Los Angeles Herald Examiner · 25 April 1987
CP-1987-066
Judge won't dismiss case against Palestinians, Kenyan
Subversion charges dropped, but INS still asks deportation on visa violations

Transcribed from the clipping
An immigration judge yesterday denied defense requests to dismiss a deportation case against eight people accused of belonging to a Palestinian terrorist organization. Immigration Judge Ingrid Hrycenko denied defense contentions that the charges are unconstitutional, that the government was singling out Arabs and that the government had engaged in misconduct.
The judge also denied a defense request that the Immigration and Naturalization Service produce evidence against their clients, saying the rule of discovery — which allows opposing sides to examine one another's evidence — does not apply in immigration court.
INS officials dropped subversion charges against six of the eight on Thursday but vowed to deport them on visa violations. Civil rights attorneys who are defending the eight yesterday called the government's tactic “a farce” and an attempt to limit political discussion on the Palestinian issue.
“What happended here is no different than what happened 30 years ago. This is new-fangled McCarthyism,” said ACLU attorney Mark Rosenbaum. The seven Palestinians and one Kenyan were arrested in January in a joint FBI-INS raid in the Los Angeles area and charged with belonging to the Marxist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.
Deemed a national security risk, the accused were held in solitary confinement in federal prison for nearly three weeks until an immigration judge allowed their release on bail. Although subversion charges have been dropped against six of them, INS spokesman William Odencrantz has said they are still a risk to national security.
Three of the accused appeared at a news conference yesterday to describe how the case has affected their lives. Julie Mungai, 29, of Kenya, said it will be difficult for her to get a job despite her MBA.
How this transcription was made
Read from the scan Maria supplied on 17 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. MASTHEAD FLAG PRESENT AND IT MATCHES. The paper's flag block sits in the middle of this clipping: "LOS ANGELES HERALD" with "EXAMINER" in an oval beneath, "USPS 319-560", "Vol. CXVI No. 360 / Saturday, April 25, 1987", "John J. McCabe/Chief Operating Executive". Both `pub` (Los Angeles Herald Examiner, no leading "The") and `date` (1987-04-25) are confirmed by the page, and 25 April 1987 was a Saturday. This is the only clipping in the batch with a flag. RESOLVES AN EARLIER UNCERTAINTY. The byline here is clean and unfolded: "By Karen Cusolito / Herald staff writer". That confirms the fold-damaged byline I flagged on la043 (26 February) as Cusolito, not Cusalito. The la043 query should be read alongside this one. PRINTED TYPO PRESERVED: the Rosenbaum quotation is set "What happended here is no different than what happened 30 years ago." The word is HAPPENDED, with the extra d, and the correctly spelled "happened" appears four words later in the same sentence. That is the page. Not repaired. AGE CHANGE: this page gives "Julie Mungai, 29, of Kenya". la043 (26 Feb) and la045 (19 Mar) and la046 (25 Mar) all give 28. Two months separate them, so a birthday is the ordinary explanation, but the archive should not silently treat 28 and 29 as a contradiction or as two people. Surname here is MUNGAI, agreeing with la043, la045 and la046 against la040's Mungabh. The forename is MICHEL again here ("Michel Shehadeh, 30"), against la045's MICHAEL. A detail this clipping adds and no other in the batch does: the eight "were held in solitary confinement in federal prison for nearly three weeks". Earlier clippings say only "held without bail" or "held without bond". Another first: INS spokesman WILLIAM ODENCRANTZ is named. la040 referred only to "an INS spokesman". Procedural state of play on this date: subversion charges dropped against six of the eight on Thursday (23 April); two of the eight — Khader Musa Hamide, 32, and Michel Shehadeh, 30, the two legal permanent residents — remain charged under the 1952 McCarran-Walter Act; Judge Hrycenko denied the motions to dismiss (she had been due to rule 14 April per la045); defence attorneys will seek a restraining order Monday from a federal court judge to halt the deportation; a deportation hearing is set for Tuesday (28 April) for the six, with the case against the other two to follow. The dek is a genuine deck, set in italic directly under the headline and above the byline rule: "Subversion charges dropped, but INS still asks deportation on visa violations". Not a kicker, not a pull quote. The page carries no photograph of the defendants. The right-hand column of the clipping is an advertisement ("YOU CAN HAVE THE BODY YOU WANT", First European Institute for Passive Electronic Exercise) which I have excluded entirely, along with the flag block's staff and subscription matter. John J. McCabe is named on the page as the Herald Examiner's Chief Operating Executive, but only inside the masthead flag block, not in the article. I have left him out of `people` for that reason; say so if the archive wants masthead officers captured. Los Angeles particulars: the joint FBI-INS raid "in the Los Angeles area"; federal prison and solitary confinement; immigration court; a federal court judge to be approached Monday. No campus is named in this piece.
Cite this clipping
"Judge won't dismiss case against Palestinians, Kenyan," Los Angeles Herald Examiner, 25 April 1987. Covering Palestine archive, CP-1987-066. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-1987-066
More from Los Angeles Herald Examiner
- Arab Unit Plans Return of LandsLos Angeles Herald Examiner · 31 May 1964
- Arabs for PeaceLos Angeles Herald Examiner · 10 May 1969
- Mideast Peace Held DoubtfulLos Angeles Herald Examiner · 1 September 1970
- Palestinians Vow Fight Will Go OnLos Angeles Herald Examiner · 13 August 1976
- 3 Israeli Settlements On West Bank ApprovedLos Angeles Herald Examiner · 11 January 1978
- Mideast Professor At UCLA Considers Possibility of PeaceLos Angeles Herald Examiner · 30 October 1978
- 9 more from this paper in the full text →
More from the 1980s
- Palestinians Under Israel: Bitter PoliticsThe New York Times · 12 January 1987
- Are jailed Palestinians terrorists or scapegoats?Los Angeles Herald Examiner · 15 February 1987
- Last 3 Arabs are freed in case of terrorist groupLos Angeles Herald Examiner · 19 February 1987
- Accused PLO members freedLos Angeles Times · 19 February 1987
- Jordanians tell of INS ‘nightmare’Los Angeles Herald Examiner · 26 February 1987
- Uneasy in ZionThe New York Times · 1 March 1987
- All 571 clippings from the 1980s →
Last updated 17 November 2026
This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.
The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.
Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-1987-066.
Everything printed in 1987 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset