← Covering Palestine

The 1950s, in full text

Every clipping in this archive printed between 1950 and 1959: 220 of them, oldest first, as plain text that can be read, searched and quoted without running any code. Each entry links to its own record, where the scan is.

· El Reno American · page 1

Arab Refugees Come Home

Associated Press Wirephoto

ARAB REFUGEES COME HOME—Arab families are reunited in Acre following repatriation of Arabs, both Christian and Moslem, who fled Palestine during the fighting. Many of these refugees were separated from their families for 18 months or more.

Armistice Commission and United Nations personnel are preparing for the homeward flow of Arabs who took refuge in neighboring countries.

A photograph of Palestinians going back, and a news agency expecting more of it. The caption stands in for a headline; the scan carries none.

CP-1950-002 →

· Pittsburgh Post-Gazette · Pittsburgh

UN Ignores Tragic Plight Of Palestine’s Christians

Dorothy Thompson, On the Record, New York, Jan. 24

“The United Nations never took one step to guarantee the lives or property of the indigenous Arab population in Jewish Palestine.

Hundreds of thousands of them have been turned into refugees… It apparently surprised Americans to learn that there were any Christians in Palestine! Yet they constitute a tenth of the Arab-speaking population… Israel and its American supporters are claiming an absolutely unique immunity from criticism—as recently pointed out by pro-Israel Walter White.”

A nationally syndicated columnist noting, in January 1950, that the existence of a whole population came as news to American readers. The Walter White she cites is the secretary of the NAACP quoted in the Alabama Tribune of 29 October 1948 on “genocide, Palestine, and the basic issue of colonies.” Seven years before this column, the Southern Jewish Weekly had invoked Thompson as the keener analyst who disagreed with the anti-Zionists.

CP-1950-006 →

· The New York Times

ARAB REFUGEES RETURN TO THEIR HOMES NEAR HAIFA

The first of the families crossing the frontier from Lebanon aided by members of the Red Mogen Dovid, Israel’s equivalent to the American Red Cross. The Arabs are going back to their old homes under an agreement recently signed by the Governments of Israel and Lebanon.

CP-1950-019 →

· The New York Times · New York

Israel to Seize Property

To Sell Arab Refugees’ Holdings to State Development Unit

JERUSALEM, March 8—Legislation enabling the Israeli Government to obtain legal title to property abandoned by Arab refugees was passed today by the Knesset (Parliament). A clause in the absentees property bill empowered the Council for Custody of Absentees Property to sell the holdings to the projected State Development Authority.

The custodian has powers to lease the properties for five years. Affected by the legislation are almost whole cities like Jaffa, Acre, Ramleh, Lydda and the Arab quarters of Jerusalem, Haifa, Tiberias and Safed, scores of villages and large areas of citrus, olive and fruit orchards, quarries and farm land.

The law provides that the buyers must pay the custodian’s full, official value of the property, which will be held in trust for the absentees. The Government’s draft of the bill provided for payment of at least 8 per cent of the value, but the Knesset adopted an amendment by Amin Jurjura, Arab member from Nazareth, increasing the price.

CP-1950-007 →

· Midland Reporter Telegram

Israel Faced With Farm Aid Problem

JERUSALEM —(AP)— Israel's Ministry of Education is training Arab teachers for the 120,00 Arabs living within the borders of Israel.

A single-sentence AP brief. People of Palestine are called 'Arabs'. No individual named. Worth keeping for the head/body mismatch alone, which is itself evidence of how little editorial attention these items got.

CP-1950-021 →

· estimated · Alexander City Outlook

ISRAELI ARMY HEAD MEETS BEDOUIN CHIEF

ISRAELI ARMY HEAD MEETS BEDOUIN CHIEF—Maj. Gen. Rav-Aloof Yigael Yadin, Israeli Army Chief of Staff, recently paid his frist official visit to Sheikh Suliman al-Hezail, head of the Tauaha tribes, and one of the most important Bedouin Sheikhs in the Negev. The meeting took place in Beersheba, Israel. Above, Maj. Gen.

Yadin (left) smiles as he accepts a sword in a silver scabbard from Sheikh al-Hezail. In the address to the Bedouin, the Chief of Staff said: “We know our friends and we shall stand by them: but woe to our foes.”

Date check: No masthead, page date line or page number is present in this clipping, so neither the 1950-05-19 date nor the publication (Alexander City Outlook) can be confirmed from the image. The photograph carries a wire-service logo in its lower left corner, a circular monogram consistent with an agency credit mark, but it is not legible enough to name.

CP-1950-015 →

· Los Angeles Mirror

UCLA Seniors to Hear Talk by Dr. Bunche

Dr. Ralph Bunche, U.N. mediator in the Arab-Palestine dispute, will be Commencement speaker at the graduation of 1950 UCLA seniors in the Hollywood Bowl on June 18. On Friday, June 16, Dr. Bunche, who was graduated from UCLA in 1927, will address 2800 Berkeley graduates of the university. President Robert Gordon Sproul will preside at the Hollywood Bowl exercises.

The ceremony will cap a week of senior activity. On June 11 the graduates will gather for religious services at St. Albans Episcopal Church in Westwood. On June 17 seniors and their guests will tour the campus. That evening the traditional Aloha Ball will be held at the Riviera Country Club.

DR. BUNCHE

CP-1950-022 →

· Los Angeles Examiner

Bunche to Speak at U. C. Commencements

Dr. Ralph Bunche, United Nations mediator in the Arab-Palestine dispute, will be commencement speaker at the University of California at Berkeley and at Los Angeles. He will talk before the 1950 Los Angeles campus graduates at 2 p. m. June 18 at the Hollywood Bowl. His Berkeley address will be given at the graduation exercises there at Edwards Field June 16. Dr.

Bunche graduated from UCLA in [illegible]. Other events scheduled for senior week include: Vesper services for graduates at St. Albans Episcopal Church with representatives of Catholic, Protestant and Jewish faiths speaking on Sunday, June 11. The Senior Pilgrimage on Saturday, June 17. The traditional Aloha Ball at the Riviera Country Club on Saturday night, June 17.

President Robert Gordon Sproul will preside over the commencement exercises in Hollywood Bowl.

CP-1950-023 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

TORTURE REPORTS STUDIED BY ISRAEL

Acheson Request Heeded After Tales of Mistreating Arabs Infiltrating Over Border

By GENE CURRIVAN

TEL AVIV, Israel, June 8—At the request of Secretary of State Dean Acheson the Israeli Government is investigating Arab reports of mistreatment approaching a point of torture allegedly perpetrated against infiltrators into Israel. The reports came from Jordan, and were supplemented by declarations from United Nations observers.

It was reported that the infiltrators, who were trying to find their way back to abandoned homes or were intent on smuggling or plunder, were eventually corralled in a detention camp east of Rehovoth. In this camp, according to Arab testimony, they were beaten up, deprived of sustaining food and in some cases tortured.

United Nations photographers have pictures showing bloody hands from which nails had been torn, along with photographic evidence of broken bones and disfigurement. Complaints of this situation have been made by Arabs to the United Nations and by the United States State Department to Israel.

This country is investigating, but apparently it has little control over the small border patrols that are constantly defending themselves against the refugees who will take any chance to infiltrate and will fight for what is left of their livelihood.

Date check: No masthead or page date line on the clipping. The credit line under the byline reads “Special to THE NEW YORK TIMES,” corroborating `pub`. The dateline reads “TEL AVIV, Israel, June 8”, consistent with publication on 1950-06-09, but the printed date is not visible.

CP-1950-018 →

· estimated · Des Moines Register · Des Moines

PROBE ISRAELI TORTURE CAMP

By Gene Currivan.

TEL AVIV, ISRAEL—At the request of Secretary of State Dean Acheson, the Israeli government is investigating Arab reports of mis-treatment and torture allegedly inflicted on Arab infiltrators into Israel. The reports came from Jordan, and were supplemented by declarations from United Nations observers.

It was reported that the infiltrators, who were trying to find their way back to abandoned homes or were intent on smuggling or plunder, eventually were corraled in a detention camp east of Rehovoth. In this camp, according to Arab testimony, they were beaten up, deprived of sustaining food, and in some cases tortured.

United Nations photographers have pictures showing bloody hands from which nails had been torn, along with photographic evidence of broken bones and disfigurement. Complaints have been made by Arabs to the United Nations and by the U.

S. state department to Israel, which is investigating, but apparently has little control over the small border patrols that are constantly defending themselves against the refugees. Both U. N. personnel and Americans here are disturbed over what they regard as the Israeli government’s complacent attitude and its obvious lack of control over its own forces.

The charge is made that the Israelis selected more than 100 of the healthiest Arabs and ordered them out of the camp. They were taken blindfolded in trucks to the nearest border and then herded over, while machine-gun bursts separated them into groups, it was said. The area was barren, with no water or food.

Some of the Arabs wandered for days until they reached Amman, while others fell by the wayside.

Date check: No masthead, page date line or page number is present in this clipping, so neither the 1950-06-10 date nor the publication (Des Moines Register) can be confirmed from the image. The credit line under the byline reads “Leased Wire from The N. Y. Times,” which identifies the source of the copy, not this paper. Unusually, the dateline carries no date at all — it reads only “TEL AVIV, ISRAEL—”, where the New York Times version of the same despatch (u1950thenewyorktime) reads “TEL AVIV, Israel, June 8”. A June 8 despatch running on June 10 in Iowa is consistent, but nothing in the image establishes it.

CP-1950-016 →

· California Eagle · page 6

A Tribute to Dr. Bunche

Dr. Ralph J. Bunche, noted alumnus of UCLA, in his quiet but very effective manner, gave good advice to the 3,586 seniors, to members of the faculty and some 10,000 friends of the university, gathered in Hollywood Bowl last Sunday at the annual commencement exercises of UCLA. It was in this very Hollywood Bowl last summer that Dr.

Bunche was awarded the Spingarn medal for outstanding service to humanity. That service consisted in bringing peace to the warring factions in Palestine, the feud between Israeli and her Arab neighbors.

Some of the sound common senese which permeated his meetings with the leaders of the Arab nations and those of Israeli, punctuated his remarks last Sunday as he spoke briefly of conditions in the United States and in the world. He said we needed less talk of fear and more confidence; less witch-hunting and more emphasis on faith in America.

“To us,” he said, with a very evident reference to the loyalty oaths demanded of UCLA faculty members, “To us, pledges, oaths, affirmations have always been superfluous precisely because the overwhelming loyalty of Americans is demonstrated spontaneously and continuously in their deeds. . . .

Our invincible strength has always been in the voluntary adherence of free men with free minds.” Dr. Bunche is director of the division of trusteeship in the United Nations. He paid high tribute to the work of the UN, and said it reflects “the fervent hopes of the war-weary and war-buffeted peoples of the world.” It was as UN mediator that Dr.

Bunche was sent to Palestine, first as assistance to Ambassador Bernadette, and then later, upon Bernadette’s death, as UN mediator direct. Dr. Bunche is a product of Los Angeles of whom every Angeleno can be proud.

Most of his life was spent in the City of the Angels; he attended Los Angeles city schools, and was graduated not only from the Los Angeles high school system, but also from the University of California which is located in Los Angeles.

CP-1950-024 →

· The New York Times · New York

GAZA ARAB EXODUS TO JORDAN ON WAY

Two years after 1948, a second movement of people out of Gaza, reported as an exodus with no one named as moving them.

CP-1950-008 →

· The New York Times · New York

Arab Infiltration Troubles Israelis

TEL AVIV, Israel, July 22—Arab infiltration of Israeli territory could be stopped within twenty-four hours if Jordan cooperated, according to Capt. Moshe Idelovitch, Assistant Superintendent of Police in Israel. The Russian-born Captain Idelovitch is commander of the Petah Tiqva area, where most of the border marauders and murderers penetrate.

While most of the frontier areas have been relatively quiet, that with Jordan remains troublesome. In June, 227 infiltrators were captured and in the preceding six months 1,600. Most of these, except known criminals, have been sent back across the border.

Captain Idelovitch and his chief, Inspector General Yehezkiel Sahar, denied reports published here and abroad that captured infiltrators had been maltreated and, in some cases, tortured. They said one of the principal troubles was that the Israeli authorities were so lenient that released prisoners constantly returned.

If they were mistreated the marauders would not return so often, these officials said. Jordan has charged that hundreds of infiltrators have been cast back into the desert without food or water, and that many of them have perished in trying to reach oases.

In a wadi (ravine) near the ancient village of Kafar Kasim, where Israeli Arabs live in a manner unchanged by time, the police were examining a spot where marauders had dragged a villager from his home. They broke his legs and beat him when he declined to tell where he had hidden his money.

At the Petah Tiqva prison, this correspondent spoke to an infiltrator from Qalqiliya, who had been captured with a grenade in his hand. He said he had come over to steal anything he could. Asked why he carried a grenade, he replied, “For self-defense.”

Two things are in this clipping and both of them arrive six years early. It is the first time an American paper in this archive uses Israeli Arab to name a person rather than a war, and the village it is standing in is Kafr Qasim — six years and three months before Israeli border police shot forty-eight of its people at a curfew they had not been told about. Lower in the same column, Inspector General Yehezkiel Sahar denies “reports published here and abroad that captured infiltrators had been maltreated and, in some cases, tortured.” A denial of reports already published is not the start of a record. It is a reply to one.

CP-1950-009 →

· Press of Atlantic City · Atlantic City · page 1

Immigrants Use Arab Properties

The Associated Press, Tel Aviv

TEL AVIV, Israel—(AP)—The Israeli custodian of abandoned property is turning former Arab properties over to new immigrants. A government bulletin said 83,000 rooms and 7,800 shops, offices and workshops which once belonged to Arabs are being used for the housing of 170,000 newly arrived Jews and former soldiers.

The custodian also has charge of nearly 900,000 acres of land which Arabs once occupied and farmed. About 62,500 acres are now being used for plantations. Most of the Arabs who once held all of these properties are now war refugees in the Egyptian-held Gaza coastal strip or elsewhere in the Middle East.

One of three papers running this dispatch. The verb in this headline is use.

Correction: {'note': 'The dateline is not visible on this scan. The identical dispatch in the Star Herald is datelined 26 August, so the 20 August date comes from the presentation caption and has not been confirmed on the page.'}

CP-1950-003 →

· Star Herald · page 1

Jewish Immigrants Get Former Arab Property

The Associated Press, Tel Aviv, Aug 26

TEL AVIV, Israel—(AP)—The Israeli custodian of abandoned property is turning former Arab properties over to new immigrants. A government bulletin said 83,000 rooms and 7,800 shops, offices and workshops which once belonged to Arabs are being used for the housing of 170,000 newly arrived Jews and former soldiers.

The custodian also has charge of nearly 900,000 acres of land which Arabs once occupied and farmed. About 62,500 acres are now being used for plantations. Most of the Arabs who once held all of these properties are now war refugees in the Egyptian-held Gaza coastal strip or elsewhere in the Middle East.

The same dispatch. The verb in this headline is get.

CP-1950-004 →

· estimated · The Daily Press · Newport News

Ten Arabs Killed By Israeli Army

Jerusalem, Aug. 27.—(AP)—Ten Arabs were killed by the Israeli Army in a large scale mopping up operation that cleaned marauding Bedouin tribesmen out of the southern Negev Desert, it was reliably reported here today. The operation near the Egyptian border was the third one of the month.

In previous actions Israeli soldiers broke up a gang of smugglers, killing 20 of them. Earlier armed Jordanian shepherds and their flocks were driven out of the territory and 1,200 of their sheep confiscated.

Date check: No masthead or page date line is on this clipping — it is a trimmed single-column story. The dateline reads “Jerusalem, Aug. 27.”, consistent with publication on 1950-08-28, but the year and the paper's name cannot be confirmed from the scan.

CP-1950-017 →

· Enid Morning News · Enid · page 1

Immigrants Taking Over Arab Property

The Associated Press, Tel Aviv

TEL AVIV, Israel—(AP)—The Israeli custodian of abandoned property is turning former Arab properties over to new immigrants. A government bulletin said 83,000 rooms and 7,800 shops, offices and workshops which once belonged to Arabs are being used for the housing of 170,000 newly arrived Jews and former soldiers.

The custodian also has charge of nearly 900,000 acres of land which Arabs once occupied and farmed. About 62,500 acres are now being used for plantations. Most of the Arabs who once held all of these properties are now war refugees in the Egyptian-held Gaza coastal strip or elsewhere in the Middle East.

The same dispatch again. The verb in this headline is taking over.

CP-1950-005 →

· The New York Times · New York

U.N. Palestine Unit Meets Here

“The United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine held its first formal meeting yesterday since returning from Jerusalem.”

Twenty-six words. Two years after the expulsions, the body charged with resolving them meets in New York and the whole of it fits in a single sentence with no outcome, no participants and no refugees in it.

CP-1950-013 →

· Houston Chronicle

Arab Student at U. of H. Finds ‘Home Folks’ Here

As a rule, foreign students at the University of Houston require a little time to become accustomed to the American way of life as practiced on the campus and in Houston. But not George Zabaq, 17-year-old freshman law major from Trans-Jordan.

Although he is 8000 miles from Ramallah, his home, the young Arab already has found three schoolmates from his home who are attending the university. In addition his father welcomed him to Houston last week, as did three cousins, an uncle and several other persons from the Ramallah area.

Zabaq is already an active member of one campus service organization, the International Relations Club, even though he has been on the campus only five days. The personable young student pointed out that the gulf coast area is a favorite part of America for the Arabs of Ramallah district. Almost 300 of them having settled in this area.

Zabaq, who speaks English with a British accent, is a graduate of National College of Ramallah, a Christian city in a Moslem kingdom. He has seen his hometown change hands three times—from British rule to Israeli, and now into the hands of Abdullah, king of Trans-Jordan. Zabaq himself is a Christian, as are the majority of the Arabs of Ramallah district.

During recent strife in the Holy Land, when Palestine was taken from the Arabs, Ramallah remained neutral, although sentiment was heavily in favor of the Arabs. Zabaq, who arrived in America two weeks ago, lives with his father, Mussa Zabaq, merchant, at 1121 La Branch.

EAST MEETS EAST, and gets an Irish smile to boot, as Dorcye Riley, left, chats with George Zabaq, right, a University of Houston student from Ramallah, Trans-Jordan. Zabaq, who arrived in Houston eight days ago, immediately felt at home with such hometown friends as Nadim Totah, center, also from Ramallah and a former schoolmate of Zabaq’s in Ramallah.

The young Arab flew over 8000 miles to be with his father in Houston and to attend the university. Dorcye, 19, a sophomore art major, is the daughter of Mr. and Mrs. S. P. Riley of 8802 Harrell.

CP-1950-020 →

· Salinas Californian · Salinas

Current Situation in Israel Explained by Speakers on Forum Here

“Hardly one rifle or mortar to oppose… our original troops… the indomitable Jews of Jerusalem saved the Holy City from destruction.”

A forum at the Jewish centre in Salinas, two years after the war. Among the speakers is Private Bobby Gateo, 17. The archive holds very little of how 1948 was narrated to American audiences in person, in small cities, by people who had just been there.

CP-1950-014 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore · page 1

U.N. Ponders Palestine

Genocide Pact Signing Shares In Interest For Day

Paul W. Ward, Sun Staff Correspondent, Lake Success, N.Y.

Lake Success, N.Y., Oct. 16 — The United Nations spotlight today shifted momentarily away from Korea, Indo-China and other foci of the world-wide Communist infection and turned instead on Palestine and “genocide.”

The shift was impelled by two developments besides the fact that the General Assembly’s 60-member political and security committee was bogged down throughout the day in repetitious technical arguments over a single section of the American “uniting for peace” plan which Moscow opposes.

Between Two Orthodoxies. One of the two impelling developments was the plight of Israel’s Government.

It was caught between two orthodoxies — Jewish orthodoxy which had unseated David Ben-Gurion’s Government at the time and Moslem orthodoxy which arraigned Israel before the United Nations Security Council here today on charges of “Zionist aggression.”

The other development was a signing ceremony here bringing into effect 90 days hence a United Nations convention defining and outlawing as “genocide” all measures undertaken in peace or war “with intent to destroy, wholly or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group as such.”

The convention binds its ratifiers to have their national legislatures enact complementary domestic laws, pledges them also to prosecute in their own courts persons accused of “genocide” and to grant extradition of persons wanted in other countries for prosecution on the same count, and, finally, projects the possible creation of an international tribunal to try “genocide” cases.

Representatives of Jordan and Israel clashed in the Security Council this afternoon as Jordan’s envoy joined with Egypt’s in virtually accusing Israel of “genocide” by charging it with attempts to wipe out Palestine’s Arab population in certain sections.

Earlier Than Hitlerism. Another link between the Near Eastern situation and the “genocide” convention was created by events here today. For Lemkin began his crusade to outlaw organized mass murder on racial or religious grounds long before the Nazis destroyed his family in Poland.

It was not Hitlerism, but a massacre of Christian Assyrians in Iraq that caused him, he says, to first propose a “genocide” convention to the League of Nations in 1933…

The Genocide Convention signed and the word used of Palestine in the Security Council on the same afternoon, reported in one story. The paper records where Lemkin says the idea came from: a massacre of Christian Assyrians in Iraq, proposed to the League of Nations in 1933, before Hitler.

CP-1950-001 →

· Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle · Milwaukee

Appraising the Arab Minority in Israel

“The Israel Arabs, unhappily for themselves and the Jews, live close to Israel’s most vulnerable frontiers and they greatly outnumber the Jewish settlers in these zones.”

Jon Kimche, writing in a Milwaukee Jewish weekly, in the column Boris Smolar usually filled. Note the form: not Israeli Arabs but Israel Arabs, a third word order that never caught on. In 1950 the name was still being tried out. What is settled already is the frame — a population described by where it sits relative to a frontier, and counted against the settlers near it.

CP-1950-010 →

· The New York Times · New York

Bedouins Raid Israeli Arabs

“Bedouins from the Sinai desert are reported to have shot a child and stolen three horses in a foray across the border last night when they attacked Israeli Arab tribes southeast of Beersheba. Local Arabs reported to Israeli military authorities that the raiders were of the Azame tribe, expelled from Israel three months ago.”

Five lines, and the term is in the headline and the body both. The last clause is the one to read twice: the raiders were the Azazme, expelled from Israel three months earlier. The paper prints the expulsion as the explanation for the raid and then moves on. The expulsion itself is not the story anywhere in this archive.

CP-1950-011 →

· Concord Monitor · Concord

Arab Refugees Poison Relations With the West

BY DOROTHY THOMPSON

“I have visited camps in Europe from the Polish frontiers to Austria. But never have I seen such conditions…”

Dorothy Thompson from Beirut, in the Concord Daily Monitor. She had reported the camps of postwar Europe and says these are worse. Three years later the same columnist gives Qibya the word massacre while the news desks are still calling it a border incident.

CP-1950-012 →

· The New York Times · New York

Arabs Take Action on Refugee Issues

League Reported Set to Aid in Resettling of Palestinians Outside of Israel

Special to THE NEW YORK TIMES. TEL AVIV, Israel, Feb. 5 — A new hope of instituting an effective resettlement program for Palestinian Arabs in the Arab League countries has arisen here as a result of the League’s reported decision to begin an immediate study of the problems involved.

Israeli officials have welcomed the decision, which still has to be confirmed officially by the League, as a possible turning point in the endeavors to bring about a settlement between this country and her Arab neighbors.

If confirmed, the decision would represent a fundamental change in the League’s policy toward Israel, which hitherto had been based on a demand for return of the refugees to their homes and land in Israel. No one here pretends to know what led the League to the decision at the windup of its latest meeting in Cairo.

But it is known that Britain has been pressing the Arab countries to undertake resettlement in their own lands with United Nations financial and technical help, and it is suspected that the United States stepped in recently with strong support for the British.

Israel Offers to Help Israeli officials reiterated today this country’s preparedness to help finance a resettlement program. The figure of £1,000,000 Israeli (approximately $2,810,000) has been mentioned in the past as the initial Israeli contribution to the reintegration fund voted recently by the United Nations General Assembly.

The Assembly appropriated $30,000,000 dollars for the reintegration fund. Israeli officials, who well knew the problems of resettlement from their own experiences, realize this sum could not go far toward settling the future of all 700,000 or 800,000 refugees now drawing assistance from the United Nations Works and Rehabilitation Administration.

What these officials would like to see is an effective start made with these funds so as to bring about a favorable psychological reaction among the refugees to the idea of settling permanently away from their former homes.

If the refugees can be given a firm hope of a decent future in, say, northern Syria or Iraq, Israeli officials believe their present passive resistance to resettlement will be replaced by enthusiastic cooperation.

CP-1951-008 →

· Duluth News-Tribune · Duluth

9 Killed in Blast Of Arab's House

“The Arab News Agency said last night nine persons were killed when Jews blew up the house of the mayor of the Arab village of Sharafat near the truce line south of Jerusalem.”

Sharafat, 7 February 1951, reaching Duluth the next day. Nine dead, and the only thing that identifies them is the Arab village of Sharafat. The dispatch is from Cairo, filed by the Arab News Agency, which is why it exists at all: no American correspondent was there.

CP-1951-012 →

· Knoxville Journal

Arabs Blame Jews In Blast

The same Cairo dispatch, a day later, under a headline that moves the killing into the realm of allegation. Nine people are dead in the first sentence; the headline is about who is blaming whom.

CP-1951-013 →

· Worcester Telegram · Worcester

Israeli-Arab Border Tension Increases

“Israeli-Arab border tension mounted yesterday in the wake of violence estimated to have taken 12 lives since Sunday.”

Twelve dead become tension, and tension is the subject of the sentence. Note the term doing the work: Israeli-Arab, the conflict sense, five years before any American paper in this archive uses the same two words to name a person.

CP-1951-014 →

· Morning World

Israeli-Arab Tension Mounts

“A deadlock in the Jordan-Israel mixed armistice commission…”

The fourth paper to run it. Sharafat is now gone from the story entirely; what remains is a deadlocked commission.

CP-1951-015 →

· The News and Advance

Palestine Refugees Will Be Resettled

United Nations, N. Y., March 23 (AP)—The United Nations announced plans today to resettle 50,000 Palestine refugees in the Sinai Desert of Egypt. The project will be carried out with full cooperation of the Egyptian government which first suggested the scheme.

The United Nations relief and works agency for Palestine refugees in the Near East hopes to make the desert bloom as it did in biblical times. The first step will be a survey of the area by a team of experts including a soil chemist and agricultural specialists. The full cost of the project has not yet been figured.

Money for it will be transferred from the agency’s direct relief funds, most of which were contributed by the United States.

CP-1951-016 →

· The Elkhart Truth · Elkhart, IN

Cana, Scene of Miracle of Wine, Example of Tolerance

CANA OF GALILEE: (AP) The village where Christ in the presence of his mother performed his first miracle, as told in John I, 1-11, today sets a fine example of inter-ecclesiastical peace.

A brown-robed, Italian speaking Franciscan brother from Yugoslavia and a black-garbed, Arabic and Russian speaking Greek-Orthodox priest from the neighboring Kingdom of Jordan now act in this village as the devoted guardians of three of the "six water pots of stone" in which Jesus turned the water into wine for the marriage guests.

On the new political map of the Holy Land, Cana—on the mountain road from Nazareth to Tiberias—is in northern Israel. The modern Israel-Arab name of the village is Kafr Kana. Kafr stands for village.

Unproved Relics There is no proof that the three pitchers shown in the red-domed Roman-Catholic church and in the green-capped Greek-Orthodox church are genuine remains from Jesus' time. The one shown in the Latin church looks too new. The two in the Greek church may have been baptismal fonts used in one of the earlier churches here. Yet people believe in their authenticity.

And most who come here like to taste the water from the well into which the original pitchers were sunk and "filled up to the brim." Inter-religious relations in New-Cana are good. As in other parts of Galilee, the Greek-Orthodox last year even celebrated Christmas on the same day as the Latins and the Protestants.

And in addition to the Christians, several hundred Moslems also live here. Once a Hermit There was big excitement among the village children recently because of a death in Cana. Following an old custom, the family of the deceased sent a few loaves of bread, a good portion of beans and some sugar to the priest, so he could bless it while praying for the dead man's soul.

After white-bearded, 60-year-old Archimandrite Prochoros performed the rites, he gave the bread to the poor and the sugared beans to the children. Archimandrite Prochoros says he likes his job among the pitchers, the rich, the poor and the children of Cana.

Before he came here, he had lived as a hermit for years among the shrubs of nearby Mount Tabor, the scene of the transfiguration of Christ.

MARIA'S FLAGGED CLIPPING. Clipped article with photograph; no masthead, no folio, no printed date, so the date is label-only. The item carries an (AP) credit inside the dateline but no byline. There is no deck; 'Unproved Relics' and 'Once a Hermit' are crossheads inside the story. Photo caption, set above the dateline in bold: 'Pilgrims view one of water-to-wine jars at Cana.' EDITOR'S NOTE MATERIAL — EXACTLY WHAT THE PAPER CALLED THE PLACE AND ITS PEOPLE, AND WHAT IT LEFT OUT. Words the paper uses for the PLACE: 'Cana of Galilee' (dateline), 'The village', 'this village', 'Cana', 'New-Cana', 'the Holy Land' ('the new political map of the Holy Land'), 'northern Israel', 'Galilee', 'other parts of Galilee', 'the mountain road from Nazareth to Tiberias', 'nearby Mount Tabor', 'the neighboring Kingdom of Jordan', and once, as a translated label: 'The modern Israel-Arab name of the village is Kafr Kana. Kafr stands for village.' Words the paper uses for the PEOPLE: 'the village children', 'the children of Cana', 'the rich, the poor', 'the family of the deceased', 'the Christians', 'several hundred Moslems', 'the Latins', 'the Protestants', 'the Greek-Orthodox', 'pilgrims', 'people', 'most who come here', and for individuals by nationality or office only — 'Italian speaking Franciscan brother from Yugoslavia', 'Arabic and Russian speaking Greek-Orthodox priest', 'Archimandrite Prochoros'. WHAT IS ABSENT: the words 'Palestine' and 'Palestinian' appear nowhere in the clipping. No inhabitant of Kafr Kana is named. No inhabitant is quoted; the only person quoted indirectly is the priest, and he is reported, not quoted. The 'several hundred Moslems' who live there have no names, no ages, no speech and no history before 1948; they appear in a subordinate clause, 'And in addition to the Christians, several hundred Moslems also live here.' The Arabic name of the village is given once and only as a modern label for a Christian site, glossed with 'Kafr stands for village' — the Arabic is treated as an etymological curiosity rather than as what the people there call their home. The village's status is reported only as a line on 'the new political map': Kafr Kana is a Palestinian village in Galilee whose inhabitants, Muslim and Christian, became citizens of Israel under military government in 1948, three years before this was printed, and the clipping says nothing of that. The 'example of tolerance' in the headline is tolerance between European and Levantine churches, not between the state and the villagers. FOR MARIA'S NOTE: Kafr Kana should not be confused with Kafr Qasim, the village of the 29 October 1956 massacre already represented in the archive by the 1956-58 Commons uploads. Different village, different district, different event; the similarity of the names is a real risk for a reader skimming the collection, and the note should say so.

CP-1951-017 →

· The Daily Times

Cease-Fire Demand In Palestine Expected

Lake Success, May 8—(AP)—A three-power demand for an immediate cease-fire by Syria and Israel in Palestine is expected to come before the Security Council today. The United States, Britain and France were reported readying such a demand for the meeting, called to consider the outbreak of fighting in the Holy Land between Syrians and Israelis.

The three nations were reported asking other countries to co-sponsor the resolution.

A short AP brief, complete on the clipping. No masthead, no folio, no printed date, no city of publication; date is label-only and the city_state field is left empty because nothing on the scan identifies which Daily Times this is. FLAG FOR EVA: 'The Daily Times' is a very common American newspaper name and there is nothing in this clipping to tie it to a particular town. If the archive already holds a 'Daily Times', confirm it is the same paper before this record is ingested, and if it is not, the two will collapse into one. The dateline 'Lake Success, May 8' places it at the UN's temporary headquarters, which the UN left in 1951; the fighting referred to is the Israeli-Syrian exchange over the Huleh demilitarized zone in early May 1951. Both are consistent with Maria's label of 8 May 1951. There is no deck. WORDS FOR THE PLACE AND PEOPLE: 'Palestine' twice, in the headline and in 'by Syria and Israel in Palestine'; 'the Holy Land' once. Palestine here is purely a theatre of operations between two other states. The parties named are 'Syria and Israel', 'Syrians and Israelis', 'The United States, Britain and France', 'the Security Council', 'the three nations', 'other countries'. WHAT IS ABSENT: in a story whose headline is the word Palestine, not one Palestinian appears, and no inhabitant of the demilitarized zone — which was farmland worked by Palestinian villagers — is mentioned at all.

CP-1951-018 →

· The Louisville Times

Israeli Regime Winks at Spread of Communism Among 900,000 Palestinian Refugees

George Weller

THE LOUISVILLE TIMES KENTUCKY'S BIGGEST AND BEST EVENING NEWSPAPER MAY 11, 1951. Refugees BETE sell so in tar then ten That

Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.

CP-1951-006 →

· The Herald News · Passaic

The Refugee Palestinian Arab

His Ideas, Energy Awakening Arabic World

George Weller

DAMASCUS, Syria — The general story of the Arab refugees of Palestine, both Christian and Moslem, is a tragedy of uprooted farmers and tradesmen, squatting in tent cities waiting for a chance at armed return to their lost farms and homes. But there is a minority among those who are part of this general tragedy who are winning success and usefulness.

There is the story of the one Palestinian in eight who has fought his way out of the hopelessness and growing Communism of the 850,000 in camps. THE entire chain of Arab nations, from Saudi Arabia to Syria, has been fertilized and stimulated by this enforced migration out of Palestine.

The Palestinian Arab, and educated coastal westerner, brought up in the British pattern of law and order, has carried the coolness and clarity of his mountain brooks and the international bustle of his Palestine coastline to the arid, slow cities of the inland desert.

The Palestinian, almost as likely as the Arab of Lebanon to be a Christian and a quick-minded modern, has whipped up the pace and efficiency of the entire Arab world. Wherever he has been given a chance, especially in the Kingdom of Jordan and republican Syria, he has spread new ideas of Arab advancement.

Only Egypt has kept its doors wholly shut to his piquant, cosmopolitan spirit. IN FAROFF KUWAIT, the fabuously rich new sheikdom of the Persian Gulf, almost the entire body of civil servants are bright, British-trained Arabs from Palestine.

The newly rich sheik wanted trained planners and bookkeepers around him to keep from squandering his wealth and he filled the vacuum with experience out of the mandate. The growing oil companies bid against the sheiks for Palestine’s brains, too.

Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.

CP-1951-005 →

· The New York Times · New York

REDS FIGHT RETURN OF ARAB REFUGEES

Say West Plans to Use Them to Build Military Bases and as Soldiers Later

BEIRUT, Lebanon, July 7—Communist forces have launched a campaign to sabotage the United Nations program for the reintegration of the Palestine Arab refugees in the economy and society of the Arab world, using two slogans to rally the resistance. The first is a summons to return to the Palestine partition plan voted by the United Nations in 1947.

The second is that “Western imperialists” intend to use the refugees as labor to fill the Near East with military bases and then draft them into an Arab army of 1,000,000 men to “die for imperialism.” The rather obvious purpose of the campaign is to keep the 879,000 registered refugees as a source of trouble in the Near East.

The campaign is aimed directly at breaking up the new effort to reintegrate the refugees within the Arab states started July 1 under the supervision of John Blandford of the United States, present director of the United Nations Work and Relief Organization for Palestine Refugees.

The Communist propaganda is carried out by a semi-clandestine organization known vaguely as the Refugee Congress, a name borrowed from a couple of ephemeral refugee organizations now rather inactive.

This organization has working committees in each country, regional committees in the areas where the refugees are living and agents in the camps and larger villages and towns where the refugees are found. The regular organ of the Communists distributed among the refugees bears the title “The Way Back.”

CP-1951-010 →

· Evening Star · Washington

Jordan King Abdullah Assassinated as He Enters Mosque to Pray

is the famous Wailing Wall of the Jews. A state of emergency was declared in Jordan. Radio Amman said the border line section of Israeli-held Jerusalem and the Jordan-held Old City was immediately closed. The broadcast said the court would go into mourning for three months. Legations and embassies abroad will mourn for a full week.

Abdullah’s death was a symtom of a serious wave of unrest sweeping the oil-rich Middle East. It began with the assassination of Prime Minister Ali Razmara of Iran, also slain at a mosque entrance. That act plunged Iran into her oil nationalization crisis.

His Majesty IBN Hussein Abdullah, ruler of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, was the second son of the late Hussein, Sherif (ruler) of Hejaz. His elder brother was Feisal, King of Syria, deposed by the French. The two were comrades in arms with Lawrence of Arabia in the Arab revolt against the Turks.

Before the French left Syria Abdullah was intent upon armed invasion of that country to restore his brother to the throne, but this never came off.

ASSASSINATED KING AND SON SUCCESSOR—King Abdullah (left) of Jordan and his son, Prince Naif, who succeeds him, during a visit to England in 1949. They are being shown around Lord Nelson’s flagship, the Victory, by Sir Algernon U. Willis, admiral of the fleet. —AP Wirephoto.

CP-1951-004 →

· The Daily Advance

Clashes Taking Place Between Jordanians and Palestinian Arabs

CAIRO (AP)—Clashes between Jordanians and Palestinian Arabs have taken place in Jordan since the murder of King Abdullah, an Egyptian newspaper reporter said today. The reporter was unable to file his story from Amman because of censorship. Jordanians blame Palestinian Arabs for the death of Abdullah.

The reporter gave this account of the situation in Jordan: Although martial law has not been proclaimed, the Arab Legion actually is in control of the country, has subdued all outbreaks so far and may have prevented civil war. Prince Hussein, 16-year-old grandson of the assassinated Abdullah, is expected to be proclaimed king under the regency of his uncle, Prince Naif.

Naif is Abdullah’s second son. Prince Hussein is the son of Prince Tallal who is entitled to the throne under the constitution. But the constitution also provides that the eldest son could be deprived of the right if physically or mentally unfit. There are many reports Tallal is suffering a nervous breakdown nearing mental disability.

Abdullah before death issued no such decree. In naming Naif regent the government acted as though such a decree existed, apparently assuming Tallal’s unfitness. Informed Amman sources said the intention of the government to give the throne to Hussein was made clear in its appointment of Naif as regent.

Hussein appeared at his grandfather’s funeral Monday with regent Naif wearing the uniform of a captain in the Arab Legion—a rank bestowed by Abdullah. He was educated at Victoria College, Alexandria, Egypt. Arab Legion troops guarded the small area in which Abdullah’s funeral was held.

Legion field guns were mounted on hills leading to the palace and the area was surrounded with barbed wire. Immediately after the funeral Jordanians attempted to attack Palestinian refugees living for three years in ruins of the ancient Roman ampitheater in Amman. Troops in armored cars and jeeps broke it up.

CP-1951-003 →

· The New York Times · New York

Arab Refugee Hospital Burns

TEL AVIV, Israel, Aug. 4—The Augusta Victoria Hospital in the part of Jerusalem occupied by Jordan was reported here tonight to have been almost totally destroyed in a fire. The hospital was under United Nations supervision and treated mainly Palestinian Arab refugees.

CP-1951-009 →

· The New York Times · New York

ARAB REFUGEES HOLD PARADES OF PROTEST

BEIRUT, Lebanon, Sept. 14—Palestinian Arab refugees in camps in Lebanon and Syria have been demonstrating for the last two days in connection with the opening of the Arab-Israeli conference of the Palestine Conciliation Commission in Paris.

Meetings and parades through the camps with black flags have been held to support telegrams that have been sent by refugee committees to the secretary general of the Arab League, the United Nations Relief and Works Agency and local authorities.

All refugee committees from Haj Amin el Husseini’s Arab Higher Committee to the most liberal groups support a demand for return of the refugees to their original homes in Palestine. The only exception is the Communists operating at present under the pseudonym of the not very clearly defined Palestine Arab Refugee Congress.

This type of spreading agitation was feared when it was learned that the Palestine Conciliation Commission would hold a conference in Paris and adopt, as it apparently has, the attitude that all fundamental Palestine problems must be settled together.

CP-1951-011 →

· Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle · Milwaukee

UN Peace Proposals Published; Call for Armistice Revision

Plan Asks for Agreement on Repatriating Fixed Number of Arab Refugees to Israel and Compensation to Those Not Returning

PARIS — (JTA) — The United Nations Conciliation Commission on Palestine made public the five-point peace proposals prepared by the commission and submitted to Israel and the four Arab States with which Israel now has armistice agreements. The proposals call for revision or amendment of the existing armistice agreements on a number of points.

The preamble to the proposals asks the governments to pledge themselves to refrain “from any use of force or acts of hostility” and thus promote peace in Palestine. The following are the points of the proposals: 1. Agreement on war damages, including mutual cancellation of claims by Israel and by the Arab States. 2.

Israel to agree to repatriate a specified number of Arab refugees who can be integrated in the Israel economy and wish to return. 3. Israel to agree to compensate the Arab refugees who do not return for their abandoned property by payment of a global sum based on the commission’s estimates. An easy payment plan would be arranged. 4.

The Arab States and Israel would mutually release all blocked accounts and make them payable in pounds sterling. 5. The Arab States and Israel to agree to revise or amend the armistice agreements. Ask “Territorial Adjustments” A broad range of questions is envisaged under the fifth point.

They include “territorial adjustments, including the demilitarized zones,” and creation of an international water authority to deal with the problem of use of the Jordan and Yarmuk rivers, their tributaries and the water of Lake Tiberias.

It would also cover disposition of the Gaza strip, now occupied by Egypt, creation of a free port in Haifa, and border relations between Israel and her neighbors with special attention to free access to the Holy Places in the Jerusalem area, including Bethlehem.

Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.

CP-1951-007 →

· Nevada State Journal · Reno

The Forrestal Diaries

Futile Attempt to Take Palestine Issue Out of Politics And Retain Arab Friendships for U. S. Security

James Forrestal, edited by Walter Millis; syndicated serialization

“THE Forrestal Diaries

Futile Attempt to Take Palestine Issue Out of Politics And Retain Arab Friendships for U. S. Security

13. The Palestine Question Forrestal’s activity in the Palestine question—one of the most controversial aspects of his career—sprang at bottom from his sense of the immense strategic significance of the Middle East.

It was just after the Republican victory in the congressional election of 1946 that he first broached the idea that Palestine, with all its explosive implications, might be lifted above the American partisan battle. Yet through 1947 it seemed to become only more deeply entangled in domestic politics, as an example indicates:

4 September 1947—CABINET LUNCH At the end of the lunch Hannegan (Postmaster General) brought up the question of the President’s making a statement of policy on Palestine, particularly with reference to the entrance of a hundred and fifty thousand Jews into Palestine.

He said he didn’t want to press for a decision one way or the other but simply wanted to point out that such a statement would have a very great influence and great effect on the raising of funds for the Democratic National Committee.

He said very large sums were obtained a year ago from Jewish contributors and that they would be influenced in either giving or withholding by what the President did on Palestine … I pointed out that the President’s remarks on Palestine of a year ago did not have the expected effect in the New York election.

(It was added) that the President was prompted to make the statement by Rabbi (Abba Hillel) Silver, who was neither a Democrat nor friendly to Truman, and said that the net effect of the President’s observation was to make the British exceedingly angry. (Forrestal determined to try his hand.)

29 September 1947—CABINET LUNCH I asked the President whether it would not be possible to lift the Jewish-Palestine question out of politics. The President said it was worth trying to do although he obviously was skeptical. Anderson asked me what I would do if I were in the other party.

I said that if I were in the other party I would listen patiently to the impact of this question on the security of the United States, and if it was dangerous to let it continue to be a matter of barter between the two parties, I felt confident that I would try to put it on a national and bipartisan basis. (Forrestal opened his campaign with Sen. J.

Howard McGrath, the Democratic national chairman.)

26 November 1947—LUNCH—SEN. McGRATH I said to McGrath that I thought the Palestine question was one of the most important in our American foreign policy, and that if we were talking about lifting foreign affairs out of domestic politics, there was nothing more important to lift out than Palestine, with all its domestic ramifications.

I said the Palestine-Jewish question was similar to the Eire-Irish question of forty years ago and that neither should be permitted to have any substantial influence on American policy. McGrath answered that he realized how serious the situation was.

Question Tied to Campaign Funds (Forrestal derived several points from McGrath’s conversation.

In the first place, Jewish sources were responsible for a substantial part of the contributions to the Democratic National Committee, and many of these contributions were made ‘with a distinct idea on the part of the givers that they will have an opportunity to express their views and have them seriously considered on such questions as the present Palestine question.’

There was a feeling among the Jews that the United States was not doing what it should to solicit votes in the U. N. General Assembly in favor of the Palestine partition.

(To this Forrestal objected that it was ‘precisely what the State Department wanted to avoid; that we had gone a very long way indeed in supporting partition and that proselytizing for votes and support would add to the already serious alienation of Arabian good will.’) McGrath said that ‘beyond this, the Jews would expect the United States to do its utmost to implement the partition decision if it is voted by the U.

N. through force if necessary.’ (The General Assembly voted partition, as the Jewish community wished, on Nov. 29.)

1 December 1947—CABINET LUNCH Lovett (then Under Secretary of State) reported on the result of the…”

An American daily serializing the private diary of the first Secretary of Defense, four years after the fact, with the Palestine chapter set out under its own number. What it records is the partition vote discussed at cabinet lunches as a domestic political question: the Postmaster General raising it in connection with fundraising, and Forrestal proposing to lift it out of party politics and failing. The account of who gave money and why is Forrestal’s own, written in 1947 and printed here in 1951; the archive reproduces it as the paper printed it and does not endorse its framing.

CP-1951-002 →

· Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle · Milwaukee · page 1

Anti-Zionists to Fight ‘Nationalism’

American Jewish Press, New York City

“NEW YORK CITY — (AJP) — Key figures of anti-Zionism in America and England conferred in London recently and swapped shop talk in the problems of combatting world-wide proponents of the Jewish State, the American Jewish Press learned.

Rabbi Elmer Berger, executive director of the anti-Zionist American Council for Judaism, met with leading anti-Zionist and non-Zionist personalities in Britain during a two week stay in the country. Returned to the U. S., Rabbi Berger told the American Jewish Press that English anti-Zionists are ‘putting up the best fight they know how.’

Following conferences with several of the anti-Zionist leaders, Rabbi Berger said that ‘their only hope to combat Jewish nationalism’ lies in making their influence more strongly felt in the English-Jewish Association. The Association, which prior to the establishment of Israel maintained a neutral stand on Zionism, was reported by Rabbi Berger as now ‘pro-Zionist.’

‘What the anti-Zionists in England are trying to do,’ he said, ‘is concentrate their energies on bringing the English-Jewish Association back to its pro-Israel stand.’”

A Jewish weekly reporting on Jewish anti-Zionists as a movement with officers and meetings. The last quoted line says pro-Israel where the sense of the sentence requires the opposite; it is transcribed as the paper set it.

CP-1951-001 →

· The Afro-American · Baltimore · page 1

Urge $800,000 UN Project To Resettle Arab Refugees

“An $800,000,000 program, under the auspices of the United Nations, to resettle the Palestine Arab refugees in the Arab states, is proposed in a comprehensive memorandum submitted to the UN General Assembly by nineteen American leaders… In making the proposals, the group points out that ‘the Arab refugee exists, his plight is tragic and his problem is the responsibility of the international community.’

But, it underscores, this is not a responsibility which ‘can be discharged by protracted palliative measures or by pressures on Israel to open its doors.’”

The headline says $800,000. The story says $800,000,000. The memorandum asks for resettlement in the Arab states and for no pressure on Israel to open its doors.

CP-1952-001 →

· St. Louis Globe-Democrat · St. Louis · page 1

Arabs Demand Return of Refugees

Reuters, Paris, Jan 11

PARIS, Jan. 11 (Reuters).—Lebanese Foreign Minister Charles Helou told the United Nations today the Arabs would accept any form of negotiations in the Palestine dispute if Israel respected UN resolutions calling for the repatriation of Arab refugees. Repatriation of the refugees was “the one condition,” he told the No.

2 political committee, which is considering resolutions on the Palestine conciliation commission. If Israel did that, the Arabs would be willing to become a member of the conciliation commission, or leave decisions to the commission or any other body, Helou said.

One condition, stated at the United Nations and printed in St. Louis.

CP-1952-003 →

· The Birmingham News · Birmingham

Starving Arab refugees could fan fires of war

John Roderick, Associated Press

“There are an estimated 850,000 of them, living in poverty and idleness on the fringes of Palestine… THERE ARE, according to independent and reliable sources, 170,000 heads of families among the 850,000 refugees, 70 per cent farmers.”

“Caution: Inflammable!—The seething Middle East is packed with situations that carry the label, ‘explosive,’ but one of the most dangerous tinderboxes is the case of Arab refugees. Map above indicates where these thousands of refugees are located. (Associated Press map.)”

An Associated Press information graphic in which 821,000 people are drawn as faceless robed figures standing on four countries, under the words Caution: Inflammable. The 1929 map gave Arabs a dot apiece; this one makes them the territory’s principal hazard. The story’s own sourcing says seventy per cent of them are farmers, two paragraphs after the word idleness.

CP-1952-004 →

· Lake Shore Visitor

Okays Palestine Study

Paris.—After a remarkable plea for Christian rights in the Holy Land by Zuloaga Mejia, Colombian delegate to the UN General Assembly, the Assembly voted to continue the Palestine Conciliation Commission.

“Twenty centuries of history, a civilization, the religion founded by Jesus Christ the Jew who died for all humanity, the blood of Christians shed in the Crusades—all forbid us of the 20th century to negotiate on the blood of those who have given their lives to give to Christianity the places that Christ has sanctified and sprinkled with His Blood,” Mejia said.

CP-1952-005 →

· Press & Sun-Bulletin · Binghamton · page 1

UN Trying to Resettle 830,000 Arab Refugees

But Opposition Rampant

Ernie Hill, Special Press Correspondent, United Nations

United Nations — The director of the United Nations agency trying to resettle Arab refugees claims that “better days are ahead for the 830,000 unhappy, dislocated people” chased out of what now is Israel. In a press conference before returning to the Middle East, John P.

Blandford, director of the UN Relief and Works Agency, claimed that the first houses were being built, vocations taught and sites for towns staked out in the $250,000,000 program. Blandford, a former United States housing expert and ambassador, is remarkable in that he refuses to become discouraged by the Arab populations which tell him the program is doomed to failure.

Won’t Resign. His organization hounded by Arab newspapers, Blandford stands almost alone in the conviction that the refugees will move into towns and housing developments and get off the UN charity rolls if they are assured the move in no way prejudices their political rights to return to what used to be Palestine.

Blandford denied the rumor printed in the Middle East that he had returned here to resign. “I am optimistic,” says Blandford. “If I were not, I could not go on with this job.” Arab newspaper reporters heckle the UNRWA director in his press conferences but he refuses to become angry or annoyed.

“Isn’t it true,” asked Abed Bouhofa of Cairo’s Al Misri, “that you are trying to bribe or blackmail the Arab countries into resettling the refugees with promises of money for projects?”

Implore Living Conditions. “Those are your words, not mine,” said Blandford. “It is true that some projects could be available for those countries that show a humanitarian approach to helping with the refugees.” Blandford refuses to use the words “resettle” or “reintegrate.”

He claims that UNRWA is only trying to “improve living conditions and help the refugees become self-supporting.” The main trouble in the Arab refugee camps is that thousands are convinced that if they take regular jobs they will never get a chance to return to their homes in Israel.

Technically, they are waiting for Israel and the Arab states to complete a peace agreement, settle boundary disputes and allow them to return to their homes now occupied by Jews. The refugees have been told recently that they will never be allowed to return but most of them refuse to believe it.

Convince Governments. Blandford’s job is to convince the governments involved that they should set aside land on which the UN can build villages and resettle the refugees. The director says that a plan to irrigate the Jordan valley and to spend $11,000,000 on vocational training should take care of 100,000 of the 450,000 refugees in Jordan.

It is hoped that 300,000 can be moved to Syria and Iraq. There are only 80,000 refugees in Syria and projects under contemplation could absorb them quickly. Iraq has only a handful. The 200,000 in the Gaza strip which is administered by Egypt provide the most difficult problem.

A U.N. official refusing to use the words resettle or reintegrate, and an Egyptian newspaperman named in the story asking him whether the agency is bribing Arab governments. The paper writes “chased out of what now is Israel” in its own voice, in the first sentence.

CP-1952-002 →

· Worcester Telegram

Plan Jobs for 15,000 Palestine Refugees

BEIRUT, Lebanon, Sunday (AP)—Work will start soon of the Yarmuk River irrigation project which will offer jobs to 15,000 Palestine refugees. Technical advice is being provided under the U. S. Point 4 plan and the United Nations Relief and Works Agency is providing the funds.

CP-1952-006 →

· The Sacramento Bee · Sacramento, CA

5,500 Year Old Villages Are Found In Israel

TEL AVIV—AP—One of the most important recent discoveries of ancient ruins in Israel might not have been made if a 23 year old farm worker had not kept his eyes open. It happened that David Alon is not only interested in chickens and cauliflowers but in archeology as well.

Whenever he can take a day off at the Kibbuz (Jewish collective settlement) at Mishmar Hanegev, David roams the countryside looking for traces of the past. One day in the Negev Desert, he came across some pottery fragments which gave him a hunch there might be something more underground.

Because he told Jean Perrot, French archeologist in Jerusalem, about his find, two 5,500 year old villages have been excavated.

Two Ancient Villages Perrot visited the suspected areas near Beersheba in Southern Israel, made a preliminary survey and found he had been led by the young man to the site of two villages from the chalcolithic age (4500-3000 BC)—villages inhabited propably a thousand years before Abraham pitched his tent in the vicinity.

The French National Center of Scientific Research in Paris granted Perrot the financial support for further diggings. Sent to Israel in 1945, Perrot took part in excavating a 7,000 year old neolithic town near Abou Gosh and then assisted the late French consul general, Rene Neuville, in his stone age discoveries in various parts of the Judean hills.

Earlier there were other excavations dating back to the chalcolithic age here but no chalcolithic dwelling ever excavated in Israel or Mandatory Palestine was built in the fortress like tower form unearthed at Bir Abou Mater.

MARIA'S FLAGGED SLIDE. Folio above the headline reads only 'Sacramento, California'; no date is printed on the clipping, so the date is label-only in effect. No byline; AP credit in the dateline. There is no deck; 'Two Ancient Villages', 'No Round Houses' and 'Would Not Happen Today' are crossheads. PRINTER'S ERROR PRESERVED: 'villages inhabited propably a thousand years before Abraham' — 'propably' for 'probably', kept as printed. WORDS FOR THE PLACE, IN THE PAPER'S OWN SPELLING AND IN ITS OWN ORDER: 'Israel', 'Tel Aviv', 'the Kibbuz (Jewish collective settlement) at Mishmar Hanegev', 'the Negev Desert', 'Jerusalem', 'Beersheba in Southern Israel', 'Abou Gosh', 'the Judean hills', 'Israel or Mandatory Palestine', 'Teleilat-el-Ghassoul in the Jordan Valley southeast of Jericho, in what is now Hashemite Jordan territory', 'Bir Abou Mater', 'Cyprus and Mesopotamia', 'the copper mines exploited by King Solomon much later are far south of Beersheba, near the Red Sea coast', 'Ouadi Fennan (Fennan Valley) on the Hashemite Jordan side of the Dead Sea canyon', 'a place very close to Beersheba of today: the old Arab name of the site is Bir Abou Mater'. THE PALESTINIAN TOWNS NAMED, WITH THE PAPER'S SPELLING FIRST: - 'Beersheba' — Bi'r al-Sab‘, the Palestinian town of the northern Negev, depopulated in October 1948. The paper calls it 'Beersheba of today' and places it 'in Southern Israel'. - 'Bir Abou Mater' — Bi'r Abu Māṭir, given explicitly as 'the old Arab name of the site', a place 'very close to Beersheba'. - 'Abou Gosh' — Abu Ghosh, the Palestinian village west of Jerusalem whose inhabitants were not expelled in 1948. - 'Teleilat-el-Ghassoul' — Tulaylat al-Ghassul, across the river in Jordanian territory, named as such. - 'Ouadi Fennan' — Wadi Faynan, likewise in Jordan. WHAT IS ABSENT: 'Palestine' appears exactly once, as 'Mandatory Palestine', and only as the former administrative label of the ground under the dig. There are no Palestinians in the article. Arabic place names survive — Bir Abou Mater, Abou Gosh, Beersheba — but the paper frames them as archaeological conveniences ('the old Arab name of the site is...'), not as evidence that people lived there and named these places. The dig employs '15 local workers' and 'a Hebrew University graduate'; the 15 are never identified by nationality, and the sentence 'There is between the two countries a well guarded armistice frontier never crossed for trade except by smugglers' is the article's only acknowledgement that a line was drawn across this landscape five years earlier. The human story the paper chooses to tell is that of a 23-year-old Jewish kibbutz worker and a French archeologist. Columns beyond the ones noted were read at page magnification; the 'Mandatory Palestine' sentence, the 'old Arab name' sentence, the lede and the Beersheba paragraph were transcribed from magnified crops.

CP-1953-013 →

· The Courier News · Bridgewater

Arabs Ask Aid From Eisenhower

Beirut, Lebanon —(AP)— An appeal to President-elect Eisenhower to undo the “injustices” done to Palestine Arabs by recent American policy has been sent by 15 American and Arab members of the faculty of the American University of Beirut.

The cable congratulated Eisenhower on his victory and declared that the group “wish to express our confidence that you will redress the grave injustices done to the Arabs in Palestine and restore to American policy its traditional insistence upon justice and freedom of all peoples.”

CP-1953-004 →

· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia

Arab Exchange Urged on Israel

“A Moslem judge in Nazareth has proposed to Israel’s President, Izhak Ben-Zvi, that the Arab minority in Israel be exchanged for Jews in Arab countries. Sheik Taher el Tabari, a kadi or judge, told Ben-Zvi that such an exchange is the only way to avert a human tragedy.”

Four sentences from the Associated Press. A Palestinian judge inside Israel proposes that his own community be traded away, and calls it the only way to avert a tragedy. The paper gives the proposal no context, no reply from anyone it would move, and no second source.

CP-1953-011 →

· The Flint Journal · Flint · page 1

Million Homeless Palestinian Arabs Camped in Middle East

By Cynthia Davis, Women’s National News Service, Beirut, Lebanon

“Beirut, Lebanon — Nearly a million homeless Palestinian Arab refugees are camped out in the torrid lands of the Middle East today.

In Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Egypt, women and their husbands and children are living in tent cities or mud huts, cellars or stalls of horse barracks — one stall to a family, with a curtain of tattered potato sacks for a doorway… ‘This is my only home,’ said a middle-aged woman in tears as she surveyed her dirty cellar. ‘I am ashamed to live in such filth.

We were never rich, but my husband used to own his own drygoods store, and we were clean.’ Down the road an aged grandmother was sitting cross-legged on the ground. Before her was a tiny bundle of burlap, and suddenly it stirred. ‘This is my granddaughter,’ the white-haired woman said, raising her hurt and bewildered eyes. ‘Her mother is dead.

How am I going to take care of her?’ … in a tent city, only one family in every four or so has a kerosene stove to cook on… With a rationing of one half a cake of soap per person every two weeks, there is not much hope of keeping things clean.… “Communists in the area are making hopeful gestures toward these refugees, displaced when their Palestine homes became part of the new nation of Israel.”… “‘This is my granddaughter,’ the white-haired woman said, raising her hurt and bewildered eyes.

‘Her mother is dead. How am I going to take care of her?’”

How Indeed? “All of the refugees are lacking in proper housing and adequate food and medical care. Their clothing is in rags.”… “In a tent city, only one family in every four or so has a kerosene stove to cook on and what furniture they own is composed of second-hand scraps.

With a rationing of one half a cake of soap per person every two weeks, there is not much hope of keeping things clean. Time hangs heavy on everyone’s hands. But adults, after all, usually learn how to take things in their stride.”

What of their children? “Skinny, big-eyed toddlers—both boys and girls line up at the clinics. ‘This child has only six months to live,’ is the message doctors and internes give over and over again to the grieving parents. For lack of tents and teachers only one child in four can go to school, and then only through the sixth grade.

Many of the adolescent boys who should be doing productive work are roaming the roadways or listening to the flowered phrases of Communist agitators. There is no vocational training for these youths, no opportunity for them to obtain even the most menial jobs. The few orphanages are jammed to overflowing with lonely waifs.”

“Rags are their only clothes” · “Many live in ‘caves’ made from huge rocks, roofed with rags” · “‘De luxe’ housing is this barracks. Each family has a compartment”

Printed directly beside a Genesee Furniture advertisement: a free plastic lounge rocker with any living room suite, and a two-piece Kroehler suite in mohair frieze at $149.95.

CP-1953-002 →

· Portland Press Herald · Portland · page 1

U.N. Urged To Set Up Fund To Resettle Arab Refugees

Associated Press, United Nations, N.Y.

UNITED NATIONS, N. Y., Oct. 25 (AP)—A group of 33 American educators and religious leaders called on the U.N. today to set up funds totaling nearly a billion dollars to develop Middle East resources and resettle Arab refugees as a step to peace in the region.

Their memorandum was sent to top U.N. officials and to delegation heads of the 60 member nations with a plea that some U.N. committee take it up.

Needs Official Sponsor. Private communications of this sort, however, are generally merely filed here unless some delegation officially sponsors it. Among signers were Sumner Welles, former U. S. under secretary of state; William Emerson, Boston financier and president of the American Association for the United Nations; Paul Porter, former U.

S. representative on the U.N. Palestine Conciliation Commission; and Jacob S. Potofsky, head of the Amalgamated Clothing Workers Union.

Council Meets Tuesday. The Security Council will meet Tuesday to hear Syria’s charge that Israel’s irrigation and power projects in the Jordan Valley violated 1949 armistice agreements. The United States has cut off financial aid to Israel during a hearing of these charges.

A Council meeting Tuesday afternoon has been scheduled to hear an over-all report on the Israeli-Arab armistice situation from Gen. Vagn Bennike, Danish chief of the U.N. Truce Supervision Commission. His report and questioning by Council members in subsequent sessions is expected to delay further action on the Syrian complaint for some time.

Recent Israel-Jordan border clashes, which drew blasts against Israel from Britain and the U. S. State Department, are at the base of the meetings with Bennike.

Resettlement proposed as the solution, by thirty-three American educators and clergy, with no Palestinian among the signatories named. The item beneath it on the page is a Portuguese swimmer breaking the Gibraltar record.

CP-1953-001 →

· San Bernardino County Sun

U.N. Supervisor Condemns Israel For Bloody Raid

Says Such Flare-Ups Indicate Tension Is At ’Breaking Point’

UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. (UP) —The United Nations’ Palestine truce supervisor condemned Israel Tuesday for the bloody raid on Qibya and said such flare-ups indicate Israeli-Jordan tension has reached the “breaking point.” The U.N. Middle East trouble shooter, Maj. Gen. Vagn Bennike of Denmark, gave his report after U.N.

Secretary-general Dag Hammarskjold made a dramatic appeal to Israel and its Arab foes to avoid “provocative acts” that could worsen the situation. CONVINCED OF ACCURACY The two U.N. officials spoke at an emergency meeting of the U.N. Security Council.

Bennike, who flew here last week in answer to a council summons, said he was convinced of the accuracy of his truce team’s report, which found that regular Israeli troops carried out the Qibya operation and which condemned the government for the raid. Bennike also described the holy city of Jerusalem as “a dangerous powder keg.”

Israel has contended that the raid on Qibya, in which 53 Jordanese were killed and more than 40 homes razed, was made by irregular forces in reprisal for a Jordan raid that caused the death of a mother and two children.

ENDORSES VIEW Bennike endorsed the view of the Big Three western powers, who brought the Middle East situation to the U.N. following the Qibya raid, that the security of the area is threatened and that council intervention is called for. Western delegates are reported considering a resolution condemning Israel for the Qibya raid.

“The Qibya incident,” Bennike said, “and other incidents to which I have referred should be considered not as isolated incidents, but as culminating points or high fever marks. “They indicated that tension had increased to breaking point, either locally, in a particular area, or perhaps generally between the two countries.”

CP-1953-008 →

· The Birmingham News · Birmingham

‘The Shells Were Made In America’ — Claim In Israel Action Points At U.S.

Dorothy Thompson

ON WEDNESDAY this column received an unsolicited report from members of the small American community in Jerusalem on the events in the Jordanian village of Qibya last Oct. 14. Of the veracity of my correspondents, whom I know well, I have no doubt. They confirm the report of Gen.

Bennike, UN truce supervisor, to the UN, and write: “We have seen the ruins of the massacre at Qibya. “In addition to what you must already have read, there are details that are quite important. At 7:30 p.m. Oct. 14 a scouting patrol killed an Arab watchman whose companion escaped.

Two hours later a barrage of heavy artillery fire preceded an attack by approximately half a battalion of regular Israeli soldiers. A local national guard unit of 30 Arabs held them up for a very short time. In spite of messages by telephone and radio, only seven soldiers of the Arab Legion (the Jordanian Army, commanded by the British Gen. Glubb) ever appeared.

The local indignation over this may become very serious. The Israeli troops blew up the schoolhouse first, then the milk distributing center operated by the Lutheran World Federation, and then 41 houses, after, in several cases, shooting the families inside them with automatic weapons. “We visited the scene next day.

The village of nearly 2,000 inhabitants is a mile inside the frontier line. Budrus, which also was shelled by mortars that are standard equipment of the Israeli Army, is nearer the frontier. Everything points to a systematic, planned attack. “Thus far 66 bodies have been recovered. Only 10 were males of military age—the rest are women and children.

The Israel press claims the action was in reprisal for the murder by persons unknown of Mrs. Susan Kanias and her two children, the Tuesday before, in the Israeli village of Moshav Yakud, 10 miles from Qibya.”

CP-1953-005 →

· The News Journal · Wilmington, DE

No Peace in Palestine

WHEN the United States and Britain expressed horror at the recent Israel-Jordan border incident, followed by temporary suspension of American aid to Israel, we remarked that judgment should be suspended until more facts were available. Most of the news at that time consisted of statements on the incident by parties to it.

Now, however, the United Nations Security Council has heard a lengthy report by General Bennike of Denmark, heading the UN truce supervision group in Palestine. In addition, Israel has made a conciliatory gesture, and American aid has been restored. His report tells of great tension on both sides, violence by both sides, with great danger to the peace of Palestine.

Each side apparently feels honestly convinced that its acts of aggression are justified as defense against the aggression of the other side. Each side feels that the other "started it." This sort of background feeling, as long as it continues, will block essential cooperation and breed more incidents by both sides.

The background is so voluminous that the general could have written volumes without including it all, so he limited himself to incidents occurring in 1953. Perhaps the initial cause of the whole business occurred in 1917, when Britain made conflicting promises to Arabs and Jews.

Then, after World War I, Arabs who with British help had won their freedom from the tyrannical Turks might have been less unwilling to let the Jews have part of Palestine than they were after World War II.

The UN failed to settle the problem peaceably, an Arab-Israeli war was fought, ending in temporary truce agreements which, as General Bennike points out, "have lasted too long not to have lost part of their effectiveness." The existence of almost 900,000 Arab displaced persons, mostly in the Palestine area, makes the problem almost insoluble.

Neither side can provide for them without outside help, and the two sides disagree on the kind of arrangement they will agree to. Eric Johnston is now in Palestine as trouble-shooter trying to overcome this impasse. Unless he succeeds, the outlook for peace in Palestine is poor.

Bennike's report is a dreary account of innumerable incidents involving outrages by each side in turn. "Infiltration" is the root of the trouble. Arabs, many of them refugees, cross the Israel borders to steal, loot, and kill. Arab governments cannot control them, and, in Israel's opinion, don't even try.

Armed forces from Israel make wanton retaliatory attacks on Arab villages. Fixing the blame in each case is of little value. Without control of infiltration—which is hardly possible without resettlement of refugees—no permanent solution is in sight.

ONE RECORD FROM TWO IMAGES, per Maria's note. s076_2 is the top of the editorial — headline 'No Peace in Palestine', drop cap W, first three paragraphs ending at 'Perhaps the initial cause of' — and s076_1 is the continuation, beginning 'the whole business occurred in 1917'. The join is verified: s076_2's last visible words run straight into s076_1's first. No masthead, no folio, no printed date; date is label-only. An unsigned EDITORIAL — note the first-person plural, 'we remarked that judgment should be suspended' — so there is no byline and no deck. The 'recent Israel-Jordan border incident' is the Qibya raid of 14-15 October 1953, in which Israeli forces under Ariel Sharon's Unit 101 killed some 69 villagers, two-thirds of them women and children; the editorial never names Qibya, never gives a death toll and never says a village was destroyed. WORDS FOR THE PLACE AND PEOPLE: 'Palestine' six times — 'No Peace in Palestine', 'the UN truce supervision group in Palestine', 'the peace of Palestine', 'let the Jews have part of Palestine', 'mostly in the Palestine area', 'now in Palestine', 'the outlook for peace in Palestine'. For people: 'Arabs and Jews', 'Arabs', 'the Jews', 'Arab governments', 'Arab villages', 'almost 900,000 Arab displaced persons', 'refugees', 'Arabs, many of them refugees', 'the two sides', 'both sides', 'each side', 'Israel', 'Israel's opinion', 'the Turks'. WHAT IS ABSENT: the word 'Palestinian' does not appear. The 900,000 are 'Arab displaced persons' — displaced by no stated agent, in a sentence where their mere 'existence' is what 'makes the problem almost insoluble'. They are a problem, not a people. The paper's solution is 'resettlement of refugees', with no mention of return. Nobody who lives in Palestine is named or quoted; the only person quoted is a Danish general. The structure is explicitly both-sides — 'violence by both sides', 'outrages by each side in turn', 'Fixing the blame in each case is of little value' — and the paper's one plainly worded condemnation of Israeli conduct is immediately neutralised by that refusal to fix blame.

CP-1953-014 →

· Houston Chronicle · Houston

U.S.-Britain Blamed In Qibya Massacre

“It is moving to see the remaining inhabitants staying in their homes, their cows, sheep and donkeys killed and they themselves dead to fear or hope. They are completely cynical, anticipating no aid from anybody nor any defense of their case.”

Dorothy Thompson, from an unsolicited report sent to her by Americans living in Jerusalem, about Qibya on 14 October 1953. The word in the headline is massacre, in 1953. Three years later, when Israeli border police shot forty-eight people at Kafr Qasim, no American paper in this archive puts that word in a headline until an Israeli military court convicts eight of them, in October 1958. It was in print well before that, in the body of a Newsday story on 13 December 1956 and inside an Arab League protest printed by the New York Times two days later. The word was available. It stayed out of the headlines for twenty-two months.

CP-1953-012 →

· The Jersey Journal · Jersey City

Say Israeli Fired on Town

JERUSALEM (UP) — Jordan officials charged today that 60 Israeli soldiers launched an attack last night on the Arab border village of Budrus, two miles south of Qibya where Israelis killed more than 40 persons last month. Soldiers of the Arab Legion and Jordani National Guardsmen returned Israeli gunfire in a 90-minute fight, the Jordan officials said.

No Arab casualties were reported. REPORTED TO U. N. Jordan reported the alleged attack to United Nations Armistice Commission officials here. They also cabled details to Gen. Vagne Bennike, chief of the U. N. Mixed Armistice Commission, who is in New York to appear Wednesday before the U. N. Security Council. U.

N. observers visited the scene today to investigate the latest reported incident in the series of clashes that have disturbed the truce along the Jordan-Israel border. NO ISRAEL REPORT There were no immediate reports from Israel on the Jordan claim of a Budrus attack. The U. N. Armistice Commission blamed Israeli troops for the Oct. 14 attack on Qibya. The incident spurred U.

N. Security Council debate on Arab-Israeli relations at the request of the United States, Britain and France. Israel claimed the Qibya incident grew out of Jordani attacks on Israelis near the border. GARRISON VILLAGE The village of Budrus, near Qibya, is a small garrison for Arab troops.

Because there were too few soldiers there to go to Qibya’s aid when it was attacked, the Jordan government ordered an investigation. Following the Qibya attack, Israel accused Jordan terroists of blowing up an Israeli freight train near the border. Yesterday an explosion cut the main pipeline carrying water to the Arab portion of the divided city of Jerusalem.

In Tel Aviv, an Israeli military spokesman denied charges by Jordan officials that Israeli police stationed at Hadassah Hospital on Mount Scopus—an Israeli enclave in the middle of Arab territory—blew up the pipeline.

CP-1953-006 →

· The Republican · Springfield

Arabs Claim New Attack By Israelis

No Casualties Reported in 90-Minute Fight at a Jordan Village

Jerusalem, Nov. 3 (AP)—Jordan officials charged today that 60 Israeli soldiers launched an attack last night on the Arab border village of Budrus, two miles south of Qibya where Israelis killed more than 40 persons last month. Soldiers of the Arab Legion and Jordani national guardsmen returned Israeli gunfire in a 90-minute fight, the Jordan officials said.

No Arab casualties were reported. Jordan reported the alleged attack to United Nations Armistice Commission officials here. They also cabled details to Gen. Vagne Bennike, chief of the UN Mixed Armistice Commission, who is in New York to appear Wednesday before the UN Security Council.

UN observers visited the scene today to investigate the latest reported incident in the series of clashes that have disturbed the truce along the Jordan-Israel border. There were no immediate reports from Israel on the Jordan claim of a Budrus attack. The UN Armistice Commission blamed Israeli troops for the Oct. 14 attack on Qibya.

The incident spurred the UN Security Council debate on Arab-Israeli relations at the request of the United States, Britain and France. Israel claimed the Qibya incident grew out of Jordani attacks on Israelis near the border. The village of Budrus, near Qibya, is a small garrison for Arab troops.

Because there were too few soldiers there to go to Qibya’s aid when it was attacked, the Jordan government ordered an investigation. Following the Qibya attack, Israel accused Jordan terrorists of blowing up an Israeli freight train near the border. Yesterday an explosion cut the main pipeline carrying water to the Arab portion of the divided city of Jerusalem.

CP-1953-007 →

· The Troy Record · Troy

Arab Village Attacked By Israeli Force

Jerusalem, Jordan (UP)—Jordan officials charged today that 60 Israeli soldiers launched an attack last night on the Arab border village of Budrus, two miles south of Qibya where Israelis killed more than 40 persons last month. Soldiers of the Arab Legion and Jordani national guardsmen returned Israeli gunfire in a 90-minute fight, the Jordan officials said.

No Arab casualties were reported. Jordan reported the alleged attack to United Nations Armistice Commission officials here. They also cabled details to Gen. Vagne Bennike, chief of the U.N. Mixed Armistice Commission, who is in New York to appear Wednesday before the U.N. Security Council.

U.N. observers visited the scene today to investigate the latest reported incident in the series of clashes that have disturbed the truce along the Jordan-Israel border. There were no immediate reports from Israel on the Jordan claim of a Budrus attack. The U.N. Armistice Commission blamed Israeli troops for the Oct. 14 attack on Qibya. The incident spurred the U.N.

Security Council debate on Arab-Israeli relations at the request of the United States, Britain and France. Israel claimed the Qibya incident grew out of Jordani attacks on Israelis near the border. The village of Budrus, near Qibya, is a small garrison for Arab troops.

Because there were too few soldiers there to go to Qibya’s aid when it was attacked, the Jordan government ordered an investigation.

Correction: The deck caption gave a shorter name than the masthead prints. Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 163 clippings in this deck.

CP-1953-010 →

· San Bernardino County Sun

Shells Used In Massacre Made In America

Dorothy Thompson

This column has received an unsolicited report from members of the small American community in Jerusalem on the events in the Jordanian village of Qibya last Oct. 14. Of the veracity of my correspondents, whom I know well, I have no doubt. They confirm the report of Gen.

Bennike, U.N. truce supervisor, to the U.N., and write: “WE HAVE seen the ruins of the massacre at Qibya. “In addition to what you must already have read there are details that are quite important. At 7:30 p.m. Oct. 14 a scouting patrol killed an Arab watchman whose companion escaped.

Two hours later a barrage of heavy artillery fire preceded an attack by approximately half a battalion of regular Israeli soldiers. A local national guard unit of 30 Arabs held them up for a very short time. In spite of messages by telephone and radio, only seven soldiers of the Arab legion (the Jordanian army, commanded by the British Gen. Glubb) ever appeared.

The local indignation over this may become very serious. The Israeli troops blew up the schoolhouse first, then the milk distributing center operated by the Lutheran World Federation, and then 41 houses, after, in several cases, shooting the families inside them with automatic weapons. “WE VISITED the scene next day.

The village of nearly 2,000 inhabitants is a mile inside the frontier line. Budrus, which also was shelled by mortars that are standard equipment of the Israeli army, is nearer the frontier. Everything points to a systematic, planned attack. “Thus far 66 bodies have been recovered. Only 10 were males of military age — the rest are women and children.

The Israel press claims the action was in reprisal for the murder by persons unknown of Mrs. Susan Kanias and her two children, the Tuesday before, in the Israeli village of Moshav Yakud, 10 miles from Qibya.”

(Note: At the time of this incident the American press reported that the Jordan government had consented to allow Israel soldiers accompanied by bloodhounds to enter Jordan territory in an attempt to trace the assassins. Apparently they did not find them.) “It is difficult to believe that even the Stern gang would be guilty of such a calculated inhuman massacre.

But it was not the work of terrorists. It was a regular military action. “TO US Americans the most painful sight was the number of cartridge cases lying about with the name of the U.S. manufacturer stamped on them. We have been told they were fired from British guns. Certainly the Arabs use British ordnance.

One is ashamed to think of the sorry share of both the U.S. and Great Britain in this dreadful situation. “It is moving to see the remaining inhabitants staying in their homes, their neighbors, cows, sheep and donkeys killed and they themselves dead to fear or hope. They are completely cynical, anticipating no aid from anybody nor any defense of their case.”

SECRETARY of State Dulles, had been barraged with a veritable avalanche of protests because he had halted and suspended aid to Israel in the face of current charges. But if a foreign army depends upon the United States for its ammunition, the United States can hardly avoid a share of responsibility for the use to which the ammunition is put.

Certainly the American people, Jewish or non-Jewish, have no desire to participate in blowing up an Arab milk center — also partly financed by Americans — or machine gunning women and children in their homes, or blowing up those homes over their heads, no matter for what reprisals. “The name of the U.S. manufacturer was stamped on the cartridge shells.”

CP-1953-009 →

· Courier-Journal · Louisville

Readers’ Point of View: Three Discussions of Arab-Israeli Discord

“READERS’ POINT OF VIEW: Three Discussions of Arab-Israeli Discord To The Editor Of The Courier-Journal: I wish to correct several factual errors which appeared in the letters of Edwin Hanna and Virginia Matthias in Readers’ Point of View December 15. In speaking of the regrettable Kibya incident, Mr.

Hanna states that the attack was in retaliation for two or three Israeli killed. He fails to mention that since 1950, 421 Israeli were killed by Jordanian marauders. Of these murders, 107 occurred from 1952 until October of this year.

The good lady from Berea says the Arabs cross the border illegally merely to visit their kinsfolk in Israel or cross into Israel (a great many of these infiltrations occur in the dead of the night) to ward off starvation.

The fact is that since 1950 when Great Britain, France and the United States guaranteed order and security in the area, there have been 128 cases of sabotage, 866 cases of armed attack, and 3,263 cases of robbery by the Arabs. The Arabs have rustled cattle, blown up factories, trains and homes, and have even stolen telegraph poles and cables. Mr.

Hanna says that General Bennike reported to the United Nations ‘that the responsibility for the major incidents are about equally divided.’ The fact is that from June, 1952, to June, 1953, the Arab-Israel mixed Armistice Commission ruled against Jordan in 159 cases as against Israel in 25 cases.

In conclusion, I wish to say that the only hope lies in peace between the Arab States and Israel. This the United Nations can accomplish by insisting that the Arab States engage in peace negotiations with Israel. Otherwise, border incidents will continue to occur in the tensions of the uneasy armistice. RUTH N. FONAROFF. Louisville.

Peace Needed in Palestine The two letters in The Courier-Journal, one by Edwin B. Hanna captioned ‘Israel-Arab Border Trouble,’ the other, ‘About Arab Infiltration,’ by Virginia P. Matthias, could easily be answered point by point; however, the crux of the problem is rooted much deeper than mere border incidents.

It has been said that there would be no anti-Semitism if there were no Jews, and there would be no Arab-Israel tension, if there would be no Israel, but God willed it otherwise.

The aim of the Arabs (feudal chiefs, not the masses) is to destroy Israel by various and devious methods, such as the boycott, propaganda, using the Arab refugees to incite world opinion against Israel.

It would be well for all of us to remember, when the Nazi hordes were at the gates of Alexandria and were about to converge on the Holy Land and the entire Middle East, the Chief Rabbi of Palestine, Isaac Halevi Herzog, spoke up to a trembling and fearful world and calmed their fears. He said, ‘Do not despair.

The divine scriptures only tell of two destructions; therefore have faith there will not be a third destruction.’ And so it was. The Nazi hordes were driven back and their retreat did not stop until they surrendered unconditionally.

The same is true today with regard to the Arab chiefs and their backers and sympathizers the world over, and, contrary to and in spite of their condemnation of the godless and the anti-god, as the Communists are called, they also are in the same category; because they also are attempting to defeat the will of providence. Senator Guy M.

Gillette, of Iowa, of the Foreign Relations Committee, who has spent some time in the Middle East and has also visited Syria, spoke in Chicago November 15 on, ‘The United States, Israel and the Middle East.’

He said, ‘When Ralph Bunche dealt with the Palestine armistice talks on Cyprus some years ago, he told both sides, “You sit here until you reach an armistice agreement, and the one who walks out will be the one blamed for the collapse of these negotiations”.’

He asked further, ‘What lies behind the hesitation to take the same forthright stand in the present case?’

Continuing, Senator Gillette said, ‘without peace there can be no possible defense against aggression from outside the area, no security against internal Communist subversion and seizure of power, no adequate economic development for any of the countries, singly or together, no possible solution of any of the grave social, financial, and political problems that cry for swift remedy.’

Let us pray that the great powers insist that future border incidents are rendered impossible by removing once and for all their primary cause—the absence of peace. HARRY SIMON. Louisville.

Arabs in Israel Called Happy Edwin B. Hanna in Readers’ Point of View states that ‘The Courier-Journal has been accused by M. Heller of being anti-Israel and pro-Arab. Perhaps The Courier-Journal is more pro-truth. I appreciate its being willing to show both sides of the question.’ If Mr. E. B.

Hanna really knew the truth, he wouldn’t have made the statement: ‘Israel has admitted that regular troops were involved in the Kibya massacre of 66 people.’

We may have complete confidence in the official statements made by the former prime minister of Israel, Ben Gurion, and the Israeli ambassador to the United States, Abba Eban, in which they categorically denied The Courier-Journal’s ‘pro-truth’ story that Israeli regular troops were involved in the Kibya incident. Mr.

Hanna said ‘Arabs were driven out of their homes to make room for Israel.’

The real truth of the matter is that the Israel government has been begging the Arabs to remain in Israel, promising them all the rights and privileges; but the Arabs were persuaded by the Mufti and the British to leave Israel in order to create out of them an army for the future invasion of Israel.

According to the information received from people who recently visited Israel, the Arabs, who didn’t listen to the Mufti and the British but remained living in Israel, are nicely progressing materially and morally and are very happy. Louisville. M. HELLER.

Shocked at Segregation View I was really shocked when I read the opinion of George C. Allen, who favors segregation.

I wonder if he actually believes that the ‘financial success’ of a small segment of the ‘colored race’ is sufficient criterion for ‘maintaining for their children as fine schools as whites,’ even with government and state aid, while maintaining segregation. What real good could this dual system incorporate?

How does this idea of separation affect the thinking and attitudes of both the colored child and the white child? No good can be derived from such a system because of the added burden on the government, federal and local. The end result is a heavier financial weight on every adult resident, white and colored.

The colored child will automatically have a feeling of being below the normal level of an average American child. The white child will feel superior. We can readily discern the product when both of these American children have become adults.

To say that ‘the spirit of Communism is abroad in our land, seeking to cause ill feeling between the white and colored people’ as Mr. Allen remarked, implies that the present condition of segregation is Utopia, and is highly acceptable as being good for all. I wonder how Mr.

Allen would feel if fate and God had put him in the situation of being born with a colored pigmentation. Would he decree upon himself such segregation? The whole is equal to the sum of its parts; America is, therefore, equal to the sum of all its citizens. EDWARD E. THORNTON. Louisville.”

The other half of an argument this archive has been holding one side of. Three readers in Louisville answer two earlier letters by name — Edwin B. Hanna’s Israel-Arab Border Trouble and Virginia P. Matthias’s About Arab Infiltration, both printed on 15 December — and they argue over Qibya, over who left in 1948 and why, and over whether the paper is pro-Arab or, as one of them puts it, pro-truth. It is the fullest multi-round exchange about Palestine between ordinary American readers anywhere in this collection. And it is not alone in the column. Two letters to the right, on the same page of the same paper, a reader answers another reader who favors segregation: The whole is equal to the sum of its parts; America is, therefore, equal to the sum of all its citizens. Louisville is arguing about Palestine and about its own schools in the same six columns, eighteen months before Brown reached Kentucky.

CP-1953-003 →

· Oregon Daily Journal · Portland

Arab Refugee Problem Laid to Arab Aggression

“It may, alas, be true that Israel’s achievements in providing homes for Jewish refugees present an ‘inspiring picture’ in contrast to the ‘tragic plight’ of refugees in the Arab countries. Who is responsible for the creation of this tragic plight, and its continuation to date?”

A letter to the Oregon Daily Journal, printed under The People Speak. The headline settles the question the letter is asking. Both ‘inspiring picture’ and ‘tragic plight’ carry quotation marks; the cause does not.

CP-1954-016 →

· Courier-Journal · Louisville

Calls Palestine Deal All Wrong

Yasir A. Khammash, Louisville

“It surprises me that the recent incident of Kibya village… gets all this attention while it really does not count when compared with previous inhuman acts committed against Arabs during previous years. Those incidents, I believe, never had been mentioned by the newspapers, fearing that the advertisement business may go down… My home is in Jerusalem.”

A Palestinian in Kentucky telling an American newspaper, in its own letters column, that American newspapers do not report massacres of Arabs, and naming advertising as the reason. The mechanism he names is an accusation, not a finding. What is not in doubt is that the complaint was being made in print in 1954, which means the silence this archive measures was audible to the people it was about while it was happening.

CP-1954-003 →

· Asheville Citizen Times · Asheville

Anti-British Influence At New High As Palestinians Take Lead In Jordan

Interpreting The News

By Wilton Wynn, Associated Press

AMMAN, Jordan (AP)—Arabs still refer to Jordan as a “British puppet,” but British influence in this desert kingdom has been declining steadily. Since the assassination of King Abdullah in 1951 British power has slipped steadily. A freely-elected Parliament replaced the monarchy as the country’s real power.

The rise of anti-British Palestinians in the government made the British position more difficult… Late in 1951, the Jordan constitution was altered to make the government responsible to Parliament instead of to the King. This change has given added power to the half million Palestinians added to Jordan after the Arab-Israeli war of 1948.

Palestinians now form a slight majority in the country. One-third of Jordan’s population are refugees who left homes in what is now Israel. The Palestinians hold Britain largely responsible for loss of their homes. Palestinian, and with it anti-British, influence has reached a new high in the current cabinet of Dr. Fawzi Mulki. Palestinians hold half the 10 portfolios.

Because of their aggressiveness and ability, these men dominate the cabinet. Led by Foreign Minister Hussein Khalidy, Minister of Economy Anwar Khatib, and Minister of Education Ahmed Toukan, this group can rally the nation on any given issue… When Israeli attackers killed 60 Arabs in Kibya village last Oct.

14, British officers in the Legion came under fire from the public. The British were accused of refusing to send aid to Kibya, even though the attack lasted eight hours. Mass demonstrations carried “down with Glubb” banners and slogans — the first time demonstrators ever have attacked the general by name.

An Associated Press explainer in an Asheville paper in January 1954, and it is one of the plainest pieces of political writing about Palestinians in this archive. Palestinians now form a slight majority in the country. They hold half the cabinet, and three of them are named with their portfolios. They hold Britain largely responsible for loss of their homes. And the piece states as fact that Israeli attackers killed 60 Arabs at Kibya the previous October — the killing a reader of the Courier-Journal would be told two weeks later to produce the evidence for (CP-1954-004). Here it is a dependent clause in a wire story about British influence.

CP-1954-001 →

· Courier-Journal · Louisville

Arab Claim Called Unfounded

Harry Simon, Louisville

“In the letter captioned, ‘Calls Palestine Deal All Wrong,’ Yasir A. Khammash talks about the ‘massacre’ of Deir Yassin… I ask him to produce the evidence; heresay and generalities are not proof.”

The reply, eleven days later, from one of the three writers Khammash had been answering. The word massacre goes inside quotation marks and the evidence is demanded. By January 1954 testimony from Deir Yassin had been in the Evening Star of Washington for nearly six years, in a survivor’s own words. The material existed. It had stopped being in anyone’s hands. “heresay” is as printed.

CP-1954-004 →

· Portsmouth Star · Portsmouth

Can Israel Survive?

Nation’s Delegate to UN Says ‘Yes’ But Egypt’s Naguib Says ‘Impossible”

An International News Service piece built as two voices answering one question. The refugees appear inside it as a problem to be solved rather than as people with a position of their own, which is the shape most of the 1950s coverage here takes.

CP-1954-017 →

· The Daily Progress · Charlottesville

Palestine Refugees Who Lost ’48 War Between Israel And Arab Neighbors Still Ragged, Sullen

Lynn Heinzerling, Associated Press, Jerusalem

These are the Palestine refugees — 868,350 of them officially… Each year, 25,000 new refugees are born… all line up and receive from UNRWA 22 pounds of flour… This totally lasts about 20 days… The Palestine Arabs always were among the most literate of Middle Eastern peoples… Dr.

Izzat Tannous… calls the UNRWA ration one on which “an animal could hardly live.”

First of a series; the correspondent traveled 2,600 miles and talked with scores of people, which this collection holds very little of. The bottom half of the page is a January furniture sale.

CP-1954-005 →

· Evening World Herald

Tiny Nazareth Boiling Over

“The Communist Party is only a negligible force in the rest of Israel, but its considerable strength in Nazareth is largely due to the fact that it has consistently and loudly assumed the role of champion of the 170 thousand members of the Arab minority in Israel.”

Reuters, on the first popular election in Nazareth’s history. The frame is the Hammer and Sickle against the Cross in the town where Christ grew up, which is how an Omaha paper was going to sell it. Inside that frame is the fact that mattered for the next forty years: the only party campaigning for Palestinian citizens of Israel was the Communist Party, and that is why they voted for it.

CP-1954-007 →

· The New York Times · New York

9 Slain in Jordan in Raid on Village; Israelis Blamed

NAHHALIN, Jordan, March 29 — Nine persons were killed… Mosque Is Sacked, 6 Homes Bombed in Midnight Attack.

Kennett Love, in the village, for the New York Times. Read the dateline and the headline together: the village is Nahhalin and the country is Jordan. Nahhalin is a Palestinian village that had been under Jordanian administration for five years. In the headline it is simply Jordan, and the nine dead have no nationality at all.

CP-1954-008 →

· The New York Times · New York

Attack at Nahhalin

“The Jordan-Israel Mixed Armistice Commission (with the Israelis absent) has condemned in the strongest terms the ‘aggression’ by a ‘large group of military-trained Israelis’ against the Jordanian village of Nahhalin.”

The Jordanian village of Nahhalin. The adjective is administrative and it is doing the work a national one would otherwise do.

CP-1954-009 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco

Nine at Nahhalin

“It was midnight. Hefting automatic weapons, hand grenades, mines and Molotov cocktails, 240 Israelis crossed the armistice line and knifed into the Jordan village of Nahhalin.”

San Francisco, filed under a standing heading that reads ISRAEL. The prose is vivid about the weapons and silent about who lived there. The Jordan village again.

CP-1954-010 →

· estimated · Hopewell News

Israel Uses Films In Effort To Keep Bedouins Settled

BEERSHEBA — (U.P.) — With their camels parked outside to chew contentedly on orange peel, Bedouin tribesmen are packing the motion picture theater in this ancient town of Israel, to watch and shout their approval of the antics of Mickey Mouse.

Mickey Mouse, Bob Hope and Tarzan are all part of Israel’s campaign to get some 15,000 primitive — though romantic — tribesmen to settle down in civilization. Whatever the tribesmen may think of the program, they like the movies, and the Negev military governor has relaxed movement restrictions so they can come here once a week.

Politics have cut across the Bedouins’ freedom to roam the desert wilderness in search of pasture for their goats. Bedouins in Israel are now limited to the Negev, which thrusts a wedge between Jordan and the Sinai Desert.

Parts of the same tribes wander through Israel, Jordan and Egypt, disregarding frontiers and sometimes smuggling arms or hasheesh or stealing each other’s herds. But rigid frontiers are forcing the Bedouin slowly to abandon the nomadic life. With an eye to peace and security, Israel wants them to settle down.

A pipeline running from Beersheba into the parched hills has enabled some tribes to pitch permanent camp The only fixed encampment north of here is quite “tame.” In fact, it is already well on the way to being spoiled by tourists, who come to buy silver-hilted daggers rather than the modern souvenirs available in cities.

Sheik Suleiman, the best-known Negev chieftain, has bought himself an American car for trips to town, although he still uses a camel for jaunts to see the children of his 49 wives.

Date check: No masthead, folio line or page date is on this clipping — it is a two-column cut from an inside page (the adjacent column carries a “Boxwood Shrubs Hard To Grow In North Climes” feature and a “LESCO’S HERE! See Friday’s NEWS” advertisement). The story is undated United Press copy with only a “BEERSHEBA” place line, so neither 1954-04-08 nor the Hopewell News attribution can be confirmed from the image.

CP-1954-018 →

· Telegram & Gazette · Worcester

Russia Blocks Action On Middle East Row

“Tension is dangerously high in the Middle East.”

Ten days after Nahhalin the story has become a Security Council procedural fight, and this is the clipping Maria marked. It is the mechanism by which these raids entered the American press at all: a complaint goes to the United Nations, the wire covers the complaint, and the village appears as its subject line.

CP-1954-011 →

· The Patriot-News · Harrisburg

U.S. Warns Israel and Jordan in U.N.

“The U.S. warned Israel and Jordan… the Arab complaint filed on behalf of Jordan by Lebanon.”

Both sides warned equally, five days after one side crossed an armistice line at midnight and killed nine people in a village.

CP-1954-012 →

· The New York Times · New York

Arabs Threaten to Boycott U.N. On Frontier Feud With Israel

Malik to Quit Security Council if More Than Nahhalin Raid Is Debated

By KENNETT LOVE

Kennett Love again, now from Amman. Frontier feud is the headline's word for it. The paper that had a reporter standing in Nahhalin eleven days earlier is now covering the diplomacy of Nahhalin.

CP-1954-013 →

· The New York Times · New York

New Israeli Attack Charged

“Israelis opened fire across the armistice line at 3:30 P.M. yesterday on shepherds tending flocks at Wadi Fukin.”

Shepherds, named by occupation, in a village the headline does not name. Four paragraphs, a fortnight after Nahhalin, in the same valley.

CP-1954-014 →

· Caravan · Brooklyn

Arabs Quit U.S. Function Angered By Israeli Speech

“Five Arab diplomats in Washington, D. C., were so angered by an Israeli speech at a government luncheon on April 8, that they got up and walked out.”

Caravan, an Arab-American weekly. The same fortnight, and the story that reaches print is a walkout at a luncheon.

CP-1954-015 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago

Court Dooms Palestinian as Gaza Spy for Israel

Reuters, Cairo

CAIRO, Egypt, June 11 [Reuters]—A military tribunal in Gaza, coastal strip on the borders of Egypt and Israel, today sentenced to death a Palestinian, Hassan Abu Haggag, for spying for Israel. It sentenced another Palestinian, Mohamed Mahmoud Abu Mussa, to life imprisonment on a similar charge.

Egypt announced yesterday the government which occupied Gaza in 1948 “to preserve the area for the Arabs,” would shortly grant it self-government.

Two hundred words of wire copy in Chicago in June 1954, and three things in it. The noun is Palestinian, used twice, as a nationality, ten years before the Palestine Liberation Organization existed. Two ordinary Palestinians are named in full. And the last sentence says plainly that Egypt occupied Gaza in 1948, with Egypt’s own stated reason in quotation marks — to preserve the area for the Arabs — and a promise of self-government. The item beside it on the page is about a suit and a wallet taken from a parked car.

CP-1954-002 →

· Sidney Daily News · Sidney

Eisenhower Envoy Feels Shaky Palestine Pact Will Prevent War

By Pierre J. Huss, International News Service

UNITED NATIONS, N. Y. (INS)—Eric Johnston said today after his latest trip to the Middle East for President Eisenhower that in his opinion the Palestine armistice, though shaky, will prevent an outbreak of war between Israel and the Arabs.

Johnston, acting as President Eisenhower’s special White House emissary to win Arab-Jewish co-operation in developing a Middle East “TVA” by harnessing the Jordan River and transforming arid land into productive farms, has just completed his third trip to Palestine.

He grappled with what has been called “an impossible task” by personally negotiating with and trying to win over the key leaders of the nations directly concerned with the Jordan Valley “TVA” project—Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Israel. His third trip was fruitful; his next is hoped to be a decisive one.

Johnston in an exclusive question and answer interview with this correspondent, canvassed the outlook for President Eisenhower’s “peace project.” The questions and answers follow: Q. On the basis of your recent discussions, what real possibilities do you see for outracing the shaky armistice situation with a workable scheme for developing the Jordan Valley?

A. I think the chances are very good. First of all, while the armistice situation is admittedly shaky, I personally believe that the statesmen of both the Arab nations and Israel are determined to exercise restraint. They seemed to me to be fully conscious of the immense responsibility which rests upon them, not merely for local peace but for world peace.

So if your question implies that the armistices may break down with resulting open hostilities, I do not agree that this is likely—possibly, yes, but not likely. Therefore I think there is every chance that we shall be able to get something going in the Jordan Valley despite the tensions which exist. Q.

Did your recent Palestine visit actually result in a perceptible advance toward common ground where the spokesmen for Israel and Jordan, for example, sat down together or indicated such a possibility? A. No, it did not. We have not asked them to get together, and I have no intention of doing so.

In the tense political atmosphere which still pervades the area, I just don’t think it possible to persuade the Arab countries to sit down to a conference table with Israel. We are therefore dealing with them separately—the Arab countries on one hand and Israel on the other.

CP-1954-006 →

· Fort Pierce Tribune

This Shriner Is Real Thing

MIAMI (AP)—One of the nobles clad in the colorful garb of a Shriner during the Southeastern Shrine convention here is the real thing—an Arabian. He is Abraham Audi, a native of Ramallah, Arabia, and now a resident of Miami. Now 66, he once was titular head of a tribe of 5,000 horsemen.

During the current Shrine convention he is acting as an aide to illustrious potentate Henry E. Kopplow of Miami’s Mahi Temple, of which both are members. Audi, then bearing the title of sheik, first came to the United States when 14 to appear in an exhibit of Jerusalem at the St. Louis World’s Fair.

Back home, he was drafted into the Turkish army but fled and joined the French. He returned to the United States in 1907, served in the First World War as an intelligence officer, and finally settled in Miami. He married a Chicagoan, Madge Mallory. He became active in the fraternal order known as the Ancient Arabic Order of Nobles of the Mystic Shrine—the Shrine.

CP-1954-019 →

· Sacramento Union · Sacramento · page 1

Who Owns Palestine?

Letters to the Editor

Anwar Ali Khan

“To the Editor of The Sacramento Union: I would like to give ‘country parson’ some information concerning his letter to The Sacramento Union of December 31st. It is an incontrovertible fact that Palestine belongs to the Arabs, lock, stock, and barrel. More, it has been the cradle of Arab culture and civilization from time immemorial.

The sons of Israel did come there but for an asylum in the good old days of Moses — but in order to escape the wrath of the persecuting Pharaohs of Egypt, who were bent upon their extermination. In fact, there is no historical evidence now to show that they continued to live there — as ‘country parson’ completely fails to understand or realize.

Even if that is granted, they must have been absorbed by the inhabitants of the place and have so mixed and mingled with the indigenous population that after a few centuries they came to be known as Arabs, and, as such, it is nothing less than absurd to build the theory, as has been done since the ’20s, that the immigration of Jews, drawn from diverse nationalities and scores of countries, is just the return of the original inhabitants of their land.

The fact is that the huge influx of ‘Jews’ is nothing less than an invasion of Palestine by aliens, and exploiters. That there was no legal, much less any moral basis to deprive the Arabs of their homes, there can be no doubt.

It was ultra vires and against the very fundamentals on which the United Nations is supposed to stand and to safeguard which it claims to exist. As for ‘parson’s’ professed ‘understanding’ of Bible prophecy: After the Seventh Century A.

D., the sons of Isaac, and those who observed the letter of the law of Moses had to withdraw from Manaan (see history). The sons of Ismael (from whom the Arabs are descended) instead, became its political as well as its spiritual leaders.

The fact that the sons of Israel had to surrender the land of Canaan shows that they had become unworthy of the divine promise which God made to them through Abraham… Palestine is for those who keep the covenant which Abraham made with God. Christians also, no doubt, claim to fulfill the covenant.

But they seem to forget that the covenant lays down an important external sign, and that sign is circumcision of the male population. Only Ishmaelites have kept the sign both before and since the revelation of the Holy Quran. The prophecy of Abraham promised blessings to both Isaac and Ishmael.

According to this promise, the sons of Isaac were established over Canaan and the sons of Ishmael over Arabia. But when the last day arrived for the sons of Isaac, then, in terms of the prophecy of David, the promise was transferred from Israel to Ishmael. The claim of Israel was now only a racial claim, that of Ishmael was spiritual.

On the basis of their racial claim, the sons of Ishmael held Mecca and the territory around. On the basis of their spiritual claim they added Canaan to their possessions after the religious deterioration of Israel.”

A reader answering another reader in a Sacramento letters column in 1955, arguing the case entirely on scripture and history. The archive holds it because the argument is being made by name, in an American paper, nine years before the PLO.

CP-1955-001 →

· The Beaumont Enterprise

Alan Salem Ahmad Native of Palestine Granted Citizenship

Alan Salem Ahmad, 26, of 905 North Pearl street, Beaumont, was granted United States citizenship in a naturalization proceeding in U. S. district court here yesterday. The only candidate for citizenship in the ceremony presided over by Judge Lamar Cecil, Mr. Ahmad is a native of Palestine and came to the United States seven years ago.

A resident of Beaumont the past 2 1-2 years, Mr. Ahmad is employed by Sun Oil company as a chemical engineer. He received his engineering degree from the University of Texas. Mr. Ahmad is a member of the Junior Chamber of Commerce, Business and Professional Men’s club and the U. S. army reserve unit here.

The court granted him permission to change his name from Abder-Raouf Salem Sayied Ahmad to Alan Salem Ahmad. The oath of citizenship was administered to him by Tom King, deputy court clerk.

CP-1955-018 →

· Southern Illinoisan · Carbondale · page 1

What’s Happening In Gaza

Palestinian Arabs Give No Allegiance

By Dorothy Thompson

“VIOLENCE in Gaza would surprise no one who has visited it since the partition of Palestine. Previous to partition Gaza was an administrative unit of Palestine, subdivided into Gaza-Beersheba. The territory was almost wholly Arab and was largely awarded to the Arabs in the United Nations partition scheme.

But the Arab-Israeli war put into Israeli hands all but the narrow Gaza ‘strip’ where the inhabitants of the whole territory are crowded on less than three per cent of the land they formerly owned, their numbers augmented by refugees from other parts of Palestine… The ‘strip’ is policed by units of the Egyptian army, there at the armistice.

But the people in Gaza have little love for Egypt, or the United Nations relief administration that feeds the refugees among them 1,700 calories a day—or for anyone. Those who are natives and not encamped cannot easily be controlled.

The land they and their ancestors owned or worked for hundreds of years lies all around them, and to them that land is theirs, never transferred by any title.

So, as opportunity offers, they raid it, to carry off crops if they can, or leave upon it the bodies of a few dead Israeli, or their own dead bodies, killing being a vengeful pleasure and dying a matter of indifference… The United Nations Armistice Commission found no evidence of such fight but declared the Israel attack to have been prearranged and planned on order of the Israel authorities and carried out by a unit of the Israel regular army with rifles, submachine guns, mortars, bazookas and grenades, resulting in 38 Egyptians killed and 31 wounded.

Yet it undoubtedly was a retaliation for something. For eight Israel killed somewhere, 38 Egyptians paid. That Israeli were ambushed by Egyptian soldiers is unsubstantiated. But dispossessed Palestinian Arabs do maraud upon ‘our own land.’ Peace is made by a state with other states.

But the Israel problem is to make peace with Palestinian Arabs, who give allegiance to no country but Palestine, recognize no external disciplines, and whose cause has the sympathy of all Arabs… Even if the Arab states should make peace, these Palestinians would not accept it, and this knowledge makes it politically impossible for any Arab state to do so, no matter how many eyes are taken for one.”

A nationally syndicated columnist in 1955 setting out who the people in Gaza are, where their land is, and why a treaty between states would not settle it. The subheading is the paper’s: Palestinian Arabs Give No Allegiance.

CP-1955-002 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

Gaza Strip—

Quarter-Million Wretched Arab Refugees Hate Everybody After 7 Years’ Waiting

By Margarita Dobert

“Thousands of Arab refugees in the Gaza strip rioted recently when Israel and Egypt had their shooting ‘incident’ near the city of Gaza; and the cries of the angry refugees illustrated the mood that has developed among them in their seven years of exile. They shouted ‘Down with Israel!’ ‘Down with Egypt!’

‘Down with the United States!’

‘Down with Britain!’ and ‘Down with the United Nations!’… About 250,000 of the refugees are jammed into the small Gaza strip, a narrow corridor controlled by Egypt, hemmed in on one side by the sea and on the other by Israel… I got my first look at Arab refugees in the old walled city of Jerusalem.

Six or eight people were living in each of the dank stone basements of the former Jewish quarter… UNRWA officials were handing out flour, beans, sugar, margarine, rice and dates, providing between 1,500 and 1,700 calories at the cost of about 6 cents a day… But building a mudhouse or planting a tree implies permanency.

It would mean that the refugees had accepted the fact of having lost Israel… But then, how could the refugees go back? Almost as many Jews have entered the country as Arabs who were driven, lured or panicked into flight. It is true that the 170,000 who remained behind, have profited by the economic progress of the country. Their wages, their income have doubled.

So—I was told—has the price of wives. But they are class B citizens and it says so unmistakably on their identity card. They live under military rule, they cannot travel freely or advance in the civil service, they have no educational equality. They have become foreigners on their own soil.

Israelis will tell you with conviction that they begged the Arabs to stay during the war; but today they are just as determined not to take them back. They do not trust them, they do not want them and they have no room for them. While Palestine was a home for Arabs and Jews, Israel is a home for Jews. The Arabs have become refugees from a never-never land.”

Seven years on, a correspondent walks through the camps and writes down what the arrangement amounts to: class B on the identity card, military rule, no free movement, no equal education, foreigners on their own soil. The verb in the sentence about 1948 is three verbs — driven, lured or panicked — and the Israeli claim that they begged the Arabs to stay is printed in the paragraph after it. The tone of the piece toward the people in it is contemptuous throughout, beginning with the line under the headline.

CP-1955-003 →

· The New York Times · New York

Gaza: six and a half years of exile

“Gaza’s inhabitants are cared for by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA). But the six and a half years of exile have made the refugees bitter. Some prefer to risk death by nightly forays into Israeli territory for equipment and cattle.

‘Retrieved,’ say the Arabs of these things. ‘Stolen,’ say the Israelis.”

A picture page on the Gaza camps, and in the caption one sentence that is this whole archive in miniature: the same act, two words, depending who is speaking. The other captions call an Israeli pipeline a lifeline and describe young Israeli-born settlers farming within gunshot hearing of Gaza while getting military training.

CP-1955-007 →

· The New York Times · New York

ISRAELIS APPEAL TO ARABS OF GAZA

“Israeli radio urged Palestinian Arabs in the…”

The word Palestinian in the body of a 1955 wire story, nine years before the PLO and twelve before the occupation.

CP-1955-008 →

· Press of Atlantic City · Atlantic City, N.J.

Shore Welfare Worker Impressed By Jewish-Arab Amity In Israel

Says It Proves Peace Possible In Middle East

By IRVING T. SPIVACK

NAZARETH, Israel—Jews and Arabs are living together in peace in this ancient town, and the fact that they are doing so is proof that peace is possible in the Middle East. Nazareth has grown rapidly since the establishment of the State of Israel, and for years it has had an in adequate water supply. There are no springs in Nazareth and water sources are far away.

A reader-correspondent piece: a South Jersey welfare worker writing home from Israel, run with a staff-set headline and dek plus an italic editor's note introducing him. The dek field holds the printed deck only ('Says It Proves Peace Possible In Middle East'); the editor's note and the standing folio are excluded. People of Palestine are called 'Arabs'; no ordinary individual is named. The framing is the softest in the batch - amity, proof of peace - and makes a useful contrast with the 1949 refugee-camp item.

CP-1955-019 →

· estimated · SF Examiner

Bedouin Slain In Negev Attack

JERUSALEM, Israel Section, Aug. 14.—(AP)—An Israel army spokesman reported today that armed infiltrators attacked a Bedouin camp near Beersheba, in the Negev Desert, last night and killed one tribesman and wounded another. The raiders took one tribesman and a flock of sheep with them when they made their escape, he said.

Date check: No masthead or folio line on this clipping; it is a trimmed single-column brief. The AP dateline reads “JERUSALEM, Israel Section, Aug. 14.”, consistent with publication on 1955-08-15, but the year and the paper cannot be confirmed from the scan.

CP-1955-016 →

· The New York Times · New York

TROUBLE IN GAZA

“The Gaza strip is in the news again, which means that Israelis and Egyptians have clashed in one…”

An editorial that defines Gaza by who is fighting over it. The people living there enter the sentence as the place.

CP-1955-009 →

· Lewiston Daily Sun

Israel Troops Cross Border, Attack Egypt

“Raiders Blow Up Khan Yunis Arab Headquarters in Gaza Sector, Withdraw.”

Khan Yunis is a Palestinian town. Gaza was under Egyptian administration. The headline makes the country Egypt and the place a sector.

CP-1955-011 →

· Chattanooga Daily Times

Israeli Army Blasts Post Inside Egypt

Troops Strike Khan Yunis Camp, Seized by Arabs in 1948 Fighting. RENEWAL OF WAR SEEN. Tel Aviv Says Cease-Fire Dependent on Enemy’s Admitting Blame.

Inside Egypt. And the deck contains a whole history in six words — seized by Arabs in 1948 fighting — describing a town whose Palestinian inhabitants had lived there before 1948 and were joined by refugees driven into it during the war.

CP-1955-012 →

· Paducah Sun · Paducah

Tanks Used In Gaza Assault; Base Wiped Out

“Israeli armor and troops smashed across Egyptian lines last night and blew up an Egyptian military headquarters at Khan Yunis, in the Gaza strip.”

Paducah, Kentucky. Maria marked this one to note that Gaza was then ruled by Egypt. That is exactly the point: the administration was Egyptian, the people were Palestinian, and only the first of those facts survives into the headline.

CP-1955-013 →

· The Idaho Statesman · Boise

Israeli Troops Attack Egyptian Military Post

Jerusalem Says Action Was Defensive Move

The fourth paper on the same morning, and the fourth to put Egypt in the headline. Boise, Idaho.

CP-1955-014 →

· The New York Times · New York

Khan Yunis Puts Raid Dead at 39

KHAN YUNIS, Gaza Strip of Palestine, Sept. 3 — Israeli forces killed fifteen policemen, twelve Palestinian Arab soldiers and eight villagers here in an armored-car raid Wednesday night.

Three days after four American papers put Egypt in the headline, Harry Gilroy of the New York Times files from the town itself, and his dateline reads Gaza Strip of Palestine. The dead are counted as policemen, Palestinian Arab soldiers and villagers. He finds a man named Abu Sharakh, formerly the mayor of Migdal — a town now inside Israel and called Ashkelon — sitting on the Khan Yunis town council. He notes the Egyptian jeeps are American-made and the Egyptian helmets British. Distance from the place decides what it is called. The wire desk said Egypt; the reporter standing in the rubble said Palestine.

CP-1955-015 →

· Arizona Post · Tucson

Advancement of the Arab Minority In Israel

“Whether these Arabs can ever become loyal Israeli citizens, so long as a virtual state of war exists between Israel and the neighboring Arab states, is a moot subject… Sharon’s followers contend that granting full rights and facilities to a potential ‘fifth column’ is suicidal.”

Joseph Nedava, identified as an Israeli writer and journalist, in a Tucson Jewish weekly. The headline says advancement. The subheading two inches below says Fifth Column Danger. The argument being reported is that rights should be withheld from citizens because the state is at war with other states — and the citizens in question were made citizens by that same war.

CP-1955-010 →

· The Catholic Times

Israel vs. Arabistan

JERUSALEM — Before describing personal experiences and subjective impressions of this somewhat bewildering land of Israel, I think it may be useful — in order to point up the sources of the tension that divides this country from its Arab neighbors — to refer to the claims or theses on which the arguments of the two sides rest.

During the many weeks in Lebanon, Jordan and Syria, I got about every angle of the Arab case, not once but a dozen times over. It is a convincing case in many ways and one that makes fairly good sense.

In Israel, it seemed to me a duty to find out as quickly as possible the Israeli attitude, and on what basis the verbal warfare, with what one local writer calls most effectively “Arabistan,” reposes. ARAB BASIC FACT.

I think it may be said quite honestly that the Arab position is that the Jews are intruders who have arrived over the past 100 years, who have through the purchase of land and other forms of colonization gradually created a substantial Jewish community in the midst of an essentially Arab Palestine.

Under the British Mandate this migration continued until the dramatic events of 1948, when British authority ceased and Israel was proclaimed an independent state. Immigration increased enormously at that time. Within the space of three years, Israel doubled the number of its inhabitants.

Arabs living in Palestine either left or were forced to flee during the warfare of 1948-49.

All of this adds up to the basic fact that the Arabs consider themselves as expelees, deprived of home and property by a lot of newcomers who have no actual claim to the land, are not the descendants of those there in Biblical days, and who would not be there today were it not for the intervention and support of the United States.

No amount of argument about Zionist claims or the “Jewish homeland” is going to convince a Palestinian Arab that he was not unjustly and cruelly deprived of what had been his for 15 centuries. ISRAELI CONTENTION. From the first day in Israel, one begins to get the opposite picture.

Here one hears constantly that the Jews were always present in Palestine from the days before Titus captured and destroyed Jerusalem; that even though the community was much reduced, it nevertheless survived in a symbolic way and that the Jews elsewhere have never abandoned their historical claim to this country. This is very far from an exhaustive statement of the two cases.

I have merely tried to suggest that the two viewpoints are as nearly irreconcilable as it is possible for them to be.

CP-1955-006 →

· estimated · The Catholic Times

The Negev Obsession

Richard Pattee

Beersheba prior to 1949 was an Arab city, center of the floating Beduoin population that lives in the arid desert and carries on precisely as in the days of David, Abraham and Herod. Now, when one comes within the outskirts of Beersheba the first sight that strikes the eye is the modernity of everything.

New sections are going up at a dizzy rate in the bright stucco functional architecture that is the delight of all Israeli. This profoundly historical city, associated with so many incidents in the Old Testament, bears no remote resemblance to anything in the past. It is a booming frontier town, comparable perhaps to what one might find in Nevada or New Mexico.

The town is all-Jewish and, aside from a small part of it previously occupied by Arabs, there is nothing that makes it stand out either for antiquity or for colorful charm. To be sure the Bedouins still come in for market, leading their camels past chemical works and phosphate factories.

The contrast of these nomadic, non-sedentary people in their flowing garb and head-dresses with the energetic vitality of Israel is one of the deepest impressions one gets in Beersheba. Incidentally, most of these Bedouins enjoy certain privileges denied the ordinary Arab inhabitant of Israel.

They are often armed — at least in a primitive fashion — and during the war of independence fought against the Egyptians in behalf of Israel. The explanation is that tribal feuds and long-cherished antipathies led them to prefer the Israeli cause to that of their so-called blood brethren on the Arab side.

More and more of them are settling down and, I imagine, it will not be too long before they occupy permanent communities and become quite indistinguishable from the rest of the population.

Date check: No masthead, folio line or page date is on this clipping; it is a two-column cut of a signed opinion column with a one-column portrait of the writer. Nothing in the image dates it, so 1955-10-21 cannot be confirmed. The text's internal reference — “Beersheba prior to 1949” — puts it after 1949 only.

CP-1955-017 →

· Newport Daily News · Newport

The Background Of Palestine’s Tangled Story

The World Today

By James Marlow, Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — Palestine’s tangled story involves not only the Jews and Arabs but the United States and Russia. It may, if war breaks out, set off the spark that ignites the world. This is the background: Palestine, about New Jersey’s size, has 1,600,000 people, half of whom entered there in the past 10 years.

Of the total, 1¼ million are Jews, 70 per cent of the rest are Moslems. From the time the Romans crushed them in 70 A.D. the Jews, until recently, did not have a majority in Palestine. Nevertheless, through the centuries they looked upon it as their homeland.

The Turks, when they jumped into World War I on Germany’s side, held not only Palestine but the surrounding Arab areas. To win the Arabs from the Turks, the French and British promised them that if the Allies won they would break up the Turkish Empire into Arab states.

Britain also—in the Balfour Declaration of 1917—said it would look with favor on the creation of a home for Jews in Palestine. The Jews at that time were only one tenth of the population in Palestine. The Allies won and began setting up the Arab states, under French and British controls.

The League of Nations also gave Britain a mandate — which meant control but not ownership — of Palestine. Came World War II and the massacre of Jews in Germany. It stung the world’s conscience—the Western world’s, that is. The Jews, worldwide, meanwhile, had been pushing for a nation of their own in Palestine.

They could always point to that British Balfour Declaration of 1917. The British had never made good. At war’s end the British said they would quit Palestine. Jews poured in. Arabs feared Jewish immigration would swamp them. Besides, they objected to creation of a new Jewish state.

But in 1947 the United Nations approved this idea: partition Palestine, letting part of it be a Jewish state, part an Arab state. On May 14, 1948, the Jews proclaimed the independence of Isreal. The next day Egypt, followed by other Arab countries, attacked Israel. The Jews, outnumbered, out ought the Arabs and, by the time an armistice was agreed on, held not only what the U.

N. had intended to be Jewish Palestine but most of what had started out to be Arab Palestine. This armistice, obtained by the U.N., was supposed to be only temporary. The U. N. thought perhaps peace could be agreed on. It hasn’t been agreed on yet.

Scarcely a week has passed since 1949 that some bloody clash has not occurred along the armistice line between Egypt and her four Arab neighbors: Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Egypt. That armistice line—besides the Arabs’ hatred of the Jews and their refusal to recognize Israel as a state—was one of the sorest points.

While that line left Israel in possession of most of what had been Arab Palestine, Jordan held a piece bordering on Jerusalem, and Egypt had a part called the Gaza Strip. The U. N. armistice also called for demilitarized zones.

Early this month fighting broke out between the Egyptians and Israelis in one of those zones — called El Auja — on the frontier between Egypt and Israel. By itself this would have been bad enough. But the fighting began shortly after Egypt reportedly had ordered 80 million dollars worth of arms from Communist Czechoslovakia.

It meant Russia was beginning to make solid contact with the Arabs. The West, but particularly the United States, while helping Israel get on its feet, wanted not only to keep the friendship of the Arabs but to keep them away from Russian influence.

Then British Prime Minister Eden made a proposal — the United States hasn’t gone along with it—which infuriated the Jews. He suggested Jews and Arabs settle their differences by making “compromises.”

The Jews said what he really meant was that they should give back to the Arabs that part of Arab Palestine which they had conquered in the fighting of 1948-49. They said no. They appealed to the United States for arms. This country said it would consider their request.

At once Egypt warned the United States that if it gave the Jews arms it would lose the friendship of the Arab world of which Egypt is leader. The United States wants to keep the Arabs friendly but, because of the large Jewish population in this country, has to think twice about refusing Israel arms.

If full-scale war breaks out in Palestine, it could in the end involve this country and Russia.

Rhode Island’s first appearance in this archive, and it opens on a count: 1,600,000 people in a place about the size of New Jersey, half of whom entered there in the past 10 years. The column is a briefing for Americans on how the place got that way, and it says the British had never made good on Balfour and that the armistice left Israel holding most of what had been meant to be the Arab state. The last sentence of the piece is about the United States and Russia rather than about anyone living there.

CP-1955-005 →

· The Herald News · Passaic

Arabs, Jewish Immigrants Now Live, Work Side by Side In Jaffa, Israel

James M. Long, Associated Press, Jaffa, Israel

“Quiet, in his dignity of years, the Arab patriarch sits in the sidewalk shade, with his hubble-bubble pipe and his unspoken thoughts of the old Jaffa and the new… But only 6,500 Arabs are left of a crowded population of 60,000… Since the last of the Iraqi troops withdrew and Israeli soldiers dynamited and mortar-fired their way through Jaffa’s Manshiye slum quarter, 50,000 Jewish immigrants have been moved into the city.”

A correspondent standing beside a man, noticing there is something he is not saying, writing the observation down, and moving to the next paragraph, which is about a Jewish shoemaker. The archive’s Jaffa section gives seventy thousand people, then two thousand; this printing gives sixty thousand, then six thousand five hundred. Both are American newspapers and neither is the archive’s own count.

CP-1955-004 →

· The New York Times · New York

Mr. Truman’s Memoirs: Palestine Crisis Erupts

“The fate of the Jewish victims of Hitlerism was a matter of deep personal concern to me. I have always been disturbed by the tragedy of people who had been made victims of intolerance and fanaticism because of their race, color or religion.”

Installment seven of Truman’s serialized memoirs. A president explains his Palestine policy to the country in his own voice, in a newspaper, eight years after recognizing Israel in eleven minutes.

CP-1956-020 →

· Buffalo Jewish Review · Buffalo, NY

Shabbat Shalom!

By DR. ELAZAR GOELMAN

ON HERZLIAH ANNIVERSARY In spite of all its troubles Israel found it important to celebrate the fiftieth anniversary of an educational institution. It was during the school year of 1905-6 that the first Hebrew High School in the world was established and named appropriately, Herzliah, after the man who organized the world Zionist movement.

Twenty-five years later a Hebrew High School and Teachers Institute by the same name made its appearance in New York City. Just as the beginning of primary education was a boon to the Hebraization of Palestine so was the emergence of secondary education a step in that direction.

The problem of the future of Hebrew elementary school graduates weighed heavily upon the minds of the parents and troubled the conscience of the educators. Yet, when Dr. Judah Leib Matmon-Cohen announced in September, 1905, the opening of the Gymnasium Herzliah, in Jaffa, he was greeted with a shower of abuse and suspicion.

To the European educated Jew, a Gymnasium was in the category of the Holy of Holies where few of his kind could ever enter. Perhaps the physical appearance of Herzliah, a two-room house in an Arab alley, in the filthy city of Jaffa, was just a shocking sight to him.

Many of the teachers were incensed the point of drawing up a protest resolution against the impudence of a colleague. Were it not for the pleas of the venerable educator Yishai Adler and the author Alexander Ziskind Rabinowitz, there would have been on record a stinging resolution opposing the establishment of the Herzliah Gymnasium.

TRIUMPH OF EDUCATION Much to the surprise of many observers Herzliah began its growth from the very first year of its founding. Increasing numbers of students from Russia and other countries eagerly came to Palestine for the sole purpose of attending classes in the Jaffa Gymnasium, as Herzliah was commonly called at the time.

Four years later the cornerstone was laid for a new school building, and the added facilities naturally brought about a continued expansion of its educational program despite the lack of appropriate textbooks on the secondary level and the absence of adequately prepared staff members.

With the organization of the "Agudat Hagymnasia Haivrit," a sponsoring group, the institution passed from private hands to public control. The fruitful partnership between the Jews in Palestine and their brethren elsewhere was responsible for the growth and development of Herzliah. Palestinian teachers and writers gave of their enthusiasm and energy to the school.

East European Jews sent their teenagers to study there and also appropriated funds for its maintenance. Jews from England and other parts of the Western World contributed liberally toward the same goal.

LABEL ORDER: Maria's label lists slide 77 as 'The Kansas City Star April 29 1949' then 'Buffalo Jewish Review March 2 1956'. The images are reversed: s077_1 is the Buffalo Jewish Review column and s077_2 is the Kansas City Star piece. No masthead, no folio, no printed date; date is label-only. Attribution to the Buffalo Jewish Review rests on the column's own last sentence, which names 'the principal of our own Buffalo Hebrew School, Samuel Israeli'. 'Shabbat Shalom!' is a STANDING COLUMN HEAD in an ornamental border, not an article headline; it is recorded in headline because the form requires it, but the column's two subjects are given by its own crossheads, 'ON HERZLIAH ANNIVERSARY' and 'TRIUMPH OF EDUCATION', which are transcribed in the excerpt as set. There is no deck. PRINTER'S ERROR PRESERVED: 'Many of the teachers were incensed the point of drawing up a protest resolution' — a dropped 'to', kept as printed. WORDS FOR THE PLACE AND PEOPLE: 'Israel', 'Palestine' four times, 'the Hebraization of Palestine', 'Jaffa' twice ('the filthy city of Jaffa'), 'an Arab alley', 'the Jews in Palestine', 'Palestinian teachers and writers', 'East European Jews', 'Jews from England and other parts of the Western World', 'the European educated Jew'. WHAT IS ABSENT: no Arab inhabitant of Jaffa is named, quoted or counted. Arabs appear once, as a possessive adjective attached to an alley, and the city they lived in is called filthy. The Palestinians of 1956 are not in this column under any name, because in this column the word 'Palestinian' has been given to somebody else. The alumni list — Moshe Sharett, Eliahu Golomb of the Haganah, the poet Abraham Shlonsky — was read at page magnification only; the quoted sentences above were transcribed from magnified crops.

CP-1956-050 →

· The Kansas City Times · Kansas City, MO

BACK PALESTINE TRUCE CHIEF.

New U. S. Plan for Palestine Denuied by State Department,

Washington, March 15. (AP)—The State department declared today its "utmost support" for the present United Nations armistice chief in Palestine and denied that any plan to curtail his authority is being considered. Lincoln White, press officer, said he can find no one in the State department "who has ever heard of" a reported plan for creation of a new U.

N. commission to operate in Israel and the Arab states. The armistice chief is General E. L. M. Burns of Canada. White's statements were in comment on a report published by the New York Times that the United States was drawing up proposals for a watchdog U. N. commission to rove through Israel and the Arab states.

MARIA'S FLAGGED SLIDE. Clipped column, no masthead, no folio, no printed date; date is label-only. The dateline 'Washington, March 15' is one day before Maria's label of 16 March 1956, which is the normal relationship between an afternoon-filed AP story and a morning paper — The Kansas City Times was the morning edition. No byline; AP credit in the dateline. PRINTER'S ERROR PRESERVED IN THE DEK: the second deck line reads 'Denuied by State Department,' — 'Denuied' for 'Denied', a transposed i and u in the metal. Kept as printed. The headline ends with a full stop and the deck with a comma, both as set. A separate AP item from Tunis about the suspension of the city's police director runs immediately below and is NOT part of this article. WORDS FOR THE PLACE AND PEOPLE: 'Palestine' appears three times — in the headline, in the deck and in the phrase 'the present United Nations armistice chief in Palestine'. In 1956, eight years after the state was declared, this American paper still calls the territory under UN truce supervision Palestine. But the parties are 'Israel and the Arab states', twice. WHAT IS ABSENT: there are no Palestinians. Palestine is the place where a truce is supervised; the people the truce is supervised over are either a state or a bloc of other states. The clipping never uses the words 'Arab refugees', 'Palestinian' or 'Palestinian Arab'. THE PALESTINIAN QUESTION BEHIND THE STORY, FOR MARIA'S NOTE: General E. L. M. Burns was Chief of Staff of UNTSO, the UN body supervising the 1949 armistice lines drawn across Palestine. The 'Palestine' in this headline is the territory those lines run through; the people whose villages those lines cut through are not in the story. Seven months after this was printed Israeli Border Police killed 49 villagers at Kafr Qasim, on 29 October 1956 — the event the archive's 1956-58 Commons uploads cover.

CP-1956-049 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

Israel

Continued From First Page

“An Egyptian spokesman at Gaza charged that the Israelis opened the shooting at 4 a.m. with automatic weapons fire from the Damra sector northeast of Gaza. The spokesman said the Israel’s opened fire later at El Burej, north of Deir El Ballah. The exchange lasted four hours.

An Israeli army spokesman, on the other hand, accused the Egyptians of starting the shooting. He said rifle and machinegun fire was directed at three Israeli outposts in the Kissufim area in the central sector, beginning about 7:30 a.m., and about three hours later rifle and machinegun shots were aimed at Israeli positions in the northern sector.

Meanwhile a sombre mass funeral for 59 Arabs, killed in a heavy cross-shelling Thursday, took place in Gaza. Most of those killed were civilians. Four Israeli’s were killed earlier this week in the Gaza area. The Israeli’s said the Thursday exchange was started by repeated shooting directed at Israeli settlements along the border.

Dispatches from Gaza said that except for the funeral the Gaza inhabitants were going about their business with schools and business places open as usual. The American Southern Baptist mission hospital in Gaza, it was said was continuing its usual operations despite some slight damage from the Thursday shelling.

The Egyptian Red Crescent Hospital, however, was reported more seriously damaged. Nine of the victims of the shelling were said to have been women patients of the hospital.”

Fifty-nine dead, most of them civilians, and nine of them women who were patients in a hospital. Each side’s account of who fired first is printed in consecutive paragraphs under the subheading “Each Blames Other,” and the subheading after that is “Business As Usual.”

CP-1956-004 →

· The New York Times

ARAB SQUADS RAID ISRAEL FROM GAZA

Reprisal Attacks Reported to Carry 15 Miles—Firing Continues at Truce Line

By Homer Bigart, Special to The New York Times

TEL AVIV, Israel, Sunday, April 8—Arab suicide squads invaded Israel from the northern tip of the Gaza strip last night, according to the Israeli Army. An Israeli spokesman said the raids were in reprisal for the Israeli bombardment of the town of Gaza Thursday. Two persons were slain and at least a dozen injured by the Arab marauders, it was reported.

At Ascalon shortly after midnight, it was added, an Israeli woman was killed when a grenade was thrown into her house. Attacks by the Arab squads, or fedayen, as they are known, were reported on Nizanim, ten miles north of the Egyptian-held Gaza strip, and at Faluja, north of Beersheba. The deepest penetrations were said to be fifteen miles.

According to Israelis, the fedayen are recruited chiefly from Palestinian Arab refugees and trained by the Egyptians. Earlier yesterday, the Israeli Army had charged that Egyptian soldiers had broken the new United Nations cease-fire along the Gaza strip three times.

No casualties were reported in the three exchanges of firing that ensued across the frontier armistice line. [An Egyptian account accused the Israelis of having fired first.] Last night, the Israeli Army said, Arab guerrillas tossed grenades at houses near Nizanim,

CP-1956-048 →

· The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City · page 1

Egypt, Israel Hurl Charges In Security Council Notes

United Press, United Nations, N.Y.

“UNITED NATIONS, N.Y., April 9 (UP)—Israel charged Monday night that Egypt established fortified emplacements within cities of the Gaza Strip, making it ‘imperative’ for Israeli forces to silence the Egyptian batteries.

EGYPT CHARGED Israel with ‘aggression against peaceful civilians’ of the towns of Gaza, Khan Yunis and Dier El Balah last Thursday, killing 59 civilians and wounding 93. Both Israel Ambassador Abba S. Eban and Egyptian Ambassador Omar Loutfi sent letters to the United Nations Security Council.

‘ISRAEL HAS once again proven that its policy is based on aggression and that it does not hesitate to massacre civilians, women and children, without any consideration for law and tradition or its responsibilities,’ Loutfi said in his note to the council.

Eban charged Egypt with sending ‘armed sabotage and murder gangs’ into Israeli territory ‘for the terrorization of the civilian population’ in a ‘warlike act.’”

Both notes to the Security Council, printed side by side in one brief. Fifty-nine dead is a number inside a quotation, attributed to Egypt. “Dier El Balah” is the paper’s.

CP-1956-002 →

· Pueblo Star-Journal and Sunday Chieftain · page 1

Palestinian Arabs Talking Of Mass March On Israel

The Associated Press, Gaza

“GAZA (on the Egyptian-Israeli Frontier) (P)—More than 250,000 Palestinian Arab refugees were reported Saturday to be threatening to stage a mass march on Israel. U. N. relief agency officials said reports of the march were circulating through the overcrowded refugee camps in the Egyptian-held Gaza strip.

The officials said there were increasing indications that the patience of the poverty-stricken Arab refugees with the United Nations’ eight-year efforts to solve their problems were wearing thin. They said such a march along the 27-mile long border would be almost impossible to stop. ‘If they decide to march,’ one U. N. official said, ‘Who can stop them?

You can’t shoot a quarter of a million people.’ Despite their exile, the refugees maintain a fanatical determination to return to their ancestral homes and farmlands in what is now Israel. School children salute the Palestine flag every morning and chant: ‘We salute you Palestine.’ Lt. Col.

Mahmoud El Massri, chief Egyptian medical officer in the strip, described the refugees as ‘multi-injured’ people. He said they suffer dangerous psychoses and neuroses as well as physical ailments.

The situation could easily lead to such desperation measures as the mass march on Israel, he said… They said reports circulating through the camps since February predicted the refugees would return to their homes by June 1. The basis for the rumors could not be pinned down, they said, but were believed by a large number of the refugees.

Some 215,000 Arabs who fled Palestine during the Arab-Israel War are concentrated in eight camps in the Gaza strip. Others live in poverty in towns and villages on nine cents of food daily. Most are jobless.”

Printed above an item about an industrial research report at a chamber of commerce luncheon. The page is dated on the clipping: Page 6A, Sunday, April 29, 1956.

CP-1956-011 →

· Evening News

Israeli Arab Village Raided in Night

“Infiltrators from Lebanon attacked an Arab village in Israel last night, killing one villager and wounding two others.”

Read the headline, then read the first sentence underneath it. The wire copy says an Arab village in Israel. The headline says Israeli Arab Village. The compound was not written by the reporter in Jerusalem; it was made on a copy desk in Harrisburg, under a column measure, by folding a prepositional phrase into a two-word label. The uncompressed original is printed two lines below its own compression. The village is Arab al-Aramshe, on the Lebanese border.

CP-1956-039 →

· The Morning Union · Springfield

Arab Minority in Israel Treated 'Best' in World

“The only Middle East country in which Arab women can vote is Israel, Mrs. Harriet L. Kronick of Greenfield told the Springfield Chapter of Hadassah last night at Beth El Temple.”

A Hadassah chapter meeting in Springfield, Massachusetts, reported as news about how Palestinians inside Israel live. Seven weeks later, border police shot forty-eight people at Kafr Qasim. The claim in the headline is in quotation marks, which is the paper’s only distance from it.

CP-1956-040 →

· The Kansas City Star · Kansas City

Big Israeli Raid Charged

“Complaint to U.N. Reports at Least 15 Jordan Police and Guardsmen Are Slain in Attack on Arab Village of Rahwa.”

Ar-Rahwa, 12 September 1956, in the Kansas City Star on the day it happened. The headline's subject is a complaint, and the dead are Jordan police in an Arab village. On the same page, a story about vegetable life on Mars.

CP-1956-041 →

· Worcester Telegram · Worcester

Ruined Jordan Sector Outpost Reminiscent of Biblical Battles

Maria marked this one to make clear the village is Palestine. The headline does something further than renaming it: it turns a place where people had just been killed into scenery, and dates the scenery to the Bible.

CP-1956-042 →

· Fort Worth Star-Telegram · Fort Worth

Israeli Armor Thrusts Deep Inside Jordan

“Israeli armored columns pushed deep into Jordan early Thursday amid fierce close-range fighting.”

Qalqilya, 10 October 1956. Maria's note on this clipping: qalqilya was part of jordan, west bank was part of jordan but it’s palestine. Fort Worth gives the country as Jordan and the town no name at all.

CP-1956-043 →

· Columbia Daily Tribune · Columbia

Israeli Jets Aided Night Attack on Arab Fortress

“Israel’s jet-supported troops wiped out Jordan’s Qalqilya police fortress during the night in a reprisal border attack.”

Jordan’s Qalqilya. The possessive is the whole argument in one apostrophe.

CP-1956-044 →

· Knoxville Journal

Battle Rages On Jordan Territory

“Qalqilya in the ‘Arab triangle’ on Israel’s coastal strip”

Knoxville. Jordan territory in the headline; in the body the town sits in something called the Arab triangle, described by its position relative to Israel.

CP-1956-045 →

· Pittsburgh Sun-Telegraph · Pittsburgh

Raiders Smash Fort In Jordan

“Israeli’s jet-supported troops wiped out Jordan’s Qalqilya police fortress during the night in a reprisal border attack that took an announced toll of 70.”

Pittsburgh, running the same INS copy as Columbia, Missouri. Seventy dead, and the place is Jordan.

CP-1956-046 →

· The New York Times · New York

Death Toll Is 66 in Israeli Foray

18 Attackers and 48 of Foe Lost in Retaliatory Raid on Jordanian Police Post

By MOSHE BRILLIANT

The New York Times, counting. Thirteen attackers and forty-eight of Foe. The dead on one side are a number attached to a noun that means enemy, and the place is a Jordanian police post.

CP-1956-047 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

250,000 Refugees Warned

“The Voice of Israel, Jerusalem radio station, warned the refugee-packed Gaza Strip that it soon would be cut off from Egypt. It asserted Israeli military operations in the Sinai Peninsula soon would be concluded with the defeat of Egyptian forces.

About 250,000 Arab refugees from Palestine’s 1948 war are packed in the 26-mile-long, 8-mile-wide area sandwiched between the Mediterranean coast and Israel’s Negeb Desert.

The Israelis claimed to have destroyed scores of Egyptian vehicles in air attacks on convoys east of Ismailia, and claimed their forces had reached within 10 miles of the Suez Canal, the ‘ultimatum’ line set by Britain and France.”

The subheading is the count: 250,000 Refugees Warned. Twenty-six miles by eight, given in the second paragraph, in 1956.

CP-1956-014 →

· Daily American Republic · Poplar Bluff · page 1

U.N. DEMANDS IMMEDIATE CEASE FIRE

Israel Claims Smashing Victory In Ground Action / Gaza City Surrenders To Invading Israeli Forces / VOTES 64-5 FOR END OF HOSTILITIES IN EGYPT

The masthead reads: “Daily American Republic. VOL. XLVII—No. 240. POPLAR BLUFF, MISSOURI, FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 2, 1956. PRICE FIVE CENTS.” The banner: “U.N. DEMANDS IMMEDIATE CEASE FIRE.” Beneath it: “Israel Claims Smashing Victory In Ground Action.”

The headings across the page read “EGYPTIAN AIR FORCE PUT OUT OF CONDITION,” “Gaza City Surrenders To Invading Israeli Forces” (By Robert Tuckman), “EDEN HUNTS FACE SAVING WAY OUT OF PREDICAMENT” and “VOTES 64-5 FOR END OF HOSTILITIES IN EGYPT.”

“DULLES HEARS BRITISH SIDE OF EGYPTIAN STORY—Secretary of State John Foster Dulles, right, and U. N. Ambassador Henry Cabot Lodge, Jr., listen on floor of the United Nations General Assembly last night as British Delegate Sir Pierson Dixon explains his nation’s actions in the crisis. Dulles arrived late when his plane from Washington was delayed by bad weather.

Others in picture not identified.” (AP Wirephoto)

Invading Israeli Forces, in a front-page headline, in 1956. The date is printed on the masthead.

CP-1956-001 →

· The Daily Item · Port Chester · page 1

ISRAEL OCCUPIES ENTIRE GAZA STRIP

Port Chester, New York, Friday 2 November 1956, across the whole front page. The verb is occupies, printed flat in the largest type the paper had, with no quotation marks and no attribution. A century of argument about that word is in this archive; in 1956 it was simply the headline. It is a streamer over the whole day’s war package rather than the headline of any one story: beneath it the page starts six separate reports, among them a local Rye Town election and a bulletin about a parkway crash. The Gaza report it sits over is held separately, as CP-1956-051.

CP-1956-005 →

· The Jersey Journal · Jersey City · page 1

Israel Tanks, Planes Win Gaza Coast

By Serge Fliegers, International News Service, Gaza Strip

GAZA STRIP (INS) — Israeli troops supported by tanks and planes today smashed Egyptian positions and conquered the 125-square-mile Gaza Strip territory along the Mediterranean coast. The Israeli troops struck the Egyptians from the rear, or southern end, of the strip and raced through the area within three hours. At the moment of this dispatch, 5:30 a. m. (10:30 p. m.

EST Thursday) I am watching Israeli guns reduce the Egyptian positions in the town of Gaza, which is near the northern end of the area that Egyptian troops seized in 1948 before the U. N. effected an armistice. Israeli artillery has just hit the main Egyptian gasoline depot northeast of Gaza. A big black cloud of smoke marks the destruction of the depot.

The pre-dawn attack began after Israeli planes opened a heavy air bombardment during the night. Artillerymen laid down a barrage and then tanks and armored cars moved into the area quickly and advanced on Khan Yunis, which is near the southern end of the territory and on the ancient road between Palistine and Egypt.

A fierce battle developed at Khan Yunis, but the Israelis positions there and moved on to Gaza.

A correspondent watching the guns as he files, at half past five in the morning. Conquered is the verb in the first sentence, and the quarter of a million people living in the 125 square miles are not mentioned. “Palistine” is the paper’s.

CP-1956-015 →

· The Daily Item · page 1

Gaza City Gives Up To Israelis

TEL AVIV (AP) — Gaza City surrendered today to Israeli tanks and troops, giving Israel control of the entire coastal strip from which she charged Egypt had launched repeated attacks. Surrender of the city, famed in Biblical history and Egyptian headquarters for the Gaza Strip, was announced by Israeli Army Headquarters here.

The Israeli Army also announced that an Egyptian force led by a lieutenant colonel had surrendered south of the Gaza Strip. The Israelis earlier had reported an Egyptian unit surrounded in the area near Abu Ageila. Gaza fell after 24 hours of fighting for the strip of territory 25 miles long and eight miles wide.

Occupied by Egypt under the 1949 armistice, it became the home of some 250,000 of the bitter, poverty-stricken Arab refugees displaced by the Palestine war. Earlier an Israeli Army spokesman said a tank-led task force had smashed into Gaza City, and fighting was in progress. The announcement of the city surrender made no report of casualties.

An Israeli Army spokesman said the armored columns which drove into the Gaza area included heavy Russian-built equipment seized only yesterday in clashes with Egyptian troops in the Sinai peninsula. Israel earlier claimed it had captured the peninsula, throwing back 20,000 Egyptian troops.

Today's announcements said advances were continuing in the Sinai area and only pockets of resistance remained. Gaza City, on the main railway line to Cairo, is about eight miles from the northern end of the strip. Israeli units yesterday captured Rafah, a communications center at the southern end of the Gaza area.

Other Israeli troops reached El Arish, a coastal town about 30 miles west of Rafah in Egypt proper. Radio Israel said in repeated broadcasts in Arabic that Egyptian authority over the Gaza Strip has ended “after eight years of terror”. Israeli planes dropped leaflets during the night warning inhabitants not to leave their homes because of the risk of bombing.

Israel has for years charged the Gaza Strip was a base for Fedayeen commandos carrying out raids into Israeli territory. Army spokesmen said some Fedayeen units entered Israel last night, blowing up a number of vehicles and irrigation pipes. Six Israelis were killed by the expolision of a mine near the Gaza border, they said.

Four Fedayeen were reported killed and one wounded in a clash with troops in the border area.

The story under the banner. ISRAEL OCCUPIES ENTIRE GAZA STRIP ran as a streamer over the whole front page (CP-1956-005); this is the report it sat above, with a headline of its own in much smaller type. Where the banner says occupies, the story says surrendered, and every sentence in it is sourced to Israeli Army Headquarters, an Israeli Army spokesman, or Radio Israel. Not one Gazan is named, quoted or spoken to.

CP-1956-051 →

· The Morning Call · Allentown · page 1

Israeli Seizure of Gaza Equals Bitter World War II Battles

‘Now We Can Work Fields in Peace’

Serge Fliegers, International News Service, inside the Gaza Strip

INSIDE THE GAZA STRIP, Nov. 2 (INS)—I rode into the battle of Gaza in an ancient New York City taxi. I watched Israeli soldiers wrest the town of Gaza and the whole refugee-jammed Gaza Strip from Egyptian troops and fadayeen suicide commandos.

The whole 135-square mile area fell to the Israelis after a furious artillery and air bombardment and a lightning blitzkrieg sweep from south to north.

Positions Softened Up. Throughout the night and early morning, I waited as the Israeli artillery and bombers softened up the Egyptian positions… rounded up and marched—hands [up]… and the local population reportedly stayed in the Gaza Strip when the Israelis launched their drive against Egypt last Monday.

Thus, in a few fateful hours, Israel increased its population by 20 per cent and presented itself with a major problem. The actual battle for Gaza was too swift to allow a mass exodus from the strip. The first Israeli troops crossed into the strip at 6 a.m. (11 p.m. EST Thursday) and the town was in Israeli hands before noon.

The fighting equalled in bitterness anything seen in World War II. The scene might have been a small French or Italian town during the war, except for the flowing white costumes of the Arabs. The victory at Gaza has real importance for the Israelis.

Murderous Raids. As we returned from the city across the smoking fields, teenaged girls and boys with guns slung over their shoulders were coming into the neighboring Arab settlements. The latter had for four years been subjected to murderous raids by the Gaza-based fedayeen.

Sixteen-year-old Diana, a girl from Nahal Oz, gazed in wonderment at the adobe houses, now spattered with bullet holes. “So this is where they came from at night,” she said. “Now the nightmare is ended. We can work our fields in peace.”

Written from inside the advance, and it says plainly what happened to the people: they stayed, because the battle was too fast for them to leave. The correspondent does the arithmetic on the spot — Israel 20% larger in a few hours, and “a major problem.” The page’s kicker is a quotation from an Israeli teenager.

Correction: {'pub': 'The Morning Call', 'date': '1956-11-03', 'note': 'masthead reads Morning Call, Allentown PA, Nov 3 1956; slide caption pairing swapped with Birmingham Post 1967'}

CP-1956-006 →

· St. Louis Post-Dispatch · St. Louis · page 2

U.N. Starts On-the-Spot Inquiry In Israeli Shooting of 30 Arabs

Protests Probably Will Be Lodged Over Recent Disturbance at Rafah—Death Reports Differ Widely.

By RICHARD DUDMAN, A Staff Correspondent of the Post-Dispatch.

TEL AVIV, Israel, Nov. 17—Thomas Jamieson, Gaza strip operations director for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, began an on-the-spot investigation today of a disturbance at Rafah last Monday in which Israeli troops shot and killed or wounded at least 30 Arabs.

Jamieson told the Post-Dispatch he hoped to have full details gathered in time to make a written report by Tuesday to his superior, Henry Laouisse, UNRWA director at Beirut. Jamieson said a protest probably would be lodged first with the Israeli Foreign Ministry and probably later with the U.N. Meanwhile, Lt. Col.

Chaim Gaon, military commander of the Gaza strip, gave reporters additional details about the incident. The Arab radio already has been publicizing the episode, and it can be expected to figure extensively in Arab propaganda as “the Rafah massacre.”

Gaon said 10 to 12 Arabs were killed and 18 were wounded by rifle and machine gun fire when they ignored an order to halt. Jamieson, who told the Post-Dispatch yesterday he was certain there were at least 50 dead and 35 wounded, said today he was having difficulty establishing exact casualty figures. “I still think there were about 50 killed,” he said.

Goan scoffed at Jamieson’s figures, saying they came only from the Arabs. But Jamieson said two members of his international staff, an American and an Englishman, were on the spot while the shooting still was going on and counted 15 Arab bodies. Jamieson said his staff carried 35 seriously wounded Arabs to the Baptist Hospital in Gaza where they underwent major surgery.

The incident culminated three days of unrest that started at noon last Saturday, the day after Israel’s Premier David Ben-Gurion announced by radio his conditional agreement to pulling Israeli forces out of Egyptian territory.

Thirty people shot, named in the headline as 30 Arabs, and the shooting named as Israeli. What the line beneath does is turn it back into a question: the event becomes a disturbance, the response is a protest that will probably be lodged, and the count is unsettled because death reports differ widely. Rafah is named. The archive holds no follow-up.

CP-1956-036 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

Israel Due to Pull Back 30 Miles From Canal

By the Associated Press, United Nations, N. Y.

UNITED NATIONS, N. Y., Dec. 1 (AP).—Israel announced today it will pull back more than 30 miles from the Suez Canal by Monday to let the United Nations Emergency Force move in. It also announced it has withdrawn another brigade, possibly 3,000 men, from Egypt to make its total withdrawals about 9,000.

These moves still left Israeli troops in occupation of the Gaza Strip and much of Egypt’s Sinai Peninsula despite U. N. resolutions demanding they all withdraw into Israel. Israeli Delegate Abba Eban gave notice of the withdrawal and the pullback in a letter to U. N.

Secretary General Dag Hammarskjold… “As a result of the progressive withdrawal of our forces,” he wrote, “there will be no Israeli forces anywhere within a wide belt of territory (about 50 kilometers) in proximity to the Suez Canal along its entire length by the morning of December 3.”… An Israeli delegation spokesman told a reporter this and the two previous brigades had not been withdrawn as units but had been thinned out through demobilization of individual soldiers.

In occupation of the Gaza Strip, in the paper’s own third paragraph, in December 1956 — a decade before the vocabulary is usually dated to. Nothing is in quotation marks and nobody is being quoted.

CP-1956-013 →

· The Republican · Springfield · page 1

Stalled Invaders Agree To Leave Without Delay; Israel Told to Quit Gaza

British and French Bow to UN Orders, Leave Canal Issue Undecided Despite Attack

Associated Press, London

London, Dec. 3 (AP)—Britain and France bowed today to the will of the United Nations and agreed to pull their troops out of the Suez Canal Zone without delay. Further, the British told Israel it should get out of the captured Gaza Strip as well as Egypt’s Sinai Peninsula and permit the strip to be made a responsibility of the UN.

In New York, UN Secretary General Dag Hammarskjold expressed hope the British and French forces will be out and the emergency UN police force will have taken command in Port Said by mid-December. Foreign Secretary Selwyn Lloyd notified the House of Commons that Gen.

Sir Charles Keightley, commander of the British-French invasion forces, has been instructed to meet with UN officials to work out a timetable for the withdrawal.

“Given good faith on all sides, it can be carried out in a short time,” Lloyd said… Lloyd’s announcement made clear that the invasion failed to achieve what many members of Britain’s ruling Conservative party had considered a prime objective: To restore the Suez Canal to international control.

The word in the paper’s own headline is invaders, and it means Britain and France. Israel is told to quit Gaza in the same line. Printed above a man killed on an icy road in Huntington and a man shot on a deer hunt in Barre.

CP-1956-016 →

· Sacramento Union · Sacramento · page 1

Life—And Business

“LIFE—AND BUSINESS—continue as usual in age-old fashion in Khan Yunis, Gaza Strip city wrested from Egypt by Israel in recent hostilities. Here, Arab date vender plies his street trade, apparently unruffled by present tensions in the Middle East.”—(AP Wire Photofax)

A man selling dates on a scale, photographed in Khan Yunis in December 1956, six weeks after the killings there. The caption says life and business continue as usual and that he appears unruffled. The verb for what happened to the city is wrested, and the city is wrested from Egypt, not from anyone who lives in it.

CP-1956-017 →

· Syracuse Herald Journal · Syracuse · page 1

Arabs Slain, Jews Face Punishment

—ATROCITY—

Associated Press, Jerusalem, Israeli Sector

JERUSALEM, Israeli Sector (AP)—Israeli authorities disclosed today the killing of a number of Arabs by Israeli frontier police in a curfew incident 45 days ago at Kfar Kassem, a village near the Jordan border. Men, women and children were slain. The exact number was not disclosed.

Premier David Ben-Gurion said it was a “terrible occurrence,” and the police responsible will be tried. The government has decided to pay $560 to every Arab family affected. All deputies in the Israeli Parliament stood in silence in memory of the victims. Joseph Sprinzak, the speaker, read a statement expressing shock and bewilderment at the shooting.

Ben-Gurion appointed an inquiry committee to establish the circumstances and the degree of responsibility of the patrol. The committee reported Nov. 6 and, in accordance with its conclusions, the commander and several of his men who “carried out an illegal order” will be placed on trial.

The day the killings at Kafr Qasim were disclosed, in a Syracuse paper, under a standing label that reads ATROCITY. The first paragraph says forty-five days ago and the fourth says the exact number was not disclosed. The compensation figure is given before the number of the dead is.

CP-1956-012 →

· The Nome Nugget

Israel Regrets Killing of Arabs in Curfew Incident

Alaska. The subject of the sentence is Israel and the verb is regrets. Forty-four days after the killing, this is how most American readers first heard of it.

CP-1956-025 →

· St. Joseph News Press · St. Joseph

Slaying of Arabs in Curfew Incident Is Revealed by Israel

Missouri. The slaying is in the passive and the only active verb belongs to Israel: revealed.

CP-1956-026 →

· The News Review

Israel Discloses Killing Of Arabs In Curfew Tift

Forty-eight people shot dead, and this headline calls it a tift. The word means a petty quarrel. Of the nine papers in this archive that carried the disclosure, this is the smallest word any of them used.

CP-1956-027 →

· Evening Star · Washington

Israel Discloses Killing of Arabs

Washington, D.C. Discloses, again.

CP-1956-028 →

· Barre Daily Times · page 1

Israeli Authorities To Punish Police For Kfar Kassem Deaths

Associated Press, Jerusalem, Israeli Sector

JERUSALEM, Israeli Sector (AP)—Israeli authorities disclosed today the killing of a number of Arabs by Israeli frontier police in a curfew incident 45 days ago at Kfar Kassem, a village near the Jordan border. Men, women and children were slain. The exact number was not disclosed.

Premier David Ben-Gurion said it was a “terrible occurrence,” and the police responsible will be tried. The government has decided to pay $560 to every Arab family affected. All deputies in the Israeli Parliament stood in silence in memory of the victims. Joseph Sprinzak, the speaker, read a statement expressing shock and bewilderment at the shooting.

Ben-Gurion appointed an inquiry committee to “establish the circumstances and the degree of responsibility” of the patrol. The committee reported Nov. 6 and, in accordance with its conclusions, the commander and several of his men who “carried out an illegal order” will be placed on trial.

The same Associated Press disclosure the Syracuse paper ran the day before, in a Vermont daily, under a headline about punishing the police rather than about an atrocity.

CP-1956-018 →

· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha

Israel Mourns Shooting of 48 Arab Citizens

Nebraska, and the verb is now mourns. The word citizens is correct and rare: the dead were citizens of Israel, shot by Israeli police.

CP-1956-029 →

· Newsday · Melville

Bare Slaying by Error of 48 Israeli Arabs

Jerusalem, Dec. 13—Forty-eight Israeli Arabs have been killed by Israeli border policemen because of a mistake, Premier David Ben-Gurion acknowledged to the parliament yesterday. Ben-Gurion said the Arab residents of Israel were slain Oct. 29 as they returned late from their fields. They were unaware that a curfew had been imposed.

Terming the shootings a “terrible tragedy,” the premier said the commander of the border police unit and a number of his men would be tried. He also said the families of the victims had been granted payments of $550 to $2,775. After Ben-Gurion’s report, the Knesset, Israel’s parliament, rose and stood in silence to express sympathy for the bereaved.

The massacre took place in the village of Kafr Kassem near the Jordan border, the premier told the Knesset in revealing details of the previously hushed-up incident. Rumors of the killings had been spread by word of mouth. The curfew, ordering the Arab villagers to be off the streets from 5 PM to 6 AM, was imposed during the military buildup for the invasion of Egypt.

Most villagers were home before the curfew hour.

New York. Bare here means to reveal. The cause is settled inside the headline before any inquiry has reported: by error. The paper’s own third paragraph calls it a massacre. Ben-Gurion’s word, quoted in the paragraph above it, is “terrible tragedy.” The headline took his.

CP-1956-030 →

· The Berkshire Eagle · Pittsfield

Israelis Disclose Killing

Massachusetts. Four words, and the only actor named is the one doing the disclosing.

CP-1956-031 →

· The Houston Post · Houston

Israel Says Innocent Arabs Slain in Curfew Incident

New York Herald Tribune, Jerusalem, Israeli Sector

JERUSALEM, Israeli Sector — Israelis were given a few official details for the first time Wednesday of the killing of an undisclosed number of innocent Arabs in the Israeli village of Kfar Kassim, near the eastern border on Oct 29 by units of border police.

Forced finally to make a statement by pressure of an angry and ashamed public, which had learned the story by word of mouth only, Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion broke his ban, imposed for security reasons, on giving the public the facts and told the Knesset (parliament) at least something of what he termed “this terrible tragedy.”

BEN-GURION said that as the time for the Sinai Peninsula operation approached, a curfew from 5 PM to 6 AM was proclaimed in a number of villages on Israeli’s eastern border “in order to protect the lives of villagers.” Most of the villagers reached home before the curfew began, but some were late.

The prime minister declared, “A few came home in all innocence after the curfew had started and were killed by members of the border police.”

Texas, and the attribution is doing the work: Israel says the Arabs were innocent. Ben-Gurion is quoted connecting the curfew directly to the Sinai operation, which is the sentence that explains why nobody heard about it for six weeks.

CP-1956-032 →

· The New York Times · New York

48 ARABS KILLED; ISRAEL PENITENT

The only headline of the nine to lead with the count and the verb killed. Then the semicolon, and the second half of the sentence is about how Israel feels. Penitent is a word about the killer’s soul.

CP-1956-033 →

· Morning Advocate

Protests Killing Of Arab Villagers By Israelis

The Associated Press

“While not disclosing their number, he expressed regret. Dr. Izzat Tannous, director of the Palestine Arab Refugee Office in New York, telegraphed the protest to the president of the General Assembly, Prince Wan Waithayakon of Thailand.”

The first headline in this sequence in which Israelis are the agent of the killing, and it arrives only because a Palestinian made a complaint. Dr. Izzat Tannous, of the Palestine Arab Refugee Office in New York, is named. The same office appears in this archive again in 1956 writing to Eisenhower.

CP-1956-034 →

· Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery

Protest Given U.N. On Attack By Israeli Band

Alabama. Israelis are the agent here too, and again only inside a protest. Band makes the border police sound like irregulars rather than a force of the state.

CP-1956-035 →

· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco · page 1

Arabs Accuse Israel, Ask U.N. Probe

New York Herald Tribune Service

“UNITED NATIONS, N. Y., Dec. 14—Representatives of 11 Arab nations asked Secretary General Dag Hammarskjold today to investigate the recent slaying of Arab inhabitants of Israel, an alleged Israeli ‘scorched-earth’ policy in Sinai, and other charges against the government of Israel. According to Mohammed F. Jamali of Iraq, the Arab bloc delegation called the U.

N. chief’s attention to ‘the crime of Genocide’ October 29, when Israeli border policemen killed 48 Arabs in the village of Kafr Kassem. Israeli Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion announced Wednesday that the police commander and others were facing trial as a result of the incident.

The Arab bloc told the Secretary General that ‘roads, railroads, communication lines, villages, bridges, water tanks and wells are being completely demolished’ by Israelis in the Sinai area.”

Forty-six days after the killings. It reaches American readers because Arab states raised it at the United Nations, not because a correspondent found it. The Israeli answer — that the police commander is facing trial — is the paragraph underneath.

CP-1956-008 →

· The New York Times · New York

Text of Arab U.N. Protest

“Although the whole story will never be told and the extent of the tragedy never be known, yet official Israeli information has revealed the shocking aspect of this criminal policy.… The Israeli Government was no longer able to hide from world public opinion its savage actions of the massacre of innocent Arab men, women and children.

The Israeli Prime Minister was compelled officially to admit in Parliament the act of genocide committed by Israeli policemen at Kafr Qasem on Oct. 29, 1956, resulting in the murder of forty-eight Arabs, men, women and children. According to the Prime Minister, these peaceful villagers were murdered as they were returning from their fields to their homes.”

The full text of a letter from eleven Arab states to the President of the General Assembly, printed as a document rather than summarized. Palestinians are described as having been terrorized into fleeing. The Times runs the charge in their own words and lets the reader weigh it — which is how the words massacre and genocide reach an American page about Kafr Qasim in 1956, two days after Newsday printed massacre in its own voice. This is quoted source text, not the paper’s judgment.

CP-1956-021 →

· Morning Advocate

Bomb attack kills watchman on Israeli estate

“…had some comment on a bomb attack Saturday night which killed a watchman on the Israeli estate of Israel Sieff, a British chain store magnate.”

Printed four days after the Kafr Qasim disclosure, on the same page sequence. One death, named context, a named owner.

CP-1956-037 →

· Buffalo Jewish Review · Buffalo

Knesset Makes Amends to Families of Arabs Slain As Curfew Violators

A Jewish community paper in Buffalo describing the dead, in the headline, as curfew violators — a curfew the court would later establish most of them had not been told about. The compensation is the news; what the dead are called is in the subordinate clause.

CP-1956-038 →

· Caravan · Brooklyn · page 1

Israeli Acts of Genocide in Gaza Strip

Sami Hadawi

“The acts of genocide and brutality which are being perpetrated by the Israelis against some 300,000 Arabs in the Gaza Strip... will go down in history as the darkest stain on the record of not only the Israelis, but also of those politicians and powers who have permitted such a state of affairs to go unquestioned.”

And later: “Whereas cries of ‘murder’ and ‘salvation’ in the case of the events taking place in certain parts of Europe are read in every newspaper in the western world... the miseries and sufferings of the 300,000 Arabs living in the Gaza Strip pass unnoticed and without even a word of condemnation or compassion.”

“Sami Hadawi”

The earliest headline in this collection to carry the word, unquoted, about Palestinians. Twelve days earlier the San Francisco Chronicle had printed the Arab bloc using it at the United Nations, inside the story. This is Arab-American community press rather than a daily: the advertisements on the page are for a Norwalk oudist and a New London dress shop. That is why it sits in a different column of the count from the mainstream papers.

CP-1956-010 →

· Caravan · Brooklyn

Arab Refugee Office Tells Ike His Words Give Them “New Hope”

“President Dwight Eisenhower was told by the Palestine Arab Refugee Office in New York that his Human…”

Caravan is an Arab-American paper, and this is the archive’s first clipping from one. The Palestine Arab Refugee Office in New York writes to the President. Eleven years earlier a Milwaukee Jewish paper had counted organizations like this one and called them propaganda; here is one of them, in its own voice.

CP-1956-022 →

· Knoxville Journal · page 1

Egypt Claims 2150 Killed

Associated Press, United Nations, N. Y.

UNITED NATIONS, N. Y., Dec. 28 (AP)—Egypt charged today that Israelis killed about 2,150 Arabs in and around the Gaza Strip after Israel invaded Egypt Oct. 29. Israel denied the charge. The announcement—issued by the Egyptian Mission to the U.

N.—quoted Egypt’s director general of information, Abdel Kader Hatem, as saying the Israelis put 750 persons to death at Rafa in the northeast corner of the Sinai Peninsula just below the Gaza Strip. He also charged that “Zionists” gathered 1,400 persons in the Gaza area and executed them without trial. Israeli Delegate Mordecai R.

Kidron branded the Egyptian charges “flat lies.” Kidron declared the U. N. had full information on conditions in the Gaza Strip. An investigation in the area was made recently under U. N. auspices. A spokesman at Egypt’s U. N. Mission said the information had come from Arab refugees who fled Israeli authority in the Gaza Strip and reached Egypt.

He said there was no definite information as to when the alleged executions occurred.

The charge, the denial and the sourcing, in nine sentences. The number matches the one the Bolton News printed ten days earlier from the Arab League. The archive holds both, and neither resolves the other.

CP-1956-019 →

· St. Louis Globe-Democrat · St. Louis

Egypt Says Israel Killed 2150 Arabs In Gaza Strip

A four-figure death toll attributed to Egypt rather than stated. Two other papers in the archive carry the same AP filing word for word, the Abilene Reporter-News at CP-1956-024 under a headline three words shorter, and the Knoxville Journal at CP-1956-019 in full. St. Louis dates the filing Dec. 26; both of the others date it Dec. 28. None of the three scans carries a masthead or folio, so which day the wire moved, and which day each paper printed it, is not settled here.

CP-1956-023 →

· The Abilene Reporter-News · Abilene

Egypt Says Israel Killed 2,150 Arabs

Texas runs the headline without In Gaza Strip, though the body prints the Gaza Strip three times. What Abilene actually cuts is the back half of the wire: Israel's denial, delivered by Mordecai R. Kidron as “flat lies,” and the line saying the figures came from refugees who had fled to Egypt. The charge runs; the answer to it does not.

CP-1956-024 →

· Escanaba Daily Press · Escanaba · page 1

Rear Attack By Israeli Clears Gaza Territory

EYEWITNESS REPORT

Serge Fliegers, INS, inside the Gaza Strip

“INSIDE THE GAZA STRIP — (INS) — Israeli troops supported by tanks and planes today smashed Egyptian positions and conquered the 125-square-mile Gaza Strip territory along the Mediterranean coast.

The Israeli troops struck the Egyptians from the rear, or southern end, of the strip and raced through the area within hours… I heard the orders go out to the troops to smash the remaining Egyptian troops in Gaza, but strive at all costs not to hit civilian sectors of the town… NO ACCURATE estimate of casualties on either side was available at this time.”

An eyewitness report from inside the strip, printed above an advertisement for a lecture series in psychology and religion. The scan is 322 pixels wide across three columns, so the middle of the story could not be re-read word by word.

CP-1957-001 →

· estimated · Solano Napa News Chronicle · Vallejo · page 1

Troops Remain Along Gaza Strip And Aqaba Gulf

United Press, United Nations, N.Y.

“UNITED NATIONS, N.Y. (UP)—Israel stood fast in the Gaza Strip and along Egypt’s Gulf of Aqaba coast today, defying the U.N. Assembly’s sixth resolution calling on her to withdraw her troops behind the 1949 armistice line.

The Israeli Cabinet in Jerusalem announced it would still keep occupation forces for the time being in the Gaza Strip and in the Sharm el Sheikh area on the Red Sea Gulf of Aqaba.

A Foreign Ministry spokesman said, ‘No guarantees have been obtained yet for definite stoppage of Egypt’s belligerence and sea blockade of Israel.’… Israel had been seeking guarantees against renewal of Arab commando raids from the Gaza Strip and resumption of Egypt’s artillery blockade of Israel-bound shipping through the Gulf of Aqaba… The strip, haven for some 200,000 Palestine Arab refugees, is former Palestine territory that Egypt administered provisionally before Israel began its invasion Oct.

29.”

Two hundred thousand refugees, in a subordinate clause explaining where the territory came from.

CP-1957-015 →

· Oklahoma City Star

UN Praises Gaza Hospital

The work of the staff of the Baptist hospital, Gaza, has received a tribute in a special report of the director of UNRWA (United Nations Relief and Works Agency) for Palestine refugees in the Near East.

The report presented in order to inform the General Assembly of the United Nations of the emergency actions taken by UNRWA as a result of the recent hostilities in the Near East covers the period from November 1 to mid-December 1956.

The following paragraph of the report deals with the Baptist hospital: “The re-establishment of UNRWA’s basic relief services during the emergency was made possible only through the devoted work of many individuals, members of the Agency’s international and local (mostly refugee) staff. Their work deserves the highest praise.

“In addition, particular mention should be made of the work of the medical staff of the Baptist hospital in caring for the many serious surgical cases caused by the fighting and the subsequent incidents at Khan Yunis and Rafah, where a number of refugees were severely wounded.”

CP-1957-025 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

Riots Feared if Israelis Leave Gaza Suddenly

By Crosby S. Noyes, Star Staff Correspondent, United Nations, N. Y.

UNITED NATIONS, N. Y., Feb. 16.—Responsible United Nations officials, recently returned from the Middle East, believe a sudden withdrawal of Israeli military forces from the Gaza Strip would result in “terrible disorders” among the 200,000 Arab refugees there. The officials, who declined to be quoted by name, have reported to top U.

N. and American officials that unless sufficient forces are on hand to take over immediately from the Israeli Army, the probability of rioting and mob reprisal actions is acute… As for political administration, there is no agency within the U. N. capable of taking over immediately the job of administering the Gaza Strip. Present U.

N. responsibilities in the area are confined to food distribution, medical care and education for about two-thirds of the entire population… Experience during the first change of management in the strip in November lends force to these warnings. The days following the Israeli takeover were marked by disruption of normal services and food distributions.

Riots followed in which food depots were destroyed and some $275,000 of supplies and equipment lost as the result of looting, burning and military action. Two serious clashes between refugees and Israeli forces at Khan Yunis and Rafah resulted in 386 civilian dead, according to U. N. figures.

Another 66 refugees and local residents of the strip were killed in scattered incidents. The results of a changeover without adequate security forces on hand, it is felt, could be even more serious. The mood of the local refugee population is described as “disturbed,” despite strenuous efforts of the Israeli regime to restore order.

The implication seems to be that anyone who holds the Gaza strip today, has a tiger by the tail, and that more than normal caution is needed to let go.

Three hundred and eighty-six civilian dead at Khan Yunis and Rafah, with United Nations figures attached, printed in Washington in February 1957. The subheadings are “No Suitable Agency” and “Would Need Big Force.” The story calls the Gaza Strip the disputed territory and calls the Israeli administration a regime, and it runs beside an advertisement for sixteen dance lessons for nine dollars.

CP-1957-011 →

· Telegram & Gazette · Worcester · page 1

Palestinian Arabs Clash With Police

The Associated Press, Cairo

“CAIRO, Egypt, Feb. 26 (AP)—At least five persons were killed today when about 500 Palestinian Arab soldiers clamoring for arms attacked an Egyptian police station in the suburb of Maadi. Police immediately clamped a tight lid of secrecy on the incident, and refused even to admit any trouble had occurred.

Eyewitnesses said, however, that at least five were killed, several wounded and more than 20 arrested when the Palestinians attempted to storm the police station from two directions to get arms and ammunition. Reliable sources said the attackers came from an Egyptian army tent camp in the desert near the suburb.”

Palestinians in the headline in 1957, in a story about them fighting the Egyptian police.

CP-1957-014 →

· High Point Enterprise

Mid-East Problems Panel Set Tonight

The Middle East is a long way from High Point, but the current crisis there will be brought here tonight in a direct and authoritative manner. The transferral will be effected through a panel discussion sponsored by the High Point League of Women Voters. The meeting, open to the public, will be held in the audio-visual room of the public library on S. Main Street.

The four-member panel will consist of two foreign college students and two WCUNC profesnors. The students, one Arab and one Israeli, will present the viewpoints of their respective countries on Middle East problems. Meron Ronnie Medzini, 21 year old native of Jerusalem, will give the Israeli side of issues.

Miss Julia Khalaf, native of Ramallah, Jordan, will explain the Arabic stand. Jordan Kurland, professor of history, and Dr. Peter Burger, professor of sociology, will be the other panel members. Tartt Bell, director of the American Friends Service Committee’s headquarters here, will act as moderator.

All panel members have extensive backgrounds which qualify them as experts on Middle East questions. Medzini served in the Israeli defense forces from 1951 until 1954, and was discharged as a lieutenant. He is presently a student at City College in New York, majoring in international and governmental affairs.

He is also chairman of the Israel Student Council for the East Coast and a representative to the International Student’s Organization. His mother is secretary to the Israeli delegation to the United Nations. Medzini, who is flying down especially for tonight’s meeting, is scheduled to arrive at Greensboro-High Point Airport late this afternoon.

Miss Khalaf has been in the United States for over three years. She was first enrolled as a student at Warren-Wilson Junior College and is now a senior at Guilford College, majoring in mathematics. She has stated her intention to attend graduate school in the United States, but will return to Jordan if that is not possible.

CP-1957-033 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

What Is the Solution for Gaza?

Israel Has Failed in Crucial Test; Her Policies Have Alienated Arabs

Dorothy Thompson, Jerusalem

JERUSALEM — The so-called Gaza Strip is, and always has been, an integral part of Palestine. Egypt’s occupation and administration of it was a result of the Palestinian war and the cease-fire that found her troops there, as it found Israeli troops in many sections of Palestine that had never been granted to Israel by the 1947 U. N. partition plan.

The inhabitants of Gaza territory are 100 per cent Palestinian Arabs, either native—whose ancestors were settled there for millennia—or fugitives from Israel. The latter constitute around three-fourths of the Gaza population. None is Egyptian, and Egypt has not annexed the territory but administered it.

The original partition scheme envisaged a Jewish and an Arab state in Palestine. Although the Palestinian Arabs were twice as numerous as the Jews and owned all except 7 per cent of the land, Israel was awarded more than half of it, but on condition that no Arabs should be displaced and that the two states be economically integrated.

Actually, four-fifths were displaced, their land and properties taken over by Israel, which has happened also in the territories annexed but never assigned to Israel. No compensation has been paid them.

Unlimited Jewish immigration has, meanwhile, more than replaced the original inhabitants—who could not possibly maintain themselves in the area in Palestine left to the Arabs, even if they could call upon foreign funds to the same extent as the Israeli… Israel wants the territory but not the Arab population of Gaza or anywhere else.

In the face of world opinion, she could hardly repeat the performance of driving them out… The late Judah Magnes, an American Jew, and rector of the University of Jerusalem, remembering the days when Arabs and Jews together, in the time of the dissolution of the Roman Empire, reached the highest point of Semitic achievement, worked for a new Palestine for the Palestinians, Jew and Arab.

But he died broken-hearted.

A nationally syndicated columnist in 1957 with the numbers and the verbs: twice as numerous, all but 7% of the land, four-fifths displaced, no compensation paid, and Israel could hardly repeat the performance of driving them out. The same column is contemptuous about communism and about the Arab masses, and finishes on Samson pulling the temple down.

CP-1957-016 →

· Duluth News-Tribune · Duluth · page 1

Working Against Time

Gib Crockett, Washington Star

“Working Against Time.” An editorial cartoon. Golda Meir and John Foster Dulles face each other across a table, both labeled by name. Between them a box of dynamite marked TICK TICK TICK sits on a crate marked GAZA, with Dulles holding the fuse.

Signed Gib Crockett, Washington Star.

A drawing, not a report: Gaza as a crate of explosive between two negotiators. Nobody who lives there appears in it. The description here is of what the cartoon shows; the only words printed on it are the title and the labels.

CP-1957-002 →

· St. Joseph News Press · St. Joseph

Just What Is the Gaza Strip?

Gerald Kloss, Milwaukee Journal

“Who Owns the Gaza Strip?

Nobody… The Gaza strip would have been part of a new Arab Palestine state under the plan… Actual ownership will not be decided until a peace treaty is signed, if ever… Before the 1949 armistice, the native Arab population of 80,000 to 90,000 barely kept itself alive through agriculture, with its chief markets Tel Aviv and Jerusalem.

These markets were cut off… some 175,000 Arab residents of Palestine migrated to the Gaza strip during the Arab-Israel war…”

A general-interest explainer that answers its own question. Set it beside the Flint Journal’s 1985 box, SOURCE OF FRICTION IN AN ANCIENT LAND: two attempts to explain the same region to the same kind of reader, twenty-eight years apart, one of which answers the question and one of which answers a different one.

CP-1957-021 →

· Indianapolis Star · Indianapolis · page 1

This Arab mother, a displaced Palestinian, spoons food for her child in hospital at the Jabalia refugee camp in Gaza

“This Arab mother, a displaced Palestinian, spoons food for her child in hospital at the Jabalia refugee camp in Gaza. Food was from supplies provided by United Nations officials. U.N. troops guard the border with Israel, which has been the scene of many Egyptian-Israeli fights.” (AP Wirephoto)

CP-1957-003 →

· estimated · Syracuse Herald Journal · Syracuse · page 1

Take a typical day in one of the eight refugee camps set up and operated by UNRWA in the strip

The Jabalia camp, in the northern portion of the strip, has about 20,000 inhabitants living in a total of some 5,000 rooms. In addition, 2,000 refugees living just outside the camp fall under its jurisdiction.

Correction: {'note': 'uncaptioned; 1957-60 era by content'}

CP-1957-004 →

· Syracuse Herald Journal · Syracuse · page 1

Arab Refugee Families from Palestine Stranded in Gaza Camp

GAZA PROBLEM CHILDREN: Arab children marching from school at Jabalia refugee camp in Gaza are displaced Palestinians caught in bitter controversy between Israel and Egypt

Two AP Wirephotos. “IN THE MIDDLE. This is Main Street in Jabalia refugee camp operated by U.N. for 20,000 displaced Palestinian Arabs who live in about 5,000 rooms in the Gaza camp located in disputed strip between Israel and Egypt. Note little girl in center taking nap in sun.” And: “GAZA PROBLEM CHILDREN.

Arab children marching from school at Jabalia refugee camp in Gaza are displaced Palestinians caught in bitter controversy between Israel and Egypt.”

Same AP wirephoto as image161, different paper, different caption

CP-1957-005 →

· American Press · Lake Charles

LUNCH ON THE U. N.

Associated Press Wirephoto, by Raoul Fornezza

“LUNCH ON THE U. N. — This Arab mother, a displaced Palestinian, spoons food for her child in hospital at the Jabalia refugee camp in Gaza. Food was from supplies provided by the United Nations officials… Picture by AP Photographer Raoul Fornezza.” (AP Wirephoto)

The Indianapolis Star ran this same Wirephoto four days earlier with the same caption and nothing in front of it (CP-1957-003). This paper added three words above it. Nothing in the caption body changed: a photograph of a woman feeding a sick child in a refugee camp hospital, slugged with a joke about who is paying for the meal. This printing also credits the photographer, which the other does not.

CP-1957-020 →

· Eugene Guard · Eugene · page 1

IN THE MIDDLE

This is Main Street in the Jabalia refugee camp for Arabs in Gaza, as it now looks. Jabalia is in the disputed strip between Israel on the north and Egypt on the south. In Jabalia 20,000 displaced Palestinians live in about 5,000 rooms. The camp is operated by the United Nations. Note the little girl in the center taking a nap in the sun.

CP-1957-006 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

U. N. Protection Due Both Sides in Gaza

On the Record

By Dorothy Thompson

“The conflict that arose recently between Joseph Alsop, Herald Tribune columnist, writing from Gaza, and the United Nations, which has questioned his accuracy, does not seem to involve much of factual substance… And it is not only necessary to protect Israel from Arab raiders but to protect the border Arab communities from Israelis, who in the raids and counter-raids of the last eight years have killed far more Arabs than Arabs have killed Israelis.

This a matter of record. The U. N. (publicly confirmed by the Israeli delegate, Abba Eban) has reported that raids into Israel during the whole period since the 1949 armistice have resulted in 443 Israeli deaths. On Arab casualties no figures are available for the whole period. But precise U. N. figures are obtainable from January 1, 1955, through September 30, 1956.

During this critical 21 months, prior to the attack on Sinai and Gaza, 496 Arabs, military and civilians, were killed, compared with 121 Israelis, the number of Arab deaths in less than two years thus exceeding by 53 the sum total of Israeli deaths in the whole period since the armistice.

There is also available a special report by the director of the UNRWA in the Near East, covering November 1, 1956 to mid-December, the first 45 days of Israeli occupation of Gaza, during which 452 Arabs are known by ‘trustworthy sources’ to have been killed. These were not casualties of fighting between Israeli and Egyptian troops, which lasted only a few hours.

The report is specific and detailed as to places and persons. The UNRWA director (Mr. Labouisse) in his past year’s report estimates that five Arabs have been killed for every Israeli in the frontier clashes. So if the U. N. has failed to protect Israelis under past arrangements, it has failed to an even greater extent to protect Arabs.

As far as Gaza is concerned, protection for both is its mission.”

A syndicated columnist doing the arithmetic in 1957, with United Nations figures and the Israeli delegate’s confirmation attached to them: four hundred and ninety-six Arabs against a hundred and twenty-one Israelis in twenty-one months, and four hundred and fifty-two Arabs killed in the first forty-five days of what she calls the Israeli occupation of Gaza. The subheadings are “Israel Rejects Patrols” and “Israelis Inflict Most Deaths.”

CP-1957-019 →

· Ruston Leader

Dr. James M. Young Continues Attracting Admiration Through Daily Toils At Gaza Hospital

Dr. James M. Young, native of Ruston and son of Mrs. Joe Gibson, continues in the Middle East crisis limelight for the courageous and uninterrupted work he has been doing at Baptist Hospital in strife and bullet torn Gaza Strip. Only a few days ago, the New Orleans Times-Picayune carried a feature article written by Alec Kitroeff, an INS correspondent.

Bearing a Gaza dateline of April 17, the article said: “Patching up torn and bleeding Gazans has become second nature to a young American surgeon who has been doing ‘nothing but’ for the last two years. “‘And it looks as if this situation is going to last for a long while yet,’ Dr. James M.

Young of Ruston, La., said as he pulled off his rubber gloves outside the operating theater of the Baptist Hospital in Gaza. “The shy, 32-year-old Southern Baptist Missionary who looks like an early edition of movie actor James Stewart, takes no sides in the conflict around him that simmers constantly and erupts occasionally in a shelling or an invasion.

“Young’s staff consists of one American, John Roper of Six Mile, S.C., and three Egyptian doctors, plus two American, one English and one Danish nurse. The rest are all Palestinians. “Young said that many of his cases were Arabs from Rafa who were shot by the Israelis for not conforming with the curfew regulations.

“The 90-bed hospital which is mainly supported by UN funds, is filled to capacity. More than a quarter of Young’s patients are stunned and bewildered victims of land mines. They are trundled daily out of the operating theater minus a hand, an arm, a leg or their eyesight.

“It doesn’t strike them as strange that their torn bodies should be repaired by a man of another faith who came across 7,000 miles of land and ocean for that specific purpose. “Like everything else that happens to them it is ‘kismet’ — the will of Allah.” Dr. and Mrs.

Young and their two young children left Ruston about January 1, 1955 for assignment to the hospital in Gaza. Mrs. Young, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. J. T. Buckner of Pinecrest, also is a native of Ruston. Until the terrific fighting last Fall, she had assisted in operating the school in Gaza, but was evacuated with her children to Beruit.

The Youngs keep in comparatively frequent communication with their parents here.

CP-1957-026 →

· The New York Times

Capture of Arab Boat Charged

GAZA, May 2 (AP)—An Egyptian official charged that an Israeli armed fishing boat captured an Arab fishing craft a mile and a half off the Gaza Strip’s north shore today. The number of Arab fishermen aboard the captured boat was not known. Egypt lodged a protest with the chairman of the Mixed Armistice Commission and demanded that the vessel be returned immediately.

CP-1957-029 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

Arab Refugees

H. Y. Orgel, Information Attache, Embassy of Israel

“In his column ‘New Serajevo in Jordan crisis?’, published on April 25, your columnist, Constantine Brown is completely wrong when he writes that ‘hundreds of thousands of Arabs were forced out of the country (Israel).

All the refugees moved across the border into the little kingdom which in the past was barely capable of supporting its own small population of nomads.’ The unfortunate human beings who are today known as the ‘Arab refugees’ were not ‘forced out’ but left at the behest of their own Arab leaders.

The Jewish agency for Palestine, which was preparing itself to become the ‘provisional government of Palestine’ was at that time making its plans on the understanding that the Arab inhabitants of the area to become Israel would remain as full citizens of the State of Israel.

Indeed, Israel’s Declaration of Independence contains an appeal to the Arabs of Israel and the neighboring countries to co-operate in living in peace with the new state for the well-being and development of the whole Middle East area. Furthermore, the refugees did not go into a ‘little Kingdom.’

Those who moved eastwards into the area controlled by the King of Transjordan went into a country which was at that time in the process of swallowing up the larger part of an area originally intended to be an independent Arab state, linked economically not with Transjordan but with the newly-established Jewish state.”

The claim in its finished form, in 1957, in a letter from the Israeli Embassy correcting the paper’s own columnist for having written that the Arabs were forced out. Nine years after the fact and two months after the same paper printed Dorothy Thompson saying the opposite.

CP-1957-017 →

· The New York Times

THE ARAB REFUGEES

The drama of the Suez is now in a quiescent stage. Israeli cargoes go up and down the Gulf of Aqaba, in spite of the continuing general tension between Israel and the Arab world. During the past few weeks, however, too little attention has been paid to the most important continuing cause of bitterness in the Middle East.

This is the existence of close to a million Arab refugees and children of refugees—over 200,000 in the Gaza Strip, over half a million in Jordan, the rest mostly in Lebanon and Syria. Ever since the State of Israel made good its independence, most of these refugees have been wards of the United Nations.

They have been orphans of the storm, never allowed to starve to death, given as much medical care as possible, and even receiving a little education. But $27 a year per capita, which is about what they have been having, does not buy luxury. Director Henry R.

Labouisse of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine refugees is now in the United States in the course of an international search for enough money to keep his work going through 1958.

CP-1957-030 →

· Birmingham Post Herald

George Salem Funeral Today

Funeral for George Salem, 65, of 3852 Glencoe-dr, will be at 2:30 p.m. today at Johns-Ridout’s West Chapel and at 3 p.m. at Holy Trinity Greek Orthodox Church, the Rev. Emanuel Bouyaucas officiating. Burial will be in Elmwood. A native of Ramallah, Palestine, Mr. Salem made his first trip to this country in 1909.

He settled in Birmingham in 1927 but continued to make frequent visits to his old country. He made his last trip in November. Mr. Salem, who died yesterday morning at a local hospital following an illness of several weeks, was a veteran of World War I and was a member of the American Legion in Brooklyn, N. Y.

He is survived by the widow; four sons, Badie, Sam, Hallie and Fred Salem; two daughters, Misses Lelia and Widad Salem; one brother, Essa Salem, all of Birmingham; and three sisters living in Jordan.

DIES—George Salem.

CP-1957-032 →

· Southern Illinoisan

Arab Refugees -- Human Bombs Of Middle East; No One Knows How Many

By JOHN P. LEACACOS

Jerusalem, Jordan Sector NEARLY a million “human bombs” walk the Middle East—a million agents for Arab nationalism and stooges for Russian communism. These are the 922,279 registered Arab refugees, half of whom are children. They are the human debris of the Palestine war of nine years ago.

The problem of the Arab refugees holds the key that will open the door to the overriding problem of the Middle East: peace between Arab and Israeli. Everyone here—Westerner, Israeli and Arab—says so. And nobody does anything about it.

The refugees are not only ready-made tools for Arab demagogues but a gigantic pressure group that in turn pushes Arab leaders to extremes. In Gaza, 217,000 refugees out of a 300,000 population supply Egypt’s Gamal Abdel Nasser with fedayeen terrorists against Israel and a “controlled laboratory” for virulent anti-Western propaganda.

In Jordan, 551,000 refugees, plus another 400,000 Palestinian cousins, in a population of 1,400,000, have been a prey to Baathist leader Abdullah Rimawi’s constant subversion. … Harder Line A U. N. chief relief supervisor in Jordan summed it up recently: “Things have changed here in my time.

In 1953 all that the refugees wanted was a chance to go home, even if it were Israel. Now they do not want to go back to live under Israel rule nor go to other Arab countries. Now they say they want to eliminate Israel and take their own.” The Arab line has hardened as compared to the pre-Suez war climate, observers agree. Even when advised of the possibility that U.

N. may sooner than later give up financial responsibility for refugees, the refugees answer: “We don’t care. We will eat thistles and wild potatoes.”

CP-1957-031 →

· Buffalo Jewish Review · Buffalo · page 6

Study of Arab Propaganda Here Lists Role of Anti-Zionist Jews

By Milton Friedman, Jewish Telegraphic Agency

WASHINGTON — An evaluation of the Arab propaganda campaign in the United States published in Beirut gives anti-Zionist Jews more credit for effective anti-Israel pressure than it allocates to Americans of Arab descent. The propaganda research project is entitled: “Who Speaks for the Arabs?”

It was prepared by Malcolm Kerr, specialist on Middle East Affairs at the School of Advanced International Studies, Johns Hopkins University. First published in Beirut by “Middle East Forum — Al Kulliyah,” it is now being distributed by the Egyptian propaganda apparatus.

The Kerr study credits the anti-Zionist “American Council for Judaism” as a group which “speaks for the Arabs.” A major share of credit for anti-Israel activities is given the ACJ, which Mr. Kerr in the material which Egypt is now distributing to its agents. WORK OF THE ARAB INFORMATION CENTER in New York, Mr.

Kerr said, “is buttressed by the normal information services of the Arab Embassies, of which the Egyptian is the most active. More is probably accomplished, however, by several American organizations, notably the American Friends of the Middle East.

Describing itself as a non-partisan, non-political group concerned with religious, cultural and social relations, AFME is in fact ... steadfastly pro-Arab.” Kerr reported that AFME “includes among its members the well-respected names of former diplomats and numerous churchmen, businessmen, and educators. The national council chairman is Dr. Edward L. R.

Elson, President Eisenhower’s pastor in Washington.” Turning to what it considers another cog in the Arab propaganda machine, the Kerr study described how the American Council for Judaism “has an extensive public relations program of its own, in which, it is felt, it has some advantages over both AFME and the Arab Information Center.”

Elmer Berger, ACJ executive director, is quoted as pointing out that “precisely because we are Jews” the ACJ could take steps against fellow Jews. THE ANTI-ISRAEL propaganda evaluation reports on agitator Alfred M. Lilienthal, identifying him as “an anti-Zionist Jew.” Mr.

Lilienthal’s book — “What Price Israel?” — has become the Arabs’ standard text in the anti-Zionist fight. A new Arab front group sparked by Mr. Lilienthal, the so-called “Committee for Security and Justice in the Middle East” will “presumably furnish valuable reinforcements,” Mr. Kerr said.

The cartoon above the story shows a figure labeled BRITISH OIL CO. standing over a sack marked ISRAEL, captioned “NO MENTION OF HIS LITTLE GREMLIN.”

This is the clipping that shows what the category is actually sorting for. Everyone listed inside the Arab propaganda machine here is an American, and the ones given the most credit are Jews — a council, a president’s pastor, an author, an executive director quoted saying precisely because we are Jews. Americans of Arab descent come further down the list. The test is not who is speaking. It is what they said. Fifteen years on, Jewish anti-Zionism is no longer an argument among Jews.

CP-1957-022 →

· Freeport Journal-Standard · Freeport · page 1

Palestinian Refugees Awaken Arab World

Washington Merry-Go-Round

Drew Pearson, Amman

“The second great awakening came when Palestinian refugees, fleeing from what is now Israel, fanned out through the Arab world. While the lot of the refugees, in many cases, has been hard, their political influence has been tremendous.

They have been the single greatest factor in the Arab awakening since the end of Turkish rule… Every Arab delegation to the United Nations in New York has one or more Palestinian refugees serving as adviser… Wealthy refugees, of course, are in a great minority. The vast majority of refugees are peasants still living in camps… The refugees would never stand for it.

They want to remain in their camps, even in poverty, as a symbol of bitterness against Israel, a symbol of determination to go back to Israel. No matter what their poverty, no matter how long they have to wait, they prefer to sit in filth and bitterness till the day comes when they can return.”

Drew Pearson’s syndicated Washington Merry-Go-Round, datelined Amman, with Palestinian Refugees in the headline in 1957. Copyright 1957 by the Bell Syndicate, Inc.

CP-1957-009 →

· Valley News · Lebanon

Drew Pearson in Amman

“Just outside my window in the Hotel Philadelphia is an ancient Roman amphitheater built before Pontius Pilate, the Roman procurator, decreed…”

Drew Pearson's syndicated column reaching the upper Connecticut valley. He opens on a Roman amphitheatre and Pontius Pilate before he reaches anyone living. The Holy Land is the frame; the Arab delegation at the United Nations is the subject.

CP-1957-027 →

· Courier Post · Camden

Half-Million Refugees From Palestine Pose Threat to Jordan

Arabs Hope to Go Home

(United Press Correspondent Russell Jones is touring the Middle East. This is the first of several dispatches he will send from that world trouble spot.) Amman, Jordan, Oct. 7 (UP)—The most dangerous man in the Middle East today may be named Halim Deeb, Abdullah Said or Mutafa Hassim. He is not a soldier nor does he hold any political power or office.

He is not much concerned over the Soviet-Western struggle. In the Arab world, his name is about as common as Jones or Smith or Brown in the United States. But common as he is, he represents the most explosive force in the Middle East. For Deeb and Said and Hassim are three of more than half a million Arab refugees who crowd this small, arid country.

Along with 900,000 other Arabs they fled homes in Palestine when war started in 1948 between the new State of Israel and its Arab neighbors. The three settled here and they have never given up the hope of going back. Together with their refugee multitudes, they could destroy Jordan and set the Middle East aflame. The backgrounds of the three vary.

Halim Deeb was an orange grower near Jaffa. Abdullah was a small merchant in Haifa and Mustafa a simple farmer west of Jerusalem. LIVE IN SQUALOR. All three of them share two things—they live in squalor in refugee camps and they are unswervingly determined to return to their homes, now part and parcel of Israel.

Any halt in the United Nations relief which keeps them alive, or any suggestion of an Arab-Israeli settlement without their repatriation, would set Deeb, Said and Hassim on the rampage.

CP-1957-023 →

· The News Tribune · Tacoma

Displaced Arabs Nurse Wrath Against Israel

JERUSALEM, JORDANIAN SECTOR—Huddled in rag tents, or at best in tiny stone huts with open windows, half a million Palestinian Arab refugees have been sitting in Jordan for nine years with only one objective in view—to get back to their homes in what is now Israel.

Completely unlike the refugee problem in Europe, there not only has been no moving of these people to other lands or new homes, there is downright resistance to moving.

The Arab refugee problem is one of those emotional situations which defies any Western logic, and as the United Nations is again asked to find $40,000,000 to take care of a total of nearly 1,000,000 refugees at an average cost of $40 a head for another year, those who ask if the problem is any nearer to a solution can find a short answer in any camp in Jordan.

It is “no!” “I have a house in the Israeli-occupied part of Jerusalem,” a cultured, soft-spoken Palestinian refugee, who is a camp official just outside of Jerusalem, said.

Driven From Their Home “My brothers and my family built that house, put everything we had into it, and then we were thrown out.

Do you know that often I go with a telescope to a hill nearby just to look across and say I thank God my house is still there, and other Arabs will sneak across the border just to have an apple or a fruit from a tree in their own gardens.” Would he return if Israel offered him his house back? “I would never go back to live under an Israeli government.

The only way is for the Israelis to go away and let us have our property back. You do not understand what land means to an Arab. We do not want to go anywhere else. It is stronger among our children even than it is with us parents. You Americans and the British before you are the ones who encouraged all those Jews to come and take our land and our houses.

How would you like your house taken away from you and be told to find somewhere else to live.”

“Jews Must Be Driven Out” Did he see any solution? “The Arabs must unite and drive the Jews out. There is no other way but a war,” he said. And then a companion added: “And if the British and French had not interfered last November, Nasser would have beaten the Jewish army.”

CP-1957-024 →

· The New York Times · New York

Gaza Strip Owners Ask Rent From U.N.

“Landowners in the Gaza Strip had demanded that the United Nations Emergency Force pay rent for their camp sites and buildings… Officials are reported to have rejected the demand on the ground that they are guests of the Egyptian Government.”

The clearest small statement of the problem in the archive. People who own the ground are told the rent question is between two governments, because the force is a guest of one of them and was previously housed free by the other. Called one of the first instances of open friction between the people of the Gaza Strip and the international police force.

CP-1957-028 →

· Buffalo Jewish Review · Buffalo · page 1

Communists Clash With Police In Demonstration On Kfar Kassem

Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Tel Aviv

TEL AVIV (JTA) — Communist efforts to exploit the first anniversary of the slaying of 49 Arabs in Kfar Kassem village led to a police crackdown in which many Communists were arrested following a clash with police in the streets of Nazareth. The clash was the second Communist-inspired effort to gain political capital from the Kfar Kassem slayings.

The first was an attempt by Tewfik Toubi, Communist Arab member of the Knesset, to break into the Arab village despite a police cordon. The Kfar Kassem disaster, which occurred on the eve of the Sinai operation, remains a source of bitterness and tension despite Premier Ben Gurion’s expressions of regret and the compensation paid to the families of the victims.

The fact that the military tribunal has not completed court martial hearings in the case has increased the bitterness of the region, which the Communists are trying to exploit.

Forty-nine people killed at Kafr Qasim, reported a year later as a problem of Communist exploitation. The killings are named in the first sentence and never described. The Arab member of the Knesset who tried to reach the village is named.

CP-1957-010 →

· The Evening Gazette · page 1

Village Named

“The two officers and seven enlisted men are accused of shooting the Arabs at the village of Kfar Kassem when the villagers—men, women and children—were found outside their homes in violation of an all-night curfew. The incident occurred immediately after Israeli launched its Sinai campaign but was not disclosed officially until Dec. 12.

Officials condemned the action in parliament.”

The suppression stated plainly in the paper’s own words: the killings happened as the Sinai campaign began and were not disclosed officially until 12 December. “Israeli” for “Israel” is the paper’s.

CP-1957-012 →

· Buffalo Jewish Review · Buffalo · page 1

Israel to Pay Compensation to Heirs of Arabs Killed in Kfar Kassem

Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Jerusalem

“JERUSALEM (JTA)—A special commission investigating the murder of 48 Arabs at Kfar Kassem an Arab village in Israel, has recommended that the Israel Government pay 5,000 pounds compensation to the heirs of every man and woman killed in the affair, plus certain other sums to dependents of the dead and to persons wounded in the shootings.

Premier David Ben Gurion has pledged to honor the committee’s recommendations. The Arabs were returning from the fields the evening of the day the Israeli Army opened the Sinai drive. Unaware of a curfew imposed on the area in their absence, they panicked when suddenly faced by an Israeli military partol which ordered them to halt.

They turned and ran and the soldier, under orders of a lieutenant, opened fire. The officer and several enlisted men are awaiting trial on charges of unjustified firing on the Arab population.”

The word in the first line is murder, and the number is 48. Printed in a Jewish community weekly in Buffalo. “partol” is the paper’s.

CP-1957-013 →

· Independent (Los Angeles)

Israeli Petroleum Student Recounts Variety In Education

It’s a far cry from the government schools of Palestine to UCLA. It’s a far cry, too, from the study of classics to laboratory experiments involving the behavior of petroleum reservoirs. This is a capsule of the life story of Aziz Odeh, 31, of 127 N. Hamilton Dr.

Los Angeles, former General Petroleum Corp. employee now on leave of absence from Magnolia Petroleum Co., to obtain his doctorate at UCLA. General Petroleum and Magnolia are affiliates of Socony Mobil Oil Co., Inc. Odeh (pronounced O’Day) is working on a research project which, if successful would be useful in most types of well drilling.

In the words of UCLA’s Professor S. T. Yuster, under whose guidance Odeh is studying: “We are tremendously excited over the prospects of this experiment.”

Specifically, Odeh is engaged in developing a permeability log, a new combination instrument for logging wells to gain information on permeability, porosity and fluid saturation in petroleum reservoirs without coring, an expensive but necessary process which furnishes samples of sub-surface strata. “We have high hopes for the success of the log,” Odeh says.

The equipment for this research at UCLA is made possible by a grant-in-aid through the Socony Mobile Contribution Committee. The funds are for the purchase of laboratory supplies and equipment. After Odeh has completed his studies, the equipment will remain in the school of Engineering for the use and instruction of other students.

Odeh was born in Nazareth, Palestine, and completed his high school education in the government schools there. In 1945 he graduated from the Government Arab College in Jerusalem, where he majored in classics. Following graduation he taught high school until the end of 1946.

Odeh’s thoughts turned to a career in medicine, and he wrote to several American colleges and universities to gain admittance into medical school. He was accepted by the University of California at Berkeley. At the same time the British government offered him a scholarship to study philosophy at the University of London; however he elected to go to the United States.

“When I first arrived in New York, I had a hard time because I didn’t know the English language,” he recalls.

OIL FIELD LABORATORY—Palestine-born Aziz Odeh, graduate student at UCLA, checks connections on equipment he is using in laboratory experiments involving behavior of petroleum reservoirs. He is former employe of General Petroleum Corp.

CP-1957-035 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

Peacemaking Feast in Kafr Kasim

“PEACEMAKING FEAST IN KAFR KASIM—Israeli Jews and Arabs join in a feast at Kafr Kasim, Israel, on the Arab Jordan border, symbolizing forgiveness and atonement for the slaughter in the village last year. An Israeli border police patrol killed 49 Israeli Arabs and wounded 14 on October 29 last year for breaking a suddenly imposed curfew.

The feast, known as Soulha or peacemaking, symbolized acceptance by Israeli Arab villagers of government compensation for their killed and wounded.”—AP Wirephoto.

A year after the killings, the photograph of the sulha: the two sides at one long table, and a caption that uses the word slaughter and gives the number as forty-nine. The last sentence explains what the meal was for.

CP-1957-018 →

· The New York Times

ARABS CRITICIZE TURKISH PREMIER

Say He Failed to Discuss Palestine Issue in Speech to Atlantic Council

By SAM POPE BREWER

CP-1957-034 →

· Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle · Milwaukee · page 1

“Palestinian” Patriots

Anita Engle, Kiryat Amal, Israel

“Palestinian” Patriots. KIRYAT AMAL, Israel — Passing through Ness Ziona, a settlement of private orange growers, to the south of Tel Aviv, I noticed an odd looking structure set amongst the buildings of the village. It looked like a mosque, but was very primitive, as though made of mud. “What is that building?” I asked someone in the bus.

“That’s the mosque belonging to the community of Arabs from Egypt which used to live here. They came to work in the orange groves of Ness Ziona, and fled during the War of Liberation.”

It suddenly occurred to me: Are these ex-Egyptians from Ness Ziona among the Arab refugees who are sitting in the Gaza strip, and elsewhere, demanding to be repatriated to Palestine? And what about the laborers from the Hauran, who created a shanty town suburb on the outskirts of Jaffa, on either side of the Jerusalem-Tel Aviv highway?

For a few pitstres these “Palestinian” patriots were always ready to create a disturbance. Armed with stones and cudgels, they started the murderous assault on traffic which began the riots of 1936. Are these patriots and their offspring also among the Arab refugees demanding to be returned to Palestine, at Jewish expense?

And what about all the other Arabs who began pouring into Palestine from Syria, Lebanon, Trans-Jordan and Egypt, from 1920 onwards? It was a natural drift from countries of depressed standards to the one country in the Middle East where there was steady work, rising wages, and decreased death rate for their children.

No Accurate Estimate Available. The Palestine Royal Commission Report of 1937 (known as the Peel Report) admits that no accurate estimate can be made of the number of Arabs who have come into Palestine from neighboring Arab lands and settled there.

This incidentally, reveals an astonishing carelessness to Arab immigration as opposed to the pained anxiety with which the Palestine Administration counted every Jewish immigrant to Palestine. As many a bereaved family remembers, the Authorities even sent refugees back to gas chambers, rather than admit one more than the “legal” limit.

Whatever the number of Arab immigrants into Palestine, the Peel Report records that during the first 17 years of the Jewish National Home, the Arab population in Palestine increased over 50%!

“These are remarkable figures,” the report admits, “especially in view of the general belief that the population of Palestine under the Ottoman regime was more or less stationary.”

And so if the truth were known — which appears to be the last thing that the governments concerned seem to want known — most of the so-called Palestinian Arab refugees are probably not Palestinian at all.

These miserable people who have been kept in stagnation and decay which is even a greater disgrace to the Western Powers, for it is they who have implanted the Arab governments to make political pawns of human being — at Western expense — these people would not so easily have fled if they had real roots in Palestine.

Some Arabs Remained. All around Kiryat Amal, where I live, and throughout the Galilee, there are Arab farmers, going their own way, as they have always done. There are Arab farmers all over Israel. They also must have heard the Arab leaders’ order to the Palestine Arabs to leave their homes “so as to clear the way for the victorious Arab armies.”

Not only were their own leaders inciting them to leave, but no less an authority than Great Britain’s Near East Arab Broadcasting Station.

Here is a quotation from a recent and shocking article on this station’s activities, as revealed by Ray Alan in American published “The Reporter”: “By playing up anti-Jewish atrocity stories and the Arab leaders” order to the Palestine Arabs to leave their homes . . . the station . . . gave strong encouragement to the exodus that created the Arab refugee problem.’

What a slimy tissue of lies has been cast over this whole business of Arab refugees. Each Power has been so busy trying to truss up Israel and throw us to the wolves, they don’t see that they’ve got themselves hog tied, and the only country left with any freedom of action in the Middle East is Russia.

The argument that the refugees were not really Palestinian, made in 1958 with the word in scare quotes in the headline. It is one of the clearest statements in the archive of the claim the collection is assembled against, and it is printed here in full.

CP-1958-001 →

· The Evening Sun · page 1

Palestinians Due More Voice In Gaza Rule

The Associated Press, Cairo, March 11

Cairo, March 11 (AP)—Egyptian authorities are to announce Saturday a new organic law for the Gaza Strip giving Palestinians greater participation in the government. But the Egyptian military government will retain supreme powers.

As published in the Gaza Official Gazette, the law gives Palestinians a big majority over Egyptians in the 30-man Legislative Council… This will be the first time Gaza Palestinians have had a hand in governing the strip as a whole…

Nasser Motives Eyed. Palestinians living in the area have elected their own municipal councils but had no participation in the over-all government… An all-Palestine government was formed in 1948 with its capital in Gaza and still exists in theory.

This government never took over administrative functions in Gaza, however, and its ministers spent most of their time in Cairo. The new Legislative Council will include 23 Palestinians and 7 Egyptians.

One dispatch, two papers, two headlines. This one leads with the people.

CP-1958-002 →

· The Herald Press · page 1

Gaza Palestinians Get Voice In Gov’t.

The Associated Press, Cairo, March 12

CAIRO, March 12 (AP)—Egyptian authorities are to announce Saturday a new organic law for the Gaza Strip giving Palestinians greater participation in the government. But the Egyptian military government will retain supreme powers. As published in the Gaza Official Gazette, the law gives Palestinians a big majority over Egyptians in the 30-man legislative council.

But the Egyptian governor general will have veto power over all legislation and Egyptians will dominate the nine-man executive council. This will be the first time Gaza Palestinians have had a hand in governing the strip as a whole. The strip has been governed by Egyptian military authorities since the 1948 Palestine war.

The same Associated Press copy as the Evening Sun the day before, trimmed and re-headlined.

CP-1958-003 →

· The News Tribune

Ancient Port Of Phoenicia Still Resisting

By JOE ALEX MORRIS JR. / New York Herald Tribune News Service

TYRE, Lebanon.—This ancient Phoenician port, once the trade capital of the known world, is today reliving its historical tradition of resistance. Tyre is once again under a virtual state of siege. Ignited by the fiery Arab nationalism symbolized by Col.

Gamal Abdel Nasser, Tyre has emerged from centuries of sleepy tranquillity and, in the words of a Lebanese deputy, severed its relations with the rest of the jittery country. Lebanese army patrols in combat dress march through Tyre’s silent streets past the slammed-down corrugated iron shutters of its shops. In the main square armored car crews lounge against their vehicles.

An army command post run by a young lieutenant just back from six months training at Fort Benning, Ga., operates from the town prison. Tyre has a reputation for toughness. Its Arabic name “Soor” means rampart.

It successfully resisted a 13-year siege by Nebuchadnezzar and it took Alexander’s famed legions seven months to reduce the town to ashes and slaughter or enslave all its inhabitants. Two violent clashes with security forces rocked the town recently and left several dead and many wounded.

Dynamite and rocks were hurled at police by angered townspeople, many of them mere youths. Hundreds were arrested. The town has been on protest strike for a week, a strike which has been joined by other communities in the south and threatens to spread through the country.

It started with the sentencing of five youths for alleged defamation of the Lebanese flag during a demonstration celebrating the birth of Col. Nasser’s United Arab Republic. A protest demonstration was organized which Mayor Abdel Rahman Khalil feels would have taken place whether they were jailed or freed. “The Communists were behind it.

Their propaganda is very effective,” the jodhpur-clad mayor said. “As long as the Americans fail to offer a constructive solution for Palestine the Communists will continue to corrupt and mislead our people under the slogan for Palestine and the Arabs.” The Palestine-Israel question is close to the hearts of the people of Tyre.

They live but 20 miles from Israel and the normal population of 15,000 has been swollen by 30,000 refugees during the past decade. The sealed border has closed off normal commercial and trade routes to the south and upset the town’s economy.

For the archive the value is in the last two paragraphs: an American wire feature in 1958 recording that a Lebanese town of 15,000 was holding 30,000 Palestinian refugees ten years on, that the border was sealed and the town's economy broken by it, and that the mayor framed the whole crisis as a consequence of America failing to settle Palestine. The paper calls it “what the Arabs like to refer to as their usurped homeland” further down the column — the distancing is the paper's own.

CP-1958-026 →

· Jackson Citizen Patriot · Jackson · page 1

Needs of Palestinian Arab Refugees Are Ignored by the UN and the World

Dorothy Thompson

“Needs of Palestinian Arab Refugees Are Ignored by the UN and the World. (Opinions herein expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily coincide with the views of the Citizen Patriot.) It is deeply regrettable that Henry R. Labouisse has resigned as director of the United Nations relief and works administration (UNRWA) — although nobody can blame him.

The former State department official who originally took the job for a year stayed four, far from his home and family. Mr. Labouisse has worked with unflagging vigor but with continual discouragement.

The plain fact is that with all the talk about the importance of the Middle East nobody wants to do much, if anything, about the Palestinian refugees, whose plight is, nevertheless, one of the scandals and these times and a chief impediment to stable conditions in the Middle East.

Meager Funds. Mr. Labouisse did all he could with the meager funds allotted by the UN for their relief, but even getting the pledged money was a continual struggle. What was pledged was wholly insufficient to do a job of rehabilitation, which was Mr. Labouisse’s ardent aim.

Recently he had been trying to increase $33,000,000 to $40,000,000 annually—which had been budgeted but was not forthcoming, and which in view of the magnitude of the problem is a pittance anyhow. The refugees number nearly a million. Their physical conditions have improved since I first visited their camps in Lebanon, Syria, and Jordan seven years ago.

Most of them now have something more substantial over their heads than a leaking tent, or the roof of a cave, or an old Roman viaduct. They are no longer living in Damascus mosques, big families separated from each other only by burlap curtains and with sanitary facilities unspeakable.

People also now know that they exist, these victims of the partition of Palestine, forced out of the land of their ancestors to make room for a new immigration from elsewhere. For a long time there was a veritable conspiracy of silence about the expropriation of their lands and property, and the circumstances under which they fled or were forced out. Now people know.

But to do anything for Arabs is an unpopular cause. When Jews lost their homes first in Germany and then in Europe and were threatened with extinction, hundreds of millions of dollars were voluntarily raised for their aid, and tens of thousands of visas made available, in America and elsewhere.

There was an immediate response from the West to aid the victims of the Hungarian uprising a year and a half ago. But there are no visas, no chance for a new life for Arab victims.

Christians. The Palestinians, originally the Canaanites, are one of the most intelligent of the Arab groups. Most of them were agriculturalists, farmers or farm workers, craftsmen and businessmen, though among them were doctors, lawyers, and other professionals. A large proportion of them are Christian.

There are few American citizens of Arab extraction, but they are exceptionally peaceable, law-abiding, thrifty and self-supporting. You seldom find an Arab name among criminals, adult or juvenile. But the Arabs, from wherever they come, continue to be treated as Ishmael and Esau, done out of their inheritance by younger brothers.”

A nationally syndicated American columnist in 1958 calling the refugees “forced out of the land of their ancestors” and naming the silence about it. It runs above an advice column and beside a note about statues of American presidents in London.

CP-1958-004 →

· Central New Jersey Home News · New Brunswick

Indian Resembles Bedouin, Israeli Visitor Believes

By HERBERT BEN-ADI

The other day someone pointed out an American Indian to me. I don’t know what he was doing here or how he came here, but he reminded me very much of the Bedouins in Israel; there is a great similarity between the two races. Not that they are of the same origin, because the Bedouins are of Arabic descent, but otherwise their ways of living are very similar.

The Bedouins, or as they call themselves the “Badawi,” are nomads who have been roaming the Arabian peninusla and Palestine for the last two thousand years. In most countries they are still the same wild nomads they used to be. In Jordan, Glubb Pasha managed to settle the mand to form them into the well known Arab Legion.

In Israel the government, in a ten-year effort, managed to make semi farmers out of the Bedouins and considerably improved their living standard. At present 18,000 Bedouins are living in Israel territory, all of them settled in the Negev. They are divied into 14 tribes, each of them ruled by a sheik.

The sheiks in most cases have been elected by the members of the tribe and their appointment is confirmed by Israeli authorities. The Bedouins cultivate about 125,000 acres of farm land and they have another quarter million of grazing lands. Like in most parts of Israel the land is owned by the government and rented to the Bedouins at 10 cents per acre.

If a Bedoiun can prove that he has been working his land for the last 15 years he becomes its owner. Besides being farmers the Bedouins also own big herds of camels, sheep, goats and horses. Today most sheiks have agricultural machines to work the land, which they rent to their tribesmen for a fee.

Although not all Bedouins have yet been convinced that it is better to work the soil the modern way it is not unusual to see a Bedouin with a wooden plow in one field and next to him another Bedouin working with a tractor.

Date check: The folio line at the top of the page reads “‘Want Ad’ Service . . . KI 5-4000” on the left and, on the right, a running head that the scan crops mid-word: “THE DAILY HO” (consistent with The Daily Home News). No date appears in the folio line or anywhere else on the clipping, so 1958-07-09 cannot be confirmed from the image.

CP-1958-025 →

· The Herald News · Passaic · page 1

Palestinian Arabs Still Expect to Regain Homes

Ration Card Is Symbol of Hope

Wilton Wynn, Associated Press, Beirut

BEIRUT, (AP)—A little card worth $1.50 a month stands between the Palestine Arab refugee and despair these days. Once the barometer of Middle Eastern politics, the refugee feels left out of things in these days of feuds between pro-Nasser and anti-Nasser factions in the Arab world. The United Nations talks more about Lebanon and Iraq than about Palestine.

But so long as the refugee hangs on to his UN ration card, he has hope. Economically, the card means he can eat. The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine distributes rations to more than 830,000 refugees in Gaza, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon.

These are the people, or children of people, who fled their homes in Palestine 10 years ago and have lived off UN rations ever since.

What He Gets. The monthly ration gives the refugee something like six pounds of flour, a pound and a half of beans, an equal amount of sugar and rice and a little more than a pound of fat or oil. On local markets, the value of these rations runs to little more than $1.50. To the refugee, the ration card also represents a political claim.

Issued by the UN, it implicitly recognizes that he has been dispossessed and that has a claim to something back in Palestine. To an outsider, it is almost impossible to believe that these refugees still are convinced they will go back to homes inside what now is Israel.

Israel has celebrated its 10th anniversary, but the Arab refugees has not begun to accept Israel as permanent. They insist the Arabs one day will conquer Israel and restore the refugees.

Resist Resettlement. This atttitude—unchanged in 10 years—partly explains the refugees’ resistance to resettlement and their determination to cling to that ration card. There are more refugees on rations now than five years ago. UNRWA is on a treadmill in its efforts to solve the refugee problem.

When an Arab dies in a refugee camp, his family may bury him secretly and continue to draw his rations. When a son goes to Kuwait or Iraq and finds a job, the family stays behind in a refugee camp in Jordan or Gaza and holds on to the son’s ration card. The son later returns to live in the camp; he doesn’t go to Kuwait to stay.

The refugees don’t want to exchange that ration card for a job. It would look too much like giving up their “ticket back to Palestine.” This straw of hope may be taken from the refugees when UNRWA’s mandate expires in 1960. UN member states are tired of contributing to a program that gets nowhere. In 1953, UNRWA was feeding 806,620 refugees.

Five years later, UNRWA is feeding 836,777. The increase is due largely to birth rate. The number who become self-supporting, who emigrate, or who are reported dead is negligible… The refugees also are in danger of losing their political position in the Arab world. Arab leaders are forgetting to list Palestine first among their grievances.

They are fighting over other things… “Did you hear that speech?” a worried Palestinian asked. “He didn’t say much about Palestine, did he?” In spite of these omens, the refugees still place blind hope in what the ration card represents.

A wire correspondent explaining, in 1958, why the ration card was refused as a trade for a job: it was the receipt for a claim. “Atttitude” is the paper’s.

CP-1958-005 →

· Newport Daily News · Newport

U.N. Ration Cards Worth Only $1.50 Give Palestine Arab Refugees Hope

Associated Press

BEIRUT (AP) — A little card worth $1.50 a month stands between the Palestine Arab refugee and despair, these days. Once the barometer of Middle Eastern politics, the refugee feels left out of things in these days of feuds between pro-Nasser and anti-Nasser factions in the Arab world. The United Nations talks more about Lebanon and Iraq than about Palestine.

But so long as the refugee hangs on to his U.N. ration card, he has hope. Economically, the card means he can eat. The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine UNRWA distributes rations to more than 830,000 refugees in Gaza, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon.

These are the people, or children of people, who fled their homes in Palestine 10 years ago and have lived off U.N. rations ever since. The monthly ration gives the refugee something like six pounds of flour, a pound and a half of beans, an equal amount of sugar and rice and a little more than a pound of fat or oil.

On local markets, the value of these rations runs to little more than $1.50. To the refugee, the ration card also represents a political claim. Issued by the U.N., it implicitly recognizes that he has been dispossessed and that he has a claim to something back in Palestine.

To an outsider, it is almost impossible to believe that these refugees still are convinced they will go back to homes inside what now is Israel. Israel has celebrated its 10th anniversary, but the Arab refugees have not begun to accept Israel as permanent. They insist the Arabs one day will conquer Israel and restore the refugees.

The refugees don’t want to exchange that ration card for a job. It would look too much like giving up their “ticket back to Palestine.” This straw of hope may be taken from the refugees when UNRWA’s mandate expires in 1960. U.N. member states are tired of contributing to a program that gets nowhere. In 1953, UNRWA was feeding 806,620 refugees.

Five years later, UNRWA is feeding 836,777. The increase is due largely to birthrate. The number who become self-supporting, who emigrate, or who are reported dead is negligible. The refugees also are in danger of losing their political position in the Arab world. Arab leaders are forgetting to list Palestine first among their grievances. They are fighting over other things.

The ration card read as a political document rather than as food. The news agency says so outright: issued by the United Nations, it implicitly recognizes that he has been dispossessed and that he has a claim to something back in Palestine, which is why the refugees will not exchange it for a job. Two counts five years apart are printed together — 806,620 in 1953 and 836,777 in 1958 — with the increase attributed to birthrate. Beside it on the page, a Middletown man is hit by a car door.

CP-1958-009 →

· Washington Daily News · Washington · page 1

Refugees Pin All Hopes on Nasser

Jericho Palestinian Group

Henry N. Taylor, Scripps-Howard Staff Writer, Jericho, Jordan

JERICHO, Jordan, Aug. 5—Here 1200 sweltering feet below sea level, where the River Jordan stagnates into the Dead Sea, sit 90,000 of the world’s angriest and—right now—most frightened people. They are Palestinian refugees who used to live in what 10 years ago became Israel. They still want to go home…

SECRETS. “I will show you two secrets,” said a man with flashing black eyes outside a refugee hut near the walls of ancient Jericho. Inside the mud brick hut he untangled a muddle of old clothes and shook two objects out on the matted floor. One was a key to his abandoned house in Jaffa, Israel. The other was a photo of Abdel Nasser…

CAME IN ’48. Most came here to Jericho in the winter of 1948 after midnight departures with little more possessions than the family and maybe a mule could carry. The refugees claim they were driven out at Israeli bayonet point.

The Israelis say they fled with no urging… along the rows of possessionless huts in a camp which houses 27,000 with only eight known beds—you hear one clear word out of every mumble of Arabic. The word is “Nasser.”

The key is kept in a bundle of old clothes, and the two explanations of 1948 are printed four paragraphs apart in the same column.

CP-1958-006 →

· The News Tribune · Tacoma

The Big ‘If’: What Will Israel Do If Jordan Falls?

By William Ryan, AP Foreign Analyst

“Hot, barren hills sprinkled with slate gray rock brood solemnly over one of the most jittery spots in the world today. The word on every tongue is ‘if.’

If anything should happen to King Hussein, ruler of the Hashemite kingdom of the Jordan— If Jordan should be attacked by one of her neighbors in an attempt to swallow up the confused little country— If Israel should feel she is threatened with complete encirclement by Gamel Abdel Nasser’s United Arab Republic. What would happen?

Would Israel move swiftly to straighten out her eastern borders? Would the Israelis occupy the eastern half of divided Jerusalem? Would the Israelis, indeed, seek to occupy that part of Palestine now a part of the Hashemite kingdom?

… The area of the most violent Arab nationalist fever lies in the northern part of Palestinian Jordan, a triangle whose points [are] Tulkarm, on the Israeli front[ier,] Jenin, to the northeast, and Nablus, to the south.

This sector has been the scene of disturbances against Hussien’s throne since the nationalist revolt in Iraq started the Palestinian kettle seething again.

Explosion Could Result. The area of Palestine held by Jordan is home for about a million Palestinians, who outnumber the Jordanians on the other side of the Jordan River by about two to one… The assault against Hussein, if and when it comes, will be staged by Palestinians. For the most part, Palestine’s nationalists will want to join Nasser’s U.A.R.

If they attempt it, some sort of Israeli response is likely. A major Middle East explosion could result.”

An Associated Press analyst in 1958 counting the people and getting the arithmetic right: about a million Palestinians in the part of Palestine held by Jordan, outnumbering the Jordanians on the other bank two to one. He calls the territory Palestinian Jordan and speaks of Palestine’s nationalists as a political force with intentions of their own — six years before the Palestine Liberation Organization was founded, in a Tacoma paper, beside a map and a department-store advertisement. The figure of speech he reaches for is a kettle, seething.

CP-1958-007 →

· Chattanooga Daily Times

8 Israeli Guards Guilty of Murder

Twenty-two months later a court has spoken, and the language changes completely. Murder, in the headline, with Israelis as the subject.

CP-1958-010 →

· Chattanooga Daily Times

8 ISRAELI GUARDS GUILTY OF MURDER

“…on Oct. 29, 1956, the day Israel…”

The second crop of the same Chattanooga page, carrying the date the killings happened.

CP-1958-011 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore

Eight Israelis Ruled Guilty In Massacre Of 43 Arabs

The word massacre in a headline, for the first time in this archive’s coverage of Kafr Qasim. It had been in print since December 1956, in the body of a Newsday story; the headlines waited until an Israeli military court convicted eight border police. Three papers carry it on the same morning. The count here is 43.

CP-1958-012 →

· The Arizona Republic · Phoenix

8 Israeli Police Found Guilty In Arab Massacre

Phoenix. Massacre again, and the police are identified as police rather than guards or a band.

CP-1958-013 →

· The Morning News · Wilmington

Israel Convicts 8 Police In Arab Village Massacre

“JERUSALEM (Israeli Sector)… privates, were acquitted by the…”

Israel is the subject again, but this time the verb is convicts. Three privates were acquitted.

CP-1958-014 →

· The New York Times · New York

8 ISRAELIS GUILTY IN ARABS’ MURDER

Compare with the same paper’s headline twenty-two months earlier: 48 Arabs killed; Israel penitent. Same paper, same event, and the difference is a verdict.

CP-1958-015 →

· Washington Daily News · Washington

8 Israelis Sentenced for Arab Massacre

Washington, D.C., 16 October 1958. Seven words, and every one of them is doing work the December 1956 headlines would not do: Israelis, sentenced, massacre.

CP-1958-016 →

· Winston-Salem Journal · Winston-Salem

Israeli Border Police Found Guilty in Massacre

United Press International

“Eight Israeli border police, including a major, were found guilty Sunday of taking part in the massacre that killed 47 persons in the Arab village of Kafr Kasim in October 1956… Judge Benjamin Halevi accused two of the convicted men — Lt. Gabriel Dehan and Lt.

Shalmo Offer — of ‘cold-bloodedly murdering unarmed men, women and children who were peacefully returning to their homes.’”

The fullest account in the archive, and the only one carrying the judge’s own words. Benjamin Halevi would sit on the Eichmann trial three years later. The count here is 47; other papers the same week say 43, 48 and 49.

CP-1958-017 →

· Evening Star · Washington

Israel Sentences Eight in Killings

Washington. Israel is the subject and the verb is sentences, which is the state acting on itself.

CP-1958-018 →

· Buffalo Jewish Review · Buffalo

Eight Israeli Policemen Convicted of Murder of Kfar Kassem Arabs

Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Jerusalem

The same Buffalo paper that in December 1956 called the dead curfew violators now calls it murder, and names the village.

CP-1958-019 →

· Arizona Post · Tucson

Israelis Found Guilty In Death Of 47 Arabs

Tucson, in a Jewish community paper. Death of rather than killing of, even in a verdict headline.

CP-1958-020 →

· Morning World

Israeli Patrolmen Given Sentences

7-17 Years

“7–17 years. Israeli patrolmen given sentences.”

The sentences, seven to seventeen years. An American paper in this archive reports in 1988 that all of them were out within three years.

CP-1958-021 →

· The Palm Beach Post · West Palm Beach

Israeli Court Convicts Eight In ’56 Massacre

Florida. The court is Israeli and so are the convicted, which the headline manages to say in six words.

CP-1958-022 →

· The New York Times · New York

ISRAEL SENTENCES 8 FOR MASSACRE

The New York Times uses the word massacre on 17 October 1958. It had not used it on 13 December 1956, when it ran 48 Arabs killed; Israel penitent.

CP-1958-023 →

· Arizona Post · Tucson

Arab Killings Probed

Israeli Soldiers Sentenced

“Israeli soldiers sentenced. Arab killings probed.”

Two weeks after the sentences, a separate inquiry. The headline uses the passive for both halves.

CP-1958-024 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

Hammarskjold Hears Complaints at Gaza

By the Associated Press, Gaza

GAZA, Dec. 26 (AP).—United Nations Secretary General Dag Hammarskjold today ended his three-day visit to the Gaza Strip by calling at two refugee camps. He was greeted by shouts of “We want to return to our homes.” Thousands of Arab refugees from Israeli Palestine lined his route to the camps carrying banners reading “Welcome to Palestine, Hammarskjold.

We demand immediate repatriation.” About one million Palestinians were driven from their homes during the 1948 Arab-Israeli war. Many of them live in this strip now administered by Israel and guarded by a U. N. emergency force. One refugee student complained to Mr.

Hammarskjold that students who graduate from secondary schools cannot find work and that UNRWA (United Nations Work and Relief Agency) is doing nothing to help them. The student complained that the U. N. alloted more money to the UNEF than to UNRWA. Mr. Hammarskjold answered that he and his assistants were working within the limits of money given by U. N. members. Mr.

Hammarskjold also visited Dier Elbalah camp where 3,000 refugees are living. He arrived Tuesday to spend Christmas with UNEF contingents patrolling the demarcation line separating Israel and Gaza.

The verb is driven, and the noun is Palestinians, in Associated Press copy in 1958. Ten years of wire stories had said fled, left, evacuated and reached. The people shouting at the Secretary-General are quoted in the second sentence, and what they shout is that they want to go home.

CP-1958-008 →

· Chicago Sunday Tribune · Chicago · page 1

Plight of Refugees in Jordan Depicted

Arab view on Middle East

Chesly Manly, Chicago Sunday Tribune

“IN JORDAN one soon gets an impression that Palestinian refugees are about its only inhabitants. Actually Jordan has only 567,369 registered refugees, 36 per cent of its total population, but there are thousands of others who never registered as refugees, and they seem to be running the country.

On the way from the airport, north of Jerusalem, to the new Ambassador hotel, the taxi driver points west toward Israel’s part of the Holy City, across a narrow strip of no man’s land. ‘I had a big automobile service station right over there,’ he says.

Hussein Affifi, receptionist at the hotel, which is on Mount Scopus, takes this reporter out in front, where there is a fine view of the whole city. He points to a three story, 12 room house a few hundred yards away and says he lost it to the Jews when they occupied most of the city outside its ancient walls in 1948.

The barman, Said Ahmad, an engaging young man, tells about the massacre at Deir Yassin, a village northwest of Jerusalem, where his father had a small farm. ‘I was 14,’ he says. ‘The Jews mowed down men, women, and children with machine guns. My father was blinded in a grenade explosion. I have supported my father, mother, and two sisters since then.

In 1951 I applied for UNRWA [United Nations Relief and Works agency] rations but was told it was too late.’ It is a cliche that Palestinian refugees greatly exaggerate Jewish atrocities.

However, the Deir Yassin massacre is described by Jon Kimche, editor of an English Zionist organ, in his ‘Seven Fallen Pillars’ as ‘the darkest stain on the Jewish record.’

Menachem Begin, former commander of the Irgun Zvai Leumi, Jewish terrorist organization, and now a member of Israel’s knesset [parliament], denies that his men massacred the villagers but does not minimize the effect of Deir Yassin on the Arabs of Palestine.

In ‘The Revolt: Story of the Irgun,’ Begin writes: ‘Arabs thruout the country, induced to believe the wild tales of “Irgun butchery,” were seized with limitless panic and started to flee for their lives. This mass flight soon developed into a maddened, uncontrollable stampede.’…

Five Persons to a Room 10 Feet Square. Four of Jordan’s largest UNRWA camps, with a total population of about 85,000, are in the Jericho area of the Jordan valley… Aqabat Jaber, largest of all UNRWA camps with more than 40,000 residents, is about one mile south of Jericho and three miles west of ancient Gilgal, where the Israelites pitched their first camp after crossing the Jordan river into the Promised Land… There are two and three family units at Aqabat Jaber, and the average occupancy is five persons to a room 3 meters [about 10 feet] square… Since UNRWA’s budget allowance for basic rations in Jordan is only $15 a year [$1.25 a month] per person, one may wonder where the refugees get the money for such commercial activity.

Ibrahim Aburish, the camp director, who is a refugee from Israel’s part of Jerusalem, explains that most of the men find work of some kind for a few weeks or a few months each year…

Insist Palestine Must Be Arab Nation. ‘Palestine must be an Arab country,’ said Mohammed Ali Kawamleh, the camp director, a refugee from Zakaria village, near Hebron. ‘There is no other solution. The hopes of the refugees now are higher than ever. All the Arab countries soon will be united, and Israel cannot resist such a force.

Without western backing, Israel is nothing. When the Arabs are united the western countries will realize that it is against their interest to back Israel. Then Israel will be finished.’ A bearded mukhtar, wearing a turban, said the director had expressed the unanimous sentiment of Kalandia’s refugees.

‘Even young children who were born here say the same,’ the mukhtar declared. ‘If Israel wants peace, the Jews will have to live in an Arab country. If not, we are ready to take our homes and our lands by force. There is no alternative.’

He said he lost 45 dunums [11.25 acres] of orange trees and a fine house, worth together about 55,000 dinars [$154,000], near Jaffa, and now is living with his wife, four sons, and three daughters in the refugee camp.

Before the Palestine war in 1948, most of Kalandia’s 3,000 refugees were small farmers, with 60 or 70 dunums of land, but some owned as much as 1,000 dunums, the camp director said.”

“Map locates points mentioned in articles on this page.”

A Chicago reporter in 1959 writing down what refugees told him, with their names, their trades and what they had owned. He also checks the Deir Yassin account against a Zionist editor and against Begin’s own book, and quotes both.

CP-1959-001 →

· The Columbus Enquirer · Columbus, GA · page Page Twelve

Evangelist-Archaeologist Tells of Jerusalem Work

By LARRY AGEE, Enquirer Church Editor

An archaeologist who found, during one of four excavations in Jerusalem, 22 towers that date from the time of Jehosaphat, is the guest evangelist in the revival this week at Gentian Boulevard Baptist Church. The Rev. Randolph D. Mullis is host pastor. Dr. Marc H. Lovelace, professor of archaeology at Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary, Wake Forest, N.

C., spent 15 months, 1955-56, as fellow in the School of Oriental Research in Jerusalem in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan. "Half of what used to be called Palestine is the Arab section," Dr. Lovelace said in an interview Sunday night. "The Jewish section is the modern state of Israel." Dr.

Lovelace spent three months excavating in Old Testament Jericho under the direction of Dr. Kathleen Kenyon, director of the Institute of Archaeology at the University of London. She is the daughter of the late Sir Frederick Kenyon, a director of the British Museum. He termed this "a very fruitful digging."

LABEL ORDER: Maria's label lists slide 73 as 'The Elkhart Truth April 14 1951' then 'The Columbus Enquirer March 23 1959'. The images are in the reverse order: s073_1 is the Columbus Enquirer and s073_2 is the Elkhart Truth. Folio reads 'Page Twelve' at the left and 'The Columbus Enquirer, Columbus, Ga.,' at the right; the date would follow that final comma but is cut off by the right edge of the scan. Paper and page are verified; the date is not. There is no deck; the crossheads 'Dhiban Excavated' and 'Tells of Rain Damage' are crossheads inside the story. The rest of the page carries unrelated items — 'Phenix Church Group Sponsors YMCA Supper', 'Two Are Injured In City Wrecks', 'Golfer Makes Ace Off Ball of Partner', 'Senator Catcher Has Broken Bone', 'Soviet Border Guards Praised In Spy Stories', 'Garcia Hurt In Exhibition' — none of which is part of this article. Photo caption: 'GUEST EVANGELIST OPENS REVIVAL—Dr. Marc H. Lovelace, left, professor of archaeology at Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary, Wake Forest, N. C., is the guest evangelist for the week's revival being held at Gentian Boulevard Baptist Church. He is shown with the Rev. Randolph D. Mullis, host pastor.—Enquirer photo by Ed Streeky.' WORDS FOR THE PLACE AND ITS PEOPLE: the article says 'Palestine' once and only as a thing that 'used to be called' that. Otherwise: 'the Arab section', 'the Jewish section', 'the modern state of Israel', 'the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan', 'Jerusalem', 'Old Testament Jericho', 'the Near East', 'Dhiban', 'Dibon', 'the Moabites', 'Tekoa', 'The Buqe-a', 'the Biblical wilderness of Judea', 'Bethel', 'Qumran', 'the Essenes', 'the Hebrews', 'the Israelites', 'King Mesha of Moab'. No living person in the land is named or quoted. Everyone named is American, British or ancient. Columns two, three and four were read at page magnification only; the Palestine quotation and the opening paragraphs were transcribed from magnified crops.

CP-1959-013 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

ISRAEL EXPANDS HOMES FOR ARABS

New Nazareth Houses Will Be Permanent Quarters for ‘Internal Refugees’

By SETH S. KING, Special to The New York Times.

NAZARETH, Israel, May 25—On one of the stony hillsides on which this ancient town is draped, workmen were putting the last fittings into rows of small, two-family concrete houses this week. Beside them, other houses, of the same blocky design, were already occupied by Christian Arab families who have lived for the last ten years in Nazareth.

The construction of these houses is part of the Israeli Government’s new effort to resettle permanently as many as possible of the 20,000 “internal refugees” left over from the Arab-Israeli war. Units to house 250 refugee families in seven Israeli Arab communities have been built or will be completed by the end of this summer.

The remaining 1,750 families that the Government says are inadequately housed will be provided for during the next two years, if they can be pursuaded to participate in the program. Some of these Arab refugees fled during the fighting from their villages to other villages that remained in Israeli territory when the armistice agreements were signed in 1949.

The rest are persons who were ordered to move from their villages, most of which were in border military zones, and were made to settle elsewhere a year or two after the fighting ended. During the last ten years all these refugee families have either not been permitted to return to their original villages or have been unable to do so because those villages were destroyed.

This resettlement program in no way applies to the estimated total of 800,000 Palestinian Arabs who fled from what is now Israel and are still living, many with the help of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees, in the surrounding Arab countries.

Date check: No masthead or folio line is on this clipping — it is a trimmed single column. The credit line under the byline reads “Special to The New York Times.”, which agrees with `pub`. The dateline reads “NAZARETH, Israel, May 25”, consistent with publication on 1959-05-31 (a Sunday) though not proving it; no year appears on the clipping.

CP-1959-010 →

· Caravan · Brooklyn

Dr. Sayegh Elected President of the Palestine Arab Congress

Leads Opposition to Hammarskjold Plan The “Sayegh Case” Goes On....

Caravan, the Arab-American weekly, 1959. In a decade when the daily press called these places Jordan and Egypt, the word Palestine is in an organisation's name in a community paper, doing ordinary work.

CP-1959-008 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

ISRAELIS KILL 3 ARABS

Bedouins Slain in Negev in Attack on Army Patrol

TEL AVIV, Israel, Sept. 20—Three Bedouins were killed yesterday by an Israel force searching the Negev wasteland for outlaws. Army headquarters here said the Arabs had been killed in an exchange of fire after they attacked an army patrol. There has been considerable military activity in the Negev since an upsurge of violence earlier this month.

An army captain was ambushed and killed Sept. 7. A land mine was later found buried in a track and six Bedouins attacked an Israeli position. The Bedouins suspected of the incidents belong to the Sinai tribe Sarahin. The nomads camped from time to time in Israeli territory. Newspaper reports said this tribe had once been active in scouting and sabotage for Egyptians.

Date check: No masthead or folio line on this clipping. Under the dek stands the credit line “Special to The New York Times.”, which agrees with `pub`. The dateline reads “TEL AVIV, Israel, Sept. 20”, consistent with publication on 1959-09-21, but no year appears anywhere on the scan.

CP-1959-011 →

· estimated · Star Tribune · Minneapolis

U.N. Unit Condemns Israel for Driving Out Bedouins

JERUSALEM — Israel was condemned Wednesday by the United Nations truce supervision organization for driving 350 Bedouins out of Israeli territory in mid-September. The Egyptian-Israeli mixed armistice commission charged Israeli troops had killed “some of the Bedouins,” burned their tents and forced them out of the western Negev into Egyptian territory.

Earlier in September an Israeli officer was killed in the western Neger while on patrol. The Israelis contended that members of this Bedouin tribe had murdered the officer. Israeli troops were sent in search of the killers. According to the Israeli army version, these troops were fired on by the Bedouins, the troops retaliated and three Bedouins were killed.

The others fled across the border, the Israelis said. Since the Sinai campaign Israel has boycotted the Egyptian-Israeli mixed armistice commission. No Israelis were present at the meeting, which was held on the border.

The Azazme tribe, whose members were involved in the incident, has for years wandered about in the desert area of the western Negev and western Sinai without regard for the border.

Date check: No masthead or folio line on this clipping — it is a three-column cut. The only standing line is the credit “Special From the New York Times” above the dateline. No date appears on the scan, so 1959-10-08 cannot be confirmed; the text says the condemnation came “Wednesday” and refers to an expulsion “in mid-September”.

CP-1959-009 →

· Odessa American · Odessa · page 2

Plight Of The Palestinian

‘You Can’t Go Home Again!’

By David Dugas, United Press International

BEIRUT (UPI) — Eleven years ago a Palestinian farmer named Yusif and his family joined thousands of their countrymen in an exodus from Palestine during the Arab-Israeli war. The departure was a speedy one and there was no promise of a speedy return.

Today Yusif is one of the more than one million men, women and children known as Palestinian refugees whose problem apparently is among the world’s most hopeless. But Yusif is not without some hope. With encouragement from Arab governments, he believes the vanished Palestine must be recreated and that he will return to it.

The United Nations has promised him compensation for his losses, or repatriation. He demands only the latter. He has neither. To take care of Yusif’s immediate needs and to help him and his fellow refugees start life anew, the U.N. in 1950 set up the U.N. Relief and Works Agency as a temporary solution.

On that basis it has been continued, receiving contributions from U.N. member nations that have amounted so far to about 263 million dollars. The present five-year mandate for UNRWA expires next June 30. There is no real doubt that its life will be extended, as asked by U.N. Secretary General Dag Hammarskjold, by the refugees and by the host Arab governments.

But the problem illustrated by Yusif and his family remains. When he fled his farm in Palestine in 1948 he took with him his wife, an aging uncle and an eight-year-old son. Now his family is bigger… Most of the time there is nothing to do but sit idly, discussing with friends the day when all will return to their own land.

Yusif and the others could choose to remain in Jordan. There they have been officially welcomed as full-fledged citizens — a status not accorded refugees in Syria, Gaza or Lebanon. But Yusif does not choose to stay. He wants to go home. Yusif and his family draw rations from UNRWA whose workers distribute flour, rice and other staples regularly at the camps.

The death of his uncle a few years ago has never been recorded and the old man’s ration is still included in the family quota. But there are two younger children now, born in Jordan, who are not eligible for rations.

Neither are the other 105,000 refugee children born since 1951, although they receive other UNRWA services such as schooling, shelter and medical care…

A named Palestinian in an American paper in 1959, five years before the PLO existed: Yusif, a farmer, who left his farm in 1948 with his wife, an aging uncle and an eight-year-old son. The detail that does the work is the ration book — the dead uncle is still on the family quota because his death was never recorded, and the two children born since are not on it at all, along with 105,000 other refugee children born after 1951. The headline is the singular noun, Palestinian, and the line under it is a borrowed American book title. The same United Press dispatch ran in at least 24 American papers in the autumn of 1959, from Springfield to Macon to Jasper to Richmond to Buffalo. The Herald of Jasper, Indiana headlined it a week earlier with the plural — Plight Of The Palestinians — so the two forms of the word were set from one piece of copy in the same month.

CP-1959-002 →

· The New York Times

ARAB REFUGEES: NO SOLUTION SEEN

They Are Pawns in Mideast Dispute

By KATHLEEN TELTSCH

UNITED NATIONS, N. Y., Nov. 14—The issue of the Palestinian Arab refugees again is before the General Assembly, this time for the eleventh successive year. The outcome already is known: First, there will be a round of angry accusations from the Arab states blaming Israel for the continuing misery of the refugees.

Israel will reply insisting the only practical approach is for the refugees to remain where they are in the Arab lands and to be absorbed into the Arab world. When all is said, the Assembly will vote as it always [illegible: one full line of type] now going to the refugees through the United Nations Relief and Works Agency and to extend U. N. R. W. A.’s life.

ARAB REFUGEES — U.N. Arab Refugee Camps

CP-1959-012 →

· Enid Morning News · Enid

CARE Seeks To Help Hungry Arab Refugees From Palestine

Dr. George S. Benson, “Looking Ahead”

“The shocking plight of these Arab refugees has not been adequately reported in America… The Texan is A. K. Baracat, Amarillo merchant. Born in Jerusalem, he came to Texas more than 50 years ago… He wrote his Congressman and Senator Lyndon Johnson. He wrote Vice President Richard Nixon, and President Eisenhower… Mr.

Baracat kept after them… It gives us a dramatic answer to the question: ‘But, what can an ordinary citizen do?’”

A Palestinian American who is neither a victim nor, in the papers’ word, a propagandist: a merchant in Amarillo who spent years writing to a president, a vice president and a future president until an aid agency moved. Told he was beating his head against a wall, and held up by a syndicated columnist as the answer to what an ordinary citizen can do.

CP-1959-007 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

Israelis Ease Curbs

“The Arabs, on the other hand, claim the Israelis are discriminating against the 213,000 Arabs who remained in Israel after the 1948 fighting. Cairo, Amman and other Arab capitals repeatedly claim the Arabs in Israel are treated as ‘second-class citizens’ subject to special restrictions and deprived of equal educational and religious opportunities.

A few months ago, the Israeli government eased special restrictions on the movement of Israeli Arabs, allowing them to travel freely—during the day—to most major communities.

Previously all Arab citizens of Israel, confined to three large military government areas, were required to obtain special permits from the military governor before they could journey from their homes to any other part of the country. The military governors still retain authority to place an Israeli Arab under ‘preventive arrest’ if his activities arouse suspicion.

The governors also are empowered to order an Israeli Arab moved from one district to another. These special regulations are not applied to Jewish citizens of Israel.”

The permit regime, explained to American readers in 1959, under a subheading that reports it as an easing. Two hundred and thirteen thousand Arab citizens, three military government areas, travel permitted during the day, preventive arrest retained, forced transfer between districts retained. The last sentence is the paper’s own and it is one line long.

CP-1959-003 →

· The Daily Report · Ontario

Arab Refugees—A Jewish Problem

William Zukerman

“The Arabs have lost, by the emergence of the state of Israel, their homes, fields and country which, as history has shown, can be regained.

But the Jews are in mortal danger of losing their souls and status as a people of justice and mercy which was their most precious possession for centuries… The Jews themselves… refused in 1906 to accept a generous offer by the British government to settle them in Uganda… Why should they expect that the Arab refugees, who had lived in Palestine all their lives… will give up their claims to their homes…?

… Is all this not too great a price to pay for a state?”

The pivot of the Jewish-dissent thread in this collection. The earlier nodes — 1898, 1907, 1919, 1922, 1947 — argue about loyalty and how Zionism makes American Jews appear. Zukerman argues about consequence, in a general-audience American newspaper, eleven years after the state, and names four Jewish figures who had said it before him: Rabbi R. Benjamin, Moshe Smilansky, I. Nachman Steinberg and Judah L. Magnes.

CP-1959-005 →

· Evening Star · Washington · page 1

Christmas in the Gaza Strip

“CHRISTMAS IN THE GAZA STRIP—These two Palestinian refugee girls are Christian Arabs, spending this Christmas in a camp for the 10,000 displaced persons living in the Gaza Strip. They are Mary Aubersi (left) and Nora Nakhle, whose father fled Palestine in 1948. Nora has never seen a Christmas tree.”—AP Wirephoto.

Two Palestinian girls, named, in a Christmas wire photograph in 1959. The caption says Palestinian refugee girls, says Christian Arabs, and ends on a detail nobody needed to include.

CP-1959-004 →

· Caravan · Brooklyn · page 3

STATEMENT ON ARAB REFUGEES

Dr. Izzat Tannous, Director of the Palestine Arab Refugee Office, before the Special Political Committee of the United Nations, 30 November 1959 · Part IV

“I happen to be a Christian Arab of Christian parents born in Nablus in Palestine. My home is in Jerusalem where I lived all my life.

I am not permitted to go back to my home by the Israelis… for the simple reason that I was not born a Jew… my home is only 300 yards away from the armistice line… I see them both in front of me and I see people in them going in and out, but I cannot move one inch forward… Give me the desert on Earth, Give me back my home.”

And, earlier in the same instalment: “This involved the displacement and expulsion of the indigenous Arab population — Christian and Moslem — and their replacement by Jews from all parts of the world… In a letter signed by Theodore Hertzl, the founder of the ‘Zionist Movement’, on the 19th day of March 1899, sixty years ago, to His Excellency Youssuf Al-Khalidi at the ‘Supreme Port’ at Constantinople, in which he offered Zionist support to Turkey for Zionist occupation of Palestine, the Sultan of Turkey refused the offer because of his subjects, the indigenous inhabitants of Palestine.

In reply on this point, Dr. Hertzl says: ‘You see another difficulty, Excellency, in the existence of the non-Jewish population in Palestine. But who would think of sending them away?

It is their well being, their individual wealth which we will increase by bringing in our own.’” The footnote to that quotation reads: “Found in: UNSCP Report, Document A/364, Add. 1, 9 September 1947.”

A Palestinian speaking at length, in the first person, in an American newspaper, in 1959. The same man had been quoted by the Associated Press in a Virginia daily five years earlier. The page around him carries a concert notice at Our Lady of Lebanon Church Hall and news of who is visiting whose family.

CP-1959-006 →

A year at a time: 1950 · 1951 · 1952 · 1953 · 1954 · 1955 · 1956 · 1957 · 1958 · 1959

Last updated 17 November 2026

Part of Covering Palestine, an archive of 3637 newspaper clippings about Palestinians printed in 748 papers between 1724 and 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles. Nothing here was printed after 6 October 2023.

The clippings belong to the newspapers and news agencies that printed them and are reproduced for research, criticism and commentary. Selection, transcription, counts and writing are © Maria Robles, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.

All decades · archive.json · Questions · Contribute a clipping · When was this printed? · How this was built · maria@rozumstudio.com