← Covering PalestineAll the patterns
Palestinian Arabs Protest — The Modern View When American papers started saying PalestinianThe word in a headline, 1924 · 1890 to 2023
Palestinian Arabs Protest — The Modern View
The Modern View · St. Louis, Missouri · 8 August 1924 · “Palestinian Arabs Protest”
Read this clipping in full →

A word for the people

When American papers started saying Palestinian

The colonization chart tracks a word for the land. This one tracks the word for the people, and it moves the other way: absent for decades, then standard.

In the 1930s these papers covered Palestine constantly. 119 of the 218 clippings from that decade put Arab in the headline. 3 put Palestinian, and neither of the two that count the dead is counting Palestinian Arabs. Three Palestinians Killed in Ambush, April 1931, reports “two Jewish men and one woman.” 106 Palestinians Killed in Weekend of Rioting, October 1938, counts Jews and Arabs together, twenty Jews among them. Here the word still means a place, not a people. The lines cross in the 1970s, and after 2000 the older word nearly disappears: 59 headlines out of 1,076.

“Arab” “Palestinian”
0%25%50%75%100%10sn=7720sn=12030sn=21840sn=33950sn=22060sn=23270sn=35380sn=57190sn=38300sn=52710sn=34320sn=206they cross1910s: 13% of 77 clippings1920s: 30% of 120 clippings1930s: 55% of 218 clippings1940s: 53% of 339 clippings1950s: 48% of 220 clippings1960s: 43% of 232 clippings1970s: 28% of 353 clippings1980s: 20% of 571 clippings1990s: 18% of 383 clippings2000s: 8% of 527 clippings2010s: 4% of 343 clippings2020s: 1% of 206 clippings1%1910s: 5% of 77 clippings1920s: 8% of 120 clippings1930s: 1% of 218 clippings1940s: 6% of 339 clippings1950s: 9% of 220 clippings1960s: 10% of 232 clippings1970s: 21% of 353 clippings1980s: 30% of 571 clippings1990s: 42% of 383 clippings2000s: 40% of 527 clippings2010s: 36% of 343 clippings2020s: 35% of 206 clippings35%

Share of each decade’s clippings whose headline or subheading uses the word. Before about 1930, “Palestinian” in these papers usually just meant of Palestine and was applied to Jewish residents too, so the left end of the Palestinian line is not national identity.

The same turn, measured in the body text

The chart above counts headlines. This one counts every time these clippings name the people in their own sentences — 17,880 references from the 1910s on, counted so that Palestinian Arabs is one name and not two. The two measures agree about the turn. They disagree about when: by the 1970s the body text has crossed, and the headlines are still level.

“Arab” “Palestinian”
0%25%50%75%100%10sn=16920sn=41830sn=58240sn=174650sn=63760sn=98170sn=193880sn=321490sn=262400sn=313510sn=159120sn=845they cross1910s: 34.9% of 169 references1920s: 63.4% of 418 references1930s: 77.7% of 582 references1940s: 88.5% of 1746 references1950s: 76.6% of 637 references1960s: 73.0% of 981 references1970s: 43.6% of 1938 references1980s: 34.4% of 3214 references1990s: 21.3% of 2624 references2000s: 9.0% of 3135 references2010s: 9.7% of 1591 references2020s: 5.9% of 845 references5.9%1910s: 9.5% of 169 references1920s: 9.6% of 418 references1930s: 5.3% of 582 references1940s: 3.3% of 1746 references1950s: 9.7% of 637 references1960s: 11.5% of 981 references1970s: 44.6% of 1938 references1980s: 60.3% of 3214 references1990s: 71.4% of 2624 references2000s: 87.0% of 3135 references2010s: 84.9% of 1591 references2020s: 90.4% of 845 references90.4%

How this was countedShare of each decade’s identity references, not of its clippings — so this chart and the one above cannot be compared by height, only by shape. Headline, subheading, excerpt and photo caption; the archive’s own notes are excluded, because those are not the newspaper’s words. Uses of Arab-Israeli that name the conflict rather than a person are excluded.

Before 1964, in their own sentences

The Palestine Liberation Organization was founded in 1964, which is the date usually given for when the word acquired its present meaning. This archive holds 164 clippings older than that which use it. Seven of them say plainly who is meant.

13 Jul 1919

“Before the ‘menace’ of Zionism, Moslems and Christians alike are united… They are no longer enemies. They are Palestinians.”

San Antonio Express, under the headline Does Palestine Want To Be Zionized? The correspondent, Clair Price, does not use the word loosely: he defines it in the sentence before. The same dispatch ran in the Deseret News the previous morning and in the Buffalo Courier Express the same day, so the two entries below are the same piece of writing arriving in three cities.

CP-1919-010
12 Jul 1919

“Resentment of Jewish Colonization by Natives Whose Demand Is ‘Palestine For Palestinians’ — Moslems and Christians For Once United.”

Deseret News, Salt Lake City. The subheading names the people, their demand and the two faiths making it together. The same dispatch: “None knows this better than the Palestinians themselves.”

22 Jul 1920

“Zionists and the Palestinian Fellaheen.”

The Philadelphia Inquirer, in a headline. Fellaheen is the Arabic for peasant farmers, so the phrase cannot be describing Jewish residents.

CP-1920-002
19 Dec 1926

“the same fear of the native Arab Palestinians”

Brooklyn Eagle, on Chesterton. Three words doing the work of a definition.

CP-1926-001
2 Oct 1948

“Palestinian Arabs Ready to Live With Jewish ‘Cousins’.”

Boston Evening Globe, reporting a rabbi’s account. The compound distinguishes them from the other people in the sentence.

CP-1948-044
1 Oct 1957

“Palestinian Refugees Awaken Arab World.”

Freeport Journal-Standard, Illinois, carrying the Washington Merry-Go-Round column. Seven years before the PLO, in a small Midwestern daily, as ordinary syndicated copy.

CP-1957-009
10 Nov 1959

“Plight Of The Palestinian.”

Odessa American, Texas. The definite article and the singular: a kind of person, assumed known to the reader.

CP-1959-002

Checked against the Library of Congress

Everything above is a count of the clippings collected here, which were found by searching, which means they can only show what searching found. So the same question was put to Chronicling America, the Library of Congress’s collection of scanned American newspapers: millions of pages, assembled by librarians for no purpose connected to this.

How this was countedCounting only pages that also mention Palestine.

PhrasePagesHeaviest decade
“Palestinian Jews”2721940s
“Palestinian Arabs”781950s
“Palestine for the Palestinians”311920s
“Jewish Palestinians”261920s
“Palestinian citizenship”251920s
“Palestine Arab delegation”221920s
“Palestine Arab Congress”161920s
“Palestinian people”141920s

American papers used this word for Jewish residents more often than for Arab ones, by roughly three and a half to one. That is the opposite of a convenient finding and it is the main thing that collection says.

What it also says is that the Arab-referent use is not a late arrival. Palestine for the Palestinians is a political slogan about Arab self-rule, and 24 of its 31 pages fall in the 1910s and 1920s. The Palestine Arab Congress, a body that first met in 1919, is named on 16 pages. So is a Palestine Arab delegation. So is the Palestinian people, ten times in the 1920s alone.

Both meanings were in circulation for decades, and the one that survived was not the more common one. The claim this actually settles is narrow: the word was in American newspapers, attached to Arab political demands, 40 years before the Palestine Liberation Organization was founded in 1964.

What complicates this

And the ones that do not count. Several early uses here are the plain geographic sense and are no evidence of anything: a 1902 New York Times reference to the Palestinian Kingdom means the ancient one; a 1920 American Israelite headline about Palestinian Restoration means the Zionist project; a 1946 New Jersey paper calls a Jewish resident of Mandate Palestine a Former Palestinian Native.

The same pattern, in the Library of Congress’s own newspaper collection

The same shape appears in the Library of Congress

Chronicling America holds millions of American newspaper pages, digitized by librarians for reasons unconnected to any of this. Searched for “Jewish colony” and “Jewish settlement” on pages that also mention Palestine, per 10,000 such pages:

decade“Jewish colony”“Jewish settlement”
1890s9.55.5
1900s21.811.1
1910s22.220.4
1920s44.261.4
1930s21.551.3
1940s17.9130.2
1950s1.731.5

Colony leads two to one in the 1900s. They run level in the 1910s. Settlement passes it in the 1920s and by the 1940s wins seven to one.

Across 263,128 pages mentioning Palestine between 1890 and 1959, Arab outruns Palestinian in every decade: 14 to 1 in the 1930s, 34 to 1 in the 1950s.

What this cannot showChronicling America stops around 1963, so it cannot test what came after.

And the word for the place, still in 2001

The chart above is about the word for the people. The word for the country took longer, and one clipping catches an American paper treating its use as news.

12 Nov 2001 · Grand Rapids

“Bush ‘Palestine’ reference noted”

Fifty-three years after the state of Israel was declared, a president used the name of the country next to it and a paper put the word in quotation marks in its own headline. The line under it explains why that was the story: Powell said it is now “appropriate” to call a future Palestinian state by its likely name, Palestine. Appropriate is doing a great deal of work in that sentence. The archive holds the same punctuation around Nakba for thirty-eight years; here it is around the name of a place.

CP-2001-022

A people can be written about for 40 years without being named as themselves. That is what the left half of this chart is. The right half is not a correction anyone apologized for; the word simply became usable, around the time there was a political movement making it impossible to avoid.

Last updated 17 November 2026

This is one section of Covering Palestine, an archive of 3637 newspaper clippings about Palestinians printed in 748 papers between 1724 and 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles. Nothing here was printed after 6 October 2023.

Read it on the site, with the reel and the search → · Full text of every clipping · How this was built