Denmark (UPI) — An Indian delegation today presented a motion to the U.N.
Decade For Women Conference equating Zionism with racism in the second such resolution in two days. The Indian delegation presented a motion calling for the elimination of “imperialism, colonialism, neo-colonialism, Zionism, racism, racial discrimination, apartheid, hedgemonism and foreign occupation” to be included in the conference’s final resolution.
The Cubans proposed a similiar amendment Thursday specifically linking Zionism with racism.
However, the Cubans withdrew their motion today in favor of the Indian one. The Israeli delegation has vowed to leave the meeting and return home if the resolution is passed, conference sources said. The Indian proposal was supported by the so-called Group of 77 nations… The Cubans allowed the Indians to take over their amendment because the Indians chair the Group of 77 and would be better able to get all group member nations to vote for the amendment… The agenda for the assembly sets aside two days, July 24 and 25, to take up the question of Palestinian women. Walkouts by Palestinian delegates and their supporters, prompted by speeches by Egyptian first lady Jihan Sadat and an Israeli representative, have already disrupted the conference twice.
Five days before this, the Associated Press had moved a photograph of Leila Khaled arriving in Copenhagen for this same conference, captioned terrorist now a delegate. Two days of the agenda were set aside for the question of Palestinian women. Five years later, at the conference that closed the same Decade in Nairobi, Israel refused travel permits to five Palestinian women invited to attend and the formula nearly collapsed the final document. The paper spells hedgemonism and similiar.
“Israeli denies torture charges. An Israeli delegate to the U.N. Decade for Women Conference likened Palestinian charges of Israeli torture to the Nazi ‘big lie’ technique and said the only Palestinian women in jail are those convicted of terrorist acts.
Israeli delegate Tamar Eshel began her angry refutation yesterday after May Sadegh, the leader of the Palestinian delegation, charged at a news conference that Palestinian women were tortured and sexually abused in Israeli jails. Ms.
Eshel said the allegations were ‘the most preposterous accusations which only remind me of the (Nazi Propaganda Minister Joseph) Goebbels technique of the big lie — just keep repeating it and some are sure to begin believing it.’”
The charge is reported only as the thing being denied: the Palestinian delegation leader is named and her accusation summarized in one clause, and the rest of the item is the refutation.
200 Arabs in Jerusalem protest hunger-strike deaths
Associated Press
JERUSALEM — Two hundred Palestinian Arabs demonstrated in East Jerusalem yesterday to protest the death of a second convicted Arab terrorist in a prison hunger strike. Demonstrators at the Red Cross building blamed prison authorities for the deaths and claimed “mass killings” were taking place in Israeli jails.
Antagonism between Moslem nations and the Israelis has intensified as Israel's parliament moves toward declaring the city, including the annexed Arab sector, capital of Israel. Turkey protested the action and in Alexandria yesterday, Egyptian Foreign Minister Kamal Hassan Aly told reporters Egypt is watching the Knesset's actions “with extreme care and caution.”
Kassam Mahmoud Halawe, 28, convicted of a hand grenade attack in Gaza in 1971 which killed two Arabs and wounded six others, was hospitalized Tuesday with two other prisoners who became ill during a hunger strike in an Israeli prison. He died yesterday.
Autopsies showed that he and Ali Muhammed Shehade Jaabari died from lung infections, which developed when liquid nutriment they were being force-fed entered their lungs. Jaabari, who died Wednesday, was also serving a life sentence for a 1968 murder.
Carrying placards reading “Let us stop this mass killing,” friends and family of the prisoners waited for a Red Cross delegation to return from Nafha, the prison for Arab terrorists, where 48 prisoners continue their hunger strike. “They told us they are dying day by day and decided they would rather die quickly,” said Badiya Nassan Malabed, mother of two Nafha convicts.
Fifteen women, family members of the Arab prisoners, later said they were joining the strike and that more were likely to join later. On Wednesday, police broke up similar demonstrations in Jerusalem and the occupied West Bank of the Jordan River. The Interior Ministry appointed a special committee yesterday to investigate the deaths and handling of the hunger strike.
Attorney Leah Tsemel returned to the Red Cross from Nafha, near Beersheba, and said: “The prisoners asked me to tell you that they have no political demands, only humanitarian demands.” The hunger strike began July 14 to protest conditions that allegedly single out Arab security prisoners for worse treatment.
But prison officials charge that the strike is organized from outside the jail for political purposes. “The prison authorities killed them. They are totally responsible for their deaths,” said Tsemel.
She described the living conditions as 10 prisoners to a small cell used for eating and sleeping, and said the Arabs sleep on mattresses on the floor and receive no medical or dental care. In Alexandria, Egypt, after a Cabinet meeting, Aly spoke to reporters about the Knesset bill changing the status of Jerusalem.
“This is just the first reading,” he said, “but we are looking into the decision very seriously, and awaiting the outcome with anxiety.” The bill received initial approval by a 65-12 majority in the Knesset on Wednesday. It goes to committee for final preparations for enactment. Egypt immediately protested the bill, saying it was “illegal.”
The measure angered Egyptian President Anwar Sadat when it was first proposed in May, and led him to suspend for two months the Egyptian-Israeli-American talks on Palestinian autonomy in the occupied territories. Israel annexed the Arab sector after capturing it in the 1967 Arab-Israeli War. It did not annex the other Arab lands it has occupied and administered since then.
The masthead is not visible in this scan; the paper and date are as given on the source deck. The clipping sits above a FloorMart carpet advertisement.
By DAVID K. SHIPLER, Special to The New York Times
JERUSALEM, July 28 — At dawn on every working day a remarkable migration takes place across the lines of Arab-Jewish hostility.
As the muezzins’ mournful calls to prayer echo through the towns and refugee camps of the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, thousands of Palestinian Arabs leave their sleeping families, walk silently through the thin first light and board buses that take them to Israel proper — and to work. The military occupation has led to economic interdependence.
About 70,000 Arabs, one of every three in the labor force of the occupied areas, hold jobs in Israel, working for Jewish employers. They do mostly unskilled tasks, lifting and carrying on construction sites, waiting table and cleaning in hotels and restaurants, laboring in the fields and orange groves, and manning the assembly lines.
Although they represent only a fraction … [NOT TRANSCRIBED IN FULL — SEE needs_rescan AND note.
Only what I can read with certainty is given below.] West Bank Occupation Brings Jobs and Dependence Continued From Page 1 of the Israeli work force of 2.1 million, their concentration in the menial ranks of certain industries — especially building and agriculture — is said to have given them a disproportionate importance in filling roles that Israeli Jews do not want. [PHOTOGRAPH across the top of the page, with credit and caption:] The New York Times/Micha Bar-Am Arabs boarding buses in Gaza Strip for the trip to Israel, where they work for Jewish employers [The remaining six columns of body text are legible only at the word level and are NOT transcribed.
The crossheads I can read with confidence are: “Higher Pay, Neglected Farms”, “‘It’s Loss of Face’”, “Obedient, Prompt, Less Corrupt”, “Impact on Economy Feared”, “Standing Protective Agreement” and “Chance of Serious Dislocation”.
A separate, unrelated story runs across the foot of the clipping: “3 Iranian Captives Ill in New York”, By LES LEDBETTER.]
Q: Are you separate from the Arab nation as a whole? A: Well, we could be a Palestinian people as part of the entire Arab world. . . . Your being people means that you are somehow distinct . . . We all have our idiosyncrasies, our own experiences and economic structures. I mean, Palestine was a bit different, economically, from the rest of the Arab world.
Q: At one time, Syria regarded Palestine as its province. A: Yes, but since 1922 Palestine was very well defined as being that territory between the River Jordan and the Mediterranean Sea. Q: You are now excluding what was once called Transjordan?
A: Well, Transjordan is a kingdom . . . that has survived since 1922 as an independent state, that is, as a protectorate of the British or as fully sovereign. Q: The same argument could be applied to Israel; it has survived for 31 years as an independent state. A: Yes, but you see there is a difference.
Israel was established . . . by denying the indigenous people the right to exist in their own country. Transjordan was not . . . Maybe somebody is not happy or content with the regime. But what happened is that with the establishment of Israel in 1947 the indigenous people were thrown out . . . and that is the big difference.
Q: Do you think that was by Israeli design or by the fortunes of war? A: No, that was by Israeli design. It was exactly what Herzl had foreseen — that the indigenous population should be spirited away and that is exactly what he writes . . . Now his followers refer to “thinning away” the non-Jewish population.
It is not coincidental (this policy) was started by Eichmann when he wanted to “thin away” the Jews in Vienna. So it is a mentality that we deal with — an aggressive racist mentality, the Zionist mentality.
Filed as The Tampa Tribune; the page prints Courier Post. Folio line at the top-left of the page, read at 14x: "4F COURIER-POST, Sunday, October 7, 197?". The paper name is unambiguous; a bleed-through ghost of the same folio from the reverse of the sheet sits just above it.
Israel Will Allow 2 Arab Mayors to Return to Appeal Deportation
“The Mayors, Fahad Kawasmeh of Hebron and Mohammed Milhem of Halhoul, were exiled in May along with the religious judge of Hebron, Sheik Raja Bayud Tamimi…”
David K. Shipler. Two elected mayors deported in May get to come back in October for the purpose of appealing their deportation. The headline files that as a permission.
“Republican candidate Ronald Reagan says the Carter administration is wrong in saying Israeli settlements on the occupied West Bank are illegal. Reagan said in Los Angeles that the settlements ‘are entirely legal’ under U.N.
Resolution 242, adopted after the 1967 Israeli-Arab war… Reagan said, ‘All people — Moslem, Jew and Christian — are entitled to live on the West Bank until a determination is made’ on the future of the area.
U.S. administrations since the mid-1960s, both Democratic and Republican, have consistently declared that the Israeli settlements were not legal, pending a final peace settlement.”
The paper puts the change on the record in its own copy: every administration since the mid-1960s had said the opposite.
Correction: {'note': 'Slide 11 captions this scan as the Los Angeles Herald Examiner, 11 January 1978. It reports the Reagan-Carter campaign, so it is the 1980 Houston paper.'}
RAMALLAH, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Palestinian writers and artists are accusing Israel of cultural oppression.
They cite the recent closing of the only art gallery on the West Bank, the confiscation of a number of books on a list of banned publications… “Carry On” to express the Palestinians’ determination to endure Israeli occupation, said Suleiman Mansour, a 35-year-old painter whose works were on display Sept.
22 when Israeli troops closed “Gallery 79” in Ramallah. Mansour, who was trained at the Israeli Bezalel Academy in Jerusalem, is one of the best-known Palestinian artists.
His painting of an old Arab carrying Jerusalem on his back was issued as a poster with the title “Carry On”… Mansour said, however, that he consciously avoided political statements in the works he showed at Gallery 79 so that it could remain in business… The book remains on sale openly in some West Bank stores, perhaps because Israeli troops haven’t gotten to them yet.
At one bookshop in Ramallah the proprietor showed a reporter a whole shelf of “banned” works, including “Sunflowers” and a book by Felicia Langer, an Israeli Communist lawyer, on the 1979 legal fight against the deportation of Mayor Bassam Shakaa of the West Bank town of Nablus… A few years ago, Miss Kalifeh was cited in an Israeli Foreign Ministry pamphlet as an example of the cultural freedom permitted under Israel’s occupation of the West Bank since 1967.
Even though her earlier novel “Cactus” said harsh things about Israel, it was published and sold freely, a Foreign Ministry pamphlet said.
The writer admitted that she once felt oddly demoralized because the Israelis permitted more freedom than the Palestinians would have had in any Arab country. “They made us feel they were so strong that they didn’t care what we did,” Miss Kalifeh said.
“But now they are starting to worry, because even though we are weak, we are drawing the attention of the world. The world wants to know more about the Palestinians, and this is why they (the Israelis) need the iron fist — they are insecure.”
Suleiman Mansour at 35, three years after the Pasadena show and eight before he stands outside Ketziot prison. The writer Sahar Khalifeh, printed here as Miss Kalifeh, describes being cited in an Israeli government pamphlet as proof of the freedom she was being permitted, and says the permission ended when the world started paying attention.
No, the Palestinians Are Not Entitled To Self-Determination
Steven E. Plaut
“Surely not every group of Arabs everywhere is unconditionally entitled to the right of self-determination.”
An op-ed, from Oberlin, Ohio, arguing the position in its own headline. Kept in the archive precisely because it is explicit: the denial of Palestinian self-determination was not a subtext in the American paper of record in 1980, it was a byline.
“Map shows border shared by Israel and Lebanon.” The map marks Sidon, Tyre, the Litani River, Taibe, Adeisseh, Kiryat Shemona, Maroun Er-Ras, Yaroun, Alma Chaab, Metulla, Ghajar, Kibbutz of Misgau AM, Ramim and the Golan Heights.
The clipping is the headline and the map; the body of the story is not on this scan.
“‘It’s a black day for the future of democracy in Israel,’ said Tewfik Toubi, an Arab member of Parliament.”
Tewfik Toubi sat in the Knesset for forty-one years. Here he is quoted on a banned conference, in a story mostly about who met Yasir Arafat in Sofia. He is a member of the Israeli Parliament describing the Israeli Government, and the paper identifies him by ethnicity before office.
2 Palestinians Expelled by Israel Begin Hunger Strike at the U.N.
The hunger strike carried out of the prison and onto the doorstep of the General Assembly. Forty-three years before a hunger striker in this archive dies in custody.
Bedouin Member of the Israeli Parliament Is Shot to Death in Jerusalem
JERUSALEM, Jan. 3 — A Bedouin Member of Parliament, Hammad Abu Rabia, was shot to death in Jerusalem tonight by gunfire from a jeep. Police roadblocks were immediately set up throughout the city and on the highways to Tel Aviv and the Dead Sea, but no arrests were reported in the killing, the first assassination of a member of Israel’s Parliament.
Israeli television initially reported that the shots had been fired from a military vehicle. However, a police spokesman at the scene, near the Holy Land Hotel, said the jeep was “apparently military, but it could have been civilian, too.” Israeli radio later quoted the police as contending that it was a civilian jeep.
The lone witness was a worker at the hotel, the police said. Mr. Abu Rabia, who was in his early 50’s, was the chief of one of the largest Bedouin tribes in the Negev. He had struggled for a compromise with the Government over its efforts to expropriate Bedouin desert land for a new air base, and he had voted against the expropriation bill in the Parliament.
Many Bedouins were reportedly dissatisfied with his performance as a negotiator, contending that he did not resist the Government strongly enough. One line of speculation about his murder tonight held that the perpetrator had come from among the Bedouins.
Another theory, put forth by some who knew him well, was that he had been murdered by Druses — members of an Arab religious sect — because of a dispute over his seat in Parliament.
Hammad Abu Rabia
Date check: No masthead or page date line is present on this clipping — it is trimmed to the headline, three text columns and the portrait. The only internal date is the dateline, which reads “JERUSALEM, Jan. 3”. The byline block reads only “Special to The New York Times”, which is consistent with `pub`.
JERUSALEM (UPI) — A parliamentary committee gave the go-ahead today for three new outposts in the occupied West Bank in Prime Minister Menachem Begin’s accelerated drive to settle more Jews in the region before he faces the voters.
The Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee voted down an appeal from Deputy Prime Minister Yigael Yadin against three of the last 10 settlements Begin has committed himself to building in the disputed region. Yadin argued the settlements were not vital for Israel’s security needs.
On a rocky hilltop northwest of Jerusalem, several hundred Jewish West Bank settlers rejected a government compromise offer and insisted that development start immediately on the permanent settlement of Givon.
The settlers, who were temporarily settled in an army camp near the proposed permanent site, moved onto the hilltop without permission Sunday, complaining the Housing Ministry was holding up plans to build their settlement town.
The settlers are pushing for immediate construction, fearing the opposition Labor Party will halt development of the site if it wins the parliamentary elections this summer as expected. Labor leader Shimon Peres has made clear his party will only agree to establishment of settlements in areas of the West Bank with low-density Arab populations.
Although Labor leaders have said Givon fits party criteria for approved settlement, the settlers don’t want to take any chances. “It’s important to create facts in the Givon area before the elections,” said an aide to Agriculture Minister Ariel Sharon, the head of Begin’s settlement committee.
Sharon has accelerated the settlement drive since the government agreed to push for early elections. The Knesset Law Committee debated a bill introduced by the government last week which would move the date for general elections from Nov. 17 to July 7 — more than four months ahead of schedule.
Labor wants elections even earlier and Begin’s coalition appeared headed toward accepting a compromise date in June. Peres is favored by opinion polls to handily beat Begin if voting were held now.
Military government officials have issued orders forbidding West Bank residents from building homes along main roads in the region, closing off hundreds of acres of land to Arab development. Officials said the land was required for road-widening.
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
Begin Gets Parliamentary OK For 3 West Bank Settlements
JERUSALEM (UPI) — Prime Minister Menachem Begin, racing to complete his controversial settlement program before national elections next year, won parliamentary approval for three more settlements on the occupied West Bank.
The move by parliament Monday swept aside objections by Deputy Prime Minister Yigael Yadin and gave Begin the go-ahead for nine of the last 10 settlements in the program, which has been vigorously opposed by West Bank Arabs.
At the same time, Begin’s deputies sanctioned the takeover by 300 settlers of a 40-acre barren hilltop near Givon, about six miles northwest of Jerusalem. The site had been earmarked for a settlement but the Supreme Court ruled last month the land was Arab-owned and ordered the settlers to leave.
Agriculture Minister Ariel Sharon, the architect of the settlement drive, said the government would appeal the court ruling and seek to legalize the takeover. “It is unthinkable that we would tell settlers who have already been promised the site to leave what are, after all, public lands,” Sharon said.
Fears that the opposition Labor Party will win Israel’s national elections this summer and freeze the settlement program lent an air of urgency to the approval of the three West Bank settlements by the parliament’s Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee.
“It’s important to create facts in the Givon area before the elections,” said an aide to Sharon, who heads the ministerial settlement committee. In other West Bank developments reported Monday, the military government confiscated about 50 acres of Arab-owned land near the village of Beit Ur, closing the land to Arab development.
Officials said the land was needed for road-widening. In the Gush Etzion area, south of Bethlehem, settlers have begun fencing off about 200 acres of land for farming. Arab residents complained the land was being cultivated by a local family that has eight buildings on the site.
TEL AVIV, Israel — A Palestinian doctor was sentenced to 10 years in prison for acting as a Soviet spy in Israel and the Israeli-occupied West Bank of the Jordan River, Israel Radio said Saturday. Dr. Johar Sayigh, 35, a Palestinian Arab from the West Bank town of Bir Zeit, was recruited by the Soviets while studying medicine in Moscow, the radio said.
It said he returned to the West Bank with orders to spy for the KGB, the Soviet secret police and intelligence agency. Sayigh was accused of spying both in the West Bank and in Israel itself. At the time of his arrest in October, the Military Command said Sayigh had been instructed to transmit his information through KGB channels at the Soviet Embassy in Amman, Jordan.
It was the first time in memory that Israel has ever claimed to have found a Soviet spy among the Palestinians.
Tel Aviv (Reuter) — Israeli military authorities said yesterday they had seized about 2,500 acres of land near Nablus in the occupied West Bank of the Jordan to add to the Jewish settlement of Ariel. An Israeli spokesman said the area was earmarked for use as an industrial zone.
Village headmen in the area at Salfit, west of Nablus, met yesterday to discuss their response and a lawyer, Felicia Langer, said later she had been asked to take steps to oppose the seizure in the Israeli Supreme Court. The headmen said the land was owned by villagers and used to grow olives, but the Israeli spokesman maintained it was state-owned and could not be cultivated.
Ariel is one of the largest West Bank Jewish settlements with a population of about 2,000. The Israelis say factories will be built there to provide jobs.
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
Israel steps up its claims on Occupied West Bank land
fore the [June 30] elections. They know that if a Labor government finds everything prepared, it will not cancel what has been done.” Khouri said he has eight new land-seizure cases pending, entailing more than 10,000 acres of Arab-claimed land in the West Bank, and that dozens of Arab landowners have come to him in the last two weeks asking for legal help.
The West Bank military government last week declared 3,700 acres of land west of Nablus to be public domain land, 1,700 acres of which have been designated for an industrial center for the Ariel settlement.
At the same time, nearly 2,000 acres near Tubas was declared state land, as well as 1,000 acres near the Biet El settlement and 1,750 acres near the Biet Givron and Meon outposts.
Khouri said an additional 3,750 acres near Jenin, 300 acres near the Gush Etzion settlement bloc and 100 acres near the Kiryat Arba high-rise settlement at Hebron have been earmarked for settlement expansion.
Israeli Deputy Defense Minister Mordechai Zippori said Tuesday night that “nothing special has been done that hasn’t been done for the last 13 years” and that Arab land claimants have the right of appeal. “We are going according to a lawful procedure. ...
Before this land is given to some settlements, we have to announce that this is public land and that we intend to take all the public land,” Zippori said.
Military government officials said that the land in question had been surveyed over the last several months and was found to be without record of ownership, or with records that are so vague that they could not withstand the scrutiny of a court test.
Such property is considered “state land” under Israeli law, and the military governor, as acting sovereign in the West Bank, assumes title.
However, Khouri and other West Bank lawyers said that much of the land not deeded to Arab owners falls into the category of miri land, meaning that its claimants have used it for grazing or cultivation for generations and, in many cases, have paid taxes to a succession of Turkish Ottoman, British and Jordanian authorities.
ANABTA, Occupied West Bank (AP) — An Israeli bulldozer has begun leveling ground for a road to a new Jewish settlement in the West Bank, touching off tension among Arab landowners.
Farmers and landowners tried to stop the bulldozer by blocking its path Thursday and Israeli soldiers fired shots in the air to drive them off, the mayor of this village six miles from the old Israeli frontier said.
Reports that the government is increasing its efforts to settle Jews in the West Bank before the June 30 national election have set West Bank Palestinians on edge again, because they say that whenever Jews move in, Arab land is confiscated.
Anabta Mayor Waheed Hamdallah said that the army informed residents of three surrounding villages that 375 acres of their land were being seized for a new settlement. Hamdallah said that according to a map the army showed the owners, it appeared that as much as 1,000 acres were being taken.
He said bulldozers went to work despite a promise by the Israelis to give the landowners three weeks to appeal the action.
The mayor, whose Palestinian nationalist activities have prompted the Israelis to confine him to his village since May, said he had called a meeting of mayors for tomorrow with the participation of Israeli lawyers who he hoped would fight the expropriations.
Israeli settlement officials denied that the three-week appeal delay had been violated, saying it was the state’s right to build access roads. Hamdallah said the road went through cultivated fields. Israeli spokesmen say the settlement is to go up in a part of the West Bank Samaria District that is only sparsely populated with Jews.
Under the Israeli doctrine that holds that settlements are vital to national security, the new outpost would be especially important because it overlooks Israel proper at its narrowest point. The new settlement, called Shavei Shomron B, is one of 10 outposts that the government says will complete its master plan of 85 Jewish villages in the West Bank.
· estimated · Sioux City Journal · Sioux City · page 1
Representatives of six Sioux City Jewish organizations raised $2,500 for the development of colonization in Palestine
Sioux City Journal
“Representatives of six Sioux City Jewish organizations raised $2,500 for the development of colonization in Palestine after an address here by Joseph Baratz of the World Zionist Action Committee.”
A one-sentence item in a looking-back column, reprinting a local notice from an earlier year. The word used for the project is colonization.
Israeli Arabs Rally in Protest Against Land Requisition
“Thousands of Israeli Arabs held peaceful demonstrations today against the Government’s land requisition policies.
The protests marked the annual observance of ‘Land Day’… Some 3,500 people crowded a schoolyard in Nazareth for a Communist-sponsored rally at which anti-Government speeches were punctuated by rhythmic chants of ‘In blood and spirit shall we redeem Galilee.’”
By 1981 the paper calls it the annual observance. The chant is the same one printed in 1977.
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Rock-throwing Palestinian youths clashed with Israeli troops in Nablus and Ramallah on the occupied West Bank today, Israel Radio reported. The demonstrations came a day before the first anniversary of car bombings that maimed the mayors of the two towns.
Troops used tear gas against students demonstrating at Al Najah college in Nablus, the main West Bank town, Israel Radio said.
By JOHN MACLEAN and JONATHAN BRODER, Chicago Tribune
On a May morning a year ago Adnan Jaber and three other Palestinian terrorists lay in wait as 30 Jews returned from Sabbath prayers in Hebron on the West Bank, where Israelis had illegally settled more than a year before. As the worshippers reached the gate of the old Haddasah clinic, one Palestinian hurled a grenade from a rooftop.
Its explosion triggered a volley of automatic fire from the Soviet-made AK-47 assault rifles of the other terrorists. Some of the Jews were armed but they never had a chance to return the fire. After five minutes, Jaber gave the signal to withdraw. Six settlers were killed and 15 wounded, making the episode one of the bloodier in Israel’s history.
When Jaber was captured four months later trying to slip across the frontier into Jordan, he told his captors of extensive military training he received in the Soviet Union, which also provided the arms for the assault in Hebron.
“The experience I received in the Soviet Union helped me along every military step I’ve had to execute,” Jaber told the Tribune in a private prison interview in Hebron. Jaber’s story exposes the link between the Soviet Union and terrorism. But it also shows the limits of that link, and the dilemma for those who condemn it wholesale.
… [THIS IS THE JUMP OF CP-1981-023, NOT CP-1980-026.] Terrorism Continued from page 1 said. “We studied six classes every day from eight in the morning until four in the afternoon. We learned theory in the classrooms and then went into the field to practice what we had learned.” The course aimed to prepare the Palestinians as platoon commanders.
Jaber said the emphasis was on conventional military techniques rather than individual acts of terror. He found this cause for complaint. “We prefer to go to Vietnam where the training is more contemporary for our kind of guerrilla war,” he said. “The Russian training is based on lessons from World War II.”
But the training was professional nonetheless, he said. During his six-month course instructors remained “detached and professional” and never attempted to foment anti-Israeli feelings. Upon return to Lebanon, Jaber commanded a platoon in the 1975-76 civil war.
Then in 1979 he received orders from PLO military operations commander Abu Jihad to infiltrate into Hebron and await orders. He did, remaining underground 15 months. In April 1980, immediately following the assassination of a top PLO official in Cyprus, Jaber received orders from Jihad to attack Jewish settlers in Hebron.
“Perhaps Abu Jihad wanted revenge and to prove he had a presence in Hebron,” Jaber said. But in Jaber’s view the Israeli settlements drive was reason enough to attack. “This is a war that both sides are fighting, not just us,” he said. “We don’t fight because we like killing. The Palestinian people are being strangled.
We must fight for our cause.” Jaber expressed no remorse for the attack, in which four women were wounded. He said some of the Israelis were armed and an ambush was necessary to success. He did say he was “sorry the situation between the Jews and Palestinians has had to reach this point.” The Palestinian cause long has attracted the Soviets.
In 1970 the Soviet press for the first time referred to Arab terrorist activities as a “liberation struggle” and supported a machinegun attack on an El Al plane at a Zurich airport. A major military aid relationship did not begin until after the 1973 Middle East war.
The Soviets found their main Middle East connection with Egypt broken in the aftermath of that conflict, when the Egyptians turned to the West as a result of U.S. diplomacy. The Palestinians then gave the Soviets a toehold in the region.
The relationship grew until the late 1970s when Palestinian officials openly acknowledged the extensive military and political ties that had grown. “Our boys go to the Soviet Union, they go to the socialist countries,” said Zehdi Labib Terzi, PLO representative at the United Nations, in a 1979 interview with the Public Broadcasting Service.
“They go for training, their education. Oh, yes, we’re getting our direct consignments to the PLO — machine guns, explosives and all that.
“The Soviet Union, and all the rest of the socialist countries, just like the rest of the world, almost, they give us the full support — diplomatic, moral, educational and also they open their military academies to some of our freedom fighters.”
And earlier this year, Muhammed ash-Sha’ir, the PLO’s representative in Moscow, boasted that hundreds of PLO officers have graudated from Soviet military academies and that 2,000 Palestinians currently are undergoing training in the Soviet Union. His statement was reported by several news agencies.
“The relations between the PLO and the Soviet Union are at their best and both sides maintain close ties on matters of policy,” ash-Sha’ir told a Beirut audience in a lecture Feb. 17. He said the PLO and Soviet Union signed an agreement in 1980 when Yasir Arafat visited Moscow calling for coordination on problems of mutual concern.
“A high level Palestinian goes to Moscow whenever a problem arises in order to coordinate a joint stand with the Soviets,” ash-Sha’ir said. PLO leaders also make no secret of their support and cooperation with terrorist groups throughout the world.
“As a revolution we take an interest in problems of liberation all over the world,” said Mag’d Abu Sharar, a member of the PLO Central Committee, in an interview with a Kuwait newspaper in January. “We exchange information and know-how with factions of all liberation forces in the world. We are not dissociated from the forces of world revolution.
Rather we are an integral part thereof.” Cooperation between Palestinians and other groups has become pervasive. Confessed terrorists often say they got Eastern bloc weapons from the PLO in return for favors such as stockpiling arms for the PLO or attacking American and Israeli installations.
One member of Italy’s Red Brigades told police, “The Palestinians are just as anxious as ourselves to undermine Italy’s stability.” In this hemisphere, the PLO helped train the Sandinista guerrillas who overthrew Anastasio Somoza in Nicaragua. In return, the Sandinista government pledged full support for the PLO.
“The cause of the PLO is that of the Sandinistas,” Interior Minister Thomas Borge said in welcoming Yasir Arafat to Nicaragua shortly after Somoza’s overthrow. With the support of the Soviet Union, the PLO has been more successful at making terror than at making peace.
Like the Soviets, the Palestinians ippear to have created a creature over which they lack control. When Arafat sought in 1979 to dampen the PLO’s revolutionary rhetoric in a bid to make the group more acceptable to Europeans, he was defeated by rejectionists within Fatah who used as their main weapon Arafat’s own words.
Meeting last summer in Damascus, Fatah called for the overthrow of Israel by armed force, although Arafat sough to soften the statement. The words adopted were his own from many years before calling for “the liquidation of the Zionist entity politically, culturally and militarily.”
The Israelis believe the Soviets also tried to thwart the peace bid in 1979 because it was carried out independently of them. Israeli government officials said the Soviets actively built ties with more radical elements within the PLO to undermine Arafat. The PLO received world attention by terrorism. Now it has found the way to peace blocked by terrorism.
Tomorrow: The Cuban terror connection. [The rest of the clipping is other material and is NOT part of this article: a second banner, “Murder”, over a continuation about the Harrison murders at Longs Bend (“Continued from page 1”, quoting a man named Baird and a man named Ray); a separate item “Gunman killed in FBI building”, ATLANTA (UPI); and display advertising — KINGSPORT FUN FEST, KINGSPORT OPTICAL, and a gold-buying advertisement.]
Date check: No masthead and no page date line survive on this clipping — it is trimmed to the headline, the italic series note, the “TERRORISM / Second of three parts” art and five text columns, with “More on page 2A, col. 3” at the foot. Nothing on the clipping confirms either the date or the paper, so 1981-06-29 could not be checked.
Prime Minister Begin feels now is the time to strike hard for Israeli security interests
Geoffrey Godsell
(Editor’s Note: Joseph C. Harsch took a few day off. His column should resume on Friday.) THE reason for the fury of the latest Israeli attacks on Lebanon is that the Israeli government perceives events as possibly moving to impede its aim of neutralizing once and for all the Palestinian position in Lebanon.
Ironically, although Israelis are not saying so publicly, one of the factors making them feel their position vis-a-vis Lebanon could be undermined is the turn taken by President Reagan’s peace envoy in the Middle East, Philip C. Habib.
What concerns the more zealous Israeli hawks is Habib’s involving himself, albeit indirectly, to get the most important of Israel’s client groups in Lebanon — the Gemayel family’s Phalangists — to unhook itself from its association with Israel.
Flushed by his recent election victory, Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin apparently feels that now is the moment to strike hard in support of what he sees as Israel’s security interests — even if this means killing Lebanese civilians in the heart of Beirut, as Israeli warplanes did last week.
Begin seems to feel that he can pursue this course regardless of its effect on the Habib mission and overall Israeli relations with the United States. He has seen that so far the pro-Israeli lobby in the United States is a trump card that he can call out or play effectively.
Presumably he also is persuaded by the argument from within and without government in Washington that the new Reagan administration still has no clear long-term Middle East policy. As for the Palestinian threat to Israel from across its borders with Arab lands, Israel has long since neutralized it from the direction of Egypt, Jordan and Syria.
In Egypt’s case, Israel has done this with a peace treaty; in Jordan’s and Syria’s, by making it clear to the governments of those two countries that the price of Palestinian action against Israel from their territories was massive Israeli retaliation.
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
JERUSALEM (UPI) — U.S. envoy Philip Habib today announced an end to two weeks of fighting between Israel and Palestinian guerrillas along the Lebanese frontier in a cease-fire that an Israeli official called a “gentlemen’s agreement.” PLO chairman Yasser Arafat told U.N.
Secretary General Kurt Waldheim he could not remain silent “toward the killing of Lebanese and Palestinian civilians,” but would stick to a cease-fire “on condition the other side abides by it.” “It’s a gentlemen’s agreement,” an Israeli official said. “If they (the Palestinians) are going to be gentlemen, then fine.
But we are very suspicious that they won’t.” In Washington, White House spokesman Larry Speakes said, “President Reagan welcomes this as a hopeful and encouraging sign on the road to achieve peace in this critical region of the world. He expresses his deepest appreciation to Ambassador Habib for his continuing efforts.”
“I have today reported to President Reagan that as of 1:30 p.m. local time (7:30 a.m. EDT), July 24, 1981, all hostile military action between Lebanese and Israeli territory in either direction will cease,” Habib told reporters in Jerusalem. “The government of Israel endorsed the statement just made to you by Mr.
Philip Habib, the emissary of the President of the United States,” Begin said. The wording of the typed, half-page agreement avoided use of the word “cease-fire” since that would require the signatures of both warring parties. Israel has refused any direct or indirect contact with the Palestinians.
The agreement also includes Israel’s northern border ally, Maj. Saad Haddad, who controls the Lebanese Christian enclave along the frontier. The United Nations was not involved in the arrangement, the officials said, but it indirectly involved Saudi Arabia.
It made no mention of Israeli reconnaissance flights over Lebanon which Israel insists must continue or the Syrian deployment of anti-aircraft missiles in Lebanon.
CEASE-FIRE ANNOUNCED — U.S. presidential envoy Philip Habib said today in Jerusalem that all hostile military action between Lebanese and Israeli territory in either direction will cease. Prime Minister Menachem Begin, right, gave Israel’s endorsement to Habib’s statement.
Correction: The deck caption read 4 July 1981. The masthead on the scan reads "FRIDAY, JULY 24, 1981 BRATTLEBORO, VERMONT"; 24 July 1981 was a Friday and 4 July 1981 was a Saturday.
Israel, Palestinian guerrillas agree to cease-fire
JERUSALEM (UPI) — U.S. envoy Philip Habib today announced an end to two weeks of fighting between Israel and Palestinian guerrillas along the Lebanese frontier in a cease-fire that an Israeli official called a “gentlemen's agreement.” PLO chairman Yasser Arafat told U.N.
Secretary General Kurt Waldheim he could not remain silent “toward the killing of Lebanese and Palestinian civilians,” but would stick to a cease-fire “on condition the other side abides by it.” In accepting the truce, the PLO referred to “United Nations efforts” toward a cease-fire, the Palestinian news agency WAFA reported.
WAFA said PLO leaders agreed “to a cease-fire effective at 5 p.m. (11 a.m. EDT) as a response to the United Nations and Gen. Callaghan's efforts.” Maj. Gen. William Callaghan, commander of the U.N. peacekeeping force in south Lebanon, has acted as a go-between Waldheim and the PLO.
Waldheim welcomed the cease-fire and said he hoped it would end “the cycle of violence” in the Middle East. “It's a gentlemen's agreement,” an Israeli official said. “If they (the Palestinians) are going to be gentlemen, then fine. But we are very suspicious that they won't.”
In Washington, White House spokesman Larry Speakes said, “President Reagan welcomes this as a hopeful and encouraging sign on the road to achieve peace in this critical region of the world. He expresses his deepest appreciation to Ambassador Habib for his continuing efforts.”
“I have today reported to President Reagan that as of 1:30 p.m. local time (7:30 a.m. EDT), July 24, 1981, all hostile military action between Lebanese and Israeli territory in either direction will cease,” Habib told reporters in Jerusalem.
TEL AVIV, Aug. 30 (UPI) — Explosives inside a cart blew up today in the occupied West Bank town of Nablus, killing an 8-year-old Arab girl and wounding 14 people in the open-air market, an Israeli military spokesman said.
Among the wounded was the man wheeling the cart, who the army said was a suspected Palestinian guerrilla transfering the explosives through the crowded market. “This is purely a terrorist project,” an army spokesman asserted. The 8-year-old daughter of a cigarette vendor was killed by the explosion, the army radio said.
The wounded, including one person who was seriously hurt, were taken to a Nablus hospital.
CAIRO, Egypt (AP) — American, Egyptian and Israeli negotiators met for the first time in 13 months today to resume the U.S sponsored talks on autonomy for Palestinians living in Israeli-occupied territory.
The talks, being held in a hotel near the great pyramids of Egypt and the Sphinx, were broken off by Egyptian President Anwar Sadat last August for a variety of reasons, including the proliferation of Israeli settlements in occupied Arab territories and Israel’s formal annexation of Arab East Jerusalem.
“We resume today the trilateral autonomy negotiations with a new hope for the success of the talks, with a new American administration and the late elections in Israel,” said Kamal Hassan Aly, Egypt’s top negotiator and foreign minister.
The talks continued behind closed doors after brief introductory statements by Aly, the head of Israel’s delegation, Interior Minister Yosef Burg, and one of the American representatives, Alfred Atherton, the U.S. ambassador to Cairo. The American ambassador to Israel, Samuel Lewis, is the other U.S. representative at the talks.
Israel has announced a plan to offer Arabs senior posts in the Israeli occupation government. A Defense Ministry statement issued Tuesday night said Israel will soon replace its 14-year-old military government of the West Bank of the Jordan River and the Gaza Strip with an Israeli-run civilian regime.
The new administration would give “senior posts” to West Bank and Gaza Arabs, it said. Israeli army generals would still handle military matters and anti-guerrilla activity in the occupied territories, it said.
The statement did not detail how the plan would change the lives of the 1.2 million Palestinians living under Israeli occupation on the West Bank of the Jordan River and the Gaza strip.
The general Israeli aim is to suppress the influence of its archenemy, the Palestine Liberation Organization, while encouraging Arab moderates to join the autonomy talks, sources close to the government said.
ROME (AP) — A bomb exploded under the hotel bed of a leader in Yasser Arafat's Palestine Liberation Organization early today, killing him instantly, police and firemen said. Police and the Rome office of the PLO identified the dead man as Majed abu Sharar, a member of the Central Committee of Arafat's Fatah Faction, the largest element of the multi-factioned PLO.
They said Sharar was also spokesman for the Unified Information Center of all PLO guerrilla factions. The attack was claimed by “the General Command of al-Assifa forces” in anonymous phone calls to news agencies in Rome and Beirut. The callers said Sharar was killed because he had left the “proper course of the Palestine revolution and the armed struggle.”
The al-Assifa Revolutionary Council is a dissident Palestinian group led by Abu Nidal, who split from the PLO and has strongly criticized Arafat for being too moderate. The group has been linked to the Aug. 29 bombing of a Vienna synagogue in which two people were killed and 20 were injured. The PLO office in Rome claimed Israeli agents murdered Sharar.
Police had first said the dead man blew himself up while working on a plastic explosive bomb. The explosion ripped through Sharar's fifth-floor room in the Hotel Flora on the fashionable Via Veneto at about 7 p.m. Thursday, Galesburg time, police said.
The blast destroyed the room, dislodged a piece of masonry that fell onto a parked car below, and started a brief fire that damaged three other rooms, police said. Nobody else was hurt in the explosion. Firemen said they were sure the bomb was underneath Sharar's bed because a piece of plaster broke off from the ceiling of the room directly below it.
Police said Sharar was in Rome for an international conference of Palestinian writers, journalists and intellectuals. The conference observed a minute of silence for him today, a PLO spokesmen said. Sharar was traveling with an Algerian passport under the name of Habbas Zithouni, police said. The Rome PLO office said Sharar used the false identity for security reasons.
Sharar, about 40 years old, lived in Beirut, where he was married and had three children. Considered one of the most strident advocates of Marxism in the PLO hierarchy, he was also a literary critic.
ROME (AP) — A bomb exploded under the hotel bed of a leader in Yasser Arafat’s Palestine Liberation Organization early today, killing him instantly, police and firemen said. Police and the Rome office of the PLO identified the dead man as Majed abu Sharar, a member of the Central Committee of Arafat’s Fatah Faction, the largest element of the multi-factioned PLO.
They said Sharar was also spokesman for the Unified Information Center of all PLO guerrilla factions. The attack was claimed by “the General Command of al-Assifa forces” in anonymous phone calls to news agencies in Rome and Beirut. The callers said Sharar was killed because he had left the “proper course of the Palestine revolution and the armed struggle.”
The al-Assifa Revolutionary Council is a dissident Palestinian group led by Abu Nidal, who split from the PLO and has strongly criticized Arafat for being too moderate. The group has been linked to the Aug. 29 bombing of a Vienna synagogue in which two people were killed and 20 were injured. The PLO office in Rome claimed Israeli agents murdered Sharar.
Police had first said the dead man blew himself up while working on a plastic explosive bomb. The explosion ripped through Sharar’s fifth-floor room in the Hotel Flora on the fashionable Via Veneto at about 1:00 a.m. (8 p.m. EDT Thursday), police said.
The blast destroyed the room, dislodged a piece of masonry that fell onto a parked car below, and started a brief fire that damaged three other rooms, police said. Nobody else was hurt in the explosion. Firemen said they were sure the bomb was underneath Sharar’s bed because a piece of plaster broke off from the ceiling of the room directly below it.
Police said Sharar was in Rome for an international conference of Palestinian writers, journalists and intellectuals. The conference observed a minute of silence for him today, a PLO spokesmen said. Sharar was traveling with an Algerian passport under the name of Habbas Zithouni, police said. The Rome PLO office said Sharar used the false identity for security reasons.
Sharar, about 40 years old, lived in Beirut, where he was married and had three children. Considered one of the most strident advocates of Marxism in the PLO hierarchy, he was also a literary critic.
ROME (AP) — A bomb exploded in a Rome hotel late Thursday and killed a spokesman for Yasser Arafat’s Palestine Liberation Organization, police and firemen said. Police and a PLO source in Rome dentified the dead man as Majed abu Sharar, a member of the Central Committee of Arafat’s Fatah Faction, the largest element of the multi-factioned PLO.
The source said Sharar was also spokesman for the Unified Information Center of PLO guerrilla factions. Callers identifying themselves as “The General Command of al-Assifa forces” phoned news agencies in Rome and Beirut, and claimed responsibility for the bombing.
The callers said Sharar was killed because he had left the “proper course of the Palestine revolution and the armed struggle.” The al-Assifa Revolutionary Council is a dissident Palestinian group led by Abu Nidal, who split from the PLO and has strongly criticized Arafat for being too moderate. The group has been linked to the Aug.
29 bombing of a Vienna synagogue in which two people were killed and 20 were injured. The PLO office in Rome claimed Israeli agents murdered Sharar. Police had first said the dead man blew himself up while working on a plastic explosive bomb. The explosion ripped through Sharar’s fifth-floor room in the Hotel Flora on the fashionable Via Veneto at about 1:00 a.m. (7 p.m.
CDT Thursday), police said. The blast destroyed the room, dislodged a piece of masonry that fell onto a parked car below, and started a brief fire that damaged three other rooms, police said. Nobody else was hurt in the explosion.
Firemen said they were sure the bomb was underneath Sharar’s bed because a piece of plaster broke off from the ceiling of the room directly below it. Police said Sharar was in Rome for an international conference of Palestinian writers, journalists and intellectuals. Friday, the conference observed a minute of silence for Sharar, a PLO spokesmen said.
Sharar was traveling with an Algerian passport under the name of Habbas Zithouni, police said. The Rome PLO office said Sharar used the false identity for security reasons.
ROME — The Palestine Liberation Organization has accused the Central Intelligence Agency and the Israeli Secret Service of the murder of a leading Palestinian activist in a Rome hotel. The PLO said his death will be avenged.
Majjed Abu Sharar, chief PLO information officer, was killed yesterday when a bomb exploded beneath his bed at the Hotel Flora on Rome’s Via Veneto.
He was reported to be in Italy for a conference of writers on Palestinian solidarity, but an unnamed PLO spokesman said Sharar was in Rome to attend a conference of Arab terrorists in a suburban Rome hotel and carried an Algerian passport as a security precaution. In telephone calls to news agencies, a Palestinian splinter group claimed responsibility.
These claims were dismissed “as a CIA coverup” by Abu Iyad, second in command to Al Fatah leader Yasir Arafat. Abu Sharar was a member of the central committee of Al Fatah, the main PLO guerrilla group, and was said to be a close friend of Arafat. Until last year he served as secretary of Al Fatah’s revolutionary council and was in charge of recruitment.
He then became director of the movement’s information office with special responsibility for Palestinian journalists in Israeli-occupied territories. He was registered in the hotel under the name of Abbas Zithouni, 47, supposedly an Algerian living in Beirut.
Rome police at first believed Abu Sharar might have been assembling the bomb in preparation for a terrorist attack when it exploded, but fire brigade experts confirmed last night they found clear evidence the bomb had been placed under Sharar’s bed. A fire caused by the explosion was restricted to Sharar’s room and was quickly brought under control.
A caller who identified himself as a spokesman for the general command of the Assifa “storm” forces said in Beirut, “Majjed Abu Sharar and his colleagues have diverted from the proper course of the Palestinian revolution and armed struggle ….
Those people represent treachery and as we have liquidated him we shall liquidate others that have diverted from the sacred course.” The name Assifa is used by the military wing of Al Fatah but the general command is a breakaway group led by Abu Nidal, a guerrilla who was expelled in 1974 and sentenced to death in absentia.
In return, he vowed to kill the Al Fatah leadership including Arafat. Abu Nidal, who is said to be based in Damascus, has been engaged in a campaign of assassination against prominent PLO representatives whom he regards as backing Arafat’s moves toward moderation and diplomatic activity rather than a military overthrow of Israel.
At an angry Beirut press conference, Abu Iyad accepted that there were differences between the Fatah leadership and Abu Nidal, but he said he was certain that the group was not responsible for Abu Sharar’s death. There was no doubt the CIA and Israeli intelligence were responsible.
Two bomb attacks on Israeli targets near the Hotel Flora the previous night had been set up to distract Italian security authorities from the Abu Sharar killing, he said. Abu Iyad said the the bomb was planted under Abu Sharar’s bed between 10 p.m. and midnight. The blast went off at about 1 a.m.
“This murder is a follow-up to the United States and Israeli decision to liquidate the leadership of the Palestinian people,” he added, praising the victim as a martyr who had given his life to the Palestinian cause.
Nine years after a bomb in a car in Beirut killed a Palestinian novelist, a bomb under a bed in Rome kills the man in charge of the PLO’s information office, who was reported to be in Italy for a conference of writers. The paper prints both accounts of why he was there without choosing between them, in consecutive clauses of the same sentence.
ROME (AP) — A top Palestine Liberation Organization leader was killed Friday when a bomb exploded under his hotel bed, authorities reported. An extremist Palestinian organization claimed responsibility, but the PLO blamed the CIA and Israeli intelligence.
Police said Majed Abu Sharar, a member of the Central Committee of Yasser Arafat's Fatah group, one of many factions in the PLO, was killed instantly by the explosion, which destroyed his fifth-floor room in the Hotel Flora on the fashionable Via Veneto at about 1 a.m.
The blast also started a fire that damaged three other rooms and knocked loose a piece of masonry that landed on a parked car in the street below. Nobody besides Sharar was reported hurt. Firemen said they could tell the bomb had been under Sharar's bed because a piece of plaster was blasted off the ceiling of the room directly below.
Anonymous callers to news agencies in Rome and Beirut claimed responsibility in the name of “the General Command of Al-Assifa forces” and said Sharar, 47, was killed because he had left the “proper course of the Palestine revolution and the armed struggle.”
The Al-Assifa Revolutionary Council is a splinter group led by Abu Nidal, who split from the PLO and accused Arafat of being too moderate in his confrontation with Israel.
In Beirut, PLO security chief Salah Khalaf, better known by the code name Abu Iyad, said at a news conference, “This criminal act is the work of the American Central Intelligence Agency and their tools, the Israeli intelligence services.” Abu Nidal, who has threatened to kill both Abu Iyad and Arafat, now lives in Damascus.
His group has been linked to Austrian authorities to the Aug. 29 bombing of a Vienna synagogue in which two people were killed and 20 injured. “Despite my feelings about Abu Nidal, I am convinced that this time he was not responsible,” Abu Iyad said.
“All other claims of responsibility for the crime only aim at covering up for the American and Israeli intelligence services who have taken a decision to liquidate the high-ranking leadership of the Palestinian revolution.” Police said Sharar was in Rome for an international conference of Palestinian writers, journalists and intellectuals.
He was traveling with an Algerian passport under the name of Habbas Zithouni, authorities said. A PLO spokesman said Sharar used a false identity for security reasons. Sharar was secretary of Fatah's Revolutionary Council until 1980 and director of the PLO's unified information services since 1972. He was born in 1936 in Hebron, now part of the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
He was married and had three children. He was elected Fatah Central Committee member in 1980.
ROME, Italy (UPI) — The information chief of the Palestine Liberation Organization was killed Friday when a bomb exploded under his bed in one of Rome's most luxurious hotels. Police said it was a highly professional assassination. Majed Abu Sharar, chief of the PLO's public relations department, died when the bomb went off shortly before 1 a.m. (8 p.m.
EDT Thursday) in his room on the fourth floor of the Flora hotel. A PLO official blamed Israel for the attack, calling Abu Sharar a victim of the “homicidal madness of Israeli terrorists.”
However, a hard-line Palestinian group in Beirut claimed responsibility for the assassination, saying it killed Abu Sharar because he had “diverged” from the radical line and had become too moderate.
The bomb, placed beneath his bed, started a fire that burned Abu Sharar's corpse beyond recognition and forced scores of tourists and other hotel guests to flee their rooms in nightclothes. Police at first theorized Abu Sharar may have been preparing the bomb for a terrorist attack and that it had exploded prematurely.
A bomb blast on Thursday damaged an Israeli tourist office only two blocks from the Flora hotel. However, fire brigade experts said later they found evidence the bomb was rigged under Abu Sharar's bed. Al Assifa, a pro-Syrian guerrilla group, telephoned news agencies in Beirut and Rome to claim responsibility for the killing.
Group Opposing Arafat Claims Responsibility but Guerrilla Group Accuses C.I.A.
By JOHN KIFNER
BEIRUT, Lebanon, Oct. 9 — A member of the Palestine Liberation Organization’s Central Council and of Al Fatah’s Executive Committee was killed today in an explosion in his Rome hotel room.
Responsibility for the slaying of Majed Abu Shrar was claimed by an organization that is supposedly secretly supported by Syria and that is dedicated to undermining the leadership of Yasir Arafat, who heads both the P.L.O. and Al Fatah, its largest constituent group. In a news conference here, however, Mr.
Arafat’s top associate, Saleh Khalef, who is better known by his code name, Abu Iyad, said the explosion was the work of the American Central Intelligence Agency and of the Israeli intelligence agency. Mr.
Abu Shrar, who headed the P.L.O.’s Unified Information Unit, was registered at the Flora Hotel, overlooking the Via Veneto, under a false name and using an Algerian passport. Palestinian sources said he was in Rome to attend a conference of journalists and writers sympathetic to the Palestinians.
This afternoon, shortly after the explosion — which was believed to have been caused by a booby-trapped telephone — callers to the Reuters bureau in Rome and to news agencies here said the bombing was carried out by Al Assifa, which is the name of the military wing of Al Fatah and also the name used by the Syrian-supported group, which is headed by Abu Nidal.
Abu Nidal broke with Mr. Arafat in the early 1970’s over the issue of Mr. Arafat’s willingness to negotiate with Israel for a limited Palestinian state. Under the protection of the Iraqi Government, he waged for a time the “war of the shadows” in which eight overseas P.L.O. representatives were killed.
The Syrian sponsorship of the organization has strained relations between Mr. Arafat’s associates and Syria, which is the ostensible protector of the Palestinian guerrilla movement in Lebanon. The caller to the Rome Reuters bureau said that Mr.
Abu Shrar had been killed beause he represented “the line of surrender,” and added, “As we killed Abu Shrar, so we shall hit anyone who will try to compromise about the principles of our revolution.”
Palestinian officials at news conference in Beirut are, from left, Abu Saleh, Saleh Khalef (also known as Abu Iyad) and Yasir Abed Rabbo. || Majed Abu Shrar, victim of bomb. (credited “Associated Press”)
ROME (AP)— A top Palestine Liberation Organization leader was killed Friday when a bomb exploded under his hotel bed, authorities reported. An extremist Palestinian organization claimed responsibility, but the PLO blamed the CIA and Israeli intelligence.
Police said Majed Abu Sharar, a member of the Central Committee of Yasser Arafat’s Fatah group, one of many factions in the PLO, was killed instantly by the explosion, which destroyed his fifth-floor room in the Hotel Flora on the fashionable Via Veneto about 1 a.m.
The blast also started a fire that damaged three other rooms and knocked loose a piece of masonry that landed on a parked car in the street below. Nobody besides Sharar was reported hurt. Firemen said they could tell the bomb had been under Sharar’s bed because a piece of plaster was blasted off the ceiling of the room directly below.
Anonymous callers to news agencies in Rome and Beirut claimed responsibility in the name of “the General Command of Al-Assifa forces,” and said Sharar, 47, was killed because he had left the “proper course of the Palestine revolution and the armed struggle.”
The Al-Assifa Revolutionary Council is a splinter group led by Abu Nidal, who split from the PLO and accused Arafat of being too moderate in his confrontation with Israel.
In Beirut, PLO security chief Salah Khalaf, better known by the code name Abu Iyad, said at a news conference: “This criminal act is the work of the American Central Intelligence Agency and their tools, the Israeli intelligence services.” Abu Nidal, who has threatened to kill both Abu Iyad and Arafat, now lives in Damascus.
His group has been linked by Austrian authorities to the Aug. 29 bombing of a Vienna synagogue in which two people were killed and 20 injured. “Despite my feelings about Abu Nidal, I am convinced that this time he was not responsible,” Abu Iyad said.
“All other claims of responsibility for the crime only aim at covering up for the American and Israeli intelligence services who have taken a decision to liquidate the high-ranking leadership of the Palestinian revolution.” Police said Sharar was in Rome for an international conference of Palestinian writers, journalists and intellectuals.
He was traveling with an Algerian passport under the name of Habbas Zithouni, authorities said. A PLO spokesman said Sharar used a false identity for security reasons. Sharar was secretary of Fatah’s Revolutionary Council until 1980 and director of the PLO’s unified information services since 1972. He was born in 1936 in Hebron, now part of the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
He was married and had three children. He was elected Fatah Central Committee member in 1980.
ROME, Italy (UPI) — The information chief of the Palestine Liberation Organization was killed Friday by a bomb exploded under his bed in one of Rome’s most luxurious hotels. Police said it was a highly professional assassination. Majed Abu Sharar, chief of the PLO’s public relations department, died when the bomb went off shortly before 1 a.m. (8 p.m.
EDT Thursday) in his room on the fourth floor of the Flora hotel on Rome’s touristfamed Via Veneto. A PLO spokesman blamed Israel for the attack, calling Abu Sharar a victim of the “homicidal madness of Israeli terrorists.”
However, a hard-line Palestinian group in Beirut claimed responsibility for the assassination, saying it killed Abu Sharar because he had “diverged” from the radical line and had become too moderate.
The bomb, placed beneath his bed, started a fire that burned Abu Sharar’s corpse beyond recognition and forced scores of tourists and other hotel guests to flee their rooms in nightclothes. Firemen quickly extinguished the blaze. Police at first theorized Abu Sharar may have been preparing the bomb for a terrorist attack and that it had exploded prematurely.
A bomb blast on Thursday damaged an Israeli tourist office only two blocks from the Flora hotel. However, fire brigade experts said later they found evidence the bomb was rigged under Abu Sharar’s bed. Abu Sharar was registered at the hotel as Abbas Zithouni, 47, an Algerian living in Beirut.
A spokesman for the PLO’s Rome office conceded Zithouni was really Abu Sharar, the PLO’s top information official and a member of the central committee of Al Fatah, the guerrilla group headed by Yasser Arafat. The spokesman said Sharar, in Rome for a conference of Arab journalists, carried the Algerian passport as a security precaution.
Al Assifa, a pro-Syrian guerrilla group, telephoned new agencies in Beirut and Rome to claim responsibility for the killing. “We have killed the traitor Majed Abu Sharar in Rome. He and his friends had diverged from the proper path of the Palestinian revolution and armed struggle. They represented the line of surrender,” the caller said.
“In the same way we killed Abu Sharar, we will kill all other who seek to compromise the principles of our revolution,” it said. Abu Sharar, born in a village in what is now Israel and father of three children, was known as a moderate intellectual. He was a close friend of Wael Zuaiter, a Palestine poet assassinated in Rome in 1972.
ROME, Italy (UPI) — The information chief of the Palestine Liberation Organization was killed Friday by a bomb exploded under his bed in one of Rome's most luxurious hotels. Police said it was a highly professional assassination. Majed Abu Sharar, chief of the PLO's public relations department, died when the bomb went off shortly before 1 a.m. (8 p.m.
EDT Thursday) in his room on the fourth floor of the Flora hotel on Rome's tourist-famed Via Veneto. A PLO spokesman blmaed Israel for the attack, calling Abu Sharar a victim of the “homicidal madness of Israeli terrorists.”
However, a hard-line Palestinian group in Beirut claimed responsibility for the assassination, saying it killed Abu Sharar because he had “diverged” from the radical line and had become too moderate.
The bomb, placed beneath his bed, started a fire that burned Abu Sharar's corpse beyond recognition and forced scores of tourists and other hotel guests to flee their rooms in nightclothes. Firemen quickly extinguished the blaze. Police at first theorized Abu Sharar may have been preparing the bomb for a terrorist attack and that it had exploded prematurely.
A bomb blast on Thursday damaged an Israeli tourist office only two blocks from the Flora hotel. However, fire brigade experts said later they found evidence the bomb was rigged under Abu Sharar's bed. Abu Sharar was registered at the hotel as Abbas Zithouni, 47, an Algerian living in Beirut.
A spokesman for the PLO's Rome office conceded Zithouni was really Abu Sharar, the PLO's top information official and a member of the central committee of Al Fatah, the guerrilla group headed by Yasser Arafat. The spokesman said Sharar, in Rome for a conference of Arab journalists, carried the Algerian passport as a security precaution.
Al Assifa, a pro-Syrian guerrilla group, telephoned new agencies in Beirut and Rome to claim responsibility for the killing. “We have killed the traitor Majed Abu Sharar in Rome. He and his friends had diverged from the proper path of the Palestinian revolution and armed struggle. They represented the line of surrender,” the caller said.
“In the same way we killed Abu Sharar, we will kill all other who seek to compromise the principles of our revolution,” it said. Abu Sharar, born in a village in what is now Israel and father of three children, was known as a moderate intellectual. He was a close friend of Wael Zuaiter, a Palestine poet assassinated in Rome in 1972.
ROME, Italy (UPI) — The information chief of the Palestine Liberation Organization was killed yesterday by a bomb that apparently exploded under his bed in one of Rome's most luxurious hotels. Police said it was a highly professional assassination.
Majed Abu Sharar, chief of the PLO's public relations department, was killed instantly in the explosion shortly before 1 a.m. in his room on the fourth floor of the Flora Hotel on Rome's Via Veneto. A PLO spokesman in Beirut, Lebanon, blamed Israel, calling Abu Sharar a victim of the “homicidal madness of Israeli terrorists.”
However, a hard-line Palestinian group in Beirut claimed responsibility for the assassination, saying it killed Abu Sharar because he had “diverged” from the radical line and had become too moderate. The explosion started a fire and burned Abu Sharar's body beyond recognition and forced scores of tourists and other hotel guests to flee their rooms.
Firemen quickly extinguished the blaze. Police at first theorized that Abu Sharar may have been preparing the bomb for a terrorist attack and that it had exploded prematurely. A bomb blast on Thursday damaged an Israeli tourist office only two blocks from the Flora. However, fire brigade experts said later they found evidence the bomb was rigged under Abu Sharar's bed.
Abu Sharar was registered at the hotel as Abbas Zithouni, 47, an Algerian living in Beirut. A spokesman for the PLO's Rome office conceded Zithouni was really Abu Sharar, also a member of the Central Committee of Al Fatah, the largest guerrilla group headed by Yasser Arafat.
The spokesman said Abu Sharar, in Rome for a conference of Arab journalists, carried the Algerian passport as a security precaution. Al Assifa, a pro-Syrian guerrilla group, telephoned new agencies in Beirut and Rome to claim responsibility. “We have killed the traitor Majed Abu Sharar in Rome.
He and his friends had diverged from the proper path of the Palestinian revolution and armed struggle. They represented the line of surrender,” the caller said. “In the same way we killed Abu Sharar, we will kill all others who seek to compromise the principles of our revolution,” the group said.
PLO information chief is killed by bomb in Rome hotel room
United Press International
ROME — The information chief of the Palestine Liberation Organization was killed Friday by a bomb that exploded under his bed in one of Rome's most luxurious hotels. Police called the assassination highly professional.
Majed Abu Sharar, chief of the PLO's public-relations department, died when the bomb went off shortly after midnight in his room on the fourth floor of the Flora hotel on Rome's tourist-famed Via Veneto. A PLO spokesman blamed Israel for the attack and called Abu Sharar a victim of the “homicidal madness of Israeli terrorists.”
However, a hard-line Palestinian group in Beirut, Lebanon, claimed responsibility for the assassination and said it killed Abu Sharar because he had “diverged” from the radical line and had become too moderate. The bomb started a fire that burned Abu Sharar's corpse beyond recognition and forced scores of tourists and other hotel guests to flee their rooms in night clothes.
Firemen quickly extinguished the blaze. Police at first theorized Abu Sharar may have been preparing the bomb for a terrorist attack and that it had exploded prematurely. A bomb blast Thursday damaged an Israeli tourist office only two blocks from the Flora hotel. However, fire experts later said they found evidence the bomb had been rigged under Abu Sharar's bed.
Abu Sharar was registered at the hotel as Abbas Zithouni, 47, an Algerian living in Beirut. A spokesman for the PLO's Rome office conceded that Zithouni was really Abu Sharar, the PLO's top information official and a member of the central committee of Al Fatah, the guerrilla group headed by Yasser Arafat.
The spokesman said Abu Sharar, in Rome for a conference of Arab journalists, carried the Algerian passport as a security precaution. Al Assifa, a pro-Syrian guerrilla group, telephoned news agencies in Beirut and Rome to claim responsibility for the killing. “We have killed the traitor Majed Abu Sharar in Rome,” the caller said.
“He and his friends had diverged from the proper path of the Palestinian revolution and armed struggle. “They represented the line of surrender. “In the same way we killed Abu Sharar, we wil[l] kill all others who seek to compromise the principle[s] of our revolution.”
PEKING — Vice Chairman Deng Xiaoping told PLO leader Yasser Arafat on Friday that Chinese aid to the Palestinian cause will be limited, the official Xinhua news agency reported. “You have to rely mainly on your own efforts and on the unity of the Arab countries and peoples,” Deng told the Palestine Liberation Organization leader.
But Arafat denied he had been rebuffed in his bid for greater Chinese assistance. He declined to spell out the results of his talks but said he obtained “very concrete” commitments from the Chinese leadership.
Arafat also told reporters that the assassination of Egyptian President Anwar Sadat proved there will be no Middle East peace until the Palestinians get their own homeland. Asked whether Sadat's death would force a change in U.S. policy in the Middle East, Arafat said, “Be sure that what happened in the area in the last 72 hours is the answer to your question.
“(There will be) no peace, no settlements, no solutions, no stability by overjumping the Palestinian rights, including our right to return to our homeland, our right for self-determination, our right for our own independent state.”
Arafat, a critic of Sadat for signing the Camp David accords with Israel and the United States, said the Egyptian army and people could never forgive “a man who capitulates and gives up the rights of the Palestinian cause, the Palestinian people and Jerusalem.” Arafat also met with Chairman Hu Yaobang during his final day in China.
Rome, Italy (UPI) — The information chief of the Palestine Liberation Organization was killed Friday by a bomb that exploded under his bed in one of Rome's most luxurious hotels. Police said it was a highly professional assassination. Majed Abu Sharar, chief of the PLO's public relations department, died when the bomb went off shortly before 1 a.m. (7 p.m.
EST Thursday) in his room on the fourth floor of the Flora hotel on Rome's tourist-famed Via Veneto. A PLO SPOKESMAN blamed Israel for the attack, calling Abu Sharar a victim of the “homicidal madness of Israeli terrorists.”
However, a hard-line Palestinian group in Beirut claimed responsibility for the assassination, saying it killed Abu Sharar because he had “diverged” from the radical line and had become too moderate.
The bomb, placed beneath his bed, started a fire that burned Abu Sharar's corpse beyond recognition and forced scores of tourists and other hotel guests to flee their rooms in nightclothes. Firemen quickly extinguished the blaze. Police at first thought Abu Sharar may have been preparing the bomb for a terrorist attack and that it had exploded prematurely.
A bomb blast on Thursday damaged an Israeli tourist office only two blocks from the Flora hotel. HOWEVER, FIRE brigade experts said later they found evidence the bomb was rigged under Abu Sharar's bed. Abu Sharar was registered at the hotel as Abbas Zithouni, 47, an Algerian living in Beirut.
A spokesman for the PLO's Rome office conceded that Zithouni was really Abu Sharar, the PLO's top information official and a member of the central committee of Al Fatah, the guerrilla group headed by Yasser Arafat. The spokesman said Sharar, in Rome for a conference of Arab journalists, carried the Algerian passport as a security precaution.
AL ASSIFA, a pro-Syrian guerrilla group, telephoned new agencies in Beirut and Rome to claim responsibility for the killing. “We have killed the traitor Majed Abu Sharar in Rome. He and his friends had diverged from the proper path of the Palestinian revolution and armed struggle. They represented the line of surrender,” the caller said.
“In the same way we killed Abu Sharar, we will kill all other who seek to compromise the principles of our revolution,” it said.
ROME, Italy (UPI) — The information chief of the Palestine Liberation Organization was killed Friday by a bomb exploded under his bed in one of Rome's most luxurious hotels. Police said it was a highly professional assassination. Majed Abu Sharar, chief of the PLO's public relations department, died when the bomb went off shortly before 1 a.m. (7 p.m.
CDT Thursday) in his room on the fourth floor of the Flora hotel on Rome's tourist-famed Via Veneto. A PLO spokesman blamed Israel for the attack, calling Abu Sharar a victim of the “homicidal madness of Israeli terrorists.”
However, a hard-line Palestinian group in Beirut claimed responsibility for the assassination, saying it killed Abu Sharar because he had “diverged” from the radical line and had become too moderate. The bomb, placed beneath his bed, started a fire that burned Abu Sharar's corpse beyond recognition. Scores of tourists and other hotel guests fled their rooms in night clothes.
Firemen quickly extinguished the blaze. Police first theorized Abu Sharar may have been preparing the bomb for a terrorist attack and it had exploded prematurely. However, fire brigade experts said later they found evidence the bomb was rigged under Abu Sharar's bed. Abu Sharar was registered at the hotel as Abbas Zithouni, 47, an Algerian living in Beirut.
A spokesman for the PLO's Rome office conceded Zithouni was really Abu Sharar, the PLO's top information official and a member of the central committee of Al Fatah, the guerrilla group headed by Yasser Arafat. The spokesman said Sharar, in Rome for a conference of Arab journalists, carried the Algerian passport as a security precaution.
Al Assifa, a pro-Syrian guerrilla group, telephoned new agencies in Beirut and Rome to claim responsibility for the killing. “We have killed the traitor Majed Abu Sharar in Rome. He and his friends had diverged from the proper path of the Palestinian revolution and armed struggle. They represented the line of surrender,” the caller said.
Abu Sharar was born in what is now Israel. He was a father of three and was known as a moderate intellectual.
ROME (AP) — Medical examiners said Monday their autopsy showed a top Palestinian Liberation Organization official found dead after an explosion could have been murdered before the blast. The official, Majed Abu Sharar, was found dead in his Rome hotel room early Friday after the blast. Sharar was spokesman for the unified information center for PLO guerrilla factions.
Police sources had said that he might have blown himself up while working on an explosive device. But a report by the state-run Institute for Legal Medicine said Sharar’s body, which was completely burned, had large wounds in the back, indicating that the bomb exploded while he was lying on a bed.
It also said the medical examiners found evidence suggesting that Sharar could have been dead or at least unconscious when the bomb went off. They said metal fragments, which were not part of the bomb, were found in Sharar’s body. They also said his hands and toes were curled up as if his body did not react to the explosion.
The Italia news agency reported that some police investigators believe the PLO official was killed with a pistol before being put on the bed. Sharar’s body was flown to Beirut where a funeral was scheduled for Tuesday. At least seven PLO officials have been killed in Europe since the early 1970s, one other this year.
In June, Naim Khader, the PLO’s representative in Brussels, was killed by a lone gunman as he walked to his office. In August, Mohammed Daoud Odeh, also known as Abu Daoud, was shot in Warsaw but survived his wounds. The PLO has blamed the Israelis for the assassinations.
· The New York Times · page Front page; story continues “Continued on Page A13, Column 1”
ISRAELIS, IN SHIFT, REPORTED BACKING A WEST BANK PLAN
CARTER PROPOSAL REVIVED — Begin Is Said to Accept a 1980 Memo for Ending Impasse on Palestinian Self-Rule
By BERNARD GWERTZMAN
WASHINGTON, Oct. 13 — Prime Minister Menachem Begin of Israel has reportedly expressed readiness to accept the principles for Palestinian self-rule proposed a year ago by the Carter Administration. According to members of the American delegation at the funeral of Anwar el-Sadat, Mr. Begin made the comment to at least two people on Saturday in Cairo.
In one conversation, he was said to have exclaimed that the Israelis “would make Linowitz famous” next week by announcing acceptance of proposals made by Sol M. Linowitz, President Carter’s special envoy to the Middle East. New Talks Scheduled for Tel Aviv On Oct.
21, in Tel Aviv, the Israelis are scheduled to open a new round of talks with Egypt and the United States on Palestinian self-rule in the West Bank and Gaza. According to the American sources, Mr. Begin did not explain what he meant by “the Linowitz proposals.” Mr. Linowitz, who was also in Cairo for the Sadat funeral, said today, “It is not clear what he has in mind.”
A year ago, in an effort to bridge differences between Israel and Egypt, Mr. Linowitz submitted and then revised and resubmitted what became known as a “memorandum of understanding” on the principles of an accord. At that time, he said, the Israelis were unwilling to go along with some of its provisions.
Issues in Linowitz Memorandum The Linowitz memorandum dealt with these issues: ¶The question of water rights in the West Bank. The American plan contemplated equitable sharing, to be determined by a commission to be made up of Israeli, Palestinian, Jordanian and possibly Syrian members. ¶The issue of future settlements on the West Bank.
The American plan obliges the Israelis and the Palestinians not to establish any new settlements without the consent of the other party.
The issue of the enlarging of existing Israeli settlements would be left to an ultimate summit meeting of Israel, Egypt and the United States. ¶On security, the American plan calls for Israel to retain responsibility for protecting the Palestinian area against external attack and proposes that the Israeli police and a Palestinian force cooperate on internal security.
This issue, too, would require discussion in the proposed summit meeting. ¶As to the question of whether the self-governing Palestinian authority should be limited to “administrative” questions, as Israel contends, or should be permitted a “legislative” function, as Egypt desires, the American plan
BEIRUT, Lebanon, Oct. 15 (AP) — The Palestine Liberation Organization recalled its representative in Rome today. The move was said to be a protest against the Italian Government's handling of an investigation into the death of a high P.L.O. official, Abu Sharar, on Oct. 9.
“He had founded the most acclaimed writing program in the nation, the University of Iowa Writers Workshop. She had helped found the most influential journal among Chinese intellectuals outside mainland China, the Free China Fortnightly.
But it took a barbecue on the banks of the Iowa River for Paul Engle and Hualing Nieh to collaborate on an idea: to bring foreign writers from around the world, no matter what their political viewpoint might be, to the United States… Now, 14 years later, the International Writing Program has become a United Nations of sorts for writers.
Each autumn, writers from countries that otherwise don’t communicate with one another travel to Iowa to discover each other and America. Writers from South Africa and Nigeria, from China and Taiwan, from Israel and those from the land they call Palestine have met in Iowa City.‘I am here without a machine gun, but with a pen,’ Sahar Khalifeh, a Palestinian writer from Jerusalem told a gathering recently in Houston. She is participating in this fall’s four-month international workshop in Iowa, along with 33 writers from such countries as Poland, Hungary, Argentina, Indonesia and Japan. ‘The U.N. could not bring Israel and Palestine together.
The Writing Program has,’ says Khalifeh, who has seen some of her books banned in Israel. Since the program’s inception, cooperation among writers has been the Engles’ goal. ‘We insist that the program be non-political,’ Engle said recently while in Houston. ‘We don’t try to persuade them to change their minds.’
The non-political approach seems to have worked. Many Communist and Third World writers have participated in the Iowa program, including noted Polish writer Waclaw Sadkowski and the People’s Republic of China’s famed poet Ai Qing.
Among major countries, only the Soviet Union has not participated… ‘Writing is the least dramatic of all the arts,’ Engle said in explaining the difficulties in raising funds. ‘A writer sits at a desk, scratching, trying to get the right words. It’s not a fascinating sight. But after a symphony is over the music disappears into thin air.
Writing lasts for 1,000 years.’”
The archive’s third clipping of this novelist in three years: her fiction printed in Des Moines in 1979, this in Houston in 1981, and the Baltimore Sun in 1980 on her books being banned. The paper writes “the land they call Palestine,” and two paragraphs later she is a Palestinian writer from Jerusalem. This scan was labeled 1991; the masthead reads Monday, Oct. 26, 1981, and the date here follows the masthead.
But Only if Palestinians First Recognize Israel’s Right to Exist
BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — President Reagan said in an interview published Sunday the United States may eventually talk with the Palestine Liberation Organization but only if the PLO first recognizes Israel’s right to exist. “I think this is part of what’s at stake here,” Reagan said when asked if he would eventually approve talks with the PLO.
“I think Saudi Arabia could be an element in this.” Pressed if this meant bringing the PLO into the Middle East peace process, Reagan said, “Yes.” In a joint interview en route home from the funeral of Egyptian President Anwar Sadat, former Presidents Jimmy Carter and Gerald Ford both favored eventual U.S. talks with the PLO.
Later, former President Richard Nixon agreed with their assessment. Reagan qualified his remarks in the interview with the Independent News Alliance, published in the Lebanese newspaper An-Nahar, by restating U.S. policy that the Palestinians must first recognize Israel.
“I don’t like to talk just about the PLO because it is a selfdeclared voice of the Palestinian people,” Reagan said. “Whether it (the peace process) includes them (the PLO) or not, the Palestinian problem has to be solved but it can’t be solved until they are willing to acknowledge Israel’s right to exist.”
This condition has been rejected repeatedly by the Palestinians who insist Israel must first recognize their organization. In another interview, former U.S. Ambassador to Syria Talcott Seeley predicted that “by next summer the (Camp David peace) process will have pretty much come to an end.
“A year from now, maybe earlier, we will find the Reagan administration looking at a new framework.” Seeley told the Beirut weekly Monday Morning he “would not rule out the possibility that sometime during their tenure, the Reagan leadership might agree to such a dialogue” with the PLO.
Seeley was one of the State Department’s senior Arab experts before retiring Oct. 21. In Beirut, PLO chief Yasser Arafat held a meeting of his organization’s military council to discuss recent Israeli reconnaissance flights over Beirut, navy patrols along Lebanese shores and troop movements at the southern border.
The Palestinian news agency WAFA said the council regarded the Israeli actions as a prelude for a massive military operation against the Palestinians in Lebanon. The area has been relatively quiet since July 24 when U.S. Middle East envoy Philip Habib won a ceasefire involving Israel and the PLO.
Habib is scheduled to resume his mission to the Middle East next month with Israel still insisting that Syria remove missiles it has stationed Lebanon.
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Israeli Broadcasting Authority has ordered all state radio and television reporters to refer to the occupied West Bank by its biblical name, Judea and Samaria. The change was initiated Monday by nationalists on the government regulatory commission, who regard the West Bank as part of ancient Israel.
It coincides with an appeal by Jewish settlers in the West Bank town of Hebron who want the Supreme Court to ban the term West Bank in the state broadcasting media. Arabs object that, using the biblical name for the territory Israel captured from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast War, implies it is an integral part of the Jewish state.
Israel and Egypt are currently negotiating a form of autonomy for the 1.3 Palestinians on the West Bank of the Jordan River and the Gaza strip, and Egypt hopes the area eventually will become a Palestinian state.
By Arthur Max, Associated Press, Ramallah, Occupied West Bank
RAMALLAH, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Israeli soldiers patrolled this restive Palestinian town today in a show of strength that blocked a planned business strike. But in nearby Jerusalem most shops were shut. Troops in the streets of Ramallah carried truncheons and equipment to force open locks of shuttered shops.
When stores opened and life appeared normal, most troops withdrew. In Jerusalem, which unlike the West Bank of the Jordan River is under police jurisdiction rather than military occupation, shopkeepers responded to the call by West Bank unions to strike, and most Arab schools closed shortly after they opened.
“We are acting with the utmost restraint, both toward those who closed their stores and toward those who opened them and need our protection,” said Jerusalem Police Chief Rahamim Confort. “But we will act to nip any disorders whatsoever in the bud.”
No effort was made to force the shops to open, but two youths were arrested for unfurling a Palestinian flag in Arab Jerusalem… West Bank leaders reject the form of autonomy offered by Israel as a cover for continued occupation and say they want full Palestinian statehood.
Last night Israeli occupation authorities summoned the rector and board of governors of Bir Zeit College and warned them against permitting more anti-Israeli activity on campus… Bir Zeit spokesman Albert Aghzarian said: “Once again, this national Palestinian university has been singled out for collective punishment as part of a larger political scheme to deny the Palestinian peole its rights to self-determination.”… Israel Radio said Al Fajr, an Arab daily published in Jerusalem, was closed for 10 days for violating military censorship, and the editor of another daily, A-Shaab, was arrested.
Defense Minister Ariel Sharon told a news conference yesterday that Bir Zeit was closed because he could not allow a campus to shelter “people who stone cars or block roads.”
The dateline is Ramallah, Occupied West Bank, and the phrase Israeli occupation authorities is in the paper’s own sentence. Two youths arrested for unfurling a flag, two newspapers shut or their editors arrested, and Sharon’s reason printed last. “peole” is the paper’s.
JAFFA, Israel — The weathered houses still stand today, bizarre American frontier relics with wooden sidewalks and hitching posts, sagging like tired western movie props against the stone mansions that distinguish this ancient port city.
And to this day, the Arabs here still refer to the small quarter tucked behind one of Jaffa’s busiest streets as “America” — for the American pioneers who came here to live after the War Between the States. Even in 1866, the Christian colonists were not the first Americans to settle in the Holy Land.
Fifteen years earlier, another group of Americans established the very first U.S. colony abroad on a remote hilltop in what is now the heart of Tel Aviv.
Disease, drought, and murderous Bedouin raids wiped out the first colony in a Middle East version of the failure of Jamestown… It was a chapter fueled by a singularly American religious fervor that wrapped the Holy Land in an otherworldly mist — and that blindly ignored the reality of Palestine’s Malaria-infested swamps and scorching climate in the backwaters of the Ottoman Turkish Empire… The first group of about 100 colonists landed on the shores of Jaffa in 1851, led by Clorinda Minor, a Philadelphian and a member of the Christian Adventist sect, which prophesied doom and salvation through a new life in the Holy Land… Melville recorded a conversation with one of the colonists, a Mr Dixon who proudly boasted he was “permanently settled on the soil of Zion, sir” Melville then asked Dixon if he employed any Jews.
In retrospect, Dixon’s reply provides an ironic counterpoint to the Zionist movement that would establish the city of Tel Aviv 50 years later. “No. Can’t afford to have them,” Melville quotes Dixon as saying. “Do all my own work with my son. Besides, the Jews are lazy and don’t like to work.” On Jan.
11, 1858, the Bedouins attacked the colony, murdering Frederick Steinbeck, the great-uncle of John Steinbeck. The Arab marauders also raped the American author’s grandmother and his great aunt, and pillaged the colony. At the time, it was one of the worst attacks on Americans abroad in U.S. history.
“Horatio Vester, 80, who still runs the hotel, with his wife Val, in a recent photo.” Photo for the Tribune by Howard Simons
American colonies in Palestine thirty years before the first Zionist congress, told in 1981 as American history. The Arabs of Jaffa still call the quarter America.
Israeli Soldiers Shoot Palestinian Student in West Bank Melee
JERUSALEM, Nov. 12 — Israeli soldiers in the occupied West Bank shot and wounded a 15-year-old student in the leg today after he had brandished a knife, military sources reported. The incident occurred in the northern town of Jenin as Palestinian Arabs throughout the occupied area continued for a second week to burn tires and throw stones.
The West Bank residents were protesting Israel’s installation on Nov. 1 of a civilian administration to replace military jurisdiction in civil affairs and the closure on Nov. 4 of Bir Zeit University, the largest school in the West Bank and a center for pro-Palestine Liberation Organization sentiment.
In Jenin this morning, according to the army radio, some 300 demonstrators were dispersed at the Zahara High School after they had unfurled a Palestinian flag and threw rocks at Israeli border patrol guards. Military sources reported that soldiers rushed into the school in pursuit of demonstrators after asking special permission from the military government.
After firing several warning shots into the air, a soldier shot Mohammed Abdel Fatah Jarar behind the knee. Military sources said that the youth had brandished a knife, but Palestinians maintained that the youth was unarmed. Meanwhile, military authorities today informed Bir Zeit University that it would remain closed until Jan. 4.
It was ordered closed by Defense Minister Ariel Sharon on Nov. 4 after three days of student protests. Israel’s Supreme Court upheld the action last week. About 60 people were detained this morning at the headquarters of the International Committee of the Red Cross in East Jerusalem for protesting the closure, Palestinian sources reported.
Tear-gas pellets were thrown by Israeli soldiers at a crowd in the Dehaisha refugee camp near Bethlehem, as demonstrators burned tires in the roads and set up stone barricades against the troops.
GAZA — Israeli security forces broke an eight-day commercial strike by Arab shopkeepers here Thursday by welding shut doors to scores of businesses and threatening mass prosecutions.
Army patrols with two diesel-powered acetylene units moved slowly up and down Gaza’s main commercial street Thursday looking for the few remaining shops that had not already been welded closed.
Meanwhile, Arab merchants scurried to open their steel shutters to avoid either a forced closing for 50 days, or to avoid being charged with a security violation that could result in imprisonment of up to five years upon conviction.
The military government maintains that if merchants are allowed to close their businesses with impunity, disobedience of regulations forbidding strikes will spread to schools and other segments of the society, leading to chaos.
The confrontation began two weeks ago when Gaza physicians, veterinarians and pharmacists objected to the imposition of a 12 percent Israeli value-added tax, saying that it is illegal under the 1949 Geneva Convention for an occupying authority to impose new taxes.
Israel has maintained that the Geneva Convention governing occupied areas does not necessarily apply to the West Bank and Gaza because the status of the territories under Jordanian and Egyptian administration from 1948 to 1967 was never legally determined.
The Gaza strike began as a protest of the Israeli tax, but that issue quickly became secondary to general resistance to the installation on Nov. 1 of a new Israeli civilian administration of the military government.
Separation of civilian and military functions in Gaza and the West Bank is part of Israel’s plan to prepare the way for autonomy — a provision of the Camp David peace process rejected by many Palestinian leaders.
Israelis Drive Bedouins of Negev Into Closed Zones
By DAVID K. SHIPLER
WADI HAMMAN, Israel — It was very cold one recent morning in the Negev Desert. Inside the goat-hair tent of Swaylim Abu Bilaya, a Bedouin of the Azazmah tribe, a fire of twigs crackled at dawn, warming his three guests.
He had covered them with thick quilts for the night, and now he was making sweet tea in a blackened pot, his leathery face set off against his white kaffiyeh in the fire’s glow.
The three visitors were Mohammed el-Khishkhar, a princely Bedouin from a neighboring tribe; Clinton Bailey, an Israeli scholar who has spent a decade studying the Bedouins, and this correspondent. As the dawn came in delicate pastels over the desert, Mr. Khishkhar told long, engaging stories of his ancestors and their tribal wars. He was in no hurry.
He did not know that at that very moment, just a few miles away, Israelis were driving his family out of their tent into the cold, and his 2-month-old son was dying.
A New Danger for the Bedouins The seminomadic Bedouins, who have survived the cruel elements of the desert and the ravages of successive conquerors, now face a new danger, one that may mean the end of their centuries-old way of life. It has the innocent name of the “green patrol,” and it operates under the Israel Ministry of Agriculture.
The green patrol has launched a silent war of attrition against the Bedouins, swooping down on their encampments in jeeps, firing guns into the air to frighten children, shooting their herding dogs, ripping down their tents, trucking their flocks of goats away to slaughter and forcing the tribes off their ancestral lands into closed zones akin to Indian reservations.
The patrol was established in 1977 under the previous Labor Party Government, but it gained authority and manpower under the Likud Government’s first Agriculture Minister, Ariel Sharon, who is now Defense Minister. He has long been known for his tough approach to the Arabs.
The unit is supposed to enforce nature protection laws — it contends that the Bedouins’ goats are ruining the land by overgrazing — but Mr. Bailey sees this as a pretext for acting out the anti-Arab impulses of officialdom. There is no overgrazing, he maintains.
The Government simply wants to clear all Bedouins out of a great swath of the Negev Desert from Dimona to Eilat for vague security reasons — sinister suspicions that they might have ties with Saudi Arabia or Jordan. With Sinai scheduled to be returned to Egypt, the Negev is taking on new security importance.
The Israeli Army and Air Force are moving their Sinai bases into the Negev. ‘I See This as Unnecessary’ Mr. Bailey denounces the suspicions about the Bedouins as absurd, noting that many of them have served loyally with the Israeli Army. “I see this as unnecessary,” he said.
“If people serve with us, they definitely should be given a fair deal.” Israeli officials, who are usually ready to speak on any subject, refused to talk about the green patrol. The head of the patrol, Allon Galili, declined to answer questions when approached in a Beersheba courthouse.
The Agriculture Minister, Simcha Ehrlich, who is also Deputy Prime Minister, said through a spokesman that he had nothing to say to the press on that matter, and turned down a request for an interview. When the green patrol arrived on that cold dawn at Mr. Khishkar’s encampment, 2 women and 10 children were in the tent.
He had gone off the day before in search of two camels that had wandered away, spent the night in the tent of his distant neighbor and had no idea of his familiy’s plight. The Israelis drove them into the open, pulled down the tent and loaded them into three jeeps, allowing them to take only three blankets, his wife, Fathma, told the Israeli newspaper Haaretz.
She pleaded with them to allow her to leave her 2-month-old infant with another family because of the cold. They refused, she said. As they rode in the open jeeps, the baby’s nose and mouth began to bleed, she told the paper. Once inside a designated area, they were put out into the desert. The next night she found that the baby was not nursing.
She took him to a clinic in Beersheba, where an Israeli doctor pronounced him dead. The concept of due process is alien to this affair. The green patrol comes swiftly, according to Mr. Bailey and the Bedouins, often with a contingent of heavily armed Israeli troops or border policemen.
They herd the goats into trucks and take them to be slaughtered the same day, paying the Bedouins one-third of their market price, minus the costs of confiscation and trucking. It means disaster for the tribesmen, who often have nothing of value besides their goats. With Mr.
Bailey’s help, the Bedouins have gone to Israeli courts to obtain some injunctions against the slaughtering, pending resolution of the larger issue. In one hearing in Beersheba last week, five young, beefy members of the green patrol smirked and sneered at a row of Bedouin men sitting erect in court.
‘They Cannot Be the Government’ In all his years in the desert, even under the British mandate, Mr. Bilaya told his guests in the tent, he had never encountered anything like the green patrol. “First of all, they’re children,” he declared. “They’re young, not from the point of view of age, but from the point of view of behavior.
People who go around bothering other people aren’t men. That’s one reason they cannot be the Government. “Second, they’re stealing from people. They’re taking their flocks away. Third, they’re damaging relations between two peoples, the Bedouins and the Jews. They know this is our land, but they want to push us out into these settlements.
We can’t live in the settlements. We’ll die in the settlements. They scare our children away and shoot our dogs. You call that a Government? That can’t be a Government.” Of the Negev’s approximately 40,000 Bedouins, Mr. Bailey said, about 15,000 have been resettled in two large tracts of land near Beersheba.
Another 6,000 are to be removed from an area where a new Israeli air base is planned, and an additional 19,000 throughout the rest of the desert are to be resettled under the Government’s plan. “I was born here,” said Mr. Bilaya, who is 66 years old. “When the Turks were here, we were here. When the British were here, we were here.
When the Israelis came, we were here. Our fathers’ graves are here. The holy men whose tombs we visit on holidays or other times are here. “Where is my father?” he said, raising his voice in the dawn. “Here. Where is my grandfather? Here. Where is his father? Here. The old man tells the young man: ‘I have to visit the graves of my ancestors.
I have to know where they are. Here.’”
Mohammed el-Khishkhar visiting a fellow Bedouin at Wadi Hamman in the Negev Desert. During his absence, Israelis drove his family out of their tent.
Date check: the masthead reads THE NEW YORK TIMES, SATURDAY, DECEMBER 26, 1981 — matches date and pub. No page number is printed on the surviving strip.
Police Patrol Israeli Campus To Prevent Arab-Jewish Fight
TEL AVIV, Dec. 25 (AP) — Police patrols entered the campus of Jerusalem’s Hebrew University today to prevent a recurrence of fighting between Arab and Jewish students, a police spokesman said.
The university officials asked the police to back up regular campus security authorities, who were reported to be searching anyone who entered the Mount Scopus campus for hidden weapons.
Last weekend an Arab student and a Jewish student were injured in brawls that began after Jewish students broke into an Arab student’s room in the campus dormitories after the Arab refused to lower the volume of his radio. As many as 350 people were involved in one of the fights.
Tensions have been high at the university, which has about 500 Arabs among its 15,000 students. While Arabs and Jews usually do not room together, they do share dormitories.
Even Israelis protest West Bank university shutdown
A rare Arab-Jew agreement
By Munir Fasheh
“THE ISRAELI military government, on Nov. 4, ordered the closing, until Jan. 4, of Bir Zeit University, the main Palestinian university in the West Bank. The acting president, Dr.
Gabi Baramki, the entire administration and a number of faculty members and students, including all members of the student council, were placed under either house or town arrest, and others were imprisoned.
Later, some were freed… Closing Bir Zeit, the most influential and well-known of the five Palestinian universities in the West Bank, is equivalent to closing the top 20 percent of the universities in the United States, deporting their presidents, putting hundreds of administrators and faculty members under arrest and jailing thousands of students… In 1974, Bir Zeit was closed and its president, Dr.
Hanna Nasir, was deported. No educational institution in the West Bank, including elementary schools, has escaped closure at one time or another; some, like Abudis University, have been shut permanently.
Bir Zeit started in 1924 as a small private school, added its first freshman year in 1951, and by 1973 was a full four-year institution… About 40 percent of the 1,800 students currently enrolled are women… Bir Zeit students, who have grown up in the shadow of the occupation, do not live in an abstract world… In addition, because of the loss of most of their land, Palestinians have increasingly turned to education as their only hope for survival.
Any measure against Palestinian educational institutions threatens the existence of Palestinian society itself. The most serious measure so far has been Military Order 854 (July 6, 1980). One provision requires that every faculty member and student, before applying to any university in the West Bank or Gaza, must apply for a permit from the military government.
What a credential to require for an education!… On Nov. 7, for example, about 100 professors and students from Hebrew University marched in the West Bank to support Bir Zeit and protest Israeli treatment of the university.
In October, a Hebrew University committee asked that Order 854 be rescinded; it released a report that, with previous closures in mind, said that closing a university is an act of collective punishment… For Israeli Jews to stand firmly against the military occupation and its policies is, however, the beginning of a real basis for Jews and Arabs to live together in peace.
The main crime of Bir Zeit University is simply that it is Palestinian. For the Israeli government to demand that Bir Zeit not be Palestinian is like telling a bird not to fly.”
A Palestinian writing under his own name in an American daily in 1982, and the paper prints his credentials at the foot: he had taught mathematics at Bir Zeit since 1962 and was dean of students from 1979 to 1981. The pull-quote the paper chose is his complaint about Arab institutions, not about Israel: “But no head of an Arab academic institution has yet raised a voice for Bir Zeit’s academic freedom.”
Tel Aviv—Israel yesterday renewed its charges that Palestinian forces in Lebanon are violating the de facto cease-fire agreement that since last summer has been largely observed along the Israeli-Lebanese border. Maj. Gen.
Yehoshua Saguy, Israel’s chief of military intelligence, said in a press conference here that units of the Palestine Liberation Organization in Lebanon allegedly now have more than 500 pieces of artillery or mortars, a doubling of their firepower since July, when a two-week conflict with Israeli forces was waged.
General Saguy said that Israel believes, but has yet to confirm, that Palestinian forces now have several 180-mm. guns, the most powerful of artillery pieces, which can fire more than 25 miles, putting them within range of Haifa.
Questioned whether the reported buildup of Israeli forces along the border might similarly be considered as contrary to the de facto cease-fire agreement, General Saguy said there could be no comparison between “a sovereign state on one side and a terrorist state on the other side.”
General Saguy denied the widespread impression of journalists here that Israel’s charges of cease-fire violations are intended as pre-justification of the invasion of South Lebanon that Israeli officials have repeatedly threatened and which Moshe Arens, Israel’s ambassador to the United States, recently said was “only a matter of time.”
General Saguy charged that the Palestinian “terrorists” are repeatedly violating the cease-fire agreement reached last summer, which he said was limited to these three points: “1. There will be no hostile military activity from Lebanon directed at targets in Israel by land, sea and air. “2.
There will be no hostile military activity from Israel at targets in Lebanon, neither by sea, land or air. “3. The same will apply to hostile military activity directed into Major Haddad’s area [the pro-Israel enclave in south Lebanon] as well as from it.”
Though Israel has accused the PLO of violating the cease-fire through its arms buildup, infiltration attempts, terrorism elsewhere, and shelling of Maj. Saad Haddad’s Christian “Free Lebanon” enclave, Israel since last summer has not accused the PLO of having fired into Israel. General Saguy yesterday repeated an earlier contention that Philip C.
Habib, the U.S. special envoy to the Middle East, who is trying to head off a renewal of fighting, told Israeli officials he agreed with their view that Palestinian actions constituted “hostile activity.” Mr. Habib, who yesterday was in Damascus, has not commented publicly.
General Saguy said it is Israel’s view that Palestinian infiltration of Syria from Jordan constitutes a cease-fire violation in that the hostile activity originates and is directed from Lebanon.
He said that, while Palestinian terrorist attacks in Europe and elsewhere may appear not to be covered by the de facto cease-fire agreement, Israel’s Prime Minister Menachem Begin has made it clear the cease-fire “would not be used as a license to kill Jews all over the world.” In apparent reply to the U.S.
State Department, which recently removed Iraq from the list of countries accused of sponsoring terrorism, General Saguy cited the killings last year by several groups allegedly trained in Iraq. He charged that the Orion, a Greek passenger ship that last fall sank outside Haifa after an explosion, was the victim of a bomb set by a terrorist who left the ship in Athens.
General Saguy said that with $85 million in aid received from Arab states since July, the PLO has increased its medium-range guns from 50 to 90, its field artillery from 60 to 150, its truck-mounted rocket-launchers from 40 to 80, its tanks from 60 to 120, and has 2 37-meter-long armed boats given by Libya that now are in the Syrian port of Latakia.
Despite the alleged buildup of Palestinian forces, he contended, “We are not speaking about an army. We are speaking about terrorists.”
JERUSALEM, March 8 — The Israeli authorities involved in driving seminomadic Bedouins off their ancestral lands in the Negev desert appear to have weathered a controversy over the death of a Bedouin baby after an eviction on a cold morning in December.
Officials of the “green patrol,” a squad of tough young Israelis hired by the Agriculture Ministry to monitor land use, say that their policies and tactics remain unchanged in the wake of the incident, which brought condemnations from several Israeli politicians, local newspapers and a few representatives of American Jewish groups.
The officials have brushed off an autopsy report, made public late last month, showing that the two-month-old boy, who died about 22 hours after he and his family were ousted from their goat-hair tent into near-freezing temperatures, had suffered from pneumonia and a heart ailment. The autopsy, performed by Dr.
Bezalel Bloch, director of the Institute of Forensic Medicine, found “signs of interstitial pneumonia” and a “slight thickening of the endocard,” which is the inner muscle of the heart.
The report did not make clear whether the heart problem was the result of a congenital disorder or a bacterial infection, nor did it discuss the possible effect of exposure to cold on such illnesses. Dr. Bloch said he could not elaborate because he had been ordered by the police to say nothing.
‘Not Good for a Sick Infant’ But two leading Israeli physicians who read the report said that exposure to low temperatures could adversely affect an infant’s chances of surviving such problems. “When a two-month-old infant takes ill and is exposed to low temperatures without appropriate protection,” said Dr.
Shimon Moses, “the combination of the two factors, the illness and the cold, are liable to be to his detriment. From my experience with infants suffering from a known infection, they tend not to retain their body temperatures when they are exposed to the cold. It is not good for a sick infant to be in other than optimal conditions.” Dr.
Moses is head of pediatrics at the Soroka Medical Center and a professor in pediatrics at the Beersheba Medical School. Because the autopsy report calls the death “natural and not caused by any blows,” the Israeli authorities have decided to interpret the findings as absolving the green patrol from any responsiblity.
“The truth has been revealed; another blood libel against us has been ended,” the head of the patrol, Allon Galili, told the newspaper Davar.
Mohammed el-Khishkhar visiting a neighboring Bedouin camp at Wadi Hamman in the Negev desert. While he was away looking for lost camels, an Israeli patrol drove his family from their tent. Less than 24 hours later his two-month-old son died of pneumonia, according to an Israeli doctor.
Date check: No masthead or page date line survives on this clipping — it is trimmed to the headline. The internal dateline reads “JERUSALEM, March 8”, consistent with a March 9, 1982 paper, and the byline credit reads “Special to The New York Times”, consistent with `pub`; but the date itself could not be verified against a masthead.
“For all their apparent differences, Todd Piker, who is a country potter, and Samia Halaby, an abstract painter with a highly intellectual approach to her work, have far more in common than the fact that both are currently showing their art in SoHo galleries. Piker grew up, gently and with privilege, in an upper-middle-class Port Washington neighborhood.
Halaby was born in 1936 in Jerusalem, which, as a Palestinian, she and her family soon had to leave.
What they share in common is the indelible marks their childhoods made upon them… Piker is relaxed and ambitious and was willing to take the enormous risk of opening his own pottery eight years ago at the age of 21; Halaby is angry and vigilant, but her work probes for ideas that will make sense of her world… She is becoming more reckless and determined in her own life, too.
A year ago last May she received notice her contract would not be renewed as adjunct professor after nine years at the Yale School of Art.
And she is fighting it. ‘I never was an activist in the Palestinian cause,’ she said. ‘But there is a connection between my experience of having to leave my home and my dolls in Jerusalem in 1948 and my sensitivity to discrimination. At Yale I was a woman and a Palestinian and I spoke up.’”
The Yale non-renewal documented as it happened, inside an art review. The byline is printed “Amel Wallach”; the critic is Amei Wallach. The review pairs a Palestinian painter’s dispossession with a Connecticut potter’s comfortable childhood as two kinds of formative memory, and gives them equal billing. Photo credit: Newsday / Naomi Lasdon.
JERUSALEM, March 14 — Ory Bernstein, an Israeli poet and lawyer, urged his countrymen recently to do what in fact few of them do: face the reality of military rule in the occupied territories. They should stop averting their eyes, he said, from the way Israel deals with the Arab inhabitants of the West Bank and Gaza. Mr.
Bernstein made the point in an article about book-banning in the occupied territories. And he gave some extraordinary examples of books that at various times have been forbidden by the military authorities. Shakespeare’s “Merchant of Venice” in Arabic translation has been on the list. That can presumably be explained by the character of Shylock.
But it is a little hard to understand why the authorities should have prohibited Orwell’s “1984.” Even more mysterious is the banning of “The Soviet Union in the Middle East” by Walter Laqueur, a critic of Communism who has also written powerfully about the world’s failure to rescue Jews from the Holocaust.
JERUSALEM — Israel’s Cabinet rejected Prime Minister Menachem Begin’s offer to quit after a tie vote in Parliament on a no-confidence motion, spurred by the military crackdown on Palestinian rioters in occupied Arab territory.
The 58-58 vote yesterday in the 120-seat Knesset, Israel’s Parliament, had brought the government to the verge of collapse because Begin had threatened to resign if he did not get a clear vote of confidence. Four Knesset members were absent.
“The Cabinet has just decided to reject the prime minister’s proposal whereby he would have gone to the state president and tendered his resignation,” Cabinet Secretary Aryeh Naor said.
The decision came during another day of Palestinian rioting in the occupied West Bank of the Jordan River and Gaza Strip, territories seized by Israel in the 1967 Middle East war. Two more Palestinians were killed and eight wounded in fresh violence in the occupied territories today, raising the toll to four dead in six days of anti-Israeli protests.
The military also reported that Israeli troops captured three Palestinian guerrillas from Lebanon near Hanita, a border settlement six miles east of the Mediterranean. They were seized without a firefight, apparently on the Lebanese side of the border.
In Cairo, Osama el Baz, a top adviser to Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, asked Israel to exercise self-restraint in the West Bank to spur chances for a negotiated settlement of the Arab-Israeli conflict.
Yesterday, Israeli troops on the West Bank fired guns into the air, smashed padlocks on stores of striking shopkeepers and tear-gassed rioters who lobbed stones, blocked roads and burned tires. Four soldiers and four Palestinian youths were reported injured in those disturbances.
A curfew was imposed on the Gaza town of Rafah, where Palestinians rioted over charges an Israeli soldier raped a teen-age girl. The military strongly denied the accusations.
The unrest began after a West Bank Palestinian mayor was fired last week for refusing to cooperate with Israel’s new civilian administration in the area, which many Arabs regard as Israel’s step toward granting Palestinians only limited autonomy. Militant Palestinians want total independence.
The alliance of opposition parties that sponsored the no-confidence motion denounced the Cabinet’s 12-6 decision to reject Begin’s resignation. Moshe Shal, chairman of the Labor Party, the largest opposition bloc in Parliament, said the Cabinet’s action would just “stave off the inevitable end.”
The 68-year-old prime minister, re-elected to a second term last June, has enjoyed immense support in the Jewish state because of his militant stand against anti-Israeli Arabs and the Palestine Liberation Organization, an umbrella group of guerrilla factions fighting for an independent Palestinian state.
But his conservative government’s harsh treatment of militant Palestinians in the occupied territories has been increasingly criticized not only by Arabs but by moderate Israelis and by the United States, Israel’s main ally.
Begin is also criticized by extreme right-wing groups opposed to Israel’s scheduled April 25 pullout from the Sinai Desert, which is being returned to Egypt under terms of the 1979 Israeli-Egyptian peace treaty.
Although the no-confidence motion focused on government action in occupied territories, it also criticized the government’s handling of other issues ranging from foreign relations to the economy.
The main headline is whether an Israeli prime minister keeps his job. The deaths are the second line. The copy underneath carries the cause of the unrest in Rafah, which is an accusation of rape that the military denied, and the cause of the unrest in the West Bank, which is a mayor fired for not cooperating.
JERUSALEM — Three more Palestinians were killed in the West Bank and Gaza. In the West Bank, an Israeli army spokesman said, one Arab was fatally shot after he stabbed and wounded an Israeli border policeman, and a second Palestinian was killed by Jewish settlers whose car had been stoned.
The spokesman said the third Arab was killed in a demonstration in the Gaza town of Khan Yunis.
Sixty-three words in which three people are killed. The word in the headline is more, which is the whole finding: by March 1982 the deaths are a running quantity the paper expects its readers to be keeping. Nobody is named, and the only source for all three is an Israeli army spokesman.
JERUSALEM, March 29 — In an effort to dampen the unrest in the West Bank and to play down the political strength of the Palestine Liberation Organization, the Israeli military authorities have tightened their censorship of Jerusalem’s Arab newspapers and have prevented most of them from circulating outside the city.
During the last four days, taxicabs and trucks carrying copies of the papers for distribution on the West Bank have been intercepted before dawn at army checkpoints, and all copies have been confiscated.
On Friday, all three Arabic dailies, plus an English-language weekly, were seized; the three dailies were confiscated again Saturday and Sunday, an army spokesman said, and today two of the three — the pro-P.L.O. Al Fajr and Al Shaab — were barred from the West Bank, while only the more moderate Al Quds was allowed to pass.
As a result, the 800,000 Arabs in the West Bank, where widespread rioting has occurred during the last 10 days, have had to depend mostly on Israeli radio and television broadcasts in English and Arabic, and on overseas broadcasts by Jordan, Syria and the P.L.O. for news of events in their own territory.
Editors complain, and Israeli officials acknowledge, that the military censor has excised all reporting on the West Bank disorders by the Arab papers’ own staffs, forcing them to publish only material that had already appeared in the Hebrew-language Israeli press. Even a good deal of that information has been cut out of the Arabic-language papers, editors say.
“This is the worst for the last 15 years,” said Mahmoud abu-Zalaf, the editor in chief of Al Quds. “Last week we appeared for two days without a single line of news on the West Bank. And if we appear with only five percent of the news, they confiscate the paper.
They won’t even allow us to print the news covered by the Israeli radio and television — not even news printed from the Israeli papers.” The confiscations have also inflicted a financial cost on the papers. “It is almost worse than closing us,” said the editor of Al Fajr, Hanna Siniora.
“Ninety percent of our issue is stopped from being distributed, after we spend money on paper and ink, electricity, printing. We have to repeat the advertisements. The paper has been constantly losing money during this period.”
The government of Menachem Begin is suppressing academic freedom in universities in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, say two professors — one Israeli, one Palestinian — who are on a three-week tour of American cities.
Military order 854, passed by the Israeli parliament in July, 1980, gives the Israeli civil administration, which governs the occupied territories, full control over academic institutions within their jurisdiction.
JERUSALEM, March 29 — President Yitzhak Navon warned Israeli Arabs today not to participate in strikes and demonstrations in support of protests on the West Bank.
At the same time, leaders of the Bedouin and Druse communities, as well as 31 of the 54 Arab local councils in Israel, declared that they would not follow the call to strike Tuesday issued by an organization supporting Arab land rights and backed by other Israeli Arab groups, many of them Communists or under Communist influence.
Tension on the West Bank continued with scattered protest action. In the only reported act of violence, a member of the Kibbutz Gush Etzion, in occupied territory south of Jerusalem, was stoned while driving on the Jerusalem-Hebron road. Injured, he retaliated by opening fire, wounding one of his attackers. He was held for questioning.
The extent of the injuries to both was not made known. There were reports today that the call for a general strike Tuesday in northern Galilee would bring increased protest activities in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
The strike was called in commemoration of 1976 clashes between Israeli Arabs and security forces provoked by protests against Israeli expropriations of Arab-owned land. Six Arabs were killed, and the anniversary has been commemorated as “Land Day.”
This year’s commemoration, however, is intended by its organizers to embrace the West Bank protesters’ cause rather than being limited to the demands for land rates and fuller equality for the nearly 600,000 Israeli Arabs.
“In Arabe, near Nazareth, one Israeli policeman restrained another who was aiming at Arab youths who stoned their station. A general strike yesterday, called by Israeli Arabs to commemorate the deaths of six Arabs in 1976, was for the most part peaceful.”
A photograph of one Israeli policeman pulling another’s aim away, and a caption that explains what Land Day commemorates. Six years on, the paper still has to say who the six were.
The same day and the same event as the Star-Ledger (CP-1982-002), and the only difference is what the dead boy was doing. Here the troops fire into protesters, which says there was a protest and that it was fired into. The Star-Ledger called the same thing Arab unrest.
Both papers that carried this on 14 April 1982 name who fired. What they disagree about is what the event was. Here the killing and the seventeen wounded happen in Arab unrest — the last three words make the Arabs the setting the shooting took place in. The Bryan College Station Eagle the same day had the troops firing into protesters (CP-1982-001). The boy is not named in either headline.
JERUSALEM (UPI) — A Palestinian was killed in the occupied Gaza strip today as Moslem demonstrators burned tires and chanted in Jerusalem, protesting the Easter desecration of the Dome of the Rock mosque in Jerusalem.
The new demonstrations came as Israel asked for last minute assurances that Egypt will not violate the Camp David treaty by stepping over limits on military equipment and personnel in the Sinai, Israeli newspapers said today. Palestinian sources said four other Arabs were wounded by Israeli gunfire in the major West Bank town of Nablus following Moslem noonday prayers.
Clashes between Israeli troops and Palestinians, angered by the attack on the Islamic shrine in annexed Jerusalem, have left two dead and 27 wounded in the last five days. More than a 100 people on both sides were injured by rocks. There were hundreds of arrests.
PRIME MINISTER Menachem Begin made the request of Egypt as U.S. and Egyptian officials embarked on a flurry of diplomatic shuttles between Cairo and Jerusalem to ease Israeli concerns only nine days before its final withdrawal from the Sinai.
Israel also asked for guarantees that Egypt would never cooperate with the Palestine Liberation Organization or spread anti-Israeli propaganda in the area, the Yedioth Ahronoth and Ha’aretz newspapers reported. Begin asked U.S.
Assistant Secretary of State Walter Stoessel to make the promises, to be signed jointly by the United States, Egypt and Israel, an addendum to the peace treaty during talks Thursday, the newspaper Ha’aretz said. Officials said Stoessel planned to head for Egypt as Egyptian Foreign Affairs Minister Butros Ghali arrived with a message from President Hosni Mubarak to Begin.
STOESSEL MET Begin again today before going on to Cairo, said after two hours of talks with Begin Thursday he was “optimistic” Egyptian-Israeli differences could be resolved before the April 25 pullback. “I continue my mission with a sense of confidence that the existing problems can be resolved satisfactorily,” said Stoessel.
But a lightning trip to Cairo Thursday by Israeli Defense Minister Ariel Sharon for talks with Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak and Foreign Minister Kamal Hassan Ali failed to resolve the dispute. Sharon emerged solemn from two hours of meetings in Cairo and merely said “all problems” were discussed.
But back in Israel, Sharon told reporters he received assurances Egypt would rectify any infractions before the pullback. Ali expressed optimism, but told reporters “more discussions are needed” on the dispute over Taba, a 700-yard-wide area southwest of the Israeli port of Eilat where an Israeli tourist facility is being built.
ISRAEL ALSO has accused Egypt of violating the 1979 peace treaty by stationing extra troops in the Sinai demilitarized zone and failing to stop military supplies from reaching guerrillas in the occupied Gaza strip.
Israel’s state-run radio said an American inspection team will look Saturday into the alleged infractions and present its findings in time for the Israeli Cabinet meeting Sunday.
Nobody kills the Palestinian in the headline, and the death is the clause that introduces a story about the Sinai withdrawal. The copy names who wounded the four others in Nablus, on Palestinian sources, and gives the running toll of the week — two dead, 27 wounded, more than a hundred hurt by rocks on both sides, hundreds of arrests. The word for the shooting at the Dome of the Rock is desecration.
To the Editor: The Camp David accords are at a stalemate primarily because P.L.O. intimidation has prevented any Palestinians from participating in the autonomy talks.
In accordance with this reality, as well as pressure from nations which eagerly look forward to the demise of Camp David, Israel has embarked on an active policy on the West Bank to reduce P.L.O. coercion and allow for non-P.L.O. representatives of the Palestinians to step forward. Will the policy work? No one knows.
But it is an earnest attempt — indeed, the first attempt by any party — to take control away from the rejectionist and terrorist P.L.O. It is therefore particularly dismaying that Anthony Lewis has chosen to distort this Israeli effort to bring forth moderates by saying that “Israel is trying, by force, to bring a million Palestinians under its permanent control.”
(“Destroying the Dream,” April 1 column). There is no factual basis for that assertion. Can we possibly induce Mr. Lewis to use his journalistic energies to expose repeated P.L.O. assassinations of West Bank moderates and to advocate an approach to protect those who would negotiate peace with Israel? The simple reality, which Mr. Lewis ignores but which Mr.
Sadat recognized and which many in Israel have long recognized, is that the way for the Arabs in the West Bank and Gaza to gain the most for themselves is to sit down and negotiate under the terms of Camp David. Israel is trying one approach to encourage local participation in government. If those such as Mr.
Lewis are unhappy with it, let them find constructive ways to deal with P.L.O. intimidation — the obstacle to progress — instead of mounting irrelevant and inaccurate ideological attacks against the State of Israel. MAXWELL E.
GREENBERG National Chairman, Anti-Defamation League of B'nai B'rith Los Angeles, April 5, 1982 Occupation ‘Taxes’ To the Editor: As a future emigrant to Israel who has lived there for several years, I feel compelled to respond to Irwin Schermer's attack (letter April 2) on Anthony Lewis's views of the current situation in the occupied territories.
As an American Zionist, I have had the unique and fortunate experience of maintaining a friendship with a number of Palestinian refugees in the West Bank. Our relationship dates back to 1973, when they first welcomed me into [illegible] lives. Since then I have witness[illegible] firsthand the increased repression Mr. Lewis has accurately portrayed in column after column.
To claim, as Mr. Schermer does, that there may exist in the West Bank more personal and political freedom than in any Arab country in the Middle East is a pathetic, if accurate, statement. Has Israel fully abandoned its own democratic values and replaced them with the morality of its repressive neighbors? Contrary to Mr. Schermer's belief, Mr.
Lewis has accurately reported the extended detention without charges of West Bank residents. I know of numerous victims of this Israeli harassment, so widespread that the Palestinians I know refer to the treatment as “taxes” they must all endure under the occupation. We are all witnessing a callous, if not evil, display of subjugation. Maybe Messrs.
Begin, Sharon and Schermer have been visited by some divine spirit that has approved the current policies, for common sense is surely missing from their logic, unless, of course, the goal is total and permanent domination of the areas.
And how long will Jews of this country stand by in silence as our brethren in the homeland expropriate Palestinian land, censor newspapers, discard elected officials, imprison without due process and ignore the fact that the P.L.O. has captured the hearts and minds of the people?
In this season, which celebrates freedom, in our case from the ancient Egyptians, it is ironic how we have created a role for ourselves as masters. There are many of us who desperately care for the future of Israel, where we intend to continue the rebirth and to work toward a better society for all. We only pray that it's not too late. STEVE EINSTEIN New York, April 4, 1982
A 12-year-old pupil studying in the Gaza district before June 1967 undoubtedly would have encountered in his Egyptian junior high school textbook this sentence: “The Arabs will never cease striving for the destruction of Israel.”
His 10-year-old counterpart in the Golan Heights would have been expected to analyze the syntax of “We shall expel all Jews from the Arab countries” as part of an exercise in a Syrian fifth-grade text titled “Basic Syntax and Spelling.” A Jordanian textbook said that Israel’s God is “bloodthirsty. fickle-minded, harsh, greedy, and is pleased with imposture and deceit.”
The book was “General History — Ancient and Modern Civilization for High School Juniors.” An urgent tasks of the Israeli administration after the six-day war was, therefore, to ensure that such deliberate, malicious incitement originating from countries at war with Israel would no longer be propagated. Censorship is a common practice in countries in a state of war.
In the United States, the 1938 Foreign Agents Registration Act required the registration of foreign principals engaged in the dissemination of political propaganda. In 1939 and 1940, it became apparent that much Nazi propaganda was being sent to the United States. This propaganda was seized by the Post Office and destroyed.
Supervision of the importation of new books comes under the jurisdiction of Israel’s chief censor, who operates according to necessary criteria. For example, an Arabic-language book published abroad will be banned for distribution in Judea, Samaria, and the Gaza district in the following circumstances: 1. It endangers the security of Israel.
Thus, a book titled “The Military Encyclopedia” was banned because, among other things, it described how to assemble an explosive charge. 2. It is published by the Palestine Liberation Organization or expresses support for that organization and its activities. 3. It contains anti-Israel, anti-Zionist, or anti-Semitic propaganda. 4.
It is liable to lead to disturbances of the peace or to violence.
“Palestinian Diaspora Today, nearly four million Palestinians are in diaspora, six times the Palestinian population of Israel. They increase by nearly 3 percent a year, with one of the world’s highest birth rates.
CHATILA, Lebanon — In this squalid Palestinian refugee camp near Beirut, alongside underfed children and 15-year-old guards packing Kalashnikov weapons, 100 handsome horses keep trim for the races.
They belong to Faysal Abukhadra, sleek as his thoroughbreds, who carries three passports, runs a worldwide industrial complex and manages a personal fortune of tens of millions of dollars.
Abukhadra’s 1,000 relatives, scattered from Damascus to Denver, are as Palestinian as stubbly jowled guerrillas of popular stereotype and refugees who have spent 30 years in temporary camps. In 1948, the creation of Israel drove Arab Palestinians to exodus.
Afraid of the Zionists and encouraged by Arab leaders, many fled with what they could carry, expecting to return in days. In 1967, a second wave fled the West Bank, ahead of advancing Israeli troops. TODAY, NEARLY four million Palestinians are in diaspora, six times the Palestinian population of Israel.
They increase by nearly 3 percent a year, with one of the world’s highest birth rates. About 1.3 million are in the West Bank and Gaza, and as many are in Jordan. Most others live in Arab states. In Kuwait, they make up a quarter of the population.
In the United States, at least 100,000 Palestinians assemble cars in Detroit, run grocery stores in San Francisco and head university departments on the East Coast. They are the most literate of Arabs, with the most university degrees, upwardly mobile in business, law, medicine, science and education. Abukhadra estimates at least 2,000 are millionaires.
At the same time, 650,000 live in overflowing refugee camps, on U.N. rations, many with keys to long-since demolished houses in Israel tucked carefully among meager belongings. ‘People don’t really know who we are,’ says Ibrahim Souse, a musician who represents the Palestine Liberation Organization in Paris.
‘But that’s changing, at a remarkable rate.’ Last Christmas Eve, Souse appeared on a French television program and talked about everything but politics. In an interview later, he said: THE ISRAELI ambassador complained, but who can say anything against a Christian Palestinian, playing piano and recalling memories of Bethlehem?
Scholars say few historic ties bind Arab Palestinians into a people. They lived scattered for four centuries in what was a province of the Turkish empire and then a territory mandated to Britain. Until 1948, Arabs and Jews alike were ‘Palestinians.’ Israel’s prime minister, Levi Eshkol, said in 1969: ‘What are Palestinians?
When I came here there were…’”
“A Palestinian child sits on a garbage-strewn sidewalk in Chatila refugee camp near Beirut, Lebanon.” Associated Press. And, under a portrait: “FAYSAL ABUKHADRA, Palestinian multimillionaire.”
Datelined Chatila, five months before the massacre there. The dispatch carries the sentence this archive spent a long time proving from headlines: Until 1948, Arabs and Jews alike were ‘Palestinians.’ It also carries the keys — 650,000 people on United Nations rations, many with keys to long-since demolished houses in Israel tucked carefully among meager belongings — and it lets a Palestinian say what the piece is about: People don’t really know who we are. Two Palestinians are named, one a millionaire and one a musician, and neither is a guerrilla, which the copy says out loud.
“A few Israelis were swept by deepening grief and worry. Some demonstrated at one of the new Jewish settlements inaugurated on the West Bank. Others wrote anguished letters to newspapers.”
A week in which the death toll among Arab demonstrators mounted, reported through the conscience of the occupier. The Palestinian dead are the subordinate clause; the Israeli grief is the subject of the headline.
JERUSALEM, May 4 — An 18-year-old Palestinian student was shot dead today and another teen-ager was wounded as Israeli troops clashed with demonstrators in the occupied Gaza Strip.
An army spokesman said the incident occurred after an army patrol passing Al Awda girls’ school in Khan Yunis spotted 10 masked men in the schoolyard pressing students to go into the street and demonstrate. The patrol entered the schoolyard, the spokesman said, arrested two of the men and ordered the students to disperse.
The students poured into the street and began throwing stones, cinder blocks, chairs and tables at the four soldiers, according to the army’s account. Shots were fired into the air, then into the crowd. Two students were hit, one 18 and one 16. The 18-year-old, identified by Palestinian sources as Ihsan Abu Daraz, was hit in the chest, the army spokesman said.
Palestinians said the bullet entered her back. Her death brought to 14 the number of Arabs killed by Israeli gunfire since severe demonstrations erupted in the occupied territories in mid-March. Palestinian journalists who interviewed demonstrators said the army’s contention that 10 masked men were inciting protests was not true.
The three major United States commercial television networks have come into conflict with the Israeli Government over what network news executives charge is “political censorship” of their reports on the war in Lebanon.
The networks charged that this week the Israelis began to censor certain film segments — primarily depicting Lebanese casualties — because such sequences are politically embarrassing. Israeli officials said that these reports constituted enemy propaganda that Israel has no obligation to help transmit to the United States.
“Every country normally has military censorship in wartime,” said Ze’ev Chafets, director of the Government press office. “No other country has been asked to put its communications at the disposal of the enemy. Israel has been bending over backward to help, but the networks have brought in things that were clearly psychological warfare.
When we didn’t permit them, they self-righteously attacked us for political censorship.” Network officials expressed dismay over the dispute and acknowledged that Israel had been better than most nations at war in accommodating foreign correspondence.
Said Reuven Frank, president of NBC News, expressing a commonly held view: “Until this week we had more access from Israel than anywhere else. Our people in Damascus can’t get stories at all, and likewise from the Palestine Liberation Organization. The British imposed what amounted to a total blackout in the Falklands.
But this is a new experience with the Israelis that amounts to a shock.” Traditional Censorship Military censorship in the Middle East, as in other war zones, customarily has focused on matters of strategic sensitivity, such as the identity of equipment and personnel or disclosure of military tactics that could violate national security.
The trouble began this week after the Syrians closed the satellite transmission facility in Beirut used by news broadcasters. On Monday, the Israeli military censor banned the transmission of an ABC News interview with Yasir Arafat, the leader of the P.L.O., that had been filmed in Beirut and transported to Tel Aviv for satellite transmission to the United States.
ABC defied the order and transmitted the interview, which appeared on “World News Tonight.” In retaliation, Israel suspended ABC’s satellite-transmission privileges from Tel Aviv, and ABC charged that Israel had committed “an intolerable act of political censorship.”
After three days of discussions, a letter of apology from ABC’s acting Tel Aviv bureau chief, Scott Willis, and a telegram from George Watson, vice president of ABC News in New York, pledging that the network would abide by Israeli censorship guidelines, Israel restored the network’s satellite transmission last night.
At CBS, two reports have been subjected to censorship to which the network has objected. Wednesday, Allen Pizzey, a contract reporter for CBS in Beirut, filed a one-minute 45-second story about civilian casualties in Beirut.
In the middle of its appearance on “The CBS Evening News With Dan Rather,” an announcement stated “22 seconds deleted by Israeli censors” as the screen stayed black for four seconds.
Another three-minute report the same day by Dan Kladstrup, a correspondent, about the effect of the war on the P.L.O., said Van Gordon Sauter, president of CBS News, was “stopped cold” by Israeli military censors. The offending segments in Mr. Pizzey’s report, according to Mr. Sauter, dealt with “the shortage of medical care and the absence of medical technicians.”
Although CBS has filed no formal protest, the CBS bureau chief in Tel Aviv, Charles Wolfson, said Mr. Sauter, has “expressed our displeasure at the removal of materials we perceive to be political, not military.” At the same time, said Mr.
Sauter, “we are not unaware that the Israelis are conducting a war and that we have asked to use their facility to convey material which in their minds may be detrimental to their effective conduct of not only a military action but a far broader information action.”
The same evening a story for the “NBC Nightly News” about refugees by Jack Reynolds was blocked by Israeli censors, and two sequences showing wounded children were dropped from a story by Steve Mallory, according to Paul Greenberg, executive producer of the program. NBC plans no protest, said Mr. Frank, because “we can do a lot more good by mentioning it on the air.”
Indeed, Tom Brokaw, the anchor, not only described the censorship on the air, but John Chancellor also chided Israel the following night for using censorship increasingly “to protect Israel’s image and to serve its political goals.” Israeli officials deny any political motivations. “We don’t ask to censor material gathered in Beirut provided it is sent from Beirut,” said Mr.
Chafets. “If they want to send through us they have to abide by our ground rules. We are in a state of war with the P.L.O.” Mr. Chafets declined to say whether Israel was considering barring completely the transmission of material gathered in Lebanon: “The American networks are large and powerful and ingenious. They can probably find other ways of getting material out.”
Network officials said they were doing just that, although such measures are often more costly and difficult than using the Tel Aviv facilities. Said Mr. Chafets, “We feel we have been badly used in this situation, and we hope it is understandable.”
THE ISRAELIS, ever the opportunists in diplomacy and war, could not have timed their blitz against Palestinian forces in southern Lebanon any better.
The government of Prime Minister Menachem Begin ordered the invasion at a time when the Arab world was preoccupied with the Iraqi-Iranian war and the specter of Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini spreading his fundamentalist Moslem revolution throughout the Persian Gulf region.
At the same time, the leaders of the industrialized West were tending to economic matters at the Versailles summit in Paris.
The Israelis, in calculating the risks of launching their offensive against the military strongholds of the Palestinian Liberation Organization, undoubtedly considered which nations might come to the PLO’s rescue and concluded that few, if any, would. Twenty months of war with Iran have left Iraq militarily exhausted and humiliated.
The Iraqi regime of President Saddam Hussein is facing the external threat of an Iranian invasion and the internal threat of a bloody coup. Hussein is in no position to help out the PLO. THE LEADERS of Saudi Arabia and the other Persian Gulf states, meanwhile, are trembling in fear of a renascent Iran. The PLO’s present plight is of secondary concern to them.
Having propped up the war-weakened Iraqi economy with more than $20 billion in aid, they now fear that Khomeini may stir up the discontent of Shiite Moslems in their midst. Khomeini has long talked of exporting his Shiite Islamic revolution to Sunni-dominated states. Of the Arab nations, Egypt may be the No.
1 military power, but despite strains in its relationship with Israel, it is not about to give up on the Camp David peace process. President Hosni Mubarak already has said he will not send troops to Lebanon. That leaves Syria, the nation most closely aligned with the PLO.
Israeli soliders guard a large number of suspected members of the Palestine Liberation Organization.
Date check: The section flag reads “World” with “D” at the right and, beneath it, “Asbury Park Press / Fri., June 11, 1982” — matches both `date` and `pub`. Standing refers at the left read “Religion 2 / Classified 4”.
PALESTINIAN GUERRILLA leaders in devastated Beirut, outgunned and trapped, are daring Israeli forces to hunt them down, but Israel says it will not push its 10-day-old invasion of Lebanon into the capital. “I think this is Lebanon’s problem, not ours,” Israeli Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Raphael Eytan said yesterday.
He spoke to reporters in Tel Aviv after Israeli tanks, warplanes and gunships sealed off every exit from Beirut, ruling out escape for embattled chieftains of the Palestine Liberation Organization.
Israeli Defense Minister Ariel Sharon, speaking to Israel Television after touring his forces camped outside Beirut, said Israel has no intention of establishing Lebanon’s new government.
But he said Israel’s nine-day-old invasion has given the Lebanese a chance to expel guerrilla and Syrian forces, and install a strong central authority in the war-shattered Middle East nation. Sporadic gunfire subsided at dusk around the PLO’s 10-square-mile zone on Beirut’s southern flank.
But earlier, guerrillas raced through streets on half-tracks bristling with anti-aircraft guns to set up new defense positions. They issued communiques vowing they will never surrender, although Israel blocks the city from the south and west and virtually controls the international airport and vital Beirut-Damascus Highway following days of repeated bombings and shellings.
Israeli-backed Lebanese Christian militias, who also oppose the PLO, control escape routes to the north and east of Beirut. An estimated 100,000 Palestinians have been trapped in the capital, many of them refugees who fled north as Israeli tanks overran southern Lebanese cities and Palestinian strongholds.
“There is no power on earth that can force us to lay down our arms,” PLO leader Yasser Arafat told guerrillas on a tour of west Beirut, the Palestinian news agency WAFA said. Its report apparently also was meant to dispel rumors Arafat had fled to safety in Syria. Dr.
George Habash, commander of the PLO’s militant wing, said if the Israelis stormed guerrilla-held positions his fighters would transform Beirut into a “new Stalingrad,” the Soviet city where tens of thousands of residents routed Nazi invaders during World War II.
PLO leader Yasser Arafat (left) and associate Hani al Hasaan confer in Beirut, according to PLO. Photo was distributed yesterday by Palestinian news agency.
JERUSALEM — The 6,000 Palestinians that Israel has captured in Lebanon are being treated humanely, but have not been given the legal status of POWs.
Israeli officials say that armed men of the Palestine Liberation Organization taken prisoner since Israel invaded Lebanon June 6 are being held as “administrative detainees” who may have to face trial and long prison sentences, though this has yet to be finally decided.
The status Israel has given the Palestinian prisoners contrasts with that of the 60 Syrian soldiers taken captive by Israel's invading army and who are regarded in all aspects as prisoners of war.
Palestinian captives have not been granted prisoner-of-war status because they were not serving in the army of a recognized state, especially one — such as Israel, Syria and most other countries — that is a signatory to the 1949 Geneva Convention relative to the treatment of prisoners of war.
Israel's position appears to be in violation of the Geneva Convention, Article 2, which declares: “although one of the powers in conflict may not be a party to the present convention, the powers who are parties thereto shall remain bound by it in their mutual relations.
They shall furthermore be bound by the Convention in relation to the said power, if the latter accepts and applies the provisions thereof.” The PLO, not being a state, is not a signatory to the Geneva Convention.
However, it has said that it is treating Israeli prisoners according to the internationally recognized rules, something Israeli officials Wednesday said they hope is true.
Israeli courts always have rejected the pleas of Palestinian infiltrators or others caught carrying out violent acts within Israel or its occupied territories that they had the right to be treated as prisoners of war, not as “terrorists.”
However, Israel never before has been faced with having so many Palestinian captives — caught not while trying to attack Israel, but while trying to defend their bases and refugee camps in Lebanon. Israel is torn by different concerns. On the one hand, it hardly wishes promptly to release thousands of PLO members who could soon be ready to fight Israel again.
On the other hand, Israel is keenly sensitive to the fate of about 10 Israeli soldiers who have been taken prisoner in Lebanon by the PLO or Syria, realizing that if the Palestinian captives are not given all the protection of prisoner-of-war status, neither are the Israeli POWs likely to be.
There is an added complication for Israel in how it legally defines the Palestinian prisoners since the national policy is to refer to all armed Palestinians as “terrorists.”
Thus Israelis would label as a “terrorist” both a Palestinian who plants a bomb that explodes and kills innocent people, and a Palestinian who was drafted into a local militia in Lebanon but never fired a shot at anyone until captured last week.
The Geneva Convention that Israel has agreed to says that prisoners of war include: “Members of the armed forces of a party to the conflict as well as members of militias or volunteer corps forming part of such forces” or members of “organized resistance forces belonging to a party to the conflict and operating in or outside their own territory.”
The Geneva Convention goes on to say that members of resistance groups who should be treated as POWs are those: • “Commanded by a person responsible for his subordinates;” • Who have “a fixed distinctive sign recognizable at a distance;” • Who carry “arms openly,” and • Who conduct “their operations in accordance with the laws and customs of war.”
Israel apparently contends that, as a terrorist organization, the PLO does not meet the last criteria, and perhaps, as a guerrilla force, not the second one. However, the PLO units are organized in military fashion, with their own flag, and members carry arms openly.
Israeli military sources said that part of the Palestinian prisoners are in Israel and part in Lebanon, living in enclosed shelters where they are being fed and receiving medical care, as well as being questioned and classified. The Palestinian prisoners reportedly include hundreds of minors, some as young as 11.
The number of PLO prisoners must be putting a strain on the military police, since they outnumber all the Palestinians being held in Israel's jails for domestic offenses by 2 to 1. The captives include a number of non-Palestinians, including men from Bangladesh, Ceylon and Arab countries who allegedly fought with the PLO.
Blindfolded and handcuffed, Palestinian prisoners sit on a road in northern Israel waiting to leave for prison camps. Some of the Palestinians are imprisoned in Israel, and others are being held in Lebanon.
The headline says handled humanely. The story reports that Israel's position appears to be in violation of the Geneva Convention and that the prisoners include hundreds of minors, some as young as 11.
TEL AVIV, June 22 — Israel suspended ABC News satellite transmissions from here today after the network used an Israeli ground station to send an interview with Yasir Arafat, the leader of the Palestine Liberation Organization, that had been filmed in Beirut. The network was accused of having defied Israeli military censorship.
The Israelis granted requests by foreign networks to transmit film from Lebanon through the satellite service here after the ground station in Beirut became unuseable a few days ago. Zeev Chafets, director of the Government Press Office, said the networks had agreed to abide by Israeli censorship rules.
He said ABC had submitted the Arafat interview for censorship but it had been banned. An appeal was lodged with the chief military censor and it was rejected. The network then went ahead and transmitted it, he said. ABC News accused Israel last night of “an intolerable act of political censorship.”
It called on Israeli officials to restore the network’s access to the satellite transmission station in Tel Aviv. The ban, a network official said, poses “a grave inconvenience and a serious interference with our ability to report the news.”
In a statement prepared for broadcast last night on “World News Tonight” — the same program that broadcast the Arafat interview Monday night — ABC News said it had “strongly protested” the cutoff in a series of meetings with Israeli diplomats in Washington.
It said the Arafat interview “in no way compromised Israeli military security — the stated reason for Government censorship.”
All dispatches filed by correspondents from Israel on the Israeli invasion of southern Lebanon are subject to censorship by the military authorities. Last Sunday, the Israelis extended military censorship to accounts issued by the United Nations on the fighting.
Foreign reporters were barred from transmitting parts of statements issued by Timur Goksel, the spokesman of the United Nations peacekeeping force in Naqura, Lebanon. Israeli military censors have also reviewed photographs filed from the the invasion zone.
On Sunday, several photographers were detained by military authorities while they were taking pictures of Israeli troops crossing the border into Lebanon. One picture filed by United Press International depicting a file of tanks crossing a bridge was retouched by military censors before it was filed.
Elana Levy, Ron Shuffler, Gary Weinstein, Daniel Hakim, Carole Resnick, Allen Miller, Andy Mager, Ingrid Fischman, Laura Wilansky, Sandee Resnick and Deborah Weissman, Syracuse
“We are outraged as human beings — and feel a pressing responsibility to publicize our outrage as Jews — at the genocidal war which Israel is presently waging against the Palestinian, Lebanese and other Arab peoples.
Estimates at the number of Lebanese and Palestinians, mainly civilians, killed in the last couple of weeks range from ten to fifteen thousand, with close to a million newly created refugees. Is this Israel’s Final Solution to the Palestine Question: Genocide?
As citizens of the United States we demand that our government immediately end all military and technological assistance to the Israeli government. Without U.S. military aid the Israeli government could not have waged this brutal attack, inflicted with U.S.-made fighter planes.
We support Mideast negotiations which recognize the right of self-determination for all the parties involved, including the legal representative of the Palestinian peoples, the Palestine Liberation Organization. We ask all peace-loving people to express their outrage at the brutal attacks waged by the Israeli government.
With great sadness that this letter needed writing, we sign ourselves: Jews Against Genocide.”
Eleven named American Jews in Syracuse during the invasion of Lebanon. The paper set the headline, and set it bare. Three other letters run on the same page, one of them headed “Lebanon for Lebanese” and one by a Presbyterian minister headed “Road to Peace?”
JERUSALEM, June 28 — Israeli military censorship applies to foreign newspaper and wire service dispatches transmitted from Israel during both war and peacetime on military and security issues. Under the rules, which are based on British emergency regulations from 1948, articles on these matters are to be submitted to the censor before they are sent abroad.
Correspondents thus are expected to exercise their own judgment, though those who attempt to send such stories without prior clearance sometimes find that midway through transmission, the censor cuts their telex lines. Accounts written by reporters in southern Lebanon behind Israeli military lines and brought back to Israel for transmission fall under the rules.
Reports about politics or the economy need not be submitted to censorship, though articles dealing with oil supplies to Israel do. Restrictions during wartime are somewhat stiffer for the Israeli press than for the foreign press.
Israeli news censors waging all-out war on the truth
Ron Alridge
BULLETS AND BOMBS aren't the only obstacles network news departments are encountering as they cover Israel's invasion of Lebanon. The American television networks also are contending with severe government censorship by the supposedly democratic government of Israel. Apparently, some of the censorship is imposed for political rather than military reasons.
Not a single network story, not a single piece of video tape, can be transmitted out of the Israeli-run satellite transmission facility without first being screened by an Israeli military censor. Even scripts are reviewed. Furthermore, an Israeli official must have been present when the story was gathered.
With war-ravaged Lebanon's transmission center closed and with other facilities difficult to reach, the American networks desperately need to use the Israeli satellite equipment. Without a green light from an Israeli censor, the networks not only can't use that equipment, they can't even ship their stories out of Israel by other means, such as airplanes.
THE CENSORSHIP IS not enforced at gunpoint, but any network that bucks the system can have big problems. ABC already has run into trouble. In late June, ABC taped an interview with Yasser Arafat, head of the Palestine Liberation Organization and an enemy thoroughly despised by Israel. An Israeli censor looked at the story and told ABC not to transmit it.
No explanation was given at the time, but the Israeli censor obviously imposed the blackout to keep Arafat's views off of American television.
The ABC interview involved no troop movements, new weapons or other military secrets that Israel's censorship supposedly is designed to protect. [Israel has since explained to ABC that, when it comes to censorship, there are no real differences between political and military considerations; that the two are too closely related to separate.] ABC still was fuming when NBC managed to get its own Arafat interview past an Israeli censor and onto a satellite.
At that, ABC angrily and defiantly beamed its story back to America without Israeli permission. The network was subsequently denied use of the Israeli transmission equipment for two days. “IT WAS A CLEAR and transparent effort to impose political censorship,” says a still-fuming George Watson, vice president for news at ABC.
“It's really a nightmare,” Jeremy Lamprecht, director of foreign news for NBC, says of the censorship in general. “It's capricious and arbitrary.” “It can vary from censor to censor,” says Ed Joyce, executive vice president of CBS News, “because it's all going through the filter of an individual human mind who is the censor and who has the power to be totally arbitrary.”
Israel also has censored reports of civilian casualties in Lebanon, though not in recent days. That censorship, too, apparently was motivated more by politics than military security. After all, killing innocent people seldom wins votes in the campaign for international support.
Standing column mugshot of the columnist, captioned “Ron Alridge / TV-radio critic”.
Israel maintained a near total blockade of food shipments today in an attempt to starve out PLO-controlled west Beirut and Israeli artillery pounded Palestinian neighborhoods in southern sections of the Lebanese capital. Soviet President Leonid Brezhnev sent a message to President Reagan warning him not to send U.S. troops to Lebanon.
“If this in fact takes place, the Soviet Union will construct its policy in accordance with this fact,” he said. With Navy ships only two hours from the Lebanese coast, the United States Wednesday renewed its offer to escort the estimated 6,000 Palestine Liberation Organization guerrillas from Beirut.
Peace talks appeared bogged down as the Palestinians again insisted Israel pull back to allow a PLO withdrawal to its refugee camps. Israeli Foreign Ministry Director Gen. David Kimche, in Beirut to confer with U.S. envoy Philip Habib, refused.
Kimche told Habib that Israel rejected any proposal that would allow any PLO presence, political or military, in Lebanon and will not agree to an interim pullback of its army.
At a news conference, Deputy Israeli Chief of Staff Moshe Levy said the army is making preparations to spend the winter in Lebanon, though not with the current number or deployment of troops, Israel Radio said. In Jerusalem, Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin stressed Israel has set “no deadline, no ultimatum” on U.S. mediation efforts.
Reports had said Israel wanted the PLO forces out of Beirut by Sunday. Begin met Sens. Christopher Dodd, D.-Conn., a member of the Foreign Relations Committee, and Carl Levin, D-Mich. “The prime minister is very optimistic about a peaceful resolution of the situation,” Dodd told reporters.
Levin stressed that Begin's statement did not “imply it (negotiation) was endless ... that it can go on forever.”
War is grown-up business — but it has a heart-wrenching impact on the usually placid world of children.
In Lebanon, the fighting bruises and maims innocent youngsters; it sends them into the streets, emulating the adults in mock war games; and it makes them pause to wonder what the next moment holds. [Associated Press] | Israeli children examine a Palestinian guerrilla recoilless rifle captured by Israeli troops in Lebanon.
The rifle and other captured arms are on display in Tel Aviv. [Associated Press]
RASHIDIYEH, Lebanon (AP) — Between 5,000 and 7,000 Palestinian women, children and old men have drifted back to this former refugee camp and PLO guerrilla base to live in the rubble left by Israeli forces that drove them out more than three weeks ago.
Only a half-dozen young men could be seen on the streets and among the ruined houses where the women and children sat quietly. The only bustle is at a former school where the International Red Cross is distributing food and blankets, the refugees’ sole aid apart from UNICEF water trucks that come in to refill cisterns.
The homeless here are among tens of thousands — estimates vary widely — that have been driven from place to place in southern Lebanon by the Israeli-Palestinian war. Some said they came back to Rashidiyeh because the Lebanese blamed the Palestinians for the Israeli invasion and didn’t want them to stay in their towns. The director of the U.S.
Agency for International Development, Peter McPherson, toured the area Thursday and said the job of caring for the refugees was only beginning. “The destruction is much more than (estimates) we got from outside sources,” McPherson said, adding that his agency’s relief money would be aimed at “helping the people help themselves.”
Many of those returning here were among the 3,000-4,000 who lived in a nearby orange grove for two weeks after the Israelis invaded Lebanon on June 6 and drove out the Palestine Liberation Organization guerrillas based in Rashidiyeh, who had been a thorn in Israel’s side. The camp is only 10 miles north of the Israeli frontier.
The Israeli military denied the refugees aid. Army officers said they were trying to force the Palestinians to leave. An old man, dressed in a kaftan and wearing glasses with one shattered lens, said he and his family fled to Tyre during the Israeli attack, but their Lebanese neighbors’ resentment had forced them to leave.
“They didn’t want Palestinans there because of the bombing,” he said. Joe Jacobs of AID said the Palestinian-Lebanese friction made relief work more difficult. “The lowest on the totem pole are the (refugee) Palestinians,” he said.
“We tried to distribute some food to Palestinian women and children in Tyre, and the Lebanese in the street were very angry. The resentment is strong.”
Palestinian women and children stand in line Thursday as Red Cross workers distribute food and blankets in the former refugee camp of Rashidiyeh, which was destroyed during the Israeli invasion. About 7,000 Palestinians have moved back into the ruins of the village, where 24,000 once lived.
Date check: No masthead or page date line survives — the clipping is trimmed to the headline block, the photograph and caption, and five text columns. Nothing on it names the paper or the date, so 1982-07-09 and “The Jackson Sun” could not be verified. The internal timing (“drove them out more than three weeks ago”, an invasion dated June 6, a McPherson tour “Thursday”) is consistent with early July 1982.
Palestinians Tried to Avert War and Are Now Being Victimized
“Approximately two million actually live under Israeli military rule in occupied West Bank, Gaza and Galilee. Israel is denying them their inalienable rights to self-determination and independence. The Palestinians are not Syrians or Jordanians. They are from Palestine.”
A reader answers a Times editorial point by point, beginning with First: and including Galilee in the list of occupied places. Written in the summer of the Lebanon invasion, two months before Sabra and Shatila.
WASHINGTON — King Hussein of Jordan yesterday rejected declarations by Israeli Defense Minister Ariel Sharon that Jordan is a Palestinian state and should become the permanent homeland of the Palestinian people.
Hussein, interviewed on ABC’s “This Week,” said Palestinian territory must include land now occupied by Israel in the West Bank, Jerusalem and Gaza.
Hussein, who said that he does not rule out the possibility that the West Bank could be a separate Palestinian state apart from Jordan, said his country has given the Palestinians a temporary home “awaiting resolution of their problem on their legitimate soil.”
Sharon, on a three-day tour of the United States, repeatedly has said that Israel would never agree to a Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza. He also has stressed that he believed 75% of what is now Jordan was once Palestine, making Jordan the proper Palestinian homeland.
He reiterated that view yesterday in appearances on both CBS’ “Face the Nation” and the ABC program. “The majority of the Palestinians are living in Jordan,” Sharon said on CBS. “Jordan, as a matter of fact, is a Palestinian state. So we are not planning to establish a Palestinian state.
There is a Palestinian state.”… More than 700 U.S. and Canadian Jewish leaders applauded his remarks at the Washington Hilton… Bethlehem Mayor Elias Freij and Rashi Shawa, ex-mayor of Gaza, said on NBC’s “Meet the Press” that Israeli talks with Palestinians in occupied territories are an illusion.
They added that Palestinians talking with the Israelis are “actually nobody whatsoever — they are collaborators with Israeli authorities.” Freij, who said he was barred by the Israeli government from traveling to the United States for the TV appearance, said that it is an open secret that the United States collaborated with Israel in its invasion of Lebanon.
“I am blaming the United States for what befell the Arab women and children and civilian people in Lebanon,” Freij said.
Two Palestinian mayors on Meet the Press, one of them barred from flying to the studio, printed beside Sharon saying Jordan already is Palestine.
The following dispatch has been altered by Israeli military censorship.
By JAMES F. CLARITY
JERUSALEM, Aug. 10 [original dateline changed by censor] — The three Palestine Liberation Organization prisoners were handcuffed and wore cloth bags over their heads as they were led by an Israeli officer through the grounds of the military prison [18 words deleted here by censor] in northern Israel.
The three were captured in the first weeks of the Israeli invasion of Lebanon and the Israelis refer to them as “terrorists,” a term Israeli officials use for all people they regard as part of the Palestinian guerrilla group. But aside from that, and their headcovers and manacles, the prisoners had little in common.
They had joined the guerrilla organization under different circumstances. Each described a different role in the organization. The invasion of Lebanon meant something different to each of them. And each has a different hope for the future. They are among the 7,400 prisoners the Israelis say they have captured since the invasion began June 6. They are kept in cells.
Israeli Jets Continue to Hit Palestinian Areas of Beirut
Israelis in Lebanon: Military Pressure Is… [section rule, rest of line outside the crop]
By JOHN KIFNER
BEIRUT, Lebanon, Aug. 10 — Israeli jets again attacked Palestinian-held areas on the fringe of the city today as the Palestinian guerrillas made preparations to leave Lebanon, apparently under the terms negotiated by the special United States envoy, Philip C. Habib.
Page A12 of the same issue as CP-1982-058 (slide 60), whose page-one story '3 Captives Tell Of Their Lives With the P.L.O.' continues on A12. This is the facing article on that continuation page; it was missed when slide 61 was paired.
Geoffrey Godsell, Christian Science Monitor Service
“Some analysis and the Begin government’s actions in Lebanon as only first steps toward a wider goal.
All current evidence indicates that the men running Israel are outmaneuvering the United States in purposefully implementing their blueprint for a greater Israel in the Middle East… The Begin government has clearly spelled out — specifically or by implication — some of the main features of its blueprint for greater Israel.
The operations in Lebanon are merely the first step. The overall features include: Destruction of both the military and political power of the hard core of the Palestine Liberation Organization in Lebanon.
Annexation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip — or Judea and Samaria, as the Israelis call them — so there can be no question of a Palestinian state alongside Israel on the West Bank of the Jordan… Yuval Ne’eman, leader of the Tehiya Party with a seat in Begin’s Cabinet, spelled it out in the Aug.
1 Observer: ‘This war is in two parts: One is what is happening up there in Lebanon, and the other is to create a situation in which there would be practically nowhere, no place left, to create a Palestinian state other than in Jordan — where there is one already.’… Israel might conceivably act as midwife for a partition of Lebanon between Syria and Israel.
In that case, the southern part of Lebanon might become an Israeli puppet Christian state, possibly under the presidency of right-wing Christian Phalangist leader Bashir Gemayel.”
A cabinet minister saying in print that one aim of the Lebanon war is to leave nowhere for a Palestinian state to be. The page it runs on is otherwise a lumberyard advertisement: Gross Lumber Company Hot Summer Specials, a grinning sun, and fencing clearance at $13.25.
“EDITOR: I HAVE a better caption for your photo of the Palestinian child (Aug. 6). It reads like this: If this boy’s father and all his father’s friends did not move into southern Lebanon and rained shells onto Israeli settlements in the Galilee year after year, this boy’s picture would not be in our paper. —David Jacobson, Camp Hill”
A reader rewriting a photograph caption. The archive’s subject is what American papers printed about Palestinians, and here a reader is arguing with a caption in the paper’s own letters column, seventeen days after it ran. He does not dispute the photograph. He disputes the sentence under it.
WASHINGTON — A small dam of words burst last Sunday and the wave that washed over the Arab-Israeli dispute rinsed a large rock that lies in the path of peace. Careful words from a king and crafty words from a Palestine Liberation Organization operative revealed deep Arab disagreement even about what the word “Palestine” designates.
On ABC’s “This Week With David Brinkley” Bassam Abu Shareef of the PLO said “an” aim of the PLO is establishment of a state on “part of” — on “any” part of — Palestine. A state on the West Bank and Gaza would be “satisfactory.”
Question: “Does this mean that (the PLO) can accept the simultaneous existence of Israel as a Jewish state?” Shareef: “This is the PLO program. It was very clear, and although many people decided not to read it carefully because they don’t want to read it carefully, we now read it to you carefully.” Oh? What “PLO program”?
Not the Palestine National Charter adopted in 1968, the first point of which is that Palestine is an “indivisible” part of the Arab world, and the second point of which is: “Palestine, with the borders it had during the British Mandate, is an indivisible territorial unit.”…
Dishonesty revealed: Shareef’s statement, another example of PLO “moderation” for American media, refers to the PLO’s 10-point program adopted in 1974. It held that “any” liberation of Palestine is but a step toward the destruction of Israel (point four) and — note well — the overthrow of the Jordanian regime (point five).
When Shareef was asked if the PLO’s argument about title to the West Bank is not “as much with Jordan as it is with Israel,” he said: “Well, who told you that we differentiate greatly between Begin and Hussein?” There, suddenly, the mask of moderation slipped, the dishonesty was revealed. Shareef was immediately followed on ABC by Hussein.
He was asked about recent statements by Israel’s foreign and defense ministers (Shamir and Sharon) that Jordan is a Palestinian state. Before considering his answer, consider this: The first modern use of the word “Palestine” to designate a specific territory was for the territory mandated to British when the Ottoman empire collapsed in 1918.
The League of Nations’ mandate designated land on both sides of the Jordan River — all that is now Israel and Jordan — as Palestine. Later, Britain separated Transjordan (now Jordan), restricting the name “Palestine” to the West Bank and what is now Israel.
But remember what Hussein never forgets: the PLO charter endorsed the original, inclusive definition of Palestine.
Responding to Israeli statements that Jordan is Palestinian, ethnically (65-70 percent) and geographically, Hussein said, obliquely: Jordan has given “a chance to feel at home” to “Palestinians awaiting a resolution of their problem, on their legitimate soil.” By “Palestinian soil,” he means everything west of the Jordan River…
“Legitimate rights”: For 19 years (1948-67) Jordan controlled the West Bank that Hussein now calls “Palestinian soil,” but made no move to offer it up to what Hussein now calls “legitimate Palestinian Arab rights.” On ABC Hussein called it “inaccurate” to say Jordan annexed the West Bank after the 1948 war.
He said, “It was an Arab effort to save what could be saved of Palestine” after the 1948 war. But no Arab nation supported Jordan’s annexation. The United States never recognized it. Only two nations — Britain and Pakistan — did… Hussein’s subtlety, even artistry, was on view Sunday.
In September, 1970, his army killed many times more PLO members than Sharon’s army killed in Lebanon. Last Sunday, when an ABC correspondent said “the Palestinians” were expelled from Jordan in 1970, Hussein deftly, almost unnoticeably rejected the equation of the PLO and “the Palestinians.” He simply said: “Not many left Jordan in 1970.
A very few did so....” That is true. Most Palestinians are still there, in Palestine.
A cartoon runs below the column, unrelated: a figure with a milkshake in each hand, captioned “A BALANCED DIET IS NOT A MILKSHAKE IN EACH HAND!” Signed Milton Davis.
A syndicated columnist arguing over what the word Palestine designates, and ending on the sentence that most Palestinians are still in Palestine. A PLO spokesman is quoted at length from American television.
Correction: {'note': 'arrived captioned Press & Sun-Bulletin 1945; the page’s own "Today in history" box reads Thursday, Sept. 2, 1982'}
WASHINGTON — A small dam of words burst last Sunday and the wave that washed over the Arab-Israeli dispute rinsed a large rock that lies in the path of peace. Careful words from a king and crafty words from a Palestine Liberation Organization operative revealed deep Arab disagreement even about what the word “Palestine” designates.
On ABC’s “This Week with David Brinkley” Bassam Abu Shareef of the PLO said “an” aim of the PLO is establishment of a state on “part of” — on “any” part of — Palestine. A state on the West Bank and Gaza would be “satisfactory.”
Question: “Does this mean that (the PLO) can accept the simultaneous existence of Israel as a Jewish state?” Shareef: “This is the PLO program.
It was very clear, and although many people decided not to read it carefully because they don’t want to read it carefully, we now read it to you carefully.”… When Shareef was asked if the PLO’s argument about title to the West Bank is not “as much with Jordan as it is with Israel,” he said: “Well, who told you that we differentiate greatly between Begin and Hussein?”
There, suddenly, the mask of moderation slipped, the dishonesty was revealed… The first modern use of the word “Palestine” to designate a specific territory was for the territory mandated to British when the Ottoman empire collapsed in 1918.
The League of Nations’ mandate designated land on both sides of the Jordan River — all that is now Israel and Jordan — as Palestine. Later, Britain separated Transjordan (now Jordan), restricting the name “Palestine” to the West Bank and what is now Israel.
But remember what Hussein never forgets: the PLO charter endorsed the original, inclusive definition of Palestine… On Monday, the Reagan administration declared that Jordan is not a Palestinian state. But on Sept. 3, 1980, Ronald Reagan said: “Israel and Jordan are the two Palestinian states envisioned and authorized by the United Nations.
Jordan is now recognized as sovereign in some 80 percent of the old territory of Palestine.”… Most Palestinians are still there, in Palestine.
The third printing of the same George Will column of 2 September 1982 in this archive, under a third headline. The masthead is not on this clipping, so the paper is unidentified.
Correction: {'note': 'arrived captioned Elmira Star-Gazette 1948; it is the same syndicated column of 2 September 1982'}
WASHINGTON — A small dam of words burst last Sunday and the wave that washed over the Arab-Israeli dispute rinsed a large rock that lies in the path of peace.
Careful words from a king and crafty words from a Palestine Liberation Organization operative revealed deep Arab disagreement even about what the word “Palestine” designates… The first modern use of the word “Palestine” to designate a specific territory was for the territory mandated to Britain when the Ottoman empire collapsed in 1918.
The League of Nations’ mandate designated land on both sides of the Jordan River — all that is now Israel and Jordan — as Palestine. Later, Britain separated Transjordan (now Jordan), restricting the name “Palestine” to the West Bank and what is now Israel.
But remember what Hussein never forgets: the PLO charter endorsed the original, inclusive definition of Palestine… For 19 years (1948-67) Jordan controlled the West Bank that Hussein now calls “Palestinian soil,” but made no move to offer it up to what Hussein now calls “legitimate Palestinian Arab rights.”… Hussein’s subtlety, even artistry, was on view Sunday.
In September 1970, his army killed many times more PLO members than Sharon’s army killed in Lebanon. Last Sunday, when an ABC correspondent said “the Palestinians” were expelled from Jordan in 1970, Hussein deftly, almost unnoticeably rejected the equation of the PLO and “the Palestinians.” He simply said: “Not many left Jordan in 1970.
A very few did so. . . .” That is true. Most Palestinians are still there, in Palestine.
A cartoon runs above the column: two soldiers marked MARINES standing in the bottom of a deep spiral pit, captioned “All quiet on the Mid-East front.”
The same George Will column of 2 September 1982 appears three times in this archive under three different headlines. Below it on this page, an unrelated editorial on space warfare reprinted from the Wheeling, W.Va., News-Register.
WASHINGTON — Administration officials said Thursday that they had received cautiously worded positive reactions from Arab nations — including Jordan, Saudi Arabia and Egypt — to President Reagan’s Middle East proposals before his speech Wednesday. “We didn’t go into this in the blind,” a key administration official said.
“We didn’t have a clear green light, but we did have an amber light.” King Hussein of Jordan, on being approached by American diplomats last week with a private version of Reagan’s plan, indicated his willingness to go along with it if he was given a mandate by other Arab leaders, but he made no commitment.
Administration officials say that the ground was thus prepared for the president’s speech Wednesday night, that they do have a strategy and that at least some of the parties consider the plan to be workable.
ADMINISTRATION officials also acknowledged that they had a plan so ambitious that a lot could go wrong: the Israelis feeling they had been betrayed and becoming totally intransigent; moderate Arab leaders fearing to support Washington and split from the radicals; Reagan’s possibly losing interest and, finally, getting tied down once again in negotiating the all-important details.
In his speech, Reagan said publicly what presidents and senior American officials have been saying in private meetings and planning papers for 15 years: that the Israelis would have to give up all or most of the territory they captured in the 1967 war, and that the Palestinians should have “full autonomy” in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip “in association with Jordan.”
But for administration after administration there was never a right time for a president to say it out loud. There were always worries about the “Jewish vote” and worries that an overall approach would not work with the Israelis, that the Israelis had to be dealt with more gingerly, more indirectly, step by step.
Officials always pointed out how the one venture in this direction, the comprehensive plan offered in 1969 by Secretary of State William P. Rogers, had backfired politically and diplomatically.
THERE IS MUCH of the same anxiety now on the part of many administration officials that the whole thing might come apart, that Thursday’s rejection of the plan by the Israeli Cabinet might be followed by Arab leaders who had indicated support getting cold feet, and that the United States could remain alone as a lightning rod for all criticism.
Has Ronald Reagan joined Israel's Labor Party? His current peace proposal for the Middle East bears a striking similarity to the one that Israel put forth in 1967 just after the Six Day War, when Labor was in power and the talk in Jerusalem was about trading land for peace and defensible borders. Reagan's new plan is neither new nor a plan.
It's a loose collection of old ideas. The president would have Israel trade Gaza and much of the West Bank for peace with Jordan, which would have to grant the Arabs there local self-rule. Reagan would also widen Israel's borders to assure her security.
About the only difference between the map he draws and the old Allon Plan, named for a late Israeli foreign minister, is that it doesn't include a small strip of fortified Israeli settlements along the Jordan River. That buffer would separate the West Bank from Jordan or, more exactly, Trans-Jordan.
But Reagan left the door open even for that possibility when he spoke of negotiating final borders. The president did not make it clear in his speech that this new semistate would be demilitarized, but perhaps that is understood. If so, this assemblage of vague suggestions could be the Allon Plan translated into laid-back Californian.
The reception accorded the president's sketchy proposal indicates how much has changed since 1967, and how much has not. Israel's kneejerk critics who denounced Golda Meir and her colleagues as “intransigent” when they put forth the Allon Plan now can be expected to describe it as quite reasonable when presented by an American president.
While the Israeli leaders — a whole different crew from those of a decade ago — now have turned down the president's proposals just as they did the Allon Plan when they were in the opposition.
JERUSALEM, Sept. 15 — Israeli security officials have closed down a Palestinian press service here at a time of heavy Israeli censorship of the Arab press. Since Israel’s invasion of Lebanon, Arab editors have complained that Israeli censorship has virtually forced them to fill their papers by translating Hebrew reports and commentaries from the Israeli press.
In recent weeks, however, the Arab press has been barred from publishing many of these features even though they have already appeared in Israeli papers, according to the Arab editors. “The war has made the Israeli censors very sensitive,” said Radwan Abu Ayash, a commentator for the left-wing daily Al Shaab.
He said his paper had been prohibited from publishing articles that had appeared in the Hebrew dailies Haaretz and Al Hamishmar. The Jerusalem Office for Translations and Newspaper Services, which was ordered closed Tuesday for six months, furnished many of the Hebrew articles in translation used by the Arab press since the invasion.
The press service, which began operations only a week before the outbreak of the conflict in Lebanon, said it would try to get a court order to reopen operations. “It will ruin us to close us for six months,” said Saman Khoury, head of the service.
The Israeli authorities ordered the press service closed under emergency regulations dating from the days of British rule in Palestine. The order said the press service was being closed “for the sake of public safety and order.” There were no arrests.
Reporters from Al Shaab and Al Fajr said that at the height of Israeli invasion of Lebanon almost no local news from the West Bank was allowed in Palestinian papers. The reporters said, however, that with the winding down of the fighting and the withdrawal of the Palestine Liberation Organization from Beirut Israeli censors had relaxed their standards somewhat.
Out of 37 articles submitted for last week’s English digest version of Al Fajr, 15 were banned, 3 were censored so heavily that they could not be printed, 6 were partly altered, 1 was “returned for revision” and 12 were approved as written, according to the reporters.
Several Palestinian journalists said they understood the reason for the heightened sensitivity of the Israeli censors during the fighting in Lebanon. “We know in advance that we’re living under extraordinary circumstances,” Mr. Abu Ayash said.
But the Al Shaab commentator and other Arab journalists accused Israel of discrimination in permitting Hebrew papers to publish reports barred from the Arab press. “They allow Yediot Ahronot and Haaretz to publish local news about the West Bank, but at the same time they don’t allow us,” Mr. Abu Ayash said.
He conceded that part of the reason was that “we write the news with a different slant,” which the Israeli authorities contend could lead to “incitement.” Despite Israeli miitary rule and censorship, Mr. Abu Ayash said, “there is democracy in allowing us to have papers, and we know that the Israelis are occupiers and we don’t expect more.” “Occupation is occupation,” he added.
“Even if an Arab country came and occupied us we would protest its occupation and censorship.”
Hundreds of Palestinians killed in Beirut refugee camp
By United Press International
“Hundreds of men, women and children were massacred in two Palestinian refugee camps in west Beirut within 36 hours, apparently by right-wing Lebanese militiamen, reporters who toured the scene said today. Bodies lay piled in groups of ten or more scattered through the ruins of the camp, which until recently housed tens of thousands of civilians.
Reporters said it was impossible to get a close estimate of the total number of Palestinians killed because the bodies were strewn across several acres of wreckage. It appeared the final toll might be well over 1,000. SOME OF THE MEN who were killed were lined up in front of a wall before they were gunned down, the reporters said.
Bulldozers had been used to pile wreckage on many of the bodies in an attempt to conceal them, but arms and legs were sticking out of the rubble, the reporters said.
Israeli soldiers guarding a hill overlooking the Chatila camp, where the most grisly mass executions took place, said Lebanese soldiers from the rightwing Phalange Party were in charge of the camp when the killing of the Palestinians began. OTHER REPORTS SAID members of the militia loyal to Maj.
Saad Haddad, a former Lebanese Army officer who has been supported by Israel, were in the area Friday. The camps had been under the control of the regular Lebanese army until the Israeli advance on West Beirut three days ago. Phalangist troops had blocked off the main entrance to the camps Friday and barred all reporters. People in the area said they heard shots being fired.
MOST OF THE Israelis guarding the vantage point overlooking the camps with two tanks and three armored personnel carriers said they saw nothing and heard nothing. One tank crewman told a UPI reporter, however, that heavy shooting broke out Friday night when the Phalangists moved through the camps, which is a densely populated neighborhood of crude cement block buildings.”
The word massacre across the top of the page in the largest type the paper had, and underneath it the deck says who was killed. The copy names the Phalange, names Saad Haddad’s militia and its Israeli support, and places Israeli soldiers with two tanks and three armoured personnel carriers on a hill overlooking the camp, most of whom said they saw nothing and heard nothing. One tank crewman told the news agency otherwise.
EDITOR’S NOTE — Associated Press photographer William Foley spent two hours Saturday in the Sabra camp, scene of a massacre witnesses said was carried out by Christian militiamen. His report is detailed on this page. SABRA REFUGEE CAMP, Lebanon (AP) — Bodies littered the streets of the Sabra refugee camp. Residents told of a massacre by Christian militiamen.
The stench of death filled the air. Survivors were not certain just who carried out the massacre. Some said the killers used the word “phalangist” and were members of the Lebanese Forces Christian militia once… we came back to the entrance and there was no one to stop our entry.
We drove down the main road, with piles of rubble and garbage on both sides of the street. We stopped the car about 400 yards into the camp and got out to look around on… saying in Arabic, “Please come inside. Please see our dead.”
They said Christian militiamen had used bulldozers to cover the bodies of some of the people massacred in the camp… A man on a bicycle passed the corpses, goggled-eyed at the sight. Looking closely at piles of garbage and rubble, I noticed pieces of human bodies sticking out from the rubble — legs, arms, pieces of limbs.
I talked briefly with a young man who said he was Lebanese and told me the Christian militiamen were “all crazy.” He claimed he saw some of the killing… …pses. They appeared to have been shot in the head. We walked into another alley where nine bodies were under and around a truck in an area that appeared to be a workshop.
At the Gaza Hospital, a 76-year-old man was afraid he would not be allowed to leave the camp unless he seemed disabled. “What will happen to me? I have internal bleeding, but I don’t appear to be severely injured,” he asked a doctor, who proceeded to bandage up his arm and leg so he could get into the ambulance for a ride into the heart of west…
A first-person account from inside Sabra, written by the Associated Press photographer who walked into it, and printed in a Texas daily the morning after. The paper gave it a whole page and flagged it with an editor’s note. What the reporter records is not a summary: a man on a bicycle staring, limbs in the rubble, nine bodies around a truck in a workshop, and a 76-year-old man at the Gaza Hospital asking a doctor to bandage him more heavily than his injuries warranted so he would be allowed to leave. The survivors themselves are uncertain who did it, and the report says so in its second paragraph.
· The Atlanta Journal and Constitution · Atlanta · page 1
‘A hellish sight . . . like Jonestown’
“DEATH IN BEIRUT: Lebanese man cycles through Palestinian camp at Sabra, in west Beirut, as bodies lie in street.” The Associated Press
Page 16-A of the Sunday paper: one photograph across the page, its caption, and a headline set larger than the caption. The story it introduces is not on this clipping. The same Associated Press photograph ran in The Morning Call the same day.
Lebanese civilian cycles through Palestinian camp at Sabra, passing two of hundreds of corpses
“Lebanese civilian cycles through Palestinian camp at Sabra yesterday, passing two of hundreds of corpses.”
“Lebanese civilian cycles through Palestinian camp at Sabra yesterday, passing two of hundreds of corpses.” Associated Press
The same Associated Press photograph that the Atlanta Journal and Constitution ran the same morning under a different caption. This one counts them: two of hundreds.
Sunday 19 September 1982. The verb is massacred, in the top line, with nobody attached to it. The people are Arab refugees, which is what they had been since 1948. The Abilene Reporter-News the same morning put the same camp on page 12-A as an eyewitness piece about a smell and a sound (CP-1982-008). This is the same Associated Press dispatch that the Abilene Reporter-News ran that morning under Sabra Camp Eyewitness: Stench of Death, Screams of Women (CP-1982-008) — William Foley’s first-person account of walking into the camp. Springfield led on the verb massacred; Abilene led on the witness.
BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — Hundreds of Palestinian civilians were massacred in two refugee camps on the outskirts of Beirut, apparently by Lebanese Christian militiamen given control of the camps by Israeli occupation forces, reporters at the scene said Saturday.
Three United Press International reporters saw bullet-torn bodies piled in groups of ten or more scattered through the Sabra and Chatila camps. The rampage apparently began Friday.
Reporters who tried to get into the camps early that day discovered the Israelis had turned them over to the militia of the Phalangists, the Israeli-allied Lebanese Christian group that has repeatedly threatened the Palestinians.
With Israeli soldiers manning a hill less than a quarter mile away from the Chatila camp, the Phalangists apparently rounded up and killed everyone they could find. At the United Nations, Palestine Liberation Organization representative Zehdi Labib Terzi claimed that as many as 1,500 civilians had been killed.
He was still attending a U.N. session late Saturday and unavailable for further comment. The U.N. Security Council, after two hours of private consultations, convened an urgent meeting Saturday night to consider sending troops back into west Beirut to prevent further bloodshed.
Arab nations planned to ask that 5,000 U.N. troops in south Lebanon, members of the earlier peacekeeping force, be sent in to protect civilians and that the Council’s five permanent members then send additional forces, according to Jordan’s ambassador, Hazem Nuseibeh. Earlier, U.N.
Secretary General Javier Perez de Cuellar agreed with an urgent appeal from the United States, France and Italy to send additional U.N. observers to west Beirut.
BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — Hundreds of Palestinian civilians were massacred in two refugee camps on the outskirts of Beirut, apparently by Lebanese Christian militiamen given control of the camps by Israeli occupation forces, reporters at the scene said Saturday.
Three United Press International reporters saw bullet-torn bodies piled in groups of ten or more scattered through the ruins of the Sabra and Chatila camps. The rampage apparently began Friday.
Reporters who tried to get into the camps early that day discovered the Israelis had turned them over to the militia of the Phalangists, the Israeli-allied Lebanese Christian group that has repeatedly threatened the Palestinians.
While Israeli soldiers manned positions on a hill less than a quarter mile away from the Chatila camp, the Phalangists apparently rounded up and killed everyone they could find.
Each of three UPI correspondents who were at the two camps — Jack Redden, Walter Wisniewski and Vincent Schodolski — said they were certain there were hundreds of bodies, probably totalling well over 1,000. Schodolski, UPI’s Beirut bureau chief, who toured sections of the Sabra camp, said he counted 60 bodies in an area 100 yards square.
A Scandinavian reporter said he saw front-end loaders carting away dozens of bodies to unknown locations. In Jerusalem, a senior Israeli official said the Lebanese army has agreed to move into the Chatila, Sabra and Fakahani Palestinian refugee camps on the outskirts of west Beirut at 10 a.m. Sunday morning. (2 a.m. EDT).
The massacre of the Palestinians in the two camps spurred negotiations that had been scheduled between the Lebanese and Israeli army officers, the official said. He also said the Israelis turned over the main financial street of west Beirut to the Lebanese Saturday “by Israeli initiative alone.”
The official stressed, however, that this did not signal the start of an Israeli withdrawal from west Beirut, as demanded by President Reagan and the U.N. Security Council. It was impossible to get an accurate estimate of the total number of Palestinians shot to death at the camps because the bodies were strewn across several acres.
It appeared the final toll would be well over 1,000. Palestine Liberation Organization leader Yasser Arafat, in an interview from Damascus, said intelligence reports showed Israelis — not militamen — massacred the civilians. “They (the Israelis) sent special commandos with guides only from (Lebanese Army Maj.) Saad Haddad,” he said.
Israeli officials expressed shock but said they had prevented an even greater massacre. One senior Israeli official said, “The moment we heard what was going on, we moved to stop it,” but admitted he didn’t know what time that was.
The Phalangists’ forces broke into the southern edge of the Chatila refugee camp “and while coming out they reported to the IDF (Israeli army) that they were involved in heavy fighting with casualties to both sides,” one Israeli source said. The Israeli officials said an investigation of the massacre will be made.
Leftist members of the Israeli parliament immediately called for the resignation of Prime Minister Menachem Begin and other top officials. The Lebanese government radio, in its first comment on the massacre, blamed it on the Christian militias of renegade Lebanese Army Maj.
Saad Haddad, who controls a strip of territory on the Lebanese-Israeli border in the south and whose troops had been reported seen in the camp Friday along with the Phalangists.
JERUSALEM (AP) — Prime Minister Menachem Begin’s government knew for at least 36 hours that Lebanese Christian Phalangists were killing Palestinians in west Beirut refugee camps but took no action to stop the slaughter, Israeli newspapers claimed today.
The reports were rejected by Minister Without Portfolio Yitzhak Modai, who said the Israeli army “acted as soon as it learned of the action, Friday afternoon.”… Modai told Israel radio that the Israeli army intervened to stop the massacre Friday afternoon. “If they didn’t intervene then, it would have been much worse,” Modai said.
He said Israeli troops knew the Christian Phalangists were entering the camps, largely inhabited by Moslem Palestinians, but did not know there would be a massacre.
“If they had the vaguest idea that this was the intent, they would have stopped it beforehand,” he told Israel radio.… Yedioth Ahronoth’s Eitan Haber wrote that the government permitted Phalangist militiamen to enter the Sabra and Chatilla camps on Thursday.
“On Thursday and Friday morning ministers and officers knew of the massacre and took no steps to stop it,” Haber wrote. “For 36 hours, the Phalange killed everybody in their path.”
“Though the government knew on Thursday night,” Haber wrote, “it didn’t raise a finger nor did it do anything to prevent the massacre until Saturday morning.” Between 300 and 1,500 Palestinians were killed, according to various estimates.
“On Friday morning, I knew about the massacre in the camps and reported to a senior officials,” Zeev Schiff, Israel’s most respected military affairs commentator, wrote in Haaretz.
“Two Palestinian women wept in Sabra Palestinian refugee camp in west Beirut.” AP Laserphoto
The accusation and the denial ran in the same column. Both are here. The papers making the accusation are Israeli: the independent Haaretz and the conservative Yedioth Ahronoth, with Davar of the opposition Labor Party.
A Washington Post editorial, reprinted, beside an editorial cartoon of an Israeli tank sinking in Lebanese quicksand
From the Washington Post
“Questions from Shatila and Sabra. Shatila and Sabra, the refugee camps in West Beirut savaged over the weekend, are the latest obscure place names to be burned into our collective consciousness by the Middle East tragedy.
Killers gunned down some scores if not hundreds of unarmed and apparently undefended children, women and old men, all of them apparently Palestinians who had survived weeks of Israeli fire on their miserable homes during the city’s earlier siege.
Pure vengeance seems to have been the single motive for the carnage, for there had been no complaint from any quarter that PLO guns were parked among these civilians. A more tragic demonstration of why a political solution must be found to the Palestinian refugee question could scarcely be imagined. The prime responsibility must fall, of course, on those who did it.
The gunmen appear to have been drawn from the ranks of the largely Christian Phalangist militia of Maj. Saad Haddad, the renegade Lebanese officer set up as a fireforce by the Israelis some years ago, and the Christian Phalangist militia, also with Israeli ties, that was commanded, until his recent assassination, by Bashir Gemayel.
At this point it is impossible to know whether the killing was done in specific retaliation for Gemayel’s murder (some 26 others died in the explosion that took his life, by the way) or in a spree of generalized revenge and bloodletting or by way of advancing the political objective of removing the Palestinian refugee presence from sensitive areas of Lebanon.
Nor is there much likelihood of a reliable future accounting, given the pervasiveness of mass murder in Lebanon’s recent history, and the lack of any system whatsoever for bringing the perpetrators of political violence to justice.
The Israelis, however, cannot avoid their own measure of responsibility. Their officials say now that the restraints placed on them by American diplomats and Moslem Lebanese politicians kept the Israeli army from imposing the firm presence in West Beirut that would have forestalled this tragedy. This is a lame evasion.
The Israelis invaded West Beirut last Wednesday — an operation that entailed shelling of the two camps where the massacre later was to take place — precisely to fill what they insisted was a vacuum of authority created by the death of Bashir Gemayel. By their invasion they made themselves accountable for its consequences.
Whether there was a degree of actual Israeli complicity in the events in Shatila and Sabra will no doubt be argued over for some time. Even if there was none, the Israelis still will not be absolved on the larger question.
Notwithstanding their insistence that they were going into West Beirut to protect people, moreover, no physical signs had been reported of any trouble in that part of the city before the Israeli army entered. At the least, it appears, their entry created the conditions in which the massacre took place…
In retrospect, another painful question arises. Where was the international peace-keeping force? The answer is known. The Americans, French and Italians sent in their men for the limited purpose of covering the evacuation of the PLO fighters from Beirut, and once that operation was completed, they pulled them out. Was that a mistake?
Should the force have been left in place to protect civilians, especially Palestinian civilians, who had been left with no military protectors of their own?… It is part of the somber picture that must be contemplated as the dead of Shatila and Sabra are mourned.”
An editorial cartoon runs above the piece: an Israeli tank sinking into a swamp lettered LEBANON, its crew calling “QUICKSAND!” Signed Marlette, 1982.
A Washington Post editorial reprinted in Honolulu. It says the massacre cannot be excused by the absence of PLO guns among the civilians, and it puts the question to the Americans as well.
A Palestinian woman grieves over the bodies of her relatives in the Sabra refugee camp of West Beirut. In background, a Red Cross worker sprays disinfectant.
“A Palestinian woman grieves over the bodies of her relatives in the Sabra refugee camp of West Beirut. In background, a Red Cross worker sprays disinfectant.” UPI photo.
Twelve rows of bodies under blankets, a Red Cross worker with a sprayer, and a woman kneeling beside one of them. The caption gives her a nationality and a relationship and no name. The verb for what was done to the people in the picture does not appear.
“this ugly affair.” “We are an ancient people with much endurance and experience and an ancient heritage of morality, justice and truth,” Navon said. “If we adhere to these values, I am certain we will endure doubled in strength and draw strength to overcome all the obstacles that today are strewn in our path.”
Afterward, Begin scheduled an emergency Cabinet session for today. Israel radio reported that the prime minister now is ready to accept an outside investigation. This was a change from the earlier reaction by Minister Without Portfolio Yitzhak Modai. “By asking for a commission of inquiry they already infer that something was wrong,” Modai said.
“As Israelis, it is criminal to even infer, to even indicate, to intimate, that Israel had anything to do with this.” Intense scrutiny of the Israeli role in the killing began Monday morning in Israeli newspapers, which returned to the streets after the two-day Jewish New Year holiday.
Anguished Israelis viewed photo spreads of mutilated women and piles of murdered children and asked one another how it could happen in a city occupied by Israeli troops.
Israel’s most respected military correspondents reported that government officials had learned of the Beirut massacre as early as Thursday and at least by Friday morning — but failed to stop the slaughter until Saturday. The government denied these stories, but changed its own account for the third time in as many days.
On Monday, various official spokesmen admitted that Israel allowed the private Christian militiamen into ill-defended neighborhoods of their Palestinian blood enemies, but contended that Israeli troops stopped the killing of civilians as soon as they learned of it, on Friday morning.
The Israelis admitted the Christian gunmen because they promised to “mop up” the remaining Palestinian and Lebanese Moslem “terrorists” in the area, according to a senior Israeli official, who briefed journalists only on the condition that he not be named.
It was reported in Washington, meanwhile, that members of Congress were given similar information in secret intelligence briefings Monday. In effect, said one congressional source, the Israelis told the Lebanese militia to “sic ’em” and sent them into the camps “to do a dirty job that the Israelis didn’t want to expose their own troops to.”
The Central Intelligence Agency reportedly told the lawmakers of “substantive reports” indicating that Israeli Army officials did not anticipate the bloodbath. “The objective was to clean out any remaining PLO’ers in the camps, with a minimum of risk to Israeli soldiers,” said the source.
Survivors from the Sabra and Chatila Palestinian “camps” or neighborhoods told reporters in Beirut that the bloodletting continued until Saturday morning. In Israel, the military correspondent for state-run television, Ron Ben-Yishai, shocked viewers when he confirmed these stories and disputed the government account.
Ben-Yishai said he based his report on talks with front-line Israeli troops and commanders, Phalangist Christian gunmen and Palestinian survivors. Phalangist militiamen streamed into the Sabra and Chatila Palestinian neighborhoods on Thursday night, by all accounts. Reports of atrocities reached the surrounding Israelis at least by Friday morning.
Israeli officers intervened with their Phalangist counterparts and asked them to call off their gunmen, Ben-Yishai reported. The killing stopped for a while on Friday, but resumed that evening, when more Christian soldiers moved into the Palestinian neighborhoods from the south.
The Israelis did not succeed in expelling the Christians and resuming control of the Palestinian areas until 8 or 9 a.m. Saturday, Ben-Yishai said. There also were conflicting reports as to whether the Phalangists were joined in the massacre by the rival forces of Lebanese Christian Maj. Saad Haddad, a renegade even more closely allied to Israel than the Phalangist militia.
Israeli government spokesmen and Haddad himself strongly denied accounts by Palestinian surivors that his militia was involved. But Yishai reported that Israeli troops shot and killed one Haddad soldier among a group trying to enter the Palestinian neighborhoods.
Another Israeli military correspondent, Eitan Haber, wrote that “on Thursday and Friday morning, ministers and army officers knew of the massacre and took no steps to stop it.” “For 36 hours, the Phalangists killed everyone who crossed their path,” Haber wrote in Yediot Ahronoth, a popular afternoon daily with a right-wing, pro-government outlook.
Zev Schiff, military correspondent for Ha’aretz, the leading Israeli morning paper, reported similar findings. He wrote that he learned of the Beirut massacre from defense sources on Friday morning and immediately phoned to inform an unnamed senior Israeli official.
“We did not know they would massacre the civilian population, but it was no secret that the Phalangists did this in the past and that they were in a fury after the assassination of their leader and sought revenge,” Schiff wrote.
Aides to two Cabinet ministers confirmed Israeli radio reports that the Cabinet approved the Phalangist advance into the Palestinian neighborhoods on Thursday night.
The senior Israeli official who briefed journalists on Monday said that Israel had no intention of sending its own troops to clear out the remaining Palestinian and Lebanese Moslem guerrillas in those neighborhoods. The weak Lebanese national army refused to do the job, so the Christian militias looked like the best alternative, the official said.
As Schiff pointed out, it was common knowledge that the Phalangists seldom distinguished between combatants and civilians, whether battling their Christian rivals or the Palestinians. Information from The Herald Washington bureau supplemented this report.
Printed four days after Sabra and Chatila, and what it is actually reporting is a fight over the record. The Israeli government changed its account three times in three days; the papers that broke it were Israeli, and the correspondents named here — Ron Ben-Yishai on state television, Eitan Haber in Yediot Ahronoth, Zev Schiff in Ha’aretz — are reporting against their own defense ministry with sources inside it. The one sentence set in large type across the middle of the page is the admission, and it is sourced to an official who would speak only if he were not named.
Cabinet Leaves Open the Possibility of Holding an Internal Inquiry
By DAVID K. SHIPLER
JERUSALEM, Sept. 21 — The Israeli Cabinet decided today to accept President Reagan’s proposal to send the three-nation peacekeeping force back to Beirut. But it rejected a call by the parliamentary opposition to establish an independent commission of inquiry into the Beirut massacre.
Although the Reagan Administration demanded an immediate Israeli withdrawal from Beirut, the Israeli Government insisted that its troops would remain until leftist Moslem militiamen and Palestinians were disarmed and the Lebanese Army was ready to take over key positions in the capital.
Prime Minister Menachem Begin, who presided over the five-hour Cabinet meeting, was reported to have opposed the naming of a judicial commission on the ground that it would give the appearance of Israeli involvement in the massacre.
The Cabinet left open the possibility that it might agree to some kind of internal examination of the massacre, in which Lebanese Christian militiamen slaughtered hundreds of Palestinian men, women and children last week.
The Government’s acceptance of the multinational force, made up of American, French and Italian troops, was an unavoidable concession in the face of United States anger over the massacre.
After the assassination of President-elect Bashir Gemayel a week ago, Israel sent its troops into Moslem West Beirut to consolidate the political and military gains that it had made during the war. The main objective was to purge the area of leftist Moslem militiamen and any Palestinian guerrillas still in the capital.
The Palestine Liberation Organization’s withdrawal from Beirut — supervised by the multinational force — was completed on Sept. 1. But Israel said later that some guerrillas had stayed behind and gone underground. The disarming of leftists and Palestinians has been going on at a rapid pace, with huge, hidden depots of weapons uncovered every day by Israeli troops.
“Protests were reported today from the Bedouin village of Ratat in the south to the Tel Aviv suburb of Jaffa and throughout northern Galilee.”
Three weeks after Sabra and Shatila. The geography in that sentence is the point: this is not the West Bank or Gaza, it is Jaffa and the Galilee, inside the state, and the paper files it under Crisis in Lebanon.
Five days after the camps, a Virginia paper putting a state in the headline as the party that wanted the outcome. Nothing in this archive from that week goes further. Compare the two headlines of 19 September, which name no one at all (CP-1982-011, CP-1982-008).
Militiamen unleash hatred, slaughter hundreds in Palestinian refugee camps
“MASSACRE. Bodies of Palestinians sprawl in street at Sabra camp as defense workers wear gas masks to take them away. Deadly drama in Beirut — 48 hours of terror. Militiamen unleash hatred, slaughter hundreds in Palestinian refugee camps.”
“Bodies of Palestinians sprawl in street at Sabra camp as defense workers wear gas masks to take them away.” United Press International. A corner flash on the page reads “MASSACRE.”
The clipping is the photograph, its caption and the headline stack; the story below was not clipped. The paper set a corner flash reading MASSACRE across the top of the picture.
“Like the United States, Israel is held by its own people and by the rest of the world to exacting standards of honest and humane conduct even in the emotional circumstances of war. It is a heavy burden, yet one neither nation could put aside without losing its character and sense of mission.
We Americans felt the anguish of blood on our hands during the dark days of Vietnam, most particularly when details of the terrible massacre at My Lai came to light. Out of this came a willingness to face the full consequences of a misguided policy, a readiness to set our priorities aright, a determination to recapture our sanity.
Now Israel must take this same hard road or find itself isolated among nations, its security undermined. Whatever excuses or equivocations may be heard from the Begin-Sharon government, the tragedy that befell Palestinians in the Sabra and Chatilla camps outside Beirut must be confronted by the Israeli people.
Prime Minister Menachem Begin misleads himself if he believes a full state inquiry into the massacre near Beirut would be an admission of Israel’s complicity. On the contrary, the denial of an inquiry would be taken by the rest of the world as an admission of guilt. Nobody is accusing Israeli soldiers of gunning down unarmed men, women and children.
What needs to be established clearly is precisely which Israeli leaders knew what and when. Americans know all too well that the search for justice after a vast crime against humanity is painful and far from conclusive or satisfying. In the case of My Lai, Lt.
William Calley was the sole person prosecuted while higher-ups in positions of responsibility were never really called to public account. But there was a public trial and an airing of the facts. Surely a raucous, instinctive democracy like Israel can and must do the same if the damage to its name is to be repaired.
It is not our purpose to join in the clamor for the resignation of the Begin-Sharon government. That is a matter for the Israeli people to decide, preferably after a full but prompt state inquiry.
That the president of Israel has demanded such an inquiry, that two prominent members of the Begin Cabinet have resigned and Israeli newspapers are demanding the truth is testament to Israel’s strength, not its weakness. Perhaps out of the Sabra-Chatilla tragedy will come a return to reason and proportion in Israel’s relations with its neighbors.
Israel could do worse than learn from the American experience.”
An American editorial reaching for My Lai as the comparison, and naming what it thinks the comparison shows: one lieutenant prosecuted and the higher-ups never called to account.
Those lucky enough to have lived tell consistent tale of death camps
Sadness of survivors
Christopher Young, Southam News, Beirut
BEIRUT — Survivors of Sabra and Chatilla had to be either lucky or smart. Arabia Hussein was a bit of both. A large woman of 32 but looking much older, she has eight children — and she and her husband managed to save them all. She is full of anger.
It is focused specifically on the Israelis, even though they did no killing, also on the Americans, the French and the Italians, the providers of the multinational force who went away and left the Palestinians to their fate, and on U.S. President Ronald Reagan and Israeli Prime Minister Begin personally.
The two names ring though the language barrier in Arabia’s flaming rhetoric as she tells what happened, suckling child no. 8 at the same time. While the world of international politics wrestles with how the Beirut massacre is to be investigated, survivors are telling a rather consistent story.
When I went back to the camps last weekend, a week after I had walked their silent streets past the bodies of the murdered people, I found the neighbors and kinfolk ready and anxious to talk about it. “That’s my home,” said one old woman, waving her hand at a pile of rubble two-and-a-half metres high among some blasted trees.
“I’m not sad for my house,” she said, beginning to weep. “I’m sad for all the people who died.” She burst into uncontrollable sobbing and could not continue. But let Arabia Hussein speak, because she is clear about times and days and because she embodies the tragic cycle of driven people and religious hatred that caused this tragedy.
Arabia was born and lived all her life in Chatilla refugee camp. Her parents were refugees from Palestine, and they ended up here, her mother pregnant with Arabia, two years after the first Arab-Israeli…
“Group of Palestinian women weep outside the ruins of their homes in Beirut’s Sabra refugee camp, where the search still goes on for those who disappeared in last week’s bloody massacre when Phalangist forces entered the camp after Palestinian fighters had quit.” UPI
A survivor given her name, her age, her children and her anger, and the reporter says why he is letting her speak at length. The clipping is cut before the end of her account.
“Tel Aviv—The Foreign Ministry said yesterday that Israel is gratified by U.S. support in opposing Israeli expulsion from the U.N. General Assembly and technical conferences of the world body. ‘Israel is very appreciative and very pleased with the American approach to the problem,’ a ministry spokesman said.
Any formal Israeli statements on the subject would be made by Foreign Minister Yitzhak Shamir, currently in the United States, he added. Secretary of State George P.
Shultz said Saturday that Washington would withdraw delegations and withhold payments to the General Assembly and the International Telecommunications Conference in Nairobi, Kenya, if those groups voted to expel Israel. In Nairobi, the balloting on the Algerian-sponsored resolution to expel Israel from the communications conference was scheduled for today.
Chief U.S. delegate Michael Gardner said he has sent copies of Mr. Shultz’s statement to the heads of all delegations. A commentary from the Soviet news agency Tass claimed Washington was backing Israel in the U.N. dispute because Tel Aviv was working to impose America’s ‘imperial designs’ on the Middle East.
‘Gross blackmail—that is how, and in no other way, one can qualify the latest demarche of the United States toward the United Nations,’ the Tass commentary said. Arab nations have spearheaded the drive to oust Israel in response to the Israeli invasion of Lebanon June 6 and the massacre of Palestinians by Christian militiamen in two Beirut refugee camps September 16-18.
Many Arabs blame Israel for the massacre because Israeli troops allowed the Christians to enter the Sabra and Shatila camps, ostensibly to rout Palestinian guerrillas.”
The camps are named in the last paragraph, and what happened there is given as what Arabs say.
Correction: {'note': 'The scan has no masthead. It arrived captioned as the Roanoke Times, 2012. The story refers to the Israeli invasion of Lebanon on June 6 and the camp massacres of September 16-18 as recent, to Shultz speaking on Saturday and to a Nairobi vote scheduled for today, which places it in the last days of September or the first days of October 1982. Neither the paper nor the exact day can be confirmed from the clipping.'}
“Your editorial ‘Israel Finds Its Voice’ (Sept. 29) misunderstands history and misreads the facts… Those who opposed Begin are in agreement with him on the dismemberment of Palestine; their disagreement is as to the instrument of torture and how far they should go… in order to establish and retain the Jewish state in Palestine.”
Published a fortnight after Sabra and Shatila, answering the paper’s own editorial.
“IS JORDAN REALLY PALESTINE? Ariel Sharon says yes. King Hussein says no. The State Department agrees with Hussein. It provides no evidence to support the king. But neither does the king; he just says it’s ‘ridiculous.’
Until recently, Hussein and the department saw no need to respond to the question, which had lingered at the edges of the Middle East debate for years. Now that the issue is joined, perhaps it will no longer be ignored. This is progress, since the matter is fundamental to resolution of the Palestinian-Israeli problem. Is Jordan Palestine?
In 1920, the World War I Allies conferred on Britain a mandate to govern Palestine, an area on both sides of the Jordan River that had been part of the Ottoman Empire. This mandate, confirmed by the League of Nations in 1922, remained unchanged during the League’s lifetime.
Though the mandate incorporated Britain’s 1917 commitment to provide a homeland in Palestine for the Jews — the Balfour Declaration — the mandate did not provide a homeland for Arabs living there, though it did protect their ‘civil and religious’ but not political rights.
Two months after the League approved the mandate, the British colonial secretary, Winston Churchill, changed the rules and the picture.
He created the Emirate of Transjordan, installing the Hashemite Abdullah, Hussein’s grandfather, as emir of all the land east of the Jordan River… However, Britain did not free Transjordan — an area constituting nearly 80 percent of Palestine — from the mandate.
The people on the East Bank — like the Arabs and Jews on the West Bank — were all considered Palestinians, traveling with Palestinian passports and subject to British control.
Moreover, according to Sir Alec Kirkbride, England’s East Bank representative, who later served for years as Abdullah’s adviser, Transjordan was ‘intended to serve as a reserve of land for use in the resettlement of Arabs once the National Home for the Jews in Palestine, which (Britain was) pledged to support, became an accomplished fact.
There was no intention at that stage of forming the territory east of the river Jordan into an independent Arab state.’ Indeed, Churchill persuaded the Zionists to suspend Jewish immigration to the East Bank on the ground that this would mollify West Bank Arabs and thus make easier a Jewish homeland west of the Jordan.
Obviously, the West Bank Palestinian Arabs were not mollified; if anything, their appetites were whetted for the whole of Palestine… Is Jordan Palestine? Yes, but not all of mandated Palestine. Israel holds a little more than 20 percent of the mandate’s Palestine, including the 5 percent known as the West Bank and Gaza.
Jordan is not only de facto Palestine because all who have lived there except for Bedouins and the king’s family are Palestinian; it is de jure Palestine. Does all of this history matter? Of course. It’s fundamental. Palestinians are a nation without a state. Jordan is a state but not a nation.
Let Hussein declare himself the king of Palestine, and the world will see the problem for what it is — a border issue between two nations, Israeli and Palestinian — who share the same land. And border problems get solved. When a people believe its nationhood has been ripped off, nothing can be settled.”
A columnist arguing the Jordan-is-Palestine case and, in the middle of it, recording that under the mandate everyone on both banks was considered Palestinian and carried Palestinian passports.
Tel Aviv Israeli authorities yesterday announced the easing of some restrictions on Palestinian universities in the occupied West Bank in an apparent attempt to get the school year started smoothly.
Initial reactions were mixed, but spokesmen at the three major campuses — Bethlehem University with 1200 students, Birzeit near Ramallah with 2400, and an-Najah in Nablus with 3300 — said there were crowds of students registering for classes.
Achiya Yitzhaki, spokesman for the Israeli civil administration, said Israeli security forces would not erect roadblocks near the schools to check incoming students and faculty members.
Yitzhaki also said the wording was being changed on a pledge that became a major point of dispute among Palestinian students and teachers — a declaration that they do not support the Palestine Liberation Organization.
Israeli columnist outwits military censor with fictional story
Associated Press, Tel Aviv
“This article was subject to Israeli military censorship. Tel Aviv (AP)—In what fellow journalists called an ingenious story that evaded military censors, an Israeli columnist informed readers of a major war debate in the cabinet by transposing it to Poland in 1922.
Amnon Abromowitz, who writes for the daily Maariv, learned two weeks ago that his government had nearly launched a new offensive in Lebanon. But military censors refused to let him publish it on national security grounds. So Mr.
Abromowitz bypassed the censors by resorting to ‘historical fiction,’ using details of the real story to concoct a mythical Polish cabinet debate 60 years ago.
What really happened, reported a week later when the government relaxed censorship on the event, was that on October 4 the cabinet defeated by one vote a proposal to attack Palestinian guerrillas in Lebanon in retaliation for a guerrilla attack that killed six Israeli soldiers. The move was proposed by Defense Minister Ariel Sharon the day after the attack.
But those who knew how to decode Mr. Abromowitz’s column knew about the vote three days after it took place. ‘I think the public had a right to know how close the cabinet was to launching an action that could have led to a new conflagration,’ Mr. Abromowitz said in an interview.
‘It was my duty as a journalist to get the story out, so I wrote it as though the whole thing happened in Poland 60 years ago.’… It turned out that Mr. Abromowitz’s description of the meeting, and the lineup of ministers in the final vote, closely corresponded to Israeli reality. ‘A lot of reporters phoned me when they read the story,’ Mr. Abromowitz said.
‘They wanted to know whether they had understood me correctly, and whether I could confirm the whole thing. All I could say was that I had nothing to add to what I wrote.’
Confronted with censorship since the Jewish state was established in 1948, local and foreign reporters sometimes must go to extreme and offbeat lengths to get suppressed stories into print… Although censorship applies almost exclusively to national security matters, violators face tough punishment.
All outgoing reports are monitored and foreign correspondents risk losing accreditation.”
A dispatch about censorship, carrying a censorship notice in its own first line, describing how reporters got around censorship.
“JERUSALEM (UPI) — An American Jewish nurse who struggled to save Palestinians shot in the refugee camp massacres says she testified before an Israeli commission investigating the massacres because she ‘can’t sleep at night.’ Testifying Monday was Ellen Segal, a nurse from Washington, along with Dr. Paul Morris, a Briton, and surgeon Suee Chai-ang of Singapore.
All were volunteers at the Gaza Hospital in the Sabra refugee camp. The medical workers were the first non-Israeli witnesses to testify before the commission… ‘I feel it was my duty to say what I heard and what I saw,’ Miss Segal said after the hearing.
‘I can’t sleep at night unless I tell people what happened there and what perhaps Israel’s involvement was, or was not, in this.’… Miss Segal testified that Israeli soldiers had been perched on a tall building overlooking the Chatilla camp and must have known about the slaughter. They could have stopped it, she said.
‘I feel that it is impossible the Israelis could not have seen from the top of that building what was going on and had to hear what was going on,’ she said. But in testimony Sunday, Maj. Gen. Amir Drory, Israel’s top army commander in Lebanon, said that he had been unable to see anything amiss from an observation post at midday Sept.
17, when he first had received reports that the militiamen might be killing civilians.”
An American Jewish nurse volunteering testimony to Israel’s own commission of inquiry, and the Israeli general’s answer from the day before, printed under it.
PARIS — He is not the kind of American you would pick for the role: prisoner of the Palestine Liberation Organization, beaten on the soles of his feet with insulated electric cable, threatened with a pistol at his temple by a prison guard and spending hours huddled in the corner of his cell as Israeli bombs flattened the part of west Beirut directly above his head.
Rather than Kenneth Timmerman, a dreamy 28-year-old novelist who lives in a cozy book-filled apartment here, you would expect someone . . . big. Someone brash. Timmerman is tall and thin, almost delicate. He wears wire-rimmed glasses and open-necked shirts, cardigan sweaters and jeans.
For five years he lived the life you read about in genial memoirs of literary expatriates: He published a magazine of poetry and fiction; he drank in cafes; he sat up late, talking books. One day each year he teetotalled — “to clean out my system.” In July, he did something new.
“I went to Beirut very much in the Hemingway tradition,” he said in his clear, high-pitched voice. “His generation had war, ours has drugs. Both provide psychic stimulus.” On July 12, he arrived at Junieh, a Christian-controlled port north of the Lebanese capital.
Two days later, after being directed through a ransacked building, he found himself — literally, for he had gotten lost — at the PLO’s Fateh crossing separating east and west Beirut.
He presented himself to “a man in a white safari suit” as a free-lance journalist interested in writing about west Beirut and was sent to the office of the PLO’s chief spokesman, Mahmoud Labadi, for a pass.
There, despite his lack of credentials, he was taken on a tour of the damaged Fakahani section of Beirut — the PLO’s main stronghold — along with two British journalists. “Labadi kept saying, ‘The great American civilization, which is supposed to send us doctors and teachers, instead sends us death,’ ” Timmerman recalled.
“One of the Brits told him he considered my presence an intrusion. Labadi then told me to get back to his office and wait.”
IN QUEST FOR SOMETHING ‘NEW’: Kenneth Timmerman spent 24 of 26 days in Beirut imprisoned by the PLO.
Correction: The deck caption gave a shorter name than the masthead prints. Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 163 clippings in this deck.
PARIS — He’s not the kind of American you’d pick for the role: prisoner of the Palestine Liberation Organization, beaten on the soles of his feet with insulated electric cable or threatened with a pistol at his temple by a prison guard.
Rather than Kenneth Timmerman, a dreamy 28-year-old novelist who lives in a cozy book-filled apartment here, you’d expect someone ... big. Someone brash. Someone dulled into fearlessness by routinely taking chances with his life. Timmerman is tall and thin, almost delicate. He wears wire-rimmed glasses and open-necked shirts, cardigan sweaters and jeans.
For five years this New York City native lived the life you read about in genial memoirs of literary expatriates: He published a magazine of poetry and fiction, he drank in cafes, he sat up late talking books. In July, he did something new. “I went to Beirut very much in the Hemingway tradition,” he said in his clear, high-pitched voice.
“His generation had war, ours has drugs. Both provide psychic stimulus. I wanted to see more of the war than I could read about in the newspapers.” Two days later, after being directed through a ransacked building, he found himself — literally, for he had gotten lost — at the PLO’s Fateh crossing separating East and West Beirut.
He presented himself to “a man in a white safari suit” as a free-lance journalist interested in writing about West Beirut, and was sent to the office of the PLO’s chief spokesman, Mahmoud Labadi, for a pass. There, despite his lack of credentials, he was taken on a tour of the damaged Fakahani section of Beirut — the PLO’s main stronghold.
At the office, Timmerman was asked by two of Labadi’s assistants to produce identity photographs. When he said he didn’t have any, they told him to leave West Beirut.
TEL AVIV, Israel — An Israeli soldier whose identification tags were found in the Sabra refugee camp after the Palestinian massacre there testified Tuesday that he was never in the camp and thought the tags were taken there by someone who found them. Sgt.
Benny Chaim told the judicial commission investigating the massacre he was wounded when Israeli forces pushed into west Beirut on Wednesday, Sept. 15, the day before the slaughter of the refugees began in the Sabra and Chatilla camps. Chaim said the dog tags were in his field jacket when he was wounded.
He said a medic cut the jacket off him and threw it aside because it was burning and contained grenades. “I personally do not know how my documents got from the site of my injury to inside the refugee camp,” he said.
The Kahan commission in session, reported as a short wire story: a soldier explaining how his identification came to be inside the camp.
‘Ideological exclusion’ has always been un-American
Shearer and Glen, Washington
WASHINGTON — Mahmoud Darwish, 40, a Palestinian poet now living in Paris, received an invitation to read from his work at a Nov. 28 New York City benefit for UNICEF.
Despite his three-week visit to America last year, however, he was unable to obtain a three-day visa because of “28.” ANGEL RAMA, 56, a renowned Latin American literature specialist who has lived and taught in the U.S. for large parts of the last 13 years, won a tenured professorship from the University of Maryland in 1980.
But when he sought permanent residency here at the university’s insistence, Uruguayan-born Rama found “28” in his way. South African Dennis Brutus, 58, is a tenured professor at Northwestern University who, after a decade of annually renewing his visitor’s visa, also sought permanent residency recently. But the State Department denied his request.
This time, too, “28” was the reason… Subsection 28 is an obscure provision of U.S. immigration law which permits the State Department to withhold entry or permanent residency from any alien alleged to hold beliefs considered contrary to the American political system.
Arbitrary in practice and anti-democratic in purpose, it’s not an issue in landmark immigration law reforms facing the House this week. But it deserves to be. Passed during the heyday of Wisconsin’s Sen.
Joseph McCarthy as part of the 1952 McCarran-Walter Act, Subsection 28 has enabled anonymous bureaucrats to classify thousands of left-wing writers, artists and others as “pro-communist” or “subversive” on the basis of weak allegations or associations.… In fact, of approximately 140,000 requests to have the provision waived over the last five years, only 136 have been denied, according to an INS official.
Yet these seemingly benign statistics belie the extent to which U.S. authorities successfully employ the rule for political ends. Simple delay tactics can often prevent an appointed visit without delaying a visa per se.
Darwish, who might have received clearance after a 21-day review by the INS, is one exemplary victim of this practice… THIS PROBABILITY has prompted reform efforts in the past and underpins an attack on Subsection 28 planned by Rep. Ted Weiss, Democrat of New York.
But if not now, when? The blackballing and punishment of individuals for their thoughts remains an affront to American ideals and is clearly hypocritical in the context of our democratic proselytizing. At some point, we owe ourselves and the world an admission that “ideological exclusion” is as un-American today as it was 30 years ago.
A poet refused three days in New York to read at a children’s charity benefit, under a clause of the McCarran-Walter Act written at the height of McCarthyism. The archive now holds seven moments of Mahmoud Darwish’s life taken from American newspapers across forty-one years: arrested in Israel in 1967 among fourteen named men, refused a visa here in 1982, his portrait illustrating a review of Edward Said in 1986, his poem printed as a threat in 1988, his own question about what a poet does on an executive council, his resignation from the PLO reported inside an arts dispatch in 1994, and his death in a Houston hospital in 2008 in six printings.
“Samir Ghazal Taflak, 19 years old. He was hit in the chest with a bullet, Palestinian sources said. An army spokesman said soldiers had fired at the feet of youths who had hurled stones.”
Nine column inches. The army says it fired at their feet; the boy was hit in the chest. Both sentences are printed, and the archive keeps the brief because it has his name in it: Samir Ghazal Taflak, nineteen, a student at King Talal High School in Nablus.
· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia · page 1
Survivors: Israelis watched massacre
Three say up to 10 soldiers were in the Shatila camp
Scheherazade Faramarzi, Associated Press, Beirut
“BEIRUT, Lebanon — Contradicting official testimony in Israel, some of the survivors of the Palestinian massacre in September say Israeli soldiers were in the Shatila refugee camp during the killings.
Three Palestinian women — Ektefa Shallah; her daughter, Jamila, 16; and their neighbor, Amenah Khalifa — said the Israelis tried to protect women and children during the slaughter Sept.
16-18 by Lebanese Christian militiamen… Informed of the women’s statements, an Israeli military command spokesman in Tel Aviv reiterated the Israelis’ previous statements that no Israeli soldiers were in the Shatila and Sabra camps before, during or after the massacre. Israeli government policy forbids identification of the spokesman… Mrs.
Shallah, 44, said she first saw an Israeli soldier standing with a Phalangist militiaman in a narrow passageway outside her concrete-block house, 175 yards from the western edge of Shatila… Mrs. Shallah and her neighbor said that a few minutes later Mrs.
Khalifa’s husband, two teenage sons and three other men were lined up against a wall and killed by Lebanese militiamen… ‘The other one [the Phalangist militiaman] wanted to kill me. He killed the children standing behind me. He cut a woman’s stomach and took the baby out,’ Mrs.
Shallah said… ‘We were put next to about 30 corpses,’ she said. ‘In front of me, a 2-month-old baby was wrested from his mother’s lap… Those who were shooting [to kill] were Phalangists, but there were Jews among them. I saw them with these eyes.
I am not lying.’… The final death toll in the Shatila-Sabra slaughter remains uncertain. Germanos has said that 328 Palestinians were killed, and 991 people are listed as missing.”… ‘When they [the Israelis and the Lebanese] talked to each other, they spoke in Arabic, but the Jews had a heavy accent,’ Mrs. Khalifa said.
‘The Jews asked a Phalangist man, “What did you do to them?” … The Phalangist man said, “I machine-gunned them, all of them.” … He then told the Jews, “Come on, shoot them. Finish them” — meaning us. One Jew said: “No baby. No madam. You’ve killed their men.
We want to interrogate them.”’ When Jamila, who does not speak Hebrew, was asked how she knew they were Israelis, she replied: ‘How shall I say? They were speaking Hebrew, and who are the Hebrews? They are Israelis.’”
Jamila Shallah (left) and her mother, Ektefa, give their account of the September slaughter. Associated Press.
The square brackets in the quotations are the Inquirer’s own. The Israeli denial ran in the same column and is here with the testimony.
“Doctors and nurses at the Gaza Hospital said they did not know about the killings… On Thursday morning the Israeli Army had sealed… Militiamen who entered the camp…”
Sabra and Shatila, reconstructed hour by hour alongside the Kahan Commission's findings. Corniche Mazraa, the Gaza Hospital, Thursday 16 September.
TEL AVIV, Feb. 17 — A military tribunal said today that the former military commander of the occupied West Bank had issued illegal orders to harass Arabs in the Hebron area last spring. The judges said orders by Col.
Yaakov Hartabi to drive people out of their homes and beat them, to shoot into the reflectors of rooftop solar heaters and to break residents' watches were unlawful and should not have been obeyed. The colonel's orders were intended to end Arab disturbances last March.
Evidence of the orders came to light in court during the trial of seven soldiers under Colonel Hartabi's command who were charged with harassment and aggravated assault. Officers Testified Their attorney, contending that the harassment had been ordered by superiors, brought military government officers to testify about the commander's orders.
The accused had not been charged with the specific acts recommended by Colonel Hartabi. The court held, however, that anyone must know that orders like those of the colonel were illegal and that orders from superiors was no defense in such cases. Colonel Hartabi was transferred from the military government in September.
There have also been calls for his dismissal or prosecution. Four of the seven defendants were convicted. For lack of evidence, the court acquitted Maj. David Mopaz, former deputy military commander in Hebron, and two sergeants major who had been charged with aggravated assault and harassment. Sgt. Maj.
Salah Salah, a Bedouin, was sentenced to two months in prison for failing to stop beatings by his subordinates. For assaulting Arabs, Cpl. David Benali was sentenced to six months, Pvt. Shlomo Levy was ordered to serve five months and Sgt. Baruch Meir was placedon good behavior.
Chief's Orders Approved The tribunal said standing orders calling for strong treatment of “troublemakers” were for the most part consistent with the law but stopped short of humiliation and beatings. An exception was an order to take students by bus and then drop them a long distance away, forcing them to return home on foot.
Hebron Mayor Says Israelis Kidnapped 2 Arab Teen-Agers
JERUSALEM, March 1 — The Acting Mayor of Hebron in the Israeli-occupied West Bank said today that Jewish settlers had kidnapped two Arab teen-agers from a nearby high school. The whereabouts of the youths is not known, the Acting Mayor, Mustapha Natshe, said.
They were taken in a car from their school in the village of Yatta by four men apparently from a neighboring Jewish settlement, he said. The Israeli military command said two Arab youths had been taken from Yatta after they had thrown rocks at the settlers' car. Mr. Natshe denied this.
“Maybe they wish to cover this up for the settlers by saying the youths threw stones,” he said. It was the second incident in the village since Monday, when settlers fired gunshots at a passing car but wounded nobody. A police spokesman said that two men had been detained for questioning in connection with Monday's incident.
In other recent incidents in the Hebron area, two Arab men were wounded last Friday when a grenade exploded outside the Kazazine Mosque. On Saturday a 5-year-old Arab girl was hospitalized after pistol shots were fired into her home near the Jewish settlement of Kiryat Arba.
PLO chief Yasser Arafat has spurned President Reagan’s proposal for Palestinian self-rule in association with Jordan and is calling for an independent Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital.
Arafat, who wants the Palestine Liberation Organization to play a formal role in Middle East peace talks, met with Jordan’s King Hussein Sunday for a second day of talks in Amman. Asked afterwards if he saw merit in Reagan’s proposal, he said: “I am sorry, I see nothing because still the Americans completely support … the Israeli aggression.”
TODAY, Arafat planned to meet in Amman with about half of the PLO’s 15-member executive committee, presumably to discuss his talks with Hussein.
On the Israeli-occupied West Bank, close to 400 more Arab high school girls were affected by a mysterious sickness, triggering anti-Israeli violence Sunday and fueling the suspicions of many residents that the Israelis are responsible. About 800 Arabs, most of them girls, have been hospitalized with nausea and other symptoms since March 21.
At the request of the Israeli government, the Centers for Disease Control in Atlanta dispatched two epidemiologists to Israel to help find the cause of the illness. Two cars full of Palestinian youths were arrested today in Nablus, the main West Bank city, for spreading a rumor that the water had been poisoned there, the military command in Tel Aviv said.
It did not say how many people were arrested. IN AMMAN, Jordanian officials declined comment on the Hussein-Arafat talks. But Khalil al-Wazzar, an Arafat deputy better known as Abu Jihad, said the Palestine Liberation Organization would not allow Hussein to negotiate with Israel on behalf of the Palestinians about Reagan’s plan.
“King Hussein wants it but we don’t find it satisfying,” he said. “The Palestinians are not going to give a mandate to anyone. There was a long struggle for sole representation. We are not going to allow anyone to speak for us.”
The Reagan administration, which refuses to negotiate directly with the guerrilla movement, had hoped Jordan could represent the PLO in talks. Israel, which occupied the West Bank in the 1967 Middle East war, has rejected the Reagan initiative as well as the Arab nations’ demand for an independent Palestinian state.
The Israelis also have refused to withdraw from east Jerusalem, which they captured from Jordan in 1967. On the West Bank, many Palestinians believe the strange sickness is part of an Israeli plot to settle more Jews in the region and make it part of Israel. It was not known why most of those contractng the disease were high school girls.
The ensuing violence has left two Israeli soldiers and a Palestinian youth wounded. In Jerusalem, three Jewish civilians were injured. A GRENADE exploded outside Al-Watani Hospital in Nablus, slightly injuring two Israeli soldiers, and Arab youths threw stones and slightly injured three Jewish civilians in Jerusalem’s old city.
The army said it was investigating reports that an Israeli motorist trying to escape stone-throwers in the southern West Bank shot an Arab youth in the stomach. Police said the youth was hospitalized. The 17-year-old nephew of militant American-Israeli Rabbi Meir Kahane was detained after he fired an automatic weapon in the air to keep away the stone-throwers, police said.
Tulkarem, Occupied West Bank Two American specialists in epidemic control began yesterday to investigate the current wave of mysterious illness among Palestinian schoolchildren, which the Israelis blame on mass hysteria and the Arabs link to poison. Drs.
Philip Landrigan and Bess Miller, epidemiologists from the Centers for Disease Control in Atlanta, began an “independent investigation” of the unexplained illness — characterized by dizziness, nausea, blurred vision and headaches. More than 800 people have been stricken since March 21 in the Jenin and Tulkarem areas of the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
Most of the victims have been teenage girls. The epidemic tapered off, then peaked Sunday when at least 394 girls were hospitalized. The Geneva-based World Health Organization of the United Nations also sent two doctors — an epidemiologist and a toxicologist — to look into the illnesses.
The American doctors were invited by the Israeli Health Ministry, which evidently hopes they will agree with its conclusion that no toxin or organic cause can explain the outbreak, and that it is a “mass phenomenon.” William Cavness, the press attache of the U.S.
Consulate in Jerusalem, emphasized the team plans an independent inquiry and does not regard its mission as one of “confirming anyone else’s findings.” Palestinian doctors repeatedly attribute the illness to “poison gas,” although they acknowledge that they have no idea what the gas is.
Israeli health officials and a truckload of police officers escorted the American doctors to Tulkarem Hospital, where they met with health officials and Palestinian doctors and visited with some of the 52 girls still in the hospital. Then they were driven to Jenin, where the epidemic began.
Course supported by history: Let Palestine be Palestine
Stephen Chapman
“‘Two million Palestinians already have a homeland in Palestine.’ So says a group called the Jordan is Palestine Committee in ads in The New York Times. It takes the same view as the Israeli government: The Palestinians already have a Palestinian state, namely Jordan.
This fiction helps to justify Israel’s expansionism and its resistance to Palestinian self-rule. But it is nonetheless a fiction… In any case, the Palestinians don’t regard themselves as Jordanians. The two groups are ethnically distinct.
Moreover, though a third of the world’s Palestinians live in Jordan, the bulk of them regard Palestine as their home and themselves as refugees… Accusing the Arab countries of failing to resettle the Palestinian refugees overlooks the crucial point, which is that the Palestinians don’t want to be permanently resettled in those countries.
They want the opportunity to go back to Palestine, preferably to an independent Palestinian state. If the Arab world has done too little for the Palestinians, that merely strengthens their claim to a state of their own… Those who fled to escape the fighting in 1948 and 1967 had their homes expropriated by Israel and were forbidden to return.
Having forced millions of Palestinians to become refugees, Israel now uses their residence in Jordan to justify making them permanent refugees… The only obstacle is the existence of 4 million Palestinians who insist on their right to just what the Israelis have — a sovereign homeland in Palestine.”
A syndicated American columnist in 1983 answering the Jordan-is-Palestine advertisement point by point. The paper ran a line of it as a pull quote.
“Newspapers often refer to violence against settlers as ‘pogroms,’ a word usually used to describe anti-Semitic actions against Jews… The Jerusalem Post said vigilantism must be eradicated, for it makes ‘a mockery of Israel’s pretense to dispense equal justice in the (occupied) territories.’”
A news agency, inside a news story, stopping to tell readers how newspapers use a word and what that word ordinarily means. It is not a stylebook entry and should never be described as one. Six years later a settler leader would use the word exactly as described, in the Miami Herald. The parenthetical “(occupied)” is the wire’s own insertion into a quotation that did not contain it. The story is one of four printings in this archive about the Karp report.
HARRISONBURG, VA.—Israeli domination of the West Bank extends to all areas of life and violates international law and human rights, a Palestinian lawyer said recently at Eastern Mennonite College.
Jonathan Kuttab, a member of both the American and Israeli bar associations, spoke May 6 on “Justice and Dignity Through Nonviolent Resistance for the West Bank Palestinians.” With the exception of East Jerusalem, Israel has not annexed the West Bank “and does not want to,” Kuttab said.
Annexing the area would bring too many Palestinians into the nation and would make the population much less Jewish, the graduate of the University of Virginia Law School said. AT THE SAME TIME, Israel does not treat the West Bank as international law says an occupied territory should be governed, Kuttab said.
“International law states that an occupying power should keep the laws as they are,” subject to minor adjustments for security reasons. In theory, the West Bank remains under Jordanian law. But in practice, that law has been replaced by “amendments” made by military order, Kuttab said.
“Is there already a Palestinian state? A group called the Jordan Is Palestine Committee says that Jordan is a de facto Palestinian state, and has taken out ads in the New York Times and Chicago Tribune to air its case. One of the ads quotes King Hussein of Jordan, who said in 1981, ‘The truth is that Jordan is Palestine and Palestine is Jordan.’
Tribune columnist Stephen Chapman doesn’t deny the statement, but claims that when Hussein made it he was ‘speaking metaphorically. If Arafat and Hussein believed it literally,’ Chapman continues, ‘there would be no argument and thus no need for these ads.’
Perhaps one should just blindly accept Chapman’s interpretation, even though it denies decades of history. After all, this is the Mideast: If water can change into wine, perhaps statements can be transformed into metaphors.
Compounding the problem, the ads fail to mention a very important fact: Jordan is an artificial country, carved out of the Palestine Mandate by Britain after it took over the Ottoman Empire at the end of World War I.
Even Jordan’s ruler, Abdullah, predecessor of Hussein, was an outsider who was given the newly created emirate as a reward for not attacking the French in Syria… But even though they bought off Abdullah, England did not free Transjordan—which constituted nearly 80 percent of Palestine—from the British Mandate.
The residents of both the East and West Banks continued to travel under Palestinian passports, subject to British rule… More to the point, Sir Alec Kirkbride, England’s East Bank representative, said Transjordan was supposed to serve as ‘a reserve of land for use in the resettlement of Arabs once the national home for the Jews in Palestine became an accomplished fact.
There was no intention at that stage of forming the territory east of the river Jordan into an independent Arab state.’ It was for that reason that Sir Winston Churchill persuaded the Zionists to suspend Jewish immigration to the East Bank. Viewed in this context, the ads are stronger in their contention that there already is a Palestinian state.
The ads center around the following points: Jordan occupied almost 77 percent of Britain’s original Palestine Mandate. Three-fourths of Jordan’s government appointments, including nine Cabinet posts, are held by Palestinians. Half of Jordan’s prime ministers since 1950 have been Palestinian.
Jordan’s first king, Abdullah, wanted to call his land ‘the kingdom of Palestine.’ Of course, all of this leads one to ask a key question: If Jordan is indeed Palestine, as the evidence indicates, why is it ruled by the Hashemites, who are not indigenous to the area, instead of Palestinians? To Hussein, as to Abdullah before him, this is a dangerous question.
Abdullah had annexed the West Bank in 1949, claiming the territory on the grounds that both banks are Palestinian. A year later, however, Abdullah issued a decree forbidding the use of the word Palestine in royal documents. Many Palestinians opposed his rule, and he didn’t want to give them ideas. Abdullah’s fear of Palestinians was justified.
He was murdered by a Palestinian in 1951, and was succeeded by his grandson, Hussein, after his son, Talal, Hussein’s father, was declared non compos mentis… It is this fear of the PLO and a Palestinian state that makes strange bedfellows of Hussein and Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin.
Both realize that a Palestinian state, no matter where it would be set up, would constitute a danger not only to Israel but to the Hashemite monarchy in Jordan. Is Jordan Palestinian? Definitely. Is Jordan Palestine?
Yes, but the Palestinians, the Arab nations that support them and the Soviet Union would rather focus their claims on that 23 percent of the Palestine Mandate that is now called Israel. Until the Palestinians realize that 77 percent of a loaf is better than none, there will be no Palestinian state—just violence as usual.”
The Jordan-is-Palestine case argued in the Tribune, answering the Tribune’s own columnist, who is also in this archive arguing the opposite. The author is identified as a former city editor of Chicago’s Jewish newsweekly.
ALI HASSAN SALAMEH, one of Yasir Arafat's most trusted lieutenants, was blown up in his car as it passed a booby-trapped parked Volkswagen in West Beirut on Jan. 22, 1979.
In “The Quest for the Red Prince,” Michael Bar-Zohar and Eitan Haber, two Israeli writers, give a fast-paced account of how the Mossad, the Israeli intelligence service, tracked Salameh for months and assassinated him.
They have also tried to blend into the tale of the Palestinian leader's violent life and death a history of the struggle between Arabs and Jews in Palestine before 1948, in the young state of Israel and in shadowy theaters of operation elsewhere.
Abu Hassan, as the flamboyant Fatah chief was known, was the son of Sheik Hassan Salameh, a Palestinian warlord who died in 1948 fighting the emergence of Israel. The sheik's son was no scruffy, unshaven gun toter but a sleek German-educated playboy who shortly before his death married a former Miss Universe, a Lebanese Christian named Georgina Rizak.
He was also a terrorist, one of the masterminds of Black September, the Fatah subgroup that shoved the Palestinian cause into the world's horrified consciousness by murdering 11 Israeli athletes during the Munich Olympics in 1972. But Salameh's most fascinating sideline and the one most relevant to his death is not mentioned in this book.
As the boss of Squad 17, the Fatah security outfit, he was Mr. Arafat's contact with the United States Embassy in Beirut and the Central Intelligence Agency. While Mr. Bar-Zohar and Mr.
Haber would have us believe that in “the Muslim-inhabited part of war-torn Beirut all foreigners were distrusted” and “all Westerners were suspected of being Israeli spies or secret agents,” the truth was far more subtle and paradoxical. During Mr.
Arafat's persistent efforts to open a dialogue with the United States, Al Fatah took it on itself to protect American diplomats in chaotic West Beirut after civil war erupted in 1975. Salameh's men guarded Americans and other foreigners as they were evacuated from a West Beirut seaside swimming club by the United States Sixth Fleet on June 20, 1976.
An American diplomat I knew in Beirut in those bizarre years liked to show off with a chuckle a gift from Abu Hassan — a heavy Palestine Liberation Organization key chain.
As David Ignatius reported recently in The Wall Street Journal, Salameh was “a backdoor channel between the U.S. and the P.L.O.,” and he furnished senior American diplomats, including former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, with tips about assassination plots planned by radical Palestinian and other terrorist groups.
He is also said to have supplied similar information to security organizations in West Germany, Italy and Japan to demonstrate that Al Fatah had gone out of the terror business and become a valid diplomatic interlocutor.
One revealing and heretofore untold anecdote is that not long before Salameh's death, a grateful C.I.A. took him to Florida's Walt Disney World, a place he had always wanted to visit. This uniquely American gesture compounded Mr. Arafat's bitterness and sense of betrayal when Salameh was slain. There was nothing angelic about Al Fatah's stealthy overtures to the United States.
Salameh was no C.I.A. agent. What Mr. Arafat and he were offering was, after all, the other hand of terrorism: protection from it in the roiled Middle East. But it is perhaps reasonable to assume that a budding Palestinian-American relationship, however unsavory its genesis, was not comforting to Prime Minister Menachem Begin, who came to power in Israel in 1977.
President Jimmy Carter was then on record as favoring “a homeland provided for the Palestinian refugees who have suffered for many, many years.” Mr. Carter had outraged Israelis by meeting with Syria's President, Hafez al-Assad, on the eve of the election that brought Mr. Begin to office. MR. BAR-ZOHAR and Mr.
Haber say that the Mossad ended its assassination campaign against Black September terrorist chieftains in 1973 after a botched operation in which Israeli agents were arrested in Norway for killing an innocent Moroccan waiter whom they mistook for Salameh. Mr. Arafat disbanded Black September in the same year.
The authors contend that some five years later the Begin Government revived plans to kill Salameh for what were essentially emotional reasons. “Israel felt that no terrorist with blood on his hands could be left in peace,” they write. “In the late 1970's Salameh's name was on the avengers' list once again.”
But a risky and meticulously planned assassination is usually not just an act of passion or vengeance. A more cynical and rational explanation of the Salameh killing would be that it was meant to disrupt Al Fatah's fitful secret dialogue with the United States, which, as Mr. Kissinger tells us in his memoirs, was initiated by Mr.
Arafat in the aftermath of the 1973 Middle East war. The Secretary of State's secret envoy, Vernon Walters, met with an unnamed Arafat confidant — almost certainly Salameh — in Rabat, Morocco, on Nov. 3 “to gain time and to prevent radical assaults on the early peace process.” “Afterwards,” Mr.
Kissinger continues, “attacks on Americans — at least by Arafat's faction of the P.L.O. — ceased.” Mr. Kissinger made a point of having key Arabs and Israelis briefed on the clandestine P.L.O. encounter.
In the ensuing peace talks in 1974 and 1975, Israel extracted a pledge from the United States not to negotiate with the P.L.O. until the P.L.O. recognized Israel's right to exist. ONE can only speculate about why the authors of “The Quest for the Red Prince” have omitted the best part of their tale.
In fact, the book contains little that has not been published elsewhere, and it leans heavily on a seven-year-old British book, “The Hit Team” by David B. Tinnin with Dag Christensen, for its cloak-and-dagger material. As Israeli citizens, Mr. Bar-Zohar and Mr.
Haber are obliged to nod to Israeli military censorship by noting repeatedly that “foreign sources” or British journalists — and by implication not Israeli intelligence — gave them information. The authors also adopt a journalistically dubious narrative manner.
They are privy to Salameh's most private mutterings to his terrorist comrades, when presumably not even a foreign source was present, and they confidently let us know that in 1948 a “sweet perfume of orange blossoms hung in the air” as Haganah sappers, “glassy-eyed with fear,” went on attack.
Such feats of empathy even permit insights into Sheik Hassan Salameh's hometown in 1918: “But when the news about the swelling stream of Jews flooding into the country reached Kulleh, it was received with typical Oriental indifference.”
Israeli, Arab tensions come to surface in occupied Hebron
By Arthur Max / Associated Press Writer
HEBRON, occupied West Bank — The latest cycle of violence in Hebron seems to have played squarely into the hands of Jewish militants who have long dreamed of wresting full control of the troubled city from its Moslem leadership.
The town south of Jerusalem has been crackling with tension since last week, when Arab assailants stabbed a Jewish seminary student to death and vengeful Jewish settlers set fire to stalls in the Arab market. The upshot of the troubles was a government decision to push ahead firmly with plans to strengthen the Jewish population in the city.
On Tuesday, Israeli occupation forces lifted the curfew imposed after the murder of American-born Aaron Gross, 18. But Hebron's central square was still cordoned off with barbed wire, and army patrols marched through the narrow alleys of the market.
The violence came as Moslems celebrated the religious holiday of Id el-Fitr, and children were playing with toy guns as armed Jewish settlers nervously went about their business in the town center. “There is no joy in the holiday this year,” said shopkeeper Gibril Zaloun.
“This is usually a time to visit family or go to the beach, but no one is doing it this year.” For more than 50 years, Hebron has been a microcosm of the religious and political passions that inflame the Middle East. It is the place where the biblical patriarch Abraham — Ibrahim to the Arabs — is buried, and his tomb is revered by Jews and Moslems alike.
Jewish settlers, armed with Uzi submachine guns, look through merchandise at an Arab shop in Hebron on the occupied West Bank. (AP photo)
The strange details surrounding a Jewish seminary student's slaying by Arab assailants have raised basic questions about Israel's ability to govern the West Bank.
By Trudy Rubin / Christian Science Monitor Service
HEBRON, West Bank — The death of young, bespectacled Israeli seminary student Aharon Gross at the hands of Arab assailants in the center of ancient Hebron and the Jewish rioting that followed it have raised basic questions about Israel's continued rule of the largely Palestinian-populated West Bank. • Can violence between the local Arabs and the Jewish settlers be avoided? • Will increased Jewish settlement in the heart of Arab cities such as Hebron inflame or calm such violence? • Can the West Bank's Israeli authorities, who dismissed Hebron's Arab mayor and council following Gross' murder, enforce the law impartially upon Jews and Arabs?
How committed are they to trying? The brutal and still-confusing circumstances of Gross' death July 7 highlight the tension between Jewish and Arab residents of the West Bank, which is felt most intensely inside Hebron. Yehudit Gross, Aharon's mother, said he was a studious 18-year-old who had emigrated with his parents from Staten Island, N.Y., in 1974.
He had chosen the Shovei Hebron Yeshiva seminary in Hebron not out of ideological devotion to Jewish settlement on the West Bank, but because he admired the rabbi who headed it.
3 KILLED IN ATTACK AT WEST BANK COLLEGE: Arab youths in an ambulance after they were wounded in an assault by masked gunmen on Hebron Islamic College. Thirty-three people were wounded. Page A6. (United Press International)
LOS ANGELES — In the final report reviewing events of the 1932 Olympic Games in Los Angeles, there is no mention of the word security. Fifty-two years later, during next summer's 23rd Olympiad in The City of Angels, it will be an altogether different story.
On hand for the 1984 Los Angeles Olympics will be an estimated 16,000 police officers, sheriff's deputies, highway patrolmen, private security guards and Secret Service agents culled from close to 60 city, county, state and federal law enforcement agencies.
There will be a crack special weapons and tactics team from the Los Angeles Police Department and a carefully trained, 42-man hostage rescue team from the Federal Bureau of Investigation. The U.S. Coast Guard here has created a special task force and, during the games, will intensify its patrol along the Southern California shoreline. U.S.
Customs and the federal Drug Enforcement Administration intend to bolster their forces substantially by hiring dozens of temporary employes, many of whom will work the ports and at Los Angeles International Airport. There will be a fleet of at least two dozen helicopters available to throw an aerial dragnet over the area.
On land, an array of sophisticated hardware — electronic sensors, metal detectors, X-ray machines and radios — will be deployed to detect the slightest ripple of potential trouble. The Los Angeles police chief already has visited West Germany to consult with that country's anti-terrorist experts.
His assistant, in charge of the department's over-all Olympics security, has made a similar trip to Israel. At both men's disposal is a vast pool of foreign intelligence information to help track and monitor every move of all known and suspected international terrorists.
JERUSALEM, Sept. 16 — President Chaim Herzog pardoned a Jewish settler from the occupied West Bank who had been convicted and sentenced to a year in jail for shooting into an Arab house in Hebron, injuring a 5-year-old girl with flying glass, the Israeli radio reported today. The settler, Arye Bar-Yosef, had served 5 months of his 12-month sentence.
The trial court originally imposed a four-month jail term, with six months suspended, and fined him the equivalent of about $750. The Justice Ministry, which has been trying to toughen punishment of Jewish vigilantes, appealed, calling the sentence too lenient, and the Supreme Court raised it to a year in jail. Mr.
Herzog thus used his power to counteract the Supreme Court decision. No reason for his decision was given.
BEIRUT, Lebanon, Oct. 7 — In the last two weeks the Syrian-backed rebels seeking to overthrow Yasir Arafat as the Palestinian guerrilla leader feel they have gained the upper hand. “We have won the first round, and the majority of the civilian and military cadres in Al Fatah are now on our side,” the leader of the rebels, Col.
Saed Musa, said at a news conference today in Baalbek in the Bekaa, Lebanon’s eastern valley. “We are now able to direct the battle, and Yasir Arafat can only make statements detrimental to the Palestinian cause,” Colonel Musa said.
Yasir Arafat, leader of the Palestine Liberation Organization, at a refugee camp Thursday near Tripoli, Lebanon.
BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — Syrian-backed Palestinians, using heavy artillery and tanks, launched a major offensive today against the northern strongholds of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, Lebanese and Palestinian reports from the scene said.
Exploding artillery shells touched off a fire at the region's only oil refinery on the outskirts of Tripoli, 42 miles north of Beirut, and shells falling directly into the city killed at least four civilians, Beirut radio said. The Palestinian camps outside Tripoli are Arafat's last stronghold after his loss of bases in the Bekaa Valley to his Syrian-backed opponents.
His northern headquarters are based at Baddawi. The Palestinian news agency WAFA said Syrian artillery gunners joined in the barrage that began escalating after 5:30 a.m. (10:30 p.m. EST Wednesday).
Beirut Radio said the troubled mountains east of Beirut were quiet today after a night of artillery and machine-gun exchanges between army troops of Lebanon's Christian-led government and Druze Moslem rebels despite the country's Sept. 26 cease-fire. Fighting also subsided in the capital.
The Lebanese leaders meeting in Geneva, Switzerland, were reported to have called their Christian and Moslem field commanders to try to silence the guns Wednesday before the outbreak threatened to scuttle national reconciliation talks.
Leaders of Lebanon's feuding factions agreed Wednesday on a basic Arab identity for their country but remained deadlocked on the crucial issue of relations with Israel.
Christian and Moslem leaders planned to resume talks today on what has become the central issue of the conference — the future of the May 17 troop withdrawal agreement between Israel and Lebanese President Amin Gemayel's Christian-led government.
BEIRUT, Lebanon — The Palestinians flow back and forth across the borders of the Middle East, an elite whose longing for a homeland will long outlast Yasser Arafat and the Palestine Liberation Organization.
For the guerrilla movement is only a fraction of the Palestinians — 4 million people who have risen… and the Arab world’s highest level… positions throughout the Middle East…
Anchorage, 1983. Homeland is the word, and it is used plainly: they are longing for one, which means they had one. The rest of the sentence is about morale, so what the headline finally reports is a feeling rather than a claim — but the noun underneath it does the work.
Education more than anything else distinguishes Palestinians
“Education more than anything else distinguishes Palestinians. Already the best-educated Arabs before what they call ‘al nakba’ — the disaster — the Palestinians since 1948 have placed such priority on education that they now may have a higher percentage of their population in universities than Israel does.”
The earliest use of the word in this archive. It arrives already quarantined: quotation marks, a translation, and "what they call."
A report issued yesterday said that it had found “pervasive” censorship of Arab publications in the occupied West Bank that “mirrors the larger struggle between Palestinians and Israelis.” The 167-page study was commissioned by the Fund for Free Expression, a New York-based affiliate of the Helsinki Watch and America's Watch, groups that monitor civil liberties.
The author of the report is Dr. Meron Benvinisti, a former Deputy Mayor of Jerusalem who is also an activist in the Israeli peace movement. According to the report, Israeli censors do not merely suppress “supposed national security secrets.”
“Rather,” it says, “the primary concern is to eradicate expression that could foster Palestinian nationalist feelings, or suggests that Palestinians are a nation with a national heritage.” The study said all materials must be submitted to the censors, including photos, advertisements and crossword puzzles.
The report said that of 1,077 English-language items by one newspaper last year, 367 were suppressed and 214 more where partly censored. A spokesman for the Israeli Embassy, Victor Harel, a press counsellor, said he had not seen the report and could not comment until he did.
David K. Shipler, New York Times News Service, Dheisheh Refugee Camp, Israeli-Occupied West Bank
“Her name is Amal Abu al-Jamiyya. Amal means hope. She has never seen a Jew without a gun… ‘Because I don’t know her,’ Amal declared, ‘and she doesn’t know me.’ … She never told him about having been in Auschwitz. Later, when her colleague asked why, she said, ‘It would have been unfair.
He was behind bars, and I was free.’”
An eleven-year-old is named, aged, described and quoted at length, which this archive has very little of. The second passage is Cordelia Edvardson of Svenska Dagbladet, a survivor of Auschwitz, interviewing the PLO officer Salah Taamri about whether the Ansar prison camp was Auschwitz, and withholding the one fact that would have ended the conversation. The headline the paper put on the reporting is Cultural-hatred roots run deep, over a story whose own first sentences say the camp has been under military occupation since six years before the child in it was born. The story’s dateline says Israeli-Occupied West Bank; the AP photograph beside it is captioned Hebron, West Bank.
“There is a strong feeling of neglect, that no one is maintaining a dialogue with us, that we receive unequal service…”
Yitzhak Shamir meets a delegation of Israel’s Arab citizens, who tell him they are not spoken to. The quotation is given without a name attached to it.
Bedouin Herdsmen Arrested In Negev Stabbing Incident
TEL AVIV, Jan. 16 — Israeli Bedouins stabbed and stoned Government rangers in the Negev Sunday, the nature reserve authority reported today. A spokesman for the authority said one ranger was hospitalized and two Bedouin herdsmen were arrested.
She said two rangers patrolling the Negev on Sunday morning saw a herd of goats and sheep grazing on an army training range near the desert town of Arad. No herdsman was in sight and the rangers prepared to herd the animals out of the area, which is restricted. Suddenly a shower of rocks smashed the windshield of their jeep, the spokesman said.
One ranger chased the rock thrower, who, when overtaken, drew a knife and stabbed his pursuer in the leg. The second ranger, who remained in the jeep, was hit on the head by a rock thrown by the second Bedouin. The Israelis drove to Arad and reported to the police, who returned to the scene and made the arrests. The Bedouin owner of the herd was summoned to remove the animals.
Date check: No masthead or page date line survives — the clipping is trimmed to the two-line headline and five paragraphs, with rules above and below. The only internal date is the dateline, “TEL AVIV, Jan. 16”, consistent with a January 17, 1984 paper, but the date and the paper could not be confirmed from the page.
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Israeli border police firing their weapons to disperse Palestinian demonstrators killed one youth and and wounded two others Saturday in the West Bank town of Nablus, a military spokesman said. The Palestine Press Service said 2,000 protesters marched through Nablus after Nasser Sarisi, 17, was killed, chanting in English and Arabic: “PLO!
Israel no!” and “No to the occupation!” According to the Israeli command, the border police were attacked by scores of rock-throwing youths shouting support for the Palestine Liberation Organization. It said the police shot into the air to disperse the crowd, but when the attacks continued they fired at the demonstrators’ feet.
It made no mention of police casualties, but the Palestine Press Service said one officer was injured. The military command’s report on the Nablus shootings said Sarisi died in a hospital and the two other youths were treated for leg wounds. There did not appear to be any particular event that sparked the Nablus demonstration.
It was the first fatality in a West Bank demonstration this year, although a Palestinian was shot and killed earlier this month during a car chase after he passed a military roadblock.
The order of the headline is the finding: the police are stoned first and the Palestinian is killed second, without anyone killing him. The copy underneath does name who fired, and it names the dead youth — Nasser Sarisi, 17 — and it uses a Palestinian source, the Palestine Press Service, alongside the Israeli command, on points where the two do not agree.
TEL AVIV, Israel — A radical Zionist group has claimed responsibility for attacking a bus in the occupied West Bank and wounding seven Palestinian construction workers, government radio stations reported today.
Interior Minister Yosef Burg said today in an Army Radio interview that police “would spare no labor or energy to find those guilty” of the shooting early Sunday near the city of Ramallah. The bus was hired by the village of Mazraa Sharqiyeh to take workers to Jerusalem, 14 miles to the south, to seek construction jobs every day.
RAMALLAH, Occupied West Wank (AP) — Gunmen opened fire at dawn yesterday on a bus carrying Palestinian construction workers, injuring seven, Israeli military sources and hospital officials said.
The Palestine Press Service in Jerusalem, a Palestinian-run agency, said the bus was attacked by a group of Jewish settlers, but there was no immediate confirmation of the report. Israel Radio reported that police with tracker dogs searched the area near the Palestinian village of Mazraa Sharqiyeh about 10 miles north of Ramallah and found 20 spent cartridges.
A mobile crime laboratory was sent to the scene, the broadcast said. Buses travel near some of the new towns settled by Israeli Jews on the West Bank. But the Palestine Press Service was the only source that blamed the attack on settlers. “About 25 of us were on our way to work in Jerusalem,” said Rawdi Hamed Fayez al-Hijazi from his bed at Ramallah Hospital.
“We were going down a hill and I saw three men standing beside the road. It was too foggy to see them clearly, but they started shooting at us.” The bus Hijazi and the others were riding was hired by the village of Mazraa Sharqiyeh to take them to Jerusalem, 14 miles to the south, to seek construction jobs every day.
Doctors said two seriously injured men were transferred to hospitals in Jerusalem, three men were treated for gunshot wounds and released, and Hijazi and another man were being treated in the Ramallah hospital. There has been a series of violent episodes in the past few months in Jerusalem and the West Bank, which Israel took from Jordan in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war.
Last Tuesday, two Soviet-made hand grenades exploded in the entrance of a Jewish-owned shop in Jerusalem, injuring 17 Israelis, three Palestinians and a Lebanese. A Marxist faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization claimed responsibility. On Jan.
26, police discovered a cache of explosives near Jerusalem’s holiest Moslem shrine, the Dome of the Rock and Al-Aqsa Mosque. The news prompted demonstrations on the West Bank, including one in Nablus in which a Palestinian youth was shot and killed by Israeli border police. On Dec.
6, a bomb exploded on a Jerusalem bus in the city’s Jewish area, killing six people and injuring about 40 others. The PLO claimed responsibility.
RAMALLAH, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Gunmen opened fire at dawn Sunday on a bus carrying Arab construction workers, injuring seven, Israeli military sources and hospital officials said. Israel Radio reported that police with tracker dogs searched the area near the Arab village of Mazraa Sharqiyeh about 10 miles north of Ramallah and found 20 spent cartridges.
A mobile crime lab was sent to the scene, the broadcast said. The bus’ route takes it near some of the new towns settled by Israeli Jews on the West Bank. But the Arab-operated Palestine Press Service was the only source which blamed the attack on settlers.
“About 25 of us were on our way to work in Jerusalem,” said Rawdi Hamed Fayez al-Hijazi from his bed at Ramallah Hospital. “We were going down a hill and I saw three men standing beside the road. It was too foggy to see them clearly, but they started shooting at us.”
The bus Hijazi and the others were riding was hired by the village of Mazraa Sharqiyeh to take them to Jerusalem, 14 miles to the south, to seek construction jobs every day.
Doctors said two seriously injured men were transferred to hospitals in Jerusalem, three men were treated for gunshot wounds and released, and Hijazi and another man were being treated in the Ramallah hospital. There has been a series of violent episodes in the past few months in Jerusalem and the West Bank, which Israel took from Jordan in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war.
Last Tuesday, two Soviet-made hand grenades exploded in the entrance of a Jewish-owned shop in Jerusalem, injuring 17 Israelis, three Palestinians and a Lebanese. A Marxist faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization claimed responsibility. On Jan.
26, police discovered a cache of explosives near Jerusalem’s holiest Moslem shrine, the Dome of the Rock and Al-Aqsa Mosque. The news prompted demonstrations on the West Bank, including one in Nablus in which a Palestinian youth was shot and killed by Israeli border police. On Dec.
6, a bomb exploded on a Jerusalem bus in the city’s Jewish area, killing six people and injuring about 40 others. The PLO claimed responsibility.
Six Arabs were wounded when gunmen fired Sunday at this bus near Ramallah on the West Bank of the Jordan River.
6 Arabs Wounded in West Bank When Gunmen Open Fire on Bus
By DAVID K. SHIPLER, Special to The New York Times
JERUSALEM, March 4 — At least six Arabs were wounded today when three or four masked gunmen opened fire with automatic weapons at a crowded bus traveling along a narrow road in the Israeli-occupied West Bank. Shell casings from American-made M-16 and Israeli-made Galil rifles were found at the scene, an Israeli Army spokesman said.
In Jerusalem, a hand grenade exploded outside the Hospice, the Old City’s only hospital, which serves Arabs. No injuries were reported. Two hand grenades were detonated outside a clothing store in Jewish West Jerusalem last week, wounding 21 people.
Today’s assaults were the latest in a series of attacks on Arabs that have led to official concern about the possibility that Jewish terrorists are operating in the West Bank. Last July, three or four masked men ran into the Islamic College in the West Bank city of Hebron, threw a hand grenade and fired automatic weapons, killing 3 Arabs and wounding 33.
Nobody has been arrested. 14 Grenades Found From December through February, 14 grenades were found rigged near the entrances of churches, mosques and Arab houses. On Jan. 27 Moslem guards foiled an attempt by intruders to plant explosives at the holiest Moslem shrines in Jerusalem, the Dome of the Rock and Al Aksa Mosque. There have been no arrests.
The grenade incidents against Arabs were followed by telephone calls to news organizations claiming that a group called Terror Against Terror was responsible. The caller, a man, usually described the actions as revenge for attacks on Jews. Today’s ambush on the bus came at about 6:30 A.M., an hour at which many West Bank residents head for work.
According to the Palestine Press Service, a group of Arab journalists, the bus was jammed with men from the village of El Mizrah El Sharqia, near Ramallah, north of Jerusalem. It was traveling on a winding road through the hills, near a military base and the Jewish settlement of Ofra, when three or four masked men opened fire from both sides of the road.
The driver barely prevented the bus from going into a ravine. The army spokesman put the number of wounded at six, but Palestine Press named seven wounded, from ages 22 to 63, and said three were in critical condition. They were taken to Ramallah Hospital, where one man’s arm was amputated, and two others were being treated for head wounds. Dr.
Abdel Rachim said the hospital had been ordered by the Israeli military government to say nothing publicly about the matter.
EDITOR'S NOTE — The following story was submitted to the Israeli military censor, who ordered significant material deleted. ISRAELI-OCCUPIED GAZA STRIP (AP) — Arab guerrillas hijacked a bus carrying more than 30 Israelis and sped toward the Egyptian border, but Israeli troops stopped it short of the frontier and stormed aboard early Friday, a military spokesman reported.
“There was a storming and I cannot tell you as yet who is alive and who is dead,” the spokesman said in Tel Aviv. Other sources said two hijackers were killed. Sources and witnesses reported that Israeli soldiers shot out the tires of the bus and punctured the fuel tank, then surrounded the immobilized vehicle.
They said several people were wounded and others were held hostage on the bus by three or four armed guerrillas. The hijackers seized the bus at about 7:30 p.m. after it had left Ashdod on its run from Tel Aviv to the Mediterranean port of Ashkelon.
Fire from the troops stopped the bus, which seats 42 people and left Tel Aviv nearly full, near the Palestinian refugee camp of Dir el Balah, 10 miles north of the Egyptian border, Israeli sources said. Some passengers fled through an open door when the bus was halted, the sources said, and two others — including a pregnant woman — were freed later.
Israeli reporters on the scene and other reliable sources said the bus was parked on a side road near the Dir el Balah camp, between Rafah and Gaza City, about 50 miles south of Tel Aviv. Military sources said the Arabs apparently boarded the bus as paying passengers, then pulled weapons and forced the driver to take it to the border.
The British Broadcasting Corp. said 41 people were aboard when the hijackers took over. It said seven passengers escaped when the bus was stopped and surrounded by Israeli troops, but five of them were wounded. NBC radio said the hijackers then demanded the release of 500 prisoners held in Israeli jails and free passage to Egypt for themselves.
Israeli soldiers and border police patrolled the roads and set up numerous roadblocks in the Gaza Strip, which Israel captured from Egypt in the 1967 Middle East war.
Meir Naim, who works in a restaurant in a gas station 12 miles north of Ashkelon, said a young woman came in trembling between 7:30 p.m. and 8 p.m., said she had been on the bus from Tel Aviv to Ashkelon and got off because “four suspicious-looking Arabs got on.” He said a man came in soon after and told a similar story.
Naim said he then reported to police that something might be wrong. The Israeli military censor blacked out coverage of the hijacking for several hours, but rumors of it spread nonetheless. On April 2, three Palestinian guerrillas threw grenades and fired automatic weapons at random on Jerusalem's main street, wounding 48 people.
EDITOR'S NOTE: The following story was submitted to the Israeli military censor who ordered deletion of some material. DIR AL BALAH, Occupied Gaza Strip (AP) — Israeli troops today stormed a hijacked bus, freed about two dozen passengers and killed the four Arab terrorists who had threatened them with a bomb during a 10-hour ordeal.
A woman passenger also was killed in a fierce pre-dawn assault on the bus that lasted only seconds, the military said. It identified her as an Israeli soldier who had been traveling on the bus. Seven other passengers were wounded, military officials said. The military today confirmed reports by army radio and Israel radio that all four hijackers were killed.
Earlier in the day, a military communique said two hijackers were killed and two were captured. The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a Marxist wing of the Palestine Liberation Organization, issued a statement in Damascus, Syria, claiming responsibility for the attack.
“The forthcoming days will see a number of spectacular operations in the occupied territories,” it added. The red-and-white bus, carrying 35 passengers, was hijacked near the Mediterranean coast city of Ashod by the four men who got on as paying passengers and then pulled their weapons and ordered the driver to head toward the Egyptian border.
The bus was disabled 10 miles north of the border by army sharpshooters who shot the tires out, and about nine passengers escaped, the military said.
From there, authorities negotiated for hours with the terrorists, who demanded the release of 500 guerrillas held in Israeli jails and safe passage to Egypt for themselves, said Defense Minister Moshe Arens, who watched the rescue mission from the scene.
“They had a bomb they threatened to explode, but we managed to take control before they had a chance to detonate it,” Arens told Israel radio. The hijackers also were armed with bottles of acid, knives and a grenade, officials said. Passenger Esther Ziv said one threatened repeatedly to kill everyone aboard. “We will kill all of you on the bus. We are starting to fight today.
Everyone on the bus will die,” Ms. Ziv quoted the hijacker as saying. “One of the terrorists took an attache case, opened it ... and said, ‘Don't anybody move or I'll blow up the bus,’” said passenger Yosef Stivi, who escaped from the bus before the final assault.
He said two of the hijackers were “very young, about 17 or 18,” another was a little older and the one carrying the attache case appeared about 26. “He was the most dangerous one. He was a real fanatic,” Stivl said. “He gave instructions to hit anyone who moved ... Most of the passengers simply sat there in shock.” The troops stormed aboard the bus just before dawn.
“I heard a tremendous burst of gunfire. I said to myself ‘This is it,’” an unidentified passenger told Israeli radio. “I immediately lay on the floor. Someone fell on top of me,” he said. Soldiers told the passengers to stay on the floor “until they know what's going on around us.”
“There were shots, lots of them, for about 15 seconds and then it was all over,” said Associated Press photographer Max Nash, who was 250 yards from the bus when it was stormed. The hijackers seized the bus Thursday evening after it left Ashdod on its run from Tel Aviv to the port of Ashkelon.
The bus broke through two roadblocks before sharpshooters stopped it near the Palestinian refugee camp of Dir el Balah, about 50 miles south of Tel Aviv in the territory captured from Egypt in the 1967 Middle East war. A pregnant woman who became hysterical was released from the bus south of Ashdod, and about nine passengers escaped when the bus stopped, the military said.
Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir announced on Israeli radio that the rescue operation had ended successfully with the release of all passengers, and said it proved terrorists had no chance of “imposing their will on us and escaping unpunished.”
“Apparently they are making a desperate effort, after their terrorist front in Lebanon was destroyed” by Israel's 1982 invasion, Shamir said. “We will prevent them. We will strike them before they reach us.” The Israeli military censor initially blacked out all coverage of the hijacking for several hours, but rumors of it spread nonetheless.
The bus hijacking was the first incident of hostages being taken in Israel since March 12, 1978, when a dozen Palestinian guerrillas landed in northern Israel in rubber dinghies. They seized two buses filled with Israeli sightseers near Kibbutz Maagan Michael, 37 miles north of Tel Aviv.
The guerrillas forced the occupants into a single bus and drove down the coast toward Tel Aviv. A shootout with Israeli forces at a highway junction just north of the city left 35 Israelis and nine guerrillas dead.
JERUSALEM — Israeli officials Friday threatened retaliation against Palestinian terrorists for a bus hijacking that ended with a lightning raid by Israeli soldiers, leaving a hostage and four guerrillas dead. Seven Israelis were injured when the soldiers stormed the bus after a 10-hour standoff with guerrillas holding 34 passengers and the driver hostage.
The hijacking appeared to signal a new phase of escalated terrorism against Israel. “Now that they have lost their base in Lebanon, the terrorists seem to have resorted to the (hit-and-run) tactics of the ’70s,” Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir said. The prime minister said that Israel “would know how to deal with the terrorists.”
All of the Israeli victims, including a 19-year-old female Israeli soldier who was a passenger on the bus, apparently were hit by Israeli gunfire in the military assault on the bus in the occupied Gaza Strip. The four terrorists were killed in the rescue, which took only seconds. “It was such an ordeal,” said a soldier who was part of the assault team.
“I am not happy with what has happened, but I did what I had to do. I pointed my gun at one of them through the bus window and shot him dead.” The Syria-based Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine claimed responsibility for the hijacking. The hijacking was the latest in a recent rash of guerrilla operations inside Israel.
It came 10 days after three terrorists opened fire with automatic weapons and grenades on a Jerusalem intersection, wounding 48 people. On March 8, three people were killed and nine wounded when a grenade exploded on a bus in Ashdod. In New York, Israeli Ambassador Yehuda Blum informed the president of the United Nations Security Council about the bus hijacking.
“The United Nations has not only failed to discharge its responsibilities in combating international terrorism,” Blum said in a letter, “it has, in fact, encouraged this despicable phenomenon by granting privileges within the organization to the terrorist PLO, in clear violation of the Charter of the United Nations.”
Medics treat one of 35 hostages held on bus before Israelis ended siege
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
Tel Aviv, Israel (AP) — The hijack of a busload of Israelis, 10 days after a grenade attack on Jerusalem shoppers, has added weight to the nation’s fears of a renewed Palestinian terrorist campaign. The dark days of the 1970s, when the Palestine Liberation Organization struck again and again, seem closer to many people in this nation.
“The terror acts recently are increasing,” Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir said after Israeli commandos stormed the bus and rescued 24 hostages from their 10-hour ordeal. The four terrorists were killed and one Israeli woman — a soldier who was a passenger on the bus — also died in the shooting. Seven were wounded.
“They are probably making a desperate effort to renew their activity after the terror arena of Lebanon was pulled from under their feet,” Shamir said. The hijacking marked the first time hostages had been taken inside Israel since the Israeli army invaded Lebanon in 1982 and forced the PLO out of its old power bases in Lebanon and Beirut.
Many Israelis had feared that after last year’s Syrian-backed rebellion against PLO chairman Yasser Arafat, the PLO once again would turn to attacks on Israelis abroad and at home.
“The terror organizations are trying with all their might, and unfortunately with no small success, to prove that despite being vanquished in Lebanon, they are still willing and able to strike,” the daily newspaper Yediot Ahronot said in a front-page analysis Friday.
In a little more than four months, seven people have been killed and 120 wounded in four attacks inside Israel. Most of the casualties were Israelis, and a few were foreign tourists. In each case, a PLO faction claimed responsibility.
Arab editors say tension sharpens censor's scissors
By Michael Widlanski
This story was censored by Israeli authorities. JERUSALEM — Every day Arab newspapers in East Jerusalem prepare editions much larger than anything they intend to publish. According to the Arab journalists, there is only one reason: the Israeli army censor, who reduces the size of their editions considerably and for no extra charge.
The amount of material banned by the Israeli army censor's office — staffed by young Israelis, all of whom have at least a master's degree in Arabic literature — depends on the newspaper, the subject being covered and whether the situation is tense in the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
If there is tension, such as during the height of Israel's war in Lebanon or during a wave of Palestinian protest, the censor's scissors are sharper, and the Arab editors give vent to their frustration: “If you want to know the news, watch Israeli television,” read the headline in the relatively moderate pro-Jordanian daily Al-Quds (Jerusalem) during the peak of Israeli operations in Lebanon in June 1982.
One editor at the paper said that during that period 70 percent to 80 percent of the material submitted to the Israeli censor was banned.
During less tense periods, however, Al-Quds' editor said relatively little was deleted, although more militant papers such as Al-Fajr (The Dawn) and Al-Awda (The Return) reported that 10 percent to 30 percent of their papers' material was banned even during tranquil periods, including obituaries, crossword puzzles and material already published in Israeli newspapers.
‘Inflammatory’ articles stricken A senior Israeli officer familiar with the details of Israeli censorship policy explained that censors monitor the Arab press to prevent the publication of articles that could present a danger to Israeli security, such as “inflammatory” articles that might incite Arab youths to resist Israeli military rule in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
An authoritative Israeli source denied that Israel censors articles that have previously been printed in the Israeli press unless the articles were altered by the Arab newspapers in such a way as to make them a form of “incitement.”
He offered several examples to prove his point — articles or pictures published in the Israeli press account of activities of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) with altered captions or wording that presented favorable descriptions of PLO acts.
An examination of four Arab newspapers' censorship files, however, showed that many articles were not changed significantly, if at all.
Sometimes, the Arab editors asserted, they have been prevented from publishing material that has already appeared on the Arabic language broadcast of Israeli state radio and television and even more frequently on the Israeli television's main Hebrew language broadcast.
“If we ask the chief censor about it [the articles in Israeli newspapers], he says it wasn't meant for us,” said Mahmoud Abu-Zalef editor-in-chief of Al-Quds. “If we say it was published by Israeli radio or television in Arabic, they say, ‘It's none of your business,’” said Abu-Zalef.
Some papers ignore censors Some of the more militant Arab papers have refused to submit all their copy to the Israeli censor for fear that significant articles would be deleted by the censor's blue pencil.
Hanna Siniora, the editor of Al-Fajr, published surveys of the West Bank's support for PLO leader Yasser Arafat last month without submitting the article to the Israeli censor because, he said, the censor would have banned the article.
Photograph Raises Questions About Fate of Bus Hijacker
Editor’s Note: The following dispatch was submitted to the Israeli military censor, who ordered several changes. TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — A news photograph of a man, apparently unhurt, who was being led away in handcuffs from the scene of last week’s bus hijacking has raised questions about the circumstances of the death of one hijacker.
The official version given by Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir and an Israeli military spokesman was that two terrorists were killed outright when Israeli troops stormed the bus early Friday and two others died of wounds on their way to a hospital.
But unpublished photographs show one, and possibly two, men who were obviously alive and uninjured being led from the scene after the raid had freed two dozen hostages.
One Israeli hostage, 19-year-old woman soldier Irit Portugues, was killed and seven were wounded during the 10-hour drama that began Thursday night on the coastal highway between Ashdod and the Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip.
Photographers who boarded the bus shortly after the hostages were freed reported seeing two dead hijackers — one in the driver’s seat, a second in the rear of the bus. A civilian medical worker at the scene told an Associated Press reporter a third hijacker was severely wounded, but he could not account for the fourth.
Initial army statements on Friday said two hijackers were killed and two captured. Later that day it was announced all four hijackers had been killed. Shamir, asked about the apparent discrepancy, said in an interview published Monday that “when they were captured, two of them were severely wounded and afterwards died of their wounds.”
Alex Levac, a photographer for the daily Hadashot newspaper, said he took a picture of a man who seemed to be a suspect about two minutes after the bus was stormed.The picture, seen by an AP reporter, shows a dark complexioned man with curly hair in handcuffs walking between two plainclothes security men.
AP photographer Max Nash, who witnessed the rescue raid, said he saw a man in custody at the scene, his hands tied behind his back and his feet shackled. The Israeli weekly magazine Koterct Rashit said three other Israeli photographers took pictures of a man being forcibly led to interrogation.
“There is considerable doubt if we are talking about the same man photographed by Hadashot,” the magazine said. None of the pictures was approved by the Israeli military censor for publication.
One of the three Israeli photographers, Shmuel Rahmani of the daily Maariv, said he took a full length photo of a man with his head down walking between Israeli army soldiers and a crowd in the background. His shirt and pants were stained, but it was not possible to say for certain if the photo was of the same man in the Hadashot picture.
Yossi Klein, editor of Hadashot, told the AP one of his reporters showed the picture taken by Levac to relatives and friends of a man identified as one of the hijackers — Majid Ahmed Abu Jama, 18, of Bani Sohella in the Gaza Strip. He said they positively identified the photograph as that of Abu Jama.
“Our reporter asked them who was shown in the picture, not if it was Abu Jama,” Klein said. A headshot a friend of Abu Jama provided to Hadashot appeared to be one taken a year or two earlier, but with the same distinctive nose and curly brown hair.
The New York Times quoted Abu Jama’s mother Fatima as confirming the picture of the man being led away from the hijack scene was that of her son. But Klein said he also showed the photo of the man being led away to four of the 35 hostages, including the bus driver, and none could identify him.
The Jerusalem Post quoted an army spokesman as saying that photographs of people being led away from the scene were probably pictures of Arab passengers who were not involved in the hijacking. Commenting on the conflicting reports, the daily Haaretz newspaper, said in an editorial that “terrorists who are not killed in clashes with our security forces should be put on trial.
We do not recognize terrorists as soldiers ... but this non-recognition doesn’t justify executing them after battle.”
Print, This One Not Banned by Government, Shows Man Being Led From Bus
By DAVID K. SHIPLER
JERUSALEM, April 25 — A leftist Israeli magazine, Haolam Hazeh, today became the first news organization here to publish a photograph of a man being led away alive from the hijacked bus in the Gaza Strip two weeks ago. The photograph is of extremely poor quality, too blurry for the faces to be identified.
It is a different picture, apparently showing a different man, from a key photograph taken by another publication, the newspaper Hadashot. The military censor has barred publication of the other, clearer photograph. Both photographs were taken after Israeli troops stormed the hijacked bus just before dawn on April 13.
The authorities said two hijackers were killed and the other two died on the way to the hospital. The barred Hadashot picture clearly shows a handcuffed man who has been identified by relatives and neighbors in the Gaza Strip as Majdi Abu-Jumaa, one of the four hijackers. No wounds are visible in the photograph.
The picture has led to questions in Israel about the possibility that one of the terrorists was killed by security forces after being captured. By contrast, the man in the photograph published today in Haolam Hazeh has not been identified. He is shown between groups of soldiers who appear to be holding or dragging him.
His head is bent forward and it cannot be determined whether he is wounded. At least two other Israeli photographers are understood to have photographed this unidentified man. One of them, Shmuel Rachmani, of the newspaper Maariv, said his picture, taken from the front, was of excellent quality and could easily be used to identify the man.
Israel Warns Correspondent JERUSALEM, April 25 (UPI) — The Israeli authorities complained to The New York Times correspondent in Israel Tuesday that he had violated military censorship in his coverage of a bus hijacking by Palestinian guerrillas. An announcement from the Government Press Office said that David K.
Shipler, bureau chief of The New York Times in Jerusalem, met with Morton Dolinsky, director of the Government office, at Mr. Dolinsky’s request. Mr. Shipler has reported growing indications that one of the hijackers was captured alive and then killed. The announcement said Mr.
Shipler “was informed that he had been in violation of military censorship, and the rules of censorship were reviewed with him.”
Israelis place spies in terror groups to stop attacks on Arabs
JERUSALEM — Stung by complaints of police laxity in combating violence by Jews against Arabs, Israel’s security forces have launched a tough new campaign against Jewish terrorism, apparently including infiltration of spies into radical nationalistic organizations headquartered in the occupied West Bank.
A senior official, talking to reporters after Sunday’s regular meeting of the Cabinet, said the government recently made a “difficult decision” to employ against Jewish terrorism some of the same methods that traditionally have been used to combat Arab terrorism.
The official, who did not wish to be identified, said the program paid off when police foiled a sophisticated plan to bomb Arab buses when they would have been jammed with passengers returning from Friday mosque services. Police have provided only sketchy details of the case, but it is now known that about 35 persons, all of them Jewish, have been arrested so far.
Most were residents of Jewish settlements in the occupied West Bank of the Jordan River or the annexed Golan Heights, although some came from communities inside Israel’s pre-1967 borders. Police rounded up about 15 of the suspects Sunday in the second wave of arrests. Most of the rest had been arrested Friday, although the case was kept secret until Saturday.
Several of the suspects appeared in court Sunday and were ordered held in jail for 15 days to provide time for a complete investigation. The court refused to permit publication of the names of the suspects or of any information that could identify them.
However, Israeli press, radio and television reports said those arrested included several prominent West Bank citizens including some active in the Gush Emunim organization, which sponsors Jewish settlement of the occupied territories. The Davar newspaper said police acted on the basis of information from a secret agent working inside the organization that planned the attack.
Security sources declined to confirm the report although all of the circumstantial evidence seemed to point in that direction. Police were clearly acting on the basis of detailed and accurate intelligence when they located and disarmed powerful bombs planted on widely scattered Arab buses Friday morning.
It is unlikely that such information could have been obtained without the use of spies. Israeli civil rights leaders have complained for years that law enforcement authorities were not effective in preventing attacks by Jews against Arabs because they were reluctant to insert agents into nationalistic organizations.
In contrast, the police and the army both are known to have penetrated most Palestinian groups.
JERUSALEM, April 29 — Israel's Supreme Court ruled today that the military censor had the right to close an Israeli newspaper's printing plant for four days after the editors published information without prior submission to censorship.
The case arose amid efforts by the Government of Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir to suppress news about the unexplained deaths of two of four Arabs who hijacked an Israeli bus with 35 passengers aboard on April 12. The newspaper, Hadashot, published a brief article Friday reporting that a commission of inquiry into the deaths had been established by Defense Minister Moshe Arens.
Mr. Arens acted after evidence, gathered principally by Hadashot, was made public indicating that at least one of the hijackers had been captured alive and killed later after Israeli troops stormed the bus. During the assault, an Israeli woman was killed and seven other passengers were wounded.
Two hijackers were also killed on the spot, but the circumstances surrounding the deaths of the other two are unclear. Publication of Photo Barred The key piece of evidence is a photo taken by a Hadashot photographer of a man being led away by two security agents after the assault.
The censor barred publication of the picture, but one of the newspaper's reporters took it to the Gaza Strip, where relatives and neighbors easily identified the man as Majdi Abu-Jumaa, who had been named by the army as one of the hijackers. His body was seen by his uncle and a neighbor when all four hijackers were buried.
Hadashot is an afternoon tabloid that began publication two months ago and has a circulation of about 50,000. It is owned by the Schocken family, which also owns Haaretz, a lively morning paper that takes a sharply critical line on the Shamir Government. The editors of Hadashot have observed the censor's ban on publishing the photograph.
But because of the paper's aggressiveness in pursuing the story and in sharing its information with foreign news organizations, the impression prevails that the Government is now bent on driving it into oblivion. Yossi Klein, the paper's editor, said he had been told about the establishment of the inquiry commission by Nachman Shai, the spokesman for Defense Minister Arens.
Mr. Shai asked him to delay publication, he said, arguing that the commission's findings would be made public soon. A similar request was made by Mr. Arens of other Israeli editors at a meeting last week. Censor's Jurisdiction Questioned Mr. Klein said he did not feel the item fell under the censor's jurisdiction and he published it without prior submission.
As a result, the same authorities that provided the information then punished the paper for printing it. The censor, an army general, is subordinate to the Defense Minister; after consulting with Mr. Arens the censor ordered the paper's printing plant closed for four days.
As with most complicated issues, it is easy to allow hyperbole to gloss over and distort the truth. A recent column published on April 24 on this page of the Star-Telegram concerning Palestinian academic freedom is one that fits in that category and does little to further the cause of understanding the problem.
Since 1967, the West Bank and Gaza have flourished economically under Israeli rule. More of its people vote, and women are no longer second-class citizens. Its citizens elect town councils and mayors.
Travel in and out of the West Bank to Israel and Jordan is unrestricted, although there are numerous checkpoints in the West Bank as part of Israel’s anti-terrorist campaign.
Israeli military censor puts short halt on major paper with rarely-used clause
EDITOR'S NOTE: The following story was submitted to the Israeli military censor. No changes were made. TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Israel's military censor, using broad powers left from when Palestine was under British control, ordered a major Israeli newspaper to shut down this week for four days. It was a rare display of the full force of the state's censorship authority.
Not since the 1950s had an Israeli newspaper been shut down because of a censorship violation. But frequently in recent days the blue pencil has been taken to press copy, both in Israeli publications and news dispatches by foreign correspondents.
At a foreign press association luncheon this week, Defense Minster Moshe Arens acknowledged the “considerable inconvenience” of having to submit sensitive stories for approval prior to publication. But he defended the need for censorship in light of Israel's perpetual state of war with neighboring Arab states.
“I think it is something that is distasteful to Israelis...But I think there is a general understanding and consensus in Israel that it is essential with the severe dangers Israel is facing,” Arens said. HAARETZ, AN independent daily owned by the same family as the closed tabloid Hadashot, suggested that the decision was political and the censorship excessively severe.
“The government's use, via the chief censor, of archaic emergency measures to shut down the Hadashot newspaper's printing presses is a sorry and dangerous chapter in the annals of government-press relations in Israel,” Haaretz said in an editorial.
The latest tensions between the press and the censor resulted from a controversy surrounding the deaths of Arab terrorists who hijacked a commuter bus April 12. Previous clashes came during Israel's invasion of Lebanon and an exchange of Israeli and Palestinian prisoners last November.
The army said two of the hijackers were killed when the bus was stormed by Israeli troops and that two others died of wounds en route to a hospital.
The official version of events was challenged, however, after photographs that the Israeli censors had banned came to light and showed at least one of the hijackers alive and apparently uninjured in the custody of Israeli security men after the bus was stormed.
Israeli newspapers and magazines, reporting on the growing controversy, appeared with large blocks of white space on their pages where the censor had deleted news and photos. Significant material was also deleted from the dispatches of The Associated Press and other foreign news organizations.
The government did not act, however, until the tabloid Hadashot broke ranks with other Israeli newspapers and published a story that Arens had appointed a respected Israeli general, Meir Zorea, to head an investigation into the deaths of the hijackers.
This story was submitted to the Israeli military censor. No changes were made.) TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Israel's military censor, using broad powers left from when Palestine was under British control, ordered a major Israeli newspaper to shut down this week for four days. It was a rare display of the full force of the state's censorship authority.
Not since the 1950s had an Israeli newspaper been shut down because of a censorship violation. But frequently in recent days the blue pencil has been taken to press copy, both in Israeli publications and news dispatches by foreign correspondents.
At a foreign press association luncheon this week, Defense Minster Moshe Arens acknowledged the “considerable inconvenience” of having to submit sensitive stories for approval prior to publication. But he defended the need for censorship in light of Israel's perpetual state of war with neighboring Arab states.
‘General Consensus’ “I think it is something that is distasteful to Israelis. . . . But I think there is a general understanding and consensus in Israel that it is essential with the severe dangers Israel is facing,” Arens said.
Haaretz, an independent daily owned by the same family as the closed tabloid Hadashot, suggested that the decision was political and the censorship excessively severe.
“The government's use, via the chief censor, of archaic emergency measures to shut down the Hadashot newspaper's printing presses is a sorry and dangerous chapter in the annals of government-press relations in Israel,” Haaretz said in an editorial.
The latest tensions between the press and the censor resulted from a controversy surrounding the deaths of Arab terrorists who hijacked a commuter bus April 12. Previous clashes came during Israel's invasion of Lebanon and an exchange of Israeli and Palestinian prisoners last November.
The army said two of the hijackers were killed when the bus was stormed by Israeli troops and that two others died of wounds en route to a hospital.
Official Version Challenged The official version of events was challenged, however, after photographs that the Israeli censors had banned came to light and showed at least one of the hijackers alive and apparently uninjured in the custody of Israeli security men after the bus was stormed.
BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — Two Syrian-backed factions of the Palestine Liberation Organization vowed new attacks against Israel in retaliation for a raid on a refugee camp in southern Lebanon.
Israeli troops entered the Ain Hilweh Palestinian refugee camp Wednesday to search for guerrillas and arms — the biggest raid on a refugee camp in Lebanon since the 1982 massacre of hundreds of refugees in the Sabra and Chatila camps. The Israeli army said no one was killed in the pre-dawn sweep.
But a Sunni Moslem radio station reported two deaths and the PLO factions said 30 people were killed. The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine and the Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine said in a joint statement Wednesday they would retaliate “for the new massacre of civilians” in the Ain Hilweh refugee camp.
Both groups, which have Marxist leanings, have claimed responsibility for assaults on Israeli targets in the past, including a recent gun and grenade attack in Jerusalem and a bus hijacking south of Tel Aviv. The statement, broadcast by the Kuwaiti News Agency, said 30 people were killed and 150 detained in the raid on the refugee camp.
JERUSALEM, May 13 — The bodies of two Arab terrorists who hijacked an Israeli bus last month have been exhumed for second autopsies, a well-placed Defense Ministry official said today. The new autopsies were ordered by an internal commission appointed by Defense Minister Moshe Arens to investigate the circumstances surrounding their deaths, the official said.
The commission was established after it became known that Israeli photographers had taken pictures of the two hijackers as they were being led away from the bus after an assault by Israeli troops. Two other hijackers were killed during the attack.
From the photographs, the two have been identified by relatives and neighbors in their village in the Gaza Strip as cousins, named Majdi and Subhi Abu-Jumaa. The Israeli military censor has banned publication of the pictures.
Held 35 Passengers Hostage The four terrorists commandeered the bus, which was on its regular run from Tel Aviv south to Ashkelon, held about 35 passengers hostage and forced the driver to speed into the Gaza Strip, where they demanded the release of 500 Palestinian prisoners in exchange for the safety of the hostages.
After a 10-hour standoff, Israeli troops stormed the bus, killing one Israeli woman and two of the hijackers and wounding seven other Israeli passengers. Autopsies were done on at least two of the hijackers, and possibly all four, according to official statements.
But a Defense Ministry official explained that the inquiry commission, headed by a retired general, Meir Zorea, had ordered new autopsies in the search for further details about the causes of death. The photograph of one of the two, Majdi Abu-Jumaa, shows him conscious, apparently alert and without any visible wounds.
His uncle and a neighbor who were allowed to see the body just before burial in a Gaza cemetery said that his head was covered with dried blood. His uncle also described a long incision in the abdomen, usually the sign of an autopsy.
The Defense Ministry official said that the results of the first autopsies were apparently not sufficient for the commission and that more information was required. The secret police, known as the Shin Beth, is understood to have had custody of the two men.
By the accounts of relatives of Palestinian prisoners, they were brought to Gaza Prison after the assault on the bus, but this could not be confirmed. No decision has been made about how much, if any, of the commission’s findings will be made public, especially in view of the fact that the Shin Beth usually operates out of public view.
TEL AVIV, Israel (UPI) — Jewish terrorists confessed to a plot to blow up Islam’s holiest shrines in Jerusalem, the al-Aksa and Dome of the Rock mosques, newspapers said Friday. Al-Aksa is on the Temple Mount where the prophet Mohammed is said to have ascended to heaven.
The Dome of the Rock is believed to be on the site of King Solomon’s first temple and where Abraham prepared to offer his son Issac as a sacrifice to God. Israeli newspapers said the 25 suspects cancelled their plans after it was clear the bombs could not avoid damaging the nearby Western Wall — Judaism’s holiest shrine.
BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — An Israeli army patrol shot and killed a Palestinian woman at a refugee camp in south Lebanon today, then fired on a crowd of women and children protesters, wounding two, a witness reported.
The Palestinian woman was killed and two other people were wounded in Ain Hilweh, the same refugee camp outside the city of Sidon which the Israelis first raided Wednesday. The Israeli army said no one was killed in the predawn sweep Wednesday, but a Sunni Moslem Beirut radio station reported two deaths.
Two Syrian-backed factions of the Palestine Liberation Organization vowed to retaliate. The PLO groups said 30 people were killed in Wednesday’s raid. It was the biggest raid on a refugee camp in Lebanon since the September 1982 massacre of hundreds of refugees in the Sabra and Chatila camps by Israeli-backed Christian militia.
A witness at Ain Hilweh, who declined to be identified, said the Palestinian woman was killed today by Israeli fire. Angered by the incident, 800 Palestinian women and children demonstrated in the camp, but only to be attacked and dispersed by heavy armed Israeli troops. “The Israelis opened fire at the demonstrators and wounded two of them.
The Israelis are now surrounding the camp with tanks and troop carriers,” said the witness. Speaking by telephone from the coastal town of Sidon, some 24 miles south of Beirut, the witness said the Israelis were apparently on a “reconnaissance by fire” mission when their gunfire struck a woman in the head.
“She was carried to a hospital, but died shortly afterward,” he added. “I saw the woman getting shot. The Israeli patrol continued its mission.”
The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine and the Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine said in a joint statement Wednesday they would retaliate “for the new massacre of civilians” in the Ain Hilweh refugee camp.
Demonstrators block street by burning tires in refugee camp of Ain Hilweh
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
· The New York Times · page A1, continued on Page A8, Column 1
ARABS WERE SLAIN BY ISRAELI GUARDS, INQUIRY CONCLUDES
Bus Hijackers, Captured Alive, Were Beaten by Security Men While in Custody
By DAVID K. SHIPLER
JERUSALEM, May 28 — The Defense Ministry announced today that a commission of inquiry had determined that two of the four Arab terrorists who hijacked an Israeli bus last month were captured alive and then killed by security men. The commission said the two terrorists’ skulls had been fractured with blunt objects.
The commission found that no order had been given by superiors that the two be killed. But a criminal investigation will be conducted by the military and civilian police and the State Attorney’s office, the Defense Ministry’s statement said, and disciplinary measures are to be taken against other security personnel.
Arens Condemns Behavior The communiqué declared that Defense Minister Moshe Arens “regards with utmost gravity — and condemns most forcefully — the behavior which led to the deaths of the two terrorists who had been captured on the bus, behavior which is in clear contradistinction to the basic rules and norms incumbent on all and especially on the security forces.
“Not even the special circumstances of this case justify such behavior,” he said. “Therefore, legal action shall be taken, in accordance with the evidence uncovered by the investigation, against those suspected of illegal acts or behavior.” Mr. Arens added, “All possible steps will be taken to insure that there be no recurrence of a similar incident.”
Individuals Not Identified In a radio interview later, Mr. Arens said that the commission was unable to determine who among those who beat the hijackers had delivered the fatal blows and that this would be a subject of the criminal investigations.
Asked if he thought the fate of Israeli soldiers being held by Palestinian factions would be affected, the Defense Minister replied: “It shouldn’t have any effect. Of course, we can’t assume for sure how terrorists will behave. The fact is it hasn’t had any effect until now. It is known that our norms of behavior are completely different from theirs.
A deviation from the norm took place here, but we also carried out the proper measures that are needed in such a situation.” After an all-night standoff, Israeli troops stormed the bus just before dawn April 13, killing an Israeli woman and wounding seven other passengers.
The army’s public statements — that two “died on the way to the hospital” — implied that all four terrorists were killed as a result of the assault. But according to the Defense Ministry, the commission found that only two of them, Jamal Kablan and Mohammed Barakeh, died “at an early stage of the strike force’s assault on the bus, as a result of the attacking force’s gunfire.”
The two others, cousins named Majdi and Subhi Abu-Jumaa, were captured, the commission said. They were apparently beaten two or three times, with the fatal blows coming later. The text of the commission’s report was not released; it was summarized by the Defense Ministry communiqué and was apparently timed to precede Mr.
Arens’s visit this week to the United States, where he could have expected to face uncomfortable questioning about the matter. Initially, the Israeli authorities tried to suppress news of the case by having the military censor ban the publication of news photographs of the two hijackers being led away from the bus. News articles on the subject were also barred by censorship.
Inquiry Commission Appointed But after The New York Times published the details despite the censor’s restrictions, Mr. Arens appointed the inquiry commission, headed by a reserve army general, Meir Zorea, who has a reputation of high integrity in Israel. The censor closed a daily newspaper, Hadashot, for four days because it reported the creation of the commission.
The authorities have been concerned about the repercussions of the case. It has been longstanding Israeli policy not to kill captured terrorists, mainly to induce them to surrender and to avoid situations in which they feel they have nothing to lose by fighting to the death and killing hostages.
In addition, interrogations of prisoners have often yielded rich details on guerrilla cells, lines of support and other such matters useful to the Shin Beth, the Mossad and other Israeli security services. The hijacking began the evening of April 12 as the bus was making a regular run from Tel Aviv south to the Mediterranean town of Ashkelon.
Four Palestinian Arabs forced the driver to continue into the occupied Gaza Strip, where they threatened to blow up the bus with its 35 passengers unless 500 Palestinian prisoners were released from Israeli prisons.
One of two Palestinian hijackers shown last month in custody of Israeli security men, whose faces in photo have been obscured by Israeli censors.
Control of Palestinian Expression Is Invisible Part of Gaza Conflict
The Washington Post
Jabalia Camp, Gaza Strip — In April 1982, Suhain Ghabin, a 7-year-old Palestinian, was shot and killed by Israeli soldiers during a violent demonstration in this squalid refugee camp where he lived. The youth was one of scores of people killed that spring in the disturbances that swept the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip.
But he lived on in the memory of his family, including his uncle, Fathi Ghabin, a locally prominent Palestinian painter. Some time after the incident, Ghabin painted a picture of his slain nephew, Suhain.
It showed the youth lying on his side, blood gushing from a wound in his chest, while in the background a crowd of demonstrators was shown with uplifted arms, a sign of defiance. COLORS OF PLO FLAG. The most prominent colors in the picture — the youth’s green and white sweater, his black trousers, the red blood — are those of the Palestinian flag.
Because of that picture, and seven others he exhibited in the Gaza Strip last summer, Fathi Ghabin is now serving a six-month prison sentence. He was convicted by an Israeli military court earlier this month on charges of possessing and displaying “inciting material.”
“First it is the colors — you have the colors of the PLO flag,” an Israeli military official said in explaining Ghabin’s conviction. “That is considered inciting material because it insinuates the ongoing armed struggle.”
Other symbolism used by Ghabin, he said, included a “broken Star of David,” a picture of an old man with a bleeding boy and billowing smoke (representing the Israeli occupation) in the background and “the use of an eagle with a beak nose as a representative of the Jews.”
Ghabin’s exhibition, the official said, “had a theme with a whole story, about the Israeli occupation, that we (Palestinians) are the oppressed, about the struggle and revenge. The use of colors is to incite for revenge.” “The Western mind won’t understand a lot of this,” the official said. “But inside the paintings there are symbols.
It’s like a puzzle.” ONGOING CONFLICT. They said Ghabin’s case illustrates an often invisible aspect of the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict in the West Bank and Gaza.
It is essentially the conflict between authorities who are intent on maintaining order and those who use the symbols and other expressions of Palestinian nationalism that are thought by the authorities to be disturbing to that order. The conflict goes on in numerous, non-violent ways.
It includes the close, prepublication scrutiny by Israeli military censors of the Arabic-language newspapers that are published in east Jerusalem. Once, one of the newspapers managed to slip past the censor a seemingly routine crossword puzzle in which the blacked-out squares formed the letters PLO — Palestine Liberation Organization.
This spring, in a once abandoned and fire-gutted movie theater in east Jerusalem, a Palestinian theater company has performed a play that is banned in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
But under Israeli law, Arab east Jerusalem has been annexed and is not subject to stringent occupation laws, said Jackie Lubeck, 31, an American-born Jew and the only non-Palestinian member of the El Hakawati Theater Co.
Raising money largely from wealthy Palestinians who live abroad, the theater group invested more than $100,000 in a six-month renovation of the abandoned movie theater, creating “the Hakawati Theater and Art Center of Jerusalem,” Ms. Lubeck said. The company has existed since 1977 and performs often in Israel, the West Bank and Gaza.
But two of the four productions it has created are not licensed for performance in the occupied territories.
One of them, whose English title is “1001 Nights of a Stone Thrower,” includes a character named “Gidi (the mean and rotten),” who is described as a “military governor” and who early in the play is depicted as “enjoying the company of the weapons salesmen and their wares,” according to a synopsis. “NOT ALL POLITICS”.
“They can’t have everybody under lock and key,” said Ms. Lubeck short before the first performance of “1001 Nights of a Stone Thrower” at the Hakawati center. “We are going by the book. We get no PLO money, no black money.” Ms.
Lubeck said the theater company plans to further test the limits of its license to perform the play in Israel by busing people to the east Jerusalem theater from the adjacent West Bank.
She argues that no serious attempt at Palestinian theater could omit references to the Israeli occupation, which has included countless military governors who may or may not resemble the fictional character “Gidi.” “We are creating material about us,” she said. “It’s not all politics. In the play we have a kid who throws a stone.
Well, Palestinian kids play with stones the way American kids play with a ball. Is that political?”
A painter jailed for six months for eight paintings, and an Israeli military official explaining the conviction to an American reporter in terms of color. The picture that did it shows Suhain Ghabin, the painter’s seven-year-old nephew, shot dead at Jabalia in April 1982, lying on his side with blood from a chest wound. The official’s objection is that the boy’s green and white sweater, his black trousers and his blood are the colors of the Palestinian flag. That is considered inciting material because it insinuates the ongoing armed struggle. He then explains how to read a painting: a broken Star of David, an old man with a bleeding boy, an eagle with a beak nose. ‘The Western mind won’t understand a lot of this. But inside the paintings there are symbols. It’s like a puzzle.’ Two other things sit in this story. A censored Arabic newspaper in east Jerusalem once got a crossword past the censor whose blacked-out squares spelled PLO. And Jackie Lubeck of the Hakawati theatre company, asked whether her play is political, answers with the plainest sentence in the archive about what counts as politics when Palestinians do it: Palestinian kids play with stones the way American kids play with a ball. Is that political?
Israeli Censor Ends the Ban On Pictures of 2 Slain Arabs
JERUSALEM, May 29 — The Israeli military censor lifted a ban today on the publication of photographs showing two Arabs being led by security men from a bus they hijacked last month. The ban was ended after an inquiry panel found that the men had been beaten to death after their capture.
The key picture, published in today's edition of the newspaper Hadashot, showed Majdi Abu Jumaa, one of the hijackers, being led by two security men whose faces were blacked out. The picture was the first piece of evidence that not all four hijackers had been killed during an assault on the bus.
A picture of a second hijacker, Subhi Abu Jumaa, was published today by the daily Maariv.
Israeli Politicians Court Long-Ignored Arab Voters
By Thomas L. Friedman
JISR AL-ZARQA, Israel, July 4 — Shimon Peres scans the eyes of the Arab voters in this tiny village, a grave look comes over his face and he asks the crowd in his somber baritone: “Is there anyone here who wants the Likud?” “Noooooooo,” the Israeli Arab audience replies in unison.
It is campaign day in Jisr al-Zarqa, a poor Arab village north of Tel Aviv, and several hundred of its Arab inhabitants have turned up in the central square to hear the Labor Party leader, speaking in Hebrew, try to win their votes.
More than ever before, Jewish politicians are looking to Israel’s 250,000 Arab, Druse and Bedouin voters to get them elected to the next Parliament. Arab voters in Israel have the strength to elect roughly 12 of the 120 members of the Israeli Parliament and in a close election, as this one is expected to be, their choices could be decisive.
“This is the first time that everybody is really going after the Arab vote,” said Shmuel Toledano, one of the Labor Party’s chief coordinators of its Arabic campaign. Here in Jisr al-Zarqa, Mr.
Peres plays the crowd with the efficiency of a neighborhood alderman, peppering his remarks with Arabic greetings, kissing a young Arab girl and reminding the locals about the new school, clinic and soccer field his party had promised, and delivered, since his last visit.
Although a village notable had to whisper to the audience, “Clap, clap” at the proper moments, the reception for Mr. Peres appeared to be genuinely warm. Just in case the soft sell isn’t enough to persuade Israeli Arabs to vote Labor, Mr.
Peres’s party is also distributing pink leaflets bearing a menacing-looking picture of Ariel Sharon with an Arabic reminder that a vote against Labor “will facilitate the return of Sharon to power.” Privately, Labor officials warn Israeli Arab leaders that if Mr. Sharon and the Likud are returned to office, Israeli Arabs will end up being treated as
Shimon Peres, leader of Israel’s Labor Party, campaigning in Daliyat el-Carmel, a Druse village near Haifa.
· estimated · The New York Times · New York · page 32
ISRAEL’S BITTER WEST BANK HARVEST
By Anthony Lewis
IT IS NOT OFTEN THAT A PIECE OF SOcial science research becomes the symbol of a fateful national debate. That has happened in Israel with a report bearing the disarmingly dry title, “The West Bank Data Project.” The author is Meron Benvenisti, former Deputy Mayor of Jerusalem.
Benvenisti and a team of researchers dug out for the first time the basic facts of life in the West Bank and Gaza, territories occupied by Israel since 1967: demography, land use, agriculture, industry, law. Their report, published by the American Enterprise Institute in Washington, fills 97 large-sized pages with maps, tables and analysis. But it is much more than that.
From the findings, Benvenisti drew a conclusion of profound political import. Israel’s de facto annexation of the two territories, he said, had passed the point of no return. The continuing process — Jewish settlements, road and water links to Israel, economic dependence, the administrative and legal apparatus — was irreversible.
“For the foreseeable future,” he wrote, “all of Palestine will be ruled by an Israeli government.” The conclusion confounded Benvenisti’s own wishes — he is a dove who did not want annexation — and outraged his political friends.
It delighted the annexationists in power in the Likud coalition Government of Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir. Yet there was discomfort for them, too, if they thought about his words. Would the 1.3 million Palestinians in the territories be treated as a subordinate caste in a Greater Israel, he asked, or would they have political rights?
He said the choice would come to this: “Is Israel to be a Jewish state or a democratic one?” The future of the West Bank is an emotional question in Israel, and understandably so. It goes to the very nature of the society and the state; it engages history, religion, the sense of Jewish destiny.
So it was not surprising that Benvenisti should touch a nerve by saying that the question had in fact already been decided.
Ramot, a suburb of Jerusalem. is typical of the new towns Israel has built on once rocky and barren hilltops on the West Bank.
Date check: No masthead — this is a magazine feature opening, page 32, with the folio “32” at the bottom left. Nothing on the page names the publication or the date. Internally the article says the Benvenisti report “coincided with the start of the Israeli election campaign that ends in voting tomorrow”; the Israeli Knesset election was held on 23 July 1984, which is consistent with a Sunday, 22 July 1984 magazine. The contributor note reads “Anthony Lewis is a columnist for The New York Times”, consistent with `pub`.
TEL AVIV, Israel (UPI) — Israeli soldiers raided the largest Palestinian university in the occupied West Bank, breaking up a show that featured handbooks on guerrilla warfare and bomb-making, Israeli authorities said today. The east Jerusalem-based Palestine Press Service said 10 people were arrested late yesterday at An-Najah University in Nablus.
It said the Israelis stormed into an exhibit of Palestinian folklore. “Security forces accompanied by a respresentative of the university administration entered An-Najah ... after having discovered that a hostile exhibit, including nationalistic and provocative displays, was taking place there,” a spokesman for Israeli occupation authorities said.
The spokesman made no mention of any arrests. “Slogans supporting both the Palestine Liberation Organization and terrorist acts perpetrated by the organization in Israel were prominently displayed at the exhibit,” he said, “along with instruction booklets on conducting guerrilla warfare, on producing makeshift explosive devices and on weapons use.”
The spokesman said troops also searched the offices of a pro-PLO student organization on campus, uncovering “knives, chains, an ax, brass knuckles, a plastic M-16 rifle and a wooden model of Kalashnikov submachine gun.” Security forces, he said, confiscated “a great deal of material from the exhibit and this organization’s offices.”
A man answering the university’s telephone said “everything is closed” and no one was available for comment. About 3,000 Palestinians study at An-Najah, the largest of the West Bank’s four four-year institutions of higher learning. Israeli authorities shut down the university from June 5, 1983, to Sept.
1, 1983, after students held a demonstration to commemorate the first anniversary of the Israeli invasion of Lebanon.
Two descriptions of the same room, printed one after the other. The Palestine Press Service says an exhibit of Palestinian folklore. The occupation authorities say a hostile exhibit with nationalistic and provocative displays. The weapons listed in the confiscation include a plastic rifle and a wooden model. Four years later the news agency that supplied the first description would itself be closed for six months.
HEBRON, OCCUPIED WEST BANK (AP) — Three families are working to establish another Jewish enclave in Hebron on a dusty hill ringed with heavy barbed wire and surrounded by Arab homes. It is the second Jewish settlement in Hebron, a city of 70,000 Arabs that is claimed as a religious site by Jews and Moslems.
The Jewish settlers — three couples and one child — brought in house trailers under cover of darkness Wednesday night. The next day, they put out flower pots and set up housekeeping, complete with water and electricity, as Arab prayer chants emanated from a mosque 100 yards away and their Moslem neighbors watched.
The settlement was accomplished with the approval of Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir’s government, which sent a half-dozen armed Israeli soldiers to help set up the barbed wire and to protect the Jews. Two blue-and-white Israeli flags marked the area.
“We moved in under cover because we thought it would be safer,” said Uri Karzen, 23, who emigrated from Chicago seven years ago. “But we believe most of the Arabs understand the Jews have reclaimed their city.” Hebron, about 30 miles south of Jerusalem, is the site of the tomb of the patriarchs Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.
Jews say it is their oldest city, but the Moslems also say Abraham is their forefather and the city is theirs. The city has been the site of frequent friction between Jews and Arabs since Israel captured the West Bank from Jordan in the 1967 Six-Day War.
And the newest Jewish settlement has angered and frightened neighboring Arabs, some of whom say they fear losing their homes. “There is nothing we can do. I am frightened even talking to you, because they might put me in jail,” said a Hebron man whose home is 50 feet from the Jewish settlement. He refused to give his name.
The ownership of the property occupied by the Jewish settlers was not clear. Karzen said the site was leased by an Arab tenant who didn’t develop it and gave up his rights to the land. But Arabs who live nearby said they believed the land is theirs, and that they are afraid their homes might be taken next. Until this week, there were 25 Jewish families in Hebron.
They live on the opposite side of the city from the new settlement.
HEBRON, Israeli-Occupied West Bank — Yigal Kutai stood on the rubble-strewn hillside lot and watched Friday as his young son slid playfully down a dirt bank where a half-dozen Israeli soldiers stood guard with M-16 automatic rifles.
“We are coming back to our homeland,” the 33-year-old former University of California at Los Angeles student told a visitor as he helped three families set up a new Jewish enclave in this once all-Arab city. “We are continuing the Zionist movement.”
The clandestine move onto this nondescript lot last Wednesday night of six travel trailers to house the families brought protests not only from Arabs, but from Jews who saw it as a provocation that can only increase tensions in this contested West Bank city.
Peace Now, an Israeli pressure group advocating territorial concessions to reach a Middle East accord, charged that the new “blackmail settlement” in Hebron amounted to tacit sanction for the “supporters of Jewish terror.” But for Kutai, there is no issue. Doubt, he said, is a fifth columnist threatening Israel.
The Arabs “get their strength from our doubts. … People here have no doubts.” The new outpost at Tel Rumeida, near an old Jewish cemetery in Hebron’s southwest section, is the first Jewish expansion in the city in nearly two years. It comes at a particularly sensitive time.
Israel’s two principal political groupings, Labor and Likud, are in the midst of negotiations to form the country’s next government.
But the parties take significantly different stands on the West Bank, and some political analysts here saw establishment of a new Jewish settlement in Hebron as an effort by hard-liners to undercut the talks and prevent any new government from taking a more conciliatory line toward the West Bank’s overwhelmingly Arab population.
An Israeli soldier guards Jewish settlers moving into trailer homes in predominantly Arab Hebron.
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
HEBRON, OCCUPIED WEST BANK (AP) — Three families are working to establish another Jewish enclave in Hebron on a dusty hill ringed with heavy barbed wire and surrounded by Arab homes. It is the second Jewish settlement in Hebron, a city of 70,000 Arabs that is claimed as a religious site by Jews and Moslems.
The Jewish settlers — three couples and one child — brought in house trailers under cover of darkness Wednesday night. The next day, they put out flower pots and set up housekeeping, complete with water and electricity, as Arab prayer chants emanated from a mosque 100 yards away and their Moslem neighbors watched.
The settlement was accomplished with the approval of Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir's government, which sent a half-dozen armed Israeli soldiers to help set up the barbed wire and to protect the Jews. Two blue-and-white Israeli flags marked the area.
“We moved in under cover because we thought it would be safer,” said Uri Karzen, 23, who emigrated from Chicago seven years ago.“But we believe most of the Arabs understand the Jews have reclaimed their city.” Hebron, about 30 miles south of Jerusalem, is the site of the tomb of the patriarchs Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.
Jews say it is their oldest city, but the Moslems also say Abraham is their forefather and the city is theirs. The city has been the site of frequent friction between Jews and Arabs since Israel captured the West Bank from Jordan in the 1967 Six-Day War.
And the newest Jewish settlement has angered and frightened neighboring Arabs, some of whom say they fear losing their homes. “There is nothing we can do. I am frightened even talking to you, because they might put me in jail,” said a Hebron man whose home is 50 feet from the Jewish settlement. He refused to give his name.
Jewish Families Work to Create Enclave Amid Hebron's Arabs
HEBRON, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Three families are working to establish a new Jewish enclave in Hebron on a dusty hill ringed with heavy barbed wire and surrounded by Arab homes. It is the second Jewish settlement in Hebron, a city of 70,000 Arabs that is claimed as a religious site by Jews and Moslem.
The Jewish settlers — three couples and one child — brought in house trailers under cover of darkness Wednesday night. The next day, they put out flower pots and set up housekeeping, complete with water and electricity, as Arab prayer chants emanated from a mosque 100 yards away and their Moslem neighbors watched.
The settlement was accomplished with the approval of Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir’s government, which sent a half-dozen armed Israeli soldiers to help set up the barbed wire and to protect the Jews. Two blue-and-white Israeli flags marked the area.
“We moved in under cover because we thought it would be safer,” said Uri Karzen, 21, who emigrated from Chicago seven years ago. “But we believe most of the Arabs understand the Jews have reclaimed their city.” Hebron, about 30 miles south of Jerusalem, is the site of the tomb of the patriarchs Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.
Jews say it is their oldest city, but the Moslems also say Abraham is their forefather and the city is theirs. The city has been the site of frequent friction between Jews and Arabs since Israel captured the West Bank from Jordan in the 1967 war. And the newest Jewish settlement has angered and frightened neighboring Arabs, some of whom say they fear losing their homes.
“There is nothing we can do. I am frightened even talking to you, because they might put me in jail,” said a Hebron man whose home is 50 feet from the Jewish settlement. He refused to give his name. “These trailers sit between several Arab houses.
In any area where the settlers put their feet, the Israeli defense forces follow,” said Mustafa Natsheh, who was deposed as Hebron’s mayor in 1983 and replaced by an Israeli military appointee.
Palestinian prisoners fast in order to gain sunlight
JERUSALEM (UPI) — Lawyers for 673 hunger-striking Palestinian prisoners said Wednesday the inmates vowed to press their 9-day-old fast until authorities improve conditions at the Jenead prison.
“We demand to be allowed to live in a human condition, to ... see the sun,” said Jihad Shakri, 25, a former hunger-striking inmate released Monday from the recently opened prison in Nablus, on the occupied West Bank. “We are prisoners, but I am a person,” said Shakri. The prisoners began the hunger strike Sept.
23 to protest lack of sunlight, denial of books and newspapers, and the crowding of as many as 18 inmates in a 26.4-square yard cell. The Lawyers Committee for the Defense of the Jenead prisoners charged the three-story prison opened only two months ago has enough space to house the prisoners properly, but the excess area is given to the guards and administrators.
Jewish and Arab lawyers for the 673 prisoners charged authorities block the cell windows with asbestos slabs and keep overhead bulbs burning 24 hours a day, perhaps concealing cameras. Police Minister Chaim Bar-Lev has visited the prison, met the inmates, and called some of their demands — such as being allowed to wear pajamas and have bed linen — justified.
But he reportedly balked at removing the asbestos blocks from the windows. Jewish lawyer Leah Tsemel, a rights activist who often defends Palestinians, said the fasting prisoners do drink a half cup of milk a day, but only because “they are obliged to.”
· Los Angeles Times · page W/Part IX page 1, jump page 9
UCLA Jewish Groups Ask Palestinian Ban
But Israel Organization Fails to Persuade University That Recent Speech Was ‘Political’
By KENNETH J. FANUCCHI, Times Staff Writer
Mirroring the international conflict between Israelis and Arabs, two UCLA Jewish organizations are locked in a struggle with a campus Palestinian group over affiliation with the university. The 3-year-old Committee for the Survival of the Palestinian People won affiliation status for the first time last spring and has applied for affiliation for the fall semester.
Its application will be heard Oct. 29. Affiliation allows groups access to campus facilities—such as rooms and telephones—and makes them eligible for university funding, most of it provided by student fees, to pay speakers' honorariums and airplane tickets.
The Jewish Law Students Assn. and the Israel Action Committee, student organizations, maintain that political groups “such as the Palestinian group” are, by University of California law, prohibited from university affiliation.
Jewish students object to use of mandatory student fees for political purposes, according to Daniel Spitzer, UCLA law student and spokesman for the Jewish Law Students Assn. Spitzer led the opposition to the affiliation of the Palestinian group last spring.
“We do not want to give someone student funds to propagandize on an issue many of us feel passionate about without a challenge,” Spitzer said. “At the same time, we support their right to air their views on campus, using their own resources.”
The Israel Action Committee last week failed to persuade the UCLA administration to reprimand the Palestinian committee for “sponsoring a political meeting.” Representatives of the Israel group decided “not to talk to the press” about the issue, said Jerry Abeles, who complained to the administration about the meeting for the group.
Members of the Palestinian committee countered that the true intent of their opponents is to shut off debate on issues critical of Israel.
“Our assessment is that they not only do not want to hear what our speakers have to say but they also do not want anyone else on campus and in the larger Los Angeles community to hear them, either,” said Susan Mordechay, an Israeli citizen and member of the Palestinian committee.
JERUSALEM (AP) — The attackers who claimed responsibility for rocketing a Palestinian bus are threatening more attacks unless terrorists who harm Jews are executed and members of a Jewish anti-Arab underground are freed, the police said today.
One young Palestinian man was killed and 10 other passengers were injured in the attack yesterday when an anti-tank rocket tore into the crowded bus. The police found a note written in Hebrew next to the rocket launcher which said the attack was in retaliation for the murder of two Israeli students last week. A Palestinian man has been charged with the killings.
The rocketing prompted the police to increase security today in Arab East Jerusalem in what Police Chief Avraham Turgeman said was a move to protect both Palestinians and Jews. In the West Bank town of Bethlehem, Palestinian students today threw stones at cars traveling on the main road from Jerusalem, damaging several Israeli-owned vehicles, Israel radio said.
The radio said students barricaded themselves inside the Bethlehem University campus, and the police used tear gas to stop the stone-throwing. Bethlehem is about nine miles northeast of the village of Sair, where the victim of the bus attack was buried last night.
The police said the note found beside the rocket launcher listed three conditions for ceasing attacks on Palestinians: execution of the Israeli students’ murderer, the death penalty for all terrorists who harm Jews, and release of alleged members of a Jewish underground.
The rocket was fired at the bus just below the walls of Jerusalem’s Old City, a few yards from the line that divided Jewish and Arab Jerusalem until Israel conquered the eastern part of the city in the 1967 Middle East war. Witnesses said they saw a man fleeing from the scene into an adjacent gully. Turgeman said three Jewish suspects had been detained for questioning.
But they were released later, Israel television said. The attacker left behind the launching tube of the rocket, which is a U.S.-designed weapon widely used by Israeli troops. The police said he also left a note which said “this is in revenge for the murder” of two students near the Cremisan Monastery last week. It referred to the Oct.
22 killing of two Israelis near the monastery, five miles south of Jerusalem. A resident of the nearby Dheishe refugee camp, Issa Nimer Abd-Rabu, was accused of blindfolding the students and shooting them in the head. The police allege he killed the two as part of his initiation into a Palestinian guerrilla group.
Israel Radio said the note found by the launcher was signed “the Avengers.” It said the police thought the group was a small one, made up of perhaps only two or three Israelis well-trained in the use of weapons. The bus was taking about 40 Palestinians to their homes in the occupied West Bank.
Israel radio identified the dead passenger as Jamal Ismail Matour, 20, of Sair. None of the 10 people hurt was reported in serious condition. Prime Minister Shimon Peres and Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin condemned the attack. Peres said the government would “take all necessary means” to bring the assailants to justice.
It was the first attack on Palestinians in Jerusalem since Sept. 22, when a grenade thrown into a coffee shop wounded four Arabs.
Correction: The deck paired this scan with the other caption on its slide. The masthead printed on the scan names this paper.
Attackers of Palestinians threaten to strike again
JERUSALEM (AP) — The attackers who claimed responsibility for rocketing a Palestinian bus are threatening more attacks unless terrorists who harm Jews are executed and members of a Jewish anti-Arab underground are freed, police said today.
One young Palestinian man was killed and 10 other passengers were injured in the attack yesterday when an anti-tank rocket tore into the crowded bus. Police found a note written in Hebrew next to the rocket launcher which said the attack was in retaliation for the murder of two Israeli students last week. A Palestinian man has been charged with the killings.
The rocketing prompted police to increase security today in Arab East Jerusalem in what Police Chief Avraham Turgeman said was a move to protect both Palestinians and Jews. In the West Bank town of Bethlehem, Palestinian students today threw stones at cars traveling on the main road from Jerusalem, damaging several Israeli-owned vehicles, israel radio said.
The radio said students barricaded themselves inside the Bethlehem University campus, and police used tear gas to stop the stone-throwing. Bethlehem is about nine miles northeast of the village of Sair, where the victim of the bus attack was buried last night.
Police said the note found beside the rocket launcher listed three conditions for ceasing attacks on Palestinians: execution of the Israeli students’ murderer, the death penalty for all terrorists who harm Jews and release of alleged members of a Jewish underground.
The rocket was fired at the bus just below the walls of Jerusalem’s Old City, a few yards from the line that divided Jewish and Arab Jerusalem until Israel conquered the eastern part of the city in the 1967 Middle East war. Witnesses said they saw a man fleeing the scene into an adjacent gully. Turgeman said three Jewish suspects had been detained for questioning.
But they were released later, Israel television said. The attacker left behind the launching tube of the rocket, which is a U.S.-designed weapon widely used by Israeli troops. Police said he also left a note which said “this is in revenge for the murder” of two students near the Cremisan Monastery last week. It referred to the Oct.
22 killing of two Israelis near the monastery, five miles south of Jerusalem. A resident of the nearby Dheishe refugee camp, Issa Nimer Abd-Rabu, was accused of blindfolding the students and shooting them in the head. Police allege he killed the two as part of his initiation into a Palestinian guerrilla group.
Israel Radio said the note found by the launcher was signed “the Avengers.” It said police thought the group was a small one, made up of perhaps only two or three Israelis well-trained in the use of weapons. The bus was taking about 40 Palestinians to their homes in the occupied West Bank.
Israel radio identified the dead passenger as Jamal Ismail Matour, 20, of Sair. None of the 10 people hurt was reported in serious condition. Prime Minister Shimon Peres and Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin condemned the attack. Peres said the government would “take all necessary means” to bring the assailants to justice.
It was the first attack on Palestinians in Jerusalem since Sept. 22, when a grenade thrown into a coffee shop wounded four Arabs.
Police Minister Haim Bar-Lev said in a radio interview that yesterday’s attackers were a group “whose size is not yet known, of people taking the law into their own hands out of racist and nationalistic motives, extremists who are willing to injure the innocent.”
Israeli medical personnel assist bus passenger injured in rocket attack.
Rocket hits Arab bus, kills one; police blame Jewish terrorists
JERUSALEM — Unidentified terrorists fired an anti-tank rocket into a crowded Arab bus in central Jerusalem yesterday, killing one Arab youth and wounding 10 other passengers. The Jerusalem police chief, Avraham Turgeman, said early indications were that the attack was perpetrated by Jews seeking revenge for the murder last week of two Jewish students on the West Bank.
He said three men, all Jews, had been detained for questioning after a police sweep through the neighborhood, but that no arrests had been made. The police rushed to the scene minutes after the attack and found the rocket launcher tucked into the bushes about 10 yards off the road, along with a note written in Hebrew claiming credit for the shooting.
According to the police chief, the hand-written note said that the attack was made “in revenge for the murder of the students at Crimesan” and because the government does not put a penalty of death on “terrorists’ murders.”
Last Monday, Issa Nimr Jibrin, a 22-year-old Palestinian Arab living in the Dehaishe refugee camp near Bethlehem, reportedly confessed to killing two young Israeli hikers, a man and woman, while they were touring the valley below the Crimesan Monastery near Beit Jalla, south of Jerusalem.
Jibrin, who claimed to have acted out of “Arab nationalist” sentiments, will be tried for murder by a military court. The maximum penalty for murder in Israel is life imprisonment. Yesterday’s attack appeared to be quite professional.
The weapon used was an American-made LAW (light anti-tank weapon), a two-foot-long rocket launcher in wide use by the Israeli infantry. The No. 23 Bus, a green Volvo belonging to the Arab-owned Hebron Bus Co., had left the East Jerusalem bus station at Damascus Gate around 3:15 p.m. and was on its way through town when the attack took place.
Packed with some 30 to 40 Arab passengers and heading for Hebron, the bus had just rounded the turn at Sultan’s Pool on the southern edge of Jerusalem and was climbing slowly up a hillside when the rocket ripped into it. It had been fired from an area of brush and small trees on the side of the road.
The rocket tore a hole 1½ feet long in the right side of the bus, just above the side door, and sprayed glass and shrapnel around those trapped inside. Both the bus and roadside were splattered with blood of the passengers, who were mostly Arab workers and shoppers who had come into Jerusalem from Hebron for the day.
A 20-year-old Palestinian Arab, Jamal Ismail Abu Matar, died minutes after the attack despite a roadside effort by ambulance crews to save him. The attack was the first such anti-Arab incident since April, when the police thwarted an attempt by a Jewish terrorist organization to plant bombs on a fleet of Arab buses in Jerusalem and the West Bank.
Shortly after the attempted bombing, 25 Jews suspected of membership in a Jewish terrorist underground were arrested. They are currently on trial in connection with several attacks, some of them fatal, on West Bank Arabs over the last three years.
The minister of police, Haim Bar-Lev, indicated to reporters shortly after yesterday’s killing that he, too, believed Jewish terrorists were again involved. “We have already confronted such fanatics in the past and we will see that these go in jail, too,” Bar-Lev said.
“After we caught the underground we knew it was not the end and the security forces continue to handle these crazies.”
Israeli medical personnel assist bus passenger injured in rocket attack.
JERUSALEM — The attackers who claimed responsibility for rocketing a Palestinian bus are threatening more assaults unless terrorists who harm Jews are executed and members of a Jewish anti-Arab underground are freed, police said today.
One young Palestinian man was killed and 10 other passengers were injured in the attack yesterday when an anti-tank rocket tore into the crowded bus. Police found a note written in Hebrew next to the rocket launcher which said the attack was in retaliation for the murder of two Israeli students last week. A Palestinian man has been charged with the killings.
The rocketing prompted police to increase security today in Arab East Jerusalem in what Police Chief Avraham Turgeman said was a move to protect both Palestinians and Jews. In the West Bank town of Bethlehem, Palestinian students today threw stones at cars traveling on the main road from Jerusalem, damaging several Israeli-owned vehicles, Israel radio said.
The radio said students barricaded themselves inside the Bethlehem University campus, and police used tear gas to stop the stone-throwing. Bethlehem is nine miles northeast of the village of Sair, where the victim of the bus attack was buried last night.
Police said the note found beside the rocket launcher listed three conditions for ceasing attacks on Palestinians: execution of the Israeli students’ murderer, the death penalty for all terrorists who harm Jews, and release of alleged members of a Jewish underground.
The rocket was fired at the bus just below the walls of Jerusalem’s Old City, a few yards from the line that divided Jewish and Arab Jerusalem until Israel conquered the eastern part of the city in the 1967 Middle East war.
Correction: The deck paired this scan with the other caption on its slide. The masthead printed on the scan names this paper.
JERUSALEM (UPI) — Terrorists fired a rocket from a hillside into a bus carrying Arabs to the occupied West Bank, killing one passenger and wounding 10 others in a revenge attack for the murders last week of two Jewish students.
Three Jewish youths were arrested for the attack launched from a hillside near Jerusalem’s Old City, police spokesman Moshe Alexandroni said. Police did not name the suspects.
The rocket ripped an 18-inch hole above the rear exit and shattered four windows of the bus, which was carrying 25 Arab passengers from East Jerusalem to Hebron in the occupied West Bank when it was hit in mid-afternoon, police said. Gamal Ismail Natour, 20, of Hebron, was killed instantly and 10 other Arab passengers on the half-full bus were wounded, Alexandroni said.
Five were released after treatment at a hospital. Alexandroni said police found a rocket launcher on the hillside shortly after the attack. Police refused to say whether the rocket was issued by Israel Defense Forces.
Near the rocket launcher was a note in Hebrew saying the attack was in retaliation for the murders last week of two Jewish students — a young man and a woman — near a monastery in Beit Jala south of Jerusalem. A Palestinian from the Dehaishe Refugee Camp near Bethlehem was charged with those murders.
The father of Ron Levi, one of the slain students, condemned the revenge attack on the bus, as did Prime Minister Shimon Peres and Defense Minster Yitzhak Rabin. Police would not speculate on whether the rocket attack was linked to a Jewish terrorist underground.
Twenty young Jews went on trial about a month ago on charges they participated in a ring accused of spreading terror among Israel’s Arab population. The ring is accused of terrorist acts that include planting bombs aboard five Arab buses in April. Police defused the bombs before they went off.
Medics and civilians help one of the Arabs hurt in the anti-tank rocket attack on a bus
JERUSALEM (UPI)—Terrorists fired a rocket from a hillside into a bus carrying Arabs to the occupied West Bank, killing one passenger and wounding 10 others in a revenge attack for the murders last week of two Jewish students. Three Jewish youths were arrested for the attack launched from a hillside near Jerusalem’s Old City, police spokesman Moshe Alexandroni said.
Police did not name the suspects. The rocket ripped an 18-inch hole above the rear exit and shattered four windows of the bus, which was carrying 25 Arab passengers from East Jerusalem to Hebron in the occupied West Bank when it was hit in mid-afternoon, police said.
Gamal Ismail Natour, 20, of Hebron, was killed instantly and 10 other Arab passengers on the half-full bus were wounded, Alexandroni said. Five were released after treatment at a hospital. Alexandroni said police found a rocket launcher on the hillside shortly after the attack. Police refused to say whether the rocket was issued by Israel Defense Forces.
Near the rocket launcher was a note in Hebrew saying the attack was in retaliation for the murders last week of two Jewish students—a young man and a woman—near a monastery in Beit Jala south of Jerusalem. A Palestinian from the Dehaishe Refugee Camp near Bethlehem was charged with those murders.
The father of Ron Levi, one of the slain students, condemned the revenge attack on the bus, as did Prime Minister Shimon Peres and Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin. The bus, owned by the Hebron Bus Co., moved about 20 feet after the explosion, spilling baskets of vegetables and fruit and two large gunny sacks.
A policeman drove the vehicle away after the passengers were evacuated. A Jerusalem-based committee of Israeli scholars sympathetic to Palestinian universities in the West Bank issued a statement saying the attack was the work of the Jewish underground, whose leaders are on trial for a series of attacks on Arabs.
“We often warned that the underground was still very much alive both in Israel and in the occupied territories,” the statement said. Police would not speculate on whether the rocket attack was linked to a Jewish terrorist underground.
Twenty young Jews went on trial about a month ago on charges they participated in a ring accused of spreading terror among Israel’s Arab population. “We are exploring all possibilities. We cannot commit ourselves at this stage,” an officer said. The ring is accused of terrorist acts that include planting bombs aboard five Arab buses in April.
Police defused the bombs before they went off. On Dec. 6, a bomb planted on a bus in Jerusalem killed six Israelis and wounded 44. Yasir Arafat’s mainstream Al-Fatah faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization claimed responsibility, but later said the bomb was planted without its authorization.
A view of where an anti-tank rocket hit an Arab bus and killed at least one person near the Old City of Jerusalem.
Attempting to defuse a student conflict between Jewish and Palestinian organizations, the UCLA Graduate Students Assn. has awarded campus affiliation to groups representing each side. On a 4-3 vote, the cabinet of the association approved affiliation for the fall quarter for the Committee for the Survival of the Palestinian People and for the Jewish Graduate Students Assn.
The UCLA Graduate Students Assn. also decided to try during this quarter to change university rules that allow affiliated groups to use the university's name in their activities, said Scott Spicer, vice president of the association. “Use of the term UCLA implies support for the particular perspective of an organization, and that is inappropriate,” Spicer said.
“We would like to make it clear that affiliation does not imply support, while at the same time protecting the right of free speech.”
Affiliation allows campus groups free use of university facilities, including rooms and telephones, and permits them to apply for funding to pay advertising costs of activities and stipends, airfare and hotel expenses incurred by speakers.
The issue became controversial last winter when the Palestinian group, then called the Committee in Solidarity with the Palestinian People, applied for affiliation. Several Jewish groups, among them the Jewish Law Students Assn. and the Israel Action Committee, fought the request on grounds that the Palestinian organization was a patently political group.
University regulations forbid affiliation for political groups. Members of the Palestinian group maintained that their organization was an educational forum designed to bring to campus speakers who expounded a position on the Middle East rarely heard on the UCLA campus.
JERUSALEM (AP) — Soldiers fired tear gas today to disperse a crowd of stone-throwing Palestinians in the occupied West Bank city of Nablus, military sources said. Soldiers also clamped a curfew on a village south of Hebron, another West Bank city, after stone-throwing Palestinians smashed the window of a civilian Israeli vehicle Thursday night, the sources said.
The disturbance in Nablus, the West Bank’s largest Palestinian city, 30 miles north of Jerusalem, began after several hundred Palestinians rallied and began chanting anti-Israeli slogans in the main marketplace after morning prayers at a nearby mosque, reported the Palestinian Press Service. The agency monitors events in the West Bank.
Palestinians from the village of Dahariye near Hebron stoned three Israeli vehicles Thursday night, smashing one window but causing no injuries, said an army spokesman, who spoke on condition of anonymity. The army later clamped a curfew on the area, forcing residents to remain in their homes until further notice, he said.
Thursday’s unrest coincided with the 67th anniversary of the Balfour Declaration, which paved the way for the creation of Israel by declaring Britain’s support for a Jewish homeland. It is a traditional day of protest by Palestinians.
The disturbances came after a week of sporadic incidents in the West Bank following a rocket attack on a Palestinian bus last Sunday. Authorities said that attack, in which one Palestinian passenger died, appeared to be the work of Jewish extremists.
There was much smoke, but no fire, in your coverage of the controversy over the status of a pro-Palestinian group at UCLA. The article as a whole, and its shocking headline in particular (“UCLA Jewish Groups Ask Palestinian Ban,” Westside section, Oct. 21), completely misstated the issues involved.
Jewish groups have always supported the right of all groups—including pro-Palestinians—to present their views on campus. Our commitment to the campus as a “marketplace of ideas” has been categorical and absolute.
Thus the characterization of our actions as seeking a “Palestinian Ban” is a scandalously irresponsible misrepresentation of the facts. What we are asking is that the UCLA administration stop giving preferential treatment to the anti-Zionist Committee for the Survival of the Palestinian People (CSPP).
At UCLA, there are two kinds of groups: independent and affiliated. Any group, of whatever persuasion, may become an independent group merely by registering with the Center for Student Programming. Independent groups have access to the campus and all of its facilities, but are not eligible to receive funds drawn from student registration fees.
Only affiliated groups are able to receive such funds, since the primary condition of affiliation is that a group be neither political nor religious.
JERUSALEM (AP) — An Israeli soldier accused in two terrorist attacks against Palestinians said yesterday he was avenging Palestinian attacks on his countrymen. Meanwhile, a second soldier was taken into custody in connection with one of the attacks, a fatal rocket bombing of a bus. A third person was being questioned and a fourth was released, authorities said.
“I make this explanation out of sorrow and pain,” David Ben-Shimol, 18, told a magistrate’s court. “Innocent Jews are being killed indiscriminately. I couldn’t stand it any longer. I hope the court would understand.”
Judge Aharon Simcha read out allegations that accused Ben-Shimol of firing an anti-tank rocket at an Arab bus in Jerusalem on Oct. 28. One Palestinian passenger was killed and 10 were wounded.
The bus attack touched off a week of violent protests by Palestinians in the occupied West Bank and prompted Israeli authorities to close Bethlehem University for four days after stone-throwing incidents there. The allegations read by the judge also accused Ben-Shimol of throwing a small bomb into a crowded cafe in Jerusalem’s Old City on Sept. 22.
Four Palestinians were wounded in that attack. The judge ordered the soldier held for 15 days for questioning but did not formally indict him. In a closed-door session, Simcha later ordered a second soldier held for six days on suspicion of being involved in the rocket attack. The second soldier’s name was not released.
Police were also questioning a woman soldier about the attacks and released a fourth soldier, Jerusalem police spokesman Rafi Levi said. A note found near the empty rocket launcher said the bus attack was in revenge for the shooting deaths of two Jewish students near a monastery outside Jerusalem on Oct. 22.
Issa Nimer Jibrin Abu Rabu, 22, a Palestinian from the outskirts of Bethlehem, was charged with murder. The indictment quoted him as saying the murders were in revenge for the shooting death of his cousin by Israeli soldiers during a riot in 1982.
Palestinians Stranded in Desert Camp as Israel, Egypt Quibble
CAMP CANADA, Egypt (AP) — The chill in relations between Egypt and Israel has left thousands of Palestinians stranded in this dusty refugee camp used by Canadian peacekeeping forces before the 1967 Arab-Israeli war.
The estimated 6,000 Palestinians in the camp originally were to have been repatriated to the nearby Israeli-administered Gaza Strip within six months of Israel’s final return of the Sinai Peninsula to Egypt in April 1982. But Egyptian and Israeli negotiators were unable to work out terms for their return.
Each blames the other for the impasse, and all contacts between Egypt and Israel on the problem have been suspended since Israel’s invasion of Lebanon in June 1982. Meanwhile, the Palestinians themselves have little choice but to pass the time drinking tea, visiting friends or playing pickup soccer in the narrow camp streets.
With jobs in the area scarce, and generally reserved for Egyptians, few of the men have jobs. Several said they would rather be across the border on the Israeli side, where there are more jobs and where many of them have relatives. But permits even for short visits to Israel are difficult to obtain.
With little hope of becoming self-sufficient or returning to the Israeli side soon, the Palestinians must rely on the United Nations for food, shelter and primary schools and on Egyptian authorities for their water and electricity. “We have houses here but this is not our home” said Nayel Saad, an 18-year-old Palestinian youth.
“Of course, the Israelis do not want us back in Palestine, and the Egyptians tell us there is no solution. But we must go back to our land and our families. We must.” Israel was formed in 1948 from what once was home to of Palestinians. The Palestinians came to the camp in 1971, after Israel occupied the area and the rest of the Sinai Peninsula in the 1967 war.
Israeli authorities settled about 5,000 people in the old camp, most of them from the Gaza Strip, which is just a few miles across the border from here.
For Arafat, Effort to Convene Palestinian Assembly Is a ‘Matter of Survival’
By JOHN KIFNER
AMMAN, Jordan, Nov. 18 — When the Palestine Liberation Organization guerrillas sailed from Israeli-besieged Beirut two years ago, firing their Kalashnikov rifles wildly into the air as if to convince themselves they had won a famous victory, their military power was battered but seemingly intact.
Now the P.L.O., once the critical focus of Middle East politics, is scattered, divided and facing a potentially critical organizational split.
With most of his troops under Syrian domination, Yasir Arafat, the P.L.O. chairman, is preparing to gamble all to keep his longtime leadership by calling a meeting here for Thursday of the Palestine National Council, the unofficial Palestinian parliament in exile. “For Arafat, it’s a matter of survival,” a Western diplomat in Amman said.
Army’s, students’ stories of attack on pro-Arafat rally differ
Thomas L. Friedman
BIR ZEIT, Israeli — Israeli troops in this Occupied West Bank settlement opened fire Wednesday on a crowd of stone-throwing Arab students who were demonstrating in support of the Palestinian guerrilla leader Yasser Arafat. One student was killed and six wounded in the clash.
An Israeli army spokesman said the troops were forced to fire on the demonstrators to extricate several Israeli soldiers who were trapped by the crowd. However, the Arab students said the army opened fire to break up the pro-Palestine Liberation Organization rally.
The town of Bir Zeit, 15 miles north of Jerusalem, was put under curfew Wednesday afternoon as hundreds of student demonstrators holed up in the cafeteria on the old campus of Bir Zeit University, hiding out from Israeli troops ringing the area.
After several hours of tense negotiations between university representatives and Israeli officials, the students agreed to disperse and were accorded free passage by the army. The Israeli commander of the central front, Maj. Gen.
Amnon Lipkin, recommended to the defense minister that Bir Zeit University, the largest Arab-run institution of higher learning on the West Bank, be temporarily closed as a result of Wednesday’s incident, military sources said. The killing of Sharif Khalil Taibe, a 23-year-old engineering student, was the first death of a West Bank demonstrator since Jan.
28, when a 17-year-old Nablus youth was shot by troops during a similar protest.
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
Arab student killed as Israelis quell protest at West Bank university
JERUSALEM—Israeli soldiers shot and killed one Arab student and wounded at least six others yesterday near the occupied West Bank city of Ramallah as they broke up a demonstration at Bir Zeit University in support of Palestine Liberation Organization leader Yasser Arafat. Maj. Gen.
Amnon Lipkin, commander of Israeli forces in the central region of the West Bank, said “several” soldiers opened fire after their commanding officer was knocked unconscious by some 200 stone-throwing students who ambushed his unit on a narrow street just off the university campus, which borders Ramallah.
Lipkin said the troops acted after first warning the demonstrators to disperse. They then fired shots in the air, and “one or two of the warning shots strayed,” according to the army account. But a university staff member and a reporter said the Israeli troops gave demonstrators no warning before they opened fire.
A woman in the university spokesman’s office, who refused to identify herself, had said earlier that 10 students were wounded and that the Israeli soldiers opened fire indiscriminately. “Some students described them as (acting like) American cowboys,” the woman said.
The clash occurred on the eve of a long-delayed meeting in Amman, Jordan, of the Palestine National Council, which functions as a Palestinian “parliament-in-exile.” Arafat called the meeting despite strong opposition from the PLO’s more radical pro-Syrian elements, and the internal conflict in the organization has had its reflection on the West Bank.
BIR ZEIT, Israeli-Occupied West Bank — Israeli troops opened fire yesterday on a crowd of stone-throwing Arab students who were demonstrating in support of the Palestinian guerrilla leader Yasser Arafat. One student was killed and six were wounded in the clash.
An Israeli army spokesman said the troops were forced to fire on the demonstrators to extricate several Israeli soldiers who were trapped by the crowd. However, the Arab students said the army opened fire to break up the pro-Palestine Liberation Organization rally.
The town of Bir Zeit, 15 miles north of Jerusalem, was put under curfew yesterday afternoon as hundreds of student demonstrators holed up in the cafeteria on the old campus of Bir Zeit University, hiding out from Israeli troops ringing the area.
After several hours of tense negotiations between university representatives and Israeli officials, the students agreed to disperse and were accorded free passage by the army. The Israeli commander of the central front, Maj. Gen.
Amnon Lipkin, recommended to the defense minister that Bir Zeit University, the largest Arab-run institution of higher learning on the West Bank, be temporarily closed as a result of yesterday’s incident, military sources said. The killing of Sharif Khalil Taibe, a 23-year-old engineering student, was the first death of a West Bank demonstrator since Jan.
28, when a 17-year-old Nablus youth was shot by troops during a similar protest. Several other violent incidents were reported around the Israeli-occupied West Bank yesterday, as some of its Arab inhabitants appeared to be trying to express solidarity with the meeting today in Amman, Jordan, of the PLO’s parliament-in-exile, the Palestine National Council.
BIR ZEIT, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, Nov. 21 — Israeli soldiers opened fire today on a crowd of stone-throwing Arab students who were demonstrating in support of the Palestinian guerrilla leader Yasir Arafat. One student was killed and six were wounded.
An Israeli Army spokesman said the soldiers were trapped by the crowd and had to open fire on the demonstrators to extricate themselves. But the Arab students said the army opened fire to break up the rally backing the Palestine Liberation Organization.
The town of Bir Zeit, 15 miles north of Jerusalem, was put under curfew this afternoon as hundreds of student demonstrators were holed up in the cafeteria on the old campus of Bir Zeit University and Israeli troops ringed the college.
After several hours of tense negotiations between university representatives and Israeli officials, the students agreed to disperse and the army let them pass. The killing of a 23-year-old Bir Zeit University engineering student, Sharif Khalil Taibe, was the first death of a West Bank demonstrator since Jan.
28, when a 17-year-old Nablus youth was shot in a similar protest clash with Israeli troops. Several other violent incidents were reported around the Israeli-occupied West Bank as some of the Arab inhabitants appeared to be trying to express solidarity with a meeting of the Palestine National Council, the P.L.O.’s parliament in exile, that is scheduled Thursday in Amman.
The disturbances in Bir Zeit began shortly after 10:30 A.M., students said. “We were chanting slogans and carrying signs in support of chairman Yasir Arafat,” one 22-year-old student said. “We were shouting, ‘With our blood and our spirit we will redeem Palestine and Yasir Arafat.’
We wanted people in Amman to know that we supported the convening of the National Council.”
Arafat opens session of Palestine National Council
Mona Ziade
AMMAN, Jordan — Despite opposition boycotts, PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat convened a meeting of the Palestine National Council on Thursday, and said the mustering of a quorum assured the “eternal continuity” of the guerrilla movement.
“The mere fact that this session of our Palestine National Council has been convened provides the biggest evidence and the irrevocable truth that there is no power on Earth that can destroy the PLO,” Arafat said at the opening session of the group, which calls itself the parliament of the Palestinian people.
Arafat’s ability to muster the needed two-thirds quorum of the 379-member Palestine National Council seemed to assure that he would get a vote of confidence in his leadership, despite the efforts of Syrian-backed factions to oust him.
But there was also widespread belief that by calling the session against the wishes of the Syrian-supported movements, Arafat was making the split in the Palestine Liberation Organization a permanent one.
Arafat needed 252 members to convene the session, and it was announced at the beginning of the meeting Thursday that the two-thirds majority had been achieved, but no specific number of delegates was given. The council has 384 seats, but five members have died since the last meeting, in February 1983, and have not been replaced.
FOUR Syrian-backed groups have been demanding that Arafat be removed as leader of the PLO since shortly after Israel’s 1982 invasion of Lebanon drove the guerrilla movement from Beirut. Those groups boycotted the meeting and said Arafat did not have enough delegates to convene the session.
“Those from our enemies, and even from our friends, who imagined that the PLO is just a temporary phenomenon in the national life of our people must today reconsider their calculations,” Arafat declared. He said the meeting “proves that no one can erase the Palestinian figure from the Middle East equation.”
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
Israel’s new U.N. ambassador says ‘Arab decade’ in Middle East is over
Frank P. L. Somerville, Religion Editor of The Sun
“The new Israeli ambassador to the United Nations told applauding Orthodox Jews at a convention in Baltimore yesterday that a dramatic shift in United States Mideast policy had resulted from the attacks on the U.S. Embassy in Beirut.
‘The Arab decade is over,’ Benjamin Netanyahu triumphantly told his audience of nearly 1,000 at the Hyatt Regency Hotel, where the Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America has been meeting since Thursday.
Security considerations prevented him from being specific about new ‘strategic’ measures for the ‘common defense’ of Israel and the U.S., Mr. Netanyahu said. But he assured his listeners that ‘important things are happening.’
The ambassador said three major shifts in the Middle East during the last two years, largely brought about because of the strength and stability of Israel ‘in the shifting sands’ of that turbulent region, are now having profound effects on international policy in Washington, London, Tokyo, the capitals of Africa and elsewhere.
These changes, he said, were: ‘The decline of Arab oil.’ The Arab oil countries, facing the pressures of international conservation efforts and competition, were done in ‘by their own greed,’ he said. African nations which were once ‘seduced and intimidated by the Arabs’ are ‘coming back to Israel through the back door.’
‘The decline’ of the Palestine Liberation Organization. This ‘did not happen accidentally,’ Ambassador Netanyahu said. ‘We smashed the PLO.’
One important result, he said, is that ‘no longer is the PLO able to say it represents the Palestinian Arabs’ — a fact, he suggested, that ‘bodes well’ for the future of relations between Israel and its Arab neighbors. And most important of all, ‘the shift that has taken place in U.S. policy in the Middle East.’
Although the United States ‘unintentionally became exposed — as a country — to Arab terrorism’ in Lebanon, the ambassador said, the ‘tragic attacks’ on the American embassy in 1983 and 1984 have taught the Reagan administration a valuable foreign-policy lesson: that such terrorism is not aimed exclusively at Israel… At least privately and seriously, according to the Israeli ambassador, ‘no one at the U.N. talks about Israel as a pariah state any more.’”
“Rabbi Chaim Goldzweig of Chicago (left) and Rabbi Menachem Genack of Englewood, N.J., meet at the convention of Orthodox Jews.” The Sun / Barbara Haddock
Netanyahu in Baltimore in 1984, saying the PLO can no longer claim to represent the Palestinian Arabs. The page around him sells table pads, stacking stools and Ralph Lauren sweaters.
DHEISHEH REFUGEE CAMP, Israeli-Occupied West Bank — The Palestine National Council, in a nightly performance of political speeches and debate, is playing to rapt audiences at this refugee camp south of Bethlehem and all across the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
Through television, the Palestinians of the West Bank have been able to see, most of them for the first time, the deliberations of their “parliament in exile” as it meets less than 100 miles away in Amman, Jordan.
Jordan’s state-run television network, which is easily received in the West Bank and most of Israel, has been broadcasting portions of the meetings since they began last week.
By all accounts, the proximity of Palestine Liberation Organization leaders such as Yasser Arafat and the sight of them at work in Amman has boosted morale among the West Bank Palestinians and strengthened their support for Arafat against the Syrian-backed PLO dissidents who are boycotting the Amman meeting.
“Before the PNC, people were depressed,” said Ali Qadan, a Palestinian journalist. “Nothing was taking place on the Palestinian side. But now, with the appearance of Arafat in Amman, it has given more hope to Palestinians and more support to Arafat.”
“They simply are not used to anything like this,” said Albert Aghazarian, an official of Bir Zeit University. “They compare the PNC to the Jordanian parliament, which is very serene. People here like this sort of activity, with the delegates standing up making different points. We need it.”
In Dheisheh, one of the most attentive viewers has been Ziad Abu Laban, 20, a student at Bethlehem University. A lifelong resident of the refugee camp who says he expects “to die in Dheisheh,” he has gathered with friends to watch the broadcasts at 4 every afternoon and again at night.
So, too, he said, has almost everyone else in the camp of about 12,000, who have crammed themselves into small, damp rooms in Dheisheh’s jumble of hillside stone houses.
Sitting in a 10-foot square room furnished with two chairs, a table and a large color television set, Abu Laban said he had been struck by the council’s freewheeling debate, the sight of “Palestinian democracy” in action. “I always heard about it, but I never saw it,” he said. “I touched this democracy through the television.”
Televised Debate Is Morale Booster For Palestinians
Dheisheh Refugee Camp, Israeli-Occupied West Bank — The Palestine National Council, in a nightly performance of political speeches and debate, is playing to rapt audiences at this refugee camp south of Bethlehem and all across the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
Through television, the Palestinians of the West Bank have been able to see, most of them for the first time, the deliberations of their “parliament-in-exile” as it meets less than 100 miles away in Amman, Jordan.
Jordan’s state-run television network, which is easily received in the West Bank and most of Israel, has been broadcasting portions of the meetings since they began last week.
Strengthens Support By all accounts, the proximity of Palestine Liberation Organization leaders such as Yasser Arafat and the sight of them at work in Amman has boosted morale among the West Bank Palestinians and strengthened their support for Arafat against the Syrian-backed PLO dissidents who are boycotting the Amman meeting.
“Before the PNC, people were depressed,” said Ali Qadan, a Palestinian journalist. “Nothing was taking place on the Palestinian side. But now, with the appearance of Arafat in Amman, it has given more hope to Palestinians and more support to Arafat.”
“They simply are not used to anything like this,” said Albert Aghazarian, an official of Bir Zeit University. ‘We Need It’ “They compare the PNC to the Jordanian parliament, which is very serene. People here like this sort of activity, with the delegates standing up making different points. We need it.”
In Dheisheh, one of the most attentive viewers has been Ziad Abu Laban, 20, a student at Bethlehem University. A lifelong resident of the refugee camp who says he expects “to die in Dheisheh,” he has gathered with friends to watch the broadcasts every day at 4 p.m. and again at night.
Arafat swamped by supporters ... He changed his mind about resigning.
“…vehemently denied. ‘The primary objective was to secure peace for the Galilee. It is intolerable for people to live underground for fear of Katuysha (rocket) attacks,’ Netanyahu said, despite rather widespread agreement that the PLO had for a year prior to the 1982 invasion abided by a cease-fire.
‘The invasion smashed the PLO infrastructure even though we had underestimated it. Lebanon’s political polity was never a consideration or a primary objective. The PLO is today divided and scattered. Syria is at odds with the (Yassir) Arafat faction and both the PLO’s political strength and its strength on the ground have been smashed.
It is a defeated, though not extinct, force in the region,’ Netanyahu said. Reminded that in the past two weeks there have been several Katuysha attacks launched from Jordan on Galilean settlements, Netanyahu chuckled. ‘Yes, King Hussein is doing a minuet with the PLO. He gives them public support.
And he may make an occasional concession and allow them to use Jordan as a base for some minor terrorist operations, but privately he does not support them.’… On the issue of the Israeli-occupied West Bank — Netanyahu vehemently decries the use of any terms other than Judea and Samaria for the area — the ambassador takes a hard line.
There will be no Arab sovereignty on the West Bank. Period. Netanyahu insists there is the broadest possible consensus in Israel in this regard. Making all the usual historical Jewish claims to the area and rejecting any Palestinian national rights on the West Bank, Netanyahu supports the current government policy: Jordan is Palestine.
Jews have every historical, political and legal right to settle the West Bank, said Netanyahu, a native of Tel Aviv who grew up in Jerusalem. While Arab states quibble over Palestinian rights, the Israeli settlements are carrying out a fait accompli on the West Bank. And with the PLO smashed in Lebanon, the issue of who controls the area is all but moot.
‘Jordan is Palestine, and Palestine is Jordan,’ Netanyahu insists, although Hussein, a minority Hashemite ruler who hardly needs 750,000 West Bank Palestinians pouring across the Jordan River, would undoubtedly disagree. ‘The Arabs already have 80 percent of old Palestine and we hold 17 percent (within the pre-1967 borders).
There is no reason to create a 22nd Arab state at the expense of the one Jewish state. What we are arguing about are borders between the Jewish and an Arab state. There is no reason why justice should demand the border be on either the east or west bank of the Jordan,’ he said. On the basis of security alone, Netanyahu said Israel can never give up the West Bank.
Israel’s eastern front will remain in IDF hands. That is not negotiable. ‘We simply can’t survive giving up Judea and Samaria. The real challenge to peace is not our occupation, but would be our giving up the region. We didn’t occupy the area before 1967 and there was no peace.
Since 1967, however, King Hussein has not been tempted to invade and has remained out of the subsequent wars.’ Netanyahu said Israel’s far left wants to solve the problem of trying to assimilate three-quarters of a million Arabs by giving up control of the territory. On the other hand, the far right wants to keep the territory but drive the people off the land.
Neither is acceptable to the ambassador, though he was unwilling to speculate on a permanent political solution beyond the status quo, except to say the two peoples will have to live together on the West Bank as they do in the rest of the country.
Netanyahu said the key to peace rests not in illusory visions of a Palestinian state, but in the Arab realization that Israel is on the West Bank to stay. Only when that realization dawns can a peace plan can be negotiated. ‘Is the so-called Palestinian problem the key to peace in the Mideast? In the Arab world comprising 21 nations, there is almost continual warfare.
Virtually every year since the establishment of the state of Israel, there has been at least one conflict between Arab states — conflicts that have nothing whatever to do with Israel or the Palestinians. Lebanon is a microcosm of the Arab world — an almost permanent state of war with family, tribal, religious, sectarian and national conflicts.
There simply is no tradition of the non-violent settlement of conflict,’ Netanyahu said. ‘The key to peace? When do the Arabs make peace with each other?’… ‘Israel’s real crime has nothing to do with the Palestinians.
What we are guilty of is being the only non-Arab, non-Moslem people who have succeeded in defying the Arab dominance of the southern Mediterranean in creating a non-Arab national entity.’”
“Spare tank supplies assembled on a helicopter pad are readied for shipment back to Israel at the start of the Israeli pullout from southern Lebanon. Soldiers in the background wait for the trip home.”
Netanyahu as ambassador to the U.N., interviewed at length in 1985, setting out the Jordan-is-Palestine position and refusing the term West Bank. The reporter notes in his own voice where the claims are disputed.
U.S. says murdered Palestinian symbolizes peace dangers
By R. Gregory Nokes, AP Diplomatic Writer
WASHINGTON (AP) — At a time when Arab leaders are trying to organize a new Mideast peace initiative, American experts say a murder in Jordan last Dec. 29 points up what moderate Palestinians risk when they seek peace with Israel.
The murder of Fahd Kawasmeh stands as a symbol — but it may have also backlashed against those who wanted to still the voice of moderation among Palestinians.
Until he joined the Palestine Liberation Organization in November, becoming a top lieutenant of Yasser Arafat, the 48-year-old Kawasmeh was seen by U.S. officials as a candidate to play a key role in future talks with Israel. Indeed, that quality may have made him a murder victim.
Kawasmeh, a former mayor of Hebron on the West Bank, had regular contacts with U.S. officials, even meeting with Secretary of State George P. Shultz in November 1982. Those contacts ended, officials say, when Kawasmeh joined the PLO.
Kawasmeh was killed by two gunmen outside his home in Jordan, where he lived after Israel expelled him from the West Bank in 1980 for allegedly inciting anti-Israel acts. While most suspicion centers on Syrian-backed Palestinian radicals, State Department analysts say Israel also had reasons to want him out of the way.
Arafat, who attended Kawasmeh’s funeral, accused Syria of masterminding the murder. Like many moderate Palestinian leaders, Kawasmeh was caught between the two countries, which despite their own conflicts, share a common hostility to Arafat’s PLO.
Kawasmeh’s family had requested that he be buried in Hebron, but Israel conditioned such a burial upon release of three POWs being held by the Jibril faction of the PLO. The demand was not met. U.S. officials had privately urged Israel to allow the burial and were dismayed when it did not occur.
Kawasmeh was said to have escaped an assassination attempt by Israeli extremists in 1980 only because the government had expelled him a short time before. Two other West Bank mayors were gravely wounded in a series of attacks on Palestinian mayors that were seen as reprisals for the death of six Israelis at Hebron.
Although the murder of Kawasmeh was thought to have been a warning to Arafat and moderate Palestinians not to get involved in peace talks with Israel, some U.S. officials and Middle East analysts believe it may have had the opposite effect.
Bill Quandt, a Mideast expert at the Brookings Institution who knew Kawasmeh, said there are signs of a “backlash” by West Bank Palestinians who were outraged by the murder. He said they may have become more forceful in challenging radicals who oppose any settlement with Israel.
The verb in the headline is murdered, of a Palestinian, in 1985. The man is named in the second paragraph: Fahd Kawasmeh, 48, former mayor of Hebron, expelled by Israel in 1980 and shot outside his home in Jordan. The copy records that his family asked to bury him in Hebron and that Israel made the burial conditional on a prisoner release that did not happen.
Israel Said to Seize Control Over 52% Of West Bank Land
By THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN, Special to The New York Times
JERUSALEM, March 31 — The Israeli Government has seized direct or indirect control of 52 percent of the land on the occupied West Bank, according to an authoritative study issued today.
The study is entitled “Land Alienation in the West Bank: A Legal and Spatial Analysis” and was produced by the West Bank Data Base Project, headed by a former Deputy Mayor of Jerusalem, Meron Benvenisti.
The study contends that the Israeli Government has assumed effective control over more than half of the West Bank and that it has monopolized virtually all the growth potential in the occupied territory for Jewish use. It also maintains that the Government has accomplished this through questionable legal tactics.
“The study gives an up-to-date picture on how far Israeli land expropriation on the West Bank has gone,” Mr. Benvenisti said in an interview. “The Israeli Government has used every legal ruse to gain control of the land. Virtually all of the Arab land that can be confiscated has been confiscated.
The Jewish settlers are now left with all of the growth potential on the West Bank and the Arabs solely with that land that they have cultivated.” Mr.
Benvenisti’s research, which is financed by the Ford and Rockefeller Foundations, is generally considered by both Arabs and Israelis to be the most authoritative and exhaustive on the West Bank and is quoted by both proponents and opponents of the Israeli
PLO Propaganda Offensive Becomes Intense in Argentina
BUENOS AIRES — Starting with a public manifestation commemorating Nov. 29 as the “International Day of Solidarity with the Palestinian People,” PLO propaganda has become more intense in Buenos Aires, culminating with a New Year’s Day statement by the president of the Argentine-Arab Foundation. The Nov.
29 public meeting took place in a municipal hall and included among its speakers the pro-government parliamentarian Horacio Huarte and Peronist parliamentarian Antonio Paleari, who suggested that President Raul Alfonsin be requested by Parliament to recognize the PLO. The Jewish Movement for Human Rights took part in the Nov. 29 meeting, responding to a very warm invitation.
A United Nations day of solidarity, observed in a municipal hall in Buenos Aires with two members of parliament speaking and a Jewish human rights group attending by invitation, filed as a propaganda offensive. The invitation is described in the copy as very warm.
SIDON, Lebanon — Moslem fighters seized a chain of villages abandoned by Christian militias on Friday, and Palestinian refugees swarmed in behind them, stripping the houses bare in a four-hour frenzy of looting. Tens of thousands of Christians fled deeper into the hill country east of this ancient port.
“They took everything of any value they could move and then burned the houses and shops as soldiers watched,” said one witness. “I've never seen so many happy, laughing gunmen. No one could live there now.” Young Palestinian fighters and refugees from nearby camps ran through the narrow, smoke-filled streets.
They broke into houses, some of which were still burning, and carried off everything that was loose or could be ripped free. They took refrigerators, radios, sofas, carpets, chandeliers, even toys and tableware. “We're not stealing,” said a young Palestinian as he heaved furniture into a battered pickup truck.
“We're only doing what the Christians have been doing to us for a long time.” At least five people were reported killed and 35 wounded in scattered clashes as the Moslem militiamen and Palestinian fighters surged into the towns above Sidon behind the Christian retreat.
Christian radio stations reported that as many as 75,000 Christians were fleeing from the Sidon area inland toward Jezzine. No independent confirmation was available, because reporters were kept out of the town by members of the Lebanese Forces, the Christian militia. The Maronite archbishop of Sidon, Ibrahim el Helou, appealed for urgent government intervention.
He addressed his appeals to Lebanon's Christian president, Amin Gemayel, and Prime Minister Rashid Karami, a Sunni Moslem.
Lebanese militia fighters exchange machine-gun fire
BEIRUT, Lebanon — Lebanese Christian and Moslem fighters battled with machine guns and rocket-propelled grenades in central Beirut on Saturday and one soldier was reported killed. Police said the soldier was slain when his position along the “Green Line” that divides the Lebanese capital into east and west was hit by machine-gun fire.
Fighting between Lebanon’s civil-war antagonists has flared for three months along the three-mile-long dividing line. In the Palestinian refugee camp of Bourj el-Barajneh in south Beirut, Moslem Shiite militias held to a Syrian-sponsored truce for the fourth day. The Shiites had besieged the camp and two others for a month, overrunning one.
Nearly 600 people were killed and 2,500 wounded in the fighting. Bulldozers were brought in Saturday to flatten sandbagged positions around the camp’s entrances after a field meeting was held between officials of the Shiite Amal militia and Palestinians under the supervision of Syrian observers.
Police said five wounded Palestinians were moved from the nearby Chatilla camp as Lebanese police prepared to take over security in the battered shantytowns.
A Palestinian amputee fires explosives with a slingshot
NAIROBI, Kenya (UPI) — Israel has denied travel permits to five Palestinian women in the occupied Arab territories who were invited to attend the U.N. Decade for Women conference, a PLO representative said today.
The General Union of Palestinian Women, the women’s branch of the Palestine Liberation Organization, said Israel barred the women in response to a request by the Reagan administration. Salwa Abu Khadra, who heads the group, told reporters at the PLO headquarters in the Kenyan capital that the women live in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip…
“Security Reasons”. Khadra said their applications to travel to attend the U.N. conference and the non-governmental meeting that started today were turned down because of “security reasons.”… “Mr. Reagan himself is involved in the action of depriving some groups of women from coming here to share in the conference.
It is all part of their strategy to bar our women. Israel decided to go along with the action requested by the United States,” Khadra said.
Khadra identified the women as Samiha Khalil, president of the Family Resurgence Society in El-Bireh; Zahira Kamal, a teacher and general-secretary of the Union of Women’s Work Committees in Jerusalem; and Siham Barghuti, Ni’mah al Helon and Amal Wahdan, all women social workers and women’s rights activists.
The earliest security-reasons clipping here, and the phrase is already in quotation marks. Six Palestinian women are named in it; the record had held two.
· The New York Times · page A1, continued on Page A6, Column 5
U.S. ASSERTS ISRAEL CAN'T VETO TALKS WITH PALESTINIANS
REJECTION OF LIST AT ISSUE — Washington Clearly Annoyed at Reaction to the Names Submitted by Arafat
By BERNARD GWERTZMAN
WASHINGTON, July 18 — The Reagan Administration said today that while it would take the views of Israel into account, it would not give it a veto over whether the United States should meet with a joint Jordanian-Palestinian group to set the stage for eventual peace talks with Israel.
A State Department spokesman asserted that if such a meeting would advance the prospects for direct negotiations between Israel and a Jordanian-Palestinian delegation, “we will do it.” “If it will hinder the goal of direct negotiations,” the spokesman, Robert M. Smalley, said, “that obviously is something we will try to avoid.”
Annoyed by Israeli Rejection Evidently annoyed by reports that Israeli leaders had rejected a list of seven candidates suggested by Yasir Arafat, leader of the Palestine Liberation Organization, the State Department also sought to reassure Jordan that the United States remained interested in such a meeting.
“In considering the prospect of a meeting between the United States and a Jordanian-Palestinian group, we will be guided by these considerations,” Mr. Smalley said. “Our decision will be taken in light of consultations with our friends in the area, but it will be our decision.” He put particular emphasis each time on the word “our.”
“The question of a veto over our decisions by one or another of the parties has come up,” he said, alluding to Israel. “This is not the way we proceed.” Arab Paper Publishes List In Jerusalem, an Arab newspaper published a list of the proposed Palestinian candidates. The Israelis rejected the list Wednesday after they got it from the American chargé d'affaires.
Today, Foreign Minister Yitzhak Shamir and an official close to Prime Minister Shimon Peres denounced the list as an effort to legitimize the P.L.O. [Page A6.] American officials said the decision on what to do about a meeting with a Palestinian-Jordanian group would be made in coming days. Secretary of State George P.
Shultz is to return soon from an Asian tour, and Richard W. Murphy Jr., Assistant Secretary of State for Near Eastern and South Asian affairs, returns from vacation on Friday.
They will have to look at the names, consider the Israeli reaction, and decide whether to set the date for a meeting, decide against a meeting or seek further names and clarifications from the Jordanians, State Department officials said. On Wednesday, the United States provided Israel with the list of Palestinians, which had been submitted by King Hussein of Jordan.
He, in turn, had been given the list by Mr. Arafat last week. From the list, about four were to be chosen for inclusion in the Jordanian-Palestinian group. Israeli officials immediately denounced the list as including members of the Palestine Liberation Organization or the Palestine National Council, the legislative arm of the P.L.O.
The United States has said it would not deal with P.L.O. members but would consider talking to council members who are not members of the organization. The names on the list published in Israel were confirmed by American officials.
Names and Backgrounds Listed Here are the seven Palestinians and their backgrounds, as made available by the Palestine Research and Education Center in Washington: Khaled al-Hassan, a founder of Al Fatah, the leading organization affiliated with the P.L.O., who is currently the chief foreign affairs spokesman for the Palestine National Council.
Faiz Abu Rahmeh, former head of the bar association in the Gaza Strip. Hatem Husseini, former head of the Palestine Information Office in Washington and a member of the Palestine National Council, who now teaches at Shaw University, Raleigh, N.C.
Saleh al-Taamri, member of Al Fatah, former P.L.O. leader in southern Lebanon, who is married to a former wife of King Hussein; he lives in Tunis. Nabil Shaat, member of the Palestine National Council, prominent member of the P.L.O. and close adviser to Mr. Arafat; he lives in Cairo. Hanna Seniora, editor of the Arab newspaper Al Fajr, published in East Jerusalem.
Henry Kattan, lawyer and historian, who lives in Paris. Of the names published in Israel, and confirmed here, three seemed to meet the American conditions: Mr. Abu Rahmeh, Mr. Seniora, and Mr. Kattan. The others appear to be known for their P.L.O. affiliation. For example, Mr. Hassan, as a founding member of Al Fatah, and Mr.
Shaat, as a P.L.O. leader, are evidently unacceptable. So are Mr. Husseini, the former head of the Palestinian Information Office here, and Mr. Taamri, the former guerrilla chief. Within hours, Prime Minister Peres said on television that he found the Palestinians unacceptable.
Foreign Minister Shamir, who is known to oppose any such talks by the United States, was even harsher in his comments.
JERUSALEM, July 18 — An Arab newspaper in Jerusalem today published a list of names of Palestinians suggested by Yasir Arafat for inclusion in a joint Jordanian-Palestinian delegation for preparatory Middle East peace talks with the United States.
The list of six names, which was confirmed by senior Israeli officials, included some prominent figures in the Palestine Liberation Organization.
Contrary to Israeli radio and television reports on Wednesday, which said that nobody from the West Bank or Gaza was included, the list contained one West Bank Palestinian and one Gaza resident, neither of them leading political figures. [. . . intervening paragraphs on the Israeli reaction and on Prime Minister Peres and Foreign Minister Shamir are not transcribed here . . .] First was Hanna Siniora, the editor of a pro-Arafat East Jerusalem daily, Al Fajr.
A Christian Palestinian, Mr. Siniora was educated in the United States and has had frequent fights with the Israeli military authorities over violations of censorship. His newspaper has been closed or banned from distribution on numerous occasions for publishing Palestinian nationalist articles that military officials deemed anti-Israeli. Mr.
Siniora is not known to have any formal links to the P.L.O. While not among the top rung of the traditional leadership in the occupied territories, he is considered by Palestinians to be a serious person who would be ready to participate in peace negotiations with Israel. In an interview with Israel’s army radio, Mr.
Siniora made it clear that he saw the primary purpose of the Jordanian-Palestinian delegation to be opening a dialogue with Washington that could pave the way for peace talks with Israel. “It is the role of the P.L.O. to negotiate the final borders of the Palestinian state,” Mr. Siniora said.
“The Palestinians believe that the state of Israel exists and to reach peace we have to talk to the Israelis.” Lawyer From Gaza Second on the list was Faiz Abu Rahmeh, a lawyer from the Gaza Strip and until recently the head of the Gaza Chamber of Advocates. A cousin of a deposed Mayor of Gaza, Rashad Shawwa, and a pro-Arafat loyalist, Mr.
Abu Rahmeh is also not considered to be among the traditional leaders of the Palestinians within the Israeli-occupied territories. He is also related to Khalil al-Wazir, Mr. Arafat’s chief military deputy. Third was Khaled al-Hassan, a member of the P.L.O. Central Committee. Mr. Hassan is one of the founders, with Mr. Arafat, of the Al Fatah guerrilla organization.
For many years he has lived in Kuwait. He is known as a moderate within P.L.O. circles and is one of Mr. Arafat’s closest advisers. Fourth was Hatem Husseini, former director of a P.L.O. information center in Washington connected with the Arab League.
Fifth on the list was Saleh al-Taamri, a former P.L.O. guerrilla leader in southern Lebanon who spent more than a year in Israel’s Ansar prison camp before being freed in a prisoner swap in Nov. 1983. Mr. Taamri is married to King Hussein’s first wife, Dina, and is believed to be residing in Cairo. He is considered to be an articulate, pro-Arafat, Palestinian nationalist.
Adviser to Arafat Sixth was Nabil Shaat. One of Mr. Arafat’s chief political advisers, Mr. Shaath resides in Cairo and is a well-known Palestinian moderate and member of the Palestine National Council, which functions in effect as a parliament for the P.L.O.
Two other names were being suggested by West Bank Palestinians as possible alternates or observers in the delegation: Henry Kattan, a lawyer and expert on the Palestinian legal claims, and Fayez Sayigh, a Palestinian economist and scholar. Both are believed to reside in Europe.
SYRIA TO OVERSEE BEIRUT AIRPORT SECURITY: Municipal workers in West Beirut removing posters and graffiti from wall as part of Syrian-backed program to bring peace to Lebanon. The Lebanese Government said yesterday that Syrian advisers would also supervise a security plan for the international airport, now being boycotted by the United States.
JERUSALEM (AP) — A court on Monday sentenced three members of an underground Jewish gang to life in prison for killing three Palestinians, and 12 others to lesser terms for attacks on Arabs in the occupied West Banks. The defendants, most of whom are Jewish settlers, claimed they acted in self defense and said they would appeal for presidential pardons.
Foreign Minister Yitzhak Shamir, leader of the conservative Likud bloc, has recommended clemency, and an opinion poll indicated most Israelis favor it. Defendants, their families and supporters responded with defiant shouts and songs when the sentences were pronounced in the heavily guarded courtroom.
Announcement of the sentences by the three-judge court ended a 13-month trial that brought into question the government’s security policies in the West Bank of the Jordan River, which Israel captured in the 1967 Middle East war.
The three defendants sentenced to life were convicted July 10 of killing three Palestinian students and wounding 33 in a 1983 shooting spree at Islamic University in Hebron, south of Jerusalem. The 12 others, also convicted July 10, received sentences of from four months to seven years in prison, plus suspended terms.
Bassam Shakaa, the ousted Palestinian mayor of Nablus whose legs were blown off by a car bomb planted by the Jewish underground in 1980, called the trial a sham. He said the punishments were lenient “for political reasons.” “These punishments will not stop such crimes,” Shakaa said in a telephone interview.
Members of the underground ring, the largest Jewish terror group in Israel’s history, won widespread symapthy for their argument that the government was lax in responding to Palestinian violence against Jews who lived in the occupied territories.
“I learned during the trial that there is a difference between law and justice,” said Menachem Livni, 35, a reserve army explosives expert who was the ringleader. “What we did, taking the law into our own hands, was wrong. But you cannot ask someone to sacrifice his life on the altar of law and order,” he said.
Judge Shmuel Finkelman said the court took Arab terror attacks into account in sentencing. He noted that the car bomb attacks an Shakaa and two other Palestinian mayors followed a terrorist attack that killed six settlers in Hebron.
The charge of causing grievous bodily harm carries a maximum 20-year sentence, but the defendants charged with the car bombing were given only three years. Five settlers received up to 45 months for planting bombs in five Arab-owned buses in Jerusalem. Thwarting the attack helped police crack the ring in April 1984.
Ten other members of the terrorist band are serving sentences of up to 10 years imposed in separate plea bargaining arrangements, and two more have completed jail terms. The lengthy trial created widespread controversy about the settlement program that has moved 50,000 Israelis into the West Bank in 18 years.
A policeman grabs the hand of Shaul Nir, one of three people sentenced Monday in Jerusalem to life imprisonment for murdering Palestinians at a West Bank university. Nir’s wife and infant child stand nearby. (UPI/Reuter photo)
NAIROBI, Kenya (AP) — Kenya’s host delegation negotiated a compromise Friday on a resolution that had threatened to undo the U.N. Decade for Women conference on its final day by equating Zionism with racism.
The new language struck the word Zionism from the resolution, which was adopted by consensus of the 3,000 delegates with the grudging acquiescence of Israel’s enemies and praise from its friends. Alan Keyes, the only male U.S. delegate, told the conference the Americans accepted the resolution after insisting the reference to Zionism be stricken.
His comments drew catcalls and some applause. “We reject the obscene notion that Zionism is racism,” Keyes said.
“No matter how much that slanderous lie is repeated, no amount of reiteration shall ever lend it any truth whatever.” Zehdi Labib Terzi, the Palestine Liberation Organization observer at the United Nations, said the PLO would accept the language to save the conference, but stood by its belief that Zionism and racism were synonymous.
“After hearing some threats and blackmail in this forum, we understand exactly what the circumstances are.
But we are willing to accept the amendment made by the host country,” Terzi said.… The delegates had adopted 94 of 372 paragraphs of a proposed document — called Forward-Looking Strategies — mapping the course of women’s advancement to the year 2000.
Then the Zionism issue threw the session into disarray Friday night and forced it past a midnight deadline for adjournment and an end to the decade the United Nations dedicated to women’s issues.
Three weeks before this, the archive holds a wire story reporting that Israel had refused travel permits to five Palestinian women invited to this conference, for security reasons. Here is the conference itself, ending past midnight, with the word struck out and a document about women’s advancement to the year 2000 left ninety-four paragraphs into three hundred and seventy-two. Neither story mentions the other.
United Press International, Hebron, Occupied West Bank
Boxed explainer beside the headline: “SOURCE OF FRICTION IN AN ANCIENT LAND. Differences of religion, language and national identity keep bitter dispute going. Moderate Israelis don’t want to see Arabs pushed out of area Jews seized in 1967.”
And in the copy: “an Arab city in the Israeli-controlled West Bank… ‘We will continue with additional actions until there are thousands of Jews in Hebron. We have a timetable.’”
Four inches apart on one page: the dateline says the territory is occupied, and the box explaining why any of this is happening answers ancientness and difference. Nothing in the box is false. A reader would come away believing they had been told the cause, and the cause they were given is one nobody is responsible for.
“Some of the 1,000 Arabs and Jews who paraded Saturday through Umm al Fahm, Israel. The marchers were protesting the views of Rabbi Meir Kahane and discrimination against the country’s Arabs.”
Kahane had driven to Umm al-Fahm to urge its residents to leave Israel. A thousand people walked through the town against him, Arabs and Jews together, and the Times ran the photograph. Kahane’s party was barred from the next election; the position outlived him.
JERUSALEM — Two assailants stabbed an Israeli in the back Thursday in the occupied Gaza Strip as Jewish settlers torched Arab houses in the occupied West Bank in retaliation for a series of attacks on Jews, authorities said.
In a wave of escalating violence in the territories Israel has occupied since 1967, Moshe Fitousi, 25, was stabbed three times in the back and shoulder by two assailants when he stopped his truck at a gas station in Gaza’s Palestine Square, military officials said. Fitousi, of Beersheba, was taken to a hospital by helicopter. He was in critical condition after surgery.
Military sources said soldiers imposed a curfew in the area and rounded up suspects. A witness to the roundup, who would not reveal his name, said about 500 people were detained.
In the occupied West Bank city of Hebron, Jewish settlers torched Arab houses and daubed them with slogans such as, “You are fair game,” and “Jews will live here,” in retaliation for attacks on Israelis.
The houses belong to Palestinians freed in May by Israel as part of an unpopular swap of 1,150 Arab and other prisoners for three Israeli prisoners of war. Recent attacks on Israelis include the stabbing Tuesday of two Israeli soldiers at Hebron’s market. One of the soldiers died.
Last month, a Jewish settler at Hebron was stabbed and wounded and a rabbi was stabbed near Jerusalem’s old city one week ago, prompting Israeli officials to warn Jordan it would attack Palestinian guerrilla centers in Amman if members were not expelled from that country.
The Palestine Liberation Organization denied involvement in Tuesday’s stabbings, saying the attacks were simply reactions to Israel’s “repressive measures.” Israel has responded to the violence by detaining 62 West Bank Palestinians without trial in the last two weeks.
It also ordered 25 Palestinians deported, but their expulsions were delayed pending appeals. The Jewish settlers want to expand the Jewish presence at Tel Rumeida and link it with Jewish neighborhoods they want built in the Arab city of Hebron, home to 60,000 Arabs. They also want 600 recently freed Arab prisoners deported on grounds that they are behind the attacks on Jews.
UNITED NATIONS — The Reagan administration deplored rising violence in the Middle East, but was in apparent disarray over whether Israel was justified in bombing a PLO facility in Tunisia. Secretary of State George P. Shultz criticized the Israeli raid Tuesday in a speech to the foreign ministers of six Persian Gulf countries during the annual special session of the U.N.
General Assembly. “We need to be clear in our opposition to the acts of violence from whatever quarter they come, and without respect to what is the presumed rationale for them,” Shultz said.
But President Reagan, in remarks to reporters at the White House, took a different view of the air strike which destroyed the headquarters of PLO chief Yasser Arafat and killed between 30 and 60 people. Reagan said nations have the right to retaliate against terrorist attacks “as long as they pick out the people responsible.”
Asked if the Israelis had met that test, Reagan said: “I always had great faith in their intelligence.” Officials at the United Nations with Shultz said they understood that Israel intended the attack against the Palestine Liberation Organization as retaliation for terrorist slayings of Israeli citizens.
However, the officials voiced concern that the “pattern of violence” would detract from efforts to arrange a peace settlement in the Middle East.
Meanwhile in Hamam Plage, Tunisia, hundreds of Tunisian and Palestinian rescue workers searched for bodies in the bombed-out ruins of the Palestine Liberation Organization headquarters today after a raid by Israeli warplanes. Yasser Arafat, head of the PLO, vowed to retaliate for Tuesday’s attack, and Tunisia demanded a meeting of the U.N.
Security Council to condemn the raid. Palestinian officials said at least 45 members of the PLO headquarters staff and some 20 Tunisians were killed in the raid. The PLO has said about 100 people were injured.
TUNIS, Tunisia (UPI) — Palestine Liberation Organization leader Yasser Arafat led thousands of mourners yesterday at the funeral of 17 Palestinians killed in the Israeli air raid on PLO headquarters near Tunis. In Paris and Bern, Switzerland, parades protested the attack.
In an interview published today in the Egyptian newspaper Al Ahram, Arafat accused President Reagan of personally approving the Israeli raid in an attempt to assassinate him. The mass funeral, which was attended by senior Tunisian officials, came a day after the U.N. Security Council passed a resolution condemning Israel for Tuesday’s attack.
Arafat, who was out jogging during the attack on his headquarters, addressed the crowd in a choked voice, saying the attack had “mixed Palestinian and Tunisian blood.” “I especially regret that Tunisia was the victim of the Israeli attack,” he said. “This is not the first time for us, we are used to it.”
At least 73 were killed and 100 injured in Tuesday’s raid, carried out by eight Israeli F-15 jet fighters. Israel said the attack was in retaliation for the Yom Kippur killings of three Israelis in Cyprus. Arafat told Al Ahram the raid was Reagan’s response to a Middle East peace proposal made by the PLO and Jordan.
The PLO chief said he remained committed to the PLO-Jordanian initiative, but vowed to “find new ways to impose our just peace” and vowed to escalate action against Israel. “We need a complete reassessment,” Arafat said. “What happened was not simply a raid by Israeli warplanes.
It is a premeditated American-Israeli operation, approved by President Reagan, to assassinate the chairman of the PLO.” “Isn’t the message clear? Doesn’t it mean that they do not want peace?” Arafat also called for an emergency Arab summit “to deal with the gauntlet that was hurled at the face of all Arabs.”
The mourners, many of them women and children, jammed streets near the leveled headquarters as uniformed Tunisian soldiers and PLO fighters marched solemnly past carrying 17 coffins aloft. The United States, which initially called the Israeli raid a “legitimate act of self-defense,” has since backed off that approval.
Washington abstained in Friday’s Security Council vote, allowing the resolution condemning the attack to pass 14-0. Bourguiba praised the U.S. move in a statement Saturday.
“Yasser Arafat embraced mourner at funeral for Palestinians killed in Tunisia” United Press International.
A photograph of a man embracing a mourner runs above a headline that is about what an American president approved. Seventy-three people were killed; seventeen coffins are carried past in the copy. The United States called the raid a legitimate act of self-defense and then abstained four days later, which the story records in consecutive paragraphs.
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y., Oct. 10 — A Palestinian leader, Farouk Kaddoumi, said today that the killing of an American aboard the hijacked Italian cruise ship was “a big lie fabricated by the intelligence service of the United States.” Mr.
Kaddoumi, who heads the Political Department of the Palestine Liberation Organization, made the comment to reporters after a Security Council meeting on the Middle East. He declined to say whether the hijackers were in P.L.O. custody and, if so, whether the organization would turn them over to a sovereign state for prosecution.
He suggested that the P.L.O., Egypt and Italy might form a joint court to try the four hijackers since the Palestinians “don’t have a territory under which we can treat these people.” “Let’s have a joint court,” he said. “I don’t have any objection to that.” Mr.
Kaddoumi, in addressing the Security Council, suggested that the American victim, Leon Klinghoffer, might have died of natural causes. “Is there any evidence that those hijackers had killed that civilian?” he said. “Where is that evidence?” Noting that Mr. Klinghoffer was 69 years old and suffered frequently from heart attacks and paralysis, Mr.
Kaddoumi said he wondered “how and why” the hijackers should attack or kill “such an old person.” He said that the P.L.O. had cooperated in ending the hijacking and that Mr. Arafat had sent his condolences to the Klinghoffer family, even though “there is no proof so far that he was murdered.”
Gerardo de Rosa, the captain of the Italian ship, has told Italian television that a hijacker, who had blood on his clothing, admitted killing a passenger.
The Security Council meeting today, originally called by nations professing nonalignment to debate the Palestine question, was dominated by a discussion of the hijacking of the Italian ship and Egypt’s release of the four hijackers to the P.L.O. In the afternoon, Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel told the Security Council that Mr.
Klinghoffer and his wife “were singled out for one thing — because they are Jewish.” He said the hijacking of the cruise ship had been carried out “with the full and prior knowledge” of Mr. Arafat, whom Mr.
Netanyahu accused of “trying once again to turn a P.L.O.-initiated terrorist operation that failed into a personal victory for himself.” Vernon A. Walters of the United States, in a general statement about terrorism, said nationals of countries “represented around this table” had been “brutally slaughtered” by terrorists.
“They include a Soviet diplomat, an American sailor, as well as private citizens of Israel, Jordan, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and many other countries,” he said, adding that nationals of France, Britain, the Soviet Union, the United States and other countries were still held hostage, an allusion to people kidnapped in Lebanon. Mr.
Walters did not mention the Tunisian and Palestinian victims of Israel’s aid raid last week on the P.L.O. headquarters in Tunis. “There is today no people, no government, no diplomat, no traveler who can count himself immune from the terrorists,” he said. “They are the enemies of us all.”
AT THE U.N.: Vernon A. Walters, after a speech calling terrorists “enemies of us all,” listening to the P.L.O. representative. | SPEAKING FOR THE P.L.O.: Farouk Kaddoumi calling account of American’s death “a big lie fabricated by . . . the United States.”
Aged Victim, Portrayed as Helpless, Is Recalled as a Strong, Happy Man
By SARA RIMER
Leon Klinghoffer has become known around the world as the frail, elderly American shot to death in his wheelchair and thrown overboard from an Italian cruise ship in the Mediterranean.
But yesterday, as they awaited the arrival of his widow in the Manhattan apartment where so much had been shared, his daughters and other relatives talked about the Leon Klinghoffer who was most of all a strong family man.
“He was a contented, happy man,” said his mother-in-law, Rose Windwehr, who met him 40 years ago when her nephew brought him to dinner at her home in East Orange, N.J. “He loved his friends and family.” Gathered together at 70 East 10th Street, Mrs. Windwehr and Mr.
Klinghoffer’s daughters — Ilsa, 28 years old, and Lisa, 34 — and the others consoled themselves by remembering, not how Leon Klinghoffer had died but how he had lived. They looked at photographs of him and his wife Marilyn and the children, and they laughed at small memories, like his fondness for the television show “Dynasty.”
“He was addicted to ‘Dynasty,’” Lisa said. “Joan Collins — wow!” Lisa, an artist whose oil paintings fill the apartment, remembered how her father encouraged her during a difficult period in her career. “A couple of weeks ago — and I’ll never forget this — he sat me down,” she said.
“He said, ‘Lisa, you have to have faith in yourself. It’s going to happen for you.’”
HEADING HOME: Mildred and Frank Hodes, at left, and Viola Meskin waiting in Cairo for a military flight back to United States. U.S. officials said Mrs. Hodes had been targeted for death by hijackers.
· San Francisco Examiner · San Francisco · page A-10
Arab activist killed by Santa Ana bomb
EXAMINER NEWS SERVICES
SANTA ANA — Arab and Jewish organizations condemned a bombing that killed an Arab-American civil rights activist as the FBI began to investigate whether a terrorist group committed the attack. The bomb yesterday ripped apart the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee’s local office, killing the group’s West Coast leader, Alex Odeh.
Odeh had called PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat “a man of peace” in an interview the night before. The 41-year-old Odeh was regional director of the committee, a 13,000-member organization of Arab-Americans that fights discrimination against people of Arab descent. Eight other people were injured in the blast, police said.
Seven received hospital treatment and all were released yesterday from Western Medical Center. Odeh, a Palestinian-born naturalized U.S. citizen, died at the hospital about 2½ hours after the 9 a.m. blast. No one claimed responsibility for the attack and no one has been arrested.
Attorney Richard Ayoob, a director of the National Association of Arab Americans, said Odeh was “very committed to the idea of dialogue with the leading Jewish organizations. . . . It would be hard for me to think anyone would harm a hair on his head.” • Alan S.
Katz and Adrian Scharlach, regional presidents of the American Jewish Congress in Southern and Northern California, respectively, condemned the attack in a joint statement. “We extend our condolences and sympathies to the families of Alex Odeh and those wounded by this inexcusable act of terrorism,” the statement said.
“No political disagreement, no matter how critical or deeply felt, justifies attacks on those engaged in peaceful and lawful pursuits.”
Alex Odeh is taken from the bombed offices of his committee. He later died in a hospital | Alex Odeh / Activist who described Yasser Arafat as ‘man of peace’
Seven Injured in Explosion at Offices on West Coast — J.D.L. Praises Action
SANTA ANA, Calif., Oct. 11 (UPI) — A bomb demolished the offices of the Arab-American Anti-Discrimination Committee today, killing the organization's regional executive director and injuring seven other people.
The explosion. at 9 A.M.. blew out windows on the second story of the three-floor office building, scattering glass on the sidewalk and in the street, Fire Chief William Reimer said. Alex Odeh, regional director of the Arab group, died in surgery about 11:30 A.M. at Western Medical Center. Mr. Odeh, a resident of Orange, was 37 years old.
The seven people who were injured were treated and released. No one claimed responsibility for the bombing. The Arab-American committee is a Washington-based organization founded in 1980 to combat racial stereotypes that Americans of Arab descent say have led to discrimination against them.
Threats Termed Not Uncommon Joseph Haiek, publisher of the Glendale-based New Circle magazine, which specializes in Arab-American affairs, said it was not uncommon for the organization to receive threats. “You have people that don't want others to talk and they threaten them,” he said.
The Jewish Defense League, often at odds with the group, denied responsibility for the bombing but praised the action. Irv Rubin, chairman of the J.D.L., said Mr. Odeh had been interviewed on television about the slaying Tuesday of Leon Klinghoffer, a 69-year-old tourist from New York City who was held hostage aboard the hijacked ship Achille Lauro in the Mediterranean.
Israel has linked the hijacking to the Palestine Liberation Organization. “Odeh appeared on television to whitewash the P.L.O. murder of Klinghoffer,” Mr. Rubin said. “No Jew or American should shed one tear for the destruction of a P.L.O. front in Santa Ana or anywhere else in the world.”
Adjacent Buildings Evacuated The police evacuated buildings on both sides of the office building that was bombed, and demolition experts searched for more bombs. Agents from the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms were investigating the explosion, said John Hoos, an F.B.I. spokesman.
Dino Tunoa, a carpenter working in the building next door said he heard the blast and ran into the building to help the victims. “When I ran upstairs, the whole place was torn apart,” Mr. Tunoa said. “When I looked at it, I realized there was an explosion and we started getting everyone out.”
SANTA ANA, Calif. (AP) — As the FBI began investigating links between telephoned threats to an Arab-American rights group and a bombing that killed its regional director, both Arab and Jewish organizations condemned the attack.
A bomb Friday ripped apart the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee's local office, killing Alex Odeh, 41, the West Coast leader of the 13,000-member organization. Odeh, in an interview the night before, had called PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat “a man of peace.” Eight others were injured in the blast, police said.
Seven received hospital treatent and all were released Friday from Western Medical Center. Odeh, a Palestinian-born naturalized U.S. citizen, died at the hospital about 2½ hours after the 9 a.m. blast. No one claimed responsibility for the attack.
Attorney Richard Ayoob, a director of the National Association of Arab-Americans, said Odeh was “very committed to the idea of dialogue with the leading Jewish organizations.... It would be hard for me to think anyone would harm a hair on his head.” Alan S.
Katz and Adrian Scharlach, regional presidents of the American Jewish Congress in Southern and Northern California, condemned the attack in a joint statement: “We extend our condolences and sympathies to the families of Alex Odeh and those wounded by this inexcusable act of terrorism.
No political disagreement, no matter how critical or deeply felt, justifies attacks on those engaged in peaceful and lawful pursuits.” Before the attack, the committee had told the FBI of receiving harassing telephone calls, and the agency has “assumed investigative jurisdiction” of the bombing, FBI spokesman John Hoos said in Los Angeles.
“Our investigation will be targeted toward determining if a terrorist group was responsible for this,” Hoos said. Odeh, interviewed by KABC-TV news Thursday night, defended the Palestine Liberation Organization's role in negotiating an end to Monday's hijacking of the Italian cruise ship Achille Lauro and killing of an American.
The four pirates surrendered to PLO representatives in Egypt on Wednesday. U.S. Navy jets intercepted the plane in which the Palestinians hoped to escape Thursday, forcing it to land in Sicily, where they were arrested. Members of a dissident offshoot of the PLO claimed responsibility for the hijacking.
Odeh said in the televised interview, “I think the media mistakenly linked this incident with the PLO. “The media ought to give the PLO and Arafat recognition. Inform the public about the PLO as a political organization and Arafat in particular as the chairman of the PLO, who is a man of peace.” In Washington, D.C., former U.S. Sen. James G.
Abourezk of South Dakota, national chairman of the ADC, condemned the bombing. “Those people injured in the Santa Ana bombing, including Alex Odeh, are innocent people. They are being made scapegoats for an act committed by four people in the Middle East with whom they have had no connection whatever,” he said.
Referring to a similar bombing at an ADC office in Boston last August, Abourezk said: “The Jewish Defense League initially claimed responsibility in a telephone call, but later withdrew the claim when news reports reported a policeman was injured.”
Irv Rubin, national chairman of the JDL, denied any role in Friday's bombing, but said, “The Jewish Defense League cannot cry about the act that occurred this morning. “Our tears have all been used for the mourning of Leon Klinghoffer, a 69-year-old, wheelchair-bound Jew who was brutally slaughtered and his remains thrown into the Mediterranean by PLO terrorists.”
SANTA ANA, Calif. — The bombing of a pro-Arab group’s offices that killed its director Friday was condemned Saturday by the White House and Palestine Liberation Organization leader Yasser Arafat.
No one has taken responsibility for the blast at the headquarters of the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee that killed Alex Odeh, 41, the group’s West Coast regional director. However, group members and Odeh’s family believe the bombing was linked to Odeh’s defense of the PLO in two TV interviews Thursday night.
“The administration deeply deplores this tragic event, and condemns in the strongest possible terms the criminal use of violence and terrorism to achieve political ends,” White House deputy press secretary Larry Speakes said in a statement Saturday.
“To think even for a moment that there exists a justification for such heinous acts does grave injustice to the principles of political freedom upon which this country was founded. The President extends his sincere condolences to Mr. Odeh’s widow, Norma, and his three small daughters, as well as to other members of the family,” the statement said.
Arafat told a news conference in Dakar, Senegal, that the bombing of the offices and the U.S. interception of an Egyptian plane carrying four Palestinians suspected of hijacking the Italian cruise ship Achille Lauro were “both terrorist acts.” “I want to denounce the attack in California against pro-Palestinian activists,” Arafat said.
“This was carried out by a band of terrorists protected by the American administration. As yet, the United States has not arrested these criminals.”
Mohammed Abbas, the Palestinian guerrilla leader sought by the United States in connection with the cruise ship hijacking, is a man in his early 40’s who has been a key strategist within the faction-ridden Palestinian guerrilla forces.
Using the code name Abul Abbas, the mustachioed, broad-shouldered 6-footer has been an active Palestinian guerrilla since 1965, when he joined a small, Jordan-based group called Vengeance. Last month he was chosen secretary general of an anti-Syrian faction of the Palestine Liberation Front at the group’s meeting in Tunis.
He and his faction are allied with the chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, Yasir Arafat. But in the last 10 years, his loyalties have shifted among various Jordanian, Syrian, Libyan and Iraqi-backed guerrilla groups as the fortunes of the Palestinian cause have risen and fallen.
Israeli officials have attributed to him the planning and organizing a 1979 raid on Nahariya in northern Israel by a four-man Palestine Liberation Front force. Four Israelis, including two children, were killed in that raid.
Arab-Americans irate over blast that killed teacher in California
By JAY MATHEWS
SANTA ANA, Calif. — His friends and relatives say he was the gentlest of men, a poet who spent what free time he had with his wife and three daughters, enjoying the parks near their Orange County condominium. He had received threats, but he was an American now in a free and mostly peaceful country.
He only occasionally took precautions, such as carefully checking his mail. What worried him were his trips back to his village on the Palestinian West Bank, where his 80-year-old father told of Israeli soldiers harassing the men in the cafes.
So when Alex Odeh, West Coast regional director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC), approached the door of his second-floor office in Santa Ana Friday, thoughts of a violent death were probably far from his mind. According to local authorities and his relatives, a tripwire attached to the door set off the bomb that tore through the lower part of his body.
The explosion was so great that it showered the palm-lined street below with concrete, torn curtains and glass. Seven people in adjoining offices or on the street were slightly injured. Two hours later the bald, soft-spoken 41-year-old author and college instructor was dead. Emergency surgery had failed to save him.
His death has caused a wave of indignation from Arab Americans who are convinced that ignorance and insensitivity within the U.S. government and news media helped inspire Odeh’s killers.
In the view of Odeh’s closest friends and harshest critics, a key to the attack was an interview he gave a local television station the day before the blast and the way the station edited the interview to match heightened public interest in the Palestinian hijacking of an Italian ocean liner and the murder of an wheelchair-bound, elderly American on board.
In the few seconds of an interview broadcast Thursday night on KABC-TV, Odeh suggested the Palestine Liberation Organization and its chairman, Yasser Arafat, had no role in the hijacking.
“The media ought to give the PLO and Arafat recognition, inform the public about the PLO as a political organization and Arafat in particular as the chairman of the PLO, who is a man of peace,” he said.
In segments of the interview that were not broadcast, according to ADC’s Los Angeles chapter president David Habib, Odeh “condemned the hijacking of the ship, condemned terrorism around the world. . . .” “Yet they decided to broadcast a little part that seemed to show Alex Odeh and the ADC are a pro-Arafat organization.”
A KABC spokeswoman declined to comment. When a relative later expressed fear of reaction to the interview, Odeh reportedly asked, “Why are you worried?” “He was a very quiet, very gentle man,” said Lisa Odeh, his sister-in-law.
“We had some fear that something might happen to him in Israel, but we never thought this would happen in the United States.” Santa Ana police, joined by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms and the Los Angeles police anti-terrorist division in the investigation, say that they have no suspects in the bombing.
But the KABC interview clearly made an impression on some people. Leaders of the Jewish Defense League, asked for comment after the bombing, denied involvement but lambasted Odeh for speaking well of the PLO. “I have no tears for Mr. Odeh,” said JDL leader Irv Rubin. “He got exactly what he deserves.”
The violent death of Alex Odeh left his friends and family outraged. His sister-in-law said, “We had some fear that something might happen to him in Israel, but we never thought this would happen in the United States.”
Palestinian Says Hijackers Told Him They Didn’t Kill Anyone
By EDWARD SCHUMACHER
TUNIS, Oct. 13 — Mohammed Abbas, the Palestinian leader wanted by the Reagan Administration on charges of organizing the hijacking of the Italian cruise ship Achille Lauro, said today that the hijackers had told him they did not kill anyone. Mr.
Abbas said that if Leon Klinghoffer, a 69-year-old wheelchair-bound American, died in the hijacking, it was probably because of a heart attack. Mr. Abbas also said that he had had nothing to do with the hijacking but that he would seek to free the four hijackers, now being held in Italy, so they could be tried in a Palestinian court.
He said the four told him they acted on their own. Mr. Abbas, leader of a faction of the Palestine Liberation Front, spoke in a long telephone interview from Belgrade, Yugoslavia. He flew to Belgrade on Saturday night from Rome, where Italian authorities ignored an American extradition request and allowed him to leave. the country.
“My plans are to keep resisting, fighting and asking for the peace process and our sovereign rights,” Mr. Abbas said. He spoke through an interpreter, Ahmed Ben Bella, an official of the Palestine Liberation Organization, the umbrella organization headed by Yasir Arafat. Mr. Abbas’s group is a member of the P.L.O. Mr.
Abbas’s wife, Rim, 30 years old, stood by in Tunis during the half-hour interview. Mr. Abbas, a tall, mustachioed man in his early 40’s, was sent by Mr. Arafat to negotiate the surrender of the four hijackers.
He was accompanying them on a plane out of Egypt when the plane was intercepted by American F-14 jet fighters from the Sixth Fleet and forced to land in Sicily. The United States has charged Mr. Abbas with complicity in the murder of Mr. Klinghoffer and has submitted an extradition request to Yugoslavia. “If someone really died, which I doubt,” Mr.
Abbas said today, “then for sure it was a matter of a heart attack and the responsibility of the captain.” He said that the four hijackers were unsure if anyone died but that they assured him they had not killed anyone. They told him that the fright and chaos on board immediately after the four seized the ship might have provoked a heart attack.
“When they were asked if they killed anyone,” he said, “they replied, ‘We are fighters for freedom, not killers, kidnappers or hijackers.’” He said the four told him they had not intended to hijack the ship. He said they had planned to sneak into the Israeli port of Ashdod when they were discovered on board.
He said proof of their intentions was that they treated the crew and passengeres in a “nice way” and did not harm any of several Israeli passengers who he said were on board. Asked about his own role, Mr. Abbas said: “I knew nothing about such kind of an operation being organized.
When I asked where they got the order, they said, ‘We decided to do it ourselves and on our own.’”
BLOOD STAINS?: An Egyptian investigator, on ladder, taking sample from possible blood stain from the side of the Achille Lauro yesterday in Port Said.
Bombing death links ‘gentle’ man to anti-Arab violence
By Jay Mathews
SANTA ANA, Calif. — He was the gentlest of men, his friends and relatives said, a poet who spent what free time he had with his wife and three small daughters, enjoying the parks near their Orange County condominium and snapping dozens of pictures of his girls.
He had received threats, to be sure, but he was an American now in a free and mostly peaceful country, and he only occasionally took precautions, such as carefully checking his mail. What worried him were his trips back to his village on the Palestinian West Bank, where his 80-year-old father told of Israeli soldiers harassing the men in the cafes.
So when Alex Odeh, West Coast regional director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, approached the door of his second-floor office here Friday on a beautiful, smog-free morning, thoughts of violent death were probably far from his mind.
According to authorities here and his relatives, a tripwire attached to the door apparently set off the bomb that tore through the lower part of his body. The explosion was so great that it showered the palm-lined street below with concrete, torn curtains and glass, and slightly injured seven people in adjoining offices or on the street.
Two hours later the bald, soft-spoken 41-year-old author and college instructor was dead. Emergency surgery had failed to save him.
In the wake of his death has come a wave of indignation from Arab Americans across the country who are convinced that ignorance and insensitivity within the U.S. government and the American news media had helped inspire Odeh's killers, as yet unidentified.
In the view of both Odeh's closest friends and harshest critics, a key trigger to the attack was an interview he gave a local television station the day before the blast and the way the station edited the interview to match heightened public interest in the Palestinian terrorist hijacking of an Italian ocean liner.
In the few seconds of an interview broadcast Thursday night on KABC-TV, Odeh suggested that the Palestine Liberation Organization and its chairman, Yasser Arafat, had no role in the hijacking.
“The media ought to give the PLO and Arafat recognition, inform the public about the PLO as a political organization and Arafat in particular as the chairman of the PLO, who is a man of peace,” he said.
In segments of the interview that were not broadcast, according to ADC Los Angeles chapter President David Habib, Odeh “condemned the hijacking of the ship, condemned terrorism around the world ... yet they decided to broadcast a little part that seemed to show Alex Odeh and the ADC are a pro-Arafat organization.” A KABC spokeswoman declined to comment.
When a relative later expressed fear of reaction to the interview, Odeh reportedly asked, “Why are you worried?”
SANTA ANA, Calif. — He was the gentlest of men, his friends and relatives said, a poet who spent what free time he had with his wife and three small daughters, enjoying the parks near their Orange County condominium and snapping dozens of pictures of his girls.
He had received threats, to be sure, but he was an American now in a free and mostly peaceful country, and he only occasionally took precautions, such as carefully checking his mail.
What worried him were his trips back to his village on the Palestinian West Bank, where his 80-year-old father told of Israeli soldiers harassing the men in the cafes, making some stand on one leg for a long time.
So when Alex Odeh, West Coast regional director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC), approached the door of his second-floor office Friday on a beautiful, smog-free morning, thoughts of violent death were probably far from his mind.
According to authorities and his relatives, a tripwire attached to the door apparently set off the bomb that tore through the lower part of his body. The explosion was so great that it showered the palm-lined street below with concrete, torn curtains and glass and slightly injured seven people in adjoining offices on the street.
Two hours later the bald, soft-spoken 41-year-old author and college instructor was dead. Emergency surgery had failed to save him.
In the wake of his death has come a wave of indignation from Arab Americans across the country who are convinced that ignorance and insensitivity within the U.S. government and the American news media had helped inspire Odeh's killers, as yet unidentified.
In the view of both Odeh's closest friends and harshest critics, a key trigger to the attack was an interview he gave a local television station the day before the blast and the way the station edited the interview to match heightened public interest in the Palestinian terrorist hijacking of an Italian ocean liner and the murder of an elderly American on board.
In the few seconds of an interview broadcast Thursday night on KABC-TV, Odeh suggested that the Palestine Liberation Organization and its chairman, Yasser Arafat, had no role in the hijacking.
“The media ought to give the PLO and Arafat recognition, inform the public about the PLO as a political organization and Arafat in particular as the chairman of the PLO, who is a man of peace,” he said.
In segments of the interview that were not broadcast, according to ADC Los Angeles chapter president David Habib, Odeh “condemned the hijacking of the ship, condemned terrorism around the world ... , yet they decided to broadcast a little part that seemed to show Alex Odeh and the ADC are a pro-Arafat organization.” A KABC spokeswoman declined to comment.
When a relative later expressed fear of reaction to the interview, Odeh reportedly asked, “Why are you worried?” “He was a very quiet, very gentle man,” said Lisa Odeh, his sister-in-law. “We had some fear that something might happen to him in Israel, but we never thought this would happen in the United States.”
Santa Ana police and the FBI said they had no suspects, but a spokesman for the Jewish Defense League, which Arab-American leaders have accused of harassment in the past, denied any involvement and said the organization “has nothing to do with this at all.”
Odeh wrote poetry in Arabic, and a volume of his work, “Whispers in Exile,” was published by The New Circle magazine two years ago. Part of one poem, translated by ADC staffer Wafa Nasr, reads: Lies are like still ashes . When the wind of truth blows, The lies are dispersed like dust and disappear .
At least we all owe thanks To the one who tries to speak, write or paint An honest thought to the world. Former Sen. James G. Abourezk, D-S.D., national chairman of the ADC, said: “Alex Odeh was a peaceful, non-violent man who was a good citizen and who tried to do his best for the United States by peacefully debating the issues of the Middle East.”
He accused President Reagan and American newscasters of exacerbating a threatening atmosphere toward Arabs, and said Odeh left a wife and three daughters with no insurance and “literally nothing to live on.”
White House spokesman Larry Speakes said, “The administration deeply deplores this tragic event and condemns in the strongest possible terms the criminal use of violence and terrorism to achieve political ends.”
Barbara Shahin, ADC deputy executive director in Washington, particularly chastised American newspapers, including the Washington Post, for running short wire-service accounts of Odeh's death while devoting pages to stories on the shipboard hijacking and murder. “This was an American killed on American soil by American terrorists,” she said.
Odeh was born in the West Bank village of Jifna to a Roman Catholic family, came to the United States as a student, returned to Jifna to marry Norma in 1975 and became a U.S. citizen in 1977. He taught Arabic at a community college and leaves three daughters, Helena, 7, Samia, 5, and Susan, 2.
Odeh's sister, Angelia (center), after news of bombing — AP Laserphoto. Second, smaller portrait of Alex Odeh captioned simply “Odeh.”
Santa Ana, Calif. — He was a gentle man, his friends and relatives said, a poet who spent what free time he had with his wife and three young daughters, enjoying the parks near their Orange County condominium and snapping dozens of pictures of his girls.
He had received threats, but he was an American now in a free and mostly peaceful country; and he only occasionally took precautions, such as carefully checking his mail.
So when Alex Odeh, the West Coast regional director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC), approached the door of his second-floor office here Friday morning, thoughts of violent death were probably far from his mind.
According to authorities here and his relatives, a tripwire attached to the door apparently set off the bomb that tore through the lower part of his body.
In the wake of his death has come a wave of indignation from Arab-Americans across the country who are convinced that ignorance and insensitivity within the U.S. government and the news media helped inspire Odeh’s killers, as yet unidentified.
In the view of both Odeh’s closest friends and harshest critics, a key trigger to the attack was an interview he gave a local television station the day before the blast.
In the few seconds of an interview broadcast Thursday night on KABC-TV, Odeh suggested that the Palestine Liberation Organization and its chairman, Yasser Arafat, had no role in the Palestinian terrorist hijacking of an Italian cruise ship and the murder of an elderly American passenger. He characterized Arafat as “a man of peace.”
In segments of the interview that were not broadcast, according to ADC Los Angeles chapter president David Habib, Odeh “condemned the hijacking of the ship, condemned terrorism around the world . . . yet they decided to broadcast a little part that seemed to show Alex Odeh and the ADC are a pro-Arafat organization.” A KABC spokeswoman declined to comment.
“He was a very quiet, very gentle man,” said Lisa Odeh, sister-in-law of the bald, soft-spoken 41-year-old author and college instructor. “We had some fear that something might happen to him in Israel, but we never thought this would happen in the United States.” Santa Ana police, joined by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the U.S.
Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms and the Los Angeles police antiterrorist division in the investigation, say that they have no suspects in the bombing. Leaders of the Jewish Defense League, asked for comment after the bombing, denied any involvement but lambasted Odeh for speaking well of the PLO. “I have no tears for Mr. Odeh,” said JDL leader Irv Rubin.
coming to the rescue. Palestinians are captives of each other’s embrace, their futures intricately woven together. Israelis fear for their own existence and debate what to do with 1.2 million Palestinians under their control. And Palestinians, searching for ways to win a homeland and freedom, grow more bitter.
When he started his car on the morning of June 2, 1980, a bomb exploded, ripping off his left foot. Members of an Israeli Jewish underground were convicted of the crime and are serving prison terms.
SNUGGLED ALONG the Bethlehem-Hebron road a few miles south of Jerusalem, Dheisheh refugee camp is a teeming burr in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, a mirror of the gloomy mood that has gripped Palestinians, Israelis and the Middle East.
“Of course, I think I’ll leave this camp, but I don’t know when,” said Ibrahim Sajada, 33, an unemployed laborer who has lived there for all but two of his 33 years.
As he sipped coffee in his modest living room and fretted about the lack of work, which has made things tough for him and his six children, a neighbor, Ahmet Salah, 38, complained about violence against the Palestinians. Jamal Abu Sabah, 23, a college student who said he had spent three years in an Israeli prison for belonging to an underground group, nodded in agreement.
Dheisheh’s residents generally say they have been terrorized by Jewish settlers who have shot at them. Jews counter that they have been attacked and stoned by refugees, leading to threats by some Israeli politicians to move the camp’s 6,000 residents far from any major highways.
THE RISING violence against Jews — 100 attacks in Israel and the occupied areas since January, a doubling from last year — fuels Israeli anxieties about what to do with the West Bank and Gaza Strip, now occupied for 18 years.
Israelis on the right, such as Ariel Sharon, the former defense minister, call for a crackdown on Palestinians and for bombing attacks on what he calls “terrorist bases in Jordan.” But Israelis at the political center and on the left fret about tearing their nation apart.
Zeev Schiff, a military correspondent for the independent daily newspaper Ha’aretz, wrote recently that what Rabbi Meir Kahane “says with racist explicitness, the (West Bank) settlers say with righteous indignation. Both will lead to another civil war in this land, unless a political solution to the conflict between us and the Palestinians is found.”
But no solution acceptable to all — or even to most — has yet been put forth by any party to the conflict. Tired of living with the problem, and unsure of any solution, some Israelis wish it would simply go away.
Achmed Hashimiyeh hugs his son, Amir, 3, in their home in the Old City section of Jerusalem, where he has lived since 1948. He and many of his brothers and sisters were born in Al Baka, a village west of Jerusalem, but his parents fled the area during the war in 1948. At left, Mahadya Karake, 80, sits on the roof of her home in the Old City, where she has lived all her life.
In the background is the mosque where she prays five times daily.
Finally, the West should recognize the evil nature of the PLO
By Benjamin Netanyahu
“New York — If nothing else, the Achille Lauro incident should have opened the West’s eyes to the true nature of the Palestine Liberation Organization. The trouble is that, even when faced with absolute evil, the mind refuses to accept what can be plainly seen.
Thus in the 1930s, when reports of the unspeakable crimes committed in the Soviet gulags reached the West, there were some who attributed them to ‘irresponsible’ elements in the Soviet secret police.
How else if not by this mechanism of denial can we explain the world’s willingness to believe Yasir Arafat’s claims that he is ‘against terrorism’? That the hijacking of the Achille Lauro was committed by his ‘enemies’? That he only wanted to ‘mediate’ the hostages’ release and ‘punish’ the culprits?
In fact, the Achille Lauro was commandeered by PLO terrorists whose direct commander, Mohammed Abbas, is one of Arafat’s closest deputies.
Yet even when Abbas’s men bungled the operation, Arafat thought he could get off without blame: The killers were to be spirited out of Egypt to PLO headquarters in Tunis, while Arafat basked in Western applause for ending the crisis.
His image as a moderate reinforced, he would then make his anticipated appearance at the United Nation’s 40th anniversary celebration. Fortunately, for once it didn’t work. The terrorists were swiftly apprehended by the United States. Freed hostages described how the killers hailed Arafat as they beat elderly passengers.
Intercepted communications between the murderers and their commander revealed they were not renegades but minions of the PLO. The evidence of Arafat’s complicity became overwhelming.
Less than 48 hours after he had offered condolences to the family of the slain hostage, Leon Klinghoffer, he denied that a murder had taken place, then threatened the United States for bagging his gunmen. Seldom has there been a more dramatic unmasking of murder and duplicity. But this was hardly the first time that Arafat tried such a ploy.
He discovered long ago that a little diplomacy and deception go a long way to assuage the West’s unease about PLO terrorism — that talk of ‘moderation’ and ‘diplomatic options’ can often erase the memory of the most heinous crimes.
Thus, it has become a cornerstone of his policy to disavow such crimes even while issuing the orders to carry them out. He first resorted to this tactic in 1970, disavowing the supposedly uncontrollable ‘splinter group’ Black September, most notorious for the slaughter of 11 Israeli athletes at the Munich Olympics.
The PLO itself later admitted that the group had been under Arafat’s direct command. In 1979, another ‘mysterious’ Palestinian group seized Egypt’s Embassy in Turkey. Arafat negotiated the release of hostages with terrorists who later turned out to be his own men. Arafat does not always disavow knowledge and responsibility.
In other cases, PLO spokesmen proudly claim credit. In the last year alone, Arafat launched some 600 terror attacks against innocent civilians, killing and severely wounding 75 Israelis — shoppers, cab drivers, teachers, tourists and the PLO’s abiding favorite, children.
Yet, incredibly, many in the West persist in being duped, in treating the PLO as a legitimate government, in accepting its emissaries and exerting pressure on Israel to establish a PLO state on its border.
Such people don’t seem to understand that the destruction of Israel remains the PLO’s unchanging goal, reconfirmed every year in its charter and repeated explicitly by Arafat’s deputies.
As recently as May, Abu Nazir, a leader of Al Fatah, said: ‘When we demand the establishment of a Palestinian state, or even a Jordan-PLO confederation, this is a strategy leading to the establishment of a state over all of Palestine. The “phased policy” provides us with a springboard towards further goals.’
Another senior deputy, Khaled Hassan, explained: ‘While the “phased policy” prescribes accepting anything possible during the first phase, we are determined to carry on the battle until the final goal is attained. The struggle will be long and will be decided only when Zionism is annihilated.’
It is one thing for Arab countries to promote the PLO as a cover for their own refusal to make real peace with Israel. It is another for Western governments to parrot endless incantations about Arafat’s ‘reasonableness’ and ‘moderation.’
By now, it should be clear enough that the PLO is not a political organization that dabbles in terrorism but a terror organization that dabbles in politics. As for the peace process, if it depends in any measure on the PLO, it will never lead to peace. Benjamin Netanyahu is Israel’s permanent representative to the United Nations.”
An Oliphant cartoon runs beside the column: a long-faced figure outside a barred window marked PRIGIONE ITALIANO, with faces behind the bars, a small aside reading ‘One for us’ and the caption ‘You made my day.’
Netanyahu under his own byline in an American daily, six years after the conference his foundation convened in Jerusalem and five months before an American news agency printed the Arab League’s answer to it. The last line is the construction the whole project was built to produce: not a political organization that dabbles in terrorism but a terror organization that dabbles in politics. He is identified at the foot of the column by his office, not as an author.
Leon Klinghoffer has been mourned and eulogized across the United States. But what about Alex Odeh? Three days after Klinghoffer was killed aboard the cruise ship hijacked by Palestinian terrorists, a bomb went off at the Southern California headquarters of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee. Regional director Alex Odeh died in surgery hours later.
With massive publicity enshrining Klinghoffer as a hero, his family has received outpourings of sympathy, including personal phone calls from the president. But Odeh — another American citizen whose family grieves in the wake of violent hatred — drew sparse media attention and perfunctory condolences from the White House.
Yet the killing of Alex Odeh in Santa Ana is as much a tragedy as anything else that has happened these past weeks. Predictably, the leadership of the fringe Jewish Defense League — every bit as bloodthirsty as any hijacker — has been upbeat about the bombing that killed Odeh.
Lumping all Arabs together, JDL chairman Irv Rubin declared: “The person or persons responsible for the bombing deserves our praise for striking out against the murderers of Americans and Jews.”
The White House said that it “deeply deplores this tragic event and condemns in the strongest possible terms the criminal use of violence and terrorism to achieve political ends.” Officials of the American Jewish Congress and the Anti-Defamation League of B’nai B’rith issued similar statements. But such regrets have a hollow ring.
Israel routinely uses deadly violence “to achieve political ends.” On Oct. 1, for instance, American-built F-15s bombed an undefended headquarters of the PLO near Tunis — killing more than 60 Palestinians and Tunisians. Reagan immediately expressed support for the Israeli air attack.
For nearly 20 years Israel’s occupation of the West Bank has rendered many thousands of Palestinians homeless, often brutalizing them in the process. Out of desperation and anger, some Palestinians have turned to violence and even terrorism. It is a dynamic that Israeli officials should well understand.
Waging a campaign for a Jewish homeland four decades ago in Palestine, some Zionist groups engaged in bloody actions that were, indeed, terrorism.
Two Americans died at the hands of terrorists last week. One death received great attention; the other was barely noted. Leon Klinghoffer, the retired New York businessman killed by the Achille Lauro hijackers, became known overnight.
We learned of his early years with immigrant parents who owned a New York hardware store, of his hard work and success in business, of his closeness to his family and circle of friends, of his charity and his dedication to Jewish causes.
Klinghoffer’s death and events that followed brought on an international crisis, soured relations between the United States and several friendly nations, dimmed hopes for progress toward peace in the Middle East and caused the Italian government to fall. Alex Odeh, 41, was the West Coast regional director for the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC).
Last week a Los Angeles television station broadcast a short snippet from a long interview with Odeh. In the half-minute chosen for broadcast, he defended the Palestine Liberation Organization and its chairman, Yasir Arafat. When Odeh opened the door to his Santa Ana, Calif., office the next morning, a bomb exploded. Two hours later he was dead.
News of Odeh’s killing came in short wire-service stories that gave the barest sketch of his life. Reaction was confined mostly to the Arab-American community, a situation that frustrates people like Noha Ismail, Minnesota’s ADC coordinator. In a letter on this page she challenges Americans for their seeming indifference to this terrorist act.
By all accounts, Odeh was a gentle, soft-spoken man, a poet, a college teacher and a defender of the Palestinian people. David Habib, president of the Los Angeles chapter of the ADC, said Odeh had devoted his life to fighting ignorance about the Middle East and discrimination against Arabs in the United States.
Odeh saw in callousness and insensitivity a challenge to work harder, not an excuse to get angry. “He was so used to it,” Habib said. “He just understood.” Odeh was born to a Roman Catholic family in the Palestinian village of Jifna, near Jerusalem. His father, a retired grocer, still lives there.
Odeh studied at Bir Zeit University and Al-Najah University on the West Bank and at the University of Cairo. He moved to the United States in 1972 and received a master’s degree in political science from the University of California at Fullerton in 1978. He taught Arabic and Middle East history at California colleges.
He was a member of an academic senate and the Los Angeles County Human Rights Commission. Odeh jealously guarded the too-little time he had for his wife, Norma, and his three daughters, Helena, 7; Samia, 5, and Susan, 2. Friends said the family particularly enjoyed the parks near their Orange County home. Odeh apparently earned a modest salary and carried no life insurance.
His death leaves his wife and daughters with very little. Leon Klinghoffer and Alex Odeh, both Americans, one of Palestinian heritage, one of Jewish, both victims of the terrible violence that dominates the Middle East. Noha Ismail is right: Americans should be outraged at both deaths; they should mourn both victims.
Tunisian Officials Leaving Doubt Whether Palestinian Can Return
By EDWARD SCHUMACHER
TUNIS, Oct. 19 — Remarks in recent days by Tunisian officials have caused confusion about whether a Palestine Liberation Front leader, Mohammed Abbas, will be allowed back into the country. Mr.
Abbas, who has been reported to be in various countries since he was allowed to leave Italy a week ago, is wanted by the United States on charges of masterminding the operation that led to the hijacking of the cruise ship Achille Lauro and the slaying of a 69-year-old American passenger, Leon Klinghoffer. The Administration has vowed to seek to extradite Mr.
Abbas, wherever he might be. If he were to return to Tunisia, that would add friction to the already touchy relations between the United States and the Government of President Habib Bourguiba. A personal envoy of President Reagan, Deputy Secretary of State John C. Whitehead, is to visit Tunisia, possibly Sunday, in an effort to assuage continuing resentment over Mr.
Reagan’s endorsement, which was later qualified, of the Israeli bombing of Palestine Liberation Organization headquarters here on Oct. 1. Mr. Whitehead is also expected to seek a clarification about Mr. Abbas, though the United States Embassy here declined on Friday to confirm or deny that Mr. Whitehead would come. Tunisia’s Prime Minister, Mohammed Mzali, the No.
2 man in the Government after Mr. Bourguiba, indicated in a news conference in Rome on Wednesday night that Tunisia might let Mr. Abbas return to his home in Tunis. “We don’t know,” Mr. Mzali said. But, according to a tape recording of the news conference, he added that Mr. Abbas “has not requested to come back and we have not asked.”
He said the P.L.O. was taking the Prime Minister’s remarks to mean “neither yes nor no” on whether Mr. Abbas would be permitted to come back. Many P.L.O. officials have said in recent days that they doubt Mr. Abbas would try to return to Tunisia as long as he remains a source of controversy. The officials said that neither Mr. Arafat nor Mr.
Abbas wanted to force an issue that might jeopardize their sensitive relations with Tunisian authorities. Mr. Bourguiba does not like the P.L.O. presence, but he appears to have accepted the advice of Mr. Mzali and his Cabinet not to evict the Palestinians, according to officials and other informed sources.
For the time being, the Government is said to be looking for increased military aid from Saudi Arabia, Algeria and other countries to compensate for allowing the P.L.O. to keep its headquarters here, the soures said. Mr. Abbas, 38 years old, is head of a faction of the Palestine Liberation Front, which is a member of the P.L.O.
His group and others in the P.L.O. that supported Mr. Arafat were expelled from Lebanon in 1983, and last year he moved his headquarters here from Baghdad. Mr. Abbas has lived here with his wife, Rim, and her child by a previous marriage.
President Reagan gave his personal pledge to the family of Leon Klinghoffer yesterday that the killers of the 69-year-old New Yorker would be brought to justice. In a solemn meeting with Mr. Klinghoffer’s widow, Marilyn, and other family members, at his tower suite at the Waldorf-Astoria, Mr. Reagan expressed his condolences and sorrow over their loss.
The President, who was joined by his wife, Nancy, delayed his return to Washington to hold the 20-minute session. The meeting came as Mr. Reagan completed three days of diplomatic activity in New York, including an address Thursday to the United Nations General Assembly. Mr. Reagan had made a similar vow in a message to the family when Mr.
Klinghoffer’s body arrived Sunday at Kennedy International Airport. Mr. Klinghoffer, a stroke victim confined to a wheelchair, was killed by terrorists who hijacked the Italian cruise liner Achille Lauro Oct. 7 off the coast of the northern Egyptian port city of Alexandria. Mr.
Klinghoffer’s body, which was dumped overboard the next day, later washed ashore near the Syrian port city of Tartus. At Mr. Reagan’s orders, United States Navy fighter planes intercepted an Egyptian commercial airliner that carried four men accused of hijacking the ship and escorted the plane to Italy.
The gunmen are awaiting trial in Italy, and the Administration has made a request to extradite them to the United States. At one point in the meeting yesterday, Mrs. Klinghoffer, who sat in a chair next to Mr. Reagan, reached across and touched his hand, saying of his instructions to intercept the plane, “I’m so proud of you for that decision.”
A White House official present at the meeting said Mr. Reagan replied, “I’m so proud of those young men,” referring to the Navy pilots conducting the mission. Mr. Reagan assured Mrs.
Klinghoffer “that justice would be done” after she said she hoped her husband’s killers would be brought to justice, Letty Simon, a family friend and spokesman, said. “He said he was of like mind,” Miss Simon said.
Nancy Reagan greeting Marilyn Klinghoffer as she and the President visited the widow of Leon Klinghoffer yesterday in New York. Mr. Klinghoffer was killed during the hijacking of the Italian cruise liner Achille Lauro.
Terrorism Killed a 2d American During the Achille Lauro Affair
To the Editor: Most of your front page and several inside pages on Oct. 12 were given over to the aftermath of the Achille Lauro hijacking, in the course of which Leon Klinghoffer was murdered.
On an inner page, it was recorded that the Santa Ana, Calif., offices of the Arab-American Anti-Discrimination Committee had been bombed, killing Alex Odeh, the committee’s regional director. Pity and horror are rightly awakened by the cruel murder of Mr. Klinghoffer, an elderly and health-impaired American.
Equal pity and horror should be felt by all of us to the murder of Mr. Odeh, a man in his early prime — and, if it matters, an American, too.
We should note with sharp agonized concern that the Santa Ana bombing and political murder seem to constitute the first spillover onto our own soil of terrorism to grow out of the far-away Middle Eastern conflict between Israel and the Palestinians.
It is, moreover, surely worthy of remark that (contrary to the stereotyped expectation) this importation of Middle Eastern-style terror bombing was directed not by, but against, an Arab-American group. This action has very properly been condemned by a number of Jewish and other organizations.
It is nevertheless true that in a despicable statement reported in your account, Irv Rubin, identified as chairman of the Jewish Defense League, is quoted as saying of the bombing that killed Mr. Odeh, “No Jew or American should shed one tear.” Well, I am not a Jew, but I am an American. As such, I do not need Mr. Rubin to tell me when to be sorrowful.
I sorrow for the deaths both of Mr. Klinghoffer and of Mr. Odeh. I am sorrowful that in the bombing that killed Mr. Odeh this brand of terrorism has been brought among us, here in America.
I hope that we will soon see in regard to the Odeh murder the kind and degree of horrified public excitement and maximal governmental reaction that have been evoked by the Klinghoffer murder. (If not, why not?) I hope also that a U.S.
Government that presents itself as resolved on destroying terrorism will keep a sharp eye on the Jewish Defense League, one of whose leaders, if your report is right, has uttered what I believe is the first public approval of political terror bombing in modern times in America. CHARLES L. BLACK JR. Sterling Professor of Law, Yale Univ. New Haven, Oct. 15, 1985
The family of Leon Klinghoffer, the 69-year-old Manhattan man who was slain during last month’s hijacking of the Italian cruise ship Achille Lauro, yesterday sued the Palestine Liberation Organization for $1.5 billion for “wanton and coldblooded murder.”
The suit, which asked for $100 million on each of 15 separate counts, was filed in State Supreme Court in Manhattan by the family’s attorney, Jay Fischer. In Federal District Court in Manhattan, Mr. Fischer filed a second suit against the owners of the the Achille Lauro, Chandris Italy Inc.; the Port of Genoa, and Club ABC Tours Inc.
The second lawsuit charged the defendants with failing to adequately insure the safety of Mr. Klinghoffer and his wife, Marilyn, while they were aboard the Achille Lauro. As examples of their negligence, the suit said that the defendants had not adequately inspected the luggage of the passengers or their passports.
The Federal lawsuit did not ask for a dollar amount, but for compensatory and punitive damages.
F.B.I. Says Jewish Defense League May Have Planted Fatal Bombs
By JUDITH CUMMINGS
LOS ANGELES, Nov. 8 — The Federal Bureau of Investigation said today that it had concluded the Jewish Defense League was “the possible responsible group” in recent bomb attacks against an Arab leader in California and two East Coast men with purported Nazi ties. Two of the attacks resulted in deaths.
The national leader of the Jewish Defense League, Irv Rubin of Los Angeles, said today that his group had nothing to do with the bombings. The most recent bombing, in Santa Ana, Calif., last month, killed Alex M. Odeh, the 41-year-old leader of an Arab-American organization, and injured seven people. Bombing Death in Jersey The other fatal bombing occurred Aug.
15 at the Paterson, N.J., home of Tscherim Soobzokov, who was a member of the German Nazi Waffen SS. Mr. Soobzokov died of injuries suffered in the bombing. His wife, daughter, a 4-year-old grandson and a neighbor were injured. On Sept. 6, a bomb injured a passerby at the Brentwood, L.I., home of Elmars Sprogis, a former Latvian police officer once acused of Nazi war crimes.
For the first time the bureau officially classified the Santa Ana bombing as a terrorist act. Such designation is given when a group claims responsibility for an attack or when a bureau investigation establishes that it was an act of terrorism.
An investigation by the bureau's anti-terrorist squad identified the militant Jewish Defense League as “the possible responsible group,” said Lane Bonner, a spokesman for the bureau in Washington. Law-enforcement agencies on the East and West Coasts have been participating in the investigations. No arrests have been made, and bureau offi—
“Ten years ago, on Nov. 10, 1975, the United Nations General Assembly adopted a resolution branding Zionism as racism. Adoption of this resolution was tantamount to declaring Israel an illegitimate state based on an illegitimate philosophy… By an almost unbearable coincidence, the resolution was passed on the anniversary of Kristalnacht, Nov.
10, 1938… Now 37 years later, in the very institution established to eliminate violence from international life, the Jewish state was marked for destruction.… To appreciate the full significance of the Zionism-is-racism resolution, it is necessary to understand the meaning of ‘racism’ and ‘aggression’ in U.N. usage. In the language of the United Nations, ‘racism’ is the ultimate political crime, the ultimate violation of human rights.
A state based on racism is then an outlaw state, unworthy of membership in what is euphemistically termed the ‘family of nations.’ A racist state has no rights at all, not even the right to defend itself.… Thus, the Zionism-is-racism resolution declared open season on Israel.
Henceforth, Israel would be fair game for armed ‘liberation.’… the Soviet Union has played a substantial role in the campaign to delegitimize Israel by co-sponsoring the original Zionism-is-racism resolution and 10 years later, at the Nairobi conference on the Decade of Women, is still pushing that famous equation.”
A former American ambassador to the United Nations marks the tenth anniversary and sets out, more plainly than anyone else in this archive, why the word mattered: in that building racism is the charge from which no state is permitted to defend itself. Her example of where the formula had surfaced most recently is the women’s conference at Nairobi. She spells it Kristalnacht.
In the same week that Leon Klinghoffer was murdered in the Mediterranean for the crime of being Jewish, Alex Odeh was murdered in California for the crime of being an Arab. Mr. Odeh, a Palestinian by birth, was killed by a bomb on Oct. 11 when he opened his office door in Santa Ana, where he was West Coast director of the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee.
On television the day before, while condemning the Achille Lauro hijacking, he had defended the P.L.O. leader, Yasir Arafat. The Odeh murder was immediately denounced by the Anti-Defamation League of B’nai B’rith as “domestic terrorism which cannot be tolerated.”
A disturbingly different judgment was offered by Irv Rubin, chairman of the Jewish Defense League: “I have no tears for Mr. Odeh. He got exactly what he deserved.” Despite these words, the league denies any part in the crime and indignantly rejects as slander the F.B.I.’s preliminary finding that it is “the possible responsible group.”
It will take a trial to determine who killed Mr. Odeh. No trial is needed to ascertain the character of the Jewish Defense League, a promoter of blatant racism in America and Israel. Mr. Rubin was named U.S. chairman by the league’s founder, Rabbi Meir Kahane, who immigrated to Israel and now sits in its Parliament as the choice of 1.2 percent of the voters.
Rabbi Kahane derides Arabs as “dogs” and “jackals” and says they must be driven from Israel with “their luggage of abomination.” In a sordid, unintended parody of Nazi ideology, he advocates making Israel ethnically pure. To defend its democracy against racism, Israel is changing its election laws to try to disqualify Mr.
Kahane’s party. But the J.D.L. also poses a moral and political problem for the United States. A life is a life, and there can be no distinction between the murder of a Jew by the P.L.O. and the murder of an Arab to punish the P.L.O. When Mr. Rubin condones the killing of Mr. Odeh, he dishonors the memory of Mr. Klinghoffer.
He needs to be reminded that anti-Semitism is odious whether practiced against Jew or Arab. The way to drive that message home is to bring Mr. Odeh’s killers to justice.
Palestinians Go on Trial Monday In Genoa on Charges in Hijacking
By JOHN TAGLIABUE
GENOA, Italy, Nov. 13 — Five Palestinians will go on trial here Monday in connection with the hijacking last month of the cruise ship Achille Lauro, magistrates announced today. The men will face charges of owning and illegally importing to Italy the guns and explosives they are said to have later used to seize the ship.
A separate investigation is under way into the hijacking of the ship and the slaying of an elderly American passenger, Leon Klinghoffer of New York. A date for a second trial on those charges is to be announced later. Under Italian law, charges involving illegal possession and use of firearms and explosives can be separated from a larger bundle of charges and heard separately.
Four of the men are charged with being the hijackers. They were seized the night of Oct. 10 when an Egyptian airliner carrying them from Cairo was forced by American warplanes to land at a military air base on Sicily. The fifth man, arrested by the Italian police in September on charges of carrying false passports, was later implicated in preparations for the hijacking.
The four suspected hijackers were identified as Magied Youssef al-Molqi, 23 years old, who was born in Jordan; Ahmad Marrouf al-Assadi, 23, born in Damascus, Syria; Ibrahim Fatayer Abdelatif, 20, born in Beirut, Lebanon; and Bassam al-Ashker, 19, born in Tripoli, Lebanon. The fifth man was identified tentatively as Mohamed Kalaf, 25, born in Damascus, Syria. Mr.
Kalaf had previously been identified as Mohammed Zainab. In addition, the prosecutors made public new details about the hijacking and preparations for it that they said had emerged from their investigations. If convicted on the weapons charges, he said, the men could face jail sentences of 3 to 12 years and fines.
The hearing will be conducted before a panel of three judges in a special high-security courthouse here. It is expected to last only one day.
Luigi Carli, the prosecutor in the scheduled trial, said he would summon eight witnesses, all Italians, and present other evidence, including photographs of the weapons said to have been used — four Soviet-designed Kalashnikov automatic rifles, eight hand grenades and nine detonators.
The magistrates said they could not give a starting date for the principal trial, in which the defendants would be tried for the events directly related to the hijacking and the slaying of Mr. Klinghoffer.
Two days ago, the magistrates let it be known that they had issued nine more arrest orders for suspects in the hijacking case, bringing to 16 the total number of warrants issued to date. One of those orders was for Mohammed Abbas, the Palestine Liberation Organization official whom Washington has claimed was the mastermind of the hijacking operation.
Seven men, including the five to stand trial next week, are in Italian custody. The others are at large.
In recent days, justice officials here have said that testimony by the men in custody and other evidence seemed to indicate that preparations for the hijacking may have begun as long ago as 10 months, and that they involved scouting the cruise ship and reconnoitering its crew by Mr. Molqi and another Palestinian, who used the name Petros Floros and is still at large.
GENOA, Italy, Nov. 20 (UPI) — One of four Palestinians accused of hijacking the Italian cruise ship Achille Lauro will have to be tried separately by a juvenile court because it has been learned he is 17 years old, legal officials said today.
A six-year, seven-month sentence given the youth this week on hijacking-related weapons charges will also have to be annulled, the officials said. He will have to be retried in the court for defendants under 18. The officials identified the hijacker as Bassam al-Ashker. When he was arrested at the Sigonella air base in Sicily, investigators recorded his birth date as Feb.
9, 1966, but further investigation proved he was born Feb. 9, 1968. Mr. Ashker’s Italian defense attorney said the correct birth date had been established by a check with the birth registry office in Tripoli, Lebanon, where he was born, and with the schools he attended in Beirut.
Fifteen other people are charged with involvement in the hijacking, in which an American from New York, Leon Klinghoffer, was killed.
WASHINGTON, Nov. 29 — A suspicious fire did major damage to the national headquarters of the Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee tonight, less than two months after the committee’s West Coast director was killed in a bombing, fire officials said.
A Fire Department spokesman, Ray Alfred, said much of the front of the building, in the Dupont Circle neighborhood, was destroyed in the blaze. No injuries were reported. James J. Zogby, the committee’s former director, said, “This seems to fit a pattern of activities that have been designed to harass, intimidate and spread fear.” On Oct.
11, the committee’s West Coast director, Alex Odeh, was killed by a bomb when he opened the door to his office in Santa Ana, Calif.
WASHINGTON, Nov. 30 — Fire Department officials said today that they were investigating the cause of a fire Friday night that damaged the offices of the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee. The fire damaged two adjoining buildings in the northwest section of the city near Dupont Circle. The buildings housed several tenants, including the committee.
The two-alarm fire burned out of control for about 45 minutes before firefighters brought it under control about 9 P.M., officials said. No one was injured.
“There’s too much there for it to have been accidental but not enough to declare it arson, so we are classifying it at the present time as suspicious,” Ray Alfred, a Fire Department batallion chief, said today.
Chief Alfred said the fire appeared to have started in offices of Susan Davis & Associates, a public relations concern that occupies the second floor of the two buildings, one of which has four floors and the other five. The buildings are adjoining brownstones whose common walls removed on the upper floors.
The Arab committee’s offices occupy the fourth floor of both buildings and the fifth floor of one. James J. Zogby, executive director of the committee from 1980 until last year, said he thought it was unlikely that Friday night’s fire was accidental. “We’ve seen too many for it not to be a pattern,” he said.
“At this point, it’s too many times.” He said he suspected the fire might have been directed at the committee’s offices by an anti-Arab hate group. “I just think it fits a pattern,” said Mr. Zogby, referring to harassment to which Arab advocacy groups have been subjected in recent years.
The most recent incident, he said, was the bombing of the committee’s West Coast office in Santa Ana, Calif., Oct. 11. Alex Odeh, the organization’s regional director, was killed in the blast. The Federal Bureau of Investigation said earlier this month that the Jewish Defense League might have been responsible for the explosion, but no arrests have been made.
The day before his death, Mr. Odeh, 41 years old, appeared in a television interview program where he defended Yasir Arafat, leader of the Palestine Liberation Organization. Mr. Odeh accused the news media of incorrectly linking Mr. Arafat to the hijacking of the Italian cruise ship Achille Lauro.
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y., Dec. 4 — Farouk Kaddoumi, an official of the Palestine Liberation Organization, said today that there was no evidence that the hijackers of an Italian cruise ship were responsible for the death of Leon Klinghoffer, an American tourist. “Perhaps it might be his wife who pushed him over into the sea to have the insurance,” Mr.
Kaddoumi said at a luncheon held by the League of Arab States to commemorate an International Day of Solidarity with the Palestinian People. Secretary General Javier Pérez de Cuéllar and the president of the General Assembly, Jaime de Piniés, were among the luncheon guests. Neither commented publicly on the remark. Referring to Mr. Klinghoffer, Mr.
Kaddoumi said, “One was killed and the campaign is spread over the world that the Palestinians are terrorist.” According to witnesses aboard the ship, Mr. Klinghoffer was shot by the hijackers and pushed overboard in his wheelchair. His body was later found with two gunshot wounds. A number of United Nations officials expressed embarrassment and shock at Mr.
Kaddoumi’s remarks. One Arab delegate explained Mr. Kaddoumi’s remarks as “an impulsive reaction” to a $1.5 billion law suit filed by Mr. Klinghoffer’s family against the P.L.O.
WASHINGTON, Dec. 5 — The Justice Department announced today that it had ordered recent attacks on Arab-Americans to be investigated under the Civil Rights Act. A spokesman for the Justice Department, John V.
Wilson, Jr., said the directive had been transmitted to the civil rights desk of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, which is already investigating one of three incidents — the death on Oct. 11 of Alex Odeh, an official of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, in a bomb explosion at his office in Santa Ana, Calif.
Two other attacks, a bombing of the committee’s Boston office in August, which injured two members of the police bomb squad, and a fire last weekend at the committee’s Washington office, are being investigated by the Treasury Department’s Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms. Today’s decision will bring the F.B.I. into those cases as well.
Former Senator James G. Abourezk, the chairman of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, had urged the F.B.I. to make an investigation. Mr. Abourezk said today that he would be meeting Friday with the F.B.I. Director, William H. Webster, to discuss the recent bombings.
The former Senator and other officials of the committee have said they have reason to believe that one person or group may be responsible for the fire and the two bombings. Mr. Abourezk said he was pleased that the Justice Department had ordered the investigation.
He Says Bureau Established Links Among U.S. Attacks on ‘Enemies of Israel’
By PHILIP SHENON
WASHINGTON, Dec. 10 — William H. Webster, Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, said today that Arab-Americans had entered a “zone of danger” and were targets of violence by a group seeking to harm “enemies of Israel.” Mr.
Webster said that the F.B.I. had found links among a series of recent attacks on Arab-Americans, although he did not provide a detailed description of the group purportedly behind the incidents.
“I think I can say that Arab individuals or those supporting of Arab points of view have come within the zone of danger — targeting by a group as yet to be fully identified and brought to justice,” he said in a question-and-answer session with reporters at the National Press Club.
Five Attacks in 1985 Militant Jewish organizations have come under suspicion in five terrorist attacks this year, including two bombings of Arab-American groups, that have caused two deaths and several injuries.
The F.B.I. had said previously that it believed the Jewish Defense League might be linked to the bombing in Santa Ana, Calif., in October of the office of the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee. The explosion killed the group's West Coast director. The Defense League has denied any responsibility. “There appears to be a common activity,” Mr.
Webster said, “suggesting the same participants who are engaging in terrorist activity, violent criminal activity, in a number of places in the country utilizing similar methods.” Mr.
Webster said that those who had orchestrated the attacks were “focusing not specifically upon Arabs as such, but upon all of those who could be in the category of enemies of Israel, and that would include those who are believed, or accused of being neo-Nazis.” ‘This Is a Turning Point’ Arab-American groups said today that they welcomed Mr. Webster's remarks.
“I think this is a turning point,” said Peter S. Tanous, acting president of the National Association of Arab Americans. “I welcome the comments, although I think they are a little late in coming.” James G.
Abourezk, national chairman of the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, said, “The authorities are finally beginning to realize that we've been brought into a war situation against our will.” The F.B.I. has begun an investigation to determine whether the civil rights of Arab-Americans have been violated in a series of attacks on the committee's regional offices.
An attempted bombing injured two members of a police bomb squad in Boston last summer. Late last month a fire destroyed the committee's Washington headquarters, and Federal investigators have clasified the blaze as “very suspicious.” The group's West Coast director, Alex Odeh, was killed in the California bombing, which occurred Oct. 11. F.B.I. Experts Called In Mr.
Webster said that he called in “40 of our experts from around the country on the first of November to marshall our resources in this area.” “We are making some headway,” he said without elaboration.
Reagan's Palestine solution shows ignorance of history
WASHINGTON — There is still some chatter at the State Department over President Reagan’s proposal to turn over the West Bank and Gaza to Jordan as an “associated” political entity. This proposal derives from the false myth that there will be no peace in the Middle East until there is a “Palestine solution.”
But as Professor Arnold Soloway of the Center for Near East Policy Research has noted in a brilliant monograph, the hundred-years war going on in the Middle East would continue, and perhaps worsen, if Israel disappeared in a puff of smoke.
What President Reagan would realize if he had any sense of history, is that the problems in the region go back many centuries and are partly rooted in Islamic beliefs. The Koran divides mankind into the House of Islam (Dar al-Islam) and the House of War (Dar al-Harb).
The Koran teaches that Islam must subjugate the rest of the world, and that non-Moslems must “pay tribute with their own hands until they are humiliated.” All worldly “Power belongs to Allah, his Apostle (Mohammed), and believers.”
Christians and Jews — the “Dhimmi” — are seen as inferior and subject peoples to be ruled by their Moslem masters. This puts the Ayatollah Khomeini in the mainstream of fundamentalist Islamic dogma. But in spite of this Pan-Islamic dogma, there are conflicts within the Arab nations and among them.
The Alawi, a Shiite sect, makes up but 12 percent of Syria’s population as against the 70 percent that is Sunni, yet it controls the country and has happily slaughtered Sunnis — 25,000 in the 1982 Hama massacre. The Sunnis are 25 percent of Iraq’s population, but they dominate the 55 percent Shia majority.
The Saudi monarchy trembles at the pro-Khomeini Shiites in its midst and at the 80 percent of a skilled labor force made up of “foreign” Arabs. Jordan, 78 percent of a British Palestine Mandate which was to become a Jewish homeland, is ruled by a Hashemite dynasty imported from Saudi Arabia by the British after World War I.
Its contribution to the Palestinians was to drive out the Palestine Liberation Organization after the bloody fighting of “Black September.” Is there an Arab nation? In 1980, a Syrian foreign minister said: “If we look at a map of the Arab homeland, we can hardly find two countries ... which are not either at war or on the road to war.”
These wars have nothing whatsoever to do with Israel or the West Bank. The map gives us the picture: Morocco vs. Algeria; Libya vs. Tunisia; Libya vs. Egypt; Libya vs. Saudi Arabia; Saudi Arabia vs. Bahrain and Qatar; Saudi Arabia vs. South Yemen; South Yemen vs. North Yemen; Abu Dhabi vs. Dubai; Iraq vs. Kuwait; Iraq vs. Syria; Syria vs. Jordan; Syria vs. the PLO; Iran vs.
Egypt; Shiite fighting Sunni in Lebanon and, of course, the big Middle East shooting war between Iran and Iraq. Given these conflicts and rivalries in the Middle East, one would have thought that President Reagan and the State Department would have come up with a “solution” to the Palestine problem that would have taken them into consideration.
But he managed to come up with one which pleases no one and which, in fact, would exacerbate the situation.
“The legitimacy of Hashemite rule over Palestine — Jordan — remains far from universally accepted in the Arab world,” Soloway points out, and he adds: “Not only was Jordan’s illegal annexation of the Palestine Mandate districts of Samaria and Judea, after the 1948 war against Israel, not recognized by any Arab country, but one or another of Jordan’s neighbors has repeatedly attempted to bring down the Hashemite monarchy by assassination, coups and threats.
In the years before 1967, the Jordanian regime was repeatedly shaken by popular rebellions east and west of the Jordan River which had to be forcibly repressed by the government.”
That President Reagan should have proposed turning over the West Bank and Gaza to Jordan showed an appalling ignorance of the history and politics of the region — and a startling insensitivity to the sentiments and policies of other Arab countries.
Someone at the State Department should have known that Egyptian troops moved into Israel in 1948 more to prevent Jordanian hegemony over the region than to bash Israel. The last thing Egypt and Saudi Arabia want is to see Jordan return to the West Bank. As for Syria, it sees not only Israel and Lebanon as its own territory, but Jordan as well.
The balkanized Middle East is a tinderbox, but the conflicts there are far older than Israel, which has become an excuse for bad and dangerous diplomacy.
PARIS (AP) — Col. Moammar Khadafy, the Libyan leader, Wednesday defended Palestinians fighting Israel for creation of their own state and warned that Libya would declare war in the Mediterranean Sea and in all the Middle East if Libya is ever attacked.
Khadafy accused the United States and Israel of leading the world to war and said any attack on Libya would cause it to declare war. “If an aggression was committed against Libya it would be the beginning of the end,” he said. “It would be the beginning of an interminable war.”
A breakaway faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization claimed responsibility for last Friday's attacks on check-in counters of Israel's El Al Airlines at the airports in Rome and Vienna, where a 18 people died and at least 120 were wounded.
The surviving terrorist in the Rome attack reportedly told investigators Libya provided support for the suicide mission and that there were 300 terrorists ready for similar missions.
Both U.S. and Israeli officials have said that the Palestinian faction headed by Abu Nidal, which they blame for the airport attacks, is based in Libya and received support from Khadafy's government. Khadafy said Palestinians are acting “as a reply to what the Israeli fighter planes did in Tunisia when they massacred Palestinians there.”
Israeli planes bombed PLO headquarters in Tunisia Oct. 1, killing at least 60 people. Israeli officials said the attack on Tunisia was aimed at an elite PLO unit answerable to Chairman Yasser Arafat. Israeli officials said their intelligence service determined that the unit had planned the murder in Cyprus of three Israeli tourists on a yacht.
In West Bank, Israeli Policies to Improve the ‘Quality of Life’ Get Mixed Reviews
By THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
NABLUS, Israeli-occupied West Bank — Since Prime Minister Shimon Peres's national unity Government came into office 16 months ago, it has viewed an improvement in the “quality of life” of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip as one of its achievements.
Interviews with Israeli military officials and experts on the West Bank, however, as well as with Palestinian lawyers, teachers, editors and business officials, suggest that its record in this area is ambiguous at best. The term “quality of life” was used by Secretary of State George P.
Shultz, and is also used by the Israeli authorities, to refer to a wide range of conditions — economic, political and those involving development — in the day-to-day existence of Palestinians living under Israeli occupation. Mr.
Shultz has said an improvement in the “quality of life” of the West Bank Palestinians would be an important contribution to advancing the peace process. Some areas of daily life have clearly been improved, the experts note.
But many others, they say, show virtually no change for the better — particularly public works, an area in which the Israeli Government continues to collect more in tax revenues from the Palestinian residents of the West Bank than it spends on programs to serve them.
More important, in some key aspects of daily life — such as the imprisonment of Palestinian activists or the reunification of families — residents of the West Bank assert that there has been a change for the worse. “Improvement in the quality of life?” said Zafer el-Masri, the new Mayor of Nablus. “I have not even seen the minimum yet.
The things that really matter to people have not been touched. If I had to give this Government a grade, I would give it an ‘F.’” Col. Ephraim Sneh, the head of the Israeli Army Civil Administration, which runs day-to-day affairs in the West Bank, says he sees the situation differently.
He said that for the vast majority of the population, the authorities were making improvements in every field, from health care to roads. Israeli officials point to the appointment of Mr. Masri as Mayor of Nablus in December as the most prominent symbol of their intention to improve living conditions for Palestinians.
Non-Cooperation Under Military Rule [...] can be arrested by the army and held in jail for six months without trial. Since the summer, 106 Palestinians — most of them student leaders, labor organizers and suspected P.L.O. sympathizers — have been put into prison for three to six months without trial. Ten others have been deported.
The detention orders handed down by the army must be reviewed by a judge, but defense lawyers are not allowed to see most of the evidence against their clients — the part collected by Israeli secret agents or through informers. “It is the same every time,” said Mona Rishmawi, a Ramallah lawyer who has represented many of the detainees.
“I go to the court and say, ‘What is the evidence against my client?’ They say, ‘This is all we can show you; the rest is secret.’ How can I plead for someone if I can't see the evidence? My clients all ask me the same thing: ‘Why am I here?
If they have real evidence against me, why don't they put me on trial?’” Administrative detention, Miss Rishmawi says, seems to have become a convenient tool for the military government to punish some activists and deter others without going through time-consuming legal proceedings that might not produce convictions. [...] Israeli Note Some Improvements [...] military officials point to several other areas in the West Bank where they maintain they have improved the quality of life.
They contend that direct international dialing and new telephone switching systems, installed for the first time in major Arab towns, have eased the sense of isolation. The number of censored books has been reduced from 1,500 to 300, and some new medical equipment has been installed in hospitals in Ramallah and Nablus, according to Israeli officials.
In addition, greater flexibility is being shown in approving economic projects that do not compete with Israeli industries. Israeli officials also say that private aid organizations that help Palestinians develop services are no longer being obstructed.
West Bank residents acknowledge these improvements but argue that they must be viewed in the wider context of the occupation as a whole. [...] In the field of political expression, newspaper editors report a slight reduction in censorship that they consider insignificant. The general ban on Palestinian nationalist activism continues. The same week that Mr.
Masri was being reinstated as Mayor of Nablus, 14 West Bank moderates led by Hanna Seniora, editor of the newspaper Al Fajr, were turned down in their request to the military government for permission to go to Amman to try to persuade the P.L.O. chairman, Yasir Arafat, to recognize Israel's right to exist.
From the Palestinian perspective, all of this is taking place against a backdrop of expansion of Jewish settlements and restrictions on Palestinian town planning and land use. Although only one new settlement has been opened in the last 15 months, the 114 existing settlements and new towns have continued to expand.
Between October 1984 and October 1985 their total population increased from 42,500 to 52,000. “The Israelis want to have it both ways,” Miss Rishmawi said. “They want to have more settlements and still be able to claim to be improving the quality of life of Palestinians. Sure, they build new roads and put in new phones. But it is not to improve our lives.
It is to better integrate the West Bank with Israel. That doesn't improve my life. It deprives me of my future.”
Marilyn Klinghoffer Dies at 58; Wife of Victim of Ship Hijackers
By ROBERT D. McFADDEN
Marilyn Klinghoffer, the widow of Leon Klinghoffer, who was slain by terrorists aboard the hijacked Italian cruise ship Achille Lauro last fall, died of cancer yesterday at Lenox Hill Hospital. She was 58 years old and lived in Manhattan. Mrs. Klinghoffer, who had entered the hospital two weeks ago, died at about 5 A.M., according to Letty H.
Simon, a friend who often spoke for the Klinghoffer family during the ordeal that had thrust its members into the public spotlight. Though Mrs. Klinghoffer had been ill for more than a year, she had never mentioned it in interviews or her public statements. Until last October, Mrs.
Klinghoffer, a small woman with short gray hair, had lived her life in relative obscurity, a personnel manager for a business- and trade-magazine publisher and, for 36 years, the wife of an appliance manufacturer who had overcome humble beginnings on the Lower East Side.
While the nation came to regard her as a voice of defiance against international terrorism, her family and friends knew her as a person devoted to her 69-year-old husband, who had suffered a stroke several years ago that paralyzed his right side and left him in a wheelchair, able to walk only a few steps with a cane.
Though she continued to work at the magazine publishers, Gralla Publications, and was herself ill, friends said, she spared no effort in caring for her husband, even checking such details as the number of steps he might have to climb or the width of doorways his wheelchair might have to pass through.
In part to celebrate their 36th wedding anniversary last fall, the Klinghoffers joined nine friends from the New York area for a cruise of the Mediterranean aboard the Achille Lauro, and were thus caught up in a drama that captured world attention for weeks. What began as a sunny vacation at sea turned into a nightmare on Oct. 7.
After hundreds of passengers debarked in Alexandria, Egypt, for a sightseeing tour, Palestinian terrorists hijacked the ship, with its crew of 350 and the 97 remaining passengers, including the Klinghoffers. The next day, Oct. 8, the Klinghoffers were among 11 American and 6 British hostages taken at gunpoint to an upper deck. There, over the protests and pleas of Mrs.
Klinghoffer, the terrorists took her husband away and, she later learned, shot him to death and hurled him into the sea. The rest of the passengers, though terrorized, were freed unharmed the next day. The terrorists were apprehended after United States jets intercepted an Egyptian plane taking them to freedom.
They have been convicted of weapons charges and are being held in Italy for trial on murder and hijacking charges. International attention focused on Mrs. Klinghoffer as she returned to her home at 70 East 10th Street and told President Reagan in a telephone call that she had seen the hijackers in jail and had spit in their faces. “Oh, God bless you,” Mr.
Reagan was said to have replied.
Marilyn Klinghoffer, center, with her daughters Ilsa, left, and Lisa as coffin of Leon Klinghoffer arrived at Kennedy International Airport on Oct. 20.
The Palestinian Arabs: It’s Time to Demythologize History
By DR. WALTER EHRLICH
“The evidence is very clear… the Higher Committee for Palestine… invading Arab armies…”
Walter Ehrlich in the St. Louis Jewish Light, answering a New York Times column. An argument about who rewrote what, conducted entirely between American writers.
F.B.I. Chief Doubts Anti-Arab Terrorists Caused Capital Fire
WASHINGTON, March 14 — A fire that destroyed a large portion of a Washington office building where the American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee had its headquarters was apparently not aimed at the committee, the Federal Bureau of Investigation said today. William H.
Webster, Director of the bureau, said there appeared to be “no relationship” between the fire last December and terrorists opposed to the group. Mr. Webster, testifying before a subcommittee of the House Judiciary Committee, seemed to suggest that the fire might have been aimed at another tenant in the building, although he would not provide details.
The fire began in the offices of a public relations concern on a lower floor. Some law-enforcement officials initially speculated that the fire, which seriously damaged the offices of the antidiscrimination committee, might have been one of a number of recent attacks on Arab-American groups.
The committee’s West Coast director, Alex Odeh, was killed last October when a bomb exploded at the group’s offices in Santa Ana, Calif. James Abourezk, the committee’s national chairman, said he accepted the F.B.I. analysis of the incident and expressed “great relief” that the group’s offices had not been the target. At the hearing, Mr.
Webster said the bureau was continuing to study whether the rights of Arab Americans had been violated in recent incidents. Last December, he warned that Arab Americans had entered a “zone of danger” and were the targets of violence by a group seeking to harm “enemies of Israel.”
He has not provided a detailed description of the group purportedly behind the incidents.
An AP News Analysis by Barry Schweid, AP Diplomatic Writer
Washington today: Views on terrorism differ WASHINGTON (AP) — Are terrorists “wild beasts” who can be conquered with military force and Western unity? Or has the Reagan administration, in its zeal to punish those who attack American diplomats, tourists and servicemen, begun to lump terrorists together with desperate men driven by a cause?
Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli ambassador to the United Nations, says terrorists are murderers, pure and simple, and they can be defeated or at least deterred. The US-educated envoy ridicules the notion that terrorism is rooted in social misery and frustration.
“It is rooted in the political ambitions and designs of expansionist states and the groups that serve them,” he says in a new book, “Terrorism: How The West Can Win.” “Without the support of such states, international terrorism would be impossible,” he said.
Clovis Maksoud, the Arab League’s ambassador to the United Nations, emphatically disagrees. “There is,” he said in an interview, “an Israeli-inspired definition of terrorism that tends to lump together genuine, legitimate resistance to occupation with terrorism.”
The purpose, he said, is political and psychological — and designed to suppress Palestinians seeking to assert a right of self-determination. Maksoud said the April 6 attack on a discotheque in West Berlin was an act of terrorism. It led to the U.S. bombardment of Libyan airfields, government command posts and suspected terrorist training camps.
But he said the capture of two Israeli soldiers recently in southern Lebanon, for instance, was not kidnapping, which conjures up an image of terrorism, but “a legitimate engagement with an occupying force.” Indiscriminate attacks on civilians is terrorism, Maksoud said.
But, he said, “I am emphasizing the need to be very discerning and discriminating about the use of the term.” Gordon S. Brown, director of Arabian Peninsula Affairs at the State Department, took a similar view last month in a broadcast televised by the U.S. Information Agency.
Brown said some of the armed assaults against Israel by the Palestine Liberation Organization were “legitimate acts of resistance” and stemmed from 40 years of conflict in the Middle East. However, the U.S. official also condemned terrorism and violence. After his remarks were circulated Brown said he had mishandled a question put to him in the interview.
The U.S. bombardment of Tripoli and Benghazi has stirred debate between the United States and some of its allies over a proper response to terrorism. But there is no apparent disagreement over the U.S. condemnation of Col. Moammar Khadafy and the nightclub bombing.
The Reagan administration takes the view that attacks on civilians are terrorist acts, although rebels trying to bring down Marxist regimes are often described as “freedom fighters.” The allies concur in the revulsion, but they generally would prefer retaliating with political and diplomatic weapons — not military might.
In 1979, the Jonathan Institute, named for Netanyahu’s brother who died in the rescue of Israeli hostages in Uganda three years earlier, defined terrorism as “the deliberate and systematic murder, maiming and menacing of the innocent to inspire fear in order to gain political ends.”
But five years later, when the institute held its second meeting here, the participants approached terrorism with varying definitions and proposed diverse responses. Netanyahu says sloppy thinking in the West often has allowed terrorists to escape retaliation.
Since Vietnam, he says, “the rules of engagement have become so rigid that governments often straitjacket themselves in the face of unambiguous aggression.” He says terrorists fear force and contrary to popular myth are usually not suicidal. West Germany, Holland and Britain all have used force to liberate hostages.
“For some time afterward,” he says, “these countries experienced no further hostage takings.” After the U.S. attack on Libya the Israeli ambassador said it would deter Khadafy.
“The main point here,” he said in an interview, “is that you don’t defeat terrorism with a single blow but you orchestrate pressures on them — economic and military ones — to drive the message home that their activities will be punished.”
Maksoud, however, is urging the Reagan administration to pause and to distinguish between terrorism, which he said starts with violence, and resistance. “Our concept is that resistance starts with petitioning, with demonstrations,” the Arab League envoy said. “It ends with violence when every other means has been exhausted.”
(Editor’s note: Barry Schweid has reported on diplomacy for The Associated Press since 1973).
Two ambassadors to the United Nations, in the same news-agency analysis, given equal type. Benjamin Netanyahu is quoted in a pull quote set beside the text: (Terrorism) is rooted in the political ambitions and designs of expansionist states and the groups that serve them. Clovis Maksoud of the Arab League gets the second pull quote and the last word: …Resistance … ends with violence when every other means has been exhausted. Between them the piece records a State Department official calling some armed assaults on Israel legitimate acts of resistance and then saying he had mishandled the question. It also names the Jonathan Institute and its 1979 definition, and notes that by the institute’s second meeting the participants no longer agreed on one.
TEL AVIV, June 10 (Reuters) — Israeli security forces have detained two Palestinian guerrilla squads suspected of planting bombs in Israel and mines at Jewish settlements in the occupied West Bank, a military communiqué said tonight. It did not disclose the total number of suspects detained in two separate sweeps in the West Bank.
ROME, June 10 — A report by Italian prosecutors has accused the Palestinian leader Mohammed Abbas of masterminding the hijacking of the Italian liner Achille Lauro last October. The report, a copy of which was made available here today, also defends the Palestinian cause and repeatedly praises Yasir Arafat, the Palestine Liberation Organization chairman.
And it upholds Italy’s decision to free Mr. Abbas, despite a request by the United States that he be held on suspicion of organizing the hijacking. The report, which will be the basis of the state’s case against 16 men implicated in the hijacking, describes the information provided by the United States at the time Mr.
Abbas was being held here as “inadequate,” even though it acknowledges that the information eventually proved correct. The report by the Genoa magistrates, who said in March that they would bring Mr.
Abbas to trial as the leader of the hijackers, said he had “created the action, chose the perpetrators, trained them for their particular task, gave the orders to the ‘commando.’” The Italian trial, covering a variety of charges, including hijacking itself and the murder of Leon Klinghoffer, a disabled 69-year-old American, is scheduled to open on June 18, with Mr.
Abbas and most of the other defendants still at large. The prosecutors have said there is virtually no chance that Mr. Abbas will be caught and tried. One of the report’s most striking aspects was the sympathetic attitude it expresses toward the Palestinian movement and the number times it specifically defends Mr. Arafat.
“This case falls within the struggle of the Palestinian people,” the report says. The Palestinians, “having lost their own land, intend to carry out a struggle to reconquer their national territory and end the disastrous (and, at times, inhuman) effects of the new diaspora.” The report repeatedly distinguishes Mr.
Arafat’s policies from those of Mr. Abbas and his Palestine Liberation Front.
“The method of Arafat’s struggle,” the prosecutors said, “is that of not bringing military episodes beyond the territory of Palestine in order not to run the risk of being accused of ‘terrorism,’ repudiated by patriots but necessarily attributed to them by those states against which acts of violence occur.”
The prosecutors appeared to be referring to Israel. The report is moving in its description of the murder of Mr. Klinghoffer, which it describes as “the extreme of ferociousness and inhumanity.” Mr. Klinghoffer, the report says, was the “victim of the violence which annihilates life simply because he was American, Jewish and handicapped.”
Although the Italian judiciary is independent of the political authorities, the report closely follows official Italian Government policy, and the Government was clearly pleased with the conclusions. Antonio Badini, Prime Minister Bettino Craxi’s diplomatic counselor, said, “I think it’s rather objective, a good report, accurate.”
NBC NEWS reconstructs the hijacking of the Achille Lauro tonight. Tom Brokaw visits the Italian cruise ship and re-enacts, in effect, the voyage that left Leon Klinghoffer dead. Mohammed Abbas, who by his own admission was the mastermind of the hijacking, appears in something like a cameo role.
The program, “Achille Lauro: A Study in Terror,” will be seen on Channel 4 at 10 P.M. Cameo role or not, however, Mr. Abbas is still the star attraction. When NBC broadcast an interview with Mr. Abbas on the “Nightly News” last month, a controversy broke out. Mr.
Abbas, who is under indictment in the United States and wanted by Israel and Italy, agreed to be interviewed only if NBC kept his whereabouts a secret. The network kept the secret; it does so again tonight. “I shall not conceal,” he says, “that there is a specific, preliminary trial program against the American Administration directly.”
The words, vague but menacing, are likely to become the most quoted remark from tonight’s program, just as the most quoted remark from the previous interview was the announcement that President Reagan was “enemy No. 1.” (And skip over now the question of whether a television network should allow, indeed invite, a terrorist to make threats.) Mr.
Abbas, who is also known as Abul Abbas, tells us nothing of substance, or anything that might legitimately be called news. Meanwhile, NBC, possibly sensitive to criticism about cooperating with Mr. Abbas, seems to go out of its way to show that it doesn’t like him. When Mr. Abbas, in his undisclosed hideout, denies, for example, that his men killed Mr.
Klinghoffer — “What is the use of killing an old man, anyway?” — Mr. Brokaw, on the deck of the Achille Lauro, says firmly, “Abbas again tries to twist the truth.” Mr. Brokaw also refers to “maniacal” hijackers, and calls some of Mr. Abbas’s bloody operations “lunatic missions.”
The program, citing Italian military and Pentagon sources, also says that the Egyptian Defense Minister, Abdel Halim Abu Ghazala, passed on the information that allowed the United States to intercept the plane that carried the hijackers from Egypt. If this is true, it clears up some unanswered questions about the military operation.
It also casts the Egyptian Government in a somewhat clearer light. Meanwhile, the reconstruction of the hijacking is vivid, even if sometimes self-conscious. Mr. Brokaw walks the deck of the Achille Lauro with the unfortunate Portuguese waiter who was forced to push Mr. Klinghoffer over the side of the ship. The waiter, who does not speak English, looks bewildered.
Hijacker of the Achille Lauro Recants Confession of Killing
By ROBERTO SURO
GENOA, Italy, June 19 — In defiant but often contradictory court testimony, the Palestinian gunman who prosecutors say once confessed to killing a disabled New York man during the Achille Lauro hijacking denied today that the crime had ever taken place. According to the confession, which the court said was given to a prosecutor Nov.
8 and which was made public today, Leon Klinghoffer, who was confined to a wheelchair, was chosen to be killed “so that everyone would know that we did not have any pity for anyone.” Magid al-Molqi, accused of being the assassin, is one of 15 men on trial here for various crimes connected with the hijacking of the cruise ship in October.
After being read the confession and being reminded of the many witnesses who confirmed it, Mr. Molqi told a court here: “I have not killed. This is not true. This person was never on the ship. He was never seen by me or my comrades. It was a scheme created by the United States and Syria.” Mr.
Klinghoffer, a 69-year-old New Yorker, was vacationing on the ship with his wife when it was hijacked off the coast of Egypt on Oct. 7. Prosecutors in the trial, which began Wednesday, say he was killed as part of a plot to force an exchange of Palestinians held in Israeli jails for hostages among the ship’s passengers. “It is true.
I killed the American passenger,” Mr. Molqi said in the confession given to the Italian authorities. The killing took place the afternoon of Oct. 8 as the hijackers were unsuccessfully trying to force the Syrian authorities to let them dock in the port of Tartus so the exchange could take place.
According to the statement read in court, the decision to start killing passengers was made after the hijackers decided the Syrians were stalling. Mr. Klinghoffer, unable to get out of his wheelchair, was pushed to the stern of the ship, and then, Mr. Molqi said, “I fired two shots at the American, one to the chest and one to the head.”
No one actually witnessed the shooting, prosecutors said. Today, Mr. Molqi repeatedly told the judge that neither he nor the other three hijackers committed the murder, and instead insisted Mr. Klinghoffer’s death was “a game between the Syrians and the Americans.”
Magid al-Molqi being taken into court yesterday in Genoa, Italy.
VATICAN CITY (AP) — Cardinal John J. O'Connor of New York warned Thursday that the plight of hundreds of thousands of Palestinian refugees may breed hatred and terrorism. “Something must be done,” the cardinal told a Vatican news conference after a two-hour audience with Pope John Paul II.
“For a long, long time now, there have been hundreds of thousands of Palestinian refugees living in misery,” he said. “Whole generations are being reared, at least a new generation is being reared in the situation that I think would have to spawn a great deal of bitterness and hatred.
There are more than a million such refugees living under such terrible conditions.” “If the situation continues, that would seem to me, it has to spawn terrorism,” said O'Connor, who had just returned from a three-day visit to Lebanon, site of Palestinian refugee camps that have been besieged by Shiite Moslem fighters.
O'Connor said refugees from what was formerly Palestine and is now Israel are living in a state of “grave violations of human rights” and that they should be given “some security, some roots.”
GENOA, Italy, June 20 — One of the hijackers of the cruise ship Achille Lauro told an Italian court here today that a fellow hijacker had admitted killing a handicapped New York man aboard the ship. He also testified that the operation had been directed by Mohammed Abbas, leader of a Palestinian guerrilla faction.
Ahmad Maruf al-Assadi, a key witness for the prosecution, said the Palestinian gunman accused of slaying Leon Klinghoffer came to him soon after the killing with blood on his clothes and announced, “I have killed the American.” Mr. Klinghoffer used a wheelchair. Testifying in the trial of 15 men accused of various crimes relating to the hijacking last October, Mr.
Assadi offered the first direct testimony to emerge in public that Mr. Abbas was responsible for the operation. The Reagan Administration has consistently accused Mr. Abbas of directing the hijacking, and a heated disagreement on this point with the Italian Government caused a period of strain in United States-Italian relations last fall. Mr.
Assadi also offered the first testimony implicating the shipboard leader of the hijacking team, Magid al-Molqi, in Mr. Klinghoffer’s killing. Appearing before the court Thursday, Mr. Molqi disavowed a signed confession in which prosecutors said he had admitted shooting the American tourist in the head and chest on Oct. 8, the second day of the hijacking.
Threats and insults shouted at Mr. Assadi by other defendants interrupted today’s proceedings several times. Mr. Assadi is the only one of the defendants to express repentance for his role, and today he appeared willing to cooperate with the prosecution despite occasional inconsistencies in his testimony.
The other two hijackers on trial have retracted statements made in the pretrial investigation, and both maintained in testimony that Mr. Klinghoffer was never even aboard the ship. The fourth member of the hijacking team, a minor, is being dealt with in separate proceedings. When the 69-year-old Mr.
Klinghoffer was killed, the ship was stopped off Syria and the hijackers were trying to persuade the Syrian authorities to let them enter the port of Tartus so they could begin negotiations for the release of 50 Palestinians held in Israeli jails, according to the prosecution. The prosecutors say the killing was designed to force acceptance of the hijackers’ demands.
Asked whether he tried to stop Mr. Molqi from killing Mr. Klinghoffer, Mr. Assadi said: “Yes, it is true, because I asked him why he wanted to take the American away, but he told me not to interfere. He swore he would not do him any harm.” Mr. Assadi, 24 years old, said he saw Mr. Molqi order a steward to take Mr. Klinghoffer away in his wheelchair.
No one actually witnessed the killing, prosecutors said, but next week the court is expected to hear the steward along with a crewman who later helped him throw Mr. Klinghoffer’s body into the sea on Mr. Molqi’s orders. After he had been gone for a half hour, Mr. Molqi returned to where Mr. Assadi was guarding a group of passengers, Mr.
Assadi said, adding: “I saw his shirt was full of blood, and I asked him what happened. He said, ‘I have killed the American.’”
Ahmad Maruf al-Assadi in courtroom yesterday in Genoa, Italy.
ITALIAN JURY GIVES CRUISE-SHIP KILLER 30-YEAR SENTENCE
11 of 15 Accused in Hijacking of Achille Lauro Convicted — Victim’s Kin Protest
By ROBERTO SURO
GENOA, Italy, July 10 — A Palestinian who confessed to the murder of Leon Klinghoffer, an American tourist aboard the liner Achille Lauro, was convicted and sentenced today to 30 years in prison for his actions during the ship’s hijacking in October.
In passing sentence, an Italian jury rejected a prosecution demand that the defendant, Magid al-Molqi, be given a life term, Italy’s maximum sentence, for killing Mr. Klinghoffer, a 69-year-old New Yorker who used a wheelchair. Mr. Molqi and two confederates were found guilty of a “kidnapping for terrorist ends that caused the killing of a person.”
The other two were given prison terms of 24 years and 15 years. The jury, however, ordered life sentences for three fugitives — the Palestinian leader Mohammed Abbas and two associates — who were tried in absentia and whom Italian officials acknowledge they are unlikely to apprehend. All were convicted for their role in organizing the hijacking.
The defendants in custody are expected to appeal their sentences. Under Italian law, people convicted of terrorist crimes are not subject to early release. In New York, Mr. Klinghoffer’s daughters expressed outrage at Mr. Molqi’s sentence and called on President Reagan to extradite the Palestinians to the United States to stand trial for murder.
The verdicts today involved a total of 15 defendants in the Achille Lauro hijacking, 5 of whom are in custody.
GENOA, Italy, July 11 — The public prosecutor’s office filed an appeal today of the verdicts and sentences in the Achille Lauro hijacking case, arguing that some of the jail terms ordered by a jury here should be more severe.
After a three-week trial, the jury condemned a fugitive Palestinian, Mohammed Abbas, and two of his deputies to life in jail in the hijacking, but rejected prosecution demands for life sentences for four others, including the confessed killer of Leon Klinghoffer, an American tourist aboard the ship.
The appeal process is likely to feed a public controversy that is developing over several of the jury’s decisions. In Rome today, the small but influential Republican Party protested what it called the jury’s “indulgence” toward the hijackers and its “contradictory” findings on important anti-terrorism laws.
Other commentators defended the jury decision against criticism. The state’s appeal will seek a reversal of the jury’s decision to issue reduced sentences for several defendants on the basis of extenuating circumstances, said the deputy chief prosecutor, Luigi Francesco Meloni.
Among those shown leniency was Magid al-Molqi, who, in a signed confession that he later disavowed, admitted killing Mr. Klinghoffer, a 69-year-old New Yorker who used a wheelchair. Mr. Molqi received a 30-year sentence. Mr. Meloni said, “We do not believe Molqi deserved a lesser sentence given the reprehensible, wicked nature of his crime.”
Judge Lino Monteverde told reporters Thursday that the “tragic conditions” the hijackers grew up in as Palestinians was an important factor in the decision to issue lighter sentences. Altogether six defendants — three hijackers, Mr.
Abbas and his two deputies — were found guilty of terrorist kidnapping with the resulting death of a victim, a crime that carries a potential life sentence. Under Italian law, the charge is distinct from a simple criminal homicide accusation, and is considered more serious because it is a crime against against the state. Conviction is in effect for political murder.
Five defendants were found guilty of lesser crimes, and four were acquitted on all charges. Judge Monteverde said the jury decided to give the heaviest sentences to Mr. Abbas and his two deputies in the Palestine Liberation Front because they conceived the October hijacking and directed it. The verdict involved 15 defendants.
Five are in custody; the three who received life sentences are all fugitives. Mr. Molqi and his three co-defendants — a fourth is to be tried separately as a minor — were arrested in Sicily on Oct. 10 after an Egyptair jet carrying them from Cairo was forced to land by United States Navy planes. Mr.
Abbas, who was also aboard the jet, was later freed; an international arrest warrant was issued for him later, after the Genoa magistrates decided that he was mastermind of the operation.
Arab-Americans protest FBI handling of Alex Odeh bombing murder case
By Stephanie Siewka
WASHINGTON — The investigation into the murder last October of Alex Odeh, director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee in Southern California, remains a top FBI priority, Oliver Revell, director of FBI investigations, told a congressional committee yesterday.
Reiterating previous statements by FBI officials, Revell blamed the bombing on “very few individuals” in Jewish extremist groups, which he linked to other terrorist attacks on the East Coast. But he would not say where the groups were located or when arrests might be made. “We have suspects in this case,” he said.
“The Alex Odeh murder has the highest priority within our domestic terrorist program. This case will not be terminated. It will be solved.” Odeh’s widow, Norma, who also testified at the House hearing focusing on attacks against Arab-Americans, said the FBI keeps her late husband’s brother, Sami, informed of its investigation. But Mrs.
Odeh criticized President Reagan for offering his condolences to the family of Leon Klinghoffer, who was murdered during the hijacking of the cruise ship Achille Lauro in October, but not to Odeh’s relatives.
“How is it that an American citizen, brutally murdered by terrorists on our own soil, has not received full recognition and support from our government, as did the victims of international terrorism during the Achille Lauro incident?” she asked. Odeh, a Palestinian who became a U.S. citizen in 1977, died Oct. 11 when a bomb in his Santa Ana office exploded.
He had appeared the previous evening on a local television show to deplore the Achille Lauro hijacking. He said he believed the Palestine Liberation Organization and its leader Yassar Arafat were not involved. He also called Arafat “a man of peace.”
Arab-American activists have cited Secret Service documents as proof the FBI has dropped its investigation of the case, which is officially classified as a domestic act of terrorism. Revell yesterday said a Secret Service memorandum sent from Los Angeles to Washington in early January stating that the FBI had suspended investigation into the Odeh case was inaccurate.
The investigators are “learning new facts every day,” he said. He said a Secret Service agent “probably” heard that the FBI had insufficient evidence to prosecute suspects, which was true, and jumped to the conclusion that the case was closed, which was false.
After testifying, Revell was asked by reporters whether the Jewish Defense League (JDL) was involved. He said he would not pinpoint any group. Other witnesses at the committee hearing testified that Arab-Americans have been negatively stereotyped as either rich oil sheiks or terrorists.
Rema Simon, a 23-year-old American of Irish and Lebanese descent, said that she recently was taken off a Delta Airlines flight by a Delta official and told to put away a book she was reading, titled “Palestine Is, But Not in Jordan,” before boarding the plane again. California Rep. Mervyn Dymally, D-Compton, former South Dakota Sen.
James Abourezk and David Sadd, director of the National Association of Arab-Americans, said Arab-Americans have become the main targets of domestic American terrorism. Dymally, quoting FBI records, said no Arab-American had committed a terrorist act against an American in more than a decade, but predicted that violence against Arab-Americans would continue.
Santa Ana bomb victim Alex Odeh / Killed after making pro-Arafat remark
On Oct. 11, 1985, Alex Odeh, the 41-year-old regional director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee in Southern California, was killed by a bomb trip-wired to the front door of the ADC office. The day before the attack, Odeh had appeared on a local TV news broadcast asserting that Arafat and the PLO had not been involved in the hijacking of the Achille Lauro.
Unfortunately, statements Odeh made denouncing the hijacking and terrorism in general were cut from the broadcast. When terrorist activity flares up in Europe or the Middle East, there is often a backlash in this country against innocent Arab-Americans. Many who initiate these attacks seem to believe that they are retaliating against enemies of the United States.
After the attack on Odeh, FBI spokesman Lane Bonner issued a statement saying, “We have attributed the bombing to the Jewish Defense League.” The JDL denied responsibility, threatened to sue the FBI and complained about being tried in the press. (The FBI now refers simply to a “possible link” between the JDL and the bombing.)
Nevertheless, Irv Rubin, head of the JDL, has not condemned the bombing: “I have no tears for Odeh. He got exactly what he deserved.” Mainstream Jewish organizations were shocked by the murder and by Rubin’s remark.
Hyman Bookbinder of the American Jewish Committee says he telephoned the leadership of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee “to express my horror.” Odeh was not a wild-eyed extremist calling for a holy war. A naturalized citizen of Palestinian origin, Odeh was a poet and a teacher of Arabic at a community college.
Despite its civil rights focus, ADC has become a primary target of terrorist attacks. Two months before the explosion that killed Odeh, a 12-inch pipe bomb was found propped against the door of a Boston building that houses the ADC offices. It exploded while being removed by the Boston bomb squad.
Two Boston newspapers reported that callers identifying themselves as members of the JDL had taken responsibility for the attempted bombing. Arrayh (the Aim), Philadelphia’s sole Arabic/English newspaper, has long been a target of harassment and violence. Moustafa Dabbas, 51, editor and printer, immigrated to the United States from Damascus 15 years ago.
Dabbas says the local JDL has periodically attacked his operation. In 1975, the printing presses were stolen. Bonnie Pechter, then president of the local JDL chapter, boasted to the Philadelphia Tribune and the Philadelphia Daily News that the JDL had the presses and planned to use them to “print up materials to combat Arab propaganda.” On Jan.
17, 1986, Dabbas was accosted by three men, one of whom, he claims, inquired if he was the editor of Arrayh. When he admitted that he was, the men beat him unconscious, leaving him with a fractured skull, a gash under one eye and bleeding from the ears.
Soon after the assault on Dabbas, Ismail al Faruqi, a Temple University religious scholar, and his wife were brutally murdered. Last July in Tucson, Ariz., a non-Arab woman was raped and beaten outside a restaurant frequented by Arab-American students. According to the Arizona Daily Star, the woman told police she might have been attacked because she was dating a Palestinian.
Police report that the woman had a Star of David cut lightly onto her chest with a knife. After major incidents in the Middle East, Arab-American students have been beaten — apparently because they looked Arab. Dr. Mohammed T. Mehdi, secretary general of the National Council on Islamic Affairs, warns that Arab-Americans are overreacting.
“It would be a mistake to make things sound worse than they are,” he insists. In the last 20 or 30 years, only one death can be attributed to anti-Arab-American attacks — that of Odeh. Bookbinder agrees that it would be a mistake to interpret isolated incidents as a “great big movement of anti-Arab violence, because there is no such thing.”
The patriotism of many Arab-Americans is being challenged. “Lots of Arab-Americans are asked to justify themselves whenever anything happens in the Middle East,” fumes Palestinian immigrant Terry Ahwal, a staffer at ADC in Detroit.
When one caller cast aspersions on her loyalty, Ahwal said: “My sister is in the Marines; I’m in the auxiliary police, and our whole family is involved in volunteer work in our community. What right have you to ask us to justify ourselves?” Lerner is a free-lance journalist in Washington, D.C. This is reprinted from the New Republic.
A Congressional hearing dealing with violence against Arab-Americans has reflected a growing perception that such violence rises in waves originating in the conflicts of the Middle East. Federal investigators and Arab-American groups say anti-Arab violence, threats and harassment all increase whenever Americans, in particular, are threatened by Arabs or Moslems.
This was the pattern after a Trans World Airlines jetliner with 104 Americans was hijacked to Lebanon in June 1985, after the cruise ship Achille Lauro was seized by Palestinian gunmen last October and after American planes bombed Libya in April, an attack that was itself a reply to Libyan-sponsored terrorism in Europe.
Some of the deepest worries among Arab-Americans have focused on the murder of Alex Odeh, the West Coast regional director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee. Mr. Odeh was killed by a bomb last October in Santa Ana, Calif., soon after the Achille Lauro hijacking. Although the murder has not been solved, Oliver B.
Revell, executive assistant director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, told the House Subcommittee on Criminal Justice on Wednesday that the bureau suspected that “Jewish extremist elements” were responsible for the Odeh murder as well as for similar bombings aimed at purported Nazi war criminals. Mr.
Revell also said that a recently disclosed Secret Service memorandum stating that the F.B.I.’s investigation of the Odeh killing had failed and had been “closed” was inaccurate. It is not just the Odeh killing, however, that is causing concern among Arab-Americans.
They also say they are worried by the signs that anti-Arab violence rises in waves, that it seems to be fueled by widespread ethnic stereotypes and that at least some of the violence appears to have been spearheaded by militant groups such as the Jewish Defense League and the Jewish Defense Organization.
Faris Bouhafa, a spokesman for the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, was asked Thursday if anti-Arab violence had risen in the United States after terrorist attacks in Europe last spring were linked to Libya and followed by American air raids on Tripoli and Benghazi. Mr. Bouhafa replied from the group’s Washington headquarters, “Yes, absolutely.”
“In Dearborn, Mich., the night of the attack, three individuals went through the Arab community smashing the windows of restaurants,” Mr. Bouhafa said, consulting his log. “Outside of a pub in Syracuse, N.Y., two days after the attack, an Arab student was jumped by 10 individuals and blinded in one eye.”
Ten days later, he said, a Detroit radio station reported that an Egyptian medical student in Cicero, Ill., had been badly beaten. Two weeks later, an Arab-American restaurant owner in New Haven reported threatening phone calls from the Jewish Defense League.
In recent months acts of anti-Arab violence appear to have receded at a time when there has been a relative absence of successful terrorist attacks against Americans, Europeans or Israelis.
After the Achille Lauro hijacking, in which Leon Klinghoffer, a retired New Yorker, was shot to death and thrown from the ship in his wheelchair, many anti-Arab incidents were reported in addition to the bombing that killed Mr. Odeh and injured seven other people. Anti-Arab language also grew heated.
The head of the Jewish Defense League, Irv Rubin, publicly approved of the killing of Mr. Odeh while denying that the league was involved in terrorism. Mordechai Levy, head of the Jewish Defense Organization, said in a telephone interview that the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, whose national chairman is former Senator James G.
Abourezk of South Dakota, was a “front” for the Palestine Liberation Organization. Mr. Levy said the Jewish Defense Organization had 3,000 members and that it encouraged them to train with firearms for self-defense. He denied that he was anti-Arab or anti-Islamic.
Unlike the Jewish Defense League, he said, “We don’t advocate throwing all the Arabs out of Israel.” He said his colleagues had beaten people but had not murdered anyone or planted any bombs. Last Dec. 10, two months after the Odeh killing, the Director of the F.B.I., William H.
Webster, told reporters that Arab-Americans had entered “a zone of danger.” Referring to extremist Jewish groups, he warned that some Arab-Americans had become targets of a conspiracy aimed at “enemies of Israel.” This year, according to Mr. Bouhafa, cases of anti-Arab violence have included the Jan.
9 shooting of a Palestinian grocer in Milwaukee by two men who took no money; the unexplained beating of the editor of an Arab newspaper in Philadelphia on Jan. 17, and threats and vandalism elsewhere.
In the Achille Lauro Trial, Justice and Palestinians Lost
By Walter Reich
WASHINGTON — In “West Side Story,” Diesel, playing a judge in a street scene fantasy, says of the accused miscreant, Action: “In the opinion of this court, this child is deprived on account he ain’t had a normal home.”
Action, elated and appreciating this sympathetic explanation for his criminality, exults: “Hey, I’m depraved on account I’m deprived!” This scene was recently enacted in Italy. But there the accused were not fantasized juvenile delinquents but real Middle East terrorists.
And the judges weren’t kids making fun of a criminal justice system but real judges, representatives of such a system, who were, without intending it, accomplishing the same end. The trial involved the hijacking of the Achille Lauro. Magid al-Molqi, the on-board leader, received a 30-year sentence, less than the life imprisonment the prosecution had demanded.
He had confessed that he had selected Leon Klinghoffer for death, coldly shot him in the head and chest and ordered him thrown overboard. After the trial, the presiding judge told reporters Mr. Molqi and two of his three co-defendants had been given reduced sentences because of “attenuating circumstances.”
Those circumstances consisted of deprivations they must have suffered because “they have grown up in the tragic conditions that the Palestinian people live through.” He apparently accepted the defense argument that Mr. Molqi and his associates were “soldiers fighting for their ideals,” not terrorists.
What about Abul Abbas and his upper-echelon co-defendants? They got life imprisonment — a theoretical sentence, since they are on the loose — because they were said to have been “not acting for patriotic motives.” But didn’t Mr. Abbas, too, have the same origins as the man who took over the cruise ship and killed Mr. Klinghoffer?
Doesn’t he have the same grievances? The main difference between them seems to be that in masterminding the operation Mr. Abbas may have tried to do two things: not only strike a blow for the Palestinian cause but strike it in a way that might be inconvenient to a rival in the Palestine Liberation Organization.
That rival, Yasir Arafat, who has struck such blows many times, and who has not abandoned the tactic, had just then put the tactic on hold while negotiating a deal, later scuttled, with King Hussein. If anything, Mr. Abbas may be thought to be a greater patriot than Mr. Molqi. He is a general in the struggle and has fought far longer than Mr. Molqi. If he thought Mr.
Arafat’s strategy wrong, and hoped to derail it and then strike a blow for liberty as he saw it, does that make him less noble than Mr. Molqi, and his deprivations any less severe? No. Nor, like Mr. Molqi’s, should his deprivations be judged morally, and therefore legally, attenuating. Both men committed terrorist murder — Mr.
Abbas by organizing the plan, Mr. Molqi by pulling the trigger — and both should be seen as terrorists and get the fullest punishment allowed for terrorist murder.
To mete out lesser punishment on the grounds that a terrorist believes himself to be a deprived, aggrieved freedom fighter undermines the ground on which justice stands by accepting terrorists’ argument that only their concepts of justice and rights, and their sufferings, are valid. This murder of justice is not good for the Palestinians, either. So long as Mr.
Molqi, Mr. Abbas, Mr. Arafat or other P.L.O. members advocate terrorism or practice it while publicly denouncing it, or focus it on civilians who happen to be Israelis or Jews or Americans, they will continue to undermine the possibility that they will ever achieve the justice they define for themselves.
The countries targeted by such attacks — especially the United States and Israel — will retaliate, and the war will go on. For all this to end, two things are necessary. The Palestinians — and any of the many groups using terrorism to satisfy grievances — should scuttle terror and find other ways, inevitably involving compromise, to achieve their goals.
And the Western democracies must reject the argument that any excuse — even one involving a background of deprivation — can “attenuate” responsibility for terrorism against innocents. Walter Reich is a senior research associate in the international security studies program at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars.
Denied an identity, Gazans losing hope in land of despair
A year before the intifada, a Florida paper putting the thing itself in the first two words: denied an identity. The sentence has no one denying it, and the last four words turn the place into a mood. But the claim in the opening is the one this whole archive is about, and it was printable in Palm Beach in December 1986.
Palestinian artist, Dutch Jewish film maker make film about homecoming
The film is a human look at the state of Israel and the Palestinian issue.
Barbara Karkabi, Houston Chronicle
“Kamal Boullata emerged from an afternoon at the Rothko Chapel with a gleam in his eye and the hope that one day he might be able to create a similar spot in his hometown, Jerusalem… ‘I want it to have the same feeling of peace and meditation that the Rothko Chapel has, and, of course, it should be non-denominational,’ said the 43-year-old Palestinian artist and writer, who says that he was raised a Christian, but is culturally a Moslem and existentially a Jew… Boullata has lived in the United States for almost 20 years, since the 1967 Israeli-Arab war, but he returned in 1985, accompanied by a Dutch Jewish film maker and his crew, who filmed the story of his homecoming.
The resulting full-length, non-fiction film, Stranger At Home, was shown in Houston last week in conjunction with an exhibition of his art work currently on display at the University of Houston… ‘One cannot think about being Palestinian, without being aware of Jews.
We’re very much tied together,’ said Boullata… ‘The price of making a film in my own life was hell personally. My wife dropped out after the second day because she couldn’t take it,’ Boullata said.
‘I had not realized it would be so intense.’… Still, he admits, he probably would never have returned to the city of his birth if it hadn’t been for van den Berg’s encouragement. For that he is grateful. He found Jerusalem to be at once different and the same from the city he left 20 years ago.
‘Of course, there are things that have changed. But, one night I took Lilly and walked around the old city of Jerusalem with my eyes closed. I knew it so well, I was able to find my way,’ he recalled. ‘I have always thought that Jerusalem was not so much a place as it was a time.’… ‘I would like to think so.
If Jews and Palestinians can’t get together on something as simple as this, then maybe there is no hope, after all,’ he said.”
Fourteen years after the Charlottesville interview and eighteen years out of Jerusalem. Money from the sale of his prints went to a scholarship endowment for two Palestinian students a year. Photo credit: Timothy Bullard / Chronicle.
“As an American Jew and a Zionist, I confess to being impressed and intrigued, as well as troubled, by the voice of Edward W. Said in ‘After the Last Sky: Palestinian Lives’ (Pantheon: $14.95; also available in hardcover, $22.95).
Said, a professor of literature at Columbia University and a familiar figure in the Western media, was born in Jerusalem, reared in Cairo, and now lives in the United States.
He is a self-described Palestinian nationalist with a mastery of Western culture, an accomplished intellectual who puts his considerable analytical and rhetorical skills at the service of his people. ‘After the Last Sky’ is an important book, potentially an influential book, and necessarily an unsettling one. The book is presented as Said’s musings over the black-and-white images of Swiss photographer Jean Mohr, who has documented the lives and landscapes of Palestinian Arabs in Israel and the Arab world.
Said’s method — and, more to the point, his mission — is to explain and enlarge upon these commonplace images of Arab life: the household, the mosque, the marketplace, the fields, the refugee camp… ‘Why these natives in their untidy backwardness could not impress the Zionists, much less the rest of the world, with their presence is something I still cannot really understand,’ he writes of the Arab population of Palestine during the formative years of Zionist settlement and early Jewish statehood.
‘It is as if the Zionist web of detail and its drama, in alliance with our own inability and recalcitrance to dramatize and speak about ourselves, screened the Palestinians not only from the world but from ourselves as well.’ Said writes movingly of the experiences and emotions of Palestinian Arabs in Israel and in the manfa (‘exile’) or ghurba (‘estrangement’).
(Significantly, he explicitly refuses to use the word ‘diaspora,’ although he ponders the provocative phrase which characterizes Palestinian Arabs as ‘the Jews of the Arab world,’ and claims — outrageously, I must say — that ‘the Holocaust has victimized us, too.’) He moves easily between Western and Arab culture, citing Yeats, Kafka and Melville as readily as Mahmoud Darwish and other Palestinian poets, scholars and writers.… What is troubling is Said’s persistence in characterizing the Palestinian Arabs as victims… without ever owning up to the moral or practical implications of the Palestinians’ choice of terrorism as so frequent a mode of expression for their rage and aspiration… ‘awdah (return) is crucial and stands at the very heart of our political quest for self-determination,’ he writes… When a man as attuned to Western sensibilities as Said expresses such sentiments, the prospect of any meaningful encounter between Arab and Jew seems very remote indeed.”
“Mahmoud Darwish, Paris, 1984.”
A book review that states its own standpoint in its first six words, which is rarer in this archive than any of the arguments that follow it. The passage Said is quoted on is close to the reason this collection exists: that the Palestinians were screened from the world, and from themselves. The photograph chosen to illustrate a review of Said’s book is of Mahmoud Darwish, whose poem an American wire story would print as a threat eighteen months later and whose obituaries this archive holds five printings of.
Israelis Kill West Bank Boy Who They Say Threw Rocks
“Israeli soldiers shot and killed a 14-year-old Palestinian boy in the West Bank today after he and other youths threw stones… The bodies of the students… Abu Dahhab and Jawad Abu Selmi, both 22…”
Thomas Friedman. Read the headline's middle clause — who they say threw rocks — which attributes the justification to the killers while stating the killing as fact. Two Birzeit students, both 22, were buried the same week; the boy was 14.
NEW YORK — The General Assembly’s finance committee has approved a $50 million budget increase, despite objections from the United States, the Soviet Union and other major financial contributors.
The vote Monday, 82-14 with nine abstentions, comes at a time Secretary-General Javier Perez de Cuellar is trying to cut costs to get through the 1986-87 budget year… In other U. N. news, the Security Council voted 14-0 Monday to deplore the killing and wounding of Palestinians by Israeli soldiers in the occupied West Bank. The United States abstained from the vote.
All other members of the Security Council voted in favor. The measure called on Israel to abide “immediately and scrupulously” by the 1949 Geneva Convention on protecting civilians in occupied territories, and to release any people arrested in violation of the convention during recent demonstrations at Bir Zeit University.
Palestinian news reports said a 12-year-old Palestinian boy died earlier Monday after being shot in his head by Israeli soldiers in the Balata refugee camp. An Israeli military spokesman said it is not clear who killed the boy. Last week, Israeli soldiers shot and killed a 14-year-old Palestinian in the same camp and two 22-year-old students at Bir Zeit University.
The Security Council resolution urged all concerned parties “to exercise maximum restraint to avoid violent acts, and to contribute toward the establishment of peace.” To overcome U.
S. objections, the resolution’s non-aligned sponsors dropped the word “condemns” so the resolution read the 15-nation council “strongly deplores the opening of fire by the Israeli army, resulting in the death and the wounding of defenseless students.” U.
S. sources said the American delegation could not support even the amended resolution because it felt Israel did not bear full responsibility for the violence. During two days’ debate, Israeli Ambassador Benjamin Netanyahu accused the Palestine Liberation Organization of inciting shooting. He insisted Israeli soldiers reacted to restore law and order. U. S.
Ambassador Vernon A. Walters abstained while occupying the chair as this month’s council president.
“Javier Perez de Cuellar”
A 12-year-old and a 14-year-old killed in Balata, and two students at Bir Zeit, reported inside a story about the United Nations budget. The word the sponsors removed to get the resolution past the United States is printed: “condemns.”
Four words, and the only thing in them a reader can count is nothing. The Buffalo News the same day gave the same protest a crowd of a thousand, the word peacefully, three dead and the people who killed them (CP-1986-003). Both papers name Israel; one of them tells you what happened.
1,000 March Peacefully to Protest Killing of Three Arabs by Israelis
Eleven words that leave nothing out: how many marched, how they marched, how many were killed, who they were and who killed them. It is the most complete headline of its kind in this archive and it ran on the same day as the Press of Atlantic City’s four-word version (CP-1986-002). Peacefully is doing work here that the reader would otherwise have to be told to assume.
JERUSALEM—Israel on Sunday expelled Akram Haniyeh, a Palestinian newspaper editor accused of being a “senior activist” for the Palestine Liberation Organization in the occupied West Bank.
Haniyeh, 33, editor of the Al-Shaab newspaper in Arab East Jerusalem, was allowed to board a Swissair flight to Zurich at Ben-Gurion International Airport outside Tel Aviv as part of a deal to avoid the risk of his being deported to Jordan, where he is blacklisted because of his opposition to King Hussein, his lawyers said.
Haniyeh’s expulsion ended a two-month legal battle with military authorities and came two days after he dropped a Supreme Court appeal against the Israeli army’s deportation order.
“I am the victim of political revenge for my struggle as a political person, as a journalist and as a writer to achieve the legitimate rights of my people,” Haniyeh said in a statement to his lawyers. The army arrested Haniyeh Nov.
3 and sought his deportation to Jordan, accusing him of being a top figure in El Fatah, the PLO’s main guerrilla fighting unit led by Yasser Arafat; conducting PLO meetings in his office and organizing demonstrations and strikes against the occupation. His newspaper, the army said, was funded by PLO money funneled into the West Bank through Jordan.
Virtually all of the evidence against Haniyeh, compiled and submitted by the Shin Bet security service, was classified secret and not shown to Haniyeh’s defense team, his lawyers said. “He said he couldn’t see any hope,” said his Israeli attorney, Felicia Langer. “I wanted a decision in the Israeli courts.
I wanted to place the authorities in an uneasy position and expose the lack of justice. But he was tired and said he didn’t see any future in the legal proceedings.” He said he was the victim of “political revenge” for his writings and denied terrorist involvement.
Israel has expelled almost 2,000 people from the West Bank and Gaza Strip since it captured the territories from Jordan in the 1967 Mideast war. Thirty-five people have been deported to Jordan this year.
Palestinian newspaper editor Akram Haniyeh, accused by Israel of promoting terrorism, is escorted by a Red Cross official to a Swissair flight at Tel Aviv’s airport Sunday.
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Israel on Sunday deported a Palestinian newspaper editor, claiming he promoted terrorism. Demonstrations broke out in the occupied West Bank, and Israeli troops shot and wounded two protesters.
Akram Haniyeh, 33, an Arabic language poet and writer and editor of the pro-PLO Al-Shaab newspaper in Jerusalem, was put on a Swissair flight to Zurich pending arrangements to continue to Algeria. Haniyeh said he was the victim of “political revenge” for his writings and denied terrorist involvement.
Israel did not make public its evidence against Haniyeh, who was detained Nov. 3. “Haniyeh didn’t handle bombs, but he was among the highest people in Fatah. ... He got a lot of money for that, for his paper and as a monthly salary for himself,” one official said. Fatah is the main guerrilla fighting unit of the Palestine Liberation Organization.
In Geneva, Red Cross spokeswoman Francoise Derron said, “The International Committee of the Red Cross deplores once more this violation of humanitarian law by the Israeli authorities.” She noted that the Fourth Geneva Convention on the treatment of civilians forbids expulsions from occupied territory.
TEL AVIV, Israel — Israel on Sunday deported a Palestinian newspaper editor in Jerusalem, claiming he promoted terrcrism. Demonstrations broke out in the occupied West Bank, and Israeli troops shot and wounded two protesters.
Akram Haniyeh, 33, an Arabic language poet and writer and editor of the pro-PLO Al-Shaab newspaper, was put on a Swissair flight to Zurich pending arrangements to continue to Algeria. Haniyeh said he was the victim of “political revenge” for his writings and denied terrorist involvement.
IN GENEVA, Red Cross spokeswoman Francoise Derron said, “The International Committee of the Red Cross deplores once more this violation of humanitarian law by the Israeli authorities.” She noted that the Fourth Geneva Convention on the treatment of civilians forbids expulsions from occupied territory.
“This is not the first case of such expulsions,” Derron said. Israel did not make public evidence against Haniyeh, who was detained on Nov. 3. “Haniyeh didn’t handle bombs, but he was among the highest people in Fatah. ... He got a lot of money for that, for his paper and as a monthly salary for himself,” one official said.
Fatah is the main guerrilla fighting unit of the Palestine Liberation Organization. In the West Bank town of Ramallah, five miles north of Jerusalem, Israeli troops wounded two Palestinians during an anti-Israeli demonstration, military sources said.
Fifteen other demonstrators were detained during three separate protests in Ramallah, said the sources, who could not be identified under army regulations. Israel Radio said the Palestinians gathered to protest Haniyeh’s deportation. Army officials said the protests also were marking the approaching anniversary of the the PLO’s founding on Jan. 1, 1964.
HANIYEH, A Jordanian citizen, was the first Palestinian to be expelled from the occupied West Bank since early this year and the first journalist deported in 14 years. He was accused of acting as a conduit for money and instructions from PLO leaders to guerrilla cells in the West Bank.
Filed as Wichita Eagle. The masthead on this scan reads THE WICHITA EAGLE-BEACON, page 4A, Monday, December 29, 1986. The three other Wichita Eagle records here are 1938, 1974 and 1980 and are left under that name, because no masthead was read on them and the Eagle-Beacon title does not cover 1938.
RAMALLAH, Israeli-Occupied West Bank — In December, on a quiet morning in this Christian Arab town north of Jerusalem, a 16-year-old Palestinian schoolboy walked up behind an Israeli soldier, pulled an ax out of his blue schoolbag, started shouting something about “Palestine” and began striking the soldier on the head.
The wounded soldier was taken to a hospital with severe cuts. The youth was taken to prison. All the army spokesmen would say about the young Palestinian was that he was acting on his “own initiative” — that is, no one ordered or paid him to do it; he just did it on his own accord.
This scene has been repeated several times in the last year, with young Palestinians using kitchen knives or sharpened screwdrivers to attack Israeli soldiers or civilians in broad daylight. And at Bir Zeit University north of Jerusalem in December, Palestinian students threw stones at heavily armed Israeli troops, who responded with live ammunition.
Two students were shot to death, but the stone throwing continued for another week at schools all over the West Bank. The Post-1967 Generation These young Palestinians are members of the post-1967 generation, who have spent all their lives under Israeli rule in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip and are increasingly making their political views felt.
… [PHOTOGRAPH across the top of the page, with credit and caption:] United Press International Arab youths throwing rocks last month at Israeli troops at the Bureij refugee center in the Gaza Strip. Incident was in reaction to the killing of two Palestinian students by Israeli troops at Bir Zeit University on the West Bank.
Palestinians Under Israel: Bitter Politics Continued From Page A1 the ax wielders. They no longer seem to view violence as serving as a means toward a particular political objective; most say that they have given up hope for any solutions. Theirs is simply a politics of revenge.
Violence ‘Just Occurs’ “I think that our generation of Palestinians have reached a point psychologically where we want any means of getting back at the Jews,” said Meral, an 18-year-old Palestinian student at Bir Zeit University who did not want to give her last name, in order to avoid repercussions.
“You just get the feeling the Jews want to aggravate us. Palestinian violence now is something that just happens. It’s not planned; it just occurs.” Sara Salah, principal of the girls’ high school in the Aida refugee district near Bethlehem, said, “My students’ main problem is that they don’t like their lives with the Jews.”
The second striking feature about the new generation of Palestinians is that although they have had more direct contact with Israel and Israelis than previous generations of Palestinians, the experience in the occupied territories has done nothing to moderate their feelings. If anything, it has radicalized them.
This Palestinian generation seems to belie the conventional wisdom that the problem with the Arabs and the Israelis is that they do not know each other. Many of the young Palestinians say they believe the problem is that they and the Israelis do know each other, and hat each wants the same land free of the other.
“We are two generations that are basically brought up the same way,” said Serene, a 20-year-old Bir Zeit student who is studying literature, speaking of her Israeli and Palestinian peers. “They are a generation brought up to hate the Palestinians, and we were brought up think the same about them.
We don’t need to talk to them to know what they are thinking because we know that they were brought up to think the same way as we do — only opposite.” “I was driving on the road from Jerusalem to Jericho one day last year and was stopped at an army checkpoint” she added.
“We were there for a while, and at one point an Israeli soldier started trying to talk to me. I wasnt very friendly. Finally, he said to me, ‘You hate us, don’t you?’ I said, ‘What do you think?’
” ‘Not Going to Condemn Him’ “I would not go out and kill an Israeli civilian myself, but I also would not condemn someone who does,” Serene said. “They are killing so many of our civilians here and in Lebanon, if someone his the guts to go out and stab one of theirs, I am not going to condemn him.”
Another indication of how little living together has led to any deeper appreciation of the other’s point of view is that these young Palestinians almost never refer to Israelis as Israelis. Instead, they call them the “Jews.”
It appears from discussions that they believe that referring to Israelis as Israelis would be to acknowledge that there is another legitimate national collective on the land. So instead, they refer to them only as Jews, with no national connotations.
When this is pointed out to them, they quickly note that many Israelis do the equivalent to them, referring to them not as Palestinians but as “the Arabs of the land of Israel,” an amorphous ethnic group living in someone else’s country.
It seems that neither side can stand the symmetry of acknowledging that there is another legitimate collective on the land, because to do that would be to relinquish some of the exclusivity of their own claim and make their own “rights” relative instead of absolute.
Losing Control of Future The most important factor shaping the attitudes of the new generation seems to be the feeling that they have lost control over their own future, as individuals and as a collective. Because of the Israeli occupation, their opportunities as individuals are highly restricted.
After they graduate, they cannot obtain a license to start a new business if it competes with an existing Israeli industry. There are few interesting Government jobs available to them, because virtually all are controlled by Israelis.
They can leave to look for work in Jordan or the Persian Gulf, but under Israeli regulations any male between the ages of 16 and 26 who leaves cannot come back for at least nine months. The regulation was imposed to prevent gun-running and to encourage settlement abroad.
One of the paradoxes of the last 20 years is that it was the Israelis who, by offering many employment opportunities to West Bank Palestinians in manual labor inside Israel, created a huge Palestinian middle class that could afford to send its children to colleges and technical schools.
When the West Bank was under Jordan, there was only a tiny middle class, and the mass of the population was composed either of peasant farmers or landed gentry. Historically, it has been the middle classes who have most often had the sophistication and the motivation for serious upheavals.
Today, according to the Center for Palestinian Studies, an Arab research organization in Jerusalem, there are 17,000 Arab youths in the West Bank and Gaza studying at 20 post-high-school institutions. Many of those who graduate from these institutions, however, never end up working at what they were trained for.
Their frustrations derive from the Palestinian identity that has been shaped in the West Bank in the last 20 years of Israeli occupation. Under the Jordanian occupation, Palestinians were never quite sure what their identity was.
Their passports were issued by Jordan, and they were represented in the Jordanian Parliament; but although some thought of themselves as Jordanian nationals and assimilated into Jordanian society, many others viewed themselves as Palestinians and resented the Jordanian attempts to play down their separate identity.
Under the Israeli occupation, by contrast, they no longer had an option of assimilating. The challenge of the Israeli occupation, coupled with the rise of the Palestine Liberation Organization and the collapse of Pan-Arabism as a predominant ideology after the 1967 war, all combined to forge a Palestinian national consciousness among West Bank youth.
“Between 1949 and 1967, whenever anyone asked me what I was, I always hesitated,” said Munir Fasheh, Dean of Students at Bir Zeit University, who grew up in Ramallah. “Legally, I was Jordanian, but emotionally I was Palestinian. Now, there is no kid on the West Bank under the age of 25 who has ever experienced anything other than being a Palestinian.
When you consider that 60 percent of the West Bank population is under the age of 20, it means that for three-quarters of them Jordan is something that doesn’t exist.” But under the Israeli occupation, his Palestinian political identity is not allowed to find expression in political parties, political assembly or self-rule.
Israel, Jordan and the United States are trying to help King Hussein reassert his traditional influence over the West Bank and to undermine the P.L.O.’s popularity there, in hopes of being able one day to arrange a Jordanian-Israeli solution.
‘60 or 70 Years Before Victory’ This policy, however, seems to be in contradiction with the mood among the young generation, whose attitudes about peace have been shaped almost entirely by the P.L.O. “For tomorrow, we want the West Bank and Gaza, with the P.L.O. in charge,” said Abdallah, a 23-year-old engineering student at Bir Zeit.
“For the day after tomorrow, we want a democratic, secular state in all of Palestine, so that the Palestinians from Haifa and Jaffa can go back home. I estimate 60 or 70 years before victory.” Zuhad, a veiled 20-year-old Moslem fundamentalist who is majoring in linguistics, said: “I want an independent state in all of Palestine by armed struggle.
Why not all tomorrow? They took it with armed struggle, so we’ll get it back with armed struggle.” As for the future of the Israelis, Serene said: “Don’t worry — we are not going to throw the Jews into the sea It is just that Jews are a religion, no a nationality. All those Jews who were here before 1917 can stay.
Those who came later will have to return to the countries they came from.” But what if they cannot? “I think they can,” she said. The Israeli authorities are not unaware of the hard-line views of many educated Palestinian youths.
They tend, however, to view the hard-liners as a minority elite that has intimidated, or out-talked, a majority who only want to be left in peace and accommodate with the status quo. “Maybe we are are talking about 12,000 students who are now intensely pro-P.L.O.,” said a top Israeli Army officer in the West Bank administration.
“We assume that whatever solution will be achieved here, this group will be out in the streets opposing it.” Arafat Is Still a Hero Moreover, the officer said, when these youths grow up and have to get jobs they will moderate their views, both because they have matured and because Jordan and Israel together control most of the employment opportunities in the area.
But others say this could lead to more frustration rather than more stability. It is hard to sit with young people anywhere in the West Bank today and not find them expressing support for Yasir Arafat, the P.L.O. chairman. This may seem incomprehensible, in that Mr. Arafat has only losses to show.
But it seems that the more he loses, the more the young Palestians identify with him as someone who, like themselves, is caught in a vise between Israel and the Arabs. “Arafat is like the stones we throw in demonstrations,” Meral said. “When we stand against the Jews, all we have is this stone.
He may be weak in what he can do, but he is the symbol of the Palestinians.
He is the stone we throw against the world.” [PULL QUOTE set between the first and second columns, boxed by rules:] ‘We want any means of getting back at the Jews.’ [The lower left of the clipping is a display advertisement (a men’s clothing “WINTER SALE”) and the newspaper’s own mail-subscription box. Not transcribed.]
A group of Arab men in Gaza being searched by Israelis last November after a Jewish man was stabbed nearby.
· Los Angeles Herald Examiner · page A3 (jump: A11)
Are jailed Palestinians terrorists or scapegoats?
Profiles of seven whom some see as cause celebre
By Timothy Carlson
The FBI and the INS said they were rounding up a group of people living in Los Angeles who belonged to one of the most feared terrorist organizations in the world — the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.
Famed attorneys and organizations like the ACLU say that six men holding Jordanian passports and a woman from Kenya are now innocent defendants in what might become the foremost civil rights case of the 1980s. The case underscores the difficulty of distinguishing legitimate political activity from support for terrorism when it comes to a volatile issue like Palestinian rights.
While the FBI and the Immigration and Naturalization Service have clamped down on releasing any information about those charged, family members and others who know them recently agreed to talk about the accused. Khader Musa Hamide, 32, of Glendale. Born in Bethlehem on West Bank. Alleged ringleader of PFLP in Southern California, according to FBI statements.
He is married to Julie Mungabh, 28, of Kenya, an accountant. Studied business at University of Oregon in Eugene at the same time she was there. His brother, Ibrahim Hamide, 36, a Eugene restaurateur, came to visit him in jail and said they both started laughing about the absurdity of his being labeled “a threat to national security.”
Hamide, within days of becoming an American citizen until his arrest, had been an activist, speaking out on Palestinian and human rights issues. Los Angeles Councilman Robert Farrell recalls Hamide warmly as a local coordinator for a concert at the Wilshire Ebell Theater of a Palestinian folk dance troupe from Bir Zeit University in the Israeli-occupied West Bank territories.
Hamide also was a delegate to a convention of Jesse Jackson's Rainbow Coalition, and a member of a Los Angeles-based club of American Arabs who backed Democratic candidates. “He is a quiet man, a really sharp person who has a real interest and zeal to participate in the democratic process,” Farrell said Friday.
“He's a man with a lot of positive energy, the kind of a man who will be a great American.”
Maxine Shehadeh, right, wife of Michel Shehadeh, says their son Ibrahim, held by Maria Garcia, “had nightmares after his father was arrested and woke up screaming. ...He asks, ‘Where's my daddy?’” | Michel Shehadeh, holding Ibrahim, was working and attending college at the time of his arrest.
Authorities yesterday released on bond the last three of eight people accused of membership in a Palestinian terrorist group. The defendants — seven men with Jordanian citizenship and the Kenyan wife of one of them — face a deportation hearing on April 28. Seven of the defendants were taken into custody Jan. 26 and the eighth was picked up Feb. 12.
Richard Kellner, the acting district director of the Immigration and Naturalization Service, said Aiad Barakat, 26, of Glendale, Naim Sharif, 26, of Northridge and Bashar Amer, 24, of Alta Loma were released from Terminal Island federal prison yesterday afternoon.
Accused PLO members freed—Naim Sharif, left, Aiad Barakat and Bashar Amer wave to supporters outside the Federal Building in Los Angeles after being released on bail from Terminal Island prison.
The three, along with five other foreigners released Tuesday, face a deportation hearing April 28 over their alleged membership in the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization.
A group of Jordanians who face deportation under a little-known law spoke publicly for the first time yesterday, describing the “nightmare” of their arrest on charges of belonging to a Marxist-Palestinian organization. The six men and a Kenyan woman were arrested Jan. 26 in an INS-FBI sweep of houses throughout the Los Angeles area. A seventh man was arrested Feb.
12 as he was taking a chemistry exam at Chaffey College. They were held at Terminal Island without bail until last week when an immigration judge decided they should be released on bail. All eight face a deportation hearing in immigration court on April 28.
“I sincerely think this is an outrageous act that I did not expect to take place in this country,” said Khader Hamide of Glendale, whom the government has alleged is the Southern California leader of the radical Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.
“All the charges are ridiculous,” Hamide, 32, said at a news conference at the Los Angeles office of the American Civil Liberties Union. ACLU and other civil rights attorneys representing the defendants have said the case could be a landmark that tests basic civil rights.
The INS is seeking to deport the eight under a McCarthy-era statute, the 1952 McCarran-Walter Act, which gives the government the right to deport aliens who belong to a group that advocates world communism.
INS attorneys have sought to present the testimony of two government witnesses in secret proceedings, citing reasons of national security, but were rebuffed by Immigration Judge Roy Daniels. Hamide said he was never read his rights, that he suffered racial slurs from guards and that he was shackled during visits with his family.
Hamide's Kenya-born wife, Julie Mungai, is also accused of the same charges. Mungai, a 28-year-old accountant, was not present during the news conference. Naim Sharif, 26, of Northridge described his arrest. “I was in bed sleeping. I opened my eyes. I saw two police officers standing at my door. He was pointing a gun at me. ... I asked them if I could change my clothes.
THE year after Egypt and Israel did battle in the 1973 war, and three long years before President Anwar el-Sadat of Egypt embarked on his peacemaking journey to Jerusalem, a young and rebellious Egyptian woman from Cairo’s elite defied her parents, her husband and her political upbringing by traveling across the divide into the mysterious, forbidden land of the archenemy.
Drawn by the taboo and by a gnawing curiosity about the Jews who had been vilified in her schoolbooks, she intended to venture into Israel for six weeks.
She stayed almost three years, working her way deeply into the political, religious, ethnic and socioeconomic complexities of the Jewish state and producing, here, a portrait of Israel that is warm, gritty, compassionate, angry and caring.
But ultimately, her exploration became something more intimate, more delicate, more troubling for her than a mere discovery of the enemy’s human face: She confronted herself. It is that confrontation, the tension about who she is and where she belongs, that vibrates like a melancholy bell through Sana Hasan’s chronicle of her sojourn in Israel.
It lends her book a novelistic quality, making her the protagonist in an exposure of both Israel’s foibles and her own. And it imparts a powerful sense of motion to this diary, for she changes during those years. She learns, she grows, she comes to understand and to value in ways she had not before.
Finally, she acquires the curse of the humane; she transcends state frontiers, moves beyond nationality and religion and thereby loses the comfort of belonging. “Having crossed so many boundaries, having invented so many Promised Lands, I could no longer find my way back home,” she writes at the end.
“I would have to make peace with an identity that did not depend on being part of a group, or a country. I would return to Egypt many times, but the world I had come to be most familiar with was that of the outsider, the stranger, the exile.
And though I would continue to long for a tangible homeland, I realized that for me its site would henceforth be no more than a place of memory or imagination, occasionally recaptured, only to be lost again.” So the joy of tolerance sets her sadly adrift.
Like a scattered few in other societies at war — the few who search for their own truth — Sana Hasan does not fit anywhere in the neat grid of definitions provided by that human organization we loosely call civilization.
Here, at the conclusion, her title, “Enemy in the Promised Land,” becomes a surreal, ironic self-indictment, a statement not merely of politics but of the most painful personal drama. If this book were not any of that, if it were merely Ms. Hasan’s observations of Israel, it would be enough.
With a keen eye and a flair for storytelling, she presents the full cornucopia of Israeli life, participating in much of it and taking us into some realms rarely seen by most Israelis themselves. Indeed, she seems to have every experience possible in Israel. About the only thing that she doesn’t manage to do is to serve in the army.
She does have a love affair with a high-ranking army officer, however, which runs like a frayed thread through the book, even creating at moments a fear that she is being set up for blackmail. Finally it unravels inconclusively. Underlying her journey are the stereotypes of Jews, which she has been taught, and Israelis’ stereotypes of Arabs, which she encounters.
As she flies to Israel in July 1974, she remembers her sixth-grade grammar homework: “The words underlined in the following sentences are in the nominative. Indicate the reason for this: “The battle for the sake of Palestine is a duty. “The Arabs will drive the Jews out of Palestine.”
But then she finds herself the object of false images, first as she is guided around the country by a Labor Party veteran, Rivka Guber, who is “amazed . . . by the fact that I spoke English so well. Never, she confessed, would she have dreamed that she would one day meet a young woman from ‘Arabia’ who was as highly educated as herself.” Soon after her arrival in Israel, Ms.
Hasan — already well known from an article in The New York Times Magazine advocating peace — is picked up by the politicians, who treat her like a showy trinket to be twirled boastfully. She does most of them in with sharp vignettes, while recognizing that her expectations of them are based on “the grotesque caricatures in the Egyptian newspapers.”
Menachem Begin, “the devil incarnate in Arab mythology,” invites her to lunch in the Knesset dining room and praises the Egyptians “unctuously” as “a more civilized, gentler people than other Arabs.”
She debates him toughly on Israeli occupation of the West Bank, and he disgusts her by summoning an Israeli Arab from a nearby table to hold forth obsequiously on “the many gains that benevolent Jewish rule had brought the Palestinians in the occupied territories.”
But at his invitation, she attends a convention of his Herut Party in Hebron, on the West Bank, recording the fierce pro-Jewish rhetoric and songs.
Sana Hasan in Jerusalem’s Mea Shearim quarter in January.
· Los Angeles Times · page 14, Part I (continued from Page 3)
DEPORT: Airport Photos of Two Palestinians Are Part of U.S. Case
source said, the government sought to avoid unfavorable publicity over arrests that would have put immigrants behind bars over the Christmas holidays. Investigators had no reason to believe that the immigrants would commit overt acts of terrorism, one source said. To think so, the source said, is to have “a naive concept” of the case.
“How the hell do they make bombs,” the official asked, “if they don't get the money?” All of the defendants have denied any involvement with the Popular Front here or abroad.
They are charged under a deportation section of the 35-year-old Immigration and Nationality Act with advocating “the economic international and governmental doctrines of world communism or the establishment in the United States of a totalitarian dictatorship ... through any written or printed publications. ...”
Arab and civil rights groups branded the arrests “Arab-bashing” and a political response to what they call the Reagan Administration's failed Middle East policies.
So far, a defense team of about a dozen attorneys, including civil rights lawyers Leonard Weinglass, former U.S. attorney general Ramsey Clark plus a group of young California attorneys have worked on behalf of the defendants.
“We see this as the Reagan Administration's [test] case to turn the corner against terrorism,” said Jorge Gonzalez, a member of the defendants' legal team. “This is a very political case.” “The arrests have absolutely nothing to do with the Arab community,” a government source responded.
“They have to do with a group that was in violation of the immigration laws. The case is easily provable.”
Eight accused of terrorist links seek dismissal of charges
By Milton McGriff
Attorneys for eight defendants facing deportation for alleged ties to a terrorist group filed several motions in immigration court yesterday, including a request for dismissal of charges on grounds of unconstitutionality. The defendants are accused of “protected First Amendment activity,” said defense attorney Marc Van Der Hout.
Van Der Hout's clients — seven Palestinians and a Kenyan — are charged with violating a section of the 35-year-old McCarran-Walter Act that allows the expulsion of aliens who advocate communism.
Another motion charged the government with unfairly singling the defendants out for prosecution “because they are Palestinians in particular, and Arabs in general,” Van Der Hout said.
Other motions filed include a request to suppress “unlawfully seized evidence,” a request to obtain prosecution evidence that will be used at the deportation hearing, a request for disclosure of use of electronic surveillance, if any, and a request for clarification and further elaboration of the charges.
Immigration Judge Ingrid Hrycenko will rule on the motions April 14, Van Der Hout said. All of the defendants are free on bail.
The defendants are Khader Hamide, 32, the alleged leader of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine in Southern California; Julie Nyangugi Mungai, 28, his Kenyan-born wife; Aiad Khaled Barakat, 26; Ayman Mustafa Obeid, 24; and his brother, Amjad Mustafa Oneid, 23; Naim Nadim Sharif, 26; Bashar Husam Amer, 24; and Michael Ibrahim Nasif Shehadeh, 30.
· Los Angeles Times · page 18, Part I (continued from Page 3)
PLO: U.S. Moves to Put 8 Suspects Back Into Prison
Immigration and Naturalization Service attorneys had urged Judge Daniels to listen to government testimony in secret to support their contention that the immigrants represented national security and flight risks and should therefore be denied bond. Daniels refused and released five of the immigrants on their own recognizance and three on low bail.
“The immigration judge clearly erred and abused his discretion,” said INS attorney Melainie Fitzsimmons, who wrote the briefs filed on Monday. The immigrants' lead counsel, Dan Stormer, said the briefs amounted to “a clear attempt to use rhetoric instead of substance.
It's exactly the same argument that was rejected by [Immigration Judge] Daniels and which I believe will be rejected by the board.” All of the defendants—seven Palestinians and a Kenyan arrested and jailed last Jan. 26—have denied being connected to the PFLP, which has a history of violence in the Middle East, Africa and Europe, primarily in the 1970s.
Khader Musa Hamide, 32, of Glendale, accused of being the group's leader in California, came under the sharpest government attack in the new court filings. Hamide, a longtime political activist, was accused of being “a dominant leader” of the PFLP who “works full time on behalf of the” faction.
Hamide, whom Fitzsimmons said entered the United States in 1971 “as a PFLP member ... distributes [PFLP] literature in Southern California and Arizona” and speaks and writes on behalf of the PLO faction.
Hamide's Kenyan wife, Julie Nyangugi Mungai, 28, helped Hamide with PFLP fund raising and worked “in liaison with [PFLP] front organizations ... and with other third party organizations” whose functions were similar to the PFLP, the government alleged.
Student Is One of Four Shot in the West Bank During a Protest Over Arrests
By THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN, Special to The New York Times
RAMALLAH, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, April 13 — Israeli troops shot dead a Palestinian student and wounded at least three others today when West Bank youths took to the streets to protest the arrest by Israel of nine Palestinians. Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin ordered the detention of the Palestinians, including two prominent intellectuals, late Sunday night.
They were put under administrative detention, under which they can be held without charge or trial for up to six months. This morning about 400 students — shouting “P.L.O.!
Israel no!” and “God is great!” — gathered for a demonstration in support of the nine Palestinians outside Bir Zeit University, 15 miles north of Jerusalem on the West Bank.
A clash erupted between the students and Israeli soldiers trying to break up the protest, and the soldiers eventually opened fire on the students with live ammunition, witnesses said.
Corpse Taken From Hospital The dead student, Musa Hanafi, 23 years old, from Rafah in the Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip, was rushed to a hospital in Ramallah, five miles north of Jerusalem, with a bullet wound in the neck. After he died, some of his friends apparently spirited his corpse out of the hospital before Israeli soldiers could impound it.
To prevent Palestinian funerals from turning into demonstrations, Israeli troops sometimes impound the bodies of Palestinians killed in demonstrations, only allowing their families to bury them at night in closed ceremonies.
Today’s shooting at Bir Zeit was the latest in a widening cycle of clashes between Israeli soldiers and settlers on one side and Palestinian protesters in the occupied West Bank and the Gaza Strip on the other.
The mounting frustration on both sides is palpable: The Israeli authorities and Jewish settlers on the West Bank seem increasingly angered by the fact that no matter how many people they arrest, no matter how many Palestinian leaders they expel and no matter what security measures they adopt, the level of anti-Israeli Palestinian violence continues to mount.
Palestinians Lashing Out If anything, Palestinian youths have become more brazen in their willingness to confront armed Israeli troops or to attack Israelis in broad daylight.
According to Majid, a Bir Zeit student council leader who asked that his last name not be used, today’s demonstration began at about 10 A.M. when students blocked roads with tires and stones around the old campus in the village of Bir Zeit. An army patrol came along and ordered them to clear the road, which they began to do, he said.
“Then all of a sudden three buses full of Israeli soldiers showed up and hundreds of students started to gather,” the student said in a telephone interview. “As soon as the soldiers came out of the buses, they started shooting at the students.”
According to an Israeli Army spokesman, today’s clash began when hundreds of students gathered outside the campus. “They started to throw stones and burn tires and block the road,” the army spokesman said.
“The soldiers fired rubber bullets and tear gas, and when this did not help disperse the students, and the soldiers’ lives were at risk, they opened fire with real bullets.”
Israeli soldiers carrying a wounded Palestinian student into a hospital in Jerusalem yesterday. A clash erupted between students and Israeli soldiers trying to break up a demonstration outside Bir Zeit University.
The following dispatch was altered by Israeli military censorship. TEL AVIV, April 13 (AP) — Israeli officials met today in Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir's office to discuss charges of high-level corruption in the state security field, the Israeli radio reported. The details of the charges are secret.
The Supreme Court has banned publication of details of the affair, the daily newspaper Yediot Ahronot reported. The officials who met today, including representatives of the Defense and Justice ministries, decided to initiate legal proceedings and to ask the Government to present its position, the Israeli radio and the Itim news agency said.
A legislator from the leftist Shinui Party, Mordechai Virshubsky, said he had appealed to Mr. Shamir and Justice Minister Avraham Sharir to prevent any attempt to block an inquiry. Fabricated Evidence Mr. Virshubsky said he had discovered that evidence had been fabricated for a court hearing, but he declined to be more specific.
He charged that Attorney General Yosef Harish was under pressure to close the case. “I appealed to whom I had to appeal, and I hope they will act,” Mr. Virshubsky said. He declined to elaborate.
The daily Hadashot reported on Sunday that the Attorney General's office had “received material showing that in a trial held in the north, illegal acts of falsifying evidence were committed.” A Justice Ministry spokeswoman refused to comment on the reports.
Hadashot said the affair involved “a highly sensitive security issue” and identified its central figure as a man whose name “was connected to another affair that shook the Israeli public.” The newspaper said the man had resigned from his post several months ago and was promoted to a senior job at a state-owned company.
Most Israeli newspaper reports on the case mentioned an article published last week by the weekly Koteret Rashit about Yossi Ginossar, a former senior agent of the Shin Beth, the internal security service. Mr.
Ginossar, 41 years old, was one of 11 Shin Beth agents pardoned without trial by the President after it was disclosed that two Palestinian bus hijackers were beaten to death after being taken captive in April 1984. The scandal dominated Israel last year.
Shin Beth agents fatally beat the two Palestinian hijackers and allegedly falsified evidence and lied about their activities in subsequent investigations. Immediately after the hijacking, officials reported all the hijackers had been killed when Israeli forces stormed the bus.
Picket protesting INS action scheduled for Federal Building
Picketing is scheduled for Tuesday, April 28 from 4:30 to 6:00 p.m. in front of the Federal Building in Seattle by the Seattle group Ad Hoc Committee for Justice.
The picketing is part of nationwide events calling for the dropping of charges against eight Palestinians and a Kenyan who were arrested January 26, 1987, in Los Angeles by the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS). Another Palestinian was arrested in February.
Speakers at the picket will include: John Caughlin, National Lawyers Guild; Paul Zilsel, International Jewish Peace Union; Ahmad Amr, Palestine Human Rights Campaign; and Barbara Nelson, Ad Hoc Committee for Justice.
Six of these individuals have been charged with violating Section 241(a)(6) of the Immigration and Naturalization Act, a section of U.S. immigration law which was enacted as the McCarran-Walter Act in 1952.
Section 241(a)(6) makes it a deportable offense to be affiliated with any “organization that causes to be written, circulated, distributed, published or displayed, written or printed matter advocating or teaching economic international and governmental doctrines of world communism.”
The INS charges that each of these six individuals is affiliated with the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a member organization of the Palestine Liberation Organization. Such affiliation is, according to the INS, “Order to Show Cause,” a violation of Section 241(1)(6).
The six individuals are: Khader Hamide, a lawful permanent resident; Amjad Mustafa Obeid; Ayman Mustafa Obeid; Aiad Khaled Barakat; and Naim Nadim Sharif. The four who are not lawful permanent residents are also being charged with technical violations of their student or visitor visas.
The remaining three individuals are all being charged with technical violations of their student visas. The INS maintained to the immigration judge that the six were a “national security risk” and they were held in detention without bail until a preliminary hearing which took place on February 17, 1987.
Judge won't dismiss case against Palestinians, Kenyan
Subversion charges dropped, but INS still asks deportation on visa violations
By Karen Cusolito
An immigration judge yesterday denied defense requests to dismiss a deportation case against eight people accused of belonging to a Palestinian terrorist organization. Immigration Judge Ingrid Hrycenko denied defense contentions that the charges are unconstitutional, that the government was singling out Arabs and that the government had engaged in misconduct.
The judge also denied a defense request that the Immigration and Naturalization Service produce evidence against their clients, saying the rule of discovery — which allows opposing sides to examine one another's evidence — does not apply in immigration court.
INS officials dropped subversion charges against six of the eight on Thursday but vowed to deport them on visa violations. Civil rights attorneys who are defending the eight yesterday called the government's tactic “a farce” and an attempt to limit political discussion on the Palestinian issue.
“What happended here is no different than what happened 30 years ago. This is new-fangled McCarthyism,” said ACLU attorney Mark Rosenbaum. The seven Palestinians and one Kenyan were arrested in January in a joint FBI-INS raid in the Los Angeles area and charged with belonging to the Marxist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.
Deemed a national security risk, the accused were held in solitary confinement in federal prison for nearly three weeks until an immigration judge allowed their release on bail. Although subversion charges have been dropped against six of them, INS spokesman William Odencrantz has said they are still a risk to national security.
Three of the accused appeared at a news conference yesterday to describe how the case has affected their lives. Julie Mungai, 29, of Kenya, said it will be difficult for her to get a job despite her MBA.
LOS ANGELES (UPI) — A federal judge Monday dismissed all charges against eight foreign nationals who accused of membership in a Palestinian terrorist group because a top immigration official failed appear at their deportation hearing. U.S.
Immigration Judge Ingrid Hrycenko angrily noted that without testimony of Gilbert Reeves, who was acting Los Angeles district director of the Immigration and Naturalization Service when the defendants were charged in December, the government could not prove that the charges had been properly authorized.
The packed courtroom immediately erupted in pandemonium as the defendants, seven Jordanians and one Kenyan, and their lawyers jumped up, cried out and hugged each other. Government attorneys left silently, without comment.
Hrycenko, shaking with anger, had said that without Reeves as a witness the government could not prove the charges were approved by someone with proper authority. Hrycenko Friday had ordered Reeves to appear at Monday's hearing. “I will terminate all proceedings because of the defective issuance of an order to show cause,” Hrycenko said.
The judge then strode from the bench, but returned moments later to tell INS attorneys sternly, “I will no longer tolerate any of these tactics. You have 10 days in which to decide whether to file an appeal.” INS officials had not decided whether to appeal the ruling.
“I'm so happy,” said defendant Michel Shehadeh, 30, a Long Beach State Univerisity student. “It proves what we've been saying all along, that we're good, lawful residents of this country. I have faith in the American people, that whatever the government will do, the American people are watching and won't let them get away with it.”
Charges against Palestinians dismissed; INS to file appeal
LOS ANGELES (UPI) — The government plans to refile charges that were abruptly dismissed by a furious immigration judge against eight foreign nationals accused of belonging to a Palestinian terrorist group, officials said.
Judge Ingrid Hrycenko said she dismissed the charges Monday because Gilbert Reeves, who was acting Los Angeles district director of the Immigration and Naturalization Service when the defendants were charged in December, failed to appear at the hearing as she had ordered.
Hrycenko, shaking with anger, said that without Reeves as a witness, the government could not prove the charges were approved by someone with proper authority. “I will terminate all proceedings because of the defective issuance of an order to show cause,” Hrycenko said.
The judge then strode from the bench, but returned moments later to tell INS attorneys, “I will no longer tolerate any of these tactics. You have 10 days in which to decide whether to file an appeal.”
Esmeralda Cabrera, the government attorney in charge of the case, said after the decision the government would refile the charges against the defendants, seven Jordanians and one Kenyan. “The cases are very much alive,” Cabrera said. It was unclear exactly what Hrycenko meant by “tactics,” and she declined to comment on her decision after the preceding.
But a Justice Department source told the Los Angeles Times that the government had welcomed the possibility of having a new judge assigned to the complex and controversial case.
Hrycenko, a former federal prosecutor, has overridden government objections that she did not have authority to hold a due-process hearing and raised questions about Reeves' authority to sign the original deportation orders.
“Was that a slick move or was that a slick move?” an unidentified goverment official told the Times, referring to the government's decision to not produce Reeves, leading Hrycenko to dismiss the charges and likely setting the scene for a new judge to hear the case.
Judge refuses to deport alleged members of terrorist group
LOS ANGELES — Khader Hamide (left), Michel Shehadeh (center) and Ayman Obeid leave court here Monday after an immigration judge dismissed deportation proceedings against them and five other immigrants accused of belonging to a Marxist Palestinian terrorist group, which all eight deny.
The government had sought to deport them under a McCarthy-era law that bars aliens who promote world communism, triggering outrage from Arab and civil liberties groups who accuse the government of harassing those who disagree with U.S. policy. The government said it would appeal.
Arabs and Jews in Israeli Schools Rally Against Unequal Tuitions
By THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
JERUSALEM, May 18 — Israeli Arabs led thousands of Jewish university students in demonstrations today against a decision by the Israeli Cabinet to charge students who have not served in the Israeli Army — Israeli Arabs, primarily — nearly 50 percent more in tuition than those who have served.
At the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, Arab university leaders delivered speeches rejecting the Government’s tuition plan and led some 2,000 Jewish and Arab students in chants of “Equality to Jews and Arabs in education!” “Down with a racist society!” “Stop the apartheid policies!” and “No, no, fascism must go!”
Students could recall no other similar display of Jewish-Arab solidarity. … There are about 4,000 Arabs among the 75,000 university students in Israel. Only Israeli Jews are required to serve in the army, or to do equivalent Peace Corps-style national service in underdeveloped areas. Israeli Arabs are not drafted by the army, although a few volunteer.
While many religious Israeli Jews do not serve in the army, most of them also do not attend secular universities. In light of the Cabinet’s decision, many students wore badges today that read: “$1,550: Second Class Citizen.” Some Arab students also came to campus sporting yellow badges that recalled the badges the Nazis forced Jews to wear.
‘A Seventh-Rate Citizen’ “I’m sick of living this way; I feel like a seventh-rate citizen, not a second-rate citizen,” Adil Gamami, an Arab student from a village near Nazareth who worked as a contruction worker last year to save money to attend Hebrew University, told the newspaper Yediot Aharonot.
“Everybody gets reductions and all at the expense of the Arab population. If there is peace I will serve in the Israeli Army, but not in an occupying army. I cannot fight against my Arab brothers.”
Israeli university students demonstrating yesterday in Jerusalem.
A civil rights organization said it will appeal U.S. District Court Judge Stephen Wilson's decision not to rule on the constitutionality of the McCarran-Walter Act which the government wants to use in a terrorist deportation case.
Federal prosecutors are trying to deport seven Palestinian men and a Kenyon woman for having alleged ties to the radical Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which advocates a violent overthrow of the United States. All eight have denied the charge.
Prosecutors contend two of the men, Khader Hamide, the alleged leader of the Popular Front here, and Michel Shehadeh, distributed communist literature.
LOS ANGELES — A federal judge declined Thursday to rule on the constitutionality of a McCarthy-era law cited in an Arab deportation case but said his court was only the first stop in a landmark test of the law.
The American Civil Liberties Union, representing two Arabs facing deportation for alleged ties to the terrorist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, had asked that the McCarran-Walter Act of 1952 be declared unconstitutional. U.S. District Court Judge Stephen Wilson said he had no jurisdiction to decide the issue, which he called enormously important.
He commended the ACLU for taking up the challenge, saying “this is just the beginning.” “The Supreme Court says the Court of Appeals has exclusive jurisdiction in all matters pertaining to deportation, including constitutional challenges,” Wilson said.
At issue is whether illegal aliens are protected by First Amendment rights, including freedom to speak out against the U.S. government. “It's a burning issue,” Wilson said. “It's a question of tremendous constitutional complexity. I suspect this case could very well reach the Supreme Court, and in my opinion, it should.”
Federal prosecutors are trying to deport seven Palestinian men and a Kenyan woman for having alleged ties to the radical Popular Front, which advocates a violent overthrow of the United States. All eight have denied the charge.
Prosecutors charge that two defendants, Khader Hamide, the alleged leader of the Popular Front here, and Michel Shehadeh, distributed communist literature. They are prosecuting the two under the rarely used McCarran-Walter Act, which allows deportation of anyone who espouses world communism. It was last used in the 1950s by the late Sen.
Joseph McCarthy during his search for communists in the federal government. Wilson, citing a case from 1892, said courts have debated the constitutional rights of illegal aliens for nearly 100 years. “No court, to my knowledge, has been presented with this precise issue,” the judge said.
ACLU attorney Paul Hoffman said the group would appeal because courts have side-stepped the issue for years and it was time to force them to decide. “I haven't heard a statement to say that aliens can speak freely. I would like to hear such a statement,” Shehadeh said.
Michael Shehadeh, left, and attorney Paul Hoffman talk with reporters outside courthouse in Los Angeles after Judge Stephen Wilson declined to rule on challenge of McCarthy-era law by the ACLU.
Palestinian Community Unsettled by U.S. Deportation Inquiry
By RONALD L. SOBLE, Times Staff Writer
Some political magazines have vanished from dealers’ shelves. Conventions, fund-raisers and even neighborhood meetings have been shunned by individuals usually considered activists. Photography is frowned upon at folk dances for fear the film will find its way into FBI hands.
Southern California’s Palestinian community appears to still be in a state of shock, brought on by the deportation case against seven Jordanians and a Kenyan accused by the government of being national security risks. Deportation hearings, interrupted last April, are scheduled to resume in Los Angeles on June 26.
“They feel they’re being hunted,” Vicki Tamoush, a Southern California Arab rights activist, said. “Now we find that we have neighbors and colleagues who are not neighbors and colleagues, but who may be undercover agents.”
After an FBI investigation of more than three years, the eight aliens were arrested last January and accused of subversion under the McCarran-Walter Act for allegedly associating with a Marxist faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization called the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.
All of the aliens, none of whom faces criminal charges, have denied the accusation. Tamoush, lawyers for the defendants and leaders of Southern California’s Palestinian community—bolstered by an array of civil liberties organizations—contend the case has had a chilling effect on Palestinians’ daily lives.
They say, for example, that shortly after the arrests, PFLP-supported magazines, which had been available in Palestinian-owned video shops and grocery stores in Los Angeles and Orange counties, suddenly disappeared. One of the government’s key allegations was that the defendants were active in distributing such publications.
“A lot of people are still nervous,” said a Palestinian merchant here who sold the magazines but who added that copies from the Mideast almost immediately dried up after the arrests. “How do they know the next day it won’t be us? Palestinians don’t feel safe.”
Palestinian meetings, fund-raisers and conventions experienced sharp attendance drops immediately after the arrests and attendance has remained low, community sources said.
JERUSALEM, June 17 — A Palestinian editor has announced plans to run for office in Jerusalem’s municipal elections next year. The Palestine Liberation Organization has condemned the idea, prompting the editor, Hanna S. Siniora, to re-evaluate his plans.
But the proposal has forced Israelis to confront a major issue arising from 20 years of territorial occupation — the increasing demands of a rapidly expanding Arab population for full democratic rights. Mr.
Siniora, a 49-year-old Christian who is an avowed supporter of the P.L.O.’s mainstream faction, Al Fatah, has the potential to control at least one-fourth of the City Council if he takes all the city’s Arab vote. In the past, however, most of the 130,000 Arab residents of Jerusalem have refrained from voting in municipal elections in order to protest Israeli rule.
‘Real People, Not Ghosts’ “I want to show that Jerusalem is inhabited by real people, not ghosts,” Mr. Siniora said in an interview at the offices of his small East Jerusalem paper, Al Fajr. “The Israelis have to know there are two peoples living in this city.”
Sitting at his desk, beneath a painting of bright red wildflowers that have been marked “Censored” with the Israeli military censorship stamp, he said, “The only way to resolve the Jerusalem issue is to give both peoples who reside in it sovereign rights, each on his own side of the city, while municipal affairs can continue to be run jointly.”
Only 12,500 of the 70,000 eligible Arab voters, a bloc that is about one-quarter of the city’s 297,000 eligible voters, took part in the last city elections, city officials said. Israeli reactions to Mr. Siniora’s announcement have varied.
Teddy Kollek, the longtime Mayor of Jerusalem, welcomed Arab participation in municipal government, but right-wing hard-liners said it was perhaps time to reconsider the right of Jerusalem Arabs to vote. Commentators on the left of the political spectrum praised Mr.
Siniora’s idea as a jolt to Israelis who have ignored the so-called demographic threat posed by the military occupation of territory in which 1.3 million Palestinians live. “Hanna Siniora’s idea,” Danny Rubinstein wrote in the newspaper Davar, “is saying to us, the Israelis: ‘You want to swallow us, please!
But you will choke with us.’” Meanwhile, most Palestinians, including the publisher of Mr. Siniora’s paper, Paul Ajilouny, have criticized the idea. To run for municipal elections, they say, is to recognize, accept and legitimize Israeli rule over Jerusalem. The Palestinian movement, they assert, is not about sewers, but about national sovereignty.
The Palestinian weekly Al Awdah said in an editorial that since 1967 “the Palestinian people have been fighting with all possible means to achieve their national goal of establishing the independent Palestinian state.” ‘Mistake as Far as Principle’ It added, “Such a move by Siniora is a serious mistake as far as principle and timing are concerned.” Mr.
Siniora, an advocate of a Palestinian homeland, said last week that he would consult with international legal experts to see how his candidacy would affect the sovereignty issue before deciding whether to pursue it further. He has firmly stated that he is not accepting the Israeli annexation of the city. Mayor Elias Freij of Bethlehem is one Mr.
Siniora’s few Palestinian supporters. “It’s a very brilliant idea,” he said. “It will not affect the political future of Jerusalem, because sovereignty does not come through City Hall. But it has reminded the world there are Arabs living in Jerusalem.” Mr. Siniora, a pharmacist by training, has been editor of the Arabic-language Al Fajr since 1974.
He said he was prompted to explore his election initiative when the hard-line Likud bloc of the Israeli Government deferred Foreign Minister Shimon Peres’s idea of an international Middle East peace conference. “I think that to find peace,” he said, “we must first find it in Jerusalem.”
Arab-Americans feel sting of U.S. crackdown on terrorism
By Stephen Franklin, Chicago Tribune
LOS ANGELES—There was an early morning pounding on his front door, a shout by federal agents to open it and then, after two days in local jails, a trip in shackles and handcuffs to a stark federal prison cell.
He says that as he was driven from his house, federal agents ignored his requests to see a lawyer and told him, “We’ll send you to Jordan, and you know the Jordanians won’t treat you as well. They’ll beat you up. They are not civilized like we are.”
Khader Musa Hamide, 32, a short, balding businessman who came to the United States 16 years ago from Bethlehem in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, recalls with hurt and outrage his arrest and 21 days in prison.
He recounts how he, his Kenyan-born wife and six other Palestinians were seized by federal agents last January and told they were unwanted aliens because of their ties to a militant and sometimes violent arm of the Palestine Liberation Organization. Most were rounded up in raids on their homes.
One, however, was seized and handcuffed by four agents while he was taking a chemistry exam at a community college. Their cases begin in federal Immigration Court in Los Angeles later this week, but the implications reach beyond the courtroom.
Initially, the eight were charged under a rarely used 35-year-old section of McCarran-Walter Act that calls for deporting aliens who espouse “world communism.” All the defendants were in the U.S. either as resident aliens or on student visas. Since the arrests the “communism” charges have been dropped.
Hamide and another defendant now are charged with violating another section of the McCarran-Walter Act and the other six are charged with lesser offenses.
After a short-lived court victory in their fight against deportation, [from left] Amjad Obeid, Naim Sharif, Julie Nuangugi Mungai, Ayman Obeid, Aiad Barakat [in rear], Michel Shehadeh, an unidentified woman, and Khader Musa Hamide celebrated outside a Los Angeles courtroom.
JERUSALEM—In a way, the first person to benefit from a unique summer course starting at UCLA this week was 9-year-old Youssef Nazzal. The Palestinian youngster was traumatized when he saw an Israeli soldier shoot an Arab girl in a student demonstration near his home in Ramallah, on the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
After that, the word “Israeli” to him meant “soldier,” and “soldier” meant “bad.” Then, his father, Nafez, a Palestinian-American professor at Birzeit, the West Bank’s largest university, brought home Edy Kaufman, an Israeli friend and colleague who is a Hebrew University political scientist.
The two men always spoke to each other in English, but one day Youssef and his 6-year-old brother, Rami, heard Kaufman speaking in Hebrew over the telephone. “They were stunned,” their father recalled in an interview here. It was only then that the boys realized that their new friend was also one of “them.”
And as a result, Nafez Nazzal said, “my sons now are able to distinguish between an ‘Israeli’ and an ‘Edy.’” It may not sound like much, but given the social and political chasm that separates most of the Israelis and Arabs who live together so uneasily in this tiny strip of land once called Palestine, it is an accomplishment.
The friendship of the two professors grew out of their dream of jointly teaching a university course on the conflict between their respective peoples, a dream that is coming true in Los Angeles this summer.
Nazzal and Kaufman are actually teaching two courses together at UCLA, one on “The Roots of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict” and another on “Current Issues and Prospects for Peace in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict.”
“To the best of our knowledge, this will be the first time in which such a course is presented jointly by a Palestinian and an Israeli,” Kaufman said.
Edy Kaufman, left, and Nafez Nazzal on the UCLA campus.
Israeli Arabs Stage a Strike, Charging Unequal Treatment
“‘We are Israelis like any other citizens, and we demand equal treatment’… Israeli Arabs, who have the right to vote but are exempt from military service, say the Government discriminates against them in public spending, employment and services, particularly education.”
Seven hundred thousand people by this count, five months before the first intifada began. The word exempt is doing quiet work: exemption from the army is what keeps them out of the housing, loans and jobs that service unlocks, which is the complaint the strike was about.
WHAT IS THE meaning of 20 years of Israeli occupation on the lives of the 1.5 million Palestinians who have been the subjects of that occupation in the West Bank and Gaza? Palestinians living in their homeland have the status of “alien resident.”
Although they must pay taxes to Israel, Palestinians cannot vote or be elected at any level; have no degree of judicial control over the government that determines the conditions of their existence; have no meaningful rights of appeal against the judgments of the military courts; and, in the words of former Israeli Foreign Minister Abba Eban, live in a society “in which a man’s rights are defined not by his conduct or by any egalitarian principle, but by his ethnic identity.”
A linear continuation of trends and policies, most begun within months after the June 1967 war, have had an extremely negative effect on every aspect of Palestinian existence. Since 1967, more than 52 percent of the West Bank and 40 percent of the Gaza Strip have been confiscated by Israel for exclusive use by Jews.
By 1986, more than 52,000 Jewish settlers lived in 104 settlements in the West Bank and approximately 2,150 Jews lived in 18 settlements in Gaza. The problems of land alienation and Jewish colonization have contributed to problems in agriculture and employment for Palestinians.
In the words of Meron Benvenisti, an Israeli Jew and former deputy mayor of Jerusalem: “Palestinian agriculture was allowed to develop only insofar as it would not affect Israeli agriculture. Palestinian agriculture could not function properly any longer within the constraints imposed by Israel and its productivity declined.”
The most serious constraint instituted by Israel has been control over water. (Others involve regulations concerning what crops may be grown, how and where they can be marketed, etc.)
Israeli soldier overlooks rubble, above, from one of four buildings that were demolished in 1980 within 24 hours after they were used by gunmen who ambushed West Bank settlers, killing five and wounding 17, and a soldier on patrol in West Bank village of Ramallah, left.
Six months before the uprising. A state is the subject, the verb is stifles, and what is stifled belongs to the Palestinians. Every part of the sentence is assigned, which is rare enough in this archive to be worth saying.
Ag Roads, Water Cisterns, Pools Improve W. Bank Farmers’ Lives
TEQOA, WEST BANK (MCC)—It was a bouncy, 25-minute ride on a twisting, rutted, dirt road. Once or twice, the driver had to back up and navigate the hair-pin turn from a different angle. Along the road were farmers, who had come from the village by horse or truck, weeding and spraying their newly sprouted wheat.
Shepherds were calling their flocks scattered along the steep slopes. Half way down one of the valleys is a cistern, which Mennonite Central Committee had helped two farm families build.
The cistern enables Esa Jadua and his family and neighbors to water their crops and their sheep without hauling water from the village, explained Yacoub Amer, MCC rural development officer in the West Bank. THE CISTERN is one of many that MCC helped West Bank farmers build this past year.
MCC provided an average of two and a half tons of cement to each of 142 West Bank farmers who built cisterns to collect the winter rains in 1986. These cisterns and the other agriculture projects are some of the ways in which MCC supports Palestinian farmers who are eking out a living on the hills of the land once known as Palestine.
In another valley town, Quazeebah, east of El Aroub, are seven cement pools that farmers had built to catch and save the water that flowed from three springs just above the village. MCC provided the cement for the pools and plastic pipes so that these full-time farmers could increase their vegetable production, Amer said.
MCC ALSO HELPED build 31 kilometers of agricultural road, connecting 14 West Bank hamlets to the markets and services of a nearby town in 1986. Visiting MCC representatives saw five kilometers of one of these bulldozer-carved roads and ate a “thank-you” feast prepared by the villagers whose lives had been improved.
The villagers live in Khalet Wahsheh, just south of Hebron, on top of a mountain not far from the “green line” that separates Israel from the West Bank. The road, in which MCC invested $10,000, just a portion of the total cost, enables the 80 people in the hamlet to bring their farm produce and their sick to town by car instead of by horse.
Date check: No masthead or page date line survives — the clipping is trimmed to the two-line headline and two text columns, closing with a house filler. Nothing on it names the paper or the date, so 1987-07-09 and “Mennonite Weekly Review” could not be verified. The dateline credit “(MCC)” and the closing house line, “• A REVIEW WANT AD provides wide advertising outreach at low cost.”, are consistent with a paper called the Review carrying Mennonite Central Committee copy.
Edy Kaufman, Director of the Harry S. Truman Research Institute at Hebrew University, Jerusalem and Nafez Nazzal, professor of Political Science at Birzeit University, West Bank, will discuss “The Middle East: Current Issues and Prospects for Peace,” on Saturday from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. at the World Affairs Center, 312 Sutter St., San Francisco.
Cost: $40 members and $50 non-members, lunch included. Information and reservations: (415) 982-2541.
LONDON, Aug. 18 — Scotland Yard detectives have seized what they say is a large cache of arms and explosives that they believe were intended for a Palestine Liberation Organization terrorist campaign in Europe.
The cache, including 68 pounds of military explosives, was found by detectives searching for the gunman who assaulted Ali Naji al-Adhami, a Palestinian satirist and cartoonist who has been on a life-support machine since being critically wounded here July 22.
Various Middle East factions and individuals had been cited in speculation as possible suspects in the shooting, since Mr. Adhami had a reputation as a scathing and wide-ranging satirist who spared no quarter in his work as the highest paid and most feared political cartoonist in the Arab world.
But in disclosing the arms cache Monday, Scotland Yard detectives said they now suspected P.L.O. supporters were the perpetrators and that links to Libyan and Iranian terrorists were considered unlikely.
Stored for ‘Future Attacks’ Rather, they now theorize that the bomb-making equipment, grenades and rifles found in a private home were being stored by P.L.O. guerrillas for “future terrorist attacks Europewide,” according to a Scotland Yard spokesman. Detectives would offer no specific details on targets.
In the announcement, the police said they had arrested Ishmail Hassan Sowan, described as a 28-year-old university researcher who has been living in England for the last three years. The raid on an apartment in Hull was made Wednesday, but the police delayed announcing the results as they pursued further leads in the investigation. Mr.
Sowan, a Jordanian, appeared in court today and was ordered held in police custody. The P.L.O.’s office in London today denied any involvement in Mr. Adhami’s shooting or any connection with Mr. Sowan. Mr. Adhami, shot at point-blank range on a London street, had been acid in depicting P.L.O. leaders as hypocritical, limousine-riding jet setters and in dubbing Mr.
Arafat “Aby Shafaya” — Father of the Lips — for his fondness for posing as a gentle leader given to kissing children in front of television news cameramen. Assault Rifles and Grenades The police said the arms cache included four AK-47 rifles and ammunition, seven hand grenades and bomb-making equipment.
Detonators were found, according to Scotland Yard, along with the plastic explosive Semtax, the Czechoslovak-made military high explosive that the police say is favored by Arab terrorists. Mr.
Adhami, 42 years old, has been on the critical list since the shooting outside the offices of Al Qabas International, the Kuwaiti newspaper that carries his political cartoons in the Middle East. He had been forced to leave Kuwait in 1985, reportedly after receiving death threats from the P.L.O.
According to Rafle Khoriti, the editor of Al Qabas, recent threats had been directly made against Mr. Adhami. In an interview with Index on Censorship three years ago, he described his satisfaction in drawing “rich Palestinians who scream all day about the land and about sacrifices, when in fact they are more interested in their financial deals and private gains.”
Emergency Brain Surgery Mr. Adhami has been in Charing Cross Hospital, briefly regaining consciousness only twice in the last month but unable to speak. He was shot in the face and underwent emergency brain surgery and has been kept on a life-support machine. In the latest suspicions about the P.L.O., friends of Mr. Adhami are speculating that Mr.
Arafat was not only personally sensitive as a target of the satire but also concerned that his sources of financing in the Persian Gulf not decide to weaken support. Mr. Adhami grew up in a Palestinian refugee district in Lebanon and made his first drawings on the walls of jail cells when he was arrested by Lebanese policemen for political activities.
He had treated the gulf war as a cruelty endured by ordinary citizens in both Iran and Iraq, depicting them as victims of torture and of Iraqi chemical weapons. In his most recent drawings, the cartoonist contended that Iraq might have deliberately been acting to draw the United States more deeply into the conflict.
There are 45,000 Palestinians in L.A., many of them from the West Bank or from Jordan. Denied a homeland by Israeli and Jordanian policies, most of them feel they are the true victims of the Mideast war. Now they and the larger Arab community in L.A. (an estimated 300,000) believe they’ve also become the persecutional targets of the U.S. government.
BY DAVID WEDDLE
The Committee for Justice is the organization formed by the Palestinian defendants and their attorneys to fund and plan strategy for their case. The committee’s office, located near MacArthur Park, is in a shabby, scuffed-up old building furnished with Goodwill rejects — a sadly apt headquarters for the Palestinians’ cause.
In the outer office a group of Palestinians huddle around a milky image on a portable black-and-white TV set; they’re watching the latest updates on the case broadcast over Arab-TV, Channel 18.
As I enter they eye me with tight-lipped suspicion — well warranted, as there has been widespread FBI harassment of the Arab community since the arrests and the trial proceedings. The committee’s phones have been bugged, the defendants and their attorneys have been followed, and people entering and leaving the building have been photographed.
(The government has until September 17 to confirm or deny that electronic surveillance has been used in the case.) When a rally was organized to drum up community support for the defendants, FBI agents tracked down the Arab residents who printed the handbills announcing the event, questioned them, and made threatening comments about their immigration status.
I ask for Khader Hamide, described by my editor as a gentle, intelligent man and a good spokesperson for the Palestinians, and I’m motioned to a larger office that accommodates a larger conference table covered with stacks of paperwork.
At the far end attorney Brian Hudson sits before a typewriter pecking out a press release and sucking on an unending chain of cigarettes. Cursing over his typos, at one point he calls out, “Doesn’t anyone around here know how to type?” No one answers him.
Khader Hamide | Aiad Barakat | The defendants (clockwise, from upper left): Michel Shenadeh, Naim Sharif, Ayman Obeid, Bashar Amer, Khader Hamide, Julie Mungai, Aiad Barakat. (Not pictured: Amjad Obeid.)
TEL AVIV, Aug 22 (Reuters) — Israeli troops shot and wounded a Palestinian youth during disturbances in the town of Nablus in the occupied West Bank Friday, an army spokeswoman said today. The spokeswoman said the youth was slightly wounded when a soldier fired at a crowd that was throwing stones at an army post. He was taken to a local hospital for treatment.
LONDON — Palestinian political cartoonist Ali Naji Awad al-Adhani died Saturday of a bullet wound to the head he received in an attack July 22 in the street outside his London office.
Adhani worked for the largest independent newspaper in the Middle East, the Kuwaiti daily al-Qabas, and was described as the most famous cartoonist in the Arab world, known especially for his criticism of Middle East governments.
He had been in critical condition since an unidentified assailant shot him at point-blank range as he left the al-Qabas office in the Chelsea district. Popularly known as Naji al-Ali, Adhani’s cartoons usually featured a tragicomic dialogue between a destitute Palestinian and Arab government figures, the officials being portrayed as wealthy “fat cats.”
A figure called Hansala generally looked on as a symbol of the silent Arab majority. Adhani frequently criticized both the Palestine Liberation Organization and Iranian leader Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini.
LONDON — Palestinian political cartoonist Ali Naji Awad al-Adhani died Saturday of a bullet wound in the head, suffered in an attack July 22 in the street outside his London office.
Adhani worked for the largest independent newspaper in the Middle East, the Kuwaiti daily al-Qabas, and was described as the most famous cartoonist in the Arab world, known especially for his criticism of Middle East governments.
He had been in critical condition in the hospital where he died since an unidentified assailant shot him at point-blank range as he left the al-Qabas office in the Chelsea district. British police have not yet traced the gunman.
Popularly known as Naji al-Ali, Adhani frequently criticized both the Palestine Liberation Organization and Iranian leader the Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini. Adhani was not believed to have been connected with any Arab political group.
Palestinian Professor Beaten After Reports of Secret Talks
“Masked men today beat Sari Nusseibeh, a Palestinian philosophy professor at Bir Zeit University in the West Bank, after reports appeared in the Israeli press that he and other Palestinian leaders had held secret talks…”
Sari Nusseibeh, beaten for talking to the Likud. Three months before the first intifada. The archive's universities thread and its who-may-speak thread meet in one paragraph.
Israeli Soldiers in Jerusalem Wound 2 Young Palestinians
JERUSALEM, Sept. 20 — Israeli soldiers shot and wounded two young Palestinians near the Damascus Gate of the Old City of Jerusalem today after one of the youths tried to grab a soldier’s rifle, a police spokesman said.
The youth who tried to snatch the rifle was shot in the leg when he tried to escape, and the second wounded man was apparently hit by ricochets, the Israeli radio said. In a separate incident early today, a bomb exploded near a kindergarten in a Jewish neighborhood here. The blast caused no injuries, the radio said.
JERUSALEM, Sept. 28 — The Israeli authorities have revoked the residence papers of a Palestinian-American who encourages Arabs in the occupied territories to engage in nonviolent action against the Israeli occupation. The Palestinian-American, Mubarak E.
Awad, director of the Jerusalem-based Palestine Center for the Study of Nonviolence, is one of few Palestinian leaders who openly condemns violence, and the only one who actively promotes and teaches nonviolent theories of resistance.
The police questioned him extensively last week about a pamphlet he wrote suggesting that Palestinians in the occupied territories refuse to fill out forms in Hebrew, that they boycott Israeli goods and that they lie down in front of bulldozers clearing land for Israeli settlements — rather than engaging in guerrilla activity and hurling rocks at Israeli soldiers.
The pamphlet, “Nonviolent Resistance: A Strategy for the Occupied Territories,” was published in 1983 by New Society Publishers in California. Financed by U.S. Professor “This is the first time I have been interrogated about something I wrote, and not something I did,” said Mr. Awad, a 44-year-old native of Jerusalem who is an American citizen. Mr.
Awad, a psychologist whose wife and children live in the United States, started the center two years ago and runs it with 13 volunteers. The center is financed primarily by Hisham Sharabi, a Palestinian-American professor at Georgetown University.
JERUSALEM (AP) — An Israeli Shin Bet security agent and four Palestinians armed with automatic weapons died in a shoot-out after a car chase in the Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip, an Israeli army statement said today. Maj. Gen.
Yitzhak Mordechai, commander of the southern region, told a news conference broadcast on Israeli army radio that the Palestinians were en route to stage a terrorist attack. He did not specify the target. Authorities imposed an indefinite curfew around the Shusiyeh quarter of Gaza City where the clash occurred Tuesday night, army spokesmen said.
The shoot-out took place after a chase near Gaza City about 1½ miles south of the entrance to the Gaza Strip, according to the statement and army officers. An army spokesman who demanded anonymity said the Palestinians, two of them jail escapees, were traveling in two cars.
After the clash, Israeli soldiers found the Palestinian group was carrying two Soviet-made Kalashnikov automatic rifles, two U.S.-made M-16 automatic rifles, two pistols, one grenade and 25 magazines of ammunition, the army statement said. “In my opinion, the amount of materials and the nature of the group indicated they were on their way to carry out an attack.
The clash prevented them from being able to carry it out and endangering lives,” Mordechai told the news conference. Mordechai said other unidentified people were arrested after the shoot-out. He did not elaborate, or provide details of how security forces spotted the car with Palestinians.
Two of the slain Palestinians were identified as members of the Islamic Jihad or Holy War, a Moslem fundamentalist group which Israeli authorities link to Yasser Arafat’s Fatah guerrillas. The two other Palestinians killed were from a group of six prisoners who escaped May 17 from a jail in Gaza City.
Two of the escapees were recaptured recently and the rest remain at large. The group, all convicted of belonging to the outlawed Palestine Liberation Organization, sawed through eight iron bars of a second-story window and then climbed over a wall to escape. Some were serving terms for murder, arms smuggling and throwing gasoline bombs.
JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli soldiers fatally shot a Palestinian woman and wounded four other people today during protests that swept the occupied territories, a hospital spokesman and Palestinian news reports said… In Ramallah, soldiers fired on hundreds of students who blocked a main road with stones and burning tires, killing one person and wounding four who were rushed to the Ramallah Hospital, the Arab-owned Palestine Press Service said.
The dead woman, identified by the hospital as 35-year-old Amayat Hindi of Ramallah, was shot while on her way to pick up her small children from school, the Press Service said. She wanted to bring her children home because of the protests, the agency said.
Two months before the intifada and before Hamas was founded. The headline says a woman was killed; the first line of the story says who shot her.
GAZA, Oct. 12 — Forty-two-year-old Suad al-Hadidi is a symbol of what Yasir Arafat calls the Palestinian “demographic bomb.” Sitting up in her bed in the maternity ward of the Remal Health Center in Gaza, Mrs. Hadidi proudly folded back some thin white sheets to show off her 10th child, a handsome girl named Ayat, who was born the night before.
Ten children is nothing unusual for Palestinians in the occupied Gaza Strip, said Dr. Zuhni Yusef al-Zahidi, head of maternal health care at the clinic. He said he knows several mothers who have up to 15 pregnancies and one man whose three wives bore a total of 25 children.
Pressure on the Israelis “Many people here say, ‘We must have more babies to compensate for our losses in Lebanon and to put pressure on the Jews to come to the negotiating table,’” Dr. Zahidi said in Arabic, as Mrs. Hadidi and other women in the maternity ward nodded approval. Because of families the size of Mrs.
Hadidi’s, in 12 years Israel and the occupied territories will be, in demographic terms, a binational state. In 1985, for the first time, the total number of Arab children under the age of 4 in Israel, the West Bank and Gaza Strip was greater than the total number of Jewish children under 4 — 370,000 Arabs to 365,000 Jews.
The problems that the rise in Arab population pose for Israeli Jews is rapidly becoming the central issue in the political debate here about the future of the occupied territories and the character of the nation in the 21st century. “We are heading for a binational state, not a Jewish state — no question about it,” said Prof.
Arnon Sofer, a leading experts on the demographic question and dean of the Faculty of Social Sciences at Haifa University. Unless Israel withdraws soon from the West Bank and Gaza Strip, he said, Israelis will eventually be faced with the “calamity” of an Arab majority.
In such a situation, Israeli Jews will either have to extend voting rights to the Arabs in the occupied territories and risk their taking over the state, or systematically deprive them of their rights and turn Israel into a South Africa-like nation. … Quandary for Israel: What Happens When Arabs Outnumber Jews? Continued From Page 1 future is so bleak.
“Everything we have accomplished here was against the statistics, so why should things change now?” asked Geula Cohen, leader of the rightist nationalist Tehiya party, which favors annexation of the entire biblical “Land of Israel” — that is, pre-1967 Israel, the West Bank, Gaza and all of their inhabitants.
“If we would have paid attention to demographic forecasts in 1948 we never would have declared a state,” Mrs. Cohen said. “Just because you get a headache, doesn’t mean you should go out and chop off your head. I don’t deny that there is a problem, but we can live with it.”
The most recent Central Bureau of Statistics figures, in 1985 recorded 3.52 million Jews living in Israel and the occupied territories, or 62.8 percent of the population. There were 749,000 Israeli Arabs, 813,000 West Bank Arabs and 526,000 Gaza Arabs for a total of 2.08 million Arabs, or 37.2 percent of the population. That picture is rapidly changing.
According to bureau figures, in 1985 Israeli Jews had an average birth rate of 21.6 per 1,000 people, while Israeli Arabs had a birth rate of 34.9, Arabs of the West Bank 41.0 and Arabs of the Gaza Strip 46.6 — more than double that of Israeli Jews. Given these rates of growth, the bureau has prepared various low and high demographic forecasts for the 21st century.
The low population forecasts assume decreasing rates of natural growth — that is, births over deaths — in each group and high rates of emigration. The high forecasts assume the opposite. Professor Sofer has averaged all of the high and low forecasts and adjusted them for the year 2000. A bureau official verified his figures.
The Numbers Are Clear: 4 Out of 10 Will Be Arab In the low average forecasts, in 12 years Israeli Jews will number 4.2 million, or 58 percent of the population, and Arabs in Israel, the West Bank and Gaza 3.1 million, or 42 percent. In the high average forecasts, Israeli Jews will number 4.3 million, or 54 percent, and the Arabs 3.7 million, or 46 percent.
In either forecast, Arabs will soon be almost half the population. The bureau, which has been doing long-range population forecasts since the early 1950’s, has consistently been highly accurate. When the changing settlement patterns of these growing Arab and Jewish populations is used as a factor, another picture emerges.
In the Golan Heights, the Jews are still a minority, 38 percent to 62 percent. In the Galilee region of northern Israel, Arabs make up 52 percent of the population and Jews 48 percent. The Negev holds what Professor Sofer called “a kingdom of the Bedouin” — a large Arab Bedouin majority, except in the major towns.
In the West Bank, Arabs outnumber Jews 813,000 to 60,000, and in the Gaza Strip, 526,000 to 2,000. There are clear Jewish majorities only in the large cities, like Tel Aviv, Haifa, Jerusalem, Tiberias, Hadera, Nahariya and Netanya, and their metropolitan areas. But for how long?
According to a study done by Haifa University, the number of Jews in Haifa increased by five-tenths of 1 percent between the censuses of 1972 and 1983, while the number of Arabs there increased by 40 percent during the same period.
This is largely because the young, better-educated generation of Hebrew-speaking Israeli Arabs are leaving their villages and moving to Jewish big city neighborhoods to find better jobs, although not without problems.
Last June, the apartments of six Arab workers, who had moved from their villages to the Jewish Tel Aviv suburbs of Ramat Amidar and Ganei Yehuda, were set afire by Jewish youths. The Israeli police described the attack as a pogrom. “We don’t want Arabs living in our neighborhood,” a Ramat Amidar resident told The Jerusalem Post.
“Let them live in their areas in the Galilee and West Bank, where they belong, but not here. This is a Jewish neighborhood. We won’t stop until the last Arab gets out.” Professor Sofer sees a security issue.
“If the present Arab population creates such problems,” he said, “imagine what it is going to be like in 12 years when their numbers will have almost doubled. We will be busy with internal security all the day.” More and more Israelis are concerned about the increase in the Arab population.
One 24-year-old Israeli college student said she has encountered increasing talk among her Jewish friends about the need to have at least five children to keep up with the Arabs. “I spoke to an old friend of mine from the army who just had his fourth son,” she said.
“When I congratulated him, he said, ‘Well, this is my contribution to the demographic war.’ ” Way to a Compromise: Stress Demographics The issue is also beginning to have a profound effect on both Israeli and Palestinian politics.
For example, Foreign Minister Shimon Peres, of the Labor Party, has used a new strategy in recent public remarks about his Likud bloc rival, Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir.
Labor officials say that because the status quo still seems tolerable for most Israelis, they believe that the only ways to induce Israelis to seriously consider a territorial compromise with the Arabs are either under the pressure of a war begun by the Arabs, or through the recognition by enough Israelis of the demographic dangers.
Since a war is neither desirable nor likely, Mr. Peres has begun to emphasize the demographics. The Likud bloc has traditionally referred to itself as the “national party.” But Mr. Peres has been telling Israelis lately that “the Likud is not the national party but rather the binational party.”
By insisting on holding onto the West Bank and Gaza Strip indefinitely, he argues, the Likud bloc, in effect, insists on turning Israel from a Jewish state into a binational state.
The right-of-center Likud bloc has countered by saying that the Labor Party and its allies are “defeatists,” who have lost faith in Israel’s ability to attract large numbers of Jewish immigrants.
The Immigration Dream And Call for Expulsions In a speech June 25, Prime Minister Shamir declared that “from its inception, our nation was ‘the smallest of all nations,’ and it always faced demographic problems.” “Yet never did out people resort to the solution of escapism,” he added.
“That is no solution” “If we can now reinvigorate the economy in order to provide appropriate employment,” he said. “we can aspire to a resurgence of immigration.” Until recently only Rabbi Meir Kahane, an extremist, dared call publicly for the expulsion of Arabs from Israel and the occupied territories.
Their continued presence in Israel, he argued, threatened the nation’s Jewish character.
But in the last two years, the Deputy Minister of Defense, Michael Dekel of the Likud bloc, and Rehavam Zeevi, a retired Major General who commanded Israel’s central front, the most important in the country, have suggested a transfer of some or all of the Arabs in the occupied territories to neighboring Arab states.
This, they say, may be the only way of avoiding what Mr. Dekel called “having this area turn into a powder keg.”
Among West Bank Palestinians there is a growing school of thought, though still a minority, that believes the “demographic struggle” — not the “armed struggle” — is the best strategy for pressing Israel to grant the Palestinians a state in the occupied territories.
A leading proponent of “demographic struggle” is Hana Siniora, a Palestinian newspaper editor from Arab East Jerusalem, who announced last June that he was considering running for the Jerusalem City Council next year.
No Palestinian from the annexed half of Jerusalem has ever run in an Israeli election out of a concern that it somehow connote acceptance, or recognition, of the occupation of Jerusalem and the West Bank. Mr. Siniora said, however, that since the Arabs of Jerusalem pay full taxes to Israel, they might as well be represented on the city council.
Many Palestinians are quietly urging him to run. “Just making more babies is not enough,” said a Palestinian intellectual, Sari Nusseibeh. “No one in Israel will be concerned by that alone. We have to put Israel on the spot. The demographic bomb will never explode without a fuse. The fuse will be our demand for equal rights.”
But even if the Palestinians in the occupied territories did one day demand equal rights, it is doubtful that Israel would accommodate them, since this would be political suicide.
More likely, said an Israeli Middle East expert, Meron Benvenisti, the Israelis will adopt the solution that the ruling Maronite Christians did in Lebanon after it was clear they were becoming a minority in their own country.
They simply stopped taking a census. [STATISTICAL CHART across the top of the page, three panels under one head:] Israel’s Predicament: High Arab Birth Rate BREAKDOWN FOR 1985 / Includes occupied territories — pie chart: ARABS 37.2%, JEWS 62.8% BIRTH RATES IN ISRAEL / Averages per 1,000 persons for Israeli Arabs and Jews in 1985.
Rate for West Bank Arabs: 41.0; Arabs of Gaza Strip: 46.6. — bar chart: ARABS 34.9, JEWS 21.6 PROJECTION TO YEAR 2000 / In Israel and occupied territories, based on 1985 data. — two pie charts: Low forecast, JEWS 58% / ARABS 42%; High forecast, JEWS 54% / ARABS 46% Source: Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics The New York Times/Oct.
19, 1987 [Also on the clipping and NOT part of the article: a short unrelated wire item, “14 Dead in Crash in Turkey”, AKSEHIR, Turkey, Oct. 18 (AP); and display advertising — Gentlepeople Ltd (a matchmaking agency), Cardio-Fitness Center, and an “ENTREPRENEUR FOR RENT” classified.]
Palestinian women with their newborn children in the maternity ward of a hospital in the Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip.
Date check: No masthead or page date line survives on this clipping — it is trimmed to the italic headline, the byline block and the text, ending at “Continued on Page A8, Column 1”. The credit line reads “Special to The New York Times” and the photo credit “The New York Times/Micha Bar-Am”, both consistent with `pub`. The only internal date is the dateline, “GAZA, Oct. 12”, consistent with an October 13 paper rather than the slide label’s October 19.
Palestinian protester shot by Israelis in Bethlehem
Reuters
“About 20 of them took to the street, throwing firebombs at soldiers and border police, officials said. The army fired shots in the air, dispersing the students.”
29 October 1987, the thirty-first anniversary. Three American papers in this archive carried the day’s events and none of the three mentions what is being commemorated.
Jordanian tells of costly fight against deportation
CHARLOTTE CHANNING, GAZETTE STAFF WRITER
A year ago, Khader Hamide, a Jordanian living under permanent residency status in Glendale, Cal., was a sales representative for an import-export firm who had strong feelings for Palestinians and no hesitancy to voice them.
He has lost his job, spent hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees and faces deportation, but has become a cause celebre among aliens who fear the McCarthy-era McCarron Walter Act could be used to deport them if they speak too loudly for causes not popular with the Reagan administration.
Federal immigration officials say Hamide, here since 1978, and seven other immigrants violated the McCarron Act by being members of an organization dedicated to the spread of worldwide communism, more specifically, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, an offshoot of the Palestine Liberation Organization.
The evidence against him included magazines confiscated at Hamide’s home when he was arrested in January, magazines he said could be obtained in local libraries and bookstores. Evidence also included a photograph of Hamide picking up a box of magazines from a Los Angeles airport.
“I picked up a box of magazines from the airport,” said Hamide, who spoke to a group of about 35 students and faculty members at Western Michigan University Thursday night. “How subversive! So watch out and don’t pick up any boxes of magazines or books.”
Hamide, his case now on appeal, visited campuses in Michigan this week to discuss his plight, solicit support and explain why aliens should enjoy First Amendment rights of free speech. His Kalamazoo visit was sponsored by the WMU group Palistinian Solidarity.
“It cancels the rights of citizens in this country to hear the truth about what is happening” in places like the Mideast, Central America and South Africa, he said. “They don’t want you to hear that a whole nation, the Palestinian nation, is being destroyed by Israel with the help of your tax dollars.”
Sami Esmail, faculty adviser for Palestinian Solidarity at WMU, concurred: “Palestinians in the United States feel we should be allowed to express the Palestinian side of the story.”
To the Editor: “A Forecast for Israel: More Arabs Than Jews” may or may not be correct in placing an Arab majority within Israeli-controlled territory in the future. But it is surely wrong to suggest that the South Africanization of Israel is in the future.
For 20 years, the Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank have been denied human and civil rights and the vote. As the Rev. Allan Boesak said recently at a Palestine Human Rights Campaign meeting, “Oppression in Palestine is so very like oppression in my homeland.”
He also said, and here many Jews would add their voices, “Your struggle and our struggle are not only against oppression and dehumanization but against forgetfulness ... We have a calling, a holy duty to remember ... We are exiles and have to sing the songs of our people in a strange land.” PETER BELMONT Lexington, Mass., Oct.
19, 1987 The writer is a Steering Committee member of Search for Justice and Equality in Palestine/Israel.
2 Arab Schoolgirls Wounded By an Israeli Driver in Gaza
Special to The New York Times JERUSALEM, Nov. 11 — An Israeli driver shot and wounded two Palestinian schoolgirls in Gaza City today when he fired a pistol to ward off protesters who surrounded his car and showered it with rocks, an army spokesman said.
A 17-year-old high school girl was killed in similar circumstances Tuesday in Deir el-Balah, a refugee area in the Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip. The police arrested four Israelis from a Jewish settlement in the Gaza Strip in connection with her death.
One of the 14-year-old girls wounded today was in good condition; the other was flown by military helicopter to a hospital in Ashkelon, where she was reported in critical condition. The police are investigating today’s incident, an army spokesman said.
“Stones were thrown toward his car, and the driver fired some shots in the air to save himself,” the spokesman said. “It appears the girls were hurt from his shots.” In a Tel Aviv suburb, a bomb apparently set by Palestinian guerrillas exploded today in a trash can, but caused no injuries, the police said.
Death of Palestinian in Israeli custody focuses attention on security agency
Robert Ruby
Involved in all these illegal things — though Mr. Rubin said the agency’s…
A death in custody is the occasion, and the subject of the sentence is the attention it focuses. Printed beside a wire item about French hostages chained to a wall, which the page treats as the atrocity story.
JERUSALEM, Dec. 10 — Israeli troops shot and killed a West Bank resident and wounded at least 15 other Palestinians today as violent unrest continued for the second day and spread throughout the occupied territories.
In the city of Gaza and in refugee districts throughout the Gaza Strip, where a 17-year-old youth was killed yesterday by troops, Palestinians gathered in throngs, burned tires, threw stones at vehicles and blocked roads, witnesses said. Army reports said 5 people were wounded by gunshots in the West Bank and 10 were wounded by gunfire in the Gaza Strip.
In addition, a dozen people were hurt in scuffles between Palestinian students and the Israeli police outside a school north of Jerusalem, according to radio reports. Soldiers fatally shot the 19-year-old Nablus man today when a group of Palestinian youths in the northern West Bank city surrounded a military patrol, pelting it with iron bars and rocks, an army spokesman said.
“The forces tried to disperse them with rubber bullets and tear gas,” a spokesman said. “But the force was endangered when its officer was wounded from an iron bar, and the soldiers had no choice but to shoot to get themselves out.”
A woman tried to stab a Border Police soldier in the nearby Balata refugee district but he managed to grab the knife from her hand just in time, an army spokesman said. In the Khan Yunis refugee district in the Gaza Strip, soldiers opened fire and wounded at least eight people after crowds threw gasoline bombs at a military patrol, an army spokesman said.
At least two wounded people were brought into the Shifa hospital in Gaza, where merchants along the main street closed their shops and schools were disrupted by protesting students, an army spokesman said.
RAMALLAH, Israeli-occupied West Bank, Dec. 12 — Israeli soldiers shot and wounded at least five residents of the occupied Gaza Strip today, as shopkeepers throughout the West Bank shuttered their stores to protest the violence that has left six Palestinians dead in four days.
Shops facing the main commercial street of Arab East Jerusalem were closed, as were stores in Nablus and Ramallah, where streets were empty except for Israeli soldiers patrolling on foot and surveying the area from rooftops.
Representatives of the army’s Civil Administration, which runs the daily affairs of the occupied territories, held a meeting with local Palestinians to discuss ways to end the disruptions, the Israeli Radio said.
Estimate of 25 Wounded An army spokesman said five people were wounded in the Gaza Strip, including two who were critically hurt, but the Palestine Press Service estimated at least 25 people were shot in the disturbances in Khan Yunis, Rafah and Deir-el-Balah.
“Often, people will go to a private doctor and not to the hospital when they are hit, because they do not want police to question them and open files on them,” a Palestinian source said.
In the West Bank, the army clamped a curfew on the Balata and Askar refugee districts when the funeral of three people killed by army gunfire Friday in Balata seemed about to set off new disturbances. West Bank Youth Wounded Rock-throwing, blocked roads and tire-burnings were reported throughout the territories.
In Hebron, a Palestinian youth was shot in the hand after throwing a gasoline bomb at an army patrol, an army spokesman said. Students held a protest at Bir Zeit University outside Ramallah, but the army did not interfere because they stayed on campus, the spokesman said. The army is still investigating the fatal shootings Friday, the spokesman said.
“A preliminary investigation says the soldiers, who were caught in a violent protest, tried all the means at their disposal — firing rubber bullets, using tear gas, shouting orders and firing in the air,” the spokesman said. “It was only when there was danger to their lives that the force fired live ammunition.”
'Kill Us or Get Out!' Arabs Taunt As the Toll in Gaza Turmoil Rises
GAZA, Dec. 15 — “Kill us all!” taunted the young Palestinians throwing rocks at the Israeli soldiers. “Come and kill us all or get out!” The band of several hundred at Shifa Hospital in a squalid refugee district was at the center of the fiercest confrontation on the worst of seven straight days of clashes in the Israeli-occupied territories.
A mosque’s minaret across the street blared encouragement. “O, you young people, go at them, don’t back off!” an amplified voice cried as the youths, in a day of scattered fighting, fell back behind the walls of the hospital’s courtyard.
Today the Israeli Army shot to death at least four Palestinians, and possibly as many as six, in the Gaza Strip, according to reports assembled late tonight from various sources.
In what was being widely described here as the most violent week since Israel occupied the strip in the 1967 war, the death toll rose even higher as a Palestinian died in the hospital today of bullet wounds received three days ago.
Near the hospital, women with heads covered according to Islamic tradition broke concrete into chunks and piled them in grocery bags for the young men. Tires burned in the streets. Patients wounded earlier in the day — hospitals were treating virtually nothing but gunshot wounds, ignoring lesser injuries — excitedly watched the fighting from upper-story windows.
“This place is like a time bomb,” said a dark-haired, 23-year-old man with a bandage over his stomach from a wound this morning. “It is filled with dynamite and it is going to go off.” Struggling for the phrase in Arabic, he turned to his sister, her head swathed in a scarf, and they came up with the formulation, “It is them or us.”
Outside, three short bursts of automatic-rifle fire cut through the chants, then more shots were heard. One youth went down, blood streaming from his forehead; he got up, then stumbled again. Others around him kept heaving rocks over the walls, running forward in waves. By the iron gate at the entrance, an Israeli soldier could be seen briefly, kneeling and taking aim.
Then the army pulled back down the scorched, littered streets. Two Palestinians, identified by the Palestine Press Service as Zaher as-Shali and Ibrahim Ali Daqar, both 23, died during this volley of gunfire. Doctors at the hospital and United Nations relief workers confirmed the deaths.
WASHINGTON Israel’s Defense Minister, Yitzhak Rabin, bristled when a questioner asked about the treatment of Palestinians in the occupied territories and drew a parallel with South Africa. Weren’t the tactics of repression in Gaza and the West Bank tearing at the fabric of Israel’s own society? “There is no parallel,” Mr. Rabin said.
There could not be, he said, because Arabs are not a majority as blacks are in South Africa. There are 3.5 million Jews and only about 2 million Arabs in Israel and the occupied territories. But of course the questioner was not raising a point of arithmetic.
The point, one that concerns many Israelis today, is that ruling someone as a subject people, without political rights, requires the use of force and more force — and corrupts those who rule. Mr. Rabin was speaking at the Brookings Institution, to an audience including specialists on the Middle East.
The tension in Gaza, the shooting of Palestinian demonstrators there, gave urgency to the occasion. But anyone who hoped for new light on the problem must have heard Mr. Rabin’s answers with despair. Israel had three options in the occupied territories, Mr. Rabin said. One was to annex them, giving political rights in Israel to all inhabitants who wished them.
The second, “at the other extreme,” was to withdraw unilaterally from most of the land taken in 1967. The third option, he said, the one actually followed by all Israeli Governments since 1967, was to occupy the territories militarily and leave their legal and political status open until Jordan and appropriate Palestinians were ready to negotiate.
As Anwar Sadat’s example had shown, only through negotiations could the Arabs get territory back from Israel. But the reality is not of a status quo carefully preserved until negotiations. Large numbers of Israelis have settled in the occupied territories, creating what the settlers call “facts on the ground.”
Israel has taken a significant portion of the land for its own use. To the Palestinian inhabitants those are deeply disturbing developments — ones that dampen their hope of ever running their own lives. Gaza, for example, is one of the most densely populated places on earth: 650,000 Palestinians, most of them living in squalid refugee camps, on 140 sandy square miles.
Yet 2,500 Jewish settlers occupy a large slice of the available land. What could be more provocative?
Strife continues in 12th day of Palestinian protests
Egypt: Israelis killing innocents
The Associated Press, Cairo and Jerusalem
“CAIRO, Egypt (AP) — Egypt accused Israeli troops yesterday of indiscriminately shooting innocent Palestinians in the occupied territories and said their actions threatened prospects for peace in the Middle East… ‘President Hosni Mubarak and the Egyptian people have followed the bloody events taking place in the occupied Arab territories of Gaza and the West Bank with deep concern and strong resentment,’ said the statement, read by Information Minister Safwat el Sherif.
‘This is because Israel is using methods of repression and persecution, showing no regard for the lives of innocent people — old men, women and children — and violating its international obligations in a grievous manner that threatens the Middle East peace process.’”
“Palestinian youths gather behind a makeshift roadblock yesterday in an East Jerusalem neighborhood after throwing rocks.” And: “Palestinian protests in the Gaza Strip spread north to East Jerusalem yesterday. Four policemen were hurt.” Associated Press.
The charge is printed, and the first word tells the reader who is making it. Attribution is what lets a paper print a sentence like this one: Israelis killing innocents arrives as Egypt’s position rather than the paper’s. Thirteen days into the first intifada.
JABALIA, Occupied Gaza Strip (AP) — This crowded refugee camp, the largest and most densely populated in the Gaza Strip, has become a center of resistance in the last two weeks of anti-Israeli rioting and bloodshed. Residents say they have nothing to lose by throwing stones at Israeli soldiers armed with submachine guns. Many here have lived in squalor for decades.
“When my sons go outside to demonstrate, I’m afraid for them, but I’m not going to stop them,” said Neama Khalil Abu Sisi, 55, whose son, Hatem, 17, was killed in a clash with soldiers the previous week.
Yesterday, about 30 camp youths confronted a dozen soldiers, throwing stones from behind barricades of burning tires and defiantly raising the outlawed Palestinian flag. In what appeared to be a well-rehearsed game, the soldiers advanced slowly, firing shots in the air. The protesters retreated into narrow side alleys.
Minutes later, a group of soldiers dragged a Palestinian teen-ager into an army base inside the camp. The boy’s mother followed a few yards behind, shouting at the soldiers… Jabalia is the most densely populated of the eight refugee camps in the Gaza Strip, and it is the only one to have an Israeli army base within its boundaries. The camp was set up in 1948.
The stone huts built then as temporary shelters have long since turned into permanent housing… About 60,000 members of the Gaza Strip’s 100,000-strong labor force work in Israel. Jabalia has been the site of daily violent clashes since Dec. 8 when an Israeli truck slammed into two vans carrying Palestinian workers.
Two camp residents were killed… The camp doctor said the army will not be able to quell the protests with force. “They (the camp residents) demonstrate because they have nothing to lose,” he said.
The same Associated Press copy as the Press & Sun-Bulletin the same week, under a different headline. The archive had held about a third of it.
Gaza refugee camp now center of resistance to Israel
Associated Press, Jabalia
JABALIA, Occupied Gaza Strip (AP) — This crowded refugee camp, the largest and most densely populated in the Gaza Strip, has become a center of resistance in the last two weeks of anti-Israeli rioting and bloodshed. Residents say they have nothing to lose by throwing stones at Israeli soldiers armed with submachine guns. Many here have lived in squalor for decades.
“When my sons go outside to demonstrate, I’m afraid for them, but I’m not going to stop them,” said Neama Khalil Abu Sisi, 55, whose son, Hatem, 17, was killed in a clash with soldiers the previous week… “Camp residents compose the bulk of the resistance (to the Israeli occupation), and the Jabalia camp is more militant than any other place,” said Faez Abu Rahme, a prominent Palestinian lawyer.
There are two main reasons for the rising tensions in Jabalia, which lies two miles north of Gaza City and is home to 55,000 refugees. Jabalia is the most densely populated of the eight refugee camps in the Gaza Strip, and it is the only one to have an Israeli army base within its boundaries. The camp was set up in 1948.
The stone huts built then as temporary shelters have long since turned into permanent housing… A camp doctor, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said residents haul drinking water from three wells contaminated by sewage, and that there was an epidemic of parasitic diseases, including intestinal worms. Four doctors see 400 to 500 patients each day, he said.
In the home of Mohammed Yousef Abu Sisi, father of the youth newly dead in violence, 13 people share four rooms. Mrs. Abu Sisi and her two daughters-in-law must wait their turn to cook for their families on a single-flame stove.
Thirteen days into the first intifada, and the Associated Press sent somebody to the camp and printed what they found: three wells contaminated by sewage, four doctors seeing four to five hundred patients a day, thirteen people in four rooms, one stove. The dateline says Occupied Gaza Strip, which most American papers were not setting at the time. Four Palestinians are named in it — a mother, her dead son, a lawyer and a father — and the mother is the first voice in the story. Three American papers ran this dispatch on 20 December 1987 under three headlines. This one calls the camp a center of resistance to Israel; the Press & Sun-Bulletin called it defiance running high (CP-1987-006); the Staten Island Advance took the residents’ own words, ‘Nothing to lose’ in camps (CP-1987-011). The copy underneath is the same in all three, and what it reports is that the water was bad.
“Defiance running high at refugee camp. Battles with Israelis a fact of life at Jabalia.” The same Associated Press dispatch. It names Faez Abu Rahme, “a prominent Palestinian lawyer”: “Camp residents compose the bulk of the resistance to the Israeli occupation, and the Jabalia camp is more militant than any other place.”
A camp doctor, speaking anonymously, “said residents haul drinking water from three wells contaminated by sewage, and that there was an epidemic of parasitic diseases, including intestinal worms. Four doctors see 400 to 500 patients each day.” It also visits the home of Mohammed Yousef Abu Sisi, father of the youth newly dead.
The same dispatch as the Courier Post. One headline says the camp breeds foes; this one says defiance.
JERUSALEM — The violence wracking Israel’s occupied territories spread to Arab east Jerusalem yesterday, when mobs of Palestinian youths trashed Israeli buildings, stoned police cars and burned tires.
Thirty-three Palestinians were arrested and four Israeli policemen were slightly injured, police said, in what was called the worst violence in Israeli-annexed east Jerusalem in more than a decade. It was the 12th straight day of upheaval in land seized by Israel in the 1967 Middle East war. Military officials say 15 Arabs have been killed.
Palestinian reports put the toll at 20… The Arab sector of the city, captured from Jordan along with the West Bank, is home to about 130,000 Palestinians… In the worst incident, about 40 youths smashed the glass storefront of Barclay’s Israel Discount Bank with rocks, tore apart the bank’s neon sign, then charged inside, smashing partitions and destroying equipment, witnesses said.
The Associated Press dispatch from Jabalia ran in the next column of the same page, under Karin Laub’s byline; it is in this archive as CP-1987-011. This record is the Jerusalem story only, and the page credits it to the Associated Press and to nobody by name.
“…more were arrested or interrogated. According to Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir, it was the PLO that moved the Palestinian masses to the streets to protest against the Israeli occupation.
By this claim, Shamir tries to discredit the PLO, by attributing this wave of protest to it and putting on its shoulder the responsibility for the deaths of Palestinians who are shot by the IDF.
This while Shamir and his colleagues in the Israeli political leadership continue to declare that the PLO does not represent the Palestinian people, and that they refuse to talk to it or accept it as a partner in any peace talks.
In fact, if the PLO was able to move the Palestinian masses to the streets to protest against the Israeli occupation, then it should be recognized as an effective leadership that has its roots deep within its own people. However, the issue is much deeper than this.
During the last 20 years of Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, the Israelis used all possible methods to liquidate the Palestinian national movement. More than 300,000 Palestinians have been in and out of Israeli jails, experiencing ill-treatment including humiliation and physical and psychological torture. More than half of the Arab lands have been confiscated.
Thousands of houses have been demolished and thousands of Palestinians have been deported. The military administration of the occupied territories, now called the Civil Administration, is staffed by right-wing, nationalist fanatics, most of whom identify ideologically with…”
“An Israeli soldier kicks a Palestinian youth, who holds his head where he was just hit by a truncheon-wielding soldier.” Associated Press
A jump page headed PALESTINIAN / from 1C, so the piece is written by a Palestinian and began on the front of the section. It answers Shamir’s claim with his own contradiction: that the PLO both moved the masses and does not represent them.
JABALIA, Occupied Gaza Strip — This crowded refugee camp, the largest and most densely populated in the Gaza Strip, has become a center of resistance in the last two weeks of anti-Israeli rioting and bloodshed. Residents say they have nothing to lose by throwing stones at Israeli soldiers armed with submachine guns. Many here have lived in squalor for decades.
“When my sons go outside to demonstrate, I’m afraid for them, but I’m not going to stop them,” said Neama Khalil Abu Sisi, 55, whose son, Hatem, 17, was killed in a clash with soldiers the previous week… The camp was set up in 1948. The stone huts built then as temporary shelters have long since turned into permanent housing.
A stagnant, reeking pool surrounded by rusted car wrecks lies at the camp’s center… A camp doctor, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said residents haul drinking water from three wells contaminated by sewage, and that there was an epidemic of parasitic diseases, including intestinal worms. Four doctors see 400 to 500 patients each day, he said.
In the home of Mohammed Yousef Abu Sisi, father of the youth newly dead in violence, 13 people share four rooms. Mrs. Abu Sisi and her two daughters-in-law must wait their turn to cook for their families on a single-flame stove… There is little employment in the Gaza Strip. Most men rise before dawn to travel to Israel to dig ditches, lay bricks or prune trees.
About 60,000 members of the Gaza Strip’s 100,000-strong labor force work in Israel. Abu Sisi, 55, works as a stone cutter in the Israeli coastal city of Ashkelon, earning $19 a day.
His son, Ghazi, 31, who holds a degree in accounting from Cairo University, is a day laborer in Tel Aviv… The camp doctor said the army will not be able to quell the protests with force. “They (the camp residents) demonstrate because they have nothing to lose,” he said.
A youth throws a stone at Israeli troops at the entrance to the refugee camp. Associated Press.
The Associated Press ran this from Jabalia on 20 December 1987 and it is in the archive twice: here, and in the Courier Post the same day under a different headline. It counts the camp’s water, its doctors and its wages, and it names the household it stands in.
Jabalia refugee camp a center of resistance to the Israelis
Karin Laub, Associated Press, Jabalia, Occupied Gaza Strip
“‘When my sons go outside to demonstrate, I’m afraid for them, but I’m not going to stop them,’ said Neama Khalil Abu Sisi, 55, whose son, Hatem, 17, was killed in a clash with soldiers the previous week… In the home of Mohammed Yousef Abu Sisi… 13 people share four rooms… Abu Sisi, 55, works as a stone cutter in the Israeli coastal city of Ashkelon, earning $19 a day.
His son, Ghazi, 31, who holds a degree in accounting from Cairo University, is a day laborer in Tel Aviv.”
The fullest portrait of a single Palestinian family in this collection: a mother, a father with his trade and his wage, a dead seventeen-year-old, and a thirty-one-year-old accountant carrying bricks. The camp is given as 55,000 people with four doctors seeing 400 to 500 patients a day.
BUREIJ, Israeli-Occupied Gaza Strip, Dec. 19 — The “shebab,” hot-eyed, desperate, angry young men, were gathered outside the tiny cinder-block dwelling — it would be hard to call it a house — mourning Abdul Salam Fteihah, who had been shot dead by the Israeli Army.
Shebab in formal Arabic means “youths,” but in the language of the street, it translates roughly as “the guys.” The word is on everybody’s lips in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank today.
It is the Palestinian youngsters, the shebab, who have grown up under 20 years of Israeli occupation and who are lashing out in violent demonstrations that have so far left at least 16 of their number dead. The hostility between the Palestinian youths and the Israelis is partly an outgrowth of the dilemma that control over the Gaza Strip poses for Israel.
Neither Egypt nor Jordan claims the territory, and Israel fears that if it were to relinquish control, Gaza could become a base for the Palestine Liberation Organization, which could use it to jeopardize Israeli security. The incident that touched off the current protests was a traffic accident early this month in which four Gaza workers died.
Rumors spread that the collision of the Arab vehicle with a truck driven by an Israeli was a reprisal for the stabbing to death of an Israeli in a Gaza market the week before. But in recent days, the riots, which were born of frustration, powerlessness and rage, have appeared increasingly organized.
They have included efforts to block Arab workers from assuming their vital role in the Israeli economy and attacks on Israeli-owned banks in Arab East Jerusalem by rock-throwing demonstrators.
Israeli soldiers ordering demonstrators to clear burning tires from a street in Gaza.
A year ago I traveled through Gaza. I thought then and believe still with all the emotion Israel arouses that all who love her should journey in Gaza. There are places on earth where aridity and bleakness are more stark, where oppression is far worse, where anger is as hot in the eyes of the young men who stand by the roadside and stare.
But for those who care for Israel, that is evasion. They know that this should not be, that Israeli soldiers should not patrol year after year in alleys of hatred. That was not what Israel was meant to be or do or stand for. Yes, there is a double standard for Israel.
She is judged by higher standards than, say, those Arab neighbors who preach death and hate and slaughter in the name of God. The double standard is not only a matter of pride and duty to Israel’s biblical roots but of strength in the world today.
It is the belief that Israel lives by principles of decency that won her essential support in the United States, decade after troubled decade. And now, newspapers and television screens are aflame with the bitterness of the young men of Gaza, that strip of territory Israel does not want but cannot let go for fear it would become a P.L.O. state.
Twenty years of Israeli occupation have only heightened hatred in Gaza, as would another 20. This is all true. But if there is to be any honest effort toward an end to the misery of Gaza and the tragedy of Israel as occupier, other truths must be faced. So far almost nothing has been said about them. The haters of Israel simply use Gaza as a club against her.
Her supporters abroad do little but shake their heads in reprimand or embarrassment.
A GENERAL STRIKE BY ISRAEL’S ARABS DISRUPTS COUNTRY
Protest Spills Out of West Bank and Gaza — Three More Palestinians Killed
By JOHN KIFNER
JERUSALEM, Dec. 21 — Hundreds of thousands of Arabs inside Israel joined others in the occupied territories today in a general strike protesting Israel’s handling of a wave of protests. At least three Palestinian protesters who reportedly threw firebombs were shot and killed by Israeli soldiers on the West Bank.
Another Palestinian died of his wounds in a Gaza hospital today, raising the confirmed death toll to at least 20 in 13 days of clashes in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.
A senior commander said tonight that the Israeli Army would send more troops into the West Bank on Tuesday, prepared to take “tougher measures” because the “restraint shown in the last two weeks has apparently been interpreted as weakness.”
Arab Laborers Stay Home Arab towns and villages in northern Galilee and other parts of pre-1967 Israel were closed down, every shop shuttered, as were those in the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem. More important, the great numbers of Arab laborers who wait on tables, pick vegetables, haul garbage, lay brick and perform most of Israel’s menial work stayed home.
More than 100,000 workers from the occupied territories go into Israel each day, in addition to the Arabs living there, filling a vital role in the Israeli economy. The protests in the West Bank of the Jordan River and the Gaza Strip, both under Israeli occupation since the 1967 war, reflect the growing frustrations of the long occupation.
Traffic Accident Rumors But the immediate cause was a traffic accident this month in which four Gaza workers died. Rumors spread that the collision of an Arab vehicle with a truck driven by an Israeli was a reprisal for the fatal stabbing of an Israeli in a Gaza market the week before.
Today, as the unrest spread from the occupied territories to Israel itself, it appeared to unite Arabs who are citizens of Israel with those who consider themselves stateless Palestinians.
“This is unprecedented in that it’s the first time the Israeli Arabs are following the Arabs in the territories,” said Yehuda Litani, an Arab-affairs specialist at The Jerusalem Post. “We’ve had clashes today in places where there have never been — Jaffa, Abu Ghosh. These places are very quiet.
Palestinian demonstrators jeering at an Israeli soldier, armed with a tear gas rifle, as they staged a march yesterday in the Gaza Strip.
Date check: No masthead survives, but the locator map at the foot of the page is credited “The New York Times/Dec. 22, 1987” — which confirms both `date` (1987-12-22) and `pub`. The byline block also carries “Special to The New York Times”, and the dateline reads “JERUSALEM, Dec. 21”, the day before.
JERUSALEM — Israeli security forces reportedly arrested hundreds more Arab youths on the West Bank and in Gaza yesterday as Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin warned that further unrest in the occupied territories would bring the Palestinians “suffering and pain.”
The security crackdown came after a wave of violence that left at least 21 Palestinians dead in the past two weeks. There have been no deaths reported in three days. But a new controversy brewed over the prospect that a large number of Palestinians may be “deported” to exile in Jordan or southern Lebanon.
The Yediot Ahronot, Israel’s largest daily newspaper, said that the army was preparing to deport “hundreds” of Palestinians believed to have instigated the recent disturbances.
Mass deportations of Palestinians would be a significant departure from past Israeli practice, in which deportations were limited to a handful representing the hard-core nationalist leadership. Such a move would almost certainly revive debate within Israel about “transferring” the Palestinian problem to Jordan.
In an interview with The Jerusalem Post, Rabin said that deportation of some Palestinians was a legal option “and there is no question that this is a means that we could use.”
ISRAEL ARMY READY TO START TRIALS FOR PALESTINIANS
John Kifner
“The Israeli army is preparing to begin military trials for nearly a thousand Palestinians rounded up after two weeks of disturbances in the occupied territories.”
Three weeks into the first intifada. Four American papers in this archive printed this dispatch on the same Sunday, and each wrote its own headline over it.
“The new proceedings will be the first major round of trials of Palestinians since an Israeli government investigation last October found that, for 16 years, agents of the internal security agency, Shin Beth, had regularly tortured suspected Palestinian suspects into confessing to crimes.
The investigation, by the Landau Commission, also found that Shin Beth agents had perjured themselves in court about the practice. The Shin Beth’s actions enabled the security service to win convictions in many cases without having to assemble evidence before a court.
Ninety percent of the cases involving Palestinians from the occupied territories never involved actual trials. ‘The service didn’t understand that the all-important mission entrusted to it may justify means, but not all means, and certainly not the means of giving false testimony,’ the commission’s report said.
But because of the importance of the Shin Beth’s ‘holy battle’ against terrorism, the report said, the use of ‘mild physical pressure should not be avoided’ when psychological means failed, but security agents should not lie about it in court. THE REPORT did not explain what would constitute ‘mild physical pressure.’
‘What we have known for a long time was confirmed by the Landau Commission,’ Kuttab, the Palestinian lawyer, said. ‘In the vast majority of military court trials, the primary, if not sole evidence, is a confession.
The confessions, he said,’ are ‘usually obtained during the intitial period of imprisonment and interrogation, during the first 18 days when the defendent doesn’t have access to a lawyer or the Red Cross.’ It is not yet known whether this is true of the current detentions.
Kuttab said that it appeared that the Landau Commission’s findings might make defense attorneys’ task even more difficult. In the past, he said, lawyers were able to challenge the confessions as coerced. Now that ‘mild physical pressure’ has been legitimized, he said, the criteria will be whether the judge believes in the truthfulness of the confession.
‘Nobody knows what it means,’ he said. ‘It’s a secret guideline.’ THESE TACTICS, partly rooted in the days of the British mandate, involve proceedings in which the evidence may be declared secret. ‘It is a terrible wall of secrecy,’ said Langer, the lawyer.
‘You are helpless as a lawyer, you don’t know what you are defending against.’”
The fullest of the four printings, and the only one in the archive that carries the Landau Commission by name. It records two things no other clipping here does: that the commission found Shin Bet agents had perjured themselves, and that its findings legitimized what the paper calls mild physical pressure. The lawyer quoted is Felicia Langer. Printed beside an after-Christmas advertisement offering sixty per cent off sterling silver.
“The Israeli peace demonstrators had been given police permission to hold a rally… When they turned a street corner near the residence, police fired tear gas and the crowd quickly dispersed.”
A Washington Post dispatch run on the same day as the military trials story, under a headline about guerrillas. Buried in it is the detail that Israeli peace demonstrators with a permit were tear-gassed, which the paper calls the first major Israeli protest against government policy.
JERUSALEM — U.S. officials were described Saturday as engaged in “intense” contacts with the Israeli government, hoping to head off the threatened deportation of a large number of Palestinians in the wake of recent unrest in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip.
The contacts are under way “at all kinds of levels,” according to an informed Western source who requested anonymity. They follow the arrests of more than 800 Palestinians in recent days for alleged involvement in what have been described as the most widespread anti-Israeli disturbances in the occupied territories in 20 years.
While dismissing an Israeli press report that the army is preparing to expel “hundreds” of Arabs, a senior Israeli official who spoke on condition of anonymity confirmed that there is a proposal before the minister of defense to deport as many as 20 Palestinians deemed to be instigators of the unrest.
The Palestinians, who were between ages 20 and 25, were on a terrorist mission, according to the Army. They wore military fatigues under civilian clothing and were armed with Kalashnikov assault rifles, hand grenades and metal spikes that they apparently planned to use to halt and ambush Israeli vehicles.
Bet Shean is on the main highway leading from Jerusalem to the Sea of Tiberias and the Upper Galilee. Their entry was detected by an Army patrol that, guided by an Arab Bedouin tracker, followed the infiltrators’ footprints. Meanwhile Bet Shean and agricultural settlements in the area were put on alert.
The soldiers came upon the Palestinians hiding in a wheat field about 400 yards from the border and opened fire. One of the Palestinians was wounded before he and his companions surrendered. The military commander of the West Bank and central Israel, Maj. Gen.
Amram Mitzna, told Israel radio, “The most important thing that I can learn from this incident is that our system that was not challenged for the last 10 years here in this area acted like it should and each of the soldiers, each of the parts of this system, did what they had to do (in) this very quiet part of the border in Israel.”
Mitzna added that, following two weeks of Palestinian unrest, “Maybe some people thought that Israel is weak, Israel cannot defend itself, and I hope that they learned the lesson... . They tried something very big and it failed.”
“When they arrested all these people last week, they said they were just arresting the ‘organizers.’ One thousand organizers? In 10 years they will just have to put a wall up around the whole West Bank and Gaza Strip to arrest all of the organizers.” — Ibrahim Karaeen, a Palestinian in East Jerusalem. [A14:6.]
NABLUS, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, Dec. 27 — Palestinian schools in the West Bank, closed by the army as a security measure a week ago, reopened today as combat-equipped soldiers patrolled the main streets and entrances to refugee centers.
Military trials for the more than a thousand Palestinians arrested during two weeks of rioting began today behind the barbed-wire fence encircling the military headquarters in this Arab West Bank town. More than 40 of the 50 prisoners processed here today had their cases put over for later hearings, some because they had asked for lawyers.
Trials are to be held Monday in the West Bank towns of Nablus, Ramallah, Hebron and Tul-Karem. Many of those arrested have been seized in the last few days in raids, sometimes at night, through refugee centers and Palestinian villages by soldiers seeking to end the disorders, in which at least 21 protesters have been killed by the army.
Total Put at 600 The army Central Command, which controls the West Bank, said today that about 600 prisoners arrested since the disturbances began on Dec. 9 were being held in four locations. The Southern Command, which is in charge of the Gaza Strip, has not issued any figures.
However, Palestinian lawyers in Gaza said today that the Ansar II detention camp used in that area has four barracks capable of holding about 50 prisoners each and that seven large tents each capable of holding from 35 to 40 prisoners have also been set up. Other detainees are also being held at a police station, the lawyers said.
Two handcuffed Palestinians being escorted by an Israeli soldier out of a military court in Nablus, in the occupied West Bank, after trials yesterday of suspected participants in recent riots.
JERUSALEM, Dec. 28 — Tucked away at the end of a narrow winding staircase atop a candy store in a back alley of East Jerusalem is probably the best source of information on the Palestinian rioting of the last few weeks.
Time and again Palestine Press Services, a tiny news agency owned and operated by Palestinians, broke the stories about shootings or flare-ups of rioting all over the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. Western and Israeli news reporters both relied on their bulletins to keep abreast of the fast-breaking story. In many ways the agency was founded for just such a news event.
Started in 1977 by Raymonda Tawil, a Palestinian journalist, and joined soon thereafter by another Palestinian writer, Ibrahim Karaeen, it was meant to be the outlet both to Israel and the world for the Palestinians living in the Israeli-occupied territories. Mrs. Tawil and Mr. Karaeen are now co-owners.
First Tips With a staff of 10 permanent editors, reporters and telex operators, and an unrivaled network of stringers in villages, towns and refugee camps across the occupied territories, the agency usually provides foreign and Israeli reporters with the first tip when something is beginning to happen. During the recent rioting, its reports proved to be generally reliable.
Most major Western news agencies and embassies subscribe to its daily telex service, which includes a morning bulletin with translations of leading stories and editorials from the Arabic press in East Jerusalem and an afternoon bulletin rounding up the day’s arrests, clashes or political developments in the occupied territories.
A Palestinian prisoner in his cell as he awaited trial.
Parents of Palestinian youths arrested during unrest in the West Bank waiting outside the courthouse in Nablus during military trials
Agence Frarce-Presse Parents of Palestinian youths arrested during unrest in the West Bank waiting outside courthouse in Nablus during military trials yesterday.
Parents of Palestinian youths arrested during unrest in the West Bank waiting outside the courthouse in Nablus during military trials
Pope Names an Arab Priest To Be Patriarch in Jerusalem
JERUSALEM, Dec. 29 — Pope John Paul II has appointed an Arab priest who was born in Nazareth to be Patriarch of Jerusalem for Latin Rite Catholics. The priest, Michel Asaad Sabbah, president of Bethlehem University, is the first Palestinian to be appointed to the post since the patriarchate was established over 800 years ago.
Father Sabbah, 54 years old, will replace Giacomo Giuseppe Beltritti, a 77-year-old Italian, who is retiring. The appointment was announced at the Vatican Monday. “This is the first apointment of a Palestinian patriarch in 1,000 years,” said Elias Freij, the Mayor of Bethlehem. “It is very, very significant.
Father Sabbah is to be made patriarch of Jerusalem on Jan. 6, in Rome. Although the Pope last week called for peace in the occupied territories, a Vatican spokesman said the appointment was not related to the recent Palestinian unrest there. Most of the Latin Patriarchate’s 65,000 followers in the Jerusalem diocese are of Arab origin, as are most of its priests.
Israel says Palestinian deportations possible despite U.S. opposition
JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli leaders said they plan to deport Palestinians accused of leading recent riots in the occupied lands, even though Washington has warned such punishments could cause more violent protests. However, one Israeli official said there would be no mass deportations and that each defendant’s case would be considered individually.
In another development, two people were slightly injured when they opened one of eight letter bombs mailed to addresses in Israel and a Jewish settlement in the occupied West Bank, police said today. The other letter bombs were defused without causing injuries, police said. The bombs were discovered today and Tuesday, police said.
They were hidden in white envelopes containing Christmas cards, and the typewritten return address on all of them was listed as D. Nissim, Istanbul, Turkey, police said in a statement.
An Arab family member of one of the Palestinian prisoners appearing before military court in Israel is denied permission to observe the proceedings on Tuesday.
BERKELEY — In an unusual rally downtown yesterday, more than 100 Jews gathered at dusk to protest Israel’s persecution of Palestinians living in the occupied Gaza Strip and West Bank.
It was unorthodox for Jews to speak against the government of their “Promised Land” and was an unlikely sight to a group of young Palestinian immigrants, who happened to see the rally and stood on its fringes to listen.
“We are outraged upon hearing the reports of continued repression by the Israeli authorities of Palestinian demonstrations against the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip,” David Cooper told 125 people carrying signs and lighted candles outside the BART station.
At least 22 Palestinians have died and many more have been wounded, jailed or face deportation for protesting, he said. “We believe that sooner or later Israeli Jews must live in an Israel sitting beside a self-governed Palestinian state. . . . The longer this situation is deferred, the more violence will occur against Jew and Arab alike.”
George Atallah, a 25-year-old Palestinian who grew up in Old Jerusalem, said he left Palestine to study in the United States and later decided to stay. “There wasn’t a future there. If I went back, I knew I couldn’t get a job,” he said. Atallah said he was pleased with the rally.
“I’m glad to see there are some Jewish people who understand what it is like for the Palestinians living in the occupied lands. The Palestinians lost their dignity, they lost their freedom, they lost everything they have. And they will keep fighting until they win it back again.” Speaker after speaker implored American Jews to speak out.
“Many Jews feel they have to keep their discontentment with Israel within the family,” said Larry Harris of the International Jewish Peace Union. “We as Jews have a responsibility for what our Jewish brothers in Israel do.” Sam Saliba, 25, a Palestinian who now lives in Concord, said he was surprised by the Jewish protest.
“I didn’t know there were Jews who knew how Palestinians felt.”… Protester Judi Hirsch said Israel does not need the occupied lands for “security” against Arab invasion, it needs peace.
“It is destructive for people who were oppressed to become the oppressors,” Hirsch said… Most of Atallah’s and Saliba’s families remain in Israel. “It is their country. They will not leave,” Saliba said. Atallah added that if a Palestinian state was formed, he would return. “It is my home, still.”
“Mary Merrill sits in silent protest while others circle the area near Berkeley BART station.” By Angela Pancrazio / The Tribune
Two young Palestinians standing at the edge of a Jewish rally in California, both named, both quoted, on the last day of 1987.
JERUSALEM — Eetta Prince-Gibson, a psychiatric social worker who emigrated to Israel from New Jersey 15 years ago, opposes violence as a solution to problems. But on Saturday night as she marched through the streets of Jerusalem chanting slogans in a peace demonstration it was clear that three weeks of violent civil demonstrations had hardened her moderate views.
While she wants peace with Arabs, she feels Israel must be tough until a peace settlement is concluded. If that means using live bullets to stop demonstrators hurling stones and firebombs, so be it. “We’re in favor of using other methods but when somebody is throwing rocks at you, you’ve got to protect yourself. Rocks kill, too,” she said.
“We’re fighting for the character of our state. But on the other hand, we believe there is a threat to our existence.” The change in her views is being echoed on both sides following the weeks of violent clashes between young Arab demonstrators and young Jewish soldiers.
In more than a score of interviews last week in Israel and the territories it seized after the 1967 Six-Day War, Arabs and Jews say that the political center has been damaged. Israel’s move toward the right has been accelerated. And Arab moderates, who had been experimenting with tentative talks with Israelis, have been drawn toward activists in their communities.
The Israelis’ fear that their country and their children are under attack has drowned out a debate that had been boiling in the country about what is to be done about the territories and their exploding Arab populations. Demographers predict that if Israel holds on to the territories, its total Jewish and Arab populations will be equal in size by the year 2000.
Some on the left argue that the territories should be returned to the Arabs. The extreme right argues for the Arabs’ expulsion.
Palestinian children add tire to burning barricade in Gaza.
Former Israeli Defense Minister Ezer Weizman: 'No government in its right mind could possibly want the place. I'd give it back tomorrow if someone would take it.' Dr. Haidar Abed el Shafi, head of the Gaza Red Crescent Society: 'It is an occupation with a definite political program.
The Israeli government considers the occupied territories as part of Israeli territory and looks on the local population as foreigners.'
Five words in a Maryland county paper. Somebody fires, the people fired on are protesters, and nothing softens either half. Compare the Star-Ledger in 1982, which put the same act in Arab unrest (CP-1982-002).
On the same page: “Israeli soldier wounds Palestine attacker in West Bank, army says”
Associated Press, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM (AP) — An Israeli soldier shot and wounded a Palestinian in the West Bank city of Tulkarem today after the man attacked an army vehicle and stabbed a female soldier, the army said. The Palestinian suffered moderate wounds, and the female soldier was slightly injured, said an army official. Israel radio said the female soldier was stabbed in the hand.
Scattered demonstrations were reported throughout the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, a day after Israeli soldiers shot and killed a 25-year-old Palestinian and wounded seven others in the Gaza town of Khan Yunis.
The Arab-run Palestine Press Service said a 20-year-old resident of the Nur Shams refugee camp near Tulkarem was shot in the head today by a soldier after the army dispersed stone-throwing demonstrators in the camp. It was not immediately clear whether the report referred to the same incident reported by the army… At least 24 Palestinians have been killed since Dec.
8, when the worst disturbances in Israel’s 20-year occupation of the Gaza Strip and West Bank broke out. Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin vowed Tuesday that Israel would toughen measures to end the unrest in the territories, which Israel captured from Egypt and Jordan in the 1967 Middle East war.
The army detained more than 1,000 Palestinians accused of organizing protests, ordered nine of them deported, set up military courts to try the detainees and poured thousands of troops into the territories. In New York, The U.N. Security Council voted Tuesday evening to approve a resolution calling on Israel to refrain from deporting Palestinians.
Israel said it would ignore the vote, which was approved by the United States. Israel’s crackdown did not cool tempers in Khan Yunis, a small town of dilapidated houses, bad roads and open sewers. Arab merchants on Tuesday kept their stores shut.
Bands of young boys, most between the ages of five and 14, patrolled intersections and stopped cars to check the identity of passengers… Tuesday’s trouble began around noon when a group of women began a protest march from the home of Hassan Abu Shakra, one of nine Palestinians ordered expelled, the army spokesman said.
Hundreds of Khan Yunis residents joined the women, while mosques played music over loudspeakers to encourage marchers, the spokesman said. The crowd threw stones at a group of soldiers, striking one soldier in the face. An officer hurled tear gas grenades and fired shots in the air to disperse the crowd.
When those methods failed, the spokesman said, the officer shot live ammunition at the legs of demonstrators, wounding three. At the refugee camp, soldiers tried to stop stone-throwing protesters with tear gas, a water cannon and warning shots. When that failed, an officer used live ammunition. One Arab was killed and four others were wounded.
The spokesman stressed that the soldiers fired after other measures failed to disperse the demonstrators. Maj. Gen. Yitzhak Mordechai, in charge of troops in Gaza, visited the scene and concluded in an initial investigation that the soldiers acted properly in both cases, he said.
Israel condemns U.N. vote on deportations. UNITED NATIONS (AP) — Israel condemned the Security Council for challenging its plan to deport Palestinian activists and said it would ignore the resolution, even though it was approved by its chief ally, the United States.
“Frankly, we were disappointed with the American vote,” Israeli Ambassador Benjamin Netanyahu said after the resolution was adopted Tuesday evening. “We think this was a day of hypocrisy in the United Nations.” Netanyahu said the resolution will encourage “the forces behind the violence” in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip.
He accused the council of playing a “rigged game,” adding: “We’ve never had a Security Council convene to condemn the murder of a Jew. Not once.” But he also praised the United States for seeing that the resolution requested rather than demanded that Israel refrain from deporting Arabs.
The United States, one of Israel’s closest allies and its staunchest defender at the United Nations, joined the other 14 council members in endorsing the resolution against the deportations in the occupied lands.
The U.S. mission said it was the first U.S. vote against Israel in the council in six years… “The United States believes that such harsh measures are unnecessary to maintain order,” U.S. Ambassador Herbert Okun said of the deportation order. “They serve to aggravate tension rather than create an atmosphere conducive to reconciliation,” he added.
“Ambassador Netanyahu”
A protest begun by women marching from the house of a man ordered expelled, and the army’s account of why live ammunition was fired at demonstrators’ legs. Beside it, the first American vote against Israel in the Security Council in six years.
January 1988, three weeks into the first intifada. The paper holds Iron Fist at arm’s length in quotation marks, and then sets its own verb outside them: the policy enslaves. And the last three words settle the question the rest of this archive spends a century circling — in their land. By June a Detroit paper was printing the same phrase with no marks at all (CP-1988-020).
“…authorities seem to be encountering is that many Palestinian youths are not afraid of any Israeli threats. Arab residents of the occupied territories are not permitted to possess firearms.
The military high command confirmed that one Palestinian had been shot and killed and seven others wounded when Israeli soldiers shot at protesters throwing stones at an Israeli patrol in the Gaza Strip town of Khan Younis. U.N. officials in Gaza City said at least 12 people had been wounded in the incident.
The Palestine Press Service, an East Jerusalem news agency that closely monitors events in the occupied territories, placed the number of those killed in the Khan Younis disturbance at two.
Military officials said they feared that the Khan Younis demonstration, in which scores of Palestinian youths hurled stones at a small Israeli squad patrolling the town, signaled the start of a second wave of violence after the deployment of about 12,000 additional troops, the arrests of 1,200 protesters and deportation orders against nine alleged inciters.
The United States has warned that the expulsions violate international law and would incite further protests in the territories. [In Cairo, Egypt, riot police used batons and tear gas to disperse hundreds of Egyptian students demonstrating Tuesday against Israel’s crackdown on Palestinians, The Associated Press reported.] The Arab mood in the territories appeared to turn from exhaustion to rage Sunday when an Israeli soldier, hit by a stone during a protest in the West Bank village of El Ram, five miles north of Jerusalem, chased a 14-year-old boy into a house and started shooting, killing a 25-year-old woman as she hung laundry in her courtyard.
The killing triggered protests throughout the West Bank and Gaza Monday that troops quelled with rubber bullets and tear gas… Under a curfew order, military authorities forbade the 11,000 residents of the Tulkarem refugee camp from leaving their houses Tuesday until further notice.
Throughout the occupied territories, where a partial commercial strike has been in effect for more than two weeks, Israeli soldiers forced merchants to open their shops by threatening to weld their shutters closed if they refused… ‘One morning, a person wakes up and discovers that he is out of punishments,’ wrote the respected Haaretz newspaper columnist Yoel Marcus.
‘This could happen in any household when a parent discovers that his severe punishments have stopped working and his children are no longer afraid. This is a moment of terrible crisis for the parent, when he discovers he has lost his authority. This is more or less the situation of the state in terms of its relationship with the territories.
For the young Palestinians there, being sent to jail carries the same prestige as an Israeli being sent to an elite army unit.’ Palestinian analysts said the defiance of Arab youth in the territories also had stripped the older generation of Palestinians of their authority, with sons rejecting the more moderate views of their fathers.
On Tuesday, a group of prominent East Jerusalem Palestinians said they would call on the 1.4 million residents of the territories to begin a non-violent campaign of civil disobedience against the Israeli occupation.
The campaign will include refusal to pay taxes to Israeli occupation authorities, a boycott of Israeli products and the wearing of black as a sign of mourning for those killed in the rioting, said Hanna Siniora, the editor of the East Jerusalem daily Al Fajr.”
Three different counts of the dead at Khan Younis in one column — the military high command’s, the U.N.’s, and the Palestine Press Service’s. A 25-year-old woman is killed hanging laundry and is not named. The story is a jump from page 1A.
JERUSALEM — Israeli troops fired on Arab protesters during clashes at two refugee camps in the occupied Gaza Strip, killing a 15-year-old Palestinian and wounding seven other Arab demonstrators, a U.N. official said. Eight other people, including an Israeli soldier, were reported injured Thursday in other violence.
Four weeks of riots in the occupied territories that have left at least 24 Palestinians dead, by official Israeli count. If Israeli authorities confirm the latest killing, it would raise the death toll to 25. The West Bank and Gaza Strip, which Israel captured from Jordan and Egypt in the 1967 Middle East war, are home to 1.5 million Palestinians.
Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir, speaking on national television, said the riots were a new Arab tactic meant to provoke Israel into a violent response. Shamir said he would not meet with U.N. envoy Marrack Goulding, expected to arrive today to examine the situation. An army helicopter circled over the Ibna refugee camp in the Gaza Strip and dropped tear gas canisters.
An Arab reporter said 10 people were arrested. An army spokesman confirmed that seven Palestinians were wounded by army marksmen when stone-throwing protesters clashed with soldiers Thursday at Maghazi and Nuseirat refugee camps in the Gaza Strip. The spokesman said he had no information about the killing.
The body of the slain youth, identified as Ismail Zaki Mosallem, was brought to a U.N. clinic in Maghazi, said Christine Dabagh, a spokeswoman for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, which provides services for the refugees. The army said residents of Maghazi and Nuseirat rose in violent protest at about 8 p.m. Thursday.
An army spokesman said troops with loudspeakers called on the Palestinians to disperse, and then fired rubber bullets and tear gas grenades at demonstrators hurling rocks. “When this did not help, soldiers started to fire from sniper rifles at their legs,” the spokesman said on condition of anonymity, in keeping with army regulations.
The army clamped a curfew on Nuseirat, home to 30,000 refugees, he said. No curfew was imposed on Maghazi, which has about 11,000 residents. Goulding was sent to Israel after the U.N. Security Council adopted a resolution Dec. 22 deploring Israel's stern handling of the riots and expressing concern over possible violations of Palestinians' human rights in the territories.
“I don't intend to meet with him. I think there's no need for it,” Shamir said Thursday. “We don't accept this U.N. resolution and we don't cooperate with any side aimed at implementing it.”
Palestinian youths are guarded by an Israeli soldier as they wait to be taken to jail.
Jewish settler kills Palestinian teen-ager on West Bank
About 62,000 Jews live among 1.4 million Palestinians in the occupied territories, perhaps a third of them in attractively priced suburban housing clusters around Jerusalem.
Many others, like the two men involved in the Beitin shooting yesterday, belong to the nationalist Gush Emunim movement, which often has established settlements on land near Palestinian villages that was previously held communally, provoking anger among Arabs there.
Gush Emunim, after the shooting, asked for a meeting with Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir to press for the release of the men involved at Beitin as well as of Jews convicted of terrorism against Arabs.
It urged a “massive Jewish settlement” drive to “prove to the whole world” that Jews “would not be broken” in their drive to establish more settlements in the occupied territories.
In the Beitin shooting, Pincas Wallerstein, a prominent leader of a controversial West Bank settlement at nearby Ofra, told police and army investigators that he opened fire yesterday morning when the car in which he was driving with bodyguard Shay Ben Yosef was mobbed and stoned by more than a dozen Palestinian youths at a roadblock of burning tires.
He was quoted as saying that he first had fired into the air to disperse the stone throwers, but that they had resumed attacking him when he and his companion sought to drive off. It was then, he said, that he chased them toward the village and opened fire to make good the escape. Maj. Gen.
Avram Mitzna, commander of Israel’s Central Command, which covers the West Bank, said initial investigation showed that the two settlers were acting in self-defense.
GAZA CITY, Occupied Gaza Strip (AP) — Palestinians rioted today in a Gaza Strip refugee camp during a visit by U.N. envoy Marrack Goulding, and Israel claimed the violence was provoked by his presence.
The U.N. undersecretary, who was accompanied by television crews, blamed the army for sending in soldiers who fought stone-throwing demonstrators with tear gas and rubber bullets. Meanwhile, preparations were reported under way to deport to Lebanon — possibly later today — four Palestinians accused of instigating unrest.
In Jerusalem, an acrimonious meeting of Israel's 10-member inner Cabinet ended without the announcement of any new measures to curb five weeks of violence in the West Bank and Gaza in which 32 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli gunfire.
Seven more Arabs were reported hurt in scattered unrest today, and some of the violence moved closer to Israeli homes as Arab youths hurled rocks through windows and damaged six houses in a Jewish residential area adjacent an Arab suburb of Jerusalem, police said.
A commercial strike kept idle large areas of the West Bank and Gaza, which Israel seized in the 1967 Middle East War. Israel-annexed east Jerusalem also observed a partial commercial strike. Soon after Goulding arrived at the camp in Rafah on the Gaza Strip's southern tip and entered a medical clinic, about 500 Arabs began hurling stones at troops escorting the visitors.
“What really made them angry was that soldiers came into the camp during our visit,” Goulding told reporters on arriving in Gaza City. “(The Arabs) were not mad at us. They made us feel very welcome. “They were also angry about the conditions in which they lived, and they had reason to be angry about that,” he added.
In Tel Aviv, the Israeli military command issued a statement accusing Goulding and the “10 TV crews” it said accompanied him of provoking the riot. “Until he entered the refugee camp, there was absolute quiet in the area,” it said. “When he entered the area, local people started throwing stones and rioting.”
Bill Lee, spokesman for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, said the disturbance began when hundreds of Arabs began chanting anti-occupation and pro-PLO slogans.
Four handed over to Marxist Palestinian guerrillas
JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli troops today detained 10 prominent Palestinians, including a newspaper editor who promoted a campaign of civil disobedience to protest Israel's crackdown on riots in the occupied territories. Four West Bank Palestinians deported by Israel were handed over today to a Marxist Palestinian guerrilla faction aligned with Syria, Lebanese police said.
They said that the Lebanese army had planned to return the four to Israeli-held territory in south Lebanon, despite a reported Israeli threat to shoot them on sight. BUT ARMY OFFICIALS changed their minds after Israel shut all crossings to its self-designated security zone along its northern border, police said.
A top United Nations official toured a refugee camp near Bethlehem to gather information on Palestinian living conditions. Paul Hunt of Amnesty International, the London-based human rights organization, also began a fact-finding mission in Gaza.
Also today, an Arab youth armed with a kitchen knife attacked a 22-year-old soldier as he walked past the courthouse in Kfar Saba, a town in central Israel, police said. The youth, from the West Bank, tried to grab the soldier's weapon, but the soldier fought him off, helped by passers-by, police said. The youth was arrested and the soldier was not hurt.
NO NEW VIOLENCE was reported today in the occupied Gaza Strip and West Bank, where at least 34 Arabs have been killed in five weeks of violence. A commercial strike continued in Gaza and at least two West Bank towns. Since the rioting began Dec. 8, more than 200 Palestinians have been wounded and 1,100 are being tried in military courts on rioting charges.
Israel captured the territories from Egypt and Jordan in the 1967 Middle East war. The army flew the four Arab deportees to southern Lebanon on Wednesday, gave them $50 each and put them in two passing taxis, which took them to the Syrian-controlled Bekaa Valley. Israel was criticized worldwide for the expulsions. The United States said it regretted the action.
The four activists were handed to George Habash's Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which opposes Yasser Arafat's leadership of the Palestine Liberation Organization, police said.
PALESTINIAN YOUTHS and children, including one child who holds an outlawed PLO flag, run away from advancing Israeli soldiers, unseen, during rock-throwing demonstrations Wednesday.
Two clauses, and the second one is the number. One person killed, and a quarter of a million people confined to their houses as the response — printed as a single line of news in a small Pennsylvania daily five weeks into the first intifada. The person killed has a nationality and nothing else; nobody in the sentence does the killing or imposes the curfew.
Correction: {'note': 'arrived dated 5 January 1988; the page line on the scan reads “The Daily News, Lebanon, Pa., Friday, January 1?, 1988”. The day’s second digit is clipped by the edge of the scan, but 5 January 1988 was a Tuesday, and the only Friday in that January with a two-digit day beginning in 1 is the 15th. Corrected to 15 January 1988.'}
JERUSALEM, Jan. 14 — The Israeli authorities detained 10 Palestinians, most regarded as members of the moderate Arab establishment, in a continuing crackdown today as scattered disturbances continued in the occupied territories. Seven of the Palestinians were freed later today, and three, all journalists, remained in custody.
The best-known of those taken into custody was Hanna Siniora, editor of the Arabic newspaper Al Fajr. He was released tonight after questioning. Five other journalists, two lawyers and two doctors were also detained. One journalist was ordered jailed for six months without trial and two others were still being held tonight.
The disturbances in the West Bank and Gaza Strip today were mostly stone-throwing clashes with the army. At least 35 Palestinians have been shot dead since early December, in the most violent wave of unrest since Israel seized the areas in the 1967 war.
The army maintained a curfew on all eight refugee camps in the Gaza Strip and several more in the West Bank, keeping more than a quarter of a million residents indoors. There were several reports that the army had broken into houses and beat people.
The tactic of imposing curfews and sealing off areas is intended to not only keep demonstrators off the streets but also divide the population from the protesters in hope of ending protests. “We will supress this violence,” Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin said on Israeli television late Wednesday night.
“It could take another week or two, a month or a month and a half. We will maintain the necessary forces.” The army said two weeks ago that it had arrested 2,000 Palestinians as leaders of the protests. On Wednesday, defying international criticism, Israel deported four West Bank Palestinians, leaving them on a remote mountain road in Lebanon.
Five more are awaiting deportation.
Gaza riots have kept many Palestinians from jobs in Israel proper.
Israel’s Economy Is Suffering As Arab Workers Stay Home
the Israeli labor force, they dominate certain fields, such as construction, agriculture and sanitation. In these areas, their absence has been palpable, as riots, curfews and threats from Palestinian militants have kept them away from work.
With 37 percent of the country’s construction workers coming from the occupied territories, the building business is the most vulnerable. And in this bustling city Arabs account for all of the street cleaners, many of the cooks and dishwashers and about one-third of the factory workers.
The unrest has also taken a heavy toll on food-processing plants and textile factories, particularly those in the south, where up to one-third of the workers in any plant may be from the Gaza Strip. The West Bank has been calmer, resulting in fewer absences from work.
Citrus Growers Are Concerned At the Polgat textile plant in the southern town of Qiryat Gat, for example, about 450 men of the total force of 1,400 have been attending work erratically for the last month because they live in the occupied territories, a personnel manager said.
Even the Jaffa orange is picked and packed by Palestinians, and citrus growers concerned about falling behind in their export schedules have been the first to demand that the Government let them bring in Portuguese and Turkish laborers. About 5,000 of the 15,000 citrus workers are Palestinians, according to Shalom Himlfarb, personnel manager at Tnuva Export.
“We’re not talking about building houses here,” Mr. Himlfarb said. “If it stays on the trees, it spoils. It’s not an emergency yet, but we want to prepare an alternative.”
Among the proposed contingency plans is the idea of recruiting students to work for either nominal wages or as volunteers, drafting soldiers to the job or offering temporary work and.wages to unemployed Lebanese who live in the Israeli-declared “security zone” in southern Lebanon.
Ministry Won’t Change Policy So far, the Ministry of Labor has refused to change its policy, apparently for political considerations. “Our first and foremost obligation is to the Arabs of the West Bank and Gaza, because they are under Israeli rule,” said a spokesman for the Minister of Labor and Social Affairs, Moshe Katzav.
“We must provide them with work. Those who have steady jobs are dedicated workers, and if they are out a day or two or there is a curfew in the camp, there is no intention of punishing them.” But he said that if the riots seriously disrupted Israeli industry, the policy could change. “In the meantime, the damage is peripheral only,” he said.
A survey conducted by the Israeli Army has estimated the economic damage from lost work at $40 million to $50 million, according to the newspaper Yedioth Aharonoth. In addition, sales of Israeli products have declined, since the occupied territories are a primary market.
But the employer-employee relationship is a symbiotic one, and Palestinians need the pay just as much as Israelis need the services. “I missed 10 days of work this month, but I got in on Tuesday and worked three days this week,” said Said, a 24-year-old from Khan Yunis, in the Gaza Strip. who was unloading crates of avocados at a market in Tel Aviv.
“The soldiers let people out to work, and we live outside the city, near orchards, so no one of our own people stopped us. “I have two children,” he said, “and everybody has to eat.”
JERUSALEM, Jan. 19 — The main street of Arab East Jerusalem was a long line of closed, gray steel shutters today as Palestinian shopkeepers refused to open their stores for the 13th day in a row.
Groups of Israeli policemen with tear-gas canisters strapped to their legs patrolled the desolate Salah e-Din Street area, and it appeared the confrontation between the Israeli authorities and Palestinian protesters had moved to a new battlefront: the war for the stores.
Any Arab shopkeepers who may have been planning to break the strike received a vivid warning against opening up Monday, when unidentified people burned down a shop on the main street in East Jerusalem.
Hanzeh el-Kurd’s money-changing business on Salah e-Din Street, which had opened occasionally in recent weeks, was burned to the ground Monday morning, and many merchants in the area suspect Palestinian nationalists in the arson. Strike Calls Renewed “I don’t blame them,” said Mr. Kurd’s 24-year-old son, Nasser.
“They burned the place,” he said. “So what? I feel bad of course, but I don’t blame anybody. We made a mistake, and we paid for it. We won’t do it again.” Although the authorities, eager to restore a semblance of normality, have encouraged merchants to return to business, Palestinian nationalists today renewed calls for a general strike.
The merchants of East Jerusalem have been observing an erratic commercial strike ever since the latest wave of unrest began in the occupied territories five weeks ago. Participation has been more consistent in the last 13 days as the death toll of Palestinians killed by Israeli troops has risen to at least 38.
Today, stores were closed not only in East Jerusalem but also in areas of the West Bank, after pamphlets, signed by the Palestine Liberation Organization and the Uprising Committee called for a three-day general strike. The pamphlets urged Palestinians to boycott Israeli goods and not to travel over the “green line,” Israel’s pre-1967 border.
Police Promise of Protection But the arson appeared intended to deter merchants who had planned to reopen their stores today with the help of the Israeli police, who had promised to protect them. Mr.
Kurd’s son, who stood in the drizzling rain Monday as he supervised workers cleaning up the gutted and blackened store, estimated the cost of the damage at $30,000 to $40,000. Although the Jerusalem police said they were investigating the possibility of a connection between the arson and the pressure to continue a commercial strike, Mr.
Kurd and merchants elsewhere on Salah e-Din Street said it was more than a possibility. Even before the store was burned, the family had received anonymous, threatening phone calls, Mr. Kurd said. “They said, ‘Close down or we’ll burn your shop. Close down or we’ll kill you,’” he said of the telephone callers.
Still, he said, he supports the strike. “Being against the Government is O.K., but being against the Palestinians — being against your own people — is not O.K.,” he said. “They can kill you.”
In Jerusalem on Sunday, after police orders to open stores were ignored or heeded only temporarily, the police held a meeting with about 40 Palestinian merchants, promising them protection if they opened shop. The opening was scheduled for today, apparently in order to give the merchants a day to rally their forces. The arson put an end to the plans. As Mr.
Kurd spoke, a handful of Palestinian youths gathered, and a cookie vendor holding a bronze tray full of sweets, passed by, asking “Want any?” in Arabic. A lone vendor sold green vegetables and persimmons from boxes opened up on the sidewalk, while two tiny kiosks did a brisk trade in newspapers and cigarettes.
Pharmacies are allowed by those leading the strike to remain open. Down the street, a jeweler who allowed a visitor into his shop worked behind closed shutters to finish an order for an overseas shipment. “I can’t go against the crowd” and open the store, he said. “I want to be like the three monkeys — see nothing, hear nothing, say nothing.”
Calling it ‘West Bank’ or ‘Judea and Samaria’, ‘occupied lands’ or ‘administered territories’
Marcus Eliason, Associated Press, Jerusalem
“When Foreign Minister Shimon Peres told an audience he was switching from ‘Judea and Samaria’ to ‘the West Bank,’ it was a verbal bombshell in a country where words often are ideological badges… The government needed a name that would cover all captured lands, but did not like calling them ‘occupied’ because Israelis prefer not to think of themselves as occupiers.
Thus ‘Administered Territories’ was born… Referring to Arabs of the West Bank and Gaza as Palestinians suggests to many Israelis a sympathy with their dreams of having their own state. Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir, and others who deny the authenticity of Palestinian nationhood, tend to speak of ‘Palestinian Arabs.’
To Israelis, who is a Palestinian is almost as vexing a question as who is a Jew. The late Golda Meir insisted there was no such thing as a Palestinian nation. She often recalled that, when Britain ruled the country, her citizenship too was ‘Palestinian.’”
The news agency explaining its own trade’s vocabulary. The page carries a map keyed OCCUPIED BY ISRAEL, naming Hebron, Halhul and Kiryat Arba, and a second Associated Press story from Jabaliya, Stones, not toys, for Arab children, which names four Palestinians — Ashraf, 12; Suheir, 9, who carries perfumed toilet paper against tear gas; Mohammed, 5; and Ashraf’s 60-year-old grandmother Nama. It ran beside a Doonesbury strip and a column of celebrity gossip.
NABLUS, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, Jan. 22 — Both hands encased in plaster casts, Imad Omar Abu Rub explained from his bed in the Rafidiya Hospital what happened when the Israeli Army came to the Palestinian village of Qabatiya. “They entered the house like animals, shouting,” the 22-year-old student at Bir Zeit University said.
“They took us from the house, kicking us in the head, beating us, all the soldiers with their rifle butts.” Then he was taken to the construction site of an unfinished house where, he said, the soldiers put an empty bucket over his head. Beaten With Two-by-Fours Several soldiers held him down, he said, gripping his arms to force his hands against a rock.
Two others, he said, beat his hands with lengths of two-by-fours, breaking the bones. The injuries are the product of a new, officially declared policy of the Israeli Army and the police to beat up Palestinians in hopes of ending the wave of protests in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip that began in early December.
At least 38 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli gunfire in the protests. The new tactic is being employed as an alternative to the use of live ammunition. In the bed next to Mr. Abu Rub’s, Hassan Arif Kemal, a 17-year-old high school student from Qabatiya, told a nearly identical story.
Mother Says She Was Beaten, Too He said that he, too, had been pulled from his house by the army and taken to a construction site, and that his hands had been broken by soldiers wielding two-by-fours. His mother, an elderly looking woman with a baleful glare, said she was beaten and bruised as she tried to stop the soldiers from taking her son.
Six people from Qabatiya were admitted to Rafidiya Hospital on Wednes-
A Palestinian who was arrested after a demonstration near Dome of the Rock Mosque in Jerusalem, above, was walked into a police station. A half hour later, he was brought out on a stretcher to an ambulance.
Readers hot over Israel's role in Gaza and on West Bank
The Jan. 8 Herald Examiner contained an Op-Ed column, “No Palestinian homeland, then more riots,” by Edward Said, a member of the Palestine National Council, the political face of the Palestine Liberation Organization. Said’s recounting of the history behind the issue started with 1971. From 1949 through 1967, however, Gaza was under Egyptian rule.
The economy was a shambles, as no Arab was allowed into Egypt to work. Gaza was an Arab ghetto where poverty and disease were rampant. At that time the only national movement in Gaza was the Fedayeen, who used Gaza as their base for terrorist attacks against Israel. From 1967 to the present, Gaza has been under Israeli rule. Some 30,000 Arabs travel daily into Israel to work.
“Palestinians riot in the Israeli-occupied West Bank.” Herald Examiner.
A full page of letters. Eight readers signed: Si Frumkin of Studio City, Stephanie Glick of Northridge, Amy Cohanim, Jacob Gendelman, Gene Galvin, Christopher D. Pascal and Alexander H. Pope, all of Los Angeles, and Jim Gregory of Joshua Tree. The transcription here is the opening of the first, by Si Frumkin, answering an Op-Ed the paper had run on January 8. Edward Said had a byline in an American metropolitan daily in January 1988.
LONDON — A Palestinian cartoonist who was murdered in London last year has become the first Arab and the only cartoonist to be awarded the Golden Pen of Freedom award by the International Federation of Newspaper Publishers. Naji al-Ali was 49 when he was shot last July and he died five weeks later.
No-one claimed responsibility for the attack, but his murder was seen as revenge by one of the Middle East groups he satirized. The Paris-based federation, which has given the award posthumously only once before in its 27 year history, said Al-Ali used his drawings to attack tyranny wherever he saw it in the Middle East.
“His cartoons were so sharp that he offended every government in the region,” but his work also attracted a wide following among those promoting compromise and understanding, the citation said. Al-Ali had lived in exile in London since 1985.
U.S. report alleges Israeli repression in occupied areas
By Walter Friedenberg, Scripps Howard News Service
WASHINGTON — The State Department’s annual global human-rights report says Israeli Jews enjoy democratic rights, but that the Israeli government subjects Palestinians in the occupied territories to repression, arbitrary detention and lethal force by the army… The annual report, titled “Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 1987,” covers 170 countries — all but the United States… Israel is described as a model parliamentary democracy with free elections, an independent judiciary and elected legislature that may limit the government and bring it down by a vote of no confidence.
But Israel’s military administration in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, captured in the 1967 Middle East war, comes in for sharp criticism. Under the category of “political killing,” the report lists 47 Palestinians killed last year and 300 wounded by the Israeli army or other security forces, the majority by the use of “lethal force” against demonstrators… Palestinians are subject to pre-occupation Jordanian law as amended by Israeli military regulations, while Jewish settlers are subject to Israeli law and administration.
This “dual system” means Palestinians are “usually treated less favorably” than Jewish settlers on a broad range of issues, including due process, freedom of movement, land use and social services. While Hebrew-language newspapers submit only military security articles to censors, the Arabic press must submit all items for censorship.
Several Arabic papers and news services were closed for six months to two years. Nine Palestinians were deported in violation of the Fourth Geneva Convention governing occupied territories. More than 120 Palestinians were detained as long as six months without charges.
ISRAELI POLICEMAN ORDERS ARAB AWAY FROM REFUGEE CAMP — The man was attempting to visit his family in a West Bank camp
In February 1988 the United States government published a finding that the territories ran on a dual system under which Palestinians were usually treated less favorably than settlers in due process, movement, land and social services. In December 1988 an American columnist wrote that the resolution calling Zionism racism was integral to the United Nations’ enterprise of delegitimizing Israel, and the Republican platform promised to cut American support for the United Nations until it was repealed. Same year, same government, two documents that never meet.
Bomb explosion, scattered protests wound four Arabs
By SERGEI SHARGORODSKY, Associated Press Writer
JERUSALEM — Police wounded two Palestinians and beat several others Saturday in scattered clashes throughout the occupied territories, Arab news reports said. Thousands of Israelis demonstrated to demand negotiations with Palestinians. The army said two Arabs were wounded in Gaza City when the homemade bomb they were preparing went off.
Thousands of Israelis from the left-wing Peace Now movement held a rally near Jerusalem’s residence of Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir to demand negotiations with Palestinians.
In the northern port city of Haifa, about 4,000 Jews and Israeli Arabs marched in the streets holding signs and shouting slogans that demanded Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank and Gaza Strip, Israel television reported.
The Arab-run Palestine Press Service said two Palestinians were wounded by army gunfire and ten others were injured by beatings or rubber bullets in Saturday’s clashes with the army. The military command said it knew nothing about injuries and described the situation as “quiet.”
A 9-day-old curfew was lifted in the West Bank town of Tulkarem, 37 miles northeast of Jerusalem. About 10,000 Palestinians live there. But more than 20,000 people remained under curfew in the nearby Tulkarem refugee camp, in the village of Anabta, and in the Deir El Balah refugee camp in Gaza.
A military official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said two Arabs apparently preparing a homemade bomb were wounded when the bomb went off unexpectedly. He said soldiers were not involved in the explosion and that the army was checking the incident.
An Arab reporter in Gaza City said Mohammed Ahmed Ibrahim, 23, and Mahmoud Nimer Mohammed El Halaby, 24, were brought to the city’s Ahle Arab hospital. He said Ibrahim was wounded in his hands while El Halaby suffered head and chest wounds. The reporter, who requested anonymity, said soldiers came to the hospital to detain El Halaby.
The Palestine Press Service said an Arab in Gaza City was shot by soldiers and four others were beaten. It said another Arab was shot and wounded in the Balata refugee camp near Nablus, in the West Bank, and that six others were injured by rubber bullets.
In Jerusalem’s southeastern Jabel Mukaber neighborhood, about 100 youths raised the Palestinian flag and threw stones, advancing towards the nearby hilltop Jewish neighborhood of East Talpiyot.
Dozens of Jewish residents gathered to watch as about 40 policemen and 15 paramilitary border policemen fired tear gas at the Arabs and then ran into Jabel Mukaber, chasing the youths with clubs.
Date check: No masthead or page date line survives — the clipping is trimmed to the three-line headline, the byline block and two text columns. Nothing on it names the paper or the date, so 1988-02-14 and “Carroll County Times” could not be verified. The story is datelined JERUSALEM with no date and reports events of “Saturday”, which is consistent with a Sunday paper; 14 February 1988 was a Sunday.
JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli soldiers shot and killed a Palestinian protester in the West Bank today, Arab hospital officials said, as demonstrations heated up before the arrival of Secretary of State George Shultz. The army said it was checking the reported death. If confirmed, it would be the 64th Arab killed by Israeli gunfire since the current wave of unrest began Dec.
8. The Arab-run Palestine Press Service identified the victim as Issam Said Abu Khalifeh, 18, and said he was killed during a demonstration at the Jenin refugee camp. Hospital officials said he was shot in the head and chest.
Four sentences, and two things this archive counts. The headline names who fired, which most of the death headlines here do not. And the dead man has a name — supplied not by the American agency but by a Palestinian one, which the copy is careful to call Arab-run.
Dear Editor: In his article about the Jewish community town meeting [“Advice and Dissent,” L.A. Weekly, Feb. 5-11], Ben Kallen quotes UCLA Hillel Rabbi Chaim Seidler-Feller as saying: “Many of us are confused . . . and shocked by the open brutality of the Israeli army . . .
We have a sense . . . that all of a sudden the reality has overtaken the mythology, and the dream is shattering.” “Confused”? “Shocked”? “All of a sudden”? The rabbi seems to be suffering from a case of selective amnesia.
Six years ago, he gave a talk at the University Synagogue in Brentwood about the situation in Israel's occupied territories. Having just returned from the area, he showed true anguish as he described the atrocities perpetrated by the Israeli authorities.
These included home and town arrests, numerous house demolitions, administrative detentions and killings of unarmed demonstrators. A few months later, Israel began its brutal invasion of Lebanon. Again, Rabbi Seidler-Feller was troubled. He started organizing forums at UCLA and began circulating petitions.
He was then told by his employers at the Jewish Federation that if he didn't “lower his voice” his job would be in jeopardy. (He told this to me and two UCLA faculty members at the time.) Rabbi Seidler-Feller not only lowered his voice.
In the next few years he did his utmost to erase all “troubling events” from his community's memory by attempting to block all meaningful discussion at UCLA of the Palestine-Israel issue. When nothing else worked, he resorted to suggestions of anti-Semitism and self-hatred against those on either side. His actions are characteristic of today's Jewish leadership.
By exhibiting “surprise” at each new wave of “troubling” events, these leaders attempt to deny their systematic nature and the fact that they are an expression of a policy whose goal has always been to drive the Palestinians off their land.
The kindness, compassion and justice these leaders claim as part of the Jewish heritage play no role in this policy.
UNITED NATIONS (AP) — The United Nations voted 143-1 for the United States to submit to binding arbitration on whether it can shut down the PLO observer mission. The United States did not vote, and Israel cast the only negative vote.
Israeli Ambassador Benjamin Netanyahu said the Palestine Liberation Organization is a terrorist group that has no place in the United Nations. The assembly also voted 142-0 for a resolution asking the World Court in the Hague for a ruling on whether the United States has the right to refuse arbitration. The arbitration would be conducted by an independent three-member panel.
The United States, which has not yet moved to close the mission, said it considered the emergency assembly meeting “premature and unnecessary.”
A hundred and forty-three votes to one, with the United States abstaining from a vote about itself.
Journalists barred from West Bank after demonstrations
Associated Press
JERUSALEM (AP) — Soldiers today turned back journalists seeking to enter the occupied West Bank as demonstrations erupted after noon prayers on the Moslem Sabbath. One woman was wounded by Israeli gunfire, an Arab report said. Authorities also discovered and defused a car bomb near the central bus station 300 yards from the hotel where U.S. Secretary of State George P.
Shultz was staying. Police Commander Yosef Yehudai said the car bomb was probably intended for a shopping center to protest Shultz’s visit. The explosives-laden car was discovered by a police officer after it ran into a wall and was abandoned.
Shultz met Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir and Foreign Minister Shimon Peres in a final, but apparently inconclusive, effort to promote Arab-Israel negotiations that would help end riots in the occupied West Bank and Gaza. At least 76 Arabs have been killed since the violence began Dec. 8, most of them by Israeli army gunfire.
“I apreciate very much the positive and constructive discussions we have just had ... and I will keep working,” Shultz told reporters after meeting Peres. Shultz left for Syria to meet President Hafez Assad and then planned to fly to Cairo for talks with Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak before wrapping up his shuttle Saturday.
The U.S. proposal calls for peace talks at an international conference which will lead to direct talks between Israel and a Jordanian-Palestinian delegation. Peres, a member of the Labor Party, has expressed support for the Shultz plan but Shamir, a member of the right-wing Likud, has not. Shamir and Peres are bitter rivals in the coalition government.
Protesters shouted anti-Shultz slogans in demonstrations erupting throughout the occupied areas after noon prayers today. One woman was shot in the right leg during a protest in the Balata refugee camp near Nablus, the Palestine Press Service reported. The outbreak came despite a crackdown on press coverage.
Israeli officials contend television cameras and still photographers inflame demonstrations. “There is no policy” to bar journalists from covering the West Bank and Gaza Strip, said a senior Defense Ministry official who spoke on condition of anonymity. “It is not a total closure,” said Brig. Gen. Ephraim Lapid, the army spokesman.
He said local commanders had been authorized to bar journalists and indicated some areas were closed because noon prayers often end in violent demonstrations. A tightening of restrictions on press coverage had been expected after Shamir warned he was considering closing occupied zones to journalists, whom he accused of being biased against Israel.
Robert Slate, chairman of the Foreign Press Association, said restrictions had been expected after Shamir’s warning. “I’m appalled but not surprised,” Slater said. “The question is whether this is limited to Fridays or more general.”
Associated Press correspondent Mary Sedor was stopped on the outskirts of the West Bank town of Ramallah, eight miles north of Jerusalem. “Ramallah is a closed military area. The only people allowed inside are the people who live here,” said an Israeli soldier, one of six manning a checkpoint behind a spiked barrier.
“We are asking everyone where they live and if they live here, they can go in. All outsiders, including the press, cannot enter,” the soldier said. Photographer Eli Hershkowitz said an army roadblock was also stopping journalists at Gush Etzion, on the road from Jerusalem to Hebron.
He said some journalists used back roads to evade the checkpoints and reached Hebron, where rumors circulated that a demonstration was planned after noon prayers today. It was not immediately known if army roadblocks were set up in the occupied Gaza Strip. The U.S. Embassy said the car bomb found in Jerusalem was not along a route Shultz was to travel today.
It was not clear when the bomb was to have gone off. Police said it had a detonating mechanism, but did not elaborate. The vehicle was abandoned near a shopping mall and close to the city’s central bus station. It was northwest of the Hilton Hotel, where Shultz spent Thursday night.
Authorities said it was unclear if the driver was on his way elsewhere when the vehicle was driven into a wall or had abandoned the car intentionally. The Jerusalem Post quoted a leaflet issued by the militant Islamic Jihad, which called for a three-day general strike starting today in Gaza. The leaflet linked the strike to Shultz’s mission.
The leaflet called Shultz “the great evil envoy” and said his mission was designed to stop the three-month uprising by the 1.5 million Palestinians of the West Bank and Gaza, which Israeli seized in the 1967 Middle East war.
Three weeks before the territories were closed outright, a wire report on the reason given for keeping cameras out: Israeli officials contend television cameras and still photographers inflame demonstrations. The denial and the confirmation sit in consecutive paragraphs — an unnamed Defense Ministry official says “there is no policy” to bar journalists, the army spokesman says “it is not a total closure,” and then a soldier at a checkpoint says plainly that all outsiders including the press cannot enter. The correspondent turned back at Ramallah is Mary Sedor, whose dispatch seven months later carried an editor’s note saying the censor had ordered deletions.
EDITOR'S NOTE: This story was submitted to Israeli military censors who ordered several deletions. JERUSALEM — Israeli soldiers shot and killed two Arabs Saturday and wounded three others in rioting in the occupied West Bank. The army arrested 64 Palestinians in an operation to protect pro-Israeli collaborators.
In northern Israel, four members of a family were wounded by Soviet-designed Katyusha rockets fired from southern Lebanon, military sources said. The wounded were taken to the hospital in the town of Nahariya. It was the first time in 18 months that casualties were reported from Katyusha-rocket attacks from Lebanon.
Nahariya Hospital deputy director Moshe Daniel said the victims suffered light to moderate wounds. Israel army radio reported that a Palestinian who was wounded Friday in the occupied Gaza Strip died Saturday at the Tel Hashomer hospital near Tel Aviv.
An Arab reporter in Gaza City identified the man as Mohammed Saahin, 32, of the Bureij refugee camp and said he had been shot in the leg and abdomen. The radio report said the man attacked an Israeli officer and the officer shot him. A soldier was injured in Saturday's West Bank fighting, according to the army.
In the Gaza Strip, two Palestinians were wounded Saturday by gunshots, 11 suffered beating or rubber-bullet injuries and 18 were arrested, Arab and Israeli news media reported. Saturday's most violent confrontation occurred in Dhahiriya, a West Bank village 28 miles southwest of Jerusalem.
Army officials said a patrol entered the village at about 10 a.m. to quell a violent protest and opened fire after a soldier was injured by the stone-throwing rioters. “We received reports about two fatalities and, apparently, two wounded among the residents,” one army official said.
The casualties were “most likely” the result of the army shooting, he said, speaking on condition of anonymity. The Arab-run Palestine Press Service said Mahel Wreidet, 25, was shot in the chest and died at Jerusalem's Mukassad Hospital. It said another villager, 30-year-old Rasem A. Kadeirat, died at the Alia Hospital in Hebron after being shot in the back.
Officials at the two hospitals confirmed the fatalities. The Arab agency also said a 36-year-old man and two girls, ages 17 and 18, suffered gunshot wounds to the head during the Dhahiriya clash. Israel radio said the army clamped a curfew on the village.
Saturday's fatalities brought to 81 the number of Palestinians killed since violence erupted in the occupied territories on Dec. 8, according to U.N. figures. In Ramallah, Associated Press photographer Martin Cleaver saw about 20 Arab youths hurling stones at soldiers. The youths stayed close to the Ramallah Hospital entrance.
The soldiers surrounded the hospital and fired tear gas at the youths. Sixty-four Palestinians were arrested in three West Bank locations in what the army said was a move to protect pro-Israeli collaborators.
Palestinian women gasp and cry from the effects of tear gas fired by Israeli soldiers on a road outside the occupied West Bank town of Ramallah.
Women Lead Palestinian Protests; 2 More Are Killed
Alan Cowell
“Security forces fired tear gas and rubber bullets to disperse marching Palestinian women today, as widespread violence continued in Israel’s occupied territories.”
Women leading, in the headline, in the first year of the intifada. The archive already holds Palestinian women organizing in 1922; this is the same sentence, sixty-six years later, with rubber bullets in it.
BETHLEHEM, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, March 13 — The Palestinian police officer rose this morning, packed his dark blue Israeli uniform in a plastic bag, went to his precinct next to the Church of the Nativity here and resigned.
That fulfillment of his political duty, as he saw it, left open the question of how he and his wife and their five children would eat after he spent his final paycheck, the equivalent of $500. “God will protect us.” the policeman. who gave his name as Rames, told a reporter. His relatives had offered a little help, too, he acknowledged.
Growing Economic Strain The decision of the 33-year-old officer, on a blustery Sunday in which rain alternated with sunshine around Bethlehem’s white stone churches, was part of the mass walkout this weekend by roughly half the 1,000 Palestinians employed by the Israeli Government as police officers in the occupied territories.
The resignations had been demanded by the clandestine leadership of the three-month-old uprising in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip. The police resignations seemed to add to the growing economic strain that the uprising imposes on Palestinians.
The strikes, riots, curfews and boycotts ordered by the uprising’s underground leadership have separated Palestinians from jobs in Israel and within the occupied territories. The Palestinians are also affected by what they increasingly see as Israeli efforts to starve out the insurrection.
“I believe there is a new policy of Israeli economic squeeze,” said a Palestinian Mayor, Elias Freij of Bethlehem, commenting on reports today that the occupation forces had ordered a halt to sending gasoline and other fuel to the occupied territories for a week. “I know of people who are having hard times,” Mayor Freij said.
“But that is not going to weaken the uprising.” He echoed what seems to be a refrain by Palestinians interviewed on the West Bank today that few feel they have an alternative. The police officer who called himself
Arab policemen returning equipment in Bethlehem after resigning.
BEIT SAHUR, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, March 26 — Bicharra Qumsaya kneaded the black worry beads in his right hand as he scanned the faces of his neighbors crowded into the Greek Orthodox Church. He wore a well-tailored dark suit and the traditional white Arab headdress, held in place with a double black band. “Dear brothers,” he began softly.
“I’ll be glad to be your servant and I swear never to betray you again. My home is open to you.” Through the early 1980’s the stout, 65-year old Mr. Qumsaya, his four sons and a handful of associates were riding high as Israeli-appointed Palestinian leaders.
… Two Palestinians, Majed Hussein Dheeb, 19 years old, and Awad Qassem Ibrahim, 30, were shot dead by Israeli soldiers during protests in the little village of Kufr Thilth near Nablus today. A third Palestinian, Ayed Salah, died of gunshot wounds suffered Friday night during demonstrations blocking roads near the village of Zawata.
… In this largely Christian village of about 8,000 next to Bethlehem, hundreds of men and women crowded into a basement room of the big stone Greek Orthodox church late this afternoon to hear Mr. Qumsaya repent. “Was what you did for the Israelis right or wrong?”
Ibrahim Jabber, 40, a former president of the church’s social club, asked in a challenging voice. “Wrong.” Mr. Qumsaya replied. “If the Israelis offered you a post again, would you take it,” Mr. Jabber pressed. “No,” Mr. Qumsaya said.
“You are invited to come to the church tomorrow to offer Confession for your sins,” said the Orthodox priest, Father Issa Musleit, a stern, bearded figure in the black stovepipe hat of his sect.
Israel considering sealing off areas for security reasons
Dan Fisher, Los Angeles Times, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — Top Israeli officials are weighing a proposal to seal off the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip this week as part of security precautions against demonstrations planned for Wednesday by Israeli Arabs and Palestinians, a senior security source said Sunday.
The source, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the proposed ban would prevent residents on both sides of the so-called Green Line from crossing it. The invisible boundary divides the territory Israel held before 1967 from the West Bank and Gaza Strip areas that it occupied after the 1967 Arab-Israeli War.
About 700,000 Palestinian Arabs live as Israeli citizens inside Israel and 1.4 million are either stateless or hold Jordanian citizenship in the territories. Israeli Arabs have declared a general strike for Wednesday as an expression of solidarity with the Palestinian uprising that has rocked the West Bank and Gaza Strip for nearly 16 weeks.
The date, March 30, also commemorates protests in 1976 against Israeli land confiscations that left six Arabs dead. The self-styled Unified National Leadership for the Uprising in the Occupied Territories has also called for a general strike that day and for “huge demonstrations against the army and [Jewish] settlers.”
Fearing that the so-called “Land Day” protests may lead to widespread violence, authorities are reportedly planning a long list of countermeasures. Israel Radio reported that Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin and Police Minister Chaim Bar-Lev briefed their fellow cabinet members on some of those measures during a regular meeting of the government Sunday.
The briefing was held in the framework of the Ministerial Defense Committee, whose deliberations were secret. It was not clear whether the proposal to seal the borders of the occupied territories was aired in the cabinet. However, the senior security source confirmed that “there is a proposal like that. It is one of the proposals. But nobody decided until now.”
The source added that a decision is expected by tonight. He added that it is not clear whether the ban would also exclude news coverage inside the occupied territories.
Meanwhile, Israel said its troops shot three Arabs in the West Bank village of Meithalun on Sunday after Palestinians attacked with iron bars and a car, but villagers accused the soldiers of firing at cars carrying wounded people.
Israeli soldiers killed a fourth Palestinian in the West Bank town of Salfit, while trying to rescue an Israeli tour bus that blundered into the Arab community. Sunday’s deaths raised to 118 the number of Palestinians killed in 15 weeks of violent protests against Israel’s 20-year occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, according to U.N. figures.
One Israeli soldier has been killed. Earlier this month, the authorities imposed a ban on travel by Palestinians between the West Bank and Gaza Strip in hopes that it would impair coordination of anti-Israeli protest actions. Israel Radio reported Sunday that many Israeli Arabs have been detained or interrogated in the northern part of the country in the last two days.
Police sources denied the allegation and said that the only Israeli Arabs held were those who had been involved in illegal disturbances during the last three months, state radio added.
The army’s account and the villagers’ are printed one after the other, and the paper does not choose between them. The running toll is the United Nations’: 118 Palestinians, one Israeli soldier.
For Edward Said, Shultz Session Proved Collegial and Constructive
By MARVINE HOWE
Even before Edward W. Said visited Washington Saturday to discuss the Middle East with Secretary of State George P. Shultz, Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir of Israel complained that the meeting violated a United States commitment not to meet with members of the Palestine Liberation Organization.
As it turned out, the first subject that the Secretary of State raised with Professor Said was the state of their alma mater, Princeton University, from which Mr. Shultz graduated in 1942 and Mr. Said in 1957. At what Professor Said called their “very cordial and informal” meeting, Mr. Shultz presented a text of his peace plan to Mr.
Said and to Ibrahim Abu-Lughod, a Palestinian-American professor at Northwestern University. The meeting was described by both sides as “an exchange of views” and not as any form of negotiation. The State Department characterized the meeting as a routine consultation with prominent Palestinians.
“We came away with the feeling that Secretary Shultz is serious about going forward with his peace effort and we recommended that he contact other members of the Palestinian Diaspora in Egypt, Jordan and elsewhere,” Mr. Said explained Saturday during an interview in the Manhattan apartment where he lives with his wife and two teen-age children. Mr.
Shultz’s plan calls for meetings between Israel and a delegation of Jordanians and Palestinians, with an international conference of the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council to receive reports on the talks but not to dictate terms of any agreement.
LONDON — As the Palestinian death toll in the present uprising in the occupied territories rises inexorably past the hundred mark, an Israeli journalist and scholar has thrown a harsh new light on the origins of the problem. He is understandably not a popular man in Israel. “People's minds have been warped by 40 years of nonsense,” said Dr.
Benny Morris ruefully after he appeared on a television chat show in Israel two years ago to explain his conclusions about the Palestinian exodus of 1948. Warped or not, people's minds were certainly made up: the switchboard of the state-run television network was jammed with protest calls.
Morris, the diplomatic correspondent of the Jerusalem Post, has bluntly asserted that the Palestinians did not leave Israel voluntarily in 1948. Nor did they just flee out of a misplaced fear that they would be massacred by Jewish terrorist groups like Irgun Zvai Leumi, which slaughtered 250 Palestinians in the village of Deir Yassin, near Jerusalem, 40 years ago.
Their fears were real. Most of the Palestinians, said Morris, were driven out — and he had the documents to prove it.
The key source he quoted was a secret Israeli army intelligence report, dated June 30, 1948, which concluded that Jewish military action accounted for 70 percent of the Arab refugees who fled their homes between the UN resolution partitioning Palestine in November 1947 and the beginning of June 1948.
Israelis bar relief workers from occupied territories
Associated Press
RAMALLAH, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Israel’s army isolated the occupied territories yesterday, but Palestinians threw gasoline bombs at patrolling soldiers and the Israelis opened fire and wounded eight of the demonstrators.
The unprecedented crackdown on the 1.5 million Arabs in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip was aimed at halting four months of unrest and at preventing mass demonstrations by Palestinians on today’s 12th anniversary of Land Day, when Israeli soldiers killed six Arabs protesting land confiscation. Foreign relief workers were barred from entering the occupied lands.
Thousands of police were mobilized yesterday evening to enforce curfews in Arab towns in Israel. Arabs reported that demonstrators took to the streets in some areas and that Israeli troops fired at the curfew violators. The eight Arabs were wounded in the village of Zaita, 40 miles northwest of Jerusalem, the army and the Palestine Press Service reported.
Palestinians in the territories threw rocks and gasoline bombs. Among the protesters reported wounded was 13-year-old girl. In Ramallah, small children tossed rocks at each other in the streets. They called the game “Jews and Arabs.” Hundreds of protesters have been wounded since riots began Dec.
8 in the West Bank and Gaza, which Israel captured from Jordan and Egypt in the 1967 Middle East War. The death toll stands at 119 Palestinians and one Israeli soldier, according to U.N. figures. Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin and Lt. Gen.
Dan Shomron, Israel’s military chief of staff, threatened for the first time yesterday to close the territories for an extended period. “For now, the decision to close the areas is for three days,” Rabin said on Israel radio. “But I’ve always said we have to adjust our measures to confront every eventuality.”
Closing the occupied lands is intended to quell the violence by imposing collective punishment on Palestinians and to keep out journalists, whose reports the Israelis claim feed the rebellion.
Although general access for journalists has been withdrawn, U.S. television pools were allowed into the West Bank and Gaza on yesterday and some individual journalists managed to get past roadblocks. Particularly harsh restrictions have been put on the Gaza Strip. The rebellion began there and the 6-mile-long Mediterranean coastal area is easier to isolate.
“No human beings are on the streets,” said Rashad al Shawaa, who was deposed by Israel as mayor of Gaza City in 1983. “It’s like a cemetery. The army announced over loudspeakers: ‘Anyone who leaves their home will be shot’.”
He told The Associated Press by telephone he saw soldiers fire on a few Palestinians who went out in his neighborhood in defiance of the curfew. Shawaa said the telephone call was the first he had received in 26 hours. Telephone service to Gaza was cut Monday and most remained down yesterday night.
Foreign journalists asked the Supreme Court to overturn the order banning them from the territories, the first in more than 20 years of Israeli occupation.
CLOSED TO TV CREWS — Israeli soldiers tell a television cameraman he is forbidden to enter the Israeli-occupied town of Ramallah, West Bank, yesterday, after the territories were declared closed for three days, in an unprecedented move by the Israel Defense Forces.
The sentence that explains the policy is in the eleventh paragraph and is not hedged: closing the occupied lands is intended to quell the violence by imposing collective punishment on Palestinians and to keep out journalists, whose reports the Israelis claim feed the rebellion. The photograph beside it shows a soldier telling a cameraman he may not enter Ramallah. The words above that picture are CLOSED TO TV CREWS. On the same day, foreign journalists went to Israel’s Supreme Court to have the ban overturned, the first such order in more than twenty years of occupation.
PALESTINIAN WOMAN SLAIN — Arab Press Agency Closed. By JOHN RICE, Associated Press Writer. RAMALLAH, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Israel today closed a key Arab information service and its soldiers shot and killed a Palestinian woman and wounded three family members in their home in the occupied West Bank.
Hospital officials said three other Arabs were wounded in clashes today, an annual day of violent protest in the occupied territories. Israeli officials hoped their ability to control unrest today might signal the end of nearly four months of violent Arab protests.
Eight police officers swept into the Arab-owned Palestine Press Service in east Jerusalem and ordered it closed for six months under 1948 emergency regulations. The service is the only Arab information agency and has been a critical source for journalists since Israel ordered the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip closed Monday.
The move was one of several measures taken by Israel in an effort to block major rioting to mark Land Day, an annual day of demonstrations against Israeli land confiscation. Six Arabs were killed in a Land Day protest 12 years ago. An extra 4,000 police were stationed today in Israel’s Arab sectors, including traffic police placed on riot duty.
Telephone lines to Gaza remained severed, troops warned on loudspeakers that curfew violators would be shot and Gaza and the West Bank were closed to most outside traffic. Only the territories’ 65,000 Jewish settlers were permitted to travel freely.
The tight security failed to prevent a killing in Deir Abu Mashal, a West Bank village 20 miles northwest of Jerusalem, according to hospital officials and a report by the Palestine Press Service made moments before it was closed.
Troops entered the home of Wajalah Rabir, 50, while she and her family were eating breakfast, and fatally shot her in the head, Ramallah Hospital officials told The Associated Press in a telephone interview. A visitor to the hospital quoted Mrs. Rabir’s 17-year-old daughter Zeinab as saying the soldiers came in and asked if there were any men in the house.
The visitor said the girl told the troops no men were home, but they entered anyway. The visitor, who spoke on condition of anonymity, quoted the girl as saying a soldier shot one brother who started to run. Other family members then lunged toward the troops, who opened fire on the family. The hospital officials said Mrs.
Rabir was killed and her husband and two sons were shot and were in serious condition. The officials, who have been banned from speaking to journalists, insisted on anonymity. The army confirmed the woman was killed and three people were wounded.
The fatality brought to 120 the number of Palestinians who have been killed by Israelis since the unrest in the occupied lands began Dec. 8, according to U.N. figures. One Israeli soldier was also killed during that time.
Three other Palestinians were wounded today in the West Bank — one in a clash near Betinuya, a small village south of Ramallah, and two, including a 12-year-old girl, in Sair near Hebron, hospital officials said. In New York, the U.N. Security Council scheduled an urgent, Arab-requested meeting for today on the unrest.
Secretary-General Javier Perez de Cuellar expressed “acute concern” over the continued killing of unarmed Palestinians. Ibrahim Kareen, publisher of the Palestine Press Service, called the closure order “another act of repression. Israeli officials are trying to impose a complete blackout on what is happening in the occupied territories.”
The killing of Wajalah Rabir is the line above the headline. The headline itself is the press agency. Three other American papers ran the same Associated Press dispatch the same day and made the opposite choice. Inside, a sentence most readers would pass over: the hospital officials who described the shooting have been banned from speaking to journalists, and so are unnamed. The paper that has just been closed is the paper that filed the report the dispatch relies on, moments before it was closed.
Israeli troops kill Arab woman, close Palestine press service
Associated Press
RAMALLAH, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Israel today closed a key Arab information service and its soldiers shot and killed a Palestinian woman and wounded three family members in their home in the occupied West Bank. Hospital officials said three other Arabs were wounded in clashes today, an annual day of violent protest in the occupied territories.
Israeli officials hoped their ability to control unrest today might signal the end of nearly four months of violent Arab protests. Eight police officers swept into the Arab-owned Palestine Press Service in east Jerusalem and ordered it closed for six months under 1948 emergency regulations.
The service is the only Arab information agency and has been a critical source for journalists since Israel ordered the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip closed Monday. The move was one of several measures taken by Israel in an effort to block major rioting to mark Land Day, an annual day of demonstrations against Israeli land confiscation.
Six Arabs were killed in a Land Day protest 12 years ago. An extra 4,000 police were stationed today in Israel’s Arab sectors, including traffic police placed on riot duty. Telephone lines to Gaza remained severed, troops warned on loudspeakers that curfew violators would be shot and Gaza and the West Bank were closed to most outside traffic.
Only the territories’ 65,000 Jewish settlers were permitted to travel freely. The tight security failed to prevent a killing in Deir Abu Mashal, a West Bank village 20 miles northwest of Jerusalem, according to hospital officials and a report by the Palestine Press Service made moments before it was closed.
Troops entered the home of Wajalah Rabir, 50, while she and her family were eating breakfast, and fatally shot her in the head, Ramallah Hospital officials told The Associated Press in a telephone interview. A visitor to the hospital quoted Mrs. Rabir’s 17-year-old daughter Zeinab as saying the soldiers came in and asked if there were any men in the house.
The visitor said the girl told the troops no men were home, but they entered anyway. The visitor, who spoke on condition of anonymity, quoted the girl as saying a soldier shot one brother who started to run. Other family members then lunged toward the troops, who opened fire on the family. The hospital officials said Mrs.
Rabir was killed and her husband and two sons were shot and were in serious condition. The officials, who have been banned from speaking to journalists, insisted on anonymity. The army confirmed the woman was killed and three people were wounded.
The fatality brought to 120 the number of Palestinians who have been killed by Israelis since the unrest in the occupied lands began Dec. 8, according to U.N. figures. One Israeli soldier was also killed during that time.
Three other Palestinians were wounded today in the West Bank — one in a clash near Betinuya, a small village south of Ramallah, and two, including a 12-year-old girl, in Sair near Hebron, hospital officials said. In New York, the U.N. Security Council scheduled an urgent, Arab-requested meeting for today on the unrest.
Secretary-General Javier Perez de Cuellar expressed “acute concern” over the continued killing of unarmed Palestinians. Ibrahim Kareen, publisher of the Palestine Press Service, called the closure order “another act of repression. Israeli officials are trying to impose a complete blackout on what is happening in the occupied territories.”
He said police told him the agency was being closed in part because it was funded by the Palestine Liberation Organization, an allegation he denied. Kareen vowed he would continue providing information to foreign journalists: “All we need is a telephone.” A general strike was observed today in Israel’s Arab towns, east Jerusalem and the West Bank.
Dozens of mounted police and foot patrols moved through east Jerusalem’s main Salah Edin Street. In Nazareth, the village where tradition says Jesus grew up, Arab activists today monitored the effectiveness of the general strike.
“We’ve been sitting in this car since 4:30 a.m. and everything has gone according to plan,” Suheil Diab, head of the local strike organization, told the AP. “This is the most successful strike we have ever had.” About 900 Arabs have been arrested in east Jerusalem since Dec. 8, Israel radio said.
The same dispatch as the Kerrville and Indiana papers, and this one runs two paragraphs the others cut. Ibrahim Kareen was told the agency was being closed in part because the Palestine Liberation Organization funded it, which he denied, and he said he would go on giving information to foreign correspondents anyway: All we need is a telephone.
Israeli soldiers kill Arab woman; key Palestinian press service closed
Associated Press
RAMALLAH, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Israel today closed a key Arab information service and its soldiers shot and killed a Palestinian woman and wounded three family members in their home in the occupied West Bank. Hospital officials said three other Arabs were wounded in clashes today, an annual day of violent protest in the occupied territories.
Israeli officials hoped their ability to control unrest today might signal the end of nearly four months of violent Arab protests. Eight police officers swept into the Arab-owned Palestine Press Service in east Jerusalem and ordered it closed for six months under 1948 emergency regulations.
The service is the only Arab information agency and has been a critical source for journalists since Israel ordered the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip closed Monday. The move was one of several measures taken by Israel in an effort to block major rioting to mark Land Day, an annual day of demonstrations against Israeli land confiscation.
Six Arabs were killed in a Land Day protest 12 years ago. An extra 4,000 police were stationed today in Israel’s Arab sectors, including traffic police placed on riot duty. Telephone lines to Gaza remained severed, troops warned on loudspeakers that curfew violators would be shot and Gaza and the West Bank were closed to most outside traffic.
Only the territories’ 65,000 Jewish settlers were permitted to travel freely. The tight security failed to prevent a killing in Deir Abu Mashal, a West Bank village 20 miles northwest of Jerusalem, according to hospital officials and a report by the Palestine Press Service made moments before it was closed.
Troops entered the home of Wajalah Rabir, 50, while she and her family were eating breakfast, and fatally shot her in the head, Ramallah Hospital officials told The Associated Press in a telephone interview. A visitor to the hospital quoted Mrs. Rabir’s 17-year-old daughter Zeinab as saying the soldiers came in and asked if there were any men in the house.
The visitor said the girl told the troops no men were home, but they entered anyway. The visitor, who spoke on condition of anonymity, quoted the girl as saying a soldier shot one brother who started to run. Other family members then lunged toward the troops, who opened fire on the family. The hospital officials said Mrs.
Rabir was killed and her husband and two sons were shot and were in serious condition. The officials, who have been banned from speaking to journalists, insisted on anonymity. The army confirmed the woman was killed and three people were wounded.
The fatality brought to 120 the number of Palestinians who have been killed by Israelis since the unrest in the occupied lands began Dec. 8, according to U.N. figures. One Israeli soldier was also killed during that time.
Three other Palestinians were wounded today in the West Bank — one in a clash near Betinuya, a small village south of Ramallah, and two, including a 12-year-old girl, in Sair near Hebron, hospital officials said. In New York, the U.N. Security Council scheduled an urgent, Arab-requested meeting for today on the unrest.
Secretary-General Javier Perez de Cuellar expressed “acute concern” over the continued killing of unarmed Palestinians. Ibrahim Kareen, publisher of the Palestine Press Service, called the closure order “another act of repression. Israeli officials are trying to impose a complete blackout on what is happening in the occupied territories.”
He said police told him the agency was being closed in part because it was funded by the Palestine Liberation Organization, an allegation he denied. Kareen vowed he would continue providing information to foreign journalists: “All we need is a telephone.” A general strike was observed today in Israel’s Arab towns, east Jerusalem and the West Bank.
Dozens of mounted police and foot patrols moved through east Jerusalem’s main Salah Edin Street. In Nazareth, the village where tradition says Jesus grew up, Arab activists today monitored the effectiveness of the general strike.
“We’ve been sitting in this car since 4:30 a.m. and everything has gone according to plan,” Suheil Diab, head of the local strike organization, told the AP. “This is the most successful strike we have ever had.” About 900 Arabs have been arrested in east Jerusalem since Dec. 8, Israel radio said.
Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin said on Tuesday night that more than 4,000 Palestinians were being held in Israeli jails, including some held without trial under six month detention orders. The figure was 25 percent higher than the one Rabin gave last week.
Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir said on Tuesday that those Israeli Arabs who take part in demonstrations today will be punished.
The fullest of the three printings and the only one that ran on a front page. It is also the only one whose headline uses the word Palestinian for the press service rather than Arab. Beside it on the page: Michael Dukakis winning Connecticut, and a photograph of mothers running from tear gas in Panama City.
Violence intensifies in West Bank, Gaza; four killed
The Washington Post, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — The occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, sealed off to forestall violence on this traditional day of Arab protest, were swept yesterday by unrest as Israeli soldiers fatally shot four Arabs and injured 60 others in some of the worst violence since the Palestinian uprising began 15 weeks ago.
Despite government claims that restricting residents and closing off the area to journalists would inhibit violence, military officials said there were major incidents in at least 23 locations. Witnesses said the army in the West Bank used more aggressive tactics and more firepower against rioters than in the past.
Three soldiers and three Jewish settlers also were reported injured. “There is no question that there were more clashes, they were more violent and more spread out,” said a military spokesman of yesterday’s violence, which brought to at least 116 the number of Palestinians killed since Dec. 9. One Israeli soldier has been killed.
By contrast, hundreds of thousands of Israel’s Arab citizens inside the so-called “green line,” delineating Israeli proper from the West Bank, staged a generally nonviolent general strike, and thousands demonstrated peacefully to mark Land Day, which commemorates the killing of six Arab protesters by Israeli police in 1976.
The army further tightened its grip on news from the territories by closing down the Palestine Press Service, an Arab-owned, Jerusalem-based news agency of activist journalists that served as a major source of quick information and reports to foreign correspondents and Western diplomats in Israel.
The violence began before dawn this morning outside the West Bank village of Deir Abu Mashal near Ramallah, according to the army’s account. A military jeep was disabled by spikes hidden on the main road and ambushed by stone throwers. The soldiers claimed pistol shots were fired at them from nearby trees.
Soldiers claimed they were attacked by an ax and club-wielding mob when they chased demonstrators into the village. They reported one soldier was hurt but because of press restrictions its account could not be verified.
Land Day, 1988. The paper says plainly that it cannot check the army’s account because of press restrictions, and reports in the same column that the army had just closed the Palestinian news agency the correspondents relied on.
· The New York Times · page front page; the story is marked “Continued on Page A8, Column 3”
4 Palestinians Die in Day of Protest Against Israel
By FRANCIS X. CLINES
SAKHNIN, Israel, March 30 — Four Palestinians were shot to death by Israeli forces in the occupied territories today as Arabs staged a widespread protest strike despite heightened security. Israeli officials said that at least 70 other people were wounded, mostly by gunfire, in clashes with Israeli soldiers and police officers.
The clashes occurred as Arabs observed Land Day, the commemoration of the killing of six Palestinian Arabs in northern Israel 12 years ago in protests over land seizures by Israel. In addition to the protests in the occupied territories, Arab citizens of Israel held their own demonstrations and marches to mark Land Day.
There was also a nationwide Arab sympathy strike, pledging solidarity with the Palestinians who were sealed off in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip by special three-day curfews and border controls. The gatherings in Israel were peaceful. Israel put thousands of extra policemen and soldiers on duty for Land Day.
It also shut down for six months the Arab-owned Palestine Press Service, which has been a major source of information on the daily clashes since the Palestinian demonstrations against Israeli occupation began 15 weeks ago. Many foreign journalists relied on the agency’s reports to supplement the information provided by the Israeli Government.
The closing represented the latest move by the Israeli authorities to bar news coverage of the protests, in which at least 111 Palestinians have been killed, along with one Israeli soldier.
Those reported killed today by Israeli gunfire were a woman in Deir Abu Mashal, a village northwest of Jerusalem, and three young men, in the villages of Shuyukh, Yamun and Burqa, all on the West Bank. Three Israeli soldiers were wounded today, as were three Israeli civilians, according to the army. But few details
Israeli Arabs demonstrating in honor of Land Day yesterday in Arab town of Taibe.
As violence builds in the occupied territories, Israeli Arabs embrace the Palestinians as ‘our people.’
By Ze’ev Chafets
ON PEACE DAY IN JAFFA, VICTOR Tayar learned something about his neighbors. “It was a Monday afternoon, about 3 o’clock,” said the burly Tayar, sipping coffee in the restaurant he owns and recalling the general strike staged by Israel’s Arab citizens on Dec. 21, 1987. “I heard that the Arabs were holding a demonstration and I was curious.
I mean, the Arabs of Jaffa have never been very political.” Tayar, a Jew, walked over to Yefet Street, not far from the Ottoman clocktower that is the chief landmark of Tel Aviv’s decaying twin city. “I couldn’t believe my eyes,” he said. “There must have been 1,500 people out there.
And they were angry.” … “We were always Arabs first, then Israelis,” said Anan Safadi, an anchorman on Israel’s Arabic television. “But since 1967, a third identity has begun to surface — Palestinian. That identity is still third for most of us, but it is growing.” NOWHERE IS THIS MORE APPARENT than in Beit Safafa, located on the southern outskirts of Jerusalem.
The minarets of the village’s mosques were visible from the living-room window of the house I lived in for many years. But I had never set foot in Beit Safafa, until this past February. … Following the war of independence, it was divided down the middle; half was ceded to Israel by Jordan.
A fence was built, guard posts were set up and the residents of the two sides were separated for 20 years. Those on the upper slope became Jordanians; their cousins down below were transformed into Israelis. “The fence ran along that road,” said Chalad Aliyan, a lifelong resident, pointing to an invisible line that he can see only too clearly.
“In those days we could only meet our relatives there on the most important festivals. It was a terrible situation.” … “What can I do?” he asked plaintively, in heavily accented Hebrew. “I have received some threats from people, but my store is across the line, and if I close, I will have problems from inside.” … ARAB RAGE Continued from Page 20 apparent irony.
“I will tell you the truth,” Aliyan continued. “We have an impossible situation. The Arabs see us as Jews and the Jews see us as Arabs. Sometimes even our relatives on the other side of the village laugh at us and call us ‘Zionists.’
” Although Beit Safafa has been reunited for 20 years, significant differences remain between the residents of the two sides. The village has only one school, but two separate student bodies. Students from the Israeli side are taught an Israeli curriculum; those from the West Bank follow a Jordanian course of study.
Students on different sides of the school are taught different versions of the same subjects and events. Recently, for example, the Palestine National Covenant — the charter of the Palestine Liberation Organization — has been introduced as a subject in the Israeli Arab school system; but no mention is made of it in the Jordanian side of the school.
The “West Bankers” of Beit Safafa carry Jordanian passports and many of them work and travel in the Arab world. Aliyan’s brother-in-law Abdulrachman was raised on the Jordanian side of Beit Safafa, and recently returned after several years in Kuwait.
Although he was 11 years old when the village was reunited, he still speaks only rudimentary Hebrew and is uneasy around Israelis. “If I go inside I feel afraid,” he said. “I try to stay on our side of the line.” “For me it is the opposite,” said Aliyan.
“I have an Israeli license plate on my car and I have been stoned in the West Bank. What am I supposed to do, drive around with a kaffiyeh on my head?” Despite the differences between the town’s Israeli and West Bank residents, there are growing signs of unity in Beit Safafa.
During a recent demonstration, six young men were arrested for clashing with the police; two of them were from the Israeli side. Abdulrachman considered this natural. “If we are all one people, then what happens on the outside should happen on the inside,” he said simply. Aliyan frowned but he didn’t contradict him. “But are you all one people?”
I asked. The mukhtar of Israeli Beit Safafa paused before he answered. “One people? Of course,” said Chalad Aliyan. “Abdulrachman is a Jordanian citizen and I am an Israeli citizen. But we are all Palestinians.”
TWENTY YEARS AGO, when Israeli leaders like Golda Meir still denied the existence of a Palestinian people, such a declaration would have been considered radical, even subversive. Today, most Arabs consider it a simple statement of fact.
Before 1967, the Israeli establishment tended to think of the nation’s Arab citizens as separate — and somehow different — from the rest of the Arab world. That changed when the Six Day War brought Israel’s Jews into contact with the more than one million Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza.
“After 1967, most Israelis began to see us the same way they see the Palestinians in the territories, as aravim — Arabs,” said Anan Safadi, the journalist. Safadi also believes that the recent uprising in the territories has reinforced the Israeli Arabs’ self-image as Palestinians.
In the last Knesset elections, in 1984, the Arab vote was almost evenly divided between non-Zionist parties — the Communists and the P.L.O.-oriented Progressive List for Peace — and Zionist parties, primarily the Labor Party. The rise of Palestinian consciousness today is most clearly visible among the Labor Party Arabs.
Once considered Uncle Toms by other Arabs and by Jews, many of them now sound remarkably like the more radical activists of the anti-Zionist camp. “The day of the nice Arab in Israeli politics is over,” said Mohammed Watad, sitting in his Knesset office. Not so long ago, Watad himself was considered the very model of a nice Israeli Arab.
As a boy, he belonged to the Arab Pioneers, an offshoot of a left-wing Zionist movement. In 1971, he wrote a play, in Hebrew, entitled “Dukium” (“Coexistence”), that was produced by the Haifa Theater. Ten years later, he was elected to Israel’s parliament as a candidate of the dovish, socialist Mapam Party.
“I wanted to change things from the inside,” he said, in flawless Hebrew. Today, Watad, the advocate of coexistence, is an angry
Right: Chalad Aliyan, an Israeli Arab from the village Beit Safafa, and his wife, Samira. “We have an impossible situation,” he says. “The Arabs see us as Jews and the Jews see us as Arabs.” / Below: Jabar Asaqla, an Arab student leader in Israel. “Twenty years ago, people didn’t dare call themselves Palestinians.
JERUSALEM — Israeli troops shot six Palestinians to death Saturday in the single most lethal day of the 16-week-old Arab uprising in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, the army confirmed. The toll Saturday reflected a much more deadly pattern of disturbances, which military sources linked to newly aggressive tactics on both sides.
The new deaths raised to at least 133 the number of fatal Palestinian victims of the violence since it began Dec. 9. One Israeli soldier has also been killed. Fourteen of the Palestinian deaths have occurred in the past four days, and 30 have occurred in the past 12 days. Military sources said several factors accounted for the accelerating trend of fatalities.
One was the reinstatement announced at a Cabinet meeting March 20 of an army policy allowing troops to fire without warning at firebombers. The change means that a “Molotov cocktail” in the hands of a demonstrator is considered, for response purposes, to be the equivalent of a rifle.
Also, the army last week announced a policy of reacting more quickly and firmly against demonstrations, particularly in remote villages. That policy went into effect in connection with planned protests March 30 and coincided with an unprecedented order declaring the territories to be closed military zones.
For three days, residents were confined to their homes or villages, and media access to the areas was banned. While the closure order was lifted Friday, the fast response policy continues, army sources said, and that is another reason for the higher casualty toll, particularly during the last four days.
Speaking after soldiers killed four Palestinians and wounded more than 50 others last Wednesday, the West Bank military commander, Maj. Gen. Amram Mitzna, said some of the clashes “would not have occurred had we not, at our own initiative, gone into villages and patrolled.”
Also, military sources said, the Palestinians are engaging in ever more daring attacks on patrols.
A masked Palestinian holds another Palestinian suspected of collaborating with Israel. The crowd beat the man Saturday in Bethlehem as more violence rocked the occupied West Bank.
JERUSALEM, April 4 — A poem by a leading Palestinian writer has set off a furor in Israel, touching on a primal fear shared by almost all Israelis.
Addressed to “you who pass between the fleeting words,” Mahmoud Darwish's poem, in an English translation in the Jerusalem Post, says: Live where you wish but do not live among us It is time for you to get out and die where you wish but do not die among us.
It ends with the lines: Get out of our land our continent, our sea our wheat, our salt, our sore our everything, and get out of the memory of memories. It is the “our everything” that rubs a raw nerve for Israelis. Mr.
Darwish, 50 years old, who is in charge of cultural affairs for the Palestine Liberation Organization's executive committee, is regarded as a moderate within the nationalist organization. He has frequently called for coexistence and dialogue between Israelis and Arabs.
Appetite for Land Feared Yet the four-stanza poem, which first appeared in The Seventh Day, an Arabic-language weekly published in Paris, says “get out” 10 times in 52 lines. It has strengthened Israelis' fears that the Palestinians will not be satisfied even if they attain an independent state in the occupied territories, that they want Haifa and Tel Aviv as well.
The poem has fueled the arguments of right-wingers, who oppose territorial compromise, and also raised doubts among leftists who favor talks with the Palestine Liberation Organization. Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir referred to it last week in a speech in the Knesset, Israel's Parliament, and it has been the subject of editorials, commentaries and letters to the editor.
“I fear this poem by Darwish is liable to give the right the Knesset seats it needs for a possible majority in the elections,” the Israeli writer Haim Guri said in the newspaper Davar. “The poem returns us to the true demons. It speaks truth; poems do not lie.” Mr. Darwish was born in a village in the Galilee region, in what is today northern Israel.
He was a member of the Israeli Communist Party, and in 1970 left the country for a conference in Moscow, never returning. He lived in Egypt and Lebanon and now resides in Paris. Only From Occupied Territories Contacted recently by an Israeli journalist, Mr. Darwish said he had been misunderstood.
All he meant by the poem, he said, was that Israel should “get out” of the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip. “Maybe it's not so clear,” he said. “In a song it's hard to say precise things. So I emphasize: Only the territories captured during the Six-Day War, not the state of Israel.”
One of the most scathing attacks on the poem came from an unexpected source, Amos Keinan, an Israeli writer who has been a consistent critic of the Government's policies. “What is so terrible,” Mr.
Keinan wrote, “is that all those thousands of Israelis, who were asleep until now and only because of the uprising started wondering if the time hadn't come to start talking with you, now may decide there is nothing to discuss with you, except through the barrel of a gun.”
Netanyahu resigns as U.N. envoy; protests Shultz-PLO meeting
To seek Knesset seat
Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Tel Aviv
TEL AVIV (JTA) — Benjamin Netanyahu, who resigned last week as Israel’s ambassador to the United Nations in order to run for the Knesset, began his election campaign as a militant Likud-Herut hard-liner only minutes after tendering his resignation to Foreign Minister Shimon Peres.
Dropping his role as diplomat, he launched blistering attacks on the United Nations, where he had served since 1984; on the American Administration, which he accused of active engagement in direct negotiations with the Palestine Liberation Organization; on Secretary of State George Shultz’s Middle East peace plan, and on his erstwhile colleague, Yossi Beilin, the political director general of the Foreign Ministry.
Foreign Ministry officials, who are aligned with Peres and his Labor Party, sharply criticized Netanyahu. He only waited a few minutes before changing from the coat of a diplomat to one of a political hack,’ a former colleague said.
He was denounced for his attacks on former colleagues and the surprise and haste with which he quit his U.S. post at a time when Israel has been under constant attack by the Arab bloc and their allies for its policies in the administered territories.
Netanyahu is considered close to Premier Yitzhak Shamir and is very popular among conservative thinkers, particularly those in the Shamir-Moshe Arens camp… While Netanyahu’s entry into the political arena was greeted enthusiastically by Likud Knesset members, some Herut old-timers appeared to resent his instant leadership within the party “without having to go through the lengthy term of work in the local [party] branches.”
Netanyahu is likely to get a spot among the first 10 names on the Likud election lists, which virtually assures him of a seat in the next Knesset. Some observers suggested that the haste of his resignation might indicate a Likud decision to call for early elections.
Netanyahu, who said when he announced his resignation that he hoped for a place on the Likud list in the Knesset elections scheduled for next November, charged that Shultz had been influenced by “all sorts of Arabist officials in the State Dept.”
He said that the secretary, who is now in Israel to resume shuttle diplomacy in the region, had “crossed the Rubicon with his very dangerous” peace plan and his meeting last weekend with two members of the Palestine National Council which Israel, unlike the United States, does not differentiate from the PLO.
Netanyahu accused Beilin, a close associate of Peres, of drumming up support for the international conference idea which is part of the Shultz plan and is favored by the Labor Party.
He had good words only for former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, who he said had warned Beilin that acceptance of an international conference meant shoving Israel back to its pre-1967 borders. According to Netanyahu, Beilin’s response to Kissinger was, “So what?”
Beilin promptly denied the charge… The 38-year-old former envoy had high praise for the “greatest [American] columnists, senators and the Jewish might” in the United States who opposed the Shultz peace initiative. Many of those senators and columnists are of a far right-wing, conservative bent.
“Benjamin Netanyahu announced his resignation as Israel’s envoy to the United Nations last week.”
A Jewish news agency reporting the start of Netanyahu’s domestic political career, and printing the criticism of him from his own foreign ministry.
JERUSALEM — A poem by a leading Palestinian writer has set off a furor in Israel, touching on a primal fear shared by almost all Israelis.
Addressed to “you who pass between the fleeting words,” Mahmoud Darwish's poem, in an English translation in the Jerusalem Post, says: Live where you wish but do not live among us It is time for you to get out and die where you wish but do not die among us It ends with the lines: Get out of our land our continent, our sea our wheat, our salt, our sore our everything, and get out of the memory of memories It is the “our everything” that rubs a raw nerve for Israelis.
Darwish, 50, who is in charge of cultural affairs for the Palestine Liberation Organization's executive committee, is regarded as a moderate within the nationalist organization. He has frequently called for coexistence and dialogue between Israelis and Arabs.
Yet the four-stanza poem, which first appeared in The Seventh Day, an Arabic-language weekly published in Paris, says “get out” 10 times in 52 lines. It has strengthened Israelis' fears that the Palestinians will not be satisfied even if they attain an independent state in the occupied territories, that they want Haifa and Tel Aviv as well.
The poem has fueled the arguments of right-wingers, who oppose territorial compromise, and has also raised doubts among leftists who favor talks with the PLO. Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir referred to the poem last week in a speech in the Knesset, Israel's parliament, and it has been the subject of editorials, commentaries and letters to the editor.
“I fear this poem by Darwish is liable to give the right the Knesset seats it needs for a possible majority in the elections,” Israeli writer Haim Guri said in the newspaper Davar. “The poem returns us to the true demons. It speaks truth; poems do not lie.” Darwish was born in a village in the Galilee region, in what is today northern Israel.
He was a member of the Israeli Communist Party, and in 1970 he left the country for a conference in Moscow, never returning. He lived in Egypt and Lebanon and now resides in Paris. Contacted recently by an Israeli journalist, Darwish said he had been misunderstood. All he meant by the poem, he said, was that Israel should “get out” of the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip.
“Maybe it's not so clear,” he said. “In a song it's hard to say precise things. So I emphasize: only the territories captured during the Six-Day War, not the state of Israel.” One of the most scathing attacks on the poem came from an unexpected source, Amos Keinan, an Israeli writer who has been a consistent critic of the government's policies.
“What is so terrible,” Keinan wrote, “is that all those thousands of Israelis, who were asleep until now and only because of the uprising started wondering if the time hadn't come to start talking with you, now may decide there is nothing to discuss with you, except through the barrel of a gun.”
Poem by a Palestinian writer fans Israelis’ fear for their land
JERUSALEM — A poem by a leading Palestinian writer has set off a furor in Israel, touching on a primal fear shared by almost all Israelis. Mahmoud Darwish's poem, in an English translation, ends with the lines: Get out of our land our continent, our sea our wheat, our salt, our sore our everything, and get out of the memory of memories.
It is the “our everything” that rubs a raw nerve for Israelis. Darwish, in charge of cultural affairs for the Palestine Liberation Organization's executive committee, is regarded as a moderate in the PLO. Yet the poem has strengthened Israelis' fears that the Palestinians will not be satisfied even if they attain an independent state in the occupied territories.
The poem has fueled the arguments of right-wingers, who oppose territorial compromise. Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir referred to it last week in a speech. “I fear this poem by Darwish is liable to give the right the Knesset seats it needs for a possible majority in the elections,” Israeli writer Haim Guri said. “The poem returns us to the true demons.
The last of three articles on the people of the Israeli-occupied territories focuses on each side's moderate factions.
By John P. Wallach / Hearst News Service
JERUSALEM — While Palestinians and Israelis wreak violence upon one another, there are those on each side trying to reach out across the growing abyss that divides their two peoples.
They are the moderates, those who reject the policies that have led to warfare between stone-throwing Palestinian youths and gun-toting Israeli troops in the West Bank and Gaza, which Israel captured in 1967. According to rough estimates, they may represent 40 percent of the Israelis and perhaps half of the Palestinians.
These are the Israelis who reject their government's contention that sovereignty over the occupied land must remain forever in Israeli hands. These are the Palestinians who reject the Arab belief that the territories can be “liberated” only by force.
It is not easy being a moderate of any shade in this land where death and terror and rigid political stances have ridden high since the uprising began four months ago. Consider the example of Ziad Abu Zayyad, 48, a Palestinian journalist who publishes a weekly newspaper in Hebrew called Gesher.
The name means bridge, and Zayyad, who started the paper in 1986, says he hopes to convince readers that “neither the Arabs nor the Jews can solve their problem by defeating the other side” and that “there is no option except a peaceful political settlement.”
Gesher publishes editorials by Palestine Liberation Organization leaders and eyewitness accounts of Palestinians being beaten by Israeli troops in order, Zayyad says, “to expose the Israelis to what they don't find in their own newspapers.” Zayyad has tried to circulate his paper widely, but newsstand owners won't accept it.
They have been pressured, he says, by Orthodox Jews and what he calls “nationalist fanatics” who see the paper as a devious effort to turn the Israeli public against the government. So Zayyad distributes his paper by mail, and it has a circulation of only 1,200 inside Israel. Palestinian moderates also face pressure from other Palestinians.
Hard-liners have broken bones of some moderates for meeting directly with Israelis. Still, Zayyad travels to kibbutzim, Israeli collective settlements, to engage in panel discussions with their leaders. “Maybe we in the occupied territories could learn something from the Israelis about their suffering in the Nazi period,” he says.
“If you tell ordinary Arabs that the Israelis are afraid of the Arabs, they'll never believe you.” Zayyad advocates either the creation of a “democratic state in all of Palestine where Arabs and Jews would owe their loyalty to the state and not (to any) religion” or the creation of a separate Palestinian state.
[series logo, not a photograph: the word "Palestine" above a Star of David containing a crescent and star, above the words "BETWEEN THE LINES"]
The Palestinian uprising in Gaza and the West Bank of the Jordan has opened many eyes that were closed, not only in those unhappy territories under military occupation but here and in Israel. It has done little yet to solve the almost unsolvable, and in the absence of great leaders, it may even deepen disagreement on what is to be done.
Consider the following poem, translated in the Jerusalem Post, which merits reading to the end: O those who pass between fleeting words From you the sword — from us the blood From you steel and fire — from us our flesh From you yet another tank — from us stones From you tear gas — from us rain Above us, as above you, are sky and air So take your share of our blood — and be gone Go to a dancing party — and be gone As for us, we have to water the martyrs’ flowers As for us, we have to live as we see fit. [… the poem continues for a further 45 lines, not reproduced here — see the scan] O those who pass between fleeting words!
Here speaks, even in translation, a considerable poet. His name is Mahmoud Darwish. He is a Palestinian. He is 50. He is director of cultural affairs in the executive committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization. He has, in the past, called for dialogue between Israelis and Arabs, and coexistence. Yet at the very least 10 times in 52 lines, he has said “get out!”
Taxed by shocked Israeli liberals, he explained that he was talking only about the West Bank and Gaza — “. . . I emphasize: Only the territories captured during the Six-Day War, not the state of Israel.” Not even all Israeli liberals believe him, and whatever Darwish meant, most Palestinians will read his poem as a passionate exhortation for Israelis to depart.
In their occupied cities, refugee camps and exiles, Palestinians have been naive for 40 years in clutching at the dream of dislodging an Israel that has most of the guns, most of the money, and lives with a desperate fear from a persecuted past.
Even its Western critics, given the inherited guilt of indifference when 6-million Jews died in Nazi camps, could not stand by again while Jews are driven into the sea. Israel’s permanence comes not from some divine right or a 2,000 year-old claim that logically is more remote than Mexico’s claim to California or the Iroquois’ claim to New York.
Nor does it depend on anyone else. Israel exists. With a rare combination of desperation and chutzpah, Europe’s Jews established their “facts on the ground” and for 40 years have defeated every attack by both the local inhabitants and outside Arabs. Israelis now have the bomb, and they are not going to leave. But not only Palestinians are naive.
So are even Israeli liberals if they expect that 40 years of defeat and occupation have produced a nation of “nice” Palestinians who will sit down gratefully and talk calmly and rationally about getting back only part of the West Bank and Gaza, which in turn are only about 15 percent of the old British Palestine mandate.
Even those who would be willing are likely to become fewer and more radical in the current struggle. Israeli liberals are likely to become fewer themselves as some are driven back into a bitter neo-conservatism by their realization of the emotion in Darwish’s poem and the testimony of Palestinian feelings like those reported in David Grossman’s poignant book The Yellow Wind.
What none of this changes is reality, not only the reality of Israel’s existence, but the reality of a Palestinian nationalism that has found its voice and inspiration in the uprising that began 16 weeks ago. They will not “be gone” either. Israel may suppress them temporarily, but in trying to crush them utterly will only wound itself as badly as it wounds the Palestinians.
The only alternative short of damnation for both peoples remains a coexistence both can live with. That awaits a leader, in Israel or the Arab world or the United States, who can bring it about.
Cal Thomas [set beside a portrait photograph of the columnist, in the standing column slug rather than as a conventional byline line]
GAZA CITY, Israeli-Occupied Gaza — They would not like being called “boys,” but to one old enough to be their father, that is exactly how many of these Israeli soldiers look. Television has done these soldiers a disservice, failing to show the true source of the provocations that have led to the violence in this embattled area. SECOND LT.
Vital Lavon, 20, says that what the television cameras and network reporters don’t show is Friday prayers in mosques where radical Muslim fundamentalists incite the masses to violence against the Israelis. “They also don’t tell you,” he says, “that (Palestinian) adults encourage young children, aged 11 to 13, to throw rocks and bottles at the (Israeli) soldiers.
They do this for two reasons. First, it is more dramatic on television. Second, the adults know that the children can get away with more than they can.” TELEVISION ALSO fails to report the contents of the declarations issued by the “United National Leadership of the Uprisings,” as the clandestine leadership of the rebellion calls itself.
They include instructions for building fire bombs, attacking Israeli patrols and conducting ambushes. Much of the world defends the Palestinians on grounds that Israel denies them their rights. But there are certain important facts that remain under-reported. First, conditions in the camps, though they are shabby, have been overstated.
And those conditions would be much better if the Arab states had shared some of their trillions of dollars in oil profits with their Arab “brothers” in Gaza and the West Bank. SECOND, THE PLO threatened with death Palestinians who moved from the territories, or who accepted better housing from the United Nations Relief Work Agency (UNRWA).
From 1971 to 1987, every Arab country voted in the U.N. General Assembly for a resolution that called on Israel “to desist from the removal and resettlement of Palestine refugees in the Gaza Strip ...” By contrast, Israel since 1970 has been the only country working to improve the living conditions of the refugees. In 1987 alone, Israel contributed $29 million to UNRWA.
Third, unemployment among those living here is between 2 and 3 percent. In Israel, unemployment is between 5 and 6 percent. FOURTH, IT IS a fiction, though it is often repeated, that Gaza is the most densely populated land in the region. Gaza contains fewer people than Tel Aviv or Jerusalem.
As long as the Arab nations and the PLO continue their hatred of Israel, the problem of the refugees will not be solved. A new song written by Mahmoud Darwish, minister of education and culture for the PLO (and considered by a “moderate”), illustrates the point. SOME EXCERPTS: “You that pass in passing words, take your names and get out ... steal whatever you want ...
Take your portion of our blood and just get out and don’t come among us like reptiles ... we have what you don’t have, a country ... go wherever you wish, but not among us ... never ... Die wherever you want, but not among us. Go out of everything. Get out of our wounds, our land, from the sea, from everything.”
Darwish means that the Jews should get out of Israel, not just the occupied territories, and he is not alone in this view. It is the driving passion in the Arab nations. IT IS WHY the Israeli boy soldiers of Gaza and of the West Bank must oppose the violence. In the long run, the very survival of their nation is at stake.
[portrait photograph of the columnist, keyed “Cal Thomas”; no caption text]
GAZA CITY, Israeli-Occupied Gaza — They would not like being called “boys,” but to one old enough to be their father, that is exactly how many of these Israeli soldiers look. Television has done these soldiers a disservice, failing to show the true source of the provocations that have led to the violence in this embattled area. Second Lt.
Vital Lavon, 20, says that what the television cameras and network reporters don't show is Friday prayers in mosques where radical Muslim fundamentalists incite the masses to violence against the Israelis. “They also don't tell you,” he says, “that (Palestinian) adults encourage young children, aged 11 to 13, to throw rocks and bottles at the (Israeli) soldiers.
They do this for two reasons. First, it is more dramatic on television. Second, the adults know that the children can get away with more than they can.” Television also fails to report the contents of the declarations issued by the “United National Leadership of the Uprisings,” as the clandestine leadership of the rebellioncalls itself.
They include instructions for building fire bombs, attacking Israeli patrols and conducting ambushes. Much of the world defends the Palestinians on grounds that Israel denies them their rights. But there are certain important facts that remain under-reported. First, conditions in the camps, though they are shabby, have been overstated.
And those conditions would be much better if the Arab states had shared some of their trillions of dollars in oil profits with their Arab “brothers” in Gaza and the West Bank. Second, the PLO threatened with death Palestinians who moved from the territories, or who accepted better housing from the United Nations Relief Work Agency (UNRWA).
From 1971 to 1987, every Arab country voted in the U.N. General Assembly for a resolution that called on Israel “to desist from the removal and resettlement of Palestine refugees in the Gaza Strip ... ” By contrast, Israel since 1970 has been the only country working to improve the living conditions of the refugees. In 1987 alone, Israel contributed $29 million to UNRWA.
Third, unemployment among those living here is between 2 and 3 percent. In Israel, unemployment is between 5 and 6 percent. Fourth, it is a fiction, though it is often repeated, that Gaza is the most densely populated land in the region. Gaza contains fewer people than Tel Aviv or Jerusalem.
As long as the Arab nations and the PLO continue their hatred of Israel, the problem of the refugees will not be solved. A new song written by Mahmoud Darwish, minister of education and culture for the PLO (and considered by a “moderate”), illustrates the point. Some excerpts: “You that pass in passing words, take your names and get out ... steal whatever you want ...
Take your portion of our blood and just get out and don't come among us like reptiles ... we have what you don't have, a country ... go wherever you wish, but not among us ... never ... Die wherever you want, but not among us. Go out of everything. Get out of our wounds, our land, from the sea, from everything.”
Darwish means that the Jews should get out of Israel, not just the occupied territories, and he is not alone in this view. It is the driving passion in the Arab nations. It is why the Israeli boy soldiers of Gaza and of the West Bank must oppose the violence. In the long run, the very survival of their nation is at stake. Cal Thomas is a syndicated columnist.
You can write to him c/o L.A. Times Syndicate, Times Mirror Square, Los Angeles, CA 90053
In an Israel tense from its confrontation with the Palestinians, even a poem written by a Palestinian has caused an uproar. The verse, reprinted recently in an Israeli newspaper, instructs Israelis to “get out of our land, our continent, our sea . . . our everything . . . ” The nationalistic sentiments are not surprising.
The reason they have attracted so much attention is that the poem was written by Mahmoud Darwish, a man who has been widely seen as a moderate on the executive committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization. In the past Darwish has called for coexistence between Jews and Arabs. Yet his words now imply that Israelis have no place anywhere in the Middle East.
He seems to again raise the old Arab goal of driving the Jews into the sea. It is a goal that has brought endless grief to Darwish's people. Yet it also causes concern for another people, one that cannot afford to take any threat of annihilation lightly. The poet claims he meant only that Israel should withdraw from the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.
“Maybe it's not so clear,” he said. “In a song it's hard to say precise things.” This song, however, is exactly the one that Israeli hard-liners want to hear. Here is the desired proof that the Arabs want not just the occupied territories but Israel itself. Thus compromise means self-destruction.
Yitzhak Shamir, the Israeli prime minister, lost no time in mentioning the poem in a Knesset speech. It raises familiar questions for Israel. Can it trust even those Arabs who claim to be “moderates”? Does the word “moderate” indicate only that an Arab wants to get rid of Israel in 20 years instead of three? These are not questions to be dismissed lightly.
LONDON AS THE PALESTINIAN death toll in the present “uprising” in the occupied territories rises inexorably past the hundred mark, an Israeli journalist and scholar has thrown a harsh new light on the origins of the problem. He is understandably not a popular man in Israel. “People's minds have been warped by 40 years of nonsense,” said Dr.
Benny Morris ruefully after he appeared on a television chat show in Israel two years ago to explain his conclusions about the Palestinian exodus of 1948. Warped or not, people's minds were certainly made up: the switchboard of the state-run television network was jammed with protest calls.
Morris, the diplomatic correspondent of the Jerusalem Post, has bluntly asserted that the Palestinians did not leave Israel voluntarily in 1948. Nor did they just flee out of a misplaced fear that they would be massacred by Jewish terrorist groups like Irgun Zvai Leumi, which on Apr.
9 slaughtered 250 Palestinians in the village of Deir Yassin, near Jerusalem, 40 years ago this month. Their fears were real. Most of the Palestinians, said Morris, were driven out — and he had the documents to prove it.
The key source he quoted was a secret Israeli army intelligence report, dated June 30, 1948, which concluded that Jewish military action accounted for 70 percent of the Arab refugees who fled their homes between the U.N. resolution partitioning Palestine in Nov. 1947 and the beginning of June 1948.
Middle Ground Erodes as Uprising Alienates Moderates
By GLENN FRANKEL / L.A. Times-Washington Post News Service
JERUSALEM – The uprising in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, now in its fifth month, appears to be at a level of stagnant equilibrium: Israel cannot seem to smother it, while Palestinians seem unable to translate their success with stones, bottles and strikes into concrete political gains.
The death toll continues to rise, with Jewish victims beginning to join the long list of at least 131 Arab dead. But rather than creating a sense of urgency about finding a peaceful solution, the deaths only seem to harden attitudes on both sides of the conflict, eroding the sparse middle ground and heightening Israeli anger and insecurity.
Radicals on both sides feed each others’ darkest fears and fantasies, drowning out moderate voices. “There is a malignant mechanism in the conflict by which the extremists in both camps reinforce each other,” Yehoshafat Harkabi, international relations professor at Hebrew University, said recently.
“The problem for the Palestinians is where do you go from here, how do you cash in your advantages before fatigue sets in.” The situation has been particularly distressing for U.S. Secretary of State George P. Shultz, who traveled to Jerusalem last week seeking to keep alive his Middle East peace initiative.
From the beginning, Shultz’s mission has been based largely on the premise that the wave of unrest ultimately would soften the positions of both Arab and Israeli leaders and create a new opening for diplomacy. But as the violence grinds on, that opening, if it ever existed, grows ever narrower. No one gave Shultz a firm “no” last week, but no one embraced his proposals.
Instead, Israelis and Palestinians appear locked in the grip of each other’s unyielding demands and deepest anxieties. The Israelis complain that the Palestinians lack a local leadership with whom they can bargain, yet for years Israel has jailed or expelled local leaders as they appeared on the scene.
At the same time, Israel’s economic sanctions are alienating the Arab middle class, a segment of the population that could be a strong ally in reaching a political solution. The tough rhetoric of Israeli political leaders and the tough tactics of the Army feed Arab intransigence further.
For their part, the Palestinians seem captive to the politics of euphoria and, perhaps, of self-delusion. Having compelled Shultz to meet with two Arab Americans close to Palestine Liberation Organization leader Yasser Arafat, many now believe they can reach their goal of an independent state within months if only they can continue to hold out.
Others talk even of the ultimate goal of a secular state throughout Palestine – in other words, the destruction of Israel. “The thing still has not crystallized in our own heads,” said Palestinian activist Mubarak Awad. ...
Those claims are ridiculed by Palestinians, who contend that Israel has exacerbated the situation by removing any leaders who might have been able to moderate popular views. Feisal Husseini, for example, a PLO supporter widely considered one of the few activists with a popular following throughout the West Bank, has been in administrative detention since September.
Security officials branded him the leading PLO instigator in the region – but the uprising took place without him. “This is a meal cooked by the Israelis,” said Ibrahim Karaeem, referring to the lack of a coherent local leadership. He is a co-owner of the Palestine Press Service, a pro-PLO news agency that recently was ordered closed for six months by the army.
“The Israelis complain that they have no one to talk to, but in fact they have locked up anyone who might have emerged as a genuine leadership.” More than 4,000 alleged instigators and rioters are in jail, leaving the uprising sputtering but still explosive in the hands of village-level activists and the young so-called shebab or “guys.”
Palestinians, their faces covered, hurl stones toward Israeli soldiers in Nablus over the weekend. Troops later fired tear gas at the demonstrators. [credit: AP LASERPHOTO]
JAMES McCARTNEY, WASHINGTON BUREAU (left column) / By CAL THOMAS (right column, Los Angeles Times Syndicate)
[LEFT COLUMN — 'Trapped between the rocks ...' by James McCartney, Washington Bureau] JERUSALEM — It is the silence that is so ominous in the Moslem sector of Jerusalem's Old City. On a normal day at noon, before the Palestinian uprising began last December, these narrow cobblestone streets were teeming with shoppers, noisy with haggling.
But now it is noon, the sun is high, the shadows sharp. And you can hear the echo of your footsteps on the stones. The only movement is a cat in the distance down the passageway. At one point you see a three-man Israeli patrol sauntering slowly ahead, cautious and watchful, rifles at the ready. It is yet another day of a general strike in the occupied territories.
All of the Arab shops are shuttered, bleak and silent. This is not violence. This is passive resistance by Arabs to the 21-year-old Israeli occupation. The closed shops, which the Israelis have fought to keep open, are a political statement that is as much a part of the uprising as hurled stones. They help to create an atmosphere of Israel today in a state of siege.
And it does seem to be in a state of siege, psychologically if not physically. Israel does not seem to know how to respond to the massive Arab protests. Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin insists that beatings and shows of force can restore “tranquility,” to use his word.
But those tactics so far, over a four-month period, have produced only a rising death toll and a great sense of national depression. Today the government is politically paralyzed, unable to respond one way or another to the new American peace plan. No one on either the Arab or the Israeli side is sure what the future may hold.
The uprising has demonstrated that Israel is a nation confused about its own sense of destiny, uncertain about what kind of country it wants to be. The conundrum was put this way by Gad Ya'acobi, Israel's minister of economy and planning, the other day in an article in The Jerusalem Post.
“The real question is whether we will continue to be a Jewish and democratic state, at peace with ourselves and our neighbors, militarily secure and capable of devoting our national energies to economic development and social and cultural advancement,” he wrote.
“Or, conversely, whether we will be forced to expend our energies in endless conflict with ourselves and our neighbors. “This is the true controversy. All the rest is a matter of mental gymnastics.” It was not always thus. Twenty years ago, after the triumphs of the 1967 war, when the West Bank and Gaza Strip were seized, the Israelis were sure.
It was a swaggering and confident nation. It had proven by force of arms that it could not only survive, but could dominate its Arab neighbors. For 20 years, from the Israeli point of view, it has worked. They have held on to the territories, in what they have described to themselves as a benign occupation.
They have systematically placed more than 50,000 settlers in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, claiming a historic right to the conquered land. But the meaning of the uprising is clearly that the Arabs do not consider the occupation so benign. They want it to end. But they have no weapons beyond stones and anger, and the weapon of passive resistance, the weapon of silence.
Through the Looking Glass Ya'acobi likened the Israeli dilemma to that of Alice, in Alice in Wonderland. “Please tell me which way to go,” Alice begged of the Cheshire cat. “For that you have to know where you want to go,” the cat replied. “It does not matter to me,” Alice said.
“If that is the case, then it does not matter which way you go,” the cat replied, with an inexorable logic. The problem of the Israelis is that, like Alice, they do not know which way they want to go, but for them it does matter.
As Ya'acobi put it, the issue is “the character, essence, and future course of the state of Israel.” [RIGHT COLUMN — 'and hard faces of fanaticism' by Cal Thomas] GAZA CITY, Israeli-Occupied Zone — They would not like being called “boys,” but to one old enough to be their father, that is exactly how many of these Israeli soldiers look.
Television has done these soldiers a disservice, failing to show the true source of the provocations that have led to the violence in this embattled area. Second Lt. Vital Lavon, 20, says that what the television cameras and network reporters don't show is Friday prayers in mosques where radical Muslim fundamentalists incite the masses to violence against the Israelis.
“They also don't tell you,” he says, “that [Palestinian] adults encourage young children, aged 11 to 13, to throw rocks and bottles at the [Israeli] soldiers. They do this for two reasons. First, it is more dramatic on television. Second, the adults know that the children can get away with more than they can.”
Television also fails to report the contents of the declarations issued by the “United National Leadership of the Uprisings,” as the clandestine leadership of the rebellion calls itself. They include instructions for building fire bombs, attacking Israeli patrols, and conducting ambushes.
Much of the world defends the Palestinians on grounds that Israel denies them their rights. But there are certain important facts that remain underreported. First, conditions in the camps, though they are shabby, have been overstated.
And those conditions would be much better if the Arab states had shared some of their trillions of dollars in oil profits with their Arab “brothers” in Gaza and the West Bank. Second, the PLO threatened with death any Palestinians who moved from the territories, or who accepted better housing from the United Nations Relief Work Agency (UNRWA).
From 1971 to 1987, every Arab country voted in the U.N. General Assembly for a resolution that called on Israel “to desist from the removal and resettlement of Palestine refugees in the Gaza Strip.” By contrast, Israel since 1970 has been the only country working to improve the living conditions of the refugees. In 1987 alone, Israel contributed $29 million to UNRWA.
Third, unemployment among those living here is between 2 and 3 percent. In Israel, unemployment is between 5 and 6 percent. A new song written by Mahmoud Darwish, minister of education and culture for the PLO (and considered a “moderate”), illustrates the point. Some excerpts: “You that pass in passing words, take your names and get out ... steal whatever you want. ...
Take your portion of our blood and just get out and don't come among us like reptiles. ... We have what you don't have, a country. Go wherever you wish, but not among us ... never. ... Die wherever you want, but not among us. Go out of everything. Get out of our wounds, our land, from the sea, from everything.”
Darwish means that the Jews should get out of Israel, not just the occupied territories. He is not alone in this view. It is the driving passion in the Arab nations. It is why the Israeli boy soldiers of Gaza and of the West Bank must oppose the violence. In the long run, the very survival of their nation is at stake.
JERUSALEM — Despite U.S. criticism, Israel today threatened to deport more Palestinians from the occupied territories to break a 4-month-old uprising. Yesterday, Israel expelled eight Arabs to Lebanon. In another development, Israeli soldiers killed two Palestinians yesterday during clashes in the occupied West Bank.
Israel yesterday issued deportation orders for 12 other Palestinians. Among them were six Arabs from the West Bank village of Beita, where an Israeli girl and two Palestinians were killed last week.
Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir, interviewed today by army radio, said he hoped the expulsions would crush the wave of Arab rioting in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, which were captured in the 1967 Middle East war.
“POETRY MAKES nothing happen,” wrote poet W.H. Auden. In an age and country in which poetry is the precious possession of a tiny minority who are viewed by the majority as odd, possibly mad, that may seem true. But elsewhere in the world, poetry not only matters but makes things happen, as events in strife-torn Israel are now demonstrating.
Case in point: the publication of an Arab’s poem that is causing many Israeli liberals to fear that there is, after all, no way of co-existing with the Palestinians.
For years, the hope of Western liberals for peace between Israel and the Palestinians has lain with the liberal, intellectual element of the Israeli people and the politicians representing them in the ruling Knesset.
Their view and their argument have been that the Palestinian Arabs are willing to “share” Palestine with the Jews and that there are moderate elements within the Palestinian movement with whom Israel can deal. That view underlies the current, highly visible effort of U.S. Secretary of State George Shultz to broker a peaceful settlement to the violent discord on the West Bank.
But the faith of Israeli liberals in the feasibility of that scheme was rudely shattered two weeks ago, when an Arabic-language Paris weekly published a poem by a man widely regarded as one of the “moderate” voices within the Palestine Liberation Organization. The poem, entitled “Those who pass between fleeting words,” is by Mahmoud Darwish.
To most Westerners, attuned to a different sort of poetry, it sounds both vague and hifalutin. But Darwish is widely respected as both poet and political activist, and his words, especially in this seemingly political poem, are causing deep doubts within the ranks of Israeli intellectual and liberal thinkers.
The particular verses troubling them go: Live wherever you like, but do not live among us It is time for you to be gone Die wherever you like, but do not die among us For we have work to do in our land.
Israelis are interpreting the lines to mean Darwish, despite earlier hope for his moderating between rival factions, shares the radical Arab view that the Israelis are intruders on land rightfully the Arabs’ and that no peace can exist as long as the Israelis are there.
The Israeli right has always maintained that Arab thought is implacably hostile and that any sort of negotiated settlement with the Palestinians is impossible. Darwish, for his part, denies that interpretation, insisting that he meant only to urge Israel to quit the West Bank and Gaza, not Palestine altogether.
Typical Israeli reaction was summed up by a professor at Hebrew University who said: “The right has always argued that if you give [Palestinians] the West Bank they will turn it into a base of operations to attack Israel. Now it seems that prediction is being borne out.” The poem, he said, has had a “really chilling effect.”
Feeling they’ve been forgotten sparks Arab to rebel in Gaza
The Associated Press, Jerusalem
“JERUSALEM (AP) — Palestinians say a feeling they have been neglected by the world and other Arabs, statements from Israel and day-by-day frustrations of occupation led to the rebellion in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. The spark was a traffic accident Dec.
8 in which an Israeli army truck killed four Arabs near the Jabaliya refugee camp in the Gaza Strip… Anger had been building among Palestinians because they felt abandoned by Arab nations and the world community… ‘It was clear to us that we had been put on the shelf,’ said Saeb Erakat, a political science professor at An Najah University in the West Bank.
‘The message (of the uprising) is that we don’t wish to become Israelis. We are not a mere community or a minority living in greater Israel.
We are a people… and we demand our liberty and our right to self-determination.’ Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir rubbed salt in the wound by noting publicly that the Arab summit put the Iran-Iraq war ahead of the Palestinian issue… An example of the harder line could be found in the poetry of Mahmoud Darwish, an Israeli Arab living in Paris who had favored Israeli-Palestinian dialogue.
Many saw his poem ‘Those Who Pass Between Fleeting Words’ as a demand for all of Israel, not just the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip.
About the Israelis, it says: ‘O those who pass between fleeting words, Carry your names, and be gone; Rid our time of your hours, and be gone; Steal what you will from the blueness of the sea and the sand of memory.’ Sari Nusseibeh, a Palestinian intellectual who advocates a negotiated settlement, said many want all of Israel included in a Palestinian state just as some Israelis want all the land for the Jewish state.
‘The question is whether both sides are ready to settle for less than what they want,’ he said. He said most Palestinians are ready for a two-state solution, but this feeling is ‘like a comet that comes close to the earth. If one wants to use it, one has to grab it while it is there.’
He also cited the cumulative affects of 20 years of occupation on the new generation, noting that half the people of the West Bank and Gaza Strip are under 20 years old and 77 percent are under 28. For them, he said, leadership status is ‘determined by how many times you have been in jail, how bad was the interrogation and has anybody in your family died fighting.’
‘The more “yeses” to such questions the more of a leader you became within your neighborhood or community,’ he added.”
The poem itself, printed in an American paper in April 1988 and read as a demand for all of Israel. Twenty years later this archive holds four obituaries of its author in which Adel Usta, a specialist on his work, says the poem was misunderstood and mistranslated, and in which Yitzhak Shamir is reported reading it aloud in the Knesset as proof that Palestinians would not live alongside Jews. Darwish is described here as an Israeli Arab living in Paris. Saeb Erakat appears as a political science professor, years before he became the chief negotiator. The page carries a self-storage advertisement: Now Open, one month free.
“DAMASCUS, Syria — Amid chaotic scenes of scuffling and emotion, Khalil Wazir, the assassinated second in command of the Palestine Liberation Organization, was buried Wednesday alongside hundreds of Palestinians who have died in their struggle for a homeland.
But intensive diplomatic efforts failed to make Abu Jihad, or Father of Struggle, as he was known, as immediately useful to the Palestinian cause in death as he had been in masterminding activities inside the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza strip… Hanni Hassan, one of Arafat’s closest political advisers, told reporters that for Arafat to have attended the funeral would have been a ‘political event’ and Syria’s invitation for all Palestinians to return for the occasion, including those long blacklisted, ‘was not a political invitation.’” — and, in the adjoining columns, the local story the photograph belongs to: “Steven Lenoff, a Congregation B’nai Torah member who attended the rally, said ‘It’s better than desecrating a synagogue.
At least he has the guts to do it in the open instead of these spineless jellyfish who come out in the middle of the night.’ The grafitti was written sometime between 1 p.m. Saturday and 8:30 a.m. Sunday. Though Boca Raton police detectives are investigating the incidents, no suspects have been reported.
A new phenomenon about the Boca Raton desecrations, Lenoff said, was that they contained a political reference to the slain PLO leader. ‘Previously, graffiti was anti-Semitic in the religious and racist sense,’ he said.
Boca Raton Mayor Emil Danciu also spoke at the rally, saying, ‘I am apologizing for the citizens of Boca Raton to the Jewish community … let’s overcome this by loving each other more.’… Mordechai Winyarz, rabbi at the Boca Raton Synagogue, said after the rally, ‘Most of the speakers tried to emphasize that this was an isolated act of anti-Semitism.
I disagree. I believe there is enormous anti-Semitism in this country and it will emerge in the future. Everything is not fine for Jews. Everyone does not love us.’”
“Alan Darman protests outside the B’nai Torah synagogue.” Staff photo by Tracey Trumbull. The hand-lettered sign reads STOP THE GENOCIDE IN PALESTINE.
The placard is the reason this page is in the archive. The page it is printed on is a report of swastikas painted on a synagogue, and a rabbi saying the desecration was not isolated. Both are here. “Grafitti” is the paper’s.
· Chicago Tribune · page 1 (front page), jump to Section 1, page 16
Israel's pain: A war within
Arab debate splits country
By Ray Moseley / Chicago Tribune
TEL AVIV—Mina Tzemach, a Harvard-trained public opinion pollster, always has considered herself a dove in the never-ending Israeli debate over issues of war and peace. But now her convictions have been shaken badly.
She has heard Palestinians involved in the current uprising in the occupied territories say they want the return of all their former land—not just the West Bank and Gaza Strip, but Israel as well. “Maybe I was naive,” she says. “When they say they want Jaffa and Haifa, then it's a matter of life and death.
I would have been willing to give back the territories 20 years ago, but now I'm afraid we're too late. Now they want an Islamic state.” Then this soft-spoken, cultivated woman says something that for her represents a radical change of attitude. “We should have shot 30 or so at the beginning of the uprising, and then we wouldn't be having this problem,” she says.
“Everybody says this.” Tzemach reflects the troubled mood of a nation that, on its 40th anniversary, still has not found solutions or even accommodations to the oldest problem in its brief history, the problem of coexisting with a hostile Arab world. At its birth, Israel confronted the problem with a single-mindedness that carried it to a succession of military victories.
Now the battle for survival has been won, and Israel is a changed nation, fighting within itself over how to go from survival toward peace. The internal struggle has a religious as well as a political dimension.
A messianic movement, believing that it has a divinely ordained mission to create a Greater Israel taking in all the lands inhabited by Jews in biblical times, has joined hands with tough-minded nationalists who argue that the only thing the Arabs understand is force.
Manning the barricades against them are pragmatists who argue that five wars should have been enough to demonstrate there is no military solution to the conflict, that continued occupation of Arab territories is corrupting the soul of Israel and that the time has come for a compromise based on land for peace.
The country is split down the middle, finely balanced between the right-wing Likud bloc that wants to hold onto the occupied territories and the Labor Party that is prepared to yield some of them. For the past four years the two have been yoked together in a mutually antagonistic coalition that passes for a national unity government but is, in fact, incurably paralytic.
Many suggest that the mood of the country is swinging to the right. While those on the left and center of the political spectrum believe the Arab uprising has made Israelis realize that the status quo no longer is viable, for others the old fears of survival have been reawakened.
A poem by Mahmoud Darwish, the best-known Palestinian poet and a man long regarded by Israeli doves as a moderate force within the Palestine Liberation Organization, has had more impact in Israeli intellectual circles than perhaps all the stones and Molotov cocktails thrown by Arab demonstrators.
The poem contains these lines: It is time for you to be gone Live wherever you like, but do not live among us It is time for you to be gone Die wherever you like, but do not die among us For we have work to do in our land . . . So leave our country Our land, our sea, Our wheat, our salt, our wounds Everything . . .
Darwish, an Israeli Arab who lives in Paris, maintains he only meant the Israelis should leave the occupied territories, but few in Israel believe him. His poem has become a powerful weapon for those who argue that Palestinians would never be satisfied with a state limited to the West Bank and Gaza Strip. The mood of the country is perceptibly hardening.
Public opinion polls show only a minority support territorial compromise and an overwhelming majority believe tougher measures are needed to deal with the uprising. Ze'ev Schiff, military analyst for the newspaper Haaretz, said many military leaders argue, like Mina Tzemach, that the uprising could have been crushed if the army had killed 20 or 30 Arabs at the outset.
“It's not so simple as that,” he said. “This is Israel, not Iraq. Tactically, the uprising can be put down. But then Israel would not be Israel. We would have to call ourselves Iraq. “You will find people who say we should put democracy aside for awhile. But I don't think we can send democracy on vacation. The test for democracy is in a time of emergency.”
Novelist Amos Oz, a leader of the Peace Now movement, argues that Israelis who fear that the Arabs still want to drive them into the sea fail to distinguish between Arab wishes and Arab capabilities. “The name of the game is not love, or changing the yearnings of the Palestinians,” he said.
“It is making a reliable deal, politically and legally, including effective demilitarization [of a Palestinian entity]. It is not our business to force the Palestinians to change their dreams or yearnings. I can't guarantee no Israeli will dream of coming back to Nablus or Hebron,” two towns on the West Bank. The words change, but how much has Israel changed in 40 years?
In 1948, before the war that gave birth to the modern state, Jews were debating whether, and on what terms, they could live with Arabs. The old Zionist dreams have, in some ways, changed beyond recognition. Many of the Zionist pioneers wanted to create a socialist state, one that would teach lessons to the Soviet Union on how Marxism should be implemented.
Over the years, Israel has gradually turned away from socialism and adopted the ways of the capitalist West. The pioneers dreamed of a state that would safeguard the Jews from further persecution, enabling them to take their place alongside other nations. Instead, Israel has become a pariah to
Israeli soldiers in civilian clothes, their weapons slung over their shoulders, are a common sight on the streets of Jerusalem. — Tribune photo by Frank Hanes
JERUSALEM (AP) — Israel suspended press credentials for two U.S. correspondents Tuesday, saying they violated military censorship rules by reporting Israel carried out the assassination of a PLO leader.
Glenn Frankel of the Washington Post and Martin Fletcher of NBC News were required to hand over their press cards to the Government Press Office in Jerusalem… Both correspondents had quoted Israeli sources in reporting Israel’s involvement in the slaying… He said military censors usually telephone correspondents when they want to block certain stories.
“We waited for them to call us and they didn’t so we assumed all was OK. I assumed what I had was right,” Fletcher said. Frankel, 38, who has been a Post correspondent in Israel for two years, said, “It is natural that there…”
April 1988, and the mechanism is domestic and routine: censors usually telephone correspondents when they want to block certain stories. The two reporters were punished for what they did not do — wait for the telephone call.
Bethlehem, Jerusalem shops ordered closed by Israeli police
Associated Press
JERUSALEM (AP) — Police arrested Jerusalem wholesalers Monday who were said to be helping the Palestinian rebellion in the occupied lands, and soldiers confiscated identity cards of several dozen Arabs accused of inciting violence… “They are the ones who send all kinds of flour to the refugee camps,” he said.
In another development, Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir was quoted as calling for action against two American journalists who did not submit to the military censor stories about Israeli involvement in the assassination of PLO military commander Khalil Wazir.
The same day as the Fort Lauderdale headline, and here the credential suspensions are the last paragraph of a story about shopkeepers. The phrase is in another development. A reader in Wilmington learned that a prime minister had called for action against American journalists, after learning about flour going to the refugee camps.
JERUSALEM (AP) — Israel suspended press credentials for two U.S. correspondents Tuesday, saying they violated military censorship rules by reporting Israel carried out the assassination of a PLO leader. Glenn Frankel of the Washington Post and Martin Fletcher of NBC News were required to hand over their press cards to the Government Press Office in Jerusalem.
“I’m sorry we have come to a situation where such prominent journalists have to be punished,” said Yossi Ahimeir, a spokesman for Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir. “We hope it will be a clear hint for all the other journalists.”
The Israeli government has refused comment on reports that Israeli agents killed PLO military commander Khalil Wazir, better known as Abu Jihad, April 16 in Tunisia. Both correspondents quoted Israeli sources in reporting Israel’s involvement in the slaying. Under Israeli law, journalists must submit reports relating to security matters to military censors.
The government has not clearly defined security matters and leaves the submission of reports to reporters’ discretion. Neither Fletcher nor Frankel submitted their reports on Wazir’s killing to the military censor. Yoram Ettinger, head of the Government Press Office, said the suspensions would remain in effect until an investigation was completed.
He would not elaborate. As a result of the suspensions, government and army officials will no longer grant interviews and access to Frankel and Fletcher, Ettinger said. Benjamin C. Bradlee, executive editor of The Washington Post, said the newspaper would protest Israel’s move against Frankel.
NBC spokeswoman Mary Lou O’Callaghan said NBC was writing a letter of protest to the Israeli government. Fletcher, 40, who has worked in Israel for five years, said he didn’t believe he violated censorship rules. He said military censors usually telephone correspondents when they want to block certain stories.
“We waited for them to call us and they didn’t so we assumed all was OK. I assumed what I had was a government leak,” Fletcher said. Frankel, 38, who has been a Post correspondent in Israel for two years, said, “It is natural that there are conflicts between any government keeping what it considers to be secrets and a free press.
This is one of those conflicts.”
Martin Fletcher
The fullest American printing of this dispatch in the archive, and it carries the sentence the shorter printings cut. A spokesman for the prime minister says he is sorry two prominent journalists had to be punished, and then says what the punishment is for: “We hope it will be a clear hint for all the other journalists.” That is the chilling effect stated out loud by the government doing it, in an American paper, on a Wednesday. The paragraph underneath explains why a reporter cannot comply even in good faith: journalists must submit anything touching security to the censor, the government has not clearly defined security matters, and the decision about what to submit is left to the reporter. Fletcher describes what that felt like from inside — he waited for the telephone call that usually comes, it did not come, and he assumed he was clear.
WASHINGTON — The government of Israel has not denied, and tends to confirm by its silence, that it ordered the murder of Khalil al-Wazir, also known as Abu Jihad. This order, efficiently carried out by Israeli gunmen, violated Israel’s established policy not to assassinate leaders of the Palestine Liberation Organization.
It violated also the decent behavior demanded of a democratic and law-abiding government. John Kifner of The New York Times has reported that the Shamir government ordered the murder of Abu Jihad because he was “directing the Palestinian uprising in the occupied territories” of Gaza and the West Bank.
If so, the order was misconceived as well as disreputable; it set off the bloodiest day of rioting yet seen, and though the situation has calmed it may yet become more difficult to control.
This act of state murder testifies, too, to the seeming blindness of the Israeli Cabinet; it acts as if what is happening in Gaza and the West Bank is not a popular uprising against Israeli occupation but something ordered and orchestrated from the outside by the PLO.
Thus, the cabinet approaches the uprising more as a temporary problem to be handled militarily than as a fundamental challenge to the existing order. How else could the cabinet conclude, as Kifner reported, that this act of counterterrorism might “give the army time to bring things back to normal”?
But Israel is faced only superficially with a military problem for the army; the Palestinian uprising ultimately calls for a political approach.
Politically, however, the violent death of Abu Jihad also appears to have backfired on its perpetrators; the murder of the military leader and second-ranking official of the PLO has resulted in at least a partial reconciliation between the PLO and Israel’s bitter enemy, Syria, where Abu Jihad was buried.
And because his burial there and not in Jordan was a calculated PLO insult to King Hussein of Jordan, it makes the king even less likely ever to be acceptable to Palestinians as their spokesman, let alone their ruler. The American initiative unsuccessfully pushed in the Middle East by Secretary of State Shultz depended heavily on Hussein’s participation.
Now it’s even less likely that he can play a useful role on behalf of Palestinians or in easing their pressures on Israel. Some Israeli sources suggest that the murder of a well-known terrorist leader was intended to remind Palestinians of Israeli strength, to discourage potential recruits from joining the PLO and to undermine PLO morale while boosting that of Israelis.
These are weak justifications for calculated state murder, and miss the main point anyway. As Zeev Schiff, the military analyst, wrote in Haaretz: “It is a mistake to think that this is what will bring the end of the uprising. It did not begin because of Abu Jihad and the P.L.O. and its end will not come because of his death.”
Schiff added that the murder of Abu Jihad, who was regarded as a moderate within the PLO, “might allow more extreme forces to take control.” And the newspaper Hadashot raised another pertinent question: “If P.L.O. leaders are targets for bumping off, with whom, actually, do we intend to discuss the settling of the Palestinian problem?”
To an American anxious for Israel’s survival and success, and alarmed by the potential for a Middle Eastern war that could result in superpower confrontation, all of this is dismaying, but not more so than the idea of Israel’s highest, most responsible leaders deliberately approving a political assassination.
It’s true that Israel lives in a virtual state of war, surrounded by implacable enemies. It’s true, too, that one not resident in that country can hardly comprehend its pressures and dangers, or the conflicting passions they produce. It’s true, finally, that the opprobrium of outsiders sometimes takes insufficient account of realities on the scene.
Nevertheless, the good opinion of mankind is important, especially to a nation whose roots are planted in moral revulsion against the Holocaust. Law-abiding behavior is necessary to a democratic government, most particularly when that government is under challenge.
Calculated murder is terrorism’s instrument, not that of decent societies, in which it must always be illegal, inhumane, immoral. For whatever purpose, Israel should not be a party to it.
Printed the same day as the news that Israel had taken the press cards off two American correspondents for reporting the same killing. Frankel and Fletcher lost their credentials in Jerusalem for putting it in the paper without clearing it with the censor. Tom Wicker, writing from Washington and syndicated to Kansas, calls it state murder, calculated state murder and a political assassination in so many words, and nothing happens to him. The column also quotes the argument as it was being had inside the Israeli press: Zeev Schiff in Haaretz saying the killing will not end the uprising because the uprising did not begin with Abu Jihad, and the paper Hadashot asking who is left to negotiate with if PLO leaders are targets.
2 Soldiers and 3 Arabs Killed in Assault From Lebanon
By JOHN KIFNER
JERUSALEM, April 26 — Two Israeli soldiers and three Palestinian guerrillas were killed in a shooting battle today when an Israeli patrol came upon the guerrillas infiltrating from Lebanon, the army said. One of the Israelis was reported to be a battalion commander.
The attempted infiltration appeared to be part of a mounting series of efforts by Palestine Liberation Organization guerrillas from beyond the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip to mount raids into Israel in support of the nearly five months of protests mounted by Palestinians.
This was the third time in the last two months that Israeli Army patrols have caught Palestinian infiltrators, the army radio noted this evening, and only Monday, the Israeli Navy said it had sunk a small boat suspected of carrying guerrillas off southern Lebanon. [The Israeli command quoted by The Associated Press, reported that six Palestinian guerrillas who had been among 50 members of the Palestine Liberation Organization’s mainstream group, Al Fatah, had been deported.
The six were captured Feb. 7, 1987 while aboard a small cargo ship seized midway in its journey from Larnaca, Cyprus, to Lebanon. A little more than a week ago, the P.L.O. military commander, Abu Jihad, who had been in charge of the guerrilla attacks inside Israel, was shot to death in his villa outside Tunis.
Palestinians attribute to Israel, while Israeli officials refuse to comment on the matter. The most spectacular recent guerrilla raid was carried out by members of Fatah, Abu Jihad’s faction, on March 7, when three Palestinians hijacked a bus in the Negev.
The latest raid occurred April 5, when two Palestinian guerrillas were killed, one was captured and four Israeli soldiers were wounded near Mount Dov, just south of the Lebanese border. In the gun battle today, the Israeli battalion commander, identified as Lieut. Col. Shmuel Adiv, and a Bedouin tracker, Wahash Ramzi, were killed.
In Lebanon, the three guerrillas were identified by security sources quoted by Reuters as members of the Marxist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. However, two other Palestinian guerrilla groups, the Syrian-based Palestine Liberation Front and the leftist Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, issued statements asserting responsibility for the attack.
The Israeli Army said the Palestinians apparently intended to attack one of the Jewish settlements in the region. “I don’t need to catch them or speak to them.” the chief of the Northern Command, Maj. Gen. Yossi Peled, said in a radio interview. “I know what their goal was: Their goal is residents, children and Israeli settlements.” ”
A wounded Israeli soldier being carried into hospital after shootout with Palestinian guerrillas at the border with Lebanon.
Date check: No masthead on this clipping — it is trimmed to the headline, deck, byline block, photograph and three text columns. The byline block does read “Special to The New York Times”, which confirms `pub`. Nothing on the page prints a publication date; the dateline reads “JERUSALEM, April 26” and the story is written for the following morning’s paper, which is consistent with `date` (1988-04-27) but does not independently confirm it.
JERUSALEM, April 26 — The Israeli Government today withdrew the press credentials of two foreign correspondents, from The Washington Post and NBC News, as punishment for reports that had not been submitted to a military censor.
The correspondents, Glenn Frankel of The Post and Martin Fletcher of NBC News, both reported last week that the Israeli Government had carried out the assassination of Abu Jihad, the Palestine Liberation Organization’s military commander, but neither account was submitted to the censor before being sent to the United States.
The Israeli Government has never said whether it was responsible for the assassination, and officials stressed that their action today was not a statement on the accuracy of the reports. Yoram Ettinger, director of the Government Press Office, said: “Their press cards are suspended until the end of the investigation.
The meaning is not of revoking or cancellation and not expulsion, at this time.” Both men have been advised that it is possible that their press cards will not be returned. Withdrawal of press credentials does not positively prevent the two from working, and both journalists say they intend to stay at work.
But working without a press card can be quite difficult because they will not get cooperation from officials in the Government, the military or the police. “What will suffer,” Mr. Frankel said, “is my ability to report and understand Government decisions and the reasoning behind them.” Mr.
Fletcher said he was surprised by the action because he got all the information for his account from Government officials. But Mr. Ettinger said he had received phone calls “not from Israeli journalists but from foreign ones, saying, ‘You can’t punish correspondents who don’t break the law and give two who ignore the law a prize.’”
· The New York Times · page A1, Col. 1, continued on Page A10, Column 4
U.S. LOSES RULING IN WORLD COURT ON P.L.O. MISSION
ARBITRATION IS ORDERED — Enforcement Powers Lacking — Judges Want a Hearing in Move to Shut Office
By PAUL LEWIS
THE HAGUE, April 26 — The World Court ruled unanimously today that the United States must submit to international arbitration in its attempt to close the Palestine Liberation Organization observer mission to the United Nations.
The court ruled that American legislation calling for the mission to be closed had created a dispute that must be settled according to arbitration procedures laid down in the 1947 treaty governing relations between the United States and the United Nations.
Although the court lacks powers to enforce its ruling, the decision represents a setback for the Reagan Administration, which has refused international arbitration. The Administration contends that there is no dispute to arbitrate because the United States has not yet closed the mission. Administration Awaits U.S.
Ruling The Administration is asking a Federal court in New York to issue an order to close the mission in accordance with legislation approved by Congress last year. But the Administration says it will not move against the mission until the American courts give a final ruling that it is obliged to do so. The legal action may take months. In Washington, Charles E.
Redman, the State Department spokesman, said the World Court ruling was “premature because the issue is still subject to litigation here,” Reuters reported. He declined to comment further. The judgment was read in French by Judge José María Ruda of Argentina, the president of the 15-member court, formally the International Court of Justice.
Two of the judges did not attend the public session. The judgment was welcomed by the United Nations representative at the hearing, Carl-August Fleischhauer, the chief legal counsel. “It corresponds with what the U.N. Secretary General has maintained all along,” he said after the session.
“We must now wait and see what effect it has on the Administration, the Congress and the U.S. courts.” The United States was not represented at the session today, and it was absent last month when Dr. Fleischhauer presented the United Nations's case to the court. The Reagan Administration submitted a short letter at the time outlining its point of view.
President Reagan had opposed the Antiterrorist Act of 1987, the legislation seeking to close the P.L.O.'s observer mission in New York as well as the group's information office in Washington. But he signed it into law because Congress attached the legislation to a State Department spending bill that the President said he could not veto. Secretary of State George P.
Shultz has described the law as “one of the dumbest things Congress did last year.” It was reported in February that a State Department legal adviser had pressed the Justice Department to delay carrying out the legislation and to invoke arbitration under the 1947 treaty. The Justice Department was said to have rejected the suggestion.
In its ruling, the World Court was responding to a resolution approved by the General Assembly at an emergency meeting March 2, when it voted to uphold the P.L.O.'s right to have an observer mission in New York and asked the court for an advisory opinion as to whether the United States should accept international arbitration. Only Israel voted against the resolution.
The United States did not take part. The ruling today does not address the fundamental question posed by the dispute, lawyers following the case said.
That question is whether the American legislation violates the terms of the 1947 treaty, known as the Headquarters Agreement, that the United States and the United Nations signed when the organization established its headquarters in New York.
Palestinians march from Daley Plaza to demonstrate outside the Israeli consulate in Chicago
“Palestinians march from Daley Plaza to demonstrate outside the Israeli consulate in Chicago earlier this month.” Tribune photo by José Moré
“Palestinians march from Daley Plaza to demonstrate outside the Israeli consulate in Chicago earlier this month.” Tribune photo by José Moré
A photograph and its caption. A Palestinian flag and a hand-lettered placard reading “too Much Ask For” are visible above the crowd, and a portrait is carried on a board. Most of the marchers photographed are women and children.
Palestinian Youth Shot Dead By Troops on the West Bank
JERUSALEM, April 28 (Reuters) — Israeli soldiers shot dead a Palestinian youth in the occupied West Bank today when hundreds of teen-agers clashed with troops, the army said. A military spokesman said the Palestinians attacked an army patrol with stones in the village of Malek, near Ramallah.
When a youth threw a firebomb at the troops, soldiers opened fire, killing the Palestinian, the spokesman said. He said several Palestinians were arrested.
Arabs, Palestinians and Jews face each other in debate
moderated by James Goodman
“The main problem for Palestinians today is not so much centered on how much territory they will regain.
The main problem is that I as a Palestinian have constantly been seen by the West as a refugee or a terrorist or an Arab — never really addressed as a Palestinian… the facts about the Palestinian — the human side — have not been presented in this country.”
Excerpts from a two-hour debate between members of Rochester’s Arab and Palestinian community and members of its Jewish community, printed at length. Abraham Kharroubi, 44, born in what is now northern Israel, names the mechanism; across the table Kilimnick describes it from the other end — “Palestinians in my mind have not only been Palestinians but terrorists… But I’m just saying this is the perception” — and says he now understands there is another story. The paper printed both without adjudicating. Also named: Basem Ashkar, 40, born in Jerusalem, a supervisor at Ragu Foods; Nabil Kaylani, 47, professor of international relations.
JERUSALEM MANY Israelis seemed reluctant last week to talk about their Army's latest victory. For the first time, the Israeli Army sought a direct confrontation with the pro-Palestinian Party of God in southern Lebanon, killing 40 of the Shiite Moslem militiamen and losing three of their men.
The Israeli soldiers also came within a few miles of Syrian front lines in Lebanon, risking a conflict with Syria. The incursion had started as a sweep against suspected strongholds of Palestinian guerrillas in southern Lebanon.
When no such guerrillas were found, the Moslem militiamen in the area who were considered friendly to the Palestinians and hostile to Israel were sought and attacked. But as the troops were deep in battle in Lebanon, Israelis seemed to want to avoid the subject.
As Foreign Minister Shimon Peres was touring the towns in the Negev desert on Wednesday, people asked him about the troubles in the West Bank, about the Middle East peace process, about roads and water and a long list of local issues. But hardly anyone asked him about Lebanon.
Israel's Lebanon experience in 1982 so wounded the country that “most people don't even want to think about Lebanon anymore,” a senior Government official acknowledged last week. “It's just like your Vietnam,” the official explained.
“Our Lebanon is behind us, and when it comes up again, people realize it has to be done and just quietly hope it can be over as soon as possible.” Uneasiness about Lebanon seemed everywhere. When word of the attack spread, Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin promised that the troops would be home “at the very latest within 48 hours.”
And, apprised of the Defense Minister's comment, Mr. Peres was asked, “Is Rabin's 48 hours anything like Sharon's 40 kilometers?” — a reference to Israel's 1982 invasion of Lebanon. At the start of the invasion, Defense Minister Ariel Sharon promised to push no farther than 25 miles into Lebanon, then rapidly advanced his troops to the outskirts of Beirut.
Few Were Consulted [...] The Government, meanwhile, debated what to do about an NBC News report that troops were being sent into Lebanon. It was broadcast before the soldiers had actually crossed the border and had not been submitted to the military censor. Some in the Government believed that the report alerted Palestinian guerrillas so they could flee.
In Washington, the United States denounced the incursion. “We deplore this kind of violence, and we do believe that Lebanon would be best served by withdrawal of all foreign forces,” Marlin Fitzwater, the White House spokesman, said in Washington, using unusually strong language. But that criticism had little, if any, impact here.
By week's end, the incursion was over, and all the troops had returned to their bases. “I'm sure that the action will have an effect on the residents” of southern Lebanon, said the Army Chief of Staff, Lieut. Gen. Dan Shomron. But he added, “It is difficult for me to know how much of an effect.” There was one immediate result.
The Lebanese press reported that the attack had brought about a rapprochement between the Party of God and a rival Shiite faction, Amal, suggesting that now the two could work together against Israel. A Party of God spokesman in southern Lebanon vowed bloody revenge against “the Zionist enemy.”
And just a few hours after the Israeli troops had withdrawn to Israel, six Soviet-made rockets were reportedly fired into Israel's declared security zone just over the border in Lebanon.
Israeli troops advancing into southern Lebanon last week. [credit: Associated Press] [A locator map beside the photograph is labelled: MILES 0 10 / Beirut / BEIRUT-DAMASCUS H[IGHWAY] / Mediterranean Sea / LEBANON / Sidon / Maidun / BEKAA / Litani R. / MT. HERMON / SYRIA / Tyre / ISRAELI SECURITY ZONE / ISRAEL / GOLAN HEIGHTS]
WASHINGTON WHEN Congress passed a law prohibiting anyone in the United States from operating an office on behalf of the Palestine Liberation Organization, its purpose seemed clear and simple. It wanted to close the P.L.O.'s observer mission to the United Nations because it had found the P.L.O. was a terrorist organization.
But enforcement of the statute has proved much more complex, because it raises novel and delicate questions of constitutional and international law. The result has been a legal battle that could last for months.
On one side, 65 United States citizens and American organizations have united, asserting that the law infringes on their rights to hear the views of the P.L.O. at a time when public interest is high because of events in the Middle East.
The Reagan Administration is of two minds, denouncing the law as an unwise policy but defending it in court as a legitimate exercise of Congress's power. Secretary of State George P. Shultz called the law “one of the dumber things that the Congress has done lately.”
He noted that the United Nations had explicitly invited the P.L.O. to participate in its deliberations, and he told Congress last year that closure of the P.L.O. mission “would be seen as a violation of a U.S. treaty obligation” — a 1947 agreement establishing U.N. headquarters in New York.
“We are under an obligation to permit P.L.O. observer mission personnel to enter and remain in the United States to carry out their official functions” at the United Nations, Mr. Shultz said. He warned Congress that the United Nations might refer the issue to the World Court, where, he said, “We [the] United States must submit the dispute to international arbitration.”
Many people are surprised to hear the Justice Department argue that a statute enacted by Congress supersedes a prior treaty if the two are in conflict. But the Supreme Court has repeatedly upheld that principle, declaring more than a century ago that a treaty had “no superiority” over a subsequent inconsistent law.
While it may be true that Congress can abrogate a treaty by passing a law, jurists also say that statutes should be interpreted wherever possible so as not to violate the American obligations under international law. “An act of Congress ought never to be construed to violate the law of nations” if any other interpretation is possible, the Supreme Court said in 1804.
In March, the Justice Department asked a Federal District Court in New York City to order the closing of the P.L.O. observer mission. Justice Department officials say they will not take action to close the P.L.O. office until there is a decision by the Federal court in New York, which could take weeks or months.
The P.L.O. is asking the court to dismiss the case, and the Justice Department is urging a quick ruling, without a full trial. The 1987 law carries no criminal penalties. “No one is going to be arrested,” a Government lawyer said.
In a legal brief filed on behalf of Zehdi Labib Terzi, the head of the P.L.O. mission in New York, Ramsey Clark, a former United States Attorney General, declared: “If the United Sates can unilaterally and cavalierly remove the P.L.O. mission from the conversation among the peoples of the U.N. at its headquarters, it can remove any nation or participant and destroy the United Nations.”
The Justice Department maintains that Mr. Terzi “cannot claim any immunity from American law” based on the 1947 agreement because, as an observer, he is not entitled to the “privileges and immunities” of diplomats representing U.N. member states. The P.L.O.'s deputy observer at the United Nations, Riyad H. Mansour, is a United States citizen.
He contends that the new law violates his First Amendment rights to freedom of speech and association.
Zehdi Labib Terzi (left), who represents the P.L.O. at the United Natons. [credit: Reuters] [The photograph shows two men shaking hands in front of a sign reading PALESTINE LIBERATION ORGANIZATION]
“Even before I started speaking with The Elkhart Truth reporter Tom Price, I said to him, ‘Usually the American media twist the words and facts about the Palestinians and even they put words in our mouths.’ But in spite of that, in Sunday’s edition (May 8) what I feared, happened exactly, which again made me less confident in the American media.
Following I will state what has been changed or quoted out of context and I trust this time The Elkhart Truth will publish it accordingly.
1. The title: I did not and will never say that ‘Israel is disaster.’ I said that this year is the 40th year of Al-Nakba, ‘the disaster’ for the Palestinians since they had lost their land and were converted to refugees or living under the Israeli occupation and power.
2. The Palestinians of today are not the Philistines which are mentioned in the Bible since the time of Abraham. They only took their name from the old Philistine. It was the Roman Emperor Hadrian who called the land Palestine in A.D. 135, and then the population was called Palestinians after the naming of the land itself.
I believe the Palestinians are those people who remained in the land after the Jews were banned from the country by the Romans.
3. To us, the 1967 war is not the ‘six day war’ as the Israelis call it, it is the 1967 expansion war by Israel.
4. I did not say I am without a country. I said I am without a state in my country where Palestinians are treated as foreigners even in their own homeland.
5.The Elkhart Truth wrote ‘Salem rejects that (peace proposals) outright.’ Again that is not the case. I said Palestinians are ready to accept any peaceful proposal that addresses our right for self-determination. In fact, the Palestinian people are sick and tired from bloodshed and war and they are crying for a peaceful settlement for their dilemma.
6. I never used the word ‘curse’ when I spoke about the Jews. The word was put in my mouth, although it is not part of my vocabulary at all.
7. I question and reject the unconditional support which the Fundamental Christians are giving to Israel. I consider myself as a brother in faith with any Christian and I call the Fundamental Christians to consider the rights of the Palestinian people too.
8. I do not believe that the Jews are chosen or were chosen by God for any merit of them. God in the Old Testament chose the Jews to be a light for the nations. But today, according to the New Testament there is neither Jew nor gentiles, and all are one in Christ.
9. I do not advocate non-violent protests only because I am a Christian since Palestinian Muslims also advocate nonviolence. I advocate nonviolence basically because it is more effective, disarming and peaceful.
10. I did not say that I am willing to let Israel keep the old city of Jerusalem. I said that Israel wants all of Jerusalem to be their capital, while the Palestinians want East Jerusalem to be their capital. So in order to resolve this, I said that each side should compromise and each people should have the right of access to their holy shrines.
11. I did not say that I agree or advocate stone throwing per se. I said that Palestinian children, as other children in the world, have the right to enjoy life instead of throwing stones and get killed.
But since the whole world is ignoring our right for freedom and a state, and because the uprising made the world at least to recognize our problem and aspiration, then in this context, I do see stone throwing as justifiable.”
A Palestinian in Elkhart, Indiana, correcting his own local paper point by point after it interviewed him — eleven numbered corrections, including the headline, a word he says was put in his mouth, and the name of the year. He opens by saying he warned the reporter this would happen. The paper printed the correction.
Palestinians Stage General Strike, But the Territories Remain Quiet
By JOEL BRINKLEY / Special to The New York Times
JERUSALEM, May 15 — Palestinians in Israel’s occupied territories staged a general strike today, and all Arab businesses were closed. But the West Bank and Gaza Strip were quiet this weekend, even though Israelis and Palestinians alike warned that there was likely to be large-scale violence.
Both sides credited the calm to curfews in some cities, to the Israeli military presence in the territories and to the unseasonable heat. Temperatures reached 104 degrees in some areas. Israelis celebrated Jerusalem Day today, marking the date 21 years ago when the army captured the city during the 1967 Arab-Israeli war.
But Palestinians marked what they call the “day of black disaster,” also known as “catastrophe day,” for Arabs the first full day 40 years ago under Israeli rule. A leaflet put out last week by the underground leadership of the Palestinian uprising called on Palestinians to observe “a special day of anger” today.
But if the Palestinians were angry, they kept it largely to themselves. The Israeli Government today reinstated the press credentials of Glenn Frankel, a correspondent for The Washington Post. The Government Press Office took his press card last month after Mr.
Frankel wrote an account of the assassination of Abu Jihad, the military leader of the Palestine Liberation Organization, that was not submitted to the Government censor. Mr. Frankel was required to write a letter of explanation, but “it was not an apology,” he said.
The Government has not returned the press credentials of Martin Fletcher, an NBC News correspondent whose credentials were taken at the same time. A press office statement said Mr. Fletcher’s credentials were being kept because NBC News broadcast a report before the Israeli move into Lebanon that was not submitted to the Israeli censor.
The Government said today that a master sergeant involved in burying alive four Palestinians in February was sentenced to four months in jail. The sergeant, Charlie Danino, was one of three soldiers who used a bulldozer to cover four Arab youths with dirt. Villagers pulled the youths out alive, but the episode caused a storm of condemnation here and abroad.
The other two soldiers involved, both privates, had already been sentenced to jail terms of several months.
JERUSALEM — THE Israeli Army raised no objections recently when several Israeli newspapers printed an evocative photograph of a soldier confronting an angry crowd of Arabs. But military officials shut down a Palestinian newspaper for a month after it published the same photo a few days later. This was not an isolated case.
Several times in recent months Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir and other Israeli officials have reaffirmed Israel's commitment to freedom of the press, but for Arab journalists in the occupied territories these words ring hollow. Thirty Arab journalists have been imprisoned since the Palestinian uprising began in December.
Most of the dozen or so newspapers, magazines and news services in the West Bank and Gaza Strip have been closed down for at least a few days and often for much longer. Even when they are allowed to publish, the publications — whether widely read mainstream daily newspapers or polemical pamphlets — complain that censorship is heavy.
“Even things already published outside are censored,” said Maher Abu Khater, managing editor of the English-language version of Al Fajr, a weekly paper published in Arab East Jerusalem. For that, the Army censor offers no apologies. “Our considerations are not public relations,” said Lieut. Col. Avi Gur-Ari, the censor for Jerusalem. “We have to follow the law.”
One extreme left-wing Israeli newspaper, Derech Hanitzotz, was closed in February and its Jewish editors imprisoned, but not because of what they wrote, Israeli officials insist.
The Government has formally charged them with treason, in essence, saying that they had become agents of Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a hardline Palestine Liberation Organization group. The case is unusual. Unlike the Arab press, Israeli papers seldom get in serious trouble.
Israeli law says the Army can apply wholly different standards to Arab and Israeli journalists, and this is just one part of a broader paradox: While Israelis live in an open, vibrant democracy, they extend freedoms to their occupied terrorities only when those freedoms do not seem threatening.
Reading the Palestinian newspaper, Al Quds, in East Jerusalem.
Slain Palestinian reporter was tortured, brother says
Bernard Edinger, Reuters, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — Palestinian journalist Hassan Abdel Halim, found dead last week after disappearing while researching fraudulent land purchases on the West Bank, was kidnapped and tortured before he died, his brother said yesterday. Also yesterday, Israeli police retracted their statement made Monday that it appeared Halim had been killed while making a bomb.
Halim’s decapitated and decomposed body was discovered Friday by Arab shepherds at Beit Horon, near the West Bank town of Ramallah. Police Deputy Superintendent David Cohen, who is heading the investigation into Halim’s death, said police were not ruling out the possibility that he was abducted and murdered. “He was definitely killed by a bomb.
The rest we don’t know and all possibilities remain open,” Cohen said. He said police who told reporters Halim was killed while making a bomb had been misunderstood. The journalist’s brother, Mohammed Abdel Halim, told a news conference there were signs of torture on the body when it was discovered — burns, missing teeth and missing fingernails.
He said Halim, 36, had been wearing different clothes when he disappeared two months ago than when his body was found. Cohen said the mutilations could have been caused by the explosion that pathologists say killed Halim.
Palestinian journalists said yesterday they suspected Arab middlemen working with Israeli contractors of having killed Halim because of his investigations of allegations that Arab land was being fraudulently purchased for Jewish settlements on the West Bank.
Halim had been reporting for the East Jerusalem newspaper Al-Fajr, which is openly supportive of Palestine Liberation Organization leader Yasir Arafat. Police charged two Israelis this month with swindling potential Jewish buyers of land in the West Bank.
At the news conference yesterday, Ziad Abu Ziad of the Arab Journalists Association of the Occupied Territories said: “What we are asking the police is to study whether Hassan’s death was not stage-managed, whether the bomb was not planted on him and then detonated.”
The Palestinian reporters said that Halim was partially blind and that it was inconceivable that he had been handling explosives.
A Palestinian journalist killed while investigating land sales, and the police account retracted within days. His brother, his colleagues and the police are all quoted, and they do not agree.
Students, Army Clash; West Bank Schools May Close Again
Daily News Wire Services, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — Israel arrested two Palestinian reporters and a writer in a continuing crackdown on Arab journalists, Arab newspapers reported today… Ahmed Hassan Hawari, 17, was killed when he was shot in the head by an Israeli officer in the village of Sebastiya near Nablus.
The army said he was about to throw a cement block at troops from a terrace when he was shot… The east Jerusalem newspaper Al Shaab said the army arrested Bader Taleb Yassin Meky, a sports reporter for the paper, at his home in Jericho.
Al Ittihad, another Arabic-language paper, said Samir Subayhat, a freelance reporter from the West Bank town of El Bireh, and Muhammad Ayub Abu-Hadrus, a writer and teacher from the Gaza Strip town of Khan Younis, were seized at their homes. A spokesman for the army said he could not confirm the reports or explain why the writers were arrested.
At least 30 journalists have been arrested and 20 of them have been jailed without charges or trial for up to six months, according to Al Haq, an Arab human rights organization.
WASHINGTON — Peace is a form of reason. In the Middle East, however, reason is a reed. It is bested, on a regular basis, by memory, desire and dream. The minds and the hearts of Israelis and Palestinians are cluttered by sacred histories, by traditions of pain, by superstitions about the other, that feel more precious than politics, more pressing than diplomacy.
And so George Shultz has failed, as others have before him, in the admirable attempt to arrange an exchange of territories for peace. Those who begin by looking backward, said Nietzsche, sometimes end by thinking backward. In the Holy Land, history is the friend of war. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is a conflict between versions of the past.
The common Palestinian understanding of Jewish history, like the common Jewish understanding of Palestinian history, is riddled with malice and myth. I see Jewish intellectuals trying to correct the malice and the myth in the Jewish community. I see Palestinian intellectuals trying to fan the malice and the myth in the Palestinian community.
Most outrageous of all, surely, is the Palestinian attitude toward the Holocaust. It cannot be allowed to pass unchallenged. Item. “I hate Hitler more than any of you,” Prof.
Said Erakat of al-Najah University, near Nablus on the West Bank, admonished the Jews in the audience at the “Nightline” debate between Israelis and Palestinians in Jerusalem. “I was on his list, too. . . . The Hitlerian evil forces took over 10 European countries between 1939 and 1944. No one spoke for improvement of life.
Or a just occupation.” Item. “We have had no Holocaust to protect us with the world’s compassion,” writes Edward Said about the Palestinians in his book “After the Last Sky.” Item. “There is no people that has not suffered, to some extent, from the Nazi threat to the future of mankind,” observes Emile Habibi, a prominent Palestinian writer and a leader of the Israeli Communist Party, in an article called “Your Holocaust, Our Catastrophe,” in the Tel Aviv Review.
“In the eyes of the Arabs,” he went on, “the Holocaust is seen as the original sin which enabled the Zionist movement to convince millions of Jews of the rightness of its course. . . . If not for your — and all of humanity’s — Holocaust in World War II, the catastrophe that is still the lot of my people would not have been possible.”
These, then, are the Palestinian propositions. The fate of the Palestinians under Israeli occupation is like the fate of the Jews under Nazi occupation. The Palestinians are the victims of the Nazis. The Holocaust was a boon for Zionism. The Jewish state exists as a result of the Holocaust. The effrontery! The analogy between Israelis and Nazis is obscene.
It is made by people who know nothing about Israelis or nothing about Nazis. Or, if it is not based on ignorance, the analogy is based on an ideological inflammation that is the enemy of decency and peace. The Jews of Europe greedily would have exchanged their predicament for the predicament of the Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza. “Certainly,” Mr.
Habibi notes responsibly, “it is impossible to compare the suffering experienced by the Jews of Europe and the suffering of the Palestinian people.” The Palestinians are occupied. The Jews were burned in ovens.
Palestinians who pity themselves for the destruction of the Jews in Europe, who maintain that the Palestinians pay the price, should come with a little irony. For it is they, the Palestinians, or many of them, and much of the Arab leadership in the 1930’s and 1940’s, who were Hitler’s little helpers in the Middle East.
The Arab “courtship of the Axis,” as one historian calls it, is well known. In 1941, for example, King Farouk of Egypt informed Hitler, through an ambassador in Teheran, that “he was filled with admiration for the Führer” and was “certain that the Germans are coming as liberators.”
And the Mufti of Jerusalem, Haj Amin Mohammed al-Husseini, met with Hitler and Mussolini, secured from them a commitment to assist in “the elimination of the Jewish national home in Palestine,” and assured them that “the Arab nation everywhere feels the greatest joy and deepest gratification” at their successes in the war.
The Arabs, of course, wished to use the Germans against the British, who ruled Palestine. The Arab apology, when there is an Arab apology, is that the alliance with Nazism was tactical. But what is the nature of a nationalism that makes a tactical alliance with absolute evil? The 1940’s were a Palestinian trauma, which Jews have not really understood.
But Jews may be forgiven for feeling that the 1940’s were also a Palestinian disgrace. The Palestinians deceive themselves, furthermore, if they believe that the Jewish state owes its existence to Hitler. For one thing, Jewish nationalism was more than half a century old when the Jews of Europe were exterminated.
The Jews had already drawn their conclusions from the anti-Semitic centuries of Europe; Hitler was only the end. More to the point, the Jewish state owes its existence to nobody but the Jews who brought it into existence.
When Hitler rose to power in 1933, when the partition of Palestine was proposed in 1936, when a Jewish state and a Palestinian state were approved by the United Nations in 1947, all the institutions of a Jewish state were already there. Israel was in place when the United Nations “created” it. Palestine was not.
The Palestinians might have remarked upon this Jewish self-reliance. It is certainly the case that the Holocaust hastened the legitimacy of Jewish self-determination and Jewish sovereignty in the eyes of the world. But let us be perfectly candid. The price — for the Jews, not for the Palestinians — was too high.
Which Jew would not prefer to have fought the Arabs and the British for another hundred years and seen six million men, women and children live? If Jews could reverse our history in this century, we would. It is true that the Holocaust gained the Jews, in Edward Said’s words, “the world’s compassion.” It should have.
But we would have done very well, thank you, without the compassion and without the Holocaust. The Jewish state is not a compensation for the Jewish catastrophe. (There are many Jews, too, who need to be reminded of this.) In no way was the Holocaust a boon to anything Jewish. It furthered only the frailty of the Jewish people.
The 20th century has been a century of darkness for the Jews, and the shaft of light called Israel does not quite dispel the darkness. Do not envy us our Holocaust, then, for we despise it. In the aftermath of Auschwitz, thousands of stateless, smashed-up Jews languished in refugee camps. They were not played for political purposes by their leaders.
They were brought to safety. To save those Jews, the Zionist leadership settled for less. It restrained itself, and agreed to the partition of the land. There are now thousands of stateless Palestinians in refugee camps. They, too, can be brought to safety, but only if their leaders, too, settle for less. In the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, less is not more.
Palestinian Firebomber Shot Dead As Israel Says Attacks Continue
JERUSALEM, June 15 — Israeli soldiers came under attack by Arabs with firebombs in three incidents today. In one of the attacks, near Bethlehem, troops shot and killed a 21-year-old Palestinian, the army said. A second Palestinian, also armed with a firebomb, was wounded.
The shooting occurred after Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin, reacting to a surge in firebombings in the occupied territories and inside Israel, told the Cabinet on Sunday that soldiers and civilians were free to shoot Palestinians seen holding the devices — which typically consist of a container filled with a highly flammable liquid such as gasoline.
The wick is lighted and the container thrown. An army spokesman said that the Palestinian killed, Nidal Ibrahim Hassan, was shot to death in the village of Battir near Bethlehem, after troops “clearly identified that two Arabs were going to throw firebombs at them.” A curfew was imposed in the village.
His death brought to at least 183 the number of Palestinians who have died since the uprising in the occupied territories began in December. Other Attacks Reported In the city of Gaza and near Hebron on the West Bank today, firebombs were thrown at army patrols but caused no damage.
In Jerusalem, a firebomb exploded harmlessly in a Jewish neighborhood, and the police arrested several Arabs in the area. On Tuesday night, two army officers patrolling on the West Bank were hospitalized after a firebomb thrown at their jeep ignited. The army said they were severely burned. The village of Beit Omar, where the attack happened, was also placed under curfew.
It was the second attack in a week in which army officers were burned by a firebomb; no one has died. The same night, leaders of a group of Jewish settlements on the West Bank reported as many as a dozen such attacks. Many Israelis say they believe that the recent surge in firebombings is a new phase of the uprising.
They also blame Palestinian arsonists for a recent wave of fires that have destroyed 400,000 acres of forest and pasture land. Israelis say these two tactics are meant as an alternative to Arab street demonstrations, which are waning. In the West Bank, the Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem; Palestinians observed a general strike today.
The army also closed all the schools in the occupied territories for two days after “students took part in strikes and demonstrations in recent days,” a spokesman said. More than 400,000 pupils are affected. A Videotape on Brutality The army today unveiled a new videotape that warns soldiers not to use brutality toward Palestinian protesters or foreign journalists.
Called “The Camera Sees Everything,” the tape included clips from American television newscasts showing troops beating young Palestinian men and children, vandalizing Arab property and using captured Palestinians as shields to ward off stone-throwing demonstrators.
“The viewer is not used to such things and such pictures,” the narrator of the videotape explains, “and is shocked by them and feels sympathy for the victim.” The narrator warns: “Don’t give the camera the opportunity to catch you in an extreme act. Brutality is illegal, and the military censor cannot delete such scenes.”
Israel's iron fist policy deals a damaging blow to peace hopes
BY RONALD R. STOCKTON
I HAVE just spent four weeks in Israel interviewing dozens of leaders, officials and activists and studying the uprising (intifada) against the Israeli occupation of Gaza and the West Bank. What I found was not encouraging. Jerusalem is a city in crisis.
Outside each gate of the Old City, there are three to 30 soldiers; snipers sit on the ramparts; the Via Dolorosa is often empty and usually has more soldiers than tourists; armored personnel carriers are positioned at key intersections, and military jeeps patrol major streets every four to five minutes.
I did not speak to a single person — Israeli or Palestinian — who is optimistic about the future. Most feel that the worst is yet to come. The closest approximation of optimism is the view — held by both Jews and Arabs — that “we can hold out longer than they can.” The uprising has won the support of traditionally conservative Palestinians.
Intellectuals, students, labor leaders and refugees are known for dissent, but the radicalization of shopkeepers, simple farmers, villagers and older people was unexpected. The uprising now includes almost all elements of Palestinian society. The Israeli government's “iron fist” strategy has backfired.
As one Palestinian activist told me, “(Israeli Defense Minister Yitzhak) Rabin is our best recruiter.”
Closing the West Bank and Gaza schools for four months freed hundreds of thousands of Palestinian children for demonstrations; the “beatings” policy touched almost every family in the territories and sent parents and grandparents into the streets to defend their children; mass arrests put thousands of village activists together into camps where they use their time to plan for the future; and the confrontation policy of the army — for example, entering villages to remove black flags of mourning — radicalized normally complacent hamlets.
If an enemy of Israel had plotted to promote policies so damaging to Israel it could hardly have done better.
A masked Palestinian waves the Israeli-banned PLO flag during a protest in the Gaza Strip. (REUTER)
Iron fist printed flat, in a paper’s own headline voice, with no quotation marks around it: by June 1988 the phrase had stopped being something Israel called its policy and become what the policy was called. The Herald Sun in January had kept the marks (CP-1988-005). What the headline measures the policy against is peace hopes, not the people it was applied to. The boxed pull quote beside it was held here as a record of its own until the page was read whole on 14 November 2026 and the sentence found on it twice — in the box, and in the body as the second of the writer’s findings. The reporter is the only person in it, and the finding is that nobody he met could see a way out.
A masked Palestinian waves the Israeli-banned PLO flag during a protest in the Gaza Strip
“A masked Palestinian waves the Israeli-banned PLO flag during a protest in the Gaza Strip.” Reuter.
Two young men, one masked, one flag, one raised hand. The caption gives the flag a legal status — Israeli-banned — and the man neither a name nor an age. Same page as CP-1988-020, whose boxed pull quote this archive held separately until the two were merged. The credit line reads Reuter, singular, as the agency styled itself.
JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli troops clashed with Arab youths in at least seven towns and refugee camps in the occupied territories yesterday. Hospital officials and radio reports said a 17-year-old Palestinian was killed. An army spokeswoman denied the youth was shot by soldiers and said troops used only tear gas and rubber bullets to break up the protests.
The death brings the number of Palestinians killed to 215 since an uprising against Israeli rule in the occupied territories began Dec. 8.
Four Israelis have also been slain… In the West Bank town of Jenin, Nael Yousef Muhamad Hamaisi died of a gunshot wound in the head after a demonstration by students erupted into a stone-throwing clash with soldiers, Israel radio and hospital officials said… In southern Israel, about 50 Israeli writers and artists staged a demonstration near the Ketziot military prison, calling for the release of the 2,500 Arabs detained without trial, many of them held in the prison. “If the people got their rights then the artists, Jewish and Palestinian, would not have to come here,” said Suleiman Mansour, a Palestinian artist.
“We demand the release of Palestinian prisoners, but our biggest demand is self-determination and a state for the Palestinian people.” Israeli author Amos Keinan said several of those jailed were Palestinian writers who were among the 25 Arabs and Jews signing a symbolic “peace treaty” at a June ceremony in Jerusalem.
Not an arts story. A painter’s argument about rights, reported from a protest outside a prison, inside a wire roundup of one day’s fighting. The headline names no killer; the Palestinian who died is named in the eighth paragraph.
In “The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, 1947-1949,” (Cambridge University Press), Mr. Morris offers little comfort to adherents of either view. His volume is a case study in the fallibility of memory. Mr. Morris relies chiefly on documents of the time, which can distort or lie.
But, as the author found, they do so far less than interviewees recalling controversial events 40 years later. Such interviews “revealed enormous gaps of memory, the ravages of accepted wisdom, prejudice and political beliefs and interests.” Mr.
Morris, The Jerusalem Post's diplomatic correspondent, dug into recently declassified state papers in Israel, Britain and the United States. He has pieced together, with clinical detachment, what happened in hundreds of cities and settlements.
Here is the story that emerges: This exodus began after November 1947, when Arabs rejected a United Nations plan for partitioning Palestine, then under British rule. It was at first a confused, uncoordinated flight from big cities. Most evacuees belonged to better-off urban families, and many left hoping to return after a successful Arab intervention.
Then in the spring of 1948 came the main emigration, 200,000 to 300,000 Arabs, in the wake of a British pullout and Israel's proclamation of independence. Did Arabs flee, as is often asserted, after hearing broadcast instructions from Arab armies preparing to invade? Mr.
Morris found no evidence of such broadcasts — nor, for that matter, of orders reaffirming earlier appeals to stay put. The absence of public instructions, especially during a massive movement from Haifa, is to the author telltale evidence of ambivalence among Arab leaders reaching for reasons to justify armed intervention.
JERUSALEM (UPI) — Soldiers attacked by a stone-throwing mob shot and killed a 17-year-old West Bank Arab Sunday as Palestinians observed the second day of a two-day general strike marking the seven-month anniversary of the Palestinian uprising.
Throughout the day, soldiers clashed with Palestinians in at least six towns and U.N.-run refugee camps in the occupied territories, Palestinian sources said.
Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin, meanwhile, told American rabbis that a majority of Israeli soldiers he has spoken with would prefer to serve along the Lebanese border than in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip even though more troops have been killed there. Since Dec.
9 when the uprising began, one soldier has been killed in the territories compared with 10 along the border, Rabin said. “When you ask them why, they say ‘There we felt we are soldiers. Here it’s more complicated,’” Rabin told the annual convention of the Rabbinical Council of America.
The 7-month-old Palestinian uprising is the type of conflict “in which you see on one hand the hatred and on the other the pain you cause to the victims,” Rabin said. Palestinian sources said in Sunday’s clashes, one Palestinian was shot and killed, two were wounded by live ammunition and 12 by rubber bullets fired by Israeli security forces.
The clashes came on the second day of a Palestinian general strike in the occupied territories and Arab East Jerusalem called for by the underground committee organizing the Palestinian uprising to mark the July 9 anniversary of the 7-month-old revolt.
Palestinian shops were closed, but reports from the territories indicated some Arab workers in parts of the West Bank went to work in Israel. Before dawn, Palestinians erected roadblocks with stones and burning tires on the main road to Nablus near a refugee camp and attacked an army patrol with stones, an army spokesman said.
Soldiers opened fire and wounded a 17-year-old Palestinian who later died in a hospital, the spokesman said. The army clamped curfews on the camp and at least six other towns and refugee camps in the occupied territories. At least 207 Palestinians and three Israelis have been killed since the uprising erupted Dec. 9 in Jabalia refugee camp in the Gaza Strip.
Monday, July 11, 1988. The agent is named in the first two words, which most of these headlines do not manage. What the last four words do is supply the reason inside the same sentence: the man who was killed was in a mob, and the mob was throwing stones. He is also an Arab, six months into an uprising these same papers were already calling Palestinian.
JERUSALEM (AP) — Palestinian singers usually known for sentimental love songs have found a new kind of music: political anthems calling for violent revolt against Israel and glorifying young Arab stone-throwers.
Israeli authorities have blacklisted the songs on grounds they incite rebellion, but they are distributed secretly in recorded form and are heard widely in Arab east Jerusalem and the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip. The current No. 1 hit, “Insurrection,” urges Palestinian children to “rise up with your stones.”
It booms from music stores and portable radios in east Jerusalem when Israeli police or soldiers are not around. In Bethlehem, junior high school students came from classes recently chanting the refrain of the song “Intefadeh” (Arabic for uprising): “With firebombs and stones, I make my revolution.”
Arab youths also gather around stereos at home and sing along to ballads such as “Palestinian,” whose lyrics say: “I fight for my identity, I fight for freedom, I fight for spring.” In Jerusalem, police have raided several music stores, confiscated tapes of songs about the uprising and charged store owners with incitement.
In the occupied territories, troops confiscate tapes of banned song if they find any during house searches, but they don't look specially for them, said a military official. “We act whenever we can, but this is not our first priority. We are too busy with other things.” Since the Dec.
8 start of the uprising, dozens of militant, anti-Israeli songs have surfaced in the occupied lands. They range from mournful ballads about the more than 200 Palestinians killed in clashes to stirring anthems glorifying teen-age stonethrowers. Intefadeh songs are recorded in makeshift studios in Jerusalem, taped from Syrian television or smuggled from Arab countries.
Some tapes are sold under the counter in music stores, while others are copied at home and passed along to friends. Among the two most popular song collections are “I Am The Son of Gaza” by the Syrian band “Palestine Roots” and “Intefadeh” by Riad Awad, a singer from the West Bank city of Tulkarem.
“Palestine Roots” also sings “Insurrection,” while Awad has recorded “Palestinian.” Awad and others are part of the so-called “Western wave,” a new musical style popular among the young. It builds on Arabic music traditions, but also uses synthesizers and electrical guitars, placing greater emphasis on rhythm.
Palestinian music store owners say that before the uprising, sentimental love songs were the top sellers. “Today, 95 percent of my customers ask for intefadeh or nationalistic songs,” said an east Jerusalem music store owner. His store was raided earlier in June after he played “Insurrection” over loudspeakers.
Police confiscated dozens of intefadeh tapes and charged the owner with incitement. He was released on bail the equivalent to $1,300. Since the raid, he has restocked his supply, keeping the tapes in two small boxes under the counter. But he no longer plays intefadeh songs loudly, and scrutinizes customers to make sure they are not undercover police officers.
Distribution of intefadeh songs is often unorthodox. A friend of the Jerusalem-born Palestinian singer Mustafa Kurd recently made the rounds of the music stores, carrying a single copy of Kurd's latest tape “The Children of Palestine.” Shopowners who wanted it made copies in their stores.
At a music store in Jerusalem's walled Old City, “Insurrection” was booming from loudspeakers one recent day, mingling with the sales pitches of street vendors in the cobblestone street. Riot police patrolled nearby, but took no notice. “I play this because I believe in it,” said the store owner. “When the cops come, I just change the tape.”
He added that he was free on bail after being charged with incitement following a raid. Military officials said all songs and written material calling for violent revolt against the 21-year Israeli occupation are illegal and subject to confiscation.
However, the officials added, military officers have not compiled a list of banned material because they can't keep up with the number of intefadeh songs flooding the occupied territories. But the songs also have their critics in the Palestinian community. Hussein Barghouti, a literature teacher at the West Bank's Bir Zeit University, said most have little to do with art.
“Art is buried in these songs. What remains is sloganism,” said Barghouti who writes songs for a Jerusalem band. “As a human being, you are touched only on a superficial ideological level.” He added that the quality of the songs might improve if they were written by the young activists confronting Israeli soldiers with their stones and slingshots.
“But the kids are too busy to write songs,” he said.
The same Associated Press dispatch the Thousand Oaks Star printed on 29 July 1988 under the headline New tune. That printing stops at the Israeli military official's quotation. This one runs the whole dispatch, including the store owner who changes the tape when the police come and the Birzeit literature teacher who gets the last word.
To the Editor: In “Why the Palestinians Left” (Editorial Notebook, July 7), Karl Meyer comments on a book by Benny Morris that purportedly addresses two questions: “Were Arabs expelled from Israel as part of a predetermined Zionist plan?
Or did Palestinians flee voluntarily as instructed, in the expectation that they would return after invading Arabs had driven Jews into the sea?” Mr. Meyer, after asking, “Did Arabs flee, as is often asserted, after hearing broadcast instructions from Arab armies preparing to invade,” reports Mr. Morris found “no evidence of such broadcasts.”
In “Semites and Anti-Semites” (New York, 1986), Bernard W.
Lewis quotes (page 270) from the memoirs of Khalid al-Azm, Prime Minister of Syria in 1948-49, listing the factors that led to Israel's success: “Fifth: the summons of the Arab governments to the population of Palestine to leave the country and take refuge in the neighboring Arab countries... this collective flight served the Jews and strengthened their position without effort. ...
Since 1948 we have been demanding the return of the refugees to their homes when we ourselves were the ones who induced them to leave them. ... We doomed a million Arab refugees, by calling on them and insisting that they abandon their land, their homes, their work and their occupations, and we made them unemployed and homeless.” Is this not evidence?
Is the Morris book then really, as Mr. Meyer states, careful “about the origins of Israel's endless conflict with Palestinian refugees”?
HESKEL M. HADDAD / President, World Organization for Jews from Arab Countries
To the Editor: Karl Meyer writes (“Why the Palestinians Left,” Editorial Notebook, July 7) that Benny Morris, an Israeli journalist in a book called “The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, 1947-49,” found no evidence of Arab broadcasts giving instructions to the Palestinian Arabs to leave their homes in the wake of the Arab armies' invasion of Palestine.
Where could Mr. Morris find such evidence? Are there transcripts of such broadcasts, or are there tapes? If there are such transcripts or tapes they are not available in the Israeli, British and American archives of declassified state papers where Mr. Morris looked.
I can state categorically that when I was in Baghdad in 1948, the broadcasts were blaring from all Arab radios, shortwave and other, imploring the Arab population of Palestine to leave their homes in the war zones to return with the victorious Arab armies and claim not only their homes but also Jewish homes.
After Israel had won and the Arabs faced a fait accompli of the war's outcome, we Jews of Iraq were told that we were being thrown out of Iraq to vacate our homes for the Palestinian Arab refugees.
Maybe some of the Arabs left in confusion, maybe some left in fear, but there is no question that the Arab governments and the Arab radios made such broadcasts imploring Arabs in Palestine to leave their homes. There is no question that we Jews of Arab countries were forced to leave our homes, though we were not involved in the war.
To end this bitter dispute, the refugee problem, both Jewish and Arab, should be resolved, and there should be a resettlement of the Palestinian Arab refugees so that they can live in homes and lead a respectable life, and in order that the Palestinian problem can be diluted and become more amenable for a political solution.
Soldiers Kill an Israeli Arab, First to Be Slain in Uprising
“Troops killed an Israeli Arab teenager, the first Israeli Arab killed in the seven-month-old Palestinian uprising… Palestinians identified the victim as Mohammed Ahmed Taher Sayef, from Arara, outside the West Bank.”
The headline needs the category to make the death newsworthy: not the first teenager, the first Israeli Arab. He was seventeen, he was from Arara inside Israel, and he was shot near Tulkarm in the West Bank. The army names nobody; the Palestinians name him.
“The purpose of the Israelis is not only to subdue, cow and reduce the populations but… Said loaded his eloquent two-hour talk with descriptions of the Israeli treatment of…”
Edward Said, speaking for two hours in Hanover, New Hampshire, in the first year of the intifada, reported by Peggy Grodinsky of the Valley News. A staff-written story — not a wire pickup — in a small New England daily, and the subject is a Palestinian explaining how Palestinians get described.
Palestinian singers express spirit of revolt in political anthems
Associated Press
JERUSALEM (AP) — Palestinian singers usually known for sentimental love songs have found a new kind of music: political anthems calling for violent revolt against Israel and glorifying young Arab stone-throwers.
Israeli authorities have blacklisted the songs on grounds they incite rebellion, but they are distributed secretly in recorded form and are heard widely in Arab east Jerusalem and the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip. A recent No. 1 hit, “Insurrection,” urges Palestinian children to “rise up with your stones.”
It booms from music stores and portable radios in east Jerusalem when Israeli police or soldiers are not around. In Bethlehem, junior high school students came from classes recently chanting the refrain of the song “Intefadeh” (Arabic for uprising): “With firebombs and stones, I make my revolution.”
Arab youths also gather around stereos at home and sing along to ballads such as “Palestinian,” whose lyrics say: “I fight for my identity, I fight for freedom, I fight for spring.” In Jerusalem, police have raided several music stores, confiscated tapes of songs about the uprising and charged store owners with incitement.
In the occupied territories, troops confiscate tapes of banned song if they find any during house searches, but they don’t look specially for them, said a military official. “We act whenever we can, but this is not our first priority. We are too busy with other things.”
Music as contraband. Cassettes blacklisted for incitement, sold under the counter, played in east Jerusalem shops when Israeli police or soldiers are not around, and confiscated from music stores whose owners are charged. The paper prints the banned lyrics, which is how they survive here: With firebombs and stones, I make my revolution, and, from a ballad called simply ‘Palestinian’, ‘I fight for my identity, I fight for freedom, I fight for spring.’ The last word goes to an unnamed military official explaining the enforcement policy: troops take the tapes if they find them during house searches, but they don’t look specially for them… We are too busy with other things.
JERUSALEM (UPI) — Arab and Israeli moderates expressed shock and criticism at the arrest of a leading pro-PLO Palestinian who was given up to six months’ administrative detention for allegedly coordinating the nearly 8-month-old Palestinian uprising.
Faisal Husseini, 48, the leading spokesman in the West Bank for the mainline Fatah movement of the Palestine Liberation Organization, was arrested Sunday during an early morning raid at his home in East Jerusalem, the third time he was put in administrative detention in less than two years.
Police also raided Husseini’s Arab Studies Society and ordered it closed for one year, with a police spokesman saying the organization had served “to promote (Fatah’s) aims and attain the objectives of the uprising.”
Husseini, who has been out of prison for less than two months, also was accused of inciting and coordinating the nearly 8-month-old uprising in the Israeli-occupied territories. But police refused to give any specific examples of Husseini’s involvement.
“I was shocked, really, when I heard the news in the morning,” said Radwan Abu Ayyash, a prominent Palestinian journalist who also was recently released from administrative detention. “I think it is not fair. It shows that they do not want to deal with the moderates.”
Israeli elder statesman Abba Eban, who said he did not personally know Husseini, criticized the excessive use of administrative detention in his case, saying: “I much prefer that if anyone transgresses the law, then people should have their day in court. ... It’s like a Turkish party. They are out and in and in and out.”
Palestinian and Israeli sources said Husseini’s detention, during which he can be held initially without charge or trial for up to six months, shows that the government fears moderate Palestinians who envision a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
“The road to peace is being obstructed by detentions, human rights obstructions,” said Hanna Siniora, editor of the Palestinian newspaper Al Fajr. “(Husseini) should be encouraged instead of jailed.”
While some observers have argued that Husseini is merely PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat’s mouthpiece on the West Bank, others — including the Israeli government — believe he coordinates PLO activity in the occupied territories. It is the third time in less than two years Husseini has been placed under administrative detention.
For five years before his jail terms he was forbidden outside his home from sunset to dawn and had to report to police weekly… Husseini, the son of Palestinian war hero Abdel Kader el-Husseini who was killed in the 1948 Arab-Israeli war, was released June 9 from nine months’ administrative detention.
Under Emergency Security Regulations dating from the time of the British Mandate over Palestine, the military can detain anyone for up to six months without charge or trial. The detention order can be renewed… East Jerusalem merchant Mustafa Abu-Zahara also was placed under administrative detention Sunday.
The archive already holds the death of Abdel Kader el-Husseini in April 1948 and the funeral that thirty thousand people attended. This is his son, arrested for the third time in two years under regulations inherited from the British Mandate. “Schocks” is the paper’s.
WASHINGTON, Aug. 3 — Yasir Arafat says that before he became chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, he was a wealthy, free-spending tourist who traveled through Europe and lived the good life. In an interview in the September issue of Playboy magazine, Mr.
Arafat provides an account of his early years, with new details of the life he led before founding Al Fatah, one of the main groups in the P.L.O., in the 1950’s Mr. Arafat said he “visited a lot of places on vacations” as a tourist. “I was once very rich,” he said. “I used to go to Europe.
I visited Greece, Italy, France, Switzerland, Austria.” In addition, he said, “I had a pocketful of money, like any tourist, and I enjoyed myself.” “I was well on the way to being a millionaire,” Mr. Arafat said, but “I gave all my wealth to the revolution.”
He asserts that the P.L.O. has played a major role in organizing the recent uprising by Palestinians in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. He said his organization had established “people’s committees in every quarter, in every camp, in every village, in every university” to resist the Israeli occupation.
In the interview, conducted by the journalist Morgan Strong in Tunis and Baghdad, Mr. Arafat said he was born in Gaza and was sent to live with an uncle in Jerusalem. Other biographical accounts say Mr. Arafat was born in Jerusalem, in 1929. Mr.
Arafat said he was the son of “a successful merchant,” received a degree in civil engineering from Cairo University, worked briefly for the Kuwaiti Government and then established his own business as a construction contractor, building roads, highways and bridges.
In the interview, he did not discuss terrorist incidents in which the P.L.O. has been involved in the last 20 years.
Palestinian child, 9, killed in riot, 29 Arabs deported
By Masha Hamilton, Associated Press
JERUSALEM — Israel expelled four Arabs Wednesday and ordered 25 more deported, the military said. Israel Television reported that a 9-year-old Palestinian girl was killed when soldiers put down a West Bank riot.
Hospital officials said Israeli troops beat 105 Arabs in the occupied Gaza Strip, where a curfew remained in effect for a third straight day, and soldiers barred West Bank Palestinians from entering Jerusalem during a daylong protest strike. The army said the curfew would be lifted from the main Gaza Strip cities at 3 a.m. Thursday (8 p.m.
EDT Wednesday) but remain in effect in several of the coastal strip’s refugee camps. Eight West Bank villages also were under round-the-clock curfews, but the orders did not prevent scattered protests in which nine Palestinians were wounded.
Israeli radio reported six wounded in the Nablus area of the occupied West Bank, and the army said three were wounded in the Gaza Strip. In the West Bank town of Jenin, 9-year-old Rasha Artawi was killed while troops dispersed a riot, Israel Television said. It quoted Arab reports as saying the girl was killed by a stray bullet.
However, army officials told the television that a local doctor said the girl was killed by a stone. An army spokesman reached by The Associated Press said he had no information about the case. The fatality brought to 248 the number of Palestinians killed in the 8-month-old uprising. Four Israelis also have been killed.
The four deportees allegedly were members of outlawed Palestinian guerrilla groups and incited the Arab uprising, the army said. They were flown by helicopter to Lebanon, given $50 each and released, military sources said. They were identified as Mohammed Gharableh, Ahmed abu Muailek, Yusri Darwish al Hums and Fathi Ibrihim Shakaki, all from the Gaza Strip.
The United States has protested Israel’s policy of deportations, but Israel defends the measure as the most effective means of deterring violence. Since the Dec. 8 start of the uprising, 33 Palestinians have been deported.
The headline has the child killed by a riot. The copy names her — Rasha Artawi, nine, of Jenin — and then gives two accounts of what killed her: Arab reports say a stray bullet, army officials say a local doctor said a stone, and the news agency’s own spokesman had no information. Five men are named as they are deported, with the sum of money each was given.
At least 244 Palestinians and three Israelis have died in the anti-Israel violence… Palestinians and United Nations relief officials said soldiers commandeered one ambulance attempting to enter Jabalia refugee camp under cover, while Israeli forces stopped another ambulance and began beating a 19-year-old Jabalia man who had been shot in the thigh.
According to a U.N. report, the Palestinian was detained at army headquarters in Jabalia for an hour before U.N. officials intervened and took him to a hospital. An army spokesman said soldiers detained the 19-year-old for questioning and then took him for treatment. He denied that the Palestinian was beaten.
UPI, datelined Jerusalem. The army’s denial runs in the paragraph directly under the U.N. account.
JERUSALEM — Israeli troops shot and wounded a 9-year-old Palestinian girl Friday when she violated a curfew by running out of her West Bank home, an Arab hospital official said.
In the Gaza Strip, a mob of Palestinians attacked a fellow Arab alleged to have cooperated with Israeli authorities, and news reports said another alleged collaborator opened fire a day earlier on a Palestinian mob that was blocking his way in the West Bank, wounding a teen-ager.
The incidents were the latest in a series of Palestinian attacks on suspected collaborators, including three in the past week. An Arab hospital official said nine-year-old Marah Nadadeli of Nablus was shot in the left leg when she ran out of her house in Nablus, the largest West Bank city.
The official, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the girl thought she heard the army announce on loudspeakers that a curfew was over…
The headline gives the child an offense and leaves out who shot her. The first sentence of the copy names the troops, and the fifth paragraph names her: Marah Nadadeli, nine, of Nablus, shot in the left leg. It also says she thought she had heard the army announce that the curfew was over.
3 Palestinians Die Of Gunshot Wounds In Fights With Army
By JOEL BRINKLEY, Special to The New York Times
JERUSALEM, Aug. 31 — Three Palestinian demonstrators died today as a result of gunshot wounds sustained in clashes with Israeli troops. It was the highest death toll in several weeks. Two of the three were teen-agers. One died in a Tel Aviv hospital from a wound suffered during demonstrations on Tuesday.
The deaths occurred on the second day of a general strike across the West Bank and Gaza Strip called to protest Israel’s recent decision to expel 25 Palestinians. During a general strike, all shops and businesses in the West Bank and Gaza Strip close for the day, and Palestinians generally stay off the roads.
Cities in the occupied territories look deserted, except where demonstrations are occurring. Palestinians said Khamis Almeenawi, 17 years old, of the Gaza Strip was shot and killed during violent demonstrations in Gaza this evening.
Also this evening, Palestinians said, Ayman Achmed Najar, 16, died of a gunshot wound to the head suffered during demonstrations at the Rafah refugee center Tuesday. At least eight other Gaza residents were reported wounded by live ammunition today.
On the West Bank, Louai Barbouti was shot and killed during riots that broke out as Israeli troops tried to make arrests in the village of Deir Ghassaneh near Ramallah. With the new casualties, at least 233 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli troops since the uprising began last December.
At the same time, officials reported that a Palestinian found beaten to death in Hebron three days ago was killed because he had been caught trying to rob a store, not because he had collaborated with the Israeli authorities, as some had suspected at the time.
On Sunday, some Palestinians said the man, Samih Yousef Dababseh, was killed because he had been working with the Israeli security police. His body was found tied to an electric pole. But today, Israeli officials said they had learned that residents had taken revenge for repeated criminal acts and tied him to a pole as an example for others.
Islamic Group Challenges PLO Over Palestine By DAN FISHER and DAN WILLIAMS, Times Staff Writers GAZA, Israeli-Occupied Gaza Strip—Neither the Palestine Liberation Organization nor anyone else has the right to endorse Israeli rule over any part of historic Palestine, according to an underground “covenant” produced by an influential Islamic fundamentalist group here.
The document, a copy of which was obtained by The Times, was apparently produced in answer to recent statements by PLO officials that they are preparing to implicitly recognize Israel as part of a move toward trying to create an adjacent Palestinian state.
See Threat to Unity Both Israeli and Palestinian nationalist sources described the declaration as a threat to the extraordinary unity that has been shown by West Bank and Gaza Strip Palestinians during their nearly nine-month-old anti-Israeli uprising.
By calling for jihad, or holy war, as “the only solution to the Palestine problem,” the covenant is seen as undermining support in the occupied territories for any moderate PLO political initiative. Palestine “cannot be given up in part or ceded,” the document says. “No one has this right.
No Arab country, nor all the Arab countries together, no king or president, nor all the kings and presidents together have that right. Neither the PLO nor any other organization has that Please see PALESTINE, Page 16 … “The covenant, dated Aug.
18 and issued under the name of the Islamic Resistance Movement/Palestine, appears at a time of growing tensions between the predominantly secular PLO nationalists and Palestinian religious fundamentalists. The fundamentalists are strongest here in overcrowded Gaza, where the uprising began and where it has been particularly violent.
But in recent weeks they have also appeared to be gaining support on the West Bank of the Jordan River, long considered a secular stronghold.
Late last month, the Islamic Resistance Movement, known by its Arabic acronym as HAMAS, enforced a full commercial strike in major West Bank towns against the wishes of the secular intifada leadership… Palestinian sources say that Israeli officials have encouraged such divisions as a means of weakening the Palestinian cause.
The government has allowed some fundamentalists to operate semi-openly here in Gaza, for example, while cracking down on militant PLO factions. ‘I have my suspicions that over the last 10 years the Israelis tried to encourage fundamentalism as a power to curb nationalism,’ said Rashad Shawa, a former Gaza mayor and head of a prominent local clan.
‘But to their disappointment, [the various groups] joined hands against the Israeli occupation.’… ‘For me, a secular state is out of the question,’ said Sheik Akhmad Yassin, a prominent Islamic leader here.
In an interview at his home in a particularly squalid Gaza neighborhood, Yassin, who is paralyzed from the neck down, said that creation of neighboring Israeli and Palestinian states ‘is not a satisfactory solution… The solution we are looking for is a unified Palestine.’… The new HAMAS covenant defines all of historic Palestine—including Israel and the occupied territories—as ‘an Islamic trust for all the generations of Muslims until the resurrection.’… The document describes HAMAS as ‘a humanitarian movement that protects human rights and is committed to Islamic tolerance toward other religions.’
It is not hostile, it adds, ‘to anyone who does not stand in its way. In Islam, followers of Christianity and Judaism can live in safety and security.’ However, the covenant cites well-known anti-Semitic tracts in condemning the Jewish national movement.”
September 1988. The intifada is nine months old and led by the secular PLO, and Hamas is still being introduced to American readers, by its acronym, as a new development. A former mayor of Gaza says Israel spent ten years encouraging the movement in order to curb nationalism. The covenant is quoted on tolerance and then on antisemitic tracts, in consecutive sentences, and the paper names them as antisemitic.
By Dan Fisher and Dan Williams, Los Angeles Times, Gaza, Israeli-Occupied Gaza Strip
GAZA, Israeli-Occupied Gaza Strip — Neither the Palestine Liberation Organization nor anyone else has the right to endorse Israeli rule over any part of historic Palestine, according to an underground “covenant” produced by an influential Islamic fundamentalist group here.
The document, a copy of which was obtained by the Los Angeles Times, was apparently produced in answer to recent statements by PLO officials that they are preparing to implicitly recognize Israel as part of a move toward trying to create an adjacent Palestinian state.
Both Israeli and Palestinian nationalist sources described the declaration as a threat to the extraordinary unity that has been shown by West Bank and Gaza Strip Palestinians during their nearly 9-month-old anti-Israeli uprising.
By calling for “jihad,” or holy war, as “the only solution to the Palestine problem,” the covenant is seen as undermining support in the occupied territories for any moderate PLO political initiative… The movement, known by its Arabic acronym as HAMAS, enforced a full commercial strike in major West Bank towns against the wishes of the secular intifada leadership.
A few days later, a second HAMAS effort to enforce a strike set off scuffling in the West Bank town of Ramallah between secular and religious activists.
The same Los Angeles Times dispatch as the covenant story, in a Westchester paper on the same day, with the dateline spelled out: Gaza, Israeli-Occupied Gaza Strip. The headline puts holy war in quotation marks and calls the authors a group.
Islamic resistance covenant rules out deal with Israel
From Herald Wire Services, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — The previously unpublished covenant of a growing Islamic resistance movement in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip rules out any compromise with Israel and says the only solution to the Palestinian problem is Holy War.
The 40-page document, obtained by Reuters news agency, cites the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, an anti-Semitic pamphlet used in Nazi German propaganda, to claim that Israel is plotting expansion from the Nile River in Egypt to the Euphrates in Iraq… The movement, known by the Arabic initials Hamas, has gained strength since a Palestinian uprising in the occupied territories began in December.
Although its stronghold is Gaza, Hamas last month staged its first general strike in the West Bank in defiance of the largely secular underground Unified National Leadership of the Uprising, backed by the Palestine Liberation Organization… That pamphlet, a purported master plan for a Jewish world takeover regarded by Western historians as an anti-Semitic fraud, claims that Jews carry out human sacrifice and use children’s blood to bake unleavened bread for the Passover holiday… “The only solution to the Palestinian problem is by Jihad.
All initiatives, conferences and proposals are a waste of time,” it says. On Sunday, West Bank Jewish settlers demonstrated to demand government permission to shoot at Palestinian stone-throwers. Soldiers in the occupied territories shot and wounded three Palestinian protesters.
At a Cabinet meeting, Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir denied news reports that he had recommended expanding defense rules to allow soldiers and civilians to fire at stone-throwers in the territories, officials said. Jewish settlers have been demanding that both the army and settlers be allowed to open fire on Palestinians throwing stones.
Only soldiers are allowed to shoot… Meanwhile, a staff member of the Palestinian newspaper al-Fajr said that Israeli security forces have raided its East Jerusalem offices and arrested managing editor Hatem Abdel-Qader. A police spokesman said Abdel-Qader was jailed without trial for six months on security grounds by order of Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin.
The day after the Los Angeles Times page, the same covenant in Miami, with the Protocols of the Elders of Zion named and called an anti-Semitic fraud in the paper’s own voice. The last four paragraphs are about who is allowed to shoot at stone-throwers, and the last two are a Palestinian newspaper editor jailed for six months without trial.
JERUSALEM — In the first serious split of the 9-month-old Palestinian uprising in the Israeli-occupied territories, an emerging Islamic fundamentalist organization is challenging the protest’s clandestine “unified leadership.”
The Islamic fundamentalists, who promote an uncompromising war with Israel and are critical of the Palestine Liberation Organization, have held three days of general strikes in the past month independent of those called by the underground leadership’s leaflets, and there have been several street fights between supporters of the two groups over whether merchants should open or close.
The emergence of the new organization, known as Hamas (or Zeal), an acronym for the Movement of the Islamic Resistance, not only poses a threat to the secular, PLO-oriented leadership of the uprising but has also complicated the efforts of several West Bank leaders to press Yasser Arafat and the PLO leadership abroad to capitalize on their political gains by offering to come to terms with Israel… The underground leadership attacked the fundamentalist group by name for the first time in leaflet No.
25, now circulating on the streets. Hamas has become a major force in the Gaza Strip. Only a little over two years ago, rivalries in the Gaza Strip were so great that Islamic fundamentalists severely beat several members of leftist PLO groups with iron pipes and set fire to an office of the Palestinian Red Crescent.
Its influence is still spotty in the West Bank, where many of the organizers are loyal to the PLO. But Palestinians said that its protest calls were likely to be heeded in traditionalist Moslem areas such as Hebron.
The pull-quote set into the page reads: “The solution to the Palestinian problem will only take place by holy war. The initiatives and international conferences only waste time.” — Movement of Islamic Resistance.
Nine months into the uprising, Hamas is reported as a threat to the people leading it. The underground leadership attacks it by name for the first time in leaflet number twenty-five.
Review by Fouad Ajami / Washington Post Book World Service
The mayor of Jaffa left “without even saying goodbye,” a British official, Sir Henry Gurney, complained in early May, 1948, adding that municipal services had broken down and that remnants of the Arab Liberation Army, a volunteer force from the urban slums of Syria, Lebanon and Iraq, led by a poseur and adventurer by the name of Fawzi al Qawuqji, would-be saviours of Arab Jaffa, were busy looting the town.
A week later the world of Arab Jaffa would become a memory. Of Jaffa's pre-war population — 70,000 to 80,000 — no more than 5,000 inhabitants would remain. And on May 18, David Ben-Gurion, the leader of the new state of Israel, visited the conquered city.
By then the mixed Arab and Jewish towns of Tiberias and Haifa had fallen, and their Arab inhabitants had taken to the road. There would be more dislocations to come: the fall of the towns of Lydda and Ramle (in July), the flight from upper Galilee and the northern approaches of the Negev (October-November), a Palestinian exodus that stretched out over a space of 20 months.
The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, a book of extraordinary power and integrity written by a young Israeli scholar and journalist, Benny Morris, takes that great tale of flight and conquest and tells it as it has never been told before: with precision and moral economy, with awesome detail and honesty, drawing from recenty declassified archival and private papers.
Hitherto this subject has been the realm of publicists and protagonists — Zionists, Palestinians, many others. In Benny Morris this episode has its first historian and chronicler — no axe to grind, no apologies to make. And it is surely no accident that Benny Morris is an Israeli, and an Israeli born in 1948 at that.
Revisionism is easier for the victors — the vanquished still have wars to fight, scores to settle.
Fundamentalists seize role in Palestinian uprising
Growing influence of extremist Islamic Resistance Movement worries both Israel and the PLO
By Glenn Frankel, The Washington Post, Bireh, West Bank
BIREH, West Bank — The quarter-mile-long stone wall outside the old Moravian Church leper colony has long been a favorite billboard for Palestinian sloganeers. But lately a new set of graffiti has appeared that, even by local standards, is harder-edged and more radical than most nationalist fare. “The end of Israel is a Koranic inevitability,” reads one.
“Yes to the revolution of the mosques… Let those calling for peace be silent… We will tell the sons of Zion that we will not forget Haifa and Jaffa. We are coming.”
Each slogan is signed by Hamas, which means “zeal” and is the Arabic acronym for the Islamic Resistance Movement, the newest and most extremist of the underground Palestinian resistance groups to have emerged during the nine-month uprising in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip.
In recent years, the combination of fundamentalism and Palestinian nationalism has been a potent force in the poorer, more traditional Gaza Strip and was a major element in triggering the uprising last December.
But Hamas is still a fledgling, but its growing influence not only in Gaza but in the wealthier, better educated and more sophisticated West Bank is a phenomenon that both Israel and secular activists of the Palestine Liberation Organization are watching with concern… Hamas is also opposed to an international peace conference, one of the PLO’s major proposals, because it believes a conference would result in territorial compromise and PLO recognition of Israel.
Its hard-line stance is one of the factors limiting Arafat’s options. “The PLO first gained respect and support because it adopted the armed struggle,” says Sheik Bassam Jarrar, one of the young imams of the West Bank who are considered spiritual leaders of Hamas.
“But now that the PLO is giving up the armed struggle, its support is lessening.”… It has a vast, built-in communications network in the mosques that cover both Gaza and the West Bank. Within a week of the issuing of its covenant, the document was posted in mosques throughout the territories. Jarrar and other local imams preach to full houses each week.
In the covenant, Hamas rejects compromise with Israel because it claims all of Palestine is an Islamic trust that cannot be yielded. It condemns the international conference proposal as “arbitration by unbelievers over the land of the Moslems.” The only solution, it claims, is “jihad” — Islamic holy war.
“Palestinians throw stones at Israeli soldiers; Islamic fundamentalists are playing a greater role in the uprising and calling for a holy war.” The Associated Press.
Nine months into the intifada, a Washington Post correspondent standing at a wall in Bireh reading the graffiti to find out who is writing it. The sheik is named and quoted on why the PLO is losing support, and the map beside the story is credited to the Christian Science Monitor.
GAZA CITY, Occupied Gaza Strip (AP) — The Israeli army’s use of plastic bullets to break up Palestinian demonstrations is filling hospital wards with casualties and prompting calls for tighter controls.
Victims of the new ammunition, including two teen-agers treated for plastic bullet wounds at Ahli Arab Hospital in Gaza City, complain that stones thrown by protesters do not warrant the penalty. “It’s unreasonable punishment,” said Mazul Abu Lail, 19, a tailor who was shot in the ankle.
In a nearby bed, 16-year-old Rifaat Massoud, a construction worker, nodded in agreement. “It isn’t right and it isn’t fair for the soldiers to shoot innocent people,” Massoud said, shifting uncomfortably with a bullet wound in his left side.
The plastic bullet was introduced in August to supplement rubber bullets, water cannons, tear gas and clubs in dealing with the uprising in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip. Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin said the other weapons “proved to be insufficient to cope with stone throwing” and that the army needed something less lethal than lead bullets.
The aim, Rabin said, is to reduce anti-Israeli violence in the territories with a minimum of fatalities. Since the uprising began Dec. 8, at least 280 Palestinians have been killed and hundreds injured. Six Israelis have died. In the past three weeks, more than 325 Palestinians have been wounded in clashes.
The army says plastic bullets can penetrate the body, but they are not supposed to be lethal if fired from at least 70 yards. However, at least four deaths from plastic bullets have been reported at Shifa Hospital in Gaza City.
Arabs Kill Two More Palestinians, Including Village Religious Chief
“Since the uprising began 10 months ago, at least nine Palestinians have been killed by other Palestinians because they were suspected of collaboration.”
Joel Brinkley. Arabs in the headline and Palestinians in the same headline, four words apart, for the same people on both sides of the verb — a clean specimen of the handover this archive tracks, caught mid-switch.
CAUGHT IN THE MIDDLE Trapped for life After 40 years, the Palestinian camps remain breeding grounds of frustration and violence [STANDFIRST, set in italic at the head of the first column] Sunday magazine writer William Mullen spent nine months touring the world’s refugee camps to discover why they have become seemingly permanent fixtures around the globe.
The longer refugee camps exist, the greater the probability of violence erupting as it has in the Gaza Strip. Second in a series. By William Mullen This year marks the 40th anniversary of the creation of the State of Israel.
It has not been celebrated even in Israel with much pomp and pageantry, for there is a corollary 40-year anniversary to be marked: the creation of Palestinian refugee camps. Palestinians hold the dubious honor of having stayed the longest in post-World War II refugee camps, but other refugee groups are not far behind.
In Uganda, 120,000 Rwandans have languished in camps since 1959. In Sudan, half a million Eritrean Ethiopians have been piling up in camps since 1962. The camps for half a million refugees in Somalia opened in 1978, the same year refugees began trickling out of Afghanistan, soon to become a torrent of 5 million.
Most of the camps housing Central American refugees were built in 1980 and 1981. For the most recent outpouring of people from Mozambique, the United Nations is preparing camps to hold them for five years. But receiving countries such as Malawi, which soon will have 750,000 Mozambicans to care for, are girding for at least a 10-year problem.
The UN High Commission for Refugees, the agency charged with caring for most of the world’s refugees, designates anybody who has been out of his country for more than three years as a “long-staying” refugee. Perhaps 75 percent of today’s refugees have been in camps for five or more years.
After 40 years, the expelled Palestinians and their 2.2 million descendants remain trapped in fetid camps across the Middle East. They have been there so long that two generations of Palestinians have been born and reared in camps, and much of the rest of the world tries not to think of them as refugees any longer.
The world has paid a high price for trying to ignore the Palestinians. Already it has meant the virtual destruction of one country, Lebanon. It has spawned an insidious new form of warfare, worldwide terrorism. The Palestinians, of course, will not let the rest of the world forget their plight.
They were largely abandoned to their fate in the camps by the rest of the Arab world after the original Arab-Israeli War in 1948, when the new Jewish state forced 700,000 Palestinians out of their homes. The rest of the Arabs did not want the Palestinians to leave the camps because that would have meant permanent resettlement elsewhere in the Arab world.
So the Palestinians have been left to their own seething discontent for 40 years. It is a discontent that is particularly galling to the 800,000 Palestinians who, since the Six-Day War of 1967, have lived in the Israeli occupied territories of Gaza, Golan Heights and the West Bank, where their status is less than second-class citizenship.
The Israelis, themselves descendants of Jewish refugees who managed to survive Hitler’s Holocaust and had nowhere else to go at the end of World War II, persuasively justify their treatment of the Palestinians. They point to 100 million Arabs surrounding them, to the Arab leaders who for 40 years have proclaimed their intentions of driving the Jewish state into the sea.
The Israelis say they are fighting for their very right to exist as a nation, and they are right. The Palestinians also persuasively justify their struggle against Israel. They are a nation of people without a land to call their own, a people denied the right to determine their own destiny.
The Palestinians say they are fighting for their very existence as a nation, and they, too, are right. With each passing year, the self-righteousness and intransigent attitudes of the Israelis, the Palestinians and the Arab world seem to harden. With each passing year, the violence and potential for violence ratchet upward.
Refugee officials around the world increasingly worry about the potential for more Palestinian-style refugee problems. They fear See Caught, pg.
2 [THREE PHOTOGRAPH CAPTIONS, none of them the one the record already holds] Palestinian refugee housing in Israel’s Gaza Strip, where the camps turned 40 years old earlier this year. [credit] Tribune photo by Frank Hanes Israeli soldiers patrol camps in Gaza Strip shortly after Palestinians rose up in violent protest of Israeli occupation. [credit] Tribune photo by Frank Hanes Sophy Juda shouts across the buffer between Gaza and Egypt, hoping to talk to his wife, who must stay on the other side. [credit] Tribune photo by William Mullen … Continued from page 1 that other long-term camps also are becoming seedbeds, fertilized by years of wrecked aspirations and wasted lives, for violent outbursts.
I met Sophy Juda in September, 1987, in Gaza, one of Israel’s occupied territories. More than half a million Palestinians, including 360,000 refugees, live in Gaza, an arid strip of land 28 miles long and 5 miles wide at Israel’s southern flank. I had gone to Rafah Camp, the southernmost of Gaza’s eight refugee camps, to watch the daily spectacle at Gaza’s border with Egypt.
There, two fences separate Gaza from Egypt, and running between them is a road that is used by Israeli security forces to patrol the border. The fences went up in 1967 after Israel took over administration of Gaza Strip after its lightning victory over Egypt and other Arab nations in what is now known as the Six-Day War.
For many refugees, the erection of the fences split not only Gaza from Egypt but their families as well. Rafah Camp before 1967 straddled the Egyptian and Gaza sides of the border, and even though members of the same family might have lived in Gaza or Egypt, they had freedom to go back and forth. Since 1967, residents do not have that freedom.
Now members of separated families come to the fence every day. They stand on anything that is handy, to give them a little elevation to see better into the Egyptian side of the camp. They cup their hands and shout to get the attention of people on the other side.
The idea is to stop somebody who knows the relatives you are seeking and get that person to bring them to the fence. There are telephone connections between Gaza and Egypt, but few refugee households can afford them, nor could they afford the $1-a-minute cost that such a phone call would incur. If you have family business to discuss or gossip to pass on, you go to the fence.
An Israeli soldier scans the horizon from a fortified watchtower in Gaza Strip after Palestinian refugees rebelled last December. Tribune photo by Frank Hanes
JERUSALEM — Israel on Tuesday suspended the press credentials of three reporters following the publication of stories in which Arabs accused Israel of running undercover death squads in the occupied territories.
Israeli authorities, including Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin, strongly denied the reports published by the Reuters news agency and the London-based Financial Times… A Government Press Office statement said: “There is no connection between the accuracy or inaccuracy of the information published and the obligation to submit news stories to the censor.
In spite of Israel’s security situation, Israeli authorities respect freedom of the press and act very liberally with overseas correspondents.”
Taylor, the Reuter bureau chief, said he stood by the story the news agency sent to its subscribers Sunday in which Weizman was quoted as saying that security sources had orders to shoot to kill fugitive organizers of the uprising “with blood on their hands.”
The Israeli government’s own explanation, printed: the punishment has no connection between the accuracy or inaccuracy of the information published and the duty to submit it to the censor. Truth is not the question. Submission is. The same statement says Israeli authorities respect freedom of the press and act very liberally with overseas correspondents, in the paragraph announcing that three correspondents have lost their credentials.
Israel Bars 3 Reporters Over 'Undercover' Articles
JERUSALEM, Oct. 25 — Israel today suspended the press credentials of three foreign correspondents who wrote that Israeli undercover squads were operating in the occupied territories. It said it would investigate if the three had violated military censorship regulations.
Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin said reports that undercover squads had been assigned to kill leaders of the Arab uprising were “total nonsense, not justified, not based of fact, and I don't have anything to add to it.”
The military censor filed a police complaint against Paul Taylor, chief correspondent here for Reuters, and Steve Weizman, a Reuters reporter, for reporting on Sunday that Israel uses such squads in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. The censor charged that the Reuters dispatch violated censortship laws.
The news agency's report said the military operated “an undercover army unit code-named Cherry deployed in the West Bank” and a “similar Gaza-based unit code-named Samson.” Article on Army Units A Financial Times correspondent, Andrew Whitley, also had his Government-issued press card suspended. Two weeks ago, Mr.
Whitley wrote an article describing undercover army units used to gather intelligence in the occupied areas. His article made no reference to assassination. Mr. Taylor and Mr. Whitley defended their reports, saying they had not been submitted to the censor for approval because they were based on previously published information. Mr.
Whitley said he believed the censor acted because “coverage of the territories was getting into areas the Defense Ministry prefers remain in the Israeli family.” The existence of the undercover units “is known to large numbers of Israelis, not just the press, but also people doing military service,” he added. Army Issues Statement Mr.
Taylor said Reuters stood behind its article about the assassination squads. The army spokesman today issued a statement saying “there is no unit in the Israel Defense Forces which is authorized to act, or which acts, against the well-known rules for opening fire, which are grounded in law.”
Those rules allow soldiers to open fire with lethal weapons only when their lives are threatened. Yoram Ettinger, chief of the Government press office, said the censor, together with representatives of the army, Defense Ministry and Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir's office, decided to press charges against the three reporters. Mr.
Ettinger added that the censor's office determined that “items of a security nature were not submitted to censorship, without any reference to their authenticity or the validity of the information as fact.” Instructed Not to Cooperate After suspending the correspondent's press credentials, Mr.
Ettinger's office instructed all Government ministries and the army not to cooperate with the three journalists. Mr. Taylor and Mr. Weizman will continue working with the assistance of the rest of Reuters staff in Jerusalem, who are still accredited by the Government. But Mr.
Ettinger's office warned that “if Reuters commits such a serious offense again, steps will be taken against its entire Israel office.” The Financial Times's sole reporter in Israel, Mr. Whitley, said it would be very difficult for him to work without a press card, since “one needs to present a press pass at frequent intervals.”
In April, the Government suspended the press passes of Glenn Frankel, The Washington Post's reporter in Israel, and Martin Fletcher, a reporter for NBC News. They had filed reports that the Israeli Government had killed Khalil al-Wazir, the Palestine Liberation Organization military commander. Neither dispatch was submitted to the censors.
Cards Returned Later A few weeks later, both press cards were returned. Press censorship laws in Israel apply to stories dealing with defense, Arab nations and what the censor's office calls “hostile organizations.”
They also cover general subjects such as water supplies, the conditions of roads in Israel, details about loans granted to Israel, nuclear research, border settlements and aerial photographs. Details of the censor's activities are also subject to censorship. Correspondents are expected to know which stories require the censor's approval and submit them voluntarily.
Foreign reporters have frequently complained that regulations regarding the defense establishment are vague and arbitrarily applied. Material previously published has traditionally been exempt. But Mr. Ettinger said the censor's office “published an update of regulations on Sept. 18” requiring that even previously published material be censored.
The regulations were published in a Government gazette in Hebrew, without any special notification to foreign correspondents. Mr. Ettinger said that “when it comes to the publication of code names of supposed units, obviously this is a security matter.” But even though Mr. Rabin said the stories were utterly false, meaning that the units did not exist, Mr.
Ettinger declined to say why publication of the stories was nonetheless a security breach.
JERUSALEM, Oct. 25 (AP) — Israeli troops opened fire on stone-throwing Palestinian demonstrators in the occupied Gaza Strip today, killing a 14-year-old girl, hospital officials said. Eighteen Palestinians were wounded in clashes between Israelis and Arab demonstrators in seven towns and refugee camps in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, hospital officials said.
Three of the wounded were shot by an Israeli truck driver who fired into a crowded Gaza vegetable market after his truck was hit by a firebomb, witnesses said. The firebomb did not cause serious damage, the witnesses said. The army confirmed that two Palestinians were wounded in the West Bank, and it said that it was checking the other casualty reports.
The dead girl was identified as Manal Samour of the Shati refugee district, on the edge of Gaza. Witnesses in Shati said the girl apparently was struck when soldiers fired on demonstrators from a rooftop. The witnesses said anti-Israeli protests broke out in the camp after word of the girl’s death spread. The camp later was put under curfew, witnesses said.
The death raised to 267 the number of Palestinians killed since December, the start of the Palestinian uprising against Israeli rule in the occupied territories.
EDITOR’S NOTE — The following story was submitted to the Israeli military censor, who ordered significant deletions. By MARY SEDOR, Associated Press Writer. YATTA, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Special Israeli army undercover units are operating in the occupied territories to identify Palestinian activists in the Arab uprising.
Existence of the units and reports that Palestinians have been killed by Israelis dressed in civilian clothes have triggered widespread rumors that undercover military squads had been formed to assassinate activists on the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
Both Palestinian human rights investigators and army officials have agreed there was no evidence to suggest the army sanctioned assassination squads or the systematic killing of Palestinians. Arabs have claimed that Israelis dressed in civilian clothes and driving unmarked vehicles have being involved in at least four incidents in which Palestinians were shot.
Three Palestinians were killed and three wounded in the shootings, the Arabs claim. Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Dan Shomron said on Israel radio “there is no army unit that is above the law, that has the right to kill or eliminate someone.”
Field worker Khalid Batrawi said Law in the Service of Man, an organization affiliated with the Geneva-based International Commission of Jurists, has investigated incidents in which Palestinians were killed or wounded by Israelis wearing civilian or Arab clothes and operating with army backup.
“There isn’t one case where we can claim the army came to kill a particular person,” he said. “But there are many cases where there was no reason for the army to shoot.” Security sources and Israeli soldiers, who spoke on condition of anonymity, told The Associated Press that undercover military units operate in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
According to foreign published reports, two units use the code names “Cherry” and “Samson.” Reports have said their mission was to identify Arab ringleaders and demonstration organizers.
The army units are distinct from the Shin Bet security forces, which have operated in the West Bank and Gaza Strip since Israel seized the territory in the 1967 Middle East war. An Israeli source familiar with the army units said they did not have orders to shoot and any use of violence was an exception to standing orders.
Unit members carry weapons and usually wear T-shirts over army-issue khaki-colored pants. They sometimes masquerade as Arabs, donning traditional keffiyeh headdresses and driving vehicles with distinctive license plates reserved for Arab-owned cars — blue in the West Bank and white in the Gaza Strip.
Although there was no indication the units had a license to kill, questions have been raised about their tactics. Dedi Zucker, a member of the Israeli Parliament, said that in response to his inquiry, Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin had confirmed the army uses confiscated Arab cars. “Rabin claimed this is legal and done officially,” he said.
The correspondent for the Financial Times of London and two Reuters journalists had their press credentials suspended by the government and are being investigated by police for reporting on the undercover units without submitting their stories to censorship. Villagers in Yatta told the AP that on Oct.
9 two Palestinians were gunned down by a group of about eight Israelis who jumped out of a cream-colored Ford Transit van bearing West Bank license plates. The gunmen wore T-shirts and khaki, army-style pants and carried pistols and automatic weapons, according to a witness, Moussa Al Sari, an uncle of one of the slain men.
Al Sari said Fadel Ibrahim Kamal Mahmoud Al Sari, 24, were walking down Yatta’s main road when the van pulled up alongside them. “The Israelis got a good look at them and then they opened fire. They knew who they were after,” claimed the elder Al Sari, adding that the men were sprayed with submachine gun fire from a distance of about three yards.
Family members said both men were wanted by the authorities for anti-Israeli activism and had been in hiding to elude troops who frequently searched their houses. They said about 60 youths had thrown stones at the van an hour earlier. An army spokesman said the men were shot by soldiers who opened fire after their lives were threatened by a stone-throwing mob.
He said one of the men was wanted by security forces. Col. Renaan Gissin, the deputy army spokesman, said the military police had launched a routine investigation into the incident to insure “the firing was called for, that it was a life endangering situation.”
Three signed affidavits collected by Law in the Service of Man describe incidents similar to the Yatta shooting elsewhere in the West Bank. Sultan Abu Hassan, 21, said he was hit with 11 bullets fired by Israelis who wore T-shirts, khaki pants and Arab headdresses. Another man, Mohammed Abu Salah, 38, was killed in the attack.
Abu Sultan said the driver told him in Arabic he wanted to enter the village, then four men emerged from the car and opened fire.
The censorship is printed inside the newspaper. Before the first paragraph, in its own bold block, the paper tells the reader: the following story was submitted to the Israeli military censor, who ordered significant deletions. What follows is a story about undercover Israeli army units, and buried in the middle of it is the sentence that closes the circle — a Financial Times correspondent and two Reuters journalists had lost their press credentials for reporting on those same units without submitting their stories to censorship. The dispatch that went through the censor reports the punishment of the journalists who did not. Note also who claims and who says. Palestinians claim throughout, including a man describing his nephew’s killing. The army said. Both are in the same column.
Undercover Israeli army units identifying Palestinian activists
The following story was submitted to the Israeli military censor, who ordered significant deletions.
By The Associated Press
“The following story was submitted to the Israeli military censor, who ordered significant deletions.
YATTA, Occupied West Bank — Special Israeli army undercover units are operating in the occupied territories to identify Palestinian activists… Arabs have claimed that Israelis dressed in civilian clothes and driving unmarked vehicles have been involved in at least four incidents in which Palestinians were shot.
Three Palestinians were killed and three wounded in the shootings, the Arabs claim…”
The same censored Associated Press dispatch as the McAllen printing, the same Saturday, under a different headline. Here the disclosure is set not as an editor’s note but as a line with a small square beside it, the way a paper flags a standing notice. The headline drops the word Arabs for Palestinian activists.
Israel undercover army units operate against Arabs in Occupied Territories
EDITOR’S NOTE — The following story was submitted to the Israeli military censor, who ordered significant deletions.
Associated Press
EDITOR’S NOTE — The following story was submitted to the Israeli military censor, who ordered significant deletions. YATTA, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Special Israeli army undercover units are operating in the occupied territories to identify Palestinian activists in the Arab uprising.
Existence of the units and reports that Palestinians have been killed by Israelis dressed in civilian clothes have triggered widespread military rumors that undercover military squads had been formed to assassinate activists on the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
Both Palestinian human rights investigators and army officials have agreed there was no evidence to suggest the army sanctioned assassination squads or the systematic killing of Palestinians. Arabs have claimed that Israelis dressed in civilian clothes and driving unmarked vehicles have being involved in at least four incidents in which Palestinians were shot.
Three Palestinians were killed and three wounded in the shootings, the Arabs claim. Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Dan Shomron said on Israel radio “there is no army unit that is above the law, that has the right to kill or eliminate someone.”
Field worker Khalid Batrawi said Law in the Service of Man, an organization affiliated with the Geneva-based International Commission of Jurists, has investigated incidents in which Palestinians were killed or wounded by Israelis wearing civilian or Arab clothes and operating with army backup.
“There isn’t one case where we can claim the army came to kill a particular person,” he said. “But there are many cases where there was no reason for the army to shoot.” Security sources and Israeli soldiers, who spoke on condition of anonymity, told The Associated Press that undercover military units operate in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
According to foreign published reports, two units use the code names “Cherry” and “Samson.” Reports have said their mission was to identify Arab ringleaders and demonstration organizers.
The army units are distinct from the Shin Bet security forces, which have operated in the West Bank and Gaza Strip since Israel seized the territory in the 1967 Middle East war. An Israeli source familiar with the army units said they did not have orders to shoot and any use of violence was an exception to standing orders.
Unit members carry weapons and usually wear T-shirts over army-issue khaki-colored pants. They sometimes masquerade as Arabs, donning traditional keffiyeh headdresses and driving vehicles with distinctive license plates reserved for Arab-owned cars — blue in the West Bank and white in the Gaza Strip.
Although there was no indication the units had a license to kill, questions have been raised about their tactics. Dedi Zucker, a member of the Israeli Parliament, said that in response to his inquiry, Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin had confirmed the army uses confiscated Arab cars. “Rabin claimed this is legal and done officially,” he said.
The correspondent for the Financial Times of London and two Reuters journalists had their press credentials suspended by the government and are being investigated by police for reporting on the undercover units without submitting their stories to censorship. Villagers in Yatta told the AP that on Oct.
9 two Palestinians were gunned down by a group of about eight Israelis who jumped out of a cream-colored Ford Transit van bearing West Bank license plates. The gunmen wore T-shirts and khaki, army-style pants and carried pistols and automatic weapons, according to a witness, Moussa Al Sari, an uncle of one of the slain men.
Al Sari said Fadel Ibrahim Shehadeh Al Najar, 25, and Kamal Mahmoud Al Sari, 24, were walking down Yatta’s main road when the van pulled up alongside them. “The Israelis got a good look at them and then they opened fire.
They knew who they were after,” claimed the elder Al Sari, adding that the men were sprayed with submachine gun fire from a distance of about three yards. Family members said both men were wanted by the authorities for anti-Israeli activism and had been in hiding to elude troops who frequently searched their houses.
They said about 60 youths had thrown stones at the van an hour earlier. An army spokesman said the men were shot by soldiers who opened fire after their lives were threatened by a stone-throwing mob. He said one of the men was wanted by security forces. Col.
Renaan Gissin, the deputy army spokesman, said the military police had launched a routine investigation into the incident to insure “the firing was called for, that it was a life endangering situation.” Three signed affidavits collected by Law in the Service of Man describe incidents similar to the Yatta shooting elsewhere in the West Bank.
A third printing of the censored dispatch on the same Saturday, and the only one of the three whose headline names the Occupied Territories.
“The soldiers killed at least 43 Arabs. Two officers involved in the incident received lengthy prison terms from a military court, but their sentences were reduced by a military high…
Within three years they were released. The Kafr Kassem incident has become a symbol for Palestinians and Israeli Arabs who believe they cannot receive equal justice and protection.”
The end of the legal story, reported in Detroit thirty-two years after the killings: seven to seventeen year sentences, and everybody out within three. The same paragraph says what the village has come to stand for.
JERUSALEM, Nov. 4 — An Arabic-language newspaper today published what it said was a Palestinian “declaration of independence” that will be issued by the Palestine Liberation Organization this month. The declaration named Jerusalem as the capital of an independent Palestinian state but made no mention of its borders or recognition of Israel.
An Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman, Alon Liel, said the declaration was “definitely unacceptable” and more extreme than expected. Mr. Liel said Israel expects the Palestine National Council, the governing body of the P.L.O., to declare an independent Palestinian state when it convenes in Algiers. The meeting is expected to begin Nov. 16.
Debate Has Intensified The P.L.O. debate over the declaration of a Palestinian state in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip has intensified since King Hussein of Jordan severed his ties with the areas. The declaration published today in Al Fajr, a Jerusalem daily, had four points.
The first said, “We the Palestinian people represented by the P.N.C. announce the declaration of the Palestinian state on the soil of Palestine and with Jerusalem as its capital, all according to the inherent rights of Palestinians to live in their homeland in accordance with United Nations Security Council Resolution 181.”
Resolution 181 is the 1947 partition resolution setting out the boundaries of proposed Jewish and Palestinian states. Mr. Liel said that Israel will “react negatively if the declaration is based on United Nations Resolution 181 and doesn’t mention Resolution 242, recognizing Israel and renouncing terror.” Resolution 242 urges Arabs and Israelis to negotiate.
‘The Only Path’ Today’s declaration also said: The P.L.O. “is the sole representative of the Palestinian people.” The P.L.O. calls on Soviet, American, Arab and European leaders to “work hard toward implementing all U.N. resolutions connected to the Palestinian problem.”
“The only path to solve the problem is the one of implementing all international resolutions through an active international conference with the participation of the P.L.O.” To the surprise of some here, Israel’s military censor authorized publication of the declaration’s text. An army officer in the censor’s office refused to discuss the reasoning.
AMMAN, Jordan, Nov. 4 — Palestinian officials here indicated in interviews today that the precise formula for declaring an independent state was still under negotiation among P.L.O. representatives meeting in Tunis.
One official said the document published in Jerusalem today was apparently one of at least three under debate in Tunis suggesting how the P.L.O. should treat Resolution 242.
“What the P.L.O. is going to announce is going to take into consideration what the world’s community wants the Palestinians to do,” said Mohamed Milhem, a member of the P.L.O.’s executive committee regarded as moderate. Mr. Milhem said the declaration would be made without reference to recognition of Israel.
But he said the declaration would be accompanied by a political program addressing other issues, including a renunciation of terrorism outside Israel and the occupied territories.
YATTA, Occupied West Bank (AP) — Special Israeli army undercover units are operating in the occupied territories to identify Palestinian activists in the Arab uprising.
Existence of the units and reports that Palestinians have been killed by Israelis dressed in civilian clothes have triggered widespread rumors that undercover military squads had been formed to assassinate activists on the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
Both Palestinian human rights investigators and army officials have agreed there was no evidence to suggest the army sanctioned assassination squads or the systematic killing of Palestinians. Arabs have claimed that Israelis dressed in civilian clothes and driving unmarked vehicles have being involved in at least four incidents in which Palestinians were shot.
Three Palestinians were killed and three wounded in the shootings, the Arabs claim. Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Dan Shomron said on Israel radio “there is no army unit that is above the law, that has the right to kill or eliminate someone.”
Field worker Khalid Batrawi said Law in the Service of Man, an organization affiliated with the Geneva-based International Commission of Jurists, has investigated incidents in which Palestinians were killed or wounded by Israelis wearing civilian or Arab clothes and operating with army backup.
“There isn’t one case where we can claim the army came to kill a particular person,” he said. “But there are many cases where there was no reason for the army to shoot.” Security sources and Israeli soldiers, who spoke on condition of anonymity, told The Associated Press that undercover military units operate in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
According to foreign published reports, two units use the code names “Cherry” and “Samson.” Reports have said their mission was to identify Arab ringleaders and demonstration organizers.
The army units are distinct from the Shin Bet security forces, which have operated in the West Bank and Gaza Strip since Israel seized the territory in the 1967 Middle East war. An Israeli source familiar with the army units said they did not have orders to shoot and any use of violence was an exception to standing orders.
Unit members carry weapons and usually wear T-shirts over army-issue khaki-colored pants. They sometimes masquerade as Arabs, donning traditional keffiyeh headdresses and driving vehicles with distinctive license plates reserved for Arab-owned cars — blue in the West Bank and white in the Gaza Strip.
Although there was no indication the units had a license to kill, questions have been raised about their tactics.
Eleven days after McAllen, and this printing has had two things taken out of it. The editor’s note is gone, so a reader in Odessa is not told that the story was submitted to the Israeli military censor. And the story stops. It ends on questions have been raised about their tactics, with an end-of-story rule under it, which cuts everything the Laredo printing carried from that point on: Rabin confirming the army uses confiscated Arab cars, the Financial Times correspondent and two Reuters journalists losing their press credentials for reporting on these units without submitting their stories to censorship, and the whole account of the shooting at Yatta — the van, the witness, and the names of the two men killed. What is left is the existence of the units and the official denials. It runs down a narrow column beside a full page of Western Auto advertising for halogen bulbs, car batteries and tires.
JERUSALEM (AP) — The 12th month of the Palestinian uprising in the occupied territories began with the fatal shooting by Israeli soldiers of a 3-year-old Arab boy. Elsewhere in the occupied lands Wednesday, 13 Palestinians, most of them teenagers, were shot and wounded by troops.
Meanwhile, Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir’s 10-member inner Cabinet debated PLO plans to declare an independent Palestinian state at the meeting of the governing Palestine National Council set to begin Saturday in Algeria. Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin and Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Dan Shomron warned that any violence coinciding with the meeting will be crushed.
“We are getting ready, deploying forces and issuing orders, to ensure one clear thing: attempts to violate public order and create mass riots … will be forcefully crushed from the very beginning,” Rabin said on Israel army radio. Shomron said additional forces would be deployed in the occupied lands during the meeting.
In the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, public transportation was halted and shops closed on Wednesday in the latest strike against the Israeli occupation of the territories captured in the 1967 Middle East war. The strike marked the start of the 12th month of an uprising that began Dec. 8. and has claimed the lives of 310 Arabs and 11 Israelis.
Osama Mohammed Abu Ganima was one of the youngest victims. The 3-year-old was shot in the chest in Gaza City’s Shajaiya quarter on Wednesday when an army jeep was pelted with stones and troops responded with gunfire, an Arab reporter said. Officials at Gaza’s Shifa Hospital said the boy was dead on arrival.
Family members said Osama was playing nearby when the shooting occurred. In the same incident, a 12-year-old Arab was shot in the jaw and a 13-year-old shot in the leg, hospital officials said. Jewish settlers in the West Bank, meanwhile, demanded tougher action against Arab rioters after a 52-year-old woman was hit in the head by a stone.
She was hospitalized in serious condition. Witnesses said police and troops brought dogs to the site…
Eleven weeks after a headline that gave a shot child an offense and no shooter, the same news agency leads with Israeli troops kill. The boy is named in the ninth paragraph: Osama Mohammed Abu Ganima, three years old, shot in the chest at Shajaiya, dead on arrival at Shifa. His family says he was playing nearby. The running count in the copy is 310 Arabs and 11 Israelis in twelve months.
JERUSALEM – An Israeli patrol yesterday opened fire at stone-throwing Palestinians in Gaza City, killing a 3-year-old boy and wounding two youths, Palestinian reports said.
The clash came as Palestinians marked the start of the 12th month of their uprising against Israeli occupation, blocking roads with burning tires, unfurling illegal Palestinian flags and shutting businesses with a general strike. At least 11 other Palestinians were reported wounded in clashes in the occupied Gaza Strip and West Bank.
In Gaza City’s Shajaiya quarter, an army jeep was pelted with stones and troops responded with gunfire, an Arab reporter said. Osama Mohammed Abu Ganima was killed when a bullet hit him in the chest, officials at Shifa Hospital said. Family members said the child was playing nearby when the shooting occurred.
In the same incident, a 12-year-old Arab was shot in the jaw and a 13-year-old was wounded in the leg, hospital officials said. An army spokesman in Gaza confirmed the child’s death. “We are questioning troops to see if the death resulted from army shooting,” he said on condition of anonymity.
Three teen-agers were reported wounded in the West Bank, hospital officials said. Jewish settlers in the occupied lands, meanwhile, demanded tougher action against Palestinians after a 52-year-old woman settler was injured in the head by a stone.
Margaret Rosner was struck Tuesday while traveling in a car that had come form the West Bank and was just inside Israel, Israeli news reports said. She was hospitalized in serious condition. The national Itim news agency said police arrested a Palestinian as a suspect.
Israel cracks down in Gaza Strip; Palestinians prepare for meeting
Associated Press
“JERUSALEM — Israeli troops in the occupied Gaza Strip wounded 12 Palestinians on Thursday and blew up the homes of nine accused of attacking soldiers with grenades or firebombs.
Islamic fundamentalists urged the Palestine National Council, which convenes Saturday in Algiers, to wage an armed struggle against Israel and criticized those who favor peace negotiations. A leaflet distributed by a group called Hamas (Zeal) said: ‘Who authorized the PNC to sign a peace agreement with the Jews?
Is it the Palestinian martyrs, is it the wounded, is it the Palestinian child … who lost an eye sitting in his mother’s lap? ‘We announce clearly: No to a Zionist state in the land of Palestine, no to peace with murderers … yes to the armed struggle.’
The 450-member PNC, which serves as a Palestinian legislature, is expected to declare an independent state in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, where 11 Israelis and at least 310 Palestinians have been killed in an 11-month-old rebellion against Israeli occupation.
Israeli troops are expected to seal off the occupied territories during the Palestine National Council meeting, barring journalists without escorts and prohibiting Palestinians from traveling to and from Israel. In the Gaza Strip, Maj. Gen.
Yitzhak Mordechai said the demolition of nine houses was a lesson to Palestinians that ‘those who try to hurt us with grenades and firebombs will find themselves hurt.’
Palestinians told Law in the Service of Man, a human rights group founded by Arab lawyers, that soldiers bulldozed 72 houses in the Jifliq shantytown near a settlement where an Israeli soldier was stabbed to death Monday. In the West Bank, soldiers raided seven Palestinian homes overnight in Nablus, Palestinian witnesses reported.
They said it was the third such action in as many days. The daily Maariv said the raids were intended to prevent violence during the PNC meeting and several Palestinians were detained.
Palestinians confirmed a report in the Jerusalem Post that soldiers smashed windows, vandalized furniture and beat residents, then ordered them into the streets to remove barricades from roads and paint over anti-Israeli graffiti. The army said it was checking the report.”
Eleven months after Hamas was founded, an American paper prints its leaflet at length and sets a sentence from it in display type across the top of the story. The paper glosses the name for its readers as Hamas (Zeal). The same page carries nine houses demolished as a stated lesson, 72 more bulldozed at Jifliq, and a Palestinian human rights group named by its own name — Law in the Service of Man, which is al-Haq.
“To The Commercial Appeal: It is sad to note that when a Palestinian child is killed by Israeli forces, it may be mentioned somewhere far down in the text of the story. However, when an Israeli child is killed your editors consider it worthy of a headline. There are only two conclusions that can be drawn from this fact.
Either The Commercial Appeal feels that a Palestinian child’s life is less important than an Israeli child’s or that so many Palestinian children have been killed by Israeli forces that it is no longer newsworthy. I suspect there is truth in both of them. RICHARD B. MEEK, Memphis”
A reader in Memphis in 1988 stating, in nine lines, the thing this archive counts: that the death of a Palestinian child goes into the text and the death of an Israeli child goes into the headline. He offers two explanations and declines to choose between them. It is the earliest clipping here in which a reader names the pattern rather than an individual story.
Israel rejects PLO declaration of independence for Palestinians
“This is another step in the war of Arab terror organizations against Israel’s existence and independence and we shall respond accordingly.” Both Peres and Shamir spoke at the Negev Desert communal farm of Sde Boker, where Israeli leaders gathered to pay tribute to Israel’s first prime minister, David Ben-Gurion, on the 15th anniversary of his death.
Left-wing Israelis welcomed the more moderate language of the PLO and the declaration’s recognition of the Jewish state. But hard-line politicians called for annexation or a massive drive to settle Jews in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip where 1.5 million Arabs and 70,000 Israelis live.
Trade Minister Ariel Sharon, a leading member of Shamir’s right-wing Likud bloc, called the declaration a “dangerous development” and said Israel should assert its claim by annexing part of the occupied land in response. He said the security situation in the occupied lands could further deteriorate.
At least 312 Palestinians and 11 Israelis have been killed in the 11-month uprising. In an interview with the daily Yediot Ahronot, Shamir called for negotiations under the U.S.-Soviet sponsorship as an alternative to a U.N.-sponsored international conference favored by the Arabs.
Negotiations would take place with Egyptian, Jordanian and Palestinian delegations but not the PLO, Yediot Ahronot reported. Israel’s major dailies headlined the PLO’s new political program announced in Algiers, focusing on its acceptance of U.N. Security Council Resolution 242 that implicitly recognizes Israel.
The Israeli reaction came after the PLO’s parliament-in-exile proclaimed an independent Palestinian state earlier today in Algeria, approving a new, moderate political program that indirectly recognizes Israel and renounces terrorism.
Addressing the body, PLO chairman Yasser Arafat declared that the state, with Jerusalem as its capital, would be run by “a democratic, parliamentary system based on freedom of expression and multiple parties.”
Correction: The deck paired this scan with the other caption on its slide. The masthead printed on the scan names this paper and this date.
ALGIERS, Algeria (AP) — It could be months before the PLO’s strategic shift from guerrilla warfare to political pragmatism, based on indirect recognition of Israel, has any real impact on Middle East peace efforts. But, if nurtured, the clear swing toward moderation by the Palestine Liberation Organization could mark the start of a serious peace dialogue.
The big question now is how far the United States and Israel are prepared to go in terms of direct talks with the PLO, which also declared an independent Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital.
Tuesday’s declarations in Algiers, by implicitly recognizing Israel and renouncing terrorism, mark a significant breakthrough in the Middle East peace process even though Palestinian pragmatists have long advocated the moves.
A veteran Western diplomat, speaking on condition of anonymity, described the Palestinian National Council’s resolutions as “a serious attempt” to break the logjam that has stymied previous efforts.
But with Ronald Reagan two months away from handing over the U.S. presidency to George Bush, it could be months before there is any significant movement in the Middle East equation.
The resolutions of the council, the PLO’s policy-making body and parliament-in-exile, spelled out for the first time, however timidly, Palestinians’ willingness to accept a state comprising only the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
The territories, which Israel seized in the 1967 Middle East war, are just part of what was originally Palestine — land the Palestinians have claimed since 1948. Nabil Shaath, head of the political committee that drafted the resolutions, said: “We expect a change in the American attitude toward the Palestinian problem.
If America looks hard and seriously enough, it will find all the elements needed for a true change in its position. “Only a blind statesman will fail to see what the Palestinians are offering,” he said. The United States’s longstanding preconditions for direct negotiations with the PLO have been that it recognize Israel and renounce terrorism.
The White House said Tuesday that the PLO resolutions had “positive elements”, and Bush said he wanted to be sure that the Palestinians have truly recognized Israel.
Israel calls PLO declaration of independence ‘doubletalk’
JERUSALEM — Israel rejected yesterday the Palestinian declaration of independence as an exercise in “ambiguity and doubletalk” that neither renounces terrorism nor clearly recognizes the Jewish state.
Israel was put on the defensive by the move toward moderation, however, and officials concede they face an uphill battle against the PLO attempt to win recognition for a Palestinian state. The Palestine National Council, acting as the PLO legislature, proclaimed the Palestinian state and issued a political declaration accepting U.N.
Security Council Resolution 242, which implicitly recognizes Israel’s right to exist. The declaration also limits PLO guerrilla action to military targets in the occupied territories. Only leftist groups in Israel praised the PLO for moderating its anti-Israeli language.
Extreme right-wing groups urged the government to respond by annexing part or all of the occupied lands and establishing new Jewish settlements.
The Foreign Ministry, which issued the Israeli government’s official reaction, said of the PLO declaration: “Ambiguity and doubletalk are again employed to excuse its advocacy of violence, resorting to terrorism and adherence to extreme positions.”
Ministry spokesman Alon Liel said: “They mentioned rejection of terrorism outside Israel, but they did not denounce terrorism inside Israel. So we still see the PLO as a terror organization, and the government decision not to negotiate with the PLO stands.”
Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir, who is expected to lead a new right-wing government, contended that moderating the PLO language was merely a tactic, part of an overall strategy to destroy Israel. He said the declaration was “another step in the war of Arab terror organizations against Israel’s existence and independence and we shall respond accordingly.”
Correction: The deck paired this scan with the other caption on its slide. The masthead printed on the scan names this paper and this date.
ALGIERS, Algeria — It could be months before the PLO’s strategic shift from guerrilla warfare to political pragmatism, based on indirect recognition of Israel, has any real impact on Middle East peace efforts. But, if nurtured, the clear swing toward moderation by the Palestine Liberation Organization could mark the start of a serious peace dialogue.
The big question now is how far the United States and Israel are prepared to go in terms of direct talks with the PLO, which also declared an independent Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital.
Yesterday’s declarations in Algiers, by implicitly recognizing Israel and renouncing terrorism, mark a significant breakthrough in the Middle East peace process even though Palestinian pragmatists have long advocated the moves.
A veteran Western diplomat, speaking on condition of anonymity, described the Palestinian National Council’s resolutions as “a serious attempt” to break the logjam that has stymied previous efforts.
But with Ronald Reagan two months away from handing over the U.S. presidency to George Bush, it could be months before there is any significant movement in the Middle East equation.
The resolutions of the council, the PLO’s policy-making body and parliament-in-exile, spelled out for the first time, however timidly, Palestinians’ willingness to accept a state comprising only the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
The territories, which Israel seized in the 1967 Middle East war, are just part of what was originally Palestine — land the Palestinians have claimed since 1948. Nabil Shaath, head of the political committee that drafted the resolutions, said: “We expect a change in the American attitude toward the Palestinian problem.
If America looks hard and seriously enough, it will find all the elements needed for a true change in its position. “Only a blind statesman will fail to see what the Palestinians are offering,” he said. The United States’s longstanding preconditions for direct negotiations with the PLO have been that it recognize Israel and renounce terrorism.
The White House said yesterday that the PLO resolutions had “positive elements”, and Bush said he wanted to be sure that the Palestinians have truly recognized Israel. Israeli leaders, however, rejected the PLO declaration of independence as being full of “double talk”, saying it did not explicity recognize Israel or renounce terrorism.
But some Israeli analysts said the move has put Israel on the defensive. The resolutions speak volumes about what moderate Palestinians see as achievable and what they will settle for to get the peace ball rolling.
The declaration of independence based its legitimacy for a Palestinian state, albeit territory occupied by Israel, on a 1947 United Nations resolution proposing the partition of Palestine into Arab and Jewish states. On that basis, it appears the PLO is prepared to negotiate.
But progress in attaining peace also hinges on how far Palestinian radicals are prepared to go along with the terms the national council laid down.
George Habash, leader of the Marxist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine and a longtime critic of PLO leader Yasser Arafat’s efforts to find a political solution, bluntly stated yesterday that as far as he was concerned the PLO has not recognized Israel.
The national council, whose members include Arafat rivals such as Habash, for the first time unanimously endorsed the Cairo Declaration on terrorism, which Arafat signed in 1985. That restricted guerrilla operations to targets inside Israel after two decades of worldwide war against the Jewish state.
Renunciation of terrorism is something Arafat twice has failed to convince the PLO’s legislative body to endorse. Neither the declaration of independence nor the political statement explicitly define the borders for an independent Palestinian state. Shaath said that even in that, the Palestinians were showing flexibility.
“It’s obvious from the political document that the shape and borders of the state is a negotiable detail.” That’s a long jump from the PLO’s 1968 charter, which stressed that the Palestinian state should embrace all the land under the British mandate after World War II, not just the West Bank and Gaza.
Asked what he thought the chances of peace were after the victory of the hard-line Likud bloc in Israel’s general election earlier this month, Shaath said: “Ironically, it helped us. The election showed the contrast between Israeli offers and Palestinian offers. The difference is striking and totally in our favor.”
About 60 people gathered in Tucson last night to celebrate the endorsing of a Palestinian declaration of independence. “This is a major step toward ending the exile,” said Jamil Qader, representing the Palestine Solidarity Committee and the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee. “It accepts a two-state solution.
I think it’s a major shift in the direction of peace. The main question now is how long will it take Israel and the U.S. to begin dealing with Palestinians and the issue of their rights,” Qader said.
Yesterday, the PLO’s chairman, Yasser Arafat, declared the state would be run by “a democratic, parliamentary system based on freedom of expression and multiple parties.” The Palestine National Council, the highest legislative body of the Palestininan people, endorsed the declaration.
“The PNC put forward some documents and a political program that will establish the first step toward bringing peace and justice in the Middle East,” said Mohyeddin Abdulaziz, also speaking for the two groups. “The Palestinian people are ready to talk peace. They are ready to talk with their enemies. There is a great opportunity for peace,” he said.
Abdulaziz said the Palestinian people recognize that the struggle will be long and hard, but they are ready for a change. He said the declaration has been made, but the West Bank and Gaza Strip still remain under Israeli occupation and “people are still being killed.”
In Tucson, the people gathered to eat, listen to music and celebrate the declaration, but they realize that they too have a struggle ahead. “We will have to double, triple, maybe even quadruple our efforts to get our (U.S.) government to recognize the Palestinian state,” Abdulaziz said.
ROADBLOCK — Israel confined 865,000 Palestinians to their homes today after the Palestinian declaration of independence, but some slipped past soldiers to place a roadblock of burning tires on the main road between the West Bank and Israel.
ALGIERS, Algeria (AP) — PLO chief Yasser Arafat said Tuesday the next move toward Middle East peace is up to the United States now that the Palestinians have declared an independent state and implicitly recognized Israel.
“The ball is now in the American court,” Arafat said a few hours after the Palestine National Council, which acts as the PLO legislature, proclaimed Palestinian independence in a ceremony early Tuesday. It accepted U.N.
Security Council Resolution 242, which implicitly recognizes Israel in its reference to the right of all countries in the region to exist within secure and recognized borders. The United States has refused to deal with the Palestine Liberation Organization until it recognized Israel and renounced terrorism.
In Washington, the Reagan administration said Tuesday there are “positive elements” in the PLO policy statement, but rejected the declaration of independence. State Department spokesman Charles Redman said the status of territories under Israeli occupation “cannot be determined by unilateral acts of either side, but only through a process of negotiations.
A declaration of independent Palestinian statehood is such a unilateral act.” The proclamation topped the list of issues taken up during the council’s four-day special session in Algeria, which ended Tuesday.
The 450-member council also voted to form a provisional government at a future date and pledged to restrict guerrilla operations to military targets in Israeli-occupied territories.
The council’s move, largely symbolic and clearly aimed at capitalizing on the 11-month-old Palestinian uprising in Israeli-occupied lands, sought to remove obstacles to U.S. and Israeli dealings with the Palestine Liberation Organization.
Referring to the intefadeh, or uprising, Arafat told a news conference: “It is true that this is the intefadeh session of the (council), but it also could be the session of peace with the U.S. administration and Israel.” The PLO chief said the council had given him a mandate to pursue a political settlement.
“But if we are met with a rebuff,” he said, “only God knows the outcome.”
Israeli soldiers oversee a pajama-clad Palestinian man paint over anti-Israel slogans Tuesday at Tulquarm in the occupied West Bank. The slogans were painted after the Palestine National Council declared an independent state Monday night.
Correction: The deck caption gave a shorter name than the masthead prints. Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 163 clippings in this deck.
GAZA CITY, Occupied Gaza Strip — Teen-agers challenged Israel’s authority with songs, rocks and flaming tires Wednesday despite army efforts to stop celebrations of the Palestinian declaration of independence. Soldiers wounded eight Palestinians in Gaza City and the town of Khan Yunis, said hospital officials in the Gaza Strip.
Those shot were protesters and violators of a military curfew that confined Gaza’s 650,000 residents to their homes for a sixth day. In the occupied West Bank, curfews and travel bans were imposed on about 250,000 Palestinians.
Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin said on state television: “I believe that the events of the last several days can become a turning point leading to a significant decrease in violence. . . . We can undertake all the legally allowed steps.”
Rabin said security actions have had a cumulative effect, “making it more and more difficult for the residents to conduct violent actions. . . . I believe that in three to six months we shall bring about a substantial quiet.”
A 25-year-old man wounded by soldiers three days ago in the Gaza Strip town of Rafah died Wednesday, raising to 313 the number of Palestinians killed since the uprising against Israeli occupation began Dec. 8, 1987. Eleven Israelis also have been killed.
Palestinians have been celebrating the independence declaration since it was issued Tuesday in Algiers by the Palestine National Council, which acts as the legislature of the Palestine Liberation Organization. Young men danced in the streets of Bethlehem in the West Bank and sang the Palestinian anthem “My Homeland, My Homeland.”
Masked youths carrying a sign saying “PLO, Israel No” marched on even after soldiers fired over their heads. Soldiers later were seen breaking into houses and ordering residents to clear rocks from the streets. Using loudspeakers, they ordered women to bring pails of water to put out fires.
Palestinian youths carry out orders to remove a roadblock and douse tires set ablaze by demonstrators in Gaza City. The city’s curfew is in its fifth day. ASSOCIATED PRESS
Strikes called to protest PLO declaration of independence
JERUSALEM (AP) — Moslem fundamentalists ordered Palestinians in the occupied lands to begin a three-day strike today to protest the PLO’s declaration of Palestinian independence. The strike call defied orders from PLO-linked leaders of the Palestinian uprising in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, and it signaled a growing rift in the Palestinian ranks.
Israel launched a political counterattack against the Palestine Liberation Organization. Foreign Minister Shimon Peres, who spearheaded the damage control effort, accused the PLO on Thursday of deceiving the world by claiming it moderated its positions.
Peres also charged that the Palestine National Council, the PLO’s policy-making body, sabotaged the peace process by declaring a Palestinian state at its four-day session in Algiers that ended Tuesday. In the occupied lands, Israeli troops shot and wounded at least 29 Palestinians in street battles Thursday, hospital officials said.
The army eased curfews and other restrictions imposed in an effort to curb riots and celebration connected with the independence declaration, but the curfew continued for the 250,000 Palestinians in the Gaza Strip’s eight refugee camps.
More than 7,000 Palestinians have been wounded in the occupied territories since the rebellion against 21 years of Israeli rule began Dec. 8. At least 313 Palestinians and 11 Israelis have been killed. Hospital officials said at least four people were seriously wounded in confrontations in the West Bank village of Tamoun and in several Gaza Strip areas.
“JABALIA REFUGEE CAMP, Occupied Gaza Strip — Smoke from a burning tire splashes as orange and black streaks of protest against the gray morning sky. Open sewers turn unpaved streets to mud and fill the air with the stench of human waste. ‘Soldiers!’ shriek a group of children as they scatter down alleys. A jeep stops in the road.
Five Israeli soldiers pile out and use M-16 rifles to force male passers-by to—”
The scan is 283 pixels wide across two columns and a map, so only the byline and the opening paragraphs have been re-read against it. The map beside the story is headed “Gaza strip.”
“The U.N.’s moral authority evaporated in the 1970s when it became dominated by radical Third World regimes… The U.N. should be called the U.R. — United Regimes. The United Nations has little to do with representing nations, properly understood as peoples united by political and cultural affinities.
One reason U.N. hostility toward Israel is so unremitting is that Israel is a real nation with a representative regime. To most U.N. members, whose national cohesion is based on coercion, Israel is either unintelligible or a reproach. The PLO, an organization formally dedicated to the destruction of a U.N. member, was granted U.N.
‘observer’ status in 1975, the year the United Nations passed the resolution equating Zionism and racism.
Actually, Zionism is an especially defensible nationalism… On the principle that the best defense is a good offense, President-elect Bush and his nominee for secretary of state, James Baker, should say to the United Nations: Go to Geneva — and do not return until you have rescinded the Zionism-as-racism resolution.
That resolution is integral to the U.N.’s principal enterprise: the delegitimization of Israel.… The Republican Party platform of 1988 says: ‘The Republican Party reaffirms its support for recision of U.N. Resolution 3379, which equates Zionism with racism. Failure to repeal that resolution will justify attenuation of our support for the U.N.’
If the United Nations wants to squander more millions on a Geneva homage to Arafat, let the sum be deducted from U.S. obligations… Now, exactly who favors cutting Medicare to subsidize Arafat?”
The repeal campaign, three years before it succeeded, written as an ultimatum and carrying the Republican platform language that made it policy. It runs beside a Jeff MacNelly cartoon in which men labeled THE EXPERTS study a wall sprayed WE RECOGNIZE ISRAEL’S RIGHT TO EXIT and reassure each other that it must be a typo.
NABLUS, Occupied West Bank — Naila Zaiter sits sullenly in her home overlooking the streets of this city, painfully recalling that October morning in 1972 — the day she learned of her brother's murder. “Wael was a peaceful person who never carried a gun,” Zaiter said, staring at his picture on the wall.
“Whenever anyone asks me about them — beasts I call them — I think of my brother, the one who said we should coexist with them. There are, of course, civilized Jews, but they are not the majority.” Wael, a Palestinian writer and outspoken critic of the Israelis, was living in Rome when he was gunned down Oct.
12, 1972, by Israeli agents, who later confessed to the killing. Zaiter sees Israelis, who have occupied the West Bank and Gaza Strip since the Six-Day War of 1967, as European invaders. “This is my land,” she said. “We come from this part of the world. We belong to it. They can't take it by force, occupy us and expect us to surrender.”
Contempt is as raw on the other side of the fence. David Ramati, chief of military security for Efrat, one of the 200 Jewish settlements on the West Bank, respects Palestinians only as enemies. “Quite a few Jews have been seriously injured,” says Ramati, a Wisconsin native who emigrated to Israel in the late 1960s.
“A few have had their brains crushed with rocks. One was shot in the back of the head.” In Ramati's opinion, Palestinians are unsophisticated people who do not understand that the territories were promised to Jews by God. “We are freeing the land of foreign domination,” he said, sitting comfortably in his small Efrat office.
Israeli security forces monitor an East Jerusalem thoroughfare as a Palestinian woman walks to the Al-Aqsa Mosque, where Muslims pray each day.
Hits home is a phrase for news arriving somewhere, and here it arrives at the people it is about — as though the uprising were weather that reached the West Bank rather than something the people of the West Bank were doing. Printed on the first anniversary.
Israeli security forces monitor an East Jerusalem thoroughfare as a Palestinian woman walks to the Al-Aqsa Mosque
“Israeli security forces monitor an East Jerusalem thoroughfare as a Palestinian woman walks to the Al-Aqsa Mosque, where Muslims pray each day.” Photo: ROB RITZENTHALER.
Two files of soldiers with batons down both sides of a lane, and a woman in a white headscarf walking between them with a man behind her. The verb the caption gives the soldiers is monitor. The woman is going to prayer, which the caption explains happens every day, as though the daily thing in the picture were the praying.
STOCKHOLM, Sweden (AP) — PLO leader Yasser Arafat arrived in Sweden today for a meeting with a group of American Jews arranged by the Swedish government.
The five-member Jewish delegation was mostly from the International Center for Peace in the Middle East, a coalition of leftist groups in Israel and abroad. The group’s members urge Israel to negotatiate directly with Arafat’s Palestine Liberation Organization with a view toward relinquishing at least some of the Arab territory captured in the 1967 Mideast War.
The Israeli government refuses to talk to the PLO and has urged its Jewish supporters in the United States not to do so. The international chairman of the peace center is Israel’s former foreign minister, Abba Eban. Its Israeli branch includes prominent members of Eban’s left-leaning Labor Party.
The Swedish Foreign Ministry said the U.S. delegation was headed by Rita Hauser, a New York lawyer and chairman of the peace center’s American branch.
Other members were Drora Kass, the center’s executive director; executive board member Stanley Sheinbaum, an economist and publisher from Los Angeles; Menachem Rosensaft, president of the Labor Zionist Alliance and chairman of the Network of Children of Holocaust Survivors; and Professor Avraham Udovitch, chairman of the department for Near East Studies at Princeton University. Arafat’s delegation included Mahmoud Darwish and Yasser Abed-Rabbo, both members of the PLO executive committee, his spokesman Bassam Abu Sharif and Akram Haniyeh, a former Palestinian journalist who was expelled by Israel. Arafat, after being greeted at the airport by Foreign Minister Sten Andersson, boarded a helicopter at Arlanda International Airport bound for Haga Palace, a government guest house… The Israeli Foreign Ministry in Jerusalem telephoned the Swedish ambassador to lodge an official protest over the government’s invitation to the leader of the Palestine Liberation Organization.
Eleven months after asking what a poet does on an executive council, here he is doing it: Mahmoud Darwish named second in Arafat’s delegation to Stockholm, in a small Illinois daily, in the week before the PLO recognized Israel. Beside him is Akram Haniyeh, identified here as a journalist Israel expelled — and the same man who, twenty years later, sat at Darwish’s bedside in the Houston hospital where he died. The paper’s spelling, negotatiate, is kept.
Police arrest 13 Israeli Arabs over a grenade attack
“The police today arrested 13 Israeli Arabs, including two soldiers, who are suspected of belonging to a faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization.”
Including two soldiers — Bedouin citizens of Israel serve in the army, which the rest of the coverage in this archive almost never mentions. The clause is a parenthesis here.
GAZA CITY, Occupied Gaza Strip — Israeli soldiers shot a teen-ager in the heart Thursday, and Palestinians held a general strike on the first anniversary of their uprising against Israel's 21-year occupation. The death of Yussef Mohammed Sbaith, 17, raised the number of Palestinians killed to at least 320 since the rebellion began Dec. 8, 1987, in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
Eleven Israelis have been slain and more than 7,000 Palestinians have been wounded. An army spokesman said Sbaith was shot in the heart when troops were stoned during a sweep of the West Bank village of Kafr Rai.
Soldiers also wounded a 22-year-old woman in the leg after meeting “violent resistance” from stone-throwing youths in the village, said the spokesman, whose name cannot be revealed under army rules. Army gunfire wounded 11 other Palestinians, including a 14-year-old boy shot in the stomach, Arab doctors said.
The clashes occurred in the West Bank's largest city, Nablus, in the villages of Kabatiya and Beit Lid to the north and in Gaza City, they said. On the political front, meanwhile, Israel's left-leaning Labor Party voted by an overwhelming majority Thursday to re-enter negotiations with the hard-line Likud bloc on forming a joint national unity government.
The decision was a reversal of the party's 110-member Executive Bureau, which last week voted against further talks. The Israeli Civil Rights Association filed a complaint Thursday alleging that paramilitary border police severely beat six Palestinian women and sexually assaulted three of them in Gaza.
The women, including one who was nine months pregnant, filed affidavits together with medical reports showing a border police raid in Khan Younis refugee camp had left one with a broken arm, another with broken teeth and a third with a broken eardrum. Palestinians closed businesses and halted public transportation throughout the occupied territories.
The underground leadership, which the Palestine Liberation Organization supports, called the strike for the anniversary of the revolt in the occupied lands. Israel captured the West Bank from Jordan and the Gaza Strip from Egypt in the 1967 Middle East war.
Israeli military authorities clamped a curfew on the entire Gaza Strip, confining more than 650,000 Palestinians to their homes. The civil rights affidavits by members of the Abu Dakka family said that on Oct. 19, as they walked to work, they were attacked and chased into a house by border policemen who teamed up to hold them, beat them and molest three of them.
Tahani Abu Dakka, 28, testified that a soldier followed her into her house and blocked her against a wall with his body, putting his hand under her blouse in front of members of her family and neighbors, she said. Nabila Halil Abu Dakka, nine months pregnant, said she was beaten by several men with clubs and rifle butts.
The dead 17-year-old is named. The army spokesman who describes his death is not, because his name cannot be revealed under army rules. The dateline reads GAZA CITY, Occupied Gaza Strip.
Two Palestinians killed, 22 hurt in occupied lands
Death toll now 10 from Israeli attack on Lebanon base
“Hosni Abu Sido, was one of a group of teen-agers who threw gasoline-filled bottles at a patrol yesterday morning several hours after a curfew was lifted and residents were allowed out of their homes… he tried to stab a guard with a homemade knife while he and other inmates in Gaza City’s prison were taken out on a daily walk, the army said… All 650,000 residents of the Gaza Strip were under curfew yesterday to prevent violence marking the first anniversary of the upris—… lence in memory of the Palestinians killed in the uprising, which began Dec.
8, 1987… Lebanon requested an urgent meeting of the U.N. Security Council to debate the attack, which drew sharp condemnation from the United States and Britain.” The line across the top of the page reads “BATTLE FOR PROMISED LAND 11A.”
A strip cut from the top of a page: the headline, the line beneath it and the first lines of four columns, each broken off. Hosni Abu Sido is named in the first of them.
Intifadah has shown Palestinians their own strength
By Mary Curtius
Globe Staff
RAMALLAH, Israeli-occupied West Bank — Palestinians living in the West Bank and Gaza Strip are counting the losses and gains of the past 12 months and digging in to keep their revolt against Israel's military rule alive. On Dec.
9, 1987, Israeli troops shot to death two Palestinian youths in Jabaliya, a Gaza Strip refugee camp, during a clash between thousands of youths and badly outnumbered troops. The youths were protesting the deaths of four Jabaliya workers who were killed when a truck driven by an Israeli struck the van they were riding in.
The demonstrations quickly spread to other refugee camps. What made these riots different from past flareups is that they could not be put down and they did not stay confined to the camps.
Despite confident predictions by Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir, Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin and other senior officials that the demonstrations could be suppressed in a matter of weeks, the violence escalated into a civil revolt.
It came out of the refugee camps, where Palestinians have little to hope for and almost nothing to lose, and for the first time engulfed Palestinian cities and villages. Passivity ends The decades-long passivity of two key elements of Palestinian society, the urban middle class and rural farmers, was ended.
“Intifadah” — literally, the shaking — is the name given to the end of that passivity. The Palestinian revolt has not ended or even seriously threatened Israel's control of the territories. It has produced a Palestinian state in name only.
And yet both Israeli officials who deal with the territories on a daily basis and the Palestinians who live there agree that the changes wrought during the intifadah are profound and quite possibly irreversible.
After capturing the territories during the June 1967 Arab-Israeli war, Israel governed the 1.5 million residents living in the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem almost effortlessly. The keystone of Israeli policy was the building of ever-stronger economic links between Palestinians of the cities and villages and Israel.
Palestinian businessmen were allowed to operate relatively freely, farmers were left alone, and workers were welcomed by the thousands into pre-1967 Israel as the government worked hard to erase the so-called Green Line that marked the pre-1967 border between Israel and the West Bank.
Israeli policy makers — starting with former Defense Minister Moshe Dayan, the man who laid the foundations of occupation policy — believed that as long as the economic links were strong, the Palestinians would never risk revolt.
That belief disintegrated in the early months of the intifadah amid the fury of demonstrations that were played out daily not only in squalid camps such as Jabaliya, but also in prosperous towns such as Beit Sahur, Ramallah, Bethlehem and Nablus.
Bearing the losses In the last 12 months, the Palestinians have shown a capacity to bear economic losses and sustain casualties that Rabin told Israeli newspaper editors he had never imagined possible. Since the intifadah began, 322 Palestinians have been killed, according to news agency tallies. Thousands have been injured. Some 20,000 have been imprisoned.
Nearly 100 homes have been demolished by the Israelis. Dozens of men have been deported. Living standards have dropped dramatically. Even so, people in the camps, towns and villages seem bouyant and determined to keep the intifadah going.
“We don't think there will be a Palestinian state in one or two years,” said Abdel Jabbar Sarhan, 34, who lives in Tulkarm refugee camp in the northern West Bank. “We have to be patient. If the intifadah hasn't brought a solution yet, it has made the Israelis aware that there is a problem.”
Sarhan said he learned patience during the six months he was held without being charged in the desert prison of Ketziot this year. Administrative detention, which allows the authorities to detain a Palestinian for six months at a time without taking the case against him to court, has been used against more than 5,000 people since the intifadah began.
Sarhan went to Ketziot in March and came out in August. More soldiers than ever He came back to the camp where he was born to find more soldiers than ever patrolling its dirt roads, and more children confronting the soldiers than he would have dreamed possible before the intifadah. The camp, which covers 2 square miles of hilly land, is home to 13,000 people, Sarhan said.
It has spent a total of three months under curfew — every resident confined to his home — since December 1987. “Everyday, there are three or four wounded,” he said. Hundreds have been arrested. Eight camp residents have been killed. What do Palestinians have to show for the sacrifices. Sarhan was asked.
“The greatest achievement was the clarification of our Palestinian identity,” he said. “That reached its peak at the Palestine National Council meeting in Algiers,” he said, referring to the Nov. 15 meeting at which the council declared Palestine an independent state.
“The greatest sacrifice is the continuous flow of blood each day,” Sarhan said. “You should view the intifadah as being done by the Palestinians for the sake of both Israelis and Palestinians,” Sarhan said. “One Palestinian eye is always on Israeli society, to gauge the impact what we do is having on them.”
The home of the Abu Ayash family in the West Bank village of Beit Ummar was destroyed by a Molotov cocktail. Graffiti on the remains reads “Palestine is our homeland, our home is not made of stone.” / Omar Abu Ayash tends his grapes in Beit Ummar.
A Boston paper, one year in, writing the uprising as something that happened to the Palestinians rather than something done to them — and the thing it did was show them what they had. The same edition carried two of them killed by Israeli troops (CP-1988-031). The paper spells it Intifadah; a Canadian paper the same day spells it intifada.
The home of the Abu Ayash family in the West Bank village of Beit Ummar was destroyed
“The home of the Abu Ayash family in the West Bank village of Beit Ummar was destroyed by a Molotov cocktail. Graffiti on the remains reads ‘Palestine is our homeland, our home is not made of stone.’”
“The home of the Abu Ayash family in the West Bank village of Beit Ummar was destroyed by a Molotov cocktail. Graffiti on the remains reads ‘Palestine is our homeland, our home is not made of stone.’” Globe photos / Thea Breite
A photograph and its caption; the story is not on this clipping. A tent stands beside the rubble, and the family’s own words are painted on what is left of the wall.
Israeli troops kill 2 Palestinians, wound 17 in day of unrest
Associated Press
JERUSALEM — Israeli troops yesterday shot and killed a Palestinian youth who hurled a firebomb at soldiers in Gaza City, the army said, and also shot to death a Palestinian prisoner who attacked a guard with a homemade knife.
At least 17 Palestinians were shot and wounded yesterday in the occupied lands, Arab hospital officials said. [...] youth, Hosni Abu Sido, was one of a group of teen-agers who threw gasoline-filled bottles at a patrol yesterday morning several hours after a curfew was lifted and residents were allowed out of their homes, an army spokesman said.
“The lives of soldiers were in danger and the commander of the patrol opened fire,” said a military spokesman who demanded anonymity.
“The boy who was killed was clearly the one who threw a Molotov cocktail.” [...] The prisoner, 20-year-old Abdallah Abu Mahruka, was killed when he tried to stab a guard with a homemade knife as he and other inmates in Gaza City's prison were taken out on a daily walk, the army said.
Abu Mahruka was serving an 18-month sentence for preparing firebombs, the army spokesman said. The deaths raised the number of Palestinians killed in the year-old anti-Israeli revolt to 322.
Eleven Israelis have been killed [...] [...] keepers closed their shops and traffic stood still for five minutes of silence in memory of the Palestinians killed in the uprising, which began Dec. 8, 1987. About 250,000 Arabs were confined to their homes in Gaza refugee camps for the third straight day.
All 650,000 residents of the Gaza Strip were under curfew Friday to prevent violence marking the first anniversary of the uprising. [...] police fired tear gas and rubber bullets to disperse demonstrators who threw rocks in the Arab commercial center near the walled Old City and in several Arab neighborhoods. No injuries were reported.
Police arrested seven girls in another clash in East Jerusalem, which began when a police van was stoned and one of its windows smashed. In northern Israel, arsonists caused serious damage when they set a mosque on fire in the Israeli city of Haifa, Israeli radio said.
An anonymous telephone caller told police he set the fire to punish [illegible]tin residents, 10 of whom were accused last week of being members of an anti-Israeli guerrilla squad. The suspected guerrillas, all Arabs of Israeli citizenship, were accused of throwing a hand grenade that blew the leg off a Haifa boy in July.
Israeli troops kill, which is plain, and then the deaths happen in day of unrest, which puts them inside a condition rather than at the end of an act. The same paper on the same day ran a column headed Intifadah has shown Palestinians their own strength (CP-1988-029).
U.S., PLO talks improve chance for Palestinian state
By Barry Schweid, The Associated Press
WASHINGTON — Establishment of a Palestinian state is more possible now that the United States is talking to the PLO and inching toward support of a seat for Yasser Arafat’s organization in Mideast peace talks. For several reasons, the PLO chairman is being vague about where the state would be set up.
Arafat said in Geneva his state would exist alongside Israel, but he has not said whether the Palestine he envisions would cut deeper into the Jewish state. Clearly, he wants to take control of the West Bank and Gaza, held by Israel since 1967 and the home of 1.2 million Palestinian Arabs and 60,000 Jews. And without question he wants part of Jerusalem, the Israeli capital.
But what about a corridor to the Mediterranean Sea? Or other land?
Palestinians carrying the outlawed Palestinian flag move to confront Israeli soldiers earlier this year.
· The Daily Item · Port Chester · page 17, A Section
U.S. holds key to justice for Palestinians, security for Israel
By Connie Hogarth
I have just returned from a two-week eyewitness human rights mission to the Middle East as part of a 10-person delegation representing peace activists and organizations from around the U.S.
We represented the Fellowship of Reconciliation of Nyack; New Jewish Agenda; National Rainbow Coalition; WESPAC; Presbyterian Church USA-Synod of Alaska-Northwest; Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom, USA; and the YWCA, USA, among others.
Our visit included overnight stays with families living in the refugee camps of the West Bank and Gaza as well as visits with members of a number of Israeli peace groups, human rights organizations, hospitals in the occupied territories, academics (most of whom are not allowed to teach since the universities in the territories have been closed) and religious leaders including Father Elias Shakour of Nazareth who is now well-known in the states for his recent book about the Palestinian-Israel conflict, “Blood Brothers.”
My observations during this trip confirm the belief that the intefadeh, the uprising, now a year old, will not cease until the Palestinian people in the occupied territories achieve their independence.
The intefadeh, the resistance to 20 years of occupation, has generated a dynamic force among Palestinians we encountered from all walks of life living in the occupied territories of the West Bank and Gaza. My experience in Gaza was with a family of a teacher and his wife, the grandmother and eight children, in the Jabalia refugee camp where the intefadeh began.
Like other refugee camps but among the worst, Jabalia is a conglomeration of overcrowded hovels of concrete, made habitable only because people have to live in them. The center of the community holds a huge cesspool, like a lake in a town plaza. Children teem through the narrow alleys, which are often sealed off by wire fences or oil cans.
Israeli soldiers sit on rooftops, rifles cocked. In the West Bank, schools have been closed for nearly a year as punishment and because education feeds resistance. In Gaza, schools are officially open but more frequently closed because of military-imposed curfews, during which everyone must stay indoors, sometimes for weeks.
Connie Hogarth
A Westchester County paper, on the day before Christmas week, putting the United States in the subject position and justice for Palestinians in the object. The sentence the visitors were asked to bring home ran in a ruled box across the tops of the third and fourth columns and was held here as a record of its own until 14 November 2026. The paper set it as “The plea was for us to bring back the message to the United States that the Palestinian people want to live in peace … sharing the benefits, beauty and riches of that Holy Land.” The ellipsis is the paper’s, and what it takes out is , two states, Israel and Palestine, and the visions of cousins. Nobody is quoted saying any of it. The words are the writer’s own, lifted from her fifth column and trimmed to fit the box, so the sentence a reader meets in display type as a Palestinian plea is an American visitor summarising what she was told. The verb the Palestinians are given is plea.
JERUSALEM How should Israel respond to the United States decision to begin a dialogue with the Palestine Liberation Organization? The legitimacy accorded by the P.L.O. to the terms “peace” and “Israel,” and, even more so, the willingness to link the two, have justifiably drawn considerable attention. None of us should ignore the evolution in the P.L.O.'s rhetoric.
Yet, given a long history of double talk and brutal performance by this organization, we must insist on a matching transformation in performance. Long and bitter experience has forced us to distinguish between Palestinians and the P.L.O. The Palestinians are a people whose legitimate rights we have long recognized.
We seek a political accommodation with them, as our dispute can have no military solution. We have set our sights on the negotiating table, and away from the battlefield, and we hope they will do the same. The P.L.O. triggers a different set of associations. In adopting a strategy of terror, the P.L.O. has united Israelis against it.
Smashing a child's head with a rock or throwing a crippled elderly man with his wheelchair into the sea are national traumas that cannot be forgotten. Moreover, we find the prospect of an independent Palestinian state worrisome. A hostile Palestinian armed force stationed between the Jordan River and Jerusalem is bound to prove unacceptable to its neighbors.
Finally, the suggestion of an independent Palestinian identity on the West Bank and Gaza is based on the notion of artificially dividing the Palestinian people.
But with Palestinians in Jordan and the West Bank sharing a common culture, dialect, heritage and family ties, the Jordan River can serve neither as a knife nor as an iron curtain severing links that do not end at river's edge. Our pursuit of a solution within a Jordanian-Palestinian framework has been based on these realities.
Now, the new dialogue between the United States and the P.L.O., as well as the decision of King Hussein of Jordan to disengage from the territories — although reversible if he so chooses — have created a new, no less complicated environment. While convinced of the need to move forward, we remain unwilling to yield to old and new obstacles.
If, at the moment, a joint Jordanian-Palestinian delegation with which to negotiate a comprehensive settlement seems unavailable, we stand ready to negotiate interim arrangements separately with each party. While the Jordanian partner is easily identifiable, even though perhaps not yet readily available, the Palestinian partner remains elusive.
Israel will sit down to the table only with Palestinians who represent their people in a nonviolent manner, who wish to promote their aspirations on a nonviolent platform, and who are people of peace seeking accommodation. They should be representatives who draw their authority not from bullets but from the ballot, elected by the people — not selected by events.
Accordingly, we propose the holding of free and secret political elections for the West Bank and Gaza, to be conducted in an atmosphere of tranquility and — on our part — total noninterference. We are tuned to hear equal readiness on the Palestinian side.
We shall observe the United States-Palestinian dialogue with an eye to its impact on the willingness of Palestinians in the territories to abandon violence and seek a mandate from their own people in a democraic way. As we are determined to contain expressions of violence, we cannot and shall not censor expressions of political aspirations.
For this program to succeed — for Palestinians to freely elect their representatives and articulate their views on interim solutions to be negotiated and a comprehensive settlement to be explored — close American-Israeli coordination is essential.
Much as we pursued a detailed and codified understanding with Washington during the previous phase, so must we agree to coordinate our efforts and formalize our mutual understanding today.
We shall seek to build on the solid foundation of American-Israeli friendship, shared values and community of interests to jointly rekindle both hope and efforts to bring long-desired peace between Israel and its neighbors.
JERUSALEM — Israel’s deputy foreign minister Thursday sought to tie the PLO to the bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 and blamed the U.S. decision to talk to the guerrilla organization for encouraging international terrorism.
The statement by Binyamin Netanyahu, a leading member of Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir’s Likud bloc, follows repeated Israeli criticism of the United States for including Yasser Arafat and the Palestine Liberation Organization in the Middle East peace process.
Talks “sending message to PLO”. “By having these kinds of talks . . . you are sending a message, a very clear message, that terrorism pays,” Netanyahu said. “The American talks with the PLO have seriously weakenened the American effort against terrorism.” He said suspicion in the Dec.
21 Pan Am bombing focused on groups experienced with the type of explosives used in the blast, including the PLO and Syria. However, he said he had no firm information on who was to blame for the bombing, and an Israeli security expert said Arafat’s mainstream PLO faction was “not a likely candidate.”
Netanyahu’s comments echoed Shamir’s, who suggested Tuesday that Washington’s decision was encouraging renewed infiltration attacks along the Israeli border. Shamir said the American move “encouraged the tendency of violent acts against Israel.”
Israel hopes talks canceled. A government source, speaking on condition of anonymity, said this week that a major Israeli foreign policy goal would be to reverse Washington’s decision to talk to the PLO. On Thursday, Netanyahu called the PLO “the foremost practitioner of aviation terrorism.”
It was responsible for the first airliner hijacking, the first destruction of a passenger plane in flight and the first gun and grenade attack on passengers, he said. “I say the PLO, I mean Fatah, I mean Arafat,” he said, referring to the PLO chief’s mainstream guerrilla group…
Expert doubts Arafat involved. Ariel Merari, an Israeli terrorism expert, told reporters at the news conference that he doubted the mainstream PLO would have carried out the attack when Arafat is making statements about peace with Israel. “I don’t think the present political situation is such that the PLO would sponsor such an attack,” he said.
“My guess is at least for a while they’ll refrain from international terrorism because it is politically counterproductive.” Merari, director of a project on terrorism at Tel Aviv University, said earlier he believed the Pan Am attackers probably were radical PLO factions opposed to Arafat’s more moderate stands.
The accusation and the Israeli expert’s doubt about it, at the same news conference, in the same story. “Weakenened” is the paper’s.
KCET tonight offers a highly provocative, meaty and very human one-hour documentary about the current state of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Written, produced and reported for PBS by John P. Wallach, the program, “Israel and the Palestinians: Will Reason Prevail?”, goes right to the key sources — the leaders and others directly involved.
This 9-10 p.m. broadcast will naturally touch the nerves of those on both sides who are sensitive to the objectivity of reports of the emotional issue — but the hour does not take the easy way out by trying to pussyfoot around issues.
On the contrary, there is some tough questioning and digging for the facts, as well as a program structure that enables viewers, whatever their feelings, to get some clear and simple perspectives on a highly complex matter. The program, of course, focuses on the controversy at the West Bank and Gaza areas.
And it was shot in October and November on the West Bank, just before the area was closed to foreign journalists. Among those interviewed are Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin, Egyptian President Anwar Sadat and Yasser Arafat, leader of the Palestine Liberation Organization.
Others questioned include Israel's former defense minister, Ezer Weizman, and ex-prime minister, Yitzhak Rabin, as well as a number of Palestinians. The hour offers a wide range of views of possible solutions to the explosive conflict, ranging from extremists to moderates. And it takes on a poignant tone in dealing with the effect of the dispute on children involved.
Shots of the land in question are a major plus in capturing the historic significance and tradition of the conflict at hand. And the crisp pace of the hour is a welcome change from the many plodding PBS documentaries that seem constructed by committees.
“Making his point: PLO leader Yasser Arafat shows the V-sign during his press conference in Helsinki Tuesday. Arafat rejected an Israeli idea of holding Palestinian elections in occupied territories.” Associated Press.
A month after the PLO recognized Israel at Geneva. The caption calls the territories occupied without quotation marks and without attribution, in the paper’s own voice — which is the thing this archive tracks across the dateline fold. The photograph is of a man making a V-sign; the caption says he is making his point.
JERUSALEM (AP) — The Israeli army began enforcing a tougher policy Tuesday against stone-throwing Arab rioters. The army blew up the homes of three people suspected of stoning soldiers, and commanders allowed Israeli soldiers to fire more freely to quell violent protests in the occupied territories.
Three Palestinians were killed Tuesday and 16 were wounded in clashes with Israeli soldiers in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, Arab reports said. Army officials confirmed the deaths and said they were checking the injury reports. The revised regulations were issued at a time of mounting Palestinian casualties, including seven teen-agers killed in the last six days.
In all, 362 Palestinians and 15 Israelis have been killed since the series of riots and violent protests began 13 months ago. The United States and the U.N. secretary-general expressed concern Tuesday over the growing casualties.
Also Tuesday, Israeli soldiers confronted Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir at an army camp outside the West Bank city of Nablus and said they had been forced to beat innocent people and betray their nation's values to maintain order.
They accused Shamir of sending soldiers into the West Bank and the Gaza Strip without understanding what the soldiers had to do to suppress the protests. Several said they were ashamed of their actions and had difficulty facing friends and loved ones when they returned home.
Shamir said that the Palestinians were intent on destroying Israel and that the soldiers must defend their homeland. “They force us to bear arms, but we must do that to survive,” Shamir said. Lt. Gen.
Dan Shomron, army chief of staff, said the new policy was aimed at quelling stone-throwing, which he called the army's key problem in putting down the protests against Israeli rule in the occupied land. “We will increase the punishment . . . so there is a higher price to pay for throwing stones,” Shomron said.
“In my opinion, this will increase deterrence.” He said the army would raze homes or order specific damage to the property of Palestinians caught throwing stones. If youths younger than 14 are involved, their parents face fines of at least $1,000, army officials said. Authorities will resort to demolition only in cases of serious damage or injury, officials said.
Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir speaking to soldiers Tuesday in Nablus, in the Israeli-occupied West Bank. He was responding to soldiers who had complained they were forced to beat innocent Palestinians.
Israeli officials play down offer from Shamir to withdraw troops
Herald Wire Services, Hebron, West Bank
“‘If the army withdraws from the cities, we expect the most horrible things, riots and demonstrations of thousands,’ Rabbi Moshe Levinger… told Foreign Minister Moshe Arens… ‘They [the Palestinians] will go out from the cities and conduct pogroms,’ said Levinger, who is under investigation in the slaying of a Hebron shopkeeper during a stone-throwing incident… More than 70,000 Jewish settlers live among the 1.7 million Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.”
One of two printings of the same Associated Press dispatch, the same morning. This one is datelined HEBRON, West Bank. The other, in Worcester, is datelined HEBRON, Occupied West Bank. Six years earlier a wire story had stopped to tell readers that newspapers use pogroms of violence against settlers; here is the word in a named speaker’s mouth, about violence that has not happened. Palestinians are the subject of every paragraph and not one is quoted.
“‘If this (withdrawal) proposal is accepted, terrible things will happen… There will be riots and demonstrations by tens of thousands (of Palestinians)… They will go out from the cities and conduct pogroms’… In the West Bank, a Palestinian was killed in a clash with troops, bringing the Palestinian death toll in the uprising to 371.”
The same Associated Press dispatch as the Miami Herald printing, the same day, and the clearest instrument in this collection. Three things differ: this dateline says Occupied and Miami’s does not; this printing carries a man’s death and a running count of 371 that Miami does not carry at all; and the same quotation appears here as tens of thousands where Miami has thousands. Whether a reader understood a settler leader to have predicted riots by thousands or by tens of thousands depended on which paper they held.
“The army had determined that one of the children, a 15-year-old boy from the village of Qabatiya, died after picking up an unexploded shell in a closed military area.”
The passive voice is the story. Devices are studied, children are killed and wounded, and the sentence never arrives at a hand that placed anything. Three branches of the Israeli security services investigate what the headline calls mysterious.
“Israel’s existence is threatened by one of the legacies of its greatest victories: the Palestinian people.”
Alon Ben-Meir, by way of the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, in the second year of the first intifada. The sentence names the people and makes them a legacy of a victory.
I would like to clarify the caption accompanying a picture illustrating the article “The Ambiguous Yasir Arafat” (by Marie Colvin, Dec. 18). In the caption, I am described as an Arafat associate. I am not Mr. Arafat’s associate. I am a Palestinian student, studying in Paris, and working as a journalist for an Arab news agency. I was in Algiers as a journalist.
BEIT SAHUR, Israeli-occupied West Bank, March 13 — At 7 P.M. this town near Bethlehem is dark, its streets empty under a a chilly drizzle. In a tiny alley called Qanaa, a heavily armed Israeli soldier is barely visible against a wall. Across the street, two companions stand guard nervously while more soldiers search a house.
Neighbors peek from their windows, then quickly retreat. “We do this twice a week,” the soldier said of his all-night patrol. “It’s a lousy job.” The women weep; the alleys are hazardous. Less than three weeks ago, an Israeli soldier died when a cinder block was dropped on his head in a similar twisted alley at the Nablus Casbah.
Yes, said the soldier, who would not give his name, he feels sorry for the Palestinians who are awakened in the early morning hours. Many times the Israeli soldiers are there to ask Palestinians to come out and paint over a slogan praising the Palestine Liberation Organization, or to climb an electric pole and bring down a Palestinian flag hung there by a youth.
“I don’t like to wake up in the middle of the night either,” the Israeli soldier said. A comrade shouted a stern order in Hebrew, ending a brief, tense conversation. It is a nightly ritual now in the life of Beit Sahur, a once well-to-do town in a picturesque valley beneath Bethlehem.
Once a thriving town where wool products, plastics, pharmaceuticals and detergents were made or distributed, today the town is feeling the severe economic consequences of the uprising, and its residents’ attitudes toward Israel and Jews are hardening.
Four days of interviews with more than 40 residents of this largely Christian town, as well as extensive conversations with prominent Palestinians and some Israelis, suggest that the legacy of the intifada — as the Palestinian uprising in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip is known to both Arabs and Israelis — is a bitterness that verges on hatred.
The uprising has hurt Beit Sahur’s once-thriving economy.
Bitter tug of war in Arab uprising hardens West Bank town’s residents
By Youssef M. Ibrahim
BEIT SAHUR, Israeli-occupied West Bank — At 7 p.m., this town near Bethlehem is dark, its streets empty under a chilly drizzle. A heavily armed Israeli soldier is barely visible against a wall in a tiny alley. Across the street, two companions stand guard nervously while more soldiers search a house. Neighbors peek from their windows, then quickly retreat.
“We do this twice a week,” the soldier said of his all-night patrol. “It’s a lousy job.” The women weep; the alleys are hazardous. Less than three weeks ago, an Israeli soldier died when a cinder block was dropped on his head in a similar twisted alley at the Nablus Casbah.
Yes, said the soldier, who would not give his name, he feels sorry for the Palestinians who are awakened in the early morning hours. Many times the Israeli soldiers are there to ask Palestinians to come out and paint over a slogan praising the Palestine Liberation Organization, or to climb a pole and bring down a Palestinian flag hung there by a youth.
“I don’t like to wake up in the middle of the night either,” the soldier said. A comrade shouted a stern order in Hebrew, ending the brief, tense conversation. It is a nightly ritual now in Beit Sahur, in a picturesque valley beneath Bethlehem.
Beit Sahur, once a thriving town, today is feeling the severe economic consequences of the Palestinian uprising, and its residents’ attitudes toward Israel and Jews are hardening.
Interviews with more than 40 residents of this largely Christian town suggest that the legacy of the intifada — as the uprising in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip is known — is a bitterness that verges on hatred. Now, 15 months into the uprising, Beit Sahur is not much different from the rest of the towns in the occupied territories.
Under rules issued by the underground leadership of the uprising, stores are to open only from 9 a.m. to noon, and only when no strike has been decreed. Days are filled with demonstrations by youths who burn tires, build rock barriers in the streets and throw stones and fire bombs. The Israeli army responds with bullets, security sweeps, arbitrary arrests and heavy fines.
In Gaza City yesterday, Israeli troops opened fire on hundreds of Palestinian protesters, killing three and wounding at least 20. Arab reports said the protests began after Israeli riot police plastered posters on walls in a neighborhood calling on residents to keep the peace.
“What’s the benefit of a demolished house, a killed son?” an Arab reporter quoted the placards as saying. Enraged Arabs gathered at a nearby mosque, calling for a “fight against the army,” the reporter said. Beit Sahur’s walls are overwhelmed with menacing graffiti.
A frequent theme, reinforcing the movement for civil disobedience, is, “The payment of taxes will not go unpunished.” At night the army wakes residents to paint over the slogans, knowing they will be back on the walls the next day. “Our main preoccupation is waiting for the army to come,” said Issa Manoli, owner of a nearly bankrupt factory.
His house has been raided four times this year, always after 2 a.m.
The depth of the alienation between Arabs and Jews is felt more intensely in this town of merchants and entrepreneurs, perhaps because Israelis once thought Beit Sahur was an unlikely candidate for anti-Israeli militancy in view of its middle-class nature and the fact that nearly 9,000 of its 11,000 people are Greek Orthodox.
But experts say the army gave the residents no choice. Over the past 16 months, three residents have died in demonstrations against the army. Hundreds of youngsters and many businessmen have been arrested. Elders refuse to pay taxes even as their businesses go bankrupt. The people of Beit Sahur are bitter. The struggle has all but canceled normal life in Beit Sahur.
The only public celebration allowed is Sunday Mass, which is usually followed by an anti-Israeli demonstration. Restaurants are closed. Families do not visit after sunset. The Rev. Saba Kheir, one of the town’s four Greek Orthodox priests, said only seven people came to the last wedding he performed, two weeks ago.
“They just stood there, got married, and left,” he said. “Two years ago, you would have had four days of eating and feasting and a thousand people in the church.” On Thursday, for the first time here since the uprising began, the Israeli army arrested three local girls. The youngest, Rana Michael al-Atrash, is 15.
They were accused of throwing stones and jailed, adding another layer of anger in this conservative Arab community where the arrest of women is seen as a violation of the family’s honor. Universities have been closed for more than a year, and schools have opened only intermittently. Teachers have tried unsuccessfully to organize clandestine education.
Daily challenges to Israel’s authority have become second nature in Beit Sahur. For the young, it is an uncompromising revolution against 21 years of occupation. For the middle-aged, like Jalal Qumsieyah, a schoolteacher, the sort of resistance in Beit Sahur is deadly but inevitable. “It is a miserable life,” he said.
“I admit we are committing suicide, but we cannot retreat. Our children want an end to the occupation, and they are running the show.” Merchants and businessmen have been driven to fury by financial pressures. Jad Isaac, a Beit Sahur resident and former chairman of the biology department at Bethlehem University, spent five months in jail without any charges.
He said that the Israeli authorities told him that he was arrested because he had encouraged Palestinians to start vegetable gardens so they would not have to rely on Israeli produce. “For people like us, things like not shaving, not brushing your teeth, not being able to wear nice clothes as I am used to, are humiliating,” he said.
“Slowly you begin to change.” Despite the hostility, there are attempts to reach out. Isaac said the military governor of the region occasionally invites him to discuss the uprising. “They ask me what we want,” he said. “I say we did our part by changing the PLO and recognizing the right of Israel to exist. I say it is you who need to change now.
They actually listen.” Constantine Banayoti, a teacher, said that some time ago a soldier asked him to paint over a slogan on a nearby wall. “I asked him, ‘Do you know what it says?’” Banayoti said. “He said no. I told him it says, ‘We want peace.’” The guy looked at me, and then he said: ‘We want peace, too. ...
This is what happens to an “occupied,” disarmed people
Paul Wilhelm, Cedar Ridge
— this is what happens to an “occupied,” disarmed people and their country…rocks vs. bullets. How dare we accuse others of terrorism when we allow the Israelis to do this day after day without demanding these atrocities be stopped.
I say stop foreign aid to Israel now and quit accusing others of terrorism — looks like we joined that club long ago — with the aid of the Israelis using our money.
A reader’s letter, signed and datelined to a small California town. The clipping begins mid-sentence: the first part of the letter is not on this scan.
For the Palestinians in Diaspora, The Vision Fades but Won’t Die
“The Palestine Red Crescent Society put on a show in the Andalus movie theater here the other night to raise funds for brethren caught in the uprising.”
Kuwait, 1989, two years before the Palestinian community there was expelled. Cowell counts the diaspora at 3.5 million and writes it through a fundraiser in a movie theater.
TIRA, Israel, March 30 — Three Palestinians died in the occupied territories today as residents marked Land Day, the Arab commemoration of land expropriated by the Israeli Government. But the army said it was responsible for only one of the deaths. Arab citizens in Israel observed the 13th annual Land Day with peaceful rallies and marches.
Here in the city of Tira, in the center of the country, several thousand Israeli Arabs gathered for the occasion, which was established in 1976 after six Palestinians were killed by troops during demonstrations against land expropriation.
Thousands of extra police officers were placed on alert across the country, most of them stationed outside Israeli Arab towns and villages, ready to enter those communities if rallies became violent. None did. Seven Israeli Arab villages did not observe the general strike called for Land Day at all.
Explaining why the village of Nin did not take part, Zuhabi Zahat, a resident, said, “We believe in coexistence, not slogans.” Large parts of the West Bank were declared closed military areas starting Wednesday night, in advance of the Land Day protests, and the Gaza Strip was sealed. Residents there were confined to their homes.
The army had hoped that these measures would eliminate the violent demonstrations that have occurred on the day in previous years. Stone Throwers Reported Shot Still, West Bank Palestinians said three residents were killed by troops battling scattered protests by youths who threw stones and tried to put up roadblocks with burning tires.
They said Saif Khawailed, 17, was shot to death while taking part in a Land Day demonstration in the village of Shuwaika, near Tulkarm. A military spokesman confirmed Mr. Khawailed’s death, but said he had been shot by an army officer when “he came out of an alley and tried to throw a large rock at the officer.”
At Ramallah Hospital, officials reported that Hamad Abed Rabbo, 23, from the nearby village of Jeeb, died of a gunshot wound to the heart after Land Day demonstrations. The army spokesman said he was “checking the reason for the death.”
In the Gaza Strip, Palestinians said a 24-year-old resident of the Jabaliya refugee district, Nasser Khalid Nasser, died when soldiers shot him in the chest during a stone-throwing demonstration. But the army spokesman said Mr. Nasser’s death was the result of “a fight between rival gangs — it was a 100 percent criminal incident.”
Again, Differing Accounts In addition to today’s deaths, Palestinians also said a 20-year-old Arab man they identified as Abdel Munem Abdallah, was shot by troops on Wednesday in Salfit, near Nablus. They said Mr. Abdallah died this morning as he was being transported to a hospital in a private car. The army spokesman said he had no information about Mr.
Abdallah’s death, except that the military believes he died in an automobile accident. In Israel, Palestinian rallies commemorating Land Day were largely peaceful. Stones were thrown in Jaffa, near Tel Aviv, and several youths burned a tire in Lod, near Ben-Gurion International Airport.
Here in Tira, the Israeli Arabs who gathered in such large numbers were seeking to demonstrate support for the uprising in the occupied territories and demanding equal rights for Arab citizens of Israel. The marchers crowded into the town center, pressing closely around the plaza’s dry fountain and climbing onto wooden sunshades for a better view.
Most of those in the crowd were men and boys; the Arab women stood on rooftops, balconies and in windows surrounding the plaza.
Waving banners, clapping, and singing, the demonstrators repeatedly chanted slogans: “With spirit and blood we’ll defend our land,” “There’s no solution without the Palestine Liberation Organization,” and “Great honor to the uprising, only the P.L.O. can solve the problem.”
By 1989 the paper uses both Palestinians and Land Day without explanation. In 1976 it had neither.
LOD, Israel — Audeh Rantisi remembers a Sunday morning in July 1948 when an Israeli soldier came to the door and told his mother the family would have to leave the house and go to the center of town. Audeh's father, George, a soap maker and landowner, locked the front door of the four-room stone house, put the keys in his pocket and started walking.
He thought he would be home in time for dinner. But their footsteps on the dusty road took them into the Palestinian Diaspora, and Audeh's parents did not return to live in Lod.
They were among the 600,000 to 760,000 Arabs who left towns and villages in what is now Israel during the first Arab-Israeli war, according to Benny Morris, an Israeli historian who has studied the Palestinian refugee problem. The 1948 war started when Israel declared its independence and Arab countries attacked the new nation.
There was no state that belonged to the Palestinians, and many Palestinians who lived in the area that is now Israel left on the advice of Arab leaders or to escape the war zone. Arabs who identify themselves as Palestinians now number roughly 4.7 million.
About half the Palestinians live in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, in the Israeli-annexed section of Jerusalem or inside the borders of Israel. About 766,000 still live in refugee camps. The rest are scattered.
A 15-month Palestinian uprising that began in December 1987 in the Israeli-occupied territories and a decision by the United States to talk with Yasser Arafat's Palestine Liberation Organization have made the Palestinians and their future a main element of the quest for peace.
Because Palestinians living abroad seek the right to return to their homes, most of which were long ago destroyed or belong to Israeli families, the Palestinian Diaspora poses one of the thorniest peacemaking problems.
Israeli politicians of the right and left are united in opposing the return of Palestinians to what is now Israel, and many Israelis are concerned about an influx of former guerrillas and improverished camp dwellers to a Palestinian state created from the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
“The Palestinian can be, and has been, a Kuwaiti, a Jordanian, a Syrian, an American, a European. But he never, under any circumstances, gave up that identification of being a Palestinian,” said Dr. Mahdi Abdul Hadi, director of the Palestinian Academy for the Study of International Affairs in Jerusalem.
For Audeh Rantisi, then 11, his three younger brothers and two sisters, leaving their home meant joining a stream of thousands of other Palestinians uprooted from Lod and Ramle on July 12-14, 1948. “We didn't realize what was happening until we were out of town. We hadn't taken anything with us, no money, no papers, no clothes.
Nobody thought we were being evicted for good,” said Audeh, who is now an Episcopal pastor and political activist in the West Bank town of Ramallah.
Palestinian brothers Jacob and John Rantisi have built a life in America, but long for their real home. (Associated Press)
JERUSALEM — Israeli troops shot and killed a Palestinian girl today during a funeral at a refugee camp in the occupied West Bank, Palestinians said. Rufida Abu Laban, 17, of Dheisheh refugee camp was shot in the head and was dead on arrival at a hospital in Bethlehem, doctors said.
At least 438 Arabs have been killed in the 16-month uprising against Israeli rule of the West Bank and Gaza strip. Seventeen Jews have also died. An army spokesman said it was checking reports of shootings at the Dheisheh camp. A spokesman at a Jerusalem hospital said a 16-year-old boy from Dheisheh had arrived in serious condition with a bullet wound to the head.
Arab news agencies quoted residents as saying Abu Laban was shot at the funeral of a 17-year-old youth killed by troops yesterday.
Five words and two numbers. No one fires, no one is wounded by anything, and nowhere is named. The Sacramento Bee printed the same day’s events on page A24 as Violence peaks in Gaza Strip; 3 Palestinians killed, 138 hurt (CP-1989-006) — one more injured person than this paper counted, and a place. Neither headline has anybody doing it.
Violence peaks in Gaza Strip; 3 Palestinians killed, 138 hurt
Page A24, Sunday 7 May 1989. Same day as the Hawaii Tribune Herald (CP-1989-004), and the two papers differ by one injured person: 138 here, 137 there. The subject of the first clause is violence, which peaks by itself; the subject of the second is the three dead. The army is in neither clause.
Correction: {'pub': 'The Sacramento Bee', 'date': '1989-05-07', 'note': "the line above the picture reads 'A24 The Sacramento Bee - Sunday, May 7, 1989'; caption pairing swapped"}
JERUSALEM — Israeli authorities arrested a Palestinian activist yesterday hours before he was to attend a meeting between Palestinian leaders and a visiting State Department delegation. Ghassan Al Katib, a political-cultural studies at the Zeit University, was arrested by soldiers and security police at his home in the West Bank city of Ramallah at 2 a.m.
He was one of six Palestinians who had been invited by U.S. officials to a meeting later in the day to discuss Israel’s proposal for holding elections in the occupied territories. Mr. Al Katib, 37, is regarded as being close to the Palestine Communist Party, which is widely regarded as the most moderate of the major Palestinian factions in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
It has supported the Palestine Liberation Organization’s recognition of Israel and its renunciation of terrorism.
Israeli authorities told U.S. officials that Mr. Al Katib was arrested for “security reasons.” Israeli authorities told U.S. officials that Mr. Al Katib was arrested for “security reasons” but gave no other information, a knowledgeable official said.
The five other Palestinians showed up as scheduled for a meeting with Dennis Ross, chief of the State Department’s policy planning staff. Mr. Ross, who had returned to Israel after talks with Egyptian and Jordanian officials, commented only that he hoped there would be more meetings in the future.
“Each of the Palestinians offered their own separate opinion,” he said. As expected, the Palestinians expressed objections to the election plan offered by Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir and approved by Israel’s Cabinet on Sunday. Mr. Shamir’s proposal rules out the eventual creation of a Palestinian state or talks between Israel and the PLO.
It offers a sketchy outline for elections in which Palestinians could choose representatives to negotiate limited self-rule and, eventually, to negotiate the permanent status of the territories. A’zedin Arian, head of the West Bank’s Red Crescent Society, Arab equivalent to the Red Cross, said that Mr. Shamir’s plan reserved all decision-making for Israel.
“Democratic elections mean that we shall be the ones to determine the form of the elections, where they should take place, when, who shall be elected and who shall have the right to elect,” Mr. Arian said. “We are not in favor of elections just for the sake of elections.”
A man arrested at two in the morning hours before a meeting with American officials, and the reason given for it, printed as a pull quote in the middle of the story.
Israelis taking over jobs of Palestinians in Ashdod
Robert Ruby, Jerusalem bureau of The Sun
“ASHDOD, Israel — Instead of attending her usual classes at the local high school, Livnette Cecil and her friends were working yesterday at cleaning streets and picking up trash. All of Ashdod was proud of them.
Their work was part of an experiment, city officials explained earnestly, an experiment at prohibiting Palestinians from working for the municipality and replacing them at any cost with Israelis, even if it means taking Israeli pupils out of school. ‘We’re trying to have a separation of forces,’ said David Artom, a city spokesman, using the language of warfare.
The city is trying to keep Palestinians and Israelis apart by telling Palestinians they aren’t welcome here, at least not now… ‘They should be kept there until they calm down,’ said a woman who walked into the video store. By the standards of the moment, she was a moderate, disagreeing with Mr.
Alfonta, the manager, when he suggested expelling all the Palestinians from the Gaza Strip and West Bank. ‘We can’t put them on trucks,’ she said. ‘We’re not Hitler.’”
A staff correspondent walks around one Israeli town and writes down what people say. The reporter’s own sentence, not a quotation, is the one that says the city is telling Palestinians they are not welcome.
For 7 Palestinians Accused in the Uprising, Common Thread Is Journalism
By JOEL BRINKLEY
JERUSALEM, May 20 — In a military court outside Tel Aviv, seven Palestinians are being tried on charges of leading the Palestinian uprising, and they have at least one thing in common: every one is a journalist.
In court documents and interviews, Israeli officials say they have concluded that Palestinians have in large part directed the uprising under the guise of covering the news. “Journalism is a very convenient cover,” a senior Israeli security official said.
“They can have a network of informants all over the territories, and under the cover of reporting the news they can be in touch with everything. But these people are making the events instead of writing about them.”
‘The Lack of Political Rights’ Daud Kuttab, one of the few Palestinian journalists who Israelis have not said is under suspicion, said, “Because of the lack of political rights, journalism is one of the only legal political activities.” Since Palestinians have no public leadership, “being a journalist and having a byline makes you a spokesman of importance,” he added.
“This is why journalism became a good cover.” Though Mr. Kuttab describes himself as a strong Palestinian nationalist, he says he nonetheless accepts that other Palestinian journalists have used his profession as a cover for what he calls “intifada leadership activities.”
As journalists, Palestinians can meet and talk with anyone, here or abroad, as part of their research for an article. Since the uprising began, at least half a dozen Palestinian press agencies have sprung up in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, serving newspapers abroad and the foreign correspondents working here.
Last month a group run by Palestinians associated with Al Fatah, Yasir Arafat’s wing of the Palestine Liberation Organization, opened an office in the Gaza Strip. Called the Gaza Media Center, it mailed leaflets to members of the domestic and foreign press here, offering news research and translation services in Gaza, a market that is already served by several other services.
Networks of Correspondents The Palestinian press agencies also hire part-time correspondents in cities and remote villages across the West Bank and Gaza who report on events there, including Israeli Army raids and other activities. Some of these enterprises fill a purely journalistic need created by the uprising.
But Israeli officials say the journalists who are involved in the uprising also use their correspondent networks to gather information for P.L.O. officers abroad, to send directives to remote areas and to test ideas they want to include in the occasional leaflets published by the uprising leadership.
And by serving the foreign press — meeting correspondents and editors from newspapers and television stations around the world — those Palestinians build important political connections and protection. Many of these people consider themselves serious journalists, even as they carry out political work at the same time.
But to most Palestinians of all professions, the nationalist cause comes first. Old Suspicions Israeli officials have long been suspicious of Palestinian journalists; they have censored or closed several West Bank and Gaza newspapers or magazines since the uprising began.
At one time last year, 30 Arab journalists, including five members of the nine-person board of the Arab Journalists Association, were in prison.
But Israeli officials say they first learned the full scope of the journalism network in February, when Hassan Abed Rabbo, who used to work for the West Bank magazine Al Awdah, named names and described how the system worked, under intense interrogation that some Palestinians assert included torture. In the following weeks, seven journalists were arrested.
The best known among them was Samaan Khouri, who used to work with Agence France-Presse and local publications. The senior security official described Mr. Khouri and one other, Talal Abu Afifeh, formerly of the newspaper Al Fajr, as senior organizers who rank high in the uprising leadership. The other five, he said, were their operatives.
All seven say they are not guilty and have nothing to do with directing the uprising. But Palestinians and Israelis say Mr. Khouri was caught with a draft of an uprising leaflet in his pocket.
Several years ago he confessed to Israeli interrogators that he was a member of the radical Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine; he ran for the Arab Journalists Association board three years ago as the Democratic Front’s candidate, a knowledgeable Palestinian said.
In addition to the seven journalists in jail, two prominent East Jerusalem Palestinians are named as leaders of the uprising but have not been arrested or charged. Their names appeared in court documents filed early this month, and Ron Shapira, the army’s chief military prosecutor for the West Bank, publicly described the allegations against them.
One is Radwan Abu Ayyash, head of the Arab Journalists Association in the Occupied Territories. He also operates a news service for the foreign press. The court documents say he is a senior Fatah leader who had a hand in drafting several uprising leaflets last year and early this year. He vehemently denies involvement.
“This drove me crazy when I heard,” he said in an interview. “As head of the journalists association I see journalists and other people daily. Anybody can ask me anything on any subject, and I’ll answer freely. I don’t need the leaflets to say my ideas.”
Philosopher Turned Journalist The other person named but not charged was Sari Nusseibeh, a philosophy professor at Bir Zeit University well known as a West Bank leader who often meets with visiting American congressional delegations and others. He was part of a group that met with Dennis Ross, head of the State Department’s Policy Planning Staff, on Tuesday. Mr.
Nusseibeh, too, denies the allegations against him. After Israel closed all the universities in the occupied territories when the uprising began, Mr. Nusseibeh found himself with a great deal of free time. So he became a journalist, he said, to chronicle the uprising for future historians.
“I was one who thought the Israelis were going to shut down all the West Bank newspapers,” he said in an interview. But then “I started seeing that this research could be sold to newspapers” abroad. So this year, working out of a fortified office in East Jerusalem, he started selling his twice-weekly Holyland Media report to correspondents and newspapers here and abroad.
The service is not yet making a profit, he said. One of the seven Palestinians under indictment is Hamza Samadi, who worked with Mr. Nusseibeh at Holyland Media. Mr.
Nusseibeh wholly discounts the Israeli assertion that journalism can be a good cover for underground activities, saying, “If they want someone — an engineer, a dentist, anyone — they’ll say whatever he is doing is a good cover.” The court documents charge that Mr. Nusseibeh distributed P.L.O. money for use in the uprising and wrote parts of several leaflets. Mr.
Samadi, the documents say, used the Holyland Media fax machine to communicate with P.L.O. operatives abroad. In early February, Mr. Nusseibeh first began hearing rumors that Mr. Abed Rabbo had named him, and at about the same time Israeli authorities called him in for questioning. “They warned me not to continue illegal activities, without saying what they were,” Mr.
Nusseibeh recalled. He asked what he was doing wrong, he said, and quoted his questioners as saying, “If you stop it, then we’ll tell you.” “I am not actively involved in anything,” he insisted. “I am an analyst. If people stop me on the street and ask me what Palestinians should do, I tell them. If they don’t, I write an article.”
Israeli officials said the United States, without naming names, urged Israel this month not to arrest the uprising leadership. If all the leaders are put in jail, American officials warned, Israel will have no one left to negotiate with. Mr. Abu Ayyash and Mr.
Nusseibeh both say they think they have been left free so they might become candidates in the Palestinian elections Israel is trying to arrange. “Maybe they want me to be one of the horses in their elections,” Mr. Abu Ayyash said.
[photo 1, credit Reuters] Radwan Abu Ayyash, center, head of the Arab Journalists Association in the Occupied Territories, as he was released from jail last year.
He is one of two men who were named in Israeli court documents as leaders of the Palestinian uprising but who have not been formally charged. || [photo 2, credit Agence France-Presse] Sari Nusseibeh, the second West Bank leader named in the documents but not formally charged.
Palestinian, 12, Dies in Gaza After Being Shot by Israelis
Special to The New York Times
JERUSALEM, May 20 — A 12-year-old Palestinian boy who was shot in the chest during a violent clash with Israeli troops in a Gaza Strip refugee camp on Friday died this morning in a Gaza hospital, Palestinians said. The death of the boy, Nathmi Abu Khatla, brings to five the number of Palestinians fatally wounded in Friday’s melee in the Rafa district.
Another Palestinian was killed in the Jabaliya district in the Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip, and three Palestinians and an Israeli soldier were killed in a gun battle near Bethlehem in the occupied West Bank.
Israeli Civilians Kill Palestinian Girl, 14, in West Bank Town
“Civilians firing a submachine gun shot and killed a teen-age Palestinian girl in the occupied West Bank today, despite new official warnings to Israelis to avoid taking the law into their own hands.”
Alan Cowell. The subject of the headline is Israeli civilians — named as the agent, which the archive's agency count finds in only 120 of 220 death headlines. She is fourteen and she is not named.
EREZ CHECKPOINT, Israeli-Occupied Gaza Strip, June 12 — The latest battle for control between Israelis and the Palestinans in their midst is being waged inside a dusty army compound here. Its weapons are computers, cameras and laminating machines, and one side has them all.
Starting at 4 A.M. today, Palestinians living in this northern sliver of the Gaza Strip filed into the army post to receive new computer-coded identity cards that the Israeli authorities began distributing six days ago.
By 1:30 P.M., 400 of them were still there, filling rows of chairs, shielded from the sun by a tarpaulin, patiently waiting to complete the long process of picture-taking and computer-checking. If they did not pass muster — if they had a criminal record or owed taxes or were judged to be political troublemakers — they could not get the cards.
Without the cards, they will not be able to leave the Gaza Strip for Israel. And if they cannot do that, many of them will have no work at all. Resentment Flares That, several Palestinians said, is as good an incentive for patience as any. Still, resentment flared.
“We all reject this card,” asserted a middle-aged man, who said he has eight children and works in Israel as a laborer. “But we need bread for our children, and so we have do it.” Sitting there for hours humiliated him, he said, adding, “They treat us as if we are dogs.” An Israeli officer in charge of the program, Col.
Ami Levy, insisted that his soldiers did no such thing. The card is necessary, he told reporters allowed inside the compound, because “it proves that a man is honest.”
A Palestinian being photographed yesterday in the Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip as part of the process of obtaining a computer-coded identity card, which will be required for entry into Israel. (Reuters) | Army plans to check identity cards at Erez and Nahal Oz. (The New York Times/June 13, 1989)
WASHINGTON, June 28 — In a novel move to improve its image in the United States, the Palestine Liberation Organization has hired an expert on graphic design to convey its message more effectively to the American people through political poster art. The expert, Daniel J.
Walsh, based in Alexandria, Va., has one of the world’s largest collections of Palestinian posters, including 4,000 to 5,000 first editions. He has been retained to disseminate such art at universities and art galleries around the country. He also plans to reprint some of the posters and sell them through bookstores and mail-order catalogues.
He confirmed today that he had a contract with the P.L.O., signed in March, when he was invited to the group’s headquarters in Tunis. But he declined to say how much he was being paid. ‘Oppositional Posters’ Mr.
Walsh, a 40-year-old veteran of the Peace Corps, is the proprietor of Liberation Graphics, a small company that distributes what he calls “oppositional posters” from the Soviet Union, Cuba, Nicaragua, El Salvador, South Africa and other countries. “The political myths surrounding the P.L.O. are susceptible to challenge and reversal,” Mr.
Walsh said in an interview in the tiny house that he uses as an office and workshop. “The political poster is a way to shatter taboos and debunk mythologies.” Since the founding of the P.L.O. more than two decades ago, Palestinians have recognized the poster as a medium for expressing their political values and goals. Mr.
Walsh says that Palestinian posters will speak to an American audience more directly and more effectively than P.L.O. leaders have been able to.
A Palestinian poster from Liberation Graphics in Alexandria, Va.
JERUSALEM, July 2 (Reuters) — Israeli authorities said today that they had banned a play written by an Israeli Arab because it was racist and would incite anti-Israeli protests. But the playwright, Riad Masarwy of Nazareth, said his work, “The Ninth Wave,” was censored because “the Government could not deal with the political situation that exists today.”
The play is about a bridegroom who is killed by Israeli troops in the occupied West Bank moments before his marriage, he said. As the bride dances around his body, relatives tell of what they call Israeli atrocities against the Palestinian people since Israeli independence in 1948.
“The play has a racist message that is anti-Jewish, anti-Zionist and anti-Israeli in the most crude way,” said the secretary of the Israeli film and theater censorship board, Sonia David. “It is liable in the existing circumstances to cause a worsening of riots. From the beginning to the end, the play is very inciteful.” Mr.
Masarwy said he would continue with rehearsals for the play, which was to open in Nazareth on Sept. 4. “I do not hurt the feelings of anyone,” he said. “I bring facts from the past and from the present. Apparently the authorities cannot handle these facts.”
He said the play had been co-produced with a Belgian theater group and involved five Belgian actors as well as five Arab actors. It was to have been performed in French and Arabic.
JERUSALEM July 10 — Five Palestinians died today after clashes in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, and the army disclosed tonight that an armed Palestinian was shot dead by troops near Hebron last week. The day’s death toll was unusually high, and brought the total number of Palestinians killed by Israelis since the Arab uprising began to at least 488.
In Ramallah, Yasir Mohammed Abu Ghosh, 17 years old, was shot four times in the back and head with a pistol by Israelis wearing civilian clothes, probably security policemen, witnesses to the incident said. They said rioting had erupted in the city immediately after an army patrol removed Mr. Abu Ghosh’s body, leading soldiers to fire tear gas and bullets.
Attacks on Collaborators Cited A military spokesman said Mr. Abu Ghosh had been shot and killed by “security forces.” He said the youth was suspected “of attacking people accused of collaborating with the Government and of being a senior coordinator of violent activities, including throwing petrol bombs.”
A 20-year-old Palestinian was wounded in the demonstrations after Mr. Abu Ghosh’s death. The army said that the man later died, and that incident was under investigation. The man’s name was not available. Palestinians identified a third man killed today as Mahiyub Musa, 18.
They said he was shot in the head during a predawn raid on the village of Khirbet Abu Falah, near Ramallah. The army spokesman confirmed the death. In the Gaza Strip, Palestinians said troops shot Rami al-Tareefi, 15, through the heart in a clash in the Bureij refugee settlement. The army said it was investigating the report.
Youth Shot Saturday Dies Another Gaza resident, 14-year-old Ayman Alla, died in an Israeli hospital today after he was shot in the heart in a demonstration on Saturday, Arabs said. The army confirmed the death. The army today also disclosed that “an armed terrorist was killed at the end of last week in the Mount Hebron area.”
The military spokesman said no other details of the episode were being made public.
WASHINGTON — In the face of Israeli Minister Ariel Sharon's demand for the elimination of Palestine Liberation Organization Chairman Yasser Arafat, and in spite of the brutal destruction of an Israeli tourist bus by a Palestinian fanatic, the Bush administration is quietly persisting in its effort to nudge the Israelis and Palestinians toward agreement on elections in the West Bank and Gaza to choose Palestinian negotiators in the initial step of a new peace process.
The logic that led the United States to encourage Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir to come forward with his proposal in May for a free election by Palestinians of their own negotiators remains intact and compelling.
As Bush officials explain it, they saw last spring a narrow window of opportunity for modest progress as the result of a number of separate but related developments. First, there had been the acceptance by PLO Chairman Arafat last December of Security Council Resolution 242 and of Israel's right to exist together with his renunciation of terrorism.
Second, there was the growing impact of the intifada in the West Bank and Gaza that carried the message to the Israelis that the preservation of the status quo was becoming increasingly costly. Behind the confrontations between soldiers and rock-throwing youths, there have been organized strikes, boycotts and demonstrations that have deepened the Israeli economic recession.
Finally, there was the growing risk of inaction for both Israeli and Arab leaders. Violence fed on violence as street clashes intensified. There was the danger on both sides that fanatical extremists would take over to turn the disputed territories into a new Lebanon, not to mention the accumulation of stockpiles of even more deadly weapons throughout the Middle East.
Israel to hold Moslem cleric under administrative detention
Marjorie Olster, The Associated Press, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — Israel is holding a Moslem cleric kidnapped from south Lebanon two weeks ago under administrative detention orders normally used to detain Palestinians without trial, the army said today.
The announcement of a six-month detention order against Sheik Abdel-Karim Obeid officially confirmed for the first time that Obeid is being held in Israel and not in the Israeli-controlled buffer zone in south Lebanon. But officials have not said where in Israel Obeid is held.
The military censor, meanwhile, has asked police to open an investigation into a report in the Sunday Times of London that said two of three Israeli soldiers missing in Lebanon are dead, said Eitan Haber, spokesman for Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin… An army spokesman said Obeid, the Lebanese cleric kidnapped by Israeli commandos on July 28, is being held for a half-year under an administrative detention order signed by Chief of Staff Lt.
Gen. Dan Shomron. Under administrative detention, which Israel adopted from 1945 British emergency regulations, prisoners can be held up to one year without being tried or charged. Israel accuses Obeid of coordinating attacks by the Moslem fundamentalist Hezbollah on Israeli troops in south Lebanon.
Administrative detainees are normally entitled to have a lawyer and appeal their detention. But the army spokesman, who is not identified under military regulations, would not say if these rights were extended to Obeid.
Obeid’s abduction drew worldwide attention after a radical Shiite group in Lebanon claimed to have killed an American hostage because Israel refused to free the cleric. It remains unclear, however, if the hostage, Lt. Col. William R. Higgins, was killed after Obeid’s abduction or before.
Israel has demanded the release of three Israelis missing in Lebanon as well as 16 foreign hostages in exchange for Obeid and other Shiite Moslem prisoners. Longest held of those hostages is Terry A.
Anderson, chief Middle East correspondent of The AP, who has been held 4½ years… The story written by the paper’s London-based Middle East correspondent Marie Colvin said intelligence officers questioning Obeid have concluded that the two infantrymen died of wounds soon after their car was ambushed in south Lebanon in February 1986.
Israel’s chief army spokesman, Brig. Gen. Ephraim Lapid, did not confirm or deny the report but said the government considers its soldiers to be alive and well unless it is given substantial documentary proof to the contrary.
In another report on the hostage affair, The Independent of London said Monday that Obeid’s abduction had sabotaged sensitive overtures by Israel to Iran and the Hezbollah to free the prisoners… The team had “opened new channels with Iran and the Hezbollah via two Palestinian Shiites who have close links with Teheran,” the paper said.
Frustrated by the slow progress of negotiations, Israel kidnapped Obeid, it said… One security source, speaking on condition of anonymity, said the report was “nonsense.”
“OBEID”
The archive holds this for a sentence in the middle of it: administrative detention is described as the order “normally used to detain Palestinians without trial,” adopted from 1945 British emergency regulations. The army spokesman is, by regulation, not named.
“The saddest story of our times is the continued idiocy of United States policy in the Middle East. The Israeli government sponsors the kidnapping of a Moslem leader and commits murder in the process. Then the oppressed freedom-fighters execute a U.S. captive they are holding. And what is this country’s response?
‘But the Bush administration made clear Monday it did not hold Israel responsible for Higgins’ reported execution.’ (The Clarion-Ledger, Aug. 1). When a nation’s ‘friends’ in a war-zone seek to manipulate events to ensnare it in the morass of perpetual crisis, it is time for that nation to drop such false ‘friends.’
Israel was established in 1948. Yet in all the years before and after that incredible piece of political magic — the appearance of Israel and the disappearance of Palestine — only two U.S. presidents have shown any wisdom and backbone in formulating this country’s policy. Roosevelt said no to the founding of the state of Israel.
And Eisenhower told Israel to get out of Suez in 1956. Since then, the moral and political idiots have ruled from the White House. The real problem lies in this and other nations’ support for a quasi-insane and immoral policy toward Palestine/Israel.
Men and women of one religious persuasion, though natives of Moscow, Paris, London, Buenos Aires, Boise and New York, are granted rights of citizenship and ownership of all the land of Israel. Yet men and women of a different faith are denied those same rights, even then they are born in Jerusalem, Nablus or Nazareth.
Meanwhile, what is the Mississippi delegation to Congress doing in making the local citizens’ desires known to the government? They’re doing just what you would expect senators and representatives from the poorest and most backward of the 50 states to do — either be quiet and fall in line or just ignore the true sentiments of their constituents.
Check the recent actions of Sen. Trent Lott and U.S. Reps. Mike Espy and Sonny Montgomery as examples. Future generations — if there will be any future for us — will look back on our era and condemn us as the vacuous moralists and war criminals that we are.
And it will all be due to our blind spot and support for the great crime of our century — the creation of Israel and the genocide of Palestine.”
A reader in Vicksburg, Mississippi, in 1989, whose argument runs through his own state’s congressional delegation. The paper put the word in the headline, in quotation marks.
· estimated · Fort Worth Star-Telegram · Fort Worth
Body of Palestinian man found in W. Bank village
JERUSALEM — The body of a Palestinian man was found today in a West Bank village raided by the army, raising to seven the number of Arabs killed by Israeli security the previous day. It was one of the bloodiest days of the 21-month Palestinian uprising against Israeli rule in the occupied Gaza Strip and West Bank.
Date check: No masthead and no page date line — the clipping is trimmed to a two-line headline and two paragraphs, nothing else. Neither “Fort Worth Star Telegram” nor 1989-09-11 appears anywhere on the scan, so neither could be verified. The one internal check available is the phrase “21-month Palestinian uprising”: the intifada began in December 1987, which puts this in September 1989 and is consistent with `date`.
“Only the United States and Israel voted against a resolution introduced by the Arab countries on behalf of the P.L.O… there were six abstentions: Uruguay, Zaire, El Salvador and the Caribbean nations of St. Vincent and the Grenadines, Antigua and Barbuda, and Grenada.”
Paul Lewis at the United Nations. A hundred and forty of a hundred and fifty-nine countries vote one way and two vote the other, and the headline calls the intifada an Arab revolt, which is the phrase the papers used for 1936.
BEIT SAHUR, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, Oct. 4 — To press the Palestinian uprising, the people of this town have refused for months to pay their taxes. In response, Israel has begun to confiscate their goods. The raids, Aysa Hanna Khier says, have produced some incongruities.
The Christian crosses carved of olivewood and the statuettes of the Good Shepherd and the Madonna may have seemed improbable commodities, but Mr. Khier said the tax collectors and soldiers seized them when they raided his woodcarving workshop here on Sept. 23.
Even the small fretwork wall-plaques showing a dove on the wing over the Hebrew word Shalom were taken in lieu of the withheld taxes, he said. Mr.
Khier is among some 60 Palestinians from this prosperous and predominantly Christian Arab town near Bethlehem to have felt Israel’s response to what Palestinians depict as a new tactic of the uprising in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, now 22 months old.
Campaign of Disobedience Beit Sahur has been elevated by the militants to a symbol of what they hope will be a new phase of civil disobedience to confound 22 years of Israeli occupation, bring scorn on Israel’s tactics and persuade the Israelis that, even in a middle-class and cozy town like this, loyalty lies elsewhere.
Israel’s response is designed to negate those arguments in the near-constant test of wills that has underpinned the uprising from its beginnings in December 1987.
And so the battle, accompanied by curfews and roadblocks and armed patrols through the streets, has spawned a litany of losses in this town of 13,000 whose pale stone walls cling to the bleached hills of Biblical lands. [Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin said Tuesday that Israel would teach a lesson to Palestinians who refused to pay taxes in Beit Sahur, Reuters reported.
Participants at a closed-door parliamentary committee meeting said Mr. Rabin told them: “There will not be any attempt to boycott taxes. If it takes a month, it will take a month but they will break.
We are going to teach them a lesson.”] Michel Kokaly, an auto mechanic, said he had forfeited hoists from his workshop and the sofas, chairs, tables and television from his spacious apartment above the shop when the soldiers and tax-collectors arrived a week ago.
What pained most, said his wife, Ibtisam, was that the children, 6 and 9 years old, did not recognize their empty home when they came home from school at noon. A third child, who is 3, threw a pebble at the soldiers and called them names, she said with some pride, as if that tempered the loss.
In the office of Mayor Hanna Atrash in Beit Sahur, other men have their stories, too. Issam Sheheibet, a wealthy merchant, says the collectors took flour, sugar, barley and refrigerators from his stores. Counting the Losses Selim Qassis, a carpenter, estimates he has lost machinery worth $35,000.
Yassa Abu Zelef says he lost his television set, VCR and hi-fi, even though he closed his shop six months after the uprising began. “I have no money to pay,” he said. “Nobody is paying now,” said Mayor Atrash, alluding to the ending of a previous exemption of some big factories from the tax protest.
“This is going to mean that all factories, all workshops, all shops are heading for a shutdown,” Mr. Atrash said. “It is beyond my imagination what will happen next.” In interviews, many men said they would not pay taxes because they did not wish to finance their own occupation and, anyway, saw no benefit from the money they had already paid.
Before the uprising, Mr. Khier, the woodcarver, said, he had been paying around $4,000 a year in taxes. Mr. Kokaly, the mechanic, said his taxes had been around $2,700 a year, counting income tax and value-added tax. Auction Is Coming Both men said they would not attend the auction the Israeli authorities plan next week in Tel Aviv to dispose of goods seized in Beit Sahur.
The confiscations mean that even if they wanted to pay taxes, some are no longer able to earn money to do so. According to Israeli officials, the taxes Palestinians pay in the occupied territories are used for the maintenance of health services, schools and transportation.
The military body that oversees the occupation, called the Civil Administration, employs 13,000 salaried Palestinians, the officials said. “We have nothing against Beit Sahur,” one official said, asking not to be identified by name, “but it is the only town where people are not paying taxes.”
He said the number of those refusing to pay was between 250 and 300. About $1 million worth of property has been seized so far. the official said, and the tax collection effort will continue. Won’t Bankroll the Occupation “I paid before the intifada,” Mr. Kokaly said, using the Arabic term for the uprising. “But because of the intifada I am not paying.
I will not finance occupation.”
After Palestinians in Beit Sahur on the Israeli-occupied West Bank started refusing to pay their taxes, Israeli officials began confiscating their goods. Asya Hanna Khier, who operates a wood-carving workshop, said crosses, figurines and wall-plaques were seized.
BEIT SAHUR, Occupied West Bank — The Israelis have come to confiscate the television sets, the furniture and the appliances of the people of Beit Sahur.
It is the Israeli way to punish the people of this suburb of Bethlehem for not paying their taxes and supporting the Palestinian intifadeh, the 22-month uprising against Israel’s occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip. For three weeks, the people of Beit Sahur have remained adamant. They say: No taxation without representation.
The middle-class community of 12,000 residents is made up mostly of professionals, many educated in the United States. They see taxation as an infringement on their rights, given that they have little say in the Israeli government.
“Taxes are paid by people to their own legitimate political bodies to cover the cost of services,” a press release signed by Beit Sahur residents said Sept. 27. “The services provided to the Palestinians are opening new jails ... building new (Israeli) settlements.”
Unlike other communities in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, who sporadically support the uprising, Beit Sahur has complied with all commands of the underground leaders of the intifadeh, particularly the tax revolt.
So Beit Sahur became the first Palestinian village in the occupied territories to be specifically targeted by the Israeli authorities for universal tax collection. Soldiers set up barriers to block journalists from covering a news conference called by Palestinian leaders outraged by the tax raids.
Embassy consuls, coming to the town to investigate, have been turned away at the roadblocks. “We tried to convince people before to pay their taxes and took no action for a long time,” Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir’s media adviser, Avi Pazner, said in a telephone interview.
“No one likes to seize property from people, but sometimes it’s the only recourse in such a situation.” Residents from Beit Sahur had to be interviewed as they tried to enter their town on foot or by bus. “Collecting taxes from occupied territories is illegal,” said Dr. Johny Matarweh, a 30-year-old general practitioner at St.
Joseph’s Hospital in East Jerusalem and a Beit Sahur resident. “So now the people of Beit Sahur are deciding not to pay taxes, even if they confiscate everything from that town,” Matarweh said. “The tax man, with the soldiers, asked if you wanted to pay.
If you said no, they broke into your home and took everything — TV sets, beds and even the chair on which you were sitting,” he said. Two women workers at a Bethlehem children’s hospital spoke of Israeli soldiers cutting off Beit Sahur’s water and electricity.
“The soldiers fired their guns at the water tower,” one woman said, adding that many homes had been without electricity for several days. Pazner said he had no reports of violence in the raids but did not deny the woman’s accusations. “These people of the intifadeh are always making up stories,” he said.
Direct verification of conditions in Beit Sahur was difficult. Armed soldiers in battle fatigues stood sentry at the main road from Bethlehem to Beit Sahur. They turned away all nonresidents, including journalists. “Beit Sahur is closed,” said a soldier. Israeli authorities do not deny the harshness of the Beit Sahur tax operation.
Instead they explain their action as one of necessity. Taxes cover expenses for basic municipal services to the territories such as roads, electricity service and water.
BOSTON — Suppose the people of some small American town decided to protest Federal Government policy by withholding their taxes. The Government responded by sending in the Army. Soldiers cut all telephone lines to the town. They stopped food from coming in and barred all visitors. They imposed a curfew from 6:30 every evening to 4:30 in the morning.
They went into homes and took furniture and other belongings worth many times a family’s unpaid taxes. They broke into shops and dumped goods in the streets. They arrested people and held them for days without charge. Unthinkable? Of course it is, in this country. But it is happening in another, right now.
And the Government responsible is not some remote totalitarian regime. It is the Government of an American ally, one that we have admired as an outpost of democracy and law: Israel. Israeli soldiers have sealed off the town of Beit Sahour, in the occupied West Bank, since Sept. 22. Telephone lines have been cut.
The town has been declared a “closed military zone” and everyone from the outside world kept out — sympathetic Israelis, journalists, Western diplomats. Christian bishops who tried to bring three truckloads of food in the other day were turned back. Beit Sahour is a town of 15,000, almost all Christians, near Bethlehem. It is a middle-class place.
This summer its business and other leaders decided, as their part in the Palestinian protest against occupation, to withhold payment of Israeli taxes. Taxation without representation is a grievance in any case. Despite the blockade, quite a lot has been reported about what has happened in Beit Sahour since Sept. 22. The army has seized property worth many times the tax claims.
It has ransacked shops. And according to the residents, it has systematically harassed and humiliated the people of Beit Sahour. I telephoned an Israeli who knows the town well, Hillel Bardin, a computer programmer at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem.
For the last 18 months he has been part of a group of Israelis carrying on a dialogue with a group from Beit Sahour, exchanging visits and talking about Israeli-Palestinian peace. Mr. Bardin began by saying that, apart from the tax protest, those in Beit Sahour who have spoken out for peace with Israel have been punished.
He mentioned two men in his dialogue group, Jamal Hilal and Ghassan Antoni. “Both have been arrested repeatedly since July,” he said. “They are never questioned or charged with anything, just held for 18 days as Israel’s law allows. “The last time, Oct.
25, they were beaten so badly by soldiers on the way to headquarters that Jamal still cannot walk properly. They are in prison again.” As to the tax protest, Mr. Bardin said the reports of harassment and force in the Government’s response were true. He said he had seen one man who was bloodied when soldiers came and took his furniture.
At Elias Rishmawi’s pharmacy, he said, “they put all the medicines in a large shipping container and left it in the sun until the drugs spoiled.”
Even a Stalemate Forces Israel to Pay A Corrosive Price
Jack Rosenthal
On the brown velvet sofa in the living room, the father gestures at the street, silent except for the occasional rush of an Israeli jeep. Suddenly, his three boys tumble downstairs, their dark eyes big with alarm: “Come quick, come quick! There’s a big machine!”
The man leads his visitors upstairs to a bedroom that looks familiar to Americans with its Formica bunks, TV and board games. From the window, one can see Israeli soldiers clustered in front of a carpenter’s house a block away as a crane lifts the lathe from his shop. The boys are frozen to the window, fear and fury in their eyes. Why the crane? Why the deserted streets?
Why the heavy military presence? Because here in the Christian town of Beit Sahour a few minutes from Jerusalem, Palestinians have been fighting the newest battle against Israel’s occupation of the West Bank and Gaza.
Despite daytime curfews and harsh Israeli efforts to make examples of people, the residents of Beit Sahour have refused to pay their taxes — even when that meant seizures of property to be sold at auction. Last week, the tax boycott ended in a stalemate, an outcome that says much about the whole 23-month uprising, the intifada.
For it too seems to have settled into a stalemate. Israel seems to have decided that it can live with the intifada, live with the status quo. But truly, there is no status quo. Israelis pay a painful price for containing the uprising — a price that abrades the army, hobbles the economy and corrodes democracy. The Army: Israeli troops are not monsters.
They struggle to be stern without being brutal. Their bullets, mostly, are rubber. But policing civilians involves constant pressure, especially for Israel’s citizen army. Many of the reservist soldiers hate this duty, so alien to the intrepid image of the hostage rescue in Entebbe. The steady erosion of morale worries Israeli commanders.
The Economy: In financial terms, the costliest price is the loss of “exports” to the West Bank. Before the intifada, Palestinians bought a billion dollars a year in Israeli products; with boycotts, the figure is down 30 percent. As one Palestinian says, in front of a graffiti-spattered wall, “The only Israeli product we buy now is spray paint.”
BOSTON — Suppose the people of some small American town decided to protest federal government policy by withholding their taxes. The government responded by sending in the Army. Soldiers cut all telephone lines to the town. They stopped food from coming in and barred all visitors. They imposed a curfew from 6:30 every evening to 4:30 in the morning.
They went into homes and took furniture and other belongings worth many times a family’s unpaid taxes. They broke into shops and dumped goods in the streets. They arrested people and held them for days without charge. Unthinkable? Of course it is, in this country. But it is happening in another, right now.
And the government responsible is not some remote totalitarian regime. It is the government of an American ally, one that we have admired as an outpost of democracy and law: Israel. Israeli soldiers have sealed off the town of Beit Sahour, in the occupied West Bank, since Sept. 22. Telephone lines have been cut.
The town has been declared a “closed military zone” and everyone from the outside world kept out — sympathetic Israelis, journalists, Western diplomats. Christian bishops who tried to bring three truckloads of food in the other day were turned back. Beit Sahour is a town of 15,000, almost all Christians, near Bethlehem. It is a middle-class place.
This summer its business and other leaders decided, as their part in the Palestinian protest against occupation, to withhold payment of Israeli taxes. Taxation without representation is a grievance in any case. Despite the blockade, quite a lot has been reported about what has happened in Beit Sahour since Sept. 22. The army has seized property worth many times the tax claims.
It has ransacked shops. And according to the residents, it has systematically harassed and humiliated the people of Beit Sahour. I telephoned an Israeli who knows the town well, Hillel Bardin, a computer programmer at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem.
For the last 18 months he has been part of a group of Israelis carrying on a dialogue with a group from Beit Sahour, exchanging visits and talking about Israeli-Palestinian peace. Bardin began by saying that, apart from the tax protest, those in Beit Sahour who have spoken out for peace with Israel have been punished.
He mentioned two men in his dialogue group, Jamal Hilal and Ghassan Antoni. “Both have been arrested repeatedly since July,” he said. “They are never questioned or charged with anything, just held for 18 days as Israel’s law allows. “The last time, Oct.
25, they were beaten so badly by soldiers on the way to headquarters that Jamal still cannot walk properly. They are in prison again.” As to the tax protest, Bardin said the reports of harassment and force in the government’s response were true. He said he had seen one man who was bloodied when soldiers came and took his furniture.
At Elias Rishmawi’s pharmacy, he said, “they put all the medicines in a large shipping container and left it in the sun until the drugs spoiled.”
At midday the word spreads among the young men of Husan: Gather at the usual place just after dark. A little before 8 p.m., about 15 youths assemble at the prearranged spot. Their faces are covered by ski masks or checkered “kaffiyehs,” and each in turn utters the password, an Arabic letter difficult for Hebrew speakers to pronounce.
Satisfied that no strangers had infiltrated the group, they set off down the narrow streets and dirt alleys of this small West Bank village just south of Bethlehem, heading for the highway. In minutes, the settlers’ bus will roll past, escorted by two jeeps full of soldiers.
Villagers the youths pass offer no more than quiet greetings, perhaps a whispered “God be with you.” If the “shebab” (literally “the guys”) respond at all, it is to point silently at a porch light — and in an instant the light is turned off. When the army starts shooting, the shebab want to be sure they can slip away into the darkness.
As the young men reach the highway, they scatter across the attack site, a boulder-strewn meadow sloping down to the pavement. One by one, they pick up stones, weighing them in their hands as they wait. Just after 8 p.m. the little convoy enters the town.
On the bright red and white Mercedes bus are just three passengers, long-bearded Jews from Betar Illit, the religious settlement up the road. Built in 1985 on land that had belonged to Husan residents, Betar Illit is little more than a few trailers surrounded by barbed wire, home to 12 families.
In the light from the nearly full moon, the shebab, crouching behind the low boulders, watch the bus approach. Sitting in a front seat is a soldier in olive green, pointing his M-16 out the window. In the jeeps leading and following the bus, troops also sit with their weapons aimed into the dark and their plexiglass face shields lowered.
As they reach the town the soldiers hear several shrill whistles — the shebab signaling to one another. From the convoy, as if in reply, comes the sound of rifle bolts snapping into place, loading bullets into chambers.
The seesaw clash between Israeli soldiers and Palestinian demonstrators is played out almost daily along the West Bank. Israeli troops (left) recently responded to a rock-throwing attack during a demonstration in Nablus. On another occasion in the same area, Palestinians threw stones and waved the outlawed Palestinian flag
BEIT SAHUR, Occupied West Bank (AP) — The Israeli army took down the barricades around this Palestinian town yesterday, ending 42 days of seizing cars, furniture and other goods to crush a tax boycott.
But as hundreds of jubilant townspeople waved “V” signs and sang, military authorities said they had succeeded in breaking the revolt, seizing the equivalent of more than $1.5 million to make up for unpaid taxes. “We are always collecting taxes. We have always collected taxes. We are the authorities,” said Brig. Gen.
Shaike Erez, head of the West Bank military government. Hanan Banura, 25, a mother of two whose husband is in jail for refusing to pay taxes, said the town’s defiance strengthened the 22-month-old Palestinian uprising against occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip. “We won something here,” she said.
“We did what we wanted to do, not what they wanted.” The bulldozers that pushed away the earthen mound blocking off the Christian Arab town of 10,000 people ended Beit Sahur’s unlikely role as a symbol of the revolt against occupation. It is a town of large, prosperous-looking homes of sun-bleached stone located down steep, winding roads from Bethlehem.
Until recently, its middle-class residents were derided as “rich revolutionaries” by poor Palestinians in refugee camps who fought Israelis with stones and firebombs. Of the more than 600 Palestinians killed in clashes with soldiers or civilians in the uprising, only one died in Beit Sahur.
But Beit Sahur, known mostly for the fields where shepherds first learned of Christ’s birth, kept up the boycott of Israeli taxes ordered by the PLO-backed leaders of the uprising long after most other Palestinians gave in to Israeli pressure. Much to Israel’s consternation, the tax revolt has gotten as much publicity as the uprising’s persistent violence.
Journalists who sneaked into Beit Sahur described refrigerators, rugs, cars, televisions and all manner of goods being hauled away. On one side, townspeople complained against “taxation without representation.” On the other, Israel claimed it was seizing goods only to collect taxes to support schools, roads and other services.
Israeli officials said that debts from 398 major tax debtors were “handled” in the six-week campaign and that confiscated goods included 33 cars, bank accounts and cash. A statement by military officials said soldiers also arrested 40 tax debtors. Thirty-five have been indicted.
Residents of Beit Sahur wave “V” sign while celebrating the ending of a campaign by the Israeli army aimed at breaking a tax boycott.
Army Ends West Bank Seizures; Both Sides Claim Victory
Associated Press
BEIT SAHOUR, Occupied West Bank (AP) — The army took down the barricades around this Palestinian town Tuesday, ending 42 days of seizing cars, furniture and other goods to crush a tax boycott. Jubilant residents took to the streets to shout victory.
But as hundreds of the townspeople waved “V” signs and sang, military authorities said they had succeeded in breaking the revolt, seizing the equivalent of more than $1.5 million to make up for unpaid taxes. “We are always collecting taxes. We have always collected taxes. We are the authorities,” said Brig. Gen.
Shaike Erez, head of the West Bank military government. “We have realized what we wanted to accomplish, and more.” Not all Israelis agreed. Seven left-wing Israeli legislators who visited the town Monday — on condition they not take journalists along — said Tuesday that the tax campaign was a failure.
Lova Eliav, a Labor Party legislator, described the campaign against Beit Sahour as “a futile, foolish exercise ... The army has turned elite soldiers into tax collectors.”
Legislator Dedi Zucker of the Citizens’ Rights Movement said what happened in Beit Sahour was “a fight over who is a sovereign ... and it has not been proven Israel is a real sovereign in Beit Sahour.”
Hanan Banura, a 25-year-old mother of two whose husband is in jail for refusing to pay taxes, said the town’s defiance strengthened the 22-month-old Palestinian uprising against occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip. “We won something here,” she said. “We did what we wanted to do, not what they wanted.”
The bulldozers that pushed away the earthen mound blocking the Christian Arab town of 10,000 people ended Beit Sahour’s unlikely role as a symbol of the revolt against occupation. It is a town of large, prosperous-looking homes of sun-bleached stone, down steep, winding roads from Bethlehem.
Until recently, its middle-class residents were derided as “rich revolutionaries” by poor Palestinians in refugee camps who fought Israelis with stones and firebombs.
Beit Sahour, known mostly for the fields where shepherds first learned of Christ’s birth, kept up the boycott of Israeli taxes ordered by the PLO-backed leaders of the uprising long after most other Palestinians gave in to Israeli pressure. Much to Israel’s consternation, the tax revolt has gotten as much publicity as the uprising’s persistent violence.
Journalists who sneaked into Beit Sahour described all manner of goods being hauled away. On one side, townspeople complained against “taxation without representation.” On the other, Israel claimed to be seizing goods only to collect taxes to support schools, roads and other services.
The army magazine Bamahane said in its most recent edition that people in Beit Sahour owed about $500,000 in taxes; but the extra goods were seized to cover “transport and storage.” Chakib Awad, the owner of a factory that makes bakery machinery and metal statues of Christ for sale to tourists, said Beit Sahour showed that it had a role in the revolt.
He displayed a list of 18 machines, which he valued at $69,250, that he said had been seized from his factory. Awad said that before the uprising, he had paid taxes to Israeli authorities or the Jordanian government when it controlled the West Bank. But he added that he no longer wanted to pay occupiers.
To the Editor: Anthony Lewis, in a column about Israel’s handling of a tax strike in the West Bank Arab town of Beit Sahour (“It Can Happen There,” Oct. 29), writes: “Suppose the people of some small American town decided to protest Federal Government policy by withholding their taxes. The Government responded by sending in the Army. . . . Unthinkable?
Of course it is, in this country. But it is happening in another: . . . Israel.” If Beit Sahour were an Israeli town that did not pay its taxes merely to protest government policy, Mr. Lewis’s comparison would have been apt. However, that is not the case.
To give the proper context, he should have written: Suppose we were still in the pre-glasnost period and Mexico had become Communist, demanding that the United States return territories taken from it in the wake of the Mexican War: Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, Utah, Nevada and California.
Suppose also a majority of former Mexicans lived in some of these areas, who felt they were discriminated against, wished to secede from the Union and started a widespread insurrection that was supported and financed by Mexico and other Communist states in Latin America.
The insurrectionists obstructed communications and access to their areas of residence and attacked civilians, the police and the National Guard with stones and Molotov cocktails; and to bring about a breakdown in governmental activity, they killed former Mexicans holding jobs with the state or Federal Governments and then began to withhold their taxes. If Mr.
Lewis had given the Beit Sahour affair this context, it would have been a constructive contribution toward understanding Israel’s position.
The agent is in the last two words and attached to the noun rather than to a verb: people die in shootings that are Israeli. Nobody shoots. The girl is counted separately from the Palestinians and called Arab, so the headline uses two different words for the same people in eight words.
To the Editor: Clinton Bailey’s comparison of the tax revolt in the West Bank town of Beit Sahour to an American town with a majority of former Mexicans “who wished to secede from the Union” is false (letter, Nov. 26). Beit Sahour does not have a “majority” of former Palestinians. It is all Palestinian, 100 percent Palestinian Arabs.
It cannot secede from Israel because it was never part of Israel. Beit Sahour is in the occupied West Bank. Its residents refused to pay Israeli taxes under the slogan of “no taxation without representation” — a slogan that should be familiar to all U.S. citizens.
Quayle asks U.N. to repeal resolution on Zionism, racism
Associated Press, United Nations
UNITED NATIONS (AP) — Vice President Dan Quayle said this week the United Nations should repeal its “odious” 1975 resolution that equates Zionism with racism in an effort to promote the Middle East peace process. He also gave Secretary-General Javier Perez de Cuellar a check for $65 million in partial payment of major U.S. arrears, an issue that has stirred anti-U.S. sentiment here.
U.N. officials said the United States now owes $365 million for the regular budget and $153 million for peacekeeping. “Repealing this resolution would re-establish the stature and moral authority of the U.N.,” Quayle said… Francois Giuliani, spokesman for the secretary-general, said it is up to the member states and General Assembly to decide. He said no resolution has ever been rescinded or repealed, but that the 159-nation General Assembly “can innovate if it wishes to do so.”
Resolutions are part of the permanent record and cannot be repealed or erased, U.N. diplomats said.… Quayle was asked how repeal would promote Palestinian rights.
He said that renouncing the resolution would help human rights in the occupied territories and send a positive signal about the Middle East peace process… The General Assembly later adopted a package of pro-PLO, anti-Israel resolutions — an annual event.
The vice president asks for the repeal and hands over a check for arrears in the same visit. The useful paragraph is the procedural one: at the end of 1989 no General Assembly resolution had ever been rescinded, and a spokesman had to explain that the body could innovate if it wished.
It’s not the Grinch who will steal Christmas in Bethlehem, Beit Sahur
Deutsche Presse-Agentur
BETHLEHEM, Israel — Festivities celebrating Christmas have been canceled in the towns of Bethlehem and Beit Sahur this year, officials said Thursday. Out of solidarity with the Palestinian uprising known as intifada, just entering its third year, both towns are refusing to put up decorated Christmas trees and lighting displays, the Beit Sahur local administration said.
In Bethlehem the mayor’s traditional Christmas reception has been canceled for the second year running, but church services will go ahead as usual, officials said. For the first time, there will be no Christmas tree this year in the Church of Nativity in Bethlehem, where more than a third of 35,000 residents are Christian.
“In view of the economic and political situation, we just don’t feel like celebrating,” said the Rev. Mitri Raheb. According to Raheb, there were 10 Christians among the more than 600 Palestinian victims. Instead of the traditional fir tree, a tree made from olive branches and decorated with locally made ornaments will be put up in the churches.
Friends of Beit Sahour work for justice for Palestinians
Andrea Tally
Felicia Langer is an Israeli lawyer, a Holocaust survivor and a woman who has devoted her professional life to defending Palestinian human rights. In her office hangs a picture of an Israeli soldier brutalizing a Palestinian youth. Underneath is the caption “Don’t say you didn’t know.”
We, members of a delegation of about 120 U.S. human rights activists who recently traveled to the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, write to share what we have come to know about the brutalization and dehumanization of the Palestinian people in that area. The occasion of our visit was an attempt to break the siege of the small Palestinian village of Beit Sahour near Bethlehem.
We met the people, walked their streets, slept in their homes, listened to their stories, witnessed their oppression and marched with them in the first demonstration there in 16 months that didn’t end in tear gas, beating or shooting.
The people of Beit Sahour have refused to pay taxes since July 1988 on the principles that there should be no taxation without representation, and the Israeli tax policy is in violation of the 4th Geneva Convention. In a letter of Nov.
5, the people wrote: “We strongly believe that every citizen has to pay taxes for his national government to enable it to perform its duties and obligations, so we enquire ‘Where is our national government?’...We refuse to pay taxes to the occupier of the land because we consider it a symbol of slavery and oppression.”
Besides, the 4th Geneva Convention mandates that taxes may only be levied on an occupied territory if the tax money is returned in services to the people of that area. “Where are the services?” the people of Beit Sahour ask, “They are almost non-existent.
There is no social insurance, no houses for the old or handicapped or orphans...The health system in the West Bank goes back to the 19th century. There is no free education...For all these reasons and as a result of our full conviction the money collected...goes to the purchase of bullets and tear gas to kill our children, we have decided not to pay taxes any longer.”
Israel to Seize Property of Young Stone-Throwers’ Parents
“There is no claim that the father threw the rock, could have prevented it or even knew about it. It flies in the face of mens rea — that to be criminally liable you have to have intent.”
Military law forbids jailing children under twelve, so the army announced it would seize their parents’ property instead. The Palestinian lawyer Jonathan Kuttab names the legal principle being set aside. Collective punishment, explained by the army in the plain language of People weren’t paying the fines.
BEIT SAHUR, West Bank — When South African Archbishop Desmond Tutu arrives today in this predominantly Christian town near the traditional birthplace of Jesus, he will find residents bemoaning their “saddest holiday ever.”
Beit Sahur, a neighbor of Bethlehem, is still reeling from Israel’s hard-hitting response to a tax revolt many of its 12,000 residents waged this fall. The revolt was part of the intifada, or Palestinian uprising against Israeli control of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, which broke out on Dec. 9, 1987, and is continuing with no end in sight.
Christians form a minority of 70,000 among the predominantly Muslim 1.75 million West Bankers and Gazans. They have played an active role in the uprising and shunned Christmas celebrations the last two years in solidarity with Palestinians killed, wounded and imprisoned in the struggle with Israel.
In Beit Sahur, the government’s tax crackdown has generated a mood that is morose even by comparison with other communities in the territories.
“There is nothing to celebrate here this Christmas,” Vice Mayor Khalil Kheir said in an interview at the town’s modest city hall on Wednesday. […] Still, residents view Tutu’s decision to offer a Christmas Eve sermon in Beit Sahur as “an encouraging show of solidarity” with their plight, Kheir added.
Tutu, a critic of Israeli policy in the territories, is visiting Israel and the West Bank at the invitation of Bishop Samir Kafity of St. George’s Anglican Church in Jerusalem. Aides have described the anti-apartheid leader’s visit as “a spiritual pilgrimage.”
Tutu is expected by residents to refocus international attention on Beit Sahur’s civil disobedience campaign, aimed at forcing a withdrawal of the Israeli army. Beit Sahur residents take pride in their non-violent refusal to cooperate with the military government.
But Israeli troops have faced stones and petrol bombs in the town in addition to civil disobedience, according to Ofra Preuss, an army spokeswoman. Residents, who were described by an informed army officer as “well-organized and well-educated,” launched their tax revolt under the American slogan of “no taxation without representation.”
According to a flyer circulated by a group calling itself “Women of Beit Sahur,” the townspeople stopped paying taxes because the money would be spent by Israel on “bullets to be used against our children.” Government officials countered that the taxes are used to provide health and other services in Beit Sahur and the rest of the West Bank.
Vowing to prevent the spread of the revolt to other towns, Israeli Defense Minister Yitzhak Rabin kept Beit Sahur closed to outsiders for six weeks in September and October. Troops and tax officials arrested 40 people for nonpayment of taxes during that period. They also confiscated an estimated $1.5 million worth of goods, according to the army spokesman’s office.
Vice Mayor Kheir estimated that the confiscated goods are worth $5 million. Since the tax raids ended, Israel has been unable to recreate a semblance of normalcy in Beit Sahur, the army officer acknowledged. “We want people to reopen their shops but they refuse,” he said.
On Beit Sahur’s once bustling main shopping street, the Street of the Churches, a post office and pharmacy were the only places showing signs of life this week. Residents now make their purchases in Bethlehem. Inside the pharmacy, its proprietor, who spent 18 days in prison during the tax raids, pointed to empty shelves where his medications were once stocked.
The tax authorities confiscated them, he said. “I’m surviving off of manna from heaven,” the pharmacist added with a smile. Other businessmen hit by confiscations said relatives and friends are supporting them. Shepherd’s Field, formerly Beit Sahur’s main tourist attraction, was even more deserted than the Street of the Churches.
The field, where shepherds are believed to have received tidings of Jesus’ birth, is now overlooked by an Israeli army position set up in September as a repository for confiscated goods. Between the army base and the field stands the house of Hanna Rashmawi.
Rashmawi, a billiard hall owner unemployed since the uprising broke out, said he will spend Christmas worrying about his son Tony’s impending trial on charges of stoning an Israeli civilian bus. The army on Friday night was slated to release Tony from prison in northern Israel for a week-long holiday break.
But Rashmawi was not impressed by that gesture, and insisted that “there can be no holiday until we achieve independence.” Still, the Rashmawis are giving visitors to their home a small Christmas present. It is a crocheted boutonniere of red, green, black and white, the colors of the Palestinian flag.
South Africa’s Archbishop Desmond Tutu watches a Palestinian boy give the “V” for victory sign as he passes the Dome of the Rock mosque during a tour of Jerusalem. At right is Sheik Mohammed Al-Jamal, deputy mufti of Jerusalem.
To the West, they are the unknown revolutionaries. Although frequently seen on the front lines of the intifada and on our television screens, their lives, history, political aspirations and social agenda remain shrouded in mystery.
They are Palestinian women, whose involvement in the rebellion in Israel's occupied territories has exceeded the political activism of other women in the Third World. Activism among Palestinian women is not new.
As early as 1921, Christian and Muslim women, the latter often veiled, participated in mass demonstrations in Jerusalem to protest unrestricted Jewish immigration to British-controlled Palestine. The Arab Women's Union, one of the oldest feminist organizations in the region, was founded that year, organized by Milia Sakakini, a Christian, and Zuleikha Shihabi, a Muslim.
Their initial agenda was nationalist; Zionism, not male chauvinism, was the enemy. Throughout Palestinian history, women have shown an uncanny strategic sense that placed them at the center of public life. Since the Israeli occupation of the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, women have created the only institutions capable of delivering social welfare services to the area.
Schools became centers of social and political activism where poorer women learned the value of economic self-reliance and abstention from the Israeli labor market. The founder of one of these schools, Samiha Khali, joined the three-member Committee of National Guidance, which coordinated resistance in the occupied territories in the 1970s.
When the economic impact of the occupation threatened to disrupt the pattern of traditional family life, women's work committees, composed of politicized and educated younger women, provided invaluable service.
The committees provided day-care services and instructed lower-class, working women in bargaining and survival techniques as they swelled the ranks of Israel's job market.
Clearly, feminism among Palestinians focused on the group, not the individual: How to salvage Palestinian society as a whole, how to survive as a nation, and how to save the family and children became the key questions for Palestinian women. Feminism in the midst of chaos and revolution imposes a heavy toll.
Women participating in the intifada have gone to prison, and their cases have attracted the attention of Amnesty International and the Israeli press. Even some Israeli women, such as the group called Women in Black, frequently demonstrate on the Palestinians' behalf.
Yet the American feminist movement is unmoved by all of this, which is surprising since American women have always expressed sympathy for the oppression of women in traditional Arab societies. Why, then, has the American feminist motto, “Sisterhood is global,” failed to include Palestinian women?
One reason may be the American movement's historical thrust against the patriarchal institution of the family. Focusing on the family as the repository of the most resilient pattern of male dominance, feminists have traditionally attacked this institution as inimical to female liberation and equality.
But, in Third World countries, the family is not an obstacle to the emancipation of women. In Palestinian society, as in all other Arab societies, women maintain access to a variety of resources within the family. Arab women have demonstrated in the past the utility of this institution as a buffer against the disruptive forces of rapid modernization and economic change.
To the occupied Palestinians in particular, the family is the only indigenous institution beside the mosque and the church to remain impervious to Israeli influences and control. The intifada has successfully mobilized a nation, male and female. Women have been asked to join with their brothers and husbands to suffer and endure until their dreams of statehood are realized.
Women have emerged as new citizens, with rights to uphold and duties to fulfill. Will there ever come a time when Palestinian women will substitute the gender war for a national struggle? Perhaps, but there are strong indications that the intifada is producing emancipated men.
In the meantime, we can only hope the Palestinian feminist experience will be recognized because, putting politics aside, affirming the universal bonds of sisterhood is what the new feminism is all about. Ghada Talhami, an associate professor of politics at Lake Forest College, Lake Forest, Ill., was born in Jerusalem.
Signed op-ed. The tagline at the foot reads: Ghada Talhami, an associate professor of politics at Lake Forest College, Lake Forest, Ill., was born in Jerusalem.
Part of Covering Palestine, an archive of 3637 newspaper clippings about Palestinians printed in 748 papers between 1724 and 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles. Nothing here was printed after 6 October 2023.