← Covering Palestine

San Francisco Chronicle · 17 July 2014

CP-2014-080

Regents appoint controversial student

Regents appoint controversial student — San Francisco Chronicle, 17 July 2014
San Francisco Chronicle · 17 July 2014
Scan 860 × 886 pixels

Send this clipping to somebody

Transcribed from the clipping

The students who addressed the regents in San Francisco — and hundreds who signed a petition against Oved — criticized him for accepting donations during a campus election from philanthropist Adam Milstein, whom they called anti-Muslim.

The students were also incensed that the regents denied a request from the UC Student Association, UC’s student government, to delay confirming Oved so his ties to Milstein could be studied further. “This student cannot represent all the students without a conflict of interest,” Marium Navid, 19, a Muslim student from UC Davis, told the regents.

Opponents recently found what they called anti-Muslim tweets from Milstein, head of the pro-Israel Adam and Gila Milstein Family Foundation. “Try to persuade people in Israel that Islam is a peaceful hijacked religion. They would laugh at you,” one tweet said.

Another referred to Palestinian participation in a women’s equality forum as “equal opportunity terrorism.” “Avi Oved confirmed receiving funding from the blatantly Islamophobic Adam Milstein,” UC Davis student Azka Fayyaz, 19, told the regents.

She accused the regents of being “complicit in Islamophobia” by selecting Oved, as students snapped their fingers in support. The Israel-Palestinian conflict is perhaps the most divisive issue among UC students, often manifesting in passionate debates over whether UC should boycott and divest from companies doing business with Israel.

Oved opposes boycott and divestment, and has helped defeat such resolutions at UCLA.

How this transcription was made

Read from the scan Maria supplied on 17 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. The page header reads ‘D6 | Thursday, July 17, 2014 | SFCHRONICLE.COM AND SFGATE.COM EB’. That matches the label date 2014-07-17 exactly, including the day of the week, and it matches `pub` ‘San Francisco Chronicle’ by way of the sfchronicle.com line. The tagline confirms it independently: ‘Nanette Asimov is a San Francisco Chronicle staff writer. E-mail: nasimov@sfchronicle.com Twitter: @NanetteAsimov’. The paper is named in full there, as the archive spells it, not as the deck’s ‘SF Chronicle’. CONSORTIUM SUBJECT, and the strongest one in the batch for ordinary voices. This is the jump of the page-D1 story on the regents’ meeting in San Francisco that confirmed Avi Oved. Campus bodies named exactly as printed: the regents / the UC regents; the UC Student Association, ‘UC’s student government’; UC Davis; UC Berkeley; UCLA; ‘the student regent selection committee’; and the Zionist Organization of America. Two UC Davis students are quoted by name against Oved, and the page prints the content of the tweets at issue. ORDINARY PEOPLE. Marium Navid, 19, and Azka Fayyaz, 19, are given only as students who addressed the regents — no office, no title — so I have marked both `ordinary: true`. Sneha Ravikumar is given only as ‘a UCLA student who supports him despite holding a different view on Israel’, also `ordinary: true`. Everyone else named holds a post: regents, a foundation head, an organisation’s representative, a staff writer. NOBODY HERE IS IDENTIFIED AS PALESTINIAN. Navid and Fayyaz are described as Muslim and as UC Davis students; Saifuddin as a Muslim student at UC Berkeley. The page prints ‘Free Palestine!’ as a shout from the gallery — ‘Most opponents had left, though one shouted, “Free Palestine!”’ — but attributes it to no one by name. All these people are therefore coded ‘w’, not ‘p’. I have not inferred anyone’s nationality from a name. SIDES. Coded ‘i’ where the page attaches the label: Adam Milstein, ‘head of the pro-Israel Adam and Gila Milstein Family Foundation’; Sam Levine, who the page says is ‘of the Zionist Organization of America’; and Avi Oved, who opposes boycott and divestment and has helped defeat such resolutions at UCLA. Same question as in la095 and la098 about Oved — see those records. NO BYLINE ON THIS PAGE. The clipping is the D6 jump (‘Regents from page D1’) and the byline stayed on D1, which is not in this deck. The author is identifiable only from the tagline: Nanette Asimov, San Francisco Chronicle. I have left `byline` empty rather than reconstruct one. Note that la098 in this same batch is the same reporter on the same story three days earlier. DEK. ‘FROM THE COVER’, reversed white out of a black bar above the headline, is a section flag, not a deck. There is no deck. TWO CAPTIONS, both recorded in `photo_caption` in page order and separated by a vertical bar. Both photographs are credited together above the first caption as ‘Photos by Michael Short / The Chronicle’. The bold subheads inside the body — ‘Objected to funder’, ‘Supporter’s views’ — are furniture and are left out of the excerpt. QUOTES BEYOND THE EXCERPT, all on this page: Sneha Ravikumar, ‘I understand where the concerns come from, but whatever his beliefs may be, they do not take away from his ability to lead,’; Regent George Kieffer, as the regents prepared to vote, ‘It may be argued that we did not listen to the UC Student Association. But listening is different from agreeing.’; Sadia Saifuddin before her vote, ‘I will vote no today because students demand it. And tomorrow I will start the process of supporting’ him; Regent Dick Blum, last year, that the student regent should ‘represent all students’; and Oved closing by quoting Audre Lorde, ‘It is not our differences that divide us. It is our inability to recognize, accept, and celebrate those differences.’ None are in `quotes` because none fall inside the excerpt. Column order was established from sense, not geometry: six columns, read left to right. Column one runs the full page height and ends ‘...passionate debates over whether UC’; column two begins ‘should boycott and divest from companies doing business with Israel.’ and ends ‘Not all speakers op-’; column three begins ‘posed Oved.’ and ends ‘said Sneha Raviku-’; column four begins ‘mar, a UCLA student’ and ends ‘said opponents’; column five begins ‘were trying to taint Oved’ and ends ‘Kieffer said, “It may be argued’; column six begins ‘that we did not listen to the UC Student Association.’ Each break completes the sentence before it, so the order is not in doubt. Columns two to five start partway down the page because the two photographs sit above them. The paper set ‘The Israel-Palestinian conflict’ in this story, against ‘the Israeli-Palestinian conflict’ in la098 by the same reporter three days earlier. Kept as printed.

Cite this clipping

"Regents appoint controversial student," San Francisco Chronicle, 17 July 2014, p. D6. Covering Palestine archive, CP-2014-080. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-2014-080

More from San Francisco Chronicle

More from the 2010s

Last updated 17 November 2026

This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.

The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.

Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-2014-080.

Everything printed in 2014 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset