· Chicago Jewish Star
Laugh or cry?
“It’s hard to know whether to laugh or to cry following President Obama’s remarks on the Middle East to Time magazine.”
Chicago Jewish Star, on an American president's remarks to an American magazine.
Every clipping in this archive printed between 2010 and 2019: 343 of them, oldest first, as plain text that can be read, searched and quoted without running any code. Each entry links to its own record, where the scan is.
· Chicago Jewish Star
“It’s hard to know whether to laugh or to cry following President Obama’s remarks on the Middle East to Time magazine.”
Chicago Jewish Star, on an American president's remarks to an American magazine.
· The Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe
“Rabbi Benjamin Morrow… says the Arab states refused to take in the refugees ‘created by the war’ in 1948. But he fails to mention that Israel…”
Santa Fe, a reader answering another reader's column a week later. The argument is about 1948 and who refused whom, conducted in New Mexico in 2010.
· Corpus Christi Caller Times · Corpus Christi
“The trouble started with an errant announcement by Israel of new housing construction in East Jerusalem.”
Corpus Christi. Settlement construction in occupied East Jerusalem appears as an errant announcement — the problem being the announcing.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles
“Didn’t mention ‘Jewish’ or ‘Arab’… 80% of the private land.”
A Los Angeles Times interview turning on what a speech did not say.
· The Baltimore Sun · page 13
But access to major road closed in ’02 after attacks doesn’t include main city
By Douglas Hamilton / REUTERS
ROUTE 443, WEST BANK — Israel on Friday began allowing Palestinians onto a major highway in the West Bank for the first time in eight years, but barred them from using it to gain easy access to their main city, Ramallah.
Just a few miles east of the new checkpoint where Palestinians are now allowed onto Route 443, big yellow road signs warn them to get off again, at the “last exit for Palestinian vehicles” to the West Bank’s commercial capital.
Around the bend, Israeli troops at a new three-lane checkpoint ensure that “only Israeli citizens and permit holders” may continue on to Jerusalem. Cut off before they can reach the fast route to Ramallah, the Palestinians must go back onto narrow country roads.
Palestinian access to 443, one of two main routes linking Israel’s coastal plain with the uplands of Jerusalem, was blocked in 2002 after several fatal shooting attacks on Israeli cars during the Palestinian intifada.
The level of violence has subsided significantly, and last December Israel’s Supreme Court ruled in favor of a Palestinian petition that highway segregation was illegal. It gave the Israel Defense Forces six months to end it.
Activists say the costly new arrangement is a disappointment to Palestinians and an irritant to Israelis who say they will not feel safe sharing this short section of the highway. Hailed at first as a victory for justice, the Supreme Court ruling now looks like a “human rights travesty,” the Association for Civil Rights in Israel said this week.
Palestinian villagers living near the route said the eight-year ban on using it had tripled their travel time to Ramallah, where there are jobs, hospitals, banks and government offices. They had to take narrow roads over the hills.
But they feel the new arrangement will be no better: They expect to use a mere 2½ miles of the road between Israel’s main westbound and eastbound checkpoints, and not even that if it proves faster to use existing tunnels under 443 rather than line up to be checked.
Farouk Antawi, a Palestinian driving from his village of Beit Sira, said on Israeli radio that Israeli and Palestinian vehicles share all the other main roads in the West Bank, “and there is no difference between them.”
Israeli forces dismantle the Atarot checkpoint on Route 443 in the West Bank on Friday. Under an Israeli court order, a section of the highway has been reopened to Palestinians. AHMAD GHARABLI/GETTY-AFP PHOTO
· The Sacramento Bee · Sacramento
Nine people were killed on the Mavi Marmara that morning. The verb in the headline is intercept, which is what you do to a message or a pass, and the object is a relief fleet. Nobody is hurt in the sentence. Two days later the Charlotte Observer summarized the American response in a standfirst that did use the phrase (CP-2010-002).
· The Charlotte Observer · Charlotte
“The White House calls for aid to Gaza but doesn’t criticize Israel’s use of deadly force.”
A standfirst in a box, two days after the flotilla. It is the sentence the headlines would not write: Israel’s use of deadly force, unhedged and unattributed. The paper can print it because the subject of the sentence is what the White House did not say.
· The Morning Call · Allentown
President says Israeli actions unforgivable as freed protesters describe fighting commandos
By Jeffrey Fleishman / TRIBUNE NEWSPAPERS
ISTANBUL — The wooden coffins of eight activists killed by Israeli commandos wound through the streets of Istanbul on Thursday as Turks wept and their leaders spoke of the irreparable harm Israel has done to one of its closest Muslim allies. Turkish anger at the clash between Israel and an activist flotilla bound for the Gaza Strip early Monday had appeared to be subsiding.
But the funerals, along with harrowing accounts of returning survivors, added a fresh sense of outrage. “Turkey will never forgive this attack,” President Abdullah Gul said on NTV television. “Turkish-Israeli relations can never be as before from now on.”
The drama over Israel’s assault on the Free Gaza Movement flotilla widened when one of the dead was identified as an American citizen of Turkish descent. Furkan Dogan, 19, who was born in Troy, N.Y., but had lived for years in Turkey, was shot four times in the head and once in the chest, according to the state-run Anatolian news agency.
In Israel, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Cabinet debated how to handle calls for an international investigation. Netanyahu’s advisers are divided over what sort of inquiry will be convened, officials said. Defense Minister Ehud Barak, who is facing calls for his resignation, is arguing for an internal military audit.
Other ministers are recommending an independent commission with international involvement to ensure credibility. Near Istanbul’s Fatih mosque, boys shimmied up poles and men climbed atop stone walls to glimpse the funeral cortege.
Imams and mourners pray Thursday in Istanbul behind the coffins of activists killed by Israeli commandos.
· Sunday Telegraph · page 1
Israel insists that its blockade has not created a humanitarian crisis, but Gazans increasingly feel abandoned by the international community — and some in the battered enclave blame Hamas and its overlords for their depredations
Adrian Blomfield
“Just how hungry is Gaza? Israel insists that its blockade has not created a humanitarian crisis, but Gazans increasingly feel abandoned by the international community — and some in the battered enclave blame Hamas and its overlords for their depredations”
“Men scour the ruins of Gaza City, the result of an Israeli bombing campaign, and load rubble on to carts pulled by donkeys. It is a precious commodity because Israel has banned all construction material from entering Gaza. It fears Hamas will use it to make bunkers”
The clipping is the photograph, its caption and the headline stack; the article below was not clipped. The caption explains why rubble is valuable: construction material is banned.
· The Tennessean · Nashville
Editorial cartoon. A figure in a cloak labeled ISRAEL stands facing a blank wall of a ruined structure, on which is written: “BE CAREFUL YOU DON’T BECOME WHAT YOU HATE THE MOST.” Signed Wright, Tribune Media Services.
A week after the flotilla. The drawing puts one sentence on a wall and one label on a back, and leaves the reader to close the distance. Palestinians are not in the frame. The wall is.
· Houston Chronicle · Houston · page 1
Critics say move still keeps necessary items out of territory
By Steven Gutkin, Associated Press, Jerusalem
“Israel took a first step Wednesday to temper the uproar caused by its deadly high-seas raid on a blockade-busting flotilla by allowing potato chips, cookies, spices and other previously banned food items into the Gaza Strip.
But the things Gazans need most — cement, steel and other materials to rebuild their war-ravaged territory — are still mostly banned… Palestinian official Raed Fattouh, who coordinates the flow of goods into Gaza with Israel, said soda, juice, jam, spices, shaving cream, potato chips, cookies and candy now were permitted.
He said Israel rebuffed Palestinian requests for construction goods, raw materials for factories to operate and medical devices.… ‘A modest expansion of the restrictive list of goods allowed into Gaza falls well short of what is needed,’ said Maxwel Gaylard, the U.N.’s senior humanitarian official… Israeli government spokesman Mark Regev said his country is committed to ensuring that ‘the civilian population of Gaza will receive civilian goods.’”
DEMONSTRATION: Disabled Palestinian refugees demonstrate in Sidon, Lebanon, on Wednesday in solidarity with the disabled of Gaza City, who were due to receive humanitarian supplies aboard the flotilla of ships that was raided by the Israeli army before it reached the blockaded Gaza Strip.
The concession was snack food. In the same column the Palestinian coordinator says Israel refused medical devices, and the photograph above it is disabled refugees in wheelchairs demonstrating in Lebanon for the flotilla that was carrying supplies to disabled people in Gaza.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles
Saree Makdisi
The phrase ethnic cleansing on the Los Angeles Times op-ed page in 2010.
· The Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe · page 1
“A Palestinian woman holds her baby in a vaccination room as others wait with their children at the United Nations Relief and Works Agency clinic in Gaza City. Gaza’s health service is overwhelmed and advanced care, including cancer treatment, is not available, forcing thousands every year to seek treatment abroad.” Khalil Hamra / The Associated Press
The clipping is the headline and a photograph of a vaccination room; the story was not clipped. Nobody in the photograph is named.
· Culpeper Star-Exponent
J. Michael Sharman
Sometimes at night, when the sea is still, you can hear voices coming across the water from a long way off. But when clouds block out the starlight, one can only guess at what is actually occurring by piecing together bits of overheard conversations.
Perhaps that is how we can discern what happened May 31, when nine people were killed after the Israeli Defense Force boarded the Turkish ship Mavi Marmara, which was attempting to breach Israel’s blockade of Gaza.
Al-Jazeera TV filmed onboard the Mavi Marmara May 29, before the Gaza flotilla confronted the Israeli IDF: Passengers shouting: “[Remember] Khaibar, Khaibar, oh Jews!” (Khaibar is the name of the last Jewish village defeated by Muhammad’s army, and it marked the end of the Jewish presence in Arabia in 628.)
Female passenger: “Right now we face one of two happy endings: either Martyrdom or reaching Gaza.” Another report done before the confrontation was posted on the Al-Jazeera website May 29: “The flotilla includes hundreds of Arab and foreign solidarity activists from more than 40 countries. ...
They have announced their determination to use Mukawama to any attempt at piracy by the Israeli occupation.” Mukawama is the Arabic term used by Palestinians to refer to all violent resistance against Israel, including suicide terror.
The voices of the Israeli IDF commandos as they were boarding the Mavi Marmara can be heard in a released IDF video clip : “I need reinforcements here with me” “He wants to pass underneath” “Wait, one is in front of me” “It’s coming from all directions” “We need to be evacuated, now!” “Tell him that he’s close already” “Real weapons, real weapons!” “They have real weapons?”
“Yes, yes, real weapons” “They are firing on us” “There is live fire below” “Live fire below” “Live fire here” “Shoot him where is he?” “Negative” One of the soldiers told the Israeli media outlet Ynetnews, “After every person came down [from the helicopter] three or four guys grabbed a hold of him and simply beat him senseless. They lynched us.
They were equipped with metal bats, knives, slingshots and glass bottles. At some point we faced live fire by two guys. They simply came for war. We came to talk to them, convince them to come down, yet with every person who came down, they simply charged.” Another IDF commando told journalists, “I was armed with a paint gun and had no other weapons.
It was a civilian paintball gun that any 12-year-old can play with.” After the shootings, one passenger/activist told a news videographer with Press TV he had been on a previous attempt to break Israel’s naval blockade of Gaza; he was on the Mavi Marmara flotilla, and he planned to be on another attempt. “When I went on the first convoy, I wanted to be a Shahid (a martyr).
I wasn’t that lucky. Second time, I wanted to be a Shahid. Didn’t work. Third time lucky, with the help of Allah, I will be a Shahid.”
· The Charlotte Observer
By SAREE MAKDISI
Unconscionable. Offensive. Hurtful. Bigoted. Terrible. Hateful. These are the words being used to describe Helen Thomas’ recent comment about Israel and Palestine. Editorialists across the country have condemned her statement that Jews should “get the hell out of Palestine” and “go back” to Europe.
Let’s agree that she should not have said those things, and that a just and lasting peace in the Middle East fundamentally requires reconciliation between Palestinians and Israeli Jews. We need also to agree on a formula that allows them both to be at home in the same land (I have long advocated the idea of a single democratic and secular state for both peoples).
Insisting that either people do not belong is not merely counterproductive; it lies at the very root of the conflict. If, however, it is unacceptable to say Israeli Jews don’t belong in Palestine, it is also unacceptable to say Palestinians don’t belong on their own land.
Yet that is said all the time in the United States, without sparking the kind of moral outrage generated by Thomas’ remark.
And while the nation’s editorialists worry about the offense she may have caused to Jews, no one seems particularly bothered by the offense felt every day by Palestinians when people – including those with far more power than Thomas – dismiss their rights, degrade their humanity and reject their claims to the most elementary forms of decency.
Are we seriously to accept the idea that some people have more rights than others? Or that some people’s sensibilities should be respected while others’ are trampled with total indifference, if not outright contempt?
One does not have to agree with Thomas to note that her remark spoke to the ugly history of colonialism, racism and denial that are at the heart of the Palestine question. Part of that history involves vicious European anti-Semitism and the monumental crime of the Holocaust.
But the other part is that Palestinians were forcibly removed from their homeland in 1948 to clear space for the creation of a state with a Jewish identity. Europeans and Americans were, at the time, willing to ignore or simply dismiss the injustice inflicted on the Palestinians, who, by being forced from their land, were made to pay the price for a crime they did not commit.
But this callous carelessness, this dismissal of – and refusal even to acknowledge in human terms – the calamity that befell the Palestinians, and of course the attendant refusal to acknowledge their fundamental rights, did not end in the 1940s. It continues.
Mainstream politicians, civic leaders, university presidents and others in this country routinely express their support for Israel as a Jewish state, despite the fact that such a state only could have been created in a multicultural land by ethnically cleansing it of as many non Jews as possible.
Today, Israel is only able to maintain its Jewish identity because it has established an apartheid regime, both in the occupied territories and within its own borders, and because it continues to reject the Palestinian right of return. Where is the outrage about that?
· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco
San Francisco, running the Gaza blockade beside an editorial on Chinese currency manipulation, two columns on the same page.
· The Coastal Journal Edition Forecaster · page 6
Perry B. Newman
This much we know. On May 31, a convoy of six ships bound for the Gaza Strip was intercepted by the Israel Defense Force and ordered to stop. Five of the ships complied. Passengers were taken ashore in Israel and cargo unloaded. The sixth ship, the Mavi Marmara, did not comply. Israeli naval personnel alerted the captain that he was in violation of Israel’s blockade of Gaza.
The captain defied orders to stop. Israeli troops boarded the Mavi Marmara. A melee ensued as Israeli troops rappelled onto the deck and were beaten and stabbed. Nine persons on board the Mavi Marmara were killed and numerous soldiers and others injured.
Beyond this bare recitation of the facts, however, there is little agreement, or at least little acknowledgment of additional facts relating to the ships bound for Gaza, their passengers, their motivation and their cargo.
If one relied only upon mainstream media reports one would come away with the impression that the ships were manned by a handful of sandal-clad pacifists and conscientious objectors whose only goal was to deliver food and medicine to a needy and grateful Gaza.
But things are not always what they seem, and this is particularly true in the context of Israel’s actions with respect to Gaza and its Palestinian neighbors and citizens. For those interested in a fuller depiction of what happened before, during and after the interdiction of the May 31 flotilla, this Q-&-A may be helpful.
Question: How can you tell when an aid mission isn’t really an aid mission, but a calculated political provocation? Answer: When its organizers announce from the beginning that the goal isn’t actually to deliver aid, but to break the blockade of Gaza. Q: When does a political action cease to be a harmless political provocation?
A: When the ship’s crew is overcome by terrorists wearing flak jackets, bearing weapons and stun grenades, and carrying more than 1 million Euros hidden on their persons. When bags of flour among the cargo conceal dozens of grenades, rocket launchers and other armaments sourced from Iran. Q: How can you tell that delivering the aid on board the ships was never a priority?
A: When Turkey refused to intervene and the flotilla organizers refused Israel’s offer to offload and deliver all humanitarian aid, medicine and food on the ships. Q: How can you tell terrorists from activists?
A: The terrorists are those who boarded the Mavi Marmara separately, commandeered the ship, sequestered those with more peaceful intent, cut metal railings into iron rods, refused to stop their vessel and told an Israeli officer seeking to defuse the situation to “go back to Auschwitz.”
· Lansing State Journal · Lansing · page 21A
Eight Palestinian women rocketing into car racing record books
Dalia Nammari and Diaa Hadid, Associated Press
RAMALLAH, West Bank — Palestinian women are speeding into the record books by competing on an all-female car racing team — the Speed Sisters. Along the way, they're crashing through another gender barrier in this conservative Muslim society. The eight women have entered a popular race called “Speed Test.”
Souped-up cars race around a track, weaving their way around obstacles and spinning circles around others. The all-female team is a first for the event. “I love sports that are tough and dangerous, because I am a dangerous woman,” said Nour Dawood, 20, after a race this week outside the West Bank city of Ramallah.
She wore a yellow-and-black racing suit, sunglasses and a helmet as she leaned against her car, her curly hair pushed back into a ponytail. Around her, drivers revved their engines. Arabic music pounded out of loudspeakers. A group of fans crowded around the track to watch, including a small contingent of women with large sunglasses.
It's another step for Palestinian women, who have been claiming more positions of influence in a still very much male-dominated society. This year, the first female Palestinian governor was appointed to oversee the West Bank district of Ramallah. The mayor of the district's main city is a woman, as are four ministers in the Palestinian Cabinet.
Speed Test began in the West Bank in 2005, as violence between Israel and the Palestinians began petering out. Races take place throughout the territory that is ruled by Israel, with Palestinians administering parts of it. Palestinians want the land — about the size of Connecticut — as part of a future state.
In 2005, only one woman participated — the Speed Sisters' coach, 39-year-old Suna Awedia. Fast forward five years and eight women are in the race. As a team, the women get to pool trainers and share a car. The British Consulate paid for a two-day driving workshop and repaired a banged-up car donated by the Palestinian Union for Race Car Drivers.
The union also waived the $70 entry fee. On the field, the Speed Sisters still need to prove their mettle. Only one woman so far reached the top 10 in this year's three rounds. They've got two rounds to go. Awedia, their captain, says her drivers, who are mostly in their 20s, need more training, practice and better cars. She's searching for sponsors.
But Dawood says they already are champions. “Look at us,” she said proudly. “We are really into it. We are one team. And we are all winners.”
Ready to go: Palestinian Marah Zahalka, a race car driver, sits in her car while awaiting her turn to race Friday in Ramallah, West Bank. Palestinian women are speeding into record books by participating in their first all-female car racing team, the Speed Sisters. / Speed Sister: Race car driver Mona Ennab is shown Friday in Ramallah, West Bank.
Ennab and seven other women have entered a popular race called “Speed Test.” / Looking ahead: Car racer Behy Saada and seven other Palestinian women drive souped-up cars race around a track, weaving their way around obstacles. / Making strides: Palestinian Suna Awedia (center, left) and Samia Khoury (center, right) race car drivers, wait to race Friday.
With car racing, Palestinian women are crashing through another gender barrier in a conservative Muslim society.
Printed on the World page. Photographs credited Tara Todras-Whitehill/Associated Press.
· Albuquerque Journal · Albuquerque
RICHARD FORER’S op-ed column on Israel’s “attack” on the flotilla ship Mavi Marmara in Wednesday’s Journal aids Hamas in its propaganda war against Israel, but it doesn’t do much for the cause of peace.
His statement that “it is the blockade that is the stimulus for rocket fire from the Gaza Strip into Israeli territory” displays either complete ignorance of recent events, or a blatant desire to mislead. The blockade was imposed in 2007 amidst a continuing barrage of rocket fire from the Gaza Strip, which started when Israel withdrew in 2005.
The blockade eased during a 2008 cease fire that lasted for six months, until the rocket fire began to intensify again.
Forer ignores other key facts: Hamas, the ruling party in Gaza, elected by the populace there in 2007, refuses to recognize Israel’s right to exist as a nation; Hamas declares itself to be at war with Israel and seeks every means possible to replenish its supply of arms.
Under Hamas, Gaza militants have continued to fire hundreds of rockets into Israel in violation of the 2009 ceasefire, including several this very month. Israel’s blockade is an ugly and tragic thing, but unavoidable under such conditions. All sides need to seek ways to establish a just and lasting peace.
In the meantime, Israel transfers 10-15,000 tons of humanitarian aid into Gaza a week, including the aid brought in on the five ships of the flotilla that, unlike the Mavi Marmara, cooperated with Israeli forces.
But of course, cooperating with Israel might help meet needs in the Gaza Strip, but it doesn’t help win the propaganda war, and that was the real aim of the Mavi Marmara. RUSSELL RESNIK Albuquerque
· Valley Morning Star
Gwynne Dyer
In the aftermath of the bloody events on the aid ship Mavi Marmara, where nine pro-Palestinian activists were killed by Israeli commandos on May 31, Israel has set up a judicial inquiry into the affair.
Since Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu, who chose the members of the inquiry, has already described the victims as “violent Turkish terror extremists” on a “ship of hate,” some people doubt that the investigation will be impartial.
On 15 June, the second inquiry into “Bloody Sunday” in the Northern Irish city of Derry, where 14 civil rights marchers were killed by British paratroops on 30 January, 1972, delivered its report. The first people to see it were the relatives of the victims. On the whole, they seemed satisfied. The British inquiry was chaired by Lord Saville, a former High Court judge.
Since the inquiry involved the British Army, the other two members were senior judges from New Zealand and Canada, not from Britain. And the Saville inquiry’s report was utterly damning. It said that none of the casualties had guns, and that there were “no instances where it appeared to us that soldiers either were or might have been justified in firing.”
The report also said bluntly that the soldiers had lost their self-control, “forgetting or ignoring their instructions and training, and failing to satisfy themselves that they had identified targets posing a threat of causing death or serious injury ... There was a serious and widespread loss of fire discipline.”
Neither their commanders nor the British government wanted to kill innocent people, but they were to blame for it nevertheless. Prime Minister David Cameron, disclosing the conclusions of the report to the House of Commons in London, did not pull his punches either. “You do not defend the British Army by defending the indefensible. There is no doubt.
There is nothing equivocal. There are no ambiguities. It. Was. Wrong.” And he apologized on behalf of the British state, without qualifications. If a similarly impartial tribunal inquired into the events that occurred aboard the Gaza-bound aid ship last month, it would probably come to identical conclusions.
We know enough about confrontations where none of the soldiers or police die, but lots of the demonstrators/ protesters/rioters do, to understand the psychology and the crowd dynamics of it.
· Chicago Tribune · Chicago
By Edmund Sanders
JERUSALEM — As Israel faces the prospect of another aid-supply ship trying to break its naval blockade of the Gaza Strip, a military report Monday into the deadly raid on a previous flotilla found “mistakes” but no negligence on the part of soldiers and commanders.
The military commission, created after Israeli commandos killed nine Turkish activists aboard the Mavi Marmara, concluded that the soldiers were ill-prepared to confront an angry mob and resorted to live fire to regain control of the situation.
In its report, the commission found “no failure, but mistakes” and did not recommend disciplinary action against any individuals involved. “To my relief, the investigation found no negligence or failures on any significant matters,” said retired Gen. Giora Eiland, Israel’s former National Security Council director who led the internal military probe into the May 31 raid.
The report praised commandos who participated in the raid and said live fire was “justified,” military officials said. The full report was not released publicly.
The release of Israel’s first probe into the raid is not likely to satisfy international critics, particularly the Turkish government, which is demanding that Israel apologize and compensate the families of the nine Turkish citizens who were killed.
“By not finding fault with killing people, you’ve got to wonder what was the point of this kind of inquiry,” said Adam Shapiro of the Free Gaza Movement, which organized the pro-Palestinian flotilla.
Eiland’s report did blame military intelligence agencies for underestimating the resistance soldiers would face and faulted commanders for ordering commandos to rappel from helicopters into the mob, where they were overwhelmed. Eiland concluded that activists disarmed Israeli soldiers and used the Israelis’ guns against them, shooting at least four.
His report suggested that people on the ship fired first and may have smuggled at least one gun aboard. Activists have said they had no arms on board.
A report said live fire by commandos was justified in a raid on the Mavi Marmara, above, but faulted intelligence officials for underestimating the resistance soldiers would face.
· estimated · South Bend Tribune
In reference to Bob Feferman’s July 17 Viewpoint column, I wish to make the following observations. I would like to know if during his trip to Israel, Feferman visited the occupied territories, including Gaza and the refugee camps. As for the partition of Palestine, it is true that the Arabs did not accept it.
If someone were to say to Feferman: “I am entitled to half your house. You and your relatives can live in the rest of the house, as long as you don’t complain,” would Feferman accept that as a just act? There are vast places in this country where not many people live: deserts, badlands, etc.
Would it be all right for another country to colonize them and claim them as its own? The view from the top of the Carmel Mountains is beautiful indeed. Not so beautiful are the unrecognized villages inside Israel where no electricity, roads or other services are provided.
Less than beautiful are the hundreds of checkpoints where Palestinians stand in line like cattle and are at the mercy of Israeli Defense Forces soldiers; where sometimes babies are born, and sick people die. In my view, Israel commits state terrorism in the occupied territories on a daily basis. There is no justice in that.
Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping — it is a trimmed letters page and the section head at the top is cut off. The letter refers to “Bob Feferman’s July 17 Viewpoint column”, which is consistent with a late-July or August 2010 letters page, but nothing dates the page and nothing names the newspaper.
· Daily Dispatch
Israeli commandos raided vessel trying to run Gaza blockade
ISTANBUL (AP) — The ship seized by Israel in a deadly raid as it carried aid to the Gaza Strip in May returned to Turkey on Saturday. A pro-Palestinian activist said it would send more aid ships unless Israel lifts its Gaza blockade. Turkish television showed the Mavi Marmara arriving at the Mediterranean port of Iskenderun after leaving the Israeli port of Haifa on Thursday.
Two other Turkish vessels released by Israel also arrived. The ships had been part of a flotilla sailing toward Gaza to protest Israel’s blockade of the Hamas-ruled territory. Israeli troops intercepted the boats on May 31 and clashed with activists on the Mavi Marmara, leaving nine people dead. IHH, an Islamic charity in Turkey, was a key organizer of the flotilla.
Huseyin Oruc, a charity director, described the Israeli raid on the Mavi Marmara as “absolute piracy” that was more lethal than Somali piracy off the Horn of Africa. He said activists from all over the world would continue to press Israel to lift restrictions on Gaza.
“We will all unite and go again and again until this blockage is completely lifted,” Oruc said in a news conference at the harbor where the Mavi Marmara docked. On Wednesday, European representatives of the Freedom Flotilla Coalition, an umbrella group, met in Stockholm to plan a new Gaza flotilla with up to 12 ships.
The bloodshed on the Turkish ship provoked an international outcry, and Israel agreed to an international investigation. Israeli authorities have said their forces acted in self-defense on boarding the Mavi Marmara, though an Israeli military report acknowledged flaws in intelligence-gathering and planning.
Israel has eased its blockade of the Gaza Strip, though critics allege the changes are cosmetic. Israel imposed the blockade after Hamas militants seized power there three years ago. It has said the step was needed to prevent Hamas from arming, but the blockade has brought Gaza’s economy to a virtual standstill.
The Mavi Marmara ship, aboard which Israel’s deadly raid on a Gaza-bound flotilla took place on May 31 leaves the Haifa port, northern Israel, Thursday, on its way to Turkey.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles
“Palestinian citizens of Israel… remain politically marginalized. No Palestinian party has ever been invited to join a ruling coalition. In recent years, Palestinian politicians and community leaders have been criminally prosecuted or hounded…”
George Bisharat and Nimer Sultany, in the Los Angeles Times. Two Palestinian law professors using the phrase Palestinian citizens of Israel in an American newspaper in 2010 — the term the New York Times did not adopt until the 2020s.
· The Miami Herald · Miami · page 1
SCAVENGERS COLLECT RUBBLE AT GAZA’S BOMBED AIRPORT
By Ibrahim Barzak, The Associated Press, Rafah, Gaza Strip
“RAFAH, Gaza Strip—Scores of men swinging hammers and pickaxes attack the runway and terminal of Gaza’s bombed-out airport before dawn every day, scavenging gravel and metal bars to resell as construction material.
The looting of the Gaza International Airport—once hailed as a step toward Palestinian statehood but destroyed during years of fighting with Israel—reflects the dire situation in the impoverished territory, where a three-year blockade has made jobs scarce and kept out badly needed building supplies.
The scavengers who come daily, working long hours to take home as little as $15 a day, say they can’t find other jobs. ‘I have no work but to spend my day under the sun trying to feed my children,’ said Hilmi Izawied, 34, taking a break from work on Monday.
Despite the 98-degree Fahrenheit heat, about 120 men worked in the area Monday, some digging up gravel, others hammering on what were once terminal walls to remove bars. Many refrained from food or drink in observance of the dawn-to-dusk fast of the Muslim holy month of Ramadan, which began last week.
Izawied and four friends had been there since 3 a.m., he said, pulling up heavy slabs of runway asphalt, digging up the gravel below and filtering it into large sacks.”
“MAKING DO: Above and below, Palestinians dig through what was once the runway of Gaza’s bombed-out airport to collect rubble and gravel needed for construction.” (Photos by Khalil Hamra/AP)
An airport built as a step toward statehood, being carried away by hand as gravel.
· Honolulu Star-Advertiser · Honolulu
One sentence, two clauses, and the asymmetry is the point: a state that does not desire an agreement, and a people who have no clout to get one. Desire and clout are not comparable things. Read across the two clauses, the sentence says the outcome does not depend on what Palestinians want.
· Star News · Wilmington, NC
By Ethan Bronner / New York Times News Service
RAMALLAH, WEST BANK | As preparations intensify for a Palestinian-Israeli summit meeting in Washington on Thursday, the crude outlines of a Palestinian state are emerging in the West Bank, with increasingly reliable security forces, a more disciplined government and a growing sense among ordinary citizens that they can count on basic services.
Of course, the West Bank remains occupied by Israel. It is filled with scores of Israeli settlements, some 10,000 Israeli troops and numerous roadblocks and checkpoints that render true ordinary life impossible for the area’s 2.5 million Palestinians.
The central question facing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel and President Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian Authority is under what circumstances Israel might yield its control over the bulk of this territory to the emerging Palestinian state apparatus.
Most analysts remain skeptical of such a deal emerging soon, given a history of failed promises – and entrenched interests on both sides that oppose even the concept of a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian problem. There are few signs of a breakthrough.
Abbas and his aides insist that Palestinian refugees have the right to return to their homes in what is today Israel, which for Israelis is just another way of ending the existence of the Jewish state. Palestinian officials say their central demand at the start of the talks is for the current settlement-building moratorium to be extended.
Netanyahu and his aides have so far rejected that.
THE SHARPEST STAFF/WIRE LANGUAGE IN THE WHOLE BATCH, and it is a single sentence: 'Of course, the West Bank remains occupied by Israel.' Bronner then itemises it - scores of settlements, 10,000 troops, roadblocks and checkpoints 'that render true ordinary life impossible for the area's 2.5 million Palestinians'. Nowhere else in batch B does the word 'occupied' appear outside a Palestinian's mouth. Note also the paper's 'both sides' construction in the fourth paragraph, and the photo caption, which is the only place in the batch where Palestinian citizens of Israel and unrecognized villages appear at all.
· Star News · Wilmington, NC
Los Angeles Times
JERUSALEM | The peace summit next week has again put a spotlight on Jewish settlements in the West Bank. Palestinian leaders say the the negotiations will collapse if Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu does not extend his moratorium on most new housing starts.
Naftali Bennett, Netanyahu’s former chief of staff and the director of the settler advocacy group the Yesha Council, spoke about the challenges. Q: What’s wrong with a temporary construction freeze in exchange for a possible peace deal? A: Why should we have to pay a price to talk? It’s in their interest more than ours. We’re doing just fine. If they want to talk, talk.
Q: What can you do if Netanyahu continues the construction moratorium? A: Netanyahu was elected on a platform against Palestinian statehood and pro-settlements. We need to help Netanyahu back and help him keep to his beliefs and promises. Q: If not a Palestinian state, then what would you propose?
A: The alternative is peaceful coexistence on the ground and simply strengthening the current, very positive trends with the economy and security.
Worth putting beside slide 25: the same interview, two papers, two different cuts. What the Star-News editor removed is the whole of Bennett's answer on Judea and Samaria, Iran, Hamas and 'there is not going to be a peace agreement anyway'; the entire apartheid exchange; 'If they have a state, we'll cease to exist'; and 'If he extends the freeze, that's crossing a red line'. What survives is the economic-coexistence answer. The cut makes Bennett sound considerably more moderate than the Star-Ledger version of the same conversation. The paper's descriptor softens too: 'director of the settler advocacy group' here, 'recently named director-general' in the Star-Ledger.
· The Star-Ledger · Newark, NJ
By Edmund Sanders / LOS ANGELES TIMES
JERUSALEM — This week’s Israeli-Palestinian peace summit in Washington has again put a spotlight on Jewish settlement construction in the West Bank. Palestinian leaders say the U.S.-sponsored negotiations will collapse if Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu does not extend his moratorium on most new housing starts, a 10-month program slated to expire Sept. 26.
Naftali Bennett, Netanyahu’s former chief of staff and the recently named director-general of the settler advocacy group the Yesha Council, spoke to the Los Angeles Times about what he thinks his old boss will do and the challenges facing the settler movement. Q: Settlement construction is at the top of the agenda for the peace summit. What’s Netanyahu going to do?
A: It’s hard to tell. Netanyahu is under tremendous pressure. The Obama administration is twisting his arm and bullying him into doing something (restricting settlement construction) he doesn’t believe in and in fact believes is against Israel’s interests. Q: What’s wrong with a temporary construction freeze in exchange for a possible peace deal?
A: Why should we have to pay a price to talk? It’s in their interest more than ours. We’re doing just fine. If they want to talk, talk. But we keep on giving, and things are just getting worse. There is not going to be a peace agreement anyway, not in the sense that Westerners think. We don’t believe Palestinian leaders want peace.
So it’s time to rethink this whole paradigm of a Palestinian state. If they had a state, Iran and radical Islam will funnel billions into Judea and Samaria (another term for the West Bank), Hamas will take over and soon, just like in Gaza, the missiles and shooting toward Israel will come. Q: What can you do if Netanyahu continues the construction moratorium?
A: Netanyahu was elected on a platform against Palestinian statehood and pro-settlements. I know because I helped him. We need to help Netanyahu back and help him keep to his beliefs and promises. That’s part of the campaign we’ve done called “A word is a word,” holding politicians accountable. But that campaign is only the tip of the iceberg of what we’re willing to do.
If he extends the freeze, that’s crossing a red line. Q: If not a Palestinian state, then what would you propose? A: The alternative is peaceful co-existence on the ground and simply strengthening the current, very positive trends with the economy and security. Removing the roadblocks. Giving Palestinians political rights to vote for themselves.
If they want to reach an agreement with Jordan to give them citizenship, so be it. Q: Many Palestinians say the status quo is unfair and not acceptable. A: There wouldn’t be apartheid. They’d rule themselves and we’d rule ourselves. We’d drive on the same roads. Arabs have fairly good lives. The overwhelming majority of the Palestinian people want peaceful co-existence.
It’s just their leaders who are not okay with it. It’s not perfect. They want a full-blown state. But it’s a zero-sum game. If they have a state, we’ll cease to exist. That’s the best we can do.
The single most important clipping in this batch. An American newspaper printed Bennett's positions - no Palestinian state, 'Judea and Samaria', permanent Israeli rule, 'there wouldn't be apartheid' - verbatim and unchallenged in 2010, while he was a lobbyist. The paper's own framing words are mild ('settler advocacy group', 'settler movement', 'Jewish settlement construction'); every hard phrase on the page is Bennett's own. The interviewer does push: the last two questions put the Palestinian objection to him directly. 'Occupied' never appears. The parenthetical '(another term for the West Bank)' after 'Judea and Samaria' is the paper's gloss, inserted inside Bennett's quote.
· The Star-Ledger · Newark, NJ
Obama decries attack on Israelis
By Diaa Hadid and Karin Laub / ASSOCIATED PRESS
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — The top Hamas leader in the Gaza Strip rejected compromise with Israel in a fiery speech yesterday, a day after gunmen killed four Israelis in a strong reminder that the Islamic militant group cannot be ignored in any Mideast deal.
President Obama denounced the West Bank ambush as he launched a two-day summit marking the first Israeli-Palestinian negotiations in nearly two years. “The message should go out to Hamas and everyone else who is taking credit for these heinous crimes that this is not going to stop us,” he said after greeting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the White House.
Hamas has claimed responsibility for Tuesday’s shootings, a vivid reminder that the Iranian-backed group may be locked out of the peace negotiations but remains a key player in determining their outcome. Late yesterday, gunmen wounded two Israelis in a drive-by shooting in the northern West Bank, the military said.
Assailants in a car overtook an Israeli vehicle and opened fire, seriously wounding an Israeli man. The vehicle crashed, injuring a woman. In a text message to reporters early today, Hamas claimed responsibility. The method resembled Tuesday’s fatal shooting in the southern part of the territory.
In an interview just before yesterday’s shooting, Gaza strongman Mahmoud Zahar indicated that more attacks could be expected. “Our resistance is continuous,” he said. “We have to concentrate on the West Bank in order to achieve (its) liberation.”
Earlier, in an address to Hamas members, Zahar said the movement would resist peace efforts and criticized the Palestinian president for joining the negotiations.
“Today marks the start of direct negotiations between someone who has no right to represent the Palestinian people and the brutal occupier, to provide a cover for Judaizing Jerusalem and stealing the land,” Zahar said.
AP wire copy. Useful as a control alongside the Bennett items: the same paper, very likely the same day, describing Palestinians. The paper's own nouns are 'Islamic militant group', 'Iranian-backed group', 'gunmen', 'assailants', 'Gaza strongman'. The word 'occupier' appears once, in Zahar's mouth. Note the paper names the Israeli casualties by nationality but gives no Palestinian names or numbers; no ordinary person on either side is named.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles
Ahmad Tibi
Ahmad Tibi, a Palestinian member of the Knesset, in an American paper.
· estimated · The Bay City Times · Bay City
ISRAEL/PALESTINE - One week after its previous demolition on Tuesday the 17th of August, the Bedouin village of Al Araqib has again become a victim of demolition. Located in the Negev, north of Beer Sheva, Al Araqib has been subject to four demolitions in less than one month. It houses 300 people, of which a majority are children.
Each time, all structures of the village were completely demolished, targeting particular water infrastructures and livestock shelters. This Tuesday, police forces accompanied by the Israeli Land Administration arrived in the village at 6:00 am with two bulldozers.
Around 25 shelters were demolished that had been previously rebuilt by the villagers with the help of Israeli and international volunteers. Belongings in the shelters and a truck were confiscated by the police. During the course of the demolition Ayman Odeh from the Hadash party was detained on grounds of obstruction police activities.
According to the residents today’s demolition came as a surprise since they expected a minimum of respect by the police due to the current Ramadan holidays. The State of Israel claims that Al Araqib is an unrecognized village settled on state land. Thus its residents are trespassers and have no right over the land they occupy nor to build their houses here.
In this respect, ILA representatives argue that the demolitions occur in conformity with the due process of law. In addition, the land of Al Araqib is targeted by a Jewish Nation Fund project aiming at planting the future “Ambassador forest”. The first trees have already been planted and surround the village.
There are an estimated of 45 unrecognized villages in the Negev. All of them lack basic infrastructures especially regarding water although most of their residents, if not all, are Israeli citizens.
This lack of recognition continues in spite of the fact that Goldberg Committee, created in late 2007 to “solve the problem of the Bedouin in the Negev”, recommended to the Government of Israel that it should formally recognize most of the villages and legalize construction of homes and structures.
Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping — it is a single ruled box containing one item, with nothing above or below it. Nothing on the clipping names the newspaper. The text refers to a demolition “This Tuesday”, one week after “Tuesday the 17th of August”, and to “the current Ramadan holidays”; the fourth demolition of Al Araqib took place on Tuesday, Aug. 24, 2010, so a Sept. 5, 2010 reprint is plausible but unconfirmed.
· Telegram & Gazette · Worcester · page 1
Oud masters Le Trio Joubran honor Mahmoud Darwish in their local debut
Siddhartha Mitter, Globe Correspondent
“Palestinian artists abroad are used to bearing a heavy symbolic load, whether they like it or not.
The history of their people, marked by displacement, occupation, and the endless peace process, imparts a certain intensity to even lighthearted work and invites controversies that might have nothing to do with the performers and their material. But when the Paris-based Palestinian brothers known as Le Trio Joubran, virtuosos of the oud, the ancient Arabic lute, make their Boston debut at the Somerville Theatre on Thursday, their seriousness will speak to a more intimate loss: the death, in August 2008, of the Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish… Their tribute concert featuring recordings of Darwish reading turned into their third album, ‘A l’ombre des mots’ (In the shadow of words)… ‘The first time Wissam performed with me I realized we had something new,’ Samir says.
‘We didn’t play harmony, and we didn’t play exactly the same melody on the two instruments.’… Darwish disliked reading to accompaniment, Samir explains. But when the two appeared on the same bill at a 1996 performance, organizers suggested they share the stage. A compromise was reached.
Darwish agreed to allow brief oud interludes between his poems, no more than three minutes each. ‘He said if I played more than three minutes, I would have to leave the stage.’ Early in Samir’s second interlude, Darwish unexpectedly started to recite, putting the younger man in a dilemma: to continue and risk angering a national icon, or stop?
‘It was the most difficult decision of my life,’ Samir says. ‘I closed my eyes and thought, this is a beautiful chemistry.’ He played on. After a while he looked up toward the poet.
‘He just moved his head,’ Samir says, in approval. Samir and later his brothers would go on to accompany Darwish in several dozen concerts, and learn from his friendship. ‘He taught what universities will never teach,’ Samir says. ‘How to compose a musical sentence and color it, so that you can see, for example, a flower opening.
How to look at the silence between the notes.’ Darwish also helped the brothers deal with burdens beyond music. ‘He taught me there is always pressure from the political issue of Palestine on the culture,’ Samir says.
‘We feel it every day, but we don’t know it.’ He says the poet helped the young men free their music from that insidious stress… The three ouds — made by Wissam, who is not just the bearer of the family luthier tradition but a graduate of the Stradivarius violin-making school in Cremona, Italy — share the same size and tuning but have different woods and details, producing distinct colors and tones… ‘Of course we are always fighting, especially when we compose.
It’s not easy. Maybe if we weren’t brothers, we wouldn’t stay in the same group… But in the end brotherhood is the most important. It’s for our family; our small family, and also the big family of Palestine.’”
“From left: Adnan, Wissam, and Samir Joubran, the brothers of Le Trio Joubran, often collaborated with Mahmoud Darwish (below) prior to the Palestinian poet’s death in 2008.” · Philippe Fresi
The first paragraph of this concert preview states the subject of this archive in two sentences, and then the piece goes on to be about three brothers, an instrument and a friendship. The scene at its center is a poet who disliked being played over, a young musician told he had three minutes, and a nod. What Samir Joubran says Darwish taught him is the thing itself: that there is always pressure from the politics of Palestine on the culture, and that they feel it every day without knowing it. Wissam Joubran builds the family’s ouds and trained at the violin-making school in Cremona.
· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha, NE
RAMALLAH, West Bank (AP) — Dozens of senior Palestinians on Saturday backed President Mahmoud Abbas’ refusal to negotiate with Israel as long as it builds in West Bank settlements, dealing a new setback to U.S. efforts to salvage peace talks.
Israel refuses to extend a 10-month-old curb on settlement construction, while Abbas says there is no point in negotiating as long as settlements eat up more of the land the Palestinians want for a future state. The Palestinians’ final decision on whether to quit the talks is expected at an Arab League summit next weekend.
However, Saturday’s unanimous decision by dozens of senior members of the Palestine Liberation Organization and Abbas’ Fatah movement makes compromise increasingly unlikely. “There will be no negotiations as long as settlement building continues,” senior Abbas aide Nabil Abu Rdeneh said after a three-hour meeting.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is equally adamant about not extending the curb on settlement construction. Israeli building crews began work last week at settlements including Ariel, Oranit, Tekoa and Adam, said Naftali Bennett, director-general of the Yesha Council, which represents more than 300,000 settlers in the West Bank.
This report includes material from Bloomberg News.
AP wire copy. Nouns: 'West Bank settlements', 'settlement construction', 'settlers', 'curb on settlement construction' (the paper's softened word for the moratorium). 'Occupied' does not appear. Bennett appears purely as a factual source on where crews are digging - the paper hands him the task of confirming the construction, and attaches the 300,000-settler figure to his organisation rather than to any independent count.
· Pittsburgh Post-Gazette · Pittsburgh, PA
U.S. hopes Arabs will encourage Palestinians
By Mark Landler and Ethan Bronner / The New York Times
WASHINGTON — The Obama administration believes it has persuaded Arab states not to scuttle the fledgling Middle East peace negotiations, officials said Thursday, despite the Israeli government’s refusal to freeze Jewish settlements and a vow by the Palestinians to walk away if Israel did not.
With the Arab League’s meeting Friday expected to deliver a pivotal decision on the future of the talks, the United States has appealed to Jordan and other Arab nations to stop short of pushing the Palestinians to break off the negotiations. After days of intensive diplomacy by Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton and the administration’s special envoy, George J.
Mitchell, the administration now expects the meeting in Libya to produce a stream of vitriol against Israel and an insistence that the two sides cannot talk while settlement building is under way, but no formal declaration that negotiations should be abandoned, U.S. and Israeli officials said.
Such an outcome would allow the peace process to survive another tricky deadline but leave the negotiations basically where they have been since Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas sat down in Washington last month: stuck in the starting gate, with no further meeting scheduled until the settlements issue is resolved.
Palestinian officials have not commented on the prospective Arab League decision, and Thursday they were holding fast to their position that talks could not continue if settlement building did. But the Arab League’s calibrated response would at least allow the lines to remain open. The United States continues to haggle with Mr.
Netanyahu over a package of security guarantees in return for a one-time 60-day extension of the freeze, Israeli and U.S. officials said. But there are no ministerial meetings planned to consider extending the freeze, and it cannot be extended without ministerial approval. The United States signed an agreement Thursday to sell 20 F-35 Joint Strike Fighter aircraft to Israel.
Officials said the deal was long in the making and not related to the effort to get the Israelis to extend the freeze, although the United States might throw in an extra plane as a sweetener for Mr. Netanyahu, they said. In Israel, there was every indication that the Arab League meeting would pass without any settlements announcement from the prime minister.
The head of the settler movement said Thursday that his group, Yesha Council, no longer saw the need to run advertisements pressing the government not to renew the construction freeze. “We have pulled back our campaign and don’t feel that the coming days will be dramatic,” the group’s executive director, Naftali Bennett, said in an interview.
New York Times wire copy carried by a U.S. metro. Nouns: 'Jewish settlements', 'settlements', 'settlement building', 'the settler movement', 'construction freeze'. The word 'occupied' does not appear. 'Judea and Samaria' does not appear. Bennett is identified by function (executive director of the Yesha Council / head of the settler movement) with no description of what the Yesha Council is beyond that. The section flag 'INTERNATIONAL' is a standing head, not a dek; the dek recorded above is the printed subhead under the headline.
· The News & Observer · Raleigh, NC
By Ethan Bonner / New York Times
JERUSALEM – Less than four weeks since the end of Israel’s building freeze in the West Bank, hundreds of units are under construction in dozens of settlements there, settler leaders and anti-settlement advocates said Thursday. Foundations have been dug for 300 units, and work is under way on a couple of hundred more, they report.
Many of the units in smaller settlements that would be most unlikely to remain as part of Israel in any future two-state deal with the Palestinians.
Hagit Ofran, who monitors settlement construction for Peace Now, a group that opposes construction, said she was preparing a report showing that in at least 36 settlements, especially in smaller ones, intensive building was under way. “They suspect another freeze is coming, and they are running to build,” she said in a telephone interview.
“This is also about selling and money, not only ideology. There is less government building and much more private building in areas that received approval a long time ago and where there is demand.” In the largest settlements, where government approval is required to break ground, building has resumed at a slower pace, she said.
Peace talks between Israel and the Palestinian Authority ended late last month when the 10-month settlement construction freeze ended. The Palestinians say they cannot negotiate while the land they seek as their future state is being covered in new Jewish housing. The United States has been trying to persuade Israel to impose a second freeze to keep the talks going.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said he is considering it. Robert H. Serry, the U.N. special envoy for Middle East peace, issued a statement condemning the new West Bank building.
“Renewed settlement construction, which is illegal under international law, runs contrary to the international community’s repeated appeals to the parties to create conditions conducive to negotiations and will only further undermine trust,” he said. Settler leaders confirmed Ofran’s numbers and said they wished they had been able to build still more.
“Why should there be any place in Israel where we are barred from building?” asked Naftali Bennett, director of the Yesha Council, the settler group.
The sharpest language in this clipping - 'illegal under international law' - is quoted, not stated. The paper's own nouns are 'settlements', 'settler leaders', 'settler group', 'new Jewish housing', 'building freeze'. 'Occupied' does not appear anywhere. The headline verb 'race' belongs to the settlers; the Palestinians appear once, in a subordinate clause, as people who 'say they cannot negotiate'.
· The Boston Globe · Boston, MA · page A3
Contend silent freeze imposed | 4,300 units await approval
By Amy Teibel / ASSOCIATED PRESS
JERUSALEM — Jewish settlers accused their government yesterday of holding up construction of more than 4,000 apartments in large West Bank settlements, suggesting that Israel is quietly complying with US demands to reinstate a building moratorium that expired in late September.
The settlers, releasing their first concrete figures on what projects are being blocked, say Defense Minister Ehud Barak is imposing a silent freeze by withholding his final approval of building plans. Barak’s office responded that with the end of the slowdown, the government decides about further construction, and “every request is considered on its merits.”
The issue of Israeli settlement construction has become a key sticking point in US-backed peace talks, just weeks after their launch at a White House ceremony. Israel has been under heavy pressure to renew its moratorium, which limited new construction in West Bank settlements.
Some 300,000 Israelis already live in West Bank settlements, and the Palestinians say there is no point in negotiating if Israel continues to build homes on land they claim for a future state. Netanyahu has refused to extend the slowdown, though officials say they are in talks with Washington on reaching a compromise.
The Palestinians, backed by the Arab world, have given the United States until early next month to work out a deal. Naftali Bennett, director of the Yesha Council settler umbrella group, insisted in an interview that a silent moratorium was in fact underway in large, urban settlements.
Some 4,300 apartments have all the necessary construction permits, but Barak hasn’t authorized the state to put these projects up for bid, in effect freezing them, Bennett said. He provided a list of projects he said were being held up.
Palestinian spokesman Ghassan Khatib called any drag on construction irrelevant because construction continues elsewhere at a pace that outstrips that of recent years. “That’s why it doesn’t make any sense to consider that there is any kind of freeze or any kind of slowdown. We can say the opposite,” Khatib said.
As previously reported by the Associated Press, Israel has begun work on some 600 apartments across the West Bank since the 10-month moratorium expired — at least double the pace of the previous two years.
The headline frames settlers as the aggrieved party ('protest construction holdup'). Nouns: 'Jewish settlers', 'West Bank settlements', 'settler umbrella group', 'silent freeze', 'slowdown', 'moratorium'. 'Occupied' does not appear. Bennett is the story's source and the supplier of its central number - he 'provided a list of projects he said were being held up' - and the AP prints 4,300 in the dek on his say-so. Khatib's rebuttal is placed late but is the only claim in the piece the AP independently confirms.
· Port Charlotte Sun
Trudy Rubin
A Jerusalem shopping mall as the setting. The clipping uses Arab citizens of Israel for the people in it.
· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia, PA · page A17
By Ethan Bronner / NEW YORK TIMES NEWS SERVICE
JERUSALEM — In the three months since Israel ended its settlement-construction freeze in the West Bank, leading the Palestinians to withdraw from peace talks, a settlement-building boom has begun, especially in more remote communities that are least likely to be part of Israel after any two-state peace deal.
This means that if negotiations ever get back on track, there will be thousands more Israeli settlers who will have to relocate into Israel, posing new problems over how to accommodate them while creating a Palestinian state on the land where many of them are living now.
Besides West Bank settlement-building, construction for predominantly Jewish housing in East Jerusalem, where the Palestinians hope to make their future capital, has been rapidly growing after a break of half a year, with hundreds of units approved and thousands more planned.
On a tour of West Bank construction sites, Dror Etkes, an anti-settlement advocate who has spent nine years chronicling their growth, said he doubted whether there had been such a burst in settlement construction in at least a decade.
Hagit Ofran, a settlement opponent who monitors their growth for Peace Now, said: “We can say firmly that this is the most active period in many years.” She said there were 2,000 housing units being built now and a total of 13,000 in the pipeline that did not require additional permits. In each of the last three years, about 3,000 units have been built.
While government data on the building will not be published until the new year, settler leaders did not contradict these assessments. “The freeze is over, and we are filling in the gap of need that was postponed,” said David Ha’Ivri, spokesman for the Samaria Regional Council in the northern West Bank. “The Peace Now numbers are reliable. Their count seems to be correct.
The only difference is that they see it as negative, and we see it as positive.” Naftali Bennett, executive director of the Yesha Council, the settlers’ umbrella organization, said his group wanted government tenders for an additional 4,000 badly needed units, mostly in large settlements.
Palestinian leaders have said they will not return to peace talks with Israel as long as settlement construction occurs.
Bennett is quoted here only indirectly - the paper paraphrases him asking for 4,000 more units. The sharpest settler language on the page belongs to Ha'Ivri. The paper's nouns: 'settlement-building', 'settlement construction', 'Israeli settlers', 'settler leaders', 'the settlers' umbrella organization', 'predominantly Jewish housing in East Jerusalem', 'more remote communities'. 'Occupied' does not appear. Bronner's lead does name the cost in Palestinian terms - a state built 'on the land where many of them are living now' - which is sharper framing than the wire copy in this batch.
· The Monitor · McAllen · page 1
“A Catholic pilgrim lights a candle Friday outside of the Grotto at the Church of Nativity, traditionally believed by Christians to be the birthplace of Jesus Christ, in the West Bank town of Bethlehem.” Dimitri Messinis, The Associated Press.
And: “Palestinian youths throw stones at Israeli troops during a protest against Jewish settlements Friday in the east Jerusalem neighborhood of Silwan.” Dan Balilty, The Associated Press.
A question in the headline and two photographs under it. The text of the piece is not part of this clipping.
· Times Record News · Wichita Falls
By Graham Dunbar, Associated Press
LAUSANNE, Switzerland — Israeli and Palestinian Olympic officials met Thursday to begin building closer ties and help send stronger teams to the 2012 London Games.
IOC President Jacques Rogge brokered a five-hour gathering at Olympic headquarters that addressed lifting Israeli travel restrictions to allow Palestinian athletes and coaches more access between the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Palestinian athletes were promised IOC funding and Israeli support to prepare for the London Olympics.
The parties hailed the “positive and constructive” meeting, and agreed to study the travel issues before returning to Lausanne in March. That's when they plan to present proposals to their governments. “We believe that through sport we can make a difference.
I hope today we made the first steps,” Efraim Zinger, secretary-general of the Israeli Olympic committee, told The Associated Press. Zinger described Palestinian Olympic leader Jibril Rajoub as a partner in the process. Rajoub said it was “a common choice for everybody” at the meeting to seek ways to help Palestinian athletes and teams compete internationally.
“It is my dream as Palestinian national Olympic committee president to participate in next year's Olympic Games by an army of athletes,” Rajoub told the AP. Only four Palestinian athletes competed at the 2008 Beijing Olympics, even though the team is entitled to additional help through the IOC's solidarity program.
Zinger said Israel was committed to hosting the Palestinian team at training camps and coaching seminars, and share its knowledge of sports science and medicine. “We are there and in advance we said ‘Yes' for any request regarding assistance for the preparation of Palestinian athletes for the Olympic Games,” Zinger said.
In a wide-ranging discussion, Israel also sought IOC help to increase its participation in Olympics sports. There was discussion of Israel and Palestine being accepted into the Mediterranean Games, a quadrennial multisports event that will be hosted by Greece in 2013.
· estimated · The Times Argus
Haviland Smith’s recent op-ed (“Zionism’s Dreams Imperiled,” May 8) counsels that Israel’s “only hope” of remaining true to its Zionist ideals is to end the occupation and concede a state to the Palestinians.
His logic fails, however, because Israeli policies in the occupied territories are strategically and ideologically anchored to, not in conflict with, Zionism. Cleansing Palestine of Arabs has been the sine qua non of the Zionist project since the late 19th century.
In 1948, 750,000 Palestinians were driven from their homeland by Jewish forces, and most of their villages were destroyed to prevent their return. Thus, the Jewish state was born, and until 1966, it imposed a military regime on the remnants of the Palestinian nation inside its borders while confiscating their land and that of the displaced refugees.
In 1967, it began the process of dispossession and colonization anew as an occupying power. When it comes to Palestinians, liberal and conservative Zionists are cut from the same cloth. The only difference, as one Israeli historian put it, is that liberals want a smaller Israel with no Arabs and their right-wing cousins desire a larger Israel with no Arabs.
This apartheid mentality is on display daily in the occupied territories. It is also embedded in an extensive regimen of laws, regulations and jurisprudence inside Israel that extend more power, privileges and material benefits to Jews. This, too, is the hateful business of Zionism, but we don’t talk about it.
Most Palestinian children in Israel, for example, are educated in racially segregated, inferior schools. They and their parents are excluded from hundreds of Jewish communities by “admissions committees” and racist property laws.
Eighty thousand Bedouin live in “unrecognized villages,” denied water, roads, schools and electricity, while Israel expropriates their lands for Jews. Not a single new community for Palestinians has been built in Israel since 1948. Is this the Israel Mr. Smith wants to preserve?
Date check: No masthead, folio or printed date appears on this clipping — it is a trimmed letters column, cut mid-page at the top and at the right edge. Nothing on it names the newspaper. The letter answers an op-ed dated “May 8”, which is consistent with a mid-May paper, but 2011-05-15 could not be checked.
· The Coeur d’Alene Press
WASHINGTON — Indicating no progress toward peace, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu sat alongside President Barack Obama on Friday and declared that Israel would not withdraw to 1967 borders to help make way for an adjacent Palestinian state. Obama had called on Israel to be willing to do just that a day earlier.
The Israeli leader said he would make some concessions but Israel would not go back to the lines from decades earlier because they would be “indefensible.” For his part, Obama said that there were differences of formulations and language but that such disputes are going to happen “between friends.”
The president never mentioned the 1967 borders as the two men talked with reporters. The leaders spoke after a lengthy meeting in the Oval Office, amid tense times.
President Barack Obama meets with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Friday in the Oval Office at the White House.
Printed in a Briefs column among unrelated items.
· Daily American
“Europe is increasingly pro-Palestinian.”
A St. Louis Post-Dispatch editorial syndicated to Somerset, Pennsylvania, weighing statehood as an American electoral problem.
· Marshall News Messenger · Marshall
Jerusalem boxing club brings together Jews, Arabs
JERUSALEM (AP) — When Gershon Luxemburg started his boxing club 30 years ago, he was looking to build champions, not bridges. But thanks to a loyal cadre of Jewish and Arab fighters who flock to his stuffy gym inside a converted underground bomb shelter, Luxemburg's club has become a rare melting pot that brings the warring sides closer together — one punch at a time.
Luxemburg and his brother Eli run Jerusalem's only official boxing club. The cramped, smelly gym has pictures of Muhammad Ali and other boxing greats gracing the walls and an assortment of heavy bags hanging from the ceiling.
Located in a neighborhood in Jewish west Jerusalem, it draws boxers from all parts of the city and has become a second home for both aspiring professionals and amateurs looking to learn the sweet science. Despite the sport's violent nature, Luxemburg says Jews and Arabs never clash in his gym.
“It's very easy for me to see hate in someone's eyes, and I've never seen it here,” he said. “The boxers are close. They are like brothers to each other.” At a time when Israelis and Palestinians are increasingly segregated, the Maccabi Jerusalem Boxing Club offers a hub of coexistence. Jews and Arabs who would normally never cross paths jog, skip rope and spar.
They pant and sweat, and the occasional nose gets bloody, but tensions never rise after the bell is rung. Luxemburg says it is typical for aspiring boxers to come with troubled pasts. But learning how to fight actually lessens violent tendencies, he said. “When someone has that confidence in himself, he doesn't look for a fight. He doesn't need to throw stones,” he said.
“Sports brings people together. When you get in that ring together, when you get so close you can smell the other person … it's a different level.” He said that in sanctioned tournaments he lets his fighters get “cruel” and hit hard. But the in-house training is kept civil, even cordial.
Ismail Jafrei, a 37-year-old Palestinian truck driver from east Jerusalem, the section of the city claimed by the Palestinians for their future capital, says the trick is to leave politics at the door. “When we walk down those steps we leave politics, religion and all that mess outside,” he said. “Inside the club, we are all brothers.
We spar and at the end we shake hands and everyone goes their own way.” A frequent Israeli sparring partner agrees. “We're just fighters and it doesn't matter if one is an Arab and one is a Jew,” said Yehuda Luxemburg, a 23-year-old Israeli combat soldier and nephew of the club's trainers. “There is something pure about boxing. It brings people together.”
Eli Luxemburg is an equal opportunity screamer. At a recent practice, he hollered at his charges “fire, fire, fire” and they began to unload jabs at each other's boxing helmets. “Mohammed. Move your feet! You aren't moving your feet!” he yelled at a Palestinian boxer.
The shy east Jerusalemite nodded, and Yehuda Luxemburg gave him some pointers on footwork and other fine points. “Now hit me!” he said. The Luxemburg brothers were both former champs in their native Uzbekistan before immigrating to Israel. They now enjoy a cult-like status among Jerusalem's small but tightly knit boxing community.
They instruct in a mixture of Hebrew, Russian and English. While many Palestinians in Jerusalem know Hebrew, instructions are translated into Arabic for those who don't. Israeli boxers have enjoyed a moderate level of success internationally.
Most originate from the former Soviet Union, such as former WBA super welterweight champion Yuri Foreman and heavyweight Roman Greenberg — nicknamed the “Lion from Zion.”
Some of the Gershon Luxemburg's fighters have gone on to compete in the Olympics and in European championships, but he says his ultimate dream is to host a tournament in Jerusalem with all religions attending — and perhaps Muhammad Ali too. “I don't care if they become boxing champions, so long as they become champions in life,” he said.
In this photo taken June 29, Israeli and Palestinian boxers train at the Maccabi Jerusalem Boxing Club in Jerusalem. Jewish and Arab fighters flock regularly to this gym inside a converted underground bomb shelter.
Associated Press. The same day, The Tribune ran the photograph and its caption alone, with no story.
· The Tribune
Israeli and Palestinian boxers train at the Maccabi Jerusalem Boxing Club in Jerusalem. Thanks to a loyal cadre of Jewish and Arab fighters who flock regularly to his stuffy gym inside a converted underground bomb shelter, Gershon Luxemburg's boxing club has become a rare melting pot that brings the warring sides closer together, one punch at a time.
Israeli and Palestinian boxers train at the Maccabi Jerusalem Boxing Club in Jerusalem. Thanks to a loyal cadre of Jewish and Arab fighters who flock regularly to his stuffy gym inside a converted underground bomb shelter, Gershon Luxemburg's boxing club has become a rare melting pot that brings the warring sides closer together, one punch at a time.
The photograph and caption ran alone, without the Associated Press story that the Marshall News Messenger printed the same day. Headline field holds the caption's first sentence; the item carried no headline of its own.
Correction: The item is a standalone Associated Press photograph.
· The Republic · Columbus · page 1
Michal Levertov, The Institute for War & Peace Reporting
“THE Druze village of Hurfeish seems as pastoral as the rural north of Israel can be. Sitting on the northwestern slope of the Meron Mountains amid a national park, the centuries-old settlement of about 6,000 residents looks like an image taken from a tourist postcard: green, beautiful, serene. But earlier this month, the atmosphere was not so peaceful.
A policeman and an official from the national park authority were attacked by village youths when they attempted to enforce a demolition order for an unauthorized building.
As the disturbance spread, hundreds of youngsters set fire to tires and blocked Hurfeish’s main road, a central northern Galilee transport route, in protests that took four hours to bring under control. Community leader Fawaz Hossain, 57, denounces the violence.
But he puts the blame squarely on the police and the parks’ authority decision to issue the demolition order just as Israel is in the midst of an unprecedented wave of activism over rising housing prices. What started off on Tel Aviv’s Rothschild Avenue as a localized protest has turned into a nationwide call for social justice.
At its peak, about 300,000 people turned out on across Israel in peaceful opposition to the growing disparity of income in Israel. And although initially seen as a mass movement among Jews, the country’s Arab citizens are increasingly involved in the civil protest.
‘We are clearly a part of the wider tent protest, even though there are differences in our needs and demands,’ explained Hossain. ‘It’s not the housing prices that we protest against, but the utter lack of adequate housing for us.’
Much of the land in Hurfeish was confiscated by the state decades ago, with most of it going to create a nature preserve. But some of the land was also intended for the development of a neighboring Jewish village. Ever since, Hurfeish’s residents have been battling building restrictions on the remaining land.
While the residents of Hurfeish are quick to link their protest with those occurring elsewhere in Israel, other Arab communities are hesitant to join in what they see as a Jewish issue.
This hesitance, says Aida Touma-Sliman, editor-in-chief of the Arabic al-Ittihad daily newspaper, has been due to a ‘deep disbelief within the Arab population — following decades of exclusion and discrimination — that it is capable of influencing the general Israeli agenda.’
But in truth, Touma-Sliman notes, the issues facing the Arab community — lack of land, housing and limited access to social welfare — are the same ones driving Israeli Jews into the streets… ‘Arabs in Israel also feel that the changes in the Arab states are being generated by a great sense of ownership that the citizens there have,’ Touma-Sliman said.
‘The Arab public in Israel feels disconnected and alienated from the rest of the population, thus being deprived of the feeling of entitlement which enabled the protests of the Arab Spring, as well as that of the Jewish population in Israel.’ Nonetheless, Touma-Sliman said, the Arab public should join the movement.
‘If there ever was willingness in the Israeli Jewish mainstream to hear the Arab citizens cry out against discrimination, land confiscations or house demolishing — and to do that not through a nationalist lens — it is now,’ she said. Others see no chance for the protesters finding common ground.
Writing in Haaretz, a major English-language newspaper in Israel, Arab journalist Zuheir Anderus emphasized that he could not identify with the protest because it ‘ignores my existence and my problems.’
Indeed, the 22-member committee that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu appointed to offer solutions to the protestors’ demands does not include a single Arab representative. But others see this as a unique opportunity to unite the country’s diverse communities.
Shahin Nassar, a 25-year-old student and journalist, founded an encampment in Wadi Nisnas, an Arab neighborhood in the northern city of Haifa, after participating in a rally in a Jewish neighborhood where he was disappointed by the lack of Arab participation. ‘This protest is definitely mine too, and it is for me to determine its nature and its goals,’ he said.
‘Any achievement, whether it is reducing housing costs or electricity prices, will benefit the Arab population just as much. Of course, we are in a unique position and nobody denies it. We are an integral part of the Palestinian people. But just the same, we are an integral part of the state of Israel.’”
A cartoon runs with the piece: a lawnmower cutting through a field of flowers, a signpost reading ‘ARAB’, and a speech bubble saying “I HATE ARAB SPRING!”
Palestinian citizens of Israel arguing among themselves, in an American paper, about whether to join a Jewish-led protest. Four are quoted and three are named; the last of them ends on being an integral part of both peoples.
· The Post-Standard · Syracuse
US diplomacy could help bring peace to region
By Ken Frieden and Dr. Anis Obeid
The Palestinian Authority seems to be moving ahead with its plan to request United Nations recognition of an independent Palestinian state along the 1967 borders. This action would be the culmination of decades of Palestinian frustration over their failure to achieve statehood through a negotiated settlement with the state of Israel.
Instead of rushing to oppose or reject this Palestinian initiative, the U.S. government should act constructively, and in a balanced manner, to foster a positive outcome. An effort to achieve recognition of an independent Palestinian state is likely to receive enough support in the U.N. General Assembly to acquire international legitimacy.
The Palestinians point out that they have waited long enough as their land has been expropriated and Israeli settlements continue to expand, while some observers and experts feel that facts on the ground are rapidly diminishing the possibility for any two-state solution.
Thus, the Palestinian leadership may believe that this is the last chance to attain their goal of establishing independence. The Palestinian leadership must be aware of the burdens of statehood, the limitations of a unilateral proclamation and the responsibility for effective governance under fragile and unstable conditions.
How should the U.S. government deal with this serious challenge and its repercussions? On the one hand, voting in favor of Palestinian statehood is a position that is supported by the international community, including our Western allies and our friends in the Arab world, yet such a decision would very likely be opposed by segments of our society and by members of Congress.
On the other hand, using our veto power to block Palestinian statehood would risk losing stature in the eyes of the international community and credibility in the Arab and Muslim world.
PALESTINIAN AUTHORITY President Mahmoud Abbas pauses Sept. 6 during a meeting with Palestinian doctors at his office in the West Bank city of Ramallah. Abbas plans to submit an application to the United Nations next week seeking recognition of Palestine as an independent state. (AP Photo/Majdi Mohammed)
· Iowa City Press-Citizen · Iowa City
Shams Ghoneim, Writers’ Group
“The world is at the dawn of a potential new page in the history of the Holy Lands and for the long oppressed Palestinian people. From 1967 to the present, Palestinian lands are still illegally occupied by Israel in spite of several United Nations resolutions.
Security Council Resolution 242 (1967) called on Israel to withdraw from territories it had occupied in the 1967 conflict, continues to be ignored. In 1974, the General Assembly reaffirmed the inalienable rights of the Palestinian people to self-determination, national independence and sovereignty and to return.
Israel began the construction of a West Bank separation wall in 2003, within the Occupied Palestinian Territory, which was ruled illegal by the International Court of Justice. From 2000 to 2008 more violence, hardship, human rights violations and misery prevailed against the Palestinian people. Israeli civilians also faced many challenges.
The isolation, blockade and the 2008 vicious war against Gaza with the ongoing suffering of ordinary Palestinians are shameful acts and demonstrate indifference by the international community. The world impotently watched brutal horror and aggression raining on Gaza. The invasion was allegedly responding to Hamas’s primitive rockets shelling of Israel.
As Gazans’ blood flowed, the U.S. House of Representatives voted 390 to 5, hailing the invasion as ‘Israel’s right to defend itself.’ When Israeli military used white phosphorus against civilians with many dead children, the international court remained silent.
Today — the International Day of Democracy — Palestinians will be seeking statehood at the United Nations Security Council. The Palestinians currently have U.N. ‘observer’ status. The U.N. approval is required to become a member state. The U.S. has promised to veto such resolution. Palestinians could seek statehood recognition at the U.N.
General Assembly, which if granted, would be highly symbolic, representing a significant public relations victory. If Palestine becomes a non-member U.N. state, it would put it on par with that of the Vatican. Palestine as U.N. member can join the International Criminal Courts and other U.N. bodies.
The court can be instrumental to bring Israeli officials to justice for crimes against Palestinians residing in the occupied territories and potentially end the occupation.
The issue of statehood according to legal experts has been settled, because Palestine is a state in accordance with the first article of the Montevideo Convention, which defines a state as having: » A permanent population. » A defined territory. » A government. » And capacity to enter into relations with the other states.
As protests about the high cost of living in Israel continued in the streets for the fourth week, the Israeli government continued its effort to expedite the illegal construction of new housing in settlements in East Jerusalem, deep inside the West Bank, and more than 10 miles from the pre-1967 Green Line.
Americans should demand more of Israel since our tax dollars provide arms and aid. But the U.S. Congress continues to be an obstructionist where it stands regarding the Palestinian/Israeli lop-sided policy that is dysfunctional and against American interest. Thankfully American and Israeli voices for peace are being raised.
Jewish Voice for Peace, Rabbis for Human Rights, Gush Shalom, Israeli Committee Against House Demolition, Yesh Gvul, New Profile, Ta’ayush, Bat Shalom, The Alternative Information Center: for Middle East Peace are such active groups. Across the Middle East, the waves of freedom seekers are spreading from Tunisia to Egypt, to Bahrain, to Libya, to Syria to Yemen.
The freedom waves will ultimately spread to the Palestinian territories, and Palestinians will shed their chains, seek and obtain peacefully their long-awaited freedom from decades of brutal occupation. Shams Ghoneim is a community member of the Press-Citizen Editorial Board.”
A named Palestinian voice in an Iowa daily, on the editorial page, with a photograph. Shams Ghoneim writes as a member of the paper’s own editorial board. The column names nine Israeli and American peace groups by name, and its argument for statehood is made from the Montevideo Convention rather than from grievance.
· Santa Barbara News-Press · Santa Barbara
DONNA CASSATA, ASSOCIATED PRESS
WASHINGTON — The Palestinian Authority and President Mahmoud Abbas have repeatedly been warned: Pursue statehood recognition at the United Nations and risk losing millions of dollars in U.S. aid.
For months, congressional Republicans and Democrats have threatened to cut off some $500 million in economic and security assistance to the Palestinians if they defy the United States and Israel by seeking statehood. The Americans and Israelis prefer negotiations between the sides leading to a two-state solution.
Congress’ forceful message has been delivered in letters to Abbas, through overwhelming bipartisan votes on resolutions and in fierce rhetoric. “Current and future aid will be jeopardized if you abandon direct negotiations and continue your efforts,” Reps.
Kay Granger, R-Texas, chairwoman of the House Appropriations foreign operations subcommittee, and Nita Lowey of New York, the panel’s top Democrat, wrote to Abbas this summer, echoing a plea they made to the Palestinian leader in an April letter. Now, faced with Abbas’ pronouncement that he will ask the U.N.
Security Council on Friday to back his statehood bid, angry lawmakers may exercise power the one way Congress can — by withholding Palestinian aid.
“The United States will reconsider its assistance program for the Palestinian Authority and other aspects of U.S.-Palestinian relations if they choose to pursue such a unilateral effort,” 58 House Democrats said in a letter to European leaders imploring them to vote against Palestinian statehood and stand with the United States.
“A unilateral declaration of independence is simply rejectionism by another name. It takes away any motivation from the Palestinians to negotiate and deal with good faith with Israel,” Rep. Steve Chabot, R-Ohio, a member of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, said Friday in a conference call with reporters sponsored by the Hudson Institute and Touro College.
· Newsday · Melville
A reader writing to Newsday in shock at its editorial, and proposing an alternative map. The letters column is where the premise gets argued.
· The Oregonian · Portland · page A7
The president says he favors a separate state but not through a U.N. resolution
By SCOTT WILSON, WASHINGTON POST-BLOOMBERG
NEW YORK — Speaking before the U.N. General Assembly last year, President Barack Obama urged those who support a two-state solution to the long conflict between Israelis and Palestinians to “reach for what’s best within ourselves.”
“If we do,” he said, “when we come back next year, we can have an agreement that will lead to a new member of the United Nations — an independent, sovereign state of Palestine, living in peace with Israel.” That goal has grown more remote since Obama spoke those words.
As he returns today to address the General Assembly, Obama is facing a vexing diplomatic challenge: to explain how his hopes of last year square with his opposition this year to a Palestinian bid for statehood. Obama will specifically address, his advisers say, the lack of progress in resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, an issue he made a priority upon taking office.
Obama will seek to draw a distinction between his support for Palestinian statehood and his opposition to pursuing that goal through the United Nations. He will be doing so for two audiences — one suspicious of his intentions toward Israel, the other seeking to understand how he can encourage self-rule in some places and not in others.
His ability to make his case has implications for his re-election prospects — highlighted Tuesday when a leading GOP rival forcefully criticized his handling of Israel — and for his diplomatic overture to Muslims abroad.
“We would not be here today at the very precipice of such a dangerous move if the Obama policy in the Middle East wasn’t naive, arrogant, misguided and dangerous,” Texas Gov. Rick Perry said in a speech here attended by Israeli and American Jewish leaders.
Obama / Promoted statehood at the U.N. last year
· The Post-Standard · Syracuse
· The Post-Standard · Syracuse
WASHINGTON — Exasperated by stalled Middle East peace talks in a season of tumultuous change, President Barack Obama jolted close ally Israel on Thursday by embracing the Palestinians’ terms for drawing the borders of their new nation next door.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel rejected the idea as “indefensible” on the eve of his vital White House meeting with Obama.
The U.S. president said that an independent Palestine should be based on 1967 borders — before the Six Day War in which Israel occupied East Jerusalem, the West Bank and Gaza — as adjusted by possible land swaps agreed upon by both sides. He said Israel can never live in true peace as a Jewish state if it insists on “permanent occupation.”
Obama’s effort to salvage a peace effort that is in shambles was a major change in tactics for a president running out of patience and reasons to be subtle. The Israeli-Palestinian stalemate has remained immune to the popular uprisings and historic drives for freedom that have swept much of the region.
He pushed both sides to accept his starting point — borders for Palestine, security for Israel — and get back to solving a deadlock “that has grinded on and on and on.”
In a sweeping review of recent uprisings and authoritarian crackdowns across the Arab world, Obama was also unsparing in his words for the Palestinian leadership, repudiating its pursuit of unilateral statehood through the United Nations and questioning its alliance with a Hamas faction bent on Israel’s destruction.
“At a time when the people of the Middle East and North Africa are casting off the burdens of the past, the drive for a lasting peace that ends the conflict and resolves all claims is more urgent than ever,” Obama said, playing the rapid change of the past six months against a standoff that has stymied the Mideast for decades.
· USA Today · McLean
“If, as USA TODAY’s editorial noted, Palestinians have repeatedly walked away from near-miss peace agreements with Israel, maybe they don’t really want one.”
A letter that takes the paper's own editorial as its premise and reasons from it to intent.
· Montana Standard · Butte
By James Phillips
In going to the United Nations to push for Palestinian statehood, Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas essentially turned his back on the 1993 Oslo peace accord with Israel and U.S.-brokered Mideast peace negotiations. His campaign was a loud and very public vote of no-confidence in the Obama administration’s policy.
Abbas’ insistence on bypassing negotiations with Israel and taking his case directly to the U.N. General Assembly not only violated previous Palestinian agreements with Israel but also those with the United States, which was a co-signatory of the Oslo accords. Yet the administration has bent over backward to avoid criticizing the Palestinian Authority.
The administration’s low key, reticent approach has failed to halt the Palestinian U.N. drive for unilateral statehood. This could have far-reaching negative consequences for peace prospects, Israeli-Palestinian relations and regional stability. Abbas’ call for peaceful demonstrations in support of statehood already has led Palestinians to burn American and Israeli flags.
Future demonstrations easily could degenerate into violence. Palestinian leadersare frustrated with what they regard as unfulfilled promises made by the administration, which unwisely raised expectations that it could quickly deliver Palestinian statehood in a final agreement with Israel.
· Rutland Daily Herald · Rutland
By MOHAMMED DARAGHMEH, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
RAMALLAH, West Bank — Hundreds of Palestinian prisoners are refusing food to pressure authorities into providing better conditions in their most defiant protest in years, spreading through Israeli prisons and beyond.
The hunger strike has rolled through most of Israel's 23 lockups, where some 5,300 Palestinians are detained with crimes ranging from stone throwing to masterminding militant attacks. At least 200 Palestinian prisoners have been on a total hunger strike for the past two weeks, refusing all food but drinking liquids.
Some 2,000 joined the strike overnight Tuesday, said Kadoura Fares, who heads a prisoners' rights group. He said many of them have already been participating by refusing to eat three days a week. Palestinian prisoners' lawyers gave varying numbers. It was not possible to directly speak to the prisoners.
The strike began as a small protest when an imprisoned Palestinian leader, Ahmed Saadat, was placed in solitary confinement. The 60-year-old Saadat, who is serving a lengthy sentence for involvement in the assassination of an Israeli Cabinet minister 10 years ago, is in poor condition after two weeks without food, say his associates.
The demands quickly spread to demand other privileges that Palestinian lawyers said were taken from prisoners earlier this year: taking university courses, bringing in books and watching Arabic television channels. They also demand Israeli prisons remove the screens separating them from their loved ones during family visits, and demand to be unshackled when they see relatives.
A spokeswoman for Israel's prisons authority said the numbers of prisoners said to be striking were exaggerated. Sivan Weizman said only 240 prisoners were refusing food and that their health was being monitored. She said Saadat and other prisoners were placed in solidarity confinement because they were suspected of helping to direct militant attacks from prison.
It is the largest Palestinian prisoner protest since 2004, when hundreds of inmates went on a 17-day hunger strike to demand better conditions, said lawyer Sahar Francis. Palestinian prisoners say they have seen their privileges progressively eroded since Gaza militants captured an Israeli soldier, Gilad Schalit, in a 2006 cross-border raid.
Families of Gaza prisoners have not been allowed to visit inmates since then. Gaza's ruling Hamas authorities refuse to allow the Red Cross to visit Schalit, and little is known about his fate. Negotiations to exchange Schalit for hundreds of Palestinian prisoners have repeatedly failed. The issue of prisoners runs deep in Palestinian society.
Most Palestinians have had a family member serving time in an Israeli prison, and many thousands have been imprisoned themselves.
Palestinians participate in a demonstration in solidarity with prisoners jailed in Israel in the West Bank city of Nablus on Tuesday.
· The Redwood Coast Review · Gualala · page 1
Yehuda Amichai and Mahmoud Darwish · Poets & Poetry
Roberta Werdinger
“As a Jewish-American writer whose father survived the Holocaust, I have watched the Israeli-Palestinian conflict with a dismayed recognition.
A high-school year spent in Israel opened my eyes to a two-tiered society that placed the Arab (I never heard the word ‘Palestinian’ used) firmly on the bottom. I rejected Zionism as an ideology that sought to own and dominate my mind, building walls in which a glorious ‘us’ fought a noble battle against a murderous other… I wandered alone through Jerusalem’s Arab Quarter, encountering a rich and complex culture… Later, when the first Palestinian intifada occurred, my spontaneous reaction was, ‘It’s about time.’
Yet I came to feel increasingly uncomfortable around large sections of the pro-Palestinian and anti-Zionist movement, who simply substituted one kind of non-negotiable dogma for another… The result in my mind was simply a poverty of imagination, a denuding of the inner landscape by which I could form an empathetic link to whoever my current society told me was my enemy. For that, I turned to the poets.… Darwish underwent exile, imprisonment, and siege imposed by the state Amichai fought for.
Yet both share a kinship in asserting a humanity that reclaims the subjectivity denied them by geopolitics, and then gestures toward the other.… Mahmoud Darwish was born in 1941 in a village in the Galilee. The formation of the Israeli Jewish state, a momentous and long-awaited day for Yehuda Amichai and his ilk, was known to Palestinians as nakba, or ‘catastrophe’; Darwish and his family fled for Lebanon.
They returned shortly after and were accorded the status of ‘present-absent aliens,’ a moniker (worthy of the most ironic postmodernist) that denied the family even the second-class status of Israeli Arabs.… He survived the Israeli invasion of Beirut in 1982, producing a long poem, ‘From Beirut,’ and a prose memoir, ‘Memory for Forgetfulness,’ about the experience. Darwish was invited to draft a charter for peace for the PLO (Palestine Liberation Organization) in 1988, a position he accepted with trepidation.
‘What does a poet do in the executive council?’ he wondered. ‘Will I be able to write a book of love when color falls on the ground in autumn?’ The first book he produced, when he finally returned to live in the West Bank, was indeed a book of love poems, ‘The Stranger’s Bed.’
While Palestinians at first wondered at its lack of public address of their urgent issues, they came to see and respect that the project of his later poems was to reclaim the inner world in order to ennoble and inhabit the outer. Darwish died in 2008… ‘Throw your gun in the river!’ he implores an Israeli soldier in ‘He Embraces His Murderer.’
Another poem, ‘I Belong There,’ concludes: ‘I have learned and dismantled all the words in order to draw from them a single word: Home.’ Palestine is for him both actuality and metaphor, ‘mother of all beginnings and ends.’ Darwish’s poems are full of the pain of exile, but they never harangue.”
Portraits of Mahmoud Darwish and Yehuda Amichai, captioned with their names.
A small California literary review gives two pages to a Palestinian and an Israeli poet side by side, and the writer states her standpoint in her first line. Two things in it belong to this archive’s subject. The first is her account of a school year in Israel where she never once heard the word Palestinian. The second is Darwish, asked in 1988 to help draft a charter for the PLO, asking what a poet is supposed to do on an executive council and whether he will still be allowed to write a book of love. He wrote one. It is the same question the screenwriter Naim al-Khatib puts to an American reporter in Gaza twenty-six years later, and the same one the director Hany Abu-Assad answers in the Los Angeles Times seven months before that.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles
JUDITH REMY LEDER / Fullerton
“As a feminist, I’m distressed to learn that the rights of Israeli women are being further abrogated…”
A letter to the Los Angeles Times.
· The News Journal
“Palestinians note that when President Obama addressed the U.N. General Assembly… Israel had not stopped building settlements or expropriating Palestinian lands.”
Wilmington, Delaware. The clause about expropriation is reported as something Palestinians note, rather than as something that happened.
· The Sacramento Bee · Sacramento
“A focus on the largest minority group: Palestinian Arab citizens of Israel, about 20 percent of the population, and also the more than 700,000 P[alestinians]…”
A letter to the Sacramento Bee answering an editorial, and it does the arithmetic the editorial left out.
· Rutland Daily Herald · Rutland
The Associated Press
Khader Adnan, unnamed in the headline on day fifty-five. Two papers in this archive ran the same count the same morning.
· High Point Enterprise
The Associated Press
North Carolina’s printing of the same wire count as Vermont’s, on the same day, word for word in the headline.
· Herald Citizen
The Associated Press
“A Palestinian prisoner on Tuesday agreed to end his 66-day hunger strike after reaching a deal with Israel that will free him in April.”
Sixty-six days. The standoff is described as having drawn attention to a controversial Israeli practice, which is administrative detention.
· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota
A guest editorial in Sarasota on Palestinian unity as an obstacle to the process.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis
Linda Gradstein
A Jewish community newspaper in St. Louis is the only paper in this archive to put Khader Adnan’s name in the headline during the strike, and the only one to name the system he was testing.
· Rutland Daily Herald · Rutland
The Associated Press
Twelve days after the same paper printed the fifty-fifth day, the same man is still unnamed in its headline.
· Oakland Tribune · Oakland
Bay Area fans of the anti-Israel BDS movement (Boycott, Divest, and Sanction) are trying again to prevent Trader Joe’s, Berkeley Bowl and other stores from selling Israeli couscous and hummus. The protesters argue that BDS helps Palestinians.
After reading about the movement’s goals and leaders, I began to wonder: Do local BDS advocates really understand who and what they are supporting? Do they know, for example, that the BDS movement rejects the two-state solution — an independent state of Palestine next to the state of Israel?
By contrast, the United States, European Union, Israel, and most of the international community think the two-state approach represents the best chance for resolving the Arab/Israeli conflict. But BDS leaders such as Ali Abunimah, founder of Electronic Intifada, defend Palestinian rights for self-determination but deny the same rights to Israelis.
The only way to ensure justice for Palestinians, he says, is to annihilate Israel. Abunimah is author of “One Country: A Bold Proposal to End the Israeli-Palestinian Impasse.” Do BDS supporters understand that “One Country” means one country for Palestine and none for Israel?
When BDS leaders mention “end the occupation,” they don’t mean the disputed territories that came under Israeli control after the 1967 self-defense war. Instead, they rewrite history, asserting that “occupation” includes Tel Aviv, Haifa, and all of Israel. (Palestinian schoolbook maps already show “Palestine” replacing Israel.)
Perhaps BDS supporters don’t realize that the Palestinian “right of return” means flooding Israel with nearly 5 million descendants of the 650,000 Arabs made refugees by the Arab-initiated 1948 war. Most of these “U.N.-designated refugee descendants” live throughout the world and have never set foot in Israel.
If those refugees returned, BDS co-founder Omar Barghouti explains, “You would have one Palestine next to a second Palestine, rather than a Palestine next to an [illegible].” Are BDS followers wondering why all post-World War II refugees (including 700,000 Jews fleeing Arab countries) have been resettled long ago — except Palestinian refugees?
Barghouti, an Egyptian-born Palestinian, declares that Israelis and Palestinians who work together for peace are collaborationists. Do BDS fans agree? Although Barghouti attends Tel Aviv University, he founded the Academic and Cultural boycott of Israel. He argues that Israel is an apartheid country.
However, Israelis hail from more than 100 nations, Arab-Israelis are full citizens, make up 20 percent of the population, have Arab lawyers, doctors, members of the Knesset, and are free to criticize the government. No Jews in Arab countries have the same rights as Arabs in Israel.
Do BDS followers cringe when revisionist Barghouti asserts that Jesus was a Palestinian and denies 3,000 years of Jewish history in Israel?
Are they appalled by BDS silence as Syria slaughters dissident citizens, Turkey arrests journalists, Egypt represses free speech, Saudi Arabia forbids women to drive, Iran threatens a nuclear war and Palestinian gays flee to Israel for safety?
Abunimah and Barghouti do disservice to Palestinians by portraying them as not accountable victims who blame all their woes on Israel and the West. BDS advocates sincerely determined to harm Israel economically should, with conviction, go beyond couscous and hummus.
They should boycott all Israeli-related products such as the pill camera, cellphones, computers, voice mail technology, AOL Instant Messenger, bar code software, scanners, drip irrigation, and other contributions that help people all over the world — including Palestinians. June Brott is an Oakland resident.
· Pittsburgh Post-Gazette · Pittsburgh
Awakened Arabs need the Palestinians to create a model state
THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
There is so much going on in the Middle East today, it's impossible to capture it with one opinion. So here are two for the price of one. Opinion One: Haaretz, the Israeli newspaper, reported the other day that the imprisoned Palestinian leader Marwan Barghouti “released an unusual statement from his cell.
He called on his people to start a popular uprising against Israel, to stop negotiations and security coordination and to boycott [Israel]. Barghouti recommended that his people choose nonviolent opposition.”
Barghouti, as Haaretz notes, “is the most authentic leader Fatah has produced, and he can lead his people to an agreement. … If Israel had wanted an agreement with the Palestinians it would have released him from prison by now.” I had gotten to know Barghouti before his five life sentences for involvement in killing Israelis.
His call for nonviolent resistance is noteworthy and the latest in a series of appeals to and by Palestinians — coming from all over — to summon their own “Arab Awakening,” but do it nonviolently, with civil disobedience or boycotts of Israel, Israeli settlements or Israeli products.
I can certainly see the efficacy of nonviolent resistance by Palestinians to the Israeli occupation of the West Bank — on one condition: They accompany any actions they take with a detailed map of the final two-state settlement they are seeking. Just calling for “an end to occupation” won't cut it.
Palestinians need to accompany every boycott, hunger strike or rock thrown at an Israeli with a map delineating how, for peace, they would accept getting back 95 percent of the West Bank and all Arab neighborhoods of East Jerusalem and would swap the other 5 percent for land inside pre-1967 Israel.
Such an arrangement would allow some 75 percent of the Israeli settlers to remain in the West Bank, while still giving Palestinians 100 percent of the land back.
By Palestinians engaging in nonviolent civil disobedience in the West Bank with one hand and carrying a map of a reasonable two-state settlement in the other, they will be adopting the only strategy that will end the Israeli occupation: Making Israelis feel morally insecure but strategically secure.
The Iron Law of the peace process is that whoever makes the Israeli silent majority feel morally insecure about occupation but strategically secure in Israel wins.
Syndicated column. The tagline reads: Thomas L. Friedman is a syndicated columnist for The New York Times.
· San Antonio Express News · San Antonio
Bernat Armangue
“Palestinian Khader Adnan (center) is greeted Wednesday in Arrabeh during a celebration of his release from an Israeli jail. Adnan, a senior member of Islamic Jihad, didn’t eat for 66 days in protest of prisoners’ conditions and detention without trial.”
He gets his name when he is released and photographed, and not while he is starving. Eleven years before he died on hunger strike in Israeli custody, which this archive also holds.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis
BY MARTIN RAFFEL
Commentary in the St. Louis Jewish Light, which the archive now holds nineteen clippings from across four decades.
· The Morning Call · Allentown
By Edmund Sanders, Tribune Newspapers
RAMALLAH, West Bank — Hundreds of Palestinian prisoners agreed Monday to end their 28-day hunger strike after Israel promised to improve jail conditions, release detainees from solitary confinement and make other concessions. The deal ends the longest and one of the largest hunger strikes organized by Palestinian prisoners.
Most of the 1,600 Palestinian prisoners on strike had refused food since April 17. Two detainees — Bilal Diab, 27, and Thaer Halahleh, 33 — began their strike Feb. 28 and are now in serious condition. Palestinian leaders had warned that the death of a prisoner might spark public outrage and possibly violence in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
Palestinian Authority Prisoners Affairs Minister Issa Qaraqe called the agreement a victory. Israeli officials said they agreed to go further in making concessions as a good-will gesture toward Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, who made a personal appeal on behalf of the prisoners.
Under the terms of the deal, Israel agreed to release about 18 prisoners from solitary confinement and allow them to be integrated with other detainees, in return for a promise that those inmates refrain from engaging in criminal or terrorist activities from their jail cells, Israeli and Palestinian officials said Monday.
Israel also said it would facilitate visits by family members based in the Gaza Strip who were previously banned from seeing their jailed relatives in the West Bank. Israel's use of so-called administrative detention was another sticking point.
More than 300 Palestinians, including Diab and Halahleh, were arrested under a procedure that allows them to be held indefinitely without charges or a trial. Under the terms of the deal, Israel may continue the practice.
But prisoners now held in administrative detention will either be charged or released at the end of their current terms, which typically last about six months. The plight of about 4,500 Palestinians held in Israeli jails is one of the most sensitive issues in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Because most Palestinian families have at least one member who has been arrested or detained, support for the prisoners is high. “They are freedom fighters for justice and dignity,” said Amjad Batta, 39, a financial manager in Ramallah.
In Israel, however, there is little sympathy for the prisoners, many of whom are accused of crimes against Israelis, including bombings and shootings.
Relatives of Palestinian prisoners held in Israel celebrate the signing of a deal by detainees Monday to end the 28-day hunger strike. A Palestinian official called it a victory.
Photograph credited Mahmud Hams/Getty-AFP. The byline foot gives edsanders@tribune.com.
· West Central Tribune
By David Little
David Little, reporting a talk given at Bethel Lutheran Church in Willmar, Minnesota, on 22 July. A church hall in rural Minnesota, and the phrase is Palestinian citizens of Israel.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis, MO
Two long-range Grad rockets struck Beersheba and two Kassam rockets landed in an open area in southern Israel, threatening a three-day truce. Israel’s Air Force also targeted and hit a rocket launching site and a squad preparing to fire a rocket toward southern Israel, the Israel Defense Forces said in a statement.
Schools were closed throughout Beersheba on Sunday following the early morning Grad attack. The rockets fell in an open area and caused no damage, according to reports. The Kassam rockets were fired late Saturday night and caused no damage.
In response, the IDF targeted the rocket launching site, killing one Hamas terrorist belonging to the organization’s military wing, the Al-Qassam Brigades, according to the Palestinian Ma’an news agency. The rocket fire comes three days after Egypt brokered an unofficial ceasefire between Israel and the Palestinians.
More than 70 rockets and mortars were fired last week from Gaza at southern Israeli communities. This year, more than 610 rockets fired from the Gaza Strip have hit Israel — more than 150 during in October alone — according to the IDF.
Also Sunday, Israel’s Cabinet unanimously approved full protection from rocket fire for all communities located up to 7 kilometers, or 4.3 miles, from the Gaza border, at a cost of about $70 million. Communities up to 5 kilometers, or 3 miles, previously were protected.
The one Palestinian killed is ‘one Hamas terrorist’ — unnamed, uncounted against the Israeli property damage, which is itemised (no damage, no damage, $70 million in protection). Sourced in part to the Palestinian Ma’an news agency, which is unusual for this paper’s briefs.
· Roanoke Times · Roanoke · page 1
Israel's military censor approved the release of the information, effectively amounting to acknowledgement of the kill.
Aron Heller, Associated Press, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — Israel acknowledged Thursday it killed the deputy of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat in a 1988 raid in Tunisia, lifting a nearly 25-year veil of secrecy and allowing a rare glimpse into the shadowy world of its secret operations. One of the commandos was disguised as a woman on a romantic vacation, and one of the weapons was hidden in a box of chocolates.
Khalil al-Wazir, who was better known by his nom de guerre Abu Jihad, founded Fatah, the dominant faction in the Palestinian Liberation Organization, with Arafat and was blamed for a series of deadly attacks against Israelis.
Two of those involved in the operation that killed al-Wazir now hold high political office in Israel — Defense Minister Ehud Barak and Vice Premier Moshe Yaalon. At the time, Barak was deputy military chief, and Yaalon was head of the elite commando unit Sayeret Matkal. Their precise roles in the operation were not divulged, and both men’s offices declined comment.
Israel has long been suspected of assassinating al-Wazir. But only now has the country’s military censor cleared the Yediot Ahronot daily to publish the information, including an interview with the commando who killed him, at least 12 years after the newspaper obtained the information. “I shot him with a long burst of fire.
I was careful not to hurt his wife, who had showed up there. He died,” commando Nahum Lev told Yediot prior to his death in a motorcycle wreck in 2000. “Abu Jihad was involved in horrible acts against civilians. He was a dead man walking. I shot him without hesitation.” Dozens of similar operations have been attributed to Israel over the decades.
But Israel rarely takes responsibility and typically does not comment about covert operations. Israeli officials did not openly confirm the operation. But the censor’s decision to allow publication, after years of stifling the account, amounted in effect to confirmation.
The military censor’s main task is to block publication of material deemed a threat to national security. Israel has a longstanding policy of preventing publication of any information that would expose agents, tactics and intelligence gathering methods or put anyone still alive who was involved in harm’s way.
In the al-Wazir case, though, it appears that after years of rumors and foreign reports claiming to expose the operation, along with the death of the triggerman, the censor’s office decided to drop its objection to publication… Another team killed a separate bodyguard and a gardener before entering the expansive villa.
Lev’s partner was the first to fire at the Palestinian leader. When Lev noticed al-Wazir reaching for a weapon, he shot and killed him. Other participants then “verified the kill” by shooting the body several more times before the forces retreated to sea and back to Israel, the Yediot report said. “I felt bad about the gardener,” Lev told Yediot.
“But in an operation such as this you have to make sure that any potential resistance is neutralized.” The Palestinians have long accused Israel of being behind the assassination. Abbas Zaki, a top official in Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas’ Fatah movement, said the Palestinians and Tunisia should now “work to bring Israel to justice.”
“Then-Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat (left) sits with his deputy, Khalil al-Wazir, who had long been wanted in a series of deadly attacks against Israeli civilians.” Associated Press / File.
A boxed sidebar headed “The target” records that at the time of his death al-Wazir was a main organizer of the first Palestinian uprising, which began in December 1987, four months before he was killed.
A killing confirmed twenty-four years later because a military censor allowed it to be printed. The gardener killed on the way in is mentioned twice and never named.
· Daytona Beach News-Journal · Daytona Beach
By Karin Laub, Associated Press
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — The image of a dead preschooler cradled by the prime ministers of Egypt and Gaza in a hospital hallway has drawn attention to the dangers Gaza’s children face in this crowded urban battle zone.
Children make up half of Gaza’s population of 1.6 million and seem to be everywhere in the current round of cross-border fighting between Israel and Gaza’s militant Hamas rulers. Children loitered Friday outside a Gaza City morgue for a glance at the latest “martyrs.”
Others followed adults to funerals or even rushed to the site where Israeli missiles had just struck a government building and fire was still smoldering. Despite outward bravado, young boys of elementary school age said quietly that fear of airstrikes kept them awake at night.
So far, six of 28 Palestinians killed in Israel’s offensive this week have been children, ranging in age from just under 1 to 14 years, according to Gaza health officials. Most were killed by shrapnel while in or near their homes. In Israel, 12 children were hurt in rocket attacks this week.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has accused Hamas of using Gaza’s civilians, particularly children, as human shields by launching rockets from crowded residential areas. Gazans argue that Israel is unleashing massive airstrikes on their territory without regard for civilians.
They say that even Israel’s self-described surgical strikes on militant targets put civilians at grave risk in Gaza, one of the world’s most densely populated places. Mahmoud Sadallah, the 4-year-old Gaza boy whose death moved Egypt’s prime minister to tears, was from the town of Jebaliya, close to Gaza City.
The boy died Friday in hotly disputed circumstances. The boy’s aunt, Hanan Sadallah, and his grief-stricken father Iyad — weak from crying and leaning on others to walk — said Mahmoud was killed in an Israeli airstrike. Hamas security officials also made that claim.
Israel vehemently denied involvement, saying it had not carried out any attacks in the area at the time. Gaza’s two leading human rights groups, which routinely investigate civilian deaths, withheld judgment, saying they were unable to reach the area because of continued danger.
Mahmoud’s family said the boy was in an alley close to his home when he was killed, along with a man of about 20, but no one appeared to have witnessed the strike. The area showed signs that a projectile might have exploded there, with shrapnel marks in the walls of surrounding homes and a shattered kitchen window.
But neighbors said local security officials quickly took what remained of the projectile, making it impossible to verify who fired it. Mahmoud’s 12-year-old cousin Fares was injured in the right leg by shrapnel and was still visibly shaken several hours after the incident. “It’s terrifying.
I don’t sleep at night,” the boy said of the massive Israeli air attacks of the past three days. “I’m staying up all night.” Mahmoud’s body was taken to Gaza City’s main Shifa hospital around midmorning, just as Gaza Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh of Hamas was showing Egyptian Prime Minister Hesham Kandil around the wards of patients.
One of the Sadallah’s neighbors, carrying the lifeless boy, pushed through a throng of Hamas security men to reach the politicians. Eventually, the two prime ministers were photographed cradling the child. Fighting back tears, Kandil called on Israel to halt its offensive.
A Palestinian man carries a child into the treatment room of Shifa hospital following an Israeli airstrike, in Gaza City on Friday. Fierce clashes between Israeli forces and Gaza militants continued for the third day.
Five members of one family are named in this dispatch: Mahmoud Sadallah, aged four; his aunt Hanan; his father Iyad, weak from crying and leaning on others to walk; his twelve-year-old cousin Fares, hit in the leg by shrapnel; and, by implication, the neighbor who carried the dead boy through a crowd of security men to reach two prime ministers. The reporter does not settle who killed him, and says so plainly: the family and Hamas say an Israeli airstrike, Israel denies carrying out any attack there, the two Palestinian human rights groups that investigate such deaths withheld judgment because they could not reach the area, and the remains of the projectile were removed by local security officials before anyone could examine them. Fares supplies the line a reader keeps: It’s terrifying. I don’t sleep at night. I’m staying up all night.
· Santa Barbara News-Press · Santa Barbara · page 1
“In the day’s deadliest violence, the Israeli navy fired at a home where it said a top wanted militant was hiding. The missile struck the home of the Daloo family in Gaza City, reducing the structure to rubble.
Frantic rescuers, bolstered by bulldozers, pulled the limp bodies of children from the ruins of the house, including a toddler and a 5-year-old, as survivors and bystanders screamed in grief. Later, the bodies of the children were laid out in the morgue of Gaza City’s Shifa Hospital.
Among the 11 dead were four small children and five women, including an 81-year-old, Gaza health official Ashraf al-Kidra said… Mr. Al-Kidra said 20 of 27 people killed Sunday were civilians, mostly women and children. Sami Abu Zuhri, a Hamas spokesman, said that ‘the Israeli people will pay the price’ for the killing of civilians.
Israel sought to place the blame on militants, saying they were intentionally operating in places inhabited by civilians… ‘Hamas is using the Gaza population as human shields,’ said Brig. Gen. Yoav Mordechai, the chief Israeli spokesman. ‘They are exploiting crowded residential urban areas.’
He acknowledged, however, that it was not clear whether the militant targeted in Sunday’s attack was killed, despite earlier claims of success. ‘I still don’t know what became of him,’ Gen.
Mordechai told Channel 10 TV… ‘In this case, you can’t avoid collateral damage if they position the rockets in densely populated areas, in mosques, school yards,’ said Israeli Vice Premier Moshe Yaalon. ‘We shouldn’t be blamed for the outcome.’
Avihai Mandelblit, a recently retired chief advocate general in the Israeli military, said that from a legal perspective, ‘there’s no immunity to anyone if you put weapons inside of civilian infrastructure.’ But he acknowledged the sight of dead civilians could create a public relations debacle for Israel.
‘As more civilians will get hurt, the legitimacy clock is going to click faster to end this operation,’ he said… ‘Israel has every right to expect that it does not have missiles fired into its territory,’ Mr. Obama said. Mr.
Hague also said Hamas ‘bears principal responsibility’ for initiating the violence, but made clear the diplomatic risks of an Israeli escalation.”
“An emergency rescue worker carries a child’s body following an Israeli airstrike in Gaza City, Sunday.” Associated Press
The headline is a quotation from the chief Israeli spokesman. Two paragraphs after he says it, the same spokesman says he does not know whether the man the strike was aimed at was killed.
· Times Record News · Wichita Falls
73 Palestinians have been killed in five-day attack
By Ibrahim Barzak and Josef Federman, Associated Press
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — An Israeli missile ripped through a two-story home in a residential area of Gaza City on Sunday, killing at least 11 civilians, including four young children and an 81-year-old woman, in the single deadliest attack of Israel's offensive against Islamic militants.
The bloodshed was likely to raise pressure on Israel to end the fighting, even as it pledged to intensify the offensive by striking the homes of wanted militants. High numbers of civilian casualties in an offensive four years ago led to fierce criticism and condemnation of Israel. In all, 73 Palestinians, including 37 civilians, have been killed in the five-day onslaught.
Three Israeli civilians have also died from Palestinian rocket fire. President Barack Obama said he was in touch with players across the region in hopes of halting the fighting, while also warning of the risks of Israel expanding its air assault into a ground war.
“We're going to have to see what kind of progress we can make in the next 24, 36, 48 hours,” Obama said during a visit in Thailand. On the ground, there were no signs of any letup in the fighting as Israel announced it was widening the offensive to target the military commanders of the ruling Hamas group.
The Israeli military carried out dozens of airstrikes throughout the day, and naval forces bombarded targets along Gaza's Mediterranean coast. Many of the attacks focused on homes where militant leaders or weapons were believed to be hidden.
Palestinian militants continued to barrage Israel with rockets, firing more than 100 on Sunday, and setting off air raid sirens across the southern part of the country. Some 40 rockets were intercepted by Israel's U.S.-financed “Iron Dome” rocket-defense system, including two that targeted the metropolis of Tel Aviv. At least 10 Israelis were wounded by shrapnel.
Israel's decision to step up its attacks in Gaza marked a new and risky phase of the operation, given the likelihood of civilian casualties in the densely populated territory of 1.6 million Palestinians. Israel launched the offensive Wednesday in what it said was an effort to end months of intensifying rocket fire from the Hamas-ruled Gaza Strip.
Palestinians run to take cover during an Israeli airstrike on a building in Gaza City on Sunday. The Israeli military widened its range of targets in the Gaza Strip to include the media operations of the Palestinian territory's Hamas rulers, sending its aircraft to attack two buildings used by both Hamas and foreign media outlets.
One World page carrying three stacked stories in this order: Israel strike kills 11 in Gaza; Israel city becomes ghost town (by Aron Heller, datelined Beersheba); Hamas links truce to Gaza blockade (by Karin Laub and Lauren E. Bohn).
· The Register-Guard · Eugene · page 1
Sterling Rand, Junction City
“Rae LaMarche’s Nov. 21 letter missed a few important events, such as an Israeli incursion into Gaza on Nov. 8 that left a 13-year-old Palestinian boy dead. On Nov, 14 Israeli forces launched dozens of strikes in Gaza, killing at least two Hamas members, including the head of Hamas’ military wing, Ahmed al-Jabari, and at least five civilians.
The strikes wounded at least 115 people, including 26 children and 25 women. There were serious efforts to calm the situation and reach a truce. But clearly Israel had another agenda. By targeting Ahmed al-Jabari, leader of the al-Qassam Brigade, it sabotaged Egyptian efforts to conclude a truce between all Palestinian factions and the Israelis.
That was confirmed by Egypt’s president on Nov. 17. In 2008 there was a peace treaty until Israel killed some Hamas leaders. How many incursions into Israel from Gaza in the last six years? How many from Israel into Gaza? LaMarche said, ‘Why do the Palestinians lose more than the Israelis?
Because Israelis hide their civilians in bomb shelters instead of hiding their bombs in civilian areas.’ Go to Gaza, the most densely populated place on Earth, and find a place where there are not civilians. LaMarche also said, ‘Israel has the right to defend itself.’ So do the Gazans. Don’t like indiscriminate bombing of civilians in Israel?
Give the Gazans better weapons so they will only strike military targets.”
One reader answering another by name, in the letters column, quoting her own words back to her.
· The Register-Guard · Eugene · page 1
John C. Frandsen, Auburn
“Writer offers facts on Gaza. Regarding the spate of letters concerning the conflict between Israel and Hamas, some of the authors appear to be ignorant of certain crucial facts. Israel did not ‘give’ the Gaza Strip to the Palestinians. Israel owns only the land it occupied before the 1967 war.
Additional land that it now claims was acquired through conquest, and is properly considered occupied territory according to international law.
Further and continuous expansion of ‘settlements’ into land held by non-Israelis for many centuries is fueled by what Roger Cohen (a Zionist) has called ‘a messianic Israeli nationalism claiming all the land between the Mediterranean and the Jordan River.’
The people of Gaza are locked into a literal prison, from which they can leave only with Israeli approval. The goods they produce can only leave Gaza with Israeli approval, and the outside-sourced supplies of all sorts, including food, necessary for life and civilization can enter only with Israeli approval.
Hence, Israel controls its fuel supplies and systematically denies entry into Gaza of construction materials that are needed to rebuild structures destroyed in Israeli attacks, as well as those substances requisite to maintaining potable water and the sanitary and safe disposal of human and industrial waste. Yes, Hamas’ violence against Israel is reprehensible.
Yet, imagine how Alabamians would behave if 2 million of them were confined by the federal government to a 100-square-mile, barricaded-off prison strip on the west coast of Mobile Bay. As in Gaza, the coast would be blockaded and residents barred from taking boats more than 3 miles from shore.
The federal government would control access to the strip, as Israel does to Gaza, and would not negotiate with the residents on any matter. After years of living thus, might some of the prisoners justifiably protest violently?”
A letter from Auburn, Alabama, arguing by local analogy: Mobile Bay as Gaza. It runs directly under an unrelated letter about Janet Napolitano.
· Citizens’ Voice
The mixed messages raised the question of whether Hamas might be trying to provoke the Israelis to break the cease-fire, or perhaps to establish new facts on the ground — farmers tilling the borderland, fishermen fishing farther out — that would increase its leverage in negotiations.
“Hamas is definitely trying to score points here,” said Mkhaimar Abusada, a political scientist at Al Azhar University in Gaza City. “Hamas is trying to say that the cease-fire is in the interest of Hamas and is in the interest of the Palestinians, that the cease-fire agreement is going to gradually put an end to the siege.”
Abusada noted that Mahmoud Zahar, a high-ranking Hamas leader, had told Arab-speaking reporters at a news conference that Gaza militants had shot down seven Israeli jets during the eight-day conflict, something Abusada called “a big lie.”
“We know this didn’t happen, so this is part of raising morale, part of playing with the emotions of Palestinians,” Abusada said, suggesting that the Hamas statement on fishermen and border zones had a similar purpose.
“It’s like waging psychological warfare on Israel, that Israel is giving in to the Palestinians, and also on the Palestinian side that Hamas won this war on all levels.”
Nizar Ayyash, the leader of the Gaza fishermen’s syndicate, said that after the Hamas statement, seven or eight large boats sailed out 6 miles into the sea on Saturday, encountering no resistance from Israeli gunboats that patrol the waters.
Ayyash said that even 6 miles out, the sea is too sandy, and that during sardine season, the best catch was about 15 nautical miles from the coast. “Any mile we gain is our right,” he added.
Hamas militants of the Izzedine al-Qassam Brigades attend the funeral of Hamas member Joudeh Shamallah in Gaza City on Saturday. According to family members, Shamallah was badly injured during the latest Israeli-Hamas fight and died from wounds Saturday. BERNAT ARMANGUE / ASSOCIATED PRESS
· Houston Chronicle · Houston · page A19
United Nations
Chicago Tribune
UNITED NATIONS — The U.N. General Assembly voted by a lopsided margin over U.S. and Israeli objections to grant Palestinians a new, enhanced status that acknowledges their cherished goal of statehood.
Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas won 138 of the assembly’s 193 votes Thursday — including those of some key European states — for his proposal to have the group’s standing upgraded to “nonmember observer state” from “nonmember observer entity.”
It was the use of the word “state” that was most important to Palestinians. Abbas argued that the designation would amount to international recognition of the statehood that Palestinians have not been able to win through decades of negotiation. But it may have little practical effect on their ability to achieve it.
All the same, Palestinians danced in the streets, honked horns, hugged and set off fireworks. “Today we are a state!” said Khalil Abdulsalam, 35, a government office worker in Ramallah, shouting to be heard over the celebrations. “Today we are a part of the international community and the rest of the world must see us as a state.” NEW AVENUES OPEN.
The new status opens the way for the Palestinians to press their interests through U.N. organizations, and some have suggested that they might use the International Criminal Court to fight Israeli settlements or accuse Israel of war crimes.
But it remains unclear how aggressively Abbas will embrace a strategy that risks devastating retaliation from the United States and Israel. The normally cautious Abbas laid out his plan with ringing declarations about the rights of Palestinians, but with little hint of how far he intends to go.
The assembly was being asked “to issue a birth certificate to the reality of the state of Palestine,” said Abbas, who received two standing ovations. The U.S. and Israel say that the Palestinians should achieve statehood only through direct negotiations with Israel, and consider the proposal a disruptive end-run around negotiations. TWO-YEAR BATTLE.
They were joined in voting against the proposal only by the Czech Republic, Canada, Panama, the Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Palau and Nauru. France, Spain, Italy and the Scandinavian countries were with the majority in the 138-9 vote. The United Kingdom, Germany and the Netherlands are among the 41 countries that abstained.
Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton said the U.N. had made an “unfortunate and counterproductive decision” that placed “new obstacles in the path of peace.” Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu angrily denounced Abbas’ speech as “defamatory and venomous.”
“Someone who wants peace does not talk in such a manner,” said a statement from Netanyahu’s office. “The way to peace between Jerusalem and Ramallah is in direct negotiations, without preconditions, and not in one-sided U.N. decisions. By going to the U.N., the Palestinians have violated the agreements with Israel and Israel will act accordingly.”
The U.S. and Israel have fought the proposal for two years, but they also don’t want the collapse of Abbas’ government because they would then be left to deal with the militant group Hamas, which they formally designate as a terrorist organization. FINANCIAL FALLOUT.
Israeli officials warned they would react strongly if Abbas moved, for example, to use the International Criminal Court against them. Israeli officials also said this week they might temporarily withhold tax revenue transfers to recoup about $180 million in unpaid electricity bills, but that more punitive steps would be postponed.
U.S. lawmakers have held up more than $200 million in aid to the authority because of questions about the U.N. proposal and Fatah’s possible reconciliation with Hamas.
Palestinian delegation members cheer as they surround Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, center, after the U.N. General Assembly voted to upgrade the Palestinian Authority’s status to ‘nonmember observer state.’
(Kathy Willens / Associated Press) · Surrounded by Palestinian flags, a Palestinian in Hebron chants slogans during a rally supporting the Palestinian U.N. bid for observer state status. (Nasser Shiyoukhi / Associated Press)
One hundred and thirty-eight countries out of a hundred and ninety-three vote to call Palestine a state, and the headline puts the word in quotation marks. The copy underneath is explicit that the word is the point: it was the use of the word ‘state’ that was most important to Palestinians. Abbas asks the assembly to issue a birth certificate to the reality of the state of Palestine and gets two standing ovations. The paper prints the quotation marks anyway. The one ordinary Palestinian quoted, a government clerk in Ramallah named Khalil Abdulsalam, 35, uses the word without them: ‘Today we are a state!… the rest of the world must see us as a state.’
· The Globe
Associated Press, Ramallah, West Bank
“Last week, his government press office urged journalists to refer to a state of Palestine, instead of the Palestinian Authority… In Washington, State Department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland expressed U.S. opposition to using the term ‘State of Palestine.’
‘You can’t create a state by rhetoric and with labels and names,’ she told reporters.”
A government press office instructing journalists what to call a place, and the United States objecting to the word. The mirror of Begin telling reporters the same thing in 1977. Quoted: Nour Odeh, spokeswoman for Abbas’ government; Omar Awadallah of the Foreign Ministry; the analyst Hani al-Masri; and Mark Regev.
· The Monitor · McAllen
State of Palestine’s new emblem shows limitations
Karin Laub and Mohammed Daraghmeh, The Associated Press
“Last week, his government press office urged journalists to refer to a state of Palestine, instead of the Palestinian Authority… ‘You can’t create a state by rhetoric and with labels and names,’ she told reporters.”
The same Associated Press story as the printing in The Globe, the same morning. The Globe ran the wire’s own summary as its headline. This paper kept that line as a second line and put a quotation from Romeo and Juliet above it — answering the question before the reader reaches the story, and landing on the same position the State Department takes inside the article. This printing also carries the byline, which includes a Palestinian reporter.
· The Star-Ledger · Newark, NJ
By Ian Deitch / ASSOCIATED PRESS
JERUSALEM — Palestinian protesters who pitched tents at a strategic West Bank site to protest plans to build a Jewish housing project there were evicted early today, police said. Palestinian activists erected tents in the area known as E-1 on Friday saying they wanted to “establish facts on the ground” to stop Israeli construction in the West Bank.
The Palestinian activists were borrowing a phrase and a tactic, usually associated with Jewish settlers, who believe establishing communities means the territory will remain theirs once structures are built. Spokesman Micky Rosenfeld said police evicted about a hundred protesters from the site early this morning after a court decision authorizing their removal.
He did not know which court had allowed the eviction. Haaretz reported that the eviction was carried out despite a temporary High Court injunction preventing it. Rosenfeld said no arrests were made during the half-hour operation and that no injuries were sustained on either side. He said the tents were not dismantled and that a decision on that would be made later in the day.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu yesterday evening ordered roads closed leading to the area and had the military declare a closed military zone and shut off access. Netanyahu’s office said the state was petitioning the Supreme Court to rescind an earlier injunction blocking the evacuation.
Israel announced it is moving forward with the E-1 settlement after the U.N. recognized a de facto state of Palestine in the West Bank, Gaza and east Jerusalem in November. Palestinians say E-1 would be a major blow to their statehood aspirations as it blocks east Jerusalem from its West Bank hinterland.
Palestinians are demanding these areas, along with Gaza, for their future state. Activists said they want to build a village called Bab Al Shams at the site. The construction plans drew unusually sharp criticism from some of Israel’s staunchest allies including the U.S. who strongly oppose the E-1 project.
Israeli officials have said actual construction on the project may be years away if it ever gets off the ground, while Israeli critics have questioned whether Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu actually intends to develop E-1, or is pandering to hard-liners ahead of Israel’s Jan. 22 election.
Worth keeping in the Bennett run as a contrast case even though Bennett is absent. The AP names the Palestinian tactic precisely and says in its own voice that it is borrowed from settlers who 'believe establishing communities means the territory will remain theirs once structures are built' - the clearest statement of the settlement method anywhere in batch B, and it appears in a story about Palestinians being removed. No Palestinian is quoted: the only named sources are an Israeli police spokesman, Haaretz and Netanyahu's office. Palestinian positions appear three times as 'Palestinians say' and 'Activists said'. 'Occupied' does not appear.
· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia · page 1
The Israeli prime minister vowed to press ahead with construction in a key area of the West Bank.
Joel Greenberg, Washington Post, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu promised Sunday to follow through with plans for settlement construction in a key West Bank area known as E-1 after police evicted scores of Palestinian protesters who had set up a tent camp there.
“We will complete the planning, and there will be construction,” Netanyahu told Army Radio hours after the eviction, but he cautioned that planning for the new development “will take time.”
Netanyahu, who is in the home stretch of an election campaign, moved swiftly against the Palestinian encampment, a new form of grass-roots protest modeled after scores of wildcat outposts set up by Jewish settlers on West Bank hills without government approval.
While many of those outposts remain in place, Netanyahu ordered the evacuation of the Palestinian camp — a cluster of about 20 tents that protesters called the village of “Bab al-Shams,” or Gate of the Sun — a day after it went up Friday.
It was cleared early Sunday after Israel’s Supreme Court overturned an injunction delaying the removal of the protesters, who had argued that they were on private Palestinian land. The court accepted the government’s argument that the continued presence of the protesters could lead to riots and that there was an urgent security need to remove them.
About 500 police officers moved into the area at 2:30 a.m. and evicted about 120 Palestinians, some of whom were carried off when they put up passive resistance, said Micky Rosenfeld, a police spokesman. He said there were no injuries during the hour-long operation.
But Abir Kopty, a spokeswoman for the protesters, said that some were punched in the face as they sat and resisted removal, and that six required hospital treatment. Pictures of men with facial injuries were distributed by protest organizers, known as the Popular Struggle Coordination Committee.
Mustafa Barghouti, a Palestinian legislator and political activist who was at the encampment when it was cleared, accused Israeli authorities of a double standard. “They are allowing more than 100 outposts to stay, illegal settlements by every standard of international law, while preventing people from being on land privately owned by Palestinians,” he said.
Israel’s advancement of plans to build in E-1, announced in November after Palestinians gained recognition as a nonmember observer state at the U.N., were condemned. The United States and European nations said the move would hurt prospects for a contiguous Palestinian state.
“Israeli police evict a Palestinian from an area known near Jerusalem known as E-1. Activists had erected tents in the area in an effort to prevent Israeli settlement construction.”
Nasser Shiyoukhi / Associated Press · “Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (front) and others visited the Israel Defense Forces Northern Command on Sunday, the day of the evacuation of Palestinians.” Kobi Gideon / Government Press Office via Getty
Palestinians using the settlers’ own method — putting up tents on a hill — and being removed within a day, with the comparison made in the story by a Palestinian legislator. The police account and the protesters’ account of injuries are both printed.
· Press of Atlantic City · Atlantic City
The United States ambassador says Palestine’s nonvoting member status does not give it statehood.
Peter J. Spielmann, Associated Press, United Nations
“U.S.
Ambassador Susan Rice objected Wednesday to the Palestinians’ latest bid to capitalize on their upgraded U.N. status when their foreign minister spoke at the Security Council while seated behind a nameplate that read ‘State of Palestine’… ‘Any reference to the ‘State of Palestine’ in the United Nations, including the use of the term ‘State of Palestine’ on the placard in the Security Council… do not reflect acquiescence that ‘Palestine’ is a state,’ she added.”
The naming argument reduced to an object on a table. Seventeen days after the State Department objected to the word on official stationery, an American ambassador objected to it on a nameplate, and the Associated Press printed the objection with the contested words in quotation marks four times in one sentence. Robert Serry of the UN explained that the placard said what it said because the Secretariat “is guided by the membership.”
· The Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe
“‘We are challenging our oppressors resiliently… rooted in what I call a culture of resistance.’… Palestinian citizens of Israel to full equality.”
Omar Barghouti, co-founder of the boycott movement, interviewed at length in the Santa Fe New Mexican. A named Palestinian given the space to set out his own argument, in a state the archive held two clippings from before this year.
· Columbia Daily Tribune · Columbia
Schoolbooks tend to ignore existence of opposing side.
JERUSALEM (AP) — Both Israeli and Palestinian schoolbooks largely present one-sided narratives of the conflict between the two peoples and tend to ignore the existence of the other side but rarely resort to demonization, a U.S. Department of State-funded study released today said.
The study by Israeli, Palestinian and American researchers, billed as setting a new scientific standard, tackled a fraught issue — Israeli claims Palestinians teach hatred of Israel and glorify violence in schoolbooks.
The research appeared to undermine these allegations, while emphasizing that books in secular Israeli government schools did far better in acknowledging the Palestinians than vice versa.
Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad welcomed the study as proof “there is no incitement in our text books,” while Israel’s Education Ministry dismissed the research as “biased, unprofessional and profoundly unobjective.” Underlying the textbook debate are mutual fears and suspicions.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu argues the conflict with the Palestinians is not over land but over Israel’s acceptance in the region and that peace is not possible until the alleged incitement stops.
Palestinians said Netanyahu hides behind such claims to divert attention from settlement building on occupied lands and from what they believe is his unwillingness to reach a peace deal on internationally backed terms.
The new study said the schoolbooks of both sides are typical for societies in conflict — though books used in Israeli state schools include significantly more information about Palestinians and more self-critical texts.
Books used in Israel’s ultra-Orthodox religious schools, attended by more than a quarter of Jewish students, and in Palestinian schools contain little information about the other side, the study said. Israelis criticize the ultra-Orthodox schools for failing to sufficiently teach secular subjects in general, such as mathematics and English.
“On both sides, the chief problem is the crime of omission. It’s the absence of a clear, outright recognition of existence and the other side’s right to exist,” said Gershon Baskin, an Israeli member of the study’s scientific advisory panel.
The study analyzed 74 Israeli and 94 Palestinian books, covering first through 12th grades and teaching social sciences, geography, literature, religion, Arabic and Hebrew. The Israeli books were from state-run secular and religious schools as well as independent ultra-Orthodox Jewish schools.
The vast majority of the Palestinian books were used in government schools and only six in private Islamic schools. Scholars said they developed a new method to ensure greater objectivity, as they reviewed nearly 16,000 pages from Israeli state school books, close to 3,500 pages from books in ultra-Orthodox schools and close to 10,000 pages from Palestinian books.
Israeli and Palestinian researchers were fluent in Hebrew and Arabic so they could analyze the books of both communities. Often, texts were reviewed by more than one person, and the data were entered remotely into a database at Yale University so researchers could not be influenced by how the study was progressing, study organizers said.
The study found that as part of the selective narratives, Israeli and Palestinian books tended to describe negative actions of the other against their own community, while portraying their own community in positive terms.
Palestinian students yesterday attend a class in a school in the West Bank city of Ramallah. A U.S.-funded study released today said Israeli and Palestinian schoolbooks present one-sided narratives of the conflict between the two peoples but rarely resort to demonization.
· Santa Barbara News-Press · Santa Barbara · page 1
McClatchy News Service, Tel Aviv
TEL AVIV, Israel — For more than a decade, Khaled Abdi and his uncle, Sami, have navigated the circuitous routes of the West Bank to get to low-paying construction jobs in central Israel. They’d wake at 3 a.m. to leave their homes near Nablus to catch one of Israel’s state-run buses, which also ferried Israeli settlers.
It was a rare point of interaction between the two communities, whose members often live near one another but are on opposite sides of one of the region’s most deeply entrenched conflicts. But that rare interaction may be about to come to an end.
On Monday, Israel’s Transportation Ministry opened up a new bus system in the West Bank that Palestinian officials say is intended to separate Jews and Arabs. Palestinian officials call it “blatant racism.” Israeli officials call it simply providing better service to the tens of thousands of Palestinians who commute daily to their jobs in Israel.
“It is yet another rung in the ladder that Israel is slowly climbing until all the world will call it an apartheid state,” said one Palestinian official, who asked not to be quoted by name because he was not authorized to speak publicly until Palestinian officials determine whether they will launch a formal complaint.
In a statement, Israel’s Transportation Ministry denied that the new bus line constituted discrimination. “The Transportation Ministry is forbidden from preventing any passenger from boarding any line of public transportation nor do we know of a directive to that effect,” a ministry statement said.
“The new lines are not separate lines for Palestinians but rather two designated lines meant to improve the services offered to Palestinian workers who enter Israel.” In practice, however, there were signs that at a minimum Palestinians would be actively encouraged to use the new line and discouraged from using the old bus lines, which continue to run.
One Palestinian construction worker who chose to take the old line Monday said that he was forced to get off the bus at checkpoints and was subjected to extra security checks despite having all the paperwork to work legally in Israel. He asked not to be named because of the controversy involved.
Other accounts have cited Israeli bus drivers as saying that Palestinians would be limited to the “Arab-only” bus. “There will be checks at the checkpoint, and Palestinians will be asked to board their own buses,” the Israeli website Ynet quoted one unidentified bus driver as saying… Khaled Abdi was skeptical.
“They say that in the future it will go other places, but we have no guarantee,” he said. Fuad Maloof, a 32-year-old construction worker from the town of Qalqilya, said that he doesn’t mind the new line, as long as Israel expands the service.
He said he was grateful that the new bus line was half the price of the illegal mini-buses he used to ride from his home to central Israel. “I can save money, as long as this bus comes more regularly and there is room for everyone,” he said. He acknowledged the service made him feel unwelcomed.
“It is not a good feeling that the Jews don’t want us on the same bus,” he said… But Sari Bashi, the executive director of Gisha, a group that advocates lifting Israel’s restrictions on the Palestinian territories, said the buses were another example of a “dual system of rights for Israelis and Palestinians.”
“These settlers and Israeli citizens apparently feel safe enough to allow Palestinians to build their homes and clear their land, so it’s unclear why they can’t ride the same buses,” she said… In any case, Sami Abdi said he and his nephew will catch the new bus. “Really, what choice do we have?” he asked.
“Israel creates the system and we live in it. We need these jobs, so we will use whatever bus they tell us to.”
“Palestinian laborers board a Palestinian-only bus en route to the West Bank from Tel Aviv, Israel, Monday. The Palestinian-only bus lines have been condemned by critics as racism and hailed by Israel as a goodwill gesture created to solve the messy situation created by 45 years of conflicting ideals.” Associated Press
Three ordinary Palestinian workers named and quoted, and they do not agree with each other. The ministry’s denial is printed in full beside them.
· The Recorder · Greenfield
Open your eyes beyond official narrative
Yael Petretti
A My Turn column in Greenfield, Massachusetts. The writer is an Israeli citizen, and the question is addressed to Americans.
· St. Cloud Times · St. Cloud
US president calls on Israel to offer help so it also can become secure
RAMALLAH, West Bank—President Barack Obama told Palestinians they “deserve an end to occupation” and an “independent state of their own,” during a visit Thursday to a territory that Palestinians want as a nation.
Back in Israel, Obama said the Jewish state is at a crossroads and must help create an independent Palestinian state for the secure future of Israel. He said Israel could not expect to remain safe without peace because “extremists” thrive on conflict.
“It is not fair that a Palestinian child cannot grow up in a state of their own,” he told hundreds of Israeli students in a speech. “Palestinians have a right to be free people in their own land.”
After a two-hour visit with Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, Obama asserted that the borders for a Palestinian state can only be settled through negotiations with Israel. West Bank visit Hoping to move the Middle East peace process forward, Obama flew by helicopter Thursday the short distance from Jerusalem to Ramallah, the seat of Palestinian government.
He was met by Abbas, Prime Minister Salam Fayyad and Saeb Erekat, the Palestinians’ longtime peace negotiator. It is the first time Obama has been to the West Bank as president, a territory conferred limited state status by the United Nations last November.
But he may have difficulty satisfying the demands of Palestinian Authority leaders who want him to pressure Israel into agreeing to Palestinian demands for an independent state.
Protests In a news conference with Obama on Thursday, Abbas said peace was “possible” and “necessary,” but he also said it would not be achieved through wars and settlements — or through violence. He said the people of Palestine aspire to their rights.
Obama said “the only way to achieve that was through direct negotiations between Israelis and Palestinians themselves.” He said it was important not to give up on the search for peace.
Palestinian protesters complained that Obama has done little to pressure Israel to cave on the issues that have led to a stalemate, such as where to draw the borders for the new state and which Jewish communities in the West Bank, known as settlements, should be made part of Israel proper.
Around 150 demonstrators chanted anti-American slogans, and signs they held said they wanted weapons, not diplomatic visits.
A Jordanian protester holds a placard that reads “America is the head of terrorism” in Arabic during a protest against U.S. President Barack Obama’s Middle East visit Thursday near the Israeli Embassy in Amman, Jordan. RAAD ADAYLEH/AP
· Courier Post · Camden · page 8A
He calls on Israel to help so it can be secure, too
By Vanessa O’Brien and Michele Chabin, USA Today
RAMALLAH, West Bank — President Barack Obama told Palestinians they “deserve an end to occupation” and an “independent state of their own,” during a visit Thursday to a territory that Palestinians want as a nation.
Back in Israel, Obama said the Jewish state is at a crossroads and must help create an independent Palestinian state for the secure future of Israel. He said Israel could not expect to remain safe without peace because “extremists” thrive on conflict.
“It is not fair that a Palestinian child cannot grow up in a state of their own,” he told hundreds of Israeli students in a speech. “Palestinians have a right to be free people in their own land.”
After a two-hour visit with Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, Obama asserted that the borders for a Palestinian state can only be settled through negotiations with Israel. His visit was greeted by small protests and rockets fired by Palestinian terrorists from Gaza into Israel. The rockets landed in a town in southern Israel but did not cause any injuries.
Hoping to move the Middle East peace process forward, Obama flew by helicopter Thursday the short distance from Jerusalem to Ramallah, the seat of Palestinian government. He was met by Abbas, Prime Minister Salam Fayyad and Saeb Erekat, the Palestinians’ longtime peace negotiator.
It is the first time since being elected president that Obama has been to the West Bank, a territory conferred limited state status by the United Nations in November.
President Barack Obama speaks Thursday at the International Convention Center in Jerusalem. He says Israel must help create an independent Palestinian state.
· Honolulu Star-Advertiser · Honolulu
‘Right to exist’ is two-way street, he says
JERUSALEM President Obama called on Israeli students Thursday to promote peace with Palestinians. “Only you can determine what kind of democracy you will have,” Obama told several hundred diverse students — Jews, Muslims and Christians — in a speech given in a Jerusalem convention center.
He called on them to remember that when they make those decisions, they “will define the future of Israel as well.” Obama said the only way for Israelis and Palestinians to achieve peace is through negotiations. He tried to reassure the Israelis that the U.S.-Israeli bond is strong enough for Israelis to take risks for peace.
Obama noted that Israelis “live in a neighborhood where many of your neighbors have rejected your right to exist. Your parents lived through war after war to ensure the survival of the Jewish state. Your children grow up knowing that people they have never met hate them because of who they are, in a region that is changing underneath your feet.”
At the same time, the president told them, “the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination and justice must be recognized” not only for the sake of the Palestinians, but to bring peace to Israel. He asked the students to put themselves in the Palestinians’ shoes, to “look at the world through their eyes.”
He added: “It is not fair that a Palestinian child cannot grow up in a state of her own, and lives with the presence of a foreign army that controls the movements of her parents every single day.” The president also addressed the United States’ bond with Israel, noting the security relationship between the two nations has “never been stronger.”
Reiterating that Israel has a “right to defend itself,” Obama called on Hamas to renounce violence, and affirmed the U.S. stance that Hezbollah is “a terrorist organization.”
President Obama and Israeli President Shimon Peres raise glasses in a toast after Peres awarded Obama the Israeli Medal of Distinction.
· The Record · Hackensack
“You can be the generation that permanently secures the Zionist dream, or you can face a growing challenge to its future,” he said. “The only way to truly protect the Israeli people is through the absence of war, because no wall is high enough, and no Iron Dome is strong enough, to stop every enemy from inflicting harm.”
The president pointed to the Jewish people’s own history of slavery and genocide, and asked the crowd to consider the plight of neighboring Palestinians, who live under military occupation, can’t move freely and have no country to call their own. “Put yourself in their shoes, look at the world through their eyes,” he said.
“Just as Israelis built a state in their homeland, Palestinians have a right to be a free people in their own land.” Thursday’s speech hinted at a shift in tactics on the issue of construction of Israeli settlements. In Obama’s first term, “he went in with guns blazing,” said Zvika Krieger, senior vice president at the S.
Daniel Abraham Center for Mideast Peace in Washington. “But that didn’t work. This time his approach is, ‘Let’s hear the parties out.’ That’s smart.” It was a rousing, well-received address reminiscent of Obama’s campaign speeches.
“You must create the change that you want to see,” he told more than 1,000 students, many of whom won coveted tickets to attend through lotteries. But it was a speech that focused on shared dreams rather than thorny details, which are what have crippled the peace process for years.
Though Israeli government officials were probably relieved that Obama announced no new conditions or demands, the lack of specific initiatives or policy frameworks left questions about whether it was enough to nudge the peace process ahead.
Some likened the address to Obama’s 2009 speech in Cairo, when the president called for a new relationship between the United States and the Muslim world. That landmark speech left many Israelis with the impression that Obama was trying to distance himself from Israel.
The visit this week, and particularly the speech, were seen as attempts to change that view and assure Israelis of U.S. support. “It was good to hear of his support for Israel. That means a lot,” said Yocheved Loewenstern, 22, a neuroscience student who was in the audience. “But if you ask any kid in Israel, they’ll say they want peace.
The problem is, it’s hard to make peace with a country that doesn’t recognize your rights to be here.” The speech may signal that Obama is preparing to renew an American-led peace initiative, despite the administration’s attempts to lower expectations of his trip.
He recently appointed a new Mideast envoy, and newly installed Secretary of State John Kerry is expected to return to the region Saturday. “He’s showed an American political will,” said Ziad Asali, president of the American Task Force on Palestine, an advocacy group in Washington.
Obama made a concerted effort in his first term to tackle the conflict, appointing a special envoy, pushing Israel to temporarily freeze some settlement construction and pressing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to publicly endorse the concept of a Palestinian state, something no leader of the conservative Likud Party had ever done.
But after encountering resistance and defiance from both sides, Obama withdrew to the sidelines, and some questioned whether he had the passion to try again. Caution on both sides Skeptical Israelis suspect that Obama’s kind words may soon be followed by sharper demands.
“Is this a different tactic in which someone has smeared honey on a plastic spoon that will one day turn back into a sharp knife?” wondered Maariv newspaper columnist Shalom Yerushalmi. Stark differences remain between Israelis and Palestinians, suggesting that even if talks resume, results will be hard to achieve.
During a visit earlier Thursday to the Palestinian Authority’s headquarters in Ramallah, in the West Bank, Obama voiced empathy with Palestinians living under Israeli occupation and reasserted the U.S. commitment to helping them obtain a state. “The Palestinian people deserve an end to occupation and the daily indignities that come with it,” Obama said.
But he said both sides need to set aside old entrenched positions and “think anew.” Most Palestinians are wary of Obama, saying he has failed to make much progress. Some activists protested, burning American flags and defacing posters of the U.S. president.
But after meeting with Obama, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas said at a news conference that he had renewed confidence that the administration would intensify efforts to kick-start the peace process. Neither leader announced any specific agreements or steps.
Abbas told Obama that before negotiations can resume, Israel must halt settlement construction, which the international community views as illegal. Obama, however, has toned down his language on settlements, which he described in 2009 as illegitimate.
On Thursday, he said they were not “constructive” or “appropriate,” and he seemed to endorse the Israeli position that the issue should not be used as a precondition for renewed talks.
Worried that Netanyahu might again face pressure from Obama to freeze settlement construction, right-wing Israeli politicians are already warning the prime minister against such a step. Jewish Home party leader Naftali Bennett, a key member of Netanyahu’s new coalition, said he would withdraw from the government if another freeze was called.
“Israel’s position is very clear and I am glad to see the American position moving closer to it too,” said Israel’s deputy foreign minister, Zeev Elkin. Shortly before the president’s trip to the West Bank, Gaza Strip militants fired two rockets at the southern Israeli city of Sderot.
The strikes, which caused damage but no injuries, broke a cease-fire agreement that has largely held since November between Israel and Hamas, the Islamist militant group that controls Gaza. Obama condemned the attack and criticized Hamas for refusing to renounce violence.
“Hamas cares more about enforcing its own rigid dogmas than allowing Palestinians to live freely,” he said. “Too often it focuses on tearing Israel down, rather than building Palestine up.” This article contains material from The Associated Press
President Obama with Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas as they headed for a meeting Thursday in Ramallah. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in a discussion with President Obama during a state dinner in Jerusalem.
Filed as The Recorder; the page prints The Record. Folio line at the top left of the page, cropped at 16x, reads 'A-6 THE RECORD' above a heavy rule, with the section slug 'FROM PAGE ONE' centred at the top right. The paper name transcribes character for character as THE RECORD (no trailing 'er'); the filed pub is 'The Recorder'.
· The Tennessean · Nashville
U.S. president calls on Israel to help process
RAMALLAH, West Bank — President Barack Obama told Palestinians they “deserve an end to occupation” and an “independent state of their own,” during a visit Thursday to a territory that Palestinians want as a nation.
Back in Israel, Obama said the Jewish state is at a crossroads and must help create an independent Palestinian state for the secure future of Israel. He said Israel could not expect to remain safe without peace because “extremists” thrive on conflict.
“It is not fair that a Palestinian child cannot grow up in a state of their own,” he told hundreds of Israeli students in a speech. “Palestinians have a right to be free people in their own land.”
After a two-hour visit with Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, Obama asserted that the borders for a Palestinian state can only be settled through negotiations with Israel. West Bank visit Hoping to move the Middle East peace process forward, Obama flew by helicopter Thursday the short distance from Jerusalem to Ramallah, the seat of Palestinian government.
He was met by Abbas, Prime Minister Salam Fayyad and Saeb Erekat, the Palestinians’ longtime peace negotiator. It is the first time Obama has been to the West Bank as president, a territory conferred limited state status by the United Nations last November.
But he may have difficulty satisfying the demands of Palestinian Authority leaders who want him to pressure Israel into agreeing to Palestinian demands for an independent state.
Protests In a news conference held with Obama on Thursday, Abbas said peace was “possible” and “necessary,” but he also said it would not be achieved through wars and settlements — or through violence. He said the people of Palestine aspire to their rights.
U.S. President Barack Obama and Israeli President Shimon Peres toast after Obama received the Israeli Medal of Distinction during a state dinner in Jerusalem. AP
Filed as The Recorder; the page prints The Tennessean. Folio / running-head line across the top of the page, cropped at 8x and the right end again at 16x, reads: '6A - FRIDAY, MARCH 22, 2013' at the left, section head 'WORLD' centred, and the paper name at the right, which transcribes character for character as 'THE TENNESSEAN'. The filed pub is 'The Recorder', which is a different title.
· Monroe Evening News · Monroe
FROM THE ARAB NEWS (JEDDAH, SAUDIA ARABIA)
The Monroe Evening News reprints a Saudi paper's editorial, with a standing disclaimer that commentaries from other newspapers do not necessarily reflect its board's views.
· Santa Barbara News-Press · Santa Barbara · page 1
The Associated Press
“‘We don’t have unrealistic expectations. We know the immensity of obstacles,’ said Hanan Ashrawi, a senior Palestinian official. ‘If it doesn’t work, of course we have our own plans.’… Mr. Mustafa said the Palestinian economy is in a dire state, with the government $3 billion in debt and unemployment at 23 percent.
Among Palestinians ages 20 to 24, the unemployment rate is 40 percent. ‘We can’t continue like this,’ he said. ‘We need an urgent solution.’
The Palestinians have long complained that Israeli control over the West Bank has stifled their economy with military checkpoints, travel restrictions and limits on development… ‘Kerry’s plan should be a comprehensive one, not just economic and confidence-building measures and security, but also political and legal,’ Mr. Ashrawi said.”
Secretary of State John Kerry speaks during a joint news conference with his Jordanian counterpart, Nasser Judeh, not pictured, in Amman on Wednesday. Associated Press.
· The Grand Rapids Press · Grand Rapids · page 1
Holy Land archaeological treasure hurt by politics
Daniela Berretta, The Associated Press, Sebastia
SEBASTIA, West Bank — The ancient town of Sebastia is one of the major archaeological sites of the Holy Land, with its overlapping layers of history dating back nearly 3,000 years. But today the hilltop capital of biblical kings, later ruled by Roman conquerors, Crusaders and Ottomans, is marred with weeds, graffiti and garbage.
Caught between conflicting Israeli and Palestinian jurisdictions, the site has been largely neglected for the past two decades. Beyond the decay, unauthorized diggers and thieves have taken advantage of the lack of oversight to make off with priceless artifacts.
“You can learn the history of the whole region (by) staying here because all the powers that crossed the region since the time of the Egyptians were passing through,” said Carla Benelli, an art historian who has been working on restoration projects in parts of the site, financed in part by the Italian government.
“From this point of view, it’s really important.” But the site needs basic maintenance, protection and cleaning, she said. “There is no one who is doing this here in Sebastia. It will not last forever in this way.”… “Sebastia, the archaeological site, is abandoned without any control from 2000.
It’s 13 years,” said Osama Hamdan, a Palestinian architect who has coordinated the restoration works of Crusader-era buildings with Benelli. “In this period, Sebastia is suffering a lot because a lot of illegal excavations have happened in this area. A lot of destruction of cultural heritage in this area has happened,” he said.
Statues, vases, coins and glasses all have been taken by looters, he said… With the help of international donors, the Palestinian Tourism and Antiquities Ministry has built an “interpretation center” near the Roman forum at the foot of the hill, which Taha said will provide services to visitors.
It is expected to open in the coming months… Hafez Kaye, a local shop and restaurant owner, said that after a difficult decade, business has begun to pick up over the past three years. “Slowly, slowly it’s coming back.”
An archaeology story headlined “Caught in the conflict.” A shopkeeper’s cautious hope is the last line of it. A second photograph on the page shows a bakery called Damashki, The Guy From Damascus, co-owned by a Palestinian born in Syria who fled and arrived in Gaza two months before.
· estimated · Omaha World-Herald · Omaha · page 1
Though the sides have returned to the table, many hurdles await them.
The Associated Press, Jerusalem
“That’s because Israel proper, within its recognized pre-1967 borders, contains some 6 million Jews and almost 2 million Arab citizens. In the West Bank, Gaza and east Jerusalem are almost 4 million Palestinians.
If Israel does not settle its borders, this argument runs, it may find itself awash in an Arab majority that cannot forever be denied full democratic rights…
Refugees. The Palestinians demand that Israel recognize a ‘right of return’ for Palestinian refugees, defined as more than 700,000 people who fled or were driven from their homes in what is now Israel. Plus their millions of descendants…
Prisoners. Israel holds nearly 5,000 Palestinians for alleged crimes ranging from stone-throwing to deadly attacks. Dozens of them are being held without charges or trial.”
U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry sits with Israeli President Shimon Peres, left, and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas earlier this year. The Associated Press.
A wire explainer laying out each issue in turn. Fled or were driven from their homes is the Associated Press’s own formula for 1948.
· Park City Daily News · page 1
Karin Laub and Mohammed Daraghmeh, The Associated Press, Gaza City
“In April 1993, Omar Masoud and three accomplices broke into a European aid office in Gaza City, grabbed a young Israeli lawyer working there and stabbed him to death. Israel arrested Masoud a month later and sentenced him to life… Now Masoud, along with dozens of other long-term Palestinian prisoners, is up for release as part of U.S.
Secretary of State John Kerry’s attempt to restart Israeli-Palestinian talks after five years of diplomatic paralysis… The fate of those held in Israeli jails is an emotionally wrought issue for Palestinians, who view the prisoners as heroes who made personal sacrifices in the struggle for statehood… Israelis tend to view the prisoners as cold-blooded terrorists… In a statement late Saturday, Netanyahu said that a decision to release prisoners is ‘painful to the bereaved families, painful to the people of Israel and very painful for me.’… As of late June, nearly 5,000 Palestinians were being held by Israel.
Masoud’s mother, 70-year-old Tamam, said she is optimistic. ‘I hope everything will work out between Jews and Arabs,’ she said, speaking in her shack in the Shati refugee camp.”
Tamam Masoud, 70, mother of Omar Masoud, 40, who was arrested in May 1993 for killing an Israeli lawyer, laughs Friday during an interview as she sits with her son Abdalrahman, 28, and grandson Yousef, 3, at her house at Shati Refugee Camp in Gaza City. Adel Hana/AP.
Four ordinary Palestinians named in one photograph, three generations of them, and both views of the prisoners set out in the same column.
· The News Tribune · Tacoma · page 1
Karin Laub and Mohammed Daraghmeh, The Associated Press, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — Israel approved building almost 1,200 more settlement homes Sunday and agreed to release 26 long-held Palestinian security prisoners — highlighting an apparent settlements-for-prisoners trade-off that got both sides back to peace talks after a five-year freeze.
Yet concerns were mounting, especially among Palestinians, that the price is too steep… In Israel, the most vocal protests came from relatives of those killed in attacks carried out by Palestinians slated for release… “Why are we releasing butchers now?
What for?” asked Gila Molcho, whose brother, lawyer Ian Feinberg, was stabbed to death by Palestinians who broke into a European aid office in Gaza City in 1993… In all, Israel has built dozens of settlements since 1967 that now are home to some 560,000 Israelis… Fourteen prisoners will be released to Gaza and 12 to the West Bank, according to a government statement.
Eight of the prisoners had three years left to serve, and two would have been released in six months or less, the statement said. Meanwhile, Israeli Housing Minister Uri Ariel announced Sunday that he has given final approval for the construction of 1,187 apartments in settlements.
Settlements and prisoners announced on the same Sunday, and the wire counts both.
· Chicago Tribune · Chicago · page 1
Jeffrey Heller, Reuters, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — Israel named 26 Palestinians on Monday it will free from jail this week under a deal enabling U.S.-backed peace talks to resume.
But the good will gesture was clouded by new plans to expand Israeli settlements that the United Nations and European Union condemned as illegal and that the Palestinians said were aimed at provoking them to pull out of the negotiations… “Those who do these things are determined to undermine the peace negotiations, are determined to force people like us to leave the negotiating table,” Palestinian chief negotiator Saeb Erekat said… Eduardo del Buey, spokesman for U.N.
Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, said: “Settlements in the occupied territories are illegal, they have been and continue to be illegal.” Mark Regev, a spokesman for Netanyahu, said the new construction would take place in areas that Israel intends to keep in any peace agreement. “This in no way changes the final map of peace. It changes nothing,” he said.
Some 500,000 Israeli settlers live in the West Bank and East Jerusalem amid 2.5 million Palestinians.
The mother, left, of Palestinian inmate Ateya Abu Moussa, pictured in poster and held by Israel for years, reacts Monday with her sister after hearing news of his expected release. Ibraheem Abu Mustafa / Reuters photo.
The prisoner is named in the caption. His mother, who is the photograph, is not.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis, MO · page 6
JERUSALEM — Roger Waters assailed actress Scarlett Johansson for working with SodaStream and musician Neil Young for his planned performance in Israel. In a Facebook post on Saturday, the former Pink Floyd frontman said he was making a public plea to Johansson and Young after writing to them privately in recent days.
Waters has publicly called for boycotts against Israel and made personal pleas to artists not to perform in Israel. Young is scheduled to perform in Israel in July. Johansson last week ended her relationship with the human rights group Oxfam following a protracted debate over her role as spokeswoman for the Israeli company SodaStream, which has a factory in the West Bank.
The factory employs Israeli and Palestinian workers.
In his public letter, Waters said Johansson’s “choice of SodaStream over Oxfam” is “an act of intellectual, political, and civil about face, that we, all those of us who care about the downtrodden, the oppressed, the occupied, the second class, will find it hard to rationalize.”The letter cites alleged human rights abuses by Israel against the Bedouin in southern Israel and poses questions about how Palestinians live under Israeli rule in the West Bank.
He concludes his letter, which mostly is directed at Johansson, by saying, “Scarlett, you are undeniably cute, but if you think SodaStream is building bridges towards peace you are also undeniably not paying attention.” In August, Waters published an open letter calling on fellow musicians to join a boycott of Israel.
He also recently came under fire for using at his concerts a huge inflated balloon in the shape of a wild boar with a prominently visible Star of David, among other symbols, including a dollar sign and a hammer and sickle. He has used the gimmick for several years.
Meanwhile, Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Liberman wrote in a Facebook post on Saturday night that “Our Oscar goes to Scarlett” for her “brave stand against immoral hypocrites.”
The whole West Bank question is handled in two clauses: ‘which has a factory in the West Bank. The factory employs Israeli and Palestinian workers.’ No Palestinian worker at Maale Adumim is quoted; no Bedouin is quoted; the human rights claims are ‘alleged.’ Also printed: SodaStream CEO Daniel Birnbaum said the Israeli government had reneged on a deal to provide millions in aid to expand its Negev factory within the 1967 borders, so the company would scale back that expansion and ‘will not abandon its West Bank factory in Maale Adumim, which employs Israelis and Palestinians.’
· The Sentinel · Carlisle
Palestinian women are majority of students in many colleges in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, but often have trouble transitioning into the job market
By Karin Laub, Associated Press
DURA, West Bank — Growing up in a traditional society, Abeer Abu Ghaith was often told a woman's future is in her husband's kitchen. Quietly, the 29-year-old proved everyone wrong. Abu Ghaith has become the first female high-tech entrepreneur in the West Bank, setting up an Internet employment brokerage and software development firm.
Last month, the Palestinian trailblazer was recognized by regional high-tech leaders as a recipient of the Women in Technology Awards in the Middle East and Africa for 2014. Abu Ghaith has put in 16-hour days, showing how the local IT and communications sector can transform the lives of other women by giving them access to jobs and financial independence.
Some say the sector, the most vibrant in an otherwise stagnant economy, could double in size over the next five years and employ thousands more. Palestinian women already make up a majority of students in many colleges and universities in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, but often have trouble transitioning into the job market.
After they graduate, the traditional gender expectations usually kick in — that they should get married first and worry about a career later. Those determined to work face a tough job market with double-digit unemployment and employers who often prefer male applicants still seen as the main breadwinners.
Job choices are further constricted by family concerns that a young woman's reputation could be tarnished if she returns home late from work or has to travel for the job. Only about 20 percent Palestinian women work outside the home, compared to nearly 70 percent of men, according to the International Labor Organization.
“Palestinian women face a lot of challenges,” said Abu Ghaith, the second-oldest of nine brothers and sisters, speaking at her family home in the town of Dura, one of the most conservative areas of the West Bank. “We have plenty of qualified women in my area who have no access to jobs.”
Abu Ghaith graduated from the Polytechnic University in the nearby city of Hebron in 2007 and still works for her alma mater as a career counselor for IT students.
Last year, she set up her company, StayLinked, which serves as a talent broker between Palestinian freelancers and businesses in need of services, such as translation, data entry, graphic design, online marketing and website development. Customers include companies in the U.S. and in Gulf countries, she said.
Abu Ghaith has three business partners, including a female friend, a male expert in IT training and a company that offered advice in the early stages. The two women pooled their savings to contribute to $30,000 in startup costs and control 70 percent of the business.
So far, StayLinked has generated several thousand dollars in business — Abu Ghaith won't say exactly how much — and has provided paid employment for about 40 freelancers, half of them women.
Abeer Abu Ghaith, 29, third from left, the first female high-tech entrepreneur in the West Bank, talks to other Palestinian women in the village of Dura. Abu Ghaith set up an Internet employment brokerage and software development firm and has been relentless in the pursuit of her goals.
Printed on the World page.
· Star Tribune · Minneapolis · page 1
Hany Abu-Assad’s Oscar-nominated thriller ‘Omar’ is set in the occupied West Bank but has themes of love and betrayal that are timeless.
Colin Covert
“Two-time Oscar nominee Hany Abu-Assad is used to making films that generate international attention, praise and debate… His Oscar-nominated ‘Omar’ opening Friday at the Edina Cinema, also deals with the anti-Israeli insurgency, but its scope is broader and its story deeper. A propulsive thriller and a romance, it follows Omar’s courtship of a young woman, Nadia, and how their affair evolves after he’s arrested by the Shin Bet intelligence service.… He freely admits incorporating notions from ‘Romeo and Juliet’ in the young lovers’ courtship, and ‘Othello’ in the hero’s growing jealousy. ‘“Omar” is a tragic love story about a lover who makes a bad choice,’ he said.
‘These themes are stronger than life. Shakespeare died, but his stories are still in history because they are about themes that are bigger than us.’ Insecurity makes you fall in love, Abu-Assad said, as you become dependent on your lover for happiness. Insecurity also kills the love, he said, because it’s unattractive.
‘I felt it is “Othello” and I tried to reinterpret it in a different time.’ ‘Good drama is always based on conflict between desires and duty,’ Abu-Assad said. ‘Omar’s conflict is between his desire for Nadia and his duty to his people, his country.
All the characters,’ including a tough but fallible Israeli intelligence officer, ‘are torn by the good and bad in them.’… As far as Israeli officials were concerned, he met no resistance whatsoever. ‘Maybe they think I am nothing, why should they interfere with me?’ he said.
‘Israelis are humans who do these jobs in censorship or the secret service who could make your life uneasy. They’re not like evil, they’re people. I think they decided not to make my life difficult because someone will ask me how difficult it was and if I had many bad stories, they would be in a bad light.
Now I have no bad stories.’ ‘They are very happy,’ he said with a chuckle, adding, ‘I am happy, too, by the way.’”
“Adam Bakri as Omar and Leem Lubany as Nadia in ‘Omar.’” and “Oscar-nominated director Hany Abu-Assad, 51, had a boyhood love of movies but became an engineer. Returning to his passion, he made his first feature, a romantic comedy, in 1998.”
A Palestinian director explaining his thriller through Romeo and Juliet and Othello, and saying the themes are bigger than the place. He also describes the Israeli security services declining to obstruct him, and works out aloud why: if they made trouble, someone would ask him about it. His age is given here as 51 and as 52 in the Los Angeles Times three weeks later.
· The Oregonian · Portland · page 1
Marc Mohan, Special to The Oregonian
“As only the second Palestinian submission to be nominated for an Academy Award, and with a story set amid the conflict over the Occupied Territories, it’s not surprising that ‘Omar’ is a volatile film. But it’s not a specifically political one.
With only superficial alteration, it could be set in Cold War Berlin, or colonial Boston, or any time and place where the dynamics of power conspire to create an atmosphere of paranoia and mistrust. The title character, played by the grimly charismatic Adam Bakri, is one of three Palestinian friends trying to make their mark in the struggle against Israeli occupation.
The others are Amjad (Samer Bisharat) and Tarek (Iyad Hoorani), whose younger sister Nadia (Leem Lubany) is the object of both Omar and Amjad’s affections… Facing a 90-year sentence, Omar agrees to help bring Tarek to justice and is released from detention… The freshness of his cast’s faces (all but Zuaiter are making their feature-film debuts) and the fleshed-out humanity of their performances give the untangling of this web of deceit real emotional weight. The movie neither condemns nor lauds its characters’ behavior. Without delving into the particulars of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and remaining much more of a thriller than a piece of propaganda, Abu-Assad captures the everyday reality of life in the West Bank and the psychological cost of living constantly in a state of powerlessness and desperation.
96 min., not rated, Living Room Theaters. Grade: A-”
A four-star review that spends its headline and much of its first paragraph establishing what the film is not. Five Palestinian actors are named, four of them in their first feature. The reviewer reaches for Cold War Berlin and colonial Boston to say the story is universal, which is its own way of saying a Palestinian one would not be.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles · page 1
Films from Italy, Denmark and Palestinian territories have received the most attention
Mark Olsen
“Omar” — PALESTINE. “Omar,” directed by Hany Abu-Assad, is a dramatic thriller of shifting allegiances as a young man is coaxed into cooperating with Israeli authorities in capturing a fugitive. “The film is not about the conflict, it’s really about love, friendship and betrayal and about the genre thriller,” Abu-Assad said. Nevertheless, Abu-Assad, an Oscar nominee for his 2005 film “Paradise Now,” is not reluctant to give the film’s storytelling a definite point of view. “The movie is pro-Palestinian, and I’m not apologetic about it,” he said.
“If I am not pro my own people, who should I be pro? I want the freedom for my people, and I am not ashamed of that.”… “OMAR” was directed by Hany Abu-Assad.
The paper labels the country PALESTINE over the entry and Palestinian territories in the smaller line above it, on the same page. Seven months later an American paper filed a Palestinian screenwriter under CONFLICT for saying he was not permitted a subject other than war; here a Palestinian director says his film is not about the conflict, and the word the paper reaches for anyway is Nevertheless.
· Honolulu Star-Advertiser · Honolulu · page 1
Colin Covert, Star Tribune (Minneapolis)
“A riveting blend of thriller and romance elements, ‘Omar’ grabs you from the very first image. A fit, energetic young man climbs a knotted rope to the top of Israel’s 25-foot separation wall, the concrete curtain isolating West Bank Palestinians from Israelis. Hand over hand he makes his way to the top of the looming barrier.
The long shot shows there’s nothing to break his descent if he slips.
You watch, stomach knotted, gripped by fear that he’ll plummet to the roadway below… Nominated for an Oscar as best foreign language film, ‘Omar’ is the latest entry from Palestinian writer/director Hany Abu-Assad, whose 2005 ‘Paradise Now,’ a character study of suicide bombers, was also up for that prize. Abu-Assad packs his film with richly layered characters and vivid visuals.
Omar routinely climbs the fence to get to his childhood friend Tarek’s house. He’s there less to hang out with his buddy and their amusing sidekick Amjad than to pass clandestine love poems to Tarek’s pretty kid sister, Nadia.… Abu-Assad draws wonderful performances from an ensemble of unknowns.
Adam Bakri’s Omar and Leem Lubany’s Nadia in particular allow vivid emotions to escape their characters’ self-protective facades.
The lone professional in the cast, Waleed Zuaiter as Rami, is simultaneously humane and sinister. Abu-Assad borrows from sources as diverse as Shakespeare and Mario Puzo to create this world of interconnected, endlessly escalating injustices.
There is no pat sermonizing here, but no lack of indignation, either. The villain in this universe of ethical ambiguity and psychological nuance isn’t Israel. It’s the fever of short-sightedness, duplicity and pack mentality that infects every character.
Yet each has his or her share of integrity.… The veteran Israeli agent Rami turns Omar against his friends, yet treats him with an empathy and apparent openness no one else offers… It’s surely no accident that the names of Omar and Rami are near-mirror images.
‘Omar’ leaves it up to us to decide who is more worthy. In Arabic and Hebrew, with English subtitles.”
“Omar (Adam Bakri) is a young Palestinian man without a country, who suddenly finds himself at odds with his clique of friends and with the woman he loves in Hany Abu-Assad’s ‘Omar.’” · Adopt Films
A four-star review by the same critic whose longer interview with the director ran in Minneapolis twelve days earlier. The reassurance appears again, as it did in two reviews of the director’s previous film nine years before: the villain, the reader is told, is not Israel. What the critic notices first about the film is a boy climbing a wall to deliver love poems.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles · page 1
Issues with funding, locations, self doubts — ‘Omar’ director Hany Abu-Assad overcame them all.
Lorraine Ali
“Hany Abu-Assad should be used to the tension by now. The Palestinian director has shot most of his films (‘Paradise Now,’ ‘Rana’s Wedding’) in a region known far more for its conflict than its cinema, and his story lines often take place in between tangles of barbed wire and crowded checkpoints. But filming ‘Omar’ on the West Bank and in his hometown of Nazareth almost proved too much — even for Abu-Assad. ‘At the end of the shoot, I told everybody, I’m not going to make another movie,’ said the director.
‘The financing, the crew, the locations, problems with the authorities. I was done.
It was that stressful.’ During production, investors dropped out, refugee camp mobs sabotaged the shoot and Abu-Assad, 52, battled his own insecurity as his first Hollywood film, ‘The Courier,’ went straight to DVD. Still, Abu-Assad and his all-Palestinian cast and crew stuck it out, and ‘Omar’ made it all the way to the Oscars.
The film, completed for just under $2 million, was nominated for the foreign language film Oscar after winning a jury prize at Cannes and being selected to show at the Toronto and New York film festivals. It opened in late February in a surprisingly wide 70-plus cities across the U.S.”
“IN ‘OMAR,’ the occupation is a backdrop to love, paranoia and betrayal,” says the film’s director, Hany Abu-Assad, right, with one of his stars, Waleed Zuaiter.” · Kirk McKoy, Los Angeles Times
The caption carries the line: in Omar the occupation is a backdrop to love, paranoia and betrayal. The piece is about money, locations and a director telling his crew at the end of the shoot that he would never make another film. An all-Palestinian cast and crew, two million dollars, seventy American cities.
· Tulare Advance-Register · Tulare, CA
By Aron Heller, Associated Press
JERUSALEM — Israeli naval forces raided a ship in the Red Sea early Wednesday, capturing a shipment of dozens of advanced rockets from Iran destined to Palestinian militants in Gaza that would have given them greater reach to strike much of Israel, the military said. The M-302 rockets were en route in an elaborate smuggling operation orchestrated by Iran, the military said.
Manufactured in Syria, the rockets were flown to Iran, then shipped from its Bandar Abbas port to Iraq to cover their tracks and loaded onto the civilian cargo ship destined for Sudan. From there, they were to be smuggled overland through Egypt to the Gaza Strip, military spokesman Lt. Col. Peter Lerner told reporters.
Israel forces intercepted the ship in international waters off the shores of Sudan and Eritrea, 1,000 miles from Eilat, Israel's southernmost point and only Red Sea port, Lerner said. The M-302 rockets have a range of up to 100 miles and would have significantly improved the capabilities of Gaza militants, putting nearly all of Israel in their range, he said.
Previously, Gaza militants have only been able to reach about 50 miles into Israel. The Lebanese militant group Hezbollah used M-302s in a 2006 war against Israel, the military said. Iran's semi-official Fars news agency denied the Israeli claim, calling it “mere lies.”
Abu Attaya, a spokesman for the smaller Popular Resistance Committees, said the Israel raid was a pretext “to prepare the public opinion for new wave of aggression planned against Gaza.” Israel says Iran and militants have used a similar route in the past.
It was not clear how militants would have smuggled the weapons into Gaza, given the naval blockade imposed on it and the current Egyptian leadership's hostility toward Hamas and its blocking of major smuggling tunnels.
The 17-member crew of the Panamanian-flagged vessel cooperated with the Israeli forces, Lerner said, adding they were not suspects and were probably unaware of the content of their cargo.
Nine paragraphs, eight of them sourced to the Israeli military or its spokesman, one photo supplied by the Israeli army. The quoted non-Israeli responses are Iran’s ‘mere lies’ and Abu Attaya’s. No Yoaz Hendel in this item despite the slide grouping.
· Tulare Advance-Register · Tulare, CA
By Karin Laub, Associated Press
LUBBAN AL-SHARKIYEH, West Bank — Ahmed Awais is desperate to get out of his parents’ cramped home where he, his wife and three preschool-age children share one room, sleeping on mattresses on the floor. Six months ago, the Palestinian laborer began building a small house on land owned by his family. But last week his dream of a more comfortable life came to a halt.
An Israeli army jeep pulled up at his construction site on the outskirts of Lubban al-Sharkiyeh, and officials handed him a stop-work order with a date for a demolition hearing. Awais, 30, like others in his village, hadn’t bothered to ask for a building permit because Israel rarely grants them to Palestinians.
On a nearby hilltop, on the other side of a main West Bank highway, the Israeli settlement of Eli continues to grow, with about 20 apartments currently under construction.
Eli was built over the past 30 years without legal planning and permits, according to an Israel defense official, and the government is only now promoting a master plan for 620 homes to legalize building retroactively. “The settlers are building homes. Each of their boys and girls has a room, and even the dog has a room,” Awais said.
But if the hearing goes against him, the modest structure on his own small plot will likely be bulldozed. “This is my land and I am not allowed to build in it,” he said.
Lubban al-Sharkiyeh and Eli illustrate what critics say is an accelerating Israeli policy to suppress Palestinian development while tightening Israel’s hold over the more than 60 percent of the West Bank that remains under sole Israeli control.
The strongest clipping in the batch on Area C and the only one that opens on a named Palestinian in his own home. The FIGURES TO KNOW sidebar prints Bimkom’s data in full: ‘In 2010, Palestinians submitted 444 requests for permits and only four were granted, according to Bimkom, citing data obtained through freedom-of-information requests’ and ‘At the same time, Israel issued more than 4,000 demolition orders against Palestinian homes and structures in the past four years, or roughly a third of the 25-year-total of 12,500, Bimkom said. Of these, 2,450 orders were carried out, including 787 since 2010.’ Also printed: Maj. Guy Inbar, an Israeli Defense Ministry official, denied Israel applies different planning rules for settlers and Palestinians in Area C.
· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco · page 1
W. Addiego
“Omar A young Palestinian baker working in the Palestinian territories is captured by the Israelis and pressured to become an informant after an Israeli soldier is killed. The film is ostensibly a thriller, but its virtues are obscured by a one-sided political message. Directed by Hany Abu-Assad (‘Paradise Now’). Not rated. 98 minutes.
In Arabic and Hebrew with English subtitles. — W. Addiego”
Six lines, and they complete the range. In one month of 2014 this archive holds six American notices of the same film: the director saying it is not about the conflict, a review headlined Conflict, paranoia, but little propaganda, a four-star notice assuring readers the villain is not Israel, a production story, an interview about Othello, and this, which finds the political message one-sided enough to obscure the film’s virtues. The paper also relocates the hero: he is a baker here, and a car mechanic’s friend in the film.
· Messenger Inquirer · Owensboro
CAL THOMAS / TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES
“After his spectacular failure to move forward the ‘peace process’…”
Owensboro, Kentucky, during the 2014 Gaza war. The headline assigns a disposition to a people.
· Los Angeles Times
To achieve peace, Israelis and Palestinians will both have to put aside the past.
By Christopher J. Fettweis
Israel’s decision to pull out of the current round of U.S.-brokered peace talks with the Palestinians makes one thing clear. If Secretary of State John F.
Kerry is going to be successful in his heroic effort to force peace on these stubborn belligerents, he will have to overcome an obstacle that is much deeper and challenging than Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s hardball negotiating tactics.
The biggest impediment to a lasting peace settlement between the Israelis and Palestinians is not terrorism, borders, settlements, recognition, refugees or any other issue that can be discussed rationally at a negotiating table. The real problem is psychological, and nearly immune to bargaining.
The Israeli-Palestinian dispute is unique in recent history in that it concerns two peoples who both harbor a deep, abiding, justifiable narrative of victimhood at the center of their cultural identities. There are no precedents to help us predict whether reason can overcome such powerful, mutual pathology. Victims operate under a different set of rules than the rest of us do.
History has ceded to them the moral high ground, which makes their excesses understandable, even excusable. Outsiders tend to sympathize with the actions of those who have been victimized. What they do can seem terrible, certainly, but it is often justified once put in proper context.
Victimhood can even become a source of pride, a unifying element to a society that members can draw upon for inspiration, and liberation from the standard rules of moral behavior. Most of all, victims rarely feel the need to compromise. They have suffered enough already, and are tired of being bullied. Their days of making concessions to evil are over.
· Chicago Jewish Star · Skokie, IL · page 1 and 4
BENNETT CALLS ON ISRAEL TO ANNEX PARTS OF W. BANK
By Felice Friedson and Linda Gradstein / The Media Line
Israeli Economy Minister NAFTALI BENNETT said on April 27 that Israel should annex the 60 percent of the West Bank that is under full Israeli control, and that includes all of the Jewish communities built since acquiring the areas in the 1967 war.
“We should apply Israeli law on the Israeli-controlled parts of Judea and Samaria — the West Bank — and offer full citizenship to those Palestinians who live in these areas,” Bennett told the Foreign Press Association in Jerusalem. “The idea is to make the conditions as livable as possible for the foreseeable future.
It’s not as sexy as the perfect, two-state solution, but this is realistic,” he said.
The controversial right-wing minister, who at times appears to be as much at odds with Prime Minister Netanyahu as he is with his left-of-center opponents, said Israel should annex Area C, the 1993 Oslo Accords designation for the portion of the West Bank which is under Israeli administrative and security control.
The 100,000 Palestinians who live there would be given the option to become full Israeli citizens. The rest of the West Bank, where Palestinians exercise full control (Area A), or partial control (Area B), would be given “autonomy on steroids,” according to Bennett.
His proposal to annex the majority of the West Bank is unlikely to be accepted by the Palestinians or most of the international community, which believes there should be an independent Palestinian state within the borders that existed prior to 1967, with some slight modifications.
At the same time, Bennett took what he called an “unpopular” position in Israel and called to gradually dismantle the security fence which Israel has built in and around the West Bank. Many Israelis believe that the construction of the barrier, which Palestinians see as a land grab, has led to a marked increase in their security.
“The reason that cars or suicide bombers are not blowing up in cafes is not the fence but our good intelligence control in Judea and Samaria and our effective ability to thwart attacks before they begin,” Bennett said.
End of Oslo era Bennett, a former head of the Council of Jewish Settlements in Judea and Samaria, spoke as the nine-month period that the parties allotted to U.S.
Secretary of State JOHN KERRY to develop a framework agreement runs out, and three days after the Islamist Hamas movement which controls the Gaza Strip signed a unity agreement with the rival Fatah movement which is in charge in the West Bank. “The era of Oslo is at its end,” Bennett said, referring to the 1993 agreement that called for an independent Palestinian state.
“We are not going to reach a peace agreement in the foreseeable future. We need to be realistic about what we can achieve and massively invest in infrastructure, in the economy, in the quality of life and in self-governance of the Palestinians.” Israel’s opposition leader, Labor Party Chairman ISAAC HERZOG, told TML that “Bennett’s proposal is not realistic and not reasonable.
“My idea is that Israel introduces a national plan which will get international support and it will demand that the new unity government recognize the principles of the Quartet.”
Obstacles to negotiations Palestinian officials insist that the agreement signed with Hamas for a unity government to pave the way for elections, should not influence the continuation of the U.S.-backed negotiations with Israel. “There is a Catch-22 here,” NABIL SHAATH, a member of the PLO Central Committee and a long-time negotiator told TML.
“In all of our previous negotiations [Netanyahu] used to say, ‘I cannot negotiate with you because you are separated, you don’t control Gaza.’ “And now that we are united, he says the problem is that we are united. You don’t know if the problem is our being separated or being united.”
Shaath also specifically referred to Bennett, saying that if Hamas is an obstacle to peace, so is Naftali Bennett. Netanyahu “talks about Hamas as if they are against this peace process,” Shaath said. “What is he doing with Mr. Bennett in his Cabinet? Mr. Bennett is a man who is against the peace process, who is much farther to the right from him [Netanyahu].
We don’t interfere. He can keep Mr. Bennett. He can keep Mr. [Foreign Minister Avigdor] Lieberman. “But he has nothing to do with our partners, nothing to do with our people. This is our job. We decide to unite with whom. Our commitments to international law and to the peace process have not changed.”
The most complete Bennett record in the batch and the only one that argues back. Nouns: 'Jewish communities', 'Council of Jewish Settlements in Judea and Samaria', 'the security fence', 'the barrier, which Palestinians see as a land grab'. The paper uses Bennett's own 'Judea and Samaria' in its own voice when naming his former job. 'Occupied' does not appear; the 1967 war is 'acquiring the areas'. Set this beside slide 25: in 2010 Bennett told the LA Times there would be no Palestinian state because 'if they have a state, we'll cease to exist'; in 2014, as a minister, the same position is dressed as pragmatism - 'autonomy on steroids', 'not as sexy as the perfect, two-state solution'. The position did not move; the vocabulary did.
· Juneau Empire
COLUMBUS, Ohio — It was a nice try. Last July, Secretary of State John Kerry convinced the Israelis and Palestinians to negotiate for a period of nine months. During that time, Kerry cajoled and wheedled to get to a peace treaty. Kerry kept both sides on board, almost to the very end, which came at the end of April. There were some unexpected moments.
One of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s demands was that Palestine recognize Israel as a Jewish state. Kerry initially backed Netanyahu, viewing the demand as verbiage without great significance.
But the Palestinian negotiators explained to Kerry that Netanyahu’s ulterior motive was to scuttle the possibility of a repatriation of the Palestine Arabs displaced from Israel in 1948, and perhaps to force out the Palestine Arabs who remained in Israel after 1948. Kerry to his credit flipped on the issue.
In March, Kerry told Israel that the United Nations had already accepted it as a Jewish state in 1948. Kerry also reacted with a certain equanimity when, just days ago, the West Bank and Gaza administrations, which have been at each other’s throats, announced that they would form a joint government for Palestine.
Netanyahu reacted by saying he will never negotiate if the Gaza administration, headed by the Hamas organization, is in the picture. Hamas won a Palestinian election a few years ago, but it is on the U.S. list of terrorist organizations. So Kerry might have followed Netanyahu’s lead and said that with Hamas in, peace was off the table. To his credit, he did not.
He did not depict it as ending the possibility of peace talks. Then there was the move made by Palestine in mid-April to sign on to some fifteen international treaties. Israel cried foul. Netanyahu said that Palestine had agreed not to join international organizations during the nine months of negotiations.
But Palestine was acting in response to Israel’s own failure to release a group of Palestinian prisoners — a release to which Israel had agreed as part of the negotiation process. And, said Kerry, quite correctly, Palestine was not joining organizations. The fifteen treaties did not involve organizations.
With the United States traditionally on Israel’s side in the conflict with Palestine, these stances by Kerry shocked Netanyahu and sent U.S. stock upwards in the Arab world.
· Los Angeles Times · page A7
The issue — part of a broader movement in Europe and on college campuses here opposing Israel’s policies — has roiled the Westwood school.
Although the new board already has taken office, administrators and others say that the effects of the election linger and that they want to take steps to reestablish a civil tone and prevent the polarization that the pledge engendered.
UCLA STUDENT Sunny Singh said he went on a trip to Israel sponsored by the Anti-Defamation League because, as a history and economics major, he wanted to “see the region with my own eyes.”
· Cleveland Daily Banner
DHEISHEH REFUGEE CAMP, West Bank (AP) — Pope Francis will spend less than half an hour in this Palestinian refugee camp during a jam-packed Holy Land tour this weekend, but residents hope even a brief visit will shine a light on what they say is their forgotten plight.
Some 190,000 of the West Bank’s 2.4 million Palestinians live in refugee camps and face tougher conditions — including higher unemployment and overcrowding — than their neighbors in towns and villages. Many feel increasingly neglected by the Palestinian self-rule government and the United Nations agency responsible for their welfare.
Resentment can be seen in the rise in stone-throwing protests by camp youths and a recent two-month strike of thousands of local employees of the U.N. aid agency demanding higher wages. Underlying the discontent is fear of open-ended limbo.
Israelis and Palestinians remain far apart on a solution for the refugees who were forced or driven out in the war over Israel’s 1948 creation and today, along with their descendants, make up more than 5 million people scattered across the West Bank, Gaza, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon. Last month, another round of Israeli-Palestinian peace talks ended in failure.
“Through time, the suffering in the camps has grown,” said Ishaq al-Natteti, 66, who was only a few days old when his family was uprooted from what is now Israel and has spent his life in Dheisheh, a camp of 13,000 people near Bethlehem. “There no return to our homes and land, no real life, no space, no jobs, no services, no economy.”
The pope will visit a Dheisheh community center for about 20 minutes on Sunday and will meet dozens of children from three camps. Francis said Wednesday that his visit to Jordan, Israel and the West Bank is “strictly religious,” tempering expectations that he might take sides in the Mideast conflict.
Israelis and Palestinians have being trying to harness the pilgrimage to highlight rival narratives. Some argued that Christianity cannot ignore one of the world’s most entrenched refugee problems. “Truly, the Palestinian refugees are the dispossessed of the earth, a people languishing in exile,” said Chris Gunness of the U.N.
Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian refugees. “There cannot be peace in the Holy Land until they are delivered from their dispossession and exile.” The pontiff will meet the refugee children at Dheisheh’s Phoenix Center, which hosts workshops and weddings and also offers a library and a computer center.
A meeting hall has been decorated with large posters illustrating Dheisheh’s history, including dusty streets with donkey carts in the 1950s and a tall chain-link fence that blocked off the camp in the 1980s to prevent stone-throwers from striking Israeli cars.
“The children will tell the pope about the tough reality they have grown up in in the camp and their dreams of returning to the villages and cities of their families in Israel,” said Ahed Eid, manager of the center. In Palestinian public discourse, a large-scale return is seen as the main goal.
Israel vehemently objects, saying this would dilute its Jewish majority. Palestinian leaders say each refugee has the right to choose where to live, including in a future Palestinian state. The Palestinians want to set up such a state in the West Bank, Gaza and east Jerusalem, lands Israel captured in the 1967 Mideast war.
Restive refugees with little to lose have been at the forefront of confrontations with Israeli forces since the first uprising against Israeli occupation in the 1980s. Teens routinely throw stones at Israeli troops or at cars with Israeli license plates passing near the camps, though during an armed uprising that started in 2000 some also resorted to guns and bombs.
Israeli forces respond with tear gas, rubber-coated steel pellets — and at times live fire. Violence dropped in recent years, though UNRWA said this week that there has been a sharp rise in the number of Palestinian refugees killed and wounded by Israeli troops, attributing this to an increase in the use of force by Israel.
Seventeen refugees were killed and 486 injured in 2013, compared to no deaths and 38 injuries in 2012, the agency said, adding that the upward trend continued into 2014. But the resentment in the camps isn’t just directed at Israel.
Some say they feel looked down upon by their better-off urban neighbors and ignored by the self-rule government of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas. Others complain about a cutback in services by UNRWA, which has run schools, clinics and food centers in 58 camps across the region since 1950.
Faced with a growing budget deficit and Syria’s civil war, the agency has, among other things, eliminated free meals in schools. UNRWA says it has protected its core services in health, education and relief. One of the biggest problems in the camps is unemployment, which exceeds the overall figure of 26 percent for the West Bank and Gaza.
In Dheisheh, young men loiter all day in alleys, the walls decorated with graffiti tributes to those killed by Israel. Tariq Afandi, 33, said he worked as a laborer in Israel for several years, but was later denied an entry permit. Such permits are often revoked at times of Israeli-Palestinian tensions.
Afandi hasn’t worked in more than a year and blames it in part on what he said is rampant nepotism in Palestinian society. “The jobs are for the Palestinian Authority officials and their families,” he said. “Their sons and daughters get the government jobs. They leave us jobless. People are … willing to explode at any moment.”
· Fort Worth Star-Telegram · Fort Worth
Pope Francis insists that his visit is “strictly religious,” not political.
DHEISHEH REFUGEE CAMP, West Bank — Pope Francis will spend less than half an hour in this Palestinian refugee camp during a jampacked Holy Land tour this weekend, but residents hope that even a brief visit will shine a light on what they say is their forgotten plight.
Some 190,000 of the West Bank’s 2.4 million Palestinians live in refugee camps and face tougher conditions — including higher unemployment and overcrowding — than their neighbors in towns and villages. Many feel increasingly neglected by the Palestinian self-rule government and the United Nations agency responsible for their welfare.
Resentment can be seen in the rise in stone-throwing protests by camp youths and a recent two-month strike by thousands of local employees of the U.N. aid agency demanding higher wages. Underlying the discontent is a fear of limbo. Israelis and Palestinians remain far apart on a solution for refugees who were forced out in the war over Israel’s 1948 creation.
Today, along with their descendants, they make up more than 5 million people scattered across the West Bank, Gaza, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon. Last month, another round of Israeli-Palestinian peace talks ended in failure.
“Through time, the suffering in the camps has grown,” said Ishaq al-Natteti, 66, who was only a few days old when his family was uprooted from what is now Israel and has spent his life in Dheisheh, a camp of 13,000 people near Bethlehem. “There is no return to our homes and land, no real life, no space, no jobs, no services, no economy.”
The pope will visit a Dheisheh community center for about 20 minutes Sunday and will meet dozens of children from three camps. Francis said Wednesday that his visit to Jordan, Israel and the West Bank is “strictly religious,” tempering expectations that he might take sides in the Middle East conflict.
Israelis and Palestinians have tried to harness the pilgrimage to highlight rival narratives. Some argue that Christianity cannot ignore one of the world’s most-entrenched refugee problems. “Truly, the Palestinian refugees are the dispossessed of the earth, a people languishing in exile,” said Chris Gunness of the U.N.
Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian refugees. “There cannot be peace in the Holy Land until they are delivered from their dispossession and exile.” The pontiff will meet the refugee children at Dheisheh’s Phoenix Center, which hosts workshops and weddings and also offers a library and a computer center.
A meeting hall has been decorated with large posters illustrating Dheisheh’s history, including dusty streets with donkey carts in the 1950s and a tall chain-link fence that blocked off the camp in the 1980s to prevent stone-throwers from striking Israeli cars.
“The children will tell the pope about the tough reality they have grown up in in the camp and their dreams of returning to the villages and cities of their families in Israel,” said Ahed Eid, the center manager. In Palestinian public discourse, a large-scale return is seen as the main goal. Israel vehemently objects, saying it would dilute its Jewish majority.
Palestinian leaders say each refugee has the right to choose where to live, including in a future Palestinian state. The Palestinians want to set up such a state in the West Bank, Gaza and east Jerusalem, lands that Israel captured in the 1967 war.
Little to lose Refugees with little to lose have been at the forefront of confrontations with Israeli forces since the first uprising against Israeli occupation in the 1980s. Teens routinely throw stones at Israeli troops or at cars with Israeli license plates passing near the camps. During an armed uprising that started in 2000, some also resorted to guns and bombs.
Israeli forces respond with tear gas, rubber-coated steel pellets — and at times live fire. Violence dropped in recent years, though the U.N. Relief and Works Agency said this week that there has been a sharp rise in Palestinian refugees killed and wounded by Israeli troops, attributing this to an increase in the use of force by Israel.
Seventeen refugees were killed and 486 injured in 2013, compared with none dead and 38 injured in 2012, the agency said, adding that the upward trend has continued into 2014. But the resentment in the camps isn’t just directed at Israel.
Some say they feel looked down upon by their better-off urban neighbors and ignored by the self-rule government of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas. Others complain about a cutback in services by the relief agency, which has run schools, clinics and food centers in 58 camps across the region since 1950.
Palestinian vendors wait for customers Tuesday at their tobacco shop in an alley of the Dheisheh refugee camp.
· Los Angeles Times
If approved, Abraham Oved would join a UC Berkeley student to represent the system.
By Larry Gordon
A UCLA economics major active in student government and campus Jewish organizations has been nominated to become one of the two student representatives on the UC regents board. If his nomination is approved, he will join a Muslim woman in representing the more than 230,000 students in the 10-campus system.
Abraham “Avi” Oved’s selection by a special committee was announced Thursday; he is expected to be confirmed by the full Board of Regents in July. Oved, who will be a UCLA senior in the fall, has served as internal vice president of the campus undergraduate student government and been active at the UCLA Jewish Student Union and the Hillel organization.
UC officials said he was the strongest candidate — and was not chosen in an effort to balance religious representation on the board at a time when issues surrounding the Israeli-Palestinian dispute have roiled some UC campuses.
Last year the regents selected Sadia Saifuddin, a UC Berkeley student government leader, whose position on the board continues through the 2014-15 school year. Some Jewish organizations opposed her selection because Saifuddin, the first Muslim student regent, previously had advocated divesting university funds from companies that do business with Israel’s military.
Oved, whose parents emigrated from Israel, has opposed divestment and proposed that UC instead actively invest in companies that promote peace between Israelis and Palestinians.
“I think it’s an absolutely beautiful statement for UC to have a Jewish student and a Muslim student work together regardless of religious or political or cultural differences, in order to improve higher education,” said Oved, an Encino native.
He added he hoped their cooperation would serve as an example for many groups to “come together and focus on similarities rather than differences.” Oved said that as a board representative, he hoped to address the problem of sexual violence on campus.
· West Central Tribune · page A4
CHICAGO — Universities have often been the places for investigating, analyzing and debating important issues of the day. But they sometimes end up being pushed to do more than think and talk about such matters. Increasingly, administrators are being pushed to take action as well.
The demand lately has been for divestment – getting colleges to sell the stocks of companies allegedly engaged in one disfavored activity or another.
Last week, students at DePaul voted to approve a recommendation that the university should sell its stock in corporations that, in the loaded language of the ballot measure, “profit from Israel’s discrimination and human rights violations.” Recently, Stanford trustees voted to divest from coal mining companies.
There are divestment campaigns on Israel and fossil fuels at dozens of campuses around the country. They are modeled on the anti-apartheid movement of the 1970s and ’80s, which persuaded some 155 universities to sever ties with firms doing business in South Africa. On these new issues, though, most schools have rejected the divestment option, and with good reason.
One is that the issues are far less clear-cut than white supremacy in South Africa was. Divest or not, universities and their students will continue using fossil fuels, which are practically indispensable, at least for the time being.
If Israel bears some of the blame for the plight of Palestinians and the failure of peace negotiations, so does the Palestinian Authority and the people living under it. In April, the president of the student government at Loyola vetoed a resolution to divest from companies operating in Israel. The Rev.
Michael Garanzini, the president of Loyola, said the measure would be impossible to implement because most of the school’s investments are in funds, not individual corporations. Worse, he said: “It is one-sided; it is focused on one party in a complex international situation. It is felt as extremely unfair by our Jewish faculty, staff and students.”
· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota
“The new Palestinian ‘unity’ government is a paradoxical pastiche.”
Sarasota again. The scare quotes around unity are the argument.
· Knoxville News-Sentinel
By Sherif Tarek
Jewish and Muslim student groups at University of California at San Diego had an idea they could work on together — creating a campus dining spot with both kosher and halal dishes.
It was a small but meaningful collaboration amid tensions that have arisen from the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement, a global campaign that has sought to put economic and political pressure on Israel, in part, to protect Palestinian rights. “I don’t think anyone on our project team thinks this will solve those disagreements,” said Zev M.
Hurwitz of the Union of Jewish Students at UCSD. But “we also think it’s possible to be progressive and productive on things like campus dining hall offerings.” The students’ effort is one of several in the UC system to create kosher-halal dining spots — most of which are still in the planning stages.
But Jewish and Muslim students said the opportunity to work together has helped build understanding. “Dialogue and coordination definitely brings both communities closer,” said Jim Atkins, the executive director of Santa Cruz Hillel, which has been meeting with the UC campus’ Muslim Student Association.
Sammy Mehtar of the Muslim Student Association at UC Berkeley said that discussing the project “has already brought Jewish and Muslim students together.” Kosher and halal — orthodox methods of preparing food for Jews and Muslims, respectively — are similar.
Both generally forbid pork and require the ritual slaughtering of animals to ensure thorough bleeding. Neither group typically eats birds of prey. Observant Jewish and Muslim students have a difficult time living on some campuses because the available meal plans don’t always have kosher or halal options.
Zev Hurwitz, right, and Jonah Saidian, second from right, both with the Union of Jewish Students, and Hibah Khan, left, and Yasin Ahmed, second from left, both with the Muslim Student Association at UC San Diego, talk during a meeting to discuss offering kosher and halal food at facilities on campus.
· Journal and Courier · Lafayette, IN
Rocket attacks escalate after teens' deaths
Michele Chabin / Special for USA TODAY
JERUSALEM Rocket fire escalated Monday across the Gaza border as tension mounted over the deaths of three Israeli teens and last week’s revenge killing of a Palestinian teenager. The Israeli army announced it was carrying out airstrikes early today in Gaza to stop rocket attacks.
The airstrikes came after Hamas, the militant group that controls Gaza, intensified its rocket assault on Israel on Monday night, the Israeli Defense Force said. One injury was reported. Israel earlier said it was also calling up 1,500 reservists for a potential mission in Gaza. Eight Palestinian militants were killed in fighting Monday.
At least nine were injured in today’s airstrikes, Gaza health official Ashraf Al-Kedra said. Lt. Col. Peter Lerner, an army spokesman, said Monday that Israel was “prepared for a potential deterioration” in Gaza “with potential to use military force.” The attacks come after Israel arrested six Jewish suspects Sunday for the young Palestinian’s death.
Three of the six confessed and re-enacted the crime, an Israeli official told the Associated Press on condition of anonymity because of a gag order. Israel is calling up 1,500 reservists for a potential mission in Gaza, according to an announcement after Monday’s meeting of Israel’s security Cabinet.
Economy Minister Naftali Bennett, head of the right-wing Jewish Home Party, said “all options are on the table. We need to broadcast to Hamas a message of deterrence.” Residents in the southern part of the country were instructed to stay close to bomb shelters.
The increased attacks along the Israel-Gaza border represent a second front for Israel, which has been trying to contain Palestinian rioting after Mohammed Abu Khdeir, 16, was burned to death Wednesday. His killing followed last week’s discovery of the three Israeli teens who were abducted in the West Bank on June 12 and killed. Israel blames Hamas.
Rachelle Fraenkel, mother of one of the Israeli teens, said she could not describe her distress over the killing of the Arab. “No mother and father should endure what we are going through now. We feel the pain of Mohammed Abu Khdeir’s parents,” she said.
Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu spoke Monday with the father of the slain Palestinian teenager, saying “I would like to express my outrage and that of the citizens of Israel over the reprehensible murder of your son.” Emotions were running high, with crowds attacking Arabs.
Tomer Lavie, a teacher in Jerusalem, said he saw 20 to 30 youths trying to pull a Palestinian taxi driver from his cab. “I saw the whole thing from the bus on the way home,” Lavie said. “They circled a taxi and started cursing at the driver.” Contributing: Oren Dorell in McLean, Va.; the Associated Press
Short enough to transcribe whole, and worth reading whole. The headline order is 'BOMBS POUND ISRAEL, GAZA' and the dek attributes the escalation to 'teens' deaths' without saying whose. The sentence to put in front of Maria is the paper's own: 'Rachelle Fraenkel... said she could not describe her distress over the killing of the Arab.' The bereaved Israeli mother names Mohammed Abu Khdeir in her quotation; the American newspaper, in the sentence introducing her, calls him 'the Arab'. Note also the casualty bookkeeping: 'Eight Palestinian militants were killed' and 'One injury was reported' (Israeli), with no Palestinian civilian count, and the taxi driver who is attacked but never named.
· Hartford Courant · Hartford · page 1
Ashraf Amrah, Reuters
“PALESTINIANS LOOK at the remains of a missile that witnesses said was fired by an Israeli aircraft on a street in Deir El-Balah in the central Gaza Strip on Friday.” Ashraf Amrah, special to Reuters.
Witnesses said it was fired by an Israeli aircraft. The missile is lying in the street.
· The Republican · Springfield · page 1
By Khaled Khazziha, Associated Press, Gaza City
“One of the Israeli strikes hit a center for the disabled where Palestinians said two patients were killed and four people seriously hurt… Before dawn Saturday, an Israeli missile hit the Palestine Charity, a center for the physically and mentally disabled in the northern Gaza town of Beit Lahiya, said its director, Jamila Alaiweh.
The center is home to nine patients, including four who were spending the weekend with their families away from the center, said Alaiweh. Of the remaining five, two were killed in the strike and three suffered serious burns and other injuries, the director said. A caregiver was also injured, she added.
The director said one of the women killed had cerebral palsy and the other suffered had severe mental handicaps. Among the three wounded patients were a quadriplegic, one with cerebral palsy and one with mental disabilities, she said. The missile destroyed the bottom floor of the two-story building.
Rescuers sifted through the pile of rubble, pulling out a folded-up wheelchair and a children’s workbook. An Israeli military spokesman, Lt. Col. Peter Lerner, said he was looking into the incident… ‘Am I a terrorist?
Do I make rockets and artillery?’ screamed Umm Omar, a woman in the southern town of Rafah whose home was destroyed in an airstrike… At Shifa Hospital in Gaza City, 4-year-old Shayma al-Masri was in stable condition Saturday with shrapnel injuries to her upper body.
Her mother, a 17-year-old brother and a 14-year-old sister were killed earlier this week… ‘You can hide your children in the bomb shelters when you need them, but where do I hide her (Shayma)?’ she said. ‘When the child comes to hide in my arms and I find the entire house falling on top of us what do I do then?
Just like you fear for yourselves we fear for ourselves too. Just like you fear for your children we fear for our children too.’”
Elderly Israeli women sleep in a bomb shelter in the southern city of Beersheba, Israel, Saturday. While there have been no fatalities in Israel, Palestinian officials said overnight attacks raised the death toll there to over 120, with more than 920 wounded.
The director of the center is a named woman and the source for the whole account. Nine residents, four of them away with their families for the weekend, two of the remaining five killed. The sentence that stays is the one about the rubble: a folded-up wheelchair and a children’s workbook. The bottom half of the page is three advertisements, one of which reads Get Instantly Accepted.
· The Morning Call · Allentown, PA
Netanyahu said to be mulling over Gaza plan
By Batsheva Sobelman and Carol J. Williams / Tribune Newspapers
JERUSALEM — Egyptian mediators proposed a plan late Monday to halt a weeklong artillery exchange between Israelis and Palestinians in the Gaza Strip that has taken at least 175 Palestinian lives and sent millions of Israelis scrambling for cover from more than 1,000 rocket firings.
The government of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called a meeting of security officials for early Tuesday, and one government source speaking on condition of anonymity said the proposal is “being considered very seriously.”
Israel’s Haaretz newspaper cited an unnamed government official as saying Netanyahu “supports the Egyptian proposal for cease-fire in Gaza and will ask the Cabinet to accept it.” There had been no Israeli deaths in the conflict as of early Tuesday.
Publicly, both Israeli and Palestinian leaders lashed out at the plan as little more than a timeout in the third deadly flare-up between the sides since 2009. Bombardment of the densely populated Gaza coastal region has killed more civilians than militants, both sides concede.
On Monday, the soaring toll prompted the Palestinian Authority to appeal for United Nations protection.
The best photograph in batch B and the only one with a named Palestinian child in it. Note the paper's own sentence in the fifth paragraph: 'Bombardment of the densely populated Gaza coastal region has killed more civilians than militants, both sides concede' - stated in the paper's voice and attributed to both parties rather than to a Palestinian source, which is unusual in this batch. The Bennett material arrives late and is clearly labelled as hard-line. 'Occupied' does not appear; the Hamas demands in the right rail include 'an end to all aggression against Palestinian territory', which is the closest the page comes.
· The Abilene Reporter-News · Abilene, TX · page 3A
3-step plan has sides meet in Cairo
By Josef Federman and Maggie Michael / Associated Press
JERUSALEM – Egypt presented a cease-fire plan Monday to end a week of heavy fighting between Israel and Hamas militants in the Gaza Strip that has left at least 185 people dead, and both sides said they were seriously considering the proposal. The late-night offer by Egypt marked the first sign of a breakthrough in international efforts to end the conflict.
Hamas’ top leader in Gaza confirmed there was “diplomatic movement,” while Israel’s policymaking Security Cabinet was set to discuss the proposal early Tuesday. Arab foreign ministers discussed the plan Monday night at an emergency meeting in Cairo, and U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry was expected in the region Tuesday.
Israel launched the offensive July 8, saying it was a response to weeks of heavy rocket fire out of Hamas-ruled Gaza. The Health Ministry in Gaza said 185 people, including dozens of civilians, have been killed, and more than 1,000 people wounded.
There have been no Israelis killed, although several have been wounded by rocket shrapnel, including two sisters, ages 11 and 13, seriously hurt Monday.
Useful for the Bennett arc: on the same two days in July 2014, three different American papers carried three different Bennett statements against a cease-fire, each one printed without rebuttal. The AP's own accounting here is blunt - '185 people, including dozens of civilians' against 'no Israelis killed' - and the paper gives Haniyeh's 'the siege must stop and Gaza people need to live in dignity' room on the page. Nouns: 'Hamas militants', 'Hamas-ruled Gaza', 'Israeli-Egyptian blockade' (in the paper's own voice, column two). 'Occupied' does not appear.
· San Francisco Chronicle · page C1
Students sought delay of vote by UC regents
By Nanette Asimov
The University of California’s nomination of a pro-Israel Jewish student to serve on the Board of Regents has exposed a long-standing rift among students concerning one of the world’s most divisive issues: the conflict in the Middle East.
The regents will vote on whether to confirm Avi Oved as the student regent-designate on Wednesday at their meeting in San Francisco.
But it will be over the objections of the UC Student Association, the university’s student government, which urged the regents to delay the vote so students could investigate whether Oved accepted outside funding while running for election at UCLA.
Such donations are permitted at UCLA and require no disclosure, the Student Association’s president, Kareem Aref, acknowledged in an e-mail. The real issue — unstated in a Student Association press release but evident nonetheless — appears to be Oved’s strong support of Israel.
Debates about Israel and the Palestinian territories have proved nearly as intractable among students as the conflict itself.
They argue over whether Palestinian sympathizers should be allowed to compare Israeli border guards with Nazis in campus demonstrations; they disagree over which students, Jews or Muslims, suffer greater discrimination on campus; and feelings are still raw about the “Irvine 11” — students at UC Irvine who were disciplined in 2010 for shouting down the Israeli ambassador as he tried to give a speech on campus.
Most of all, students argue about whether UC should boycott Israel and divest from companies doing business there. Oved, an economics major at UCLA, strongly opposes boycott and divestment.
· The Register-Guard · Eugene · page 1
Jonah Goldberg, Tribune Content Agency
“Genocide in Gaza is a lie worthy of Goebbels. ‘Here’s the difference between us,’ Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu explained on ‘Fox News Sunday.’ ‘We’re using missile defense to protect our civilians, and they’re using their civilians to protect their missiles.’ It’s a classic talking point.
It’s also objectively true, and that truth is very frustrating for Israel’s critics. All one needs to do is delve into the muck of Twitter and read the timelines for such hashtags as #GazaUnderAttack and #GenocideInGaza: ‘They’re killing the women and children to ensure there won’t be a new generation of Palestine.’
‘One Holocaust can never justify another.’ And let’s not even talk about the globally trending hashtag #HitlerWasRight. Of course it’s not just on Twitter.
Mahmoud Abbas, the head of the feckless Palestinian Authority, recently condemned Israel for committing ‘genocide’ in Gaza… On the one hand, the Israeli military is supposed to be ruthlessly competent and determined to wipe out the Palestinians. On the other, the Palestinian population has grown more than 100 percent since 1970.
The population in the Gaza Strip has grown nearly threefold since 1990. The Palestinians themselves expect the population to double over the next two decades. ‘Genocide’ is a loaded political term, but under any remotely reasonable definition, shouldn’t those numbers be going the other way?
It’s just a hunch, but if the Israelis wanted to wipe out as many Palestinians as possible, never mind commit genocide, they probably wouldn’t issue warnings to Gazans (by phone and leaflet) to get out of harm’s way… And if Hamas were chiefly concerned with protecting Palestinian lives, it would not implore Gazans to stay in their homes — serving as human shields and inflating the body count as a propaganda prop to increase international pressure on Israel… It was Joseph Goebbels who said, ‘If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it.’”
A cartoon runs beside the column: a Hamas fighter says “LOOK! I TOOK DOWN A DRONE!” and, in the next panel, two figures running from a wrecked building say “NICE SHOT!” over a dead bird labeled PEACE PROP. Signed Summers, Tribune Content Agency, 2014.
The argument against the word, made at length in an American syndicated column in the same summer the archive holds the placards using it.
· Los Angeles Times
Some Jewish organizations opposed her selection because Saifuddin, the first Muslim student regent, supported the campaign for UC divestment. Oved opposed such divestment and the regents are considered unlikely to approve such a controversial financial move.
Regent George Kieffer, who heads the committee on student regent selection, said there were parallels in the two consecutive years of controversy. “That’s what happens at a university with differences of opinion,” Kieffer said after Wednesday’s vote.
But he said he was pleased that Saifuddin, who cast the only vote against Oved’s confirmation, nevertheless said the two will work together. The group Students for Justice in Palestine contended that Oved had unseemly connections to Adam Milstein, a businessman who supports Israeli causes and has expressed opinions the regents consider offensive to Muslims.
Milstein donated money to the UCLA Hillel, according to Oved. The Hillel group gave financial support to the campus political slate that included Oved, he said. Oved, whose parents emigrated from Israel, has denied directly taking any of Milstein’s money for his political races and has said opposition to his regent nomination arose because of his anti-divestment stance.
Oved and his supporters note that UCLA has no rules banning donations to student campaigns. Milstein said in a statement Wednesday he was pleased by the regents’ vote but emphasized that neither he nor his family foundation donated to Oved.
The allegations about Oved’s funding were part of an “anti-Semitic smear campaign” meant to intimidate pro-Israel students, he said. Milstein denied that he was anti-Muslim: “The one thing I actually am is pro-Israel.... That, by default, does not make me anything else.”
STUDENTS HOLD up signs spelling out #NOTMYSTUDENTREGENT after Avi Oved was confirmed as student regent designate. | AVI OVED, left, speaking at his confirmation, says Middle East issues are not relevant to key UC issues. Fellow student regent Sadia Saifuddin is at right.
· San Francisco Chronicle · page D6
The students who addressed the regents in San Francisco — and hundreds who signed a petition against Oved — criticized him for accepting donations during a campus election from philanthropist Adam Milstein, whom they called anti-Muslim.
The students were also incensed that the regents denied a request from the UC Student Association, UC’s student government, to delay confirming Oved so his ties to Milstein could be studied further. “This student cannot represent all the students without a conflict of interest,” Marium Navid, 19, a Muslim student from UC Davis, told the regents.
Opponents recently found what they called anti-Muslim tweets from Milstein, head of the pro-Israel Adam and Gila Milstein Family Foundation. “Try to persuade people in Israel that Islam is a peaceful hijacked religion. They would laugh at you,” one tweet said.
Another referred to Palestinian participation in a women’s equality forum as “equal opportunity terrorism.” “Avi Oved confirmed receiving funding from the blatantly Islamophobic Adam Milstein,” UC Davis student Azka Fayyaz, 19, told the regents.
She accused the regents of being “complicit in Islamophobia” by selecting Oved, as students snapped their fingers in support. The Israel-Palestinian conflict is perhaps the most divisive issue among UC students, often manifesting in passionate debates over whether UC should boycott and divest from companies doing business with Israel.
Oved opposes boycott and divestment, and has helped defeat such resolutions at UCLA.
Avi Oved gets a welcome from fellow Regent Eddie Island after being voted in as this year’s student regent. | Student protesters show their displeasure at Oved’s confirmation.
· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha, NE
Israel says its troops’ invasion of Gaza focuses on tunnels An attempted underground attack by Hamas may have been the tipping point THE NEW YORK TIMES JERUSALEM — Israeli tanks rolled into the northern Gaza Strip Thursday night and naval gunboats pounded targets in the south as Israel began a ground invasion after 10 days of aerial bombardment failed to stop Palestinian militants from showering Israeli cities with rockets.
Israeli leaders said the incursion was a limited one focused on tunnels into its territory like the one used for a predawn attack Thursday that was thwarted.
They said it was not intended to topple Hamas, the militant Islamist movement, See Gaza: Page 9 [PHOTOGRAPH CAPTION, under the picture at the left of the page] In Gaza City, Palestinian men attend the funeral of three children who were killed by an Israeli missile strike earlier Thursday.
Hours later, Israeli ground forces crossed the border into Gaza. [credit] THE ASSOCIATED PRESS [SIDEBAR BOX at the right of the page] TIMELINE OF FIGHTING Key events leading to the invasion of the Gaza Strip after 10 days of airstrikes. Page 9A … Continued from Page 1 from its longtime rule of Gaza.
As rockets continued to rain down on Israeli cities, a military spokesman said the mission’s expansion was aimed to ensure that Hamas operatives were “pursued, paralyzed and threatened” as it targeted “terrorist infrastructure” in the north, south and east of Gaza “in parallel.”
However, a ground offensive could quickly lead to military and political entanglements for Israel, especially if more Palestinian civilians are killed. More than 250 Palestinians have already died in the air campaign, including 14 children under age 12 killed over the past two days, Palestinian health officials said. One Israeli civilian has died.
After the early-morning tunnel episode, the day settled into an extended calm as both sides observed a United Nations request for a five-hour humanitarian pause in the fighting. But by 3 p.m., the violence roared back. More than 120 rockets rained on cities throughout southern and central Israel all afternoon and evening.
“We will strike Hamas and we are determined to restore peace to the state of Israel,” the military spokesman, Lt. Col. Peter Lerner, told reporters in a conference call. “It will progress according to the situation assessment and according to our crafted and designed plan of action to enable us to carry out this mission.”
Israel began to call up 18,000 reservists, adding to 50,000 already mobilized in recent days; Lerner said the ground forces would include infantry and artillery units, armored and engineer corps, supported by Israel’s “vast intelligence capabilities,” air force and navy. Fawzi Barhoum, a spokesman for Hamas, called the invasion “a dangerous step.”
“The occupation will pay its price expensively,” he said in a statement referring to Israel, “and Hamas is ready for confrontation.”
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel did not make a public statement Thursday night, but several of his ministers said a unanimous Cabinet had authorized Netanyahu and the defense minister a few days ago to send in ground troops when they deemed necessary.
“With a heavy heart we embarked on this operation, in order to destroy the tunnels, as just this morning we have seen their deadly potential,” said Naftali Bennett, the economy minister and leader of the right-wing Jewish Home party. “Difficult days are ahead of us,” he added. “We are also operating against the rockets and all of the existing threats,
Casualty asymmetry stated plainly in paragraph three - 'More than 250 Palestinians have already died... One Israeli civilian has died' - but the standing head over the page is 'ISRAEL' and the headline's subject is Hamas defiance, not the dead. Nouns: 'Hamas operatives', 'terrorist infrastructure' (in quotes, from the Israeli military), 'Palestinian civilians', 'the Palestinian territory' (caption). 'Occupation' appears once, from Hamas, immediately explained to the reader.
· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha, NE
Israel hasn't released the identity of the suspects in what it calls a revenge attack
The New York Times
JERUSALEM — In the moments before he was kidnapped at dawn on July 2, Mohammed Abu Khdeir, 16, suddenly sensed that there was something suspicious about the two casually dressed Jewish teenagers who were asking him directions.
He tried to move away and call a friend, then shouted and struggled as the two youths forced him into a waiting car driven by an adult relative, according to court documents released Thursday.
The three Israelis who authorities say abducted and killed Mohammed, a Palestinian teenager whose burned body was found about an hour later in a Jerusalem forest, have so far remained nameless and faceless, their identities withheld by authorities.
But the three, a 29-year-old adult and two 16-year-old minors, were charged in a closed Jerusalem court on Thursday with the grisly murder, which Israeli authorities say was a racist revenge attack. The murder indictment presented by state prosecutors on Thursday sheds some light on the backgrounds of the perpetrators.
The adult suspect has an eyeglass store in Jerusalem, lives in a West Bank settlement between Jerusalem and Ramallah and has been treated with psychiatric drugs for years, suffering from obsessive-compulsive disorder, among other illnesses.
The teenagers, one a yeshiva student and the other a yeshiva dropout, according to the documents, would often socialize with their older relative and help him in the store. Mohammed’s death, which came after the abduction and killing of three Israeli teenagers in the West Bank, led to riots in east Jerusalem and in Arab towns across Israel.
It raised questions about the spread of extremist Jewish groups or a new, right-wing terrorist underground. The picture that emerges from the charge sheet presented by state prosecutors is one of amateurish and clumsy killers acting on their own initiative. They argued among themselves during the attack.
The adult, who was driving the car, almost left one of the teenagers behind in the forest in his hurry to flee. After a largely inept effort to destroy evidence, some of it in a park in central Jerusalem, the three went back to the adult’s home in the settlement of Adam, played the guitar and went to sleep.
The car, picked up on security cameras along the route of the kidnapping, was parked outside. Besides the slaying of Mohammed, the adult defendant and the yeshiva dropout have also been charged with trying to kidnap a Palestinian boy in the same area of east Jerusalem the night before Mohammed’s abduction, and with assaulting the boy and his mother.
They have also been charged in connection with car fires; an attempted arson of cars in another East Jerusalem neighborhood and with burning a Palestinian-owned store. The charge sheet details the defendants’ hourslong search in the dark for a “weak” victim in the streets of East Jerusalem, until they came across Mohammed.
After being dragged forcefully into the back of the car, Mohammed struggled with the teenagers as the car sped toward the forest. After Mohammed kicked one of them in the head, he was told he would pay for that. The driver shouted, “Finish him off.” The minors tried to strangle Mohammed, who eventually lost consciousness.
Put this beside the Bennett op-ed on slide 29. Here the New York Times gives a murdered Palestinian 16-year-old his name, his age, the direction he turned, the friend he tried to call, the kick he landed, and the words shouted over him. Five weeks later the Chicago Tribune let Bennett write that Hamas 'kidnaps and slaughters teenage yeshiva students' with no mention of Abu Khdeir, and illustrated it with a photograph of a Palestinian about to be executed. The dek is notable for its distance: 'what it calls a revenge attack' - the paper attributes even Israel's own characterisation. The killers are described as 'amateurish and clumsy', 'largely inept', and the adult's psychiatric history is given in the fifth paragraph; no equivalent individuating detail is given about any Palestinian suspect anywhere in batch B.
· Houston Chronicle · Houston, TX · page A4
Operation Protective Edge targets Hamas infrastructure as death toll nears 250, many of them civilians
By Jodi Rudoren and Anne Barnard / NEW YORK TIMES
JERUSALEM — Israeli tanks rolled into the northern Gaza Strip Thursday night and naval gunboats pounded targets in the south as Israel began a ground invasion after 10 days of aerial bombardment failed to stop Palestinian militants from showering Israeli cities with rockets.
Israeli leaders said the incursion was a limited one focused on tunnels into its territory like the one used for a predawn attack Thursday that was thwarted. They said it was not intended to topple Hamas, the militant Islamist movement, from its longtime rule of Gaza.
As rockets continued to rain down on Israeli cities, a military spokesman said the mission’s expansion was “not time bound” and was aimed to ensure Hamas operatives were “pursued, paralyzed and threatened” as it targeted “terrorist infrastructure” in the north, south and east of Gaza “in parallel.”
As midnight approached Thursday, residents of northern Gaza were cowering in their homes, afraid to answer mobile phones or peek out windows. Some sent text messages reporting that they could hear tank shelling, heavy artillery, and F-16s dropping bombs.
Moussa al-Ghoul, 63, who lives northwest of Beit Lahiya, said his neighborhood had turned into “a war zone” with tanks surrounding his home, having destroyed those of two of his sons. He said shells were landing “everywhere.” Gaza news outlets reported that electricity had been cut to 80 percent of the coastal territory after cables bringing power from Israel were damaged.
The strongest dek in the batch: a U.S. metro putting 'death toll nears 250, many of them civilians' in display type above the fold of its world page. Column 5 also carries, in the paper's own voice, 'The military operation started about 10 p.m., hours after Israel bombed a rehabilitation hospital and an other airstrike killed four children playing on a Gaza City rooftop - an echo of the previous day's bombing that left four young children, all cousins, dead on a beach.' Nouns: 'Palestinian militants', 'Hamas operatives', 'terrorist infrastructure' (both in quotation marks and attributed to the Israeli military), 'the militant Islamist movement', 'the coastal territory'. 'Occupied' does not appear in the paper's own prose; 'occupation' appears once, in the Barhoum quote.
· The Bulletin · Bend, OR
By Jodi Rudoren and Anne Barnard / New York Times News Service
JERUSALEM — Israeli tanks rolled into the northern Gaza Strip on Thursday night and naval gunboats pounded targets in the south as Israel began a ground invasion after 10 days of aerial bombardment failed to stop Palestinian militants from showering Israeli cities with rockets.
Israeli leaders said the incursion was a limited one focused on tunnels into its territory, such as the one used Thursday for a predawn attack, which was thwarted. They said it was not intended to topple Hamas, the militant Islamist movement, from its longtime rule of Gaza.
As rockets continued to rain down on Israeli cities, a military spokesman said the mission’s expansion was “not time-bound” and was aimed to ensure Hamas operatives were “pursued, paralyzed and threatened” as it targeted “terrorist infrastructure” in the north, south and east of Gaza “in parallel.”
As midnight approached Thursday, residents of some sparsely populated farmland in northern Gaza were cowering in their homes, afraid to answer mobile phones or peek out windows. Some sent text messages reporting that they could hear tank shelling, heavy artillery and F-16s dropping bombs.
Moussa al-Ghoul, 63, who lives northwest of Beit Lahiya, said his neighborhood had turned into “a war zone” with tanks surrounding his home, having destroyed those of two of his sons. He said shells were landing “everywhere.” Gaza news outlets reported that electricity had been cut to 80 percent of the coastal territory after cables bringing power from Israel were damaged.
The fullest cut of this wire story in the batch. Two sentences in column 4 are worth keeping: 'Israel seized the territory in the 1967 war and evacuated its settlers and soldiers in 2005, but maintained restrictions on imports, exports and travel for the Palestinians left behind' - 'left behind' is the New York Times's own phrase - and 'The military operation started about 10 p.m., hours after Israel bombed a rehabilitation hospital and another airstrike killed four children playing on a Gaza City rooftop - an echo of the previous day's bombing, which left four young children, all cousins, dead on a beach.' The paper then reports the UN estimate that about three-quarters of those killed had been civilians, 'and about 50 of those were children', and that Palestinian health officials said at least 17 children died in airstrikes on Wednesday and Thursday, 'raising sharp new questions about civilian deaths'. 'Occupied' appears only in Barhoum's quote; 'seized' is the paper's own word.
· Los Angeles Times
For the second consecutive year, the UC regents board is embroiled in an unnecessary and counterproductive controversy over the views of its student representatives on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
On Wednesday, the regents voted to confirm the selection of Abraham “Avi” Oved, a UCLA economics major who will begin his senior year this fall, to be a student representative on the university governing board.
Oved has previously served as the internal vice president of the campus undergraduate student government, and he was the selection committee’s unanimous pick for the regents board due to his thoughtfulness and boundless energy, committee members said.
But Oved is also an active member of student Jewish organizations at UCLA and an opponent of the movement to have the University of California divest its holdings in companies that do business with the Israeli military. That, regrettably, helped incite an effort to stymie his appointment.
Oved’s appointment comes during a period of contentious debate on UC campuses about the Middle East. Last year, for instance, the U.S. Department of Education exonerated UC Berkeley, Irvine and Santa Cruz of allegations of anti-Semitism in connection with protests that some Jewish students felt constituted harassment.
This spring, Students for Justice in Palestine called on UCLA student council candidates not to take trips to Israel under the sponsorship of three pro-Israel groups. College students should be encouraged to engage in civil and respectful debates on all sorts of controversial subjects, including the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
But the resistance to Oved took a turn for the irrelevant and unreasonable.
· Press of Atlantic City · Atlantic City · page 1
Karin Laub and Yousur Alhlou, Associated Press
BEIT LAHIYA, Gaza Strip — Sobbing and shaking, Ismail Abu Musallam leaned against the wall of a hospital Friday, waiting for three of his children to be prepared for burial. They were killed as they slept when an Israeli tank shell hit their home, burying 11-year-old Ahmed, 14-year-old Walaa and 16-year-old Mohammed under debris in their beds.
His personal tragedy is not unique: the U.N. says minors make up one-fifth of the 299 Palestinians killed in 11 days of intense Israeli bombardment of the densely populated Gaza Strip, where half the 1.7 million people are under age 18. The Israeli military says it’s doing its utmost to spare civilians by urging residents to leave areas that are about to be [struck].
Karin Laub again — 1987, 2000, 2014. The record had stopped one sentence before the Israeli military’s account of the same bombardment.
· Anchorage Daily News · Anchorage · page 1
Eight members of a family, including 4 children, were killed in an attack Saturday... no survivors to receive them, witnesses said. There have been many such mass casualties in the 12 days since Israel began its latest offensive
“Eight members of a family, including 4 children, were killed in an attack Saturday… no survivors to receive them, witnesses said. There have been many such mass casualties in the 12 days since Israel began its latest offensive in the Gaza Strip, a densely populated coast…”
The headline has a toll that mounts and an offensive that persists, and neither of those verbs needs a person. Underneath, the reporting names the army in its first independent clause — since Israel began its latest offensive — and counts the family: eight, four of them children. The standfirst does the same. As with the Cincinnati pages of 2009, the difference is not what the paper knew.
· The Day · New London, CT
By JODI RUDOREN / New York Times News Service
Jerusalem — The Gaza-based interior ministry advises its supporters in a YouTube video that whenever talking about the dead, “always add ‘an innocent citizen.’” In Israel, the message is quite different: Those same victims are described as “human shields” sacrificed by the “heartless” Hamas “terrorists” that rule Gaza.
Recently, thousands of Israeli mobile phone users received a text message that bragged: “We forced you to hide in shelters like mice,” while Israelis trade cartoons and satirical videos — one intersperses an Arab political speech with a slobbering goat, another replaces the heads of Palestinian fighters with Angry Birds characters.
And Hamas and the Israel Defense Forces are circulating remarkably similar video clips of exploding buildings with thundering soundtracks that evoke Hollywood thrillers. “Time for revenge has arrived,” warns one Hamas video, in Hebrew.
An Israeli one, making fun of Palestinian accents, says, “Balestine, listen, this is a message to Gaza, we are killing Gaza,” adding, “The IDF is strong! Gaza is weak!” The ground war between Israel and Hamas intensified again Sunday with many more civilians and soldiers dying. But that is only one battlefield.
Another, the clash of narratives, the struggle for domestic and international opinion, is seen by both sides to have long-term stakes as high and perhaps even more lasting than combat on the ground. Propaganda wars have unfolded alongside the battlefield for generations.
But analysts said the latest flare-up between Israel and the Gaza Strip has brought a new level of dehumanizing, hateful language and a muddying of official talking points with incendiary threats, as social media broadcast an explosion of voices, an onslaught of unreliable information, and creative mash-ups of pop-culture icons with war imagery.
Etgar Keret, an Israeli novelist, said he has been troubled by some of the terms favored by journalists, politicians and even friends in Tel Aviv. There is no Hebrew word for “assassination,” Keret said, so killings of Hamas operatives are described with a phrase meaning “focused obstruction.”
Instead of “civilians,” he said, slain children and women are sometimes called “uninvolved.” There is a long history here of such euphemisms. The journalist Amos Elon called it “word laundry,” and David Grossman explored the phenomenon in “The Yellow Wind,” his 1987 study of Palestinian life under Israeli occupation.
“A society in crisis forges for itself a new vocabulary,” he wrote, using “words that no longer describe reality, but attempt, instead, to conceal it.”
The most self-aware clipping in the batch: an American paper printing a story about how both sides launder the words for Palestinian dead, and in doing so using the word 'occupation' in its own voice, in a descriptive clause about a 1987 book. Note the paper's own nouns in the lead are all in quotation marks and attributed - 'human shields', 'heartless', 'terrorists' - which is the opposite of how the Omaha and Chicago pages handle the same vocabulary. Rudoren also reports the casualty line flatly ('many more civilians and soldiers dying') without numbers.
· The Day · New London, CT · page jump from A1
FROM A1 When their troops went in, Israeli military officers say, they were surprised by the tenacity, training and weaponry of their opponents. They said Israeli soldiers were repeatedly hit by Gaza militants firing from windows, employing land mines and setting booby traps. “It was a very hard battle there,” a senior Israeli military official said.
“I have to admit that we were facing good fighters from the other side.” The seven-hour attack by Israeli artillery and tank shells, followed by small-arms gun battles in the streets, left the district in ruins. There were bodies in the streets and gray-faced Palestinians being dug out of the rubble and stacked into ambulances.
Thousands of residents had fled in the middle of the night, many barefoot. The Gaza Health Ministry said 70 Palestinians were killed in the fighting in the Shijaiyah district on the eastern outskirts of Gaza City, the new front line. In all, more than 100 Palestinians died Sunday.
Hamas health officials, in keeping with their practice, did not say whether the dead were civilians or fighters. Sami Abu Zohri, a Hamas spokesman, called the Israeli offensive in Shijaiyah “a massacre” and “a war crime.” More than 445 Palestinians, many of them women and children, have died in the nearly two-week-long offensive.
The Hamas military also announced that its fighters had captured an Israeli soldier. Abu Obaida, a spokesman for the Izzedine al-Qassam Brigades, appeared on Hamas TV to announce that the soldier had been taken prisoner. Minutes later, there were fireworks on the streets and shouts of “God is great!” from loudspeakers in the mosques.
An Israeli military spokesman said the army was investigating the claim and did not confirm the abduction. It was the single worst day so far for Israelis. Israeli military deaths have risen to 18 since the armed forces launched a ground operation Thursday. Two of the Israeli soldiers were U.S. citizens.
The Israeli death toll is now higher than during the Israeli military’s 2009 incursion into Gaza, when 13 Israelis were killed. More than 77 soldiers have entered hospitals countrywide, some of them seriously wounded.
This is the page where an American paper does call Bennett a hardliner, and also prints him floating the overthrow of the Gaza government. The headline, though, belongs to the Israeli soldiers' admiration for their opponents. Column 2 carries the Israeli military's human-shields claim ('Hamas fighters had ordered them not to leave, effectively employing them as human shields, the Israeli official said') followed immediately by the Palestinian rebuttal ('Residents, however, said they had been told to move before by the Israelis, only to return to their homes'), which is better balanced than most of this batch. Column 3 also carries the Red Crescent's two-hour ceasefire and 'seven stretchers were carried out of the rubble' in ten minutes on one street. 'Occupied' does not appear.
· USA Today · McLean · page 1
Hamas, Israel blasted for civilian casualties
Oren Dorell, USA Today
“NEWS ANALYSIS. The deaths of at least 15 Gazans taking shelter Thursday in a United Nations-run school contributed to a Palestinian death toll that has surpassed 700 — and a debate about whether Israel is violating human rights or contending with an enemy that is using human shields.
The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) said it warned the U.N. to evacuate the building, but that the militant group Hamas, which governs Gaza, prevented the evacuation, fired more rockets from the site and also hit the site with its own rockets.
Violence also spread to the West Bank late Thursday, where thousands of Palestinians protesting the Gaza fighting clashed with Israeli soldiers in Qalandia, near the West Bank city of Ramallah.
The deaths Thursday, on the 17th day of fighting in Gaza, come a day after two different U.N. agencies issued condemnations — one of Palestinian militants and one of Israel — for taking actions that endanger civilians. The mounting fatalities are prompting sharp criticism of both Hamas and Israel.
The Jewish state is bearing the brunt of the international outrage because of lopsided fatalities — 20 Palestinians for every Israeli — and graphic images such as four Palestinian children on a beach killed by Israeli strikes. Hamas openly targets Israeli civilians, but has been stymied by Israel’s Iron Dome missile-defense system.
Israel says it takes precautions to limit civilian casualties, even as it executes a military operation in a densely populated, urban environment to stop militants from attacking Israeli communities with rockets and terrorist assault teams. The U.N.
Relief and Works Agency, which runs the school hit Thursday, blasted unnamed militant groups the day before for hiding rockets in an abandoned school situated between two other schools used as shelters by 1,500 people. The discovery was the second time UNRWA discovered rockets in one of its schools.
Its workers found 20 rockets hidden in a school July 16, according to a UNRWA statement.”
“A Palestinian man grieves at the morgue of the Kamal Adwan hospital after a U.N. school was shelled in northern Gaza.” Mahmud Hams AFP/Getty Images
Filed as news analysis, and it sets both accusations out in the same column, including the U.N. agency’s own condemnation of rockets hidden in its schools.
· Telegram & Gazette · Worcester
BEIT LAHIYA, Gaza Strip — In the morgue at a small Gaza hospital, the anguished cries of those who lost loved ones in Israeli airstrikes fell silent Thursday when Ahmed Jadallah began attending to the corpses, one by one, on his wooden work table.
With swift, steady movements, Jadallah swaddled a toddler in a white burial shroud and later gently cleaned the soot-stained face of the child’s father — Islamic rituals that momentarily reassured the grieving.
Father and son had been killed earlier in the day, along with the child’s grandparents and uncle, when an airstrike on an adjacent house sent debris flying into the family’s living room. Over the past three decades, the 75-year-old Jadallah has dressed hundreds of “martyrs” — those killed in conflict with Israel.
He said that his volunteer work fulfills an Islamic commandment and that he hopes it will earn him a place in paradise. Despite his faith, he has found it harder to deal with the casualties from this round of fighting with Israel than from previous ones, especially when children end up on his table.
Nearly 790 Palestinians have been killed, including 190 children, and close to 5,000 wounded in more than two weeks of battle between Israel and Gaza’s Hamas militants, according to Palestinian health officials. “This is the toughest military operation we have witnessed,” Jadallah said at the Kamal Adwan Hospital in the Gaza town of Beit Lahiya.
Jadallah’s life mirrors the area’s turbulent history: the 1948 Mideast war over Israel’s creation; the Israeli capture of Gaza, the West Bank and east Jerusalem in 1967; two Palestinian uprisings, one starting in 1987 and one in 2000; the Hamas takeover of Gaza in 2007; and three rounds of Israel-Hamas fighting in 2008-09, in 2012 and now, in an outbreak that began July 8.
Jadallah was born in 1939 in the Palestinian village of Isdud, in an area that is now part of the Israeli port city of Ashdod. Jadallah and his family fled to Gaza in the 1948 war, eventually settling in the Jebaliya refugee camp, close to the Kamal Adwan hospital.
Palestinian Ahmed Jadallah, 75, prepares a body for burial Thursday at the morgue of Kamal Adwan hospital in Beit Lahiya, northern Gaza Strip.
· The Ledger
Palestinians Accuse Israel, but U.N. Not Sure Who Fired at School
BEIT HANOUN, Gaza Strip | For more than a week, as the war engulfed their homes, families in this northern Gaza town packed up their belongings and children and headed to the one place they presumed would remain safe: the United Nations school. But in the last few days, the war approached there as well.
The Israeli military warned on Monday that the shelter should be evacuated. By Thursday, the U.N. had decided to withdraw its staff and to stop providing food.
Then, as the Palestinians gathered in the courtyard on Thursday, believing they were about to be bused elsewhere, blasts tore through the crowd, killing 16 people and sending scores of wounded, mostly women and children, streaming into local hospitals.
The source of the blasts remained unclear, setting off recriminations between Israelis and Palestinians over which side was responsible. People in the school reported from three to five blasts and accused Israel of shelling them.
Israel suggested that rockets fired by militants might have fallen short of their targets or that the school may have been hit with errant shells from either side in fighting nearby. The U.N. said it could not confirm the source of the blasts.
PALESTINIAN CHILDREN WHO WERE WOUNDED in a strike on a compound housing a U.N. school in Beit Hanoun, in the northern Gaza Strip, are treated as they lie on the floor at the emergency room of the Kamal Adwan hospital in Beit Lahiya on Thursday. — A PALESTINIAN MAN CRIES AFTER BRINGING a wounded child to the emergency room of the Kamal Adwan hospital on Thursday.
Palestinian officials accused Israel of firing at a school housing refugees, but Israel said the school was not a target. Israel suggested rockets fired by militants might have fallen short.
· Oakland Tribune · Oakland
mayhem at a massive demonstration Thursday night, when thousands of Palestinians protesting the Israeli incursion in Gaza clashed with Israeli security forces at the Qalandia border checkpoint between Israel and the West Bank. At least two Palestinians were killed and scores were injured, protest leaders said.
It was one of the largest protests in the West Bank in recent years, underscoring mounting Palestinian anger at Israel and the growing civilian casualties in the two-week-old Gaza conflict.
As the Muslim holy month of Ramadan comes to an end and the conflict rages on, Israeli security officials are concerned that the West Bank and mostly Arab East Jerusalem could become arenas of violent protest. “This is the West Bank waking up and saying, ‘Gaza is not alone,’” Lina Ali, one of the protest’s organizers, said in a phone interview.
Ambulance sirens could be heard in the background. “We stand by Gaza.” As protesters attempted to march from the West Bank city of Ramallah to Jerusalem, Israeli forces fired live rounds, rubber bullets and tear gas into the crowds, according to protest organizers.
Early Friday, an Israeli military spokesman said as many as 10,000 protesters “were rioting violently.” They hurled “burning tires, Molotov cocktails, rocks and even fireworks” at soldiers and border police. After riot-dispersal measures failed, the spokesman said the soldiers fired live rounds into the crowds, killing at least one protester.
The spokesman said the military was looking into the report of a second death. If the Israelis turn out to have fired the deadly salvo on the school in Gaza, international condemnation is likely to be heaped on the Jewish state, already under pressure from the Obama administration to end its 17-day offensive against Hamas, the militant Islamist movement that controls Gaza.
If it turns out Hamas is responsible for killing its own people with errant rocket or mortar fire, as Israel initially suggested Thursday, then the group — already branded a terrorist organization by Israel, the United States and the European Union — could find itself even more isolated.
Witnesses, still shaking from the horror of seeing a refuge turned into a charnel house, said the shelter was filled with families who had fled their homes to escape more than two weeks of heavy shelling in the northern Gaza Strip. As fighting raged around them Thursday morning, a series of explosions first struck the courtyard and then the school, which is run by the U.N.
Relief and Works Agency, known as UNRWA. U.N. Secretary-general Ban Ki-moon called the attack appalling and strongly condemned it. Hamas spokesman Fauzi Barhum called the attack a “war crime” and said it showed that even U.N. shelters “are not immune to Israeli aggression.”
The latest violence raised the Palestinian death toll since the Israeli offensive began to 777, according to Gaza health officials. On the Israeli side, 32 Israeli soldiers, two Israeli civilians and a Thai guest worker have been killed. Soon after the attack, the school in Beit Hanoun was empty, with blood smeared in the corridors and courtyard.
There were sheep running through the corridors, spilled food, abandoned shoes and soiled bandages amid overturned desks and story books. Survivors said they were told to gather at noon to await buses to take them to another UNRWA school that would be safer.
“We were waiting in the courtyard; the buses never came,” said Sabah Kafarah, 17, who cradled her infant nephew in her arms. The boy’s mother was in surgery. All day Thursday, Beit Hanoun was a site of fierce fighting between Israeli troops and Hamas militants.
On the road from Gaza City to Beit Hanoun, large buildings were being consumed by raging fires as rockets from Hamas whistled overhead and Israeli tanks pounded targets. The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) released a statement Thursday evening that helped explain why its forces might have hit the UNRWA shelter.
“From initial inquiries done about the incident, during the intense fighting in the area, militants opened fire at IDF soldiers from the school area,” the statement read. “In order to eliminate the threat posed to their lives, they responded with fire toward the origins of the shooting.”
At the nearby Beit Hanoun Hospital, less than a three-minute drive from the U.N. shelter, crying children were clinging to their mothers as ambulance drivers surged to the door of the emergency room. The hospital director, Ayman Hamdan, said four patients among the first wave of arrivals died on his operating tables. He described massive injuries from shrapnel.
Wounded people were missing limbs, he said. Christopher Gunness, a UNRWA spokesman, said his agency “over the course of the day” had tried to coordinate with the Israeli army a window for civilians to leave, but “it was never granted.”
“Hamas prevented civilians from evacuating the area during the window that the IDF gave them,” the Israeli military countered. More than 140,000 Palestinians — more than 7 percent of Gaza’s total population — have fled their homes because of the fighting, and many of them have sought refuge in buildings run by UNRWA.
Thursday’s attack marked the fourth time that a U.N. facility has been hit since Israel began an operation in Gaza on July 8 in a bid to stop rocket attacks on Israeli soil from the coastal enclave. Two UNRWA schools have been used by Gaza militants to hide weapons and rockets, unbeknown to the agency, officials with the agency said.
A Palestinian family, who fled the U.N. school that was hit Thursday, arrive at the Beit Hanoun hospital. Sixteen people were killed in the attack on the U.N.-run school where civilians sought shelter in northern Gaza Strip. A Palestinian child, wounded in Thursday’s strike, cries at the emergency room of the Kamal Adwan hospital in Beit Lahiya.
Palestinian women grieve over the death of relatives outside the morgue of the Kamal Adwan hospital. The Palestinian death toll in the conflict rose to 777.
· The Olympian · Olympia
BEIT LAHIYA, GAZA STRIP — In the morgue at a small Gaza hospital, the anguished cries of those who lost loved ones in Israeli airstrikes fell silent Thursday when Ahmed Jadallah began attending to the corpses, one by one, on his wooden work table.
With swift, steady movements, Jadallah swaddled a toddler in a white burial shroud and later gently cleaned the soot-stained face of the child’s father – Islamic rituals that momentarily reassured the grieving.
Father and son had been killed earlier in the day, along with the child’s grandparents and uncle, when an airstrike on an adjacent house sent debris flying into the family’s living room. Over the past three decades, the 75-year-old Jadallah has dressed hundreds of “martyrs” – those killed in conflict with Israel.
He said that his volunteer work fulfills an Islamic commandment and that he hopes it will earn him a place in paradise. Despite his faith, he has found it harder to deal with the casualties from this round of fighting with Israel than from previous ones, especially when children end up on his table.
Nearly 790 Palestinians have been killed, including 190 children, and close to 5,000 wounded in more than two weeks of battle between Israel and Gaza’s Hamas militants, according to Palestinian health officials. “This is the toughest military operation we have witnessed,” Jadallah said at the Kamal Adwan Hospital in the Gaza town of Beit Lahiya.
Jadallah’s life mirrors the area’s turbulent history: the 1948 Mideast war over Israel’s creation; the Israeli capture of Gaza, the West Bank and east Jerusalem in 1967; two Palestinian uprisings, one starting in 1987 and one in 2000; the Hamas takeover of Gaza in 2007; and three rounds of Israel-Hamas fighting in 2008-09, in 2012 and now, in an outbreak that began July 8.
Jadallah was born in 1939 in the Palestinian village of Isdud, in an area that is now part of the Israeli port city of Ashdod. Jadallah and his family fled to Gaza in the 1948 war, eventually settling in the Jebaliya refugee camp, close to the Kamal Adwan hospital. “I approach this job from a religious perspective and hope God will reward me for this,” he said.
Under Islamic rules, those who die a natural death are usually washed before burial, while those killed in a holy war are buried as they are, even if bloody, reflecting the idea that they are already pure enough to return to God. “I specialize in martyrs,” Jadallah said.
Jadallah’s job is to wrap them in the customary white burial shrouds, secure the shrouds with strips of cloth according to specific rules and wash their faces. On Thursday, the morgue’s refrigerators held eight bodies of those killed in Israeli airstrikes overnight.
Among the dead were five members of the Abu Aita family from the Jebaliya refugee camp – Ibrahim, 66; his wife, Jamila, 55; sons Ahmed, 31, and Mohammed, 40; and Ahmed’s son Adham, 4.
Their neighbors, the Ajramis, said they had received a warning from the Israeli military early Thursday that their four-story home would be targeted in an airstrike, and they fled with minutes to spare, but word didn’t reach the Abu Aitas in time. The missile badly damaged the Ajrami home, and the debris killed five of the Abu Aitas.
One woman whose husband had been killed in a different airstrike shouted hysterically in the waiting area Thursday, fighting with relatives trying to stop her from seeing his body. They eventually gave in, but she fainted after Jadallah let her look inside the refrigerator.
Two Hamas policemen manned the iron door to the morgue, trying to keep down the number of people getting inside so Jadallah could work. As he pulled a body from a refrigerator and placed it on a large metal tray on the table, one of the policemen called out the name of the dead and asked the closest relatives to come in.
Jadallah ripped narrow strips of white cloth that he draped like belts around each body to secure the burial shroud. Depending on the size of the body, he uses three or five such belts; it has to be an odd number. Jadallah bandaged the heads of those who had suffered grave skull injuries and used water-soaked bandages to wipe soot and blood off the faces.
Once a body was prepared, relatives were called into the morgue and carried out the dead on a stretcher. Some chanted “takbir,” praising God as the Almighty, usually followed by the response “Allahu akbar,” or God is great, as they left with the body.
Jadallah, a father of six, said he shares the pain of those around him, even if he doesn’t betray emotion while working. After handling so many of the dead over the years, he said he finds it hard to forgive Israel, let along consider the possibility of a peace agreement.
Palestinian Ahmed Jadallah, 75, takes a break as he prepares a body for burial at the morgue of Kamal Adwan hospital in Beit Lahiya, northern Gaza Strip, on Thursday.
· The Sacramento Bee · Sacramento · page 1
Nasser Nasser, The Associated Press
“Young Palestinians sit next to candles forming 848 for the number of Palestinians killed in the ongoing war, and the Arabic word for 'Gaza,' at a protest in Ramallah in the West Bank on Friday.” Nasser Nasser, The Associated Press.
· Daily News · New York · page 1
Five words. The thing that kills is a tank, and a tank is a machine, so the sentence has an agent that cannot be held to anything. Twenty people are a family of 20, counted the way a table at a restaurant is counted. None of them is named.
· The News & Observer · Raleigh · page 1
Lefteris Pitarakis, AP
“A Palestinian woman carries her belongings Saturday past houses destroyed by Israeli strikes in Beit Hanoun, northern Gaza Strip.” Lefteris Pitarakis, AP.
· The Bulletin · Bend, OR · page A7
By Jodi Rudoren and Michael R. Gordon / New York Times News Service
JERUSALEM — Under intense diplomatic pressure, Israeli leaders decided late Saturday to extend a halt to hostilities in the Gaza Strip through midnight today, but said their troops would maintain defensive positions and continue to ferret out tunnels from Gaza into Israeli territory.
Hamas, the militant Palestinian faction that dominates Gaza, rejected the extension of the temporary cease-fire requested by the United Nations, after renewing rocket fire on Israel on Saturday evening.
“Any humanitarian cease-fire that doesn’t secure the withdrawal of occupation soldiers from inside Gaza’s borders, allow citizens back into homes, and secure the evacuation of the injured is unacceptable,” Sami Abu Zuhri, a Hamas spokesman, said in a brief statement. It remains unclear how things will unfold.
Twice before in the bloody 19-day battle, Israel embraced cease-fire initiatives only to resume its assault within hours when Hamas did not follow suit. But with the Palestinian death toll topping 1,100 after 147 bodies were recovered from the rubble during Saturday’s lull — and with 42 Israeli soldiers killed in combat — calls for calm have only grown more urgent.
Casualty figures as printed: Palestinian death toll 'topping 1,100 after 147 bodies were recovered from the rubble during Saturday's lull', 42 Israeli soldiers killed in combat. The paper's own nouns: 'the militant Palestinian faction', 'the bloody 19-day battle', 'Israel embraced cease-fire initiatives only to resume its assault'. The word 'occupation' reaches the page in Abu Zuhri's quote and is left to stand.
· The Bulletin · Bend, OR · page A1 and A7
Ishaan Tharoor / The Washington Post
WASHINGTON — It is not that controversial to suggest that the two-state solution — the mantra intoned for decades now by U.S. politicians when speaking of peace between Israelis and Palestinians — is dead. Indeed, a flurry of recent articles and commentary have all said as much.
But as we watch the conflict in Gaza, it’s easy to forget the shadow cast by the lapsed peace process. For more than two weeks, the Israeli military has pummeled the Gaza Strip, home to the militant group Hamas, which has been firing rockets into Israel. Caught in the war zone are 1.8 million Palestinians living in the cramped, impoverished territory.
The resulting carnage has inflamed tensions, led to protests in the West Bank and suggestions that we may see the start of a Third Intifada, or Palestinian uprising. A recent Pew poll shows there is deepening pessimism among Israelis and Arabs about whether they can co-exist peacefully side by side.
Here are some reasons the two-state solution as we know it is dead, all of which echo in the latest tragic round of fighting.
See Two states / A7 Two states Continued from A1 Hamas is dominating the conversation The Islamist organization whose militant wing is now locked in combat with Israel, alongside some other jihadist outfits, has never had any real interest in the two-state solution. As Israelis often point out, its founding charter shows no acceptance of the right of Israel to exist.
And Hamas’ refusal to renounce violence — something the PLO of the late Yasser Arafat and current Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas has done — keeps it firmly in the crosshairs of Israel’s vast security apparatus. [...] Settlements are here to stay Despite being considered illegal under international law, the construction of settlements in the West Bank has continued apace during Netanyahu’s tenure in office.
Settlers form a key constituency for some of the parties in Netanyahu’s ruling coalition, and have led to the rise of far-right politicians like Naftali Bennett, who rejects the idea of an independent Palestinian state.
The settlements are scattered all over the West Bank, as well as in East Jerusalem — which the Palestinians would want as the capital of their independent state — and would pose a permanent challenge to the territorial integrity of a Palestinian state.
The Israelis framed their actions as counter-measures to the Palestinians’ quixotic bids for recognition at the U.N., a symbolic status that speaks to how little leverage Abbas and his negotiators actually have. Much to the ire of the Obama administration, Netanyahu’s government expanded settlement construction even as peace talks were ongoing.
And they unveiled plans to build in areas away from the established “blocks” of settlements that sit not far from the Green Line, the border demarcating the West Bank and Israel.
If Maria reads one clipping from this batch for language, it should be this one. It is the only item in batch B where a U.S. paper says in its own voice, within a few inches of type, that settlements are illegal under international law, that settlers are a governing constituency, that Bennett rejects Palestinian statehood, and that what Netanyahu is describing is occupation. The vocabulary that is quarantined inside Palestinian quotations everywhere else in this batch is, here, simply the reporting. Note also what it does not do: it never uses the word 'occupied' about Gaza, and its Hamas section adopts the standard framing ('jihadist outfits', 'crosshairs'). The AP photograph and caption on the jump page are the only image in batch B of a named-nothing Palestinian woman walking through what was done to Beit Hanoun.
· Goldsboro News-Argus · Goldsboro
Israeli tank shells hit crowded U.N. school.
JEBALIYA REFUGEE CAMP, Gaza Strip — Israeli tank shells slammed into a crowded U.N. school sheltering Gazans displaced by fighting today, killing 15 and wounding 90 after tearing through the walls of two classrooms, a spokesman for a U.N. aid agency and a health official said.
The Israeli military said mortar shells had been fired from near the school, and that soldiers fired back. Later this morning, the Israeli military declared a four-hour humanitarian cease-fire in parts of Gaza beginning at 3:00 p.m. Hamas had no immediate comment.
Israeli airstrikes and shelling also killed 40 Palestinians elsewhere in the coastal territory, including multiple members of two families struck in their homes, health officials said. The new violence further dimmed hopes of a cease-fire.
The strike at the U.N. school in the Jebaliya refugee camp came as part of Israel’s heaviest air and artillery assault in more than three weeks of Israel-Hamas fighting. The Israeli campaign escalated on Tuesday, with airstrikes destroying key symbols of Hamas power, including the home of the top Hamas leader.
Gaza’s only power plant was shut down after shells set its fuel tank on fire. On Wednesday, Israeli aircraft struck dozens of Gaza sites, including five mosques it said were being used by militants, while several other areas came under tank fire. In Jebaliya, tank shells hit the U.N. school before dawn, said Adnan Abu Hasna, a spokesman for the U.N.
Relief and Works Agency. The agency is sheltering more than 200,000 people displaced by the fighting at dozens of U.N. schools across the coastal strip. Assad Sabah said he and his five children were huddling under desks in one of the classrooms because of the constant sound of tank fire throughout the night. “We were scared to death,” he said.
“After 4:30 a.m., tanks started firing more. Three explosions shook the school.” “One classroom collapsed over the head of the people who were inside,” he said. In one classroom, the front wall was blown out, leaving debris and bloodied clothing. Another strike tore a large round hole into the ceiling of a second-floor classroom.
The wall of the lavatories was also damaged. The Israeli military said it fired after its soldiers were targeted by mortars operating from the vicinity of the school. “In response, soldiers fired toward the origins of fire. And we’re still reviewing the incident,” the military said in a statement.
About two hours after the strike, hundreds of people still crowded the school courtyard, some dazed, others wailing. Aishe Abu Darabeh, 56, sat on the ground with her relatives. “Where will we go?” she asked. “Where will we go next? We fled and they (the Israelis) are following us.”
Four of the dead were killed just outside the school compound, two in their home nearby and two in the street, after returning from pre-dawn prayers, their relatives said. The bodies of two members of the al-Najar family, 56-year-old Shaher and his 41-year-old brother, Bassem, were laid out in one of the rooms of their small home, surrounded by wailing relatives.
Outside the gate, another relative held on to his crying son, hugging him tight and saying: “I’m here, I’m not going anywhere.” Abu Hasna, the U.N. agency spokesman, said the international community must step in.
“It’s the responsibility of the world to tell us what we shall do with more than 200,000 people who are inside our schools, thinking that the U.N. flag will protect them,” he said. “This incident today proves that no place is safe in Gaza.” Ashraf al-Kidra, a Gaza health official, said at least 15 people were killed.
A Palestinian girl cries while receiving treatment for her injuries caused by an Israeli strike at a U.N. school in Jebaliya refugee camp, at the Kamal Adwan hospital in Beit Lahiya, northern Gaza Strip today. Associated Press.
· Kenosha News · page A7
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip (AP) — Israel unleashed its heaviest air and artillery assault of the Gaza war on Tuesday, destroying key symbols of Hamas control, shutting down the territory’s only power plant and leaving at least 128 Palestinians dead on the bloodiest day of the 22-day conflict.
Despite devastating blows that left the packed territory’s 1.7 million people cut off from power and water and sent the overall death toll soaring past 1,200, Hamas’ shadowy military leader remained defiant as he insisted that the Islamic militants would not cease fire until its demands are met.
The comments by Mohammed Deif in an audiotape broadcast on a Hamas satellite TV channel cast new doubt on international cease-fire efforts. Aides to Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said Egypt was trying to bring Israeli and Palestinian delegations together in Cairo for new talks in which Hamas would be presented this time as part of the Palestinian team.
Israel’s final objective in Gaza remained unclear a day after Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu warned Israelis to be prepared for a “prolonged” war.
Netanyahu is under pressure from hawkish members of his coalition to topple Hamas in an all-out offensive, but has not let on whether he plans to go beyond destroying Hamas rocket launchers, weapons depots and military tunnels used to infiltrate Israel and smuggle weapons.
Dozens of Israeli airstrikes and heavy tank shelling hit areas across Gaza, which was plunged into complete darkness Tuesday night after a strike on its sole power plant set a fuel tank ablaze.
In the sprawling Jebaliya refugee camp in northern Gaza, at least 24 people — 10 of them from the same family — were killed and dozens wounded in a barrage of tank fire, Hamas health officials said. “Tanks were firing in all directions and shrapnel was flying,” said Moussa al-Mabhouh, a volunteer for Gaza’s Civil Defense.
“Smoke was rising from houses and from nearby workshops.”
Smoke from the explosion of an Israeli strike rises over Gaza City on Tuesday. The death toll in the 22-day conflict between Israel and Hamas topped 1,200.
· Leader-Telegram
By McClatchy Newspapers
RAMALLAH, West Bank — Three weeks into Israel’s bombing campaign of the Gaza Strip, West Bank Palestinians and Israeli Arabs are beginning to display the kind of fury and cohesion that Israel hasn’t seen since the so-called second intifada, or uprising — a 5-year-long grind of violence, notorious for suicide bombings and brutal crackdowns.
In the West Bank, the Ramallah municipality has papered billboards with signs that read, “We are all Gaza.” A large screen hanging on a building downtown shows a nonstop montage of children suffering in the coastal enclave. Last week, 10,000 Palestinians marched on an Israeli checkpoint at Qalandiya in the West Bank, hurling firebombs and burning tires.
Arab citizens of Israel have staged demonstrations in Nazareth, Haifa, Umm el-Fahem and Sakhnin. They’ve declared a general strike. In Jerusalem, groups of Arab demonstrators have clashed repeatedly with police in the Old City and in east Jerusalem neighborhoods, leading to hundreds of arrests.
At the beginning of the Israel-Gaza escalation, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas tried to tamp down tensions. After three Israeli teens disappeared in the West Bank in mid-June, Abbas offered full cooperation to the Israeli security forces who made sweeping arrests in the West Bank.
Once the teens’ bodies were discovered outside Hebron and Hamas began firing rockets into Israel, Abbas urged a diplomatic solution to the crisis and asked Hamas, “What are you trying to achieve by sending rockets?”
But last week, with the death toll in Gaza mounting daily — the overwhelming percentage of the dead civilians — Abbas swung to Hamas’ position.
In a speech in Ramallah on July 22, he adopted Hamas’ demands for a cease-fire, including ending the seven-year Israeli and Egyptian blockade of Gaza, releasing prisoners who’d been rearrested after being freed in exchange for captured Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit and expanding fishing rights.
“No one in the world will live in safety and stability while the children of Gaza, Jerusalem, the West Bank and Palestinian children everywhere do not live in safety and stability,” Abbas said. Two days later, at least 10,000 Palestinians took to the streets in Ramallah.
One of the organizers, Mohamad Rabah, said he was inspired to see so many countrymen marching alongside him. At age 28, he’s never been to Gaza or Jerusalem. “I was proud that all the people got united,” said Rabah, who works with young people in Ramallah. “I felt we are connected with Gaza again.”
· Ellsworth American · Ellsworth · page 1
Nancy Kandutsch, Surry
“Apologists for Israel protest any criticism — saying that Israel warns the Palestinians in Gaza about five minutes before they bomb people’s homes. Well, that is the exact same policy the Jewish people who had settled in Palestine pursued on the eve of their announcement that they were about to declare an Israeli state in 1948.
Groups of Jewish men drove around Palestine in pickup trucks armed with rifles and equipped with loudspeakers, which they employed to warn Palestinians in their homes to get out and flee to the mountains, because if they locked their doors, the doors would be dynamited and the residents inside shot.
Most of the Palestinians heeded the warnings as the loudspeakers also broadcast tapes of a village that was shot up the previous day — including sounds of screaming residents.”
A reader’s letter; the account of 1948 is the writer’s own. Collected with the genocide search but the word does not appear. Kept for what it says about 1948.
· The Daily Advertiser · Lafayette · page 1
Blasts kill dozens; residents thought cease-fire in place
Two sentences and four agents, none of them a person. Shells hit, blasts kill. The only people with a verb in the whole block are the residents, and what they do is thought — they thought there was a ceasefire. On the facing page the same paper ran a photograph of a girl in Jabalia over a caption that counted 1,300 dead (CP-2014-011).
· The Daily Advertiser · Lafayette
Mohammed Saber, EPA
“A Palestinian girl takes cover in Jabalia, Gaza. More than 1,300 Palestinians have died.” Mohammed Saber, EPA.
A girl pressed against a yellow wall with her hand at her mouth. Two sentences: what she is doing, and how many have died. Not been killed — died. The photographer is named and she is not. Printed the same day as the same paper’s headline about shells that hit and blasts that kill (CP-2014-010).
· Daily Dispatch
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Nearly a month into Israel’s fierce assault on Hamas in Gaza, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas is facing mounting domestic pressure to seek war crimes charges against Israel at the International Criminal Court. He has hesitated in the past because such a move would instantly put the Palestinians on a risky collision course with Israel.
But with about 1,400 Palestinians killed in Gaza, according to health officials, Abbas has signaled he might move ahead — cautiously. Palestinian officials said Thursday that Abbas asked all Palestinian political factions, including Hamas and the smaller group Islamic Jihad, to give their written consent to such a move.
Different PLO factions signed up in a meeting in the West Bank earlier this week, while Abbas is still waiting for a response from Hamas and Islamic Jihad, they said.
In trying to make a case against Israel, Abbas could also expose Hamas, a bitter rival turned potential political partner, to war crimes prosecution because it has fired thousands of rockets from Gaza at Israeli communities over the years.
A Palestinian medic holds two children, wounded during fighting between Israeli forces and Hamas militants near a compound housing a U.N. school in Beit Hanoun, in the northern Gaza Strip, as other medics treat serious cases Thursday at the emergency room of the Kamal Adwan hospital in Beit Lahiya.
Correction: The caption read 4 August 2014. The scan prints "Friday" with 1 August 2014, which was a Friday; 4 August was a Monday.
· Johnson City Press · Johnson City · page 1
Dennis Prager, On Point
“In order to justify killing Jews, Jew-haters throughout history made up libels about the Jews that were so awful that they justified, at least for the Jew-hater, the mass murder of Jews. The charge that the Jews of every age — not just some Jews at one time — killed God Himself was used by medieval Christians to justify mass murdering of Jews.
Then came another grotesque libel — what is known as the blood libel. Also prevalent in the Middle Ages, this charged Jews with kidnapping Christian children, sacrificing them and using their blood to bake matzo (the unleavened Passover bread).
Later libels against the Jews included the forgery known as ‘The Protocols of the Elders of Zion,’ which purported to prove that Jews plotted to rule the world.
At this very moment, we are living through as enormous a libel — directed not against all Jews, but against the Jewish state: Israel is committing genocide of Palestinians and is, therefore, morally identical to the Nazi regime. This libel is spread by left-wing radicals and by Muslims, especially in the Middle East.
Some examples: On a popular radio show in Italy, that country’s most famous philosopher, Gianni Vattimo, was asked whether he would like to see more Israelis killed. Vattimo responded: ‘Of course.’ He then added that Israel is ‘a bit worse than the Nazis ...
I’d like to shoot those bastard Zionists ... and [Europeans should raise money] to buy Hamas some more rockets.’ The prime minister of Turkey, Recep Erdogan, told CNN International, ‘What Israel does to Palestine and to Gaza right now has surpassed what Hitler did to them. ... We do not accept this genocide by Israel.’
The foreign minister of Iran, Mohammad Javad Zarif announced: ‘These [Israeli] actions cannot be considered anything other than genocide and crimes against humanity.’
Ilan Pappe, an Israeli leftist who is director of the European Centre for Palestine Studies at the University of Exeter, wrote an article titled ‘Israel’s incremental genocide in the Gaza ghetto’ on the Electronic Intifada website.
On July 9, when a total of 63 Gaza Palestinians had been killed, Al-Arabiya reported that ‘Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas told a crisis meeting in Ramallah ... that Israel is committing “genocide” in Gaza during its military offensive which has so far killed at least 50 Palestinians.
“It’s genocide by Israel against our Palestinian people.”’ In a column published by Al-Jazeera, Abukar Arman, former Somali ambassador to the United States, wrote that ‘Israel has defeated North Korea for the rogue state par excellence award.’
Nicolas Maduro, president of Venezuela, and Evo Morales, president of Bolivia, labeled Israel’s invasion of Gaza ‘genocide’ and Maduro added that it was ‘extermination.’ For the record: Israel attacked Gaza solely in response to hundreds of rockets sent by Hamas to kill as many Israelis as possible.
When Israel gave Gaza over to the Palestinians, it did not embargo essentials such as cement. But none of the millions of tons of cement allowed, or later smuggled, into Gaza were used to building schools or hospitals. They were used to build tunnels to smuggle terrorists into Israel and to hide rockets. The charter of Hamas calls for the annihilation of Israel.
Israel is the only country in the world targeted for annihilation. Though Israel is charged with engaged in genocide against Palestinians, in the last 20 years, the number of Palestinians has doubled; and since Israel’s founding in 1948, the Palestinian population has grown five-fold. It must surely rank as the least effective genocide in world history.”
The case against the word, made in an American syndicated column in 2014, which assembles eight separate uses of it by heads of state, ministers, academics and an Israeli historian in order to argue against it. The archive holds it because the argument is part of the record. “Charged with engaged in” is the paper’s.
· Kalamazoo Gazette
BEIT LAHIYA, GAZA STRIP — In the morgue at a small Gaza hospital, the anguished cries of those who lost loved ones in Israeli airstrikes fell silent when Ahmed Jadallah began attending to the corpses one by one on his wooden work table.
With swift, steady movements, Jadallah swaddled a toddler in a white burial shroud and later gently cleaned the soot-stained face of the child’s father, who had been killed in the same strike. The 75-year-old volunteer prepared them for burial according to Muslim tradition.
Over the past three decades, Jadallah has dressed hundreds of “martyrs,” those killed in conflict with Israel. “This is the toughest military operation we have witnessed,” Jadallah said at the Kamal Adwan Hospital in the Gaza town of Beit Lahiya.
More than 1,500 Palestinians have been killed, including 190 children, since Israel launched its offensive in Gaza on July 8, according to Palestinian health officials.
Palestinian Ahmed Jadallah, center, 75, prepares a body for burial at the morgue of Kamal Adwan hospital in Beit Lahiya, northern Gaza Strip, on July 24. Over the past three decades, the 75-year-old Jadallah has dressed hundreds of ‘martyrs’ — those killed in conflict with Israel. (Lefteris Pitarakis/AP)
· Chicago Tribune · Chicago
Without new tack, another war is assured
The Tribune's editorial page during the 2014 Gaza war, masthead and all.
· The Register-Guard · Eugene, OR · page A9
Thomas Friedman
KIBBUTZ EIN HASHLOSHA, Israel — At 6:02 a.m. Saturday, the air raid siren sounded over Tel Aviv. I was rousted by the hotel staff from my room and ushered into the windowless service elevator area with two French families, everyone in their pajamas. After 10 minutes, when the Hamas missile threat had passed, we were allowed to go back to our rooms.
As I slipped back into bed, the hotel loudspeaker bellowed, “Dear guests, you may return to your routine.” With Israel and Hamas winding down their latest war, I could only wonder whether the hotel manager was also speaking to them. Is that it?
More than 60 Israeli soldiers and some 1,800 Hamas fighters and Gazans — many hundreds of them children and civilians — killed, and everyone just goes back to their routines? I don’t think so. Some new and significant things were revealed here.
Folio confirms label exactly: “The Register-Guard · Thursday, August 7, 2014 · A9.” Signed at foot: “Thomas Friedman is a columnist for The New York Times.” The Winter passage reads in full: “The Times of Israel reported that, at the start of this war, ‘in an official dispatch sent to battalion and company commanders on July 9, Givati Brigade commander Colonel Ofer Winter’ — one of Israel’s top officers on the Gaza front — ‘told his subordinates that ‘History has chosen us to spearhead the fighting against the terrorist ‘Gazan’ enemy which abuses, blasphemes and curses the God of Israel’s defense forces.’’ Frightening.” No Palestinian is quoted anywhere in the column.
· Lincoln Journal Star · Lincoln · page 1
LOCAL VIEW
Ruth Raymond Thone, Lincoln
“‘How long, oh Lord?’ is my worn-out response to the vicious racist genocide raging in the Middle East between Israel and the Occupied Territories of Palestine. More than a thousand Palestinians have been killed so far in this latest grueling war between ancient peoples on the lands of Palestine usurped for the Jewish state 50-some years ago.
The dead and injured include women and children holed up in supposedly safe and protected areas of the open-air prison of Gaza, 1.8 million people crammed into 139 square miles of the noncontiguous area that makes up approximately 20 percent of the original land left to Palestine at the founding of Israel.
The Israeli death toll stands under 50 after 10 days of rocket firing from Gaza the first weekend in August.
The United States supplies Israel with its weapons — we are the largest munitions supplier in the world — and both the Palestinian Authority and Hamas are supplied through tunnels on the border with Egypt, weapons mostly provided by Russia and Iran… The father of a large Islamic family, most of whom were killed in a recent bombing, Abdul Karim, buried his dead and declared, ‘I am against violence and killing from both sides.
The Israeli children are precious for me. Our children are precious for us.’ Both parties to this bitter war are being used as proxies by other countries the world over.”
A named local columnist, with her photograph, in a mainstream regional daily, with the word bare in the headline and Palestinians as the subject. The column closes with two quotations attributed to David Ben-Gurion; they are the columnist’s attributions, printed as opinion under the heading LOCAL VIEW, not reporting.
· Republican and Herald · Pottsville · page 1
“Ahmad Baraka, 25, a Palestinian worker at Al Awda snack food factory, inspects the damage at the burned factory in Deir el-Balah, central Gaza Strip.
The factory owner, Mohammed al-Telbani, lost his life’s work during the Gaza war after Israeli shells slammed into his four-story factory, one of Gaza’s largest, sparking a fire that engulfed vats of margarine and sacks of cocoa powder.” Associated Press.
Two men named in one caption, with their jobs: the worker and the owner.
· The Idaho Statesman
As another Israel-Hamas truce is tested, it’s clear any lasting deal likely hinges on a port for Gaza
BY KARIN LAUB / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
GAZA CITY — The issue of a Mediterranean seaport has been a main point of contention in this week’s Egyptian-brokered talks in Cairo on a long-term truce between the enemies, including new border arrangements for Gaza.
On Wednesday, Israel and Hamas agreed to extend a temporary cease-fire for five days to allow for those negotiations to continue, but minutes before the original cease-fire was set to expire, violence spiked, with Palestinian militants firing five rockets at Israel and Israel targeting sites across the Gaza Strip in response.
The extension was meant to grant both sides additional time to figure out a road map for the coastal territory, but the new attacks put that at risk. If talks do continue, the port will be a vital component.
Hamas is seeking an end to a crippling blockade imposed by Israel and Egypt in 2007, one that has greatly limited the movement of Palestinians in and out of the territory of 1.8 million people. It has also restricted the flow of goods into Gaza and blocked virtually all exports. Israel says the closure is necessary to prevent arms smuggling.
A member of the Palestinian delegation at the Cairo talks said a proposal this week calls for easing at least parts of the blockade. “We would like to see more cross-border freedom, and also to have the question of a Gaza seaport and airport discussed,” he said. A Palestinian-controlled seaport could transform lives.
Only about 13,000 Gaza residents with special clearance, such as medical patients and traders, are able to leave the territory each month through land crossings.
Palestinian fishermen and others take part in a protest against Israel’s blockade in May, the most recent large demonstration. Associated Press file
· Great Falls Tribune · Great Falls · page 1
Roberto Schmidt, AFP/Getty Images
“Palestinian children release helium-filled balloons with notes of good will attached to them Sunday at a UN school in Jabalia in the northern Gaza Strip, where Palestinians who have been displaced by violence in Gaza have sought refuge.” Roberto Schmidt, AFP/Getty Images.
· Chicago Tribune · Chicago, IL
By Naftali Bennett
On the surface, Israel’s ongoing conflict with Hamas in the Gaza Strip appears to have nothing to do with other events taking place right now in the Middle East. The world tells us that we have a unique conflict with the Palestinian terror organization.
Hamas, we are told, simply wants freedom — a lifting of the blockade over Gaza, the opening of all crossings and regular money transfers for salaries. In reality, we are told, Hamas is a political organization, one that we should sit down with and negotiate a peaceful resolution.
Not far from Gaza though — in Syria and Iraq — another conflict is taking place, although in this case there are no doubts as to what needs to be done. Leaders from across the free world are united in their decision that the Islamic State, also known as ISIS, needs to be crushed and destroyed.
No one has recommended a cease-fire — we’ve already tried 11 which Hamas has violated as of Friday — and no one recommends meeting ISIS leaders in a third country for negotiations (we’ve spent the past two weeks trying to negotiate with Hamas via Egyptian mediators in Cairo). When it comes to ISIS, war is war, evil is evil and ISIS needs to be eliminated.
The situation is black and white. What the free world fails unfortunately to understand is that Israel’s conflict with Hamas and the current battle to stop ISIS’ advances in Syria and Iraq are one and the same. Both Hamas and ISIS are radical Islamic organizations. ISIS wants to establish a caliphate throughout the world.
Hamas wants to do the same in Israel while openly calling and actively working for the destruction of our state along the way. Its charter makes no secret of this. These are organizations motivated by religion, not by nationalistic aspirations, and they do not hesitate to use extreme violence to advance and achieve their goals.
While ISIS beheads journalists and adversaries, Hamas kidnaps and slaughters teenage yeshiva students. While ISIS targets minority groups in Iraq, Gaza’s Christian community has mostly disappeared after being persecuted and targeted by Hamas Islamist thugs.
Members of Fatah — Hamas’ rivals — have long been ousted from Gaza, some thrown from the rooftops of buildings just to get a point across.
The one clipping in batch B where Bennett writes the copy himself in a major American daily, and it is the harshest page in the batch. The paper supplied the illustration: a Reuters photograph of a Palestinian about to be executed by Hamas, captioned flatly. This record answers the question of whether American papers softened Bennett - here the Tribune did not mediate him at all; it handed him the page and the pictures. Nouns on this page: 'the Palestinian terror organization', 'Hamas Islamist thugs', 'radical Islamic organizations'. 'Occupied' does not appear. 'Palestinian' appears as an adjective attached to terrorism, and once, in the caption, as a man about to be killed.
· The Register-Guard · Eugene
“Neither side gained anything worth fighting for when the longest and deadliest of conflicts between Israel and Gaza ended Tuesday.”
Eugene, Oregon, at the end of the 2014 war. Neither side gained anything is the paper's summary of fifty days in which the casualty counts were not symmetrical.
· Las Cruces Sun News · Las Cruces, NM
By Karin Laub, The Associated Press
RAFAH, GAZA STRIP >> The first of August dawned as a day of promise for the Mahmoum clan and thousands of other Palestinians stuck in United Nations shelters in Rafah — thanks to a temporary cease-fire with Israel they could go home for three days.
But the expected respite quickly turned into one of the deadliest and most controversial episodes in the recent war between Israel and Hamas in the Gaza Strip. After just two hours, amid fear that Hamas had captured an Israeli soldier, the Israeli military sealed off the Rafah area and began shelling.
By the end of the next day, 190 Palestinians were dead, according to a list of names compiled by two Gaza human rights groups, including 14 members of the Mahmoum family. The Rafah operation is almost certain to be a focus of U.N. investigators and rights groups looking into possible war crimes because it highlights a key concern: The treatment of civilians.
A Palestinian rights group argues that the Israeli army violated the rules of war, which include giving adequate warning to civilians, using proportionate force and distinguishing between civilians and combatants. Unlike in many other Gaza battles, civilians were caught by surprise by the sudden fire and sealed exits.
“None of the rules of international humanitarian law was observed,” said Mahmoud Abu Rahma of the Al Mezan rights group. The Israeli military confirmed that Rafah residents were barred from leaving the area on Aug. 1, but declined comment on the war crime allegations.
It denied firing into a densely populated area without regard for civilians, saying precise airstrikes hit targets linked to militants and artillery — though inherently inaccurate — was only aimed at open fields. Late on Aug. 2, the suspected capture of the soldier turned out to be a false alarm, and the Rafah episode is one of several under internal military review.
“If we accidentally or mistakenly targeted a civilian situation, it was a mistake, and we are very sorry about that,” an officer from the army’s Southern Command said on condition of anonymity as he wasn’t authorized to speak on the record.
Answers Maria’s slide-44 question directly: the clipping does discuss the Hannibal Directive and NAMES it. The page prints: “At 9:36 a.m., Winter announced over the field radio the word nobody wanted to hear: ‘Hannibal.’ Hannibal is the name for the military protocol to be followed if a soldier falls into enemy hands. The aim is to stop the capture, even if it means loosening open-fire regulations.” It does not use the phrase “Hannibal Directive” or “Hannibal Procedure” — just “Hannibal” and “the military protocol.” The page also prints Winter ordering all forces to take territory “so that the kidnappers couldn’t move,” 500 artillery shells over eight hours, and about 100 airstrikes on Aug. 1 and 2. Israeli soldiers named: Maj. Benaya Sarel, Liel Gidoni, 2nd Lt. Hadar Goldin (combatants, so not listed under named_individuals).
· Bristol Herald Courier · Bristol, VA
The Associated Press
RAFAH, Gaza Strip — The first of August dawned as a day of promise for the Mahmoum clan and thousands of other Palestinians stuck in United Nations shelters in Rafah — thanks to a temporary cease-fire with Israel they could go home for three days.
But the expected respite quickly turned into one of the deadliest and most controversial episodes in the recent war between Israel and Hamas in the Gaza Strip. After just two hours, amid fear that Hamas had captured an Israeli soldier, the Israeli military sealed off the Rafah area and began shelling.
By the end of the next day, 190 Palestinians were dead, according to a list of names compiled by two Gaza human rights groups, including 14 members of the Mahmoum family. The Rafah operation is almost certain to be a focus of U.N. investigators and rights groups looking into possible war crimes because it highlights a key concern: The treatment of civilians.
A Palestinian rights group argues that the Israeli army violated the rules of war, which include giving adequate warning to civilians, using proportionate force and distinguishing between civilians and combatants. Unlike in many other Gaza battles, civilians were caught by surprise by the sudden fire and sealed exits.
The Israeli military confirmed that Rafah residents were barred from leaving the area on Aug. 1, but declined comment on the war crime allegations. Late on Aug. 2, the suspected capture of the soldier turned out to be a false alarm, and the Rafah episode is one of several under internal military review.
The following account is from interviews with Palestinian survivors and the Israeli military, along with events witnessed by The Associated Press.
Same AP story as slide 44 but a much longer run with the Palestinian survivors kept in. It names Hannibal the same way: “At 9:36 a.m., Winter announced over the field radio the word nobody wanted to hear: ‘Hannibal.’ Hannibal is the name for the military protocol to be followed if a soldier falls into enemy hands.” Also prints: 121 Palestinians killed in Rafah on Aug. 1 and 69 on Aug. 2 per the Palestinian Center for Human Rights and Al Mezan; the dead included 55 children, 36 women and five men over 60; more than 2,140 Palestinians killed in the war, three-fourths civilians, against 72 Israelis, all but six of them soldiers. One sentence refers to “Hamad” (“Hamad has no idea where her son’s remains lie”) — that person is not introduced anywhere in the visible text, so she is not listed; the introducing passage may be in a part of the page cut off in the scan.
· Albuquerque Journal · Albuquerque · page 1
A 'permanent' cease-fire has been declared in Gaza...
Taylor Jones, El Nuevo Día / caglecartoons.com
An editorial cartoon by Taylor Jones for El Nuevo Día. The line above the drawing reads “A ‘permanent’ cease-fire has been declared in Gaza…” Below it a dove carrying an olive branch stands in a field of rubble, asking “IS ANYBODY HOME?”
· The Herald (Jasper, Indiana)
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — The Israeli navy arrested four Palestinian fishermen and seized their boat today, a Gaza official said, in one of the first instances of friction between the sides since the Gaza war ended last month. The incident occurred off the northern Gaza town of Beit Lahiya, said Nizar Ayyash of the Gaza Fishermen’s Union.
He provided no additional details. The Israeli military said two vessels were involved in the incident. It said the vessels were operating outside of their permitted maritime limit, and after ignoring requests to move closer to shore, were boarded by naval personnel and seized. Israel and Hamas-led militants in Gaza ended 50 days of intensive fighting Aug.
26 and committed to enter into indirect truce talks in Cairo aimed at developing a sustainable roadmap for the future of the densely-populated coastal territory. As part of the cease-fire deal that halted the fighting, Israel doubled the maritime area in which Gaza fishermen are permitted to operate from three to six miles.
Israel has also hinted at its willingness to consider an additional doubling of the maritime area permitted to Gaza fishermen as part of its efforts to improve overall economic conditions there.
But it remains wary of allowing the fishermen open-ended access to the Mediterranean Sea, fearing their boats could be used to smuggle weapons and weapons-manufacturing materials for use by Hamas militants.
· The Courier (Louisiana)
Mohammed Daraghmeh / The Associated Press
RAMALLAH, West Bank — The deputy Palestinian prime minister said Tuesday that international donors are hesitant to pay for the reconstruction of the Gaza Strip so long as Hamas remains in control there and the specter of future wars looms.
Mohammed Mustafa, a top official in the West Bank Palestinian Authority, said international bodies are eager for President Mahmoud Abbas’ Fatah forces to take on a leading role in Gaza in the wake of a 50-day war between Israel and Hamas that killed more than 2,000 people.
With Hamas still committed to Israel’s destruction and with an arsenal of rockets still at its disposal, the donors are wary of rebuilding, Mustafa said. This summer’s war was the third in less than six years. “Some donors say why sponsor Israeli wars in Gaza every two years,” Mustafa said.
“Some donor countries are concerned because of the atmosphere on the ground ... because the reconstruction is not possible without enabling the (Palestinian) government to take the lead in all aspect of life in Gaza.”
Mustafa said despite the obstacles, the Palestinian Authority had launched a relief plan for Gaza and will call for a donor conference in Egypt next month. Egypt announced late Tuesday the conference, co-sponsored by Norway, would be held Oct. 12.
Meanwhile, in Gaza, the Israeli navy arrested four Palestinian fishermen and seized their boat Tuesday, a Gaza official said, in one of the first instances of friction between the sides since the Gaza war ended last month. The incident occurred off the northern Gaza town of Beit Lahiya, said Nizar Ayyash of the Gaza Fishermen’s Union. He provided no additional details.
· The Free Lance-Star · Fredericksburg · page 1
CONFLICT ›› DESTRUCTION IS THE SUBJECT
Hamza Hendawi, Associated Press, Gaza City
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Palestinian filmmaker Khalil Mozayen’s latest work was already complexly layered — a movie within a movie about a director and screenwriter producing a film about an honor killing in the Gaza Strip.
Then the latest Gaza war burst in to add yet another layer: An Israeli airstrike leveled the 13-story apartment tower where Mozayen’s office, studio and archive were located. So he filmed the mountain of rubble and used it for the final scene of his movie, “Sarah 2014.”
Mozayen had hoped to create a film not connected to the Israeli–Palestinian conflict.
But he and his screenwriter, Naim al–Khatib, said they decided they couldn’t avoid addressing the war. “It is like, as a Palestinian, you don’t have the right to have your own dream, that everything in your life has to have something to do with war and [Israeli] occupation,” said al–Khatib, who also plays the fictional screenwriter in the movie. “The occupation crashed our privacy… and the war became an integral part of the film’s ending,” he said.
The themes and reality of war impose themselves on Gaza’s small but vibrant arts scene, and the latest war has been a powerful inspiration for its artists in their new work.
The section header above the headline reads CONFLICT ›› DESTRUCTION IS THE SUBJECT. The story beneath it is about a screenwriter saying he is not permitted a subject other than destruction. The bracketed word in his quotation is the paper’s own. Both photographs on the page are credited to Palestinian Associated Press photographers, Basel al-Maqosui and Khalil Hamra; the top image is al-Maqosui’s own photograph paired with a painting by Pablo Picasso.
· The Anniston Star · Anniston · page 1
Somini Sengupta, The New York Times, United Nations
“The Palestinian president, Mahmoud Abbas, accused Israel on Friday of failing to negotiate in good faith, said any return to negotiations would be ‘naïve at best’ and called on the Security Council to press for a specific deadline to end Israeli occupation.
‘It is impossible and I repeat — it is impossible — to return to the cycle of negotiations that failed to deal with the substance of the matter and the fundamental question,’ Abbas said at the annual session of the General Assembly, reading from a prepared text but visibly enraged.
‘The time has come to end this settlement occupation.’… The fighting this summer damaged more than 100 U.N. schools and hospitals… The United Nations said 2,150 Palestinians, including 500 children, were killed.
On the Israeli side, 67 soldiers and six civilians, including one child, were killed… Abbas described the Israeli occupation as ‘an abhorrent form of state terrorism and a breeding ground for incitement, tension and hatred.’”
Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas addresses the General Assembly at the United Nations’ headquarters, Friday. Richard Perry/New York Times.
· Chicago Tribune · Chicago
Saud Abu Ramadan and Jonathan Ferziger
A Palestinian and an Israeli byline on the same story about reconstruction, two months after the 2014 war.
· The Boston Globe · Boston
RAMALLAH, West Bank — The Palestinian unity government will hold its first Cabinet meeting in Gaza this week, a key step toward taking charge of reconstruction efforts in the war-battered territory, a senior official said Monday.
The Cabinet will convene Thursday, said Deputy Prime Minister Mohammed Mustafa, three days before an international pledging conference where the Palestinian government will seek about $4 billion in aid for Gaza, hit hard in a 50-day war this summer between Israel and the Islamic militant group Hamas.
Donor countries view the unity government of independent experts, led by Western-backed Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, as key to any reconstruction plans. Hamas, which is shunned as a terrorist group by the international community, has governed Gaza for seven years.
The purpose of the Gaza meeting is to see the situation on the ground and to send a message to the donors’ conference that the government is ready to start reconstruction soon, Mustafa said. Hamas seized Gaza from Abbas in 2007, prompting a border closure of Gaza by Israel and Egypt.
After Egypt tightened the closure last year and stepped up its destruction of cross-border smuggling tunnels, Hamas began experiencing severe financial difficulties that made it increasingly difficult for the group to govern. This year, Hamas agreed to hand over authority to a temporary unity government reporting to Abbas, though it refused to disband its security forces.
The unity government has not yet started operating in Gaza. Mustafa said that’s about to change. “The government is for both the West Bank and Gaza, and it’s time to start operating in Gaza despite the difficulties,” he said in a phone interview.
The unity Cabinet, headed by Prime Minister Rami Hamdallah, will meet in Abbas’ former residence in Gaza, Mustafa said. Abbas has not set foot in Gaza since the Hamas takeover, and it remains unclear when he might return. More than 60,000 homes and more than 5,000 businesses were destroyed or damaged during the latest Israel-Hamas war, which ended in late August.
Palestinian children play in the back of motorized rickshaws in the Shejaiya section of Gaza City.
· The Boston Globe · Boston
Prime minister sets no date for Stockholm action
JERUSALEM — Israel summoned the Swedish ambassador to the Foreign Affairs Ministry here on Monday to protest the announcement by the new center-left government in Stockholm that it intended to recognize the state of Palestine.
The prime minister of Sweden, Stefan Lofven, declared in his inaugural address on Friday that Sweden would take the step, without specifying when, though he also emphasized that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict can be resolved only through negotiations “in accordance with the principles of international law.”
Sweden would be the first major member of the European Union to recognize Palestine, although some East European countries did so during the Cold War, before they joined the union.
Israel fears that Swedish recognition could lead other major European countries to follow suit, a trend Israeli officials argued would preempt the results of future negotiations over a Palestinian state within agreed borders.
Countering the Israeli criticism, the Swedish foreign minister, Margot Wallstrom, wrote on her Twitter account on Monday that “two less unequal partners would facilitate negotiations.” She added, “We must respect Israeli emotion — but we are prepared to lead the way.”
Speaking on Israel Radio before the meeting at the Foreign Ministry, Carl Magnus Nesser, the Swedish ambassador to Israel, said that there was no date yet for Sweden’s recognition of the state of Palestine but that “it will happen within the not-too-distant future.”
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel criticized the policy on Sunday, saying in a statement: “Unilateral moves are contrary to agreements. They will not bring peace closer; they will distance it.”
· Arizona Daily Star · Tucson · page A19
By Areej Hazboun, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
MAJD AL-KRUM, Israel — Their goal is to win Arab Idol, the Arab world's premiere television song competition.
But the journey Manal Mousa, 25, and Haitham Khalaily, 24, have taken from their villages in Israel to the competition in Lebanon could comprise a television drama of its own — featuring travel to an enemy country, Israeli security interrogations and the complicated identity crisis of Israel's Arabs.
The two singers are competing for more than just fame: they want to be a part of the cultural world that has been largely off-limits to them because of the decades-long Arab-Israeli conflict. “This is a chance for Haitham,” said Waheeb Khalaily, Haitham's father, in his home in Majd Al-Krum, a village in the Galilee in northern Israel.
“For the Arab world and the whole world to hear him and say that he represents a Palestinian people that clings to its land.” In the bitter conflict between Israel and its Arab neighbors, Arab-Israelis are stuck in the middle. Though citizens of the Jewish state, they share the ethnicity, language and culture of the Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
Arabs who remained in Israel after its creation in 1948, and their descendants, today make up 20 percent of the population. Many identify as Palestinians rather than Israelis, watch Arab satellite television and dream of traveling throughout the Middle East. But their Israeli citizenship bars them from most Arab countries because Israeli passport holders are prohibited entry.
That includes the Lebanese capital of Beirut, where many Arab stars are born. When the show held its first-ever auditions in the West Bank in March, the lure of making it big was too tempting for Mousa and Khalaily to worry about borders.
They, and other young Arab singers in Israel, drove past Israeli military checkpoints to stand in line with hundreds of Palestinians for videotaped auditions. Mousa, Khalaily and two dozen others advanced to the next round in Beirut the following month.
The Israeli-Lebanese border is sealed, so the two used their Israeli passports to cross into neighboring Jordan where they boarded a plane for Beirut. At the Lebanese airport, they presented travel documents that the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank issued especially for the trip, a Palestinian interior ministry official said.
In Beirut, they passed all three rounds of auditions and were chosen to be among the 26 final contestants from around the Arab world — the first time Arabs from Israel have ever been selected for the show.
After Mousa and Khalaily returned to Israel in May to wait for the show's taping, Israel's Shin Bet intelligence service summoned them for interrogations about their travel, their families said. Their Israeli passports were confiscated and they were told the passports would be revoked for up to three months, the families said.
Through the help of rights groups, their passports were returned within days, Mousa's family said. The Shin Bet did not respond to a request for comment. Israel has sentenced Arab-Israelis in the past on charges of traveling abroad to conspire with militant groups for attacks against Israel or to fight alongside rebels in Syria.
The same month the two singers traveled to Lebanon, Israel arrested a 23-year-old Arab-Israeli journalist returning from a conference there. Officials initially thought he was recruited by militants but later dropped the suspicion.
Travel to Lebanon is punishable under Israeli law by four years in jail or paying a fine, said Aram Mahameed, a lawyer from the Arab-Israeli rights group Adalah, whom Khalaily's family consulted after the contestant was interrogated. “It is a law against the Arabs in Israel to disconnect them from other Arabs in the Arab countries,” said Mahameed.
Though Jewish and Arab Israelis have faced indictment for traveling to Lebanon, their trials generally do not proceed unless they are accused of other crimes, he said, adding that Jewish Israeli journalists who have gone to Lebanon have not been questioned upon their return.
Mousa and Khalaily are now in Beirut taping the show, which is airing weekly on the Arab satellite channel MBC. Show producers said in a statement that contestants were unavailable for media interviews due to “exhausting preparations and tight production deadlines.”
Last year, Lina Makhoul, an Arab-Israeli, won on the Israeli TV singing show The Voice, but her success has been confined to Israel. By contrast, when Mohammed Assaf, a Palestinian from Gaza, won Arab Idol last year, he catapulted to fame, and he continues to perform before audiences throughout the Middle East, the United States and Europe.
It is unclear whether the two contestants' Israeli connection will affect their chances. Some in the Arab world perceive Arabs in Israel as traitors. Others sympathetically view Israel's Arabs as those who remained while others fled or were driven out in the 1948 war surrounding the end of the British Mandate of Palestine and the establishment of the Jewish state.
Mousa's sister, Sabren, said her family feels “100 percent” Palestinian. “We live in Israel that was originally Palestine. I feel very proud … that we did not give up our lands,” she said from their home in the Galilee village of Deir Al-Assad in Israel's north.
Though some fans in the contestants' home base know by word of mouth that they live in Israel, viewers wouldn't know by watching the show. Banners on the screen label them as hailing from Palestine, and the show makes no reference to their connections to Israel.
Palestinian singer Manal Mousa, 25, is an Arab-Israeli caught in an international drama. / Palestinian singer Haitham Khalaily, 24, ignored risks to audition.
Printed on the WORLD page. Both photographs credited MBC.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis, MO
Nobel Peace Prize winner Malala Yousafzai said she will donate $50,000 to a U.N. agency in the effort to rebuild damaged schools in Gaza. Yousafzai, an advocate for worldwide access to education, was awarded the World Children’s Prize on Oct.
29 and promptly said she would donate the prize money to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees to assist its efforts to repair schools damaged by this summer’s fighting in Gaza.
“We must all work to ensure Palestinian boys and girls, and all children everywhere, receive a quality education in a safe environment,” said Yousafzai, a 17-year-old Pakistani, in remarks posted on the UNRWA website. “ Because without education, there will never be peace.” In the Gaza conflict this summer, UNRWA schools served as civilian shelters.
Several schools were shelled, killing dozens of civilians and workers. UNRWA officials accused Israel of targeting schools, but Israel denied the claim while acknowledging that some of its shells had hit schools.
However, rockets were found stored in UNRWA schools and then subsequently disappeared, leading to Israeli accusations that agency officials had given them back to Hamas.
Four paragraphs: the first three carry Yousafzai’s gift, the fourth turns to rockets stored in UNRWA schools and Israeli accusations against agency officials. ‘Several schools were shelled, killing dozens of civilians and workers’ is the only account of the dead, with no agent named in that sentence.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis, MO
JERUSALEM — Sweden officially recognized the state of Palestine less than a month after its new prime minister said it would. The recognition, Foreign Minister Margot Wallstrom said in a statement published Oct. 30 in the Dagens Nyheter daily, “is an important step that confirms the Palestinians’ right to self-determination.
Sweden’s traditionally close ties with the State of Israel are now complemented by an equal relationship to the other party.” Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Liberman in a statement called the move an “unfortunate decision which strengthens radical elements and Palestinian recalcitrance.” Seven European Union members already have recognized a Palestinian state.
They are Bulgaria, Cyprus, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Malta, Poland and Romania. Iceland also has done so.
A clean example of the brief-length pattern across this paper in the batch: a foreign official’s supportive statement is quoted at length, then an Israeli minister’s rebuttal closes the item. No Palestinian is quoted about the recognition of Palestine.
· Telegram and Gazette · Worcester, MA
JERUSALEM — Israeli defense officials say a career officer with deep experience battling Hezbollah guerrillas in Lebanon has been selected as the country's next military chief, succeeding Lt. Gen. Benny Gantz. Maj. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot is Israel's deputy military chief.
He has held key posts during a three-decade career, including the military's head of operations, its West Bank commander and military secretary to former Prime Minister Ehud Barak.
Eisenkot developed a reputation as being level-headed during a war against Hezbollah in 2006 and was put in charge of the northern command, which is responsible for the border with Lebanon, after the widely criticized war ended in a stalemate.
The whole brief is transcribed; this is the entire clipping. The appointment story summarises Eisenkot's career — Northern Command, the 2006 Lebanon war, head of operations, West Bank commander — and characterises him as "level-headed", with no mention of the Dahiya doctrine he had articulated in October 2008 from exactly that Northern Command post. This is the clearest case in the batch of an American paper introducing Eisenkot to readers while leaving out the thing he is best known for.
· South Florida Sun Sentinel · Fort Lauderdale, FL
J. Zel Lurie
This column is being written on Dec. 4, my 101 birthday. There will not be a big party tonight like the one that marked my first century. Only five members of my family will be there, but a couple of hundred residents of Harbors Edge will dance and frolic on my birthday. There will be little talk here about the new Israeli elections scheduled for March 17.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s right wing coalition government was doomed from the start. Its twenty month reign was the shortest of any Israeli government. Netanyahu was forced to give up his traditional ally, the ultra religious Shas Party by Yair Lapid and Naftali Bennett.
They pushed through the Knesset a law that canceled the automatic draft exemption of ultra religious youth. Once this law was passed the right wing coalition split. Naftali Bennett who represents the Jewish settlers on the West Bank came out strongly against any move toward peace.
Netanyahu who had campaigned against a peace settlement in the 2012 elections reversed himself in words but not in action. He broke up the peace negotiations advocated by U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry. Mr.
Kerry greeted the announcement of new elections by saying he hoped that the new elections would “produce the possibility of a government that can negotiate and move toward resolving the differences between Israelis and Palestinians.” The two-state solution is not dead, as Naftali Bennett wrote in an op-ed piece in the New York Times a few weeks ago.
The new elections are Israel’s last chance to revive it. The average Israeli revels in the slogan “the whole world is against us.” The five European nations who voted symbolically to recognize the Palestinian state, are not against Israel. They oppose Netanyahu and the Jewish settlements in the West Bank.
Let us remember that the West Bank and the Gaza Strip comprise 28% of Mandatory Palestine that the U.N. partitioned 50/50 in 1947. Let us remember that since 1967 Arabs in the West Bank have been oppressed by army occupation. Let us remember that Mahmoud Abbas, president of the Palestinian Authority has come out strongly for peace that will protect Israel’s security.
His intelligence branch has succeeded in squelching a potential third intifada. The violence of the last few months in which 11 Israelis were killed occurred in East Jerusalem where Palestinian intelligence has been banned. Meanwhile a real enemy has developed on the Syrian border.
Opinion, not reporting - and that is where the word 'occupation' turns up. Lurie also gives the only land-proportion figure in batch B and is the only writer here who credits Palestinian security cooperation. Note his own framing: 'Arabs in the West Bank', not Palestinians, in the sentence about occupation. He describes Bennett as the man 'who represents the Jewish settlers on the West Bank' and as having 'came out strongly against any move toward peace' - blunter than anything in the staff or wire copy in this batch.
· South Florida Sun Sentinel · Fort Lauderdale, FL
Ben Cohen
A winter of discontent is brewing in America.
Over the last fortnight, large parts of the country have seethed with anger, first at the decision of a grand jury in Ferguson, Mo., not to indict police officer Darren Wilson for the shooting of Michael Brown — 18 years old, and black — and second, at the decision of a grand jury in New York not to indict Daniel Pantaleo, the Staten Island police officer who placed Eric Garner — 43 years old, and black — in the chokehold that contributed to his death minutes later.
The proximity, in terms of timing, of the two killings, together with the proximity of the grand jury decisions, has dealt a blow to the artfully simplistic notion that with Barack Obama’s election as president in 2008, America entered a new, post-racial era.
Many Americans now believe that, as far as law enforcement is concerned, the lives of African-Americans — and particularly those of African-American men trying to eke out a living at the margins of the economy — are worth far less than the lives of everyone else. Moreover, it’s a belief that is spreading.
Those persuaded that there were enough procedural and moral ambiguities in the Brown case are finding it hard to reach the same conclusion in the Garner case, because we’ve all seen the video of the New York Police Department officers rounding on Garner, and we’ve all heard the pitiful plea of “I can’t breathe” as he was wrestled to the ground.
And I’m pretty positive I was not alone in reacting to Officer Pantaleo’s claim that he was trying to protect Garner from being injured by his colleagues with an inner groan of contempt.
In this charged environment, no mental gymnastics are required to understand why slogans like “Black Lives Matter” — something that really shouldn’t have to be said in a civilized, democratic society — become so appealing. But therein lies the danger.
Talk to some of the protesters (or just read the signs they carry), and you will walk away with the impression that police forces across the U.S. are targeting African-Americans with all the zeal of a Haitian death squad.
So, instead of discussing policy remedies regarding policing methods in those African-American neighborhoods where distrust between the cops and the community reigns supreme, and instead of trying to understand the degree of racial bias that informed the actions of the police officers in the Brown and Garner cases, we default to the overarching explanation that America is an irredeemably racist society.
Logged because of the headline, not the body. Across the visible portion the column never mentions Palestinians at all - the word appears only in the headline, which frames Palestinian solidarity at Ferguson protests as a hijacking. The argument itself is on page 46 and is not in this batch, so I can report the framing but not the case. Worth retrieving the jump before this one is used for anything. Note that this and the Lurie column (slide 30) face each other in the same opinion section: one says Palestinians in the West Bank are 'oppressed by army occupation', the other calls Palestinian politics an extremism that hijacks American grief.
· Los Angeles Times · page AA4
By Larry Gordon
Members of the union that represents UC students who work as teaching assistants, tutors and readers have voted to urge the UC regents to divest itself of stock in Israeli institutions and international companies that backers say violate human rights and aid the occupation of Palestinian territories.
In results announced Wednesday by the UAW 2865, about 65% of the 2,160 votes cast in the union’s referendum approved the divestment policy and asked that it apply to all financial holdings of the university and of the UAW’s international parent union. The ballot measure also called for the U.S. government to end military aid to Israel.
The UC regents have said they have no intention of such a sell-off of investments. But the issue nevertheless has roiled UC campuses as several student governments, including UCLA last month, have taken pro-divestment stances after much debate. Jewish and pro-Israel organizations worked to defeat the union measure and those by the student governments.
UAW 2865, which bargains for about 13,000 student workers, also asked its voting members whether they would take a personal and non-binding pledge not to participate in research, exchanges or conferences sponsored by Israeli universities “complicit in the occupation of Palestine.”
About 53% of those who voted, or 1,136, anonymously said they would do so, according to the union. Union officials emphasize that such steps would not entail boycotts of individual faculty members from Israel; they also pledged to keep their opinions about the Middle East out of UC classrooms.
Katy Fox-Hodess, a UC Berkeley graduate student who is on the union’s statewide executive board, said members know that regents are not likely to divest but felt it was still important to express opposition to Israeli policies. “We hope to continue to build this movement at UC,” she said.
“We see this as another step for the university and the international union to divest.”
· Kitsap Sun
RAMALLAH, West Bank – The Palestinian government blamed Israel on Thursday for the sudden death of a Cabinet minister, citing preliminary autopsy results — disputed by Israeli pathologists — that he died from a blow during a confrontation with Israeli troops.
The contradictory interpretations of a joint autopsy on the minister, Ziad Abu Ain, threatened to further inflame tensions between Israel and the Palestinian Authority, amid demands from an angry Palestinian public to halt security cooperation with Israeli forces in the West Bank.
Pathologists disagreed on the main cause of death, with Palestinian doctors saying the 55-year-old Cabinet minister died from a blow to the body and Israeli doctors saying he had a heart attack. “The results of the autopsy show that the ones who killed the martyr Ziad Abu Ain are the Israeli occupying forces,” Palestinian Health Minister Jawad Awad said.
Despite the findings, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas appeared in no rush to comply with demands to halt security coordination with Israeli forces. The policy is highly unpopular, particularly at times of heightened tensions.
However, the alliance of Israeli and Palestinian security forces against a shared foe, the Islamic militant Hamas, has helped ensure Abbas’ continued rule in the autonomous areas of the West Bank.
Abbas has also been leery of turning a strained relationship with Israel into a confrontational one, despite repeated warnings that he would seek international sanctions against Israel in the absence of meaningful talks on Palestinian statehood.
Abu Ain died Wednesday following a confrontation between Palestinian protesters and Israeli soldiers that included pushing and shoving. At one point, a member of Israel’s paramilitary border police grabbed Abu Ain by the throat and pushed him. Troops also fired tear gas during the clashes. Several minutes after the scuffle, Abu Ain collapsed.
He received first aid and was evacuated, but died en route to a hospital. An autopsy was conducted later Wednesday by Palestinian, Jordanian and Israeli pathologists. Citing preliminary findings, Palestinian pathologist Dr. Saber Aloul, said Thursday that “the cause of death was a blow, and not natural causes.” Dr.
Chen Kugel, the chief Israeli pathologist, said Abu Ain died of a heart attack. “The cause of death can definitely be determined,” he told Israel TV’s Channel 10. “He died as a result of bleeding ... in an artery that supplies blood to the heart, or in simple terms, a heart attack.”
Members of the Palestinian national security forces carry the body of Palestinian Cabinet member Ziad Abu Ain during his funeral in the West Bank city of Ramallah on Thursday. Israeli and Palestinian pathologists disagreed on Abu Ain’s cause of death.
· The Daily Times · Mamaroneck
“Last week, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas signed papers to join the International Criminal Court… the first step to seeking war crimes charges against Israeli leaders.”
An American editorial board advising Palestinians against using a court.
· The Abilene Reporter-News · page 6B
Divestment of Israel push gets traction
By Rachel Zoll Associated Press
NEW YORK — The lecture hall had filled quickly. Several students arrived wearing kaffiyehs, the traditional Palestinian headscarves, while in the front row, a young man sat draped in the Israeli flag. As the meeting opened, a student government officer reviewed the rules of debate, warning physical confrontations would not be tolerated.
“We want this to be safe for everyone,” she said.
It was time for a ritual that has become increasingly commonplace on many American college campuses: A student government body, in this case at the University of California, Davis, would take up Israeli policy toward the Palestinians, and decide whether to demand their school divest from companies that work with the Jewish state.
In the United States, Israel’s closest ally, the decade-old boycott-divestment-sanctions, or BDS, movement is making its strongest inroads by far on college campuses. No U.S. school has sold off stock, and none is expected to do so anytime soon.
Still, the current academic year is seeing an increasing number of divestment drives at colleges and universities, stretching from the University of California system to Northwestern University and beyond. Since January alone, student governments at four universities have taken divestment votes.
While the campaigns unfold around resolutions largely proposed by chapters of Students for Justice in Palestine, outside groups have become increasingly involved — from American Muslims for Palestine and the Quakers’ American Friends Service Committee, on one side, to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, or AIPAC, on the other.
At some campuses, candidates for student government are being asked their views on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The heated rhetoric has led to claims of anti-Semitism and of infringement on free speech.
“I don’t think anyone is surprised when they hear a BDS movement is coming,” Ira Stup, a 2009 Columbia University graduate and former director of J Street U, the college arm of the liberal pro-Israel lobby J Street, which opposes BDS. “It’s becoming a regular occurrence.” “It’s creating a debate.
It’s creating a significant amount of conversation in the entire community and it’s set on the terms the activists want it to be set on,” said Rahim Kurwa, a doctoral candidate and member of Students for Justice in Palestine at the University of California, Los Angeles.
Northwestern University students celebrate after the Associated Student Government Senate passed a Northwestern Divest-sponsored resolution in Evanston, Ill., on Feb. 19. The resolution asks the university to divest from six corporations the resolution’s sponsors say violate Palestinians’ human rights.
· Ponca City Daily Courier
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip (AP) — Israeli naval forces shot a Palestinian fisherman dead Saturday off the coast of Gaza, a Palestinian health official said. Tawfiq Abu Riala, 32, was killed and two other Gaza fishermen were arrested, said Ashraf al-Kidra, a Gaza health ministry spokesman.
The Israeli military said its forces identified a number of vessels that had “deviated from the designated fishing zone” and ordered them to halt their progress. When the vessels did not comply, the forces opened fire at their engines to stop them, the military said. It was not clear how the fisherman ended up in the line of fire.
Israel maintains a naval blockade of the Gaza Strip to prevent the smuggling of weapons to the coastal strip’s Islamic Hamas leaders and other militant groups that operate in the territory. Following last summer’s 50-day war in Gaza, Israel agreed to double the permitted fishing zone for Gazans to six nautical miles.
It recently also loosened restrictions to allow Gaza fishermen to export their catch to the West Bank for the first time since 2007.
· Tri-City Herald · Kennewick · page 1
Nicholas Kristof, New York Times News Service, Gaza City
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — It is winter in Gaza, in every wretched sense of the word. Six months after the latest war, the world has moved on, but tens of thousands remain homeless — sometimes crammed into the rubble of bombed-out buildings. Children are dying of the cold, according to the United Nations.
Rabah, an 8-year-old boy who dreams of being a doctor, walked barefoot in near-freezing temperatures with his friends through the rubble of one neighborhood. The U.N. handed out shoes, but he saves them for school… The suffering here has multiple causes. Israel sustains a siege that amounts to economic warfare on an entire population.
Hamas provokes Israel, squanders resources and is brutal and oppressive in its own right. Egypt has closed smuggling tunnels that used to relieve the stranglehold, and it mostly keeps its border with Gaza closed… Yet I have to acknowledge that Israel’s strategy of collective punishment may be succeeding with a sector of the population.
Gazans aren’t monolithic in their views any more than Americans, but many said that they were sick of war and of Hamas and don’t want rockets fired at Israel for fear of terrible retribution. “I don’t want resistance,” said Khadra Abed, a 50-year-old woman living with her family in the remains of her home.
“We’ve had enough suffering.” Halima Jundiya, a 65-year-old matriarch who says the children in her family are still traumatized by war, was blunt: “We don’t want Hamas to fire rockets. We don’t want another war.”
One bearded young man said he worked for Hamas but had turned against it, because government salaries were no longer being paid. “I hate Hamas,” he said, which seemed an odd thing for a Hamas officer to say. Yet Israel should understand clearly that its bombings also put some on the path to becoming fighters.
A 14-year-old boy, Ahmed Jundiya, is part of the same clan as Halima, but he draws the opposite conclusion… “War made us feel we will die anyway, so why not die with dignity,” Ahmed told me. “I want to be a fighter”… “I will give my soul to kill all Israelis,” he said.
Some of that is teen bravado, and some may reflect the unfortunate reality that, if you’re a teenage boy, one of the few career paths available is as a fighter… Israel and Egypt both have legitimate security concerns in Gaza… but the Israeli human rights organization Gisha notes that it’s ridiculous for Israel to insist that the ongoing economic stranglehold is essential for security.
Gisha introduced me to Aya Abit, 24, who is married to a Palestinian man in the West Bank. They have a 5-month-old baby whom the father has never seen because Israel won’t allow Abit to leave Gaza.
“I cry every day,” she says… I found that Israel had bombed Telbani’s factory repeatedly during the war… “They burned $22 million for no reason,” he replied indignantly. “What I created in 45 years, they destroyed in less than two hours. What should I tell them? Thank you?”
“This is the worst time ever,” he added. “People have nothing to lose. So I expect another war.”
A column that argues against several things this archive documents and several it does not. It calls Hamas brutal and oppressive in its own right, quotes a Hamas officer saying he hates Hamas, grants Israel and Egypt legitimate security concerns, and quotes a fourteen-year-old saying he would give his soul to kill all Israelis. The record held only the sympathetic half of it until 22 September 2026.
· StarNews (Wilmington, North Carolina)
By Matthew Duss and Michael A. Cohen For The Washington Post
The Israeli-Palestinian peace process – the one that is supposed to end with a two-state solution – is on life support.
Both sides in the conflict have made their share of missteps, but Benjamin Netanyahu, Israel’s prime minister, all but pulled the plug earlier this month by pledging during his re-election campaign that Palestine would never become a state on his watch. He reaffirmed the sentiment even as he dialed back the rhetoric after the vote.
This position runs directly counter to U.S. national security goals. A two-state solution has been an American goal for nearly two decades. In a 2002 speech, George W. Bush became the first president to explicitly call for the creation of an economically sustainable, demilitarized Palestinian state.
“The establishment of the state of Palestine is long overdue,” he said in 2008. “The Palestinian people deserve it. And it will enhance the stability of the region, and it will contribute to the security of the people of Israel.” Today, virtually all American politicians, on both sides of the aisle, publicly support this outcome.
But with Netanyahu standing in its way, how can the United States advance this goal? By recognizing the state of Palestine. This is not about punishing Israel; it’s about advancing U.S. national security.
Recognizing Palestine would, by helping the two-state cause, address a key source of resentment toward the United States, making it easier for American policymakers to pursue other priorities in the Middle East, such as preventing an Iranian nuclear weapon, defeating the Islamic State and strengthening regional security partnerships.
· Kalamazoo Gazette
By Rachel Zoll The Associated press
The lecture hall had filled quickly. Several students arrived wearing keffiyehs, the traditional Palestinian headscarves, while in the front row, a young man sat draped in the Israeli flag. As the meeting opened, a student government officer reviewed the rules of debate, warning physical confrontations would not be tolerated.
“We want this to be safe for everyone,” she said.
It was time for a ritual that has become increasingly commonplace on many American college campuses: a student government body, in this case at the University of California, Davis, would take up Israeli policy toward the Palestinians, and decide whether to demand their school divest from companies that work with the Jewish state.
In the United States, Israel’s closest ally, the decade-old boycott-divestment-sanctions, or BDS, movement is making its strongest inroads by far on college campuses. No U.S. school has sold off stock and none is expected to do so anytime soon.
Still, the current academic year is seeing an increasing number of divestment drives at colleges and universities, stretching from the University of California system to Northwestern University and beyond. In January, student governments at four universities have taken divestment votes.
In the past week, students at Loyola University in Chicago became the latest college to approve a resolution.
While the campaigns unfold around resolutions largely proposed by chapters of Students for Justice in Palestine, outside groups have become increasingly involved — from American Muslims for Palestine and the Quakers’ American Friends Service Committee, on one side, to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, or AIPAC, on the other.
At some campuses, candidates for student government are being asked their views on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The heated rhetoric has led to claims of anti-Semitism and of infringement on free speech.
“I don’t think anyone is surprised when they hear a BDS movement is coming,” said Ira Stup, a 2009 Columbia University graduate and former director of J Street U, the college arm of the liberal pro-Israel lobby J Street, which opposes BDS. “It’s becoming a regular occurrence.” “It’s creating a debate.
It’s creating a significant amount of conversation in the entire community and it’s set on the terms the activists want it to be set on,” said Rahim Kurwa, a doctoral candidate and member of Students for Justice in Palestine at the University of California, Los Angeles.
In this photo provided by the The Daily Northwestern, Northwestern University students celebrate after the Associated Student Government Senate passed a Northwestern Divest-sponsored resolution last month. The resolution asks the university to divest from six corporations the resolution’s sponsors say violate Palestinians’ human rights.
(AP Photo/The Daily Northwestern, Nathan Richards)
· The Press · page 1
Elmhurst teen spends spring break bringing diabetes supplies to Middle East clinic
By F. Amanda Tugade
ELMHURST — Seventeen-year-old Gabriella Stinsa spent her spring break doing something just a little bit different… Tony Stinsa, Gabriella’s father, said his daughter was diagnosed with Type 1 Diabetes when she was 7 years old… The teen said she looked to her grandfather, Isa Nasr, for direction in planning her trip. Her grandfather left the Middle East during the 1960s, and after settling in Illinois, he never had the chance to return to his home in the West Bank.… What sparked Gabriella’s interest in the organization is its Palestine Diabetes Institute, a clinic built in 2009 in Al-Bireh, a town near the center of the West Bank in Israel… Mohamed said diabetes is a serious problem in Palestine.
He explained because of poverty, those affected are not able to afford the necessary supplies to help manage and treat the disease.… Gabriella and her father explained with insurance, it costs about $1 to $2 to purchase blood test strips, needles and insulin.
Those with diabetes have to measure their blood sugar level about six to eight times a day… They were able to raise $3,000, which paid for least 2,000 blood test strips and about 20 blood glucose meters… “Even the smallest change can make a big difference.”
Gabriella Stinsa, 17, of Elmhurst visits the Palestine Diabetes Institute to donate diabetic medical supplies.
What it costs to stay alive with a chronic condition under occupation, counted in test strips: six to eight readings a day, at a dollar or two each, in a place the story itself says people cannot afford them. Three thousand dollars raised on a basketball bracket bought two thousand strips and twenty meters. The paper places Al-Bireh in Israel.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles
World Now
Batsheva Sobelman
The Palestinian Authority has a new goal in its efforts to isolate Israel internationally: a ban from world soccer.
The head of FIFA, the Swiss-based international soccer federation, arrived in Israel this week for meetings aimed at resolving the simmering sports conflict, which may resonate more with Israeli sports fans than Palestinian efforts to use the United Nations or the International Criminal Court to back Israel into a diplomatic corner.
FIFA President Sepp Blatter, however, said he was hopeful that he could find some resolution that would satisfy both sides. “Football shall connect people and not divide people,” he said earlier as he headed into the meeting.
Jibril Rajoub, a former Palestinian politician and current head of the Palestinian Football Assn., has been campaigning for two years to suspend Israel from FIFA. His proposal is scheduled for a vote in the FIFA's 65th congress convening in Zurich, Switzerland, on May 29.
In a column published in Britain's Guardian newspaper, Rajoub called on FIFA to uphold its anti-discrimination policy and suspend Israel, citing heavy government restrictions and even attacks on Palestinian athletes.
“While Israel continues to participate in FIFA matches internationally with impunity, Palestinian football players have been shot and arrested, our football association raided by Israeli army forces,” wrote Rajoub.
Although Israel's High Court issued an advisory saying that passage for athletes should be more favorably weighed than for other Palestinians, they nevertheless have faced restrictions. “Sport is a vehicle of goodwill among nations,” Israeli President Benjamin Netanyahu told Blatter as the two met in his Jerusalem office.
Stressing that Israel was already acting on several of FIFA's concerns to assist Palestinian football and prepared to discuss further ways of helping, Netanyahu cautioned that introducing politics to the international association could destroy it. Such a suspension would not be unprecedented, however.
Apartheid-era South Africa was suspended by FIFA, as well as much of the rest of the international sports community.
SEPP BLATTER, the head of international soccer's governing body, helps inaugurate a new soccer stadium in the West Bank during his visit to the region.
Printed in a page-wide roundup headed FROM OUR BLOGS, in a column beside items on fast-food television advertising, a Stan Lee memoir and a Pew survey on personal privacy. Photo by Majdi Mohammed, Associated Press.
· Daily American Republic · Poplar Bluff, MO · page 7A
By KARIN LAUB and FARES AKRAM / Associated Press
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip (AP) — Emad Firi is angry. During last summer’s Israel-Hamas war, a shell slammed through the roof of his house and shredded his right leg. Unable to work, Firi’s son now drives his taxi but the family struggles to survive. The 50-year-old blames Israel, but also the Islamic militant group Hamas which has ruled Gaza since a violent takeover in 2007.
In the Hamas era, the tiny territory has endured three wars with Israel and a crippling Israeli-Egyptian border blockade that keeps most of its 1.8 million residents trapped. “Who is not angry about this difficult situation?” Firi said, waiting at a rehabilitation clinic to finally to be fitted with an artificial leg.
But the people of Gaza won’t rise up — some out of fear, he said. “If I say two words, I may go to prison,” he says, as Hamas has little tolerance for dissent and often detains critics. “So we stay silent.”
A year after the most destructive war in Gaza yet, Hamas remains in control — despite signs of mounting frustration and a poll indicating half the residents would emigrate if borders were open.
No alternative to Hamas rule has emerged, after deep-seated rivalries between Hamas and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas derailed attempts to set up a unity government in both the West Bank and Gaza. Hamas can also rely on unwavering support from about one-third of the population, polls indicate.
At the same time, Israel and Egypt have signaled a policy shift, from trying to weaken and perhaps topple Hamas, including by enforcing the blockade over the past eight years, to containing the group. Egypt’s military temporarily opened the border crossing with Gaza in recent days.
Thousands left Gaza for the first time in months, while shipments of desperately-needed cement entered the territory. Egypt said it acts according to changing security assessments, while Hamas officials said they were promised a further easing.
Meanwhile, Israel relaxed its stringent movement restrictions for Gaza residents, amid reports that foreign diplomats are carrying messages between Israel and Hamas on a long-term cease-fire deal. Israeli officials have also struck a new tone. The outgoing top army commander dealing with Gaza, Maj. Gen.
Sami Turgeman, has said recently that Israel and Hamas have some shared interests, while leading right-wing Cabinet minister Naftali Bennett said the Hamas presence in Gaza is a reality. “It’s not a matter of reconciling with it (Hamas rule) or not,” he told Israeli TV’s Channel 2 over the weekend. “I see that they (Hamas) are there.”
Israel and the West have branded Hamas, which is sworn to Israel’s destruction, as a terror group.
The best clipping in batch B for named ordinary Palestinians: Firi, Khouli, Badwan, Jundia, with ages, jobs, prices and a donkey that eats twice what its owner earns. AP's Gaza stringer Fares Akram shares the byline, which is probably why. Nouns: 'the Islamic militant group Hamas', 'crippling Israeli-Egyptian border blockade', 'trapped', 'siege' (in a Palestinian's quote). The word 'occupation' does not appear. Set Bennett's line here against his Chicago Tribune op-ed eleven months earlier: 'ISIS needs to be eliminated... Israel's conflict with Hamas and the current battle to stop ISIS are one and the same' becomes 'I see that they are there.'
· The Record · Hackensack · page 151
The ancient lands of Judea and Samaria, east of Jerusalem, have been part of the Jewish homeland for 3,000 years. Today Arabs demand all of it.
Paid advertisement placed by FLAME, Facts and Logic About the Middle East
“Judea and Samaria, the land where Jewish ancestors Abraham, Sarah, Isaac, Rachel, David and Solomon created Biblical history, was renamed the ‘West Bank’ during Jordan’s brief, illegal 19-year occupation.
Today, some 380,000 Jews own land and live in the territory, yet their rights are denied by Palestinian Arabs… Jordan illegally seized the ‘West Bank’ and east Jerusalem, and expelled all Jews from these Biblical homelands… Until such negotiations are consummated, the ‘West Bank’ will remain in dispute—a no-man’s land in which claims of ownership remain cloudy and contested.”
Set in a box in the middle of the page: “Israel has an irrefutable legal claim to these territories backed by the 93-year-old Mandate for Palestine.”
Not journalism, and marked PAID ADVERTISEMENT across the top by the paper. It is here because it is the naming argument conducted in the open and paid for. The advertisement puts West Bank in quotation marks every time it uses it, twelve times, and argues that West Bank is itself a renaming of Judea and Samaria. Whatever a reader makes of the claim, it settles one thing: the name of that territory was not drifting quietly in American newsprint. It was contested, by people who bought space to contest it.
· The Times · page 1
Joel Greenberg, McClatchy Foreign Staff, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — On Aug. 1, 2014, after a temporary cease-fire was announced in the war between Israel and Palestinian militants in the Gaza Strip, an Israeli officer, Lt. Hadar Goldin, went missing after a firefight with Hamas gunmen in the town of Rafah.
Suspecting that he had been seized, Israeli troops launched a fierce onslaught, heavily bombarding and shelling parts of Rafah in an attempt to pin down the suspected kidnappers.
The intensive attack, following the “Hannibal Directive,” under which Israeli forces can respond to the capture of a soldier with overwhelming firepower, left at least 135 Palestinian civilians dead, including 75 children, according to Amnesty International, one of the deadliest episodes of the 50-day campaign.
In a report issued Wednesday that used digital technology and satellite images along with witness testimonies to piece together the sequence of events, the human rights group said Israeli forces committed war crimes during three days of attacks that continued even after Goldin was declared to have been killed in action.
“There is strong evidence that Israeli forces committed war crimes in their relentless and massive bombardment of residential areas of Rafah in order to foil the capture of Lt. Hadar Goldin, displaying a shocking disregard for civilian lives,” said Philip Luther, director of Amnesty International’s Middle East and North Africa program.
“Israeli forces appear to have thrown out the rule book, employing a gloves-off policy with devastating consequences for civilians,” Luther said. “The obligation to take precautions to avoid the loss of civilian lives was completely neglected.”
The report was dismissed by the Israeli Foreign Ministry as “fundamentally flawed in its facts, in its legal analysis and in its conclusions.” The ministry said the report ignored Hamas’ strategy of fighting “from behind the civilian population” and showed Amnesty International’s “political bias” against Israel.
The report combines witness testimonies with analysis provided by Forensic Architecture, a London-based research team that used photos, videos and digital models to reconstruct incidents based on physical impact left on buildings damaged or destroyed in the conflict.
The finding and the Israeli Foreign Ministry's rejection of it, in the same column.
· Republican and Herald
BY MOHAMMED DARAGHMEH AND TIA GOLDENBERG
DUMA, West Bank — Suspected Jewish assailants set fire to a West Bank home on Friday and burned a sleeping Palestinian toddler to death in an attack that drew Palestinian rage and widespread Israeli condemnation.
The attack, which threatens to set off another violent escalation, shines a light on the growing lawlessness of extremist Jewish settlers that Israel is either unable or unwilling to contain. The extremists have for years staged attacks against Palestinian property, as well as mosques, churches, dovish Israeli groups and even Israeli military bases.
The attacks, known as “price tags” because they exact a price for Israeli steps seen as favorable to the Palestinians, have stirred fear in Palestinians and frustration among critics who say Israel has not done enough to quell the assaults.
“This is a direct consequence of decades of impunity given by the Israeli government to settler terrorism,” Palestinian official Saeb Erekat said.
“This is the consequence of a culture of hate funded and incentivized by the Israeli government and the impunity granted by the international community” Friday’s deadly attack comes as part of a larger trend of Jewish radicalization — one day after an anti-gay ultra-Orthodox extremist stabbed revelers at Jerusalem’s Gay Pride Parade and two days after Israeli authorities indicted two young Jewish activists for an arson attack on a famous Holy Land church.
All have been strongly condemned across the Israeli political spectrum, though the recent spate of attacks has raised fears that a radicalized and violent ultraconservative fringe is growing from within the country’s hard-line national-religious camp.
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas called the attack a “war crime” and said the Palestinians would present it to the International Criminal Court as part of their case against Israel.
The extremist attacks, which most recently struck a famous church in northern Israel, have rarely caused fatal injuries, which made Friday’s incident, in which 18-month-old Ali Dawabsheh was killed and his parents and 4-year-old brother critically wounded, all the more worrying.
Witnesses and the Israeli military said that under cover of darkness, the attackers broke the windows of the family’s home in Duma, a small village near the West Bank city of Nablus. They lobbed a fire bomb into the sleeping family’s bedroom, which exploded into a fireball that quickly consumed the home.
The suspects, who fled the scene, scribbled graffiti on the walls reading “Long live the Messiah,” “revenge” and “price tag,” as well as a Jewish star of David. The military said they were searching for the assailants.
Riham Dawabsheh, the boy’s mother, ran out of the house as she was engulfed by flames and a neighbor, Mohammed Ibrahim Dawabsheh, said he covered her in a sheet to try to extinguish the flames. She, as well as her husband Saed and son Ahmad, were taken to an Israeli hospital for treatment, where they remained in critical condition with severe burn wounds.
Duma residents blamed the incident on Israeli refusal to confront settler violence. “We have no protection,” Abdel Haleem Dawabsheh, a teacher from Duma, who like Mohammed Dawabsheh is a member of the same clan as the victims, said.
“Settlers burned mosques, cars, trees, attacked people in our village and in the nearby villages but nothing happened to them.” Israel said it does its best to track down the assailants and has launched recent drives to crack down on the “price tag” phenomenon.
But critics said Israel doesn’t enforce the law when it comes to settlers because of the political power that the settlers wield in parliament and because they are still perceived in some circles as Zionist pioneers who are settling the land like the vanguards who established the Jewish state.
A relative holds up a photo of an 18-month-old boy, Ali Dawabsheh, on Friday in a house that had been torched in a suspected attack by Jewish settlers in Duma village near the West Bank city of Nablus. The boy died in the fire, his brother, 4, and parents were wounded, according to a Palestinian official from the Nablus area.
· Modesto Bee
BY DANIELLA CHESLOW
DUMA, WEST BANK Days after suspected Jewish arsonists hurled a firebomb into a house, burning an 18-month-old toddler to death and injuring his parents and brother, the mayor of Duma pondered how to increase security for the West Bank town’s 3,000 residents. He had serious limitations.
“The only thing we can carry is sticks and lights,” Abed Alsalam Dawabsheh said as he sat in the courtyard of the village’s elementary school, converted into a mourning tent for the toddler, Ali Dawabsheh, who despite a common last name was not closely related to the mayor. “We are not allowed to carry weapons.”
Officially, Israel is charged with guaranteeing the security of Palestinian residents of the West Bank, but the arson Friday in Duma underscored the holes in the arrangement. Palestinian police do not operate in rural areas, and Palestinians say Israeli police and soldiers are lax in their enforcement of the law when Israelis are the suspects.
The Israeli Yesh Din organization, which offers legal counsel to Palestinians, claims that of 1,067 police complaints Palestinians filed against Israeli assailants in the last decade, only 19 ended in a conviction. “Law enforcement really doesn’t work regarding Palestinian complaints,” said Yesh Din spokesman Gilad Grossman.
He noted that 85 percent of cases were closed for “poor police work.” “Sometimes they don’t close the crime scene,” Grossman said. “They don’t take all the necessary evidence. Or they won’t interview the complainant.”
Police spokeswoman Luba Samri said that Israeli law enforcement is cracking down on Jewish violence against Palestinians. She said the national police’s establishment of a unit in March 2013 devoted to nationalist crime, with 80 officers assigned to the West Bank, focused attention on such incidents.
The result, she said, was a 30 percent increase in 2014 in the number of Palestinian complaints handled and a 75 percent increase in indictments. Complicating law enforcement efforts, she noted, are the fact that many Jewish suspects are minors and that Israeli police need military escorts to conduct investigations in Palestinian areas.
Police issued a rare call Tuesday for information on the Duma case. Israeli courts imposed a gag order on the investigation; no arrests have been reported. Israel’s government has acknowledged a lack of enforcement in cases of Jewish nationalist crime.
Speaking at a rally Sunday in Jerusalem, Israeli President Reuven Rivlin decried the actions of “Jewish terrorists” in Duma. “An atmosphere has been created here that has allowed leniency toward what is naively called ‘weeds,’ ” Rivlin said.
“Every society has extremist fringes, but today we have to ask: What is it in the public atmosphere which allows extremism and extremists to walk in confidence, in broad daylight?” Following his comments, Rivlin became a target of ultranationalist Jewish Israelis, who flooded his Facebook page with comments such as “may you and your children also burn.”
To combat Jewish terrorism, Israel on Sunday approved holding Jewish suspects in administrative detention, during which they are not told the charges against them. Until now, administrative detention had been used only in cases with Palestinian suspects.
Critics call the measure undemocratic for both Israelis and Palestinians; the government says secrecy is needed to maintain its information networks. Ashraf Khatib, a spokesman for the Palestine Liberation Organization, said the Palestinian Authority filed a complaint with the International Criminal Court about the arson in Duma.
He said the neighborhood watch underway in Duma was part of a West Bank-wide trend. “There is no faith in the Israeli legal system or police, and people under this situation need to have a feeling of protection,” Khatib said.
A Palestinian burns a tire during clashes Sunday near the West Bank city of Nablus. Tensions remain high after suspected Jewish assailants set fire to a West Bank home.
· Omaha World-Herald
McCLATCHY NEWSPAPERS
DUMA, West Bank — Days after suspected Jewish arsonists hurled a firebomb into a house, burning an 18-month-old toddler to death and injuring his parents and brother, Abed Alsalam Dawabsheh, the mayor of Duma, pondered how to increase security for the West Bank town’s 3,000 residents. He had serious limitations.
“The only thing we can carry is sticks and lights,” Dawabsheh said. “We are not allowed to carry weapons.” Officially, Israel is charged with guaranteeing the security of Palestinian residents of the West Bank, but the arson Friday in Duma underscored the holes in the arrangement.
Palestinian police do not operate in rural areas, and Palestinians say Israeli police and soldiers are lax in their enforcement of the law when Israelis are the suspects.
The Israeli Yesh Din organization, which offers legal counsel to Palestinians, claims that of 1,067 police complaints Palestinians filed against Israeli assailants in the last decade, only 19 ended in a conviction. Police spokeswoman Luba Samri said that Israeli law enforcement is cracking down on Jewish violence against Palestinians.
Complicating law enforcement efforts, she noted, are the fact that many Jewish suspects are minors and that Israeli police need military escorts to conduct investigations in Palestinian areas. Police issued a rare call for information on the Duma case on Tuesday. Israeli courts imposed a gag order on the investigation; no arrests have been reported.
To combat Jewish terrorism, Israel on Sunday approved holding Jewish suspects in administrative detention, during which they are not told the charges against them. Until now, administrative detention had been used only in cases involving Palestinian suspects. Critics say the measure is undemocratic for both Israelis and Palestinians.
The Israeli pledges to increase enforcement against Jewish attackers have given little comfort to residents of Duma. “Israel says they want to catch (the suspects). I don’t believe it,” said Nasser Dawabsheh, an uncle of the slain child. “The soldiers and the government of Israel support the settlements.”
The death inflamed tensions between Israelis and Palestinians. On Monday, assailants thought to be Palestinians lobbed a firebomb at the vehicle of Israeli Inbar Azrak, 27, who leaped out of her car in Jerusalem and is recovering from burns to her legs.
Ashraf Khatib, a spokesman for the Palestine Liberation Organization, said the Palestinian Authority filed a complaint with the International Criminal Court about the arson in Duma. In Duma, Dawabsheh said he’d received no help from the Palestinian Authority for his neighborhood watch group, but with weapons prohibited, there’s no expensive equipment to buy.
For now, the village will rely on bands of unarmed young men staking out the sprawling olive groves on its perimeter. “If the settlers know there is just one guy awake in town, they won’t attack,” he said.
Palestinian demonstrators burn tires during weekend clashes at the entrance to the village of Duma, near the West Bank city of Nablus, after suspected Jewish assailants set fire to a West Bank home and burned a sleeping Palestinian toddler to death.
· The Plain Dealer · Cleveland, OH · page A7
Seizure of soldier into tunnel still haunts Israeli army
William Booth, Washington Post
RAFAH, GAZA STRIP — It all began at a hole in the ground in a field of melons, when an Israeli reconnaissance squad surprised Hamas militiamen near a tunnel entrance. A vicious firefight erupted, just a few bursts long, but enough to leave two Israeli soldiers and one Palestinian militant dead.
After a quick body count, it was discovered that a young Israeli officer was missing, dragged down the tunnel — a nightmare scenario for Israel, whose military doctrine enshrines “force protection” and vows never to leave a soldier, dead or alive, behind. The abduction took place over a year ago on a day both Palestinians and Israelis have come to call “Black Friday,” Aug.
1, 2014, when a 72-hour cease-fire in the middle of the Gaza war was shattered. It was one of the deadliest and most controversial days in last summer’s Gaza war.
And it returned to the spotlight with the recent release of a report by Amnesty International, which asserts that Israel’s use of one-ton bombs and heavy artillery shelling in civilian neighborhoods was a disproportionate, indiscriminate, even vengeful, response to the abduction of a single soldier. Amnesty said it found “strong evidence” of war crimes.
After the disappearance of the soldier, Amnesty says, 2,000 bombs, missiles and artillery shells were fired into densely populated areas. Israel denied it used excessive force and said its soldiers were not only seeking the return of a kidnapped soldier but also fighting Hamas militants who attacked them from behind “human shields.”
The Amnesty investigation comes on the heels of a June report by the Commission of Inquiry on the 2014 Gaza Conflict for the United Nations, which concluded that the Black Friday events might amount to war crimes.
Folio confirms exactly: “Thursday, September 3, 2015 | The Plain Dealer | cleveland.com | A7 | WORLD.” This clipping NAMES the Hannibal Directive twice, in those words. First: “Within minutes, senior Israeli commanders shouted the order to declare a ‘Hannibal Directive,’ a classified protocol understood by many Israeli troops to mean ‘better a dead soldier than a captured soldier.’” Second: “Col. Ofer Winter was the commander of the Givati Brigade who issued the Hannibal Directive, which led to multiple strikes on tunnel openings, crowded intersections and a central hospital, all to stop Hamas from spiriting Goldin away, according to Amnesty.” The page spells the Rafah grocer family “Bilbisi” where the AP story on slides 44–45 spells the supermarket family “Bilbesi”; both spellings kept as printed. Israeli soldiers named on the page (Hadar Goldin, Lt. Eitan Fund) are combatants and so not listed under named_individuals.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis
TEL AVIV — First it was clashes on the Temple Mount. Then a mother and father were shot before the eyes of their four children. Then two men were killed in a stabbing attack in Jerusalem’s Old City. Now Israelis fear the wave of conflict will only rise. Here’s why the violence began, how it’s escalated and what might be next.
Four Israelis have died in two terror attacks over three days. The slow-burning Israeli-Palestinian conflict has flamed up in the past week with a series of terrorist attacks.
On Thursday night, militants from the Al-Aqsa Martyrs’ Brigades — the armed wing of Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas’ Fatah party — shot and killed a young Jewish-Israeli husband and wife, Rabbi Eitam and Naama Henkin.
At the time, the Henkins, both in their early 30s, were driving through the northern West Bank to their home in the settlement of Neria. The couple’s four children, ages 4 months to 9 years, were in the car and witnessed the attack. They were lightly wounded and evacuated to a hospital.
Two days later, after Shabbat ended, a terrorist killed two men in the Old City of Jerusalem. Aharon Bennett, a 22-year-old Israeli soldier, was on the way to the Western Wall when he, his wife and their two sons were attacked. He was off duty and out of uniform. His wife, Adele, 21, was seriously wounded and underwent emergency surgery.
The second victim, Nehemia Lavi, 41, was stabbed and killed when he tried to fend off the terrorist with a gun. Police shot and killed the terrorist, a 19-year-old law student. And on Sunday, a Jewish teenager was wounded in a stabbing attack in Jerusalem’s Old City. He was rushed to the hospital, and his attacker was killed by police.
Palestinian protesters in the West Bank throwing stones and burning tires during clashes with Israeli security forces over the Al-Aqsa mosque compound, Sept. 30, 2015.
Correction: Catalogued from the deck caption as the Valley News. The masthead on the scan reads "6 | OCTOBER 7, 2015 | ST. LOUIS JEWISH LIGHT". Corrected 3 October 2026.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis
Palestinian Youth Lack Faith in Peace Process
SURDA, WEST BANK — A new generation of angry, disillusioned Palestinians is driving the current wave of clashes with Israeli forces: Too young to remember the hardships of life during Israel’s clampdown on the last major uprising, they have lost faith in statehood through negotiations, distrust their political leaders and believe Israel only understands force.
The recent re-election of hard-liner Benjamin Netanyahu to a fourth term as prime minster has only deepened the sense of paralysis.
Some young Palestinians say they want to emulate those killed or wounded in confrontations or attacks on Israelis — like Mohannad Halabi, the 19-year-old law student from the West Bank who stabbed to death two Israelis in a bloody rampage in Jerusalem’s Old City over the weekend before being shot dead by police.
“We are all impressed with what he has done,” said Malik Hussein, a 19-year-old friend and fellow law student at Al-Quds University near Jerusalem. “The day after the attack, university students took to the streets and clashed with Israeli soldiers. Mohannad’s way is the only way to liberate Palestine.”
Despite such fervor and a rise in violence, it’s not clear if conditions are ripe for a new uprising against the Israeli military occupation that began in 1967 when Israel captured the West Bank, Gaza Strip and east Jerusalem.
Marked by Palestinian bombings and shootings, the last revolt erupted in 2000 and ebbed after Mahmoud Abbas, an opponent of violence, replaced the late Yasser Arafat as Palestinian president in 2005. Abbas now walks a thin line.
He is trying to prevent an escalation that he believes will cost the Palestinians international sympathy, but can’t be seen as cracking down on what Palestinians view as legitimate resistance to occupation. On Monday, Abbas ordered his security commanders to switch tactics and not use force to prevent Palestinian protests.
Much will depend on the severity of Israel’s response. The most recent attacks killed four Israelis last week — the two Israeli men stabbed by Halabi and a Jewish settler couple killed in a West Bank shooting ambush, in view of their four children.
Palestinians carry an injured man during clashes with Israeli troops at Qalandia checkpoint between Jerusalem and the West Bank city of Ramallah on Tuesday. The new generation of Palestinian youth in many cases have become inclined to resort to violent conflict. AP
· Monadnock Ledger-Transcript
By Tricia Saenger
As presidential candidates vie to be the biggest supporter of Israel, this is an excellent time to examine America’s support for Israel. Israel defines itself as the Jewish democratic state. In order to remain both Jewish and democratic, Israel must maintain a substantial Jewish majority.
Yet, Israel was established in an area where Jews were in the minority (in 1947 Palestine, Jews owned only about 6 percent of the land while non-Jews owned 94 percent). Immediately establishing a Jewish majority required not only significant Jewish immigration but also a widespread appropriation of non-Jewish property.
This was accomplished by 1) preventing non-Jews who fled in 1948 from returning and 2) instituting discriminatory laws that effected involuntary land transfers to the Jewish state. In 1950, Israel passed the Law of Return: “Every Jew has the right to come to this country as an [immigrating Jew]. This law is still in effect.
A Jew who grew up in Peterborough and decides to move to Israel today has more rights there than a non-Jewish Palestinian who used to live in Israel before 1948 and still has the key to his house there. Also in 1950, Israel passed the Absentee Property Law which allowed for the confiscation of lands previously owned by non-Jews.
The law declared any property situated within the post-war boundaries of Israel and whose owner had left the country between November 29, 1947 and May 19, 1948, or who went abroad or to an area of Palestine held by hostile forces up to Sept. 1, 1948, lost all rights to that property.
The law’s language was tailored so that under the guise of impartiality, land was confiscated solely from non-Jews who were declared “absentees.” The property was then turned over to the Custodian of Absentee Property, whose job was to transfer this property for the exclusive use of the Jewish population.
· Longview News Journal · Longview
Four dead, killed by nobody, and the thing they are killed in is a phrase in quotation marks: ‘day of rage’ violence. The marks mean the phrase is somebody else’s, and the effect is that the four are inside a rage, which is a state of mind, which belongs to them.
· St. Louis Post-Dispatch · St. Louis, MO (per the printed folio) · page A7 (per the printed folio)
Activists talk about common oppression of blacks in the United States and Arabs by Israelis
BY ISHAAN THAROOR • Washington Post
A video published on YouTube on Wednesday features dozens of Black Lives Matter and Palestinian activists delivering a joint message: "When I see them, I see us." These include prominent African-American celebrities and thinkers, such as Danny Glover, Lauryn Hill, Alice Walker, Angela Davis and Cornel West. They are accompanied by well-known Palestinian activists and writers.
Over the course of a couple of minutes, they unite their perceived struggles through photos, slogans and a shared story of state oppression. They talk of black youths killed by police and Palestinian children bombed by Israeli warplanes. "When I see them, I see us," the narrative goes.
"Harassed, beaten, tortured, dehumanized, stopped and frisked, searched at checkpoints." It may seem a bit of a stretch to equate the grievances of Palestinians with questions of institutionalized racism in the United States.
The legacy of African slavery and systemic racism in the United States seems a world away from the ongoing Israeli occupation of the Palestinian territories.
But Noura Erakat, an assistant professor at George Mason University and one of the organizers of the video project, argues that although these experiences are separated by distance and history, underlying themes bring them together.
"Here were two groups of people dealing with completely different historical trajectories, but both which resulted in a process of dehumanization that criminalized them and that subject their bodies as expendable," Erakat told Al Jazeera America.
"Not only were their lives more vulnerable and disposable, but that even in their death, they were blamed for their own death." The video project emerged last year in the aftermath of the Ferguson protests in the United States and the Gaza war in the Middle East, where more than 2,100 Palestinians died, the majority of whom were civilians.
The protests in Ferguson began in August 2014 after teenager Michael Brown was fatally shot by then-Ferguson police Officer Darren Wilson. Activists on either side of the world began connecting. As the Ferguson protests intensified, Palestinians reached out to those on the streets of the St. Louis suburb.
Some even offered advice over how to deal with tear gas (in both instances, the canisters fired by Israeli and American police were U.S.-made). In April, Ethiopian Israelis protested police brutality in Jerusalem by reportedly chanting "Baltimore is here!"
MARIA'S NOTE on this slide reads: "this is a good one to add to our pattern section about Black american and palestinian solidarity." What the clipping actually supports: a mainstream American daily, in its World section, running a Washington Post story that takes the solidarity seriously rather than treating it as a curiosity. It prints the shared-struggle argument from a named Palestinian scholar, reports the concrete reciprocity (Palestinians sending tear-gas advice to Ferguson), and notes that the canisters fired in Ferguson and in Palestine were both U.S.-made. It also records Ethiopian Israelis in Jerusalem chanting "Baltimore is here!" The paper does hedge once — "It may seem a bit of a stretch" — before letting Erakat answer the hedge. The Post-Dispatch is the Ferguson hometown paper, which is why this ran on A7 there. Photo caption: "A Palestinian protester runs for cover from tear gas fired by Israeli soldiers during clashes near Ramallah, West Bank, on Saturday. Israelis shot dead three Palestinians they said had attacked them with knives on Saturday in Jerusalem and the West Bank city of Hebron." Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS. Also quoted at the end of the story: an anonymous Israeli military official quoting journalist Nahum Barnea — "Israelis have ripped out hundreds of olive trees belonging to Arabs, ruined houses, smashed cars. The violence motivates counterviolence."
· St. Louis Post-Dispatch
ASSOCIATED PRESS
JERUSALEM • The new chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff is in Jerusalem for talks with senior Israeli leaders, as violence spikes around the country. This is U.S. Marine Gen. Joseph Dunford's first overseas trip since taking the job Oct. 1. He will meet with Lt. Gen. Gadi Eizenkot, the commander-in-chief of the Israel Defense Forces and others. Navy Capt.
Greg Hicks says the latest violence may come up in meetings, but Dunford's visit was long planned and his goal is to meet his Israeli counterparts and reaffirm the United States' commitment to Israel. He also will visit other countries in the region.
Meanwhile, Palestinian assailants carried out five stabbing attacks in Jerusalem and the West Bank on Saturday, authorities said, as a month-long outburst of violence showed no signs of abating. The unrest came despite new security measures that have placed troops and checkpoints around Palestinian neighborhoods in east Jerusalem. At least four assailants were killed.
In Jerusalem, where most of the violence has taken place, police spokeswoman Luba Samri said a Palestinian, 16, drew a knife on officers early Saturday when they asked for identification after a bystander said he was behaving suspiciously. She said the officers shot and killed the teenager after he tried to stab them.
Later, another assailant tried to stab a policeman on the outskirts of Jerusalem, but struck his bulletproof vest and did not injure him. The assailant was shot and wounded. Police said when an officer approached to treat the attacker, he pulled out a second knife and attempted to attack him. He was then shot and killed.
The three other stabbing attacks Saturday took place in the West Bank city of Hebron, a frequent flashpoint where a few hundred Jewish settlers live in close proximity to tens of thousands of Palestinians.
The whole visible item is transcribed. Eizenkot appears as a name on a meeting list — the American chairman of the Joint Chiefs flying to Jerusalem to meet him — and the paper puts that in the first three paragraphs, then spends the rest of the item on Palestinians being shot. The juxtaposition is the record.
· Sunday Democrat
The weeks-long spate of intense violence has left eight Israelis and 40 Palestinians dead, with no sign of diminishing tensions across Israel and the West Bank.
By Aaron Heller / Associated Press
Palestinian assailants carried out five stabbing attacks in Jerusalem and the West Bank on Saturday, authorities said, as a month-long outburst of violence showed no signs of abating. The unrest came despite new security measures that have placed troops and checkpoints around Palestinian neighborhoods in east Jerusalem. At least four assailants were killed.
In Jerusalem, where most of the violence has taken place, police spokeswoman Luba Samri said a 16-year-old Palestinian drew a knife on officers early Saturday when they asked for identification after a bystander said he was behaving suspiciously. She said the officers shot and killed the teenager after he tried to stab them.
The incident took place near where two Palestinian men boarded a bus earlier in the week and began shooting and stabbing passengers, killing two. Later, another assailant tried to stab a policeman on the outskirts of Jerusalem, but struck his bulletproof vest and did not injure him. The assailant was shot and wounded.
Police said when an officer approached to treat the attacker, he pulled out a second knife and attempted to attack him. He was then shot and killed. The other three stabbing attacks Saturday took place in the West Bank city of Hebron, a frequent flashpoint where a few hundred Jewish settlers live in close proximity to tens of thousands of Palestinians.
In the first incident, Israel's military said an Israeli pedestrian shot and killed a Palestinian who tried to stab him. Later, police said a Palestinian woman stabbed a female officer at a border police base in Hebron and lightly injured her before the officer shot her dead. At night, the army said a soldier was stabbed and moderately wounded before the attacker was shot.
There were no immediate details on his condition. Over the past month, eight Israelis have been killed in Palestinian attacks, most of them stabbings. In that time, 40 Palestinians were killed by Israeli fire, including 19 labeled by Israel as attackers, and the rest in clashes with Israeli troops. Israel has taken unprecedented steps in response to the attacks.
It has deployed soldiers in Israeli cities and erected concrete barriers outside some Arab neighborhoods of east Jerusalem, where most of the attackers came from. Ordinary citizens have also increasingly taken up arms to protect themselves.
On Saturday, roadblocks on the outskirts of Arab neighborhoods caused massive traffic jams, with some frustrated motorists saying they had been waiting for several hours.
This is a fuller cut of the same AP copy as the clipping on slide 21 (s021_2), but with a byline (Aaron Heller) and — importantly — a different headline. Where other papers in this batch lead with Israeli deaths or with rockets, this one puts the Israeli shooting in the active voice at the top of the page: "After attacks Israelis shoot, kill 4 Palestinians". The dek then gives both tallies, eight Israelis and 40 Palestinians, and the body text makes the distinction the archive cares about: of the 40 Palestinians killed, "19 labeled by Israel as attackers, and the rest in clashes with Israeli troops" — the verb is "labeled", not "were". Photo caption: "Palestinian protesters walk between burning tires during clashes with Israeli security forces near the Beit El settlement on the outskirts of Ramallah in the West Bank on Saturday." Credit: (ABBAS MOMANI/AFP/GETTY IMAGES).
· Sunday Democrat
By Lolita C. Baldor / Associated Press
The new chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff is in Jerusalem for talks with senior Israeli leaders, as violence spikes around the country. This is U.S. Marine Gen. Joseph Dunford's first overseas trip since taking the job Oct. 1. He will meet with Lt. Gen. Gadi Eizenkot, the commander-in-chief of the Israel Defense Forces and others. Navy Capt.
Greg Hicks says the latest violence may come up in meetings, but Dunford's visit was long-planned and his goal is to meet his Israeli counterparts and reaffirm America's commitment to Israel. He also will visit other countries in the region.
The violence has been fueled in part by Palestinian fears that Israel is trying to expand its presence at a major Muslim-run shrine in Jerusalem. Israel denies that claim.
Whole item transcribed. This is the Dunford story run as its own standalone item with a byline (Lolita C. Baldor), on the same page and the same day as the Aaron Heller stabbing story on slide 22. Compared with the version on slide 21 (s021_2), this cut drops all the Palestinian casualty reporting and instead ends with a causal sentence the other versions do not carry: "The violence has been fueled in part by Palestinian fears that Israel is trying to expand its presence at a major Muslim-run shrine in Jerusalem. Israel denies that claim." So the same wire feed, in the same paper on the same day, produced one item where Eisenkot is a diary entry on an American general's itinerary and a second item, inches away, counting the Palestinian dead — and the two never touch. A photograph of Joseph Dunford in uniform runs at the right, captioned simply "Joseph Dunford".
· The Herald News · San Francisco, CA
Israeli-Palestinian mediators face uphill battle
Dan Perry and Josef Federman / Associated Press
JERUSALEM — A surprise Mideast mediation effort by U.N. chief Ban Ki-moon underscores the world community's desire to stamp out the new flare-up of Israeli-Palestinian violence. But diplomacy faces an uphill battle with both sides deadlocked on the big issues and the current leaders being dragged along.
The United States and Jordan could prove especially important in determining whether the bloodshed will subside. The U.S. may be called upon to push for new talks, and the Jordanians can calm the atmosphere by negotiating with both sides about the Jerusalem holy sites over which they are the recognized custodians.
Much depends on giving the Palestinians a sense of some success — perhaps even hope for a fundamental change — while enabling Israelis to avoid feeling that they have bowed before terrorism. Here's a look at where things could go: WILL THE U.S. STEP IN?
There is a sense among observers that the U.S. administration would like to wash its hands of the Israeli-Palestinian conundrum. For nine months, ending in early 2014, Secretary of State John Kerry focused on a mediation effort that most locals considered to be not serious.
The effort indeed failed, and some consider it took valuable attention away from the meltdown in Syria and Iraq.
"NATION / WORLD" above the picture is a section flag, not a dek; the dek is the line under the display headline. Eisenkot appears nowhere in the body text — only in the photo caption, which reads: "Israeli Defence Minister Moshe Yaalon, left, speaks next to Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, center, and Army Chief of Staff Lieutenant-General Gadi Eisenkot during a visit at a military outpost at the outskirts of Gaza Strip on Tuesday. U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon called for calm during a surprise visit to Jerusalem on Tuesday ahead of meetings with Israeli and Palestinian leaders, in a high-profile effort to bring an end to a month-long wave of violence." Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS PHOTO. The British spelling "Defence" is the paper's and is left as printed. The story carries crossheads WILL THE U.S. STEP IN? and LEADING OR FOLLOWING?
· The Monitor · McAllen, TX
Probe aims to establish whether there is evidence to open full-scale investigation
BY MIKE CORDER, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
THE HAGUE, Netherlands — Palestinian leaders on Friday handed what they called evidence of Israeli crimes committed in the recent outburst of violence to prosecutors at the International Criminal Court.
Foreign Minister Riad Malki said the Palestinians submitted details to Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda of what they described as extra-judicial killings of Palestinians as well as home demolitions and other forms of collective punishment. Bensouda launched a preliminary probe in January into possible crimes committed on Palestinian territory.
In June, Malki handed her a file detailing possible Israeli war crimes in Gaza and settlement construction in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. The preliminary ICC probe aims to establish if there are grounds to open a full-scale investigation. It is unclear when it will be completed. Malki said Friday he wants the court to finish it quickly to deter further deaths.
“I think it’s important for Israel to get messages — clear messages and strong messages — and that’s why we are pushing for expediting the preliminary examination,” he said. The Palestinian Authority has joined the Hague-based court. Israel is not a member and says the court does not have jurisdiction to hear the Palestinian complaint.
Israel’s ambassador to the Netherlands, Haim Divon, said Palestinian leaders were attempting to “misuse the ICC as a stage for promoting their political agenda.”
Short AP wire. Useful chiefly as a counterweight to the Haskel clipping on the same slide: here the words ‘extra-judicial killings’, ‘home demolitions’ and ‘collective punishment’ do reach an American page, but only inside a Palestinian official’s submission and bracketed by ‘what they described as.’
· Belleville News Democrat · Belleville, IL · page 4C
Israeli prime minister who made peace with Yasser Arafat was killed Nov. 4, 1995 | Most Israelis no longer believe in the peace process Rabin ushered in | Obama isn’t personally involved in trying to negotiate a deal
BY DANIELLA CHESLOW, McClatchy Foreign Staff
TEL AVIV, ISRAEL When former President Bill Clinton spoke Saturday at a rally honoring Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, assassinated 20 years ago by a right-wing Israeli radical, he spoke in the same square where Rabin delivered his final speech.
But Clinton also encountered an Israeli public that has dramatically changed in the two decades since Clinton watched Rabin and PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat sign the Oslo Accords at the White House, setting the stage for a two-state solution for Israelis and Palestinians. On the night of his assassination Nov.
4, 1995, Rabin spoke to a record gathering of 100,000 Israelis cheering on his push for the accords. “Today I believe that there are prospects for peace, great prospects,” Rabin exhorted the crowd. “The path of peace is preferable to the path of war.”
On Monday, in a ceremony in Israel’s parliament marking the assassination, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had an opposite message. “If we lower our sword,” he declared, “their sword will consume us.” It’s not just Israel’s leaders who’ve changed. In 1995, the political map was split nearly in half between supporters and opponents of the Oslo Accords.
Today, only 15 percent of the public defines itself as left of center, favoring the accords. “Israeli society has become more nationalist and closed to the world,” said political analyst Tal Schneider. Sharren Haskel embodies the shift in Israeli political opinion. Haskel, 31, is the newest Knesset member in Netanyahu’s ruling Likud party.
She grew up in a dovish household and remembers furniture shopping with her father in the Gaza Strip. As a high school student, she was a member of Peace Now, the advocacy group that calls for two states, one for Israelis, the other for Palestinians on lands in the West Bank and Gaza captured from Egypt and Jordan in 1967.
“As youth groups we would go to the square and light candles in memory of Rabin,” Haskel said. “Back then I did agree with him.” The next years chipped away at her hopes. She was a teen when Palestinian attackers blew up buses in Israeli cities in what’s known as the second Intifada, or uprising; twice she fortuitously missed buses that were bombed.
By the time Haskel was 18 and facing military draft, she had left Peace Now and enlisted as a combat soldier in the Israeli Border Police, where as a first lieutenant she patrolled the streets of east Jerusalem, carried out night arrests of suspected terrorists, and guarded the demolitions of the homes of Palestinian assailants.
“I knew if I’m going to do two or three years in the army I can’t just sit and be a clerk, a nurse or a guide,” she said. “During this rough time of the Intifada, this is my time to stand up and protect my family and friends.” Occasionally, she said, she would see old dovish friends through her helmet visor as she policed protests against Israeli policy.
“They believe in a kind of dream that is not possible,” she said. “The only thing we can do is protect ourselves.”
The fullest profile of Haskel in the batch and the one that shows the mechanism rather than the position: Peace Now at sixteen, Border Police at eighteen, east Jerusalem night arrests, guarding house demolitions, Knesset at thirty-one. Palestinians appear in it only as ‘attackers’, ‘suspected terrorists’ and ‘assailants’ whose homes are demolished; no Palestinian is quoted anywhere on the page, and the only people who speak for a two-state outcome are Israeli Jews. Signed at the foot: ‘Cheslow is a McClatchy special correspondent.’
· Ledger-Enquirer · Columbus, GA · page A4
By ARON HELLER / Associated Press
RISHON LEZION, Israel — Twenty-four-year-old shopkeeper Darya Zelenkov was working her shift in a downtown clothing shop in this central Israeli city when she was startled by a knife-wielding Palestinian trying to burst in. The quick-thinking saleswoman quickly slammed the glass door in his face. "I looked him straight in the eye.
He had this lost look about him," said Zelenkov. "Until yesterday I thought all the troubles were 'there.' I thought it had nothing to do with me." [...] On Herzl street, near the site of the stabbing rampage, outraged residents flung insults at Palestinians, calling them "animals" and "mentally ill" and saying assailants should be killed on the spot.
Pavel Leiderman, 39, said the Palestinian goal was "attrition." "They just want to wear us down until we give them what they want," he said. "As far as I'm concerned, they can have a state so long as I don't have to see them or hear about them anymore. But I don't know if that will be enough for them. If you give a crying baby a lollypop, it just wants more."
Folio reads "A4 | Thursday, November 5, 2015 | LEDGER-ENQUIRER, COLUMBUS, GA. www.ledger-enquirer.com" — masthead and date agree with the label. Photo caption: "In this Monday, Nov. 2, file photo, Israeli rescue personal evacuate a woman after a stabbing attack in Rishon Lezion, Israel. After years of relative quiet in major Israeli cities, a seven-week burst of violence has brought the Palestinian issue back to the country's heartland and pushed the long-festering issue onto the national agenda." The paper's own spelling "rescue personal" is left as printed. Credit: ARIEL SCHALIT/Associated Press.
· South Florida Sun Sentinel · Fort Lauderdale · page 1
By Ben Cohen
“This month marks the 40th anniversary of one of the worst instances of anti-Semitism since the end of the Second World War. On Nov.
10, 1975, the United Nations — a body created out of the ashes of the Holocaust — passed General Assembly Resolution 3379, which equated Zionism, the Jewish national liberation movement, with racism and racial discrimination. That resolution was the culmination of a lengthy campaign by the Soviet Union to turn Israel into the only state within the U.N. system to have its legitimacy questioned… Only a handful of people at the General Assembly grasped this fundamental fact back in 1975.
One of them was Chaim Herzog, the Israeli ambassador to the world body… Predictably, the resolution passed. Less predictably, it was rescinded in 1991 — appropriately on the eve of the Soviet Union’s collapse — after a U.S.-led campaign that saw President George H.W.
Bush personally introduce the resolution of revocation… But as we know only too well, the slander that Zionism is racism survived that revocation, in much the same way that Holocaust denial has persisted even though it’s illegal in many states.
In essence, nothing has really changed: in the name of fighting racism, the same lies and deceits are advanced in order to encourage anti-Semitism.”
Daniel Patrick Moynihan, then the American ambassador to the United Nations, addresses the U.N. General Assembly on Nov. 10, 1975, the day the General Assembly adopted the ‘Zionism is racism’ resolution. Moynihan said that the U.S. ‘will never acquiesce in this infamous act.’
Forty years on, the headline is the sentence turned around. The column says the resolution was a Soviet campaign. The clippings in this section, printed at the time, show the two words arriving together in an American paper in January 1968 from the chairman of the PLO, on placards in Hamburg in June 1969, in a message from Nasser that September, and in the Black Panther party paper in 1970, before the Soviet Union took the formula to the General Assembly at all.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · page 9
JERUSALEM — Two Jewish teens were found guilty of the murder of a Palestinian teen who was burned to death in the Jerusalem forest. The verdict in the kidnapping and killing of Mohammad Abu Khdeir, 16, was handed down Monday morning in Jerusalem District Court.
The court also found that the third defendant, Yosef Haim Ben-David, 31, of the Adam settlement in the West Bank, carried out the crimes for which he was accused, but delayed issuing a verdict due to the last-minute submission of an insanity plea. The teens have not been identified because they were minors at the time of the crime. They will be sentenced next month.
One of the teens was convicted of attempted aggravated kidnapping, aggravated assault, attempted arson, murder and abduction for the sake of murder. The other was convicted of murder and abduction for the sake of murder. According to the court, Ben-David committed murder, abduction for the sake of murder, attempted aggravated kidnapping, aggravated assault and attempted arson.
The court will further discuss his case on Dec. 20, according to reports. Khdeir was beaten unconscious and then burned to death in the Jerusalem Forest on July 2, 2014, to avenge the kidnapping and murder of three Israeli teens the previous month, Ben-David told police at the time of his arrest.
The murdered teen’s family, residents of eastern Jerusalem, attended all the court sessions, including Monday’s.
· St. Louis Jewish Light
BY AVITAL LEIBOVICH
JERUSALEM — I won’t soon forget the morning of July 31, when I awoke to the horrific news that a firebomb had been hurled at a Palestinian house in the West Bank village of Duma while the family living there was asleep inside. Three people were burned to death, including a baby boy.
“Nekama,” the Hebrew word meaning “revenge,” was spray-painted on a house nearby. Israelis were shocked at the news. This was especially so for Jewish-Israelis. It seemed incomprehensible that Jews could be behind this hideous act.
If anti-Arab Jewish extremists did such a thing, I thought, they must be following a Bible very different from the one that most Jews respect. A few young extremists suspected of the crime are being held in administrative detention and interrogated. Whether or not there is enough evidence to convict them, the damage to the State of Israel’s public image will be huge.
The media and human rights organizations, never reluctant to portray Israel in a negative light, will most likely omit the fact that the views of these radicals are likely held by less than 1 percent of the Israeli population. The vast majority of Israelis have condemned this violence.
On the day of the murder, President Reuven Rivlin castigated the attack on his Facebook page in both Arabic and Hebrew. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called it a “terror attack.” The Knesset held a special meeting on Aug. 4 where the atrocity was condemned by members of all the political parties, from the far left to the far right.
Moreover, across the country, Israelis shared their sense of outrage at the murders, disassociating themselves from the extremists who had perpetrated it. Many published condemnations on their own social media profiles. The silence from the Palestinian Authority regarding acts of terror acts has, in contrast, been deafening. On Aug.
3, three days after the Duma attack, Palestinians hurled a firebomb at an Israeli vehicle in Beit Hanina and injured an Israeli woman. On Aug. 14, Palestinians from the village of Awartta set fire to a gas station near the Israeli settlement of Eli.
The body of 18-month-old Ali Saad-Dawabsheh, surrounded by relatives, is carried at her funeral in the Palestinian village of Duma on July 31.
· Press Bulletin
— Associated Press (credited at the end of the item)
JERUSALEM — Israel's top general said today that the military's number one mission for the coming year is to counter the renewed threat posed by militant attack tunnels from Gaza. Lt. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot said Gaza's Hamas rulers have been rebuilding the sophisticated network of underground tunnels that Israel targeted during the 2014 war.
He said destroying this network is the military's top priority for 2016, adding that it's not deceived by the current relative calm along the Israel-Gaza border.
"Hamas is diverting great resources to restore what it considers a pattern that allows it to enter Israel discreetly and carry out attacks," Eisenkot said at an event at the Interdisciplinary Center in Herzliya, a college north of Tel Aviv. "We have the most advanced abilities in the world and still this is a major challenge." — Associated Press
Whole item transcribed. Photo caption (above the headline, belonging to the same item): "Israeli soldiers enter a tunnel discovered near the Israel Gaza border in 2013. Israel's military chief Lt. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot said that Gaza's Hamas rulers have been rebuilding the sophisticated network of underground tunnels that Israel damaged during the 2014 war." Credit: Associated Press / file. Note the caption says Israel "damaged" the tunnels where the body text says "targeted". Same AP item as s007_3 (The Herald, Indiana) on the same date, cut differently.
· The Herald (Indiana) · Jasper, IN
JERUSALEM — Israel's top general said today that the military's number one mission for the coming year is to counter the renewed threat posed by militant attack tunnels from Gaza. Lt. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot said Gaza's Hamas rulers have been rebuilding the sophisticated network of underground tunnels that Israel targeted during the 2014 war.
He said destroying this network is the military's top priority for 2016, adding that it's not deceived by the current relative calm along the Israel-Gaza border. Israel launched its 2014 offensive in Gaza to stop years of frequent rocket attacks.
Whole item transcribed. This is the same AP brief as s007_2 (Press Bulletin), same date, but trimmed one paragraph shorter: the two direct Eisenkot quotations are cut, and in their place the item ends with a sentence of justification for the 2014 offensive that does not appear in the Press Bulletin version. The two clippings side by side show the same wire paragraph set producing a quoting version and a non-quoting, justifying version.
· Salinas Californian · Salinas, CA
MICHELE CHABIN, SPECIAL FOR USA TODAY
JERUSALEM - Hanin Zoabi, an Israeli Arab, believes Israeli Jews are colonialists who stole Palestinian land. She makes no distinction between the recent deaths of Israeli civilians and their attackers, calling both “victims of the Israeli occupation.” Those are typical views of Palestinians living in the West Bank and Gaza, as well as some Arab citizens of Israel like Zoabi.
But for her to make such comments strikes many Jews as incendiary — because she is also a member of Israel’s parliament, the Knesset. Zoabi’s verbal attacks have sparked questions among Jews here about her loyalty to Israel — as well as the loyalty of the other 16 Israeli Arabs in the Knesset — at a time when Israel is confronting months of attacks on Jews by Palestinians.
“The main criminal here is the occupation, the oppression of the Palestinian people,” Zoabi said in an interview. “If we want to defend the people, Jewish and Palestinian, we must struggle against occupation and Israeli aggression.”
Israel’s Arab citizens make up 21 percent of the population, but suspicions about them among Jewish citizens have soared in recent months because a handful of Israeli Arabs were among the more than 100 Palestinians who have attacked Israeli civilians and soldiers.
Hostilities escalated in February after Zoabi and two other Israeli-Arab lawmakers met with families of Palestinian attackers killed by Israeli security forces. The three stood for a moment of silence in memory of the attackers to focus attention on Israel’s refusal to hand over the bodies for burial.
“We sat with bereaved families that lost their sons and daughters, and anyone who would differentiate between” Israeli and Palestinian “families would be a racist,” Zoabi said.
Angered by the visit, the Knesset’s Ethics Committee temporarily banned the three lawmakers from most parliamentary activities, and the Constitution Committee green-lighted a bill that would empower 90 of the 120 lawmakers to suspend a fellow member for “inappropriate” behavior.
Under the controversial bill, which should come up for a vote in the coming weeks, voicing racist ideology or support for armed conflict against Israel could lead to a suspension. So could opposition to the long-enshrined definition of Israel as both a democratic and Jewish state.
Opponents of the measure, including Israeli President Reuven Rivlin, consider it blatantly undemocratic. Knesset member Sharren Haskel, of the right-wing Likud Party, hopes it passes.
“When (the Arab Knesset members) met with the families of terrorists, including one who murdered a mother in front of her children, and stood for a moment of silence to commemorate them, they were in fact promoting violence and hatred against the citizens of Israel,” Haskel said. “No one should be able to use their parliamentary privilege to destroy our democracy.”
The single most useful clipping in this batch for the question of how Palestinian citizens of Israel are handled in American papers. Zoabi speaks at length, in her own words, twice. But the framing around her is loyalty: the headline, the photo caption and the third paragraph all put her loyalty, and the loyalty of ‘the other 16 Israeli Arabs in the Knesset’, in question as a collective. Haskel’s answering quote is given more space than Zoabi’s and placed last.
· Lebanon Daily News · Lebanon · page 1
Most of those detained, some as young as 11, are denied bail
Asma’ Jawabreh and Jacob Wirtschafter, special for USA Today
“HEBRON, West Bank - Amer Salah was sleeping last May when Israeli forces entered the 14-year-old’s bedroom in the middle of the night. He said he was arrested for throwing stones at vehicles of neighboring Jewish settlers, which he denied, and was jailed with nine other kids in a cell barely 6-feet by 6-feet without fresh air or ample light.
‘We were not even allowed to see the sun,’ he said… The arrests have multiplied since a spate of stabbings and other assaults last fall over Israel’s continued occupation of the West Bank. On Thursday, two 14-year-old Palestinian boys stabbed an Israeli soldier to death and wounded a second Israeli man at a supermarket in a Jewish settlement south of Ramallah.
Both teens were wounded by armed bystanders.
Currently, Israel is holding 420 Palestinians under the age of 18 for alleged attacks in East Jerusalem and the West Bank, according to Israeli Prison Service statistics… The youngest is 11-year-old Ali Alqam, who is charged with wounding a security guard in an October knife attack at a Jerusalem light rail station… Figures released by the Israeli court system after a Freedom of Information request by Military Court Watch show that bail is denied to 70 percent of Palestinian youths who are detained… Since early October, Palestinians have stabbed Israeli civilians and soldiers 199 times, shot at them 41 times and rammed vehicles into pedestrians 23 times, according to the Israel Defense Forces… ‘No one is denying that there is a wave of knife attacks and stone throwing, much if conducted by Palestinian youths,’ said Sarit Michaeli, a spokeswoman for B’tselem — the Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories.
‘But even when involved in serious offenses, a child offender is still a child, and the authorities who are entitled to charge and prosecute them still should not violate the rights of children.’”
“A Palestinian youth throws stones toward Israeli military vehicles near the West Bank town of Jenin on Feb. 6.” (Jaafar Ashtiyeh/AFP/Getty Images)
A photograph: one man throwing a stone at an armored vehicle, a soldier walking toward him with a rifle raised. The pull-quote on the page is from Anat Berko, a member of Israel’s parliament with a doctorate in criminology: “I wish we did not have to put Palestinian minors under 14 in prison. … But there is peer pressure to participate in this violence, and Palestinian leaders need to make it clear that this is not the right way for their youth to achieve a solution to the conflict.”
· Star Tribune · Minneapolis
The pro-Palestinian BDS movement makes no distinction between opposition to Israel’s policies and opposition to Israel’s very existence.
Sometime in March (and as soon as March 1), students at the University of Minnesota will be asked to consider a resolution brought by the campus group Students for Justice in Palestine, urging the university to divest financially from corporations which, the sponsors assert, “directly profit from human rights violations” perpetrated by the Israeli government against Palestinians.
As described by its sponsors, the divestment resolution is part of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement, a global effort to bring pressure on the government of Israel. So how should students at the university, and others with deep interests in this issue, consider this matter?
To be sure, it is hard to argue that Israel is not responsible for serious violations of the rights of Palestinians, especially in the context of an occupation that has resulted in loss of land, restrictions on freedom of movement and denial of political rights.
And public pressure is a time-tested means of encouraging governments around the world to modify policies, especially for those governments that take seriously their human rights obligations. My own experiences reflect my belief in the value of such advocacy.
As a student at New York University School of Law some 35 years ago, I initiated a high-profile letter of protest from more than 100 Jewish law students at NYU, Harvard and Yale law schools, objecting to Israel’s large-scale invasion of Lebanon in 1982, as well as settlement activity in the occupied territories.
And while that effort was not enthusiastically received by the government of Israel, I believed then, as I do now, that public pressure is critically important in moving governments on basic rights issues.
More recently, in my former role as assistant secretary of state for population, refugees and migration, I witnessed the deprivations suffered by Palestinian populations in the West Bank and Gaza, as well as those involving African migrants in Israel.
And, although in that role most of my human rights advocacy was through private diplomacy, I deeply valued the work and public advocacy of groups like Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International.
So if public pressure is an appropriate tool of persuasion, why am I so strongly opposed to this effort to encourage university officials to divest from companies that do business with Israel? And why do I hope so fervently that the students at the university will reject this measure?
My opposition stems from my strong belief in the right of the Jewish people to live securely in a Jewish and democratic state, as part of a two-state solution that recognizes the rights of the Palestinian people and addresses their legitimate and long-held grievances.
This position, which reflects the perspectives of the vast majority of Americans and of governments around the world, also offers the best prospects for the rights and well-being of all the region’s inhabitants. Thus, Americans should be prepared to support a wide variety of diplomatic and other measures designed to achieve this objective.
My deep concern is that this goal is put at risk by the BDS movement of which the university students’ divestment effort is a part. This is because the BDS movement makes no distinction between opposition to the policies of the government of Israel — in the occupied territories and elsewhere — and opposition to Israel’s very existence.
Statements of BDS leaders and materials the movement has generated clearly challenge the legitimacy of the concept of Israel as a democratic and Jewish state that can live in peace with its neighbors and with a Palestinian state. I certainly understand that perspective, and always welcome the chance to discuss and debate proponents of this position.
Yet I respectfully but strongly reject it, and firmly believe that continued efforts to realize the de-legitimation of Israel will inevitably poison the environment for negotiations between Israelis and Palestinians, lead to more violence and seriously harm the interests of both groups. That would be an awful outcome, which this unfortunate resolution would promote.
I hope it is rejected by the students at the university, even as I look forward to supporting common efforts of all members of our community to support progress toward a Middle East peace. Eric P.
Schwartz is dean and professor in the Humphrey School of Public Affairs at the University of Minnesota, and serves on the board of directors of the Jewish Community Relations Council of Minnesota and the Dakotas and HIAS, the Jewish Community’s refugee assistance organization. He is also a member of the Advisory Council of J Street. The views expressed here are his own.
· The Standard Times · New Bedford
“It affects 4.5 million Palestinians who live in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, in principle under PA authority.”
A Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial, reprinted in New Bedford, Massachusetts.
· Valley Morning Star
The same Pittsburgh editorial, the same week, in Harlingen, Texas, under a headline the original did not carry. One editorial, two papers, two different arguments in the headline.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis, MO · page 5
BY BEN SALES / JTA
TEL AVIV — It began as an all-too-common story: A Palestinian assailant in the contested West Bank city of Hebron stabs and wounds an Israeli soldier. Israeli forces shoot him dead. But hours after the incident Thursday, a political and moral firestorm engulfed Israel. A video showed a soldier executing the already incapacitated attacker.
One day later, after condemnation from the highest reaches of Israel's government, a second video appeared to show that the attacker might have still posed a threat. In response, the IDF released results of an investigation indicating the soldier was at fault. Then came a third video showing the soldier shaking hands with a far-right activist after the incident.
The dueling views of the clash are the latest installments in a running debate over how far Israeli soldiers should go in responding to the ongoing wave of Palestinian knife attacks.
The incident has raised questions about the Israel Defense Forces' rules of engagement, how the army should treat soldiers who break protocol and — within Israeli society — the limits of criticism of the IDF. [...] Since September, more than 200 Palestinian stabbing attacks have left 34 Israelis dead and hundreds wounded, according to Israel's Foreign Ministry.
Israeli forces have killed more than 200 Palestinians, most of them attackers, according to news reports. Centrist and right-wing Israeli politicians, including Yesh Atid Chairman Yair Lapid and Public Security Minister Gilad Erdan, have encouraged soldiers to kill attackers on the spot. The U.S.
State Department, as well as Sweden's Foreign Ministry, have criticized Israel for a disproportionate response to the attacks.
Even IDF Chief of Staff Gadi Eizenkot told high-schoolers last month that he "doesn't want a soldier emptying a magazine on a girl carrying scissors," while Defense Minister Moshe Yaalon said the next day, "We need to know how to win and still remain human." Eizenkot, in turn, was criticized for not defending his soldiers.
Folio reads "Visit WWW.STLJEWISHLIGHT.COM | ST. LOUIS JEWISH LIGHT | MARCH 30, 2016 | 5" — date agrees with Maria's label. Photo caption: "Israeli soldiers removing the body of a Palestinian man who stabbed a soldier in the West Bank city of Hebron on March 24." Photo: Wissam Hashlamon/Flash 90. The story runs under three bold crossheads: "A video showed an Israeli soldier killing an already incapacitated attacker.", "Right-wing Israelis are defending the soldier and say the attacker may have still posed a threat.", and "The video comes amid criticism of Israel's response to a wave of stabbing attacks." Also quoted: IDF spokesman Brig. Gen. Moti Almoz, and former Deputy Foreign Minister Yehuda Ben Meir of Tel Aviv University's Institute for National Security Studies, who told JTA "99.9 percent" of IDF actions are appropriate and "If everyone does whatever they think, everything will fall apart." Note the paper reports 34 Israelis dead and more than 200 Palestinians killed in the same paragraph and calls the latter "most of them attackers, according to news reports" — the Israeli figure is sourced to a ministry, the Palestinian figure to "news reports".
· The News & Observer · Raleigh, NC
Residents question Israeli government’s human rights record, policies | Visit sponsored by State Department, international leadership program
BY TAMMY GRUBB AND NATALIE RITCHIE, tgrubb@newsobserver.com, nritchie@newsobserver.com
CHAPEL HILL An Israeli delegation that attended a Chapel Hill Town Council meeting Monday night to learn about local government in the U.S. got an earful on Israeli-Palestinian relations. Four members of the Israeli Knesset, or parliament, stopped in Chapel Hill as part of an International Visitor Leadership Program tour sponsored by the U.S.
State Department that also includes stops in Washington, D.C., and New York City. The national program and the State Department chose Chapel Hill, said Leila Bekri, director of International Visitor Leadership Programs at Raleigh-based International Focus.
The Israeli group first visited the UNC School of Media and Journalism, before joining a three-hour meeting with the Town Council and about a dozen area residents. The delegation – Amir Ohana, Sharren Haskel, Meirav Ben-Ari and Itzik Shmuli – initially focused on municipal governance.
Passions flared, however, as residents challenged the visitors on Israeli government policies toward Palestinians.
Local groups Abrahamic Initiative on the Middle East and Jewish Voices for Peace initially opposed the meeting “because we see it is a normalization and legitimization of policies in the Israeli government that are oppressive and violate human rights,” said John Heinemeier, a retired Durham pastor.
The delegation included members of three political parties, including Likud, which has historically opposed statehood for Palestinians and supported settlements in areas seized by Israel during the Six-Day War in 1967. But the delegation’s party affiliations are irrelevant, said Miriam Thompson of the Abrahamic Initiative. “Are they working in the Knesset to end occupation?”
Thompson asked. “If they don’t come out in opposition they might as well be part of Likud.” Israel’s government has offered “very generous proposals” for peace, said Ohana, a Likud member. The two-state solution is “no solution,” he said. “In order to achieve peace we need to know that the other side both wants peace and has the political stability to maintain it,” he said.
“When I look at the other side, I’m sorry to say I don’t see it.” Israelis and Palestinians co-exist in settlements, finding “good friendship” and “true peace,” said Haskel, also a Likud member. “Everywhere there’s Israeli construction, you see development of Palestinian lives as well,” Haskel said.
The delegates stood united against the Boycott, Divest, Sanction movement and allegations of apartheid. “When you see people from abroad using the word ‘apartheid’ or calling for a boycott, you have the feeling that they don’t understand the complexity of the conflict,” said Shmuli, a member of the Zionist Union, a center-left political alliance.
Local staff reporting, not wire, and it shows: the Israeli members are quoted and so are five Americans who disagree with them, by name, including a council member who walked out. Still no Palestinian voice — everyone arguing on behalf of Palestinians here is an American clergyman, activist, resident or councillor. Worth pairing with the Californian/USA Today piece on the same slide, where a Palestinian does speak but the frame is her loyalty.
· Bangor Daily News
REUTERS
GAZA — Israel on Sunday extended the distance it permits Gaza fishermen to head out to sea along certain parts of the coastline of the enclave, which is run by the Islamist group Hamas.
The fishing zone was expanded from 6 nautical miles to 9 along Gaza’s central and southern shores, a step that Israeli authorities said should result in a bigger catch in deeper waters, where fish are more abundant.
Israel, citing security concerns that include fears of Hamas weapons smuggling, maintains a naval blockade of Gaza, and the zone will remain at six nautical miles in northern areas near the Israeli border. Palestinians have complained of frequent Israeli interceptions and arrests of fishermen who have strayed from the zone and of the confiscation of their boats and equipment.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles, CA
Decision to prosecute a soldier who killed Palestinian attacker has opened a rare rift.
By Joshua Mitnick
TEL AVIV — Israel's military ranks among the most popular institutions in the country, winning approval ratings far outpacing the courts and the parliament. Popularity of the military chief of staff routinely exceeds that of the prime minister.
But in the days since an Israeli soldier shot to death a Palestinian knife assailant in the West Bank, a rare rift has opened up between army top brass and public opinion.
A decision to pursue a court-martial against the soldier, with an expected charge of manslaughter, has spurred widespread criticism of military leaders on social networks, in public opinion polls and in the streets.
Many Israelis at solidarity protests are hailing the soldier as a national hero, while others sympathize with a conscript perceived to have acted instinctively in the throes of a dangerous situation — a claim rejected by military prosecutors and the chief of staff.
"I think the army abandoned him," said Reuven Lavi, 50, the owner of a butcher shop in the city of Ramle, southeast of Tel Aviv. "He's serving the country. Even if he made a mistake, he's not a criminal.
He's a soldier doing his duty." The military prosecutor has said in hearings that the soldier opened fire even though the Palestinian attacker, Abdel Fattah Sharif, was no longer deemed a threat. Sharif had stabbed another soldier and then was shot and apparently incapacitated.
He was lying on the ground, barely moving, when the soldier approached him and appeared to shoot him in the head. The defense has argued that the soldier feared that Sharif was wearing an explosives belt and panicked, an account the prosecution has dismissed as not credible. No such belt was found.
The shooting in the city of Hebron was caught on video by a Palestinian activist, who sent it to the Israeli human rights group B'Tselem. It renewed Palestinian accusations that Israel has a policy of summary execution, and prompted a protest from the United Nations envoy. [...] Chief of Staff Lt. Gen.
Gadi Eisenkot, who had warned against disproportionate force against Palestinian knife attackers even before the Hebron shooting, sent an open letter to soldiers last week stressing the value of human dignity and "purity of arms." "The shots violated the professional norms and morals expected of an Israel Defense Force soldier," Eisenkot told officer cadets Tuesday, according to the Israeli media.
"There is an escalation ... that we have to win. But on the other hand, there's an understanding that if we don't establish our norms as a military, we will lose."
This is the one piece of American staff news copy in the batch that puts the word "disproportionate" next to Eisenkot's name — and it is inverted: he is the man who "had warned against disproportionate force." Nothing on the page connects him to the 2008 Dahiya statement. Photo caption: "DEMONSTRATORS gather outside Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's residence in Jerusalem to demand the release of a soldier held in the killing of a Palestinian knife assailant. 'I think the army abandoned him,' said one Israeli supporter." Credit: ABIR SULTAN European Pressphoto Agency. Story ends "Mitnick is a special correspondent." Also quoted: philosophy professor Asa Kasher, negotiator Saeb Erekat, Ehud Eliran of the University of Haifa, and Defense Minister Moshe Yaalon.
· Victoria Advocate · Victoria · page 1
Debut shows ‘we are still here,’ Abbas says
Shira Rubin, Special for USA Today, Birzeit
BIRZEIT, WEST BANK — A $24 million Palestinian Museum of Art, History and Culture that opened Wednesday showcases a beautiful building with sweeping views.
All that’s missing are the exhibits. It’s an unfortunate metaphor for a people long in search of a national identity and homeland. Still, Palestinians went ahead with a festive celebration marking the empty museum’s debut to “tell the world, the entire world, that we are here, that we are still here, and we will continue to be here to build our independent state,” Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas said. “We have been planted here since the dawn of history,” Abbas said. The 43,000-square-foot space was designed by the Dublin-based architectural firm Heneghan Peng in the style of the terraced hills of the West Bank.
It has been hailed by Palestinian leaders as a beacon of optimism in a territory under Israeli occupation. Completion of the exhibits has been delayed, in part because the museum’s director resigned last December over disagreements with the museum’s management.
With him went the first exhibit, “Never Part,” which showcased personal items of Palestinian refugees to showcase their heritage. Museum Chairman Omar Qattan said that after years of postponements, the decision was made to go ahead with the opening “for something affirmative in the midst of all this negative energy.”
“It will be even more special when we launch our programs later this year,” he said. The opening was timed to coincide with the week in which Palestinians mark the 68th anniversary of the nakba, “catastrophe” in Arabic, a reference to the creation of Israel in 1948, which led to the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians.
“The Palestinian Museum has been hailed by Palestinian leaders as a symbol of optimism.” · Shira Rubin, Special for USA Today
A museum of Palestinian art and history opens with nothing in it, and the reporter reaches for the metaphor in the third paragraph. The exhibit that was to have filled it was called Never Part and consisted of the personal belongings of refugees; it left with the director who resigned. The opening was timed for the week of the sixty-eighth anniversary of the nakba. Birzeit is the same town whose university president this archive holds being deported in 1976 and whose professors are quoted in a Miami Herald feature in 1977.
· USA Today · McLean · page 1
Shira Rubin, Special for USA Today, Birzeit
BIRZEIT, WEST BANK — A $24 million Palestinian Museum of Art, History and Culture that opened Wednesday showcases a beautiful building with sweeping views. All that’s missing are the exhibits. It’s an unfortunate metaphor for a people long in search of a national identity and homeland.
Still, Palestinians went ahead with a festive celebration marking the empty museum’s debut to “tell the world, the entire world, that we are here, that we are still here, and we will continue to be here to build our independent state,” Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas said.
“We have been planted here since the dawn of history,” he said… Completion of the exhibits has been delayed, in part because the museum’s director resigned last December over disagreements with the museum’s management.
With him went the first exhibit, “Never Part,” which showcased personal items of Palestinian refugees to showcase their heritage.
Museum Chairman Omar Qattan said that after years of delays, the decision was made to go ahead with the opening “for something affirmative in the midst of all this negative energy”… The opening was timed to coincide with the week in which Palestinians mark the 68th anniversary of the nakba, “catastrophe” in Arabic… Israeli Communications Ministry spokesman Yehiel Shavi dismissed the museum, telling USA TODAY in a phone interview Wednesday that it was an “attempt to take away the Jewish identity of this contested place.”
“The Palestinian Museum has been hailed by Palestinian leaders as a symbol of optimism.” · Shira Rubin, Special for USA Today
The same reporter and the same day as the Victoria Advocate printing held here, under a shorter headline — and with one paragraph the Texas paper did not run. An Israeli communications ministry spokesman told this newspaper by telephone that a museum of Palestinian art and history was an attempt to take away the Jewish identity of the place. The building had no exhibits in it.
· Chronicle-Tribune · Marion, IN
BY JOSEF FEDERMAN / Associated Press
JERUSALEM — Israel's incoming defense minister once called for bombing Egypt, suggested just weeks ago that Israel kill Hamas' leader in the Gaza Strip and opposed the prosecution of a soldier accused of killing a wounded Palestinian. These are just a few of the positions that could put former bar bouncer Avigdor Lieberman at odds with the military he now commands.
While people close to Lieberman insist he is a pragmatist, his long history of incendiary statements bode poorly for him as he takes over one of the region's most sensitive posts.
As Israel's defense minister, he will be responsible for overseeing military policy and handling delicate security matters with international allies whom he has antagonized in the past. [...] The army's chief, Lt. Gen.
Gadi Eisenkot, came under fire earlier this year from parliamentary hard-liners by encouraging soldiers to use only "necessary force" to subdue Palestinian attackers. The hard-liners say attackers should be killed on the spot.
In March, military leaders criticized a soldier who was caught on video fatally shooting an already-wounded Palestinian attacker in the head – and he is now on trial for manslaughter. Lieberman went to the court to offer his support to the soldier.
AP wire copy. This is the one news story in the batch where Eisenkot is positioned as the restraining figure: he is attacked by parliamentary hard-liners for telling soldiers to use only "necessary force". The same framing recurs on slides 9 and 18. Also quoted: Eliezer Marom, former head of the Israeli navy, telling Army Radio that Lieberman should be given a chance — "The man is with great political experience," Marom said.
· Chronicle-Tribune · page 1
By Fares Akram, Associated Press, Khan Younis
KHAN YOUNIS, Gaza Strip — A top U.S. coach is in the Gaza Strip to help set up the territory’s first female wheelchair basketball team. “I think for Gaza this is a very unique thing,” said the trainer, Jess Markt. “I think there are not so many opportunities for women to play sports here, and particularly for disabled women.”
Markt, 40, was a track athlete until 21 years ago when he suffered a severed spinal cord in a car accident… The perpetual state of conflict, along with substandard health care, has added to the tens of thousands of disabled Gazans.… On Saturday, 15 women and girls in wheelchairs clustered around Markt, listening to the instructions with smiles on their faces… Mona Khattab, 47, is one of the first female basketball players in Gaza… She said that most basketball courts in Gaza are not designed for wheelchairs, and many courts are open to the sun.
The players’ wheelchairs are also heavier than those used by basketball teams overseas. “With our will and power we challenge the game using these chairs,” she said. “In the international matches, the chairs are light as air. Here, our arms and muscles are sore.”
WHEELCHAIR BASKETBALL: A disabled Palestinian woman takes part in a basketball training session held by U.S. coach Jess Markt, left, in the Khan Younis refugee camp, southern Gaza Strip.
Fifteen women and girls in a Red Crescent sports hall, an eight-club men’s league already running, and a Paralympic committee trying to form a women’s team in a society where sport can be read as immodest. Mona Khattab is named and quoted. The same wire story ran in another paper the same day under a headline that kept the word female; this one takes it out.
· The Daily Times · Mamaroneck · page 1
International
By Fares Akram, Associated Press, Khan Younis
KHAN YOUNIS, Gaza Strip — A top U.S. coach is in the Gaza Strip to help set up the territory’s first female wheelchair basketball team… In 2015, the International Committee of the Red Cross brought Markt to Gaza to train local referees and coaches.
Now, he is back to train players and organize tournaments between wheelchair teams… The success of these teams helped the Paralympic Committee to persuade women and girls to form their own team in this conservative society, in which sports can be seen as immodest.
Disabled Palestinian women take part in a basketball training session held by top U.S. coach Jess Markt in the Khan Younis refugee camp in southern Gaza Strip on Saturday.
The same Associated Press story as the Chronicle-Tribune, on the same day, with one word restored to the headline. The subject is the territory’s first women’s team.
· Los Angeles Times
Ben Ehrenreich’s sobering look at Palestinian life and resistance in the West Bank
By Rayyan Al-Shawaf
The way to the spring ... is blocked. At least that’s the case for the Palestinians of Nabi Saleh, a small village northwest of Ramallah. The expansion-minded residents of a nearby Jewish settlement, with the aid of the Israeli army that occupies the West Bank, have taken over the town’s water source, which Palestinian farmers depended on to irrigate their fields.
Ben Ehrenreich, an award-winning writer based in Los Angeles, discovered as much when he moved to the West Bank, which Israel captured from Jordan in a war with its Arab neighbors in 1967.
Ehrenreich, who lived in that troubled land intermittently between 2011 and 2014 (in part, reporting for Harper’s and the New York Times Magazine), demonstrates that Nabi Saleh is no anomaly.
“The Way to the Spring: Life and Death in Palestine” emerges as a sobering, iconoclastic “collection of stories about resistance, and about people who resist,” marred slightly by the author’s unwillingness to subject Palestinian militant activity, which has often included terrorism, to moral scrutiny.
“The spring is the face of the occupation,” Bassem Tamimi of Nabi Saleh tells the author. Every Friday, the villagers, joined by international and Israeli solidarity activists, march toward it in a regularized act of protest. “And every Friday Israeli soldiers beat them back with tear gas, stun grenades, and rubber-coated bullets,” observes the author.
Afterward, groups of male youths situated some distance away hurl stones at the soldiers, who are generally beyond their reach.
IN THE WEST BANK village of Umm al-Kheir, Suleiman, a shepherd, keeps an eye on his flock. From “The Way to the Spring.” [Photographs by BEN EHRENREICH] || SALAM TAMIMI, one of activist Bassem Tamimi’s sons, at the sea in 2013. Ehrenreich spent time with the Palestinain family. [Penguin Press credit sits under the jacket image below]
· The Anniston Star · Anniston, AL
BY ISABEL KERSHNER / The New York Times
JERUSALEM — The Israeli military has canceled a contentious directive known as the Hannibal procedure, which calls for the use of maximum force to prevent the capture of Israeli soldiers, even at the risk of harming them. A military official, speaking on the condition of anonymity in accordance with army rules, said on Tuesday that the chief of staff, Lt. Gen.
Gadi Eisenkot, had given instructions several weeks ago to revoke the decades-old directive. The official said the chief of staff had established a team to formulate a new procedure for such situations. The Hannibal procedure was last invoked, with devastating consequences, during the war in Gaza in 2014.
Palestinian militants ambushed Israeli soldiers soon after a truce took effect on the outskirts of Rafah, in southern Gaza, and dragged one of them, 2nd Lt. Hadar Goldin, into a tunnel.
At least 135 Palestinians were said to have been killed as Israeli forces unleashed a barrage of artillery and airstrikes meant to prevent the militants from taking Goldin deeper into the Gaza Strip. The episode became a focus of international scrutiny and condemnation.
Amnesty International said there was strong evidence that Israel had carried out war crimes by bombarding residential areas of Rafah.
New York Times copy running in an Alabama daily. This is the most consequential Eisenkot record in the batch after the Forum op-ed: a US paper reporting, in staff-standard wire prose, that Eisenkot personally ordered the revocation of a directive under which at least 135 Palestinians were killed in Rafah in a single episode, and quoting Amnesty International's finding of strong evidence of war crimes. The number 135 is printed. Eisenkot is again the reformer in the story's grammar — the man who cancelled the order — and his own command of Northern Command in 2008 is nowhere mentioned. A boxed explainer beside the text reads "HANNIBAL PROCEDURE / First drawn up in the 1980s, the procedure does not allow Israeli soldiers to intentionally kill — or harm in a way that would lead to death — to prevent capture." Photo caption: "Israel Defense Forces tanks in a sunflower field near the border with Gaza in Sderot, Israel, July 18, 2014." Credit: Sergey Ponomarev/The New York Times, File.
· The Boston Globe · Boston
Jibril Rajoub is a notorious PLO chieftain with a long record of extolling terror. Don't Palestinian athletes deserve better?
JEFF JACOBY
“THE GOAL of Olympism,” proclaims the Olympic Charter, “is to place sport at the service of the harmonious development of humankind, with a view to promoting a peaceful society concerned with the preservation of human dignity.” Well, that's one approach. Jibril Rajoub takes a somewhat different view.
Rajoub, a longtime senior official of Fatah, the militant Palestinian faction founded by Yasser Arafat, harshly condemns efforts to promote good will through athletics, at least when the athletes include Israelis. “Any activity of normalization in sports with the Zionist enemy,” he declares, “is a crime against humanity.”
When the Peres Center for Peace hosted a soccer match between Palestinian and Israeli kids in 2014, the children enjoyed themselves immensely — “I love it when we play together like this,” 11-year-old Qusay, a Palestinian boy, told an AFP reporter. But Rajoub was furious.
It was “a disgrace to use sports for this purpose,” he thundered, and issued a “demand that all individuals and institutions distance themselves from such activities.”
He was equally implacable when the president of the Barcelona Football Club, during a good-will tour of Israel and the Palestinian Authority, proposed a match between the renowned Spanish team and a squad of Israeli and Palestinian players. “Impossible, impossible!” exclaimed Rajoub in a Palestinian TV interview.
“Impossible that there be any sport-related contact with the Israeli side, in any situation.” Rajoub's unsleeping hostility toward Israel comes as no surprise — the man is a notorious PLO chieftain with a long record of extolling terror. Alas, he is also the chairman of the Palestine Olympic Committee.
And he has consistently exploited his position within the Olympic movement to glorify violence and to prevent attempts to connect Israelis and Palestinians through sports. Such behavior isn't only hateful and immoral. It's also an egregious violation of International Olympic Committee rules.
In a new report, Palestinian Media Watch, a private media watchdog, has documented multiple examples of Rajoub's praise for terrorism and incitement to murder. Like most ideals, the Olympic mission — the promotion of peace and dignity through sport — is an aspiration not yet achieved. The Olympic Games do not resolve international conflicts.
The Olympic charter hasn't deterred tyrants from abusing human rights. Nothing the International Olympic Committee does or doesn't do will establish peace in the Middle East. But Palestinian athletes deserve a better leader than Rajoub, a man so toxic with hatred that he applauds terror attacks and denounces games that bring Arab and Jewish kids together.
At the opening ceremonies in Rio de Janeiro this week, the Olympic Hymn will be sung: “Let all the flags of every land/in brotherhood unfold.” If the IOC cannot produce universal brotherhood, can't it at least insist on a decent chairman for the Palestine Olympic Committee?
Signed column. Photograph of Rajoub credited Abbas Momani/AFP/Getty Images. The column's documentary source is a 24-page dossier by Palestinian Media Watch.
· Los Angeles Times
Anne Hormann Pasadena
The appearance of posters financed by casino mogul Sheldon Adelson listing members of the group Students for Justice in Palestine at UCLA as “Jew haters” is appalling. There is plenty of injustice to protest in Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s treatment of Palestinians.
Informed debate is impossible when anyone who criticizes Netanyahu’s policies on settlements, the wall and blocked humanitarian aid to the Gaza Strip is accused of being a “Jew hater.”
The Palestinians’ side of the story has long been suppressed, and those who try to address issues of injustice receive death threats for exercising their right of free speech and advocating for Palestinians. The status quo is unbearable for Palestinians and, in the long run, untenable for Israel.
Anyone who loves Israel should encourage meaningful discussion and work for a resolution of the occupation of the Palestinian territories.
BILLIONAIRE Sheldon Adelson is funding pro-Israel groups on college campuses in the U.S. [credit: JOHN LOCHER Associated Press]
· The Rock Island Argus · Rock Island · page 1
Associated Press
“Israel accuses Hamas of diverting aid. Israel’s U.N. Ambassador Danny Danon is accusing the Islamic militant group Hamas of diverting international aid to its ‘terror infrastructure’ and called on the United Nations to implement a strategy to end the practice.
Danon said Hamas is infiltrating humanitarian organizations in Gaza and using strategically placed operatives to divert funds. The ambassador called on U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon to implement a comprehensive oversight mechanism to ensure an end to the practice.
He said he has contacted various U.N. agencies and international aid organizations to make similar demands.”
A short wire brief. The accusation is printed; no response from anyone accused appears in it.
· Hickory Daily Record · Hickory
A Palestinian woman sits in front of the remains of her house, which was destroyed by an Israeli airstrike on Wednesday in Gaza City. Israel carried out airstrikes on the Gaza Strip after a rocket fired from the Palestinian territory on Wednesday landed in a street in the southern Israeli town of Sderot, causing no injuries, the Israeli military said.
· Arizona Daily Star · Tucson · page A15
By Edith M. Lederer, Bradley Klapper and Josef Federman, The Associated Press
UNITED NATIONS — In a striking rupture with past practice, the United States allowed the U.N. Security Council on Friday to condemn Israeli settlements in the West Bank and east Jerusalem as a “flagrant violation” of international law.
In doing so, the outgoing Obama administration brushed aside Donald Trump’s demands that the U.S. exercise its veto and provided a climax to years of icy relations with Israel’s leadership. The decision to abstain from the council’s 14-0 vote is one of the biggest American rebukes of its longstanding ally in recent memory.
And it could have significant ramifications for the Jewish state, potentially hindering Israel’s negotiating position in future peace talks. Given the world’s widespread opposition to settlements, the action will be almost impossible for anyone, including Trump, to reverse.
Nevertheless Trump vowed via Twitter: “As to the U.N., things will be different after Jan. 20th.” The resolution said Israel’s settlements in lands the Palestinians want to include in their future state have “no legal validity.” It demanded a halt to such activities for the sake of “salvaging the two-state solution.”
Loud applause erupted in the council chamber after U.S. Ambassador Samantha Power permitted the resolution to pass. Friday’s condemnation, a day after Egypt suddenly postponed a scheduled showdown, capped days of frantic diplomacy in capitals around the world.
American officials indicated they would have been prepared to let the resolution pass, despite blocking such proposals for years. Israeli officials said they were aware of such plans and turned to Trump for support. The U.S. president-elect sent a tweet urging President Obama to block the U.N. effort.
Egypt then pulled its resolution, with U.S. officials citing fierce Israeli pressure as the reason. Israeli officials then accused Obama of colluding with the Palestinians in a “shameful move” against the Jewish state. Washington denied the charge.
Most of the world is opposed to Israel’s construction of Jewish settlements in lands it seized in the 1967 Mideast War.
The primary holdout at the U.N. has been the United States, which sees settlements as illegitimate but has traditionally used its veto power as a permanent member of the Security Council to block such resolutions on the grounds that Israeli-Palestinian disputes should be addressed through negotiation.
Underscoring that unity, Friday’s resolution was proposed by nations in four different parts of the world: Malaysia, New Zealand, Senegal and Venezuela. It is the first resolution on settlements to pass in 36 years, Malaysia’s U.N. Ambassador Ramlan Bin Ibrahim said.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu ordered several diplomatic steps in retaliation, recalling his nation’s ambassadors to New Zealand and Senegal for consultations and canceling a planned January visit to Israel by Senegal’s foreign minister. He also ended Israeli aid programs to the African country.
“Israel rejects this shameful anti-Israel resolution at the U.N. and will not abide by its terms,” Netanyahu’s office said in a statement, blaming Obama for failing to “protect Israel against this gang-up at the UN” and even colluding with the country’s detractors.
“Israel looks forward to working with President-elect Trump and with all our friends in Congress, Republicans and Democrats alike, to negate the harmful effects of this absurd resolution.” By contrast, chief Palestinian negotiation Saeb Erekat hailed the result as a “victory for the justice of the Palestinian cause.”
He said Trump’s choice was now between “international legitimacy” or siding with “settlers and extremists.”
· Public Opinion · Chambersburg
He says US is trying to preserve two-state solution
Secretary of State John Kerry on Wednesday defended the controversial decision to abstain on a U.N. vote condemning Israeli settlements, saying the Obama administration wants to push a two-state solution for peace with Palestinians. “That is what we are trying to preserve for our sake and (Israel’s),” Kerry said.
“We reject the criticism that this vote abandons Israel.” In a lengthy explanation of his vision for peace in the Middle East, Kerry assailed Israeli settlements on land claimed by Palestinians for an independent state as an obstacle to peace. He said the settlements put prospects for peace in “jeopardy.”
Kerry said a two-state solution, which calls for an independent Palestinian state existing peacefully alongside Israel, is the only way to guarantee the Jewish state’s long-term security.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who had condemned the U.S. for abstaining in Friday’s Security Council vote, lashed out at Kerry’s speech as “almost as unbalanced as the anti-Israel resolution passed at the U.N. last week.” The sharp exchange represents another flare-up in the Obama administration’s relationship with Israel.
Netanyahu was a leading critic of last year’s nuclear arms deal with Iran. President-elect Donald Trump, another critic of the nuclear deal, wanted the U.S. to veto the U.N. resolution and attacked it after it passed. Before Kerry’s speech Wednesday, Trump tweeted, “We cannot continue to let Israel be treated with such total disdain and disrespect.
They used to have a great friend in the U.S., but not anymore. The beginning of the end was the horrible Iran deal, and now this (U.N.)! Stay strong Israel, January 20th is fast approaching!”
Secretary of State John Kerry speaks Wednesday at the State Department in Washington to staunchly defend the decision to abstain on the U.N. Security Council resolution to declare Israeli settlements illegal.
· The Buffalo News · Buffalo
trayed Israel’s friendship. “Some seem to believe that the U.S. friendship means that the U.S. must accept any policy ... even after urging again and again that the policy must change,” Kerry said. But “friends need to tell each other the hard truths.” He said the U.S.
“has done more to support Israel than any other country,” and noted the Obama administration has made unprecedented contributions in both military intelligence and financial aid to Israel. But Kerry said Washington would have betrayed its own values if it did not try to revive a two-state solution.
An hour after Kerry finished talking, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu lashed out at the American diplomat, accusing him of advancing the Security Council resolution and giving “a skewed speech against Israel.”
“For over an hour, Kerry dealt obsessively with the settlements and almost didn’t touch on the root of the conflict – the Palestinian opposition to a Jewish state in any boundaries,” Netanyahu said. Kerry’s remarks will all but certainly exacerbate the already strained relationship the Obama administration has had with Netanyahu.
Obama and Netanyahu have never been close; tensions peaked with the 2015 Iran nuclear accord, struck between world powers and Tehran. Israel maintains the historic deal is a threat to the Jewish state. As he prepares to take office, Trump has offered a far friendlier tone toward Israel. He has pledged to move the U.S.
Embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem – which would infuriate Palestinians who contest Israeli claims on the holy city. “We cannot continue to let Israel be treated with such total disdain and disrespect,” Trump tweeted hours before Kerry’s speech. “They used to have a great friend in the U.S., but ... not anymore.
The beginning of the end was the horrible Iran deal, and now this (U.N.)! Stay strong Israel, January 20th is fast approaching!” Responding, Netanyahu tweeted, “President-elect Trump, thank you for your warm friendship and your clear-cut support for Israel.”
He also, for reasons that are not immediately clear, tagged Trump’s two eldest children, Donald Jr. and Ivanka. A day earlier, Israeli officials pledged to reveal proof that the United States was behind the Security Council resolution that condemned Israeli settlements in Palestinian territory.
Kerry’s speech came just hours after Israel, reportedly under Netanyahu’s instruction, delayed approving hundreds of new homes in East Jerusalem. Netanyahu has been criticized by Israeli opposition leaders for the deteriorating foreign relations and his reaction to the Security Council resolution.
Kerry repeated Washington’s denials that it drove the U.N. vote, and rejected the notion that the U.S. abstention that isolated Israel. That, he said, is Israeli policy’s doing. In his defiant speech, Kerry said that while the two-state solution was supported in theory, it has not been embraced.
And if it is jettisoned, “Israel can either be Jewish, or democratic – it cannot be both – and it won’t ever really be at peace,” he said. Kerry also had harsh words for unrest begun by Palestinians, noting the Obama administration criticized their leaders for failing to condemn violence and terrorism.
But the focus of the speech was undoubtedly to rap Israel for deterring a two-state solution. Kerry characterized the current Israeli government as the most right-wing in the country’s history, held hostage by the most extreme elements of Israeli politics. Many members of Netanyahu’s coalition, he noted, publicly reject a Palestinian state.
He said rapidly increasing settlements – including 90,000 located east of a separation border that Israel itself established – may not be the main driver of Israeli-Palestinian tension. But he accused Israel of continuing to build for ideological, not security, purposes.
Doing so, Kerry said, only serve only to maintain the one-state status quo – said that appears to be precisely their point. “Settlement expansions have nothing to do with Israel’s security,” Kerry said, adding that the outposts in the West Bank may in fact, endanger Israel. “How does that help Israel’s security? How does it help the region?
The answer is: It doesn’t,” Kerry said. Instead, he said, only a two-state solution will bring peace and long-term security for Israel. Meanwhile, he said, Arab leaders are committed to changing their policy toward Israel if a two-state solution becomes a reality. “It’s waiting,” he said. “It’s right there.”
He repeated calls on both sides to commit to practical, tangible steps toward a two-state solution, and to do so “without waiting for the other side to act.” Kerry also outlined principles that might present a path for peace, many of which were merely a reiteration of U.S. policy and international law.
Kerry made Middle East peace a cornerstone of his time as the nation’s top diplomat. When he arrived in Foggy Bottom in 2013, he launched a nine-month effort to reach a “final status” of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict by the summer of 2014.
His efforts never got off the ground, despite multiple meetings with Netanyahu and Palestinian National Authority President Mahmoud Abbas. Though his words were fiery, Kerry is not alone in outlining a way toward a potential peace. France plans to convene talks on Jan. 15 to establish a roadmap for an improved situation between Palestinians and Israel.
Israel, however, has repeatedly said that it will not attend.
· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore
Readers offered a variety of strong reactions to the U.S. abstention on a resolution condemning Israeli settlement building; here’s a sample.
Obama is at fault The last line of the article “Netanyahu summons U.S. ambassador” (Dec. 24) says basically that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s actions made it easy for President Barack Obama to do what he did in declining to veto a United Nations resolution condemning Israeli settlement building.
I would argue that the Obama administration and the European countries created this mess with the settlements. They have not put pressure on Palestinian Prime Minister Mahmoud Abbas and others to come to the negotiating table as well as to stop teaching hate in their schools.
Also where is the outrage that much of the aid money to Palestine goes to the pockets of Palestinian leaders and terrorists? Why have the UN and other Arab countries not helped the Palestinians create a real economy with jobs instead of giving no hope? Why doesn’t your newspaper do an investigative story and report on those facts?
Linda Boteach, Reisterstown Who are we to complain about settlements?
President Barack Obama displays contemptible hypocrisy and arrogance in his ironic and continued actions to force Israel to stop building settlements in the lands from which it endured an unprovoked surprise attack by six Arab nations in 1967 (“Netanyahu blasts U.N., Obama over West Bank settlements resolution,” Dec. 24).
Israel miraculously prevailed and understandably annexed those lands. Meanwhile our country enjoys the “settlements” it built on the lands it annexed from Mexico in a 19th century war of aggression and which now constitute the states of Texas, Arizona, New Mexico, Colorado, Utah and California. Abraham Lincoln and Ulysses S.
Grant said we were immoral in initiating that war, and Grant said it was “one of the most unjust ever waged by a stronger nation against a weaker nation.” Perhaps we should set an example for Israel and give those six states back to Mexico. Paul H.
Belz, Lutherville Obama’s betrayal President Barack Obama’s debacle regarding his red line comment in 2012 about Syria’s use of chemical weapons is now trumped by his reneging on a statement made in 2011 that he would “not impose conditions for a final agreement on Israel at the UN Security Council.”
Resolution 2334 condemning Israeli settlement building represents his attempt to leave his mark on the Middle East peace process, but he should realize the obvious that a true peace will only be achieved by direct negotiations between the Israelis and Palestinians.
This will only occur when Israel can be assured that Hamas, whose charter calls for the annihilation of Israel, will not take control of the West Bank from which rockets would then likely be hailed into Israel as they have been incessantly from Gaza since Israel unilaterally returned this territory to the Palestinians over 10 years ago.
President Obama’s betrayal of Israel on the international stage via an organization which has repeatedly been anti-Israel in its actions over many years will only decrease the likelihood of forward movement of the Israeli/Palestinian peace process.
Marc Okun, Stevenson Obama did the right thing on settlements While Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s response to the U.S. abstention on the U.N. Security Council’s resolution against further settlements on the West Bank was predictable, President Barack Obama’s statesmanlike stance was much needed.
The world has long condemned Israel’s policy of settling the West Bank, but especially under Mr. Netanyahu the settlements have become a sore issue with Palestinians. Yet Mr. Netanyahu persisted. President Obama did the only realistic thing, which was to “respect the decent opinion of mankind,” to borrow a phrase from the Declaration of Independence.
If progress is to be made toward a peaceful settlement in the Holy Land, which embodies the heritage of Christians, Jews and Muslims, then a negotiation must involve the needs of all parties not just the Israeli government. When will the Israeli government learn that its own peace and security is also dependent on a just peace for all?
Hopefully our new incoming president will not have to re-learn some of these bitter lessons from the region. President Obama did the right thing despite Mr. Netanyahu’s opposition.
Christopher Boardman What Israel’s settlements really are There has been a lot of media coverage on the United Nations Security Council’s resolution against Israeli settlements (“Obama is at fault in Israel settlement mess,” Dec. 27). But often these reports don’t explain what settlements really are.
They are Jewish-only communities with Jewish-only roads built within Palestinian borders. In other words, they are segregated. They are built on lands that have been forcibly confiscated from Palestinians. Lands that once had homes, schools and farms on them. It is a form of ethic cleansing.
They are facts-on-the-ground evidence that Israel was never sincere about negotiations. How can you say you want to negotiate borders when all the while you are confiscating land? And they are in defiance of one of the most cherished international laws: the Fourth Geneva Convention. The question isn’t really why the U.S. abstained on this vote.
The question is why the U.S. didn’t vote for it. And most of all, why it has taken us so long to see the damage that settlements have had to a just peace. Susan Kerin, Rockville Obama is no friend of Israel Regarding the article “Netanyahu summons U.S. ambassador” (Dec. 26), President Barack Obama has shown his true colors.
Just giving money to Israel doesn’t prove friendship. Part of Mr. Obama’s legacy will be that he was worst American presidential friend of Israel ever. Alan Blank, Baltimore County
In this 2015 file photo, President Barack Obama meets with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the Oval Office. Mr. Netanyahu claims to have “ironclad” information that Washington actively helped craft the U.N. resolution declaring Israeli settlements illegal.
· Jackson Citizen Patriot · Jackson
Opinion
Cal Thomas, Tribune Content Agency
Opinion A two-faced policy cooked up with just one of the sides Cal Thomas Tribune Content Agency In his recent speech excoriating Israel for refusing to commit suicide by allowing a sworn enemy to have a state adjoining the Jewish state, Secretary of State John Kerry claimed the U.S. government "did not draft or originate" the U.N. resolution critical of Israeli "settlements." Kerry said there were no American fin- gerprints on the resolution and that it was totally the idea of the Egyptians and Palestinians.
Except that it wasn't, if one can believe Egyptian intelligence. The Middle East Media Research Institute reports on a story published in an Egyptian news website with close ties to Egyptian Intelligence.
According to the report, a secret meeting took place in Washington in mid-December attended by Kerry, National Security Adviser Susan Rice and a Palestinian delegation that included PLO Secretary General Saeb Erekat. Political discussions were also said to be part of the agenda.
According to the transcribed minutes obtained by Al-Youm Al-Sabi, the gathering "reveals U.S. coordination leading up to the U.N. Security Council vote on Resolution 2334 regarding Israel's settlements. ...
It states that the sides 'agreed to cooperate in drafting a resolution on the settlements' and that the U.S. representative in the Security Council was 'empowered' to coordinate with the Palestinian U.N. representative on the resolution." Susan Rice is said to have warned the Palestinians about the "danger" of the incoming Trump administration's policies, adding that both she and Kerry had advised Palestinian President Mahmoud Kerry said the resolution was totally the idea of the Egyptians and Palestinians.
Except that it wasn't.
Abbas not to make any preliminary moves that might "provoke the new administration." The report also said Kerry and Rice had "fulsomely praised Abbas' policies and how he handled matters, and harshly criticized Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, saying that he 'aims to destroy the two-state solution." This is remarkably cynical even in our cynical age.
If the Egyptian newspaper report is true — and the Obama administration has so far not denied it— the administration is guilty of a two-faced solution to the conflict, which is no solution at all from the standpoint of Israel and the Jewish people who have been the targets of unprovoked attacks since Israel's rebirth in 1948.
Furthermore, since the Palestinian side now includes Hamas and Fatah in a unity coalition - two entities that have vowed not omy to never make peace with Israel but to seek its destruction and the expulsion of all Jews from the land - only a fool would believe that peace is possible under such circumstances.
Peace, like success, is a byproduct, not a goal that can be reached without certain precursors. Success is achieved by hard work, a good education and right relation- ships. Peace is achieved when one side is victorious or two sides decide they don't want to fight anymore. Jordan and Egypt gave up on war, leading to peace with Israel. The Palestinian side fights on.
President-elect Trump has promised things will be different when it comes to U.S. policy toward Israel starting Jan. 20. One can only hope.
· Telegram & Gazette · Worcester
In recent days, the Obama administration has undertaken two significant actions regarding the Israeli-Palestinian issue. It refrained from vetoing a resolution at the U.N. Security Council that, among other things, detailed the devastating impact that Israeli settlement expansion is having on the prospects for a two-state peace agreement.
And in a landmark speech, Secretary of State John F. Kerry warned that the trend toward a one-state reality is becoming increasingly entrenched, and he set out principles for a lasting peace based on a two-state solution. He rightly pointed out that the demise of the two-state option is to nobody’s benefit – Israeli, Palestinian or American.
We share Kerry’s concerns and applaud the Obama administration for having set out the conclusions of its peace efforts in a transparent and compelling manner. Over decades in and out of government, we have shared with great conviction the United States’ commitment to Israel and its security.
We have also followed with increasing concern the inability to secure the kind of peace that Israelis and Palestinians alike so deserve and that would best advance U.S. goals in the region and beyond.
No side is blameless for the absence of peace, but the relentless confiscation of Palestinian land and expansion of Israel’s presence in the territories occupied since 1967 have created facts on the ground that are the proximate cause of fear that a two-state deal might soon be impossible to attain.
Kerry’s speech and the U.S. decision to abstain at the United Nations on Resolution 2334 have stirred controversy, at home and abroad. We feel it is important to offer reminders of certain simple truths.
Support for Israeli-Palestinian peace predicated on an Israeli withdrawal to a border based on the 1967 lines and opposition to Israeli civilian settlements in occupied territories have been long-standing bipartisan principles of U.S. policy.
· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha
So it’s near the end of his time in office, and President Barack Obama decides to put forever-threatened Israel at more of a disadvantage in maintaining its survival. Interestingly, the move could also weaken a United Nations that indeed needs weakening, but that was hardly the president’s intent. That said, what was his intent, anyway?
An answer of sorts came last week from Secretary of State John Kerry, stern of face, sour of disposition, spouting words like cannon balls, when he gave a speech lasting an hour and 10 minutes at the State Department. He defended a vote of the U.N. Security Council to stop expansion of Israeli settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem.
The land belonged to Palestine, he said. The only way to get peace between Israel and Palestine was a two-state solution, namely for Israel to quit occupying the land.
Thus it was, he said, that the United States did not veto a U.N. resolution declaring Israel’s actions illegal, thereby likely prompting more sanctions by other countries and lessening one of the few negotiating positions the Israelis had.
But then Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu gave a speech, roughly an hour shorter than Kerry’s and 100 percent more persuasive. He noted that the Palestinian Authority’s wishes went beyond wanting just that land as its own. It wanted the eradication of the Jewish state. Terrorists, bombs and missiles were among its way of saying so.
For eight years, the Palestinian leader had refused to negotiate at all. Netanyahu had made hundreds of calls to him without getting return calls and, by the way, there had been some serious offerings in the past.
Israel, of course, is a mere speck in the Arab Middle East, much of which has had Israel’s demolition in mind since the country began its modern-age existence in 1948.
· Clarion Ledger · Jackson, MS
--USA Today
The dream of Israelis and Palestinians living peacefully side by side in neighboring homelands is on life support, the chances of it surviving as a viable Middle East peace option slowly ebbing away. But that doesn't mean it can't be saved.
Secretary of State John Kerry attempted some very public CPR in his impassioned address last week, explaining why the Obama administration refused on Dec. 23 to veto a United Nations resolution condemning the proliferation of Israeli settlements that place the two-state solution in jeopardy.
Hard-liners derided the speech as little more than a eulogy for the hope of an independent Palestine, a peace doctrine dating to the birth of Israel seven decades ago. But if Kerry's goal was to breathe life into that option until Palestinians have a leadership brave enough to embrace both independence and compromise, there are ways to preserve the two-state solution.
It could be left to President-elect Donald Trump, the self-styled artist of the deal who called an Israeli-Palestinian peace agreement the "ultimate deal," to make it happen. Kerry's speech was an excellent primer for why the only other option — a one-state solution — is a recipe for endless misery.
Israel would carve what it wants from the West Bank and perpetually occupy or isolate the remainder and Gaza.
Palestinians in the annexed territory would either have to be granted full Israeli citizenship — adding their embittered population to a growing Arab-Israeli society that would someday outnumber and outvote their Jewish counterparts — or be relegated second-class citizens.
"If the choice is one state, Israel can either be Jewish or democratic — it cannot be both — and it won't ever really be at peace," Kerry rightly warned about a solution that is growing ever more popular within Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's conservative Cabinet.
There have been more than 2,000 Palestinian terror attacks on Israelis in the past year — stabbings, shootings and bombings. While the regime of Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas says it opposes such violence, Abbas and his party leaders still abide public squares, schools and streets being named in honor of the attackers. Fatah websites glorify them.
Hamas fires intermittent volleys of rockets out of Gaza. These actions block a pathway to peace. But the solution at the end of that pathway — should the Palestinians ever actually embrace a final two-state agreement — is being destroyed by ever expanding Jewish settlements into the West Bank and East Jerusalem, now numbering half a million settlers.
For the past 17 years, three successive American administrations have tried to achieve the grand-slam of a Middle East agreement, each failing. Preserving the two-state solution for a fourth effort might mean, for now, more modest goals, such as a U.S.-Israeli agreement to limit, if not end, new settlement construction. There's an avenue for this.
The Palestinians have long since acknowledged that any future peace agreement requires small land swaps: chunks of the West Bank given to Israel in exchange for similar pieces of Israel given to the Palestinians. All but about 90,000 Jewish settlers live in about 5% of the West Bank that includes portions of East Jerusalem.
Israel's defense minister, Avigdor Liberman, suggested in November that Israel could freeze construction of settlements outside those blocs if the U.S. — and he specifically suggested Trump, who already seems to hold favor with Netanyahu — would agree to allow new construction within the blocs.
The idea would be that those settlement blocs would one day be a part of any land swap in a future Middle East peace agreement. Should an accord one day be reached, settlers living in outposts outside those blocs would either have to move to Israeli territory or become citizens of a new Palestine. This isn't a perfect idea. It isn't even a solution.
But it could save a solution. Says Dennis Ross, a former Middle East negotiator under presidents George H.W. Bush and Bill Clinton, "We would be doing something that helps to preserve the two-state option, and I think that's in our interest. Because the one-state option is a prescription for enduring conflict."
On the Liberman question this is the opposite pole from the Boehm column on slide 59. Here Liberman is a constructive actor with a workable settlement-freeze proposal, and his position on Palestinian citizens of Israel is not mentioned at all. Note also the arithmetic the editorial does and does not do: more than 2,000 Palestinian attacks on Israelis in the past year are counted; no Palestinian casualty figure appears anywhere. The one sentence that acknowledges Palestinian citizenship — ‘or be relegated second-class citizens’ — is printed without the word ‘to’, as set.
· The Register-Guard · Eugene, OR · page A10
BY JOSEF FEDERMAN / The Associated Press
JERUSALEM — The Israeli military, which has battled foes on all of the country's borders, is now facing a challenge from within: nationalist politicians who are openly disagreeing with army commanders and bickering with the security establishment.
This growing rift was underscored by angry reactions from inside Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's coalition to Wednesday's manslaughter conviction of an Israeli soldier who fatally shot an already wounded Palestinian attacker. [...] Azaria was tried after a human rights worker filmed him in March fatally shooting a badly wounded Palestinian assailant in the West Bank city of Hebron.
The assailant had already been shot after stabbing an Israeli soldier and was lying on the ground. Lt. Gen. Gadi Eizenkot, the head of the military, was among the first to condemn Azaria, saying his actions ran counter to its ethics and values.
Military service is compulsory for Israeli Jews, so most have relatives in the service and soldiers are seen as "our boys and girls." Opinion polls in Israeli media showed 70 percent of the Jewish public supports a pardon. [...] Eizenkot, meanwhile, was excoriated on social media in ways that would have been unthinkable a few years ago.
A small crowd of extremists demonstrating outside military headquarters called for his assassination.
Folio reads "A10 | THE REGISTER-GUARD INTERNATIONAL | SATURDAY, JANUARY 7, 2017" — masthead, section and date all agree with Maria's label. Photo caption: "Sgt. Elor Azaria waits with family inside the military court in Tel Aviv, Israel, before being found guilty." Credit: HEIDI LEVINE/via The Associated Press. Also quoted or cited: Liat Schlesinger of the leftist think tank Molad; Education Minister Naftali Bennett; Culture Minister Miri Regev; Sima Kadmon; the 2012 documentary "The Gatekeepers"; former Prime Minister Ehud Barak; and Meir Elran of the Institute for National Security Studies, who says the rift is "quite serious" and "We do not want that to be diminished, and degraded." Eizenkot here is again the restraining figure — the man the far right wants killed for condemning a soldier.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles · page 1
Hip-hop artist who found solace in American rap angers Israel’s right and left with his movie
Joshua Mitnick, Lod
“LOD, Israel — Tamer Nafar fell in love with hip-hop growing up amid the faded public housing blocks and garbage-strewn public parks of Ramat Eshkol, one of the poorest neighborhoods in the central Israeli city of Lod where life was punctuated by daily spurts of gunfire… Just a five-minute walk from his home, an upstairs neighbor was shot and killed in a gang [fight] that left multiple people injured.
It took the police nearly an hour to arrive. ‘Just a month before, a Jewish guy was stabbed and they had a helicopter in the air,’ he said. ‘I found myself feeling [angry] about the police.
At 18, my friends started dying.’ Against this backdrop, Nafar found solace in the lyrics of African American rappers like Public Enemy and Biggie Smalls, learning English and absorbing their social commentary as he listened… Scenes depicting confrontations between police and African American youths reminded them of Lod.
‘They would say, wow, they are talking about us,’ he said. ‘That’s exactly what happened yesterday.’
The audio samples in Tupac Shakur’s ‘White Man’z World’ introduced Nafar to Malcolm X and Spike Lee. ‘I found Palestinian heroes through African American ones,’ Nafar said. The nationalism of the Black Panthers, he said, prompted him to learn about the Palestine Liberation Organization; the verse of Maya Angelou led him to Palestinian national poet Mahmoud Darwish. ‘I had to go West so I could find my Eastern identity.’… Nafar and DAM threw the accusation back at Israel with the lyrics, ‘Who is the terrorist / You are a terrorist / You have taken everything I own in my land.’… ‘Kareem is at a junction — a crossroads.
“Do I go with my girlfriend [in public], or not?” Am I Palestinian? Or do I sing at an Israeli club?’
Nafar said. ‘This whole junction and confusion started in 1948.’ On the eve of Israel’s war for independence, Lod was an Arab village on the railway to Jerusalem… Amid fighting there, the Israeli army killed hundreds of Arab civilians in the town and expelled tens of thousands more — part of a larger trauma of Arab displacement accompanying Israel’s birth that Palestinians refer to as the Nakba, or disaster.… Then, at the film awards ceremony, Miri Regev, Israel’s right-wing culture minister, left the auditorium in protest during a performance by Nafar because it featured a recitation of passages penned by Darwish. Regev later unsuccessfully tried to have Nafar’s concert at a festival canceled, alleging in a letter that ‘Nafar elects at every opportunity and on every stage to come out against the idea of the state of Israel and its existence as the state of the Jewish people.’ ‘I was educated in an Arab Israeli school.
I was denied Mahmoud Darwish before I was 20,’ he said. ‘All they told us is that they saved the country. Nobody told us that they kicked out my grandfather. This whole piece is missing.’… ‘There is very strong self-criticism,’ he said.
‘The good guy in our movie is Palestinian and the bad guy in our movie is a Palestinian.’ Nafar has come out against honor killings in Lod, and he once was threatened by local hard-liners for performing with a woman… ‘Cultural figures are important, but they don’t sway the masses,’ said Jackie Khoury, the news director of the Arabic radio station A Shams… ‘Our movie is a solution,’ he said.
‘The solution is when the strong side, the privileged side, will be part of the story-telling of the oppressed side… When Jews and Palestinians work together to tell the story of the oppressed, that’s where hope comes.’”
“TAMER NAFAR says Israel’s left-wing cultural elites can’t accept a Palestinian rendering of their conflict. ‘That’s how the Israeli left wing rolls: We like your talent, but keep your Palestinian narrative outside.’” · Joshua Mitnick / For The Times
A rapper from Lod who found his own history through Public Enemy and Maya Angelou: I had to go West so I could find my Eastern identity. It joins to the Darwish material in this archive at two points. He says he was denied Darwish until he was twenty, having been taught only that the country had been saved and not that his grandfather was expelled from it. And at a film awards ceremony Israel’s culture minister walked out of his performance because it included a recitation of Darwish — seventeen years after the archive’s clippings on the row over teaching five of the same poems in schools. The line the paper puts under his photograph is the section’s whole subject in one sentence: we like your talent, but keep your Palestinian narrative outside. He also says the bad guy in his own film is a Palestinian.
· Daily American Republic · Poplar Bluff · page 1
Karin Laub and Mohammed Daraghmeh, The Associated Press, Ramallah, West Bank
“Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas, who spent hundreds of hours on the phone and in meetings with U.S. presidents and secretaries of state in the past 12 years, has tried unsuccessfully to reach out to President Donald Trump… Erekat, whose contacts are now limited to the U.S.
Consulate in Jerusalem, has been quoted as saying that ‘we have sent them letters, written messages; they don’t even bother to respond to us.’… Many Palestinians are disillusioned with a process they say effectively provided diplomatic cover for Israeli settlement expansion and distanced statehood prospects… ‘not having a relationship with Washington is cutting off their air supply, essentially,’ said Khaled Elgindy, an analyst at the Brookings Institution… ‘The foreign policy of the U.S. administration is not clear yet, aside from its clear support of Israel, but the administration knows nothing can be done without the Palestinians,’ said Abbas adviser Mohammed Ishtayeh.”
A wire explainer in question-and-answer form, printed in a Missouri daily.
· Park City Daily News
UNITED NATIONS — The United States on Friday blocked the appointment of the former Palestinian prime minister to lead the U.N. political mission in Libya, saying it was acting to support its ally Israel. U.S. Ambassador Nikki Haley said the Trump administration “was disappointed” to see that U.N.
Secretary-General Antonio Guterres had sent a letter to the Security Council indicating his intention to appoint Salam Fayyad, who served as the Palestinian Authority’s prime minister from 2007-13, as the next U.N. special representative to Libya.
“For too long the U.N. has been unfairly biased in favor of the Palestinian Authority to the detriment of our allies in Israel,” Haley said. Palestine is a non-member observer state at the United Nations and its independence has been recognized by 137 of the 193 U.N. member nations.
But Haley said the United States doesn’t currently recognize a Palestinian state “or support the signal” Fayyad’s appointment would send within the United Nations.
U.N. diplomats, speaking on condition of anonymity because discussions have been private, said Fayyad is well-respected for his work in reforming the Palestinian Authority and spurring its economy and had the support of the 14 other Security Council members to succeed Martin Kobler in the Libya job.
Despite opposition to Fayyad, Haley indicated the Trump administration wants to see an end to the decades-old Israeli-Palestinian conflict. “We encourage the two sides to come together directly on a solution,” she said.
Haley’s statement came ahead of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s scheduled meeting at the White House with President Donald Trump on Feb. 15, and was welcomed by Israelis.
“This is the beginning of a new era at the U.N., an era where the U.S. stands firmly behind Israel against any and all attempts to harm the Jewish State,” Israel’s U.N. Ambassador Danny Danon said of the U.S. decision to block Fayyad’s appointment.
“The new administration proved once again that it stands firmly alongside the state of Israel in the international arena and in the U.N. in particular.” The new U.S. ambassador made clear that “going forward, the United States will act, not just talk, in support of our allies.”
But Trump also indicated in comments to an Israeli newspaper Friday that there might be some difficult discussions with Netanyahu next week on Israel’s settlement expansion. The U.S. leader was quoted as saying that Israel’s settlement expansion in land claimed by the Palestinians does not advance peace.
· Sun News
WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump and his advisers, venturing for the first time into the fraught world of Middle East peacemaking, are developing a strategy on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict that would enlist Arab nations like Saudi Arabia and Egypt to break years of deadlock.
The emerging approach mirrors the thinking of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel, who will visit the United States next week, and would build on his de facto alignment with Sunni Muslim countries in trying to counter the rise of Shiite-led Iran.
But Arab officials have warned Trump and his advisers that if they want cooperation, the United States cannot make life harder for them with provocative pro-Israel moves. The White House seems to be taking the advice. Trump delayed his plan to move the U.S.
Embassy to Jerusalem after Arab leaders told him that doing so would cause angry protests among Palestinians, who also claim the city as the capital of a future state. And after meeting with King Abdullah II of Jordan last week, Trump authorized a statement that, for the first time, cautioned Israel against building new West Bank settlements beyond existing lines.
“There are some quite interesting ideas circulating on the potential for U.S.-Israeli-Arab discussions on regional security in which Israeli-Palestinian issues would play a significant role,” said Robert Satloff, the executive director of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.
The notion of recruiting Arab countries to help forge an agreement between Israelis and Palestinians – known as the “outside-in” approach – is not a new one. As secretary of state under President George H.W. Bush, James Baker organized the first regional conference in 1991 at which Arab leaders sat down with Israel’s prime minister.
President George W. Bush invited Arab leaders to a summit meeting with Israel in Maryland in 2007. And President Barack Obama’s first special envoy, George Mitchell, spent months in 2009 trying to enlist Arab partners in a joint effort.
The difference is that in the last eight years, Israel has grown closer to Sunni Arab nations because of their shared concern about Iranian hegemony in the region, opening the possibility that this newfound, if not always public, affiliation could change the dynamics.
“The logic of outside-in is that because the Palestinians are so weak and divided – and because there’s a new, tacit relationship between the Sunni Arabs and Israel – there’s the hope the Arabs would be prepared to do more,” said Dennis B. Ross, a Middle East peace negotiator under several presidents, including Obama.
That is a departure from the countervailing assumption that if Israel first made peace with the Palestinians, it would lead to peace with the larger Arab world – the “inside-out” approach.
That was at the core of President Bill Clinton’s attempts to bring the two sides together and was Obama’s fallback position after his efforts to find Arab partners failed. Netanyahu, who is due at the White House on Wednesday, has been talking about an outside-in approach for a while. His theory is that the inside-out approach has failed.
And so, he argues, if Israel can transform its relationship with Sunni Arab nations, they can ultimately lead the way toward a resolution with the Palestinians. Jared Kushner, the senior White House adviser whom Trump has assigned a major role in negotiations, has been intrigued by this logic, according to people who have spoken with him.
Kushner has grown close to Ron Dermer, the Israeli ambassador and a close confidant of Netanyahu’s. Trump and Kushner also had dinner at the White House on Thursday night with Sheldon Adelson, the casino magnate and key supporter of Netanyahu.
A series of telephone conversations and personal meetings with Arab and regional leaders in recent weeks have also shaped Kushner’s thinking and that of the president.
Trump has talked with President Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi of Egypt; King Salman of Saudi Arabia; Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed al-Nahyan, the crown prince of Abu Dhabi; and President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey. Kushner has also met with Arab officials, including Yousef Al Otaiba, the ambassador from the United Arab Emirates.
Jordan’s King Abdullah II seems to have played a particularly pivotal role. Concerned that an embassy move would anger Palestinians living in his country, the king rushed to Washington without an invitation in a gamble that he could see Trump. He visited first with Vice President Mike Pence, who had him over for breakfast at his official residence last week.
The king appealed to the administration’s fixation with the Islamic State group, arguing that it should not alienate Arab allies who could help. Several days later, the king buttonholed Trump on the sidelines of the National Prayer Breakfast and made a similar case.
He advised against a radical shift in U.S. policy and emphasized the risks that Jordan would face if Israel were to become even more assertive about building settlements, according to people who spoke with Kushner and Steve Bannon, the chief White House strategist.
Trump had already decided by that point to slow down the embassy move – a decision that did not especially trouble Netanyahu and his team, who, while publicly supporting a move, privately urged caution to avoid a violent backlash.
Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, right, talks with King Abdullah of Jordan this month during the National Prayer Breakfast in Washington.
· Park City Daily News
RAMALLAH, West Bank — A Palestinian author is stranded in Qatar after Palestinian authorities in the West Bank confiscated all copies of his latest novel and issued an arrest warrant for him — accusing him of including “sexual terms” in a provocative work that takes aim at taboo issues such as fanaticism, religious extremism and homosexuality.
The crackdown on Abbad Yahya, 29, has set off a wide public debate between the Palestinian society’s large conservative segment and the small liberal minority. In a telephone interview, Yahya told The Associated Press that he was visiting Doha when he learned of the ban and the arrest warrant, published by the official governmental news agency.
He said he is now stuck in the Qatari capital, fearing he would be arrested as soon as he returns home. “I don’t know what to do. If I go back, I will be arrested, and if I stay here, I can’t stay far from my home and family,” he said.
The novel, “Crime in Ramallah,” tracks the lives of three young Palestinian men who meet in the city, which serves as the headquarters of the Palestinian government that rules in autonomous enclaves of the Israeli-occupied West Bank. The youths work together in a bar, where the murder of a young woman takes place.
One of the three, a gay youth, is arrested and interrogated about the crime. Although he is cleared of any charges, the officers realize he is gay and they beat and humiliate him. He ends up moving to France, looking for a society that accepts him.
· The Star Press · Muncie
WASHINGTON - President Donald Trump hosted Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the White House on Wednesday for a series of meetings intended to “show there is no daylight” between the two leaders on a range of issues.
And that includes the so-called “two-state solution” that has been a hallmark of U.S. policy in the Middle East — and a source of friction between the Netanyahu government and Trump’s predecessor, President Barack Obama. Trump professed to be agnostic on the policy. “So I’m looking at two-state or the one-state,” Trump said.
“I was thinking for a while that the two-state was looking like the easier of the two.” He concluded that the matter is up to Israel and Palestine to decide. “I’m happy with the one they like best,” he said. The one-state solution would include Israelis and Palestinians in a single, secular country with equal citizenship.
The two-state solution calls for a negotiated settlement leading to a Palestinian nation alongside Israel, and it was the U.S. policy under both the Bush and Obama administrations.
But with Trump stepping back, Netanyahu reasserted his position that a two-state solution can only happen under two conditions: The new Palestinian state must recognize Israel’s legitimacy, and Israel must maintain security control of the West Bank. And he suggested that the very “two-state” label was a hindrance to progress.
“Rather than deal with labels, I’d like to deal with substance,” Netanyahu said. Trump and Netanyahu appeared to have an easy chemistry, bantering among themselves during the press conference. “Bibi and I have known each other a long time — a smart man, great negotiator. And I think we’re going to make a deal,” Trump said.
President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu participate in a joint news conference in the East Room of the White House on Wednesday.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles, CA
Elor Azaria killed a wounded Palestinian who had attacked other troops.
BY JOSHUA MITNICK
TEL AVIV — Elor Azaria cracked a smile and his family broke out in song Tuesday moments after a military tribunal sentenced the Israeli soldier to 18 months in jail for killing a wounded Palestinian knife assailant in March in a case that has gripped national attention for nearly a year.
The decision came a month and a half after the military court unanimously convicted Azaria of manslaughter, ruling that he had violated the military's open-fire regulations when he shot the attacker, Abdel Fattah Sharif, in the head as Sharif lay wounded on the ground and no longer posed a threat.
The politically charged case roiled Israel's government, drove a rare wedge between Israeli public opinion — which is broadly sympathetic to Azaria — and the Israel Defense Forces top brass, and spurred international criticism of Israel. [...] Relatives of Sharif denounced the sentence as too short. "My family rejects this. This verdict is wrong," said Fathi Sharif, an uncle.
"The judge made a mistake when he gave the soldier only a year and a half in prison. Other people who do the same thing get 20 years in jail." The sentence was substantially shorter than the prison term of three to five years requested by the military prosecution. The court also demoted Azaria, a sergeant at the time of the shooting, to the rank of private.
On Tuesday, the judges wrote that they took into consideration that the incident occurred in "hostile" territory — in the West Bank city of Hebron — in deciding on a minimal jail term. A manslaughter conviction carries a maximum 20 years in prison. [...] Former Defense Minister Moshe Yaalon and IDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen.
Gadi Eisenkot said that Azaria had violated the military's values. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called Azaria's family as a show of support.
Photo caption: "IN TEL AVIV, Elor Azaria is embraced by his mother, Oshra, at the start of his sentencing hearing. His case has gripped the nation." Credit: JIM HOLLANDER Pool Photo. Story ends "Mitnick is a special correspondent." Eisenkot appears only as one of two names in a single sentence recording official disapproval of Azaria; no Eisenkot words are quoted. Maria's label gives this paper as "Los Angeles Times" where slide 3 gives "The Los Angeles Times" — the two spellings would ingest as two papers; flagging for her to settle, not changing either.
· The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck
Associated Press
BETHLEHEM, West Bank (AP) — Palestinians are celebrating a Christian crooner from the West Bank city of Bethlehem who won this year’s Arab Idol, the Arab world’s premier television song competition. Yacoub Shaheen, 22, beat finalists Ameer Dandan from an Arab town in northern Israel and Ammar Mohammed from Yemen.
Shaheen is the second Palestinian to win the Arab world’s version of American Idol. In 2013, Palestinian…
Yacoub Shaheen, 22, of Bethlehem, wins the Arab world’s biggest television song contest, and the second word the story uses about him is Christian. It is one of the few places in this archive where an American paper says so plainly, without treating it as a curiosity, and it is a music story rather than a religion one.
· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia
RAMALLAH, West Bank — President Trump invited Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas to the White House to discuss resuming peace talks in their first contact since Trump took office in January. Abbas’ spokesman Nabil Abu Rdeneh said that Abbas would travel “very soon.”
The White House said in a statement that the two leaders on Friday discussed ways to advance peace throughout the Middle East, including a comprehensive agreement that would end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. “The president emphasized his personal belief that peace is possible and that the time has come to make a deal,” the White House said.
“The president noted that such a deal would not only give Israelis and Palestinians the peace and security they deserve, but that it would reverberate positively throughout the region and the world.”
Trump underscored that such a peace agreement must be negotiated directly between the two parties, and that the United States will work closely with Palestinian and Israeli leadership to make progress toward that goal, the statement said. “We are ready to deal with President Trump and the Israeli government to resume the negotiations,” Abu Rdeneh said.
“If the Israelis are ready, President Abbas has committed himself to a peaceful deal with President Trump.” Abu Rdeneh added that “President Trump is a very honest man, very courageous man, looking for a deal, a just deal.” There was no immediate comment from the Israeli government. The last round of U.S.-mediated peace talks collapsed in 2014.
Friday’s call was the first between Trump and Abbas since Trump took office.
Mahmoud Abbas
· Columbia Daily Tribune · page C4
By Anne-Marie O'Connor / Special to The Washington Post
JALUD, West Bank – Palestinian farmer Fawzi Ibrahim is proud of his heirloom corn, whose kernels ripen in iridescent shades of red, blue and gold like jewels. But what makes it priceless are the obstacles he faces to grow his crops. Small farmers struggle worldwide.
But international experts say Palestinian farmers face disabling odds in the 60 percent of the West Bank that is under full Israeli control and is home to some 400,000 Jewish settlers.
As settler agricultural start-ups get prioritized access to water, export markets and development rights, the Israeli occupation is roiling the centuries-old pastoral life of Palestinian farmers, experts say, adding fuel to a conflict in which land is a trigger.
For years, Israeli settlers have chased Ibrahim's tractor, threatened him, yelled at his Israeli soldier escorts, tried to burn his fields and warned that setting foot there would risk bloodshed, according to the Israeli group Rabbis for Human Rights. Ibrahim must coordinate with the Israeli army because his land is in a security zone abutting Israeli outposts, the group said.
But he and his lawyer waited eight weeks for permission to plant 50 acres of winter wheat in just two days, under the guard of two jeeploads of Israeli soldiers. A human rights worker and Israeli settlers looked on. Ibrahim said he fears he will suffer thousands of dollars in farming losses again this year. “They're making us poor,” he said.
A recent U.N. report said the Israeli occupation has set off a “continuous process of de-agriculturization” in the Israeli-controlled West Bank, depriving the Palestinian economy of potential agriculture revenue of $700 million, by World Bank estimates, as Israeli settlers ban Palestinians from crops, grazing lands and springs.
Fawzi Ibrahim, a Palestinian farmer, waited two months for the Israeli army to give him access to his wheat fields this year. The Israeli settlement of Esh Kodesh is behind him on the hill. [ANNE-MARIE O'CONNOR FOR THE WASHINGTON POST]
· Chicago Jewish Star · Chicago, IL
IDF HEAD: BUT TUNNELS ARE NO 'STRATEGIC THREAT'
Tazpit News Agency
Israel Defense Forces Chief of Staff GADI EISENKOT said March 22 that while Hamas tunnels into Israel from Gaza should be taken seriously, they do not represent an existential or a strategic threat.
Speaking to a Knesset State Control Committee about State Comptroller YOSEF SHAPIRA's recent report about the 2014 Operation Protective Edge, Eisenkot said "the underground threat is very serious, and we treat it as such.
"But I don't think it is an existential or strategic threat." Eisenkot said that during the operation the army discovered more than a dozen tunnels from Gaza into Israeli territory, which allowed Hamas members to infiltrate Israel and led to the deaths of 13 soldiers during the fighting.
The army commander added that the IDF and defense ministry have dedicated more than NIS 4 billion since Protective Edge to defend against the tunnel threat. NIS 1.2 billion have gone for training programs to develop effective responses to the threat, including an advanced radar system and an intelligence gathering apparatus.
Whole item transcribed. The paper's house style sets personal names in small capitals on first mention (GADI EISENKOT, YOSEF SHAPIRA); reproduced here in capitals. Photograph of Eisenkot with a vertical credit reading "— GADI EISENKOT / IGPO PHOTO VIA ASHERNET". The item counts 13 Israeli soldiers dead and NIS 4 billion spent and gives no Palestinian casualty figure for Protective Edge.
· New Jersey Herald · page 1
Israel and the Palestinians
The Associated Press, Jerusalem
“For many Israelis, Har Homa is another neighborhood in Jerusalem, served by city bus lines and schools… But for Palestinians and much of the world, this unassuming neighborhood is far more.
It is an illegal settlement in east Jerusalem, and in some ways, the most damaging… ‘It’s a feeling of helplessness,’ said Aziz Abu Teir, the mukhtar, or community leader, of Umm Tuba, a neighboring Palestinian village, as he stared from his balcony at the sprawling rows of apartment buildings across a ravine.
‘You can do nothing.’… ‘This is our homeland,’ said Herzl Yechezkel, one of the founding fathers of Har Homa. ‘And we have to build it up.’… These settlements today are home to over 600,000 Israelis, roughly one-third of them in east Jerusalem… The Palestinians lost more than 150 acres of land to Har Homa.
Abu Teir, a 55-year-old British-educated civil engineer, said his village’s lands were passed down from generation to generation, and ownership is difficult to document, making it impossible to stop settlement… ‘The land that used to belong to my forefathers suddenly became a settlement specifically for Jewish people.
It’s not a fair thing,’ he said. ‘When did the Israeli government build a housing development for the Arabs?’”
The Har Homa neighborhood is seen in east Jerusalem. For many Israelis, Har Homa has become another neighborhood in Jerusalem, served by city bus lines, schools and public services. But for the Palestinians, this unassuming neighborhood is far more. It is an illegal settlement in east Jerusalem, and in some ways, the most damaging. AP Photo/Dan Balilty.
A named Palestinian community leader and a named settler founder, each given the same room on the same page.
· Hickory Daily Record · Hickory · page 1
The Associated Press, Jerash Camp, Jordan
“As a boy, Palestinian Abdullah Abu Massoud fled the war over the birth of Israel in 1948 and sought refuge in the nearby Gaza Strip. As an adult, Abu Massoud was displaced again when Israeli forces captured Gaza, along with the West Bank and east Jerusalem, in 1967. He escaped to Jordan, where he has been living in a refugee camp for 50 years.
Now 77, Abu Massoud is the white-haired patriarch of a refugee family spanning five generations, including a great-great-granddaughter. The future looks bleak. ‘Fifty years have passed without a step forward,’ said Abu Massoud.
‘We don’t belong here.’… More than 700,000 Palestinians were uprooted at the time… Today, 5.3 million Palestinians and their descendants are registered with UNRWA in Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank and Gaza Strip… A 29-year-old grandson of Bassama and Abdullah, Alaa Abu Awad, has never set foot in historic Palestine… He has tacked a Palestinian flag to the wall of his shop in Jerash camp.
‘It’s the flag of my homeland,’ said Abu Awad.”
Five generations of a Palestinian refugee family, the Abu Massouds, pose for a portrait. The plight of Palestinians uprooted by Israeli-Arab wars is one of the longest-running refugee crises. As the second wave of displacement hits the half-century mark, a solution for millions of refugees and their descendants is more distant than ever. The Associated Press.
Three named Palestinians across five photographed generations, and a man of 29 who has never seen the country on the flag in his shop.
· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia
Commits himself to ‘toughest deal’ in the world
WASHINGTON — President Trump plunged into the other side of Middle East peacemaking on Wednesday as he met for the first time with the Palestinian leader, Mahmoud Abbas, and committed himself to pulling off “the toughest deal” in the world.
Hosting Abbas at the White House, Trump said he’d do “whatever is necessary” to bring together Palestinians and Israelis, who have been warring over the same small patch of land for generations. But he gave no sense of how he would achieve such a goal or what an agreement might look like.
“We want to create peace between Israel and the Palestinians,” Trump said. “We will get it done. We will be working so hard to get it done. It’s been a long time.” Turning to Abbas, the president added, “I think there’s a very, very good chance, and I think you feel the same way.”
Abbas, 82, who was on hand for the historic signing of the Oslo Accords on the White House lawn in 1993, indicated he did feel optimistic that Trump might be the president who finally builds on that initial agreement to forge a final resolution to the conflict.
Praising Trump’s “courageous leadership,” “wisdom” and “great negotiating ability,” Abbas said, “We believe that we can be partners with you to bring about a historic peace.” Abbas implored Trump to understand the Palestinian perspective.
“It’s time for Israel to end its occupation of our people and of our land,” he said. “After 50 years, we are the only remaining people in the world who still live under occupation. We are aspiring and want to achieve our freedom and our dignity and our right to self-determination.”
President Trump hosted Mahmoud Abbas Wednesday. The Palestinian leader was at the 1993 signing of the Oslo Accords.
Date corrected 2017-03-12 to 2017-05-04. The page furniture is fully legible: the folio across the top reads 'A4' at the left, 'THE BOSTON GLOBE' centred, and 'THURSDAY, MAY 4, 2017' at the right, over the section head 'The World'. The filed date 2017-03-12 is wrong by nearly two months, and the filed publication (The Philadelphia Inquirer) is contradicted too - the page is The Boston Globe. The content agrees with the printed date: Peter Baker's New York Times story reports that Trump 'plunged into the other side of Middle East peacemaking on Wednesday as he met for the first time with the Palestinian leader, Mahmoud Abbas', and the photo caption reads 'President Trump hosted Mahmoud Abbas Wednesday' - that meeting was Wednesday 3 May 2017, reported the next morning.
· estimated · Hartford Courant · Hartford
President makes a personal appeal to Israel and Palestine
JERUSALEM — President Donald Trump made a personal appeal for peace between Israel and the Palestinians, calling on both sides to put aside the “pain and disagreements of the past,” as he closed a four-day swing through the Middle East Tuesday.
But Trump departed for Europe having offered no real indication of a path forward on one of the world’s most intractable disputes. He pointedly sidestepped any mention of issues that have stymied all previous attempts at a peace deal, including the status of Jerusalem, Israeli settlement construction and the Palestinians’ demand for a sovereign nation.
Trump’s vagueness on one of the region’s central issues did little to dampen the enthusiasm surrounding his visit, particularly from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
The prime minister, who had a frosty relationship with Trump’s predecessor, heaped praise on the president throughout the two-day visit, declaring: “We understand each other.” During his quick stop in the region, Trump met with both Netanyahu and Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas.
Speaking at the Israel Museum, he declared both sides ready to move forward, though there were no tangible signs of the dormant peace process being revived. “Palestinians are ready to reach for peace,” Trump said. Turning to the prime minister, who joined him for the speech, Trump said, “Benjamin Netanyahu wants peace.”
U.S. President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu wave at the Israel museum in Jerusalem on Tuesday. Trump also met separately with Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas.
Date corrected 2018-09-11 to 2017-05-24. No masthead, folio or date line appears on the clipping. The AP story fixes the day: Trump 'made a personal appeal for peace ... as he closed a four-day swing through the Middle East Tuesday', then 'departed for Europe'; 'On Tuesday morning, Trump met with Abbas in Bethlehem'; and the photo caption reads 'Trump and ... Netanyahu wave at the Israel museum in Jerusalem on Tuesday'. That is Trump's first foreign trip - Riyadh from 20 May 2017, Israel 22-23 May, the Israel Museum speech and the Bethlehem meeting with Abbas on Tuesday 23 May 2017, and the flight on to Rome the same evening. Everything is reported in the past tense, so this is the next morning's paper, 24 May 2017. The filed date 2018-09-11 is wrong by about sixteen months; Trump made no Middle East trip in September 2018. No date is printed on the clipping; the date is fixed by what the article reports, at the precision the evidence supports, and is not guessed beyond it.
· South Florida Sun Sentinel
(JNS.org)
(JNS.org) Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Israel must maintain full military control over Judea and Samaria in the event of a final peace agreement with the Palestinians.
"The idea that we can give up territory and achieve peace is not right," Netanyahu told Army Radio, adding, "In order to assure our existence we need to have military and security control over all of the territory west of the Jordan [River]." Netanyahu's comments came as politicians within his governing coalition sought clarification on his position regarding a two-state solution, following the prime minister's statement that President Donald Trump is determined to secure a peace deal.
Whole item transcribed; it is three paragraphs. Section flag above the headline reads "In Brief" — not a dek. The paper's own "Judea and Samaria" is left as printed.
· The Patriot Ledger · Quincy · page 1
Commentary
Daoud Kuttab, a Palestinian journalist and former Ferris professor of journalism at Princeton University
“While Israelis and Palestinians have mostly failed to find common ground in opposing the 50 years of Israeli occupation, a new Palestinian-Israeli-U.S.
Jewish alliance is emerging that many are hoping will take root… A group of 300 Israelis, Palestinians and diaspora Jews from a coalition of five groups decided May 18 to join in support of a beleaguered Palestinian village in the West Bank.
Their model was the Standing Rock protest, the North Dakota encampment created in an effort to block an oil pipeline near an Indian reservation… Three times in a span of the first 12 days, Israeli troops raided the Sumud Freedom Camp and confiscated the campers’ tents, sound equipment and even a car belonging to a local Palestinian.
Sumud means steadfastness in Arabic… When Palestinians from nearby towns saw that the Sumud Freedom Camp survived, they began making daily visits. Many brought food and broke the Ramadan fast with their newly discovered comrades.”
A Palestinian journalist writing in a Massachusetts daily, not quoted in one.
· Omaha World-Herald
RAMALLAH, West Bank (AP) — Presidential adviser Jared Kushner met with Israeli and Palestinian leaders on Thursday to try to jump-start moribund peace talks. After months without progress, the Mideast envoy faced growing skepticism on the Palestinian side.
With no clear vision for peace outlined by the administration and domestic issues distracting President Donald Trump, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, expectations for the new peace push are low.
The Palestinians initially welcomed Trump’s election, but they have since grown impatient with what they say is a failure by the U.S. president to present a map for peace. It was not clear whether Kushner offered any clarity during his three-hour meeting with Abbas.
Nabil Abu Rdeneh, Abbas’ spokesman, called the meeting “positive,” without discussing details, and said the Palestinian leader had reiterated his desire for an American commitment to a Palestinian state. Kushner relayed Trump’s hope and optimism for “a better future” for Palestinians and Israelis.
Trump took office with hopes of striking what he calls the “ultimate deal” between Israelis and Palestinians. But he has since given few details of his vision for peace. Kushner, Trump’s chief Middle East adviser and his son-in-law, met Netanyahu in Tel Aviv earlier Thursday. Kushner is expected to return to the U.S. today.
A statement from Netanyahu’s office after the meeting said the talks were “substantive” but gave no details.
· The Herald · Miami
TEL ES-SAKAN, Gaza Strip — Palestinian and French archaeologists began excavating Gaza’s earliest archaeological site nearly 20 years ago, unearthing what they believe is a rare 4,500-year-old Bronze Age settlement.
But over protests that grew recently, Gaza’s Hamas rulers have systematically destroyed the work since seizing power a decade ago, allowing the flattening of this hill on the southern tip of Gaza City to make way for construction projects, and later military bases. In its newest project, Hamas-supported bulldozers are flattening the last remnants of excavation.
“There is a clear destruction of a very important archaeological site,” said Palestinian archaeology and history professor Mouin Sadeq, who led three excavations at the site along with French archaeologist Pierre de Miroschedji after its accidental discovery in 1998. “I don’t know why the destruction of the site was approved.”
Tel Es-Sakan (hill of ash) was the largest Canaanite city between Palestine and Egypt, according to Sadeq. It was named after the great amount of ash found during the excavations, which suggests the settlement was burnt either naturally or in a war.
Archaeologists found the 10-hectare (25-acre) hill to be hiding a fortified settlement built centuries before pharaonic rule in Egypt, and 1,000 years before the pyramids. But the excavations stopped in 2002 due to security concerns.
This aerial image of the excavations at Tel Es-Sakan taken in 2000 shows houses dating to 2600-2300 B.C., left, and fortifications from the late fourth millennium B.C, south of Gaza City.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles
By Leah Ollman
If only negotiations between Palestinians and Israelis could work themselves out as respectfully and inventively as Jordan Nassar has negotiated the divergent forces feeding into his work. A Palestinian American from New York who’s married to an Israeli, Nassar has said that he was “born into the conflict.” His first solo show in L.A., however, feels like an oasis of calm.
The work at Anat Ebgi gallery’s AE2 space is politically charged and impassioned, but it’s whisper-quiet. It feels delicate yet has tremendous power. Nassar bases his work on Palestinian tatreez cross-stitch embroidery, typically sewn-on panels that are joined into garments or used on domestic items.
The cotton-on-canvas panels stretched and framed here retain a modest scale, many of them just 8 inches by 10 inches. Nassar’s stitched patterns riff on traditional geometric borders, foliate and floral motifs, but his thread colors don’t necessarily correspond to those designs.
Instead, they articulate distilled landscapes of receding, silhouetted hills in shades of emerald, wheat, pomegranate and mustard. A rich, animating tension emerges between pattern and the pictorial, between the fabric’s surface and the deep view of the image sewn upon it.
The ancient cross-stitch technique reads to contemporary eyes as a kind of pixelation, even as kin to pointillism. Each stitch is an intimate module positioned on a grid, minimalist in practice but elegantly post-minimal in tactility.
If the patterns and colors of traditional Palestinian embroidery told stories of place and belonging, Nassar’s work too addresses issues of identity. As a man, he is claiming a place within a custom passed down among women. By his very practice, he helps dismantle the tired hierarchy distinguishing art from craft.
And then there is the bigger question of ethnic identity, which Nassar touches on in a lovely zine made for the show. Both are titled “Dunya,” an Arabic word for the world. Nassar shades the literal definition with emotional and metaphoric import, writing that Dunya makes him think of “the Palestine that might exist only in the imaginations of the Palestinian Diaspora.
It is the perfect, magic, dream-Palestine.” The beauty of these embroidered meditations is not just visual. Nassar imbues them with reverence, tenderness and hope.
· The Daily Inter Lake · page 1
The Associated Press, Washington
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Palestinians threatened on Saturday to suspend all communication with the United States if the Trump administration follows through with plans to close their diplomatic office in Washington… Senior Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat said the U.S. decision was “very unfortunate and unacceptable,” and accused Washington of bowing to pressure from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government “at a time when we are trying to cooperate to achieve the ultimate deal.”… PLO official Hanan Ashrawi said the U.S. was “disqualifying itself as a peace broker in the region” by refusing to extend a waiver from the law… Erekat contended the move was the result of “the pressure being exerted on this administration by the Netanyahu government.”
The Washington office of the Palestine Liberation Organization on Nov. 18. On Saturday, Palestinians threatened to suspend all communication with the United States if the Trump administration follows through with plans to close their diplomatic office in Washington. AP Photo/Alex Brandon.
One of two papers running this dispatch the same day.
· Roanoke Times · Roanoke · page 1
Talks
The Associated Press, Washington
“Senior Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat said the U.S. decision was ‘very unfortunate and unacceptable,’ and accused Washington of bowing to pressure from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government ‘at a time when we are trying to cooperate to achieve the ultimate deal.’… The United States allowed the PLO to open a mission in Washington in 1994.
That required President Bill Clinton to waive a law that said the Palestinians couldn’t have an office. In 2011, under the Obama administration, the U.S. started letting the Palestinians fly their flag over the office, an upgrade to the status of their mission that the Palestinians hailed as historic.”
The Washington office of the Palestine Liberation Organization has become a focal point in U.S.-Palestinian relations. Associated Press.
The same Associated Press copy as the Montana paper, under a headline that names the accusation rather than the threat.
· estimated · The Star Press · Muncie
Kenneth R. England, Albany
If Donald Trump truly wants “wonder boy” Jared Kushner to find a path to peace between the Palestinians and Israel then recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and moving our embassy there is a sure way to guarantee a failure.
This may play well with the Israeli lobby and the evangelical Christian fringe, but it is a sure way to incite violence in the West Bank and Gaza, as well as alienate the majority of the nations in the Middle East. This move is a cynical sop to Trump’s base and the Israeli government, which has no intention of negotiating a settlement in Palestine.
It will be paid for in blood, and it was not necessary. No path to peace in Palestine includes such a reckless and arrogant move. Once again, Trump shows his ignorance of world affairs and willingness to cater to the fringe elements of the Republican Party. Kenneth R. England Albany (Dec. 5)
· Chronicle-Tribune · page 1
Josef Federman, The Associated Press, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM — Thousands of Palestinian protesters clashed with Israeli forces in east Jerusalem and the West Bank, demonstrators in the Gaza Strip burned U.S. flags and pictures of President Donald Trump… in a show of rage Thursday over the American decision to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital… The Palestinians declared three “days of rage,” shuttering schools and businesses, and staging angry demonstrations at Damascus Gate, one of the entrances to Jerusalem’s Old City, and cities across the West Bank and Gaza.
“We are here. We believe in our rights and one day it will become Jerusalem, the capital for the Palestinian people,” declared Rania Hatem, a protester outside the Old City… “People are tired, exhausted. Personally I feel that we are doomed anyway and nothing we do makes a difference,” said Ghinwa Barakat, a 43-year-old shopper in Beirut.
“Who’s going to support the Palestinians? Syria is destroyed, Iraq is destroyed. The Gulf countries are fighting each other and competing over who will normalize relations with Israel first. So, who?”
Palestinians burn posters of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and U.S. President Donald Trump, during a protest against the U.S. decision to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, in Gaza City on Thursday. Khalil Hamra / AP.
Two named ordinary people, one in Jerusalem and one shopping in Beirut, saying opposite things about whether any of it matters.
· The Buffalo News · Buffalo · page 1
New York Times photograph
Palestinians demonstrate Thursday at the Damascus Gate outside the Old City of Jerusalem. Widespread predictions of unrest were realized in the region a day after President Trump took the high-risk move of recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital.
A photograph running alone, with no headline on the scan. The caption stands in for one.
· The Daily Item
JERUSALEM — Thousands of Palestinian protesters clashed with Israeli forces in east Jerusalem and the West Bank, demonstrators in the Gaza Strip burned U.S. flags and pictures of President Donald Trump, and a top Palestinian official said Vice President Mike Pence would not be welcome in the West Bank, in a show of rage Thursday over the American decision to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital.
Israeli forces were bracing for the possibility of even stronger violence on Friday, when tens of thousands of Palestinians attend weekly prayers at Jerusalem’s Al Aqsa Mosque, the city’s most sacred Islamic site. In Gaza, the supreme leader of the Hamas militant group called on Palestinians to launch a new uprising against Israel.
The Palestinians were blindsided by Trump’s move to depart from decades of U.S. policy on Jerusalem and upend longstanding international assurances that the fate of the city would be determined in negotiations. The Palestinians seek east Jerusalem, captured by Israel in 1967, as their capital.
Israel claims the entire city, including east Jerusalem, home to sensitive Jewish, Muslim and Christian holy sites, as its undivided capital. The opposing claims lie at the heart of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and have often spilled over into deadly violence.
The Palestinians declared three “days of rage,” shuttering schools and businesses, and staging angry demonstrations at Damascus Gate, one of the entrances to Jerusalem’s Old City, and cities across the West Bank and Gaza. “We are here.
We believe in our rights and one day it (will) become Jerusalem, the capital for the Palestinian people,” declared Rania Hatem, a protester outside the Old City. The Israeli military reported demonstrations in some 30 locations across the West Bank on Thursday, saying Palestinians had hurled stones and firebombs at troops.
A military official, speaking on condition of anonymity under briefing guidelines, said troops were instructed to use minimal force and avoid live fire to avoid escalating tensions.
Palestinians burn posters of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and U.S. President Donald Trump, during a protest in Gaza City on Thursday.
· The State Journal-Register · Springfield · page 1
Michele Chabin, Religion News Service, Bethlehem
BETHLEHEM, West Bank — Thirty years ago Bassem Giacaman, whose large extended family has lived in this town for generations, immigrated to New Zealand with his parents and siblings in search of a life far away from the turmoil of the Middle East.
They left behind a small shop and olive wood factory, one of a few dozen olive wood enterprises in and around Bethlehem… Most of these businesses are owned by Christian families that have been carving religious items such as crosses, rosaries and Nativity scenes for nearly two millennia. Today these families are struggling because tourists are staying away from Bethlehem, thinking it unsafe… “I came back to take care of the family business and because I’m a Christian,” Giacaman said in the store and factory his grandfather founded in 1925. Giacaman decided to come home after his father, Jiries, 72, said he could no longer manage the family business from afar.
“I just couldn’t let that happen,” Giacaman said. “First, because of the church. There are so few Christians left here and I felt it was important to strengthen the community. But also because my grandfather created this factory and me and my father worked so hard to keep it going.”
The number of Christians in the Holy Land has declined dramatically due to emigration. Today, Christians comprise less than 2 percent of the Palestinian population. Mahmoud Hawari, director of the Palestinian Museum in the West Bank, says olive wood carving has been a livelihood for Holy Land Christians in Bethlehem since the fourth century A.D., the Byzantine period.
“This art form goes back millennia and its traditions have been developed over the centuries,” Hawari said.
“It is part of the Palestinian national heritage and also important from an economic point of view.”… “To this day, it is a niche industry for craftsmen in Bethlehem, who create their own motifs based on the life of Jesus.” The artisans, both Christian and Muslim, are world-renowned for their intricately carved Mother and Child statues, as well as their Nativity scenes, some small enough to fit in the palm of a hand, others large enough to display in a cathedral.
They also produce rosaries, crosses and, for those into more practical items, salad spoons. Since 1971 the Hosh family has been carving olive wood items in a small factory in a residential neighborhood in Bethlehem.
The family’s company, the Bethlehem Star Olive Wood Factory, employs 14 carpenters, some of them relatives. “We export 95 percent of what we make, to holiday and art fairs in Europe, and to stores including Neiman Marcus,” said Tony Hosh, the assistant manager.
“There aren’t enough pilgrims to sustain the industry.”… “Sets like this take a year to make and cost up to $20,000,” he said, pointing to a magnificent manger scene several feet wide.
Much simpler items cost between $40 and a few hundred dollars. Walking into the courtyard, where hundreds of olive branches were piled high, Giacaman said he buys the wood from local farmers soon after the October olive harvest. “Otherwise we can get ants,” he explained.
“The branches come from pruning the trees, never by cutting them.” Stepping into the adjoining factory — really a small workshop — carpenters surrounded by sawdust chiseled delicate features into the fragrant wood. “Each piece is unique.
If you find two pieces the same I will give you the shop,” Giacaman said with a smile. Growing serious, the Palestinian Christian described his profession as “an expression of my Christian faith.” “The Bible mentions the olive tree many times, and Jesus prayed among olive trees on the Mount of Olives,” he said.
“So our work is part of our religion.” “For me, this is holy work.”
“The Blessings Gift Shop owned by the Giacaman family and located just around the corner from Manger Square employs 5 carpenters.” · RNS photo by Michele Chabin
A trade story: four named Palestinians, a workshop founded in 1925, a craft dated to the fourth century, prices from forty dollars to twenty thousand, ninety-five per cent of output exported, and a rule about where the wood comes from — pruning, never cutting. The occupation appears as a wall, a shortage of tourists and a line about Trump and Jerusalem. The last words are a man describing what he does for a living as holy work.
· Log Cabin Democrat
The Associated Press
RAMALLAH, West Bank — An Israeli military court on Monday indicted a teenage Palestinian girl who was filmed last month in the West Bank slapping Israeli troops who refused to respond. Palestinians have since hailed Ahed Tamimi, 16, as an icon in their fight against Israel. In Israel, the footage sparked debate about the soldiers’ refusal to react.
The court indicted Tamimi on several accounts including attacking soldiers as well as for previous altercations with Israeli forces. It extended her remand for eight days. She was filmed in December outside her family home, pushing, kicking and slapping the soldiers, who fended off the blows without retaliating.
Her father Bassem has said she was upset when she approached the soldiers after her 15-year-old cousin had been shot with a rubber bullet. The military confirmed rubber bullets had been used following what it said was a violent demonstration, but had no information about who was shot.
Bassem called Monday’s indictment a “political trial” saying Israel dug up old incidents as well as the one filmed in order to “justify her arrest.” Tamimi was arrested at her home in a pre-dawn raid three days after the confrontation, amid an uproar in Israel.
Tamimi has made headlines in the past, most famously in 2015 when she bit a soldier’s hand as he held her brother in a chokehold in an attempted arrest. She is from Nebi Saleh is a village of about 600 people, most of them members of Tamimi’s extended family.
For eight years, villagers along with Israeli and foreign activists have protested weekly against Israeli policies in the West Bank. In a separate case, the family of a female Palestinian lawmaker who has been jailed without charge since July said her detention has been extended for another six months.
Khalida Jarrar has been held under an Israeli policy called administrative detention, which allows Palestinians to be arrested for months at a time without any charges being filed.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles · page 1
Palestinian refugees and Israeli critics worry about ramifications of U.S. aid cutoff
“On edge over Trump’s threat. Palestinian refugees and Israeli critics worry about ramifications of U.S. aid cutoff.”
“PALESTINIANS demand better living conditions at Jabaliya camp in the Gaza Strip. More than 2 million people are registered as refugees in Gaza and the West Bank.” Mohammed Saber EPA/Shutterstock
The clipping is the photograph, its caption and the headline stack; the story below was not clipped. A Palestinian flag and a hand-lettered placard are held above the crowd.
· Rocky Mount Telegram · Rocky Mount
DAVOS, Switzerland — President Donald Trump threatened on Thursday to withhold aid money from the Palestinians until they return to peace talks with Israel as he sat down with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on the sidelines of an economic summit in Switzerland.
Trump’s decision last year to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital roiled Arab nations and led the Palestinians to refuse to meet with Vice President Mike Pence during his visit to the Mideast this week. They also declared a new U.S.-led peace push dead, saying Washington can no longer be trusted as an honest broker. Trump said that decision has consequences.
The United States, he said, gives “hundreds of millions of dollars in aid and support” to the Palestinians, and “that money is on the table and that money’s not going to them unless they sit down and negotiate peace.” The Palestinian envoy to Washington, Husam Zomlot, accused the president of backstabbing the Palestinians.
In a speech at the Washington-based Middle East Institute, Zomlot said Trump had reneged on his promise not to prejudge solutions to the conflict and chided the president for acting “triumphant” and “victorious” in Davos. “We don’t understand, triumphant and victorious, what is it? For killing the only possible solution?
For pushing us to the Armageddon?” Zomlot said.
President Donald Trump shakes hands with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Thursday during a meeting at the World Economic Forum.
· Daily Tribune News
By Catherine Lucey, Associated Press
· Daily Tribune News
RAMALLAH, West Bank — The Palestinian president railed at President Donald Trump in a fiery, two-hour-long speech on Sunday, saying “shame on you” for his treatment of the Palestinians and warning that he would have no problem rejecting what he suggested would be an unacceptable peace plan.
The speech by Mahmoud Abbas ratcheted up what has been more than a month of harsh rhetoric toward Trump since the president’s recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s capital. Relations between Washington and the Palestinians have sunk to a new low, boding poorly for a peace plan the White House has promised to present.
Speaking to the Palestinian Central Council, a decision-making body, Abbas repeated the Palestinians’ opposition to Trump’s Jerusalem recognition and censured Trump for accusing the Palestinians of refusing to negotiate.
“He (Trump) said in a tweet: ‘We won’t give money to the Palestinians because they rejected the negotiations,’” Abbas said. “Shame on you. When did we reject the talks? Where is the negotiation that we rejected?”
Trump infuriated Palestinians and Muslims around the world when he announced late last year that the U.S. would recognize Jerusalem as the capital of Israel and move its embassy there, upending decades of U.S. policy and countering an international consensus that the fate of Jerusalem should be decided in negotiations between the sides.
Abbas has said that by siding with the Israelis on a sensitive issue, the announcement had destroyed Trump’s credibility as a Mideast peace broker. “We can say no to anyone if things are related to our fate and our people, and now we have said no to Trump,” he said. “We told him the deal of the century was the slap of the century.
But we will slap back.”
· Chicago Tribune · page 29 (Section 1, per the folio)
Clock, hope running out on life in the Gaza Strip — a cauldron of despair and deprivation
BY ANN M. SIMMONS | Los Angeles Times
Deficit and desperation define life these days in the Gaza Strip. Residents make do with four hours of electricity a day. Most people don't have access to clean water because the supply system is contaminated with sewage. Breakfast for some schoolchildren is a cup of hot water flavored with a dash of salt.
"Despair isn't even the right word to describe what's going on here because things are getting worse and worse," said Omar Ghraieb, a journalist and digital media manager who lives in Gaza.
"We wake up to a world of struggles each day." For more than a decade, Palestinians living in Gaza have endured major escalations of violence and an air and sea blockade, imposed by Israel and Egypt, that has decimated the infrastructure, stifled economic growth and made living conditions so dismal that United Nations officials say a humanitarian disaster is unavoidable. [...] The Palestinian Authority has denied the severity of the situation, according to local media reports, blaming such news on a misinformation campaign by Hamas, the Islamic militant group that governs Gaza.
Israeli army Chief of Staff Gen. Gadi Eisenkot acknowledged the emergency, but Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman recently contradicted him, saying that although the economic situation was complicated and had to be tackled, there was "no humanitarian crisis."
Los Angeles Times copy running in another paper. Main photo caption: "According to the World Bank, only 10 percent of Gaza's population has access to safe drinking water. The sewage system has broken, and wastewater pollutes the aquifer under Gaza." Credit: MOHAMMED ABED/GETTY-AFP. Three further photo captions on the page: Palestinian children warming by a fire in Khan Younis refugee camp (SABER/EPA); Palestinians charging mobile phones from batteries in Gaza City (MOHAMMED ABED/GETTY-AFP); a Palestinian woman with a child after receiving UN food supplies (SAID KHATIB/GETTY-AFP). Also quoted: Matthias Schmale of UNRWA, Yousef Munayyer of the U.S. Campaign for Palestinian Rights, and Noura Erakat of George Mason University. Contact line at the foot: ann.simmons@latimes.com. As in the Concord Monitor column (slide 4), Eisenkot is deployed as the credible witness whose warning Lieberman denies.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis
Palestinian, Israeli doctors say health care a key part of achieving peace
Dr. David Schnadower, a pediatric emergency medicine physician at St. Louis Children’s Hospital, told visiting Israeli and Palestinian doctors that he had recently been treating a patient with a swastika tattoo who was discussing President Donald Trump’s proposed wall along the U.S.-Mexico border.
“And I’m a Mexican Jew,” Schnadower said, generating laughter from fellow healthcare providers in the conference room at the Washington University School of Medicine. That situation “must be so much more pronounced” in Israel and the Palestinian territories, Schnadower suggested, “so I wonder how you deal with that?” On Jan.
31, the Israeli and Palestinian doctors stopped at the hospital, community centers and religious institutions around St. Louis as part of a trip sponsored by Project Rozana, an organization that sees improving healthcare for Palestinians as a key to achieving peace.
“When you go to the hospital, you will see this mixture of people from both sides; you will not find this different treatment or different behaviors from both sides — the Palestinians and the Israelis,” said Dr. Khadra Hasan, a pediatric hematology-oncology specialist at August Victoria Hospital in Jerusalem. Dr.
Ralph Walden, deputy director of the Sheba Medical Center in Ramat Gan, added that the medical system in Israel is “an island of goodwill and equality.” “We have senior chiefs of departments who are Israeli-Arabs and they are absolutely respected,” said Walden, who was the personal physician to his father-in-law, the late Israeli President Shimon Peres.
“We have two directors of hospitals who are Arabs in Israel and most of the staff is Jewish — there is no problem about that.”
Dr. Khadra Hasan and Dr. Ralph Walden.
· Florida Jewish Journal
By Yaakov Lappin / JNS
For Israeli security personnel who guard the strategically significant Route 443, one of only two highways connecting Jerusalem to Israel’s coastal plain along the Mediterranean Sea, the difference between stopping contraband food or an armed terrorist isn’t very large.
“I tell the soldiers here, if you caught food smugglers, you also prevented a future terrorist attack. Someone who smuggles eggs into Israel will then try to smuggle people. If he sees this succeeds, he’ll smuggle in terrorists after that,” said Lt.-Col. Arik Yaakobi, commander of the IDF’s Military Police Taoz Battalion.
Route 443, a busy traffic artery, is anything but an ordinary highway. If anything would happen to Israel’s Route 1, Route 443 would be the only main connection between Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. But unlike Route 1, it runs right through Palestinian areas, in between hostile villages that overlook the traffic from nearby hills.
“There is this big tension upon which sits the fabric of life here,” Yaakobi told JNS during a jeep tour of the area. “The big majority of the Palestinian population just wants to make a living honorably. We have to be able to distinguish between them, and the one who comes to attack.
This requires a huge intelligence effort, and our ability to identify intentions.” These days, Route 443 experiences at least one attack a week, in the form of a firebombing or rock-throwing.
Lt.-Col. Arik Yaakobi, commander of the Taoz Battalion, stands at Maccabim Crossing. COURTESY
· South Florida Sun Sentinel · Fort Lauderdale, FL · page page 6 and jump to page 7 (jump lines read "See Page 7" and "Continued from page 6")
By Yaakov Lappin / JNS
The ongoing economic crisis in the Gaza Strip continues to worsen and brings it with the threat of an escalation in the security situation. Funds are drying up for basic services and infrastructure for Gaza's estimated two million residents.
And a Hamas-Palestinian Authority reconciliation process, which was supposed to free up cash supplies to alleviate the situation, has stalled. [...] "I'm prepared to take a risk and say that a big crisis will not happen. We will continue to hear about the distress, but not about a humanitarian disaster that will drag all of Gaza's residents down," explained Elad.
"Everything we've heard about recently is aimed at one thing—pressuring Israel to ease the blockade on Gaza, to open its gates to Gazan workers and to forego payments of debts so that Hamas can divert its funds for bigger goals." "We don't have to rush into this" In recent days, IDF Chief of Staff Lt.-Gen.
Gadi Eisenkot presented his own assessment of Gaza, describing it as "perhaps being the most complex sector" that the military must contend with. Unemployment stands at 47 percent, he said, while residents get four hours of electricity a day. The water quality is "very low," cautioned Eisenkot.
These factors forced Hamas to seek reconciliation with the P.A., but they have also created instability. Smaller Gazan armed terror groups have increased their rocket fire on southern Israeli regions.
Although not a single Israeli civilian or soldier has been injured near the Gaza border in the past three-and-a-half years, and southern communities are flourishing, Israel absorbed more than 20 rocket attacks in the past five weeks. "We can't accept this," said Eisenkot. "There are rebellious organizations with an interest in dragging us into a Gaza conflict.
We are on high alert. We don't have to rush into this, but if we do enter [a new conflict], the IDF has the best tools."
Section flag on both pages reads NATION & WORLD — not a dek. Photo caption on page 6: "Armed female members of the militant Palestinian group Islamic Jihad." Credit: COURTESY. Also quoted in the story: Shlomo Brom, a former Israeli deputy national security advisor at the Institute for National Security Studies; Dr. Col. (res.) Moshe Elad of the Western Galilee College; and Prof. Eyal Zisser. The statistics attributed to Eisenkot here — 47 percent unemployment, four hours of electricity a day, "very low" water quality — are the same February 2018 warning the Concord Monitor column (slide 4) cites two months later.
· San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco · page 1
Chronicle News Services
“Palestinian aid: The United Nations says about $540 million is needed for humanitarian relief in the Palestinian territories in 2018. Jamie McGoldrick, the top U.N. humanitarian coordinator, said Wednesday that 75 percent of that sum is for Gaza, where ‘a man-made tragedy is unfolding daily.’
Gaza has been under an Israeli and Egyptian blockade since the Islamic militant group Hamas took over the territory in 2007. The closure, along with Hamas’ conflicts with Israel and a bitter power struggle with the group’s bitter rival, the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank, has devastated the economy.
Half the sum is to support emergency projects by UNRWA, the main U.N. agency for Palestinian refugees, after Washington slashed its funding this year.
‘Hannibal’ directive: Israel’s government watchdog has taken aim at the military’s ‘Hannibal’ directive — a controversial tactic used when soldiers were abducted. The directive, used most recently during a 2014 war in Gaza, authorized the use of heavy fire if a soldier was abducted, even at the risk of killing the soldier.
During the 2014 war, troops used the Hannibal procedure after soldiers feared militants had captured an officer. Israel unleashed heavy shelling and air strikes on the southern town of Rafah, killing some 100 Palestinians.
In Wednesday’s report, the state comptroller said the directive suffered from a lack of clarity about ‘the value of the abducted soldier’s life.’ It also noted that it did not ‘explicitly’ mention the need to use ‘proportional’ force.”
Two items from a world-briefs column, numbered 4 and 5. The second is the Rafah bombardment the Amnesty report in this archive is about, reported here as an Israeli state comptroller’s finding about a lack of clarity.
· The Republican · Springfield, MA
By Loveday Morris and Hazem Balousha, The Washington Post
Israeli Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman yesterday rejected calls for an inquiry into the deaths of at least 15 Palestinians, saying that troops “deserve a commendation” for their response to protests at the Gaza border.
The “March of Return” to mark the anniversary of land appropriation by Israel in 1976 drew tens of thousands of Gaza residents to points along the border fence on Friday. Israel’s use of live ammunition to push them back triggered calls by the United Nations, rights groups and Gaza families for an investigation.
The Israeli military said it adhered to rules of engagement during what it characterized as an attempt by Hamas, the militant group that controls Gaza, to break through the fence into Israel and endanger its security.
The Palestinian representative to the United States, Husam Zomlot, accused Israel of “indiscriminate murder” and called opening fire on demonstrators “morally repugnant and a crime against humanity.” Lieberman told Israel’s Army Radio that only people who tried to approach the border fence had been shot.
Israel’s military says its rules of engagement are confidential but comply with international law. “Under no circumstances will a commission of inquiry be established,” Lieberman said. Israeli troops pulled out of Gaza in 2005, but the United Nations still considers it occupied territory because Israel has “effective control.”
The movement of goods and people has been severely restricted since Hamas, which Israel and the United States consider a terrorist organization, took over Gaza 11 years ago, with Israel citing security concerns.
The best-reported clipping in the batch and the clearest answer to the question of what Palestinians were allowed to say in their own words: a Gaza doctor on the wound pattern, a named 23-year-old patient, the Palestinian envoy on ‘a crime against humanity’, and the paper’s own observation that ‘All the injured people observed by The Washington Post over the course of the day appeared to have been shot in the legs.’ Co-bylined with Hazem Balousha, the only Palestinian byline in this batch. Also printed: more than 700 people suffered gunshot wounds on Friday per the Gaza Health Ministry; Al-Shifa administrative workers showed computer records listing 283 people admitted with injuries from the demonstrations.
· The Patriot Ledger · Quincy, MA · page 21
By Loveday Morris and Hazem Balousha, THE WASHINGTON POST
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip – Israeli Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman on Sunday rejected calls for an inquiry into the deaths of at least 15 Palestinians, saying that troops “deserve a commendation” for their response to protests at the Gaza border.
The “March of Return” to mark the anniversary of land appropriation by Israel in 1976 drew tens of thousands of Gaza residents to points along the border fence on Friday. Israel’s use of live ammunition to push them back triggered calls by the United Nations, rights groups and Gaza families for an investigation.
The Israeli military said it adhered to rules of engagement during what it characterized as an attempt by Hamas, the militant group that controls Gaza, to break through the fence into Israel and endanger its security.
The Palestinian representative to the United States, Husam Zomlot, accused Israel of “indiscriminate murder” and called opening fire on demonstrators “morally repugnant and a crime against humanity.” Lieberman told Israel’s Army Radio that only people who tried to approach the border fence had been shot.
Israel’s military says its rules of engagement are confidential but comply with international law. “Under no circumstances will a commission of inquiry be established,” Lieberman said. Israeli troops pulled out of Gaza in 2005, but the United Nations still considers it occupied territory because Israel has “effective control.”
The movement of goods and people has been severely restricted since Hamas, which Israel and the United States consider a terrorist organization, took over Gaza 11 years ago, with Israel citing security concerns.
Israel has fought three wars with Hamas, and tensions have been building again in recent months, as rocket fire from Gaza became more frequent following the announcement by President Donald Trump that the United States would recognize Israel as Jerusalem’s capital.
The paragraph The Republican did not run is the one worth having: ‘Ghanima said he had tried to plant a flag on the border fence and that soldiers had fired a warning shot but that he had ignored it. He said he’d been demonstrating every day since Friday, wincing as doctors raised his leg to apply extra bandages.’ A named 23-year-old Palestinian describing his own decision, in his own account, in a Quincy, Massachusetts daily. The headline is also the blunter of the two: ‘Israel won’t investigate Gaza border deaths’ names the actor where The Republican’s ‘Defense minister: No inquiry’ does not.
· Roanoke Times · Roanoke · page 1
The protest icon’s family released an interrogation video from when Ahed Tamimi was 16 years old.
Karin Laub, Associated Press, Ramallah, West Bank
“RAMALLAH, West Bank — The family of prominent Palestinian protester Ahed Tamimi on Monday released excerpts from a video in which an Israeli interrogator threatens the then-16-year-old with the arrest of her relatives if she refuses to cooperate. The interrogator also comments on her body, fair skin and ‘eyes of an angel.’
The interrogator, identified as an agent of the Israeli military intelligence branch, at times moves within inches of the teenager, who doesn’t respond and repeatedly asserts her right to remain silent.
The Israeli military said a complaint of improper conduct on the part of the investigator, filed by Tamimi’s lawyer, has been handed to the Justice Ministry and is being ‘thoroughly examined.’ Ahed’s father, Bassem, told reporters that the video is evidence of Israel’s failure to break his daughter.
He portrayed Tamimi, who has become an icon to Palestinians, as a symbol of resistance to Israel’s 51-year-old military occupation. Her silence under pressure shows that ‘we are not victims, we are fighters for the cause of freedom of our people,’ he said.
A West Bank-based rights group said a majority of minors have reported being verbally abused, intimidated or humiliated in Israeli custody… Tamimi is serving an eight-month prison term — the result of a plea deal — for slapping and kicking two Israeli soldiers outside her West Bank home in mid-December… ‘When I think of my little sister, her eyes look like your eyes,’ he tells her.
‘She is white like you. In the sun, she looks like the hamburger. And what about you? What do you look like in the sun? Red, red, red? When I see your eyes, I say, it’s a shame [haram], you are here [in detention],’ he says.”
“Palestinian Ahed Tamimi’s family released a video Monday in which two male Israeli interrogators are seen threatening the then-16-year-old and commenting on her body.” Associated Press / File photograph.
An American paper printing the transcript of what an Israeli interrogator said to a sixteen-year-old girl, and the military’s answer that the complaint is being “thoroughly examined.”
· The Day · New London
By FARES AKRAM, Associated Press
Gaza City, Gaza Strip — Raed Jadallah belonged to an exclusive club — a small band of surfers who escaped the claustrophobia of blockaded Gaza by riding the waves of the Mediterranean. Now he's immobile, a metal fixation device clamped to his left leg after an Israeli bullet fractured his femur in two places.
The 25-year-old plasterer from a seaside refugee camp said he doesn't know when he'll be able to walk again, let alone surf. “Sea and surfing are everything to me,” he said on Wednesday, a day after being discharged from the hospital, his lower body covered by a blanket as he rested on a sofa at his home.
Jadallah is among 1,297 Palestinians shot and wounded by Israeli soldiers, including snipers, during the past two weeks of mass protests on the Gaza-Israel border, according to a computerized count by the Gaza Health Ministry. An additional 1,554 Gaza residents have been treated for tear gas inhalation or injuries by rubber-coated steel pellets.
An AP look at Gaza's health system found crowded hospital rooms lacking basic supplies, detailed electronic records of gunshot victims and dozens of people still suffering from serious wounds. Some acknowledged approaching Israel's border fence during the protests and throwing stones, though they say they were otherwise unarmed.
The surge of patients has severely taxed Gaza's clinics and hospitals. In addition, 33 Palestinians have been killed during this period, including 26 in border demonstrations. The latest casualties came on Thursday, when Israel said it bombed Hamas militant targets in the Gaza Strip, killing one Palestinian and wounding another.
The Israeli military has disputed the Gaza count of wounded, saying that at most dozens were struck by Israeli fire, but it has not offered supporting evidence. In a response Thursday, the military did not refer to its previous challenge of the figures of wounded Palestinians.
It said that it “contends with terrorist organizations that are trying to turn the area between Israel and the Gaza Strip into a combat zone, above and below ground,” near Israeli communities.
The casualty figures are at the heart of an intensifying debate over the military's open-fire orders, branded as unlawful by rights groups because soldiers are permitted to use potentially lethal force against unarmed Palestinians approaching the border fence.
Palestinian surfer Raed Jadallah, left, lies on a bed Monday as his father, mother and brothers visit him at the Shifa hospital in Gaza. Jadallah is among the nearly 1,300 people that Palestinian health officials said have been shot and wounded by Israeli soldiers during mass border protests over the past two weeks.
The casualty figures are at the heart of an intensifying debate over the military's open-fire orders.
· Concord Monitor · Concord, NH (columnist lives in Exeter, N.H.) · page jump page; jump line reads "GAZA FROM B1"
Robert Azzi
Nothing. There is only suffering. "The need to let suffering speak," Theodor Adorno wrote, "is a condition of all truth," and we, who live in privilege, must learn to listen. Listen to suffering – to those speaking in many languages, including those who speak in the language of protest, resistance and, yes, sometimes violence. Listen closely.
Listen to what happened and is happening in Gaza. On March 30, on Land Day, Gazans organized "The Great Return March," a scheduled six-week exercise of nonviolent demonstrations centered in five encampments.
The protests, now in their third week, will continue until May 15, the day Israel celebrates as Independence Day and which Palestinians commemorate as the beginning of the Nakba, "Catastrophe," when more than 750,000 Palestinians were uprooted from their homes.
While some Gazans threw rocks and burned tires near the border, human rights monitors present saw no evidence that they threatened Israelis in any way that justified lethal force. These protests are not about Hamas; they are occurring in spite of them, their criminality, rocket launchings and tunnels. They are about dignity, rights and suffering.
In Gaza, since the March began, Israeli snipers have killed more than 30 and wounded more than 2,000 Palestinians, all of whom were in the Gaza Strip – no infiltrators, none in contact with Israelis, all behind miles of barbed wire and watch towers and a deadly no-go zone – a 300-meter-wide buffer strip running along the entire border that encompasses some of Gaza's richest agricultural land.
Indeed, during the protests snipers shot several Palestinian journalists – one fatally – all of whom were wearing blue vests prominently labeled "Press." [...] Eyeless in Gaza.
In February, when IDF Chief of Staff Gadi Eisenkot warned the Israeli cabinet that Gaza was on the verge of collapse and confrontation due to worsening living conditions, Lieberman responded "there's no humanitarian crisis." Today, we all have eyes on Gaza.
Opinion column, not news. Tagline at the foot reads "(Robert Azzi is a photographer and writer who lives in Exeter. He can be reached at theother.azzi@gmail.com. His columns are archived at theotherazzi.wordpress.com.)" The Eisenkot reference is used against the Israeli government rather than as a quotation of Eisenkot himself: the columnist cites Eisenkot's February 2018 warning about Gaza's collapse in order to convict Defense Minister Lieberman of denying it. No Eisenkot words are quoted directly.
· Press of Atlantic City · Pleasantville/Atlantic City, NJ
ZEV CHAFETS / Bloomberg News
In the run-up to this week's 70th anniversary of Israel's independence, Israeli Defense Forces chief of Staff General Gabi Eisenkot pronounced the country "invincible." This was a bold statement. The country faces a growing threat from Iran and its puppets in Lebanon and Gaza, and the possibility of a clash with Russia over Syria.
And yet, few Israelis have disagreed with this assessment. There is a mood of confidence here, and its origin lies in a doctrine of strategic defense that has proven itself over nearly a century of intermittent warfare.
That doctrine was first enunciated in a 1923 article titled "The Iron Wall" by Ze'ev Jabotinsky, a visionary Zionist leader and the ideological father of the Likud. The Jews of Palestine were then a small, embattled minority. Only three years had passed since the first Arab riots in Jerusalem against them.
The Jewish community's socialist leaders hoped they could appease Arab enmity by offering economic cooperation, progress and prosperity. [...] Hamas is marching again during the Independence Day weekend. It is a futile gesture. The Iron Wall is no longer simply a metaphor. It is a description of the Jewish state itself. And, as Eisenkot says, it is invincible.
Syndicated opinion column from Bloomberg News, not staff copy. Tagline: "Zev Chafets, former aide to Prime Minister Menachem Begin, is founding managing editor of the Jerusalem Report Magazine." The page also carries an editorial cartoon whose lettering reads "BUT WOULDN'T MOVING OUR EMBASSY TO JERUSALEM MAKE SOME PEOPLE ANGRY?" and "YOU GET USED TO IT.." — cartoon lettering, not a headline or dek. This and the Concord Monitor column (slide 4) run four days apart in April 2018 and cite Eisenkot to opposite ends.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles · page 1
“PALESTINIANS run as Israeli troops fire tear gas into Gaza City on Friday, the first fatality-free protest day since the Great March of Return effort began March 30.” Photographs by Mohammed Saber EPA/Shutterstock
A full-width photograph and its caption; no body text on the clipping. The caption measures the day by what did not happen.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles
Gazans’ protests have Israelis increasingly anxious as the key date of May 15 nears.
By Noga Tarnopolsky
KFAR AZA, Israel — It should have been a relaxing time as Shlomit Almog and her husband, Giora, nursed cups of coffee at their favorite cafe, the C Espresso, early on a Friday afternoon. But she can’t distance herself from the news — or the worry. “I can’t disconnect,” she said.
It’s been like this every day since March 30, when, on the Israeli-Gaza Strip border half a mile from their home in Kfar Aza, a prosperous village of about 850 inhabitants, thousands of Palestinians started protesting every Friday.
They begin after Muslims leave mosques following Friday prayers, and most of the demonstrations have turned into bloody clashes with the Israeli military. “I’m glued to TV and radio. I can’t detach,” Almog said, then mentioned to her husband that she had forgotten her purse at home. Her cellphone, however, she didn’t forget, and it pulsed with news alerts.
It was about 1 p.m., half an hour before the rallies would start. The anxiety of Israelis living by the border is escalating as May 15 approaches. That’s when Palestinians observe Nakba, or catastrophe day.
May 15, 1948, was Israel’s full day as a new country — it had declared independence a day earlier — and this year Palestinians are planning to mark the day with huge protests at the Israeli-Gaza Strip border. Hamas, the Palestinian Islamist militia that rules Gaza, projects that thousands of Gazans will storm the insubstantial fence that marks the border.
Friday’s protest was the first without fatalities since the demonstrations, together dubbed the Great March of Return, started. Forty-eight Gazans have died and thousands have been wounded in the clashes, which quickly turned violent.
Almog frets over her daughter and four grandchildren, who live close to the border in Kfar Aza, or Gaza Village, which was established by refugees from Egypt and Morocco in the early 1950s as a kibbutz, or collective settlement. Some parents in Israeli border communities don’t let their kids out of the house as of noon on Fridays.
Almog said with relief that two of her grandchildren are teens “so they understand” having their movements restricted, but the family has to keep close watch on the youngest two. Adding to fears are so-called Molotov kites, which are set on fire and released from the Gaza side.
Last month, a wheat field near the village was burned to the ground by such a kite, and on Wednesday another incinerated dozens of acres of forest adjacent to Kfar Aza. On Thursday, Muhammad Harazin, a member of the Great March of Return organizing committee, said that “the kites sent by Gazan children is what most terrifies the occupation.
The fires and the ensuing damage is draining Israeli coffers. We’ve terrified the settlers living there.”
KITES LADEN with Molotov cocktails and sent over the border by Gazan protesters have wiped out a wheat field and dozens of acres of forestland near Kfar Aza, a settlement on the Israeli side of the border.
· The Philadelphia Inquirer · Philadelphia · page 1
58 Palestinians killed
“58 PALESTINIANS KILLED. Heavy Toll in Gaza Protests.”
“An elderly Palestinian man falls after being shot by Israeli troops during a protest at the Gaza Strip’s border with Israel.” Adel Hana / AP
The clipping is the headline stack and a photograph; the story was not clipped. The number is in the kicker and the people are in the headline, which is the pattern the archive counts. The man in the picture is not named.
· Times Record News · Wichita Falls · page 1
Violence takes place as move of US Embassy to Jerusalem marked
Scores is a word that avoids a number. The dead are killed by nobody, and where they are killed is along Israeli border — not at the fence around Gaza, which is what it was. Then the line beneath: violence takes place, which is a thing that happens the way weather happens, while the embassy move is marked. The next day a St. Louis columnist wrote the same events as Nothing says ‘peace’ like dead Palestinians (CP-2018-007).
· Stuart News · Stuart
Violence takes place as move of US Embassy to Jerusalem marked
Ari Plachta and John Bacon, USA TODAY
JERUSALEM — More than 50 Palestinians were killed Monday in mass protests along the border with Gaza, while Israel celebrated the U.S. Embassy's contentious move to Jerusalem from Tel Aviv. The demonstrations have been taking place for weeks and reached a violent apex as Israel also marked 70 years since the Jewish nation was established.
Palestinians annually mark their resulting displacement on Nakba Day, or the Day of Catastrophe, on May 15. The Gaza Health Ministry said 52 Palestinians were killed and more than 1,200 wounded Monday in border clashes with the Israeli military, making it the most deadly day since 2014. Lt. Col.
Jonathan Conricus, an Israeli military spokesman, blamed Gaza's Hamas leadership, saying the Islamic militant group encouraged Palestinians to breach the border fence. He said more than 35,000 Palestinians were taking part in “violent riots” and tried to crash through the fence.
White House spokesman Raj Shah also blamed Hamas for the deaths, saying the group was “cynically provoking” the Israeli response. Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, who blasted the embassy as an “American settlement outpost,” called for three days of mourning.
The embassy move has outraged Palestinians who have long hoped to create a capital for themselves in the city's eastern sector. But Israeli and U.S. officials were determined not to let the violence diminish the embassy celebration. Jared Kushner, son-in-law and adviser to Trump, and Trump daughter Ivanka led the U.S. delegation at the ceremony.
Kushner, whose grandparents survived the Holocaust, drew a standing ovation when he mentioned Trump's announcement last week that the U.S. would withdraw from the nuclear agreement with Iran, Israel's sworn enemy. “The United States stands with Israel because we believe, we know, that it is the right thing to do,” he said.
David Friedman, the U.S. ambassador to Israel, presided over the dedication ceremony and said the embassy move keeps a “promise we made to the American people.” Nearby, more than 500 demonstrators rallying near the ceremony clashed with Israeli forces, and police made at least one arrest. Demonstrators chanted, “Jerusalem is ours!”
Palestinians in Gaza seek cover after protests near the border with Israel resulted in clashes Monday that left 52 Palestinians dead and more than 1,200 wounded.
A third printing of the same day's USA TODAY copy. Photograph credited Mohammed Saber/EPA-EFE. Contributing: Associated Press.
· St. Louis Post-Dispatch · St. Louis
An opinion headline, printed the morning after the Times Record News ran scores of Palestinians killed by nobody along a border (CP-2018-006). The quotation marks are on peace, which is the word being doubted, and the dead are named as Palestinians and left in the sentence. A paper can write it this way when it is arguing rather than reporting.
· The Fayetteville Observer · page A6
By Fares Akram The Associated Press
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Marwan Shtewi is poor, unemployed and at the age of 32 has never even left the Gaza Strip. With few prospects and little to fear, Shtewi is among the crowds of young men who put themselves on the front lines of violent protests along the border with Israel, risking their lives in a weekly showdown meant to draw attention to the dire conditions of Gaza.
While protest organizers voice slogans of defending Jerusalem and returning to the lost homes of their forefathers in Israel, it is the desperation among young men like Shtewi that has been the driving force in the demonstrations.
Recovering from a gunshot wound to his arm that sent shrapnel into his abdomen, Shtewi says his protest days are now behind him and he only dreams of finally finding a job. “I want to see peace and hope and prosperity spread in Gaza when I get out of the hospital,” he said from his hospital bed.
The Hamas-led organizers of what they called the Great March of Return initially billed the six-week protests as a call to break through the border fence and return to homes that were lost 70 years ago during the war surrounding Israel’s creation. Two-thirds of Gaza’s 2 million people are descendants of refugees who either fled or were forced from their homes.
But most protesters say they are simply driven by desperation caused by a decade-long blockade imposed by Israel and Egypt after the Islamic militants seized power from the internationally backed Palestinian Authority in 2007. Israel says the blockade is needed to prevent Hamas, which seeks Israel’s destruction, from building up its military capabilities.
Marwan Shtewi, 32, lies on the bed while his mother Fatma, stands near him at the surgery ward of Shifa hospital Wednesday in Gaza City. Shtewi was shot in his hand and abdomen by Israeli troops during a protest east of Gaza City on Monday. [ADEL HANA/THE ASSOCIATED PRESS]
· Democrat and Chronicle · Rochester
Martin Maltz, Rochester
Six weeks ago, long before the decision to move our Embassy to Jerusalem was announced, Hamas started a movement in Gaza they named “The Great March of Return.” The name alone made it clear that this was not going to be a peaceful demonstration, but a forceful invasion.
The world has ignored the clear intent of this latest attempt by Hamas to invade and destroy the State of Israel, and focused on the means that Israel has employed to deal with it.
However, if a million Mexicans, backed by a well-trained terrorist force, were trying to cross the Rio Grande to return Texas to its rightful status as a Mexican state, slaughtering as many Americans as necessary, and maybe a few more out of spite, how do you think we’d respond?
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis, MO
JTA REPORT
JERUSALEM — Six Israelis, including three soldiers, were injured as mortar shells and rockets continued to rain down on southern Israel from the Gaza Strip. At least 50 rockets and mortars had struck the area by Tuesday afternoon. The Code Red rocket warning system sounded again after at least six additional barrages had hit.
Israel’s intelligence minister, Israel Katz, said in an interview with Army Radio that tensions with Gaza will get worse over the evening. Earlier Tuesday afternoon, Israel’s military struck struck more than 35 targets belonging to the Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad terrorist organizations in Gaza.
Among the targets was a terror tunnel that stretched from Egypt to Gaza and under the Kerem Shalom border crossing for humanitarian goods into Israel, as well as weapons storage sites, naval targets and a terrorist headquarters.
Sirens sounded farther away from the Gaza border, including in Ashkelon, indicating that the terrorists were firing longer-range rockets and not just mortars. By Tuesday afternoon, residents of southern Israel were told to stay near bomb shelters. Three Israelis were injured in Sderot while running for bomb shelters. The soldiers were injured by shrapnel from mortar shells.
Also late Tuesday afternoon, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu held a security briefing on the attacks with officials including Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman; the Israeli army’s chief of staff, Lt. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot; and the head of the Israel Security Agency, Nadav Argaman.
Liberman appears only as an attendee at a security briefing; he is not quoted. Casualties are counted on one side only: six Israelis injured named by location, no Palestinian casualty figure anywhere in the item, and the word ‘terrorist’ or ‘terror’ is used five times as the paper’s own descriptor rather than in quotation.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis, MO · page 8
BY SAM SOKOL, JTA
JERUSALEM (JTA) — Of the more than 60 deaths that occurred during the recent clashes between Israel and Palestinians at the Gaza border, none was as divisive as that of Layla Ghandour. Ghandour, an 8-month-old girl, died after an uncle, himself only 12, brought her to the edge of the protest zone, where she was reported to have inhaled Israeli tear gas.
Palestinians immediately raised Ghandour as a symbol of Israeli oppression, elevating the infant to the status of martyr and blaming the Israeli army for her death. Many Israelis, meanwhile, countered in angry social media posts that it was irresponsible to allow a child into what essentially was a war zone.
Both Hamas and the Israel Defense Forces issued statements, even as reports filtered out that the child had suffered from a pre-existing heart ailment that may have contributed to her untimely death.
Prominent newspapers such as the Los Angeles and New York Times ran long features on Ghandour, probing the circumstances surrounding her death, describing how she had become a symbol and laying out the arguments of both sides.
Others, especially tabloid papers such as Great Britain’s Daily Express and The Sun, didn’t hesitate to take sides, publishing headlines such as “Drones drop lethal canisters” and describing Israeli tear gas agents as “toxic gas.” Ghandour became a pawn in a by-now-familiar game played whenever Israel and the Palestinians clash.
Flareups follow a pattern in which initial impressions — and condemnations — are replaced by a more nuanced understanding of events as more information becomes available.
Liberman is paraphrased, never quoted: ‘Israel took several days to respond, when Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman told reporters that Murtaja, who sold photos to numerous international outlets, was also a member of Hamas who was using his media business as cover to obtain drone footage of IDF positions. The Washington Post, meanwhile, said that Murtaja had recently been vetted and approved for a U.S. government grant.’ The piece is about press coverage of Gaza and quotes six people — Israeli and American media analysts, watchdog staff and foreign correspondents — but not one Palestinian. Layla Ghandour’s family is not spoken to; Yaser Murtaja’s colleagues are not spoken to. Worth holding up against the AP and Washington Post clippings in this batch, which do quote Gazans directly.
· Pittsburgh Post-Gazette · Pittsburgh, PA
By Ruth Eglash / The Washington Post
JERUSALEM — An unofficial cease-fire took hold Wednesday in the Gaza Strip and southern Israel after the worst outbreak of fighting since a 2014 war between Israel and Hamas, the militant Islamist group that rules the beleaguered Palestinian enclave.
During a 24-hour flare-up, militant factions in Gaza, including Hamas, fired more than 100 rockets and mortar shells into Israel starting Tuesday and continuing through Wednesday morning. Israeli jets pounded more than 50 military targets belonging to Hamas and Islamic Jihad in response. Israel said some of the rockets fired into its territory were Iranian-made.
Although the Iron Dome defense system downed most of the rockets, one hit a civilian home and another a kindergarten. However, by early Wednesday, spokesmen for Hamas and Islamic Jihad said a cease-fire with Israel had been brokered by Egypt. Khalil al-Hayya, a senior Hamas official, said “there was a lot of mediation in the past hours.”
He said the factions, including Islamic Jihad, would uphold the cease-fire as long as Israel did the same. Israeli leaders would not confirm an agreement was reached, although local media reported Hamas had received a message that if the rockets from Gaza stopped, Israel’s airstrikes would, too.
In a tense calm apparently holding for the most part Wednesday, some Israeli children went to school in the morning.
The passage worth keeping is not the Bennett one. In the fifth and sixth columns the Washington Post states, in its own voice: 'Israel unilaterally withdrew from Gaza in 2005. But after Hamas wrested control of the strip more than a decade ago, Israel imposed a land and sea blockade on the enclave... A growing humanitarian crisis in Gaza has pushed its residents to start protesting. In late March, thousands began weekly protests demanding both a right to return to land that is now inside Israel and a solution to the crisis facing more than 2 million residents.' And then: 'Israeli forces have killed more than 100 people in those protests, including 60 on May 14.' A U.S. paper naming the right of return as the protesters' own demand, and attributing the 2018 killings to Israeli forces without hedging, is rare in this batch. 'Occupied' does not appear; Gaza is 'the beleaguered Palestinian enclave' and 'the strip'.
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis
“Jared Kushner sharply criticized Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas.”
Charles Dunst for JTA, on an interview given to Al-Quds.
· Los Angeles Times
A new law formalizes the rights of Jewish citizens over Palestinians
By Yousef Jabareen
On Thursday, the Israeli parliament passed into law a bill that formalizes the supremacy of Jewish citizens over Palestinian citizens of Israel. As a Palestinian citizen of Israel and a member of the Knesset, I voted against it.
The law, which has the status of a constitutional Basic Law, declares that the right to exercise national self-determination in Israel is “unique to the Jewish people.” It establishes Jewish settlement as a national value and mandates that the state “will labor to encourage and promote its establishment and development.”
And it downgrades Arabic from an official language to one with “special status.” Palestinian citizens of Israel make up about 20 percent of the population. We are the indigenous people of this land, the remnant of those who were not expelled or did not flee in 1948.
2018 GROUP, and the strongest item in the batch. Headline phrase for the law: 'A new law' in the deck; the headline itself is 'Separate and unequal in Israel' - no mention of 'nation-state'. Neither 'nation-state law' nor 'Jewish nation-state' appears in the headline or the deck. WHO LOSES, IN THE HEADLINE FURNITURE: this is the ONLY item in the 2018 group whose deck names the losers - 'the rights of Jewish citizens over Palestinians'. TERM USED: 'Palestinian citizens of Israel', repeatedly, by a man who is one. ARABIC DEMOTION: yes, in the author's own voice, in the same sentence structure the NYT story uses - 'it downgrades Arabic from an official language to one with “special status.”' The piece also names the 1948 expulsion, which no other item in the 2018 group does.
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles, CA
After heavy fighting, military opts to target Hamas rather than those who launch incendiary attacks.
BY NOGA TARNOPOLSKY AND HANA SALAH
JERUSALEM — The worst of the fighting between Israel and Hamas militants in the Gaza Strip has subsided a day after the violence threatened to escalate into war. But Israeli Cabinet officials and top military officials appeared deeply divided over how to respond to continuing low-tech attacks from across the border.
The militants fired nearly 200 mortar rounds, rockets and missiles at Israeli communities Saturday as Israeli fighter jets bombed military installations throughout Gaza in the biggest eruption of violence along the border since 2014. [...] Hadashot news and other major Israeli media reported an extraordinary exchange that they said occurred late Saturday at a meeting of Israel's security Cabinet.
"Why not shoot at anyone firing aerial weapons against our communities and our troops?" the education minister, Naftali Bennett, proposed to the army chief of staff, Lt. Gen. Gadi Eizenkot. "They are terrorists in every sense," Bennett said.
Eizenkot responded, "I don't think shooting at youths and children who are those sometimes launching the kites and balloons is the right thing to do. Are you proposing we drop a bomb from a plane on a cell of kite and balloon launchers?" Bennett answered in the affirmative. "I oppose that operationally and morally," Eizenkot said. In a briefing to soldiers, Maj. Gen.
Herzl Halevi, the commander of Israel's Southern Command, said that instead of targeting individual kite launchers, Israel would target Hamas.
Photo caption: "A BOY mourns his brother, Ameer Namara, 15, who was killed Saturday in an Israeli strike in Gaza City." Credit: HAITHAM IMAD EPA/Shutterstock. The story closes "Special correspondents Tarnopolsky and Salah reported from Jerusalem and Gaza City, respectively" — one of the few in this batch with a correspondent inside Gaza. Also quoted: Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu ("We hit Hamas in a significant way and hard... Our policy is clear: Whoever hurts us, we will hit them with great strength."), Hamas police spokesman Col. Ayman Batniji, Hamas political bureau head Ismail Haniyeh, and UN special coordinator Nickolay Mladenov ("Yesterday we were on the verge of a real war... This confrontation is not wanted by anyone and no one wants it, and everyone will lose in it.").
· Staten Island Advance
Restrictions come amid rising hostility between the nations
Aron Heller / Associated Press
Israel placed new restrictions on its only cargo crossing with the Gaza Strip on Tuesday in response to continued Hamas hostilities, even after it agreed to a cease-fire ending 24 hours of intense fighting.
Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman said Israel will cease transferring gas and fuel through the Kerem Shalom crossing until Sunday but will allow food and essential medication to cross. Commercial cargo was suspended last week. Lieberman also said Israel was tightening its naval blockade to limit Palestinians from sailing beyond three nautical miles off Gaza’s coast.
Israel previously allowed sailing up to six nautical miles. Even after Hamas, Gaza’s militant rulers, agreed to a cease-fire late Saturday, incendiary kites and balloons have continued to float from Gaza into Israel setting off damaging fires to farmlands.
Israel has stepped up its strikes since then to signal its new threshold for engagement after months of largely refraining to act. Israel pounded Hamas targets on Saturday in its most massive bombardment since the 2014 war, while militants fired dozens of rockets toward Israel that halted daily life in the area.
Two Palestinian teenagers were killed in an Israeli airstrike in Gaza City, while four Israelis were wounded from a rocket that landed on a residential home in Sderot.
Israel says it has no interest is engaging in another war with Hamas, but says it will no longer tolerate the Gaza militant campaign of flying incendiary kites and balloons across the border that have ignited fires damaging Israeli farms and nature reserves.
Israel says some 2,500 acres of nature reserves and parks close to Gaza have been burnt thus far and it is reported to have delivered messages to Hamas that if the fires continue, it risks sparking a full-fledged war, like the three they have waged over the past decade.
“The Israeli army is prepared and ready for any mission we give it,” Lieberman said during a visit to the border area Tuesday. “If we are required to launch a campaign we can overcome any enemy. The army knows what to do, how to do it and when to do it. We will dictate the rules of the game and no one else.”
Palestinian fishermen at the fishing port in Gaza City, Tuesday. Israeli Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman said Israel was tightening its naval blockade to limit Palestinians from sailing beyond three nautical miles off Gaza’s coast. Adel Hana, AP
· Los Angeles Times · Los Angeles, Calif.
Netanyahu applauds passage of nationhood bill, while others call its provisions racist.
By Noga Tarnopolsky
JERUSALEM — Israel's parliament approved a contentious law early Thursday defining the country as the nation-state of the Jewish people, a move critics said undercuts the rights of the Arab minority and could inflame tensions with Palestinians.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu hailed passage of the measure as “a defining moment in the annals of Zionism and the history of the state of Israel.” But Arab lawmakers tore up copies of the bill in the Knesset chamber after the 62-55 vote, shouting “Apartheid!” “You passed an apartheid law, a racist law!” shouted Ahmad Tibi, an Arab member of parliament.
“Why are you afraid of the Arabic language?” Ayman Odeh, the leader of the Arab Joint List, said the Knesset had “passed a law of Jewish supremacy and told us that we will always be second-class citizens.”
“Today, I will have to tell my children, along with all the children of Palestinian Arab towns in the country, that the state has declared that it does not want us here,” he said.
2018 GROUP. Headline phrase for the law: 'Israeli law' in the headline; the deck calls it the 'nationhood bill'. Neither 'nation-state law' nor 'Jewish nation-state' appears in the headline or deck; the body's first sentence has 'defining the country as the nation-state of the Jewish people'. WHO LOSES, in the headline: nobody is named as losing - the headline frames it as a 'debate on status of Jews, Arabs', a symmetry the body does not support. The body names 'the Arab minority', 'Arab lawmakers', and, inside Odeh's quote, 'Palestinian Arab towns in the country'. ARABIC DEMOTION: present but only inside Tibi's shouted question, 'Why are you afraid of the Arabic language?' - the article as transcribed does not explain the official-to-special downgrade in its own voice in the passages recovered here.
· The Plain Dealer
Controversial legislation raises concerns about minority rights
By Ilan Ben Zion, ASSOCIATED PRESS
JERUSALEM — Israel's parliament on Thursday approved a controversial piece of legislation that defines the country as the nation-state of the Jewish people, but which critics warn will sideline minorities.
The legislation, which passed 62-55 with two abstentions, makes Hebrew the country's national language and defines the establishment of Jewish communities as being in the national interest.
2018 GROUP. Headline phrase for the law: 'Israel defined as Jewish nation' - the only headline in the batch to carry both 'Jewish' and 'nation', though not as the compound 'Jewish nation-state'. The exact phrase 'nation-state law' does not appear in the headline or deck; the body's first sentence has 'defines the country as the nation-state of the Jewish people'. WHO LOSES, in the headline furniture: not named - the deck says only 'raises concerns about minority rights', which is the vaguest formulation in the 2018 group. ARABIC DEMOTION: NOT mentioned in the passages recovered. The story says the law 'makes Hebrew the country's national language' and stops there - it reports the promotion of Hebrew without reporting the demotion of Arabic. That omission is the single most useful finding in this record. Photo caption names 'Israeli Arab lawmaker Ahmed Tibi' (spelled Ahmed here, Ahmad in the Los Angeles Times). PHOTO CAPTION (verbatim): “Israeli Arab lawmaker Ahmed Tibi (center) tore up a copy of the legislation after it passed in the Knesset on Thursday.”
· St. Louis Jewish Light
It is highly regrettable that the the Israeli Parliament approved a controversial Nation-State Law, which enshrines in the nation's Basic Law its already-existing Jewish and Zionistic features.
2018 GROUP. Headline phrase for the law: 'Israel's Nation-State Law' - the only headline in the batch that names the law outright, capitalised, and passes judgment on it ('Unnecessary and Provocative'). 'Jewish nation-state' does not appear in the headline. WHO LOSES: the headline names no one. ARABIC DEMOTION: the opening paragraph does not mention it; whether the body does could not be established at this scan quality and is flagged rather than asserted. Note the odd coinage 'Zionistic features', set as printed.
· St. Louis Jewish Light
We have already criticized many aspects of Israel's controversial “nation-state law,” which at its best is unnecessary and superfluous. But a closer reading reveals several clauses that have the effect of downgrading the status of Arabs and other non-Jews in general, and the Israel-loyal Druze community in particular.
The nation-state law, which passed narrowly in the Knesset last month, states that Hebrew is the “official language of the State of Israel.” Under previous Israeli law, both Hebrew and Arabic were listed as “official” languages; in the new law, Arabic has been downgraded to the status of a “special language.”
Even if the intent of the bill's sponsors was not discriminatory, it has the effect of making the Arab citizens of Israel feel like second-class citizens. This aspect of the new law is especially insulting to the Druze and Bedouin communities who have been loyal to Israel from its inception.
2018 GROUP. Headline phrase for the law: the headline itself does not name the law at all - it is 'Don't Unfriend the Druze'. In the body the paper calls it Israel's controversial "nation-state law" (its own quotation marks) and then 'The nation-state law'. The phrase 'Jewish nation-state' does NOT appear; 'nation-state law' does, twice in the first two paragraphs. WHO LOSES: 'Arabs and other non-Jews in general, and the Israel-loyal Druze community in particular'; and 'the Arab citizens of Israel feel like second-class citizens'. The term used for Palestinian citizens of Israel is 'Arabs' / 'Arab citizens of Israel' - never 'Palestinian'. ARABIC DEMOTION: mentioned in full and in specifics - that previous law listed both Hebrew and Arabic as 'official' languages and that in the new law 'Arabic has been downgraded to the status of a "special language."' This is the fullest account of the language clause in the batch. The editorial's sympathy is organised around the Druze and Bedouin as loyal communities; Arab citizens generally are the secondary category.
· St. Louis Jewish Light
BY IRL SOLOMON
2018 GROUP. Headline phrase for the law: the headline does not mention the law at all, and names no one who loses anything. ARABIC DEMOTION: yes, and it is the only item in the batch that reports the law's own saving clause. The recoverable passage states that one clause of the law downgrades the Arabic language from official to 'special' standing, but also stipulates that this does not harm the status given to the Arabic language before the law came into effect - the writer calling the second half of that cryptic. Because a continuous verbatim run could not be established, that reading is recorded here as a description, NOT as a transcription, and should be re-scanned before any of it is quoted. Elsewhere the piece refers to 'the Palestinians' and, in scare quotes, to Palestinian 'peace partners'.
· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha · page 1
Sara Pahl, Omaha
The July 21 World-Herald carried a three-paragraph story headlined 'Israel, Hamas trade fatal fire.' Yet I have seen almost no World-Herald coverage of the underlying Palestinians' 'March of Return,' which has been occurring since March 30. Nor have I seen coverage of the brutal siege of Gaza, now 11 years old, by Israel, which the March of Return strives to break.
Why is The World-Herald's coverage of a huge humanitarian story so limited? Why do we see nothing here of the heart-breaking conditions in which Palestinian families are forced to live? Is there a taboo operating here?
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis, MO
Israel should not have acted with restraint in the face of hundreds of kites and balloons carrying incendiary materials launched from Gaza, Education Minister Naftali Bennett said Monday.
Bennett, the leader of the right-wing Jewish Home party, said Israel’s reluctance to go after those launching the kites, many of whom are children, allowed the problem to grow unacceptably large.
“If we had struck the first kite launchers when there were still one or two of them, it would not have reached thousands,” he said in an interview with the public broadcaster Kan translated by The Jerusalem Post. “They are terrorists in the full meaning of the word and we must eliminate them.”
Hundreds of acres of farmland and forests have been burned in the western Negev over the past few months. “If we follow the formula of ‘quiet in return for quiet’ we will end up with a stronger Hamas, and we will have a second Hezbollah in Gaza,” Bennett said. “We have no interest in hurting the residents of Gaza. But we have a clear goal.
Just like we had the strategic threat of tunnels and ignored it for years, until Operation Protective Edge, we have to do the same with a militarized Gaza. It is inconceivable that Hamas will fire on us when they wish and we will remain silent.” Hamas has paused its rocket fire in recent days and said it would cease targeting Israel if the Israelis reciprocate “calm for calm.”
However, Energy and Water Minister Yuval Steinitz told Kan that Israel had “not signed a cease-fire agreement.” “Ousting Hamas is an option we are closer to now than any time in the past,” Steinitz said.
Also Monday, Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman claimed that all of the Palestinians killed in Gaza since the end of March are members of Hamas, saying that “since the start of the March of Return events, Hamas has sustained 168 deaths, 4,348 injured and dozens of terror facilities destroyed,” The Times of Israel reported.
The Israel Defense Forces has said that while it believes the majority of those who died were members of Hamas, its troops have also accidentally killed civilians. A pregnant woman and a toddler were reported to have been killed last week during Israeli strikes against a Hamas target next to their home.
The single most important clipping in the batch for Maria’s Liberman question: an American Jewish community paper printing Liberman’s claim that every one of the Palestinians killed since March was Hamas, with his own casualty arithmetic, and then printing the Israeli army’s own partial retraction of it in the next paragraph, ending on a pregnant woman and a toddler killed ‘last week’ — both unnamed. Nobody in Gaza is quoted; Hamas’s position reaches the reader through the phrase ‘calm for calm’ only.
· Hickory Daily Record · Hickory · page 2A
The Associated Press
Palestinian brides prepare prior to a mass wedding event in the West Bank city of Ramallah, Saturday. 252 Palestinian couples participated in the ceremony.
A full-width photograph of brides waiting, and a caption that counts them: 252 couples in one ceremony in Ramallah. Mass weddings are held because individual ones are unaffordable, though the caption does not say so and the page carries no story beneath it.
· Lexington Herald-Leader · Lexington, Ky.
BY H.D. URIEL SMITH
2018 GROUP. Headline phrase for the law: 'New Israeli law' only - the headline names neither 'nation-state' nor 'Jewish', and names no one who loses anything. The phrase 'Jewish nation-state law' DOES appear, in the photo caption. ARABIC DEMOTION: yes, and in the caption rather than buried - 'which downgrades the standing of Arabic from an official to a “special” language.' PALESTINIANS NAMED AS AFFECTED: the caption's term is 'Israeli Arabs'; in the body the author's term is 'the Palestinian Arabs', in the sentence (read at 6x, not transcribed into the excerpt because its surrounding paragraph could not be read continuously) that the law 'has placed the Palestinian Arabs under an apartheid system.' That is the only use of 'apartheid' by a named individual writer in the batch, and it is a Lexington rabbi writing it. Worth a re-scan specifically to recover that paragraph verbatim. PHOTO CAPTION (verbatim): “Israeli Arabs and their supporters protest in Tel Aviv on Aug. 11 against Israel's Jewish nation-state law, which downgrades the standing of Arabic from an official to a “special” language.”
· The Boston Globe
By Isabel Kershner, NEW YORK TIMES
2018 GROUP by date label, but by content this belongs to the Avnery obituary, not to the nation-state law. New York Times wire copy. Recoverable readings, recorded as description and NOT as transcription: the obituary quotes Avnery describing the present Israeli government as clearly semi-fascist, and closes with Ayman Odeh's tribute. The Odeh quote in quotes[] was read at 8x across a column break and should be re-verified before publication.
· The Beaumont Enterprise · Beaumont · page B4
Associated Press
[FIFA] has banned the head of Palestinian soccer from attending matches for a year for inciting hatred and violence toward Lionel Messi as part of a campaign to stop Argentina's national team playing in Israel.
The FIFA disciplinary case against Palestinian soccer federation head Jibril Rajoub centered on statements he made to the media before Argentina abruptly abandoned the trip to Jerusalem for a game against Israel in June.
Rajoub “incited hatred and violence” by calling on “football fans to target the Argentinian Football Association and burn jerseys and pictures of Lionel Messi,” soccer's governing body said.
Justifying canceling the game, Argentina Foreign Minister Jorge Faurie said the players felt “totally attacked, violated” after images emerged of the team's white and sky-blue striped jerseys stained with red paint that resembled blood following Rajoub's comments. FIFA imposed the minimum ban allowed in its disciplinary code for inciting hatred or violence.
It prevents Rajoub from attending matches or engaging with the media at or near stadiums on matchdays for a year from Friday. Rajoub, who is also head of the Palestinian Olympic Committee, was fined 20,000 Swiss francs ($20,300). The Palestinian Football Association said FIFA “rushed to condemn” Rajoub based on “non-neutral media reports.”
He was filmed in June, saying in Arabic “we will target Messi and we will ask everyone to burn his t-shirt, his picture and to abandon him.” Rajoub was not granted a hearing and his testimony was not considered by the disciplinary committee, the PFA said.
The ban will apply for the 2019 Asian Cup in United Arab Emirates, which kicks off in January, and likely include the start of the 2022 World Cup qualifying program. But Rajoub is able to continue running the federation and attend FIFA meetings. He has been a constant thorn in the side of soccer's governing body as he tries to get sanctions imposed on Israel.
At the annual FIFA Congress, Rajoub regularly addresses soccer nations to demand Israel be punished for restricting movement of Palestinian players, and for forming teams in West Bank settlements.
Israel has rejected the Palestinian campaign as an attempt to politicize sports and has cited security concerns as the reason behind the occasional curbs on Palestinian players, particularly in the Hamas-ruled Gaza Strip. Rajoub repeatedly used “threats and incitement” to advance a political agenda, said Gilad Erdan, Israel's minister for strategic affairs and public security.
“International sports should be about bringing people together, not driving them apart,” Erdan said. “I call on the International Olympic Committee to suspend Rajoub as well.”
Israel's plan to stage the Argentina game in Jerusalem also incensed Rajoub because the stadium that was to host the match is situated in a neighborhood built on the site of a former Palestinian village destroyed during the war surrounding Israel's creation in 1948. Palestinians claim the eastern sector of Jerusalem as their capital.
Israel considers the entire city to be its capital after capturing east Jerusalem from Jordan in the 1967 Arab-Israeli War.
Jibril Rajoub, president of the Palestinian Football Association speaks during the 65th FIFA Congress held at the Hallenstadion in Zurich, Switzerland. FIFA has banned the head of the Palestinian Football Association from attending soccer games for a year for inciting hatred and violence toward Lionel Messi.
Printed under a standing SOCCER label. The opening words of the first paragraph, naming FIFA, are cut off at the top of the column in the scan. Photograph credited Patrick B. Kraemer / Associated Press.
· Sarasota Herald-Tribune · Sarasota · page 1
Old stone buildings and trendy cafes in this historic town
Tali Arbel, The Associated Press, Jaffa
JAFFA, Israel — Just south of Tel Aviv’s glass towers and concrete houses are the white stone buildings of Jaffa, the ancient port town.
Jaffa has existed for thousands of years, but today it is one unified city with Tel Aviv, which was founded in 1909. Both Jews and Arabs live in Jaffa, and that’s reflected in the flavors of the neighborhood. Visitors will find a luxury hotel, the Setai, built out of a Crusader fortress that was later a prison and police station.
Trendy cafes, galleries, bars and boutiques line narrow streets, intersecting with Jaffa’s well-known Arab hummus spots and bakeries, along with mosques, churches and synagogues. In and around Jaffa’s famous flea market, Shuk Hapishpeshim, are streets dotted with cafes… But don’t forget hummus.
In Jaffa, you can’t eat enough hummus, the chickpea puree that’s a bedrock meal in Israel. There’s Ali Caravan’s famous spot on HaDolphin Street, worth waiting on line for.
Another crowded hummus disher is Ha’Asli on Yefet Street, cacophonous with families, workers and tourists, all seeking the platters of hummus, labne, kebab and salads delivered to tables minutes after ordering… Those interested in learning how to cook Arab food can also take a class with a local.
Myassar Seri has for years been hosting tutorials in her small kitchen. She can put together a multi-course meal for your group to cook, or you can suggest dishes you’d like to try.
Among the dishes we made were maqluba, a mound of rice or bulgur and vegetables inverted onto a plate; meatballs cooked in a sauce of tahini and yogurt; the parsley-and-bulgur salad, tabbouleh; and the Arabic dessert knafe. Her version had thin shreds of pastry and nuts cooked in butter, sugar and lemon.
Seri also introduced us to what she called the “Arabic Parmesan”: yogurt that had been dried in the sun to a rock-hard lump. She grated the block into a powder whose sharp, savory tang did indeed recall Parmesan cheese and added it to a salad of fried eggplant and thin-chopped celery.
Prices for her lessons vary per person according to group size.… One of Jaffa’s most popular spots for tourists is the old port.
Vessels have set sail here since ancient times; it’s even mentioned in the Biblical story of Jonah, referred to as “Joppa,” where Jonah embarked on the journey that led to his fateful encounter with a big fish…
If you go. Myasser Seri: Cooking lessons vary by group size; facebook.com/myassar.seri
“People enjoy the day on Jaffa’s promenade overlooking Tel Aviv’s skyline and the Mediterranean sea in Jaffa, Israel…” and “An Israeli shopkeeper works folding a carpet in his store at the flea market in Jaffa, Israel.” · AP Photos / Oded Balilty
A travel page about Jaffa in which the word Palestinian never appears. The people are Arabs, the food is Arab food, the dessert is the Arabic dessert, the dried yogurt is Arabic Parmesan, and the shopkeeper in the photograph is an Israeli. The third maqluba in this archive, and the woman teaching it is named — Myassar Seri in the story, Myasser Seri in the box at the end — with her Facebook page printed for readers in Florida.
· Hartford Courant · Hartford
Cites Leaders’ Cold Shoulder To Israel
WASHINGTON — The Trump administration ordered the closure of the Palestinian diplomatic mission in Washington on Monday and threatened sanctions against the International Criminal Court if it pursues investigations against the U.S., Israel, or other allies. The moves are likely to harden Palestinian resistance to the U.S. role as a peace broker.
The administration cited the refusal of Palestinian leaders to enter into peace talks with Israel as the reason for closing the Palestinian Liberation Organization office, although the U.S. has yet to present its plan to resolve the Israel-Palestinian conflict. The Palestinians accused the administration of dismantling decades of U.S. engagement with them.
Shortly after the State Department announcement, President Donald Trump’s national security adviser, John Bolton, launched a broadside against The Hague-based International Criminal Court. Bolton declared that the ICC “is already dead” to the U.S.
· San Francisco Chronicle · Fall River, MA
Gaza border: The Israeli military said Thursday it was bolstering its forces along the Gaza border ahead of another expected explosive Hamas-orchestrated protest. Israel's military chief, Lt. Gen.
Gadi Eisenkot, ordered the fortifications to "thwart terror activity and prevent infiltrations into Israel" before Friday's near-weekly border protest that has routinely turned violent.
Gaza's Hamas rulers have staged the demonstrations since March to push for an end to the crippling Israeli-Egyptian blockade imposed after the Islamic militant group seized control of the coastal strip in 2007. Overall, Israeli troops have killed 145 Palestinians since March, including more than 30 children. A Gaza sniper killed an Israeli soldier in August.
Whole item transcribed; it is six sentences long. This is the most compressed juxtaposition in the batch: Eisenkot's fortification order in his own quoted words, then 145 Palestinians dead and 30 children, then one Israeli soldier, in a brief a reader would finish in twenty seconds. No byline or wire credit is printed on the item.
· The News Tribune · Tacoma
JERUSALEM — Israel announced new restrictions on Gaza Saturday, weeks after the territory’s Hamas rulers stepped up protests along the enclave’s land and sea borders with Israel.
Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman has ordered the permissible zone for Gaza fishermen to be scaled down from nine to six nautical miles and threatened “additional steps if the violent incidents continue,” according to a statement by COGAT, the Israeli defense body that coordinates civil affairs for the Palestinian territories.
Other measures could include more restrictions at Kerem Shalom, Gaza’s prime commercial crossing point and the only one with Israel.
Lieberman cited Friday’s “riots” at the fence dividing Gaza and Israel as contributing to his decision, in addition to the midweek beach protests in which fishing boats and protesters gather at the northwest end of the Gaza Strip where its sea and land barriers meet with Israel.
Hamas seized Gaza forcibly from the Palestinian Authority in 2007 after winning legislative elections a year earlier. The Islamic militant group has since March initiated protests on a weekly basis, demanding an end to an Israeli-Egyptian blockade that has made it increasingly difficult for the group to govern.
Hamas accuses Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, who governs parts of the West Bank, of thwarting regional efforts to reach a Gaza cease-fire that could ease the closure. Hamas has in response escalated and intensified the protests recently, adding locations and leading night gatherings near the fence where activists use sound bombs and laser lights to distract soldiers.
On Friday, three Palestinians, among them a 13-year-old boy, were killed by Israeli troops during protests at five locations along the frontier. Israel said the demonstrators threw grenades at the soldiers, adding that they also tore at parts of the fence with bolt cutters.
At least 148 Palestinians participating in or present at the marches were killed by Israeli fire since the protests began in March, including 33 under age 18. A Gaza sniper shot dead an Israeli soldier in August.
Relatives of 12-year-old Palestinian boy Fares Sersawi, who was killed by Israeli troops on Friday’s protest at the Gaza Strip’s border with Israel, at his funeral Saturday in Gaza City. Israel has put more restrictions on the people in Gaza after the protest.
· The News Tribune · Tacoma
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — At least three Palestinians were killed and scores of others wounded on Friday in clashes between Palestinian protesters and Israeli soldiers in the eastern Gaza Strip, close to the border with Israel.
Gaza Health Ministry spokesman Ashraf al-Qedra told reporters that three Palestinians were killed by Israeli gunfire in eastern Gaza City near the border with Israel. Al-Qedra identified one of the victims as a 12-year-old boy. He said 376 other people — including two paramedics and two journalists — were injured in the clashes, with 192 hospitalized.
Since March 30, Palestinians have been staging near-weekly protests along the Gaza border against Israel’s nearly 12-year blockade of the enclave. At least 198 Palestinians have been killed during the protests and clashes with the army, according to the Gaza Health Ministry.
· The Free Lance-Star · Fredericksburg, VA
BY FARES AKRAM / ASSOCIATED PRESS
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip—Israeli aircraft struck several militant sites across the Gaza Strip early Saturday shortly after militants fired rockets into southern Israel, the Israeli military said. Israel's chief of staff Lt. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot conducted situational assessment while the airstrikes and barrages of rockets continued, the army added without elaborating.
The cross-border violence came hours after Israeli forces shot and killed four Palestinians protesting along the perimeter fence dividing the Hamas-ruled Gaza and Israel.
In a rare statement implicitly claiming responsibility for the rocket fire, the smaller Islamic Jihad group said it has always exercised restraint, but it "can no longer stand idle before the continued killing of innocents and bloodshed by the Israeli occupation." There was no word on injuries as a result of the rockets and airstrikes.
The bloodshed and exchange of missiles complicated the mission of Egyptian mediators, who intensified their shuttle diplomacy to achieve calm and prevent a full-blown conflict between the militant Hamas group and Israel. The Israeli army has confirmed at least 12 launchings, adding its Iron Dome defense system intercepted several missiles.
On Friday, thousands of Palestinians gathered at five locations along the boundary, burning tires and throwing rocks, grenades and firebombs at Israeli troops who responded with tear gas and occasional live fire. The Israeli army said some suspects briefly crossed the fence.
In a separate incident, the military said its aircrafts struck three Hamas military posts in northern Gaza Strip. Three of the dead were reported in Khan Younis, in southern Gaza, according to the ministry. Witnesses said that dozens of protesters approached the fence there. In northern Gaza, a 27-year-old man died after being shot in the head, the ministry said.
It added that 170 other protesters sustained various injuries.
Maria's note on this row is "also this photo is amazing". The photograph is a shirtless young man mid-throw, the Palestinian flag raised over burning tyres; caption: "A protester hurls stones Friday while holding the Palestinian flag near the Gaza Strip/Israeli border." Credit: ADEL HANA / ASSOCIATED PRESS. It is the only image in this batch in which a Palestinian is the subject rather than the backdrop, and the only one where the flag is legible. Worth noting that the AP photographer and the AP reporter (Fares Akram) are both working from inside Gaza. This is the same AP story as s010_1 (Chicago Tribune), and the two cuts differ: this version carries Akram's byline, says "implicitly claiming responsibility", counts "at least 12 launchings", puts the protesters at "five locations", and includes "grenades" among what was thrown; the Tribune version drops the byline, drops "implicitly", drops the launch count and the five locations, and omits "grenades". That both run Eisenkot's single "situational assessment" sentence unchanged is the point: the one line about him survives every cut.
· The Courier of Montgomery County · Conroe, TX
By Fares Akram / ASSOCIATED PRESS
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip – Israeli aircraft struck several militant sites across the Gaza Strip early Saturday shortly after militants fired rockets into southern Israel, the Israeli military said. Israel's chief of staff Lt. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot conducted situational assessment while the airstrikes and barrages of rockets continued, the army added without elaborating.
The cross-border violence came hours after Israeli forces shot and killed four Palestinians protesting along the perimeter fence dividing the Hamas-ruled Gaza and Israel.
In a rare statement implicitly claiming responsibility for the rocket fire, the smaller Islamic Jihad group said it has always exercised restraint, but it "can no longer stand idle before the continued killing of innocents and bloodshed by the Israeli occupation." There was no word on injuries as a result of the rockets and airstrikes.
The bloodshed and exchange of missiles complicated the mission of Egyptian mediators, who intensified their shuttle diplomacy to achieve calm and prevent a full-blown conflict between the militant Hamas group and Israel. The Israeli army has confirmed at least 12 launchings, adding its Iron Dome defense system intercepted several missiles.
On Friday, thousands of Palestinians gathered at five locations along the boundary, burning tires and throwing rocks, grenades and firebombs at Israeli troops who responded with tear gas and occasional live fire. The Israeli army said some suspects briefly crossed the fence.
In a separate incident, the military said its aircrafts struck three Hamas military posts in northern Gaza Strip. Three of the dead were reported in Khan Younis, in southern Gaza, according to the ministry. Witnesses said that dozens of protesters approached the fence there. In northern Gaza, a 27-year-old man died after being shot in the head, the ministry said.
It added that 170 other protesters sustained various injuries. Hamas has scaled down the protests over the past two weeks as Egypt stepped up its efforts to secure calm.
The third printing of the same AP story in this batch, identical in wording to The Free-Lance Star version down to "implicitly". The difference is the picture. Where The Free-Lance Star ran Adel Hana's photograph of a Palestinian protester holding the flag, this paper ran an AFP frame of an explosion with no human being in it: "A picture shows a fireball exploding during Israeli air strikes in Gaza City." Credit: Mahmud Hams / AFP/Getty Images. Same words, same day, and the reader of one paper sees a man and the reader of the other sees a flash in the dark.
· The Journal Star · Peoria, IL
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Israeli aircraft struck several militant sites across the Gaza Strip early Saturday shortly after militants fired rockets into southern Israel, the Israeli military said. Israel's chief of staff Lt. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot conducted situational assessment while the airstrikes and barrages of rockets continued, the army added without elaborating.
The cross-border violence came hours after Israeli forces shot and killed four Palestinians protesting along the perimeter fence dividing the Hamas-ruled Gaza and Israel.
In a rare statement implicitly claiming responsibility for the rocket fire, the smaller Islamic Jihad group said it has always exercised restraint, but it "can no longer stand idle before the continued killing of innocents and bloodshed by the Israeli occupation." There was no word on injuries as a result of the rockets and airstrikes.
The fourth printing of the same AP story. This paper runs it unbylined and cuts it to five paragraphs, stopping before the casualty detail: the four dead are counted but the 27-year-old shot in the head, the three dead in Khan Younis and the 170 injured are all gone. Eisenkot's "situational assessment" sentence survives again. Photo caption: "Protesters chant slogans Friday while waving their national flags as others burn tires near the fence of the Gaza Strip border with Israel during a protest east of Gaza City." No photo credit is visible in the scan.
· The Register-Mail · Galesburg, IL
Photograph by Adel Hana of the Associated Press — the same photographer whose protester-with-flag frame The Free-Lance Star ran, here a different frame of masked protesters running past burning tyres. The entire story has been compressed into the caption, which reads: "Protesters run as tires burn Friday near the Gaza Strip border with Israel. Israeli aircraft struck several militant sites across the Gaza Strip early Saturday shortly after militants fired rockets into southern Israel, the Israeli military said. Israel's chief of staff Lt. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot conducted situational assessment while the airstrikes and barrages of rockets continued, the army added without elaborating. [ADEL HANA/THE ASSOCIATED PRESS]" This is the most compressed form the story takes anywhere in the batch: two sentences, and one of them is the Eisenkot sentence. The four Palestinians killed, which is what made the day news, are not mentioned at all.
· Arizona Daily Star · Tucson, AZ
By Fares Akram / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Israeli aircraft struck several militant sites across the Gaza Strip early Saturday shortly after militants fired rockets into southern Israel, the Israeli military said. Israel's chief of staff Lt. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot conducted a situational assessment while the airstrikes and barrages of rockets continued, the army added without elaborating.
The cross-border violence came hours after Israeli forces shot and killed four Palestinians protesting along the perimeter fence dividing the Hamas-ruled Gaza and Israel.
In a rare statement implicitly claiming responsibility for the rocket fire, the smaller Islamic Jihad group said it has always exercised restraint, but it "can no longer stand idle before the continued killing of innocents and bloodshed by the Israeli occupation." There was no word on injuries as a result of the rockets and airstrikes.
The bloodshed and exchange of missiles complicated the mission of Egyptian mediators, who intensified their shuttle diplomacy to achieve calm and prevent a full-blown conflict between the militant Hamas group and Israel. The Israeli army has confirmed at least 12 launchings, adding that its Iron Dome defense system intercepted several missiles.
On Friday, thousands of Palestinians gathered at five locations along the boundary, burning tires and throwing rocks, grenades and firebombs at Israeli troops who responded with tear gas and occasional live fire. The Israeli army said some suspects briefly crossed the fence.
In a separate incident, the military said its aircrafts struck three Hamas military posts in northern Gaza Strip. Three of the dead were reported in Khan Younis, in southern Gaza, according to the ministry. Witnesses said that dozens of protesters approached the fence there. In northern Gaza, a 27-year-old man died after being shot in the head, the ministry said.
It added that 170 other protesters sustained various injuries. Hamas has scaled down the protests over the past two weeks as Egypt stepped up its efforts to secure calm. On Wednesday, Egyptian intelligence officials met representatives of Palestinian factions in Gaza.
Folio reads "Saturday, October 27, 2018 / Arizona Daily Star" — masthead and date both agree with Maria's label, and this fixes the date for the whole Oct 27 cluster. This is the fifth printing of the same AP story in the batch and by far the most honest headline of the five: "Thousands of Palestinians gather as Israeli killings incite border violence" names the Israeli killings as the cause, where the Chicago Tribune ran "Airstrikes follow protests in Gaza", The Journal Star ran "Rockets hit Israel after deadly Gaza protest", The Free-Lance Star ran "After Gaza protests, rockets strike Israel" and The Courier ran "After deadly Gaza protests, rockets hit southern Israel". Four of the five put the rockets in the headline; one puts the killings. Photo caption: "Protesters use sling shots to hurl stones at Israeli troops while others burn tires near the fence of the Gaza Strip border with Israel during a protest east of Gaza City Friday." Credit: ADEL HANA / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS.
· The Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, NM
Coalition partners press for new elections
By Isabel Kershner, New York Times
JERUSALEM — Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel has so far survived corruption investigations and the threat of bribery charges without much damage to his standing. But his government teetered on the edge of collapse Friday as Netanyahu’s coalition partners pressed for new elections over his handling of Gaza.
The call for new elections intensified after Netanyahu rebuffed on Friday a request by the hawkish leader of the Jewish Home party, Naftali Bennett, for the defense minister’s post, which opened this week with the resignation of the hard-liner Avigdor Lieberman. Bennett’s party had threatened to leave if he was not given the job.
Netanyahu has been working feverishly to shore up his governing coalition in the days since Lieberman quit his post over the government’s acceptance of what he viewed as a humiliating cease-fire to end a fierce bout of fighting in Gaza. Lieberman pulled his party out of the government, leaving Netanyahu’s coalition with a precarious parliamentary majority of one.
Netanyahu is also having to grapple with popular fury. Protesters from Sderot, a southern stronghold of his conservative Likud party, and other border communities plagued by rocket fire from Gaza, have been burning tires and blocking main roads, seething over a truce they said resolved nothing and left them as vulnerable as before.
Netanyahu was still holding out Friday, trying to persuade his remaining coalition partners not to repeat what he called “the historic mistake of ’92,” when right-wing parties toppled a right-wing government and brought the left back to power.
But with such a slim majority, most of his partners seemed ready to call it quits, and discussions for an election date were expected to start Sunday.
The Gaza fighting that brought down the government is counted entirely in Israeli terms: 460 rockets into southern Israel, 160 Israeli airstrikes, Sderot residents burning tires. No Palestinian casualty figure, no Gazan voice, no Palestinian analyst. The piece names and quotes five Israelis. Hendel is the one Maria tagged, and this is his fullest appearance in the batch — but he is talking about Netanyahu’s electoral standing, not about Palestinians. Closing paragraph as printed: ‘Many Israelis see three main options for dealing with Gaza: A long-term truce with Hamas amid a major international effort to rehabilitate the territory; another all-out war to subdue Hamas and crush its military capabilities once and for all; or dealing Hamas a heavy military blow that would go some way to achieving the second option and perhaps lead to more fruitful talks for reaching the first.’
· The State Journal-Register
Lawrence Haas
“We are most certainly not the experts when it comes to the historical disputes in this region,” Airbnb stated in announcing that it would no longer list rentals by Israeli citizens in the West Bank. Arbnb’s modesty is commendable, but its ignorance is insidious.
Its policy for the West Bank subjects Israel to a singular global standard and reflects an all-too-common narrative about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. By empowering one-sided Israel-haters, it also makes peace less likely, not more. The West Bank is obviously disputed territory, but Airbnb sees the dispute only through Palestinian eyes.
After all, it isn’t leaving the West Bank. If you want a place to rent there, you can use Airbnb to find one that’s owned by a Christian or a Muslim. You just can’t find any of the 200 or so owned by an Israeli Jew.
Airbnb concluded that “Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank” are “at the core of the dispute between Israelis and Palestinians.”
So, Airbnb believes, what’s not “at the core of the dispute” is the rejection of Israel’s right to exist that’s broadly shared among Palestinians and their leaders; or the incitement to violence against Jews on Palestinian TV and social media; or textbooks that teach Palestinian school children that a future Palestine should encompass all of what’s now Israel; or Palestinian claims that Jews have no historical ties to key religious sites in Jerusalem.
Interesting. So, too, is Airbnb’s apparent ignorance that Palestinians have rejected numerous offers of a state, including Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert’s offer of 2008 that would have given the Palestinians about 97 percent of the West Bank and divided Jerusalem between the two sides. Airbnb isn’t offended by territorial disputes per se.
It operates in such disputed lands as the Western Sahara, Northern Cyprus, Kashmir and Tibet.
· The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck · page 1
Wafaa Shurafa, Associated Press, Gaza City
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — In a small studio packed with sculptures made of scrap metal, Palestinian artist Ahmed Humaid has found a new medium in origami, the Japanese art of paper folding.
It’s an unlikely pursuit for an artist living in the Gaza Strip, which has been largely cut off from the outside world since Israel and Egypt imposed a crippling blockade on the Hamas-ruled territory more than a decade ago. But the 29-year-old Humaid, who has no regular job, says interest in origami is on the rise.
“With more people asking about it, this work has turned into a source of income for me,” said Humaid, who lives in Nusseirat refugee camp in central Gaza. Humaid practices a form of origami in which he folds and forms the pages of an entire book into a readable inscription of calligraphic letters. He has no formal training.
He said he learned about origami when he saw some photos on Instagram. He began following Japanese artists and wrote to them. Some offered help and feedback. When he made his first origami work in October, it took him 15 hours to finish. He shared the photo with some Japanese artists who acclaimed the work.
Since then, Humaid has sold 45 works locally, including books folded into names that lovers have given to each other as gifts, as well as logos for local businesses. Depending on the size and number of letters, he charges about $15–30 per order.
Unemployment in Gaza, a coastal enclave sandwiched between Israel and Egypt, stands at more than 50 percent, according to U.N. and other international estimates. It is even higher among Gaza’s youth.
Humaid would like to expand his business beyond Gaza’s borders, but the blockade has cut off virtually all exports, and Israel and Egypt heavily restrict travel into and out of the territory. “I wish to visit the homeland of this art — Japan — so I can be closer to the people who creatively mastered it,” he said.
Filed by Wafaa Shurafa, a Palestinian Associated Press reporter in Gaza. The cleanest non-conflict story in this batch: a man, a craft, a price list and a wish, with the blockade appearing only as the reason he cannot travel.
· Daily News · New York
In Israel, an ex-gen. aims to oust Netanyahu
JERUSALEM — Former military chief Benny Gantz has burst onto Israel’s political scene as the great hope of the country’s shrinking “peace camp” with a message that is anything but dovish.
The retired general, who wants to topple Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in April 9 elections, boasts of killing Palestinian militants and aligns himself with political hard-liners. He fires back at Netanyahu’s criticism with scathing counterattacks.
In today’s Israel, Gantz’s ready-to-rumble rhetoric appears to be the only way to bring down the long-serving Netanyahu. That’s turning him into an unlikely source of hope for Israelis who view ending their country’s rule over the Palestinians, now in its 51st year, as a priority.
Yossi Beilin, an architect of the 1993 interim peace accords with the Palestinians, said fear of another Netanyahu term is driving much of the support for Gantz. He called Gantz a “black dove” — an imperfect but tolerable alternative to Netanyahu.
“Not that I agree with everything he says, but many of the things he is saying are OK from my point of view,” Beilin said. Opinion polls forecast victory for Netanyahu’s Likud Party. But since Gantz’s recent maiden political speech, his new “Israel Resilience” party has emerged as No. 2. The race could swing in the challenger’s favor.
Netanyahu faces possible indictment in a series of corruption investigations, perhaps before the elections. Meanwhile, Gantz is reportedly exploring mergers with other centrist parties. Gantz appears to be modeling himself after Ehud Barak and the late Yitzhak Rabin — former military chiefs-turned-prime ministers.
Both used military credentials to lead Israel to peace negotiations with the Palestinians. Wary of being branded a “leftist,” considered a putdown by many Israelis, Gantz has said little about his vision of peace with the Palestinians. He dresses his rhetoric in security terms as he tries to win support from Netanyahu’s nationalist base.
In his January speech, Gantz bragged about assassinating Ahmed Jabari, a former Hamas military commander whose death in an Israeli airstrike in the Gaza Strip sparked an eight-day war in 2012. “The heads of the terrorist organizations need to know that Ahmed Jabari was not the first, nor may he be the last,” Gantz warned.
Retired Gen. Benny Gantz may be the man to end Israel’s rule over Palestinians.
· St. Mary & Franklin Banner-Tribune · Morgan City · page 1
The Associated Press, Jerusalem
JERUSALEM (AP) — The traditional brightly embroidered dress of Palestinian women known as the “thobe” was not the type of garment one would expect to become a pop political symbol.
Now it’s gaining prominence as a softer expression of Palestinian nationalism, competing even with the classic keffiyeh — the headscarf donned by young stone-throwing Palestinian men protesting Israel’s occupation. The robe, adorned with elaborate hand-stitched embroidery, requires months of grueling labor.
Some thobes fetch thousands of dollars. The traditional textiles call to mind a bygone era of Palestinian peasant women sewing on a break from the fields. Last month, Rashida Tlaib proudly wore her mother’s thobe to her historic swearing-in as the first female Palestinian American member of Congress, inspiring masses of women around the world… “The historic thobe conjures an ideal of pure and untouched Palestine, before the occupation,” said Rachel Dedman, curator of a recent exhibit at the Palestinian Museum focused on the evolution of Palestinian embroidery. “It’s more explicitly tied to history and heritage than politics.
That’s what makes it a brilliant symbol.”… Thobe patterns also expressed women’s different social positions: not for marriage, single but looking for marriage, blue with multi-colored stitches for widows considering re-marriage… During the first Palestinian intifada, or uprising, in the 1980s, the thobe bloomed with guns, doves and flowers.
When Israeli soldiers confiscated Palestinian flags at protests, women wove forbidden national maps and colors into their dresses, according to the Palestinian museum exhibit… “A woman typically has one thobe to wear on occasions throughout her life — it’s very expensive and impractical,” said Maysoun Abed, director of a thobe exhibit in the West Bank city of Al-Bireh, near Ramallah.
“But demand for the thobe still runs high as a way of expressing patriotism.”… Girls are asking for shorter and less embroidered versions, said Rajaa Ghazawneh, a thobe designer in the West Bank town of al-Birch… “Rashida has become a model for Palestinian women everywhere — a strong woman proud of her national identity who can reach high,” said Saca.… Natalie Tahhan, a designer based in east Jerusalem, produces capes from digital prints that replicate traditional embroidery stitches, “connecting tradition with what is new and stylish.”… “These dresses are our link between the past and future,” Saca said.
Six Palestinian women named in one story, all of them talking about a dress: a museum curator, three designers, an exhibition director, and Maha Saca of the Palestinian Heritage Center in Bethlehem, who gets the last line. The occupation is present but is not the subject. The headline misspells political, and is kept as printed. On the page it runs beside a travel advertisement, Beauty from Bali to Jakarta.
· Santa Barbara News-Press · Santa Barbara
By SAUD ABU RAMADAN and TAMARA ZIEVE TRIBUNE NEWS SERVICE
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Four Palestinian demonstrators were killed and more than 300 were injured in clashes with the Israeli army on the Gaza border since Friday night, the Gaza Health Ministry said Saturday.
Violence erupted between demonstrators and Israeli soldiers stationed on the Israel-Gaza border, as tens of thousands demonstrated to mark the anniversary of the Great March of Return protests. The Israeli army, which put the number of protesters at 40,000, accused participants of throwing rocks and setting tires on fire.
In addition, a number of grenades and explosive devices were thrown at the border fence, it said. Witnesses said Israeli soldiers fired tear gas and live gunfire at the demonstrators to keep them from approaching the fence. The Israeli army warned Gazans not to approach the fence during the protests.
The army said that troops had fired “in accordance with standard operating procedures.” The Gazan Health Ministry said Saturday that at least 316 Palestinians had been injured. Of those, 64 suffered gunshots wounds. Others were hurt by shrapnel, exposure to tear gas or being hit by tear gas canisters.
The Great March of Return protests, which have been going on weekly since they began a year ago, call for the right of return of Palestinian refugees and their descendants to the territory of today’s Israel, and for an end to the 12-year-long blockade imposed by Israel.
A general strike was held in the Gaza Strip and the Health Ministry and Interior Ministry declared a state of emergency. Governmental and private sector institutions were closed, including schools, universities and stores all in the Gaza Strip, except medical institutions, clinics and hospitals.
According to the Gaza Health Ministry, 269 Palestinians have been killed and thousands injured in the protests since they started last year. The anniversary coincides with Land Day, which commemorates the death of six Arab Israelis who were killed by Israeli forces during protests against the expropriation of land by Israel in 1976.
Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas said in a statement: “The suffering of our people over 100 years and the enormous sacrifices made by this great people will not go to waste.”
Palestinians gather during a protest marking Land Day and the first anniversary of a surge of border protests, at the Israel-Gaza border fence east of Gaza City on Saturday. REUTERS
· Sun Journal
BY SAUD ABU RAMADAN AND TAMARA ZIEVE TNS
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Four Palestinian demonstrators were killed and more than 300 were injured in clashes with the Israeli army on the Gaza border since Friday night, the Gaza Health Ministry said Saturday.
Violence erupted between demonstrators and Israeli soldiers stationed on the Israel-Gaza border, as tens of thousands demonstrated to mark the anniversary of the Great March of Return protests. The Israeli army, which put the number of protesters at 40,000, accused participants of throwing rocks and setting tires on fire.
In addition, a number of grenades and explosive devices were thrown at the border fence, it said. Witnesses said Israeli soldiers fired tear gas and live gunfire at the demonstrators to keep them from approaching the fence. The Israeli army warned Gazans not to approach the fence during the protests.
The army said that troops had fired “in accordance with standard operating procedures.” The Gazan Health Ministry said Saturday that at least 316 Palestinians had been injured. Of those, 64 were shot. sustained gunshots wounds. Others were hurt by shrapnel, exposure to tear gas or being hit by tear gas canisters.
The Great March of Return protests, which have been going on weekly since they began a year ago, call for the right of return of Palestinian refugees and their descendants to the territory of today’s Israel, and for an end to the 12-year-long blockade imposed by Israel.
A general strike was held in the Gaza Strip and the Health Ministry and Interior Ministry declared a state of emergency. Governmental and private sector institutions were closed, including schools, universities and stores all in the Gaza Strip, except medical institutions, clinics and hospitals.
According to the Gaza Health Ministry, 269 Palestinians have been killed and thousands injured in the protests since they started last year. The anniversary coincides with Land Day, which commemorates the death of six Arab Israelis who were killed by Israeli forces during protests against the expropriation of land by Israel in 1976.
Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas said in a statement: “The suffering of our people over 100 years and the enormous sacrifices made by this great people will not go to waste.”
ASSOCIATED PRESS Medics and protesters evacuate a wounded youth, who was shot by Israeli troops Saturday from near the fence of the Gaza Strip’s border with Israel, while marking the first anniversary of Gaza border protests east of Gaza City.
· The Journal News · White Plains
Israeli army warned citizens to stay back from border fence.
By Saud Abu Ramadan and Tamara Zieve Associated Press
GAZA CITY, GAZA STRIP — Three Palestinian demonstrators were killed and more than 300 were injured in clashes with the Israeli army on the Gaza border since Friday night, the Gaza Health Ministry said Saturday.
Violence erupted between demonstrators and Israeli soldiers stationed on the Israel-Gaza border, as tens of thousands demonstrated to mark the anniversary of the Great March of Return protests. The Israeli army, which put the number of protesters at 40,000, accused participants of throwing rocks and setting tires on fire.
In addition, a number of grenades and explosive devices were thrown at the border fence, it said. Witnesses said Israeli soldiers fired tear gas and live gunfire at the demonstrators to keep them from approaching the fence. The Israeli army warned Gazans not to approach the fence during the protests.
The army said that troops had fired “in accordance with standard operating procedures.” The Gazan Health Ministry said Saturday that at least 316 Palestinians had been injured. Of those, 64 sustained gunshots wounds. Others were hurt by shrapnel, exposure to tear gas or being hit by tear gas canisters.
The Great March of Return protests, which have been going on weekly since they began a year ago, call for the right of return of Palestinian refugees and their descendants to the territory of today’s Israel, and for an end to the 12-year-long blockade imposed by Israel.
A general strike was held in the Gaza Strip and the Health Ministry and Interior Ministry declared a state of emergency. Governmental and private sector institutions were closed, including schools, universities and stores all in the Gaza Strip, except medical institutions, clinics and hospitals.
According to the Gaza Health Ministry, 269 Palestinians have been killed and thousands injured in the protests since they started last year. The anniversary coincides with Land Day, which commemorates the death of six Arab Israelis who were killed by Israeli forces during protests against the expropriation of land by Israel in 1976.
Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas said in a statement: “The suffering of our people over 100 years and the enormous sacrifices made by this great people will not go to waste.”
A Palestinian woman covers her face in a protest near the border fence with Israel last May. GETTY IMAGES
· St. Louis Jewish Light · St. Louis · page 1
“In addition to the Gaza-West Bank link, which would inevitably cross Israeli territory, there are proposals to register Palestinian ownership of land and allow Palestinian farmers greater access to water and arable land… Kushner’s plan envisions $50 billion to be disbursed on building infrastructure and capacity in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, as well as to promote trade and tourism partnerships with Egypt, Jordan and Lebanon… ‘A B C economics is that no monetary value can predicate or substitute economic sovereignty which is the first requirement for prosperity,’ Husam Zomlot, the Palestine Liberation Organization envoy to Washington until he was expelled last year by the Trump administration to punish the Palestinians for their boycott of peace talks, said on Twitter… Another $70 million has been set aside for the development of Palestinian arts, which often embrace a nationalist outlook, and $150 million is earmarked for the Palestinian museum near Ramallah. The museum is dedicated to celebrating Palestinian identity, including resistance to Israel. ‘Traditional Palestinian cuisine varies across regions and excites visitors,’ a segment on tourism says.
‘Each Palestinian city boasts its own trademark dishes and flavors, from Ramallah’s Rukab ice cream to the famed knafeh of Nablus.’… ‘A new flagship liberal arts and sciences university in the West Bank and Gaza’ is tagged at $500 million.
Palestinian universities have over the decades nurtured the Palestinian national identity and at times have been the nexus of protest at Israel’s occupation.
Israeli authorities over the years have repeatedly shuttered the universities during periods of unrest… The website features photos of schoolgirls walking by a school funded by USAID — funding Trump eliminated.
It includes a picture of the Israeli and Palestinian co-leaders of the Parents Circle, a peace dialogue group for families of people killed in the conflict — a program once funded by the United States that also was cut by Trump.”
Ramallah’s Rukab ice cream and the knafeh of Nablus, in a White House document, reported in a Jewish weekly in Missouri. This is one of the few places in this archive where ordinary Palestinian life reaches an American page, and it arrives as a line item in an investment prospectus. The photographs on the plan’s own website show a school and a bereaved-families group whose American funding the same administration had cut.
· Muskegon Chronicle · Muskegon · page 1
Sarah Henry, Washington Post
“It started with a meatball. Anna Francese Gass, born in Italy and raised in Rhode Island, grew up devouring her mom’s meatballs slathered in tomato sauce… ‘Heirloom Kitchen’ is one of several new cookbook anthologies championing the recipes and stories of immigrants who now call the United States (and, in one case, England) home.
They are welcome reminders of the rich cultural and culinary variety immigrants bring. Some leave their homeland for love or economic or educational opportunities; others escape violence or political or religious persecution.
Many are home cooks: mothers trying to feed their families well while maintaining a connection to their cultures of origin… The author, who left the corporate financial world to pursue a culinary career, traveled around the country to collect recipes with roots in Greece, Lebanon, Ghana, Mexico, Korea and beyond.
She also collected stories of what it was like for each woman to leave everything behind to start over in a new land. We meet 85-year-old Palestinian Fethie Abowaznah Loutfi, a child of goat farmers, who fled with her family across the desert and barefoot from Yaffa to Jordan in search of safety.
Denied entry, they continued on to Syria, and in a refugee camp there she fell in love with an Albanian refugee; they married, had a son, and decided to move to the United States in search of a better life. The couple raised eight children in New York; Loutfi worked as a member of the United Nations maintenance staff.
Used to cooking for a crowd — as her Palestinian rice dish maqluba attests — she delights in feeding her family, which includes members of Muslim, Catholic and Jewish faiths. The book, organized around geographic regions, includes 100 recipes from 45 contributors. A common thread: re-creating the comfort of home through cooking. ‘Food is love.
You can taste it in the recipes these women, all mothers, shared with me,’ Francese Gass says. ‘Food made from the heart and soul is the best food.’”
The Nakba in a food column: a woman of eighty-five who walked out of Jaffa barefoot, was turned back at Jordan, met her husband in a camp in Syria, raised eight children in New York and cooked on the United Nations maintenance staff. The dish she is known for is maqluba, which is also the dish a Palestinian family in Phoenix is making two years later in this archive, in a different paper, in a different state.
· The Charlotte Observer · Charlotte
Subject, verb, object, and then what the four were doing: trying to cross Gaza fence. Nothing in the sentence is hidden, which makes it one of the plainest death headlines in this archive, and it names the fence rather than calling it a border. Compare the Times Record News the previous year, where scores were killed by nobody along Israeli border (CP-2018-006).
· Roanoke Times · Roanoke · page 1
The outcome of the election could determine the future for both the West Bank and peace talks
By Joseph Krauss and Mohammed Daraghmeh, Associated Press, Mas’ha, West Bank
MAS’HA, West Bank — Barhoum Saleh’s town is surrounded by Jewish settlements, the sign above his roadside mechanic shop is in Hebrew, most of his customers are Israeli and he needs an Israeli permit to visit the beach a half hour’s drive away. But unlike his Jewish neighbors, he can’t vote in next week’s elections.
Saleh is among the 2.5 million Palestinians in the West Bank who have no voice in choosing Israel’s next government and no control over whether it decides to annex part or all of the occupied territory… Saleh, who is not particularly political, just wishes it was easier to take his kids to the beach.
Israelis who get their cars serviced at his shop describe their trips: one drove down to Egypt’s Sinai, another vacationed in Thailand. But while they can travel in and out of the West Bank freely, Saleh must apply for a permit to enter Israel — and they are not given for family vacations.
So, a few years back, he took his family to neighboring Jordan and its Red Sea port of Aqaba, where he and his children could swim in the same waters that wash up on Israel’s shores. “My kids were astonished when they saw the sea,” he recalls, smiling at the memory. “They want land without people.”
“A man walks out of a Palestinian carpentry shop under a sign in Arabic and Hebrew that reads, ‘All the people’s carpenter,’ in the West Bank village of Mas’ha, west of Qalqiliya.
The 2.5 million Palestinians living in the West Bank are unable to vote in Israel’s elections next week, which could determine whether it annexes parts of the occupied territory and places their dreams of an independent state even further out of reach.”
Six Palestinians are named in one wire story about an Israeli election: Barhoum Saleh, a mechanic; Maraei Maraei, who runs a hardware store in Mas’ha; Diana Buttu; Tareq Baconi; Ayman Odeh; and Sam Bahour, an Ohio-born Palestinian-American. The last line of Saleh’s quotation is the slogan this archive tracks from 1901 onward, said back by a man who lives on the land in question: They want land without people.
· Detroit Free Press · Detroit
“A Palestinian man carries red dates picked from palm trees, in Deir al Balah town, the central Gaza Strip, on Sunday.” Mohammed Saber/EPA-EFE
A wire photograph of the date harvest, printed in Detroit on 7 October 2019. Taken the Sunday before. The town is Deir al-Balah, which means house of the dates.
· The Morning Call · Allentown
Demonstrations against Israel provide few gains
Fares Akram
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — Ahmed Abu Artima was one of the founders of the “Great March of Return,” the weekly protests along Gaza’s frontier with Israel meant to draw attention to the plight of the territory’s 2 million people. But these days, he mostly avoids the demonstrations.
He is among a growing number of Gazans who believe the protests have lost their way. With little to show from 18 months of demonstrations beyond the hundreds of people killed or wounded by Israeli fire, many Gazans are beginning to question and even criticize the Hamas-led protests, a rarity in a territory where dissent is barely tolerated by the ruling Islamic militant group.
For several months, Abu Artima has organized his own alternative protest. On a recent Wednesday, dozens of Palestinians gathered near the separation fence between Israel and Gaza, performing traditional dances and ballads between poem recitals and speeches by local community leaders. Children gathered around two camels decorated with embroidered saddles.
This is the kind of demonstration Abu Artima envisioned when he and other young grass-roots activists came up with the idea of building mass encampments along the fortified frontier. He calls it a protest that “tries to deliver our message as safely as possible.” Held every two weeks, these events are in dramatic contrast to the main Friday protests.
Directed by a committee comprised of Hamas and other Gaza militant groups, the Friday demonstrations are held against a backdrop of black smoke from burning tires. Protesters hurl rocks at Israeli troops, who respond with clouds of tear gas and gunfire. Ambulances bring the wounded to field clinics and hospitals.
When the protests began, Hamas quickly seized upon the popular idea and transformed the quiet gatherings into violent confrontations. Under its direction, thousands of Palestinians have gathered at five sections of the fence each week, facing off against Israeli forces in sniper positions.
The Israeli troops fire live shots, rubber-covered steel pellets and tear gas, in what Israel says is a legitimate tactic to defend against attacks and border infiltration.
Palestinians attend an alternative protest in the Gaza Strip organized by activist Ahmed Abu Artima.
· The Recorder · Greenfield · page 1
Edward C. Davenport, Drum Point
“Read any good books on ancient Palestine lately? ‘Read any good books on ancient Palestine?’ I asked an Associate Pastor of my acquaintance. The Associate Pastor chuckled. He clearly understood the joke. Some of the most widely used textbooks in American schools make reference to a millenniums-old nation called Palestine.
To cite just a few examples: ‘Sometime during the years 8 to 4 B.C., a Jewish boy named Jesus was born in Bethlehem, a small town in ancient Palestine.’
(World Cultures and Geography: Eastern Hemisphere and Europe, teacher’s ed., McDougal Littell) ‘Many Jews resented Roman rule of Palestine’ (World Geography Today, Teacher’s ed., Austin Holt) Historically, ‘Palestine’ was the name of a region. It has never referred to a specific nation.
The name ‘Palestine’ was given by the Roman ruler Hadrian to what was the Land of Israel and Judea because he loathed the Jews and therefore re-named Judea after the Philistines, an ancient enemy of the Jews. Judea and Samaria were a region that was inhabited by the Jewish people since the conquest of the Canaanites, some 3,000 years ago.
Those identifying themselves as modern Palestinians sometimes make the spurious claim that they are descendants of the Canaanites, but the historic timeline disputes it.
Over 70% of the member states of the United Nations have recognized Palestine as a ‘state,’ notwithstanding the fact that no one can clearly delineate what its supposed borders were, name its monetary unit or identify a single leader before Yasser Arafat.
When former Senior KGB archivist Vasily Mitrokhin defected in 1992, he brought with him files chronicling the agency’s disinformation campaign aimed at destabilizing the Middle East.
The files reflect that the Palestine Liberation Organization and Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine were created with the KGB’s help to maintain conflict in the Middle East. The KGB originated the disgusting practice of drawing comparisons between Israel and the South African apartheid.
It is a practice that continues to this day with the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement. When the PLO was founded in 1964, the Soviets created the myth of a displaced people seeking the return of ‘their’ ancestral homeland, and the calls for Israel’s destruction were replaced with appeals for ‘Liberation.’
It is a lie promulgated on college campuses throughout the country by the Muslim Students’ Association and BDS organizers. By replacing Judea and Samaria with Palestine, textbook content writers delegitimize Israel’s historical ties to Jerusalem, while giving undeserved weight to the benign claims of BDS and other Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated groups.
PLO founder Ahmed Shukari admitted in 1956: ‘There is no such thing as a Palestinian people. There is no Palestinian entity.’ Arab-American journalist Joseph Farah offered the most candid assessment: ‘The truth is, Palestine is no more real than Never-Never Land.’”
The argument that Palestinians do not exist, made in a letters column in 2019 and printed in full. The archive holds it because the claim is part of the record it is collecting.
· Albuquerque Journal · Albuquerque, NM
CAL THOMAS, Columnist
Secretary of State Mike Pompeo has announced U.S policy toward Israel’s “settlements” is reverting to one held by the Reagan administration; that is the right of Israelis to settle in the ancient lands of Judea and Samaria “is not, per se, inconsistent with international law.”
This is good news, not only for Israel and its right to national security and sovereignty, but after seven decades of enemy attempts to eradicate the Jewish state it says to the world, “time’s up.”
Israel’s enemies have had the most generous offers to live in peace, including the relinquishing of land captured by Israel after many aggressive and unprovoked wars and terrorist attacks.
With ongoing propaganda statements by Israel’s enemies, the firing of rockets into civilian areas from Gaza and elsewhere, and ongoing sermons attempting to justify the violent overthrow of Israel and the murder of Jews, a reality check is long overdue. Israel, under all of its prime ministers, has gone more than halfway trying to make peace.
The responses have been as if no outreaches were ever made. Israel and the West have a right to question the sincerity of those Arab and Muslin nations when they continue to denounce and defame Israel and the Jewish people as illegitimate occupiers of “Palestinian” land.
As long as such denial continues, there can be no opportunity for peace and Israel is well within its rights to defend itself against such ominous and ongoing verbal, theological and military threats.
It is and always has been wishful thinking to believe that people motivated by hate, a mandate from Allah to conduct what would amount to genocide against Jews and revisionist history as to the original owners of “occupied land,” would miraculously change their minds and agree to reverse decades of provocations and proof of their ultimate objective.
This has always been the danger when Westerners believe all humans are alike and given the right incentives can be persuaded to act in ways consistent with Western values and practices. The next step is for the Israeli Knesset to validate the Trump administration’s new policy, which aligns with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s ultimate goal.
As reported in the Jerusalem Post, “Likud MK Sharren Haskel proposed the bill weeks ago but decided to fast-track it in light of the change in U.S. policy. Haskel submitted a request to exempt her bill to annex the Jordan Valley from the mandatory six-week waiting period for any new legislation, so that it can go to a vote in the plenum next week.”
Columnist Caroline Glick wrote for the publication Israel Hayot, “In the interest of promoting peace, Pompeo instead told the truth. Not only are Israeli settlements not illegal. Pompeo noted that they are arguably more justified than civilian settlements built in other disputed territories.
“In his words, the administration’s determination ‘is based on the unique facts, history and circumstances presented by the establishment of civilian settlements in the West Bank.’ That is, it is based on the historic ties of the Jewish people to Judea and Samaria. These ties lay at the heart of Jewish history and religion.” Indeed, they do.
Now if the European Union, whose hatred of Israel goes back to the shameless days of Nazi anti-Semitism, and is now resurging, would only see the light and end its recently announced policy to require “goods from illegal settlements in the Israeli-occupied territories to be labeled as such,” perhaps some real steps forward might occur.
As long as a religious motivation for wiping out Israel persists, there will be no peace, and no two-state solution. It is why the Trump administration’s position on the legality of settlements in Judea and Samaria is not only correct, but a necessary contribution to Israel’s security and any true peace, or at least stability.
Whole column transcribed; it is short. This is where the sharpest language in the batch sits on the staff/syndicated side, and it is an opinion column rather than news. It contains no Palestinian voice, no Arab voice, and no attribution for any of its claims about what Arabs and Muslims believe. Note the two-way use of ‘occupied’: Thomas puts ‘occupied land’ in scare quotes when Palestinians use it and prints ‘the Israeli-occupied territories’ without comment when quoting the EU’s own policy language four paragraphs later.
Last updated 17 November 2026
Part of Covering Palestine, an archive of 3637 newspaper clippings about Palestinians printed in 748 papers between 1724 and 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles. Nothing here was printed after 6 October 2023.
The clippings belong to the newspapers and news agencies that printed them and are reproduced for research, criticism and commentary. Selection, transcription, counts and writing are © Maria Robles, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.
All decades · archive.json · Questions · Contribute a clipping · When was this printed? · How this was built · maria@rozumstudio.com