← Covering Palestine

Olathe Daily News · 12 May 1987

CP-1987-067

Judge drops charges in deportation case

Judge drops charges in deportation case — Olathe Daily News, 12 May 1987
Olathe Daily News · 12 May 1987
Scan 860 × 294 pixels

Send this clipping to somebody

Transcribed from the clipping

LOS ANGELES (UPI) — A federal judge Monday dismissed all charges against eight foreign nationals who accused of membership in a Palestinian terrorist group because a top immigration official failed appear at their deportation hearing. U.S.

Immigration Judge Ingrid Hrycenko angrily noted that without testimony of Gilbert Reeves, who was acting Los Angeles district director of the Immigration and Naturalization Service when the defendants were charged in December, the government could not prove that the charges had been properly authorized.

The packed courtroom immediately erupted in pandemonium as the defendants, seven Jordanians and one Kenyan, and their lawyers jumped up, cried out and hugged each other. Government attorneys left silently, without comment.

Hrycenko, shaking with anger, had said that without Reeves as a witness the government could not prove the charges were approved by someone with proper authority. Hrycenko Friday had ordered Reeves to appear at Monday's hearing. “I will terminate all proceedings because of the defective issuance of an order to show cause,” Hrycenko said.

The judge then strode from the bench, but returned moments later to tell INS attorneys sternly, “I will no longer tolerate any of these tactics. You have 10 days in which to decide whether to file an appeal.” INS officials had not decided whether to appeal the ruling.

“I'm so happy,” said defendant Michel Shehadeh, 30, a Long Beach State Univerisity student. “It proves what we've been saying all along, that we're good, lawful residents of this country. I have faith in the American people, that whatever the government will do, the American people are watching and won't let them get away with it.”

How this transcription was made

Read from the scan Maria supplied on 17 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. Running head present and the date matches: "The Olathe Daily News Tuesday, May 12, 1987 Page 2". 12 May 1987 was a Tuesday, so the label date 1987-05-12 is confirmed by the page. MASTHEAD AGAINST `pub`, FLAGGING AS REQUIRED. The running head on this page reads "The Olathe Daily News", WITH a leading "The". The archive's `pub` for this record is "Olathe Daily News", without it. I have not changed `pub`. This is precisely the kind of difference that would ingest as a second newspaper, so somebody should decide which form the archive holds before this record goes in. Note that only a running head is visible, not the paper's own front-page flag, and running heads sometimes carry the article "The" where the flag does not. This is a UPI wire story (dateline "LOS ANGELES (UPI)"), so the same text may appear in other papers in this deck on or about 12 May. la050 and la051 are labelled the same date and should be compared; if they carry the same UPI copy they are separate printings of one story, not independent accounts. TWO PRINTED ERRORS IN THE LEAD SENTENCE, both preserved: "eight foreign nationals who accused of membership" (missing "were") and "failed appear at their deportation hearing" (missing "to"). Both are as set. ANOTHER PRINTED TYPO PRESERVED: "a Long Beach State Univerisity student" — UNIVERISITY, with the letters transposed. Checked at 9x; it is the page, not the scan. HAMIDE'S AGE IS GIVEN TWICE IN THIS ONE STORY AND THE TWO DISAGREE. Column 4: "the other two, Khader Hamide, 33, and Shehadeh, who are permanent resident aliens". Four lines later: "Hamide, 32, is a suspected leader of the California faction of the PFLP." I magnified both figures to 22x; the first is unmistakably 33 and the second unmistakably 32. The wire copy contradicts itself. Every other clipping in this batch says 32. Julie Mungai is given as 28 here ("Hamide's wife, Julie Mungai, 28, a citizen of Kenya"), against la048's 29 seventeen days earlier. The defendants are called "seven Jordanians and one Kenyan" in the pandemonium paragraph but the charge is "membership in a Palestinian terrorist group". The word Palestinian is never applied to the people in this story. NEW NAME, and an important one for the case's collapse: GILBERT REEVES, acting Los Angeles district director of the INS when the charges were signed, whose non-appearance brought the dismissal. Also new: ERNEST GUSTAFSON, District Director, who signed the revised charges. William Odencrantz, named in la048 as "INS spokesman", is given here with a fuller title: "regional counsel for the INS". The page says the defendants "were charged in December" — i.e. the orders to show cause were signed in December 1986, before the 26 January 1987 arrests. No other clipping in this batch dates the charging documents. What the ruling actually turned on, per this story: not the First Amendment, not McCarran-Walter, but whether the order to show cause had been properly authorised — "the defective issuance of an order to show cause". Odencrantz said the government did not feel it needed to put Reeves on the stand because the revised charges were signed by District Director Ernest Gustafson, while Reeves had signed the original charges. The INS's stated options after the dismissal: take it to the Board of Immigration Appeals in Washington, or file the same revised charges against the eight again in Los Angeles. Beyond the excerpt, defense lawyer Mark Rosenbaum is quoted outside court: "The real seditionists, the real subversives in this case are the INS," and "These charges were nationality-based charges ... and it turned out the government terrorized the constitution." Not carried into `quotes` because they fall outside the transcribed excerpt. Residences as set here: Aiad Barakat, 26, OF GLENDALE; Naim Sharif, 26, of Northridge; Bashar Amer, 24, of Alta Loma. Barakat is placed in Glendale, agreeing with la041 and la044 and against la040's Northridge.

Cite this clipping

"Judge drops charges in deportation case," Olathe Daily News, 12 May 1987, p. 2. Covering Palestine archive, CP-1987-067. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-1987-067

More from the 1980s

Last updated 17 November 2026

This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.

The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.

Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-1987-067.

Everything printed in 1987 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset