← Covering Palestine

The 1970s, in full text

Every clipping in this archive printed between 1970 and 1979: 353 of them, oldest first, as plain text that can be read, searched and quoted without running any code. Each entry links to its own record, where the scan is.

· The News · Paterson

Arab Refugees

Harry Golden, “Only In America”

“I think it incumbent upon the objective reporter to present points of view before drawing moral conclusions, which I am not going to draw today… They remain a static problem for a variety of reasons, one of which I have discussed, Israeli intransigence… For 20 years newsmen from the world have traversed these dirt streets taking pictures and interviewing the inhabitants and they haven’t offered any compelling ideas on the subject either.”

The longer of two printings of the same syndicated column. Golden walks a camp on the Bethlehem hills with an Israeli escort, quotes an Israeli captain and an Israeli major, and announces that drawing moral conclusions is not the objective reporter’s job. Not one refugee speaks. He then names the failure of his own trade, four paragraphs from the end.

CP-1970-004 →

· The New York Times

Israel to Settle 1,000 Jews In Arab Town of Hebron

JERUSALEM, March 25—The Israeli Government announced today that it would assist in the settlement of 250 Jewish families in Hebron, an Arab town in the occupied part of Jordan. Deputy Premier Yigal Allon, speaking in Parliament, said the Government would seek private investment as well as treasury funds to assist in housing and employment. Mr.

Allon, apparently anticipating the furor the decision would create in the Arab world and in some Western capitals, said it had no political significance for the future of the occupied West bank of the Jordan River. This view was challenged last night in a Labor party caucus when the decision was taken. Opposition also was heard today when Mr.

Allon announced the plan in Parliament. Opponents said Israel was losing all her options for peace by settling the occupied areas little by little. Others charged that the Government was being influenced by extremists. Mr. Allon said that the plan had nothing to do with a proposed Jewish suburb that had been the subject of an earlier debate.

Many observers believe that the establishment of an estimated 1,000 Jewish settlers in a major Arab urban area will be taken as indication of Israeli intentions to remain in the area. Mr. Allon may believe this to be the case, too.

He was reported on the state radio tonight as having said in the course of his announcement that time was having its effects in the area under Israeli administration. The proposed settlement will be the largest of the 31 civilian and paramilitary outposts established in the occupied areas or planned for this year.

All but a cluster of three in the Etzion area, between Hebron and Jerusalem, are border settlements. There will be 14 such settlements in the Syrian heights, seven in the Jordan valley, five in the northern Sinai and Gaza Strip, three in the Etzion bloc and one—Modiin in Israel—will be moved across the old Jordanian border.

It is understood that the new Hebron settlement will be on a hill over the city and next to a British-built police fort, now the headquarters of the military government and the residence of about 100 Jewish settlers who sought to live in Hebron shortly after the 1967 war. They moved into a hotel and then announced their intention to stay.

The Cabinet eventually decided to permit them to remain, but within the army compound. The hilltop location recalls the establishment of Upper Nazareth after the 1948 war. Jewish settlement was planned for the hills around the Arab town of Nazareth as a security measure, some thought then. Upper Nazareth has grown to contain thousands of Jewish families. Mr.

Allon spoke of the new Jewish community in Hebron, the home of 38,000 Arabs, as a continuation of Jewish settlement over thousands of years. He spoke also of other families settling in the area in the future. Hebron was said to have had a Jewish community since the return from the Babylonian exile in the sixth century B.C.

After the 16th century, it became one of the four holy cities of Palestine.

CP-1970-020 →

· El Paso Times

Palestine Week Scheduled

Four University of Texas at El Paso organizations will sponsor Palestine Week, Tuesday and Wednesday on campus. Aziz Sagr, chairman of the week, said Palestine Week dramatizes “the physical existence of the Palestinian people as a political entity engaged in a national liberation struggle.” University faculty members and students will give talks on the subject.

Sponsors of the week are the Organization of Arab Students, the Young Socialist Alliance, the Alianza and the National Association of Black Students. The program includes a faculty discussion from noon to 2 p.m. Tuesday in the Union Theater, and a student discussion in the theater at 2 p.m. Wednesday.

Faculty discussion speakers will be John White, English Department, who will discuss “Big Power Politics in the Middle East; Edward George, Business Department, who will cover “Economic Realty of the Middle East Crises,” and Khalid Babaa, director of the Arab Information Center, Dallas “Palestine Problem Revisited.”

Moderator will be Leonard Bailes Jr., a student.

Student discussion speakers and their subjects will be Eric Kangas, “The Origin of the Middle East Crises”; Alexander Sutton, “Black Opinion of the Palestine Movement”; Samir Haddad, “The Origin, Means and Objectives of the Palestine Liberation Movement”; Richard Garcia, “Comparison of Two Liberation Movements: Chicano and Palestinians,” and Chuck Sutton, “Liberation of All Oppressed People.”

Moderator will be Kathy Stallworth, also a student. Literature on Palestine Week will be available in the Student Union, from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Tuesday and from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. Wednesday.

CP-1970-029 →

· The New York Times

ISRAELIS REPORT KILLING 21 ARABS

Toll in Guerrilla Battle at Jordan River Is Termed Largest Since ’67 War

By RICHARD EDER

JERUSALEM, May 4—Israeli military authorities announced today that an Israeli patrol surprised and killed 21 armed Palestinian infiltrators shortly after they crossed the Jordan River into Israeli-controlled territory last night.

At the same time the Israelis reported some tentative signs that intensive air strikes on Egyptian artillery positions west of the Suez Canal were beginning to ease the recent pressure on Israeli troops on the east bank.

Last night’s encounter with the guerrillas involved the largest death toll reported by Israeli forces since the start of the struggle with Arabs infiltrating into territories occupied by Israel after the 1967 war.

According to the account provided by Israeli military authorities, the infiltrators, members of Al Fatah guerrilla organization, were pinned down by fire from the Israeli patrol just before midnight, not far from the banks of the Jordan River. The infiltrators tried to take shelter in scrub and thornbushes, the account continued.

Apart from firing one bazooka shot, it went on, they made no move to answer the Israeli fire, which went on heavily but intermittently all night and which, by sunup, had killed all but six of them.

CP-1970-021 →

· Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle · Milwaukee · page 1

Black Panthers Hit Jews, Zionism and Racism as Same

Party Decline Charged in Diatribe; Assails “Zionist” Judges in US

Jewish Telegraphic Agency, San Francisco

SAN FRANCISCO — (JTA) — The Black Panthers have discarded their barely concealed anti-Semitism, insisting in the past they were not against Jews but only against Zionism, and have now declared that Jewishness, Zionism and racism are identical. Connie Matthews, international co-ordinator of the Black Panther Party, now blames dwindling support for the organization since it “took its stand on the (support of) the Palestinian people’s struggle” on the “fact” that the “white left in the USA is comprised of a large percentage of the Jewish population.”

Miss Matthews observes that since the BPP’s stand the white left “started floundering and became undecided. This leaves us with no alternative than to believe that a large portion of these people are Zionists and are therefore racists.” This venomous diatribe by Miss Matthews appears in the latest issue of the BPP official organ, The Black Panther.

As evidence of the basic Jewish-Zionist-racist character of the white left, she notes that a “Zionist judge, Judge (Julius J.)

Hoffman” allowed “Zionist” defendants in the “Chicago conspiracy” trial to go free while jailing Bobby Seale to four years for contempt of court… The BPP official reiterates the organization’s support of the Palestinian people’s struggle “against Israeli imperialism and Zionism aided and abetted by U.S. imperialism,” and declares: “The one-eyed bandit from Tel Aviv (General) Moshe Dayan must be hunted down and killed.”

Miss Matthews does not elaborate further on this… What Miss Matthews did not state was that only two of the remaining seven defendants — Abbie Hoffman and Jerry Rubin — were Jewish.

A news agency for the Jewish press, reporting one official’s article in one issue of one party paper, and checking her arithmetic in the last paragraph. The piece carries plain antisemitism: the claim that judges ruled as Zionists, and a call to kill a named man. It is here because the standard account of the 1975 resolution says the Soviet Union invented the formula, and this is an American paper watching the same words move through American politics five years earlier.

CP-1970-003 →

· Seattle Post-Intelligencer

Palestine Week Set By Arab Students

For Arab students at the University of Washington, this will be “Palestine Week” commemorating the dissolution of Arab Palestine with the creation of the nation of Israel in 1948 and the displacement of a million Palestinians. The week will be observed with seminars, films and speeches in the Student Union Building (HUB) under sponsorship of the Arab Students.

All sessions are open to the public. Randa Khalidi el-Fattal of New York, editor of the magazine “Arab World” and an Oxford graduate, wife of Dia Allah el-Fattal, counselor to the Syrian mission to the United Nations, will speak Friday, and at the Palestine Dinner Saturday.

George Abed of Berkeley, Calif., Arab Middle East news analyst on the NET “World Press” weekly program, will speak on “Objectives of the Guerrilla Movement” at 2:30 p.m. Monday. Hisham Quaddumi of Austin, Tex., a leader of Arab students in this country, will speak on “The Guerrilla Movement” at 1:30 p.m. Wednesday.

CP-1970-030 →

· Journal and Courier

Palestine Week In Full Swing On Campus

Palestine Week is in full swing on the Purdue University campus. The week’s events, to end Sunday, included a coffee hour at 3:30 p.m. Friday in Room 130, Union Building. Two movies will be shown followed by an informal question - and - answer session.

Saturday and Sunday two films, one a winner of 11 international film awards, will be shown in Fowler Hall, Memorial Center. At 7 and 9:30 p.m. Saturday the movies, “Battle of Algiers,” award winner, and “The Palestine Guerrilla” will be shown in that order. The films will begin at 7:30 p.m. Sunday.

The week is sponsored by Purdue’s Organization of Arab Students, an independent student organization which does not represent in any way official Arab or American institutions, according to the organization’s president, Usamah R. Abdus-Samad.

CP-1970-031 →

· Seattle Post-Intelligencer

Plan Arabian Night of Feasting

BY JOAN FRISCH

Foreign cuisine is for sampling — to educate the taste and to delight the palate. From pine nuts to pomegranate seeds, semolina to sumac, Arabic cuisine is full of exotic ingredients and aromas. But one doesn’t have to hail from the Middle East to enjoy them!

To surprise guests with new tastes and colorful combinations, prepare Tabooli, a Lebanese salad mixture of crushed wheat, tomato, green onion, parsley and mint. Lemon juice and olive oil are the simple dressing ingredients. For those who like the smell and flavor of fresh baked bread, try little flat loaves of Khubiz (Arabic Bread) which puff up when baked.

(Or buy the finished product at the Pike Place Market and reheat.) For a simple yet delicious dessert, serve Kamar el Din (Apricot Nectar Pudding) with dainty Namoura (Semolina Cakes), which are sprinkled with nuts and bathed in a lemon rind-sugar syrup.

Join Arabs throughout the world who are commemorating Palestine Week, May 10 through 16, and serve this enticing food to family and guests. The Arabic Cook Book, filled with additional exotic recipes, is available at most large book stores in the Seattle area. Some of the recipes are given here.

Or, for those who prefer to let experts prepare the exotic fare, plan to attend an Arab feast on Saturday, 6:30 p.m. at the University Congregational Church. Reservations may be made with Colleen Shanahan at 3500 West Howe. Proceeds from the event go to the Red Crescent (the Red Cross in the Middle East.)

EVELYN ZAKHARY OF CAIRO, EGYPT, OFFERED ARABIC COFFEE TO PALESTINIAN MOUSA R. MURAD / Arabic cuisine on tray included Stuffed Zucchini, Leg of Lamb, Garbanzo Bean Dip and Tabooli Salad — P-I Photo by Bob Miller.

CP-1970-032 →

· The Decatur Review

Palestinians Want State, Refugee Funds

No Unified Voice

Harold Piety

AS LATE AS June 15, 1969, Prime Minister Golda Meir of Israel disputed the existence of a Palestinian people. In an interview with a correspondent of the Sunday Times of London, Mrs. Golda Meir asked: “When was there an independent Palestinian people with a Palestinian state?

It was either southern Syria before the first world war, and then it was a Palestine including Jordan. It was not as though there was a Palestinian people in Palestine considering itself as a Palestinian people and we came and threw them out and took their country away from them. They did not exist.”

That attitude is a luxury the Israeli government does not permit itself today. The fedayeen have changed that. Denounced as terrorists by the Israelis, honored as patriots by the Palestinians and Arab nations, the fedayeen have forced a recognition of the Palestinians as a group distinct from other Arab belligerents.

“The first thing we have to do is to recognize that the Palestinian Arabs exist as an infant nation,” said Arye Eliav recently. Eliav, secretary general of the Labor Party, the leading force in Israeli politics, is not an isolated voice in Israel.

Kamal Naser, a Palestine guerrilla leader, says the movement seeks to replace Zionist Israel with an Arab-Jew country.

Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.

CP-1970-007 →

· The New York Times · New York

Jewish Museum Bars Pamphlets By Artist Group

By GRACE GLUECK

The Jewish Museum has removed Black Panther literature from a table of political pamphlets set up in its lobby by members of the New York Artists Strike Against Racism, Sexism, Repression and War.

While the artists charged the museum with “censorship,” David Finn, chairman of the museum’s board of governors, said: “One of our basic rules is that nothing will be shown in the museum that is offensive to anybody of any religious persuasion.”

He added that some of the museum’s members and visitors had objected to the display of Panther literature “because in the past it has contained anti-Semitic and anti-Zionist statements.”

At its board meeting on May 27, the trustees passed a resolution agreeing—“with no commitment to their aims and policies”—to the artists’ request for the establishment of a ground-floor information center. The resolution also specified that the material selected must have “the discretionary approval” of the museum’s director and an ad hoc committee to be selected by the board.

Receive Complaints After a table with the literature was set up on June 4, a museum spokesman said, staff members at both the museum and the Jewish Theological Seminary of America, its parent body, began to receive complaints about the display. One of the apparently offensive quotes in a pro-Panther pamphlet referred to “U.S. warmongers in Vietnam, Cambodia and Palestine.”

Palestine as a reference to Israel is no longer accepted by Zionists. Mr. Finn and other members of the museum board, along with seminary officials, met with three members of the artists’ Ground Floor Committee and, reminding them of the resolution, asked them to remove the offending literature.

But the artists replied that they could not accept a “censored” table, and said that they personally had no knowledge of the resolution, although other members of their group had known about it. If the museum wanted to put up its own table, they said, they would remove theirs until the matter had been resolved by a full committee.

The museum then removed the table in the artists’ presence. But yesterday, the artists came back with their own table, and set it up again. Their literature included a number of pro-Israel pamphlets in addition to the Black Panther material, but Mrs. Ann Doherty, administrator of the museum, removed the samples of both.

After the literature had been removed, Merle Leech, the solitary artist on political duty, said that he and the table would remain.

CP-1970-019 →

· Baltimore Afro American

An Appeal by BLACK AMERICANS For United States SUPPORT to ISRAEL

The crisis in the Middle East is a cause of great concern to all Americans—non-Jew as well as Jew, black as well as white. Our concern as black Americans is motivated not only by the threat to world peace which is posed by the Arab-Israeli conflict.

We are also moved by the ideals of democracy and social justice, ideals which we have struggled to achieve in this country and which we firmly believe the United States must uphold in the Middle East. In our opinion, the United States can best stand by these ideals by unequivocally guaranteeing Israel’s security.

While we are aware that Israel, like any other nation, has its shortcomings, it is by far the most democratic country in the Middle East. What is remarkable is that the high degree of political freedom in Israel has not diminished despite the constant need to maintain military preparedness.

In contrast, countries like Iraq, Syria, and Egypt are dictatorial one-party states where the press and the courts are rigorously controlled and non-Moslem minorities are severely persecuted. Moreover, Israel has made tremendous strides toward achieving an equalitarian economic order.

Its sophisticated system of educational, health, and welfare services is more advanced even than in our own country and has enhanced the quality of life for Arab as well as Jewish Israelis. The incidence of poverty in the Arab countries, on the other hand, remains appalling.

The income from oil has been used to sustain wealthy sheikdoms—and often terrorist organizations as well—but rarely to alleviate the suffering of the poor.

CP-1970-011 →

· Florida Times Union · Jacksonville · page 1

‘Palestine Solution’

Samir Salameh, Jacksonville

“The Palestinian revolution has officially adopted the creation of a democratic, none-sectarian Palestine, where Christian, Jews and Moslems can live, work and worship without discrimination, as the ultimate objective of it’s liberation struggle.

Establishment of a progressive open society for all the Palestinians is the only humanitarian and permanent solution to the problem. It certainly is superior to ‘throwing the Arabs to the desert’ or ‘throwing the Jews in the sea.’… The Palestinians have out grown their bitterness and prejudice in a relatively short time through armed struggle.

A few years ago, discussing this proposal would have been considered as a complete ‘sell out’ or high treason… Annihilation of the Jews or the Palestinian exiles and the creation of an exclusive racist state in Palestine, be it Jewish, Christian or Moslem, is totally unacceptable, unworkable, and cannot last. The oppressed Palestine masses will fight and make all needed sacrifices to demolish the oppressor.

The Israelis are greatly irritated by the idea of a democratic Palestine; it reveals the contradictions of Zionism. The adoption, by several significant progressive Jews of the new goal, scares world Zionism. The Zionists are stepping up their campaign to discredit the idea, especially among the Jews.

Their effort has been in vain; the force of logic and the effect of years of presecution are opening the eyes of Jews and others in the world to the only permanent solution that will bring lasting peace and justice to Palestine.”

A reader’s letter, printed in full. Its spelling is the letter’s own throughout. This Samir Salameh is not the painter of the same name, and not the Samir Salameh who appears in the archive in 1996 as a bombing suspect’s brother; four different men of that name run through this material and none of them are linked here. Earliest record in the archive from 1970. The writer’s own background is not stated anywhere in the letter, which refers to Palestinians in the third person throughout, so this archive does not present him as a Palestinian voice.

CP-1970-001 →

· The New York Times

Israelis Report Killing 13 Guerrillas

TEL AVIV, Aug. 28 — An Israeli spokesman said today that 13 Arab guerrillas were killed during the night as they attempted to penetrate Israel from Lebanon and Jordan.

The biggest engagement was said by the spokesman to have occurred in the Jebel Ros area in Lebanon, near the border area where the Israelis recently set up positions on the slopes of Mount Hermon that they control.

The positions give the Israelis command over much of the rocky, hilly region between Mount Hermon and the Hasbani River, which the Lebanese Government has virtually abandoned to the guerrillas. Early this morning, the spokesman said, the Israelis detected a guerrilla force moving in the darkness from Shaba, Lebanon, toward Israeli-held territory.

In the engagement, seven Arabs were said to have been killed and one Israeli wounded. Three other guerrillas were reported killed in the Jordan Valley, east of Kfar Ruppin, a collective settlement that in recent weeks has been a frequent target of the guerrillas. One Israeli soldier was killed in that engagement, the spokesman said.

The three other Palestinians were reported to have died in a clash farther south in the Jordan Valley, in the Nahal Argaman sector. Israeli officials have noted a marked decline in cooperation between the Jordanian Army and the guerrillas.

Previously, it was said, the Jordanians frequently helped the Palestinians with intelligence data, provided covering fire and shelter in military positions. In recent weeks, the cooperation was said to have become infrequent and to have been confined to the lowest echelons.

The change was attributed to the apparent friction between the Palestinians and the Jordanian Government over King Hussein’s acceptance of the United States initiative for a peaceful settlement of the Arab-Israeli conflict. The main guerrilla action in recent weeks has been on the Lebanese, rather than Jordanian, front.

Clashes flared near Jebel Ros (1) in Lebanon and in the Kfar Ruppin (2) and Nahal Argaman (3) areas.

CP-1970-022 →

· The Berkeley Gazette

‘No Hope’ for Mid-East

LOS ANGELES (UPI)—The keynote speaker at the 19th annual convention of the Organization of Arab Students in the U.S.A. and Canada says there is no hope that a settlement will be reached at the Middle East peace talks.

“Whoever fancies that the current discussions...will lead to a settlement of the Middle East crisis is, in effect, engaging in a pathetic exercise in self-delusion,” Dr. Fayez A. Sayegh said. Sayegh, a displaced Palestinian and senior consultant of the Foreign Ministry of Kuwait, spoke to the convention at California State College at Long Beach.

CP-1970-033 →

· Los Angeles Herald Examiner

Mideast Peace Held Doubtful

Dr. Fayez A. Sayegh, a displaced Palestinian and senior consultant to the Kuwait Foreign Ministry, doubts that a settlement will be reached at the Middle East peace talks.

He told the 19th annual convention of the Organization of Arab Students at California State College in Long Beach Sunday that “whoever fancies that the current discussions will lead to a settlement is, in effect, engaging in a pathetic exercise in self-delusion.”

Sayegh added that “Israel comes to these discussions not in order to ensure the implementation of the Security Council resolution of 22 November 1967 but in order to ensure Arab consent for its retention of most of the territory it occupied in June, 1967. “Let not the world delude itself.

It did so 20 years ago when it participated in the creation of Israel in Palestine against the objections of the indigenous Palestinian people and the result in terms of turbulence and bloodshed has been tragic throughout these years.”

CP-1970-034 →

· Shoshone News Press

Arab Guerrillas Hijack BOAC Airliner

Arab guerrillas today hijacked a British BOAC VC10 airliner with 130 persons aboard and said they ordered it to fly to Dawson’s field outside Amman to reinforce their demand that seven Arab commandos be released in western Europe.

They also reiterated their threat to destroy a TWA and a Swissair jet already at the desert field, with 184 hostages aboard, if their ransom demands are not met by 10 p.m. EDT today. The Red Cross was trying to arrange a three-day delay in the deadline.

The United States and Britain called for a meeting of the United Nations security council for later today to take up the hijacking of international airliners by Arab guerrillas. The British government was reported “actively considering” placing armed guards aboard British planes.

Airport sources in Beirut said Abu Khaled, a leading official of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, told them an El Al Israeli airliner also was hijacked to Dawson’s Field today, but El Al in Tel Aviv officially denied this report.

CP-1970-014 →

· The Holland Evening Sentinel · Holland

Ultimatum of Hijackers Is Extended Three Days

Palestinian guerrillas holding more than 250 hostages aboard three hijacked airliners in the Jordanian desert today extended their ultimatum deadline for 72 hours but threatened once again to blow up the passengers and planes unless their ransom demands are met.

The International Red Cross was still trying to negotiate their release in exchange for seven Arab commandos held in West Europe but informed sources in New York in touch with the negotiations indicated there was a hitch—that the guerrillas wanted to release only the non-Israelis aboard the planes.

The United States and Britain were reported demanding the release of all passengers and crew regardless of nationality or religion. The guerrillas in announcing the deadline postponement criticized the Anglo-American “attitude.” Israeli Premier Golda Meir said today in Tel Aviv Israel opposed releasing imprisoned Arab guerrillas in exchange for the passengers.

She did not say flatly Israel would refuse to release guerrillas if such an exchange was part of an international package deal. In a speech to the Organization of Working Mothers from the Trade Union Federation she said the world was being held up to bribery and blackmail because the lessons learned from earlier attacks on Israeli jetliners and El Al offices had been ignored.

“Now the whole world is confronted with a horror the like of which it has never known before,” Mrs. Meir said. “The only thing it can do is pay a bribe. And what sort of a bribe? To free criminals and murderers. We know who the people are who are sitting in our jails. They are terrorists who attacked and murdered innocent people.”

The airlines involved, TWA, Swissair and BOAC, issued a breakdown of passnengers which said 258 or 259 passengers and crewmen remained aboard the planes and 154 women and children were taken to the Inter-Continental Hotel in Amman—where a near civil war raged.

ATTEND PASSENGERS — Stewards attend passengers aboard a Swissair jetliner held captive by Arab guerrillas at Dawson’s field near Amman, Jordan. The hostages increased their bag of hostages Wednesday to three jetliners and 299 passengers and crewmembers in their attempt to bargain the release of seven Arab commandos from western European jails. (UPI cablephoto)

Correction: The deck caption gave a shorter name than the masthead prints. Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 163 clippings in this deck.

CP-1970-012 →

· The Sunday Courier and Press · Evansville

Will They Upset Peace Talks?

Earl Foell

UNITED NATIONS — Can Palestinian guerrillas upset the Arab-Israeli peace talks that started here last week? Prevailing diplomatic opinion here is: No. Guerrilla attacks might provide an excuse for a later Israeli decision to break off the talks. But in themsleves the attacks are not decisive.

If Israel has felt itself isolated against much of the world in recent months, so have the Palestinians.

Aligned against their pledge to disrupt the peace talks are: — Egypt’s President Nasser, who backs the Palestinians publicly but isn’t interested in creating any Arab revolutionaries aside from pro-Nasser ones. — The Soviet Union, which has placed all its bets on Nasser, isn’t happy with uncontrollable revolutionaries and, in any case, is worried about the Palestinians’ increasing ties to Peking. — The United States, where the Nixon Administration is placing high hopes on authoring a Mideast peace and claiming the laurels that have eluded it in Indochina. — A sizable array of U.N. members, some of them sympathetic to the Palestinian cause, who nevertheless want to see the Egypt-Israeli-Jordan quarrel settled at this time to end a perennial annoyance and the possibility of a big two clash.

Correction: The deck caption gave a shorter name than the masthead prints. Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 163 clippings in this deck.

CP-1970-015 →

· The New York Times

Hijacking Mastermind Is No. 2 in the Popular Front

By John M. Lee

BEIRUT, Lebanon, Sept. 13 — In July, 1968, just after the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine hijacked an El Al airliner for the first time, the guerrillas called a news conference in Beirut to boast of their exploit.

At the gathering in the modern offices of the procommando newspaper Al Anwar, the front’s press officer, Ghassan Kanafani, answered newsmen’s questions. But he turned repeatedly for whispered advice on hijacking details to a slight, frail looking man seated next to him. This was the first public appearance of Dr. Wadi Haddad, the No.

2 man in the front, who over the next two years acquired notoriety as the mastermind of aerial hijacking. It is Dr. Haddad, a 43-year-old physician, who has directed seven hijackings, including the four last Sunday, one of which failed, and another on Wednesday.

Seldom Seen in Public But when newsmen pressed forward at that 1968 news conference to learn more about that mysterious man, Dr. Haddad slipped away. He has seldom been seen in public since, and only sketchy details are known of his life and methods.

Last week — at a most crucial moment for the Popular Front, during negotiations for the hostages, an off-and-on civil war with the Jordanian Army and a bitter split in the commando movement — the front’s leader, Dr. George Habash, was almost unaccountably out of the Middle East. Dr. Haddad was in charge. Dr.

Habash was reported to be in North Korea on a trip that included Peking and Hanoi. Some persons speculated he was trying to channel financial and military assistance directly to his maverick Maoist group rather than through the Palestine Liberation Organization. The Palestine Liberation Organization is a loose coordinating body for ten or so commando groups.

But it is headed by Dr. Habash’s more moderate rival, Yasir Arafat, leader of the biggest and best-financed guerrilla group, Al Fatah.

A spokesman for the Popular Front said that the hijackings had been planned since early August, almost from the moment that President Gamal Abdel Nasser of the United Arab Republic accepted the Mideast cease-fire, which the guerrillas are attempting to wreck. Dr. Habash and Dr. Haddad are closely associated, and once Dr. Habash had approved the hijacking effort, Dr.

Haddad was free to plan the details, Palestinians here say. Dr. Haddad is said to use an intelligence staff of about 10 persons to keep track of airline routes, schedules, passengers and airport security measures so as to choose successful targets. There is apparently a hijacking squad trained in aerial navigation and aircraft mechanics.

The authorities at the Beirut International Airport, where two of the hijacked airliners landed for refueling last week, were impressed by the technical knowledge of the hijackers. Student Colleague of Habash Dr. Haddad is about 5 feet 6 inches tall and has thinning hair and a thin mustache. He studied medicine at the American University in Beirut and was a colleague of Dr.

Habash, who received a similar education. Both men are Greek Orthodox in religious background. They both worked in a medical clinic in Amman, Jordan, in the early nineteen fifties. Dr. Haddad joined his friend when Dr. Habash established the Arab Nationalist Movement, which had branches in Syria, Lebanon, Southern Yemen and Jordan.

The Government leaders of South Yemen today are considered Dr. Habash’s disciples, and the leader of the opposition in Kuwait, Dr. Ahmed Khatib, is part of the same group. He was a student with Dr. Habash and Dr. Haddad at the Beirut University.

The Arab Nationalist Movement was the forerunner of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which was formed in 1967 and has become the most spectacularly radical of the commando groups. Its strength is estimated at 3,500. Its headquarters are said to be the Wahdat camp for Palestinian refugees in Amman.

Haddad’s Apartment Attacked The front has carried the fight of the Palestinian Arabs against Israel outside the Middle East, with hijackings and attacks on airplanes at Western European airports. It is also believed responsible for the blowing up of an oil pipeline in Syria and the bombing of the United States Embassy and the Bank of America branch in Beirut.

In July, rockets struck an apartment building in the heart of Beirut. The occupants of the apartment under attack were Dr. Haddad, his wife and his two children, a boy and a girl. No one was seriously hurt. Front members blame Israeli intelligence agents for the attack. But the guerrillas said the intended target was not Dr.

Haddad, but his guest that evening — Leila Khaled, who was one of the hijackers of a Trans World Airlines jet in August, 1969, and who is now being held in London after an abortive attempt at a hijacking last Sunday.

CP-1970-024 →

· The New York Times

Guerrillas Raise Their Price

By Eric Pace

AMMAN, Jordan, Sept. 15 — Arab guerrillas, at a news conference today, denounced the Red Cross, rejected international law and raised their asking price for the release of the airline passengers and crew members they are holding.

Two spokesmen for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine set out its increased demands in what seemed to be an attempt to generate pressure on the five Governments concerned, to make separate deals to free their nationals.

“We can’t wait forever,” one spokesman for the Marxist guerrilla group told the reporters packed into the front’s information center here. But no deadline was set for arrangements to free the 54 hostages, some of whom have been held since the front hijacked three airliners a week ago Sunday. A fourth was seized last Wednesday.

Reports from Israel put the number of hostages at 55. Today the front added two demands: the release of “10 Lebanese soldiers taken as prisoners” by Israel earlier this year and the release of the “Swiss comrade taken as a prisoner in Haifa” this summer on suspicion of pro-commando activities.

Elaborating on past declarations, the spokesmen read a statement that called on Israel to “announce in principle her acceptance” of the new demands and others made earlier. The guerrillas have called on the Israelis to release some of their comrades seized in the past as well as Arabs detained Sunday.

They also want to conclude separate deals with Britain, West Germany and Switzerland under which nationals of those countries held hostage would be exchanged for imprisoned guerrillas, seven in all.

After the new demands are met, the statement said, the Popular Front will submit a list of other prisoners held by the Israelis whose release it wants in exchange for freeing hostages who are “Israelis and bearers of American-Israeli dual citizenship.”

The American hostages would also presumably be freed at that point since the Popular Front has said that it will treat and release them “on the same basis as Israelis.”

One of the spokesmen read an English translation of the statement, which also accused the International Committee of the Red Cross of having “tried to gain time for the benefit of the imperialist countries” in its negotiations here last week. Red Cross Declines to Reply Red Cross officials declined to comment on the allegations.

The statement also said that “we consider that the international law put by the imperialists does not commit us because it was the same law under which our people was forced out of the homeland.” Asserting the Popular Front’s independence of outside influences, the statement said: “Our law is the victory of the revolution.”

It warned against “stupid intervention to free the hostages” and said they were being looked after by a medical team. It also indicated that they would be denied foreign visitors or outside medical help.

The hostages are said to include eight Britons from a British Overseas Airways Corporation VC-10 hijacked en route from Bahrain to Beruit and eight persons — Swiss, Germans and an American — from a Swissair DC-8 seized between Zurich and New York.

There are also 38 passengers and crewmen from a Trans World Airlines Boeing 707 that was hijacked while en route between Frankfurt and New York after a stop in Israel. Western informants said there was a diabetic among the 38 who needed regular medical attention.

They said that one passenger, Rabbi Hunter, 70 years old, of 670 Rockaway Parkway, Brooklyn, was understood to have been particularly uncomfortable. The Americans include non-Jews, among them four T.W.A. crew members and an airline pilot who was a passenger. Another non-Jew who happened to be on board is John Hollingsworth, an American diplomat stationed in Algiers.

As far as is known he has no Israeli visa. Captain Termed Uncooperative The guerrillas seem to be holding such men merely because they are able-bodied Americans. The hostages also include five women, four of them girls apparently considered to be of military age since Israel uses women soldiers.

The informants said the Americans had been dispersed to three locations, one of which was a quarter of an hour or so from the Hotel Intercontinental in Amman. The captain of the jet was understood to be pressing for better treatment of his passengers and crew. He is said to have been characterized by the guerrillas as “not cooperative.”

Their statement said that the front would treat the hostages “in the same way their Governments treat our prisoners.”

The second speaker, an editor named Ghassan Kanafani, said the hostages would be given the same food and accomodations as the guerrillas themselves, saying, “Our commandos are treated humanely, but we can’t afford the standard of the European kind of living.”

Some Westerners who have been involved in negotiations on freeing the hostages said the news conference had cleared the air by presenting the demands in a systematic way. Despite the demands, the British, West German and Swiss Governments adhere to the American position that a settlement must provide for the release of all the hostages.

According to those involved in the contacts, the prospects for an over-all arrangement depend heavily on the guerrillas’ list of prisoners held by Israel whom they want freed. “The Israelis must value some of their prisoners a lot higher than others,” an informant observed.

The guerrillas’ spokesmen indicated that their organization would consult with other groups before presenting its eventual list, which other guerrilla sources have said would contain “much fewer than a thousand names.” The list would be in addition to those whose release has already been demanded. They include Leila Khaled, a hijacker held in Britain.

The front says it will release the eight hostage Britons if she is freed with the body of a man who was killed during the unsuccessful hijacking of an El Al jetliner. The front has also demanded the release of three held in Switzerland and three held in West Germany.

The freeing of two Algerian officials seized by Israel this summer when their plane stopped at an Israeli airport has also been demanded. No explanation was made for the new demands, but the news conference seemed to usher in a new phase in the effort to exploit the hostages.

Despite the criticism of the Red Cross, the spokesmen indicated that they would not rule it out as a mediator. They indicated they felt it had shown bad faith in getting them to lift deadlines they had originally set.

The statement said the front had blown up a Pan American World Airways jumbojet in Cairo and the three airliners in Jordan “because of the maneuvers exercised by Switzerland, West Germany, England and the United States.” It added, “The destruction was to prove to all these powers that any more challenges will only incur losses on their part.”

The front also said it was “completely responsible for the hostages” and would “forbid any unnecessary contacts with the hostages the same way our prisoners are treated.”

After the news conference reporters were taken to a Popular Front hospital to see Ahmed Hudhud, a young blind man who said through an interpreter that he had been tortured by the Israelis. He said that all his teeth had been pulled and that he had lost his sight because of inadequate and incorrect treatment for an eye ailment.

CP-1970-025 →

· The New York Times

Terms Unchanged, Arab Says

By John M. Lee

BEIRUT, Lebanon, Sept. 17 — A spokesman for the Palestinian hijackers said today that the heavy shelling in Amman made no difference in the hijackers’ terms for release of the 54 or 55 airline hostages presumably still held in or near the embattled Jordanian capital.

“It is very dangerous for them,” said Ghassan Kanafani, editor of the weekly newspaper of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, who returned from Amman last night. In an interview in the Popular Front’s office, here, Mr.

Kanafani denied that the guerrillas had caused a deadlock in the negotiations over the hostages by refusing to give details of their demands for the release of guerrillas held by Israel. He said the basic problem was that Israel had not accepted the principle of an exchange.

Once this is done. he said, the Popular Front will divulge the names of Palestinian prisoners it wants exchanged. This list would presumably be the basis for further discussion. The other conditions being demanded of Israel, as restated by Mr.

Kanafani, are the release of a Swiss charged in Haifa with spying, the release of two Algerians taken off a British airliner in Israel last month and the release of 10 Lebanese soldiers taken prisoner in January.

He also reiterated the Popular Front’s other demand for the release of seven guerrillas held in Western Europe in return for British, Swiss and West German hostages. But he dwelt on his charge that the next move was up to Israel. “I am not ready to give our list until they announce in principle they will release our people,” Mr. Kanafani said fervently.

“The bombing makes no difference.” Speaking of the hostages in Amman, he said, “they are on the same level as our men. We could not give them better shelter than the shelter we give ourselves.” He reiterated that the American hostages “are being treated on the same basis as the Israelis because the United States Government is an enemy.”

He said that the Americans would be released with the Israelis only when Israel accepted the commandos’ terms.

CP-1970-026 →

· Sacramento Union · Sacramento

Palestinian Guerrillas’ Common Motto: ‘We Will Meet in Tel Aviv!’

Ray McHugh

WASHINGTON — Who are the Palestinian guerrillas? Who leads them? What do they want? Where do they get their money? To too many Americans, the Palestinian Arab has arrived on the Middle East scene with surprising force. Too many, including some in official positions, persistently ignored or minimized him.

The Middle East was vexing enough when studied in terms of national boundaries and rivalries. To mix in 500,000 homeless Arabs living in miserable United Nations camps in four or five countries converted difficult analyses into impossible equations. September events have wiped away this luxury.

After the hijacking and destruction of five jet airliners and the eruption of full-scale civil war in Jordan, no one any longer can afford to ignore the Palestinian Arab. THE TURN of events has not surprised frequent visitors to the Middle East.

Beirut and Amman, the Gaza Strip, Damascus and Baghdad for years have festered with the anti-Israeli passions and the frustrations of these half-million people. The Palestinian is not a “typical” refugee. Nor does he meet the Westerner’s traditional notion of an Arab.

Products of the days of the British mandate in Palestine from 1918 to 1948, the older refugees are largely artisans, farmers, small businessmen and a few professional men and workers. Many served in the British army. Not a few worked in the British civil service. Some participated in Palestine’s first anti-Zionist demonstrations in 1918.

Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.

CP-1970-010 →

· San Francisco Chronicle

A Mixed Rally at Federal Building

It was a sort of “mixed bag” rally against United States and Russian involvement in the Palestinian Arab revolution. By 1 p.m. yesterday, some 300 persons had gathered in front of the Federal Building.

Although the thrust of the rally was pro - Arab and anti U.S. and Russia, the participants carried signs reading: “Free Los Siete,” “Free Bobby Seale,” and “Support Israel; Expose Soviet-Arab Intrigue.”

People involved in the rally included the Progressive Labor Party, the Young Socialist Allliance, an the bra-less members of the Women’s Liberation Movement. The pro - Arab demonstrators carried signs reading: “Sixth Fleet Hands Off Jordan,” “U.S.

Police Stay Home,” “Hussein is a Puppet of Imperialism,” and “No Cambodia in Jordan.” The demonstration was relatively calm; although there was some chanting and at least one shoving instance. The group marched to the World Trade Center, in the Ferry Building, where they gave a petition to Farouk A.

Mawlawi, director of the Arab League Office in the Western United States. The petition said the Organization of Arab Students gave their full support to the “struggle of the masses against the Jordan regime.”

CP-1970-035 →

· The Turlock Journal

Pro-Arab Group’s Rally Draws Unusual Variety

SAN FRANCISCO (UPI)—A pro-Arab group called a rally Tuesday but pickets carried signs for many another cause in the march from the Federal Building to the Ferry Building. “Victory to the Palestinian People” and “Yankee Stay Home,” read some of the signs.

But others said, “Free Bobby Seale,” “Free Los Siete,” and “Jews, Yes, Zionists, No.” One even said, “Support Israel.” Roy Heath, 23, a San Jose State College student who carried the last one, was struck and shoved by several pro-Arab demonstrators, police reported.

Taking part were the Organization of Arab Students, the Progressive Labor Party, the Young Socialist Alliens and some bra-less members of the Women’s Liberation Front. Bobby Seale, a Black Panther Party member, is charged in Connecticut in connection with a murder.

“Los Siete” refers to six youths with Spanish surnames who are charged with killing a San Francisco policeman.

CP-1970-036 →

· The New York Times

Stuff of Arab Legends

Yasir Arafat

He does not look to be the stuff of which legends are made. Despite his short stature, a rather stocky figure a prominent nose, a receding chin and baldness concealed by his omnipresent kaffiyeh, or headdress, Yasir Arafat is a hero to millions in the Arab world.

For multitudes disillusioned by the failures of established Arab leaders in their conflict with Israel, active hope centers on the soft-spoken Mr. Arafat, the 41-year-old leader of Al Fatah, the largest and most active Palestinian guerrilla group, and the head of the Palestinian Liberation Organization, a coordinating body for about 10 commando groups. Yesterday Mr.

Arafat, who has recently taken to issuing his orders under the title Commander in Chief of the Palestinian Revolution, agreed to a cease-fire in Jordan. These days his leadership among the guerrilla organizations is unchallenged.

His decision to stay on in Amman to lead the outnumbered guerrillas in the bitter fighting against King Hussein’s army has elevated him to a new level of esteem among militant Arabs. … Replying to reporters, he put aside questions of ideology. “As a refugee,” he said, “I have no time to spare arguing over the left and right.

What is important is action and its result.” “We have believed that the only way to return to our homes and land is the armed struggle,” he said. “We believe in this theory without any complications, and this is our aim and our hope.”

Offers action when others offer rhetoric.

CP-1970-027 →

· The New York Times · New York

A Proposal for Mideast Peace...

And Frantis Jate olateste ...And Last Cal for Statesmanship Voices of Palertinian Heard to dil Siles

CP-1970-017 →

· New York Amsterdam News

Palestinians And Blacks

To The Editor: I have recently been reading letters printed in The Amsterdam News which compares the struggle of the Palestinians to that of Black people. When the Jews began migrating to that part of Palestine that is today Israel, the land was virtually uninhabited and barren. Most Arabs lived in the part of land that is today Jordan.

Twenty four thousand Jews lived in the part that is today Israel. In 1948, over 70 percent of the population of the part of Palestine that is today Israel was Jewish. Jews wanted determination over their own lives after experiencing many Arab massacres of men, women and children, especially that of Hebron. All of the Arab nations were established by colonial powers.

Israel was established by the UN. The Jews were even willing to see the land in which they were a majority split in two, as the price for independence but when Britain pulled out of Palestine, six Arab nations declared war on this small, new and free state. Egypt closed the Suez Canal to Israeli ships. Egypt blocked the Straits of Tiran to Israeli shipping.

The Arab League today threatens boycott against companies wishing to deal with Israel. While Israel was under siege she was helping Ghana to build her merchant marine and training Black technicians from the Congo in skills badly needed by that African nation. Biafra called itself “the Israel of Africa.”

Egypt sent pilots to fly planes and shot Biafran children in numerous air raids. Jewish refugees thrown out of Arab countries lost their political rights, their property, and often their lives.

Israel was one of the first nations in the world to respond by sending medical supplies and equipment to Peru after the recent earthquake and Israel supplies a number of African countries with technical aid and assistance. Israel’s contribution to the Arab refugees last year was over half a million dollars. Egypt contributed only $1800.

I would think that Black Americans would relate more sympathetically to the nine Jews hanged by Iraq than by the oppressive Arab State that did the lynching. Arab history shows who the slave traders in East Africa were; they were Arabs. Today Blacks living in the southern Sudan are fighting for self determination against an Arab regime.

Israel, with the cooperation of Uganda, is helping to supply Blacks with guns while the Arabs slaughter these people in village raids, much like those conducted against civilians living in villages in Israel. The idea brought forth by some people that the struggle of Black Americans is like the struggle of the Palestinian is utter nonsense.

Blacks are a minority in America and Jews are a minority in the Middle East. No one threatens the Arabs with annihilation but Blacks have been threatened with it and the Jews of Israel are threatened with it.

Ever since Trofim Kitchko, the Soviet writer who was “rehabilitated” after serving the Nazis, began to use “Zionists” as an evil word, every Jew hater in sight picked up this phrase. The so called Zionists of Israel believe in the right of their people to govern their own lives. This too, has been the hallmark of the Black struggle in America.

The population of Israel today is over 70 percent immigrants thrown out of Arab countries and young Jews who were born in and devote their lives to the dignity of all men in a small nation called Israel.

On a recent trip to the Middle East, the bus I rode on from Jerusalem to Eilat, in the southern Israeli desert, was guarded by a Black Israeli commando (one of many Black Israelis) who summed it up in his native Hebrew language — “Am Yisroel Chai” — the nation of Israel must live.

CP-1970-016 →

· The New York Times

A Palestinian Solution

The hiatus in efforts to promote a comprehensive Middle East peace settlement caused by the death of Egypt’s President Nasser and by continuing uncertainty in Jordan should not forestall all attempts to break the Arab-Israeli deadlock.

The cause of world peace and the interests of all Middle East factions call for support of the appeal by President Nixon and British Prime Minister Heath for an extension of the ninety-day Arab-Israeli cease-fire.

A precondition for such a move toward resumption of peace negotiations, however, is that Egypt and the Soviets repair their credibility by correcting their past violations of the agreement.

Meanwhile, the current paralysis of policy in Cairo and Amman presents a unique opportunity for would-be peacemakers to focus their attention on the real root of the crisis—the Palestinian problem—in an area which remains relatively undisturbed, the Israeli-occupied West Bank of the Jordan Valley.

Some Israelis have long urged that the West Bank, with its 600,000 or more Palestinian residents, should become a showplace for the kind of Israeli-Palestinian coexistence that was envisioned in the original United Nations plan for the partition of Palestine.

The Israeli Government has tried to win the hearts and minds of the captive Palestinians by ambitious efforts at economic development and by allowing them considerable latitude for managing their own affairs.

In spite of substantial success in the economic field—West Bank incomes are reported to have doubled in the last three years—and a minimum of military repression, Israel’s hopes for rapprochement have been disappointed. Like any alien occupation, however benign, Israeli rule has bred at least as much resentment as friendship.

West Bank Arab leaders have thus far spurned Israeli suggestions that they come forward with their own proposals. This was partly because they suspected Israeli intentions, partly because of opposition from the Jordanian Government and guerrilla leaders, and partly because some clung to the hope that Nasser would somehow solve their problem.

The death of Nasser and events in Jordan that have tended to discredit both King Hussein and the guerrilla extremists in the eyes of West Bankers may help to persuade these reluctant leaders that the time has come to act in their own behalf.

CP-1970-023 →

· The New York Times · New York

Bomb Wrecks Office of Palestine Group

“The offices of the Palestine Liberation Organization were extensively damaged by a bomb blast last night… a bomb, apparently placed in a briefcase outside the organization’s office, exploded shortly before 11 P.M., blowing out windows and doors on the floor…”

Michael Knight. 101 Park Avenue at 40th Street, Manhattan. A bombing of a Palestinian office in midtown New York, no one hurt, no one named as a suspect, and the archive holds nothing about who did it or whether anyone was ever charged.

CP-1970-018 →

· The Blade · Toledo · page 1

Glimpse At Words, Style Of Palestinian Commandos

“An Egyptian leftist in Paris had referred me to Ghrassan Kanafani, editor of the Popular Front’s ‘Al Hadaf’ magazine and who is Dr.

Habash’s representative in Beirut. He is a charming young man who has written several novels based on the Palestinian plight, and is generally regarded as an intellectual hero of the Palestinian revolution. His office looked like a political campaign headquarters.

In one corner he had a pile of captured Israeli bombs, and in another the seat taken from the American Embassy in Amman. Walls were papered with posters of Dr. Habash, flanked by others of Lenin and Che Guevara, and there were photos of alleged Israeli brutality in the occupied West Bank, slogans for the liberation of Palestine, and a detailed street map of Jerusalem.

While we spoke, Leila Khalad, the skyjacker who spent some time in a London jail, was typing herself into a frenzy in an outer office. I asked Mr.

Kanafani to describe the Popular Front’s ultimate goal for Palestine, and he outlined a secular, democratic binational state in which Jews and Arabs would live together as brothers — ‘after we have driven out the Zionists’… Shortly, a man with very proper deportment, accompanied by a woman journalist, walked in and introduced himself as Bonn’s representative in Beirut… began by admiring Mr.

Kanafani’s toys. He oh-ho’ed the American Embassy seal, and then started bouncing one of the Israeli bombs in his hands. ‘What have we here?’ he chuckled. ‘I would advise you to be careful — that bomb is live,’ Mr.

Kanafani exhorted, looking up from a letter with icy nonconcern. The German looked abashed and gently replaced the bomb to its corner… ‘You know,’ the diplomat said, ‘some people are calling you barbarians and criminals, and surely you don’t want that.’ Mr. Kanafani exploded: ‘You dare to speak to me of our “crimes.”

How long will these Zionist agents of imperialism commit crimes against our people? Where is the truth about these new Nazis, these murderers who do worse things to Arabs than were ever done to Jews? We are the Jews, we are the ones being butchered.

Moshe Dayan is far worse than Hitler — and the only thing keeping him from exterminating all the Arabs under his rule now is that he lacks the technical means.’… ‘There are no Palestinians on the West Bank,’ he asserted, ‘only so many Quislings.

The Palestinians are all in prison, or here with us, fighting for the liberation of our homeland.’ Those practicing law in Ramallah or operating a business in East Jerusalem, for example, evidently have no right to call themselves Palestinians, in the guerrillas’ view.”

“GHASSAN KANAFANI — Writer and editor”

Twenty-one months before he was killed, and this paper’s caption under his photograph reads Writer and editor. It is also the clipping in which he is hardest to defend: he compares Moshe Dayan to Hitler, and he tells the reporter that the million Palestinians living on the West Bank are Quislings and not Palestinians at all. The reporter puts the million back in. Both stay.

CP-1970-002 →

· The New York Times · New York

An Appeal by Black Americans Against United States Support of the Zionist Government of Israel

WE, the Black American signatories of this advertisement are in complete solidarity with our Palestinian brothers and sisters, who like us, are struggling for self-determination and an end to racist oppression.

The recent bloodbath in Jordan, resulting in tens of thousands of dead and wounded Palestinians, would not have been possible without the encouragement, armaments and financial aid of the United States Government.

America’s support for King Hussein’s slaughter of Palestinian refugees and freedom-fighters is consistent with its support of reactionary dictatorships throughout the world—from Cambodia and Vietnam to South Africa, Greece and Iran.

We stand with the Palestinian people in their efforts to preserve their revolution, and oppose its attempted destruction by American Imperialism aided by Zionists and Arab reactionaries. WE STATE that we are not anti-Jewish. We are anti-Zionist and against the Zionist State of Israel, the outpost of American Imperialism in the Middle East.

Zionism is a reactionary racist ideology that justifies the expulsion of the Palestinian people from their homes and lands, and attempts to enlist the Jewish masses of Israel and elsewhere in the service of imperialism to hold back the Middle East revolution. The Zionist Organization of America in an ad in the New York Times of Sept.

17, 1970 stated: “It is appropriate for the United States to begin to treat Israel, the only democracy in the Middle East, as a de facto ally for the safeguarding of American interests.” According to the National Observer of May 18, 1970, the world Zionist movement is big business.

“When the blood flows, the money flows,” observes Gottlieb Hammer, chief Zionist fund collector in this country.

CP-1970-013 →

· Washington Daily News · Washington

Arab refugees are in their third generation

Harry Golden

“‘Let us agree,’ he said seriously, ‘that the refugees constitute a terrible human problem… Israel is not going to solve the problem because of its moral implications…’ Since the one chance to disagree had been forthwith subtracted from the dialogue, I listened… The Arab refugees are now into their third generation.

No one has come up with an alternative.”

The shorter printing, and it ends on a sentence that opens a paragraph in the longer one. Four paragraphs are missing from the bottom: the one naming Israeli intransigence, the one describing returning refugees as “300,000 potential enemies” whose homes had been razed for highways and kibbutzim, and the two closing paragraphs in which Golden says twenty years of visiting newsmen had produced nothing. The paper cut from the bottom, which is how columns are cut. The paragraphs nearest the bottom were the ones assigning responsibility.

CP-1970-005 →

· Florida Today · Melbourne

Palestinian Refugees: They're Bitter, Bored

The water comes from Irbid by a pipe which also is connected to the camp’s minimal sanitation facilities—five public showers and about 200 outhouses. Hundreds of children played in the dusty alleys outside, some peering occasionally into Moussa’s tent.

The children live sometimes six or seven in a room with parents in the shacks lined over three acres of a barren hill. Moussa is resigned to dying in the camp “even though a day doesn’t pass when I don’t think what it would be like to return to Haifa. Everything’s changed, I’m sure, but I would like to go back.

“That is unrealistic but so are all the other solutions mentioned— including a state on the west bank federated with Jordan. That doesn’t get any of us back to our homeland.”

Critics of the camps charge that a welfare mentality has developed — that Palestinians cling to the dole from the United Nations the same way some U.S. families depend on welfare checks. But like many in the United States, the refugees, most of whom were farmers, have no skills they can turn into jobs.

And there is a suspicion that Arab governments prefer to keep them in the camps as political pawns. In Israel, officials complain that no other peoples in the world have remained “refugees” for such a long period. Other refugee people, like the Armenians and White Russians, have quietly assimilated in their adopted lands, they add.

A BAREFOOT AND BEDRAGGLED REFUGEE CHILD ... she lives in Bekaa Camp near Amman, Jordan

CP-1970-008 →

· Oakland Tribune

Ex-Wife of Hussein Weds Again

CAIRO (AP) — Princess Dina Abdul Hamid, former wife of King Hussein of Jordan, has married a Palestinian commandc, the authoritative newspaper Al Ahram reported today. In a dispatch from Amman, Al Ahram quoted sources close to the Al Fatah guerrilla group as saying the marriage took place secretly last month.

It identified the husband as Asaad Abdel Rahman, code named Salah by his guerrilla associates. The newspaper said Dina obtained Hussein’s permission and also consulted her 15-year-old daughter by the Jordanian monarch, Alia, before going through with the marriage. Alia is studying at a girls’ college in Britain.

Al Ahram said Dina met Rahman during a “Palestine Week” political campaign in London. Dina, 36, a former Cairo University professor, married Hussein in 1955. They were divorced after two years, reportedly because of the couple’s inability to have a male heir to the throne. Hussein is now married to British-born Princess Muna.

CP-1970-037 →

· Springfield Daily News · Springfield

Palestinian Influence Is Assessed at American Outpost in Mideast

Elias Antar

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — “This,” said the angry Palestinian student, “is what is happening in this part of the world, and you can’t get away from it.” He was pointing to a bulletin board at the American University of Beirut, and a poster from Al Fatah.

“Forward to liberation, not backward to settlement,” it said, alongside a portrayal of a commando unit raiding into Israel. It was one of several guerrilla signs posted outside the main student canteen on the beautifully landscaped campus of the university, America’s showpiece of learning in the Middle East.

Angry Student The student was angry because the appeal of the guerrilla movement in the Arab world has sparked a right-wing backlash in Lebanon over alleged Palestinian domination of the school. Palestinians resent this and say claims of domination are unfounded.

They assert that Lebanese politicians and leading religious figures have put pressure on the university’s administration to reduce Palestinian presence on the campus. University officials, however, say professors still are hired strictly on professional qualifications, and students are accepted on the basis of grades, not nationality.

Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.

CP-1970-009 →

· The New York Times

Christmas Scene in Bethlehem Spans the Centuries

By PETER GROSE

BETHLEHEM, Israeli-Occupied Jordan, Friday, Dec. 25 — Christians, Moslems and Jews mingled solemnly last night in Bethlehem’s Manger Square, each playing a distinctive role at the center of the world’s celebration of Christmas. The Christians came by the thousands as they have for hundreds of years, as pilgrims—less or more devout—to Christendom’s holy place.

The Moslem villagers in the surrounding Judean Hills were the willing hosts; they have learned to put up cheerfully, once a year, with the throngs, the closing off of traffic, the roadblocks and—even here—the litter that crowds of visitors leave behind.

To the Jews of modern Israel, under whose control Bethlehem has found itself since the war of 1967, fell the technical arrangements for the expression of faith, the provision of armed troops on the roofs of the town to insure that no untoward elements intrude. Here, where it all started, the scene of Christmas is a garble of the centuries.

… [JUMP OF THE MATCHED ARTICLE — this is the part that merges into CP-1970-028:] BETHLEHEM SCENE SPANS CENTURIES Continued From Page 1, Col 4 lights and loudspeakers of downtown Bethlehem, there were clusters of youths from a dozen countries, their bedrolls laid out on the stone pavement, their guitars gently harmonizing with the carols and hymns from the amplified organ of the church over the manger revered as the one where Jesus was born.

Here the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churches are in control. The midnight mass is theirs, but with the important understanding that one representative each of the Eastern Orthodox and Armenian churches stand on the southern side of the main iron door of the basilica of the Nativity as the Latin, or Roman Catholic, patriarch enters.

Other Groups Participate Moreover, for half an hour yesterday afternoon, before the arrival of the Latin patriarch, Msgr. James Joseph Beltritti, the Armenians were authorized to ring the bells and the Eastern Orthodox placed their icon in the Grotto of the Nativity, removing it promptly when their worship was concluded and the Latin patriarch arrived at 1:30.

The Eastern Orthodox Church celebrates Christmas on Jan 7, the Armenian Church on Jan. 19, all because of different calendars that have evolved since the beginning of the Christian era. The intricate arrangements of the various Christian denominations have their uneasy focus at the celebration of the holy days — Christmas in Bethlehem and Easter in Jerusalem.

As the Israelis discovered in 1967, when they found themselves supervising these arrangements as the political authorities on the spot, the rivalries and prerogatives are complex. The head of the Christian Division of the Israeli Ministry of Religious Affairs, Saul P. Colbi, has written: “True, the rights and privileges of the communities had been defined in 1852.

But to master the subtle intricacies, one must acquire a thorough knowledge of the de facto situation prevailing in the shrines from a perusal of the main precedents set and decisions promulgated by the governments which successively ruled the Holy Land.”

Below the basilica, down a flight of curving stone steps, a stream of the curious and the devout passed to see the Grotto of the Nativity, the cave that medieval Biblical translators turned into a stable. “Hic de Virgine Maria Jesus Christ natus est,” the inscription reads. “Here the Virgin Mary gave birth to Jesus Christ.”

The grotto was open to all pilgrims who came; the pontifical high mass could be joined only by those who had received tickets from the local church authorities.

All outside in Manger Square, however, could observe the process of worship on a two-story-high screen erected on the side of a hotel to give closed-circuit television coverage of the high altar. [END OF THE MATCHED ARTICLE. Below is a SEPARATE item printed on the same clipping, with its own head and dateline.

Not part of CP-1970-028.] Grenade Hurled Near Bethlehem BETHLEHEM, Friday, Dec. 25 (AP)—A hand grenade apparently thrown by an Arab guerrilla, exploded last night on the outskirts of Bethlehem, Israeli security agents said. No one was injured, they reported.

They said that the grenade had been hurled at an Israeli civilian car but had missed. [A further item begins below a rule at the foot of the scan. Only the first two words of its headline are on the page and the second is cut by the crop: “Crosses A…”. Nothing of its body is on the scan.]

WHERE JESUS WAS BORN: Pilgrims filing into the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem yesterday for worship

CP-1970-028 →

· The New York Times

Arabs in Israel: Minority Torn Between 2 Worlds

By Peter Grose

ABU GHOSH, Israel, Jan. 28 — “As Israeli Arabs, our problem is that other Arabs dismiss us as Israelis and other Israelis suspect us as Arabs.” Speaking in a soft and cultured voice, Dr. Subhi Abu Ghosh, a 42-year-old social scientist thus summed up the identity crisis of 330,000 Arabs who chose, or whose parents chose, to live under the flag of Israel.

These are the more modest families of Palestine who decided in 1948 to remain in their cities, towns, villages and farms within the newly proclaimed country, rather than flee, like the intelligentsia and politically conscious, to become refugees in neighboring Arab countries.

Now an inarticulate minority in an allen society, their plight has political, economic and social aspects. There are no powerful champions of the Israeli Arabs, neither within their own ranks nor in foreign capitals, near or far. No one takes up their cause; they have produced no rebels. The rest of Israel is bustling and building.

The Arab villages remain dusty or muddy, depending on the season, sleepy and crumbling as they have been

Israeli Arab women in a part of their Abu Ghosh home that is provided for livestock. Woman photographer took picture — men visitors do not generally see women at home.

CP-1971-013 →

· The New York Times · New York

Arab Fratricide and Hate of Israelis Grow in the Dust and Despair of Gaza

By PETER GROSE, Special to The New York Times

GAZA, Feb. 1 — The first day of the month is pay day for the 7,2[illegible digit]0 local Arabs who overcame old political scruples and have started working for high pay in Israeli factories a short bus ride up the Mediterranean coast from this town.

The local banks were predictably crowded this morning, with depositors in long lines into the streets, when shortly after 9 A.M. a large explosive charge went off at the downtown postal savings bank. The concrete building crumbled to the crowd. Over 60 persons were injured at the counter. Eight of them were close to death.

This is what happens in Gaza, where Arab fratricide has become a way of life. As Israeli occupation forces stand by, scarcely able to protect their own, Arab goes on killing Arab in warfare that has defied resolution for two decades. This is where the first tragedies of the homeless Palestinians are played out.

To the visitor, the dominant emotion of Gaza is one of helplessness, mounting with each turn of a corner in the dusty, dirty streets. The Israelis think they have the solution to the problem of the Gaza strip, through economic integration and development, but it will take time and require basic everyday safety.

EXPLOSION RIPS BANKING OFFICE IN GAZA: Men viewing rubble inside hole in the wall of postal savings bank in the Israeli-occupied city. Concrete building crumbled. Many were injured as yesterday was payday for more than 7,000 Arabs. [credit] The New York Times/Peter Grose

Date check: DATE AND PAPER CONFIRMED ON THE PAGE. The running head reads “THE NEW YORK TIMES, TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 2, 1971”, which matches both `pub` and the slide-label date of 1971-02-02. The dateline reads “GAZA, Feb. 1”.

CP-1971-012 →

· The New York Times · page 24

Haj Amin el-Husseini Dies; Ex-Palestine Grand Mufti

BEIRUT, Lebanon, July 4—Haj Amin el-Husseini, the former Grand Mufti of Jerusalem and a veteran Palestinian political leader, died here today at the age of 80. An announcement by his physicians gave the cause of death as heart failure. He was admitted to the American University Hospital two days ago suffering from cardiac trouble. He is to be buried here tomorrow.

The Grand Mufti, who was popularly known as Haj Amin, had been living at a villa in a Beirut suburb since he left his exile in Cairo in 1959. The Mufti was one of the most powerful Arab leaders for 30 years after World War I. His influence declined when such Moslem leaders as President Gamal Abdel Nasser of Egypt came into power.

President Nasser headed a populous nation in arms, whereas the Mufti had headed only dissident factions. Although the title Mufti designates an expounder of Islamic law and there were any number of muftis, Haj Amin el-Husseini, Mufti of Jerusalem, became “The Mufti.” He was a figure of violent controversy.

When he was a power in the turbulent affairs of the Middle East, he was described as a handsome and soft-spoken Moslem gentleman. One journalist said his face was that of “a jolly elf.” He had keen and often smiling blue eyes. His close-clipped beard was reddish when he was a young man.

He usually wore the impressive black, gold-lined flowing robe of a Moslem religious leader.

CP-1971-014 →

· Beaumont Journal · Beaumont · page 1

Terror Stalks Gaza

Copley News Service, Jebeliye Refugee Camp, Occupied Gaza Strip

JEBELIYE REFUGEE CAMP, Occupied Gaza Strip — The young boys crowded around the truck loaded with watermelons, dickering with the seller over the price and blocking all other traffic along the main street of Jebeliye’s market.

Groups of men sat in open-air cafes over long-finished glasses of coffee, shielded from the sun by corrugated tin roofs held in place by large stones. Others shopped, along with a handful of women dressed in the traditional peasant garb of Palestine.

The otherwise peaceful scene was briefly interrupted by three armed Israeli soldiers walking slowly down a side road, Uzi submachine guns ready for use. The youths walked several yards apart—protection if a grenade is tossed—and one of them turned to give a warning stare at a group of boys when a pebble was thrown.

Then the soldiers walked on, and the men in the cafes resumed their talk, the women their investigations of fruits and vegetables. But when dusk comes, the scene is far different… Even within the camps’ mud shacks, many refugees are not safe. Almost 70 murders were committed in Gaza in the first six months of 1971, about half of them in Jebeliye.

Some are committed with automatic weapons, others with knives.

Often women are beaten to death—perhaps because their husbands “collaborated” with the Israelis, perhaps during an attempted rape… And though many Arabs acknowledge that some of the murders are personally motivated, few are willing to accept the Israeli verdict that most of them are unconnected with politics.

The same Copley dispatch the Jonesboro Sun ran three days later, under a different headline. This version opens on boys buying watermelons and keeps the paragraph about women beaten to death, and the sentence saying few Arabs accept the Israeli explanation.

CP-1971-004 →

· The Sun · Baltimore · page 1

Terror Still Stalks Residents Of Gaza Strip As Political Murders Increase In Number

By Jeanne Kuebler, Copley News Service, Jebeliye Refugee Camp, Occupied Gaza Strip

JEBELIYE REFUGEE CAMP, Occupied Gaza Strip — The young boys crowded around the truck loaded with watermelons, dickering with the seller over the price and blocking all other traffic along the main street… At night few residents venture outside their homes.

The only ones on the streets — other than armed Arab terrorists — are occasional Israeli vehicular patrols… Even within the camp’s mud shacks, many refugees are not safe. Almost 70 murders were committed in Gaza in the first six months of 1971, about half of them in Jebeliye.

The terrorists themselves are not immune to the nightly violence… The murders are not all that unusual, spokesmen for the military government in Gaza insist. Murders are often the outcome of family feuds or a way to avenge the besmirched honor of a wife, daughter or sister.

But the pace of the killings has risen sharply… “We see these killings as primarily for political reasons,” one long-term Gazan said. “The man is murdered because he is working for the Jews either publicly or secretly and the woman because she refuses to tell the fadayi (guerrillas) where the man is.”

Murder isn’t the only form of guerrilla activity in Gaza, “home” to some 360,000 people, 220,000 of them classified as refugees by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency and 163,000 in camps—50,000 in Jebeliye alone.

Attacks on Israeli soldiers and the “collaborating” population — such as the 12,000 Gazans who travel each day to Israel to work—also take their toll. Through mid-June authorities recorded nearly 200 incidents — a grenade tossed into a bus loaded with Arab workers or at an Israeli soldier stationed at an intersection.

In those daily incidents 37 were killed — six Israelis and 31 Arabs — and well over 300 injured, 80 per cent of them Arabs… Israeli spokesmen admit security forces have never made house-to-house weapons searches in all of Gaza town and the refugee camps.

“We don’t want to disturb normal life too much,” one officer said… The Israeli buses that make daily runs to Gaza from Ashkelon and Beersheba have heavy wire mesh over their windows to ward off grenades.

Barbed wire has created one-way streets in areas where incidents are common, blocking escape paths… Israeli spokesmen insist little can be done about the frequent murders and that, as Defense Minister Moshe Dayan recently told reporters, the security situation is “satisfactory.”

“STREET near Jebeliye Refugee Camp in the Gaza Strip is quiet by day; is often the scene of violence when the sun goes down. Arab guerrilla groups harass refugees.” CNS Photo.

Gaza in 1971, sixteen years before the intifada and seventeen before Hamas. The dateline reads Occupied Gaza Strip. The dead are counted by side — six Israelis and 31 Arabs — and 80% of the injured are Arabs. A map runs beside it with Gaza in Arabic and Hebrew at the top.

CP-1971-003 →

· Daily Oklahoman · Oklahoma City · page 1

Israeli Program Ousts Number of Refugee Families in Gaza Strip

By Richard Eder, New York Times Service, Gaza

GAZA — In the swarming, bone-white refugee camp of Jabaliya, five mukhtars, or headmen, sit on a bench outside the camp office, asking futile questions and making futile complaints about the bulldozer that is razing houses nearby. An old mukhtar in a black, gold-threaded robe, speaks, pushing out his phrases and letting them hang in the air, tiredly.

“The Israelis know the guerrillas” names,’ he said. “If they are caught, they are killed or arrested. That is individual punishment. But as for the demolition of our houses and the eviction of our families, that is a collective punishment for which the refugees have no crime or fault.”

The Israelis, without major publicity and without making their ultimate intentions completely clear, are evicting families from the three most crowded camps here, offering them other quarters — mostly in El Arish, south of the Gaza Strip — and bulldozing their houses.

More than 1,200 families have been ousted so far and the program continues… It has been like a minor earthquake in Gaza, the quarter-century-old monument to the wretchedness that the conflict of Arabs and Jews has brought to the Middle East… The population has protested without effect.

A general strike, like others in the past, fizzled this week after the army sealed 15 striking shops and threatened similar measures against others. The terrorists threw grenades, but the victims were the refugees themselves… Israeli officials are not yet prepared to discuss fully the long-range aspects.

They say they are legally justified in moving refugees from Gaza into occupied Egyptian territory in Sinai Peninsula.

The earliest of the three printings of this dispatch, and the reporter is named here: Richard Eder. Nine days and three papers later the same sentences carry three different headlines — ousts, relocating, bulldozed by Jews. It runs beside a half-price dress shirt advertisement and a revolving charge account.

CP-1971-009 →

· Minneapolis Tribune · page 1

Relocating of Gaza refugees upsets many

By Richard Eder, New York Times Service, Gaza Strip

“In the swarming, bone-white refugee camp of Jabaliya, five mukhtars, or headmen, sit on a bench outside the camp office, asking futile questions and making futile complaints about the bulldozer that is razing houses nearby. An old mukhtar in a black, gold-threaded robe speaks, pushing out his phrases and letting them hang in the air, tiredly.

‘The Israelis know the commandos’ names,’ he said. ‘If they are caught, they are killed or arrested. That is individual punishment. But as for the demolition of our houses and the eviction of our families, that is a collective punishment for which the refugees have no crime or fault.’

The Israelis, without major publicity and without making their ultimate intentions completely clear, are evicting families from the three most crowded camps here, offering them other quarters — mostly in El Arish, south of the Gaza Strip — and bulldozing their houses. More than 1,200 families have been ousted so far and the program continues.

The immediate purpose is to clear roadways through the camps to permit Israeli patrols to go through in their quest for terrorists… It is the first far-reaching effort to change conditions in the strip, where more than 300,000 Palestinian refugees sit in squalor, frustration and fear that have lasted since 1948, when they fled after Israel was established… The United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA), which provides food, educational and health services to the refugees, has been studying the situation.

It has said nothing publicly, other than to deny that it had agreed to the evictions, but its field officers appear deeply disturbed. The Israelis point to the paralysis and hopelessness, and above all to the terror, that have dominated the camps.

Apart from killing five Israeli soldiers and injuring 85 in the last year, members of Palestinian resistance groups have assassinated 135 residents of Gaza and injured more than 500. Fifty-six terrorists have been killed by the Israelis and more than 50 captured… Israeli officials are not yet prepared to discuss fully the long-range aspects.

They say they are legally justified in moving refugees from Gaza into occupied Egyptian territory in Sinai Peninsula… The refugees complain about the quarters in El Arish.

The Israelis say that they are at least as good as the camp houses and that most — among them flats abandoned by Egyptian officers at the time of the 1967 war — are much better… ‘I would rather eat sand in Gaza than go to El Arish,’ an old man called out. ‘When Jews are arrested in Russia, the world hears about it.

Aren’t we human, too?’… ‘These camps seem like hell to me, but I can see that they might seem like paradise to them,’ said a senior Israeli officer. ‘They have lived here 23 years, the UNRWA gives them free food and suddenly we transfer them.’”

The headmen of Jabaliya on a bench outside the camp office while the bulldozer works, and one of them naming the distinction the whole page turns on: individual punishment for the men they want, collective punishment for everyone else. Both sides’ counts are printed in consecutive paragraphs, and the Israeli officer’s explanation is the last word. The word for moving people out of Gaza, in the Israeli officials’ own sentence, is transfer.

CP-1971-007 →

· The Morning Union · Springfield · page 1

What to Do With 400,000 Refugees

TAMING THE GAZA STRIP · First of Two Parts

By John de St. Jorre, Special to The Union

“A little over a week ago, at 8 o’clock in the morning, a giant bulldozer nosed its way into Jabalia camp in the Gaza Strip and methodically began to reduce to rubble houses that Palestinian refugees had lived in for almost 20 years. The operation was watched by senior Israeli army officers and protected by an unusual display of force.

The occupants of the houses had been warned beforehand but many refused to leave their homes. In order to avoid burying them alive, the Israeli soldiers went into the houses and drove them out with blows from sticks and batons. Within a few days a swath, 30 yards wide and 100 yards long, had been cut along one edge of the camp.

Fifty houses had crumbled into dust and 500 people, half of them young children, were homeless. On the Sabbath the soldiers—and the bulldozers—rested. That day I went into Jabalia.

The camp, built and looked after by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) which has been responsible for feeding, housing and educating the Palestinian refugees since 1949, was in an uproar. Long lines of houses along another perimeter and down the center of the camp had been marked for demolition with red crosses.

The bulldozer, we were told, was due back the following morning to continue the work of widening roads around and through the camp to improve security, and to encourage resettlement. Thirteen of the dispossessed families had been taken for ‘resettlement’ by the army to a smaller camp called Bureij 10 miles away.

Appalled at what they found there, the refugees had returned to Gaza town. We later went to Bureij. The accommodation consisted of half a dozen tumbledown and derelict houses, most of them without roofs.

The other alternative offered by the Israeli authorities to the growing number of homeless was in the town of El Arish, six miles down the coast and outside the Gaza Strip in occupied Egypt. The nature of the accommodation and the method of getting there were, according to the refugees, not specified. The rest of the homeless squeezed in with friends and relatives.”

A reporter walks into Jabalia the day after the bulldozer and counts what it did: a swath thirty yards wide and a hundred long, fifty houses, five hundred people, half of them children. The red crosses marking the next row are in the sixth paragraph. The word resettlement is in quotation marks in the paper’s own sentence, and the place they were resettled to had no roofs. The standing head is Taming the Gaza Strip — a word for animals and for frontiers — and the headline underneath is a logistics question: What to Do With 400,000 Refugees. The people are the problem in the sentence, not the subject of it, and the verb belongs to whoever is deciding. Neither line says who that is.

CP-1971-006 →

· Fort Myers News-Press · page 1

Gaza Strip Homes Bulldozed by Jews

By Richard Eder, New York Times Service, Gaza

GAZA — In the swarming, bone-white refugee camp of Jabaliya, five mukhtars, or headmen, sit on an old bench outside the camp office asking futile questions and making futile complaints about the bulldozer that is razing houses nearby… More than 1,200 families have been ousted so far and the program continues… A visitor to a group of houses marked for demolition found men, women and children at work tearing down the rooms they had added to the houses and loading the stones aboard the trucks along with their furniture.

They will use them to put up new shelters. They clustered, in obvious anguish, around the visitor. “I would rather eat sand in Gaza than go to El Arish,” an old man called out. “When Jews are arrested in Russia, all the world hears about it. Aren’t we human, too?” The refugees complain about the quarters in El Arish.

The Israelis say that they are at least as good as the camp houses and that most — among them flats abandoned by Egyptian officers at the time of the 1967 war — are much better. Another point, one partly conceded by the Israeli authorities, is that jobs are scarce in El Arish and that a refugee working in Gaza finds it impossible to move so far.

The central objection is to leaving the strip… “These camps seem like hell to me, but I can see that they might seem like paradise to them,” said a senior Israeli officer. “They have lived here 23 years, the U.N.R.W.A. gives them free food and suddenly we transfer them.”

The refugees fear that the plan for El Arish is simply the opening move to scatter them through Israeli-administered Arab territories and thus end the Gaza problem.

That they feel, would eliminate their one bargaining counter before world opinion: Their miserable concentration in what is still a no-man’s land and possibly the only important populated territory in the world that no nation claims… A high Israeli officer was watching the demolitions in Shati when a woman came up to him. Things are much better, she told him.

She liked the new, wide streets. How about the neighbors who had to move? the officer asked. She was sure they were happy. “But, sir,” she added, “just don’t touch my house. Be blessed.”

The same New York Times dispatch the Minneapolis Tribune ran a week earlier under the headline “Relocating of Gaza refugees upsets many.” Here the headline is Gaza Strip Homes Bulldozed by Jews. The copy is the same; the subheadings are “1,200 Families Ousted,” “Protests Fizzle” and “Eat Sand in Gaza.” It ends on a woman in Shati telling an officer she likes the wide new streets and asking him not to touch her house. It runs beside a full-page Sears furniture sale.

CP-1971-008 →

· Lansing State Journal · Lansing

Uneasy Gaza Strip Region Where People Forgot How to Smile

GAZA (AP) — To the Israelis, the Gaza Strip has been the most troublesome of the areas they occupy. To the mayor, it’s a place that has forgotten how to smile. The Strip, 30 miles long and 4 miles wide, is a finger of sand dunes, citrus groves and refugee camps that juts into Israel from Sinai along the Mediterranean coast.

About two-thirds of the 360,000 population are refugees. Camps have been the home for many since they fled from Palestine, now Israel, in the war of 1948. Grenade assaults and sabotage have made life miserable for both Israeli soldiers and the Arab population. But the Israelis report a “most spectacular decline” in the activity of Arab guerrillas.

The Israelis also point to more than 15,000 Arabs from Gaza who are working inside Israel—where there is a shortage of unskilled labor. This development has grown despite occasional sabotage against buses carrying workers. One year ago the strict curfew and violence had turned Gaza City into an eerie town with motorized patrols forming the major traffic.

Now the main street of Omar el-Mukhtar is almost bustling with honking taxis and busy shops. But if his life is safer, the Gazan shows no outward joy. Mayor Rashid el-Shawa says: “The lessening of violence gives a false atmosphere of tranquility. There is no satisfaction, only dissatisfaction.”

Since the British mandate ended in 1948 the area has known military government rule: Egyptian-style until the 1956 Sinai campaign, an Israeli interregnum for 126 days, and back again to Egyptian control until the Israelis returned in 1967.

CP-1971-010 →

· The State · Columbia · page 1

War Continues In Refugee Camps In Gaza Strip

Associated Press, Gaza Strip

GAZA STRIP (AP) — The cease-fire on the Suez front has gone on a year, but war continues in the Gaza Strip between Israeli and Arab. It involves camps crowded with Palestinean refugees in this coastal rectangle adjoining Israel and the Sinai.

Grenades are often thrown at Israeli army personnel, and there are collaborators—Arabs who in any way co-operate with the occupying Israelis. This year authorities have counted 83 such murders in the Gaza Strip, nearly half of them in the Jabaliya refugee camp. “The hunt for the hablanim goes on all the time.

I don’t remember when we ever stopped searching for them,” says a swarthy corporal of 21… “Hablanim” is Hebrew for saboteurs—Arab guerrillas, fedayeen, terrorists or freedom fighters, depending on one’s sympathies… Another soldier admits that innocent Arabs may be killed or injured in the fighting.

He explains: “We have orders to fire in the direction of the attacker. It’s the only way, otherwise the hablanim would always attack us from the crowds, and we wouldn’t be able to do a thing.”… The Israelis have seen the problem grow in the four years since they captured the Gaza Strip.

In July they started moving Jabaliya families to new habitation, bulldozed old homes into rubble and built new asphalt roads—for security purposes—in their stead. In all, the Israelis plan to resettle a third of the strip’s 210,000 refugees.

Arab states have complained bitterly, calling it expulsion, but the bulldozers work on inexorably… An officer is asked about Arab claims that camp residents are brutally treated. “Well, I don’t think that’s fair,” he says. “For instance, if there’s one thing I hate, it’s stopping a man to search him, or check his papers.

In seconds, hundreds of women and children have gathered. They scream and curse, and it’s difficult to keep cool and not start shooting when they start hitting and throwing stones. There’s not much point in being brutal. But we are firm. That’s the best word, I think. No nonsense.

If we see somebody in the street after curfew has started, we fire one burst into the air. If he doesn’t stop, we shoot at him. Sometimes we catch a hablan. We know his comrades are somewhere in the area. If he won’t tell us where, we might slap or kick him. It’s all that’s required, usually.

Don’t forget, what’s happening in the camps is a war. We have to win it. And anyway, there have been 40 murders in Jabaliya alone this year. Collaborators, they call them. What’s collaborating? Working in Israel for better wages? Sometimes women and children get murdered.

What have they done to deserve it?”… “And once, a particularly tough force was moved into Gaza. They mistreated some civilians. There was an official inquiry, because the Arabs complained. The committee made its investigation, and some high officers were reassigned, because of the rough treatment.

So I don’t think it’s fair to accuse Israeli soldiers of brutality. You get into trouble with your own commanders for being too rough.” Under regulations, the military men spoke with the understanding their names would not be used.

Israeli soldiers in Gaza talking to the Associated Press in 1971 on condition of anonymity, and the paper printing what they said at length. The demolition of Jabaliya is described as moving families and building asphalt roads for security purposes, and the next sentence gives the word the Arab states used for it: expulsion. The last column is an officer explaining the rules for shooting after curfew. “Palestinean” is the paper’s.

CP-1971-005 →

· The New York Times · New York

An Attempt to Kill Arafat Reported

“The Palestinian guerrilla leader, Yasir Arafat, escaped an assassination attempt today, the Fatah guerrilla group reported. His driver was killed.”

Four sentences. The man who lived is in the headline; the man who died is in the second line and has no name, which is the oldest habit in this collection.

CP-1971-011 →

· The Times

Beirut Moves Against Guerrillas To Quell Israeli Raids

CP-1972-017 →

· The New York Times · New York

Giant Step for Arab Women

By RAPHAEL ROTHSTEIN

JERUSALEM—At the East Jerusalem Vocational Center, a stone building not far from the ancient walls that encircle the Dome of the Rock, the Holy Sepulchre and the Wailing Wall, Fatma Muhammed Algul and 24 other Arab women are learning to adapt the traditional Palestinian embroidery skill to the technique of the sewing machine.

From 8 A.M. to 3 P.M., Sunday through Thursday, Mrs. Algul, a mother of six in her early 40’s, is preparing herself for future employment as a seamstress in an Israeli factory or workshop by learning sewing construction and tailoring for mass production.

Although the idea of seeking employment outside the home may seem tame to Western women, it is an act of enormous social significance in East Jerusalem.

Before the Six-Day War of June, 1967, and the annexation of the former Jordanian sector of Jerusalem by Israel, the attitude of most Moslem and Christian Arab men toward their wives and daughters might have been summed up by an ancient Arabic saying: “A woman is like a precious jewel kept in a glass jar. The smallest crack in the jar may hurt the precious gem inside.”

Tradition ruled that women stay home, raise children, cook the meals and serve the men in the family. Those few women who did work in other than menial capacities were limited to teaching. But the aftermath of the war with Israel brought the Arab women of East Jerusalem into contact with Israeli women, most of whom hold jobs.

Their example, coupled with employment opportunities created by Israel’s buoyant postwar economy, made them aware of new possibilities. In outside work they saw a chance to widen their horizon.

Lessons and Social Activities The East Jerusalem Vocational Center is sponsored by Moetzet Hapoelot/Pioneer Women, a social service organization supported in Israel by working women and in the United States by the Women’s Labor Zionist Organization. In addition to Mrs.

Algul and her 24 co-students enrolled in the eight-month sewing course, another 20 women are studying hairdressing. Their ages range from 18 to 50 and they are frequently joined by friends and neighbors who attend the lectures, Hebrew lessons and social activities the center runs to foster Arab-Israeli understanding and cooperation. Mrs.

Violet Batat, the Israeli, Arabic-speaking director of the center, says that the demand for skilled workers in Israel’s booming needle trades export industries virtually guarantees that all her graduates will be placed. They will join the already substantial percentage of East Jerusalem’s 18,000 adult Arab women who have found employment in Israeli businesses.

The East Jerusalem center is one of 30 Arab women’s clubs run by the Moetzet Hapoelot in Israel. No clubs have been opened on the West Bank because the political status of the territory is uncertain. Mrs. Batat insists there is nothing political in the center’s effort.

“We want to help make these girls more productive, proud members of their families and community,” she said in an interview. “We also hope this effort eventually contributes something to the kind of peace we all want.” The women have their meals at the center and are given a grant of about $1.20 a day for each day they attend class, by the Israel Labor Ministry.

They pay an 80-cent-a-month registration fee. Women arrange with relatives and neighbors to care for their children during the day. Male Authority Still Supreme Defying centuries-old customs by going out to work is a mild revolution, really just a beginning, observers of the Palestinian women say.

There is still a long way to go before these women even approach the raised-consciousness level of an increasing number of women in Europe and the United States. Terms like “male chauvinist” and “sexist” are unheard of. Mr. Algul said that she and her husband, a gardening supervisor for the Jerusalem municipality, discuss most things.

“But,” she added, “the man has to have respect. He has the final word.” Some of the younger Moslem women in the sewing class wore the embroidered maroon and black long dresses characteristic of Palestinian peasants. Raja Mughrabi, 23, the secretary-coordinator of the center, explained that the Moslems tend to be more traditional than the Christian women.

Miss Mughrabi, whose father was a deputy governor of Jerusalem under King Hussein, said Arab women generally are developing more self-confidence. But, she added, “The men are still in control and likely to remain so.” The only taboo at the center, Mrs. Batat says, is politics. All other subjects, including birth control methods, are discussed freely.

Politics and the question of Palestinian nationalism, however, are not the immediate concerns of the increasing number of East Jerusalem working women. “Life has become complicated and expensive here as in the rest of the world,” Ruhaifa Zein, 24, said. “Before my husband said, ‘Stay at home.’ But now there has been a big change. My husband is proud of my embroidery.

He is pleased that I will work and earn money.”

CP-1972-026 →

· Columbia Record

Israeli Raid Forces Beirut To Face Up To Guerrilla Problem

CP-1972-016 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Israel to Discipline Officers In Bedouins’ Displacement

TEL AVIV, March 26—The Chief of Staff, Lieut. Gen. David Elazar, told the Cabinet in Jerusalem today that senior army officers and a civilian official had “overstepped their authority” during the evacuation of Bedouins from an area in the occupied Sinai Peninsula that had been fenced as a security measures.

He said disciplinary measures are to be taken against the officers. The Cabinet anunouncement was not clear, but an authoritative source said that a committee of inquiry had not criticized the displacement of the Bedouins, only the method. According to complaints, the soldiers bulldozed dwellings, sealed wells and destroyed crops. The land fenced was south of Rafa.

The Israelis said that the area had been used by guerrillas who had attacked Israeli settlements in the Negev Desert. General Elazar told the Cabinet that a committee had been appointed to deal with resettling the Bedouins.

Date check: No masthead or page date line survives — the clipping is trimmed to the two-line headline, the credit line “Special to The New York Times” and three paragraphs. The only internal date is the dateline, which reads “TEL AVIV, March 26”. The credit line is consistent with `pub`; the year is not confirmable from the page. Date corrected 1982-03-27 to 1972-03-27. FILED YEAR WRONG BY TEN YEARS. The clipping has no masthead or page date line; the only printed date is the dateline 'Special to The New York Times / TEL AVIV, March 26-'. The content fixes the year beyond doubt: 'The Chief of Staff, Lieut. Gen. David Elazar, told the Cabinet in Jerusalem today that senior army officers and a civilian official had “overstepped their authority” during the evacuation of Bedouins from an area in the occupied Sinai Peninsula that had been fenced as a security measure', with the fenced land 'south of Rafa' and a committee of inquiry that 'had not criticized the displacement of the Bedouins, only the method'. David Elazar was Israeli Chief of Staff only from January 1972 to April 1974 and died in 1976; by March 1982 the Chief of Staff was Rafael Eitan and Sinai was weeks from being handed back, not 'occupied'. The Rafah Salient evacuations took place in January 1972 and the cabinet inquiry reported that March, so the dispatch is of 26 March 1972 and the paper of 27 March 1972 - the filed day and month are right and only the year is wrong. No date is printed on the clipping; the date is fixed by what the article reports, at the precision the evidence supports, and is not guessed beyond it.

CP-1982-054 →

· The Daily Progress · Charlottesville · page 1

Artist Seeking Mideast Togetherness

Jean Myking

“Kamal Boullata is a political artist for the simple reason that he believes every human being is a political animal. He is a Christian Arab born in Jerusalem and after leaving in 1966 to exhibit his paintings at a one-man show in Beirut, Lebanon, he was denied his return after the six-day war of 1967.

Boullata had been a refugee once before when his family fled to Bethlehem in 1948… But after the fall of Jerusalem in 1967, ‘I felt that my whole history as a person had been reduced to the size of a bag I was carrying from one country to another,’ said the 29-year old poet-artist in an interview this week… As a refugee from his home city, Boullata became a kind of ward of the Quakers who he said were aiding about 18,000 West Bank students, and about a million refugees in all… ‘It was during that year,’ he recalled, ‘that I was able to form my political views.

All my life I was a-political. Ironically, it was among the Quakers that I discovered the differences between defensive violence and offensive violence, the violence of the oppressed and the violence of the oppressors.’ The Arab-Israeli conflict, he believes, ‘might come from a specific religious group, but I am not against the Jews.

Because today I feel more of a Jew than a Christian. When I read the Old Testament, it applies to the Palestinians who were born in Palestine and who have centuries of history there, and who today are being denied that.’… ‘They are the people I can hope in.

These are the people I want to share the land with,’ he explained, citing the Israeli League for Human Rights and its leader, Israel Shahak. Shahak, he says, who lost his family in Germany during Nazi persecution, then fought the Arabs.

‘Now he stands up to Israel.’… ‘At heart I feel that anyone who supports the state of Israel is anti-Semitic,’ Boullata said… ‘But it is harmful to Palestinians. It is of our own interest that anti-Semitism doesn’t exist,’ Boullata said.

‘I believe in an ideology that doesn’t solve the question of Jews in the world. I feel that anti-Semitism is a Western concept. Arabs stood up for the Jews in the German holocaust. We are all Semites.’”

Boullata is 29 and three years into exile. The paper notes his appearance was “counterbalanced” four days later by Israel Kessar of the Histadrut speaking at the University of Virginia on “Minority Problems in Israel.” Photo caption: “KAMAL BOULLATA, PALESTINIAN ARTIST — His Paintings are on Display at Westminster Church.”

CP-1972-003 →

· The Morning Call · Allentown

Israel cites POW torture; Palestinians ask statehood

The Associated Press

Two stories welded into one headline by a copy desk in Allentown. The torture in it is the torture of Israelis; the Palestinians in it are asking for a state. Read the semicolon as the whole editorial decision.

CP-1972-018 →

· Great Falls Tribune · Great Falls

Palestinian killed by Israelis

Associated Press

TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Israeli troops opened fire on Palestinian rioters Friday in the occupied West Bank of the Jordan River, killing one person and wounding about 30, Arab sources said. They identified the slain youth as 18-year-old Jamal Shamir. He was the 11th Palestininan killed by security forces in demonstrations against Israeli rule on the West Bank this year.

The fresh outburst was prompted by a new Israeli tax. A journalist in the West Bank town of Nablus reported troops fired on hundreds of demonstrators swarming through the Christian sector of the city. An army officer said the demonstrators threw stones at Israeli soldiers and set fire to the tax office and the Israel National Bank building.

There was no official comment by the Israeli military command on the demonstrations. An uneasy, six-week calm ended.

Five days before a bomb in Beirut killed Ghassan Kanafani, a Montana paper carries the death of an 18-year-old in Nablus and names him: Jamal Shamir. The copy also counts him — the eleventh that year — and says what the protest was about, which was a tax.

CP-1972-015 →

· Jacksonville Journal · Jacksonville · page 1

Arab Militant Leader Dies In Car Explosion

United Press International, Beirut

BEIRUT (UPI) — Ghassan Kanafani, 34, official spokesman for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), was killed today in an explosion in his car, police sources said. They said a bomb apparently went off as he got into the vehicle in the ground floor garage of his apartment building in the Hazmieh suburb of Beirut.

Kanafani’s 14-year-old niece, Lamice Fayez, also was killed in the blast, they said. Kanafani’s Danish wife Anna and their two young children, a boy and a girl, were not with him at the time of the blast and were unhurt… Kanafani’s body was virtually blown to pieces.

A hand was found on the roof of a neighboring house and policemen were gathering up the remains. The car, an Austin 1100, was unrecognizable. The biggest single piece was a battered door. The dead girl, another niece and their mother — Kanafani’s sister — were visiting the Kanafanis and had stayed overnight, neighbors said.

Kanafani, an extreme leftist and a graduate of the American University of Beirut, paid several visits to Scandinavia on behalf of the PFLP. Kanafani, editor of the magazine Al Hadaf, issued statements in the name of the front, including one in May claiming responsibility for the Tel Aviv airport massacre in which 28 persons were killed and scores injured.

The United Press version. It gives his age as 34 and the niece as Lamice Fayez, 14. It calls him an editor and does not mention that he wrote novels. The Associated Press version, moving the same day, gives his age as 36, the niece as Lamiss Nejim, 15, and says he was well known in the Middle East as an author of books, short stories and poems. Both are in this archive.

CP-1972-004 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Arab Terrorist Spokesman Killed As Auto Explodes

BEIRUT (UPI) — Ghassan Kanafani, 34, official spokesman for the extremist Arab guerrilla organization, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), was killed today in a powerful explosion that literally blew him and his car to bits.

Police sources said a bomb apparently went off when Kanafani got into his automobile parked in the ground floor of his apartment building in the Hazmieh suburb of Beirut. Kanafani's 14-year-old niece, Lamice Fayez, also was killed in the blast that shattered windows in the four-story modern building and blasted a foot-deep hole in the concrete garage floor.

A statement issued by the executive committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), of which the Front is a member, said “the martyr-fighter and hero Ghassan Kanafani, one of the leaders of the PFLP and an information expert in the Arab homeland, was martyred this morning as a result of a treacherous assassination incident.” The “assassins” were not identified.

But the Front vowed to avenge Kanafani in a manner “most cruel and most painful.” “All comrades of the martyr can only take an oath on his noble blood to take revenge against all who prepared this operation,” a Front statement said.

“The Popular Front announces...its reply to the enemy this time will be most cruel and most painful...it will be comparable in size to the tragedy that has struck his friends.” (While the “enemy” was not specifically identified, the term is usually used by the Arab guerrillas in reference to Israel.

Arabs had expected some retaliation for the Lod airport massacre of May 30 in which 28 persons were killed and nearly 80 wounded by three Japanese terrorists said to be working for the PFLP.) Kanafani's Danish wife Anna and their two young children, a boy and a girl, were not with him at the time of the blast and were unhurt.

UPI Correspondent David Zenian said Kanafani's home on the first floor of the four-story building was crowded with weeping neighbors and PFLP officials. The neighbors said Mrs. Kanafani was not at home when the explsion occurred but returned later. They said she was taken to a friend's home but they declined to say where.

Zenian said the explosion must have been of considerable power. Kanafani's body was virtually blown to pieces. A hand was found on the roof of a neighboring house and policemen were gathering up the remains.

CP-1972-035 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Bomb in car kills Arab guerrilla chief

BEIRUT (UPI) — Ghassan Kanafani, 34, official spokesman for the extremist Arab guerrilla organization, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), was killed today in a powerful explosion that literally blew him and his car to bits.

Police sources said a bomb apparently went off when Kanafani got into his automobile parked in the ground floor of his apartment building in the Hazmieh suburb of Beirut. Kanafani’s 14-year-old niece, Lamice Fayez, also was killed in the blast that shattered windows in the four-story modern building and blasted a foot-deep hole in the concrete garage floor.

A statement issued by the executive committee of the Palestine Liberation Oorganization (PLO), of which the Front is a member, said “the martyr-fighter and hero Ghassan Kanafani, one of the leaders of the PFLP and an information expert in the Arab homeland, was martyred this morning as a result of a treacherous assassination incident.” The “assassins” were not identified.

But the Front vowed to avenge Kanafani in a manner “most cruel and most painful.” “All comrades of the martyr can only take an oath on his noble blood to take revenge against all who prepared this operation,” a Front statement said.

“The Popular Front announces...its reply to the enemy this time will be most cruel and most painful...it will be comparable in size to the tragedy that has struck his friends.” (While the “enemy” was not specifically identified, the term is usually used by the Arab guerrillas in reference to Israel.

Arabs had expected some retaliation for the Lod airport massacre of May 30 in which 28 persons were killed and nearly 80 wounded by three Japanese terrorists said to be working for the PFLP.) Kanafani’s Danish wife Anna and their two young children, a boy and a girl, were not with him at the time of the blast and were unhurt.

CP-1972-041 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Arab Who Claimed Massacre Credit Dies

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — A Palestinian guerrilla leader was killed here today by bomb booby trap that wrecked his sports car as he started it up. His organization, the Marxist-Leninist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, blamed the Israelis for the killing and vowed to avenge his death with “a most ruthless strike.”

The victim, Ghassan Kanafani, 36, was the chief spokesman for the front, which had accepted responsibility for the Lod airport massacre in Israel and the hijacking of three Western airliners to Jordan in 1970. The blast also killed Kanafani’s niece, Lamiss, 15, who was in the car with him. Kanafani was a novelist well known in the Arab world as well as an editor.

The front statement, calling him a martyr, claimed his death was the Israeli reprisal for the May 30 airport massacre at Tel Aviv because, it said, some Western newspapers had identified Kanafani as the mastermind. Kanafani issued a statement after the massacre in which the front accepted responsibility for the attack.

A high security official claimed Israel has sent unidentified persons from the occupied west bank of the Jordan River to carry out assassinations in retaliation for the May 30 massacre at Tel Aviv airport. Palestinian sources said it could not be ruled out that a dissident faction of the front, or Jordanian agents, were responsible for the blast.

Kanafani, editor of the magazine Al Hadaf, issued statements in the name of the front, including one in May claiming resposibility for the Tel Aviv airport massacre in which 28 persons were killed and scores injured.

CP-1972-042 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Bomb Booby Trap Kills Palestinian Guerrilla Leader

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — A Palestinian guerrilla leader was killed here today by bomb booby trap that wrecked his sports car as he started it up. His organization, the Marxist-Leninist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, blamed the Israelis for the killing and vowed to avenge his death with “a most ruthless strike.”

The victim, Ghassan Kanafani, 36, was the chief spokesman for the front, which had accepted responsibility for the Lod airport massacre in Israel and the hijacking of three Western airliners to Jordan in 1970. The blast also killed Kanafani’s niece, Lamiss, 15, who was in the car with him. Kanafani was a novelist well known in the Arab world as well as an editor.

The front statement, calling him a martyr, claimed his death was the Israeli reprisal for the May 30 airport massacre at Tel Aviv because, it said, some Western newspapers had identified Kanafani as the mastermind. Kanafani issued a statement after the massacre in which the front accepted responsibility for the attack.

CP-1972-045 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Arab Extremist Killed by Bomb Planted in Auto

BEIRUT (UPI) — Ghassan Kanafani, 34, official spokesman for the extremist Arab guerrilla organization, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), was killed today in a powerful explosion that literally blew him and his car to bits.

Police sources said a bomb apparently went off when Kanafani got into his automobile parked in the ground floor of his apartment building in the Hazmieh suburb of Beirut. Kanafani's 14-year-old niece, Lamice Fayez, also was killed in the blast that shattered windows in the four-story modern building and blasted a foot-deep hole in the concrete garage floor.

VOWING AVENGE A statement issued by the executive committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), of which the Front is a member, said “the martyr-fighter and hero Ghassan Kanafani, one of the leaders of the PFLP and an information expert in the Arab homeland, was martyred this morning as a result of a treacherous assassination incident.”

The “assassins” were not identified. But the Front vowed to avenge Kanafani in a manner “most cruel and most painful.” “All comrades of the martyr can only take an oath on his noble blood to take revenge against all who prepared this operation,” a Front statement said.

CP-1972-048 →

· The Flint Journal · Flint · page 1

Israel Accused in Assassination Blast

The Associated Press, Beirut

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine accused Israel of assassinating one of its leaders Saturday and vowed to avenge his death with “a most ruthless strike.” Ghassan Kanafani, 36, was killed by an explosion that demolished his sports car after he turned on the ignition outside his suburban Beirut apartment.

His niece, Lamiss Nejim, 15, also was killed in the blast… “The front vows by his blood to take revenge… The front has proven its ability to pursue the enemy everywhere and inflict painful blows.

We declare our reply this time will be the most ruthless and most painful.”… Guerrillas said Kanafani’s death was a reprisal for the attack because some Western newspapers had described him as its mastermind. Kanafani, editor of the leftist weekly Al Hadaf, was well known in the Middle East as an author of books, short stories and poems, many of them about the plight of the Palestinians.

One collection of stories has been translated into Hebrew.… A military demolition expert estimated that about 10 pounds of dynamite was wired in the exhaust pipe of the brown Austin 1100 car and went off when Kanafani started the car at 11 a.m.

The Associated Press version keeps the novels, the short stories and the poems, and the detail that a collection of them had been translated into Hebrew. The headline is about who is accused.

CP-1972-005 →

· The Sunday Oregonian · Portland · page 1

Mideast guerrillas pledge to revenge chief’s bomb death

The Associated Press, Beirut

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine accused Israel of assassinating one of its leaders Saturday and vowed to avenge his death with “a most ruthless strike.”… Kanafani, a slight, personable intellectual who chain-smoked and carried a revolver, was born in Acre, Palestine, in 1936, but the family moved to Lebanon after the 1948 war.

He was graduated from Damascus University in Syria and taught in Kuwait before returning to Beirut to become a journalist and join the front. He is survived by his mother, his Danish widow Annie and three children.… Leila Khaled, the woman hijacker who failed in an attempt at the same time to hijack an Israeli airliner was a close friend of Kanafani.

She was reported to be in Berlin.

The same Associated Press dispatch as CP-1972-005, run longer and under a different headline. The word this version reaches for is intellectual. He was eleven when his family left Acre.

CP-1972-006 →

· The Star-Ledger · Newark · page 1

Explosion kills leader of Arab terrorist group

United Press International, Beirut

BEIRUT (UPI) — Gassan Kanafani, a leader of the extremist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), was assassinated yesterday when a powerful explosion blew his car to pieces.

His 14-year-old niece also was killed in the blast so powerful it split and partially melted Kanafani’s handgun, scattered bits of metal and flesh over a wide area and left a foot deep hole in a concrete parking lot.

Kanafani was official spokesman and high ranking leader of the front which took “complete responsibility” for the May attack in Israel’s Lod International Airport that killed 27 civilians… A statement by the executive committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) of which the front is a member, said: “The martyr-fighter and hero Gassan Kanafani, one of the leaders of the PFLP and an information expert in the Arab homeland, was martyred this morning as a result of a treacherous assassination incident.”… He was married to a Dane, Anna, and had two young children — a boy and a girl… The girl who died, Lamice Fayez, was the daughter of Kanafani’s sister and had been visiting the Kanafani’s with her mother at the time.

“Gassan Kanafani, Palestinian guerrilla leader killed by a bomb in Beirut, Lebanon” · Associated Press Wirephoto

The hardest headline of the five this archive holds for the same killing. Set beside the Anchorage Daily Times of two days later, the range runs from artist to terrorist over one man in one week. This version spells him Gassan and, like the other United Press copy here, does not mention that he wrote novels.

CP-1972-008 →

· Greensboro Daily News · Greensboro · page 1

Palestinian Guerrilla Is Slain

Vengeance Vowed By Popular Front

The Associated Press, Beirut

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine accused Israel of assassinating one of its leaders Saturday and vowed to avenge his death with “a most ruthless strike.” Ghassan Kanafani, 36, was killed by an explosion that demolished his sports car after he turned on the ignition outside his suburban Beirut apartment.

His niece, Lamiss Nejim, 15, also was killed in the blast… Kanafani, editor of the leftist weekly Al Hadaf, was well known in the Middle East as an author of books, short stories and poems, many of them about the plight of the Palestinians.

One collection of stories has been translated into Hebrew.… Kanafani, a slight, personable intellectual who chainsmoked and carried a revolver, was born in Acre, Palestine, in 1936, but the family moved to Lebanon after the 1948 war.

He was graduated from Damascus University in Syria and taught in Kuwait before returning to Beirut to become a journalist and join the front. He is survived by his mother, his Danish widow Annie and three children.

“Ghassan Kanafani”

The sixth printing of this killing in the archive and the sixth different headline. The photograph carries his name and nothing else. One of the six, in Anchorage, called him an artist.

CP-1972-009 →

· The Sunday Star-Bulletin & Advertiser · Honolulu · page 1

bomb in car kills Kanafani

Popular Front spokesman

Jim Hoagland, Washington Post Service, Beirut

BEIRUT — Ghassan Kanafani, 26-year-old Palestinian revolutionary and spokesman for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, one of the most violently inclined radical organizations in the world, gently reproved a friend last week who expressed concern over Kanafani’s safety.

“I am determined not to be assassinated,” Kanafani said. But he continued to move about Beirut without any special security precautions, despite speculation that reprisals might be taken against officials of his group for the killing of 26 persons May 30 at Tel Aviv’s Lod Airport. KANAFANI’S reassuring words were erased yesterday by a bomb blast that instantly killed the quiet intellectual. The bomb exploded at about 10:30 a.m. when Kanafani turned on the ignition of his small, British-made automobile outside his home in the Beirut suburb of Hazmiya. Kanafani’s 19-year-old niece, Lamis Najem, a passenger in the car, was also killed. Lebanese police said they were investigating the blast.

Kanafani’s revolutionary colleagues in the PFLP immediately issued a statement that asserted that “the imperialist Zionist camp” was behind the assassination, whoever may have actually planted the bomb… LOCAL SECURITY officials would not rule out the possibility that Kanafani’s murder may have been connected with internal antagonisms and competition within the Palestinian movement, although they stressed that there was no evidence of this immediately available.… Some Palestinians blame the Popular Front for provoking the clashes between the guerrillas and the Jordanian army that resulted in the guerrillas being expelled from Jordan after heavy Palestinian losses last year.

The Popular Front’s spectacular airliner hijackings and its political consistency had been winning increasing support among young Palestinians, however, and producing a more radical movement within Al Fatah… Sitting in his office at Al Hadaf, a weekly news opinion magazine he published and edited, Kanafani two weeks ago defended the attack on Lod as necessary to the PFLP.

He dismissed criticism from the West and from among some moderate Palestinians as an “unscientific, unmoral reaction that condemns only us and ignores other tragedies, especially those committed by Israel.”

“Only rubble remains of car in which Kanafani died.” · UPI Photo

The eighth American printing of this killing held here and the fullest, filed by a Washington Post correspondent in Beirut. It is also the one that complicates him most: two weeks before he died he sat in his own magazine office and defended the Lod airport attack, in which twenty-six people were killed, and dismissed criticism of it. The clipping stays whole for that reason. It carries one line nobody else has — a friend worried about his safety the week before, and Kanafani answering, I am determined not to be assassinated. The phrase this reporter reaches for is the quiet intellectual. Across the eight printings the archive holds, his age is given as 34, 36 and here 26, and his niece’s as 14, 15 and here 19.

CP-1972-011 →

· The Mobile Register · Mobile · page 1

Palestinian Guerrilla Leader Dies In Blast

Harry Dunphy, Associated Press Writer, Beirut

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine accused Israel of assassinating one of its leaders Saturday and vowed to avenge his death with “a most ruthless strike.” Ghassan Kanafani, 36, was killed by an explosion that demolished his sports car after he turned on the ignition outside his suburban Beirut apartment.

His niece, Lamiss Nejim, 15, also was killed in the blast. A statement issued by the Marxist-Leninist Front mourned the “martydom” of Kanafani and declared, “No matter who did it, the origin is the imperialist-Zionist-reactionary enemy camp”… Kanafani, the front’s “information commissar” or spokesman and member of its Politburo, announced the front’s responsibility for the Tel Aviv airport, massacre May 30, in which three Japanese trained gunmen, by the front, killed 28 persons, and wounded scores more.

Guerrillas said Kanafani’s death was a reprisal for the attack because some Western newspapers had described him as its mastermind. Kanafani, editor of the leftist weekly Al Hadaf, was well known in the Middle East as an author of books, short stories and poems, many of them about the plight of the Palestinians.

One collection of stories has been translated into Hebew.… The possibility that a group that had split with the front earlier this year was involved was not ruled out.

A military demolitoin expert estimated that about 10 pounds of dynamite was wired in the exhaust pipe of the brown Austin 1100 car and went off when Kanafani started the car at 11 a.m. The car hit the overhang of the building under which it was parked and landed 50 feet away, police said.

The blast blew in doors and shattered windows in the middle-class neighborhood of Hazmieh, southeast of Beirut.

Police said Kanafani returned home after midnight and the device was planted sometime during the night. A high-ranking government security official said “suspicious elements” had been inquiring about various front leaders in recent weeks, but he refused to elaborate… Leila Khaled, the woman hijacker who failed in an attempt at the same time to hijack an Israeli airliner was a close friend of Kanafani.

She was reported to be in Berlin.

A portrait, captioned simply “KANAFANI”.

The ninth American printing of this killing held here, the fullest of the Associated Press versions, and the only one carrying his photograph. It gives both halves of him without deciding between them: the front’s information commissar, who announced its responsibility for the Lod airport attack, and an author of books, short stories and poems, one collection of which had been translated into Hebrew. The paper’s spellings, martydom, demolitoin and Hebew, are kept. Ten pounds of dynamite in the exhaust pipe, planted after he got home past midnight.

CP-1972-012 →

· Democrat and Chronicle · Rochester · page 1

Bomb Kills Leader, Arabs Vow Revenge

The Associated Press, Beirut

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine accused Israel of assassinating one of its leaders yesterday and vowed to avenge his death with “a most ruthless strike.”

Ghassan Kanafani, 36, was killed by an explosion that demolished his sports car after he turned on the ignition outside his suburban Beirut apartment. His niece, Lamis Ndjim, 15, also was killed in the blast.… Kanafani, the Front’s “information commissar” or spokesman and member of its Politburo, announced the Front’s responsibility for the Tel Aviv airport massacre May 30, in which three Japanese gunmen, trained by the Front, killed 28 persons, and wounded scores more… Kanafani, editor of the leftist weekly Al Hadaf, was well known in the Middle East as an author of books, short stories and poems, many of them about the plight of the Palestinians.

One collection of stories has been translated into Hebrew.… A military demolition expert estimated that about 10 pounds of dynamite was wired in the exhaust pipe of the brown Austin 1100 car and went off when Kanafani started the car at 11 a.m.… Kanafani, a slight, personable intellectual who chain-smoked and carried a revolver, was born in Acre, Palestine, in 1936, but the family moved to Lebanon after the 1948 war.

He was graduated from Damascus University in Syria and taught in Kuwait turning to Beirut to become a journalist and join the front. He is survived by his mother, his Danish widow Annie and three children.… Leila Khaled, the woman hijacker who failed in an attempt at the same time to hijack an Israeli airliner was a close friend of Kanafani.

She reported to be in Berlin.

“GHASSAN KANAFANI”

The tenth American printing of this killing held here. It carries the fullest life: born in Acre in 1936, the family leaving for Lebanon after the 1948 war, Damascus University, teaching in Kuwait, then Beirut and journalism. He was eleven or twelve when they left. It also gives the fifteen-year-old girl who died beside him a fourth spelling. Across the ten printings she is Lamiss Nejim, Lamice Fayez, Lamis Najem and here Lamis Ndjim, and her age is given as fourteen, fifteen and nineteen. Ten American newspapers reported her death in one week and could not agree what she was called.

CP-1972-013 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Assassin's Bomb Kills Arab Terrorist Leader

BEIRUT (UPI) — An assassin's bomb Saturday took the life of Gassan Kanafani, a leader of the Arab guerrilla group that claimed “complete responsibility” for the May massacre at Israel's Lod International airport. An estimated 11 pounds of explosives literally blew Kanafani to pieces. His 14-year-old niece who was with him also was killed.

The blast was so powerful it split and partially melted Kanafani's handgun, scattered bits of metal and flesh over a wide area and left a foot-deep hole in a concrete parking lot.

KANAFANI was the official spokesman and a high-ranking leader of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), which took “complete responsibility” for the attack at Lod airport that killed 27 civilians.

Shortly after the front announced that the three Japanese men who indiscriminately sprayed Lod airport with bullets and handgrenades were working under PFLP orders, the group's leaders disappeared from their usual Beirut haunts, apparently in fear of Israeli retaliation.

A statement by the executive committee of the Palestine Liberation organization (PLO) of which the front is a member, said: “The martyr-fighter and hero Gassan Kanafani, one of the leaders of the PFLP and an information expert in the Arab homeland, was martyred this morning as a result of a treacherous assassination incident.”

THE ORGANIZATION said the incident encouraged its members to “continue on the road of revolution until victory and liberation.” Kanafani was ranked fourth or fifth in the movement, according to sources close to the PFLP. He was married to a Dane, Anna, and had two young children — a boy and a girl.

They were not near the explosion, which took place in the ground floor parking lot directly under Kanafani's apartment in the Hazmieh suburb of Beirut. The girl who died, Lamice Fayez, was the daughter of Kanafani's sister and had been visiting the Kanafani's with her mother at the time.

THE PLO statement said “the fall of a leader will not stop the will of fighters but will only increase their capabilities to continue on the road of revolution until victory and liberation.” The Middle East news agency quoted police experts as saying 11 pounds of explosives and some plastic bombs were placed in the car and exploded when Kanafani switched on the engine.

KANAFANI

CP-1972-038 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Assassin’s Blast Kills Palestine Extremist

BEIRUT (UPI)—Gassan Kanafani, a leader of the extremist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), was assassinated Saturday when a powerful explosion blew his car to pieces.

His 14-year-old niece also was killed in the blast so powerful it split and partially melted Kanafani’s handgun, scattered bits of metal and flesh over a wide area and left a foot deep hole in a concrete parking lot.

Kanafani was official spokesman and a high ranking leader of the front which took “complete responsibility” for the May attack at Israel’s Lod International Airport that killed 27 civilians.

Shortly after the front announced that the three Japanese men who indiscriminately sprayed Lod Airport with bullets and handgrenades were working under PFLP orders, the group’s leaders disappeared from their usual Beirut haunts, apparently in fear of Israeli retaliation.

A statement by the executive committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) of which the front is a member, said: “The martyr-fighter and hero Gassan Kanafani, one of the leaders of the PFLP and an information expert in the Arab homeland, was martyred this morning as a result of a treacherous assassination incident.”

The organization said the incident encouraged its members to “continue on the road of revolution until victory and liberation.” Kanafani was ranked fourth or fifth in the movement, according to sources close to the PFLP. He was married to a Dane, Anna, and had two young children—a boy and a girl.

They were not near the explosion, which took place in the ground floor parking lot directly under Kanafani’s apartment in the Hazmieh suberb of Beirut. The girl who died, Lamice Fayez, was the daughter of Kanafani’s sister and had been visiting the Kanafani’s with her mother at the time.

The PLO statement said “the fall of a leader will not stop the will of fighters but will only increase their capabilities to continue on the road of revolution until victory and liberation.”

CP-1972-046 →

· Daytona Beach Morning Journal · Daytona Beach · page 1

Palestinian Guerrillas Vow To Avenge Kanafani Killing

The Associated Press, Beirut

BEIRUT (AP) — Palestinian guerrilla groups here vowed Sunday to avenge the killing of Ghassan Kanafani by dealing “ruthless blows” at the Israelis. In Tel Aviv, Israeli authorities denied involvement in the death of the Arab guerrilla official in his booby-trapped car.

They claimed the killing was linked to the mailing of “parcels containing bombs to personalities in Israel and abroad.” Kanafani, 36, was a spokesman for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine — PFLP — and editor of the leftist magazine Al Hadaf. He was killed Saturday by a bomb explosion when he started his car.

The funeral is scheduled for Monday afternoon. Beirut newspapers bannered such headlines as “Israel Did It,” and “Zionist and Imperialist Agents Killed Kanafani.” The PFLP issued a statement saying, “Our revenge this time will be proportionate to our bereavement…Our reply to the enemy will be most ruthless and most painful.” The Palestinian news agency WAFA claimed investigators at the scene of the explosion had found a slip of paper bearing an image of the Israeli Menorah candelabrum and another reading, in English: “With the compliments of the Israeli Embassy in Copenhagen.”

A police spokesman in Tel Aviv said the slips did not prove Israeli involvement.

He observed that Kanafani was married to a Danish woman, and it could have been easy to obtain a slip from the embassy there. He said Israeli law agencies had warned last week of a possible renewed spate of mailed bombs similar to those of last December. The Israeli press called Kanafani’s death “an outcome of his own deeds,” and denied Israeli involvement. But Yasir Arafat, head of the Palestine Liberation Organization said: “We must be fully alert against Zionist criminal conspiracies aimed at destroying our very existence.”… The Lebanese government said it was investigating the assassination.

The seventh American printing of this killing held here, and the seventh headline. One of the seven called him an artist. This version, like the two United Press ones, gives his occupation as spokesman and editor and does not mention that he wrote novels. It is the only one that carries the slip of paper the Palestinian news agency said was found at the scene, printed in English with the compliments of an embassy, and the Israeli press describing his death as an outcome of his own deeds.

CP-1972-010 →

· The New York Times

Arafat Says Killing of Guerrilla Heralds New Blows at Israel

Special to The New York Times

BEIRUT, Lebanon, July 9 — Yasir Arafat, the Palestinian guerrilla leader, said today that the assassination yesterday of a prominent leader of the Marxist commando group known as the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine was the beginning of “a new stage” in the warfare between the guerrillas and Israel. In a statement published here, Mr.

Arafat said that the murder of the front’s former spokesman, Ghassan Kanafani, “is a sign of a new development in the struggle introduced by Israel.” The guerrilla movement, the leader asserted, “must retaliate with painful blows that will shake the entire Israeli society.” Mr. Arafat is the leader of Al Fatah, the largest guerrilla organization.

He is also the chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, which embraces the main guerrilla factions, including the Popular Front. Niece Died With Him The Popular Front swore yesterday to exact “strong and cruel” revenge for Mr. Kanafani’s assassination. It happened in the parking lot of the apartment building in a Beirut suburb where Mr.

Kanafani lived with his wife and their two children. He and his 17-year-old niece, Lamis Najem, had just gotten into Mr. Kanafani’s car and it exploded when he tried to start it. While the Lebanese investigation of the assassination continued today under a cloak of secrecy, commando sources insisted that Israeli intelligence agents were behind the killing.

They reported that “evidence” had been found at the scene of the blast, and described it as a piece of paper bearing the official Israeli emblem of candelabrum and the following sentence, written in English: “With the compliments of the Israeli Embassy in Copenhagen.”

Israel Sees Guerrilla Plot TEL AVIV, July 9 — An Israeli police spokesman said today that the police believed that the bomb explosion in Beirut that killed an Arab guerrilla leader yesterday was connected with a terrorist plot to send parcels containing bombs to Israelis.

Superintendent Mordecai Tavor, spokesman for National Police Headquarters in Jerusalem, said the police had reason to believe that the victim, Ghassan Kanafini, had been in possession of bomb parcels or material for bomb parcels when he was killed as his car exploded.

The guerrillas, the spokesman said, had planned to attach to the parcels cards bearing the Israeli coat of arms and the inscription, “With the compliments of the Israeli Embassy in Copenhagen.” Mr. Tavor said that the card found in Beirut was a type commonly attached by the Copenhagen embassy to its invitations and publicity material. He noted that Mr.

Kanafani’s brother was living in Denmark. Newspapers here did not discount the suggestion that there was an Israeli hand in the assassination.

CP-1972-030 →

· Los Angeles Times · page 21 (Part I)

Bomb Victim Had Expected Death

BY WILLIAM J. COUGHLIN

BEIRUT — Ghassan Kanafani, the Marxist Palestinian leader who died here Saturday in a bomb explosion that demolished his car in typical gangland style, had a premonition he would be assassinated by the Israelis.

He told an interviewer recently he expected the Israelis to retaliate for the Lod International Airport massacre by killing the leaders of the Palestinian guerrilla movement rather than by a massive counterassault such as the December, 1968, attack on Beirut Airport “Our organization is thoroughly infiltrated by Israeli spies,” he acknowledged.

“They know who we are and where we are at all times.” The death of Kanafani was believed by members of the extremist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, for which he was spokesman, to be the first of a series of assassinations planned by the Israelis in retaliation for the Lod Airport terrorism.

Tied to Possible Feud That belief corresponded to information reaching here from the Israeli side. But it also was possible that Kanafani might have been slain as a result of feuding within the strife-torn PFLP itself, the most active and second largest to Fatah of the fedayeen groups.

The already splintered PFLP split again recently when an antihijacking faction broke away from the leadership of Dr. George Habash and the group which Kanafani represented. Many officials of the PFLP left their homes in Beirut and went underground after the Lod Airport attack on May 30 which killed 27 persons and wounded 78, many of them Puerto Rican pilgrims.

Kanafani, however, continued to be available to foreign correspondents here in his role as official spokesman for the front and as editor and publisher of the PFLP weekly, Al Hadaf. He claimed credit for the PFLP for the Lod Airport attack and boldly defended it.

Writers Denounced Saturday's issue of Al Hadaf denounced Western correspondents based here for reporting that some Palestinians were horrified by the Lod massacre.

Ironically, Kanafani will be buried in Beirut today, the same day that Kozo Okamoto, the only survivor of the three Japanese who shot up Lod Airport, goes on trial in Israel Kanafani and his 1[5 or 6]-year-old niece, Lamice Najem, died in a shattering explosion just after they got into his car in the garage beneath his apartment in the Beirut suburb of Harmiyah.

Police believed the blast was caused by 11 pounds of plastic explosives which detonated when Kanafani switched on the ignition.

CP-1972-034 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Egyptian Forces Termed Near Point Of 'Undeclared Rebellion'

By United Press International

The respected weekly An Nahar Arab Report said Sunday the Egyptian armed forces are on the point of open rebellion and President Anwar Sadat's efforts to reassert his authority seems doomed to failure.

The weekly, which is published in Beirut and is reported to have reliable sources in the various Arab capitals, gave no specific reason for the unrest but said it “has has reached the point of undeclared rebellion,” particularly in the air force.

Unofficial reports from Cairo said the armed forces were becoming increasingly disenchanted with government policy after five years of a no-war, no-peace situation. The semiofficial Egyptian Middle East News Agency (MENA) reported the arrival in Cairo Sunday of Syrian President Hafez Assad from Moscow with a Soviet pledge to strengthen his armed forces.

Sadat was at the airport to greet Assad, who, official sources said, would brief the Egyptian leader on details of his four days of talks with the Kremlin leadership. Funeral services were scheduled to be held Monday in Beirut for Gassan Kanafani, 36, a radical Palestinian leader who was killed Saturday when a bomb exploded in his car.

A 14-year-old niece also died in what Arabs denounced as an “assassination.” Kanafani was official spokesman for the extremist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) guerrilla organization which claimed “complete responsibility” for the Japanese terrorist attack on Israel's Lod International Airport on May 30.

The trial of Kozo Okamolo, sole survivor of the three-man Japanese death squad that killed 26 persons and wounded scores more, is scheduled to begin in Israel on Monday. He faces four charges, three of which are punishable by death.

The English-language newspaper Daily Star of Beirut said “there appears to be enough ground to justify the charge made by the Popular Front...that Israel and the Zionists are behind the assassination...”

Most Beirut newspapers carried reports from the Palestine News Agency that a card bearing the inscription “with the compliments of the Embassy of Israel, Copenhagen” was found near the site of the explosion.

CP-1972-039 →

· Anchorage Daily Times · Anchorage · page 1

Kanafani: The Artist Who Turned Revolutionary

Mike Doogan, Times Staff Writer

“Editor’s Note: Times staff writer Mike Doogan spent the summer of 1970 in the Middle East studying the situation of Palestinian refugges and guerrilla organizations as preparation for a model United Nations meeting held in San Francisco in November.

The following are his remembrances of Ghassan Kanafani, guerrilla spokesman, editor and novelist who was killed in a booby trapped car in Beirut, Lebanon last Friday… Ghassan Kanafani came in out of the afternoon sun looking like a man who had been dragged through a strainer.

His green sport shirt and tan pants were rumpled and sweat stained and there were stress lines running from the corners of his dark eyes toward his short sideburns. ‘I must apologize for being late,’ he said as he moved around the scarred wooden desk and slouched into a swivel chair behind it, ‘but I have been extraordinarily busy.

Last night someone tried to kill a man in our organization and we have been looking for him.’… ‘telling was not enough. So I joined the Front and work on the newspaper. I work where I am most effective, but I will fight too. We all fight.’

He was serious about the fighting but he had no illusions about it. ‘I carry a gun you know,’ he said and produced a black automatic from a pocket. He set it down on the table and looked at it. ‘I can see what will happen when they come for me. I’ll say, “Wait a minute” and try to get the gun out.

They’ll shoot me full of holes while I am trying to get the gun out.’ He was laughing and so were his dinner companions. ‘It will make headlines in all the papers: “Ghassan Kanafani got caught with his pants up but his gun down”.’… The woman, dressed entirely in black, sat on the curb, begging.

She had been driven from her home in southern Lebanon by the continued fighting between fedayin and Israelis and the resultant collapse of the area’s chronically depressed economy… ‘That’s why we struggle,’ Kanafani said, gesturing at the woman with the end of one in a chain of smoldering cigarettes, ‘we struggle for these people and the people in the (refugee) camps.’

He turned back into the room. ‘I would rather have peace,’ he said. ‘I would rather have the time to spend with my family, my wife and daughter, and my writing. But because of these people, we must continue the struggle.’ He shrugged and sat with the cigarette dangling from his lips.

‘Please,’ he said to a visitor who was fingering an antipersonnel grenade of Eastern European manufacture, ‘put that down carefully. Out of all my decorations, you are now handling the one that is not deactivated and we could all be gravely inconvenienced. I don’t have time to be blown up, I have too much to do.’”

Ten American papers in this archive carried his killing. This is the only one whose headline calls him an artist. Two years before the car bomb he acted out for a reporter how they would come for him, and made a joke about what the headline would say. The headlines said Arab militant leader, and guerrilla chief, and one of its leaders. The paper’s own spelling, refugges, is kept.

CP-1972-007 →

· The New York Times

9 Injured in Explosion at Tel Aviv Bus Terminal

Associated Press

TEL AVIV, July 11 (AP) — A grenade exploded in the central bus terminal here today, injuring nine persons, none seriously. Soldiers struggled to prevent angry bystanders from attacking Arabs in the area. The explosion, in a men’s room, blew out a wall and window, showering the street with glass and masonry.

Security men and the police surrounded the area and set up road blocks around Tel Aviv. About 100 Arabs were detained for questioning. The blast site was 10 miles from the heavily armed army base where a Japanese, Kozo Okamoto, is being tried for his part in the international airport massacre of May 30.

The explosion was the fourth known act of sabotage in the vicinity of the bus station since the 1967 Middle East war. The worst was in November, 1970, when explosions killed 2 persons and wounded 24. It was the second bus station explosion in Israel in two weeks.

Last week an explosive device went off prematurely in the station in Netanya and wounded an Arab from the occupied West Bank sector of Jordan. Group Takes Responsibility BEIRUT, Lebanon, July 11 (Reuters) — The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine said here tonight that it was responsible for the explosion.

A spokesman said it was a reprisal for the death of a commando leader, Ghassan Kanafani, who was killed when an explosion destroyed his car outside his home here Saturday.

Policemen in Tel Aviv taking an Arab into custody after a grenade exploded in a washroom of the central bus terminal, injuring nine persons. A number of Arabs were held for questioning after the incident.

CP-1972-031 →

· The New York Times

Israel Intensifying Settlement of Seized Territories

By PETER GROSE

JERUSALEM, July 24—The Government of Israel is quietly intensifying the establishment of new settlements in the lands captured from the Arab countries in the 1967 war.

Israel Galili, one of Premier Golda Meir’s most influential confidants, made a brief statement to this effect in the parliament last week, but it was little noticed amid the intense discussions here and abroad of Cairo’s moves to reduce the Soviet presence in Egypt. “Israel will leave no vacuum in these areas,” said Mr.

Galili, who holds the title Minister Without Portfolio. “No area is out of bounds to Jewish settlement.” Then, apparently in an attempt to deflect charges that he was proclaiming the policy of “expansionism” that the Arab countries have asserted Israel pursues, Mr.

Galili said that Jewish settlement would be limited by the “sensibilities and needs of the local inhabitants”— meaning Arabs— and that other “national needs” of Israel often took higher priority than establishing Jewish settlements.

The minister disclosed that 44 new communities for Israeli settlers had been founded since the 1967 war in the occupied territories, the last one only three weeks ago. Fifteen of these are on the Golan heights, captured from Syria, 15 are on the West Bank of the Jordan River, and 14 are in Sinai and the Gaza Strip, formerly administered by Egypt.

Israel’s ambiguous policy on settlement has been criticized inside and outside Israel since the first weeks after the war ended. Arabs and many foreign officials and commentators have challenged Israel’s right to settle in these captured territories at all on the ground that, at the least, settlement precludes eventual withdrawal.

More recently, the hard-line Opposition parties in Israel have become more vocal in criticizing Mrs. Meir’s Government for failure to establish settlements in the new territories quickly enough. It was in response to a motion from the Opposition that Mr. Galili made his remarks in parliament.

The Opposition Gahal bloc is strongly opposed to any withdrawal and fears that the Government is holding open the possibility of an eventual pullback.

Military and civilian authorities usually say that the new Israeli settlements fall into three categories: Those like East Jerusalem and Sharm el Sheik, at the southern end of the Sinai Peninsula, which the Government says openly will not be relinquished even after a peace treaty is negotiated.

Settlements such as the Orthodox Jewish religious community in the West Bank city of Hebron, where Israel expects Jews to live permanently, if necessary as foreign residents if sovereignty is returned to an Arab government.

Exclusively military settlements, to assist in border security as long as Israel holds the present cease-fire lines but which presumably could be abandoned in the event of a negotiated withdrawal. The ambiguity—and officials concede that it is deliberate — is that no Government spokesman has ever designated into which of the categories each settlement is placed.

CP-1972-027 →

· The New York Times · page 7

A Bomb in Beirut Injures New Aide of Guerrilla Unit

Associated Press

BEIRUT, Lebanon, July 25, (AP) — A parcel exploded today in the Beirut office of a leftist newspaper, Al Hadaf, seriously injuring the new spokesman for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, the police said. The spokesman, Bassam Abu Sharif, who is 29 years old, suffered severe injuries in the face and chest, the police said.

The bomb reportedly exploded while he was opening the package. Mr. Abu Sharif became the spokesman for the Marxist guerilla group after Ghassan Kanafani, the former spokesman and editor of Al Hadaf, was killed by a bomb explosion in Beirut on July 8 when he started his car.

Al Hadaf, a weekly, is the organ of the Popular Front, which said it sponsored the three Japanese terrorists who killed 24 persons and wounded 74 persons, two of whom later died, in the Tel Aviv airport massacre on May 30. A Palestinian writer and a Lebanese bank employe were injured in booby-trap explosions in Beirut last week.

Five other parcels with bombs addressed to Palestinian guerilla leaders are reported to have been intercepted and defused.

CP-1972-032 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Israel Tries 2 Arab Women in Hijacking

By HENRY KAMM, Special to The New York Times

RISHON LE ZION, Israel, Aug. 1 — Two young Arab women accused of participating in the hijacking in May of a Sabena airliner bound for the Tel Aviv airport went on trial today before a military tribunal.

Two men, the principals in the act of piracy, were shot to death when Israeli troops stormed aboard the Boeing 707 at the airport, in an operation directed by Defense Minister Moshe Dayan. A young Israeli woman died later of wounds she suffered in the assault.

The plane, seized during a scheduled flight from Brussels to Tel Aviv, landed at its destination on the hijackers’ orders. In return for its release, the hijackers demanded the freeing of about 300 Arab terrorists from Israeli prisons. They threatened to blow up the plane and its passengers if their demand was not met.

The women defendants — Rima Issa Tannous, 21 years old, and Therese Halasseh, 18—faced the three-member court, including a woman major, in the same barracks at the Sarafand army camp where last month Kozo Okamoto was sentenced to life imprisonment for his part in the airport massacre by Japanese terrorists on May 30.

The two women pleaded not guilty to a four-count indictment without, however, challenging the accuracy of the account of the acts of which they are accused. Their court-appointed lawyers made evident that they intended to concede the essentials of the prosecution’s version of the dramatic events in midair and in the long hours on the ground preceding the final shoot-out.

Therese Halasseh, left, and Rima Issa Tannous listening to the charges read against them yesterday at their trial in Rishon le Zion, Israel. They were accused of taking part in the hijacking of a jet in May. [credit] Associated Press

Date check: No masthead or folio line survives on this clipping; the top edge carries only the bottoms of lines from the stories above (“a national scandal, a case” / “away from Bruay, and when the” / “Brigitte.” When a man with”). The credit line under the byline reads “Special to The New York Times”, agreeing with `pub`. The dateline reads “RISHON LE ZION, Israel, Aug. 1” and the photo caption says the charges were read “yesterday”, both consistent with publication on 1972-08-02, but no date appears on the scan.

CP-1972-025 →

· The New York Times · New York

18 Israeli Arabs Seized at Village

“Eighteen Israeli Arabs were arrested today as they tried to reoccupy the village of Berem on the Lebanese frontier… The former residents of Berem have recently staged protests against the Government’s refusal to return them to their village, from which they were evicted in 1948 during Israel’s war of independence.”

Henry Kamm. Bir’im — Berem here — was emptied in 1948 on a promise of two weeks. Twenty-four years later its people are arrested for walking back into it, and the paper calls them Israeli Arabs, which is to say citizens of the state that will not let them go home.

CP-1972-021 →

· The Union (Grass Valley, California) · page 1

Israelic warplanes bomb 2 bridges

By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

Israeli warplanes bombed two bridges across Lebanon’s Litani River and ground troops launched a massive assault on Palestinian commandos inside that neighboring nation today. The Lebanese government declared a state of emergency throughout the country. The Cabinet went into session to consider asking for a meeting of the U.N. Security Council.

The parliament scheduled a meeting tonight to debate the attack. “The Lebanese army is doing its utmost to defend the homeland,” declared Prime Minister Saeb Salam. But he noted the superiority of the Israeli forces.

The warplanes hit the Elhardala and Aquiya bridges, which linked southern Lebanon — where thousands of guerrillas are encamped — to Nabatiye, a commandc headquarters also bombed by Israeli planes. On the ground, tanks and half-tracks swept through 13 Arab villages, destroying dozens of houses harboring guerrillas, an Israeli spokesman said.

The bombing of the bridges was seen as a bid to block the guerrillas’ escape routes from the Israelis, goaded into action by the Munich massacre and two recent attacks on the Lebanese border.

Six hours after the dawn raid began, the Tel Aviv spokesman said Israeli forces were 12 miles inside Lebanon, had suffered one man killed and killed or captured “several guerrillas”, and had clashed with the Lebanese army. But he denied reports the Lebanese forces had managed to hold off the attackers. “Everything is going according to plan,” he said.

Earlier, the spokesman named 10 villages hit. To this list he later added three more, indicating a northeastward thrust to the Israeli raid.

Commenting on Arab claims that Israeli planes bombed a Palestinian refugee camp near Nabatiye, the spokesman charged the aircraft hit a guerrilla headquarters “which was probably placed near the refugee camp in the hope of gaining additional security from bombing.”

CP-1972-058 →

· Pueblo Chieftain · Pueblo · page 1

Berem Arabs Demanding To Return to Former Home

Marcus Eliason, Associated Press, Berem, Israel

BEREM, Israel (AP) — Twenty-four years ago, with war raging in the Middle East, an Israeli army officer drove into this Arab village and ordered its 800 inhabitants to leave. He promised they could return “in a short time” after the Israelis had cleared the nearby border with Lebanon of mines and enemy pockets. The Arabs claim the officer said 15 days.

But when the villagers tried to return to Berem they were blocked by Israeli troops. They appealed to the Israeli Supreme Court, which ordered their return home on the grounds no formal expulsion order had been issued. The army hurriedly wrote out the orders and dodged the court ruling. Then, in 1955, the Israel Defense Forces blew up every house in the village.

The Arabs were given alternative housing nearby and each subsequent request to return to Berem was rejected “on security grounds.” It seemed like the end of the affair. Now Berem is back in the news, haunting Israelis at the highest level.

It Happens Again. Berem — along with the villagers of neighboring Iqrit who suffered the same fate — appears to be a replay of the murky, time worn controversy over what really happened in 1948: were the Arabs expelled by the Israelis to make way for the Jewish state, or did the indigenous Arabs obey the orders of their leaders to evacuate for the invading Arab armies?

The Israelis have said the Arabs in 1948 abandoned their homes when they ran away from the fighting. The Arabs claimed they were ordered out by the Israelis who feared a large Arab population inside the burgeoning Jewish state. This argument will be at the center of any agreement reached on the return of the Arab refugees to Israel or on payment of indemnity.

The Israeli government says it has kept Berem empty because its proximity to the Lebanese border could provide shelter for Arab guerrillas attacking Israel. There have been dozens of incidents in the area in the past three years, including an attack on an Israeli bus near Berem that killed 12 school children.

Demands Renewed. Now, Berem and Iqrit residents once again are pressing their demand to return home…

Jewish Supporters. What has helped the villagers stir favorable public opinion is that the Beremites are of the Maronite Catholic faith, remembered here for the solid support it voiced for European Jewry under Hitler.

The Beremites also proved their allegiance to Israel by testifying in favor of the Jews to various British committees that sought a peaceful settlement of the Palestine problem in the 1940s. The Rev.

Kemal Farah, 29-year-old spiritual leader of Berem, rejects Israel’s argument on security, pointing out that displaced villagers have been resettled in Gush Halav, only two miles east of Berem and equally accessible to infiltrators. Today, Berem is a heap of rubble, overgrown by wild grapevines. Next to it stands the remains of a third-century Jewish synagogue.

The synagogue has been fenced in and a small park built for tourists. But the signposting says nothing about a Christian village or church, and foreign visitors have no idea that 24 years ago people lived on the hill.

Part of Berem’s 3,000 acres of farmland row belong to Jewish settlements, Israel’s attorney general, Meir Shamgar, says ample compensation was offered the villagers, but only six out of 90 families accepted. The six received a total of some $50,000, plus 10 building plots and farm acreage equal to what they owned in Berem.

Despite the government decision not to allow them to return, the Beremites have vowed to fight on. “We have owned this land for 600 years,” said Riad Suliman.

Kafr Bir’im, the village the Batrice family came from — a photograph of its ruins runs with the 2021 Courier-Journal column in this archive, forty-nine years later. The villagers are Maronite Catholics. The paper sets both accounts of 1948 side by side and says the argument will decide any settlement on the refugees. The archive holds this village three times: 1972, 1973 and 2021.

CP-1972-001 →

· The New York Times

Bonn Bans 2 Palestinian Organizations

By DAVID BINDER

BONN, Oct. 4 — West Germany announced today that it had banned two Palestinian organizations because they had threatened violence here. The prohibition on the General Union of Palestinian Students, with 800 listed members, and the General Union of Palestinian Workers, with 1,000 members, was disclosed by Interior Minister Hans-Dietrich Genscher.

It was one of a series of increasingly severe measures taken to control Arabs residing here since the raid in Munich by eight Arab terrorists on Sept. 5 that led to the killing of 11 members of the Israeli Olympic team.

The Interior Minister disclosed that “well under 100 Arabs” had been expelled from West Germany since then on suspicion of links with Palestinian terrorists, and that 1,990 Arab travelers had been turned back at border-crossing points for lack of proper papers or on suspicion of unacceptable connections.

There are 50,000 legally registered Arabs living and working in West Germany. It is believed that 10,000 more live in the country without having registered. Among those expelled in the last four weeks was Abdullah Hassan Yums el-Frangi, the 30-year-old chief of the Palestinian Student Union, who was one of eight Arabs taken into custody and deported Sept. 27.

CP-1972-033 →

· The New York Times · New York

Mideast Tensions Afflicting the Arab Communities Here

“The alien registration last January signed up only 6,600 citizens of Arab countries in the city — far short of the evident reality. It listed, for example, only 39 Palestinians… only those who left before the British mandate expired in 1948 hold Palestinian papers.”

John L. Hess on Atlantic Avenue a month after Munich, among the bakeries and the Arabic press — Fred Koury of Al Hoda, the oldest Arabic paper in the country. Thirty-nine Palestinians on the register of a city that had thousands, because the paperwork that would make a person Palestinian stopped being issued in 1948. One of them, born in what is now Israel and moved four times since, asks the reporter: where are you going to go?

CP-1972-024 →

· Maryville Daily Forum

Palestinian Political Aspirations Debated

By Francis Ofner / The Christian Science Monitor News Service

TEL AVIV, ISRAEL — A vigorous debate is under way here about how to deal in the long term with the political aspirations of Palestinian Arabs.

Three basic trends of Israeli thought are discernible: —One calls for creation of some state -like entity to fulfill Palestinian nationalist longings. —A second opposes any Palestinian political configuration in the region. —A third refuses to address itself to the problem at all, assuming that extensive involvement in such approaches will only distract Israel from what should be its foremost consideration, its own security.

The debate has been given a fresh twist by Egyptian President Sadat's proposal for a Palestinian government-in-exile. For, while the proposal is shrugged off here as wholly unrealistic and liable only to deepen the rifts between rival Palestinian groups, it lends a new topicality to the subject.

Proponents of a Palestinian entity have been buoyed by the current efforts of Arye Eliav, the past secretary-general of the governing Labor Party. In a series of appearances before party chapters around the country, Mr. Eliav is propounding his view that the occupied territories should be kept free of Jewish settlement. This restraint, argues Mr.

Eliav, would embolden those Palestinians who favor self-determination alongside a formal peace with Israel. A recent book by Mr. Eliav, based largely on this thesis, has become a best seller in Israel. It serves as a platform for his declared campaign to win a Cabinet seat in the next government.

A political leader with similar inclinations is Mordechai Bentov, who served under former Prime Ministers David Ben-Gurion and Levi Eshkoi in the war Cabinets of 1948, 1956, and 1967. An Arabic translation of his book, “Israel, the Palestinians, and the Left,” has been receiving favorable response from a number of Palestinians on the west bank of the Jordan River.

The camp that opposes a Palestinian state includes three of Israel's most powerful leaders: Prime Minister Golda Meir, Foreign Minister Abba Eban, and Minister without Portfolio Israel Galili. All three have stated flatly that “there is no place for a third state in the region between the Iraqi border and the Mediterranean.”

ARAB HOPES CONFRONT ISRAELIS in debate over whether to establish statehood for Palestine. This smaller-scale debate between Arab and Jew occurred recently at a border checkpoint. (Gordon Converse)

CP-1972-028 →

· The Shreveport Times

Fate of Palestinian Arabs Being Debated in Tel Aviv

By Francis Ofner / Christian Science Monitor News Service

TEL AVIV, Israel — A vigorous debate is under way here about how to deal in the long term with the political aspirations of Palestinian Arabs.

Three basic trends of Israeli thought are discernible: —One calls for creation of some state-like entity to fulfill Palestinian nationalist longings. —A second opposes any Palestinian political configuration in the region. —A third refuses to address itself to the problem at all, assuming that extensive involvement in such approaches will only distract Israel from what should be its foremost consideration, its own security.

The debate has been given a fresh twist by Egyptian President Sadat's proposal for a Palestinian government - in - exile. For, while the proposal is shrugged off here as wholly unrealistic and liable only to deepen the rifts between rival Palestinian groups, it lends a new topicality to the subject.

Proponents of a Palestinian entity have been buoyed by the current efforts of Arye Eliav, the past secretary general of the governing Labor Party. In a series of appearances before party chapters around the country, Eliav is propounding his view that the occupied territories should be kept free of Jewish settlement.

This restraint, argues Eliav, would embolden those Palestinians who favor self-determination alongside a formal peace with Israel. A recent book by Eliav, based largely on this thesis, has become a best seller in Israel. It serves as a platform for his Cabinet seats in the next government.

A political leader with similar inclinations is Mordechai Bentov, who served under former Prime Ministers David Ben-Gurion and Levi Eshkoi in the war Cabinets of 1948, 1956, and 1967. An Arabic translation of his book, “Israel, the Palestinians, and the Left,” has been receiving favorable response from a number of Palestinians on the west bank of the Jordan River.

The camp that opposes a Palestinian state includes three of Israel's most powerful leaders: Prime Minister Golda Meir, Foreign Minister Abba Eban, and Minister without Portfolio Israel Galili. All three have stated flatly that “there is no place for a third state in the region between the Iraqi border and the Mediterranean.”

Arab Hopes confront Israelis in debate over whether to establish statehood for Palestine. This smaller-scale debate between Arab and Jew occurred recently at a border checkpoint. (Christian Science Monitor Photo)

CP-1972-029 →

· The Forum · page 1

Arabs Seek Recovery of Town Taken by Israelis 24 Years Ago

Marcus Eliason, The Associated Press, Berem, Israel

“BEREM, Israel (AP)—Twenty-four years ago, with war raging in the Middle East, an Israeli army officer drove into this Arab village and ordered its 800 inhabitants to leave. He promised they could return ‘in a short time,’ after the Israelis had cleared the nearby border with Lebanon of mines and enemy pockets. The Arabs claim the officer said 15 days.

But when the villagers tried to return to Berem they were blocked by Israeli troops. They appealed to the Israeli Supreme Court, which ordered their return home on the grounds no formal expulsion order had been issued. The army hurriedly wrote out the orders and dodged the court ruling.

Then, in 1955, the Israel Defense Forces blew up every house in the village… Berem—along with the villagers of neighboring Iqrit, who suffered the same fate—appears to be a replay of the murky, time-worn controversy over what really happened in 1948: were the Arabs expelled by the Israelis to make way for the Jewish state, or did the indigenous Arabs obey the orders of their leaders to evacuate for the invading Arab armies?

The Israelis have said the Arabs in 1948 abandoned their homes when they ran away from the fighting. The Arabs claimed they were ordered out by the Israelis who feared a large Arab population inside the burgeoning Jewish state… ‘We have owned this land for 600 years,’ said Riad Suliman, a 24-year-old student. ‘We would not give it up any more than the Jews give up Israel.

The fact that only six out of 90 families from Berem accepted compensation speaks for itself.’… Then, in 1955, the Israel Defense Forces blew up every house in the village… Part of Berem’s 3,000 acres of farmland now belong to Jewish settlements.

Israel’s attorney general, Meir Shamgar, says ample compensation was offered to the villagers, but only six out of 90 families accepted.”

“Berem, near Lebanese border, today is heap of rubble.” (AP Wirephoto)

The photograph of the ruins runs above the headline as part of the same clipping. The record previously carried ‘The village’ as its headline; that phrase is not on the scan.

Correction: {'note': 'Headline corrected on re-read: the record had “The village”, which is not printed on this page.'}

CP-1972-002 →

· Press and Sun Bulletin

Guerrilla Chief’s Kin Assassinated

ROME (AP) — A relative of Palestinian leader Yasir Arafat was assassinated in Rome Monday night. He was employed at the Libyan Embassy and was active in propagandizing the cause of the Palestinian Arabs. Police said the man was Abdel Wael Zuaiter, 38, whose father was a cousin of Arafat. Zuaiter was felled by eight pistol shots in the courtyard of the building where he lived.

Witnesses said they saw two men run to a waiting car after the shooting. Two of Zuaiter’s brothers were killed in an Israeli raid on guerrilla camps in Lebanon four years ago.

CP-1972-047 →

· The Bee

Palestinian Leader's Cousin Assassinated

ROME (AP) — A relative of Palestinian leader Yasir Arafat was assassinated in Rome Monday night. He was employed at the Libyan Embassy and was active in propagandizing the cause of the Palestinian Arabs. Police said the man was Abdel Wael Zuaiter, 38, whose father was a cousin of Arafat. Zuaiter was felled by eight pistol shots in the courtyard of the building where he lived.

Witnesses said they saw two men run to a waiting car after the shooting. Two of Zuaiter's brothers were killed in an Israeli raid on guerrilla camps in Lebanon four years ago.

CP-1972-051 →

· Minneapolis Star

Relative of Arab guerrilla leader killed

ROME, Italy (AP) — A relative of Palestinian guerrilla leader Yasir Arafat was assassinated here last night. He was employed at the Libyan Embassy and was active in propagandizing the cause of the Palestinian Arabs. Police said the man was Abdel Wael Zuaiter, 38, whose father was a cousin of Arafat.

Zuaiter was felled by eight pistol shots in the courtyard of the building where he lived. Witnesses said they saw two men run to a waiting car after the shooting. Two of Zuaiter's brothers were killed in an Israeli raid on guerrilla camps in Lebanon four years ago.

CP-1972-053 →

· Colorado Springs Gazette Telegraph

Terrorist Leader's Relative Is Killed

ROME (AP) — A relative of Palestinian leader Yasir Arafat was assassinated in Rome Monday night. He was employed at the Liyan Embassy and was active in propagandizing the cause of the Palestinian Arabs. Police said the man was Abdel Wael Zuaiter, 38, whose father was a cousin of Arafat. Zuaiter was felled by eight pistol shots in the courtyard of the building where he lived.

Witnesses said they saw two men run to a waiting car after the shooting. Two of Zuaiter's brothers were killed in an Israeli raid on guerrilla camps in Lebanon four years ago.

CP-1972-054 →

· The New York Times · page Page 1, Col. 8, continued on Page 14, Column 4

Official of Al Fatah Shot Dead in Rome

ROME, Oct. 17—A Libyan Embassy employe, a Jordanian who is believed to have been a member of Al Fatah, the Palestinian guerrilla organization, was shot dead last night outside his suburban apartment. The 38-year-old victim, Abdel Weil Zuaiter of Nablus, Jordan, was described today by Fatah's press agency in Beirut as its representative for Italy.

It said he was a martyr and hero of the Palestinian cause, “assassinated” by Israeli secret-service operatives. A Jordanian Embassy official said Mr. Zuaiter was a nephew of Akram Zuaiter, Jordan's Ambassador in Beirut, but declined to confirm reports that he was also a second cousin of Yasir Arafat, leader of Fatah. The police said the murder had been carefully planned.

Neighbors told the police they saw two men fire and then escape in a waiting car. The car was found a few blocks from the scene. The police said it was rented Sunday by a man who showed a Canadian driver's license, on which he was named as Anthony Hutton, 47, of Toronto. The police disclosed that Mr.

Zuaiter, who officially was a translator for the Libyan Embassy, had been ideologically involved in activities on behalf of Palestinian refugees and guerrillas. Two of his brothers were killed four years ago during an Israeli incursion into Lebanon, it was said. According to the police, Mr.

Zuaiter had been a contributor to Palestina, a pro-Palestinian periodical issued here until a year ago, and organized and led meetings of Italian leftist pro-Arab and rightist anti-Jewish movements. Recently, he collected funds to build a hospital in a Palestinian guerrilla camp. In September, 1970, he was reported in Amman and was a frequent traveler to Libya. Mr.

Zuaiter was questioned in connection with the attempt by two Jordanians to blow up an Israeli airliner on Aug. 17, the police said.

A statement by the Ambassadors to Italy and the Vatican of the 18 member countries of the Arab League said that the “horrible crime recalls the actions of the Zionist bands that have written notorious pages in the history of terrorism and violence, in Palestine and elsewhere.” … ‘Zionist’ Terrorists Accused Special to The New York Times BEIRUT, Lebanon, Oct.

17—Al Fatah, the major Palestinian commando organization, accused pro-Israeli terrorists today of killing the Fatah representative in Rome. “This is part of the Zionist terrorist campaign being carried out in all parts of the world by the enemy,” a Fatah statement said.

The dead man, Abdel Weil Zuaiter, was born in Nablus, now part of the West Bank of the Jordan River, which was occupied by Israel in 1967. He was “another martyr whose blood will be avenged,” the statement said.

CP-1972-036 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Italian Police Link Bombing, Slain Arab

ROME (AP) — Police investigating the mystery killing of the Palestine Al Fatah propaganda chief in Italy said Tuesday he had been questioned about the bombing of an Israeli jetliner two months ago.

A full day of investigation gave police no clues about the identities of the two gunmen who riddled Abdel Wael Zuaiter, 38, with 12 shots in the courtyard of his apartment building Monday night. Spokesmen for Israeli extremist groups that swore revenge for Palestine guerrilla violence abroad said in Jerusalem they had nothing to do with the Rome slaying.

Al Fatah, largest of the Palestine guerrilla organizations, said it was the work of Israeli agents. Zuaiter, whose father was a cousin of the Al Fatah leader Yasir Arafat, worked at the Libyan embassy here as a translator. He had been questioned by police after a booby-trapped record player exploded aboard an El Al plane with 149 persons aboard on Aug. 17.

Only two passengers were injured and the jet landed safely.

CP-1972-037 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Al Fatah Agent Killed in Rome

ROME (UPI) — Police ordered a nation-wide manhunt for the killers of Adel Zuaiter, a 38-year-old Palestinian employe of the Libyan embassy in Rome, identified yesterday by the Al Fatah guerrilla organization as its representative in Italy. Zuaiter was ambushed and shot eight times by two men as he was about to enter the elevator in his apartment building Monday night.

A Libyan embassy spokesman said Zuaiter, who had a Jordanian passport, worked as an “interpreter” there. Police said they were investigating all possible connections Zuaiter might have had but refused to comment further. The Roman newspaper Il Messaggero said he was distantly related to Al Fatah leader Yasser Arafat and was well known in Palestinian circles in Italy.

In Beirut, Al Fatah said Zuaiter was the representative of the Palestinian organization in Italy and a “martyr assassinated by Zionist intelligence.” In a statement issued by the Palestinian news agency WAFA, Fatah said Zuaiter was among the first men who had been able to take the “Voice of Palestine” to the European public.

“This assassination is part of a Zionist terrorist campaign which is being carried out all over the world and which condemns the real terrorists,” Fatah said. Police said at least two men waited for Zuaiter, opening fire when he reached for the elevator door. He stumbled back into the courtyard where he was fired upon again and where he dropped and died, they said.

Twelve empty pistol shells littered the lobby and courtyard of Zuaiter’s apartment building near the center of Rome. Police said they found a Rome University identification card dated 1962-63 on his blood-soaked body.

Il Messaggero quoted witnesses as saying they had seen a light blue Fiat sedan with two men and one woman parked outside Zuaiter’s house before the shooting began. Zuaiter was born in 1934 in Nablus, now occupied Jordan, and came to Rome in the early 1960s, ostensibly to study engineering at Rome University.

Adel Zuaiter lies in pool of own blood in Rome. (UPI)

CP-1972-043 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Embassy employe ambushed

ROME (UPI)— Police ordered a ntionwide manhunt for the killers of Adel Zuaiter, a 38-year-old Palestinian employee of the Libyan Emnbassy in Rome, identified Tuesday by the Al Fatah guerrilla organization as its representative in Italy. Zuaiter was ambused and shot eight times by two men as he was about to enter the elevator in his apartment building at Monday night.

A Libyan Embassy spokesman said Zuaiter, who had a Jordanian passport, worked as an interpreter there. Police said they were investigating possible conenctions Zuaiter might have had, but refused to comment further. The Roman newspaper Il Messaggero said he was distantly related to Al Fatah leader Yesser Arafat and was well known in Palestinian circles in Italy.

In Beirut, Al Fatah said Zuaiter was the representative of the Palestinian organization in Italy and a “martyr assassinated by Zionist intelligence.” In a statement issued by the Palestinian news agency WAFA, Fatah said Zuaiter was among the first men who had been able to take the “voice of Palestine” to the European public.

“This assassination is part of a Zionist terrorist campaign which is beng carried out all over the world and which condemns the real terrorists,” Fatah said. Police said at leat two men waited for Zuaiter, opening fire when he reached for the elevator door. He stumbled back into the courtuyard where he was fired upon again and where he dropped and died, they said.

Twelve empty pistol shells littered the lobby and courtyard of Zuaiter’s aprtment building near the center of Rome. Police said they found a Rome University identification card dated 1962-63 on his bloodsoaked body.

CP-1972-044 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

El Fatah Blames Israelis for Death of Arafat's Cousin

The El Fatah Palestinian guerrilla organization accused Israeli intelligence today of murdering its Rome representative and vowed to avenge his death and other Arabs killed by the Israelis.

The Palestine news agency in Beirut, Lebanon, quoted a Fatah statement as saying the assassination of Abdel Wael Zuaiter, 38, whom it described as one of its prominent members, was part of a Zionist terrorist campaign carried out by the Israelis against the Palestininian guerrillas in various parts of the world.

Zuaiter was identified as a second cousin of Yasir Arafat, leader of the Al Fatah, and a nephew of Akram Zuaiter, Jordan's ambassador to Lebanon. The Fatah statement said the murder was carried out by Israeli intelligence agents as part of a world-wide Israeli plan against Arab guerrillas following the murder of 11 Israelis at the Olympic games.

Rome police said Zuaiter was a Jordanian employe at the Libyan Embassy. Eight bullets were shot into Zuaiter in the courtyard of the apartment building where he had been living. Neighbors told police they had seen two men fire at him and then escape in a waiting car in which there were one or two persons. The car was found this morning a few blocks from the scene.

Police said it had been rented Sunday by a man who had shown a Canadian driver's license. Police disclosed that Zuaiter had been ideologically involved in activities on behalf of Palestinian refugees and guerrillas. He was the fifth son of a distinguished Jordanian intellectual. Two of his brothers were killed four years ago during an Israeli incursion in Lebanon.

CP-1972-049 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Jordanian slain in Rome called Arafat's cousin

ROME—A Libyan embassy employe, a Jordanian who is believed to have been a member of the Palestinian Al Fatah terrorist organization, was shot dead Monday night outside his suburban apartment. The victim, 38-year-old Abdel Weil Zuaiter of Nablus, Jordan, was described yesterday by Al Fatah in Beirut as the organization's representative for Italy.

It said he was a “martyr” and a “hero” of the Palestinian cause, “assassinated” by Israeli secret-service operatives. Rome's left-wing newspapers said he had been a member of the terrorist organization but was an intellectual rather than an activist.

A Jordanian embassy official said Zuaiter was a nephew of Akram Zuaiter, Jordan's ambassador in Beirut, but declined to confirm the report by a Roman newspaper that he was also a second cousin of Yasir Arafat, leader of Al Fatah. Police in Rome and elsewhere said the murder had been “carefully planned” and was quite likely politically motivated.

Eight bullets were fired into Zuaiter in the courtyard of his apartment building. Neighbors told police they had seen two men fire at him and then escape in a waiting car. Police said Zuaiter, who officially was a “translator” for the Libyan embassy, had been ideologically involved in activities on behalf of Palestinian refugees and guerrillas.

He was the fifth son of a distinguished Jordanian intellectual. Two of his brothers were killed four years ago during an Israeli incursion into Lebanon.

CP-1972-050 →

· Dayton Daily News

Relative of Arafat Slain in Rome

ROME — (AP) — A relative of Palestinian leader Yasir Arafat was assassinated in Rome Monday night. He was employed at the Libyan Embassy and was active in propagandizing the cause of the Palestinian Arabs. Police said the man was Abdel Wael Zuaiter, 38, whose father was a cousin of Arafat.

Zuaiter was felled by eight pistol shots in the courtyard of the building where he lived. Witnesses said they saw two men run to a waiting car after the shooting. Two of Zuaiter's brothers were killed in an Israeli raid on guerrilla camps in Lebanon four years ago.

CP-1972-052 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Arab in Rome slain in ambush

ROME — Police mounted a nationwide search yesterday for the killers — possibly Jewish terrorists — who ambushed a Jordanian employed by the Libyan embassy and cut him down in a hail of bullets outside his home.

The hunt for the killers spread throughout Italy as Rome police announced they suspected the killing to be politically motivated and possibly carried out by a Jewish terrorist group. The Al Fatah Palestinian guerrilla organization said the victim — Abdel Wael Zuaiter, 28 — was its Rome representative.

Zuaiter was hit by a dozen .22 caliber bullets Monday night as he was about to enter a elevator in the courtyard of the apartment building where he lived.

CP-1972-056 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

MURDER VICTIM — Adel Wael Zuaiter, 38, a Palestinian employe of the Libyan Embassy

MURDER VICTIM — Adel Wael Zuaiter, 38, a Palestinian employe of the Libyan Embassy, lies dead in a pool of blood outside the Rome apartment building where he lived. Zuaiter was said to be related to El Fatah leader Yasser Arafat.—UPI Photo.

CP-1972-057 →

· The New York Times

Rome Police Suspect Feud in Slaying

ROME, Oct. 18—A police official hunting the men who shot and killed Weil Abdel Zuaiter, the Libyan Embassy clerk said to have been the top agent in Italy of Al Fatah, the Palestinian guerrilla organization, said today that his killing might have been a result of a feud between factions of Palestinians.

The head of the political branch of Rome’s police voiced a belief that the murderers might have been “political enemies” of the Palestinians or “compatriots” involved in a feud between Black September and other Palestinian terrorists movements. Libyan, Jordanian and Israeli diplomatic officials all denied they had known of Mr. Zuaiter’s membership in Al Fatah.

He was shot Monday night as he was entering his suburban apartment house. Ashour Elaman, the Libyan Embassy’s press officer, said that Mr.

Zuaiter had worked part time for his office over the last five years as a translator of Italian periodicals but that he had not been checked on hiring because as a local employe his hiring did not need the Libyan Foreign Ministry’s approval.

An Israeli Embassy official denied the allegation by Al Fatah that Israeli secret service operatives had been behind the murder, saying the embassy had not heard of him before. Alberto Moravia, the writer, who said he had known Mr. Zuaiter for more than a year, asserted “everybody knew that Mr. Zuaiter was the cultural agent of Al Fatah in Italy.” But Mr.

Moravia said he was unaware that he also had a political role. Mr. Moravia also said that Mr. Zuaiter introduced him to Yasir Arafat, leader of Fatah, in March of last year during a trip, through Kuwait, Syria, Lebanon and Iraq.

Speculation that the killers were agents of a dissident faction within the Palestinian terrorist movement was supported today by Il Giornale d’Italia, a conservative Rome daily, which quoted a woman friend as saying that Mr. Zuaiter left Fatah about a year ago and had lived since in a state of fear. Police sources said that they were checking telephone numbers found in Mr.

Zuaiter’s apartment and fingerprints in a car in which two men escaped after the shooting. The car had been rented by a man who produced a false Canadian driving license.

CP-1972-055 →

· The New York Times · New York

Two Arab towns that plumb Israel's conscience

“The Government is suddenly showing a new sensitivity to the often-heard accusation that Arab Israelis are second-class citizens. Even as it refuses the restoring of Berem and Ikrit to their former inhabitants, the Government has resolved to review its entire policy toward the Israeli Arab minority of some 400,000 souls, or 14 per cent…”

Amos Elon in the Times magazine, on Bir’im and Iqrit. Both word orders stand in adjacent sentences, written by the same man on the same afternoon: Arab Israelis carries the accusation, Israeli Arab carries the policy. It is tempting to read a rule into that and the rest of the paper does not support one. What it does show is that in 1972 the two forms were interchangeable to a careful writer.

CP-1972-022 →

· The New York Times · page 5

A New Policy Of First Strike

—TERENCE SMITH

JERUSALEM—In the 26 months since the Suez Canal cease-fire went into effect, the intermittent fighting between Israel and her Arab neighbors has followed a seemingly inflexible pattern.

Each guerrilla raid across the frontier, or Arab hijacking of an airliner, has brought a prompt and punishing Israeli response, usually in the form of air strikes or ground assaults into Lebanon and Syria.

Last week Israel broke that pattern, and in so doing, announced to the world that she would henceforth strike at the Arab guerrilla organizations outside her borders without warning or provocation. The first implementation of the new policy came in the placid afternoon last Sunday.

Israeli fighter bombers roared in over the Mediterranean beaches and struck at four guerrilla installations in Lebanon and one in Syria. “This time we had the element of surprise going for us,” a senior Israeli official observed on Monday. “We nailed them in their camps and training bases when they didn't expect it.”

In contrast to previous strikes, Israel made no effort to justify this attack by citing either a guerrilla build-up or terrorist actions. The philosophy behind the strikes was articulated by Vivian Herzog, the former chief of Israeli intelligence whose broadcasts over Israel Army radio reflect the Government's view.

“The very presence of terrorists near our borders is a provocation,” he said. “No longer will we wait for them to strike us before we strike them. This is not a matter of a reprisal, we are engaged in a continuing war.” In tactical terms, the old policy of retaliatory strikes was becoming less and less effective.

The guerrillas had taken to fleeing their bases, particularly in southern Lebanon, every time a terrorist incident occurred. This was especially true after the murder of 11 Israelis at the Munich Olympics. As a result, the Israeli air and ground strikes into Lebanon and Syria that followed that tragic incident were disappointing from Jerusalem's point of view.

“By confining ourselves to retaliation,” an Israeli officer said last week, “we were providing the terrorists with an infallible early-warning system.” Internationally, the message to the Arab states is unmistakable: the mere harboring of guerrillas, even if their activities are restricted, will bring Israeli bombs and rockets raining down on the Arab territory.

Internally, the policy is aimed at fulfilling, at least in part, the restive desire of many Israelis for revenge.

This emotion was stirred up more powerfully by Munich than any event in recent memory, and its political implications, particularly in the upcoming election year, are obvious. [Later in the same article:] The principal mystery of the week surrounded the fatal shooting on Monday of an interpreter at the Libyan embassy in Rome who was identified as the representative of the Fatah in Italy.

The man, Wael Adel Zuaiter, was cut down by eight pistol shots as he entered the elevator of his Rome apartment building. It was impossible to determine whether the shooting was the work of Israeli counter-terror agents, as the Fatah claimed, or a manifestation of the internal squabbling among the guerrillas, as the Israelis claimed.

As one Israeli official observed: “You could make a plausible case for either.”

As Israel launched a tough new offensive policy against Arab terrorist groups, the fedayeen last week were reported feuding among themselves. One victim of the conflict, though whether from Israeli or Palestinian bullets was in dispute, was Wael Adel Zuaiter, a Palestinian employe of the Libyan Embassy, shot dead in Rome, above. [credit: United Press International]

CP-1972-040 →

· The Cleveland Press · page 1

The UN fails on terror

“The United Nations has failed shamefully in its duty by declining to take any action against international terrorism. UN Secretary General Kurt Waldheim himself had urged the General Assembly to act. But since his call came right after the murder of 11 Israeli athletes at the Munich Olympics, the Arab states were opposed.

They didn’t want anything even resembling condemnation of the Palestinian terrorists.

They were joined by the African bloc, which feared that a meaningful anti-terror move could hamper guerrillas in South Africa, Rhodesia and Portuguese colonies in Africa… This showed that with its Afro-Asian-Communist majority, the United Nations is incapable of acting constructively whenever the issue of ‘Zionism,’ ‘racism,’ ‘white rule,’ ‘imperialism’ or ‘capitalism’ is raised — even spuriously.… It is the United Nations which is losing credibility.

Its looking more like a political jungle than a forum where men can seek the rule of law.”

Three years before the vote, an American editorial already files Zionism and racism together in a list of the words it puts in quotation marks. The paper’s own Its for It’s is kept.

CP-1972-014 →

· Times Record · Fort Smith

Truman Besieged on All Sides by Palestine

By MARGARET TRUMAN

Margaret Truman writing about her father, syndicated to Fort Smith, Arkansas. Palestine appears as something that besieged an American president — a problem that happened to Washington.

CP-1972-023 →

· Courier-Journal · Louisville

Group charges Israel tortures Palestinians

The Associated Press

“A British organization charged today that Israel has tortured many prisoners in a reign of terror waged against Palestinians in Arab territory occupied in the 1967 Middle East war.”

The earliest torture allegation in the archive, five years before the United Nations committee and the London Sunday Times. The source is the Union of Liberal Students, an offshoot of the Young Liberals in Britain. Printed the same day as the Palm Beach Post ran the same dispatch under a different headline.

CP-1972-019 →

· The Palm Beach Post · West Palm Beach

Israeli Torture

“Israel has tortured many Palestinian prisoners in a reign of terror it has waged against Palestinians in Arab territory occupied in the 1967 Middle East war, a report by a British organization charged today.”

The same wire story the Courier Journal printed in Louisville on the same morning. Louisville told its readers a group had made a charge. Palm Beach put the charge in the headline as a fact and the attribution at the end of the sentence. One dispatch, two different things to have read.

CP-1972-020 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

French Plan Protection For Israeli

PARIS (UPI) — French police chiefs met today to work out special security measures, including preventing street disturbances, during Israeli Prime Minister Golda Meir's scheduled visit here this weekend. Left-wing and pro-Palestinian organizations said they will stage protest demonstrations Friday and Saturday when Mrs.

Meir and other foreign leaders will attend a meeting of the Socialist International. Jewish student groups said they plan to hold counter demonstrations to show support for Mrs. Meir. Police officials said they planned exceptional precautions to insure Mrs. Meir's safety.

The anti-Israeli demonstrations were called following the death Tuesday of Mahmud Hamshari, head of the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) office in Paris. Hamshari died from wounds he received in a Dec. 8 explosion of a powerful bomb planted in his apartment by unidentified attackers. Arab diplomats and pro-Palestinian groups blamed the explosion on “Zionists”.

Hamshari died a few hours after a powerful terrorist bomb wrecked the offices of the Jewish Agency on Rue Fortuny. The explosion shattered windows throughout the street but the offices were empty during the pre-dawn blast.

Leaders of various Jewish organizations said Paris police had refused to assure protection of the Agency's offices on the ground it was a private charity organization and that protection was granted only to official missions. Police security was tightened around all Israeli diplomatic and consular offices today. Mrs.

Meir's travel plans are expected to be kept secret, police sources said. The Israeli premier and other foreign socialist leaders maintained their travel plans although President Georges Pompidou at his news conference Tuesday, condemned their meeting in Paris as a open intrusion into French domestic affairs.

Pompidou said the meeting could be seen as showing support for the opposition French socialists who are engaged in a bitter campaign battle with the Gaullists for the March parliamentary election.

CP-1973-019 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Paris Police Plan Special Security Measures for Meir

PARIS (UPI) — French police chiefs met today to work out special security measures, including preventing street disturbances, during Israeli Prime Minister Golda Meir's scheduled visit here this weekend. Left-wing and pro-Palestinian organizations said they will stage protest demonstrations Friday and Saturday when Mrs.

Meir and other foreign leaders will attend a meeting of the Socialist International. Jewish student groups said they plan to hold counter demonstrations to show support for Mrs. Meir. Police officials said they planned exceptional precautions to insure Mrs. Meir's safety.

The anti-Israeli demonstrations were called following the death Tuesday of Mahmud Hamshari, head of the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) office in Paris. Hamshari died from wounds he received in a Dec. 8 explosion of a powerful bomb planted in his apartment by unidentified attackers. Arab diplomats and pro-Palestinian groups blamed the explosion on “Zionists”.

Hamshari died a few hours after a powerful terrorist bomb wrecked the offices of the Jewish Agency on Rue Fortuny. The explosion shattered windows throughout the street but the offices were empty during the pre-dawn blast.

Leaders of various Jewish organizations said Paris police had refused to assure protection of the Agency's offices on the ground it was a private charity organization and that protection was granted only to official missions. Police security was tightened around all Israeli diplomatic and consular offices today. Mrs.

Meir's travel plans are expected to be kept secret, police sources said.

CP-1973-022 →

· Los Angeles Times · page 5

Mrs. Meir's Safety Studied

PARIS (UPI)—French police chiefs met Wednesday to work out special security measures, including preventing street disturbances, during Israeli Prime Minister Golda Meir's scheduled visit here this weekend. Left-wing and pro-Palestinian organizations said they would stage protests Friday and Saturday when Mrs.

Meir and other foreign leaders attend a meeting of the Socialist International. Police officials said they planned exceptional precautions to ensure Mrs. Meir's safety. The anti-Israeli demonstrations were called following the death Tuesday of Mahmud Hamshari, head of the Palestinian Liberation Organization office in Paris. Hamshari died from wounds received in a Dec.

8 explosion of a powerful bomb planted in his apartment by unidentified attackers.

CP-1973-023 →

· Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle · Milwaukee

Cases of senseless murder and wanton destruction

“There have also been cases of senseless murder and wanton destruction, such as the mass killing in 1956 of…”

A Jewish community paper in Milwaukee, seventeen years on, naming it as mass killing in its own voice.

CP-1973-015 →

· Duluth News-Tribune · Duluth

Palestinian Runs : Arab Newspaper In E. Jerusalem

CP-1973-009 →

· Daily World · New York · page 1

Israeli Arabs and Jews unite for right of villagers to return

Tel Aviv (by mail)

TEL AVIV, (By mail) — The government, alarmed by the tide of public opinion in favor of the right of the former inhabitants of Biram and Iqrit to return to their villages, has declared that region to be a “closed area.” This means that no one will be allowed to enter this area without permission from the military authorities.

In using these strongarm tactics, the government is trying to isolate the struggle.

On the 24th anniversary of the eviction of the inhabitants of Biram and Iqrit and on the 21st anniversary of the demolition of the villages in contradiction to the orders of the court, large meetings were held, on the initiative of the national council for solidarity with the villagers of Biram and Iqrit, in which over 1,000 people participated including Jewish and Arab citizens from all over the country.

Among the public figures who participated was the writer Mordechai Avi-Shaul, who brought a letter of solidarity with the villagers from the “Israeli League for Human Rights,” Knesset member A.

Levenbraun; members of the political bureau of the Communist Party of Israel, Emil Habibi and David (Uzi) Bornshtein; Alkas Masis, from “Ha Olam Ha Zey,” and members of Matzpen and Siah. Archbishop Joseph Ria, leader of the solidarity committee, briefly surveyed the history of the eviction from Biram and Iqrit on Dec. 23, 1948, and the struggle to return.

Biram is Kafr Bir’im. The archive now holds this village three times, across forty-nine years: evicted here in 1973 on the twenty-fourth anniversary, told at length by the Associated Press in 1972, and photographed in ruins beside a Palestinian American’s column in the Courier-Journal in 2021. Jewish and Arab citizens are in the same meeting, and the paper names them.

CP-1973-001 →

· The Miami Herald · Miami · page 1

Downing Airliner Also Terrorism

Nancy Withington, Kent, Ohio

“Downing Airliner Also Terrorism. In an editorial of Feb. 23, you make the statement that the Israelis ‘have been besieged by all manner of terrorism for years.’ Indeed, bandits living in a stolen house might fear the owners’ attempts to recover it.

Israeli bombing of refugee camps in Lebanon and Syria caused hundreds of civilian deaths — but you do not call this ‘terrorism!’ The Israeli ‘tragedy’ is that a Jewish state could only exist by the genocide of Palestine. That genocide has continued for 50 years. Apparently you favor religious apartheid in the Holy Land.”

A reader in Kent, Ohio, answering the paper’s own editorial. Both “genocide” and “apartheid” are used here in 1973, in a letters column, by a correspondent with an American name.

CP-1973-002 →

· The Buffalo News · Buffalo

Invaders Slay Guerrilla Chiefs, Hit Refugee Sites

BEIRUT, April 10 — Israeli commandos invaded the heart of the Lebanese capital early today, killing three Palestinian guerrilla leaders in their apartments and attacking refugee camps. It was thought at first that the raid was in retaliation for Arab attacks Monday in Cyprus on the residence of the Israeli ambassador and an Israeli airliner.

But an authoritative Lebanese source said there were indications that preparations had been made by an advance party that came to Beirut several days ago. Al Fatah, the biggest Palestinian guerrilla organization, said the victims included its No. 2 man, Mohammed Yussef Najjar, known as Abu Yussef. He was one of the founders of Al Fatah.

THE LEBANESE Defense Ministry said 11 persons were killed and more than a dozen wounded in the strike that began shortly after midnight. But guerrillas at the Sabra camp, which houses 5000 Palestinians, said at least 30 persons were killed and residents were searching the debris of blown up buildings for more bodies.

One of the buildings attacked was the headquarters of the Maoist Popular Democratic Front. Al Fatah centers also were hit. The Israeli chief of staff, Lt. Gen. David Elazar, said in Tel Aviv that two Israelis were killed in the 2½-hour raid and two were wounded.

He warned that Israel may hit Beirut again, saying: “It is impossible to honor the sovereignty of Lebanon and its capital when there is complete freedom for the terrorists, their bases and commands in Lebanese territory.”

CP-1973-012 →

· Indiana Gazette · Indiana

Israeli Commandos Leave Path Of Destruction In Beirut Attack

Lebanese Troops Patrol Streets—

Associated Press

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — Blood and bullet-shattered cars littered a street in the heart of Lebanon’s capital today, and screams came from the rubbled houses in a small coastal village on Beirut’s southern outskirts.

The Israeli commandos had struck again, leaving civilians and Palestinian guerrilla leaders dead in this Mediterranean city more devoted to pleasure than war. Lebanese troops, police and armored cars patrolled the seaside avenue known as the Corniche.

Palestinian guerrillas in civilian clothes and camouflage fatigues materialized out of the refugee camps, armed with bazookas, AK47 assault rifles, machine guns and revolvers. One guerrilla in olive drab and a red-checked kaffiyeh headdress spotted American newsmen and angrily told a crowd of onlookers: “The Americans are fighting us.”

But a new widow in the Village of Ouzai screamed at some guerrillas outside her door: “Your Palestinian presence is responsible for my husband’s death.” A resident of the Beirut apartment building where Kamal Nasser and Kamal Adwan were slain told this story of his night of fear: “I was sleeping soundly when I woke up to the sound of shots.

At first I thought it was nothing important. I knew there were four guerrilla guards in the building, and I thought they had seen someone suspicious and fired warning shots. It has happened before. “I went back to sleep. Two minutes later, I awoke to a massive volley of tommy-gun fire, automatic weapons. I told my wife and eight children to lie on the floor.

“Then I heard shouts on the staircase outside our door. I couldn’t understand the language. It wasn’t American, Arabic or French. I told my wife, ’I think the Israelis are attacking the building.’ I crawled to the window and peeked out through the Venetian blinds.”

CP-1973-013 →

· (newspaper unidentified) · page 1

RAID BY ISRAELIS AT BEIRUT KILLS 2 FATAH LEADERS

ARABS IN CYPRUS / Band Attacks an El Al Plane and Home of the Ambassador || OFFICE BLOWN UP / Attackers Enter City After Exchange of Fire With Police

By JUAN de ONIS (right-hand column); By The Associated Press (left-hand column, Nicosia)

BEIRUT, Lebanon, Tuesday, April 10 — Israeli commandos attacked Arab guerrilla bases early today in Beirut and Saida, on the Lebanese coast. The raids, carried out in darkness, followed a Palestinian commando attack yesterday on Israelis in Cyprus.

The Ministry of Defense announced in a preliminary casualty report that two Lebanese security agents and nine civilians had been killed, while an army officer and nine security agents were wounded. Two prominent leaders of the Palestinian Fatah guerrilla organization were killed in the attack at Beirut.

The raiders blew up the apartment of Mohammed Yussef Najjar, also known as Abu Yussef, a member of the executive committee of Fatah. Mr. Najjar and his wife were both killed. The Israelis reportedly killed several guards and kidnapped a son of the Fatah leader.

They also killed Kemal Adwan, another Fatah leader, and blew up the headquarters of the Democratic Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a small but militant commando group led by Nayef Hawatmeh, a Marxist.

There were unconfirmed reports that the Israelis also killed Kemal Nasser, spokesman of the Palestinian Liberation Organization, who lived in an apartment in the same building with Mr. Najjar.

The attacks were carried out in the center of the Lebanese capital in the area of the Palestinian refugee camp called Sabra, which is where most of the commando organizations have their headquarters.

CP-1973-025 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Raiders leave little town a blood-filled shambles

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — Blood and bullet-shattered cars littered a street in the heart of Lebanon's capital today, and screams came from the rubbled houses in a small coastal village on Beirut's southern outskirts. The Israeli commandos had struck again, leaving civilians and Palestinian guerrilla leaders dead in this Mediterranean city more devoted to pleasure than war.

Lebanese troops, police and armored cars patrolled the seaside avenue known as the Corniche. Palestinian guerrillas in civilian clothes and camouflage fatigues materialized out of the refugee camps, armed with bazookas, AK47 assault rifles, machine guns and revolvers.

ONE GUERRILLA in olive drab and a red-checked kaffiyeh headdress spotted American newsmen and angrily told a crowd of onlookers: “The Americans are fighting us.” But a new widow in the village of Ouzai screamed at some guerrillas outside her door: “Your Palestinian presence is responsible for my husband's death.”

A resident of the Beirut apartment building where Kamal Nasser and Kamal Adwan were slain told this story of his night of fear: “I was sleeping soundly when I woke up to the sound of shots. At first I thought it was nothing important. I knew there were four guerrilla guards in the building, and I thought they had seen someone suspicious and fired warning shots.

It has happened before. “I went back to sleep. Two minutes later, I awoke to a massive volley of tommy-gun fire, automatic weapons. I told my wife and eight children to lie on the floor. “Then I heard shouts on the staircase outside our door. I couldn't understand the language. It wasn't American, Arabic or French.

I told my wife, 'I think the Israelis are attacking the building.' I crawled to the window and peeked out through the Venetian blinds. “THREE explosions rocked the building, and then I saw the Israelis run out into the street below. There were many of them, in civilian clothes, and there was a woman with them. What a woman. . . .

I'd like to have her address even if it is in Tel Aviv. . . . She had long blonde hair, a fantastic figure, and she was shouting orders to the men as if she was the leader. “Five of the men fanned out around the building with their guns at the ready while the others started climbing into three cars. One car was a big white sedan.

“Then two Lebanese police jeeps drove up, and both sides started shooting. One Lebanese policeman was hit as he was climbing out of his jeep. Another was hit inside the jeep, and he started screaming. The two policemen in the other jeep didn't even shoot. They just sat there as the Israelis drove away. “The whole thing lasted maybe 20 minutes.

We were still too scared to leave our apartment.” In the apartment building across the street, blood smears led up the stairs to the apartment of guerrilla leader Mohammed Yussef Najjar; known as Abu Yussef.

Neighbors said the commandos blew open the door with explosives, shot him with bursts of automatic weapons fire and killed his wife when she tried to shield her husband's body. ISRAEL'S chief of staff, Lt. Gen. David Elazar, laughed at the report of a blonde woman leading the attack on the apartment houses.

He told a news conference in Tel Aviv that no women took part in the raid, but these days “it is very difficult to tell the difference in many cases.” Kamal Adwan's wife told newsmen her husband was writing at his desk when they heard shots outside their second-floor apartment.

“My husband grabbed his Kalashnikov (assault rifle) and told me to take cover in the bedroom with our two small sons,” said Maha Jayyousi Adwan. “Minutes later, an explosion tore open [our apart]ment door and five or six Israelis stormed in with blazing machine guns. “He fired and hit one or two of them before he was cut down at our bedroom door.”

Kamal Nasser was writing letters at his dining room table, alone in his third-floor apartment, when the Israelis stormed in. A huge pool of blood covered the dining room floor, papers were scattered about and the table was gouged with bullet holes. A divan bed was scorched, and the bedroom was a shambles of bricks, broken glass and fallen plaster.

A friend said an Italian woman living next door opened her door when she heard the shooting and the Israelis shot and killed her.

YUSSEF NAJJAR No. 2 in Al Fatah KAMAL NASSER Guerrilla leader

CP-1973-029 →

· Press Telegram

Commandos Hit Guerrilla Camps

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — Israeli commandos invaded the heart of the Lebanese capital early today, killing three Palestinian guerrilla leaders in their apartments and attacking refugee camps. It was thought at first that the raid was in retaliation for Arab attacks Monday in Cyprus on the residence of the Israeli ambassador and an Israeli airliner.

But an authoritative Lebanese source said there were indications that preparations had been made by an advance party that came to Beirut several days ago. Al Fatah, the biggest Palestinian guerrilla organization, said the victims included its No. 2 man, Mohammed Yussef Najjar, known as Abu Yussef. He was one of the founders of Al Fatah.

The Lebanese Defense Ministry said 11 persons were killed and more than a dozen wounded in the strike that began shortly after midnight. The statement indicated the casualty total might rise. The Israeli chief of staff, Lt. Gen. David Elazar, said in Tel Aviv that two Israelis were killed in the 2½-hour raid and two were wounded.

He warned that Israel may hit Beirut again, saying: “It is impossible to honor the sovereignty of Lebanon and its capital when there is complete freedom for the terrorists, their bases and commands in Lebanese territory.” Another group of Israeli commandos blew up a garage in Sidon, on the coast 24 miles south of Beirut, but there were no casualties there.

The Israelis said the garage was used by guerrillas. President Suleiman Franjieh held an emergency session of the Lebanese Cabinet, and a protest to the U.N. Security Council was believed imminent.

The Israelis, some dressed in civilian clothes and some in fatigue uniforms, apparently landed by helicopter at Ouzai, a village three miles south of Beirut, and split into two groups. Boarding unlicensed cars, one party headed for the center of the city and the apartments of the three Palestinian leaders. The other went to the ShatilaSabra refugee camp near the airport.

The Palestinian leaders lived in apartment buildings off Rue Verdun, in the center of the city. The raiders burst into these buildings, threw explosive charges and then stormed the men's apartments with machine guns blazing. Najjar's wife died as she tried to shield her husband's body.

The others killed were Kamal Adwan, who sources in Israel claimed was in charge of guerrilla operations in the territories occupied by Israel in the 1967 war, and Kamal Nasser, a leading Arab poet who was the spokesman for the Palestine Liberation Organization.

Guerrillas at the Sabra camp, which houses 5,000 Palestinians, said at least 30 persons were killed and residents were searching the debris of blown up buildings for more bodies. One of the buildings attacked was the headquarters of the Maoist Popular Democratic Front. Al Fatah centers also were hit. Helicopters lifted the raiders back to Israel from Beirut.

Today, armored cars and soldiers with machine guns lined the Corniche, the wide Beirut avenue along the Mediterranean. Guerrillas in civilian clothes and camouflage fatigues and armed with bazookas, AK47 assault rifles, machine guns and pistols, emerged from the refugee camps onto the city's sidewalks.

Civilian cars were stopped at several checkpoints between the city center and the airport. Israeli forces had not struck at the Lebanese capital since December 1968, when airborne commandos hit the airport and blew up Arab airliners in retaliation for guerrilla forays. The last Israeli raid into Lebanon was Feb.

21, when seaborne commando units hit seven Arab guerrilla bases around the City of Tripoli and killed an estimated 50 Arabs. Israel claimed the Tripoli bases were training schools for Black September terrorists.

The raids today came about 12 hours after nine Arab guerrillas blew up the Israeli ambassador's apartment in Nicosia, the capital of Cyprus, and made an unsuccessful attempt to blow up an Israeli airliner at Nicosia airport.

CP-1973-030 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore

Lebanon chief quits after Israeli raids

migrants, an Italian woman bystander and about 30 other Palestinians. Israel said two of is soldiers died after the attack.

The slain guerrilla leaders were Mohammed Yussef Najjar, who is known by an assumed name as Abu Yussef and is regarded as the second-in-command of Al Fatah, the largest guerrilla group; Kamal Adwan, a member of its executive council, and Kamal Nasser, the spokesman for the Palestine Liberation Organization, the umbrella agency for most of the guerrilla groups.

Western, Jordanian and Israeli diplomatic and intelligence sources had linked Mr. Najjar and Mr. Adwan to the Black September terrorist organization. The Palestinian commandos have denied the link. A mood of fear and bitterness, some of it expressed as anti-American protest, spread through Beirut yesterday.

Student demonstrators tried to stage a protest march to the American Embassy here but were turned aside by Lebanese policemen. Palestinian guerrillas demanded to inspect an Italian Catholic boys school where they suspected Israeli soldiers were still hiding. They were allowed to search the school but found no Israelis.

The Lebanese government imposed censorship on domestic and foreign news dispatches. The Palestine News Agency, which speaks for the guerrillas, issued a statement accusing the American Central Intelligence Agency of assisting the Israeli attackers. The U.S. Embassy replied with a sharp denial.

In Israel, the raid was hailed as a “serious blow” to the Palestinian guerrillas and as a warning to Lebanon that it would face further attacks unless it cracked down harder on the commandos. Lt. Gen.

David Elazar, the Israeli chief of general staff, said at a press conference in Tel Aviv: “The Lebanese government has to draw conclusions from this operation because there is no possibility of honoring the sovereignty of Lebanon and its capital when there is complete freedom for terrorist activity, bases and command on Lebanese territory.”

The bedroom in the Beirut apartment of Kamal Nasser, a spokesman for the Palestine Liberation Organization, shows scars of the raid by Israeli commandos in which Mr. Nasser and two other guerrilla leaders were killed. — Lebanese civilians and Palestinian guerrillas view damage at the village of Ouzi. Israeli raiders struck there and at other points, including Beirut.

CP-1973-010 →

· The New York Times · page 14

Three Slain Were Prominent Commandos

Special to The New York Times

BEIRUT, Lebanon, April 10—If the Palestinian guerrilla movement had a foreign minister, Mohammed Yussef Najjar, who was killed early today by Israeli commandos, would have been a likely candidate. Mr. Najjar was one of three prominent Palestinians killed in the raid. The others were Kamal Adwan and Kamal Nasser. Abu Yussef, as Mr.

Najjar was known in the commando movement, was a founder of Al Fatah, the main guerrilla organization, when he and Yasir Arafat, now Fatah's leader were Palestinian refugees working in Kuwait in 1965.

For a while he was in the movement's second rank but began to rise to prominence after King Hussein's Army ousted most of the Palestinian guerrilla from Jordan in the 1970 civil war. Mr. Najjar was not prominent as a guerrilla fighter but he had shown unusual diplomatic and negotiating abilities. A mind-mannered man of 47, educated as an engineer, Mr.

Najjar was an expert on government relations and negotiations between guerrilla factions. He is probably the nearest thing to an Arab guerrilla diplomat. These qualities were tested in 1969 when serious problems developed between the Palestinian community and the Lebanese Government. Mr.

Najjar was put in charge of liaison between Fatah, representing politically the 250,000 Palestinians in Lebanon—many of them in refugee camps—and the Government. Friend of Politicians He became a close friend of Lebanese political leaders, including Premier Saeb Salam, who resigned today, and of many Arab ambassadors here and in other countries. Mr.

Najjar was one of the two Fatah representatives on the executive committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization. He headed the political department, which coordinates representation of the Palestine Liberation Organization in various countries, including Western Europe, as well as relations with the Arab League.

Although his name has been linked, because of reported intelligence activity, to the Black September guerrilla organization — which takes its name from the September, 1970, war in Jordan—it is not believed in informed guerrilla circles that Mr. Najjar was in any operational control of the secret terrorist group.

Kamal Adwan, about 37, rose in Fatah ranks after the Jordanian war, becoming head of the information department, but this job was short-lived because Fatah agreed to unify information services under the Palestine Liberation Organization. Organizing Resistance Since then Mr.

Adwan was said to have been assigned responsibility for organizing resistance cells among Palestinians living on the Israeli-occupied West Bank of the Jordan River. He is not so well known publicly as Mr. Najjar and has tended to stay in the background of the commando organization.

Kamal Nasser, who had been official spokesman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, did not join the active resistance until after the 1967 Arab-Israeli war when the Israelis expelled him from his home on the West Bank. Mr. Nasser, once a left-wing deputy of the Baath Socialist party in Jordan until King Hussein suppressed the party, is more of a poet than a guerrilla.

He is known in Beirut as an animated conversationalist in cafe and intellectual circles, and his allegiance to the guerrilla movement expressed itself more in words than in armed action. He became spokesman of the Palestine Liberation Organization because he was independent in his relations with the various commando groups and because of his reputation as an intellectual.

He was considered an excellent writer of Arabic poetry, an art form he had practiced since he was 15. But as an information specialist he was disorganized and often, in the view of Western journalists, imprecise and hard to find when information was wanted. Mr. Nasser was a Christian.

He had always been a peaceful man and refused to carry a gun despite warnings that his life might be in danger.

Bedroom in the Beirut apartment of Kamal Nasser, the official spokesman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, after the Israeli raid. [credit: Associated Press] / Three portrait photographs are captioned, left to right: "Kamal Nasser" (Associated Press), "Mohammed Yussef Najjar" (Associated Press), "Kamal Adwan" (United Press International).

CP-1973-020 →

· The New York Times · page 14

Lebanese Premier Resigns After Attack

[Continued From Page 1, Col. 2] said he would reply tomorrow. The Israeli raid, which followed a Palestinian commando attack on Israelis in Cyprus yesterday, is believed to have resulted in the deaths of at least seven Palestinians besides the three leaders. One of these was Mrs.

Najjar, who died while trying to shield her hus[band]... [the column runs off the bottom edge of the scan here] ...Israeli raiders blasted the door of Mr. Adwan's apartment. He was reportedly shot to death in front of his wife while he tried to fire his Kalashnikov assault rifle at the attackers.

Near the Sports City stadium and the big Palestinian refugee camp known as Shatila, a sprawling settlement of small shops, closely packed houses, [cafes and headquarters offices — column runs off the bottom edge of the scan here] ...broadcast only official communiqués.

This measure was adopted after the Palestine Liberation Organization's information office accused the United States Embassy here of having assisted in the Israeli attack. The commandos said that the Israeli raiders had “relied on elements of American military intelligence in Beirut.” The statement, issued early in the afternoon, suggested that some...

CP-1973-021 →

· (newspaper unidentified) · page 1 (jump: “RAID A REPRISAL, ISRAELI DECLARES / Continued From Page 1, Col. 3”)

Premier Quits in Lebanon; Raid Reprisal, Israel Says

3 Top Guerrillas Slain || Explanation in Tel Aviv

By JUAN de ONIS (left-hand story); By TERENCE SMITH (right-hand story)

BEIRUT, Lebanon, April 10—Premier Saeb Salam submitted his resignation today following a predawn raid by Israeli commandos in which three prominent Palestinian guerrilla leaders here were killed. Mr.

Salam, a Moslem, was a close friend of Mohammed Yussef Najjar, chairman of the political department of the Palestine Liberation Organization—the over-all guerrilla group — who was slain in a heavily guarded apartment house here. Mr. Najjar was also known by the code name Abu Yussef. “It is in the public interest that I submit my resignation,” Mr.

Salam, who has been Premier for two years, said after an emergency Cabinet meeting. || JERUSALEM, April 10 — Lieut. Gen. David Elazar, the Israeli Chief of Staff, said today that his forces’ spectacular commando raid in Beirut this morning was staged in response to “the intensification of terrorist acts in Europe and other places in the last months.”

“It is true that most of those acts failed,” he said at a news conference in Tel Aviv, “but we had to act against the phenomena of terrorist activity against Israeli targets abroad.”

General Elazar said that the raid could be considered in part as a retaliation for the Arab guerrilla assaults against an El Al airliner and the residence of the Israeli Ambassador in Cyprus yesterday, but he conceded that the timing was “to some extent a coincidence.”

His implication seemed to be that the raid actually had been planned well in advance of the Cyprus incidents and would have been carried out had they not occurred. Noting that three top guerrilla figures had been assassinated in their own apartments, he added, “The terrorist leaders now must realize our ability to find them in any place.”

The three dead guerrilla leaders were identified as Kamal Adwan, whom General Elazar described as “the man responsible for most of the terrorist activities carried out inside our country,” and Mohammed Yussef Najjar and Kamal Nasser. In an unusual move, General Elazar declined to describe any of the operational details of the raid.

He refused to comment, for instance, on Beirut reports that the Israelis had entered the Lebanese capital from the sea and had been met on the beach by a fleet of rented cars that drove them to their targets. One report said that the commandos had been dressed in civilian clothes and had been guided to their destinations by a woman.

“I have no doubt that there will be many stories coming out of Beirut,” he said with a small smile, “but we are not going to reveal the operational details because I am not sure that we will not be forced to continue this type of operation in the future.”

… Meanwhile, Premier Golda Meir convened the Cabinet at midday to hear detailed reports from the military on both the Beirut raid and the Cyprus incidents. Mrs. Meir also called a special session of Parliament to consider recent guerrilla attacks against the [one word unresolved].

Referring to the raid in Beirut, she told the Parliament: “It was very marvelous because we killed the murderers who were planning to murder again. Shining pages will be written about this.”

CP-1973-026 →

· The New York Times

Slain Palestinian Leaders Are Buried in Lebanon

...commandos fired hundreds of rounds from their automatic weapons. But Yasir Arafat, the head of the Palestine Liberation Organization, ordered the shooting halted. “Don’t waste your bullets — save them for the enemy,” said loudspeakers in the cemetery, which is in a pine wood beside the Shatila refugee camp, where [illegible]0,000 Palestinians live.

The procession from the great El-Ummari Mosque to the cemetery took more than two hours, with at least 100,000 persons marching and many thousands more along the route. The wooden coffins, each wrapped in the red, black and green flag of the Palestinian movement, bobbed like small boats on a sea of uplifted hands.

Lebanese Marronite Catholic priests in black robes and Moslem religious scholars wearing white-and-red turbans marched behind the coffins. There were nine coffins in all.

The three most prominent persons killed in the Israeli raid early Tuesday were Mohammed Yussef Najjar, head of the political department of the Palestine Liberation Organization; Kamal Nasser, the organization’s official spokesman, who was a Christian, and Kamal Adwan, an organizer of guerrilla activities in the occupied West Bank of Jordan. Mr.

Najjar’s wife was shot to death when she tried to shield her husband against the Israeli attackers who burst into their apartment and she, too, was buried today. The other dead were Palestinian guerrillas killed fighting the raiders. The procession was escorted and kept orderly by hundreds of Palestinians carrying weapons.

Many rode in pickup trucks with mounted .50-caliber machine guns, rocket and grenade launchers and other heavy weapons. During the procession, slogans were chanted that attacked the Lebanese Army for failing to strike at the Israeli raiders Tuesday.

“The army to the border with Israel!” was one slogan; another demanded “full freedom for the revolution”—the right to attack Israel from Lebanese territory. ... [no] policemen or troops in sight along the route of the procession and the commandos exercised full control, including the detention of a number of foreign journalists who were taking photographs.

This correspondent and Georgie Anne Geyer, a correspondent of The Chicago Daily News, were detained and questioned for more than two hours at an office of Al Fatah, the main guerrilla group, in the Shatila camp. The questioners appeared to be concerned primarily with the possibility that photos of commandos might fall into the hands of Israeli authorities.

“They want to hunt us,” said an interrogator who called himself George. Despite evident suspicion among the Palestinians that Israeli agents could be posing as foreign journalists, the treatment by heavily armed commandos was courteous. They shared cigarettes with us, served tea and engaged in friendly conversation after checking with sources that confirmed our identities.

Mourners in Beirut, Lebanon, trying to touch the coffin of Mohammed Yussef Najjar yesterday. The guerrilla leader, a founder of Al Fatah, was killed during an Israeli raid Tuesday. [credit: United Press International]

CP-1973-027 →

· The Mobile Register

Final Rites Held For 8 Slain Guerrillas

By HOLGER JENSEN / Associated Press Writer

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — Firing machine guns in a final salute, Palestinian guerrillas buried eight comrades killed by Israeli commandos striking in the heart of this city and Sidon. About 40,000 persons turned out for Thursday's funeral rites and heard tirades barked over bullhorns against Israel and the United States. Palestinian guerrilla leaders have accused the U.S.

Central Intelligence Agency of participating in the attacks early Tuesday that killed three top commanders. In New York, the U.N. Security Council was summoned into special session to hear a complaint of the Lebanese government against Israel. The crowd jammed approaches to the Martyrs' Cemetery in a pine forest near a Palestinian refugee camp on the edge of the city.

Loudspeakers exhorted the slain men's families: “Mothers be happy! Your sons died like real men!” REPEAT CHANT They repeated a Moslem chant, “La ilaha illa Allah” — There is no God but Allah. Guerrillas carrying the coffins danced up to the freshly dug graves then retreated to prolong the burial, signifying that the deaths at the hands of the Israelis were noble.

Then men dressed in camouflage commando uniforms fired machine-gun bursts into the air and the dead were laid to rest. The crowd dispersed quietly. The burials followed emotional funerals in a mosque and a Christian church — one guerrilla was a Protestant — and a procession by chanting mourners, many of them heavily armed, through Beirut's streets.

The city was closed down; a general strike was in effect. Symbolic funeral processions also took place in Cairo, Damascus, Baghdad and Kuwait. CARRY COFFINS The crowd of mourners in Beirut carried the coffins, draped in the green, white, black and red-striped Palestinian flags, raised above their heads along a four-mile route from the center of the city to the cemetery.

Led by Palestinians, they chanted anti-Israeli, anti-U.S. and antigovernment slogans. “The deaths of the martyrs will strengthen our revolution and pave the way to victory over Israel!” they shouted. “The Israelis didn't come by boat ... They didn't come by air ... They came from the U.S. Embassy!” they yelled.

At one point, several youths tore down a huge portrait of the Lebanese premier, Saeb Salam, who resigned after the Israeli raid. They shouted, “Down with the cowards!” Few prominent Lebanese leaders took part in the procession. Guerrilla leader Yasir Arafat was notably absent.

Guerrillas in civilian clothes and the khaki uniforms and red berets fought to prevent the mourners from toppling the coffins. Many brandished pistols, machine guns and bayoneted rifles. The U.S. Embassy was heavily guarded. Guerrillas have threatened to strike at U.S. interests in Lebanon as reprisal for the Israeli raid.

ROADBLOCKS SET Police set up roadblocks around the U.S. Embassy late Thursday and were checking occupants of cars driving past on Beirut's main Seaside Avenue. An imam, or religious leader, at services in the Omari Mosque called for a holy war “to check Israeli treachery and reclaim Islamic dignity.” At the Protestant Evangelical church, the Rev.

Fuad Bahnan praised Kamal Nasser, spokesman for the Palestine Liberation Organization, as a “true Christian because he was against oppression, and Christianity is a revolution against oppression. Let the medal of martyr you earned be blessed.”

Nasser's coffin later was taken to the mosque where the procession began, preceded by a guerrilla band with instruments that included saxophones and bagpipes. Some of the mourners chanted a poem Nasser had written, called, “We are Returning to the Usurped Homeland.” Shops and schools were closed in Beirut and other Lebanese cities to mourn the slain Palestinians.

FUNERAL FOR GUERRILLA LEADER — The coffin of slain Palestinian leader Kamal Nasser is carried from a Protestant Church in Beirut Thursday for start of funeral procession to Martyrs' Cemetery near a Palestinian refugee camp at the edge of the city. Eight victims of an Israeli raiding party into Lebanon Tuesday were buried in the Lebanese capital in a public procession.

(Mobile Register AP Wirephoto)

CP-1973-031 →

· The New York Times

Captured Papers Linked To Arab Arrests in Israel

By TERENCE SMITH

TEL AVIV, April 12 — Israeli security forces reported arresting a number of suspected Arab guerrillas in Israel and the occupied territories last night and today on the basis of documents described as having been seized Tuesday during the Israeli commando raid in Beirut.

The Israeli radio reported tonight that “scores” of suspects had been picked up in the last 24 hours, but reliable military sources said that “scores” was inflated. They confirmed, however, that arrests were continuing. “We got a lot of good information in Beirut,” one military source said, “but our men are still sifting through it.

It’s too early to say how many people will be arrested as a result or what the consequences will be.” Data Called Voluminous The documents, which the sources said were voluminous, were reported seized by the Israeli commandos who broke into the apartment of Kamal Adwan, one of the three guerrilla leaders assassinated during the raid.

The papers reportedly included plans for guerrilla actions against a number of sites in Israel in connection with the celebration May 7 of the 25th anniversary of Israeli independence. Incidents of sabotage also reportedly were scheduled for the eve of the anniversary, when it is estimated that 100,000 tourists will be in Israel.

According to reports from Beirut, the seized documents also included copies of the codes used by guerrilla radios to communicate with agents in Israeli territory. The guerrilla radio in Cairo broadcast warnings to this effect yesterday. Israeli officials declined to comment on these reports.

Meanwhile, the Arab residents of the occupied West Bank demonstrated their sympathy for the guerrilla cause today with a memorial service for Kamal Nasser, another of the slain leaders. The service was held in Beit Zaid, a small village northeast of Jerusalem, where Mr. Nasser was born. A number of leading Arabs were reported to have attended.

In addition, other Arab leaders placed notices in the Arab papers published in East Jerusalem mourning the killing of the “martyrs” in the Beirut raid. The notices drew the anger of the Defense Minister, Moshe Dayan. Speaking at a Labor party gathering in Tel Aviv tonight, Mr. Dayan said heatedly: “When I see those things, I explode.

But I realize that if we are going to give them freedom of expression — and we must—then we will have to put up with it.”

CP-1973-032 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Arab Action Against U.S., Israel Demanded in Beirut

BEIRUT (UPI) — About 70,000 mourners, shouting for revenge, lined Beirut streets or marched in the funeral procession Thursday to honor three guerrilla leaders and six other Palestinians killed in Beirut by Israeli raiders Tuesday. There were also anti-Israel and anti-American demonstrations in other Arab cities. “With blood we shall revenge you,” youths in Beirut shouted.

Others demanded: “Why don’t the Arab governments do something? Bring the Arab armies to Lebanon.” The U.N. Security Council was summoned into urgent session Thursday at Lebanon’s request to discuss the raid and “the threat it poses to the peace and security of the Middle East.”

A military source in Tel Aviv said Israeli security services have begun rounding up Arabs in Israel and Israeli-occupied territory whose names appear on guerrilla rosters captured in Tuesday’s raid. The source said scores of suspects had been arrested and charged with belonging to illegal organizations and that more arrests are expected.

In Beirut the mourners lined the three-mile route from the downtown Grand Omari Mosque, where the main funeral service was held, to the Martyrs Cemetery in a pine wood on Beirut’s southern outskirts. In Cairo, an estimated 3,000 Egyptians and Palestinians marched in a “symbolic” funeral Thursday morning.

There were surprisingly few anti-American chants during the Beirut funeral procession. But one section of mourners shouted in unison: “The enemy did not come from the sea. They did not come by submarine. They came from the American embassy.”

That echoed charges by the Palestinian guerrilla leadership that American CIA agents helped the Israeli raiders and that the U.S. embassy in Beirut sheltered them. The embassy has issued a denial of these charges. At the United Nations, U. S.

Ambassador John Scali indignantly denied Palestinian charges that the United States was involved in the Israeli raid against guerrilla bases. Scali compared the charge with the “big lie” technique of Adolf Hitler during World War II and Arab accusations, which he said later were retracted, that the United States participated actively in Israel’s war against them in 1967.

After Lebanese Ambassador Edward Ghorra opened debate with a demand for “meaningful action in order to put an end to Israel’s aggression against Lebanon,” Scali gained the floor without waiting for an Israeli reply, as is customary.

“The tragic events in Lebanon were followed by attempts to spread a big lie around the world that my government connived, colluded and in some way participated in those events and is harboring some participants in its embassy in Lebanon,” Scali said.

He said that report, not only spread by “clandestine” means but published by recognized media in many countries, was an example of Hitler’s big lie technique in World War II. “It is an art form of the totalitarian mentality,” Scali said. “By its enormity, it succeeds in deluding because no one believes that such a monstrous untruth could be invented.”

The slain leaders buried Thursday included Kamal Nasser, official spokesman for the Palestine Liberation Organization, Mohammed Yussef Najjar, deputy leader of Al Fatah and Kamal Adwan, spokesman for Al Fatah. Also in the funeral procession were the coffins of other victims of the Israeli attack, including Najjar’s wife.

Coffin of Palestinian Leader Kamal Nasser Is Carried From Church He Was a Christian, the Other Leaders Slain Were Moslems

CP-1973-033 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Holds Arab Editors On a Censorship Charge

By TERENCE SMITH

JERUSALEM, April 16—Two Palestinian editors of an East Jerusalem Arabic weekly were arrested by the Israeli police today on charges of evading censorship and inciting revolution among the residents of the West Bank of the Jordan River. The two men were the first such editors to be arrested on political grounds since the 1967 Arab-Israeli war.

They are Joseph Nasr, editor and publisher of the weekly Al Fajr, and Jamil Hamad, the assistant editor. They were taken into custody after publishing an article asserting that Israeli and Jordanian intelligence officers had met and exchanged information before the Israeli commando raid directed against Arab guerrilla headquarters in Beirut, Lebanon, last week.

Israeli officials dismissed the report as a fabrication. A court today ordered the editors held in custody for 15 days while the prosecution prepared its case. Announcing the charges today, a police spokesman said that the two editors had published the article about alleged collusion between the Jordanians and Israelis without having submitted it to the censor.

Israeli law requires that all material intended for appearance in the press be submitted to a military censor for examination before publication. Emotional Editorial In addition to the news report, the paper ran an emotional editorial on the front page mourning the death of the three guerrilla leaders assassinated during the Beirut raid.

The editorial said that the funeral for these “martyrs should be the occasion for a national procession in which we celebrate the birth of a thousand more Abu Yussefs and Kamal Nassers.” Abu Yussef—the code name for Mohammed Yussef Najjar—was one of the three guerrillas. He was chairman of the political department of the Palestine Liberation Organization.

Kamal Nasser was spokesman for the organization, which is the over-all guerrilla group. The third victim was Kamal Badwan, an organizer of guerrilla activity on the West Bank. The editorial—with a photograph of Mr. Nasser bordered in black—said, “We should thank the Israelis because they have taught us again how to love Palestine, its people and its land to the death.”

The editorial was the most militant of a series of sympathetic articles about the slain guerrillas and their cause in the three Arabic dailies and three weeklies published in the former Jordanian sector of Jerusalem.

Israelis Startled This sudden and conspicuous display of identification with the guerrilla movement has startled many Israelis and has forced them to question the apparent goodwill toward Israel that seemed to have developed among West Bank Arabs since 1967. Finance Minister Pinhas Sapir expressed disappointment in a weekend interview with Maariv, an Israeli daily.

He said that the fiction of a gradual reconciliation between Israelis and the West Bank Arabs “has crashed up against the wall of cruel reality.” Although violations of the censorship law are frequent, and journalists in past cases have lost their credentials as a result of them, none had been arrested.

CP-1973-017 →

· The Anniston Star · page 5A

Beirut: Night of bombs, machine guns

By GAVIN YOUNG

BEIRUT—Madame Clara Morelli, a harmless Italian lady, aged 64, woke up at about 1 a.m. on Tuesday when a bomb blew out the door of her flat. When she went to see that was happening a machine-gun burst hit her in the face. Madame Morelli was in Beirut on a visit to her grandchildren.

Unfortunately, she stayed in the same building as one of the three Palestinian leaders killed so spectacularly this week by Israeli gunmen. She is not the first or last innocent to be killed by Israelis or Arabs. “Very marvelous, shining pages will be written about this,” said Golda Meir, the prime minister of Israel, after the operation. It was indeed brilliant.

But it has set the Arab-Israeli struggle firmly in the gutter. It was planned a long time ago, so the operation was not a retaliation for the two abortive and senseless Palestinian terror attacks in Cyprus the day before—one consisting of a bomb that destroyed half the Israeli ambassador's residence, the other a futile shoot-out around a pilotless El Al plane on the runway.

The Israeli agents who strolled in to Beirut as tourists came via Europe more than a week ago. Mrs. Meir referred to them sentimentally as “our boys.” Some were hardly boys.

THEY PRESENTED valid-looking passports to their hotel receptionists: Gilbert Limbert, 35, Belgian; Pieter Althofer, West German; Andrew Witchlow, 47, British; Charles Haussart, 41, Belgian, coming from Rome; George Elder, 31, British, coming from Frankfurt; Andrew Maisy, British, from Munich. However false their passports, they were not in their first youth.

The hotels were chosen as much for convenience as comfort, for they are all on or very near the coast outside Beirut: The coral beach, the Sands, the Atlantic. The Englishmen were “very polite, very English.” They were eccentrically addicted to midnight fishing at sea, the hotel staff said later, scratching their heads.

(They left without paying—“Bill to be settled 24 hours before checkout,” a notice says in my hotel.) They rented some fast cars—three Buick Skylarks, a Plymouth Valiant, a Plymouth station wagon, a Renault 16. Very early Tuesday morning, they drove to the sea front and picked up the uniformed Israeli commandos who had landed from small boats and gunboats south of the city.

They landed cheekily, on a beach that is well overlooked by houses and hotels. While one force attacked a building heavily guarded by Palestinian guerrillas of the leftist organization, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), others sped off to the Rue Verdun area.

There they spring from the cars and into two apartment buildings in narrow Khalid Ibn Walid Street. THIS IS WHERE the morning's main business was conducted. One Palestinian target, Kamal Adwan, seems to have come to his apartment door and been shot on the threshold.

Mohamed Youssef El Najjar (code name Abu Youssef) and his wife were riddled with machine-gun bullets side by side in bed. Kamal Nasser was sitting in his pajamas writing when he heard the shots and explosions outside. He picked up a pistol, but the door was shot open and the machine-guns gave him no chance. This was about the time that Madame Morelli was shot.

Kamal Nasser was a poet and a spokesman for Al Fatah. He was frequently heard on Arab radio stations; he was famous for his voice. So there was a particularly vicious element to his end.

As he lay dead on the stone floor, leaking blood into a small Arab rug, amid the wreckage of the furniture, the cheap record player, the plastic venetian blind, someone stopped to fire 10 or 12 shots into his mouth and jaw. All three men had been to a meeting that night. They had obviously been watched meticulously for days.

Stupidly, fatally, they had neglected the urgent rule that says “Don't stay in the same room or house two nights running. Don't make a routine.” After years of semi-clandestine political life, these Palestinians had not yet thrown off the customs and inclinations of their upbringing.

As if to show an assassin the way, Abu Youssef had even pinned his name-card to the outside of his front door like any proud householder. KAMAL NASSER HAD discussed the possibility of an Israeli murder attack. “I fully believe they could come to Beirut,” he told friends. But he couldn't leave the urban life he'd grown up with.

Abu Youssef and Kamal Adwan said they needed a normal life to bring up their families in, a life near schools and supermarkets. Yasser Arafat, the Al Fatah chief, and other Palestinian leaders, resist these temptations and keep moving.

Kamal Nasser was not only a poet—one of the best Arab poets, most agree, to emerge in the 1960s—he was a large, ebullient, highly emotional man, with a loud voice, a cruel wit, an eye for the girls, and a speaker of his mind—which got him into trouble at times with people like President Nasser or even Yasser Arafat, his boss. He was afraid to die and could joke about that.

At the height of King Hussein's crackdown on the Palestinian guerrillas in Jordan in 1970, Arafat said: “Kamal, go to Amman at once.” Nasser, in mock anguish, replied: “Please I beg you. My name is Kamal Butros Nasser, not Richard the Lionheart”!

He was a Christian from a highly respectable family connected to a fine college at Bir Zeit, near Jerusalem on the occupied West Bank of Jordan. Kamal Nasser was obsessed by Israel's occupation of Arab lands. He was possessed by that nationalistic demon that inspires thousands of his countrymen. But he was not a terrorist.

He was, in fact, considered a moderate in the Palestinian spectrum. Kamal Adwan was of sterner stuff—dour, unsmiling, bitter-tongued. He was once in the fanatical Muslim Brotherhood. He might have condoned terrorism. IT MAY CONSIST of some Fatah members and other group members as well. But it seems to be amorphous—an almost freelance affair.

It does not refer, for example, to Arafat or other leaders before a strike. It has acted, as in the shooting at the Saudi Arabian Embassy in Khartoum, against the current interests of Al Fatah, which was at that moment trying to get a large sum of money unfrozen from Saudi banks.

The third man who died, Abu Youssef, was the Fatah high committee member who had just been in Riyadh negotiating the release of the money, so it is unlikely that he would be the one to pull the trigger in Khartoum, even by remote control. Abu Youssef came originally from Jaffa. After its fall to the Israelis in 1948, he went to the Persian Gulf.

Like Kamal Nasser, he joined Al Fatah after the Arab defeat in the Six-Day War of 1967. He was quiet, a little austere-looking, responsible for Al Fatah's relations with Lebanon. The killing of the three prominent Palestinians was the nub of the Israeli raid.

But it seems that the plan evolved in Tel Aviv had been intended to do away with other leaders too—Yasser Arafat, perhaps, or his number two man, Abu Ayyad. But they were elusive. The other actions in Tuesday's darkness were comparatively unspectacular.

In the attack on the PFLP, perhaps five Palestinians were killed and others wounded, but here it seems after much shooting the Israelis were repulsed.

They and the force in civilian clothes from Rue Verdain sped back to the beach in their cars, to the waiting boats back past the “After Eight” night club and Panayotis Restaurant, the shimmering new apartment blocks with their sleeping Kuwaiti sheikhs, playboys, silk-pajamaed crooks and businessmen. Near the airport at Ouzai, the Israelis blew up a number of houses.

Next day, puzzled Lebanese workers in the area said “Why here? There are no Palestinians there.” THERE SEEMS TO BE MORE point to the attack at Dora. This is on the north side of Beirut on the road to the Casino du Liban, with its Paris Lido-like chorus girls, waterfalls, live horses on stage, and a gambling hall as big as a dance-hall.

Here the Israelis seem to have destroyed a garage, a store or two, a small machine shop belonging to a Palestinian called Hassan Laza, and, more important, a guerrilla explosives factory. At Sidon, the petrol station and garage on the beach that was blown up had not been in use for vehicle maintenance by Al Fatah for a month.

It did not seem a blow at the very vitals of Palestinian terror. All that remained after the withdrawal—which, according to some, came three hours after the landings—were the cars, some Biretta pistols with silencers, sub-machine guns, a pair of black street shoes. And a general conviction that in other hotels in Beirut there were other undercover “tourists” still.

Perhaps that's why the Israeli chief of staff Gen. David Elazar declined to reveal in his press conference last week just what had happened in Beirut on Tuesday morning. It may prove to be the first of a series. It also left behind anguish, shame, a vast impatience, and a considerably enhanced hatred for America.

The rumor is believed that the Americans were in cahoots with the Israelis and even that one or two cars were driven by the raiders into sanctuary in the American Embassy compound on the seafront. “ONE OF OUR CARS followed a raider's car down into the city. At the embassy police check point, the raider's car was allowed through, ours was stopped.

What does that mean, I ask you?” That was said to me by a very unhysterical Palestinian friend. Certainly, Gen. Aharon Yariv, who organizes counter-terror raids for the Israelis, could hardly have a more favourable battleground than Lebanon in general and Beirut in particular. The Israelis need not be supermen to succeed here. Lebanese society is venal to a high degree.

And many Lebanese detest the Palestinians for disrupting the calm climate needed for compulsive money-making. We paid a dollar and got our visas. How, even if everyone is honest, do you keep Israelis out of a holiday country? But the Palestinians have other things to beat. Not only Israelis but King Hussein's Jordanians, too, want to eliminate the guerrillas.

Arabs and Israelis infiltrate them. If the Americans don't try to implant six-foot CIA men into Palestinian ranks it is not because they wouldn't like to, particularly after two American diplomats were killed by Black September at Khartoum. Few doubt that the CIA helps the Israelis with operational information, at the very least.

Thus Al Fatah may be wrong to say that the Americans physically helped the Israelis the other night. But they are not wrong to regard the American government as their enemy. SO THE PALESTINIANS cannot be blamed for seeing murderous hands behind simple things.

The street lighting suddenly cutting out on the cornice, the telephones in several Palestinian offices going dead simultaneously. Their enemies are amongst them. This week's events are a serious escalation. The Israeli army, in raids along Lebanon's borders, as in raids on Jordan in the past, have killed scores of Arab civilians.

Their counter-terror has knocked off Palestinian representatives in Paris and Rome and other individuals in other places. But large-scale operations into a city like Beirut are something else. Next time, more innocent people than Madame Morelli may be killed. All this is not to bury Arab murders—Munich, Wasfi Tel and the diplomats at Khartoum by Black September among them.

Each side is accumulating that sort of “battle honor.” It is possible that the Palestinian commando organizations will move out of Beirut—perhaps to Cairo (a little remote) or Damascus (not much more secure than Beirut). But the war is not going to end here. The Palestinian operations — by Black September or other groups—are sure to continue.

Three middle-aged martyrs—and they are regarded as such—will not deter the younger generation. They learned their notions of terror operations from the various Zionist terrorists of the pre-Israel years: The blowing up of British headquarters, the barrels of explosive rolled into market places, political assassinations. NOW THE WHEEL has turned again.

Both sides have adopted the letter bomb, the silenced revolver, the electronic device detonated by a telephone call. The aspirations of Israelis and Palestinians are essentially noble. The anguished, deprived young Palestinian student and the young Israeli in his kibbutz or university are equally fine.

But now those mutual aspirations have driven their leaders far from the ideal. There is a difference between a straight military confrontation and the sticks of dynamite under a suburban bed. The leaders of Black September remain in the shadows, more prudent but not necessarily the more heroic for that.

The Israelis succeed brilliantly in detail, but in doing so, they do not rid themselves of a degrading conflict.

CP-1973-028 →

· The New York Times · New York

Remembering A Victim in Palestine

“Would we visit his family? His uncle Musa Nasir runs the private college at Beir Zeit, not far from Jerusalem, on the West Bank. Tell them I’m well. Give them my love.”

Kamal Nasser, the PLO’s spokesman, was assassinated in his Beirut apartment by Israeli commandos in April 1973. The woman who writes this met him as a journalist and places him in a sentence with Panther headquarters in Chicago, Berkeley, Wounded Knee, East Los Angeles and Bedford-Stuyvesant. An American drawing that map in the Times in 1973.

CP-1973-014 →

· Longview Daily News

Death threats not chasing Palestinians from ‘jobs’

By Gavin Young, The London Observer

Consider it. You go to your office one morning. You open your mail and a bomb explodes in your face. Mightn’t you be thinking seriously of changing your job? If you are Palestinian, probably not. Bassam Abu Sharif, a youngish university graduate, spokesman for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) whose leader is Dr.

George Habash, was aware that Israeli agents would try to kill him. His boss, poet and author Ghassan Kanafai, had recently been blown to pieces in his car. Bassam’s bomb would come. It came by post in a small book that had Che Guevara’s picture on the cover. He flicked the pages and saw it, flat, brown, waxy, like a book within a book.

There was nothing he could do. The explosion hurled him across the room. But he was lucky: It only destroyed three fingers and one eye. That was last year. Today Bassam, scarred, mutilated, wearing dark glasses, is back in his office among the handouts, the coffee cups and the posters. As before, he is dispensing information, not organizing terror.

He says: “I’d be lying if I told you that it’s not a strain living under threat. But I knew what joining the movement might mean. When I was hit, I didn’t think for a moment of leaving. Perhaps I’m more determined now.” ISAREL IS 25 YEARS old this week.

After a quarter-century of dreams, sweat and tears, what is the state of Palestinian resistance? What makes Bassam run? The Palestinian movement as a whole is at a low ebb, although certainly not down and out.

Almost pacified in Israel itself and the occupied territories, driven out of Jordan in 1971, contained in Syria, in open conflict with Lebanon’s army, the Fedayeen organizations have been going through a period of reappraisal. In their top ranks, self-criticism has abounded. At least a wild scrimmage for leadership has been avoided.

Yasser Arafat of Al Fatah, George Habash of the PFLR and Naif Hawatmeh of the Popular Democratic Front remain in control of their groups. No one is thinking of changing them. Still, these are hard times. The level of operations into Israel seems to have fallen to near zero. They always seemed unwise against a regular Israeli army.

Apart from that, King Hussein has denied them a long, immensely valuable frontier with Israel. The intelligence services of Israel, Jordan, America, perhaps other states too, work assiduously against them. IMAGES FILL THE PALESTINIAN mind that may never be eradicated.

In 1948, a young Yigal Allon whispering to Arab headmen in Galilee that the Jews would burn every Arab village, all Arabs should escape while there was time. “The flight numbered myraids,” Allon wrote later.

A younger Moshe Dayan driving with his soldiers hell-for-leather through Lydda (Lod) in July 1948, shooting up the town to drive the Arab population of 30,000 in terror into exile. In the context of the birth of Israel 25 years ago, those incidents are mild. But to Palestinians, they are as evocative as a portrait of Abraham Lincoln on an American living-room wall.

George Habash says: “You get up each day and there’s a choice: Is it going to be tea this morning or Nescafe? Shall I go to this or that country for a week or a month? We live daily in camps. And how people live dictates their way of thinking.”

[EDITORIAL CARTOON ABOVE THE ARTICLE] ‘Ah, but it’s great to be young!’

CP-1973-034 →

· Newsday · Melville · page 1

Arab women in the Jabalia refugee camp get their UN-supplied food

“Arab women in the Jabalia refugee camp get their UN-supplied food: They have been living there for 25 years . . . They want to go back.”

“Arab women in the Jabalia refugee camp get their UN-supplied food: They have been living there for 25 years . . . They want to go back.”

A photograph and its caption. The caption’s second half is set in italic, as a separate thought: what the women want.

CP-1973-003 →

· Honolulu Advertiser · page A-12

Allon's plan for peace in Mideast

Agence France-Presse

TEL AVIV — The Palestinians have “legitimate rights” to territory and King Hussein's plan for a federal kingdom is a possible solution, Israeli Deputy Prime Minister Yigal Allon has declared. Speaking out his peace ideas at length last weekend, the No.

2 member of the government, after Prime Minister Golda Meir, called for restitution of most of the territory seized from the Arabs by Israel in 1967. Security was impossible if Israel gave up all the occupied territories but peace was impossible if it kept them all, Allon yesterday told a symposium in Jerusalem on ways of achieving peace in the Middle East.

A COMPROMISE was needed, he said, adding: “Even if the adversary refuses it, it is better for the blame to fall on him.” Observers described Allon's plan as a platform for an expected effort by the deputy premier to succeed Mrs. Meir in the premiership when she eventually retires.

He said Israel must keep its sights set firmly on peace “because without that goal the most just of wars becomes corrupted.” Jews and Arabs were as capable of living together as were Frenchmen and Germans, he added.

While Israel had historical rights to the whole of Palestine, it would be a mistake to try to translate those rights into the “political realities of today.” The past was important “but our duty is to the present and future,” he said. And the Palestinian community also had“legitimate rights.”

While it had never had a national existence, the fact remained that “an Arab population has lived on this and for centuries and developed its own personality.” TWO NATIONAL homelands coexisted in Palestine, Allon went on: Israel and Palestinian entity, which could be named Jordan or something else.

CP-1973-018 →

· Corpus Christi Caller · Corpus Christi · page 1

Palestinian food, music survive

“Mrs. Donald Hanna, the former Norma Pennon, discussed Palestinian wedding customs. ‘Weddings are usually large and elaborate,’ she said. ‘There is a lot of singing and dancing. In fact, guests go to the home of either the bride or the groom several nights before the wedding, so that there is a series of parties.’

The guests compose songs spontaneously in Arabic and make specific references to the bride and groom. The odd, bamboo flutes and the durbaeque are used to welcome the guests. The durbaeque is a small, highly-ornamented drum. The Hannas were of the Syrian Orthodox faith and are now members of the Episcopal Church. Hanna has never returned to his hometown, Ramallah.

The town had been the scene of considerable fighting during World War I when he was still a boy. Their home was 10 blocks from the downtown area and cannons sounded for four or five days during one fight between the Turks and the English.

Other homes were destroyed, but the Hannas’ house was not hit.… ‘Family ties are very strong and we are stricter with our children than most people,’ Dr. Hanna said.

‘Grandparents play an important role; they are looked up to and their wisdom is depended on.’… ‘When I was growing up here, I learned what discrimination was because people thought I was a Mexican-American,’ Dr. Hanna said.

‘I used to tell them that if they wanted to dislike me, then do it for what I was.’ He helped in the grocery story and later worked his way through college and dental school as an ice man, in a filling station, as an oilfield roughneck and as a Fuller Brush salesman… His father said that sometimes discrimination closed doors to Middle Eastern immigrants.

He recalled not being able to eat in places in Refugio when he was still traveling… The number of Arabic-speaking families in Corpus Christi was still under a dozen when Mr. and Mrs. Said Karam and their daughter, Amelia, came here from Omaha, Neb., in 1929.”

A family group of thirteen, three generations of Hannas, named individually in the caption: Mrs. Fahed Hanna holding Robert Hanna Jr., Gail Hanna, Fahed Hanna, Iris Hanna and Kelly Hanna in the foreground; Dr. and Mrs. Donald Hanna and Chrissy in the middle row; Owen Hanna, Mrs. Robert Hanna and Robert Hanna behind.

A Sunday feature on the Arabic-speaking families of Corpus Christi, in which the Palestinian one gets its own standing head: Palestinian food, music survive. What survives is a wedding — nights of parties before the day, songs composed on the spot in Arabic naming the bride and groom, bamboo flutes and a small ornamented drum the paper spells durbaeque. A dentist who worked oilfields and sold Fuller brushes says the discrimination he grew up with was for being taken for Mexican-American. Thirteen members of the family are named in the photograph caption.

CP-1973-006 →

· Birmingham Post Herald · Birmingham

Israel calls Habash top terrorist

NICOSIA, Cyprus — There is only one man now among the Arab commando leaders the Israelis would do anything to get their hands on—revolutionary terrorist George Habash. This was demonstrated on Friday night when they defied world opinion and forced down a Lebanese airliner they believed he was travelling in.

For Habash is the man who first led the Palestine commandos into the terror tactic of hijacking, kidnapping, and the mass murder of innocents, in the name of revolution and the fight against Israel. Habash, born 47 years ago in Palestine, a medical graduate of the American University in Beirut, has been an extreme revolutionary most of his adult life.

He was the founder of the Arab Nationalist Movement, a political party dedicated to the idea of Arab unity and the overthrow of the “reactionary regimes” he believed stood in the way. For that reason his party was not recognized by most Arab regimes. But he had his agents scattered throughout the Middle East.

His men were the hard core of the National Liberation Front which carried out terror campaigns against the British in Aden from 1964 to 1967 and are now leading members of the Chinese-backed extreme left regime there. His men are at work now in Yemen, Oman and the Persian Gulf.

After the Arab defeat in the war against Israel in 1967 he abandoned the A.N.M. and set up a Maoist revolutionary commando group—the now notorious Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. His followers preach the gospel of Mao through all the Palestine refugee camps in Jordan and Lebanon.

Correction: The caption read 15 August 1993. The masthead on the scan reads "Wednesday, August 15, 1973"; 15 August 1973 was a Wednesday and 15 August 1993 was a Sunday.

CP-1973-011 →

· The Sun · Baltimore

Mideast war begins again

Mideast war begins again (Photos by UPI) Wounded soldier wheeled into hospital Israeli reservists prepare to move out ISRAELI DECRESSIE MORE ABA LAND NIXON CAN ILURESSTION PALESTINE Arab demonstration in New York HARVIS-INTE Israeli demonstration in New York A victim views her shambles

A page of United Press International photographs with captions; there is no article text.

CP-1973-007 →

· The Sun · Baltimore

Hussein Asks Nixon Palestine Backing

WASHINGTON (AP) — Jordan’s King Hussein arrived at the White House today and met with President Nixon to urge support for his plan to establish a semiautonomous Palestinian nation on the west bank of the Jordan. Nixon met Hussein in his Oval Office in the White House. Before the start of the actual talks the two posed for pictures and chatted.

The meeting was private and in addition to seeking American backing for his Palestinian proposal, Hussein is expected to ask for $40 million in new U.S. military aid for the next fiscal year. HUSSEIN’S visit, his fifth since the 1967 Arab-Israeli war and third since Nixon became president, is described as strictly private.

In addition to his appointment with the President, the king will lunch with Secretary of State William P. Rogers and return to the White House for a dinner with Nixon. Hussein might elicit an American reaction to his proposal for a semiautonomous Palestinian state on the West Bank, now occupied by Israel.

Since the king disclosed his plan in a speech March 15, U.S. officials have declined any comment on it. Nor has there been a response from the pro-Arab Soviet Union, despite noisy denunciations of the Hussein proposal in several Arab capitals. SILENCE should not be interpreted as approval, some officials say privately.

They acknowledged, however, that Hussein’s initiative at least represents some movement in an otherwise-frozen situation. Informists say the United States had no part in the preparation of the proposal and was not informed of it officially before the monarch spoke.

Military aid to Jordan, suspended when Hussein ignored Washington’s advice and went to war against Israel in 1967, was resumed in the fall of 1970 after the king defeated the Palestinian guerillas in Jordan and their Syrian supporters.

Under a supplemental appropriation voted be Congress in December of that year, Jordan has received $30 million, and the current fiscal-year budget provides for a $45 million grant to Jordan. The Administration is asking for $40 million for the coming fiscal year.

CP-1973-008 →

· The New York Times

Israeli Press Curb Illustrates Problems in Coverage of War

By TERENCE SMITH

BEERSHEBA, Israel, Oct. 16 — Israeli military authorities today barred newsmen from the Sinai Peninsula, where a major battle of the war remains to be fought. The action was one illustration of why certain aspects of the Israeli-Arab war are reported in detail, and others not at all.

A group of journalists including this reporter was turned back early this morning when it reached this Negev town, which serves as the headquarters for the southern command. The newsmen had departed for the canal front from Tel Aviv two hours earlier with an escort officer and full authorization to visit the Israeli lines in Sinai.

An Israeli source said later that the newsmen had been barred because of intensified shelling and fighting in the central sector of the front. Problem for Newsmen The curb was an example of the problems the still-growing army of foreign journalists is encountering in attempting to report Israel’s fourth war with the Arabs.

The international press corps that gathered in Israel this week is one of the largest ever assembled anywhere. More than 600 newspaper and magazine reporters, photographers and television personnel from more than 30 countries have been accredited since the war began 11 days ago. The basic Israeli policy is not to permit newsmen to accompany forces at the front.

The policy seems to stem not so much from a desire for secrecy as a concern over congestion at the front and the safety of the newsmen. As a result, no newsmen were permitted to visit either front until last Wednesday, the fifth day of the war.

By then, the Israelis had broken the back of the Syrian offensive in the Golan heights and had retaken all but small pockets of the area west of the former cease-fire line. Since then, reporters have had considerable freedom of movement on the Golan heights.

Because of the area’s rolling, almost treeless terrain and because the forces there are relatively concentrated, it is possible to see the fighting on the Syrian front and to follow its course in at least a limited area. In Sinai, however, it has been another story.

The area is vast, the front is three times as long as that on the Golan heights and the Israeli forces have been mostly on the defensive. Until the area was closed today, newsmen were able to drive to bases 15 to 20 miles back from the canal. But they saw little real action.

In the absence of personal observation, newsmen have only the official military communiqués issued several times a day and a nightly briefing provided in Tel Aviv by a reserve colonel from the army spokesman’s office.

Data Often Conflict Frequently the information and battle-damage figures conflict with the descriptions emanating from the Arab countries, leaving the newsmen little alternative but to take account of both. One factor influencing the reporting from the Israeli side is the military censorship of all news articles and film transmitted from here.

All articles, including this one, must be submitted in advance of transmission to military censors who scrutinize them line by line for information they regard as useful to the enemy. Israeli censorship is in effect even in peacetime, but is far more rigorously applied in wartime.

In most cases, the deletions ordered by the censors are arguable on the grounds of legitimate security interests of a nation at war. In some instances, however, the objective is clearly to sustain the public morale and protect the Israeli image.

CP-1973-024 →

· Kenosha News · Kenosha · page 1

Arabs and Jews: To whom was the "Promised Land" promised?

To whom was the “Promised Land” promised? An historical perspective on the Middle East war.

Robert Cochnar

“The Palestinian Refugees. An armistice was arranged in 1949, but there was no peace. The Palestinian Arab state was never created. Instead, Jordan annexed the territory west of the Jordan river, Egypt assumed a protectorate over the Gaza Strip, and Israel absorbed a part of Jerusalem, the Negev and parts of Galilee.

The general Arab reaction to the establishment of Israel was ‘one of bitterness, frustration, and a sense of humiliated impotence,’ according to the AFSC. ‘Their chief satisfaction for a long time came from a war of propaganda rarely matched in passion and vituperation . . .

But they have believed that their cause was just and that it would prevail in the end.’ But the establishment of Israel had another, more specific, result: a group of Palestinian Arabs, who had been promised a separate state, were now homeless refugees. Today a second generation of refugees live in squalid camps, eating food supplied by the U.N.

Relief and Works Agency, clinging to a dimmed hope that they will one day return to Palestine, a land which technically no longer exists. The refugees have no home left. Nor have they been compensated for the property they lost.

This is the source of their bitterness — a bitterness which has spawned the Palestinian Liberation Organization, the El Fatah, the Black September Movement and other groups which, encouraged by the Arab states, have staged hijackings, murders and terrorist attacks of protest around the world.

Moreover, the Palestinian refugees have been abandoned by the rest of the world. Arab countries have not attempted to resettle refugees because, they say, a successful resettlement would help the world forget Israeli injustice and would solidify the existence of Israel as a fait accompli.”

Printed during the October war, in Wisconsin, as background. The AFSC is the American Friends Service Committee, cited earlier in the same piece. The section runs beside advertisements for Halloween costumes and Schlitz.

CP-1973-004 →

· The New York Times · New York

Middle East Stirs Arabs in Brooklyn

“‘We cannot stay here. We cannot go back to our homes in Palestine. So, we think about it all the time,’ said Ali Abdul Jabbar, a young Palestinian student-turned-salesman, one of 30,000 Arabs…”

Shuja Nawaz, in a Brooklyn mosque and an Arab club on Court Street, during the oil embargo. A named Palestinian in New York saying the sentence the whole archive circles: cannot stay, cannot return.

CP-1973-016 →

· Courier-Journal · Louisville · page 45

A Free Palestine

Some proposals for a secure peace to include the forgotten Arabs

By Arnold Toynbee

A Free Palestine once more, and by 1973 the phrase has changed hands entirely. In 1915 and 1917 and 1920 the New York Times used it for a Zionist project (CP-1915-001, CP-1917-003, CP-1920-005). Here it heads a proposal to include the forgotten Arabs. The same three words, the same paper country, fifty-eight years, and the people they refer to have swapped. The byline is Arnold Toynbee, the historian, then 84 and a year from his death, writing in a Louisville Sunday paper.

CP-1973-005 →

· The New York Times

Most Arabs Boycott Jerusalem Election

By HENRY KAMM

JERUSALEM, Dec. 31 — The great majority of East Jerusalem's Arabs boycotted today's municipal election, setting back Israeli hopes for advancing the integration of the city under Israeli rule. Jerusalem was divided between Israel and Jordan until the 1967 war.

All resident foreigners in Israel are eligible to vote in local elections, while only Israeli citizens vote for the national government. East Jerusalem, having been annexed by Israel, is the only territory occupied in 1967 where elections were held today.

Shortly after the polls closed at 11 P.M., aides to Mayor Teddy Kollek, whose re-election was believed to be nearly certain, reported Arab participation at about 5,000 votes, or 12 per cent of the 43,000 eligible voters. In the last city election in 1969, 7,800, or 22 per cent of 35,000 Arab voters, cast their ballots.

Until last October's fighting, Israeli officials appeared to be justified in the hope that this year's turnout of Arab voters would surpass that of 1969. The war, however, has enhanced Arab nationalism, and the beginning of Arab-Israeli peace negotiations has raised Arab hopes for a change in the total control of Jerusalem by Israel.

The widespread Arab boycott reflected also a campaign by the branch of the Palestine Liberation Organization in the Jordanian territories occupied by Israel to intimidate Arabs from participating in the election. Mr. Kollek said two cars belonging to Arab managers of his re-election campaign had been stolen, overturned and burned in the last 24 hours.

Large quantities of printed pamphlets signed by the National Front for the Defense of Palestine, affiliated with the Palestine Liberation Organization, have been circulated and posted in the last three days, he said. The leaflets listed the names of Arabs participating in the election campaign, accusing them of treason. They warned Arabs against voting.

Meron Benvenisti, an associate of Mr. Kollek on the City Council and manager of his campaign in Arab Jerusalem, said also that a number of his Arab assistants had been threatened and the house of his chief Arab aide, whose car was burned last night, had been smeared with the inscription “You are a traitor.” “I wouldn't like to be in their shoes,” Mr.

Benvenisti said of his Arab associates. “I understand their terrible dilemma. They're Arabs and they're trying to do the best for their people.” The bulk of Jerusalem's Arab vote normally goes to Mr. Kollek, who has emphasized equal status for Arabs in the city.

Friction in Arab Community The election campaign has caused serious friction among some sectors of the Arab population. Eleven editorial members of the Arab daily Al Quds went on strike yesterday because the publisher, Mahmoud Abu Zuluf, printed a full-page campaign advertisement for Mr. Kollek. The walkout left Mr.

Zuluf to publish his newspaper with almost no editorial assistance, which he intends to do. Ali Khatib, editor of Al Shaab, the other Arab daily, has refused such advertising. Interviewed at his office today, he said: “If they gave me all the money in the Bank of Israel to publish one line, I would not do it.” Mr.

Khatib presented printers' proofs of his editorial denouncing the election, which bore the stamp of the Israeli censor and markings deleting almost the full text. Instead, Mr. Khatib printed under his standard heading on the front page, “The Talk of the Shops,” the terse comment, “We regret, we did not find it.” Mr.

Khatib said that the boycott of the election by most of the 43,000 eligible Arab voters proved that “99 per cent of the population of Jerusalem as well as the entire West Bank are against the occupation, against annexation, against all actions done by Israel.” While Mr.

Khatib's estimate appeared high, it was difficult today for a foreigner to find among his Arab acquaintances anyone who would admit having made use of his right to vote. “No, I won't” a young man said when asked whether he would vote. “It's not ours. It's against our will.” “I might vote,” said his friend, “in 1975 or 1976, I hope.”

He was alluding to a hope, born of the war and its diplomatic aftermath, that by then Jerusalem's Arabs would be free of Israel's dominance. A waiter replied when asked whether he had voted: “No, I don't have to, I don't work for the government.”

Many here feel that Arabs who vote are either municipal employes protecting their jobs or merchants requiring licenses or permits, or poor people responding to political bribes.

CP-1974-028 →

· The New York Times

The Terrorist: Intellectual, Radical, a Political Loser

By John L. Hess

Terrorism became so commonplace in 1973 that only the most spectacular exploits made the newscasts. Between the commercials, embassies were sacked, hostages were killed, travelers were massacred at the Rome airport and Beirut was penetrated by commandos who executed enemies in their beds. Will the option be renewed in 1974? There seemed little doubt it would.

A prominent London Jew who had aided the Israelis was shot on New Year’s eve and there were reports of an Arab death squad loose in the city.

Yesterday, the British Army went to the extraordinary length of ringing Heathrow Airport, one of the world’s busiest, with light tanks and armored cars to thwart what was reported to be a plot by terrorists to shoot down an American or Israeli commercial plane.

While the men and women who engage in acts of terror are very different from country to country, while their educational backgrounds may be totally dissimilar and their places on the economic ladder uneven, there are nonetheless threads of outlook and behavior that establish a pattern among terrorists.

The typical leader of a terrorist movement is a radical intellectual, fired by patriotism and/or a sense of social injustice, who, thwarted by political defeats and frustrations, turns more and more toward violence. Such is Dr. George Habash, a graduate of the American University of Beirut and leader of the extremist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.

Such were his associates Ghassan Kanafani, a gentle-mannered novelist and party spokesman killed by a boobytrap in his automobile; Bassem Hassan, another writer, blinded by a letter bomb; and Mr. Hassan’s wife, Leila Khaled, born in Haifa, trained at the American University, and the hijacker of three airliners.

Their followers were less educated youths, recruited in the squalor of the Palestinian refugee camps in and outside Israel. They trained to become fedayin, guerrilla fighters staging sneak attacks into Israel. But successive defeats and the crushing of the fedayin by King Hussein of Jordan in September, 1970, ended most forays into Israel.

Excitement of the Bomb Chiefs of the Provisional wing of the Irish Republican Army are also moderately educated men. Their followers, however, are slum youths snared by the excitement of the ambush, the skirmish and the bomb. In the Bronx, they might be members of fighting gangs; in Northern Ireland they have produced warfare that has taken 1,000 lives in recent years.

Radical intellectuals in Latin America have tried through example to enlist peasants and workers in violent resistance to dictatorship or oligarchic rule. Except for Cuba, they have generally failed. But here and there, some keep trying. The Palestinians have perhaps tried hardest. And of the Palestinians, the “Black September” group has been the most ferocious.

It emerged on the Middle East scene with the assassination in Cairo in November, 1971, of Jordanian Premier Wasfi Tal. The action was widely popular in Palestinian quarters and it gave the Black September group the impetus that culminated in the massacre at the 1972 Munich Olympics.

Black September was organized so secretively that even today the identity of most of its leaders is uncertain. One leader who was known was Daoud Audeh, better known as Abou Daoud. He was arrested in Jordan last February and sentenced to death. He was later reprieved and released by King Hussein.

The Palestinian activities have provoked counterterrorism by Israelis to the extent that a secret “war” has raged around the world. Arabs have been gunned down in Madrid, Paris and Oslo and an Israeli commando raid in Lebanon resulted in the deaths of at least 25 men, women and children.

Some of the extremist actions have antagonized even the people they claim to be helping. The Rome airport massacre was disavowed and condemned by Yasir Arafat, the Palestinian leader and he has said he wants the perpetrators brought to trial. Uncertainty over how popular such a move might be, seems to have delayed that action, however.

Other Arabs are the victims of a different kind of terrorism elsewhere in Europe. Racial antagonism spurred by the influx of Arab laborers seems to have been behind the bombing of an Algerian consulate and the murders of 13 Arab immigrants in France. Roman Catholic and Protestant extremists in Northern Ireland continue their slaughter of the innocents.

There, as in the Middle East, a slender hope for the end of the terror rested on efforts to achieve a permanent peace through compromise. Basque terrorists, seeking independence for their homeland, have robbed banks, kidnapped officials and warred with the police in northern Spain.

They apparently bear responsibility for the assassination last month of Spanish Premier Luis Carrero Blanco. Further south, in Africa, terror tactics are used by black guerrillas against white farm settlement in Rhodesia and African guerrilla fighters are active against the Portuguese police and army in the colonies of Mozambique, Angola and Guinea-Bissau.

Guerrillas claim they have the full support of the people; the Government claims the people are against terrorism. Terrorists in Latin America are mostly students, frustrated because the old political oligarchies or military dictatorships offer no hope for democratic change. So they resort to violence, generally to fail.

Their failure stems partly from their divided ranks: they include Castroites, Moscow Communists and Maoists. And partly it comes from the fact that they have been largely unable to rally mass support.

CP-1974-025 →

· The New York Times · page 1 (jump to page 4, column 3)

Palestinians Speaking Out Against the Israelis' Rule

By HENRY KAMM / Special to The New York Times

JERUSALEM, Jan. 17—Three months after the October war, the Palestinian Arabs on the West Bank of the Jordan River and in the Gaza Strip speak more openly against Israeli occupation than at any time since they were conquered six and a half years ago.

But although the Palestinians speak more hopefully than ever before about an end to occupation, they show no greater will to resist Israel. The Israeli armed forces continue to dominate the areas they conquered from Jordan and Egypt with a presence that is no more visible than the low profile they maintained before the latest war.

Two weeks of interviews and conversations in the occupied territories, whose ultimate disposition will be a crucial element in any peace settlement, disclosed a wide gap between the expressed resentment against the occupation and readiness to act to overcome it.

The Palestinians living under Israeli rule—650,000 on the West Bank and 380,000 in the Gaza Strip—expect to take no share in freeing themselves. The Palestine Liberation Organization is the chief beneficiary of the West Bank's resurgence of nationalism.

But not even its most vocal supporters seem to evidence any inclination to participate in activity designed to seize Palestine. In fact, many hold official posts under the occupation or engage in profitable commercial relationships with Israel.

The scores of people questioned included leading West Bank “notables,” nationalist editors who in the absence of free political movements enjoy a special political importance and outspoken foes of the occupation, as well as young radicals studying at universities in Arab countries.

Openly or implicitly they expressed full reliance on the Arab countries and their armies to eject the occupiers. [The jump, page 4:] The principal loser in the swing to the Beirut-based Palestine Liberation Organization, a grouping of ideologically and politically divergent factions, appears to be King Hussein of Jordan, whose laws are still the law of the West Bank.

The King's supporters among the “notables,” most of whose were originally appointed by Hussein, appear to be the only West Bank political figures who prefer to keep their own counsel in the present atmosphere. This occasioned no surprise among Arab and Israeli experts, in view of the terrorism that has been their opponents' principal weapon.

Ex-Minister Is Cautious “You will understand that in the present confusing circumstances I find it impossible to talk to journalists as I used to in the past,” said Anwar Nuseibeh, a former Jordanian Cabinet Minister and ambassador, in his East Jerusalem home. Among those who espouse the majority view, reticence has vanished since the October war.

Said Aladin, also a former minister in King Hussein's Government but one who had confined expression of his views to his circle of friends, repeated them openly in an interview in an East Jerusalem hotel. “Jordan doesn't matter to us Palestinians,” he said. “Jordan has already made her peace with Israel, and between them things are normal. The bridges between them are open.

Jordan did not make itself popular in 1967, when they gave up the West Bank without fighting. “Then, in 1971, they butchered so many Palestinian Arabs. They killed left, right and center. And in the last war they did not allow the fedayeen to take part.

I think Jordan is not a factor.” [Later in the jump:] But over cups of Arabic coffee in his East Jerusalem residence, the Mufti, Saad-Eddin al-Alami, declared that the war had brought about “a revival of nationalism” on the West Bank. “It has made for us some hope,” he said in English.

A Palestinian Arab expanding his house in the Gaza Strip early last year. While the Palestine Liberation Organization, a guerrilla group, is benefiting from increased nationalism, scores of established Arabs are quiet. [credit: The New York Times/Micha Bar Am]

CP-1974-027 →

· The Journal Star

Dowry Inflation

Associated Press

DOWRY INFLATION. TEL AVIV (AP) — Like everything else, the price of Palestinian brides has soared, the national news agency ITIM reported. In 1967, a dowry for a young Arab woman in lands held by Israel was under $300. Now it’s $2,380, and double that for an educated girl.

Four sentences, filed as a curiosity under an economics pun, and inside it a number that does the same work as a whole feature thirty-three years later. A dowry for a young Arab woman in the lands Israel took in 1967 has gone from under $300 to $2,380 — and double that for an educated girl. In 2007 the Associated Press would spend a full page discovering that a Palestinian bride’s degree is worth an extra salary. The Journal Star printed the same fact in 1974 in fifty-one words, as a brief about inflation.

CP-1974-010 →

· The New York Times

Home for Many Israelis Is ‘Occupied Territory’

By NAOMI SHEPHERD

JERUSALEM—From the six-day war onward, Israel has played political solitaire on the map of the occupied Arab territories, placing settlements to stake out her claim to optimal frontiers.

Once the question of disengagement of Israeli and Syrian troops on the Golan Heights is resolved—contacts are to be made this month in Washington—these settlements will unquestionably be close to the center of discussions in the “real” peace negotiations to be resumed in Geneva.

Initially, the settlements were positioned at strategic points to check infiltration or ensure an Israeli presence in case of renewed war. Immediately after 1967, almost all the territory occupied, with the exception of Jerusalem, the Golan Heights and minor strips of land elsewhere, was considered negotiable currency to be exchanged for formal peace treaties.

However, the Arab states refused to talk. The numbers of settlements increased, although their purely military function diminished. Right-wing and religious elements in Israel claimed the West Bank of the Jordan was part of the Jewish patrimony.

The first of the 13 Jordan Valley settlements were set up on the army’s initiative to check infiltration and the formation of sabotage cells in the West Bank towns. Some have already “gone civilian.” The three Etzion settlements in the Judean Hills have risen from the ashes of prestate kibbutzim destroyed in 1948 by the Arab Legion.

After the six-day war, the children of the defenders persuaded then Prime Minister Levi Eshkol to reconstruct the kibbutzim, though they do not farm lands that in the interval between 1948 and 1967 had been cultivated by Arabs. In nearby Hebron, Orthodox Jewish settlers have revived Jewish tenancy in a city abandoned since the 1929 massacre of the Jewish community.

Though first penned in the military compound, the settlers’ tenacity forced the Government’s hand and established the Jewish suburb of Kiryat Arba. The Hebron affair created a precedent: historical and religious claims were now justification for Jewish residence even in areas likely to be returned to Arab rule.

In the Gaza Strip, the Nahal camps are little more than sentry posts between the refugee camps. But the Rafiah area south of Gaza attracts many farming families. Recruited often by newspaper ads, briefed by selection committees, offered spacious housing, land and new equipment, these pioneers are attracted by profit rather than risk.

Sharm el Sheik has expanded from an outpost guarding the Strait of Tiran into a tourist center. Its first permanent settlers, army officers’ families and local workers, are due to move into the first 90 apartments this month.

The entire range of settlements, with the possible exception of a few Nahal camps in Gaza and the South Sinai coast, seems programed for permanence. Only Shalhevet, a family suburb for the workers at the Abu Rodeis oilfields in Sinai has folded, clearly as the result of new military deployments.

If all areas are negotiable, as Israel has often maintained, some areas (like Gaza with its refugees and the West Bank towns) are more negotiable than others. Yet the October war underlined the ambivalent status of the new settlements. On the one hand, new schools, regional centers and even towns are planned for the Golan and Rafiah areas.

Bulldozers are already leveling the ground. In the Jordan Valley, Gigal, a former Nahal kibbutz, produces winter vegetables and manufactures sprinklers. Winter roses bloom on the lawn and the kibbutz, like the others, is air-conditioned in the searing summer heat.

CP-1974-024 →

· El Paso Herald-Post · El Paso · page 1

ISRAEL ATTACKS LEBANON IN REPRISAL

Warplanes Strike Palestinian Refugee Camps

The banner and the line above it say two different things. The small italic line names what was struck: Palestinian Refugee Camps. The banner underneath, in the largest type on the page, says ISRAEL ATTACKS LEBANON IN REPRISAL — a state attacking a state, and the last two words supply the cause before a reader reaches the story. The camps are in the small type.

CP-1974-001 →

· Wichita Eagle · Wichita · page 3A

Many Palestinians Killed In Israeli Revenge Raids

“…low-income housing project near there was heavily damaged by waves of Israeli F4 Phantom jets. An Arab guerrilla at the scene said as many as 300 persons may have been killed or wounded in the complex. A doctor at a hospital in Sidon said 50 casualties were brought in there and 11 of the victims were dead on arrival.

‘Many other casualties were taken to another hospital in the city, but I don’t know how many,’ the doctor said. In Cairo, Egyptian Foreign Minister Ismail Fahmy warned that Arab states could not stand idly by in the face of ‘Israeli acts of aggression.’

And in Washington, the White House said of the Arab attack on Maalot and the Israeli retaliatory strikes: ‘Continuing cycles of violence of this sort can only obstruct the achievement of a peaceful settlement of the Middle East.’

Despite the Israeli air strikes into Lebanon, Secretary of State Henry Kissinger flew as scheduled to Damascus Thursday and held long discussions with Syrian President Hafez Assad in a continuing effort to bring about a troop disengagement along the Israeli-Syrian front.

In his report on the Israeli raid near Sidon, Jensen said one of the three-story apartment houses in the housing complex was demolished and that entire walls and all the windows of others were blown out. Bomb craters 20 feet deep could be seen all around the area.

The main target of the Israeli attack in the Sidon area was the Ein el Helweh refugee camp, largest in Lebanon, Jensen said. Guerrillas there said scores of children were buried in rubble in the camp and that many more casualties were coming in from the Lebanese-populated housing complex.

Three other persons were reported killed in Nabatiyem, a township 10 miles southeast of Sidon. A spokesman in Sidon for the Al Fatah guerrilla organization said the Israeli air strikes in that area lasted about 45 minutes. The Lebanese Defense Ministry in Beirut earlier said the raids on all seven guerrilla bases and refugee camps lasted about 20 minutes.

The spokesman, identifying himself only as ‘Salah,’ told Jensen he saw 12 Israeli Phantoms striking together at one time. ‘Tell your government that Phantoms are very effective against innocent civilians,’ the spokesman added. Ambulances sped down the coast highway into Sidon packed with casualties on blood-spattered stretchers.

Armed Palestinian guerrillas patroled the devastated areas, Jensen reported. Funerals for the teen-age victims of the Maalot incident began in northern Israel just as word was given to the nation that the air strikes were carried out.

The Israeli military command first said the air strikes were aimed only at guerrillas bases but since some of these are near refugee camps civilian areas may have been hit. It said at first that the raids were strategic military strikes and not revenge actions for Maalot.

Fire and smoke rose up from a guerrilla base near the international airport at Beirut, Lebanon’s capital. Air raid sirens sounded in that city for the first time since the Middle East war in October and people scurried for cover as Israeli planes shrieked overhead. In four towns in northern Israel, funeral services were held for the Maalot victims.

A service at Safad, near Maalot, was broken off when a group of youths broke through police lines shouting, ‘Death to the Terrorists!’ President Ephraim Katzir of Israel and Deputy Premier Yigal Allon tried to calm them but failed. They departed under heavy police guard.

The terrorists seized about 85 Israeli teen-agers in a school at Maalot on Wednesday and threatened to blow them up unless Israel released 20 terrorists held in Israeli jails. Israeli troops rushed the building with guns blazing in what officials said was an operation to prevent the terrorists from killing the children.

There has been no official report on how the children were killed or wounded — whether by crossfire or by the Arabs themselves. An Israeli military source maintained, however: ‘All the children were killed by the terrorists. The Arabs started shooting the kids immediately when Israeli soldiers entered the building.’

Targets in Thursday’s retaliatory air raids included the Urj el-Barajneh guerrilla camp near the Beirut airport; the Hein el Halweh camp near Sidon, which was Lebanon’s largest Palestinian refugee camp; the Al Ashbal camp, also near Sidon, which was used as a military training center for Palestinians; the second largest refugee camp, at Rashidieh, on the outskirts of the Biblical port city of Tyre, 40 miles South of Beirut; and the southern Lebanese villages of Rachieya el Foukhar, Khraibe and Mahrouneh also were attacked.

An Israeli military communique said: ‘Targets attacked included terrorist concentrations in southern Lebanon and Fatahland, and offices, headquarters, ordinances and workshops of terrorist organizations in the Nabativa Sidon and Sur region—on the Lebanese coast.’ ‘Also attacked was a training camp of the Popular Front, south of Beirut.

The targets … belong to Al Fatah and the Popular Front—Habash—and the Popular Front Jebel and Hawatmeh Popular Democratic Front. The latter two organizations were involved in yesterday’s acts at Maalot.’”

“THE RUBBLE OF REPRISAL SCARS LEBANESE TOWN OF SIDON … Debris searched for survivors after Israeli air attack …” AP Photo.

The headline names who did the killing and calls the raids revenge, which the Israeli military command in the same copy says they were not. Underneath it, the paper prints both of the day’s accounts of the Maalot school: that there is no official report on how the children were killed, and an Israeli military source saying all of them were killed by the attackers. The photograph of Sidon shares the page with an illustrated advertisement for summer fashions.

CP-1974-006 →

· Tampa Bay Times · St. Petersburg

Israeli Planes Raid Guerrillas In Lebanon

Compiled from Washington Post, New York Times, AP, UPI Wires

BEIRUT — Waves of Israeli fighter bombers smashed Palestinian refugee and guerrilla camps across Lebanon Wednesday in vengeance raids that killed at least 15 persons and seriously wounded scores of others.

The Israeli planes bombed, rocketed and machine-gunned seven target areas, including El Helewen, the largest refugee camp in Lebanon, a guerrilla training area on the outskirts of Beirut and small concentrations of guerrillas in the Arquob area of the slopes of Mount Hermon.

INITIAL unofficial reports indicated that the day’s final casualty total would be even higher than that of the Palestinian guerrilla attack on an Israeli school at Ma’alot Wednesday, which evidently provoked the wide-ranging aerial strikes Thursday. The toll of Israeli teenagers killed rose to 24 Thursday as two more students died from wounds.

Seventy Israeli youngsters were wounded and the three Arab gunmen holding them hostage were killed when Israeli troops stormed the Ma’alot school in a desperate rescue bid. Lebanese television reported 27 dead, 138 wounded and 20 others missing in the attacks.

An Israeli spokesman in Tel Aviv said civilian deaths could not be ruled out since the targets were near refugee camps.

The Lebanese defense ministry announced that 36 Israeli warplanes took part in the series of raids carried out for half an hour in the early afternoon, while Secretary of State Henry Kissinger was flying from Jerusalem to Damascus for more talks on a Syrian-Israeli disengagement of forces agreement.

The Israeli national radio reported that Prime Minister Golda Meir’s government had suggested to Kissinger a 10 day pause in his mission which is now approaching its point of decision after long talks with Syrian President Hafez Assad Thursday, in order to let Israel and Syria take stock and prove their peaceful intentions.

The report was denied by an Israeli foreign ministry spokesman. After 7½ hours of talks with Assad, Kissinger said, “We made some progress, but we obviously have not reached an agreement.” He and Assad had agreed to make last-minute “new approaches” to break the deadlock between Israel and Syria over military disengagement in the Golan Heights.

Kissinger will discuss these with Israeli leaders later today. In Washington, the White House decried the “continuing cycles of violence” in the Mideast. EYEWITNESSES to the raids said four of the American-manufactured Phantoms and Skyhawks returned at dusk to strike a second time at the Nabatiyah refugee camp in southern Lebanon.

Hardest hit was El Helweh, a sprawling camp of 20,000 persons located at the edge of the southern port town of Sidon. A doctor said 11 persons had arrived dead at the Sidon Hospital and scores more were being brought in with serious injuries.

ANNOUNCING the raids in Tel Aviv, an Israeli military spokesman said they had been aimed at guerrilla storehouses, workshops and training camps principally in the Nabatiyah, Sidon and Tyre areas. The Lebanese defense ministry announced a preliminary total of eight Lebanese civilian dead and 64 wounded. An incomplete count said there were 13 Palestinians killed and 70 wounded.

In Cairo, Egyptian Foreign Minister Ismail Fahmy warned Israel that its attacks against civilian targets in Lebanon will have “the gravest consequences.”

“A Palestinian Killed In Israeli Raid On Nabatiyeh Is Carried Away” UPI.

The same Thursday as a Kansas paper that headed it Many Palestinians Killed In Israeli Revenge Raids. Here the object of the raid is guerrillas, and the Palestinian dead appear in the caption under the photograph instead. Four counts of the dead are printed in one story and none is chosen: at least 15, then 27 from Lebanese television, then eight Lebanese civilians from the defense ministry, then an incomplete count of 13 Palestinians.

CP-1974-007 →

· Santa Barbara Independent · page 1

Zionists Called Racists

Terry D. Post, letter to the editor

“Dear Editor: The racist attitude of Israel and the world’s press has caused a surging rash of liberalism among ‘progressive’ elements of the Santa Barbara community. In order to build an effective mass, anti-imperialist movement, Palestine must clearly be recognized as the oppressed of the Middle East.

The Palestinian movement should also be considered in the same perspective as other national liberation struggles.

The masses should not fall prey to bourgeois press influence and their classification of Palestinian guerrilla organizations as ‘terrorists’; these courageous people are fighting for their liberation, not for the annihilation of the Jews… Israel attacks Palestinian refugee camps with napalm armed Phantoms which have been supplied by the United States.

The Palestinian peasants find very little protection against Israeli bombs from their canvas tents… Zionism should be recognized in the proper light; as outright racism. Every document of the Palestinian movement makes it very clear as to how all Jews will be treated under a free Palestine; a non-sectarian, multi-religious state where all people will be free to worship as they please.

It must also be immediately recognized that President Nixon’s massive annihilation bombings in Vietnam and Cambodia for the purpose of freeing American POW’s was a much greater crime against humanity than any guerrilla activity directed against Zionism… Thank you, Terry D. Post. P.S.

The above views should be considered as my own, and not representative of Vietnam Veterans Against the War/Winter Soldier Organization of which I am a member.”

Eighteen months before the General Assembly voted, in a letters column, by a member of Vietnam Veterans Against the War who takes care to say he is not speaking for them. The American route to the phrase runs through Vietnam.

CP-1974-004 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israelis Kill 6, Capture 2; New Massacre Plot Seen

By CHARLES MOHR

TEL AVIV, May 23 — Six Palestinian guerrilla infiltrators were killed and two were captured today by Israeli troops. An Israeli spokesman said that the two captured guerrillas had said that the group planned to carry out a “massacre” similar to the killing of students at Maalot last week.

Just a few miles west of Maalot machine gun fire and grenade explosions were heard for 30 minutes this afternoon as troops combed heavy scrub in a search for other guerrillas after one other infiltrator was killed last night near the Lebanese border.

Security alerts and other searches were on in other scattered areas of northern Israel in the struggle between Palestinian terrorists and Israel.

The six Palestinians killed and two captured were reportedly an eight-man team that infiltrated across the Syrian-Israeli lines into the Golan Heights with the apparent intention of taking hostages in one or two kibbutzim, or collective farms, in Israel proper and demanding the release of guerrilla prisoners held by Israel.

This was the pattern that led to last week’s tragedy at Maalot, far to the west. Surrender Reported An Israeli military spokesman said that the group intercepted today of the Golan Heights was found when an army patrol “encountered two terrorists who surrendered to the patrol.”

“Following their interrogation, a pursuit was mounted after the rest of the gang,” the Israeli announcement continued. “Towards noon, the gang was spotted and, in the exchanges of fire that ensued, the remaining six terrorists were killed.” Israel said she had suffered no casualties.

The Palestinian killed last night was found near high cliffs and dense shrubby canyons close to Adamit near the Lebanese border. He must have been on a separate mission, and a major security alert was under way in northwest Israel in case he had had companions.

The two men captured in the Golan Heights said during questioning by Israeli intelligence officers and journalists that they belonged to the Popular Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, led by Nayef Fawatmeh, which says it carried out the attack at Maalot a week ago yesterday.

The official Israeli announcement gave the names of the captured men as Cassar Cashian and Muhammad Kanju Sharkaz Hilal, but they told a reporter for United Press International that their names were Abdullah el-Mehdi and Abu Turki.

Equipment Carried The six dead and two captured men, Israeli spokesmen said, were carrying eight Russian-designed automatic rifles, 30 hand grenades, four revolvers, about 22 pounds of explosive bricks ready for detonation, two loudspeakers, a map with marked routes, two small transistor radios, compasses and binoculars.

The Israeli spokesman said the captured men admitted that they had been sent to carry out a terrorist act similar to the massacre at Maalot and added, “They were found to be in possession of a demand for the release of 30 terrorists imprisoned in Israel, as well as letters in English addressed to the Ambassadors of Rumania and Japan.”

Questioned by reporters, the captured men said they had been ordered to “take civilian hostages” in the kibbutzim of Din Gev and Haon near the Sea of Galilee in exchange for the release of Palestinians held in Israeli jails and the return of the bodies of three guerrillas shot dead at Maalot.

“We were told that we could permit an extension of our deadline for one hour but that if the demands had not been met there would be a massacre,” a journalist quoted Mr. Mehdi as saying.

CP-1974-023 →

· The New York Times

Palestinians Gather in Cairo to Map Future Policies

By HENRY TANNER, Special to The New York Times

CAIRO, June 1—More than 150 members of the Palestine National Council, the parliament of the Palestine Liberation Organization, opened a four-day meeting here today to discuss policies to be followed in the coming months.

The gathering, at the headquarters of Arab League, next to the Hilton Hotel in downtown Cairo, may become one of the most important meetings held by the Palestinians since their guerrilla movement was founded 10 years ago.

At stake is the question whether the guerrillas should now take part in the search for negotiated settlement with Israel or continue to rely on armed action alone.

At the opening session today the chairman of the council, Khaled Fahoum, said the Palestinian cause was living through a crucial period and the debate therefore would help determine “the fate of generations” of Palestinians.

Message From Sadat President Anwar el-Sadat, in a message, stressed that the Syrian and Egyptian disengagement agreements were purely military in character and constituted “the beginning and not the end of the struggle.” The tone of the message seemed to take into account that many Palestinian leaders have been critical of Mr.

Sadat’s advocacy of a policy of peace supported by the United States. The council also received a message of support from Premier Chou En-lai of China. The meeting took place behind closed doors. With the signing yesterday of a disengagement agreement between Syria and Israel, the Palestinian question has become the central issue of the Middle East conflict.

A minority, led by George Habash, the head of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, has made it known publicly that it will reject all proposals for accommodation.

A moderate majority, including Yassir Arafat, the chairman of the Palestine Liberation organization, the umbrella group, is known to feel that the Palestinians should send a delegation to the Geneva peace conference if the conditions are right. Individual members of this majority are believed to have widely divergent views on what these conditions should be.

The members of the council will also elect a new enlarged executive committee for the Palestine Liberation Organization. The new executive will have 15 members compared with nine in the old one.

CP-1974-026 →

· High Point Enterprise

Palestine Question Is Block To Peace

DAMASCUS, Syria (AP) — The Stars and Stripes fluttered over the Syrian capital for the first time in seven years Saturday, welcoming President Nixon for an unprecedented visit that sources said could herald the resumption of diplomatic relations between the formerly hostile nations.

Nixon told a state banquet Saturday night that a cultural exchange program with Syria was being re-established, but neither he nor his host, President Hafez Assad, mentioned a restoration of the diplomatic ties broken by Syria in the 1967 Middle East war. Syria has had close ties with the Soviet Union.

The two presidents were to confer privately before Nixon goes to Israel on Sunday. His fifth and last stop in the Middle East will be Jordan.

On Nixon’s arrival in Damascus — the first Syrian visit by any American president — he was greeted by an unexpected escort of Soviet-built Syrian MIG jets, a hearty handshake from Assad and the waves of a crowd of 450,000 waiting in the sweltering heat.

But as at his last stop in Saudi Arabia, where he promised more military aid to King Faisal, the reception was more subdued than the frenzied welcome that millions gave him in Egypt. A force of 5,000 soldiers and 2,000 plainclothes security agents was on hand in case of trouble.

At the banquet, Assad became the third Arab leader in four days to tell Nixon that a lasting peace in the Middle East cannot be achieved until the Palestinian question is resolved. The American President replied that “I understand your concern about Palestine.”

But he said that issue as well as the question of Israeli occupation of Arab lands and “other matters” must await future negotiations. “I would like to tell you that I had an instant solution for these very complex problems,” Nixon said. “But you would know ... that I do not bring any instant solution....”

He described the disengagement of Israeli and Syria troops along the Golan Heights as “a beginning — and a good beginning.” He added that “now we must move forward step by step as each case permits ... until we reach our goal of a just and equitable peace.”

AT DAMASCUS AIRPORT Assad (Left) Greets Nixon (AP Wirephoto)

CP-1974-011 →

· The Oregonian · Portland

Arab refugees

“To the Editor: In a prosaic style best described as ‘emotional Israeli’… to talk to the PLO because ‘they are basically against a compromise by the Palestinians’ (Time, July 8). And rightfully so, when Israel’s concept of ‘compromise’ involves permanent exile of the Palestinians in the currently…”

A reader in Portland answering a Time magazine column.

CP-1974-021 →

· Lexington Herald-Leader · Lexington · page 1

Palestinian Refugee Camps Breeding Places For Terrorists

Breeding places is a phrase for insects and for disease. It is applied here to the places where several hundred thousand people were living, in a Kentucky paper in 1974, in the paper’s own headline voice and without quotation marks. Five months earlier the El Paso Herald-Post had those same camps struck from the air in small italic type above a banner about a reprisal (CP-1974-001).

CP-1974-002 →

· New York Amsterdam News

Blacks study Palestinians

Editor’s note: This is the 2nd in a series of four articles by representatives of the Black Press who visited the Middle Eat on a study tour during the recent easing of the Arab-Israeli crisis. In the group were Mrs. Marjorie B. Parham, Cincinnati Herald; Robert A. Sengstacke, Chicago Defender; Charles E. Belle, Los Angeles Sentinel and San Francisco Sun-Reporter.

DAMASCUS, Syria (NNPA) — Abdul, a dust covered farmer, and his equally dust covered family — a wife, 10 children, and grandparents over 80 — were smiling broadly when we visited their tent, because they were anticipating their return home.

But most Palestinian refugees ar not smiling, because no plans have yet been made for millions of them to return to their native villages. Some have geen camping in the desert for nearly 30 years. And this is the crux of the Middle East problem, we were told about over and over again.

However, Abdul and his family, who were among 25,000 emcamped just outside this Biblical city where Paul had his conversion, are preparing to return to their homeland as a result of the negotiated agreement between Syria and Israel following the shuttle diplomacy of Secretary of State Henry Kissinger.

Abdul had walked over 60 miles with his eight-month pregnant wife, and other members of his family after hostilities broke out last October. They spent last winter in the tattered tents where we visited them. Somethimes there were as much as four feet of snow on the ground.

The United Nations under its Relief and World Agency (UNRWA) supplies these people only 7c per person, per day. Individual governments provide meagre supplemental help. Fortunately, soon they will be home again. But what of the other 3.5 million Palestinians who still live in tent cities or temporary shelters in Jordan or Lebanon or are roaming throughout the Arab World.

Some have been nomads since 1946. So fierce is their determination to return home to what was once Palestine that they refuse more permanent quarters. There are second and even third generations of refugees in these camps. Some were driven from camps in the Six Day War of 1966 to settle in new shelters.

Basil Aqu, an articulate spokesman for the Palestinian Liberation Movement, told us quite pointedly that the Middle East matter cannot be solved until a full resolution is made of the refugree question. Immaculately dressed and speaking perfect English, Aqu echoed the sentiments of everyone with whom we spoke on this issue.

The way out “There must be peace with justice,” is the way it is put. It sounds much like Black Americans adding that all important word to those who speak of “law and order.” Seated in a conference room in Cairo, Egypt, Aqu defended the violent acts of Palestinian guerillas.

“We have an obligation,” he said, “to keep reminding world public opinion of the ‘persecution’ of the Arab people.”

CP-1974-013 →

· New York Amsterdam News

Future of Middle East outlined to Blacks

Black publishers in Egypt Future of Middle East outlined to Blacks By CHARLES E. BELLE CAIRO, Egypt (NNPA) — Here in Egypt, we were told by officials that the future of the Middle East depends on the use of funds from oil for agricultural and industrial development. Dr.

Ahmed Lel Morshidy, Egypt’s First Under Secretary of State for Planning, informed us that he estimates that the Arab members of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries will soon have a surplus of up to $50 billion a year for investment. Egypt, he said, intends to be one of the places for these investment funds.

If we get loans we will use them to further develop agricultural production along the Nile River through irrigation, the increased use of commercial fertilizer, and an expansion in the size of farms from five-acre plots in some instance to 200-acre co-op plantations assigned to two or three families, he asserted.

To Feed 40 Million Our nation must feed its 40 million people, Dr. Morshidy added, and we now have only six million acres that can be farmed. These form a three-mile-wide strip along both sides of the Nile. The rest of the land is now barren desert. But water and fertilizer can help make a wider strip arable and also increase crop yields, he explained.

This can be done over a projected seven-year period, he thinks, if funds can be obtained from Egypt’s oil-rich neighbors to build petrochemical and fertilizer plants, extend irrigation canals, as well as drill deep wells. Other Egyptians pointed out to us that their economy has suffered from the ups and downs of wars.

After the 1956 war, the government curtailed money for the military and turned its attention to in- (Continued on Page A-2) [EDITOR’S NOTE, boxed between rules at the head of the second column, display matter rather than body text] Editor’s note: This is the 3rd in a series of four articles by representatives of the Black Press who visited the Middle East on a study tour during the recent easing of the Arab-Israeli crisis.

In the group were Mrs. Marjorie B. Parham, Cincinnati Herald; Robert A. Sengstacke, Chicago Defender; Howard B. Woods, St. Louis Sentinel; and the writer. … (Continued from Page A-1) ternal development such as the Aswan High Dam. This is the reason, some say, that their country was unprepared for the six-day war in 1967.

Since then, more of the funds have gone to the military, and their victory, as they see it, in the October war of 1973 assures further military expenditures. They explain that as a result of increased spending for the armed forces, President Sadat has to seek funds for agricultural and industrial development outside the country.

In Jordan In Jordan, we were told, it is the hungry mouths of the pitifully poor Palestinian refugees that intensifies the need for more economic development. There are 650,000 Palestinians on the east bank of the Jordan River, and 850,000 on the west bank in the Israeli occupied territory. All look to Jordan for aid.

In addition, the country has its own population of two million. From among the Palestinians, come the commandos. Jordinians say their country could once again be the bread basket of the Middle East, if more of the water of the Jordan River could reach them. Israel has diverted to its Negev Desert most of the water that would flow into the river from the Sea of Galilee.

Efforts to improve the water supply are being made by Dr. Michael I. Marto, director of the economic research department of the Royal Scientific Society (RSS) which is headed by Crown Prince Hassan. Dr. Marto told our group that plans are underway for the completion of a dam on the Jordan and extension of sections of a canal. Cost is estimated at $240 million.

(Next week: Economic development in Lebanon, Syria, and Kuwait will be discussed).

The Palestinian people seem to feel a strong bond of brotherhood with U.S. Blacks. Above photographer Robert Sengstacke poses with unidentified Fedayeen commando who asked to be photographed with him. (Photo by R. Sengstacke)

Correction: Catalogued from a headline read by machine, which took the masthead line. The headline over the article, and its pull quote, are read off the scan.

CP-1974-015 →

· The New York Times · New York

Peace in the Middle East?

Noam Chomsky

Long before he was interested in Vietnam, Noam Chomsky was interested in the Middle East. As a young man, he tells us in his new book, he hovered on the fringes of left-wing Zionist groups.

In the days before the establishment of Israel, he opposed Jewish statehood, favored some form of bi-nationalism, thought that the main struggle was not between Arabs and Jews but between socialism and capitalism. Almost 30 years later he holds fast to those views.

He still believes that socialist bi-nationalism is the “correct position” and now, on the first anniversary of the fourth Arab-Israeli war, he has published a book to defend that position. Actually, it is something less than a book. Chomsky has brought together speeches and articles written over the past five years.

The pieces are sometimes powerful, but they are also unrevised, repetitious and radically incomplete. In no sense do they add up to a consecutive argument. The last of them is given over to a bitter attack on some recent critics who are accused of distorting and misrepresenting Chomsky’s views.

I am not one of those attacked (although my own views are more mildly criticized in another essay), but I have some sympathy with those who are. For the truth is that at crucial points the essays reveal only a skillful evasiveness and it is very hard to say what Chomsky thinks.

Were it not for the place he has made for himself on the American Left, I doubt that any publisher would have accepted these articles in their present form. Given his standing, however, we must try to figure out his arguments. His basic position is simply put. Jews and Arabs have equal claims to all of old Palestine.

CP-1974-018 →

· The New York Times · New York

Allon Denounced on Palestine View

TEL AVIV, Oct. 6—A statement by Foreign Minister Yigal Allon in New York that Israel might agree to a federation between a future Palestinian state and Jordan has drawn fire from the right-wing opposition.

The statement, in an interview with The New York Times published yesterday, was the second in less than a week in which a Government leader has expressed views representing a substantial softening of the policies of the previous Government, led by Mrs. Golda Meir.

Premier Yitzhak Rabin in a television interview last Tuesday offered to consider a limited Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank of the Jordan River in return for a Jordanian declaration of nonbelligerency. The Parliament will interrupt its recess Wednesday to hold a special session in response to a demand by the Likud party for a discussion of Mr. Rabin’s remarks.

A Likud deputy said today that the party’s spokesman would also attack Mr. Allon’s statement. Moshe Dayan, the former Defense Minister, was also reported by friends to be critical of the statements by the Premier and Foreign Minister.

Observers here view the controversial statements as signals to Jordan that Israel wanted to strengthen the position of King Hussein in his rivalry with the Palestine Liberation Organization, the umbrella guerrilla grouping.

CP-1974-019 →

· The New York Times · New York

Even the Palestinians Can't Agree on Policies

Naomi Shepherd

JERUSALEM—The political future of the Palestinians is today as much an internal Arab problem as an issue between the Arabs and Israel.

Egyptian President Anwar el-Sadat admitted this last week when he said that the main obstacle on the road to Geneva was now the rival Jordanian and Palestine Liberation Organization claims to represent the Palestinians of the West Bank and Gaza.

There is nothing Israel can do to prevent the probable granting of observer status to the Palestinians at the United Nations next month, and thus international recognition of their right to self determination. Nor, were Israel to return parts of the West Bank to Jordan’s King Hussein, could he prevent the subsequent setting up there of a Palestinian state.

Israeli Premier Yitzhak Rabin has reiterated Israel’s willingness to return areas of the West Bank to King Hussein in exchange for a nonbelligerence pact, and Foreign Minister Yigal Allon has emphasized Israel’s acceptance of a Palestinian state in federation with Jordan.

But there is no indication that the Palestine Liberation Organization, despite its new political credentials, will take up these options.

The policy of the Palestine Liberation Organization, accepted by all factions, is still that laid down at the twelfth Palestinian Congress in Cairo last June: the continuation of the struggle against Israel from a first-stage base through a “National Authority” to be set up in parts of Palestine liberated from Israeli rule, and the overthrow of the Hashemite regime in Jordan.

No Palestinian state with such a political agenda could survive sandwiched between Jordan and Israel, a fact of which the Palestine Liberation Organization’s current leader, Yasir Arafat, is aware. It must thus be tempting for Mr. Arafat to join Mr. Hussein’s delegation to Geneva, an eventuality which Mr. Allon has said Israel would accept.

CP-1974-020 →

· The New York Times · New York

Arab Leaders Issue Call for a Palestinian State

1974 Price higher in alt delvery dities. 20 CENTS ARAB LEADERS ISSUE CALL ARAFAT GIVEN MAIN ROLE Yasir Arafat, Palestinian guerrilla leader, after Arab meeting yesterday in Rabat

CP-1974-016 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestinian Coup

Leaders of the Arab world have dealt a major psychological blow to prospects for new Arab-Israeli agreements in the near future. Recognition of the Palestine Liberation Organization by the Rabat summit conference seems sharply to reduce the possibility of negotiations between Israel and Jordan leading ultimately to Israeli withdrawal from the Jordan West Bank.

In effect, the Arab leaders have opted for an aggressive ideological stance rather than for a pragmatic position offering hope of early diplomatic movement. As throughout their unhappy history, the Palestinian Arabs find themselves mere pawns in a high-level power game.

For all the talk about the P.L.O. coalition as “sole legitimate representative of the Palestinian people,” the legitimacy of this shadowy organization is unproved, either in its origins or its popular support.

Hated though he was among many refugee militants, King Hussein was at least ready to let a referendum of Palestinians determine a popularly based leadership and form of government.

Instead, the Arab chieftains took it upon themselves to designate the Palestinians’ leaders, as did the United Nations General Assembly and a number of outside governments which bowed to the pressures of a self-styled leadership-in-exile that has been guilty of innumerable acts of terrorism.

Whether the West Bank was to be restored to Jordan or to some other political unit, it has long seemed inevitable that an autonomous Palestinian leadership would eventually assume control of Israel’s eastern frontier, wherever it was drawn.

Recognition of the national claims and identity of the Palestinians—alongside those of the Israelis—has long been the crucial missing element in Arab-Israeli diplomacy.

CP-1974-017 →

· Worcester Telegram · Worcester · page 1

Says Zionism Is Racism

George J. Arraj, letter to the editor

“What an irony! The whole world condemns Russia for holding its Jews captive until large sums of money are paid to the state, and now here is Israel doing the exact same thing to some of its Jews.

Where are all the voices of protest? This is simple racism when a state recruits one man from Argentina to come to Israel just because he is Jewish, but refuses to allow native Palestinians to return because they are not Jewish. Such is the irrationality of creating a ‘Jewish’ state.”

A reader in Worcester answering two syndicated columns the paper had run about Zionist agencies recruiting Jews out of Argentina. A year before the vote he states the argument in one sentence, as a matter of who is allowed to arrive and who is not.

CP-1974-005 →

· The Raleigh Register · Beckley

A Promised Arab State Was Never Set Up

By Gerry Nadler, United Press International

“The Palestinian problem began 27 years ago when the United Nations voted to partition the British-administered territory into Arab and Jewish states. The Arab state was never set up. Both states, according to the U.N. resolution, were to come into existence after Britain surrendered a 1920 League of Nations mandate to run Palestine.

The resolution unleashed a guerrilla war between Palestine’s Arabs and Jews, forcing the first of an estimated 700,000 Palestinian Arabs to flee their homes. After Britain departed Palestine on May 15, 1948, the Jews declared an independent state called Israel. The armies of seven Arab nations then attacked.

The war and the three 1949 truce agreements ending the hostilities obliterated the Palestinian Arab state outlined in the U.N. resolution. Egypt took the Gaza Strip, turning the Mediterranean coastal slice into a huge refugee camp for dispossessed Palestinians.

Transjordan, which had been formed from Palestine’s eastern wing, annexed the West Bank of the Jordan River and renamed itself Jordan. Israel incorporated the remainder of the proposed Arab state. Some of the Palestinians moved to refugee camps in Jordan, Lebanon, Syria and Gaza to be cared for by the U.N. Relief and Works Agency.

Others became citizens of the new Jordanian state. And 140,000 remained in Israel, where they lived under martial law until 1966. The better educated resettled in Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and the Persian Gulf sheikhdoms, working as doctors, lawyers, accountants and administrators.

Palestinian political consciousness, which never died, began stirring in 1956 when a group of young refugees in Gaza formed Al Fatah — an Arabic acronym for the Palestine Liberation Movement. Al Fatah demanded that the Palestinian issue be viewed as a problem of statehood rather than one of refugees.

The original Gaza group included a young engineer — Yasser Arafat. Al Fatah spawned other groups. The guerrilla fedayeen — men of conscience — joined together in 1964 as the Palestine Liberation Organization. Arafat became head of the PLO after the 1967 Middle East War.

With the disastrous defeat of the Arab armies in the six-day war, the PLO came to prominence as the sole and immediate force resisting Israel. The PLO demanded that Palestinians rely on themselves to resolve the Palestinian problem and not depend on socalled ‘Arab unity.’

To focus world opinion on their plight, the guerrillas turned to terror tactics outside as well as inside Israel. Israeli reprisals, however, led King Hussein to force the commandos out of Jordan in 1970. Despite terror attacks, the PLO has continued to gain world recognition as the spokesman for the national rights of Palestinians.

The United Nations invited the PLO to send a delegation to this week’s debate on the Palestinian problem. And the 20 Arab heads of state have granted the PLO sole authority to set up a state in any ‘territories liberated’ from Israel.”

“PLO LEADER YASSER ARAFAT · Charter Member Of Al Fatah”

West Virginia’s first appearance in this archive, and the headline is a plain statement of the half of partition that did not happen. The news agency explainer counts 700,000 forced to flee, records that 140,000 stayed in Israel and lived under martial law until 1966, and dates Palestinian political consciousness to a group of young refugees in Gaza in 1956.

CP-1974-009 →

· New York Amsterdam News

Palestine Lives

TOWARDS the end of the 19th century, when the Zionist political movement was founded, its slogan was: “Give us a land without people for a people without a land.” It meant Palestine.

WHEN the Zionist movement began, with the active help of the British to colonize Palestine after World War I, its leader Chaim Weizmann once declared: “Palestine will be as Jewish as England is English and France is French.” AT the turn of the twentieth century the Zionists denied the existence of the Palestinians, the people of Palestine.

Thirty years later the Zionist leaders declared their intention to vacate Palestine of the Palestinians. In 1948 they embarked on realizing that design by force of arms, resulting in a million and a half Palestinians now living in refugee camps OUTSIDE Palestine.

YET • The Palestinians have never ceased to exist. • The Palestinians have refused to acquiesce in the Zionist plan aiming at their annihilation. • The Palestinians have never relinquished their claim to their own country. AS LONG AS THERE IS A PALESTINIAN PEOPLE, PALESTINE LIVES, IN THEIR HEARTS, THEIR SOULS, THEIR MINDS, THEIR WILL.

THE LEAGUE OF ARAB STATES 747 Third Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10017

CP-1974-014 →

· The New York Times · New York

…P.L.O. vs. UNESCO

In the name of “culture,” the Arab bloc and its obedient Communist and African allies have succeeded in politicizing the heretofore nonpolitical United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization by banning Israeli participation and cutting off the modest aid received for its museums, libraries and restorations—a sum, incidentally, that amounts to about one-eighth of Israel’s own contribution to UNESCO.

This shameful act, condemned by the United States, Canada and most of the Western European and Latin-American nations, in effect makes the Palestine Liberation Organization the censor of UNESCO’s activities.

Archeologists from Israel and other countries have been uncovering the debris of the centuries that has accumulated around the southwestern edge of Jerusalem’s Western Wall to reveal the history and artifacts of the ancient city of Herod without, however, touching any of the buildings or monuments belonging to any religious group.

Despite the recognized international nature of Israel’s and UNESCO’s activities, the P.L.O. forced the general conference in Paris to withhold aid because the “historical features” of Jerusalem have supposedly been altered.

The politicized bloc went beyond this—revealing that its aim was not preservation at all—by excluding Israel from the European or any other of the regional groups. Its Lebanese spokesman declared that Israel is “a state that belongs nowhere.”

When UNESCO took the initiative of organizing international action to safeguard ancient Egyptian monuments in Nubia at the request of the United Arab Republic and the Republic of Sudan, the nations of the world helped preserve these archeological treasures.

Millions of dollars were contributed by Western countries, without considering these monuments part of any political bloc or geographical region. UNESCO, like other specialized U.N. agencies, has up to now been above the battles in the General Assembly.

The P.L.O. would tear it all down and, with it, the work of educators and scientists who have cooperated across the curtains of the world. Not one historical excavation but UNESCO itself will collapse in ruins if the P.L.O. dominates the past—and the U.N.’s future.

CP-1974-022 →

· Princeton Daily Clarion · Princeton

Five Palestinians killed by Israeli troop patrol

By United Press International

“Israeli troops patrolling inside Lebanon battled a squad of Palestinian guerrillas and killed five of them, the Tel Aviv military command reported today. One guerrilla escaped. The first frontier clash in a month took place north of Kibbutz Dan Thursday night on the eve of Israeli celebrations marking the 27th anniversary of the U.N. vote to create the Jewish state.

‘We were on a routine patrol near the frontier and by the light of the moon we saw a group of terrorists about 100 yards away,’ a member of the Israeli patrol said in an interview with the armed forces radio. He said the equipment they carried indicated ‘they were aiming at hitting one of the settlements’ inside Israel.

‘It was a hard, fierce firefight.’ A military command spokesman in Tel Aviv said there were no Israeli casualties in the battle near the collective settlement at Dan, built on the site of ancient Israel’s northernmost outpost.

The Palestine News Agency said in Beirut the guerrillas attacked an Israeli army camp northwest of Dan with artillery, rockets and machine guns, but gave no casualty figures. ‘A big confrontation battle took place between the revolutionaries and the enemy forces in the area,’ the news agency said.

The Beirut newspaper An Nahar quoted Arab diplomatic sources today as reporting Egypt has told U.N. Secretary General Kurt Waldheim it will reject any Israeli withdrawal from Sinai unless it is accompanied by a similar withdrawal from the Golan Heights. Sinai is Egyptian territory, while the Golan Heights are Syrian territory.

Israel has occupied both since the 1967 Middle East war.”

A small Indiana daily carrying three accounts of one night: the Israeli military command, a soldier on the armed forces radio, and the Palestine News Agency in Beirut, with the Beirut paper An Nahar at the end. The headline names who did the killing. The soldier’s own word for the five is terrorists; the headline’s is Palestinians.

CP-1974-008 →

· The Press-Tribune · Roseville

Israeli warplanes hit refugee camps

Four years earlier, and the same paper’s construction has no euphemism in it at all: Israeli warplanes hit refugee camps. Subject, verb, object, and the object is where people live. Nothing in the line explains it away.

CP-1974-003 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Prison Chief Denies Any Torture Of Arab Prisoners

“Aryeh Nir, the Commissioner of Prisons, rejected today as ‘ridiculous’ published charges by a Lebanese farmer that he and his son had been tortured in Israeli jails last year.”

The denial is the news and the charge is its object, three years before the archive’s 1980 example of the same construction. The man making the allegation is a Lebanese farmer and is not named in the headline; the commissioner who denies it is named in the first line.

CP-1975-023 →

· Nashua Telegraph · Nashua

Palestinians Confident New State Will Be Formed

NABLUS, Israeli-occupied Jordan — Confidence that an independent Palestinian state will eventually be established appears to be growing rapidly among the approximately three million Palestinian Arabs living in what they consider to be a new state.

James F. Clarity for the New York Times News Service, printed in Nashua. Read the dateline: Nablus, Israeli-occupied Jordan. The West Bank is named for the state that administered it until 1967 and the state that occupies it after, and the word Palestine appears in the piece only as a thing the people are confident about. The clipping came to this archive dated 1955; the masthead says Wednesday, 5 February 1975, and 5 February 1975 was a Wednesday.

CP-1975-026 →

· Midland Daily News

Kissinger hopeful; Marxist Palestinian pledges war

CP-1975-020 →

· News Chronicle · Shippensburg · page 1

Refugee art on display at SSC during March

“‘Children’s Testimony at a Time of War’ is a selection of crayon drawings by Palestinian refugee children that will be on display during the month of March in the Huber Art Center at Shippensburg State College. Kamal Boullata, a Palestinian artist living in Washington, D.C., will speak at 7 p.m.

Wednesday, March 5… The 35 pictures were done by children, ages 5 to 14, who were made refugees as a result of the 1967 Arab-Israeli War. Many of them were children of parents living in refugee campus near Jericho when the 1967 war began, but all of them came to live in the Baqaa Refugee Camp north of Amman, Jordan, where they fled from the fighting in what John P.

Richardson of ANERA describes as ‘the terrifying trek east to escape attacking soldiers and warplanes.’ Richardson also describes the camp which accommodated 36,000 persons. ‘The shelters, sanitary facilities, water supplies, clinics and schools that were established were rudimentary.

The entire situation conspired to oppress the spirit as well as the body.’

A young artist from Amman, Mona Saudi wanted to do something for the children in the camp, so in 1968, she left her studies in Paris and went to Baqaa camp with paper and crayons giving the children an opportunity to express themselves freely outside of school… Titles of some of the pictures are ‘Girl, Tent and Apple,’ Fatima Salem, 6; ‘Planes: Birds of Prey,’ Fatima Abdul Fattah, 9; ‘Shepherd Watching His Sheep,’ Neimeh Salem, 6; ‘Assifa Goes to Battle,’ Mustafa Hussein, 11; and ‘Mosque of Omar,’ Muhammad Kandil, 11.

Neimeh Salem spoke of the children’s ordeal, ‘We walked in the mountains and the valleys all day, passing the dead, the bombs… the planes were following us wherever we went… it was like walking in a dream.’ The artist Boullata praised the children, ‘In front of the human monumentality of these naked works created by the tiny hands of sincere children, I feel all my best work is now reduced to the size of a postage stamp.’”

Six Palestinian children named with their ages, and one of them, Neimeh Salem, aged six, quoted at length. The archive holds a companion piece printed six days later that names none of them.

CP-1975-008 →

· Public Opinion · Chambersburg · page 1

Drawings on display

SHIPPENSBURG — A selection of crayon drawings by Palestinian refugee children, “Children’s Testimony at a Time of War,” are on display this month in the Huber Art Center at Shippensburg State College. The 35 pictures were created by children, ages five to 14, who became refugees as a result of the 1967 Arab-Israeli War.

The exhibit originated through the combined efforts of Kamal Boullata, a Palestinian artist living in Washington, D.C., and another Palestinian artist, Vladimir Tamari, who lives in Beirut. Tamari assembled the drawings and shipped them to the United States where Boullata selected the works and supervised the arranging and mounting.

The exhibit is on display in the Huber Art Center from 8 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. Monday through Friday.

The same exhibition, in the same county, six days after CP-1975-008. That paper printed six of the children’s names and their ages and quoted Neimeh Salem, aged six, on walking all day past the dead. This one names the two adult artists and the opening hours. Nothing was cut from a shared dispatch here: these are two papers making the same choice differently, and the whole difference is whether a child gets a name.

CP-1975-009 →

· The New York Times · New York

U.N. Agency Deficit Is Said to Threaten Palestinian Schools

“As many as 270,000 Palestinians go to schools financed and supervised by the United Nations agency in Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, the West Bank of the Jordan River and the Gaza Strip.”

A budget story. UNRWA runs short, Arafat cables Arab heads of state, and a quarter of a million children’s schooling is the line item. Fifty years before the same agency’s funding became the subject of the same argument.

CP-1975-021 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel Hits Refugee Camp And Guerrillas Retaliate

“Palestinians at refugee camp near Saida, in southern Lebanon, which was attacked by Israeli planes.”

Palestinians at refugee camp near Saida, in southern Lebanon, which was attacked by Israeli planes.

A photograph of a camp after an airstrike, printed beside a story about American bases in Asia. The grammar of the headline pair is worth reading twice: Israel hits, and guerrillas retaliate.

CP-1975-022 →

· Courier-Journal · Louisville · page 1

Kissinger's current peace effort stirring debate among Israelis

“In one movement that might indicate the seriousness with which Kissinger’s efforts are being viewed in the Middle East, some Arab groups outside Egypt have begun attacking what they evidently consider to be an imminent Sinai disengagement pact.

‘This American agreement, which now seems to be getting into the stage of actual implementation, poses the greatest danger to the nationalist cause — that is, the Arab struggle with Zionism — since the June 1967 war,’ commented Zuhair Mohsin, head of the Palestine Liberation Organization’s military department and leader of the Syrian-backed guerrilla group, Al Saiqa.

Yesterday a Beirut daily, Al Sharq, which usually reflects official Syrian views, mentioned a reported understanding that would commit Egypt to a position of nonbelligerency, which it said violated a standing Arab agreement on ‘no separate solutions and the necessity of prior consultations on each solution.’

The Iraqi-supported daily, Beirut, yesterday attacked the prospective Sinai accord for the first time, charging that it means ‘an end to the Palestine struggle … and the overall Arab struggle for the liberation of Palestine.’”

CP-1975-001 →

· Daily Oklahoman · Oklahoma City · page 1

Resolutions Set U.N. Stage for Vote on Zionism as Racism

Associated Press, United Nations, N.Y.

UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. (AP) — The General Assembly adopted two pro-Palestinian resolutions Monday, drawing heated reaction from Israel, and set the stage for a vote later on a third measure equating Zionism with racism. It appeared, too, would pass.

One of the approved resolutions, adopted by a vote of 93-18 with 27 abstentions, in effect bypasses Security Council decisions about Israel’s right to existence and stresses instead the rights of the Palestinians to return to their homes and property. Israel criticized the resolution as aimed at its destruction.

The other resolution calls for the participation of the Palestine Liberation Organization “in all efforts, deliberations and conferences on the Middle East” held under U.N. auspices. The vote was 101-8 with 25 abstentions. The United States voted against both measures.

In Jerusalem, Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin flatly rejected the resolutions, saying they “sabotage efforts to achieve peace between Israel and Arab states.”

He added that Israel will not cooperate with any committee set up to enforce an earlier resolution ensuring the Palestinians’ right to sovereignty and a return to land in what is now Israel, and will not talk with the PLO.

Last-minute efforts to block General Assembly approval of the resolution equating Zionism with racism apparently failed, and the anti-Israel coalition at the United Nations claimed enough votes for its approval. They beat back an attempt by Western and nonaligned nations to delay the vote until next year by a vote of 67-55 with 15 abstentions.

One European representative said he feared the expected assembly action would touch off hostile reactions to the world organization in the U.S. Congress, among the public and throughout Western Europe. The U.S. House of Representatives, in a resolution sponsored by 436 of its 437 members, asked the assembly to reject the resolution.

Two resolutions on Palestinian rights of return and PLO participation, with the vote counts, printed on a page otherwise given over to advertisements for Young Frankenstein, the Righteous Brothers and a seafood buffet.

CP-1975-002 →

· The Blade · Toledo · page 1

U.N. Issue On Zionism As Racism Is Approved

Vote Is 72-35; Arab-Led Resolution In Assembly Opposed By U.S., Israel

Associated Press, United Nations

UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. (AP) — The U.N. General Assembly overrode bitter opposition from the United States and Israel Monday night to approve an Arab-inspired resolution that labels Zionism “a form of racism and racial discrimination.” The vote was 72-35 with 32 abstentions. “A great evil has been loosed upon the world,” U.S.

Ambassador Daniel P. Moynihan told the 143-nation assembly after casting the U.S. vote against the resolution. “The abomination of anti-Semitism has been given the appearance of international sanction.”

Among those voting against were the United States, Israel, the nine members of the European Common Market, Australia, and Canada. Supporters of the resolution equating Zionism with racism said it was anti-Zionist but not anti-Semitic. They argued that Zionism — the movement for a Jewish national homeland in Palestine — is exclusive and thus racist. Mr.

Moynihan said the assembly had granted “symbolic amnesty, and more, to the murderers of the six million European Jews” during World War II.

He added that the United States “does not acknowledge, will not abide by, will never acquiesce in this infamous act”… Israeli Ambassador Chaim Herzog, taut with emotion, charged that the United Nations “is on its way to becoming the world center of anti-Semitism.” It was fitting, he said, that the decision was voted on Nov.

10 — the date in 1938 when Nazi stormtroopers attacked Jewish homes, businesses, and synagogues throughout Germany, smashing so many windows that it became known as “Krystal Night.”… Secretary General Kurt Waldheim said the vote “reflects a deep and bitter division among the membership at a time when the need for understanding on a wide range of critically important questions is more than ever necessary”… The votes followed approval of two resolutions on the Palestine Liberation Organization.

One of the approved resolutions, adopted by a vote of 93-18 with 27 abstentions, in effect bypasses Security Council decisions about Israel’s right to exist and stresses instead the rights of the Palestinians to return to their homes and property… The other resolution calls for the PLO’s participation “in all efforts, deliberations, and conferences on the Middle East” held under U.N. auspices.

The vote was 101-8 with 25 abstentions. The United States voted against both measures.

ANGRY MR. MOYNIHAN DENOUNCES U.N. ACTION — Assembly told U.S. will never accept ‘infamous act’

The vote itself, on the front page in Toledo, with the count, the losing arguments and the winning ones. Two other resolutions passed the same night and are reported in the same column: the right of Palestinians to return to their homes and property, 93 to 18, and a seat for the PLO at every United Nations conference on the Middle East, 101 to 8. The paper spells it Krystal Night.

CP-1975-011 →

· Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery · page 1

Communists’ Reactions Differ On Zionism-Racism Resolution

Associated Press

“The Italian Communist party, the largest in the West, differed with Moscow and criticized the U.N. General Assembly vote equating Zionism with racism, saying it was damaging to the Arab cause.

The Soviet news agency Tass hailed the resolution, and said Zionism is racism of the same kind that was practiced in Hitler’s Germany… French Communists straddled the issue, indicating that opposition to Zionism was not the same thing as advocating the destruction of the Israeli state… AFL-CIO President George Meany said, ‘It was a cowardly, reprehensible act, reminiscent of the days of Hitler and appeasement.’

He added: ‘The U.S. Congress must immediately re-evaluate continued United States participation in the U.N. How long can the American taxpayer be expected to bear a disproportionate share of the U.N.’s bills when it produces this kind of evil?’… The Canadian House of Commons, in a step similar to that taken Tuesday by the U.S.

Congress, unanimously condemned the U.N. action and said it was dangerous to the continued survival of the world organization. The resolution was greeted by cheers from both sides of the Commons. The president of the U.S.

Catholic Conference, Archbishop Joseph Bernadin of Cincinnati, expressed ‘profound disagreement’ and ‘great disappointment’ at the vote. Mayor Pete Wilson of San Diego said he has quit the board of the United Nations Association of San Diego in protest and said the United States ought to pull out of the United Nations itself.”

The same dispatch in Alabama, under a headline about Communists rather than the world. It runs on page 16. The paper spells the archbishop Bernadin.

CP-1975-012 →

· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha · page 1

Zionism Vote in U.N. Splits Russian, Italian Communists

Associated Press

“The Italian Communist party, the largest in the West, differed with Moscow and criticized the U.N. General Assembly vote equating Zionism with racism, saying it was damaging to the Arab cause. The Soviet news agency Tass hailed the resolution and said Zionism is racism of the same kind that was practiced in Hitler’s Germany.”

The third printing of the same dispatch, cut to two sentences and a headline about a split between Communists. What survives compression is the disagreement between Rome and Moscow. Everything about what the Palestinians said, and everything about the American reaction, is gone.

CP-1975-013 →

· The Times Picayune · page 1

World Reaction Varied Toward Zionism Vote

Associated Press

“The Italian Communist party, the largest in the West, differed with Moscow and criticized the U.N. General Assembly vote equating Zionism with racism, saying it was damaging to the Arab cause… The Italian Communist organ Unita said, ‘for reasons of principle we do not accept the equation between Zionism and racism.’

‘We regard this . . . as damaging the Arab cause itself, which thus loses rather than gains allies in those countries of Western Europe from which a positive contribution might have come toward a just and peaceful settlement in the Middle East,’ the newspaper said. The Soviet news agency Tass hailed the resolution… ‘One need hardly cite other facts to prove that daily practice of Zionism is racism pure and simple of the same kind that is being practiced today by South Africa and Rhodesia and was practiced in the not too distant past by Hitler’s Germany,’ it added.

Tass cited the eviction of Palestinians from their own land as testimony ‘to the fact that the Israeli Zionist authorities have made anti-Semitism’s methods their own.’… AFL-CIO President George Meany called the vote ‘a cowardly, reprehensible act, reminiscent of the days of Hitler and appeasement’… Secretary of State Henry A.

Kissinger, at a news conference in Pittsburgh, Pa., called the vote ‘extremely unhelpful and highly irresponsible’ in efforts to bring lasting peace to the Middle East.

He said, however, ‘We must now not swing to the other extreme of not realizing some of the benefits that the U.N., with all of its failings, still has for the United States.’… Iraq and Libya told the 138-nation assembly of the Food and Agriculture Organization in Rome that Israel should be expelled from the big U.N. agency.

‘There is no place for racism in this humane organization,’ said Iraqi Agricultural Minister Hassan Fahmy Jumah. But he offered no specific resolution.”

One Associated Press dispatch on how the world answered the vote, printed in three papers in this archive on the same day under three different headlines. New Orleans calls it varied.

CP-1975-014 →

· The New York Times

Zionism and Racism

By A. M. El-Messiri

Asian and African states that supported the United Nations resolution equating Zionism with racism acted the way they did not out of fear of Arab threats or blackmail, nor for love of Arab gold. They were simply giving a legal and concrete form to their long-held view of the Zionist state.

From the perspective of an Afro-Asian, it is not difficult to see Israel as yet another manifestation of a racist form of colonialization — namely, settler colonialism. Nineteenth-century Europe was overburdened not only with a surplus of commodities but also with what came to be termed “the human surplus.”

This last factor led to the establishment of pockets of settler colonialists in Algeria, Rhodesia, Angola, South Africa and Palestine, in order to absorb Europe’s unwanted surplus.

If some “idealists” saw the settlement of the Zionist pioneers as a fulfillment of Biblical prophecies, the displaced and evicted victims of the Zionist vision choose to see the whole process otherwise.

The Balfour Declaration of 1917, the first European official sanction of the Zionist ideal, referred to the Arab Moslems and Christians of Palestine, who made up over 90 percent of the population, as the “non-Jewish communities” — that is, the indigenous majority was already being ruthlessly relegated to the status of a minority in favor of Europe’s forthcoming surplus.

Zionist visionaries, under the aegis of British imperialism, did not come to share their knowledge and culture with the native Palestinians.

The settlers, guided by such ideals as Hebrew Labor, or Conquest of Soil, which implied that the redemption of the land of Israel and the regeneration of the “Jewish character” could not be achieved except through purely “Jewish” labor, actively set up institutions that acquired, by necessity, military traits because they excluded the indigenous population.

It was this exclusivist vision of the purely Jewish state that led all the Afro-Asian countries represented in the United Nations in 1947 to vote against the creation of a Jewish state in Palestine, South Africa being the only obvious exception. Through the years, the attitude of the Afro-Asian to Zionist supremacist isolationism solidified.

The new state promulgated the Law of Return granting the right to any Jew to become a citizen of Israel upon his arrival there, while denying the same right to a Palestinian who was probably born and reared there.

The collaboration between Israel and Britain and France in the 1956 invasion of Egypt helped to demonstrate that the new state was encapsulated in its racist view of itself as existing in Asia and Africa but not of them.

But Zionist racism is not a matter of political practice alone, for Zionist literature is rife with such phrases and terms as “Oriental barbarism” or “the super-nation,” a term coined by Ahad Haam, a leading spiritual Zionist. Even a soft-spoken “liberal” as Abba Eban claims that the goal of Israel is not one of integration.

“Quite the contrary,” he has assured everyone, “integration is rather something to be avoided.” In a 1957 book, he expressed his fears of brother Jews coming from “Oriental” countries, lest they should “force Israel to equalize its cultural level with that of the neighboring world.”

The United Nations resolution on Zionism is simply applying the principles of the United Nations to a structure and a movement about which some of the Western powers feel uneasy.

But it is a moral myopia to try to solve Auschwitz by Deir Yassin (the 1948 massacre of 254 unarmed Arab villagers by Irgun and Stern Gang terrorists) and, in answer to the Occidental concentration camps, propose the dispersion of the Palestinians: Justice knows no discrimination.

We even claim that the resolution helps the cause of peace in the Middle East, because as long as the Zionist state is free to impose its racist practices, the Arabs, with the support of other nations, will have to fight for their human rights and dignity.

An Israeli community, on the other hand, willing to integrate in being accepted would lay the foundation for a just and permanent peace, permanent precisely because it is just. Nor does the condemnation of Zionism imply any condemnation of Judaism, which is a matter of religious choice, unrelated to any land.

The Jews have undoubtedly religious and spiritual ties with a land they consider holy, a feeling comparable to that of many other peoples for many other lands; but that feeling is different from a political ideology that claims monopoly of a piece of land and dispossesses its people.

To insist on the identity of Zionism and Judaism is to insist that all Jews are Zionists, and, by implication, to attribute “eternal” political attitudes and loyalties to the Jew regardless of time and place.

Is not that the essence of anti-Semitism, which objectifies the Jew, rather than sees him as an ordinary human being rooted in his history, who has his quota of vices and virtues, and who is likely to espouse any political position?

The civil rights of the Jews are “sacred” insofar as human rights are sacred, but there is nothing inherently sacred or profane about any political ideology, even if it is Zionism, or any state, even if it is Israel.

A condemnation of Zionism as a form of racism is a condemnation of certain political ideals the Arabs consider exclusionary, and of a certain political practice we consider racist. Let me reiterate: Not all Jews are Zionists and not all Zionists are Jews.

One can even startle the American reader by pointing out that there are non-Zionist and even anti-Zionist groups and public figures inside Israel itself. Their critique of Zionism is getting sharper and more radical. Are they, too, going to be muzzled by being labeled anti-Semites?

CP-1975-027 →

· Standard Star · New Rochelle · page 1

Zionism not racism

“I don’t agree with the resolution. We should do more for the Zionists. They are people who have done nothing but good. The Israelis have the right to the land. The Arabs don’t have rights to the land because all they do is fight and they don’t want peace. The Isarelis want to live in peace and make the land prosperous for everyone there.

They should have the land. Zionism is not racism. You can’t say that if you want to live in peace. We shouldn’t pull out of the UN. We should all try to live in peace, the Israelis and the Arabs too. They shouldn’t leave a minority group like the Zionists out without a country.

Israel has gone through too much to have other countries, especially America, forget about them.”

A street interview in New Rochelle four days after the vote, printed with the speaker’s name, occupation and full home address, which was ordinary practice. The paper spells Isarelis. This is what the Harris Survey was measuring, one person at a time.

CP-1975-015 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel's Arabs Are Neither Pariahs Nor Fully Accepted

“They are Israel’s Palestinians: the Arabs who stood their ground during the turmoil of the 1948 war and have lived and worked in… There are no Israeli Arabs among the ranks of the Israeli establishment. Their absence from the army keeps them out of the single most cohesive and upwardly-mobile institution in the country.”

Terence Smith, and the first clause settles a question the rest of this archive spends decades circling. They are Israel’s Palestinians. The Times prints it plainly in 1975, in the same paragraph in which it goes on calling them Israeli Arabs for the next thirty years. The headline tries a fourth form again — Israel’s Arabs, possessive.

CP-1975-025 →

· The Boston Globe · Boston · page 1

On UN resolution branding Zionism as racist

Letters to the editor

“New York demonstrators denounce United Nations resolution equating Zionism with racism.” The lead letter is by Benjamin Varon, former Ambassador of Israel to the Dominican Republic, Jamaica, and Paraguay, of Brookline. Five more follow, headed “Vote ‘a disgrace’” (Norman B.

Meisner, Newton Centre), “Day of infamy” (Louis Lowy, Newton Highlands), “Zionism means freedom” (Steve Copeland, Hull), “Aimed at Christians” (Harry Cotton, Worcester) and “Get UN out of US” (Leo F. Kahian, Middleboro).

New York demonstrators denounce United Nations resolution equating Zionism with racism.

A full letters page a week after the vote, printed under a news photograph of a Jewish Defense League demonstration in New York. Three placards are legible in it. One reads NEVER AGAIN. One reads 20 COUNTRIES FOR ARABS ONE FOR JEWS. The third reads ANTI-ZIONISM CODE WORD FOR ANTI-SEMITISM — which is the argument that would be made in a headline forty years later, already on a stick, three weeks after the resolution passed.

CP-1975-016 →

· Knoxville News-Sentinel · Knoxville · page 1

Palestinians Called Victims of Zionism

Jim Harb, 2301 Laurel Ave

“EDITOR, The News-Sentinel: The editorial ‘The UN Against Israel’ printed Nov. 12 in which you refer to ‘the vicious and unfair move by the United Nations General Assembly in calling Zionism a form of racism,’ while emotionally strong in its thrust, was rationally weak in its analysis of the situation.

Zionism is an international political movement intended to ingather the Jews of the world into Palestine to create a national home for the Jewish people. It is differentiated from Judaism, a monotheistic religion of universalist values.

Since there are Jews who are not Zionists and Zionists who are not Jews, it is essential to keep in mind the distinction between Zionism and Judaism.

The aim of the Zionist movement, as formulated by the First Zionist Congress held in Basle, Switzerland, in 1897, was stated thusly: ‘Zionism strives to create for the Jewish people a home in Palestine secured by public law.’

The congress went on to state that Zionism would be achieved by ‘the promotion on suitable lines of the colonization of Palestine by Jewish agricultural and industrial workers’ (‘Zionism,’ Leonard Stein, p. 62).

At this time, when plans were being formulated for colonization of Palestine by world Jewry, the Jewish population of Palestine was less than 2 per cent of the total population of Palestine, while the Christian and Moslem population constituted the remaining 97 per cent of the population.

It is then that Theodore Herzl, known as the father of modern Zionism and the first president of the World Zionist Organization, wrote ‘The Jewish State.’ This book, first published in 1896, was an important foundation of the Zionist movement.

Herzl went on to write about the Palestinian population: ‘We shall try to spirit the penniless population across the border by procuring employment for it in the transit countries, while denying it any employment in our own country’ (Complete Diaries, Vol. I, p. 88).

In 1948, the Zionists proclaimed the State of Israel, and it was forceably defended in the war of 1948-1949. At this time over 750,000 Palestinians were made refugees. They were not allowed to return to their homes and villages.

During this war, Yigal Allon, then commander of the Palmach, the underground Zionist army, and later to become Israeli foreign minister, talked about the Palestinians in the Galilee area of Palestine.

Said Allen, ‘We saw a need to cleanse the Inner Galilee and to create a Jewish territorial succession in the entire area of the upper Galilee’ (‘Palestine Is The Issue,’ Association of Arab-American University Graduates, 1975). During the war of 1948-1949, a well-known incident occurred at the Palestinian village of Deir Yasin.

As reported by the International Red Cross, 254 Palestinian men, women and children were killed by members of the Irgun and the Stern Group, two Zionist military units.

Menachem Begin, leader of the Irgun, commented on the incident: ‘The massacre was not only justified, but there would not have been a state of Israel without the victory at Deir Yasin’ (‘The Revolt: Story of the Irgun,’ Menachem Begin, 1951).

After the State of Israel had been created and after the 1967 war, which saw more Palestinian land occupied and more Palestinians made refugees, Moshe Dayan, defense minister of Israel, said that the Palestinian refugees created by the 1967 war could be taken back by Israel, but that Israel would not do so because Israel would become ‘either a binational or poly Arab/Jewish state and we want to have a Jewish state.

We can absorb them, but then it won’t be the same country’ (‘New York Review of Books,’ Aug. 3, 1967, p. 3, I. F. Stone).

And commenting on the fact that the Palestinians had lived in Palestine long before the Zionists/Israelis, Moshe Dayan later told a group of students at the Haifa Technion that ‘there is not a single Jewish village in this country that has not been built on the site of an old Arab village. The village of Nahalal took the place of the Arab village of Mahloul. . . .

Gifat took the place of Jifta. . .’ (‘The Guardian,’ Nov. 14, 1973, p. 16). These examples reflect Zionism and the goals and objectives that Zionists have historically pursued, particularly as those goals and objectives related to the Palestinians.

But even more revealing is a quote by Golda Meir, then prime minister of Israel, which reflects the Zionist mentality toward the Palestinians as a people. Mrs. Meir said ‘There was no such thing as Palestinians . . .

It was not as though there was a Palestinian people in Palestine considering itself as a Palestinian people and we came and threw them out and took their country away from them. They did not exist’ (Sunday Times, London, June 15, 1969).

Obviously the Zionists would not consider themselves racists, for if the Palestinians as a people do not exist, then there is no one to be racist toward. The world, however, knows different. We know the Palestinians exist. We know that they have lived in the land of Palestine for centuries, held together by a strong and lasting culture.

What we must now decide is whether this political movement of Zionism is in fact racist in nature toward the Palestinian people. Herzl’s fundamental proposition was that the only security for the Jews, and the only cure to anti-Jewishness, was to ingather all Jews into the Jewish state. That is why the Zionists want an exclusively Jewish state.

That is why Israel will not let the Palestinians return to their homeland. That is Zionism. What is wonderful about the Zionists of Israel is that they fought back against tyranny and oppression and anti-Jewishness throughout the world. They seized their own destiny and became masters of their own fate.

What is terrible about the Zionists is that the creation of the State of Israel occurred at the expense of the Palestinian people.”

A reader answering the paper’s editorial, at the length of a column, with a page citation after every quotation. The paper printed it whole.

CP-1975-003 →

· Des Moines Tribune · Des Moines · page 1

Says Zionism fights racism

Jay Brown, letter to the editor

“I was shocked when the U.N. voted for a resolution stating that Zionism is racism… Zionism was started as a protection against racism, not to promote it.”

Nine days after the vote, a reader in Des Moines sets out the four courses he says were open to Jews after the Russian pogroms — assimilation, revolution, tradition, and Zionism — and answers the resolution with the fourth. His full street address is printed under his name.

CP-1975-017 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago

THE UNITED NATIONS HAS CONDEMNED ZIONISM. THE UNITED NATIONS HAS NOT CONDEMNED JUDAISM

“On November 10, 1975, the General Assembly of the United Nations voted to condemn Zionism, not Judaism, as a form of racism and racial discrimination.

The Zionism that this resolution speaks about is a concrete political ideology, articulated by a concrete political organization and which manifested itself in concrete practices, which had the effect of excluding some people on the basis of their being non-Jews and including others on the basis of their being Jews.”

A full advertisement bought in the Chicago Tribune eleven days after Resolution 3379, arguing the distinction in its own headline. The archive holds the resolution’s long afterlife elsewhere; this is somebody paying for newspaper space to define the terms.

CP-1975-024 →

· The Morning Call · Allentown · page 1

Consul deplores equating Zionism with racism

Dick Cowen, of The Morning Call

“Emanuel Shimoni, consul general of the Israeli Consulate in Philadelphia, concentrated on what he regards as the three major current issues involving Israel during an interview yesterday afternoon in Allentown.

These were the United Nations resolution which equated Zionism with racism, the proposed extension of a U.N. force on the Golan Heights between Israel and Syria, and a proposed $2.3 billion in American aid to Israel. The interview was at the Allentown Jewish Community Center, where Shimoni spoke at a rally in the evening.

During the interview, his wife Rayla was visiting at the home of her cousin, Mrs. Dorothy Roth of Allentown. Mrs. Shimoni and Mrs. Roth have known each other since childhood in South Africa.

The envoy said the reaction of Jews to the U.N. resolution branding Zionism as racism ‘is one of outrage and also of an attempt to explain to the world there is no relationship whatsoever between Zionism and racism.’

He said the U.N. resolution was an attempt by a group of nations, led by Arabs and supported by Moslems, Communists and a number of African countries, to discredit Israel and the Jewish people. ‘Although the resolution talks about Zionism, today anyone who supports Israel and believes in the right of the Jewish people to have a state of their own is a Zionist.

Anti-Zionism is that effort to suggest that there should be no State of Israel politically and to place Israel in the position where, if attacked by the Arab states, she will not have the support of the world for her existence as she has in the past.

The resolution is part of an overall strategy of the Arabs to isolate Israel politically and to place Israel in the position where, if attacked by the Arab states, she will not have the support of the world for her existence as she has in the past.

The nations that supported the anti-Zionism resolution include all the dictatorships, the Communists, the countries that have used repression and have been lacking in humanity. The resolution was opposed by all the enlightened nations of the world, led by the U.

S., supported by Western Europe, Scandanavia and a number of Central American and African states, despite the pressure of the Arabs on them. The Jews all over the world are reacting vehemently to this resolution. It has in it the grains of a new anti-Semitism which represents a threat to Jews and Jewish communities everywhere.’

Shimoni declined to comment specifically on a boycott by American Jews of Mexican tourist spots. Mexico voted for the U.N. resolution.

‘But it does not surprise me,’ he said, ‘that anybody who considers himself a Zionist should not want to visit a country which has supported a resolution denigrating Zionism and calling for its elimination.’… Shimoni said the Middle East conflict has been globalized because the Arabs have obtained ‘tremendous quantities of arms and military equipment’ from Russia, plus additional purchases from Western Europe and even the U.S.

‘Israel is unable to match what the Arabs have with her own resources. Therefore, we have asked the U.S. to insure the balance of power in the Middle East by providing us with the means to purchase arms.’ He said the Arabs have obtained $15 billion in arms since October 1973.

Israel considers a ‘reasonable balance’ of armaments being outnumbered 4-1, he said. But this balance can only be achieved through U.S. assistance, he added.”

“Emanuel Shimoni — Explaining dilemma…” · “… need for U.S. aid”

An Israeli consul interviewed in Allentown three weeks after the Zionism-is-racism vote, given the whole column. The reporter records where his wife spent the afternoon.

CP-1975-005 →

· Santa Barbara News-Press · Santa Barbara · page 1

Zionism, racism: Another viewpoint

Our Readers’ Views

Theodore A. Kalil, letter to the editor

“In answer to our ambassador to the United Nations, Mr. Moynihan, and his savage attack on the UN resolution… Ben-Gurion, quoted by I. F. Stone: ‘. . . Israel is the country of the Jews and only of the Jews.’

Moshe Dayan on ‘Face the Nation’: ‘There are about a million Arabs whom we don’t want as citizens in Israel . . . it would turn Israel into either a bi-national or an Arab-Jewish state instead of a Jewish state, and we want a Jewish state.’

Golda Meir to the Knesset: ‘I want a Jewish state with a decisive Jewish majority which cannot change overnight . . . I always believed this was plain Zionism.’… Moshe Dayan to students in Haifa: ‘There is not a single Jewish village in the country that has not been built on the site of an Arab village.

The village of Nahalal took the place of the Arab village of Mahloul . . . Gifat took the place of Jifta.’… Joseph Weitz of the Jewish Agency Colonization Department, in Davar: ‘The only solution is Palestine without Arabs . . . not one village, not one tribe should be left.’”

A month after the vote, a reader answers Moynihan not with an argument but with a stack of quotations from Israeli leaders, assembled and printed as he assembled them. The paper runs its own rules for letter writers in a box alongside: keep them to 250 words or fewer, be fair, be factual, disagree if you must, but try not to be disagreeable. These are quotations as the letter printed them, not as this archive has verified them.

CP-1975-018 →

· Longview Daily News · Longview · page 1

Americans disagree with U.N. on Zionism as racism

The Harris Survey

“A 49-9 per cent plurality of the American people disapproves of the recent United Nations resolution proclaiming that ‘Zionism is racism and a form of racial prejudice.’

However, a significantly high 42 per cent either are not sure of how they feel about the issue or simply have not followed the event… A 66-12 per cent majority of the college educated disapproved, as does an even higher 70-8 per cent majority of professional people… On a straight-out sympathy question between the Israelis and the Arabs, the margin is now eight to one pro-Israel, which had dropped close to five to one just this past summer… The main reason that people are opposed to the U.N. action is the feeling that ‘Jewish people are entitled to have a homeland of their own.’

And no more than 9 per cent of the American people believe that ‘Zionism is racism.’”

A national poll, 1,475 adults, taken between November 22 and 29, 1975. The single largest figure in the table is 42 per cent not sure. Among those with eighth-grade schooling or less, 63 per cent were not sure; among college graduates, 22 per cent.

CP-1975-006 →

· The Kansas City Times · Kansas City · page 1

Zionists Are Racists, Envoy Says

John Redmon, New York Correspondent

New York — “Zionist propaganda” is working to obscure the issues underlying last month’s anti-Zionism resolution in the United Nations and to confuse the world body’s legitimate condemnation of Israel’s “racist” policies in the Arab-Israeli conflict, an Arab spokesman here believes.

Marwan Kanafani, information director at the Arab League’s Office of the Permanent Observer to the United Nations, said recently that many Americans who sympathize with the Israelis in their struggle against the Arab states would nonetheless disapprove of the racial discrimination that he alleged is being practiced in Israel… “This has nothing whatsoever to do with Judaism as a faith,” he said.

“In this resolution, the international community has condemned a political ideology which manifests itself in concrete practices.”… Kanafani said the resolution is constructive in that it frames this issue in proper terms. “We are not anti-Semites. We are Semites ourselves.

We are especially aware in the Middle East of the difference between Judaism as a faith and Zionism as a political ideology, and the international community has now shown that it agrees with us.”… “Whatever I tell you about New York,” he said, “it will be understandable. There are more Jews here than in Israel.

But you must remember that New York is not the whole world.”… “Those are beautiful letters,” he added, smiling. “The other group…,” his smile faded, “they cut our ads and put dirty words on them and send them back. You ought to see some of them.

You would be ashamed to be an American.”… “You can criticize anyone here in the United States,” he said with a smile, “but you can’t criticize Israel. Oh, you can go out onto the street corner and say bad things about Israel, but just try to get it on television or in the newspapers.

You can’t do it.”… “These people just write dirty words,” he said. “They do not discuss; they do not make sense. They just take it for granted that if you talk against Zionism, you are talking against the Jews.”… “I was born in Palestine,” he said. “My father was born there.

My great-grandfather was born there. The Israelis say we do not deserve to be citizens in Israel.

But Golda Meir, who was born in Russia and raised in the United States — she is a Jew, and she thinks she automatically has to have full citizenship.” Kanafani, a Moslem, said, “I believe I am closer to a Palestinian Jewish young man than I am to a Pakistani Moslem.

But a Jew from anywhere in the world is thought to be closer to an Israeli Jew than an Arab from 10 miles away.” Kanafani brushes aside Israeli arguments that Arabs are citizens in Israel and that some occupy very prominent positions.

Arabs are only “third class” citizens, he said, and those who are in high positions are placed there only for propaganda purposes.

“The president of France, under Vichy, was French,” he said, referring to the World War II pro-Nazi government… In contrast to the “aggressive, exclusivist, and expansionist” state of Israel, he said, the P.L.O. seeks a democratic secular state in which no distinctions as to race or religion would be drawn.

A Palestinian official taking apart the difference between a faith and a political ideology, printed down a narrow column on page 8A. The rest of the page is a JCPenney toy sale: Sunshine family van, now 8.44; Big Jim’s Sky Commander, now 2.99; Merry Christmas from JCPenney. Nothing was cut. The argument simply runs beside the toys.

CP-1975-010 →

· Staten Island Advance · Staten Island · page 1

Most disapprove of U.N. Zionism proclamation

The Harris Survey

By Louis Harris

“A 49-9 per cent plurality of the American people disapproves of the recent United Nations resolution proclaiming that ‘Zionism is racism and a form of racial prejudice.’

However, a significantly high 42 per cent either are not sure of how they feel about the issue or simply have not followed the event. A 66-12 per cent majority of the college educated disapproved, as does an even higher 70-8 per cent of professional people… nowhere in the country does approval of the U.N.’s action reach a mark higher than 14 per cent… The main reason that people are opposed to the U.N. action is the feeling that ‘Jewish people are entitled to have a homeland of their own.’

And no more than 9 per cent of the American people believe that ‘Zionism is racism.’… By 54 per cent, a majority takes the U.N. vote as a sign that ‘anti-semitism is high in many parts of the world’… On a straight-out sympathy question between the Israelis and the Arabs, the margin is now eight to one pro-Israel.

This had dropped close to five to one just this past summer… Between Nov. 22 and 29, the Harris Survey asked a cross section of 1,475 adults nationwide… The United States may have been outvoted in the recent United Nations debate on whether Zionism is indeed racism, but in the process, U.S. support for the U.N. has been seriously weakened.”

The second printing in this archive of the same syndicated column, the same day as the Longview Daily News version already held. This one prints both tables in full, broken down by schooling and by job: approval never rises above 12 per cent in any group, and among people who left school at eighth grade, 63 per cent have no view at all. Nine per cent of Americans agreed with the resolution. Forty-two per cent had not followed it.

CP-1975-019 →

· The Times Record · page 1

Arabs push UNESCO through resolution vote

‘Zionism equals racism’

Associated Press, Paris

PARIS (AP) — Arab states Wednesday pushed through a vote at a meeting of the United Nations Scientific, Educational and Cultural Organization — UNESCO — introducing the explosive “Zionism equals racism” resolution adopted by the U.N. General Assembly this year.

Grim-faced members of the U.S. delegation, who had led a fight against any reference to Zionism at a meeting on the work of the mass media, consulted immediately with Washington on their future action here. There have been suggestions that the United States and some other Western nations were contemplating walking out of the meeting if the vote went through.

The Israeli delegation said before the vote that if it was accepted “we will see no further purpose in this meeting.”

The vote came at a meeting of government experts preparing a draft declaration on “fundamental principles governing the use of the mass media in strengthening peace and international understanding, and in combating all war propaganda, racism and apartheid.”

The meeting voted, 36 to 22, with seven abstentions, and the rest of the 80-odd delegations absent, to include in the preamble references to the General Assembly’s Zionism resolution and two previous U.N. votes on Zionism.

The vote was on a Yugoslav proposed compromise giving only the numbers of the resolutions, after Arab states led by Algeria had put forward a wording spelling out the alleged link between Zionism and racism.

The document on the mass media has been under discussion at various levels since the idea was first proposed by the Soviet Union in 1972… Voting with the Arab nations were a scattering of other Third World countries and most of the Soviet bloc nations. Many African nations were absent from the session for the vote… U.S. chief delegate Robert F.

Stowe, assistant legal adviser for United Nations affairs at the State Department, said the vote “was as much as we had expected, but we had hoped to avoid a vote.”

The United States, backed by the nine European Common Market countries, Australia and Canada, among others, had called for the meeting to continue the consensus policy it had adopted on other portions of the text.

The aftermath of the General Assembly resolution, six weeks later, at a meeting about the mass media. No Palestinian is quoted in it.

CP-1975-007 →

· The New York Times

Palestinians and Leftist Factions Open an Offensive in Beirut

By JAMES M. MARKHAM

BEIRUT, Lebanon, Jan. 7—After a bombardment of Christian positions by rockets and mortars, Palestinian guerrillas and their leftist allies today opened an offensive in the eastern suburbs of Beirut, reportedly seizing sections of one small Christian suburb.

The Christian right-wing Phalangist Party, which had blockaded the heavily armed refugee camp of Tell Zaatar and neighboring Moslem quarters for two days, acknowledged that the attackers had moved into the Horj Tabet quarter.

A spokesman for the Phalangists said Palestinian guerrillas had occupied two hospitals in the quarter and the villa of a Christian millionaire, Tanois Saba. The spokesman said that the captured quarter of Horj Tabet, which is on high ground overlooking Tell Zaatar, had been held by Lebanese security forces.

He said that at 12:30 P.M. the Christian rightists began a counteroffensive for the high ground and that “the fighting is still continuing.” A Palestinian spokesman acknowledged that guerrillas were fighting alongside Lebanese leftists. But he asserted that the attack was defensive, intended to break a blockade on food imposed by Christians.

“Most of the fighters are Lebanese because the hungriest are Lebanese,” he said, adding that the camp of Tell Zaatar had stocks of food but that the Moslem shantytowns did not. Unofficial reports said that 22 armed men had been killed and 44 wounded in the fighting in the suburbs. But it was believed that the toll of casualties was higher.

A spokesman for Wafa, the Palestinian press service, said that the guerrillas involved in the offensive were from a “broad spectrum” of Palestinian organizations. In the past, notably in the battle for Beirut’s luxury hotels late in October, major Palestinian guerrilla groups supported leftist and Moslem Lebanese factions against the Christians.

But today was the first time that Palestinians openly acknowledged involvement in the factional strife in Lebanon in the last nine months. Some accounts said that hundreds of armed men had been thrown into the battle in a stretch of poor suburbs between the Beirut River and the steep hills to the east.

At least two armored personnel carriers manned by Lebanese security troops were reported to have been destroyed by the assault force, which used rockets, mortars, machine guns and antiaircraft guns.

In the wake of the offensive, exchanges of rocket and mortar fire spread along Beirut’s so-called “confrontation line,” which runs from the Damascus Highway to the charred downtown section of the city. But the focus of the fighting appeared to remain in the suburbs. The largely Christian quarter of Sin el-Fil was reported to be under intense shelling tonight.

The Phalangists contend that the Moslems want to link the Tell Zaatar area with the Moslem quarter of Nabaa, which lies on the other side of Sin el-Fil. The Phalangists were reported to have attacked the Karantina port area, while Moslem forces were reported to be advancing from the suburb of Chiyah into the neighboring Christian stronghold of Ain el-Rummaneh.

A Phalangist militiaman on guard in Sin el-Fil, a heavily Christian suburb of Beirut, Lebanon, during an attack yesterday by Palestinian forces. | Palestinian and allied offensive was reported in Sin el-Fil area.

CP-1976-024 →

· Paducah Sun · Paducah · page 1

Equation Of Zionism With Racism Shocked Cleaver

By Eldridge Cleaver

“Two aspects of the recent U.N. resolution labeling Zionism as racist both shocked and surprised me.

Shocked because of all the people in the world, the Jews have not only suffered particularly from racist persecution, they have done more than any other people in history to expose and condemn racism. Generations of Jewish social scientists and scholars have labored long and hard in every field of knowledge, from anthropology to psychology, to lay bare and refute all claims of racial inferiority and superiority.

To condemn the Jewish survival doctrine of Zionism as racism is a travesty upon the truth… I have the deepest sympathy for the Palestinian people in their search for justice, but I see no net gain for freedom and human dignity in the world if power blocs, because of their ability to underwrite sagging economies for a season, are able to ram through the U.N. resolutions repugnant to human reason and historical fact. I believe that the time has come to reexamine the credentials of all the members of the General Assembly.

Why should all these little so-called countries with minuscule populations have a vote equal in weight to that of the United States? The so-called hardline adopted at the U.N. by Ambassador Moynihan seems too soft to me… It may seem paradoxical that I write these words from a prison cell in California.

I am certainly not a stranger to racism — I have personally experienced it in the ghettoes and prison yards of America.”

A guest column written from a prison cell in California by a founder of the Black Panther Party, six years after a party official had declared in the party paper that Jewishness, Zionism and racism were identical. The column also carries a sweeping charge against Arabs as a people, which is printed here as the paper printed it. Two months later a professor in Honolulu answered it by name.

CP-1976-012 →

· Midland Reporter Telegram · Midland

Arab prisoner manages to retain political attitudes

Colin Legum

William Naguib Nasr is one of Israel’s 2,786 Arab prisoners. Convicted of crimes from mass killing of civilians to organizing political resistance. Still only in his early thirties, he is soft-spoken with a gentle manner and very tender eyes. He had an Arab father and a Jewish mother.

He has already served seven years for his part in a political murder, but his time in prison has done nothing to alter his political attitudes. Ignoring the two warders who accompanied me into the “politicals” exercise yard in Ramle prison, he introduced himself to me as “a member of el Fatah” — the Palestine Liberation Organization.

I explained that I had been given permission by Israel’s Minister of Police Shlomo Hillel to visit any — or all — of the prisons in which Arab political prisoners were held, to examine reports of ill-treatment. “Why,” he asked, “did you choose Ramle? This is the Hilton of all the prisons.”

I had, in fact, deliberately chosen Ramle because a prisoner who had escaped from there reported in Beirut that regular mass public beatings of prisoners occurred there in the presence of the minister of police and the director of prisons.

Of the score or so of prisoners I spoke to in Ramle prison — and I left it to each of them to approach me voluntarily — all said that none of them experienced physical violence in Ramle. Nasr, however, told me that prisoners had been punished for talking politics before the October 1973 war. What kind of punishment?

“We were sent into solitary confinement, denied canteen privileges or put in the dungeons. Some, including myself, were sent to a special punishment prison at Ashkelon, where we were made to kneel, forced to address prison officers as “Sir,” and where we were beaten as many as three times a day.

Nothing like that has happened here, but I am told it is still going on at Ashkelon.” At Ashkelon and at other prisons, similar stories are told — but all the reports refer either to events before 1970, or are still believed to occur in “the other prisons.”

CP-1976-018 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago

Drive to liberate Palestine intensifies

SHTAURA, Lebanon — They stride into the little coffee shop carrying their Kalashnikov rifles and breathing defiance against an enemy they may never fight on their own terms, much less defeat in battle.

“We will drive them into the sea,” says a grizzled 15-year veteran of the Palestine Liberation Army, repeating one of the oldest of Arab taunts against the Jewish invaders, pointing his rifle angrily to illustrate what he will do to the Jews when . . . . But when will they begin this campaign?

It is a question that most Palestinians can only answer with more generalities, more lour boasts, more shouts, more speeches, more imprecations — and little substantive information or insight.

BENEATH THE LEVEL of rhetoric, however, the drive to “liberate Palestine” has gained unprecedented momentum in recent months as a result not only of the war in Lebanon but of international recognition of the existence of a Palestinian national identity.

A few years ago the world was hardly aware of the concept of a Palestine state, leaders of the Palestine Liberation Organization are fond of pointing out. Now Middle East experts generally acknowledge the Palestinians are a major key in any peace settlement. The passage of years has not mellowed the rhetoric.

If anything, the fighting zeal of the Palestinians appears to have hardened, as epitomized by the PLA soldiers encountered here. “We will defeat them all,” bellows the veteran, a native of the Isreali-held “West Bank” region, as a couple of young PLA soldiers grin approvingly.

“When I go back, it will not be across the bridge but through the mountains.”

CP-1976-017 →

· Honolulu Star-Bulletin · Honolulu · page 1

Zionism and Racism

A Particular Point of View

By Yasumasa Kuroda, Professor of Political Science, University of Hawaii

“Little has been said in the United States in defense of the Third World and its sponsorship of the resolution… The British authority reports that less than seven per cent of the land in Palestine belonged to Jewish owners at the end of the mandate in 1948. There is no democratic way or peaceful means through which Zionists could have realized their goal of developing an exclusively Jewish state in Palestine without jeopardizing the civil rights of non-Jews.

There are only two ways. You either drive the natives out into the desert or subjugate them as third class citizens. How else can anyone build a country on somebody else’s land?… The Israeli Law of Return gives every Jew, just because one is a Jew, the right to immigrate at any time to Israel and to obtain Israeli nationality.

On the other hand, even Gentiles who were born in Palestine are not allowed to return to their homes in Palestine just because they happened to be either Christians or Moslems.

Foreigners such as Soviet Jews are welcomed in Israel but native Palestinians are not allowed to return to their homes. If this is not racism, what is?… Even Americans of Palestinian origin are treated differently as they enter Israel.

They are asked to go through a special and separate gate at Tel Aviv International Airport… Why do our mass media call those who resisted the Russian occupation of Czechoslovakia freedom fighters while we continue to refer to those who resist the Israeli occupation of Palestine ‘terrorists’?

Are we in our zeal to prove our freedom from antisemitism, inadvertently transferring our antipathy from one Semite group to the other, i.e., anti-Jewish to anti-Arab?”

A signed op-ed defending the resolution in an American daily, which is rare, by a political scientist in Hawaii who is neither Arab nor Jewish. It answers Eldridge Cleaver’s column of two months earlier by name. Its last question — whether opposing antisemitism has been turned into antipathy toward Arabs — is the argument that would be running in American papers forty years later, made here in 1976 and pointed the other way. The paper spells Ashkanazi.

CP-1976-013 →

· Bellingham Herald · Bellingham · page 1

Plight of four schoolgirls illustrates frustration of West Bank occupation

World Affairs

William Frye

RAMALLAH, Occupied West Bank, Israel — Four distressed high school girls, aged 16 to 18, sat in Mayor Karim Khlaf’s office and told a story that epitomizes the sadness and the frustration of the Israeli occupation of the Jordanian West Bank. The girls had taken part in a demonstration in their 11th and 12th grade classrooms at the Ramallah Secondary Girls School, cheering for the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) and against Israeli occupation.

Israeli soldiers came and took some of them away. They were brought before a military court and 20 of them were fined between 5,000 and 6,000 Israeli pounds each. This is a sum equivalent to between $677 and $800. They could not pay. The court gave them a month to raise the money. The deadline was near, and they were terrified.

If they did not pay, their fathers would be taken to jail. The girls sat near the mayor’s desk, twisting their hands and trying to fight back the tears. Their parents, one said, tossing black pigtails defiantly, supported them.

But naturally, the fathers did not want to go to jail. Mayor Khalaf, a 38-year-old Palestinian, said he would try to get the fines reduced, and if that failed would see if he could raise the money among Ramallah businessmen. The girls left with a ray of hope… The spokesman, David Zohar, said there were many such cases each year.

The fines, a spokesman said, range between “some hundreds and some thousands of pounds.” In the Israeli view, this is a relatively mild security measure.

In one school, the Kadri Toukan School in Nablus, 73 youngsters were hurt by club-swinging soldiers. In another, the Al Bireh Secondary Girls School near Ramallah, a 26-year-old teacher, Floranda Lahham, blocked the soldiers’ way in a doorway and was sentenced by a military court to five years in prison.

The jail term was later commuted, but Lahham had to pay a 2,500-pound ($340) fine and was suspended from her job without pay for six months. Her mother is dead and her father is unemployed. The four girls spilled out these stories, and others, with great earnestness and deep concern. Their sincerity was evident. The mayor and an Anglican priest, the Rev. Audeh G.

Rantisi, head of a nearby evangelical home for boys, supported their account… Thirteen college men were hospitalized and five were fined 3,500 pounds (almost $500) each. The mayor and city council later resigned in protest… Children have taken to the streets because their elders do not dare protest openly and they do, it is said.

Schoolgirls of sixteen to eighteen, fined more than a year’s wages for cheering in a classroom, sitting in the mayor’s office trying not to cry because their fathers will go to prison if they cannot pay. One of them tosses her pigtails and says her parents are behind her. A twenty-six-year-old teacher, Floranda Lahham, stood in a doorway to stop the soldiers and was given five years, commuted to a fine and six months without pay. Her mother is dead and her father has no work, and the paper prints that too.

CP-1976-011 →

· Effingham Daily News · page 1

Arabs Killed In Rioting In Israel

United Press International, Deir Hana, Israel

DEIR HANA, Israel (UPI) — Security forces opened fire on a crowd of rioting Arabs today, killing three demonstrators in the early hours of the first general strike by the nation’s minority Arabs. The renewed violence raised the death toll in northern Galilee to four in what may be the worst outbreak of Arab rioting in Israel since the birth of the Jewish nation.

A government spokesman said troops and police shot and killed three Arab youths in the village of Sakhnin hours after killing another young Arab in nearby Deir Hana. The spokesman said the security forces fired warning shots first in an attempt to break up a crowd of Arabs hurling stones, bottles and firebombs.

He said the troops fired into the crowd when the Arabs ignored the warning. Nine policemen and soldiers were wounded in the confrontation. Seventy Arabs were arrested… Tens of thousands of Arabs went on strike in Israel, bringing economic life to a halt in the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Nazareth, Galilee’s major town.

Authorities reported sporadic disturbances all across Galilee this morning in the strike called to protest the seizure of thousands of acres of Arab land. The predominantly Arab Israeli Communist party accused troops of beating up children without provocation during the morning in Nazareth, but the Israeli government reported the city quiet.

Arab sources said police arrested dozens of youngsters in towns and villages around Nazareth. They reported a “total strike” on the West Bank with the region’s major towns—Hebron, Nablus, Ramallah, Bethlehem and Jenin—brought to a standstill. One Arab was killed and at least 16 were injured Monday night.

Authorities imposed a round-the-clock curfew on three Galilee towns and sealed them off from the rest of Israel… The overall impact of the walkout among the 400,000 Arabs living in Israel was not known. But a sympathy strike by Arabs on the occupied West Bank of the Jordan River and in East Jerusalem appeared more successful.

Arab sources there reported virtually all stores and schools closed in Bethlehem, Nablus, Hebron and Ramallah, the major West Bank cities, as well as in the Old City of Jerusalem.

Land Day, the day it happened, in an Illinois daily. Four hundred thousand Arabs living in Israel, a general strike against the seizure of their land, and four of them shot. The government account and the Arab account are printed in consecutive paragraphs. The headline calls it rioting.

CP-1976-002 →

· Pittsburgh Press · Pittsburgh · page 1

Israel Fights ‘Worst Arab Riot’

6 Killed, 69 Wounded In General Strike

By Ohad Gozani, United Press International, Deir Hana, Israel

DEIR HANA, Israel (UPI) — Arabs hurling rocks, torches and fire bombs clashed with Israeli troops in northern Galilee today in the worst outbreak of Arab rioting in Israel since the birth of the Jewish state 27 years ago.

Authorities said six persons were killed and 69 persons wounded, including 38 policemen and border patrol troops, and hundreds arrested as the first general strike by the nation’s minority Arabs crippled commerce in Galilee, the West Bank and annexed East Jerusalem.

Arab and Jewish sources told of flareups across Galilee but the worst of the unrest was at the three-village complex of Deir Hana, Sakhnin and Arabe… Hundreds of Israeli troops backed by armored cars sealed off the villages, drove the rest of Israel and refused to let reporters past the outskirts of Deir Hana.

Israeli troops fanned out among the olive trees ringing the hilltop village as demonstrators chanting anti-Israeli slogans gathered… About 10,000 Jordanians marched across the East Bank from Amman to the edge of the Jordan River to show their support for the strike, called to protest the Israeli takeover of thousands of acres of Arab land in Galilee.

The Jordanian government closed the Allenby Bridge between the East Bank and West Bank, which Israel captured during the 1967 Middle East War… Tens of thousands of Arab students, teachers and shopkeepers went on strike across Israel.

The recently formed “Committee to Protect Arab Lands” called on the 400,000 Arabs living in Israel to honor the 24-hour walkout.

Land Day on a Pittsburgh front page, under the tornado that hit Cabot, Arkansas, and beside a photograph of George Burns holding an Oscar. Six killed, sixty-nine wounded, hundreds arrested, four hundred thousand Arabs living in Israel, and a committee formed to protect Arab land. The headline puts “Worst Arab Riot” in quotation marks and attributes it to nobody.

CP-1976-003 →

· Port Arthur Daily News · page 1

Arabs rioting in Galilee

Worst outbreak in 27 years

United Press International, Deir Hana, Israel

DEIR HANA, Israel (UPI) — Arabs hurling rocks, flaming torches and firebombs battled Israeli forces in northern Galilee today in the worst outbreak of Arab rioting in Israel since the birth of the Jewish state 27 years ago.

Authorities reported six persons were killed, dozens wounded and hundreds arrested as the first general strike by the nation’s minority Arabs crippled commerce in Galilee, West Bank and annexed East Jerusalem.

Left-wing Arab officials citing “information from the people,” told of one more death and accused the battle-equipped Israeli troops of provoking the violence… A government communique said troops and police shot three Arab youths to death in Sakhnin Tuesday morning after killing a young Arab man in Araba the night before… Israeli troops fanned out among the olive trees ringing the hilltop village as hundreds of chanting Arabs demonstrated inside Deir Hana.

A large cloud of black smoke hung over the town. One reporter managed to get within 200 yards of the demonstrators before being forced by Israeli troops to leave the area. Dozens of gunshots could be heard amid the chants of the demonstrators… refused to let reporters past the outskirts of Deir Hana.

The Texas version of the Land Day wire, with the reporters kept two hundred yards back and then turned away altogether. The headline calls it rioting; the line under it calls it the worst outbreak in twenty-seven years.

CP-1976-005 →

· Lincoln Journal Star · Lincoln

Arabs Fight Israel Land Takeover

The first Land Day, 30 March 1976. Nebraska names what is being fought over.

CP-1976-019 →

· Times Herald

Arab Students in Riots

The same day as the Nebraska headline about a land takeover. Here the land is gone from the sentence and what is left is students and riots.

CP-1976-020 →

· The Evening Sun · Baltimore · page 1

Galilee Calm; Arabs Set Burials

Associated Press, Tel Aviv

“Tel Aviv (AP)—Israeli police patrolled in force in tense but calm Arab villages in Galilee today as villagers prepared to bury six Israeli Arabs killed by police and Army gunfire.

In occupied west Jordan, where spasms of anti-Israeli rioting have erupted for weeks, military officials said demonstrators stopped cars and lit bonfires in the streets of some towns, but no violence was reported. There were fears that the funerals in Galilee would ignite new rioting.

But Police Minister Shlomo Hillel ordered security forces not to shoot unless lives were threatened.

He lifted a curfew imposed on villages north of Nazareth… Five of the Arabs were killed Tuesday during riots that accompanied a 24-hour strike by Arab citizens of Israel which the Israeli Communist party called to protest government purchase of some 1,600 acres of arid Arab land for housing and development projects.

Another Arab was killed in a pre-strike riot Monday night.

Authorities reported 31 Israeli Arabs and about 50 police and soldiers were injured during the riots, and at least 285 persons were rounded up for investigation… Tewfik Zayad, the Communist mayor of Nazareth and the leader of the strike, charged that ‘police clashes came only “when police provoked the people.”’ He claimed the police ‘ran after people and shot at them.’

The fighting was the first between Israeli troops and Arab citizens since Israel became a state in 1948. The Arabs who chose Israeli citizenship then rather than join the Palestinian exodus to Lebanon, Syria and Jordan and their children now make up 16 per cent of the population of Israel.

They have equal rights with Jews under the constitution and enjoy the highest Arab standard of living in the Middle East. But they have not been allowed to form their own political parties, and the youngest generation has turned away from Israel’s ruling Labor party to the anti-Zionist Communist party and the Palestine Liberation Organization.”

“ROCK-THROWER ARRESTED—Truncheon-wielding Israeli troops run an Arab youth down the street by his hair after they caught him hurling rocks at police officers and soldiers in the riot-hit town of Nazareth.”

The day after Land Day, with the mayor of Nazareth quoted, the land given as 1,600 acres, and a sentence that says this was the first fighting between Israeli troops and Arab citizens since 1948. The last paragraph says they have equal rights under the constitution and then says they have not been allowed to form their own political parties. The photograph is captioned as an arrest and shows a boy being dragged down a street by his hair.

CP-1976-004 →

· Messenger Inquirer · Owensboro · page 1

Security forces kill 5 Arabs in Galilee

Associated Press, Nazareth, Israel

NAZARETH, Israel (AP) — Security forces shot and killed five rioting Israeli Arabs as violent clashes shattered years of calm between Israel’s three million Jews and 500,000 Arabs… Towns in occupied West Jordan — already swept by anti-Israeli riots for more than a month — joined the strike in sympathy.

Police reports said 38 policemen were injured and 31 Arabs hospitalized.

Police arrested 285 demonstrators… In a cable to Waldheim, the 20-member league said Arabs in the occupied territories were being “subjected to a wave of barbaric and terroristic measures launched by the Israeli occupying authorities in the ugliest demonstration of hate and violence that the unarmed Arab population has yet faced.”… Israel’s Arab-Jewish Communist party promoted the strike against the forced sale of rocky, unused Galilee land, which the government plans to use for Jewish and Arab development projects… The west bank Arabs are not Israeli citizens.

Largely Palestinian, they have lived under Israeli occupation since the 1967 Mideast War. “Palestinian Arabs of the west bank are fed up with the occupation,” said the Bethlehem Mayor Elias Freij.

“We are brothers and sisters of the Arabs of Israel, and we support them.”… “The clashes occurred only when police provoked the people,” Zayad told correspondents. “They ran after people and shot at them. They attacked my wife and family.”

Troops stood outside Zayad’s home tossing furniture and flower pots back at demonstrators pelting them from inside the house… Arab leaders who supported the strike insisted it was strictly to protest the takeover of Arab-owned land. “Our lands are being confiscated,” said Deputy Mayor Monen Jarjoura of Nazareth.

“The number of Arabs is increasing and the size of their land is shrinking,” protested the mayor of occupied Bethlehem. Israel’s housing minister, Avraham Ofer, however, said the land issue was a pretext for protest. “If you want to develop an area you have to confiscate some lands,” the minister said.

“We have done this very slowly with extreme consideration and much patience.”

Three mayors and a housing minister, all quoted, on the same page. The minister’s sentence is the one that settles the argument about what the strike was about: if you want to develop an area you have to confiscate some lands. The last paragraph notes that fifty thousand West Bank Arabs went to work in Israel anyway, some because they feared losing their jobs.

CP-1976-006 →

· Mobile Press · page 1

Galilee quiet as Arabs prepare to bury strike riot dead

By David Lancashire, Associated Press Writer, Tel Aviv, Israel

TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Israeli police patrolled in force in tense but calm Arab villages in Galilee today as villagers in northern Israel prepared to bury six Arabs killed by police and army gunfire… Five of the Arabs were killed Tuesday during riots that accompanied a 24-hour strike by Arab citizens of Israel which the Israeli Communist party called to protest government purchase of some 1,600 acres of arid Arab land for housing and development projects… Tewfik Zayad, the Communist mayor of Nazareth and the leader of the strike, charged the clashes came only “when police provoked the people.”

He claimed police “ran after people and shot at them.” Zayad is also a member of the Knesset, the Israeli parliament. Rakah, the Communist party, introduced a motion of no confidence accusing Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin’s government of aggression against Israel’s 500,000 Arab citizens.

The fighting was the first between Israeli troops and Arab citizens of the Jewish state since Israel became a state in 1948. The Arabs who chose Israeli citizenship then rather than joining the Palestinian exodus to Lebanon, Syria and Jordan and their children now make up 16 per cent of the population of Israel.

They have equal rights with Jews under the constitution and enjoy the highest Arab standard of living in the Middle East. But they have not been allowed to form their own political parties, and the younger generation has turned away from Israel’s ruling Labor party to the anti-Zionist Communist party and to the Palestine Liberation Organization.

“We were wrong for 28 years in thinking we could ignore the ethnic difference,” said Defense Minister Shimon Perez. “You can’t expect an Arab to be a Zionist, support Jewish immigration to Israel and sing the national anthem.”

However, Justice Minister Haim Zadok said the importance of the unrest should not be exaggerated and that the rioting did not mean an “uprising” by Arab citizens… “Palestinian Arabs of the West Bank are fed up with the occupation,” said the mayor of Bethlehem, Elias Freij.

“We are brothers and sisters of the Arabs of Israel, and we support them.”

The Alabama version, and it carries the line the others do not: the Israeli defense minister saying you cannot expect an Arab to be a Zionist or sing the national anthem, and admitting twenty-eight years of being wrong about it. Printed beside a life insurance recruitment advertisement and notice of a 1932 high school reunion.

CP-1976-007 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore

5 Israeli Arabs die in land protests

“…died from clashes with Israeli security forces. The West Bank Arabs are not Israeli citizens. In the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, also occupied since 1967, Israeli troops ordered striking shopowners to open for business.”

The third version of 30 March 1976 in this archive, and the only one that counts the dead in the headline. Baltimore also explains the distinction the other two leave out: the Arabs inside Israel are citizens and the ones in the West Bank are not.

CP-1976-021 →

· Oakland Tribune · Oakland

Israel's Ominous Role in Lebanon

April 1976, and ominous is the paper’s own word, in its own headline, about a state’s role in another country — six years before Sabra and Shatila. The archive holds the 1978 raids (CP-1978-003) and the 1982 camps (CP-1982-008, CP-1982-011, CP-1982-015) on the far side of it.

CP-1976-001 →

· The New York Times · New York

120 Israelis in the West Bank Dig in to Hold New Settlement

By TERENCE SMITH, Special to The New York Times

CAMP KADUM, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, April 2—Viewed from the road a few hundred yards away, Kadum looks like a typical Israeli Army camp. Once inside the gate, however, the incongruities emerge: children playing tag among the jeeps, young mothers pushing baby carriages, women in jeans setting tables in a communal dining hall.

No ordinary army camp, Kadum is the temporary home of about 120 zealous Israelis who are determined — despite the opposition of the Government—to establish Israeli settlements here and elsewhere throughout the occupied West Bank of the Jordan River.

Each new settlement, in their view, serves as another spike to nail down the occupied areas and block any attempt to return them to Arab control as part of a negotiated agreement. The settlements also are one of the irritants that led to the recent rioting by West Bank Arabs.

The Government has yet to make a final decision on Kadum, but the settlers were busy this morning making themselves at home. Workmen were laying water and sewer linen while the settlers carried mattresses and furniture into 30 new house trailers that the Defense Ministry has installed on the slope above the military portion of the camp.

In three short months, Kadum has become the prime political issue in Israel. It is being described as a political time bomb that could easily explode and bring down the Government of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin.

Yosef Porat, a volunteer from the Kiryat Arba settlement, works on the roof of a new dining room at Camp Kadum. Newly installed house trailers are in the background. [credit] The New York Times/Micha Bar-Am

Date check: DATE AND PAPER CONFIRMED ON THE PAGE. The running head reads “THE NEW YORK TIMES, SATURDAY, APRIL 3, 1976”, which matches both `pub` and the slide-label date of 1976-04-03. The dateline reads “CAMP KADUM, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, April 2”.

CP-1976-023 →

· Brattleboro Reformer · Brattleboro

Elections Scheduled for Arabs In Israeli-Occupied West Bank

United Press International, Nablus, Israeli-occupied Jordan

“Occupation authorities said 18,810 ballots were cast by 11 a.m., 5,897 of them by women, who had the vote for the first time.

An 80 per cent turnout was expected… Four women are among the 544 candidates… ‘The voters are voting for a refusal of the occupation and more stubborn candidates will be elected,’ said Cana Abdul Hadi, a Nablus city councilman for 17 years…”

Palestinians voting, covered as an election — turnout, polling places, candidates chatting outside, women voting for the first time. The dateline calls the territory Israeli-occupied Jordan while the headline above it says Israeli-Occupied West Bank: one story, two names, neither of them Palestine.

CP-1976-016 →

· The New York Times

Israeli Arabs’ Status

By Atallah Mansour

NAZARETH, Israel — On the whole, one can easily say that Israel has treated its Arab minority as equals. The Israeli Arabs are in a legal position to express themselves, vote in the national general elections, run for any office. They can produce their own newspapers, publish any books. They may organize in political, social, cultural or religious groups.

Moreover, the Ministry of Education permits them to preserve and sustain their different national and cultural heritage in their own schools. Still, it is seldom that Israeli Arabs can be heard in a private conversation expressing anything close to satisfaction with their lot, and it is very easy to understand and justify their deep frustration and bitterness.

First of all, they were part of the Arab majority of Palestine up to 1948, and they remember it all too clearly. The natural shock of a community that evolved overnight from a dominant majority into a humiliated minority cannot but suffer a deep trauma.

The fact that the Arab world, both official and public, ostracized them as traitors because they refused to leave the regions of Palestine that became Israel served only to balance their anti-Israeli feelings. If our “brothers” were so badly lacking in understanding, why were we to expect the Jews to be warm and friendly?

Arabs in Israel were certainly treated with strong suspicion. For some twenty years, they needed a written permit from the Israeli military governor to move around and look for a job, visit a medical clinic, and attend classes at a school outside their own villages. Their contacts with the Government agencies were made through special “Arab departments.”

All these restrictions were removed by 1966, except the “Arab departments.” The official claim is that those departments are meant to give Arabs special — but also favorable — treatment. The employees in such offices are usually able to speak Arabic, and specially trained to treat the “Arab mentality” and its unique needs.

But the Arab counterclaim is not less convincing: One can justify a special department of Arab education, but who decreed that all these “specialists” ought to be Jewish, and who said that public housing for young couples should be different depending on whether the couples are Christian, Moslem or Jewish?

And what bothers the Arabs in Israel most: Why should the Government expropriate lands from Arab private owners and townships to turn them over to Jewish settlers? An Arab in Nazareth who lost his land in the mid-1950’s and cannot today purchase an apartment built on it in the new Jewish town of Nazareth-Elit cannot help but feel deep fury.

The Ministry of Housing advertises in the Hebrew press there that there are empty apartments in the Jewish town, but hundreds of Arab couples have been waiting for years for the fulfillment of pledges to build them “special” homes. Not one such apartment has been built in Nazareth in the last eight years.

I recently heard the mayor of Jewish Nazareth-Elit, Mordechai Alon, elaborating on the plans to attract Jewish residents to his town.

He said that 8,800 apartments were planned or already built in his town and that he was now offering a package deal: a new Ford with a home in Nazareth-Elit at a lower price than a home in Tel Aviv, and of course, with a generous Government subsidy. That is the sort of discrimination that lies beneath most of the grievances of the Israeli Arab.

Why are our villages and townships lacking industrial plants, why are educational facilities missing, why do we not share in Israeli political parties (except Rakah, the New Communist List) or participate in the pressure groups that rule and influence policy (especially that of our own affairs)?

The State Land Authority owns three million dunams of land (a dunam equals a quarter acre) in Galilee; Arab private owners only half a million dunams. Why expropriate our land? The inability of the Arabs, except the Druse, to serve in the army sharply limits their mobility and promotion into the main sphere of influence in Israel.

But the Israeli Government treatment of the Druses who served and courageously fought in all Israeli wars does not induce Christian and Moslem leaders to ask the Government publicly to integrate Arabs into army service and to treat them on an equal footing with the other citizens.

The official Government claim is, We exempt Arabs from military service to save them the dilemma of fighting their Arab brothers. The authorities say they have a “good” reason for the special privileges bestowed on Jewish settlers in Nazareth-Elit and similar new settlements: It is Jewish money donated by Jews for Jews.

But they have not shown any evidence that those Jews are donating money to close a dangerous and growing gap between Arabs and Jews in Israel. This gap is a time bomb that may eventually explode and cause more damage to peace in Israel, and to its international reputation.

CP-1976-041 →

· Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle · page Five

Shattered Illusions

Arab Riots Show Failure of Israeli Policies

By Yosef Goell, Jerusalem Post News Service

March 30, 1976 will be a day to remember in the history of Israel’s Arab minority; in this at least Rakah, the predominantly Arab nationalist Communist Party, has succeeded. For the first time since the state was established, Israel’s Arab citizens dared attack Israeli soldiers and policemen — including a not insubstantial number of Druse and Arab servicemen.

It is a watershed date, which should hasten a long, overdue reassessment of policy towards the Arab minority. What happened among Israel’s Arab citizens on that Tuesday; why did it turn out the way it did? And what lies ahead on this new volatile front that has opened for Israel?

Hundreds of rioting Arab men and boys vented their rage and hatred against Israel in a fashion that elicited an extreme reaction from the security forces, which had been posted in the Galilee and the Sharon region in anticipation of trouble on the day of the Rakah-fomented strike.

Several thousand Arab citizens of Israel passively supported the strike by closing their shops and staying home from work and school.

In the midst of the passions engendered by these dramatic events, it is easy to forget that hundreds of thousands of Israeli Arabs — the silent majority — went to work, plowed their fields, attended school and otherwise went about the normal course of their workaday lives — although they were certainly aware of the violent events around them.

What accounts for the difference in behavior?

Traffic stalls on Israeli roads as drivers clear debris from Arab riots.

CP-1976-046 →

· The New York Times · page 1

ISRAEL PLANNING TO SETTLE MORE OF OCCUPIED LAND

Cabinet Examines Program for ‘More Than a Dozen’ Places in Coming Years | THREE AREAS AFFECTED | Golan, West Bank and Gaza to Get New Communities Under the Proposals

By TERENCE SMITH

JERUSALEM, May 10—Israel is drawing up plans for the establishment of a large number of new settlements in occupied Arab territory over the next several years, government officials familiar with the plans said today.

The settlements, which are to range from small agricultural villages to industrial towns, are to be located in the Golan Heights, the Jordan valley and other parts of the West Bank, and the Rafah area of the Gaza Strip. There are already 68 Israeli settlements in occupied territory.

The officials declined to disclose exactly how many new settlements are contemplated or their precise locations. One official said “more than a dozen” were involved, while others suggested that the program would eventually include several dozen. Each new settlement will have to be approved by the Government before it is established.

But this is largely a formality, since a broad consensus already exists within the Cabinet in favor of intensified Israeli settlement in the Arab lands captured in 1967. The whole settlement policy remains a source of controversy at home and abroad.

It is opposed by Israeli doves and has been criticized by the United States as an obstacle to a negotiated peace with the Arab states. Referring to this today, one official described Israeli policy as a “calculated risk” of confrontation with the United States. Nonetheless, he said, the Government appears determined to press ahead with the new settlements.

The plans for these new settlements were outlined to the Cabinet yesterday at the outset of a 10-hour debate on settlement policy.

Since the 1967 war, Israel has set up 68 settlements (shown by dots) in occupied lands. Four are off map, one being west of El Arish, three in south on Gulf of Aqaba. Sites of settlements to come were not given.

CP-1976-025 →

· Stamford Advocate · Stamford · page 1

U.N. resolution cynical, says Israeli

It equates Zionism with racism

By Tom Lydon, Advocate Staff Reporter

“Attacking a U.N. resolution which equates Zionism with racism as ‘cynical and vicious,’ an Israeli minister to the United Nations said here Sunday his country will not accept ‘the indefensible borders of 1967.’ ‘Our defense is our own responsibility, which is a major reason why, even though for real peace we are ready to compromise our territory, we will not be pushed back to the indefensible borders of 1967,’ Mordechai Lador told a Zionist Organization of America dinner at Agudath Sholom Synagogue. Mr.

Lador serves as ambassador to the permanent mission of Israel at the United Nations. In that capacity, he is a key aide to Israeli U.N.

Ambassador Chaim Herzog… The Israeli official warned his audience that once again the world has turned against the Jewish people and is attacking the Hebrew state ‘for no other reason than because it is small and because it is Jewish.’”

How the resolution actually reached American towns: a synagogue banquet in Stamford, an award for a man who supported a technical high school in Israel, and a staff reporter taking notes. The story beside it is a city representative and a city engineer arguing about basement flooding on Sleepy Hollow Lane.

CP-1976-014 →

· The New York Times

ISRAELI SOLDIERS KILL ARAB YOUTH

2d Such Death in 2 Days—Government Fears Unrest Is Growing Worse

By TERENCE SMITH

KALANDIA, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, May 17—An 18-year-old Arab student was shot and killed by Israeli soldiers fleeing an angry mob today as riots continued on the West Bank of the Jordan River for the third day.

The continuing disturbances on the occupied West Bank tended to confirm the fear expressed recently by Israeli leaders that the riots are growing progressively worse and more difficult to control. The latest series began Saturday in several West Bank towns to mark the 28th anniversary of the establishment of Israel.

The victim today, a resident of this Palestinian refugee camp north of Jerusalem, was shot in the head as he watched a fight between two Israeli soldiers and a crowd of stone-throwing Arab demonstrators who were attacking their truck. Ninth Arab Victim According to Arab witnesses, one of the soldiers raked the crowd with machine-gun fire as the battered truck sped away.

Israeli military sources confirmed that the soldier fired his weapon, but said that it was in self-defense. … Apparently in fear of their lives, the soldiers pulled away. Fifty yards further down the road they passed the Kalandia Vocational Training School, a project of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency. The headmaster, Nabih M.

Awad, was standing at the gate with a group of students watching the fighting. “As the truck raced by I suddenly saw an Uzi submachine gun barrel poke out of the driver’s window,” Mr. Awad said. “There was a burst of fire and we all dived to the ground. When I looked up I saw that one boy had been hit in the head. The truck never stopped.”

The victim was Abdullah Mustapha Halil Hawas, a student whose family lives in the nearby Shuafat refugee camp. Mr. Awad said that neither he nor any of the boys from the school had participated in the fight against the truck. … Israeli Soldiers Kill an Arab Youth on West Bank Continued From Page 1, Col. 4 student by Israeli soldiers in Nablus.

Both that incident and the shooting today are being investigated by military authorities. It was also announced that Clara Guinness, a 32-year-old immigrant from Colombia, died last night of the wounds she received two weeks ago in a bomb explosion in downtown Jerusalem. Mrs.

Guiness was one of 30 people wounded in the attack, for which a Palestinian guerrilla organization in Beirut took responsibility. Mrs. Guinness had given birth to a baby nine days before the explosion. In Nablus, thousands of residents thronged the streets waving Palestinian flags, chanting slogans and shouting “murderers” at Israeli soldiers on patrol.

Heavy reinforcements were called in and beat back the crowds with baton charges and water cannon. All the shops and schools in Nablus were closed as part of a two-day general strike to protest the shooting yesterday. The young woman, Hassan Lina Hassan Nabulsi, was the daughter of an influential family and a relative of a former prime minister of Jordan, Suleiman Nabulsi.

The army imposed a curfew on many sectors of Nablus, the northern town of Jenin and the camp at Balata, where 20,000 Palestinian refugees live in squalid one-story shacks. In Ramallah, where this reporter spent much of the day, there were demonstrations throughout the morning and afternoon.

Angry crowds of Arabs surged through the streets throwing up stone barricades and setting fire to tires. Black smoke from dozens of such fires drifted across the mountain town. Truckloads of armed, helmeted border police moved through the town, breaking up crowds wherever they could catch them.

In one instance, the border guards fought a pitched battle with a mob of 200 high school students. They chased the students into the grounds of the Ramallah Teachers College, picking up the stones that had been thrown at them and hurling them back. Despite standing orders not to enter schools, the enraged soldiers rushed into the college with their white riot batons swinging.

Several persons were injured, including three members of the faculty who tried to block the soldiers at the entrance. The shooting incident at Kalandia illustrated the problems encountered by Israeli soldiers who lack any special riot training but now are being forced almost every day to battle an aroused civilian population.

The two soldiers involved were driving in an army truck from Jerusalem to Ramallah about 8 A.M. when they suddenly encountered a roadblock across the highway opposite the Kalandia refugee camp. A crowd estimated by Israeli sources at 200 descended on the truck, showered it with rocks and shattered all the windows. Apparently in fear of their lives, the soldiers pulled away.

Fifty yards further down the road they passed the Kalandia Vocational Training School, a project of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency. The headmaster, Nabih M. Awad, was standing at the gate with a group of students watching the fighting. “As the truck raced by I suddenly saw an Uzi submachine gun barrel poke out of the driver’s window,” Mr.

Awad said. “There was a burst of fire and we all dived to the ground. When I looked up I saw that one boy had been hit in the head. The truck never stopped.” The victim was Abdullah Mustapha Halil Hawas, a student whose family lives in the nearby Shuafat refugee camp. Mr.

Awad said that neither he nor any of the boys from the school had participated in the fight against the truck. The youth was buried this evening in a ceremony at the Mosque of Al Aksa that followed an hour-long funeral procession through East Jerusalem. The several hundred mourners marched through the streets carrying Palestinian flags and flower wreaths.

After the ceremony, several dozen of the mourners clashed with a phalanx of border policemen drawn up outside the walled Old City.

The border guards used clubs and tear gas to break up the crowd and ripped the Palestinian flags from their standards. [Below the article in the first column, a SEPARATE and unrelated story: “Canadian Labor Authorizes Strike Over Economic Curbs”, datelined QUEBEC, May 17 (UPI). Not transcribed — nothing to do with Palestine.

The lower half of the page is display advertising: Puro Corporation of America (Koldwave air conditioner), Mervin S. Levine Custom Tailors, Backgammon, and a Fresh Air Fund notice.]

Young Arabs hurl stones at an Israeli patrol on a street in Ramallah, in Israeli-occupied Jordan

CP-1976-048 →

· Southern Illinoisan · Carbondale · page 1

Do Americans know how the Palestinians suffer?

Commentary

Hatem Hussaini, Washington

“Wherever I move or turn in this country I see images of my occupied country, Palestine, and its dispossessed people, the Palestinians. Every breathing moment I feel the exile, suffering and pain of it all. As if mankind’s wounds and tragedies are centered in Palestine, in me. And I keep asking: Do Americans really know the suffering of my people?

I have seen myself distorted on United States television so many times. ‘Terrorists, infiltrators, murderers.’ Even my five-year-old daughter, born in this country, said suddenly to her mother, ‘Palestinians are bad.’

And we have to explain: No, beautiful one, we Palestinians are good; we want peace, brotherhood, happiness. But very few listen and understand… Of the thousands expelled since 1967 two came here to explain, Hanna Nasir, a humane president of Birzeit College expelled by the Israeli military on Nov.

21, 1974, and Abdel Jawad Saleh, a popular mayor of the town of Al-Birah, expelled on Dec. 10, 1973. No charges, no trial, simply a military order of ‘deportation’ read by Israeli soldiers at the border. They tried to explain here that this is illegal, contrary to Geneva Convention agreements. No response.

The only moving thing they did was to speak by telephone to their wives and children, whom they cannot see on the occupied West Bank. I will never forget Mr. Nasir’s emotional words: ‘Don’t worry, son. I will return. I love you all.’… Wael Zeiter, a young Palestinian activist murdered in Rome on Oct.

16, 1972, was denied the right by the Israeli authorities to be buried in his hometown, Nablus… When I applied in 1972, two Israeli officials interviewed me at length in Washington, D.C., and demanded, ‘Why do you want to return?’ Because I love my people and want to live in peace and teach at a college.

They made me fill seven long application forms and never replied to me… And we to become like the native Indians, faceless, strangers in our own land, withering away in reservations?… We have learned, however, the humane thought of Jews like Ahad Ha’am and Judah Magnes and Israelis like Israel Shahaq and Felicia Langer who have spoken of justice for Palestinians… I tell my daughter and my angry conscience: We want peace and brotherhood in Palestine.

The guns will be turned into plowshares soon, so my child, all children, will play in peace under the ancient olive trees and sing and learn the Arab and Jewish humane heritage and culture.”

A cartoon captioned “A spoonful of sugar …?” shows Uncle Sam spooning U.S. AID into an armed figure standing on the word ISRAEL, beside an untouched cup labeled SEPARATE STATE OF PALESTINE.

A signed Palestinian commentary in a southern Illinois daily. The editor’s note says only that Hatem Hussaini works for the League of Arab States. The archive already holds him speaking two years later at the Palestine Information Office in Washington. Hanna Nasir, Israel Shahak and Felicia Langer each appear in other clippings here across the 1970s and 1980s.

CP-1976-009 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago · page 1

Conference links zionism, racism

By Alan Merridew, Chicago Tribune Press Service, Vancouver

“The United Nations Conference on Human Settlements [Habitat] Friday night adopted a declaration of principles which by association equated Zionism with racism. The vote in favor was 89-15, with 10 abstentions. Voting no were Australia, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, France, West Germany, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Britain, and the United States… A general principle in the declaration says it is the duty of all people and governments to join the struggle against ‘any form of colonialism, foreign aggression and occupation, domination, apartheid, and all forms of racism and racial discrimination, referred to in the resolutions as adopted by the General Assembly of the United Nations.’ The last phrase was taken to be a link with last November’s General Assembly resolution which equated zionism with racism.… NEITHER OF THESE two amendments named Israel or mentioned Palestinians.

But it was clear to all participating that Palestinians living in Israeli occupied territories was the subject… THE ISRAELI SPOKESMAN responded bitterly. The amendment was ‘just one more tired act in the world-traveling Arab circus,’ he said.”

Seven months after the vote the formula turns up at a conference about housing. It would do the same at UNESCO in Paris, at a racism conference in Geneva, at the women’s conferences in Copenhagen and Nairobi, and at Durban. Each time it attaches itself to a meeting convened about something else, and each time the something else is what gets held up. The Tribune sets zionism in lower case in its headline.

CP-1976-015 →

· Lawton Constitution · page 5C

Pan-Arab Ceasefire Appeal Ignored In Lebanon

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — Christian militiamen today stepped up their bombardment of the last major Moslem holding in southeast Beirut, the Tal Zaatar Palestinian refugee camp. Both sides ignored a Pan-Arab appeal for a ceasefire in the civil war. Arab foreign ministers meeting in Cairo issued the appeal for a cease-fire at midday.

They also urged an airlift of troops from Arab counties to begin separating the warring Lebanese factions. ABOUT 1,300 Saudi Arabian and Sudanese sowdiers left Damascus today to join the 800 Syrian and Libyan troops sent to Beirut last week as the vanguard of the Pan-Arab peacekeeping force. The Syriafs and Libyans have stayed away from the firing lines.

As the cease-fire deadline passed, heavy rockets roared from Moslem areas headed for Christian positions. Shelling from the Christian side set several fires in the Moslem neighborhood of Tariq el-Gedideh. An awl-night rocket and artillery pounding of the camp set a number of fires in the refugee camp.

YASIR ARAFAT’S Palestinian guerrillas rejected a Christian ultimatum to “surrender or be wiped out.” They vowed to defend the camp “to the last man and last drop of blood.” “The camp is as good as fallen,” said a spokesman for former President Camille Chamoun’s Tigers militia.

“We are at the main gates of the camp and have already changed its name to Tigers Hill.” Tal Zaatar means Thyme Hill. A Palestinian spokesmen said the defending guerrillas were fighting hand-to-hand and had lowered the muzzles of their antiaircraft guns to fire point-blank.

The camp formerly housed 20,000 Palestinians and an estimated 30,000 Lebanese refugees from Israeli raids into southern Lebanon. But most of the civilians are believed to have fled, and the camp was reported defended by 1,000 to 2,000 guerrillas.

THE CHRISTIAN militiamen completed their conquest of the smaller Jisr el-Basha refugee camp nearby, which the Palestinians abandoned Wednesday. The Palestinians accused the Christians of “blasting to death hundreds of women and children in air raid shelters” in the camp.

But Christian spokesmen said most of the civilians in the camp escaped when the attack began 10 days ago, and about 200 guerrillas who were defending the camp at the end escaped to Tal Zaatar. The Palestinians and their leftist Lebanese Moslem allies were retaliating with mortar and artillery attacks from Moslem west Beirut on Jisr el-Basha and Christian residential areas.

But the Christians said a Palestinian-Moslem counterattack on the Christian suburb of Ein Rummaneh had evidently failed. As the Christians concentrated their attack on Tal Zaatar, Syrian troops and tanks were reported to have overrun Palestinian positions in the mountains 30 miles east of Beirut around the town of Ayoun Siman.

“OUR FORCES in Ayoun Siman have taken up new hilltop positions and will fight the Syrian invaders from hill to hill,” said a communique from the joint central command of Palestinians and Lebanese Moslems.

The Christians expressed determination to purge all Palestinian and Moslem pockets between west Beirut, which they control, and the Christian enclave stretching northeast from the city to the mountains and Tripoli. They said the battle was a clearing operation in preparation for the possible partitioning of Lebanon.

Palestinian guerrilla leader Yassir Arafat, left; Arab League secretary general Mahmoud Riad and Sheikh Mohamed Moubarak El Khalifa, Bahrein foreign minister, talk during the opening session of Arab foreign ministers in Cairo, Egypt, Wednesday night.

CP-1976-026 →

· The New York Times

ISRAEL IS DETAINING 50 WEST BANK ARABS

TEL AVIV, July 12—Israel announced today that its security forces in the occupied West Bank of Jordan had smashed eight terrorist cells belonging to the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. Israelis hold the Popular Front, led by George Habash, responsible for a series of hijackings, including the recent seizure of an Air France plane.

Military headquarters here said 50 suspects were detained “in recent weeks.” Some of the prisoners were said to have been in custody previously. An unofficial source said the prisoners included many intellectuals. The groups did not plan immediate acts of terror, but were organizing and supplying themselves for future operations, the source said.

The army said four more rings were exposed recently in Samaria and two more in the Tulkarm area. One group was said to have been responsible for gunfire at a bus taking Arab workers to jobs in Israel on March 28 as well as a grenade attack in Nablus on April 12, the day of mayoral elections in the occupied areas.

CP-1976-049 →

· The New York Times · page 1, Column 2; continued on Page 7, Column 1

Israelis Say Raider Impersonated Amin

By TERENCE SMITH

JERUSALEM, July 12—The Israeli units that rescued hijacking hostages from the Entebbe airport a week ago took with them a Mercedes limousine carrying an Israeli officer with blackened face impersonating President Idi Amin of Uganda and two Land-Rovers full of men dressed as Palestinian bodyguards, according to Israeli sources.

The impersonation confused the Uganda soldiers at the airport and gave the Israeli raiding party a few extra seconds to reach the passenger terminal where the hostages and the crew of the hijacked Air France airliner were being held, the sources said.

The First Few Minutes More details of this deception and of the extraordinary rescue are emerging only now, more than a week after the commandos succeeded in freeing the 103 hostages and flying them back to Israel.

Some of the details are being reported abroad and some have been repeated in the newspapers here, attributed to foreign sources because of the restrictions of Israeli military censorship. Perhaps the most dramatic tale concerns the first few minutes of the operation, when two or three Israeli Hercules C-130’s landed quietly at the airport shortly before midnight on July 3.

Before launching the raid the Israelis learned that President Amin had used a large black Mercedes-Benz protected by two Land-Rovers full of bodyguards, most of them hired Palestinians, during his repeated visits to the hostages.

To confuse the Uganda soldiers the Israeli raiders did everything possible to make the arrival of their first units look like another visit by General Amin. According to reports from Nairobi, the first American-built plane glided toward a quiet landing with its engines throttled back and braked to a stop rather than employing the noisy reverse thrust of the engines.

The plane came to a halt at a distant, darkened spot at the end of an old runway, well out of sight of the Ugandan guards near the terminal. As the big rear door dropped open, a black sedan bearing the same number plate as President Amin’s official vehicle rolled out.

Seated in the rear was a bulky, broad-shouldered Israeli commando dressed in the uniform of a Uganda field marshal and with his face blackened. Behind came the two Land-Rovers painted in the buff camouflage color favored by Palestinian units. Ten Israeli commandos in the uniforms of Palestinian bodyguards were aboard, their Soviet-built Kalashnikov assault rifles at the ready.

President Amin apparently uses hired Palestinian bodyguards when he moves about Kampala because of doubts about the loyalty of his presidential guard. As the motorcade moved into the floodlit area around the terminal, the Uganda guards posted along the runway snapped to attention. Some reportedly even saluted.

Exploiting the confusion, the Israelis were able to get within a few yards of the terminal before the first shots were fired. The Ugandans apparently discerned the ruse only when they realized that the men pouring out of the Land-Rovers were not Palestinians.

CP-1976-051 →

· Victoria Advocate

Christians Allow Evacuation

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) - Under a shaky truce, the International Red Cross evacuated 91 badly wounded persons Tuesday from the besieged Palestinian refugee camp at Tal Zaatar. In Geneva, the International Red Cross Committee said 150 more wounded will be evacuated from the camp Wednesday.

An announcement by the Swiss-based humanitarian organization said the situation of the camp was “dramatic.” “Some among them require surgery, which was impossible inside the camp, and have been waiting for weeks for medical treatment of their wounds,” the committee said.

A convoy of two ambulances and nine trucks entered the battered camp on Beirut’s outskirts, loaded the wounded and carried them back through the Christian sector and across the no man’s land that divides Beirut to a hospital in the Moslemcontrolled part of the city.

While the convoy wound through the narrow streets of the Christian district, scores of people gathered in the streets and on balconies, mostly in silence, to watch it pass. As it crossed into the Moslem sector, Palestinian guerrillas and other Moslem soldiers cut loose with a frenzied barrage of gunfire in the air, celebrating the rescue of the wounded.

A Swedish photographer said that among those rescued was Eva Stahl, a 27-year-old Swedish nurse who lost an arm, suffered a broken leg and miscarriage during the siege. She was the wife of a guerrilla leader killed early in the battle.

The evacuees were the first of some 4,000 wounded the Red Cross hopes to take from the camp, which has been under siege by Christian rightist forces for six weeks. Tuesday’s operation took nearly seven hours from start to finish, with the Red Cross convoy spending about 3½ hours actually inside Tal Zaatar.

During the period, there were sporadic exchanges of gunfire around edges of the camp. But the Christian militia that had prevented five previous evacuation efforts generally abided by the truce negotiated by the Red Cross and the Arab League, and signed by the leaders of all Christian factions.

Christian officers refused, however, to let the Red Cross take one truckload of medical supplies and water into the camp. A tense moment came just after the convoy, with Red Cross chief delegate Jean Hoefliger in the lead car, left Tal Zaatar and was waiting to pass a checkpoint manned by troops of several Christian factions.

A few of the soldiers got into a heated argument apparently about who was going to check the trucks to verify that they contained only wounded. Two of them suddenly began firing their automatic rifles wildly, sending newsmen and other observers diving for cover.

The convoy was delayed for about an hour near the checkpoint and a Red Cross source later said it was because the Christians, in checking the wounded, found five who could walk and forced them to get off the trucks. But after a long discussion, they allowed the five to board the trucks again and leave with the convoy.

Palestinian spokesmen charged that the convoy had come under Christian sniper fire as it reached a former soccer field inside the camp that had been chosen as the place where the wounded would be loaded. The Christians denied the claim, but there was no way to be certain who was right, because of frequent sporadic firing during the entire operation.

WOUNDED NURSE — Eva Stahl, a Swedish nurse who was trapped in Tal Zaatar Palestinian refugee camp under Christian seige in Beirut for six weeks, is brought to hospital in Moslem sector of Beirut Tuesday. She was evacuated by the Red Cross. She lost her right arm and broke her left leg during the shelling of the camp.

She is a seven months pregnant widow of a Palestinian guerrilla killed in the seige.

CP-1976-027 →

· The New York Times

FOE SAID TO ENTER PALESTINIAN CAMP

Lebanese Christians Keep Up Pressure on Tell Zaatar

By IHSAN A. HIJAZI

BEIRUT, Lebanon, Aug. 11 —Right-wing Christian forces kept up military pressure today against the Palestinian camp of Tell Zaatar, on the outskirts of Beirut. A right-wing radio station reported that the Christian forces had advanced into the camp “to help civilians who wanted to leave to reach safety.” It said the camp was totally besieged.

The new onslaught by the rightists was launched yesterday, the 49th day of the siege.

Meanwhile, Kamal Jumblat, leader of the leftist-Moslem alliance, has announced plans for recruiting a “popular army” to keep up what the alliance described as the “armed struggle and steadfastness” in the 16-month civil war against the Syrian forces that have intervened here. Mr.

Jumblat called on men aged 17 to 40 in Moslem and leftist-controlled areas to join the new army. Salaries up to 500 Lebanese pounds ($140) a month have been offered to volunteers. The leftist-Moslem alliance comprises 11 groups forming “a central political council,” of which Mr. Jumblat is the president.

The political council, in a statement last night, rejected Syrian terms for forming a joint committee to be in charge of establishing an effective cease-fire. The statement accused Syria and the rightists of keeping the leftists and Palestinian guerrillas preoccupied with futile negotiations to enable the Christian forces to liquidate Palestinian and Moslem pockets.

The statement demanded the immediate withdrawal of Syrian troops from Lebanon. Informed quarters put the number of these troops at 20,000, backed by 450 tanks. The leftists and Palestinians have accused Syria of siding with the Christians in the offensive against Tell Zaatar.

President Hafez al-Assad of Syria was reported to have assured President Suleiman Franjieh in a message yesterday that his policy in Lebanon would not change as a result of the Cabinet shuffle last week. The terms rejected by the leftist-Moslem alliance called for participation by pro-Syrian Lebanese in the proposed security committee.

The leftists protested that those leaders had no popular following and that they derived their strength from the Syrian military presence. The proposed committee was part of the agreement reached between Palestinian and Syrian officials in Damascus July 29 as a beginning of the process of resolving the Lebanese crisis.

The committee was to be under the chairmanship of an Arab League representative and to include Syrian, Palestinian and Lebanese members. A committee meeting was postponed twice last week at Syria’s request.

Yasir Arafat, leader of the Palestine Liberation Organization, has sent messages to Arab heads of state urging them to exercise their “responsibilities” in saving the people of Tell Zaatar. He said that the forces attacking “innocent women and children at the camp do not know the meaning of military honor and humanitarian values.”

CP-1976-028 →

· The Anniston Star

Will avenge Tal Zaatar, Palestinians warn foes

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — The Palestinians and their leftist Moslems Lebanese allies threatened today to avenge the fall of the Tal Zaatar Palestinian camp and vowed that Lebanon’s civil war would continue. Palestinian leader Farouk Kaddoumi said his men would “avenge Tal Zaatar elsewhere in Lebanon.”

Leftist papers said the Moslems might “escalate fighting in Christian-held mountain areas,” through which Moslem villages are still scattered. “Lebanese will have to brace for a protracted war,” said Kamal Jumblatt, the Moslem leader of the Lebanese leftists. “We must brace ourselves for more shocks, similar to that of Tal Zaatar.

“Our prime duty now is to set up a strong popular army to resist the Syrian invasion and to liberate captured areas. We will have to resist partition, because a Christian state in our midst would turn out to be another Israel in the heart of the Arab region.”

The fall of Tal Zaatar Thursday removed the last Moslem stronghold from Christian East Beirut and consolidated the area with the Christian hinterland north of the capital. Christian militiamen fought mop-up actions today against isolated pockets of defenders in the 74-acre camp.

Palestinian sources said scattered hand-tohand fighting continued but admitted that the camp had been conquered. Hours after Tal Zaatar fell, Moslem gunmen of the Ambushers militia laid siege to the Assyrian quarter in the heart of Moslem West Beirut.

The Ambushers accused the quarter’s 3,000 Christians of supporting “Christian atrocities” against refugees from Tal Zaatar. Street fighting escalated during the night along the dividing line in Beirut and nearby mountain towns. An incomplete count of casualties by security officers and hospitals showed at least 186 persons killed and 215 wounded.

The war has taken more than 34,000 lives since it erupted in April 1975. Leftist gunners fired artillery and mortar barrages into the Christian suburb of Ashrafiyeh, and Christians returned the fire, officials said.

A spokesman for the French Embassy said two French guards were killed and a third one was wounded when shells hit a terrace in the embassy compound in western Beirut and the ambassaodr’s residence. Leftist sources said Christian militias supported by Syrian forces were “opening a new front” in mountain areas southeast of Beirut.

They said the Syrians had reinforced positions near Jezzine and Dhahr Ramleh, east of the Moslem port of Sidon, with 40 tanks equipped with long-range cannon. Christian leaders estimated that 200 to 300 Palestinians were still fighting from underground bunkers, slit trenches and the ruins of houses in Tal Zaatar.

“There can’t be more than seven of them in any one spot,” said a weeping old man. “The boys who were fighting, may Allah rest their souls, were all killed.”

Christian artillerymen held their fire as some 12,000 Lebanese and Palestinian civilians — most of them old people and children — poured out of the camp and through the Christian lines to Moslem West Beirut.

Arab League mediator Hassan Sabri Kholi said 8,000 persons were evacuated by trucks supplied by the Red Cross, the League’s peacekeeping force and the Christian Phalange militia, while 4,000 fled on foot. Christian fighters overran the Moslem slum of Nabaa, about a mile from Tal Zaatar, last weekend.

The twin conquests continued the de facto partition of the smaller-than-Connecticut nation.

CP-1976-029 →

· Daily News

An Epic Ends as Tal Zaatar Falls

Beirut, Lebanon, Aug 12 (AP)—The Palestinian camp of Tal Zaatar fell to Christian forces today after a fierce seven-week siege. Thousands of wailing refugees poured out to safety. Palestinian sources claimed that a handful of holdouts were still fighting hand-to-hand with right-wing gunmen who stormed into the camp.

But they admitted that Tal Zaatar had, in effect, been conquered. A weeping old man just out of the camp said of the remaining defenders: “There can’t be more than seven of them in any one spot . . . The boys who were fighting, may God rest their souls, were all killed.”

Palestinian spokesman charged that their fighters were “tricked early today when Red Cross trucks approached Tal Zaatar accompanied by Christian gunmen. The guerrilllas held their fire, thinking it was an evacuation mission, the Palestinian spokesmen said, but then the Christians launched a surprise attack as the trucks drove away.

The collapse of Tal Zaatar — reduced to rubble by thousands of artillery rounds — clears Christian-held east Beirut of the last significant stronghold of the alliance of Palestinians and leftist Moslems and reinforces the virtual partition of Lebanon. The fall gave the right-wing Christian leadership perhaps its greatest victory in 16 months of civil war.

Palestinian chieftains had vowed to defend Tal Zaatar to the bitter end. The residents of Tal Zaatar began fleeing as it became apparent that the victorious Christian forces were holding their fire in an undeclared truce.

Estimates of the number of people inside the devastated hovels of Tal Zaatar has ranged as high as 30,000, including Lebanese Moslems, but this was never certain because residents filtered out over the months of fighting. A nurse evacuated from the camp last week said as many as 2,000 may have been killed during the seige.

Tal Zaatar falls after long siege by Christians.

CP-1976-030 →

· Los Angeles Herald Examiner

Palestinians Vow Fight Will Go On

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — The Palestinians and their leftist Moslems Lebanese allies threatened today to avenge the fall of the Tal Zaatar Palestinian camp and vowed that Lebanon’s civil war would continue. Palestinian leader Farouk Kaddoumi said his men would “avenge Tal Zaatar elsewhere in Lebanon.”

Leftist papers said the Moslems might “escalate fighting in Christian-held mountain areas,” through which Moslem villages are still scattered. “Lebanese will have to brace for a protracted war,” said Kamal Jumblatt, the Moslem leader of the Lebanese leftists. “We must brace ourselves for more shocks, similar to that of Tal Zaatar.

“Our prime duty now is to set up a strong popular army to resist the Syrian invasion and to liberate captured areas. We will have to resist partition, because a Christian state in our region.”

The flight of emaciated, weeping civilians from Tal Zaatar was arranged by the International Red Cross and Palestinian civilian leaders from within the camp, who negotiated directly with Christian militia officers leading the siege.

The radio station of Pierre Gemayel’s right-wing Christian Phalange party claimed the evacuation also was secretly agreed to by Palestinian security chief Abu Hassan in a Wednesday night meeting with Gemayel’s nephew Alexandre.

The residents of Tal Zaatar began fleeing when it became apparent the victorious Christian forces were holding their fire in an undeclared truce. Kholi said in a news conference 8,000 persons were taken out of the camp by trucks from the Red Cross, the Arab peacekeeping force and even the Christian Phalange militia. He said another 4,000 simply fled.

The fall of Tal Zaatar Thursday removed the last Moslem stronghold from Christian East Beirut and consolidated the area with the Christian hinterland north of the capital. Christian militiamen fought mopup actions today against isolated pockets of defenders in the 74-acre camp.

Palestinian sources said scattered hand-to-hand fighting continued but admitted that the camp had been conquered. Hours after Tal Zaatar fell, Moslem gunmen of the Ambushers militia laid siege to the Assyrian quarter in the heart of Moslem West Beirut.

The Ambushers accused the quarter’s 3,000 Christians of supporting “Christian atrocities” against refugees from Tal Zaatar. Street fighting escalated during the night along the dividing line in Beirut and nearby mountain towns. An incomplete count of casualties by security officers and hospitals showed at least 186 persons killed and 215 wounded.

The war has taken more than 34,000 lives since it erupted in April 1975. Leftist gunners fired artillery and mortar barrages into the Christian suburb of Ashrafiyeh, and Christians returned the fire, officials said.

CP-1976-031 →

· The New York Times

The Fall of Tell Zaatar

In many ways, Tell Zaatar was symbolic of the Palestinian plight in the Middle East. A heavy fortification in the midst of an industrial suburb, home away from home for a whole generation of displaced peoples; nothing in the Tell Zaatar refugee camp held out any promise of a better life for the tens of thousands who lived there.

A strategic obstruction on a vital communications route, Tell Zaatar became the focal point of Lebanon’s civil war, just as the Palestinian issue stands astride the Middle East peacemaking process. The camp was too pivotal to be bypassed, it acquired an abstract meaning too emotional to be abandoned.

At Tell Zaatar, humanity was made to suffer for ideological advantage; the defenders chose resistance to the end.

The fall of Tell Zaatar yesterday, after seven weeks of siege, wanton murder and duplicity, gives Lebanon’s Christian community its long sought territorial contiguity between its strongholds of eastern Beirut and the Mediterranean littoral northeast of the capital. In itself, that solves none of Lebanon’s real problems.

But it may begin to set up the situation in which those problems can finally be addressed, the start of a new political dispensation for Lebanon’s heterogeneous society. For the Palestinians, the loss of their Tell Zaatar base could generate a trauma far deeper than would normally follow the collapse of a strategic position.

In the weeks to come, Palestinians of all factions—no less than the influential forces outside—would benefit from a fundamental rethinking of an ideology of war and revanchism that has sapped the energies of a whole generation, and achieved nothing.

CP-1976-032 →

· The New York Times

BEIRUT CHRISTIANS TAKE TELL ZAATAR AFTER LONG SIEGE

Palestinian Camp Is Seized in Hand-to-Hand Combat —Refugees Fleeing

By IHSAN A. HIJAZI

BEIRUT, Lebanon, Aug. 12—Right-wing Christians announced today that the Palestinian camp of Tell Zaatar had fallen to their forces, which had the camp under siege since mid-June. Palestinian sources were quoted by a left-wing radio station as having said that hand-to-hand fighting was still going on inside the camp.

Witnesses reported that thousands of civilians were streaming out of Tell Zaatar and surrendering to right-wing forces. Women and children were crying while old men stumbled over rubble-strewn streets carrying small bundles of belongings, the witnesses said, and added that they had seen few men of fighting age leaving the camp.

They reported that they had seen the bodies of 10 young men at the entrance of the camp. The fall of Tell Zaatar seemed bound to bring about a new deterioration in the 16-month civil war. An Arab diplomatic source commented: “Lebanon has taken yet another jump into the unknown.”

The leftist radio station accused the rightists of mistreating the civilians who were fleeing to seek refuge in the Moslem-controlled districts of western Beirut.

A right-wing radio station broadcast a communiqué by the Command of the Lebanese Forces, which comprises militias of the Christian political parties and breakaway Christian army troops, declaring the Tell Zaatar compound a prohibited area “because of the danger of mines planted in the camp, and to prevent the spread of epidemics.”

The right-wing radio reported that a rightist leader, Camille Chamoun, who is the Minister of Interior, met today with Dr. Hassan Sabry el-Kholy, the Arab League’s special envoy, and Jean Hoefliger, the head of the International Committee of the Red Cross in Lebanon, and made arrangements for transporting the evacuees to the Moslem areas.

The leftists and the Palestinians accused the rightists of reneging on a promise they reportedly gave Dr. Kholy last night not to storm the camp and to allow a peaceful evacuation of the inhabitants.

CP-1976-033 →

· The New York Times · page A7

Hundreds of Embittered Palestinian Refugees From Tell Zaatar Camp Gather at School in Beirut

BEIRUT, Lebanon, Aug. 12 (Reuters)—Hundreds of Palestinian refugees from the Tell Zaatar camp assembled by the truckload at an empty school in southwestern Beirut today.

There were old people and children, and many of the women were weeping over the fate of their husbands, sons, fathers and brothers who had died fighting or had been taken from them by the right-wing Christians who have had the camp under siege. Elderly women in black, their faces tattooed, sat surrounded by children, clutching bundles containing all they could bring with them.

A helper handing out packets of food from a cardboard box was mobbed by scores of ravenous children, eager for their first peaceful meal after 52 days under siege. A middle-aged woman wearing a black headscarf wandered around gesticulating wildly. Her companion said she had been deafened by shellfire.

A teen-age girl burst into tears, crying out her troubles in the school hallway. Her father and brother had died in the camp. A little girl ran up to an interpreter, clutched him tearfully by the arm and said her father was dead and she wanted to see her mother, who was in a hospital.

Some of the 2,000 refugees at the school sat apart, silent and stunned, keeping their shock and grief to themselves, ignoring the furor echoing down the corridors. For a few there was the joy of finding a friend or relative who lived in western Beirut and had gone to the school hoping for a reunion. “One or two from every family have been killed,” an old man said.

He had just arrived from the camp after being robbed of his watch and money by what he described as rightist gunmen. He had been making his way through rubble-filled alleys toward safety. He was taken to a point outside the camp where all male prisoners were being collected, he related.

There young men were picked out, he said, and someone was told to take them away and shoot them. Almost every group had a similar tale: While making their way from the camp their men were taken away by right-wing gunmen and they did not expect to see them again. But no one said they had actually witnessed men being shot.

Though scores no doubt died in the final hand-to-hand battle for the camp, it was impossible to tell whether unarmed inhabitants had been killed. Another old man said he thought many young men had been saved by the arrival of Amin Gemayel, a son of Pierre Gemayel, head of the Phalangists, the leading right-wing Christian group.

He said Amin Gemayel saw the men being rounded up and ordered his militia not to shoot them. But by then, the old man said, he had already seen a good number taken away and heard the sound of shooting. For the thousands at the school, today marked the end of a bitter experience.

It also marked the destruction of the only home many have known, even though it was a squalid shantytown. The weeping will stop but the bitter memories will remain. Palestinians and Lebanese alike will find it hard to forget the siege of Tell Zaatar.

CP-1976-034 →

· Clarion Ledger · page 5

City Of Death

Tal Zaatar — Bloating Corpses Amid Destruction

Washington Post-L.A. Times Service

TAL ZAATAR CAMP, Lebanon — The corpses lie bloating under the burning Mediterranean sun. Many families died together as they attempted to flee. Dead mothers hold dead children in their arms. Many are disfigured beyond recognition, heads half blasted away or torn completely from their bodies.

THOSE WHO dropped on the roads remain there, flattened by the vehicles of the Christian conquerors. No effort was made to clear the bodies away before the vehicles rolled over them. This was Tal Zaatar Friday. Once a bustling Palestinian refugee camp of some 30,000 souls, it is now a dead town, with hardly a building intact and many still burning.

The littered streets were patrolled by Christian fighters in black shirts. Among them was a 17-year-old girl named Eliane. She carried a Kalashnikov submachine gun and she was helping to root out the last resistance. Scattered shooting was still going on but it was not enough to deter the looters already moving in to salvage what had not been destroyed.

MANY OF THEM were Christian fighters. As Danny Chamoun, military leader of his father’s Christian militants, “The Tigers,” put it: “These people are fighting without pay. What they loot is all the pay they get.” One of them, a man with a gun in one hand and a sack of loot in the other, said: “You see Tal Zaatar?

This the most bad people, The Palestinians.” The final three-day battle, capping a two-month siege of the camp, was the bloodiest in 16 months of civil war here. Chamoun estimated there were 1,500 corpses rotting in the sun here, and the overall death toll could be 2,500.

It was the climax of the Christian drive to eliminate all pockets of resistance within territory they claim as their own. THE BATTLE started in the spring with the clean-up of the Karantina slum district near the port. From there, Moslem and Palestinian fighters had attempted to isolate Christian eastern Beirut from the Christian hinterland.

The Karantina has now been partly bulldozed flat and the same is scheduled to happen here, according to Beshir Gemayel, son of Christian Falange boss Pierre Gemayel and leader of the Falange military. Tal Zaatar will be renamed William Hawi Hill, after the Falange military leader who was shot dead by a sniper last month as he tried to arrange an evacuation from Tal Zaatar.

“Tal Zaatar will not exist any more,” Beshir said. At the same time, he rendered homage to “the great heroism and sacrifice” of Tal Zaatar’s Palestinian defenders. Certainly there is little left of Tal Zaatar worth trying to salvage. Hardly a hut, house, or factory remains intact, and the mosque is a riddled ruin.

CP-1976-035 →

· The Miami Herald · page 4-A

Buildings Burn and Corpses Rot In What Remains of Tal Zaatar

By JOE ALEX MORRIS Jr.

TAL ZAATAR CAMP, Lebanon — The corpses lie bloating under the burning Mediterranean sun. Many families died together as they attempted to flee. Dead mothers hold dead children in their arms. Many are disfigured beyond recognition, heads half blasted away or torn completely from their bodies.

Those who dropped on the roads remain there, flattened by the vehicles of the Christian conquerors. No effort was made to clear the bodies away before the vehicles rolled over them. THIS WAS Tal Zaatar Friday. Once a bustling Palestinian refugee camp of some 30,000 souls, it is now a dead town, with hardly a building intact and many still burning.

The littered streets were patrolled by Christian fighters in black shirts. Among them was a 17-year-old girl named Eliane. She carried a Kalashnikov submachine gun and she was helping to root out the last resistance. Scattered shooting was still going on but it was not enough to deter the looters already moving in to salvage what had not been destroyed.

Many of them were Christian fighters. As Danny Chamoun, military leader of his father’s Christian militants, “The Tigers,” put it: “These people are fighting without pay. What they loot is all the pay they get.” ONE OF them, a man with a gun in one hand and a sack of loot in the other, said: “You see Tal Zaatar? This the most bad people.

The Palestinians.” The final three-day battle, capping a two-month siege of the camp, was the bloodiest in 16 months of civil war here. Chamoun estimated that there were 1,500 corpses rotting in the sun here, and the over-all death toll could be 2,500.

It was the climax of the Christian drive to eliminate all pockets of resistance within territory they claim as their own. The battle started in the spring with the cleanup of the Karantina slum district near the port. From there, Moslem and Palestinian fighters had attempted to isolate Christian eastern Beirut from the Christian hinterland.

The Karantina has now been partly bulldozed flat and the same is scheduled to happen here, according to Beshir Gemayel, son of Christian Falange boss Pierre Gemayel and leader of the Falange military. Tal Zaatar will be renamed William Hawi Hill, after the Falange military leader who was shot dead by a sniper last month as he tried to arrange an evacuation from Tal Zaatar.

“Tal Zaatar will not exist any more,” Beshir said. At the same time, he rendered homage to “the great heroism and sacrifice” of Tal Zaatar’s Palestinian defenders. CERTAINLY there is little left of Tal Zaatar worth trying to salvage. Hardly a hut, house, or factory remains intact, and the mosque is a riddled ruin.

The hospital is one of the few buildings still standing. Its operating room in the cellar, equipped with a Chinese operating table, was one of the few relatively clean rooms anywhere.

Nearby was the ruins of a munitions factory, where the Christians said the Palestinians were making rocket-propelled grenades under the supervision of foreign technicians, presumably from Communist countries. These technicians have not been captured, and Chamoun said they probably escaped.

“We will try to help the Palestinians establish themselves any place else,” said Beshir Gemayel. “But we will never again allow a belt around Beirut.” The refugees are in fact establishing themselves around west Beirut, moving into empty apartments long since deserted by the well-to-do who fled to safer climes.

The Tal Zaatar Refugee Camp, Scene of War’s Most Bitter Battle . . . deep inside, a handful of Palestinians still are holding out

CP-1976-036 →

· The Daily Progress · Charlottesville · page A2

Witnesses Report Mass Executions, Atrocities

BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — Witnesses Saturday reported mass executions and other atrocities in the fall of the Tal Zaatar Palestinian refugee camp to Christian soldiers. Heavy fighting erupted at dusk in what Lebanese predicted would be new Christian onslaughts.

Artillery duels broke out across battlelines in Beirut and heavy fighting was also reported in the countryside, the mountains east of Beirut and in northern Lebanon.

The fighting came at the end of a day of quiet on most fronts but Lebanese predicted the Christians would follow their capture of Tal Zaatar with new attacks to capture more territory from the Palestinian and Moslem forces.

International Red Cross mission chief Jean Hoefliger, whose team has been searching the ruins of the Tal Zaatar camp for wounded victims, refused to confirm any specific massacre reports, saying “the page has been turned on Tal Zaatar.” But he spoke bitterly of “regrettable incidents.”

Western witnesses reported they had seen “dozens” of Palestinian men taken prisoner by Christian militiamen being lined up and machine-gunned to death at Dikwaneh, a suburb near the camp. Some of the refugees who made it safely to Moslem-held west Beirut described mass executions of whole families and other atrocities.

Their reports could not be confirmed by other sources. Hoefliger said the Red Cross knew nothing of the fate of more than 100 men taken by the Christians at the end of the 56-day siege of Tal Zaatar. “We are asking to visit the prisoners and ensure their repatriation,” he said.

“We have been told (by Christian leaders) that there are about 100 prisoners, but there were surely many more.” Among those who escaped death at the camp was Mohammed Salim Kanaan, a frail, white-bearded Lebanese Moslem who said he was 111 years old.

Kanaan, who left the camp Friday huddled in the back of his son-in-law’s van, said he and his wife hid in their basement during the final Christian attack. “But now we can’t find my wife,” he said in a feeble voice. “I don’t know where she’s gone.”

Red Cross officials searching for remaining wounded said they found only corpses and that Kanaan apparently was the last man out alive. Lebanese sources predicted an escalation of the war in the wake of the bloody Christian takeover of the Tal Zaatar camp.

“The rightists are ready to press their military advantage wherever they can, and the Palestinians and leftists are bent on avenging Tal Zaatar,” one Lebanese source, who did not want to be named, said.

RUBBLE-STREWN STREET IN THE TAL ZAATAR PALESTINIAN REFUGEE CAMP / Two Christian Gunmen Inspect the Ruins

CP-1976-037 →

· The State Journal-Register

Mass executions reported in Palestinian refugee camp

BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — Witnesses Saturday reported mass executions and other atrocities in the fall of the Tal Zaatar Palestinian refugee camp to Christian soldiers. Heavy fighting erupted at dusk in what Lebanese predicted would be new Christian onslaughts.

Artillery duels broke out across battlelines in Beirut and heavy fighting was also reported in the countryside, the mountains east of Beirut and in northern Lebanon.

The fighting came at the end of a day of quiet on most fronts but Lebanese predicted the Christians would follow their capture of Tal Zaatar with new attacks to capture more territory from the Palestinian and Moslem forces.

International Red Cross mission chief Jean Hoefliger, whose team has been searching the ruins of the Tal Zaatar camp for wounded victims, refused to confirm any specific massacre reports, saying “the page has been turned on Tal Zaatar.” But he spoke bitterly of “regrettable incidents.”

Western witnesses reported they had seen “dozens” of Palestinian men taken prisoner by Christian militiamen being lined up and machine-gunned to death at Dikwaneh, a suburb near the camp. Some of the refugees who made it safely to Moslem-held west Beirut described mass executions of whole families and other atrocities.

Their reports could not be confirmed by other sources. Hoefliger said the Red Cross knew nothing of the fate of more than 100 men taken by the Christians at the end of the 56-day siege of Tal Zaatar.

CP-1976-038 →

· The New York Times

ISRAELI’S PROPOSAL ON ARABS DISPUTED

Controversy Is Aroused by Official’s Plan for Measures to Curb Presence in Galilee Area

By William E. Farrell

JERUSALEM, Sept. 8 — The publication of a confidential report written by an Israeli official suggesting ways to curb the growing number and influence of Israeli Arabs in the Galilee region has provoked a sharp controversy here.

The report, written by Israel Koenig, the Ministry of Interior’s chief official in the Galilee region, said that by 1978 Israeli Arabs in the area would outnumber Jews. Such a situation, according to the report, raised the question whether Israeli rule in the area might be threatened.

The report went on to recommend that a hard line be taken against the growth of the Arab population through steps that would include a rapid increase of Jewish settlements in areas with heavy Arab concentrations, a decrease in state subsidies to Israeli Arabs with large families and a program encouraging Arab youngsters to go abroad to study and then remain there.

Report Followed Red’s Victory The report was said to have been written late last year after an Israeli Arab, Toufik Zayad, a Communist, won election as Mayor of Nazareth. It was said to have been circulated six months ago, about the time that Arabs rioted in the Galilee district.

At that time, six Israeli Arabs were killed and scores were injured in the first general protest among the 450,000 Israeli Arabs since Israel was founded in 1948.

The document was published yesterday in Al Hamishmar, the newspaper of the left-wing Mapam Party, to call attention to what the paper termed “the grave and dangerous nature of the report’s findings.”

If the authorities had accepted some of these proposals, the result would have been “a serious deterioration in the relations between Israel’s Arabs and the Jewish population,” Al Hamishmar said. Too ‘Damaging’ an Outlook The newspaper called for the removal of Mr.

Koenig from his post because “an individual possessing an outlook as potentially damaging as Koenig’s should not be responsible for so sensitive an area as the Galilee.”

The publication of the report again brought into focus one of Israel’s touchiest social questions — the role of Israeli Arabs, who have often been labeled “second-class citizens.” Its disclosure prompted a spate of editorials in papers representing the full political spectrum. Yediot Ahronot, an independent publication, said that Mr.

Koenig’s report pinpointed “a demographic threat in the Galilee that should not be lightly dismissed” but that his proposals “do not accord with Israel’s democratic regime and its world image.” At the end of 1974, Israeli Arabs constituted about 47 percent of the 520,000 residents in the northern Galilee district.

According to the Koenig report, the figure will rise to 51 percent in two years. Hatzofeh, the organ of the National Religious Party, praised the report, saying that Mr.

Koenig had taken “pains to warn us in good times of the dangers lurking in the northern part of the country where, if something is not done, the Arabs may well constitute a majority within two years.”

CP-1976-042 →

· The New York Times

ALLON ASSAILS A PLAN TO CURB GALILEE ARABS

Reuters

JERUSALEM, Sept. 13 (Reuters) — Foreign Minister Yigal Allon denounced as “a miserable document” today a report by a Government official who recommended curbs on Arab population growth in Galilee. Mr.

Allon said the report, by Yisroel Koenig, the Government’s chief representative in Galilee, had harmed Israel’s efforts toward coexistence between Arabs and Jews.

It was the strongest attack yet by a Government leader against the report, which called for harsh penalties against local Arab leaders who criticized the Government, reduction in allowances to large Arab families and encouragement of young Arabs to study abroad and stay abroad.

The report, disclosed last week by the left-wing newspaper Al Hamishmar, was written six months ago after a wave of rioting among Israeli Arabs in which six died. Senior ministers have disowned its recommendations; there is continuing Arab anger that Mr. Koenig remains in the area. Mr.

Allon said in reply to questions by reporters that “This is a miserable document — there is absolutely no connection whatever between its contents and the actual policy of the Government.”

CP-1976-043 →

· The New York Times

Israelis Kill an Arab Demonstrator In Old Jerusalem, Wound Another

Complaints of many of the West Bank’s 650,000 Arabs have focused in recent months primarily on the expropriation of West Bank land by Israel for the purpose of creating new Jewish settlements. In addition, actions by ultrarightist Israelis near Nablus and Hebron have intensified tensions between the West Bank Arabs and the Israelis.

The ultrarightists’ actions have also caused consternation in Israel, particularly an unauthorized settlement months ago about eight miles west of Nablus. The settlement, called Camp Kaddum, was criticized by the Israeli Cabinet, which said the settlement must be moved at an early date to another site. That was in April.

So far, the Government has made no move to relocate the settlers, who have steadily been improving their community. Another major tension spot is in Hebron, where members of the ultraorthodox Gush Emunim sect have repeatedly attempted to reclaim an abandoned Jewish hospital in the middle of an Arab market quarter for purposes of creating a synagogue.

In addition, Arabs and Jews in Hebron are at odds over the continued growth of a new Gush Emunim settlement, Kiryat Arba, which looks down on Hebron from a promontory. Besides the growing uneasiness among West Bank Arabs, there has been growing agitation of late among Israeli Arabs, who number 450,000.

Six months ago, six Israeli Arabs were killed and scores were injured in the first general protest in the Israeli Arab community since the state of Israel was founded in 1948. The protest in the Galilee region turned into a riot.

The Israeli Arab community was outraged last week by the publication of a secret report written by an Israeli official who suggested ways to curb the growing influence of the Arabs in the Galilee area.

CP-1976-039 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Arabs Call a Strike in Galilee

Officials Assail Recommendations in a Secret Report to Curb Influence of the Minority

By WILLIAM E. FARRELL

The secret report is the Koenig Memorandum, written by the Interior Ministry’s district commissioner for the north and leaked that September. It recommended thinning the Palestinian population of the Galilee and limiting its political organisation. Six months after Land Day, the people it was written about read it in the newspaper and called a general strike.

CP-1976-022 →

· The New York Times

Israeli Arabs Halt Work in a Call For Ouster of Top Galilee Official

By William E. Farrell

JERUSALEM, Sept. 28 — Israeli Arabs from the Galilee region quietly demonstrated today to back demands for the dismissal of an Israeli official who provoked a furor with his report recommending measures to curb the growth and influence of the country’s Arab population.

Sympathy strikes for the Israeli Arabs were held by Palestinian Arabs in Israeli-occupied towns of the West Bank of the Jordan and in the Gaza Strip. There were violent incidents, mainly involving clashes between Israeli security forces and stone-throwing bands of Arab youths in a number of towns, including Nablus, Hebron, Gaza and Tulkarm.

The Israeli-Arab protest, which took the form of a two-hour work stoppage by municipal employees in many communities in the Galilee, was in sharp contrast with one last March 30, which erupted into riots that left six Israeli-Arabs dead and scores injured.

One resident of Nazareth contrasted today’s Israeli Arab protest with the Arab disturbances in the territories Israel has occupied since the 1967 war, and said it demonstrated that “Israeli Arabs are Israelis first and Arabs second although some Israeli Jews tend to put us in the same basket.” Israel’s Arab population currently numbers about 450,000.

From 1948, when the state of Israel was formed, until the March 30 protest, the Israeli Arabs were generally quiet and nonmilitant. But that is changing. Growing numbers of Israeli Arabs are fighting against what they term their “second-class”citizenship in Israel.

The latest focus of their discontent occurred about three weeks ago with the publication in a newspaper here of a secret report written by Israel Koenig, the chief Israeli official in the Galilee region, that Israeli Arabs have labeled “racist and fascist.” Mr.

Koenig said that in two years, the Israeli Arabs would constitute a majority in the Galilee region and that “their increase in the Galilee contains a threat to our very rule in the region.”

He recommended a number of proposals to curb the growth and influence of Israel’s Arabs, including a decrease in state subsidies to large Arab families and other recommendations offensive to Israel’s Arabs. These have been disavowed by a number of Israeli leaders as contrary to official policy.

But the disavowals have been regarded as inadequate by Israeli Arab leaders, who are calling for Mr. Koenig’s ouster from his post in the Galilee. “There is more bitterness today because this [Mr. Koenig’s report] affects everyone,” an Israeli Arab journalist said. The Israeli Arab demand for Mr.

Koenig’s ouster provided a new impetus for demonstrations by Arabs in the Israeli-occupied territories. In the West Bank town of Nablus, the evidence of a protest was far more visible than in Nazareth, where shops were open and clusters of tourists wandered through winding streets.

In Nablus, stores were shuttered and for most of the day roving bands of Arab youths periodically occupied a main square burning tires, stoning a branch of an Israeli bank and taunting Israeli security forces and pelting them with rocks.

CP-1976-044 →

· The New York Times · page 13

Controversial Jewish Settlement at Hebron Illustrates the Challenges Israel Faces in Occupied Arab Lands

By WILLIAM E. FARRELL

KIRYAT ARBA, Israeli-Occupied West Bank, Sept. 30—This raw-looking settlement of 1,500 Jews has become a microcosm of the problems facing Israel because of the territories it captured here on the West Bank of the Jordan during the 1967 war.

The problems touch on a broad range of concerns—politics, religion, relations with the Arabs, history, Zionism, obedience to Israeli law, expansion. These complex and conflicting issues have now focused on the activities of Rabbi Moshe Levinger, a resident of Kiryat Arba and a leader of the right-wing religious bloc called Gush Emunim, meaning the Bloc of Believers.

Kiryat Arba’s walkways and paths bustle with construction by day. At night they are empty and lunar as they are bathed in a halo of floodlights. The community sits atop a promontory looking down at the old Moslem town of Hebron, where Jews, although unwelcome, lived for centuries and where 63 of them were massacred by their Arab neighbors in 1929.

For many weeks Rabbi Levinger has led a band of his followers into a busy quarter of Hebron to demonstrate and pray near an abandoned Jewish hospital. The demonstrations have heightened tensions between Jews and Arabs; on many occasions Israeli soldiers on duty in the occupied territories have had to intervene.

Rabbi Levinger and his followers insist that they have every right to enter Hebron. The military government of the West Bank says his forays only make a bad situation worse. The military governor recently forbade the rabbi to enter the town, but he ignored the action.

After an arrest order was issued this week he resisted, staying in his apartment with a phalanx of his followers while soldiers camped on his doorstep. Assertions in the Israeli Cabinet that the law was being flouted were followed by a move by the soldiers to arrest the rabbi, and fights broke out between him and his followers.

It was finally agreed that if the soldiers departed Rabbi Levinger would go to the military governor’s office, where he was booked and released on bail. He said that for the time being he would discontinue the visits to Hebron while political leaders decided what to do.

Gush Emunim and other right-wing blocs claim the occupied lands of Judea and Samaria as historical parts of the Jewish homeland and maintain that no government can prevent their settlement there. Many secular Jews deplore their actions, arguing that they impede peace efforts, inflame the Arab residents of occupied areas and ignore Israeli law.

Other secular Jews, while dissociating themselves from the fundamentalist brand of Judaism the Gush Emunim espouse, are in sympathy with their expansionist position and insist that the issue is Zionism.

CP-1976-040 →

· The New York Times

Arabs and Israelis Clash on West Bank

ARABS AND ISRAELIS CLASH ON WEST BANK Two Sides Accuse Each Other of Desecrating Artifacts By WILLIAM E. FARRELL Special to The New York Times HEBRON, Occupied West Bank, Oct.

3—Rioting and violent clashes erupted here today between Arab youths and Israeli security forces after Moslems and Jews accused one another of desecrating Moslem and Jewish artifacts at a shrine sacred to both faiths.

The charges and countercharges of vandalism in the Tomb of the Patriarchs here also triggered rock-throwing protests in a number of other Arab West Bank towns occupied by Israel, including Nablus, Tulkarm, Jenin and Ramallah.

About 60 arrests were made during a melee at the shrine here and up to 55 Arabs were reported to have been injured in fights with Israeli security forces. Six Arab youths and an Arab girl of 14, all of them from the nearby village of Halhoul, were shot. Two of them were reported to be in critical condition in a hospital in the town of Beit Jala.

One of the injured youths said he had been shot by a civilian. This tense town has been the scene Continued on Page 3, Column 1 … of many conflicts in recent weeks between Arabs and ultrareligious residents of a new nearby Jewish settlement, Qiryat Arba. The immediate origins of today’s clashes were said by both Arab and Jewish officials to have begun Friday.

But that was the only area of agreement about events in the tomb where Arabs and Jews pray at separate hours. Defense Minister Shimon Peres of Israel, who was at the scene, said the incident began when Jews discovered that a cloth for the Ark of the Covenant had been stolen. Mr.

Peres said that subsequently some copies of the Koran had been flung to the floor, apparently in reprisal. Mayor Fahad Kawasmeh of Hebron gave a different version. He said that on Friday night some members of the ultranationalistic Jewish Gush Emunim bloc had disturbed the prayers of a small group of Arabs gathered in the huge vaulted shrine. Early Saturday morning, Mr.

Kawasmeh said, some 15 Jewish residents of Qiryat Arba returned to the shrine “and tore the Koran and trod on it with their feet.” The mayor said he had complained to the Israeli military commander for the occupied territory and again warned that Gush Emunim protests in Moslem Hebron over the past three months had created an incendiary situation.

Whichever side touched off the incidents, the effect today at the beginning of Yom Kippur was an explosive one. Hundreds of Arab youths, many of them carrying copies of the Koran, held a sit-in at the tomb. Clashes with Israeli security forces broke out and Jewish scriptures, furniture and other items were desecrated.

Reporters Barred A curfew was imposed and by this afternoon the town was shuttered as numerous Israeli patrols moved in formation through the streets. The area around the tomb was barred to reporters who wanted to inspect the damage. Mr.

Peres said in an interview that the curfew would remain in effect tomorrow but that Arabs and Jews who wished to pray at the Tomb of Abraham and other parts of the shrine could do so. The Defense Minister, who has been critical in recent days of the actions of some members of the Gush Emunim bloc, would not comment when asked if the group had fomented the disturbances.

Mayor Kawasmeh said that members of Gush Emunim had repeatedly demonstrated in a crowded Arab market quarter and “had increased the heat to the point of boiling.” Mr. Peres said he had appealed to Arab and Jewish religious leaders to help calm the situation. At the hospital in Beit Jala, near Bethlehem, Dr.

Shehadeh Shehadeh said that he had admitted seven shooting victims from Halhoul, which is north of Hebron. One of the victims, Hatim Molhem, 17, who was shot in the leg, said he did not know who fired on him as he was delivering milk to his father’s store.

Another of the victims, Sadee al-Wayheh, who had minor arm and foot wounds, said he was taking grapes to the marketplace when a pickup truck with an Israeli license plate stopped alongside the road. One of the three men inside the van opened fire and the truck took off, he said. He said his attacker wore civilian clothes.

A demonstration was taking place not far from where he stood, the 24-year-old Arab said, but he said he had not participated in it. Mr. Peres said that a team of police officials was being appointed to investigate the unrest.

Armed Israeli soldiers lining up in the marketplace of Hebron, in occupied Jordan, to enforce curfew

CP-1976-047 →

· The Tampa Times · Tampa · page 1

Arab-American convention hears horror stories from Israeli Arabs

Andrea Brunais, Times Staff Writer

NEW YORK — Hanna Nasir already was asleep when Israeli authorities in Birzeit called him to their offices to discuss student demonstrations at Birzeit University. The students had been demonstrating against continued Israeli occupation of the West Bank.

It was close to midnight in November 1974 when Nasir got the call, but the president of the Palestinians’ only university did as he was told. There were no discussions, however. Nasir was handcuffed, blindfolded and driven to the Lebanese border with three other West Bank Palestinians.

They were told to move north, if they returned they would be shot… Nasir is one of the 1,300 well-educated professionals who have been deported — illegally, they say — from the Israeli-occupied West Bank of the Jordan. Nasir left behind his wife and four children, who later joined him in Amman, Jordan, where he continues to run the university in absentia.

His expulsion, he said, was part of a systematic policy by the Israelis to eliminate any possibility of leadership among the Palestinians on the West Bank… Felicia Langer, a Jewish author and attorney on the West Bank, described “institutionalized terror” against the Arabs in the occupied territories, including tactics such as illegal deportation, years-long “administrative detentions” without hearing or trial, brutal interrogations, collective punishments and the destruction of homes… Some members of the AAUG hoped the organization would join the struggle to improve the image of the Arab in the minds of the American public.

Keynote speaker James Abourezk, Democratic senator from South Dakota, noted that most Americans think of Arabs only as “greedy, rich spendthrifts or murderous bandits.”… In deference to the bloodshed in Lebanon, however, the festivities were scrapped.

Instead, the outspoken leftist mayor of Nazareth, Tawfiq Zayyad, proved himself as adept at poetry as he is at aggravating the Israeli authorities. He recited one of his poems about Palestine, which set some members of his audience to tears. “We will not leave (Palestine),” he recited. “We are staying, to attend our homes, our lands, our fences.

We were here in the past, we will maintain it in the present, because the future is ours.” Tomorrow: Palestinians under Israeli rule.

A poem recited at a convention and printed by an American paper as news. The parenthesis in “We will not leave (Palestine)” is the paper’s own. Zayyad was mayor of Nazareth and a member of the Knesset — a Palestinian citizen of Israel, which the paper marks in its headline by calling the speakers “Israeli Arabs.”

CP-1976-008 →

· The Tampa Times · Tampa · page 1

Life not democratic for some in Israel

Arabs within Israel and in the occupied territories complain of second-class citizenship, jailings for political beliefs and terror tactics such as the blowing up of homes.

Andrea Brunais, Times Staff Writer

NEW YORK — Israel is often referred to as the only democracy in the Middle East. But according to prominent Palestinian Arabs living in Israel and on the occupied West Bank of the Jordan, life is anything but democratic for them.

Tawfiq Zayyad, the mayor of Nazareth, described a “regime of oppression” under which the Palestinians — even those who are citizens of Israel — live.

The leftist mayor-poet said Israeli authorities are carrying out “a policy of national discrimination” by expropriating Arab lands, implementing “spiritual and cultural Judaization” and retarding the development of Arab cities and villages within Israel. Israeli Arabs are labeled “non-Jews” and they study Arabic by listening to lectures in Hebrew, Zayyad said.

As for schools, “the vast majority of the existing school buildings should be called stables because they are more for animals than human beings.” Some Palestinian Arabs, like Zayyad, are citizens of Israel who did not leave when the state was created in 1947.

Others do not have Israeli passports, such as those who live in the occupied territories, and life for them is no easier under Israeli military rule.

Felicia Langer, a Jewish attorney on the West Bank and author of “With My Own Eyes,” has defended many of the Palestinian Arabs arrested by Israeli authorities for crimes ranging from passing out leaflets to giving a glass of water to a demonstrator. “There’s nothing lawful in the eyes of the authorities,” she said.

Four thousand Arabs are in jail for political reasons, said Mrs. Langer, who was born in Poland and whose husband survived Buchenwald. In occupied Jerusalem, the West Bank, Gaza and the Golan Heights, more than 19,000 buildings have been destroyed, and with them the myth that the Israelis have brought prosperity to the occupied lands, she said.

In the case of some of the Arabs she has represented in court, the homes of their parents were blown up without the parents ever being told why their sons or daughters had been arrested.… Other speakers included Sen.

James Abourezk, D-South Dakota; Shafiq el-Hout, director of the Beirut office of the Palestine Liberation Organization; and Clovis Maksoud, a senior editor of Beirut’s al-Nahar… “Those of us who understand the forces operating in the area know full well there will be neither peace nor justice in the Middle East if the focus is on the Arab-Israeli issues, and the issue of Palestine is ignored,” said Elaine Hagopian, president of the Arab-American group and a professor of sociology at Simmons College in Massachusetts.

“Palestine is and will continue to be the issue.”… Editor Maksoud told the conference, “It is not that our enemies plan; it is that we fall into the trap.” Tomorrow: The Arabs and information.

The second of a three-part series; the first is CP-1976-008, printed the day before, which ends with Tawfiq Zayyad reciting a poem. The photograph on this one is Felicia Langer, captioned only “…19,000 buildings destroyed.” The third part ran on 14 October under the line the paper prints here: The Arabs and information.

CP-1976-010 →

· The New York Times

Unease Is Deepening in Israel Over the Arab Minority

By William E. Farrell

JERUSALEM, Nov. 1 — “When I go to Tel Aviv people look at me as an Arab and suspect me. When I go to Nablus, on the West Bank, they look at me as an Israeli and suspect me.”

These widely quoted remarks were made several years ago by an Israeli Arab official who capsulized the continuing dilemma confronting Israel’s largest minority group — the 500,000 Arabs who are citizens, some say second-class citizens.

The problems of the Israeli Arabs, who total 15 percent of the population, are deeply complex and thorny, rooted in the violent history of this part of the Middle East.

The issues, which touch on many spheres — political, social, cultural, religious, educational — have taken on new urgency in recent months as a result of protests by once-placid Israeli Arabs and of a controversial report by an Israeli official that has inflamed many members of the minority group.

The paradoxes and complexities posed by the growing minority, whose members are kin to nations bent on Israel’s destruction, are not lost on the Israelis.

“We were experts at being a minority for 2,000 years,” said Shmuel Toledano, an Israeli Jew who is Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin’s adviser on Arab affairs, “and the first time we are a majority we have to deal with the most complicated problems of a minority.”

The Israeli Arabs — they are not to be confused with the million Palestinian Arabs in the territories of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, which have been occupied by Israel since the 1967 war — have been here since the birth of the nation in 1948, when they numbered 150,000.

For many years they were a quiescent population, some nurturing their discontents and grievances in muted undertones, others trying to adapt to the realities of finding a role in a society dominated by Jews and forging ahead in such areas as jobs, schooling and housing. Within the last year there have been overt, sometimes violent, manifestations of discontent.

These have been coupled with a rising nationalism that is part of a larger search for a new identity or for a way to accept the one imposed on them: Israeli Arab, an appellation that is inherently ironic given the protracted state of war between Arabs and Jews.

The current focus on the problem followed publication of a highly controversial secret report written by Israel Koenig, a Government official, suggesting ways to curb the growth and influence of the Arabs in Israel. The report was based on the prospect that within two years the Arabs in the Galilee region, where most of the Arabs of Israel live, would constitute a majority.

“Their increase in Galilee contains a threat to our very rule in the region,” Mr. Koenig wrote.

Among his recommendations were a policy of reward and punishment for Israeli Arab leaders based on their degree of cooperation, a rapid increase in Jewish settlements to offset the Arab population gains, a decrease in subsidies to Arabs with large families and a program encouraging young Israeli Arabs to study abroad, with “obstacles” placed in the path of their return.

The Koenig document, which caused a furor among Jews as well as Arabs and which was described as fascist and racist, spoke of “the superficial and Levantine Arab character.” The reaction to it was intensified by Mr.

Koenig’s position as the Ministry of the Interior’s chief official in Galilee, with a good deal of say about allocation of funds to municipalities. Several orderly protests — in contrast to a rally against Israeli expropriation of Arab-owned lands on March 30, which turned into a riot that saw six Israeli Arabs killed — were held to seek Mr.

Koenig’s ouster. Ranking Israeli officials, including Mr. Rabin, said that the report was no more than the private musings of a civil servant and that it contravened policy. But the failure to dismiss Mr. Koenig is still a sore point with many Israeli Arabs, and his memorandum has provided a good deal of grist for anti-Israeli propaganda mills.

Some Arabs, among them Toufik Zayad, a Communist who is the Mayor of Nazareth, Israel’s largest Arab town, maintain that the attitude expressed by Mr. Koenig merely reflects tacit Government policy despite statements about equality for Arab citizens. In an interview Mr.

Toledano, the Prime Minister’s adviser, said that implementation of the policy of equality was not always easy and added, “I haven’t met a serious man who thinks for a minute the clock can be turned back.” He was alluding to the period before 1966, when Israeli Arabs lived under military rule and to the hard line advocated by Mr.

Koenig, a line that has more than a few supporters among the majority. In the early days of the new nation the Israeli Arabs were preoccupied with bread-and-butter issues.

With large amounts of Government aid illiteracy went from 85 percent to 15 percent; housing improved; roads were built to villages previously inaccessible by car; jobs were created; social services were provided. Those benefactions are partly responsible for the current discontent. As Mr.

Toledano put it, “The more people are educated the more they ask, ‘Who am I?’ and the question gets very difficult.” In addition, the aftermath of the 1967 war enabled Israeli Arabs to make contact with West Bank Arabs, many of them militant supporters of a Palestinian state.

As all this ferment and groping takes place among the Arabs, the Israelis cannot forget their first-hand experience of suffering and casualties at the hands of outside Arab enemies — violent incidents that have colored their attitudes toward the Arabs within their borders. “We can’t forget these people are part of the Arab world,” an official said.

“We can’t be sure of who is going to harm us. We have to be careful, and yet we have to integrate.” Echoing those sentiments, Mr. Toledano said: “The main problem is whether we can implement the policy of integration — which is not easy. We have to convince.

It’s a question of convincing the people, and it’s not easy in this dilemma of war. But the other choice is worse.” On the other side are the Arab suspicions about the Jewish majority’s intentions, accentuated by increasing challenge from a new generation that regards the leaders of the Arab community as hidebound Uncle Toms.

Land Policy Called Irritant Atallah Mansour, an Israeli Arab journalist who writes for the Hebrew newspapaer Haaretz, commented recently that a major source of disaffection among the Arabs was the Government’s land-expropriation policy.

“An Arab in Nazareth who lost his land in the mid-1950’s and cannot today purchase an apartment built on it in the new Jewish town of Nazareth-Elit cannot help but feel deep fury,” he said. A crucial difference between an Israeli Arab and an Israeli Jew concerns military service.

Most able-bodied male Jews are subject to a three-year draft and many years of reserve duty, but the Arabs are not. According to the Government, this is to spare them from having to fight against other Arabs; in addition a security problem is seen in any large Arab military contingent.

The number of Israeli Arabs continues to grow, doubling in 17 years, according to figures prepared by the Labor Party, while the Jewish population, based on the current growth rate, will not double for 44 years. As the population ratio changes, so will the problems flowing from the condition of the minority.

Crucial to the solution of many of them is the answer to a question that has been with Israel since its inception: Can an Arab minority be a full partner in a state that Prime Minister Rabin recently described as being based on “the ingathering of the Jewish people’s exiles, living the life of a Jewish state”?

CP-1976-045 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Tear Gas Used to Quell West Bank Protests

TEL AVIV, Dec. 12 (UPI)—Troops used tear gas today to disperse young Arab demonstrators in Nablus, the largest town on the West Bank of Jordan River, and later imposed a curfew on the town.

It was the third time in five days that military authorities had clamped a curfew on the town after young Arabs bombarded Israeli border police with rocks, burned tires in the streets and set up roadblocks. The troops responded with tear gas as the young people chanted anti-Israel slogans and waved the flag of the Palestine Liberation Organization.

The protests were set off when an 8 percent sales tax imposed in Israel was extended to include the administered'territories. The Arabs were also angered by plans to requisition Arab lands in the territory captured by Israel from Jordan in the 1967 war.

CP-1976-050 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Beersheba, Once Scorned by Israelis, Is Booming Amid the Desert

Beersheba, Once Scorned by Israelis, Is Booming Amid the Desert By WILLIAM E. FARRELL Special to The New York Times BEERSHEBA, Israel, Jan. 25—Not so many years ago, urbane Israelis liked to put down this now booming town in the Negev Desert in much the way Manhattanites might make snide remarks about Brooklyn or the Bronx.

In those days, Beersheba was regarded as not much more than a sand-encrusted “burg” a traveler stopped in for gasoline or to pacify hunger pangs until he could be seated in a decent restaurant in Tel Aviv. But even then, Beersheba had come a long way from the 4,000-year-old water hole which tradition says was used by the Patriarch Abraham and his sheep.

Concrete was being poured, giant cranes were arching, houses were going up, water was being pumped into homes and kitchens and the city fathers talked ceaselessly of Beersheba as a major factor in the future of the state of Israel. But it was the kind of place some people found it necessary to live in, but hardly anyone wanted to visit.

Today, Beersheba is still not a city that will make esthetes purr with delight. But as a traveler drives along the endless wastes of the Negev it looms like an industrial Oz; it has grown from 1,800 Bedouins in 1947 to 104,000 inhabitants from a staggering number of places—Jews from India, America, Argentina, the Soviet Union, Morocco, Iraq and Egypt, to name just a few.

Varied People Reflect City’s Nature Rather than look at its architecture—it has a few distinguished or at least controversial buildings—a visitor can best understand Beersheba by looking at its varied inhabitants—Bedouins, North African Jews, recent Jewish immigrants from Soviet Georgia.

It is an array that in some way confirms what the city’s early boosters were saying about this vast, uncultivated and often inhospitable desert that holds a key to the country’s future.

“If the state does not put an end to the desert, the desert may put an end to the state,” David Ben-Gurion once said in one of his many exhortations to Israelis to settle the Negev. “It’s a city of newcomers,” said Mayor Eliyahu Nawi, a lawyer capable of making puns and telling jokes in Hebrew, Arabic and English.

“Here we have representatives of all the Jewish Diaspora.” Long a resident and Mayor for nearly Continued on Page 26, Column 5 [PHOTOGRAPH AND MAP CAPTIONS, five of them, set under the pictures across the top of the page, not body text] Booming Beersheba In the Negev [map credit] The New York Times/Jan.

29, 1977 A Soviet immigrant woman buys chicken from Bedouin in marketplace Concrete building of Ben-Gurion University of Negev is nearly completed Yitzhak Ephraim, immigrant from India, in hothouse where he grows roses [credit] The New York Times/Micha Bar-Am Needy Bedouins being assisted at Beersheba’s state welfare office … 14 years, Mr.

Nawi remembers early immigrant influxes of illiterate and backward Jews from caves in Yemen “and the girls who came with head lice who now drive their private cars.” He also remembers when the jackals would howl during fierce sandstorms. The sandstorms still occur but the jackals have retreated.

“Beersheba is the city of the future of the country because we are living on the reserves of land of the country,” Mayor Nawi said, referring to the open stretches now beginning to be industrialized.

Beersheba now has a good chamber orchestra, thanks primarily to the recent wave of Soviet immigrants, numbering about 2,000 families, as well as a budding university that represents the Israeli Government’s commitment to long-term development of the city. Spending a night in downtown Beersheba is about as exciting as listening to a “windbag” tell his life story.

But Beersheba is trying, or at least a lot of the young Beershebans—students with hot-combed hairstyles and mod clothes—are trying. But three of four “night spots” visited on a recent evening were off-limits to itinerant pleasure seekers because private wedding parties were in progress.

The fourth—a dingy boite located in a cellar—tried its best to affect an aura of world-weariness and decadence. The music was 1960’s rock and there was a flickering light show that flashed on gyrating dancers in a darkened room now and then. Its sins were venial; its boredom mortal.

Each Thursday morning at dawn, a timeless caravan of Bedouin peddlers arrive in an open area in Beersheba and set up a market where one can buy everything from a rancid goat or camel to a dubious Caesar coin—dating from the time of Sid rather than Julius.

Date check: No masthead, folio line or page date is on this clipping. It is the jump leg of a story: the first line under the headline reads “Continued From Page 21”, and the body begins mid-sentence (“14 years, Mr. Nawi remembers…”). Nothing on the scan dates it or names the paper, so 1977-01-29 and The New York Times cannot be confirmed from the image.

CP-1977-029 →

· The New York Times · New York

Thousands Pay Respects To Palestinian Leader

“Thousands of Israeli Arabs and West-Bank Arabs streamed through a muddy, winding path to a hilltop cemetery in Musmus today to pay their respects to Rashed Hussein… Israeli policy has been to prohibit public funerals of Palestinian militants lest their graves become shrines for nationalist demonstrations.”

The poet Rashed Hussein, who died in a hotel fire in New York at forty-one. The sentence keeps two categories apart — Israeli Arabs and West-Bank Arabs — and then describes them walking up the same hill to the same grave.

CP-1977-028 →

· The New York Times · New York

U.N. Agency Says Israel Tortures and Pillages

“The United Nations Human Rights Commission adopted a resolution today accusing Israel of torture and of the pillaging of archaeological and cultural property in the Arab territories it occupies.”

February 1977, four months before the Sunday Times investigation. The resolution couples torture with the removal of antiquities, which is how the two complaints travelled together in the 1970s record.

CP-1977-022 →

· Press of Atlantic City · Atlantic City

Arafat Praises Carter's Stand

CAIRO — An obviously pleased Yasser Arafat Thursday welcomed President Carter’s latest statement concerning a Palestinian “homeland” and called it “a very important note and a progressive step.”

Excerpts from the President’s Clinton, Mass., remarks about Middle East problems and peace prospects were read to Arafat during a break in the Palestine National Council, the “parliament” of the Palestine Liberation Organization which is meeting here.

The PLO chairman smiled when he heard Carter’s statement that “There has to be a homeland provided for the Palestinian refugees who have suffered for many, many years.” No American President has so directly addressed the Palestinian question before. “He has put his hand on the heart of the problem of the Middle East crisis,” said Arafat.

“If it is true what he said, it helped the whole situation in the area. A good step.” Whether the Carter remark and Arafat’s reaction portend a break in the long-standing impasse over Palestinian representation at any future Arab-Israeli peace negotiations remains to be seen.

However, it was clear from the reaction of some of the delegates to the national council that they were surprised and pleased by what appeared to be a more conciliatory American attitude toward them.

CP-1977-017 →

· Poughkeepsie Journal · Poughkeepsie · page 29

Carter Publicly Endorses Palestinian ‘Homeland’

By Barry Schweid, Associated Press Writer

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Carter’s public endorsement of a “homeland” for Palestinian refugees represents highly unorthodox diplomacy while sharpening the outline of a possible final Middle East peace settlement. In less than two weeks the President has: 1.

Given assurances to Israel that he believes it should have “defensible borders” to insure that an over-all agreement with the Arabs “might never be violated.” 2. Suggested that Israel and the Arab countries agree on a sovereign border, to be achieved in phases, and that Israeli defenses could be extended up to 13 miles beyond the border. 3.

Declared that a homeland must be provided for Palestinian refugees with the “exact way” to be determined by the Arab countries negotiating with Israel. Each pronouncement was surprising, principally for two reasons: First, the key issues Carter discussed must eventually be negotiated by the Arabs and Israelis.

Any apparent U.S. tilt beforehand could complicate the process. Second, presidents and their mediators traditionally shun substantive public comment while pursuing such settlements. Henry A.

Kissinger, as secretary of state, went beyond normal limits of diplomatic secrecy, having himself quoted as “a senior U.S. official” to disguise his generally uninformative observations. Carter, in his campaign last fall, struck at “secrecy” in foreign policy and promised to run it with greater “openness.”

His Middle East remarks are in line with that, but his approach is unfamiliar and it is hard to gauge the significance of his words. For instance, after Carter endorsed a Palestinian “homeland” in remarks to a town meeting on Wednesday, White House and State Department officials had a double and somewhat contradictory problem.

Caught off guard, they had to recover quickly and offer assurances to a concerned Israeli embassy that the administration had not decided on a formula for a Palestinian homeland. At the same time, these officials were obliged to maintain that U.S. policy had not changed — despite Carter’s unprecedented declaration.

Carter did not make the situation any easier to handle when he later tried to explain what he meant by his homeland reference. At first he seemed to placate Israel when he said he was talking in “the framework of the nation of Jordan.” But he went on to say “or by some other means.”

As one official put it, Carter went two steps forward, but then took one step back. Since Carter declined to say what he meant by “some other means,” the officials are faced anew with trying to explain what he was driving at while maintaining that the words speak for themselves. “I do not make flippant statements,” Carter recently said.

By that he indicated his statements, while often extemporaneous, also represent a thought-out policy.

Carries the standing label AP News Analysis.

CP-1977-019 →

· Houston Chronicle · Houston

Jimmy Carter shakes hands with a Palestinian and

CP-1977-018 →

· The New York Times

New Violence on the West Bank Is Feared as Arab-Israeli Tension Rises

By WILLIAM E. FARRELL

RAMALLAH, Israeli-Occupied West Bank—Long the scene of protests and demonstrations, the towns of the West Bank of the Jordan River are becoming increasingly restive as young Palestinians take to the streets in opposition to the continued presence of Israeli occupation forces on lands lost in the 1967 war.

According to Palestinian guerrillas and officials interviewed during a trip to Beirut, Lebanon, last week, the Palestine Liberation Organization is encouraging West Bank dissent and hopes to keep it visible and voluble in the months ahead.

“With the Lebanon situation what it is, it makes sense to keep the protests and demonstrations going along the West Bank,” said one Palestinian official in Beirut.

And there are indications here that the Israeli military is taking tougher measures against overt dissent now to try to avoid a repetition of last spring's embarrassing riots in the towns of Ramallah, Nablus, Hebron, Tulkarm and Jenin. “It's not like last year,” said a Palestinian activist from Ramallah. “They want it to be stopped before it gets under way.

It's not like April and March of last year.” The Israelis have striven during the years of their military occupation of the Arab territories to depict themselves as benevolent occupiers who want to keep to a minimum restrictions on human rights.

Since last year, that effort has begun to crumble for a number of reasons, not the least being the fact that the words “benevolence” and “occupation” are incompatible.

As the Israelis approach their 10th anniversary in the West Bank lands—an anniversary some believe will be the focus for further protests—they face increasing militance from young Palestinians dedicated to formation of a Palestinian state.

In addition, there is a growing militant spirit among Israeli Arabs—those who stayed when Israel was created in 1948—that found expression last March 30 in land-appropriation protests in Galilee in which six Israeli Arabs died and scores were injured. Several protests are scheduled in Israel later this month to commemorate last year's fatalities.

More West Bank sympathy protests are also expected.

Retention by Israel of the territories has been the subject of international criticism, including some from its staunch ally, the United States, which last November supported a United Nations Security Council resolution expressing “grave anxiety and concern over the present serious situation in the occupied territories as a result of continued Israeli occupation.”

In recent months, there have been West Bank protests and strikes over a number of issues—the condition of Arab security prisoners in the Ashkelon prison, a reaction against the imposition of a new Israeli tax, and expressions of support for the P.L.O. as the authorized representative of the Palestinian cause.

Israel has labeled the P.L.O. as “terrorist” and adamantly refuses to sit down at a negotiating table with it because its founding charter calls for the dismemberment of Israel.

The Arab countries insist that the P.L.O. be given recognition at any negotiations and that the gap between Israel and the Arabs on the question of the P.L.O. is a major stumbling block to renewal of some sort of peace talks. Underlying all the demonstrations is the antipathy the West Bankers feel toward the continued Israeli presence.

A recent protest in Ramallah, involving students at a teacher-training center operated by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, resulted in injuries to 17 men in their 20's and has raised questions about the conduct of the Israeli military.

Sympathy for Hunger Strikers The protest was in support of Arab hunger strikers in the Ashkelon prison who say they are subject to overcrowding and deprivations and are not treated as well as Israeli prisoners. Israeli officials concede that the prison system is overcrowded but deny that there is bias in the distribution of food and other necessities.

The prison protest, aside from any merit it may have in terms of prison conditions, has become the focus for political dissent. A melee ensued in last week's demonstration at Ramallah. Military spokesmen contend the injuries sustained by the teacher trainees occurred when they stumbled and fell while fleeing Israeli soldiers. The students tell a different story.

One of them, Iyad Abdul Latif Husein Zahen, 20 years old, said that when the soldiers caught him he was beaten and humiliated without cause. “They hit us with sticks and with their shoes and their guns,” he said in an interview. “One soldier caught my hair and put my head on the ground and put his shoe on my mouth. They broke our watches and told us to say ‘Thank you.’

They ordered us to curse Mohammed and they put our belts around our necks and pulled us to the right and to the left. They told us ‘You are not boys, you are donkeys and the demonstrations are not helping your problems.’” One teacher at the institute, who corroborated Mr.

Zahen's account, said: “All of this will be exported by teachers we're sending to places like Saudia Arabia. Of course, we'll be exporting hatred.” Dr. Antoine H.

Dibsy, the chief of internal medicine at Augusta Victoria Hospital in East Jerusalem, where the students were treated, said that they suffered from broken bones, broken teeth, wrist wounds suffered when their watches were smashed, and cross-hatched back bruises apparently caused by clubbings.

Very little about the Ramallah protest was reported in the English-language press in Israel. There was more in the Hebrew press.

But the Arabic press in East Jerusalem was banned from detailed reporting of the demonstration and was forbidden to run photographs of it, apparently because the Israeli censor said the nature of the protest was political and extensive coverage of it would serve to provoke further demonstrations.

Censorship After Broadcast Al Quds, an Arab newspaper, said yesterday: “It is really amazing that the censor stops us from writing something that the Israeli radio has broadcast and which Israeli papers have written about.”

Davar, the newspaper of the governing Israeli Labor Party, reported that recently the military government of the West Bank had been preventing the import of nonpolitical newspapers and weeklies from Jordan over the bridges separating Jordan and the West Bank. Davar noted that these publications had previously been permitted from the time Israel captured the lands.

The New York Times/March 25, 1977 Names in panels are of centers of rising anti-Israeli feeling.

CP-1977-035 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Arabs Rally In Galilee to Protest Land Expropriation

William E. Farrell

“About 10,000 Israeli Arabs, along with scores of Israeli Jewish supporters, gathered today in this village in northern Galilee to protest the Israeli Government’s policy of expropriating Arab-owned lands… A number of speakers accused the Israelis of overreacting to the demonstration last year and deplored the Government’s seizure of Galilee lands for a housing project.”

The first anniversary of Land Day, and the beginning of a run in this archive that reaches 2000. Farrell records the chant in both languages: With spirit and with blood we shall redeem Galilee. He also notes that Israel’s Arab population is about fifteen per cent of the country.

CP-1977-027 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago · page 1

Under friendly exterior—an ex-terrorist

Jonathan Broder, Special to The Tribune, Tel Aviv

TEL AVIV—It’s hard to believe that underneath the warm, friendly exterior of Menahem Begin lies the past of an underground Jewish terrorist leader.

Despite Begin’s gracious European manners and an eloquence that marked his 29 years as leader of the right-wing parliamentary opposition, there is a fierce nationalism forged by Nazi persecution and the turbulent days before Israeli statehood… Speaking to the nation, Begin set down tough terms for peace with the Arabs and declared that his party was unwilling to withdraw from the occupied Jordanian West Bank under any circumstances and was unwilling to allow a Palestinian state in the West Bank to become a belligerent Soviet satellite… BORN IN POLAND, Begin emigrated to Palestine in 1942 after three years under Nazi rule.

He preached a militant philosphy that placed him at odds with the Palestinian Arabs, the ruling British authorities, and the Labor leaders that ruled the Palestinian Jews. He founded the Irgun underground guerrilla group which carried out brutal attacks on Arab villages and British installations and blew up Jerusalem’s King David Hotel in 1946, killing 91 persons.

The aim of the Irgun was to establish a Jewish homeland on both sides of the Jordan River, according to biblical prophecy. Begin still dislikes being called a former terrorist. During a visit to Britain three years ago, he told newsmen, “You call me a terrorist, but I call myself a freedom fighter.”

HE GAINED respect as the leader of the right-wing Herut Party in Parliament after Israel won its statehood in 1948. But he revived his reputation for militancy by leading violent clashes against the government of Premier David Ben-Gurion over Israel’s decision to accept reparations from West Germany for the Nazi holocaust.

The morning after the election, in the paper’s own headline: ex-terrorist. The word is not in quotation marks and is not attributed to anyone. Begin’s answer is printed in the same column. The same paragraph uses Palestinian Arabs and Palestinian Jews of the 1940s, and the phrase in Begin’s policy sentence is the occupied Jordanian West Bank. “philosphy” is the paper’s.

CP-1977-005 →

· The Miami Herald · Miami · page 1

The Palestinians

Will Thousands of Refugees Ever Have Their Homeland Again?

“More than 600,000 Arabs still live in 63 refugee camps in Israeli-occupied territories, like Gaza… But who are the Palestinians, where are they, and what do they want? Can they have a homeland as Carter has suggested, and if so, where?

What are the major obstacles to finding a solution to the ‘Palestinian problem’?… This camp is a good place to start looking for an answer… It is called the Beach Camp. It is in a traditionally Arab area called the Gaza Strip, some 20 miles south of Israel’s Tel Aviv, on the shores of the Mediterranean.

The site should be a land developer’s dream. But for nearly 30 years it has been one of the world’s most miserable slums. More than 36,000 Palestinian Arabs live here, supported in part by the United Nations… One young man on the street is Mohammed, 20, who was born in this camp, as were five brothers and a sister.

His father, a hospital worker, fled Askelon in 1949, seeking shelter from the Israelis in an Arab area. Mohammed makes his living selling soft drinks in the hot sun but hopes to build a house outside the camp on government land. He has never had a full-time job. Another is Rafi, 23, father of three and expecting a fourth.

He lives with his parents, also from a small Arab town now in Israel. He also was born in the camp and he makes some money laying tile. ‘I must get out of this camp,’ Rafi says. ‘I’m working to do it. It is the difference between day and night to be out of this camp.’ He pauses and then blurts: ‘There should be peace.

Everybody is waiting for peace.’… There are an estimated 3.3 million Palestinians scattered throughout the world… Nearly half of all Palestinians live under Israeli control, either in occupied territories or in Israel itself. This is a potent political time bomb for the Israelis… ‘Does it make sense?’ asks Dr.

Ramzi Rihan, a professor at Bir Zeit University on the West Bank. ‘Economically, I would say no. It is an arid land, largely devoid of natural resources. The Gaza Strip has great potential as a port, however, and Gaza might be developed for light industry.’ Dr. Mohammad Hallaj says: ‘It would fall into the category of a minor, underdeveloped country.

But no one really knows what’s here. No studies have ever really been made.’… ‘We did not take the Palestinian problem seriously,’ acknowledges one high U.S. official. ‘We thought the Palestinians would be absorbed by neighboring countries.’

That hasn’t happened, and today we realize it is a major key to a solution in the Middle East.

Arabs have claimed that for years. Almost any Palestinian will tell you instantly what he wants: ‘We want our land back.’… Mohammed Esa Dudir, a moderately well-to-do farmer near Hebron, who was born on the West Bank and whose ancestors have farmed land near Hebron for generations, has no vision of what needs to be done.

‘What we need here is peace. We do not want an army,’ he says. ‘What we want is the right to think and act for ourselves.’ He suggests that the West Bank be placed under international trusteeship and totally demilitarized for ‘five or six years’ to learn to get on its own feet. Then he advocates a vote on what should happen next.

‘Maybe we would join Jordan, maybe Syria, maybe neither. I don’t know. But we would like to decide that for ourselves.’”

Five Palestinians named and quoted: two men born in the Beach Camp in Gaza who have never had steady work, two professors at Birzeit, and a farmer near Hebron who wants a demilitarised trusteeship and then a vote. The farmer’s answer is the longest in the piece and the least quoted anywhere since. The feature shares its page with a column on the Anita Bryant campaign in Dade County, an essay on how the word gay changed, and the week’s bestseller list.

CP-1977-008 →

· The News and Advance · Lynchburg · page 1

Israel, PLO In Touch

William R. Frye, Patriot Ledger U.N. Correspondent, United Nations, N.Y.

UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. — There is a certain wry irony about the public postures being adopted by the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) and Israel about negotiations with each other. The fact is that the two already have engaged in arms’ length exchanges, and made some progress toward agreement.

Key Exchanges. The fact of these exchanges has long been known, but their substance has been closely held. They are carefully disavowed on both sides. But they have been far from unimportant. What has happened is that a group of Israeli doves with excellent Zionist credentials, including Maj. Gen.

Mattiyahu Peled, director of the Department of Arab Studies at Tel Aviv University, have met with middle-level PLO officials in a series of talks which began last July in Paris, and continued intermittently thereafter.

In their initial meetings, they agreed on a basis for negotiation: creation of a Palestinian Arab state on the West Bank and in Gaza, with boundaries essentially those of 1967; Jerusalem to remain unified, but with sovereignty to be shared by Israel and the Arab Palestine; PLO acceptance of the 1967 Israel — which is to say, in effect, coexistence of Israel and the PLO.

The Israeli negotiators reported to the government in Jerusalem the fact of the meeting and the initial accord which had been reached. The Rabin cabinet voiced no objection. It could have cut the talk off by calling them “dealings with the enemy,” a serious crime; it did not. Nor did the Knesset, which debated the matter.

No Responsibility. The Israeli government thus permitted the talks to continue. It accepted no responsibility for them, but declined to interfere.

Subsequent meetings, over a period of months, evoked from the PLO side a willingness to state publicly that it would recognize the state of Israel and refrain from hostile action against it, provided Israel would promise to respond favorably to this step. The response would include willingness to negotiate with the PLO on establishment of an Arab Palestine.

The offer was relayed to Jerusalem, and the answer that came back was “no.” Israel has never fully explained the refusal. One reason, however, was doubt about the authority of the PLO negotiators.

The PLO representatives included Said Hammami, the PLO representative in London, and Assam Sartawi, an aide; but it was not clear that they could “deliver” the top PLO leadership, much less survive a challenge from the “Rejection Front,” the PLO group which resists all peace moves…

Controlling Majority. Independent specialists believe a large segment, probably a controlling majority, of the PLO is in fact now willing to coexist with it. The Israeli election in May will determine whether moderates are to be in control of the Israeli government. The Cairo meeting next month may determine whether moderates are in control of the PLO.

Until then, public postures on both sides are likely to be unyielding — and of relatively little long-range significance.

An American correspondent reporting in 1977 that the PLO had offered to recognize Israel and that the answer from Jerusalem was no. Both PLO negotiators are named; Said Hammami was assassinated the following January.

CP-1977-001 →

· The News and Advance · Lynchburg · page 1

West Bank Belongs To Jewish Homeland

Ralph de Toledano

“WASHINGTON — Menachem Begin, whose Likud Party won the recent Israeli elections, was speaking fact when he stated that the West Bank of the Jordan River was ‘liberated’ territory and ‘our land.’ By any reasonable reading of history, the West Bank does belong to the Jews, however convenient pundits and State Department types may find it to ignore the facts… 6.

The Jews sadly accepted the partition, but the Arabs turned it down. Egypt and Transjordan invaded Palestine.

The Egyptians were routed, holding on only to the Gaza Strip which they turned into what has been described as ‘a concentration camp for Palestinians.’… It should be remembered that the ‘legitimate aspirations’ of the Palestinians were satisfied when the British gave them two-thirds of Palestine.

If King Hussein has made them second-class citizens in Jordan, the Palestinian quarrel is with him, not with Israel.”

The maximalist case, printed in an American daily in 1977, in a syndicated column. The argument is numbered, one to eight, from the Balfour Declaration to the 1967 war.

CP-1977-002 →

· Newsday · Melville

The Fragile Right to Be Israel

George F. Will, Washington

“His has been an insistent voice proclaiming Israel’s right to Judea and Samaria—the ‘West Bank’ seized by Jordan in 1948… Israel must express its claims to legitimacy in the West’s shared vocabulary of liberal democratic politics.

Its aspirations must be intelligible to the secular people who could not care less what God promised Abraham.”

A nationally syndicated columnist using Judea and Samaria unmarked and bracketing West Bank — five months before the Associated Press explained to readers that the two names were ideological badges. The column is itself about which vocabulary to use with Americans.

CP-1977-011 →

· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota

Israeli Expansion Could Prove Too Costly

JUDEA AND SAMARIA?

George F. Will, Washington

“His has been an insistent voice proclaiming Israel’s right to Judea and Samaria—the ‘West Bank’ seized by Jordan in 1948… Israel can not seem to be hearing mysterious voices and obeying strange impulses. It must express its claims to legitimacy in the West’s shared vocabulary of liberal democratic politics.”

The same syndicated column as the Newsday printing, the same Monday. Newsday headlined it as Israel’s right being fragile; this paper headlined it as expansion being costly, and put the contested name in a kicker with a question mark after it. This printing is also the longer of the two and keeps sentences Newsday cut.

CP-1977-012 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Torture of Arab Prisoners Reported by London Sunday Times

“Allegations of this nature have been repeatedly put out by Arab propaganda sources in recent years and proved to be totally unfounded in the light of detailed and documented investigations.”

The Sunday Times of London published its investigation on 19 June 1977 and the New York Times reported it the next morning. The quotation here is the Israeli embassy’s statement, and the sentence directly beneath it on the same page is about a benzene fire in Vienna’s sewers.

CP-1977-023 →

· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles · page 1

Show of Artists from Palestine

“A collection of 50 paintings by 11 Palestinian artists will be on public exhibit noon to 8 p.m. Monday through Thursday at Pasadena Civic Auditorium.

Sponsored by the Assn. of Arab-American University Graduates in Southern California, the exhibit, the first of its kind, is designed to present the Arabic art and culture of the Palestinian people to the American public. Two of the artists, Issam Badr and Suliman Mansur, are touring with the exhibit.

Others whose work is represented in the show are: Bashir Sinwar, Ibrihim Saba, Ismail Ashour, Jamal Badran, Nabil Anani, Samira Badran, Vera Tamari, Laila Al-Shawa and Khalil Dadah.”

Eleven Palestinians named in five lines, four of them women, in a listing so short it carries no byline. Two of these names recur in this archive decades later: Nabil Anani builds an upside-down Statue of Liberty in the rubble at Ramallah in 2002, and Suliman Mansur — spelled Suleiman Mansour by every later paper here — has his gallery closed in 1980 and stands outside Ketziot prison in 1988. The sponsoring body is the same association whose 1976 convention the Tampa Times covered in CP-1976-008.

CP-1977-006 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israelis Deny a London Paper’s Charges of Torture

Roy Reed

Several detainees reported similar details about torture and prison — officers have been prosecuted for brutality in the past, and it is Israel’s policy…

Two weeks after the Sunday Times story, the denial gets its own article and its own headline. The paper that is being denied is named; the prisoners are not.

CP-1977-024 →

· The New York Times · New York

Arab Captives in Gaza Say Israelis Beat Them but Don’t Use Torture

Bernard Edinger

“The following dispatch, by Bernard Edinger, was submitted to the Israeli military censors, who requested under Israeli law that 166 words be deleted on the ground that they disclosed army interrogation techniques. The rest is as submitted to the censor.”

The second censorship artifact in this archive, and the more explicit of the two: the Times tells its readers the exact number of words an Israeli censor took out of the story they are about to read, and prints the story anyway. What survived includes a prisoner’s account of a fellow Arab, suspected of collaborating, slowly roasted over an open fire to make him talk. The headline splits the difference the censor left behind.

CP-1977-025 →

· The Boston Globe · Boston

The Mideast's other side: What the Palestinians want

President Carter’s position on the Palestinian problem has been well reported as has that of Israeli Prime Minister Menahem Begin. But what of the Palestinians themselves? The following article, by a member of the National Council and the PLO, sets their views out in detail.

For the first time in 30 years, the United States now has a “Palestine policy.” The Carter Administration no longer perceives the Middle East problem in just two dimensions: normalization of inter-state relations and withdrawal from occupied territories.

Its acknowledgment that the Palestinian problem cries out for a just solution, as an integral part of durable Mideastern peace, provides its vision with that vital third dimension to which previous administrations blinded themselves. At last, America is in step with the rest of the world.

To recognize the existence of a problem, however, is one thing; to prescribe an appropriate and adequate remedy is quite another. The two cardinal elements of President Carter’s “Palestine policy” — namely, a “Palestinian homeland” and “compensation for Palestinian refugees” — are, respectively, ambiguous and deficient.

What does the much-flaunted concept of a “Palestinian homeland” mean? Is that “homeland” to be a “reservation” for Palestinians in a non-Palestinian state? Will it be an independent state in its own right, equal in sovereignty to all other states? Or will it lie somewhere in between? And where will that “homeland” be located?

In Palestine itself or somewhere else? Whether the imprecision with which the “homeland” idea has been expressed reflects the groping of a new Administration for clearer visions or whether it represents a deliberate, tactical ambiguity is not relevant. Sooner or later, equivocation must give way to precision.

Unless the idea is then translated into sovereign Palestinian statehood in Mandated Palestine, this cornerstone of Mr. Carter’s “Palestine policy” will have proved to be neither morally just nor politically useful.

If the ambiguity of the “homeland” concept obscures its potential defectiveness, the concept of “compensation” manifests its deficiency from the start.

By implying that mere monetary compensation constitutes sufficient redress for the injustices which the Palestinians have suffered, the Carter Administration arbitrarily abridges the natural human rights of the Palestinian refugees.

And the call for mere compensation represents a retreat from the established position of the United States Government, which was consistently maintained from 1948 until 1976.

CP-1977-015 →

· estimated · High Point Enterprise

Arabs said to seek PLO, Carter talks

Beirut, Lebanon (AP)—A Beirut newspaper said yesterday “serious Arab efforts” were under way to arrange a meeting between President Carter and the Palestine Liberation Organization.

The weekly supplement of An Nahar, an independent newspaper, quoted unnamed “informed Arab sources” as saying the meeting may take place in New York during the United Nations General Assembly session next month. Officials traveling with Cyrus R. Vance, the U.S. Secretary of State, en route to China said no such meeting had been arranged.

United States policy is to have no dealings with the Palestine Liberation Organization unless it recognizes Israel’s right to exist. Al Mostakbal, another Arabic-language magazine based in Paris, reported that Yasser Arafat, the guerrilla chief, would go to New York for the U.N. session.

Israel refuses to negotiate with the Palestine Liberation Organization, asserting it is a terrorist group dedicated to the abolition of the Jewish state. President Carter has said he supports the concept of a Palestinian homeland, but the United States has said it will not deal with the Palestine organization unless it drops its commitment to destroy Israel.

Date corrected 1974-06-16 to 1977-08. The clipping is a single AP story, 'Arabs said to seek PLO, Carter talks', datelined 'Beirut, Lebanon (AP)' with no day, and the scan carries no masthead or date line; the last paragraph is badly faded. The content fixes the month beyond doubt: it names 'President Carter', has 'Officials traveling with Cyrus R. Vance, the U.S. Secretary of State, en route to China' deny that a Carter-PLO meeting had been arranged, and reports An Nahar's weekly supplement saying the meeting 'may take place in New York during the United Nations General Assembly session next month'. Vance made his only visit to China as Secretary of State on 22-25 August 1977, and the 32nd General Assembly opened on 20 September 1977, so 'next month' puts the paper in August 1977. The filed 1974-06-16 is impossible - Carter was not president and Vance not Secretary of State until 1977. No date is printed on the clipping; the date is fixed by what the article reports, at the precision the evidence supports, and is not guessed beyond it.

CP-1974-012 →

· The New York Times · New York

U.S. LAWYERS SAY ISRAEL TORTURES ARAB PRISONERS

The Associated Press

“Israeli security agents frequently use torture to extract confessions from Arab prisoners from the West Bank of the Jordan River and the Gaza Strip, a group of American lawyers who toured the area said.”

Americans this time, and lawyers, who went and looked. Printed beside the day’s United Nations schedule, in which the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination meets at half past ten.

CP-1977-026 →

· The New York Times

ISRAELI SAID TO URGE MORE SETTLEMENTS

Security Plan Reported to Involve a Major West Bank Influx

JERUSALEM, Sept. 1—An Israeli Government minister has reportedly prepared a security plan for the occupied West Bank that would involve surrounding what are considered to be Arab trouble areas with new Jewish urban and rural settlements.

The plan, which apparently would require tens of thousands of new settlers, has not yet been submitted to Prime Minister Menahem Begin and his Government for approval. According to the newspaper Maariv, it was being completed by a planning team working under the supervision of Minister of Agriculture Ariel Sharon, who is chairman of the Ministerial Committee on Settlements.

The minister, a former general, acknowledged, when reached today in the Parliament cloakroom, that he had a plan but said that he had never discussed it publicly and refused to reveal details at this time.

CP-1977-031 →

· The Cincinnati Post

Letters: Israel’s vanished villages

To the editor of The Post: The series of articles by Polk Laffoon IV about Israel has been, for the most part, informative and objective. But the piece entitled “Golan Heights: Where peace is only a word,” was neither—although Mr. Laffoon is perhaps innocent of any intent to deceive.

While the northern part of Israel beneath the Golan Heights today seems rather desolate, with Qiryat Shemona, Safad, and Rosh Pinna the only sizeable settlements, it was once a livelier place. The change took place in 1948 and after, when the Israeli government began the destruction of hundreds of Arab towns and villages throughout Israel.

El Ja’une, El Khalisa, Dawwara, Ez Zawiya, Saliha, Es Salihiya, Kafr Bir’im, Qadas, En Na’ima and Hunin are some of the Arab towns which once existed in this region which Mr. Laffoon found desolate.

In most cases, everything was leveled and covered over—houses, walls, and even cemeteries, so that no trace remained once the wild flowers and weeds covered the scars in the earth. This was a deliberate effort by the Israeli government to “rewrite” this history of the area.

New Jewish settlers, flowing in from around the world, were not told that they would be living and farming on land evacuated only a few months before by Arabs—who either fled the threat of terrorism or who were later evicted at gunpoint by Israeli soldiers.

History books authorized by the government avoid any mention of the existence of most of these Arab towns, or of official programs leading to their destruction.

CP-1977-033 →

· The New York Times

FIRST ISRAELI COLONISTS MOVE TO WEST BANK SITE

TEL AVIV, Sept. 7—A vanguard of Israeli colonists today quietly moved into Yattir, south of Hebron, in the first step toward carrying out the Government's controversial decision to establish three Jewish settlements in the occupied West Bank. The decision has been criticized by the United States as creating obstacles to peace.

The first settlers at Yattir moved into rangers quarters in a 5,000-acre forest near their settlement site. According to a 20-year plan devised by Minister of Agriculture Ariel Sharon but not yet submitted to the Government for approval, Yattir is expected to be the first of a chain of villages between Beersheba and Aram.

Israel television said tonight the site for the second settlement, at Dehariya, has already been approved. The settlers at Yattir are headed by Eddie Dribbin, a one-time sheep herder from Freedom, Wyo., who will manage a 4,000-acre sheep ranch. He said the first settlers will include about 30 couples with 100 children.

The settlers belong to Gush Emunim, a militant Jewish group.

CP-1977-032 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

West-Bank Voices

By John B. Oakes

RAMALLAH, Israeli-Occupied Jordan—The prosperous Arab businessman sat quietly puffing away at his waterpipe in the garden of a comfortable home overlooking the lights of Jerusalem, a few miles away. “The water supply of this town is desperately inadequate. Even the hospital ran out of water the other day,” he observed.

“The Israelis have laid pipe within a few hundred feet of here and we could easily hook up our system to theirs as they want us to. We need it badly, but the people who run this town are so much under P.L.O. influence that they won’t move—and we’re without water for no good reason. What nonsense — and what stupidity.”

But “the people who run this town,” and virtually every other Arab town in the West Bank, retort bitterly that “if we link our water or our electricity to theirs, that’s just one more step extending Israeli influence and control to the West Bank. We’d rather make do with what we’ve got than give them another foothold.”

When the Israeli Government announced the other day that it intended to extend Israel’s much higher standards of social service to the West Bank as a “humanitarian gesture,” the reaction was equally hostile. Yet, though no Arab will admit it, this is surely one of the mildest military occupations in history. Israeli troops are hardly to be seen.

Arab inhabitants of the West Bank commute freely to work in fields and factories in Israel proper at wages far higher than they could hope to obtain from local Arab employers. A building boom is evident in every Arab town.

Date check: No masthead, folio line or page date is on this clipping — it is a two-column cut of an Op-Ed page column. The tag line at the foot reads “John B. Oakes is Senior Editor of The New York Times.”, which agrees with `pub` though it is an author identification rather than a masthead. The dateline carries no date, only “RAMALLAH, Israeli-Occupied Jordan”. Nothing on the scan confirms 1977-09-09.

CP-1977-030 →

· The Star-Ledger · page 1 (front page), jump to Page 10

Israel agrees to U.S. plan for Palestinians at Geneva

Star-Ledger Wire Services

JERUSALEM — Israel yesterday reversed its stand and agreed to a United States proposal that it meet at Geneva with a unified Arab delegation.

The U.S. proposal, considered face-saving for both Israel and the Arabs, provides for the unified Arab representation at the opening ceremonies and participation by the Palestinians — so long as they are not known members of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO).

If the front-line Arab states also agree to the plan, it could be the first step in making a 1977 Geneva peace conference possible. There have been hints Egypt and Jordan might agree to the American proposal, advanced by President Carter. However, no response was forthcoming from any of the Arab countries.

But the new plan, approved by the Israeli cabinet, drew angry condemnation from a major Palestinian commando organization. The Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, one of the umbrella groups under the PLO, described the initiative as “trickery” aimed at depriving Palestinians of equal and independent representation.

A major facet of the proposal accepted by the government of Prime Minister Menahem Begin was that the Arab delegation could not engage in any negotiations, an Israeli spokesman emphasized. He also said that the plan provided for the talks to divide into separate negotiations between Israel and each of the Arab states.

An Israeli Radio commentator said the plan made the prospects for Geneva look their best yet. But one diplomatic source cautioned: “A lot of water will have to flow under the bridge yet.” In Washington, Israeli Foreign Minister Moshe Dayan confirmed his government's acceptance of the plan.

But he said the reconvening of the conference would be a symbolic gesture in which the Arab delegation would meet Israeli negotiators.

Interviewed on the CBS program “Face the Nation,” Dayan added that the U.S. suggestion had not yet been formally accepted by the Arab states and that, in any event, the proposal “does not include negotiations with the united delegation — it is just the opening of the conference.”

He said the delegations would then depart and subsequent talks would be conducted with the individual countries. The foreign minister denied that by agreeing to reconvene the Geneva conference Israel was softening its previous stand against dealing with a united Arab front or the PLO.

He referred to Begin's recent remarks that Israel would not check the credentials of the Palestinian Arabs at Geneva, but added: “They must not represent the PLO. If they sympathize with the PLO in the bottom of their hearts, we cannot check this.”

Dayan did not indicate when the conference would be reconvened, and State Department officials in Washington declined to comment on the proposal until it is officially informed of Israel acceptance. In Jerusalem, the government spokesman said the plan was approved by the cabinet at its weekly meeting under Begin.

Ten ministers voted in favor and one, strongly nationalist Agriculture Minister Arik Sharon, came out against the plan. The spokesman emphasized that the proposals originated with Carter during talks in Washington last week with Dayan. The Israelis made one condition for acceptance.

This was that there should be no alterations made to United Nations Resolution 242 — the basic Security Council prescription for Middle East peace. In recent weeks there have been proposals to make Resolution 242 more acceptable to the PLO.

CP-1977-037 →

· The Galveston Daily News · page 1, continued on 2-A (“See ISRAEL Page 2A” / “(Continued From Page 1)”)

Israel Agrees On Truce

Palestinian guerrillas and Christian rightists battling near the Israeli border said Sunday they had agreed on a U.S.arranged cease-fire, but reports from the region indicated the truce failed to halt artillery exchanges.

The guerrillas, who launched a deadly mortar barrage earlier in the day from their stronghold in a 12th century Crusader castle, said “Palestinian forces stopped firing at 5 p.m. in accordance with orders from the leadership.”

But a UPI reporter at the scene said a salvo of the Palestinian rockets slammed into the Israeli coastal town of Nahariya after the deadline — the day’s second guerrilla attack on an Israeli settlement. And a Lebanese journalist on the other side of the border said Israeli gunners also ignored the deadline and pounded key Palestinian guerrilla positions in southern Lebanon.

He said Israeli gun emplacements and Lebanese rightist artillery positions inside Lebanon were focusing on the guerrilla stronghold of Khiam and the Palestinian-held frontier town of Rachaya al Foukhar to the northeast. The shelling was answered by steady Palestinian and Lebanese leftist salvos against the rightist border strongholds of Marjayoun and Kleia, the reporter said.

UPI correspondent Mathis Chazanov reported from Metullah, Israel’s northernmost town and a vantage point overlooking the battle zone in southeast Lebanon, that British-built Centurion tanks moved along the frontier.

Troops in U.S.-built armored personnel carriers moved into Lebanese territory where the Palestinians and the Christian forces supported by Israel have been battling for about 10 days, Chazanov reported.

Israeli military censors for the first time permitted journalists to report the armored vehicle drive into Lebanon, but they banned publication of other details surrounding Israeli activity in the area. Israeli radio earlier reported “a cease-fire appears to have taken hold (in Lebanon) among all sides.”

“Presumably it has been mediated by the Americans,” the government-run network said. The truce was aimed at ending nearly a year of bitter fighting between the Palestinians and their Lebanese leftist allies against Christian rightists, who have been able to survive in Lebanon’s southeast corner only with assistance from Israeli artillery.

Lebanese rightists said formal announcement of the cease-fire awaited Israel’s acceptance of the terms. The cease-fire reportedly calls for an implementation of a peace plan drawn up by Syria and endorsed by the Palestinians and Lebanon’s government in July.

It would send in Lebanese army troops to separate the guerrillas and the Christians in the border region and called for Palestinian forces to pull back at least nine miles from the border. Earlier reports Sunday from both Lebanon and Israel indicated the artillery, tank, mortar and machine-gun duels were slackening in the border region.

Israel said it was taking “very seriously” rocket attacks fired across the frontier into its northern settlements. The Israeli newspaper Haaretz said the United States passed a “severe warning” to Syria and the guerrillas that “Israel cannot and will not tolerate” continued shelling.

The Palestinians, who have fired Soviet-made Katyusha rockets into Israeli settlements several times in recent days in apparent retaliation for Israel’s aid to the Christians, are “taking the wrong road,” a senior Israeli government source warned, “because Israel cannot sit with folded hands while its population centers are shelled.” “The artillery and tank fire continues.

It is relatively steady,” a Lebanese reporter in the battle zone said Sunday. “But it has fallen off since its peak Saturday and the level of most of the last week.”

Palestinian guerrillas and Lebanese leftists at Beaufort Castle, a fortress built in 1139 atop a crag in southeast Lebanon overlooking the main battle area, fired mortars across a steep valley into Deir Mimass, a cluster of whitewashed buildings halfway up a slope leading to the Israeli border town of Metullah, the reporter said.

At least eight persons were killed and five others wounded in the mortar fire, he said. “It seems the great majority were civilians.”

CP-1977-038 →

· estimated · The Gazette and Daily · York

‘Everyone has home except Palestinians’

The chicken, rabbit, horse, fish, cat, bird — everybody has a home but the Palestinian. The home of the Palestinian is in Palestine but it is occupied. However, the Palestinian will regain his home through struggle and sacrifice. This is the theme of a popular Palestinian children’s book called “Home.”

Its message is reminiscent of the Jewish people’s great romantic longing through the centuries for a national home. In many respects, the Palestinians have become the Jews of the second half of the 20th century.

They live as dispersed minorities in many countries, stir strong hostility and admiration in their new surroundings, suffer persecution and are bound by an overriding faith in the return to their homeland.

Their driving force, however, is not a religious concept of a promised land but rather a profound sense of injustice over the loss of the land which they have inhabited since neolithic times. It is not a messianic movement like Zionism but rather contemporary nationalism.

The Palestinian question has now been recognized by practically everyone, except Israel, as central to any comprehensive Middle East settlement. It was at the heart of the fighting in southern Lebanon last week and was a principal topic in high-level talks in Washington that seek renewal of peace talks.

There are roughly 2.2 million Palestinians disseminated abroad in addition to 1.5 million still estimated to be living under Israeli occupation. There are the classic refugees, about half a million of them living in camps in Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, the West Bank and Gaza. But the camps are largely dormitories for women and the very young, old and sick.

Most of the men are off working to support their families.

Date corrected 1970-10-07 to 1977-10. No masthead, folio or date line is printed on the scan. The piece is Marvine Howe's (c) New York Times dispatch from Cairo. It quotes Nabeel Shaath on 'the recognition of the Palestine Liberation Organization by many countries since 1974' and on Palestinian university enrolment 'now ... 85,000, or more than double the figure in 1972'; it says the question 'was at the heart of the fighting in southern Lebanon last week and was a principal topic in high-level talks in Washington that seek renewal of peace talks', and that the Arab governments want to keep the PLO 'as an effective fighting force in the event of another war with Israel' - language impossible after the PLO's 1982 expulsion from Beirut. The bank advertisement on the same page reads 'Our lobby will be closed October 10 for observance of Columbus Day'; the second-Monday rule took effect in 1971, and in the window the content allows, 10 October fell on a Monday only in 1977. The filed year 1970 is impossible: the text postdates 1974 throughout. Month and year are fixed at October 1977; the page prints nothing that fixes the day, so the filed day 07 is left as the record has it and is not contradicted. No date is printed on the clipping; the date is fixed by what the article reports, at the precision the evidence supports, and is not guessed beyond it.

CP-1970-006 →

· Edwardsville Intelligencer · Edwardsville

Palestinian Refugees

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — Some 1.4 million Palestinian refugees were registered with the U.N. Relief and Works Agency on July 1, 1969. The largest number, 506,038, were in Jordan. Lebanon had 170,025, Syria 158,717, the Gaza Strip 311,814 and 271,796 no the Israeli-occupied west bank of the Jordan River.

Some 590,000 of the refugees live in 68 camps, the rest in villages and towns. About 40 per cent of the refugees are under 15 years of age. UNRWA, financed mainly by voluntary contributions from governments, had an operating budget of $47.6 million in 1969 and estimated it would need $48.5 million in 1970.

Besides direct relief, the agency runs schools for 200,000 refugee children and vocational training centers.

CP-1977-020 →

· The Birmingham News · Birmingham · page 1

Pressure growing against laxer immigration policies

Dean Reed, News Washington Bureau

WASHINGTON — Pressure is growing for reconsideration of new U.S. immigration policies — particularly a recent law change that allows Communist spokesmen and militant Palestinians to travel and speak freely in the United States. The change occurred when Congress approved a legal amendment sponsored by Sen. George S.

McGovern, D-S.D., upsetting long-standing U.S. immigration policy barring known troublemakers. Now opposition to the McGovern amendment is coming from such Democratic Party leaders as Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan, D-N.Y. Moynihan, for example, says the amendment is “inviting to our country Soviet government agents masquerading as trade union leaders”.

The hard-hitting New York lawmaker referred to a U.S. tour by four Soviet spokesmen in October. The group, Moynihan said, promised not “to engage in controversy” — and then in Pittsburgh said that American unions have fewer rights than Soviet unions.

“A FINE EXAMPLE of what the Soviets mean by reciprocity,” said Moynihan… Meanwhile, the American Jewish Congress is protesting to Secretary of State Cyrus Vance the granting of a visa permitting an officer of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) to “roam the country at will”… At issue is a coming trip by Palestinian Mahmoud Salem Darwish.

When asked about his affiliation with the PLO, State Department officials said the information was confidential and won’t be released except in case of a court trial…

A Washington column on immigration law, and the man whose visa is being protested is named Mahmoud Salem Darwish. This archive holds the poet Mahmoud Darwish being refused a three-day American visa in 1982 under a McCarthy-era clause of the same body of law. Whether the man named here is the same person is not established by this clipping and is not claimed: the middle name does not match the poet’s usual rendering, and the State Department would not say what his affiliation was. What the clipping does establish is the machinery — a 1977 amendment that let Palestinians speak in the United States, the pressure to reverse it, and the same statute still being used to keep one out five years later. The other half of the column is a comic item about a senator trying to find a room to name after Hubert Humphrey.

CP-1977-009 →

· Tampa Bay Times · St. Petersburg · page 1

U.N. report says Israel tortures Arab prisoners

R. M. Sorge, United Press International, United Nations

UNITED NATIONS — Israel frequently tortures Arab prisoners with hypnosis, electric shocks and having “their manliness mocked” by Israeli women soldiers, a special U.N. report charges. The lengthy report released Tuesday by the U.N.

Special Committee to Investigate Israeli Practices drew a bitter denial from Israel, which termed it “biased, false and one-sided.”

Israeli Ambassador Chaim Herzog said the report was based on hearsay and unsubstantiated evidence and charged the committee was, “like all other U.N. committees dealing with Israel, no more than a tool in the hands of Arab propagandists in their unremitting war against the Jewish state.”

The report by the three-member committee said Israeli security agents make “frequent use of torture” when interrogating Arab prisoners suspected of belonging to Palestinian guerrilla groups. Most of the charges were based on testimony by Mrs.

Lea Tsemel, a defense lawyer for Arab prisoners, and reporters from the Sunday Times of London, which published a series of investigative articles on the alleged torture of Arab prisoners in Israeli jails.

But the three members of the U.N. committee — Sri Lanka, Senegal and Yugoslavia — also cited International Red Cross reports of severe overcrowding in Israeli jails and Israeli press reports to back up many of the allegations.

According to one report, published last summer by the Jerusalem Post magazine, Arab prisoners were sometimes “stripped (to) have their manliness mocked by a girl soldier to make them feel small.”

The report said that Israel had refused to cooperate with its investigations and seconded an International Red Cross recommendation that an international commission of inquiry compose of neutral states be established to look further into the matter.

The charge and the denial in the same column, and the news agency names its sources: an Israeli defense lawyer, the Sunday Times of London, the Red Cross and the Jerusalem Post. “Compose of” is the paper’s.

CP-1977-003 →

· Bryan Times · Bryan

12 Palestinians killed in bombing

United Press International

BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — Lebanese newspapers today said a dozen Palestinians were killed in the second Israeli bombing attack on southern Lebanon in three days and some warned of a major attack by Israel within 48 hours.

Earlier Palestine Liberation Organization reports minimized the casualty count in Friday’s bombing and indicated the Israeli jets were driven off by ground fire before they could inflict serious damage. Political sources said U.S.

Ambassador Richard Parker told President Elias Sarkis in a one-hour meeting Friday the United States could not prevent Israel from “exercising its right of reprisal or even its right of pursuit.” But the sources said the United States apparently was not prepared to allow Israeli occupation of south Lebanon.

They said Parker was understood to have advised Sarkis that if rocket attacks on Israeli settlements continued, “a military escalation could follow in which the Lebanese population of the south may suffer heavily.” The independent daily An Nahar and several other newspapers today listed 12 persons killed in the strikes Friday.

The PLO said the strike was aimed at the Palestinian refugee camp at Rashidiyeh just north of the Israeli-Lebanese border. An Nahar said the 12 killed were Palestinian guerrillas and initial hospital reports said at least 14 persons were injured.

The right-wing daily Al Ahrar, in a front-page story, said Israel has warned Lebanon through the American ambassador that unless the Palestinians withdraw completely from south Lebanon, Israeli forces would launch a large-scale attack against the south within 48 hours.

Another rightist daily, Al Bayraq, also said Parker expected potentially serious developments in south Lebanon over the weekend. In the first Israeli bombing in and around the biblical port of Tyre Wednesday, nearly 100 persons — most of them Lebanese civilians — died. The Israelis said the strikes were targeted only at guerrilla military positions.

“After that, you can bet we were ready,” said a PLO spokesman. He said anti-aircraft fire and SAM-7 ground-to-air missiles kept the planes away Friday and forced them to return to Israel. PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat presided Friday night over an emergency meeting of the guerrilla group’s leadership.

The PLO later issued a statement saying the guerrillas were “fully committed” to observing the Cairo and Shtaura accords regulating their presence in the south.

Al Bayraq reported that Arafat told the PLO Executive Committee that Syria’s President Hafez Assad told him: “I shall be very frank with you; either the Shtaura Accord or Israel in south Lebanon. So go back and carry it (the accord) out.”

PLO officials said the success of the guerrillas in driving off the attack on Rashidiyeh, south of Tyre, was due to a full military alert put into effect after the Israeli raid Wednesday. Israeli planes Friday also tried to attack Nabatiyeh in the southeast, but the PLO said they were turned back before bombs could be dropped.

Friday’s bombing attack came after Israel announced that rockets had been fired on the north Israeli settlement of Kibbutz Yiron, about a mile from the Lebanese border. Israeli officials said the planes bombed missile sites after the jets were fired on.

But a Lebanese reporter in the area said the attacking planes at Rashidyeh dropped many of their bombs harmlessly into nearby orange and banana groves and into the sea to the west. One Palestinian group, the Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, quoted witnesses as saying an Israeli plane had been shot down, but there was no confirmation of the report.

Israeli gunners pounded several southwest areas in retaliation for the Yiron rocket attack, which caused no injuries.

Four Lebanese papers are named as sources in one news agency dispatch — An Nahar, Al Ahrar, Al Bayraq — and set against the PLO’s account and Israel’s. The figure from the previous raid is in the copy and not in the headline: nearly 100 persons — most of them Lebanese civilians — died at Tyre on the Wednesday. Directly beneath this story on the page, in type of the same size, a Rotary speaker says education adds opportunities to life.

CP-1977-013 →

· Clarion Ledger · Jackson

Farewell To The Holy Land

Greek Catholic Archbishop Hilarion Capudji kneels on the tarmac of Tel Aviv’s airport after kissing the ground as his last farewell before his deportation from the Holy Land to Rome recently. He had served three years in Ramleh Prison for allegedly smuggling weapons to Palestinian guerrillas operating in Israel.

CP-1977-021 →

· Troy Daily News · Troy

12 Palestinians killed; another attack coming?

United Press International

BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — Lebanese newspapers today said a dozen Palestinians were killed in the second Israeli bombing attack on southern Lebanon in three days and some warned of a major attack by Israel within 48 hours.

Earlier Palestine Liberation Organization reports minimized the casualty count in Friday’s bombing and indicated the Israeli jets were driven off by ground fire before they could inflict serious damage. Political sources said U.S.

Ambassador Richard Parker told President Elias Sarkis in a one-hour meeting Friday the United States could not prevent Israel from “exercising its right of reprisal or even its right of pursuit.” But the sources said the United States apparently was not prepared to allow Israeli occupation of south Lebanon.

They said Parker was understood to have advised Sarkis that if rocket attacks on Israeli settlements continued, “a military escalation could follow in which the Lebanese population of the south may suffer heavily.” The independent daily An Nahar and several other newspapers today listed 12 persons killed in the strikes Friday.

The PLO said the strike was aimed at the Palestinian refugee camp at Rashidiyeh just north of the Israeli-Lebanese border. An Nahar said the 12 killed were Palestinian guerrillas and initial hospital reports said at least 14 persons were injured.

The right-wing daily Al Ahrar, in a front-page story, said Israel has warned Lebanon through the American ambassador that unless the Palestinians withdraw completely from south Lebanon, Israeli forces would launch a large-scale attack against the south within 48 hours.

Another rightist daily, Al Bayraq, also said Parker expected potentially serious developments in south Lebanon over the weekend. In the first Israeli bombing in and around the biblical port of Tyre Wednesday, nearly 100 persons — most of them Lebanese civilians — died. The Israelis said the strikes were targeted only at guerrilla military positions.

“After that, you can bet we were ready,” said a PLO spokesman. He said anti-aircraft fire and SAM-7 ground-to-air missiles kept the planes away Friday and forced them to return to Israel. PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat presided Friday night over an emergency meeting of the guerrilla group’s leadership.

The PLO later issued a statement saying the guerrillas were “fully committed” to observing the Cairo and Shtaura accords regulating their presence in the south.

Al Bayraq reported that Arafat told the PLO Executive Committee that Syria’s President Hafez Assad told him: “I shall be very frank with you; either the Shtaura Accord or Israel in south Lebanon. So go back and carry it (the accord) out.”

The same United Press dispatch as the previous day’s, in another Ohio paper, word for word. The only difference is the headline, which keeps the twelve dead and adds a question about what happens next.

CP-1977-014 →

· The Morning News · page 6

Arab revenge bombs kill 2 in Jerusalem

By ARTHUR MAX

(Editors' Note: This story has been censored by the Israeli military censor.) JERUSALEM (AP) — Two bombs exploded in Jerusalem yesterday, killing two Arab teenagers and wounding five persons in the worst terrorist attack in the city in 18 months.

(In Beirut, the Popular Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a Marxist guerrilla organization, claimed responsibility for the bombings and said they were in retaliation for Israeli air strikes in South Lebanon last week.

(A communique from the PDF said “a special group working inside occupied Palestine planted the timed charge that exploded as planned, killing and wounding several Zionists and inflicting heavy damage in surrounding buildings.”) The first explosion occurred near an Arab school in the Old City's Christian quarter.

The blast ripped through the upper floor of the two-story building, toppling one wall and spewing rubble into the street. A student was killed and four other persons wounded, two seriously, police said. As authorities sifted through the debris for clues, another bomb exploded about three hours later in the Jewish suburb of Talpiot across the street from a nursery school.

An Arab teenager was rushed to a hospital but died of his wounds. Another man was injured. Police and civil guardsmen stepped up their checks of parcels and shopping bags at entrances to public buildings.

In another development, the Israeli military announced that 46 Arabs from towns in the occupied West Bank of the Jordan River had been arrested on suspicion of belonging to five underground guerrilla cells which carried out a string of bombings starting in mid-1975.

A military communique said members of one cell from the town of Ramallah north of Jerusalem bombed four government offices there over a two-year period, while another planted bombs on two Jerusalem buses. The other detainees were from Hebron and Nablus.

The PDF, the Palestinian organization that claimed responsibility for the bombings, has said in Beirut its secret cells inside Israel have been instructed to intensify bomb attacks against Israel in retaliation for Israeli air strikes in southern Lebanon last week.

Israel said it sent jets to attack Palestinian bases after rockets launched from Lebanon killed three Israeli civilians in north Israel. Palestinian and Lebanese authorities said 110 persons were killed and more than 200 wounded in the air strikes.

The wall of a home in the Christian quarter of the old walled city of Jerusalem is reduced to rubble yesterday after a bomb blast tore through the building. An Arab high school student was reported killed and four persons were hurt in the blast. (AP)

CP-1977-034 →

· Fort Worth Star-Telegram · page 4a

2 dead, 5 hurt from 2 bombs in Jerusalem

Editor's Note: This story has been censored by the Israeli military censor. JERUSALEM (AP) — Two bombs exploded in Jerusalem on Sunday, killing two Arab teen-agers and wounding five persons in the worst terrorist attack in the city in 18 months.

In Beirut, the Popular Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a Marxist guerrilla organization, claimed responsibility for the bombings and said they were in retaliation for Israeli air strikes in South Lebanon last week.

(A communique from the PDF said “a special group working inside occupied Palestine planted the timed charge that exploded as planned, killing and wounding several Zionists and inflicting heavy damage in surrounding buildings.”) The first explosion occurred near an Arab school in the Old City’s Christian quarter.

The blast ripped through the upper floor of the two-story building, toppling one wall and spewing rubble into the street. A student was killed and four other persons wounded, two seriously, police said. As authorities sifted through the debris for clues, another bomb exploded about three hours later in the Jewish suburb of Talpiot across the street from a nursery school.

An Arab teen-ager was rushed to a hospital but died of his wounds. Another man was injured.

JERUSALEM BOMB BLAST . . . The wall of a home in the city’s Christian quarter was reduced to rubble by one of two bombings Sunday. [credit: —Associated Press Laserphoto]

CP-1977-036 →

· The Evening Sun · Baltimore · page A7

For Israel, It’s ‘Judea And Samaria’ And Not The West Bank

Sabastiyah, Occupied West Bank (AP)

Associated Press

“Ruins lie upon ruins at Sabastiyah, a Palestinian Arab town with a Greek name honoring a Roman emperor and now administered by Israelis… There are three ways of referring to this disputed area of 2,270 square miles, and each has a different political significance… ‘Don’t call it ‘the West Bank’,’ Prime Minister Menahem Begin admonished reporters after his nationalistic Likud party won last May’s election.

‘It’s ‘Judea and Samaria’…’ ‘This was Palestine until 1948, then it became the West bank,’ a young Arab teacher said in Ramallah. ‘Now we want it to be Palestine again.’ … The 700,000 Arabs of the West Bank have no terms corresponding to Judea and Samaria.

They are more likely to divide the area into ‘the Hills of Hebron’ or the ‘Hills of Nablus’… ‘We love to call our places by their biblical names,’ said Dr. Zeev Vilnay, of Jerusalem, a guidebook author, former soldier and member of the Israeli government place-names committee.”

A whole wire article about what to call the territory, datelined from the town the archive tracks as Sebustiye (1929), Sebastia (2013) and Sebastia/Shomron (2023). It enumerates the three names and what each one means, quotes a prime minister instructing American reporters, quotes the Israeli government’s place-names committee, and quotes a Palestinian teacher. It is the only clipping here that records what Palestinians called the region around them.

CP-1977-010 →

· Daily Breeze · Torrance · page 1

Palestinians are the key to Mideast peace

L. Edgar Prina, Copley News Service, Washington

WASHINGTON — If there is to be peace in the Middle East, it is generally agreed, the Arabs and Israelis will have to solve what is known as the “Palestinian problem” or, more precisely, the “Palestinian refugee problem.” Who are the Palestinians? Where did they come from and where are they now? Who are their leaders?

What do they want and what will they settle for? The answers to some of these questions come easily; to others, with great difficulty, if at all… The vast majority of the approximately 3.4 million Palestinians in the world today live in the Middle East.

Curiously, there are more Palestinians (7,000) in the United States than in Libya (fewer than 5,000)… Although not all Palestinians left — there are 460,000 now living in Israel — many poured into Jordan, the West Bank of the Jordan and the Gaza Strip.

According to latest estimates, there are a million Palestinians in Jordan, 700,000 in the West Bank area and 350-400,000 in the Gaza Strip.

Syria has approximately 250,000 Palestinians; Lebanon 300,000; Egypt only 20,000-25,000; Kuwait, 140,000; other Persian Gulf states 15,000; Saudi Arabia 20,000; Iraq 15,000, and Algeria 5,000. Palestinians are descendants of the Philistines and, ironically, are sometimes referred to as “the Jews of the Middle East.”… It is estimated that about one-third of the Palestinians live in refugee camps run by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency in Jordan, Syria and Lebanon… Palestinians are better educated, in general, than other Arabs in the Middle East.

This is, in part, because UNRWA has provided them with a decent school system. Having a good educational start and faced with the need for better qualifications to compete for available jobs, many Palestinians continued their studies on through the universities.

According to one observer of the area, Edward Mortimer of the Times of London, more Palestinians, per capita, have graduated from schools of higher education than have Arabs from any other nation and as many as citizens of any West European country. “Many of these graduates occupy key positions, especially in the oil-producing states,” he said.

“They are found not only in technical posts but also in administrative ones, in both the private and public sectors, and even in the (Arab) diplomatic services, at the United Nations and in embassies abroad.”

A wire-service explainer that sets out to answer who the Palestinians are, and gets a population figure for every country in the region. It also prints, as fact, that Palestinians are descendants of the Philistines. The paragraph on education is the rarest thing in it: a page of this archive in which Palestinians are being counted for something other than casualties or refugee registrations.

CP-1977-007 →

· The Boston Globe · Boston · page 1

The PLO’s goal is equal rights, say Palestinians in America

“The long-term solution for Palestinians, as uttered by the PLO and all their supporters, has come to be called ‘a democratic secular state’ in what is now Israel, Gaza and the West Bank, where Jew, Moslem and Christian could work out an existence where all had equal social and political rights.

Needless to say, even most Palestinians acknowledge that Israeli military power and policies would make such a solution impossible… There are about 732,000 in the West Bank and about 400,000 in Gaza. The non-Jewish population of Israel is 530,000, and it is overwhelmingly Palestinian.

So about half of all Palestinians are now under Israeli rule… It is believed that 500,000 more live in Lebanon, Egypt and Syria. Of the Palestinians outside of Israel, the West Bank and Gaza, about 640,000 live in refugee camps.”

Palestinians living in the United States, interviewed in an American daily in 1977, saying what they want. The piece counts them: about half of all Palestinians then under Israeli rule, and about 640,000 in refugee camps.

CP-1977-004 →

· Hartford Courant · Hartford

Carter's Palestine Views Criticized by Sadat, PLO

Egyptian President Anwar Sadat said Thursday he was surprised, disappointed and embarrassed by President Carter’s rejection of an independent Palestinian state — “the core and the crux of the whole problem.” He said Carter’s comments would delay a Middle East settlement.

The Palestine Liberation Organization said Carter’s position was an “insult to the entire Arab nation” and hinted at retaliation with terrorism against U.S. targets.

Carter said in a television interview Wednesday, “My preference is not to have an independent state (in the Middle East),” in effect rejecting a key Sadat demand in peace negotiations with Israel. “For sure, I am disappointed,” Sadat said in an interview with CBS television in Cairo.

“For sure, because I should like that we put all our efforts toward ending these Middle East problem. “This will postpone (the solution) for some time because we have to reopen the whole issue (of the Palestinians) again,” Sadat said, sounding weak from his traditional Thursday fast.

“He is making my job very difficult,” Sadat said of Carter’s statements. Sadat said he was not only disappointed, but surprised and embarrassed by Carter’s statement, which also characterized Israel’s proposal of Palestinian self-rule with continued Israeli military presence on the Jordan River’s West Bank as “flexible.”

“This (Carter statement) embarrasses me. What surprises me most, I mean, is ignoring the importance of the Palestinian issue... the core and the crux of the whole problem.” “Without solving the Palestinian question ... we cannot establish peace,” Sadat said. Secretary of State Cyrus Vance moved Thursday to soften Egyptian displeasure.

Vance, speaking to reporters aboard Carter’s plane en route to Warsaw, said the United States did not support the plan as put forward by Israeli Prime Minister Menahem Begin and said only it was “an appropriate starting point” for discussions.

CP-1977-016 →

· West Bend News

PLO ridicules Carter's Palestine stand

The Palestine Liberation Organization today ridiculed President Carter’s renewed support for the “legitimate rights of the Palestinians.” Israeli officials expressed “some concerns” about the term and said “the question is who determines these rights.”

Mahmoud Labadi, spokesman for Yasir Arafat’s PLO in Beirut, said: “Let Mr. Carter tell us where he wants these rights realized — on the moon or on earth.”

He was commenting on Carter’s statement after meeting with Egyptian President Anwar Sadat in Aswan today that there must be a resolution of the Palestinian problem ensuring “the legitimate rights of the Palestinians” as a principle for lasting Mideast peace.

“The American president is still vague and appears to be unaware of what he really wants,” Labadi said. “It does not become a superpower to be unable to formulate a policy on a specific issue. “It is high time for the Carter administration to make up its mind and tell us what it really envisages for the Palestinian people.

“As far as the PLO is concerned, it knows what it wants. We want a sovereign, independent Palestinian state. We shall never give up this right or compromise.” In Jerusalem, government spokesmen said they were waiting for a full report on Carter’s talks with Sadat and the leaders of Iran and Saudi Arabia before issuing a formal statement.

Privately, however, they expressed concern. Carter phoned Prime Minister Menahem Begin from his presidential plane en route to Paris to give a partial report, they said, and a more complete analysis was expected within a day or two.

Israel reacted vehemently the first time Washington subscribed to the term “legitimate rights” in a joint communique with the Soviet Union last September. Israel said then the statement was “unacceptable” and hampered peace.

Meanwhile, a new Palestinian terror group claimed it assassinated another Arab “collaborator” on the Israeli-occupied West Bank of the Jordan River, and that more heads “will soon roll.” The victim was identified as Bajes el Jaabari, a relative of the mayor of the West Bank town of Hebron. The mayor is a staunch foe of the PLO.

Responsibility for the killing was claimed in Beirut by a group calling itself “The November Organization” — for the month of Sadat’s precedent-setting journey to Jerusalem last year. “The heads of other traitors will soon roll in accordance with the death list prepared by the command of the Palestinian revolution,” it said.

CP-1978-014 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

American Woman Jailed In Israel as Spy for Arabs

EDITOR'S NOTE — This story has been censored by the Israeli military censor. TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Terry Fleener, a 23-year-old American convicted of supplying information about the Jewish state to Arab guerrillas, began a five-year prison term Monday.

Miss Fleener, of San Antonio, Texas, confessed during a one-day trial last Tuesday to charges of conveying information to the enemy, conspiring to convey information to the enemy and rendering service to unlawful groups, her attorney reported. Other charges were dropped after she entered the guilty plea.

“It's better than the death sentence,” Miss Fleener said after the closed-door trial. Her Israeli lawyer, Felicia Langer, called the five-year sentence, handed down Monday, “cruel and unbased.” She said she will appeal. “This is not a heavy sentence, compared to the maximum of 15-20 years,” said prosecuting attorney Sarah Sirotta.

“These are offenses which strike at the security of the state. In other countries she would be hanged.” Details of the proceedings were withheld, the customary procedure here in cases dealing with security. Miss Fleener was arrested Oct. 25 on arrival at Israel's Ben-Gurion Airport. In December, U.S.

Embassy officials said Miss Fleener, who is not Jewish, was suspected of intending to photograph military installations in Israel. The indictment alleged she was to gather information in Israel and pass it to a member of an Arab guerrilla organization in Lebanon. Her mother, Mrs. Mary Boettcher of Enon, Ohio, and Dr.

Catherine Edwards, her former professor at the University of Texas in San Antonio, were present at the sentencing and testified as character witnesses during the trial. “She is idealistic, somewhat naive, impetuous, and fiercely loyal to her friends and principles,” said Dr. Edwards, trying to shed light on Miss Fleener's motives.

“She was interested in the Middle East, and very well read. “She confessed in court ... but the sentence does not reflect what she actually did. She didn't hurt anyone,” Dr. Edwards told The Associated Press. Mrs. Boettcher burst into tears after the sentence was read — first in Hebrew, then in English. She said her daughter stood stoically during the sentencing.

Miss Fleener was then taken, under armed guard, to Ramleh prison near Tel Aviv, where she changed her gray-and-white striped dress for prison blues.

TERRY FLEENER . . . .jailed as spy

CP-1978-021 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Woman begins sentence for aiding Arabs

EDITOR’S NOTE — This sto- (EDITOR’S NOTE: This tory has been censored by the Israeli military censor.) TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Terry Fleener, a 23-year-old American convicted of supplying information about the Jewish state to Arab guerrillas, began a five-year prison term Monday.

Miss Fleener, of San Antonio, Texas, confessed during a one-day trial last Tuesday to charges of conveying information to the enemy, conspiring to convey information to the enemy and rendering service to unlawful groups, her attorney reported. Other charges were dropped after she entered the guilty plea.

“It’s better than the death sentence,” Miss Fleener said after the closed-door trial. Her Israeli lawyer, Felicia Langer, called the five-year sentence, handed down Monday, “cruel and unbased.” She said she will appeal. “This is not a heavy sentence, compared to the maximum of 15-20 years,” said prosecuting attorney Sarah Sirotta.

“These are offenses which strike at the security of the state. In other countries she would be hanged.” Details of the proceedings were withheld, the customary procedure here in cases dealing with security. Miss Fleener was arrested Oct. 25 on arrival at Israel’s Ben-Gurion Airport. In December, U.S.

Embassy officials said Miss Fleener, who is not Jewish, was suspected of intending to photograph military installations in Israel. The indictment alleged she was to gather information in Israel and pass it to a member of an Arab guerrilla organization in Lebanon. Her mother, Mrs. Mary Boettcher of Enon, Ohio, and Dr.

Catherine Edwards, her former professor at the University of Texas in San Antonio, were present at the sentencing and testified as character witnesses during the trial. “She is idealistic, somewhat naive, impetuous, and fiercely loyal to her friends and principles,” said Dr. Edwards, trying to shed light on Miss Fleener’s motives.

“She was interested in the Middle East, and very well read. “She confessed in court ... but the sentence does not reflect what she actually did. She didn’t hurt anyone,” Dr. Edwards told The Associated Press. Mrs. Boettcher burst into tears after the sentence was read — first in Hebrew, then in English. She said her daughter stood stoically during the sentencing.

CP-1978-024 →

· Huntsville Times · page 3

U.S. Woman Starts Israel Prison Term

EDITOR'S NOTE — This story has been censored by the Israeli military censor. TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Terry Fleener, a 23-year-old American convicted of supplying information about the Jewish state to Arab guerrillas, began a five-year prison term Monday.

Miss Fleener, of San Antonio, Texas, confessed during a one-day trial last Tuesday to charges of conveying information to the enemy, conspiring to convey information to the enemy and rendering service to unlawful groups, her attorney reported. Other charges were dropped after she entered the guilty plea.

“It’s better than the death sentence,” Miss Fleener said after the closed-door trial. Her Israeli lawyer, Felicia Langer, called the five-year sentence, handed down Monday, “cruel and unbased.” She said she will appeal. “This is not a heavy sentence, compared to the maximum of 15-20 years,” said prosecuting attorney Sarah Sirotta.

“These are offenses which strike at the security of the state. In other countries she would be hanged.” Details of the proceedings were withheld, the customary procedure here in cases dealing with security. MISS FLEENER was arrested Oct. 25 on arrival at Israel’s Ben-Gurion Airport. In December, U.S.

Embassy officials said Miss Fleener, who is not Jewish, was suspected of intending to photograph military installations in Israel. The indictment alleged she was to gather information in Israel and pass it to a member of an Arab guerrilla organization in Lebanon. Her mother, Mrs. Mary Boettcher of Enon, Ohio, and Dr.

Catherine Edwards, her former professor at the University of Texas in San Antonio, were present at the sentencing and testified as character witnesses during the trial. “She is idealistic, somewhat naive, impetuous, and fiercely loyal to her friends and principles,” said Dr. Edwards, trying to shed light on Miss Fleener’s motives.

“She was interested in the Middle East, and very well read. “She confessed in court ... but the sentence does not reflect what she actually did. She didn’t hurt anyone,” Dr. Edwards told The Associated Press. Mrs. Boettcher burst into tears after the sentence was read — first in Hebrew, then in English. She said her daughter stood stoically during the sentencing.

Miss Fleener was then taken, under armed guard, to Ramleh prison near Tel Aviv, where she changed her grey-and-white striped dress for prison blues. MISS FLEENER visited Israel once before, in 1976. It was not clear if the charges against her resulted from activities during that visit or from her actions outside Israel.

Under Israeli security laws, persons can be tried for offenses committed against Israel in other countries. According to her mother, Miss Fleener went to Lebanon in 1975 and spent 1½ years working as a stewardess for Kuwait Airlines, living in Kuwait and traveling throughout the Middle East. She quit that job in 1976, her mother said, and returned to her studies in Texas.

CP-1978-026 →

· The Missoulian

American Gets Five Year Term As Spy for Arabs

EDITOR'S NOTE: This story was released after censorship by the Israeli military censor. TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Terry Fleener, a 23-year-old American woman convicted of supplying information about the Jewish state to Arab guerrillas, began a five-year prison term Monday.

Fleener, of San Antonio, Texas, confessed during a one-day trial last Tuesday to charges of conveying information to the enemy, conspiring to convey information to the enemy and rendering service to unlawful groups, her attorney reported. Other charges were dropped after she entered the guilty plea.

“It's better than the death sentence,” the defendant said after the closed-door trial. Her Israeli lawyer, Felicia Langer, called the five-year sentence, handed down Monday, “cruel and unbased.” She said she will appeal. “This is not a heavy sentence, compared to the maximum of 15-20 years,” said prosecuting attorney Sarah Sirotta.

“These are offenses which strike at the security of the state. In other countries she would be hanged.” Details of the proceedings were withheld, the customary procedure here in cases dealing with security. Fleener was arrested Oct. 25 on arrival at Israel's Ben-Gurion Airport. In December, U.S.

Embassy officials said Fleener, who is not Jewish, was suspected of intending to photograph military installations in Israel. The indictment alleged she was to gather information in Israel and pass it to a member of an Arab guerrilla organization in Lebanon. Her mother, Mrs. Mary Boettcher of Enon, Ohio, and Dr.

Catherine Edwards, her former professor at the University of Texas in San Antonio, were present at the sentencing and testified as character witnesses during the trial. “She is idealistic, somewhat naive, impetuous, and fiercely loyal to her friends and principles,” said Dr. Edwards, trying to shed light on the defendant's motives.

“She was interested in the Middle East, and very well read. “She confessed in court ... but the sentence does not reflect what she actually did. She didn't hurt anyone,” Dr. Edwards told the Associated Press. Fleener visited Israel once before, in 1976. It was not clear if the charges against her resulted from activities during that visit or from her actions outside Israel.

Under Israeli security laws, persons can be tried for offenses committed against Israel in other countries.

Terry Fleener

CP-1978-028 →

· Los Angeles Herald Examiner · Los Angeles · page 1

3 Israeli Settlements On West Bank Approved

Joel Epstein, The Associated Press, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM (AP) — The government won final approval Tuesday for three new and potentially controversial Jewish settlements on the occupied West Bank of the Jordan River.

The go-ahead came one day before Egypt and Israel begin the next stage of peace negotiations… Israeli settlements — about 91 of them scattered across Arab territory captured by Israel in 1967 — are one of the key sticking points in the Egyptian-Israeli peace dialogue, begun by Egypt’s Anwar Sadat last November.

President Sadat has said “not a single Israeli” can remain on Arab lands after peace. Israel’s Begin is equally adamant that the settlements will stay.

Israeli-built apartment buildings, foreground and distant background, in former Jordanian territory annexed to Jerusalem by Israel after 1967 war, will be among considerations in Middle East peace talks. AP Photo.

Ninety-one settlements, counted in a wire story in 1978.

Correction: {'note': 'Slide 11 captions this scan as the Houston Chronicle, 15 October 1980. It reports the foreign ministers’ conference opening in Jerusalem on 16 January and the start of Egyptian-Israeli talks, so it is the 1978 Los Angeles paper.'}

CP-1978-005 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia · page 1

A land so sacred to all who have held it

“‘One day they came to me at the market and told me, “The Jews are working your land.” I went crazy. I stood right here and threw stones at the bulldozer until they made me go away and there was nothing I could do’… ‘They asked me to take money — 3 million Israeli pounds! But I don’t sell my grandfather’s land.

It is my sister. My daughter. How could I sell my land?’… ‘Throwing the Arabs out would be the most humane solution to the demographic problem,’ he said.

‘If we don’t want to be another South Africa with a rule by a small minority, the most humane and life-saving solution would be to put all the Arabs on trucks and carry them outside.’”

The new confronts the very old: The town of Kiryat Arba (foreground) was built in past eight years, across valley from Hebron, a site occupied for 6,000 years. Special to The Inquirer / Gideon Gitai.

A settler proposing removal by truck, in 1978, and naming South Africa as the thing to avoid. The scan is a dense jump page; only passages legible at full resolution are transcribed.

CP-1978-006 →

· The Times · page 1

Israeli Settlements

Map shows many of the 90 Israeli settlements in occupied territories. Israeli settlements are triangles; Arab towns, squares; Israeli towns, circles. Large-scale Israeli settlements are identified by name and/or large triangle.

A map, printed a month after another paper in this archive counted about 91. The legend gives Arab towns their own symbol.

CP-1978-007 →

· Post Star

Israelis Split On Settlements

EDITOR'S NOTE: The Israeli military censor ordered the rephrasing of parts of this story. TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — The Israeli cabinet is divided over whether to press on with Jewish settlement on occupied Arab land, a split apparently widened by American censure of the settlements in recent months, sources reported Tuesday.

The sources said two rival camps have been taking shape lately — one led by Defense Minister Ezer Weizman, who wants to freeze settlement projects, and the other by Agriculture Minister Ariel Sharon, who is calling for construction of many new outposts in the territories.

Weizman has considerable support among the 19 ministers in the cabinet, some of whom were shaken by the vehemence with which the Carter administration has criticized the settlements, the sources said. The debate, which began at a special cabinet meeting Monday, was adjourned until next Sunday, and Prime Minister Menachem Begin remained neutral, the sources said.

The cabinet met as a ministerial security committee — a format from which, under Israeli law, no details may be reported. The split threw into doubt a proposal by the Jewish Agency, which finances the settlements, to build 31 new outposts in occupied land over the next four years. There now are 94 settlements.

If Weizman gets his way, the plan could remain on the drawing boards for a long time. Weizman is known to feel that the establishment of new settlements hampered his negotiations with Egyptian authorities last month for an agreement on the future of the Sinai Peninsula.

He wants to freeze all existing settlements, halt the expansion of outposts in northeast Sinai, where 3,500 Israelis live in a dozen farm communities, and restrict the government to “thickening” settlements in the West Bank of the Jordan River without building new ones, the sources reported.

CP-1978-027 →

· Concord Monitor · Concord

Anti-Palestinian Sentiment Growing In Egypt

“An undercurrent of anti-Palestinian sentiment… A prominent science professor agreed, saying, ‘If Sadat wanted to…’”

Cairo, after the Larnaca raid. An Arab government's public turning against Palestinians, reported in Concord, New Hampshire.

CP-1978-018 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Terrorists Seize Bus In Israel

Editor's note: This dispatch was subject to censorship by the Israeli military censors. TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Arab gunmen who reportedly came from the sea seized a tourist bus Saturday on the main Israeli coastal highway and the bus blew up after a 30-mile ride toward Tel Aviv, police said. Sources said several civilians died in the attack.

No official casualty figure was immediately available. A Tel Aviv city spokesman said 10 persons were hospitalized here. Witnesses said the bus caught fire in a shootout with Israeli troops, but Israeli military censors clamped down on efforts to report further details.

In Beirut, a spokesman claiming to represent Yasser Arafat's Palestinian guerrilla group Al Fatah telephoned The Associated Press and said Al Fatah had carried out the attack. “The enemy forces rushed army and police units to the area,” the caller said. “Our forces managed to destroy completely two trucks carrying a number of Zionist enemy soldiers.”

At least some of the attackers escaped from the bus and were believed to be hiding in the farm fields and coastal scrub seven miles north of Tel Aviv, Israeli radio said. The nationalities and number of people aboard the bus were not known. Police sealed off the area and a search was mounted for the escaped terrorists.

“There were six or seven of them, and they were continually shooting over our head,” passenger Arza Tazor, 24, told reporters. “I remember police breaking the windows of the bus and telling us to jump,” she said. “I jumped.” She was hosptialized in shock.

Israeli radio said the gunmen came by sea and beached at the kibbutz cooperative farm Maagan Michael, 37 miles north of Tel Aviv. The road is Israel's main coastal highway. The radio said the gunmen had fired on passing cars for several minutes before the bus went up in flames.

Air force helicopters were circling the site as ambulances raced back and forth along the highway, witnesses said. The gutted, smoking red bus stood beyond a police barricade on the north-south highway.

FIREMEN HOSES DOWN CHARRED REMAINS OF TOURIST BUS / A firemen hoses down the smoldering hulk of a tourist bus that was seized by Arab terrorists today. The attackers reportedly drove the bus toward 30 miles on the main Israeli coastal road toward Tel Aviv where, according to witnesses, the bus exploded during a gun battle between the terrorists and Israeli troops.

No official casualty figure was available this morning. (AP)

CP-1978-023 →

· The New York Times · New York

Egypt Denounces the Raid as ‘Organized Genocide’

Christopher S. Wren

“An Israeli soldier leads men presumed to be Palestinian guerrillas, captured in Lebanon. The prisoners are blindfolded: pencil marks covering the faces in the photograph were made by Israeli censors.”

An Israeli soldier leads men presumed to be Palestinian guerrillas, captured in Lebanon. The prisoners are blindfolded: pencil marks covering the faces in the photograph were made by Israeli censors.

Read the photo caption, not the headline. The Times tells its readers plainly that the faces in the picture were scribbled over by Israeli military censors before the paper was allowed to print it, and then prints it anyway, marks and all. A record of the censorship survives inside the censored image.

CP-1978-015 →

· The New York Times · page 11

Invasion Focuses Attention on Censorship in Israel

By DEIRDRE CARMODY

The Associated Press received a dispatch from its Tel Aviv bureau Friday describing the military action in Lebanon and saying that a guerrilla rocket had smashed into a residential section across the Israeli border.

A short while later a second message came from the Tel Aviv bureau saying that the Israeli censor had asked that the description be changed from “smashed into a residential section” to “smashed into a house.” It was a reminder that in Israel all news organizations are under military censorship.

The foreign press there must submit all articles, news dispatches, television scripts, photo captions, photographs and film to the Office of Military Censor, where they are scrutinized for sensitive military information. Telephone lines in news offices are monitored by the censors.

The Israeli press is also subject to censorship laws, which have been in effect since the days of British rule. There is a list of subjects that might affect national security and if journalists write on any of these subjects, the articles must be submitted to the censor.

An editor who wants to contest the censor's decision can do so and a special committee is quickly called in to rule on the matter. Israeli officials are sensitive to the charge that they exercise censorship at all and say quickly that military censorship exists only for reasons of security and that there is no political censorship.

However, editors point out that there are times when the line between the military and political can be somewhat obscure. The censorship example from The Associated Press yesterday is not typical because censors usually catch items before they have been transmitted.

An assistant foreign editor of the Associated Press, Edward Butler, commented that he did not know whether the correction had been made because the censor had second thoughts or because more specific information had been received about the rocket attack after the dispatch had been transmitted.

Face of Soldier Blacked Out The Associated Press was also involved in a censorship matter Wednesday, when censors blacked out in a photograph the face of an Israeli soldier holding two prisoners captured in Lebanon. United Press International sent out an almost identical picture some time later in which the soldier's face was left untouched.

“We protested to the censor,” said Hal Buell, executive news photo editor of The Associated Press. “It appears that we were early and then orders changed on the matter.” Television, too, is subject to scrutiny on military matters. The night before Israeli troops crossed into Lebanon a CBS crew shot film of armored vehicles moving north and of troops massing.

The crew members were told to hold the film until after the invasion had begun and had been announced. “We've had a lot of fights with the Israeli censors,” said Sidney Feders, foreign editor of CBS News. “Sometimes the telephone will go dead and the censor will cut in on the telex.” Foreign correspondents view aspects of this as somewhat of a game.

The night before the invasion of Lebanon, a correspondent in Jerusalem was talking with his editor in New York. Suddenly the phone went dead in New York as the censor in Jerusalem cut in and reminded the correspondent about what could and could not be transmitted. The correspondent argued with the censor, meanwhile dialing another phone.

As soon as he had reached New York, he hung up on the censor and continued the conversation with his editor on the other phone. One of the dodges used by correspondents — and presumably recognized by the censors — is to attribute information that might not otherwise pass the censors to “published reports.”

For instance, while the censor will not allow the correspondent to write about the size of the invading force, a sentence saying “foreign press reports placed the combined Israeli forces as high as 20,000” tends to get through.

CP-1978-022 →

· The Daily Record · page A9

Life On Lebanese Border: Rockets, Refugees, Tourists

By JOEL EPSTEIN

KLEIA, Lebanon (AP) — Driving through southern Lebanon behind the Israeli military advance is an eerie experience when you are accustomed to viewing it only through the fence from the other side of the border. For years, Israeli motorists riding near the frontier would watch the barbed-wire fence uneasily for guerrillas who occasionally took potshots at passing cars.

An Israeli acquaintance used to point to a white two-story villa with red pillars about 200 yards inside Lebanon. “Drive fast past that house,” he would say. “Sometimes they aim rocket-propelled grenades at our road.” Now I drive right in front of the house. It is deserted.

The streets of Kleia are empty except for a ragged mob of children waving and shouting “Shalom, Shalom, Israelis!” When we stop, a few men wearing green Israeli army jackets come out of buildings. They call to us in Hebrew. Israeli soldiers? No. Christians who have been supported by the Israelis in the fight against the Palestinians and their leftist Moslem allies.

Sometimes the only way to distinguish between the Christians and the Israelis is by the large crosses the former wear around their necks. Kleia has been at war for two years. A farmhouse has a gaping hole in its red-tile roof. In the front yard where you would expect to find the family station wagon, an armored car is parked.

The Katyusha rocket is a brute of a weapon — big, erratic and devastating when it hits its target. Palestinians fired four or five across the border into northern Israel, killing two Israelis. The Israeli villagers sit in the open, brimming with good humor. “The Katyusha fell — Boom! — like that,” said Tsili Namir, 19.

It blew out the ceiling and smashed the windows of a neighboring house. No one was hurt. Israeli border towns have their trove of miracle stories. Like the one about the family that decided to ignore the air raid warning and stay at the dinner table. A Katyusha crashed through their shelter. Had they been inside they probably would have died.

One woman invited her guests to take tea on the porch. Then they changed their minds because it was chilly, and sat inside. A Katyusha reduced the porch to rubble. The fighting on the Lebanese border is a minor tourist attraction. One busload of sightseers stopped at the fence and the tourists gazed at white puffs of smoke where Israeli planes were attacking.

Some stayed overnight for the experience of sleeping in shelters. “That’s something to write home about,” says one straw-hatted camera-clicker.

CP-1978-029 →

· Daily News · New York

Guerrilla gestures excitedly during interview near former Palestinian stronghold

Guerrilla gestures excitedly during interview near former Palestinian stronghold.

An Associated Press photograph printed on its own, with no accompanying story on the clipping. The man was interviewed. Neither his name nor a word of what he said is printed. The masthead reads only Daily News and the city is unconfirmed.

CP-1978-012 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Torture, They Said

Monroe H. Freedman and Alan M. Dershowitz

“Like other Americans concerned with human rights, we have been deeply disturbed by reports of systematic…”

Two American law professors answer the torture reports in the New York Times. One of them is Alan Dershowitz, twenty-three years before he argued publicly for judicially supervised torture warrants. The archive keeps the earlier position next to the headline it was written under.

CP-1978-016 →

· The New York Times · New York · page B1

The Storm Over the Negev: Bedouins of Israel Are Victims of Progress

WILLIAM E. FARRELL, Special to The New York Times

ABU TULUL BEDOUIN ENCAMPMENT, Israel—After miles of travel over an ill-defined series of ruts and little gullies that the locals call a road, a traveler’s eyes, suffused with the stark unending desert landscape, catches sight of a modest garden and an even more modest orchard with apples, figs and almonds.

Near this pleasing bit of green in a surrounding of alkali white are the crushed remains of a house, a surrealist jumble of cinder blocks, twisted iron window grates and a mash of household items.

The house was the home of a Bedouin tribesman and his family until mid-May, when it was bulldozed by order of Israel’s Green Patrol, created a few years ago to police the Negev. The force totals only a dozen men who work under Minister of Agriculture Ariel Sharon, a hero of the 1973 war known for hawkish views and bluntness.

The demolished Bedouin house is one of 45 dwellings—block houses, goatskin tents and hovels—razed in recent weeks by the Green Patrol with the explanation that they had been erected illegally on land marked for industrial development.

The action by the patrol has provoked a storm of protest in Israel over tactics and has focused attention on a minority group, the Negev Bedouin, whose presence in the desert dates back to 636 A.D.

Land problems regarding the Bedouins are old and complicated, involving deeds or the lack of them and claims by the tribesmen that their historic presence in the desert is in itself a right to the land. For many years, these issues simmered below the surface because the lands of the Negev were not regarded as having much value.

That changed as the Israelis set about transforming parts of the desert into farms, industrial areas and towns.

The destruction of Bedouin houses in Israel, like those in Abu Tulul, left, has focused attention on a national minority that has roamed the Negev desert for more than 1,300 years. [credit on the lower photograph] The New York Times/Micha Bar-Am

Date check: DATE AND PAPER CONFIRMED ON THE PAGE. The section front carries the full nameplate “The New York Times” with “TUESDAY, JUNE 20, 1978” and “Copyright © 1978 The New York Times” at the left, and the page slug “L+ B1” at the right. This matches both `pub` and the slide-label date of 1978-06-20, which was a Tuesday.

CP-1978-019 →

· The New York Times

4 SLAIN IN PAKISTAN IN A RAID ON P.L.O.; IRAQIS SUSPECTED

Terrorists With Submachine Guns and Grenades Hit Islamabad Mission of Palestinians

By Reuters

ISLAMABAD, Pakistan, Aug. 5 — Four armed men broke into the Palestine Liberation Organization’s office here today and killed four persons, bringing Arab-against-Arab terrorism to this country for the second time in four days. The assailants, carrying submachine guns and grenades, murdered a radio operator for the P.L.O., two Palestinian students and a Pakistani police guard.

Palestinian witnesses said the assailants spoke an Iraqi dialect of Arabic. All four raiders escaped and a police search was started. P.L.O. Aide Accuses Iraqis The chief representative here of the Palestine Liberation Organization, Yousuf Abu Hantash, who was unhurt, declared: “This is the responsibility of the Iraqi regime.”

In Beirut, Lebanon, the P.L.O. headquarters charged that Iraqi intelligence agents had carried out the assault, the latest in a deadly exchange between the P.L.O. leadership and Iraqi-backed radicals that has has brought violence to Beirut, London, Paris, Karachi and now Islamabad.

Iraq, which proclaims a hard line on the issue of Israel, accuses the leaders of the Palestine Liberation Organization of a conciliatory attitude, especially in considering a compromise settlement that would include formation of a Palestinian state in the Israeli-occupied West Bank of the Jordan. 2 P.L.O.

Officials Slain in Paris On Thursday, two P.L.O. aides were killed in Paris when Arabs burst into their office hurling grenades and firing submachine guns. … [JUMP OF THE MATCHED ARTICLE — this is the part that merges into CP-1978-020:] 4 Murdered at P.L.O.

Office in Pakistan in New Round of Arab Feud Continued From Page 1 was killed outside the office when he demanded that the four open bags they were carrying.

A Palestinian described as second secretary of the P.L.O. office, Majed Abu Shama, described the attack: “I was in the reception room downstairs with a Palestinian student when one of the gunmen burst in and fired off a complete magazine, killing the student. I was sitting opposite and I don’t know how the gunman failed to see me.

He went outside to change his magazine.” The other Arabs then killed the radio operator and rushed upstairs to search for the head of the office, Mr. Hantash. He was in another building at the time. As the assailants fled, they threw a grenade that killed another Palestinian student.

First Round Began in January Four senior officials of the P.L.O. have been killed in Arab violence this year. The organizations’s London representative, Said Hammami, was murdered in January. In June, the P.L.O.’s representative in Kuwait, Ali Yasin, was shot to death.

Two days ago, two Arabs attacked the P.L.O. office in Paris and killed its chief representative in France, Ezzedine Kalak, and his deputy, Adnan Hammad. In the Paris attack, the French police charged that Iraqis opened fire on the Arab assailant after he had surrendered and was being taken to a car.

A French detective and an Iraqi guard were killed in the shootout and three Iraqis, who claimed diplomatic immunity, were expelled from France. [END OF THE MATCHED ARTICLE. Below is a SEPARATE Reuters story printed on the same clipping, under its own headline and dateline.

It is closely related — it is the Paris funeral of the two men named above — but it is not part of CP-1978-020 and should not go into its excerpt.] Arabs Cry for Vengeance PARIS, Aug.

5 (Reuters) — Hundreds of mourning Arabs cried for vengeance today when the flag-draped coffins of two slain officials of the Palestine Liberation Organization were bome from a Paris mosque. “With our souls and with our blood, we shall avenge you!” chanted Palestinians and other Arabs.

The coffins, covered with Palestinian flags, were carried out of the mosque to trucks for a procession through the streets of Paris before being flown to the Middle East for burial. Mr. Kalak will be buried in Syria and Mr. Hammad in Beirut.

Iraqi Regime Called Instigator At the funeral service, the top surviving P.L.O. official in Paris accused Iraq of being behind the killings.

Ibrahim Souss, head of the P.L.O. mission at the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, told mourners: “There is no doubt whatsoever that the cover, support and encouragement for this act came from an Arab state that pretends to be a friend of the Palestinian revolution.

We consider that the sole responsibility for the acts of the Abu Nidal gang lies with the Iraqi regime.” The two assailants held in the killing told French investigators their orders had come from a Palestinian extremist leader, Abu Nidal, who broke with the P.L.O. and moved to Baghdad.

Assailants Face Death Penalty The two were charged today with premeditated murder, which carries a possible death sentence. They were identified as Hatem Abdul Kadir, 25 years old, and Kayed Hassad, 21, both Jordanian nationals believed to be of Palestinian origin. Ambassadors of Arab countries attended the funeral service at the mosque in the Latin Quarter of Paris.

The new Iraqi Ambassador, who arrived yesterday, was absent. He declined to speak to reporters on his arrival. Iraq has denied any involvement in the killings. French sympathizers with the Palestinian cause, mainly young leftists, joined Arabs in filing past the coffins. Guerrilla battle songs and cries of “Yahiya Falestin!”

(“Long Live Palestine!”) rang out during the service. [PHOTOGRAPH across the top right of the page, with credit and caption:] United Press International Fists raised, mourners carried coffin of Ezzedine Kalak at Paris funeral for leader of the branch office of the Palestine Liberation Organization, who was slain by two terrorists Thursday along with an aide. [Two further columns on the clipping carry wholly unrelated wire stories — “Crane Begins Presidential Drive With a Visit to New Hampshire” (BEDFORD, N.H., Aug.

5, AP) and “Pentagon Plans 6-Month Review Of Study on Closing of 9 Bases” (WASHINGTON, Aug. 5, AP) — plus a “HELP THE FRESH AIR FUND” notice. Not transcribed; nothing to do with Palestine.]

CP-1978-020 →

· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis

E. Jerusalem Guides Probed For PLO Propaganda

Jewish Telegraphic Agency

TEL AVIV (JTA) — Security forces are investigating complaints from tourists that some of the guides from East Jerusalem are propagating Palestine Liberation Organization propaganda and turning tourists against Israel. The complaints were received by the Commerce Ministry’s Tourism Dept. and turned over to the security services.

According to reports, it is possible that hundreds, if not thousands, of tourists handled by East Jerusalem tourism contractors and operators were subjected to PLO propaganda by their guides. There is concern that many of the tourists may have left Israel with distorted information about the country.

Following the investigation, a top level decision is expected regarding East Jerusalem tourism operations.

The whole item is seven sentences and it needs no gloss. A Palestinian guide in East Jerusalem describes the city he lives in to visitors; a tourist complains; the Tourism Department passes the complaint to the security services. What is under investigation is a man talking about where he is from.

CP-1978-010 →

· Jackson Citizen Patriot · Jackson

Camp David accord ignores Palestinians

Ibrahim Abu-Lughod

“The Camp David accords concerning the disposition of Israeli-occupied Sinai and the Palestinian areas of the West Bank and Gaza are not the first Arab-Israeli ac… It would have been more prudent for President Carter to pay close attention to the Arab national consensus and to inspire accords that would be consistent with it.”

A Palestinian professor of political science at Northwestern, writing in a Michigan daily three weeks after Camp David, and named as Palestinian in the editor’s note. The archive holds very little from 1978 and almost nothing in which a Palestinian academic addresses American readers directly about a treaty signed on their behalf.

CP-1978-017 →

· Johnson City Press-Chronicle · Johnson City · page 3

Students from Middle East discuss problems of peace

By BILLIE FARTHING, P-C Staff Writer

(EDITOR'S NOTE: Last week staff writer Billie Farthing, who covers East Tennessee State University news for the Johnson City Press-Chronicle, talked with several foreign students with roots in the Middle East about recent progress toward peace in that area.

Participating in the discussion were Abdul Al-Shari, Saudi Arabia; Mohamed Bakir, Palestine; Raja Choucair, Lebanon; Raad Saleh, Iraq; and Janet Abboud, Jordon, who was interviewed separately because of a schedule conflict. Bob Cohn, a ETSU photographer and member of the local Jewish community was also called on to give his views of the prospect for peace.

Cohn lived in a kibbutz in Israel for several months in 1972 and '73. It should be pointed out however, that the views of these students are not meant to be a representative view of their nations, but are their personal opinions and are printed here as such.) Q: What is your opinion of the Camp David accords? Do you believe they will lead to peace in the Middle East?

Al-Shari: “The Middle East has experienced war for about 30 years and now they are ready to experience peace. But peace is going to take some time . . . I hope Sadat will succeed if he gets a guarantee that the Arab rights will not be ignored.” Choucair: “The result, apparently, is a good step, but the biggest problem wasn't even touched yet.

The Sinai problem really wasn't a big conflict . . . but when you've had a conflict for over 30 years you can't solve it just like that; you have to go step by step. So if they practice and do what they talked about and signed for, that's good. But I'm not very optimistic . . . There have been many talks, but no action . . .

It doesn't seem to be a big problem in Egypt, the people seem to welcome it in general, but it seems it might be a problem in Israel . . .”

Bakir: “Ever since 1948 since the Palestinians were kicked out of Palestine and they formed the Palestine Liberation Organization . . . there was always the question asked the United Nations, why did they have to kick the Palestinians out of Palestine? Why couldn't they let the Jewish people live with the Palestinians? . . .

And now that's what they're coming up with right now, the question has come up again. Can they live, Palestinian and Israeli people, in one country? . . . Most probably if there is an agreement, most people will go for it because the people in Israel want peace, the Palestinians living in Israel . . . they all want peace too. None of them really want to fight . . .

They'll probably come up with some good solutions for all sides. If they did it might not last long; it will probably last two, three, four months, five months, I don't know. It might all blow up again.” Cohn: “I was quite elated for the prospect of peace.

I think it took courage among the three leaders and I think it is going to take courage on both sides, the basic people, to make a decision in which way they really want to go. If they really do want peace, if they can really live together.

And of the Arab side of that I think they are going to have to realize the Israeli people are going to be there from now until doomsday and I think if the people accept that the Israelis are going to be there maybe they can work together . . .” Saleh: “I believe there will be no peace until the Palestinian people enter the negotiations with them.

The main thing is the Palestinian people because that is their own land over there and Mr. Sadat or Mr. Carter or Begin, they can't decide about these people until they bring them into the negotiations with them . . .”

Abboud: “I don't agree with them (the Camp David accords) for the reason that first of all, they didn't settle the key issues of the Western Bank and the Gaza Strip . . . You see the people of Europe and the United States, they fail to understand that it is not really an Arab-Israeli conflict. It is an Arab-Israeli conflict but the key issue is the Palestinian problems . . .

In my opinion, if they fail to give them a homeland in the occupied territory of the Western Bank and Gaza Strip, I don't think there will ever be any peace. And by homeland of course it's not meant to give them autonomy . . . The Camp David peace accords, it is very ambiguous, their statements about the West Bank . . .

It says the future of the Western Bank will be determined by letters between President Carter and Menachem Begin in future months . . . these are key issues and the Camp David peace talks don't touch on these key issues . . . It is not a comprehensive settlement, that's what I have mainly against it.

As far as peace, I think we are all willing for peace, everybody in the area is sick and tired of war. And I think there is area for everyone to be accomodated, Jews as well as Arabs . . .” The initial questions led the group to discuss the Palestinian problem. Choucair: “Now, about the Palestinian problem. What is going to be their future: what's going to be their destiny?

Who is going to decide?” Bakir: “They just want to live in peace. Live and let live. They want to be left alone . . . No one would like to be kicked out of their own homes or fields they've been farming for generations and generations but that is the way some people feel. And that's the reason it might not last . . .

Most people living on the Gaza Strip are Palestinians, partly Egyptians, but mostly Palestinians. But they have been living there since 1948 under control . . . There are so many Palestinians living in Palestine, living in Israel . . . The Palestinians don't like living in Israel because, let's say a bomb explodes in a movie theatre or something or a bus.

They go up and stop every Palestinian, start searching their cars, start going to their homes looking for weapons. Every Palestinian, I'm talking about everybody . . . They pick them up, start putting them in lines . . . if they want to go from one city to another they have to be searched. They are prejudiced against them; they call this security.

Whether there's somebody guilty or innocent, he's in it . . . See, nobody likes to be treated like a dog.” Cohn: “From what I know, some of the Arab people working and living in Israel are better off economically. I'm not sure about the other part of it. I think the Israelis want to coexist with the Arab peoples, maybe I'm wrong but I would hope so.”

Choucair: “Okay, you are right about some people who are working there and are mixed in the society, but not all of them by choice.” Cohn: “There's always going to be division because there is not peace and as soon as peace is there I think the barriers will break down . . . It's the same thing in American with the black people and the white people.”

Choucair: “No, it's completely two different situations.” Bakir: “Blacks have rights here. It's two different situations.” Cohn: “Yeah, but they (Palestinians) don't have their rights because they don't have peace.” Bakir: “Okay, I'll give you an example. If a Palestinian girl gets raped they get the police. The police will ignore it, the whole situation.

They'll probably pretend to be looking for whoever raped the girl, but if it turned out later on to be an Israeli that's got influence, he'd be dismissed because the Palestinians there are considered low class because they're controlled by the government.” Choucair: “They keep talking about human rights.

During the French revolution the French people decided about their human rights and what liberty meant to them themselves. Same thing for the American revolution. So I think the same way should be for the Palestinian people because any country, the Arabs, anybody, can't decide for them because they are the people and that's their problem.

But they should define what's their human rights . . .” Bakir: “They didn't even ask if they would accept or something.

All they did in 1948 was France, England, Russia and the United States and the organization of Jewish people that was formed during World War II to help other Jewish people from Hitler, they got together, they felt pity for the Jewish people and they decided to give them land of their own . . . They were supposed to have just the part around the Mediterranean Sea only.

But greediness during 1948 drove them to take over the whole country and they kicked the Palestinians to Lebanon, Syria, Jordon and Egypt.” Choucair: “An example of a living together, just take before 1948. The eastern Jews who were living there and are from Palestine and the Palestinian people were just living like you and I and anybody else.

Then of course, that miserable Hitler started and that's what created that sympathy for the Jewish people. You have a people who were persecuted, to get out of that persecution, persecuted another people. Okay, I feel sorry for the Jewish people, Hitler was a killer, but it doesn't mean to help that people you go and kill another people.”

Abboud: “As a Palestinian I really think the Jews have a right to the area. (within the Israeli borders prior to 1967) I don't think the Jews should be killed or expelled from the area even if we were capable of doing it, even if we had the power to do it I don't think we should. People here think all the Palestinians want to drive the Jews out and we hate them.

We don't hate them, we think they have historical rights in the area. We think they have the same rights as us. I believe the Jews should be given security. They should be given safe borders. But I do believe there should be a Palestinian homeland. I think a Palestinian homeland could be accomodated in these occupied territories (West Bank and Gaza Strip).

If Israel is willing to give this land back . . . This is a question of people who were kicked from their land in '48 and they are not going to be quiet about it. There is no way. Look at Israel. Israel has succeeded in creating a homeland after 19 centuries.”

The discussion turned to the Palestine Liberation Organization when Cohn asked the group who spoke for the Palestinians in the occupied territory. Al-Shari: “The PLO is now the representative of the Palestinian people . . . If you want a representative of the Palestinian people, they are the representatives.” Cohn: “How did the PLO become the representative?”

Choucair: “It's like George Washington became the leader of the Revolution. It is a reflection of the situation.” Cohn: “Is it possible for the Palestinians to come up with an organization that Israel would accept? It is like asking the Jewish people to talk to Hitler about peace.” Choucair: “How can you make that kind of comparison? You can't do that . . .

Hitler wasn't making a revolution. Hitler was making a war, was the agressor.” Al-Shari: “If Hitler was so terrible to the Jews, the Palestinians shouldn't have to pay the price for that. What did the Palestinians do?”

Cohn: “The refugees and Arab people living in Israel and occupied land now are really getting the bad end of the stick because I think the average person there would really like to coexist. But at the same time, perhaps they shouldn't let the PLO make their voice for them . . .

Let's say the PLO is dissolved, perhaps people could elect their own leader that is not a symbol of violence to the Israelis and yet these people that could be elected could speak for the refugees and work closely with the Israelis. What is the solution if the Israeli people, rightfully, I think, will not talk to the PLO?”

Choucair: “Because you might have a leader who might have his own interests and it doesn't mean because he is a leader for now that he is going to lead or present their general opinion . . .” Bakir: “If there's a leader and they don't like the leader, they'll not accept him . . . if he doesn't want to get off they'll kick him off.”

Abboud: “I really think the Camp David Treaty is going to have more troubles in the area because the Palestinians are really desperate people and what they call terrorism is really a result of this desperation of these people who have been homeless for so many years . . . I don't approve of terrorism. I really don't, but I see why terrorism is created.

After all, Begin himself was the leader of a terrorist organization. Of course here, in the Western press because it is so prejudiced, they always say, 'well, he was a nationalist,' or a hero. He was a leader of a liberation. It's a matter of definitions . . . I don't see the difference between what he did and between what the Palestinians are doing now.”

Al-Shari: “If you go back to who introduced violence in the Middle East the people who introduced violence were the Jews when they came from Germany . . . Begin was the one that led his army to massacre people . . . If we look back through history we will see so many black points but now we are looking for something new, the Israeli who wants peace . . .

He will accept the Palestinians . . .” Q: Do you believe Sadat was correct in attempting to make a separate peace with Israel? If peace between Israel and Egypt is achieved, how will that affect the other Arab nations? Choucair: “Basically, and for this moment, that agreement will help directly only Egypt and Israel, and no body else.

Especially Israel because it is going to loose the tension on their borders. You see, when they put Egypt out, then they don't have to worry about it. In case of war, even for the first air attack, they are stronger now because they have one less front to fight . . . See, if you want to be realistic now, let's suppose we don't want to call Sadat a traitor or anything.

He just wants to do something for his country, which sometimes probably you can't blame someone who's desperate. They've had problems for years and years. His country is poor. He says, you know, 'if I can get something out of it, I'm going to do it.'” Cohn: “Don't you think that's the only step he has right now, to do what he's doing?” Choucair: “It's not the only step.

But this is one of the choices. But that's going to keep the others probably out, especially if that step doesn't go through.” Al-Shari: “But if the aim of this treaty is to divide the Arabs from the eastern part, that the Arabs will not fight, I think this would be a big mistake.”

Abboud: “I could understand Egypt's drive for peace because it's a country having a population explosion, their economy is sagging and this money they are giving for the military they could spend it on other important things . . . But I think he (Sadat) should have waited and tried to have more collaboration with the other Arab countries.

But I do understand his motives, I don't really condemn him. I don't think he is completely wrong. I have visited Egypt and seen the poverty there. Even King Hussein, who is a very moderate monarch who cracked down on guerrillas and violence . . . he objects to the treaty.

Here is a king who is ready to have peace and has a very moderate stand . . . he has objected to the treaty because it fails to decide on the key issues of the Palestinian question . . .” Q: What about the ambiguity concerning the fate of the city of Jerusalem? Saleh: “The main thing I think is that the Israel government does not want the Palestinian people in Jerusalem.

They want their temple because it is special for them and this is impossible because the Arab Moslems and Arab Christians, they believe more than the Jews in Jerusalem. And they also want to go over there and pray.” Cohn: “Are they being stopped now?” Choucair: “I don't think any Arab applicant for a visa to Israel would get one.

And I don't think that he would dare go anyway.” Cohn: “At this point the whole city of Jerusalem is being run by the Israeli government but at the same time, aren't all faiths allowed to go to the city and pray?” Al-Shari: “What is the way, under occupation? If I'm praying under the gun of an Israeli soldier? How can I pray? I can't accept that.”

Choucair: “The problem now is not religion. We lived with the Jews and Christians more than 1,300 years. The problem is nationalism and vanity. Now what's caused the problems is nationalism . . .” Q: And Carter's role in the peace talks? Choucair: “Personally, among those three leaders, I really admire Jimmy Carter's step because that was very courageous.

He might not be a genius politican but he sure is a person that cares and has some morality. And that's something very rare in a politician . . . I think he is probably the best United States president in the last decade. Because he cares . . . because he had to deal with two extreme sides where each one is probably stubborn, especially Begin . . .”

Bakir: “See, Carter is the second president, the first was Kennedy, that faced Jewish control of the United States. And that is why he is admired very much outside the United States, especially by the Arabs.”

Abboud: “I really think that President Carter is interested in peace in the area, there is no doubt about that, but I think he was so desperate to succeed in the Camp David talks because it would boost his popularity here . . . I think he has a personal objective also. I think he wants to be re-elected in 1980 . . .

But I really doubt, I genuinely doubt that any peace is going to be in the very near future after this treaty . . . I don't think there will be peace, at least not soon.” Choucair: “One thing you can be sure was done. An Israeli and an Arab leader met each other face to face. That had never happened . . .

I'm not really sure they are going to accomplish everything they signed for, but it was a good step.”

Raja Choucair, left, and Abdul Al-Shari. Staff Photo by Alan Broyles

A transcript of a discussion at East Tennessee State University three weeks after the Camp David summit, printed with the students' names attached to their words. Of the six people at the table one, Mohamed Bakir, is identified as Palestinian; Janet Abboud, listed as Jordanian, speaks of herself as a Palestinian and was interviewed separately. The page also carries a separate staff report on the summit itself. The paper's spelling of Jordon is kept.

CP-1978-013 →

· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha · page 1

Four Million Palestinian Refugees ‘Alienated, Dispossessed, Amputated’

Weekend Focus · Other Comment and Opinion

Hatem I. Hussaini, acting director, Palestine Information Office, Washington DC

The paper’s own introduction: “Americans generally have read and heard more about the Israeli point of view than about that of the Palestinians. Supporters of the Palestinians have contended that their side of the story has not been adequately told.

In answer to this, The World-Herald sought out the writer, acting director of the Palestine Information Office in Washington, D.C., who provided this commentary.” And then the writer: “In the United States, very little is known about the Palestinian people.

The American media has either ignored them or reduced them to distorted and stereotyped images of violent and destructive terrorists. Thus, the American public has little knowledge about the historical tragedy of the Palestinians, their persecution and exile, their present dispersion and suffering.

Of all the nations of the Middle East, the Palestinians, approximately four million, are stateless and homeless. While every people enjoy security, freedom, and national rights in their own state, the Palestinians remain in ‘refugee camps,’ alienated and dispossessed, a whole nation amputated and scattered in different states and continents.”

The same newspaper Sara Pahl writes to in 2018 asking why it carries no coverage. Forty years earlier it went looking for a Palestinian to write for it, printed him at the top of the page with a map, and ran his office address in the byline. The page is dated Oct. 22, 1978, 17-B.

CP-1978-001 →

· Wilmington Morning Star · Wilmington · page 1

Soviets, Arabs attack Nobel Prize decision

Associated Press

“Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin, co-winner of the 1978 Nobel Peace Prize with Anwar Sadat, said Saturday he telephoned the Egyptian president to congratulate him and the two agreed that ‘real prize is peace itself.’ New bitterness over the award emerged in some world capitals.

The Soviet news agency Tass printed 600 words of international commentaries that variously described the Norwegian Nobel Committee’s decision as an ‘insult,’ ‘a bad joke’ and an ‘outrage.’ Begin, who had withheld comment until after the Jewish Sabbath, said in Jerusalem he was deeply honored to receive the award.

‘It is a day of joy for us,’ he said. ‘But the real great joy will come on the day when i will be able to announce that the peace treaty between Egypt and Israel is concluded, signed and ratified.’

Sadat, at a villa outside Cairo, said the honor went to the people of Egypt and all who have supported his peace initiative… Begin said he would receive the prize in the name of the Israeli poooople because ‘there is no other nation on Earth that wants peace more than our people.

I am only the addressee.’… The Soviet Union has made no direct comment except for Foreign Minister Andrei A. Gromyko’s remark in Paris dismissing the award as ‘a joke.’

The Tass compilation of critical commentaries included one report saying the Nobel Committee could have awarded the prize ‘with equal success’ to Nazi dictator Adolf Hitler and British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain, who negotiated the Munich pact, which Chamberlain said would bring ‘peace in our time,’ a year before the outbreak of World War II.

In Damascus, Syria, the government-run radio said: ‘It is not an honor for Sadat to share any prize with an anti-Arab terrorist like Menachem Begin.’ A Palestine Liberation Organization spokesman in Damascus said the award comes ‘while Begin is still an aggressor against Palestinian land and rights, while Sadat is Begin’s partner.’

The Algerian government-controlled newspaper El Moudjahid commented, ‘At first sight, one wonders whether to denounce a scandal or a practical joke.’ Describing the two prize-winners as ‘warmongers par excellence,’ the front-page editorial accused them of seeking ‘the disappearance of Palestine and the genocide of the Palestinian people.’

It described Begin as ‘the terrorist leader ... assassin of women and children and perpetual arsonist of the Middle East,’ and Sadat as ‘he who betrayed his people and the entire Arab nation, who denies the existence of the Palestinian people.’”

“Prime Minister Begin — ‘a day of joy for us’” · “President Sadat — an honor for the people of Egypt”

The word “genocide” reaching an American paper in 1978 as a quotation from an Algerian editorial, printed without comment alongside the Nobel announcement. “Poooople” is the paper’s typesetting.

CP-1978-002 →

· Los Angeles Herald Examiner · page A-12 (jump page); the opening column's own page number is not in the crop

Mideast Professor At UCLA Considers Possibility of Peace

Dr. Malcolm Kerr is a professor of political science at UCLA, specializing in the Middle East. He was born and raised in Lebanon and wrote “The Arab Cold War: Gamel Abdel Nasser and His Rivals.” Kerr was interviewed by staff writer Darrell Walker.

Question: If Israel and Egypt sign a peace treaty as a result of the Camp David Summit, will the other Arab countries negotiate with Israel? Kerr: That's the $64 question, and nobody knows. I think the prevailing sentiment in most of the Arab world is no.

There is a lot of anger against (Egyptian President) Sadat on the part of the people in the other countries that would have to make peace with Israel — plus the Palestinians, who are the core of the conflict. Q: What would the Palestinians' reaction be to a separate peace? A: This is very complex, because the Palestinians are scattered in various places.

The Palestine Liberation Organization is the closest and they have to be a representative organization. And the PLO will resist the Camp David accords, because (the accords) shut them out. The PLO sees (the accords) as being entirely at its expense, and at the expense of Palestinian national rights. Q: Is Israeli Prime Minister Begin correct in refusing to deal with the PLO?

A: “Correct” is a subjective word. It's a matter of political judgment, and a matter of what your objectives are. Since the PLO has been an active and prominent organization over the last 10 years, the standing policy in Israel has been not to deal with them. It goes back much further, actually.

If you go all the way back to the beginning of Zionist settlements in Palestine — which takes us back a whole century — there has been a systematic avoidance, partly conscious, partly unconscious, of coming to grips with Palestinian national representatives. They have uncomfortable claims to confront Israel with, or to confront the Zionist movement with.

DR. MALCOLM KERR Sees ‘anger against Sadat’

CP-1978-030 →

· The Atlanta Journal and Constitution · Atlanta · page 14-B

Palestinian Dance Performance Turns Into Political Event Here

By Mary Jo Padgett, Journal-Constitution Dance Critic

“A performance by the Palestinian Folk Dance Troupe on the campus of Emory University Friday night turned into a political event. A crowd of Jewish demonstrators marched and protested outside the Woodruff Medical Center Auditorium, where the performance was held.

Because of the confusion and some parking problems, the evening began late, but to a full house in the 500-seat auditorium.

Greetings were made by Omar Latouffe, president of one of the sponsoring Emory organizations, the Council on Arab-American Relations, and a short speech was made by the group’s U.S. sponsor, Abdulla Wajeeh, professor of math at the University of Michigan, who spoke about the Palestinian problem on ‘60 Minutes’ several weeks ago.

Wajeeh reaffirmed the dance troupe’s respect for the Jewish, Christian and Islamic heritages, ‘heritages which all blend to make the heritage of the Palestinians.’ Once the performance began, one realized that since 1948 politics have also become a heritage of the Palestinians.

Their songs, all sung in Arabic, and their dances speak of displacement, ‘the ruler’ and the desire to return to the home land. The troupe was composed of about 25 Palestinian orphans who live in a boarding school in Beirut. After opening at the Kennedy Center in August, they have traveled to about 25 universities and communities around the country.

After the Atlanta performance they will dance in New York and then return home. The native costumes were simple and several of the musicians had on military camouflage outfits. A feeling of familiarity with fighting and death from fighting was woven throughout the songs and dances. Bagpipes were a part of the music, not an instrument often associated with the Arabic culture.

The girls wore simple white dresses or brightly embroidered black overjackets over trousers. The male dancers wore black full pants with white shirts. All had on boots that emphasized the stamping that is an integral part of the dancing.

Contrary to many folk dances where either the men or women do most of the dancing and the fancy steps while the other claps and looks on, the Palestinian dances are very democratic. The boys and girls did the same steps, there were no real show-off moments for anyone in particular. The dances are a group effort equally shared by male and female.

Singing is inherent in the dancing. The dancers sang, which required strong lungs, and a group of singers stood to the side of the stage and sang as well. The music of trumpet, accordian and drum were the usual accompaniment. The evening ended with a skit-dance about a Palestinian wedding.

It reflected much of the Arabic culture in the women’s calls to the people to come celebrate and in the various solos that described the excellent properties of the bride and groom. A bride, all dressed in white, came on stage with two candle bearers and sat while the wedding party members danced in celebration.

Someone finally called from the audience, ‘Where is the groom?’ Shortly, four boys in military outfits came to disrupt the celebration and announced that the groom had been killed in guerrilla warfare.

After an appropriate singing of sad songs, the bride rushed off stage and returned in military garb, saying she would avenge her fiance’s death by joining the guerrilla movement. Folk dances are often the best reflection of the essence of a group of people.

For the last 30 years, more than the lifetime of the dancers we saw, fighting and displacement have become the culture of the Palestinians.”

A newspaper’s dance critic reviews twenty-five Palestinian orphans from a boarding school in Beirut, and files the only piece in this archive that treats Palestinian performance as performance. She notices the choreography: the Palestinian dances are very democratic. The boys and girls did the same steps, there were no real show-off moments for anyone in particular. She notices the bagpipes. The troupe’s American sponsor tells the audience the company respects ‘the Jewish, Christian and Islamic heritages, heritages which all blend to make the heritage of the Palestinians.’ The closing number is a wedding. A bride in white comes on with two candle bearers, the party dances, and then somebody in the audience calls out asking where the groom is. Four boys in military dress arrive to say he has been killed. The bride leaves and comes back in military clothes. The critic’s last sentence is the review: For the last 30 years, more than the lifetime of the dancers we saw, fighting and displacement have become the culture of the Palestinians.

CP-1978-011 →

· The New York Times

Arrest of 15 on West Bank Raises Crackdown Issue

By WILLIAM E. FARRELL

RAMALLAH, Israel-Occupied West Bank, Nov. 26 — The recent arrest or detention of 15 West Bank residents opposed to the Camp David accords has raised the question of whether the Israeli military administration is cracking down on Palestinian Arabs opposed to a transitional civil-autonomy plan for the West Bank and Gaza.

Eight students at Bir Zeit University, a focus of Palestinian nationalist sentiment, have been summoned to military headquarters in the last few days, according to university officials. Four of the students are still being detained. Five residents of Ramallah, a militantly Palestinian town, were arrested Thursday and Friday and are still being held.

Two more were arrested early today. The wives of two of the five said in interviews yesterday that their husbands had been taken by soldiers in postmidnight house searches and had not been told the charges against them.

Based on interviews here, the arrested men have several things in common — they oppose the civil-autonomy plan, they have connections with a social club called the Orthodox Club and all favor the creation of a Palestinian state. Military authorities have also canceled a number of lectures at Bar Zeit recently that were expected to be critical of the autonomy plan.

The lectures were part of a special school program called “Palestine Week” that emphasized Palestinian nationalism, folk art and customs. Reaction to the Autonomy Plan The Israeli military spokesman’s office said today that the seven Arabs in Ramallah were arrested because they were “suspected of terrorist activities and not because of their views on the autonomy plan.”

No other details were provided. Lisa Taraki, a socialist on the faculty of Bir Zeit, said in an interview that the main purpose of the detentions was “to find out how the students feel about the autonomy plan and Camp David — who’s speaking out against it and who is for it.”

Two students who said they had recently been detained by the military authorities and who asked for anonymity said they had been questioned at length about the autonomy plan and the mood on the campus concerning it. They also said they had been beaten.

Miss Taraki, who has kept a chronology of the detentions, said the three students still under administrative detention were Rizziq Shuqair, Hakam Qadri and Rivhi Aruri. A fourth student, Mahmoud Ahmed Halasseh, was also being detained. Prof.

Wasif Abboushi, a political scientist who is an American citizen, said three people who had been ordered not to give their planned speeches on the autonomy plan during “Palestine Week” were Suleiman Bashir of Jerusalem, Bashir Barghouti, a leftist editor of a West Bank Weekly called Talia, and Haidar Abdul Shafi of Gaza, a trustee of Bir Zeit. Dr.

Abboushi, who said he opposed the Camp David accords, accused the Israeli military administration of harassing Bir Zeit and of trying to quash opposition to the autonomy plan for the 1.1 million Palestinian Arabs of the West Bank and Gaza.

The plan was agreed upon by Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin and Egyptian President Anwar el-Sadat at the Camp David summit talks in September. The plan calls for a five-year transition in which the present military administration of such things as health, education and welfare would be replaced by an Arab administration.

However, for security purposes, Israel would retain a military presence in the territories captured during the 1967 war.

The seven arrested in Ramallah are Sami Sima’an, an electrician; Mahfouz Yousef Kahwoush, who works in the military administration health ministry and is a part-time insurance broker; Ghattas Bousheh, an account for a Ramallah charity; Yousef Jubeh, who runs a bookstall in Ramallah; Nicola Dabit, a public school teacher; Adel Samarra, a bookstore owner who has written against the Camp David summit, and his brother Omar.

All but Omar have connections with the Orthodox Club, which has links to the Greek Orthodox Church in this heavily Christian Arab town. The Wives Descriptions The wives of two of those arrested, Mary Kahwoush and Margaret Bousheh, were interviewed in English yesterday. Mrs.

Bousheh, who held an infant swaddled in woolens, said about 10 soldiers came early Thursday morning and took her husband. They searched the house, and “he asked them ‘why are you here’ and they said you don’t have to know.” She has retained a lawyer, she said, but so far he has been unable to talk with her husband.

She said her husband was not a political activist but that, like the others, he aired his disenchantment with the autonomy plan at Orthodox Club gatherings. “He was expressing his feelings,” she said. “He declared his rejection of Camp David.” Mrs.

Kahwoush gave a similar account of her husband’s arrest, adding that he spoke “frankly of his opinions” but that he was not a militant activist. “We have a very normal conventional life,” she said. “I can’t think of any reason why they’d take him. It was a big shock.”

A member of the staff of the Arab newspaper Al Fajr in eastern Jerusalem said that no mention of the arrests had been made in the local Arab press because the military censor had forbidden it. After the Camp David summit meeting, the Israeli military administration on the West Bank lifted its ban on political gatherings.

But regulations were tightened again because the rallies that were held were adamantly opposed to the autonomy plan and highly critical of the Camp David summit mmeting.

CP-1978-025 →

· Duluth News-Tribune · Duluth · page 1

U.N. Assembly again links Zionism to racism

Associated Press, United Nations

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — The U.N. General Assembly voted three times Saturday in favor of a declaration that links Zionism with racism. Zionism is the movement backing Israel as the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.

Israeli delegate Ilana Ben Ami told the assembly its actions revived “the tendentious formula of 1975” when it passed an Arab-authored resolution calling Zionism “a form of racism.” “For the people of Israel, in the same way that Judaism cannot be divorced from Zionism, anti-Zionism cannot be divorced from anti-Semitism,” she said. The assembly votes centered on a declaration of the U.N.-sponsored World Conference to Combat Racism and Racial Discrimation held in Geneva Aug.

14-15. The resolution spoke of “increasing relations between the Zionist state of Israel and the racist regime of South Africa” and accused Israel of “racial discrimination” against the Palestinians. The United States, which boycotted the Geneva conference, did not participate in the assembly voting. U.S. delegate Richard W.

Petree said nothing had occurred to change the U.S. position.

The sentence in the middle of this dispatch is the whole of the later argument, spoken on the floor of the General Assembly in December 1978 by an Israeli delegate: anti-Zionism cannot be divorced from anti-Semitism. Thirteen years before the resolution was repealed and thirty-seven before an American paper ran it as a headline. The Kansas City Star ran the same dispatch the same day and cut that sentence out. The paper spells it Discrimation.

CP-1978-008 →

· The Kansas City Star · Kansas City · page 1

Zionism Again Given Racism Label by U.N.

Associated Press, United Nations

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — The U.N.

General Assembly voted three times Saturday in favor of a declaration that links Zionism with racism… Israeli delegate Ilana Ben Ami told the assembly its actions revived “the tendentious formula of 1975”… The General Assembly, acting on a recommendation of its social committee, took these actions: Voted 107-18 with 11 abstentions to approve the conference declaration.

Voted 101-19 with 15 abstentions for another resolution endorsing the declaration and asked for a study the idea of establishing an international voluntary fund to help “national liberation movements in their struggle against racism and apartheid.” The Palestine Liberation Organization, which has observer status with the assembly, presumably could request money from such a fund. Voted 98-21 with 16 abstentions for a provision “welcoming” the declaration. When the Geneva conference passed the Israeli-South Africa declaration, 12 countries walked out.

They were the nine European Common Market members, Britain, Ireland, Denmark, Belgium, the Netherlands, Luxembourg, France, West Germany and Italy, along with Australia, Canada and New Zealand. They cast “no” votes Saturday. The United States boycotted the Geneva conference and did not participate in the assembly voting.

The same dispatch as the Duluth News Tribune, with all three vote counts kept and one sentence removed: the Israeli delegate’s line about anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism. This version also records that the United States boycotted a United Nations conference on racism, which it would do again at Durban twenty-three years later.

CP-1978-009 →

· The Lima News · Lima

3 Palestinian bases in Lebanon attacked by Israeli warplanes

Two papers carried this on 20 December 1978 and they disagree about what was hit. Here it is 3 Palestinian bases, which is a count and a category. A Canadian paper the same day called them Lebanon Guerrillas — people rather than places, and a word that supplies its own justification. Both name Israel.

CP-1978-003 →

· The New York Times · New York

Dayan warns Arabs in Israel and the territories

“Mr. Dayan warned in a speech before an American and Canadian delegation of fund raisers for Israel that Arabs living in Israel and the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip risked expulsion if they actively sided with the P.L.O.”

Moshe Dayan, to a room of fundraisers. The threat is addressed to citizens and to people under occupation in one breath, which is the clearest statement in this archive of how little the distinction protected anyone when it mattered.

CP-1979-026 →

· The New York Times

SIX ARAB STUDENTS IN ISRAEL CONFINED

Ordered to Remain in Homes After Distribution of a Leaflet That Supported P.L.O.’s Goals

TEL AVIV, Jan. 26 — Israeli authorities, concerned over a recent increase in guerrilla activities, have ordered six Israeli Arab students suspected of circulating a leaflet supporting the Palestine Liberation Organization to leave Jerusalem’s Hebrew University and return to their homes.

They also announced that an Arab group in an occupied West Bank village that was responsible for 10 terrorist attacks in the Jerusalem area had been broken up. Orders issued by the Israeli Army were delivered to the students last night requiring that they remain in their homes in the evenings and report twice daily to the nearest police stations.

The Government, in order to avoid going through the court system, invoked an emergency regulation held over from the British mandate period in Palestine that permits army commanders to issue administrative orders limiting personal freedom for security reasons.

The leaflet supporting the P.L.O., which was reported to dispute indirectly Israel’s right to exist, was issued in the name of the Progressive Nationalist Movement, an Arab student organization of which the six students are members.

Education Minister Zevulun Hammer, denouncing the leaflet in Parliament this week, said, “A citizen who does not recognize the state or one who supports a violent struggle against it cannot enjoy its good services.”

A woman participating in a leftist demonstration in Tel Aviv is roughed up by an opponent. The demonstrators were demanding an end to what they called persecution of Israeli Arabs who support the Palestinians.

CP-1979-034 →

· Honolulu Advertiser · Honolulu · page 1

Are Israelis guilty of systematic torture? Perhaps, U.S. reports cautiously suggest

Perhaps, U.S. reports cautiously suggest · Three Arabs tell tales of brutality and humiliation

T. R. Reid and Edward Cody, Washington Post Service

“Are Israelis guilty of systematic torture?

Perhaps, U.S. reports cautiously suggest. WASHINGTON — Amid the routine flow of cable traffic that came clattering through the State Department’s teletypes last May 31 was a confidential message from Jerusalem that opened a new chapter in the old debate over charges that Israel violates the human rights of Palestinian prisoners in Jerusalem and the occupied West Bank… ‘Jerusalem 1500’ concluded: ‘Israeli torture of Arab prisoners in the occupied territories may be a widespread and even common practice.’

In an ensuing cable on Nov. 30, 1978 — this was Jerusalem 3239 and classified ‘secret’ — the consulate reported on 14 more cases and drew the more severe conclusion that: ‘Physical mistreatment is systematically used on many Arab security suspects interrogated in the West Bank.’ It seems clear from the research of Ms.

Johnson that… Israeli practices on the West Bank go beyond acceptable civilian norms…

Three Arabs tell tales of brutality and humiliation. CHICAGO — Elias believes he understands just what the State Department means in the 1979 human rights report by ‘instances of mistreatment.’ He says he learned all about it during a month of questioning, beating and torture by Israeli interrogators on the occupied West Bank.

Israel insists that brutality by interrogators is forbidden by Israeli law and that any violations are punished. Elias disagrees.

The way he tells it, his education on the subject began when three Israeli security officers, backed up by armored cars and soldiers in the street, entered his family’s house about 1 a.m., tied his hands behind his back, threw him face down in the rear of a Land Rover, and drove him off to prison.

It ended, he says, about 30 days later — after a bottle was shoved up his anus twice, after he was twice hung naked in the ‘meat locker,’ his feet off the floor and his hands tied to steel hooks in the wall while interrogators beat him on the back, legs and genitals or squeezed his testicles.

Finally, he broke and confessed to what the interrogators wanted ‘just to be able to stand my body.’ ‘Man is only flesh and blood,’ he said in an interview here. He turned away his eyes with a short nervous laugh. ‘I told them what they wanted.’

Elias’ treatment at the hands of Israeli interrogators is one of 29 such cases in Jerusalem and the occupied West Bank that make up the body of two classified cables from the U.S.

Consulate in Jerusalem… All are identified by nicknames or abbreviated versions of their names because of their fears that relatives still in Jerusalem or the West Bank could suffer reprisals… Abu Raad, 32, a Palestinian, says he still suffers stomach pains, digestion trouble and cramps in his right leg because of what was done to him during two weeks of interrogation… Samih, a 1975 graduate of the American University of Beirut, also got to know Abu Ariel, Johnny and Abu Jamil, three interrogators whom Abu Raad had mentioned.

He was arrested in April 1976 and taken to the Russian Compound for interrogation… That was the first of many such sessions, he said, sometimes at the rate of eight a day and at other times once every few days.”

Three Palestinians describing what was done to them, and the paper explaining in its own voice why none of them is fully named: their relatives in Jerusalem and the West Bank could suffer for it. The Israeli position — that brutality is forbidden and violations are punished — is in the same paragraph as the first account.

CP-1979-001 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

Israel Denies Torture of Arabs

JERUSALEM, Feb. 7 — The Israeli Government emphatically denied today that Arab political prisoners were being tortured in Jerusalem or in the West Bank. In a broadcast tonight, Justice Minister Shmuel Tamir invited international jurists and representatives of “fair and neutral countries” to see for themselves.

The Minister said that the International Red Cross was in constant touch with Israeli authorities and had access to administrative detainees here but that Amnesty International had not yet been invited to inspect conditions here.

He also said that United States Congressional committees, American judges, lawyers and “people of standing” would be welcome if they wanted to study prison conditions here. The American Consulate General here has been embroiled in controversy on earlier occasions because his jurisdiction covers East Jerusalem and the West Bank.

Israeli politicians, officials and newspapers have accused the Consulate at times of pro-Arab bias and meddling in domestic Israeli affairs. The United States Consulate General here is in touch with United States citizens of Arab extraction who live in the occupied territories, and occasionally is in contact with mayors of West Bank towns and other local dignitaries.

“We are urging Arab notables to take part actively in the peace process in the spirit of Camp David,” an American official said.

Date check: No masthead or folio line on this clipping — it is a trimmed single column. Below the headline stands the credit line “Special to The New York Times”, which agrees with `pub`; at the foot, below a rule, runs the Times’s standing house line “DO NOT FORGET THE NEEDIEST!”, which is also characteristic of the paper. The dateline reads “JERUSALEM, Feb. 7”, consistent with publication on 1979-02-08, but no year appears on the scan. Printed the day after a Honolulu paper published the State Department cable concluding that torture may be a widespread and even common practice. Both are in this archive, one day apart.

CP-1979-028 →

· The New York Times

Colony for U.S. Jews Is Approved by Israel

TEL AVIV, Feb. 7 — The Israeli Government approved the establishment today of a colony of American Jews in the Hebron area of the occupied West Bank.

The decision, made by the ministerial settlement committee, was not formally announced, but an official said that the colony would be an urban center to be called Efrat and that it would serve the cluster of Jewish settlements in an area called the Ezion block. The site will be on the eastern side of the Bethlehem-Hebron Road.

Rabbi Solomon Rivkin of the Lincoln Square Synagogue in New York was said to have recruited more than 100 settlers for the new community. Construction of the first 100 houses will begin in the next fiscal year, which starts on April 1.

CP-1979-031 →

· Des Moines Register · Des Moines · page 1

Writers

Sahar Khalifeh

“Sahar Khalifeh is a Palestinian novelist. Her book, ‘Assubbar (Cactus),’ is being translated into English at Georgetown University. It is a story of life on the West Bank in the early 1970s. She is completing her third novel, ‘Aabbad Ashams (The Sun Flower).’

In this excerpt, two women have been thrown into the same jail cell.… Tears stood in Khadra’s eyes. She said, ‘At least, Saadia, you have somebody who cares for you. But for me, mercy on me and my luck. I have no one except an old man and instead of offering me help he increases my burden.

I ran away from the first, God tear him to pieces — he used to beat me like hell. I ran away. I thought, I’ll relax, but what’s the use.

I told you, we run from suffering, and where we think we’ll have refuge we only have more suffering.… I married another and thought he could support me and would keep me from having to serve in people’s houses, from stealing and prostitution. He turned out to be sick. Instead of him feeding me, I feed him.

The poor man, his heart is sick, he has attacks in which he faces death. I feed him and take care of him and buy him medicine. He is warmhearted, his tongue is sweet, he calls me Khadra, The Princess. From him, I’ve heard words I’ve never heard before.’ ‘You know, Saadia? No one can bear what’s in a broken heart except broken people like us.

My husband is as old as my father, but he is kind. My father was kind too, until my mother died. After that, he became a wild horse. Whenever one of us said, “Father, I’m hungry,” he would begin beating us all like hell… you don’t know what beating does. When you are beaten the first time, you keep silent. The second time, you keep silent.

The third time, you might say, “Savior.” A new light comes in your eyes. You roll up your sleeves and sharpen your teeth and begin biting left and right.’… ‘So, then I learned that the beating which you do not give back is more painful. Even the one who beats you, when he realizes that you can face him, he begins to fear you and be on his guard.

And you, if you take revenge and beat him, his beating will not hurt you. It hurts, but not so much as when you keep suffering in your heart and your spleen swells up. By God, Saadia, this is life.’”

An American daily gives most of a page to a Palestinian woman’s fiction, with a studio portrait, under a standing head that reads Writers. The excerpt is about two poor women in a cell talking about their husbands. The occupation is not in it. A year later the same novelist appears in this archive in the Baltimore Sun, spelled Kalifeh, describing how an Israeli government pamphlet cited her as evidence of the freedom she was being allowed.

CP-1979-008 →

· Des Moines Tribune · page 7

Treaty or not, Palestinian issue remains bedeviling

“I must diet,” she said. “The best diet is to be in jail. I lost 11 kilos in jail last year. I am under house arrest now. If I go out of the house, they claim I am inciting. They will put me in jail. It might be good for my diet. No, I have been last year in jail. Once is enough.”

“Have you spoken to Arafat about the peace treaty?” she was asked. “Why me? It is Carter who should speak to Arafat. Carter should look at Iran and then he would know he should speak to Arafat. Your Mr. Carter, the prophet, should go directly to Arafat. He speaks for all Palestinians.” Which was not thoroughly accurate.

Sometimes, the Palestinians do not talk to themselves. Later in the day, in Bethlehem, which was a grim town, with soldiers standing on rooftops in the rain and truckloads of troops at roadblocks, the home of the former mayor of the city was pointed out as an illustration of the troubles among Palestinians.

The Palestinian Christians, who live in the town of Bethlehem, do not speak to the Palestinian Moslems who live in the refugee camp at Bethlehem. The former mayor, Bandak, a Christian, went beyond this; his animosity toward the Moslems was extraordinary and the Moslems were always eager to return it.

Bandak then stole much money as mayor and bought land directly across the street from the entrance to the refugee camp. He built an expensive stone house and atop the house placed a high television tower. Running down the tower, in the kind of letters used to advertise cigarettes, is the name “Bandak.”

Across the street in the refugee camp, everytime a Moslem raises his head he must see Bandak's name. Then, when he left office, Bandak had the City Council name the street in front of the refugee camp “Bandak Street.” Each time a Moslem leaves the refugee camp, he spits at the sign that says he lives on Bandak Street.

CP-1979-039 →

· The New York Times

Arab-Americans Attack Treaty Over Issue of Palestinian Rights

By IVER PETERSON

DETROIT, March 22 — North America’s largest Arab-speaking community here in Detroit does not respond to the proposed Egyptian-Israeli peace pact any more favorably than the leaders of Saudi Arabia and Jordan did to the Administration’s recent efforts to enlist their support for it.

From the immigrant slums of Dearborn’s industrial South End to the trim middle-class enclaves of Southfield, Arab-Americans see the treaty as fatally flawed by not being specific enough on Palestinian rights. “Don’t call it a peace treaty,” said Edward Ajlouni, an attorney, “because I honestly don’t think it will result in peace.

The problem will continue until the Palestinian people can return to a country they can call their own.” … No One Criticizes Carter “Maybe it will make peace,” said Chafik Hassein, a steelworker at the Ford Motor Company’s River Rouge plant.

For him, as for other recent arrivals, the tension and sporadic fighting in the area were an encouragement to emigrate. Their fresh memories of the uprooting may account for their yearning for peace. “Here everybody can live together,” added Mr. Hassan, 27 years old. “Maybe they can learn it from President Carter.”

CP-1979-035 →

· The New York Times · New York · page A3

As Israel’s Military Turns to Negev, Treatment of Bedouins Sets Off an Outcry

By JONATHAN KANDELL

LAGIYA, Israel, April 10 — With the signing of the Egyptian-Israeli peace treaty, the vast redeployment of military installations from Sinai to the Negev is about to begin and has spurred fears about Israel’s treatment of its Bedouin population.

During the last decade, well before a Sinai withdrawal was imaginable, the Israeli Government had already undertaken efforts to relocate the 35,000 Negev Bedouins to a half-dozen “townships” to facilitate the development of the desert’s agricultural and industrial potential.

But the situation has acquired a new urgency because of the $4 billion program to build up military installations in the Negev in the next three years.

In the last week, the simmering conflict with the Bedouins exploded with an attempt by Israeli police forces to bulldoze a large Bedouin family off their property in this small agricultural community about 10 miles north of Beersheba.

The incident brought a rebuke against the Government by the Supreme Court, which ordered the Israeli authorities to remove all equipment from the area and show cause by the end of the month why farm lands belonging to the Bedouins had been expropriated for the construction of a township.

The court ruling has annoyed military officials because it threatens to delay the transfer of installations from Sinai. And the Israeli opposition, centered on the Labor Party, has called an urgent session of Parliament to demand an explanation from Prime Minister Menachem Begin and his Government.

The “Lagiya affair” began last Wednesday morning when Salah Abu Karen, a 32-year-old Bedouin farmer, two of his brothers and an uncle were summoned at 7:30 A.M. to the police headquarters in the nearby town of Arad.

While the Bedouin men were at the police station, other Israeli policemen and Government workers arrived on their property and, without a court order or other legal permit, began to clear a 100-yard swath of fence and land to make way for a road. When the Bedouin women tried to drive away the bulldozers with stones, the police beat them.

The next day, the police and bulldozers were back, and the women were beaten again when they tried to interfere. “We asked the police if they could show us any documents telling us to move,” said Salah Abu Karen, standing on the bulldozed land slicing in front of his wheat fields like an ugly brown scar. “They told us we were too small to ask such questions.

We’re citizens of Israel and it doesn’t mean a thing to them?”

A Bedouin on a road near Lagiya, 10 miles north of Beersheba.

Date check: the masthead reads THE NEW YORK TIMES, WEDNESDAY, APRIL 11, 1979 — matches date and pub; page slug at right reads L+ A3

CP-1979-029 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israeli Court Aids Bedouin Cause

By JONATHAN KANDELL

JERUSALEM, April 25 — In a move with important implications for Israeli military security and the treatment of Bedouins, the supreme court issued an order today forbidding the Government to expropriate lands belonging to the Bedouins of the Negev region until the matter is ruled upon by local courts.

With the signing of the Israeli-Egyptian peace treaty, a vast redeployment of military installations will take place over the next three years from the Sinai Peninsula to the Negev, in the south of Israel adjacent to Sinai. The court’s decision may mean a delay in the construction of new military bases in the Negev, some of them on Bedouin land.

But the court’s ruling was also meant to assuage fears over Israel’s behavior toward the 35,000 Bedouins in the Negev. Earlier this month, Israeli police units, acting without a court order, began to bulldoze the property of a large Bedouin family in Lagiya, a small agricultural community about 10 miles north of Beersheba.

When the women of the family tried to interfere, they were severely beaten by the police. The Government intended to build a township on the property to house several thousand Bedouins whose land was being used for military purposes. The incident, now called the “Lagiya affair,” brought a rebuke by the supreme court against the Government on April 6.

The justices ordered the authorities to remove all equipment from the area and show cause by the end of the month why farm lands belonging to Bedouins had been expropriated for the construction of a township.

Government Is Declared Guilty Today’s decision in effect declared the Government guilty and ordered the authorities to pay the Bedouin family court costs equivalent to about $250 and to compensate them for damage to their property. The Government, represented by Attorney General Yitzhak Zamir, apologized to the court for its handling of the Lagiya incident. Mr.

Zamir also informed the court that disciplinary measures would be taken against the officials involved in the incident. Until recently the Government had extolled the good relations between Jews and Bedouins, a clannish people who have largely remained aloof to the nationalistic calls of other Arabs.

Many Bedouins voluntarily serve in the Israeli military and have achieved a reputation as scouts and trackers. But as plans for the development of the Negev have unfolded and as the value of lands held by Bedouins has risen, there have been increasingly frequent reports of high-handed treatment of the Bedouins by the Government.

In most cases of land disputes, the Bedouins have insisted that they are willing to turn over their property to the Government for security purposes, if they are compensated on the basis of market value. The Government has contended that most Bedouins do not hold legal deeds for their land, even though it acknowledges that they may have held the property for generations.

The Bedouin family involved in the Lagiya incident, the Abu Karen clan, said the Government had offered them about $80 an acre, despite the fact that only a few miles away in the suburbs of Beersheba, real estate values have soared to thousands of dollars per acre.

Salah Abu Karen, a member of the clan, said shortly after the clash with Israeli policemen earlier this month, “I have no objection if they need this land for security purposes or to build a township. After all, I’m an Israeli citizen — I am practically Jewish. But we want to negotiate with the Government and we want just compensation.”

Date check: the masthead reads THE NEW YORK TIMES, THURSDAY, APRIL 26, 1979 — matches date and pub

CP-1979-030 →

· Lexington Herald-Leader

Israelis to Release Arab, Palestinian Prisoners

The Israeli government will free dozens of Arab prisoners and Palestinian sympathizers as a goodwill gesture prior to a new round of talks with Egypt later this month, Israeli State Radio reported Friday.

There was no official confirmation of the report, which would meet an Egyptian call for goodwill gestures to encourage Palestinians to join the talks focusing on autonomy for the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Israel's Foreign Ministry Friday rejected an Egyptian claim that the Camp David peace accords automatically require Israel to withdraw from the West Bank, Gaza and the Golan Heights as it already is doing in the the Sinai Desert.

The ministry said there was “no foundation” to the Egyptian contention, issued Thursday, and a continued Israeli military presence in the areas is mentioned in the peace treaty, signed March 26.

In other developments Friday: Israeli jets drew anti-aircraft fire from Palestinian bases surrounding Beirut and sent residents scrambling for cover as they swooped low over the Lebanese capital. Syrian Air Force planes began protective flights, but the forces did not clash. There were no injuries.

The Israeli government closed two West Bank universities after troops used tear gas to halt demonstrations by Arab students. United Nations officials were trying to free three Dutch soldiers and a Finnish civilian who were taken captive by armed villagers in southern Lebanon.

The Egyptian Foreign Ministry called on other Moslem states to focus their attention on re-establishing Arab control over East Jerusalem during an Islamic conference in Morocco next week. The predominantly Arab sector of the city was seized by Israel, along with the West Bank, Golan Heights, Sinai and Gaza, in the 1967 Mideast war.

CP-1979-040 →

· The New York Times

Arabs on West Bank Reject Gesture by Israeli Liberals

By PAUL HOFMANN

JERUSALEM, May 13 — A few hundred vines and olive saplings, plants of age-old Mediterranean civilization, have become symbols during the last few days of the conflicts between Arabs and Jews in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and of the frustrations that await anyone seeking to ease the strains.

Today Arabs uprooted the vines and saplings, which a group of liberal Jews had set into a gentle hillside near the city of Hebron southwest of here in a demonstration Friday of sympathy and support for the Arab population in the area.

Those who pulled the plants out of the ground explained that Jews, whatever their motives and intentions, must not be permitted to do any work on Arab land because they may later make claims on it. Besides, the Arab farmers who cleared the hillside told bystanders that the Jews who had taken part in the symbolic planting did not know how to handle vines.

“Sour grapes?” an announcer of the Israeli broadcasting network asked in a news program later today. But hardly anyone here seemed to find the episode amusing.

The demonstration on Friday was organized by Peace Now, a Jewish movement that advocates amity between Jews and Arabs, and opposes efforts to strengthen Israeli control of the West Bank by the creation of Jewish settlements and other means.

The group had decided to plant the vines and olive trees to express their disapproval of a raid last month on an Arab-owned vineyard on top of Jaabari Hill near Hebron. In the action the invaders cut 550 vines with a power saw.

CP-1979-032 →

· The Kansas City Times · page 13A

Israel Still Stalling on U.S. Prisoner

mary mcgrory

WASHINGTON — It's taking almost as long to get one American woman out of an Israeli jail as it did to get a Middle East peace treaty signed. The Israelis just can't seem to find the right moment to release Terre Fleener, a rash 24-year-old from San Antonio who has been in jail for 18 months. They keep saying they will, but they can't bring themselves to do it.

They also know that the longer they wait, the worse it's going to be for them. Terre Fleener is inexorably becoming their most famous prisoner, a human rights cause and a source of friction between the U.S. and Israel. Terre Fleener is serving a five-year sentence on espionage charges. What she did was to take pictures of the Israeli coastline and hotels.

The Israelis paint her as a vicious terrorist. Her friends say she's impulsive. In the confession she signed after continuous interrogation, she said she “supposed” the pictures she took for an allegedly PLO boyfriend, were “for border attacks.”

But even at the sentencing after her secret trial, the judge said there was “no evidence that she is a member of any terrorist organizations.” The Israelis have let 395 Palestinian prisoners out since the peace with Egypt was signed. Terre Fleener's mother, Mrs. Mary Boettcher, went to Israel on April 27, hoping to bring her daughter back with her.

But she came home with only a promise from Israeli Justice Minister Shuvel Tamir that she would be released “in three weeks.” Mrs. Boettcher, who lives in Enon, Ohio, was enjoined to public silence, which the Israelis have insisted was one of the keys to freedom.

The State Department, which has made frequent declarations of imminent release, has often said the same thing.

CP-1979-041 →

· Ann Arbor News · Ann Arbor · page 1

Closed

Arab school shutdown called rights issue

By Max Gates, Higher Education Reporter

“The closing of Bir Zeit University, an Arab university on the Israeli-occupied West Bank of the Jordan River, is a human rights issue, not a political issue, according to the university’s exiled president. ‘Human rights is a non-controversial issue,’ said Dr. Hanna Nasir.

‘If you believe in human rights you must believe in it for all people — Arabs, Jews and Christians.’ Nasir, deported from the West Bank by Israeli military authorities in 1974 after two years as Bir Zeit’s president, addressed a group of about 100 at the Michigan Union Wednesday night.

His talk was sponsored by the Palestine Human Rights Commission… The troubles began, Nasir said, when an Israeli, a professor, shot an Arab student in an unprovoked attack, leading to demonstrations by Bir Zeit students.

The Israeli army closed the university indefinitely and the next day secured a search warrant which permits them to search the university at any time, he said. The closing of Bir Zeit is only one of several violations of human rights by the Israelis on the West Bank, Nasir said.

Others include imprisonment of Palestinians without trial, torture of prisoners and deportation of students and faculty members and of Nasir himself. ‘It is the same story which the Israelis tell of the Nazis,’ Nasir said. ‘They came knocking at my door in the middle of the night.

They take you from the area you have worked all your life building up and throw you across the Lebanese border.’

Other schools have been closed by the Israelis, he said, including the Catholic-run Bethlehem University and a United Nations-supported school… ‘Hebrew University was a cornerstone of the state of Israel, and Bir Zeit would be the same for a Palestinian state,’ he said.

‘It is a threat to the Israelis just by the truth it portrays.’… Nasir, born in Palestine and a graduate in physics from Purdue University, said a major problem in the education of Palestinians is the shortage of people with advanced degrees on the West Bank… ‘The first responsibility comes on the Arabs of the United States,’ he said… Nasir said the Israelis pledge of ‘self-autonomy’ for the West Bank is only another term for occupation.

‘The Israelis admit they have no intention of withdrawing after five years or ever,’ he said. ‘How do people expect the Palestinians to rejoice?’… ‘If the Israelis state clearly that they are ready to withdraw from the West Bank and the Gaza, we would provide the next step.

Then the whole process of peace would work in the right direction.’”

“Nasir: ‘How do people expect the Palestinians to rejoice?’” News photo by Cecil Lockard.

A deported Palestinian university president photographed and quoted at length in a Michigan daily in 1979, five years after they took him across the Lebanese border in the night. The paper prints his comparison to the Nazis as he made it, and prints his conditions for peace in the last paragraph.

CP-1979-005 →

· Press of Atlantic City · Atlantic City

Israeli Bombers Retaliate After PLO Kills 3

At Least 10 Palestinians Killed

By United Press International

“At Least 10 Palestinians Killed

Israeli Bombers Retaliate After PLO Kills 3 Israeli warplanes screamed into Lebanon and strafed and bombed two Palestinian targets Wednesday in quick and deadly reprisals for a PLO-planted bomb that killed three people outside Tel Aviv, including a mother and her infant daughter.

‘The casualty figure could double,’ said one official at WAFA, the Palestine Liberation Organization news agency. ‘A delayed-action bomb exploded after the raid in Damour and caused nearly as many casualties as the raid itself.’

Beirut PLO spokesman Mahmoud Labadi said the Palestinian-run Gaza Hospital on the southwest outskirts of Beirut was flooded with casualties after the air strikes. Two UPI reporters who visited the scene of the attacks at Damour, reported many ambulances speeding north along the coastal highway taking the air raid victims to hospital.

A communique from Yasser Arafat’s high command in Beirut said 14 Palestinians and Lebanese, including civilians, were killed and 50 wounded in the attacks. Western newsmen reaching one of the stricken villages saw the bodies of three guerrillas who were killed when a bomb dropped on an anti-aircraft position.

The military command announced the attack on ‘terrorist concentrations’ in Lebanon eight hours after Shula Abudran, 33, her 18-month-old daughter Zehavit and Sarah Eichenboim, 51, were fatally wounded. Officials reported 11 others were wounded. They had been waiting for a bus across from a busy department store in suburban Petah Tikva.

Police said a time bomb was placed atop a fiberglass shelter at the bus stop. Arafat’s Palestine Liberation Organization said it placed the bomb as part of the PLO campaign to ‘wrestle the natural rights of our people that Israel usurped since 1948.’

Since April 22, when Palestinian guerrillas killed four Israelis in an attack on the northern Israeli town of Nahariya, over 60 Palestinians and Lebanese have died in the Jewish state’s land, sea and air strikes on Lebanon. More than 115 others were wounded.

In Washington, State Department spokesman Ken Brown said, ‘We condemn these terrorist acts … (and) those responsible.’ Asked about Israel’s retaliation, he noted ‘the futility of this continuing cycle of violence.’ The PLO said one of its guerrilla squads carried out the morning attack in the Tel Aviv suburb of Petach Tikva.

The explosion of a bomb in a nylon bag hidden on the roof of a bus stop killed a 33-year-old woman waiting for a bus and her 1½-year-old daughter. The third fatality — also a woman — died in a hospital where she was taken with 13 other persons injured in the blast.

Hours later Israel’s jets roared into action, flying bombing runs against Damour, 10 miles south of Beirut, and Aichiyeh, a hill village in south Lebanon, about 25 miles from the Israeli border.

On the diplomatic front, at the Sinai desert town of El Arish, Egypt stuck to the letter of its peace treaty and refused to let Israelis cross the border for eight more months, even though Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin promised the frontier would open Sunday.”

The cleanest specimen of the habit this archive counts. At least ten Palestinians killed is the kicker, set small in italic above the fold line. Three Israelis killed is the headline, in the largest type on the page, with the killer named. The three Israeli dead are named in the copy — Shula Abudran, 33, her daughter Zehavit, 18 months, and Sarah Eichenboim, 51. The ten Palestinians are not, and the figure from the PLO’s own communiqué is 14. Further down, in a sentence with no headline of its own, the running count since 22 April: over 60 Palestinians and Lebanese dead and more than 115 wounded.

CP-1979-010 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore · page 1

The Closing of Bir Zeit University Ought To Be Reconsidered

By Linda Compton

“ON TOP of the heated controversy surrounding Jewish settlements in occupied Jordan, there is now the dispute over Bir Zeit University, the foremost school for Palestinian Arabs on the West Bank: Israeli military authorities closed it more than a month ago and are giving no indications it will be allowed to reopen.

Some 1,100 students are being prevented from finishing the academic year, and the senior class can not graduate. The closing has been called by some critics an infringement on academic freedom.

The shutdown of Bir Zeit in the aftermath of student protests has drawn angry complaints from 60 Israeli professors, including Ernst Simon, a founder of Hebrew University, former General Matti Peled and religion professors Galia Golan and Moshe Greenberg.

The 60 said in a statement that: ‘The closing of the university denies the tenets of democracy, free speech and free thought.

As Israeli educators, we are under special obligation to assure that the Palestinian Arabs are secure in the same rights we demand for ourselves, including the right to higher education.’… The West Bank military governor closed Bir Zeit after disturbances May 2, Israel’s independence day… When armed Israeli demonstrators from the right-wing Gush Emunim (Bloc of the Faithful) drove through Bir Zeit in convoy, they opened fire on the Palestinian flags.

A Palestinan student was struck in the chest by a bullet; he has recovered… It was founded as a high school by Palestinians in 1924. In 1961 it became a junior college.

In 1972—five years after Israel’s occupation of the West Bank in the Six Day War—Bir Zeit started a four-year program… Israeli Defense Minister Ezer Weizman has singled out Bir Zeit as a ‘hotbed of incitement’ against Israel and does not seem inclined to change his mind right now. Dr.

Hanna Nasir, the exiled president of Bir Zeit University, rejects the Israeli claim that the university is a political center and not an academic institution. He maintains that Bir Zeit has become a scapegoat for the military authorities who find it increasingly difficult to deal with the deep discontent prevailing in occupied areas.

Harsh measures breed resentment and probably work against Israel in the long run. Repressive policies often backfire… Thoughtful Israeli citizens—like the 60 professors—are dismayed by what they see as attempts to curtail education, for it goes against the grain of Judaism’s liberal, humanistic traditions.”

Sixty Israeli professors petitioning for a Palestinian university to reopen, quoted at length, and the exiled Palestinian president of it answering the defense minister. The first sentence of the piece says occupied Jordan; the rest says West Bank. “Palestinan” is the paper’s.

CP-1979-004 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago

Arab refugee can go home to Jerusalem — only as visitor

Instead, Isak prefers the shade of the orange, fig, lemon, and almond trees in his yard. Geraniums and mint grow from a row of large tin cans. Darwish has the incongruous appearance of a French bohemian. He was born and raised in the West Jerusalem village of El Malha, a small hilltop cluster of Arab houses now adjacent to the Jewish neighborhood of Kiryat Yovel.

THE DARWISH house, the largest in El Malha, was a huge stone villa beside the village mosque with a sweeping view of the surrounding hills. There Darwish’s father, one of the wealthiest landowners in prestate Palestine, taught his sons to ride horses and hunt partridge and quail.

Once each year, Sheikh Abdel Darwish took his sons to the desert so they could learn the traditions of their Bedouin ancestors. His father described how the Darwish clan, members of the fierce Beni Hassan tribe, rode into Palestine from Hijaz, Arabia, to help defeat the crusaders in the 12th Century and then settled in Jerusalem.

In 1948, the Darwish clan defended El Malha against an Israeli assault in the battle for Jerusalem—and lost. UNDER ISRAEL’S Absentee Property Law, the government expropriated their property and sold, rented, or leased the land and houses to Jews.

His father died heart-broken soon after the war, and Isak, the eldest son, quarreled with Hassan over money and family responsibility. Now a cat has come forward and gently laps at a saucer of beer next to Darwish’s foot. He reminisces to an American visitor about conditions in the camp after that war.

Isak Darwish lived in this stone villa in El Malha until his family and some 60,000 other West Jerusalem Arabs fled their homes in the 1948 war.

They are forbidden to return under Israeli law, but Darwish paid a recent visit to the place that houses so many memories. — Isak Darwish built this ramshackle 3-room hut in the Dheisheh Palestinian Refugee Camp that has been his home since he retired in 1977.

CP-1979-021 →

· (newspaper unidentified)

Israel to Free American Imprisoned as a Spy for P.L.O.

RAMLE, Israel, June 29 (AP) — An Israeli parole board today approved the early release of Terre Fleener, the 24-year-old American imprisoned for 20 months for spying for the Palestine Liberation Organization, and ordered her to leave Israel immediately, according to her lawyer.

The lawyer, Felicia Langer, said, “After looking at all the material submitted to them, the commissioners decided to release her on condition that she immediately leave the country.” “She could leave tomorrow and be at home Sunday,” Mrs. Langer told reporters after the brief hearing at the prison here in a suburb of Tel Aviv. Before the proceedings, Mrs.

Langer said she would argue for Miss Fleener’s freedom on grounds of her good behavior in prison, her good character and the fact that no actual damage or injury had resulted from her spying. Miss Fleener, who is from San Antonio, was convicted in January 1978 after a secret one-day trial. The charges against her were not specified at that time.

She had been arrested at the Tel Aviv airport the previous October upon her second arrival in Israel. She was originally sentenced to five years in prison, but the term was cut in half three weeks ago after Secretary of State Cyrus R. Vance and other United States officials recommended leniency.

An Israeli Government source said the United States had exerted “tremendous pressure” for the release of Miss Fleener, the only American now imprisoned in Israel for security offenses. Israeli officials recently disclosed that she became friendly with members of the P.L.O. after Kuwait Airlines hired her in Lebanon four years ago as a flight attendant.

The newspaper Maariv recently printed a long article apparently quoting from the previously secret testimony at Miss Fleener’s trial. It reported that she said she gave the P.L.O. “photographs of hotels in Jerusalem, Tel Aviv and Haifa.” “I photographed beaches I had been requested” to, she is quoted as having said at the trial.

“I told them about the security arrangements in the post offices and theaters I had been to in Israel.” In a court hearing last year on a petition to reduce Miss Fleener’s sentence, her lawyer said such pictures could be bought in Israel “by the hundreds.” The young woman’s “only intention was to do an innocent favor,” Mrs. Langer contended.

CP-1979-037 →

· The New York Times

Palestinians May Join Autonomy Talk, Says A West Bank Leader

JERUSALEM, June 29 — An Arab leader in the West Bank said today that representatives from the occupied territories might join autonomy talks between Egypt, Israel and the United States if the Palestine Liberation Organization agreed.

Another condition for joining the talks, according to the Arab community leader, Hikmat al-Masri, was acknowledgment of the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.

CP-1979-038 →

· The Daily Comet · page 1

Radical Bir Zeit Unversity ‘Berkeley of the West Bank’

By Paul Hofmann, 1979 N.Y. Times News Service, Bir Zeit, Israeli-Occupied West Bank

BIR ZEIT, Israeli-Occupied West Bank — Bir Zeit University, a cluster of old school buildings and private houses in this Arab hilltop town 15 miles north of Jerusalem, is sometimes called the “Berkeley of the West Bank.” Like the Berkeley campus in the 1960s, Bir Zeit is in a state of agitation and turmoil.

When the Berkeley label was mentioned, the dean of Bir Zeit’s arts department, Dr. Mohammed Hallaj, quickly replied: “Berkeley — which one?”

Hallaj said Bir Zeit would like to have the reputation for academic excellence of the University of California at Berkeley, but did not care for the image of radicalism that the California school developed during the Vietnam war… Bir Zeit University, the foremost nondenominational center of higher learning for Palestinian Arabs in the occupied territories, was closed by Israeli authorities for an indefinite period after disturbances on May 2, Israel’s Independence Day, in which military vehicles were stoned and a student was shot in the chest… Hanan Mikhail-Ashrawi, a lecturer of English at Bir Zeit, said student views at the university, “on the whole nationalist, reflect the general mood in the West Bank”… She conceded that many Palestinian Arabs in the region were reconciled to the idea of some kind of permanent coexistence with Israelis, “but first give us independence.”

An American professor in the cultural studies department at Bir Zeit, Hugh R. Harcourt, said support for Palestinian nationalism and radicalism among the students was “fairly general, but emotional rather than organizational.”

The scholar, who formerly taught at the American University of Beirut, did not hide his distaste for the way the military government administers the West Bank.

The dateline reads Bir Zeit, Israeli-Occupied West Bank. Hanan Mikhail-Ashrawi is a lecturer in English here, quoted in an American paper in 1979, more than a decade before she became the person Americans knew as the Palestinian spokesperson. The headline misspells the word university. The page carries an air-conditioner advertisement across half its width.

CP-1979-006 →

· Centre Daily Times · page 1

Israelis Decide To Reopen Bir Zeit, Palestinian School

Associated Press, Tel Aviv, Israel

TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — The Israeli military government has decided to reopen Bir Zeit University, the Palestinian school in the occupied West Bank of the Jordan River that was closed May 2 after political demonstrations.

The decision coincided with the visit of Robert Strauss, President Carter’s special Mideast envoy who will take part in Palestinian autonomy talks… The acting president of Bir Zeit University, Dr. Gabi Baramki, said today that following meetings with Defense Minister Ezer Weizman and the West Bank military governor he was told the school could reopen.

Weizman also halted plans to prosecute a number of leading West Bankers for June demonstrations against Israeli settlements in occupied territory, the Israeli press reported.

The two actions marked an easing of the tough Israeli stance in the occupied area and appeared to be an attempt to calm Palestinian protests and world criticism of closure of Bir Zeit and Israel’s settlement policy.

Baramki said resumption of classes for the 1,100 Palestinian students at the university 15 miles north of Jerusalem awaits only formal notification of the decision. A spokesman for the Defense Ministry said “every punishment comes to an end” and that Baramki had promised that Bir Zeit would operate “in peace and quiet.”

The university was closed after a demonstration in which Israeli cars were stoned and an Arab youth was wounded by shots fired by Israelis. More than 100 Bir Zeit students were taken in for questioning about the demonstrations.

There had been plans by the military government to bring charges against a number of West Bankers — incluidng Nablus Mayor Bassam Shakaa — for participating in a banned demonstration on June 17 against the new Israeli settlement of Elon Moreh.

The closing of a university described by a defense ministry spokesman as a punishment, in one sentence: every punishment comes to an end. The word occupied appears four times in the paper’s own voice. “incluidng” is the paper’s.

CP-1979-007 →

· Great Falls Tribune

Israeli politician says soldiers were told to kill Palestinians

Editor's Note: Portions of the following story were deleted by the Israeli military censor. JERUSALEM (AP) — Israeli soldiers on a massive anti-guerrilla invasion of southern Lebanon last year apparently were ordered to shoot suspected guerrillas on sight and not to take prisoners, an Israeli parliament member claimed Wednesday.

The assertion by Meir Pail of the small leftwing Sheli Party came during a debate of no-confidence in Prime Minister Menachem Begin's government in the context of new allegations of misconduct during the “Litani Operation” — the three-month occupation of southern Lebanon that began in March 1978.

The Knesset, or parliament, easily defeated the motion by a 54-4 vote with 25 abstentions. Pail's party had demanded the government's ouster for failing to fire Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Raphael Eytan after he reduced the sentence of a paratroop lieutenant convicted of murdering Arab prisoners.

Pail said Eytan had not exceeded his legal authority by reducing the lieutenant's eight-year prison term to two years, but he charged the army commander had used poor judgment in a case of a war crime.

Pail told the Knesset: “If I put this on the background that orders have been given, apparently also during the Litani Operation, not to take prisoners, meaning to kill them, and if it is true that during the Litani Operation orders were given that every armed person should be shot at once and not taken prisoner,” then the government is not enforcing standing orders “and is not fit to govern.”

Pail later told The Associated Press orders to shoot on sight apparently came from field commanders, and violated the army's fighting code. “I don't know who gave the orders, but orders were given not to take prisoners,” he said.

In another allegation in the growing scandal, Pail asserted a top general pressed Eytan to grant clemency to the lieutenant because the general's daughter was the young officer's girl friend. Pail later named the general as Maj. Gen. Danny Matt, in charge of the Israeli-occupied territories captured in 1967.

Pail conceded he had no proof Matt's intervention was behind Eytan's controversial decision. In a report that created a national furor earlier this year, the state comptroller blasted the army for lack of discipline that cost an undisclosed number of lives during the Litani Operation.

The incident in which the unidentified lieutenant killed two Arab prisoners was banned from publication for more than a year by military censors, and details of the incident are still under censorship. Pail said earlier reports that four prisoners were killed were inaccurate. The first public acknowledgement of the affair came during a Knesset debate on censorship Monday.

The censors, apparently by mistake, failed to strike the information from the Knesset record. Two army censors sat in the visitors' gallery during Wednesday's two-hour debate. Without prompting from the army officers, Knesset speaker Yitzhak Shamir ordered one sentence of Pail's speech struck from the protocol when he named the officer involved in the case.

CP-1979-036 →

· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota · page F1

Terrorism . . . A Threat To Western World

By Suzanne Weaver, Wall Street Journal

“Not long ago the city of Jerusalem, which has played host to a few international gatherings in its time, was the site of an international conference of politicians, journalists and intellectuals on the subject of terrorism. Despite the location, the conference didn’t turn out to be mainly a discussion of Mideast politics.

Instead it was a demonstration of how much terrorism has become part of the broader debate now going on about the proper foreign policy posture of Western nations. It wasn’t exactly a surprise that this was the message to emerge from the gathering.

The meeting was put on by an Israeli foundation named the Jonathan Institute, established in memory of Jonathan Netanyahu, the Israeli officer killed while leading the successful rescue mission to Entebbe in 1976.

In the words of Benjamin Netanyahu, brother of the slain soldier and organizer of the conference, the foundation aims to combat Israel’s ‘growing isolation’ on the international scene. Terrorism, the institute people think, is one of those issues dramatizing the fact that the forces threatening Israel are the same as those threatening the West in general.

So the delegates to the conference were, by and large, people who believe in the usefulness of making such connections. The conference attracted not only Israeli participants but an international cast of characters from the United States and Western Europe. There were speakers from Italy, Ireland, the Netherlands and France.

From West Germany there were terrorism specialist Hans Josef Horchem and journalist Gerhard Lowenthal. The British contingent included diplomat and writer Lord Chalfont, former Home Secretary Merlyn Rees and Brian Crozier, specialist in the subject of political violence.

Scholars And Writers The large American group included a range of scholars and writers like Harvard economist Thomas Schelling, Harvard Soviet specialist Richard Pipes, former CIA official Ray Cline and columnist George Will. A number of U.S. politicians also turned up: presidential candidate and former CIA director George Bush, Congressman Jack Kemp, Sen.

John Danforth and Sen. Henry Jackson. The speakers covered subjects like the scope of possible international cooperation on terrorism, the legal restraints on coping with terrorism and possible future forms of terrorism.

But since this was a conference mainly of public figures rather than technical specialists, the talk was less of the operational problems in fighting terrorism than it was of the political ones.

High on the speakers’ agenda was the issue of language: Too many reporters and analysts, many said, were legitimating terrorism by speaking of it as a natural response to flaws in Western society or a tactic in wars of national liberation, instead of calling it first and foremost an atrocity and a crime against humanity.

The most notable words on the topic came from conference speaker Paul Johnson, British author and former editor of the magazine ‘The New Statesman’. Terrorism, he argued, is a threat to Western civilization ‘in many respects more serious than the risk of nuclear war.’

In our recoverable history, major civilizations have fallen several times and Dark Ages have replaced them. And each of these falls occurred ‘when the spread of metals technology, and the availability of raw materials, enabled the forces of barbarism to equal or surpass the civilized powers in the quality and quantity of their weapons.’

Modern terrorism, he said, is a sign that just such a transfer of resources is going on. Many people hide this fact from themselves by viewing the terrorists as idealists whose worthy goals at least partly redeem their use of violence.

So, Johnson said, it is necessary to instruct people on why this is not so, and why the impact of terrorism on humanity is instead ‘intrinsically evil, necessarily evil and wholly evil.’

This impact comes from what Johnson called terrorism’s ‘seven deadly sins’: It is a deliberate ‘exaltation of violence over other forms of public activity.’ It requires a ‘deliberate suppression of the moral instincts in man.’ It is a ‘rejection of politics as the normal means by which communities resolve conflicts.’

Far from fighting repression, the terrorists’ activity ‘systematically and necessarily assists the spread of the totalitarian states’ which furnish the terrorists with their base.

Further, it favors totalitarian states over democratic ones, since ‘it can destroy a democracy, as it destroyed Lebanon, but it cannot destroy a totalitarian state’ which is willing to repress it ruthlessly.

Terrorism ‘exploits the apparatus of freedom in liberal societies and thereby endangers’ that freedom; and, finally, it ‘saps the will of a civilized society to defend itself.’

Necessary Step Many speakers during the conference echoed this theme: A necessary step in fighting terrorism is to educate democratic nations about how massive a moral and practical threat it is to their beliefs.

But one of Johnson’s points in particular dominated the proceedings: the assertion that terrorism is not just some random natural occurrence, but an instrument in the foreign policy of totalitarian nations — especially, nowadays, the Soviet Union.

Senator Jackson put the argument simply: Most terrorist groups, he said, use Soviet bloc weapons, get training in Warsaw Pact countries or Mideast nations like South Yemen or PLO-controlled Lebanon, and find sanctuary in the same places. In fact, he said, modern terrorism is a form of ‘warfare by remote control’ by these countries and groups.

Analyst Ray Cline elaborated. Western statesmen, he said, had to face up to ‘the widespread adoption of terrorism as a preferred instrument of policy by a finite, known number of modern states.’

More specifically, the current wave of world terrorism began after 1969, ‘when the Soviet KGB persuaded the Politburo of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union to accept the PLO as a major political instrument in the Mideast and to subsidize its terrorist policies by freely giving money, training, arms and coordinated communications.’

Many Soviet-related terrorist activities, he argued, ‘have been no more than largely unintended byproducts of Soviet dabbling in troubled international waters.’ Still, the supporting role played by the Soviets and surrogates like Cuba, North Korea and East Germany has ‘hardened into a system — an international troublemaking system.’

Cline gave specifics — KGB attempts to form terrorist cells in Saudi Arabia, KGB links with parts of the Irish Republican Army, Soviet influence on Latin American and African guerrilla groups through Cuba’s intelligence services.

But still more provocative accusations of Soviet involvement came from speaker Robert Moss, editor of the ‘Foreign Report’ put out by the British magazine ‘The Economist.’ Moss charged, for example, that the Soviets, plus Libya and the PLO, were heavily involved in the campaign to overthrow the Shah.

In Iran today a Soviet-trained PLO unit ‘functions as the nucleus of a secret police, a revolutionary SAVAK.’

In Nicaragua, to take another example, the Sandinist offensive against the Somoza regime was ‘planned and supervised, in meticulous detail, by Cuban staff officers’ and aided by ‘a miniature, international Communist brigade, including ‘volunteers’ from West Germany’s terrorist underground.’

The Sandinistas, in turn, are helping train terrorists from El Salvador and Guatemala. Other such proxies, Moss went on, are operating elsewhere in the world. For instance, it is probable that the Soviets, through Libya and the PLO, provided the Strela missiles that Rhodesian guerrilla Joshua Nkomo used to shoot down two civilian airliners.

The PLO has been a specially active surrogate, maintaining supportive contacts with guerrilla groups from Turkey to Argentina and many points in between.

Vision Of Detente Even more directly, Moss said, the Soviet Union maintains schools and camps to train foreigners in insurrection, including terror tactics. And what is most remarkable is that Western governments, hostage to their vision of detente, have refrained from publicly exposing all this Soviet involvement.

A considerable number in the press corps covering the conference were much annoyed by Moss’ charges and told him so. Where was he getting his information? Was he really asking people to believe he had respectable evidence of a Soviet-led conspiracy in these matters? The reporters demanded a special press conference from Moss the next day. He obliged.

Certainly he didn’t believe in a single-cause terrorist conspiracy, he explained to the reporters; but the connections he had alluded to were real and it was perfectly sound journalistic practice for him to refuse to reveal his sources.

The full extent of Soviet involvement, he argued, couldn’t be ascertained and publicized except by a government intelligence operation with more resources at its disposal than those of a journalist. But why weren’t Western governments making the effort? And why weren’t journalists pressing them to do so?

In Moss’ question lay the central issue that the conference attempted to place on the public agenda.

Most of the participants would have agreed that the first political task at hand on the issue of terrorism is to cut the idea of terrorism loose from the connection it now has in many Western liberal minds with notions of national liberation and social justice; only then can terror be viewed plainly as a crime and a threat.

But their second task is to establish another kind of connection, and to make people see terrorism not as just a random occurrence but as a tactic in the Soviet war against the West. If this attempt makes headway, the already-embattled idea of Western detente with the Soviets will be under even more intense challenge.

And political leaders who try to push detente-based policies, from trade agreements to SALT, will have even harder going ahead.”

The Jonathan Institute’s first conference, reported in a Florida Sunday paper. Benjamin Netanyahu is 29 and is named here as its organizer, five years before the earliest clipping this archive previously held of him. What the page records is a conference setting itself a task in plain words: the first political task at hand on the issue of terrorism is to cut the idea of terrorism loose from the connection it now has in many Western liberal minds with notions of national liberation and social justice. The PLO appears in the copy eight times, always as an instrument of the Soviet Union, and never in connection with Palestinians. No Palestinian is quoted, named or described anywhere on the page. The drawing above the text is a masked man with a rifle and a bandolier standing in front of the arms of the Soviet Union and a passenger airliner.

CP-1979-009 →

· The Grand Rapids Press · Grand Rapids

Jackson Carried Off On the Shoulders of Arabs After Speech

Associated Press

NABLUS, Occupied West Bank (AP) — The Rev. Jesse Jackson fired up a Palestinian crowd to a screaming pitch today with black pride chants in the heart of the Israeli-occupied West Bank of the Jordan River. The Arabs later carried him off on their shoulders, chanting, “Jackson! Arafat!”

“Do not put symbols over substance, do not allow acts of terror to divert you from a homeland,” Jackson said after receiving a tumultuous welcome from an overflow crowd of hundreds at the Nablus town hall.

The Palestinian crowd chanted, “Palestine is Arabic!” and raised V-for-victory signs in a reception that contrasted with the cold shoulder the Israeli government gave Jackson because of his support of the Palestine Liberation Organization.

Speaking through an interpreter who translated his remarks into Arabic, Jackson supported the Palestinian goal of a homeland but said West Bankers should reassess their tactics, taking the black struggle for civil rights in America as a model.

“We became disciplined and determined, and nothing could stop us from achieving our human rights and our place in the sun and self-determination,” he said. “You are very close to freedom and liberation,” he said.

Jackson repeated the message he stressed to Israelis earlier in his tour: “Somebody must have the strength to break the cycle of terror and pain.” Some Palestinians in the crowd shook their heads as Jackson urged moderation, implying criticism of the radical sentiment which prevails in Nablus, the largest city in the West Bank and the most nationalistic.

But Jackson roused the crowd to a screaming pitch with a civil rights cheer: “I am somebody!. We can win! We ought to win!. We must win!.” The crowd reverted to Palestinian slogans as they carried the American from the room on their shoulders chanting “Jackson! Arafat!”

Jackson will meet PLO chief Yasser Arafat when he goes to Lebanon after visiting Jordan. Starting his day in Jerusalem, Jackson condemned terrorism in a sermon to about 150 worshipers at the Lutheran Church of the Redeemer in the Old City.

“I shall appeal to the PLO to stop their tactics of terrorism, to recognize Israel’s right and need to exist, to articulate its own goal for self-determination and a homeland and to fight for peaceful coexistence,” Jackson said.

Earlier, two American Jews traveling with Jackson attacked his motives for the trip after the black leader canceled a meeting with the leader of the World Organization of Jews from Arab Countries.

Raymond Mallal, an executive member of the world Sephardi Federation, and Phillip Blazer, publisher of the Los Angeles magazine “Israel Today,” both accused Jackson of using the trip to the Mideast to advance his own political career in the United States.

Blazer claimed to be a good friend of Jackson since the two organizaed opposition to the pro-Nazi march in Skokie, Ill., in April 1978, but Jackson has said that he “hardly knows” Blazer.

In Israeli press reports published today, Jackson retorted that Blazer was using Jackson’s tour in order to get press coverage of Blazer’s publishing and public relations activities.

The Israeli government has turned a cold shoulder to the visiting delegation and Prime Minister Menachem Begin refused to meet them because he considered the group’s pro-PLO leanings antagonistic.

The clearest document in this archive of an American civil rights leader offering the Black American movement to Palestinians as a model, and of Palestinians answering. Jackson tells a crowd in Nablus to take the black struggle for civil rights in America as their method, leads them in I am somebody, and is carried out of the town hall on their shoulders while they chant his name and Arafat’s. The copy also records that some in the crowd shook their heads at him.

CP-1979-011 →

· The Daily News · Longview

Arabs cry ‘Jackson! Arafat!’

Associated Press

NABLUS, Occupied West Bank (AP) — The Rev. Jesse Jackson fired up a Palestinian crowd to a screaming pitch today with black pride chants in the heart of the Israeli-occupied West Bank of the Jordan River. The Arabs later carried him off on their shoulders, chanting, “Jackson! Arafat!”

“Do not put symbols over substance, do not allow acts of terror to divert you from a homeland,” Jackson said after receiving a tumultuous welcome from an overflow crowd of hundreds at the Nablus town hall.

The Palestinian crowd chanted, “Palestine is Arabic!” and raised V-for-victory signs in a reception that contrasted with the cold shoulder the Israeli government gave Jackson because of his support of the Palestine Liberation Organization.

Speaking through an interpreter who translated his remarks into Arabic, Jackson supported the Palestinian goal of a homeland but said West Bankers should reassess their tactics, taking the black struggle for civil rights in America as a model.

“We became disciplined and determined, and nothing could stop us from achieving our human rights and our place in the sun and self-determination,” he said. “You are very close to freedom and liberation,” he said.

Jackson repeated the message he stressed to Israelis earlier in his tour: “Somebody must have the strength to break the cycle of terror and pain.” Some Palestinians in the crowd shook their heads as Jackson urged moderation, implying criticism of the radical sentiment which prevails in Nablus, the largest city in the West Bank and the most nationalistic.

But Jackson roused the crowd to a screaming pitch with a civil rights cheer: “I am somebody! We can win! We ought to win! We must win!” The crowd reverted to Palestinian slogans as they carried the American from the room on their shoulders chanting “Jackson! Arafat!”

Jackson will meet PLO chief Yasser Arafat when he goes to Lebanon after visiting Jordan. Starting his day in Jerusalem, Jackson condemned terrorism in a sermon to about 150 worshipers at the Lutheran Church of the Redeemer in the Old City.

“I shall appeal to the PLO to stop their tactics of terrorism, to recognize Israel”’s right and need to exist, to articulate its own goal for self-determination and a homeland and to fight for peaceful coexistence,’ Jackson said.

The same dispatch the Grand Rapids Press ran that day, stopped short: this paper cuts it at the Jerusalem sermon and leaves out the two American Jewish travelers who accused Jackson of careerism and Begin’s refusal to meet the delegation.

CP-1979-016 →

· The New York Times · New York

Jesse Jackson Visits A Palestinian Camp, Sees Jewish Memorial

“He applauded an old man in a white kaffiyeh headgear who told him that the refugees recognized the Palestine Liberation Organization as their voice. He gave a soul-brother handshake to a young Palestinian who said he had been arrested and tortured by the Israelis.”

Jackson at Kalandia camp, three weeks after Andrew Young resigned over meeting the PLO. Shipler writes the handshake rather than the position, which is how you can tell he was standing there.

CP-1979-024 →

· The Times · Shreveport · page 10-A

Jackson meets with Arafat

Associated Press

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — The Rev Jesse Jackson and PLO leader Yasser Arafat met and embraced Saturday and held talks that the U.S. black activist leader said “could very well establish a beachhead” for official U.S.-PLO discussions. “It was a very effective and free and serious interchange.

I have reason to believe that we are very close to making some real progress,” said Jackson. The two men, accompanied by Jackson’s wife, Jacqueline, were scheduled to talk again late Saturday night.

“For two hours we were grappling with some critical issues, dealing with reassessment, dealing with fundamental issues about the quest for self-determination for the Palestinian people,” Jackson said after the first meeting at the headquarters of the Palestine Liberation Organization.

He reiterated that the United States must rescind its five-year-old pledge to Israel not to talk with the PLO because, he said, the promise prohibits the United States from resolving the Mideast crisis.

“Our discussions tonight could very well establish a beachhead for our government to see whether there is a possibility for it to assume its responsibility — which is in fact to open up talks and reconcile America’s several interests in the Middle East,” Jackson added.

“We have national interests here, we have moral interests here, we have economic interests here — all three of those interests must converge and not collide.”

Posing for photographers before the meeting began, Arafat told Jackson that Palestinians struggling for a homeland were dealing with the same problems American blacks faced during the civil rights movement in the United States. “We are very happy you are here to give us strength and power for our struggle,” Arafat told Jackson.

Palestinians, Arafat said, “suffered from the same attitude, the same circumstances” as American blacks. But, added Arafat, quoting from the song known as the theme of the U.S. civil rights movement: “We shall overcome.”

Jackson, whose Mideast mission went first to Israel and Jordan and goes to Egypt Sunday after a visit here, has repeatedly spoken of the need for Israeli security and Palestinian justice. He has urged the PLO to recognize Israel and vice versa. And he has called on both sides to end the “cycle of terror” in the Mideast.

Earlier in the Rashidiyeh refugee camp outside the southern Lebanese city of Tyre, throngs of Palestinians lifted Jackson onto their shoulders, shouting “Welcome brother, welcome brother.” The crowds shouted “Jackson, Arafat, brothers in the struggle for freedom” as Jackson sat on their shoulders, resting his palms on their heads.

Jackson, head of the Chicago-based PUSH, People United to Save Humanity, promised the refugees he would try to talk the Carter Administration out of a commitment to Israel which keeps U.S. officials from meeting with PLO leaders.

And he pledged to try to convince President Carter to hold a new peace conference that would take into consideration all parties in the Mideast dispute. Jackson met with President Carter Sept. 21 before beginning setting out on his Mideast tour with a 17-member delegation of black and white religious leaders.

Arafat quotes the American civil rights anthem back to an American delegation: Palestinians, he says, ‘suffered from the same attitude, the same circumstances’ as American blacks, and then — We shall overcome. Three papers carried this meeting on 30 September 1979 under three different headlines.

CP-1979-013 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia

Jackson talks with PLO chief

Associated Press

“… prohibits the United States from resolving the Mideast crisis. ‘Our nation must be freed from its no-talk policy with the PLO,’ he said.

‘Our discussions tonight could very well establish a beachhead for our government to see whether there is a possibility for it to assume its responsibility — which is, in fact, to open up talks and reconcile America’s several interests in the Middle East,’ Jackson said.

‘We have national interests here, we have moral interests here, we have economic interests here — all three of those interests must converge and not collide,’ he said.

Posing for photographers before the meeting began, Arafat told Jackson that Palestinians struggling for a homeland were dealing with the same problems that American blacks faced during the civil rights movement in the United States. ‘We are very happy you are here to give us strength and power for our struggle,’ the PLO leader said.

Palestinians, Arafat said, ‘suffered from the same attitude, the same circumstances’ as American blacks. But, Arafat added, quoting from the song that became identified with the U.S. civil rights movement: ‘We shall overcome.’ Jackson, who traveled to both Israel and Jordan before coming to Lebanon, is to go to Egypt today.

During his Mideast trip, he has repeatedly spoken of the need for Israeli security and Palestinian justice. He has urged the PLO to recognize Israel’s right to exist, while urging Israelis to accept the need for a Palestinian homeland. He also has called on both sides to end the ‘cycle of terror’ in the Mideast.

Jackson is here as the head of a 17-member delegation of American church leaders, but some sources believe that he may be carrying a message from President Carter to Arafat. Jackson would not comment on that, but did say that he would call on Carter to convene a conference on the Mideast, to be attended by all parties, as soon as he returned to the United States.

Jackson met with Carter on Sept. 21, before setting out on his Mideast trip. Earlier yesterday, in the Rashidiyeh refugee camp outside the southern Lebanese city of Tyre, throngs of Palestinians lifted Jackson onto their shoulders, shouting ‘Welcome brother, welcome brother.’

The crowds shouted ‘Jackson, Arafat, brothers in the struggle for freedom’ as Jackson sat on their shoulders, resting his palms on their heads. Jackson, head of the Chicago-based Operation PUSH (People United to Save Humanity), promised the refugees that he would try to talk the Carter Administration out of keeping that promise not to meet with PLO leaders.”

“A warm embrace … Jackson and Arafat”

The same news agency dispatch as the Shreveport Times of the same morning, under a different headline and cut differently: this paper keeps the line about Jackson possibly carrying a message from President Carter, and drops the closing paragraph about the new peace conference.

CP-1979-014 →

· The Atlanta Journal and Constitution · Atlanta · page 10-A

Jesse Jackson Fails to Get Arafat To Accept Israel, Quit Terrorism

By Lee May, Constitution Staff Writer

BEIRUT, Lebanon — Palestinian Liberation Organization leader Yasser Arafat treated members of the Rev. Jesse Jackson’s Mideast fact-finding delegation to a sumptuous meal, three hours of talks, two informal discussions and many hugs and good wishes Saturday.

But Jackson emerged empty-handed from a meeting Sunday morning, in which he tried to get Arafat to agree to recognize Israel and renounce terrorism. Jackson, president of Operation PUSH, said he came here seeking written agreement from PLO leader on two issues: Israel’s right to exist and a pledge by the PLO not to engage in “terroristic activity.”

At about 1:30 Sunday morning, Jackson and Arafat told reporters and other members of the American delegation that the letter of agreement on those two points must wait until the PLO National Council meets to discuss the matter.

Because such an agreement would be viewed as a success for the fact-finding mission, Jackson said, he agreed to return to Beirut on Wednesday after visiting Syria. “Our nation has an obligation to chairman Arafat and the Executive Committee,” Jackson said, explaining, “In my judgement we have made a measure of progress.”

After the second meeting with Arafat, Jackson was visibly tired. In the first meeting Saturday evening, he said that he and Arafat spent three hours “grappling with tough issues.” Jackson said he added Syria to his itinerary at the request of the PLO and because he was invited to Damascus by Syrian President Hafez Assad.

He also said he feels there is a good chance he will receive an agreement from the PLO after he visits Syria and that to forego the trip likely would indicate to Arafat that he is not fully committed to getting a comprehensive view of the situation in this troubled region.

Additionally, Syria represents a strong military presence in Lebanon, giving Assad’s country a large stake in any agreement involving Lebanon. The delegation’s presence here was warmly received by Arafat. At the first meeting he shook Jackson’s hand and said: “We might not have known each other before, but you are here as old friends of my people.

Our hearts will be together until victory. We will overcome.” Following his first meeting with Arafat, Jackson said, “America can no longer use two yardsticks to measure justice; we must use one yardstick.”

Jackson explained, as he has done throughout the tour, that he means both the Israelis and the Palestinians have legitimate concerns that have to be addressed simultaneously. America’s concerns in the Middle East, he said, are national, moral and economic.

After his first meeting with Jackson, Arafat, relaxed and smiling, talked with the Americans in his living room, insisting over the objections of his aides that reporters sit in on his rare English-language session with the 17-member delegation.

One member of Jackson’s group, referring to America’s pledge to Israel not to talk with the PLO, asked Arafat if he were interested in talks with the U.S. government. “Please, if you find a way, I will accept,” Arafat said. “I am not an idiot to neglect this superpower.” Jackson’s delegation has visited Israel, Jordan and Lebanon.

It has scheduled a trip to Egypt Sunday. The PUSH leader has said one of its main goals is to find a way for the American government to talk to Arafat’s PLO. Arafat said that in addition to a PLO official’s contact with former U.N.

Ambassador Andrew Young in June and a chance meeting last July between a PLO official and the U.S. ambassador to Austria, Milton Wolf, there were contacts between the group and former Secretary of State Henry A. Kissinger during the 1975-76 Lebanese civil war.

Young resigned last month following an international flap over the unauthorized meeting with Zehdi Labib Terzi, PLO observer at the United Nations. “During the Lebanese crisis, Kissinger contacted us, and we sent our representative to the American embassy to facilitate the evacuation of American citizens” from Lebanon, Arafat said.

The guerrilla leader said Kissinger’s personal thanks were relayed through Egyptian President Anwar Sadat and the Egyptian leadership. He called Kissinger a “cheat” for talking with the PLO when he needed it, but promising Israel he would not negotiate with the Palestinian force.

Sitting on a couch under a portrait of himself, Arafat told some 35 persons packed into the tiny room he does not “have the cards” Sadat had to negotiate with Israel. But, he said, “I have a few cards, and I am not ready to play my cards.”

He said Sadat had “offered the Israelis everything” and the Israelis were “humiliating him every day” with their policies in occupied territories and their positions on the Camp David accords, which are the basis for the current Mideast talks.

Arafat said the PLO’s national charter does not call for the extermination of Jews, but for a democratic secular state in which Moslems, Christians and Jews would live in harmony. “We are not against Jews. And believe me, in our revolution, in our movement, we have Jews,” he asserted.

Obviously relishing one of his first audiences with Americans, Arafat explained that the Palestine National Council agreed in 1974 to accept a Palestinian state on any piece of Arab land the Israelis evacuate.

He said he would set up a sovereign state on the West Bank or Gaza Strip, which the Israelis occupied during the 1967 Middle East War, or even in the tiny village of Jericho, if need be. Pointing to his Palestinian advisers in the room, Arafat noted that none had a passport from the country of his birth, Palestine, and that many of them had no passport or identity card.

He answered questions about Paletinian “terrorism” by referring to Israels’ use of America’s most sophisticated jet fighter, the F-15, of American-made cluster bombs and other weapons against Palestinian-held villages in Lebanon.

“Why are you stressing only the resistance (and not) the legal right — the international right — for any people under occupation to use all the methods of resistance?” he asked. “Why were you resisting?” he asked his American guests. “Why did you not accept the British Empire occupation?”

Arafat said he accepted the joint U.S.-Soviet declaration of October 1977, which would guarantee the security of Israel and the Palestinians.

Not a news agency dispatch: this paper sent its own reporter to Beirut, and the headline it wrote calls the trip a failure on the same morning two other papers called it a meeting. The piece carries the longest printed record in this archive of Arafat speaking English to Americans — the passport none of his advisers hold, and the question he puts back to his guests about the British Empire.

CP-1979-015 →

· The Lexington Herald · Lexington

Jackson, Arafat Meet in Lebanon

By Stephen Hindy, Associated Press

BEIRUT, Lebanon — The Rev. Jesse Jackson met with Palestinian guerrilla leader Yasser Arafat on Thursday, seven hours after being released from a hospital where he was treated for a stomach ailment. Leftist sources said said Arafat met with the Palestine Liberation Organization Executive Committee before going into the session with the American black activist.

The report could not be confirmed immediately. Jackson, Arafat and his aides were rushed into a small conference room bedecked with photographs of the guerrilla leader and one of the Iranian revolutionary leader, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini. Arafat and Jackson posed for photographers but made no comments.

Jackson was expected to seek a “document” from Arafat, outlining basic PLO objectives. He wants the PLO to renounce terrorism and repudiate clauses in its charter calling for the destruction of Israel and the establishment of a secular democratic state.

The civil rights activist and his 17-member delegation had planned to leave Beirut for the United States on Thursday, but on Wednesday, Jackson, suffering from what he said was a case of food poisoning, was hospitalized, forcing him to cancel a meeting with Arafat. But Arafat came to the hospital and the two chatted.

Jackson advocates American and Israeli contacts with the PLO and Israeli Foreign Minister Moshe Dayan has hinted Israel might talk with the PLO to find a solution to the Palestinian refugee problem. But Dayan has attached conditions to the proposal that are unacceptable to Arafat.

PLO sources say the Jackson meeting with Arafat is not likely to result in any major changes in PLO policy because revisions could not be made without the approval of the 390-member Palestine National Council.

But the meetings and Arafat’s pledge to consider Jackson’s calls for non-violence and diplomacy are seen as goodwill gestures that enhance the PLO leader’s image as he seeks recognition among Western European nations and in America.

Jackson arrived here Wednesday from Damascus where he met Syrian President Hafez Assad, and brought him a message of reconciliation from Egyptian President Anwar Sadat, whom he met earlier this week.

The official Syrian news agency said Assad reiterated Sadat had “deviated from Arab ranks and that the Camp David accords and the subsequent Egyptian-Israeli treaty of surrender … create an obstacle to peace.”

“Yasser Arafat greets Jesse Jackson with embrace in Beirut hospital” Associated Press.

Nine days after Nablus, the meeting itself, with a photograph of the embrace above the headline. The copy notes that Arafat came to the hospital when Jackson was too ill to come to him. The word the paper uses for Jackson throughout is the American black activist and the civil rights activist; the word for Arafat is Palestinian guerrilla leader.

CP-1979-012 →

· Argus Leader · Sioux Falls · page 9A

Jackson, Arafat speak privately

Associated Press

BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — The Rev. Jesse Jackson met with Palestinian guerrilla leader Yasser Arafat on Thursday, seven hours after being released from a hospital where he was treated for a stomach ailment. Leftist sources said Arafat met with the Palestine Liberation Organization Executive Committee before going into the session with the American black activist.

The report could not be confirmed immediately. Jackson, Arafat and his aides were rushed into a small conference room bedecked with photographs of the guerrilla leader and one of the Iranian revolutionary leader, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini. Arafat and Jackson posed for photographers but made no comments.

Jackson was expected to seek a “document” from Arafat, outlining basic PLO objectives. He wants the PLO to renounce terrorism and repudiate clauses in its charter calling for the destruction of Israel and the establishment of a secular democratic state.

The civil rights activist and his 17-member delegation had planned to leave Beirut for the United States on Thursday, but on Wednesday, Jackson, suffering from what he said was a case of food poisoning, was hospitalized, forcing him to cancel a meeting with Arafat. But Arafat came to the hospital and the two chatted.

Jackson advocates American and Israeli contacts with the PLO and Israeli Foreign Minister Moshe Dayan has hinted Israel might talk with the PLO to find a solution to the Palestinian refugee problem. But Dayan has attached conditions to the proposal that are unacceptable to Arafat.

PLO sources say the Jackson meeting with Arafat is not likely to result in any major changes in PLO policy because revisions could not be made without the approval of the 390-member Palestine National Council.

But the meetings and Arafat’s pledge to consider Jackson’s calls for non-violence and diplomacy are seen as goodwill gestures that enhance the PLO leader’s image as he seeks recognition among Western European nations and in America. Jackson, who began his Mideast trip Sept.

24 and has been snubbed by Israeli leaders, has said he hopes to report to President Carter on his findings.

“Black American civil rights leader Rev. Jesse Jackson, at left, offers an unidentified patient flowers he received from Palestinian leaders after being treated for food poisoning. Jackson received several bouquets, which he gave to patients before leaving the hospital to meet with guerrilla chieftain Yassar Arafat. (AP Photo)”

The same dispatch the Lexington Herald ran that morning, under a different headline and with a different last paragraph: this one ends on Jackson being snubbed by Israeli leaders, the other on Assad calling the Egyptian treaty a surrender.

CP-1979-017 →

· Courier Post · Camden

Pessimism Prevalent in Palestine

JERUSALEM — In the dusty, sun-bleached Arab towns of the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, where late summer’s merciless and unchanging weather was ending, a visitor senses that the mood is one of disappointment, cynicism and concern. Even whispered hopes that the Camp David accords will bear fruit seem to have vanished.

Though the Palestinians rarely are optimistic in this divided, violence-prone land, those contacted recently seem uniformly pessimistic because of these major problems: • The political impasse in Egyptian-Israeli negotiations toward Palestinian autonomy. • Israeli “security” crackdowns in the West Bank and Gaza, coupled with terrorism directed at West Bank leaders. • A deteriorating Israeli economy. • And now the unsettled nature of the Iraq-Iran war to the east.

Somewhere out in the world of conference tables and salon chairs — far removed from the winding streets, noisy souks and hilly olive groves of Israeli-occupied territory — Egyptain, Israeli and American diplomats struggle to continue the Camp David peace talks.

But this process at times seems only vaguely connected with the lives of West Bankers and Gazans — the people who will be the ultimate benefactors or victims. “How far from reality we have come in these autonomy talks,” lamented a frustrated Egyptian negotiator shortly after Egypt’s President Anwar Sadat ordered the talks suspended Aug.

2 in retaliation for the new Israeli law formalizing the annexation of East Jerusalem. “We have been meeting and conducting abstract exercises in Alexandria (Egypt) and Herzliya (Israel), and to what end?” he continued. “We have all become great experts on autonomy, but what is that?

We are so far from the situation as it relates to the people of Palestine.” Even so, the autonomy talks had offered the possibility, however slim, of change for the better.

Though the talks were openly embraced by few, if any, Palestinians, they did give rise to sub rosa hope in the occupied territories — and they also fed the endless, impassioned dinner-table arguments that seem to be the daily bread of Arab and Israeli alike.

But with negotiations now suspended, with stepped-up Israeli military activity in the West Bank and southern Lebanon and with most diplomats awaiting the outcome of the United States presidential election, little hope is evident.

IN HEBRON — Israel’s Military Displayed

CP-1979-020 →

· The New York Times · New York

P.L.O. Aide Charges Jesse Jackson Sought to Split Arabs' Ranks

“Abdel Jawad Saleh of the P.L.O.’s Executive Committee was quoted as having charged that Mr. Jackson had sought ‘to split the Arab and Palestinian ranks by demanding a freeze in the Palestinian armed struggle, recognition of Israel and participation in the Camp David accords.’”

The day after Jackson came home from Beirut. The archive already follows him through the American papers that year; this is the same trip read from the other end, and the criticism is specific rather than dismissive, which is rare in the coverage of him.

CP-1979-027 →

· Telegram & Gazette · Worcester

Connally and Israel

Last week John Connally made the most important speech of the presidential campaign to date. Important, not only for what he said, but for what he implied about our future course in the Middle East. Connally was the first presidential candidate to flatly link our policy toward Israel with our need for oil.

Without actually saying so, he indicated that oil comes first, Israel second. In order to protect Israel and our own national security, he said that we must force Israel to accept the sort of settlement that the Israelis have stubbornly resisted. Thus: “Israel must withdraw from the West Bank, Gaza and Golan, all of which will be demilitarized . . .

“All Israeli civilian settlements, including the so-called paramilitary ones, must be withdrawn from the West Bank, Gaza and Golan . . . “The Palestinian people should decide for themselves whether they prefer the West Bank and Gaza to be governed as an entirely independent entity or to be an autonomous area within the Kingdom of Jordan.”

Finally, Connally proposed a settlement for Jerusalem that will give the Arabs more say than the Israeli government has ever been willing to concede. That speech is bound to raise a storm of protest in Israel and among American supporters of Israel.

Connally, a shrewd politician, has obviously considered the possibilities and concluded that it is no longer political suicide to criticize the Jewish state. As he noted: “It is only candid to say that support for this level of aid (to Israel), in the absence of greater willingness by Israeli leadership to compromise with their neighbors, is eroding.”

Although some may not think so, Connally has done a service in posing the issue in such a candid fashion. Middle East oil is extremely important to our future as a nation. Israel’s stubborn attitude is an obstacle to a peace settlement. Many people have felt this way, including President Jimmy Carter, but few have expressed it so bluntly.

It is ironic that, three days after Connally’s speech, the Israeli cabinet voted unanimously to expand seven Jewish settlements on the occupied West Bank. It is this sort of folly that makes some people wonder whether the Israeli government understands its precarious situation in regard to American public opinion.

The danger in the Connally speech is that it will lead to an overreaction. The Andrew Young episode already has shown what can happen when pent-up emotions explode. A strong and secure Israel is still a key part of our Middle East strategy. No other nation offers us the potential support and facilities that might be needed in case of an emergency in the Persian Gulf.

Second, it is as much in our interest as it is in Israel’s interest to prevent a Soviet-dominated Palestinian state from being established in the area. We still have no reason to believe that the PLO can be trusted.

But the Israelis themselves agree with Connally that “any Palestinian leader who is willing to put aside violence, sit down and work constructively on the details of a compromise peace settlement should be welcomed.” John Connally has opened up a hornet’s nest with this speech.

But it’s better to have these things out in the open and frankly debated, than festering beneath the surface. Because of its oil and its capacity to produce instability, the Middle East has become enormously important to the whole industrialized world. John Connally thinks he has come up with the formula to solve the problem. He is taking a big political risk.

So would the United States, if it decided to go the Connally route.

CP-1979-019 →

· The Herald Mail

Israelis hit fierce resistance

BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — Israeli tanks supported by artillery fire pushed into south Lebanon Monday but were driven back across the border by heavy Palestinian guerrilla fire, radio and Palestinian news agency reports said. In Tel Aviv, the Israeli military command denied any such attack. “Nothing of the kind happened,” a spokesman said.

The government-controlled Beirut radio, right-wing Phlangist radio and the Palestinian news agency WAFA said the attack centered near the strategic Khardaly Bridge between Marjayoun and Nabatiyeh, six miles north and eight miles northwest of the border. The valley and the bridge separate the Christian rightist forces of renegade Lebanese Maj.

Saad Haddad at Marjeyoun and Palestinian positions at Nabatiyeh. Beirut radio said five Israeli armored vehicles, protected by artillery fire from both Israelis and Haddad’s forces, struck at the Khardaly Bridge but were driven back by Palestinian gunfire.

There was no immediate confirmation of the report from the Lebanon government in Beirut or from other official sources. The Palestinian news agency WAFA said the shooting went on after dark. The reports said both Israeli armored vehicles and Haddad troops, armed and supported by Israel, opened the attack in the late afternoon.

The reports of new clashes again threatened a shaky cease-fire which has held in south Lebanon since Aug. 26, and came hours after Palestinian guerrillas claimed responsibility for a weekend bomb attack against a passenger train in Israel.

Phalangist radio said Monday that an Israeli force and Haddad’s troops had “infiltrated” the Khardaly Bridge and had launched rocket and artillery fire against the Palestinian-controlled “citadel” of Arnoun three miles from the Lebanese-Israeli border.

CP-1979-022 →

· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota

PLO Says It Repulsed Israeli Tanks

BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — Israeli tanks supported by artillery pushed into south Lebanon Monday but were driven back across the border by heavy Palestinian guerrilla fire, radio and Palestinian news agency reports said. In Tel Aviv, the Israeli military command denied any such attack. “Nothing of the kind happened,” a spokesman said.

U.N. headquarters in Naquora reported to New York that the clash was between the Israeli-backed Christian militas and the PLO and no Israeli armored vehicles were involved.

The government-controlled Beirut radio, right-wing Phalangist radio and the Palestinian news agency WAFA said the attack centered near the strategic Khardaly Bridge between Marjayoun and Nabatiyeh, six miles north and eight miles northwest of the border. The valley and the bridge separate the Christian rightist forces of renegade Lebanese Maj.

Saad Haddad at Marjeyoun and Palestinian positions at Nabatiyeh. Beirut radio said five Israeli armored vehicles, protected by artillery fire from both Israelis and Haddah’s forces, struck at the Khardaly Bridge but were driven back by Palestinian gunfire. The Palestinian news agency WAFA said the shooting went on after dark.

The reports said both Israeli armored vehicles and Haddad’s troops, armed and supported by Israel, opened the attack in the late afternoon. In New York, a U.N. spokesman said U.N. officials at Naquora, Lebanon, reported that Israeli-backed Christian militia had started the shooting with machine-gun fire Monday afternoon.

The Palestine Liberation Organization forces responded with two mortar rounds. The report said the Christian militia fired 90 tank and 24 artillery and mortar rounds in the next one and a half hours. U.N. headquarters then requested a halt to the fighting and the firing stopped, the report to New York said.

The reports of new clashes again threatened a shaky cease-fire, which has held in south Lebanon since Aug. 26, and came hours after Palestinian guerrillas claimed responsibility for a weekend bomb attack against a passenger train in Israel.

Phalangist radio said Monday that an Israeli force and Haddad’s troops had “infiltrated” the Khardaly Bridge and had launched rocket and artillery fire against the Palestinian-controlled “citadel” of Arnoun three miles from the Lebanese-Israeli border. A half-hour later, the radio said, Israeli artillery struck Nabatiyeh itself.

The Palestinian news agency said the Israeli shelling of Arnoun and Nabtiyeh began shortly after 5 p.m. (10 a.m. EST) and that an hour later Israeli artillery struck Nabatiyeh itself. It was the third time in five weeks that fighting has been reported around the Khardaly Bridge. Palestinians blamed the Haddad forces, supported by Israel, for attacks on Sept.

23 and again on Oct .15. The gunfire has shaken but never quite shattered the ceasefire that the United Nations managed to put together Aug. 26 to end some of the heaviest attacks in months in southern Lebanon.

CP-1979-023 →

· The Plain Dealer · Cleveland · page 14-A

Israel bars hunger strike by Arab mayors in Gaza

GAZA, Occupied Gaza Strip (AP)

GAZA, Occupied Gaza Strip (AP) — Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip demonstrated yesterday with hunger strikes, business shutdowns and sit-ins against Israel's plan to deport Nablus Mayor Bassam Shakaa. Israeli troops thwarted an organized one-day hunger strike by Palestinian Arab mayors who had planned to meet at Red Cross headquarters here.

Soldiers stopped some of the mayors as they left their West Bank towns. They stopped others at the edge of Gaza. Gaza Mayor Rashid A-Shawa was turned back before he had walked 100 yards from his home. The protests were non-violent except for one reported rock-throwing incident in the Arab sector of Jerusalem.

Shakaa was arrested last Sunday and a committee of Israel's cabinet formally decided on Wednesday to banish him from the West Bank, where he is mayor of the largest town, Nablus.

No formal charges have been brought against Shakaa, but the government claims he is sympathetic to PLO terrorist attacks and cites his record of resistance to Israeli rule and frequent anti-Israeli statements, which it says amount to incitement. Shakaa has appealed the deportation order to Israel's Supreme Court, which has scheduled a hearing on the case for Thursday.

Yesterday's hunger strikes were declared in sympathy with Shakaa, who refused solid food for the second day. General strikes closed businesses in most West Bank and Gaza towns. All three West Bank universities were closed yesterday, normally a school day.

An Israeli army officer (back to camera) tells Gaza Mayor Rashid A-Shawa (in dark suit) that he and other Gaza notables cannot attend a planned hunger strike.

The dateline the paper prints is GAZA, Occupied Gaza Strip. The scan is damaged in two places, where the story reads PLO and where it reads resistance.

CP-1979-018 →

· The New York Times

The Palestinian Mission

By Edward W. Said

The question of Palestine is a matter with a detailed history traced in the lives of the four million Palestinians. It is not something that can be made, whether by legal, military, cultural, or psychological means, to go away.

Yet the question of Palestine is a concrete historical one that can be comprehended in human terms; it is not a gigantic, psychological monster poised to threaten the entire world. But this is precisely how it has been represented.

Zionism first refused to acknowledge the existence of native inhabitants in Palestine, and when it did, it recognized only native inhabitants with no political or national rights; insofar as those natives claimed rights, the struggle for those rights was equated with terrorism, genocide, anti-Semitism.

This is not only nonsense; it is also license to extend a century of violence against Palestinians for another long period of time, and to refuse to settle with history and with truth. Worse, such an attitude insures the recurrence of more violence, more suffering, more waste, more futile “security arrangements.”

The almost total impossibility of talking rationally about the Palestinian question in the United States today is of service to no one. On every level, it is an incontrovertible fact that attitudes of negation, denial, fear will only produce more fear, less peace.

Is there not an astonishing irony in a state of affairs by which the United States does not recognize the Palestine Liberation Organization, while at the same time saying that the Palestinian question is at the center of the whole Middle East conflict?

In the end the Palestinians are not going to disappear, and fear of them and nonrecognition will not make them disappear either. I understand as best I can the fear felt by most Jews that Israel’s security is protection against future genocidal attempts on the Jewish people.

CP-1979-033 →

· The Herald Sun · Durham · page 1

Palestinian Said Tortured In Israel

Associated Press, Tyre, Lebanon

TYRE, Lebanon (AP) — A PLO spokesman said a Palestinian guerrilla whose body was returned here Wednesday was tortured to death in an Israeli prison. Israel denied the charge. The Palestine Liberation Organization spokesman, known by the codename Mustafa, said the guerrilla fighter died Dec. 21 after being imprisoned in Beersheba, Israel for nine years.

He said an autopsy would be performed on the body of Yasser Faour. An Israeli police spokesman said in Tel Aviv that pathological tests were being conducted to determine how Faour died, but said his death was “not the result of violence.”

Faour was arrested in 1970 in the village of Tershiha on the occupied West Bank of the Jordan River as he was returning from a guerrilla operation, PLO officials said. Faour’s father died mysteriously while visiting the imprisoned guerrilla in Beersheba last year, Mustafa said.

The dead guerrilla’s body was handed over to Red Cross officials who transported it across the Israel-Lebanon border a day after artillery exchanges in the area. Mustafa, who claimed that five guerrillas have died in Israeli prisons this year, said it was the first time Israel delivered a dead guerrilla across the Lebanese border.

Dead guerrillas’ bodies are ususally returned via of Jordan, although prisoner exchanges have been conducted on the Israel-Lebanon frontier. The Red Cross official in charge of southern Lebanon, Marc Dryer, said the transfer was approved by the Israelis and their rightist Lebanese Christian allies.

The rightists control a 6-mile-deep border strip of Lebanon and are enemies of the Palestinians. “We had the cooperation of all sides,” he said.

The paper prints the accusation, the denial, and the detail that the man’s father had died while visiting him in the same prison. “Ususally” is the paper’s spelling.

CP-1979-002 →

A year at a time: 1970 · 1971 · 1972 · 1973 · 1974 · 1975 · 1976 · 1977 · 1978 · 1979

Last updated 17 November 2026

Part of Covering Palestine, an archive of 3637 newspaper clippings about Palestinians printed in 748 papers between 1724 and 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles. Nothing here was printed after 6 October 2023.

The clippings belong to the newspapers and news agencies that printed them and are reproduced for research, criticism and commentary. Selection, transcription, counts and writing are © Maria Robles, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.

All decades · archive.json · Questions · Contribute a clipping · When was this printed? · How this was built · maria@rozumstudio.com