Los Angeles Times · 14 March 2006
CP-2006-038
Two sides on the Israeli fence

Transcribed from the clipping
Re “Drawn into a blueprint of bias,” Opinion, March 10 UCLA’s relentless Palestinian propagandist Saree Makdisi writes articulately that Israel’s security fence wreaks havoc on Palestinian life. For sure, it’s a shame that such a wall exists and that suffering continues — on both sides of it.
The Israelis gave up Gaza unilaterally last summer and were thanked in the form of continuing rocket attacks. If they were to undo the wall, what message would that give to the same barbaric folks who perfected the art of suicide bombing?
MARTIN ZUCKER Canoga Park • Makdisi’s arguments would draw more water had they touched on the fact that the Israeli wall has demonstrably reduced the number of suicide bombings launched from the Palestinian areas affected by the barrier.
The Palestinian electorate has given ample evidence of where its heart lies, as witnessed by the election of a Hamas majority to its governing body. What part of “we call for the destruction of the state of Israel” doesn’t Makdisi understand? LOUIS H. NEVEL Los Angeles • Thank you for publishing Makdisi’s beautiful Op-Ed article.
She confronts issues of human rights, justice, injustice and censorship, particularly relating to the interrelationship of Israel, Palestine and the United States, with sensitivity, clarity, compassion, elegance and power. UCLA is lucky to have her on its faculty. JEANIE SHATERIAN Berkeley
How this transcription was made
Read from the scan Maria supplied on 17 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. No masthead, no folio line and no date on this clipping — it is cropped to the letters package alone, with white space above the headline and below the last signature. So the label date 2006-03-14 cannot be confirmed from the page. The only date printed anywhere on it is inside the reference line, “Opinion, March 10”, which dates the op-ed being answered, not this page. A letters column running four days after the piece it answers is ordinary, so nothing contradicts the label, but nothing confirms it either. LOS ANGELES AND UCLA — the second strongest Consortium clipping in the deck, and the one that shows the argument happening in Los Angeles rather than being reported from abroad. All three letters are about a UCLA faculty member, Saree Makdisi, and his op-ed. Quoting the page: the first letter opens “UCLA’s relentless Palestinian propagandist Saree Makdisi writes articulately that Israel’s security fence wreaks havoc on Palestinian life.” The third closes “UCLA is lucky to have her on its faculty.” Two of the three signatures are Southern Californian — Martin Zucker of Canoga Park and Louis H. Nevel of Los Angeles — and the third, Jeanie Shaterian, writes from Berkeley. A Los Angeles paper, a Los Angeles campus, Los Angeles readers, arguing over a Palestinian scholar. AN ERROR THE PAPER PRINTED, LEFT AS SET. The third letter refers to Saree Makdisi twice as a woman: “She confronts issues of human rights...” and “UCLA is lucky to have her on its faculty.” Saree Makdisi is a man. I have transcribed it exactly as printed and repaired nothing. Worth noting that the letter praising him is the one that does not know who he is. The italic line “Re ‘Drawn into a blueprint of bias,’ Opinion, March 10” is a reference line naming the op-ed being answered, not a deck and not a kicker, so dek is empty. I kept the line at the head of the excerpt because it is set above the first letter’s text and belongs to the package as printed. No byline. This is a letters column; the three letters are signed at the foot in small caps with the writer’s town in italic beneath. The bullet between letters is a printed separator, transcribed as •. NO QUOTES RECORDED. The only quoted matter on the page is the fragment “we call for the destruction of the state of Israel” in the second letter, which is not a whole sentence and which the writer attributes to nobody by name. Under the standing rule it cannot go into quotes[]. The letters themselves are the body text, not quotations. The three letter writers are marked ordinary true because they are members of the public rather than officials, but they are named as authors of opinion, not as people something was done to. If the review pages are meant for people named for what happened to them, these three do not belong there. Flagging so the filter is applied deliberately rather than by accident. Saree Makdisi is marked side p because the page itself identifies him as Palestinian (“UCLA’s relentless Palestinian propagandist”); he is a named academic and op-ed writer, so ordinary is false. He does not speak on this page — he is spoken about. I could not check the masthead against pub, because this clipping carries none. The archive’s “Los Angeles Times” with no leading “The” matched the one clipping in this deck that does show the running head, la084; the deck caption here again adds a “The” (“The Los Angeles Times March 14 2006”) that nothing on the page supports.
Cite this clipping
"Two sides on the Israeli fence," Los Angeles Times, 14 March 2006. Covering Palestine archive, CP-2006-038. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-2006-038
More from Los Angeles Times
- The Palestinians’ EvolutionLos Angeles Times · 21 March 1969
- Bomb Victim Had Expected DeathLos Angeles Times · 10 July 1972
- Mrs. Meir's Safety StudiedLos Angeles Times · 11 January 1973
- Show of Artists from PalestineLos Angeles Times · 24 June 1977
- UCLA Jewish Groups Ask Palestinian BanLos Angeles Times · 21 October 1984
- UCLA Renews Rival Groups' StatusLos Angeles Times · 1 November 1984
- 60 more from this paper in the full text →
More from the 2000s
- Mind-set of suicide bombers covered in Globe-winning filmThe Grand Rapids Press · 20 January 2006
- Bush: U.S. won’t deal with advocate of Israel’s destructionThe Blade · 27 January 2006
- Hamas victory surprises White House, CongressThe Daily Press · 27 January 2006
- Bush: U.S. won’t deal with Hamas if it threatens IsraelThe Morning Herald · 27 January 2006
- Hamas’ landslide victory takes world by surpriseLincoln Journal Star · 27 January 2006
- Hamas prepares to governThe Oregonian · 27 January 2006
- All 527 clippings from the 2000s →
Last updated 17 November 2026
This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.
The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.
Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-2006-038.
Everything printed in 2006 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset