← Covering Palestine

Los Angeles Times · 17 March 2021

CP-2021-029

UCLA able to shield identities of 64 activists

Judge rules university may withhold the names of advocates for Palestinian rights.

By Teresa Watanabe

UCLA able to shield identities of 64 activists — Los Angeles Times, 17 March 2021
Los Angeles Times · 17 March 2021
Scan 1475 × 2048 pixels

Send this clipping to somebody

Transcribed from the clipping

UCLA can continue to shield the identities of Palestinian rights activists to protect them from harassment and guard their constitutional rights to freedom of association, privacy and speech, a Los Angeles judge has ruled in a case that drew national attention to the volatile battles at college campuses over the Mideast conflict. Superior Court Judge James C.

Chalfant denied a request by a New York attorney to order the disclosure of the names of 64 presenters at a 2018 conference sponsored by Students for Justice in Palestine at UCLA.

The attorney, David Abrams of the Zionist Advocacy Center, said in court filings that he wanted the information for research into “anti-Israel terrorists” and was entitled to it under the California Public Records Act.

But the University of California, in its legal filings, said an investigation by UCLA police had concluded none of the speakers were terrorists and argued that disclosing their identities would subject them to harassment and undermine the university’s mission to promote free speech and academic inquiry.

UCLA provided evidence to the court of past harassment of campus supporters of Palestinian rights, including a declaration from a professor citing hate mail and copies of fliers targeting students and faculty by name as allies of terrorists and promoters of “Jew hatred.”

Chalfant found UC had demonstrated that its concerns were valid and outweighed any public interest in disclosure — especially because the speakers were private figures at a private student conference not sponsored or organized by UCLA.

Supporters of Palestinian rights hailed the ruling as a breakthrough, saying it marked the first time a court recognized they face harassment for their activities. “This ruling is a victory that shows you cannot silence us,” said Irom Thockchom, who organized the 2018 conference while a student at UCLA and is now attending graduate school elsewhere.

“The movement for justice is too strong.”

How this transcription was made

Read from the scan Maria supplied on 17 November 2026, at magnification, band by band. NO MASTHEAD AND NO DATE APPEAR ON EITHER IMAGE. Neither half carries a folio line. What the pages do print are the jump lines: the first half ends “[See UCLA, B2]” and the second begins “[UCLA, from B1]”, which fixes the pages as B1 and B2 of the same edition but gives no date. The strongest dating evidence is on the B1 page but belongs to the story NEXT TO this one, “A wave of hate against Asians” by Anh Do, which reports a Stop AAPI Hate study “released Tuesday” documenting 3,795 attacks “from March to February”; that report was issued on Tuesday 16 March 2021, which would make this page Wednesday 17 March 2021. That agrees with the label date, but it is a neighbouring story’s internal date and not a masthead. This article’s own text is consistent with it: the 2018 conference is described as being in the past and the ruling as just handed down. THIS RECORD IS ASSEMBLED FROM TWO FILES, AND ONE OF THEM IS FILED UNDER ANOTHER CLIPPING. The page-one half is the file listed as la107’s src2, /Users/mariarobles/Desktop/Palestine Archive/research/newscans/la2026/107_2015-04-05_KalamazooGazette_b.png. The file listed as la114’s own src, 114_2021-03-17_LosAngelesTimes.png, is only the jump. The deck caption for la114 says “these are the same article, keep together” while listing a single image, which is what first made me look. The src lists for la107 and la114 need correcting before ingest. COLUMN ORDER, AND HOW I DECIDED IT. Not inferred from sense alone — it is printed. The 107_b page ends mid-name, “said Irom Thock-”, with “[See UCLA, B2]” set beneath it; the 114 page opens “[UCLA, from B1] chom, who organized the 2018 conference”. The broken word Thock/chom joins the two halves with no room for doubt. So the order is 107_b first (page B1), then 114 (page B2). LOS ANGELES / UNIVERSITY — THE STRONGEST ITEM IN THIS BATCH FOR THE CONSORTIUM. The whole article is about UCLA. It names UCLA Chancellor Gene Block, UCLA police, the University of California as a litigant, a UCLA professor’s declaration about hate mail, Students for Justice in Palestine at UCLA, a Los Angeles Superior Court judge, and a unanimous Los Angeles City Council vote. The page prints: “UCLA was flooded with emails and calls to drop the conference, including a unanimous vote by the Los Angeles City Council backing cancellation.” And: “But Roland Ruiz, a threat-management sergeant with UCLA police, told the court he had verified that the State Department had not listed the National Students for Justice in Palestine or the affiliated UCLA organization as terrorist organizations.”. The named student organiser, Irom Thockchom, is given across the page break; the full surname only exists when the two halves are read together, which is another reason the src correction matters. SIDE CALL: Irom Thockchom organised an SJP conference at UCLA but the page does not identify him as Palestinian, so I filed him side “w”, ordinary=true. David Abrams of the Zionist Advocacy Center is filed side “i”, ordinary=false. Gene Block, James C. Chalfant and Roland Ruiz are officials and are ordinary=false. NOT TRANSCRIBED: the second story on the B1 page, “A wave of hate against Asians” by Anh Do, about a Stop AAPI Hate report. It is a neighbouring story and nothing of it is in this record except the date reasoning above. NO MASTHEAD TO CHECK AGAINST PUB. Neither half names the paper, although the body refers to the paper as “The Times” twice — “Abrams wrote to The Times in a Facebook message” and “Gene Block ultimately wrote an op-ed in The Times”. That is the paper referring to itself and is consistent with the Los Angeles Times, but it is a self-reference in body copy, not a nameplate, so it does not settle pub on its own. FILING NOTE: gained the B1 opening. The join is printed: B1 breaks a name mid-word at 'said Irom Thock-' and B2 resumes 'chom, who organized the 2018 conference'. Irom Thockchom's surname only exists when both halves are read together.

Cite this clipping

"UCLA able to shield identities of 64 activists," Los Angeles Times, 17 March 2021, p. B1, jumping to B2. Covering Palestine archive, CP-2021-029. https://coveringpalestine.org/archive/cp-2021-029

More from Los Angeles Times

More from the 2020s

Last updated 17 November 2026

This record is part of Covering Palestine, an archive of American newspaper clippings about Palestinians, 1724 to 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles.

The clipping belongs to the newspaper that printed it, or to the news agency that supplied the copy. It is reproduced here for research, criticism and commentary. A city here is where the newspaper was published, not where the story came from, and on most records it was taken from the masthead.

Something wrong here, or something you know about this clipping? The archive is still being built and corrections are wanted: maria@rozumstudio.com, quoting CP-2021-029.

Everything printed in 2021 · Printed on this day · See it in the archive reel · Full text of every clipping · Dataset