Sanford Herald · 12 May 1987
CP-1987-068
Charges against Palestinians dismissed; INS to file appeal

Transcribed from the clipping
LOS ANGELES (UPI) — The government plans to refile charges that were abruptly dismissed by a furious immigration judge against eight foreign nationals accused of belonging to a Palestinian terrorist group, officials said.
Judge Ingrid Hrycenko said she dismissed the charges Monday because Gilbert Reeves, who was acting Los Angeles district director of the Immigration and Naturalization Service when the defendants were charged in December, failed to appear at the hearing as she had ordered.
Hrycenko, shaking with anger, said that without Reeves as a witness, the government could not prove the charges were approved by someone with proper authority. “I will terminate all proceedings because of the defective issuance of an order to show cause,” Hrycenko said.
The judge then strode from the bench, but returned moments later to tell INS attorneys, “I will no longer tolerate any of these tactics. You have 10 days in which to decide whether to file an appeal.”
Esmeralda Cabrera, the government attorney in charge of the case, said after the decision the government would refile the charges against the defendants, seven Jordanians and one Kenyan. “The cases are very much alive,” Cabrera said. It was unclear exactly what Hrycenko meant by “tactics,” and she declined to comment on her decision after the preceding.
But a Justice Department source told the Los Angeles Times that the government had welcomed the possibility of having a new judge assigned to the complex and controversial case.
Hrycenko, a former federal prosecutor, has overridden government objections that she did not have authority to hold a due-process hearing and raised questions about Reeves' authority to sign the original deportation orders.
“Was that a slick move or was that a slick move?” an unidentified goverment official told the Times, referring to the government's decision to not produce Reeves, leading Hrycenko to dismiss the charges and likely setting the scene for a new judge to hear the case.
How this transcription was made
Read from the scan Maria supplied on 17 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. NO MASTHEAD AND NO DATE LINE. The strip above the headline is the tail of an unrelated story on the same page, not a running head; I magnified it to check. Neither `pub` (Sanford Herald) nor `date` (1987-05-12) is confirmed by the page. Internal evidence: the dismissal happened "Monday" and the story is the second-day follow, so publication on Tuesday 12 May 1987 fits, as 11 May 1987 was a Monday. Consistent, not confirmed. No masthead, no folio, no byline. `pub` and `date` unverified from the page and not changed. SAME WIRE SERVICE, DIFFERENT STORY, SAME DAY. This is a UPI story datelined LOS ANGELES, as la049 is, and both are labelled 12 May 1987 — but they are NOT the same copy. la049 is the first-edition story ("A federal judge Monday dismissed all charges"); this is the fuller second-day version led on the government's plan to refile ("The government plans to refile charges that were abruptly dismissed by a furious immigration judge"). Several paragraphs are shared verbatim — the Hrycenko quotations, the Shehadeh quotation, the Rosenbaum quotation, the roll of the other defendants — so the two records will duplicate text. They are two different UPI takes, not a duplicate clipping, and both should stand. la049 reports Hrycenko telling INS attorneys "sternly"; this version omits the adverb. That is the kind of small difference that marks two distinct wire takes rather than one. HAMIDE'S AGE: 33 here, and only 33 — "Khader Hamide, 33, and Michel Shehadeh, 30". la049, from the same wire service on the same day, prints 33 in one paragraph and 32 in the next. Every clipping before May in this batch says 32. THE SAME TYPO APPEARS IN BOTH UPI CLIPPINGS: "Long Beach State Univerisity". Because it occurs in la049 (Olathe) and here (Sanford), it is in the wire copy, not introduced by either local composing room. Preserved in both. Further printed errors on this page, all preserved: "an unidentified goverment official" (GOVERMENT, missing the n) and "she declined to comment on her decision after the preceding" (where the sense wants "the proceeding"). NEW NAME: ESMERALDA CABRERA, "the government attorney in charge of the case". She is not named in any other clipping in this batch. This clipping is the only one in the batch that gives the length of the investigation: "The arrests of the eight defendants in January, after a 3 1/2-year investigation by the FBI and the INS, sparked outrage among Arab-Americans and civil libertarians, who accused the government of trying to muzzle debate on the Palestinian issue." The fraction is set as a proper 3 1/2 with a fraction glyph; I have not carried it into the excerpt, which stops earlier. This story sources two separate claims to the Los Angeles Times — a Justice Department source and an unidentified government official — with "Los Angeles Times" and then "Times" set in italic. A UPI story quoting a Los Angeles Times scoop is worth noting for the consortium's media trail; the Times's own coverage of this day is not in this batch. What the judge actually ruled on is unchanged from la049: the defective issuance of the order to show cause, not the First Amendment and not McCarran-Walter. `photo_caption` empty; no photograph on this clipping. Pen or pencil marks cross the first column of the scan (a curved line through the Hrycenko paragraphs); they do not obscure any word, and I read every affected line at 5x to be sure.
Cite this clipping
"Charges against Palestinians dismissed; INS to file appeal," Sanford Herald, 12 May 1987. Covering Palestine archive, CP-1987-068. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-1987-068
More from the 1980s
- Palestinians Under Israel: Bitter PoliticsThe New York Times · 12 January 1987
- Are jailed Palestinians terrorists or scapegoats?Los Angeles Herald Examiner · 15 February 1987
- Last 3 Arabs are freed in case of terrorist groupLos Angeles Herald Examiner · 19 February 1987
- Accused PLO members freedLos Angeles Times · 19 February 1987
- Jordanians tell of INS ‘nightmare’Los Angeles Herald Examiner · 26 February 1987
- Uneasy in ZionThe New York Times · 1 March 1987
- All 571 clippings from the 1980s →
Last updated 17 November 2026
This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.
The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.
Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-1987-068.
Everything printed in 1987 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset