Modesto Bee · 5 February 2008
CP-2008-029
Siege is taking terrible toll

Transcribed from the clipping
Israel must lift its siege of Gaza. While it has been exhilarating to see hundreds of thousands of Gaza residents free themselves from the prison that was their lives, they have been able to obtain in Egypt a fraction of the supplies they need.
Israel refuses to allow anything other than the bare minimum of industrial fuel to keep the territory’s solitary power plant operating and a few truckloads of humanitarian aid. On Jan.
30, Israel’s Supreme Court approved these actions, with the callous view that “during wartime, the civilian population is the first and central victim of the fighting, even when efforts are made to minimize the damage.”
Israel’s blockage even of humanitarian supplies is new, but for years it has otherwise largely cut off Gaza from the outside world, suffocating the economy and thus reducing the population to penury.
It has done so even though international law holds Israel — not Hamas — responsible for the welfare of the population, since it remains an occupying power, despite its partial redeployment in 2005. The World Food Programme warned this past November that because of Israel’s restrictions, less than half of Gaza’s food import needs were being met.
Basics including wheat, vegetable oil, dairy products and baby milk were in short supply. Few families could afford meat. “We are seeing evidence of the stunting of children,” noted the U.N. Relief and Works Agency, which supplies food to the refugee population of Gaza.
Today, 80 percent of the population of Gaza’s 1.5 million people depend on food assistance. Unless Israel relents, they could starve. Gaza is not only out of food.
Because of Israel’s siege, the water system is faltering, the sewage system has broken down and is discharging raw waste into streets and the sea, the power supply is intermittent at best, hospitals lack heat and spare parts, and dozens of lifesaving medicines are no longer available.
In the last few weeks, far more people have died unnecessarily because of hospital shortages than have been hurt by the firing of homemade rockets across the border into Israel. There is no excuse for firing those rockets, but Israel was squeezing Gaza long before the first of those projectiles was cobbled together.
The vast majority of Gazans are refugees — or descendants of refugees — who were expelled when Palestine was destroyed and Israel was created in 1948. Like all Palestinian refugees, those of Gaza have a moral and legal right to return to the homeland. Israel blocks their return for the same reason it expelled them in the first place.
Their presence would undermine its claim to Jewishness; that is the nature of its “demographic problem.” Israel’s chief Ashkenazi rabbi recently proposed transferring the population of Gaza to the Egyptian desert. “They will have a nice country, and we shall have our country and we shall live in peace,” he said. That attitude is unacceptable.
So is Israel’s siege.
How this transcription was made
Read from the scan Maria supplied on 17 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. This is the only clipping in the deck with a dated folio line, and it agrees with the label. Across the top right, in small caps: “TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 5, 2008”, followed by the page number “B-7*” (with a star, an edition mark). The label date is 2008-02-05 and 5 February 2008 was indeed a Tuesday. No disagreement. No nameplate appears, only the dated folio line and the section flag “Opinions”, so I cannot check the page against pub “Modesto Bee”. The name “Modesto” and the word “Bee” appear nowhere on the image. The deck caption and pub agree with each other here (both without a leading “The”); the page settles neither. TWO COLUMNS BY DIFFERENT WRITERS UNDER ONE PACKAGE HEAD. The banner across the page reads “Gaza blockade effects: Myth or reality?” That is the package head, not this article’s headline, so I did not record it as the headline. Under it sit two opposed opinion columns with their own headlines and bylines, with the photograph between them. LEFT: “Nobody wins in theatrics”, “By TOM TEEPEN”, tagged at the foot “Teepen is a columnist for Cox Newspapers.” and credited “NEW YORK TIMES NEWS SERVICE”. RIGHT: “Siege is taking terrible toll”, “By SAREE MAKDISI”, tagged “Makdisi is professor at UCLA and author of ‘Palestine Inside Out: An Everyday Occupation.’” and credited “McCLATCHY-TRIBUNE”. I built the record on the Makdisi column. “Opinions” above the banner is a section flag, not a deck; dek is empty. NEAR-DUPLICATE OF la090 — CHECK BEFORE INGEST. This is the same syndicated Saree Makdisi column that la090 carries, run one day later by a different paper. It is NOT a duplicate record (different paper, different date, different headline, materially different text), but the two will read as near-identical to any text-similarity check, so flagging it now. WHAT MODESTO CUT, set against the Charlotte text in la090, because the cuts are the finding. GONE ENTIRELY: “Emergency stocks are near zero, as Israel for two weeks blocked relief agencies from delivering needed amounts of food and medical supplies.” GONE: “down from 250 a day arriving last year.” GONE: the three-word paragraph “Gaza is dying.” GONE: “and seemingly invisibly to the world’s media”. GONE: the three bold subheads (“Economy suffocated”, “Utilities failing”, “Israel blocks return”). TRIMMED: “its ALREADY TENUOUS claim to Jewishness” becomes “its claim to Jewishness”; “proposed A SOLUTION: transferring” becomes “proposed transferring”; “expelled from their homes” becomes “expelled”; “OR THE descendants” becomes “or descendants”; “depend on food assistance FOR DAY-TO-DAY SURVIVAL” becomes “depend on food assistance”; “supplies MOST OF THE food” becomes “supplies food”; “warned LAST November” becomes “warned THIS PAST November”. CHANGED IN CASE: Charlotte sets “Israel’s supreme court” in lower case, Modesto sets “Israel’s Supreme Court”. ALSO: Charlotte uses en dashes in the parentheticals, Modesto em dashes; Charlotte “life-saving”, Modesto “lifesaving”; Charlotte “Anemia rates rocketed.” is cut here. The author’s tagline is cut too: Charlotte prints his full title, his book’s publisher and year, the Progressive Media Project credit and his ucla.edu address; Modesto prints only “professor at UCLA” and the book title. UNIVERSITY — the tagline reads, in bold at the foot of the column: “Makdisi is professor at UCLA and author of ‘Palestine Inside Out: An Everyday Occupation.’” Third clipping in this deck to turn on UCLA, after la084 and la089/la090. The photograph sits between the two columns and belongs to the package rather than to either column; its credit, set flush right above the caption, reads “THE ASSOCIATED PRESS”. I recorded the caption because it is the only caption on the page. Tom Teepen’s opposing column is not transcribed here. If Maria wants it, note that it argues the blockade “isn’t inhumane”, that “The Gazans weren’t starving”, and that “Thus Palestinians once again get indulgent sympathy rather than progress toward their own state”; it names Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and Palestinian Authority leader Mahmoud Abbas, and closes that the border events are “just another in a long line of the destructive distractions that the Palestinians celebrate as victories.” It would make a clean second record. Israel’s chief Ashkenazi rabbi is quoted but, here as in la090, not named.
Cite this clipping
"Siege is taking terrible toll," Modesto Bee, 5 February 2008, p. B-7. Covering Palestine archive, CP-2008-029. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-2008-029
More from Modesto Bee
- Bomb explodes in Jerusalem marketModesto Bee · 29 May 1990
- Arabs’ West Bank village vulnerableModesto Bee · 5 August 2015
More from the 2000s
- Food, not bombsColumbia Daily Tribune · 16 January 2008
- Gaza falls into darkness as fuel cut offCentre Daily Times · 21 January 2008
- Breakout from GazaGreat Falls Tribune · 24 January 2008
- Egypt works to restore borderChicago Tribune · 28 January 2008
- Gaza siege takes terrible tollThe Charlotte Observer · 4 February 2008
- Punishing the people in Gaza feeds extremismDaily Herald · 4 February 2008
- All 527 clippings from the 2000s →
Last updated 17 November 2026
This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.
The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.
Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-2008-029.
Everything printed in 2008 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset