← Covering Palestine

The Daily Item · Port Chester, New York · 21 December 1988

CP-1988-034

U.S. holds key to justice for Palestinians, security for Israel

By Connie Hogarth

U.S. holds key to justice for Palestinians, security for Israel — The Daily Item, 21 December 1988
The Daily Item · Port Chester, New York · 21 December 1988
Scan 860 × 571 pixels

Send this clipping to somebody

Transcribed from the clipping

I have just returned from a two-week eyewitness human rights mission to the Middle East as part of a 10-person delegation representing peace activists and organizations from around the U.S.

We represented the Fellowship of Reconciliation of Nyack; New Jewish Agenda; National Rainbow Coalition; WESPAC; Presbyterian Church USA-Synod of Alaska-Northwest; Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom, USA; and the YWCA, USA, among others.

Our visit included overnight stays with families living in the refugee camps of the West Bank and Gaza as well as visits with members of a number of Israeli peace groups, human rights organizations, hospitals in the occupied territories, academics (most of whom are not allowed to teach since the universities in the territories have been closed) and religious leaders including Father Elias Shakour of Nazareth who is now well-known in the states for his recent book about the Palestinian-Israel conflict, “Blood Brothers.”

My observations during this trip confirm the belief that the intefadeh, the uprising, now a year old, will not cease until the Palestinian people in the occupied territories achieve their independence.

The intefadeh, the resistance to 20 years of occupation, has generated a dynamic force among Palestinians we encountered from all walks of life living in the occupied territories of the West Bank and Gaza. My experience in Gaza was with a family of a teacher and his wife, the grandmother and eight children, in the Jabalia refugee camp where the intefadeh began.

Like other refugee camps but among the worst, Jabalia is a conglomeration of overcrowded hovels of concrete, made habitable only because people have to live in them. The center of the community holds a huge cesspool, like a lake in a town plaza. Children teem through the narrow alleys, which are often sealed off by wire fences or oil cans.

Israeli soldiers sit on rooftops, rifles cocked. In the West Bank, schools have been closed for nearly a year as punishment and because education feeds resistance. In Gaza, schools are officially open but more frequently closed because of military-imposed curfews, during which everyone must stay indoors, sometimes for weeks.

How this transcription was made

Read from the scan Maria supplied on 14 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. The page slug reads "A Section" at left, "Gannett Westchester Newspapers/Wednesday, December 21, 1988" centred, and "17" at right. December 21, 1988 was a Wednesday, so day and date agree with each other and with the label 1988-12-21. FULL HEADLINE, the thing Maria asked for. The headline is printed across the top of the page in one line and reads, in full: U.S. holds key to justice for Palestinians, security for Israel. The archive's stored version does stop at "Palestinians" and is therefore truncated. Maria's longer version is correct word for word. MASTHEAD vs PUB, and this one needs a decision. The only paper name anywhere on this page is the centred slug "Gannett Westchester Newspapers". The words "Daily Item" do not appear on the scan at all. The Daily Item of Port Chester was one of the Gannett Westchester Newspapers group, and the group ran a shared slug across its editions, so pub as stored is not contradicted - but it is also not confirmed by this page. I have NOT changed pub. If the archive wants the group name recorded it has to come from Maria, not from me. CP-1988-035 / image47, the pull-quote record: CONFIRMED present on this page. It is set as a display pull quote in a ruled box spanning the tops of the third and fourth columns, directly under the headline, opening with a large quotation mark and closing with another. As printed there it reads: "The plea was for us to bring back the message to the United States that the Palestinian people want to live in peace ... sharing the benefits, beauty and riches of that Holy Land." The ellipsis is the paper's. AND HERE IS THE CATCH on that pull quote. I found its source in the body text, column 5, and the pull quote is NOT a quotation of anybody. It is Connie Hogarth's own prose, lifted and trimmed. The body sentence reads in full: "Over and over again, the plea was for us to bring back the message to the United States that the Palestinian people want to live in peace, two states, Israel and Palestine, and the visions of cousins sharing the benefits, beauty and riches of that Holy Land." The pull quote elides ", two states, Israel and Palestine, and the visions of cousins". No Palestinian is quoted saying these words; an American visitor is summarising what she was told. If CP-1988-035 is filed anywhere as a Palestinian quotation, that attribution is wrong and should not survive the merge. I have therefore recorded NO quotes for this clipping. There is no directly quoted speech from any Palestinian, Israeli or official anywhere in this column. The only quotation marks on the page are around the book title "Blood Brothers" and around the "V" sign. The two records should indeed merge: CP-1988-034 and CP-1988-035 are the headline and the pull quote of one and the same article on one and the same page. maria_note ("replace the quote one AND the headline clipping"): the scan carries the complete signed column - roughly 7,000 characters across six columns, plus a portrait of the author and a closing italic tag line. Both existing stubs can be replaced by one real record. The paper's own spellings, left as printed: "intefadeh" throughout (not intifada), and "Father Elias Shakour" (the Nazareth priest usually written Elias Chacour). ILLEGIBLE, flagged rather than guessed: in the column 5 paragraph the author lists "the towns and villages of Bethlehem, Beta, [?], Nablus". The third name is five or six letters beginning Sa- and ending -r and the scan will not resolve it at any magnification - it could be Sanur, Sanir or Sa'ir. It does not fall inside my excerpt, so nothing in the transcription depends on it, but I am not going to invent a West Bank village. photo_caption holds only the two-word cutline under the author's portrait. There is no news photograph on this clipping. The italic tag line at the foot of the last column reads: Connie Hogarth is director of WESPAC, Westchester People's Action Coalition Inc. and a member of the national board of the National Rainbow Coalition.

Context added by this archive

A Westchester County paper, on the day before Christmas week, putting the United States in the subject position and justice for Palestinians in the object. The sentence the visitors were asked to bring home ran in a ruled box across the tops of the third and fourth columns and was held here as a record of its own until 14 November 2026.

The paper set it as “The plea was for us to bring back the message to the United States that the Palestinian people want to live in peace … sharing the benefits, beauty and riches of that Holy Land.” The ellipsis is the paper’s, and what it takes out is , two states, Israel and Palestine, and the visions of cousins.

Nobody is quoted saying any of it. The words are the writer’s own, lifted from her fifth column and trimmed to fit the box, so the sentence a reader meets in display type as a Palestinian plea is an American visitor summarising what she was told. The verb the Palestinians are given is plea.

Cite this clipping

"U.S. holds key to justice for Palestinians, security for Israel," The Daily Item, 21 December 1988, p. 17, A Section. Covering Palestine archive, CP-1988-034. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-1988-034

More from The Daily Item

More from the 1980s

Last updated 17 November 2026

This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.

The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.

Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-1988-034.

Everything printed in 1988 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset