← Covering Palestine

Miami News · Miami, Florida · 30 June 1987

CP-1987-001

Israel stifles Palestinians’ human rights

CHERYL A. RUBENBERG / Special to The Miami News

Israel stifles Palestinians’ human rights — Miami News, 30 June 1987
Miami News · Miami, Florida · 30 June 1987
Scan 860 × 1919 pixels

Send this clipping to somebody

Transcribed from the clipping

WHAT IS THE meaning of 20 years of Israeli occupation on the lives of the 1.5 million Palestinians who have been the subjects of that occupation in the West Bank and Gaza? Palestinians living in their homeland have the status of “alien resident.”

Although they must pay taxes to Israel, Palestinians cannot vote or be elected at any level; have no degree of judicial control over the government that determines the conditions of their existence; have no meaningful rights of appeal against the judgments of the military courts; and, in the words of former Israeli Foreign Minister Abba Eban, live in a society “in which a man’s rights are defined not by his conduct or by any egalitarian principle, but by his ethnic identity.”

A linear continuation of trends and policies, most begun within months after the June 1967 war, have had an extremely negative effect on every aspect of Palestinian existence. Since 1967, more than 52 percent of the West Bank and 40 percent of the Gaza Strip have been confiscated by Israel for exclusive use by Jews.

By 1986, more than 52,000 Jewish settlers lived in 104 settlements in the West Bank and approximately 2,150 Jews lived in 18 settlements in Gaza. The problems of land alienation and Jewish colonization have contributed to problems in agriculture and employment for Palestinians.

In the words of Meron Benvenisti, an Israeli Jew and former deputy mayor of Jerusalem: “Palestinian agriculture was allowed to develop only insofar as it would not affect Israeli agriculture. Palestinian agriculture could not function properly any longer within the constraints imposed by Israel and its productivity declined.”

The most serious constraint instituted by Israel has been control over water. (Others involve regulations concerning what crops may be grown, how and where they can be marketed, etc.)

How this transcription was made

Read from the scan Maria supplied on 14 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. There is no full masthead on this clipping - it is an inside page. The section flag reads "Columns" with the date line "Tuesday, June 30, 1987" beside it and the page number "13A" at the right. June 30, 1987 was in fact a Tuesday, so the printed day and date are internally consistent and agree with the label 1987-06-30. PUB SPELLING, the thing Maria asked about: this page prints the paper's name TWICE and the two do not match each other. The credit line under the byline reads "Special to The Miami News" - WITH "The". The house box at the foot of the last column reads "Miami News Columnists John Keasler and Mort Lucoff are on vacation." - WITHOUT "The". There is no nameplate on the page to break the tie, because this is page 13A, not page one. So the scan supports Maria's slide label ("The Miami News") in the credit line and the archive's stored spelling ("Miami News") in the house box. I have NOT changed pub. If this is to be settled it needs a page-one nameplate from this paper, not this clipping. The line above the headline, "West Bank and Gaza mark 20 years of occupation", is set in italic ABOVE the headline, so it is a kicker, not a deck. Per the rule I have left dek empty rather than file a kicker as a deck. Stored headline "Israel stifles Palestinians' human rights" matches what is printed; the apostrophe is a typographic right single quote, given here as ’. maria_note ("Use this to replace the one we have as just a headline"): this scan is a full op-ed page, not a headline band. It carries roughly 11,000 characters of body text across five columns, two photographs with a shared caption, an author bio block and a portrait of Rubenberg. CP-1987-001 can carry a substantial excerpt. I transcribed the opening ~1,900 characters, ending at a complete sentence. This is a signed opinion column by an outside contributor, not a news report - worth knowing before it is filed alongside wire copy. The paper prints the U.S. Secretary of State's name as "George Schultz" (with a c). The man's name is Shultz. Transcribed as printed in my reading notes; it does not appear inside the excerpt. The caption calls Ramallah a "West Bank village". Ramallah was a city. Left as printed. There are NO direct quotations from any Palestinian anywhere in this column. The only quoted speakers are two Israelis, Abba Eban and Meron Benvenisti. Eban's quoted words are a relative clause, not a whole sentence, so by the whole-sentence rule I have not recorded them in quotes - they do appear inside the excerpt. Most of the people array is drawn from the body of the column BEYOND the excerpt I transcribed (columns 3-5), not from the excerpt itself. Only Abba Eban, Meron Benvenisti and the author appear inside the excerpt. ORDINARY/OFFICIAL CALL I am least sure of: Taysir Aruri. The column gives him no office at all - "a physicist at Birzeit who was imprisoned under administrative detention for almost four years" - so by the stated test he is an ordinary person named because of what was done to him, and I marked him ordinary true. But the column introduces him as "One well-known early case", which hints at a public profile the text does not spell out. Every other Palestinian named here carries an explicit title (university president, mayor, editor, student council president, student leader, society president) and is marked false. Maria may want to overrule me on Aruri. The photo_caption field is filled even though excerpt is also filled, because the clipping genuinely carries a captioned Associated Press photo pair alongside the article. Photo credit reads "Associated Press".

Context added by this archive

Six months before the uprising. A state is the subject, the verb is stifles, and what is stifled belongs to the Palestinians. Every part of the sentence is assigned, which is rare enough in this archive to be worth saying.

Cite this clipping

"Israel stifles Palestinians’ human rights," Miami News, 30 June 1987, p. 13A. Covering Palestine archive, CP-1987-001. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-1987-001

More from Miami News

More from the 1980s

In these collections

Both arguments, as printed200

Last updated 17 November 2026

This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.

The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.

Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-1987-001.

Everything printed in 1987 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset