Every clipping in this archive printed between 1960 and 1969: 232 of them, oldest first, as plain text that can be read, searched and quoted without running any code. Each entry links to its own record, where the scan is.
· Herald Statesman
Gaza Strip Refugees Are Fed, Clothed, Housed
David Hinnawi
AL SHATI CAMP, GAZA STRIP — “There is little else to do, but marry and die,” said Amina Hasan, an Arab refugee woman explaining the high marriage rate among the 240,000 refugees jam-packed in the Gaza Strip. For 11 years Amina Hasan has been living in a refugee camp near Gaza along the Egyptian-Israeli border.
Last year she turned eighteen and, as do most refugee girls her age, got married right away. “In this refugee camp, only two things seem to happen — the young marry, and when their time comes, the old dies,” said Amina. “Otherwise the days are exactly the same, except for changes in weather.”
Amina’s refugee husband, Ahmed Hasan, also had nothing else to do — he just passed twenty. Getting Married No Problem “Getting married is no problem here,” he said. “You don’t have to worry about supporting your wife, getting a job or finding a place to live in.
“The ‘Agency’ takes care of all that,” he added with more bitterness than gratitude in referring to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA). Hasan and his wife live in a one-room brick house built by the U. N. Agency. Both are jobless.
There is little work in the overpopulated, underdeveloped Gaza Strip and too many idle refugees lost their homes and property in Palestine in the Arab-Israeli war of 1948.
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
Marry, Wait to Die Lament of 240,000 Gaza Refugees
Al Shati Camp, Gaza Strip—(AP)—“There is little else to do but marry and die,” said Amina Hasan, an Arab refugee woman explaining the high marriage rate among the 240,000 refugees jampacked in the Gaza Strip. For 11 years Amina Hasan has been living in a refugee camp near Gaza along the Egyptian-Israeli border.
Last year she turned 18 and, as do most refugee girls her age, got married right away. “In this refugee camp, only two things seem to happen—the young marry, and when their times comes, the old die,” said Amina. “Otherwise the days are exactly the same, except for changes in weather.”
Amina’s refugee husband, Ahmed Hasan, also had nothing else to do—he just passed 20. “Getting married is no problem here,” he said. “You don’t have to worry about supporting your wife, getting a job or finding a place to live in.
“The ‘Agency’ takes care of all that,” he added with more bitterness than gratitude in referring to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA). Hasan and his wife live in a one-room brick house built by the UN agency. Both are jobless.
There is little work in the over-populated, underdeveloped GAZA Strip and too many idle refugees who lost their homes and property in Palestine in the Arab-Israeli war of 1948.
AL SHATI CAMP, Gaza Strip—“There is little else to do, but marry and die,” said Amina Hasan, an Arab refugee woman explaining the high marriage rate among the 240,000 refugees jam-packed in the Gaza Strip. For 11 years Amina Hasan has been living in a refugee camp near Gaza along the Egyptian-Israeli border.
Last year she turned 18 and, as do most refugee girls her age, got married right away. “In this refugee camp, only two things seem to happen — the young marry, and when their time comes, the old die,” said Amina. “Otherwise the days are exactly the same, except for changes in weather.”
Amina’s refugee husband, Ahmed Hasan, also had nothing else to do — he just passed 20. “Getting married is no problem here,” he said. “You don’t have to worry about supporting your wife, getting a job or finding a place to live in.
“The ‘agency’ takes care of all that,” he added with more bitterness than gratitude in referring to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency. Hasan and his wife live in a one-room brick house built by the U.N. agency. Both are jobless.
There is little work in the overpopulated, underdeveloped Gaza Strip and too many idle refugees who lost their homes and property in Palestine in the Arab-Israeli war of 1948. At the end of each month the U.N. agency gives Hasan a ration totting up to 1,500 calories per day per person — the minimum required to keep a man’s body operating provided he does no work.
The Hasans are expecting a baby, but this does not worry them. They are pleased, for more than one reason. Amina will, at last, have something to do, and there will be more food. The baby, according to regulations, will receive a full ration. Moreover, there is a special grant of milk and eggs during pregnancy and the first months after the child’s birth.
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
The first notable Arab voice of reason concerning the million Arab refugees — a key…
1960, a year the archive held eight of. An editorial board awarding the adjective reason to one Arab voice, which tells you what it thinks of the others.
GAZA, Gaza Strip (AP)—Bullet marks streak the walls of the home of Zahia Nour, a Gaza housewife. “They are the remains of Israeli occupation in 1956. You will find them in most Gaza homes,” she explained. Why don’t you have the walls plastered? “Why should I?” shrugs Zahia. “Tomorrow, the day after, there may be more shooting.
Then I will have to paint the walls all over again.” The mood of this refugee-packed city lying on a low coastal plain within Israeli gun range is one of uncertainty and despair. The fact the United Nations Emergency Force now patrols the explosive Egyptian-Israeli border is reassuring, but inhabitants of Gaza still have their fears, says Zahia. Last fall when the U. N.
General Assembly was discussing renewal of the UNEF term, a rumor spread through Gaza that UNEG was planning to pull out. “I was going to leave right along with them,” said Zahia, “I’m getting old and I have had enough.” Since the U. N. force came here three years ago there have been no major incidents along this tense border.
The group entered Gaza early in 1957 on the heels of the withdrawing Israeli forcs, which occupied the city for about four months. Zahia, 50, mother of an 18-year-old son, remembers the occupation days well.
Three times, she says, her son was taken to the city’s main square, where he squatted on the ground under the nose of a threatening machine gun for 24 hours at a stretch.
Correction: The deck caption named the paper Morning World. The masthead on the scan reads "8-B Friday, February 5, 1960 Monroe Morning World", which also confirms the date. The machine-read headline had run two columns together.
Sale or Slaughter of Drought-Menaced Sheep Is Urged
BEERSHEBA, Israel, March 2—The Israeli Government is trying to persuade the Bedouin tribes of the Negev that they will have to sell or slaughter most of their flocks of sheep if a three-year drought continues. There is every indication it will continue.
The short winter season of rain is over and it brought the Negev’s sun-baked dusty hills only [illegible: two-digit figure] per cent of their average rainfall. For most of the country, this was the driest year in 111 years of record keeping. Putting the bad news to the Bedouins is the task of Lieut. Col.
Pinhas Amir, military governor of the Negev district, southern Israel’s triangular semidesert region. He is the man who exercises military control over these Arabs. He is also the man who ministers to their needs. “The Bedouins understand force” he says. “As long as we show force, we have no need to use it. They respect our authority.
They also turn to it for help. This is the way they run their own society. This is the life of the desert.”
Colonel Amir has spent twenty-two of his forty-four years working with or against Arabs—in Haganah, the Jewish underground army that operated in Palestine before the creation of Israel, in the Israeli Army intelligence service and, for the last two and a half years, as military governor here. He is convinced that he knows the workings of the Bedouins’ minds.
“I put myself in their skins,” he explains. And he is responsible for 15,000 Bedouins, all in a single reservation of 275,000 parched acres.
Bedouin tribesmen inspecting the livestock at the sheep market in Beersheba, Israel
Date check: A running head along the very top of the page reads “THE NEW YORK TIMES, M” — the scan is cropped at the right edge mid-word, so the paper agrees with `pub` but the date that would follow is cut off. 1960-03-14 was a Monday, which fits the surviving “M”, but the date itself is not visible. The dateline reads “BEERSHEBA, Israel, March 2”.
BEERSHEBA, Israel — Sheikh Audah Abu Muammar was entertaining guests in the big reception tent of the Azazme tribe. The Bedouin tent, pitched in the parched wilderness some 15 miles south of Beersheba, had an air of tattered majesty.
It was carpeted with colorful, patterned rugs, furnished with thick cushions — and made of old burlap bags still bearing the faded names of British sugar companies.
An aged minstrel, who accompanied himself on a primitive viol with a single string made of horsetail hair, had barely finished a song when a Bedouin strolled in and seated himself confidently at the Sheikh’s side. A lengthy conversation punctuated with much laughter ensued.
Clearly the stout man was the object of complex jokes, but he took the joshing graciously, as if this were an old story. The stout man’s father, a military government captain whispered in explanation, was a village Arab from Galilee who had fled to the Negev desert during the first World War.
The son was born in the tribal tents and has lived all of his 40-odd years among the Bedouins. He is a member of the proud Azazme tribe. To the Bedouins, however, he is still a peasant’s son and himself a peasant. “The Bedouins are animals,” the stout man said in joking response to a crack at his expense.
“We are animals?” the tall, lean Sheikh asked with mock scorn, and added: “Look at you. You’re fat!” The tribal elders gathered in a semi - circle laughed appreciatively.
Date check: No masthead, folio line or page date is on this clipping — it is a two-column cut from an inside page. The dateline carries no date at all, only “BEERSHEBA, Israel”. Nothing on the scan confirms 1960-03-31 or the Columbia Record.
BEERSHEBA, ISRAEL. — Sheikh Audah Abu Muammar was entertaining guests in the big reception tent of the Azazme tribe. The Bedouin tent, pitched in the parched wilderness some 15 miles south of Beersheba, had an air of tattered majesty.
It was carpeted with colorful, patterned rugs, furnished with thick cushions—and made of old burlap bags still bearing the faded names of British sugar companies.
An aged minstrel, who accompanied himself on a primitive viol with a single string made of horsetail hair, had barely finished a song when a Bedouin strolled in and seated himself confidently at the Sheikh’s side. A lengthy conversation punctuated with much laughter ensued.
Clearly the stout man was the object of complex jokes, but he took the joshing graciously, as if this were an old story. The stout man’s father, a military government captain whispered in explanation, was a village Arab from Galilee who had fled to the Negev desert during the first World War.
The son was born in the tribal tents and has lived all of his 40-add years among the Bedouins. He is a member of the proud Azazme tribe. To the Bedouins, however, he is still a peasant’s son and himself a peasant. “The Bedouins are animals,” the stout man said in joking response to a crack at his expense.
“We are animals?” the tall, lean Sheikh asked with mock scorn, and added: “Look at you. You’re fat!” The tribal elders gathered in a semi-circle laughed appreciatively.
Date check: The running head across the top of the page reads “CORPUS CHRISTI TIMES, M” — the scan is cropped at the right edge, so the paper agrees with `pub` but the date that follows is cut off. 1960-04-04 was a Monday, which fits the surviving “M”. The dateline gives no date, only “BEERSHEBA, ISRAEL.” The copyright line reads “(Copyright, 1960, N. Y. Herald Tribune)”, confirming the year but not the day.
Gaza Arabs Get Education But No Promise For Future
Refugee Problem
GAZA, Gaza Strip — A generation of young Arab refugees from Palestine is being educated here for a future offering little hope. It is a depressing sight, and one that becomes painfully obvious during a tour of any of the teeming refugee camps in this overcrowded strip of old Palestine.
Young men are everywhere, a few playing football, others just lolling about, and a surprisingly large number absorbed in some worn paperback political treatise or novel. You see them in empty schoolyards seated on orange crates, outside the squalid refugee huts, even lying in the dust beside a road with their backs against a wall.
They may be barefoot and badly clothed, but they are literate—a generation educated for at best an uncertain future of unemployment and waiting for a miracle to happen. In the Arab world, where mass education is still the exception rather than the rule, this literacy would ordinarily be a welcome sight.
But in the Gaza Strip, where about 300,000 refugees plus a sizable indigenous population are crammed into an area of 117 square miles, it brings up the question: Education for what? READY ANSWER At the official level, the Arabs have a ready answer. Lt. Gen.
Ahmed Salem, the Egyptian military governor of Gaza, says, “We must prepare them for the future—until they go back to Palestine.” He estimates that there are 80,000 Palestinian youths in Gaza schools today. The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine (UNRWA) says 51,000 of these are refugee youths.
They are a subject of concern to both the Arab administration and UNRWA officials, whose job to keep the refugees alive until war or the world conscience produces a solution to the refugees’ problem acceptable to all.
Until such a time, the prospect for all but a slender minority is either unemployment, under-employment or, if they are lucky, a job which, while not commensurate with their education, at least brings in a little money and keeps them occupied.
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. (AP)—Canadian Indians at the Fisher River Indian Reserve in Manitoba have given $16.37 to the U.N. Relief agency for Palestine refugees. Last Christmas they donated $24. The Rev. E. C.
Prenselaar of the reserve’s United Church of Canada Mission said interest in the Arab refugees was aroused by a radio broadcast by a Canadin solder who had served with the UN Emergency Force in the Gaza Strip.
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
Iraq Protests to U.S. Against Sen. Kennedy's Speech to Zionists
WASHINGTON (JTA)—Iraq has handed a formal diplomatic note to the State Department, protesting a recent address by Senator John F. Kennedy, Massachusetts Democrat, before the Zionist Organization of America. The Iraqi Embassy made known that it has protested to the Department here and that the Iraqi Foreign Ministry handed a note to the American Embassy in Baghdad.
According to an Iraqi news agency report the protest was lodged because the Kennedy speech “contained blatant praise of world Zionism and Jewry.”
The note said that “it is truly painful that electioneering propaganda should be exploited for the purpose of harming the Arabs and their legal rights and for supporting the usurping group which continues committing crimes against the rights of the peaceful Palestinian Arabs — a group responsible for displacing one million Arab refugees.”
The Iraqi Foreign Ministry note stated that the Kennedy speech affected American-Arab relations and that this stand was not in the interest of relations between Iraq and the United States.
A half-hour by car south of Beersheba in the Negev is a cubist landscape of jagged peaks and long plateau walls studded with Bedouin encampments. Through this desert — brown except for a lavender mantle of wildflowers in the spring — Moses and the Israelites wandered 33 centuries ago.
In the third century B.C., another group of nomads, the Nabateans, passed this way seeking a settled existence. By the time of Jesus they had built flourishing cities whose remains remarkably evoke the daily life of that period. The Nabateans were a tribal people who came from Arabia and who adopted the Aramaic language.
Long before modern-day kibbutzniks they created a water-collection system that made it possible for them to live in the desert.
Though less visually spectacular than the Nabatean capital of Petra in Jordan, their three ancient cities in the Negev — Oboda (now called Avdat), Mampsis (Mamshit) and Subeita (Shivta) — offer considerably more in the way of actual remains.
They should be seen before April 1982, when the Israeli Army completes its pullback from the Sinai and the Negev becomes a border area again. Atop a limestone plateau overlooking the desert between Yeroham and Mitzpeh Ramon are the ruins at Avdat, which was a caravan station on the road from Petra to Gaza; now Avdat is a rest stop on the road between Beersheba and Elath.
I walked through its streets, chapels, fortress and columned porticos with the hollow ring of the desert wind in my ears. The past came alive for me here as vividly as it did when I visited Pompeii and Ephesus. It is an easy 10-minute climb from the main road and entrance to the plateau’s summit.
The escarpment is dotted with burial caves, one of which was quite elaborate.
Roman and Byzantine ruins dating from the first through the sixth centuries A.D. at Avdat, which was known as Oboda in biblical times. [credit] Louis Goldman/Photo Researchers
Date check: No masthead or folio line is on this clipping, so nothing on the page states a date. BUT THE TEXT ITSELF RULES OUT 1960: the third paragraph reads “They should be seen before April 1982, when the Israeli Army completes its pullback from the Sinai and the Negev becomes a border area again.” The final Sinai withdrawal under the Camp David accords took place in April 1982, so this piece was written in or shortly before that period — roughly 1981 — not on 1960-11-02. The modern photo-typeset body face and the Photo Researchers picture credit agree with an early-1980s setting.
A woman in a white headscarf holding a child, photographed in Jabalia in 1960 and printed in Louisville. The caption gives the camp and the territory and no names. The headline calls them forgotten people, which is a paper conceding that its own readers had not been told. Jabalia appears in this archive across sixty years: here, in 1987 with one army base inside its boundaries (CP-1987-005), in 2003 as a boy holding a bomb casing in the rubble of his house (CP-2003-001), and in 2014 as a girl taking cover against a wall (CP-2014-011).
TEL AVIV, Israel, Feb. 1—An Israeli Army unit patrolling the desert killed two armed Bedouin, it was announced tonight by army headquarters. A third was wounded and captured during an exchange of fire in the Negev.
Date check: No masthead or folio line on this clipping — it is a trimmed single-column brief. Under the headline stands the credit line “Special to The New York Times”, which agrees with `pub`. The dateline reads “TEL AVIV, Israel, Feb. 1”, consistent with publication on 1961-02-02, but no year appears on the scan.
“‘Justice My Duty.’ Eichmann judge showed independence in Arab case.”
Louisville, April 1961. Benjamin Halevi is about to try Adolf Eichmann, and an American paper introduces him to its readers through the case in which he convicted Israeli policemen of murdering Arabs. The two trials in one sentence, by a paper in Kentucky.
Nomads to Be Encouraged to Settle in Negev Instead
By LAWRENCE FELLOWS, Special to The New York Times.
BEERSHEBA, Israel, April 22—The Israeli Government has abandoned a plan to move the Bedouin tribes out of the Negev Desert and into houses in the populated interior of the country. “They are wise,” explained Hassan Abu Rubeya, the tall and powerfully-built leader of the Abu Rubeya tribe. “They are wise, because this is our land.
There is no reason why we should move.” Instead, the Government will undertake a long-range program to entice these Arabs with roads, schools and water into five or six places in the Negev where they will be encouraged to leave their tents and build houses of stone so that the Government can better keep an eye on them.
The Government contends that it would provide the Bedouins with services more easily that way. But this is only about the sixth reason for the whole effort, according to Lieut. Col. Pinhas Amir, the military governor of the Negev. “The first five reasons, in order,” Colonel Amir explained, “are security, security, security, security and security.”
Date check: No masthead or folio line on this clipping — it is a trimmed single column. The credit under the byline reads “Special to The New York Times.”, which agrees with `pub`. The dateline reads “BEERSHEBA, Israel, April 22”. The slide-label date is 1961-04-30, eight days later; the scan carries no date of its own.
ATLANTIC CITY N. J. (UPI)—Seif Eddine Zu’pi, mayor of Nazareth, Israel, charged Wednesday night that more than one half of Arab refugees supposedly in camps in nations near Israel have been absorbed into the population of those countries but propagandists have been “secretive” about it.
Zu’pi, a Moslem, said Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon now hold some 300,000 in the camps but have not told the story of the absorption of the majority of the refugees from Israel. He said the Arabs would not return to Israel “even if they were offered the opportunity.”
Zu’pi is in the United States to attend the International Mayor’s Conference in Washington. The 150,000 Arabs who live in Israel today, Zu’pi said, have full citizenship rights and are “loyal citizens.”
A Palestinian mayor of Nazareth, touring the United States, arguing the opposite of what most Palestinian voices in this archive argue. The paper prints him without a reply.
MIDDLEBORO, Mass., Aug. 11—Mrs. J. Edward Wiksten has announced the engagement of her daughter, Miss Barbara Donne Heleen, to Ibrahim Ibrahim, an artist. He is the son of Mr. and Mrs. Hanna Ibrahim of Reiny, Nazareth, Israel. The couple will be married in Jerusalem next month. Miss Heleen, daughter also of the late William A. Heleen, received an A.
B. degree in theatre arts last year from Brandeis University. She lives in Jerusalem. Her fiancé studied at the Bezalel Art School in Jerusalem under an Israeli Government scholarship and won an award at the first Biennale of Young Painters at the Museum of Modern Art in Haifa last year.
The director of the U. N. Relief and Works Agency for Palestine refugees is once more compelled to report to the General Assembly that this tragic problem has not been solved. The costs for the basic necessities are, and have been for years, seven cents a day for each refugee. Nobody under U. N. R. W. A.’s supervision is starving for food.
What they are starving for is hope. The problem is not simple. It never has been. The very number of the refugees has been uncertain. Are the children of refugees also refugees? They have to be taken care of. Are all those who describe themselves as refugees actually refugees?
What is certain is that there are about a quarter of a million persons recognized as refugees in the Gaza Strip, about half a million in Jordan and about 100,000 each in Syria and Lebanon. Whether other Arab states could take in some of these displaced persons is in dispute. They are not doing it. Under Henry Labouisse and more recently under John H. Davis, U. N. R. W.
A. has tried not only to the keep the refugees alive but to train them, especially the younger ones, to be self-supporting. The annual cost is about $34 million, to which the agency proposes to add $16 million during the next three years for vocational training. This constructive work could be more intensive if all members of the U.
N. contributed; but as it is the money for it is again running out. At present the United States, Great Britain and Canada put in more than 90 per cent of the funds. Russia and her satellites have contributed nothing.
BEERSHEBA, Israel. ISRAEL is nursing a fond hope that she can somehow persuade the 16,000 Bedouin of the Negev Desert to settle down. Only recently, the Government offered to help build stone houses for these nomadic Arabs in Lydda, Ramle and in other towns of the populated interior.
Two families accepted; the others showed not the faintest sign of folding their black, goat-hair tents. Before Israel became a state there were probably close to 70,000 Bedouin scattered over the Negev, a barren, undulating section of Israel, wedged like an arrowhead between Jordan and Egypt’s Sinai Peninsula.
Most fled Israel during her war with the Arab states, or have since been driven into Jordan and Sinai. But for those who stayed, things have remained pretty much the same. A few have bought transistor radios and some have taken to fancy shoes instead of sandals. But the Bedouin, with their flowing robes, are still children of the desert.
They have learned to adapt to the desert, rather than to struggle against it. Rain is sparse, and the soil ungrateful. Forced to wander with their flocks and tents in search of pasture, as they have for centuries, they give little cooperation to the Israeli authorities who have been trying to confine them to a 275,000-acre reservation.
… (Continued from Page 69) in Wadi Shegheb, which is very near Beersheba.” “How long would it take to walk to Beersheba from here?” “About the time to smoke two cigarettes.” The Bedouin measure many things in cigarettes, even the height of the scraggly barley, wheat and durra they plant in the spring and fall.
The men do the plowing, for the plow is pulled by camel and no woman handles this noble animal. Anyway, the women already are burdened with drawing water and almost all other routine labor. DESPITE their wanderings the Bedouin now plant about 10,000 acres.
But when the sowing is done they feel freed from any further obligation to the soil and return happily to their flocks and the unending search for pasture. Packing everything, to the last battered cooking pot, they follow the ancient routes the patriarchs took—southward into Sinai, and northward into Judaea and Samaria, returning, finally, in time for the harvest.
Their social culture is deep and their sense of humor is nothing short of magnificent: a group of Bedouin, having noticed that the small water line into the Negev is extended only in election years, has just petitioned the Government to hold elections every year. While the Bedouin stick as much as they can to their nomadic ways, they have more trouble with each passing year.
For one thing, the Jewish settlements in Judaea and Samaria do not exactly welcome these wanderers to their new fields and orchards. For another, part of old Judaea is now Jordanian territory, and the Israeli authorities are no happier about the traffic into Jordan than they are about the traffic into Sinai.
FLOUR, sugar and kerosene flow out of Israel with the Bedouin, and animals, playing cards, demitasse sets and sundry other items are brought back. Families are split and reunited, wives are bought and sold—and the Government just can’t keep up with it all. The Israeli Army says frankly it is unable to stop the crossings.
However, Israel has not given up its desire to see its Bedouin settled and it is now working on a long-range program to entice them into five or six centers in the Negev where they can be watched more easily. Eventually, water will be drawn, roads laid, schools and clinics built. Those tribesmen wishing to build houses anywhere else will be forbidden to do so.
Perhaps the Bedouin will move their tents closer to the amenities. Perhaps, in time, they will live in houses of stone. The desert has taught them not to struggle against their environment. The Israeli Government is counting on this.
Wandering Bedouin and transport in the Negev Desert.
Date check: DATE CONFIRMED ON THE PAGE. A folio line at the foot of the clipping reads “NOVEMBER 5, 1961”, which matches the slide-label date of 1961-11-05 exactly. No paper name appears anywhere on the scan; the page furniture (a magazine folio date with no running head, a drop-cap opening and “Continued on Page 72”) is that of a Sunday magazine section.
Huts and Walls of Mud Isolate Palestine Refugees in Mideast
By DANA ADAMS SCHMIDT
JERICHO, Jordan, Nov. 12—Here in the bleak shadow of the Mount of Temptation, on the arid side of the Jordan Valley, are scattered the mud huts of 8[illegible],000 Palestine refugees. Their hopeless isolation bears out the observation on camp life made a few days ago by Henry K[illegible]rvich, director of the Kalandia vocational training center.
“Once they’re in training, I don’t let my boys go back to the camps,” he declared. “Every time they do, they come back with a morale problem.” “The people have deteriorated in those camps. You’d be surprised—the language, the filth, in every sense the cultivated hopelessness.”
This correspondent has been visiting the camps—in Jordan, Lebanon and the Gaza Strip—and the men and institutions whose task it is to bring hope to the hopeless. When the refugees poured out of the Israeli-held parts of Palestine in 1948 and 1949 most of them settled where they first found security. At first they sought caves or pitched tents.
Then, depending on soil and weather, they built mud huts in traditional style or put together shacks of flattened kerosene tins and oil drums. That is where most of them are today.
UNITED NATIONS, N. Y., Nov. 25—Following are excerpts from a report to the United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine by its special representative, Dr. Joseph E.
Johnson, and the text of the report’s conclusions: Despite all too frequent signs of intransigence and even of a bellicose attitude, I believe that responsible statesmen on both sides want peace in a general way and as a long-term goal.
Unhappily, however, these statesmen have not yet been able or willing to translate that generalized desire into a sufficiently strong and active search for peace with the “other side” to make certain adjustments that would seem to be necessary for true peace in the area.
Indeed the public record, as can be seen very clearly from the summaries of the positions of the governments in the two recent working papers of the commission, reveals a consistency of obdurate determination on both sides. There is even evidence that the passage of time has witnessed a hardening of public positions on some issues.
No one who has had an opportunity to confer at length with responsible statesmen in the area can fail to conclude that there is a large degree not only of mistrust and suspicion but of active fear on both sides.
“Nothing I have ever seen in Hong Kong, India or elsewhere compares to the frightful conditions of Camp Wavell and Gouraud, near Baalbeck in Lebanon… No one can tell me that the Arabs want to remain in this type of camp. I don’t believe it… Americans do not know the truth about the Arab refugee situation.”
An Arab-American weekly reporting a gift from the anti-Zionist American Council for Judaism. Henry S. Moyer, the fund’s president, had been to the camps. The loans bought sewing machines, carpenter tools, fruit and grocery stands and cobblers’ equipment — the same object the Mennonites brought to Surif in 1970 and the same one the Surif Women’s Cooperative was still working with in 2023.
CAIRO, March 9 (AP) — President Nasser today proclaimed a constitution for the Gaza Strip, a coastal segment of Palestine that has been under Egyptian administration since the Arab-Israeli war of 1948. He said, however, a Palestine state is the goal.
A presidential decree declared Gaza is “an integral part of Palestine lands and its people (many of them among the million Arab refugees of the war) are part of the Arab nation.” The new constitution, Nasser said, is applicable in Gaza until such time as a permanent constitution is issued for a Palestine state.
‘Guaranteees Equality’ The decree said the Palestinians in Gaza will form a national union with “the aim of restoring the usurped lands in Palestine.” The decree guaranteed for Palestinians equality of rights and duties with no discrimination of race, language or religion; and individual freedom of expression and private ownership.
The decree also organized executive, legislative and judiciary branches of the Gaza government. An appointed governor general will head the executive council of 10 directors responsible for economy, finance, education, health and security.
The governor general will head the legislative council comprising the executive council, 22 elected members of national union committees and 10 members appointed by the governor general.
CAIRO (AP)—President Gamal Abdel Nasser proclaimed a constitution Friday for the Gaza Strip, a coastal segment of Palestine that has been under Egyptian administration since the Arab-Israeli war of 1948. He said, however, a Palestine state is the goal.
A presidential decree declared Gaza is “an integral part of Palestine lands and its people—many of them among the million Arab refugees of the war—are part of the Arab nation.” The new constitution, Nasser said, is applicable in Gaza until such time as a permanent constitution for a Palestine state is issued. IT’S NATIONAL UNION.
The decree said the Palestinians in Gaza will form a national union with “the aim of restoring the usurped lands in Palestine.” The decree guaranteed for Palestinians equality of rights and duties with no discrimination of race, language or religion; and individual freedom of expression and private ownership.
The decree also organized executive, legislative and judiciary branches of the Gaza government. An appointed governor general will head the executive council of 10 directors responsible for economy, finance, education, health and security.
The governor general will head the legislative council comprised of the executive council, 22 elected members of national union committees and 10 members appointed by the governor general. WITHDREW IN 1956.
The armed forces stationed in the Gaza Strip, the constitution said, will be subject to a command to be determined by the supreme command of the United Arab Republic armed forces. Nasser’s forces withdrew from Gaza in 1956 during the Suez crisis, but returned after the cessation of hostilities and the stationing of a U.N.
Emergency Force along the demarcation line separating Gaza from Israeli territory.
JERUSALEM (Israeli Sector), April 18—Salim Hussary became today probably the most popular man in Jerusalem. He is a retired grocer and a Christian Arab and as such he is the only person authorized to sell bread to the non-Jewish population in the city and the surrounding area for the week of Passover, which began tonight with the rise of the first full moon of spring.
Long before sundown the last grocers in Jerusalem had cleaned out their stores of bread and at least symbolically of beer and noodles and anything else with a vestige of ferment that could make dough rise. Throughout the day housewives came in a steady procession to the little stone house of Salim in the former Greek colony of Jerusalem to place their orders for bread.
By the end of the day he had taken orders for 3,100 loaves, which he will fetch in three trips through the week from a bakery that will stay in operation in Tel Aviv.
Will Not Discourage Attempt at Direct Mid-East Negotiations
JERUSALEM — (JTA) — The Cabinet has approved the Foreign Ministry’s recommendations about the stand to be adopted by the Israel delegation at the forthcoming United Nations General Assembly on various items on the agenda.
The recommendations presented by Foreign Minister Golda Meir followed deligerations held during the past week at the Foreign Ministry with the participation of Ambassador Michael Comay, chairman of the Israel UN delegation. It is understood that Israel will not discourage any possible move on the part of some nations to call for direct Israel-Arab negotiations.
Such a move was initiated last year by a number of African and Latin American countries and received support of 34 states. It failed, however, to get the necessary majority to ensure its passage. Both the Soviet Union and the United States opposed the move last year on the grounds that it was poorly timed.
In the contest for the post of President of the Assembly between representatives of Pakistan and Ceylon, Israel’s expected to back the latter. The major issue of the Arab refugees was discussed by the Cabinet only briefly and will be taken up again after the publication of reports by Dr. John H.
Davis, commissioner-general of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees, and by Joseph Johnson, Palestine Conciliation Commission to the Middle East. No change was envisaged in Israel’s stand on this issue.
The appointment of Parliamentary members of Israel’s delegation to the General Assembly was postponed until next week’s cabinet session because of difficulties that developed within Herut and the National Religious party over the nominations of delegates.
Arab Refugee Camp Is Still A Major Problem After 14 Years
Leaders Refuse To Admit Israel Exists
HYDE PARK, N.Y.—The plight of the Arab refugees who left Israel as a result of the 1948 war in Palestine continues to be a troublesome problem in the Near East after years of fruitless attempts to solve it. To understand the nature of the problem, one must go back to that unhappy period in 1948 after the U.N. had drawn the boundaries for the new state of Israel.
For many years previously, land had been bought by individuals and organizations for refugees from countries where the Jews were being oppressed. These refugees settled in rural areas and both Great Britain and the United States had agreed that their settlements in Palestine should be the nucleus of a future homeland for the Jews. But the Arab states would have none of this.
Their attitude was that Israel had no right to exist and hence no right to set up a government. They refused to accept the boundaries drawn by the U.N. and announced that they would drive these few people who called themselves Israelis into the sea.
In the war that followed, as in all wars, there were cruelties and atrocities and each side felt that the opening side was the one really to blame.
The Arabs in Israel became fearful of the treatment they might receive during the hostilities, whereupon the Mufti in Jerusalem, as the representative of the Arabs, called on them to leave Palestine temporarily until the Arab army had driven the Israelis into the sea.
He advised them to leave their possessions behind, and they were taken in British lorries to the nearby Arab countries for temporary refuge. The Israelis, of course, won the war. Those Arabs who had possessed the courage to stay where they were are still there, in possession of their homes and belongings.
But those who heeded the Mufti’s call and fled the land were naturally unable to return. Thus the governments of the Arab states had to set them up in camps and take on the problem of their economic support.
Mrs. Roosevelt
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
“The U.S. Food for Peace program will provide 95,000 tons of floor to help feed 1 million Palestine refugees in Jordan, the Gaza Strip, Lebanon and Syria. The program will be administered by the United Nations Relief & Works Agency (UNRWA).
Use of surplus products, under the Food for Peace program, has enabled the United States to reduce its cash contribution to the UNRWA.”
Four sentences in a Black Mississippi weekly in 1962. A million Palestine refugees, counted, in a note about American surplus grain — and the last sentence is about what the arrangement saves the United States. “floor” is the paper’s.
Israel: Eighty students from Jewish secondary schools went to Acre for ten days to attend Arab schools, work in bakeries and nurseries, and watch the local Kadi administering Muslim law in the religious court. The boys, numbering 30, stayed at a Dervish monastery, according to a special religious permit from the Kadi.
The fifty girls who stayed at a hotel, heard lectures in Arabic, met local Arab youth, and visited homes and neighboring villages. The visit was aimed at improving understanding between the students and the Arab population, as well as polishing up their Arabic.
This is the first time that such a study-tour has taken place in Acre, as well as the first time that half of the teaching staff was composed of Arabs.
Short news brief, no byline. The lede begins with a standing geographic label 'Israel:' rather than a dateline. People of Palestine are called 'Arabs', 'local Arab youth' and 'the Arab population'; the word Palestinian does not appear. No ordinary individual is named - the only person referred to is 'the local Kadi', unnamed.
By Mohamed Mirghani — Editor’s Note: Mohamed Mirghani, managing editor of the Arab News Agency in the Sudan and Khartoum Correspondent of Newsweek Magazine, is here on a State Department exchange program for six weeks at The Patriot Ledger.
“The United Nations Special Political Committee this week will once more resume its discussions of the problems of the Palestinian Arab refugees living in the various camps in the Middle East under the responsibility of the United Nations.
Thorny Issue. …The overall conflict is a result of the Arab-Israeli war over Palestine in 1948. That war, beside bringing Israel into being, created the long-existing differences among the Arab States which accused each other of being responsible for the loss of war and loss of Palestine… Dr.
Johnson, an American acting for the United Nations, proposed settlement of the conflict through the return of refugees, who wish to do so, to Israel, with Israel giving them full right of citizenship. Others who prefer to stay where they are now in the guest countries of the United Arab Republic, Syria, Iraq, Jordan and Lebanon, Dr.
Johnson suggested, should be taken permanently as citizens of those countries and be treated accordingly… The Jordanian ambassador to the United Nations, Sayed Abdel Moneium El Rifai, who was assigned by the Arabs to convey their views to Dr. Johnson, said: ‘I have told Dr. Johnson that the Arabs not only reject the plan but reject even the idea of considering it.
We still hold to our first position that the solution only remains in the historic United Nations General Assembly resolution sanctioning the right of the Arab refugees to go back to their land and home.’ So, the failure of Dr.
Johnson’s proposals keeps the whole problem unsettled, leaving the unrest and security dangers as they always have been in the Middle East area for the past 12 years…
Sensitive Issue. …no Arab state, politician or individual will dare to express any other view than the absolute right of the Arab refugees to take back the land now occupied by Israel.
I will suggest no solution myself here, other than expressing a hope that the question will be solved, and the sooner the better to release the Middle East from its present existing state of tension.”
An Arab journalist, writing under his own name across a full width of an American paper in December 1962, on a State Department exchange. The editor’s note explains who he is and why he is there. He sets out the American proposal, quotes the Jordanian ambassador rejecting it, says what the Arab states will and will not say in public, and then declines to offer a solution himself. The phrase in the headline is Palestinian Arab refugees — the adjective and the noun together, in 1962, two years before the Palestine Liberation Organization existed.
Assembly Votes For Extension Of Aid to Palestinian Refugees
By KATHLEEN TELTSCH
Palestinian in a New York Times headline in 1962 — two years before the PLO was founded, and before the date usually given for the word acquiring its present sense.
U.S. Senator's Illicit Jordan Trip Helped Sow Revolt
Javits and Unnamed Congressman Blamed
Jerusalem, Jordan, April 25—Two irregular crossings of the Jordan border by a U.S. senator and a congressman played a leading role in weakening the Cabinet of King Hussein and sowing parliamentary revolt.
One incident, hushed up by censorship, put into ferment the 600,000 refugees from Israeli Palestine who were waiting in Jordan for United Arab Republic President Gamal Abdel Nasser to give them new leadership.
Even while cross-bearing pilgrims toiled up the Mount of Olives during Easter week the prediction was whispered in Jerusalem’s stony bazaar: “The whole west bank will blow up as soon as the Christian pilgrims leave.”
The visit of the first of the two pro-Zionist American politicians, with its far reaching political unrest, occurred in the late winter under these circumstances, reports of which were strictly censored at the time.
Just outside the plush new hotels of flourishing Arab Jerusalem lie the two festering refugee camps of Akbat Jabar, with 40,000 people living in shacks, and Ein Salta, with 15,000. In both, the refugees face their lost homes inside Israel’s barbed wire.
KING HUSSEIN — Winked at banned trip. SENATOR JACOB JAVITS — Aroused Palestinian ire.
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
“Rabbi Elmer Berger, a leading anti-Zionist spokesman executive vice president of the American Council For Judaism, yesterday urged givers to the United Jewish Appeal to understand what they are involved in when they contribute to it.
‘No U.S. citizen should be asked or pressured into giving money to a fund which is partially in the interest of a foreign state,’ he said, at a press conference in Hotel Sheraton-Cleveland.
He urged newspaper, television and radio representatives to help American Jews understand what is involved in their support of Zionism, which he described as ‘an extremely sophisticated movement.’ RABBI BERGER asserted that efforts to get a thorough accounting of the final allocation of all money raised by the United Jewish Appeal have not been successful.
‘We have to deal with this problem rationally and responsibly,’ he explained. ‘We understand the emotional support for Israel and Zionism, especially since Hitler.’ Rabbi Berger said he was not sure that in 50 years any of the small states in the Middle East, including Israel, would be in existence. HE SAID THAT the American Council For Judaism has its own philanthropic fund.
He said his organization’s membership was not growing rapidly but asserted its influence was expanding. The council is a national organization of anti-Zionist Americans of Jewish faith.”
Jewish anti-Zionism in a mainstream metropolitan daily in 1963, with a press conference, a local chapter and forty people at a reception in Shaker Heights.
Weizmann's Book Disavers Alleged Bribe to Ibn Saud
NEW YORK —(JTA)— Allegations made by Lt. Col. Harold Hoskins, an emissary for President Roosevelt, who said the late Dr. Chaim Weizmann allegedly offered a bribe to King Saud of Saudi Arabia, were shown here to be completely baseless. The charge that Dr.
Weizmann had offered a bribe of 20,000,000 pounds sterling to King Saud for Jewish control of Palestine was contained in a 1943 memorandum by Hoskins to President Roosevelt. The State Department published the memorandum last weekend, among other documents, in “Foreign Relations of the United States, Vol. IV, the Near East and Africa.” Col.
Hoskins had been known during World War II for his pro-Arab attitude. Dr. Weizmann, then president of the World Zionist Organization, dealt with the Hoskins allegations and other related issues in his 1950 autobiography, “Trial and Error.”
He wrote that not only had he never made such an offer, but “in fact,” some such an offer had been made to him by St. John Philby, a representative of King Saud. Talked to Churchill In his book, Dr. Weizmann described how he was asked to go to the United States because President Roosevelt wanted him to work on the problem of synthetic rubber. In March, 1943, Dr.
Weizmann planned the trip but before doing so, visited Prime fice to say farewell to Churchill’s Minister Winston Churchill’s of-private secretary, John Martin, who suggested he see Churchill for a moment. Dr. Weizmann said Churchill had wished him luck on the trip to the United States and then told Dr.
Weizmann: “I want you to know that I have a plan, which of course can only be carried into effect when the war is over. I would like to see Ibn Saud made lord of the Middle East — the boss of bosses — provided he settles with you.” According to Dr. Weizmann, Churchill said “you might talk it over with Roosevelt when you get to America.” Dr.
Weizmann recorded that he was “rather dazed” by Churchill’s remarks.
Arabs Create Organization For Recovery of Palestine
The founding of the Palestine Liberation Organization, reported from the Jerusalem congress of May 1964 — three years before Israel occupied the West Bank and Gaza. Until this clipping the archive held almost nothing from the organization’s first years.
JERUSALEM, Jordan Sector (AP)—Ahmad Shukairy, longtime spokesman for Palestinian Arabs, has announced creation of “the Palestine Liberation Organization” to work for return of lands now held by Israel. The organization was formed by 400 delegates to a Palestine national conference, which elected Shukairy as its president.
He is a Palestine-born Arab who has represented both Syria and Saudi Arabia at the United Nations.
Ahmad Shukairy announces creation of the Palestine Liberation Organization
AHMAD SHUKAIRY, long-time spokesman for Palestinian Arabs, announced Friday creation of “the Palestine Liberation Organization” to work for return of lands now held by Israel. The organization was formed by 400 delegates to a Palestine national conference, which elected Shukairy as its president.
He is a Palestine-born Arab who has represented both Syria and Saudi Arabia at the United Nations.
Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
JERUSALEM, Jordan Sector (AP)—Ahmad Shukairy, longtime spokesman for Palestinian Arabs announced creation of “the Palestine Liberation Organization” to work for return of lands now held by Israel. The organization was formed by 400 delegates to a Palestine national conference, which elected Shukairy as its president.
He is a Palestine-born Arab who has represented both Syria and Saudi Arabia at the United Nations.
“…chosen last January at a conference of Arab leaders in Cairo to establish what is now referred to as the ‘Palestine entity.’”
PALESTINIANS in a New York Times headline in May 1964. The body calls the thing being founded a Palestine entity, in quotation marks, which is the paper hedging on a word its own headline has already used.
The same founding congress on the same day as the New York Times headline about Palestinians. Los Angeles calls it an Arab unit; New York calls them Palestinians.
Damascus (AP)—The English-language Kuwait Times reports Kuwait has ordered a 5 per cent monthly income tax on all the thousands of Palestinians working there to be channeled by the finance ministry to the Palestine Liberation organization.
How the new organization was financed, in a Kansas City brief: a levy on Palestinian workers in Arab states.
Palestinian Artists Depict Tragedy of Great Exodus
Worth a Thousand Words
“Two Palestinian artists, the husband and wife team of Ismail and Tamam Shammout, today are looking back to the experience of their recent exhibition, warmed by the reception of Valley viewers and still carrying the memory of faces, both old and young, as they first looked upon the canvases.
The exhibit, called the Arab Art Show and held at UCLA International Center, depicted the story, through pigment and brush, of the artists’ own personal tragedy, lived with almost a million other Palestinians… A native of Lydda, Ismail was only 17 when he trekked out of his home town in 1948 with his family and 80,000 other refugees.
A frail, 3-year-old brother died of thirst and exhaustion on the 24-hour exodus under a searing sun to the nearest Arab town. Here, for the first few years of refugee life, Ismail earned an existence selling bread and fruits. It was not until four years later that he could even afford paper and pencil.
After teaching for a short time at a Quaker refugee school in Gaza, where the classroom was a tent and the students sat on the floor, Ismail went to Cairo where he finally managed to join the School of Fine Arts. Here the boy worked daily until midnight to earn his scant living. But with all the hardships and privations, there was one consolation: There was Tamam.
Tamam was another Palestinian refugee with an almost identical background, from Jaffa.
She and Ismail were bound closer together when they discovered that each sought the same goal — to put on canvas, the plight of their countrymen… Both now have built themselves a name of international honor, with their lives still devoted to the original goal of recording for all time, in the blood-reds, the deep blacks, the grays and the earth-browns of their palettes, the tragedy of Palestine.”
[TOP PHOTOGRAPH] GREAT BEAUTY shines from face of subject in this painting of wife Tamam by Ismail Shammout, right. Selective brush strokes portray sensitivity, warmth of Tamam, with more, both seen and unseen and understood only by those who know both husband and wife and tragedy shared by artists in earlier years. With Ismail are Dr.
Abe Farid, scientist at UCLA, and wife Fawkia Farid MD, whose offices are in Northridge. Couple lives in Sherman Oaks. Dr.
Abe Farid heads art exhibit’s sponsoring United States Organization for Medical and Educational Needs Inc. — The News photo [LOWER PHOTOGRAPH] POIGNANT SCENE is portrayed in outstanding work shown at just closed Arabic Art Show by internationally renowned husband and wife team Ismail and Tamam Shammout. Among those from Valley attending event from left are Mrs.
Chester Sidell, Mrs. George El Kouri and 15-year-old daughter Patti, all of Encino. Exhibition was held at UCLA International Center. — The News photo
The archive had nothing from 1964 before this. A suburban California paper, nineteen years before the word Nakba reaches American print, describing the expulsion from Lydda, eighty thousand people on the road and a three-year-old dead of thirst on the way — on a page of local news, under a standing head that reads Worth a Thousand Words. The dead child is the only person in the story who is not named. The exhibition was held at the UCLA International Center, and one of the two photographs on the page names Dr. Abe Farid, a scientist at UCLA, who headed its sponsor — the United States Organization for Medical and Educational Needs. Twenty-three years later the same Los Angeles organisation appears in the government’s case against the eight Palestinians arrested in Los Angeles in 1987.
After 17 Years, 30,000 Refugees Still Wait at Aqabat Jaber
After 17 Years, 30,000 Refugees Still Wait at Aqabat Jaber to Return to Palestine — By BROOKS ATKINSON
Brooks Atkinson, the Times' former chief drama critic turned correspondent, in the largest refugee camp in the Jordan valley. The headline names the camp, the number, the years, and what they are waiting for.
Palestinian Arabs Reportedly Engaged in Sabotage Campaign
Beirut (UPI)
Beirut (UPI) — A secret commando organization of Palestinian Arabs is reported to have started a campaign of sabotage against targets inside Israel. The organization, calling itself “Al-Asifa” — Arabic for storm troops — has issued nine communiques describing such attacks since early January.
Observers say it is the first such campaign since 1955-56 when Egyptian-trained Palestinian “fedayeen” (the faithful) carried out raids inside Israel from the neighboring Gaza Strip. Al-Asifa's communique No. 1, published here Jan. 4, said the “newly created, clandestine” commando outfit, dedicated to regaining Palestine, had “started operations inside Israel.”
A leading pro-Egyptian Beirut newspaper, apparently caught off guard, immediately labeled the organization as part of a “plot by Israel and CENTO” designed “to give Israel an excuse before international public opinion to wage aggression against neighboring Arabs.”
When the government-controlled Cairo press later began publishing Al-Asifa communiques straight, the pro-Egyptian papers here followed suit and there has been no more talk of an Israeli or CENTO plot. The Israelis themselves have publicly acknowledged only two attacks, both times giving somewhat different and far less dramatic accounts of the same incidents.
The paper glosses fedayeen as “the faithful.” The word means those who sacrifice themselves.
Beirut — Seventeen years after the Arab-Israeli War of 1948, the Palestinian refugees — now numbering more than 1,500,000 — are still living in exile and appalling poverty, that would not be considered suitable for hogs on a good United States farm.
They are all-but-forgotten dependents of the United Nations, which voted to partition their homeland in November, 1947, and now supports them at less than 10 cents a day a person for food, shelter, education and health services. Their rations, dietetically unbalanced and inadequate, cost only 4½ cents a day.
They live in squalid mud brick huts, and many families with half a dozen or more children are crowded into single rooms 10 feet square. HOPE, PRAY, SWEAR. The Arabs hope and pray — and some swear — to return. I have visited United Nations Relief and Works Agency headquarters in Lebanon, Jordan, and the Gaza Strip of Palestine, now under Egyptian Administration.
I have visited Israel. School boys and girls in the Gaza Strip still sing “Innana A’Edoun” (We Shall Return) just as they did when I visited seven years ago. Yet the attitude of the refugees is changing. They are obviously disillusioned and less hopeful.
“Our people are more determined than ever to go back, but they no longer believe in promises,” said Ibrahim Abu Kish, leader of the sprawling Aqabat Jaber Camp in Jordan. “They have had so many promises from the United Nations, UNRWA, and others that they don’t believe anybody. They believe they must rely upon their own efforts.”
“MILLION COULD STAY.” “We would be generous,” Hamdi Hirzallah, Gaza leader of the new Palestine Liberation Organization said. “The Jews who were in Palestine in 1948 — 650 thousand or whatever it was — could stay there, together with their natural increase. We could accommodate one million of them if necessary.
But all those Jews who came to Palestine after 1948 would have to go back where they came from.” Some refugees say they would be willing to go back and live in Israel. “DIRE POVERTY.”
“It is clear,” he writes, “that a large part of the refugee community is still living today in dire poverty, often under pathetic and in some cases appalling conditions.” Life in some of the camps in winter is cold and wet. There is no heat. Many of the camps are ankle-deep in mud. The summers are hot and dry and dust swirls through the narrow alleys.
There are no sewers and the improvised drainage systems — mostly shallow ditches — repugnant to sight and smell. In the Burj El Barajneh Camp, south of Beirut, for instance, the stench is intolerable. CHILDREN GROW UP. Old people live out their wretched lives and children by the thousands are born and grow up in dehumanizing poverty and hopelessness.
On June 30 there were 1,280,823 registered refugees. More than half of them are under 18 and thus were born in exile. The monthly ration a person is 22 pounds of flour, 1.3 pounds each of sugar and dried peas, beans, lentils, etc., 1.1 pounds of rice and 13 ounces of oil or fat.
This provides a daily average of 15 hundred calories a person, which is increased to 16 hundred calories in the five winter months. CAKE OF SOAP. Each refugee gets one cake of soap each month and, in the five winter months, three pints of kerosene a month.
Refugees look upon Israel as their arch enemy, but they blame the United Nations and particularly the United States for the adoption of the Palestine Partition Resolution in 1947. Many of their leaders are familiar with the statement of James P.
Forrestal, Secretary of Defense in the Truman Administration, that “coercion and duress on other nations” to pass the partition resolution “bordered closely onto scandal.” The refugees feel that the United Nations has further betrayed them by failing to carry out Paragraph 11 of its famous Resolution 194, adopted December 11, 1948.
In that paragraph the General Assembly resolved “that the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live in peace with their neighbors should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date and that compensation should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return.”
Thus it is clear that world opinion, to the extent that it is expressed by the U.N., holds that Israel has not discharged its responsibility to the refugees.
The same reporter, the same week, and a headline that measures a million and a half people against American livestock in order to make them visible. The comparison is the writer’s own and it is meant sympathetically, which is what makes it worth keeping: in 1965 the way to get an American reader to look at Palestinian refugees was to tell him they were housed worse than his hogs. The detail underneath is precise in a way the headline is not. Rations costing four and a half cents a day. One cake of soap a month. Fifteen hundred calories, sixteen hundred in winter. 1,280,823 registered refugees, more than half of them under eighteen and therefore born in exile. The man quoted at length as the new Palestine Liberation Organization’s leader in Gaza is Hamdi Hirzallah — the same man who served as this reporter’s escort and interpreter at the ration window in the companion piece.
GAZA, Palestine, Sept. 26 — Refugee women were filing thru the ration distribution center of Gaza’s Beach camp, collecting a 15-day allotment of flour, rice, lentils, sugar, and vegetable oil. A woman behind the wire screen saw this reporter, notebook at the ready, talking to Hamdi Hirzallah, his escort and interpreter.
As interpreted by Hirzallah, she said: “Why don’t you stop giving us these miserable rations and help us get back to our homes? We’ve been here 17 years. Isn’t that long enough? We’d rather go back home and eat grass, if we had to, than stay here and eat this stuff. Tell the world about us!”
She said she was 15 when she came here in 1948 from Majdal, now in Israel. She married another refugee here in Gaza and they have five children. One was born after Gaza’s cutoff date for rations and the family of seven draws rations for six. “DO PEOPLE THINK WE’RE CHICKENS?”
Another woman held up a tin cup containing 300 grams of dried lentils, one ration for 15 days, and exclaimed: “Do other people think we are chickens? Look at this stuff. Do you believe it’s enough for a person to live on? If our husbands can’t find jobs, how can we live?”
Another woman held up her arm and displayed a tattered sleeve as she descanted upon her troubles in Arabic. Hirzallah explained that she was left alone with her eight children when her husband was transferred to a hospital in Egypt by the United Nations relief and works agency after three operations in the American Baptist hospital here.
There are 300,000 refugees in the Gaza strip, which is only 25 miles long and 3 to 5 miles wide and has a total area of only 135 square miles. It is all that is left of Palestine’s original land and water area of 10,435 square miles, of which Israel now occupies 8,078 square miles and Jordan 2,222. STRIP HAS ITS OWN PALESTINIAN FLAG.
The Gaza strip is under Egyptian administration, but it has its own Palestinian flag and legislative council, just as it did in the days of the British mandate, and the people are governed under Palestinian law, not Egyptian. The exact refugee population on Dec. 31, 1964, was 293,024, but the net annual increase is about 8,000. The nonrefugee population of the strip on Dec.
31, 1944, was estimated at 136,000. Thus more than 436,000 people are living on 86,400 acres of land, of which less than half is cultivated and the rest consists of sand dunes and desert.
Palestine refugee children with supplementary food from U. N. (U. N. Relief Agency Photo)
Three Palestinian women speak at length in an American newspaper in 1965, and not one of them is named. The reporter is standing at a ration window in Gaza’s Beach camp with an interpreter; the women see the notebook and come to it. The first tells him she was fifteen when she left Majdal in 1948, that her family of seven draws rations for six, and then gives him an instruction: ‘Tell the world about us!’ The second holds up a tin cup of lentils and asks whether people think they are chickens. The third holds up a torn sleeve. Two other things this page settles. The dateline reads GAZA, Palestine. And a subheading says the strip has its own Palestinian flag and legislative council, just as it did in the days of the British mandate, and the people are governed under Palestinian law, not Egyptian — printed thirty-seven years before an American column would call the Palestinian people an invention.
GAZA (AP) — Almost 18 years after the Arab-Israeli war, the Palestinian refugee population grows steadily, posing grave, new problems for administrators seeking to guide displaced Arabs to useful lives. The refugee issue is a costly hangover of the 1948 Arab-Israeli conflict.
Some critics allege the issue is deliberately kept alive by Arabs as a political weapon against Israel. Arabs, denying this, point to efforts to resettle the refugees. There are many aspects to the refugee problem, but none is more serious than the plight of young adults who seek a better life against tremendous economic odds.
The refugees poured from their Palestine homes into four so-called host countries — the Gaza Strip, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria. The Gaza Strip, an Egyptian-administered remnant of Palestine, is home for 294,000 refugees who streamed here in the wake of war, bringing little more than bundles of clothes. The influx increased the Strip's population 200 per cent.
What has happened in Gaza typifies the refugee situation in the other three host nations. The refugees, mostly agricultural workers, farmers and fishermen, have lived for almost two decades in crowded, temporary housing. Their number has steadily increased. “We're trying to urge birth control,” says Maj. Gen. Gamal Eddin Sabry, director for refugees in the Gaza area.
“But this is not an easy thing to do. Most of these people have their own ideas about such things and are reluctant to accept instruction.” Sabry cooperates closely with the United Nations Relief and Works Agency — UNWRA — which furnishes funds for educating Palestinian refugees. Its appropriations have recently been cut.
“Next to the increase in population,” says Sabry, “the UNWRA deficit is the biggest problem we currently face. It stands about $5 million and it means we are going to have to cut back services drastically.” “We are constantly trying to resettle the refugees. We have tried, for example, to settle them in Sinai.
But they feel that if they leave Palestine, their hopes of ever regaining their homes are finished. They are Palestinians who already have guilt feelings about having given up their lands instead of having fought to the death to hold them.
“Be assured of one thing — any attempt to make them leave Palestine and to make them renounce for good their homes in Palestine, will surely fail.” Sabry says the same condition prevails among all the 1,262,649 Palestinian refugees living in the four host countries.
PALESTINIAN REFUGEE CHILDREN gather around women getting water from a pump in the center of their camp at Gaza. This population, despite the end of the Arab-Israeli war almost 18 years ago, grows steadily to pose problems for administrators seking to guide displaced Arabs to useful lives. Boy, third from left, wears a mask on his face. (AP Wirephoto)
No byline. The same Associated Press dispatch ran in the Orange Leader, Texas, a month later, bylined Garven Hudgins and under a kicker reading Posing Grave Problems. The paper's own spelling of UNWRA and of seking is kept.
GAZA (AP) — Almost 18 years after the Arab-Israeli war, the Palestinian refugee population grows steadily, posing grave, new problems for administrators seeking to guide displaced Arabs to useful lives. The refugee issue is a costly hangover of the 1948 Arab-Israeli conflict.
Some critics allege the issue is deliberately kept alive by Arabs as a political weapon against Israel. Arabs, denying this, point to efforts to resettle the refugees. There are many aspects to the refugee problem, but none is more serious than the plight of young adults who seek a better life against tremendous economic odds.
The refugees poured from their Palestine homes into four so-called host countries — the Gaza Strip, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria. The Gaza Strip, an Egyptian-administered remnant of Palestine, is home for 294,000 refugees who streamed here in the wake of war, bringing little more than bundles of clothes. The influx increased the Strip's population 200 per cent.
What has happened in Gaza typifies the refugee situation in the other three host nations. The refugees, mostly agricultural workers, farmers and fishermen, have lived for almost two decades in crowded, temporary housing. Their number has steadily increased. “We're trying to urge birth control,” says Maj. Gen. Gamal Eddin Sabry, director for refugees in the Gaza area.
“But this is not an easy thing to do. Most of these people have their own ideas about such things and are reluctant to accept instruction.” Sabry cooperates closely with the United Nations Relief and Works Agency — UNWRA — which furnishes funds for educating Palestinian refugees. Its appropriations have recently been cut.
“Next to the increase in population,” says Sabry, “the UNWRA deficit is the biggest problem we currently face. It stands about $5 million and it means we are going to have to cut back services drastically.” “We are constantly trying to resettle the refugees. We have tried, for example, to settle them in Sinai.
But they feel that if they leave Palestine, their hopes of ever regaining their homes are finished. They are Palestinians who already have guilt feelings about having given up their lands instead of having fought to the death to hold them.
“Be assured of one thing — any attempt to make them leave Palestine and to make them renounce for good their homes in Palestine, will surely fail.” Sabry says the same condition prevails among all the 1,262,649 Palestinian refugees living in the four host countries.
The same Associated Press dispatch the Grand Forks Herald ran on 6 February 1966 without a byline and with an AP Wirephoto of children at a water pump. This printing carries the byline and no photograph. The paper's own spelling of UNWRA is kept.
Palestinians' Dream Lives On Despite 18 Years of Exile
Palestinians’ Dream Lives On Despite 18 Years of Exile — By THOMAS F. BRADY
1966, a year the archive held nine of. A feature whose subject is Palestinian national persistence, a year before the war that is usually said to have created it.
WASHINGTON — The Palestine Liberation Army is sending volunteers from the Arab refugee camps to fight with the Viet Cong against the United States. They go to Red China first for guerrilla training. Meanwhile the United States is paying most of the food bill for their families back home.
The U.S.A. contributes 70 per cent of the United Nations budget for Palestine refugees.
The Palestine Liberation Army is sending volunteers from the Arab refugee camps to fight with the Viet Cong against the United States. They go to Red China first for guerrilla training. Meanwhile the United States is paying most of the food bill for their families back home. The U.S.A. contributes 70 per cent of the United Nations budget for Palestine refugees. . . .
The night before Saudi Arabia’s King Faisal made his crack against Israel he was entertained at the White House. Among the guests was Mike Feldman, a former White House aide, who has previously acted as unofficial ambassador between Israel and the White House. The invitation was not a mistake. Feldman was deliberately invited to represent the Jewish community.
Nine Israeli Arabs Accused of Espionage for Jordanians
TEL AVIV, Nov. 10—Nine Israeli Arabs from a village near the Jordanian border were held today as suspected members of a ring spying for Jordan. Judge Shlomo Kassan of the Haifa district court ordered their detention until their case comes up, probably in two months. The ring was said to have been based in a village in the Irron Valley.
All nine were charged with conspiracy to collect and deliver information about Israel and military installations to the Jordanian intelligence service.
“Israel’s retaliatory raid on the… solution to the problem requires a…”
The Samu raid of 13 November 1966, in which Israeli forces destroyed a Jordanian village, editorialised in North Carolina. One of the events usually named as a step toward 1967, and the archive had not held it.
JERUSALEM, Jordanian Sector (AP) — Palestinians demanding arms to fight Israel rioted in cities and towns north and south of Jerusalem Thursday. Jordanian Arab legion troops had to be called in to restore order.
About 10,000 Palestinians from surrounding refugee camps swarmed through the city of Hebron south of Jerusalem for seven hours, scuffled with troops and police and finally were dispersed. Witnesses said three demonstrators were wounded.
To the north of Jerusalem at Ramallah, steel-helmeted legion troops fired over the heads of about 5,000 refugees who threw stones at police and the soldiers for five hours. By midday, order was restored but more violence erupted in the afternoon and a curfew was imposed.
The rioters tried to cut off the road between Ramallah and Jerusalem but troops cleared away the makeshift roadblocks of empty oil drums and piles of stone. The streets of Ramallah were strewn with rocks and rubble.
It was the second straight day of demonstrations in Ramallah and Hebron by Palestinians angered by the November 13 Israeli army attack across the border south of Jerusalem. It was estimated 350 rioters were arrested. The refugees demanded arms to fight Israel, fortification of frontier villages and a free hand for Arab commandos staging raids into Israel.
The Jordanian government officially is pledged to stop the raids, the reason given by Israel for its retaliatory attack. The streets of Ramallah were deserted. Hebron looked like an armed camp with heavy police and army patrols touring the city. Shops were closed.
Nablus, another scene of earlier disorders about 40 miles north of Jerusalem, was sealed off from the rest of Jordan for the fourth straight day. Townspeople were reported barricaded in their houses and firing at police and troops. Demonstrations in Nablus and Hebron first broke out last week after the Israeli attack on the village of Samu.
Jordanian Arab Legion troops were called Thursday to restore order in Ramallah and Hebron, where Palestinians were rioting. (AP Wirephoto)
One of two clippings filling 1966, a year this archive previously held nothing from. It records the aftermath of the Israeli raid on Samu on 13 November, seven months before the 1967 war: ten thousand people from the camps in Hebron, five thousand at Ramallah, Nablus sealed off for a fourth day, 350 arrested. What the crowds are asking for is in the headline and is unusual in this archive: arms. Not a ceasefire, not negotiations — weapons, fortified border villages, and a free hand for the commandos. The soldiers firing over their heads are Jordanian.
Palestinians accusing Jordan — the state then administering the West Bank. The headline uses Palestinians as a political actor distinct from the Arab states.
CAIRO, Nov. 27 — “I have never been an anti-Semite; I am a Semite myself,” Ahmad Asaad Shukairy observed yesterday in a mellow bass voice that resounded through the marble-floored villa that houses his headquarters here. Mr.
Shukairy is a polished Arab orator who, as chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization, claims to speak for 1.3 million Arab refugees from Palestine, who seek the destruction of the state of Israel so they can return to their arid homeland. Lately Mr.
Shukairy’s speaking talents, honed through years of practice at the United Nations, have been used in attempting to stir up discord in Jordan. In speeches in Cairo and on radio broadcasts throughout the Arab world he has been accusing the Jordanian Government of acting in collusion with Israel and has been demanding that it resign.
Palestinians, who make up a majority of Jordan’s population, have echoed his charges during demonstrations that have shaken the country since Israel launched a punitive foray into the Hebron area on Nov. 13 in retaliation for terrorist attacks. The demonstrators, who Mr.
Shukairy says have been encouraged and led by men from the Palestine Liberation Organization, have also demanded that King Hussein permit troops of the organization, based in Gaza, to enter Jordan and strengthen the defenses of her border with Israel. Despite the truculence of his views, Mr. Shukairy is a courtly figure, fond of ripe, romantic phrases.
Gray-haired and jowly at the age of 58, he sat slumped and evidently tired behind a vast polished desk at his villa yesterday. He apologized for receiving his visitor in a sports shirt — of fine cotton and excellent cut—and, turning his large brown eyes toward a map of Palestine on the wall, gave a melancholy historical résumé.
“There are so many sad pages in Arab history, so many catastrophes,” he said. “One can speak of the Crusades as one of these, of the Mongol invasion, of the foreign domination after the Middle Ages. All these are catastrophes for our people, but this [the creation of Israel] is the climax and summit of all our calamities.”
WASHINGTON — One undisclosed incident before the crisis between Israel and Jordan was a talk between Premier Eshkol of Israel and Myer Feldman, former White House aide. Feldman was in Israel on private business, and Eshkol asked his advice about taking retaliatory measures against the Jordanian village of Es-Samu which harbored Jordanian commandos.
Feldman’s advice to Eshkol was not to permit the Jordanian border raid. He warned that it would bring a rebuke from the United States. Feldman’s advice was sound. The U.N. Security Council has now unanimously censured Israel. U.S. Ambassador Goldberg, now Chairman of the Security Council, a Jew and a strong Zionist, was also emphatic in his rebuke.
Goldberg has sometimes differed with the State Department, but in this case there was no difference between them. Both the State Department and Ambassador Goldberg were aware of the fact that King Hussein of Jordan has been a stabilizing influence for peace and has had trouble curbing some of his own populace who have long wanted to attack Israel.
An unofficial army of Palestinian refugees has been on the Israeli - Jordanian border, some of them bitter against King Hussein. He has had difficulty restraining them. REFUGEE BITTERNESS. Some time ago I visited Jericho, at the north end of the Dead Sea, where there is a huge Palestinian refugee camp. It has been there for 16 to 17 years.
During these years it has been Arab policy to discourage Palestinian refugees from getting jobs in Arab countries or planting their roots in Arab soil. Actually many of the Arab countries bordering Israel need labor. Some refugees have disregarded the rule by migrating to Iraq to work on reclamation projects; but the great majority have remained in refugee camps.
One notable exception was Musa Alami, who left the Jericho camp, drilled a well, struck water, and started a truck farm. He raised chickens, installed a refrigeration plant, planted bananas, and soon operated a thriving business, hauling his produce to American Oil Company employees in Saudi Arabia.
But one day when Jordan was seething against the West, the refugees at Jericho decided to take out their vengeance on one of their own number. Storming down the road to Musa Alami’s farm, yelling “Get the traitor!” they destroyed his refrigeration plant, and wrung the necks of 35,000 chickens. Musa had employed at times as many as 1,200 refugees.
However, he made the fatal mistake of accepting the permanency of his residence in Jordan. He had given up the idea of returning to Israel. This made him a “traitor.” During the long years the refugees have been sitting in heat and idleness at the head of the Dead Sea, they have built up a burning, passionate hate.
They hate Israel, and they hate Britain and the United States who have befriended Israel. Fanatic Arab leaders have used this as a weapon. Moderate Arab leaders have bowed to it because they are prisoners. King Hussein has been trying to resist becoming a prisoner.
A syndicated Washington columnist under a headline that puts the feeling in the refugees and the cause in American generosity. What the column underneath actually reports is narrower and stranger. Pearson had been to Jericho. He gives an account of Musa Alami, who left the camp, drilled a well, struck water, farmed, raised chickens and employed up to 1,200 refugees — and whose refrigeration plant was wrecked by a crowd from the camp shouting Get the traitor!, who wrung the necks of 35,000 chickens. His offense, as Pearson explains it, was accepting the permanency of his residence in Jordan. He had given up the idea of going back. The column also records that the United Nations Security Council had unanimously censured Israel over the Samu raid, and that the American ambassador — a Jew and a strong Zionist — was emphatic in the rebuke.
JERUSALEM (Jordan), Dec. 10 — The 18-year-old “Palestinian question” was posed anew by Israel Nov. 3 with a massive attack on the Jordanian village of Es Samu.
The result has been sporadic disorder in Western Jordan and a spate of bitter Arab left-wing propaganda against King Hussein’s Government, with Israel taking second place in the revived antagonism. But the answer to the Palestinian question seems no nearer.
The Palestinian Arabs, whose “diaspora” began in 1948, have their own ready response to anyone who suggests they solve the Middle East’s most emotion-ridden problem by accepting the status quo and making new lives for themselves wherever they can. “The Jews,” they say, “remembered Palestine for 2000 years.
Why should we begin to forget so soon?”
THE REFUGEES: The majority of Palestinians who fled what is now Israel (map) “live in squalid penury” in places like the Dheisheh camp near Bethlehem (above). Most, like the man at a Lebanese camp receiving a bundle of clothes (lower left), rely on aid from UN.
“Some pieces of twisted metal, a pile of rubble from which the dust rises, a row of sullen women, a hole in the minaret of the mosque: it seems a small enough tragedy, even rather prosaic, a cliché of war.
Yet this shattered village, which is called Es Samu and lies in the Hebron Hills very near the western frontier of Jordan, will probably become one of the more important place names in the dog gazetteer of Arab-Israeli relations.”
A long magazine piece built on the ruins of Es Samu, six weeks after the raid. It reports that eighteen Jordanians and one United Nations figure were killed, and that the Israeli reason given was reprisal for Arab guerrilla activity inside Israel. The headline makes the Arabs the ones who deny a reality.
BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — The militant Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) said today in a Cairo broadcast it would send one of its brigades to strike at the palaces of King Hussein and the homes of his cabinet members in a bid to overthrow Jordan's monarchy.
The Cairo-based PLO Radio said the "Abdel Kader al Husseini Brigade" would carry out acts of sabotages in an effort to oust the 32-year-old King who has used his own tough legionnaires to put down unrest stirred up by the PLO. The broadcast said the brigade was responsible for three explosions which rocked the Jordan sector of Jerusalem Monday.
The explosions were heard in the Israeli sector but there was no information from Jordan as to their origin. Damascus Radio—which also leads the antiHussein faction of the Arab countries—said the explosions were directed at the office of the governor of Jerusalem, a Jordanian officers' club and a broadcasting station.
The PLO radio broadcast said the "brigade" had made its threat against "traitor Hussein and his ministers" in leaflets distributed in Jerusalem's Jordanian sector.
The only pre-June-1967 clipping in the batch, and useful as a baseline for the vocabulary question precisely because it predates the occupation. Note what the American wire calls things in January 1967: 'the militant Palestine Liberation Organization', 'the Jordan sector of Jerusalem', 'the Israeli sector', 'Jerusalem's Jordanian sector'. The word 'Palestinian' does not appear; 'Palestine' appears only inside the organisation's own name.
Also worth noting for the archive: this is a Palestinian organisation reported entirely through its enemies' and its own broadcasts — PLO Radio from Cairo, Damascus Radio, and an absence ('there was no information from Jordan'). Nobody is interviewed, nobody is named on the Palestinian side, and the single quotation is a slogan from a leaflet. That is the standard shape of PLO coverage in this period and it is worth having one clean pre-war example of it.
BEIRUT, Lebanon (UPI) — The militant Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) said today in a Cairo broadcast it would send one of its brigades to strike at the palaces of King Hussein and the homes of his cabinet members in a bid to overthrow Jordan's monarchy.
The Cairo-based PLO Radio said the "Abdel Kadar al Husseini Brigade" would carry out acts of sabotage in an effort to oust the 32-year-old King who has used his own tough legionnaires to put down unrest stirred up by the PLO. The broadcast said the brigade was responsible for three explosions which rocked the Jordan sector of Jerusalem Monday.
The explosions were heard in the Israeli sector but there was no information from Jordan as to their origin. Damascus Radio—which also leads the anti-Hussein faction of the Arab countries—said the explosions were directed at the office of the governor of Jerusalem, a Jordanian officers' club and a broadcasting station.
The PLO radio broadcast said the "brigade" had made its threat against "traitor Hussein and his ministers" in leaflets distributed in Jerusalem's Jordanian sector. "The road of treason is full of bombs and mines," the leaflets said.
"The house of victory is close at hand." The brigade takes its name from Abdel Kader al Hussein, a Palestinian who died leading Palestinians against the Jews in the 1947 Arab-Israeli war. He is regarded as a martyr by Palestinians. The PLO was set up by Arab heads of state in 1964 to spearhead the Arab "liberation" of Palestine from the Jews.
Last year the Arab heads split into right-and-left-wing factions and Hussein broke off relations with the organization, charging its leaders were Communist tools plotting against his throne. The anti-Hussein propaganda has grown since Israel's retaliatory attack against Jordanian border villages last Nov. 13.
Last Tuesday, Ahmed Shukeiry, chairman of the PLO, announced from Cairo the movement was going underground to strengthen its anti-Hussein efforts. Observers have expressed fears that if Hussein and his moderate government is overthrown by Arab extremists the Israelis will move against Jordan to forestall any attack from militant Arabs.
THE EARLIEST AND CLEANEST INSTANCE OF THE MOVE MARIA FLAGGED — and it predates the 1967 war by five months. United Press International, January 1967, in its own voice, unattributed:
'The PLO was set up by Arab heads of state in 1964 to spearhead the Arab "liberation" of Palestine from the Jews.'
Two things happen in that sentence. 'Liberation' is put inside scare quotes, so the wire marks the word itself as a claim rather than a description. And the thing Palestine is to be liberated FROM is given as 'the Jews' — not Israel, not the Israeli state, not Zionism. The wire makes the object of liberation a people rather than a state, and then flags the word as propaganda. That is precisely the fusion Maria read on slide 112, executed in one clause, two and a half years earlier, by a wire service rather than a headline desk.
The same paragraph-and-a-bit also does the opposite thing, which is why this clipping is worth showing whole. Three sentences earlier: 'The brigade takes its name from Abdel Kader al Hussein, a Palestinian who died leading Palestinians against the Jews in the 1947 Arab-Israeli war. He is regarded as a martyr by Palestinians.' UPI uses 'Palestinian' as a noun for a person, 'Palestinians' twice as a people, and reports — flatly, without quotation marks or hedging — that they regard a man as a martyr. In January 1967. Set that against the 1969 Sulzberger column (s099_3), which puts 'Palestine' in quotation marks every single time and never uses 'Palestinian' at all.
So the vocabulary did not move in one direction. The same wire service in the same paragraph can call a man a Palestinian and call his cause a 'liberation'.
BETHLEHEM, Jordan, June 9—In the sun-baked square behind the Church of the Nativity, Israeli soldiers with submachine guns lounged in the shade beneath a tattered awning. Jeeps criss-crossed the square every few minutes, and two Sherman tanks sat roasting in the afternoon sun, their hatches open.
A blue and white flag with the six-pointed Star of David, flapped from a pole on top of the police station, and from a far corner of the square, a group of Arabs watched impassively. Bethlehem lies eight miles south of Jerusalem, and the Israeli forces took it late Wednesday.
They took it without firing a shot, but only after two days of furious fighting between Jerusalem and here with the Arab Legionnaires of Jordan. The Arabs had made determined stands on virtually every hilltop. Once they had been pushed back to this point, the Jordanians stopped fighting and broke into a retreat to the east. The Israeli tanks rumbled into town unopposed.
City Suffers Some Damage Even though there was no real battle for Bethlehem, the city suffered some damage from the shelling. The Israelis pounded it briefly before they entered, and Jordanian rearguard was posted at the borders of the town for two hours to protect the retreat.
The Church of the Nativity, revered by millions of Christians as the birthplace of Jesus, received 12 direct hits. Eleven of the shells struck the heavy outside wall, leaving deep scars in the gray stone. The twelfth struck the roof and punched a hole through the ceiling of the Armenian wing.
The church, which covers the equivalent of a city block, is divided into three sections, each with a separate altar. The Armenian Catholics occupy one section, the Greek Orthodox another, and the Roman Catholics a third. The people of Bethlehem stayed in their homes for most of yesterday.
Only this morning, finally convinced that the Israelis would not harm them, did they emerge. Air of Tourist Town Even during the military occupation, Bethlehem had the air of a tourist town.The main street is called Manger Street and it is lined with souvenir shops.
There is the Three Wise Men store, the Holy Manger gift shop and the King David religious goods factory, which is near the intersection of Manger Street and St. Joseph Street. The Bethlehem Oriental Store (manufacturers of mother-of-pearl and olivewood articles) was open today and doing a brisk business.
Israeli soldiers crowded into the narrow shop, looking over the ornate medals and the vaguely religious jewelry. The soldiers were paying for the articles they selected, but only after a long haggling session with Jean Michel, the proprietor. Mr. Michel was the picture of tortured misery as he completed each sale. “I’m losing on every item,” he moaned.
“Like hell you are,” said one Israeli soldier. “Your prices have been going up all morning. We know what these things are worth and that’s what we are paying you.” A guide inside the cool dark interior of the Church of the Nativity said that the Israelis who had come into the church had caused no harm.
“All they did was to take pictures with their movie cameras and wander around,” he said. Tomb of Rachel Visited In addition to the tourist shops, the Israeli soldiers were looking at the site of the Tomb of Rachel, which lies just to the north of Bethlehem on the road to Jerusalem.
Rachel was the wife of Jacob and the mother of Joseph and Benjamin, according to the Old Testament. She is revered as one of the mothers of the tribes of Israel. A visitor driving on the eastern outskirts of the city found a group of Arabs sitting in a restaurant nestled in a clump of trees.
They reported that the Jordanian soldiers had retreated eastward over the road in front of the restaurant, but that the Israelis had not yet come to see them. Asked if they would prefer to live under Jordanian or Israeli rule, the men laughed. “It makes no difference to us,” one said. We regard this area as Palestine.
During the British mandate, we lived with the Jews as brothers. We went to the same schools and rode in the same buses and taxis. We don’t care who runs the government. We just want peace.”
Well-to-Do Say Israel Must Pull Out, Poor Don’t Care
By TERENCE SMITH, Special to The New York Times
JERUSALEM, June 11—A portly Arab businessman sat in the living room of his home in the comfortable Sheik Jarach section of Jerusalem. “Israel must not keep all of Jerusalem,” he said in a quiet, firm voice. “It is just as holy a city to us as it is to them. If they try to keep it all, there will be no end to the fighting.”
Less than a mile away, in a hovel in the walled Old City, Badwizen Muhammed, a grocer, told a visitor: “We don’t care who is the government. We don’t care if it is Israel or Jordan or the United Nations. We just want peace. We want to be able to open our shops and make a living.”
Among the Arabs of what was the Jordanian sector of Jerusalem, who have been under Israeli rule for five days now, concern about the future seems to vary with affluence. The well-to-do businessmen insist that the Israelis must withdraw to the former border, which divided Jerusalem and left the Old City in Jordanian territory.
The very least that would be acceptable, they say, would be to internationalize the city and have it administered by the United Nations. No Time for Politics The poor of the Old City have no time for politics. They have been without water and electricity for nearly a week, and their food supplies are running low.
They want help, and they are in no position to worry about where it comes from. According to the Israeli military government that is administering the captured section of the city, they are about to get help. Some 20,000 bottles of milk are due in the Old City tomorrow, along with truckloads of food and supplies.
Before the hostilities there were about 61,000 people in the Jordanian sector, about half of whom lived within the gray stone walls of the Old City. Some of the 61,000 are assumed to have fled during the three-day siege, but no one is sure how many. The best guess on the current population is somewhere between 45,000 and 55,000.
The job of feeding these people, providing them with the essential services and policing them has fallen to the Israeli military government, headed by Brig. Chaim Herzog. A curfew has been imposed on the Jordanian population from 5 P.M. to 9 A.M.
From L.A. Times-Washington Post Service and NYT Dispatches
“A new refugee problem of tragic proportions is shaping up as a result of the Middle East war and Israeli occupation of Jordan’s West Bank area.
The United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) issued an urgent appeal yesterday to the world for money and medical supplies to cope with a flood of new refugees into Jordan—a flood now estimated to have reached the 100,000 mark.
UNRWA officials in Beirut said 80 per cent of the new refugees were people already on their rolls, which number 1.3 million Arabs who fled Palestine in 1948, plus their descendants born to the refugee life.
Meanwhile, the United States was reported by Johnson administration officials yesterday to have cautioned Israel against any forceful eviction of Palestinian refugees and Jordanian citizens from the territory it has occupied in Jordan.
In reply, the Israeli government was said to have given general assurances of humanitarian treatment for any refugees and Jordanian citizens remaining. Within State Department circles, however, there is some question whether the Israeli government may be encouraging some of the Arab residents to leave strategic areas near the Israeli border.
The new refugees fled across the Jordan River to the east during last week’s warfare despite appeals by Jordan’s King Hussein to stay where they were. It was a similar exodus in 1948 — that time at the urging of some Arab leaders who wanted to clear civilians out of the area so Arab armies would not harm them — that led to the refugee problem itself.
Despite Hussein’s pleas, the new refugees are reported still clogging the roads leading to the Jordan River. Although most appeared to come from camps on the West Bank, many villages—”
Four days after the war ended, one column carries both accounts of why people leave: the State Department wondering whether Israel is encouraging it, and 1948 explained as the urging of Arab leaders. The subheading between them is a question the paper asks itself — “Encouragement From Israel?” The standing head is “Flight From Israelis,” the word occupation is in the first sentence, and the item beside it on the page is about rioting in the Negro section of Cincinnati.
Imminent Tragedy Of The Refugees Constitutes Grim Legacy Of Fight
Arabs Flee Jordan’s West Bank
By Joe A. Morris, Jr., The Los Angeles Times, Beirut
BEIRUT — A new refugee problem of tragic proportions is shaping up as a result of the Middle East war and Israeli occupation of Jordan’s west bank area.
The United Nations relief and works agency (UNRWA) Monday issued an urgent appeal to the world for money and medical supplies to cope with a flood of new refugees into Jordan, now estimated to have reached the 100,000 mark.
UNRWA officials here said that 80 per cent of the new refugees were people already on their rolls, which number 1.3 million Arabs who fled Palestine in 1948 plus their descendants born to the refugee life. The new refugees fled across the Jordan River during last week’s warfare despite appeals by Jordan’s King Hussein to stay where they were.
It was a similar exodus in 1948 — that time at the urging of some Arab leaders who wanted to clear civilians out of the area so Arab armies would not harm them — which led to the refugee problem itself. Despite Hussein’s pleas, the new refugees are reported still clogging the roads leading to the Jordan River.
Although most appeared to come from camps on the west bank, many villages there are also reported deserted or semideserted… Perhaps 400,000 refugees remain in Israeli-occupied territory on the west bank.
Officials here had little information about conditions in the occupied area, but UNRWA Commissioner General Laurence Michelmore has authorized the continuation of services there on humanitarian grounds.
This may be difficult since the Israeli army did not spare UNRWA when it seized every vehicle it could get moving during the takeover… UNRWA carefully sidestepped any question of implicit political recognition of the Israeli territorial acquistions by emphasizing that continued services behind the lines were being carreid out on humanitarian grounds… More than half the refugees on its rolls appear at present to be technically ineligible for aid.
The same sentence as the Courier-Journal ran the day before, from the same Los Angeles Times copy: the 1948 exodus explained as the urging of Arab leaders who wanted to clear civilians out so Arab armies would not harm them. Beside it, a Crawford cartoon of Uncle Sam holding a UN bag, captioned “All Dressed Up And No Place To Go,” with notes at his feet reading GET LOST! — SYRIA, NO THANKS! — CAIRO and DON’T SHOW YOUR FACE AROUND HERE! — ISRAEL. “acquistions” and “carreid” are the paper’s.
KALANDIA, Jordan, June 14 —You probably will not find this village on any map, unless it is based on the ones drawn up by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, which is charged with looking after Palestinian Arab refugees of the 1948 Arab-Israeli war. It stands a few hundred yards from the main Jerusalem-Nablus road and the twin Arab towns of Ramallah and El Birah.
These towns, one Christian and the other Moslem, dislike each other too much—and are too preoccupied with their own problems—to worry about Kalandia’s difficulties. It is not much to look at, a battered conglomeration of huts and hovels that grew to house 8,000 refugees between the 1948 war and last week’s hostilities.
Most of the 8,000 are still here, stunned by the outcome of the renewed war, concerned mainly, so they say, about a return to normality, but unconcerned, or so they say, whether it be under Israeli or Jordanian rule. “What can we think?” said one middle-aged man. “We lived here before. We will live here in the future.
Some of our young men ran away when Jerusalem fell. We hope they will come back.”
Victory Brings Israel Peacetime Problem of Occupying New Territory
By Lawrence Malkin, Associated Press, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM (AP) — For the Jews of Israel, victory has brought peace but more peacetime problems. The exhilaration of swift triumph over the Arabs in the six-day war is beginning to fade away. Now the Israelis face tasks of reoganization not even imagined before the war erupted on June 5.
Israel, a nation of 2.6 million, has swallowed, at least temporarily, about a million Arabs in the Gaza Strip and on the west bank of the Jordan River. Toward the Jews of Israel, they have only implacable hatred. It is believed now that rather than cutting down on military expenses after victory, Israel will be obliged to increase its army to man occupation forces.
House-to-house searches for arms have been ordered. Retreating Jordanians left weapons in the hands of people thirsting for vengeance… One Israeli bank official has estimated that the annual cost of maintaining captured areas would be about $50 million. “We can handle that, if we have to,” he said.
“I am confident we can stay in the territories for a long time if the Arabs refuse to talk. If this goes on long enough, perhaps we shall develop the occupied areas ourselves.” As of now, the chief value of the occupied areas appears to be as bargaining pawns, if and when the Arabs decide to talk.
As Israel takes stock of the results of the brief war, it can consider that the battle was not without its spoils… The Israeli harvest of captured military equipment was enormous. On the drive through Jordan, for example, Israeli forces captured scores of trucks in new condition, all bearing the clasped-hands insignia of the U.S.
Agency for International Development program… If the Israelis keep the west bank of the Jordan, they will have land rich in phosphates and with plenty of surplus space to make the desert bloom with fruits and vegetables for export to Europe.
Eleven days after the war, occupying is in the headline and occupied is in the copy three times, none of it in quotation marks. A million Arabs are swallowed in the fourth sentence, the occupied areas are bargaining pawns in the eighth, and the last column is about phosphates and export markets. “reoganization” is the paper’s.
“CROSSING THE JORDAN — Arab refugees from the Israeli-occupied west bank of the Jordan River cross the damaged Allenby bridge to the east bank in the vicinity of Jericho.” (AP)
A wire photograph of people walking out across a wrecked bridge, twelve days after the war. The caption says Israeli-occupied in its first line, plainly, with nothing attributed.
United Press International, Allenby Bridge, Jordan
Allenby Bridge, Jordan (UPI)—The number of Palestinian refugees who have fled from Israeli-captured western Jordan since last week’s fighting is now believed to be about 200,000, preliminary results of the first head count showed yesterday. The final figure was to be announced today.
It is substantially higher than the 150,000 estimate issued earlier by the Jordanian government and the 100,000 estimate compiled by UN Relief and Works Agency.
The count began early yesterday as dozens of teams organized by the government and UNRWA moved into towns, villages and refugee camps eastward from the Jordan River which now forms the Jordan-Israel truce line… In this neighboring Arab nation, new refugees were seen crossing the Jordan River by the hundreds yesterday at the wrecked Allenby Bridge, made passable with wooden boards across the collapsed center part.
Men and women carrying babies, small children and bundles of clothing and blankets scrambled down the steep concrete bed of the shattered bridge. They were met by crowds of anxious relatives. Israeli soldiers on the west bank made no attempt to halt fleeing refugees, but watched carefully to stop any trying to come in their direction.
Israeli authorities were making it easy for refugees to leave by busing them to the bridge. The first attempt to bring injured Jordanian prisoners of war from the Israeli-captured west bank failed yesterday. Israel cancelled the plan without explanation.
“JORDAN CROSSING. Young and old Arab refugees from the Israeli occupation of the Jordan River’s west bank are helped across the Allenby Bridge at Jericho yesterday by Israeli troops. A little Arab girl, left, is carried across the Jordan by a soldier, while other soldiers guide an aged man, right, along the damaged bridge toward unoccupied territory.”
AP Wirephotos.
Two hundred thousand, counted, twelve days after the war. The mechanism is in one sentence: the soldiers made no attempt to halt the refugees leaving, watched carefully to stop anyone coming the other way, and the authorities were busing people to the bridge. The photographs are captioned as help, and the caption uses the words Israeli occupation and unoccupied territory.
· Santa Barbara News-Press · Santa Barbara · page 1
The Palestinian Refugees…
Our Readers’ Views
Sheldon T. Mills, a former United States ambassador to Jordan
“Editor, News-Press: I wish to thank the News-Press for its kindness in inviting me on June 5 to express my views on the Middle East crisis. When speaking with your reporter I did not know that armed conflict had broken out.
Had I known, I still would have confined my remarks largely to the main reason, as I see it, for continued turmoil in the area, namely the presence in countries surrounding Israel of Palestinian refugees from their homes, farms, business establishments, and other livelihoods in Israel.
It is in response to numerous requests for more information on this subject, received from a large number of total strangers, that I am writing this letter. It appears this problem is growing worse instead of better. News dispatches report that some 100,000 Palestinians, some of them the refugees of 1948, have crossed the Jordan River from the West Bank.
That is the part of Jordan which includes the old city of Jerusalem, Bethlehem, Hebron, Nablus, Tulkarm and Jericho, now occupied by Israeli forces. Is Israel intent on having these people leave their homes or their temporary homes, so it can use their farms, houses, business establishments and other fixed properties for its own purposes?
The situation of the refugees is not really understood by many Americans who have not traveled in the countries which have extended them temporary homes. Looking at the map, one sees vast areas in the Arab countries and quite naturally asks why the refugees are not settled on these territories. There are valid reasons.
Most of the Arab Middle East is without sufficient water to sustain agriculture. There are light rains on the deserts and a brief crop of grass. Very limited numbers of nomads, by going from oasis to oasis can sustain themselves as herdsmen. Few of the refugees, however are nomads. They are either city and town people or farmers from the villages of Palestine.
They could no more sustain life in the desert than you or I. Those who can be absorbed have been absorbed, at least in Jordan. None wish to live on the 10 cents per day UN ration in refugee camps.
Refugees have provided a considerable proportion of the professional people and government officials of Jordan — doctors, dentists, pharmicists, businessmen, bankers, architects, builders, etc. The 80 per cent in refugee camps are those who were farmers or laborers. There is no land with water for the former.
There are few industries to provide work for the latter, who also must compete with the unskilled labor force of the East Bank. Many traditional Arab farmers of Palestine were forced to leave the land even before Israel came into being.
They were tenant farmers of absentee landlords who sold their land to Jewish organizations who wanted it not for its yield, but for Jewish immigrants. Mobile Americans, particularly Californians, find it difficult to understand attach…”
A former American ambassador to Jordan writing to his local California paper to answer strangers who had asked him why the refugees were not simply settled elsewhere. He answers with water, soil and the tenant-farming system. The story continues on A-15.
The Arabs' View of the conflict's history (Toynbee)
Prof. Arnold J. Toynbee, written for UPI
The last line of the Israelis’ view, as Toynbee sets it out: “…time by a Western people, the Germans, in Europe. We are not going to let the Arabs commit the same crime of genocide against us here, in our own land of Israel.”
Then: “THE ARABS’ VIEW of the conflict’s history: In 1918, 90 per cent of the population of Palestine was Arab, and Palestine had been ours since we wrested it from the Romans in the Seventh Century A.D. Since 1918, a militant and aggressive foreign body has been thrust into the heart of our Arab world.
This has been done, against our protests, by force of arms — British force until, under the protection of British bayonets, the Zionist Jewish intruders had built up sufficient force of their own to be more than a match for our Arab strength. Then the British scuttled, and left us to our fate.
Our fate has been that 900,000 Palestinian Arabs (there are more than a million of these now) have been forcibly deprived of their homes and property and have been turned into refugees, living on a dole. Any Palestinian Arab refugee who tries to return home and resume possession of his property is shot by the Israelis, who have robbed us of our country and our property.
The Palestinian Arabs who have not lost their homes are being treated by the Israelis, under whose rule they have fallen, as penalized second-class citizens. The Arab territory that the Israelis have seized by force stretches from the Mediterranean to the Red Sea at Elath. This foreign-occupied territory cuts the Arab world in two.”
A second clipping from the same Arizona Republic page as the Toynbee feature. The word genocide appears in the Israeli case, set out immediately above the Arab case, and the Arab case is printed at the same length.
'U.S. Has Made Arabs Pay for Germany's Crime Against Jews'
Eleven days after the war, in a Phoenix paper, and the whole sentence is inside quotation marks — which is what let it be printed. Somebody said it, so the paper can set it in headline type: that the United States has made Arabs pay for Germany’s crime against Jews. The archive holds the same mechanism in 1987: a claim about Israel arrives in an American headline when a third party can be named as its author (CP-1987-003).
A Distinguished Historian Views the Mideast Crisis
The Arab-Israeli Conflict: Its History and Its Prospects
By PROF. ARNOLD J. TOYNBEE, Written For UPI, Copyright 1967
I will try to put, first, the Israelis' view of this as I see it, then the Arabs' view, and thirdly my own view. I am neither an Arab nor an Israeli. I am British, so I feel deeply my country's share in the responsibility for this tragic conflict between two other peoples.
Britain issued the Balfour Declaration in 1917; Britain was in power in Palestine for 30 years ending in 1948; Britain's precipitate abdication in Palestine after the second World War left the way open in 1948 for the first of the three Arab-Israeli wars.
THE ISRAELIS' VIEW of the conflict's history: We are Jews, the living representatives of Judah, one of the 12 tribes of Israel that conquered most of Palestine in the 13th Century B.C. We held Judah's share of the conquered territory for seven centuries, till we were deported by Nebuchadnezzar in 587 B.C.
We were back again within less than half a century, and we then held Judea, once more, for the next 773 years, till we were evicted by the Romans in A.D. 135. We have never renounced our claim to the land of Israel. We have always hoped, believed, and proclaimed that we will get this land back again. It is our land, we contend.
After another 1,883 years (continuing the Israelis' view) we did recover a foothold there in 1918, and during the half century since then, by devoted hard work, ability and military valor, we have built up our present national state of Israel, and have inflicted three smashing defeats on the Arabs, who have been trying to evict us once again.
We want to have a country of our own again, like other peoples and like our own ancestors. We also need to have a country of our own, because, since the conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity in the Fourth Century A.D. we have been penalized and persecuted by the Western Christian majority among whom we have had to live.
This persecution has culminated in the unprecedented crime of genocide which has been committed against us in our lifetime by a Western people, the Germans, in Europe. We are not going to let the Arabs commit the same crime of genocide against us here, in our own land of Israel.
THE ARABS' VIEW of the conflict's history: In 1918, 90 per cent of the population of Palestine was Arab, and Palestine had been ours since we wrested it from the Romans in the Seventh Century A.D. Since 1918, a militant and aggressive foreign body has been thrust into the heart of our Arab world.
This has been done, against our protests, by force of arms — British force until, under the protection of British bayonets, the Zionist Jewish intruders had built up sufficient force of their own to be more than a match for our Arab strength. Then the British scuttled, and left us to our fate.
Our fate has been that 900,000 Palestinian Arabs (there are more than a million of these now) have been forcibly deprived of their homes and property and have been turned into refugees, living on a dole. Any Palestinian Arab refugee who tries to return home and resume possession of his property is shot by the Israelis, who have robbed us of our country and our property.
The Palestinian Arabs who have not lost their homes are being treated by the Israelis, under whose rule they have fallen, as penalized second-class citizens. The Arab territory that the Israelis have seized by force stretches from the Mediterranean to the Red Sea at Elath. This foreign-occupied territory cuts the Arab world in two.
The Israelis' crime against the Arabs is flagrant (the Arabs would go on to say). But it is not the Arabs who have committed crimes against the Jews. When we conquered Palestine from the Romans, we allowed Jews to reside in Judaea again for the first time in five hundred years.
When we conquered Spain from the German Goths, we liberated the Jews in Spain from the Goths' Nazi-like oppression of them.
The Prophet Muhammad in the Koran had commanded Muslims to tolerate and protect law-abiding Jews and Christians under Muslim rule, and our Muslim Arab record, in adhering to this commandment, has been fine compared with the Western peoples' treatment of the Jews. Yet now we have been made to pay for a Western peoples' crime against the Jews.
The Germans tried to exterminate the Jews. The western victors in the Second World War, the Americans, above all (the Arab argument goes on), have made the Arabs, not the Germans, pay for the Germans' crime. In Western eyes, the Germans may be criminals, but they are also fellow-Westerners, so they are privileged. We Arabs do not count.
We are “natives,” just part of the fauna of Palestine. We have no human rights. The Israelis, on the other hand, have the West's ear, the West's sympathy, and the West's support. In Western countries, the Jews have money-power and voting-power, which we Arabs do not have there. We are never going to submit to this injustice, the Arabs say.
The Israeli intruders are the spearhead of Western neo-imperialism in the Arab world. We have suffered from Western aggression in Palestine once before. That time, it was the Crusaders. We succeeded in expelling the Crusaders, though that took us 200 years. We are going to expel the Israelis too, however long this may take us.
MY POINT OF VIEW, as a British Westerner: By 1948, the Palestinian Arabs had been the inhabitants of Palestine for more than 1,300 years. This length of time has given them a prescriptive right to continue to live in Palestine and to retain their property there. As for the Jews' claim to have a right to reoccupy Palestine, the statute of limiations applies to this.
The Israelis have no right to keep the Palentinian Arabs out of their homes and to rob them of their property, as they have done.
TOP PHOTOGRAPH (AP Wirephoto): EXODUS FROM ISRAEL—Arab refugees from the west bank of the Jordan River trudge toward Amman, capital of Jordan, on road halfway between the river and the city. || LOWER PHOTOGRAPH (AP Wirephoto): CROSSING JORDAN'S WATERS—A woman is helped ashore on the east bank of the Jordan River by two fellow refugees as they reach territory still held by Jordanian forces.
The west bank is in the hands of the Israelis.
A full page given to a historian who sets out the Israeli case, then the Arab case, then his own. The two subheadings on the page are “U.S. Has Made Arabs Pay for Germany’s Crime Against Jews” and “The Arabs Must Recognize That Israel Is a Fact.”
Key to Solution in Mideast Rests on Fate of Refugees
By Prof. ARNOLD J. TOYNBEE, Written for UPI, Copyright 1967
I will try to put, first, the Israelis' view of this as I see it, then the Arabs' view, and thirdly my own view. I am neither an Arab nor an Israeli. I am British, so I feel deeply my country's share in the responsibility for this tragic conflict between two other peoples.
Britain issued the Balfour Declaration in 1917; Britain was in power in Palestine for 30 years ending in 1948; Britain's precipitate abdication in Palestine after the Second World War left the way open in 1948 for the first of the three Arab-Israeli wars.
The Israelis' view of the conflict's history: We are Jews, the living representatives of Judah, one of the 12 tribes of Israel that conquered most of Palestine in the 13th Century B.C. We held Judah's share of the conquered territory for seven centuries, till we were deported by Nebuchadnezzar in 587 B.C.
We were back again within less than half a century, and we then held Judaea, once more, for the next 773 years, till we were evicted by the Romans in A.D. 135. We have never renounced our claim to the land of Israel. We have always hoped, believed, and proclaimed that we shall get this land back again. It is our land, we contend.
AFTER ANOTHER 1,883 years (continuing the Israelis' view) we did recover a foothold there in 1918, and during the half century since then, by devoted hard work, ability, and military valor, we have built up our present national state of Israel, and have inflicted three smashing defeats on the Arabs, who have been trying to evict us once again.
We want to have a country of our own again, like other peoples and like our own ancestors. We also need to have a country of our own, because, since the conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity in the Fourth Century A.D. we have been penalized and persecuted by the Western Christian majority among whom we have had to live.
This persecution has culminated in the unprecedented crime of genocide which has been committed against us in our lifetime by a western people, the Germans, in Europe. We are not going to let the Arabs commit the same crime of genocide against us here, in our own land of Israel.
11 June 1967, in Flint, Michigan. Everything in the Middle East is said to turn on the fate of the refugees — which is a thing an American paper could say plainly in 1967 and said less and less afterwards. The refugees are still refugees and not a people; the word Palestinian is not in the line.
“JERICHO (AP) — All day long under the merciless sun, war’s tragic river of sorrow flowed down toward the—… Israel’s two decades old refugee problem has almost dissolved into King Hussein’s refugee problem… crouched behind a .30 caliber machine gun looking out across the shallow, gurgling river…”
A strip cut from the top of a page: the headline, the line beneath it and the first lines of three columns, each broken off.
“Arabs Crossing River. An Arab couple with their child make their way across the bombed-out Allenby Bridge over the Jordan River at Jericho to the east bank of the river. They were among Arab refugees heading into Jordan away from the Israeli occupation on the west bank of the river.” (AP Wirephoto)
The photograph that ran with the Jericho dispatch on the same page.
Israeli Governor Threatens Occupied City With Loss of Water and Electricity
GAZA, June 19 — The Israeli military governor of this occupied city threatened today to disband the local government and curtail essential services unless the Arab population began to turn in its arms. In a brief, strained meeting with the Mayor and the 14 town councilors, Col.
Isaac Moday gave them 48 hours to persuade their constituents to obey the emergency regulations he had issued. Among the regulations is an order directing the civilian population to turn over all weapons. If the Arabs do not begin to comply, Colonel Moday told the councilmen, he will dismiss the local government.
If that does not bring results, he said, he will cut off the water supply, electricity and other services that the Israelis restored when they occupied the city after the fighting ended here on June 7. “The matter is entirely up to you,” he said. “You are the people who can make this work, so I am going to leave it to you.”
After a curt handshake with the plump, bald Mayor and a perfunctory nod to the councilmen, the colonel strode from the council chamber in the ramshackle city hall. Security Troubles Explained Back in his own office in what used to be the district courthouse, he explained the difficulties he was having in making the city secure.
“Because the Palestine Liberation Organization was so active here,” he said, “there are weapons all through Gaza.” [The Palestine Liberation Organization is a military group of Palestinian refugees aimed at the overthrow of the Israeli Government.]
By James Feron, (c) 1967 New York Times, Jerusalem
“‘We’re in King Hussein’s office,’ the Israeli military governor said. ‘Just six days ago the King was sitting in it. It’s hard to believe.’ Brig. Gen. Chaim Herzog, military governor of the West Bank, or occupied Jordan, is a 48-year-old rabbi’s son with a touch of brogue and a sense of humor.
His job is to direct, from an office in former Jordanian Jerusalem, the restoration of order in the occupied area. ‘But do you know what my biggest problem is?’ he asks. ‘It’s the Jews. They want to go to the Wailing Wall and they want to see their old homes and they want this back and that back. It’s very difficult.’
From his window on one of the main streets he can see Israeli soldiers checking passes as Arabs and Israelis arrive with a spectrum of problems. The Arab shops across the street remain tightly shuttered… Herzog said that his advice to Israeli governors in Arab towns, now that the fighting is over, is ‘use plenty of common sense and plenty of Arab labor.
We don’t want separate Israeli administrations.’ ‘The Jordanians have been amazed at our approach. The former governor, Anwar El Katib, told me he was flabbergasted. They expected the conquest to be something quite different.’ The result, he said, is that while many Jordanians fled, many have also returned.
The flight across the Jordan River continues, he said, but the majority have remained and ‘we hope they will soon open their shops’… ‘In any case, we don’t want the United Nations in here,’ he said. ‘My view is that the U.N. has been a divisive force, not a unifying one. They’ve become a vested interest here.
I’d like to work without them.’
He said Israeli instructions were broadcast on expanded Arab transmissions, were contained in bill posters and were announced over megaphones after curfew, which begins at 3 p.m. in cities and 6 p.m. in the country… Israeli soldiers remain on duty throughout Jersualem and other cities… Sunday was the last day to turn in weapons.
‘Then we will have to find them house to house,’ he said. Jerusalem continues to shake with the rumble of unexploded shells being touched off by demolition experts… Bulldozers have cleared a huge plaza in front of the Wailing Wall, Judaism’s holiest site, and tomorrow tens of thousands of Israelis made their first pilgrimage there this week.”
The military governor of the West Bank interviewed in King Hussein’s office sixteen days after the war, in a small Illinois daily. He calls the territory occupied Jordan, calls the war the conquest, says the Jews are his biggest problem, and describes the curfew, the house-to-house weapons search and the bulldozers clearing the plaza at the Wailing Wall. The Arab quarter cleared for that plaza is not mentioned. “Jersualem” is the paper’s.
ON THE RIVER JORDAN, Jordan, June 21, AP—Arab refugees crossing from the Israeli-occupied west bank of the River Jordan said the Israelis forced them from their homes and they left all belongings behind. Many of the men and women who clambered across the twisted steel girders of the wrecked Allenby bridge brought little more than the clothes they wore.
They said they did not know what they would do in the future. One man, a teacher of the Koran, the Moslem holy book, said he was prepared to go back as a guerrilla fighter to regain his home and his property. “I can pray, but I also know how to fight.
Vengeance will never be forgotten,” the man told reporters who watched the refugees crossing into Arab-held territory. Many refugees said the Israelis used a combination of harassment and force in driving them out of their villages.
One 70-year-old farmer who crossed with his family of 10 said the Israelis used bulldozers to knock down all the houses in his village near Jerusalem with the exception of three dwellings, which they used as observation posts.
“We told them we were willing to live under Israeli rule provided we could stay on our land,” he said, “But they said only ‘Go to Nasser.
Go to Hussein.’” … One refugee, 45-year-old farmer Abdel Khalim Hamoud from Beitour near Jerusalem, brought the five women in his family over the river because he said they were too frightened by the Israeli soldiers.
Eliav Simon, United Press International, Jerusalem
“JERUSALEM, Israel (UPI)– Informed sources today said Israel has drawn up plans to resettle Palestinian refugees from the 1948 Middle East war. About 700,000 Palestinians who fled from what is now Israel fell under Israeli control again in this month’s war. They live in vast, futureless camps in the Gaza Strip and in western Jordan.
The presence of the Palestinians, idle for two decades in their camps, has long been a bar to peace in the Middle East… The sources said plans for the refugees are being drawn up regardless of whatever territorial adjustments are made as a result of Israeli conquest of Arab lands.”
Seven hundred thousand, and the word Palestinians, in a 1967 wire story. The sources are Israeli, the money is to come from world Jewry, international organizations and the Arab states, and no Palestinian is quoted.
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Israel plans to settle tens of thousands of Arab refugees in the Gaza Strip and on the west bank of the Jordan River, an authoritative economics writer said Thursday.
Quoting official sources, David Krivine wrote in the Jerusalem Post that the resettlement plans would be made on economic grounds without regard for whatever territorial adjustments eventually may be made between Israel and Arab states.
A refugee rehabilitation and settlement authority would be set up, “terminating two decades of confinement and idleness within the refugee camps,” Krivine wrote. Some refugees have been in camps since they were displaced in the 1948 Palestine war.
The program would be financed by Israel, but world Jewry, international bodies, and the Arabs themselves would be asked to contribute. “Much depends on the cooperation of local Arab authorities,” Krivine wrote. “The first step is to get economic activity restored to its former levels.”
Eighteen days after the war, a plan to settle the refugees where they are, sourced to an Israeli newspaper quoting official sources. The word for what happened to them in 1948 is displaced, and the two decades in the camps are described as confinement and idleness.
By Elias N. Antar, Associated Press, Amman, Jordan
AMMAN, Jordan AP — Palestinian refugees charged today that Israeli troops occupying the Jordan River’s west bank are systematically deporting inhabitants of villages along the 1949 armistice line between Jordan and Israel.
Refugees, interviewed in their temporary quarters in an Amman school building, claimed villagers are being removed by force, intimidation and trickery. Several refugees said they were threatened with death if they tried to return to their homes.
They said at least two villages on the western edge of the Israeli-occupied west bank region have been leveled by Israeli demolition crews and bulldozers. Other villages were partly destroyed and some of their young men taken away by the Israeli troops, the refugees said.
They said the Israelis used “terror tactics” to frighten the villagers, then forced them to leave in buses and on foot for the River Jordan marking the truce line. Thousands of these refugees have crossed into east Jordan since the cease-fire.
The villages affected are in an area from which the Israelis claimed Arab guerrillas staged raids into Israel before the six-day war.
The two villages which the refugees said had been razed were Qalqilye, an agricultural community of 12,000 about 30 miles northwest of Jerusalem, and Imwas, a village of 3,000 12 miles west of Jerusalem… An Israeli spokesman in Tel Aviv has denied charges that Israeli forces had evacuated Qalqilye and demolished the town.
He admitted the town was badly damaged, but said this resulted from the fighting. The spokesman also denied that Palestinian refugees were being herded across the Jordan River by Israeli soldiers. The refugees who were interviewed said they came from Qalqilye and Imwas and from the small village of Kafr Jammal north of Qalqilye.
Others said they came from Tulkarm, a town of 25,000 inhabitants 10 miles north of Qalqilye. A 75-year-old farmer and landowner from Imwas said the Israelis tricked him and his family into leaving the village by saying they were being taken to the nearby town of Rammalah for two hours.
The verb is deporting, in the headline and in the first sentence, attributed to the people it happened to. The method is force, intimidation and trickery. Four villages are named with their populations. The Israeli denial runs to two paragraphs and is printed in full, and the last paragraph is a seventy-five-year-old man explaining how he was got out of his house.
WASHINGTON (AP) — The American Red Cross is shipping $350,000 worth of drugs and medicines donated by 10 U.S. pharmaceutical firms to aid thousands of refugees displaced by the Israeli-Arab war.
AMMAN, Jordan (AP) — Palestinian refugees charged that Israeli troops occupying the Jordan River’s west bank are systematically deporting inhabitants of villages along the 1949 armistice line between Jordan and Israel.
Refugees, interviewed in their temporary quarters in an Amman school building, claimed villagers are being removed by force, intimidation and trickery. Several refugees said they were threatened with death if they tried to return to their homes.
They said at least two villages on the western edge of the Israeli-occupied west bank region have been leveled by Israeli demolition crews and bulldozers.
The same dispatch, cut to five paragraphs and stacked under a Washington item about donated medicine, with the headline changed from deportation to exodus. The Israeli denial is not in this version.
ARAB REFUGEE CHILDREN are helped across the wrecked Allenby Bridge
ARAB REFUGEE CHILDREN are helped across the wrecked Allenby Bridge over the Jordan River from the Israeli-occupied section of Jordan yesterday. No official count was available but it was the biggest one-day movement of refugees in the 15 days since the cease-fire between Jordan and Israel. (AP Wirephoto by radio from Amman)
ARAB REFUGEES LIMP TO JORDAN, VICTIM OF MIDEAST HERITAGE
By RAY MOSELY and JOSEPH GRIGG, United Press International
They come from Jerusalem, Ramallah, Nablus and Hebron, struggling across the Judaean wilderness on foot, in stifling buses, ancient automobiles or oxcarts. Hour after hour, day after day, they limp through biblical Jericho, hard by the banks of the River Jordan.
Tens of thousands of them, loaded down with pots and pans, baby carriages and whatever else they can salvage from the Middle East war. They are the refugees, the human flotsam and jetsam of war. The children in their ranks face long years—perhaps a lifetime—in the spirit-destroying hopelessness of refugee camps.
All have a single goal: The Allenby Bridge leading from Israeli-occupied Jericho into Jordan. The bridge’s steel girders, destroyed by the fleeing Jordanian army, sag into the muddy, brown waters five miles east of Jericho. … Israel has not said it would take them and the Arab states in the past have refused to absorb them. Why do they flee, those who are able?
For a multitude of reason. Said a student waiting at the Allenby Bridge: “My father works in Kuwait. He used to send me money but he don’t now and I’m broke. That’s why I am going to Amman.” “Some are going because they are afraid,” said an Arab cab driver shuttling back and forth to Jerusalem.
“Some are uncertain about the future. Some are going because they are separated from their families.” Jericho’s only remaining mailman sought Israeli permission to cross over into Jordanian Jordan and bring back his family. He was told this was impossible and he, too, joined the one-way traffic across Allenby.
A man from the Old City of Jerusalem drove some friends to the bridge. “The Jews drove me from my home once,” he said. “They won’t again. Nothing will get me to leave.”
AMMAN, Jordan (AP) — Palestinian refugees charged Saturday that Israeli troops occupying the Jordan River’s west bank are systematically deporting inhabitants of villages along the 1949 armistice line between Jordan and Israel.
Refugees, interviewed in their temporary quarters in an Amman school building, claimed villagers are being removed by force, intimidation and trickery. Several refugees said they were threatened with death if they tried to return to their homes.
They said at least two villages on the western edge of the Israeli-occupied west bank region have been leveled by Israeli demolition crews and bulldozers. Other villages were partly destroyed and some of their young men taken away by the Israeli troops, the refugees said.
They said the Israelis used “terror tactics” to frighten the villagers, then forced them to leave in buses and on foot for the River Jordan marking the truce line. … The refugees who were interviewed said they came from Qalqilye and Imwas and from the small village of Kafr Jammal north of Qalqilye.
Others said they came from Tulkarm, a town of 25,000 inhabitants 10 miles north of Qalqilye. A 75-year-old farmer and landowner from Imwas said the Israelis tricked him and his family into leaving the village by saying they were being taken to the nearby town of Rammalah for two hours. “But when we tried to go back, they stopped us.
I managed to sneak through the hills to Imwas,” he said. “All the houses had been blown up, including mine. Only three were left standing which the Israelis used as observation posts.” He and his family walked part of the way to the Jordan River and rode the rest of the way to the Allenby Bridge in buses provided by the Israelis.
A woman from Qalqilye said some houses were damaged when the village was taken on the first day of the fighting. After the shooting stopped, the Israelis told everyone, “go, go, go away,” she said. She and her husband and children left the village with most of its stone houses still standing.
Later, she said, other inhabitants of Qalqilye joined her on her trek to the river and told her the village had been leveled. A refugee newly arrived from a hamlet six miles north of Hebron said the Israelis had earmarked about 15 villages for destruction by the time he and his family left.
“They suspected members of the Palestine Liberation Organization were living there,” the man said. He said the Israelis terrorized the villagers by firing through doors and windows at night and by looting.
ALLENBY BRIDGE, Jordan (AP) — Israelis let Arab refugees return to their homes in the Israeli-occupied sector of Jordan on Sunday, apparently in a reversal of a previous policy. But the stream of refugees into eastern Jordan from the Israeli sector continued.
Israeli guards on Allenby Bridge were allowing Arabs who had fled the Israeli occupation earlier to return to their homes on the west bank of the Jordan River. Arabs seeking to return last week were turned back.
The day’s exodus from the Israeli sector ran smoothly in contrast to previous days and no shooting was heard from the western end of this damaged bridge across the river. Several groups of women and children were allowed back, even being helped by Israeli soldiers. Fathers seeking contact with families on the west bank also were able to get over.
According to unofficial estimates, between 4,000 and 5,000 people crossed eastward and more than 100 went westward by midday Sunday either to return home or to bring out members of their families. The refugees moved eastward into Transjordan at a rate of 600 an hour at the peak period.
There was no panic and little hysteria, in marked contrast to the rush days of the exodus in the middle of last week. The refugees appeared to be better organized. They were able to bring with them more of their household possessions.
Sewing machines, tape recorders, tables, chairs, beds and bulky mattresses were carried across the rickety improvised footbridge placed on the broken steel girders.
Four to five thousand going east and a hundred going west, in one day, three weeks after the war. Six hundred an hour at the peak. The paper counts the furniture they carried over the broken girders. Printed beside an advertisement headed “Facts You Should Know About Car Insurance.”
Israelis to Allow Refugees To Go Back to West Bank
JERUSALEM, July 2—The Israeli Government announced today that it would allow the Arab refugees who left the west bank of the Jordan River after the Israelis occupied it to return to their homes. It said that detailed conditions would be broadcast until July 10 and that the refugees would then have one month to return.
Persons who leave after Wednesday will not be allowed to return, the Government said. The decision, which followed a Cabinet meeting this morning, was made under increasing pressure from Western Governments and from the United Nations. The move represented a reversal for Maj. Gen. Moshe Dayan, who has opposed encouraging the refugees to return.
Some 100,000 Arabs have moved across the Jordan since the Israelis took control of the west bank on June 7. Opposed by Dayan At a news conference a week ago, General Dayan, who is Defense Minister, said he opposed the return of the refugees.
He said that he would not oppose the reuniting of families, “but if the 100,000 who left would feel like coming back, I would not be for letting them come back.” Asked why he opposed the return, General Dayan said: “Why should we? We are two and one-half million Jews here, and the last contact that we had with these people was that they wanted to destroy us.
That was just 20 days ago, if you recall.” The announcement today said that returning refugees would have to prove that they had been west-bank residents and that they were not “security risks.” Experts on Committee The Government also decided to appoint a committee to work on “rehabilitating Arab refugees.”
A Foreign Ministry spokesman said that this applied to refugees in the Gaza Strip as well as on the west bank. Dr. Raanan Wietz, head of the settlement department of the Jewish Agency, will direct the committee, consisting of experts in economics, agriculture, irrigation, industry, commerce, development, artisan work, social problems and demography.
Bethlehem—Not all Arabs living and working in the areas newly occupied by Israel feel the same degree of resentment toward their conquerors. Take Victor Jarjoura, an Arab who lives in Bethlehem. Jarjoura is a Christian and a manufacturer of religious objects.
Asked how painful the occupation boot of the Israelis is to him, he smiled and said, “In my case, it’s not boot, not even a shoe, but a soft slipper.”
CLOCKWATCHERS. A Jordanian family hastens home recently to meet the evening curfew imposed by Israeli forces. The family of Arabs lives in a community in the “Big Bulge” area of Jordan occupied by the Israelis.
Arabs at a Jordanian Camp Spurn Offer to Let Them Return to West Bank
By ERIC PACE
ZEIZEIA, Jordan, July 3—Palestinian refugees, interviewed at a camp here today, rejected Israel’s offer to ‘let them return home and shouted that all Israelis were “kazabeen”—liars. Their complaint was echoed, though more mildly, by a Jordanian Government spokesman who said that “the Israelis are trying to deceive us.”
An Israeli radio broadcast announcing that refugees from the Jordan River’s west bank, now occupied by Israel, would be permitted to return was heard yesterday on transistor radios in the camp at this desert water hole 20 miles south of Amman. Today, one refugee, Ali Ahmed Almallah, scowled and said: “I do not go back to the west bank if the Jews remain.
I will rather die here.” Mr. Almallah, who is 56 years old, gestured at the rows of tents. A crowd of men around him talked angrily. A Jordanian police official, Hassan Ahmed, murmured to an American visitor: “Do not say you are an American or they will kill you.”
The United States is providing 10,000 tents for the refugees, but they resent America’s support of Israel in the past. Israel offered to let refugees come back to the west bank if they returned by Aug. 10. No one who leaves after July 4—tomorrow—will be allowed to return, the Israelis said.
A spokesman for the Jordanian Information Ministry, Ghazi Saudi, said that the Israeli offer had been made for propaganda purposes. Government officials said privately that poor refugees feared that they would not … [JUMP OF THE MATCHED ARTICLE — this is the part that merges into CP-1967-044:] Refugees at Camp Spurn Israeli Offer Continued From Page 1, Col.
7 be able to support themselves under Israeli occupation. Refugees at the camp, whose thousand tents are pitched near a Roman cistern renovated by American aid, said that the Israelis had destroyed and looted some houses on the west bank and threatened to shoot Palestinians if they did not leave.
By Allenby Bridge, across the Jordan River, scores of refugees tried to return home to the west bank. They were turned away by Israeli officials, who told them to come back in a few days. [END OF THE MATCHED ARTICLE.
Everything below is SEPARATE material printed on the same clipping — three distinct sidebar stories with their own heads, bylines and datelines, plus a photograph and caption.
Transcribed so nothing on the page is lost, but NOT part of CP-1967-044 and NOT to be merged into its excerpt.] [SIDEBAR 1 — separate story, own byline:] Dayan Visits Allenby Bridge By JAMES FERON Special to The New York Times JERICHO, Jordan, July 3—Maj. Gen.
Moshe Dayan, the Israeli Defense Minister, traveled to Allenby Bridge today to find out why refugees were continuing to leave the Israeli-controlled west bank. Although the Cabinet decided yesterday to give those who had left a month in which they could return, the traffic was still outward bound this morning.
Fifty to 60 trucks loaded with furnishings and other possessions waited on the narrow road leading to the demolished bridge across the Jordan River. General Dayan, who speaks Arabic, talked with Arabs and with Israeli officers. The conversations made it clear that the refugees are leaving for a variety of reasons, mostly dealing with family and financial problems.
“Some of these people have their relatives on the other side, men who sent families to Amman while they stayed on to keep the cattle or protect the house or the business,” General Dayan said. “Now they want to join their family.” “Others are moving their whole household away, the ones you see with the furniture,” he added.
“In some cases, the wage earner is in Kuwait or Saudi Arabia and they cannot receive his assistance unless they go to Amman. “And there are others who simply would rather live under Arab rule than under Israeli rule. We are not Arabs, let’s face it.”
General Dayan was asked what kind of proof would be required of returning refugees to show that they had been residents of the west bank. He said that had not been worked out, but that it would not be complicated. He watched for several minutes as refugees walked slowly across the unstable boards and planks of the bridge.
About two dozen trucks and several hundred men waited on the other side.
There was no sign that anyone was returning. [SIDEBAR 2 — separate story:] Arabs Urged to Return Special to The New York Times BEIRUT, Lebanon, July 3—Laurence Michelmore, Commissioner General of the United Nations Relief and Work Agency for Palestine Refugees, today urged Arabs who fled the west bank area to return to their homes.
The situation on the east bank of the Jordan River, he said, “caused me great anxiety” before the Israeli announcement that refugees could go back.
“Temporary accommodation in schools, where five or six families were living in one room, posed a serious health hazard, not only for refugees but also for surrounding communities,” he said. [SIDEBAR 3 — separate story:] Hussein Welcomes Offer Special to The New York Times LONDON, July 3—King Hussein of Jordan today called the Israeli offer to allow refugees to return to their homes on the west bank of the Jordan River “a welcome development.”
“Only time will show whether this offer was sincere,” he said at a news conference in the Jordanian Embassy here. The King estimated that 120,000 to 150,000 refugees had crossed the river, fleeing for a variety of reasons. He said that some had feared napalm and fragmentation bombs, that some had found their homes destroyed and that others faced hunger or looting.
The Amman radio urged west-bank inhabitants to stay in their homes and urged those who had departed to return, the King said. King Hussein said that he was giving first priority to bringing about an Arab summit meeting. “This is the time for it,” he said. “All indications make me feel it will be held.”
He had just come from lunch with Prime Minister Wilson and George Brown, the Foreign Secretary. [SIDEBAR 4 — separate item:] King Arrives in Paris PARIS, July 3 (Reuters)—King Hussein arrived here tonight from London for talks tomorrow with President de Gaulle. [PHOTOGRAPH, top right of page, with credit and caption:] United Press International Cablephoto Prime Minister Wilson welcoming King Hussein of Jordan outside 10 Downing Street in London yesterday.
ALLENBY BRIDGE, Jordan (UPI)—Israeli Defense Minister Moshe Dayan appealed in person to Arab refugees Monday not to flee from the Israeli-held west bank of the Jordan River. Dayan flew to Allenby Bridge by helicopter. He watched somberly as nearly 1,000 refugees clambered slowly and laboriously across the broken girders in 100-degree heat.
The Israeli government said Sunday that between July 7 and Aug. 10 any residents of western Jordan who fled across the river to the Arab-held east could return if they wished. Israel had been refusing to let Arabs back but relented in the face of mounting humanitarian problems regarding the refugees’ welfare.
It was generally estimated about 20,000 refugees had fled across the Jordan since the six-day Arab-Israeli war ended. Another 80,000 to 100,000 were thought to have crossed during the fighting. TALKS IN ARABIC Talking to scores of refugees in Arabic, which he speaks fairly fluently, Dayan asked why they were fleeing and told them they could return between July 7 and Aug. 10.
He reiterated repeatedly that Israel was doing and had done nothing to drive Arabs out of the occupied west bank territory. Dayan later told newsmen. “I feel very sorry about this flight of thousands of Arabs, particularly from the humane point of view.” “If people do want to leave, I have no objections and I cannot prevent them.
But I have told them repeatedly we are not driving them out nor forcing them to leave and reminding them they can come back if they want.”
· Corpus Christi Caller Times · Corpus Christi · page 1
Dayan Says Gaza Strip Will Be Part of Israel
Comment Angrily Attacked
Dayan said in Gaza: “The Gaza Strip is Israel, and I think it should become an integral part of the country.” The head of Jordan’s U.N. delegation, Ambassador Muhammad H. el Farra, told a newsman: “This is part and parcel of the expansionist designs of Zionism.”
He added that the “dreams of Zionism” for acquiring more lands and displacing more people will not be fulfilled.
A month after the war, on Guam, and the verb is annex — printed flat, as the state’s own announced plan. In the next column the same page runs Arabs Balk At Zionist Expansion, so both words are on one page in July 1967.
But Anti-Jewish Material in Books and on Walls Will Be Eliminated First
By TERENCE SMITH / Special to The New York Times
TEL AVIV, July 7—Israel intends to reopen the Arab schools in her newly occupied territories, but only after ridding them of all traces of anti-Israeli propaganda. Israeli troops who captured the major towns in the Gaza Strip reported finding virulent anti-Israeli material in the textbooks and defamatory murals on the school walls.
The Israelis also said they found a lesser amount of propaganda in Jordanian schools in the west-bank area. The military officer in charge of civilian affairs in the occupied territories said the schools would be opened in the fall, but that the offending textbooks would be removed and the walls repainted to cover the anti-Israeli drawings.
The most extreme examples of propaganda, according to the Israelis, were discovered in the schools in Gaza, where the Palestine Liberation Organization was most active. Drawings on Walls The troops who took the town of Khan Yunis, near the southern end of the Gaza strip, reported that the walls of the main elementary school there were covered with drawings.
In a room that served as an art class for youngsters in the second and third grades, the soldiers reported finding a mural, apparently painted by the teachers and students, that depicted a Zionist Jew with a huge nose, being bayonetted by a handsome Arab soldier. Another mural was said to show a Zionist Jew assaulting an Arab woman while Arab refugees looked on in horror.
In textbooks used in Gaza to teach arithmetic to third-grade students, the Israelis said they found problems with political overtones.
An Israeli officer said one problem posed the following situation: "If 10 Fedayeen [Arab terrorists] cross the border into Israel and kill 20 Zionists, what is the average number of Jews killed by each Feydayeen?" "We've known about these anti-Israeli textbooks for some time," the officer said, "and we have made protests to the United Nations over the years about their use.
But the murals were a surprise to us." The Israelis will also attempt to weed out extremist teachers from the Arab schools. A survey has already been started to determine how many qualified teachers are still in the occupied areas and the condition of the school buildings, many of which were damaged during the fighting.
The plan to reopen the schools is one of several steps the Israelis are taking to make life in the occupied areas normal.
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — the earliest clipping in the thread (8 July 1967, a month after the war) and the one that matters most for the 'anti-Jewish' question. THE DECK IS THE FINDING: 'But Anti-Jewish Material in Books and on Walls Will Be Eliminated First.' That is The New York Times speaking in its own voice, in its own deck, over a staff-written story. The body of the story never uses 'anti-Jewish' — it says 'anti-Israeli propaganda', 'anti-Israeli material', 'anti-Israeli drawings', five times over, and attributes every instance to Israeli troops, Israeli officers or 'the Israelis'. The deck converts attributed 'anti-Israeli' into unattributed 'Anti-Jewish'. That is the same slide Maria flagged on slide 112, happening here first, in the paper of record, over a staff byline — and here it is cleaner, because you can see the body text the deck departs from. If only one clipping in this batch carries the argument, it is this one, paired with s112_2.
Who is censoring: the military officer in charge of civilian affairs in the occupied territories; offending textbooks removed, walls repainted, 'extremist teachers' to be weeded out. Whose voice: the reporting is scrupulously attributed throughout ('Israeli troops … reported', 'according to the Israelis', 'the soldiers reported', 'was said to show'). Smith is careful. The deck is not. Is any Palestinian quoted: no — no Arab teacher, parent, pupil or official appears, and the only Palestinian voice in the piece is, again, the content of the confiscated books and murals.
VOCABULARY: the headline says 'Occupied Territories' in capitals; the lede says 'her newly occupied territories'; the body says 'the occupied areas' four times, 'the west-bank area', 'Arab schools', 'the Gaza strip' (lower-case s). No hedging, no 'so-called', no scare quotes. The Times in July 1967 simply calls it occupation.
Stop the arrests and the police terror! Release the political prisoners
The Central Committee of the Communist Party of Israel
“The Central Committee protests strongly against the arrest of persons opposed to the war, against the arrest of leaders and members of the Communist Party of Israel and others. Immediately with the opening of the war, many administrative arrests were made according to the British Mandatory oppressive emergency rules from the year 1945. The following comrades were arrested: Zahy KARKABY, member of the Secretariat of the C.C.; the C.C.-members: Mun’em JARJURAH and Othman ABU-RASS; Tawfiq ZAYYAD, Councillor of Nazareth; the members of the editorial board of the organ of the Communist Party (Arabic), AL-ITTIHAD: Ali ASHOUR, Mohammad KHAS, Samih EL-KASSEM and Mahmoud DARWISH; the members of the C.C. of the Young Communist League of Israel, Salem JUBRAN and George GHREIB; Abdul-Hamid ABU-ITA, member of the C.P. district committee of the Triangle and Councillor of Taibeh; Assad MAKI, member of the district committee in Tel-Aviv-Jaffa, secretaries of local branches of the Party and other activists.
Some of the arrested were released after 14 days. The arrests of others was prolonged and more were arrested.
Lately arrested were: the member of the C.C. and the head of the Communist group in the town council of Nazareth, comrade Fuad KHOURY; the member of the C.C. and councillor of Acre, Ramsi KHOURY; the lawyer Abdul-Hafiz DARAWSHEH, councillor of Nazareth; Youssif SH’HADEH, deputy mayor of Kufr-Yassif; Nassri EL-MOOR, councillor of Ibbeleen, and others.
All these comrades are still imprisoned, without guilt and without trial. Other Arab citizens, who are known to be against the war, were arrested too… In the Arab districts of Israel, heaviest restrictions of the freedom of movement were introduced.
The Arab people living in those areas were ordered to remain at their homes for several days, without any possibility to go to work and earn a living. In some places, like Taibeh and Kufr-Yassif, police-terror reigned. People were brought to the police-stations and beaten up most brutally ‘to teach them a lesson.’
While doing this, the policemen called: ‘The time has come to settle accounts’ — ‘Democracy has come to an end’ — etc.… The aim of the terror is to quiet the voice of the other Israel, the one which is against war, against aggression and conquests, against hostilities aimed at the Arab people, the voice which fights for a just peace between Israel and the Arab states.”
Fourteen Palestinians named in one column, six weeks after the June war. Two of them are among the best known poets their people have produced: Mahmoud Darwish, who is in this archive again in 1994 and lying in a Houston hospital in 2008, and Samih al-Qasim. A third, Tawfiq Zayyad, turns up nine years later reciting a poem to an American convention. The arrests are made under emergency regulations the British wrote in 1945, and the statement says so in its third sentence. The capitals are the paper’s own.
“The writer is chairman of the Department of Physics at American University of Beirut. The Observer’s Forum column of July 18 carried a letter from Rabbi Israel J. Gerber under the headline, ‘What About Aggressor Who Loses?’
Visiting your pleasant city, I noticed this letter and as a Palestinian Arab, now a citizen of the Republic of Lebanon, I feel I should try to clarify some points made or assumed in Rabbi Gerber’s comments on the Middle East.
Rabbi Gerber begins by stating ‘Except for Russia and the Arab blocs, most governments, news correspondents, analysts and editorial writers agree that the Arab states were the aggressors ...’
It may have been stupid for the Arabs to have had all their planes on the ground when the Israelis attacked in June, but that type of unpreparedness is no characteristic of an aggressor.
On the CBS news special July 13, the statements by Israeli military leaders and the comments of General Marshall (USA, Ret.) made it clear that Israel attacked first and at an hour when United Nations delegates would be asleep in New York. I should like to refute some of the many other myths about Palestine to which Americans are so often exposed.
1. The assertion that Palestine has been the property of the Jewish people ‘since the days of King David’ is a myth. For some 2,500 years prior to 1948, there was no political entity called Israel and Palestine was inhabited by Semitic peoples, Aramaic-speaking before the seventh century and mainly Arabic-speaking since.
It is untrue that Palestine was an empty land when Zionist colonization began; Arab men, women and children were living there as they always had.
2. The refrain constantly echoed by Zionists that Palestinian Arabs left Palestine of their own accord or at the command of aggressive Arab governments is false.
The truth — that Arabs fled from terrorism perpetrated against defenseless people such as those of Deir Yassin, a village near Jerusalem — is contained in the statement of a British Middle East authority: ‘The massacre of Deir Yassin, the latest link in a chain of terror, had struck fear into the hearts of these civilians whose homes lay in the path of Zionist forces.
Just as, in 1940, Frenchmen in their thousands fled the advancing Nazis, so, in 1948, before the Zionists, thousands of Arabs did the same and for the same reason.’ (Stewart Perowne, ‘Levant Diary: the Refugee Situation,’ Middle East in Transition, ed. by Walter Z. Laqueur, p. 222)
3. The charge that Arabs are anti-Semitic and persecute Jews is a ludicrous libel. Arabs are Semites themselves.
Jewish citizens traditionally played important roles in Arab society and cultural life; the Arab relationship with their Jewish ‘cousins’ was generally happy until the Zionist colonization of Palestine, a project with the declared aim of expelling the Arab population and establishing a Jewish nation-state, began in modern times.
Arabs do not hate Jews; Arabs are hostile only to Zionism, a movement dedicated to the expropriation of land on which they had their homes and on which their forefathers had lived for centuries…
5. The assertion that refugees are deliberately confined to camps and kept in penury by Arab governments is untrue. An analogy will illustrate the magnitude of the refugee problem. In Lebanon, the 1948 war brought an influx of some 150,000 refugees into a population numbering 1.5 million.
To Lebanon, this was like what bringing 18 million destitute persons into the United States within a few weeks would be to America. For Jordan the situation is worse; there are as many refugees as non-refugees.
It should be remembered that some 92 per cent of all private property in Palestine was owned by Arabs before May 15, 1948 (see Encyclopaedia Britannica, 1967, XVII, 171) and that the owners of this land were not only expelled from their homes and the land they loved but were not compensated for even the material loss.
My own family, for example, holds United Nations records of our property holdings in Haifa; but for 20 years we have been exiled from our home and for 20 years we have received no offer of compensation.
4. The statement often made that Arab states have received more financial assistance than Israel has is false…
8. Contrary to general opinion here, the Arabs are working hard to solve the refugee problem. Unfortunately, our economic and educational handicaps have prevented our healing the physical wounds (to say nothing of the psychological ones) inflicted upon us by superior power.
Like many Southerners, we Arabs perhaps brood overmuch on our wrongs and relive too often our defeats. And because we have not mastered Western techniques of persuasion and public relations, we have failed to do justice to our own just cause.”
A cartoon runs in the same column, unrelated: two figures under an umbrella among a crowd, captioned “They say the earth will soon be overcrowded. How will we know?”
A Palestinian physicist at the American University of Beirut answering a rabbi’s letter point by point in an American forum column, seven weeks after the June war. He cites the Britannica and a British diarist by page number, and gives his own family’s United Nations property records in Haifa as evidence. The closing comparison is to Southerners brooding on their defeats.
A Holy City Torn By War, Where Hope, Hate Continue
By LOWELL BLANKFORT
SIMON said, “There has been enough fighting. Yes, Arabs who had lived in old Palestine have suffered injustices, but that is all past now and we should start anew. Arabs, Jews, Christians—we are all the same people and really the same religion. We must learn to live together in peace.”
AT WAILING WALL—The centuries old contrasts that make up Jerusalem are highlighted in this photo, showing a bearded old man hobbling along in the foreground dressed in modern slacks and short sleeved shirts of today.
KHARTOUM — The Palestine Liberation Organization made public Tuesday a proposal that all 13 Arab nations… The organization, which is backed by the United Arab Republic and the Arab League, claims to represent all…
Six weeks after the June war, in Nashua, New Hampshire. The PLO is explained to a reader who may never have heard of it, and the verb in the headline is urged.
A bitter legacy of the war was the expulsion of several hundred thousand Palestine Arabs from their villages to slums on the outskirts of cities in Lebanon, Syria and Jordan and to the Gaza strip. Natural increase brought the refugee population to over 1,000,000—fertile soil for fanatical anti-Israel agitation by Arab nationalism.
A full-page history primer — Herzl, Balfour, Wingate, Irgun, Bernadotte’s assassination, Suez — run in a Texas daily in 1967. The word is expulsion.
Arab merchants and shopkeepers i nthe former Jordanian sector of Jerusalem padlocked their doors Monday in protest against Israel’s unification of the city. Nearly all the more than two thousand shops and stores inside the walls of the Old City of Jerusalem and in the new part of the Arab sector were closed.
The shutdown was called by a “Defense Committee of Arab Jerusalem” in leaflets distributed Sunday. Israel officials said the strike was instigated from outside Jerusalem and that it was called to coincide with the arrival in Israel of United Nations representative Nils G. Gussing, who arrived in Jerusalem Sunday from Amman.
Israel and Jordan meanwhile resolved a deadlock that had been blocking repatriation of an estimated 260 thousand Arabs who fled from the west bank of the Jordan River during and after the six-day war. But Egypt postponed the transfer of Egyptian civilians from the Israeli-occupied Sinai desert into Egypt.
Cairo newspapers reported an Arab summit conference will be held in Khartoum, Sudan, strating August 29. The Foreign Ministers of the 13 Arab nations ended a conference in Khartoum Saturday with a cali for the meeting and a pledge to “eradicate all vestiges of Zionist imperialist aggression.”
JERUSALEM ARABS IN GENERAL STRIKE TO RESIST ISRAEL
All Shops and Restaurants in the Formerly Jordanian Area Are Shut for Day · POLICE PATROLS HEAVY · No Incidents Reported—Taxes as Much as Politics Are Viewed as Motive
By TERENCE SMITH
JERUSALEM, Aug. 7—The Arab population of East Jerusalem staged a general strike today against Israeli control of the former Jordanian sector, halting all business activity, including shops and restaurants. It was the most dramatic example of Arab resistance to Israeli occupation since the six-day war ended on June 11.
Every one of East Jerusalem’s business establishments, estimated to total 2,000, remained shuttered during the day. In the twisting, narrow streets of the historic Old City, Arabs lounged outside the closed shops, grinning at passersby as though they were enjoying a private joke. The Israeli authorities kept a watchful eye on the situation.
Reinforced patrols of heavily armed border policemen moved through the Old City. In the late morning, after rumors of an impending Arab demonstration began to circulate, three jeeps with machine guns mounted between the seats rolled into the area. The demonstration did not materialize and there were no reports of incidents.
JERUSALEM, Aug. 8—Four stores in East Jerusalem were padlocked by the Israeli authorities today and five arrest warrants were issued in retaliation for the general strike by the Arab population yesterday. In addition, the operating license of an Arab bus company serving the eastern part of Jerusalem and its suburbs was lifted for an indefinite period.
The warrants were issued against five suspected instigators of the strike, which halted all business activity in the former Jordanian sector. The accused organizers were not identified. They were expected to be arrested shortly.
NABLUS, Israeli-Occupied Jordan — The Arab bank manager’s house — modest, spotless, clean and cool — sits on the edge of a hill on the outskirts of Nablus looking across a…
Ten weeks after the war, and the standing head is ISRAELI OCCUPATION in small capitals — a Spokane paper using the word as a department label, the way another page would say SPORTS. Underneath, the headline takes the two subjects to be joblessness and closed banks, and gives the people the adjective impoverished rather than the verb.
Israel Rewriting Arab Textbooks To Erase Anti-Zionist Propaganda
TEL AVIV (AP) — Some 235,000 children whose Arab schools were closed by the Middle East wargo back to school Monday under Israeli supervision, and with books carefully rewritten to eliminate anti-Zionist propaganda. The educational experiment in Arab territories occupied by Israel is being watched by Israelis, Arabs and the world beyond the Middle East.
Some of the children will have no books. Israeli authorities still are printing thousands of new texts on history, geography and literature. And some will have no teachers. Most of the more than 7,000 Arab teachers have indicated they will work under the Israelis, but many have refused. No Israeli teachers will work in the Arab schols.
"If teachers don't have books, they'll just have to teach without texts or on the subjects for which we have cleared books," an Israeli Education Ministry spokesman said. Arab books were scrutinized by Israeli educators for weeks. Of 134 types of books seized in the Israeli-occupied west bank territory, only 56 were found acceptable.
Only 39 of 129 from the Gaza Strip were cleared as free of anti-Zionist material. Israeli officials said most of the objectionable material was found in history, geography and Arab literature books.
But officials said in one arithmetic book they found 8-year-olds were given the following problem: "If our defense forces killed three Zionist terrorists and captured another when seven attacked our town, how many were left?" In such a case the entire book has to be reprinted under the Israeli rule.
"We have to reprint even if there is only one sentence we find objectionable," said Ya'acov Sarid, director-general of the Israeli Education Ministry. "If we just crossed it out or snipped it out the children would ask questions." The new textbooks are printed in Arabic and generally the Israelis say they have not changed the Arab curricula.
Israel does, however, intend to introduce Hebrew gradually into Old Jerusalem, the sector of the holy city seized from Jorbrew will be introduced in other occupied areas "if the parents request it." The 200,000 Arab children on the west bank of the Jordan River and the 100,000 in the Gaza Strip will receive free schooling.
But in Old Jerusalem, parents will have to pay fees based on size of family and amount of family income.
THE FOURTH HEADLINE on the Blanche dispatch, and the most explicit of the four about the operation:
s112_1 'Israel Opens Schools For Arab Children' (kicker 'Some Books Rewritten')
s104_2 'Israel Revises Slanted Arab Textbooks'
s105_1 'Israelis Censor Arab Textbooks'
s106_2 'Israel Rewriting Arab Textbooks To Erase Anti-Zionist Propaganda' <- this one
This desk used two decks' worth of headline and named the whole action: Israel, rewriting, to erase. 'Erase' is the paper's word, not the wire's — the AP copy says 'rewritten to eliminate anti-Zionist propaganda'. The headline is not hostile to Israel and not hostile to the books; it is simply the most complete description of what happened that any of the four desks wrote.
This clipping and its slide-mate make the best single pairing in the batch. s106_1, the Reuters item, is four paragraphs long and reports that several hundred Jordanian teachers threatened a boycott, that Israel abandoned the replacement textbooks, and that as a compromise 'offending pages and passages in the old books will be removed or blacked out'. s106_2, on the same slide, carries Ya'acov Sarid explaining why Israel wanted whole books reprinted instead: 'If we just crossed it out or snipped it out the children would ask questions.' Two wires, same week, same slide — the policy and the resistance that broke it, and the reason the resistance mattered.
Is any Palestinian quoted: no, in either. Across both clippings the Palestinian teachers act decisively and are never once given a sentence.
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — The Palestine Arab refugee cast miserably adrift by the Arab-Israeli war of 1948 finds himself 19 years later again a victim of conflict beyond understanding — still unwanted, a problem to all sides, a negative factor in the bargaining for peace. He and his family are among the world’s most pathetic people.
They and their kind were caught in the middle of the June 5-10 Middle East war, and many once more set out to transplant again the uprootings of a past generation. Some moved farther away from the lands that once were their homes.
They are the people who were forced out or abandoned their holdings in Palestine when Israeli arms carved this nation out of the traditional Holy Lands of Jew, Christian and Moslem in 1948. They settled in crowded camps in Arab lands around the Israeli perimeter — some within heartache sight of their old homes.
· The Sacramento Bee · Sacramento, CA · page Page A
Israeli Censors Purge Hate In Arab Textbooks
By Eric Gottgetreu
JERUSALEM (AP)—A team of 30 Arabic-speaking Isareli educators is working its way through a roomful of Arab school books, closely reading every word, hunting for propaganda. The books, nearly 400, were seized by the Israelis when they occupied the west bank region of Jordan, Syria's Golan Heights and the Gaza Strip last June.
The team's job is to cut out every word of what the education ministry calls "objectionable material." So far, 79 of 134 Jordanian textbooks have been cut. One hundred of the 139 books found in Egyptian desks and two-thirds of those taken from Syria have been expurgated.
Were Shocked An education ministry spokesman commented: "We were shocked at the amount of hate and incitement we found. We knew it was going on, but didn't realize it was to such an extent." Reprinting the thousands of textbooks is costing the Israelis nearly $1 million.
One woman scrutinizer, a mother of two, said bitterly: "It makes my blood run cold to see the horrible things the Arabs allowed their children to be taught." So far, only one Jordanian book has been banned outright—"The Palestine Problem," for high school students, written by Doukan Al-Handawi, a former Jordanian education minister.
It closed with this appeal: "You, the Arab student, are called upon to save your homeland, with all your strength and resources." Mohammed Plot "Arabs and Moslems," a fourth-grade Jordanian history book, declared the ancient Jews plotted to "get rid of Mohammed," the prophet of Islam, and were expelled by him from Medina when he discovered their plan.
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — the fullest account of the screening operation anywhere in the batch, and the only one that names a banned book.
Who is censoring: 'A team of 30 Arabic-speaking Israeli educators … closely reading every word, hunting for propaganda.' The paper's own verbs are 'seized', 'cut out', 'expurgated', 'banned outright', and the headline's word is 'Censors'. That is the second headline in the batch to use it (with s105_1, 'Israelis Censor Arab Textbooks'). What was removed: 79 of 134 Jordanian books, 100 of 139 Egyptian, two-thirds of the Syrian, at a reprinting cost of nearly $1 million.
THE FINDING THAT MATTERS FOR MARIA'S SLIDE-112 NOTE is the banned book. One book in the whole operation was banned outright rather than cut: 'The Palestine Problem', a high-school text by Doukan Al-Handawi, a former Jordanian education minister. The AP tells us what it closed with: 'You, the Arab student, are called upon to save your homeland, with all your strength and resources.' That is the evidence the wire chose to print for the single most severe act of censorship it is reporting — and it is a sentence about saving a homeland. No Jew, no Israel, no slur, no weapon. It sits four paragraphs above a genuine piece of religious antisemitism from a fourth-grade history book ('the ancient Jews plotted to get rid of Mohammed'), and the piece makes no distinction between them. Set this beside the UNESCO bullet — 'the duty . . . to liberate Palestine' — and the pattern is the same operation performed twice, two years apart, by two different wires: a Palestinian statement of attachment to the land is filed as an instance of hatred of Jews.
Is any Palestinian quoted: only Al-Handawi, and only through the one sentence of his that got his book banned. He is not asked about it. Nobody is.
The only ordinary person in the thread is on the other side: 'One woman scrutinizer, a mother of two' who finds it horrible what the Arabs allowed their children to be taught. The Arab mothers whose children's books she is cutting are not in the piece.
JERUSALEM — (Reuters) — Israeli occupation officials abandoned plans to introduce their own textbooks into Jordan West Bank schools next month after opposition by Jordanion teachers. Large numbers of new textbooks—based on the curriculum used in Arab schools in Israel—were printed to replace Arab textbooks, which were found to contain strong antiIsraeli sentiments.
Several hundred Jordanian teachers threatened to boycott classrooms at the start of the new school year on Sept. 1 unless the old books could be used. An Israeli official acknowledged that the plan to use new textbooks was abandoned, although many were printed. As a compromise, offending pages and passages in the old books will be removed or blacked out.
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — the short one, and the only clipping in the batch in which the Palestinian side wins anything concrete. Four paragraphs, and all four matter.
Who is censoring: 'Israeli occupation officials' — and that phrase is Reuters' own, in the first four words of the story, unhedged. No other clipping in the thread names the actor that way; the others say 'Israeli educators', 'Israeli authorities', 'the Israelis', 'the Israeli Education Ministry'. Reuters says occupation officials.
What happened: Israel printed 'large numbers' of its own replacement textbooks, based on the curriculum used in Arab schools inside Israel. Several hundred Jordanian teachers threatened to boycott the classrooms unless the old books could be used. Israel backed down — 'An Israeli official acknowledged that the plan to use new textbooks was abandoned, although many were printed.' The compromise: 'offending pages and passages in the old books will be removed or blacked out.'
That last sentence is the one to show Maria. Everywhere else in this thread the censorship is invisible by design — Ya'acov Sarid tells two American wires that whole books had to be reprinted precisely so that the children would not see the gap and ask questions (s105_1, s109_2). Here the teachers' boycott forces the opposite outcome: the old books stay, and the deletions are made visible, blacked out on the page in front of the child. The Palestinian teachers lost the passages and won the evidence that something had been taken.
Is any Palestinian quoted: no. The several hundred teachers act, and change the outcome, and are not given a word. The only person quoted even indirectly is 'An Israeli official'.
Note also that Reuters calls them 'Jordanian teachers' and the schools 'Jordan West Bank schools'; the children are not mentioned at all and the word Palestinian does not appear.
TEL AVIV (AP) — Some 235,000 children whose Arab schools were closed by the Middle East war went back to school Monday under Israeli supervision, and with books carefully rewritten to eliminate anti-Zionist propaganda. The educational experiment in Arab territories occupied by Israel is being watched by Israelis, Arabs and the world beyond the Middle East.
Some of the children will have no books. Israeli authorities still are printing thousands of new texts on history, geography and literature. And some will have no teachers. Most of the more than 7,000 Arab teachers have indicated they will work under the Israelis, but many have refused. No Israeli teachers will work in the Arab schools.
"If teachers don't have books, they'll just have to teach without texts or on the subjects for which we have cleared books," an Israeli Education Ministry spokesman said. Arab books were scrutinized by Israeli educators for weeks. Of 134 types of books seized in the Israeli-occupied west bank territory, only 56 were found acceptable.
Only 39 of 129 from the Gaza Strip were cleared as free of anti-Zionist material. The new textbooks are printed in Arabic and generally the Israelis say they have not changed the Arab curricula. Israel does, however, intend to introduce Hebrew gradually into Old Jerusalem, the sector of the holy city seized from Jordan.
Israeli officials said Hebrew will be introduced in other occupied areas "if the parents request it." The 200,00 Arab children on the west bank of the Jordan River and the 100,000 in the Gaza Strip will receive free schooling. But in Old Jerusalem, parents will have to pay fees based on size of family and amount of family income.
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — one of the strongest items in the batch. Who is censoring: named plainly as 'Israeli authorities', 'Israeli educators', 'an Israeli Education Ministry spokesman'. What was removed: books judged to contain 'anti-Zionist propaganda' / 'anti-Zionist material'; the paper gives the count in its own voice — of 134 types of books seized in the west bank only 56 were found acceptable, and only 39 of 129 from Gaza were cleared. The paper reports the screening as fact in its own voice ('books carefully rewritten to eliminate anti-Zionist propaganda' sits in the lede, unattributed), and attributes only the operational detail to the ministry spokesman. No Palestinian is quoted anywhere in the piece; the 7,000 Arab teachers who 'have refused' are counted but never given a sentence. The kicker above the headline reads 'Some Books Rewritten' — that is a kicker, not a deck, so dek left empty. Note the vocabulary: 'Arab territories occupied by Israel', 'the Israeli-occupied west bank territory', 'Arab children', 'the Gaza Strip'. 'Palestinian' does not appear.
Arab leaders have been meeting in Khartoum to discuss policy towards Israel after the Middle East war. Here ALBERT HOURANI, Director of the Middle East Centre at St Antony’s College, Oxford, and author of books on Middle East and Arab history, describes the problem of Palestine and Israel as the Arabs see it.
“Palestinian Arabs fleeing along the road out of Bethlehem earlier this year. Picture by David Newell Smith.” The three maps beside it are captioned: “United Nations’ plan, rejected by Arabs, would have split Palestine into Jewish State, Arab State and International zone round Jerusalem, linked in economic union.”
“First war left Israel with area twice that of Jewish State in UN plan, with rest of Palestine, including Jerusalem Old City, incorporated into Jordan, except Gaza Strip, under Egyptian rule.” “In latest war Israel occupied all former Palestine, Egyptian Sinai desert down to Suez Canal, and about 700 square miles of Syria.
Israel is claiming permanent possession of Jerusalem Old City (UN still advocates internationalised Jerusalem) but is not yet decided about other claims.”
A page given to a historian to set out the Arab case, three months after the June war. The page is dated on the clipping: The Observer, 3 September 1967, page 7. A British paper, so the spellings in the map captions are its own.
TEL AVIV (AP) — Some 235,000 children whose Arab schools were closed by the Middle East war go back to school today under Israeli supervision, and with books carefully rewritten to eliminate anti-Zionist propaganda. The educational experiment in Arab territories occupied by Israel is being watched by Israelis, Arabs and the world beyond the Middle East.
Some of the children will have no books. Israeli authorities still are printing thousands of new texts on history, geography and literature. And some will have no teachers. Most of the more than 7,000 Arab teachers have indicated they will work under the Israelis, but many have refused. No Israeli teachers will work in the Arab schools.
"If teachers don't have books, they'll just have to teach without texts or on the subjects for which we have cleared books," an Israeli Education Ministry spokesman said. Arab books were scrutinized by Israeli educators for weeks. Of 134 types of books seized in the Israeli-occupied west bank territory, only 56 were found acceptable.
Only 39 of 129 from the Gaza Strip were cleared as free of anti-Zionist material. Israeli officials said most of the objectionable material was found in history, geography and Arab literature books.
But officials said in one arithmetic book they found 8-year-olds were given the following problem: "If our defense forces killed three Zionist terrorists and captured another when seven attacked our town, how many were left?" In such a case the entire book has to be reprinted under the Israeli rule.
"We have to reprint even if there is only one sentence we find objectionable," said Ya'acov Sarid, director-general of the Israeli Education Ministry. "If we just crossed it out or snipped it out the children would ask questions." The new textbooks are printed in Arabic and generally the Israelis say they have not changed the Arab curricula.
Israel does, however, intend to introduce Hebrew gradually into Old Jerusalem, the sector of the holy city seized from Jordan. Israeli officials said Hebrew will be introduced in other occupied areas "if the parents request it." The 200,000 Arab children on the west bank of the Jordan River and the 100,000 in the Gaza Strip will receive free schooling.
But in Old Jerusalem, parents will have to pay fees based on size of family and amount of family income.
THE HEADLINE THAT NAMES IT. Three American desks took the same Ed Blanche AP dispatch:
s112_1 'Israel Opens Schools For Arab Children' (kicker: 'Some Books Rewritten')
s104_2 'Israel Revises Slanted Arab Textbooks'
s105_1 'Israelis Censor Arab Textbooks' <- this one
The first headlines the schools opening. The second adds a word the wire never uses — 'Slanted' — and makes the books the guilty party. The third says plainly who is doing what to whom: Israelis, censor, Arab textbooks. Three verbs for one programme: opens, revises, censors.
That is worth putting in front of Maria beside the AP UNESCO set, because it runs the other way. On the UNESCO dispatch, four of six desks sharpened the copy against Palestinians. Here, one desk out of three sharpened it against the occupying authority — and did it in two words, with no editorialising anywhere in the body. Only two clippings in this entire batch use the word 'censorship' or 'censor' in the paper's own voice: this headline, and the three-paragraph UNESCO brief on slide 98 ('a dispute about Israeli censorship of textbooks in schools for Arab refugee children'). Everywhere else the thread runs on the censoring authority's vocabulary — cleared, edited, revised, expurgated, decontaminated, rewritten, book surgery.
And this is the fullest text of the dispatch, with the rule stated outright by the official who made it: a single objectionable sentence means the whole book is reprinted, because a visible cut would make the children ask questions. Is any Palestinian quoted: no. The 7,000 Arab teachers, the 200,000 west bank children and the 100,000 Gaza children are counted and never heard.
JERUSALEM (AP) — Israel reopened Arab schools in the Israeli-held west bank region Monday for the first time since the June Middle East war. But many Arab teachers refused to show up and two educators were arrested. First reports also indicated some Arab parents kept their children home, apparently following an Arab leaflet campaign urging them to resist Israeli authority.
There are 200,000 Arab children and 6,500 teachers in the west bank territory. When the 855 schools were to begin classes, at least 100 of them were without teachers and many that did open had small turnouts by staff and pupils. Some hours before the Arab schools were to reopen, military authorities arrested two senior Arab educators, an Israeli government spokesman said.
They were suspected of inciting Arab teachers not to hold classes, he added. The two were identified as Husni Ashab, a former Jordanian Education Ministry inspector for Jerusalem, Jericho and Bethlehem, and Youssef Jalajil, former ministry inspector for the Ramallah district. Informed Arab sources said two other senior Arab school officials also were arrested.
There was no official confirmation. Israeli sources said if the resistance continued, strong measures likely would be taken against the boycotters. Refusal of Arab teachers to work was in protest at Israeli expurgation of anti-Zionist material in Arab textbooks and the occupation of the area, officials said. Israeli educators cleared only 56 of 114 Arab books.
The rest are being edited and reprinted to omit anti-Zionist passages.
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — second printing of the arrests dispatch, and the headline is the thing.
s109_1 'Many Arab Teachers Boycotting Schools'
s107_1 'Schools Open; Few Arabs Attend' <- this one
Same copy. One desk headlined the teachers' action; the other headlined the attendance figure and made the Palestinians the absent party rather than the acting one. Neither headline mentions the two arrests, which are in the lede of both.
Content as at s109_1: who is censoring — 'Israeli educators', and the word the wire uses in its own voice is 'expurgation'. What was removed — the rest of the 114 books 'are being edited and reprinted to omit anti-Zionist passages'. The teachers' stated reason is given plainly and it is two reasons, not one: 'in protest at Israeli expurgation of anti-Zionist material in Arab textbooks AND the occupation of the area'. Is any Palestinian quoted — no. Husni Ashab and Youssef Jalajil are named, arrested, and never heard from; 'Informed Arab sources' report two further arrests and the paper immediately adds 'There was no official confirmation', a qualifier it attaches to no Israeli claim in the piece.
This is the clipping with a masthead, so it is the one to cite for the date of the reopening and the arrests: Monday 4 September 1967.
JERUSALEM (AP) — Israel reopened Arab schools in the Israeli-held west bank region Monday for the first time since the June Middle East war. But many Arab teachers refused to show up and two educators were arrested. First reports also indicated some Arab parents kept their children home, apparently following an Arab leaflet campaign urging them to resist Israeli authority.
There are 200,000 Arab children and 6,300 teachers in the west bank territory. When the 815 schools were to begin classes, at least 100 of them were without teachers and many that did open had small turnouts by staff and pupils. Some hours before the Arab schools were to reopen, military authorities arrested two senior Arab educators, an Israeli government spokesman said.
They were suspected of inciting Arab teachers not to hold classes, he added. The two were identified as Husni Ashab, a former Jordanian Education Ministry inspector for Jerusalem, Jericho and Bethlehem, and Youssef Jalajil, former ministry inspector for the Ramallah district. Informed Arab sources said two other senior Arab school officials also were arrested.
There was no official confirmation. Israeli sources said if the resistance continued, strong measures likely would be taken against the boycotters. Refusal of Arab teachers to work was in protest at Israeli expurgation of anti-Zionist material in Arab textbooks and the occupation of the area, officials said. Israeli educators cleared only 26 of 114 Arab books.
The rest are being edited and reprinted to omit anti-Zionist passages.
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — the clipping that connects censorship to arrest. Who is censoring: 'Israeli educators'; the word the paper uses is 'expurgation' — 'Israeli expurgation of anti-Zionist material in Arab textbooks'. What was removed: of 114 Arab books only 26 cleared; the remaining 88 'are being edited and reprinted to omit anti-Zionist passages'. Whose voice: the censorship figures are given flatly in the paper's own voice, unattributed ('Israeli educators cleared only 26 of 114 Arab books'); the motive of the teachers is attributed to 'officials'; the threat is attributed to 'Israeli sources'. Is any Palestinian quoted: NO. Palestinians appear here only as actors described by others — teachers who 'refused to show up', parents who 'kept their children home', an 'Arab leaflet campaign', and 'Informed Arab sources' who report two further arrests that the paper then undercuts with 'There was no official confirmation.' The two arrested men are named but not quoted, and nothing in the clipping says what became of them. NOTE for the pattern: this is the single most important item in the textbook thread because it establishes consequence — the other clippings describe a screening process; this one shows men taken into custody over it. It is also the only one that states the Palestinian teachers' own stated reason: protest at the expurgation AND at 'the occupation of the area'.
ON MARIA'S SLIDE-109 NOTE ('a pattern or ig carousel around education/textbook censorship maybe?'): this clipping and its slide-mate are the two strongest in the batch, and they come from opposite ends of the American press — a small AP item and a long Miami Herald–LA Times wire feature — on consecutive days. Together with s112_1, s112_3, s110_2 and s104/105/106/107 they give a thread, not a one-off. See my report for the count.
NABULUS, Israeli-Occupied Jordan (AP)-Every school in this troubled West Bank town remained closed and embittered Arab teachers owed schools would remain shut until Israel "stopped distorting history." They referred to the Israeli cutting of alleged anti-Jewish hate material from Arab textbooks. "They can stay shut a year or ten years," said one teacher.
"But we're not going to give in." The town's 40 schools had been scheduled to open Monday along with the rest of the West Bank. But teachers refused to report for duty and parents to send their children to use the expurgated books. An estimated 40 per cent of the 950 schools, mostly in the area north of the Jordan's West Bank, were still shuttered Tuesday.
But the protest also was political. Leaflets signed by the "West Bank Teachers Union" were distributed here calling on parents to resist "attempts by the occupation forces to impose new systems of education by unfair means." Israeli educators said they had edited 78 of 134 "objectionable" Arab school books. Nabulus teachers said, however, the books were being rewritten.
They claimed the Israeli aim was to "weaken our national feelings and obliterate our religion and Arabic language." "We will resist until death the occupation, the annexation of Jerusalem and the books," said Municipal Councilor Abdul Aziz Setir, father of ten.
He claimed the teachers had received the shutdown orders from Amman "and no teacher will go back to work until Amman says so."
THE MOST IMPORTANT CLIPPING IN THE BATCH, and the one I would put in front of Maria first.
Across roughly twenty clippings on the textbook censorship, Palestinians are counted, arrested, instigated, boycotting, refusing, 'embittered', 'fanatical', punching a pillow — and almost never quoted. Here, in eleven paragraphs of Associated Press copy in a small Pennsylvania daily, they speak six times:
— a teacher: 'They can stay shut a year or ten years. But we're not going to give in.'
— the teachers collectively: Israel must stop 'distorting history'
— the West Bank Teachers Union, from its own leaflet: resist 'attempts by the occupation forces to impose new systems of education by unfair means'
— the Nablus teachers on the purpose of it: to 'weaken our national feelings and obliterate our religion and Arabic language'
— and Abdul Aziz Setir, municipal councillor, father of ten, named: 'We will resist until death the occupation, the annexation of Jerusalem and the books.'
That last sentence is the whole argument of the archive in one line, said by a Palestinian in 1967 and printed in an American newspaper: the schoolbooks are not a separate question from the occupation and the annexation. They are the same thing, and he lists them in one breath.
Also note what this paper does that the others do not. Its headline is 'Occupied Schools Remain Closed' — occupation in the headline, in the paper's own voice. Its dateline is 'NABULUS, Israeli-Occupied Jordan'. It keeps the word 'alleged' in front of 'anti-Jewish hate material'. It reports both counts — the Israeli educators' claim that books were 'edited' and the Nablus teachers' answer that they were being 'rewritten' — and does not adjudicate. And it gives the Palestinian side the last four paragraphs.
PAIR THIS WITH s109_2 (the Los Angeles Times 'decontaminating' feature) AND s110_2 (the Sacramento 'Israeli Censors Purge Hate' piece). Three papers, the same autumn, the same programme: one calls it decontamination, one calls it purging hate, and this one lets the people whose books they are say that it is an attempt to obliterate their religion and their language. None of the three printed the other two's version.
· Corpus Christi Caller Times · Corpus Christi · page 1
Gaza Refugees Cross Border
Israeli Officials Remove Restrictions on Travel
Three months after the war. The headline has the refugees doing something — crossing — and the line beneath supplies who made it possible and what it was before: a restriction on travel, now removed by Israeli officials. Beside it on the page, a photograph of a child in a supermarket aisle.
Miami Herald-Los Angeles Times Wire [the reporter is David Larsen of the Los Angeles Times — named in the Grand Rapids printing of the same dispatch, s104_3; this paper printed no byline]
JERUSALEM, Israel — "There were 14 Israeli soldiers. Six were killed and three were captured. How many got away?" Pupils attending elementary schools in the Gaza Strip this fall will no longer learn their arithmetic in that manner. "I hate Israel and the Jews. The whole Arab people hate Israel. We shall chase out the enemy. The day of victory is near.
It will be a day of rejoicing for all Arabs." The pupils will no longer recite such sentences in their reading classes. "The homeland has been stolen. The Arabs will not rest until their paradise is returned to them. Holy war is a duty." Pupils on the west bank of Jordan will find other phrases in their grammar books.
There are nearly 300,000 school-age children in the areas of Egypt, Jordan and Syria which Israel now controls as a result of the June war. When they start school this month, they will find a new format to their textbooks — no propaganda. It might have been a temptation for the conquering Jews to substitute such phrasing in the readers as "Look, look. See the Arabs run.
Israel wins again." But instead the Israelis have undertaken an intensive and somewhat expensive program of editing the Arab textbooks — of "decontaminating" them, as one education official put it. The decision was not without controversy. For one thing, the teachers, particularly those on the west bank, made noises for a while about not returning to their jobs.
But the Israelis have paid their wages ever since the war, have given assurances that children will be allowed to learn the Koran and will have the holy day of Friday off, and have announced that they will not force the teaching of Hebrew, all of which has alleviated the pain over the book surgery.
The chore of reading through all the textbooks used in the Gaza Strip, along the west bank of the Jordan River, and in Syria's Golan Heights, fell to Israel's inspectors for Arab education. On the west bank they found 56 textbooks acceptable, 78 unacceptable. In the Gaza Strip they found 39 satisfactory, 90 unsatisfactory.
The proportion of the Syrian books was similar to the Egyptian. Israel has budgeted $1.2 million for the reprinting of textbooks. There was no alternative. "We couldn't just snip out a page," said Yaakov Sarid, director-general of the Ministry of Education. "The pupils would notice and ask questions." The new versions are not yet off the presses.
Until they are, the teachers will stick to subjects for which the books have been approved, or else will lecture without texts. And there will be no propaganda in their lectures. "All teaching of the hatred of peoples and the destruction of states must be eliminated," said Yosef Gadish of the Ministry of Education.
"Those teachers who cannot accept this principle will be asked to leave." While Israel is concerned that its young Arab residents be educated, it has made it clear that the teachers have a responsibility also. "If they don't show up, there will be no classes," said a spokesman from the Ministry of Education. "We just don't have enough Israeli teachers to replace them."
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — the longest and most self-aware piece in the batch, and the one whose language is sharpest. Who is censoring: 'Israel's inspectors for Arab education', the Ministry of Education; two officials named, Yaakov Sarid (director-general) and Yosef Gadish. What was removed: west bank, 56 books acceptable and 78 unacceptable; Gaza, 39 satisfactory and 90 unsatisfactory; $1.2 million budgeted for reprinting. Whose voice: this is where it gets interesting. The paper does not merely attribute — it adopts. The headline 'Arabs Learn ABCs With the Hatred Left Out' is the paper's own and treats the censorship as a benign subtraction. 'It might have been a temptation for the conquering Jews to substitute such phrasing in the readers as "Look, look. See the Arabs run. Israel wins again." But instead the Israelis have undertaken an intensive and somewhat expensive program of editing' — that sentence, in the paper's own voice, frames censorship as the restrained alternative to something worse, and invents the worse thing itself. 'Book surgery' and 'the conquering Jews' are the writer's phrases, not quotations. The closing paragraphs go further: 'But he might have added that this war has created an opportunity — an opportunity for Israel to communicate with a future generation of Arabs as it has not been able to do with the present one,' followed by the Prophet Mohammed quoted as the kicker: 'The ink of the scholar is more sacred than the blood of the martyr.' The piece ends by using a Moslem scripture to bless the rewriting of Moslem children's books. Is any Palestinian quoted: NO. Not one, in roughly 1,100 words. The Palestinians present in the piece are the voices IN the confiscated textbooks — 'I hate Israel and the Jews', 'The homeland has been stolen' — reproduced only as specimens of what is being removed. That is the whole finding, and it is a sharp one: the only Palestinian speech the paper prints is speech it is reporting as deleted.
ON MARIA'S SLIDE-109 NOTE: yes, there is a pattern, and this clipping is the spine of it. 'Decontaminating' is the word to lead with.
NABLUS, Jordan, Sept. 19—The merchants of this west-bank city staged a general strike today to coincide with the opening of the General Assembly of the United Nations. A leaflet calling the strike mentioned the opening of the session and urged the Arab residents to demonstrate their opposition to the Israeli annexation of East Jerusalem and occupation of the west bank.
The strike was called for the entire west bank and Jerusalem, but it was fully effective only in Nablus, traditionally a center of Arab nationalism. All the stores here except cafes and groceries remained shuttered. The Israeli military police arrested 10 persons.
BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — A problem of humanity that has gone on nearly 20 years—what to do about the Palestine refugee—is growing in the wake of the Middle East war. It started when the old British-mandated territory of Palestine was partitioned to form a Jewish homeland, now Israel.
It reached a climax in the Arab-Israeli war of 1948, when many Arabs were uprooted from their homes.
… Michelmore’s report to the General Assembly in 1966 had a prophetic paragraph: “As year succeeds year, there is no sign that the refugees are becoming any less embittered by their conviction that a grave injustice has been done to them through the loss of their homes and country and the continued deprivation of any benefit from the property they left behind.
The implications for peace and stability in the Middle East of the continued existence of the Palestine refugee problem thus remain as grave as ever.”
West Bank Proves Israel’s Worst Occupation Headache
By ROBERT GAMZEY (Mr. Gamzey, author and journalist, is a special correspondent for The Courant in Israel).
TEL AVIV —The name of the game is “What to do with the West Bank.” Every Jew fancies himself a political expert and a military strategist, and so answers are freely offered, ranging from “Don’t give up an inch” to “Give it back—except—.” “Except” means Jerusalem and strategic border adjustments.
It’s no more than a game, apparently, because King Hussein of Jordan shows no inclination to negotiate with Israel for the return of the West Bank of his amputated kingdom. The same reluctance to face the Israelis at the conference table is reflected in Cairo and Damascus.
An Arab self-delusion, refusing to face up to the reality of their joint military disaster, forestalls peace talks with Israel, the victors have no alternative but to talk of possible solutions while preparing for an indeterminate period of occupying conquered territory in West Jordan, Syria and Sinai.
The West Bank of Jordan is the worst occupation headache for Israel, if long-range prospects are considered. More and more, Israelis are openly talking and writing about the demographic danger of being outnumbered by Palestinian Arabs, whose birthrate is far higher than Israel’s, should Israel eventually annex the West Bank.
The alternative to annexation which means granting equal voting rights in a democratic country is a repugnant prospect of suppressing the national and individual aspirations of more than a half million Palestinian Arabs in some sort of “buffer canton.”
TEL AVIV (AP) — Israeli troops, aided by helicopters, fought a running gun battle with suspected El Fatah terrorists in the mountains near the troubled west bank town of Nablus Sunday, the army here said. Thirteen Arab terrorists were captured, 11 of them wounded, an army spokesman said.
A small arsenal of weapons, including Soviet automatic arms, Czech mines and Syrian hand grenades were seized, he added. It was the second gunfight around Nablus, suspected of being the El Fatah base in the Israeli-occupied west bank, in two days. Saturday night, border police killed one of a gang of terrorists which ambushed them. Another was captured.
There were no Israeli casualties in Sunday’s fight. Scores of terrorists and saboteurs have been rounded up in the occupied west bank in the last two weeks, during which Arab terrorism has been intensified.
Military authorities clamped down Friday on Nablus, where merchants are suspected of financing and supplying El Fatah squads known to be hiding in the hills around the town.
TEL AVIV (℗)—Israeli troops, aided by helicopters, fought a running gun battle with suspected El Fatah terrorists in the mountains near the troubled west bank town of Nablus Sunday, the army here said. Thirteen Arab terrorists were captured, 11 of them wounded, an Army spokesman said.
A small arsenal of weapons, including Soviet automatic arms, Czech mines and Syrian hand grenades were seized, he added. It was the second gunfight around Nablus, suspected of being the El Fatah base in the Israeli-occupied west bank, in two days. Saturday night, border police killed one of a gang of terrorists which ambushed them. Another was captured.
No Israeli Casualties There were no Israeli casualties in Sunday’s fight. In Nablus itself, the army said, two Arabs were arrested in possession of a submachine gun. Israeli security patrols are scouring the west bank hills flushing out El Fatah squads, believed to be infiltrating across the Jordan River frontier.
Scores of terrorists and saboteurs have been rounded up in the occupied west bank in the last two weeks, during which Arab terrorism has been intensified. Arabs Gunned Down Military authorities clamped down Friday on Nablus, where merchants are suspected of financing and supplying El Fatah squads known to be hiding in the hills around the town.
Two Arab police sergeants were gunned down in a street cafe last Wednesday by terrorists.
JERUSALEM — There is violent controversy at the uppermost levels of Israeli administration over the explosive problem of Arab refugees. Everyone agrees that the problem can and must be solved.
Moreover, the six-day war between Israel and the Arab nations last June provided a unique opportunity for unilateral solution, presenting the Arab world with accomplished facts rather than hollow-sounding propaganda barrages.
The Israelis have under their immediate control two-thirds of the one million refugees whose enforced stagnation in squalid camps for the last 19 years was exploited for festering hostility in the Middle East.
If the refugees are resettled and compensated for lost property, Israel not only will remove the prime source of Arab hostility and resentment, but also deprive fanatical Arab nationalists of their principal recruiting ground for saboteurs, spies and subversives.
But while everyone in the government agrees that the problem must be tackled without delay, a dispute among three opposing factions threatens to upset the refugee boat before it is launched. The final shots of the war had not yet been fired when Premier Levi Eshkol appointed the Inter-Ministerial Committee on Refugees headed by Dr.
Raanan Weitz, Israel’s top resettlement expert. It was then pointed out to the premier that no blueprint would work without a sound economic foundation. Eshkol appointed a second commission on refugees headed by Aryeh Eliav, a prominent agricultural planning and economic integration specialist.
On top of these two bodies, the foreign ministry has a committee dealing with the Arab refugees from the political, psychological and propaganda aspects, their impact on world public opinion, and the like. The first report of the Weitz committee has just been published, and answering shots are being fired from all sides.
“Six more public elementary schools in the former Jordanian sector of Jerusalem were quietly opened this week by the Israeli education authorities. This brought to 22 the number now holding classes. Before the Arab-Israeli fighting in June there were 26 elementary schools and two high schools.”
Four months after the occupation began. Twenty-two of twenty-eight, and the teachers on the West Bank are refusing to meet their classes. The schools are the first move and the universities are the long one — Birzeit closes in 1981 and this archive follows it to 1990.
“Israel’s conquest of the Golan heights has added a dividend to this country’s precious water supplies, and Israeli engineers have begun collecting it… the water may be sweet enough so that as much as 320 million cubic feet may be obtained, adding almost a third to the total supply.”
Seth S. King, datelined Gadot. The headline says conquest without flinching and then files it under resources. A third of a country’s water, counted as a dividend, four months after the territory it sits under changed hands.
Jews Say Negro, White Extremists Spread Arab Propaganda In America
New York Times News Service
Houston, Tex. — The Anti-Defamation League of B’nai B’rith yesterday accused two groups, one anti-white and the other anti-Negro, of disseminating Arab-sponsored, “gutter level propaganda” in this country against Jews and Israel. Benjamin R.
Epstein, national director of the league, who made public the study, named the Student Nonviolent Coordinating committee (SNCC) and the National States Rights party (NSRP) as the groups in question. He described SNCC as a “black racist and leftwing revolutionary organization” and its “polar opposite, NSRP,” as “neo-Nazi, white racist.”
The league study declared that the two groups circulate propaganda materials produced by the Palestine Liberation organization and the Palestine Arab delegation. The Arab groups, the league said, are registered with the United States government as agents for foreign powers.
The report highlighted the closing session here of the three-day meeting of the national executive committee of the league, which is devoted to safeguarding the civil and religious rights of Jews throughout the world. The league also plays a role in the civil rights movement.
Epstein charged that the SNCC newsletter and the states rights party’s “Thunderbolt” publication showed almost “word-for-word dependence” on Arab propaganda material against Jews, zionism and the state of Israel.
The league study described the Palestine Liberation organization as a “notorious and extremist Arab propaganda apparatus, masterminded by Ahmed Shukairy, a long-time Arab spokesman who has engaged in anti-Jewish tirades on the floor of the United Nations and elsewhere.”
Four months after June 1967, and the frame does a new thing: it brackets the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee with a neo-Nazi party by way of what they both allegedly read. The link asserted is not a shared politics — the report goes out of its way to call them polar opposites — but a shared source. The charge is word-for-word dependence, which is a charge about where a sentence came from rather than whether it is true.
SNCC and White Racists Use Arab Propaganda Sources, ADL Charges
Jewish Telegraphic Agency
HOUSTON, Tex. — (JTA) — Benjamin R.
Epstein, national director of the Anti-Defamation League of B’nai B’rith, said here that virulent anti-Israel and anti-Jewish propaganda put out by the Palestine Liberation Organization and the Palestine Arab Delegation is disseminated in the USA by two racist organizations, the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC) and the white supremacist National States Rights Party.
Speaking before the ADL’s national executive committee, Mr. Epstein displayed copies of the SNCC’s newsletter and the states rights party organ, “Thunderbolt,” which showed the same “word-for-word” dependence on Arab propaganda material against Jews, Zionism and Israel, although the white and Negro groups are “polar opposites.”
Mr. Epstein said that the SNCC newsletter “parroted whole sections of a 1966 Palestine Liberation Organization diatribe produced in Lebanon” while the “Thunderbolt” reproduced whole paragraphs from a Palestine Arab Delegation polemic issued last July 14. Both Arab organizations are registered with the U.S.
Government as agents for foreign powers under regulations of the Foreign Agents Registration Act.
The same announcement four days later from a different news agency, and the headline puts SNCC first. Under the last paragraph the column is closed out with a filler line: America — half-brother of the world. —Bailey.
NEW YORK — UN diplomats believe there may be a glimmer of hope in one of the saddest human tragedies of our times: the Palestine refugee problem. Paradoxically, the element of hope springs in part from the June war which, for the short run, has made the problem vastly worse, adding 239,000 new refugees and uprooting once again 116,000 victims of the 1948 war.
THE VERY DESPERATION of these new refugees — the fact they face winter’s rigors in flimsy tents or less, with little but rags on their backs, few blankets and near-starvation rations — has jolted governments which have kept the problem frozen for nearly 20 years. If there is no solution, thousands of people could die.
Benyamina, Israel. The census completed by the Israeli authorities at the beginning of October shows that the population of the occupied lands is just over 1,000,000, of whom 300,000 are of school age. Whatever the ultimate outcome, at the moment Israel is responsible for the education of these Arab children, and this poses several problems.
First there is the fact that both in Jordan and Egypt compulsory education is on paper only. Not only the Beduin (so numerous in Jordon and even on the West Bank) but also many children from the rural areas never go to school, or do so belatedly, and nobody cares.
Statistics show that on the West Bank last year (before Israel occupied it), only 24 per cent of the 6-year-olds went to school. The Beduin in Israel are tending more and more to settle, but in Jordan they are still purely nomadic, which makes schooling impossible.
The whole of Palestine in Mandatory Times had one Beduin school; now the Israeli Beduin have fifteen elementary schools, free, of course. The teachers are mainly from Northern Israel. In Syria there is no compulsory education; but the population on the Golan Height (occupied by Israel) is mainly Druze, friendly to Israel and eager to have schooling for their children.
In Israel there has always been compulsory free education for Arabs and Jews alike. The second problem is the teachers. On the West Bank and in Eastern Jerusalem only a minority have reported back for work at the beginning of the school year. It seems that this is due to instigation from Amman, by radio.
Still, where the children have come in, teachers have been found from the Israel side, and slowly, in Eastern Jerusalem, in the Gaza Strip, on the West Bank and at long last even in Nablus, a hotbed of resistance, a good many schools have opened. Attendance varies, from 50 per cent to 90, but it is constantly growing. The third problem is that of the schoolbooks.
Except for the French and English textbooks which are printed abroad, nearly all schoolbooks are geared to an education in hatred unparalleled anywhere, including Nazi Germany.
The history books teach, for example, that "It is difficult to know how the Hebrews came to Palestine and settled there," and "Israel is a cancer in the eye, a bone in the throat," and "The Arabs in 1948 attacked the Jews and killed off those in the kibbutzim and in Galilee, until these places were clean of them." The grammar and mathematical exercise books for elementary schools contain such things as "The Jewish enemy is a trickster and a traitor" and "The Jews are wicked criminals." The foregoing examples are taken from a brochure issued by the Israel Information Office of the Education Ministry, which reprints the Arab text in full, translating into English only certain gems.
It gives chapter and verse for every item. A sidelight is the information that these same textbooks are also in use, or were until now, in UNRWA schools. These books were taken out of circulation in the schools of the occupied areas and replaced by hastily printed copies of the textbooks in use in Israeli Arab schools. Some teachers protested volubly.
Despite these difficulties a majority of the elementary schools and a good many high schools have been opened.
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — and the clearest case in the batch of the American press printing a government handout as reporting, with the admission sitting right there in the text. The writer lays out the textbook quotations — 'Israel is a cancer in the eye, a bone in the throat', 'The Jewish enemy is a trickster and a traitor' — and then says where they came from: 'a brochure issued by the Israel Information Office of the Education Ministry, which reprints the Arab text in full, translating into English only certain gems.' The word 'gems' is the writer's. She notices that the Ministry translated selectively, prints the selection anyway, and draws from it the sentence 'nearly all schoolbooks are geared to an education in hatred unparalleled anywhere, including Nazi Germany.' That comparison is the sharpest language anywhere in the batch, and it is not a quotation — it is the writer's own, unattributed, in a signed piece.
Who is censoring: the Israeli Education Ministry; books 'taken out of circulation in the schools of the occupied areas and replaced by hastily printed copies of the textbooks in use in Israeli Arab schools.' Is any Palestinian quoted: no. Palestinian teachers appear in six words — 'Some teachers protested volubly' — and the protest is given no content. Nablus is 'a hotbed of resistance'. The non-attendance of teachers is explained away as 'instigation from Amman, by radio', never as a decision the teachers made.
VOCABULARY for the 1967-69 tally: 'the occupied lands', 'the occupied areas', 'before Israel occupied it', 'the Golan Height (occupied by Israel)', 'Arab children', 'the Beduin', 'Israeli Arab schools'. The writer uses 'occupied' plainly and repeatedly, with no hedge — which is worth noting precisely because the piece is otherwise entirely sympathetic to the occupying authority.
Israel Resumes Admission of Some Arabs to the West Bank
By TERENCE SMITH
JERICHO, Israeli-occupied Jordan, Nov. 27—Israel readmitted a handful of prosperous Arabs to the west bank today as she inaugurated a new program for the reunion of families divided by the six-day war of June. Seven persons crossed the Allenby Bridge to the west bank area, while the usual daily flow of about 200 departing Arabs crossed in the opposite direction.
The eastbound traffic consists of impoverished refugees, mostly from the Gaza Strip. Barefoot, dressed in rags and clutching bundles of clothing and blankets, they provided a sharp contrast to the well-dressed Arabs returning to the west bank.
Under the new program for the reunion of divided families, Arabs in the occupied west band who have relatives on the east bank may apply to the Israeli authorities for permission to reunite their families.
Israel submits the applications to a rigid security check and weeds out men of military age, Palestinian refugees of 1948 and any residents the former Jordanian part of Jerusalem. About 300 applications have been received since the program was announced six weeks ago.
The Israeli authorities have approved 30 applications for return today, and neither they nor the Jordanian officials at the bridge could explain why only seven persons had appeared.
Those who did cross arrived at the bridge in taxis shortly after the appointed hour, 11 A.M. the first woman across the bridge was followed by porters carrying two pieces of matched plain luggage and 15 cardboard cartons. The cartons contained, among other things, 144 bars of soap, all but 12 of which were held by Israeli customs officials pending the payment of duties.
The other returning Arabs were well dressed and seemed comfortably off. They barely glanced at the shabby refugees crossing in the opposite direction. The eastbound refugees are required to sign forms in which they state that they are leaving of their own free will and that they will not return to the west bank without the express permission of the Israeli Government.
One Arab father with his veiled wife and four children said that his reasons for leaving were principally economic. “There is nothing for me in Gaza any more,” he said. “I can’t find any work and the prices are going up every day. Even if I work on the roads, the Israelis only pay me £5 ($1.45) for a day.
If I go across, I will have a better chance. If not in Amman, then perhaps in Kuwait or Jidda.”
Nasser Hero of Lebanese Truce, But That Isn't the Whole Story
BY HENRY J. TAYLOR
When Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser gets his name in the world's papers on the side of peace, this will do for openers, as old-time poker players say. Yet this wily coercer stands as the hero in cooling the caldron in the so-called Lebanon dispute. The causes of the crisis are a fascinating lesson in the Middle East situation, in which we have such a stake.
And the probable results of Nasser's intervention are something like the man who fell off the top of the Empire State Building and said to a first-floor resident as he passed him, "so far so good." Israel was founded on April 15, 1948. This U. S.-supported act alone made 100 million Arabs pale with fury.
Throughout all history the Jews have always been outnumbered, and the continuing Middle East war still comes down to 11 million Arabs against 3 million Jews. AL FATAH LEADERS Lebanon is in the forefront of the armed attacks against Israel — but not officially. The task is chiefly in the hands of the Palestine commandos or fedayeen.
The main commando organization, Al Fatah, is led by fanatical Yasir Arafat, a Cairo-educated Palestine Arab, with whom Nasser made his deal which is now in the news. The second leader is former diplomat Ahem Shukairy, who has represented Syria and Saudi Arabia. The third chief is George Habache, a Palestinian who became a doctor in Lebanon.
If all this news mystifies us it is probably because we fail to distinguish the Palestine Arabs from the other Arabs in the Arab world. Accordingly, who are the Palestine Arabs?
As a booty of World War I Britain seized Palestine under the Balfour Declaration, obtained a League of Nations mandate, and set up shop to enhance Britain's commercial and strategic interests — thereby violating every pledge Britain had given the Arabs in order to gain their help against the Turks in World War I.
It was then that the true influx of European Jews and the eviction of the Palestine Arabs began. In this development, and with the founding of Israel, the Palestine Arab evictees now total about 2½ million, many more than generally supposed.
In the 1948 Palestine war Israel took about 3,000 square miles more territory than the United Nations resolution of November 29, 1947, gave her. About a million of today's evicted Arab refugees date from that time — 21 years ago.
The largest number of Palestine Arabs, living mostly in refugee camps, are in the former territories of Jordan, the Gaza Strip and the west bank of the Jordan River and in what remains of Jordan itself. But there are also large and violently resentful groups in Lebanon, Syria and throughout the oil sheikdoms of the Persian Gulf.
NO POLITICAL LIFE Throughout all these years these fragmented people have had no political life. Fanatical Yasir Arafat and his Al Fatah commandos are mainly a political instrument dedicated to uniting the far-flung Palestine Arabs.
Arafat himself once summarized the Al Fatah objective to me: "The Palestine Arabs," he said, "can be mobilized only around the issue of fighting." He sounded like he'd been taking a course in "How To Talk Like James Cagney Telling The Mob What's What."
AN OP-ED COLUMN, not reporting — and the sharpest language in the batch sits here, in both directions at once, which is what makes it worth showing. Taylor writes that Britain 'seized Palestine', that the mandate 'violat[ed] every pledge Britain had given the Arabs', and that with the Balfour Declaration 'the eviction of the Palestine Arabs began'. He puts the 1948 refugee figure at about a million and the total of 'Palestine Arab evictees' at 2½ million, 'many more than generally supposed', and he notes that Israel took about 3,000 square miles more than the 1947 partition resolution allotted. For a syndicated American conservative columnist in 1969 that is a remarkably unhedged account of dispossession — the word he uses is 'eviction', four times, in his own voice.
And in the same column: Arafat is 'fanatical' twice in four paragraphs, Palestinians are 'violently resentful groups', 'these fragmented people' who 'have had no political life', and Arafat's one quoted sentence is answered with a James Cagney gangster joke. The column grants the history and denies the politics. The dispossession is real; the people dispossessed are a mob with a spokesman.
TERMINOLOGY — useful for the vocabulary question. Taylor uses 'the Palestine Arabs' as his standing term and asks the question outright: 'who are the Palestine Arabs?' But he also writes 'George Habache, a Palestinian' — so 'Palestinian' as a noun for a person appears in the same column that otherwise insists on 'Palestine Arabs'. The two words are doing different work on the same page.
The South African Negro is a man of an utterly different race and level of civilization than the white... Apartheid is such an attempt. It is a separation of the races in order to solve various ethnic problems...
One of the most intelligent and just appreciations of apartheid is found in the works of a Zionist author, Paul Giniewski, who emphasizes that Zionism is basically an application of the same principle of pure ethnic separation, as regards the relationship between the Israelis and the Arabs.
This, Israel has in common with South Africa: because of her policy, she, too, has to justify herself in the eyes of the world.
The Israel-apartheid comparison drawn in 1967 BY A DEFENDER OF APARTHEID, approvingly, citing a Zionist author making the same comparison. The single most striking document in the archive.
JERUSALEM, Israel — Tanks rumbled through the streets of Jerusalem one night last week. This time, though, there were no accompanying artillery bursts, no squads of soldiers taking up positions in doorways, no strident calls on portable loudspeakers for surrender.
The only real interest in the rumbling armament came from a knot of men, some in uniform and with stop watches in hand, checking the time the tanks took to travel from one corner to the next. They were preparing for Israel’s Independence Day parade on May 2, and the fact that the men with the stop watches were working five months in advance of the event surprised few.
A nation that can defeat three Arab armies in six days apparently knows something about the need for careful planning. The parade, the biggest in the country’s history, will be the highlight of Israel’s 20th-anniversary celebration. Israel is preparing a year-long birthday party for herself.
It began early last month with the celebration of the 50th anniversary of the Balfour Declaration, Britain’s pledge to help establish a Jewish national home in Palestine, and will last through most of next year. Many of the celebrations have been planned with the tourist in mind and this, in turn, has created a few problems.
But they are the kind of problems to gladden any Tourism Minister’s heart, because the tourists were already on their way. Israel’s 20th year comes right after a victorious war that has channeled much of the traditional Holy Land traffic through the nation’s sea and air ports.
OLD JERUSALEM—This view, from slope of Mount of Olives, looks over Valley of Kidron, wooded area in foreground, to wall of the Old City. Beyond the wall is area known as Temple Mount and, above it, at extreme right, is the Dome of the Rock, a sacred Moslem site.
Beyond that, to the upper left, rises the smaller dome of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, which contains last of the Stations of the Cross.
TEL AVIV (AP) — Israeli Premier Levi Eshkol left for the United States today to ask President Johnson for U.S. arms to offset the “tremendous Soviet arms supplies to countries in the region.”
Eshkol, accompanied by his wife, Miriam, and several aides, planned a two-week tour to United Nations headquarters in New York, the LBJ Ranch in Texas, Canada and London… In a brief airport statement Eshkol said after Israel’s victory over the Arabs in the six-day June war, “There has been opened before us the prospect of security and peace, but at the same time we are possibly faced by new dangers…” In Beirut, meanwhile, the new head of the Palestine Liberation Organization, Yahya Hammouda, was quoted as saying there was nothing to prevent Arabs from sharing a common future with Jews “who have given up Zionism and racism.”
The earliest pairing of those two words in this archive, and it is the last sentence of a story about an arms request. Seven years and ten months before the General Assembly voted. This printing stops there. The Telegram and Gazette, running the same dispatch the same day, carries the rest of the interview, in which Hammouda offers to share the country.
TEL AVIV (AP) — Israeli Premier Levi Eshkol left for the United States today to ask President Johnson for U.S. arms to offset the “tremendous Soviet arms supplies to countries in the region”… In Beirut, meanwhile, the new head of the Palestine Liberation Organization, Yahya Hammouda, was quoted as saying there was nothing to prevent Arabs from sharing a common future with Jews “who have given up Zionism and racism.” “We must face facts and not ask for the impossible,” Hammouda said in an interview with the newspaper Al Nahar.
“It is stupid for us to ask the Israelis to return to their countries of origin.” “We ask the Jews—all the Jews, even those who came to Palestine after 1948—do you really want peace and coexistence?
Then git rid of zionism as a political and racist ideology and agree to live with the Arabs in an Arab-Jewish Palestinian state where each can have his share,” Al Nahar quoted him as saying. It was the first time Hammouda had aired his views on the Arab-Israeli crisis since he replaced the firebrand Ahmed Shukairy as head of PLO last month.
Hammouda was interviewed in Aamman, Jordan. If the Israelis refuse to give up Zionist principles, Hammouda said, then Palestinian Arabs should be allowed to return to parts of Palestine they inhabited before 1948, when Israel was created from that territory. “Otherwise it will be a constant struggle. The battle will be very harsh and long.
We may lose it, but the Israelis will not win it.”
The same wire story the News ran that morning, with five more paragraphs on the end. Here the phrase arrives attached to what it was attached to: an offer of one state shared by both peoples, an explicit refusal to demand that Israelis leave, and a warning. One American paper printed the accusation. This one printed the proposal. The paper’s own spellings, git and Aamman, and its lower-case zionism, are kept.
“United Nations, N.Y. The American Indian is getting genuine if lopsided support these days from some very unexpected quarters with definitely dubious motives. Old cowboys-and-Indians movies serve as evidence of America’s ‘genocide’ against the original inhabitants here.
The argument is made that the racial situation in Alabama, Mississippi, Georgia and Arkansas ‘is not dissimilar from that in southern Africa in regard to discrimination against blacks.’ All this is taking place in the U.N.
Commission on Human Rights currently meeting here… The Convention on Genocide is a carefully worded legal document which defines genocide as a deliberate attempt to eliminate a nation, or a substantial part of it.
In other words — a mass murder or devastation of a people, perhaps something on the scale Hitler did to the Jews, or the Chinese Communists are in the process of doing to the people of Tibet… Thus, Egypt said Australians committed genocide by driving the aboriginals out of their land. The U.S. did the same to Red Indians.
The Israelis copied the Nazis in Palestine against the Arabs. Colonialism is ‘slow genocide,’ Nasser’s delegate stated… The U.S. delegate, Morris B. Abram, said these charges were ‘full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.’”
News copy, and the accusation is attributed rather than made, with the American answer printed in the last line. Notable because it places Palestine inside the anticolonial argument about the word, twenty years after the Convention.
Israelis Jail Arab Student For Harboring Subversive
TEL AVIV, March 12—An Arab student leader at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem was jailed today for nine months for harboring a subversive. He is Khalil Toame, secretary of the Arab Students Committee on the campus. Mr. Toame, in his fourth year at the faculty of law, has been prominent in left-wing student circles. Mr.
Toame acknowledged before a military court that he had sheltered Ahmad Khalifa, in his Jerusalem apartment but pleaded he had been unaware that the organization was illegal. Mr. Khalifa has been sentenced to two years’ imprisonment for activities endangering the security of Israel.
‘It may take us 100 years … we will liberate Palestine’
Associated Press
AMMAN, Jordan (AP) — An Arab guerrilla in a camouflage uniform scratched at the rubble of a wrecked army depot Friday, then raised his head. His look was sullen and vengeful. “It may take us 100 years,” he said, “but we will liberate Palestine.”
The charred ruins at Shuneh, two miles from the Jordan River frontier with Israel, were typical of others, blackened and desolate, along the route of Thursday’s 15-hour Israeli air, tank, and ground assault. Rocket casings, some bearing the U.S. handclasp of friendship, littered the roads where jets had strafed.
Many were marked “Saudi Arabia” — presumably American aid passed on to Egypt and captured by the Israelis in last June’s Middle East war… Karameh, the refugee camp three miles east of the Jordan that the Israelis said was the El Fatah command post, was a dust bowl of demolished huts.
Dynamite charges had blown apart a movie theater and mixed with the rubble were strips of torn film… Western newsmen who watched them were accosted by armed civilians, describing themselves as local defense volunteers. They clicked the bolts of their rifles and were calmed only after the newsmen’s cameras were surrendered.
Out of 42 Israeli tanks and halftracks reported destroyed by the Jordanians, the newsmen saw only two Korean War-vintage Centurion tanks knocked out at Shuneh… Israel claimed it had killed 150 El Fatah guerrillas, but a spokesman for it and two other guerrilla organizations said their losses were “very little” compared to the Israelis, who acknowledged the loss of 30 men.
A Palestinian’s sentence given the whole headline in a Michigan daily in 1968, four years after the PLO was founded and nineteen before the first intifada. The rest of the column is a reporter checking numbers against what he can see with his own eyes. The Jordanians reported 42 Israeli tanks destroyed; the newsmen counted two. Israel claimed 150 guerrillas killed; the guerrillas said their losses were very little. And the cameras did not survive the trip — armed men worked the bolts of their rifles and were calmed only when the newsmen handed the cameras over.
Attack by Israelis Failed to Destroy Base at Karameh or Wipe Out Commandos
By Thomas F. Brady
KARAMEH, Jordan, March 22—If the Israelis’ purpose in yesterday’s attacks across the Jordan River was to wipe out Palestine guerrilla commandos and their bases, it failed.
Karameh Camp was swarming today with men carrying Soviet-made machine guns and grenades and voicing pride over the fight they put up yesterday. [The fighting was hailed in many Arab countries as an Arab victory.] But the men here do not like visitors, and they would not talk to foreigners.
Some of them talked with Jordanians, who sometimes relayed the information to foreign reporters.
Israeli Tells U.N. Raiders Uncovered Big Terrorist Base
By Drew Middleton
UNITED NATIONS, N. Y., Saturday, March 23—Israel told the Security Council yesterday that Thursday’s raid into Jordan had uncovered a huge terrorist base at Karameh, serving about 1,000 men.
The base was stocked with large quantities of arms and ammunition, Ambassador Yosef Tekoah reported, and was the headquarters of the Iraqi command of Al Fatah, a guerrilla organization, and of the Palestine Liberation Organization.
Some of the prisoners were trained in Egypt, the Ambassador continued, and it is known that some of the Fatah commanders received their military training in Communist China. Mr. Tekoah offered a detailed report of the Israeli findings as justification for the Israeli attack on the second day of an increasingly acid debate in the 15-member Council.
The meeting was called by Jordan as a result of Israel’s attack Thursday. Muhammad el-Farra, Jordan’s representative, maintained that the Israeli raid was an invasion of Jordanian villages in which the Israelis “looted and destroyed, plundered and murdered at will.”
Resolution Says Attack on Karameh Was ‘Flagrant Violation’ of U.N. Charter
By Drew Middleton
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y., March 24—The Security Council adopted unanimously tonight a resolution condemning Israel’s recent reprisal raid into Jordan and deploring all violence by Arabs or Israelis in violation of the Middle East cease-fire.
The resolution warned that military reprisals “cannot be tolerated” and declared that the Council would have to consider economic sanctions and military measures as envisioned in the United Nations Charter to prevent a repetition of the Israeli operation Thursday against the guerrilla camp at Karameh in Jordan.
Yosef Tekoah of Israel told the Council that his country retained the “right and duty” to take “all necessary measures” in self-defense against Arab raids, terrorism or sabotage. He replied to passages in speeches by Algerian and Iraqi spokesmen supporting guerrilla warfare against Israel and, to some extent, to the wording of the resolution itself.
Jordan’s representative, Muhammad H. el-Farra, recalled to the Council its seven previous warnings to Israel against “aggression” and “expansionism.” The present resolution, he said, should be the final warning to Israel. He said he hoped that the Charter would be invoked to prevent any further aggression.
Ousmane Socé Diop of Senegal, this month’s President of the Council, presented the draft of the resolution to the Council when it assembled at 6:30 P.M. The Council then adopted the resolution, voting by show of hands.
The resolution represented a compromise between the bitterly anti-Israeli original draft, circulated last night by India, Pakistan and Senegal, and the demand of Arthur J. Goldberg of the United States, Lord Caradon of Britain and other Western members for a resolution that would also censure, if only by implication, Arab guerrillas.
Ambassador Goldberg, in a series of meetings with the sponsors of the original resolution and the Arab delegations, argued vehemently and, in the end, successfully for the inclusion of a clause censuring all violence in the area. As a result, the resolution included the statement that the Council “deplores all violent incidents in violation of the ceasefire.”
77,000 Refugees Reported to Have Abandoned Camps —Farmers Leave Fields
By Thomas F. Brady
AMMAN, Jordan, March 24—The eastern side of the Jordan Valley, across the river from Israeli guns and patrols, is becoming a no man’s land. A wave of departures has followed strikes aimed, according to Israeli statements, against the fedayeen, or commandos, resisting Israeli occupation of the west bank.
According to figures of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, 77,000 Arabs have left the valley to move east toward Amman since Feb. 15, when Israeli pilots bombed areas and camps where they thought the fedayeen were based.
Now, in the wake of the Israeli ground attack last Thursday, even farmers and villagers who have lived in the valley and tilled the soil there for years are moving eastward. Tractors pulling trailers filled with household goods have been crawling up the roads out of the valley for three days, since Israeli tanks and paratroops crossed the river.
Jordanian officials hope the farmers will go back by day to till their fields and gather the harvest, but no one expects them to go on living in the valley. From the Dead Sea north to the great archeological site of Deir Alla, the valley is almost empty. North of Deir Alla, villages are already down to half their population.
Fedayeen — literally “those who sacrifice themselves” — are in the old refugee camp at Karameh, armed and hardly amiable men to the Jordanian authorities. But in eight other valley camps, where there were 77,000 Arab refugees Feb. 15, there are now fewer than 100, according to the United Nations figures.
The dusty ghost camps visible from the road are scarred by war and almost lifeless. Meanwhile, camps on the Jordan plateau teem with new inhabitants. The camp population to the east has jumped since Feb. 15 from 71,000 to 161,000, a total that includes Arabs displaced by the June war with Israel as well as refugees from the 1948 displacement when Israel was established.
Six new refugee camps, with a population of 63,000, have been organized by the United Nations agency on the plateau since Feb. 15, and four old plateau camps have grown by 27,000 people.
BEIRUT, Lebanon, March 27 (Reuters) — Al Fatah, the Arab guerrilla group, announced tonight that it had decided to rebuild Karameh, in Jordan, “to be the first defense town in a plan to establish defensive fighting towns and villages.” Karameh was badly damaged last week in an attack by the Israelis.
More Arab-Israeli Fighting Likely; Palestinians Contest Hussein Power
JERICHO (UPI)—Less than a year after 1967’s six-day war, Israelis in the kibbutzim (settlements) along the Jordan are spending as much time in their shelters as did their countrymen along the old Syrian frontier before last June. Some of them find it safer to go armed.
With a million Arabs within Israel’s present frontiers, many Jewish settlements may eventually find themselves as hard put to defend themselves against marauders as they did before 1948. This is some of what is happening since the Israeli attack of March 21 on the guerrilla operational base at Karameh on the east bank of the Jordan river.
The attack may slow down infiltration for a shorter or longer period. But more important it has had two side effects: it has brought home to Israelis that they face guerrilla war, and it has brought to a head the struggle for power in Jordan between King Hussein and the Palestinians.
Casualties Small The present casualties from infiltrators are not heavy—roughly not much worse than road accident casualty figures, and so far the population of the occupied territories is not cooperating with the guerrillas. But Israel is not prepared to accept infiltration as one of the hazards of modern life, as she feels some of her critics would like her to do.
One of the reasons why the number of soldiers killed in the Karameh raid—28—was regarded as high by the public was that the losses came so soon after a war Israelis expected would make life safer for them.
Before the March 21 raid it was estimated Israel captured about 80 per cent of the guerrillas crossing from Jordan, and since the six-day war about 500 El Fatah men have been killed in skirmishes. More than 1,500 guerrillas are in Israeli jails.
However, the 2,000 members of various organizations now in Jordan vastly outnumber the hundred or so guerrillas operating before last June. Not Negligible The arms, sabotage devices and explosives captured at Karameh were so much in excess of expectations that Israel no longer regards the guerrillas as a negligible force.
An Israeli Decision Reported, Allowing Jews to Remain
By JAMES FERON
HEBRON, Israeli-occupied Jordan, May 15 — The Israeli Government is reported to have decided to accept the presence of a group of Jewish settlers who have been living for a month in this occupied town on the west bank of the Jordan River.
The settlers, a group of about 80 ultra-Orthodox Jews, moved into the Park Hotel on the northern outskirts of Hebron last month ostensibly to celebrate the Passover holiday but then announced that they had come to stay.
They said that Hebron, which is holy to both Jews and Moslems, had been a Jewish city a thousand years ago and that its capture in the June war last year was part of the redemption of the land of Israel. Their presence created a split in the Cabinet. Ministers who favor retention of the occupied West-Bank area of Jordan applauded the move.
Others regretted it as an obstacle to peace talks. The Government was forced to decide whether to order the removal of the settlers or accept their presence and, by doing so, extend Israeli protection to them.
Reliable sources said tonight that the decision had been made in the form of an authorization to the Israeli military governor in Hebron to “attend to the defense and housing needs” of the settlers.
It is likely to infuriate Arab leaders, who have been pleading with the Israeli authorities for weeks to remove the settlers before their presence touched off incidents.
The Mayor, Sheik Mohammed Ali Jaabari, said earlier today in an interview that took place before the Israeli decision was known that the Israelis should not be allowed to settle in Hebron before the status of the west bank was decided. He said that the people of Hebron did not want Jews settling there.
Hebron was the site of a massacre of several dozen Jews in 1929 and nearby Kfar Etzion, one of four Israeli settlements, was the scene of a similar massacre in the 1948 war between Israel and the Arabs.
The Hebron settlement, which will expand considerably in the fall if its leaders’ plans are fulfilled, would represent the first purely civilian Israeli settlement in the occupied areas. It would also represent the first Jewish settlement in an Arab urban center.
There are 50,000 Arabs in this town, the vast majority Moslem, and no Jews except for the Park Hotel group and the occupation soldiers. Israel has established about 10 nahal, or paramilitary border settlements in the occupied areas, mostly in the Golan heights, captured from Syria. One of the most controversial cases was the return of settlers to the Etzion area.
Although technically a nahal, the new Etzion settlement is occupied by religious Israelis some of whom share the background and training of the Park Hotel group. Eliezer Waldmann, spokesman for the new Hebron settlers, said today that “God has shown us the way to redeem the Jewish nation.” He said that Hebron was the first city of the Kingdom of David.
“He lived here for seven years before going to Jerusalem,” Mr. Waldmann said as he spoke of the holiness of Hebron for Jews. It contains the Tomb of the Patriarchs, a site that is second only to the Western (wailing) Wall of Jerusalem in its sacredness to religious Jews. The same structure is called the Haram al Khalil by Moslems, and is equally holy to them.
JERUSALEM, June 17—The dominant figures in the Israeli Cabinet have reached a consensus on a plan for the eventual disposition of the occupied west-bank area of the Jordan River. The chief feature of the plan is a provision for a string of paramilitary Israeli settlements in the Jordan Valley along the western edge of the river.
The settlements would provide Israel with a so-called security belt against infiltration and attack, but would avoid the problem of incorporating large numbers of Arabs into the state.
“It has long been the editorial policy of the Miami News to pour contempt on the human rights of the indigenous Palestinian Arabs of whom some 1,500,000 are refugees from a homeland seized by military force by Israelis… Americans are constantly brainwashed by the American press into believing that Arab arms lack the West’s anointing virtues.”
Printed directly beneath the signature, in bold, by the paper: “(Editor’s Note: As resident lecturer in Florida for the Arab Information Center in New York City, the author of this letter is a paid propagandist for the Arab government.)” The accusation in the letter is that the paper pours contempt on Palestinians; the paper’s answer, printed on the spot, is a line about the accuser. Fifteen years earlier the Southern Jewish Weekly had introduced a witness before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee the same way.
Arabs of Israel: A People in Search of an Identity
By TERENCE SMITH
JERUSALEM, July 27—“They still dream, while we have stopped dreaming,” the dark-haired young man explained over a cup of sweet black coffee. “They listen to the Arab radio, just as we do, but they still believe the claims of Al Fatah, no matter how fantastic they are.”
The speaker was an Israeli Arab, a schoolteacher who had grown to manhood in Israel and had attended Hebrew University in Jerusalem. He was recalling his first visit since the 1967 Arab-Israeli war to the Israeli-occupied area on the west bank of the Jordan River.
It should have been a joyous reunion when thousands of Israeli Arabs poured across the old border in the months after the six-day war to visit the relatives and friends on the west bank whom they had not seen for nearly 20 years. It should have been, but in many cases it was not.
“We had nothing in common,” the teacher said over … The 312,000 Arabs of Israel: A People in a Continuing Search for a Sense of Identity THEY FEEL APART FROM NEIGHBORS But Many Have Experienced Material Gains, If Not a Sense of Belonging Continued From Page 1, Col. 6 his coffee in a cafe in Jerusalem. “People I had known as a child were wary and suspicious of me.
They regarded me as an Israeli, not an Arab. Once, when I went into a shop in Bethlehem and asked the price of something in Arabic, the shopkeeper took one look at me and the clothes I was wearing, and answered me in Hebrew.”
The teacher’s experience has been shared by many of the 312,000 Israeli Arabs who have tried, in the wake of the war, to restore some of the ties they cherished before Palestine was partitioned in 1948.
For the Arabs who stayed behind in Israel, their inability to communicate with their former brothers on the west bank and in the Gaza Strip is yet another frustration in their continuing search for an identity.
Twenty years after they had elected to remain behind when more than a million of their brethren had fled to other countries, the Arabs of Israel are in as much of a quandary as ever. The majority of them are Moslems who think of themselves as Arabs, and members of the greater Arab Nation, but their sense of identity has been muddled by their surroundings.
They live in a country where the symbols and mode of life continually remind them that they are outsiders. Confusion Is Compounded The national flag bears the Star of David, the national anthem is Hatikvah and the avowed national goal is the “ingathering of the exiles.” Needless to say, the slogan refers to Jewish, not Arab, exiles.
Neither genuinely Arab nor genuinely Israeli, the personality of the Arabs of Israel has gradually split over two decades. Many of them speak Hebrew as fluently as Arabic, and their day of rest is Saturday, the Jewish Sabbath. Some have assimilated to the point of taking Jewish wives. It is estimated that 700 Arab men have married Jewish women.
However, there is only one recorded instance of a Jewish Israeli taking an Arab wife. All of these conflicting influences have left the Arabs of Israel confused about their own identity, and that confusion has been compounded by discoveriy in this last year of how little they they have in common with the Arabs of the west bank.
More often than not their reunions with their relatives and friends have served to remind them of their own isolation. “It made me wonder who we really are,” the teacher said. “We are certainly not Israelis, but we are a world apart from the people on the west bank.”
The continual exposure to the Jewish and Zionist elements of their adopted country has had a profound effect on the Arabs in Israel. Among the more educated, it has intensified their Arabness. The continual reminders that they are not part of the establishment of the state, that is, not Jews, have caused many to cling more stubbornly to their Arab tradition.
They maintain it in their dress, speech, literature and customs, and devote their energy to seeking equality as a protected minority. There are some, of course, who are avowed Arab nationalists, and their hatred for Israel is as fierce as any in the Arab world.
But this is an extreme group and though its members many devoutly wish for the elimnation of Israel as a state, few of them dare say so publicly and even fewer are prepared to do anything to bring it about. In this sense at least, the Arabs in Israel are loyal Israelis.
Attitude Is Ambivalent Their loyalty is partly motivated by a concern about how they would be treated by a conquering Arab army. And because of this, they had an ambivalent attitude toward the 1967 war.
“The war was a time of great personal conflict for the Arabs in Israel,” Abdul Aziz Zouabi, one of the Arab members of the Knesset, (Parliament), said in an interview. “We did not really want either side to lose.” Mr. Zouabi added: “We did not want to see our Arab brothers killed, but we did not want to se Israel overrun either.
After all, we live here and this is our country now, so we did not want Israel to lose. Also, we could not be sure how an Arab army would treat us.” An Arab student studying at Hebrew University in Jerusalem confirmed Mr. Zouabi’s view.
“We were afraid of both sides,” he said, “we knew that the Jordanians regarded us as Zionists and traitors, and we were worried about what the Israelis might do to us.” In fact, the Israeli authorities took only minimal security precautions.
In the two weeks before the war, only 52 Arabs were rounded up and detained, and during the six days of the fighting, only small units of border police were stationed in the Arab areas. There were no incidents of demonstrations of any kind in the Arab villages and towns in Israel during the war.
In the main, the Israeli Arabs stayed in their homes and listened to the radio, switching from the Israeli broadcasting service, to the Cairo radio, and back. Those who lived in and around Tel Aviv weer able to see for themselves that the Cairo radio reports of great fires in the city as a result of Arab bombs were fiction.
Some Arrested for Espionage In the period since the war, there have been a number of arrests of Israeli Arabs on espionage charges, but the total is small for the population. Twenty-four Arabs have been convicted of aiding guerrilla activities in the west-bank and Gaza areas.
An Israeli Army source concerned with the matter describes the security problem among Israeli Arabs as negligible. The real or imagined problem of security among the Arabs in Israel has been the stated reason for nearly all the restrictive measures that the authorities have applied against them over the 20 years of Israel’s existence.
When the war of independence was over in 1948, 170,000 Arabs of a prewar population of 1.3 million remained inside Israel. Those who left included most of the wealthy and the intelligentsia. Those who stayed behind were mostly uneducated peasants and laborers. They lived in villages and towns around Haifa, in the area near the Sea of Galilee and along the Jordanian border.
The city of Nazareth, for instance, was — and is — overwhelmingly Arab. Other Israeli areas with sizable Arab populations include: the Afula-Petah Tiqva region, Jaffa and Lydda. In 1949, military governments were established in the Arab districts and special defense and security zones were created.
Israeli Arabs were forbidden to travel into or out of these areas without a pass from the military commander. Military courts were established in the Arab districts. All trials were summary and could be held in closed session.
Restrictions Are Imposed With the consent of the Minister of Defense, the military commanders in the Arab areas could limit individual movements, impose restrictions on employment and business, issue deportation orders, search and seize at will, and detain a person up to one year if it was deemed necessary to maintain security.
Ironically, these regulations were originally set up by the British mandate authorities in Palestine to curb Jewish terrorism. The Israeli Government has never removed them from the books. Despite occasional protests in the Knesset from Arab members and liberal Israelis, the military government continued to administer the Arab areas until 1965.
The restrictions on travel were continued until last year, when they were lifted for all areas except the city of Elath, on the Gulf of Aqaba, which Israeli Arabs may still only visit by permit. The majority of Israeli Arabs describe themselves as second-class citizens.
In addtion to the military governments and travel restrictions, they cite as discriminatory the laws regarding expropriation of land and citizenship. Under the provisions of the so-called Law of the Return, any Jew coming to Israel may claim immediate citizenship simply by declaring his intention to settle. Non-Jews must undergo a waiting period.
The land-acquisition law, passed soon after the 1948 war, specified that the land of any person who fled his village and was absent when the Israeli forces entered the area would automatically be turned over to the custodian of absentee property. This applied even in cases where the landowners merely went elsewhere in Israel during the fighting.
When they returned to their homes they found their property taken over by the custodian. All told, about 1.6 million acres of Arab land was taken under this law, according to figures compiled by United Nations investigators.
An additional 120,000 acres of Arab land sequently turned over for Jewernment over the next 15 years, ostensibly for “security reasons and public purposes.” Criticized by Israeli Liberals Most of this land was subsequently turned over for Jewish settlement. Of 370 new Jewish settlements established between 1948 and 1953, 350 are on former Arab property.
In the case of the expropriated land, the Government is bound by law to pay compensation either in kind or cash. Of 15,000 claims for compensation, 11,400 have been settled so far. “The compensation is never adequate,” said one Israeli Arab whose family lost substantial property in the Jerusalem area.
“They offer you a fraction of what the land is worth, and you take that, or you get nothing.” The severity of this land policy has frequently been criticized by liberal Israelis, inside the Government and out, but the criticism generally has come after the fact.
Although the rights of the Arab minority are guaranteed by law in Israel, the Government has never made any serious effort to fully integrate them into the state. There are no Arab ministers in the Cabinet and no senior Arab civil servants.
The adviser on Arab affairs to the Premier is a Jew, as is his deputy, and the head of the Arab section in the Histadrut, the giant labor federation. There are seven Arab members of the Knesset, of a total 120 members. The Arabs of Israel do not serve in the army, but they and the Government agree that this situation is desirable.
“If it came to a war, we would have to fight Arabs.” Mr. Zouabi said, “We cannot very well be expected to kill our brothers and cousins.” In terms of army service and asecurity precautions, Israel makes a distinction between Arabs and the 32,000 Druze who live in the state.
The Druze are members of a sect that split off from traditional Islam in the 11th Century. Though they speak Arabic and live among the Arabs, they have proved themselves loyal fighters in Israel’s wars against the Arab countries.
There are special Druse units in the Israeli armed forces and Druse make up a significant part of the manpower of the paramilitary Israeli border police. The travel restrictions did not apply to them. Social Conditions Better On the positive side, the Arabs of Israel live in infinitely better social conditions now than they did 20 years ago.
New roads and housing have been constructed and there are now 353 Arab schools in Israel while in 1948 there were 56. The number of Arab pupils has risen from 11,129 in 1948 to 77,000. According to Government figures, the average yearly income of an Arab family in Nazareth is $2,000, while that of the average Jewish family is $2,100.
The figures are misleading, however, because there are usually several more working members in an Arab family. In addition, virtually no Arabs attain the $3,800-per-year average income earned by Jews in the professions in Israel. With the exception of teaching, the professions are largely closed to Israeli Arabs.
Many Israeli Arabs were inclined to discount these improvements over the years since they continually heard reports from the Amman and Cairo radios contending that the same progress was being made in the Arab countries. It was only after the 1967 war, when they visited the west-bank area that they discovered that the reports were untrue.
“I got quite a shock when I saw the way they were living.” Omar Masalha, an Israeli Arab psychology student at Hebrew University said. “Very little had changed, they were just as primitive as ever. Materially, we are much better off. Despite this advantage, Mr. Masalha is sharply critical of the Israeli Government’s treatment of the Arab minority.
“I always feel like a stranger—an outsider—here in my own land. The Government makes me feel as though I own nothing and can make no claim to anything in the state.” Mr. Masalha is one of 300 Israeli Arab students studying at Hebrew University.
He is also one of 20 who have recently received orders from the Government directing them not to travel in the occupied territories or in the former Jordanian sector of Jerusalem. “I got this order because the Government thinks I am critical of the state,” he said. “They did not really know what I think, but that does not matter.
If they decide you are against them, they restrict you.” More than anything else, Mr. Masalha is offended by the attitude he believes most Israelis harbor toward the Arab people. “They think we are all stupid and primitive and lazy, and it comes through in their attitude towards us, he said.
“I hear them talking in Hebrew about Arabs in the cafes attitude towards us,” he said. “I don’t like what they say, but I don’t speak up because here in Israel, they are strong and I am weak.” [PHOTOGRAPH, top centre of the page, with credit and caption:] The New York Times HEBREW UNIVERSITY in Jerusalem has 300 Israeli Arab students.
These are some. [MAP, top of the page right of the photograph, showing Lebanon, Syria, Haifa, Nazareth, Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, Beersheba, the NEGEV, ISRAEL and JORDAN, keyed to Arab population centres. Credit line beneath: “The New York Times” and “July 28, 1968”.
The key is too small to read reliably at this scan resolution and I have not transcribed it.] [The remainder of the page, right-hand side and foot, is display advertising — Tiffany & Co., Miss Bergdorf, “Tailored Woman” — and is not part of the article.]
Bedouins in typical Arab garb listen to radio in Beersheba cafe. Constant reminders that they are not part of the Israeli state have caused many to cling to their Arab tradition.
3 Israeli Soldiers Killed As Mine Blows Up Vehicle
TEL AVIV, Sept. 27 — Three Israeli soldiers were killed yesterday evening when a mine blew up their ammunition carrier in the Negev. Two other soldiers were seriously injured, but three escaped unhurt. The men were returning to their base. The mine was laid in a dirt track five miles south of the ruins of the Byzantine city of Subeita.
It was said to have been laid by a band of Bedouins who recently planted other mines in the Negev. Some of them damaged vehicles, but other s were detected before they caused damage. Meanwhile, the police here announced that in cooperation with the security services they had uncovered a terrorist cell in the village of Tira in the Sharon Plain. Four Israeli Arabs were arrested.
Date check: No masthead or folio line on this clipping — it is a trimmed single column. Below the headline, between rules, stands the credit line “Special to The New York Times”, which agrees with `pub`. The dateline reads “TEL AVIV, Sept. 27”, consistent with publication on 1968-09-28; no year appears on the scan.
Fanatic Arab Guerrilla Fighters Intend To ‘Liberate’ Palestine
AMMAN, Jordan (AP) — Guerrilla fighters speak confidently of turning Israel into another Vietnam if it takes 20 years. They claim to represent the objective of a restored Palestine in the area that is now Israel, and some of them at least seem impelled by a fanaticism spawned in the loss of a homeland.
They reject in advance any Middle East settlement that provides for the continued existence of the Jewish-led state. The best available information indicates that the guerrillas are currently about 3,000 strong, with no shortage of recruits or money to buy weapons. Jordan officials describe them as a problem for the Arab governments.
Leaders of Al Fatah, most effective of several guerrilla organizations, argue that the Arab people would overthrow any Arab government within 24 hours if it began peace talks with Israel. Most guerrilla camps are in Jordan. “Let King Hussein raise a finger to begin negotiations and we will cut it off,” threatened one Al Fatah member.
“The king would like to talk peace with the Jews but he knows he cannot.” If it came to a showdown, Jordan’s army, by striking hard and fast might be strong enough to overcome guerrilla resistance. But every week the guerrillas seem to become stronger, in numbers, efficiency and firepower.
The guerrillas harbor no hopes of a quick victory over the Israelis and an Al Fatah spokesman reported boys of 9 and 10 are being trained to carry on in the years ahead. “We are still in the first stage of a long campaign,” he said. “This is the stage of hit and run. We know we are not strong enough to tackle the Israeli army in the occupied territories.
We can only make life uncomfortable for them.” Vietnam is a far cry from the rocky, sun-bleached hills of Jordan, but the spokesman says: “If the Viet Cong can defy the mightiest army on earth, how much more can we do against an Israeli army of 200,000 men? “The Viet Cong began just as we are.
It took them 20 years to beat the French and fight the Americans to a standstill. We are prepared to fight just as long.” Al Fatah contends that Palestine was stolen from Arab owners and that the Jewish state has no right to exist.
The movement’s political spokesman said Al Fatah’s sole intent is to “liberate” Palestine with all other political questions in abeyance until that is achieved. Jews who lived in Palestine before 1948, when Israel was born, would be permitted to remain. Those who arrived since then would be expelled, he said.
Al Fatah is believed to have ample funds, mainly from private Kuwaiti and Saudi Arabian sources. Some of the other organizations receive money from Arab governments. “If we lose two, even five, men for every Israeli it doesn’t matter,” said the Al Fatah spokesman. “There are 100 million Arabs and only two or three million Israelis.
RAMALLAH, Israeli-Occupied Jordan, Oct. 23—A week of rising tension stimulated by student demonstrations culminated today in violence, arrests and a curfew in this prosperous town in the Israeli-occupied area on the west bank of the Jordan River.
More than 25,000 residents of Ramallah and a sister town of Birah were ordered off the streets at 8 A.M. by Israeli troops and border policemen. The move came after 400 girls in green school uniforms had marched into the center of Ramallah carrying pictures of President Gamal Abdel Nasser of the United Arab Republic.
Shouting anti-Israeli slogans and chanting: “We are all fedayeen,” or Arab commandos, the girls carried what had been daily schoolyard protests into the downtown area. Israeli officials said that when the girls began throwing stones and spitting at Israeli soldiers, the occupying forces turned high-pressure hoses on them and ordered the curfew.
Roadblocks cut the town off from the rest of the west-bank area and severed the main highway through the Judean Hills. A dozen arrests were made, the Israelis said. By midafternoon the town was deserted. At one point, two single shots and then a burst of automatic gunfire could be heard on the outskirts.
Soldiers carrying batons moved along the empty streets, shouting at women who peered out of windows in the long rows of stone building. Jeeps carrying border policemen were the only vehicles in sight.
JERUSALEM, Oct. 24 —The Israeli occupation authorities warned today that they would fire on west-bank Arabs violating curfews if that became necessary to maintain public order. The threat was included in new orders issued to security forces to impose curfews at the first signs of public protests and to use tanks if necessary to enforce them.
With the stricter security measures came reports that 3,000 schoolgirls demonstrated this morning in Nablus and that two other groups of students rioted in Jenin.
Both towns in the Israeli-occupied area on the west bank of the Jordan River were placed under curfew while Ramallah and Birah, where demonstrations led to violence yesterday, were released from their curfew after a visit by Defense Minister Moshe Dayan.
The Defense Minister, who has advocated a policy of Arab self-administration, said that while the Mayors could not be expected to assist the Israelis in finding saboteurs, they should be able to keep schoolgirls under control.
The Arab refugees — irreconcilable, dreaming of only one thing: return to old homes
“My only memories until last June were of Gaza. I have been told by the people who raised me that my parents used to live near Tel Aviv. I don’t know. There was a time when I wanted to know who my parents were, whether they were alive or dead, and where I came from.
I have stopped asking those questions. I know only that until last June I spent all my life in Gaza with hundreds of thousands of other Palestinian Arab refugees. Almost all of us were driven out of Gaza last June. Some went to the west bank of Jordan, now occupied by Israel… There used to be about 6000 people in Kalandia. In the June war about half of them fled.
Some new people who had their villages destroyed came and took their place. They are lost people.”
Parade went into tens of millions of American Sunday papers, which makes this one of the largest audiences any Palestinian in this archive ever addressed directly. The speaker is Munther Hammad Alsalhi, 23, a student in Cairo, and the magazine prints him at length and in the first person alongside three others, two Arabs and two Israelis. Then it puts this over the top of the page: The Arab refugees — irreconcilable, dreaming of only one thing: return to old homes. A man who says he has stopped asking who his parents were is called irreconcilable in the headline above his own words. His testimony was transcribed on 5 October 2026; the record previously held only the headline and the introduction.
Fatah Being Betrayed by Arabs Enabling Israel to Nab Terrorists
By ROBERT GAMZEY (The writer is a special correspondent for The Courant in Israel).
LYDDA, ISRAEL — Abu Harb, 19-year-old East Jerusalem self-proclaimed "freedom fighter" for the Palestine Liberation Front, stood in an Israeli military court here and casually admitted "I placed time bombs in Jerusalem near Bickur Holim Hospital Aug. 18 and Sept. 4 in the Tel Aviv bus station and it was my duty to do so. I have proof that I had the right to place the bombs.
I am innocent and shall prove it." Abu Harb was one of four East Jerusalem Arab youths, aged 18 to 20, who faced trial for planting explosives in public places. In the same court, 19-year-old Ahmed Mohammed Muheimar turned on another suspect, Latif Kamel, 18, and accused Kamel of betraying him to the Hebrew police.
Kamel took the stand to tell how he joined the Fatah terrorist organization on a visit to Amman last June when he was paid 30 Jordanian dinars to organize a sabotage group in Jerusalem.
Out of such testimony freely given by 1,300 Arab terrorists held in Israeli prisons can be gleaned the reasons for the failure of Fatah and other Palestine "freedom fighters" whose exaggerated exploits were advertised in a Time magazine cover story. Kamel's betrayal of Muheimar was typical of the Arab penchant for informing on each other.
This streak of ingroup disunity aids the police in breaking ring after ring of saboteurs.
THE SHARPEST LANGUAGE IN THE BATCH SITS HERE, and it is in a staff correspondent's news story, not an op-ed. Two sentences, in The Hartford Courant's own voice, unattributed: 'Kamel's betrayal of Muheimar was typical of the Arab penchant for informing on each other. This streak of ingroup disunity aids the police in breaking ring after ring of saboteurs.' That is a racial generalisation about a people, stated as a fact that explains a police result, under a staff byline, on page 5 of a major American daily. It is not a quotation from an Israeli official. It is the newspaper talking.
The headline does the same work in shorter form: 'Fatah Being Betrayed by Arabs Enabling Israel to Nab Terrorists.' Note the vocabulary across one page: 'terrorists' five times in the paper's voice, 'Arab terrorists' as a category of prisoner, 'saboteurs', 'the Fatah terrorist organization', and 'freedom fighter' / 'freedom fighters' always inside scare quotes and always prefixed 'self-proclaimed' or 'other Palestine'. The paper never uses the word without distancing it.
And yet this is also the one clipping in the batch where a Palestinian speaks at length. Abu Harb gets 48 consecutive words. The reporter frames them with 'casually admitted' and the page is built so that his statement is evidence against him, but the words are there, printed, and they include 'it was my duty to do so' and 'I am innocent and shall prove it.' For an archive of what American papers printed about Palestinians, that is a find: the longest Palestinian quotation in seventeen slides is a teenager defending himself in a military court.
The photograph at the top of the page shows Israeli children running to a shelter. There is no photograph of the four defendants.
ATHENS (UPI) — Two Palestinians… Police heard shots being fired and saw smoke coming out of…
The attack on an El Al airliner at Athens, the day after Christmas. The headline's noun is terrorists; the body's is Palestinians. It is one of the earliest uses of the first word in this archive.
MAJDEL CHAMS, Israeli-Occupied Syria — This is a Druze village high on the slopes of Mt. Hermon, bordering Lebanon. What goes on here shows how Israel is integrating the Golan Heights into Israel's economy, so that the people left in this area — perhaps 6,000 of the original 90,000 before the June war—never will want to break away from Israel.
No Druze left although all were Syrian citizens. The Golan Heights occupied area is about 17 miles deep by 55 miles wide, sitting atop the escarpment and mountains from the Sea of Galiliee northward. It is critically important because from here Israel can dominate Damascus — and with it all Syria —as Syria used to sit atop the Israeli villages and look down their throats.
All occupied areas — Golan, West Bank (the Judea-Samaria areas of former Palestine) and the Gaza Strip are under the direction of one man — Defense Minister Moshe Dayan. He is the military government. Under him are seven military governors in regional towns ranging from Jericho and Nablus in occupied Jordan to Kuneitra in occupied Syria.
Thus it is a deliberate policy and no accident of a different administrator when the contrasts are noted in handling the people of Golan and the people of the West Bank (600,000 Arabs there, perhaps 6,000 Druze and a few hundred Moslem Arabs in the Golan area). The Jordan occupation is strict segragation.
The Palestine Arabs are left to run their own affairs, provided they obey the ground rules: Don't propagandize against Israel, don't support the El Fatah sabotage units, continue daily life normally. The Golan-Druze area occupation is strict integration.
Every move Israel makes with the civilian population is intended to build up bonds that, in effect, will demand that Israel keep control and the area never be returned to Syria. The best way to show the contrasts is to list the differing ways Israel treats the same problems in the two areas.
What comes through is that while in both cases this is a military occupation, Israel is far from an arrogant conqueror. Our group of 10 editors and reporters from America, on a fact-finding mission sponsored by the United Jewish Appeal, found the following: THE MILITARY HAND West Bank—The army is as invisible as possible, except at road blocks.
The gun emplacements are well hidden, camouflaged. Golan Heights—The army is as visible and tough-appearing as possible. Personnel carriers are lined up, ready to move toward Syria. [...] Golan-Druze area—There are no restrictions on Druze movement in or out of Israel.
The Druze, an 850-year-old sect, are fanatical Arab - haters, one reason they get along so well with the Israelis. Now the Syrian area Druze are visiting relatives in Israel and are stunned by the living standards they find.
But I was in the home of Sheik Saliman, the mukhtar (leader) of Majdal Chams, and it was more lavishly furnished, in its own heavy style, than many a home in Cleveland Heights would be.
EDUCATION West Bank — Teachers and parents began a school strike last September over "interference" by Israel in local autonomy — the order to eliminate from Arab textbooks anti-Jewish passages, such as: "If you kill two Jews and three Jews, how many Jews have you killed?
This was solved by Defense Minister Dayan's astuteness in letting the Arabs fight a pillow which would not punch back. He let them alone, saying that if they wanted illiterate children, that was their business and the schools would stay closed. Eventually the parents sent their children back.
THE SOURCING ADMISSION IS THE FINDING, and the reporter prints it himself: 'Our group of 10 editors and reporters from America, on a fact-finding mission sponsored by the United Jewish Appeal, found the following:' Everything that follows — the whole comparative list, the access to Sheik Saliman, the roadblock photograph — comes from an organised trip paid for by an advocacy organisation, and the paper discloses it in one clause and then presents the results as findings. It sits in the same paragraph as 'while in both cases this is a military occupation, Israel is far from an arrogant conqueror', which is the conclusion the trip was built to produce.
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — this clipping is the thread's epilogue, written from the other end. Who is censoring: Israel, by 'the order to eliminate from Arab textbooks anti-Jewish passages'. Note the phrase: 'anti-Jewish passages', flat, in the paper's own voice, where the 1967 AP copy said 'anti-Zionist material' and attributed it. What happened: 'Teachers and parents began a school strike last September over "interference" by Israel in local autonomy' — and 'interference' is the one word the paper puts in scare quotes, so the Palestinian characterisation is marked as a claim while the Israeli one is not. How it ended, in the paper's own voice: 'This was solved by Defense Minister Dayan's astuteness in letting the Arabs fight a pillow which would not punch back. He let them alone, saying that if they wanted illiterate children, that was their business and the schools would stay closed. Eventually the parents sent their children back.' Dayan is 'astute'; the Palestinian parents are punching a pillow and are offered their children's illiteracy as the alternative. Is any Palestinian quoted: no. The strike is six months of Palestinian collective action rendered as a tactical problem Dayan solved by waiting.
SHARPEST LANGUAGE: 'The Druze, an 850-year-old sect, are fanatical Arab - haters, one reason they get along so well with the Israelis.' That is a staff Associate Editor, in his own voice, in a major metropolitan daily, explaining a political alignment by ascribing racial hatred to a whole sect as a compliment.
VOCABULARY, which is unusually candid for the batch and worth quoting against the rest: the dateline is 'MAJDEL CHAMS, Israeli-Occupied Syria'; the body has 'All occupied areas', 'occupied Jordan', 'occupied Syria', 'The Golan Heights occupied area', 'this is a military occupation', 'The Jordan occupation', 'The Golan-Druze area occupation'. It also calls the West Bank 'the Judea-Samaria areas of former Palestine' — the only use of the Israeli settler-movement toponyms anywhere in this batch, and it sits in the same sentence as 'former Palestine'. And 'The Palestine Arabs are left to run their own affairs, provided they obey the ground rules'.
By RICHARD Z. CHESNOFF / EXAMINER-NEWSWEEK SERVICE
The first-grade "readers" passed out to Syrian grammar school students begin like basic primers all over the world. But within a few pages, the young mind starts to reap a harvest of hate carefully sown by the government. Beneath a drawing of a bayonet-wielding Arab, a passage reads: "Palestine is a dear Arab land.
The Jews are wicked criminals who came to Palestine and drove out its people. We will drive the wicked criminal out of the country." Throughout the Arab world, hatred for Israel and the Jews is doled out in every course, from the first grade through high school. In Jordan, a composition question in a textbook states: "Israel was born to die.
Prove it." In Egypt, 12 year olds must analyze the structure of the sentence: "The Arabs do not cease to act for the extermination of Israel." By the time the Syrian child reaches fifth grade, his syntactical exercise concerns the sentence: "We shall expel all the Jews from the Arab countries." The purpose of that vituperation is spelled out in a Jordanian high-school text: "Like the cry of Cato, the famous Roman orator, 'Carthage must be destroyed,' so you Arab boys and girls must cling to the slogan, 'Israel must be destroyed!'" The first proof that Arab textbooks were training children for terror came at the end of the 1967 Middle East war, when Israeli troops entered the towns they had conquered.
"I glanced through a mountain of books our soldiers had picked up in the Golan Heights, on the West Bank and in the Gaza Strip," recalls an Israeli sociologist. "They were incredible. Hatred was cultivated deliberately.
How could we possibly ever hope that young people growing up on such filth could think of us even as human beings?" One Syrian Ministry of Education official says flatly, "The hatred we instill into the minds of our children from the day of their birth is sacred." It is also essential to the cause of Arab unity.
A foreign relations textbook explains: "Carrying out the unity of the countries of the Arab homeland will provide them with the strongest possible weapon enabling them to strangle Israel, to tear to pieces her ambitions and to throw her to the sea." For each new generation of Arab children, annihilation of Israel becomes a lifelong ambition.
An exhibit of paintings by girls between 8 and 12 years old was titled "The dream of slaughtering Israel." The canvasses were violent portrayals of Arab soldiers hacking up Jews. Jews are assailed not only as a nation but as a people.
"The Jews in Europe were persecuted and despised," claims one text, "because of their corruption, meanness and treachery." Jews rule the U.S., says Syria's "Modern Sociology," "through the Jewish families of the Rockefellers, the Morgans and the Vanderbilts." The classic anti-Semitic forgery, "The Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion," is taught as proof that Jews rule the whole world.
"If it weren't for the Arabic writing," says an Israeli school teacher, "I'd swear I was looking at 'Der Stuermer' (a violently anti-Semitic Nazi magazine)."
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — second printing of the Chesnoff feature, and the headline is the thing to compare:
s104_1 'Arab textbooks carry message of hatred' (Albany Democrat-Herald)
s111_1 "Arabs Create 'Schools of Hate' for Young" (this one)
The Albany headline is about the books. This one is about the people: Arabs, plural, unqualified, create schools of hate for their young. 'Schools of Hate' is in quotation marks, and the phrase does appear in the piece — but in its last line, in the mouth of an Israeli official ('these "schools for hatred" must disappear'), and in a slightly different form. The desk lifted a phrase from an Israeli official's closing quotation, changed 'for hatred' to 'of Hate', and made it the subject of a sentence whose actor is 'Arabs'.
Sourcing as at s104_1, and worth repeating because this printing makes it starker by cutting the UNESCO paragraph: there is no dateline and no city, and every source is anonymous — 'an Israeli sociologist', 'One Syrian Ministry of Education official', 'an Israeli school teacher', 'Israeli intelligence sources'. No Arab or Palestinian educator, official or parent is named or quoted anywhere.
And note again the opening specimen, which this printing keeps: 'Palestine is a dear Arab land. The Jews are wicked criminals who came to Palestine and drove out its people. We will drive the wicked criminal out of the country.' Three sentences, printed as one undifferentiated example of hatred. The first is an attachment to a place. The second is a slur wrapped around a historical claim. Only the third is a threat. The piece is built so the reader cannot tell them apart — which is the same move the AP headline desks made on the UNESCO dispatch four months later.
(Newsweek Feature Service) [the reporter is Richard Z. Chesnoff — named in the San Francisco printing of the same piece, s111_1; this paper printed no reporter's name]
The first-grade "readers" passed out to Syrian grammar school students begin like basic primers all over the world: "Child - The Child - The child is clean; Moon - The moon is shinning." But within a few pages, the young mind starts to reap a harvest of hate carefully sown by the government.
Beneath a drawing of a bayonet-wielding Arab, a passage reads: "Palestine is a dear Arab land. The Jews are wicked criminals who came to Palestine and drove out its people. We Arab children will always remember Palestine. We will drive the wicked criminal out of the country. Long live Palestine, and long live the Arabs!" The lesson is not unusual.
Throughout the Arab world, hatred for Israel and for the Jews is doled out in every course, from the first grade through high school. In Jordan, a compostition question in a textbook states: "Israel was born to die.
Prove it." In Egypt, 12-year-olds must analyze the structure of the sentence: "The Arabs do not cease to act for the extermination of Israel." And by the time the Syrian child reaches fifth grade, his syntactical exercise concerns the sentence: "We shall expel all the Jews from the Arab countries." The ultimate purpose of the torrent of vituperation is spelled out clearly in a Jordanian high-school text: "Like the cry of Cato, the famous Roman orator, 'Carthage must be destroyed,' so you Arab boys and girls must cling to the slogan, 'Israel must be destroyed!'" The first solid proof that Arab textbooks were training children for terror came at the end of the 1967 Middle East war, when Israeli troops entered the towns they had conquered.
"I glanced through a mountain of books our soldiers had picked up in the Golan Heights, on the West Bank and in the Gaza Strip," recalls an Israeli sociologist. "They were incredible. Hatred was cultivated deliberately, carefully.
How could we possibly ever hope that young people growing up on such filth could think of us even as human beings, let alone consider the possibility of living with us in peace?" Officially, the Arab states adhere to UNESCO principles which state that textbooks should be free of "any passage likely to harm international or religious understanding." In practice, however, the Arabs claim a sort of holy immunity, As one Syrian Ministry of Education official says flatly, "The hatred we instill into the minds of our children from the day of their birth is sacred." It is also essential to the cause of Arab unity.
A foreign relations textbook explains: "Carrying out the unity of the countries of the Arab homeland will provide them with the strongest possible weapon enabling them to restore the stolen right, to strangle Israel, to tear to pieces her ambitions and to throw her to the sea." For each new generation of Arab children, the annihilation of Israel becomes a lifelong ambition.
An exhibit of paintings by girls between 8 and 12 years old was titled "The dream of slaughtering Israel," and the canvasses were violent portrayals of Arab soldiers hacking up beak-nosed Jews. Jews are assailed not only as a nation but as a people.
"The Jews in Europe were persecuted and despised," claims one text, "because of their corruption, meanness and treachery." Jews rule the U.
S., says Syria's "Modern Sociology," "through the Jewish families of the Rockefellers, the Morgans and the Vanderbilts." The classic anti-Semitic forgery,"The Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion," is taught as proof that Jews rule the whole world.
The fingers of loathing reach even to Russia: the late Lavrenti Beria, Joseph Stalin's hatchet man, is accused of being a spy for "the objectives of World Zionism." "If it weren't for the Arabic writing," says an Israeli school teacher, "I'd swear I was looking at 'Der Stuermer' ( a violently anti-Semitic Nazi magazine).
Julius Streicher and his gang couldn't have produced anything worse." Israeli intelligence sources are positive that many of the Arab texts are the work of ex-Nazis now living in Arab countries.
Simon Weisenthal, the Vienna-based Nazi-hunter whose documentation center has tracked down thousands of Nazi war criminals, says that Egypt's Ministry of Propaganda employs several ex-Hazis who are responsible for preparing textbooks.
He cites as specific examples former Streicher aide Franz Bunsche, who has lived in Alexandria since 1946, and Hans Appler, a former member of the Nazi Information Ministry who now uses the Arab alias Salah Chaffar. After the six-day war, Israel was faced with the task of educating thousands of Arab children who suddenly came under its jurisdiction.
Rather than just excising the anti-Jewish passages in the texts, the Israeli government has spent some $700,000 revising and reissuing more than a million Arabic-language books. "It is expensive," concedes an Israeli official, "but if we can undo some of the damage, it will be well worth the investment.
If there is to be any hope for peace between our peoples, these 'schools for hatred' must disappear."
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — the propaganda end of it, and the clipping that shows how far the story travelled from the occupied schools it started in. Who is censoring: the Israeli government, which 'has spent some $700,000 revising and reissuing more than a million Arabic-language books'. What was removed: 'the anti-Jewish passages in the texts' — and note the construction, 'Rather than just excising the anti-Jewish passages … the Israeli government has spent some $700,000 revising and reissuing', which frames mass reprinting as the generous option. Whose voice: the paper's own, throughout, with no hedging whatever. 'A harvest of hate carefully sown by the government.' 'Hatred for Israel and for the Jews is doled out in every course.' 'The torrent of vituperation.' 'For each new generation of Arab children, the annihilation of Israel becomes a lifelong ambition.' None of that is attributed to anyone. Is any Palestinian quoted: NO.
THIS IS WHERE THE SHARPEST LANGUAGE IN THE BATCH SITS — sharper than the Hartford Courant's line about 'the Arab penchant for informing on each other', because it is longer and more systematic. The piece builds an equation across its last third: Arab textbooks = Der Stuermer = the Protocols = ex-Nazis on the Egyptian payroll. It is unbylined feature-service copy, which means it ran in an unknown number of American dailies under an unknown number of headlines, exactly like the AP dispatch on slides 99/102/103/112.
Also worth noting for the 'liberating Palestine' question: the first-grade passage the piece quotes to open its case is 'Palestine is a dear Arab land. The Jews are wicked criminals who came to Palestine and drove out its people. We Arab children will always remember Palestine.' Two of those three sentences are a statement of dispossession and remembrance; one is a slur. The piece prints all three as a single specimen of hatred, which is the same fusion the AP headline desks performed four months later. Here it happens inside the quotation itself.
He Says the Arabs Must Not ‘Run Wild’ in Protests · Calls Demonstrations Held in Schoolyards Acceptable
NABLUS, Israeli - Occupied Jordan, Feb. 11 — Defense Minister Moshe Dayan plunged today into the towns and villages of the Israeli-occupied west bank of the Jordan River, drawing distinctions between demonstrations and disorder.
He visited Qalqilya, Tulkarm, Jenin and this crowded hilltop city, and spoke with Israeli military government officials and shopkeepers and schoolchildren. These towns, and others on the west bank and in the Gaza Strip, have seen violence and arrests in the last two weeks as Israeli soldiers have attempted to suppress political protests.
To a few newsmen who accompanied him Mr. Dayan said: “We will not intervene if demonstrations are held in schoolyards, not even if they carry Nasser’s picture and shout anti-Israeli slogans.” Military government officials also have been reducing the pressure by fining arrested protesters immediately rather than holding them while additional protests build up.
“We will not let them run wild and we will not let them spill over into the streets to block traffic,” he said. Mr. Dayan’s impact was felt, as it usually is on trips of this kind, during the impromptu stops he makes in some unlikely places in the Arab areas.
He stopped at a fishmonger’s stand in this casbah in Nablus, and became involved in a long discussion over the price of fish. Details were lost in the babble of the throng but Mr. Dayan’s final advice was clear enough: “Sell it in Tel Aviv.” Outside Taibeh, an Israeli Arab village just outside the west bank border, Mr.
Dayan walked through ankle-deep mud in a parsley field to discuss farm problems. Mr. Dayan is a former Agriculture Minister. Nearby at Tulkarm on the west bank, he walked a quarter of a mile into an orange grove to discuss marketing problems. The topic was timely because Jordanian officials appeared today to be reimposing restrictions on traffic at the Damiya Bridge.
The Jordanians barred pedestrian traffic across the bridge, which spans the Jordan River cease-fire line, after a night of shooting in the area. Truck traffic continued, however. Mounting a stone parapet, he asked: “Why don’t you go to school?”
From within the chorus of mumbling replies a young man stepped forward—Bashir Sabah, a 19-year-old third-year student. He shook Mr. Dayan’s hand and said: “We are like those in the other cities. If Nablus finishes striking, we will finish.” Neither he nor Mr. Dayan knew it then, but the strike in Nablus had ended.
The boy continued: “We want to know what will become of our city.” “But you don’t know what will happen,” Mr. Dayan replied. “Will you stay on strike until peace talks are completed?” “You cannot expect us to be placid when our situation remains unclear,” the boy said. Mr. Dayan shrugged.
The exchange was indecisive, like so many other aspects of life under occupation.
Patricia A. Campbell, age 13, 21 Prescott St., West Boylston
“This is in response to the Jan. 12, 1969, advertisement, ‘Justice and Truth Is the Issue.’ Yes, justice and truth is the issue, but from BOTH sides. Israel was NOT created by the free vote of the United Nations in 1948. There is evidence that President Truman pressured certain countries, such as Cuba and Panama, who were against Israel.
Those countries, wanting certain favors of the United States at the time, yielded and abstained from voting. How can this be defined as ‘free’?… Many people do not realize that Palestine is also the traditional homeland of the Arab ancestors, not just the Jews. What right do the Jews have to deny them their homeland in Palestine?
Genocide never was the intention of any Arab government, and there are official denials to prove it. It’s the fanatics who talk about ‘genocide’ and the ‘extermination’ of Israel. But the Arabs are not all fanatics. There are many more who are willing to sit down and talk it out. Yes, the Jews need a homeland and a place to live happily.
But why at Arab expense and the price of Arab suffering? The Moslem Arab and the Christian Arab have deep religious memories as well as the Jews.”
A thirteen-year-old answering a paid advertisement that ran in the same paper on 12 January. Both of the loaded words are in quotation marks, and she gives her street address.
JERUSALEM — A thick stream of workmen flows down the long hill from West to East Jerusalem every afternoon — Arab laborers returning from jobs in the Jewish sector. The hill, near the old city wall, used to be part of Suleiman Road. For nearly two decades it stood unused and grown over in the no-man’s land between Jordanian and Israeli Jerusalem.
In 1967 the city that had been divided in one Arab-Israeli war was reunified in another. The street was cleared, repaved and renamed by the victorious Israelis. Now it is Paratroopers Brigade Road. Ignore Change The Arabs do not bother with that name, and it is not the only change they ignore, if they can.
Nearly two years after the six-day war, Jerusalem stands whole, but still divided. An East Jerusalem schoolteacher, Joseph Nasri Nasr, put it this way: “There’s a difference between removing the physical barriers between the two halves of the city and removing the barriers between the people themsleves.
“It is true that most parts of the populations of East and West Jerusalem go into each other’s sectors quite frequently. But I don’t think they like each other very much. “When I go to West Jerusalem I have to look over my shoulder; if I go to a coffeehouse, I have to watch what I say. Perhaps I try to hide the fact that I am an Arab.
“I know what happened to me on several occasions when they found out that I was an Arab. They started looking at me and feeling apprehensive about my presence.” There was apprehension, too, on that morning three weeks after the battle for Jerusalem had ended when the dividing barriers were torn down and the enemy populations were allowed to mingle.
ILL FEELING among Arabs was created when Jews bulldozed the slum quarter in front of the Wailing Wall.
Ibranim Ebeid, President, The Action Committee on American-Arabs Relations, Cliffside Park
“Zionist Genocide. Dear Editor: Charles Feuereisen in his recent letter has failed to realize that the so-called ‘terrorists’ are the victims of the Zionist genocide and its survivors. Zionist occupation, air attacks, napalms, brutalities and so on, were the motive behind the commandos and their movement to liberate their Palestine.
To stop the suffering of Palestine people and to restore peace to the area, people of good will should: SUPPORT the plight of the Palestinian people in their struggle to restore peace in the area and to go back to their homes and property. THE WHOLE world should join hands to stop the Zionist nazism as they stopped the Hitlerite nazism once, before the whole world be afire.
To save human lives in the Middle East, the U.S. government should stop the sale of the 50 Phantom jets to Israel and give anti-aircraft missiles to Jordan to protect its citizens. America should not become subjected to the pressure of any minority to the detriment of national interest.
The Zionists have done more damage to American good will in the Middle East than millions of Communists could ever do. If Israel really wants peace the Zionist should negotiate face-to-face, not with Nasser or Hussein, but with the Palestine Liberation Movement, with Al-Fatah, which represents the people of Palestine, and with its spokesman Yaser Arafat, Abu Ammar.”
A letter using the word in its own headline in 1969, answering another reader by name. It runs directly beneath a letter about American Indians signed Johnny Mohawk.
A reader in Michigan listing massacres and their counts. The archive keeps it because remembering is the subject, and it is a reader doing it rather than a paper.
AMMAN—A would-be Lawrence of Arabia wrote the first accounts of the Palestine commandos or Fedayeen, and wrongly made it seem that a guerrilla force of some 5,000 men based primarily here in Jordan could do serious damage to Israel by raids and terrorist activities.
In fact, the military operations of the Fedayeen exist chiefly for the political purpose of rallying the Palestinian arabs. The Palestinians are of crucial importance because they are the party in direct conflict with Israel. Palestinian Arabs had lived for hundreds of years in what is now Israel when European Jews began settling in large numbers at the turn of the century.
Led by local notables and with only a faint sense of national identity, the Palestinians offered weak resistance to the Jewish political and economic penetration that took place up to World War II. When the going got truly rough, after the war, many of the Palestinian Arabs, instead of standing and fighting, fled.
They now number about 2,500,000 persons spread all over the Arab world. Thus fragmented, the Palestinians for years had only an artificial political life. Their battle against Israel was waged, on a very intermittent basis, by the Arab states.
Their leadership was vested in persons picked by the rulers of those states—notably Ahmed Shukairy, a Palestinian who worked as a diplomat for Syria and Saudi Arabia. The combination of abundant grievances and almost total impotence yielded the usual foaming at the mouth.
In the interim, however, many of the Palestinians living in exile in the booming states of Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Libya and Lebanon made it as engineers, financiers, professors, lawyers and businessmen. These men have put together the Fedayeen movement and emerged as the new leaders of the Palestinian Arabs.
Thus Yaser Arafat, the leader of the main commando organization, Al Fateh, is a Palestinian educated in Cairo who worked as an engineer in Kuwait. Georges Habeche, the head of a front which has pulled off most of the terrorist activity, including the assault on Israeli planes, is a Palestinian who became a doctor in Lebanon.
The commando movement, whatever its military significance, represents an undoubted political evolution for the Palestinians. Precisely because they are doing practical things to achieve their objectives, they no longer need to fulminate about pushing the Jews into the sea. The official objective now is a bilateral state, including both Jews and Arabs.
BEIRUT, Lebanon (AP) — A new clash broke out between Palestinians and troops in Lebanon today and four persons were reported killed despite a state of emergency designed to keep the nation calm.
Several thousand Palestinian refugees, protesting restrictions on Arab guerrillas operating in Lebanon against Israel, broke through a cordon of troops in the southern town of Tyre and attacked a police station. Twelve persons were killed and 82 were wounded in scattered clashes Wednesday.
The imposition of a state of emergency was accompanied by curfews in Beirut and five other major towns. At least a dozen refugees were reported wounded in the new clash at Tyre where troops and riot police were supported by armored cars.
One witness said the Palestinians burned a Lebanese flag at the police station before being driven back to Tyre’s Rashidien refugee camp. The camp holds 10,000 Palestinians uprooted from homes in Israel. Army reinforcements were rushed to Tyre and the entire area was sealed off. Strict military censorship has been imposed under the state of emergency laws.
All security forces were placed under the command of the army chief, Gen. Emile Bustani. In the north of the country armored cars sealed off the Christian village of Zhorta near Tripoli for fear of clashes between Christians and Moslems. In Beirut’s Palestinian quarter many people defied the curfew to carry on normal business.
Police dispersed gatherings of more than two or three but there was no violence.
“There is more than an Israel headache in the dramatic Arab commando suicide attacks that explode in the news. The political purpose is powerful—and effective.
The Arabs reason that their guerrilla warfare is the first and best step in forcing Israel to evacuate the Sinai Peninsula, the west bank of the Jordan River and the Golan Heights of Syria held since the six-day 1967 war. And our State Department considers the Arabs’ special facilities for this to be more widespread than we may suppose.
The key comes in the failure to distinguish the Palestine Arabs from other Arabs in the Arab world. In the 1948 Palestine war Israel took about 3,000 square miles more territory than the United Nations resolution of November 29, 1947, gave her. About a million of today’s evicted Arab refugees date from that time—20 years ago.
But this is only the better known part of the pressure.
Contrary to our general misimpression of ancient mutual hatred, there is probably nowhere on earth that Jews have traditionally lived more peacefully and successfully than in the Arab world, and for centuries… It was the Arab peoples and the Moslem ‘church’ which gave shelter and asylum to Jews fleeing Christian Europe from the Spanish Inquisition and the persecution of tsarist Russia down to the ghastly exterminations which Hitler called ‘the final solution.’
As a booty of World War I, Britain seized Palestine under the Balfour Declaration, obtained a League of Nations mandate, and set up shop to enhance Britain’s commercial interests—and by so doing violated every pledge Britain had given the Arabs in order to gain their help against the Turks in World War I.
It was then, not 1948, that the influx of European Jews and the eviction of the Palestine Arabs began.
The 92 per cent Arab, 8 per cent Jewish population changed to 65 per cent Arab, 35 per cent Jewish by the time Britain surrendered the Palestine mandate to the United Nations after World War I… In this long process the Palestine Arab evictees total about 2½ million, many more than generally supposed, and they are scattered on a scale we seem to have missed entirely… Through all these years these fragmented people have had a political life.
The Palestine commandos or fedayeen are mainly a political instrument dedicated to uniting the far-flung Palestine Arabs. Fiery-eyed Yaser Arafat, a Cairo-educated Palestine Arab, leads the main commando organization, Al Fateh. A second leader is former diplomat Ahmed Shukairy, who has represented Syria and Saudi Arabia.
And a third, Georges Habeche, a Palestinian who became a doctor in Lebanon, is on record in summary of the objective: ‘The Palestine Arabs can be mobilized only around the issue of fighting.’ The State Department finds that such leaders as Aarafat, Shukairy and Habeche talk of ‘fighting for 20 or so years.’
They even have training camps for 12-year-old youths, an expanding cadre called Baby Tigers. In effect, the Palestine commandos are moving to take the destiny of the Palestine Arabs out of the hands of the Arab world leaders and into their own.
The result is an important new force, and a very hard one for the United States to influence in that pressure-cooker part of the world.”
An American column in 1969 arguing that the eviction began under the mandate, not in 1948, and that Jews had lived more peacefully in the Arab world than in Christian Europe. It gives the population shift as a pair of percentages.
ABDUL RAHMAN AL-ZAMIL, President, Organization of Arab Students at The University of Southern California
We, the Arab students in universities and colleges in Southern California, are shocked that a man of Congressman Gerald Ford’s stature would make the unfounded accusation that the Arab students in the United States are trained in Red China and are actively involved in campus disorders in America.
We take this matter very seriously and demand that Ford either provide evidence of his accusation or make a public apology to the Arab students. If Congressman Ford is truly concerned about American interests, then he might want to direct his attention to an investigation of the activities of the Zionist organizations in the United States.
These groups have for the past 21 years been actively raising billions of tax-free American dollars under false pretenses of charity while in fact the funds are channeled into Israeli war efforts and territorial expansion into the Arab countries.
The Arab students in the U.S. are primarily engaged in seeking education and acquiring the tools and skills which they will use in contributing to the economic and industrial development of their countries. We have neither the time nor the interest to disrupt the learning process on American campuses.
Israel Hopes to House Negev Bedouins, a People of Space and Sky
By ADA LOUISE HUXTABLE, Special to The New York Times
BEERSHEBA, Israel, May 13—In the Negev wilderness of southern Israel, where the turn of a new road can reveal a scene of black-robed Arabs tending sheep in the barren hills straight out of the Old Testament, the Israeli Government is building a modern village for Bedouins.
About five miles from the Negev city of Beersheba a freshly asphalted road leads to Tel Sheva, a small, permanent settlement for the nomads of the desert. Housing for Bedouins is something like refrigerators for Eskimos, and no one is at all sure if the experiment is going to work.
The Bedouin tribes, moving from one meager grazing spot to another in this landscape of harsh grandeur for thousands of years, have provided literature with some of its most sublime clichés—ships in the desert and Arabs folding their tents and silently stealing away.
Along the road to Tel Sheva, the dark winter tents, still in use in May, cluster in traditional temporary encampments. But even the Bedouins are changing. Nearly half of the 30,000 believed to have been in the Negev before 1948—it is hard to find out who, if anyone, has taken a census of nomads—left after the state of Israel was established.
Of those who remained, some have become near-permanent employes of the new towns the Israelis have established in the south. They go to work daily from their camps, which are untouched by chance. These are the Bedouin “sophisticates.” They are skilled mechanics and good workers, and have advanced to pinup girls and omnipresent radios.
Scene in Tel Sheva, small, modern settlement Israeli Government is building for Bedouins [credit] Micha Bar-am
Date check: DATE AND PAPER CONFIRMED ON THE PAGE. The running head reads “THE NEW YORK TIMES, MONDAY, MAY 19, 1969”, which matches both `pub` and the slide-label date of 1969-05-19 exactly. The dateline reads “BEERSHEBA, Israel, May 13”.
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. (AP) — Some Arab textbooks advocate war on Israel and show contempt for Jews and should be banned for U.N.-operated schools for the children of Palestine refugees, a U.N. agency suggested Sunday. Fourteen of the 127 books used in the schools fell into that category in a survey conducted by the U.N. Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization—UNESCO.
The books are used in schools operated jointly by UNESCO and the U.N. Relief and Works Agency—UNRWA. They are printed in Lebanon, Jordan and Egypt and are used by Arab refugees’ children in Lebanon, Jordan and two Israeli-occupied areas—Jordan’s West Bank and the Gaza Strip in Egypt.
American, French and Turkish experts named by UNESCO read the 127 books and recommended that 48 of them be kept, mended that 48 of them be kept, 14 withdrawn and 65 modified for future use. The UNESCO executive board ordered the study in June and has it on its agenda for consideration in September.
Short AP wire brief, fully transcribed. For the terminology question this is the useful 1969 anchor: a story entirely about Palestinian refugee children in which the word “Palestinian” does not occur, “Palestine” survives only inside the UNRWA term of art, and the people are otherwise “Arab”.
· Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, WA · page S 21
Arab Schoolbooks Advocate War, Anti-Semitism
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. — (AP) — Some Arab textbooks advocate war on Israel and show contempt for Jews and should be banned for U.N.-operated schools for the children of Palestine refugees, an U.N. agency suggested yesterday. Fourteen of the 127 books used in the schools fell into that category in a survey conducted by the U.N.
Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization—UNESCO. They are printed in Lebanon, Jordan and Egypt and are used by Arab refugees' children in Lebanon, Jordan and two Israeli-occupied areas — Jordan's West Bank and the Gaza Strip in Egypt.
American, French and Turkish experts named by UNESCO read the 127 books and recommended that 48 of them be kept, 14 withdrawn and 65 modified for future use.
Some of their findings: —Contemptuous terms such as liar, cheat, usurer and idiot were applied to Jews in some passages. —Some Arabic readers referred to "the duty . . . to liberate Palestine" and some Arabic grammars contained sentences such as: "The Palestine army was created as the vanguard of the Arab armies which are struggling to evict Israel." —Many history textbooks contained "appeals to violence" in their treatment of Palestine. —In some geography books, "the term Israel is never used and is never featured on any map to designate a state entity."
THE THIRD HEADLINE. This is the same Associated Press dispatch as s099_1 and s112_2, and the three desks gave it three different headlines over identical copy:
s099_1 'Arab Textbooks Advocate Waging War with Israel'
s099_2 'Arab Schoolbooks Advocate War, Anti-Semitism' <- this one
s112_2 'UNESCO Would Withdraw 14 Anti-Jewish Textbooks'
The wire itself attributes everything: 'a U.N. agency suggested', 'Some of their findings:', every characterisation inside quotation marks and sourced to a three-man expert panel. None of the three headlines attributes anything. Each converts a finding about 14 of 127 books into a flat statement about 'Arab Textbooks' or 'Arab Schoolbooks' as a class, and two of the three attach the charge of anti-Jewishness or anti-Semitism to a list on which 'the duty . . . to liberate Palestine' is one of four items.
That is Maria's slide-112 note, demonstrated three times on one piece of copy, with one of the three masthead-dated. It is much stronger evidence than any single clipping, because the variable is isolated: the text is constant and only the headline moves.
No Palestinian is quoted; nobody is quoted at all except the expert panel and the Universal Declaration.
· The Times Picayune · New Orleans, LA · page Section One, Page Four
U.N. Agency Suggests Ban of Arab Textbooks
Being Used in Refugee Schools of Unit
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. (AP) — Some Arab textbooks advocate war on Israel and show contempt for Jews and should be banned for U.N.-operated schools for the children of Palestine refugees, a U.N. agency suggested Sunday. Fourteen of the 127 books used in the schools fell into that category in a survey conducted by the U.N.
Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization — UNESCO. The books are used in schools operated jointly by UNESCO and the U.N. Relief and Works Agency—UNRWA. They are printed in Lebanon, Jordan and Egypt and are used by Arab refugees' children in Lebanon, Jordan and two Israeli-occupied areas — Jordan's West Bank and the Gaza Strip in Egypt.
American, French and Turkish experts named by UNESCO read the 127 books and recommended that 48 of them be kept, 14 withdrawn and 65 modified for future use. The UNESCO executive board ordered the study in June and has it on its agenda for consideration in September.
Meanwhile, UNESCO Director-General Rene Maheu said in a report on the study that he had asked Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt and Laurence V. Michelmore, an American who is UNRWA's commissioner-general in Beirut, to comply with its recommendations.
The experts who conducted the study were professors Sevkiye Inalcik of the Ankara Faculty of Letters, Henri Laoust of the College of France in Paris, and R.B. Winder of New York University.
They measured the books against provisions in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights that say education should promote respect for human rights, human development, and "understanding, tolerance and friendship." Some of their findings: —The Iraeli - Arab conflict was implicit in virtually all the textbooks studied," except for a few science or English conversation textbooks." —Contemptuous terms such as liar, cheat, usurer and idiot were applied to Jews in some passages and, as "part of the deplorable language of international anti-Semitism, cannot be tolerated." —Some Arabic readers referred to "the duty . . . to liberate Palestine" and some Arabic grammars contained sentences such as: "The Palestine army was created as the vanguard of the Arab armies which are struggling to evict Israel." —Many history textbooks contained "appeals to violence" in their treatment of Palestine, and some purported "to show that the Arabs, after having been the victims of the Crusaders, the Moslems and the Ottoman despotism, are now the victims of international imperialism and Zionism." —In some geography books, "the term Israel is never used and is never featured on any map to designate a state entity." —Moslem religious textbooks "usually (but not always) emphasize the religious significance of Jerusalem to Christians and Moslems, but make no mention of its symbolic importance to Jews—a regrettable omission." —Some civics textbooks were primarily concerned "with political indoctrination," a subject not "likely to foster the proper intellectual and moral education" of the children entrusted to the U.N.'s charge.
THE FOURTH HEADLINE, and the one that shows the others were choices. Same AP copy, four desks:
s102_1 'U.N. Agency Suggests Ban of Arab Textbooks' (+ deck: 'Being Used in Refugee Schools of Unit') <- this one
s099_1 'Arab Textbooks Advocate Waging War with Israel'
s099_2 'Arab Schoolbooks Advocate War, Anti-Semitism'
s112_2 'UNESCO Would Withdraw 14 Anti-Jewish Textbooks'
The Times-Picayune headline attributes ('U.N. Agency Suggests'), names the actor, and makes no claim in the paper's own voice about what the books are. Three other desks, given the identical paragraphs, wrote headlines that asserted. That is the cleanest possible demonstration that the assertion was editorial and not in the wire: one of the four desks did not make it.
This printing is also the fullest text of the dispatch and should be the one the archive quotes from. Note that even here, the structure of the bulleted list does the work Maria noticed: seven findings in a row, of which one concerns actual slurs against Jews ('liar, cheat, usurer and idiot'), one concerns an omission from Moslem religious textbooks, one concerns 'political indoctrination' in civics books, and one concerns Arabic readers that 'referred to "the duty . . . to liberate Palestine"'. They are set as equivalent items. Nobody in the piece distinguishes between a slur and a political aspiration, and no Arab or Palestinian educator is given a line to make that distinction. The only named people are three European and American professors, a French director-general and an American commissioner-general.
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. (AP) — Some Arab textbooks advocate war on Israel and show contempt for Jews and should be banned for U.N.-operated schools for the children of Palestine refugees, a U.N. agency suggested Sunday. Fourteen of the 127 books used in the schools fell into that category in a survey conducted by the U.N.
Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization — Unesco. The books are used in schools operated jointly by UNESCO and the U.N. Relief and Works Agency—UNRWA. They are printed in Lebanon, Jordan and Egypt and are used by Arab refugees' children in Lebanon, Jordan and two Israeli-occupied areas—Jordan's West Bank and the Gaza Strip in Egypt.
American, French and Turkish experts named by UNESCO read the 127 books and recommended that 48 of them be kept, 14 withdrawn and 65 modified for future use. Ordered Study The UNESCO executive board ordered the study in June and has it on its agenda for consideration in September.
Meanwhile, UNESCO Director-General Rene Maheu said in a report on the study that he had asked Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt and Laurence V. Michelmore, an American who is UNRWA's commissioner-general in Beirut, to comply with its recommendations.
The experts who conducted the study were professors Sevkiye Inalcik of the Ankara Faculty of Letters, Henri Laoust of the College of France in Paris, and R.B. Winder of New York University.
They measured the books against provisions in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights that say education should promote respect for human rights, human development, and "understanding, tolerance and friendship." Findings Noted Some of their findings: —The Israeli-Arab conflict was implicit in virtually all the textbooks studied, "except for a few science or English conversation textbooks." —Contemptuous terms, such as liar, cheat, usurer and idiot were applied to Jews in some passages and, as "part of the deplorable language of international anti-Semitism, cannot be tolerated." —Some Arabic readers referred to "the duty . . . to liberate Palestine" and some Arabic grammars contained sentences such as: "The Palestine army was created as the vanguard of the Arab armies which are struggling to evict Israel." —Many history textbooks contained "appeals to violence" in their treatment of Palestine, and some purported "to show that the Arabs, after having been the victims of the Crusaders, the Moslems and the Ottoman despotism, are now the victims of international imperialism and Zionism." —In some geography books, "the term Israel is never used and is never featured on any map to designate a state entity." —Moslem religious textbooks "usually (but not always) emphasize the religious significance of Jerusalem to Christians and Moslems, but make no mention of its symbolic importance to Jews—a regrettable omission." —Some civics textbooks were primarily concerned "with political indoctrination," a subject not "likely to foster the proper intellectual and moral education" of the children entrusted to the U.N.'s charge.
THE FIFTH HEADLINE — and the kicker is the thing to show Maria. Over the same AP copy as four other papers, the Sarasota desk set:
kicker: 'WAR ADVOCATION' CITED BY U.N.
headline: Banning Of Some Arab Textbooks Urged
The headline is careful — 'Some Arab Textbooks', 'Urged', no actor claimed. The kicker above it is not. 'War advocation' is not a phrase in the dispatch; nobody says it; it is the desk's own coinage, set in quotation marks as if it were a quotation. Quotation marks around a phrase the paper invented is exactly the move worth documenting, because the marks tell the reader someone else said it.
Running tally of what five American desks did with one attributed AP dispatch about 14 of 127 books:
s102_1 'U.N. Agency Suggests Ban of Arab Textbooks' — attributes, asserts nothing
s103_1 'Banning Of Some Arab Textbooks Urged' + kicker "'WAR ADVOCATION' CITED BY U.N."
s099_1 'Arab Textbooks Advocate Waging War with Israel' — asserts, unattributed
s099_2 'Arab Schoolbooks Advocate War, Anti-Semitism' — asserts, unattributed
s112_2 'UNESCO Would Withdraw 14 Anti-Jewish Textbooks' — asserts 'anti-Jewish'
One of five attributed cleanly. That ratio is the finding, and it is worth more than any single clipping.
Agency Says Arab Textbooks Advocate War, Show Contempt
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. (AP) — Some Arab textbooks advocate war on Israel and show contempt for Jews and should be banned for U.S.-operated schools for the children of Palestine refugees, a U.N. agency suggested Sunday. Fourteen of the 127 books used in the schools fell into that category in a survey conducted by the U.N. Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization—UNESCO.
The books are used in schools operated jointly by UNESCO and the U.N. Relief and Works Agency—UNRWA. They are printed in Lebanon, Jordan and Egypt and are used by Arab refugees' children in Lebanon, Jordan and two Israeli - occupied areas — Jordan's West Bank and the Gaza Strip in Egypt.
American, French and Turkish experts named by UNESCO read the 127 books and recommended that 48 of them be kept, 14 withdrawn and 65 modified for future use.
They measured the books against provisions in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights that say education should promote respect for human rights, human development, and "understanding, tolerance and friendship." Some of their findings: —The Israeli-Arab conflict was implicit in virtually all the textbooks studied,"except for a few science or English conversation textbooks." —Contemptuous terms such as liar, cheat, usurer and idiot were applied to Jews in some passages and, as "part of the deplorable language of international anti-Semitism, cannot be tolerated." —Some Arabic readers referred to "the duty . . . to liberate Palestine" and some Arabic grammars contained sentences such as: "The Palestine army was created as the vanguard of the Arab armies which are struggling to evict Israel." —Many history textbooks contained "appeals to violence" in their treatment of Palestine, and some purported "to show that the Arabs, after having been the victims of the Crusaders, the Moslems and the Ottoman despotism, are now the victims of international imperialism and Zionism." —In some geography books, "the term Israel is never used and is never featured on any map to designate a state entity." —Moslem religious textbooks "usually (but not always) emphasize the religious significance of Jerusalem to Christians and Moslems, but make no mention of its symbolic importance to Jews—a regrettable omission." —Some civics textbooks were primarily concerned "with political indoctrination," a subject not "likely to foster the proper intellectual and moral education" of the children entrusted to the U.N.'s charge.
THE SIXTH HEADLINE, and the second of six that attributes: 'Agency Says Arab Textbooks Advocate War, Show Contempt'. Two words — 'Agency Says' — are the whole difference between this headline and s099_1's 'Arab Textbooks Advocate Waging War with Israel'. Identical copy, identical claim, and one desk put the attribution in and the other did not.
Final tally for the AP UNESCO dispatch of 18-19 May 1969 as it appears in this batch — six printings, six headlines:
ATTRIBUTES THE CLAIM (2)
s102_1 The Times-Picayune, New Orleans: 'U.N. Agency Suggests Ban of Arab Textbooks'
s103_2 (labelled Southwest Times Record): 'Agency Says Arab Textbooks Advocate War, Show Contempt'
ASSERTS IT AS FACT (4)
s103_1 (labelled Sarasota Herald Tribune): 'Banning Of Some Arab Textbooks Urged' + kicker "'WAR ADVOCATION' CITED BY U.N."
s099_1 (labelled Seattle P-I, probably Warren Times Mirror): 'Arab Textbooks Advocate Waging War with Israel'
s099_2 Seattle Post-Intelligencer (folio-confirmed): 'Arab Schoolbooks Advocate War, Anti-Semitism'
s112_2 (labelled The Albuquerque Times, probably a Connecticut paper): 'UNESCO Would Withdraw 14 Anti-Jewish Textbooks'
Two of six held the attribution. Four dropped it, and two of those four attached 'anti-Jewish' or 'anti-Semitism' to a list on which 'the duty . . . to liberate Palestine' is one item among seven. That is the answer to Maria's slide-112 question, and it is an answer with a denominator.
GAZA, Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip—Next month children here will hear a sound familiar to youngsters everywhere: School bells ringing out the start of another term. But when—and if—the Arab children return to classes, the'yll find many changes. Their land now is ruled by Israel, not Egypt.
The Gaza Strip—a Manhattan-sized finger of sandy land along the Mediterranean between Israel and the Sinai Peninsula—was overrun by Israel the first day of the war in June. Gaza children may see the same teachers but they'll be supervised by Israeli education officials. There will be many new textbooks, printed by Israel.
Israeli officials say the old textbooks used in Gaza and other Arab lands now occupied by the military victors were filled with propaganda against the Jews and Israel.
An Israeli supervisor and one arithmetic text included this problem: "If there were 10 Israeli soldiers and four were killed by Egyptian forces, how many soldiers were left?" GRAMMAR BOOKS USED in Gaza and in the west bank area (Jordanian territory west of the Jordan River now occupied by Israel) included expressions like these: "The Arabs will not rest until their paradise (Israel) is returned to them." "Our army has routed the enemy." "Holy war is a duty." Yosef Gadish, Israeli education official, said in Jerusalem that "every second textbook in Gaza and the west bank has been rejected as unsuitable." He said texts used in schools run by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) "were no less offensive than those used in Arab government schools." Gadish also maintained that "hate propaganda was found in history, geography and literature books." The Israeli Educational Ministry in Jerusalem is rushing to printers new books to be used in Arab schools next month.
MANY SCHOOLS WERE damaged during the June fighting. They are being repaired or new buildings are being obtained. Israeli education staffs generally have found school supplies to be adequate. In El Arish, one Israeli official said he found "one million pencils, all made in Red China." El Arish, the largest city on the Sinai Peninsula, is about 30 miles west of Gaza.
A major question is whether Arab teachers will co-operate with Israeli authorities. Israeli officials are optimistic, but on the west bank Arab teachers are being urged by the Jordanian government (through radio broadcasts) not to work next month. Israeli offciials say they intend to employ as many former Arab teachers and supervisors as are willing to return.
On this point, Gadish said: "Of course, the teachers must recognize there will be changes. All teaching of the hatred of peoples and destruction of states, including the state of Israel, must be eliminated.
Those teachers who refuse to accept this principle will be asked to leave." SCHOOL NEVER HAS been compulsory in the Gaza Strip, which came "under Egyptian administration" as part of the U.N.-sponsored armistice agreement of 1949 but was not formally annexed by Cairo.
Most of the inhabitants are refugees who fled their homes in Palestine during the fighting that followed the creation of Israel the previous year. They have never been allowed to travel freely into Egypt, even the nearby Sinai Desert.
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — the richest single clipping on it, and the only one in the batch where the censoring authority is named, quoted at length, and states the penalty for refusal. Who is censoring: the Israeli Educational Ministry in Jerusalem, through 'Israeli education officials'; Yosef Gadish is named. What was removed: 'every second textbook in Gaza and the west bank'; grammar-book example sentences ('Holy war is a duty.'); 'hate propaganda … in history, geography and literature books'. Whose voice: mixed, and the mixing matters. The claim that the old books 'were filled with propaganda against the Jews and Israel' is attributed ('Israeli officials say'). But the dateline itself — 'GAZA, Israeli-occupied Gaza Strip' — and the phrase 'other Arab lands now occupied by the military victors' are the reporter's own, and 'the military victors' is an unusually candid formulation for 1967 American copy. Is any Palestinian quoted: NO. Not one. The piece runs on Israeli officials throughout; Arab teachers appear only as a management problem ('A major question is whether Arab teachers will co-operate with Israeli authorities'), and Palestinians appear as 'Most of the inhabitants are refugees who fled their homes in Palestine during the fighting that followed the creation of Israel the previous year.' The Khan Yunish High School for Girls is named at the end as a place where 'there is evidence that even art lessons will change' — the piece appears to continue past the bottom of the clipping under a subhead beginning 'Sci… and Medici…'; that continuation is not in the scan.
Some Arab Textbooks Advocate War On Israel, Contempt Toward Jews
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. (AP) — Some Arab textbooks advocate war on Israel and show contempt for Jews and should be banned for U.S.-operated schools for the children of Palestine refugees, a U.N. agency suggested Sunday. Fourteen of the 127 books used in the schools fell into that category in a survey conducted by the U.N. Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization—UNESCO.
The books are used in schools operated jointly by UNESCO and the U.N. Relief and Works Agency—UNRWA. They are printed in Lebanon, Jordan and Egypt and are used by Arab refugees' children in Lebanon, Jordan and two Israeli-occupied areas — Jordan's West Bank and the Gaza Strip in Egypt.
American, French and Turkish experts named by UNESCO read the 127 books and recommended that 48 of them be kept, 14 withdrawn and 65 modified for future use. The UNESCO executive board ordered the study in June and has it on its agenda for consideration in September.
Report On Studies Meanwhile, UNESCO Director General Rene Maheu said in a report on the study that he had asked Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt and Laurence V. Michelmore, an American who is UNRWA's commissioner-general in Beirut, to comply with its recommendations.
The experts who conducted the study were professors Sevkiye Inalcik of the Ankara Faculty of Letters, Henri Laoust of the College of France in Paris, and R.B. Winder of New York University.
They measured the books against provisions in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights that say education should promote respect for human rights, human development, and "understanding, tolerance and friendship." —The Israeli-Arab conflict was implicit in virtually all the textbooks studied,"except for a few science or English conversation textbooks." —Contemptuous terms such as liar, cheat, usurer and idiot were applied to Jews in some passages and, as "part of the deplorabel language of international anti-Semitism, cannot be tolerated." —Some Arabic readers referred to "the duty . . . to liberate Palestine" and some Arabic grammars contained sentences such as: "The Palestine army was created as the vanguard of the Arab armies which are struggling to evict Israel." —Many history textbooks contained "appeals to violence" in their treamtent of Palestine, and some purported "to show that the Arabs, after having been the victims of the Crusaders, the Moslems and the Ottoman despotism, are now the victims of international imperialism and Zionism." —In some geography books, "the term Israel is never used and is never featured on any map to designate a state entity." —Moslem religious textbooks "usually (but not always) emphasize the religious significance of Jerusalem to Christians and Moslems, but make no mention of its symbolic importance to Jews—a regrettable omission." —Some civics textbooks were primarily concerned "with political indoctrination," a subject not "likely to foster the proper intellectual and moral education" of the children entrusted to the U.N.'s charge.
THE EIGHTH HEADLINE, and the completion of the set. The Lexington desk wrote a two-line headline that simply restates the wire's lede: 'Some Arab Textbooks Advocate War On Israel, Contempt Toward Jews'. It keeps 'Some' and it keeps both charges in the wire's own order — but it drops the attribution ('a U.N. agency suggested') that the lede carries, so it still asserts in the paper's own voice.
THE COMPLETE HEADLINE SET for the AP UNESCO dispatch of 18-19 May 1969, eight printings found in this batch:
ATTRIBUTES THE CLAIM (2 of 8)
s102_1 The Times-Picayune, New Orleans — 'U.N. Agency Suggests Ban of Arab Textbooks' + deck 'Being Used in Refugee Schools of Unit'
s103_2 (labelled Southwest Times Record) — 'Agency Says Arab Textbooks Advocate War, Show Contempt'
ASSERTS IT (6 of 8)
s113_1 Lexington, Ky. — 'Some Arab Textbooks Advocate War On Israel, Contempt Toward Jews' <- this one
s103_1 (labelled Sarasota Herald Tribune) — 'Banning Of Some Arab Textbooks Urged' + kicker "'WAR ADVOCATION' CITED BY U.N."
s099_1 (labelled Seattle P-I) — 'Arab Textbooks Advocate Waging War with Israel'
s099_2 Seattle Post-Intelligencer — 'Arab Schoolbooks Advocate War, Anti-Semitism'
s108_1 (labelled The Plain Dealer) — "'Some Arab Books Unkind to Jews'"
s112_2 (labelled The Albuquerque Times) — 'UNESCO Would Withdraw 14 Anti-Jewish Textbooks'
One dispatch, eight desks, eight different headlines. Two held the attribution; six dropped it. Two — s099_2 and s112_2 — attached anti-Semitism or anti-Jewishness to a bulleted list on which 'the duty . . . to liberate Palestine' is one item among seven, the others being slurs against Jews, an omission from Moslem religious books, 'political indoctrination' in civics books, the absence of Israel from maps, and an Arab account of Arab history. That fusion is what Maria read on slide 112, and this batch now documents it eight times over on identical copy, with the denominator attached.
UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. (AP) — A U.N. agency has recommended that 14 Arab textbooks be banned from U.N.-administered schools in the Middle East because they advocate war on Israel and show contempt for Jews. The books were among 127 rated by a team of American, French and Turkish educators in a survey conducted by the U.N.
Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO). A report on the study was released Sunday. The 127 books are printed in Lebanon, Jordan and Egypt and are used by children of Arab refugees from Palestine in schools in Lebanon, Jordan and two Israeli-occupied areas—the west bank of the Jordan River and the Gaza Strip.
The report recommended that 48 of the books be retained, 14 withdrawn and 65 modified for future use. It said some of the books referred to Jews as liars, cheats, usurers and idiots, and that some contained “appeals to violence” and referred to “the duty . . . to liberate Palestine.”
HAMBURG, Germany (UPI) — Arabs, Jews and West Germans fought with fists, clubs and other weapons in Frankfurt and Hamburg Universities Wednesday night… There also was loud applause as placards hoisted on the platform by leftists were torn from their bearers.
The placards bore such slogans as “Zionism is racism,” “for the victory of the Palestinian revolution,” and “Zionism must go.” Then there was a mad scramble to get to the microphone by members of leftist so-called “extra-parliamentary opposition” and supporters of the El Fatah Palestinian freedom movement… Most kept quiet as the questions and answers flew but there still were shouts of “El Fatah.”
These were gradually drowned out however by applause for the ambassador. The meeting broke up with no more fighting.
The second American printing of the Hamburg placards, the same day, under a headline that turns a riot into a debate. Both papers kept the slogans. It runs above a bank robbery in Venezuela and a ruling that kept Coleman Young off the ballot for mayor of Detroit.
HAMBURG, West Germany (UPI) — Arabs, Jews and West Germans fought with fists, clubs and other weapons in Frankfurt and Hamburg universities Wednesday night. In Hamburg, Israeli ambassador Asher Ben Nathan was prevented from making a speech for the second time in three days by pro-Arab leftist students shouting “El Fatah . . .
El Fatah.”… When the ambassador entered the discussion hall at Hamburg University he was greeted by a minutes-long chorus of whistles and shouts. The hall was packed with about 2,500 students and newsmen… There also was loud applause as placards hoisted on the platform by leftists were torn from their bearers.
The placards bore such slogans as “Zionism is racism,” “For the victory of the Palestinian revolution,” and “Zionism must go.” Then there was a mad scramble to get to the microphone… Some Arab students produced clubs and a UPI reporter saw at least one switch-blade knife appear in the hand of an Arab, before fellow Arabs took it away from him.
For an hour, Ben Nathan tried to begin his speech. Eventually, he agreed to skip his speech and discuss the Mideast question with the leftists… The meeting broke up with no more fighting.
The exact phrase, printed on a placard, six and a half years before the General Assembly voted. A wire reporter counted the signs in a lecture hall in Hamburg. Six years later the Boston Globe would photograph a demonstration in New York where a placard read anti-Zionism code word for anti-Semitism.
Arabs Protest Security Step at Village Near Hebron
By JAMES FERON
JERUSALEM, June 21 — The Israeli authorities have requisitioned 300 acres of Arab-owned land near Kfar Etzion, an Israeli settlement in the occupied West Bank area, and have given about 100 people living there a week to leave.
The order, issued last Monday, has caused dismay in the Hebron region and confirmed some Arab fears that the Israelis are embarked on an expansion of the Etzion settlement or on building a new one. The mayor of Hebron, Sheik Mohammed Ali Jaabari, said he had sent a message to Mrs. Golda Meir, the Israeli Premier, begging her to rescind the order.
Arab notables met with military government authorities seeking its cancellation, but the response was apparently negative. Some observers believe that the Israelis may use the land to establish a nahal, or paramilitary settlement, largely as protection for the Etzion settlers.
They have not been attacked, but a military source said that there has been an increasing number of sabotage and terrorist incidents in the northern Hebron region. He said the requisitioned land was needed for security. Government officials suggested that an army base would be established there but that it would not be a nahal.
Israeli and Arab sources agree that the land is Arab-owned. Sheik Jaabari said it had been in Arab hands for centuries. An Israeli source said that most of the houses belonged to residents of the nearby village of Irtech and that they had others in the village itself. He added that the Arab owners were being compensated.
Kfar Etzion was established shortly after the Israeli victory in the six-day 1967 war on one of the sites of four settlements overrun by Jordanian forces in the 1948 war. The settlements, known as the Etzion Bloc, were destroyed by the Jordanians, and many inhabitants were slaughtered.
In 1967 the Israeli Government came under strong pressure to permit settlers, including children of the original Etzion Bloc farmers, to return to the area. Bowing to strong pressure, the Government, under the late Premier Levi Eshkol, permitted the re-establishment of the Etzion name in the region.
The move caused furor in the Arab world, where fears of Israeli territorial expansion were seemingly confirmed. Israelis who opposed acquisition of territories taken in the six-day war also objected.
NEW YORK — (Special) — Propaganda designed to win sympathy for the Arab cause and to spread hostility to Israel has been stepped up in tempo and volume and is becoming increasingly professionalized, a new report by the American Jewish Committee has disclosed.
The 24-page report, “Arab Appeals to American Public Opinion Today,” indicates that since the Six Day War in June, 1967, the Arab propaganda effort has replaced its “clumsy unselective approaches of yesteryear ... by more sophisticated techniques aimed at particular audiences — such as church groups, the student left, or the disaffected blacks.”
A major focus of the Arab effort, the report continues, has been in churches, where Arabs and their supporters have employed both anti-Zionism and religious anti-Semitism to sway attitudes of American churches toward Israel. In this effort, the survey declares, “substantial headway has been made, especially among Protestant leaders.”
Many welfare groups to alleviate the plight of Arab refugees have been established or reactivated, the survey points out. In some of them, “humanitarian aims ... seem to be accompanied by ill will or propagandistic intent toward Israel,” the report states.
Another major Arab effort, the survey states, is being made in establishing ties with the Black Muslim movement and with other black extremists.
Here the word arrives at its widest reach. Church congregations, student groups, Black organizations and refugee relief charities are all described as fronts or targets, and humanitarian aid for Palestinian refugees is set down as something that seems to be accompanied by ill will or propagandistic intent. Once relief itself is a delivery system, there is no form the speech can take that clears the bar.
“Anti-Semitism would be only academic in Germany these days for there are only some 20,000 Jews in the country. There have been instances of Swastikas daubed on synagogues or Jewish gravestones but there always is a crackpot fringe and those caught receive stiff penalties. Most of the Jews are in Berlin, Frankfurt, Hamburg and Munich.
They are thriving especially in Frankfurt where Germans go out of their way to accommodate them. There is little public criticism of Jews or Israel except by extreme leftwing students who adopt the pro-Arab Communist line that ‘Zionism is racism.’”
By August 1969 an American paper can set the phrase in quotation marks and give it a political address without explaining it to the reader. It is already a known slogan with a known owner. Six years before the General Assembly votes.
Rabat — An absent President Nasser dominated the opening ceremony of the first Islamic Summit Conference with a message from his sickbed calling on all Moslem states to back the Arabs against “zionism and racism backed by imperialism.” The message Monday was read to representatives of 25 Islamic states by Anwar Sadat, the Egyptian leader’s personal representative.
Sadat said that the fire at the Al Aksa Mosque was premeditated and was one aspect of “the threat to all free peoples.”
News raced through the hall as the participants were gathering that Yasir Arafat, chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization and head of the Fatah commandos, had arrived… A member of Fatah said he had received a personal invitation from King Hassan after the PLO had intimated that it would publicize the fact that no representative of the Palestinian people had been invited… While Syria said it would not attend because it had no diplomatic relations with Morocco, Iraq at the last minute sent word it had sent no representative because the organizers could not guarantee to give the Palestine Liberation Organization an opportunity to present its fighting program.
Alluding to the “catastrophy” of the Al Aksa fire, King Hassan called on Moslems everywhere to “expunge this shame” by unified action. No Moslem, he asserted, could forget “our brethren suffering in tents” — the Palestinian refugees.
A head of state pairs the two words at the first Islamic Summit, six years before the vote, and an American paper prints it with a lower-case z. The summit was called after the Al Aqsa fire of August 1969. Iraq stayed away because the organizers would not promise the PLO a hearing.
NICOSIA, Cyprus (AP) — A conference of the World Council of Churches has called for “a redress of the injustice done to Palestinian refugees” and pledged to boost the council’s refugee aid programs to $2 million over the next two years.
The decisions were taken by 100 archbisrops, other high church officials and laymen at a meeting here called to discuss the Palestinian refugee problem. The delegates were from the Middle East, Europe, America and Australia.
An official statement issued at the end of the conference said the delegates agreed “to call upon the World Council of Churches to ask its member organizations to provide funds for new programs over the next two years, in support of self respect and the individual dignity of Palestinian refugees and displaced persons.”
The statement added: “Besides relief and rehabilitation programs, there must also be a response to the aspiration for self determination and nationhood of Palestinians.”
“The Palestine Arabs WHEN Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser gets his name in the world’s papers on the side of peace, this wily coercer stands as the hero in cooling the cauldron in the so-called Lebanon dispute. The causes of the crisis are a fascinating lesson in the Middle East situation, in which we have such a stake.
And the probable results of Nasser’s intervention are something like the man who fell off the Empire State Building and said to a window-washer as he passed him, ‘So far so good.’ Israel was founded on April, 15, 1948. This U.S.-supported act alone made 100 million Arabs pale with fury.
Throughout all history the Jews have always been outnumbered, and the continuing Middle East war still comes down to 11 million Arabs against 3 million Jews.
Commando Units Lebanon is in the forefront of the armed attacks against Israel—but not officially. The task is chiefly in the hands of the Palestine commandos or fedayeen. The main commando organization, Al Fatah, is led by fanatical Yasir Arafat, a Cairo-educated Palestine Arab, with whom Nasser made his deal which is now in the news.
The second leader is former diplomat Ahem Shukairy, who has represented Syria and Saudi Arabia. The third chief is George Habache, a Palestinian who became a doctor in Lebanon. If all this news mystifies us it is probably because we fail to distinguish the Palestine Arabs from the other Arabs in the Arab world. Accordingly, who are the Palestine Arabs?
As a booty of World War I, Britain seized Palestine under the Balfour Declaration, obtained a League of Nations mandate, and set up shop to enhance Britain’s commercial and strategic interests—thereby violating every pledge Britain had given the Arabs in order to gain their help against the Turks in World War I.
It was then that the true influx of European Jews and the eviction of the Palestine Arabs began. In this development, and with the founding of Israel, the Palestine Arab evictees now total about 2½ million, many more than generally supposed. In the 1948 Palestine war, Israel took about 3,000 square miles more territory than the United Nations resolution of Nov.
29, 1947, gave her. About a million of today’s evicted Arab refugees date from that time — 21 years ago.
In Refugee Camps The largest number of Palestine Arabs, living mostly in refugee camps, are in the former territories of Jordan, the Gaza Strip and the west bank of the Jordan River and in what remains of Jordan itself. But there are also large and violently resentful groups in Lebanon, Syria and throughout the oil sheikdoms of the Persian Gulf.
Throughout all these years these fragmented people have had no political life. Fanatical Yasir Arafat and his Al Fatah commandos are mainly a political instrument dedicated to uniting the far-flung Palestine Arabs.
Arafat himself once summarized the Al Fatah objective to me: ‘The Palestine Arabs,’ he said, ‘can be mobilized only around the issue of fighting.’ He sounded as if he’d been taking a course in ‘How to Talk Like James Cagney Telling the Mob What’s What.’
In effect, this group is moving to take the destiny of the Palestine Arabs out of the hands of the Arab world leaders and into their own. The result is an important new force in the dynamite-loaded Middle East, and a very hard one for the United States to influence.
The group reasons that its guerrilla warfare is the first and best step in forcing Israel to evacuate the Egyptian, Jordanian, Syrian and other outside lands Israel has held since the 1967 war. But they have also run wild inside their Lebanon base, have fought a recent bloody battle with Maj. Gen.
Emile Bustani’s (American-equipped) Lebanese army, an threatened the existence of Lebanon’s pro-Nasser government itself. Nasser’s intervention and the Lebanon truce he made with Yasir Arafat in Cairo was totally self-serving. His aim in his pressure-cooker part of the world is the ultimate military defeat of Israel.
And for this objective Nasser needs such disunity in the Arab ranks as the Lebanon explosion about as much as the Sahara needs more sand.”
A syndicated columnist setting out to answer his own question — who are the Palestine Arabs? — for American readers in 1969, and answering it with the word eviction. He writes that Britain seized Palestine as booty, violating every pledge it had given the Arabs, and that the evictees now number about two and a half million. He also records that Israel took about 3,000 square miles more than the partition resolution gave it. Then he quotes Arafat from his own interview, accurately, and compares him to James Cagney.
PARIS, Nov. 3—A compromise resolution, unanimously adopted today by the 30-member executive board of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, smoothed over a dispute about Israeli censorship of textbooks in schools for Arab refugee children. It agreed that the 55,000 pupils were entitled to an Arab education, free of hate propaganda.
But the organization left to the mediation of United Nations officials and the local authorities the question of how recent Middle Eastern history should be taught.
SCHOOLBOOKS THREAD — short, but the single most useful sentence in the batch for the vocabulary question, because of who is saying it. 'Israeli censorship of textbooks in schools for Arab refugee children' — that phrase is in the paper's own voice, in the lede, unattributed, unhedged. Not 'alleged censorship', not 'what Arab states call censorship', not 'the screening of textbooks'. Censorship. Every other clipping in this thread reports the same programme using the censoring authority's own vocabulary — 'editing', 'decontaminating', 'expurgation', 'clearing', 'book surgery', 'eliminating anti-Jewish material'. This one names it. It is also the only item in the thread in which the Palestinian side wins anything, however thin: the board 'agreed that the 55,000 pupils were entitled to an Arab education, free of hate propaganda' — and then 'left to the mediation of United Nations officials and the local authorities the question of how recent Middle Eastern history should be taught', which is to say it settled nothing about the thing actually in dispute.
No Palestinian is quoted; nobody is quoted at all. The word 'Palestinian' does not appear — the children are 'Arab refugee children' and the education they are entitled to is 'an Arab education'.
When Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser gets his name in the world's papers on the side of peace, this will do for openers, as old-time poker players say. Yet this wily coercer stands as the hero in cooling the caldron in the so-called Lebanon dispute. The causes of the crisis are a fascinating lesson in the Middle East situation, in which we have such a stake.
And the probable results of Nasser's intervention are something like the man who fell off the top of the Empire State Building and said to a first-floor resident as he passed him, "So far so good." Israel was founded on April 15, 1948. This U.S.-supported act alone made 100 million Arabs pale with fury.
Throughout all history the Jews have always been outnumbered, and the continuing Middle East war still comes down to 11 million Arabs against 3 million Jews. Lebanon is in the forefront of the armed attacks against Israel—but not officially. The task is chiefly in the hands of the Palestine commandos or fedayeen.
The main commando organization, Al Fatah, is led by fanatical Yasir Arafat, a Cairo-educated Palestine Arab, with whom Nasser made his deal which is now in the news. The second leader is former diplomat Ahem Shukairy, who has represented Syria and Saudi Arabia. The third chief is George Habache, a Palestinian who became a doctor in Lebanon.
If all this news mystifies us it is probably because we fail to distinguish the Palestine Arabs from the other Arabs in the Arab world. Accordingly, who are the Palestine Arabs?
As a booty of World War I Britain seized Palestine under the Balfour Declaration, obtained a League of Nations mandate, and set up shop to enhance Britain's commercial and strategic interests — thereby violating every pledge Britain had given the Arabs in order to gain their help against the Turks in World War I.
It was then that the true influx of European Jews and the eviction of the Palestine Arabs began. In this development, and with the founding of Israel, the Palestine Arab evictees now total about 2½ million, many more than generally supposed.
In the 1948 Palestine war Israel took about 3,000 square miles more territory than the United Nations resolution of November 29, 1947, gave her. About a million of today's evicted Arab refugees date from that time — 21 years ago.
The largest number of Palestine Arabs, living mostly in refugee camps, are in the former territories of Jordan, the Gaza Strip and the west bank of the Jordan River and in what remains of Jordan itself. But there are also large and violently resentful groups in Lebanon, Syria and throughout the oil sheikdoms of the Persian Gulf.
Throughout all these years these fragmented people have had no political life. Fanatical Yasir Arafat and his Al Fatah commandos are mainly a political instrument dedicated to uniting the far-flung Palestine Arabs.
Arafat himself once summarized the Al Fatah objective to me: "The Palestine Arabs," he said, "can be mobilized only around the issue of fighting." He sounded like he'd been taking a course in "How To Talk Like James Cagney Telling The Mob What's What." In effect, this group is moving to take the Palestine Arabs out of the hands of the Arab world leaders and into their own.
The result is an important new force in the dynamite-loaded Middle East, and a very hard one for the United States to influence. The group reasons that its guerrilla warfare is the first and last step in forcing Israel to evacuate the Egyptian, Jordanian, Syrian and other outside lands Israel has held since the six-day 1967 war.
But they have also run wild inside their Lebanon base, have fought a recent bloody battle with Maj. Gen. Emile Bustani's (American-equipped) Lebanese army, and threatened the existence of Lebanon's pro-Nasser government itself. Nasser's intervention and the Lebanon truce he made with Yasir Arafat in Cairo was totally self-serving.
His aim in this pressure-cooker part of the world is the ultimate military defeat of Israel. And for this objective Nasser needs such disunity in the Arab ranks as the Lebanon explosion about as much as the Sahara Desert needs more sand.
THE SECOND HEADLINE ON ONE COLUMN. Identical copy, two desks:
s098_2: 'Nasser Hero of Lebanese Truce, But That Isn't the Whole Story'
s100_1: "'Peacemaker' Nasser Seeks Israel's Defeat" <- this one
The first headline reports Taylor's hedge; the second reports his conclusion and puts 'Peacemaker' in sneer quotes. Same mechanism as the three-headline AP set on slides 99 and 112, this time on an opinion column, where the desk is at least headlining an argument rather than a news report.
This printing carries the column complete, including the closing paragraphs that s098_2's scan cuts short — the guerrillas' reasoning ('the first and last step in forcing Israel to evacuate the Egyptian, Jordanian, Syrian and other outside lands Israel has held since the six-day 1967 war'), the Bustani battle, and the Sahara line. So this is the better text of the two.
The content is as described at s098_2: an unusually blunt account of dispossession ('the eviction of the Palestine Arabs', 'Palestine Arab evictees', 'evicted Arab refugees', Britain 'violating every pledge') set inside a column that calls Arafat 'fanatical' twice and Palestinians 'these fragmented people' who 'have had no political life'. The history is granted; the politics is denied. No Palestinian is quoted except Arafat, in one sentence, answered with a joke.
By C. L. SULZBERGER / (C) New York Times News Service
PARIS—"Vietnam" has been the codeword for the formidable array of troubles that has weakened the United States during the last five years. "Palestine" may be the codeword symbolizing other agonies during the next five.
Like crystals, political societies contain hidden lines of fracture which, if discerned by a revolutionary expert who presses a wedge along their axes, can produce a shivering effect. Such political diamond-splitting was effectively accomplished along class lines when Lenin destroyed old Russia's dilapidated system. Class lines of fractures do not exist in all societies.
For example, neither in underdeveloped black Africa nor in overdeveloped America are there such horizontal, if hidden, layers. The lines of possible fracture are instead vertical: In Africa, tribe and superstition and in the United States, race and religion.
Those who would fragment U.S. society can hardly attempt this along class lines because every American either is, was or aspires to be a capitalist.
But verical lines are more dangerous because, regardless of common nationality and common economic goal, Americans still differ sufficiently in racial and religious antecedents so that they can be aroused against each other during times of acute tension.
Analyses of recent American elections dealt with the black vote or the Puerto Rican, Irish, Jewish or Italian vote much as they argued about the Catholic vote nine years earlier. This wide diversity is, of course, the obvious result of a melting pot society whose varied ingredients make it especially vital when everything bubbles happily under normal conditions.
However, when the temperature reaches boiling point, diversity can make for less happiness. This has been underscored during the bewildering Vietnam war, which coincides with a sharp rise in the expression of Negro discontent.
"Vietnam" as a codeword therefore came to symbolize not only a tragic new kind of war but race tension and urban problems, all of which have been leavened by the yeast of what is called the new left. "Vietnam," furthermore, stands for both internal confrontation between discontented Americans and external confrontation with our most dangerous adversaries, Russia and China.
When, as now seems more and more likely, "Palestine" develops as a codeword, similar internal and external confrontations can be anticipated. Bipartisan U.S. policy supports Israel with economic, military and diplomatic aid. But the conflict continues to fester, enhancing the possibility of a potential showdown with the U.S.S.R., which is committed to help Israel's enemies.
Now the Fedayeen, of Palestine Arab guerrillas, have become a dynamic force inside Jordan, Syria and Lebanon. China has been pro-Fedayeen all along while Russia ignored the movement. But there are hints that Moscow hopes to make up for lost time.
It is a good guess that if the guerrillas ever proclaim an Arab "Palestine government in exile" it will be recognized by the Kremlin.
Fedayeen propaganda stresses the word "Palestine" and insists the conflict is a "Palestine war" and not an "Arab-Israeli war." A new Paris magazine called Africasia emphasizes the Fedayeen cause and, it may be noted, the publication is heavily supported by Algerian governmental advertisements.
The new "Palestine" propaganda thrust aims savage barbs at the United States, Israel's primary backer, and deliberately seeks new left support. Also, it may be no accident that Africasia's second target is apparently the CIA, another common codeword familiar to opponents of the U.S. system.
AN OP-ED COLUMN, and the one clipping in the batch that is explicitly ABOUT the word Palestine rather than about events in it. Sulzberger's thesis is that 'Palestine' is becoming a codeword in American politics the way 'Vietnam' did — a term that fuses an external confrontation with the Soviet Union to an internal one among Americans divided by 'race and religion'. He is not reporting a claim that talking about liberating Palestine is anti-Jewish; he is doing something adjacent and, for Maria's purposes, more interesting. He treats Palestinian self-naming as itself a propaganda operation: 'Fedayeen propaganda stresses the word "Palestine" and insists the conflict is a "Palestine war" and not an "Arab-Israeli war."' The insistence on the name is the evidence of the propaganda. Every use of the word in the column is inside quotation marks.
So the column records, in 1969 and in a New York Times News Service column syndicated to small American dailies, the exact moment the term was contested — and comes down on the side of treating it as a Soviet- and Chinese-adjacent slogan rather than a description. Note also the frame he builds around it: Palestine as a wedge to 'fragment U.S. society' along lines of 'racial and religious antecedents', with American Jews and the new left named as the two poles. That is one step from the argument Maria flagged, and it is in a column, not a news story.
No Palestinian is quoted. No Palestinian is named. The only actors are Moscow, Peking, Algiers, the Kremlin, the CIA, the new left and 'the Fedayeen'.
TERMINOLOGY: 'Palestine Arab guerrillas', 'the Fedayeen', 'an Arab "Palestine government in exile"'. The word 'Palestinian' does not appear once.
“But those who still oppose genocide — and more particularly the Jewish left-wing intellectuals — had better have another look at what is happening in the Middle East.” And at the close: “if we are not ready to tolerate genocide in Israel (pray God!), the United States may have to face another very grave Cold War problem in the Middle East.”
The control for this entire section. A nationally syndicated columnist, in a mainstream paper, using the word bare in the headline and twice in the copy. No quotation marks, no attribution, no hedge. The victims he has in mind are Israeli.
Tension Grips Gaza Strip After Killing and Reprisal
By JAMES FERON
GAZA, Nov. 18—A few miles north of the occupied Gaza Strip, at the last major Israeli intersection, soldiers stand hitching rides to their posts in the sector. A highway sign reads “Road Closed.” The road is not closed, however. The sign is simply a device to discourage casual visitors. Once inside the Gaza Strip, it is not hard to see why.
At the checkpoint, an Israeli soldier asks the visitor where he is going and why. Finally convinced that it is a matter of official business, the soldier says “O.K.” But he indicates that he is coming along, for the visitor’s protection. As he gets in he rolls up the side window and signals to the driver to do the same as a precaution against grenades.
“It is not good times,’ the soldier says. An afternoon in Gaza town offers additional evidence to support the soldier’s assessment. The main street is deserted, with all the shops’ shutters pulled down. The nearby market also is empty. An Israeli half-track sits in the main square, another in the market.
The areas are under curfew, imposed as punishment because residents have refused to come forward with information about terrorist incidents. Traffic moves freely through the streets, but shopkeepers who were assumed to have seen the men who threw grenades at Israeli patrols are prevented from doing business.
In addition, there is a night curfew, from 8 P.M. to 4 A.M., which prohibits all movement and is tightly enforced by the occupation authorities. Last night, in Rafah, a town in the Gaza Strip, two residents were killed by Israeli soldiers for being on the street at 10:30 P.M.
Israeli Arabs Caught In Vise Of Explosive Middle East
Ronald Thomson
“Israel’s 320,000 Arab citizens are being caught up in a cruel conflict of loyalties — one that spells a special brand of trouble in the endless torment of the… ‘I had always hoped to visit my family in Jordan, and suddenly that became possible after the six-day war. But I found something strange.
I went to these relatives as a citizen of Israel, including Israeli citizens… The reception they gave me was frigid. I was treated almost as a traitor and told I had sold my soul to Satan. I don’t go there any more.’”
A long 1969 feature on Palestinian citizens of Israel, quoting one of them on being treated as a traitor by his own relatives across the river. It records that only two of Israel’s 200 judges are Arabs, and that Archbishop Joseph Raya of the Greek Catholic church in Galilee says social contact is minimal and Jewish residents live in upper Nazareth, the Arabs in lower Nazareth.
In Israel, the girls wear miniskirts and you eat chicken to your heart’s content. The wine is good and the movies first-run. In Egypt, hotel balconies overlook the Nile, the selection of meats is varied, you can gamble at a casino and the Cairo airport is a hub of traffic for Africa, Asia and Europe.
Sandwiched between the two is the Gaza Strip, a prison for 270,000 human beings. They are the victims of world politics. For more than 20 years, in the refugee camps the United Nations administers on the Gaza Strip, the people have waited for someone to do something. Egypt champions their cause in words. And Israel says it’s a pity the Egyptians don’t do more for them.
These are the people who fled when Palestine was carved into Israel and Jordan in 1948. They are the Arabs who found their land within Israeli territory. Many of them say they were forced out by the Israelis in a reign of terror. And the Israelis say they fled despite Israel’s good intentions. There are other refugee camps like this.
One sits just west of Amman, Jordan, on a dusty plain between the mountains. There used to be another camp in Jordan called Karameh. Palestinian refugees settled there in 1952 just across the Jordan River from Israel and Israel claims it was a jumping off point for terrorist attacks on its land.
Karameh was wiped out in a battle on March 21, 1968, 10 months after the Six-Day War ceasefire agreement. The casualties ran heavy on both sides and each military force claimed some measure of victory. Men, women and children were killed and a city leveled. The Israelis have had their share, too.
In a kibbutz called Neve Ur, which fronts the Jordan River south of the Sea of Galilee, the children don’t sleep with their parents. When darkness falls, the children are taken to a bomb shelter for the evening. Jordanian artillery attacks made it necessary.
In Bet She’an, an Israeli town at the top of what they call the Jordan Valley Hot Line, bomb shelters are dug in the front yard of every private home. Larger ones are built near apartment houses and schools. Although the city has been shelled only twice this year, they brace for more. To north is a kibbutz just below the Golan Heights.
When Syria still had control of the Heights, the people of Gadot were sitting ducks for artillery shells. “In April, 1967,” says Eytan Sat, secretary of the kibbutz, “just about every building was damaged. “The government wanted us to build bomb shelters. But we decided the Syrians were not going to force us to live underground like animals.”
Jabalia is one of eight crowded Arab refugee camps in the Gaza Strip
“Jabalia is one of eight crowded Arab refugee camps in the Gaza Strip. Within its boundaries live 33,000 persons in a bleak, day-to-day existence aggravated by the tension and hostility of the country they now call home.
What help these Arabs receive is generally given to them by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA), whose work is limited by the succession of terror incidents and security measures in the region.”
“UNDER THE WATCHFUL EYES of an Israeli soldier, Arab women hurry by with bags of cotton on their heads. Terrorists continue to plague the area and relief services have been irregular because of various hostilities and demonstrations.” “CHILDREN PLAY in the shadow of a demolished Gaza Strip building.
Schools were reopened recently after being shut down for two months following anti-Israeli demonstrations.” “GAZA STRIP is a tense, occupied land. Seated in their jeep, Israeli soldiers watch as inhabitants go about their daily existence.” “YOUNGSTER licks the spoon while eating his daily ration of beans and peas at a mess hall in the Jabalia refugee camp.”
“HAPPY DAY arrives when Jabalia refugees collect monthly supplies from the United Nations distribution center.”
Five photographs and a standfirst. The same page calls the Gaza Strip “a tense, occupied land” and says terrorists continue to plague the area.
By DANA ADAMS SCHMIDT, Special to The New York Times
BEIRUT, Lebanon, Dec. 2—In spite of intervention by Dr. René Maheu of France, director of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, Arabs and Israelis have reached an impasse over the textbooks to be used in United Nations Relief and Works Agency schools in the occupied territory on the west bank of the Jordan and in the Gaza Strip.
As a result of the dispute, Palestinian schoolchildren in the camps operated by the United Nations agency are faced with an acute shortage of books. The Israelis have banned 127 titles—two-thirds of the texts previously used in the west bank and all but eight in the Gaza Strip. When Dr.
Maheu visited Israel in August the Israelis agreed in principle to introduce texts approved by a UNESCO commission of experts if the Arabs would withdraw the texts that the commission designated as offensive. In Jordan, Dr. Maheu found the Arabs willing to discuss the texts that the commission had said should be withdrawn or amended.
They told him that they would see about withdrawing offensive texts when the Israelis issued import licenses and permitted use of the texts that the commission had found inoffensive. In fact nothing has happened.
The Israelis are waiting for the Arabs to move, the Arabs are waiting for the Israelis to move and the Palestinian refugee children and the United Nations groups are caught in the middle. Expurgated Versions Planned The dispute goes back to the weeks following the June, 1967, war.
The Israelis complained to the United Nations relief agency about textbooks being used in the refugee camps, and they banned 127 titles.
KARAMEH, Jordan (NANA)— [first word cut off by the scan] you come down here to the bottom of the world, just north [of] the Dead Sea and three kilometers from where the Israelis stand on the hills above the Jordan River, you can still see Israeli tank-treads grooved into the tar of Karameh’s main street.
A year and a half ago, 50,000 Palestinians were living in this once-thriving agricultural community. Now Karameh is a mangled shell of a town, a maze of bullet-pocked concrete, dynamited houses and twisted metal, all sitting silently under the summer sun. The villagers have fled northeast into the highlands.
Karameh is symbolic of how the military war continues in the Middle-East, especially on Israel’s Eastern Front. The town was a base area for small-scale guerrilla strikes against the Israeli-occupied West Bank of the Jordan River until March 21, 1968. On that day, fed up with the terrorism originating from here, the Israelis moved in and cleared this base once and for all.
Their operation was a military success in terms of its specific objective: Karameh was destroyed and there are no more raids being staged from here. On the other hand, the 15,000 Israeli troops suffered staggering losses in both men and materiel, and Karameh has since become the Arab “Alamo.”
Not only was it proven that the Israeli army was not invincible, Palestinians now say, but it was here in the Battle of Karameh that serious partisan warfare against the enemy can mark it’s birth.
Even though it was the regular Jordanian army which bore the brunt of Karameh’s defense, the fedayeen are the toast of Arab militants and a force no Arab conservative can afford to ignore.
Thus, Israel’s devilish military problem with the Arab “War of Attrition”: Each time they score another military success—and they have scored plenty since the Six-Day War—Arab stubbornness, intransigence and resistance only increases. But as the winter of 1969 begins, Israeli is still clearly on top of the military balance of pressure.
While Israeli army officers admit that Arab terrorism has “never been as bad as this” since 1948, they maintain they have the situation well in hand.
Each Israel Victory Only Serves To Increase Resistance Of Arab Forces
By THOMAS RESTON, North American Newspaper Alliance
KARAMEH, Jordan — If you come down here to the bottom of the world, just north of the Dead Sea and three kilometers from where the Israelis stand on the hills above the Jordan River, you can still see Israeli tank-treads grooved into the tar of Karameh’s main street. A year and a half ago, 50,000 Palestinians were living in this once-thriving agricultural community.
Now Karameh is a mangled shell of a town, a maze of bullet-pocked concrete, dynamited houses and twisted metal, all sitting silently under the summer sun. The villagers have fled northeast into the highlands. Karameh is symbolic of how the military war continues in the Middle East, especially on Israel’s eastern front.
The town was a base area for small-scale guerrilla strikes against the Israeli-occupied West Bank of the Jordan River until March 21, 1968. On that day, fed up with the terrorism originating from here, the Israelis moved in and cleared this base once and for all.
Karameh Destroyed Their operation was a military success in terms of its specific objective: Karameh was destroyed and there are no more raids being staged from here. On the other hand, the 15,000 Israeli troops suffered staggering losses in both men and materiel, and Karameh has since become the Arab “Alamo.”
Not only was it proved the Israeli army was not invincible, Palestinians now say, but it was here and in the Battle of Karameh that serious partisan warfare against the enemy can mark its birth.
Even though it was the regular Jordanian army which bore the brunt of Karameh’s defense, the fedayeen are the toast of Arab militants and a force no Arab conservative can afford to ignore.
Resistance Increases Thus, Israel’s devilish military problem with the Arab “War of Attrition”: each time they score another military success — and they have scored plenty since the Six-Day War — Arab stubbornness, intransigence and resistance only increase. But as the winter of 1969 begins, Israel is still clearly on top of the military balance of pressure.
While Israeli army officers admit that Arab terrorism has “never been as bad as this” since 1948, they maintain they have the situation well in hand. All along the eastern front with Jordan, they have constructed an electronic security fence, which they maintain has all but stopped infiltration.
Most of the incidents at the moment are limited to shelling and mortaring the tough little kibbutzim in the Beit Shean Valley, just south of the Sea of Galilee, where the children sleep in bomb shelters every night and every morning Israeli mine detection teams sweep the frontier fields before allowing the farmers to get to work.
Losses Heavy Al Fatah and other guerrilla movements based out of Amman tell the story differently, but even though their claims are exaggerated, it cannot be denied they are right when they calmly report “this is only the beginning.”
ALGIERS (AP) — Palestine guerrilla leader Yassir Arafat said Saturday that the Israelis have killed 6,000 Palestinians “by torture, massacre or napalm” since the 1967 war. Another 16,000 including 1,700 women, have been imprisoned, he said. Arafat was addressing the opening session of the first International Congress of Committees of Support for Palestine.
It was attended by delegates from 10 countries including the United States and by representatives of African liberation movements and the Black Panthers. Arafat came to Algiers after attending the Arab summit conference in Rabat, Morocco. After addressing the Algiers meeting, he continued on to Tunis.
The number and the actor are both in the headline, and the second line takes them back: Guerrilla Claims. What the forty words underneath also record, in a Texas paper in December 1969, is who was in the room — delegates from ten countries including the United States, representatives of African liberation movements, and the Black Panthers.
Part of Covering Palestine, an archive of 3637 newspaper clippings about Palestinians printed in 748 papers between 1724 and 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles. Nothing here was printed after 6 October 2023.