The Catholic Times · 7 October 1955
CP-1955-006
Israel vs. Arabistan

Transcribed from the clipping
JERUSALEM — Before describing personal experiences and subjective impressions of this somewhat bewildering land of Israel, I think it may be useful — in order to point up the sources of the tension that divides this country from its Arab neighbors — to refer to the claims or theses on which the arguments of the two sides rest.
During the many weeks in Lebanon, Jordan and Syria, I got about every angle of the Arab case, not once but a dozen times over. It is a convincing case in many ways and one that makes fairly good sense.
In Israel, it seemed to me a duty to find out as quickly as possible the Israeli attitude, and on what basis the verbal warfare, with what one local writer calls most effectively “Arabistan,” reposes. ARAB BASIC FACT.
I think it may be said quite honestly that the Arab position is that the Jews are intruders who have arrived over the past 100 years, who have through the purchase of land and other forms of colonization gradually created a substantial Jewish community in the midst of an essentially Arab Palestine.
Under the British Mandate this migration continued until the dramatic events of 1948, when British authority ceased and Israel was proclaimed an independent state. Immigration increased enormously at that time. Within the space of three years, Israel doubled the number of its inhabitants.
Arabs living in Palestine either left or were forced to flee during the warfare of 1948-49.
All of this adds up to the basic fact that the Arabs consider themselves as expelees, deprived of home and property by a lot of newcomers who have no actual claim to the land, are not the descendants of those there in Biblical days, and who would not be there today were it not for the intervention and support of the United States.
No amount of argument about Zionist claims or the “Jewish homeland” is going to convince a Palestinian Arab that he was not unjustly and cruelly deprived of what had been his for 15 centuries. ISRAELI CONTENTION. From the first day in Israel, one begins to get the opposite picture.
Here one hears constantly that the Jews were always present in Palestine from the days before Titus captured and destroyed Jerusalem; that even though the community was much reduced, it nevertheless survived in a symbolic way and that the Jews elsewhere have never abandoned their historical claim to this country. This is very far from an exhaustive statement of the two cases.
I have merely tried to suggest that the two viewpoints are as nearly irreconcilable as it is possible for them to be.
How this transcription was made
Transcribed by optical character recognition and read back against the scan by hand.
Cite this clipping
"Israel vs. Arabistan," The Catholic Times, 7 October 1955. Covering Palestine archive, CP-1955-006. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-1955-006
More from The Catholic Times
- The Negev ObsessionThe Catholic Times · 21 October 1955
More from the 1950s
- Who Owns Palestine?Sacramento Union · 3 January 1955
- Alan Salem Ahmad Native of Palestine Granted CitizenshipThe Beaumont Enterprise · 28 January 1955
- What’s Happening In GazaSouthern Illinoisan · 10 March 1955
- Gaza: six and a half years of exileThe New York Times · 13 March 1955
- Gaza Strip—Evening Star · 13 March 1955
- ISRAELIS APPEAL TO ARABS OF GAZAThe New York Times · 12 June 1955
- All 220 clippings from the 1950s →
Last updated 17 November 2026
This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.
The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.
Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-1955-006.
Everything printed in 1955 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset