The Flint Journal · Flint, Michigan · 18 June 1967
CP-1967-007
Key to Solution in Mideast Rests on Fate of Refugees
By Prof. ARNOLD J. TOYNBEE, Written for UPI, Copyright 1967

Transcribed from the clipping
I will try to put, first, the Israelis' view of this as I see it, then the Arabs' view, and thirdly my own view. I am neither an Arab nor an Israeli. I am British, so I feel deeply my country's share in the responsibility for this tragic conflict between two other peoples.
Britain issued the Balfour Declaration in 1917; Britain was in power in Palestine for 30 years ending in 1948; Britain's precipitate abdication in Palestine after the Second World War left the way open in 1948 for the first of the three Arab-Israeli wars.
The Israelis' view of the conflict's history: We are Jews, the living representatives of Judah, one of the 12 tribes of Israel that conquered most of Palestine in the 13th Century B.C. We held Judah's share of the conquered territory for seven centuries, till we were deported by Nebuchadnezzar in 587 B.C.
We were back again within less than half a century, and we then held Judaea, once more, for the next 773 years, till we were evicted by the Romans in A.D. 135. We have never renounced our claim to the land of Israel. We have always hoped, believed, and proclaimed that we shall get this land back again. It is our land, we contend.
AFTER ANOTHER 1,883 years (continuing the Israelis' view) we did recover a foothold there in 1918, and during the half century since then, by devoted hard work, ability, and military valor, we have built up our present national state of Israel, and have inflicted three smashing defeats on the Arabs, who have been trying to evict us once again.
We want to have a country of our own again, like other peoples and like our own ancestors. We also need to have a country of our own, because, since the conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity in the Fourth Century A.D. we have been penalized and persecuted by the Western Christian majority among whom we have had to live.
This persecution has culminated in the unprecedented crime of genocide which has been committed against us in our lifetime by a western people, the Germans, in Europe. We are not going to let the Arabs commit the same crime of genocide against us here, in our own land of Israel.
How this transcription was made
Read from the scan Maria supplied on 14 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. The folio line across the top of the page reads, left to right: 'Sunday, June 18, 1967' | 'The Flint Journal, Flint, Michigan' | 'Page Fifteen'. Agrees exactly with the slide date 1967-06-18, and 18 June 1967 was indeed a Sunday. MASTHEAD vs PUB — THE ARCHIVE IS RIGHT AND THE SLIDE LABEL IS WRONG. The folio line prints 'The Flint Journal, Flint, Michigan' with the leading definite article clearly set. The archive's spelling 'The Flint Journal' therefore matches the paper; Maria's slide label 'Flint Journal' is the one that drops the 'The'. pub is unchanged, and no new paper should be created. I checked this twice: the folio sits at the very top of the scan and my first pass mis-located it and read nothing, so I re-cropped it at 14x and read 'The' letter by letter before saying so. THIS IS THE SAME ARTICLE AS image29. The Flint Journal printed the identical Arnold J. Toynbee essay syndicated by UPI, on the identical date, under a completely different headline and a different set of section heads. The byline block here reads 'By Prof. ARNOLD J. TOYNBEE / Written for UPI / Copyright 1967' and the text opens with the same sentence as the Arizona Republic's. These are two genuine separate records — two different American newspapers printing the same wire essay, which is exactly the thing the archive exists to document — but a reader browsing will meet the same essay twice, and Maria should know that before both go live. I did not merge them. The Flint Journal's own section heads, in printed order, every one of them read from its own magnified crop rather than from a view of the whole page: (1) ‘Israelis Have ‘West's Support’’ (the inner phrase is set in single quotation marks), (2) 'Arabs See Israel As Foreign Body', (3) 'Jewish Claims Need Distinction', (4) 'Both Sides Must Accept Peace', (5) 'Vicious Circle Needs Breaking', (6) 'Refugees Need Compensation', (7) 'Dr. Magnes’ Words Recalled'. All are display italic; heads 5 and 7 are set in a sans-serif italic while the rest are a serif italic. NOT ONE of them is 'U.S. Has Made Arabs Pay for Germany's Crime Against Jews' — that head belongs to the Arizona Republic's setting alone, which is further confirmation that the two papers headed and sub-headed this wire copy independently. SETTING DIFFERENCES I CONFIRMED between the two papers' printings of the same copy, all transcribed here as the Flint Journal set them: Flint 'Second World War' against Arizona 'second World War'; Flint 'we shall get this land back again' against Arizona 'we will get this land back again'; Flint 'ability, and military valor' against Arizona 'ability and military valor'; Flint runs 'AFTER ANOTHER' as a bold-caps run-in where Arizona sets it as plain 'After another'; Flint opens the section with plain 'The Israelis' view of the conflict's history' where Arizona sets a bold-caps 'THE ISRAELIS' VIEW'; Flint sets 'The Western victors in the Second World War' with a capital W where Arizona sets 'The western victors in the Second World War' lower-case; and Flint opens the Arab section 'Next the Arabs' view of the conflict's history' where Arizona sets 'THE ARABS' VIEW of the conflict's history'. These are compositors' choices, not errors, and they are evidence that each paper reset the wire copy itself rather than taking a common plate. TWO READINGS I AM NOT FULLY SURE OF, flagged rather than smoothed over. This scan is a whole broadsheet page at 860x1096, so a body column is only about 110 pixels wide and individual glyphs degrade before whole words do. (1) 'we then held Judaea' — the final letters read as 'aea' to me at 11x, but the Arizona Republic sets the same sentence as 'Judea', so this single word deserves a second eye on a better scan. (2) 'by a western people, the Germans' — I read a lower-case 'w' where the Arizona Republic capitalises 'Western'; I am less than certain of the capital at this resolution. Nothing else in the transcribed passage is in doubt. The excerpt stops at 'in our own land of Israel.' — a complete sentence at the foot of the first column's second section — rather than running further. The rest of the essay is present and legible on the page, but I would rather hand back a shorter passage I have actually verified than a longer one carrying guesses. maria_note: 'Use this to replace the one we have as just a headline'. Confirmed and satisfied. CP-1967-007 currently carries the 737x170 headline band and no excerpt; this scan supplies the full page, so the record can now carry the printed headline exactly as set, the byline block, the page and folio, and a verified opening excerpt. The page also carries a portrait photograph of Toynbee at upper right with the caption 'PROF. ARNOLD TOYNBEE, one of the world's best known — and most controversial — historians', and two editorial cartoons with the captions 'We Grew Them this Morning.' and 'Well, Now . . . I Expect You Boys Will Want to Reorder . . .'. These are page furniture around the essay rather than captions belonging to it, so photo_caption is left empty; say the word if you want the Toynbee portrait caption recorded there instead. The folio sets the page as 'Page Fifteen' in words; I have put the numeral 15 in the page field for sorting.
Context added by this archive
11 June 1967, in Flint, Michigan. Everything in the Middle East is said to turn on the fate of the refugees — which is a thing an American paper could say plainly in 1967 and said less and less afterwards. The refugees are still refugees and not a people; the word Palestinian is not in the line.
Cite this clipping
"Key to Solution in Mideast Rests on Fate of Refugees," The Flint Journal, 18 June 1967, p. 15. Covering Palestine archive, CP-1967-007. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-1967-007
More from The Flint Journal
- HEBREW BOTANIST STUDIES REMEDIESThe Flint Journal · 4 October 1932
- Million Homeless Palestinian Arabs Camped in Middle EastThe Flint Journal · 13 August 1953
- Church Group Backs Palestinian RefugeesThe Flint Journal · 5 October 1969
- Israel Accused in Assassination BlastThe Flint Journal · 9 July 1972
- Palestinian killed in Gaza stripThe Flint Journal · 16 April 1982
- Israeli soldiers force four squatters to leaveThe Flint Journal · 20 August 1985
- 1 more from this paper in the full text →
More from the 1960s
- Arabs Call Unity Meeting For Israel OppositionThe Arizona Republic · 2 January 1967
- Middle East Pots Boiling on New Year'sTulsa World · 2 January 1967
- New Blow At Jordan ThreatenedThe Clarksdale Press Register · 3 January 1967
- PLO Plans To Strike At HusseinClovis News-Journal · 3 January 1967
- Even in War, Bethlehem Has Air of Tourist TownThe New York Times · 10 June 1967
- JERUSALEM ARABS DIVIDED ON FUTUREThe New York Times · 12 June 1967
- All 232 clippings from the 1960s →
Last updated 17 November 2026
This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.
The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.
Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-1967-007.
Everything printed in 1967 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset