San Francisco Chronicle · 15 July 2014
CP-2014-078
Pro-Israel nominee faces close scrutiny
Students sought delay of vote by UC regents
By Nanette Asimov

Transcribed from the clipping
The University of California’s nomination of a pro-Israel Jewish student to serve on the Board of Regents has exposed a long-standing rift among students concerning one of the world’s most divisive issues: the conflict in the Middle East.
The regents will vote on whether to confirm Avi Oved as the student regent-designate on Wednesday at their meeting in San Francisco.
But it will be over the objections of the UC Student Association, the university’s student government, which urged the regents to delay the vote so students could investigate whether Oved accepted outside funding while running for election at UCLA.
Such donations are permitted at UCLA and require no disclosure, the Student Association’s president, Kareem Aref, acknowledged in an e-mail. The real issue — unstated in a Student Association press release but evident nonetheless — appears to be Oved’s strong support of Israel.
Debates about Israel and the Palestinian territories have proved nearly as intractable among students as the conflict itself.
They argue over whether Palestinian sympathizers should be allowed to compare Israeli border guards with Nazis in campus demonstrations; they disagree over which students, Jews or Muslims, suffer greater discrimination on campus; and feelings are still raw about the “Irvine 11” — students at UC Irvine who were disciplined in 2010 for shouting down the Israeli ambassador as he tried to give a speech on campus.
Most of all, students argue about whether UC should boycott Israel and divest from companies doing business there. Oved, an economics major at UCLA, strongly opposes boycott and divestment.
How this transcription was made
Read from the scan Maria supplied on 17 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. Neither image of this article carries a masthead or a dated folio: image _b is the top of a section front (it ends ‘UC continues on C4’, so it is C1) and image _c is the C4 jump, headed ‘Nominee scrutinized’ over the line ‘UC from page C1’. The paper is confirmed from the article’s own tagline on the jump: ‘Nanette Asimov is a San Francisco Chronicle staff writer. E-mail: nasimov@sfchronicle.com Twitter: @NanetteAsimov’ — which matches pub ‘San Francisco Chronicle’ in full, not the deck’s ‘SF Chronicle’. The date is supported, not contradicted, by three independent things on the pages: the story says the regents ‘will vote’ on Oved ‘on Wednesday at their meeting in San Francisco’, and 15 July 2014 was a Tuesday with Wednesday falling on 16 July; and the obituary column sharing page C4 carries ‘Ro Ro left us on Monday, July 14th, 2014’, ‘Georgette Marie Beainy March 11, 1937 – July 13, 2014’ and a funeral set for ‘Thursday, July 17, 2014’, which brackets the printing between 14 and 17 July 2014. The label date 2014-07-15 sits inside that bracket. IMAGE _a DOES NOT BELONG TO THIS CLIPPING. The deck said ‘same article keep together’ for all three images. That is wrong for the first one. 098_2014-07-15_SanFranciscoChronicle_a.png is a different article, in a different newspaper, on a different date: its masthead reads ‘Los Angeles Times’ in blackletter with the folio ‘TUESDAY, MAY 20, 2014 A7’. Its headline is ‘Israel issues roil UCLA’; it opens with the jump line ‘[UCLA, from A1]’, so it is the A7 continuation of a page-one story; its photograph is captioned ‘UCLA STUDENT Sunny Singh said he went on a trip to Israel sponsored by the Anti-Defamation League because, as a history and economics major, he wanted to “see the region with my own eyes.”’, credited ‘CHRISTINA HOUSE For The Times’; and it signs off ‘jason.song@latimes.com’. I have transcribed this record from images _b and _c only. Image _a needs its own record, under Los Angeles Times and 20 May 2014, and the A1 opening of that story is not in this deck at all — only the A7 jump is. Flagging for Maria rather than creating a record I was not asked for. COLUMN / IMAGE ORDER. Established from the sense of the text, not from geometry. Image _b ends mid-sentence, ‘Such donations are permitted at’, followed by the jump line ‘UC continues on C4’. Image _c is headed ‘Nominee scrutinized’ with the italic line ‘UC from page C1’ and its first column opens ‘UCLA and require no disclosure, the Student Association’s president, Kareem Aref, acknowledged in an e-mail.’ The sentence completes exactly across the break, so the order is _b then _c. Within _c the article’s first column runs the full height of the page and the remaining article columns occupy only the top strip, above the ‘Life Tributes’ section that fills the rest of the page; I followed the text from column to column by sense (‘...Oved’s campaign, ‘We are excited to represent the Jewish community and the ideologies of Israel and further / strengthen our unwavering support,” Oved wrote...’). CONSORTIUM SUBJECT. Institutions named exactly as the page gives them: the University of California and its Board of Regents; the UC Student Association, ‘the university’s student government’; UCLA; UC Berkeley; UC Irvine; and the Daily Cal, the UC Berkeley student paper. The body is the confirmation vote on Avi Oved as UC student regent-designate, which the UC Student Association asked the regents to delay. Divestment is the substance: the page reports that in a note published July 3 in the Daily Cal at UC Berkeley, ‘Oved expresses satisfaction at helping quash a boycott and divestment resolution at UCLA’; that a year earlier pro-Israel groups urged the regents to reject Sadia Saifuddin ‘for co-sponsoring a successful boycott and divestment resolution at UC Berkeley’; and that on Wednesday Regents Bruce Varner and George Kieffer told the UC Student Association they won’t postpone Oved’s nomination. QUOTES ARE EMPTY, AND THAT IS A CHOICE. Every direct quotation in this article falls past the first ~1,750 characters, so none can be recorded without pushing the excerpt to roughly 3,000 characters. The ones worth having, all on page C4: Oved, in a 2013 e-mail thanking Adam Milstein, ‘We are excited to represent the Jewish community and the ideologies of Israel and further strengthen our unwavering support,’; Oved on the conflict-of-interest allegations, ‘Any suggestion that I violated the election code by failing to provide information not required is spurious and is nothing more than an attack against me as a pro-Israel student,’ and ‘No similar demand has been made of any other candidate.’; Oved saying he has been criticized continuously ‘for the beliefs I hold on one issue: Israel.’; Kareem Aref in a press release, ‘We have a duty to ensure that our students’ concerns are being met,’ and ‘This new information just requires that we take a closer look to ensure Avi is the candidate we believe him to be.’; Regent Dick Blum, abstaining from the vote confirming Saifuddin, ‘If you’re going to be the student representative, you have to represent all students. You don’t want to alienate them.’; and Oved on Saifuddin, ‘I hope this serves as an example for communities on campus (to) focus on the similarities between one another rather than their differences.’ If the consortium wants any of these, the excerpt has to be lengthened and I should be told to do it. The kicker ‘HIGHER EDUCATION’, set above the headline in spaced capitals, is a section flag and is not the deck. The deck is the two-line italic-weight line beneath the headline, ‘Students sought delay of vote by UC regents’. The jump page also carries bold subheads inside the body — ‘Unstated sticking point’, ‘Focus on lone issue’, ‘Previous controversy’ — which I have left out of the excerpt as furniture rather than body text. I read ‘Irvine 11’ at 6x magnification; at the scan’s native size the phrase can be misread as ‘Intifada 11’, and the magnified crop settles it as ‘Irvine 11’, consistent with the clause that follows, ‘students at UC Irvine who were disciplined in 2010’. Gila Milstein’s name appears on the page only inside an organisation’s name, ‘the pro-Israel Adam and Gila Milstein Family Foundation’. I have not listed her in `people`, since she is not named as a person who did or said anything; Adam Milstein is listed because the page says Oved thanked him by name. SIDES. The page identifies no one as Palestinian and no one as holding Israeli office. I have coded ‘i’ only where the page itself attaches the label: Avi Oved, whom the page calls ‘a pro-Israel Jewish student’ in its first sentence and ‘Pro-Israel nominee’ in its headline, and Adam Milstein, whose foundation the page calls ‘the pro-Israel Adam and Gila Milstein Family Foundation’. Everyone else is ‘w’: Kareem Aref is named only as the UC Student Association’s president, Saifuddin only as ‘a practicing Muslim’ majoring in social welfare at UC Berkeley. I have not inferred anyone’s nationality or politics from a name. See the harmonisation note: in la095 the same Avi Oved is coded ‘w’, because that page never prints the label ‘pro-Israel’ for him; Maria should decide one coding for the man across the archive. BRIEFING MISMATCH. My instructions named la098 as ‘Los Angeles Times, 25 May 2014’ and a consortium subject, and described the three-image entry as la095. The input file has it the other way round: la098 is the three-image entry, labelled San Francisco Chronicle 2014-07-15, and it is the only entry with `label_uncertain` true. The pages confirm the file for images _b and _c and confirm neither for image _a, which is Los Angeles Times, 20 May 2014. FILING NOTE: image _a removed: its masthead reads Los Angeles Times, TUESDAY, MAY 20, 2014, A7, headline 'Israel issues roil UCLA'. Restaged as #118.
Cite this clipping
"Pro-Israel nominee faces close scrutiny," San Francisco Chronicle, 15 July 2014, p. C1. Covering Palestine archive, CP-2014-078. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-2014-078
More from San Francisco Chronicle
- Palestine Is Celebrating Its Ten Years of ProgressSan Francisco Chronicle · 20 November 1927
- Palestinian ProblemSan Francisco Chronicle · 13 October 1944
- Arabs Call Partition Decision Russ VictorySan Francisco Chronicle · 5 December 1947
- Arab Leader Predicts Renewed Violence in PalestineSan Francisco Chronicle · 19 December 1947
- A Zionist Answer to Mr. LevisonSan Francisco Chronicle · 4 February 1948
- Jaffa——‘Ghost City’San Francisco Chronicle · 9 May 1948
- 25 more from this paper in the full text →
More from the 2010s
- Roger Waters rips Scarlett Johansson, Neil Young over Israel; SodaStream stock dipsSt. Louis Jewish Light · 5 February 2014
- Palestinian women make strides in high-tech jobsThe Sentinel · 12 February 2014
- Stories in and out of timeStar Tribune · 16 February 2014
- Conflict, paranoia, but little propaganda in ‘Omar’The Oregonian · 21 February 2014
- The front-runnersLos Angeles Times · 23 February 2014
- Masterful ‘Omar’ dives deep into notion of conflictHonolulu Star-Advertiser · 28 February 2014
- All 343 clippings from the 2010s →
Last updated 17 November 2026
This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.
The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.
Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-2014-078.
Everything printed in 2014 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset