← Covering Palestine

Los Angeles Times · 1 November 1984

CP-1984-056

UCLA Renews Rival Groups' Status

Palestinians Granted Affiliation Despite Jewish Protests

By KENNETH J. FANUCCHI, Times Staff Writer

UCLA Renews Rival Groups' Status — Los Angeles Times, 1 November 1984
Los Angeles Times · 1 November 1984
Scan 860 × 989 pixels

Send this clipping to somebody

Transcribed from the clipping

Attempting to defuse a student conflict between Jewish and Palestinian organizations, the UCLA Graduate Students Assn. has awarded campus affiliation to groups representing each side. On a 4-3 vote, the cabinet of the association approved affiliation for the fall quarter for the Committee for the Survival of the Palestinian People and for the Jewish Graduate Students Assn.

The UCLA Graduate Students Assn. also decided to try during this quarter to change university rules that allow affiliated groups to use the university's name in their activities, said Scott Spicer, vice president of the association. “Use of the term UCLA implies support for the particular perspective of an organization, and that is inappropriate,” Spicer said.

“We would like to make it clear that affiliation does not imply support, while at the same time protecting the right of free speech.”

Affiliation allows campus groups free use of university facilities, including rooms and telephones, and permits them to apply for funding to pay advertising costs of activities and stipends, airfare and hotel expenses incurred by speakers.

The issue became controversial last winter when the Palestinian group, then called the Committee in Solidarity with the Palestinian People, applied for affiliation. Several Jewish groups, among them the Jewish Law Students Assn. and the Israel Action Committee, fought the request on grounds that the Palestinian organization was a patently political group.

University regulations forbid affiliation for political groups. Members of the Palestinian group maintained that their organization was an educational forum designed to bring to campus speakers who expounded a position on the Middle East rarely heard on the UCLA campus.

How this transcription was made

Read from the scan Maria supplied on 17 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. The folio at the top left reads “4 Thursday, November 1, 1984/W”. That agrees exactly with the label date 1984-11-01, which was a Thursday. The “/W” marks the Westside edition. THE PAPER'S NAME IS NOT ON THIS PAGE. The folio gives only the page number, the date and the edition letter; there is no nameplate and no running head. The byline's “Times Staff Writer” and the identical byline, subject, section letter and house style link it to la034, whose jump page does carry the Los Angeles Times nameplate — but that is inference from a sibling clipping, not evidence on this page. Recording `pub` as unverified from this scan alone. The date, by contrast, is on the page and is confirmed. A NAME CHANGES SPELLING BETWEEN TWO CLIPPINGS BY THE SAME REPORTER. This page sets “Scott Spicer, vice president of the association”. la034, eleven days earlier, set “Scot Spicer, vice president of external affairs for the graduates”. Same man, same post, two spellings and two job titles, both by Kenneth J. Fanucchi. I have transcribed each as printed and changed neither. If the archive dedupes people by name, these will not merge. The Palestinian group's own name also changes: this story says it was “then called the Committee in Solidarity with the Palestinian People” last winter, and is now the Committee for the Survival of the Palestinian People. And la034's jump page set it once as “the Committee for the Survival of Palestinian People”, without the second “the”. Three forms across two clippings. SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, and the sequel to la034. This is the outcome: on 1 November 1984 the UCLA Graduate Students Assn. cabinet voted 4-3 to affiliate the Committee for the Survival of the Palestinian People for the fall quarter, and the UCLA administration rejected the Jewish groups' request that it be denied affiliation. The affiliation was granted for a quarter only, not the full academic year. The group's next event was a programme featuring Joel Benin, a history instructor at Stanford University, in mid-November, funded with “$400 and change” from the university's campus programs committee. A named Palestine solidarity organisation with university standing and university money in Los Angeles, two years and three months before the LA 8 arrests. The crossheads “Affiliation Privileges”, “Political or Educational?” and “Palestinians ‘Very Happy’” sit inside the body. Crossheads, not deks; left out of the excerpt. The single bold line under the main headline, “Palestinians Granted Affiliation Despite Jewish Protests”, is the deck and is recorded as such. Sherry Vatter is described only as “a graduate student majoring in Middle East history and a member of the Committee for the Survival of the Palestinian People”. The page does not say she is Palestinian, so I have given her side “w”, the same call I made for Susan Mordechay and Edward Keenan in la034, and for the same reason. Again, no Palestinian is identified as such anywhere in the story. Her quotations fall past the end of the excerpt. Recorded here: her group is “very happy” with the renewed affiliation, and “Of course,” she said, “we would have liked to be affiliated for the entire year. But we do not expect to be disaffiliated. We plan to continue with our educational program.” Also past the end: Spicer, on the closeness of the vote and the quarter-long term, “There is a general sense among the graduates that this issue is a waste of our time.” and “Trying to figure out the definition of what is or is not political has proved to be impossible. In some ways, the campus effort to define what is political is so narrow as to be an illegal restraint on free speech.”. The last line of the story is worth noting for the record: “Spokesmen for the Jewish Graduate Students Assn. were unavailable for comment.”. The paper sets the instructor's name “Joel Benin”. Transcribed as printed.

Cite this clipping

"UCLA Renews Rival Groups' Status," Los Angeles Times, 1 November 1984, p. 4. Covering Palestine archive, CP-1984-056. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-1984-056

More from Los Angeles Times

More from the 1980s

Last updated 17 November 2026

This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.

The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.

Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-1984-056.

Everything printed in 1984 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset