← Covering Palestine

The 1910s, in full text

Every clipping in this archive printed between 1910 and 1919: 77 of them, oldest first, as plain text that can be read, searched and quoted without running any code. Each entry links to its own record, where the scan is.

· The Cincinnati Enquirer · Cincinnati · page 1

Customs as in the Time of Christ

Life and religion of the fellaheen — or peasants — of Palestine who represent the aboriginal inhabitants of the Holy Land

Evangeline Ben-Oliel

On land: “All the land around the village is one of two kinds—the freehold or the communal land.” “The communal land is apportioned to the villagers annually. Each year they receive a different allotment.” On government: “The fellaheen of a village are divided into clans and are governed by a Sheik.

The Sheik is the Governor and the father of the community, a man revered and feared by all the inhabitants of the village.” On hospitality: “There is one building in every village set apart for visitors—the guest house, or ‘medafe’.”

Fellah’s Primitive Life. “The various clans have a common language and a common religion, and their customs are the same, but there is no such thing as unity among them all. Patriotism and national pride are unknown words to the fellaheen.

Their love is entirely limited to their own clan and their own village, and their affection for their own hut, or mud house, is very great indeed. The Sheik is a law unto himself.

Each clan wages war with the other clans, and lives only for its own clan and family.”… “The fellah lives the most primitive life imaginable in his rude stone house, or mud hut, on the rocky slopes of the hill.”…

How Land Is Held. “The freehold consists of gardens and vineyards.

They are divided into little plots of 12 feet square, with trenches of earth around them, with openings for irrigation, there being no rainfall for six months of the year.”… “The ‘Sok,’ or market place, is the meeting place for rich and poor, active and idle… It is the center for gossip, there being no newspapers, and the people being illiterate.”

Center of Village Life. “To the market place the women bring their baskets of produce.

Here sits the Scribe, who will read or write their letters for them for payment.”… “Every village has a Khatheeb—priest, teacher, lawyer and scribe, all in one.”… “The fellaheen are all of the Mohammedan faith, but only in name, for they know little regarding their religious beliefs.”… “A bride is bought by her husband and is paid for either in money or cattle, or in exchange for some other fair relative.”

Going to Market · Sheiks of Villages · A Maiden of Bethlehem · The Road to Hebron · A Turkish Minaret—From Here the Muezzin Calls to the Followers of Mohammed Five Times a Day That It Is the Hour of Prayer

A full illustrated Sunday page, thirty-eight years before 1948, describing Palestinian villagers as the people of the place: their land tenure, their courts, their schools, their hospitality to strangers. The subheading calls them “the aboriginal inhabitants of the Holy Land.” The same page calls them primitive and illiterate, and says their faith is a name only.

CP-1910-001 →

· The New York Times · New York · page 2

ZIONISTS IN CONVENTION

Express Hope for Haven in Palestine for European Jews.

1910, seven years before the declaration, and the word is haven — a place of refuge rather than a state. The people the haven would be in are not mentioned. Two years later the same paper was printing Jewish Colonists Redeem Palestine (CP-1912-001).

CP-1910-002 →

· Telegram & Gazette

FRIENDS.

“My Denomination at Work in Other Lands” was a subject which brought out many interesting remarks. The leader Sunday evening was Khalil A. Totah, who told about the work of the Friends’ Mission at Ramallah, Palestine. Mr Totah was well posted on the work, being a native of Ramallah and having been to the mission there.

Other members spoke of the work being done by Friends in Madagascar, Africa, and China. The meeting was a lively one from start to finish, and was well attended.

CP-1910-003 →

· Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham

The Farms Of Palestine

By Frank G. Carpenter

“Zammarin, Mount Carmel, Palestine. I give you to-day some bits of Palestine out of doors. Within the past few weeks I have kept away from the cities and towns, and have watched the shepherds and farmers. I have seen the real Palestine, with the same sky, the same rocks and hills and the same carpet of wild flowers that were here in the days of our Lord.

I have talked with the farmers in the fields, have ridden side by side with the modern Balaam as he climbed the hills on his ass, and have even put my hand to the plows, such as were used in the times of the Scriptures, and with a goad have pricked on the bullocks and donkeys as they turned up the sod.

The Land of the Farmer. The Palestine of the Bible was a land of the farmer. The children of Israel and their leaders were reared or worked on the farm…”

The same Frank Carpenter column as the Richmond Times-Dispatch printed that Sunday (CP-1911-002), and the whole difference is the room it was given. Richmond ran it across a page under a headline naming stock, grain, shepherds and sheepfolds, with four photographs of the people doing the work. Birmingham ran it in one narrow column headed The Farms Of Palestine, between an advertisement for a drunkenness cure and one for Curo Grains of Life. The copy underneath is the same.

Correction: {'note': 'The presentation captions this scan as the Birmingham Post-Herald. The masthead reads THE AGE-HERALD, which is the Birmingham paper that existed in 1911; the Post-Herald was formed later. Filed under the name on the page.'}

CP-1911-001 →

· Richmond Times-Dispatch · Richmond

Farms of Palestine

Farms of Palestine—How They Raise Stock and Grain in Land of Milk and Honey—Among Shepherds and Sheepfolds

By Frank G. Carpenter

“Zammarin, Mount Carmel, Palestine. I give you to-day some bits of Palestine out of doors. Within the past few weeks I have kept away from the cities and towns, and have watched the shepherds and farmers. I have seen the real Palestine, with the same sky, the same rocks and hills and the same carpet of wild flowers that were here in the days of our Lord.

I have talked with the farmers in the fields, have ridden side by side with the modern Balaam as he climbed the hills on his ass, and have even put my hand to the plows, such as were used in the times of the Scriptures, and with a goad have pricked on the bullocks and donkeys as they turned up the sod.

The Land of the Farmer. The Palestine of the Bible was a land of the farmer. The children of Israel and their leaders were reared or worked on the farm…”

“SHEPHERD WITH ONE OF HIS LAMBS.” · “SHEARING A CAMEL. A COMMON SIGHT IN PALESTINE.” · “GATHERING TARES FROM THE WHEAT.” · “HOW THEY PLOW IN PALESTINE.”

A syndicated American correspondent spends a few weeks away from the cities and writes down what the people of Palestine do for a living: plowing, threshing, shearing, keeping sheep in folds, gathering tares out of the wheat. Four photographs run with it here. The subheads across the page are The Land of the Farmer, The Sheep of the Holy Land, Among the Shepherds, In the Sheepfolds, Camels and Donkeys, A Land of Milk and Honey, How They Plow, On the Farms, Taxed by the Mohammedans, In a Jewish Colony and A Furnace Town in the Holy Land — so the piece distinguishes the population that was farming the country from the colonies being planted in it, and gives most of its space to the first. The same column ran in Birmingham the same morning as a single narrow column with no pictures (CP-1911-001).

CP-1911-002 →

· Lincoln Journal Star · Lincoln

Nebraskans Visit Old Palestine

Special Correspondence, Cairo, Egypt, Dec. 21

“We were annoyed by a guide or dragoman, as they class themselves, who insisted we should engage him for our tour in Palestine, and we later found out he was very dishonest, as is often the case with this class of people. The venders in the bazaars offer choice sugar candies for sale, but so mixed with dirt that they are uninviting to the stranger.

Fresh dates are plump and have an excellent red color, but are hard and astringent. We saw our first herd of camels here, which reminded us of the circus menagerie, but on noticing them heavily laden with huge stones we found that they were being used as beasts of burden. Everything is done in the most primitive manner, as the sawing of timber.

The log is placed on high horses, one man standing on top of it and the other below on the ground, pulling the saw…”

“No. 1, Caravan en route to coast. No. 2, Dome of the rock, Harunesh Cherif, Jerusalem. No. 3, Golden Gate, Jerusalem. No. 4, Mary’s Well, Nazareth.”

Nebraskans on a tour, writing home, and the people of the country appear three times in a paragraph: as a guide who is very dishonest, as is often the case with this class of people, as venders whose candy is mixed with dirt, and as two men sawing a log. They have no names, no numbers and no country of their own here — the country is Old Palestine, and the photographs are of a caravan, a dome, a gate and a well. The same page carries a department-store advertisement for dollar hats.

Correction: {'note': 'The presentation captions this scan as the Lincoln Journal Star. The masthead reads SUNDAY STATE JOURNAL, the Sunday edition of the Nebraska State Journal, which the Journal Star descends from. Filed under the established name so it does not become a second paper.'}

CP-1911-003 →

· Courier-Journal · Louisville

Young Turks Would Drive Jews From Palestine

In Spite of Laws Forbidding Acquisition of Property and Limiting Residence, Zionists Believe That the Judaization of Palestine Is Arrested Only Temporarily—The Cause Has Powerful Allies, and Is Still a Factor In Hidden Politics of the Turkish Empire—While Theoretically There Are No Hebrews in Promised Land, the Number Has Increased 50 Per Cent. In Last Five Years—Many Aged Israelites Go Home To Die and Crowd Ghettoes For Protection—All Must Enter By Stealth and Bribery, and There Has Been An Active Traffic In American Passports.

By William Ellis

JERUSALEM, April 30.—Of all the nationalistic stirrings within the breasts of men to-day the most romantic is the longing of devout Jews to get back for themselves the land of Abraham and David. All Christendom is interested in this project. Some schools of Christian theology stake vast prophetic issues upon it.

Statesmen of Europe are interested in it as one solution of the question of what to do with the Jew… One reason for the complaints of the Syrians at the presence of the Jews is that the latter are not dependent upon their labors for a livelihood, and are also able to exist on a very meager scale, and so are able to greatly undersell the natives in their little shops…

“A GROUP OF YEMENITE JEWS.” · “A JERUSALEM JEW.”

Here for one word. In 1911 the Courier-Journal’s correspondent in Jerusalem calls the Arab population of Palestine Syrians, and a line later calls them the natives. They appear once in a long page, as shopkeepers being undersold. Everything else on the page is about who may enter the country and on what terms: residence laws, property laws, stealth, bribery, and an active traffic in American passports. The people already there are the background of a story about arrival.

CP-1911-004 →

· The New York Times · New York

Palestine’s Transformation

Long Periods of Drought Responsible for the Aridity of the Holy Land

A review of Palestine and Its Transformation, by Ellsworth Huntington (Houghton Mifflin Co.)

“NOT only the high, narrow plateau of Judea, whence came the religious inspiration of nearly one-half of the world’s inhabitants, but the neighboring regions of Palestine, the Arabian desert and Asia Minor, have long puzzled geologists, historians, and archaeologists. Here was once an extensive empire, rich and densely populated, but now the abode of desolation.

Over the sparsely peopled deserts are scattered the ruins of such important ancient cities as Palmyra, Petra, Philadelphia, Gerasa, Hebron, and Beersheba, innumerable villages, and the remains of orchards and vineyards, temples, aqueducts, baths, theatres, and similar remains of a luxurious civilization.

Various answers have been offered to questions regarding the transformation of this empire into an arid waste. The most plausible and generally considered is climatic changes. Others are the ravages of war, deforestation, exhaustion of the soil, changing tides of commerce, and a failure of the inhabitants to conserve their resources.”

The empty-land description in its scholarly form, in the New York Times of 1911, reviewing a Yale geographer. The land is now the abode of desolation and sparsely peopled; what is scattered over it is ruins. The list of possible causes ends on a failure of the inhabitants to conserve their resources, which is the only appearance the inhabitants make. Four months earlier a syndicated correspondent had spent a page describing those inhabitants plowing, threshing and keeping sheep (CP-1911-002); six months later the News Herald opened a column with the flat statement that Palestine has a present population (CP-1911-007). All three ran in American papers in the same year.

CP-1911-005 →

· The Dispatch · Columbus · page 1

Zionists To Purchase Land

Plan of American Society Is to Buy 100,000 Acres in Palestine Annually — To Establish Colonies of Jews in Holy Land — 14th Annual Convention Held in Peoria

“To buy 100,000 acres of land annually in Palestine in order to establish colonies of Jews was the principal proposition of a practical nature placed before the fourteenth annual convention of the Federation of American Zionists at its session in Peoria Saturday.

This proposition was made by the National Fund Commission, which is the active agency of the Zionist movement for the purpose of regaining the Holy Land for the Jewish people. The National Fund Commission reported through Dr. M.

Bodenheimer, of Cologne, Germany, that in addition to the thirty-eight agricultural colonies established in Palestine through the efforts of Zionists, a residential suburb for artisans had been established close to the port of Jaffa.”

Colonies in the subheading, and a purchase target in acres per year, decided at a convention in Illinois.

Correction: {'note': 'Slide 9 of the presentation captions this scan as the Buffalo Jewish Review, 19 July 1929. It reports the fourteenth annual convention of the Federation of American Zionists, held in Peoria in 1911, and discusses the Young Turk party in the Ottoman Empire. Filed to the caption on the other scan on that slide.'}

CP-1911-008 →

· Hartford Courant · Hartford

Palestine Is In Hands Of Jews

FUTURE OF CRADLE OF CHRISTIANITY DEPENDS ON THEM. · Work Among Moslem and Hebrew As Seen By Dr. D. W. Torrance. · MISSIONARY SPEAKS AT ASYLUM HILL CHURCH.

“That the future of Palestine is in the hands of the Jews was the belief expressed by Dr.

David Watt Torrance, the medical missionary of the United Free Church of Scotland, stationed at Tiberias, on the Sea of Galilee who is spending a few weeks in this city, in the course of his address on ‘Work Amongst the Moslems and Jews in Palestine,’ at the Asylum Hill Congregational Church yesterday morning. Dr.

Torrance explained at the beginning of his address that it was not his purpose to preach a sermon, but rather to paint a picture of the work and of the tragedy of having to send missionaries to Palestine, the cradle of Christianity, the place where theoretically there should be the least need of a missionary.

Palestine, in connection with our Lord, was a point of great strategic importance and the speaker expressed the belief that it was to be so again in the future. He then gave a short sketch of the history of Palestine, the crucifixion, the fall of Jerusalem, and the dispersal of the Jews, Christians and Romans. Tiberias was one of the four holy cities of the Jews.

It was a Jewish capital for about two centuries and there the Jerusalem Talmud was compiled. There also is a University for Jews, and the Jews come there yearly in great numbers to visit the tombs of their famous rabbis. Dr. Torrance then took up the rise of Mohammedanism during the seventh century in Arabia, the cradle of Mohammedanism and Mohammed.

Here Mohammed, aspiring after holiness and religion, was raised. Here he, coming in contact with debased Judaism and Christianity, and not being satisfied, evolved the religion which bears his name.

In a little more than 100 years this religion spread from its home to the surrounding countries, including Palestine, across the whole northern coast of Africa and into Spain, and was only stopped from occupying France by the victory of Charles Martel.

Following this, the Crusaders strove with the sword of steel to regain the control of Palestine and sadly failed, and the Moslems have remained undisputed in its government until the present day. Modern Christendom has thrown aside the sword of steel and is using the sword of the spirit, with far greater success.

The speaker then took up Palestine as it is today, giving an outline of its natural features, its richness of soil, and of its neglected and starved condition, its very hills, once terraced and covered with vines and fig trees, now staring one in the face like hungry ribs. He took up the unique feature of the Jordan River, beginning at the foot of snowy Mt.

Herman, which is between 9,000 and 10,000 feet high, passing down through Lake Merom, which is at sea level, thence on down the chasm to the Sea of Galilee, 680 feet below sea level, and winding reluctantly away in serpentine coils to its death in the Dead Sea, 1,300 feet below sea level, and 1,300 feet deep. Dr.

Torrance then gave a detailed description of the Sea of Galilee, itself, telling how the ancient cities of the Scripture, associated with the life of the Lord, had passed away, an awful commentary on the woes mentioned against them by Christ, himself, for their neglected opportunities.

Tiberias, the headquarters of the mission, the only town left, although there are numerous villages, probably was never entered by Christ. The present city occupies only a part of the ancient city of Herod Antipas, but its walls are, perhaps, identical in site with those of the times of the Crusader.

Immediately behind the hospital, which was started in 1884, is the site of the Castle of Tancred. The climate at Tiberias, on account of its low depression, is peculiar in the extreme.

During the summer months it has a tropical temperature, the thermometer reaching 118 degrees in the shade, but in the winter it is fit to become a most popular health resort, both on account of its natural beauty, its associations—both sacred and profane—its hot springs and its warm, well modulated temperature. At first his efforts, Dr.

Torrance said, met with opposition from the Jew and Turk, and he was forced to live in a native house. The first hospital was fourteen feet square. At one time a Moslem priest, in order to extract baksheesh from him, got up an accusation of murder against him, which was carried on for eighteen years without the priest realizing any money.

It seems that an Arab had met with an accident in which he broke one of his legs. He was attended by native surgeons, and, as a result of the treatment, gangrene set in. When in a nearly dying condition, he was brought to the hospital for treatment, and, shortly after his leg was amputated, died.

According to the Moslem faith, a Moslem who loses a leg in his natural life, never regains it in the world to come. The Arab’s wife was naturally upset by the death of her husband, and, when she left the hospital, she chanced to meet the Moslem priest, who questioned her, after which he took her before a Cadi and had a charge of murder preferred against the doctor. Dr.

Torrance said, however, that his assistants stood by him, and that the difficulty has now been overcome.

An interesting part of his work has been the camping trips among the villages and the Bedouins, where he has spent much time giving health lectures, a particular feature of which was the cautioning of the natives against their habits of laziness, which permitted them to drink the filthy water in the old abandoned Roman cisterns, rather than to walk a small distance to the natural springs.

The result of these trips was the increased interest taken by the natives in the hospital, who half-support it themselves. At present there are about 2,000 visits a month to the institution, and the forty beds are constantly full.

Plans are under way for the extension of the hospital, the addition of a maternity hospital for the training of midwives, the extension of the nurses’ training home, and the establishment of a new medical mission hospital in the further East in the Hauran, among the Druses and the Arabs, who at present are flooding the parent institution.

In the hospital patients of all religions are received and people who, outside the institution would be flying at one another’s throats, are seen working together like brother and sister. The environment outside is one of Turkish oppression, bigotry and ignorance, while inside is that of a Christian home.

A short time ago a prominent Moslem chief came to visit his son, Derweesh, who was undergoing treatment in the hospital. He was struck with amazement at the comfort and beauty of the place and exclaimed, ‘God give victory to the Sultan,’ believing that he had built the hospital.

When told of his mistake he said, ‘God give victory to the Queen of England,’ and when again informed of his mistake, asked, ‘Who am I to thank for this?’ Dr.

Torrance then explained to him the names of the different congregations, Sunday schools and individuals supporting the beds, mentioning, as he did so, that the bed his son was lying in had no name except the Scripture verse, ‘Inasmuch as ye do it unto the least of these, my brethren, you have done it unto me.’

The Moslem then inquired again as to what supported the bed, and received the reply that God knew who supported it. At that the Moslem went into a corner and removing his girdle, which proved to be a purse, shook out every coin, amounting to several pounds, and gave them to the doctor to use in the name of the Messiah.

Late that night the physician, while in his study, was found by his assistant, who, instead of calling him for an accident, said that Derweesh’s father, on retiring, had found another gold coin in his girdle and had brought it to the hospital. His home and town in the Hauran are now open to the Christian missionary. Dr.

Torrance told several other anecdotes of a similar character, after which he took up the Jew in Palestine, saying that the Jews of late have been like parasites living on the Haluka, a fund sent by their brethren in Europe, to support them in holding the Holy Sites, and to support them in study and prayer, but which, in reality, was proving to be a pension on laziness and was having a most deteriorating influence on the progress of the land.

Things were changing though. The Jew was beginning to work, agricultural colonies have been established, and today the best crops in Palestine were sown by Jewish hands. Hebrew was being revived as a living tongue and, altogether, a new era had begun.

In his experience he had found that the Jews were not opposed to Christ, but to the debased persecuting Christianity with which they had come in contact. In conclusion, Dr. Torrance said that it was well worth while establishing Christian missions among them.

There were no people, in comparison with their numbers, who wielded so much influence in the world today, and if they were won to Christ what could they not do for the world? Dr. Torrance is on a leave of absence, and, with his wife, is spending a few weeks in this city.

During his stay he is planning to speak to the prisoners at the state prison on Palestine, believing that it will be of interest in connection with the fresco, ‘Christ After the Resurrection Forgiving Peter at the Sea of Galilee,’ soon to be presented to the prison and placed in the chapel, by Miss Genevieve Cowles of Farmington.

Miss Cowles spent three years in Tiberias collecting material for her work.”

A Scottish medical missionary at Tiberias, reported in Hartford in 1911, and the headline asserts as settled fact something that was not true of the population: Palestine is in hands of Jews. The subheads name the people the mission worked among — Moslem and Hebrew — so the paper knew who lived there while the headline said whose the country was. What the future of the place is made to depend on, in the second line, is Christianity.

CP-1911-006 →

· News Herald · Morganton

Palestine Races

The Hebrews Were the Light-Bearers of Pre-Christian Times

By Rev. P. A. Laury

“The present population is a mixture of many different races. Even before Abraham migrated, Palestine seems to have been a meeting-place of many races…

The Horites. The earliest inhabitants of the land, according to the researches of explorers in Petra and Gezer, were the Horites…

The Canaanites. The name is widely and differently used. The people of Canaan are mentioned in letters from Egypt (Amarna Tablets of 15th Cent. B. C.) The Canaanites became powerful enough to give the land of Palestin the name,—‘The Land of Canaan.’…

The Hebrews Amidst Other Races. When Israel entered upon the inheritance of Canaan under Joshua, the earlier inhabitants were not wholly exterminated. While the Canaanites intrenched themselves in fortified cities, the Israelites occupied the rural districts… By the time of the crusades comparatively few Jews were left in Palestine.

By means of colonies from Russia, Hungary, Germany, etc., numerous Jews (c. 100,000) are again found in the ‘land of the fathers.’ For a long time the Moslems had supreme control of the Holy Land, but their influence is on the wane… May all races of the world soon acknowledge Him their Saviour and King!”

The first sentence is the reason this is here: The present population is a mixture of many different races. In 1911, in a small American paper, the existence of a present population of Palestine is the opening premise and needs no argument. The rest of the column is a race survey running from the Horites to the Crusades, and it counts about 100,000 Jews arriving by way of colonies from Russia, Hungary and Germany — the paper’s own word again. It ends by hoping every race will acknowledge Christ.

CP-1911-007 →

· The New York Times · New York · page 6

JEWISH COLONISTS REDEEM PALESTINE

Over 100,000 of Them Now There, and They Are Transforming the Country. · PEOPLE BECOMING WEALTHY · Foreign Jews Furnishing Capital and Executive Ability to Make the Natives Self-Supporting.

The New York Times, 1912, in its own headline voice: colonists, and the verb is redeem. This is the clipping the colonization section of this archive is built around, and the last of its four lines is the one people miss — Foreign Jews Furnishing Capital and Executive Ability to Make the Natives Self-Supporting. Every element of a colonial prospectus is in it: foreign capital, executive ability, and natives who are to be made self-supporting. Nobody hid any of this; it was the selling point.

CP-1912-001 →

· Reading Times · Reading

CHRISTIANS MOWED DOWN BY MOSLEMS AT JAFFA, PALESTINE

Athens, Greece, Nov. 20

“Reports of massacres of Christians in Jaffa, Palestine, caused the commander of the Russian cruiser Oleg to weigh anchor and depart hurriedly for that district today… There are supposed to be about 10,000 Christians among the inhabitants, the total of whom is estimated at about 40,000.”

The headline states an atrocity as fact. Underneath it: an Athens dateline, a rumor whose only evidence is that a warship sailed, no casualty counted, no witness quoted — and then three-quarters of the item is an inventory of missionary staff. This is held as a control. The machinery is identical to what produces the other kind of error, and here it runs the other way.

CP-1912-002 →

· The Cochran Journal · Cochran

New Era In Palestine

“PHILANTHROPIC work of a new sort which has been instituted in Palestine through the generosity of Nathan Straus has reached such proportions that Mr. Straus is now on his second trip to that country… The institutions which are already in existence through Mr. Straus’s activities are known as the Nathan Straus Relief Fund and the Health Bureau.

The first operates exclusively among the poor of Jerusalem, while the second extends over all of Palestine and concerns some 600,000 persons.

Now he proposes to introduce the system which has been so successfully employed here of providing trained nurses to disseminate hygienic knowledge in districts where modern methods have hitherto been unknown and to teach medical principles so that the ignorance of the people in regard to such subjects may be dissipated… Under his direction the first steps have been taken that the dwellers in the city of Jerusalem and the surrounding country have ever known for the relief of the conditions that have so long impeded the commercial and social progress of that portion of the Turkish empire… With all this charity and benevolence among them, after so many years of neglect, the people of Palestine are taking new heart.

They who have been a downtrodden and discouraged race are now hopeful and cheerful… Betterment of one means improvement of the other, and both are on the forward march. There is a new era in the Holy Land.”

“NATHAN STRAUS” · “STREET SCENE IN BETHLEHEM” · “SCENE IN JERUSALEM”

A Georgia weekly in April 1913, and two things in it are worth keeping. The health bureau extends over all of Palestine and concerns some 600,000 persons — a working population figure for the country, printed without argument, at a moment when other American pages were calling the same country desolate. And the phrase for who they are is the people of Palestine, undivided, with no adjective in front of it. What they get in the same sentences is condescension: ignorance to be dissipated, a downtrodden race taking new heart. The page’s other half is a column of jokes headed Gathered Smiles.

CP-1913-001 →

· Courier Post · Camden

Condition Of Jews In Russia Not Helped By Our Stand

American Government’s Action Has Had a Great Moral Value for History, Says Nahum Sokolow, Noted Publicist, Now Here, but Little Actual Effect—Looking to Palestine for a New Home.

“Since Zionism started in its present form, Herr Sokolow said, some sixteen years ago, the number of Jewish settlers in Palestine has increased about 50,000, there being now about 100,000 there. Fully 90 per cent., he declared, came from Russia.

That there had not been immigration into the Holy Land in greater numbers, he said, was due to the great uncertainty at first hedging about the possibilities of colonization in Palestine, the great question whether or not the natural resources of the land were such as to promise success for the labor of the pioneer settlers and the uncertainty as to the political outlook there… ‘There has been a great change since then,’ he said, ‘and what seemed then a land of little promise and of unknown and doubtful potentialities as concerned its ability to respond to and repay the work of settlers has now, in the colonies conducted by Zionists, shown itself full of promise and plenty to those who will work.’… ‘As for the present greater tide of immigration from Russia to the United States, we Zionists do not consider that a loss to Palestine or to our cause.

There is no competition between this country and Palestine in that regard. We realize that immigrants who come to this country and learn to live under its free institutions and to work under its equal opportunities grow stronger and more enterprising and courageous, more efficient workers for colonization.’”

“NAHUM SOKOLOW” — portrait drawing, signed Rosen.

A leading Zionist figure interviewed in an American paper in 1913, and the vocabulary is his own: colonization twice, settlers, pioneer settlers, the colonies conducted by Zionists. What the country is measured by is whether it will respond to and repay the work of settlers. The one sentence about America is worth keeping too: immigrants who go to the United States are not a loss, because they come back more efficient workers for colonization. Nobody already living in Palestine is mentioned in any of it.

CP-1913-002 →

· estimated · Evansville Courier & Press · Evansville

…ough the Desert to the Holy Land

… J. Merritt, Rabbi of the Washington Avenue Temple

treated with the utmost kindness and cordiality. These Bedouins live in tents made of black goats hair, which is spun and woven by the women into strips of coarse cloth about twenty inches in width and perfectly water proof. Several of such lengths are then sown together to make a tent. Each tent requires at least nine poles, placed in rows of three.

The shiek of the village usually has a large tent, never less than twenty feet long. This is divided near the center pole into two apartments. That on the right is called the “mehram” or woman’s apartment and into this no men strangers are admitted under any circumstances.

On the arrival of male guests, a cloth is immediately drawn across the woman’s apartment and they must remain out of sight. This explains the incident of Sorah when the angels visited Abraham to fortell the birth of Issac. You will remember they said, “Where is Sarah, thy wife?”

And he said, “Behold, in the tent.” that is in the woman’s apartment where she might hear but not be seen of her husband’s guests. Coming from houses crowded with furniture, the Bedouin tent offers a striking, but I will not say a refreshing contrast. It is hard to conceive such bareness.

Date check: No masthead and no date line appear anywhere on this scan. The slide date of 1913-06-22 cannot be confirmed or contradicted from the image.

CP-1913-003 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

CALLS PALESTINE ARID LAND

But Prof. Gregory’s Assertions Are Denied by Sir John Gray-Hill.

LONDON, Dec. 13.—Prof. J. W.

Gregory of the University of Glasgow, in lecturing this week before the Royal Geographical Society, discussed the changes of climate in Palestine, and said that the Palestine described in the Bible as a land flowing with milk and honey and fertile in vine and olive and, according to Old Testament statistics, with a dense population, was now a barren and arid land with scanty vegetation, occupied by some 700,000 people, mostly Arabs and paupers.

Sir John Gray-Hill, who has traveled extensively in Syria and owns a house and land near Jerusalem, denies Prof. Gregory’s assertion that Palestine is barren and arid. In a letter to The Times he points out that Judea is only a part of Palestine and the least fertile part.

The plains of Sharon, Carmel, Esdraelon, and Samaria are still very fertile, and even in the rocky parts of Judea a great deal of cultivation is possible. He says he planted over twenty acres of stony land on the ridge of which the Mount of Olives forms a part, with figs, vines, olive, and other trees.

Even now at modern Jericho bananas and the largest oranges he ever saw are grown in gardens. He added: “As to the milk and honey spoken of in the Bible, the Israelites coming from the desert to Moab would naturally hail the latter as a most fertile land.

I have drunk excellent milk from camels, goats, and sheep in Moab, and wild honey is still found in the crevices of the rocks in many parts of Palestine, both east and west.”

Date check: No masthead appears on this clipping — it is a trimmed single column. The credit line under the deck reads "Special Cable to THE NEW YORK TIMES.", which agrees with `pub`. The dateline reads "LONDON, Dec. 13.", one day before the slide date of 1913-12-14, which is the normal gap for a cabled story. No printed date is visible to verify the year.

CP-1913-004 →

· El Paso Times

HOLY LAND NATIVES SCARED.

Vedrines’ Aeroplane, First They’d Seen, Caused Consternation.

By the Associated Press

Jaffa, Palestine, Dec. 28. — Jules Vedrines, the French aviator, passed over this port on his way to Cairo. His appearance caused consternation among the inhabitants, most of whom were ignorant of the existence of flying machines.

CP-1913-005 →

· The New York Times · New York · page 3

SAYS THE ZIONISTS DISTURB PALESTINE

Dr. Paul Nathan of Berlin Asserts Jewish Cause Is Imperilled. | TERRORISM, RUSSIAN STYLE | Statements Exaggerated, New York Jews Say—Dispute Over Question of Language.

BERLIN, Jan. 17.—Grave charges against what he terms the “arrogant Zionist activity” in Palestine, with which prominent men in New York are identified, are preferred by Dr. Paul Nathan, a well-known Jewish leader in Berlin. Dr.

Nathan has just returned from the Holy Land, where he went on a trip of investigation on behalf of the German Jewish National Relief Association, through which the Jewish philanthropists in America and Europe operate. In a pamphlet issued to-day Dr.

Nathan accuses the Zionist elements in Palestine of stirring up discord, even among the Mohammedan and Christian populations, to such an extent that the entire Jewish cause is imperilled. Allegations based on documentary evidence are made that alleged Zionists are carrying on a campaign of terrorism modeled almost on Russian progrom lines.

Their hostility is directed mainly against the schools established under the auspices of the German Association and is said to spring from failure to realize their desire to establish a great technical college at Haifa, where wealthy American Jews already have endowed various institutions. Dr.

Nathan declares that attempts have been made to blow up some of the German schools, and that the Zionists have not shrunk even from organizing riots. Matters recently reached such a pass that the Mohammedan Governor of Jerusalem was compelled to issue a public warning against further disturbances of the peace.

Only strong resistance on the part of the religious elements in the country resulted in effecting a partial restoration of order. Dr. Nathan says he desires to raise his voice against the “overwrought Jewish rationalist chauvinism.”

As a friend of Zionist works he appeals to their supporters throughout the world to suppress the “officious intriguing elements at work in Palestine,” which threaten Judaism’s interests with incalculable and irreparable harm.

Four years before Balfour. The verb in the headline is disturb and the thing disturbed is Palestine — a country with a settled enough life to be disturbed. The objection in the line beneath is made on Jewish grounds by a Jewish figure in Berlin, which is how the New York Times could print the headline flat.

CP-1914-001 →

· estimated · Fort Worth Star-Telegram · Fort Worth

Strange Customs of Palestine Told by Visitor—Curiosity of Natives One of Aids to Conversion.

Dr. E. V. Jago, missionary to Palestine, is in Fort Worth to show his brethren the great opportunities that political and religious unrest is creating for the Christian missonary in foreign lands. Since Thursday Dr. Jago, assisted by U. S. Lewis of Atlanta, vice president of the Christian Alliance, has been holding conferences at the First Congregational Church.

Sunday afternoon at 3:30 at the Congregational Church he will speak on the “Development of Prophecy and the Signs of the Times.” This will be the most significant of his series of lectures delivered in Fort Worth. “There is a great stirring of social and religious thought throughout the world,” said Dr.

Jago Friday afternoon, “and this is responsible for the opening of the missionary fields as never before. The heathen systems of religion are on the wane, and the people are looking for something to take their place. Western Ideals Sought. “They are looking with most longing eyes toward Christianity.

Western ideals and Western civilization are being sought as never before. The Christian Missionary Alliance, of which I am a worker, believes that the crucial time for the advance on heathen religions has come. This organization is trying to arouse the churches of this country to an interest in the situation.”

Date check: No masthead and no date line appear on this scan — the clipping begins at the article’s own headline. The slide date of 1914-02-08 cannot be confirmed or contradicted from the image. The article says Dr. Jago spoke "Friday afternoon" and will speak "Sunday afternoon at 3:30", so the page is a Saturday paper; 1914-02-08 was a Sunday, which does not fit that internal evidence.

CP-1914-003 →

· New York Tribune · New York · page 1

Zionism

An Authoritative Exposition of the Movement.

Reviewing ZIONISM. By Richard J. H. Gottheil, Professor of Semitic Languages in Columbia University; Sometime President of the Federation of American Zionists. The Jewish Publication Society of America.

“There is certainly something attractive and inspiring in the proposal to give the land without a people to the people without a land. In any case, almost, it would seem logical and practical.

But it far transcends those qualities when the land and the people in question belong to each other by virtue of a possession among the most ancient in the world, and of circumstances making the strongest of appeals to equity and to sentiment. There are various other peoples who plead for or demand a fuller control of their own land.

But the Jewish people stand alone in asking that their land be restored to them after their enforced exile from it for eighteen hundred years. Professor Gottheil is, of course, a Zionist, and he writes the history of the Zionist movement from the point of view not merely of a sympathizer but of an earnest propagandist.

Yet we cannot accuse him of partiality, at least to the extent of doing any injustice to those who differ from his views… With his vindication of the patriotism of Zionists in the lands in which they now happen to be sojourners there will be hearty agreement on the part of thoughtful men.

The loyal Americanism of Jews has been too often proved to be doubted now because they advocate the restoration of their ancient home to their scattered race… we may in default of fuller demonstration assume that if Zion were restored large numbers of perfectly loyal Jews would remain in America and elsewhere, while there would also be a large number who would hasten to Palestine; enough, we imagine, to populate that country well, and to effect a redevelopment of its resources.”

The phrase, in an American newspaper, in its own voice, in 1914 — and then the same sentence continues into its opposite: the land and the people in question belong to each other. This is the clipping the slogan claim rests on, and it is rarer than the claim implies. It runs beside a review of a book about industrial efficiency called The Job, the Man, the Boss.

CP-1914-002 →

· The Boston Globe · Boston · page 41

ON WAR-TRODDEN FIELDS

SYRIA AND THE HOLY LAND—FROM DAMASCUS TO JERUSALEM, WHERE THE KAISER AND THE SULTAN HAVE UNITED THE CROSS AND THE CRESCENT.

By JAMES MORGAN

At the tomb of Saladin, in a court of the great mosque of Damascus, there lies a Maltese cross in a wreath of silver and gold. That cross is the tribute of the German Emperor to the memory of the greatest of the soldiers of the crescent.

The celebrated pilgrimage of Emperor William II to Palestine in [year illegible] marked the opening of a new era in a land of uncounted eras, and all up and down the Asiatic shore many things date from the time “when the Kaiser was here.” For seldom has the Caliph of the Prophet been honored with a call from a Christian monarch.

Roads were hastily improved and constructed for the visitor’s reception. Part of the old wall of Jerusalem, by the Jaffa Gate, was torn away to admit the Emperor’s carriage into the city, where wheeled vehicles never had been seen.

More than [number illegible] Turkish dignitaries were detailed to wait upon his majesty throughout his journey, and the Sultan exhausted the resources of Oriental hospitality in his attentions to his brother sovereign and guest. The Kaiser in the Holy Land.

Landing at Beirut from his yacht Hohenzollern, the august pilgrim and his Empress journeyed to Baalbeck and Damascus and afterward across the Plain of Sharon and over the Mountains of Judea to the Holy City.

THE MINARET OF THE GREAT MOSQUE OF DAMASCUS | THE TOMB OF SALADIN | A VIEW OF THE OLDEST BATTLEGROUND IN HISTORY – ON THE PLAIN OF JEZREEL (Photo by Am. Colony, Jerusalem) | OUTSIDE THE JAFFA GATE, JERUSALEM, WHICH THE SULTAN WIDENED FOR THE KAISER (Photo by Am. Colony, Jerusalem) | CHRISTMAS IN BETHLEHEM (Photo by Am. Colony, Jerusalem)

Date check: the masthead reads THE BOSTON SUNDAY GLOBE—DECEMBER 27, 1914, with the page number 41 at the right. This matches both `pub` and the slide date of 1914-12-27, and December 27, 1914 was a Sunday.

CP-1914-004 →

· Detroit Free Press · Detroit

Palestine a Nation

That Is Considered a Possible Outcome of the Great World War

Charles M. Pepper

ZION as a protected nation is one of the possible outcomes of the war that is now seriously discussed in Europe, especially in England. Hints, somewhat vague yet tangible, are thrown out regarding a prospective Jewish state of Palestine.

The Zionist movement is more or less familiar to newspaper readers, though usually it is looked upon solely as an aspiration, or even as a dream. Zionist leaders themselves never have contemplated that twelve million or fourteen million persons of the Hebraic race scattered throughout the world could all be gathered together in Palestine.

What they have proposed has been to colonize Palestine with some of their own race and to realize the dream of centuries by placing the Jewish people in control both numerically and politically.

Sir Moses Montefiore, the Jewish philanthrophist of London, before his death at an advanced age years ago, among his other benefactions provided for the re-establishment of his people in Jerusalem. Other rich Hebrews supplemented his gifts, while Zangwill and intellectual leaders gave their encouragement.

It is to be said for the Zionist proponents at the present time that they are taking a sensible view of what may come from the world war and are not encouraging wild hopes for the Jewish people. Yet they realize that the opportunity to re-establish Palestine as the land of the Hebrews may be near at hand.

Palestine has felt the movement of western civilization which during the last ten years has awakened the orient. There have been efforts to fall in with the industrial march and to adopt modern ideas. Some of these efforts have been directed toward agricultural improvement.

Palestine is an agricultural land and the first advance step has been to adopt modern agriculture, although farming after biblical methods still prevails there. Establishing Jewish agricultural colonies was part of the program of the Zionists, and while the experiments attempted on a small scale were not brilliantly successful, the experience gained from them was valuable.

What there is of modern agriculture, however, has been due to other nationalities. Most of the orange groves of Jaffa were developed by French and English growers. The Jaffa orange has a market all over Europe, and occasionally a cargo finds its way to the United States.

A beautiful French Catholic church at Jaffa from its roof unfolds a splendid panorama of orange groves as well as of wheat fields.

Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.

CP-1915-005 →

· Sedalia Capital

Holy Land Opens Up

While Tide of Immigration Has Set Towards New Strip, Yet Conditions Remain Primitive

Washington, D. C., Jan. 2.—The latest land to have been brought within the rapidly expanded war area is that thin strip upon the eastern coast of the Mediterranean Sea, the Holy Land, sacred to the believers of three world-religions, to Christians, Jews and Moslems, and ground where in were cradled ideals which have made almost all civilization tributary.

It is a bridge between the Moslem power and Asia Minor and the Moslem power in Egypt, and so assumes strategic importance in the war of the nations. Yet the Holy Land is a land embalmed in the spirit and customs of 3,000 years ago, according to a description of village life there as prepared by John D. Whiting for the National Geographic Society.

“Manners and customs which prevailed in Palestine in Biblical days are still unchanged. While the townspeople are losing their ancient customs and quaint costumes, the villagers are, in these things, as they were 3,000 years ago.

Three distinct classes inhabit the land: The Bedouin, a nomadic, war-loving race; the Fellaheen, agriculturists, shepherds and village-dwellers; and the Madaniyeh, who live in the towns and cities and are artisans.

Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.

CP-1915-007 →

· The Times Record

Ancient Customs

Which Still Prevail in Villages of Palestine

The latest land to have been brought within the rapidly expanded war area is that thin strip upon the eastern coast of the Mediterranean Sea, the Holy Land, sacred to the believers of three world-religions, to Christians, Jews and Moslems, and ground wherein were cradled ideals which have made almost all civilization tributary.

It is a bridge between the Moslem power in Asia Minor and the Moslem power in Egypt, and so assumes strategic importance in the war of the nations. Yet the Holy Land is a land embalmed in the spirit and customs of 3,000 years ago, according to a description of village life there as prepared by John D.

Whiting for the National Geographic Society: “Manners and customs which prevailed in Palestine in Biblical days are still unchanged. While the townspeople are losing their ancient customs and quaint costumes, the villagers are, in these things, as they were 3,000 years ago.

Three distinct classes inhabit the land: the Bedouin, a nomadic, war-loving race; the Fellaheen, agriculturists, shepherds and village-dwellers; and the Madaniyeh, who live in the towns and cities and are artisans. “The present-day villages are located, as a rule, either on the tops of hills, originally for protection, or near some spring or source of water.

Many are built upon the foundations of buildings whose origin dates back thousands of years. There does not exist a single example of a peasant village that has been founded in modern times. “Village streets are crooked, narrow and unpaved. The farmers’ houses are crowded close together for protection. These houses consist of one large room, usually square.

About two-thirds of the space within is devoted to a raised, masonry platform, some 8 to 10 feet above the ground, and this is the kitchen, store room, bed room and living room of the family. Below this platform, the cattle and flocks are housed, goats and sheep, a few work cattle, and perhaps a donkey or camel.

CP-1915-008 →

· The Daily Item

LITTLE CHANGE IN HOLY LAND IN LAST 3000 YEARS

Common People Live in Manner But Little Different From Biblical Times.

The latest land to have been brought within the rapidly expanded war area is that thin strip upon the eastern coast of the Mediterranean sea, the Holy Land, sacred to he believers of three world-religions, to Christians, Jews and Moslems, and ground wherein were cradled ideals which have made almost all civilization tributary.

It is a bridge between the Moslem power in Asia Minor and the Moslem power in Egypt, and so assumes strategic importance in the war of the nations. Yet the Holy Land is a land embalmed in the spirit and customs of 3000 years ago, according to a description of village life there as prepared by John D.

Whiting for the National Geographic society: “Manners and customs which prevailed in Palestine in Biblical days are still unchanged. While the townspeople are losing their ancient customs and quaint costumes, the villagers are, in these things, as they were 3000 years ago.

Three distinct classes inhabit the land—the Bedouin, a nomadic, war-loving race; the Fellaheen, agriculturists, shepherds and village-dwellers, and the Madaniyeh, who live in the towns and cities and are artisans. “The present-day villages are located, as a rule, either on the tops of hills, origanally for protection, or near some spring or source of water.

Many are built upon the foundations of buildings whose origin dates back thousands of years. There does not exist a single example of a peasant village that has been founded to modern times.

CP-1915-003 →

· Roanoke Times · Roanoke

PALESTINE PEASANT LIVES IN HUTS

Washington, Jan. 11.—The latest land to have been brought within the rapidly-expanded war area is that thin strip upon the eastern coast of the Mediterranean sea, the Holy Land, sacred to the believers of three world-religions—to Christians, Jews and Moslems—and ground wherein were cradled ideals which have made almost all civilization tributary.

It is a bridge between the Moslem power in Asia Minor and the Moslem power in Egypt, and so assumes strategic importance in the war of the nations. Yet the Holy Land is a land embalmed in the spirit and customs of 3,000 years ago, according to a description of village life there as prepared by John D.

Whiting for the National Geographic Society: “Manners and customs which prevailed in Palestine in Biblical days are still unchanged,” he writes. “While the townspeople are losing their ancient customs and quaint costumes, the villagers are, in these things, as they were 3,000 years ago.

Three distinct classes inhabit the land—the Fellaheen agriculturists, shepherds and village dwellers, and the Madaniyeh, who live in the towns and cities and are artisans. “The present-day villages are located, as a rule, either on the tops of hills, originally for protection, or near some spring or source of water.

Many are built upon the foundations of buildings whose origin dates back thousands of years. There does not exist a single example of a peasant village that has been founded in modern times.

CP-1915-006 →

· Washington Post

Welcome Kaiser to Islam

Palestine Natives Think Emperor Is Convert to Prophet’s Religion.

London, Feb. 6.—A dispatch to the Daily News from Cairo says, on the authority of a missionary who has arrived there, the Turkish military preparations point to apprehension of a British invasion of Palestine.

The hills around Nazareth, the correspondent says, the missionary told him have been fortified, and that roads suitable for the transport of heavy guns are being constructed from Acre, Syria, to Mount Carmel. There is a general belief among the natives still, according to the missionary, that Emperor William has been convertde to islam and will undertake a pilgrimage to Mecca.

Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.

CP-1915-009 →

· Washington Post

PALESTINE IN WASTE

What Shall Be Her Future? Is Ever-Rising Question. — ONCE OF “MILK AND HONEY” — Little Country Where Saviour Trod Now Mostly Neglected. — Movement Is Started in London to Oust Turk From Holy Places—New State, It Is Declared, Will Not Be Jewish, But Will Have Plenty of Room for All Hebrews Who Wish to Settle There—Two Policies Are at Hand.

London, Feb. 6.—“A land flowing with milk and honey”—thus was Palestine once, but today it is largely a waste. Will the present world struggle result in the new birth of the little country where the Saviour lived?

A movement has started here to oust the Turks from the holy places—Bethlehem, Jerusalem, Lebanon, and the Mount of Olives—when the Mohammedan masters and their German allies shall have been soundly beaten. This new state will not be Jewish, but will have plenty of room for all the Jews who wish to settle there. It will be tolerant toward all religions.

The country came under Turkish dominion in 1516, after the war between the Ottoman sultan and the Egyptian mamelukes, and thereafter for over 300 years the history of Palestine has been a record of sanguinary quarrels between the landed sheikhs, and of the oppression of the peasantry by them and by Turkish officials.

It was not until 1840 that the arbitrary power of the sheikhs was curbed. The Turks then began to strengthen their hold, and though much has been done for the betterment of the country, the blight of Ottoman government has continued to oppress it.

Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.

CP-1915-010 →

· The New York Times · New York · page 2

A FREE PALESTINE.

That Is Suggested as One of the Possibilities of the War.

DAVID STARR JORDAN

Stanford University, California, March 30, 1915. To the Editor of The New York Times: In the various efforts made in America for the relief of Europe, one suffering region has failed to receive the attention it deserves. This is Palestine. To the people of this region we owe the first escape from the absurdities of polytheistic belief.

To a Jewish ethical teacher we owe the foundation of Christianity, the religion which, whatever else it may be, rests primarily on the conception of good will among men, and the love of a Divine Father who counts all men as his children.

To the prophets of Palestine we owe the first broad conceptions of ethical principles which are the same for prince as for peasant, for families and for empires. The energetic, enduring, and devoted people of Palestine were subdued by the Roman Empire, and not long after definitely driven from their homes and scattered over the face of Europe.

This expulsion from the land of their fathers (A. D. 70) has left its mark on all Jewish history for almost nineteen hundred years.

The Jew has been a stranger in most of Europe, despised and restrained by unjust laws in many regions, driven into pauperism for lack of opportunity, or forced to use his superior keenness and initiative to take financial advantage (the only advantage possible) of his persecutors.

Only in the freer air of Western Europe and America, and in the freer air of the later centuries, has the Jew come to full recognition as a human being. These conditions of Jewish life have had certain effects on the race. Persecution, alternating with supplications for financial help, has made many Jews very poor, and a few others immensely rich.

Opportunity and initiative have given the Jewish race in recent years more than its share of scholars and of artists of creative skill. Persecution again has tended to keep the Jewish race relatively pure, and the physical and mental traits of a race so long outside the “melting pot” are in general prepotent over those of European races in general.

The identity of the Jewish religion with the Jewish race has been a strong factor in maintaining relative race purity. Yet the degree of this race purity has been exaggerated. The race in its historical beginning was mingled with other Semitic tribes, and the Jew in Europe in greater or less degree partakes of the quality of the nation in which he lives.

This is more than association. It means kinship in blood.

April 1915, two and a half years before Balfour. Free is doing something specific here: free of the Ottomans. What the freedom would mean for the people living there is not in the sentence, and the thing that might deliver it is the war.

CP-1915-001 →

· Dayton Daily News · Dayton

Farm Life In Palestine!

Read Before the Montgomery Co. Horticultural Society

Rev. R. A. Herbruck

THERE is properly speaking, no farm life in Palestine, as we know it in our land, and yet it is an agricultural country, the work being carried on by the Fellaheen or ploughman, as the name signifies. I did not realize this fact when I first looked about me in that country so remote from civilization and so financially clinging to customs of three thousand years ago.

One does not see solitary farm houses or cottages dotting the landscape as we see them whenever we leave our cities; there are no hedges, no ston walls, no ditches or fences of any kind except such as enclose gardens, orchards or vineyards. These are surrounded by hedges of the prickly pear and sometimes by rude stone walls.

The country people, the farmers and laborers, the rich and the poor, live together in unwalled villages and from these villages they go forth, some times many miles to cultivate the ground or reap the harvests. About the villages there is nothing that is attractive. There is no effort made by the people to beautify the vicinity by the planting of shrubbery or trees.

The houses generally are built of sundried blocks of clay; the streets are narrow and filthy, and the heat in the warm summer months can hardly be described. When one gets into the country, he discovers that the land is not marked off by division lines.

The roads skirt along the grainfields or pass right through them, and are so narrow that one can reach down from his horse as he passes along and pluck ears of wheat on either side. What would be considered a misdemeanor in our country is permitted over there. I refer to the matter of taking fruit from the trees or grain from the fields.

The traveler has the privilege of taking all that he can eat but dare not carry any away with him. It will be remembered that in the gospel we are told that the Pharisee found fault with the disciples of our Lord for plucking the ears of grain and eating them.

The protest was not against the appropriating of the grain but the fact that they took it on the Sabbath day which was regarded as reaping, and the rubbing of their hands together was looked upon as threshing, both of which acts, they said, implied labor and were unlawful on the Sabbath day.

Correction: Read off the scan by hand during a full check of all 93 clippings in this deck.

CP-1915-004 →

· Courier Post · Camden

The Tents of the Arabs

Longfellow wrote many popular lines, but few better known than “And the night shall be filled with music, And the cares that infest the day Shall fold their tents like the Arabs, And silently steal away.” It is not a remarkable stanza, but it caught the ear.

Sentimental young people chose it for their graduating essays and paragraphers referred to persons not scrupulous about rent or to those who lay hands on their neighbors’ fowls, as folding their tents like the Arabs, and as silently stealing away. Hard times in Palestine have caused many Arabs to start for North or South America.

Longfellow did not forecast the Arab pitching his tent near the Bronx, or on the shores of Lake Michigan, or along the Gulf of Mexico, or at the Panama-Pacific Exposition. Travel does not worry the Arab, but it may surprise him to learn there are communities in this republic which would bar out the camel while tolerating the swine.

Since the Jaffa and Jerusalem Railroad, we have grown used to the contemplation of Orientals traveling in Occidental style.

CP-1915-002 →

· Chicago Tribune · Chicago

Palestine and Patriotism

Current Comment Page · The National Sunday Magazine Section · A Reply to Rabbi Schulman, Opposing Zionism

By Louis D. Brandeis

“THE War of the Civilizations has directed fresh attention to the Zionist movement which of course, is not a movement to remove all the Jews of the world to Palestine. In the first place there are fourteen million Jews, and Palestine would not accommodate more than one-fifth of them. In the second place, it is not a movement to compel anyone to go to Palestine.

It is essentially a movement to encourage the Jews to exercise the same right now exercised by practically every other people in the world—to live at their option either in the land of their fathers or in some other country; a right which members of small nations as well as of large, Irish, Greek, Bulgarian, Servian or Belgian, may now exercise as fully as Germans or English.

Furthermore, Zionism is not a movement to wrest from the Ottoman the sovereignty of Palestine. The relation of the Turks to the Jews has been friendly.

Zionism merely seeks to establish in Palestine for such Jews as choose to go and remain there, and for their descendants, a legally secured home, where they may live together and lead a Jewish life; where they may expect ultimately to constitute a majority of the population, and may look forward to what we should call home rule… First: That Palestine is fit for the modern Jew.

Second: That the modern Jew is fit for Palestine. This land, long treeless and supposed to be sterile and hopelessly arid, has been shown to have been treeless and sterile only because of man’s misrule. It has been shown to be capable of becoming again a land ‘flowing with milk and honey.’

Oranges and grapes, olives and almonds, wheat and other cereals are now growing there in abundance… In a single generation the export of oranges increased from 60,000 boxes to 1,500,000… But as the Ghetto walls are falling Jewish life cannot be preserved and developed, assimilation cannot be averted, unless there be re-established in Palestine a centre, from which the Jewish spirit may radiate… To accomplish this, it is not necessary that the Jewish population of Palestine be large as compared with the whole number of Jews in the world… Furthermore—is it desirable that America should be practically the only country to which the Jews of Eastern Europe may emigrate after this war?

Is it not desirable that Palestine should give a special welcome to the Jews, as the Zionists propose?”

A future justice of the Supreme Court, writing in a Sunday magazine supplement in January 1916, twenty-two months before the Balfour Declaration, over his own signature. Two sentences are worth reading slowly. The aim is a legally secured home, where they may live together and lead a Jewish life; where they may expect ultimately to constitute a majority of the population. And the land was sterile only because of man’s misrule. The people whose misrule is meant, and against whom the majority would be counted, are not named anywhere in the essay. The orange figure he cites — 60,000 boxes to 1,500,000 — is the same export trade a California paper had reported in 1901 as a Palestinian business (CP-1901-001). The page is shared with an advertisement for hair color restorer.

CP-1916-001 →

· The Daily Item · Lynn · page 5

The Zionist Movement In Palestine

Interesting Discussion of Its Phases by a Leader Recently Escaped From Turkish Prison

“‘The Zionist movement in not of the moment, it is historical, and as long as we continue to live in history we will seek to develop a home for which a foundation has already been laid which has not been destroyed by the war,’ declared Zueibluvel, the Zionist leader of Palestine who has been banished by the Turkish government for taking an active part for his stand in the establishment of the Jews as an independent nation… ‘The economic conditions in Palestine are very severe,’ said the speaker.

‘The government has taken possession of the cattle and all productions for war purposes so that the colony is unable to carry on its work.

Grasshoppers, which have existed in Palestine for many years, reappeared this year and destroyed the plants and trees to the extent of 5,000,000 francs.’… ‘It was insinuated by many that money sent for the Jews in Palestine were also distributed among the Arabians,’ said Mr. Zueibluvel.

This is not true for the American consul ordered that it should be turned over where it was specifically stated it should be. But a ship load of food and medical supplies which was sent by the American Jews was given to all the colonies, including the Arabians because it was collected with that understanding.

He explained why the Turkish government has become aligned against the Zionists in Palestine, and said that it was because all the nationalities in Turkey are seeking to establish independent states while the war is going on.

Arabians who established themselves as an independent state under France were killed by the Turkish government, while many Jewish advocates who have been interested in the Zionist movement have been banished said the speaker.”

A lecture reported at length in a Lynn, Massachusetts daily in March 1916, reported at length. The word for the Palestinians here is the Arabians, and they appear twice. Once as an insinuation to be denied — that relief money for Jews was also going to them — and once as people who did receive a shipload of food and medicine, because it had been collected on that understanding. And once more, at the end, as a nationality that tried to establish an independent state and was killed for it. Three appearances, all of them in someone else’s sentence about something else.

CP-1916-002 →

· Evening Public Ledger · Philadelphia

$1,000,000 Corporation To Conduct Colony Of Zionists In Palestine

Resolution Unanimously Adopted at the Closing Session of Federation’s Convention · PLEA FOR WAR VICTIMS

“A plan to form a $1,000,000 corporation to colonize Palestine after the war is over and thus make the place a haven for Jews of the entire world was recommended in a resolution unanimously adopted this afternoon at the closing session of the 19th annual convention of the Federation of American Zionists at the Hotel Walton.

Today’s action caused considerable enthusiasm among those attending the convention, in view of the fact that it follows quickly the announcement yesterday of the proposed establishment of a Jewish colony in Palestine, to be financed by Mrs.

Joseph Fels, who is devoting her life to furthering the cause of single tax… The stock of the proposed corporation, advocated in the resolution, is to be subscribed by the Jews of the United States… Fully 5000 persons in Palestine are facing starvation since the war, according to Dr.

Levin Epstein, of New York, who in a forceful plea asked the convention to increase its subscription for the war relief in Palestine from $30,000 to $54,000. He said that much was needed annually, and there were 1000 families in want. The Jews there, he said, are helped by getting the opportunity to help themselves.

They are given employment, and if the money received is insufficient for their needs loans are made to be paid after the war.”

A corporation with a capital figure, a stock subscription, a board and a plan, reported as business news in Philadelphia in July 1916. The verb in the first sentence is colonize and the noun in the headline is colony, neither of them hedged, sixteen months before Balfour. What the money is for is set out twice over: a colony, and relief for five thousand people facing starvation. The people already living in the country are not a party to either, and the last sentence is about loans repayable after the war.

CP-1916-004 →

· estimated · The New York Times · New York

ZIONISTS AID PALESTINE.

Federation to Maintain a Hospital Unit in the Holy Land.

PHILADELPHIA, July 5.—The Federation of American Zionists at its closing sessions trday discussed plans for more thorough organization of relief work for suffering Jews abroad than those in effect at present.

The convention indorsed the plan of the Palestine Committee of the Federation to undertake the organization of a corporation with capital stock of $1,000,000 for the purpose of aiding Jewish colonies in Palestine and developing the resources of the Holy Land. The expenditure of $25,000 annually for the maintenance of a hospital unit in Palestine was approved.

Miss Henrietta Szold, President of the Hadassah, the women’s organization affiliated with the governing body, told the delegates that the European war had created a demand for physicians and nurses and that it remained with the American Zionists to provide a hospital unit, to be wholly American, and ready to start for Palestine in September.

An advisory board of physicians had been organized for the purpose of judging the qualifications of the physicians and nurses who will compose the unit, she said. Officers were elected at the final session as follows: Dr. Harry F. Friendenwald, Baltimore, President; Louis Lipsky, New York, Chairman of the Executive Committee; Louis Robinson, New York, Treasurer, and Bernard A.

Rosenblatt, New York, Honorary Secretary.

Date check: No masthead appears on this clipping — it is a trimmed single column with rules on both sides. The dateline reads "PHILADELPHIA, July 5.", one day before the slide date of 1916-07-06, which is the normal gap for a wire story. The year cannot be verified from the image.

CP-1916-007 →

· El Paso Herald · El Paso

Church Reports Show Many Thousands Killed By Turks

In Northern Palestine 60,000 Have Been Butchered and Throughout Palestine and Armenia More Than 500,000 Have Been Killed; The Conditions in the Holy Land Are Hopeless and Many Become Insane.

“THROUGH church channels comes the first authentic information concerning Palestine and Armenia conditions obtainable from these war-ridden states in months. The names of the sources of information cannot be given, owing to war conditions, but the reliability of the news cannot be questioned.

Figures published here within a fortnight, that in northern Palestine 60,000 to 80,000 people have been murdered by the Turks, or starved to death by them, and questioned here, are now known to be accurate…

500,000 Butchered or Starved. Throughout Palestine and Armenia it is now known that 500,000 persons have been butchered, hanged or starved and that in addition to this number of dead fully 1,000,000 have been deported. These deportations have been invariably toward the east, where new homes are impossible.

Deportations now as in times past are equivalent to murder… The Turkish government has prohibited relief of every kind from being given by foreigners. It has even shut off all relief from the Red Cross. Its enmity extends, not to Armenians alone but to those who speak the Arabic tongue.

The 1,500,000 dead and dying are, therefore, Armenians, Moslems of Arabic descent, and Jews. The few Americans have not been molested, and are known to be well at this time… As always happens, a new terror is added to murder and starvation. It is thousands going mad, and not only harming themselves but harming others.

This danger is at the moment appallingly prevalent throughout all Palestine. Locusts are known to have stung the olives and ruined the crop. Scarcely a person has been able to get out of Palestine for months.”

One sentence in the middle of this is why it is here. The paper reports that Ottoman enmity extends, not to Armenians alone but to those who speak the Arabic tongue, and then counts the dead and dying as three groups together: Armenians, Moslems of Arabic descent, and Jews. In 1916, in El Paso, the Arabic-speaking population of Palestine is inside the number, named, and grieved over in the same sentence as everyone else. The column runs beside an advertisement for a cold remedy.

CP-1916-005 →

· Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery

Zionistic Movement Hopes To Re-establish the Jews As a Nation in Palestine

Noted Lecturer Discusses Effect of Present European War on Realization of These Hopes · Beginning of Movement · The Present Leaders · Favored By England · Many Resources · Form Not Considered · Very Enthusiastic

“An interesting account of the origin of the modern Zionistic movement, the success which it has achieved up to the present time, and the prospects for the ultimate triumph of the idea, is given by Philip M.

Raskin, the celebrated Zionistic leader… ‘We have received definite assurances from England that she will favor the national aspirations of the Jewish race,’ said Mr. Raskin.

‘England does not want to see a powerful military nation installed in Palestine, so near to Egypt and the Suez canal, in a region which is at the junction of, and is the key to Europe, Asia and Africa.

If the allies win it probably will be the end of Turkey, but the beginning of a new Jewish state… Turkey knows that Palestine must be occupied by some one, and like England would prefer the Jews to a rival nation, and the German emperor is known to favor the project.’

Many Resources. ‘Jewish colonization has proven that Palestine is still a land “flowing with milk and honey,”’ said Mr. Raskin, ‘and suffering only from lack of exploitation.

In addition to the 110,000 Jews, the population of the land consists of only about 300,000 Arab nomads, who have made no attempt to develop its natural resources.’

The boundaries of the new Jewish state of Palestine will be the same as those of David’s kingdom—from the border of Egypt to the river Euphrates, and from the Mediterranean to the Syrian desert…

Form Not Considered. With regard to the form of government to be employed in the new state, Mr. Raskin declared that the movement at present is to seek the establishment of the Jewish race in Palestine, and that the question of national political independence would come later…

Very Enthusiastic. ‘The Jewish nation, settled in its original home on the borders of Africa and Asia… will form the outpost of civilization on the edge of two great and uncivilized continents…’”

Montgomery, Alabama, eleven months before the Balfour Declaration, and nothing in it is inferred. The country is suffering only from lack of exploitation. The people already there are counted — only about 300,000 Arab nomads — and the sentence that counts them says what they are for: they have made no attempt to develop its natural resources. The proposed borders run from Egypt to the Euphrates. The form of government is explicitly deferred: first the establishment, then the question of independence. And the purpose is stated as an outpost of civilization on the edge of two great and uncivilized continents. Five years earlier a syndicated American correspondent had spent a full page on those same people plowing, threshing and keeping sheep in folds (CP-1911-002).

CP-1916-006 →

· The New York Times · New York · page 10

Palestine Not a Solution of Jewish Problem

Zionism Has No Positive Message to Jews in America—Preservation of Hebraic Spirit Needed Rather than Separate Nationality

By Henry Moskowitz

ZIONISM, in the last twenty-five years, has become one of the most articulate Jewish weapons directed against anti-Semitism As such, it has been a barometer of the progress anti-Semitism has made in various lands. Whenever a pogrom takes place the adherents of Zionism increase in number.

If there is a lull in the anti-Semitic movement, Zionism registers that lull by a loss in aggressive strength. After the pogrom in 1881 the Zionist movement as a political force received great impetus. Even in America the tragedy of Kishineff brought many unsynagogued Jews into the racial fold.

The sufferings of Israel gave even the agnostic and radical Jew a consciousness of kind from which the Zionist and Nationalist movement gained. This movement became the refuge of many Jews to whom Judaism as a religious message had ceased to appeal. Zionism as a political weapon against anti-Semitism has always represented a minority in Israel.

For the purposes of clear thinking we must consider Zionism, first, as a solution to the general Jewish problem; second, as a movement which can satisfy the soul of the Jew; third, as a limited experiment for the purpose of establishing Jewish colonies and a Jewish cultural centre; and fourth, the message of Zionism, if it has any, to the Jews of America. […] From a practical point of view the existence of Palestine as a home land will not solve the problem except as a refuge for those Jewish dreamers who will consecrate themselves to make their Jewish dreams come true.

But they are not the only dreamers. The dreamers of Israel have lived and suffered and have made their Jewish dreams come true for the world without a Jewish State, and they will still exist. […] To the Jews of America Zionism has no positive message. The American Jew is nationally an American only.

He is thrilled by one flag, which symbolizes the ideals of a democracy in which men and women of all races have joined together to make government of the people, for the people, and by the people a success. […] My conclusion, finally, is that Jewish nationalism as a philosophy of life is not satisfactory; that it is reactionary; that it leads to a racial egotism and that it does not conduce to profound moral and spiritual but rather to romantic emotions.

The New York Times Magazine, June 1917, five months before the Balfour Declaration, arguing against the project on its own front. The objection is about what Jews in America need, and it is printed at feature length. Palestine appears in the headline as a proposed solution being declined, not as a place with anyone in it.

CP-1917-001 →

· The Baltimore Sun · Baltimore · page 1

PLANS IDEAL PALESTINE

Achooza Corporation Lays Land System Before Zionists. SPECULATION IS PROHIBITED. Jewish Congress To Be Asked To Give $5,000,000 To Aid In Colonization Scheme.

“PLANS IDEAL PALESTINE. Achooza Corporation Lays Land System Before Zionists. SPECULATION IS PROHIBITED. Jewish Congress To Be Asked To Give $5,000,000 To Aid In Colonization Scheme.” “The Achooza, the Palestine Company organized under the laws of New York, yesterday morning laid its plans for the realization of Zionists' ideals upon the table at the Academy of Music.” Mrs.

Joseph Fels of New York “spoke on the advisability of a single tax for the colonies of Palestine.” “Purchasers of land certificates who settle in the colonies must use the land for agricultural purposes.” “Jewish soldiers, who at the close of the war will have no homes to return to, will be granted the privilege of settling upon the lands of Palestine.

These soldiers, according to present plans, will comprise an agricultural army.”

Colonization in the subheading, colonies in the body, in the Baltimore Sun in 1917.

Correction: {'pub': 'The Baltimore Sun', 'date': '1917-06-27', 'note': 'two captions arrived swapped; the content is from the First World War (Jewish soldiers “who at the close of the war will have no homes to return to”, American Jewish Congress)'}

CP-1917-002 →

· San Antonio Express News · San Antonio · page 28

WAR TANKS WHERE SAMSON LIFTED GATES OF GAZA

Modern War on Spot Where Samson, the Strongest Man, Did Stunts When World Was Young. Big Shells on Hagar’s Well and Blowing Up the Beer-Sheba Railroad—Scenes of Old Bible Story Where Abraham Received the Three Angels, Solomon Met the Queen of Sheba and Philip Met the Eunuch.

STERLING HEILIG

MARSEILLES, July 8.—I have information from a party who knows Gaza.

At last hearing the British, in a raid of Camel Corps, mounted troops, desert column and field engineers, blew up the railroad to Beer-Sheba—“not a length of rail remained whole, not a railroad tie intact, and not a bolt without its head knocked off”—so that the Turks, who had great need of railroad material and were hastily tearing up the road to build a new line back of Gaza, “could not find a sound rail or sleeper!”

He is a Frenchman, learned in the languages, who rendered service to the English and knows everything about the wonderful old Bible land here. Also, there is a woman. I can name her without mentioning her work, for she is a great friend of mine—the celebrated Myriam Harry, who was brought up in Jerusalem and the Sinnai Peninsula.

Do not these names bring things home to your childhood?

Think, there is not a bald-headed American business man today but who pored over (as a little boy, of Sunday afternoons) the steel engraved plates of the family Bible—pictures of Hagar and her child in the wilderness, of Abraham receiving the three angels, and of Samson, the strongest man, carrying off the gates of Gaza on his back!

“Samson Carrying Off the Gates of Gaza.” This is one of the most famous steel-engraved plates of the old American family Bibles, published between 18[illegible]0 and 18[illegible]0.

Probably there is not one American-born business man today in ten who did not, as a boy (of Sunday afternoons, or of long winter evenings in the old homestead) pore over this picture of the strongest man doing his second greatest stunt. (He is carrying the gates up Samson Ridge, as it is called, still, today. Yesterday, an English “tank” went up there!)

Date check: the masthead reads SAN ANTONIO EXPRESS: SUNDAY MORNING, JULY 22, 1917., with the page number 28 at the left. This matches `pub` and the slide date of 1917-07-22, and July 22, 1917 was a Sunday.

CP-1917-010 →

· The New York Times · New York · page 9

JEWISH SOCIALISTS FOR FREE PALESTINE

Appeal to Brethren Here and in Russia to Oppose Anything That Hinders Allies, Who Aid It.

July 1917. Free Palestine again, four months before Balfour, and here it is Jewish socialists asking other Jews to back the Allies because the Allies back it. The freedom in the phrase is freedom from the Ottomans; whose country it would be afterwards is not a question the headline has to answer.

CP-1917-003 →

· The American Jewish World · Minneapolis

Turkish Jews Opposed to Zionism.

“The Chief Rabbi of Turkey sent an open letter to the government in which he disavows any relationship of the Jews of Turkey with the plans for a Jewish state in Palestine which is advocated by Jews of Russia and of America.”

Eight weeks before the Balfour Declaration. Not American or European Jews weighing assimilation, but the Jews already living under the sovereignty the plan proposed to break up — and their Chief Rabbi, in an open letter to his own government.

CP-1917-007 →

· estimated · Pittsburgh Post-Gazette · Pittsburgh

Gaza and Beersheba, Ancient Places, Taken By Modern New Armies

By MARION H. DAMPMAN

IN war no place is holy ground. Even Palestine, that has seemed to the modern traveler a place only for pilgrimages and a country to be held in reverence, now resounds to the armed warriors’ feet. The Australian and New Zealand troops have taken Gaza and Beersheba in their offensive against the Turks.

The contrast of the ancient and the modern in those names “Gaza and Beersheba” in juxtaposition with “Australians and New Zealanders” is unusual and striking.

So new to civilization are the latter peoples that their armies springing up mushroom-like in this ancient land is as wonderful as some of the miracles that were performed on this same soil ages ago.

It was at Gaza, nearly [number illegible] years ago, that Joshua smote the Amorites; and that he might do it effectually the sun stood still a whole day; “and he smote them from Kadesh-Barnea even unto Gaza.”

In the charge made November [day illegible] the movement was accomplished by moonlight and was a complete surprise to the Turks, who were “caught napping” and overwhelmed. In modern warfare the sun’s light is not so necessary as it was in Joshua’s day.

FAMILIAR SCENE IN GAZA | Drawing water from a cistern.

Date check: No masthead and no date line appear on this scan — the clipping begins at the article’s own headline. The slide date of 1917-11-18 cannot be confirmed or contradicted from the image. The article refers to a charge "made November [day illegible]", consistent with a mid-November 1917 publication.

CP-1917-009 →

· Evening Capital News · Boise

IN PALESTINE.

“Palestine has always been renowned for its vines and grapes, the climate, soils and other conditions being much the same as ours. Numbers xiii, 23, refers to bunches of grapes which required two men to carry them, and in Psalm 80 David speaks of a vine figuratively that covered the hill and had boughs like the goodly cedars.”

Sixty-four words, three weeks after the Balfour Declaration. No people, no politics, no mention that the country had just been promised to somebody. The climate is compared to Idaho’s. A country turned into a growing region and a Bible reference, in the month its future was being decided, for readers who grew fruit.

CP-1917-006 →

· The New York Times · New York · page 3

JEWISH NATION NOT WANTED IN PALESTINE

The Views of Those Who Are Opposed to Zionism Expressed by a Leading American Rabbi.

Three weeks after the Balfour Declaration, in the New York Times, as a plain statement across two lines. The line beneath makes clear whose views they are and that a leading American rabbi is expressing them. This is the earliest of the Jewish anti-Zionist headlines in this archive from after the declaration, and it ran as news rather than as controversy.

CP-1917-004 →

· Miles City Star · Miles City

HEBRON, PALESTINE, OCCUPIED BY BRITISH

London, Dec. 7—General Allenby reports that he has occupied the town of Hebron, in Palestine, the British war office announces tonight. Ancient Hebron, is situated about twenty miles southwest of Jerusalem with approximately 15,000 inhabitants. Tradition identifies it as the site of the tombs of Abraham and other patriarchs.

King David resided there the first seven years of his reign.

The place name is set in the headline, in capitals, as an ordinary geographic fact. The same London dispatch ran in the Democrat and Chronicle of Rochester on the same day under a different headline, Allenby Occupies Hebron, Palestine. Neither paper was making a point about the name. It was what the town was called.

CP-1917-005 →

· estimated · The Star Press · Muncie

WAR ON IN CITY OF SCISSOR STAR

Delilah, Who Cut Tresses of Late Mr. Samson, Lived in Captured Town. A TYPICAL ARAB VILLAGE

London, Dec. 15.—Until the capture of Beersheba and Gaza, the largest and most important village in Palestine, the British expeditionary force had hitherto occupied Kara Yunis, says the Manchester Guardian’s correspondent with the Egyptian forces.

The name translated becomes simply John’s Tavern, and here there must have been from of old a halting place on the great caravan route from Egypt to Syria. The village lies midway between Rafa, our border town, and Gaza, separated from the sea by two or three miles of rolling sand dunes.

Around it on every side is a belt of trees and orchards a mile or more in depth, and the water which makes possible this sudden blossoming of the plain is pumped from ancient wells lying in the midst of its lands.

Date check: No masthead and no date line appear on this scan. The dateline reads "London, Dec. 15.", one day before the slide date of 1917-12-16, which is the normal gap for a cabled story. The year cannot be verified from the image.

CP-1917-011 →

· estimated · Birmingham Post Herald · Birmingham

Palestine the Key To the Possesion of Europe

Famous Authority on the Holy Land Tells Why It Must Never Be Given Back to the Turks, and Advocates an Autonomous Palestine Under British Protection, With Careful Guarantees of Religious and Economic Freedom.

By BASIL MATTHEWS

London, December 6.—(Special Correspondence.)—A shining oasis in the desert of British unpreparedness for war was the fact—hitherto, I believe unpublished—that a few weeks before the war broke out a British survey was completed of the hitherto unmapped district between the Egyptian survey and the old Palestine exploration fund survey of Palestine.

The maps were finished but not printed. The result is that in the present brilliant campaign General Allenby has perfect maps of every wady and spring of the desert between Palestine and Egypt, while those in the hands of the Turko-German forces are relatively incomplete and inaccurate. In this work of Palestinian exploration and survey Wr.

Masterman of Jerusalem, took a continuous and active part. His knowledge at once of the country’s history, present condition and of the amazing blend of races that inhabit Palestine is unsurpassed. It was a joy to me, some months before war broke out, to go over the highly efficient hospital that Dr.

Masterman has been developing and controlling for some years in Jerusalem.

Date check: No masthead and no date line appear on this scan. The dateline reads "London, December 6.—(Special Correspondence.)", twenty-four days before the slide date of 1917-12-30; that gap is plausible for mailed special correspondence rather than cable. The year cannot be verified from the image.

CP-1917-008 →

· estimated · Tulsa Tribune · page TWO

Palestine, Truly Home Of the Jews, Should Be Kept From Turks

LONDON, Jan. 5.—A shining oasis in the desert of British unpreparedness for war was the fact—hitherto, I believe unpublished—that a few weeks before the war broke out a British survey was completed of the hitherto uninappd district between the Egyptian survey and the old Palestine Exploration Fund Survey of Palestine. The maps were finished but not printed.

The result is that in the present brilliant campaign Gen. Allenby has perfect maps of every wady and spring of the desert between Palestine and Egypt, while those in the hands of the Turko-German forces are relatively incomplete and inaccurate. In this work of Palestine exploration and survey Dr. Masterman of Jerusalem took a continuous and active part.

His knowledge of the country’s history, present condition, and of the amazing blend of races that inhabit Palestine in unsurpassed.

Date check: No masthead appears on this scan; the page is labelled TWO at the top left. The dateline reads "LONDON, Jan. 5.", the same day as the slide date of 1918-01-05. The year cannot be verified from the image.

CP-1918-010 →

· Bellingham Herald · Bellingham · page 1

British Forces Make Advance In Palestine

London

LONDON, Feb. 15. — The British forces in Palestine yesterday made an advance of two miles on a front of six miles northeast of Jerusalem, the war office announces.

A two-sentence war-office bulletin. Nobody who lives in Palestine appears in it.

CP-1918-001 →

· Freeport Journal-Standard · Freeport · page 1

British Forces Capture Nablus

United Press Leased Wire, London

“London, March 4.—Astride of the westward road leading from Jerusalem to Nablus, Gen Allenby’s forces advanced a maximum depth northward of three thousand yards on a 12 mile front Saturday and Sunday, it was officially announced today. The enemy offered little opposition. Nablus, 33 miles north of Jerusalem is a city of about 25,000 population.

It is the ancient center of the Samaritans and in biblical times was called Shechem. Jacob’s well was located nearby.”

The headline says the city was captured. The story says the line moved three thousand yards toward a city thirty-three miles away, and the paragraph under it gives Nablus a population of twenty-five thousand.

CP-1918-002 →

· estimated · Indianapolis Star · Indianapolis

Flaneur’s Letter.

FLANEUR

THERE are other inhabitants in Palestine besides the Jews. The most numerous element are the Arabs. Most of them are Moslems, but whether Moslem or “infidel,” they have no liking for Turkish misrule. Strangers are astonished at the attitude of detachment shown by the Arabs toward the Turks.

Both are alike Moslems, but the Arab considers himself superior in intelligence. Between the attitude of the Turk and Arab toward their religion the difference is great. Though the Arab of Syria does not possess the fiery fervor of his brother of the desert, he takes his religion seriously.

It is an Arab religion, born of his country and race; its sacred books are in his language. The Turk, on the other hand, is a central Asiatic; his race has never produced a religion or even a heresy; he becomes conservative to what he has received, never questions its truth. But he remains a Turanian.

While the Arabs have produced many forms of dissent, it can hardly be said that the Turks have even invented a heresy. The Arab independence of views, as shown among the Wahabees, the Senussi (the most powerful of the Bedouins) and other dissenters, has always taken the form of returning to the simplicity of the early faith.

The result of the divergence of attitude between Arab and Turk has been to increase their mutual hostility.

Date check: No masthead and no date line appear on this scan — it is a single trimmed column headed by the standing head "Flaneur’s Letter." in a box. The slide date of 1918-03-14 cannot be confirmed or contradicted from the image.

CP-1918-009 →

· The New York Times · New York · page 11

SEES ROOM FOR FEW IN PALESTINE COLONY

Viscount Bryce Finds Country Able to Support Not More Than 300,000 Additional Souls. · MIGHT GAIN BY IRRIGATION · With Large Capital Expenditure Water Could Be Had to Make Land Serve 600,000.

A British statesman putting a ceiling on it in 1918: room for 300,000 more, or 600,000 with a great deal of money spent on water. Twenty-three years later a Buffalo paper printed the legal adviser of the Jewish Agency saying the country could take three million (CP-1941-001), and quoting an unnamed British official’s earlier estimate only to laugh at it. This is the kind of estimate he meant. Neither headline mentions the people already living there; the word in this one is colony.

CP-1918-003 →

· estimated · The Sun · Baltimore

The Return Of The Jews And Their Lawful Right To Palestine

J. G. Wiltshire, Baltimore, Md.

“The Return Of The Jews And Their Lawful Right To Palestine. To the Editor of The Sun—Sir: In this history-making epoch one need not be a prophet to forecast the future of the Jews and Palestine—a subject of increasing interest to the Christians of the world today.

In studying it the principles of my narrative must be taken collectively; they are so correlated that they cannot be separated without destroying the identity of both. Cast your eye upon the horizon of events as they are rapidly occurring in the world and you will readily see how the prophecies to Abraham as recorded in Holy Writ are being fulfilled to the letter.

See Genesis, xv, 18, and read: ‘Unto thy seed have I given the land from the Nile to the Euphrates.’

Look on your map and you will see that the deed thus recorded corresponds with Palestine—a country consisting of fertile soil, through which the mutual commerce of trade of the near East and West passed in olden times, and through which it will pass again should the Jews colonize Palestine.

In studying this question it may be of interest to note the genesis, development and character of the Jewish people. Most of the students of Jewish history content themselves with the idea that the Jews are descendants of Abraham.

They are in a sense, but Abraham’s roots reach back into antediluvian soil, reaching out with their rootlets, as by destiny, to embrace the world, carrying with them the religion intrusted to their fathers 3,000 years ago.

They have been a persecuted people for many years, but inasmuch as the rapidly occurring events in the Holy Land point to a divinity at work on the second dramatic act in the history of the Jewish people—their return pilgrimage to the ford across the Jordan—I shall spare them the pain of referring to the causes of the evil arrows of pestilence that were sent into their homes, so poignantly given in Jeremiah.

Refined in the furnace of affliction, although having no nationality, they have developed into a strong and useful people in the solution of political, social and economic questions of the countries in which they reside, and today are fighting gallantly for civil and religious liberty of the world.

Preferring to live alone, they have chosen few people other than their own, thus preserving their racial characteristics to this day.

The thing that lends the brightest coloring to their history is their united respect for their women, whom they have preserved and gallantly protected all these years of wandering, holding up virtue to them as a pearl of great price in one’s character, without which the evil hour must come (the saddest of them all), the burial robes put on and the coffin lowered into the grave from sight forever.

Ye, gentiles, gather this valuable lesson to your bosom and let us throw around our women that protection for which we were created, or the clods of the valley will fall on our coffins and our graves be closed forever.

I find I am digressing—let’s get back to our text: ‘I will bring again the captivity of my people of Israel and they shall build the waste cities, and they shall plant vineyards and gardens, and I shall plant them upon their land and they shall no more be pulled up out of their land, which I have given them.’

Not that God said: ‘He will bring the captivity of my people again, and they shall not be rooted up any more.’

As one who has been removed from the land of his nativity, carrying with him the sweet memories of his childhood, on returning to the scenes of his early delights sits under the old oak that sheltered him in his youth and calls up this sweet memory and another, so have the Jews clung to the traditions of their fathers and the hopes that were born of God’s promise to give to Abraham Palestine 2,700 years ago.

Though exiled… and forbidden ownership of these lands by the Sultan of Turkey, they can be seen mounting the peaks around Jerusalem to catch a glimpse of their old camp ground. This is their center of gravity, and so sacred is it to all Christians that many knightly sacrifices have been made at various times to rescue it from the enemies of Christianity, but in vain.

The knightly Cœur de Lion’s crusade against the Saracens proved to be a disaster to his fond hopes to restore that holy spot to the Christians; you will recall how he, as by the irony of fate, was recalled to England through political intrigue at home after the battle of Askalon. The time for the restoration of Palestine to the Jews had not come.

What Cœur de Lion failed to do in 1192 Allenby did in 1917, thus opening the gates of Palestine to all who care to enter their promised land.

The establishment of Jewry in Palestine means the formation of a government at Jerusalem (I would suggest under the protection of England and the United States) at the head of which strong men will stand, whose influence will be potent for good at the peace conference that we hope for in the interest of the peace of the world. This is as far as we can see at present.

We can but sit on the hilltop of expectancy and watch for the coming act in the drama of events. In a confidential talk with His disciples the Saviour said: ‘When the Jews have returned to Jerusalem I will come again.’ He is the Messiah for whom the Jews have been praying for past centuries.

Before closing my paper allow me to make a timely suggestion: Egypt was cruel to Judea, which so displeased God that He avenged the wrongs done her people by leading them through the Red Sea and causing its waters to destroy the pursuing army.

Egypt is no more—wrapped in fine linen, her Pharaohs have long since been laid away in their pyramids, while Judea still lives and is forging on to the mark of her high calling. J. G. WILTSHIRE. Baltimore, Md.”

A reader’s letter in a Baltimore paper, arguing the case on scriptural grounds and in the vocabulary of law: a lawful right. The argument is addressed to Christians and rests on prophecy, and the government it proposes for Jerusalem is one under the protection of England and the United States.

Correction: {'pub': 'The Sun', 'note': 'addressed “To the Editor of The Sun”, not the Philadelphia Inquirer as captioned'}

CP-1918-008 →

· The Jewish Daily News · page 1

The Modern Protest Rabbis

“The Dispatch sent by Rabbi Ephraim Frisch of the New Synagogue, this city, to President Wilson, protesting against his endorsement of Zionism, is similar to the protest of the rabbis twenty-two years ago, when Herzl called together the first Zionist Congress.

The few reform rabbis who have gained their knowledge of Judaism from German-Jewish reformers, or better said, assimilators, are very ill advised when they—as Rabbi Frisch, their spokesman, did—assailed the loyalty of American Zionists… With the exception of one or two, the others are blatant ignoramuses; and, which is worse, they absolutely decline to learn.

They are theorists, and like all theorists, refuse to face facts squarely and honestly. We grant them the right to their opinion, but when they tell the President that the loyalty of Zionists is to be questioned, then they stand before the world branded as miserable slanderers… President Wilson does not need to be told who is loyal. He knows Louis D.

Brandeis; he knows Julian W. Mack; he knows Stephen S. Wise; he knows Felix Frankfurter… No one will doubt the Americanism and loyalty of Theodore Roosevelt. He, too, has endorsed a Jewish State in Palestine. What unutterable impertinence on the part of these rabbis! Chutzpah is their long suit, their stock and trade.

Representing a dying minority, they want to make the world believe that their voice is the voice of American Israel. They are fooling no one but themselves. There will be a Jewish State in Palestine, protest rabbis or no protest rabbis… For twenty-five years and more the Zionist Movement has gone on, growing from strength to strength.

Where are the protest-rabbis of those days? Where the modern protest-rabbis will be. They are forgotten; they were execrated. History repeats itself.”

1918, in a New York Yiddish daily with English pages: the Zionist answer to the rabbis who wrote to Wilson against Zionism, printed as a front-page editorial. The archive carries the anti-Zionist letters; this is what was said back, in the same decade, at the same volume.

CP-1918-006 →

· The New Republic · New York · page 1

Zionism and Palestinian Natives

Correspondence: David Philipson, Cincinnati, Ohio, and Jacob De Haas

David Philipson, of Cincinnati: “I fear the separatist nationalistic movement among Jews known as Zionism has led you to this conclusion.

But let me remind you that there are any number of Jews in the United States who have no conscious separatist solidarity other than a religious solidarity and a solidarity of sympathy with their suffering co-religionists abroad… This is our homeland.”

Under the heading “Zionism and Palestinian Natives,” Jacob De Haas answers, quoting the British declaration of November 2, 1917: “nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country,” and the Zionists of America in convention at Pittsburgh, June 25, 1918: “First: We declare for political and civil equality irrespective of race, sex or faith, of all the inhabitants of the Land.”

An argument between Jewish Americans about Zionism, printed as correspondence three weeks after the Armistice. The first letter runs on from the previous page and carries no heading of its own; the heading recorded here is the one over the reply.

CP-1918-004 →

· The New York Times · New York

AMERICANISM VS. ZIONISM

Many American Jews Unsympathetic to a Political Homeland in Palestine, Says Former Attorney General of New York

THE NEW YORK TIMES, SUNDAY. DECEMBER 22, 1918. + AMERICANISM VS. ZIONISM Usias satisnalien It there were Many American Jews Unsympathetic to a Political.

Homeland in Palestine, Says A Bracing Christmas Crippled Children Here Tals ver ta calling attention to de Out of some 8,000 survivors of the Infantile Paralysis Epidemic under our care more than one-quarter now can use their limbs as The continua- lies taver well as ever, and others are coming along finely. tion of this work is dependent entirely on voluntary contributions. $60,000 Is Needed.

Every Little Bt Helps This Is a Christmas Appeal for Crippled Children Every dollar will be used for braces and treatments New York Committee on After Care of Infantile Paralyoio Caoco Sir. Wale fleeta Deser 289 FOURTH AVENUE He De bar Nr. Holart T5. de Fares! NEW YORK We Alice de wak TELEPHOSE. INS GAMEST Remember Tiny Tim and Bob Cratchil, the s

CP-1918-007 →

· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha · page 12

Arabs Fear Zionists Menace in Palestine

Grand Mufti Explains Foreigners “Too Progressive” for Backward Natives. · Says Would Have Same Distrust of Americans or Englishmen.

By Marion Weinstein

“Jerusalem, Feb. 10.—Up the rocky path that skirts the foot of Mount Olivet I climbed to the home of the Grand Mufti, the head of the Moslems of all Palestine. I wanted to learn from their spiritual leader how the 500,000 Arabs here view the future of the Holy land.

The Grand Mufti, I was told by representatice men of all three faiths in Jerusalem, could speak for his people. For ten years he had been their patriarch, as his father was for forty-five years and his grandfather and great-grandfather before him.

Though a heavily branched family tree, they said, he traced his descent straight from Mohammed… We passed into the dim parlor of the Grand Mufti. A slight figure rose in the lamplight, turbaned, a dark silk jubbeh falling to his feet. Above a thin, short round beard his eyes shone with kindliness.

Makes Visitors Welcome. ‘Make yourself welcome higher up,’ my companion interpreted the Grand Mufti’s soft Arabic accents. (Moslem hospitality dictates, he further explained, that a guest occupy the ‘head’ of his host’s ‘tent.’) ‘And how do you like El Khuds?

If you have drunk of its waters, you will never forget it.’ It was my first direct evidence of the Moslem’s love for his ‘El-Khuds,’ Jerusalem, next to Mecca his Holy City… ‘We Arabs here see uneasy days now,’ he began in answer to my questions. ‘We are anxious.

We are afraid the Jews will soon be our masters and we their servants. ‘Praised be Allah, in Palestine Jews and Moslems have lived for centuries as brothers. While in Christian countries there were pogroms, we dwelt in peace.

It is not that we look askance at Jews now, but we fear we shall slowly be forced out, bought out perhaps, but still forced out, from a land where the earth is the dust of our dead bones. ‘I have been asked if the Hedjas kingdom will satisfy our national aspirations. Not at all. That is for the Bedouins across the Jordan. We are different peoples.

Our native country is Palestine,’ the Mufti continued, his spare brown hands nervously fingering his black beads. ‘But there is this likeness: we both love our home lands.’

Nomads Love Country. The Bedouin never tarries in the same spot a month. But read his love songs to his fair maiden. Always the thought of his home land is uppermost, the land where he pitches his tent. How much more should we who are not Nomads love our mother country!

‘Palestinian Arabs have gone away to Egypt and America and found fortune, but they have always come back, content to live in wretched little huts in the villages like Bethlehem, like Ramleh. We are orientals and can never adopt a foster country. Besides, would we be satisfied to leave this fertile field for the desert wastes of Arabia?

‘We stand not only against a Jewish home land here now or in the days to come, but even against Jewish immigration. What is more, we want no immigration, no foreigners of any kind to enter here. As pilgrims we shall welcome all who come, Chirstian and Jew. Love of the guest is in the nature of the east.

But we are helpless after years under the Turkish heel, and foreign colonists with plenty of gold and modern ways would engulf us. Especially the Jews, who are ready to fling money away here—not to grow profit, but for a religious dream.

We feel the people in the country should have the fruits of the new freedom and not have to give up the lion’s share to strangers. ‘This land is not like America—that can embrace thousands of foreigners. When we have become half of what America is in enlightment, in riches, in power, we shall not only welcome but invite aliens.

But not now, when we are prostrate. We would even welcome the Zionists in such a day.

No Match for Zionists. ‘We consider Zionism a menace to us because we are no match for the Zionists. It is well known to all that they are the most civilized people, first in enlightenment; energy and enterprise. On the other hand, the natives here are just the reverse—ignorant, backward. It is not that we look upon Zionists as wolves.

We would have the same fear of Americans or Englishmen. We want time to turn our own deserts ourselves into oases. ‘This great war was fought out with the professed idea to lift every oppressed nation to its feet. No nation has been more oppressed than the Arabs under the Turks. They were taxed many fold.

If a man ploughed with forty yoke of oxen he was so ground down with tithes that his sons would plough with twenty and his grandsons with ten. Now is it the consensus of intention to give us bread or to eat off the little flesh now left to our bones? ‘We have put our protest against the Balfour declaration on record.

When we learned of it, a delegation of natives headed by the mayor of El Khuds went to the military governor with a petition that set forth our rights. Still we realize that the declaration is elastic. Many interpretations can be put upon it. So far I have heard nothing definite from any official source. Each man is reading it in the light of his own hopes.

Only Allah knows what will be the fate of Palestine and he has shown no inclination to reveal it.’

Ignorant of Advantages. ‘Did Dr. Weizmann explain to you,’ I asked of the Mufti, ‘that your people will profit when the Zionists come here and rebuild the land.’ ‘No,’ the moslem head replied. ‘Dr. Weizmann visited me at my home many times and we had long talks. But we only exchanged expressions of good will.

We never had a practical discussion. The war was still on. The Turks were entrenched in Palestine. The land was dark as night. Nobody could tell what the future would bring. I knew what Dr. Weizmann’s desires were for the Holy Land, but just how far they had gone toward their goal I did not know. We only spoke as host and guest.

‘No other Zionists have discussed Palestine’s future with me. Not half a per cent of the Arabs here are reconciled to their plans. I know they speak of their benefiting one another. But that has not been our experience in the past. The Jews always remain in their own quarters and do business with themselves.’

‘Moses is your prophet, too,’ I said to the mufti. ‘Don’t you believe Palestine is the promised land of the Jews?’ The Grand Mufti smiled broadly. ‘Politics does not enter the field of religion,’ he answered. ‘And even if it did the land promised the Jews lies far below the present surface.

A new civilization has covered it, stone on stone. Besides, after the bible came the Koran, that says Allah gives the land as a heritage to the ‘salihen,’ the just, to him who tends it. We have cultivated it for centuries.’

Majority Share Opinion. ‘We are told that only the offendis, the landowners, are opposed to Zionism, because they are afraid they will no longer be able to exploit the peasants, the fellaheen,’ I remarked. ‘That is not so,’ the mufti corrected. ‘These views I express are the opinion of the majority of the Arabs here.

Our real offendis are our aristocracy. They never exploited the fellaheen. The small portion of their countrymen that did live off them were the government employes. But that was the fault of the Turkish system. An agent received no more than 100 piastres ($15) a month, not enough to pay for his cigarets and coffee. ‘Now things have changed.

No one oppresses the fellaheen. They are joining with the offendis to keep the land in the hands of the Arabs. Under the Turk every man was glad to be rid of his farm, for it brought him only tax burdens. You would often come upon a fellah cutting down a beautiful olive tree to evade the tithe. But today we are under a just rule. Nobody overtaxes our land.

No one commandeers our camel, our donkey, our ox. We are not afraid to own our belongings.’ ‘Then Jews who plan to come here may expect to find an unfriendly Moslem?’ I asked the grand mufti. ‘If they come to stay,’ was his smiling answer. The grand mufti rose with us as we prepared to leave. His own son had served us tea to honor us, his guests.

His own hands now lighted our path back to the city of David. His ‘sallam’ was the last word we hear—‘Peace’—so like the Hebrew ‘sholom’—the greeting of his fellow semite that the mufti does not want to hear in the promised land.”

The earliest sustained Palestinian political argument in this archive, printed in Nebraska in March 1919. A named American correspondent, Marion Weinstein, climbs the path past Mount Olivet to ask the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem how the 500,000 Arabs here see the future, and prints his answer at the length of a column and a half. He fears being bought out perhaps, but still forced out, from a land where the earth is the dust of our dead bones. He rejects the Hedjaz as a substitute — our native country is Palestine. He says a delegation headed by the mayor of Jerusalem had already taken a petition against the Balfour declaration to the military governor. He says Weizmann visited him many times and they never once had a practical discussion. And asked whether only landlords object, he corrects the reporter: these views I express are the opinion of the majority of the Arabs here. The paper’s own subheading over the central passage is No Match for Zionists.

CP-1919-001 →

· The Buffalo News · Buffalo · page 9

Arabs in Holy Land Fear Jews; Say Zionism Menace

Grand Mufti Asserts Moslems Are Afraid They Will Be Slowly Forced Out of Palestine.

Marion Weinstein

“…‘Then Jews who plan to come here may expect to find an unfriendly Moslem?’ I asked the grand mufti. ‘If they come to stay,’ was his smiling answer. The grand mufti rose with us as we prepared to leave. His own son had served us tea to honor us, his guests. His own hands now lighted our path back to the City of David.

His ‘sallam’ was the last word we heard — ‘Peace’ — so like the Hebrew ‘sholom’ — the greeting of his fellow Semite that the mufti does not want to hear in the Promised Land.”

The same interview the Omaha World-Herald ran two days earlier (CP-1919-001), and the line under the headline is the one that matters: slowly forced out of Palestine, stated as what the Grand Mufti asserts, in an American paper in March 1919. Omaha had used the space to say instead that the foreigners were too progressive for backward natives. The main headline here also swaps the noun: Omaha’s Arabs fear Zionists; Buffalo’s fear Jews, with Zionism held back for the second clause.

CP-1919-002 →

· The American Jewish World · Minneapolis

CONGRESSMAN KAHN’S ANTI-ZIONIST ACTIVITY REPUDIATED.

“He has no authority to appear for us before the Peace Conference on that question… Should anyone attempt to speak on behalf of the Order for or against that question I will denounce him.”

Adolph Kraus of B’nai B’rith disowning Congressman Julius Kahn of California after Kahn presented an anti-Zionist petition to President Wilson. Eighty-five years later the Chicago Tribune would cite that petition — 299 rabbis and laypeople, opposing a Jewish state because displacing Palestinians would be “contrary to the principles of democracy” — as a road not taken.

CP-1919-015 →

· Omaha World-Herald · Omaha · page 1

Arabs Violently Opposed to Zionism

Despite Statements of Emir Feisul, Head of Hedjaz Delegation to Peace Conference, Relations With Jews in Palestine Strained to Breaking Point—British, Ever Watchful, Take Precautions to Prevent Bloodshed

Marion Weinstein

“during my three months’ travels in Palestine, fellaheen and effendis, peasants and landowners. I have had long conversations with members of the leading families, with educated Arabs, not only in Palestine, but in Damascus and in Beirut.

I have spent much time here in Cairo with a member of Emir Feisul’s own staff and with one of the officers in his army, both educated, both coolheaded.” And, under the subhead “Wild Rumors in Palestine”: “I have never found a single Arab, Moslem or Christian, who looks with the deepest sympathy upon the Zionist movement.”

Three months of reporting, and the correspondent lists the society she moved through: peasants, landowners, leading families, educated Arabs, Muslim and Christian. The unanimity is the finding. So is the fact that somebody went and asked.

CP-1919-003 →

· The Binghamton Press · Binghamton · page 8

Arab-Jewish Crisis in Palestine Result of Anti-Zionist Propaganda

Foes of Movement to Establish Commonwealth in Holy Land Using Two Systems, One Emanating From Arab Damascus, the Other from French Beirut

By Marion Weinstein

BY MARION WEINSTEIN. ARTICLE IV. The present Arab-Jewish crisis in Palestine is the direct result of a system of anti-Zionist propaganda — organized, unscrupulous, incendiary. In fact, there are two systems, equally questionable, the greater emanating from Arab Damascus and the other from French Beirut.

In order to understand how this propaganda functions, it is necessary to recall the present administration of Syria and Palestine. It is an Allied military occupation in four divisions, all under a Commander-in-Chief, General Sir Edmund Allenby, now Special High Commissioner of Egypt in addition. HOW COUNTRY IS ADMINISTERED.

“Occupied Enemy Territory Administration” it is called officially and familiarly referred to as “Oeta.” Palestine is “Oeta South,” under a British administrator, with headquarters in Jerusalem.

“Oeta East,” centering about Damascus, has local Arab rule, while “Oeta West,” Syria extending to Adana, is administered by the French from Beirut. Cilicia was added late in January, under Turkish officials, as a new section, “Oeta North.” These divisions, according to General Allenby, are purely military.

Political settlements are to be left entirely to the Peace Conference. The arrangement is simply a matter of control to maintain order.

Arabia proper with its capital Mecca is a separate, distinct kingdom under King Hussein, father of Emir (Prince) Feisal, head of the Hedjaz delegation to the Peace conference, representing Arab interests not only in his own realm but in “Oeta.” COUNTRY ALIVE WITH INTRIGUE.

Despite the Allies’ “gentleman’s agreement,” on which the “Oeta” divisions are based pending the final dictum of the Peace Conference, the Hedjaz Arabs and the French are unsettling Palestine with political propaganda.

The country is alive with intrigue, the details of which are well known to the British authorities and to the Zionist leaders. The British scorn counter propaganda, but the Zionists have recently begun to counteract these stealthy attacks upon them in a dignified campaign among the Arabs.

I have in my possession official copies of Arab propaganda that emanated from Damascus last Winter and was circulated throughout the Holy Land. The agitators did not dare to send statements of any length through the mails or by courier. For the British, however inactive, were watchful. So they hit upon the idea of printing anti-Zionist sentiments on perforated sheets of paper.

One of these little squares could easily be slipped through the post or a few distributed in the streets without attracting attention. Thus, one by one the whole set would finally reach its destination. WORKINGS OF PROPAGANDISTS. The set I secured was used in this way in the streets of Damascus and later in Beirut. Scores of copies found their way to Palestine.

It has thirty-five “Sentiments.” Here are some of the most striking: “Palestine is the soul of the Arab movement.” “If Zionism succeeds in Palestine, woe to Syria!” “Immigration of Zionists to Palestine must be prevented.” “The menace of Zionism requires Syria if it is spread in Palestine.”

“Palestine is a Moslem, Christian, and Arabic country.” “Give the Jews no chance in Palestine.” “Selling lands to Zionists is treachery.” “El Aksa, the third Mosque, is in Palestine.” CRIME AGAINST PALESTINE. “There will be no peace with the Zionists in Palestine.”

“Easy dealing of the natives with the Zionists is a great crime against Palestine.” “Zionist power is wealth and our power is unity.” “A Zionist rule? Ah! AH! Oh!” “Shall the Jew cast forth from Europe rule in Palestine?” “Can England become Germany? Then Palestine can become a Zionist State.”

“Every Jew is a Zionist and every Palestinian is an Arab.” Memoranda to the Arabs, urging them to arise against Zionism, were posted in the streets of Damascus and of Nablus, the center of Arab propaganda in Palestine. I have one of the original Arabic posters, of which I give here a free translation in part: TRANSLATION OF POSTER.

“To the Palestinians: The Jews have become aware of our unity and our fixity of purpose against their air castles. They have become convinced that they are the losing party and see before them certain disaster. So they have begun to spread false reports in the whole country.

They say that the Zionists have made agreements with the most representative Arab families in Palestine. They say, too, that they are in agreement with the hero of the Arabs, Emir Feisal, about Palestine. In this way they hope to sow enmity between the Christian and Moslem Arabs.” ANTI-ZIONIST MASS MEETINGS.

Another favorite propaganda stunt was to send Hedjaz officers down from Damascus on leave in Palestine. They would present their credentials to the British military governors and a few days later begin to hold anti-Zionist meetings among the Arabs. I know this was the case more than once in Tiberias and I have heard of similar occurrences in other cities in Palestine.

The agitators played upon utterly unfounded fears of the Arabs. These peasants were led to believe that their holy places were in danger of being seized by the Jew; that they would be expelled outright from the country, frozen out or overwhelmed by Jewish immigration.

The disturbers insisted falsely that the Zionist aim was a theocracy, in which non-Jews would have no comfortable place, if any place at all.

The earliest use of the word in this archive, and it is doing the whole job by itself. What the article actually describes is Palestinians writing political sentences, printing them on perforated squares small enough to pass through the post unnoticed, and handing them to each other. The word for that is propaganda. The word for the other side’s version, two paragraphs earlier, is a dignified campaign. Thirty-five of the sentences are counted and eight are reprinted, which means an American newspaper in 1919 carried Palestinian political speech to Binghamton in the act of dismissing it — including the line Every Jew is a Zionist and every Palestinian is an Arab, and a street poster that opens To the Palestinians.

CP-1919-016 →

· The State · Columbia

New Arab-Jewish Crisis Result of Propaganda

Foes of Movement for Holy Land Commonwealth Active — TWO SYSTEMS USED FROM DOUBLE SOURCE — One Emanates From Arab Damascus, the Other From French Beirut — Overzealous and Misguided Zionists Great Detriment to Their Cause.

By Marion Weinstein

One Form of Anti-Zionist Propaganda Used by Antagonistic Arabs in Palestine. PALESTINE IS OUR OWN COUNTRY · BE ON YOUR GUARD AGAINST ZIONISM · PALESTINE IS THE FORTRESS OF SYRIA · IF ZIONISM SUCCEEDS IN PALESTINE WOE TO SYRIA. Translation of Arabic Stickers Which Were Mailed One by One to Thwart the Censor.

Of the three printings of Marion Weinstein’s Article IV in this archive, this is the one that shows the thing itself. A plate in the middle of the page reproduces four of the Arabic stickers, and the paper prints an English translation of each underneath. The line below the plate explains how they traveled: mailed one by one to thwart the censor. So the earliest use of the word propaganda in this collection sits directly above the earliest description of Palestinians working around a censor, on the same page, in a South Carolina Sunday paper.

CP-1919-018 →

· The Evening Herald · Albuquerque · page 3

Arab-Jewish Crisis in Palestine Result of Anti-Zionist Propaganda

Foes of Movement to Establish Commonwealth in Holy Land Using Two Systems, One From Arab Damascus, the Other from French Beirut — Great Detriment to Their Cause

By Marion Weinstein

One Form of Anti-Zionist Propaganda Used by Antagonistic Arabs in Palestine. PALESTINE IS OUR OWN COUNTRY · BE ON YOUR GUARD AGAINST ZIONISM · PALESTINE IS THE FORTRESS OF SYRIA · IF ZIONISM SUCCEEDS IN PALESTINE WOE TO SYRIA. Translation of Arabic Stickers Which Were Mailed One by One to Thwart the Censor.

The same Marion Weinstein article, ten days after Binghamton and two thousand miles west, and it carries the sticker plate and the four translations as well. What is different is the company it keeps. Above it on page three is a Ripley cartoon headed It’s a Funny World. To the right is a shoe sale for the Golden Rule Dry Goods Company, and beneath both is a lemon-juice remedy for freckles. Under the whole page runs the comic strip Father ’n the Boys. The Palestinian sentences reach Albuquerque as filler between a cartoon and a shoe advertisement.

CP-1919-017 →

· The Oregonian

FIGHT OVER TURKISH MANDATES PROMISED

People of Palestine and Syria Are Badly Divided. | ZIONISTS PREFER BRITAIN | Christians and Moslems Favor American Guardianship; Vote to Be Taken in Damascus.

BY WILLIAM T. ELLIS.

JERUSALEM, July 6.—(Special Cable.)—The arrival here of Henry Churchill King and C. A. Crane, American commissioners named by the peace conference to investigate conditions in the Turkish empire and to report on questions concerning mandates over countries to be formed out of this empire, has created intense interest.

Their presence in Jerusalem also is serving to remove any danger of violence by natives against the Zionists. The consensus is that there will be no outbreaks, at least until after the decision of the peace conference has been announced.

The antipathy between natives and Zionists, however, is markedly increasing and certainly will become a battle of words before the American commissioners. The Zionists want a British mandate over Palestine, especially because of the promises made to them several months ago by Arthur J. Balfour, British minister for foreign affairs.

On the other hand, both Christians and Moslems want Syria and Palestine united under an American mandate. These Christians and Moslems now present a solid front, while there appears to be at least a slight division in the Zionist ranks.

CP-1919-019 →

· Deseret News · Salt Lake City · page 1

The greatest peril to the peace of Palestine is Zionism

Clair Price

It will see another war unless Zionism is arrested. Given peaceful development under British direction, it will develop into the peak of the British empire...

But given the continued menace of Jewish immigration, its population will break out into an anti-Zionist war which quite conceivably may bring down Egypt, Mesopotamia, Persia, Afghanistan and India and involve the world in a new chaos.

CP-1919-004 →

· Deseret Evening News · Salt Lake City · page 1

Is "Zionism" A Menace to World Peace?

Deseret News Foreign Correspondent Describes Bitter Resentment of Jewish Colonization by Natives Whose Demand Is, “Palestine For Palestinians”—Moslems and Christians For Once United, Say They Will Fight to the Death Rather Than Give Up Their Country to the Jews—“Zionist” Methods Resented, Especially Lavish Use of Money, by Which Agents Buy Best Land at High Prices—Strained Feeling Among Arabs and Other Natives Who Declare They Are Being Sold Out by Allies Without Their Consent—Demand For American or British Protectorate.

Clair Price

The masthead reads: “DESERET EVENING NEWS. FOREIGN NEWS, SOCIETY NEWS. MUSIC, THE DRAMA, AND LITERATURE. SECTION THREE. SATURDAY JULY 12 1919 SALT LAKE CITY UTAH.” The banner: “Is ‘Zionism’ A Menace to World Peace?”

“JAFFA—The Leading Zionist Center in Palestine.” “JERUSALEM—Headquarters of the Zionist Commission in Palestine.” “HAIFA—Landing Place of the Famous Zionist Party.”

The whole argument is in the standfirst, in 1919, including the demand as the correspondent heard it: Palestine for Palestinians. The masthead prints the date.

CP-1919-005 →

· Deseret News · Salt Lake City · page 1

Buying Up the Land

Clair Price

“BUYING UP THE LAND.<br>Zionism, however, commands unlimited wealth. There is hardly an Arab in Palestine who could turn down a Jewish immigrant’s offer of $500 for a piece of land worth $100.

Only this week Zionist agents offered $15,000,000 cash for a piece of land on the Jerusalem-Bethlehem road, worth at the most $10,000,000, belonging to the Brotherhood of the Holy Sepulchre of the Greek Church.

Unless Zionism is checked at once, it will succeed in the next few years in buying up all the good land in Palestine and in peopling it with Jewish colonies, leaving the 750,000 present inhabitants of Palestine as hirelings and strangers in their own homeland.<br>None knows this better than the Palestinians themselves.”

CP-1919-006 →

· Deseret News · Salt Lake City · page 1

The colonies would be welcomed were they not forerunners of a planned wave

Clair Price

“Palestinians explain the fair amount of success which has been gained by the Jewish colonies by the unlimited resources which Zionism has placed at their command. The success they have obtained is beside the point in the eyes of Palestinians.

The colonies would be welcomed in Palestine were they not forerunners in a planned wave of Jews intended to buy the country away from its people.”

CP-1919-007 →

· Deseret News · Salt Lake City · page 1

Interview with leaders of the Mohammedan-Christian society

Clair Price

'If the Jews have a right to Palestine,' they told me, 'we Arabs have a right to Spain and the Indians have a right to New York.' 'We Arabs have been here for 5,000 years... Today they constitute only 12.5 percent of our population... Haven't we Moslems respected the Christians' holy places?

Haven't we permitted Jewish pilgrims to flow into and out of the country with perfect freedom? Is it grateful of them to return our favors by demanding that we give up our country to them? Where will we go?'

CP-1919-008 →

· Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham

ZIONISM IS DANGER TO WORLD PEACE SAYS CLAIR PRICE’S JERUSALEM LETTER

Natives Bitterly Resent Jewish Colonization, Whose Great Wealth Makes It Irresistible Force

Clair Price, Jerusalem, June 30 (Edward Marshall Syndicate)

“Before the menace of Zionism, Moslems and Christians alike are united. Never before have these two religions sunk their differences as they have sunk them before the common peril of Jewish colonization.

They are no longer enemies. They are Palestinians. … The fact is that Palestine’s population now, as before the war, consists of 600,000 Arabs, all of whom are Moslems; 75,000 Christians, a large proportion of whom are natives; and 75,000 Jews…”

A fourth city for the Clair Price dispatch the archive already holds from Salt Lake City, Buffalo and San Antonio — the earliest of the four datelines, and the only Southern one. The Mohammedan-Christian Society interview in the same column is CP-1919-008. The assertion that Palestinian national identity was manufactured later has to contend with this sentence, set in ordinary body type in Alabama in July 1919.

CP-1919-014 →

· Buffalo Courier Express · Buffalo · page 45

ZIONISM MAY BRING MORE WORLD WAR, SAYS CLAIR PRICE

Correspondent finds Palestinians very bitter on the point of Jewish colonization. · DON’T CONCEDE RIGHT · Say Hebrews have same claim on land as Indians have to New York or Arabs to Spain. · BRITISH COME IN FOR ABUSE · Natives wondering if they are to be displaced again, now that the Turk has been driven out.

By Clair Price

“…It is not on these matters that the bulk of the society’s attention is being spent at present, however. Just now its political commission is directing all its strength toward securing the passage of a law prohibiting all Jewish immigration into Palestine.

‘During the war the United States prohibited immigration,’ they say; ‘why can’t we prohibit Jewish immigratiln?’

War against Zionism. They are determined to fight Zionism to the end, even though Palestine is bathed in blood before the end comes. With them, it is a matter of keeping their country from being taken out from under their feet and sold to an alien race.

In this, they come into direct clash with the intended future of over 50 Zionist colonies already established in Palestine. The most fmous of these colonies is Tel-Aviv at Jaffa. This is the particular pride of Zionism.

It is a suburb of Jaffa with broad streets, lined with well-built bouses surrounded by little gardens and characterized by an unmistakable atmosphere of western neatness. Its administration is carried on by a town council elected by its inhabitants…”

Clair Price, the correspondent who a year earlier had written the sentence They are Palestinians, reporting what the Palestinian political commission was actually doing in July 1919: campaigning for a law to stop Jewish immigration, and arguing it by American precedent — the United States had stopped immigration during the war, so why not here. The headline stack over it is four decks long and every one of them is the Palestinian case: that Palestinians are bitter on the point of Jewish colonization, that Hebrews have the same claim on the land as Indians have to New York or Arabs to Spain, and that the natives are wondering whether they are to be displaced again now that the Turk has been driven out. The sentence in the body is the one the headline is made from: even though Palestine is bathed in blood before the end comes.

CP-1919-009 →

· San Antonio Express · San Antonio · page 1

Does Palestine Want To Be Zionized?

Correspondent Finds Remarkable Union Between Christians and Mohammedans Opposing Settlement of "Their Country" by Jews

Clair Price

JERUSALEM, June 30.—The greatest peril to the peace of Palestine is Zionism. The little link between the three continents of Europe, Asia and Africa which is Palestine, has seen more fighting than any other land in the world during its 5,000 years of history. It will see another war unless Zionism is arrested.

Given peaceful development under British direction, it will develop into the peak of the British Empire… Before the “menace” of Zionism, Moslems and Christians alike are united. Never before have these two religions sunk their differences as they have sunk them before the common peril of Jewish colonization. They are no longer enemies.

They are Palestinians. It is Zionist money that they fear. Turkish tax collectors have left Palestine a poverty-stricken country. The “osher” has left its mark everywhere in the arrested development of Palestine.

For years, the “osher,” the principal tax in the Ottoman Empire, was sold by public tender in Palestine and was collected by its purchaser or tax farmer, whose primary interest was collecting many times the amount he paid for it. The only limit to the amount he could collect was the necessity of avoiding a complaint to the Porte.

Provided the tax farmer did not provoke a revolt, he could rob right and left. The result is that today the number of Moslems in Palestine whose personal fortunes exceed [figure illegible] could be named on the fingers of one hand. The vast majority of Palestinians live from day to day.

Zionism, however, commands unlimited wealth… Unless Zionism is checked at once, it will succeed in the next few years in buying up all the good land in Palestine and in peopling it with Jewish colonies, leaving the 7[5]0,000 present inhabitants of Palestine as hirelings and strangers in their own homeland. None knows this better than the Palestinians themselves.

Their answer to it is the Mohammedan-Christian Society, an organization whose headquarters is in Jerusalem and whose branch offices now cover Palestine like a blanket. Its governing board consists of thirty Moslems and ten Christians.

“The Wailing Place” of the Jews · Jerusalem, Headquarters of the Zionist [movement] · Jaffa, the Leading Zionist Centre in Palestine · A View of Haifa

A correspondent writing from Jerusalem in 1919 uses “Palestinians” as a national noun and defines it on the page: Moslems and Christians who stopped being enemies. He names their organization, the Mohammedan-Christian Society, and counts its board. He also counts them on the same page — 600,000 Arabs, 75,000 Christians, 75,000 Jews — and says what he expects will happen to them. Forty-five years before the PLO was founded.

CP-1919-010 →

· The Jewish Bulletin · page 1

Jews and Anti-Zionists

Reprinted from the Portland Tribune

“Our inimical friends, the anti-Zionists, striving to strengthen their opposition to Zionism, besides accusing the Zionists of treachery to the countries of which they are citizens—a most vicious falsehood—they quote some Gentile writers who happen to sound anti-Zionistic sentiment.

One of these self-appointed keepers of Israel in his weekly or weekly, after re-stating his anti-Zionistic position and assuring his readers that Zionism has lost out because of its misinterpretation of the Balfour Declaration, quotes Dr. William T.

Ellis, special correspondent of the New York Herald in Damascus, who, among other things, said, also: ‘It is simply impossible to turn Palestine over to the Jews without precipitating a great massacre,’ and that the natives object to an English mandate in Palestine… To them every anti-Semite becomes a renowned authority, so long as he promotes anti-Zionism.”

A warning printed in 1919 and quoted in order to dismiss it. The argument that opposing Zionism amounts to antisemitism is already fully formed here, twenty-five years before the Baltimore Sun reported it from a convention platform.

CP-1919-011 →

· The Jewish Monitor · page 2

PEACE CONFERENCE COMMISSION TO HOLD INVESTIGATION.

from the Jerusalem correspondent of the Jewish Morning Journal

“The very first question that was put to the spokesmen of Palestine Jewry was ‘What would be the attitude of the Jews toward the non-Jewish inhabitants of Palestine?’ … The Commission wanted to know how large a Jewish population in the opinion of the delegation could be absorbed in Palestine.

The reply was four million… it was evident from the questions put by the Commission that the Palestine it had in mind was not limited to the territory west of the Jordan.”

The King–Crane Commission beginning work in Jaffa on 10 June 1919. Its opening question names roughly nine-tenths of the country’s population by what they are not — the Balfour Declaration’s own construction, reprinted in an American paper. One line of type in the third column is set upside down; the inversion is the paper’s. “accomodate” is the paper’s spelling.

CP-1919-013 →

· The Jewish Monitor · page 1

Palestinian Jews Awarded Medals

“The medal of the Order of the British Empire has been presented to two Palestinian Jews who performed deeds of exceptional heroism in the campaign against the Turks.

The presentation was made by Major General Hodgson in front of the Military Governorate, and was witnessed by a very large gathering, including the staff of the Military Administration, representatives of the Zionist Commission and of the American Zionist Medical Unit, as well as members of the various Jewish communities in the country. The recipients of the medals were Mr.

Lova Schnerson and Mr. Yussef Davidesco, both of whom were employed in the Intelligence Department of the Egyptian Expeditionary Force. Mr. Schnerson crossed the enemy lines twice in disguise, at great peril to his life, and obtained very important information. Mr. Davidesco also crossed the Turkish lines, and—”

Palestinian Jews, meaning Jewish residents of Palestine, in 1919. The clipping is cut off mid-sentence.

CP-1919-012 →

A year at a time: 1910 · 1911 · 1912 · 1913 · 1914 · 1915 · 1916 · 1917 · 1918 · 1919

Last updated 17 November 2026

Part of Covering Palestine, an archive of 3637 newspaper clippings about Palestinians printed in 748 papers between 1724 and 2023. Researched and assembled by Maria Robles. Nothing here was printed after 6 October 2023.

The clippings belong to the newspapers and news agencies that printed them and are reproduced for research, criticism and commentary. Selection, transcription, counts and writing are © Maria Robles, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.

All decades · archive.json · Questions · Contribute a clipping · When was this printed? · How this was built · maria@rozumstudio.com