Springfield Daily Republican · 29 November 1926
CP-1926-006
Jewish Colonization of Palestine Called Visionary
Trustee of Carnegie Endowment for International Peace Reports Adversely on Zionist Movement, Deploring It as Undertaking That Accentuates Bitterness on Part of Native Arabs

Transcribed from the clipping
New York, Nov. 28—(AP)—Jewish colonization of Palestine is “visionary” and involves in its execution “results that cannot fail to be unfortunate,” says Dr Henry S. Pritchett, trustee of the Carnegie endowment for international peace, in report made public today by Dr Nicholas Murray Butler, president of the endowment.
The report, Dr Butler explains, was prepared after Dr Pritchett visited Egypt, Palestine and Greece. It is to appear in International Conciliation, official publication of the Carnegie endowment. The Arabs of Palestine and Egypt, says Dr Pritchett share the same ambitions, both seeking freedom from foreign control and their own government.
In Palestine, the “burning question” is that of making the country “the national home of the Jews.” Irritating to Arabs “The very expression is irritating to the Arabs who demand to know, and with reason, what is to become of them if Palestine is to be made a national home for the Jews,” says the report.
“The Zionist movement to colonize Palestine with Jews from other parts of the world appeared to me an unfortunate and visionary effort. As a practical effort, the plan seems to have almost nothing to commend it. “From the standpoint of economics, it is difficult to see how any great Jewish population is to live in Palestine.
The Arabs who now cultivate the soil are able to obtain only a meager sustenance. The inherent poverty of the country, its lack of resources, the absence of an industrial life, operate to make futile the economic success of such an effort.
The enterprise is an artificial one having its chief justification in the enthusiasm of well-meaning men who apparently do not appreciate the difficulties of their problem nor the interests of the existing native population.
“The movement to colonize Palestine with Jews seems to me regrettable not merely on the basis of its visionary character but still more regrettable for another reason. Palestine is a part of a region where racial, religious and political hatreds exist to an extent scarcely equaled in any other part of the world.
“It is impossible to settle a million people in Palestine without to a great extent displacing the present Arab population and this can not be done without accentuating at each step the bitterness that already lies below the surface.”
How this transcription was made
Transcribed by optical character recognition and read back against the scan by hand.
A correction
Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.
Cite this clipping
"Jewish Colonization of Palestine Called Visionary," Springfield Daily Republican, 29 November 1926. Covering Palestine archive, CP-1926-006. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-1926-006
More from the 1920s
- Palestine Arab Executive Makes Issue of Haifa Court SentenceWisconsin Jewish Chronicle · 26 February 1926
- WEIZMANN DEMANDS MORE LAND FOR JEWSThe New York Times · 8 June 1926
- Jewish Colonization Will Extend Beyond Palestine Frontier, Weizmann Tells Actions CommitteeBuffalo Jewish Review · 6 August 1926
- Treatment Of The Arabs In The Holy LandThe Sacramento Bee · 14 October 1926
- Treatment Of Arabs In The Holy LandFresno Bee · 15 October 1926
- Colonization of Palestine VisionarySpringfield Weekly Republican · 2 December 1926
- All 120 clippings from the 1920s →
The same copy, in 1 other paper
Their text and this one are nearly identical. Found by comparing transcriptions, not by reading them side by side, so this establishes that the text overlaps and not that these papers ran the same dispatch. How this was done.
Last updated 17 November 2026
This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.
The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.
Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-1926-006.
Everything printed in 1926 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset
